Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 1/16/2008
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
1/16/2008
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Board actions.pdf
Transportation 2007 accomplishments, 2008 goals and challenges.pdf
VTrans2035.pdf
Rail Industrial Access Program application briefing.pdf
1. Recap of 2007 Awards of Excellence
2. Legislative and Budget Update
3. Secondary Street Acceptance Regulations
Secondary street acceptance requirements.pdf
4. VTrans2035 – Moving the Vision Forward
5. I-95 / I-395 Transit / TDM Study
I-95_395 Transit_TDM study.pdf
6. Rail Industrial Access Project-Reyes Holdings, LLC
7. DRPT Directors Report
8. Recreational Access Fund Policy
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:00
Good afternoon.
00:00:00
I'd like to welcome everyone to the January meeting, the first of 2008 of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:07
We're going to typically, in most parts of the year, we do a work session one day and a business session the next.
00:00:16
Thank you to the General Assembly who will do both our work session and our business meeting today, Wednesday.
00:00:22
I want to thank everybody for traveling safely and it's turning a beautiful day outside and we have a beautiful agenda to capitalize on that.
00:00:31
For starters, I would like to recognize Commissioner Ekern who is going to talk about the many awards and much of the excellence that occurs within the Department of Transportation on a daily basis.
00:00:45
As the first meeting of 2008, it's probably a good opportunity to look back on 2007 and some of the good things.
00:00:51
Welcome, Commissioner.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:54
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
00:00:55
Now I have to take two seconds and smile.
00:00:58
And he promised he wouldn't come back.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:02
You didn't believe him, did you?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:04
Good afternoon everybody and Happy New Year.
00:01:06
It's nice to have you here and it's nice to be able to be first on the agenda to talk about something that is obviously, whether it's Matt or whether it's I, in our jobs as your arm in our agencies,
00:01:25
One of the things that we take a lot of pride in, and I can tell you this is true having experienced it in three states and with my peers across the country, you take tremendous pride.
00:01:41
And it doesn't take you long to develop it.
00:01:43
In terms of what your staff does every day for the public and the achievements that they reach every year as they move and change the days of transportation in this country.
00:02:02
And so it's seldom that we take some conscious effort
00:02:07
to sit down and try to highlight some of that excellence for you.
00:02:12
I asked the secretary if we could do that today because I thought it was really an auspicious time to do it as we begin 2008.
00:02:22
Normally we would have what we call the Garber Conference in May.
00:02:29
This year, as a part of our strategies to stretch dollars, we are not going to hold the Garber Conference.
00:02:36
And that's our event where we try to make sure that we get some recognition done.
00:02:41
So I thought and asked and believed that this would be just a great opportunity because I've gotten to know what advocates for transportation, the members of this board are over my first two years here.
00:02:56
And so you always want to work with a receptive audience.
00:03:00
So what you have at your place, and each of you should have a little table that looks like this.
00:03:07
Because I'm not going to read all the names today, but I am going to ask some teams and some individuals to stand up because over the last year, in 2007, we've received recognition around projects and innovative practices
00:03:26
that we have achieved as a Commonwealth on 42 different occasions, not counting an additional 10 that we award internally and through the Governor's programs.
00:03:40
So that, what that totals up to you is if you look at these charts about right is
00:03:45
51 different activities and initiatives recognized for their excellence and their contribution to the future of the commonwealth.
00:03:55
And I wanted to highlight about six or seven of those in just a few minutes here.
00:04:02
And what you see in the audience or the people you see in the audience are representatives of those teams.
00:04:10
So as I talk about any given item, I'm going to ask them to stand up.
00:04:14
I won't go through their names because Norwegians don't do phonetics very well.
00:04:21
You need to think about that.
00:04:24
And so I'd rather not embarrass myself by doing that.
00:04:29
If it's Peterson or Nelson or Johnson, I'm really good at it.
00:04:34
And I've arranged these in a particular order because I wanted to get kind of a showcase around what we have adopted as our strategic initiatives as we take the goals adopted by the CTB, the goals of the governor's programs,
00:04:51
and our business plan tie all those things together.
00:04:55
I've talked to the board several times about our focus around changing the transportation system, improving our business practices on an ongoing basis to give you the most efficient, effective, and sustainable transportation business in the country, and third, our focus around our people.
00:05:17
There's no doubt over the last five years that VDOT has undergone some of the most radical change ever attempted by a DOT in the country.
00:05:30
And we use that simple statistic that the people that are here providing services and direction today are fewer in number than when we began the interstate era in 1958.
00:05:46
How have they accomplished that?
00:05:47
They've accomplished that through what I'm showing you here today.
00:05:52
A team approach, new business practices, using technology, and just plain dedication to public service.
00:06:01
That's what excites me about being the Commissioner of VDOT.
00:06:07
The first project, and so as you look down this chart, I want to highlight a couple of initiatives in the business practice area, which highlight really our technology growth.
00:06:23
And the first project I've got is what we have labeled as the Integrated Project Manager Program.
SPEAKER_17
00:06:30
And I'd like that team to rise.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:32
Well, I'd like them to stand up.
00:06:33
You don't have to rise.
SPEAKER_17
00:06:34
Stand up.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:37
That got the Digital Government Award from the Center for Digital Government and it was recognized by the Commissioner's Award as an outstanding achievement in innovation and quality improvement.
00:06:52
This is the team that took an outdated and very costly system to manage our projects in the field.
00:07:00
translated it, turned it into web-based software, and made it transparent for use throughout the agency.
00:07:08
You can't accomplish that by just using anybody.
00:07:12
These people are experts in the business they do.
00:07:16
They know what the system has to do to accomplish good, efficient use and ensure that our properties are managed on a tight basis.
00:07:27
That's one of the keys to helping us get to on-time and on-budget as we've demonstrated in fiscal year, in calendar year 2000.
00:07:37
These folks are terrific in what they do and so I wanted to make sure that you saw the kinds of folks that really put those systems together for us.
00:07:58
The second project that I wanted to highlight today really deals with, under the business practices piece, something that's near and dear to our hearts as we've managed change in funding across the programs that we operate in.
00:08:14
So I'm going to ask the team that has developed a federally paving schedule contract development tool to kind of stand up.
00:08:26
Now, why is this important?
00:08:29
Again, it's another use of technology, but as you know, over the last two years, we have started to utilize federal aid on the maintenance side for the first time in our history.
00:08:42
That brings a new level of complexity to how we deliver projects in a traditional maintenance setting.
00:08:49
That means you've got to meet some new requirements, you've got to set up your funding differently, and in order to accomplish that, this team sat down and created a contract development schedule that included all the environmental clearances, the safety reviews, and the Federal Highway Administration requirements.
00:09:11
They did it as an independent project within a district and we have now spread that throughout the department as a usable tool so that on maintenance projects, we no longer have to start from scratch on every maintenance project that's going to utilize Federal Aid.
00:09:27
This gives the department that template.
00:09:29
This makes us efficient.
00:09:32
This ensures that when we get at the end of the day, we've got projects that are ready to let.
00:09:40
In the Stanton District, in fiscal year 2006, we were able to attribute about 9.4 million dollars in savings because of the use of this scheduling system.
00:09:58
We estimate as it permeates throughout the department that it will save us about $100 million annually.
00:10:08
What does that mean?
00:10:09
It turns into pavement.
00:10:11
It turns into smoother roads.
00:10:14
It turns into safe bridges.
00:10:16
That's why this kind of stuff gets me excited.
00:10:19
So another neat business practice change.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:31
Mr. Chairman, that means the Stanton District gets a percentage of every other district's money back.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:38
Rick Hall will explain to you later the copyright laws and a few things like that.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:43
But it's good innovation, we appreciate that.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:46
Now I want to highlight a couple of projects in the transportation system category as we use our business plan.
00:10:54
The first one is the Chickahominy Bridge Project.
00:11:00
It's the Judith Stewart Dresser Memorial Bridge on Route 5 over the Chickahominy Bridge.
00:11:10
That got a Governor's Award for Teamwork and it was recognized by the Commissioner as an outstanding achievement in our project development system.
00:11:24
Here's what they faced.
00:11:26
And obviously, Mr. McCarthy understands what we're facing in this particular project.
00:11:34
68-year-old swing bridge near Williamsburg deteriorated and repeatedly closed.
00:11:43
And every time we had to shut it down, it was a 63-mile detour.
00:11:49
This team
00:11:50
put together the program.
00:11:53
Preliminary Engineering developed a project to replace it with a 2,500-foot-long fixed-band bridge, 52 feet over the water, so you got good water clearance.
00:12:04
That project, we thought, would take three or more years to develop.
00:12:08
They did it in 18 months.
00:12:11
The total cost of engineering was 5% of the construction budget as compared to a typical 12 to 15%.
00:12:21
That turned into real dollars at about $5.3 million worth of savings in that project development cost, again turned into real projects.
00:12:34
What really caught my attention about this team is the fact that one of their members, a gentleman by the name of John Wells, passed away before the project was completed.
00:12:49
He was recognized by this team, who organized a special event for him over at the library, and unfortunately he died at the age of 52.
00:13:03
One of his loves was the research of history and the protection of the environment.
00:13:10
In his role on this team, he helped that team ensure that the project was in fact environmentally sound and recognized its true history and what it played as a role in the Commonwealth.
00:13:27
That team, as I got to know them and had a chance to visit with them, you get a real sense of their enthusiasm and their pride and their dedication to one another and the care that they had for a coworker.
00:13:43
So you saw an awful lot of the best of VDOT right there in one project.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:57
Mr. Chairman, this project didn't even exist five and a half years ago and our district came to me that summer of 2002 and said we have a serious bridge problem and I said well I hope you can fix it and they said it's going to cost a lot of money that we don't have and they put this team together on it and in lightning fast time they got this thing moving and are getting it done and
00:14:26
It is in one of the most historic areas of the country.
00:14:30
They've done it sensitively, efficiently, and effectively.
00:14:34
I am very, very proud of them for the job they've done on this one.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:38
I appreciate that.
00:14:39
Thank you.
00:14:39
That's a compliment that we all take very seriously.
00:14:45
The second project I wanted to highlight is the Lord Delaware Bridge replacement on Route 33 in West Point, Fredericksburg District.
00:14:55
I think we are all aware of the West Point Bridge and what a statement that is and what dedication it took to deliver that project.
00:15:12
It is one of those projects that really faced a number of environmental challenges, particularly as we dealt with the sensitivity of the Chesapeake Bay Watership, including time of year restrictions for working in the water, tidal basin influences, and a really soft subsurface.
00:15:34
Those of us that are in the engineering community really get nervous about that kind of stuff, if you really want to know the truth, because then you get to drive ponds all over the place.
00:15:42
End result of this project, very frankly, it met every environmental requirement that was established for it in the environmental process.
00:15:52
It was completed on time and on budget.
00:15:56
It forged some really strong partnerships between federal, state, and local groups as we were in the process of bringing that project to fruition.
00:16:06
It is one of those hallmark projects that you can look at in terms of the term we've used here around context-sensitive solutions because it really welded together those four tests that I always talk about public involvement, good engineering, sound financial planning, and a respect for the environment and the quality of life here in the commonwealth.
00:16:31
It used some really innovative bridge construction techniques
SPEAKER_15
00:16:36
And if I'm not mistaken, this is the bridge where we had trouble getting the dedication set a couple of times because it's snow.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:44
But this group I'm really proud of and it is a beautiful bridge.
00:16:50
I've been into the West Point community and looked at what it's done and what it did to bring that community together.
00:16:56
So let's give them a round of applause.
00:17:06
The last on the system transformation that I wanted to highlight is the rest area program and particularly the Interstate 64 rest area that we opened up this summer and why it was important.
00:17:22
It represents a series, the beginning of a series of directions that we started to build green buildings.
00:17:34
To reutilize what we have and to ensure that we get the best use of materials available and don't just start from scratch.
00:17:46
I've got to have Jake Porter stand up.
00:17:48
He's been the leader of this thing.
00:17:50
If you want to get really engaged with somebody who has enthusiasm and love for what they're doing and see the vision
00:18:00
of how we can reduce our environmental footprint and still have quality.
00:18:07
Talk to Jake.
00:18:10
He'll get you so charged up, it'll just drive you nuts.
00:18:17
Simple examples.
00:18:19
In this particular rest area, we got the Green Leadership Award from the James River Green Building Council.
00:18:26
It's a 9,000 square foot safety rest area with all the state-of-the-art traveler amenities that you would want.
00:18:35
They have a system that collects rain from the roof and takes about 250,000 gallons of that rainwater, which is then used for flushing the restroom toilet.
00:18:47
So they've built a cistern into the place and so all of a sudden you're not having to drain on a water supply.
00:18:53
They have a stormwater bioretention facility to control and filter runoff from the parking lot before we put it back out into the watershed.
00:19:05
They have a 32-well geothermal system that uses the constant temperature of water 400 feet below the surface of the earth to reduce the need for supplemental heating and air conditioning.
00:19:21
So consequently you have an energy-efficient building.
00:19:25
And it has a terrazzo floor, which you would think would be a terrazzo tile, that is made from recycled mirrors and glass rather than traditional granite and marble.
00:19:39
And you can't tell the difference.
00:19:40
I've been there, looked at it.
00:19:41
I was there for the dedication.
00:19:43
And that's just a couple, three of the kind of highlights.
00:19:46
Same kinds of practices were used on the Interstate 95 rest area we just opened up in the Fredericksburg district, where in fact they salvaged the existing concrete.
00:19:58
So we didn't tear up all the concrete entrances and exits, we used it.
00:20:02
George Romack, by the way, has his initials in one of the concrete slabs.
00:20:08
So if you see George again, he's here.
00:20:10
He'll take you and show you where he put his initials in that slab in 1964, I think is the year that he did it.
00:20:19
And so they'll be there for another 60 years.
00:20:22
He's really proud of that.
00:20:23
But, you know, I'm really proud of this rest area program.
00:20:26
I know it was a priority for the board, and I know you're starting to see it really bear its fruition throughout the Commonwealth.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:41
Mr. Chairman, once again I have to express as the district representative my appreciation for not only the outstanding job but the outstanding leadership that they've demonstrated to show that you know being green and being good and being effective all work compatibly well together and this sets a whole new standard for VDOT to pursue in the future.
00:21:05
It's just terrific.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:07
The last two that I've got now go to the next piece that I really care about, and that's our workforce.
00:21:14
How do we demonstrate that changing workforce, that work ethic, the sense of public service that comes with a productive workforce that we have here in the Commonwealth?
00:21:27
The first individual I'm going to ask to stand up is Langston T. Williams.
00:21:32
He's really LT, if you know him.
00:21:38
He got a Governor's Award for safety in the workplace.
00:21:42
He was recognized by the Commissioner for our achievement in the workforce.
00:21:48
And his demonstration and the reason he got the award is not just because of what he did, but because he wouldn't take no for an answer.
00:21:58
He is one of the most tenacious individuals you will ever come across when he found a problem and I'll just brief it to you this way.
00:22:07
He works in the Stanton District and one of our tractors out there caught fire while stored overnight and that created a hazard because we have those tractors all over the town for all VDOT equipment shops.
00:22:24
He determined the cause of the fire, an electrical cable that rubbed against a steering hose, so it was a design defect in the tractor.
00:22:34
Not only did he take initiative to take care of our fleet and make sure that we did corrective action, but he also took on the company.
00:22:44
So they got a worldwide change in the specification for that piece of equipment.
00:22:51
By doing that, obviously he did get us a new tractor.
00:22:57
It saved us $36,000 in the deal.
00:23:01
But that shows you the kind of tenacity and attention to safety in the workplace that just is critical to a productive workforce.
00:23:12
I got to know LT a lot last year.
00:23:15
Once he gets ahold of you, he's like Jake.
00:23:18
He's going to be perfect.
00:23:19
It's really cool.
00:23:20
LT, thank you.
00:23:28
And the last workforce piece I wanted to highlight is one that you've heard about before, but I couldn't let it pass, another opportunity to talk to you about it.
00:23:38
The VDOT Wounded Veteran Internship Program, which you know has been recognized by the Federal Highway Administration,
00:23:46
for their Strive for Excellence Award and see what that program accomplishes in terms of transitioning veterans coming back to the United States and having a place to start.
00:24:04
I had a chance to have dinner last night with Rick Capco from the Federal Highway Administration.
00:24:11
We're doing another event on the 26th of January in Fredericksburg to try to help get that program spread across the country.
00:24:21
We were the first
00:24:22
We are the best.
00:24:24
They have exceeded every goal and all I can tell you is every place I go I get nothing but compliments from the willingness of this Commonwealth to step up and help those people who have served our country and served our country well.
00:24:43
So it's a real pleasure to have this team here and let you give them a round of applause one more time.
00:24:56
Mr. Secretary, I really appreciate it.
00:24:57
This is as fast as I can go through a topic.
00:25:00
And believe me, I would have loved to have all 51 kinds of award winners here.
00:25:06
And hopefully we can do this again for you.
00:25:09
It's exciting to do this kind of thing.
00:25:11
And we appreciate the support that you give us in being able to do this.
00:25:16
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:18
Thank you, Commissioner.
00:25:19
Can I ask the board, let's give everybody a standing ovation for all the individuals and groups here.
00:25:40
I would like to say thank you as the governor says often public service is a calling and these are just such great examples of that calling the other side of it too is public service is fun and we see a smile on everyone's face it's important to enjoy what we do because we do well what we enjoy and thank you again for not only doing a great job but enjoying what you do thank you
00:26:13
The next item on our agenda will be our legislative and budget update, which is timely, given the General Assembly's visit here, and presenting will be Deputy Secretary Barbara Reese, and Nick Donohue may be here to answer any substantive legislative questions, as well as Joanne Maxwell from the Attorney General's Office.
00:26:33
Welcome, Ms. Reese.
Barbara W. Reese
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:26:34
Good afternoon.
00:26:35
Rather than speaking from the presentation that I believe was sent, I emailed it to all of you either late last week or early this week.
00:26:44
This is the second in a series of presentations the Secretary has made to the various General Assembly members.
00:26:50
This one incorporates
00:26:51
Some of the budget items that are included and I put three pieces of information at your desk.
00:26:58
The first one is a document that says at the top, Secretary of Transportation General Assembly category report.
00:27:08
And then there's another one that is a written document, which is just referred to as transportation.
00:27:15
And lastly, it is the actual pages out of the Governor's budget proposal on transportation.
00:27:20
So those are the three things I'll work from.
00:27:23
And then if you have questions about anything, I'll be happy to talk about those.
00:27:28
As the Secretary mentioned, we have been in session now.
00:27:31
The General Assembly has been in session, I guess it's a week.
00:27:34
We have any number of bills.
00:27:36
The largest category of bills we have thus far are appealing the abuse of driver fee.
00:27:43
Those bills have a revenue impact in addition to what we've already briefed you on in December of about $385 million.
00:27:50
We do have two legislators who have offered to repeal those abuse of driver fees but then replace
00:27:58
The lost revenues with either a gas tax increase or a sales tax increase.
00:28:05
If you turn on the first page of this report, you'll see there are 17 bills which are referred to as the Secretary's Bills.
00:28:14
Those bills are bills that were introduced
00:28:16
by the administration that we are hopeful will be successful through the session.
00:28:23
In the most part, most of those are either technical cleanup bills or they are bills that deal with some form of safety or some kind of regulatory requirement.
00:28:35
The only revenue fee increase bill that the Governor submitted is the last one on that page, Senate Bill 512.
00:28:41
Senator Von Miller, who is our new Chairman of the Senate Transportation Committee, is the patron of that bill, and it does increase the driver's license fee from $20 to $30 for a five-year period, or $2.
00:28:57
And if you would note in that presentation that I sent you, DMV was the agency that really wasn't addressed last year in terms of funding.
00:29:09
And this is a way of getting them about $14 million a year in funding.
00:29:14
Their long-term funding need, based on their latest spending and estimates, is about $20 million a year.
00:29:21
And so there's some other minor revenue changes that I can talk about in the budget for them.
00:29:26
bottom line is that bill is meant to try to get them some stability to their financial picture.
00:29:32
Again on page two- Question.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:34
I have a question, Mr. Chairman.
00:29:36
Mr. McCarthy.
00:29:37
Ms. Reese, what is House Bill 1301 on page one?
Barbara W. Reese
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:29:41
The bridge replacement and repair, CTB powers, that simply adds bridge replacement and repair as a category of design build so that for many of the small bridges, Commissioner Ekern has an initiative to try to address a lot of the smaller bridges around the state, and that's a way to try to help facilitate that.
00:29:58
Just as you were commenting on the great teamwork, it's a way to making sure that we can facilitate that activity.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:05
Great.
00:30:05
Thank you.
Barbara W. Reese
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:30:07
Pages 2, 3, and 4 are abuse of driver bills.
00:30:11
I'm not going to walk you through all those.
00:30:13
Basically, they all say the same thing.
00:30:17
In terms of land use, we are still seeing some bills dealing with land use or different components of land use, including development rights and impact fees, which is on page 7.
00:30:36
And there's a couple other categories.
00:30:38
So far, I do want to point out that all the bills have yet to be introduced.
00:30:42
They can still introduce bills.
00:30:43
I think it's through Friday of this week, so we're not done yet.
00:30:47
The other category, we have not seen a tremendous number of bills, but we've seen some that would have tremendous policy implication, which is on our PPTA program, where, for example, we had a bill introduced that would not allow us to look at doing hot lanes on 95-395.
00:31:04
So that is one that we are working closely with the patron on and working to educate him on the whole use of our public-private program.
00:31:15
On the bottom of page 9, there are 15 bills for those of you from Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia that in some form modify the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority or the Hampton Roads Transportation Authority.
00:31:28
For Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, most of the bills there are either technical cleanup bills or they may change the structure of the taxes and fees that can be imposed.
00:31:42
For Hampton Roads, the bills run the gamut from repeal the Hampton Roads Transportation Authority to change their tax and fee structure to giving them additional power.
00:31:52
So there's a variety of bills there.
00:31:55
There are three, well actually four revenue sharing bills, two of which on the bottom of page 10, House Bill 111 and Senate Bill 99, which represent a compromise position that we were able to reach last year with the General Assembly about the revenue sharing program.
00:32:16
And we are working with all the patrons of those bills to get to one bill for the rest of the session so that we can have that subject go through the General Assembly smoothly.
00:32:28
What it would do, the compromise bill would get rid of the million dollar requirement.
00:32:33
for Match, but it still would require the priority setting so that if a local government said we'll invest $700,000, we're asking for $500,000 from the revenue sharing program, they would still receive a priority, but the highest priority would be local administration of the project.
00:32:52
So we are working on that effort now.
00:33:00
That's pretty much, I guess, overall all the ones that are the most significant.
00:33:07
There are, beginning on page 14, a number of transportation funding bills that change the allocation formula.
00:33:14
To be honest, this is a much lower number than what we traditionally see each year.
00:33:18
and bottom line is without revenues to support any change in the formula there are winners and losers and most of the time these bills decrease funding on the primary system for example to all the more rural districts and increase the funding in the more urban districts.
00:33:35
So with that, I'll be happy to answer any questions about specific pieces of legislation.
00:33:41
As the Secretary mentioned, Nick Donohue and our Office of the Assistant Secretary is the lead on keeping us organized on that along with the great staff here at VDOT.
00:33:50
Margaret Redford and Keith Martin and the Policy Director keeps us on top of things, but we can answer questions on any individual bill that you may have.
00:34:02
And with that I'll just briefly go through the budget.
00:34:05
I would highly recommend this transportation summary you have, which is a written document.
00:34:10
This is actually the document that the Senate Finance and House Appropriations Committee staff put together jointly every year at the beginning of the session to provide the overview
00:34:20
of the Governor's budget proposal.
00:34:22
It's very well done.
00:34:23
It's written in layman's terms and it's short and sweetened to the point.
00:34:27
You don't have to read through the arcaneness of budget language to understand it.
00:34:30
So if you have a few minutes, you might want to read that.
00:34:34
We really have made no significant proposals in terms of the Department of Rail and Public Transportation or VDOT.
00:34:42
In DRPT, the one area I will point out that is included and it is on page
00:34:52
400 of the document that's the actual budget pages, paragraph E, and certainly Mr. Tucker can speak to this more.
00:35:02
We have included language to try to work toward more public benefit and maintenance of effort activities for all the public transit and rail programs.
00:35:11
That is something, as you know, we've tried to do systematically through the rail enhancement fund, and we have offered language that would begin to lay out that process.
00:35:22
The other significant item in the Department of Rail and Public Transportation from a funding perspective is that there is language included in the governor's budget that would allow this board to authorize Mr. Tucker to have no more than three percent of a total project cost for project administration compliance and management out of his office.
00:35:43
One of the things that we've discovered is as you, particularly on the rail enhancement fund projects where you have
00:35:50
The intermodal site work being done and then you have Norfolk light rail safety compliance and all these different activities.
00:36:00
There is no source of funding for Mr. Tucker and the agency to bring in consultant support or help or to even pay for some additional resources there.
00:36:08
So this is just language that gives them the authority to be able to have a way of funding for that kind of work.
00:36:15
And the only other issue or item that's fairly new that we don't know how the General Assembly will react to it, we think positively from all indications is on page, at the bottom of page 400, top of page 401, where we are putting some process and parameters and dates around the rail plan and moving forward to have passenger rail service in the 95 corridor as well as other corridors in Virginia.
00:36:44
With that, I'll turn to VDOT.
00:36:46
To be perfectly honest, there is no change of any significance in the VDOT language in the budget.
00:36:54
The numbers for the various programs are based on House Bill 3202 and on the items that you were briefed on in December, but we've taken on no new initiatives or anything in their budget.
00:37:06
That is, it's fairly a stagnant budget for the most part.
00:37:10
And with that, enjoy your afternoon.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:15
Any questions of Ms. Race?
00:37:17
Mr. Koelemay.
00:37:17
One question.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:19
Barbara, we've read in the paper just this morning that the governor is hinting strongly that there may be a revenue re-estimate in February.
00:37:30
Can you give us some indication on how that might affect transportation per se?
Barbara W. Reese
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:37:35
Well, two areas where we would have the greatest concerns and the two areas that will likely, if there are signs that there needs to be a revenue re-forecast will happen are in recordation taxes, which are the new source of funding that is going primarily to the public transportation program starting in July, was two cents of the recordation tax as well as one cent of the recordation going to highway maintenance.
00:38:02
So if those
00:38:03
Revenues turned down, there will be a decrease in those items.
00:38:07
The second area is the sales and use tax.
00:38:10
One of the things that we forget is that the Transportation Trust Fund receives a half a percent of that sales and use tax revenue.
00:38:17
So when you hear about declining sales, December sales information came out and it was abysmal.
00:38:24
If there is, that would be another area likely that would be down.
00:38:29
The other thing is we all have to recognize as gas goes over $3 or hoovers around $3 a gallon, our tax is not based on a percentage, it is a percent as people drive less or adjust to try to deal with that higher gas prices and energy prices overall.
00:38:47
I know I got my first heating bill for the year and it was not a pleasant experience.
00:38:52
That we expect those revenues will continue to be shaky.
00:38:56
We've already lost, if you recall from December, $400 million out of the revenue estimate for the six years based on a weakening economy.
00:39:07
But we'll keep you informed as we know.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:09
Okay, any other questions of Ms. Reese?
00:39:13
I would add the starting point right now for reductions in the existing six-year program is $400 million.
00:39:21
If the abusive driving fees are eliminated by the General Assembly and agreed to by the Governor, that's about another $400 million.
00:39:32
If there are federal rescissions, remember the Federal Highway Trust Fund is also in a deficit posture, the numbers, the reductions could continue to grow.
00:39:40
And that's based on the current revenue estimates.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:44
Maybe this is not the topic of losing the money from the abusers possibility of having our six-year budget reduced by that $385,000.
00:39:56
There are a number of ideas floating about.
00:40:03
Is the administration optimistic that that gap
00:40:08
might be filled or it really is the will of the General Assembly or how to, is there anything we can do?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:16
The Governor has said that he is open to revenue replacements particularly on a larger scale in April when he did reach a compromise on House Bill 3202 acknowledged the gap in maintenance funding.
00:40:34
was the largest single piece of business before the General Assembly and was not fully addressed by any stretch of the imagination.
00:40:44
So there was last April an identified gap of about $260 million annually, but that's the gap between the amount that is transferred out of construction and into maintenance on an annual basis.
00:40:59
That number, as we all know, grows a little bit or a lot.
00:41:03
depending upon your perspective each and every year.
00:41:05
So that dynamic is still with us.
00:41:08
The elimination of the abusive driving fees just exacerbates that trend.
00:41:16
I would also, while Mr. Donohue is coming up, there is something at your places, which is 2007 Accomplishments and Goals.
00:41:24
You received a copy of this electronically.
00:41:26
This has been briefed to the two transportation committees and the two transportation subcommittees.
00:41:34
In 2007, it's worth going back just like the commissioner did with some of the awards that look at some of the significant progress that occurred
00:41:43
Programmatically, in terms of business practices, in terms of projects, in terms of programs, there are also a list of some goals for the upcoming year.
00:41:53
They are project oriented, some of them are program oriented.
00:41:57
There is also a list of challenges.
00:42:00
Some of those challenges are financial but by far our biggest challenge is highway safety and we did cross a very terrible threshold this year and we as Commonwealth Transportation Board have an obligation to respond to that challenge of over 1,000 fatalities this year and we'll be talking about each and every meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board that's coming here.
00:42:26
The next item on our agenda is the secondary street acceptance regulations.
00:42:31
This is a periodic update from Mr. Donohue.
00:42:34
Welcome, Mr. Donohue.
00:42:35
Thank you, Mr.
00:42:35
Chair.
SPEAKER_00
00:42:36
My name is Nick Donohue and I'm here to provide the board with an update on the development of the secondary street acceptance requirements.
00:42:44
As a reminder, this initiative is a result of legislation that was proposed by Governor Paine in the 2007 General Assembly session and was unanimously passed by the General Assembly.
00:42:54
And the intent of this initiative is to ensure that streets accepted for VDOT for perpetual public maintenance provide a public benefit.
00:43:01
The enabling legislation includes several mandatory provisions.
00:43:05
It states that the regulation shall include provisions to ensure the connectivity of road and pedestrian networks.
00:43:12
Provisions to address performance bonding and other cost recovery mechanisms, and provisions to minimize stormwater runoff and reduce impervious surface area through reduced streetways.
00:43:22
The Secretary hasn't paneled an implementation advisory committee which consists of representatives from the development, local government community, and other stakeholders.
00:43:31
This committee has worked five times to review and refine draft regulation.
00:43:35
In addition to this committee, there is a VDOT technical committee that consists of district representatives as well as central office staff that has been meeting throughout this process and will continue to meet to address the technical issues of this regulation.
00:43:49
I'd like to share with the board a tentative timeline that we have sketched out for the development of this regulation.
00:43:55
We welcome any comments you all have on this timeline.
00:43:58
Currently we have ongoing outreach with several localities and look to expand that outreach.
00:44:04
We also have outreach with several developers.
00:44:06
I believe tomorrow VDOT staff will be meeting with
00:44:10
members of the Region 2000 MPO, as well as meeting with members from the TASMO delegation with Mr.
00:44:16
Keen.
00:44:17
I've been in contact with many of our partners in the private sector and we will continue that outreach and we will expand it as we move forward.
00:44:26
Once we, after this outreach is conducted, we hope to publish the regulation for public comment either in February, March, or April so we can hear from a wide community as well as hear additional comments from those who we previously spoke with
00:44:39
After the public comment is solicited and a public hearing is held, it is our intent that the Implementation Advisory Committee will be reconvened to review these public comments and find a draft regulation based on those public comments.
00:44:53
After they have refined the regulation, we will reinitiate outreach with localities and developers to get additional public comments.
00:45:01
And after that, I anticipate that we would bring the regulation to the CTB for final action in late summer or fall of this year.
00:45:08
As we have stated throughout this process, we will continue to brief this body on the development of the regulation.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:16
And Mr. Donohue, it's the clear understanding of staff that the publication of an initial draft regulation will not occur without review and discussion by the Commonwealth Transportation Board prior to publication for advertisement.
SPEAKER_00
00:45:34
Certainly, and that was my mistake in not mentioning that fact.
00:45:36
Thank you for clarifying that.
00:45:39
There are several just key high-level points I'd like to hit with the board, and I believe one of the most important ones that we have not previously discussed is the vesting provisions.
00:45:49
The regulation will recognize vested property rights and valid site plans, preliminary site plans, proffered rezonings, and subdivision plats that were approved prior to the effect of this regulation may be accepted under formal requirements.
00:46:04
This is a very important issue.
00:46:07
We can't administratively undo a vested property right which is granted in the code.
00:46:16
Recognizing the diversity of the Commonwealth from the varying levels of development and the needs of the Commonwealth, as we have previously briefed the Board, the regulation would recommend establishing three area types, compact, suburban, and rural.
00:46:29
These area types will be based on federal, regional, and local planning boundaries.
00:46:34
The regulation also includes provisions that allow the local governing body to request a modification of the area type if they believe that it may not be appropriate.
00:46:44
And this would be in areas where the comprehensive plan designates 10-acre lots and it's out in the western part of Loudoun.
00:46:53
Perhaps that shouldn't be in a certain area type and the local governing body could request a change.
00:47:01
The connectivity requirements is one of the mandatory provisions of this regulation and I believe it's the real meat of this regulation.
00:47:08
So I would like to just discuss some of the benefits of connectivity.
00:47:12
By having connected local street network, we can help keep the local trips off of the regional network.
00:47:18
In many areas of the state where developments have one way in and one way out, short local trips that otherwise could take place on local roads are forced out into the regional transportation network, which causes problems both for those local travelers as well as through regional traffic.
00:47:35
By improving this connectivity we can help reduce some of the trips that utilize the Regional Transportation Network and improve emergency response times.
00:47:49
The connectivity requirements that are in the draft regulation vary based on area type.
00:47:57
The link-node ratio requirement, and if the board will recall, a link is a segment of street that exists or a stub-out or a cul-de-sac, and a node is the end of a cul-de-sac or the intersection of several streets.
00:48:10
And the length-node ratio requirement that is proposed for compact area types is 1.6 or higher.
00:48:17
And I would like to remind the board that the compact area type is generally, the way it is laid out would be in areas where higher growth is anticipated to take place, such as urban development areas, transfer of development right receiving areas, and other areas of infill development.
00:48:32
There's also a requirement for external connectivity and that requirement would be one external connection as well as an additional external connection to dove out for every 50 links within a network addition.
00:48:45
Network additions within the suburban area type would need to have a link node ratio of 1.4 or above as well as and have the same external connectivity that is required of the compact area type.
00:48:57
In the rural areas, there is no link node ratio requirement recognizing the level of development and topography that tends to exist.
00:49:05
There's only connection for external connectivity.
00:49:13
And I understand that looking at 1.6 and 1.4 really can be hard to understand without seeing that in context.
00:49:19
So here are just several examples of link-node ratios I wanted to share with the board.
00:49:24
If you look at the image on the top left there, that's a Gridge Street network.
00:49:28
It has a link-node ratio of over 2.5, which is generally the peak that can be reached for link-node ratios.
00:49:35
And then if you look at the graphic in the middle,
00:49:37
That is an example of a development that is the link node ratio of one.
00:49:41
That is the lowest link node ratio that can be achieved assuming that the streets connect to other streets.
00:49:47
The graphic below the grid street system shows an example of a network addition that would meet the proposed compact area link node ratio requirements.
00:49:57
And then the graphic on the far right there shows an example of a network addition that would meet the proposed suburban area type network addition requirements.
00:50:09
One thing I want to stress to the board is that these connectivity requirements are not absolutes.
00:50:14
We understand that there will be instances and circumstances where these provisions cannot be met and there will be exceptions in the draft regulation.
00:50:23
Currently, there are exceptions for incompatible land use, such as detached single-family housing next to a factory.
00:50:29
In those instances, the actual connectivity requirements would be waived.
00:50:33
The requirements could also be waived when terrain such as mountains, rivers, or other physical impedances such as limit access highway would make it difficult, if not impossible, to meet the requirements.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:47
Mr. Donohue, who would determine whether a particular project would qualify for these exceptions?
SPEAKER_00
00:50:53
The district administrator or his designee as the regulation is currently drafted.
00:51:03
And another thing I want to stress with the board that I failed to mention in my previous presentations and I apologize for that.
00:51:09
The connectivity requirements will not apply to rural addition roads or industrial or economic access roads.
00:51:15
Those roads will continue to be governed by the same criteria that governs our acceptance into the system today.
00:51:22
Another provision in the draft regulation is conditional acceptance, where if allowed by a locality, a developer may choose to meet their link node ratio requirement through the use of stub outs.
00:51:39
And this would be a situation where the developer
00:51:42
J. Thomas III, Michael A. Thomas III, Michael A. Thomas III,
00:52:06
These provisions would not apply to the majority of subdivisions and do not apply to stub outs that are required to meet the external connectivity requirements.
00:52:19
The second mandatory provision of the legislation is, or another mandatory provision, excuse me, of the legislation is the requirement for pedestrian connectivity in compact area types, which as I mentioned earlier, areas where we, based on their planning designation, we anticipate denser growth.
00:52:36
Sidewalks will be required along both sides of the street.
00:52:39
In suburban areas, developers will have several options.
00:52:43
They may provide sidewalks along both sides of the streets or they may use a system of trails and sidewalks which provides general pedestrian mobility and accessibility throughout the development.
00:52:54
And in certain areas in the suburban area type where the developments have lots that are generally two acres or larger, they may provide a sidewalk along one side of the street or just a system of trails.
00:53:05
In rural area types, draft regulation proposes that a system of trails or sidewalk along one side of the street would be acceptable.
00:53:13
However, on streets where the annual daily traffic is anticipated to be 200 vehicles or less, the pedestrian accommodation requirements would be waived.
00:53:27
The last mandatory provision of the legislation is to address performance bonding and other cost recovery requirements.
00:53:35
The performance bonding has been increased in the draft regulation from $2,000 per 10th of lane mile to $3,000 per 10th of lane mile.
00:53:44
This increase is based on the increase in highway construction CPI, which since the development of the former requirements has gone up somewhere around 40%, I do believe.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:54
Mr. Chairman, the last issue just before the surety, you were talking about 200 cars per day?
00:54:05
Yes, sir.
00:54:05
How was that chosen?
00:54:09
Because a lot of rural roads that I'm familiar with, 300 cars a day is very common, very rural roads.
00:54:16
Why did you choose 200?
SPEAKER_00
00:54:17
The reason we chose this number is in the, if you recall, the traffic impact analysis regulations.
00:54:25
This body as well as VDOT established several measures of pedestrian quality of service.
00:54:30
And so using several of the methodologies that are in that regulation, we evaluated various street conditions.
00:54:36
For traffic to see where the level of service or quality of service at sea could be achieved and generally based on the aggregate of those analysis of 200 vehicles per day is what was chosen.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:49
I'm familiar with a lot of unpaved roads out in the area that have 300 cars a day.
00:54:54
I would see no reason in the world to put a sidewalk along those unpaved roads.
00:55:04
It just seems like it's an unreasonably low number to me.
00:55:09
I just wondered if there was a basis for choosing the 200 as opposed to 500.
00:55:16
Because even 500 a day, if you break it up over a 24-hour period, that's what you do, isn't it 24 hours?
00:55:22
Yes, sir.
00:55:23
That's still not very much traffic.
SPEAKER_00
00:55:28
Well, and we do understand in terms of we will revisit this issue and do some additional analysis.
00:55:33
This number was just, as I said, chosen based on, with the goal of providing an adequate quality of service for the pedestrians in those areas.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:42
I just want to understand something about compact area types.
00:55:51
Is it correct that compact area types can exist, be identified and exist in rural areas, for example as towns and villages?
00:56:01
in rural areas where even though you may have overall a rural county, the compact area type requirements would apply.
SPEAKER_00
00:56:13
That is accurate.
00:56:14
There is flexibility in the area type designations that would allow a local governing body to designate any area within their locality to apply to either the suburban or compact area types if you were in a rural area type.
00:56:26
And there are also provisions that if there's a town or other growth area designated within the comprehensive plan that those areas would either fall into the suburban or compact area type as opposed to the rural area type.
00:56:40
So for example, Warrington and Flockhire County would fall into the compact area.
SPEAKER_15
00:56:52
Mr. Dickens.
00:56:54
Briefly, how do you plan to coordinate these rules with the local government rules and regulations?
SPEAKER_00
00:57:03
Well I would say that first we need to have continued outreach with the local governments to discuss what is proposed for the area types as well as the requirements.
00:57:11
But after that I would believe that the residency administrators and the local government bodies could work together to identify the areas that would be affected based on local planning decisions.
00:57:21
And I would imagine that the changes wouldn't be something that would occur overnight but rather be something that would be updated every year or several years.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:34
Mr. McCarthy.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:35
Should I ask now or wait till he finishes the last page or two?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:40
Fire away.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:41
I assume that many of us sent you comments back in mid-December when you'd asked for them.
00:57:47
You know I did.
00:57:50
What happens with those?
00:57:51
Like I had several questions and comments and I don't recall getting a response.
SPEAKER_00
00:57:59
I apologize.
00:58:00
I do not believe I received comments from Mr. McCarthy.
00:58:05
However, I will go back and see if I may have overlooked those and will provide you with responses to any questions you may have raised.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:11
Well, you could look for December 12th at 10 a.m. As I said, I apologize if I failed to respond to you.
SPEAKER_00
00:58:19
That was an oversight of my part, and I will respond to you by the end of the week.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:24
Ms. McCarthy, if you have a copy of that, you might want to leave that with Mr. Donohue.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:28
Right, right.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:32
Any other questions on that page?
SPEAKER_00
00:58:36
Okay.
00:58:36
As I was saying, the performance bonding requirements have been increased to reflect the inflation and highway cost, and the length of the surety varies based on the type of inspection process that is used.
00:58:50
For example, if a developer relies on a local certification process, such as the one that exists in Prince William County, the surety would be completely waived.
00:58:58
If a developer relied on the normal standard VDOT inspection process, which is a less robust inspection process and some of the other alternatives that are provided in the regulation, the surety would need to exist for three years.
00:59:12
The regulation also increases the administrative cost recovery fee from $2,500 per tenth of a two-lane roadway to $3,000.
00:59:23
And this increase is based on a study that the Virginia Transportation Research Council conducted during 2006 and 2007 where it examined the cost of VDOT's land development activities and that it was determined that the current costs were
00:59:40
were far below what was necessary to recover VDOT's expenses.
00:59:46
The regulation also includes a $1,500 per lane mile inspection fee to help VDOT recover its cost of inspecting these roadways prior to acceptance into the system.
01:00:01
Several other provisions that are in the regulation.
01:00:03
The regulation contains a defined appeals process with set timeframes for VDOT response.
01:00:11
The regulation will also, excuse me, the subdivision street design guide will also contain street lists that vary based on whether or not there's on the street parking or off street parking.
01:00:23
Another change in the regulation is that stormwater management facilities will be allowed within the VDOT right-of-way provided an agreement is signed with the locality that absolves VDOT of any liability.
01:00:34
And there's also provision in the regulation that says all parties shall take steps to minimize the impact of cut-through traffic
SPEAKER_17
01:00:42
With your permission Mr.
01:00:44
Chair, what would be examples of steps that could minimize the impact of cut-through traffic?
SPEAKER_00
01:00:51
Several examples would be basing the street with us on whether or not there is on-the-street parking.
01:00:57
In a lot of instances, a street would be built 36 or 40 feet wide to accommodate on-the-street parking.
01:01:03
However, every house that is on that segment of street has a two-car garage as well as a driveway which can easily accommodate another four or five vehicles.
01:01:14
So what you've ended up with is a situation where very few people
01:01:19
I have a park on the street and we have a street that is wider than some would say is necessary so drivers who are on the streets feel more comfortable traveling at higher speeds which can, one, residents generally don't like higher speeds in front of their houses and can also create conflicts with kids playing in the street.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:39
I think one of the, that's traditional traffic calming, so it might be narrower streets, it might be speed humps, it could be traffic circles, I mean there are a variety of techniques that are employed today in neighborhoods throughout the Commonwealth.
SPEAKER_00
01:01:59
And with that I'd be happy to entertain any questions the board may have.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:05
The official vote on this is when?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:07
Well, the board has to authorize at some point in spring or summer a draft regulation for publication and that is subject then to public comment and then the current schedule calls for summer fall adoption based on that public commentary.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:28
Mr. Chairman, let me extend thanks to Nick and you and the staff for taking into consideration concerns that I had when we were in run off addressing some of those concerns and the fact that we will now have counties and local governments involved
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:45
Mr. Chairman, let me chime in as well with thanks because there has been a considerable amount of concern in my district about these proposed regulations and the staff has been very quick in an outreach effort
01:03:07
to one of the local MPOs and perhaps there will be another one that will want to have a presentation but he made reference to the fact there will be a presentation tomorrow afternoon in Lynchburg to that MPO.
01:03:18
And for those board members who have not availed themselves of that resource, that will be a great way.
01:03:26
I'm looking forward to getting a lot of local feedback from that session.
01:03:30
So I would encourage you to contact the staff if you'd like those kind of presentations in your district.
01:03:38
And thank you very much for providing that service.
SPEAKER_12
01:03:45
Go back to the fee of $3,000, I believe that's what it is, right?
01:03:50
Yes ma'am.
01:03:50
And that's the fee that doesn't exist at all now, right?
SPEAKER_00
01:03:53
No, this fee does exist today.
01:03:55
It's $2,000 per 10th of lane mile and we're increasing it
01:03:59
based on the increase in highway construction CPI.
SPEAKER_12
01:04:04
And who pays for this?
SPEAKER_00
01:04:07
This would be a bond that the developer would take.
SPEAKER_12
01:04:11
I know that.
01:04:12
The reason I ask that is because, of course, that's passed on to the homeowner.
01:04:19
You have nothing to do with that.
01:04:20
That's okay.
01:04:21
You're doing your job and I appreciate what you've done.
01:04:25
It's just a concern of how much more we create and how much more we do to pass on to a homeowner who cannot afford homes at this present time and that's my concern.
SPEAKER_00
01:04:40
And we do understand those concerns and that's why one of the things we've sought to do in this regulation is provide several
01:04:45
Alternatives to surety such as utilizing the local certification process or other means that are spelled out in the regulation, which in those instances the surety would be waived or reduced.
SPEAKER_15
01:05:00
Nick, would you go back to the slide with the grid pattern on it?
01:05:05
I'm not sure I understand the external connector.
01:05:10
If I remember correctly, your description said
01:05:13
One external connector, and do I understand that external connector not being the exit from the subdivision to the main street, but to an adjacent subdivision?
01:05:28
Am I right or wrong there?
01:05:31
Straighten me out, please.
SPEAKER_00
01:05:32
I believe you may have a little bit of a misunderstanding.
01:05:34
What the intent for that provision was is that for every network addition, there would be at least one external connection.
01:05:43
And then in addition to that, there'd be another second external connection as well as a stub app.
01:05:49
And as the size of the network addition increased,
01:05:52
So would the requirements for the external connectivity.
01:05:55
So say if your development had a hundred links, which is a very substantial size development, it would need to have four external connections and two stub outs.
01:06:05
Or if it saw fit, six external connections.
SPEAKER_15
01:06:08
Is the stub out the connection to the adjacent neighborhood?
SPEAKER_00
01:06:14
And depending on whether or not this is infill development or greenfield and the conditions that exist around it, the stubout could be that site for future connection to the joint parcel or that external connection could be to a stubout that exists on a parcel that was already developed.
SPEAKER_15
01:06:30
Well, where I'm headed with all this is I'm concerned that we're
01:06:34
The external connections are putting everybody in the neighborhood back out on the main road and not providing opportunities for people to go to adjacent neighborhoods or businesses or whatever without getting back out on the major road.
01:06:49
Am I missing something here?
SPEAKER_00
01:06:51
Well, and that would be at the discretion of the developer.
01:06:55
However, the hope and intent would be that some of these connections would be on the main roads and then other connections would be with other local roads.
01:07:02
However, we didn't think it would be appropriate to put in very restricted requirements stating that one of these connections must be on another roadway designated as local just because that would put in another appeals or exceptions process and might, you know, create conflict with certain conditions on the ground.
SPEAKER_17
01:07:21
Somebody correct me if my memory is falling.
01:07:24
One of the first things I remember when I came on the board was we set up a mandate to consider bicycle accommodation with new construction, and if that is correct,
01:07:37
Would we want to make the same expectation of developers or is that covered under pedestrian accommodations?
SPEAKER_00
01:07:44
I believe the way the regulation is written it does reference the CTB policy that was adopted in 2004 and then spells out some additional guidance that builds upon that policy.
SPEAKER_17
01:07:55
Okay, so that would be in the fine print in the text.
SPEAKER_00
01:07:57
Yes, sir.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:00
Nick, we had a case in Richmond not so long ago where a developer wanted to do the right thing according to this.
01:08:07
It's not adopted yet, but they were going to have connectivity within the subdivision and then an external whatever that was going to connect to an adjacent existing subdivision.
01:08:18
which seemed like a good idea on paper until the existing subdivision found out about it.
01:08:27
How do you deal with that in these regulations?
01:08:31
Because that would be an external link from a proposed one, but it would be going someplace where it might not be wanted by the adjacent subdivision.
01:08:43
I'm not even sure what my question is here.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:49
Mr. McCarthy, I think the issue is that those are what are known as inter-parcel connectors and they may or may not be an external connection as Mr. Donohue was talking about.
01:09:01
Those are a requirement today.
01:09:05
However, they may be weighed by local governing bodies.
01:09:09
And the issue here, and you're right, this will generate local controversy and some of our newly elected members are going to experience this pain first hand.
01:09:19
But if there is not conductivity, you're pushing the traffic out onto the main street.
01:09:24
That's one of the major objectives of these regulations.
01:09:28
And one of my observations, having worked for many years in those wonderful vineyards of local government, is if they say my hands are tied, I have to approve these, that it is not, today is not a strong requirement.
01:09:42
It does indeed create, in some cases, that citizen opposition.
SPEAKER_14
01:09:50
Don't I understand though from the regulations if the first community does not accept that the roads come out of the system?
SPEAKER_00
01:09:59
That's the way I read that.
01:10:02
That situation would only exist if the initial development that was put in place chose to use stub outs to meet their link node ratio requirement and in that instance they would first have to receive approval from the local governing body to do so.
SPEAKER_14
01:10:16
But if they use stub outs, that's what the new development would be tying into, wouldn't it?
01:10:21
So the only way the new development would tie into an existing is if the existing had stub outs, which were approved.
01:10:28
Therefore, back to the question, if the existing doesn't, you know, they've got a stub out, but they don't want the new neighborhood to connect into them, do they lose their streets?
01:10:36
Do those streets come out of the system?
SPEAKER_00
01:10:39
only if the initial development if you look at some of the examples up here assume we are in the suburban area types so if you look at the graphic on the far right there
01:10:48
Only if we took out, if that internal street network had reduced, if some of those links were missing and there were more cul-de-sacs in that initial one, and to make up for the presence of those cul-de-sacs, additional stub outs were provided.
01:11:00
Only in that instance would the conditional acceptance apply.
01:11:05
All the examples you see here, even if they had stub outs and those stub outs were never connected to, they would continue to remain in the system.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:14
Mr. Koelemay One final comment, Mr. Chairman.
01:11:17
We struggle with Northern Virginia constantly with what I call the fallacy of cut-through traffic.
01:11:23
The fact isn't a public facility that can't be cut through traffic because it's a public facility.
01:11:30
And that's what we all need to understand is that our protection of the system really is our top priority here.
01:11:37
I mean, there's others who will argue the protection of the neighborhoods and the protection of individual streets.
01:11:42
But I would like to even see that removed from your nomenclature and presentation and so forth.
01:11:48
The idea of cut-through traffic is a set of assumptions that may or may not exist.
01:11:55
It's not cut-through traffic if a fire truck is trying to get to a home on fire, for example.
01:12:01
and I understand people own their neighborhoods but in fact if these are going to be public streets maintained by the state we need to make sure that that's understood as a primary objective not as a secondary.
SPEAKER_15
01:12:16
And I'd like to agree with Mr. Koelemay and what you said earlier.
01:12:20
This whole thing is about trying to help keep traffic off of the major streets.
01:12:26
And if we water it down to a point where we're not strongly encouraging the connectivity between neighborhoods, we've not really accomplished a whole lot.
01:12:37
I would support as making it as strong as we can to encourage that sort of positive behavior.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:49
Any other questions or comments?
01:12:52
Mr. Donohue, is there an actual revised draft of the regulations that's the basis for the presentation today?
SPEAKER_00
01:12:59
I'm currently churning the latest draft.
01:13:02
The General Assembly has slowed my progress slightly.
01:13:04
However, I anticipate I could probably finish one over the weekend.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:08
Okay.
01:13:09
Again, I don't think it's necessarily that urgent, but this is an iterative process, and every time we are able to focus collective wisdom on that and provide informed comments,
01:13:21
This is such a diverse state, and what works in Bristol probably doesn't work on the Eastern Shore.
01:13:28
And so that's the challenge of writing a regulation like this, and where your valued input, advice, and guidance, again, given the regional diversity of this group, is so very important.
01:13:40
So if you would please send that out once again, and when you do that, you make that available to the Policy Committee and to other folks who are involved in the drafting process.
01:13:49
It is, in effect, a public document, correct?
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:51
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
01:13:56
Nick, I just wanted to say that I really do appreciate what you're doing on this, and I think we all recognize that when you break new ground like this, it's very, very difficult.
01:14:07
in terms of trying to address in advance so many of the issues but we also recognize that inevitably when these regulations get adopted circumstances will come up subsequently where we'll look at them and we'll say oops we need to refine it in one
01:14:23
way or another and so echoing the chairman's comments it'll be an iterative process not only between now and the time we adopt the regulations but subsequently as well and there'll be no lack of comments and criticisms I'm sure even after they're adopted but I do want to thank you for the hard work you're doing on this.
01:14:45
Thank you.
01:14:45
Good job.
01:14:46
Well said.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:48
Okay, Mr. Dottie.
SPEAKER_00
01:14:50
And one thing I would just like to inform or let the board know is Delaware has recently revised their street standards and have attempted to address some of the same issues and have some of the same goals that our initiative has and they actually use lake node ratio to measure connectivity throughout their state.
01:15:07
So I just wanted to let the board know that and if you would like I could send a copy of those regulations along to you all.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:13
Will that reduce the toll on the Delaware Bridge?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:18
I don't believe so.
01:15:19
That's a three-county state.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:23
They'll be so busy circling around in their internal street system they won't.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:28
Okay, any other final questions or comments?
01:15:34
Ms. Donnie, thank you.
01:15:35
This is a Herculean task.
01:15:36
and we do appreciate your outreach efforts and the great staff work.
01:15:40
Commissioner as well you've been devoting a lot of internal resources to this and I think this is to the point where again I know you have this underway but so that folks understand the individual districts are starting to pull this apart.
01:15:56
I think there's a good framework here where some of the major issues have been resolved and it's important to view these through the prism of individual
SPEAKER_12
01:16:04
Thank you for passing those comments along
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:28
The next item on the agenda number four is the Breachans 2035.
01:16:33
We've advanced from 2025.
01:16:37
Moving the vision forward, Deputy Secretary Ralph Davis will be presenting.
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:16:43
Welcome, Mr. Davis.
01:16:48
VTrans 2025, there's a lot of discussion in my presentation about VTrans 2025.
01:16:55
About six of you were involved on a panel several years ago to do VTrans 2025.
01:17:06
And to get those of you who were not engaged in that process, if I can get this up here.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:25
Can we get Mrs. Connally to autograph this session?
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:17:44
While we're here next, Frank, first, we have to have defense 2025 to let you know what we have done to defense 2025, but those individuals were not involved.
01:17:58
With my PowerPoint, the first slide starts to talk some about the legislative department.
01:18:05
Your department will often do a long-term plan every five years.
01:18:16
You're required in law to do a long-range plan every five years.
01:18:21
There's also a COPA vision which requires the Office of Intermodal Planning and Investment to assist you in doing a long-range plan, and I'm the Office of Intermodal Planning and Investment.
01:18:33
So my charge today is to work with you in terms of developing your long-range, next round-range transportation plan.
01:18:41
One of the things I wanted to do was briefly talk a little bit about VTrans 2025.
01:18:46
And in the dark, I'll just hand it out.
01:18:50
If you would turn to page 13, I'll run through a couple of these things.
01:18:55
We did VTrans 2025, and we actually have lots of results.
01:18:58
If you go to page, and I'm not gonna go through these in detail, but if you look at page 13 of this dark minute, it talks about recommendations.
01:19:12
One of those recommendations dealt with land use.
01:19:16
And look at the bottom of what it said was address transportation land use conflict.
01:19:22
The General Assembly should address the conflict that arises from the separations of authority for transportation of land use.
01:19:30
That's what we were saying back in 2002-2004.
01:19:34
What has happened?
01:19:37
We've seen some results as a result of the recommendations that you made.
01:19:43
Connectivity, it says thanks multimodally.
01:19:47
We're still working there.
01:19:48
That's where we still need to continue to make improvements.
01:19:51
We're not quite there.
01:19:53
Priorities study, I want to look on page 14, it says plan multimodally.
01:19:58
You've detected this criteria.
01:20:00
We're making progress in that area as well.
01:20:03
Other kinds of things in here, one of the major recommendations was that we needed a substantial investment in transportation.
01:20:12
That was made by you back in 2004.
01:20:15
And as a result of that, we've seen significant investment in transportation.
01:20:21
Transportation plans normally don't have a very good, very long shelf span.
01:20:26
But I think with VTrans 2025, we have seen results from the recommendations that you have made.
01:20:34
Hopefully with VTrans 2035, we will see something very similar.
01:20:39
Background.
01:20:42
We established a vision, and that vision was we wanted a safe, strategic, and seamless transportation system.
01:20:48
I would not go through these, but I think that it's important that we talk about vision and goals, that we continue to talk about that same vision and goals.
01:20:56
And I think if I say it often enough, four or five years, just keep saying safe, strategic, and seamless, that sooner or later we believe it.
01:21:08
The thing about a vision is it's not something that we can accomplish in one or two or three years.
01:21:14
If we want a safe, strategic, and seamless transportation system, that's something fairly far out.
01:21:20
And one of the things you can see in this presentation is the theme is moving the vision forward.
01:21:25
And what that is, is we cannot achieve that particular vision in our two, three, four years since the plan was last done.
01:21:32
It's really a long-term kind of thing.
01:21:34
So that's something, the theme of this whole presentation is that we need to, or for B-Trans 2035, is that we need to move the vision forward.
01:21:42
More background, again, I won't go through all of this.
01:21:45
The board did adopt the plan long-range goals back in 2004.
01:21:50
One of the things that happened with VTrans 2025 was that we were reviewed by the Joint Legislative Audit Review Commission.
01:21:59
And that was a day of relief for me because they kind of put the gold seal with this such a thing.
01:22:03
When J.
01:22:04
Luck talked out and said your methodology and your numbers and so forth are reasonable, which is what they said, it kind of gave credence to all the work that we've done for three to four years.
01:22:15
And they said the methodology, the numbers, we had some big numbers in this report in terms of what the needs were.
01:22:21
And J.
01:22:22
Luck reviewed it and said the methodology and numbers were reasonable.
01:22:26
On the other side, in 2005, the APA looked at what we had done and said we still lacked, we lacked a coordinated transportation plan.
01:22:36
We had worked four years trying to coordinate.
01:22:38
We still have stovepipe planning.
01:22:40
We have transit, we have roads, we have air force, we have ports.
01:22:44
That's part of this seamless, that's where we need to get.
01:22:47
We're not quite there yet.
01:22:50
Another plus is that when I started this thing in 2002 within Governor Warner, one of the challenges was to Governor Warner is do I talk at all about revenues?
01:23:03
Because I came out in an environment where you just could not talk about revenue needs and transportation.
01:23:09
You just would not talk about it.
01:23:12
And I was hesitant to talk to Governor Warner about having some revenue or comparing revenue and needs.
01:23:18
Over time we were able to talk about it and eventually the numbers that we had kind of framed the debate in terms of being able to talk about transportation and revenue needs and the need for investment in transportation.
01:23:31
It played a very big role in that.
01:23:35
The approach is moving the vision forward.
01:23:40
What we want to do is not repeat VTrans 2025, but we want to expand on it.
01:23:46
We need to continue to work on unifying the highway rail and transit plans.
01:23:51
We need to integrate the MPO plans.
01:23:54
There are 14 MPOs out there.
01:23:58
All the plans are different, and they're separate rural plans that VDOT does.
01:24:02
Some of what we need to do in this next plan is do a better job at integrating those MPOs, those rural plans, into the overall state plan.
01:24:09
That's some of what we want to do this time, which we didn't do last time.
01:24:13
We need to think long term.
01:24:14
As I've thought about this thing over the last
01:24:16
Several months, a year, is that VTrans 2025 turns out to be, the numbers are 20 years, but the policies and kind of things we're talking about are really more like three to five years.
01:24:30
Most of what we had in VTrans 2025 we have done.
01:24:33
What we need to do in VTrans 2035 is what does transportation, what do we think it looks like 20, 30 years after?
01:24:43
Not five years.
01:24:45
Well, what do we think?
01:24:46
And perhaps we need some thought leaders with you and others to thank Transportation 2035.
01:24:53
What does it look like?
01:24:56
One way is think back at it.
01:24:58
What did it look like 20 years ago?
01:25:01
I don't know, but some of what we want to do in this process, one of the elements on here you can see at the bottom bullet is a futurist element.
01:25:12
I'm looking at some kind of thing, a visioning kind of session where we get some of the thought leaders so we can start thinking about
01:25:21
20, 30, 20, 35, what does transportation in Virginia look like?
01:25:27
I don't have a good idea, but there are a lot of people, a lot smaller than I am, who could probably help us envisioning Virginia Transportation 2035.
01:25:39
I'm looking at a series of technical reports, and one of those technical reports would be the VTrans accomplishments.
01:25:50
We need to go back, much like I did the two-second look at accomplishments, but I'd like a detailed look at what did you say you were going to do and did you do it?
01:26:00
What have you actually accomplished?
01:26:01
And I think there are a number of accomplishments.
01:26:03
And one of the things I'd like to do, another pops in my head is we've talked about the separate rail funding streets.
01:26:10
We've talked about additional funding for transit.
01:26:12
All this stuff were things that the U.S. Policy Committee recommended that actually happened.
01:26:20
And so we want to go back and revisit that.
01:26:22
Long-term viability of fuel stacks.
01:26:26
We are about multimodal, we are about choices, we are about bike riding, transit, all other kinds of things that are non-highway centric.
01:26:37
If it's non-highway-centric, our highway fund depends on the fuel stacks.
01:26:41
So what we want to do is do those kind of things that say, you know, drive your car.
01:26:47
The result is, as you look further and further out, not only are we moving to different choices and not using those cars, but the efficiency of the vehicle stock is changing.
01:26:57
We're talking about electric vehicles.
01:26:58
We're talking about alternative fuel types of vehicles.
01:27:01
So what that means is our core source of revenue as you look further and further out
01:27:06
will be declining.
01:27:08
So as we know that, what do we need to do about it?
01:27:11
What I'm suggesting here is we not wait.
01:27:14
We not wait until the Oregon Modeling Speed Study.
01:27:17
Why doesn't Virginia get ahead of it?
01:27:19
Why don't we start thinking about that seriously now?
01:27:22
There's a subcommittee that Pierce is on that deals with fuel-efficient vehicles and transportation funding.
01:27:30
We, I think USCTB should be ahead of that, understand what is happening to your core source of funding.
01:27:38
We need to look at what other national and state kinds of studies.
01:27:41
But essentially our core source of funding, gas tax based on gallons, over long term, flat to declining.
01:27:51
We need some options.
01:27:52
What are the options?
01:27:54
The Oregon study results are for 2030, 2035.
01:27:57
It essentially has instruments within cars.
01:28:04
You need similar kind of instruments on the fuel, on the gas tanks.
01:28:07
And what you're doing is recording mileage.
01:28:10
That's a very difficult, very costly process.
01:28:13
And my review of the Oregon study says that's 2030.
01:28:16
We're going to have issues far before 2030.
01:28:20
And we need to think about other ways of dealing with that core source of funding.
01:28:25
And that needs to be in your term.
01:28:26
And we need to be making recommendations.
01:28:28
In the near term, in terms of how we deal with the fact that we'll be declining over a long period of time.
01:28:36
There are a couple of pieces in this proposal that I call signature pieces.
01:28:41
And one of those is the economic impact of the transportation investment.
01:28:45
I worked on the Transportation and Talent Quality Commission.
01:28:48
One of the things they kept saying is, how can you continue to ask for money?
01:28:51
You keep talking about your needs.
01:28:52
What are we getting in return?
01:28:55
So, one of the ways to deal with that is to say, let's do an economic impact of transportation investment.
01:29:00
So we can say, if you start with investing in transportation, this is what it means in terms of gross state product, in terms of earnings, in terms of employment and so forth.
01:29:09
So this would be a study that we would do that doesn't currently exist.
01:29:13
Matt's probably have done some, there's some done for aviation, there's one similar done for the port, but there's not one done for overall transportation.
01:29:22
So the idea here is we do a study, to have a commission, we study, that said, what is the economic impact
01:29:29
of your dollar invested in transportation.
01:29:32
You can talk about direct benefits, indirect benefits, return on each dollar, dollar invested.
01:29:38
And this is something we haven't done but didn't do in VTrans 2025.
01:29:41
We'd like to see done for VTrans 2035.
01:29:46
As I'm going through this, this is not of my long-range studies, your studies.
01:29:53
And I'm looking for feedback and input from you in terms of if something is missing out of here or something should be taken out or added, I'd like your input in terms of what that should be.
01:30:04
In VTrans 2025, we started something called manualistic, which was a multiple investment network, a series of major corridors in the state.
01:30:12
We'd like to pursue a bit more of this, go around, further identify those corridors, what kind of investments do we need in those corridors, and so forth.
01:30:23
Those are a series of tactical reports that have some dates in terms of when I think they will be coming out.
01:30:28
The idea here is I will be coming forward before you on a periodic basis, updating you in terms of what we're doing and results.
01:30:36
So there are some dates in terms of when we will be generating those reports.
01:30:42
Of the tactical reports, there will be a series of chapters in this VTrans document.
01:30:47
We will not necessarily go through all of those.
01:30:50
You can see those.
01:30:51
I provided them to you.
01:30:54
There may be some additions here and there that I may need to make.
01:30:58
For example, I have got some feedback from one or two of you on this.
01:31:03
As you look at the changing socioeconomic trends and forecasts, one of the things we may need to do is add something in the on-transit carpooling and so forth.
01:31:12
How those things change, I'm sure Matt has all of that, but some of this is really pointing that process and making sure that it's not only about highways, but it's about these other modal entities as well.
01:31:23
One of the other things I'll mention on the third bullet,
01:31:26
We are required to do, through the authorities, regional performance measures, two authorities have to develop those measures according to you.
01:31:37
We will be working with those authorities in coordinating that process.
01:31:43
Next slide here.
01:31:47
I think this is an opportunity for, again, a signature piece.
01:31:52
What are the trends in safety?
01:31:55
As Secretary mentioned, the milestone this year in safety, 112 folks based on the latest piece of data.
01:32:01
I've done a quick and dirty kind of analysis.
01:32:05
Essentially, VMT, which is miles traveled, goes up by 2% a year.
01:32:12
If we maintain the current level of fatalities per VMT,
01:32:16
We're talking 2035, probably 1700 to 2004 being killed on our highways.
01:32:26
That's just, we don't do anything and VMT continues to go up essentially and there are no changes in the relationship between VMT and photographer because that continues to creep up.
01:32:41
And some of what we're doing is something that the Commissioner's done is we've got to put in place strategies and plans to deal with this.
01:32:50
A lot of that may well not be things that we do.
01:32:55
A lot of it may be technology involving vehicles.
01:32:58
Some of the risks we've seen, some decreases in fatalities, is the best way to have vehicles safer.
01:33:04
We have seat belts.
01:33:06
We have airplanes and those kinds of things we didn't have back in the 70s.
01:33:10
But we've got to think about what the trends are, what choices do we have, and what can we do about it.
01:33:16
I will not go through each of those, but there are a series of trends and choices.
01:33:21
And the idea there is to look at them, talk about what the trend is, what we should be doing about those things as we move forward.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:30
Ralph, I realize this is a framework document, but I think on the slide that you're on now, the trends and choices, I would suggest that we take regionalism and put it right up there under safety as a trend and a choice that needs to be analyzed and really examine and look at its potential impact not only on rural Virginia, but on the state as a whole.
01:34:00
And if that's where we're going to end up with nine or ten regional transportation authorities out there 2035, what's going to be the impact?
01:34:09
It would appear that they're in that will to step up and finance a statewide system from legislative revenue generation so that they want to kick it out and I guess have other
01:34:24
ways to generate revenue with different authorities but I think that's going to be something that we really need to examine and try to look at the impact that's going to have on areas outside those regions that have ability to increase additional and raise additional taxes because
01:34:43
You know, the hurt will be felt statewide if some of these rural areas can't continue to develop some revenue-generating businesses in those areas.
01:34:53
So I stress that when there shouldn't be, I don't take it to the bottom of the page that it's not important, but I'd like to sit up near the top for consideration.
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:35:02
Thank you very much Christine.
01:35:03
There was no thought process in terms of how these, I should have asked, but yes.
01:35:09
Well, safety is known, but beyond that, there was not a lot of thought process there.
01:35:14
I do think with each of these things that they're such, with the regional resident, I think the governor has talked a lot about the importance
01:35:24
of building on the infrastructure and so forth that's available in a particular region.
01:35:29
We talk a lot about regionalism.
01:35:31
At the same time, you are about the state of Virginia.
01:35:34
And it's not just about the wealthy region, but about the rural as well.
01:35:39
So we have that conflict.
01:35:41
What I would see here would be a white paper kind of thing where we look at the conflict and we make some recommendations in terms of what kind of choices we would have for each of these.
01:35:52
So regionalism is one of those elements that I think we do have some trade-offs that have to occur, and it has to be a lot of discussion in that area.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:05
Ralph, what does preservation mean on that list?
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:36:09
That's sort of what I thought, but I wanted to make sure.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:37
On the environmental arena,
01:36:40
Of course, the governor has now appointed his climate change commission.
01:36:44
I'm not sure of their schedule.
01:36:45
At one point, I heard they're going to try to finish up by the end of this year.
01:36:49
Transportation is the largest source of greenhouse gas emissions in Virginia.
01:36:56
I don't know what they're going to conclude ought to be done about that to adapt or change or reduce or whatever they're going to do eventually but clearly that's going to have some kind of effect on what transportation looks like in 2035 so I guess I'm just trying to encourage you as strongly as possible to
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:37:18
One other choice that's not on here that should be and it's more energy.
01:37:30
Essentially transportation is the largest energy source in the Commonwealth that uses 43% of all energy as transportation.
01:37:39
and that needs to be here and what kinds of things do we need to do.
01:37:43
The governor has an energy plan.
01:37:46
Some of what I need to do and we need to do is look at what's in the energy plan and what are those goals that they've set and a lot of it's about more fuel efficient vehicles.
01:37:55
It's about using more transit and more rail and those kinds of things.
01:37:58
But it's a critical part of the process and needs to be fully integrated into what we're doing.
01:38:05
Other key components, I'm on slide 10 now.
01:38:09
There's the finance section.
01:38:11
We need to not only look at state but federal and local and the partnerships.
01:38:15
We need to look at House Bill 3202 and how does that fit in this whole process.
01:38:20
When we did VTrans 2025, there was no 3202.
01:38:24
I'd like to think that VTrans had something to do about it.
01:38:27
But we need to figure out how does that fit into our overall revenue outlook.
01:38:32
We need the latest revenue forecast.
01:38:35
Then investment adequacy.
01:38:36
We did a lot of work on that last time.
01:38:39
We talked about the crossover.
01:38:40
We talked about maintenance.
01:38:42
It was $400 million.
01:38:43
It's down to $200 million.
01:38:45
Similar to later, we had more and more issues that were moving.
01:38:49
Basic construction money into maintenance.
01:38:50
We need to look at that.
01:38:53
What are the minimum needs?
01:38:54
That's one of the things we did last time.
01:38:56
What are the minimum needs to make the transportation fund hold?
01:39:00
And I think we were looking at it again as well.
01:39:03
In terms of oversight, my plans would be to come before you very often, probably a workshop to give you updates in terms of where we are.
01:39:12
Again, this is your plan, and a lot of feedback from you on that.
01:39:16
I would see you actively involved in the summit, as I mentioned, in terms of planning and being
01:39:23
I think the key area of policy is really around these trends and choices.
01:39:30
I would like to see you heavily engaged in that process and make sure that what you see as trends and what the potential choice is so you're engaged in that.
01:39:38
We will have several advisory committees.
01:39:41
One is the advisory committee of basically mobile agency heads who are basically looking more at the actual plans and how they make sure there's consistency and there's coordination across plans.
01:39:55
We had a technical committee last time.
01:39:57
These are staff people from various mobile agencies.
01:40:01
They help see communication between the agencies, so all agencies, Stanford, Norwood, North Carolina,
01:40:06
This is really often a public kind of document, so we need to get stakeholders involved in the process as well.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:14
Mr. Chairman, Ralph, did you include in that, maybe it's coming further down, legislature involvement?
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:40:25
I did not include the legislative or legislative involvement.
01:40:30
It would seem that the committee's transportation especially it might be really helpful to at some phase draw them into the giving them a chance to have an input while they learn
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:59
All the things that are also being recommended by all the other constituencies.
01:41:04
If it's possible, it would be a very positive thing.
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:41:08
For BCAS 2025, I did go before a circle-legged body, but it's really at the end of the process rather, and perhaps something we can think about is getting engaged up front of the process.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:41:22
I would acknowledge they now have a joint commission on transportation accountability which is both House and Senate membership and that might be a good body.
01:41:32
We're starting to use that to brief them on our major PPTA projects.
01:41:38
It's a good point of contact and you don't have that division necessarily between House and Senate so I think that's an excellent suggestion we should easily incorporate into our process.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:41:50
Mr. Chairman, if I could, I do want to acknowledge and compliment the Deputy Secretary on particularly the piece on page 9 of your overheads or the slide on page 9.
01:42:04
If you look at that in the perspective I've looked at it,
01:42:07
Departure from the traditional thought process around developing long-range plans by going to topic matter, and as I viewed that list and think about it, I think the real question at the table is it gives us as staff working on these kinds of activities a way to parse and put together
01:42:32
Manageable Topics.
01:42:33
And it's an easy way for people to articulate what the end state number of chapters in this book ought to look like.
01:42:43
One of the lessons we've learned, at least in the states I've worked on, people get lost in the journey.
01:42:51
But if you can articulate the topics
01:42:55
It gives you the freedom to think about what you would want to know about in 2035.
01:43:01
This week as I participated at the Transportation Research Board proceedings, which obviously is a worldwide gathering, this has been a pretty specific set of topics.
01:43:15
That has been going on and there's much to be learned from that when you bring 10,000 people together from across the world.
01:43:24
All of a sudden you can define a set of chapters.
01:43:28
We can then produce papers very quickly because there's a large body of both international and national information from which to draw as we put a Virginia twist.
01:43:39
on where we think we want to be in 2035.
01:43:41
So I do need to compliment and acknowledge the work the Deputy Secretary has done in putting this framework together because I think it's a major step forward in a way to think about this.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:43:56
Thank you.
01:43:56
Other questions or comments?
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:43:59
As sort of the godmother of the first plan, I am very encouraged about the continuation and the expansion.
01:44:13
Good luck.
01:44:14
I'm very glad that you added
01:44:15
The Energy on to page nine because that's something I feel very strongly about not only to minimize our environmental footprint but also to recognize some of the pricing impacts that gasoline at six and eight dollars a gallon our issues may be substantially different but that
01:44:36
There's plan A and plan B, but I think we have to consider at least some of that as a possibility, but I'm just again heartened by this and I think it's a very reasonable approach.
SPEAKER_15
01:44:55
The godmother of this 2025 and all those folks who were involved with this thing.
01:45:01
It's a great product and a good roadmap.
01:45:05
I'd like to also agree that my friend Mr. Davis' suggestion of bringing legislators in is an excellent idea.
01:45:14
If they're involved with the process, they're learning and they're also understanding what decisions are being made and how they're being made.
01:45:23
I agree with that.
01:45:24
And Mr. King's comment about regionalism, I can't agree more that a regional look at the transportation network is critical.
01:45:34
If you look at it in any other way, you're going to end up with an inefficient and expensive product.
01:45:42
So I would encourage that to be very high up on the list.
01:45:45
I agree 100%.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:45:49
Thank you, Mr. Davis.
01:45:53
What I would hope that as we stage the work plan, because this is at the end of the day the CTB's long-range plan.
01:46:03
That we can space out some of the work products for deliberation.
01:46:08
There were some technical reports, there were some policy issues, and my hope would be that assuming those deliverables get reasonably as projected, we get through the subdivision street regulations, which are going to take a lot of time, but by the time we're done with that, that we can devote at every session
01:46:26
Some very significant effort on either the policy issues or the technical reports in that way.
01:46:32
We kind of do it a chapter at a time.
01:46:34
You're not asked to swallow a single 3,000 page report at the last minute, which I think all of us would appreciate.
01:46:43
Okay, thank you.
01:46:44
The next item on the agenda is the I-95-395 transit and TDM study and Mr. Corey Hill presented.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
01:47:05
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
01:47:06
Again, I'm Corey Hill, here to talk to you today about a study that is complementary to the I-95-395 Top Lanes project.
01:47:16
This particular study is called the 95-395 Transit and Transportation Main Management Study.
01:47:23
A quick study background for you.
01:47:26
The I-95-395 Hot Leans Project and the I-495 Hot Leans Projects are both consistent in that they provide improved opportunities for transit.
01:47:37
The I-95-395 Hot Leans Project scope
01:47:39
Currently, as it is conceived, includes significant benefits for transit.
01:47:45
The scope includes 3,000 new park and ride spaces, 33 new entry and exit ramps, an in-line bus rapid transit station, and a 28-mile extension of the HOV lanes.
01:47:56
That's already included in their scope.
01:47:59
When the private partners last year discussed this project and the scope and these benefits for transit, they also put together a proposal for extending, improving transit above and beyond that, and they made a commitment of about $195 million.
01:48:16
That proposal was provided to the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments as part of the input into their constrained long-range plan.
01:48:24
And at the same time, we, the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, were asked to work with a technical advisory committee consisting of federal, state, regional, local jurisdictional staff, transit operators,
01:48:36
So on and so forth, to do a more complex and detailed analysis and then come back the following year, this time, with an update to the proposal that was made for transit last year.
01:48:47
So that's where we are.
01:48:49
And again, just one point of emphasis, the improvements that we're talking about are above and beyond the scope items that you see on the second bullet.
01:48:59
Funding for improvements, though, would also be coming from the commitment, in addition to the commitment from the private sector, we would expect revenues to come from FairBox, from the FairBox as the operators operate new service and collect money for that service, and then federal discretionary funds.
01:49:16
The important point that I want to emphasize to you all, though, is that the revenue, the $195 million commitment from the private sector is not a done deal yet.
01:49:26
That dedicated revenue is subject to final negotiation by VDOT and Ford Transurban and ultimately comes back to you for allocation.
01:49:35
So at a point in the future, if a deal is successfully negotiated, if those revenues are secured, then we will come back to you about how those funds are allocated.
01:49:46
But this study is a proposal as to how that might happen.
01:49:52
Touching on the study corridor, it's a 56-mile study corridor to the south.
01:49:55
We've got Massaponics to the north, the District of Columbia.
01:49:59
The study also, though, felt that it was important because we're looking at transit.
01:50:04
We're looking at travel markets.
01:50:06
So we know that there's a significant portion of the traveling public that's coming up the 95 corridor and taking the beltway to places like Tysons Corner and Maryfield.
01:50:17
So we've looked at some additional markets beyond just up and down the line, so to speak.
01:50:23
In terms of goals for the study, the study had two major goals.
01:50:26
Number one, preserve transit and HOV ridership while implementing hot lanes.
01:50:29
There was some concern from the community that hot lanes would impact transit and people wanted to make sure that that didn't happen.
01:50:37
And secondly, a goal of utilizing the new hot lanes features to attract new transit and HOV riders.
01:50:43
How do we use this as a benefit and further grow the transit market?
01:50:48
An important point to keep in mind is that this is a very mature corridor.
01:50:54
There are a number of existing transit and transportation and van management services in the corridor today.
01:50:59
You've got bus service.
01:51:02
You can see when I say northern and southern portion on these bullets, the northern portion would be the existing HOV Lane facility that's out there today that goes from Dumfries north to the district.
01:51:14
South would be the number of buses that are coming up from the Massaponics area up through the corridor.
01:51:21
Rail service, you've got Metro Rail service in the corridor today, you've got Virginia Railway Express on their Fredericksburg line operates in the corridor today, there's some Amtrak service.
01:51:30
Also of significance, you've got 500 van pulls, which is a very big number in terms of the size of that fleet, 21 park and ride lots, and then 19 slugging locations as well.
01:51:42
So there's a huge effort and a huge alternative transportation market out there today.
01:51:47
Great question.
01:51:48
For slugging, slugging is basically is carpooling that occurs at the park and ride lots.
01:51:56
It's actually, it's not a government program.
01:51:59
It was something created by the citizens.
01:52:01
It's rather innovative.
01:52:02
And they actually even have kind of their own rules and procedures.
01:52:05
And basically people go to a park and ride lot and look for additional people to come by, pick them up so that they can take advantage of the HOV lanes rather than having to drive by themselves in the general purpose lanes.
01:52:15
So it's organized carpooling.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:17
And Mr. Hill and members of the CTB, the chair is a former slugger, so when you look at it, you can see what a slugger looks like.
01:52:26
That's right.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
01:52:26
And it's a very interesting phenomenon.
01:52:29
It's one that is very well recognized for Northern Virginia.
01:52:33
and it's people using the market to find creative ways to get to work and they take advantage of the park and ride lots and work with each other to take advantage of the HOV lanes, it's quite successful.
01:52:44
And you'll see in just a minute, it's a very, it's a community that's very concerned about this project and I'll talk about that a little bit more in just a minute.
01:52:52
As we talk about doing this kind of study, the first thing that we start with is we take a look at what is the existing service out there, which I just described, and then on top of it, for the region's long-range plan, what are they saying that they're already going to do?
01:53:06
And we take that existing network and what people are saying they're already going to do in their long-range plan, and we call that the baseline.
01:53:14
And then from there we look at alternatives above and beyond that to determine how effective they'll be compared to the baseline.
01:53:21
Now this was a comprehensive effort because you've got a 56 mile corridor, multiple jurisdictions, multiple operators, multiple modes, many things going on and so collectively when we worked with the technical advisory committee we came up with 60 different strategies to analyze as part of this study and because it was such a vast universe of strategies we decided that the logical way to go forward
01:53:45
would be to group them into three different tiers and then test those three tiers.
01:53:50
And the way we did that was by grouping them financially.
01:53:53
Now because the VDOT 4 Transurban contract is not a done deal, we had to make some basic assumptions on different levels of investment.
01:54:01
At the same time we recognized though that people would want to see what is the ultimate vision of the quarter and how do some of those ultimate improvements perform as well.
01:54:09
So we've got a low
01:54:10
Tier that's targeted about approximately $250 million of investment, a medium tier of about $500 million, and then a high tier which is financially unconstrained just so that we can see the max of what we can do.
01:54:23
The low alternative in simple terms would increase existing bus service and bus service that's planned in the long-range plan by 100%.
01:54:31
It would expand VRE capacity and provide just a number of improvements that you see listed here below, in addition again to what's already planned.
01:54:41
The medium alternative would increase bus service by 145 percent, would include the concept of bus rapid transit, and again a substantial increase in VRE service.
01:54:53
And then the high alternative, the unconstrained, you have again a 145 percent increase in bus service, but a 130 percent increase in VRE service, as well as a metro rail extension to Potomac Mills West testing.
01:55:07
So basically, if you took those three alternatives, the low, the medium, and the high, and you compared them to what's going on out there in the existing environment today and what's planned in the future, you see that we are making those kind of increases.
01:55:22
And this is kind of just sort of an imaginary line just south of Springfield, how many buses are operating over that line an hour, how many VRE trains, how many metro trains.
01:55:30
It just sort of gives you some perspective about the increase in the tiers.
01:55:37
When you take 60 different strategies like that, you need several different ways to analyze them.
01:55:42
What we did was we used a travel forecasting demand model that is a common tool for the Northern Virginia market.
01:55:49
It's based on the Transportation Planning Board's model.
01:55:53
We also used market research and we also used the experience of the Technical Advisory Committee and input from the public and a number of policy boards such as the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, the Northern Virginia Transportation Commission, the Potomac and Rappahannock Transportation Commission, and our friends down to the South, FAMPO, the Fredericksburg area MPO.
01:56:15
I'm going to focus on this slide about the travel forecasting.
01:56:18
It's just one tool in the toolbox, but here's what the results were from that effort.
01:56:21
We realized that the CLRP that was in the baseline alternative, it's part of it, has significant service additions and is already a very strong performer.
01:56:32
We were surprised at just how much transit service the region is already contemplating in the core.
01:56:39
It was an important finding to make sure that all the locals knew just how much transit they had signed up for in their long-range plan.
01:56:46
It was important to discuss that with them and make sure that that was a true and valid assumption.
01:56:50
Secondly, the most difference between the tested alternatives was really in the competition among transit modes.
01:56:55
One of the things that we were very sensitive to was if you're making investments in putting new services out there in a corridor that's already robust, how many people are we taking out of single occupant vehicles versus how many people are we taking out of a bus and putting onto a train?
01:57:09
In trying to figure out where are people shifting to as you introduce new strategies into the environment our goal obviously to be getting single occupant vehicle motorists out of their cars and into transit and not so much to take them out of van pools and put them in a bus or take them out of the bus and put them in a train.
01:57:26
The hot lanes generally did not adversely impact transit or carpool mode share versus today, which is again a very key finding.
01:57:34
Many people were very nervous that people were going to bail out of transit and use the hot lanes, and we're finding that generally speaking that was not the case.
01:57:43
Transit and carpooling enjoy an incredibly huge share of the market.
01:57:48
Northbound in the morning, what you will find is that roughly 65 percent
01:57:55
Of the folks that are traveling northbound in the morning, trying to get into the District of Columbia, 65% are in alternative transportation.
01:58:05
They're in a carpool, they're in a vanpool, they're on a bus, they're on a train.
01:58:09
That is an enormous percentage market share for a corridor like this.
01:58:13
So, an incredibly important piece of information, they are the ones, all that alternative transportation is what allows the roadway to work as well as it does today.
01:58:22
And even today, it's not working that great, man would agree.
01:58:25
The transit TDM alternatives do maintain that mode share again even with significant increases of travel in the corridor so they're holding their own as we test those alternatives and many of the new routes that we found performed very well so while there's a lot of transit service in the corridor today we found a lot of good opportunities for new service that would work well if we implemented it.
01:58:46
Moving on to the market research, this is kind of interesting because typically what you do is you have a number of rounds of public meetings and that is your opportunity for public input.
01:58:56
We felt that it's difficult for people to get to those public meetings, the elementary school on a rainy Thursday night, so we wanted to find more opportunities for the public
01:59:05
to engage in this process.
01:59:06
So we had an online survey that we invited people to participate in that gave us statistically reliable results and allowed us to analyze many different markets in many different ways.
01:59:16
And this is just a couple of the highlights, but there's a lot more information that we have in our files.
01:59:24
But basically, awareness of hot lanes is very high.
01:59:27
Nearly all sluggers are aware of the hot lanes.
01:59:30
Again, they're that community that I mentioned before that is really sensitive as to what the impacts and what the benefits of this project are going to be all about.
01:59:37
Interestingly enough, the SOV users were the least aware of the hot lanes project, but still a high level of awareness at 75%.
01:59:48
The sluggers were especially likely to believe that hot lanes were going to discourage drivers from picking up sluggers.
01:59:54
What they thought was, instead of a driver coming into a park and ride lot,
01:59:59
picking up a couple of passengers and then traveling on the HOV lanes, now that as a driver I can get into the HOV lanes and pay money and drive by myself, I don't need to bother with picking people up anymore.
02:00:11
And that's what their real fear was.
02:00:12
However, most trains in an HOV commuter said that they will not change their commute in any way when the hot lanes are open and functional.
02:00:20
And what's interesting is, again, you've got an incredibly high number of sluggers and carpoolers that are saying, I'm not going to abandon what I do today when you put this new option out on the street.
02:00:32
I'm going to stay in transit, I'm going to stay in my carpool, I'm going to stay in my bus, you know, whatever it is I do today.
02:00:38
And a lot of that we're sensing is,
02:00:40
So much in order, Virginia, where the congestion is so high, you're building your life a lot around how you get to work.
02:00:48
It is such a challenge up there that people are, you know, the van works for me.
02:00:52
It allows me to keep the schedule I need for my family.
02:00:55
I'm not going to go and change that now.
02:00:57
Now, as you see, though, for the SOVs, only 53%.
02:01:00
So you are going to see a number of single-occupant vehicle motorists that are traveling in the general purpose lanes taking advantage of the hot lanes.
02:01:09
The likelihood of using hot lanes is highest among commuters from the South, Spotsylvania, Stafford, and Prince William County.
02:01:16
One interesting finding that we didn't expect was that 34% of the SOVers say there's no park and ride lot located along their commute to catch express bus, or if there is a lot, it's usually full.
02:01:27
But 24% of them couldn't answer this question.
02:01:30
They didn't know if a park and ride lot was near them or not.
02:01:33
And when we asked them if there was one that you were aware of and it was near you, would you use it?
02:01:37
And 11% said yes.
02:01:39
So right off the bat, we know that we've got a communications issue in which we need to let people have greater awareness of where park and ride lots are and what the services that are available at those park and ride lots are.
02:01:51
And just by doing that, we can probably increase usage of transit right there without a major investment.
02:01:58
From the three major tiers of alternatives, the low, the medium, and the high, we then said, okay, time to boil this thing down and get to a bottom line on it.
02:02:07
And when we did that, we kind of created a refined alternative that was made up of the best performing strategies.
02:02:12
So we took those 60 strategies, picked the best ones out of the low and the medium and the high, and developed a refined alternative that was basically
02:02:20
About a $650 million package of investments, $230 million of capital, and enough money to operate the services for 20 years.
02:02:31
From there, we then took our final step in the process, which was, again, to come back and improve upon the input that was provided in the constrained long-range plan last year, which meant that we needed to take our refined alternative and financially constrain it.
02:02:49
The way we did that was we prioritized and phased the proposed improvements based on productivity, ease of implementation, and long-term regional net effects.
02:02:57
We also did our best to look at available funding sources and then also needed to recognize that we wanted to respect what was already currently planned and programmed and not duplicate or use those valuable revenues from the Hot Lanes project to do something that someone else was already planning to do and fund.
02:03:14
So from that, the refined alternative finally boiled down to the fiscally constrained alternative, and from there you've got about a $298 million package.
02:03:25
It includes a $195 million Hot Lanes lump sum payment, about $40 million of federal discretionary funding, and $63 million in revenues recovered from the fare box.
02:03:36
The farebox recovery figure, unlike the proposal from last year, is derived from actual services proposed.
02:03:42
So we sharpened the pencil to make sure that farebox recovery figure was as accurate as possible.
02:03:48
Also a big difference from last year was last year they were planning, the proposal was to operate a lot of bus service which generated a lot of farebox revenue.
02:03:57
Here, the technical advisory committee felt very strongly that there were a number of important facility improvements like bus rapid transit stations, for example, and additional park and ride spaces that were important to invest the money in.
02:04:10
Park and ride lots and bus rapid transit stations are capital facilities that are not generating revenue.
02:04:16
So that revenue figure for the farebox recovery is lower in this proposal compared to last year's for that reason.
02:04:23
In terms of, okay, so what do I get for the refined fiscally constrained alternative?
02:04:28
The bottom line for that $298 million package is you get about $137 million worth of capital improvements and enough money to operate the services for 20 years at a cost of about $161 million.
02:04:41
Again, that package breaks down into a number of service modifications, so taking existing bus services and increasing their frequency, for example.
02:04:49
Extending the hours of bus service or the days that bus service is provided and increasing the length of VRE trains.
02:04:55
So we don't have to purchase a new slot for a VRE train.
02:04:59
We're really just lengthening the train as an example from six cars to eight cars so we can carry more passengers.
02:05:06
And it's a great bang for the buck idea.
02:05:09
New services, there's all kinds of new bus routes that are important that provide great new service.
02:05:14
We did take the
02:05:15
Brack, into consideration as we were talking about some of this and the changes that would happen there and how do we better serve the base, and just a number of routes all up and down the corridor.
02:05:25
Facility improvements, we've got improvements to two existing Metrorail centers and a new transit center down in Massaponics is proposed, five in-line BRT stations, platform extensions for VRE and a number of other items, and then transportation and demand management program elements as well that we thought would be important for the carpoolers and the vanpoolers.
02:05:45
One thing I will say is that while we did not go at this with the strategy of how do we get
02:05:51
10% of the investment in Fredericksburg, 10% in Stafford, 10% here, 10% there, we really were going straight for what are the best performing bang for the buck strategies, period.
02:06:03
What's been a nice result though is you look at all of these improvements, there's great equity up and down the court.
02:06:08
Every jurisdiction is getting improvements, every jurisdiction is getting service enhancements that are going to benefit the citizens in that jurisdiction.
02:06:17
Finally, our next steps, again, is to revise that CLRP submission that's happening as we speak.
02:06:23
That proposal has been put forward.
02:06:25
It is a proposal.
02:06:26
Again, we'll be coming back to you for actual allocation of dollars based on specific strategies.
02:06:31
We'll issue a final report likely at the end of the month or early February.
02:06:35
And then the next step is to continue to work with VDOT, who served on the technical advisory committee with us,
02:06:40
To advance elements of the recommendation that potentially impact roadway design, such as those bus rapid transit stations, we want to work closely with the private sector and VDOT to make sure that the design of those facilities is done in a successful way so that VDOT doesn't go forward and then we come back a year later and say, hey, wait a second, you've got to change something.
02:07:01
So we're working together on that and that's really one of our few next steps.
02:07:05
With that, I'd be happy to answer any questions.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:08
Questions for Mr. Hill?
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:12
To what extent has the district been engaged in this?
02:07:18
I don't recall whether you said they were on your advisory panel because I know the 14th Street Bridge is certainly an important link, final link into the district and it doesn't belong to us.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:07:33
That's true.
02:07:34
It is a key issue and we have been working with the District of Columbia and talking to them about all of the issues that you've described in various forms.
02:07:41
VDOT talking with the District about 14th Street Bridge, DRPT and WMATA talking with the District about the improvements that would go down there and how do we do that.
02:07:50
We have more work to do there.
02:07:52
and that's part of the effort is now that we know what strategies work we really need to kind of bring together some very specific service planning ideas talking about you know perhaps improving the traffic lights and how do we make it flow once we get into the district and that's a key effort that's coming up as well.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:09
I have one other question.
02:08:10
It's sort of an in-the-weeds question, but when you were talking about the 65 percent that go up and down the corridor that are not in SOVs, do you know what the figure would be for those who peel off on 495?
02:08:28
Occupancy ratio might be?
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:08:31
I don't have that figure.
02:08:33
The 65% figure actually comes from a VDOT traffic count study that was looking at basically, again, an imaginary screen line just south of the district covering 395 and Route 1 and the like.
02:08:46
There has not been a traffic count study that's done exactly that.
02:08:50
The percentage down, as you get further south, that percentage goes down, but I can't tell you this.
02:08:55
I don't have the data to tell you by how much.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:57
Yeah, I was just interested as we were looking at congestion management for some of the Tysons area and the impact I was wondering if we had some data on.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:09:06
Right, we do know though that it was important to us to look at Tysons that there are some existing bus routes in the CLRP that are already planned and part of the package here for the financially constrained package is additional bus routes to serve Tysons because it is an important track market.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:26
Ms. Koelemay.
02:09:30
One of the assumptions that people often make is that new highway capacity generates its own traffic.
02:09:36
Is one of the assumptions of this study that increased capacity for transit, particularly bus rapid transit, will create additional traffic or additional ridership?
02:09:50
Just by being there?
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:09:51
Right.
02:09:55
What you have today is you have a pretty robust express bus market that's operating today.
02:10:01
Part of the challenge is the always travel times, reliability, and things of that nature.
02:10:07
And I think one of the things that we heard from the public, I heard specifically myself from our public meetings, was people are looking for almost the highest quality service they can possibly get.
02:10:18
And I think part of bus rapid transit with the in-line stations gives you
02:10:22
That faster travel time, that greater convenience, that higher quality service that people are really after.
02:10:28
I think a key aspect though of working with VDOT and Fort Transurban is making sure, obviously, that the travel speeds that the buses enjoy today will be maintained and protected so that we can again have that scheduled reliability and those travel time advantages over the general purpose lines.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:45
Mr. Chairman, the best explanation of this whole project that I've ever heard is we're going to improve transit and HOV's capacity in this corridor and sell the excess to individual drivers and vehicles.
02:11:01
To me, these are the primary benefits of the whole Hot Lanes proposal.
02:11:09
I'll ask you this about sluggers because it seems to be counterintuitive what they think.
02:11:13
If now people slug because they can save time, why wouldn't they also slug more if they can also save money?
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:11:23
Well, I think you're right.
02:11:24
I think, again, people are saying that they are going to stay with people.
02:11:28
We're not going to see people deviate from slugging.
02:11:30
There's two reasons why.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:31
Mr. Hill, could you describe for the CTB what a slugger is?
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:36
We did, while you were out of the room.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:11:39
We decided to name it Dynamic Carpooling.
02:11:41
They caught me much quicker on that.
02:11:44
I didn't get too far before I stopped on that, although we'll throw out an additional term very quickly while we're talking about the people that go by and pick up the people that are standing at the park and ride lots.
02:11:53
We refer to them affectionately as body snatchers.
02:11:57
The way it really works is the driver drives up to the line and says 14th and K. Each person in line, the first guy gets to make a decision.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:15
That may be close to where he's going or he may not want to go, so he passes.
02:12:19
The first three who accept
02:12:21
That is a destination.
02:12:23
Climb the car and they're off.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:12:24
And they'll actually line up in specific lines based on the locations that they're at.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:29
Very organized approach to it.
02:12:30
In town, you'll stand at a certain corner knowing that's where people pick up to go back.
02:12:34
So, Pentagon, you know, there are destinations.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:38
It's real time.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:39
An observation I'd like to make on your market research page is I know Arlington spends over $2 million a year simply publicizing its transit services, where buses go.
02:12:53
If you're ignorant in Arlington about transit, it's because you can't read here and you don't go anywhere.
02:12:59
But that would be an important component about transit.
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:13:03
And that's part of those transportation and management programs is increasing the marketing outreach and increasing the awareness.
02:13:13
Again, that finding that 24% of people didn't know if they had a parking lot available to them and if they did, 11% of them would use it.
02:13:21
I have one last question.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:26
This project overlaps the two districts, but it also overlaps two transit districts and planning districts and other kinds of things.
02:13:35
I mean, I didn't see any reference to the sort of built-in governance issues here.
02:13:43
Is this vision you're expecting to be and planning expect to be carried down to each one of those units?
02:13:49
or have you made any recommendations about perhaps combining or forming some new unit that would actually make this work a lot better?
Corey Hill
Chief of Transit and Congestion Management
02:13:59
Certainly we're talking about program management here for a corridor and we've got the technical advisory committee which has helped us come up with a recommendation at this point and when we come back to you with specific programming decisions right now in terms of governance it's envisioned that DRPT would be the one coming back to you all to make the, you know, with a recommendation for you all to make the decision.
02:14:18
James A. Davis III, John J. Davis III, Peter B. Schwartz
02:14:34
Transportation Planning Board, CLRP in Washington, and then we have the one in Fredericksburg.
02:14:39
The one in Fredericksburg, the timing was a little bit further behind, so we had to get to the Washington one first, but we will be coming to the Fredericksburg one as well to make sure that these recommendations and inputs are part of that planning process and incorporated in the necessary documents.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:52
Mr. Tucker wanted to comment.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:55
I think the question that you raised, Mr. Koelemay, is excellent.
02:14:59
One of the things that I think as we started to look at Northern Virginia and if you look at the projects from the Beltway project to this project, to Dulles Rail, and going back even to the Deputy Secretary's presentation on regionalism,
02:15:12
We really have to start looking at these transit projects and even some of the ways transit is operated from a more regional perspective.
02:15:19
I mean, when I looked at this project, one of the things I said to Mr. Hill is he was becoming the lead with the different communities working with the technical advisory committee.
02:15:29
At the end of the day, we should be focused on mobility in the corridor and not necessarily what are my parochial needs, desires, and wants with money that may be available.
02:15:39
I think as we continue to refine the work that he's doing here along with the work that we're doing toward development of a statewide plan and really start focusing in on corridors, that's where we're going to get to those sets of questions and difficult choices that are going to have to have people act differently.
02:15:55
Bus rapid transit
02:15:56
It's something that we've talked a lot about internally as an agency and one reason we talk about bus rapid transit because it's a lot easier to do from a financial perspective and an operating point of view than for us to say we're going to implement a metro rail extension or implement light rail.
02:16:13
But within that framework, you've got to have a pretty dynamic system-oriented plan in place to make it work.
02:16:19
And so this is going to be part of the curve and the learning curve that we're going to have to make as a state towards looking at different modes and figuring out how to incorporate it and not necessarily be from a parochial approach.
02:16:31
It's going to have to be more on a regional basis.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:37
Okay.
02:16:38
Okay.
02:16:38
If there's no other questions or comments, thank you, Mr. Hill.
02:16:41
That's a very challenging but a real cutting edge project like the Beltway Hot Lanes as well.
02:16:49
The next item on the agenda is the Rail Industrial Access Project Reyes Holdings.
02:16:54
Item six, welcome Mr.
02:16:55
Page.
02:16:57
Yet another good investment not only in transportation but employment.
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:17:01
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
02:17:03
Mr. Hill was talking about scrapers and sluggers.
02:17:06
I'm going to talk about McDonald's, French fries, and hamburgers.
02:17:10
It's amazing.
02:17:11
DRPT is widening its breadth of what we're doing here in Virginia.
02:17:15
What I'm doing today is I'm briefing you, the 30-day pre-briefing on a rail industrial access project.
02:17:20
This is an exciting project for us.
02:17:23
It's been several months with Ray's Holdings, which is doing business in Virginia as Lone Oak, up in the Prince William County area.
02:17:31
I'll be going in more detail in a second, but the $450,000 action item with the $150,000 local match requirement will be coming to the Board at the February 20th meeting.
02:17:42
Ray's Holdings is doing business in Virginia as Martin Brower Corporation.
02:17:48
For those of you who are familiar with the Gainesville area up in that along Prince William County, this is a site that will be located off of Randolph Ridge Lane out in between Wellington and Gainesville.
02:18:03
It's located on Norfolk Southern's Manassas Line and it does provide good local service on a daily basis.
02:18:11
This project again is a Martin Brouwer development under Ray's Holdings.
02:18:16
They are the company that supplies McDonald's, hamburgers, french fries franchises.
02:18:22
600 of those franchises will be served out of this facility.
02:18:27
If you ever want to see what one of these looks like inside, Modern Marvels did a special
02:18:32
on cable TV, obviously, on how food service is being mechanized for the quality and consistency of those services, and Martin Brower is a big part of that.
02:18:41
They're currently located in Prince William County today.
02:18:44
The challenge, Mr. Chairman and members of the board, was that they were now going to have to ramp up to higher standards to supply a more consistent and quality product.
02:18:51
Martin Brower then worked with the county and the Department of Rail and Public Transportation to put forth a strategy with the Economic Development Partnership that would seek to locate them again in the county.
02:19:04
They're basically moving down the tracks and to use a McDonald's term, they're going to supersize their facility.
02:19:09
They're going to set out a new rail facility that will accommodate up to 12 rail cars at a time and they will have a ramping of beginning around 500 cars and then moving up from there on a basis over the next 15 years.
02:19:24
This $22 million project is going to retain 225 employees and also provide 65 additional jobs in the new mechanized plant that they're putting together.
02:19:34
We will again come back to you in February and Prince William County did approve the local resolution in October 2nd of 2007 and the Economic Development Partnership has also come forth and supported this project in coordination with that.
02:19:49
Mr. Chairman, if there are any questions, I'll put this back to you and I'll be happy to come back to the board in February for action.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:57
Any questions for Mr.
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:19:57
Page?
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:58
I'm just curious.
02:19:59
I never would have expected McDonald's to use so much rail.
02:20:03
What do they get?
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:20:05
That's a very good question.
02:20:07
Potatoes come from the Midwest.
02:20:10
Beef comes in refrigerated cars now in large volumes.
02:20:13
and also Martin Brower is supplying into the Latin American continent now.
02:20:17
So under NAFTA and the good trade quarters that Norfolk Southern has been able to put forth in working with what they refer to as a crescent quarter, we're hoping to see even greater opportunities in just domestic traffic within the United States but also some traffic that could go south of the border.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:20:31
That's very interesting.
02:20:34
What's their service area?
02:20:36
I mean, is it a tri-state?
02:20:37
Do they go as far as Maryland?
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:20:39
Currently today it's along the mid-Atlantic regional states.
02:20:43
I mean, the center will serve...
02:20:46
Yes ma'am, 600 restaurants is what they will be serving out of this one facility.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:20:54
Mr.
02:20:54
Page, is it fair to say that
02:20:57
This investment will occur in roughly the same location where the I-81 rail improvements are incurred?
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:21:05
Yes sir, and that's the reason why you see that the county actually passed a resolution back in October.
02:21:10
DRPT is making an assertive effort that we come to the CTB with projects that don't interfere with other projects.
02:21:16
And what we did was we actually went back to Norfolk Southern and Martin Brower worked very collectively with them and in a cooperative fashion we actually moved the second track project just a little bit so that we could get that switch in and accommodate without conflicts to potential expansion of VRE service or the I-81 phase one project that's being funded through the General Assembly's actions.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:40
Theoretically, absent those rail improvements, some of these potatoes might be coming on a truck and over 64 and up 81 and up 66.
02:21:50
So this is the kind of investment, granted it's a couple hundred thousand dollars, but it does make a difference and it meshes with some of our larger investment goals.
02:21:59
Thank you so much.
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:22:00
Thank you, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:00
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
02:22:02
The next item is the DRP Director's Report.
02:22:05
Mr. Tucker.
02:22:08
And we'll take a break after the web session.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:14
Mr.
02:22:15
Chair, I promise to be quick.
02:22:17
A couple of housekeeping items.
02:22:18
I know from the CTB meeting that we had back in Roanoke a couple of months ago there were questions relative to the 81 freight study.
02:22:29
I know Mr. McCarthy had raised some questions and Mr. Davis.
02:22:33
We are in fact working on answers to their questions.
02:22:36
We've submitted questions to the consultants and we're working through those answers and we look forward to coming back to you next month.
02:22:42
And we'll try to catch up before the meeting to discuss the findings based upon the questions that we received.
02:22:49
I also wanted to update on a couple of other items.
02:22:53
One item I want to update if you recall from the 2007 budget language there was a requirement
02:22:58
that DRPT execute an operating agreement with CSX prior to allocation of additional funds to CSX for rail improvements.
02:23:08
We have executed that agreement with them.
02:23:11
That agreement sort of sets the stage for the future direction of passenger rail in the Commonwealth.
02:23:18
There's a couple of, two big pieces of information in there.
02:23:22
We set an internal policy goal of an on-time performance of 95% for passenger rail for the state of Virginia.
02:23:31
If you're aware that Amtrak and CSX were doing a study for 80% on-time performance over the entire Amtrak range of operations, but what we've said in Virginia that the standard has to be a lot higher if we truly want to see people get out of their car and get into the train.
02:23:49
The other issue is that we've gotten CSX to agree with us on development of basis of design requirements and agreement on means and methods for construction activities.
02:24:00
It just goes back to the heart and soul of some of the heat restriction issues that have occurred historically.
02:24:06
It really deals with the fact that we know that we're going to be operating a railroad
02:24:09
That's going to have both freight and passenger rail needs.
02:24:13
It cuts both ways when you have the discussion about reaching agreement on basis of design requirements because at the end of the day it ultimately means in some instances you're going to pay more in order to make sure that you can have the passenger rail operate with the reliability and speeds that you're looking for.
02:24:31
But that is well underway with CSX and we're in the process now of looking at additional agreements that help move the ball forward for passenger rail.
02:24:39
One other item I wanted to update everyone on is the asset management system development.
02:24:46
One of the interesting discussions in Virginia is that we're a maintenance first state that's actually only been implemented, Mr.
02:24:54
Chair, on VDOT's side of the house.
02:24:57
If you look at the Department of Rail and Public Transportation,
02:25:00
We really have not had a program that was essentially a maintenance first.
02:25:04
Throughout all of the years, when we had the years of 22% match availability, we took new projects in at the same time.
02:25:12
What the asset management system is going to allow us to do is, one, get a good understanding of the condition of key assets throughout the state.
02:25:20
And it's also going to help us in terms of looking at various allocation scenarios depending on whether we got a lot of money
02:25:26
or we got less money than we thought we had and it's going to really put you in a position as a board to have better information about the choices that we make in allocating funds.
02:25:36
As you all are aware, we received a $60 million additional funding from HB 3202 through the bond program and that comes from a different pot that has some restricted uses that go against with the standard funds that we use that cover a wide array of capital needs.
02:25:54
So we're going to have to look at how we fund items that are eligible and then when we look at that we're going to also be probably having some capability in some instances to fund new projects but the key question is going to be what are the projects that provide the highest rate of return for the Commonwealth of Virginia.
02:26:10
So July 1, we're going to be in a position to be able to present a baseline of information to you, and I think it's going to fundamentally change the way that we look at transit in Virginia and help us be able to predict out over a short-range, six-year, and a long-range vision 20 years of what our asset needs are going to be on the transit side.
02:26:27
I also wanted to update the board on the meetings that we've had with the Federal Railroad Administration.
02:26:33
I know folks have heard a lot of discussion about funding being created to support Amtrak.
02:26:40
The Federal Railroad Administration actually would be the entity in charge of administering those funds.
02:26:46
There are two programs that they have up and running.
02:26:49
One is a mainline relocation fund that essentially provides money to communities or states or public entities to offset costs towards moving rail traffic from one line to another line.
02:27:03
It's not a lot of money, but it's $20 million that's going to be available to that.
02:27:07
Of the $20 million, $5 million has already been earmarked, so you can look for $15 million that would be available on a nationwide basis.
02:27:15
There's also a state grant program that was created.
02:27:20
That program is a 50-50 match between the Federal Railroad Administration and states, and that fund would provide about $30 million on an annual basis to support projects for enhanced passenger rail.
02:27:35
We've had a lot of discussions with the folks at FRA and we're trying to be prepared at the point that they actually release accept applications to support projects and initiatives that may be important to Virginia.
02:27:49
The last thing is just one update on a couple of studies really quickly.
02:27:53
We're going to be moving forward with the regional transit study for the Hampton Roads region.
02:27:58
We've talked to all of the parties in the region from the MPO to the transit authority and we're all on the same page in terms of moving forward with that.
02:28:06
The Richmond area of study is already underway, but we also have worked with Greater Richmond Transit Company.
02:28:12
They have plans for bus rapid transit, so we're going to collaborate with them on a bus rapid transit project that we hope to move forward rather quickly.
02:28:21
If you take a look out on Broad Street, there have been bus only lanes striped.
02:28:27
One other thing, they're tight.
02:28:29
and we're really starting to take a good look within our own backyard of how can we make transit much more relevant in the region.
02:28:36
My whole transit system is a system that I think has some opportunities and we're looking forward to work with them.
02:28:43
And interestingly enough, we've been receiving a lot of requests from rural communities
02:28:47
For us to come in and work with them on regional transit studies, Martinsville and a couple other areas have sent us letters that we responded back to saying that we would support them in terms of needing to complete regional studies to either determine the feasibility or look at a long-range approach to providing public transit.
02:29:07
That completes my comments, Mr.
02:29:08
Chair.
02:29:09
Questions, Mr. Tucker?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:12
Mr. Davis?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:12
Any possibility of
02:29:15
That crossed the top of Northern Virginia for rail service?
02:29:20
Has that been included in any of the discussions?
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:23
Well, I think if you look at the legislation that's out there, it's a requirement for us to look at rail within Virginia, particularly 95 Quarter.
02:29:30
But we have been looking at, throughout the state of Virginia, in all of our rail planning activities for passenger rail, looking at what is short range and what is long range for the state of Virginia.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:40
Speaking of Winchester to Manassas.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:42
We're looking at that.
02:29:46
Any other questions?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:48
Congratulations on the CSX agreement.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:52
Thank you Mr. Tucker
02:29:54
The final presentation is by the ever-patient, Mike Estes, who has a collection of local assistance programs that are among the most difficult to administer in the Commonwealth.
02:30:07
Thank you for being with us today and sharing your views on recreational access fund policies.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:30:12
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
02:30:14
It's difficult, but they are fun, so we're going to make this fun six slides or less on recreational access.
02:30:23
You'll be getting a policy hopefully next month for your approval and that's what we're going to talk about is kind of what that is going to be next month.
02:30:30
So we're down to five to go.
02:30:32
I thought I would start with a general overview of kind of the program itself.
02:30:37
Just a simple reminder.
02:30:39
It is of course set in code.
02:30:41
We're granted about a million and a half dollars each year through the appropriation act.
02:30:45
It provides access to public recreational areas or historical sites, roads and bikeways, an important factor of the program.
02:30:54
We do a lot of extensive coordination with both the Department of Conservation and Recreation as well as the Department of Historic Resources.
02:31:03
Again, limits are set by law.
02:31:06
We can fund up to $400,000 for state sites.
02:31:11
We can fund $250,000 unmatched with an additional $100,000 match for locality or authority sites.
02:31:17
And bikeways are funded actually separately.
02:31:19
We can fund up to $75,000 maximum for a state site and $60,000 unmatched with an additional $15,000 match for locality or authority sites.
02:31:29
One of the big emphasis is also in the CTB policy is the fact that land acquisition and utility relocations, we typically leave those to the authority, the state agency development site, or the locality.
02:31:45
Recent changes and this has been, you'll see here in a minute, most of them came out of a legislative session a few years back.
02:31:52
Really they were to kind of bring us back into line with practice that we had been utilizing already within our guidance and really I think was somewhat inferred already in the CTB policy and we'll talk about that in a minute.
02:32:05
But through some discussions we were having on a potential project, and I'll show you an example, the Attorney General's Office brought up a concern of whether we could actually grant two access roads into one facility.
02:32:16
I'll give you a good example here in a minute.
02:32:19
So we brought that to the attention of DCR a couple years ago.
02:32:22
They picked up a legislative proposal, moved that forward through the General Assembly, and have corrected that concern in the Code.
02:32:31
For the policy next month, again, we'll clarify some of that as well.
02:32:35
During that correction, during 2005, Department of Historic Resources asked for a little more participation level with the program, so they were added as a consulting agency within the code as well.
02:32:49
We'll talk about that very briefly.
02:32:51
Here's an example.
02:32:53
I won't go into any great detail, but Clodmore Park up in Loudoun County.
02:32:58
This one example is, you can see the one road at the bottom of the screen was approved by the board in 1993.
02:33:06
And then what happened, that got access into the museum site subsequently later in 2001.
02:33:17
Working with DCR, they came back to us and said, we have a new location for visitor centers that doesn't have adequate access to the board-granted access to that site at that time.
02:33:28
Again, the concern was under the strict interpretation of the code, we weren't sure we were able to do that, so we got that clarified back in 2005.
02:33:37
I won't go through this in any detail.
02:33:39
This is simply just giving you, for your reference, the exact changes in the code to clarify, again, working with DHR, the ability to work with multiple sites within recreational or historical sites.
02:33:56
So again, you have a copy of the policy that we'll be bringing to you.
02:34:00
It's in its draft form.
02:34:02
We've done it in track changes, so you can see what we've tried to change.
02:34:05
It really just simply reflects, clarifies some things.
02:34:08
We've taken away some of the stipulations and concise requirements for bikeways, tried to make that a little broader to be more in line with CTB's policy on bicycle and pedestrian facilities, and clarified some of the existing language.
02:34:24
Once, if it is the board's wish that we approve that next month, we'll go forward and update our internal guide so that the localities and our staff in the districts and residencies will have a better document to work on.
02:34:36
The last bullet in our effort to make sure on fiscal responsibility we are proposing it in our guide that we start putting more emphasis on moving projects forward within a certain amount of time frame to the last bullet.
02:34:50
With that, Mr. Chairman, that's my six slides or less on recreational access.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:54
Okay, questions of Mr. Estes?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:56
Are these requests generated only by DCR or can they be generated by the site, a locality, a private entity, a non-profit that runs the site?
02:35:07
I mean, how do these things come to us?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:35:09
Great question.
02:35:10
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Koelemay, typically it's going to be at the local level.
02:35:15
The locality is working with an entity or an authority to generate that at the local government level.
02:35:22
They'll contact DCR to generate the site interest and get the qualifications through DCR and maybe the Department of Historic Resources.
02:35:30
And then we kind of come into it towards the latter stages of the planning stages up to, well, how do we get access to it?
02:35:37
And that's where VDOT comes in to help with that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:41
OK, so we'll see this at next month's CTB business session, correct?
02:35:46
Yes, sir.
02:35:47
Thank you, Mr. Estes.
02:35:49
That concludes the work session.
02:35:51
We'll recess until 3 o'clock, and we'll come back and take the business agenda up, hopefully briskly.
02:35:58
And then again, remember at 5 o'clock, we have to wrap 29 discussions.
02:36:03
That is for interested members of the CTB.
02:36:06
We know there will be more than four, so it is a public meeting, but that is not part of the official agenda, so if you don't have an interest in the 29 study, don't feel compelled to stay.