Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 12/4/2018
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   12/4/2018

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • 2018 Report on the Performance and Condition of the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority.pdf
  • I-95 Express Lanes Fredericksburg Extension.pdf
  • I-81 Corridor Improvement.pdf
  • SMART SCALE Update.pdf
  • Transit Funding and Reforms.pdf
  • Vital Infrastructure Report Overview.pdf
  • 1. WMATA's annual capital budget;

  • 2. WMATA's annual independent financial audit;

    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:05:48
      Thank you very much.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:07
      Now I don't know what to do.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:08
      It's not big enough for all the microphones.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:14
      Good morning.
    • 00:06:17
      Gosh, this is great.
    • 00:06:19
      And I do want you to know our CTB meetings always look like this.
    • 00:06:23
      Yes.
    • 00:06:25
      Good morning.
    • 00:06:26
      I am Shannon Valentine.
    • 00:06:27
      I'm Secretary of Transportation here in the Commonwealth.
    • 00:06:31
      Welcome to a special session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:06:35
      I am joined this morning by a very dear friend we've been commiserating.
    • 00:06:41
      We shared time together in the Virginia House of Delegates.
    • 00:06:45
      And Brian Moran is now Secretary of Public Safety and Homeland Security for Virginia.
    • 00:06:50
      And so we are very proud to be here today at this meeting.
    • 00:06:54
      I really can't think of a better place to make this announcement than at a CTB board meeting.
    • 00:07:01
      The Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:03
      has been sincerely committed to safety and reliability across our transportation platform.
    • 00:07:09
      And so this to me is the right place to do this.
    • 00:07:13
      Today, Secretary Moran and I are very honored to make this announcement.
    • 00:07:18
      It is to announce Governor Northam's executive directive formalizing the governor's executive leadership team on highway safety.
    • 00:07:29
      This executive leadership team, the first of its kind in the country, is to, in the governor's words, to proactively drive a positive traffic safety culture in Virginia.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:45
      The Governor has tasked us with a vital mission, reducing highway deaths to zero in our Commonwealth.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:53
      And as a part of this, kicking off today, the inaugural Your Stay VA Digital Town Hall, an open forum to gather citizens' inputs on distracted driving, a growing and tragic epidemic that Governor Northam is committed to addressing as we promote safety and well-being of all Virginians.
    • 00:08:15
      He is the first governor to designate, as you all remember, April as full month to highway safety.
    • 00:08:21
      This year, he signed legislation to expand the parent driver education requirement, which includes education on the dangers of impaired driving.
    • 00:08:29
      In September, I was there with him to announce DADS, and I know Commissioner Holcomb's here.
    • 00:08:34
      It was very exciting.
    • 00:08:36
      The Driver Alcohol Detection System for Safety, DADS, which detects blood alcohol content before a vehicle will start.
    • 00:08:45
      Virginia is the first state in the United States to take this technology out of the laboratory and into the real world for testing.
    • 00:08:53
      And just last week, Governor Northam announced the Commonwealth's new Highway Safety Web Portal towards Zero Desk Virginia, TZDVA.
    • 00:09:04
      All of these initiatives could not come at a more important time.
    • 00:09:08
      In 2017, there were 15,000 injuries and 843
    • 00:09:13
      Fatalities on Virginia's Roadways, representing a 20% increase in fatalities over just the three years prior.
    • 00:09:21
      Of those fatalities, 208 are attributed to distracted driving.
    • 00:09:27
      Through Thanksgiving of this year, there have already been 738 traffic fatalities recorded, and of those, 118 attributed to distracted driving.
    • 00:09:38
      The critical point
    • 00:09:39
      is that these injuries and fatalities, the devastating loss of life, the terrible loss to our communities, the irreparable loss to families are all entirely and completely preventable, which is why today and this work is just so important.
    • 00:09:59
      I'm going to ask Secretary Moran to come and give the perspective from the state police and public safety on what is truly a growing epidemic in Virginia.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:10:15
      I don't know if you want to say our time in the legislature.
    • 00:10:19
      We were commiserating.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:10:20
      Wasn't it fun?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:10:23
      It was fun to be in the legislature, right, Senator Williams?
    • 00:10:26
      Well, thrilled to be here.
    • 00:10:27
      Good morning.
    • 00:10:28
      Good morning.
    • 00:10:29
      It is wonderful to be with Secretary Valentine and all of the agency heads who are well represented here today, traffic safety advocates, and of course, CTB.
    • 00:10:39
      And before I go on, I just want to say thank you to CTB.
    • 00:10:43
      You know, I travel
    • 00:10:45
      The Roads of the Commonwealth with great frequency.
    • 00:10:48
      I'll be heading off to Harrisonburg this afternoon and often in Hampton Roads and of course Northern Virginia.
    • 00:10:54
      I'll be up there Thursday and Friday.
    • 00:10:56
      So I just want to say thank you.
    • 00:10:58
      There's a lot of construction going on and the decisions you make.
    • 00:11:02
      I'm surprised.
    • 00:11:04
      You've got a big crowd here today.
    • 00:11:06
      There must be a heck of an agenda.
    • 00:11:10
      Well, we'll let you get to all that, but I do want to just say thank you to all of you for the work you do.
    • 00:11:16
      It's an important position and so a lot of exciting things going on in the Commonwealth.
    • 00:11:21
      We've had
    • 00:11:22
      Jr., John C. Brich, John C. Brich, John C. Brich, John
    • 00:11:42
      Wonderful things going on in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 00:11:45
      And then we're saddled with these issues with respect to the deaths, preventable deaths as Secretary Valentine has said.
    • 00:11:53
      And why we are here today is to announce a very collaborative effort.
    • 00:11:59
      with our Secretary of Education, Atif Carney is here, Secretary Kerry, Health and Human Resources, represented with the Department of Health will be working on this endeavor.
    • 00:12:09
      It's a collaborative effort, a collective effort of all the state agencies to bring our experience, our abilities, and commitment to reducing, if not eliminating, traffic deaths in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 00:12:25
      too many, as secretary mentioned 738 up to today, that's more than two, just over two per day.
    • 00:12:33
      That's just unacceptable.
    • 00:12:36
      So we have to find
    • 00:12:37
      Many of the root causes and eliminate these deaths and injuries.
    • 00:12:45
      Much of it is through education.
    • 00:12:47
      A wonderful education campaign is a joint effort led by the Secretary and DMV.
    • 00:12:53
      That was a lot of exciting things.
    • 00:12:55
      Design and engineering.
    • 00:12:57
      has to go into this as well, much of what you know and are doing here at CTB.
    • 00:13:01
      And then of course, enforcement.
    • 00:13:02
      And we want to recognize Superintendent of the State Police, Colonel Gary Settle and his team, enforcement, making sure the roadways are safe.
    • 00:13:10
      And I have to mention, you know, we have a move over law in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 00:13:16
      Through education and enforcement, the traveling public of the Commonwealth need to know they must move over when first responders and police and others are responding to a traffic accident.
    • 00:13:30
      And we just have too many instances where
    • 00:13:34
      There were accidents on the road and we recently had a first responder die in nearby Hanover County in a very, very sad tragedy.
    • 00:13:43
      So, again, that's an education campaign along with enforcement.
    • 00:13:48
      And as we talk about traffic deaths, we have to mention distracted driving.
    • 00:13:52
      And this is one of those things where it's frustrating.
    • 00:13:56
      We have wonderful technology.
    • 00:13:58
      And I will say Senator Williams was Chair of Transportation, Secretary Valentine, Delegate Valentine at that time, and I served on the Transportation Committee for 13 years.
    • 00:14:09
      We actually have some very good laws in the Commonwealth of Virginia around enforcement.
    • 00:14:13
      As a father of an 18-year-old and a 16-year-old, I know all too well about teenage driving and the risks involved.
    • 00:14:21
      But our laws dictate parental involvement.
    • 00:14:24
      They require or prohibit so many kids in a vehicle at any particular time, whether it's a school event and others.
    • 00:14:32
      I mean, we really have legislated particularly well around these issues.
    • 00:14:37
      But like all of our laws, we have difficulty keeping up with technology.
    • 00:14:42
      Technology far outpaces our ability to legislate, and that certainly is the case around our electronic equipment in our vehicles.
    • 00:14:50
      Again, as a father of a 16, 18-year-old, they've become appendages.
    • 00:14:56
      That phone is constantly in their hand, and we need to figure out a way, and I know we're capable of it, to put that phone down.
    • 00:15:06
      You're driving a multi-ton vehicle,
    • 00:15:10
      You have to put those electronics down.
    • 00:15:12
      We have to incorporate technology so that they don't have to hand-hold the technology, whether it's in the dashboard or other abilities within the vehicle.
    • 00:15:20
      So I know we're capable of that, and that's why we're coming together today.
    • 00:15:25
      We're putting the whole force of state government behind this effort, along with our non-governmental agencies or organizations.
    • 00:15:36
      I know you've done a lot of wonderful work in the private sector.
    • 00:15:38
      and our advocacy groups around traffic safety.
    • 00:15:41
      So together we're going to accomplish this.
    • 00:15:44
      It's doable and with collective spirit and will, we will get it done.
    • 00:15:49
      So it's wonderful to be with Secretary Valentine for this exciting announcement and let's get it done.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:03
      And the greatest way I think that we can honor those who have died and actually pay a tribute to them
    • 00:16:08
      is to rewrite their story, to reverse the trends, to lower the numbers, and to accept nothing less than zero, which is exactly what the Governor's Executive Directive that we are announcing today is intended to do.
    • 00:16:24
      There are so many partners, as Secretary Moran mentioned, some who are here today, partners and leaders across the Commonwealth, Commissioner Rick Holcomb,
    • 00:16:34
      And DNV actually led a distracted driver license plate competition here.
    • 00:16:40
      I will share with you that the winners came to the Capitol a few months ago.
    • 00:16:44
      It was during, was it April?
    • 00:16:47
      They came, they had the winners from all nine districts.
    • 00:16:51
      And the governor asked the group of students, you know, tell me what, tell me some of the things that you're seeing out there.
    • 00:16:57
      when we discussed distracted driving.
    • 00:16:59
      And one of the students actually raised her hand and said that on her way to the Capitol she saw someone brushing their teeth, which he did admit was the first of its kind.
    • 00:17:11
      Beyond Rick Holcomb, we have Secretary of Education out of Kearney.
    • 00:17:17
      Thank you so much for being here.
    • 00:17:18
      Secretary Dan Carey has been very instrumental in this as well.
    • 00:17:23
      Jessie Young,
    • 00:17:25
      Virginia Division Administrator, I saw you earlier, Jesse.
    • 00:17:28
      Thank you for Federal Highways.
    • 00:17:30
      Dale Bennett from the Virginia Trucking Association, there you are.
    • 00:17:35
      Dale, thank you so much for coming.
    • 00:17:38
      We have Carol Brooking from Drive Smart Virginia, Martha Mead from AAA, and probably many other partners, and forgive me if I've missed you, but we all know how just important all of this
    • 00:17:51
      I would also like to announce those who are part of this executive leadership team.
    • 00:17:57
      We have Secretary Moran and myself, Deputy Secretary of Public Safety and Homeland Security, Ryan Washington.
    • 00:18:06
      Ryan has been a tremendous leader in getting us all organized and really kind of setting direction for this, so thank you very much.
    • 00:18:14
      Virginia Deputy Commissioner Rob Carey,
    • 00:18:17
      I know he's here.
    • 00:18:18
      Thank you, Rob, for all that you do, and particularly in this region.
    • 00:18:22
      Commissioner George Bennett, who's presented to the CTB.
    • 00:18:26
      We have Jeff Stover from the Department of Health Operations.
    • 00:18:29
      Lieutenant Tracy Rocio.
    • 00:18:31
      I know you have been very instrumental as part of this team.
    • 00:18:35
      Our own Marshall Herman, special assistant.
    • 00:18:39
      And all the representatives from DMV, VDOT, Virginia State Police, Department of Health, and Education who have helped make this possible.
    • 00:18:47
      I would like to give a special recognition to former Deputy Secretary Quinton Elliott, our own tin man, who I'm not sure he's in the room.
    • 00:18:56
      We tried.
    • 00:18:57
      He may be listening, as the CTB will know, but certainly we would not be here today without him.
    • 00:19:04
      And now, as I prepare to lead a board meeting with the CTB, I'm going to turn this over to Marshall Herman, our special assistant, who has from our office been the linchpin in getting this done.
    • 00:19:17
      to let you know what else is taking place today.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 00:19:27
      Thank you Secretary Valentine and everyone here today we really appreciate your support
    • 00:19:33
      in this initiative.
    • 00:19:34
      And as we close things down, any members of the media will be taken back to show demonstrations of the surveys.
    • 00:19:42
      But this is just a reminder that one way we can all take part in this, and everyone in this room, anyone listening today, you can take part by visiting the Commonwealth's new portal for highway safety.
    • 00:19:54
      information, that's tzdva.org and you can participate in the Your Say VA Digital Town Hall.
    • 00:20:03
      Thank you all again for coming today.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:12
      Thank you all so much.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:20:15
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:26:18
      Morning.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:44
      Morning.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:45
      So thank you all for being here.
    • 00:26:47
      And as we start all of our meetings, will you please join me in saying the Pledge of Allegiance?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:52
      I pledge an order.
    • 00:26:55
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:21
      We have a very busy agenda.
    • 00:27:23
      And so it's been a somewhat lively morning with our subcommittee meetings and the announcement on the executive directive.
    • 00:27:31
      And so we're just going to go straight to business.
    • 00:27:33
      And we have Kate Mattice here from NVTC.
    • 00:27:39
      Good morning.
    • Kate MatticeExecutive Director
    • 00:27:40
      Good morning.
    • 00:27:42
      It's always fun to start after a celebration.
    • 00:27:44
      So good morning, Madam Chair, members of the board.
    • 00:27:48
      My name is Kate Mattice, and I'm with the Northern Virginia Transportation Commission.
    • 00:27:53
      And I'm here this morning to present the first annual report on WMATA that's required by the new dedicated funding that passed earlier this year.
    • 00:28:04
      Fantastic.
    • 00:28:05
      Just a little bit high-level background about NVTC.
    • 00:28:09
      We actually have an over 50-year history, and it really is rooted in the Washington metropolitan metro rail system.
    • 00:28:15
      In addition, though, we do manage state and regional funding sources on behalf of our local jurisdictions up in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:28:23
      We are the co-owner of the Virginia Railway Express commuter rail system.
    • 00:28:26
      You'll see me probably once or twice every year coming and talking about our Commuter Choice Program, which is using toll revenues to fund transit in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:28:36
      And then we also do a number of different areas of regional transit research and technical expertise for the transit providers in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:28:47
      The special relationship that NVTC has with WMATA is really based in the fact that the members of NVTC are the signatures of the WMATA Compact in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:28:57
      And what that really means is those localities have a responsibility, both as we represent and provide representation on the WMATA Board, but it really comes down to the funding
    • 00:29:08
      Our Northern Virginia jurisdictions that make up NVTC are, within Virginia, the responsible parties for meeting the funding obligation for WMATA, which means if any other funding falls short, whether it be at the state level or region or what have you, it's the localities that are responsible for meeting the funding commitments of WMATA.
    • 00:29:27
      So these localities take this responsibility very seriously and a big part of the venue within NVTC and the work that we do is really making sure that we understand and represent those jurisdictions that are ultimately paying the bill for WMATA in Virginia.
    • 00:29:43
      So a little bit about this report, and it's actually sitting at your desk at your place at the table.
    • 00:29:48
      This is actually the first annual report that's required of NVTC in the HB 1539 legislation that passed this year.
    • 00:29:56
      Just as a reminder, a little bit I think in the summer into the fall, this body did take action on some provisions that would lead to the withholding of state funding for WMATA.
    • 00:30:09
      So obviously we've got this coming from a bunch of different places both here at the Commonwealth Transportation Board but also with NVTC.
    • 00:30:18
      Spelled out in the legislation are a number of different responsibilities of NVTC, one of which is that we at NVTC are to report
    • 00:30:25
      on the performance and condition of WMATA every year to the Governor and the General Assembly, as well as we are supposed to be making sure that WMATA reports on a number of different elements, sending us certain things that must be certified for the receipt of those funds.
    • 00:30:41
      So this report is representing that first annual report on performance and condition.
    • 00:30:49
      According to the statute, there's a number of different elements that are in here.
    • 00:30:52
      A number of these are really about starting a benchmark of sort of a baseline, I should say, of benchmarking data moving forward.
    • 00:31:02
      So there is a need and what's included in this report is data on safety and reliability, on financial performance of both the rail and bus, as well as the use of the funds that are provided under the dedicated funding source and data for such things as ridership.
    • 00:31:17
      The report also though is an opportunity for NVTC to put out some markers of policy and priorities when it comes to controlling costs.
    • 00:31:26
      So really what this document is is both a data and a policy document from NVTC.
    • 00:31:33
      So again, a lot of data is included in the report.
    • 00:31:36
      I am not going to go through that.
    • 00:31:37
      But just to tell you a little bit about our methodology, the information that is included in the report was specifically chosen because it's data that is used from year to year.
    • 00:31:46
      It's auditable.
    • 00:31:47
      It's validated.
    • 00:31:48
      It's using methodologies that are used by transit agencies across the country.
    • 00:31:53
      And so that's the information.
    • 00:31:55
      I know we've had questions before.
    • 00:31:57
      Why aren't there certain different metrics that are included?
    • 00:31:59
      And the reality is because we want to be able to repeat these every year.
    • 00:32:03
      And we want to have a standard methodology.
    • 00:32:05
      And we also want to have the ability to say look at WMATA and perhaps look at other transit agencies and be able to use comparable data.
    • 00:32:11
      So that's just a little bit about that.
    • 00:32:13
      Again, the data that is in here is a first year.
    • 00:32:16
      The first year of this dedicated funding, it's the first year of the data.
    • 00:32:19
      Moving forward, we will be able to show trends.
    • 00:32:23
      As I mentioned, the other part of this document is really a policy piece for NVTC to articulate its concerns.
    • 00:32:30
      NVTC does have two members on the WMATA board representing Virginia.
    • 00:32:33
      One of them is a secretary's appointment or governor's appointment, I should say, and one's an appointment from NVTC.
    • 00:32:39
      Both of those board members of WMATA sit on NVTC and are active in the conversations.
    • 00:32:45
      For this first report, we identified a number of different strategies of things that the Commission, again, that Northern Virginia thought were very important, and so these are up here on your slide, but it really came down to looking at things about efficiency and cost controls, maximizing and optimizing revenues, and looking at creative ways to move forward
    • 00:33:05
      whether it be about use of contractors are also in the way they do performance for their own employees.
    • 00:33:11
      So we have a number of things again within the report and I ask you to take a look for any of those details.
    • 00:33:17
      One of the things moving forward is that we will be reporting on how the dedicated funding from WMATA that was included in this package is being used.
    • 00:33:25
      This is the very first report.
    • 00:33:27
      The funding is only just coming in, so that's silent.
    • 00:33:30
      But moving forward, we will be reporting on the use of that dedicated capital funding that was approved by the General Assembly earlier this year.
    • 00:33:39
      And then finally, again, this is one part of a number of different things that NVTC is doing.
    • 00:33:44
      Responsibility for WADA is definitely sitting within the board and within the jurisdictions.
    • 00:33:50
      And so we do, again, provide a lot of support to our board members.
    • 00:33:53
      We do on-board coordination across the six jurisdictions within NVTC.
    • 00:33:57
      We work with DRPT and actually DMV on the administration of regional gas taxes that are used for WMATA.
    • 00:34:06
      And then we were involved in a lot of the things on the budget and the budget development.
    • 00:34:10
      As I mentioned earlier this year, this body took up a policy position on potentially withholding funds
    • 00:34:16
      from WMATA if there were cost escalations from year to year.
    • 00:34:20
      We work very closely with DRBT as well as with WMATA on what that means as this next budget goes, is in the process of being developed right now.
    • 00:34:31
      And again, come this winter into spring, we'll be working on this next report for the next coming year.
    • 00:34:37
      So that's pretty much the teaser, and so I'm happy to answer any questions.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:43
      I'm secretary.
    • 00:34:45
      Kate, thanks very much.
    • 00:34:46
      I know how much work this is and I really just have one observation.
    • 00:34:51
      based partly on the fact that I served on the WMATA board at a time that there was a lot of scrutiny of the numbers.
    • 00:34:59
      And I'm remembering back to Secretary LaHood's report last year, which really tried to put WMATA into a national context so that people could understand it.
    • 00:35:09
      And that really is my observation on some of the costs that you're reporting on, which those are great.
    • 00:35:18
      It would be helpful, I think, in the future to sit them in the national context a little bit.
    • 00:35:23
      We don't have another rail system like this in Virginia.
    • 00:35:27
      And so people tend to lose sight of the fact that, well, sometimes the costs look high.
    • 00:35:35
      When you look at other transit agencies across the country that are at a similar level of activity, they're not high.
    • 00:35:43
      They're in the ballpark.
    • 00:35:45
      So I would just wonder, I know that's not required by the legislation but it is information that over time might really help people to not see it as a ready target for efficiency, efficiency, efficiency.
    • Kate MatticeExecutive Director
    • 00:35:59
      Absolutely.
    • 00:36:00
      And actually, I would point to the efforts that were done in support of the LaHood study.
    • 00:36:04
      There was a really comprehensive benchmarking of LaMotta against other rail systems.
    • 00:36:10
      So in some ways, that's a fantastic place to be looking for that going on.
    • 00:36:14
      We are going to explore how we're reporting the data moving forward on the annual basis.
    • 00:36:20
      And so thank you for that recommendation.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:24
      I will just say, Kate, this is an excellent overview.
    • 00:36:30
      It's kind of setting us up for a lot of information that's going to be coming in 2019.
    • 00:36:35
      I do want to say a special thank you to Jennifer Mitchell with DRPT and your organization for how well
    • 00:36:43
      We have worked on the reforms and the collaboration and all the reporting requirements.
    • 00:36:48
      I just have one question.
    • 00:36:49
      As the hard work begins, we begin actually investing these funds to bring the system up to state of good repair.
    • 00:36:57
      How are you coordinating with Metro as lines shut down and services interrupted?
    • Kate MatticeExecutive Director
    • 00:37:03
      Absolutely.
    • 00:37:04
      And so that actually is a line of work that we do at NVTC as a part of our responsibility in coordinating across the region.
    • 00:37:11
      We are actually active in working with all the local jurisdictions, transit agencies, as well as Metro, VDOT, and others on how to respond.
    • 00:37:20
      There are some major shutdowns that are going to be occurring this summer, specifically within sort of Springfield up to Alexandria and Arlington.
    • 00:37:29
      And those are active right now.
    • 00:37:31
      We've got a team of folks that are coming together
    • 00:37:33
      to identify different transportation solutions.
    • 00:37:37
      We actually did the same thing during previous shutdowns and so we've just continued that work.
    • 00:37:41
      So facilitating those conversations is a big part of the things that we do.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:47
      Just that we're working with NVTC as well as representatives from the local transit agencies up there.
    • 00:37:54
      WMATA has convened a group of people, but we also probably want to add some additional emphasis with the local transit systems up in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:38:03
      We have also announced and included funds in our six-year plan as well.
    • 00:38:07
      Okay, with that, thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:36
      OK, Marcy Parker.
    • 00:38:38
      Marcy, I feel like we've been spending a lot of time together lately.
    • 00:38:44
      We have, but it's been great.
    • 00:38:45
      Welcome to Richmond, again, again.
    • 00:38:47
      It's been great.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:38:48
      So good morning, Madam Secretary and members of the board.
    • 00:38:51
      I'm Marcy Parker.
    • 00:38:52
      I'm the Fredericksburg District Engineer, and I'm here to update you on the I-95 Express Lanes extension project.
    • 00:38:59
      And I do apologize.
    • 00:39:00
      My husband gave me his cold, so I'm trying to get over that.
    • 00:39:04
      So just to update you a little bit on the scope of the project, the project does extend the current express lanes about 10 miles south.
    • 00:39:11
      Right now it ends at exit 143 and it'll carry down to exit 133.
    • 00:39:15
      It will have a direct connection with the I-95 southbound Rappahannock River crossing project which is currently under construction.
    • 00:39:24
      and it will also have a direct connection to the northbound Rappahannock River crossing which will be a future project that will be advertised in 2019.
    • 00:39:33
      There will be three new access points to the project and they are circled on the map in front of you.
    • 00:39:39
      So we will have new access around exit 148 Russell Road.
    • 00:39:43
      That is so the employees of Quantico will be able to use it from the Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania area.
    • 00:39:49
      They'll be able to get off and on in the morning and evening.
    • 00:39:54
      At Exit 140, there will be a new access point.
    • 00:39:57
      We are currently putting in a diverging diamond at that interchange, and we're actually moving the interchange a wee bit south.
    • 00:40:04
      So the existing Route 630 will have our new park and ride lots on it, and there'll be a direct connection from the park and ride lots.
    • 00:40:11
      North facing only, so they'll be able to get on in the morning and get off in the afternoon will be the access there.
    • 00:40:18
      And then, of course, at the new southern terminus,
    • 00:40:21
      which will be Route 17 in Stafford County.
    • 00:40:23
      You'll be able to get off in the afternoon and get on in the morning.
    • 00:40:27
      So where are we with the project?
    • 00:40:30
      We started discussions about two years ago on this project and you can see the italicized parts are the parts that we are finished.
    • 00:40:37
      Currently we are in the design-build procurement in which Transurban is performing that.
    • 00:40:42
      Come winter, late winter, early spring will be a commercial close and then you can see financial close later, a few months later.
    • 00:40:50
      We will begin construction in the summer of 2019, and then service commencement, which means the lanes will be open to traffic, will be in the fall of 2022.
    • 00:40:59
      And that lines right up with both our northbound and our southbound river crossing projects.
    • 00:41:05
      The southbound river crossing project will be open in May of 2022, and then Fred X will open, and then the northbound river crossing project will be around December of 2023.
    • 00:41:16
      So not only am I here to give you a little update, but I'm also here to give you a little preview.
    • 00:41:21
      So in January, I'll be back.
    • 00:41:24
      And at that point in time, I'll be asking you to approve the HOV hot designation.
    • 00:41:29
      So that'll designate the express lanes as hot lanes.
    • 00:41:32
      It will also specify that the lanes will be HOV 3.
    • 00:41:36
      And it will authorize the commissioner to establish the conditions for the use of the express lanes in accordance with the comprehensive agreement.
    • 00:41:45
      I will also be asking for you to approve the tolling memorandum of understanding with FHWA.
    • 00:41:51
      It will eliminate or it will I guess cancel really the terminate the existing tolling MOU and it will establish a new one.
    • 00:42:00
      So we'll be asking you to approve it and also asking you to authorize the commissioner to execute that MOU with FHWA.
    • 00:42:09
      And with that, that is all I have, three little slides.
    • 00:42:12
      And if you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:15
      May I say how much you were extolled and applauded for being very efficient?
    • 00:42:23
      On my first time.
    • 00:42:24
      Yes, thank you.
    • 00:42:25
      So any questions or comments?
    • 00:42:29
      Commissioner?
    • 00:42:31
      All right, Ms. Parker, thank you so much.
    • 00:42:33
      All right, thank you very much.
    • 00:42:34
      Excellent.
    • 00:42:37
      Okay, Mr. Donohue, wouldn't be a meeting without you.
    • 00:42:41
      And you're looking incredibly rested, can I just say that?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:42:47
      Madam Chair, members of the board, Nick Donohue, I appreciate the opportunity to be with you this morning.
    • 00:42:52
      This is your, I believe, fifth update on the I-81 corridor plan here before you.
    • 00:42:58
      You do have an action item on your agenda for tomorrow.
    • 00:43:02
      I'm going to give you just a quick overview of what we've done on this plan and then some changes that were requested by some of your peers to the recommendations that were presented to you at your last meeting.
    • 00:43:13
      And again, there is an action item tomorrow for you all to approve or
    • 00:43:17
      Notte Jr.,
    • 00:43:35
      Interstate Truck Traffic we have unfortunately 45 crashes a year where people sit on the roadway for more than four hours waiting to move on and again to put that in perspective you've been here for an hour so four times longer no coffee no water no bathroom breaks you're sitting there on the roadway just really want to put a fine point on what that experience is like for people who unfortunately have it and there's also been 11,000 crashes almost over the last five years so again
    • 00:44:01
      A key corridor, there are definitely some needs for improvement and it really serves as kind of the backbone of the economy of Western Virginia.
    • 00:44:08
      And I think, so the legislature has asked us to study this.
    • 00:44:11
      They asked you all to develop potential recommendations.
    • 00:44:15
      They have asked you to specifically say which recommendations you believe are most critical and then to provide them with financing options that they can consider as to whether or not they would like to enact to move forward
    • 00:44:26
      to put in place the recommendations you have identified.
    • 00:44:29
      So again we've had discussions at past meetings and I want to be really clear.
    • 00:44:32
      You are not approving a financing option.
    • 00:44:35
      You are approving financing options for them to consider.
    • 00:44:38
      You are specifically though approving the recommendations that are included in the report.
    • 00:44:43
      81 is mostly a two-lane interstate through Virginia.
    • 00:44:47
      That does make it different than a lot of the main corridors that we talk about.
    • 00:44:51
      It also has some of the steepest grade and terrain of any of our interstates in the Commonwealth.
    • 00:44:55
      And when you combine that with the truck traffic that we have, that makes some of the issues with those truck volumes even more significant.
    • 00:45:02
      When you have those grades of over 3%, a truck can take up almost as much space as five passenger cars.
    • 00:45:08
      And so the
    • 00:45:10
      The effective amount of space you have in that roadway really is reduced when you have those steep hills and other conditions on the roadway.
    • 00:45:15
      81 is also different than many of our interstates because the majority of the delay that we see there is incident-related delay.
    • 00:45:24
      On most interstates, the delay we have, as I've talked about in the past, is recurring delay.
    • 00:45:28
      Every morning at 8 a.m., the road slows down.
    • 00:45:31
      That's inconvenient and at times very unpleasant, but it is predictable to a certain extent.
    • 00:45:37
      What you see on 81 more though is you are moving along helpfully at the speed limit and you round a corner and there's red brake lights at an unplanned location where the last Monday there was nothing.
    • 00:45:49
      And then the Monday after that there will be nothing in that same location but at random spots throughout the corridor we have significant issues there related to these incidents that cause people to experience a fair amount of delay on the 81 corridor.
    • 00:46:02
      I think the other key component about 81 and I think was a major driving factor in why the General Assembly asked this board to undertake this study is last fall there was a lot of discussion about whether 81 was getting its fair share relative to other interstates through the SMART SCALE process that this body has adopted.
    • 00:46:21
      At that time we did an in-depth review looking at the first two rounds of SMART SCALE as well as all capacity expansions funded on these roadways and what we saw is that under SMART SCALE
    • 00:46:32
      There are some differences between these corridors, but the reason you see 22 miles of orange cones on 64 and Hampton Roads is not because of SMART SCALE.
    • 00:46:40
      The reason 22 miles of 66 outside of the Beltway are being upgraded for $7 billion is not for SMART SCALE.
    • 00:46:46
      In fact, there's not a single dollar of SMART SCALE funding on 66, yet there's more work on I-66 than there is on any other interstate in the Commonwealth.
    • 00:46:56
      That will change in February when the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel procurement hopefully is approved.
    • 00:47:01
      But at this time, I-66 has the most work and it has no SMART SCALE funding on it.
    • 00:47:07
      What they do have though are dedicated regional taxes or tolls, and that is what is advancing the major corridor improvements that we see in Northern Virginia and in Hampton Roads.
    • 00:47:19
      And when we presented this information to the legislature, I believe a member actually of the House Appropriations Committee at that time said, I need to go back and start talking to my constituents about whether this is something they'd be interested in to move forward with to improve 81.
    • 00:47:32
      That was last October.
    • 00:47:34
      Here we are now the following December and we have a plan before you that talks about ways to establish a dedicated funding source for this corridor to move forward with the improvements.
    • 00:47:44
      So quick rehash, we've identified the top problem areas along 81 and presented that to the public in 12 different meetings.
    • 00:47:52
      We had almost 1,000 attendees at these meetings.
    • 00:47:55
      And again, just to put that in perspective, you've all been to your Six-Year Improvement Program hearings.
    • 00:48:00
      I consider a crowd of 40 or 50 to be good at many of those meetings.
    • 00:48:04
      At some of these meetings, we had 150 people show up.
    • 00:48:08
      And they didn't just show up to one meeting.
    • 00:48:09
      They showed up to all three of the meetings in their areas.
    • 00:48:11
      And so there's really a large amount of engagement from the public.
    • 00:48:15
      We had more than 2,000 public comments that we received.
    • 00:48:18
      And we've had five briefings before you all.
    • 00:48:20
      So again, we looked at the top problem areas related to the delay, person hours of delay on the corridor.
    • 00:48:27
      We looked at lane closures between incidents, which again, is really trying to get at that incident-related delay that takes place when there's a crash and the roadways close for a period of time.
    • 00:48:37
      We also looked at safety along the corridor, and we looked at safety both in the raw amount of crashes and the severity of those crashes, along with the rate
    • 00:48:47
      of those crashes trying to understand where we had more unsafe conditions relative to the amount of driving versus other areas.
    • 00:48:55
      Then for each of those areas, you know, we went back in and we developed key improvements that could try and address those.
    • 00:49:02
      But what we also did is we developed an operations plan because even with these capital improvements we know there are still going to be incidents along the 81 corridor and we want to make sure that while we are very confident we'll be reducing the number of incidents
    • 00:49:15
      They will still take place and when they happen we want to make sure the severity of those incidents and the impact on the traveling public is reduced.
    • 00:49:23
      And so the commissioner working with his team focused on the top problem areas along the corridor for where we have accidents resulting in lane closures and developed an operations plan that will help us identify when incidents happen faster
    • 00:49:37
      get the correct personnel out on the ground more quickly so that we can clear those incidents in a much more timely manner and importantly provide information to the traveling public so hopefully less people have the experience of rounding a corner when there's an interchange just before the curve there and they could have gotten off and they round that corner and they see brake lights.
    • 00:49:56
      Hopefully there's a sign now before that incident that warns them accident ahead, lane blocked, bad things will happen if you don't exit.
    • 00:50:04
      Please exit the roadway.
    • 00:50:06
      And then if we're encouraging people to exit the road, we are also making improvements to those parallel routes to make sure that when we're encouraging a thousand people to get off I-81, that Route 11, Route 460, the Stanton Bypass or those other roads can handle that influx.
    • 00:50:23
      The truth is today some people use Waze like Mr. Fralin.
    • 00:50:26
      He would always wave his phone and talk about how he used that often while driving.
    • 00:50:29
      We would encourage you to set your destination before you get in the car, but if you have that in there and it tells you to get off today, we haven't made those upgrades to those roads to be able to handle that increased flow.
    • 00:50:39
      That is a real part of this plan kind of moving forward so that we have a better experience for those commuters.
    • 00:50:47
      This slide goes into some of the specific details, but again, more message signs, more cameras, and upgrades to our parallel facilities here.
    • 00:50:55
      The total cost of the operations plan capital is $43 million.
    • 00:51:00
      There is an ongoing cost of around $6 million.
    • 00:51:02
      This would all be funded by either financing option moving forward.
    • 00:51:07
      The operations plan is responsible for 10%
    • 00:51:12
      of the delay benefits for this overall package and it is $40 million of a over $2 billion package.
    • 00:51:19
      So these are very, very cost-effective improvements that we're putting in place with this plan along the corridor.
    • 00:51:26
      As I mentioned earlier, for the other problem areas, we went to each of those top problem areas we identified and, where possible, determined what those contributing factors were and when the contributing factors could be addressed by engineering.
    • 00:51:39
      And as I mentioned, there are some instances where someone went into diabetic shock or a deer jumped out in the roadway or someone was very drunk.
    • 00:51:46
      There's little with engineering we can do to address that, but in most places, we could.
    • 00:51:50
      We developed potential solutions.
    • 00:51:52
      The total cost of those solutions was in excess of $4 billion.
    • 00:51:56
      Then what we did is we did not believe that delivering $4 billion in improvements was possible at this time, so we prioritized this list down to a package of $2 billion along this corridor.
    • 00:52:10
      It's about half of the overall cost of the potential solutions.
    • 00:52:14
      We used a SMART SCALE-like process using three of the measures from SMART SCALE there, congestion, safety, and access to jobs to prioritize these projects and distribute the money throughout the districts.
    • 00:52:27
      This slide here gives you a summary of the revised recommendations plan.
    • 00:52:31
      These numbers are slightly different than what was shown at the last meeting and I'll highlight some of those changes as we go through this.
    • 00:52:39
      On this slide I do think it's important to note that the Bristol District, all 27 of the potential improvements are funded.
    • 00:52:46
      There I do know the total is slightly lower.
    • 00:52:49
      They had a lower needs total in general and the Bristol District is actually the only district of I-81 in the Commonwealth that has six-lane sections of 81.
    • 00:52:57
      So there's 18 miles of I-81 that are six-lane today and every single one of those is located in the Bristol District.
    • 00:53:04
      In the past they were the only district that got major improvements on this corridor relative to the Stanton and Salem districts.
    • 00:53:12
      So in 81 we have a widening recommended in the Bristol just outside of the city of Bristol.
    • 00:53:18
      We have several truck climbing lanes that are added.
    • 00:53:20
      I do want to note there's a new truck climbing lane that Mr. Stinson working with the district has recommended adding to this list.
    • 00:53:27
      That is a southbound lane between mile marker 34 and 33.
    • 00:53:31
      There's also several different auxiliary lanes and those last two ones you see there are really improvements at the southern 77-81 interchange which was a big hotspot
    • 00:53:41
      That was recommended and again we were able to work and value engineer down from a $330 million improvement until approximately a $40 million improvement that provided 50% of the benefits of that larger $300 million improvement in the Bristol area.
    • 00:53:57
      In the Salem District, you see several large widenings that are recommended.
    • 00:54:03
      There is a change that Mr. Smoot, working with his staff in the district, has recommended that I do want to highlight.
    • 00:54:09
      That's that last bullet that you see there, widened northbound and southbound from mile marker 144 to 150.
    • 00:54:17
      What you'll also see is we are now recommending widening southbound from exit 141 to 137.
    • 00:54:23
      Those improvements were able to be funded by taking away funding for a set of auxiliary lanes in the Salem area.
    • 00:54:31
      When we went back and reviewed the recommendations northbound from 137 to 141, we had recommended both widening
    • 00:54:38
      and auxiliary lanes creating effectively a four-lane section heading northbound while southbound we had we didn't have that full widening and so we have kind of modified the plan to go from auxiliary lanes in both directions doing widening in both directions the staff also then did work on value engineering and in certain areas today they were proposing 12-foot shoulders those have been shrunk dramatically
    • 00:55:02
      in certain urban sections to reduce the cost because we now don't have to bridge replacements in this urban area between Salem and Roanoke there and so that's what allowed us to fund these additional projects in the Salem district.
    • 00:55:17
      And the commissioner has reviewed all of these cost estimates along with his team.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:20
      I'd also say that some of those auxiliary lanes were looking at having impacts to the interchanges as well.
    • 00:55:28
      So certainly there's some significant cost savings that allowed us to look at the third lane and the widening sections.
    • 00:55:36
      So absolutely.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:55:39
      The Stanton District, here we have some modifications.
    • 00:55:42
      I think at the last meeting Mr. Whitworth indicated he wanted us to go back and take a look at the Winchester area.
    • 00:55:48
      We have.
    • 00:55:49
      We now recommend widening from four miles there between exits 313 and 317.
    • 00:55:54
      That's Route 50 up to the 37 bypass where it ties in there.
    • 00:55:59
      That project is included.
    • 00:56:00
      We did
    • 00:56:01
      take away a proposed widening in Rockbridge County and then also truncated several auxiliary lane projects that were recommended in the Stanton District to be able to advance this.
    • 00:56:11
      Where the widening in Rockbridge is recommended to be removed, we did put in place shoulder improvements
    • 00:56:16
      which we believe will help address many of the safety problems that the widening was intended to get at in that area.
    • 00:56:22
      We have also truncated the widening in the Stanton area.
    • 00:56:26
      Previously the recommendation was to go from the Stanton Bypass on the north down to exit 217 which is about four miles south where 64 ties into 81 at Stanton.
    • 00:56:37
      We're now saying widen from 64 north
    • 00:56:39
      to the Stanton Bypass and then put in place an auxiliary lane southbound so that when you're taking 64 west and going on to 81 south you have extra space to merge before the southern Stanton Bypass ties in to the corridor there and so we believe that is a responsible set of improvements that Mr. Whitworth working with the district has recommended.
    • 00:57:00
      Overall, these improvements will reduce on average more than 6 million vehicle hours of delay along the corridor.
    • 00:57:09
      Trucks will receive 3.6 million of those hours of delay benefits along the corridor.
    • 00:57:15
      And we also anticipate that of approximately 2,000 crashes a year, we'll reduce about 450 of those.
    • 00:57:21
      And today, about 130 of those crashes involve some type of injury there.
    • 00:57:26
      So a very significant reduction in the number of incidents along this corridor, including those where someone is injured.
    • 00:57:34
      We do have three items that I mentioned at the last meeting that are still ongoing.
    • 00:57:38
      So these are all items that require ongoing collaboration and partnership with external stakeholders.
    • 00:57:44
      When it comes to implementing operations or a project on 81, that is something VDOT can do all on its own.
    • 00:57:51
      These other items, though, require us to partner with external stakeholders, and we are not able to complete that work within this six-month time period that we've been working on the plan.
    • 00:58:00
      And so we are going to be establishing a truck parking task force to again look at establishing a reservation system working with both public and private truck stop operators to provide certainty to truckers as they use this corridor where they can reserve a spot in advance to be able to maximize their use of their hours of service and have that certainty that there will be parking
    • 00:58:19
      As they run out of their available hours.
    • 00:58:22
      We are also putting in place a speed enforcement task force.
    • 00:58:25
      This is really going to be focused more on the northern end of the corridor.
    • 00:58:29
      Again, this was one of the key items of public comment.
    • 00:58:32
      That was not something we readily identified in the data at first.
    • 00:58:35
      But what we're seeing is in the Bristol District, we don't have a big problem with speeding.
    • 00:58:39
      But once you get into kind of the Stanton District, where the road's a little bit flatter, and for whatever reason, local law enforcement does not patrol it, as they do in the Bristol District,
    • 00:58:48
      Speed Enforcement was a major, major theme throughout the public comments there and so we're going to be talking with local law enforcement, Virginia State Police and others to figure out what are some strategies we can use to try and address those issues, particularly in the Stanton District there.
    • 00:59:03
      DRPT is also going to be working to develop multimodal improvements along this corridor.
    • 00:59:08
      And again, as I mentioned at the last meeting, this is talking with Norfolk Southern to try and get the second train down to Lynchburg and Roanoke and also talk about extension of service to the Christiansburg area.
    • 00:59:18
      This is also going to involve working with VEDP.
    • 00:59:21
      to really market, you know, spur connections to potential sites along that corridor both operating and perspective and could include potential bus improvements in the future as well.
    • 00:59:31
      We've talked about you all funded an intercity bus service along that corridor for the first time I believe in several decades and we've seen ridership exceed our expectations by about 200% in the Virginia breeze.
    • 00:59:42
      which is that service that runs I believe from Blacksburg all the way to Washington DC and so again that's what we're looking at there the plan would set aside a hundred million dollars to implement these recommendations as we move forward again at this time we don't have a specific this is exactly what we're going to do we have a set of ideas that we're moving towards and we believe a hundred million dollars should be sufficient to address those moving forward.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:10
      Question on that $100 million as it relates to the multimodal improvement options.
    • 01:00:16
      How will those decisions be made?
    • 01:00:17
      I'm sure we can come up with a lot of good solutions in the corridor to improve it.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:00:21
      I believe Director Mitchell and her team would bring those recommendations back to the board once they had reached a kind of a place where they thought they were firm enough to be able to move forward with implementation.
    • 01:00:31
      Again, we've been in discussions with Norfolk Southern along with the VEDP and others to date, so these are ongoing discussions.
    • 01:00:39
      What we're hoping is that over the next 12 months we can come to some type of resolution and path forward on those items, and when we do we would bring those back to the board for your consideration.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:51
      Secretary, Mr. Donohue, thank you for all the hard work that you and your team have put into this analysis.
    • 01:00:58
      It's extensive and I know it's exhausting, yet at the same time it provides what we need to go back to the legislature.
    • 01:01:06
      A couple of questions.
    • 01:01:07
      Do you have any idea
    • 01:01:09
      In consideration of the announcement that we had this morning of distracted driving incidents, both for automobiles and trucks, and you have an idea about the number of deaths, if you will, that are on Route 81 that tie into truck activity.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:01:27
      Madam Chair, Mr. Johnson, I don't have specific figures for the 81 corridor related to distracted driving there.
    • 01:01:35
      I can follow up before the end of the day with the best statistics we have relative to specific fatalities and the breakdown between truck-related incidents and non-truck-related incidents.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:46
      I just thought with the announcement this morning, that might be something to have in your quiver, so to speak.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:01:50
      And safety has been a big focus of this.
    • 01:01:52
      Again, I will ask the team there of those 450, how many of those did we in the past have typically involved a truck?
    • 01:02:00
      And perhaps we can get some of that information for you.
    • 01:02:01
      They all have it at their fingertips.
    • 01:02:03
      I unfortunately, I'm the one presenting the information.
    • 01:02:05
      I did not do the analysis.
    • 01:02:07
      That's why it actually makes sense.
    • 01:02:08
      So I will go talk with them.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:12
      Mr. Dodson.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:02:22
      That's a very good question.
    • 01:02:24
      I should have said rest areas.
    • 01:02:26
      So again, as we talked with the truckers through the surveys we did along the corridor, most of the truckers don't actually want to use the rest areas for their long-term breaks.
    • 01:02:34
      Again, we're prohibited by federal law from actually providing convenient services like a hot shower or a meal.
    • 01:02:40
      All we can do is sell food out of vending machines.
    • 01:02:42
      And so when truckers hit their end of their hours of service, they really want to
    • 01:02:46
      Go to a place where they can avail themselves of some of those services that are going to be stopped for eight hours.
    • 01:02:51
      However, most of them actually said there was a 50-50 split on short-term parking as to whether or not they wanted to use a public rest area or a private truck stop.
    • 01:03:01
      And so again, it's just making sure that if we are able to create this reservation system that we do have information about the availability of our public spaces as well when folks are looking for those short-term stops.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:16
      Mr. Donohue, I have a request actually because I hadn't seen this particular presentation and attended the last four public hearings.
    • 01:03:25
      The emphasis on multimodal was very strong and I really think as we are making these presentations and particularly with the General Assembly coming up, while we didn't create a specific plan, we identified lots of opportunities and I think that should be included in the presentation.
    • 01:03:43
      I think we should identify
    • 01:03:45
      The opportunities we have as we go into the next year and actually create an action plan.
    • 01:03:52
      Because so many of them are good and the impact is far greater than even I realized what we're able to do with moving trucks off the quarter.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:04:02
      No, and I apologize.
    • 01:04:04
      We had some of that in the past presentation.
    • 01:04:06
      I know it's incorporated into the report that would go to the assembly, but we will make sure in the future presentations we provide that higher level of detail just like we did with the roadway improvements there, creating that balance.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:16
      You're going to have some presentations coming up, and I'm thinking I like a lot of the edits to this, to be honest, but I do think that was an important piece.
    • 01:04:25
      Anything else?
    • 01:04:27
      All right.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:04:28
      But moving on to the financing options here.
    • 01:04:31
      And again, we had some discussions about this.
    • 01:04:33
      We do have more details today.
    • 01:04:35
      I'm just going to start really at the high level here and then move into some of the more specific details.
    • 01:04:41
      So again, the legislation does direct you to develop potential financing options that can pay for these recommended improvements.
    • 01:04:47
      So there's two financing options that you will see today.
    • 01:04:51
      We have worked with financial advisors, the Department of Taxation, and with traffic and revenue consultants.
    • 01:04:57
      We are confident that either of these scenarios can, through a mix of debt financing and pay-as-you-go funding, cover the $2 billion in capital improvements, the $100 million for the ongoing items, including the multimodal improvements, and then also the $43 million in upfront operating
    • 01:05:14
      Capital Improvements along with the $6 million in ongoing annual expenses related to those operating improvements.
    • 01:05:21
      I just want to say that at the front end we have those detailed financial scenarios.
    • 01:05:26
      We have worked with Prague and other advisors and we are confident that we can cover those costs moving forward.
    • 01:05:33
      So here are the two options, and again, I'm going to go into them in much more detail, but just to kind of get it out there at the outset.
    • 01:05:40
      There's a regional tax option that would require imposing two different taxes along the corridor, a 0.7% retail sales and use tax.
    • 01:05:50
      That is the same incremental rate that the General Assembly enacted in Northern Virginia and in Hampton Roads.
    • 01:05:56
      For additional transportation improvements and there's also you would require a 2.1 percent regional fuels tax that would apply to both gas and diesel along the corridor that is similar to a regional gas tax that's imposed in Northern Virginia, Fredericksburg, and Hampton Roads for transportation improvements.
    • 01:06:14
      So again we really try to focus on
    • 01:06:17
      funding sources the assembly had previously expressed an interest in using for transportation on a regional basis rather than trying to recommend something that they'd either rejected in the past or had not previously considered affirmatively.
    • 01:06:30
      We wanted to kind of stick on within areas of precedent.
    • 01:06:33
      when we looked at those regional taxes.
    • 01:06:35
      The second is a tolling option which would be a time of day tolling where we'd have higher tolls during the day and then lower tolls at night along with an annual pass that would be available for automobiles to use that facility.
    • 01:06:48
      While these generate initially different revenue streams due to nuances in the credit worthiness of the types of debt that can be leveraged, they can both support the capital plan that has been outlined in this
    • 01:07:02
      in this presentation.
    • 01:07:04
      So on the tax option again we have focused on structuring this in the same way that the General Assembly has previously imposed regional taxes and that with one exception has always been at the planning district commission level or regional level.
    • 01:07:18
      So we looked at every planning district commission through which I-81 runs through and so if you see
    • 01:07:23
      I-81,
    • 01:07:41
      where the road actually runs and the planning district commissions to which it actually does run.
    • 01:07:45
      They have not traditionally imposed taxes at a local level or within a single jurisdiction for transportation improvements at the assembly.
    • 01:07:53
      It has really been focused at this kind of more regional level there and so we have mirrored that approach in developing this option.
    • 01:08:02
      On the tolling option, there are several things I just want to walk through.
    • 01:08:05
      This is a slightly more explanation is required here.
    • 01:08:09
      So the Commonwealth Transportation Board does have the authority to impose tolls on interstate highways.
    • 01:08:16
      There are several specific things that those tolls must do.
    • 01:08:19
      They are listed here.
    • 01:08:20
      And I would say that the plan does finance interstate construction, reduce traffic congestion, promote efficiency, and address air quality.
    • 01:08:28
      I-81, though, is unique.
    • 01:08:30
      and that you do as a board have the authority to impose a toll on any new lane on any interstate in the Commonwealth with the exception of I-81 for which General Assembly approval is needed.
    • 01:08:42
      That bill was put in place in 2008 as a reaction to a public-private partnership that had been proposed at the time, STARS Solution.
    • 01:08:51
      My personal experience from being around then and being the leading these public meetings to date is we're getting a different reception with regard to this plan than was how Star Solutions was received there.
    • 01:09:02
      So again, that was something they put in place and the legislators who sponsored that legislation, they do not like to describe this as a prohibition on tolling on 81.
    • 01:09:10
      They like to describe it as you need to develop a plan that we believe is worth financing and come talk to us about 81.
    • 01:09:16
      And again, that's not verbatim, but Secretary Valentine's been in these meetings with me and that's
    • 01:09:21
      That's generally how it's described and again I'm sure I'll be corrected if I got a little off here in the coming weeks but that's my recollection of how it was stated.
    • 01:09:31
      There are also you must meet federal requirements to move forward with tolling.
    • 01:09:36
      There are four general ways in which the federal code allows for the tolling of interstate highways.
    • 01:09:42
      We list all four of those here.
    • 01:09:44
      As you will see, the 81 plan we believe could fit into three of those different federal funding authorities.
    • 01:09:51
      The one that does not work
    • 01:09:53
      481 would be the hot lane section of code and as we talked about we did examine the use of hot lanes in this corridor and the good news for the 81 corridor is they do not have a level of traffic congestion that really makes hot lanes a good financing option for improvements in this corridor unlike Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia where
    • 01:10:13
      The levels of traffic congestion are high enough where hot lanes is a viable financing option.
    • 01:10:18
      So again, we'll be exploring these if this is what the General Assembly ultimately advances, but we did want to let you know we have been talking with the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 01:10:27
      I've actually been to headquarters with John Lawson and Morteza several times to talk with those folks.
    • 01:10:32
      I know there's also been discussions with the District Office, and so we have been evaluating those opportunities.
    • 01:10:36
      Again, we do believe there are three ways, if tolling is the option selected by the Assembly, that we could move forward with the tolling
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:43
      I'm trying to understand and think through this as you said it.
    • 01:10:55
      There's not enough congestion to justify the hot lane concept.
    • 01:11:03
      I'm trying to balance that against we have a problem.
    • 01:11:10
      So we're talking about adding lanes, we're talking about adding cameras, we're talking about this, we're talking about auxiliary lanes and truck climbing lanes, but there's not enough congestion.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:11:20
      So I understand it's the numbers, but help me.
    • 01:11:24
      I should have said that in a more nuanced fashion.
    • 01:11:26
      So I believe when the hot lane provision was added in there, it's whether or not adding hot lanes could create a sufficient revenue to pay for the hot lane or pay for other improvements.
    • 01:11:37
      There are benefits that could be derived in this corridor from adding hot lanes.
    • 01:11:41
      However, the hot lanes would not generate enough revenue to pay for themselves or for other improvements in the corridor.
    • 01:11:47
      So that's why that was not advanced as an option.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:50
      In addition to these other improvements or by themselves?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:11:54
      If you just did hot lanes, our review showed that they would not pay for themselves, adding the extra lane and putting up the other gantries.
    • 01:12:05
      I would note there's very few places where they actually do that.
    • 01:12:08
      Northern Virginia is one of them, which
    • 01:12:12
      D. Smith Jr.
    • 01:12:36
      The other thing is the plan would have differential toll rates for either heavy commercial vehicles versus autos.
    • 01:12:42
      And again, just to be clear, we are defining a heavy commercial vehicle as anything that's Class 6 and up using the Federal Highway Classification.
    • 01:12:49
      Again, here's the picture.
    • 01:12:51
      You can take a look at that.
    • 01:12:52
      But generally, a tractor trailer is a heavy commercial vehicle.
    • 01:12:55
      My sedan is not.
    • 01:12:59
      There would not be any toll booths under the tolling option.
    • 01:13:03
      Tolls would be collected through all electronic toll collection along the corridor.
    • 01:13:07
      We would use gantries just as we do in Hampton Roads, Richmond, and Northern Virginia for these tolls.
    • 01:13:12
      We do not build toll booths in Virginia anymore.
    • 01:13:15
      There was a law actually put in place in 2007 that directed all new toll roads should have at least the option of electronic tolling, though we are not prohibited from toll booths.
    • 01:13:24
      Due to the advances in the last 11 years, we don't think toll boosts are necessary anymore.
    • 01:13:28
      So you would either pay through an E-ZPass or a toll sticker, or if you have neither of those, we would take a picture of you and send you a bill several weeks in the mail later requesting that you pay that toll.
    • 01:13:38
      We did assume there would be six gantries along the corridor, so this is not going to be something where you see a toll gantry at every single interchange.
    • 01:13:46
      Rather, they would be spaced out in 40 to 60 mile increments along the corridor, really trying to just catch people traveling along 81 there.
    • 01:13:55
      We have looked at multiple types of locations and we haven't finalized any specific toll gantry location.
    • 01:14:00
      That's something that would take place if the assembly were to authorize the toll financing options as we developed an investment grade traffic and revenue and sought to sell bonds.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:08
      Look at possible toll gantries on some of the exit ramps to catch people that used 39 of the 40 miles between them and are you trying to avoid catching them?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:14:27
      Madam Chair, Mr. Williams, we have been exploring that opportunity.
    • 01:14:30
      Some of those federal programs work better for that than others.
    • 01:14:34
      And we have talked, we've had some more preliminary discussions on that matter there.
    • 01:14:38
      But I think you would see us consider the installation of gantries on like the first and last exit before that.
    • 01:14:45
      And so again, if we know you've been driving on and you got off the exit ramp and got right back on, I think we would be able to determine what you had done and effectively say, you're paying the toll.
    • 01:14:55
      So if you just drive down the ramp, sit at the red light for 30 seconds, then keep going back up the next side, we do not want to encourage that type of behavior.
    • 01:15:05
      Madam Secretary.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:06
      Of course Mr. Williams would ask the question.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:10
      Mr. Malbon.
    • 01:15:12
      Looking at the regional authorities, how many regional authorities would be created along that corridor?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:15:19
      Madam Chair, Mr. Malbon, that would ultimately be a decision the General Assembly would make.
    • 01:15:26
      What I would say is there are 36 independent jurisdictions that exist along the 81 corridor.
    • 01:15:34
      I believe there were 11 votes for chair of the Hampton Roads Transportation Accountability Commission with 14 jurisdictions.
    • 01:15:40
      And so I think if you created a 36-member authority with weighted population voting and a requirement of two-thirds of the jurisdictions of the 36 and two-thirds of the population, I hope I am not there running the spreadsheet figuring out whether it's an affirmative vote.
    • 01:15:55
      That's why I was asking the question.
    • 01:15:57
      It seemed a little clumsy to me.
    • 01:15:58
      I'm not sure how that... You would probably need to establish a single authority if that was the desire because the ability to finance this is predicated on all the revenues being used in the financing scheme and if you break that up, I'm not sure if everything aligns perfectly.
    • 01:16:15
      There, I think the key thing is we've talked with legislators along that corridor.
    • 01:16:20
      If we go to the regional tax option, what I've heard is they want to make sure there is an appropriate level of engagement and input and collaboration with those jurisdictions along the corridor.
    • 01:16:31
      That could mean you establish a regional authority.
    • 01:16:33
      or it could mean we create new legal requirements for this board in VDOT relative to their interaction with those existing planning district commissions and others where you meet with them annually, provide them with information in a greater degree of detail than maybe we do with some of our traditional statewide dollars.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:50
      However, if the tolling option is chosen, we already have the Code of Virginia which would dictate how those monies could be spent and policies in place from this board
    • 01:17:01
      where the funds where you wouldn't have to create an authority there would be a sub-account within the CTB just like NVTC in Northern Virginia.
    • 01:17:09
      We would set up that memorandum along the quarter but the funds generated from the tolling mechanism would have to be dedicated to the quarter and benefit the toll payers along 81.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:17:22
      And Madam Chair, to your point there, both the tolls and the regional taxes, if the General Assembly imposes either, they cannot go help Mr. Brown with the 64-95 overlap here in Richmond.
    • 01:17:32
      They can't be redirected either by the Assembly or this Board.
    • 01:17:35
      The taxes would need to stay within those jurisdictions, so they could actually be used off I-81, again, legally.
    • 01:17:42
      I'm not saying that would be the appropriate policy or how the General Assembly would structure the law, though laws can change.
    • 01:17:48
      We know with Northern Virginia's experience this past session but again they would need to be used for transportation improvements in those jurisdictions if it's the tolls by court case president dealing with the constitutionality of user fees they would have to benefit that corridor and could not for example go to do improvements on I-64 and Covington even though that's still in the Planning District Commission it would be a hard sell to say that's benefiting the toll paying user on I-81.
    • 01:18:14
      It could make improvements so to say Route 11
    • 01:18:16
      because again that's a detour route 481 it could help with bus service running on the corridor and things like that that benefit the corridor but the tolls are much more tightly constrained and as the secretary noted in both instances they would go into special segregated sub accounts within the transportation trust fund which is how the law has been set up both for tolls and these regional authorities.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:41
      Nick have we satisfied ourselves or have we been
    • 01:18:46
      I am advised by counsel that the tolling option does not run afoul with the interstate commerce issue favoring non-commercial over commercial in the fees.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:19:00
      Yes, Madam Chair, Mr. Whitworth, and for those of you who may not have read all the correspondence or need just a quick refresher, we did receive a letter from some individuals talking about how they were concerned about the toll financing option that was being recommended because it appeared to be similar to West Virginia's option, and so just a quick
    • 01:19:19
      A quick moment here.
    • 01:19:21
      The West Virginia Turnpike is in the process of establishing an annual pass for autos that use that facility.
    • 01:19:27
      However, what they are doing is slightly different than what is being proposed here.
    • 01:19:31
      They also distinguish between commercial and non-commercial vehicles.
    • 01:19:35
      And so if you have a pickup truck
    • 01:19:38
      That is Marty Williams' personal pickup truck.
    • 01:19:40
      That would be eligible for the annual pass in West Virginia.
    • 01:19:44
      But if Mr. Dodson has a pickup truck and he's a painter, and that is owned by Dodson Painting, that truck, even though it is the same size, same use and impact on the roadway, would not be eligible
    • 01:19:55
      for that commuter pass.
    • 01:19:56
      And so we have been in discussions with the Attorney General's Office and we believe because we would offer the pass both to commercial and non-commercial vehicles, rather we distinguish whether it's an auto or a heavy commercial, heavy vehicle
    • 01:20:10
      that we would be in compliance with the Commerce Clause.
    • 01:20:13
      I should be very upfront.
    • 01:20:15
      I believe there are some and maybe even some in this room who would tell you they feel otherwise.
    • 01:20:20
      What I will tell you is we have engaged our Council on this matter and we are comfortable with what we are proposing to you.
    • 01:20:26
      Have we heard back from Council yet?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:29
      Yes.
    • 01:20:29
      And they concur?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:20:34
      Yes.
    • 01:20:34
      Thank you.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:21:21
      I'm going to start and then I'm going to turn it over to the commissioner here.
    • 01:21:24
      I think there's several things.
    • 01:21:25
      One, we have tried to develop conservative cost estimates for these projects.
    • 01:21:31
      I would rather us build all these and have extra cash than be extremely aggressive and realize, well, the last three just aren't going to make it.
    • 01:21:38
      I think that would be an unfortunate outcome.
    • 01:21:39
      I think the other thing we've really tried to do is also kind of put a governor on the amount of work
    • 01:21:45
      That would go out over this period of time and so again we developed four billion dollars in solutions.
    • 01:21:50
      I think it's fair to say both the Commissioner and I had concerns about whether that level of new work could be absorbed in the industry without seeing inflationary kind of cost increases.
    • 01:22:01
      The plan does assume these are built over I believe a seven to eight years.
    • 01:22:05
      7 to 10 years, excuse me, period there.
    • 01:22:08
      So again, we are spreading out this work over a period of time and we did direct staff to develop these as conservative cost estimates to hopefully give us that wiggle room.
    • 01:22:17
      But again, I know the Commissioner has personally reviewed these and so I'd turn it over to him.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:21
      I would say that we've had each of our district engineers and their preliminary engineering managers looking at each of these projects in a very conservative manner so that we don't overextend ourselves in projecting this out.
    • 01:22:33
      So by having bad soils or other
    • 01:22:38
      I'll just say the rock in the region is going to be very laborious to be able to build the facilities that we're talking about but we have taken that into consideration in those cost estimates and we will need some flexibility as we go along but we think that this is a realistic and conservative set of estimates
    • 01:22:55
      to be able to be built over this next seven to ten years.
    • 01:22:58
      The good news is many of these projects at least in some of these regions were SMART SCALE projects to begin with so we see that there is an opportunity to be able to expand the work that's already been going on with the environmental documents.
    • 01:23:10
      Thank you.
    • 01:23:27
      I'll say a couple years, several years to be able to do, but we have a plan of an implementation plan that we'll be working on if this is successful to be able to get this moving in a timely fashion.
    • 01:23:39
      But I'd say part of the cost estimates are relative to the time that they would be put into
    • 01:23:46
      Go to construction.
    • 01:23:48
      So there are inflationary factors associated with it and again to the secretary W secretary Donahue's point They are conservative cost estimates so that we don't overextend ourselves and over promise Really good question, especially with everything that we've been managing
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:24:50
      And Madam Chair and Ms. Hunt, I would say in each of these, when you establish a dedicated funding source,
    • 01:25:14
      you will always have the ability in the future for additional improvements at some period of time and so again how these are structured the exact amount that's raised up front if they decide to go that route even if they scale back or curtail to a certain extent the amount of revenue that is raised I think we would have the ability because we've prioritized all these projects to adapt the plan
    • 01:25:36
      You know find other ways to move forward with it and then in the future at some period of time there would be the ability to consider second tranches of improvements.
    • 01:25:44
      I would hope at that time we do another needs assessment update and don't just grab whatever was left on the cutting room floor the previous time because conditions will change over those 10 or 15 years but there will with the dedicated revenue stream be some opportunity in the future for other improvements.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:00
      I was just going to follow up on the comment that was made is the scalability of this is certainly there.
    • 01:26:07
      We've identified in the early stages a fairly unconstrained program of projects in the beginning stage, and then we've gone through a prioritization methodology now to be able to identify the 2.1 billion.
    • 01:26:20
      So if we get 3 billion, then we have
    • 01:26:25
      Well, I'll put it there, but if we go down to 1.5, everything is scalable in this nature so that we can adjust as we need to be able to meet the needs, but I think we do have that prioritized set of projects out there today that should the scalability come into question, we'll be prepared to be able to meet the demands.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:20
      I think that is a good point.
    • 01:27:21
      I haven't seen the final rendition of the report, but I think that is something that we can add to it.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:27:30
      No, and it is clear that if you do not enact the full financing option that we cannot build all of these.
    • 01:27:37
      I would also say that I believe on your iPads you do have the executive summary of the report.
    • 01:27:42
      The final report is still in proofing there, but it is clear that
    • 01:27:47
      To get the 2.143, you must approve either the regional tax, the toll, or some hybrid of the two that generates a substantially similar amount of money.
    • 01:28:04
      Madam Chair, Mr. Williams, it does not specifically lay out a hybrid.
    • 01:28:08
      I think we were presenting to the Assembly two different ways.
    • 01:28:12
      I think they may come up with 10 more before everything is said and done.
    • 01:28:16
      We know the numbers.
    • 01:28:17
      Yes.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:17
      We know the big numbers, the number we need to generate each year.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:28:22
      Right.
    • 01:28:22
      We know what that generally is, if it's toll or tax, and if it's in between, I'm sure we can quickly figure that out as well.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:28
      They have the appetite for it.
    • 01:28:29
      They'll figure that out.
    • 01:28:31
      Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:32
      Thank you, Ms. Secretary.
    • 01:28:35
      Two slides back you talked about the tolling policies and programs that we could access and the section 129 general toll program is one I'm not fully understanding what we're saying because it says you can do this as long as you are restoring or rehabbing and that you don't lose toll-free lanes or they're not reduced.
    • 01:29:03
      And you suggest in your slide that as long as toll gantries are near or on reconstructed or rehabilitated bridges that it meets that criteria.
    • 01:29:13
      So you're saying like if I'm tolling the whole interstate, which means the number of free lanes otherwise are reduced, but I put the gantries next to where I made the improvements that all of a sudden now I'm not tolling, now I haven't reduced my free lanes.
    • 01:29:31
      Is that what you're saying?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:29:32
      Madam Chair, Mr. Miller, I would readily admit that I did not write the federal code and it is often choppy, but what I will say is that Section 126 will allow you to toll an interstate, excuse me, 129 will allow you to toll an interstate, all lanes on that interstate, if it is related to and in proximity to bridges that are being rehabbed or replaced.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:55
      Okay, so maybe we could just, one set of language doesn't seem to agree with the other, but
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:30:00
      I accept you know a lot more about it than I do.
    • 01:30:03
      We have written the federal code generally in a way that it is written, and if you are saying that the federal code is written in a confusing manner, I would 100% agree.
    • 01:30:10
      What I will say to you is that in Rhode Island...
    • 01:30:12
      When I read it, I was confused.
    • 01:30:14
      In Rhode Island, I'll give you an example, real world, they have replaced several bridges on I-95 in Rhode Island, and they are currently tolling the use of all lanes for the use of that interstate near where they have replaced those bridges.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:29
      As long as number of toll-free lanes are not reduced.
    • 01:30:35
      Seems pretty clear to me what that says.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:30:37
      And I think what they would say is that if you have a hundred mile stretch of interstate in a state, and let's make up its state, Mars, and there are no bridges on that interstate, then you could not exercise section 129.
    • 01:30:50
      If you're in Virginia and you have 325 miles and there are hundreds of bridges on that, you have hundreds of opportunities to exercise Section 129 should you determine that as the policy goal you wish to implement.
    • 01:31:02
      But it is confusing in the manner in which it is written.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:07
      Madam Chair and Nick, how much of the $2 billion would be debt financed?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:31:12
      Madam Chair, Mr. Smoot, again, the specifics of this will change as interest rates and other things change, but it's approximately, I believe, three quarters that is debt financed and the other remaining five, six hundred million is PAYGO financing.
    • 01:31:28
      And again, I want to stipulate those will change.
    • 01:31:31
      I promise you that is not the exact number, but it's in the ballpark.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:35
      But the funding plan as presented here
    • 01:31:38
      would generate about $310 million a year, which is considerably more than it would take simply to address the debt service.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:31:48
      Madam Chair, Mr. Smoot, I believe I may have not presented that slide well.
    • 01:31:52
      Those are two separate financing options.
    • 01:31:54
      So I would say one financing option generates $145 million and a second and separate financing option generates $165 million.
    • 01:32:03
      So it's not a $310 million financing plan.
    • 01:32:06
      It's $145 million financing plan and another separate $165 million financing
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:13
      If you, in fact, implemented all of the options, it would be 310, correct?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:32:19
      If you did both options, which is not necessary to do the 2 billion, then yes, it would be 310, but we are not recommending- But Mr. Smoot can get that through the General Assembly.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:28
      I don't know.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:29
      I'm just trying to understand how much of the 310 we need to do this project.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:32:35
      So you do not need 310.
    • 01:32:36
      You need either the 145 or separately you need the 165.
    • 01:32:41
      We are not saying do both at the same time.
    • 01:32:43
      We are saying do either the tax or if you do not want to do the tax, do the toll or say it whichever way you prefer, do the toll or if you do not like that, do the tax.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:52
      I think it's important to encourage understanding of that because if I'm hearing feedback, there seems to be an assumption that the entire 310
    • 01:33:04
      We will make sure to drill that point home as we talk with the legislators.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:33:13
      That is not the intent.
    • 01:33:17
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:18
      It would take care of Ms. Hines' issues.
    • 01:33:29
      Well, we have the executive summary, but the full report we do not yet.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:33:42
      That's very helpful.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:03
      Mr. Whitworth, I was getting over here.
    • 01:34:05
      I saw you.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:08
      The annual auto pass is available for citizens only or anyone?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:34:19
      Can I use that as a transition to get into more details on the tolling which will then get to that question in two slides?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:25
      And the other question which you may want to get to also has to do with our recommendation of which we're not making a recommendation, I understand, as to whether we should
    • 01:34:38
      make a recommendation.
    • 01:34:41
      There are some implications of one versus the other, I believe, that had to do with bonding, would have to do with debt caps.
    • 01:34:54
      I don't know if that's addressed in the report or not, but it would seem to me that if I were the legislature, I would
    • 01:35:05
      I would ask that question, and you're probably going to be asked that question if we don't address it ourselves.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:35:11
      Yes, I will address both of those in due haste here.
    • 01:35:14
      So just for more detail on the tolling option, when we last were before you, we said the toll rates would not exceed 17 cents.
    • 01:35:20
      We have specific rates today that are based on, again, our discussions with financial advisors and traffic and revenue consultants.
    • 01:35:27
      We do again have variable tolls because our goal is to encourage behavioral change and to get those using the road during the day to consider whether or not their trips can operate at night.
    • 01:35:37
      We have many 24-hour distribution and logistics operations along this corridor and I rarely hear a complaint about I-81 at one in the morning.
    • 01:35:47
      And so if we could encourage some of those folks who are using it at the heaviest travel time around five to use that roadway at one,
    • 01:35:53
      That will only make this roadway work better for everyone along the corridor.
    • 01:36:00
      So we are again proposing a truck toll rate of 15 cents per mile during the day and that would be half that rate at night.
    • 01:36:08
      We are looking at a car toll rate that would be seven and a half cents per mile during the day and five cents during the night and there would be an auto pass available for anyone driving not a heavy vehicle whether they were a resident of Virginia or a different state to purchase a $30 pass for unlimited use for ID1 for that year in which they purchased the pass.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:30
      Good question on the financial model on the toll recommendations.
    • 01:36:37
      Are there any roadways in the country that are currently doing time of day sensitive truck tolling?
    • 01:36:44
      We have any comparators?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:36:46
      Yes, there's actually the Elizabeth River crossings and Hampton Roads have time of day tolling.
    • 01:36:52
      They actually are a little more nuanced than what we're proposing due to different traffic volumes in that area.
    • 01:36:58
      But they have a peak period in the morning and a peak period in the evening where I believe the rates are two times higher for trucks.
    • 01:37:06
      There and then during the midday and evening periods the toll, as you said differently, is one half of what it is during those peak periods.
    • 01:37:14
      I do know there are also some other areas that have that but at the moment they are escaping me.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:19
      So have we modeled our expectation of what the congestion reduction will be by incentivizing truckers to drive that road at night versus the day?
    • 01:37:29
      Do we have any quantifiable
    • 01:37:33
      information on what that might be from a standpoint of actual reduction to congestion.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:37:41
      Research that shows that the concept of variable tolling can help encourage that behavioral change.
    • 01:37:47
      I would need to talk to the folks who have run, worked with the traffic and revenue consultants to see what degree of a change we have assumed in our traffic and revenue so I don't have a clean answer for you at this time on that.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:00
      The answer would be of course you have or you couldn't come to the number that you have on the page.
    • 01:38:05
      Right.
    • 01:38:05
      Because if a truck pays half of what it was going to pay, you wouldn't know what the revenue was going to be unless you modeled it.
    • 01:38:10
      That's what I'm saying is the answer exists.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:38:12
      I just need to look at it and compare that to what it is currently over a 24-hour period versus what is assumed in that traffic and revenue report.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:20
      Because I would add to that, Nick.
    • 01:38:21
      So we're discounting in a way that's going to forego revenue in doing that.
    • 01:38:26
      And so if we took an estimate of that, it could be 10 or 15 percent revenue that we would forego by doing that rate.
    • 01:38:32
      My question is, as we look at this and model it, could the money that we end up foregoing by having a night toll rate be better spent on multimodal options and increase the $100 million number rather than creating a differentiated toll rate?
    • 01:38:49
      So which is going to be more beneficial from a standpoint of congestion reduction?
    • 01:38:53
      We've got a net deduct or a diminished toll level based on the night tolling, which is about a third of the day.
    • 01:39:02
      Could the money that we would take in based on a consistent level of tolling be better spent in deploying more multimodal options to the corridor and reducing congestion that way rather than expecting that we'll change behavior of the truckers?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:39:17
      Madam Chair, Mr. Kasprowicz, I think many people have many different opinions to that question and I don't think there's a pure black and white answer and I'm not saying that to be opaque in my response there.
    • 01:39:30
      What I would say is that at the moment we are still working with the people we would need to collaborate with on those multimodal improvements.
    • 01:39:38
      And I don't think we have a discrete set of improvements and I think the unknown factor for us there is if we were to say have a flat toll rate, which as you noted would generate money, I think it's actually a slightly higher bar than what you noted.
    • 01:39:52
      What we do not know yet is whether or not the people we would need to partner with would be willing to partner with us to implement that level of improvement.
    • 01:40:00
      along the corridor at this time when it comes to some of the larger scale investments.
    • 01:40:05
      Many of the smaller investments like the spurs are in the hundreds of thousands to the millions of dollars and those can easily be implemented through the existing revenues that would be created by either these options or by the rail industrial access program.
    • 01:40:18
      On those larger scale improvements I think that would be a result of the discussions we have with Norfolk Southern.
    • 01:40:24
      And I just, at this time, I cannot prejudge where those discussions will end up.
    • 01:40:30
      What I think I could say to you is if those discussions go well and there are greater opportunities than anticipated, we could come back to you guys and ask for potential modifications to this plan.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:43
      I was going to say, Nick, I understand this is an inexact science and we're making estimates, but I would like to see some suggestion of what the benefit of having the day-night rates might be to congestion mitigation in the other 18 hours of the day or 16 hours of the day is where they don't apply.
    • 01:40:58
      And I'd certainly prefer if we had additional funds that we spent on multimodal, but you could make, I guess, a case that if those congestion reductions are minimal, that that money might be better spent if we did have full tolling throughout the day on additional improvements that would add lane miles or exit and entry ramp improvements.
    • 01:41:21
      I think it'd be beneficial to at least see some estimate of what we expect that to do before we give up this
    • 01:41:26
      Fairly significant piece of revenue from the tolls.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:32
      Thank you.
    • 01:41:33
      Mr. Secretary, you brought it up, so I'm going to jump on it.
    • 01:41:38
      You know, I like a lot of the points about what you have offered, what your team has offered here, and I think it's been well thought out.
    • 01:41:48
      And I understand the different parts of the Commonwealth are different.
    • 01:41:53
      You know, they operate differently, they have different traffics, they have through traffic versus commuter traffic, they have more trucks, less trucks, whatever it is.
    • 01:42:02
      But as we go through this experience we've been through in the last 8, 10, 12 years, I get concerned that we treat different regions differently in a way that makes them unhappy in a different region, if you will.
    • 01:42:19
      So you brought up ERC for example and I had the pleasure of sitting through this meeting some years ago when that was briefed to us and we didn't approve or disapprove it because that wasn't our role at the time.
    • 01:42:32
      But I've got lots of people down there who pay $1100 a year after tax to get to work where they paid zero before.
    • 01:42:43
      And there is no good alternative for many of them.
    • 01:42:46
      People would say there is, but the reality is from someone who lives there, there isn't.
    • 01:42:51
      And now somebody on 81 is gonna get a lot of improvements and they're gonna pay 30 bucks a year.
    • 01:42:56
      So I got one person paying 1,100 and another person paying 30.
    • 01:43:01
      Now they're different projects, I get all that.
    • 01:43:05
      But it's really hard for me to look my folks in the eyes in Hampton Roads and say, yeah, it's okay.
    • 01:43:11
      Because it's really not okay.
    • 01:43:13
      And that's one of the reasons that tolls are more difficult.
    • 01:43:20
      Because in order to get the same result, it's got to be different, depending on where you are.
    • 01:43:25
      But if we raise this money at the Commonwealth level, or even the regional level differently, that argument, that issue sort of goes away.
    • 01:43:35
      So I'm concerned as we look at more tolling options,
    • 01:43:42
      That we keep perspective of what we're doing in various parts of the Commonwealth so that we're not pitting one, you know, we're balkanizing this game basically, but we're not getting people in one region thinking they're being taken advantage of and it's not equitable versus another region, because that region, that's not good for anybody.
    • 01:44:02
      And I'm not suggesting this does that by design, but the $30 pass, man, if I wave that in front of some people down home, they're going to go, can I get a $30 pass?
    • 01:44:12
      And we're going to say, no, your pass costs $1,100.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:23
      And that's the concern.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:27
      It's going to be really good.
    • 01:44:28
      Thank you, Madam Secretary.
    • 01:44:31
      Nick, thank you for the work you've done on this and everybody on the staff that's done a lot of work on this and the hearings that people participated in.
    • 01:44:40
      But I'm just kind of struck by the absence of rail with so much freight up and down this highway.
    • 01:44:45
      I know we're going to be asked about that, at least I will.
    • 01:44:50
      What do we do to review RAIL and what is the impact on RAIL on this?
    • 01:44:56
      I know we've got restrictions on that too.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:44:59
      Well, I'm going to note a point that the Secretary raised earlier.
    • 01:45:02
      I was obviously deficient in not replicating some of the slides from the previous discussion in this one, so let me apologize to the board just upfront on that particular matter.
    • 01:45:11
      We have had discussions with Norfolk Southern about rail in this corridor.
    • 01:45:14
      There are some advocates and they did come to these public hearings that are advocating what they call the steel interstate.
    • 01:45:20
      They advocated that in the early 2000s as well.
    • 01:45:24
      Based on our discussions, we do not believe at this time that is a viable concept, which does not mean they're not viable rail improvements.
    • 01:45:31
      I want to really stress the difference there.
    • 01:45:33
      The steel interstate is a concept that trucks like Drive to Bristol and then the auto train, they all load onto the train, go through Virginia and then somewhere north of Winchester, you have the Sanford stop on the auto train and you all get off and get back on the roadway there.
    • 01:45:46
      For a whole host of reasons, both economic and Norfolk Southern's willingness, that is not a viable option.
    • 01:45:53
      There are very viable rail improvements, however, in this corridor.
    • 01:45:58
      One of the main issues when it comes to freight rail is the connection of these sites to the main line.
    • 01:46:03
      And so what we are trying to do, we've had some very successful projects recently and I've talked about one several times this meeting, that's the interchange cold storage facility in the Harrisonburg area where they're making a $40 million investment and I believe we're spending $450,000 to connect their facility to the main line and they're now going to start shipping goods by rail.
    • 01:46:24
      And again, absent that $450,000 investment, they couldn't do that.
    • 01:46:28
      They're actually pretty close to the rail line but if
    • 01:46:31
      If you don't have a spur into your facility, you can't load onto the mainline because Norfolk Southern is not going to let you stop all the other trains while you load yours up.
    • 01:46:38
      And so we're trying to work with VEDP and this is going to have to be an ongoing effort.
    • 01:46:43
      where we, one, talk to existing distributors along that corridor and look for opportunities where those folks can be more efficient by moving their goods by rail and trying to fund some of those improvements either through the funds set aside in this plan if it's implemented or through the rail industrial access program which is what we've used in the past.
    • 01:47:02
      In addition to that, we are planning to work with VDP to try and market new sites to new folks that could be served by rail and make sure that if those new investments are made, we have the ability to put in that rail spur up front so that they start operations with that rail access.
    • 01:47:18
      Norfolk Southern has indicated to us they believe they have capacity on the crescent line, which is what we kind of call those two rail lines that are parallel.
    • 01:47:26
      Jr., John
    • 01:47:44
      Kupferberg Jr.,
    • 01:48:07
      It's not just Jennifer having the program, it's the people in the corridor being aware of their ability to make those types of improvements and have state support to help them do so, which a lot of times can change the dynamic on whether or not it's something that is financially feasible from their perspective to kind of move forward with.
    • 01:48:29
      But I think in those instances, Norfolk Southern has said they are
    • 01:48:32
      Happy and interested in serving those customers when the opportunity rises.
    • 01:48:37
      On the passenger rail side, we have been in extended discussions with Northwark Southern about trying to add additional service to the Crescent line.
    • 01:48:46
      And again, all of these go across the Longbridge.
    • 01:48:49
      I just need to state, because we're going to talk more about the Longbridge in the coming months.
    • 01:48:53
      But again, from DC through Alexandria, and then they break away from the 95 corridor, go down the Manassas VRE line, and then kind of parallel
    • 01:49:01
      81 through Culpeper, Charlottesville, Lynchburg and then over to Roanoke.
    • 01:49:05
      What we are trying to have discussions with Norfolk Southern about now is whether or not we can secure a second train to Lynchburg and hopefully Roanoke and then what opportunities are there to try and extend that service into Christiansburg.
    • 01:49:19
      The folks in the New River Valley are doing something similar to what the folks in Roanoke did several years ago where they are exploring feeder bus service
    • 01:49:27
      to the Roanoke station.
    • 01:49:29
      That is actually what predicated the Roanoke service was the establishment of a feeder bus from Roanoke when the Lynchburg train started in 2009 to that Kemper Street station from Roanoke.
    • 01:49:40
      We saw high ridership there which demonstrated I think sufficient passenger demand to justify the investment to extend the passenger service from Lynchburg to Roanoke.
    • 01:49:51
      And so that is what we're working with Norfolk Southern on now.
    • 01:49:55
      I will be honest, I wish
    • 01:49:57
      The team here, we could all stand up and say, we have an agreement at this stage.
    • 01:50:02
      We do not at this time.
    • 01:50:04
      I think we do have a commitment to keep engaging on those issues with Norfolk Southern there.
    • 01:50:11
      But I think that's really some of the rail components that we're looking at trying to move forward.
    • 01:50:16
      And this is, I think, at least a personal frustration of mine, is when it comes to the roadway side, Commissioner Brich, working with Secretary Valentine, is the authority.
    • 01:50:26
      Nobody else owns I-81.
    • 01:50:28
      So if we want to go change I-81, we want to put different light bulbs in new towing companies and widen the road.
    • 01:50:35
      We don't have to ask anyone for permission, assuming they're the financial capabilities to do so.
    • 01:50:41
      There isn't in this instance, which is why we have to ask the General Assembly.
    • 01:50:43
      But for smaller scale improvements, we can just move forward, design them, and implement them.
    • 01:50:48
      On the rail side, and in particular, passenger and commuter rail relative to transit, but also with transit,
    • 01:50:55
      We typically have to coordinate with some other party and reach a mutually agreeable solution, and that just takes a little, it takes more time, takes more partnership, it takes more coordination, and again, it's harder, and hard isn't bad.
    • 01:51:09
      You know, I don't mean to say that that's a negative thing, I just kind of view it as a fact.
    • 01:51:14
      If I want to go get lunch, I can just go pick where I want to go, but if Mary and I are going to go get lunch, I'm going to have a discussion with her, and she may not want to go eat chicken wings, and that may be what I want, and so it's just, that's like, you know, a silly thing, but that's kind of the discussion we're having with Norfolk Southern.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:27
      I can't see Mary eating chicken.
    • 01:51:32
      I think everyone who has spoken on this, all the comments have been really helpful.
    • 01:51:39
      I do believe if we outline the opportunities, it would help all of us see the direction that we're going.
    • 01:51:46
      So we're going to try to do that by tomorrow to add that in.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:51:51
      Yeah, the slides exist, I apologize.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:52
      Yes, we just need to add that piece.
    • 01:51:55
      The second thing is, you know, are we setting aside enough money in this, in the discussion, what the opportunities are, and again, the return on those investments.
    • 01:52:07
      So, I think that's something that we could actually consider and see if we are indeed setting aside enough money for the multimodal opportunities.
    • 01:52:16
      Because, in addition, we can also use this, and maybe the
    • 01:52:21
      The four points at the end, we should add operational and technology to that because as we are learning more and developing more through the Office of Innovation, there's going to be some other, I think, interesting opportunities that we want to take advantage of and so maybe have four subsets going forward and making sure we set aside enough money to be able to do that.
    • 01:52:43
      Ms. Hines.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:53:42
      I.
    • 01:54:19
      And I before
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:18
      I don't really have a good choice.
    • 01:55:34
      You know, that's their perception.
    • 01:55:36
      I think they do have choices.
    • 01:55:38
      But they don't have a choice running right alongside the thing that they're on.
    • 01:55:42
      So I really think we got to, you guys have to help us figure out how to talk about this in a more consistent, grounded in philosophy manner.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:55:55
      I think we can certainly work on some of those items and to be clear there but I also do want to note and it's not going to help with these discussions but I think it is important to raise is that the roads are different.
    • 01:56:12
      We're talking about $2 billion spread out over 325 miles.
    • 01:56:16
      In Hampton Roads, you spent $2 billion on a mile.
    • 01:56:20
      And so there are differences in what is being received there.
    • 01:56:24
      I mean, 66 Inside is a road they couldn't use before.
    • 01:56:28
      I understand people are still not necessarily happy about having a choice they previously did not have.
    • 01:56:33
      But making the comparisons is just not
    • 01:56:36
      It's not candidly fair in my opinion.
    • 01:56:38
      Like if we were going to make the comparison, which doesn't mean it will not happen.
    • 01:56:42
      If we were to make the comparison between what is being proposed in 81 to 66, it would be tolling the general purpose lanes outside the beltway.
    • 01:56:49
      And that's a very different type of discussion there.
    • 01:56:51
      But I do think we have to recognize, while it will be inconvenient and probably not always pleasant conversations with members of the public or other elected officials, that these roads are different.
    • 01:57:03
      The types of improvements that were done are different and at times that may require a different solution.
    • 01:57:08
      I'm not saying that is always right or appropriate or there may not have been a better way to do some of those past deals.
    • 01:57:14
      Some in particular.
    • 01:57:17
      But I do also think that a 325-mile interstate
    • 01:57:22
      through a smaller urban and rural area is very different than a tunnel between two dense cities or an all HOV road that ends at a stoplight in the District of Columbia next to the Kennedy Center.
    • 01:57:34
      Like those are just entirely different roads and comparing them while people will do it and it is easy to do, I don't think it's always, it's not necessarily fair, which doesn't mean the comments won't be raised.
    • 01:57:45
      So we will put together talking points for you all.
    • 01:57:47
      But again, I also just, I needed to say that out loud for the record.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:57
      The details of how the roads are different of who pays and why get lost over time and That you could help everybody not quite honestly.
    • 01:58:10
      I'm worried about Northern Virginia legislators.
    • 01:58:12
      We have lots of new people and
    • 01:58:14
      who have no history on any of this, who ran on fixing roads, who are going to glom onto this and say, well, let's go get that $30 pass up here.
    • 01:58:26
      And it's not appropriate.
    • 01:58:29
      You and I know that.
    • 01:58:30
      But it doesn't mean that they're not going to land there and then they'll be in a world of hurt.
    • 01:58:34
      And that may happen in Hampton too.
    • 01:58:36
      They have a lot of people of lesser means for whom these tolls are really an imposition and they don't have good options.
    • 01:58:43
      So again, I just, my plea is as you do this, help us not have the stupid conversation.
    • 01:58:52
      Help us have the right conversation about why or why not this is the right fit.
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:01
      So thank you, Madam Secretary.
    • 01:59:03
      So while I appreciate the perspectives that our members have regarding the individual recommendations,
    • 01:59:14
      I just want to clarify what we're being asked to do here, right?
    • 01:59:18
      I think what I understand is that we're being asked to endorse the report going to the General Assembly with regard to financing options.
    • 01:59:27
      Well first, recommendations on improvements and then how do you pay for them?
    • 01:59:31
      And ultimately the General Assembly will decide
    • 01:59:36
      which of those options that we'll pursue notwithstanding our preferences about these issues.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:59:43
      Madam Chair, Mr. Brown, I would say the thing the General Assembly explicitly asked you to endorse was a set of recommendations based on a data-driven needs assessment of the corridor.
    • 01:59:54
      That is like the number one ask
    • 01:59:56
      of that legislation.
    • 01:59:57
      Another ask, a major one in there is what are potential ways they could consider, and I want to stress the word they, could consider to finance these improvements.
    • 02:00:08
      I want to stress that we have presented them many options in the past as the executive branch and occasionally they've listened, but many other times they've chosen entirely different courses to do so.
    • 02:00:20
      And I think you saw the...
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:21
      It might not even be in this report.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:00:22
      You saw the Governor propose one way of funding WMATA and the General Assembly took half of it and then turned right when we asked them to go left.
    • 02:00:29
      And so again, there's 100 members of the House and 40 members of the Senate and it takes 51 in the House and 21 in the Senate that can get a vote for something that may or may not be something that's in this report.
    • 02:00:40
      Or it could be something entirely new.
    • Carlos M. BrownMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:41
      I'll finish just by saying this and why I agree and I'm sympathetic to Mrs. Hines' point and I think we ought to be educated because we then can be tools to educate our various delegations.
    • 02:00:52
      At the end of the day I kind of agree that the General Assembly will likely have its own mind about this and I think
    • 02:01:00
      Our concern, if there is, it should be whether or not we think there's something in the recommendations that we think it would be irresponsible to recommend.
    • 02:01:09
      And maybe that's what you're getting at, Ms. Hynes, but unless we believe that there's something that's irresponsible to recommend, I think that the team has done a very thoughtful kind of thinking outside and inside the box approach to how do you address these.
    • 02:01:25
      I've made it no secret that I'm a big fan of the regional authorities, that I've
    • 02:01:30
      Just last week I met with our regional transportation forum and with our MPOs and presented very much the same presentation with regard to the fact that projects are getting done around the state principally because of regional dollars and that if Hampton Road, I mean if the metropolitan Richmond area does not get on board we will be
    • 02:01:53
      The fourth region in the state to come on board if, in fact, the Stanton District or others decide to do this.
    • 02:02:01
      So, again, I'm sympathetic to the fact that we have preferences about this, but I think, ultimately, the General Assembly is going to decide, and our challenge here is do we believe there's something irresponsible in the report.
    • 02:02:12
      I don't.
    • 02:02:13
      There are things that I don't necessarily agree with, but I don't think they're irresponsible to recommend looking at things holistically, but I appreciate the work that the team has done in putting this together.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:23
      Part of what we're doing, and Mr. Williams knows this very well, is we're doing the homework to present to the General Assembly.
    • 02:02:33
      We were specifically asked about truck tolls, we were specifically asked to look at this, and so we are doing our due diligence trying to look at how we could possibly fund improvements along the 81 corridor.
    • 02:02:46
      I think we've learned a lot
    • 02:02:49
      Since HB 2313 had passed, I believe it was truly the expectation that this would solve a tremendous amount of funding needs across Virginia.
    • 02:03:03
      And what we found is that the impact of those revenues are actually diminishing.
    • 02:03:10
      You all were at a meeting last month when we had the Governor's Conference and you know when we started out with the first round of SMART SCALE we had a billion dollars, the second round we have 900 million and right now we're looking at diminishing numbers below 760,000.
    • 02:03:28
      And the point being that where we are today is not where we expected to be and so we are already undertaking
    • 02:03:44
      as part of 2019 and VTrans looking at how do we create sustainable funding and transportation.
    • 02:03:51
      It is a much bigger issue.
    • 02:03:53
      As part of this, we set up the regional authorities and Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads because of the fact we did not have enough revenues to address the infrastructure needs in these regions.
    • 02:04:04
      And the fact that you all who live there have to deal with
    • 02:04:11
      A tremendous congestion.
    • 02:04:13
      I was giving a report on 66.
    • 02:04:14
      2015, it was voted, and I quote, it was named the worst damn highway in America.
    • 02:04:24
      Seven and a half hours of congestion a day.
    • 02:04:28
      It is just not how people or businesses want to live.
    • 02:04:32
      So we're trying to find ways with extremely limited resources to solve problems, to solve infrastructure problems.
    • 02:04:41
      I put that as the backdrop that a few, maybe two months ago, I was at a forum with Secretary Pete Rahn from Maryland and Jeff Marucci and Director from DC.
    • 02:04:54
      We were on a panel and we were talking to this audience about the fact that we share this policy of wherever we are trying to move the most people, moving the most people that we possibly can for the lowest possible cost.
    • 02:05:09
      It's very targeted, our strategies are different, and as what Jeff Maruchian actually said, and they should be different, because we're trying to solve a problem moving the most people for the lowest possible cost.
    • 02:05:21
      This is an example of we're trying to find a targeted solution for a particular corridor that has 11,000 crashes over the last five years.
    • 02:05:33
      And when the delays happen, it is, you know, it's three to six hours.
    • 02:05:38
      Mr. Smoot, you can attest to what it is like.
    • 02:05:41
      It actually shuts the corridor down.
    • 02:05:43
      So in one area, we're dealing with a congestion, we're dealing with waterways, and
    • 02:05:50
      different issues, different congestion issues in Hampton Roads.
    • 02:05:53
      This is much more even though we're referring to as congestion is a reliability issue of this quarter.
    • 02:06:00
      So we're really trying to solve problems and that's what I think the whole intention behind this is.
    • 02:06:05
      I think Ms. Hines' point though is as we're going through this, as we're being asked to create this report, you know, how do we communicate
    • 02:06:19
      what our policies are, what we're trying to accomplish, and why the strategies do differ.
    • 02:06:25
      It's making sure we're all on board.
    • 02:06:26
      And I think your point is really, really good.
    • 02:06:29
      So I will think about how to do that.
    • 02:06:31
      We might need to consider setting up a task force to do exactly that, to look at these policies.
    • 02:06:37
      But it really is to solve problems, to be good stewards of a financial situation which is serious.
    • 02:06:48
      So right now we're trying to move this forward, but the context of this discussion I think is significant.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:57
      I don't want to belabor it, Madam Chairman, but may I say one last thing on this?
    • 02:07:02
      Some years back we actually flirted and talked about devolution here, meaning we were going to push these needs out to the localities and let them do it, which was insanity in my view.
    • 02:07:14
      And so what we did is we didn't raise enough revenue.
    • 02:07:16
      That's our basic problem.
    • 02:07:17
      So we couldn't do it.
    • 02:07:19
      So we sorta, sorta did devolution where Northern Virginia went off and did their own thing, raised their own money.
    • 02:07:26
      Hampton Roads went off and did their own thing, raised their own money.
    • 02:07:28
      Now we're talking about 81 going off and doing their own thing, raise their own money.
    • 02:07:32
      And so we have these inequities in policies and procedures and philosophies because we look at them area by area by area.
    • 02:07:43
      And I understand the need for that.
    • 02:07:44
      I get it.
    • 02:07:46
      But at the end of the day, we're all citizens of the Commonwealth.
    • 02:07:49
      I'm not a citizen of Hampton Roads or Northern Virginia or the Roanoke Valley.
    • 02:07:53
      I'm a citizen of the Commonwealth.
    • 02:07:55
      And what we ought to be telling legislators is
    • 02:07:58
      Respectfully, y'all created this problem.
    • 02:08:01
      We're just trying to help you solve it now.
    • 02:08:03
      If we'd raised the money that we needed to do what we need to do for the Commonwealth and its citizens at the Commonwealth level, we wouldn't be worried about all these little things that we have to do in each region and the inequities that that brings.
    • 02:08:18
      So I think y'all are doing a great job.
    • 02:08:22
      I don't disagree with a lot of the recommendations or stuff that's in the report,
    • 02:08:26
      But we are there because of the refusal of the General Assembly historically to provide the funds to do the work.
    • 02:08:34
      So we went off and did it on our own.
    • 02:08:37
      And now we're balkanizing again and that's just not a good way to do it.
    • 02:08:42
      But it's what we have and I think we're doing as best we can.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:44
      And I think the policies of this board are really important because as we are raising revenue and addressing issues in regions we do want to make sure that we're creating a platform that works.
    • 02:08:56
      Mr. Williams.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:57
      I just think it's important though to think back and what is your service required on this board and it's
    • 02:09:05
      As a board, not as individual members, we're free to lobby the legislature and tell them all sorts of things.
    • 02:09:13
      Philosophically, I totally agree with what you just said.
    • 02:09:15
      I hated to see it happen, but the legislature directed that it happen, and it happened, and that's who can make things happen.
    • 02:09:24
      And this is the same way this report that they've worked so diligently on, they asked us for a menu of items.
    • 02:09:32
      We're not going to make that selection and I would be extraordinarily uncomfortable for us as a board to tell them what's the right way to do this.
    • 02:09:40
      They're going to decide that.
    • 02:09:42
      They're going to decide the way they want to do it, whether it's the right way or the wrong way.
    • 02:09:46
      They may decide to do nothing, which is catastrophic in and of itself, but it's not this board's, the board duty to tell them that.
    • 02:09:58
      I'll call my friends there and tell them what I think.
    • 02:10:01
      I'm not advocating for that.
    • 02:10:04
      We're not an advocacy group.
    • 02:10:07
      And I wouldn't want to see the board try to be that.
    • 02:10:11
      I mean, I've looked at it from the other side, you know, as a legislator, and I've seen, been close with the governors that have looked at it from the other side, and that's not what they want from us.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:23
      Secretary?
    • 02:10:24
      Do we have comments on the plan, or are we still in?
    • 02:10:28
      We're still presenting.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:10:30
      Four more slides if.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:31
      Sorry, all right, Mr. Donohue.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:10:33
      So I'm going to go ahead and skip a few just to kind of get to the...
    • 02:10:37
      So Mr. Whitworth, you asked about the Annual Pass.
    • 02:10:39
      It's available to anyone that is driving a vehicle that is not defined as a heavy vehicle.
    • 02:10:44
      So that would be Class 1, which is a motorcycle, up through Class 5, which there's a picture on the chart on the previous slide there.
    • 02:10:50
      But if you're driving an SUV, you're driving a sedan, you're driving a motorcycle, you, whether you live in California or Bristol, would have the opportunity to purchase the Annual Pass if that's something you decided was worthwhile for you.
    • 02:11:04
      We did an economic impact analysis.
    • 02:11:06
      When I spoke to you last, that was in draft form.
    • 02:11:09
      We had made kind of rough assumptions about what a toll rate could be.
    • 02:11:12
      We have updated that with the specific recommendations, including the modifications recommended by Mr. Whitworth, Mr. Smoot, and Mr. Stinson, along with the specific tolling policy that I outlined for you several slides ago.
    • 02:11:26
      What we did in this economic impact analysis, and this was a requirement of the plan, is we took a look at reduced transportation costs that accrued to Virginia trucks and then looked at some of those impacts specifically by certain industries as was required by the legislation.
    • 02:11:43
      So we looked at the cost savings from reduced travel times
    • 02:11:47
      The cost savings from reduced fuel and labor costs due to travel time savings and monetary cost savings due to approximately 20 to 25 percent less incidents in this corridor on an annual basis.
    • 02:12:00
      We again did not include the cost of injuries or deaths because candidly those do not accrue to the specific business, they accrue to society.
    • 02:12:09
      We also did not include the benefits of
    • 02:12:13
      having a more reliable corridor and what I mean by that because this is so I say it clearly is we do obviously have the specific time savings and we but we also know that today if you're driving 200 miles or 300 miles you build in some buffer if you're doing kind of on-time goods delivery because you know that every fourth trip there's going to be some impact and you kind of spread that out over your trips
    • 02:12:39
      We know that number is going to be less than we have worked to try and quantify it.
    • 02:12:44
      We were not able to do that in a manner that gave us confidence about incorporating that benefit.
    • 02:12:49
      But I do know that if there's 20 to 25% less incidents on this roadway, that whatever that buffer you have to build into that trip will be less into the future for these companies that are making these deliveries.
    • 02:13:02
      And that also is not
    • 02:13:03
      included in this analysis.
    • 02:13:05
      So that's kind of my way of saying is we know there are other benefits, but we are sticking to ones we can very clearly identify and include in here to have a conservative estimate of the economic impacts to the Virginia trucks there.
    • 02:13:19
      And again, what is a Virginia truck?
    • 02:13:21
      It's a truck that starts somewhere else and stops in Virginia.
    • 02:13:24
      It's a truck that goes from two places in Virginia back and forth, or a truck that starts in Virginia and then goes somewhere else.
    • 02:13:31
      So overall, over a 40-year period in 2017 dollars, there are 3.4 billion dollars in reduced transportation costs that will accrue to Virginia trucks.
    • 02:13:43
      Those trucks are estimated to pay about 2.3 billion dollars in tolls over that time period for a net
    • 02:13:49
      transportation cost reduction benefit of 1.1 billion.
    • 02:13:54
      Expressed as a ratio, that's 1.49.
    • 02:13:57
      That is a positive economic output for those trucks using this corridor.
    • 02:14:02
      As we've said many times, our goal here is to improve the corridor for those using it and those paying for it.
    • 02:14:08
      If we had a plan before you that had a number less than one, I would ask you to reject it.
    • 02:14:13
      I'm happy to say that is not the case.
    • 02:14:15
      That was also by design that it's not the case.
    • 02:14:17
      We really focused on prioritizing the top problem areas and then the top cost-effective projects in those problem areas and that is why I think you see this positive number here before you.
    • 02:14:30
      The economists then did a second step where they took the net transportation cost reductions and converted those into direct economic impacts
    • 02:14:40
      And so what you see here is those impacts across all sectors and then specifically called out by the various industries that we were directed to examine in the legislation.
    • 02:14:51
      Again, agriculture, logistics, and manufacturing there.
    • 02:14:55
      And so again, these are the net benefits there.
    • 02:14:57
      As those were shown over a four-year period, these are also
    • 02:15:00
      over a 40-year period and again it's taking the net transportation costs and converting those into output, new value added and additional labor income across those sectors and in the industries.
    • 02:15:13
      This was done externally by a consultant who can do these things.
    • 02:15:17
      We did not do this in-house there but it's a firm that we've worked with many times, HDR who's done a lot of our federal grants and other things where this type of information is to be supplied.
    • 02:15:31
      So moving forward, tomorrow you have a resolution before you that would allow the Secretary to submit the report to the General Assembly.
    • 02:15:39
      As I said, the final report is still being, through drafting, is being reviewed to make sure all the content is 100% correct and there aren't spelling errors and other things of that nature.
    • 02:15:50
      The Executive Summary we will ensure you have now if you don't already have it.
    • 02:15:56
      If you vote in the affirmative tomorrow then we will ensure that a copy of this report is given to the General Assembly by no later than January 9th.
    • 02:16:03
      If you're wondering why January 9th, session starts on the 10th.
    • 02:16:06
      And the bill required that we submit this report no later than one day before the General Assembly starting.
    • 02:16:11
      Our goal of course would be to get it to them prior to then but we would make sure it was no later than January 9th.
    • 02:16:17
      So with that Madam Chair I'd be happy to answer any remaining questions.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:21
      Yes, going back to our discussion last week, and obviously Stinson wasn't here on Monday.
    • 02:16:29
      We talked about other issues on Tuesday, but I brought up the planning districts one and two not being included in the corridor.
    • 02:16:39
      Right now, as it stands, if you live in Tazewell County, you would not pay the additional tax.
    • 02:16:45
      But if you live in Bland, you would.
    • 02:16:47
      If you live in Russell County, Stinson though, you wouldn't pay for it.
    • 02:16:51
      Washington County, Smith County, you would, adjoining counties.
    • 02:16:54
      Scott County, you wouldn't be paying for it, and Washington County would pay for it.
    • 02:16:59
      I know you've probably got all the numbers and priority things baked into your report, what have you, but I would suggest, I want to hear from, obviously, our members, Mr. Stinson, is that we've got two state senators.
    • 02:17:10
      Ben Chaplin and Mr. Carrico, both your state senators from the areas, and looking at the rundown, they would have split areas.
    • 02:17:20
      One county would have additional tax, another county wouldn't have an additional tax, and I just wanna, since he represents that area, I just wanna see, would they have any difficulty, and I didn't talk about the delegates, but I just talked about the state senators, would they have any issues as far as one county having additional tax and another one?
    • 02:17:37
      Jerry?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 02:17:40
      I would imagine that there would be some disparity with part of the districts having to pay and some wouldn't.
    • 02:17:54
      Any tax that's not equally applied, typically there is going to be someone would not be happy.
    • 02:18:05
      I haven't heard either Senator comment directly on it.
    • 02:18:12
      and so it's an assumption on my part but it goes a whole lot to the discussions that went around the table here in the last few minutes using the example of some folks with a $30 pass and some folks with a $1100 pass so much along the same line as that so I would think that there would be some folks in districts that were asked to participate and others were not that
    • 02:18:42
      that they would most certainly hear from.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:44
      So you're in the districts, if they went with a regional gas tax or a sales tax, it would be for the whole district?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:19:00
      Planning district.
    • 02:19:03
      Yeah, well, and Madam Chair, Mr. Dodson, to your point, today we have many Senate and delegate districts that are partially within the Northern Virginia or Hampton Roads tax area and partially outside of it.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:13
      So, for example, and again, I'm not stating this as a discussion, discussion on 81.
    • 02:19:19
      I mean, I realize that.
    • 02:19:20
      I mean, I've been part of Virginia politics for 30 years.
    • 02:19:22
      I realize that it's split all over the place, but the discussion's on 81 now as far as this plan.
    • 02:19:29
      So if you want to, I'm just saying that I totally should pay the fare, okay?
    • 02:19:36
      And what have those counties, those seven counties out in that far southwest of January, which I've been to every county, they depend on 81 as much as Bath County doesn't have, doesn't get up against 81.
    • 02:19:50
      Allegheny County doesn't get up against 81.
    • 02:19:51
      They're in the different planning districts, but they include it in the proposal.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:19:57
      The rationale behind it is because I-81 does not run through planning districts one or two.
    • 02:20:03
      I'm not saying it's the perfect or right one.
    • 02:20:05
      It's simply the one we've made.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:07
      I'd say it's not too far.
    • 02:20:09
      Those seven counties depend on 81 as much.
    • 02:20:12
      Now, if you've been out, the barbers have been out in those counties.
    • 02:20:16
      They have.
    • 02:20:18
      Okay.
    • 02:20:19
      81 is vital for those economies.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:20:22
      I'm just simply letting you know how we derive that.
    • 02:20:24
      I would also say when I go out there in Buckhannon County, they talk about the Coalfields Expressway and they've never once raised 81 to me, which doesn't mean they don't benefit from it.
    • 02:20:32
      I'm just merely noting that I think there are many instances where the issues you raise could be noted.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:41
      I mean the people, I mean I don't live in that far southwest agenda.
    • 02:20:47
      Do you think they depend on the viability of 81, their relatives having crashes, I mean law enforcement, delay in traffic, you know all the problems of 81.
    • 02:20:59
      Do you hear problems about 81 where you live out in Russell County?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 02:21:05
      Certainly we do, and I will concede a point to Mr. Donohue.
    • 02:21:11
      He and I have been to Buchanan County, and we've heard about Coldfield Expressway, and I'd certainly be remiss if I didn't say something about that.
    • 02:21:20
      In all of our counties in southwest Virginia, we do depend on 81.
    • 02:21:25
      It is, and it's used by everyone there.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:32
      May I make a recommendation that we just include that as part of a consideration or a recommendation we could look at it to how this actually is drawn and considered is going to be out of our hands but we could certainly just that's all yet to be
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:21:48
      The General Assembly is not constrained by an advisory report by this board.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:53
      Yes.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:54
      I would doubt that the General Assembly is looking for more people to tax on this.
    • 02:21:57
      I would suggest that you tell them what they could get from it, but I doubt they'll be looking for it.
    • 02:22:02
      Can we get some more people in this?
    • 02:22:04
      I doubt they're going to be looking for that.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:06
      Mr. Donohue, can we get a copy of the report today or by this evening just on where we are, if it's being proofed?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:16
      Of the 11.7 million trucks a year how many of those trucks are coming through?
    • 02:22:32
      How many are not Virginia trucks?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:22:38
      Madam Chair, Mr. Whitworth, I know the percentages there, and it varies throughout the interstate, but it is, I believe, over, it's around, depending on what part of the quarter you're on, it's between 50 and 60% are through trucks, which is to say their original origin and final destination are outside of the Commonwealth.
    • 02:22:57
      And if you look at VMT, I believe that figure would be higher, because if you're driving all 325 miles versus between two points in Virginia, your trip is going to be a longer trip.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:08
      and which in my mind and there again this will be certainly I couldn't agree more that it's going to be the General Assembly's decision, rightly so.
    • 02:23:21
      But I do think that statistic and the fact that 42% of our interstate trucking is coming through that would speak to a favorable
    • 02:23:37
      financing through tolling rather than gas tax because of the amount of revenue that would be generated through out-of-state usage of it versus one versus the other.
    • 02:23:53
      I think that's where I was coming from to say isn't there some realistic reason to favor one over the other?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:24:06
      Again, I think many members of the board and many members of the legislature will have those options that they prefer.
    • 02:24:12
      What we will have available to them if you decide to approve the report tomorrow is information on who pays, how they pay, and how much is generated.
    • 02:24:21
      Again, as we've discussed many times, there are people who may prefer the sales tax for a whole host of reasons.
    • 02:24:27
      It's a broad-based tax and it's a small increment.
    • 02:24:29
      There are those who may not prefer the sales tax because the vast majority will be paid by in-state residents, whereas
    • 02:24:35
      When you look at the usage of the roadway, you don't have that same distribution.
    • 02:24:39
      I think what we will do, and I'm looking at the Madam Chair to tell me if I'm wrong here or to pull me back, is we will make sure we have those answers for the members of the Assembly.
    • 02:24:49
      Again, assuming that you all choose to approve this report tomorrow, we have that information and can provide that to them.
    • 02:24:55
      Some of them have already started to ask those types of questions, but yes, I would say tolling
    • 02:25:00
      By its very nature of being a per-mile user fee has a more direct relationship to usage of the facility than a broader base tax, which does not mean it is the better option or not.
    • 02:25:11
      That is just a factual statement.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:14
      An automobile driving from Pennsylvania through the state might put $50 of gas in the car, which would generate $2 of tax.
    • 02:25:28
      But toll-wise, it would generate $12, $14.
    • 02:25:31
      Is that correct?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:25:35
      I'm not as quick on math in my head with the gas one, but I know the toll figure is right.
    • 02:25:41
      Mr. Dodson.
    • Bert Dodson Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:42
      Can we stop and get a drink and some food?
    • 02:25:44
      That would be a sales tax too.
    • 02:25:45
      And those other states have a lot higher gas tax than we have now.
    • 02:25:49
      So the traveling public will be inclined to stop in Virginia even with additional tax compared to that.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:57
      Madam Chair, whenever transportation is discussed in the Salem District, and it is daily, the conversation quickly turns to the unreliability of Interstate 81.
    • 02:26:12
      And there is a plea from many different groups, civic groups, economic groups,
    • 02:26:21
      that something be done to address it.
    • 02:26:23
      I believe the plan that has been put before us today addresses quite well the concerns.
    • 02:26:32
      It is a data-driven plan.
    • 02:26:33
      It is a plan that has been through a number of iterations and public hearings.
    • 02:26:40
      It is not a perfect plan.
    • 02:26:41
      I doubt there is a perfect plan.
    • 02:26:44
      I think the plan has been strengthened by some of the matters that have been raised in the room this morning by different members of the board.
    • 02:26:53
      But I hope that we will decide to move forward with this when it comes before us tomorrow.
    • 02:27:02
      It will do a lot to
    • 02:27:05
      restore credibility to responsiveness to a major transportation issue in the Salem District and I think in others too.
    • 02:27:15
      As Shep helped us understand, different districts, different areas have different situations.
    • 02:27:24
      The fact is that when you look at the traffic out on 81,
    • 02:27:29
      A lot of it is pass-through traffic.
    • 02:27:32
      If you look at the traffic on I-66, for example, most of it is relatively local traffic.
    • 02:27:40
      Another important difference is that the reliability issue is random on I-81.
    • 02:27:48
      One can drive down I-66 as I do periodically, and you can count on if you're there at 8 o'clock, it's going to be terrible.
    • 02:27:57
      But if you're there at 5 o'clock, and I know it's a lot more than that, there are going to be real challenges.
    • 02:28:03
      I-81 is very different from that.
    • 02:28:06
      You might be there at 8 o'clock in the morning, and everything's great.
    • 02:28:11
      and at 11 a.m. it's terrible but it's random because it tends to be incident created rather than volume created.
    • 02:28:21
      So all in all I appreciate very much the extensive work that has gone into this.
    • 02:28:27
      I've had several great conversations with the Salem District staff who I know have given a great deal of attention to the Salem District and I hope that we can move forward with this tomorrow.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:42
      Okay, well thank you Mr. Smoot.
    • 02:28:43
      I see your district engineer back there, Ken Kang.
    • 02:28:46
      I'm sure he's really happy to hear that.
    • 02:28:48
      Anything else?
    • 02:28:51
      Okay, we will adjourn for lunch.
    • 02:28:54
      And so, what is the plan?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 02:28:57
      Lunch is in our normal venue right down the hall over in the HR training room.
    • 02:29:01
      It's already set up.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:03
      Okay, we are going to reconvene at 1.15 and at 12.55 or 1 o'clock I'm going to ask that Mr. Johnson, Mr. Malbon, Mr. Miller join Nick Mortese and me maybe in this back corner and if I could find a quiet room we'll do that too.
    • 03:30:42
      We are a few minutes late.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:45
      Anyway, we're back.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:46
      Thank you, Mary Hynes.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:47
      You saved us.
    • 03:30:48
      You're welcome, Madam Secretary.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:50
      We were passing out a letter, but we did divide.
    • 03:30:53
      We divided and conquered.
    • 03:30:55
      So before we go on to the next presentation, I'm going to ask the commissioner to share some information.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:31:02
      So during the last presentation with regard to I-81, Mr. Johnson asked the question about distracted driving along the corridor for the interstate.
    • 03:31:12
      So staff worked during the presentation to give me the updated statistics for the last five years.
    • 03:31:20
      We had, as the presentation showed, approximately 11,518 crashes along the corridor for a five-year period.
    • 03:31:29
      Of those, 14% were considered distracted driving, which is about 1,600 crashes.
    • 03:31:35
      Out of those 1,600 crashes, 492 can be associated or involved a truck.
    • 03:31:45
      So truck-involved crashes that were labeled as distracted only represent 4% of the overall crashes, but a third of the distracted crashes that are out there.
    • 03:31:59
      But I do need to say that just because it's
    • 03:32:03
      A truck-involved crash does not insinuate that the truck was at fault for that, so I don't have those statistics in front of me for who was charged in the violation, but certainly the quick breakdown is again 11,500 crashes, about 1,600 distracted total, and about 500 truck-involved distracted driving for the five-year period.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:33
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:32:42
      And with that, we're going to have Mr. Tucker.
    • 03:32:51
      Hello.
    • Chad TuckerSMART SCALE Program Manager
    • 03:32:52
      Good afternoon, Madam Secretary, members of the board.
    • 03:32:55
      I'm here to give a brief update on SmartScale.
    • 03:33:01
      A couple of things I'm going to be going over are just general statistics related to round three, the results of the validation and screening process, a general observation about round three, and then next steps.
    • 03:33:17
      So it is a very brief presentation.
    • 03:33:21
      So just to kind of recap what I presented to you back in September, this is a breakdown of the applications that were received for SMART SCALE this round.
    • 03:33:29
      There were 468 total applications.
    • 03:33:33
      Here's a breakdown of the number of applications per district and we've included information on the SMART SCALE requested amount for each district as well as the total project cost for each district, which would include leverage funding or previous allocations being brought to bear on those particular projects.
    • 03:33:53
      As a reminder, it is estimated somewhere around 800 million will be available for round three and of course that's going to be split between the statewide high priority pot and the district grant program.
    • 03:34:11
      Screen out decisions by round just to so you have a point of reference these are the number of applications that were screened out in rounds one two and then in the current round by district you'll see the general trend is
    • 03:34:29
      The numbers are going down, so in round one we had 321 applications were submitted and there were 34 applications that were screened out.
    • 03:34:38
      A little over 10%.
    • 03:34:43
      In round two, the number of applications went up rather significantly.
    • 03:34:48
      We got 437 applications that round, and we screened out 33.
    • 03:34:53
      So the percentage went down to 7.6%.
    • 03:34:56
      In this current round, the total number of applications is 468, and we're recommending 23 of those be screened out.
    • 03:35:08
      Three reasons, and just as a reminder, there are three main reasons to screen a project out.
    • 03:35:13
      It doesn't meet a VTrans need, the project is not eligible for SmartScale, or the project is not deemed to be ready.
    • 03:35:22
      There's additional work that needs to be done to that particular project to meet the readiness bars that have been established by this board.
    • 03:35:31
      So I'm going to come back to the 4.9% here because the numbers do look good, but there is a caveat that I do want to share with the board as a whole.
    • 03:35:40
      In round three for screening decisions, this is a breakdown for each district of the 23 total applications to be recommended to screen out.
    • 03:35:52
      So there are four projects in Bristol District and each of you should have a handout and this is going to be posted publicly on the website.
    • 03:36:01
      The details on each of the specific projects that are being recommended to screen out.
    • 03:36:05
      On the far right of this slide, what you're going to see are the reasons the projects are being screened out.
    • 03:36:12
      And there are several projects that are being screened out for more than one reason, which is why those numbers will often total up to a number greater than the number of applications being screened out.
    • 03:36:24
      There are two projects where the screening decision is pending and both of those projects are in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:36:32
      It's the Route 28 corridor in Manassas and the Soapstone Connector.
    • 03:36:38
      We're still working through some of the readiness concerns related to those projects.
    • 03:36:42
      There are four applications that have been withdrawn by the applicant.
    • 03:36:47
      There are two by Fred Transit and two in Portsmouth that the applicant did not intend to be submitted.
    • 03:36:54
      And there are also two applications where alternative funding source has been identified.
    • 03:37:03
      That's sort of a breakdown for each district of the number of applications being screened out.
    • 03:37:09
      So all in all, you know, a very successful round compared to previous rounds.
    • 03:37:15
      I just want to spend a couple minutes talking about project readiness.
    • 03:37:19
      So, as you'll remember, the changes for round three included extending the amount of time that we have once the final applications are submitted.
    • 03:37:31
      It went from three months to five months, so there were two extra months built into the process.
    • 03:37:36
      I would say had that not occurred, the number of projects that would have been screened out would have been significantly higher than what we're bringing here today.
    • 03:37:45
      And it's really a testament to the staff at VDOT, both in the district as well as here in the central office and L&D and in planning, of working with the applicants to address a lot of the readiness issues that we're seeing when the applications were originally submitted.
    • 03:38:04
      The most common issues were, if you remember, the board strengthened the policy that if an applicant was submitting a project that was deemed to be a major widening or a roadway on new location, that they had to demonstrate that they had gone through a planning process that showed that they at least considered and looked at ways to improve the existing network and the existing capacity.
    • 03:38:29
      That was an area of weakness in a number of the applications.
    • 03:38:33
      that needed to be worked through new interchanges and traffic signals, a signal needing to meet signal warrants and have gone through a signal justification process.
    • 03:38:47
      There were a number of applications that had those issues that folks with the state worked with the applicants over the past several months to address those issues.
    • 03:38:57
      So 56% of the projects on the screen out list are being screened out for that project readiness issues.
    • 03:39:05
      And project readiness is really critical to ensure that the scope of the project doesn't change in the future as well as that the cost estimate is reasonable.
    • 03:39:16
      And a lot of these larger type improvements, heavy capacity expansion projects really needed some additional work.
    • 03:39:25
      So that two extra months really came in handy.
    • 03:39:28
      As far as next steps, the plan is on January 15th, we are going to come back to the board with the results of the scoring process.
    • 03:39:40
      February through April will essentially be taking the staff recommended funding scenario that we're going to bring in January and really the board making decisions on what projects to fund.
    • 03:39:53
      Are there any
    • 03:39:55
      projects that they potentially would want to fund out of order and what the justification is for the final adoption of the next six-year improvement program occurring in June, as usual.
    • 03:40:06
      And so with that, I'll take any questions you may have.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:12
      Questions, thoughts?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:15
      That $800 million is for the two years, is that correct?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:21
      I do want you to know that the forecasts are going down.
    • 03:40:26
      Not a final number, but we've been warned.
    • 03:40:35
      Mr. Connors?
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:37
      What's the appeals process on some of these that were screened out?
    • 03:40:45
      When will these be funded?
    • 03:40:47
      What funding year are these?
    • Chad TuckerSMART SCALE Program Manager
    • 03:40:50
      We're talking fiscal year or 2020?
    • 03:40:52
      2020.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:53
      Yeah.
    • Chad TuckerSMART SCALE Program Manager
    • 03:40:55
      And that's correct, right?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:40:57
      So the projects, the funding that is set aside in terms of volume of funds available is based on the six-year program.
    • 03:41:06
      However, that does not mean a product is necessarily going to be funded in the fifth and sixth.
    • 03:41:12
      I think the amount of money we have available is that that's the total amount.
    • 03:41:16
      Based on the actual schedule of projects from round one and round two, some of the projects, particularly in round two, might still need funding in FY23, which then means there will be available funding in 21 or 22, and so you may see some products from round three that can get funding sooner, but the funding is
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:41:38
      I just want to talk to you about the Fredericksburg project that was screened out in more detail.
    • 03:41:44
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:41:46
      Thank you.
    • 03:41:47
      Anyone else?
    • 03:41:50
      But if anyone has specific questions from their district, they can reach out to you.
    • Chad TuckerSMART SCALE Program Manager
    • 03:41:55
      That means yes.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:41:56
      Okay.
    • 03:41:56
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:41:59
      Next up we have Jennifer DeBruhl, and Jennifer I need to step out for a moment with Alison DeTuncq, and she might not even know this, but you and I need to sign some papers.
    • 03:42:11
      And so I'm going to turn this over to our Vice Chair.
    • 03:42:14
      Do not let him make any funding amendments while I'm gone.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:42:21
      What are we voting on?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlChief of Public Transportation
    • 03:42:28
      Good afternoon Madam Secretary and members of the board.
    • 03:42:37
      This is the most recent update on our series of transit funding reforms that were passed by the General Assembly earlier this year.
    • 03:42:45
      I'm going to walk you through our current status on the operating allocation changes that were prescribed by legislation in the presentation today.
    • 03:42:53
      So as a refresher, I'll start off and say that the code language that was changed as part of the transportation package requires us to transition to a operating allocation formula that's 100% based on performance factors for fiscal year 2020.
    • 03:43:20
      All right, there we go.
    • 03:43:21
      So this work is not something new to the transit community.
    • 03:43:26
      Actually, there was work that began as far back as 2011, incorporating different performance measures into the operating allocation formula.
    • 03:43:34
      The change with this particular legislation is the move to 100% of the allocation being based on performance factors.
    • 03:43:44
      I'd like to start off and give you a little bit of a background about how our funds are allocated under the current formula.
    • 03:43:51
      There are really two parts to our funding allocation formula.
    • 03:43:56
      There's what is called the traditional funding formula, which accounts for roughly two-thirds
    • 03:44:01
      of the funds that are allocated under our operating assistance program and that allocation is based on a proportion of operating expenses.
    • 03:44:09
      So that is just basically how big an agency's budget is and what proportion of the overall program that they represent.
    • 03:44:17
      The other third of the program has been allocated based on performance.
    • 03:44:21
      There are two factors to that performance-based funding.
    • 03:44:24
      There are two measures that are used for sizing, and I'll explain sizing to you in a little bit more detail in a couple of minutes, and then an adjustment based on three performance factors.
    • 03:44:36
      Those two elements of the program come together to sum up to be the total operating assistance allocation per agency, and that's what we've used for the past several years.
    • 03:44:47
      So we are working with the Transit Service Delivery Advisory Committee on developing this new approach.
    • 03:44:53
      We started out with the TSDAC back in September and recognizing that any time you're changing allocations, you're going to have some folks that are going to come out on the winning end and some folks that are not going to come out on the winning end because our budget isn't changing.
    • 03:45:06
      That is completely different than the situation when the performance factors were added to the formula a few years ago.
    • 03:45:13
      So rather than jump into scenarios and different ways to allocate funding, we started out with the TSDAC and had a discussion about what are we trying to achieve with the program or what are our policy objectives.
    • 03:45:24
      And working with the TSDAC, we came up with the following list of policy objectives.
    • 03:45:28
      Obviously, we want to promote fiscal responsibility.
    • 03:45:31
      We want folks to have efficient operations.
    • 03:45:34
      We want to support robust transit service and reward higher patronage.
    • 03:45:39
      We want to promote mobility.
    • 03:45:40
      We want to support a social safety net, recognizing that some of our users, this is their only mode of transportation.
    • 03:45:48
      And we need to find something that works where data exists on a level playing field for all agencies that receive funding through the formula.
    • 03:45:57
      So with that as the backdrop, we also talked about some of the challenges that come with switching to a performance-based allocation process.
    • 03:46:06
      Primarily those come from data.
    • 03:46:08
      Our systems range from the largest one that is in the side of the formula is Hampton Roads Transit and the smallest is Greensville Area Transit that runs two routes.
    • 03:46:19
      So we're dealing with very diverse systems that have different types of data, different levels of sophistication.
    • 03:46:26
      So we started off and we said we need to work with data that's available.
    • 03:46:30
      Something that's already collected, reported, something that can be reviewed for quality control to make sure that it's reliable and consistent and timely.
    • 03:46:40
      Something that's based on an agreed upon set of standards and the data can be validated.
    • 03:46:46
      We also talked a lot over the past few months about the diversity in system and service characteristics.
    • 03:46:52
      I mentioned that everything from Hampton Roads to Greensville County, but we also have systems that provide different types of service.
    • 03:47:00
      We have systems that provide fixed route service, we have commuter bus routes, we have demand responsive rural transit, and we have light rail and heavy commuter rail, all part of the same formula.
    • 03:47:11
      So that does present some challenges as well.
    • 03:47:15
      When we started looking at metrics, we really saw four potential areas for metrics that could be used for a performance-based funding allocation.
    • 03:47:25
      Obviously, we have cost metrics that are part of our current formula.
    • 03:47:30
      There are delivered service metrics that look at what type of service is being provided, how much service is being provided.
    • 03:47:37
      Clearly ridership is important, and we also identified the potential for service area characteristics to be part of those metrics.
    • 03:47:46
      We moved forward and looked at cost metrics, delivered service and ridership in more detail.
    • 03:47:52
      We did eliminate service area characteristics fairly quickly in the process because in looking at service area, you're talking about population or the size of a particular area.
    • 03:48:04
      It could be compared, but it doesn't necessarily
    • 03:48:06
      So as I mentioned in that earlier flow chart slide, there are really two elements to our performance side of our existing allocation process and what we see as a good way to move forward.
    • 03:48:28
      There are sizing metrics, and those sizing metrics were designed originally to account for this diversity of systems.
    • 03:48:36
      to look at the relative scale and scope of operations across diverse agencies.
    • 03:48:40
      So that's important to keep in that formula.
    • 03:48:44
      So we're going to talk about sizing metrics in more detail in a minute.
    • 03:48:47
      The performance metrics piece is a method to adjust the allocation to reward that exceptional performance as compared to statewide averages.
    • 03:48:55
      And so those are making adjustments kind of as a second step of the process.
    • 03:49:01
      To eliminate, and again this is something we're using now and we see continuing going forward, to eliminate those one-year swings, and there can be one-year swings in performance data, all of our metrics are calculated using a three-year rolling average.
    • 03:49:15
      So that smooths that out over time and really gives us a better opportunity to look at trends.
    • 03:49:23
      So as we started to look at some potential sizing metrics and also with performance metrics, we always tied everything that we were looking at back to the policy objectives.
    • 03:49:34
      So the chart on the screen is an example.
    • 03:49:36
      I'm showing you a slide that we've shared with TSDAC and it's there as an example to show you that everything that we considered as potential metrics or measures to use in the formula, we did tie back to those seven policy objectives that the TSDAC established at the outset.
    • 03:49:54
      We determined early on in looking at the different types of systems, and again sizing is to take, the sizing part of the formula is to take that into account, that there was one real outlier in the process, and that was the Virginia Railway Express, which is commuter rail.
    • 03:50:11
      It's very different in terms of a service profile than our bus operated systems.
    • 03:50:16
      It is the entirety of Virginia Railway Express.
    • 03:50:19
      They don't operate anything but commuter rail.
    • 03:50:22
      And we realized that there was probably a need to take a slightly different look at commuter rail just for the purpose of sizing.
    • 03:50:30
      So the recommendation that came through the TSDAC and that we share with you today is that we would take a slightly different approach to calculating basically the size of the pool that's attributed to commuter rail based on passenger miles traveled, revenue
    • 03:50:46
      hours and revenue vehicle miles.
    • 03:50:49
      And so using that we were able to calculate
    • 03:50:53
      A portion of the total revenue that is available for the purposes of funding commuter rail.
    • 03:51:00
      This does not pull VRE out into a separate pool or pull them out into separate from the performance allocation process.
    • 03:51:07
      It is simply a different ways to size them, but the performance adjustment factors and the statewide averages apply to VRE as well, the same as the bus operations.
    • 03:51:17
      It's simply an opportunity to look at them as slightly different because their service profile is so different.
    • 03:51:23
      So moving to the performance piece or the performance metrics piece of that performance side of the formula, we did the same thing that we did with sizing.
    • 03:51:33
      We came up with a series of potential metrics and then we tied those back to the policy objectives looking to find some alignment opportunities to do that performance adjustment to the formula.
    • 03:51:51
      As we went through this process, we ran literally dozens of scenarios.
    • 03:51:56
      I think we might have been, we probably presented somewhere over a dozen, maybe a dozen and a half to TSDAC, but I think we probably ran close to a hundred just looking at different options and tweaking things.
    • 03:52:09
      So we started to see some trends.
    • 03:52:11
      So one of the things that jumped out very quickly to us is that, you know, again, we're applying a formula across a very broad and diverse program.
    • 03:52:21
      and we're going from using basically applying a third of our funding through performance metrics to all of the funding.
    • 03:52:27
      So there were some things that jumped out quickly as unintended consequences.
    • 03:52:32
      One of the things that we saw is particularly for some of the smaller agencies in the state that have relatively low cost operating cost profiles but they have growing ridership that we started seeing these really big unanticipated jumps in what their allocations would be.
    • 03:52:48
      More funding than they could lives.
    • 03:52:52
      They have other funding that's available to them, federal funding and local funding.
    • 03:52:56
      It just, we saw some anomalies.
    • 03:52:59
      And as part of that in discussion with TSDAC and what is in the recommendation that we're preparing in our draft policy is to apply a cap to the percentage of an agency's operating costs that could be supported with state operating assistance.
    • 03:53:15
      If you look at the fiscal year 19 operating allocations as a share of that percentage of the agency's operating costs, we see a range from about 18% to 32% of an agency's operating costs that's covered by state operating assistance.
    • 03:53:30
      The average is 22%.
    • 03:53:33
      If we applied and what we're recommending is a 30% cap, there would be one agency that would receive less or that would be impacted by that that had that 32%
    • 03:53:44
      cost recovery last year.
    • 03:53:47
      But by applying a cap to what the state's percentage of funding could be, it's going to eliminate those large swings for individual agencies and it's going to allow us to have a similar proportion of state funding across agencies.
    • 03:54:02
      What we envision is a way to level out the program and we could take the funds that are above that cap, and they're generally pretty small amounts, but those could be reallocated back through the formula to all the other agencies to get that performance-based funding complete.
    • 03:54:21
      I'll show you how this ties back in in a graphic in a minute.
    • 03:54:26
      In the beginning, I showed you a chart that had two sides.
    • 03:54:31
      This is the new and what we are proposing as the operating assistance methodology.
    • 03:54:37
      You'll see we're in one single column that's all performance-based funding.
    • 03:54:41
      It is similar to what was on the right side of that current chart.
    • 03:54:45
      We have sizing metrics.
    • 03:54:46
      We have performance adjustments.
    • 03:54:48
      But we do have a couple of changes, and I'll walk you through those briefly.
    • 03:54:52
      For sizing metrics, our current formula has two sizing metrics.
    • 03:54:56
      That's operating cost and ridership.
    • 03:54:59
      Part of the discussion through the TSDAC was that that may not, with 100% of the formula funding going through performance, that may not capture all of the diversity in systems
    • 03:55:11
      that may be negatively impacted may have a different service profile that's not captured in the allocation formula.
    • 03:55:21
      So what we're recommending is
    • 03:55:23
      50% based on operating costs, which is consistent with our current formula, 30% based on ridership, and then 10% each based on revenue vehicle hours, so that's a function of how much service is provided in terms of the hours of operation, and revenue vehicle miles, which is a measure of how much service is provided based on the number of miles that those vehicles travel.
    • 03:55:47
      You'll see commuter rail, that sizing metric off to the side and the tie back into performance adjustments.
    • 03:55:53
      So once we go through that sizing for all of the agencies, we would go through and adjust those allocations based on performance.
    • 03:56:02
      Right now we have three measures of performance and our recommendation is to go to five measures of performance.
    • 03:56:08
      They are all built off of the data points out of the sizing metrics.
    • 03:56:12
      So we're using, it's basically four points of data, but what we're looking at is the relationship between passengers and service and operating costs and service and then passengers and service.
    • 03:56:24
      So, for those performance adjustments, we're recommending that they each be weighted at 20%, that we'd have passengers, or the number of ridership by revenue vehicle hour, so that's how many passengers you're providing per revenue vehicle hour, passengers per revenue vehicle mile, so that's how many passengers you're moving per revenue vehicle mile, your operating cost divided by revenue vehicle hour, and then revenue vehicle mile, and then finally the operating cost,
    • 03:56:54
      divided by your number of passengers or your ridership.
    • 03:56:57
      Once we get through that tier of the formula, we would then recommend applying that 30% cap.
    • 03:57:03
      Any residual funds that would go unallocated after applying the cap would go back to the top of the formula, go back through until we end up with every available dollar for operating assistance allocated per agency.
    • 03:57:19
      So I recognize this is really, we've worked on it a lot so it's really complex to walk through in front of the board.
    • 03:57:26
      I will say that the TSDAC did vote on that recommendation yesterday and the one thing that we've heard consistently from TSDAC through this process
    • 03:57:38
      is that there is a need for a transition plan.
    • 03:57:41
      This is a significant change to go from a third of the formula being performance or allocated based on performance to 100%.
    • 03:57:50
      The way the code is structured, the language provides for a one-year notification prior to any implementation or prior to implementation of any new measures by the board.
    • 03:58:01
      The way that the legislative change was drafted and the enactment clauses that were tied to it provided an exception for fiscal year 19, but did not provide an exception for fiscal year 20, meaning that this 100% based on performance has to go into effect in fiscal year 20.
    • 03:58:20
      We are deep into the annual budget process for transit agencies, for local governments.
    • 03:58:27
      Potentially is a big change.
    • 03:58:29
      So we did receive a request fairly early on to look at how could we phase the implementation or look to mitigate potential negative impacts that are coming late in the budget cycle.
    • 03:58:42
      So what we have, and I'll walk you through this in the next slide, is a set of modified metrics that we're recommending would apply to fiscal year 20 funding only that would ease that transition for those agencies that are most negatively
    • 03:58:59
      The process that was outlined in that last chart taking effect in 2021.
    • 03:59:05
      Yesterday the TSDAC did request that we consider and present to you the potential of an additional transition year in fiscal year 2021 with modified metrics that step towards that final recommendation.
    • 03:59:21
      So I will go back to the graphic.
    • 03:59:24
      And so the change that we're recommending just for this transition year in fiscal year 20 is the blocks that are highlighted in yellow.
    • 03:59:33
      There is a slight change, and that is to increase the percentage that is
    • 03:59:39
      The percentage of the sizing metric based on operating costs is 60% and reduce ridership from 30% to 20% just for fiscal year 20.
    • 03:59:49
      That is our staff recommendation to the board.
    • 03:59:54
      TSDAC did request that there be additional consideration once we get through the fiscal year 20 cycle and see
    • 04:00:00
      While this plays out with complete performance data that agencies will be reporting the first of February and potentially consider an additional transition year 2021 that would modify those two yellow blocks again and make them 55 and 25 as we step towards that final staff recommended proposed allocation methodology.
    • 04:00:27
      So with that, I know I've walked through a lot of detail on a lot of flow charts.
    • 04:00:33
      This is your first workshop briefing on the operating allocation.
    • 04:00:37
      We are working on a draft CTB policy that we plan to release for public comment mid-December.
    • 04:00:46
      That needs to go out for a 45-day public comment period.
    • 04:00:49
      We're following the same process that we did on the capital and on the strategic planning work.
    • 04:00:56
      That we would come back to you in January with another workshop briefing on that draft CTB policy.
    • 04:01:02
      We can give you an update on where we are with the public comment at that point with the intention of bringing back the CTB policy for action at your February meeting.
    • 04:01:12
      And with that, I would be happy to answer any questions.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:19
      Questions?
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:20
      Mr. Chairman, if I might, Mr. Vice Chairman.
    • 04:01:24
      Jennifer, just remind us, is this something where we then have to send it to the legislature or this is entirely within our purview?
    • 04:01:34
      If we wanted to pursue the second year extension that I know many Antistacs supported sort of taking two years to transition instead of one, would we have to go back to the General Assembly?
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:50
      The legislation, it's a little bit schizophrenic in the legislation, but it does allow for this one year period, but it says very clearly that these changes have to go into effect in FY20.
    • 04:02:03
      And so, the reason we recommended one year of transition is because we believe that
    • 04:02:13
      really meets the intent of the legislators to get this into place in a year, but with some easing into it.
    • 04:02:19
      Two years, in my opinion, pushes that a little bit too much, but I will say as well, when you start to break down the impacts of these on a jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction basis, the impacts are not always so extreme, but it's, again, it was our recommendation to have a one-year transition period, so, as opposed to two.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlChief of Public Transportation
    • 04:02:41
      Based on the discussion with TSDAC yesterday, what we've drafted for CTB's consideration in the draft policy shows the one-year transition with some language that there be consideration of an additional year once we see how this really happens, how this really plays out.
    • 04:02:56
      We'll have another year of performance data so that three-year rolling average is going to change.
    • 04:03:02
      It gives us time.
    • 04:03:03
      We don't have to commit to a second year or have that conversation right now.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:08
      So I appreciate that and as I think some people know I've been kind of following from afar so I have the advantage of having seen the same kind of iterations that Mr. Connor has seen and you have kindly played this out on various systems so I'm aware of that and you know
    • 04:03:28
      I hope when you come next time that we'll talk about some of that.
    • 04:03:32
      But I do want to express one concern that I have.
    • 04:03:37
      And I appreciate that you all decided in the service area characteristics that there really wasn't a whole lot that you could do that would actually influence
    • 04:03:51
      How this would work.
    • 04:03:52
      But I want to raise an issue and perhaps you've discussed it and I missed it but I think it's worthy of conversation.
    • 04:03:59
      I was on the school board for many, many years and in Northern Virginia the cost of hiring a teacher is considerably more than it is in other parts of the state.
    • 04:04:08
      And so there's a differential that the General Assembly has applied to school aid in Northern Virginia and they call it the cost of competing.
    • 04:04:18
      And the bus driver market is equally challenging in certain parts of the state.
    • 04:04:24
      Unemployment's very low.
    • 04:04:26
      People have to have a CDL.
    • 04:04:28
      They have to pass a drug test.
    • 04:04:29
      If they're driving a bus all day, it's a different kind of thing than driving a school bus even where you have the middle of the day off.
    • 04:04:36
      And I really, I wonder, because I don't think this difference is a thing that goes away.
    • 04:04:44
      Your population can change, your configuration of development can change, but your need for labor, this is a very labor-intensive business.
    • 04:04:54
      And so I really do wonder whether we are adequately capturing this thing over which bus systems have no control, which is how much do I have to pay in the market to get that qualified person to drive the bus in a safe manner so that all these people get to the places they need to go on time.
    • 04:05:17
      And so I raise that as an issue for you to tell us how you all have been thinking about it, but also to tell us how that is reflected in what you're presenting.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:05:31
      Some of that is reflected in the fact that 50% of the formula is still based on operating costs, which will reflect labor costs.
    • 04:05:38
      I can say we've been doing some research as well that I'd be happy to share with you all on systems and what their cost per rider is.
    • 04:05:45
      There's actually, we're not seeing a trend where it's so much higher in Northern Virginia compared to other parts of Northern Virginia.
    • 04:05:52
      For example, Arlington and Alexandria's system have very low cost per rider, Fairfax's is very high.
    • 04:05:58
      And so even within Northern Virginia there's some disparities there, so it's not quite as uniform within one region compared to others.
    • 04:06:08
      And there's different reasons for that, I'm sure, because there's a lot of different components of operating cost and ridership.
    • 04:06:14
      But like I said, it's not necessarily uniform even within a high-cost labor market like Northern Virginia.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:06:25
      I do serve on the TSDAC subcommittee and I really appreciate the hard work that Jennifer Mitchell and Jennifer DeBruhl and staff put into this and the members too.
    • 04:06:37
      I was very impressed with the knowledge in the room and I learned a lot about transit including the fact that
    • 04:06:43
      Every part of the state, when we talk to the Journal Assembly, every part of the state is benefiting from increased use in transit and I think, quite frankly, there needs to be more investment in transit.
    • 04:06:55
      Blacksburg is a growth area because of mainly Virginia Tech student usage and the utility they see in transit down there.
    • 04:07:06
      There were issues that came up about operating costs and the differences in the operating costs.
    • 04:07:13
      I wish we had remembered the cost of competing phrases.
    • 04:07:16
      I remember that on my supervisor days talking about school funding.
    • 04:07:22
      I do think that's going to be, I think you're going to hear more about that in the 45-day comment period.
    • 04:07:27
      There is a 45-day comment period, so all of those folks who are interested in transit should
    • 04:07:33
      I look at this very closely because it is a new way of doing business and I totally agree with what we're trying to do here, but there is room probably for improvement as these comments come in.
    • 04:07:44
      And I think that what I've noticed is there's a willingness to listen and do the hard work and get this right.
    • 04:07:52
      And it's probably not going to be like SMART SCALE.
    • 04:07:54
      We're not going to probably get it right the first time out.
    • 04:07:56
      So we have to adjust it again, perhaps.
    • 04:07:59
      And I think that's well within our purview as well.
    • 04:08:02
      So I want to just again reiterate the hard work that went into this.
    • 04:08:05
      And I'm really impressed with the knowledge on DRPT staff and around the state.
    • 04:08:12
      We've got some good people working on this.
    • 04:08:14
      Thank you.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:17
      Any other comments?
    • 04:08:20
      Thank you, Mr. DeBruhl.
    • 04:08:24
      Secretary said she'd see us at dinner.
    • 04:08:29
      Okay, Garrett, you want to address vital infrastructure?
    • 04:08:40
      She left.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:08:44
      Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 04:08:48
      As a note, before we start with the short presentation, we sent this out a week ago Monday, the current version of the draft.
    • 04:08:58
      It has not changed since then, and we called everybody and either left a message.
    • 04:09:04
      I think we talked to most everybody so that you could have a detailed look at it.
    • 04:09:08
      In the end, this will be the Commonwealth Transportation Board's report, not VDOT's report.
    • 04:09:13
      And we have a list of comments that we're still working on.
    • 04:09:16
      We've still gotten them as recently as today.
    • 04:09:18
      So if you have some, there's still time for us to incorporate.
    • 04:09:22
      None of those that we've seen so far, though, really changes the outcome or the main body of the report.
    • 04:09:28
      So let me go ahead and get started.
    • 04:09:35
      These are the five general topics that we're going to talk about.
    • 04:09:40
      Some of this, as you can tell, kind of recaps what we did last time we met.
    • 04:09:48
      Let me give you the general overview of how we got where we are.
    • 04:09:53
      And I think Mr. Miller is one of those that probably remembers maybe Mr. Whitworth as well.
    • 04:10:00
      In 2013,
    • 04:10:02
      As I took over this position end of 2012,
    • 04:10:06
      We were recovering, I say recovering, starting to recover parts of the system.
    • 04:10:12
      We had had 295, 95, 85, and most visibly, 64 and 264 sections of pavement had badly failed.
    • 04:10:21
      I mean, they called it potholes, but really we had segments that had been lost, and we were in a different position then.
    • 04:10:28
      And somehow that had snuck up on the department, and at that point in time,
    • 04:10:32
      My biggest concern was somewhat getting through the next few months and making sure that we could recover the system faster than it deteriorated.
    • 04:10:41
      It's just not a position that anybody wants to be in, nor do you want to leave the future of the Commonwealth in that type of situation.
    • 04:10:52
      So at that time we were hitting the highest risk first.
    • 04:10:55
      At the same time,
    • 04:10:56
      as we went through 2013 and we started recovering that system and catching up on it and probably by the summer or fall getting to the point where we were starting to get ahead and then finishing that recovery of those portions into 2014 and 15 and then spreading it.
    • 04:11:15
      The idea came that we ought to start looking at the next big risk and shift from being reactive to proactive.
    • 04:11:22
      So starting in 2013, we started looking at potentially are there things that we either are too big to address, what are the most critical, and that was kind of the start of
    • 04:11:34
      Putting a list together of at that time we were thinking 25 or 30 structures or 35.
    • 04:11:40
      It ended up being 25 as we got into 14.
    • 04:11:43
      End of 14 probably started firming up a list.
    • 04:11:45
      15 and 16 we were
    • 04:11:50
      The state of good repair bill was passed and we were implementing that.
    • 04:11:54
      Really didn't cover some of these larger structures.
    • 04:11:58
      So in parallel we started developing, okay what is it, what are the potential costs?
    • 04:12:03
      And that kind of brings us where we are now.
    • 04:12:05
      So over time we had this thing that we've put together now.
    • 04:12:10
      And it was always intended to be proactive.
    • 04:12:13
      It wasn't the sky is falling, but it was a long-term address so that we don't end up in that position again.
    • 04:12:19
      So that we're looking out and we're able to make decisions in a deliberate way rather than an emergency way where potentially you're spending more money
    • 04:12:27
      rather than doing it smartly.
    • 04:12:28
      So that's kind of how we got there.
    • 04:12:30
      And then in 2018, the General Assembly put this language in and asked for some recommendations on funding and how to approach it.
    • 04:12:37
      So over time, this is how it developed.
    • 04:12:45
      So what are the things that was asked in this Commonwealth Transportation Board report?
    • 04:12:51
      And those things are the overall condition,
    • 04:12:55
      And that's, if you look in the second page of the appendix, you can find it's listed in a table there, and there's also some, in the summary, there's some general comments on that.
    • 04:13:05
      The funding needs is also rolled up in the executive summary.
    • 04:13:08
      And to answer Mr. Miller's question last time of, is it a big number, yes, the three point, I'll get to the punch line, 3.6 plus, so that's in 2018 dollars, it's not been adjusted for time, even though the current version of this is turned into a 30-year
    • 04:13:24
      And then the recommendations for addressing funding with State of Good Repair.
    • 04:13:33
      And that's in there as well and some other things, but it also tells us some, assessing the impact.
    • 04:13:41
      So we're going to ask for your, make a recommendation to you and also later on to continue this with a comprehensive review and I'll get into that in the conclusions.
    • 04:13:56
      But going further on, this is what we talked about.
    • 04:13:59
      Last time, as reviewed, these 25 structures consist of large complex structures, complex bridges over 2,000 feet, we have some others over 2,000 feet, but these are the most complex, movable bridges and tunnels, which tunnels currently aren't even talked about in State of Good Repair because they are not rated as structurally deficient or not, and these are big, long-term things, but this is basically a review from last time for anybody that wasn't here and is watching.
    • 04:14:27
      So what were the big findings of this?
    • 04:14:30
      And this is just the, I guess the wave tops.
    • 04:14:33
      As I mentioned to you all, $3.6 billion in 2018 dollars.
    • 04:14:39
      We're needing to prioritize them.
    • 04:14:43
      And it will severely impact the state of good repair funds if it were to be taken solely out of that.
    • 04:14:49
      In our view, the state of good repair probably would not be able to meet its intent if we just take it out of this pot.
    • 04:14:58
      So that's what we will report.
    • 04:15:01
      We've answered the mail on that.
    • 04:15:03
      So what we're also looking at doing is coming back
    • 04:15:08
      and asking for another year to do a more comprehensive review for investment strategies.
    • 04:15:15
      What are those things and some of the discussions with you, they could include P3 across the other funding sources that we have and a variety of things so that we can come back with a more comprehensive review, use that with our chief financial officer and spend some real time so that we do this in a very deliberate way.
    • 04:15:32
      This is not an emergency, it's something that we're proactively doing, so we should take the time to do this the right way.
    • 04:15:39
      And we've used the term here, holistic, I think in the report we will probably change that to comprehensive.
    • 04:15:44
      We've heard that from several, that's probably a better word to use.
    • 04:15:49
      And the ask that we will have is that the CTB approve the current report as a preliminary report, knowing that we're coming back next year.
    • 04:15:58
      And I think the actual resolution, since we're still getting comments, will ask that the commissioner be given the ability to make edits on the final, realizing that this will not change the $3.6 billion or the impact, the major effects of this.
    • 04:16:15
      And we are looking that in 2019,
    • 04:16:18
      We hope that this will be a very comprehensive financial document as well as an engineering document that we can move forward with.
    • 04:16:29
      And this is something that we're very pleased that we're able to look proactively and change the way that we're looking at things that perhaps we should have been doing 20 years ago.
    • 04:16:42
      And I think this is a good change for us in doing that.
    • 04:16:47
      Are there any questions?
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:16:50
      In the risk assessment that you did at the start of this, did you consider the impact of climate change on the cost in developing that $3.6 billion number?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:17:05
      It should have been and is in the assumptions of our things like if we're putting trestles in.
    • 04:17:13
      I would say originally they weren't, but as we do estimates, and I can tell you that we are doing those pretty routinely.
    • 04:17:21
      So it's not done comprehensively, but I know it goes into the evaluation of our estimates.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:17:29
      I guess in looking at these numbers, a large percentage of these structures are in Hampton Roads area.
    • 04:17:35
      Probably the number I have is 76, over 70 percent.
    • 04:17:40
      Since we started this discussion there's been a national study released on the effects of climate change and it specifically called out Hampton Roads and identified surprisingly that within two years we could lose several million hours per year of
    • 04:17:58
      vehicle delay time based on flooded roadways.
    • 04:18:01
      I was kind of surprised by that number but I guess I would just encourage as you move into this next year if there's further risk analysis that can be done that we consider some of those impacts as well.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:18:11
      I agree and I think that there are, I would call this a very good number for a 30-year investment.
    • 04:18:20
      There are bridges like the Gwynns Island Bridge, the Norris Bridge, some other components that we know are reaching the end of their life and we know what it would take to replace them.
    • 04:18:30
      I think the bigger picture that overarches this is depending on how much sea level rise there is, how much investment do you put in structures and at what point does it become
    • 04:18:41
      The sea level rise, the communities that you're servicing then have to be displaced.
    • 04:18:47
      So I think that question needs to be part, I don't know how much visibility we'll have on that in a year, but it's certainly an assumption, hopefully an educated assumption we're going to be able to make going in and doing that.
    • 04:18:59
      I agree.
    • 04:19:00
      And could that change that number?
    • 04:19:02
      It and other things could, but I think it's as good a planning number as it could be.
    • 04:19:07
      The things that would change it would be if we're no longer going to use the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel, but the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel we're moving forward with, and we're also moving forward with assumptions that we're going to raise some of those structures in the two to three foot range, you know, based on what we know now.
    • 04:19:23
      And that, you know, if you start to raise more than that, then the question becomes, how do you get to them?
    • 04:19:28
      You know, what are you servicing?
    • 04:19:29
      So this is something that is,
    • 04:19:32
      The things that we can design to now are much more accurate than what you can predict at 100 years.
    • 04:19:38
      So it's really getting what you can do accurately now and then trying to look at the range of where things are going to go and then bounce that against what would the
    • 04:19:49
      decisions be for local governments and stuff to either stay in place or move or shift and that's developing what we're still doing work.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:19:59
      So is that two to three foot number baked into this 3.6 billion dollar we've considered that in the risk analysis?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:20:04
      It's consistent with that.
    • 04:20:06
      We have run numbers against what's happening and we have a stand in place number here
    • 04:20:12
      for it that if we were to do it by itself that is consistent with a different number that's being used in the current procurement because that is efficiencies because
    • 04:20:22
      It's not a separate project, there's not a separate mobilization, but we've compared those numbers and they are both, they are in proportion and frankly that number that's going to be very defined here in another three or four months may vary depending on the approach taken by the winning bidder.
    • 04:20:40
      So that number can shift, so that's where we're at, but we have compared them, yes sir.
    • 04:20:46
      Does that answer the question?
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:47
      I think so.
    • 04:20:48
      I guess I just found it interesting that the report uses a 30 to 40 year window to project cost and economic impacts of sea level rise in particular.
    • 04:20:59
      I just thought it was interesting that it ties in with our 30 year window that we're looking at.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:21:03
      They are not, they were not done
    • 04:21:06
      They're not related to each other.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:21:08
      I understand, but I just thought it was an interesting opportunity to take a look at and compare to what we've used as assumptions in the past as we have this one year to perhaps revise or change it based on new information.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:21:18
      No, I think it needs to be part of it considering where those structures are.
    • 04:21:22
      Yes, sir.
    • 04:21:23
      Thanks, Garrett.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:21:24
      Mr. Chairman?
    • 04:21:26
      Mr. Chairman?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:21:30
      Oh, yes, go ahead.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:21:32
      She disappeared again, so you're on deck.
    • 04:21:36
      Garrett, I was, you know, we're really fond of saying in Northern Virginia that all the bridges are in Maryland or the district and that they're not in Virginia, but I was recently reminded that in fact we may have MOUs that say we're responsible for a certain portion of a bridge or the bridge got a landing spot in Virginia and so we're on the hook
    • 04:21:57
      for a little bit of money, relatively speaking, a little bit of money.
    • 04:22:02
      And I'm just wondering in this whether there's an appendix or something like that where those potential requirements are sort of there even though they're not baked in your number.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:22:19
      We noted those both for cities and for bridges like the Woodrow Wilson that we don't own.
    • 04:22:26
      We do have a maintenance of the near shore and some MOUs where we do go across the bridge and I believe they're still in the appendix.
    • 04:22:34
      I'm not, but they were in at one time.
    • 04:22:37
      We did account for them.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:22:39
      With a number, like an estimate?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:22:41
      We did not put an estimate with them.
    • 04:22:43
      We said they're out there, but since we do not have control over them, and the same with the cities, we did not take the same level of detail with them.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:22:52
      It's as people start to focus in on, this is my mantra today I guess, as people focus in on numbers and say well if we find this much money we're kind of golden, some of those are really hanging out there and may cost us a dime.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:23:05
      They are and part of this was just trying to
    • 04:23:09
      developed the scope around what we were asked to do, but we did identify those.
    • 04:23:14
      And we have them internally.
    • 04:23:15
      I believe they made it into the report.
    • 04:23:17
      I did not check that again before coming in.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:23:19
      If they're not, I guess I would ask that you put them in, just so it's all in one place.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:23:24
      Ma'am.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:23:27
      You have to say something, Stephen.
    • 04:23:28
      Madam Secretary.
    • 04:23:28
      Mr. Johnson.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:23:30
      Oh, did he get passed back?
    • 04:23:32
      Yes.
    • 04:23:32
      Oh, I was trying to be so quiet sitting here.
    • 04:23:34
      I'm sorry, Mr. Johnson.
    • 04:23:36
      All right, madam.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:23:42
      With the fact that Hampton Roads is materially presented in terms of the numbers of assets, it's about assets that are anywhere from two years old to 80.
    • 04:24:04
      I'd like to ask you to recognize when we cut it off at 25, but I guess we could have gone to 50 or 75 assets and looked at those other assets.
    • 04:24:14
      And in that next tier group,
    • 04:24:16
      What kind of assets do you envision?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 04:24:40
      We're going together to try and deal with those assets.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:24:59
      So I've been rambling a little bit, but at the same time recognize that this is a critical issue for the state long term.
    • 04:25:07
      And there are, I mean if you talk to the guys in the Hampton Roads District, especially Chris Hall, he worries at night as I do, as I'm sure that Mr. Malbon does, if we lose the Berkeley Bridge either up or down, we either have got a channel that's blocked or we've got 87,000 people a day that can't get across the bridge.
    • 04:25:27
      and I recognize that's a vital interest and we've been doing the best that we can and I think everybody recognizes it's a function of do we have the assets?
    • 04:25:39
      We haven't had them put forward into these maintenance.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:25:55
      Let me answer the question as best I can and tell me if I've hit it.
    • 04:25:59
      At the time in the 2013-2014 when we started to look at putting a list together, we went to the highest risk first to do that.
    • 04:26:12
      The other thing that we did at that time, and I did both in the districts I was in and in the job, and we've had some great people on our bridge that have worked towards this,
    • 04:26:22
      is we knew that the system was aging.
    • 04:26:25
      The average bridge is 49 years old in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 04:26:30
      Most of those bridges are 50 years old, to be 50 years old, maybe 75.
    • 04:26:39
      So the average is 49.
    • 04:26:41
      We're replacing on average at a cycle of 170 years age of bridge.
    • 04:26:49
      We knew at that time that you can't sustain that.
    • 04:26:54
      So what I did and others did is we attacked both the highest risk pavements and the bridges and we said we're gonna get this in as good a condition as we can knowing that we don't have the money to do full replacements and get that 170 years down to
    • 04:27:17
      An average of 35 or 40 or 45 years that it should be.
    • 04:27:22
      Because you want to get your stuff, it's like a car or anything else.
    • 04:27:25
      You want to get it as good a shape as you can and then for the long term what you want to do is then get to that opportunity that you can start replacing at a better cycle.
    • 04:27:36
      And we've made very, very good progress at that.
    • 04:27:39
      I'm very appreciative of the people doing it.
    • 04:27:40
      We were in a very bad place
    • 04:27:43
      six to eight years ago and really this started a little bit before that and we've gotten to a place where the condition is good.
    • 04:27:50
      I would say fair to good.
    • 04:27:52
      It's not excellent.
    • 04:27:53
      It's fair to good because that condition that you see generally says it has a high number in fair.
    • 04:27:59
      That age will continue to climb from 49 to 50.
    • 04:28:02
      At some point, I don't know if it's 55 or 60, at some point it becomes unsustainable.
    • 04:28:08
      It's like having a fleet of vehicles that are so old that you have breakdowns all the time and it will feed on itself.
    • 04:28:15
      So we got to a point where we have some distance between us and what was happening in 2013 and in other cases before.
    • 04:28:25
      You're right that some of the bridges over the James up here are also aging and in other places in the state, but we focused on the most critical because it was, first of all, they were the most
    • 04:28:39
      They're the most impact on defense, on the movement of goods and people in the state, but there is another tear down that we have to also have that it does not do away with the aging of our bridges is getting older and older and older.
    • 04:28:58
      We're doing more to keep them in good condition so they don't go into the death spiral, but at some point, not now, but within five,
    • 04:29:09
      maybe 10 years we're going to reach critical mass and we will not be able to keep up and the thing and the quicker that we attack this as a Commonwealth the better
    • 04:29:22
      It will, the cheaper it will be 20 years from now, 30 years, because if you keep your stuff and you keep a cycle, you're in better shape.
    • 04:29:29
      So yes, I think you've recognized something that's out there.
    • 04:29:32
      We've done our best to get this in as good a condition as we can with the resources that we have, and we will continue to do that, and I think doing this with the
    • 04:29:44
      These vital infrastructure will help us do it, but I think what the Commissioner is looking to do is take a comprehensive look so that we can do the best we can with the resources we have so that we are not, for instance, if you were to take it all out of the capital program
    • 04:30:02
      and make that completely, you know, unsolvent, then you're not getting replacements.
    • 04:30:06
      And how do you get that right mix?
    • 04:30:09
      And that's really up for the board to do.
    • 04:30:10
      But I can just give you the history and where I think we've gotten with it.
    • 04:30:15
      I don't know if that answers your question adequately.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:30:20
      Mr. Secretary, taking on a topic like this right behind 81 kind of makes my stomach turn.
    • 04:30:30
      This number is large and I'm willing to, as we get deeper in the analysis, this number is going to grow as we get better educated about what's coming, for example, climate change.
    • 04:30:47
      And there's no
    • 04:30:49
      And then we see smart scale trending the wrong way and our whole revenue stream that we rely on in terms of building infrastructure and maintaining what we built is getting at an issue where
    • 04:31:05
      Prioritization is what we do, but we may not be able to, based on the amount of money we have, there may be some assets that we just don't, no matter what the prioritization process is to get to.
    • 04:31:18
      My biggest fear is we have a vital structure that has a catastrophe, and the drive motor's gone, the gear assembly's not made anymore, takes 90 days to build it, and we have a major facility down for six months.
    • 04:31:34
      We will spend whatever money it takes to get it back up.
    • 04:31:38
      I don't care what it is, we will spend it.
    • 04:31:41
      But that will be a wake-up call for us, that we've got those impending situations coming to us again.
    • 04:31:49
      I'm just preaching a little bit to be honest with you, but I think we have to be serious with the General Assembly that now's the time we revisit the funding stream because we know we have a declining composite of revenue.
    • 04:32:05
      and our needs are increasing.
    • 04:32:07
      The more this capacity we build, the more maintenance we impose on ourselves because we have more lane miles, we have more complexity.
    • 04:32:17
      And my fear is we're banging around five or six billion dollars right now that I don't know if there's any realistic plan to fund it.
    • 04:32:30
      But I think we need to be a little bit more progressive because even if we did have some great ideas about the future, it would take a long time to educate all the stakeholders and have something put in place, particularly with the decline in our revenue and the needs increase.
    • 04:32:49
      I just thought I'd make that comment.
    • 04:32:52
      You know, this comes right behind 81.
    • 04:32:56
      I mean, it makes you shake your head a little bit.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:32:59
      Mr. Malbon took three minutes to say that.
    • 04:33:01
      I'll just say ditto.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:33:03
      But for right now, to be just totally accurate, we are still lowering the percentage of structurally deficient bridges, although that rate has slowed that we're doing it.
    • 04:33:14
      I mean, at some point, you get there and then, so we are still reducing that.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:19
      No, but you mentioned 10 years.
    • 04:33:20
      This is a 30-year plan, and I'm
    • 04:33:22
      They're saying if we're going to be in a position ten years from now, we have to start acting today.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:33:29
      That's the idea.
    • 04:33:30
      This is a proactive, long-term push.
    • 04:33:32
      It's not... That's my point.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:33
      Today is when we have to start...
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:33:35
      Exactly.
    • 04:33:36
      Try to leave it for our successors in a way that gets the best value for the dollar.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:44
      I'd like to follow up on a number of points that Garrett raised.
    • 04:33:50
      Certainly the important part of what we're trying to accomplish with this document and moving forward is developing that reserve fund for funding of those elements that have a finite useful life and start preparing for that future.
    • 04:34:05
      The example of the switch gear down on the Berkeley Bridge, we know that that has a finite useful life.
    • 04:34:11
      That motor, you saw some pictures of the Gwyn Islands Bridge, it looks like a 1920's tractor engine right now that's being held together with bailing wire.
    • 04:34:20
      We need to be in a position that we're spending the money and proactively planning for that replacement at the year that we anticipated rather than having a catastrophe happen and a re-prioritization of the monies on that annual basis.
    • 04:34:36
      So this is that first attempt to do that.
    • 04:34:39
      It is going to take us a little bit more time to be able to look into that.
    • 04:34:44
      from that standpoint.
    • 04:34:45
      That's why we're recommending coming back in a year's time frame, look at the entire maintenance program so that we do take a blended approach to how can we fund this in a legitimate way.
    • 04:34:56
      Right now we're putting 20 to 30 to maybe 40 million dollars away into these structures, all of these 25 structures on an annual basis.
    • 04:35:04
      and we still know that we aren't addressing a motor that's on the James River Bridge that frankly got hit by lightning this summer and we had to go out onto the open market to buy capacitors that have to be handmade.
    • 04:35:20
      We keep spares on hand but the number that we're blowing out this time, we didn't have them to be able to fix.
    • 04:35:26
      So we were down to the point where do I keep that in the open position to allow for maritime commerce to reach the port of Richmond?
    • 04:35:34
      Or do I lower it to be able to facilitate traffic until I could get shipments brought in or these things handmade?
    • 04:35:43
      These things are past our useful life.
    • 04:35:46
      So part of this is how do we prepare ourselves for the future, put these into a reserve fund so I'm not spending either my SGR or my maintenance money on an annual basis.
    • 04:35:58
      If it's going to take
    • 04:36:01
      It's just as if we're going to invest in an air conditioner unit for our house.
    • 04:36:06
      Maybe we put a thousand dollars, two thousand dollars away to be able to normalize these costs rather than in one year have a thirty to fifty million dollar investment and really hurt the system.
    • 04:36:16
      But if I'm putting five million away, it makes it a very palatable opportunity.
    • 04:36:21
      But I think in this approach that we want to take,
    • 04:36:24
      for next year is to take a very blended approach.
    • 04:36:27
      What do I have in our maintenance program?
    • 04:36:30
      What can I use there?
    • 04:36:32
      What can I use out of SGR or our construction program?
    • 04:36:35
      The opportunity for P3 or other and look at it in a very comprehensive and
    • 04:36:42
      I know people don't like the term holistic, but I'll say comprehensive and holistic manner, but we need to be doing that.
    • 04:36:50
      Part of what we brought back to the board in July, August, and September timeframe was looking at our performance measures for our assets.
    • 04:37:01
      We said that we were going to look at our pavements and bridges.
    • 04:37:04
      Part of this is looking at our entire investment strategy across the board.
    • 04:37:09
      Do we have any opportunity to change our level of investment in maybe some of our assets to be able to help fund this?
    • 04:37:19
      Maybe we don't.
    • 04:37:20
      We're not in that position to certainly say that, but this review that we want to undertake will take a look at how do we create a sustainable program for each of our assets, including the vital assets that have been shown here for the 25 structures.
    • 04:37:36
      We might not have it right.
    • 04:37:37
      We still might not be fully funded.
    • 04:37:40
      All of our assumptions that we're making is the dollars that we get today are the dollars that we're going to have in the future, and there is no increase.
    • 04:37:49
      So how do we address this and then how do we go through this prioritization?
    • 04:37:54
      Part of this is recognizing that many of these assets do have the finite useful life of switch gears, motors, movable components, bearings.
    • 04:38:04
      Toling Systems, we need to be putting away for that over that 30-year period.
    • 04:38:09
      And then some of these structures, frankly, as we said, the Norris Bridge will have a finite useful life.
    • 04:38:15
      We continue to extend it.
    • 04:38:16
      It's a safe bridge.
    • 04:38:18
      It's structurally not deficient.
    • 04:38:20
      And we're going to continue to maintain it that way.
    • 04:38:22
      If something breaks, we will re-prioritize what we have in the program, but by having that reserve fund, that will help alleviate and really normalize how we look at making sure that we don't have large swings in the program and need to do a wholesale re-prioritization of what we have so we can be planning for that future.
    • 04:38:43
      So that's what we want to undertake in the 2019 period, but it is truly a very comprehensive look at all of our assets as well as our performance targets to be able to meet this and then identify how can we fund the vital structures in a reserve fund component.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:39:04
      Mr. Williams.
    • 04:39:06
      Mr. Smoot, I apologize.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:39:09
      Based on the years I had in the legislature, and I think Madam Chair would share this with you also, it better be a mighty tight lockbox you put that reserve fund in, because committee staff, Appropriations Committee and Finance Committee staff, they know where every dollar is.
    • 04:39:27
      And although it's great planning, you know, they have a panic
    • 04:39:32
      with a tremendous amount of stuff underfunded every year.
    • 04:39:35
      And when they make up their mind that they're underfunded, issue in front of them is more important than the reserve fund that you set aside.
    • 04:39:44
      That reserve fund would quickly disappear.
    • 04:39:46
      So I would just caution using that as a planning guide, even if it's exactly what I wanna hear.
    • 04:39:52
      I mean, it's the sort of thing I love coming out of a guy running such a huge agency.
    • 04:39:57
      It's exactly what you'd want your CEO to be doing.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:40:01
      I think that is part of probably the recommendations that we'll need to bring back because there will be a sizable sum of money at some point in time that will appear to be sitting idle but we know that within the next year or two we're going to see some significant requests for funding whether it be for switch gears that we're ordering or buying at some point in time
    • 04:40:24
      F. Smith Jr.,
    • 04:40:34
      The expenditures that we have and put money away in a savings account for those times and all of that will be transparent in what that plan is and what the expenditures, planned expenditures will be.
    • 04:40:47
      So certainly, and I would anticipate the board having that authority and that action to re-prioritize within that plan as it sees fit and if money is sitting idle then I think those people that are having the oversight at that point would need to come back in and
    • 04:41:03
      either re-prioritize or shift funding out of that reserve fund at some point.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:41:07
      I don't doubt there's not a right way to do it.
    • 04:41:09
      I just urge caution.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:41:11
      We've started that conversation, but I think that conversation will grow next year.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:41:18
      Mr. Smoot, you have been so patient down there.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:41:21
      So at this time, Jerry, so you have already identified those projects that are included in the vital
    • 04:41:36
      Dohue
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:41:52
      They actually already laid out that way by what is actually you know there's fire and life safety things but by structure and I would say most of that stuff is probably pretty good but like any 30-year plan as Mr. Kasprowicz said if for some reason
    • 04:42:09
      Something happens where that portion of the state has a different use, we may do something different if there's a capacity issue that we now replace it in another way.
    • 04:42:19
      So I wouldn't say it's absolutely locked in, but I'd say a high percentage of those will likely happen as planned.
    • 04:42:36
      Will the prioritization within the plan give attention to such things as level of use?
    • 04:42:38
      For example, we have tunnels
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:42:39
      Are, to get into the
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:43:07
      the 25.
    • 04:43:08
      That was a consideration in where they were and so forth.
    • 04:43:13
      However, it was not a consideration.
    • 04:43:15
      It was mainly age, condition, and what needed, and actual hard requirements.
    • 04:43:20
      There was not a, because you could make an argument that the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel for instance is going to probably be
    • 04:43:29
      A higher priority than just about anything else in the state.
    • 04:43:33
      So it was hard requirements based on, for instance, fire life safety, the actual need to do it, not if it had 10,000 vehicles a day versus 15.
    • 04:43:44
      One other thing, the implication on state of good repair, which you noted in your report, could be severe.
    • 04:43:54
      Yes.
    • Raymond D. Smoot Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:06
      It takes good businesses to plan for major expenditures, but we need to understand what's that going to do to your maintenance of projects, of infrastructure that's much closer to people.
    • 04:44:23
      There's been some problems.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:44:28
      Yes, I agree and that's something that we thought needed another year to really get into that level of projection in the finance item.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:36
      I'd follow up that we have started that projection and looked at it through the state of good repair as well as HMO but to Garrett's point
    • 04:44:46
      having another year to be able to hone in on that, look at the prioritization, is that the right year of expenditure that we anticipate?
    • 04:44:54
      What I would say, Mr. Smoot, is that Appendix B of that report does indicate the 30-year plan horizon for each one of the structures and the replacements or components of the replacement for those
    • 04:45:05
      facilities or structures that we're looking at.
    • 04:45:08
      So it is fairly comprehensive.
    • 04:45:10
      We know where it is.
    • 04:45:11
      Whether it's year 10, 11, or 12, we could still move that and that may have some impact on our level of investment that we would need to make in that subsequent year.
    • 04:45:24
      So those are there.
    • 04:45:27
      We'll take the next year to be able to refine that information and hone that in much more sharper than what it is today.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 04:45:35
      We have a table that actually
    • 04:46:04
      that actually lays it out over 30 years and that tells you what goes when.
    • 04:46:09
      Appendix B. Mr. Connors.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:46:14
      Thank you, Madam Secretary.
    • 04:46:16
      Thank you, Garrett and Commissioner Brich for this comprehensive report.
    • 04:46:23
      We heard a lot of talk about P3s at the conference.
    • 04:46:26
      Is there anything to prevent us from doing a P3 right now?
    • 04:46:30
      If somebody came to us with an unsolicited P3, would we look at it?
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:46:34
      Absolutely.
    • 04:46:34
      I would be more than happy to take a look at it and its viability.
    • 04:46:38
      Yes.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:46:40
      And we have had some presentations on P3-like opportunities that we just need to do more homework on is what I would say.
    • 04:46:54
      How we could manage that and what's possible.
    • 04:46:58
      But we are working to include that.
    • 04:47:01
      I also left and leave the door open that
    • 04:47:04
      Besides looking for how we're going to do it out of existing funds, you know, as we look at trying to identify sustainable funding revenues, could there be a dedicated source for something like this as well?
    • 04:47:17
      So I wanted to make sure that that was part of the report, just leaving that as a possibility.
    • 04:47:22
      Because Mr. Williams made a really good point about setting up those reserves.
    • 04:47:27
      Anything else?
    • 04:47:30
      Okay, thank you very much.
    • 04:47:33
      You all did a tremendous amount of work on that this year.
    • 04:47:37
      We had to switch some presentations with January and I'm going to have Cathy McGhee come up and give you all a presentation that we actually swapped out of January.
    • 04:47:48
      It is the 2019 UAS plan.
    • 04:47:52
      I do not have this in your computers, by the way, on the big screen.
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 04:48:21
      I'm going to give you just a brief update on where we are with unmanned aerial systems and please feel free to interrupt with questions at any time.
    • 04:48:33
      So VDOT has really been looking at how we can bring UAS into our daily operations for a number of years and we've done a few demonstration projects.
    • 04:48:45
      both on in the infrastructure assessment area bridge inspection as well as for traffic and incident management.
    • 04:48:55
      We've also done some work with our university partners looking at rock slope condition and how we evaluate rock slopes and then develop mitigation plans when they are found to be at risk.
    • 04:49:10
      and then of course public communications.
    • 04:49:12
      It's a great tool to explain to the public what's happening on particularly larger scale projects like the Route 29 Solutions Project.
    • 04:49:22
      We were also fortunate earlier this year to host a peer exchange.
    • 04:49:26
      We received a grant from FHWA that allowed us to bring representatives from other state DOTs to Virginia to share their experiences with UAS in their own departments.
    • 04:49:39
      and allowed us to ask a lot of really practical sort of down to earth questions about how that was going in their own states.
    • 04:49:49
      But now we're at a point where we're ready to roll.
    • 04:49:52
      We've created an action plan for 2019.
    • 04:49:56
      I will say calendar year 2019 to really begin to put UAS into action
    • 04:50:04
      in agency operations.
    • 04:50:06
      And so I'd like to walk you through just a couple of focus areas for that plan.
    • 04:50:11
      The first is infrastructure inspection.
    • 04:50:14
      When people talk about UAS and state departments of transportation, that tends to be where they go first, primarily because it's a big task.
    • 04:50:22
      There's a lot of money there, and it is federally required.
    • 04:50:27
      There are
    • 04:50:28
      parts of a bridge inspection that today can't be done with UAS and that's always been a stumbling block for us.
    • 04:50:35
      So now we've decided to focus on what we can do and to enhance our inspection program rather than try to overtake it with UAS.
    • 04:50:45
      So we've done a number of things.
    • 04:50:47
      Structure and bridge is modifying contract language for ancillary structures to allow robotic inspection which would include UAS among other technologies.
    • 04:50:58
      In those contracts, we don't specify means and methods, so if it is the best choice from an economic or safety or efficiency standpoint, we believe that contractors will bring that option to the table.
    • 04:51:12
      We also plan to incorporate the use of UAS for hard to access elements and larger areas of our structures.
    • 04:51:20
      For example,
    • 04:51:21
      cable stays, tall pier shafts, those kinds of things that are difficult for humans or unsafe for our employees or our contractors to access can be fairly easily done with UAS, a visual assessment of those elements.
    • 04:51:37
      We're also going to look at unmanned underwater vehicles.
    • 04:51:41
      Scour certainly is a concern for us, and we believe that rather than sending divers down, we can perhaps bring UAS, or you
    • 04:51:51
      W. S. to bear in those cases.
    • 04:51:55
      So we've also looked at robotic technologies and we're going to continue to look at how those kinds of things can be used particularly in small areas like culverts where we can send a robot in and get the information that we need in a relatively, in a very safe and relatively inexpensive way.
    • 04:52:19
      Another area that we're looking at very actively is incident and traffic management.
    • 04:52:26
      I believe that you've heard already about our initiative partnering with Virginia State Police on accident reconstruction.
    • 04:52:34
      As you know, when there is a fatal crash, we are required to collect additional data on the details of that crash.
    • 04:52:44
      Other states, North Carolina for example,
    • 04:52:47
      have had really good success substituting their traditional land-based data collection systems with UAS, bringing the time required to collect that data down to under 30 minutes in some cases, which is if you've been in a queue behind a fatal crash, you know that is a significant
    • 04:53:12
      Shortening of the time required.
    • 04:53:14
      And the data is very accurate.
    • 04:53:15
      I will say that as we begin to roll this out, we will collect data both ways.
    • 04:53:22
      We need to get a few cases through the courts to make sure that the data will be accepted.
    • 04:53:27
      So we will continue to do it the traditional way for some period of time.
    • 04:53:31
      But we are in the process of providing training to the state police reconstruction teams, allowing them to get their pilot certifications.
    • 04:53:42
      and then we'll move forward with procuring the vehicles.
    • 04:53:46
      We're also committing to doing some post-event damage assessment with UAS in 2019.
    • 04:53:55
      We certainly hope we don't have any natural disasters, but in the event that we do, UAS have been found to be very efficient in collecting damage assessment.
    • 04:54:06
      We can even do volumetric analysis so we can determine how many dump trucks we're going to need to send in to bring the debris out before we can get vehicles into the site.
    • 04:54:18
      In the area of environmental applications, there are a number of initiatives we believe that UAS can be brought to bear.
    • 04:54:28
      Post-construction stormwater management inspections are required.
    • 04:54:32
      Again, that volumetric capability is really important here.
    • 04:54:35
      We can tell whether or not those
    • 04:54:39
      Stormwater facilities are doing the job or if we need to go in and do some additional work.
    • 04:54:45
      As you can imagine, mapping accurately wetlands during project development is very important.
    • 04:54:52
      The technology and the sensors that we can put on these UAS will allow us to do that very, very efficiently.
    • 04:54:59
      And then monitoring wetland mitigation sites once they are developed is also another application of the technology.
    • 04:55:10
      I mentioned rock slope stability earlier.
    • 04:55:13
      We are partnering with Radford University to develop a framework for this particular application that we believe that will then be applicable to other areas.
    • 04:55:25
      But rock slope stability is one that's
    • 04:55:28
      Really, really important to us.
    • 04:55:30
      You can imagine the safety implications of not having to send someone climbing the face of a slope to look for critical fractures.
    • 04:55:41
      We can do that with UAS.
    • 04:55:43
      We can do change detection so we can fly the same slope repeatedly over time and identify any even very small changes
    • 04:55:52
      In the makeup of that slope before a rockfall occurs and then develop mitigation strategies to deal with any potential risks that we see.
    • 04:56:05
      In the surveying area, you can imagine there are all kinds of applications.
    • 04:56:08
      Basically, we're talking about aerial surveys on a relatively small platform, but the construction division has committed to take 10 projects in the calendar year 19 program.
    • 04:56:22
      to provide weekly progress photos on those projects and then embed those in the plan so that we make sure if we're coming from the left and the right we meet in the middle when that time comes.
    • 04:56:34
      Again, another ten projects, perhaps some overlap in those projects to document as-built conditions to get those really accurate
    • 04:56:45
      measurements of exactly what was built and what's in the field so when we need to go back later we have that accurate data to work with.
    • 04:56:53
      Sediment runoff at construction sites, again another 10 construction sites will monitor runoff after any major storm.
    • 04:57:01
      So that we can deal with any issues that are determined there.
    • 04:57:04
      And then maintenance of traffic in our work zones is really critical.
    • 04:57:09
      We want to make sure that both our own staff and our contractors are abiding by the rules in the MUTCD and the Virginia Work Area Protection Manual.
    • 04:57:19
      And we'll be able to do inspections really efficiently
    • 04:57:24
      with UAS.
    • 04:57:25
      So up to 35 projects in the state this coming year will be using UAS to monitor the work zones.
    • 04:57:33
      And that's a really quick overview of what we have planned for FY19.
    • 04:57:37
      I will say that we have an internal work group that's gonna monitor these efforts, make sure we're sharing lessons learned across divisions and identify any early issues that might come up.
    • 04:57:53
      We will be evaluating all of these projects to make sure that we're seeing cost
    • 04:57:59
      benefits or safety benefits that these are the right applications to move forward with in future years and then to add to those applications as we learn more about the technology and as the sensors develop over time.
    • 04:58:13
      So I would be happy to answer any questions.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:58:16
      Before I open it up, do you mind just speaking very briefly how you're coordinating with aviation and the spaceport in the Port of Virginia?
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 04:58:24
      Yes, great question.
    • 04:58:25
      So we are a part of a work group being led by Mark Flynn at the Department of Aviation.
    • 04:58:34
      That work group is focused on policy and regulation, particularly in making sure that we can remove any barriers to the growth of a UAS industry in Virginia.
    • 04:58:47
      We would really like to grow our own as much as possible and that group is really focused at removing barriers and so they have a number of task groups that are looking at education and outreach, they're looking at regulation, they're looking at
    • 04:59:05
      local and state use, not to the application level like I just described, but how we can best facilitate procurement mechanisms and that sort of thing.
    • 04:59:17
      And so that group is active.
    • 04:59:19
      It meets about every month to make sure that we stay on track and deliver our work product in a very short amount of time that will be useful to facilitating the overall program.
    • 04:59:32
      In terms of the spaceport,
    • 04:59:34
      We were very lucky to be able to facilitate the construction of a runway, a UAS runway over at Wallops.
    • 04:59:42
      And if you haven't been there, I encourage you to go and check it out.
    • 04:59:46
      A lot of the work that's happening there today is defense-related.
    • 04:59:51
      They tend to be larger vehicles that require a runway.
    • 04:59:57
      And so that's a lot of the work that they're doing over there.
    • 05:00:00
      But we certainly hope to coordinate and collaborate more with them over time.
    • 05:00:04
      to learn more about the technology.
    • 05:00:07
      As most technologies or a lot of technologies, things happen in the defense industry and then move into more common uses and we believe that will continue to happen over there.
    • 05:00:19
      The nice thing about the spaceport is it gives us an opportunity for multimodal application development because they obviously
    • 05:00:28
      sit on the water so some of that underwater stuff I spoke of earlier we can also do some evaluations and investigations of that there as well.
    • 05:00:39
      They do control their airspace because of the nature of the facility so some of the rules that apply in general from FAA don't apply over there because they do control their own airspace and so it allows us to do a few more things that are a little more out there.
    • 05:00:56
      as we go forward with this initiative.
    • 05:01:00
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:01
      Is there anything you'd like to say?
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:03
      I'm very impressed with what you've been able to do and I'd like for you to just educate or just talk to us a little bit about the educational and apprenticeship opportunities with universities and community colleges because there's a huge opportunity there I think all across the state.
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 05:01:22
      Virginia Tech
    • 05:01:23
      is in fact one of only a handful of sites that is a part of the Integrated Pilot Program that was initiated by FAA last year.
    • 05:01:35
      They also have the Mid-Atlantic Aviation Partnership which was an earlier designation.
    • 05:01:42
      They are the only site that has both and it allows for a number of research activities to occur there
    • 05:01:50
      That brings in students.
    • 05:01:52
      It's helping the overall industry because we're looking at some of the federal regulations that currently restrict what we can do.
    • 05:01:59
      You cannot fly beyond visual line of sight, so you can't lose sight of your vehicle, which makes it really hard.
    • 05:02:06
      If you can imagine flying under a bridge to look at something, we've lost visual line of sight.
    • 05:02:12
      You can't fly at night.
    • 05:02:13
      You can't fly over people.
    • 05:02:16
      So we couldn't do a linear inspection of our roadway if there was traffic on it.
    • 05:02:21
      So that site and that IPP designation is allowing them to do a lot of testing that feeds back to FAA and allows for changes to existing rules.
    • 05:02:32
      But it also brings the student component in, which is really, really valuable as we begin to understand the fullness of what can be done with this technology.
    • 05:02:41
      At the community college level, there are a number of programs that exist
    • 05:02:47
      that are training pilots, training technicians I would say in terms of how we build these vehicles and how we repair them.
    • 05:02:56
      They do sometimes come down unintentionally and require repair.
    • 05:03:03
      And as well as
    • 05:03:06
      Helping to develop the applications that will use the technology.
    • 05:03:11
      So I think there's a lot of opportunity to develop a workforce around this and our community colleges and what they're doing is probably the most exciting because it's capturing some of that population that may not be headed to a four-year institution and allowing them a really meaningful career.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:03:33
      And I will say, you know, I asked Cathy to come up and do this and for some of you who don't know, Cathy is currently Director of the Transportation Research Council out of Charlottesville and so she has been very instrumental in working on so many of these issues.
    • 05:03:51
      A few months ago, I had asked Cathy if she would serve as an acting director of the Office of Innovation.
    • 05:03:57
      And because, for those of you who are perhaps new to the board, when I first came into this position, I had shared with all of you that I thought our legacy was going to be based on three things.
    • 05:04:09
      It might be four, finding money might be the top one in making this all sustainable.
    • 05:04:15
      But it really was around execution and delivering superior projects.
    • 05:04:19
      It was tying more deliberately
    • 05:04:20
      transportation to economic competitiveness, and finally by embracing innovation.
    • 05:04:26
      And the governor gave me the opportunity to open an office of innovation that actually crossed the entire secretariat for the first time.
    • 05:04:35
      So I just would like to announce that Cathy has accepted the position as director of what is now being called the Research and Innovation Office.
    • 05:04:45
      within the Transportation Secretariat.
    • 05:04:47
      And so we are just thrilled to have you and just wanted them to get a sense of where you are and how you are hitting the ground running.
    • 05:04:56
      So congratulations.
    • 05:05:04
      So Cathy, she's already running away.
    • 05:05:07
      I will say this, I knew you were going to ask that Mr. Williams, I could read your lips.
    • 05:05:11
      Cathy, the Research Council is still going to report to Cathy, but you did designate, I looked at the list, 25 things that she's no longer going to be in charge of.
    • 05:05:24
      But we're working very collaboratively with the commissioner and Rob Carey to make all of this work.
    • 05:05:31
      Is there anything you'd like to say before you try to dart out the door?
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 05:05:37
      I really appreciate this opportunity.
    • 05:05:40
      Your enthusiasm for innovation is definitely contagious, and I'm really excited about the opportunities.
    • 05:05:47
      But I will say that the Research Council will not certainly be ignored.
    • 05:05:51
      We have a tremendous staff there.
    • 05:05:56
      and most importantly the Deputy Director, Meg Fitch, who will be taking on a lot of those tasks on that long list.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:02
      We'll have to have Mike Fitch come over and present us around and give us an update from over there.
    • Cathy McGheeDirector of Research and Innovation
    • 05:06:07
      Absolutely.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:08
      Yes.
    • 05:06:09
      So anything else?
    • 05:06:10
      Okay, thank you so much.
    • 05:06:13
      Mr. Williams, I don't want to put you on the spot, but I know that you chair a task force.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:23
      I was at my front door and I was looking at him.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:41
      I just wanted to give you an opportunity to kind of update us on where your task force is.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:53
      Working with the group trying to provide some at least just some guidance so we can keep it moving but of course Garrett Moore and Rob Carrier doing all the work but it's
    • 05:07:05
      We're working with the stakeholders on refining the policies for underground utility installations, responsibility for those, how the different agencies work together.
    • 05:07:17
      I don't mind telling you the biggest problem that I was aware of prior to hearing about all the other problems we have with it is that, at least mostly under design-build contracts, in order to facilitate the quick movement of the project, the VDOT
    • 05:07:36
      Puts the responsibility for relocating the underground utilities that have to be, that's on the contractor's responsibility list.
    • 05:07:46
      Well, it doesn't always work out really well for the contractor to be able to do it.
    • 05:07:51
      Part of the risk they accept when they accept the contract, but it, I don't like to put the blame on anybody.
    • 05:07:59
      The utility companies are not beholden, are not in the responsibility of the contractor.
    • 05:08:05
      The contractor called them to say, I want you there tomorrow.
    • 05:08:08
      And they could say, well, so what?
    • 05:08:10
      I'll be there next month.
    • 05:08:12
      On the other hand, they also could call and say, I want you there tomorrow.
    • 05:08:15
      They should have called them four months ago and asked them to be there.
    • 05:08:19
      And the complaint might be the same.
    • 05:08:20
      They didn't come when I told them to.
    • 05:08:22
      So it's straightening out that relationship and writing a Rob's group is going to, Rob and Garrett's group is going to undertake
    • 05:08:33
      kind of a rules of the road, this is how we do it kind of thing to get everybody to sign off on, the utility companies, the contractors and VDOT to all sign off on.
    • 05:08:42
      So this is how we're gonna do these, this is how we're gonna conduct this process and you signed off on it and it's, you know, I don't think you can codify something like that and make, you know, make people be accountable financially when it's be really hard to prove who messed up.
    • 05:09:01
      If everybody got on the same page, I think it would be important for that to happen.
    • 05:09:04
      There's other things that we're looking at in the meantime, but that's one of the biggies.
    • 05:09:10
      The utility companies tend to think that when it's just VDOT, if it's a design-bid-build job, they don't have much problem because VDOT goes out ahead of time and tries to do all the relocation, prior to the job even being bid.
    • 05:09:25
      A lot of times, or at least they've got everything set up and paid for and all that.
    • 05:09:31
      Well, these design-build projects, you don't have that in order to expedite them.
    • 05:09:38
      VDOT does put the risk on the contractor to make it happen, and a lot of times it doesn't.
    • 05:09:44
      I don't think the problem is as big as I thought it was, but I think it's still pretty big and needs to be resolved.
    • 05:09:49
      So they're all working
    • 05:09:51
      We've got all the stakeholders there, the big utility companies, the road builders associations there.
    • 05:09:57
      They're all there participating and I'm always amazed at the wealth of knowledge and data that VDOT has about all this stuff.
    • 05:10:06
      If you ask any question, there is and they've got it.
    • 05:10:09
      So I'm really happy to see that all the time too.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:10:12
      Secretary.
    • 05:10:14
      Ms. Hines.
    • 05:10:14
      Ms. Williams, I'm struck just to ask you, is VML participating in this?
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:10:22
      No, you've got a couple of localities that are.
    • 05:10:25
      OK.
    • 05:10:25
      But VML itself, no.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:10:27
      Because I would say, in my years on the Arlington County Board, because we controlled our streets, we had one full-time staff person whose sole job was to communicate with Dominion and problem solve with Dominion.
    • 05:10:40
      So for the localities that are doing road projects cities, towns in particular and some of the larger counties it's a big issue and we talked about it when we were talking about the dashboard in Northern Virginia for NVTA about whether we needed a separate color for we were delayed because of Dominion.
    • 05:11:01
      And so I just would offer that to you maybe there's some maybe we can make sure
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:11:07
      Well, I would say to you that a lot of the discussion was, from the utilities perspective, was that when it was a VDOT administered project, things went pretty well.
    • 05:11:21
      On the design-build projects, things were, you know, sometimes if the contractor was on top of it,
    • 05:11:28
      So was the utility companies.
    • 05:11:29
      It was rarely a case where the contractor could clearly point to the utility and say, I told you six months in advance, I asked you every week, you said you'd do it and you didn't.
    • 05:11:38
      That's rare.
    • 05:11:40
      But the utilities wholeheartedly said some of the biggest problems we have are locally administered projects.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:11:47
      Mr. Johnson, I see that you brought some show and tell with you today.
    • 05:12:17
      You know what, is your microphone working?
    • 05:12:19
      I don't know.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:19
      Speak it up close and speak into it.
    • 05:12:21
      Is that better?
    • 05:12:21
      I apologize.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:22
      Well, I just noticed some of them weren't coming on, so I just, it could have been the system.
    • 05:12:26
      Sorry.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:27
      Start the discussion again.
    • 05:12:30
      Transportation Conference, Robert Poole spoke.
    • 05:12:33
      He had a booth there.
    • 05:12:35
      And in a meeting with Mr. Malbon at the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel Authority, and he represents CTB, and I still go there because I was on that board for a while.
    • 05:12:47
      In any event, this book was given to all the directors, commissioners sitting around the table that day.
    • 05:12:53
      And I got a copy, had a chance to read it, and it talks about
    • 05:12:59
      New ways of looking at things about finance, about what's happening with federal government, what's happening with state and local governments.
    • 05:13:08
      New ways of looking at P3 activity, looking at infrastructure funds that are doing jobs around the world and around the United States.
    • 05:13:19
      So it offers a great deal of information.
    • 05:13:22
      It's very complimentary on Virginia, by the way, for the P3 activity that we have with inside and outside on Route 66.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:13:30
      I look at Mr. Morteza over there, as you say that.
    • Stephen A. JohnsenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:13:39
      Chance, have you read the book?
    • 05:13:41
      Do you have a copy of the book?
    • 05:13:42
      Yes, I have read it.
    • 05:13:44
      It gives you, at least for me anyway, I found it gave a lot of information that a lot of people sitting around the table here might find interesting in terms of the discussions that we have, especially so many.
    • 05:13:56
      I just thought it was important that at least a copy for everybody sitting around the table and I hope you enjoy.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:14:07
      I'd just like to emphasize it is a good read.
    • 05:14:13
      This guy, his thought process connected with mine, which I don't know if that's good or bad.
    • 05:14:22
      I guess nobody will read the book now, but it was amazing when you talked about funding and things.
    • 05:14:35
      I think the challenge we have in increasing any revenue streams is because people don't trust us.
    • 05:14:42
      People don't trust government in terms of protecting their money or doing what they said as opposed to a utility.
    • 05:14:52
      There's a whole different mindset of paying a power bill or a water bill than paying any type of payment for transportation because there's a disconnect there.
    • 05:15:04
      Anyway, that was just one of his points, but the guy's pretty interesting and it's worth the read, so thanks.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:15:10
      Thank you.
    • 05:15:11
      Great.
    • 05:15:11
      Thank you, Mr. President.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:15:13
      Pleasure.
    • 05:15:13
      Our pleasure.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:15:15
      So, Director Mitchell?
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:15:18
      Just a couple quick updates.
    • 05:15:20
      One of the items we reported on this morning to the rail committee was we have back some preliminary ridership information for Amtrak.
    • 05:15:29
      They're unaudited results for their federal fiscal year 19 over 18, but the great news is that we're seeing
    • 05:15:37
      increase of 8% for ridership over last year.
    • 05:15:41
      Now we had seen a slight dip between 17 and 18 but we're very excited to see this trend overall.
    • 05:15:47
      It's really been driven quite a bit by increases in the Roanoke Line which is also the previous the Lynchburg Line.
    • 05:15:55
      It's the Lynchburg Line that we share with Roanoke.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:15:58
      Exactly.
    • 05:15:59
      Right Mr. Dodson?
    • 05:16:07
      Inaugural Run, October 1, 2009.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:16:17
      We also saw an increase of about 8% in Norfolk and also in the Norfolk line and also about 3% in the Richmond line as well.
    • 05:16:26
      So we do have seasonal variations with our Amtrak ridership.
    • 05:16:30
      We were concerned about some ridership trends we were seeing earlier in the year but actually
    • 05:16:35
      Very pleased to see this turn around.
    • 05:16:37
      And then finally one other thing I wanted to mention for any of you that may have read about this in the paper.
    • 05:16:45
      You've heard a lot from us about the Long Bridge Project and the DC Department of Transportation is leading the environmental study for that right now.
    • 05:16:53
      They did have a public meeting this past week where they released the preferred alternative which is a very important step in the NEPA project or in the NEPA process.
    • 05:17:03
      They've identified the alternative as a new two-track structure that will be just on the north side of the existing two-track structure and then joining in with four tracks on both the Virginia side and the DC side.
    • 05:17:18
      They've also proposed as a potential mitigation opportunity
    • 05:17:22
      A bike ped bridge, which is an issue that has garnered a lot of interest by advocates up there in Northern Virginia.
    • 05:17:29
      And anyway, that has been out there.
    • 05:17:34
      We are continuing to work with DDOT on this really, really important project.
    • 05:17:39
      We still don't expect to have a final record of decision until early 2020.
    • 05:17:45
      It's a very long environmental process because of some of the
    • 05:17:50
      Actually, the easiest part of it is locating the bridge.
    • 05:17:53
      That was actually the easiest part because it's like threading a needle through there.
    • 05:17:56
      There's really only one place it can go.
    • 05:17:58
      The hardest part though is some of the mitigation aspects on either side and working with the park service and some other people.
    • 05:18:05
      So anyway, we'll keep you updated on that, but we were excited to see that hit the news this week and look forward to continuing to advance that.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:18:14
      And the draft environmental due in the spring of 2019.
    • 05:18:22
      Mr. Commissioner.
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:18:22
      I just have two items for you today.
    • 05:18:26
      You may have noticed on the agenda package for today we did not talk about at-risk projects.
    • 05:18:32
      We are still working with the localities for those four projects that I mentioned to you back in October.
    • 05:18:38
      to be able to either re-scope those or identify opportunities for additional funds whether they're going to bring those funds to fruition.
    • 05:18:47
      I anticipate having those conversations completed in time for the January meeting and hopefully we won't have a briefing but I have a feeling at least one of those projects on that list is not going to come to fruition so we'll bring that for your information in January and probably some action in the February meeting to be able to take the appropriate action at that point in time.
    • 05:19:08
      So I'll spare you the hour and a half conversation today for January.
    • 05:19:15
      And I'd like to depart on a good note that this year VDOT has been awarded two very high honors from the Design Build Institute of America awards.
    • 05:19:28
      One of which was the I-66 Route 15 Interchange Design Build project in the Northern Virginia District that was constructed by Lane, the team of Lane and RDA.
    • 05:19:40
      and then the second one was the I-64 capacity improvement segment one which was a Shirley Dewberry team.
    • 05:19:48
      I do want to note that the I-66 Route 15 was that project was selected by DBIA as the project of the year award.
    • 05:19:59
      And so that is the highest honor that is granted to a design-build project there.
    • 05:20:05
      It's the equivalent of winning a gold medal.
    • 05:20:07
      So in order for that to do that, it had to not only win its transportation merit
    • 05:20:15
      as number one in that, but it also competed against the other 11 sectors of design build, so kudos to our team, the Northern Virginia District, as well as the Lane RDA team for bringing that award back to Virginia this year.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:20:32
      Congratulations.
    • 05:20:34
      Really great.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:20:37
      What made it when?
    • 05:20:40
      Where were the metrics?
    • Stephen C. BrichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:20:41
      I can't answer that.
    • 05:20:44
      Yeah, thanks.
    • 05:20:45
      You should have prepped me beforehand.
    • 05:20:47
      I'll be able to give that back to you.
    • 05:20:49
      I don't know.
    • 05:20:49
      Garrett, do you have any?
    • 05:20:52
      Shlender's not here for that.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:20:54
      I'm just curious.
    • 05:20:55
      I'm sorry.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:20:56
      Okay.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:21:11
      And as we discussed during the earlier discussion on I-81, we're still working with Norfolk Southern on this and trying to get this moving forward as fast as we can.
    • 05:21:19
      It's been a long process.
    • 05:21:23
      But we are still in discussions with them over it.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:21:27
      The second train would be the one that would actually be extended, our vision is that would be the one that would be extended to Blacksburg-Christiansburg.
    • 05:21:35
      So it's all, pardon me?
    • 05:21:38
      Well, it would go through Roanoke-Lynchburg up through Charlottesville.
    • 05:21:44
      So yes, we are still, it's all part of our multimodal plan.
    • 05:21:50
      Right, Mr. Kasprowicz?
    • 05:21:52
      That we're working to get more money into.
    • 05:21:54
      I don't know where Mr. Donohue went, but.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:21:57
      Secretary, we don't actually have new business, but there's a topic that keeps coming up that I have been wondering whether CTB or some convening might be able to help with.
    • 05:22:13
      And the topic is scooters, electric scooters, which have become ubiquitous and have actually no real place that they belong.
    • 05:22:22
      They don't belong on sidewalks.
    • 05:22:23
      They go too fast.
    • 05:22:24
      They actually go too fast for the bike lanes because they go 25 miles an hour.
    • 05:22:29
      They don't belong in the regular lanes because people have no helmets or protection and ride stupidly.
    • 05:22:35
      And every jurisdiction where these things have landed is struggling with what to do.
    • 05:22:42
      And I just wondered whether there was capacity in our realm here
    • 05:22:49
      Thank you.
    • 05:23:09
      On motorized vehicles potentially coming at you on both sides of your vehicle going the wrong direction.
    • 05:23:16
      I had a very near accident with two early teenagers who just were cut in corners.
    • 05:23:26
      But it's not just me.
    • 05:23:27
      People are coming up to me at church and in the grocery store, and everybody is very concerned that someone's going to die.
    • 05:23:34
      Well, it was one of the issues.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:23:37
      There are a few issues like that, but that's one of the issues that I hope to possibly work through.
    • 05:23:42
      The Office of Innovation, where would that go?
    • 05:23:45
      How do we look at policy implications?
    • 05:23:47
      How would this board be involved?
    • 05:23:49
      So it's residing there right now.
    • 05:23:51
      There hasn't been a lot of movement, but certainly has been an issue that has come up.
    • 05:23:56
      Yes.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:23:58
      Mr. Stinson, anything?
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:24:00
      So we have got some budget meetings that we need to attend this afternoon.
    • 05:24:07
      So with everyone's permission, we are going to suspend.
    • 05:24:12
      I said bye.
    • 05:24:16
      Gosh, that was not even painful.
    • 05:24:19
      We're going to suspend for today, and then we'll come back in the morning.
    • 05:24:23
      I may have some other remarks, and we'll go into our action meeting.
    • 05:24:27
      So, Carol, do you want to just tell everyone what the logistics are?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 05:24:31
      Logistics tonight are if you haven't checked into the hotel yet, you're staying at Commonwealth Park Suites on Bank Street.
    • 05:24:37
      We will have a shuttle there at 5.45 to pick you up from the hotel, and we are going to Acacia for dinner tonight.
    • Shannon ValentineChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:24:48
      Okay, with that we're suspended.
    • 05:24:49
      Thank you.