Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 2/19/2019
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   2/19/2019

Attachments
  • HIGHWAY AUTOMATION DIALOG WORKSHOP.pdf
  • Hampton Roads Bridge-Tunnel procurement update.pdf
  • Martinsville Southern Connector _ Route 220 environmental impact statement.pdf
  • Issuance of the Series 2019 Capital Projects Revenue Bonds.pdf
  • Roadside.pdf
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:06:40
      What the hell's going on, man?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:51
      Okay well good morning everybody.
    • 00:06:53
      Naturally it's February and we have some weather coming in so there is a 10 o'clock weather call this morning and we'll get an update and then we'll figure out if there are any logistics we need to deal with Carol.
    • 00:07:10
      So in the meantime let's start with the Pledge of Allegiance.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:27
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:36
      So first up on the workshop today, we're going to get an update on the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
    • 00:07:42
      Is that right?
    • 00:07:45
      By the expression on your face, Jim, I wasn't quite sure.
    • 00:07:48
      Yes, I think we are.
    • 00:07:49
      And I think you all were sent the announcement that came out this week.
    • 00:07:55
      Steve and Mr. Johnson, thank you very much for your note.
    • 00:07:59
      Largest transportation project in Virginia's history.
    • 00:08:03
      It could not have happened without the collaboration with
    • 00:08:06
      are CTB board members from the region with HRTAC, with the HRTPO, the Commonwealth Virginia with VDOT.
    • 00:08:17
      It has been quite a collaborative effort.
    • 00:08:20
      And so with that, Jim, Mr. Utterback, I welcome you here this morning.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:08:23
      Madam Chairman, members of the board, thank you.
    • 00:08:25
      I'll take a minute to give an update as the presentation's coming up.
    • 00:08:38
      Okay so this morning again this is going to be a procurement update I just want to set the stage that we still are under an active procurement so there's some information we won't be sharing today just to again protect the integrity of the procurement we will be providing a more detailed brief
    • 00:08:56
      Next month at the March meeting and go through some of the details on the agreement with HRTAC for funding.
    • 00:09:04
      So the way it's going to work this morning is Morteza and I are going to tag team on this.
    • 00:09:08
      I'll go through the procurement on the project itself and Morteza will talk about the project funding and administration agreement with HRTAC, where that stands and some of the terms associated with that.
    • 00:09:21
      and Morteza has been involved, as you can see he's dual-hatted as Acting Deputy Secretary and Director of P3 Office, so he's been involved with the procurement since the start.
    • 00:09:34
      I will say that I'll just spend a second on this.
    • 00:09:37
      I've been to the board twice I guess in 2018.
    • 00:09:40
      In June I came and talked about the procurement and at that time we had shortlisted the offers and then in September I came back and talked about the key terms and briefed the board on that in Winchester if you remember.
    • 00:09:53
      So we're not going to spend too much time on that.
    • 00:09:57
      has not spent too much time on this as well.
    • 00:10:00
      So the project is 10 miles, goes from settlers landing on the peninsula side and basically where we go to a four-lane section we'll be increasing it to a six-lane section, a drivable shoulder.
    • 00:10:13
      We'll cross the harbor with about three and a half miles of a bridge tunnel facility that will
    • 00:10:17
      Go from four lanes current capacity to eight lanes and then when we get on the south side again the four lane section will go to six lanes plus a driveable or managed shoulder so the current tunnels will will both go westbound and the new tunnels will go eastbound and there will be two new tunnels.
    • 00:10:39
      This is the procurement schedule.
    • 00:10:40
      I'm happy to be here today, so we've been quite a journey.
    • 00:10:44
      We have managed to keep this on schedule.
    • 00:10:48
      We had a little bit of an adjustment in December, but as you can see, we started December of 2017 and have gone through the draft RFP.
    • 00:10:59
      We had six rounds of meetings with
    • 00:11:01
      with the two teams that were pursuing this project.
    • 00:11:06
      From that standpoint, we did a final RFP.
    • 00:11:09
      We had three addendums.
    • 00:11:11
      The technical proposals came in January 15th with price proposals coming in on February 8th and price evaluation is bringing us up to today.
    • 00:11:22
      So let me just clarify.
    • 00:11:23
      So we had two proposals were received.
    • 00:11:27
      Both of these teams are world class teams.
    • 00:11:30
      So they put in good responsive proposals.
    • 00:11:35
      So the technical proposals came in, met minimum requirements and all the pass fail criteria.
    • 00:11:42
      One thing I will say is we scored these and when we completed the technical scoring, we had those scores when the teams delivered their price proposals, they were given their technical proposals at that time.
    • 00:11:58
      So they had a clear, they knew when they put their price proposal in, we gave them their technical score.
    • 00:12:05
      So the best value determination is very kind of straightforward.
    • 00:12:11
      And we talked about this at the, just as a reminder, at the September meeting.
    • 00:12:16
      This particular project, due to the technical complexity, we had gone with a 40 technical, 60 price.
    • 00:12:23
      So typically you see a 30, 70, or 70, 30.
    • 00:12:26
      So we went a little bit higher based on the technology.
    • 00:12:30
      So with
    • 00:12:32
      technical and price being added together to give you your max score.
    • 00:12:38
      Again, the technical evaluation, I got ahead of myself, was completed prior to the price proposals.
    • 00:12:44
      There was a fairly extensive effort to make sure that all of the requirements were met and then the actual scoring was an executive scoring panel.
    • 00:12:54
      You can see there, deputy commissioner, chief engineer.
    • 00:12:57
      Project Director and the HRTAC Executive Director was a non-voting member participant.
    • 00:13:02
      So you can, from the standpoint of the points, we really kind of divided the points and the factors you can see in the table there, ranging from key personnel, partnership into design concepts, construction, environmental maintenance.
    • 00:13:18
      So all of the things that we were looking at that would be value to us, or out of value, is how we looked at scoring this.
    • 00:13:32
      The financial proposed score is 60 points.
    • 00:13:35
      So basically the way the formula works is each point is worth 30 million dollars.
    • 00:13:40
      We establish that through a number of communications with the teams and again the complexity of the project to arrive at a value for each point that would basically
    • 00:13:51
      Be attractive for the technical scoring and the price scoring.
    • 00:13:55
      So the way it works is the lowest bid price by any offer is the benchmark and they get 60 points.
    • 00:14:02
      There's then a calculation between the two proposals to distinguish basically the higher proposal or the best proposal subtracted from the higher proposal and that is divided by 30 million to give you your points.
    • 00:14:19
      So that's
    • 00:14:19
      That's really how the equation works.
    • 00:14:22
      It's fairly straightforward.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:26
      Was the technical side scored the same way that the highest technical score was 40 and then a reduction?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:14:35
      The way the scoring worked on the technical side, there was a maximum of 40 points.
    • 00:14:42
      So you saw the points there.
    • 00:14:43
      There was a number of criteria under each one of the categories.
    • 00:14:46
      So it was just accumulative.
    • 00:14:48
      So you went through and scored each one of the factors.
    • 00:14:50
      Their points were what the points were.
    • 00:14:52
      You didn't start at 40 and work.
    • 00:14:54
      The points were what the points were, yes.
    • 00:14:56
      So the calculation with the 30 and the 60, basically so you can see if the bid difference was 30 million dollars, then one team got 60 points, the other team got 59 points.
    • 00:15:08
      The technical scores were added to that to give you the total.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:15:15
      So on the technical side, if the teams would give us exactly what we have asked in the proposal, just meeting all of our requirements, they basically get zero.
    • 00:15:24
      For anything that they exceed, they go above and beyond what we have asked them to provide.
    • 00:15:29
      If it falls under one of those categories that Jim mentioned earlier, and we deem that that's valuable to us, based on that value, we give them extra points.
    • 00:15:37
      So that's how the technical is working.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:15:45
      Okay, so my last slide is the apparent best value proposer is the Hampton Roads Connector Partners.
    • 00:15:52
      And just as a reminder, the lead contractors are Dragados USA, Vinci Construction Grand Projects, Flatiron Constructors, and Donan Compagnon Bernard.
    • 00:16:02
      So the lead designers were HDR and Mott McDonald.
    • 00:16:06
      This team met all the qualification experience requirements and we actually ended up with the best scenario and the best value you can hope for.
    • 00:16:15
      So I stress that as the highest technical score and the lowest financial score.
    • 00:16:22
      highest technical score and financial score.
    • 00:16:24
      So in other words, the best technical proposal and the lowest bid price.
    • 00:16:29
      So that's what you can hope for in these type of scenarios.
    • 00:16:33
      The design build contract value is 3.3 billion dollars.
    • 00:16:41
      That's all I had.
    • 00:16:42
      If there's no questions, I'll go to Morteza and he'll step through the project funding agreement and the remaining milestones to contract award.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:49
      Then we may come back and do questions at the end.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:16:55
      Thank you Jim and good morning.
    • 00:16:58
      So I will try to walk you through the effort that we have gone through it over the last couple of months and we need to go to the next slide.
    • 00:17:11
      Okay perfect.
    • 00:17:12
      So in order for us to proceed with this project, we need to execute a document that we call it Project Administration and Funding Agreement with Hampton Road Transportation Accountability Commission.
    • 00:17:27
      Over the last couple of months we have been collaboratively working with HRTAC and we have been able to develop a term sheet that was the first step for us so that we can at least agree on major business terms that we want to put in that funding agreement, PAFA.
    • 00:17:47
      That term sheet was finalized on February 8th.
    • 00:17:51
      Based on that term sheet, we started drafting the PAFA.
    • 00:17:55
      A draft of that was completed and shared with HRTAC at the same time that it was shared with us and VDOT to review it, so we're going through that process right now.
    • 00:18:05
      We haven't really been able to comment on it or finalize it, so that draft was just drafted by lawyers.
    • 00:18:11
      But we have the opportunity between now and probably end of this month to go through it and finalize that document.
    • 00:18:21
      Our goal is to be able to finalize it and have it ready for both CTB and HRTAC to see a version of that and take
    • 00:18:30
      and action in the respective meetings in March to authorize Commissioner of Highways and Chairman of HRTAC to execute that document.
    • 00:18:40
      There was a meeting just last week that Deputy Secretary Donohue, myself, we went to Norfolk and we met with HRTAC, HRBT Funding Agreement Advisory Committee.
    • 00:18:53
      We
    • 00:18:54
      We briefed them on the procurement.
    • 00:18:56
      Some of the information that we are sharing with you today, we shared with them on Friday.
    • 00:19:01
      Also we discussed the term sheet with them.
    • 00:19:04
      On their side they are also trying to brief their board and make sure that everyone is on the same page for a March action.
    • 00:19:14
      So I will just try to walk you through some of the major terms of PAFA.
    • 00:19:19
      You should have received a copy of the term sheet in your package if you want to read through it.
    • 00:19:28
      It's not a very...
    • 00:19:33
      Large document, it's probably just 10, 11 pages, but I'll try to walk you through some of the major items in that agreement.
    • 00:19:43
      First of all, the SCOPA project is being outlined in the document.
    • 00:19:47
      VDOT and HRTAC each have their own roles and responsibilities.
    • 00:19:51
      VDOT in this case is going to administer the contract, execute and administer the contract.
    • 00:19:57
      HRTAC is going to be the funding partner.
    • 00:20:00
      Project funding in general, you will see that HRTAC is the main source of funding for project $3.217 billion.
    • 00:20:09
      That's being backed by HRTAC tax dollars.
    • 00:20:13
      About $345 million is going to be backed by toll revenue.
    • 00:20:19
      And both of those two numbers come from HRTAC's plan of finance that has been already adopted by their board.
    • 00:20:29
      Potential SMART SCALE funding, that's something that you have already been briefed on.
    • 00:20:32
      This project has submitted an application for $200 million SMART SCALE that we are waiting on your decision to award that.
    • 00:20:39
      And another item that I need to highlight here is that VDOT will pay for South Island Trestle bridge replacement.
    • 00:20:49
      That's an agreement that we have with HRTAC.
    • 00:20:51
      VDOT has 180 days
    • 00:20:53
      from the time that we received our contract to go through that process, identify funding for it and be able to keep it in the contract.
    • 00:21:03
      So that is already part of the $3.3 billion price that Jim mentioned earlier and it's going to be paid by VDOT.
    • 00:21:10
      There are a couple of limited notice to precedes in this project.
    • 00:21:16
      I just want to take a second to just explain what they are.
    • 00:21:20
      Some of you probably remember that in the past we have had some issues with permitting process and now in our P3 projects we want to make sure that we can manage that risk and we are not really getting ahead of ourself and overspending money before we have certainty that project has permit.
    • 00:21:40
      So in this case, we are going to issue a limited notice to proceed after the contract is executed upon satisfaction of certain documents that they need to provide to us.
    • 00:21:51
      That would get $125 million and they don't get all of that money upfront.
    • 00:21:56
      We still need to go through the invoicing process on a monthly basis.
    • 00:21:59
      They submit their invoices to us and we pay them.
    • 00:22:03
      But what happens is that that amount is capped at $125 million and it's intended to be spent on advancing their design and advancing their permitting activities so they can submit a permit application.
    • 00:22:16
      When they submit their permit application, LNTP2 and LNTP3 happen.
    • 00:22:22
      Upon satisfactory submission of a complete permit application, we give them $75 million that they can use toward ordering a board machine.
    • 00:22:33
      It takes some time to put the order in, manufacture it, send it to the site, assemble it, so that $75 million is supposed to cover some of those expenses.
    • 00:22:44
      So while they are going through permitting process, we want to make sure that that activity also starts, otherwise project is going to be delayed.
    • 00:22:51
      And also they get $50 million that they can spend to prepare a launching pit and make sure that when the boarding machine is transferred on site, site is also ready for the boarding machine.
    • 00:23:03
      And then finally, if everything goes according to plan, about 18 months after LNTP1, if we have no reason to believe that the permit is not going to be issued and commissioner is satisfied with their progress, we can authorize them to spend another $75 million.
    • 00:23:21
      And that's really when we are almost there, just waiting for the signatures to be on the document.
    • 00:23:27
      So everything is capped at $325 million and no event is going to go beyond that.
    • 00:23:32
      HRTAC is paying for all of that amount except for that $75 million for whatever reason, commissioner authorizes it but we don't move, for whatever reason we can't get the permit and move forward.
    • 00:23:46
      That is the risk that VDOT is going to take.
    • 00:23:50
      And then finally if we get permit we go to notice to proceed similar to all other projects.
    • 00:23:58
      Financial responsibility for cost increases, we have defined a project contingency account.
    • 00:24:05
      So as long as we are within that contingency account, we have a process that is outlined in the term sheet.
    • 00:24:11
      We need to go through the change order process, depending on really what is the amount of change order we may need to go to HRTAG, get approval, or we may not need to go to HRTAG and get the approval.
    • 00:24:21
      So I'm not going to go into the details of how that's going to work, but there are basically different steps depending on what is the amount of change order, as long as you're within that contingency amount.
    • 00:24:31
      If we go beyond contingency, we have identified a couple of options for us to be able to deal with that.
    • 00:24:37
      One option could be
    • 00:24:39
      maybe working on project scope and see what we can do in terms of adjusting project scope to get the project back within budget or finding other sources so that project can move forward.
    • 00:24:51
      Of course, if there is that scenario that we can't really make things happen by those two options, we always have the option to terminate a contract for convenience.
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:03
      That's always an option in all of the contracts.
    • 00:25:09
      In your process of developing the contingency, were there some hot items that you have identified as potential risk factors that could escalate costs or do we presume that we're well within our budget plan and the contingency is just there?
    • 00:25:29
      to accommodate anything unanticipated, but I guess I'm just trying to figure out, are there some risks that we've identified that could arise that we can talk about now?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:25:41
      Yes, the answer is those risks have been identified and Jim can explain this in more detail too, but there was a cost estimate review process with Federal Highway Administration.
    • 00:25:52
      We developed a risk register.
    • 00:25:55
      For each one of those risks, we looked at the probability of the risk happening.
    • 00:25:58
      We looked at the impact of that risk happening.
    • 00:26:01
      And then there was a Monte Carlo simulation that we go through it.
    • 00:26:04
      to come up with the most likely case that what is a reasonable amount of contingency that we should believe and I believe Jim and his team have also gone through the process of kind of identifying different milestones in the project for example during early phases scope validation what type of risk can happen after that what type of risk can happen you want to
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:26:22
      Yeah, I think the only thing I'll add is what Mortez just hit on is the scope validation at the beginning of the project, the first 180 days is where there's a risk in what we've missed as the contractor goes out and verifies all the information we provided in the bid documents.
    • 00:26:38
      So as you get through scope validation, the other risk that's outside of that is the geotechnical work.
    • 00:26:45
      So as he goes through and does the geotechnical work for the boring machine, that's a risk that we're...
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:53
      Yes, to translate for some of us non-technical folks, when you're saying geotechnical risk, meaning that when you bore, you know, is the soil, the substrate, all of that, what you expect it to be, or is there some risk that there could be something there that we don't know about that...
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:27:07
      Exactly.
    • 00:27:08
      That's exactly right.
    • 00:27:09
      So we have a baseline so they'll go out and validate or test or get data against our baseline.
    • 00:27:15
      So that's pretty much it.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:18
      Thanks.
    • 00:27:18
      Mr. Brown, I will just add that this past year really has the main focus or a main focus has been on identifying the risk given the magnitude of this project.
    • 00:27:29
      So identifying the risk, managing it and mitigating it.
    • 00:27:32
      So building that into this entire procurement has been a huge focus.
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:37
      I'm a little sensitive.
    • 00:27:38
      I have a little experience with big projects.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:40
      And for us, a small change can translate into a large problem.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:27:50
      That's exactly the case and that's why in our PPTA guidelines we have at least two risk workshops in different stages of project development and procurement.
    • 00:27:59
      We have to go through it and then we have to sit down with Federal Highways to go through it one more time.
    • 00:28:04
      So there have been multiple steps throughout this process.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:08
      Madam Chair, in the event of an issue with a project of this magnitude, there will be issues.
    • 00:28:17
      What is the size of our reserve to be able to deal with any potential issues?
    • 00:28:27
      Was it $300 million?
    • 00:28:28
      I remember I saw it at one point in time.
    • 00:28:30
      Is it $200 million?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:28:32
      I don't have the exact number right now, but ballpark I think you're right.
    • 00:28:35
      That's almost the size of the contingency account that has been identified.
    • 00:28:38
      But we are trying to finalize it now with Trestles being in and with a couple of other things that are happening.
    • 00:28:45
      In March we can give you an exact amount for that, but ballpark I think you're close to the amount.
    • 00:28:55
      Okay, so we talked about what happens in case we are spending more than the amount that we were supposed to spend and tapping into the contingency, but also the other side of it is that if we don't use all of the contingency, all of the money that is in the contingency, the remaining of that fund goes back to HRTAC because they are the ones who are funding this project.
    • 00:29:18
      So that is the second bullet we have there.
    • 00:29:22
      VDOT is going to own the facility.
    • 00:29:25
      VDOT is going to operate and maintain the facility, regular operation and maintenance of the facility.
    • 00:29:31
      We are discussing the tolling policy
    • 00:29:35
      Jr. issues with HRTAC.
    • 00:29:37
      That's a conversation that we have had in multiple meetings with them and we have made very good progress.
    • 00:29:44
      Commissioner wrote a letter to Chairman Hippel and in that letter he basically committed to work with them in the future to make sure that
    • 00:29:57
      We collectively address the objectives that both HR Tech and VDOT have.
    • 00:30:03
      There are a couple of studies that are ongoing.
    • 00:30:05
      We are waiting for the results of those studies.
    • 00:30:07
      So when we get our operational analysis that is underway, our traffic and revenue numbers, I think we can have a more informed discussion on the tolling side.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:17
      So today- Madam Chair, that brings me, where did the 345 million toll revenue come from?
    • 00:30:23
      Who created that number?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:30:25
      That is the number that was assumed by HRTAC in their plan of finance.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:32
      That's not based on any in-depth TNR study or certainly not an investment grade.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:30:41
      No, that amount comes directly from final finance that HR tag has, but I can tell you that all the scenarios I have seen so far in TNR studies that we have ran, I think we can raise at least that much.
    • 00:30:56
      Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:01
      Thank you, Orteza.
    • 00:31:05
      The studies that have been done so far, the TNR studies that have been done so far you're saying are covering that 345 in the various scenarios.
    • 00:31:13
      And that study's not done yet, correct?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:31:16
      That study is still underway.
    • 00:31:18
      We have not finalized it yet because depending on really what the final scope is, our traffic and revenue scenarios may change.
    • 00:31:26
      We have run multiple scenarios internally.
    • 00:31:29
      We have run multiple scenarios at HR tax requests that we have provided to them.
    • 00:31:33
      We have the model.
    • 00:31:34
      We have created the model and that model is really ready to run any scenario that we may want to run based on the
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:42
      So when Mr. Hall came to HRTAC last month and spoke about the operational analysis and the study, there was some concern about the parameters of the study.
    • 00:31:58
      Are you familiar with that concern?
    • 00:32:01
      Meaning that the question was were we looking for maximum throughput and operational efficiency?
    • 00:32:10
      Were we looking for maximum revenue?
    • 00:32:12
      Where were we on that scale?
    • 00:32:15
      And there were two points that he was going to bring us data on, neither of which was no revenue.
    • 00:32:24
      So how does that all sort of work itself through and where are we versus maximum revenue versus maximum congestion relief slash throughput?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:32:35
      So in traffic and revenue studies usually creating the model is the hardest part.
    • 00:32:40
      When they create the model we can run different scenarios.
    • 00:32:43
      We can basically adjust the model any way we want.
    • 00:32:46
      I specifically asked your consultant that question that where are we now?
    • 00:32:50
      Are we maximum throughput?
    • 00:32:51
      Are we maximum revenue?
    • 00:32:53
      The response I have got is that it really depends on which scenario you're talking about, but they told me that in some of the scenarios that at least I have seen, there's not a lot of difference between them.
    • 00:33:03
      So that's what the consultant told me.
    • 00:33:06
      As I explained earlier, we have just created the model.
    • 00:33:09
      The model is just a vehicle.
    • 00:33:11
      Now we can adjust it any way we want.
    • 00:33:13
      So the hard part is being done.
    • 00:33:15
      From now on, we can just make the policy decision and go and adjust the model.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:18
      And I think what's going to happen is when you go back with those numbers, they're going to say,
    • 00:33:24
      They're going to ask you exactly the question I just asked you.
    • 00:33:27
      So we should be prepared to, to the extent that it's feasible, prepared to look at it in, you know, those different ways.
    • 00:33:35
      Because as you know, there's some sentiment that there'd be no tolls.
    • 00:33:39
      Of course we can't do that, we don't think.
    • 00:33:41
      And then there's sentiment to have tolls be minimum and then there's sentiment for some to maximize toll revenue.
    • 00:33:47
      So, you know, all along the continuum you're going to have different points of view and I think it's important that we
    • 00:33:53
      are able to respond to that, to those folks that are making the decisions at HRTAC.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:01
      Mr. Miller, I think it's really important that we're talking about two different things.
    • 00:34:05
      One is the traffic and revenue models that Morteza is referring to so that we can actually run different options for developing the actual model that we want the information to deliver.
    • 00:34:19
      The second is the operational piece, how this network is going to actually operate and connect because it's a fairly complicated system.
    • 00:34:30
      Right in the middle we have reversible lanes, you have High Rise Bridge, you have Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
    • 00:34:38
      That analysis is currently being done, how all the segments connect.
    • 00:34:43
      And then you put it together to determine what is the best operational and traffic and revenue model for Hampton Roads.
    • 00:34:53
      So all the pieces have to come together.
    • 00:34:55
      The operational piece, the initial analysis is due in April.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:35:04
      End of April, yes.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:05
      End of April.
    • 00:35:06
      That is ongoing, so I think it's a matter of taking this information and putting it together, but it is two pieces.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:14
      I understand that, but they are related.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:16
      Exactly.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:17
      One affects the other, if you will.
    • 00:35:22
      I just know that when we go back,
    • 00:35:25
      Taitre attack, regardless whether it's the operational efficiency or whether it's the toll and revenue study, they're gonna wanna see as much data as they can see to understand the impact of less tolls versus more tolls and how all that plays out.
    • 00:35:41
      And so we need to be, I think we need to be sensitive to that and smart and get ahead of that and say, okay, well, if it was X, you know, really de minimus, it would do Y, et cetera, et cetera, as opposed to coming in and just saying,
    • 00:35:54
      Here's where it is at this point.
    • 00:35:57
      So I know you can change it.
    • 00:35:58
      I'm just encouraging us to sort of present it that way.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:02
      Mr. Commissioner.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:03
      Madam Chairman, you're absolutely right.
    • 00:36:05
      I was going to say that we're disaggregating the two because the traffic and revenue and operations are separate.
    • 00:36:11
      I'd say from the starting point for the operational analysis, we are using the regional model and the effects of what a tolling regime would look like
    • 00:36:21
      from the regional HRTPO model and those assumptions that are built into it.
    • 00:36:26
      So that is going to give us how the general purpose lanes are going to function as well as the operations of the regional network and the ingress and egress points and identify any deficiencies that we have.
    • 00:36:39
      We recognize that the reversible lanes are flowing
    • 00:36:42
      in the opposite direction of an AM peak period.
    • 00:36:45
      So what is that net effect going to have on the region and the network and as vehicles egress the hot lanes, the managed lanes that we have right now in the eastbound direction from the HRBT and flow into the general purpose lanes, how is this going to affect it?
    • 00:37:03
      It's really laying the foundation for having
    • 00:37:07
      Sound decision-making moving forward in the effects of the regional network on a performance basis.
    • 00:37:14
      So I think that's one of the messages that we need to carry forward to the TPO as well as HRTAC that this is going to be the foundational from to start asking those questions as to whether it's maximization of revenue or throughput and then what are the deficiencies or the efficiencies that we have in the network that have to be addressed.
    • 00:37:37
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:38
      I think the main point is to make sure the region has all the information to make the decision.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:44
      Exactly.
    • 00:37:45
      That's the main point.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:46
      Ms. Hines.
    • 00:37:48
      Just to follow up, sitting where I sit and watching this
    • 00:37:52
      play out in Hampton Roads is pretty interesting because I was involved in the early conversations about tolling in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:38:00
      And I guess my request is that once we get through this, I don't want to complicate this, but once we get through this, I'm wondering if we don't need to look at what the CTBs
    • 00:38:11
      Kupferberg,
    • 00:38:28
      in a policy format craft a bit of messaging about what our goals are that then becomes a lens we can look through every time.
    • 00:38:37
      I know the answers are different in different places and I understand that but I am a little concerned and we saw a little bit of this in the 81 conversation
    • 00:38:46
      that if we're not clear in our messaging, people really do start looking at what the cost from their pocket is compared to what the cost from someone else's pocket is and we don't have a way, I don't have a way to sort of explain that away or put it into a context and it may be that having a more deep policy conversation once we have two or three experiences will get us to a better place in terms of communication.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:39:16
      Thank you.
    • 00:39:17
      Thank you.
    • 00:39:18
      And then finally, there are other topics that you will see in the term sheet, such as a process that has been defined for change orders.
    • 00:39:28
      I mentioned earlier that depending on really what is the amount of the change order and how much of contingency we have already spent where we are in terms of that contingency account, we have defined different steps that we need to take.
    • 00:39:41
      Some of them VDOT does not need to go to HRTAC.
    • 00:39:43
      Some of them we need to go to them for their approval for larger amounts.
    • 00:39:47
      We have a dispute resolution process.
    • 00:39:49
      It's very typical just in case there is any disagreement between the parties, what happens.
    • 00:39:54
      And we have a termination clause there too that if there is a termination, depending on really who is the cause of that termination, the consequence might be different for different parties.
    • 00:40:06
      But all of those details are in the term sheet that was provided to you.
    • 00:40:09
      I'm not going to go into the details, but I'll be happy to answer any questions that you may have.
    • 00:40:14
      And then finally there is a reporting and inspection rights process that basically says that VDOT is going to provide monthly reports to HRTAC in terms of the expenditures, in terms of where we are overall, in terms of contingency account and other things.
    • 00:40:32
      And HRTAC has the right to request for additional information at any time.
    • 00:40:38
      This is a partnership between VDOT and HRTAC so we wanted to make sure that it's very transparent and we are working together to make sure the project is going down the right path.
    • 00:40:50
      In terms of next steps, after this presentation we are going to initiate what we call a PPTA audit.
    • 00:41:01
      You might be familiar with that audit because it's in the code.
    • 00:41:04
      Any project that is procured under PPTA toward the end will need to bring an independent
    • 00:41:10
      We're a contractor consultant on board, provide them with procurement information.
    • 00:41:15
      They basically go through all of our records and make sure that we have followed that process.
    • 00:41:20
      They have the responsibility to raise flags anywhere that they think we have taken risks that are not ordinary for a project of this size and magnitude.
    • 00:41:30
      That report is going to be presented to Commissioner over the next two to three weeks.
    • 00:41:35
      At the same time, we are going to finalize our comprehensive agreement.
    • 00:41:39
      We are not really negotiating anything else in the comprehensive agreement, but we need to go back to that document and make certain adjustments.
    • 00:41:45
      There are a lot of blanks in the document we need to fill.
    • 00:41:48
      Also, wherever they have made commitments to us on the technical side, remember I mentioned earlier that we were giving them points for anything that they are
    • 00:41:56
      Exceeding in terms of what we had asked and what they have provided, we go back to our documents and make sure that we can capture as many of those as possible into the comprehensive agreement so it becomes binding for them.
    • 00:42:08
      So that process is going to happen between now and March 20th.
    • 00:42:14
      We will be back in front of you on March.
    • 00:42:17
      Commissioner needs to brief you on the certification of finding a public interest.
    • 00:42:25
      He has to sign that document before he can execute
    • 00:42:30
      The comprehensive agreement that's in the code, if you remember, finding a public interest was first signed by the previous commissioner when we started procurement in the code all the way toward the end.
    • 00:42:43
      Commissioner needs to certify that everything that we said back then is consistent with what we are delivering now and there are no surprises.
    • 00:42:51
      So that's going to be a step that needs to be taken and in my conversations with him, he's ready to brief you on his findings in March.
    • 00:43:02
      Right after that, actually in that meeting, Commissioner would also ask you to authorize him to enter into an agreement with HRTAC, PAFA that we discussed earlier.
    • 00:43:13
      Brich, Stephen A. Johnsen III, Stephen C. Brich,
    • 00:43:36
      The last step would be to execute CA, which we believe that's going to happen before April 15.
    • 00:43:43
      That's our goal, to make sure that the project stays on a schedule and moves forward smoothly.
    • 00:43:51
      There would be another PPTA steering committee briefing.
    • 00:43:54
      In the code, we are required to brief them on the CA and on the procurement again no later than 60 days after execution of CA.
    • 00:44:02
      We plan to do that.
    • 00:44:03
      And construction LNTP, as I mentioned earlier, could be issued within days after we execute the contract, the first one, so that they can start their design and permitting activities.
    • 00:44:16
      And the project completion date is November of 2025.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:44:22
      Can you please advise whether that $3.3 billion is inclusive or exclusive of funds for VDOT to manage the project?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:44:37
      That is exclusive.
    • 00:44:38
      That is only the value of the design bill contract with the contractor.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:44:44
      What do you have as an order of magnitude at this point to look at the additional costs to manage the program?
    • 00:44:51
      And I take it those are not being funded or are they being funded by HRTAC?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:44:56
      The answer to that is that the contract administration cost is going to be based on a per rata basis.
    • 00:45:03
      An agreement with HRTAC is that let's say if the cost of Trestles is just throwing out numbers now, 10% of overall project cost, VDOT would fund 10% of project administration cost.
    • 00:45:17
      and H. R. Tack would find 90% of that.
    • 00:45:19
      The exact numbers are not known right now.
    • 00:45:21
      Jim is trying to finalize them, but it's in the order of about $100 million, a little bit more or less.
    • 00:45:28
      Don't quote me on that, because as I mentioned earlier, we're still going through the process of finalizing it.
    • 00:45:33
      Really depending on different elements that are being finalized now, that number may be a little bit higher.
    • 00:45:40
      or maybe a little bit lower.
    • 00:45:41
      In March we will give you the exact numbers and we will tell you exactly what is the share of VDOT from that amount and what is the share of HR tax from that amount.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:50
      Thank you.
    • 00:45:50
      Mr. Smoot.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:52
      Thank you.
    • 00:45:53
      In projects such as this where tolling is a portion of the financial package, who is the at-risk party if tolling revenue is not recognized?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:46:07
      That is conversation that is happening between us and HRTAC to finalize the details of how the bonds would be issued for tolls.
    • 00:46:16
      We haven't finalized that conversation.
    • 00:46:18
      All options are on table.
    • 00:46:20
      But depending on really what is the final option that we are going to use, that risk may change on what party it's going to be.
    • 00:46:31
      But what I mentioned earlier is that
    • 00:46:34
      Under pretty much all the scenarios that I've seen so far, that amount is a safe amount to assume that can be raised off of this total revenue.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:46
      I assume that this body does not have the authority to commit the Commonwealth for indebtedness for which this body has no authority to collect the money.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:47:02
      This body does not have the authority to authorize that.
    • 00:47:06
      So if we go down the path, and that's why I said that we are looking at different options, and for each one of those options, what is the process to get the right approvals?
    • 00:47:16
      There are multiple options that are being discussed.
    • 00:47:19
      One option can be HRTAC issuing the bonds.
    • 00:47:22
      The other option could be maybe using one of the vehicles that Commonwealth has to issue the bonds.
    • 00:47:27
      But of course, for those options, we'll need to go through the process and get the necessary approvals.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:31
      So that decision is not a decision here but rather within the debt structure of the Commonwealth and those who have the authority to approve Commonwealth debt.
    • 00:47:43
      That is correct.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:46
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:46
      Mr. Williams.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:50
      My statement is not for anything technical.
    • 00:47:52
      It's just in general having represented the Senate District for 12 years that was directly impacted every day by this project.
    • 00:48:00
      And I know no one here believes that I was alive to ride in a car across the ferry before they ever had a bridge tunnel there, but I was.
    • 00:48:07
      I don't look it, but I was.
    • 00:48:10
      This is the day that I fought for for 12 years in the General Assembly, never got any traction.
    • 00:48:15
      Nobody wanted to do anything about it.
    • 00:48:17
      I want to commend the governor.
    • 00:48:18
      I want to commend you, Madam Secretary, and Steve, and Jim, and all your team's forgetfulness to this day.
    • 00:48:25
      I never thought I'd see it.
    • 00:48:27
      So I'm thrilled it's here.
    • 00:48:29
      You know, it's a tough, Hampton Roads is a lot tougher than most, given the constraints of all the water that we have there, and this is a nut I never thought I'd see cracked, and you folks have done it, and I applaud you for it.
    • 00:48:44
      I'm really proud of you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:45
      Mr. Williams, I will assure you, you were not alone.
    • 00:48:48
      Thank you for
    • 00:49:07
      The Commonwealth and with HRTAC and the TPO and the region, Senator Wagner has been a real leader and really the entire team.
    • 00:49:18
      So it's taken a lot.
    • 00:49:19
      And I'll also say that the Attorney General's Office, we have spent many, many long days going line by line through contracts.
    • 00:49:28
      trying to negotiate the best terms for this.
    • 00:49:34
      So, anyway, many, many people made this possible.
    • 00:49:37
      Did you want to add something to that?
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:40
      Who's going to go to the bond market to sell these bonds?
    • 00:49:47
      HRTAC or VDOT?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:49:49
      We don't know the answer to that yet.
    • 00:49:51
      That's the conversation that is happening with HRTAC and that's going to be captured under a different document.
    • 00:49:56
      We talked a little bit earlier about that master tolling agreement that is in Commissioner's letter, a reference to it.
    • 00:50:03
      We still need to get the results of operational analysis, traffic and revenue study.
    • 00:50:08
      We still need to finalize the final scope for tolling and the tolling policy.
    • 00:50:13
      And then we also need to look at different options that we have because to be honest, some of those options may give us a better interest rate.
    • 00:50:20
      They may have less risk for us.
    • 00:50:22
      Some of those options may be a little bit not as favorable.
    • 00:50:27
      So we need to go through that process, look at all of them, and we will have an answer for you in the coming months, but not today.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:33
      The reason I ask this is that we've done this many, many times, gone to the markets for funding.
    • 00:50:42
      This would be something new for them.
    • 00:50:44
      It seems to me that we would have the expertise to structure this debt properly.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:50:51
      Mr. Lawson?
    • 00:50:52
      I just want to add that there are two pieces though when we talk about the bonds.
    • 00:50:55
      HRTAC will be issuing debt that's supported by the HRTF.
    • 00:51:00
      So the only piece that would be at question from the Commonwealth versus HRTAC would be the toll revenue bonds.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:08
      I will say that, you know, our intention that it be done collaboratively and if any of the expertise from the Commonwealth can be of assistance as we're going to get TIFIA loans and so very collaboratively is how we would like to move forward and support them, yes.
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:25
      But with regard to our other recent PPTA projects, was it not the Commonwealth that issued the bonds for 495 and I-66 and others?
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:51:37
      Now with other projects that we procured on the PPTA, let's say I-66, we had a private entity that was financing the project.
    • 00:51:44
      This project is a little bit different.
    • 00:51:45
      This is just a design and construction piece has been transferred to private sector.
    • 00:51:51
      The financing stays with Commonwealth.
    • 00:51:54
      And we had very lengthy conversation.
    • 00:51:56
      The first finding of public interest that I mentioned, it actually goes through that determination that why at the time we decided not to procure this project similar to, let's say, I-66 that has full design, build, operate, maintain, finance package.
    • 00:52:11
      This particular project, financing, is not going to be transferred to the team that was mentioned earlier.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:52:17
      I don't think we've done it.
    • 00:52:22
      The only component of it.
    • 00:52:24
      I don't think we've done a project like this in recent memory where we didn't have a private partner where tolling was involved.
    • 00:52:33
      Is that correct?
    • 00:52:37
      But there wasn't major construction to the degree that we're talking about here.
    • 00:52:42
      So the tolling there was not – this tolling is to fund the project, which is I think the distinction.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:52:49
      No, in 66 Outside Beltway, probably because we need to be careful, sorry I didn't mention when I said 66 earlier.
    • 00:52:57
      So we have 66 Inside Beltway, we have 66 Outside Beltway.
    • 00:53:00
      66 Inside Beltway is being operated by VDOT and we collect tolls.
    • 00:53:05
      66 Outside Beltway is the P3 project I was referring to.
    • 00:53:09
      I66 Mobility Partners, they have the responsibility to design, build, and also finance and operate and maintain the project in the future.
    • 00:53:19
      So they have the full package.
    • 00:53:21
      But just to maybe refresh your memories about what was discussed about them maybe a year and a half ago when we started this procurement, we looked at all different options for this project.
    • 00:53:33
      We looked at all different delivery models for this project.
    • 00:53:36
      We went through the process of even discussing it with the industry.
    • 00:53:40
      At the time when we looked at different options, a scenario like what we just discussed for 66 did not make sense for this project for a lot of different reasons.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:53:52
      I will say that the way that the legislation was written with HRTAC, they do have the authority to issue bonds.
    • 00:54:01
      And so it's actually making the SMART decisions about who would be the right party to actually do that.
    • 00:54:11
      You know, the AAA bond rating of the Commonwealth versus what would be perhaps the regional entity.
    • 00:54:16
      So I think a lot of it has to be weighed in trying to make some of those decisions.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:21
      Yeah, Madam Chairwoman, absolutely.
    • 00:54:27
      I think at the end of the day it's who's going to do it best for the citizens of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:54:32
      H.O.
    • 00:54:33
      Tuck has issued debt.
    • 00:54:35
      I think they're up to about a billion dollars between
    • 00:54:38
      debt they closed last year in February and there's about 500 million and then they had they got a 450 million dollar TIFIA loan that they're involved in so there's some there's some work they've done in that regard but I'm happy to hear the collaborative situation because at the end of the day it's whatever works best is who ought to make sure it happens with.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:02
      There's some great synergy there.
    • 00:55:03
      Exactly, absolutely.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:06
      Last question.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:08
      Mr. Malbon.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:09
      Morteza, as we go into this permitting process, which you estimate 18 months, and I know there will be a lot of work in terms of design and ordering the machine, will any construction occur in that time frame that doesn't need a permit, for example, work on the islands, preparing for the machine, or
    • 00:55:31
      We won't be moving any dirt or any construction until the permit is issued.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:55:37
      The only thing I'm aware of and I will let Jim to follow up after that is what I mentioned earlier about the launching pit.
    • 00:55:44
      Just making sure that the site is ready for the boarding machine to come and be installed on site.
    • 00:55:49
      That's what I'm aware of but is there anything else?
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:52
      So the slurry walls could be under construction.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:00
      Okay, well thank you Mr. Farajan and Mr. Utterback and we will, you'll be presenting I guess the
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:11
      As Morteza just showed in the next steps, the March meeting will be heavy on a number of items, one of which will be the certification and then the, as well as looking forward to the board authorizing myself to enter into an agreement with HR TAC with the project administration financing agreement.
    • 00:56:31
      So we'll have a number of action items for you at that point in time.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:37
      I will just close by saying that the TNR numbers and the models that are being produced and how closely revenue versus throughput are actually very close together.
    • 00:56:49
      I will tell you that it's become very clear to me that the region wants to maximize throughput.
    • 00:56:55
      So I will say that it has been presented to us many, many times that that is a priority of the region and so it's our intention to make sure that we do.
    • 00:57:08
      All right.
    • 00:57:15
      C. Oh, Angel Deem, how are you?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 00:57:17
      Very well, thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:18
      I had the pleasure of being able to work with you on a couple of projects recently.
    • 00:57:22
      Yes.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 00:57:23
      Yes, ma'am.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:24
      So welcome this morning.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 00:57:26
      Thank you.
    • 00:57:26
      Madam Chair, members of the board, I'm here to provide an introductory presentation on the Martinsville Southern Connector Route 220 EIS.
    • 00:57:36
      That stands for Environmental Impact Statement.
    • 00:57:38
      That's the level of NEPA document that we are completing for this federalized study.
    • 00:57:48
      So here's a graphic that depicts the study area.
    • 00:57:53
      Essentially, 220 is a seven-mile corridor in this area through Henry County.
    • 00:57:58
      Our EIS was actually initiated a year ago in February of 2018.
    • 00:58:03
      The 220 corridor, as many of you know, has been designated as a corridor of statewide significance, and therefore, this study has been pursued to look at improvements in the area.
    • 00:58:18
      Specifically, you can see on the screen the purpose and need for this EIS.
    • 00:58:23
      This is the first major step when you develop this level of NEPA document is to determine what problem it is that you're trying to solve with the project.
    • 00:58:33
      So, in summary, we're looking at enhancing mobility for both local and regional traffic in this area.
    • 00:58:41
      220 provides regional access between the cities of Roanoke and Greensboro, but it also provides local access to a number of businesses, homes, schools, and recreational facilities in Henry County as well as the town of Ridgeway.
    • 00:58:57
      So those are different interests and different travel needs.
    • 00:59:00
      The third need element that's been identified is to address the geometric deficiencies and inconsistencies along this corridor.
    • 00:59:12
      So the initiation of the EIS is to sort of bring you up to speed on what we've been doing.
    • 00:59:18
      As I mentioned in February of 2018, we initiated the study and that's done by publication of a notice of intent in the Federal Register.
    • 00:59:27
      We then engage the federal, state, and local entities that we would like to participate in the study so we can begin scoping.
    • 00:59:35
      That occurred in March of 2018.
    • 00:59:38
      I did want to mention as an EIS this study is following VDOT's NEPA 404 merged process.
    • 00:59:45
      That process is intended to enhance the environmental review process with a special interest with permitting to ensure that the decisions made during NEPA have the ability to be sustained as we move forward to project implementation.
    • 01:00:03
      So we did initiate the study and I'll talk more about that.
    • 01:00:07
      In May we hosted a citizen information meeting to introduce the study and that was key in helping develop the purpose and need.
    • 01:00:15
      In July of last year VDOT and those federal entities involved in the merge process
    • 01:00:21
      concurred on impact methodology.
    • 01:00:23
      So that is the first concurrence point in our merge process.
    • 01:00:27
      It's key because it sets an understanding of the level of analysis that we're going to use to inform and help the federal agencies make decisions.
    • 01:00:37
      And then surprisingly, in August of 2018, Federal Highway identified this project as one that would meet the criteria for the one federal decision executive order.
    • 01:00:49
      So you'll see me refer, or hear me refer to OFD.
    • 01:00:53
      That's one federal decision.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:58
      So what is OSD?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:01:16
      So OFD was prescribed under Executive Order 13-807 which was issued in August of 2017.
    • 01:01:23
      It prescribes timelines to obtain a NEPA decision and the related federal permits.
    • 01:01:30
      The goal is generally 24 months which is an aggressive goal.
    • 01:01:35
      VDOT's average for completion of an EIS has been about 36 months in recent years.
    • 01:01:41
      The country average is somewhere around
    • 01:01:44
      for four to five years for completion of an EIS.
    • 01:01:47
      So an aggressive goal.
    • 01:01:48
      I would say that OFD is very much in line with VDOT's NEPA 404 merge process.
    • 01:01:55
      It has the same objective that you have the right folks involved and that they're formally agreeing as you move through the process to prevent some sort of downstream conflicts when you get to authorization decisions that happen after NEPA.
    • 01:02:10
      A major difference with OFD is the assumption that you will obtain permits at the conclusion of the NEPA process.
    • 01:02:20
      So federal agencies identified projects eligible to qualify or apply for OFD.
    • 01:02:26
      So Federal Highway has identified three projects across the country, two in Maryland and our Martinsville Southern Connector.
    • 01:02:39
      So what are the implications of this designation on this particular EIS?
    • 01:02:46
      Well, it compels FHWA, VDOT, and its partner agencies to maintain the published schedule.
    • 01:02:53
      It provides, if you will, national visibility and accountability for that schedule, and any lapses in the schedule are noted on a federally maintained and publicly available dashboard.
    • 01:03:04
      So I'll pause there to tell you that because we had already been underway for several months, our published schedule was 36 months in line with our typical timeline for an EIS.
    • 01:03:16
      There was a lot of discussion early on with this designation and Federal Highway did agree that we could maintain that schedule.
    • 01:03:23
      We did not need to compress it to meet the 24-month goal, but that we really needed to strictly adhere to that 36-month schedule.
    • 01:03:34
      So another big implication that I alluded to is the required permit information that needs to be brought to bear so that the Corps can actually issue permits at the end of the NEPA process.
    • 01:03:47
      So then the last bullet there and the main reason for my presentation today is that OFD really necessitates that the preferred alternative be identified in the draft EIS so that it can be presented
    • 01:03:59
      to the agencies and the public and so that we can actually obtain permits following publication of the final.
    • 01:04:06
      Now that's not unheard of.
    • 01:04:08
      Some states do present a preferred alternative in a draft EIS.
    • 01:04:12
      Typically Virginia has not done that.
    • 01:04:14
      We carry forward alternatives for consideration in a draft.
    • 01:04:18
      We come to this board for your designation of the preferred and then we document the preferred in the final.
    • 01:04:24
      So this is causing us to have to back that schedule up.
    • 01:04:34
      So some changes made to accommodate those implications.
    • 01:04:38
      We've had to increase the level of data and analysis to be included in the EIS to inform those permitting actions, specifically engineering considerations and natural resource analysis.
    • 01:04:51
      So I mentioned in July of last year we had agreed to impact methodologies.
    • 01:04:56
      We essentially had to revisit that.
    • 01:04:57
      We had to enhance what we're doing in those two arenas in order to achieve the objectives of OFD.
    • 01:05:04
      We also had to add public involvement to that schedule but maintain the schedule that we had issued without it if you will.
    • 01:05:11
      Additional public involvement of course to inform you all so you're comfortable making a decision on the preferred prior to issuance of the draft.
    • 01:05:19
      The additional documentation, obviously, and then we've also had to make some adjustments in order to accommodate FHWA and the Corps issuing their federal authorizations or ROD and permit at the same time, which is assumed to be 90 days after publication of the final EIS.
    • 01:05:46
      So how does this look moving forward?
    • 01:05:48
      We'll be back to brief this board in the spring on the range of alternatives that are being studied and considered.
    • 01:05:56
      And then in August we'll hold a public hearing, that's the additional public involvement there, on the recommended preferred alternative and seek public input on that.
    • 01:06:05
      We'll ask the federal agencies involved in our emerge process to concur on the preferred alternative in September.
    • 01:06:11
      We'll then brief you all on all of that and seek your decision on the preferred in October.
    • 01:06:17
      We'll issue the draft EIS in December.
    • 01:06:19
      We'll hold a public meeting while that draft is out again to solicit public input.
    • 01:06:24
      We'll do all the analyses to refine that preferred alternative, prepare the permit documentation, and issue the final in December with again the ROD or the permit both being issued early in 2021.
    • 01:06:39
      So that concludes my remarks and I'm happy to take any questions.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:06:44
      Thank you.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:06:44
      Mr. Kasprowicz?
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:45
      Thank you.
    • 01:06:46
      Angel, I just want to make sure I understand the progression of events here.
    • 01:06:49
      So under this new executive order, the compressed time frame becomes 24 months.
    • 01:06:54
      That's the absolute.
    • 01:06:55
      It can't be more than that under the executive order.
    • 01:06:58
      But they've allowed us, because we were already underway, to maintain our current 36-month schedule to do this.
    • 01:07:05
      So we're not really adding.
    • 01:07:07
      It's kind of in keeping with what our time frame would have been as we started this project without the executive order.
    • 01:07:14
      I know we're organizing things differently and perhaps changing some of the sequencing, but the timeframe is essentially unchanged.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:07:22
      Correct.
    • 01:07:23
      And I would just maybe add the caveat that we had no intention of obtaining permits for this project at the conclusion of NEPA, so that has changed things fairly dramatically for our team, but optically, yes, the schedule is maintained at 36 months.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:39
      So one of the major things that have changed is we make a recommendation on the preferred alternative.
    • 01:07:46
      That goes on to FHWA.
    • 01:07:50
      So this board makes that decision on the preferred alternative.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:07:52
      Right.
    • 01:07:53
      FHWA recognizes that this board is authorized to make location decisions in Virginia.
    • 01:07:59
      So they tend to defer to that.
    • 01:08:02
      So the difference is that rather than you all making that after several alternatives have been published in a draft EIS, you'll make it in advance of publication of that draft.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:11
      It's a very different level of responsibility for this board because we need to be, I guess, integrated in that process to be prepared to make that, it's a very critical decision, it's a big one.
    • 01:08:21
      How do we, I know you've got a briefing schedule in there, but I'm concerned that that be sufficient to keep us
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:08:29
      up to a level of understanding that allows us to move comfortably through that decision
    • 01:08:47
      In just a couple of short months to describe all the alternatives that have been considered, both along 220 and the new location alternatives, the feedback that we've received from the public, et cetera.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:01
      So we'll see that sometime spring or late spring, then we have how long to consider that?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:09:07
      You'll have until September, yes.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:12
      Do we have a projected month for that?
    • 01:09:14
      I just think of our summer schedule as being somewhat short with August.
    • 01:09:18
      For the spring?
    • 01:09:21
      Yeah, when we might have that briefing.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:09:24
      I'm assuming it will be April to May, but we'll solidify that pretty soon.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:31
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:09:34
      Once we were identified as one of the three projects, did we have an option whether we wanted to be included?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:09:45
      I would say no.
    • 01:09:47
      We did discuss it quite robustly with Federal Highway as to why the designation was occurring given the context of this project.
    • 01:09:56
      I mean it is an EIS and that's the main criteria for designation.
    • 01:10:01
      But no, there was no opt-out option.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:10:04
      You had mentioned that one big change obviously is the required permitting at the end and that was not the original intention in the project.
    • 01:10:12
      What sort of impact does that have?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:10:15
      So back to the changes that we made on our methodologies for analysis.
    • 01:10:21
      So we've had to amp up our natural resource work.
    • 01:10:24
      So that's the work we do out in the field to assess impacts.
    • 01:10:28
      We've also had to increase the engineering considerations on the study to make sure we can inform a permit decision.
    • 01:10:35
      And we've been working quite well with the Corps of Engineers regarding how
    • 01:10:40
      How they will need to receive information at this early stage, if you will, and be able to issue a permit.
    • 01:10:47
      So it's really just been a result of a lot of collaboration and continued collaboration with our federal permitting partners to make sure we're all on the same page about what information they will need in order to issue a permit because clearly we won't be at final design.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:11:04
      That means the project is a go at that point.
    • 01:11:07
      Yes.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:08
      Subject to funding.
    • 01:11:12
      So where's the funding coming from?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:11:14
      Correct.
    • 01:11:14
      So this project is in an interesting situation where it will have federal permits without construction funding which is not something we would typically do and which was part of our discussion with Federal Highway over the designation as well.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:33
      The answer is we don't know where the money is coming from.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:11:36
      There is no requirement for us to fully fund it.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:40
      The permits lapse after a certain period of time?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:11:43
      Yes, you have to move forward within I believe it's five years of issuance of the permit.
    • 01:11:49
      Typically design is underway, but that is a question I would imagine.
    • 01:11:53
      I would hazard to guess that we will be reevaluating this decision when we are in a position to implement the project because enough time will have passed to require us to do so.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:08
      Thank you.
    • 01:12:11
      Angel, one more question.
    • 01:12:12
      So this is a complex issue and you guys have obviously weighted it and studied it and you've made modifications to our current timeline and the way you're allocating resources.
    • 01:12:21
      Can you just kind of at a high level articulate what you see as the benefits of this compared to the way we've done it historically and traditionally?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:12:31
      Sure.
    • 01:12:31
      The benefits much in line with the reason that Virginia moved forward with the NEPA 404 merge process is to create assurances, if you will, that the project can be implemented as envisioned during the NEPA process.
    • 01:12:46
      So this really formalizes nationally that objective, that there be a single federal decision from which future decisions can be based upon.
    • 01:12:56
      Instead of circumstances, we
    • 01:12:58
      We've been in in the past where we receive a federal NEPA decision but then we're unable to receive a federal permitting decision for the same alternative, if you will.
    • 01:13:07
      So that's a benefit.
    • 01:13:08
      This project will also be a good test case, we believe, to demonstrate that you can conclude NEPA without
    • 01:13:16
      Brown, John M. Brown III, John M. Brown III
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:46
      In summary, what they're doing here is requiring you to do more work up front, but the benefit is some degree of certainty with regard to timeline.
    • 01:13:56
      I think it's important to appreciate that if the work done up front isn't adequate, you still won't get a permit.
    • 01:14:03
      I think industry was very interested in having some certainty around timing, but the compromise was you've got to invest more in the front end, and if you
    • 01:14:16
      You better make sure that you've done your diligence or you're going to have some sort of cost.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:20
      Yeah, I'm just always suspect when a timeline that has a national average of four to five years, and granted that's a long time, is compressed to 24 months, what are we giving up in that?
    • 01:14:31
      Now in the case of this project as it relates to Virginia, we still have a 36-month timeframe.
    • 01:14:35
      We've been, I guess, grandfathered in, but longer term I just have concerns about
    • 01:14:41
      What we lose in a 24-month process, especially from a standpoint of public involvement in the decision.
    • 01:14:47
      I mean, that really is the critical part of this, understanding and taking the time to present these.
    • 01:14:51
      So, just in the opinion.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:14:52
      Sure.
    • 01:14:52
      It puts you in a position of front-loading the NEPA process.
    • 01:14:55
      That's how you get it done.
    • 01:14:56
      You do more during planning.
    • 01:14:58
      Again, you have to have the agencies, the environmental agencies involved buy into that work that you've done during planning as sustainable into the NEPA process, but that's how you get it done.
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:09
      And one consideration is that a lot of agencies and organizations would start the clock early without having done all this work because they expected the process to take
    • 01:15:25
      Five years.
    • 01:15:27
      So you would file your application without all the diligence because you knew it was going to take that long and kind of have an iterative process as opposed to front-loading the process which is what they're trying to encourage here.
    • 01:15:38
      So there's gaming on both ends of this and I think this was about trying to rationalize some of that and say let's just do your diligence up front and we'll promise you we'll get you something done within a reasonable expectation of time.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:52
      We'll be looking forward to the spring presentation.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:55
      Chairman, can I just ask one other thing?
    • 01:15:58
      When you go out to do that August public hearing, you're going to go out with several options and a preferred alternative already chosen so that the hearing people will know that you looked at a variety of things, yes?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:16:13
      And we just had a public information meeting where we shared what we call preliminary alternatives so they already have a flavor of what we're looking at and we're still receiving feedback on that.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:24
      And that's from the localities involved, correct?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:31
      Correct.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:32
      Madam Chair, I appreciate the efforts to put this project in a position where it might at a future time move forward.
    • 01:16:42
      As I suspect you know, the 220 work really is to some extent a proxy
    • 01:16:52
      for the regional desire for Interstate 73 which would connect I-95 in southern North Carolina with I-81 in Roanoke.
    • 01:17:04
      That project, at least at this time, is prohibitively expensive.
    • 01:17:09
      So the alternative has been to try to improve sections of Route 220 that are the most congested and result in the greatest delay.
    • 01:17:21
      This particular segment has been so identified and I am hopeful that this work would put us in a position later to move this project along.
    • 01:17:35
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:35
      I appreciate that context.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:37
      It was helpful.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:41
      I was going to ask a follow-up.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:44
      It's been a while since I drove from Greensboro to Roanoke up 220.
    • 01:17:49
      On the Carolina side, is that four-lane or two-lane?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:17:51
      They have a project underway to four-lane that.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:54
      It's not four-lane now?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:17:57
      I don't believe it is up to the state line.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:00
      Under construction, I believe.
    • 01:18:03
      In 73 obviously that's been a big issue for a number of years as far as so.
    • 01:18:08
      And the population of Henry County, does that remain the same or has it declined the last 10 years?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:18:14
      That I'm not certain of.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:16
      Obviously the job loss in Henry County has been significant over the last decade and a half.
    • 01:18:20
      I didn't know that was obviously part of the process as far as anticipating population growth if you had some type of study like this.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:18:29
      That's certainly included in our socioeconomic analysis, but we also look more broadly at regional travel as well rather than, as I mentioned in the Purpose and Need, we're focused on both the regional accessibility that this quarter provides as well as local accessibility.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:45
      How long, maybe I missed it, how long is the segment for the Carolina border up to 58?
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:18:50
      Seven miles.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:51
      Seven miles, okay, thank you.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:18:53
      Mr. Williams.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:54
      The Angel's presentation, and this is not meant to reflect on all the good work she does.
    • 01:18:58
      She is the expert on this stuff, and I appreciate it.
    • 01:19:02
      But it just kind of reminds me, go back to the last subject we had, the Hampton Bridge Tunnel.
    • 01:19:07
      And Scott, you know, expressing concerns that we couldn't constrain it to 24 months is a, you know, what do you miss?
    • 01:19:16
      And I just, I look at all the things we have to do now to site a project.
    • 01:19:20
      We built the first bridge tunnel
    • 01:19:23
      for $44 million in around 1955.
    • 01:19:27
      We built the second one 20 years later for $95 million.
    • 01:19:31
      And now we're looking 40 years later to duplicate what we have on the ground now for $3.5 billion.
    • 01:19:40
      And, you know, it's all useful.
    • 01:19:45
      It's all good.
    • 01:19:47
      But
    • 01:19:48
      We've kind of done this to ourselves.
    • 01:19:49
      We've just driven it to, and I don't know how much tougher it's going to get.
    • 01:19:53
      So thank God we're building these projects today because maybe five years from now the Hampton Roads Bridge Zone will be $10 billion.
    • 01:20:00
      We find out other ways to make it hard to do, but just a general rule.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:06
      Thank you.
    • 01:20:21
      You know part of making sure that we are on schedule is really really important because I mean even with the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel the fact that in some of the negotiations if a contract is delayed or something falls behind you're really looking at 120 million dollars a year in delay so really making sure that we are on time that we're delivering the scope
    • 01:20:49
      The timetable is really, really important and I am learning that to the point where I actually call people on holidays, New Year's Day, I was saying we really have to do this because we cannot fall behind.
    • 01:21:03
      That's how critical the timing is.
    • 01:21:06
      Mr. Kasprowicz.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:07
      Just to follow up to Marty's comment.
    • 01:21:09
      So in the presentation ultimately of the options for preferred alternative, are we considering the cost of those as we look at this series of options?
    • 01:21:19
      We are.
    • Angel DeemChief of Policy
    • 01:21:20
      Yes.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:21
      Okay.
    • 01:21:21
      So that's going to be part of our discussion in making a selection preferred alternative.
    • 01:21:26
      So I guess to some extent, Marty, we gain the benefit of looking at lower cost alternatives.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:33
      Okay.
    • 01:21:33
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:21:35
      Is Rob Carey out here?
    • 01:21:37
      Laura, you can come up.
    • 01:21:39
      I'm just going to ask him just to give a brief update.
    • 01:21:43
      I know you were on the snow call this morning, weather call.
    • Rob CaryChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 01:21:47
      Right.
    • 01:21:48
      And, excuse me, happy to report, you know, the VDOT is ready for the weather that's coming in.
    • 01:21:54
      The weather's going to start from the southwest and move to the northeast starting this afternoon, going into tonight.
    • 01:22:02
      There is a lot of uncertainty with it, particularly around where that mix between snow and sleet and freezing rain, exactly when that will happen and take place and where exactly it will.
    • 01:22:11
      But I will say we're expecting potentially heavy snowfall.
    • 01:22:15
      Four to eight inches in Culpeper, six to nine in northern Stanton.
    • 01:22:19
      5-8 in Western Nova and 3-6 in Northwest Lynchburg.
    • 01:22:24
      Obviously there's snow in other places around the state, but those are the worst areas that they're targeting right now.
    • 01:22:32
      We also are seeing potential for up to 3 tenths of an inch of ice and an inch of sleet as well across Stanton, Culpeper, Salem, Bristol, and Lynchburg districts.
    • 01:22:43
      So what are we doing to get ready?
    • 01:22:45
      We just held a statewide conference call as the secretary mentioned.
    • 01:22:49
      We do that with the state police, we do that with VDOWM and other partners in this to make sure that we're all coordinated and ready to go.
    • 01:22:56
      We have pretreated roadways across the Commonwealth in anticipation of the storm and
    • 01:23:02
      We would ask people, that's ongoing, so we would ask people to be cautious around those crews that are out there because they typically are going about 45 miles an hour many times on the interstate or other high volume primary routes and somebody not paying attention could be tragic running into the back of that.
    • 01:23:18
      Night crews are being sent home early today so that they're rested to come back tonight and ready to go.
    • 01:23:25
      We have tree crews ready as well, anticipating the ice and the potential for tree limbs down and utility lines down, have them ready to go to get those out of the way.
    • 01:23:34
      We also are coordinating with the utility companies to make sure that we know all the right contacts and they have all our contacts for whatever might come at us.
    • 01:23:45
      We do ask drivers to watch their travel, sort of plan their travel around the storm as best that they can.
    • 01:23:52
      We do know that it's likely to impact the morning commute and evening commute tomorrow.
    • 01:23:58
      Our communications staff is actively sending out communications in that regard.
    • 01:24:03
      There's probably, if you haven't gotten something, there's something about to go out from them right now.
    • 01:24:08
      We'll continue those efforts throughout the storm, communicating with people, also working with our field staff, our customer service center, and monitoring social media to make sure we're up on what's happening all across every corner of the state.
    • 01:24:22
      So lastly, I would just say that we're ready for the storm, whatever comes at us, and as an example, Northern Virginia will have 3,000 plows out ready to go, and the last thing I'd say is 28 days till spring.
    • 01:24:36
      3 o'clock in the Bristol area, moving up to about 10 o'clock up in Northern Virginia tonight.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:48
      So I know that there are members here who probably have some decisions to make about their travel plans so we will discuss that and I'm going to ask Mr. Walton just because the meeting tomorrow because it is announced legally we do have to meet, how's the Lynchburg, I mean Lynchburg, how's the Richmond district tomorrow?
    • Rob CaryChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 01:25:10
      They're calling for a couple inches of snow here, but as usual, Richmond's always right on that line between where the snow and the ice and sleet could be, so we'll see.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:20
      We're hoping that we're going to have a quorum, at least with the Richmond folks here, in case... Madam Secretary, I'll be here.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:29
      Thank you, Mr. Dunn.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:36
      We just need to make sure we got plenty of salt on knife and broad so we can get here.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:49
      Carol has all the power by the way.
    • 01:25:51
      So anyway, just wanted to kind of update you on that and we can have further discussions.
    • 01:25:55
      Mr. Walton, do you mind just sharing with the group what is a quorum for us?
    • 01:26:04
      But you can come up or I think we can hear you, whatever you prefer.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 01:26:07
      A quorum of the four is six, and my view is it includes the Secretary, the Commissioner, and the Executive Director, DRPT.
    • 01:26:17
      But looking at the Hampton Roads folks here, who hopefully will stay, and the Richmond folks, and then Mr. Dodson from Lynchburg, I count six right there of CTB members.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:29
      Okay.
    • 01:26:30
      All right.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:26:31
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:32
      Well, I think we're going to have, we would actually be counted as part of a six if we ever needed that.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 01:26:39
      Okay.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:41
      Okay.
    • 01:26:41
      But we have lots.
    • 01:26:42
      Okay.
    • 01:26:43
      Thank you, Mr. Carey.
    • 01:26:44
      And with that, Laura Farmer.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:47
      Oh yeah.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:26:50
      For sure.
    • Laura FarmerFinancial Planning Division Administrator
    • 01:26:51
      Good morning, Madam Chair and members of the board.
    • 01:26:54
      I'm here today to present the issuance of the series 2019 capital projects revenue bonds.
    • 01:27:02
      Today's workshop item supports tomorrow's action item.
    • 01:27:07
      We're asking you to turn this around and approve it tomorrow so we can continue with our schedule.
    • 01:27:12
      The 2018 bond proceeds were spent down faster than anticipated with VDOT activity as well as DRPT activity.
    • 01:27:20
      And so we'd like to bring in proceeds this fiscal year in the April timeframe.
    • 01:27:24
      So we appreciate your consideration.
    • 01:27:26
      And as I walk through this, I'll be happy to answer any of your questions.
    • 01:27:31
      To give you an overview of the program, about 12 years ago, the General Assembly approved the Capital Projects Revenue Bonds Program, or CPR bonds, establishing it in the code with dedicating 20% minimum to transit capital, 4.3% minimum to rail capital, and the balance was used for federal match, revenue sharing, and statewide and regional projects.
    • 01:27:56
      When that was enacted, the annual limitation was set at $300 million and we could carry over anything unsold each year to the subsequent years.
    • 01:28:05
      Today that total authorization sits at $3.23 billion.
    • 01:28:09
      That consists of the original $3 billion.
    • 01:28:11
      It was increased by $180 million in 2009 based on some general fund revenues that were replaced with bond proceeds.
    • 01:28:20
      And then last year's action related to WMATA capital and that legislation granted us an additional $50 million to be used for the PREA match if it's so needed.
    • 01:28:32
      And that's currently planned for fiscal year 2021.
    • 01:28:38
      To date, the board has issued $2.7 billion of CPR bonds.
    • 01:28:44
      With this next sale, we'll leave a balance of $243 million left to issue.
    • 01:28:49
      And the bill in 2011 accelerated some issuances.
    • 01:28:54
      So you'll see in 2011 and 12, we were able to issue $600 million twice to support project activity.
    • 01:29:03
      This is the eighth new money transaction for these bonds.
    • 01:29:07
      We've also had one refunding over the course of the sales to take advantage of some advance refunding abilities back in 2017.
    • 01:29:16
      And I need to remind you that the bond proceeds are fully allocated in the Six-Year Program between VDOT and DRPT.
    • 01:29:23
      These are not new dollars that will be programmed to projects.
    • 01:29:26
      We are just applying this cash to projects that are underway.
    • 01:29:31
      This table provides a summary of the use of the bonds and how they were dedicated in the Six-Year Program and VDOT and DRPT budgets totaling the $3.23 billion.
    • 01:29:45
      The first sale back in May 2010 was used to reimburse both agencies for some activity we'd incurred while we awaited the issuance.
    • 01:29:54
      And this slide walks through the further issuances and how we applied those to projects.
    • 01:29:59
      The most recent transactions have just been ongoing support activities for both us and DRPT.
    • 01:30:09
      The debt service payments for the bonds are supported by the Priority Transportation Fund.
    • 01:30:14
      It's provided from the taxes on insurance premiums.
    • 01:30:18
      One-third of that revenue is dedicated to the PTF.
    • 01:30:22
      It is also receiving 4% of the motor fuels taxes today.
    • 01:30:26
      And this table provides a summary of the revenue that we expect to receive in the PTF over the next six years, starting at $205 million this current fiscal year, growing to about $255 million in 2024.
    • 01:30:39
      The code of the Virginia requires that our PTF fund
    • 01:30:49
      provide a hundred percent of the annual debt service that is needed to cover the bonds for our planning purposes and good debt policy we strive to maintain a 1.15 times coverage in the current year with this sale we're at 1.16 it's the lowest coverage but again we feel with the balances in the fund and its current revenue we're in good shape and are expected to be with the additional sales planned after this one
    • 01:31:19
      So this table provides a summary of the terms of the offering.
    • 01:31:23
      We expect the ratings from the rating agencies there on the table.
    • 01:31:31
      Our plan sale is in April.
    • 01:31:33
      After board approval, we proceed to Treasury Board in March and get rating agencies in perspective in April.
    • 01:31:43
      I've summarized the security of the bond.
    • 01:31:46
      We are seeking a $255 million in par value and the bond's maturity is over 25 years.
    • 01:31:57
      So as I said previously, we are seeking your approval tomorrow for this transaction and go to Treasury Board in March and get rating agencies subsequent to that and go for a competitive sale in April to get proceeds.
    • 01:32:14
      With our current numbers today, we expect true interest costs on this transaction today of 3.49%.
    • 01:32:21
      So a lot can change between now and April, but that's what we're looking at today.
    • 01:32:28
      Be happy to answer any additional questions.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:32
      Can we go back to the funding slide that showed where the resources to pay this off will come from?
    • 01:32:37
      That one, exactly.
    • 01:32:39
      So we project that out only to 2024.
    • 01:32:43
      We've got motor fuel tax looking relatively flat.
    • 01:32:48
      Do we project beyond that given the maturities of these bonds?
    • 01:32:52
      Is that
    • Laura FarmerFinancial Planning Division Administrator
    • 01:32:54
      Yes sir, so for our long-term projections we do take into account what expectations are around motor fuel and generally today they have been relatively flat so as this program is going to peak over the next couple of years our debt service payments will fall off as the bonds mature and so we will be able to cover that for the ongoing cycle of the bonds.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:16
      So that's a conservative estimate that's being made and applied to this?
    • Laura FarmerFinancial Planning Division Administrator
    • 01:33:19
      Yes sir, I believe so.
    • 01:33:20
      We size the bonds according to the revenue available as well as the projected costs that VDOT and DRPT will incur.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:28
      Thank you.
    • 01:33:30
      Do these bonds have call provisions if we have a favorable opportunity to do that?
    • Laura FarmerFinancial Planning Division Administrator
    • 01:33:37
      Yes, I believe we have 10-year calls built into the transaction so if the opportunity arises after 10 years we should be able to make that.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:53
      Mr. Kasprowicz, I'll just add that as we've been making presentations to the money committees and looking at the revenue from the motor fuels tax, this board knows that for the first time vehicle miles in Virginia are going up and the gas tax is flat, but it's artificially flat because we have a floor
    • 01:34:12
      In our gas tax, which is helping to keep that flat, but some of us have actually questioned whether or not flat is actually accurate, whether or not it's going to go down more than anticipated.
    • 01:34:24
      So we're going to look at that this year, but that's a really good point to bring up when you're looking at this.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:28
      It's a small piece of this, Madam Secretary, but a much larger piece of our overall transportation funding.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:34
      You know, the floor only protects us not on the price, not on volume.
    • 01:34:38
      The floor only protects us on the price, not on volume.
    • 01:34:43
      And I think where he's going with electrification, we really don't know how that, to what extent that's going to be deployed, certainly in this 25-year horizon for that.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:54
      I think for now, the estimates that we're getting from tax show it is flat over the next six years.
    • 01:35:00
      Yes, ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:35:02
      Madam Secretary, from my standpoint though, that's the first time I've seen it documented that we're actually projecting it to go down.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:15
      Anything else?
    • 01:35:16
      Thank you, Ms. Farmer.
    • 01:35:18
      Thank you.
    • 01:35:22
      Let's see, Mr. Moore.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:35:26
      Good morning Madam Secretary and members of the board.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:29
      Everybody's going to know how important this presentation is, are they?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:35:33
      You do.
    • 01:35:38
      This is a presentation for discussion and information only, and it has to do with cleanup and a little background on roadside.
    • 01:35:46
      Bronco Vlacich is here with me and Joe Williams.
    • 01:35:49
      We're not going to bring Bronco up unless we have to because he's still recovering his voice.
    • 01:35:53
      And I've also put Rob Carey on here because as I transition towards the fall in continuity, he may be the one, if he briefs it again, that you see in three or four months doing this so you know what's going on.
    • 01:36:06
      And we're going to talk about what we do and then also what we can do to get better on some of this in a limited resource environment.
    • 01:36:14
      Some of the things that's going on that we have done, and not talk so much about cleanup, but what are we doing for environmental stewardship.
    • 01:36:22
      And we found ourselves starting to build some partnerships and about four weeks or so actually put a tasking out to the maintenance side that we need in our best practices and environmental stewardship section and they're working on that here in the coming weeks as we start to build some of these things.
    • 01:36:39
      One of those things we kind of came on accidentally and that's our pollinators.
    • 01:36:42
      The Monarch Butterfly we were approached maybe four or five years ago by people that said hey they're becoming extinct and we need to do something about that.
    • 01:36:51
      The next thing I know I was up in the Eisenhower building on the grounds of the White House with Kevin Gregg and learning about these things and we were able to very quickly do something that
    • 01:37:01
      in our right-of-ways helped the monarchs that we believe are starting to recover.
    • 01:37:06
      And it was cheap.
    • 01:37:07
      We stopped mowing the insides of some of our wide right-of-ways.
    • 01:37:10
      So if you go down to North Carolina and you see these beautifully mowed areas, the reason we're not mowing the insides in many of those is because it is habitat for the monarchs and things like milkweed.
    • 01:37:22
      And what we
    • 01:37:23
      do or learn from them is it saves us money.
    • 01:37:26
      But then come October, November, we do a full-width mowing so that it doesn't grow up with trees.
    • 01:37:32
      So that's what happens.
    • 01:37:33
      It will regenerate what they need.
    • 01:37:35
      So we adopted our program really at no additional cost.
    • 01:37:38
      The other thing that we've done is in our total maximum daily load practices, our best practices for runoff and getting the phosphorus out of it and so forth, is we use native plants.
    • 01:37:50
      Those are both in existence and so we're starting to put these things in a stewardship section and there are some other things that we're developing.
    • 01:37:58
      We've been approached from the Piedmont Environmental Council for a, they've gotten some grants on identifying
    • 01:38:04
      sections so we can bring the native fish back.
    • 01:38:07
      We're working with them to do that.
    • 01:38:09
      The nice thing about this is, unlike some of the things we do, whether it's environmental or other, where there's kind of a sledgehammer that throws lots of resources at it, it's very targeted.
    • 01:38:19
      In other words, you know, maximum effect for the dollars.
    • 01:38:22
      I think that's something that we really like.
    • 01:38:24
      The other thing we've been approached from a group in Charlottesville that is underway
    • 01:38:28
      is some native plants and how do we replace some of the things we've been using for decades with native plants and that's a little less far along.
    • 01:38:36
      We actually have some money on the native species so we are looking to see these partnerships grow.
    • 01:38:41
      We see these as very targeted and low cost and that's something that really doesn't have so much to do with roadside cleanup but you may ask the question why are we doing certain things.
    • 01:38:51
      That's why you don't see it mowed like you do in some other states.
    • 01:38:54
      We actually have a program that covers that.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:57
      I think that's outstanding.
    • 01:38:59
      I think we have an opportunity to let people know that we're doing that because people classically drive down the highway and I do it all the time.
    • 01:39:07
      I'm like, why in this mode?
    • 01:39:09
      It's like really high.
    • 01:39:11
      Well, there's some good reason why it may not be a mode and we ought to take the opportunity to let people know why so we get some points for doing something good.
    • 01:39:21
      Number one, number two, have we ever
    • 01:39:24
      I've been engaged in the discussion with the, I don't know whether it's enforcement or whether it's the laws or whatever but it's just outrageous how much stuff gets thrown on the roads and you know whether it's trash, whether it's cigarette butts, whatever it is and it drives me insane when I see somebody at the stoplight or whatever flick their cigarette out
    • 01:39:49
      on the road or throw a bag of trash out at the stoplight and you know we're spending a gazillion dollars cleaning it up.
    • 01:39:56
      It looks terrible.
    • 01:39:59
      Have we ever been engaged in that?
    • 01:40:01
      I mean sort of from this body's perspective.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:03
      Mr. Miller, I will tell you that this is a huge priority of mine, personally, driving across Virginia.
    • 01:40:12
      And it's worse after the winter.
    • 01:40:13
      And don't ask me after it snows why it always seems worse.
    • 01:40:19
      But as we are trying to be very deliberate and environmental in what we're doing with our roadsides, making sure we are dressing the trash.
    • 01:40:29
      We get a lot of phone calls about what we do on our roadsides because people are not aware that we are being deliberate in some cases, right?
    • 01:40:38
      That we're trying to be good stewards.
    • 01:40:41
      But on the other hand, the trash is really something that
    • 01:40:46
      that I really want us to address.
    • 01:40:48
      And what's really shocking to me is when I bring this to Mr. Moore's attention, other people's attention, the amount of money it costs us to pick up trash, to have that picked up.
    • 01:41:00
      Commissioner, a million dollars?
    • 01:41:06
      A million dollars to pick up trash.
    • 01:41:08
      So part of what I have actually tasked Mr. Moore and others with is could we develop a more comprehensive program where it may be appropriate for us to pay?
    • 01:41:20
      What can we do as a volunteer effort?
    • 01:41:22
      What can we do as administration?
    • 01:41:24
      How do we make this a priority?
    • 01:41:26
      I do believe Mr. Miller that it does reflect on us.
    • 01:41:29
      So anyway.
    • 01:41:31
      Mr. Williams.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:32
      I do know the last year or the year before we now partnered with Keep Virginia Beautiful and they're hopefully there.
    • 01:41:38
      Got to be in there.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:40
      That's coming in the slide deck.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:41:47
      What are we doing with invasive species like kudzu?
    • 01:41:51
      Are we actively treating and fighting that?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:41:55
      There's two things.
    • 01:41:55
      Yes, we are and we also are in a new partnership with natural resources and looking at, and that's the native species to try and do more on that.
    • 01:42:07
      But we have done springs and things like that, but we're actually trying to bring back natives.
    • 01:42:12
      But we're in the infant
    • 01:42:14
      probably an infinite role in that partnership.
    • 01:42:16
      I think like the pollinators a year from now we'll have a more active program going because one of the things in our early discussions with them is they don't, the groups that have come to us have said we don't have the science yet so part of that is
    • 01:42:33
      We've asked them to do is what do we want to attack first?
    • 01:42:35
      What's the worst problem?
    • 01:42:37
      And then do we need to work with the research council to get those top one or two or three?
    • 01:42:43
      And then once the ball starts rolling, we think, but we have not
    • 01:42:48
      We're not at the point where we're able to put Natives back into replace because one of the reasons things are in there are to help maintain the slopes for erosion and sediment control.
    • 01:42:57
      So anything you do has another effect, but we're not as far as we'd like as far as bringing Natives back.
    • 01:43:03
      We have had a program for invasive, but I don't think it's where we want it to be.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:10
      So, Garrett, I happen to have, I think, fairly regular contact with at least two of those checkmarks represented, people in the native plant community and the native species on the fish side of this.
    • 01:43:20
      And I actually spoke with some of the native plant people as recently as yesterday.
    • 01:43:25
      And I have to say I consider this a form of public-private partnership, kind of a non-financial one.
    • 01:43:31
      This is the best of government where we're collaborating with, you know, in this case, non-profits.
    • 01:43:36
      But I will tell you that on both sides, the native species and the native plants, VDOT has received rave reviews about the level of cooperation and willingness to engage.
    • 01:43:46
      And that yesterday was part of the discussion and they did identify you by name in several instances.
    • 01:43:53
      So I commend you for your willingness to step into this.
    • 01:43:56
      It's an area that often has been controversial and VDOT has appeared to be autocratic or kind of singularly focused to the public that's interested in these things.
    • 01:44:06
      We all benefit.
    • 01:44:07
      It truly is a partnership, and I think your leadership in this is making a big difference, so thank you.
    • 01:44:11
      Thank you, sir.
    • 01:44:13
      It's a great opportunity, so we'll keep at it.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:15
      Thank you for saying that, Mr. Chairman.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:17
      It's a great opportunity if you seize it, and I believe you're doing that, so my compliments.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:44:25
      So kind of moving on to, there we go, moving on to roadside cleanliness which I think when we had this discussion last week kind of started the discussion of where we are.
    • 01:44:38
      What are we doing now?
    • 01:44:40
      Three times a year along with our mowing we do a roadside pickup and this is on the primary typically as well.
    • 01:44:48
      Secondary is usually one or two times a year in the rural areas.
    • 01:44:52
      In the urban areas, it's generally three.
    • 01:44:54
      If you go up somewhere in Northern Virginia, they would like it to be six or seven, but we are weighing resources against what we have.
    • 01:45:02
      It's the same pot of funds for maintaining bridges, maintaining pavements, sidewalks.
    • 01:45:07
      All of that comes out of the same pot, so trying to get the most out of the resources.
    • 01:45:13
      We have a partner.
    • 01:45:14
      with Keep Virginia Beautiful.
    • 01:45:16
      They help us.
    • 01:45:16
      There's citizen volunteers that you talk about, the volunteers.
    • 01:45:19
      So we work with them.
    • 01:45:21
      We'll talk a little bit about that a little more later on.
    • 01:45:23
      We do have comprehensive roadside management.
    • 01:45:26
      This is where local government, if you go to some towns, I think Lynchburg, if you go to Warrenton, you go to other places.
    • 01:45:32
      They will actually do a higher level of both mowing and pickup around there and that helps quite a bit.
    • 01:45:37
      So that's available and we do that under permit.
    • 01:45:40
      We also have volunteers like businesses and they enter into agreement with us.
    • 01:45:44
      Sometimes if it's near their business they believe it's more attractive so we're able to partner in that way.
    • 01:45:50
      So all of those are existing and generally when you're dealing with government they stay in existence.
    • 01:45:57
      Sometimes when a business transfers or goes out a bit that will change a little bit but most of these are pretty stable things and it's what we do already and again doing it in line with the mowing contract seems to work pretty well in keeping that happening but it's not really enough.
    • 01:46:13
      So what have we been looking for, what is developing?
    • 01:46:16
      Over the last probably three months we've been working with two companies, and I can't get their names straight, but we've met with one of them, and it's sponsorships and it's Adopt-a-Highway, both is in the name, they're two different companies, and you can see their name, and what they do
    • 01:46:34
      is they do sponsorships and what they want to do is come into a state and actually get the more highly traveled areas so that they can put a sponsorship sign up for a company similar to what we've done on the rest areas with GEICO and get something and they don't charge for that but they come in and they will actually do a certain amount of pickup
    • 01:46:53
      quote for free and then the sponsor's name is out there.
    • 01:46:56
      That takes a while to build.
    • 01:46:58
      We're requesting information now and we will likely go out with some sort of RFP or request for proposal in the next few months, but that's going to take a long time to do it.
    • 01:47:10
      The good news is we can get the maximum for no further resources.
    • 01:47:14
      The downside of it is
    • 01:47:16
      It's generally in more highly traveled areas.
    • 01:47:19
      The good side of that is more highly traveled areas generally have more litter to pick up.
    • 01:47:23
      So that's something that we're working actively and hope to have a program in place within about six months.
    • 01:47:29
      The other thing that we've done here occasionally is have a high visibility kind of cleanup, not the full million, but go out to places like
    • 01:47:38
      395, there's places down on top but places the districts pick out and I'll say we want to go out on the cheap let's get the most high visibility places and just pay our contractors to come in and do a sweep and we're looking at trying to do that end of winter and then probably sometime in between those three mowings in the peak tourism season and that for low dollars can get you the high visibility impact.
    • 01:48:02
      And then the last one on here is from some discussion with the Secretary.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:06
      Now I've got a whole program in here.
    • 01:48:07
      It's amazing.
    • 01:48:08
      Well, it's not a program.
    • 01:48:11
      I'm asking you shall receive.
    • 01:48:13
      It's not a program.
    • 01:48:13
      It's looking very official now.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:48:16
      It's not a program yet, but it's still developing.
    • 01:48:20
      This is probably the least mature of them, but we're working.
    • 01:48:24
      Well, thanks.
    • 01:48:28
      I didn't mean it that way.
    • 01:48:33
      Basically, and this is largely the Secretary's idea and we kind of bounce some things around, is the day of the six-year plan reviews, which goes to every district, go out there maybe in the morning and work with the localities and go out and do two or four hours in Janes and go out and pick a place and do that and maybe get local community folks to do that and we've talked to Kim Pryor and she says I think we can fit it in the schedule so
    • 01:48:56
      It looks like we can do it and get with communications.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:00
      I've talked to contractors, they say they want to come join us.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:03
      We could do that too.
    • 01:49:04
      Just one potential additional to that list.
    • 01:49:09
      So in my area we have a lot of adopt the roadway areas and the level of commitment on the part of those that are involved in this is variable but some of them are extraordinarily dedicated and I just wondered if as part of this there might not be an opportunity at some point during the year to recognize some of these groups.
    • 01:49:27
      My road is 12 miles long.
    • 01:49:29
      There is a single person who patrols that daily.
    • 01:49:32
      You will not find a cigarette.
    • 01:49:34
      And he's never recognized.
    • 01:49:36
      And I think small efforts towards...
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:39
      I think that's such a great idea.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:49:41
      Yeah.
    • 01:49:41
      I should have included that in there.
    • 01:49:43
      We have actually done things like that where, well I guess there's two things.
    • 01:49:47
      One, we've had local groups come in and usually in April and springtime volunteers do it and do it for a day or a weekend.
    • 01:49:54
      And that's something that's part of the partnership.
    • 01:49:56
      But the other thing is, yes, recognize.
    • 01:49:58
      I know in your part of northern Fauquier, there are places they keep the right-of-way better than we would ever keep it, both in mowing and it's kept pristine.
    • 01:50:07
      I mean, that's a very good, so it would be nice to recognize people.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:09
      Yeah, they're very much unsung.
    • 01:50:10
      I think around the Commonwealth, you know, that recognition.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:13
      Those rich people live where Scott lives.
    • 01:50:15
      They can pay for that stuff.
    • 01:50:18
      They get an assessment for living on the road.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:20
      We're not as mature, but we're getting there.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:50:24
      We're so glad you're here.
    • 01:50:29
      But we will develop it to a level of maturity and put it into action here in the next few weeks.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:33
      It's an and, Mr. Kasprowicz, right?
    • 01:50:36
      There you go.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:37
      Mr. Miller.
    • 01:50:38
      I know I've said this once, but I'm going to say it one more time.
    • 01:50:41
      Think about us here.
    • 01:50:43
      We're thinking about all these ways that we can get people to go pick up someone else's trash.
    • 01:50:49
      What's wrong with that picture?
    • 01:50:51
      You know, there's some trash that just happens through, I'll say through no fault of anybody's.
    • 01:50:58
      You know, it's a mistake, it happens, stuff happens, right?
    • 01:51:02
      That's not most of the trash that's out there.
    • 01:51:04
      People are opening the windows and throwing it out the car, right?
    • 01:51:09
      Or you got people in trucks that aren't securing their load properly.
    • 01:51:14
      When are we going to stop
    • 01:51:16
      We're running around spending our time and money to pick up their mess instead of holding them accountable. You know, I mean, you never see anybody getting a ticket for throwing a cigarette butt out the window. There's no way to report it. Nobody cares. Nobody cares. I care. I suggest you lobby your legislature. Well, that's my question. Is it the legislature? Is it the enforcement? Is it the enforcement?
    • 01:51:42
      Is the laws okay the way they are?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:45
      Well, you know, it's a shame Mr. Miller wasn't in the earlier discussions with us, because I think many of us would appreciate stronger laws and enforcement on these issues, and I know many of us had voted, have voted over the years for this as well.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:59
      You killed all that stuff when I was chairman.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:00
      So I think it's both.
    • 01:52:02
      It's both.
    • 01:52:02
      You make a good point, but there are many of us who would like for it to be tougher.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:52:08
      I wouldn't disagree, but it's not just what you think of trash.
    • 01:52:11
      I mean, our crews are oftentimes out picking up refrigerators, mattresses, I mean, things that people just...
    • 01:52:17
      It's amazing the things that I've been out picking up and actually had it come out the window.
    • 01:52:22
      It's almost like in your face out the window when you're doing it.
    • 01:52:25
      It's kind of odd, so, you know.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:28
      I was just going to observe that when I was a little girl was when seatbelts first came in and there was lots of resistance to seatbelts and in the part of the world where I grew up there was a contest that was sponsored in the elementary schools to make posters about why seatbelts were important so they went to the kids
    • 01:52:50
      And they basically said, oh, here's a contest.
    • 01:52:53
      You can win $100 savings bond.
    • 01:52:54
      Everybody made posters.
    • 01:52:56
      It was a big deal.
    • 01:52:57
      The adults changed their tune because their kids were sitting in the backseat saying, put your seat belt on, Daddy.
    • 01:53:04
      You're going to die, right?
    • 01:53:06
      And I just wonder, as part of this, if there isn't a way
    • 01:53:11
      to partner with VSBA and VML and VACO to promote some kind of a contest around don't litter from your car.
    • 01:53:21
      And also it goes to the safety, you know, we did the license plate contest, but we could also have the distracted driver thing and just really kind of build it into this fun thing.
    • 01:53:33
      But I think what happens is the conversation changes inside the cars.
    • 01:53:39
      which is really where you need it to happen is mom picks up the phone you know dad tosses whatever out the window and the kids in the back seat are saying hey wait a minute and that's the generational shift to me that has to happen and you know they those organizations are perfectly capable of running a poster contest that we would then celebrate and reproduce well i love that
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:03
      Madam Secretary, I agree totally with Mr. Miller.
    • 01:54:08
      I share his passion for that.
    • 01:54:10
      I also feel the same way about our waterways too that are increasingly getting and there's a lot of ways to attack this through education, through enforcement, through collaboration with volunteer groups.
    • 01:54:27
      I remember many years ago there was a
    • 01:54:30
      An ad that was effective to me, and if you remember, someone threw trash out of a car and there was an Indian standing there with a tear.
    • 01:54:42
      But that type of awareness as a young person had an impact to me, because I never throw anything out of a car.
    • 01:54:50
      And I can't, you know.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:51
      Well, you know, maybe we'll get our communications folks engaged in this as well.
    • 01:54:57
      to see you know how perhaps we could do something here in Virginia.
    • 01:55:01
      Our message boards are always recognized for being so smart and clever and so maybe there's a way to broaden that a little bit.
    • 01:55:11
      I will also just add to what Ms. Hines was saying that Mr. Dodson knows in Lynchburg, I've picked up a lot of trash just working with Habitat and Lynchburg Housing Partnerships and I will say that when you do it
    • 01:55:24
      It's contagious in neighborhoods that if you start doing that and people are picking up trash or not tolerating trash, that becomes a shift.
    • 01:55:35
      And so I think that is what we're hoping to create in transportation.
    • 01:55:41
      So Mr. Moore.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:55:42
      Yes, ma'am.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:43
      Who knew this was going to be as exciting as it is?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:55:46
      Program, ma'am.
    • 01:55:48
      Absolutely.
    • 01:55:51
      And we're, believe it or not, and we're going to look at this as a baseline to build from because we need to get better at this.
    • 01:55:59
      You know, the tourism and just the way we want things to look, we've worked hard on our infrastructure and we want it to look good too, but we did get from
    • 01:56:08
      An award from Keep America Beautiful, I think seven states got this partnership award and we just want to kind of use this as the baseline to move up and see what we can do better and I think it would make the Commonwealth look better and at the same time with our limited resources if we get public awareness it
    • 01:56:23
      This is costing the taxpayers money to clean it up.
    • 01:56:27
      So that's maybe another line on this too.
    • 01:56:30
      So that's where we're at with things and I don't know if there's any other to appreciate the discussion as we go forward.
    • 01:56:36
      We have a program to do it and we'll keep growing it.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:40
      Anything else?
    • 01:56:42
      Thank you, Mr. Moore, and thank you again for kind of taking the lead on this.
    • 01:56:47
      We go from having the largest transportation project in the Commonwealth of Virginia to picking up trucks.
    • 01:56:53
      We cover the gamut.
    • 01:56:56
      So with that, pardon me?
    • 01:56:59
      Yeah, very versatile, many priorities.
    • 01:57:03
      So, lunch is here, so do you have any instructions?
    • 01:57:08
      Take time.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:57:14
      During lunch, if you want to see me, let me know.
    • 01:57:19
      I'll let you know what the weather is going to be, what the weather is going to be that we need to adjust your accommodations tonight, and whether or not you're going to be able to attend the dinner tonight so I can make those adjustments as necessary.
    • 01:57:33
      Just see me at lunchtime.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:34
      Okay, and because we are in the middle of session, we're still navigating session.
    • 01:57:42
      I'm going to ask for an hour break, so we will reconvene at one o'clock, just so I can take care of a few things, and then we'll come back and that will give you time to work on logistics.
    • 01:57:54
      Okay, we stand in recess.
    • 03:00:43
      There would not be a meeting without Mr. Donohue giving us an update, right?
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:02
      Hi Mr. Donohue.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:03
      There's nothing going on.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:01:05
      Our finest hour.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:06
      Our finest hour.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:01:08
      Well, Madam Chair, members of the board, Nick Donohue, I'm here to give you an update on where things stand with the General Assembly.
    • 03:01:13
      Just as a really important caveat, the General Assembly is still in town.
    • 03:01:17
      That means many of the things I tell you could change before everything hopefully adjourns this Saturday.
    • 03:01:23
      Saturday is the scheduled adjournment of the General Assembly.
    • 03:01:28
      At the moment the budget is still in conference, so I cannot tell you what the conference report on that might look like.
    • 03:01:35
      But what I do want to do is just walk through some of the bills we discussed with you last time, give you an update on their fate or current status, whatever the case might be, and then also discuss some things that were introduced after you were last here and talk about where those are and any importance they may have.
    • 03:01:50
      So let's start with the big kind of issue in the room, which was the I-81 Corridor Improvement Plan.
    • 03:01:57
      The governor did introduce legislation sponsored by Delegate Landis, Delegate Austin, Senator Obenshain, Senator Carrico.
    • 03:02:04
      That legislation is still alive.
    • 03:02:06
      It is in conference.
    • 03:02:08
      I will say though that it unfortunately does not currently include a funding source.
    • 03:02:12
      So there was a lot of discussion during the Senate and in the House kind of in one-on-one meetings but also in the Senate Finance Committee regarding what would be the appropriate funding source.
    • 03:02:24
      I think ultimately this bill lacks one at the moment because the legislators were not able to coalesce around that which they believed to be the most appropriate funding source.
    • 03:02:33
      There were many who wanted to impose a tax of some form
    • 03:02:36
      Really looking at statewide taxes, interestingly enough.
    • 03:02:41
      So as you recall, when I met with you last time, there were two other revenue generating bills that we discussed.
    • 03:02:47
      One was Senator Hanger's bill, which would have done a 2.1% fuels tax increase along the planning district commissions on the 81 corridor.
    • 03:02:55
      One of the issues with that bill, again, is for diesel, trucks remit through a system called the International Fuels Tax Agreement when they buy fuel.
    • 03:03:04
      So even if they don't buy gas in Virginia, they're not paying because, again, they have several hundred gallon tanks.
    • 03:03:08
      They could easily drive through Virginia without buying gas.
    • 03:03:12
      The International Fuels Tax Agreement does not capture tax money from a regional tax source.
    • 03:03:17
      And so ultimately, you know, that kind of,
    • 03:03:20
      resulted in some discussion on that bill and that bill was rolled into Senator Edwards' bill, 1470, which did report out of the Senate Finance Transportation Subcommittee to the full committee, which would have increased, or actually, excuse me, it would have doubled the wholesale tax on gasoline and increased the wholesale tax on diesel by
    • 03:03:42
      I think it's 84 or 88 percent.
    • 03:03:44
      I'm not great at math.
    • 03:03:45
      Five divided by six, if anyone's better.
    • 03:03:48
      That's what it would have done there.
    • 03:03:49
      And then it would have taken approximately, sorry.
    • 03:03:58
      There we go.
    • 03:03:59
      Somebody's better at math.
    • 03:04:00
      And it would have dedicated $200 million off the top from the funds for the 81 corridor.
    • 03:04:08
      In the Senate Finance Committee, that bill was made to look very different.
    • 03:04:11
      Then it came out of the subcommittee and all the revenue generating provisions were stripped out of it and ultimately what was left was a section one bill directing the Secretary of Transportation to study the impact of fuel economy and hot electric vehicles on Virginia's revenue streams and report back to the General Assembly by December 15th of 2019 regarding ways to address kind of the unsustainability of our revenue streams.
    • 03:04:38
      While that may seem like a
    • 03:04:39
      Waterdown version of its former self, I will say, I think the members of the General Assembly heard the Secretary's point that we are really, we've hit an inflection point when it comes to fuels tax because for the first time ever, VMT has gone up and our actual collections have gone down year over year.
    • 03:04:55
      And by gone down, I don't mean we missed a projection, we thought we'd be four and we were 2%.
    • 03:05:00
      I mean, we were supposed to grow at 1% and we went down 1.4%.
    • 03:05:04
      And I think folks have really heard that and that's important.
    • 03:05:08
      That's something very important for the General Assembly members to understand.
    • 03:05:12
      That bill is currently in the House Appropriations Committee.
    • 03:05:16
      Similar language to that is included in the House budget, so ultimately we do expect that direction in charge to the Secretary to pass, though I think it's more likely to be included in the budget than in this bill.
    • 03:05:28
      The 81 bills would establish the 81 corridor fund.
    • 03:05:32
      They would establish an 81 committee.
    • 03:05:35
      Congratulations, members of the board, Mr. Smoot, Mr. Whitworth, and Mr. Stinson.
    • 03:05:40
      I see two of you weren't here, but you'll be at the I-81 corridor meetings if these bills come out of committee.
    • 03:05:47
      And that committee has similar membership as the introduced bill.
    • 03:05:50
      So it's the five planning district commission chairs along the corridor, the three CTB members from the corridor.
    • 03:05:55
      They did increase the legislative membership.
    • 03:05:59
      So instead of being three House members and two Senate members, it's four House members and three Senate members in the House bill and four and four in the Senate bill.
    • 03:06:08
      And that committee is charged to discuss in public
    • 03:06:11
      ways that would be potentially build consensus to try and fund I-81.
    • 03:06:15
      Again, there's some other differences in these bills.
    • 03:06:17
      They're currently in conference.
    • 03:06:19
      We'll see what comes out of the conference here in the next few days.
    • 03:06:21
      Again, all conference reports have to be out by Friday, I believe it is.
    • 03:06:24
      Maybe it's Saturday actually.
    • 03:06:26
      But again, that information will be out later this week and we'll see what
    • 03:06:29
      ultimately is included with that.
    • 03:06:31
      The tolling proposal drew concerns from a host of different reasons.
    • 03:06:36
      Some of the folks in Northern Virginia were concerned about the annual pass for commuters.
    • 03:06:41
      That exists despite numerous attempts by the Secretary and myself trying to explain the differences between dynamic pricing or a road built with tolls versus a toll-free interstate being converted to a toll road.
    • 03:06:52
      And I will maintain very vigorously there's a dramatic difference between the two.
    • 03:06:55
      However, that was not
    • 03:06:57
      Persuasive with the majority of the members in our discussions.
    • 03:07:03
      We do.
    • 03:07:04
      At the same time, the gas tax bill also was not persuasive.
    • 03:07:08
      And one of the major concerns that was noted with that, particularly with the statewide tax increase, was you'd be taking $200 million off the top and then running the rest of the money through the formula.
    • 03:07:18
      And so the net effect of that, if you're from Hampton Roads or Northern Virginia, is you are taxing yourself for your own roads in both regions, and then you'd also be taxing yourself for 81.
    • 03:07:28
      And then you'd run the money through the formula.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:30
      So ultimately, I think that kind of... Mr. Smoot loved that idea.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:07:34
      That kind of impacted the future of that legislation.
    • 03:07:39
      There were several other bills that we were watching that I just want to update you guys on.
    • 03:07:43
      Delegate Watts had a bill that would have basically put in place the governor's amendments to the WMATA bill which would have generated around 30 million dollars annually for NVTA.
    • 03:07:52
      That bill was left in House Rules.
    • 03:07:54
      Senator Stanley had a bill that would have redirected recordation tax revenues in approximately 25 to 30 years that are currently in the Route 58 program to a new I-73 corridor development plan.
    • 03:08:08
      That bill passed the Senate 26 to 13 but was tabled in the House Appropriations Transportation Subcommittee.
    • 03:08:14
      And again I want to note
    • 03:08:16
      That's a very forward-looking bill, if you will, because, again, it would take effect when the Route 58 debt service was retired.
    • 03:08:23
      We are just getting ready to do the first of three debt issuances for Route 58 next year.
    • 03:08:29
      The final one would be, I believe, four years from now.
    • 03:08:32
      So, again, I think it's a 30-year look ahead, if you will, from when that would have been effective if it had made it out of the General Assembly.
    • 03:08:40
      On the online sales tax front, that legislation has passed both the House and Senate and it is before the governor for his consideration.
    • 03:08:49
      I don't believe it is a seven-day bill.
    • 03:08:51
      I don't think it's been formally communicated at this stage.
    • 03:08:54
      Importantly, I think for you all, it does include provisions that would
    • 03:08:58
      run the online sales tax through the existing sales tax formula and repeal the provision that would reduce the gas tax from 5.1 back to 3.6%.
    • 03:09:10
      That is a very big positive.
    • 03:09:12
      That means instead of losing $100 million we'll get a little bit of money, then again that money is baked into the figures you've been using.
    • 03:09:18
      But that is very important and again it did pass both chambers with very, very significant margins.
    • 03:09:24
      There were several bills dealing with I-66, one from Delegate Delaney and one from Delegate Hugo.
    • 03:09:29
      Both of those were tabled in House Appropriations.
    • 03:09:32
      There was a separate bill from Delegate Hugo that has passed both the House and Senate that would prohibit the Board from exercising its authority to impose tolls on a limited access highway that previously was a secondary road that is between 30 and 33 miles in length.
    • 03:09:48
      And if you're wondering what that is, that is the Fairfax County Parkway.
    • 03:09:51
      There's the only road in the Commonwealth that would meet those requirements, though at the moment it's not a limited access highway, so you don't even have authority to impose tolls on it anyway.
    • 03:09:59
      But should it become a limited access highway in the future, this bill would restrict your authority from doing so.
    • 03:10:05
      That is passed both the House and Senate.
    • 03:10:08
      There were several bills dealing with the Dulles Greenway.
    • 03:10:11
      There was one from Senator Stanley in delegate Iraq that would have dramatically changed the governing regulations of how the SEC, what investments it considers when it determines whether or not the toll rate imposed by the Greenway operator
    • 03:10:25
      was appropriate.
    • 03:10:26
      That was a pretty contentious bill.
    • 03:10:29
      Ultimately, Senator Stanley's bill failed to report six to seven after about two hours of debate in the Senate Transportation Committee.
    • 03:10:36
      There was a separate set of bills that the Secretary and I worked on with Delegates Bell and Reed and Senator Favola that would have asked
    • 03:10:45
      The Secretary to study whether there were opportunities through the combined operations of the Dulles Toll Road and Dulles Greenway to lower tolls, implement distance-based pricing, and increase person throughput along that corridor.
    • 03:10:59
      If you take a look at travel trends in Northern Virginia, particularly east-west travel, what you'll see is over the last 10 to 15 years, as you've seen large toll increases on those two roads, the share of east-west traffic when you look at Route 7,
    • 03:11:12
      route 267 which is the toll road 66 and 50 is the percentage of traffic heading on routes 267 has dropped by about 10%.
    • 03:11:22
      So it used to be around 35% of all east-west traffic and it's now around 25%.
    • 03:11:28
      That's not good news for those other parallel roads, and so we think there might be some opportunities there.
    • 03:11:33
      However, that bill was also tabled in the House Transportation Committee.
    • 03:11:38
      However, we do not need permission to do studies, but sometimes we can be directed to do them.
    • 03:11:45
      A bill from Delegate Stolle has passed both the House and the Senate, which would allow the rail enhancement fund to use federal funds for freight rail projects as its match.
    • 03:11:56
      So as you may recall, the rail enhancement fund does require a 30% non-state match.
    • 03:12:01
      That initially started as private.
    • 03:12:04
      It was then expanded to local.
    • 03:12:05
      And with this change, it would now allow for federal funds to match the rail enhancement fund, provided those funds were for a freight rail project.
    • 03:12:12
      And that language is intentionally
    • 03:12:15
      We do want to acknowledge the Port and DRPT for really working to get that language right.
    • 03:12:30
      One other large issue for the board is there is two competing provisions related to the transit operating performance formula.
    • 03:12:41
      As you all recall, Director Mitchell and her agency were directed by the WMATA and transit reform bill last session to implement a funding formula to prioritize operating funding without any additional operating funding being put into the system.
    • 03:12:56
      That
    • 03:12:57
      Predictably has created some consternation.
    • 03:13:00
      Whenever you change the allocation of funds but add no new money, they're invariably winners and losers.
    • 03:13:06
      Depending on how you want to do it, different groups of people become winners or losers as the case may be.
    • 03:13:10
      There are two proposals that are out there.
    • 03:13:13
      One would provide $3 million out of DRPT's operating reserve to hold transit agencies harmless.
    • 03:13:19
      for a year and a second one which was included in the Senate budget would have delayed the implementation of this I believe for two years and then specifically directed certain measures be used in the performance formula that allocates funding there.
    • 03:13:35
      So I expect this issue will ultimately be adjudicated in the budget conference and so we'll see where the negotiations end up
    • 03:13:43
      hopefully in the next few days again Director Mitchell I know has worked very closely with both sides provided lots of information to folks and again there's 90 million dollars in this program if we use a performance system that actually changes how funds flow which based on my understanding of what the goal is there will be a winner and loser in that and I think the ultimate question is who's winning and who's losing and how does that all kind of turn out unless the General Assembly puts additional funds into that program.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:12
      Is there anything you want to
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:15
      Now just to mention that we were originally planning to, as you may recall we briefed you all last month on this and we were originally planning to bring that to you all this month for a vote but given the contradictory language that's still in the budget right now we've decided to postpone that until March so we can see what the outcome of that legislation is and based on that we'll be briefing all of you individually before the March meeting to talk with you about what happened and
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:14:44
      There were also two bills dealing with the SMART SCALE process.
    • 03:14:52
      There was one that would have added a new factor dealing with resiliency, specifically with evacuation routes and the resiliency there, and another that would have said that in Northern Virginia you could only fund projects that had congestion reduction even
    • 03:15:09
      I can't explain it clearly at the moment because I'm a little tired, but basically it would have said if there's a product that makes any car go any amount slower than it currently does, even if that's the intent for safety purposes, you cannot fund it if there's any project that allows any car to drive faster than it currently does, even if it's 0.1 miles per hour if it's unfunded.
    • 03:15:29
      Both those bills were tabled in the Transportation Committee and did not advance.
    • 03:15:35
      And with that, Madam Chair, I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • 03:15:37
      Again, several things are still up in the air, particularly the budget.
    • 03:15:40
      There weren't many amendments to the transportation section relative to others, so I don't have much to report there.
    • 03:15:46
      But again, we will see the conference report hopefully here in the next two or three days, and we'll obviously update you at the next meeting.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:53
      Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:54
      Thank you, Madam Secretary.
    • 03:15:56
      The Robert O. Norris Bridge Bill, can you help us with that one?
    • 03:16:01
      I meant to mention that one, I apologize.
    • 03:16:03
      Specifically, does that language correlate to our vital structures?
    • 03:16:09
      Because it calls it critical structures and speaks to bridges.
    • 03:16:13
      We did a vital structure thing, right?
    • 03:16:16
      That we were directed to do.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:16:18
      Madam Chair, Mr. Miller, I do apologize.
    • 03:16:21
      There was two pieces of legislation introduced after you all met in January.
    • 03:16:26
      One was Senate Bill 1749 and the other was House Bill 2748.
    • 03:16:30
      Both of these pieces of legislation have passed both houses and I believe Senate Bill 1749 is a seven-day bill.
    • 03:16:37
      This legislation is a follow-on
    • 03:16:39
      to the special structures as it was called in the budget, vital structures as it was renamed by you all and it is now called the Robert O. Norris Bridge and Special or Critical Structures Fund.
    • 03:16:51
      This bill has several specific components to it.
    • 03:16:55
      One of those is important for the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
    • 03:16:58
      Brich, Stephen C. Brich,
    • 03:17:21
      What amount of money from the State of Good Repair Program as well as from the Highway Maintenance and Operating Program could we take to be able to fund these special structures as identified in the Vital Structures Report you considered?
    • 03:17:33
      And then what would be our performance target for pavement and bridge that would be sustainable over a 20-year period?
    • 03:17:39
      And then it actually directs and provides that you all shall allocate that amount of money out of those two programs starting in July 1, 2020?
    • 03:17:48
      And so it creates the fund that those would go into to fund these structures.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:53
      Does that mean that we would, that the pavement piece
    • 03:18:02
      of these vital structures, not the underlying piece.
    • 03:18:07
      You're talking about pavement, but I'm talking about bridges.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:18:10
      No, Madam Chair, Mr. Miller, I think it's telling us to re-evaluate our current pavement and bridge targets.
    • 03:18:15
      We're looking at what could be a sustainable target if we took money out of the HMOF and the State of Good Repair Program to fund the replacement of those 25 special structures.
    • 03:18:27
      I think some folks have noted that we are well in excess of the kind of targets in our current performance today.
    • 03:18:33
      So if we dial them back to a certain target, how much money would that free up?
    • 03:18:38
      And could that allow us to fund the special structures or vital structures or critical structures?
    • 03:18:43
      You know it's 25 bridges I'm talking about.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:47
      Yes, because I believe the recommendation that came out of the vital structures report
    • 03:18:55
      But includes the targets, maintenance, date of good repair.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:18:58
      And again, this was legislation introduced independently by Senator McDougall and then Delegate Hodges, so I think they both represent districts where it includes the Robert O. Norris Bridge, so I'm guessing that's where the name came from.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:12
      We appreciate that.
    • 03:19:13
      I know Ms. Hines certainly did.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:16
      Madam Secretary.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:17
      Mr. Dodson.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:18
      Couple questions.
    • 03:19:18
      Who of the four senators appointed to this I-81 study group?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:19:22
      Madam Chair, Mr. Dodson, so again it could be three or four senators or some other number because that is one of the differences being debated in conference but those would be selected by the President of the Senate.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:33
      Okay.
    • 03:19:34
      The other issue I was going to ask going through these ones, there's
    • 03:19:39
      This is from the General Assembly Staff Report we've given out.
    • 03:19:43
      The 29 Eastern Bypass Evaluation, was that a bill put in by one of the Senators from our area?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:19:52
      I believe there was a joint resolution put in by Senator Peek.
    • 03:19:55
      That bill was, I believe, tabled in the Senate Finance Committee.
    • 03:19:58
      though there was a provision concluded in the Senate Finance Transportation Subcommittee report so that is one of the issues that's ultimately being hashed out by the conferees.
    • 03:20:07
      I would note that I believe the language in the subcommittee report from the Senate was slightly watered down from the studied version because some of the discussion at the Senate Finance Committee was that what was being asked in the budget would not have a physical impact whereas the joint resolution I believe was tabled because of a physical impact and so we'll see what happens there ultimately but there was a slight
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:27
      I see you in the hallways, the General Assembly too.
    • 03:20:32
      There was a trooper that was murdered near Farmville recently, Lucas Dowell, and I see there's legislation for a reason.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:20:38
      This is where I need to hand it over to Jo Anne Maxwell.
    • 03:20:40
      There's a discrete number of bills that I keep track of, but she is very capable of going through the rest of these.
    • 03:20:45
      I will probably give you inaccurate information if I try and answer that question, so I'm going to exit stage left and let Jo Anne know.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:52
      I was going to ask off the issues of murder recently, serving a warrant on someone who's tried to, but my question is, which is fine, but there's interest in Amherst County, where he served at, to have another bridge, is this a petition to start, is there anything about, if this petition, he's from Southwest Virginia, and it's wonderful, it seemed like a wonderful young man, is there any,
    • 03:21:18
      Is the prohibition about having two bridges named after anybody in the state code if it comes up?
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:21:24
      Madam Chair, no there's not and there are even times where you can name the same bridge a couple of times and you can actually incorporate the prior name but there's nothing in the code and I know there was some discussions about which bridge or facility should be named so I know that's on the minds of the legislators.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:44
      The other one is the North Virginia one, it said VDOT to stay to purchase the Dulles Greenway.
    • 03:21:50
      Does that mean from, it was from Senator Black, is that correct?
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:21:54
      Yes, yes, Madam Chair.
    • 03:21:56
      This particular resolution moved out of House Rules Committee yesterday, so it's headed, I mean it has basically passed.
    • 03:22:08
      And so this would not be the first time that VDOT has studied purchase of the Greenway.
    • 03:22:13
      I think the last time that we studied was 2013.
    • 03:22:15
      The issues that we were to look at in doing that study are slightly different from the issues that are involved or dictated by this particular study.
    • 03:22:25
      But at the end of the day, the last study found that it basically would not be feasible to purchase it.
    • 03:22:29
      I think the primary issue there was that we found that the purchase price far exceeded the market value of the asset.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:37
      The last question, a local engineer said there's a bill put in by Senator Peek for $100,000 to study Route 60 going from two lane to four lane from the Powelltown-Chesterfield line to the town of Amherst.
    • 03:22:51
      I didn't see it much, but is that something still current, or do you know?
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:22:56
      Madam Chair, if it's not on this list, it is no longer active.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:00
      Okay, that's what I assume.
    • 03:23:02
      Thank you, Madam Chair.
    • 03:23:03
      Thank you, Mr. Dodson.
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:23:04
      And Madam Chair, there was one other study that it looks like likely the CTB will need to be doing, and that's the I-95 corridor.
    • 03:23:13
      So that is another study that is directed directly at CTB.
    • 03:23:18
      Finally, there's one other minor, very minor bill, but it was extremely important to the senator that heads or chairs Senate transportation, and that is a bill that dealt with naming by the Commonwealth Transportation Board, or namings of highways.
    • 03:23:33
      Currently under the law, when a bridge or a facility is named after an individual, the locality in which the particular facility is located is the entity that has to approve the naming, and then the locality has to agree to pay for the signage.
    • 03:23:53
      In this bill, which is now passed,
    • 03:23:58
      If it involves a state official, then the entity that has actually, for whom the state official worked, is the entity that will be approving the naming, and the price for the signage, the cost of the signage, is to come from Commonwealth Transportation Funds.
    • 03:24:15
      So that's gonna be a slight change.
    • 03:24:17
      You all, it won't be that significant when we don't believe that, I mean, we haven't seen that many namings in the last few years for state officials, but nevertheless, it's a slight change for you all.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:24:27
      Madam Secretary, do we know what we're looking to study on Route 95?
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:24:35
      I think some of the details are dictated.
    • 03:24:38
      Let me look at your sheet.
    • 03:24:49
      I will say that in looking at the study itself, we did determine that it would be very similar to the I-81 study.
    • 03:24:59
      It would entail very similar activities.
    • 03:25:03
      I can't find it at this point.
    • 03:25:06
      There it is.
    • 03:25:12
      Basically, it is only for
    • 03:25:15
      Mile Marker 118 through the Springfield interchange.
    • 03:25:22
      But basically, and I can get you more details, actually.
    • 03:25:26
      I can certainly provide more details as to the specific items to be studied.
    • 03:25:31
      But staff concluded in looking at the study when they were reviewing the bill that it's going to be very similar to I-81.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:25:40
      And I think, and I agree with you, I think it was actually to be modeled a little bit after I-81, the process, the identification of improvements, very much because people appreciated how the 81 study had been conducted.
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:25:56
      And Madam Chair, I think the one difference in this case is that we do have hot lanes operator in the area, which was not an issue presented by the 81 study.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:06
      And I believe it was something too that the Commissioner had last year expressed a willingness to do in looking at the quarter.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:17
      I'm sorry, Jo Anne, I don't have the bill number, but there was a concern raised in Northern Virginia about a bill that was put in related to the state joining some of the climate change or the greenhouse gas emission coalitions, and that that might pose some problems relative to using CMAQ money.
    • 03:26:43
      I just wonder if there's an update on that.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:26:45
      Madam Chair, Ms. Hines, there were I believe two bills both sponsored by Delegate Poindexter.
    • 03:26:50
      One was House Bill 2269 and I apologize I don't recall the other bill number.
    • 03:26:54
      Those both passed both chambers by party line votes.
    • 03:26:57
      I know at least one of those is a seven-day bill and I apologize a seven-day bill basically means
    • 03:27:02
      By this Saturday the Governor will have amended, signed or vetoed that legislation and it will be back before the Assembly for its consideration.
    • 03:27:11
      Those are typically done with bills that have a high level of consensus or that people want to make sure are discussed promptly.
    • 03:27:18
      We did have discussion with some of the localities in Northern Virginia regarding this legislation.
    • 03:27:24
      I don't believe this would impact their use of CMAQ funds because you do not have to be a member of any transportation or climate change initiative or regional greenhouse gas program to use your CMAQ money.
    • 03:27:37
      So I don't think it has any impacts from that perspective.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:41
      But good question.
    • 03:27:43
      Anything else?
    • 03:27:46
      Okay.
    • 03:27:47
      Well, thank you both.
    • Jo Anne MaxwellGovernance and Legislative Affairs Division Administrator
    • 03:27:48
      Thank you, Jo Anne.
    • 03:27:49
      Thank you, Nick.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:50
      You know, as they said, though, we're still in the middle of session, so anyway.
    • 03:27:56
      It's always interesting.
    • 03:27:58
      Pardon me?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:58
      Anything could happen.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:28:00
      Anything could happen.
    • 03:28:01
      That's exactly right.
    • 03:28:03
      And Amy White, who is Assistant Secretary of Transportation, has been kind of holding the repository of all the legislation across the secretariat.
    • 03:28:14
      And the only one I think that wasn't mentioned was the towing compact bill.
    • 03:28:18
      Do you want to give a quick update on that?
    • 03:28:22
      which is something we're doing with DC and Maryland.
    • 03:28:25
      So I just mentioned that to you.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 03:28:28
      Madam Secretary, members of the board, the Potomac River Bridge Towing Compact SB 1296 has made it through both chambers.
    • 03:28:36
      It's not yet enrolled but what that legislation does is add the remaining four bridges over the Potomac to that compact with Maryland and DC.
    • 03:28:45
      So now all of those bridges will be covered
    • 03:28:47
      by this compact which helps any law enforcement personnel who's nearby, who's closest to an incident on any of those bridges to respond regardless of jurisdiction.
    • 03:28:59
      So it's a safety highway operations and incident management bill but it's also one of three topics covered in an incident management task force among the three jurisdictions that's been going on for over a year.
    • 03:29:16
      It continues and VDOT and Virginia have taken a very active role.
    • 03:29:21
      So that is one of the three topics.
    • 03:29:22
      We've also talked about the move over legislation, so moving over for emergency vehicles.
    • 03:29:28
      And that's something we continue to work on.
    • 03:29:31
      A couple of bills along that topic did not make it through this session.
    • 03:29:36
      Our Potomac River-Bridgetone Compact has Maryland and D.C. have also agreed to pass similar legislation.
    • 03:29:43
      So they have our language.
    • 03:29:45
      They will pass mirror legislation so that it can go into effect in all three jurisdictions.
    • 03:29:50
      Unfortunately, Maryland did drop the ball during this session, so we will have to wait a year for that.
    • 03:29:55
      But D.C. has agreed because they have a rolling legislative session to implement theirs as soon as Maryland complies as well.
    • 03:30:03
      Any questions?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:05
      And Amy took the lead on getting that initiated, so thank you.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:09
      Should have taken the lead in Maryland.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:12
      Well, we have an enactment clause, so it's all good.
    • 03:30:15
      It's all good.
    • 03:30:17
      So, I cannot see.
    • 03:30:21
      Yes, Cathy McGhee is back there.
    • 03:30:22
      The Innovation Committee met this morning, and so I was just going to ask Cathy McGhee, our Director of Research and Innovation, just to give us an update from the committee this morning.
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 03:30:35
      Madam Secretary, thank you for the opportunity to give you just a summary of our meeting this morning.
    • 03:30:42
      We did start with a great summary from one of our members, Scott Kasprowicz, about his trip to LA to visit the boring company and all that he learned about Hyperloop and Loop and the boring company itself and the opportunities to improve the way we bore underground tunnels.
    • 03:31:05
      and his assessment of where we stand with those technologies.
    • 03:31:08
      So we really appreciate his sharing that information with us.
    • 03:31:13
      I will tell you that he also suggested a way that we can better share information with all of you.
    • 03:31:20
      about technologies that we see on the horizon and we'll be working collaboratively to put together a briefing book for you and then perhaps give you regularly scheduled updates as things change on those technologies in the briefing book.
    • 03:31:35
      So more to come on that and I appreciate the suggestion and the offer of assistance in putting that together.
    • 03:31:43
      We also had a presentation from Virginia Langham, who is the Connected and Automated Vehicle Program Manager at VDOT.
    • 03:31:52
      She put together a workshop on automated vehicles for VDOT staff several weeks ago.
    • 03:32:01
      And really the opportunity that was there was to provide a level setting
    • 03:32:08
      For all of us in terms of the conversations we have about automated vehicles and to make sure that when we're using terminology it means the same thing to all of us and to bring in some of the folks in VDOT who perhaps haven't been as engaged in those conversations but will be impacted as we move forward towards an automated future.
    • 03:32:29
      So we had maintenance folks and people from
    • 03:32:34
      structure and bridge, traffic engineering and communications and just really across the agency to talk about what automation will mean to the way we provide transportation services and the core functions that we've established in VDOT.
    • 03:32:50
      Those conversations will continue to happen across the Commonwealth and as the meetings move around we'll be inviting localities to participate because much of the
    • 03:33:03
      Sort of automated shared use mobility future will rest in the hands of our localities and so we want to bring them into the conversation as well as DRPT and state police and certainly DMV from the regulation side.
    • 03:33:19
      So we will continue to have those conversations.
    • 03:33:22
      And if you would like, we can make you aware of meetings that might be happening in your areas of the Commonwealth so that you can participate in those conversations as well.
    • 03:33:32
      The initial meeting really was modeled after something that happened at the federal level.
    • 03:33:38
      Last year, there were a number of these workshops held across the country on different topic areas, freight, data, infrastructure,
    • 03:33:47
      In our meetings, we're trying to combine all of those as opposed to stove piping the individual issues.
    • 03:33:52
      So I think it's a really great opportunity to make sure everyone understands where the technology is and where we're headed with it.
    • 03:34:02
      I then took just a few minutes to update the committee on a number of things that are happening.
    • 03:34:08
      For those of you who aren't aware, there is a local Virginia company developing automated vehicle technology, Perrone Robotics is the name of the company.
    • 03:34:18
      and they are working with Albemarle County and Jaunt to do a demonstration of a low-speed electric neighborhood vehicle, a shuttle basically, that would be automated in the Crozet area of Albemarle County and it's anticipated that that demonstration will go live in March, towards the end of March.
    • 03:34:42
      The important thing to note about that particular demonstration is not a one-off.
    • 03:34:48
      They have plans to expand their work in the automated area with Jaunt into the future, and I think that's a really good point of departure for that particular demonstration.
    • 03:35:00
      So many of them are one and done, and they really do have a plan for how they bring automation into their future services.
    • 03:35:09
      We also discussed briefly an effort that we're getting underway with Transurban and DBI and
    • 03:35:19
      Virginia Tech to work on automated crash cushions, the truck-mounted attenuators that are so important to providing safety for our workers in work zones.
    • 03:35:31
      Unfortunately, they can be quite hazardous for the people who drive them, so if we can remove the driver from that vehicle, that would be a great safety advancement.
    • 03:35:41
      And then finally, Audi did release today their press release about our work with them to provide signal timing information, which they're providing directly into their vehicles in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:35:59
      The press release acknowledges that Virginia is the largest
    • 03:36:03
      deployment they've had to date with all of our signals in the region going live in their system.
    • 03:36:10
      So we're really excited about that and look forward to providing them additional signal information as our central system goes online and we have the ability to provide that statewide.
    • 03:36:23
      I believe that was it.
    • 03:36:25
      Any questions?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:36:25
      And the announcement's very exciting.
    • 03:36:27
      So and I would say this that I've been trying to as we're making these announcements publicly to make sure that the board is also receiving the press releases.
    • 03:36:36
      So I do think when we do that with the Audi release too that the board also gets it.
    • 03:36:41
      I just ask that.
    • 03:36:42
      Mr. Kaspowitz.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:36:42
      Madam Secretary, thank you.
    • 03:36:45
      I just wanted to comment on Cathy's identification of the crash barrier program that we will maintain ownership of the intellectual property or any developments that come from that so we can potentially benefit from that in the future.
    • 03:37:00
      I thought that was an interesting
    • 03:37:02
      I also wanted to just take a minute and say I think what Audi did today and that announcement is going to be something we'll remember and look back on.
    • 03:37:12
      It's, to my knowledge, the first time that we have a real-time application in people's cars using our data portal to improve traffic flow and to improve their mobility through the corridor.
    • 03:37:23
      It's a huge deal.
    • 03:37:24
      and I think we're going to see a lot follow them and there's going to be a lot more of this but it's facilitated by not only the implementation of these SMART controls but by the availability of that information in our data portal.
    • 03:37:35
      So my compliments to all who have been part of that.
    • 03:37:39
      I know there's been a lot of hard work.
    • 03:37:41
      It's a big day.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:37:42
      I don't know if Murali and Hari are still here, but they certainly played an important role.
    • 03:37:48
      And whereas other states are doing it kind of signal by signal, we're able to, how many in Northern Virginia?
    • 03:37:53
      Over 1,400.
    • 03:37:54
      Signals at one time that we're able to
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 03:37:57
      To date they're VDOT signals, but we certainly would extend the opportunity to our local partners to help them make that go region-wide.
    • 03:38:16
      It's interesting to note that there are approximately 4,000 signals connected to Audi's system right now and 1,400 of them are ours, so that's a significant contribution.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:38:27
      Is there anything, Mr. DeTuncq or Mr. Yates, you'd like to add to the discussion from today?
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:38:34
      Scott did a great presentation and really tickly did it and I think it's great to let the whole CTB know what's going on with the white paper report and there's some technology, as he mentioned, that's so far out that we can't spend a lot of time on it, but there's some that we should.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:38:50
      Mr. Johnson?
    • 03:38:51
      Scott, if you would, how about thinking about coming to the rail committee and giving your presentation on Hyperloop?
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:38:57
      I'd be glad to do that.
    • 03:38:59
      I'd have to miss a technology committee.
    • 03:39:04
      That's a good idea, actually, because the technology aspect of rail is something we haven't spent a lot of time on.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:39:09
      Billy, last thing before you step down.
    • 03:39:11
      The four buckets now that you're kind of covering, just to make sure the board is understanding where your priorities are.
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 03:39:17
      Yes.
    • 03:39:17
      So there are four priorities for the Office of Innovation.
    • 03:39:22
      And I will tell you that I have reconfigured the project discussion from last month to really reflect those buckets so that we can talk about the program as opposed to individual projects.
    • 03:39:32
      But the four buckets are data and analytics, obviously a key one for us as we move forward.
    • 03:39:39
      Connectivity, both for VDOT to operate more effectively, but also to contribute to the larger effort to bring connectivity to all parts of Virginia, VDOT.
    • 03:39:51
      in particular has considerable resources that we can bring to bear on that effort and we want to make sure that we're doing that as well as we can.
    • 03:40:03
      The third one is Automated Virginia.
    • 03:40:05
      So we've talked a lot about automated vehicles and we'll continue to do that but it also includes the UAS that I spoke with you about a number of months ago and the shared use mobility piece.
    • 03:40:15
      Those all sort of play together and electrification comes in there too so that goes on the list.
    • 03:40:21
      And then the fourth bucket is cybersecurity, which really underpins everything we're doing because if we don't have a secure system, if our technology is not robust enough to ensure that it can't be corrupted, then the rest of it falls apart.
    • 03:40:40
      So that is sort of the underpinning to the other three buckets.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:46
      Okay, thank you.
    • 03:40:48
      Thank you.
    • 03:40:49
      Mr. Williams, we have an update on your subcommittee?
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:54
      On the Underground Utility Committee, the big issue we face is the coordination of underground utilities on construction projects.
    • 03:41:04
      The utilities and the contractors all agree that when VDOT does a design, bid, build, they take care of the utilities ahead of time and the utility companies in concert would all agree
    • 03:41:18
      That is a very good process and works extremely well with VDOT.
    • 03:41:22
      Design build, not so much.
    • 03:41:25
      The responsibility for the utility relocation is with the contractor.
    • 03:41:32
      Or locally administered projects, the same problem.
    • 03:41:36
      It just comes up again and again and again.
    • 03:41:38
      And often time you have three losers in the process.
    • 03:41:41
      So what we've tried to do is come up with the best management practices to bring back to the board for a policy decision that takes what's working currently.
    • 03:41:52
      What VDOT is doing right now, if they're ahead of the project and the design bid bill, everyone agrees it works very well.
    • 03:41:59
      So we're updating that manual.
    • 03:42:01
      Some of the things we're considering is additional training by VDOT to train the local government people in managing underground utilities, managing projects that include them, coordinating the utilities, locating them properly on the project.
    • 03:42:21
      also with the design builder having a consistent if the design builder follows the guidelines have a consistent process that works in all the other phases so everybody's going to be a winner currently sometimes the situation is everyone is a loser nobody it's never a winner and a loser in the same project so we're trying to fix it and I think what what we really need to do is come back
    • 03:42:46
      in March if it's the Secretary's pleasure to give a little more detailed report with some written information so everyone else can digest it and then we should be able to come back in April with a full report.
    • 03:42:59
      So a report for consideration to adopt as a policy and I know Steve stays close to it because he's the Commissioner because his folks are involved very much with the with the ongoing so hopefully they would be prepared to accept
    • 03:43:15
      whatever responsibility for them comes out of this so we'll come back to it but more importantly than that or more importantly than the three and a half billion dollars that we just agreed to spend on the bridge tunnel you know I've been chairing this commission for about six months and I noticed that Mr. Whitworth doesn't chair any and he's not currently here he's been
    • 03:43:36
      W. Whitworth Jr.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:06
      That's right.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:09
      That's exactly right.
    • 03:44:10
      You always get an assignment when you're not here.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:17
      Two of his former colleagues sort of got his back here, Mr. Tonk and myself, because he has some yardie over you.
    • 03:44:25
      We have his back, Mr. Whitworth.
    • 03:44:27
      So Marty, not happening.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:34
      We do hope Mr. Whitworth is enjoying the sunny warmth of Florida.
    • 03:44:50
      Yeah, exactly.
    • 03:44:52
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:44:54
      Who knew that we were actually going to get work, that this was going to produce results for us?
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:59
      That's going to be great.
    • 03:45:02
      It's going to make a good difference.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:05
      That's really great.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:05
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:45:07
      We're just going to take really the best practices that VDOT already uses and just implement that throughout the industry.
    • 03:45:13
      It's going to be better for everybody.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:15
      Excellent.
    • 03:45:16
      Okay, Director Mitchell?
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:20
      We did announce this morning again or just as a reminder that we're going to be starting the second train to Norfolk on March 4th.
    • 03:45:27
      We're very excited about that.
    • 03:45:28
      There will be an event there in the morning.
    • 03:45:31
      The train will be leaving at 9 a.m.
    • 03:45:34
      This will be a new departure time for Norfolk.
    • 03:45:38
      It does also change the departure time for the Newport News train as well and adds an earlier train for them.
    • 03:45:45
      We shifted around some of the
    • 03:45:48
      We also updated the board on the fact that on March 13th we'll be having an open house for our new Northern Virginia office for DRPT.
    • 03:46:08
      We've actually been in it for a few weeks but I'm really excited because it's
    • 03:46:12
      Thank you.
    • 03:46:29
      Update on where we are with our grant application cycle, which closed on February 1st.
    • 03:46:35
      We're in the process of reviewing applications.
    • 03:46:37
      We received 215 applications for funding in our transit program under different, all of our different programs.
    • 03:46:45
      That does include four major expansion projects as well.
    • 03:46:49
      This is the first year that we will be using the new prioritization process for our capital applications and so we're in the process of going through all of that right now and we expect we'll be bringing back more information to the rail committee in the March meeting as well.
    • 03:47:07
      On the rail side, we also got 17 applications for funding.
    • 03:47:11
      That includes two for our inner city passenger rail, one for our REF program, 14 for our preservation program.
    • 03:47:18
      This year, the focus of our six-year plan update, though, will also be incorporating funding for Longbridge and the Atlantic Gateway Program, too.
    • 03:47:26
      So again, more information to follow on that as our applications get reviewed and scored.
    • 03:47:35
      I did want to just give you all an update on our AMTAC ridership as well.
    • 03:47:40
      We saw some slight declines in December and January which we actually attribute primarily to the government shutdown which really affected a lot of contractors and workers in this area.
    • 03:47:53
      We saw a decline of about 1.7% in December and another 1.4% in January.
    • 03:48:00
      I should note though as well that that includes riders that
    • 03:48:04
      We have what's called VRE step-up tickets, where VRE riders can actually buy an Amtrak ticket, and they're counted as an Amtrak rider for that, and it's at a subsidized price.
    • 03:48:17
      VRE saw a significant decline in ridership in January of, I think, almost 25%.
    • 03:48:21
      So we believe that was factored into it as well.
    • 03:48:24
      But as we get more information about that, we'll certainly let you know.
    • 03:48:27
      The good news is we're still up about 2.3% in ridership for the year to date.
    • 03:48:34
      And with that, that's the end of my update.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:48:37
      Ms. Mitchell, there have been a lot of back and forth about the Metro budget and I'm just wondering if you have any comments on that.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:48:46
      Sure.
    • 03:48:47
      We and our board members, Christian Dorsey and Paul Smedberg have both been very sort of strong and forceful in their statements that we have a lot of concerns about proposals to bring back late night service on Metro because that really cuts into the maintenance window that WMATA has where they really get to do a substantial amount of their track work.
    • 03:49:08
      And really that's very, very important especially with the new funding that we just approved that WMATA be able to have the time and the resources to actually do the rehabilitation work that we need.
    • 03:49:19
      So we're very concerned about that.
    • 03:49:24
      FTA has come out and said that because of this change and because this could have a safety impact on WMATA that they could end up delaying certification of the Metro Safety Commission, which as you know for the federal deadline for that is April 15th of this year.
    • 03:49:44
      MSC is still in a good position to be certified, but we are concerned about that.
    • 03:49:49
      It would create a withholding of 100% of our federal funds, all of our federal funds for transit in Virginia.
    • 03:49:58
      So that would affect all 40 of our transit agencies and
    • 03:50:01
      and 60 human service operators.
    • 03:50:03
      It also would include, the total amount of funding that would be withheld from the region would actually be about 1.6 billion.
    • 03:50:10
      That also includes the formula funding that WMATA gets plus money that FTA had committed for the Purple Line in Maryland.
    • 03:50:17
      And so that's been a significant concern of ours too.
    • 03:50:22
      But we're continuing to monitor that and our board members are working closely with the DC board members and Maryland and federal members as well to resolve that.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:31
      Anything else, Mr. Johnson or Mr. Smoot, from the committee meeting this morning?
    • 03:50:37
      Okay, Commissioner.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:40
      I just have two quick updates for you.
    • 03:50:42
      Obviously, since we met last, we did have a very large announcement for folks up in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:50:48
      About a billion dollars of added work along 495 and 95.
    • 03:50:52
      The extension of two and a half mile extension of the 495 express lanes leading up to the American Legion Bridge.
    • 03:51:00
      New Ramp at the Opitz Boulevard as well as the Occoquan Auxiliary Lane all of which we announced about two weeks ago which we had out there and so we've been certainly busy between 495 and 95 and now 64 in the HRBT expansion project so we've a lot of announcements within the last 30 days so very positive work.
    • 03:51:27
      On a flip side, certainly the weather forecast coming in, just making aware, last October, November timeframe, I briefed the board just very quickly about all the tropical storms and the rainfall events that we've had.
    • 03:51:46
      It's been an extraordinary year.
    • 03:51:48
      We're monitoring our highway maintenance and operations program fund very closely right now.
    • 03:51:54
      Going into this storm, we have about $55 million left out of the original budget.
    • 03:52:02
      Looking at this storm and the mobilization that we have,
    • 03:52:07
      In Northern Virginia alone, 3,000 pieces of equipment is going to be about a million dollars an hour that we're going to spend in snowfall.
    • 03:52:16
      So with this type of mobilization on a statewide basis, we are currently, as of today, projecting that we're going to come in slightly under our budget threshold, but we are monitoring our program very closely.
    • 03:52:30
      And there's going to be about a four to six week lag in when those expenditures hit.
    • 03:52:35
      So we may be back in the April timeframe taking a very close look at what our planned activities are for the remainder of this year and leading into next year and maybe asking for a loan to be able to bridge a gap going from this fiscal year to next fiscal year.
    • 03:52:52
      But we are very, very close in where our budgets are.
    • 03:52:56
      And it's been, again, it's been an extraordinary year of weather events for us.
    • 03:53:01
      We're still in the recovery mode.
    • 03:53:02
      Certainly down in the Lynchburg District still have a significant number of roadways closed because of the rain and the tropical storm events that we've had.
    • 03:53:13
      As of right now I'm going to say that our projections are that we're going to come in at or underneath our budget but again with the uncertainty of tonight's storm coming in we are going to spend money unfortunately recognizing that the temperatures are going to be back up in the 50s and 60s with the rain by the end of the weekend so
    • 03:53:35
      We will mobilize.
    • 03:53:36
      We will have crews out there.
    • 03:53:38
      We're prepared to tackle the storm and reopen the roads as soon as possible.
    • 03:53:43
      But we will look to demobilize as soon as possible just to be able to save the money.
    • 03:53:49
      But the movement of goods and services are going to be the paramount issue.
    • 03:53:53
      But I just, again, want to make sure that depending on what happens, we may be back in front of you saying what services we may need to reduce just to be able to make budget this year.
    • 03:54:05
      I just want transparency and bring it to you at an early stage.
    • 03:54:12
      One more big event and we're done.
    • 03:54:16
      We've been done before but in this case we're monitoring very closely and we do have a little bit of cushion but we can't have many more of these.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:31
      Secretary, unfortunately he can't dictate whether we're going to have another one or not.
    • 03:54:36
      But we have been through this before and we'll get through this one just as well.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:44
      Well, people ask me if I get nervous when we get bad weather.
    • 03:54:50
      I just didn't want it to snow for four years.
    • 03:54:52
      I do love snow, but we could just have a little reprieve.
    • 03:54:56
      But I will be honest with you that those who actually manage all of this under the leadership of the Commissioner and our Situation Room, I really do not.
    • 03:55:06
      It is pretty amazing.
    • 03:55:08
      I feel as though I have such confidence in their abilities to manage this.
    • 03:55:14
      We just need to make sure we address everything on over on 81, Mr. Smoot.
    • 03:55:19
      And so a lot of these improvements could help over there during bad weather as well.
    • 03:55:25
      Thank you for bringing up the announcements for Northern Virginia.
    • 03:55:29
      It's bringing in a billion new dollars of investment in Northern Virginia with four major projects, including Aquapon,
    • 03:55:37
      which we're actually going to pay for from the savings that we are able to get from the really competitive design bill price as well as negotiating the TIFIA loan savings that I will give a lot of credit to Morteza Farajan for helping us manage that.
    • 03:55:55
      But Transurban's been a great partner through this, so they'll be really great work.
    • 03:56:02
      And then almost a year's worth of work in just getting the announcement for Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
    • 03:56:08
      And as we do that, 3,700 other projects taking place in Virginia.
    • 03:56:12
      So there's a tremendous amount going on.
    • 03:56:15
      I will just close by giving a great thanks that during the government shutdown, how many of our folks
    • 03:56:23
      Here in transportation really rally to try to be as supportive as possible whether it was front loading transit agencies looking for ways to
    • 03:56:34
      We never ended up having to do this, but we were trying to find ways to help people with easy passes, making sure we weren't sending bills or charging late fees if people were not able to replenish their easy passes, and looking at Metro, what we could do with Maryland DC for people to move through the corridor.
    • 03:56:54
      I think if anything like that were to happen again, we would be ready from the first hour, but everybody really came together to try to do what they could for our neighbors to make sure people can manage the shutdown.
    • 03:57:08
      And so with that, I know this is a bit of a shorter meeting for us, only because, well, for several reasons, but the most important being the fact that we're still working with the General Assembly.
    • 03:57:20
      So do you mind telling the logistics for this?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:57:23
      evening okay our dinner this evening it's going to be hotels at six o'clock we're at Terrence West which is one one one time we talked in Richmond we are going to have a show at the hotel at 5 40 we're going to have an additional show at 5 30
    • 03:57:44
      at First National.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:46
      So we just pick it up at 5.30?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:57:50
      I must know really important people, that's what I would say.
    • 03:57:57
      And then our meeting tomorrow begins at 9 o'clock.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:00
      Now for those of you, is Rick Walton still here?
    • 03:58:04
      Right now the way our policies are, for those who are going home this evening, how many of you, do you mind just raising your hand if you're staying?
    • 03:58:14
      I tricked you, yeah.
    • 03:58:16
      So we're staying, so okay.
    • 03:58:18
      And you're here, right?
    • 03:58:20
      So we will definitely have a plan, but people can listen in, but they can't vote, is that right, Mr. Walton?
    • 03:58:25
      Correct.
    • 03:58:25
      Can we ever create a policy where they could?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 03:58:28
      There is a mechanism to do that, but again, the reasons for being able to do it electronically, there's the simple one, technically, Mr. Stinson.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:40
      I'm gonna see, we are having a hard time hearing you right now.
    • 03:58:44
      because I know so many people have said, boy, it would be really great if we could have this policy.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 03:58:52
      Madam Secretary, there are two situations.
    • 03:58:54
      The one we've already done, we did when we met in Winchester with Mr. Stinson where you give advance notice or certain requirements and you can do that.
    • 03:59:06
      I think you're limited on the number of those you can do and you have to do certain after the fact reporting.
    • 03:59:12
      The other provision which allows a member due to sickness, disability, emergency to call the chair even a day ahead of time to say I cannot make it, I'd like to participate electronically, that requires a written policy to be adopted that addresses those situations.
    • 03:59:33
      So I mean if the board desires or you desire we can come up with a draft written policy for that situation and then on others like with Mr. Whitworth if he wanted to and we knew in advance we could have sent out the requirements of the statute that he could have participated electronically on the meeting tomorrow.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:56
      But I do wonder this, there are people here at this board meeting who actually work to get here but are actually going home because of bad weather.
    • 04:00:04
      So I wonder if that can be addressed in the policy.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:00:07
      The way the law reads for, normally it's a three day, three business day notice of any electronic meeting and things of that nature.
    • 04:00:16
      You can have
    • 04:00:17
      Special, emergency, and continued meetings where you give notice to the public at the same time you notice the members of the board.
    • 04:00:27
      That is, we've used that in the past where the boards had to meet to award a particular contract between meetings.
    • 04:00:35
      It's really a situation where nothing is scheduled.
    • 04:00:39
      But you have to call a special or emergency meeting to address an immediate situation.
    • 04:00:43
      In that particular situation, you can do it electronically.
    • 04:00:47
      You can do it in person.
    • 04:00:49
      Again, the code has various requirements depending on which electronic meeting concept you're going to operate under.
    • 04:00:56
      Some of them require that a quorum of the board be physically present in one location.
    • 04:01:02
      Others do not.
    • 04:01:03
      So it will depend on the circumstances.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:06
      Well, perhaps you could draft something for the board to take a look at.
    • 04:01:11
      And if, in the future, if we needed to address the code and put in legislation to modify it to fit some real-world examples, that might also be helpful.
    • 04:01:22
      OK. OK.
    • 04:01:23
      So with that, we're going to adjourn the workshop.
    • 04:01:27
      And I will see most of you tomorrow.
    • 04:01:29
      And for those who are leaving, please be safe.
    • 04:01:32
      Thank you.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:33
      Thank you.