Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 9/19/2017
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
9/19/2017
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
I-81 Corridor update.pdf
1. DC2RVA Hanover/Hanover Area Community Advisory Committee Update
▶︎
19:12
DC2RVA Ashland _ Hanover Area Community Advisory Committee update.pdf
2. Smart Scale Update
▶︎
1:21:29
SMART SCALE updates.pdf
3. FY 2017 Budget / Actual Performance FY 2018 Year-to-Date August Revenue Update – CTF and Regional Revenue Expectations
▶︎
2:32:30
FY 2017 Budget _ Actual Performance FY 2018 Year-to-Date August Revenue Update – CTF and Regional Revenue Expectations.pdf
4. PPTA Implementation Manual & Guidelines - 2017 Updates
▶︎
2:51:09
Public-Private Transportation Act Implementation Manual and guidelines, 2017 updates.pdf
5. I-64 Express Lanes proposed Toll Supported Transit Services
▶︎
5:14:50
I-64 Express Lanes – Proposed Toll Supported Transit Services.pdf
6. Update on Vanpool/VA Implementation
▶︎
5:21:27
Update on Vanpool!VA implementation.pdf
7. Rail Industrial Access Program Application Briefing Steel Dynamics Roanoke Bar Division
▶︎
5:28:57
Rail Industrial Access Program application briefing, Steel Dynamics Roanoke Bar Division, Roanoke.pdf
8. VDOT Roadway Lighting - Energy Performance Contract
▶︎
5:32:09
VDOT roadway lighting energy performance contract.pdf
9. Commissioner’s Items
▶︎
7:08:18
10. Director’s Items
▶︎
7:15:26
11. Secretary’s Items
▶︎
7:17:56
SPEAKER_14
00:03:13
and Steve Toulon.
SPEAKER_10
00:04:23
That's number 3, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, September 19, testing CTB, 1, 2, 3, 4.
SPEAKER_00
00:05:52
with today's disciplines.
00:14:58
Good morning.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:15:01
I'm Aubrey Layne, chairman of the Commonwealth Transportation Board and secretary of transportation for the state.
SPEAKER_03
00:15:26
Before y'all get too comfortable, let's go ahead and get this out of the way.
00:15:53
The vote will be tomorrow.
00:15:55
I know Mr. Arzinsky will be a little bit late.
00:15:59
He'll be here hopefully around noon.
00:16:01
You say half will be a little bit late also?
00:16:03
He'll be later here today, Mr. Connors.
00:16:05
And I don't think the others are scheduled to be with us today.
00:16:09
So we do have a full agenda.
00:16:13
And I'm going to add a couple things to point out before we start.
00:16:17
There will be an item added this afternoon.
00:16:27
I do believe there are some things that are inaccurate and some of the things that have been said.
00:16:39
So I've asked Nick to put together all the things that have transpired on 81, the projects and the issues as to where we stand and what the options are in terms of
00:16:59
We have spent quite a few hours with legislators up and down the corridor with VDOT looking at options on the road and while we're in detail this afternoon I would remind everybody there is a prohibition specifically at the state level against any type of tolling on anyone and if you look at what's happened
00:17:24
I think there's this misconception that a lot of state money is going into Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads for these major interstate projects.
00:17:31
And quite frankly, very little of state money is on its tolls and regional monies that are supporting the majority of these projects.
00:17:38
So I just want to get everything out there.
00:17:41
I'm not trying to be defensive, but I want to be factual as to how we go forward, because it looks like it's going to be an issue that may be
00:17:51
taken up by this board in the future, and it may become a political objective of the governor, which is the interview.
00:17:59
I just want to make sure we're off the speed as to what it may be.
00:18:04
Also, tomorrow, we are having, and the governor will be up here for an event, kicking off the intermodal aspects of Interstate 66 and other things, and you're all welcome to join us after that event.
00:18:20
And in fact, if you're on the plane, you have no choice but to come to that event because the plane's not going to take you back until after that's done.
00:18:28
So I just want to point out everybody.
00:18:30
We're looking forward to that tomorrow too.
00:18:33
Before we get started, I do see a couple of people.
00:18:36
I'd like to recognize you, Mr. Jim Dyke back there in the back of the room.
00:18:40
Jim, thank you for being here today.
00:18:46
You can come up here and vote if you want.
00:18:49
Anyway, so thank you for that.
00:18:53
I know, is Quintin still here from CSX?
00:18:56
Yes, thanks for being up.
00:18:57
Randy, thanks for being here.
00:19:00
And so just appreciate the partnership we have with CSX and working through things.
00:19:05
So welcome.
00:19:07
So with that, I think we'll go right ahead and get into the agenda.
00:19:12
We decided to start with a non-controversial conflict in the DC to RBA Hanover Area Community Advisory Committee.
00:19:21
So Ms. Stock, good morning.
Emily Stock
Manager of Rail Planning
00:19:25
Good morning.
00:19:26
Thank you.
00:19:30
So I'm Emily Stock.
00:19:31
I'm with the Virginia Department of Rail and Public Transportation.
00:19:34
And I am going to be focusing on the Ashland and Hanover area in the presentation today.
00:19:42
This is a portion of the D.C. to RBA project for
00:19:48
The Ashland-Hanover area has presented unique challenges and we recognize that we needed to do some more community work in this area to help us narrow down some alternatives. So, I'm joined by Barb Nelson, who's going to get up and present the last slide that we have with recommendations.
00:20:13
Barbara is from the Richmond Regional Transportation Planning Organization.
00:20:19
So she sat on the Ashland-Hanover Community Advisory Committee and that's the name of the group that was formed to help discern some of the issues with rail and expanding rail capacity through the Ashland-Hanover area.
00:20:37
And I thank all of the groups that participated in this process, the town of Ashland,
00:20:43
C.S.E.P.S., Hanover County, Randolph-Macon College, and of course Barbara Nelson from the Richmond Regional Transportation Planning Organization.
00:20:53
And I'll talk a little bit about the purpose of the Community Advisory Committee.
00:21:00
It was meant to advise and inform DRPT on DC to RVA alternatives in the Ashland and Hanover area and review all of the alternatives that have been brought forth to date.
00:21:14
So in the draft environmental impact statement and through the alternatives development process, DRPT reviewed probably 30 different alternatives through this area.
00:21:26
It presents unique challenges because of the density of development in downtown Ashland and the historic structures and historic nature of downtown Ashland.
00:21:37
And also the fact that we did explore the possibility of a bypass.
00:21:41
And so there are potentially more impacts in this area than in the rest of the 123 miles of DC to RBA.
00:21:52
So we really leaned on the community advisory committee for their assistance and their knowledge of the area and to get some additional feedback on the different alternatives that were considered.
00:22:04
So their goal was also to identify and represent the concerns of each one of these different communities because each alternative would affect each community a little bit differently from the college to the county to the town and also the region
00:22:21
and we also wanted to apply a structured and transparent approach to seeking consensus.
00:22:27
So all of our meetings were open to the public and were recorded and all the materials are up on our website.
00:22:37
So I do want to take a minute and talk about the draft environmental impact statement for the full corridor.
00:22:43
We do have a draft environmental impact statement available for review right now, and this process with the Ashland Hanover community was going on parallel to actually getting the draft environmental impact statement out.
00:23:00
So I don't want to minimize the
00:23:05
The importance of the overall document.
00:23:08
This is a National Environmental Policy Act required document and it's out for 60-day public comment right now.
00:23:16
So it's a formal public comment period.
00:23:19
It started on Friday, September 8th and goes until November 7th.
00:23:24
And we are having public hearings associated with that public comment period.
00:23:29
The announcements for those public hearings will be going out this week.
00:23:32
And we'll be having a couple in Northern Virginia in Fredericksburg area, one in Ashland and one in the Richmond area.
00:23:39
So even while this CAC process was going on, we had the draft environmental impact statement.
00:23:48
recommendations for preferred alternatives in the rest of the state, but we left the area in Ashland and Hanover open-ended in the draft environmental impact statement, so you'll see that our recommendation does not cover that area, that's about a 14-mile area. So the four different alternatives that were carried forward in the draft environmental impact statement are no additional track in downtown Ashland, So that's also known as the 3-2-3 option.
00:24:18
that narrows the tracks from 3 to 2 through downtown in order to minimize impacts.
00:24:25
We also looked at three tracks through Ashland with a couple of different scenarios, one adding a third track to the east of the existing alignment and another is to center the three tracks so that there is equal space on either side.
00:24:44
And then we also looked at a two-track western Hanover County bypass as part of the draft environmental impact statement.
00:24:51
Now there is an appendix of the DEIS called the Alternatives Technical Report where all 30 alternatives are described in detail.
00:25:01
But these were the alternatives that we focused on in the draft EIS.
00:25:07
And that's because most of that report was written before the CAC convened for the first time.
00:25:14
It was in FRA review for a few months and is now out.
00:25:19
So we are looking to of course brief the CTB on the CAC activities and also incorporate all of the work that the Community Advisory Committee did over the last few months in a supplemental report that will be included in the final environmental impact statement.
00:25:40
So there will be a report that documents everything that the CAC did including meeting minutes and the recommendations.
00:25:48
That will be included in the final report so that none of this work is lost.
00:25:53
So the next slide goes through the meetings that we had with the CAC.
00:25:59
We started in May and had our last meeting in September and so in May in the early meetings we really talked about some of the technical details and the policy issues with NEPA study and how we could best incorporate the comments of the CAC and also the technical details of the different alternatives.
00:26:25
And through the process of talking about these alternatives, getting comments from the Community Advisory Committee, and then also getting comments from the public, we did have one meeting where there were public comments that came through.
00:26:40
We had a session of public comments in the July public meeting, or CAC meeting.
00:26:47
So through that process, we found that there is an alternative that we needed to explore more fully, and that's the tunnel
00:26:55
So, like I mentioned, we looked at bypasses, we looked at third tracks in town, we even looked at elevated rail, we looked at a deep ore tunnel to submerge tracks, but one option that really came out of this process is to have a shallow trench for all three tracks going through town.
00:27:20
So that's an alternative that's now on the table that wasn't before and we believe that it's an alternative that's valid and feasible when compared to the others and so we made sure that we talked about that and talked about the technical details of that with the Community Advisory Committee and the special thing about this particular option is that it does give us more capacity through the town of Ashland
00:27:50
without the impacts because the rail would be submerged and there could be traps that are built across the tracks in certain spots and they could be landscaped.
00:28:06
And it also solves the traffic problem at grade road rail crossings through the town of Ashland that are a problem now and that can cause accidents now.
00:28:14
Now I don't want to minimize the construction impacts.
00:28:17
There are huge construction impacts for this alternative, and we expect that the construction period would take about three years.
00:28:24
So there still would be work to do on this alternative as construction is planned, if it were the preferred alternative at some point.
00:28:33
But since that's not in the DEIS, I wanted to talk a little bit about that particular option.
00:28:39
So the goal that we had for the Community Advisory Committee once we went through this process was to choose least objectionable alternatives within the different categories of alternatives that we looked at.
00:28:53
So we asked for a least objectionable through-town alternative.
00:28:58
We asked for a least objectionable bypass alternative.
SPEAKER_03
00:29:01
We asked for a preferred, but we could not get consensus on that.
00:29:05
Let me just make clear.
00:29:07
We asked for them to come to preferred.
00:29:09
What they ultimately said is we will give you our list of least objectionable.
00:29:14
I think that's a key point to keep in mind here.
00:29:18
And I'm trying to prejudice one or the other
00:29:22
W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
Emily Stock
Manager of Rail Planning
00:29:53
And any alternative in this area would have huge impacts.
00:29:59
We don't anticipate that historic buildings in town would need to be taken.
00:30:07
We've minimized the impacts as much as possible.
00:30:09
But of course, having a third tractor town does make a difference.
00:30:14
And we don't want to minimize the impacts of any of the alternatives, certainly the western bypass as well.
00:30:19
There are more potential property impacts in this 10, 14-mile stretch than there are in the rest of the corridor.
00:30:28
Thank you.
00:30:29
So the different categories that we looked at were below ground, above ground, sort of track through town.
00:30:37
or possibly only a two-track option for the town and then a bypass.
00:30:43
So we were able to get to least objectionable alternatives within those categories.
00:30:50
I do want to point out, as the Secretary mentioned, that these are not meant to be endorsements of these alternatives by the groups that helped us through this process.
00:31:01
And I'm going to turn things over to Barbara Nelson to talk about the
00:31:06
A little bit about the process and the recent actionable alternatives.
00:31:10
I do want to point out I handed out a memo from Jennifer Mitchell to the CTB that lists those and describes those and also lists all of the other alternatives that were considered.
00:31:27
Thanks.
SPEAKER_08
00:31:27
Good morning.
00:31:28
Good morning.
00:31:28
Thank you.
00:31:29
I'm Barbara Nelson with the Richmond Regional Transportation Planning Organization.
00:31:34
and on behalf of our organization and the Community Advisory Committee, we appreciate the opportunity that DRPT and the Commonwealth Transportation Board have extended for the additional analysis of this board.
00:31:49
We know that there were a number of public meetings and discussions that have been going on since November 2014 and that as of December of 2016, there were still significant concerns and unanswered questions on behalf
00:32:05
Ashland and Hanover Community, and I think there's a sincere appreciation by the members of the CAC and the dedication of resources that the Commonwealth Transportation Board has dedicated to exploring, yes, a desire to achieve a preferred alternative, and it was a very challenging process, and I think everyone
00:32:32
had the intent and the best interest of achieving that desire of selecting the preferred alternative, but in the end, the selection came down to three.
00:32:45
As Emily mentioned, DRPT from May through September provided the legal foundations of the EIS process, which for the community advisory committee, it was very important for them to have an understanding
00:33:01
of the differences of what a planning level EIS can do versus the details that can come out of the final EIS as we move forward into the design.
00:33:13
The community has a much better understanding of the environmental and technical aspects and appreciate the efforts that DRPT made in not only accepting but responding to a significant number
00:33:30
At the September 11th meeting, the final evaluation of 15 alternatives was reduced to three.
00:33:42
As Emily mentioned, there were three through town, three under town, four to the west, five to the east, that were in the final, the 30 alternatives that Emily mentioned have been written down to 15, and three were selected
00:33:59
And as noted on the slide, they are the least objectionable as recommended by the advisory committee.
00:34:10
And they include a 323 option, which is adding rail capacity to the south and to the north and maintaining two tracks through town.
00:34:22
The third track, Trench, I think as Emily mentioned, it's also important to note
00:34:27
that while this is a very interesting proposal and it was one that was recommended from the former, the advisory committee really only had from August 20th to consider that.
00:34:42
And so perhaps, and we understand the challenge of time and the opportunity of time, but the time to evaluate that as an option has not been as extensive as the other options through town to the west or to the east.
00:34:58
The final recommendation that came out of the advisory committee was for western by-laws.
00:35:05
As I mentioned, there were four alternatives that were considered for the west.
00:35:10
The one that was recommended was the AWD-1, as the least objectionable, and that is the alignment that comes closest to the town.
00:35:27
I'd be glad to answer any questions that you may have regarding our process, but again, since our appreciation to DRPT and CTB for the additional resources and the time to have these.
SPEAKER_03
00:35:45
Perhaps, Ward, I'm going to ask Mr. Kendall to come up and talk and then maybe we can have questions after you've heard them.
00:35:51
As everyone knows, the
00:35:55
That tract was not owned by the Commonwealth, it was owned by CSX.
00:36:00
And they have been great partners and are part of our Atlanta Gateway Project.
00:36:04
And part of this, the real issue, we're dealing with 120-some miles that we're trying to get an alternative on from the federal authorities.
00:36:13
And as you recall, 66 is 22 miles.
00:36:17
So this is an extremely long corridor and lots of divergent issues.
00:36:22
But the issue,
00:36:24
We are partnering with CSX not only here but at our Port of Virginia and there is substantial more freight movements going to be coming up this quarter in addition to the options for additional passenger rail.
00:36:37
So I think it's important that we hear from CSX and what they want to say about this as we make our decisions.
SPEAKER_11
00:36:46
Thank you for being here.
00:36:47
Thank you very much Mr. Chairman and thank you Director Mitchell for allowing me to come speak.
00:36:55
and this project between CSX and DRPT.
00:36:58
But for years, on multiple administrations, how do we increase freight capacity on the RFMP, freight and passenger capacity, and do it jointly, benefiting both and harming neither?
00:37:11
And it's fascinating, we're 25 years from the initiation of DRE service, and we cave in, everyone had eyes wide open, knowing that we would not have enough capacity on the RFMP
00:37:37
We've made progress incrementally.
00:37:39
I will say, under the leadership of Governor McAuliffe and Secretary Layne and Director Mitchell, we've shot forward with rocket fuel.
00:37:46
There's a lot of great work that has been done to add rail capacity in Virginia.
00:37:51
And you all are to be commended, and we see you as being an outstanding partner.
00:37:55
I want to also appreciate the work and commend DRPT on the work on this study.
00:38:00
Director Mitchell, Emily Stock, this is a big, big deal.
00:38:06
Smith Jr., and Emily Stock.
00:38:14
Thank you.
00:38:40
I don't like it.
00:38:41
But this committee, I think, just did a great job where they were very thoughtful.
00:38:47
Clearly, what they're trying to do is protect the interests of their fellow citizens.
00:38:49
But they never lost sight of the big picture.
00:38:51
And they do see how rail capacity will help the overall benefits of the Commonwealth.
00:38:59
But I did want to come here.
00:39:00
It's in the spirit of continuing partnership to be transparent, fact-based, and clear with our position on the study.
00:39:12
Throughout this process, it's been very, very clear about not having a specific position on the alignment.
00:39:20
This is a passenger rail study.
00:39:22
The idea of the CRDA is to add nine new round-trip trains in.
00:39:27
So we're not picking any side or any alignment on this.
00:39:32
But it is critical to note that the FRA modeling that was shared with us regarding the 323 option showed some unacceptably degraded
00:39:41
In the scenario that we looked at, the average delay for 100 train miles is nearly 30 minutes.
00:39:47
And about 20% of the freight trains that are delayed are delayed for three hours or more.
00:39:54
And we see on this the freight trains can be stopped in Newport News.
00:40:12
McPherson Jr., John F. McPherson Jr., John F. McPherson Jr.,
00:40:40
So the delays would, in fact, negate these investments and make it very, very unreliable service for us.
00:40:48
So again, while we maintain no position on any of the DCR data alignments, we are opposed to a 3-2-3 proposal as the modeling to date shows an unacceptable level of degradation in freight service.
00:41:01
Again, we value the longstanding positive relationship we have with the Commonwealth.
00:41:05
Working together, we've achieved a lot of goals and will continue to do
00:41:25
So we appreciate and understand that CTB and several federal policy makers have difficult decisions to make to achieve passenger train goals and we hope this information will benefit your consideration.
00:41:38
So thank you again Mr. Chairman and Mr. Director Mitchell for the time today.
SPEAKER_03
00:41:41
Thank you and I assume if we get a discussion you'll be able to answer some questions for us.
00:41:46
Absolutely, absolutely.
00:41:47
Let me make a couple comments and I will let Mr. Mitchell say a few things.
00:41:51
First of all, 323 with your product will be no-build option, just so you understand what that is.
00:42:00
Quintin mentioned the Port of Virginia, the $700 million investment.
00:42:07
We are the highest percentage port on the East Coast to move stuff by rail, almost 40%.
00:42:16
The capacity right now at the Port of Virginia, we're going to be around 2.8%.
00:42:21
A million TEUs a year.
00:42:24
We've been growing every month, setting new records, big ships coming, the whole bit.
00:42:31
The capacity will add an additional million TEUs.
00:42:36
A million TEUs.
00:42:37
That means 400,000 rail movements and 600,000 of trucks leaving the Port of Virginia.
00:42:47
So the capacity is coming.
00:42:49
This is not, you know,
00:42:52
something that we don't know about.
00:42:54
It is coming.
00:42:55
We've been setting new records every month at the port in that.
00:43:00
So, the reason I point that out is this is not something that is static in nature.
00:43:09
I mean, we've already seen, in fact, some cases the increase in the activity at the port has exceeded the modeling we've looked at because the port's growing quicker than we envisioned.
00:43:20
That's all good news.
00:43:21
for Virginia.
00:43:23
It's not such good news for the town of Ashland or that surrounding area, because this is not something from the standpoint that's going to be avoided.
00:43:32
There's going to be impacts there, because there's going to be more trains going up and down that corridor, no matter what in that regard.
00:43:40
So this brings in safety, and you've all put the CTB up there.
00:43:44
You've all seen.
00:43:46
That one's right through the middle of town in that regard.
00:43:50
One other thing, we did ask that these are improvements that you should know will probably won't be made for 20 years or more in there.
00:43:58
In other words, that as we look at other improvements, it'll take precedent.
00:44:02
And we did ask the federal authorities to give us a record of decision without a final decision in action because it's going to require whatever the position we take is going to require additional study when we get closer down the road.
00:44:18
The Feds said no, you must pick
00:44:20
Now, they did not give us that option.
00:44:23
They did not want to kick down the road anymore.
00:44:25
It doesn't mean whatever is picked will actually get done, but it means we'll be on record as what will be an alternative for the basis of what will eventually get done.
00:44:37
So I just thank you just to refresh everybody what's going on here.
00:44:41
And with that, Ms. Mitchell, I'll turn it over to you.
00:44:45
You've been in this with Ms. Stock and others for a long time.
00:44:50
and your comments greatly appreciate it.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:52
Yeah, and I do want to, again, recognize the work that the CAC did.
00:44:56
We had a number of community members from Ashland, from Dacolich and Canada County, from Randolph-Hagan, and while I think our original goal to try to get to a preferred alternative was a very ambitious one, the fact that we actually got down to some least objectionable ones actually represents a lot of work.
00:45:18
and I do also want to recognize Emily and her team.
00:45:22
They spent a lot of time.
00:45:23
They were sitting in people's living rooms.
00:45:26
They went out on Saturdays.
00:45:28
They had a lot of extra meetings to help facilitate this.
00:45:32
I do want to recognize the team that we had that was working on this as well.
00:45:38
I guess we had a lot of discussion with CSX as well about
00:45:45
A preferred alternative, and at this point we're not making any recommendation to the CTB today.
00:45:52
We plan to come back in October and we're going to brief you on the entire corridor.
00:45:57
At that point we will still be in the middle of the public comment period.
00:46:02
The public comment period closes I believe November 8th or 9th, around there, and so
00:46:08
What we will then do is come back to you again in December.
00:46:13
And we're going to ask you in December to make a finding on a preferred alternative.
00:46:17
But at the workshop meeting, we will also brief you on any major things that we've heard during the public comment period.
00:46:24
And we do expect that at our CTB meetings, we'll probably have some members of the public also coming here to provide you with some comments as well.
00:46:35
I will say that regarding the issues of freight delays, we're very concerned about this as well because obviously freight is extremely important to us in Virginia.
00:46:46
The Port of Virginia is extremely important too.
00:46:49
We've done some modeling ourselves to try to get to and try to understand some of the same issues that our partners at CSX were seeing too.
00:46:59
I think
00:46:59
What we've seen, at least through the work that the analysis that our team has done, is that those freight delays are really not necessarily the results of the additional passenger trains, but really present in what we call the near-build scenario with just as a result of the background freight road that we expect to see.
00:47:22
And those assumptions are ones that we've worked on with FRA, with CSX,
00:47:27
to come up with some generally acceptable assumptions about what we expect to see for freight growth in the future.
00:47:36
The difference between a three-track alternative and a three-two-three or two-tracks is really not that significant.
00:47:45
Less than 5% difference, at least, in terms of the freight delays that we saw in both scenarios.
00:47:50
And so while the issue of having adequate freight capacity is very important to us,
00:47:56
We would want to make sure that we make investments throughout the state to minimize those.
00:48:02
We didn't necessarily see a huge difference between a three-track option and a three-two-three option.
00:48:10
But again, we're working with CSX on that.
00:48:12
It's very important to us that we don't have significant pre-release in the state.
00:48:18
But we are trying to accomplish some goals with passenger service as well.
SPEAKER_03
00:48:26
Just with mention there, they go hand in hand, quite frankly.
00:48:30
And this is sort of like, I would say, the conversation on global warming.
00:48:35
Whatever causes it, the Earth is still getting warmer.
00:48:39
And that is similar to what's happening here.
00:48:42
Whatever the original design, whatever, we are faced with significant freight movements in addition to other capacity that is coming through this quarter.
00:48:51
In fact, the state wants to come through this quarter.
00:48:54
Now, before we open this up, just think
00:48:57
Every time we look at a project like this, I know a lot of people think it's just, we just go down the road without a lot of thought, but that is not true.
00:49:06
In fact, we've had conversations, you've probably seen about the bikes on 66 in terms of what the purpose.
00:49:14
Here's what I know my team, we look at in working with the other departments.
00:49:20
Our first as a board is to enhance transportation movements in the economy.
00:49:27
That is what the Commonwealth Transportation Board is supposed to do, to move that forward.
00:49:33
Now, on top of that, obviously, there are other constituents.
00:49:38
And the hierarchy I tend to go through is, what is that, what is necessary to move that forward?
00:49:45
Obviously, safety would be the number one topic, and that can come into play here.
00:49:54
That would be the impact to the homeowners or the property owners that are in the past.
00:50:02
But the overriding issue for us is to move forward transportation in the Commonwealth, minimizing the impact as we go down that hierarchy.
00:50:15
And that's not just for freight, it's for passenger rail, it's for road work we do.
00:50:20
So a lot of thought is given that.
00:50:23
When we direct improvements to our concessionaires or contractors, we lay that out.
00:50:30
And then there are some things that are just not as important to us.
00:50:33
Well, they're important, but they come after that hierarchy in terms of what we're doing.
00:50:38
So I'll end and open up the discussion.
00:50:41
There is going to be no easy answer here.
00:50:45
We've heard from our partners at CSX that the current configuration is going to forestall
00:50:52
O'Hare Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr.,
00:51:13
Everybody, when you make this vote, come around saying, I'm really happy.
00:51:18
Everybody's not going to come up to you and say, I'm really happy you did that.
00:51:21
There is going to be someone that's not going to be happy.
00:51:24
I'm sorry.
00:51:25
And that's the way we have approached it.
00:51:30
When I met with them, I think the first meeting he had, when I said to him, I hope we can reach consensus, but I wish I could stand here and tell you there's not going to be somebody impacted.
00:51:39
And that has unfortunately held true.
00:51:43
So I just throw that out there as we go through this.
00:51:47
This is going to be one of those decisions that's very, very difficult.
00:51:51
And again, why are you independent?
00:51:54
Because there's going to be a lot of political pressure on you to do one thing or another.
00:51:59
So anyway, I throw that out there.
00:52:01
And with that, let's throw any questions or discussion.
00:52:04
And I'm sure Ms. Stock, Ms. Nelson, and Mr. Pendle will be happy to answer questions
00:52:14
W. Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:29
It was something that really came out of the process when we were looking for some less impactful underground options.
00:52:37
And it really, I would say, I guess I can answer why it didn't come up sooner, but trenches are used elsewhere around the country.
00:52:45
And so this was something that our team generated while we were talking through the community advisories committee process.
00:52:55
So a new alternative.
00:52:58
you know if this were to be carried forward we would have to do some additional study on it and it certainly offers a lot of benefits in the long term and in its final form but the construction impacts are not insignificant.
00:53:11
and that is something that we talk about.
00:53:13
So it doesn't, we didn't get the level of analysis necessarily that the other alternative did through the DBIS process, but I think if it does get carried forward, it's something that has some promise and could potentially be a good alternative long-term.
00:53:32
Will we be able to make a decision without the additional analysis or do we have that time to be able to make a decision?
00:53:39
I think the information that we'll have, we've got some preliminary design information and more than happy to provide all of that to you as well.
00:53:48
And some information about the impacts too and cost information too.
00:53:54
I think though that if it is carried forward, there's a lot of work that would still need to be done that's more final design related that would relate to where the caps could be and really more about aesthetically what
00:54:09
The impact would be on the town.
SPEAKER_03
00:54:11
Well, I can make a point of your comment.
00:54:13
First of all, the decision you're going to make is an unconstrained decision.
00:54:17
You do not have to consider cost, although this is extremely worse.
00:54:21
It's more expensive.
00:54:22
But so I want to make clear we're picking.
00:54:25
And as I said, it's going to get a lot more look down the road when it's actually done in that.
00:54:30
So I think that's a point to be made here.
00:54:35
This is
00:54:36
What you'd like to see may not be what in fact happens.
00:54:41
I would also say it's the same thing, this technology for the first time in the state's history appears we're going to have a board tunnel at the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel.
00:54:53
So I think the technology in terms of what's been happening, at least of its acceptance in the Commonwealth, in fact the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel, Mr. Kilpatrick is going to look at those options.
00:55:05
I think to answer your question here, there were a lot of things that I really compliment the staff and the community trying to find what's the right way to do it.
00:55:18
And that's how it came out of that with these technology coming out.
00:55:22
It wasn't like this was something out there that no one just decided what they were going to think about for costing everything else.
00:55:29
It was simply an evolution that had come through.
00:55:32
But that is another key point to remember.
00:55:36
When you make these decisions, Jennifer will give numbers about costs, but it's an unconstrained decision.
00:55:42
It's like what you'd like to see happen in that.
00:55:45
Now, don't get me wrong, it's going to set a path forward if you're in that, but you're not mandated to consider costs in this decision.
00:55:56
You may consider it, but you're not mandated to.
00:56:00
And the fact of the matter is, whenever you decide there's no money to build in this
00:56:05
E. Scott Kasprowicz, John Malbon, Marty Williams H. Kasprowicz, John Malbon, Marty Williams
00:56:34
That's why we ask the federal authorities, let's see how these other things progress and possibly not make a decision here, but that was rejected by the federal authorities.
00:56:44
And the last thing I'll mention on this, they may not take your recommendation.
00:56:49
It is up to the FRA to make the final decision.
00:56:52
Now they typically, their history has been they have taken the state's recommendation, but they are under no guidelines that they have to take.
00:57:04
So there will be federal oversight of this also.
00:57:08
And as you all know, transportation is being talked about.
00:57:13
Trump administration, while we've gotten a lot of details, have talked a lot about freight movements and movements of goods in addition to people in terms of their looking at transportation.
00:57:26
I can't give you any guidance on that because we haven't seen anything other than to say it's been talked about a lot.
00:57:35
Greg, that's part of it and how it came out and we are trying to minimize any impacts and this would be probably, we think, although Jennifer is gone, we don't know what the impact is.
00:57:48
You know this, railroads don't like brakes, either down or up, because their trains, you know, they kind of slow down and the whole bit.
00:57:59
So anyway, that's another thing we have to consider.
SPEAKER_08
00:58:06
I keep thinking about the maintenance of service during any construction that would be going on and so I guess when you come back to us I would like to understand a little bit better that issue particularly around the trench is how could service be maintained as you were digging a hole and
00:58:34
And does that have implications for that we ought to be thinking about how you're going to divert during that time period.
00:58:42
Maybe there's something that we see people out here looking at.
00:58:45
So I'd just be interested in understanding that better.
00:58:50
And then I know when we went to the town and when people came and testified, there was a lot of town identity kind of tied up.
00:59:00
And it wasn't just the trains going through to me, but it was the station as well.
00:59:04
So I think I want to understand that too when you come back.
00:59:09
Where does the station mean and under which scenarios does it mean?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:17
As far as your second question goes with the station, with a trench or the 323 option, it looks like we would not be able to keep the station there in order to make those alternatives work.
00:59:31
with a bypass there would still be an alternative to have a station in Ashland and we certainly recognize it really and all of that will be determined in a final health service development plan we do recognize that the town is has a lot of identity you know wrapped up in as a railroad town we heard that over and over and over which is you know really important thing for Ashland we
00:59:58
However from an operational standpoint there are impacts and if there is a way to you know also I would say when they when trains stop they also do block the roads that are crossing the Americans so there is impacts to having a number of passengers all stopped in downtown but yeah we'd be happy to bring back some more information about that.
SPEAKER_04
01:00:26
As we look at this the next time, do we have definitive projections on what the freight traffic growth will be specifically over the next 10-15 years?
01:00:36
I think that will be helpful to quantify that and help to understand the impacts.
01:00:40
I would assume that there's a point where it would become difficult to travel through town if there's a significant increase in freight traffic that could shut down crossings through a period of time.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:49
Yeah, and we have done, our team has done some analysis to look at the
01:00:54
The one thing I'll note about the 323, while it is a new build alternative, it does include raid separations on both the north and south side of town, so it does provide some additional connectivity
01:01:18
across the tracks that does not exist today.
01:01:20
So while we call it a no-build option, it's really not.
01:01:23
It's got a significant amount of improvements.
01:01:27
Yeah, it is a very important part of that plan.
01:01:31
But I think we agreed on some background assumptions with FRA.
01:01:37
I don't remember exactly what those, I think it was maybe 3% a year for background freight growth.
01:01:46
A lot of that is obviously driven by economic issues.
01:01:51
But the plan does account for a significant amount of freight growth between now and 2045, which is the horizon.
SPEAKER_03
01:02:01
And I think CSS could provide what their, you know, Mr. Fennell, anything you could enact.
01:02:08
And I have just a question.
01:02:11
If, you know, this is CSS practice.
01:02:15
Can they be forced to do something they don't want to do?
01:02:20
In other words, let's say at the end of the day it's their property and we pick something and we don't know the answer.
01:02:34
Are there rules or laws that force a private railroad to do something that they're the objective?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:42
You know, there's certainly a regulatory structure that involves also the service transportation board when it comes down to some things like this, but in Virginia, we've always worked on passenger rail as a very collaborative effort where we negotiated the ability to get new trains.
01:02:59
I absolutely expect that that's what's going to continue in the future as well.
SPEAKER_03
01:03:04
I expect, and don't get me wrong, this was solely a technical question.
01:03:08
I don't think it's wise or anything, but my point is I just want to
01:03:12
I'm saying that because let's say we choose something that the citizens are least objectable to and it doesn't fit what CSX wants.
01:03:26
Can they be forced to take that?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:29
You know, it's a recommendation and a study.
01:03:31
At the end of the day, we're still then negotiating for projects.
SPEAKER_03
01:03:35
No, that's my point.
01:03:36
I just wanted to mention out here.
01:03:38
I don't see any scenario without a collaborative way
01:03:41
That we achieved the state's goals.
01:03:46
So that's what I was really trying to get to.
01:03:48
Where they may technically get to that, we're not going to achieve because we have to negotiate for every slide, every train in that regard.
01:03:57
So I just wanted to make the board aware of that, too.
01:04:01
Because I've had some citizens say, well, you can force them to do it.
01:04:04
Well, maybe there's a process, but there's all, you know, at the end of the day,
01:04:10
They don't have to sign other agreements either.
SPEAKER_14
01:04:14
Mr. Malton.
01:04:16
This forecast of demand, and I agree, and also the forecast of passenger rail demand and where that may go, does one track provide a long-term solution to this forecast of demand?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:34
You mean one additional track, the third?
SPEAKER_14
01:04:37
Because this could be a 100-year decision when you think about it.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:41
Sure.
01:04:44
The modeling that we've done shows, and really it's not just about can you accommodate the demand, but also what's your on-time performance?
01:04:53
And so what kind of performance do you get from the trains that you're actually adding?
01:04:59
We've looked at an alternative that would have three tracks or the equivalent of a bypass as well.
01:05:06
having a 3-2-3 option.
01:05:08
We also looked at some scenarios that will have, what happens if you have a track out, what does that mean, which is obviously very impactful.
01:05:17
We believe, at least what we've seen so far, that we can still meet the on-time performance goals with a 3-track option or a 3-2-3 option.
SPEAKER_14
01:05:28
And with your forecasted demand model,
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:32
Yeah, in terms of meeting on-time performance for the passenger trains, as I mentioned before, there are still freight delays, but the freight delays also appear in what we call the new build scenario.
01:05:46
So in the future, the freight delays are significant, but not necessarily attributable to one alternative or the other.
SPEAKER_03
01:06:00
This decision, I just want to make sure
01:06:03
Is this, when you're talking about capacity, are you talking about current capacity of passenger rail or additional capacity?
01:06:09
Additional.
SPEAKER_04
01:06:13
Jennifer, I know that we don't have the sort of cost of making a decision on this, but of course it's meaningful in the context of will that be built.
01:06:21
Do we have basic cost information as we look at these?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:24
We do.
01:06:25
We do have some cost information that we'll provide to you.
01:06:28
We did also share that with the Citizens Advisory Committee.
01:06:33
I think, you know, on the issue of the large bore tunnel, for example, they recognized that the cost associated with that was so significant that they felt that it wouldn't necessarily be a responsible recommendation to try to put that forward.
01:06:52
And a tunnel is not without its impacts as well.
01:06:54
Ventilation shafts and things like that have a major impact on the town.
01:06:58
But so that was something that they did take into account.
01:07:02
So we'll have that information for you.
01:07:04
It's something that we can use as a barometer as you're discussing different alternatives.
01:07:09
But it's not the sole alternative that you have to take into consideration.
SPEAKER_14
01:07:14
I was thinking that with the grade issue, that's going to be one long tunnel or a trench.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:19
A very long tunnel.
SPEAKER_14
01:07:21
Ms. Hines?
SPEAKER_08
01:07:23
So I understand that.
01:07:26
that the decision that we're being asked to make here is about accommodating additional passenger rail.
01:07:32
That's the fundamental decision.
01:07:35
But if, as Mr. Malbon says, this is a potentially 100-year decision, does the freight issue that is of concern to CSX that appears throughout
01:07:54
Is there any of these alternatives that you have studied that actually improves the freight situation at the same time that we are dealing with the increased passenger and the on-time reliability of passenger service?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:08
In the work that we did and the analysis that we've done, we see freight delays in all of those scenarios.
01:08:14
And so what I would say, though, is that
01:08:19
We were looking at a 28-year horizon period, and so we would work very closely with CSX as I'm sure they would make investments throughout the corridor too to try to keep those cragglies from happening.
01:08:31
The network, we assumed, in the model didn't show new infrastructure improvements aside from what we were looking at in the corridor, but realistically,
01:08:41
We would want to make investments.
01:08:43
They would make investments as well throughout the quarter to try to remove bottlenecks, remove some of those hot spots, and to try to alleviate some of those delays.
SPEAKER_08
01:08:52
So Jennifer, just to make sure I understand, what you're saying is in the modeling that you have done, looking at the various alternatives that are now kind of moving forward in the DEIS, you see the same level of brake delay, regardless of which of these solutions might be chosen.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:10
There's freight delays in the new build scenario, which does not assume any new passenger trains at all, just the background freight.
01:09:21
There are significant, I think it's 43 minutes for every 100 miles of rail movement, which is significant.
01:09:33
So we did see an uptick in freight delays when you start adding the passenger trains,
01:09:39
with either three tracks or the 3-2-3 option we did. So there's the increase in freight delays was a little bit higher with the 3-2-3 option but not significantly. So there like I said there's delays in both of those scenarios. But not in the bypass. No with the bypass as well. Yes. When we say free tracks. It gets better with the bypass but still delays but it's not as much. But there's still an increase in the Bible.
SPEAKER_08
01:10:11
Well, we modeled the three tracks and the bypasses there.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:16
It's the same thing.
01:10:18
From a capacity standpoint.
SPEAKER_03
01:10:20
So the point is, there are current issues with the road now, the track now.
01:10:28
The question is, do we just consider passenger, which I understand, or do we work with their partners and make both?
01:10:35
While you are right, this decision is about passenger, it also impacts rate pretty significantly.
01:10:43
I think I see where you're going to in that, but every vote does have, look, it's the same tracks.
01:10:55
And the only reason, quite frankly, I would suggest that CSX is willing to put up money is, look, they make the money off freight lines.
01:11:04
And so to the extent they're benefiting while we're using, and of course the federal money is just for passenger.
01:11:11
I guess what we're saying is to get the passenger rail, it's what's the least impactful to the freight is the way CSS would look at it.
SPEAKER_08
01:11:34
I don't think they're going to fix it.
SPEAKER_03
01:11:39
That's my job is to think about that.
SPEAKER_07
01:11:51
But the third track is going to benefit CSX because you will be able to increase the capacity on all three lines.
01:11:59
Is that correct?
01:12:01
So you know it does open the door.
01:12:03
I mean I think John you asked a really good question.
01:12:05
Is it going to be able to handle
01:12:07
Well, you know if we go through town
SPEAKER_04
01:13:00
Actually, the question relates to the networking decisions made up and down the corridor.
01:13:05
So we're going to have to look at considered cost and the potential for actually building either a trench or whatever this selected option is.
01:13:16
In the context of how that compares with other improvements up and down the corridor, I guess my question is how do we look at this holistically from a network perspective?
01:13:25
And a simple example would be if we have a delay that's created by
01:13:30
3-2-3 scenario in Ashland.
01:13:32
Can that be compensated in other places in the quarter to improve performance at less cost or less impactfully than perhaps doing the trench?
01:13:43
So it's hard to look at this as a standalone item without considering the impacts up and down the quarters.
01:13:48
We've been spending a lot of money on it.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:49
Yeah, we would not be precluded at all from making investments elsewhere in the network to try to alleviate delays that are associated
01:13:58
We are talking about a third track throughout the rest of the corridor and a fourth track in Northern Virginia leading into the Long Bridge as well.
01:14:21
It's a tremendous amount of capacity and a tremendous investment from the state. As we've talked about and as the Secretary mentioned, our priority is going to be Northern Virginia. And the investment is up there because that's where the congestion is. And then leading into the Longbridge project, any investments made in the southern part of the corridor are going to be after that. So a ways off. It's similar, Mr. Malindale and Mr. Kilpatrick. I mean, people were asking a little while.
SPEAKER_03
01:14:51
We've got 20 miles left on 64 that we're not widening.
01:14:57
We've got bridges and credit cards that we're not doing.
01:15:02
I mean, it's sort of a question, oh, we've got 10 miles or whatever it is through here we're not doing.
01:15:07
I mean, obviously, if we had a perfect world, we've been at capacity everywhere, obviously.
01:15:15
But that's not what we're facing, Scott.
01:15:17
But you're right.
01:15:18
I mean, this will be a quarter where there will be three or four tracks.
01:15:21
if that's obviously acceptable in this particular area.
01:15:24
I'm not saying it should be good or bad, I'm just saying that's the fact of what it is.
01:15:30
And you are right, there are ways to mitigate that by having third trains running faster.
01:15:36
But I would say it puts a lot more coordination effort along the system.
01:15:40
Now, Jennifer and I and Nick, we've been down and we've actually been in the operations center at CSX on this corridor where they have
01:15:52
So in 24 hours a day right now, there's activity on that line.
01:16:02
So obviously, capacity is needed.
01:16:05
The question is, what is the right difference?
01:16:09
I don't think we've been talking about it.
01:16:11
But this is not about they've got some magic screw that they can throw, and all of a sudden, we've got more capacity because of operation.
01:16:19
I think it's fair to say, Jennifer,
01:16:22
They've been great.
01:16:23
I think they've flown every switch they can to try to move stuff in there.
01:16:29
So adding additional train sets on their line, obviously it's an important quarter for them.
01:16:38
We did talk about the Virginia Avenue tunnel double stack and what that means to the Port of Virginia.
01:16:46
This quarter, by any estimate, is in Virginia
01:16:51
I would submit CSX as their heart blood of moving, not only people, but freight people.
01:17:04
I should say, I don't want you to interpret my comments as leading one way or the other.
01:17:09
I'm just trying to give you the facts of what we're dealing with.
01:17:13
Seriously.
01:17:14
This is a tough decision.
01:17:16
And particularly in that
01:17:18
And when we're spending about a billion for, well that's including the highway, so we're spending 500 million in Northern Virginia, roughly, teaming with CSX and us.
01:17:36
So we're talking about a small percentage that we actually can build.
01:17:41
I do understand that even though the funds aren't there, it does put a shadow or anybody living in that quarter because
01:18:10
Whether it's built or not, it's now been designated that whatever happens is going to happen.
01:18:14
So I get it.
01:18:16
I mean, this is a very difficult situation.
01:18:21
So that's why we wanted to have the meeting.
01:18:24
We went up to CTB.
01:18:26
We briefed it again.
01:18:27
Well, you guys have, and I hope the audience, they all listen and get with us.
01:18:33
We'll have another briefing at the Transportation Board meeting in October.
01:18:40
And then we'll have another briefing in December.
01:18:44
That gives another 60 days for people to continue to write in.
01:18:49
And then in December, we need to make a decision to give the federal authority.
01:18:56
It's in the register.
01:18:57
It's published.
01:18:58
No action is really not good, because then we may have to start the process over.
SPEAKER_14
01:19:12
Absolutely.
01:19:15
I was only pointing out that when I said I was constrained,
SPEAKER_03
01:19:39
This is all about hypothetical numbers that are going to happen in the future.
01:19:43
So what I'm saying on 5B, if you think another project is going to cost $200 million more today, that's not necessarily what will be the... What I'm saying is it's all relative.
01:19:54
In other words, if you thought the best decision today was X and it cost $200 million more, and we're projecting a $5 billion quarter 20 years in the future, I would say
01:20:06
That would not be an overriding decision to say, oh, we're not going to do that because it's going to cost us $280.
01:20:12
Nobody's bid this.
01:20:14
Nobody.
01:20:15
It's our best guesses.
01:20:17
That's what I meant by that.
01:20:18
But obviously, and what Jennifer pointed out, the board, Donald, that was a magnitude of many more times than people said.
01:20:27
No matter what the cost, you know, today's dollar of the future, that's going to be many more times.
01:20:31
But you're right, Mr. Whitworth.
01:20:33
I was only pointing out
01:20:35
That should not be a critical point in this because that's just a guess anyway.
01:20:41
We know it's going to be more expensive to do the trends probably than the other options, but to say it's $200 million more or whatever.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:20:49
It's not that far off though from the cost of a bypass.
SPEAKER_03
01:20:56
That's all I was mentioning.
01:20:58
I wasn't ensuring at all that cost wasn't important.
01:21:00
I'm just saying for this decision in the parameters, it's more of a relativity.
01:21:05
And I do believe the impact to constituents, you know, for that little bit of money, quite frankly, you know, the whole scheme of things, you know, all that we're in, you know, you can strongly consider that.
01:21:16
On the other hand, that could be four times what we take it as.
01:21:20
We just, you know, it's our best
01:21:29
Okay, Mr. Donohue's ready to go back there for the smart scale.
01:21:34
Emily, Ms. Nelson, Quintin, Randy, thank you all very much.
01:21:39
Thank you all.
01:21:40
And I would reiterate, all the constituents that have written in, and talked, and sent meetings, Jennifer, your team, we did promise them that we would hear everybody, we have heard everybody.
01:21:53
He never promised that everybody would be happy, but it can at least be transparent as to how we make these decisions.
01:22:01
And I think that we've lived up to that.
01:22:05
I think you're going to talk about sports field watching Mr. Donahue.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:22:15
Thanks Chairman, Members of the Board, I'm here today to make a quick update.
01:22:28
I want to kind of recap some of the quick changes.
01:22:30
There were a few homework items the board gave staff to take a look at, and then I also wanted to give you kind of an update overall of some of the input we've received to date.
01:22:39
That input has kind of been growing in the coming weeks, so I do expect we'll continue to receive input as staff go out and do trainings with the folks in the various districts, and we'll continue to provide that information to the board.
01:22:51
But there's very quickly kind of a recap of changes.
01:22:53
We want to extend the amount of time available
01:22:56
for Scoring, which means that applications will be due sooner.
01:22:59
So we're asking for applications to be due on August 1st with that intake process starting at the beginning of March there.
01:23:06
That would give us five months instead of three months to score applications, which we think is going to be necessary as the number of applications submitted continues to increase.
01:23:15
One of the other things that we've talked about is putting a cap on the number of applications.
01:23:20
What you see here is the revised concept people scored after
01:23:28
I wanted us to think of a more streamlined version.
01:23:31
So we came up with two tiers.
01:23:32
Again, either eight applications or four applications depending on the population in the area served by the submitting institution.
01:24:03
What some of the district administrators have provided to us is that some of the localities are very unhappy with this.
01:24:13
And I will get to that kind of input later.
01:24:15
Again, we outline the number of localities or jurisdictions or submitting entities that would be impacted.
01:24:21
It was, I believe, about 14.
01:24:24
So far, every single person who has provided comment has said, I do not like the cap, so I don't want to imply to the board that there's
01:24:32
Ground 12 consensus among the stakeholder community on this issue.
01:24:37
Well, actually there is consensus.
01:24:39
The consensus is that this is a bad idea.
01:24:41
I will tell you that as staff, we feel as strong, if not stronger, that if there are not capped, we cannot promise you that we can actually deliver you all scores in January with the current proposed schedule.
01:24:53
Because very candidly, with the three month schedule we had this year and 400 applications, it was down to the last week.
01:25:01
We had literally had another 20 applications.
01:25:03
I don't think we would have made it.
01:25:04
Or we would have slept a lot less in the two months leading up to that than we did, which, you know, again, it's just we do not believe that without a cabinet application we can actually deliver these results.
01:25:16
I understand a lot of people are unhappy with that.
01:25:19
We do this every two years.
01:25:21
I would just ask, who needs more than eight projects and a two-year window?
01:25:27
And the simple truth is, you know, I don't think anyone's actually seen eight projects being built.
01:25:31
in a two-year window with state funds.
01:25:33
And so I understand there's consternation.
01:25:35
I understand there's concern.
01:25:36
I'm not saying it's unjustified on their perspective.
01:25:40
I'm merely saying with the current amount of resources we're providing to this program, which is an increased level from what was previously anticipated, we do not believe that we can deliver the scores to the board in a time frame required by law with the schedule that we have.
01:25:57
If we increase the amount of time
01:25:59
I think as the secretary said with the action kind of exactly no matter what you all decide someone will be in
01:26:26
I think people recognize some type of cap is necessary.
01:26:30
They just want whatever category they're in to be hired.
SPEAKER_03
01:26:35
I think here the overriding policy is what is the reasonable cap for the staff to do a competent job and on the other hand not exclude any type of significant project that would otherwise be in there.
01:26:52
I guess there is some point where there's a financial
01:26:55
We have a cap that, you know, is something, but as you all know, it has to be sort of down the line funding.
01:27:03
And quite frankly, I do believe a part of this ought to be to the localities and the communities and the region.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:27:11
So they do their part in that too.
SPEAKER_03
01:27:12
I mean, I think so, just like we were asked to, they should too in that regard.
01:27:18
So anyway, that's what we looked at besides.
SPEAKER_08
01:27:23
A question has arisen about which transit agencies are eligible and it's partly because in Northern Virginia Metrobus provides the regional bus and we have localities who have developed local bus service in different miles.
01:27:41
Some of it is outsourced to a transit board that's separate from the government body, some of it's run by the government body.
01:27:48
So I think up here we would just appreciate clarity
01:27:52
M. Doolittle Jr., John M. Doolittle Jr., John M. Doolittle Jr.,
01:28:20
The other point I would bring up that has come up from some of our jurisdictions is the issue of unincorporated towns who are small entities who are not eligible to apply on their own and in some of our larger counties it means giving up if there is a cap one of their eight slots which leaves our unincorporated towns feeling like they would
01:28:54
So I don't know if there's any way to address that.
01:28:56
I don't have a good suggestion, but I wanted people to know we've heard that from our community.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:29:02
Mr. Chairman, to Ms. Hines' point, the transit agencies, I do think there's a unique situation in Northern Virginia that we need to go work on.
01:29:10
And so in the Roanoke region, for example, the Greater Roanoke Transit Company is an independent entity.
01:29:15
And we always envisioned that they would be separate from the city of Roanoke, the city of Salem, the county of Roanoke.
01:29:21
And so I think we need to try and make sure we have similar rules for the transit systems here in Northern Virginia.
01:29:26
I agree with Ms. Hines that it's not fully clear in the current
01:29:30
I'm a technical guy, so we will be working to address that.
01:29:34
On the issue of unincorporated towns, I have less faith that we'll be able to reach a resolution that will make all parties happy, because candidly, an unincorporated town is the county.
01:29:47
Everything that's not incorporated could say they're an unincorporated area.
01:29:51
And so where do we start drawing these lines?
01:29:54
And you are not an independent government entity.
01:30:00
So there are unincorporated areas throughout the Commonwealth.
01:30:04
And if we said basically any unincorporated area that's like a post office name, oh, you're now under 200,000.
01:30:10
You can submit four.
01:30:11
We effectively have no tabs at that point.
01:30:16
And again, the population of that unincorporated town is included in the population total for the county.
01:30:21
So they are getting some benefit for that.
01:30:24
I will be honest, I doubt the population of unincorporated town is so large.
01:30:29
So I'm not sure if pushing them into a new tier or anything else of that nature, but I just don't know how we do that in a fair manner, to be very honest.
SPEAKER_08
01:30:42
But the county could.
01:30:43
Yeah, 100% the county.
01:30:45
And the county, sometimes they have them wrong, but sometimes not.
SPEAKER_03
01:30:52
Let me point out one thing.
01:30:54
One of the guiding principles behind this is supposed to be
01:31:01
I mean, it really is.
01:31:02
It's supposed to be, remember, the whole idea behind this and elsewhere in 1887 was to take away funding every little locality, I don't mean that little in terms of whatever, but where they weren't getting any money to do anything, and then they wouldn't work together to get anything done.
01:31:20
You can't remember going across the state, and one road ends in this county, and the next county didn't want to do it, and they did the project.
01:31:29
So part of it is, inherent to this, is asking our governments and the policies that we're forcing them, the local governments, to work together.
01:31:39
And those citizens ought to be represented in account.
01:31:42
I mean in that regard.
01:31:43
So that's part of the actual policy behind SMART SCALE and House Bill 1887, is to make it a more regional-based system.
01:31:57
I don't dig into account if you dig the political ideology going on that we're just not going to listen to that town.
01:32:05
I can't fix that.
01:32:08
But I just throw that out.
01:32:09
That is an underlying, and that doesn't mean we don't have an answer, I'm just playing, but I'm just saying, that is the underlying philosophy is we want the localities and municipalities to work together.
01:32:24
Because maybe we're not doing it under the old system.
01:32:28
Not as much as we would be with the limited resources.
01:32:32
We had lots of towns that, I knew in Hampton Roads that 17 independent cities, over $180 combined on projects that either they couldn't agree on or stopped and they didn't, were saving up.
01:32:47
So that's part of the reason behind this.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:32:53
The next kind of just general changes is increasing and clarifying the product readiness requirements.
01:32:58
And this is, you know, if you're building a new interchange, particularly if it's on existing load access facility, there's certain documentation and other things you need available.
01:33:06
Similarly, you're putting in place a signal.
01:33:08
We need to have some analysis to show that signal is in fact necessary.
01:33:12
The last bullet there is, you know, something we ran into in round one in two separate instances where we want to make sure that whoever submits the product, there is a
01:33:23
I want to make sure that they take an affirmative vote in advance to be very clear
01:33:49
This is what they want so that their citizens and residents also know what it is that they're submitting to the board for consideration.
01:33:57
We had several instances in round two where people submitted projects that were not eligible.
01:34:02
Staff thought the technical guide was clear the first time and we were going to make it even more clear.
01:34:07
Now, if you want to replace a bridge, that is a state of good repair project and that is something we do when a bridge is in need of repair.
01:34:13
There are many people who submitted those types of projects in the SMART SCALE either because they didn't get funding under state of the repair or they were unclear where to get funding.
01:34:23
We are going to just enhance that information to make it very clear as to where they should be submitting those projects for funding.
01:34:30
We also put in place a requirement saying that, or proposed requirements you made, saying that if a product was fully funded, the product would not be considered under SMART SCALE.
01:34:40
There's been a lot of discussion about this.
01:34:41
The technical guide lays out three very distinct criteria that this would apply to.
01:34:46
So this does not apply, to be very clear, to a constrained long-range plan of the regional planning model.
01:34:52
Almost every single product that is submitted
01:34:55
and then MPO's Constrained Long Range Plan.
01:34:58
Because it's not in that plan, you can't use federal dollars.
01:35:01
So this policy does not apply to plans.
01:35:05
What this applies to is the locality's capital improvement program, typically a four-year type of document, which is truly committed money.
01:35:13
You can let a contract for a project once it is funded in a capital improvement program.
01:35:18
Similarly, the projects included in MPO's transportation improvement program, you can let a contract
01:35:25
based on that
01:35:51
That this would apply to.
01:35:53
Again, there's been a lot of discussion about this.
01:35:55
I think once folks have actually talked with staff and myself about what the three categories are, they have been much calmer.
01:36:02
But I want to be very clear, this does not apply to a plan.
01:36:05
It does not apply to a plan of finance.
01:36:07
Plans are plans.
01:36:09
Plans change.
01:36:10
Programs are actual documents that you can go to bid with.
01:36:14
You can put a contract and execute a contract if something is in a transportation improvement program, capital improvement program.
01:36:21
And that is all this is intended to capture.
SPEAKER_03
01:36:24
So this specific example, this model will use Hampton Roads, HR TAC.
01:36:30
They have a funding plan where they are looking out in the future.
01:36:34
This was the confusion with Hampton Roads.
01:36:37
Funding plan is not covered by the procurement rules.
01:36:43
It's the TPO down there.
01:36:45
So certainly, people are looking at plans.
01:36:48
But the legislation happened to deal with the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:36:53
The Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel was not in the TPO's six-year plan or five-year plan, whatever they do, their four-year constrained plan down there.
SPEAKER_13
01:37:02
So it did not apply to that at all.
SPEAKER_03
01:37:05
MBTA has a funding plan, but these rules don't apply.
01:37:11
But if the TPO puts it in, I just want to make it clear that funding plans have no bearing on the planning process in terms of how it goes to procurement the technical side of it.
01:37:27
I want to make that clear, because obviously you're looking at funding.
01:37:31
All they're doing is helping to fund.
01:37:34
But if you've got a plan that's in the six-year construction constraint plan already funded, that's a different issue.
01:37:45
The region has made a decision, and it wasn't intended for you to say, oh, we've already committed that.
01:37:50
I'm going to try to get monies from the SMART SCALE.
SPEAKER_14
01:37:57
Well, help me with that a little bit.
01:38:00
When the TPO does the 2040 formula,
01:38:04
That's right.
SPEAKER_03
01:38:07
If it's in the plan, then Hampton Roads Bush Center was not in that plan.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:38:13
Mr. Secretary, so plans do not count.
01:38:17
A plan is a plan.
01:38:20
No one commits money in a formal manner over a 40-year process.
01:38:25
So, for example, if you were a contractor, would you bid on a project that started construction in 2032 knowing that the
01:38:33
MPO could change that plan, but they're planning to provide that money.
01:38:37
They just want you to commit to spend it and build it 12 years, 13 years into the future.
01:38:43
Things like that don't count.
01:38:44
So the 2040 plan does not account for this.
01:38:48
What counts is the transportation improvement program of the region.
01:38:52
And again, Hampton Roads, the HR TAC does not have the authority to create a program.
01:38:57
In North Virginia, NVTA does.
01:38:59
So NVTA's program would count, but Hampton Roads
01:39:03
Hampton Road Transportation Accountability Commission's plan of finance has no legal standing as a program.
01:39:09
It is merely a plan.
01:39:10
Plans do not count.
01:39:12
Only capital improvement programs count.
01:39:16
And so it would have to be in the HRTPO's Transportation Improvement Program, which covers a four-year period, and is updated every two years.
SPEAKER_03
01:39:28
And in Hampton Road.
01:39:30
in Northern Virginia, what is it called in the NVTA?
01:39:33
I believe they're calling it their six-year promotion.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:39:37
And they're currently in the process.
SPEAKER_03
01:39:38
So is it different between planning, procurement, and that's where I think the confusion got in.
01:39:49
And I know, particularly with HRTAC, it was intentionally done that way, because the TPO is what makes the products work.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:39:59
And similarly, the NPO was given different authority.
01:40:01
The NPO here is cross-bounding DC, Maryland, and Virginia.
01:40:05
So they gave North Virginia Transportation Authority a different degree of authority.
01:40:09
Because unlike Hampton Roads, the NPO extends outside of the state.
SPEAKER_03
01:40:20
I learned something.
01:40:22
Well, we did meet with the staff from down there.
01:40:25
And it's funny that you're not Senator Wagner.
01:40:26
So I just want to make sure we're alert.
01:40:28
Make sure it's not.
01:40:31
Two things.
01:40:32
The monies on the SMART SCALE are, for the true House of Lincoln 87, are not meant to supplant for regional monies.
01:40:40
And the way the formula works, they never will, because they automatically get them, right?
01:40:44
You get the formula, so they never will.
01:40:47
And conversely, it's not meant for the people to go to procurement and have this all planned out and then all of a sudden say, well, now we really want to do that on the SMART SCALE.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:41:00
And I guess I can give you an example of Mr. Malbon that was raised with some of his folks in the Hampton Roads region.
01:41:05
They said, well, we'd like to be able to apply two separate rounds for the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
01:41:10
And the reason for that is they said, well, we'd like to get more state money for the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
01:41:15
And I said, well, what is the end outcome you're seeking to achieve?
01:41:19
And they said, well, we'd like to get $400 million for the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel so then we can take $200 million of regional money we would have spent on the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel and go do something else.
01:41:29
And there's a very simple solution here.
01:41:31
Apply for the HRBT, get that funding, and then the next round, apply for the other project you would have taken your money and gone and built and asked for state money.
01:41:39
There's a very simple way to do this.
01:41:42
And so it's just, you know, you have to try and... Or ask for the 400 million on the Hampton Roads Bridge.
SPEAKER_03
01:41:47
I'll see if you get money.
01:41:49
You're not going to get the 400 million.
01:41:51
Well, I'm not prejudging anything.
01:41:53
But what they're trying to do is, you know... And we've encouraged where it makes
01:41:58
Sents to segment throws, right?
01:42:01
I mean, you have a segment project.
01:42:03
You have no problem with that.
01:42:05
You did that on 64, Section 1, 2, and 3.
01:42:08
Well, they have you did it in utility.
01:42:10
But just because you want more money, take a better shot.
SPEAKER_14
01:42:15
Let me ask a hypothetical question.
01:42:17
Would they approach the HRPT in phases?
SPEAKER_03
01:42:23
What would be the phases?
01:42:25
We'll go half a tunnel?
01:42:27
I would say that I'm not sure there's independent utility.
01:42:44
That's where I started the conversation where it made sense with independent utility and what kind of costs does that add to the project?
01:42:54
My point is that this is not intended to take away good procurement planning.
01:43:01
It's just like tax consequences, right?
01:43:03
Sometimes minimizing tax doesn't necessarily give you the right answer.
01:43:10
So my point of what we're trying to say is if you want extra money on a project, ask for it.
01:43:21
But by him saying that we're going to do it at two,
01:43:23
We don't think we can get 400.
01:43:25
Well, what's that saying to the rest of the state?
01:43:28
Of course we can go into that.
01:43:29
So that's the point we're talking about.
SPEAKER_14
01:43:32
I think the point is independent of choice.
01:43:34
I think the point is tough.
SPEAKER_03
01:43:35
Totally.
01:43:36
That's what we've used the entire time.
01:43:40
That's the one way you can get a record decision, right?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:43:44
Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
01:43:44
I learned something else today.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:43:46
I'm trying.
01:43:49
We didn't move several changes to measures and we see something bolder that we're going to come back to in a second.
01:43:54
So again, there are several changes we proposed to try and just ensure that we were taking into account the scale of a project.
01:44:00
So we have proposed a change of congestion measure, looking at person throughput over the length of a project.
01:44:06
Again, if you have a 10-mile project that 5,000 more people can get through all 10 miles of that versus a one-mile project where 5,000 people can get through, there's 10 times the impact.
01:44:18
On that first example, we don't take that into account today.
01:44:22
Under safety, we propose moving DUI crashes where simply the impairment of the driver, not the condition of the roadway, is what we believe likely resulted in the incident.
01:44:33
That cost fatalities here.
01:44:36
We also want to use a blended rate for fatal and severe injuries there as far as cost perspective, because we found that the age of the driver, age of the vehicle, tends to be
01:44:48
A major influencing factor is whether or not someone is severely injured or dies in a crash that takes place.
01:44:55
So again, we're going to blend that rate because the roadway circumstances that cause that are very similar and it's going to be the major car and age of the person that drives that.
01:45:04
On accessibility, we are recommending eliminating the 45 and 60 minute cap for access to jobs for auto and transit.
01:45:11
We do have decay curves again that take into account how far away a job is.
01:45:16
And so a job that's closer still is valued at a higher amount, which no longer will draw an arbitrary line at 45 minutes or 60 minutes there.
01:45:25
And under land use, we are really proposing a new methodology that is more objective rather than subjective for determining whether or not there is mixed use or other types of transportation-efficient development that reduces the impact on the transportation network.
01:45:41
On person throughput, we are still working on the specifics of this measure.
01:45:46
We thought this was going to be easier to implement than it has turned out in practice.
01:45:51
And so some of the problems we're running into is on a 10-mile project, you may have an increase of 5,000 people at an intersection in the first two miles, but three miles down, you don't have the same increase in capacity.
01:46:03
And so we're trying to work on a methodology that can capture the differences and the increase in throughput throughout the core and also making sure that we treat products that are modeled versus those that are done without a model in a similar fashion.
01:46:18
We are going to put pencils down on this in the next few weeks and either declare victory or declare defeat.
01:46:23
It is our sincere hope that we will be able to notify you.
01:46:26
We have figured out a way to do this.
01:46:29
I would say right now it's 50-50 as to whether or not we can figure this out in time
01:46:35
It's a simple sounding concept that implementing is much more difficult.
SPEAKER_04
01:46:43
It actually doesn't sound simple to me.
01:46:46
And it's hard for me to scale this and take this abstract concept and put it into real-world context and the things we're looking at and then come back to the example that I think has been cited in the past in the station platform improvements from the congestion perspective versus the 8-mile stretch of the road.
01:47:01
How will they compare and model where?
01:47:03
I guess to the extent that you put pencils down, if you can model whatever suggestions you're making, some real-world examples, I think would be extremely helpful.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:47:15
I have a hard time conceptualizing.
01:47:17
Mr.
01:47:17
Chair and Chair, if we do find methodology, what we're doing now is testing them on projects, and so we will have examples that we can provide to the board.
01:47:25
Again, at this point I would say it's 50-50.
01:47:31
One of the other changes we want to bring to the board, and this is one we have not previously mentioned, but it's something that came out of the public input process and was actually recommended by the Fredericksburg area MPO, is essentially today when we look at congestion, we measure out to 2025, so kind of a short horizon into the future.
01:47:51
They essentially said, why are you measuring into the future and counting places that may end up having congestion
01:47:59
in 10 years after some amount of growth, and we have a bunch of congestion today.
01:48:04
And so as staff, we were responding to their comments, and very candidly, we can argue both sides of this issue, and so we want to bring this to the board.
01:48:14
And so again, there's pros and cons to this.
01:48:16
I think if you were to switch to just examining current congestion, one, you're focusing on areas with our problems today rather than areas where there may be a problem in the future.
01:48:27
Again, our projections
01:48:29
out to 2025 we believe are generally accurate but I know they're not completely precise.
01:48:35
The other thing is you know you're really you're just you know you're dealing with a discrete problem.
01:48:41
The kind of cons for that is you know there may be high growth areas that don't have congestion today that might happen in the future and do we want to proactively try to address those problems and again the argument that Frederick and Mary made was proactively address their future problems after you address our current
01:48:58
And so again, this is just something we wanted to bring to the board to get some feedback and reaction to the staff.
SPEAKER_04
01:49:06
I think we are kind of comfortable going into that.
01:49:11
I think I would say the oft-repeated statement that limited resources tend to favor our current approach to the congestion issue, to take projections and attempt to solve
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:49:33
McPherson Jr., John F. Kasprowicz Jr., John F. Kasprowicz Jr.,
01:49:57
Go fix a future problem that does not yet exist before you would fix our existing problem.
01:50:02
And I think that's a compelling case.
01:50:05
A lot of other models, sometimes people go 20 years out.
01:50:09
But again, you don't know if your projections of what will take place 20 years in the future are accurate.
01:50:15
And so again, this is something that they've raised.
01:50:17
And I guess I would just look to other board members.
01:50:21
I guess we're looking for feedback.
01:50:22
And I guess I've heard one in favor of, let's just go to today.
01:50:25
We know that's a problem.
01:50:26
We have limited resources.
01:50:27
Fix the existing problems before you focus on future ones.
SPEAKER_08
01:50:33
I would say from the work that I'm familiar with at NET, we actually do look at both.
01:50:39
It did become data points for the board as it moved toward deciding where to put the money.
01:50:46
And neither one has more value than the other.
01:50:50
And that's the decision we make as we allocate the dollars.
01:50:55
I think there's some wisdom in having both as points available.
01:51:00
It doesn't help in your scoring necessarily, and I don't know how you would do that, but there's also, I think, the other dilemma we're in, which is we're doing a lot of projects, and maybe now I'm speaking more about HRTAC and the TA, where we're doing a lot of projects, and the network is gonna have considerable change
01:51:22
over this time period from locally funded and under projects.
01:51:27
So that's the other reason I think it actually matters to see both points.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:51:33
Well, Ms. Sharon, Ms. Hines, I don't believe we are proposing to do both.
01:51:39
I hear you.
SPEAKER_08
01:51:39
I'm sort of arguing that maybe you should.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:51:42
From a resource standpoint, I think we're telling you we can do one.
01:51:47
Do you want to do 2025 or do you want to do that?
01:51:52
I understand more would probably be better, I just don't think we can, I don't think we can pull that off.
SPEAKER_03
01:51:57
And I'm not sure there are always congruence, in other words, you know, measuring something in the future, virtues today may not, you know, score the projects the same.
01:52:11
In other words, and so, look, I think what, you know, Ms. Casper mentioned, and I think it may be the reality, we are truly working out of a fairly
01:52:28
I think it's a very good case to be made.
01:52:39
We're a long ways from being able to have the luxury of planning what might happen in the future.
01:52:45
I'm not suggesting we ignore it at all, because many factors don't.
01:52:49
But look, this whole thing with congestion mitigation,
01:52:54
That's a big member of the whole discussion with the General Assembly.
01:53:00
I wanted 75% in Northern Virginia in the whole bit.
01:53:06
So I think we've proven the more you allow one factor, the less skewed, the more skewed you get on maybe all good decisions, but decisions that most people would accept would be more reasonable in that.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:53:22
But I think the whole
SPEAKER_03
01:53:24
Emphasis behind that is we need to solve congestion today.
01:53:29
I think that was really the message we heard.
01:53:33
They said, well, I mean, we want you to put it on 75%, and we pushed back a little bit, saying, well, that's going to give, we're not sure that's doing that.
01:53:40
But I think inherent in that is we want you to solve the congestion problems we have today.
01:53:46
So that would be my input based on the reading.
01:53:50
I think I have a better understanding with the General Assembly.
SPEAKER_07
01:53:59
I would just like to add to your point that when we were going through the factors early on about what percentage should be attributed to congestion in the larger metropolitan areas, I remember
01:54:17
Kupferberg, John Kupferberg, John Kupferberg, John Kupferberg
01:54:40
And that's why the percentages were actually, I think, put forward the way they are, 45 versus the 75, because it was kind of looking at the short term, planning for the long term.
01:54:55
And there was a lot of time put into this, I know.
01:54:57
So hopefully, as Mary's putting out, they're both important.
01:55:03
But in measuring the project, what do we take care of today?
SPEAKER_03
01:55:09
So one word to that discussion one more item.
01:55:13
It's what we talked about when we were looking at VTrans.
01:55:17
I'm not even sure the pot of money is big enough to solve fixing congestion today if that's all we focus on.
01:55:25
I mean, I think a billion dollars roughly every two years, we've got, I'll mention it to say 81, there's three or four years worth, or three
01:55:38
W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:56:06
The next one we talk about is economic development and again we've made a host of changes here really kind of eliminating whether or not utilities are programmed.
01:56:14
It turns out everyone believes they have utilities in place and it's very difficult for us to determine whether or not they have utilities in place for the industrial use.
01:56:22
Or the current potentially agricultural residential use that might be on site there.
01:56:27
So again, we're going to focus much more on the type of site plan that was submitted and the degree where it is in the kind of approval process.
01:56:35
And so again, giving more points for a detailed site plan rather than a conceptual site plan.
01:56:40
And the reason we're really focusing on site plans is that's one of the clearest form of indicators of private sector interest because a company has come by and has expended money to prepare some type of document.
01:56:53
And again, a detailed site plan is more expensive than a conceptual site plan.
01:56:57
And so again, we're just giving more points because we believe that is not going to be our best way of measuring the readiness of a project.
01:57:04
We had a whole host of factors in rounds one and two
01:57:07
We thought there were going to be great metrics of measuring readiness and it turned out they weren't because almost everyone said, yes, we have that.
01:57:15
Mr. Gaspard.
SPEAKER_04
01:57:15
Let me just ask a question on the specifics of that.
01:57:18
Does that mean if in a situation where there's an application that was looking to score points for economic development and had an associated master plan for a comprehensive plan could benefit from this improvement?
01:57:33
If there were no submitted site plans,
01:57:36
they would get zero score for the economic development component.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:57:40
Mr. Chairman, that is not how it works.
01:57:42
So if there are certain buffer areas, again, we're proposing the maximum would be three miles around the improvement area.
01:57:49
If you're in the comprehensive plan and you're zoned and you have direct access, then we would count that development.
01:57:55
What we're saying, if there's two sites, both have master plans and direct access from the improvement, but one also has site plan
01:58:04
F. Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine
SPEAKER_04
01:58:26
If you will, would count, would be weighted higher.
01:58:29
I understand, but in any case, the site plans would have been submitted by a private entity looking to develop the site.
01:58:35
So if there are none, if there is a planned expansionary industrial development zone, a retail center, and there are actually no site plans filed, can you get economic development points if it's just the plan?
01:58:47
If you have direct access to the site.
SPEAKER_03
01:58:50
We narrow that direct access.
01:58:55
This has very real-world applications.
01:58:57
You probably have seen in the news clippings over the last few years.
01:59:02
There's a small tech company wanting to put another East Coast potentially headquarters.
01:59:09
Mr. Kilpatrick and I think we've filled it.
01:59:12
Every city in the Commonwealth believes they are the best site that we've been answering questions for.
01:59:20
And of course, our economic development team
01:59:22
working on that responding.
01:59:25
But it's where it sort of came in.
01:59:27
Some of the sites that we've looked at are just a line on the map.
01:59:31
They've drawn a circle and said this would be a good one, notwithstanding all the houses it would take on the home.
01:59:39
But I'm just saying, it really is real world.
01:59:41
Because look, people are excited.
01:59:43
They want to get something going.
01:59:45
They think this is the case.
01:59:48
And so it's just really hard to define.
01:59:51
I think this is a great improvement.
02:00:04
It really provides some quantification.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:00:20
There are two areas that we had homework on.
02:00:22
One was in our July retreat on SMART SCALE.
02:00:25
The board asked us to see if there was a way where we could take into account the economic distress of a given area and provide some small bump to kind of sites.
02:00:34
So again, if you have two sites, all things being equal, one's in a distressed area and one's not, give a small bump up to the one that's in that distressed area.
02:00:42
The other was, as we had talked with the board about, we had a
02:00:46
Not a lot, but a few products that have been submitted where essentially people have said, we're going to have more growth in the next 10 years than we've had in the last 100, which is to say that just the amount of square footage of commercial and industrial growth that certain applications put in stretched the kind of bounds of what we believe was possible there within a 10-year period.
02:01:07
And so we've been working on a few methods trying to capture that and make sure that
02:01:12
People or not, they may have put in place a ton of conceptual site plans, which sometimes local governments will put in place.
02:01:18
But it may be for an amount of growth that we just vastly exceed what's currently present within a given jurisdiction.
02:01:25
So I'll start with the economic distressed area.
02:01:28
So we have found kind of a more nuanced map.
02:01:32
And we did talk about this at the last meeting from the Economic Policy Institute, which is a nonprofit based in this region.
02:01:39
We like this because it goes down to the zip code level.
02:01:42
And again, counties are not kind of all the same.
02:01:45
And so Western Henrico County is a very different economic condition than Eastern Henrico County and there are other counties as well where you can find that condition.
02:01:55
What we're proposing is they rank all jurisdictions in the Commonwealth as well as every other state on a scale of 0 to 100.
02:02:02
And we simply would use their localities ranking, again, 100 is
02:02:07
Hi, you know trust zero is very low.
02:02:10
We would use that as a percentage and multiply that by the point, the half a point we're willing to give for this.
02:02:15
And so if you were the most economically distressed community in Virginia, all of your sites would get a 0.5 bonus on there.
02:02:23
And if you're the most least economically distressed, you would get no points.
02:02:27
And if you're somewhere in between, you'd get a pro rata add on to those sites based on where you are.
SPEAKER_03
02:02:36
Again,
02:02:36
Just for some background, this is a very real issue in our state.
02:02:42
The Secretary of Finance, they've identified not only distressed but fiscally strained areas in that regard.
02:02:52
And it gets back to the limited resources.
02:03:00
Should they go in areas that help provide for opportunities?
02:03:05
or deal with current situations.
02:03:07
Now, we're certainly in transportation.
02:03:09
Most of our money, as you know, under House 1887 is directly goes to the localities based on land and population.
02:03:23
You might, so it's only 27 and a half percent that we even have any discretion on where they go when these are the significant active areas of statewide pot.
02:03:35
You know, that's probably a discussion.
02:03:38
You know, when we hear some of the things about how SMART SCALE is not helping the area, it's not SMART SCALE, it's the allocation of money that goes there.
02:03:47
I mean, so that's a much different discussion than just, as you know, we did not change, that was what the General Assembly, those were the formulas they wanted.
02:03:58
But if you're allocating based on that, is that the right measure to really change the economic
02:04:05
I don't think SMART SCALE on its own is going to do that.
02:04:11
SMART SCALE, all it does is help you pick projects based on where the money is allocated.
02:04:16
And I think it helps a lot on that.
02:04:18
But, as a statewide, again, that money is allocated to districts based on formulas derived by the General Assembly.
02:04:28
We have no control over it.
02:04:30
It's good or bad, we have no control.
02:04:33
So I hear a lot of people saying, well, SmartScale's not working for those economically depressed areas.
02:04:38
I don't agree with that.
02:04:39
What may not be working is the amount of resources dedicated to those areas based on the formulas.
02:04:46
But that's not, in our purview, that is set by the General Assembly.
02:04:52
I'll just throw that out there because I do believe that there is a part of the Commonwealth that believes they have not been allocated appropriate resources
02:05:03
to better some of the situations.
02:05:06
That may be accurate, may be true.
02:05:09
I'm pointing out that smart scale is not the problem while we're not building it.
02:05:16
It's the amount of resources that are allocated.
02:05:21
That's a tough, tough decision, but I do think if there's anything we can do to help, at least when they go there, to recognize that the benefits of this may change
02:05:31
The situation, I think that's a positive thing to consider.
02:05:35
But just changing this is not going to fix the issue of how much money goes there besides.
SPEAKER_08
02:05:41
Mr. Secretary, I really do appreciate that this is a tiny piece of Northern Virginia's calculation.
02:05:50
It has come up though as projects look relative to each other.
02:05:54
And if you look at this map,
02:05:56
It's pretty obvious that Northern Virginia, nobody's going to get any points.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:06:02
I tell you we get less points because in some of the original methodologies we were looking at was either you are distressed or you are not distressed.
02:06:09
We're now saying everybody's zero to one, if you will, and we're going to multiply your percentage times half a point.
02:06:16
So everyone will get some amount of points.
02:06:20
I would say some more distressed areas will get a higher amount of that half a point than
SPEAKER_08
02:06:25
Right, and I would say that this is partially about how the Northern Virginia projects stack up among themselves is how this gets applied and that's why I feel like I should bring it up.
02:06:38
There are pockets in Fairfax County, there are pockets in Prince William County, there are pockets in Loudoun that would be more toward the yellow-orange than toward the green.
02:06:51
But doing it at the zip code level
02:06:54
in Northern Virginia, basically if we want to mask that.
02:06:59
And so that's the concern in Northern Virginia is the way this is structured is unlikely to help us identify those projects that are more targeted to distressed areas that are sub zip code.
02:07:15
And so I don't know if there's a fix for that, but that's how I want to lay this out.
02:07:18
It isn't about us saying we should get more than the places that are red or orange.
02:07:23
But as we stack in our district and as our high priority, we agree this should count towards something.
02:07:31
And we're a little concerned it's not granular enough to capture that.
SPEAKER_03
02:07:38
And I'll point out that conversation that speaks multiple, where you're concerned about a small section of the subject code and they are accountable for every clip code.
02:07:52
And I'm not saying it's right or wrong.
SPEAKER_08
02:07:54
I totally recognize that, but I have a job to do.
SPEAKER_03
02:07:58
My point is, I've always learned that not to be critical of what you can do, but to point out that this issue is a significant one for the state.
02:08:10
And I would say right, wrong, or indifferent, I'm just looking at actions.
02:08:14
What we have done at the state level has not moved this needle.
02:08:19
Now, there are those who
02:08:20
don't think the needle should be moved and there are those who you know because of different things in that you know lots of different philosophical differences in that but you know I was only pointing again pointing out again what you're saying besides makes perfect sense in the context it's in but sometimes when you're looking at solutions you tend to look at things that you can control and blame I don't know if that's the right word
02:08:49
And that's easy to say, well, you know, SMART SCALE isn't working right here because we're not getting it.
02:08:54
And the real issue is the allocation of resources.
02:08:58
So I would agree with your context, Ms. Hynes, in looking at it.
02:09:01
And what you're trying to do is help those in the areas you're competing in.
SPEAKER_07
02:09:05
That's right.
SPEAKER_03
02:09:05
Yeah.
02:09:06
But that's why I brought it up.
02:09:07
We want to be lost in the fact that, well, you know, the world of Virginia's worried about a half a zip code, and we've got the whole, you know, western, southwest part of the state that is in that.
02:09:19
That's the political and the real issue here, and I do believe it's going to be a fairly significant topic in this upcoming General Assembly session.
02:09:29
You read the editorials in that part of the state, you read some of the comments coming out, so that's one of the reasons I'm pointing out.
02:09:38
I think it's going to be something that is going to be really looked at at this Assembly session.
02:09:45
We've got to be careful that the solutions are not
02:09:49
You know, hurting the things that are really helping to make the situation better.
02:09:57
When you really get down to it, every major decision that we're dealing with is really a resource-based decision.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:10:09
I will say we've been looking, this is the most granular version we have found today, maybe in future rounds there will be things.
02:10:16
they get below this but that is one of the reasons we are recommending this one to the board is the other ones were on a whole jurisdiction basis and they also didn't have kind of a 0 to 100 scale so it was either we had to draw a line where we as staff were saying you're either distressed or you're not which is I don't believe the appropriate role for us or there was already one driven and it was black and white either over it or under it so we we are recommended because it's the most nuanced version we could found we'll keep our eyes out for future rounds though.
02:10:46
The next was on trying to capture some reasonableness test and the amount of square footage that was submitted with some applications.
02:11:03
What we had proposed originally to the board and we went out and tried to test over the past few months was basically saying some percent cap saying if you as a locality today have 10 million square feet
02:11:16
Don't tell us that in the next 10 years you're going to have another 10 million because it's taken you 50 some years if not longer to get to this 10 million and we highly doubt you will double that in 10 years from this one improvement project.
02:11:29
So we went out and we tried to survey localities and asked them to tell us how much commercial industrial square footage they had because we'd need to know that for every single jurisdiction and I am unhappy to report that that did not go well.
02:11:41
We had a very difficult time getting information from localities.
02:11:45
We were getting different types of information from one locality versus another.
02:11:49
There were some jurisdictions who said they didn't have the ability to report that.
02:11:53
Again, I believe their tax assessor could have done it, but ultimately it proved to be extremely difficult.
02:11:59
So we want to recommend a different mechanism to the board, which is simply to say that we're just going to put in a kind of threshold.
02:12:07
And if you're saying you have more than 10 million square feet,
02:12:10
That would have impacted a grand total of four applications out of 400 in the last round
02:12:26
I'm there so we believe for most people this will not have an impact and I would state and there may be those who disagree with me but I'm going to say it anyway that if you have a single transportation project that you believe will create more than 10 million square feet of economic development you should have something to justify in fact that statement up.
02:12:46
Now again I think the important thing is for us to make sure we have a reasonable type of documentation request for these jurisdictions and we don't make them
02:12:54
Go spend money on some very detailed market analysis.
02:12:57
At the same time, 10 million square feet is a lot of commercial and industrial growth.
02:13:02
And if you're saying that's going to happen, we are going to be looking for some type of justification to do so.
02:13:08
Again, I think the first one we proposed to you was more nuanced and more accurate.
02:13:12
It ultimately proved to be too difficult to implement even on a pilot basis.
02:13:16
So I'm pretty sure we can't do it for 140 jurisdictions.
02:13:20
I think 10 million cap is a crude,
02:13:23
I believe it is an arbitrary method.
02:13:24
However, I believe it has a very limited impact or is reasonable.
SPEAKER_14
02:13:38
When was the deadline for all responses to be received?
02:13:41
We are still receiving responses.
02:13:43
That was my question because I'm aware of two ideas that are meeting this week to formulate responses.
02:13:52
So I'm assuming that these adjustments you've made are not inclusive of everything that you might consider making.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:14:01
Mr. Chairman, what I would say is that we are showing you all changes that we plan to make if we receive public feedback or input that we believe justifies any change.
02:14:12
I think we would send materials to you all in advance of the next board meeting.
02:14:15
I believe public input closes two and a half weeks or three weeks before your October meeting.
02:14:20
And so our goal
02:14:23
I'm not quite as far as it is.
02:14:25
But we would provide any other changes to you all in advance with a rationale for it.
02:14:30
Beyond what I'm showing you here today, we do not intend to make any changes again unless public input, just like the one with congestion, raises an area that staff believe we should bring to you all.
02:14:40
And ultimately, you all, if you disagree with what someone has said or are valuing of what they have said,
02:14:47
I'm showing you all the changes that we are going to propose from the state.
02:15:02
If somebody sends in a compelling case in their public comments, which is possible to happen, which has happened so far, we would notify all of them.
SPEAKER_14
02:15:13
Like I say, I'm aware of two MPOs this month, this week.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:15:17
W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
SPEAKER_04
02:15:38
I don't want to belabor this, but I know you guys don't give up easily, but it seemed the Kinetic Seed X percent total seemed practically reasonable.
02:15:46
How did that break down?
02:15:47
I mean, 10 million sounds like a very blunt instrument to use across the Commonwealth.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:15:51
I agree with everything you said, Mr. Kasprowicz.
SPEAKER_03
02:15:55
All I can say is...
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:15:58
First version we proposed I thought was the one that was the most context sensitive that recognized the differences between the jurisdictions and the differences in the status of economic conditions across the state.
02:16:13
I would just tell you it was like trying to get a seven-year-old to do their homework to get responses from the local governments and the amount of commercial and industrial square footage.
02:16:23
And again, every jurisdiction has a tax assessor.
02:16:27
Most have
02:16:28
Differential rates, or at least understand what classification of property is under for purposes of taxation, even if they don't have differential rates.
02:16:39
We were not able to get the information from most of the people we asked.
02:16:42
And I think we asked, was it 20?
02:16:43
10 or 20?
02:16:44
It was an accountability issue more than a practical application.
SPEAKER_03
02:16:50
I think it had to do.
02:16:51
There's a lot of people who don't really want their economic development data published.
02:16:56
for competitive reasons, or vice versa, showing that they don't have much.
02:17:03
No, I mean that in other ways, you know what I'm saying?
02:17:07
So I don't want to show their hand in that regard.
02:17:10
So I think that's part of it.
02:17:12
The whole, because we deal with this in economic development, it's very much more secretive.
02:17:18
It's beating against everybody.
02:17:20
And it is much more difficult to get that type of data.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:17:24
And I can understand that.
SPEAKER_03
02:17:26
We'd probably make a better decision, but we think this blunt instrument is probably the best compromise without going, and it's not going to really attack a lot of people.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:17:37
Mr. Chairman, the real problem we had is we were trying to figure out what percentage of existing growth, so we weren't able to even pilot test, like, what's the right percentage?
02:17:46
Is it 100%, is it 50%, is it 10%?
02:17:49
And we wanted to see, like, 20 jurisdictions be able to come up with a reasonable number, comparing that to applications that we had received, and we just couldn't even get enough information to do that, so I agree that what we had initially proposed is a more accurate, appropriate way to do it.
02:18:07
If we were able to do it, and I just don't know why it proved so difficult, but we really, we asked, we asked, we begged, we completed, a few people responded, the vast majority did not.
02:18:20
Again, I think 10 million is blunt, it is proved.
02:18:23
I also think it would capture some of the issues though that led staff to want to recommend this measure, and so there are only four products in round two that had that.
02:18:31
I think one of the ones that stands out drove a whole host of other changes, which was the Patriot Place roundabout,
02:18:37
In the Salem District where we had the cul-de-sac on the secondary road going to a roundabout on the secondary road where every piece of property within three miles was zoned agro-industrial.
02:18:49
And so they counted every piece of land within three miles of that property.
02:18:53
Again, that's driven a whole host of change.
02:18:56
Another example where I think they could provide documentation would be I-95 Route 10 in Chesterfield County, which is near Amazon, the proposed Tranlin paper site, and some other things.
02:19:07
They can easily provide us with documentation showing that.
02:19:11
I think after round three we may want to say, is it ten?
02:19:16
Is it eight?
02:19:17
Is it fifteen?
02:19:18
You're right.
02:19:19
Ten is wholly arbitrary.
02:19:21
I think what we did is we looked at applications and basically said, where can we draw a line where we're capturing the truly top tier of products submitted with regard to square footage?
02:19:32
and not impacting some of the lower tier ones where we don't want to make people justify something that on its face appears reasonable.
02:19:38
So it is crude and it is arbitrary, but I think it's the best thing we can do, unfortunately, for round three at this time.
02:19:50
So just quickly, some of the input that we've received to date, and I do want to say just to date, we did put out a track changes, a red line version of the technical guide on August 20th.
02:20:00
If anyone is interested in where we've added commas, put in new quotations, updated punctuation, or put in new actual words, you can go online to smartscale.org.
02:20:10
All that information is there.
02:20:12
It's easy to see.
02:20:13
Again, it's in track changes.
02:20:16
On the application limits, there has been just concern raised by everyone who's provided input that they're not a good idea or that they're a good idea for those people, but ours should be higher.
02:20:28
And so again you have rural areas worried that theirs is too low.
02:20:32
You have urban areas saying we're so much bigger ours should be higher.
02:20:36
You have the incorporated town issue that Ms. Hynes raised.
02:20:40
Generally, I think what we have is people adjusting to the fact that there may be caps and trying to figure out how they can make sure they have as much flexibility within whatever cap is imposed moving forward.
02:20:51
Nobody has said yes, please apply a cap to me.
SPEAKER_06
02:20:59
What about areas that may want to consider changing that category?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:21:07
Mr. Chairman, that's a varied question.
02:21:09
I should have mentioned that.
02:21:10
One, we've received a request from a single Planning District Commission, which is the RAPANIC-RAPANAM Planning District Commission, to move from area type C to D.
02:21:19
I think if that type of input is received, we would look to the district member.
02:21:24
If the district member concurs, we would recommend that change.
02:21:27
And if the full board was comfortable, we would just adopt that in the updated policy.
02:21:32
And do we generally default to what we started and default to what they want to be?
02:21:39
I would note, Mr. Chairman, Mr.
02:21:41
Stunt, that I think people tend to view their area types
02:21:45
based on the outcomes of a single round and what may have helped you in round two may not help you in round three.
02:21:51
So remember we did those sensitivity testing.
02:21:54
The change was not nearly as dramatic as everyone thought and we saw that sometimes urban areas had projects that did great in economic development and got funded when that was weighted higher there.
02:22:04
We saw there were some areas like C and D projects that when congestion was weighted higher they got funded and so I would just encourage
02:22:12
and any of the Planning District Commissions or others who might be seeking that change to think long and hard about it because they may end up wishing at the end of round three they were in the one they were in in round two with a change.
02:22:28
On the full funding project, again, there were those folks who raised concerns about plan versus program.
02:22:33
If you read the text about it, I believe it's very clear.
02:22:36
There's also some concerns expressed by jurisdiction saying, hey, we understand this improvement is proffered.
02:22:43
But the development isn't moving as fast, and we want the road now.
02:22:47
And I think just very candidly, we have limited resources.
02:22:51
I believe if there's an obligation for someone to construct a project, that the state should not be supplanting those monies.
02:22:58
The local jurisdiction has two options available to them.
02:23:01
They can try and work with the developer to expedite that profit, which I'm sure would involve some other changes to that zoning approval.
02:23:09
Or they do have the option, and I'm not saying I recommend this,
02:23:12
Go back to the zoning approval and rescind the proffer.
02:23:16
Now again there's the legislation approved down in Richmond that essentially makes imposing new proffers on a voluntary basis in the future close to impossible unless you're near a transit station which is really just at Northern Virginia and Norfolk.
02:23:29
But they do have that option of relieving that liability and then there's no one who is responsible for constructing that and then they can submit that project.
02:23:38
A staff we do not believe would be appropriate, though, for the state to use its limited dollars to go fund a project that someone else is going to need to build as a part of the approval process for a given development.
02:23:51
It's not a popular position that staff have.
02:23:53
I'll be very clear about that, but at the same time,
02:23:58
That means we're funding something a developer would have otherwise funded, and we can't build something somewhere else where there is no developer who has said they will pay for that improvement.
02:24:08
And that is just a real equity issue.
02:24:12
On the readiness side, we received several questions about whether or not it requires a signal clearance or interchange justification reports.
02:24:23
We want to know, how is it going to be paid for?
02:24:24
How long will it be?
02:24:27
I believe we need to provide some additional clarity back to those jurisdictions.
02:24:32
Some people are concerned that if they do one of these reports now and their funding doesn't come from four years and we have to redo it, that seems to be inappropriate to me.
02:24:42
I think as staff we need to work with some of these jurisdictions and clean up that language and provide some clarity to folks.
02:24:49
We can't ask them to do the same study twice just because a certain amount of time is passed.
02:24:54
They would probably rather have had the money sooner.
02:24:56
That's not anything they've done.
02:24:58
We're going to work with those jurisdictions on that issue.
02:25:02
On congestion, we had two requests.
02:25:05
One was the one we brought to you all about using current year analysis, which we will update the guide to reflect that.
02:25:10
The other was, and this also came from the Fredericksburg area, MPL was to use weekend traffic very candidly.
02:25:17
There are no traffic models in Virginia that include weekend traffic.
02:25:21
So we are unable to do that analysis.
02:25:24
That is not standard practice.
02:25:25
We are actually not aware of a single traffic model in the United States that has weekend traffic on a large-scale basis, if I remember that correctly.
02:25:37
So we understand that there may be worse congestion on certain portions of 95 in the Frederick River area on Saturdays and Sundays.
02:25:44
Our current methodologies and tools, however, just don't allow us to do that.
02:25:50
On safety, there were also folks who wanted us to provide points for where someone was putting in place an improvement that would make the roads safer, but they weren't having crashes.
02:26:00
We do not recommend that change to the board.
02:26:02
Again, we want to focus on problem areas where problems are happening, not just whether or not you're putting in place an improvement that would prevent a crash elsewhere.
02:26:11
On accessibility, there are those who support and oppose removing the 45 and 60-minute caps on the access to jobs.
02:26:17
I think one of the key things we need to provide to them is kind of the decay curves that show how a job is valued.
02:26:23
And again, the further away a job is, it's valued less because we have survey data that shows us every American will drive 10 minutes toward it.
02:26:31
When you get out to 60 minutes, that drops precipitously like 10% of Americans.
02:26:35
And so we give pro-ratic credit based on that.
02:26:39
That's been something we've had internally that we need to show to external stakeholders so they can understand the impact of this.
02:26:46
On economic development, we had a whole host of recommended changes there.
02:26:51
Again, it was make the area bigger, give more weighting to some of the other factors and other things of that nature.
02:26:56
We're not recommending any of those changes to you all as a board.
02:26:59
And then on land use, I think the biggest thing we've heard is, please provide us with more information on the non-accessibility measure, and we are going to be putting that information on the website.
02:27:09
For the stakeholders to take a look at.
02:27:12
So again, we are doing training and outreach on all these changes at each district.
02:27:16
It tends to be aligned with the fall hearing that we have in the area.
02:27:20
And so whenever we kind of come out to that hearing, we tend to have folks come out early in the day, meet with health staff for several hours and go through these.
02:27:28
As we continue to receive comment, we're going to review it and we'll provide responses to those provided comment.
02:27:34
And again, if anyone submits
02:27:36
H. Public comment that provides a compelling reason to make an additional change beyond what has been suggested here. Our plan is to notify the board as a whole of that change and then plan to move forward with that unless we receive feedback saying you all can operate. With that, Mr. Chairman, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Yeah, Mr. Whitworth, just a comment, and it has always followed me a little bit, that sometimes we take our position.
SPEAKER_14
02:28:11
For those that are hearing or listening in, I just think we need to assure our districts, because I mean my district, for instance, is not having a meeting until October 10th, that there's not a closeout on these recommendations.
02:28:32
My brothers probably would have had this review to be following the end of the transportation meetings,
02:28:41
I just think it's important that the districts that have not had their opportunity to communicate feel that it's not communication in vain.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:28:54
I'll also point out that they've had an opportunity at their meetings.
02:29:03
Everyone involved in this process coming out to this meeting, taking notes, in communication with folks, that is an accurate statement.
SPEAKER_04
02:29:13
Mr. Kasprowicz, I have one more question on the accessibility of the 45 and 69 caps.
02:29:20
I understand that taking away the hard line is out in the perhaps diminishing end of the K curve, but won't still be an actual theme of essentially giving more points to a, I guess, a longer commute process?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:29:36
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Kasprowicz, it will
02:29:39
It would allow projects that today may have increased access to jobs between that 45 and 50 minute mark to receive points that they wouldn't have.
02:29:50
I think that applies to projects of whether or not they're...
02:29:57
It wouldn't deal with long commutes, but I think there's this perception that eliminating...
02:30:02
I'll make a broad generalized statement which would be enacted on the nuances of people's opinion.
02:30:07
But in Northern Virginia, the comments I've received basically are
02:30:09
The inner jurisdiction say, please don't remove this.
02:30:12
This is bad.
02:30:13
The outer jurisdiction say, please remove this.
02:30:15
We've been penalized.
02:30:16
And the truth is that it will help projects in both Fairfax and in Loudoun.
02:30:21
It will help projects both in Arlington and in Prince William because an improvement, say, on 395 in Arlington would capture some of those benefits throughout, justice and improvement, say, on Braddock Road and Loudoun would also capture some of those benefits.
02:30:37
Again, there is a K-curve, so something within 10 minutes is that job's value at 100%.
SPEAKER_04
02:30:42
Still, there's still a piece of the K-curve that wasn't measured in the current 45 to 60 that will be.
02:30:48
That's correct.
02:30:49
So is this model from the perspective of it helping both more suburban and more urban areas?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:30:56
I think we could provide you with that information.
02:30:58
I think that we are recommending the removal of this based on the
02:31:03
Williams, John M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown
02:31:33
I also think the 45 and 60 is easier for the ordinary person to understand than the decay curve.
02:31:40
We are currently using the decay curves.
02:31:42
We just drew an arbitrary line at 45 and 60.
SPEAKER_03
02:31:50
Okay, that was another short briefing
02:32:03
Very important.
02:32:04
I think our citizens do appreciate the time that the board has spent on this.
02:32:09
It's really something that is one of the reasons why it's been so successful.
02:32:15
I should have mentioned, we have to have a hard break at noon because lunch is not going to be brought in.
02:32:21
We have to go down to the restaurant.
02:32:23
So Mr. Lawson, if you're not done by then, please, we'll just have to interrupt you.
02:32:28
We'll complete after lunch.
SPEAKER_12
02:32:30
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
02:32:32
I shouldn't have any problems being done before you.
02:32:46
This morning what I'm going to do is just give you a real brief update of how fiscal year 2017 wrapped up.
02:32:53
And just a little insight as to where we're headed for 18 and what the kind of the future revenue forecast are beginning to look like.
02:33:01
It's obviously very early in the year, but there's been some information put out that I want to bring to your attention.
02:33:09
Just to summarize, kind of three main things that I'll be talking about.
02:33:14
One, fiscal year 2017 did slightly better in forecast.
02:33:19
I'll speak to that in a little detail,
02:33:22
And I say slightly, I mean very, very slightly.
02:33:26
And before we get excited about the extra money, the additional revenues are above forecast all by code put into the private transportation department.
02:33:36
So that's a requirement that we have to follow.
02:33:39
In terms of 2018, obviously, we are very early in the year.
02:33:44
From an actual perspective, we only have July, and all this data is just coming out too late for the incorporated
02:33:52
McPherson Jr.
02:33:53
But what we are seeing though is it is likely that the trends we saw for that slight increase in 2017 will continue as we go forward.
02:34:05
So focusing a little bit on 2017, as I mentioned, we did exceed forecast slightly.
02:34:10
Year-over-year revenues were 2.9% growth over 2016.
02:34:16
M. 4.9% of growth that was forecast. So that's a full percentage point. That percentage point equates to a little bit about 32 million miles. You can see that on the next slide. The increase in performance is really driven by two areas. You've heard me talk about this one a lot, but motor vehicle sales and use continue to outperform. You can see we had year-over-year growth of about 4.3% compared to a forecasted growth I think it's over 2%.
02:34:49
McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson,
02:35:08
also grew about 2% year-over-year, but it did fall short of the forecast of 2.3%.
02:35:16
So that's an area that just kind of illustrates how the economics of the state are still struggling to rebound based off of the recession.
02:35:27
In federal revenues, they continue to do what
02:35:36
Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
02:36:00
F. Thomas, John F. Kasprowicz Jr., John F. Kasprowicz Jr.,
02:36:27
Our federal revenues, as you can see, we collected, I guess for all practical purposes, we were flat with higher fiscal year.
02:36:37
Our revenues were just shy of 1.2 billion dollars in federal revenue collections.
02:36:42
And as you see there in the chart, the majority of those revenues, about 700 million are related to the construction program.
02:36:51
We have about 340 million related to the maintenance program.
02:36:55
We have been utilizing federal monies to support the program for about 10 years now.
02:37:05
As we were struggling with crossover many years ago and trying to make sure we had funds, sufficient funds in that area.
02:37:12
And it also reflects the increased money we received last year through the bonus obligation for August redistribution process.
02:37:24
Year over year spending.
02:37:25
As you can see on this chart, everything lines up very, very closely the same, with the exception of the construction bar you see at the very top.
02:37:35
We were a little low on the construction side.
02:37:39
And really, looking at that, it's kind of a combination of things.
02:37:45
The biggest single piece otherwise is the last of the $100 million payments that we were to make to EMWA was made last year.
02:37:53
So that season was made in 16.
02:37:56
So with that not being made in 17, we saw immediate reduction there in spending.
02:38:02
And as we talked before, as we kind of had the delay to get started with SMART SCALE, we did lose a little ground in some of our spending.
02:38:10
And obviously, that's picking back up now as we move forward.
02:38:19
Maintenance program.
02:38:22
also spent very close to what was spent in 2016.
02:38:26
It's been about $1.7 billion.
02:38:30
And we got lucky last year in terms of net snow.
02:38:35
Snow fell in at $147 billion with actual snow expenditure, which is about, round numbers, $50 million below the forecast.
02:38:44
So hopefully we'll experience the same great fortune this year and then be able to put those monies toward
02:38:52
and David Lincoln's activities.
02:39:05
The regions continue to collect pretty close to forecast.
02:39:11
You'll see here that in 2017, in Northern Virginia, we had forecasted 325, collected 32 million,
02:39:21
and Hampton Roads, a forecast that won 55 and collected $156 million.
02:39:25
So they were for the most part, they can credit tax on having a good forecast on both of those areas.
SPEAKER_03
02:39:35
Still below what was anticipated when they passed because of the price of gasoline.
SPEAKER_12
02:39:41
Hampton Roads, it's about $50 million probably below forecast because the other one is impacted here by
02:39:50
The gas tax isn't a component of no one in this forecast.
02:39:58
The area still is experiencing the same fate in that sense.
02:40:06
And then just from a cash perspective, you can see how we ended the year about 170 million
02:40:20
Where we began the year, a good portion of that was a combination of operating revenues or operating funds you see at the top, as well as just timing along closely to the bottom.
02:40:39
In terms of 2018, just for a minute, and as I kind of alluded at the beginning, it's really too early
02:40:50
McPherson Jr.
02:40:51
When looking at what we have seen in July, motor vehicle sales and use tax continue to be a little better than the prior year.
02:41:03
Retail sales tend to be a little lower than they were the previous year.
02:41:08
So I think what we're seeing all in all is setting up to be a continuation of what we saw in the prior year.
02:41:17
From a spending perspective,
02:41:21
I think we have to credit a wet season to lower construction and maintenance spending in July and hopefully that will recover as we move along through the year.
02:41:36
We will be bringing on the two inside the Beltway and the 64 Express lanes already scheduled to go into operations later this December and we will be
02:41:50
including that extending rate in the annual program as they move forward.
02:41:59
Now I want to give you a, you can conclude, just kind of a brief update on where we are in terms of revenue forecast.
02:42:07
Taxation did an August revenue update this year.
02:42:12
For the most part, that August update is focused on general fund revenue sources.
02:42:18
But they undertook the update this year to take a look at the major transportation value sources.
02:42:28
And what they found was largely what we saw in 2017.
02:42:35
It does appear that revenues related to motor vehicle sales will likely be forecasted upward.
02:42:47
as well as slight increase as it relates to fuel tax.
02:42:52
And I say forecasted upward, the official forecast that we operate under will not be updated until December as part of the governor's budget process.
02:43:02
So we kind of take this summertime August look, where does it look like we're going?
02:43:08
And then in December, they'll actually come out with an official forecast.
02:43:12
And the official forecast is what I come to you with, typically in January to give you
02:43:24
What we are seeing again is pretty consistent with what we saw for in 2017 looking at something in the 25 to 30 billion a year in increased revenues.
02:43:38
Mr. Chairman?
SPEAKER_03
02:43:40
You really did do that.
02:43:44
I think the news here that John's brain has been pretty steady executing
02:43:54
We'll get more visibility, as you mentioned, after the actual update.
02:43:59
Even though it's getting some insight, we can't do anything until the tax authorities say this is the official forecast.
02:44:08
John and I, I think on Thursday, we are meeting with the rating agencies as part of the status meeting with the rating agencies, giving an overview of what's going on in the state.
02:44:19
And unlike previous years,
02:44:23
W. Smith Jr. Transportation is a big part of that because of all the things that have happened.
02:44:28
And if you looked at the rating agency or the rankings of states to do business, Virginia has moved up and they pointed out the reforms we've taken in transportation.
02:44:40
And of course, part of that's the Port of Virginia and what's happening there.
02:44:45
I mention that because I do believe this is going to be a very, very difficult budget for the new government.
02:44:53
Unlike our revenues who are a little bit steady, that is not going to be the case.
02:44:59
And you probably saw on the paper today, they're trying to build up reserves for impact.
02:45:05
And one of the things that the rating agencies have pointed out is even though the budget has been balanced the last couple of years, it's gone into the Ready Day Reserve Fund.
02:45:16
And they don't believe that's structurally a way forward.
02:45:22
And so they have put us on a negative outlook in terms of our Triple A credit rating.
02:45:27
And I can tell you there's going to be a very, very significant effort to make sure that it's not impacted.
02:45:34
So you're going to have that plus the fact that there are just some automatic spending increases that go on in the general fund that relate to health care, that relate to education spending that are just, no matter what the policy is, they're going to go up.
02:45:48
I do want to point that out in that I do believe the General Assembly will be looking at all the available funds, sources of funds, to help Virginia achieve its goals, not only stripping away credit rating, but other aspects in the biennial budget that's coming up.
02:46:12
So, I just want to give you the heads up.
02:46:14
I do expect there will be
02:46:17
counterparts in the general fund agency.
02:46:20
You probably saw it was D&D presented yesterday to the money committees.
02:46:27
And one of the suggestions that the commission earned, even though I said I was not in favor of it, rightly so, didn't put to their attention that there could have been more money coming from the moneys that flow through VDOT keeping more in D&D.
02:46:46
specifically said I would not support that and that was the position of the money committees yesterday also in that. But DMV is facing a fairly significant shortfall of about $16 million a year so I wanted you to be aware of the environment that this budget will be going in. Particularly in light of this So.
02:47:11
Mitchell has pointed out in previous discussions regarding transit funding and all that.
02:47:16
So it's going to be a very, very significant session.
02:47:22
But it looks like from our perspective, the Tomahawk Transportation Fund monies, we're planning to plan.
02:47:28
No real big increases one way or the other.
02:47:31
But I know the construction monies are increasing as we go because
02:47:39
of the SMART SCALE and the ability for Charlie to issue those contracts in a more timely method because they can plan them out.
02:47:47
So I anticipate that to continue to increase.
02:47:53
I want to just steal one.
02:47:54
Charlie had the best line I have ever heard about the funding.
02:48:00
And he basically was referring to all the barrels, the orange barrels.
02:48:04
And I've taken this to be my own.
02:48:12
I did get asked in the hallway about a procedural issue because as you all know there were three of our members that were up for reappointment
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:48:43
in the July 1.
SPEAKER_03
02:48:47
But the policy of this board is that you are member until reappointed.
02:48:53
So from an actual quorum or a policy, there is no issue.
02:48:56
I will mention that the three members have been told they're going to be reappointed.
02:49:01
But there is one position that Mr. Fallon left, one position that remains unfilled in terms of that position.
02:49:12
I do believe it's the governor's intention that the court would be going over to fulfill the district member in that regard.
02:49:23
So I just want to point out procedurally and whatever what's going on, there's a rule urban at large that's being looked at.
02:49:31
So in terms of our functioning, our policies are that you're a member of the court until appointed by another person.
02:49:43
And the second thing is when we just received the email from Mr. Connors that he will not be here at all.
02:49:54
He's had a business commitment that's come up or he can't get out of.
02:49:58
So that probably means we will have to cancel the technology meeting tomorrow since he will not be able to get here.
02:50:05
I did not want people to show up in that setting.
02:50:15
So just letting you know that that will not happen tomorrow.
02:50:19
So we'll start it here at 8.30 tomorrow.
02:50:21
So a couple of administrative items.
02:50:24
I just want to make sure everybody was aware of that.
02:50:29
I should caveat, to any employment official, the governor can certainly change his mind, but that is his intent.
02:50:36
I don't want anybody.
02:50:37
I always say that because I don't make the appointments.
02:50:40
And so I don't want to get ahead of the governor, but I think he's lost.
02:50:47
All right, Morteza, we've got 20 minutes, but if we don't finish, we'll have to apologize.
02:50:55
We'll break through there and we'll come back afterwards.
SPEAKER_15
02:51:00
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
02:51:03
My name is Morteza Farajian and I'm the director of the P3 office for VDOT.
02:51:09
Today, I want to brief you on
02:51:12
Some of the changes or updates that we have made to PPTA implementation manual and guidelines, and I want to walk you through those changes.
02:51:22
The document is out on our project website for public comment.
02:51:27
It has been posted.
02:51:29
In this presentation, I just want to highlight the areas that we have updated, mainly because of legislative changes that we've had in 2015 and 2017.
02:51:42
Going to the first slide, you are probably familiar with the requirements that we have on the Public Private Transportation Act.
02:51:54
Any public entity that wants to use the Act needs to have guidelines, that's a requirement.
02:52:02
VDOT and DRPT adopted, last time that they adopted their guidelines was back in 2014.
02:52:09
Since 2014, they have had
02:52:12
At least two rounds of legislative changes, once in 2015 and most recently in 2017.
02:52:19
So the guideline that today is in place is out of date.
02:52:24
It needs to be updated and that's exactly what we are trying to do.
02:52:28
This is all part of the process that we have gone through to look at our P3 program again and come up with
02:52:38
A better approach, a better structure for our PT program, reform it, and this is one of the last steps that we have to go through.
02:52:47
All of the legislative changes now we need to make sure that they are reflected and guidelines on the process that we follow to report every project.
02:52:55
The guideline that we have put on our website, it mainly applies to VDOT and DRPT.
02:53:01
The reason behind it is that some of the legislative changes in 2017
02:53:05
Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
02:53:27
P. P. T. A.
02:53:28
This new concept is about finding of public interest.
02:53:32
It now requires the CEO of the responsible public entity to make a finding of public interest, to have a statement of benefits in that document, to have a statement of risk, right on liabilities, responsibilities,
02:53:47
and especially the ones that are assumed by public sector as well as the ones that are being transferred to private sector.
02:53:56
It needs to make a determination on whether those risks are high-level risks or medium-level risks or low-level risks and also it needs to state the rationale for using competitive negotiations whenever it has been used.
02:54:11
So that's one of the changes that was put in the legislation in 2015.
02:54:17
The CEO must also certify the finding of public interest all the way at the end before signing a comprehensive agreement to Governor and General Assembly.
02:54:27
So that's another step that needs to be taken.
02:54:31
It's new in the legislation, but of course there are some requirements regarding public comment throughout the process.
02:54:41
There's a 30-day public comment period for any agreement that's entering the agreement that VDOT or DRPT wants to enter into with private sector, as well as a 30-day public review and comment requirement for issuance of final RFP.
02:54:59
So basically before issuing final RFP, the documents need to be posted online and the public needs to have at least 30 days to provide comments.
02:55:10
Now moving to 2017, some of the key legislative changes in 2017.
02:55:14
I want to start with probably the most important one, which is a mandate that public sector analysis and competition needs to happen before we can issue a draft RFP.
02:55:32
Well, there are different steps that we need to go through, but the analysis is somehow comparable to an old analysis that's called value for money analysis, which had some fatal flaws.
02:55:45
And I think this new approach that State is implementing now is trying to fix some of the issues that value for money analysis had.
02:55:53
It's very simple.
02:55:55
Basically, what we do is that we try to
02:55:58
Look at the project and look at how Commonwealth can deliver that project on its own.
02:56:03
Look at the costs and risks and different options that we have under public sector financing and delivery models.
02:56:12
And based on those, we try to draft term sheets that those term sheets would look at
02:56:18
What are basically the requirements that we have as the state from private sector to deliver as part of the project?
02:56:26
That's all done up front before we start the procurement.
02:56:30
Based on our analysis of public sector options, we come up with maximum public contribution for the state.
02:56:37
That basically says that if we want to do the project ourself, this is how things would look like.
02:56:42
Now inviting private sector to submit proposals and only if they can do the project better than what the state can do on their own, then we can advance in this process and go to private sector and sign a contract with them.
02:56:58
So that's in essence
02:57:01
I would say taking that whole analysis that previously was being done based on assumptions, going to market and testing really the market, knowing exactly what we can get done, and making sure that as we go through the process we get value from advancing the project under PPTA.
02:57:22
I will explain a little bit later how in the process we look at different options and analyze options.
SPEAKER_14
02:57:40
A.
SPEAKER_03
02:57:40
Sickness Jr. Well, I know it's a whole lot more than number driven, but it's also that Morteza and his team will go through the VDOT and score it.
02:57:52
That would be incredible.
02:57:53
It's not just steps, but at the end of the day, it is that they can deliver the project that we want less expensively and with incredible analysis.
SPEAKER_14
02:58:05
We have an internal estimate.
SPEAKER_03
02:58:07
Jordan internal, we put it in the public, we put it in the term sheet.
02:58:12
We say here's what the public, and I don't know if you can jump in here, but this is what was very clear to me, the value for money analysis assumed all kinds of assumptions where risk was related from previous situations, and I know risk is different from situation to situation.
02:58:31
That was probably one of the fatal flaws that I observed.
02:58:35
What this is is that
02:58:37
We just say, here's what VDOT can do it for by going after their normal procurement.
02:58:43
What they would do and you working with Morteza in the financial markets.
02:58:47
And where we assume there's tolls, Morteza goes to the same consultants that the private sector might use and say, here's something for toll and data working with John and his team.
02:58:58
And we come up with the model.
02:58:59
And we say, that's what we can finance it for, run it for.
02:59:05
The term sheet's published, not hidden.
02:59:07
It's like we did 66.
02:59:10
And you guys beat this?
02:59:12
Let's talk.
02:59:15
I mean, it's not a very, it used to be a very, very subjective analysis.
02:59:22
I'm not saying we don't use subjective analysis in here now, but like for instance, when tolls are required, Morteza will go through this, we gotta have two independent rating agencies coming up with their financial model.
02:59:34
We just don't take their word.
02:59:36
The rating agency is also what's called a qualified proposal.
02:59:43
But what it's saying is, look, we went back to it.
02:59:49
The three risks in these deals, the three are the construction, the operating risk, and the financial risk.
02:59:57
The financial, the revenue, and the interest rates.
02:59:59
Well, we know how to handle the first two pretty easily.
03:00:04
We've done it for a long time, construction and maintenance with it.
03:00:08
No secret, I think, very qualified.
03:00:10
The ones that we weren't as was the financial risk, but there's no reason we can't use the same third parties that they do.
03:00:19
We've gotten a lot of experience now.
03:00:21
Morteza's done this, and Charlie has done quite a few of these.
03:00:25
We've gone by some of the experiences in that.
03:00:29
But also,
03:00:31
Nobody can finance with our private or public debt options.
03:00:38
Nobody can finance any cheaper than us if we choose to.
03:00:43
But what we do is we say, you know, here's what it would be.
03:00:49
And we found under 66, they substantially were able to do it less than us.
03:00:58
And I'll remind you, we were
03:01:00
A million dollars better than what we were to the value for money in the house before we started. And yet we actually got a billion dollars better proposal we competitively had other people willing to get out here. So it's... How can the private sector do a billion dollars better than us? Well, I can tell you because they assess risk differently than we do. Yes sir, I'm going to give you two examples. 66 is a great one where
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:30
As the Secretary said, in terms of interest rates that we can get for public debt are probably as good as you can get.
03:01:39
But they assess risk differently and their revenue line very differently than we might going into the Commonwealth selling debt versus an investor.
03:01:49
This investor put a large amount of equity at risk in the case of 66, and they believe that they can take that risk.
03:01:58
So that's where the big difference.
03:02:00
It wasn't so much in the design-builds what we believe the construction costs would be.
03:02:05
Frankly, it was very close amongst bidders and with our estimates.
03:02:09
It really had to do with their view on the revenue side and what they believe, what they were willing to put at risk.
03:02:17
The state, to some level, doesn't
03:02:25
and probably more conservative trafficking revenue model.
03:02:30
So that's where the big difference happened there.
03:02:32
But I'll give a different example of the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
03:02:35
It may be under our traditional procurement methods, we have some limitations in terms of how we can conduct procurement, where under the P3 model, we have broader authorities in terms of the procurement itself, which may bring better value
SPEAKER_03
03:02:54
Look, the real issue is competition because no value for money analysis can say what motivates someone to do it.
03:03:03
You don't take into account they have competitive pressures because they don't want a competitor to control the entire market.
03:03:10
You don't know what their true cost of capital is because they may be in a foreign country that has a negative cost of capital in the country.
03:03:19
You don't know what construction they just finished.
03:03:21
They want to keep people busy.
03:03:24
I mean, just like we were talking yesterday at Chesapeake Bay Bridge talking.
03:03:27
You don't know.
03:03:28
Those are things, the only way you get those is through competitive business.
03:03:33
Only way you get them.
03:03:35
We can sit down and agree all we want and make rational decisions about what would be, from our risk standpoint, that's what we do.
03:03:45
But the only way you know is if you have competition.
03:03:49
It's not just related to construction.
03:03:52
Think about it, it stops.
03:03:54
So I don't know that we're going to have 66 type of results on every P3.
03:04:14
Don't get me wrong.
03:04:20
I don't think that's going to be the case.
03:04:27
But I also know, I can assure you, that I can't determine what motivates somebody to make an actual bid.
03:04:38
And this states that these are multinational companies for the most part.
03:04:41
They're doing business all over the world.
03:04:43
And quite frankly, there's no way you're going to out-negotiate them unless you start with what
03:04:48
you want and let them compete against it.
03:04:54
I mean, I think that's pretty consistent from what we've been saying ever since we went through 66.
03:04:59
And I can't say what the results will be.
03:05:04
And there might be a time when we found that we were perfectly happy at going forward with 66 that nobody could beat it.
03:05:12
I wouldn't beat it.
03:05:15
Take a look at the risk rock and prove it.
03:05:17
That's the right one.
03:05:19
And that may happen, but at least then we know we've gone to the private sector and verified what we thought.
03:05:29
And while I can join, I can stand, or whoever's here after us, we can stand up in front of them and say, the money committees, the steering committee, and say, I can tell you it's the best deal we can do.
03:05:42
Either because the private sector beat it, or if they couldn't beat it, then I'm comfortable saying the public ought to deliver this.
SPEAKER_14
03:05:51
It doesn't have to.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:00
We'll tell you that we've done a number of the public-private transportation act does not require it to be a toll type of facility or a revenue generating facility in order to do it under the P3.
03:06:16
The evolution of P3 has largely gone to toll supported facilities.
03:06:20
But it doesn't preclude them.
03:06:24
The example that says the Cambridge Tunnel, the Federal Shoals Tunnel, I believe it was actually secured under the PPTA, not under the procurement.
SPEAKER_03
03:06:35
So we in Virginia primarily do demand risk transfer concessions.
03:06:42
So that's why there could be other areas where it makes sense
03:06:50
to procure it under the P3, but maybe follow a normal procurement, but for other reasons, do it under the P3 Act.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:59
We have currently active PPTA projects that are not tolled.
03:07:07
The Coldfields Expressway project is not a tolled facility.
03:07:11
The 58 improvements down in the south side is not a tolled supported P3.
03:07:19
Rick, was it procured under the P3?
03:07:23
Yes.
03:07:24
So the 28 improvements in Fairfax and Loudoun County, that concession was also procured under that Act, but it's not a sole support facility.
SPEAKER_03
03:07:35
By going forward, if we use it, we have to prove to the public why it is better and what risks are being transferred.
03:07:43
It used to be before the Secretary could say it was going to be a P3.
03:07:47
We can't do that.
03:07:48
We have to say,
03:07:50
why we are doing it under a P3.
03:07:54
And there could be other reasons other than tolling and risk transfer related to revenues, but they gotta be disclosed up front.
03:08:03
You just can't, because remember the P3 suspends a lot of the normal procurement protections off of it, and that was what got us into trouble with VDOT being directed to do some things I don't think were appropriate.
03:08:20
I can direct them all at once, but we've got to stand up in front of the steering committee and say, here's why we think this should be procured as a P3.
03:08:30
Or it's got to be approved before we can actually go down that path.
03:08:36
Morteza, it's new.
03:08:38
What we probably should do, because we've interrupted you at this point, is probably take
03:08:55
All right, so at 1 o'clock, that'll give you time for everybody to check in or answer questions.
03:09:03
So we come back here at 1 o'clock, Morteza, and then we'll go through this.
03:09:09
All right, so we will spend the conversation at 1 o'clock.
03:09:17
Oh, I'm sorry.
03:09:18
Down in Tavern 64, there's a reserved area
04:25:49
because we took a little longer than lunch based on the accommodations here, but it was good.
04:25:58
So, Morteza, why don't we go ahead and keep going here.
SPEAKER_13
04:26:04
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_03
04:26:09
I think where we left off, you were going through
04:26:16
Again, I want to point out to everybody this is basically the P3 office and Morteza updating the guidelines for the legislation that has been passed.
04:26:32
So there is nothing new here that hasn't been briefed to the board over the last couple of years.
04:26:40
I think it's great for Morteza to do this as a review of sort of where we are now.
04:26:46
We've got some big procurements coming up.
04:26:50
Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel, potentially, and others.
04:26:54
Understanding the procurement of the P3 and when it's applicable and when it's not, I think is very, very appropriate.
SPEAKER_15
04:27:03
Thank you very much.
04:27:05
Just need to mention that everything that we're discussing today is related to our PPTA implementation manual.
04:27:14
A couple of other guidelines that we have.
04:27:17
One of them is value for money analysis, which after you all hear this one and vote on a resolution next month, as soon as this is taken care of, it will go and actually update that document.
04:27:33
And now we will have a public sector option analysis and competition.
04:27:39
And in that document, we will talk about different steps that we need to go through in order to develop a public sector option and come up with a process on how each project needs to create that option.
04:27:52
So that document, updating that document with follow-up updating this document.
SPEAKER_03
04:27:56
And that's a key point.
04:27:58
This is a realistic public option.
04:28:01
This is not something out there to try to make the private sector do something that's not fair.
04:28:09
We want to make sure it's a real public option to be delivered.
04:28:13
It's not fair to the private industry if we're just putting things out there just to try to some type of negotiating strategy.
04:28:21
That is not it at all.
04:28:22
That's why there is a steering committee and others that would look at this.
04:28:26
This has to be something that can actually be delivered.
04:28:30
Mr. Kasprowicz.
04:28:30
Will we have input into that process of the updating of the command?
SPEAKER_15
04:28:35
Definitely.
04:28:36
So come back and update the field now if you want to.
04:28:38
Yes, we can do that.
SPEAKER_03
04:28:40
And follow those steps too.
04:28:41
So I want to make it clear, this is not a prejudice one way or the other, P3s, either for or against the private sector.
04:28:51
I think it's important to them that they have a very level playing field, know what to expect, and we're consistent because, quite frankly,
04:29:00
It is in the best interest of the public, if they can, to form a better service than we can.
04:29:07
And that's the whole purpose of it.
04:29:08
And I think there are some times where that is going to make, you know, it's going to be obvious and clear.
04:29:14
But it has to be in the public's interest, and this way will go through it.
04:29:18
I just, again, want to reiterate, this is really, as much for the private sector, they have a realistic goal of procurement they're looking at in a turn sheet, not just something made up
04:29:30
Bob Bedot or somebody else to say, you know, we're going to do this publicly if we can't do it.
04:29:35
It's got to be something that we can do.
04:29:37
So I think that's a very important part.
SPEAKER_15
04:29:41
Moving to the next bullet point on this page.
04:29:43
Another change that was made in the legislation was creation of transportation public-private partnership steering committee that Mr. Secretary also referred to it.
04:29:55
There are a couple of
04:29:58
places that they play a role.
04:30:00
I have listed the three places that they play a role under that item.
04:30:07
First, they need to meet and review the assumptions that basically form public sector option.
04:30:15
We need to go in front of them.
04:30:17
We need to explain to them what is public sector option.
04:30:20
We need to share with them the assumptions that we have used in our analysis.
04:30:24
And they need to concur with
04:30:27
those assumptions and analysis.
04:30:29
That's the first step.
04:30:30
And I will explain later when it happens.
04:30:34
The next step is after CEO of the responsible public entity makes its finding of public interest they need to
04:30:44
now vote on whether they concur with the decision or they don't concur with the decision.
04:30:49
And of course the last one which it's not an action that they need to take it's just a briefing that we need to go in front of them again after we sign the contract and basically explain to them that
04:31:01
The whole process that we started from the beginning all the way to the end, everything that we had in the term sheet, has been reflected that it's in accordance with the comprehensive agreement that was signed.
04:31:11
So that's the third step.
04:31:13
All three of those bullets, again, are in legislation.
04:31:15
We haven't added anything that's outside legislation.
04:31:18
I'm just summarizing for you what changes we're making in legislation.
04:31:21
And we're trying to reflect those changes exactly in our values.
SPEAKER_03
04:31:26
Why don't you share what the makeup of the steering committee is, too, if you would,
SPEAKER_15
04:31:31
Sure, so Deputy Secretary of Transportation will be the Chairman.
04:31:36
There will be two members from CTB.
04:31:39
There will be the Staff Director for House Committee on Appropriation, there will be the Staff Director for Senate Committee on Finance, CFO of the Responsible Public Entities, so that's VDOT Project is going to be CFO of VDOT, and a non-agency public finance expert.
SPEAKER_03
04:32:02
So that this is not just the Transportation Department, it is the Legislature, it is the Commonwealth Transportation Board, it is the Department of Finance, my counterpart, Rick Brown, everybody looking at this an objective look that this makes sense to do.
04:32:24
And I would remind you, this is a big department, this is putting the CTB in this process, where before the CTB
04:32:32
Other than getting a briefing, there was no vote.
04:32:35
There was nothing.
04:32:36
It could be executed totally within the executive branch.
04:32:41
So this is all changed now in that.
04:32:44
And frankly, we believe this way, it eliminates political risk up front.
04:32:49
Because now when this is signed off up front, all the constituents have said, and so our private parties know if they come to an agreement, it's going to go to fruition.
04:33:01
Instead of getting to the end, and we put some of our private parties in some deals, we signed a tough position.
04:33:07
Because another administration comes in, they don't like the deal, may have been a good reason why it shouldn't have been, but that's not fair to private parties either.
04:33:16
And this way, everybody signs off, everybody knows what's gonna happen, it talks about the risk being transferred, doesn't tell you the value of the risk.
04:33:24
But I mean, it's no secret it's gonna be a total road.
04:33:27
It's no secret it's going to be, those are the type things
04:33:30
that are now up front and people know what those risks are being transferred.
04:33:37
Not just the transportation area and the space, if that's where the big ones are going to be.
04:33:42
But the executive branch and the legislative branch are involved in the process to eliminate political risk up front.
SPEAKER_15
04:33:55
The other change in the legislation is now with Scott to... What about that?
SPEAKER_03
04:34:00
So who are the current CTB members?
04:34:02
Scott and Mr. Fraver.
04:34:04
So we will need to make a, I will confer with my team and we will, I will reach out and ask for another member.
SPEAKER_15
04:34:23
Another step that was added to the code is a step that signature
04:34:39
Kupfer with the finding of public interest at CEO of Responsible Public Entities. If Commissioner Kilpatrick makes a finding of public interest, Secretary Layne and his role as chairman of CTB must confer with his finding of public interest before we can move forward. That's also legislation. And it works the other way, too, is to keep the executive branch from railroading VDOT. They have to take ownership in this instead of just being Thank you.
SPEAKER_03
04:35:08
Well VDOT signed because I can tell you I heard that in the time.
04:35:11
Well VDOT, but I understand how that works and what VDOT was told to do.
SPEAKER_15
04:35:19
And finally, there are some limitations that now VDOT and DRPT would have when they want to enter into certain interim agreements.
04:35:29
That's another change that was put in the legislation.
04:35:32
I'm going to the next slide.
04:35:34
This is basically a slide that shows the process.
04:35:38
The next couple of slides will walk you through each step of this process.
04:35:43
And I will try to show an enlarged version of this slide so you can actually read the text.
04:35:49
It's a little bit hard to read here.
04:35:52
But the point I want to make in this slide is that each one of these P3 projects is very complicated and it's unique.
04:36:00
It's really hard to come up with a process that we can say that we need to go through these steps exactly for every single project.
04:36:09
That usually doesn't happen.
04:36:10
Each one of the projects has to be a little bit different.
04:36:14
So this is the general P3 process based on what we understand is required by law, but sometimes depending on
04:36:22
The complexity that the project has, depending on really what outcomes we get out of our analysis, certain elements in the school chart may change.
04:36:31
So I just wanted to make that comment that if for whatever reason we don't need to go through one of those elements, it doesn't mean that you're not following the law.
04:36:41
All it means is that for that particular project, maybe the circumstances allow us to go through a different way, and maybe that way provides a better value.
04:36:49
But every time that we do that, we need to explain that why we are deviating from this culture.
SPEAKER_03
04:36:54
I think that is a very, very key point.
04:36:57
These laws and procedures that we put in,
04:37:00
I have basically eliminated some of the bad things off that could happen that no one knows about.
04:37:07
But at the end of the day, it's the deal that is done is what's going to make the real difference as to the benefit to the taxpayers.
04:37:20
So while Nick and I were talking about this the other day, while we put a lot of this in legislation and reform, it's going to still require end up explanation
04:37:29
and particularly from the steering committee in this group asking those questions because we can only put so many things in and we can stop some things that just truly shouldn't happen but that doesn't fix everything.
04:37:45
The word maybe isn't fixed but it doesn't highlight everything in a better world.
04:37:49
So I think this is, understanding this process and what Morteza is trying to point out is that
04:37:55
The best result is going to be people asking and understanding and making sure we have that interplay for the public.
SPEAKER_04
04:38:03
Mr. Secretary, I'd like to make a comment on your comment.
04:38:06
I think one of the things that's missing from Morteza's very complete presentation is just the dramatic difference in transparency in the current P3 process we just went through
04:38:25
I commend your leadership on that issue because you really kept the majority of the process in the public eye, information available, and I think that's one of the most significant changes that's occurred.
SPEAKER_15
04:38:43
Thank you.
04:38:43
So going to the next slide, this is basically the initiation phase for the process.
04:38:52
We have combined a couple of steps
04:38:58
Dita Level Screening, and the four that we have in the project identification phase.
04:39:03
What we have done here is that we have consolidated all of those.
04:39:06
We call it project screening phase.
04:39:09
In the project screening phase, we have a couple of criteria that we'll look at, both from qualitative side and from quantitative side.
04:39:20
On the qualitative side, one of the important items for us is if there is a project that we're trying to screen it,
04:39:27
whether that project meets some of the transportation needs that we have in the Commonwealth or not.
04:39:33
In other words, we just don't want to start looking at the project, pushing the project down the pipeline, the process that we have, unless that project clearly is meeting one of the transportation needs that we have.
04:39:49
That's one of the criteria that
04:39:51
We have in our report and we will investigate it and we will report back to the CEO of a responsible public entity that how this project is going to help with one of the transportation needs.
04:40:04
On the quantitative side, this is when we start looking at how we can build a project ourselves.
04:40:15
The next stage is public sector analysis and competition.
04:40:19
This is when we start putting some cost estimates together.
04:40:23
We would have a traffic and revenue study at a very high level at this stage, but the goal is to be able to put some numbers together and see whether at least a very high level thing would add up and make sense.
04:40:36
The reason that we have this stage is that before we go to the next step,
04:40:42
We start really burning money and burning funding in that stage, bringing consultants on board and spending real dollars.
04:40:51
Maybe that's the best way to say.
04:40:54
We want to screen the projects at this stage and only let those projects go forward that they meet the criteria.
04:41:02
So that's the reason that we have this step.
04:41:06
When we prepare the report, we go to the CEO of the responsible public entity, Director Mitchell or Commissioner Kilpatrick.
04:41:14
We presented them all of our findings and if they, based on the information that we provided them, if they decide to move forward and go to the project environment phase and take all of those studies into more detail, we can proceed and go to the next step.
04:41:33
Next step, as I mentioned is project development phase.
04:41:36
This is one-degree consultants on board and we start having a project UPC and some funding for the project and develop a little bit more detailed cost estimates, risk register, traffic and revenue study, financial analysis, further develop a public sector option and
04:41:58
That public sector option, as the Secretary mentioned, is a realistic option based on data and information that we can back them up with studies that we are conducting.
04:42:13
Again, you present all the information to the CEO of the responsible public entity and that's the time that they need to magnify the public entity.
04:42:24
If Finding of Public Interest says that they want to proceed under PPTA, that's when we go to Secretary who needs to concur with the Finding of Public Interest as a treatment of CTB, and then we go to PPTA steering committee.
04:42:40
The purpose of this first meeting with PPTA steering committee is to hear about the public sector option, the assumptions and how it has been developed, because we want them to hear everything that we have done so far and concur with us that they're on the right track.
04:42:56
If they concur with everything that we have done, and it seems that we are on the right track, that's when we come back to CTB and brief CTB on everything that we have done.
04:43:07
And by this time, we also have term sheets.
04:43:10
If we are moving forward with
04:43:13
PPT, under PPT with a P3 option, a public finance option, similar to 66.
04:43:18
We'll come back to CTB, we'll brief you on the term sheets, we'll brief you on everything that we have developed for finding a public interest and the steering committee.
04:43:29
And then if everyone is on the same page, procurement with initiative with a request for qualification issues.
04:43:41
One thing that I want to
04:43:43
mentioned before we go to the procurement stages that although the majority of projects that we anticipate to receive would be solace of the projects, in case there is an unsolace of the project, still we need to go through the same steps.
04:43:59
We have one more step in our project screening
04:44:04
of the United States.
04:44:22
And if we can make that case, and if it's in your mind that that idea is a good idea, still we need to go through all of the systems.
04:44:31
We need to go through finding the publications, we need to go through the steering committee, and then we need to put the project out for competition.
04:44:41
So again, although we don't really expect to get a lot of answers and proposals, but that flexibility is in the document, just in case we do something.
SPEAKER_08
04:44:50
Just a quick question.
04:44:52
So if you get an unsolicited proposal, is the state still going to develop its baseline after you receive that unsolicited proposal?
04:45:01
Yes.
SPEAKER_15
04:45:01
OK, thanks.
04:45:02
That's exactly what I meant.
04:45:04
We simply go through all the steps.
04:45:09
OK, so if everyone is on the same page, now we can go to the procurement phase, which, like what I mentioned before, it's
04:45:19
It's a process that starts with issuance of a request for qualifications.
04:45:26
This chart that you see is basically very similar to the process that we followed for I-66 project.
04:45:36
The way that it worked in that project, and that's exactly how we have in the chart, is that after we issue requests for qualifications, let's say that for simplicity we have two options.
04:45:46
We have a design-build option, which is our public sector option, and we have a design-build, finance, operate, maintain option, which is our P3 option.
04:45:55
We ask market to provide the receiving of qualifications under either one of these options or both options, if they want to.
04:46:03
We go through their qualifications, and if they're qualified, then we will ask them to submit to us a conceptual financial proposal indicating the price.
04:46:14
We get that information from them, exactly similar to what we did for our I-66 project.
04:46:19
We will look through all the information that they have submitted to us.
04:46:24
We don't specifically look at one bid.
04:46:26
We'll look at the range of numbers that we get from them.
04:46:29
We'll look at the numbers that we have developed ourselves and we present all of that information to CEO of Responsible Public Entity and then CEO needs to make a determination based on the information received from our team as well as information received from market that which one of those two options he believes provides best value to the Commonwealth.
04:46:52
In case of 6-6, for example, a DBFOM option was selected.
04:46:56
And that's how we proceeded with procurement.
04:47:00
We issued a request for proposals, which we called it a draft request for proposals.
04:47:05
And through multiple meetings with private sector, we finalized that document.
04:47:11
The draft request for proposal was uploaded on our website.
04:47:15
For a couple of months, it was there.
04:47:17
We received comments from localities, private sector, from anyone who was interested, basically, to read through a thousand pages of the document and provide comments to us.
04:47:27
and after that period of time we called the final RFP, we received proposals, we evaluated proposals and we presented the results again to CEO of Responsible Public Entity and he made a determination on best value proposals.
04:47:46
When he selected the best value proposal, another item that I want to highlight here is the audit that
04:47:57
We had to conduct.
04:48:00
Again, this isn't a code.
04:48:01
For our PT projects in the past, we have done an audit.
04:48:05
In that audit, basically, an independent auditor would be brought on board and look at the entire process and look at the comprehensive agreement, all the risks that mainly we have retained as a state.
04:48:16
And they give us their opinion that whether those risks are aligned with similar projects in the market or not.
04:48:23
And if something is out of ordinary, they need to raise the flag.
04:48:26
They provide that information to the CEO and he needs to validate his finding of public interest at that point of time.
04:48:36
Basically what that validation says is that the results that we have got at the end of procurement is consistent with
04:48:43
the term sheet that we had and with assumptions that we had when he made his finding of public interest and he presented the finding of public interest to the history community up front.
04:48:55
Morteza, who performs that audit?
04:48:59
It's an independent auditor that would bring on board someone who has not been involved with the project.
04:49:04
Independent.
04:49:06
It's not internal audit.
04:49:10
It's a consultant.
04:49:11
No, that's fine.
04:49:13
It should be a consultant who has not been involved in the procurement of the project because we need new sets of eyes.
04:49:18
Sometimes we get too close to the project that we might not be able to see something.
04:49:23
So we want to bring someone on board who has never worked on a project that's very set of eyes to look at that project and independently write that report.
SPEAKER_04
04:49:35
Is that information publicly available as well, the consultant's report?
SPEAKER_15
04:49:39
At some point it becomes available, of course.
04:49:43
Prior to financial close, it's a little bit hard because of the sensitivity around financial numbers, but after financial close, yes.
04:49:53
And then after CEO of responsible public entity validates his finding of public interest, usually they come to you and they brief you on major business terms of the contract one more time.
04:50:06
before comprehensive agreement is signed.
04:50:07
It's not required in the law, but it's a best practice that in the past VDOT has done.
04:50:16
When the contract is signed, again we go back to PPT steering committee and we brief them again on the results of the procurement and the contract.
04:50:27
It's not a decision point because their role is really the selection of the delivery model
04:50:34
which happens before we issue draft RFP.
04:50:39
At this stage is mainly just a confirmation that whatever decision you made is consistent with the result that we got.
04:50:46
So there's no decision.
04:50:54
So like what I said, not every project is gonna go through all of those steps.
04:51:00
Sometimes they may go through a modified version of this chart, but more or less, this is the general process that it will go through.
04:51:08
It's consistent with one within the I-66 project.
04:51:11
And I think both VDOT and industry now are familiar with the steps that we see in this chart.
04:51:19
So for next steps,
04:51:22
As I mentioned at the beginning of my presentation, the draft document, PPTA implementation manual, 2017 version, has been uploaded on our website.
04:51:33
It was uploaded earlier this month, I believe on September 6th.
04:51:37
We are seeking comments from anyone who is interested to review the process and provide comments until October 5th.
04:51:45
After that, after we have collected all the comments, we will go back and we will look at the comments and if there is a need for any modifications, we will be happy to do that.
04:51:53
We'll come back to you again in your October meeting, asking for a resolution that if you take an action, basically what the action would say is that it's going to encourage the two CEOs that we have here for DRPT and VDOT to go ahead and adopt the manual, 2017 version of the manual.
04:52:19
And with that, I would
04:52:22
Just ask them if anyone else has any comments or questions that they can answer today.
04:52:29
I'll be happy to do that.
04:52:30
What do you have as the private sector reacting to the changes?
04:52:34
As I mentioned earlier, it's not the first time that they see it.
04:52:38
I-66, we follow the exact same process.
04:52:41
And I think they're pretty familiar with it.
04:52:47
Initially, they got a lot of pushback when we were starting IC66 process, but we went through the process and everything worked out the way that it was supposed to work out.
04:52:55
And the other item that I should reiterate is that everything that I said today is already in the code, so we cannot not follow it.
SPEAKER_03
04:53:06
I can tell you, and I see one of our representatives from Transurban back there, Christian here, I think
04:53:14
It's been a process and it's been a constructive process and I had dinner with the CEO and Ms. Almond and they basically said they understood it and as long as we're consistent they understand where we're going and they've been great partners to work with on the 395 extension and 95
04:53:44
under these new proposals and stuff.
04:53:46
So I think a lot of it had to do, quite frankly, with just the fact changes or whatever, but also making sure, and that's why I made that comment, that it was gonna be fair to the private sector.
04:54:01
That's really a key part, that this is, I think the private sector, it's like you hear about the stock market and buying and interest rate, they just wanna know what the deal is.
04:54:13
and then they adjusted that.
04:54:15
So, you know, John, I think it's been well accepted and I'm, not only trans-urban others, we've worked with them and try to make them understanding why we had to do it.
04:54:27
I think it's in the best interest of not only the state, but them and the long-term health of P3s.
04:54:33
And in fact, we've heard from other states that have basically said, you know, demand-risk P3s were basically dead in the country.
04:54:41
But under this model, there's been interest in there.
04:54:45
So I can say, I don't want to say everybody's jumping up the door and saying, glad you did it.
04:54:52
I think it was the right thing to do for all the parties.
SPEAKER_15
04:54:55
So that'd be it.
04:54:58
Ms. Hines?
04:54:59
One other thing I can add there is another comment we have received from private sector is that they like certainty.
04:55:06
They like to, they don't want us to do our due diligence, our work.
04:55:10
before we really asked them to spend a lot of money to put a proposal together.
04:55:15
And with this process, a lot of that discussion happens up front, which reduces some of the political risk and the risk of not knowing exactly how the project is going to look like up front with the term sheet that we have, or with the process that we have, telling them exactly what the steps we're going through, and the committee and CEO making that decision early on, and everyone signing their name
04:55:41
on the decision that they're making.
04:55:42
I think they get a little bit better certainty that at least after that point, everything is going to be streamlined.
04:55:51
So that's something that they have told us again and again that you take your time, do whatever you need to do before you put the project out for competition and come to us and ask us to spend millions of dollars putting the proposal together.
04:56:06
Make sure that you have a project that
SPEAKER_03
04:56:12
I'll come to you.
04:56:13
I should have also mentioned, I mentioned Transurban Central, quite frankly, 66 also, big support.
04:56:19
I'd like to also throw out the fact that I know Central and Transurban have coordinated on transitioning on 66 and in 95 and all that.
04:56:28
So, look, the private sector, what they really want is the return of their money and on their money and the ability to, I think they all want to be good citizens, and I think this process
04:56:41
allows all that to come into play.
04:56:44
Because the last thing we want is a 50 or 60 year relationship where one side feels like it's taken advantage of.
04:56:53
And it's not fair to put some of these guys in a political position.
04:56:57
I'm quite comfortable.
04:56:58
The other thing was the right thing to do, but some of the partners in the downtown midtown tunnel, they had their issues and should have been called out, but some of the things
04:57:09
they were just doing what their fiduciary responsibility called them to do we should never put them in that position but we did and it became a political very political so that's not good for the product sector either.
SPEAKER_08
04:57:24
Thanks Mr. Secretary.
04:57:26
I'm reflecting a little bit that you know on the tail end of this process now up in Northern Virginia and the late arrival on the table of
04:57:35
And so if I look at this whole development plan here, the question I have for wearing the public hat is where are those key moments when the public should be surely tuned in?
04:57:59
Because once a decision is made, the train has left the station a little bit, no pun intended.
04:58:05
But if there are some places where we really want those local elected bodies to check in on our plan, is everything we would like here if this is really going to happen?
04:58:20
So not saying it all has to be included in the Commonwealth's plan, but where's that moment?
SPEAKER_03
04:58:27
That's where I made the comment about we put in policy, but there are just certain things like who the key stakeholders are in contact.
04:58:35
And as you recall, we did that on 66, where we went and met with them up front, let them know the locals and where we're going and the whole bit.
04:58:47
So that's one of the things that those key players could change from deal to deal.
04:58:52
So it's hard to put them in a process
SPEAKER_08
04:58:56
There aren't moments, though, where that's where you need to hear from, regardless of the order.
SPEAKER_03
04:59:01
Well, let me finish.
04:59:03
Also, there is an outreach, public outreach, and maybe where's Ms. Johnson?
04:59:07
She might be out taking a call, where we can overlay, because this is not about the public input.
04:59:13
This is just about the procedures that the state goes through.
04:59:17
This is not going to supplant anything that the agency like VDOT or DRPT and reaching out to the public in that regard.
04:59:25
You know, obviously Morteza mentioned all these documents are online.
04:59:32
We post them.
04:59:32
We let people know they're online.
04:59:34
There's public comment periods.
04:59:36
Everything about the process is open to the public.
04:59:40
I don't think it's, quite frankly, you know, there is also part of the public's responsibility, the local, to understand what's going on.
04:59:51
You say some of the
04:59:53
Lake, things on 66.
04:59:54
It's been no secret about the bike path on 66 for two years.
04:59:59
It's been no secret about some of the things.
05:00:02
So I'm with you, and I'm cognizant of that.
05:00:05
I think that's something that really is upon the people doing the deal, knowing when it needs to be successful instead of having it put in there.
05:00:12
But certainly, right up front, the idea ought to be vetted, just like we've done several times.
05:00:18
certainly the term we went through the major term before we made them with the local officials and then made them public for public comment so those are things that come to mind and certainly if something were to change to go back and talk with the local officials on in that so but i'd be hard there's no doubt there are points it'd be hard to full press when those should be made other than those few that i mentioned
SPEAKER_08
05:00:46
I think organizes how localities and neighbors respond and that's really my point is this if this is the manual and it's mostly meant for the private sector that's fine but we do have an expectation that there will be public outreach that there will be a plan etc.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
05:01:11
Our NEPA process on, I use examples of 66 and HRBT where the NEPA document is right there sort of just in time in terms of a project.
05:01:24
We don't have a NEPA document that's been laying out there for a long period of time.
05:01:29
So those two projects, a lot of outreach went on during the NEPA process and a lot of decisions in terms of scope and scale were resolved
05:01:41
I can tell you the time to any changes of significance is not during the procurement process.
05:01:50
Once we put out our term sheets and all the public outreach that's led up to that point, once we get into a bidding environment to go back, or even worse, once we receive bids, any sort of significant changes in scope or scale or terms of the project become very difficult.
SPEAKER_03
05:02:11
and plus that doesn't even include the outreach over and above them related to the federal policies and I remember having meetings in Northern Virginia where I think there were hundreds if not thousands of V-Trap mailers and the whole bit and you know this some of this well we didn't know about this then I just found that it was just not being up front but I mean I agree the concept's well taken
SPEAKER_08
05:02:37
I really think the more we can focus people on once the term CHEAP is set, then we're going into a different kind of environment.
05:02:46
And so put your energy in before that.
05:02:48
The more that message can be contained, the better off everybody is in the process.
SPEAKER_03
05:02:53
Yeah, because that's a key point.
05:02:54
Whenever we go, we're in procurement.
05:02:57
If we have to change it, then we got to go back to the process as Morteza said.
05:03:01
But number two, after procurement,
05:03:04
These are not just going to your local legislator and say, I want you to change it.
05:03:08
These have compensation events.
05:03:10
It's controlled by contractual law.
05:03:13
And it's not the normal relationship where you can go vote.
05:03:16
We can go vote, but it's cost to us and that stuff.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
05:03:20
Mr. Kilpatrick.
05:03:21
And I think the 66 example.
05:03:24
We are continuing to have outreach and design public hearings that we'll be going through and being related to the final design of the project.
05:03:32
And as the Secretary spoke last night on a specific issue of the trail, we're continuing to work with the community to find opportunities to isolate the trail from the highway.
05:03:43
Because that's just a goal that many people have.
05:03:47
But fundamentally, we said from the beginning, we're going to limit the right-of-way impact.
05:03:53
So to the extent that design details can fit within a public broader tenets of that draft term sheet,
05:04:03
with individual communities and individuals, but if it's something that is outside of what I'll call the original intended purpose of the project. And one of the big things on 66 was to limit or eliminate right of way impacts outside the right of way. So that's where it gets sort of well beyond.
SPEAKER_03
05:04:30
This is a broader point, I'll stop on this, but there is some responsibilities now for the citizens to have some idea of what's going on around them.
05:04:44
And in terms of being a little more than just saying I didn't know about it.
05:04:50
That's called citizenship engagement.
05:04:52
And I'm not suggesting, we're not trying to hide the ball at all here.
05:04:56
I mean, if you hadn't read the paper,
05:04:59
or listen to the TV or seeing all the different things that went on, then you were just a person who chose not to pay attention.
05:05:10
And I don't mean that to be critical, but I do think this is a bigger thing in our, quite frankly, our democracy.
05:05:19
There is some personal responsibility that is required here of being a citizen and understanding what's going on in your community.
05:05:27
And I understand that most people don't react until it becomes a reality.
05:05:31
There are touch points.
05:05:34
But as I said, and Charlie mentioned, we changed this project significantly from public input, significantly from it.
05:05:44
This was not something that was just drawn to this the way it is.
05:05:47
It changed quite a bit from public input.
05:05:51
But there does come a point where it's got to be done because it's time to move on.
SPEAKER_07
05:05:56
In my mind, this is a way of, we're deciding how we're going to pay for it.
05:06:05
It's a procurement process.
05:06:06
But the design and the scope of the process goes through exactly the same process as we would for any project.
05:06:13
So there were so many design elements, all the alternatives we went through, whether it's transit, pedestrian traffic, the whole thing, and putting the design together.
05:06:27
Yeah, that's right.
05:06:30
But look, there are
SPEAKER_03
05:06:52
I get it that because some of those factors are very very sensitive to these are big to localities for instance how close is it coming to my home we have those but you also have what are the tolls going to be there are
05:07:14
things that these are pretty complicated projects.
05:07:17
So there is a duty upon us to do it.
05:07:20
You're right.
05:07:22
You're both right.
SPEAKER_07
05:07:23
And I'm agreeing with you.
05:07:24
And I think one of the things that Ms. Himes has brought forward a couple of times is standardizing our public engagement so that people understand throughout this process.
05:07:34
It's not just for PPTA.
05:07:37
It is letting people know we deliberately want to engage with the public to work
05:07:44
So I was going to go back to a point that I think you bring up often.
SPEAKER_08
05:07:51
It's protection for the agency, honestly, to have as much clarity as possible around who's making the decision and at what point is the conversation going on.
SPEAKER_03
05:08:01
I don't think anybody in the last four years has said that VDOT and DRPT, based on 66 and a half months, that the agencies aren't engaged in trying to get their information.
05:08:11
but I will say there will be some people that simply are against the project and no matter what and all we can do with those people is say explain to them why and I think that's our responsibility but at the end of the day it is about moving the projects forward.
SPEAKER_08
05:08:32
I would also say for those people who are never going to support Mr. Secretary the best defense we have is to show them all the opportunities they have
05:08:41
to participate, and then we chose not to ask questions.
SPEAKER_03
05:08:45
Hard for me to listen to someone say they didn't understand the contract when it's been posted online for two years and didn't take the chance to read it.
05:08:54
I mean, particularly an elected official.
05:08:57
That doesn't go over very well with me, but I only have a few more months left.
05:09:02
I'll have to read that.
05:09:03
So that's it.
SPEAKER_04
05:09:04
All right.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
05:09:05
Any more questions before we work?
SPEAKER_04
05:09:06
Mr. Kasprowicz.
05:09:07
One more question.
05:09:08
Morteza, at the end of financial close,
05:09:10
Is there any information that was gathered during the competitive process that remains confidential?
SPEAKER_15
05:09:17
Certain information may still be confidential.
05:09:19
Can you describe what that is?
05:09:21
Well, based on the code, if there is a trade secret, for example, that one of the teams has shared with us, or if there is certain financial information about the company that needs to be kept confidential.
05:09:35
But there are certain elements that if we need to keep it confidential,
05:09:38
We need to consult with representatives from OAG and go exactly to the section of the code that allows us to keep it confidential.
05:09:46
Otherwise, we need to release it.
SPEAKER_04
05:09:48
Is that process described in the implementation manual?
SPEAKER_15
05:09:51
That's not in the implementation manual.
05:09:53
Actually, I'll take that back.
05:09:55
We do have, I believe, if I remember right, we do have a section that talks about Freedom of Information Act.
05:10:03
And in each one of our contracts,
05:10:06
Not contracts request for proposals or request for qualifications that we usually put out. They have a section that specifically says What force of the proposal can be kept confidential what force cannot become usually the line is what is it? That's true on any procurer It is trade secret issue is one that is problematic in prior Well, uh, look, uh,
SPEAKER_03
05:10:36
Yeah, you're right.
05:10:40
But it was not because, it was problematic because they didn't do it.
05:10:44
It wasn't because of law.
SPEAKER_04
05:10:45
But I'd like to be clear, this is a public manual.
05:10:48
You can at least articulate that and not require that somebody go to another source to identify what might be the proprietary information at the end of the project or process it to help
05:10:59
just generically described as you just thought.
SPEAKER_03
05:11:01
Or the nature, because I could think of the nature of those types of things.
05:11:04
Because there could be some, I'll tell you what else would be confidential until we accept a bid, is they may have something that is very, very positive to their bid winning.
05:11:15
They certainly want the other bidders to know that they're thinking that.
05:11:18
Yeah, I'm speaking post close.
05:11:20
Yeah.
05:11:21
Oh, post close.
05:11:21
Post close, yeah.
05:11:22
I'll show you a very short list.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
05:11:24
Yeah.
SPEAKER_15
05:11:25
And the way that the process works is that when they submit their bid there is a section that in that section they need to identify what force of the proposal should be confidential and why.
05:11:40
Then if they go and consult with AG's office and if they concur
05:11:46
I can think about a lot of different instances that we actually pushed back on it and said, no, this doesn't meet the requirements of the code, so it can't be confidential.
SPEAKER_03
05:11:56
The one that has gotten the most attention is the algorithm used for the dynamic pricing.
05:12:05
All the concessions, I believe that to be proprietary.
05:12:10
So what we do is have the right to automate and all that type of stuff, but that's probably the one where everybody
05:12:17
I would like to see, but I quite frankly believe it falls directly in the proprietary role.
05:12:24
I would agree, that sounds like a treat.
05:12:26
We've had several laws and that simply is, but what we do have is the right to go on it.
05:12:34
If we think they're not applying it correctly, we have the right to do that.
05:12:40
That's the one, you're right, post-close, and that's from the very one we started.
05:12:45
These were all done in secret.
05:12:46
We said, we're going to oppose the torture.
05:12:50
There's nothing secret about this.
05:12:51
So I think you'll find the default is that it's disclosed.
05:12:57
It's only, as Morteza said, that they can show an overriding thing.
05:13:02
If it's any greater, the Attorney General's got to say it.
05:13:04
Otherwise, it's always closed.
SPEAKER_04
05:13:06
Yeah, I understand.
05:13:06
I just think we benefit from putting it in the implementation section.
SPEAKER_03
05:13:14
Any other comments or discussion?
05:13:17
Casey, good job, thank you very much.
05:13:20
And hopefully we'll be using a lot more of this process.
05:13:26
I think we're going to need to deliver the transportation department right here.
SPEAKER_13
05:13:30
Mr. Secretary, I think it will behoove us to, as we approach the inaugural use of the I-66 inside the beltway, since it's us and not
05:13:44
P. Threepartner, in this case, that we again go to the airways and the media to explain dynamic price at its hold.
05:13:56
Because I still think it's something that the public doesn't understand.
05:14:00
I know Transurban goes out of its way to try to make sure the public does.
05:14:04
But there are going to be new users now coming on that haven't used it before on 66.
05:14:11
And you're right, the big question mark
05:14:14
Although it's proprietary, it's how the sum of those numbers flash when you see certain conditions on roadways.
SPEAKER_03
05:14:22
The good news is, other than inside in that way, is that there's always a choice.
05:14:28
But I agree with you, and I think that we had that meeting this morning because this is the first time that VDOT will be doing dynamic pricing, and Mr. Kilpatrick all there, just so you know,
05:14:41
We're not going to open that until we're damn sure it works right.
05:14:46
I think that was the gist of the meeting.
05:14:50
Speaking of that, speaking of I-64 express lanes, we have Mr. DeBruhl to talk about the benefits of this besides having a choice.
05:15:01
Money is available for multi-modal transportation.
SPEAKER_06
05:15:04
Exactly, and those funds are all about providing a choice to folks traveling in some of the most congested corridors in the Commonwealth.
05:15:11
So for the past couple of months, we've been working closely with Hampton Roads Transit to look at some options around providing some enhanced transit service using toll revenues in Hampton Roads as the I-64 express lanes come online later this year.
05:15:26
There have been prior investments in transit service using toll revenues in Hampton Roads, primarily related to the Elizabeth River crossings project.
05:15:35
There were three bus routes and some ferry service that have been funded through toll revenues.
05:15:39
They've been really successful.
05:15:41
in providing an alternative to the tolled tunnel facilities down there connecting Fort Smith and Norfolk.
05:15:47
They've been successful already and with the redevelopment of the waterside district of Norfolk we expect the number of boardings and the use of those services to increase in the future.
05:15:57
As a refresher, the location of the 64 express lanes is basically along I-64 on the south side of Hampton Roads between I-564 and I-264.
05:16:07
So we've been looking, in order to make sure we're providing that nexus to the toll payer, we've been looking for transit services that serve basically the same corridor, similar corridors in travel movements.
05:16:20
There are a couple of routes that we've looked at in particular thus far with HRT.
05:16:24
Both of them are what they call max routes, so they're more like a commuter service, and they both connect the south side with the peninsula via the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
05:16:35
What we have looked at today is how toll revenues could be used to increase the level of service on those routes and in that corridor because the tolls are peak hour tolls in Hampton Roads and we're looking at only applying transit funded through toll revenues during the peak hour and we think that the peak hour frequency of those two routes in particular could be almost doubled for additional trips daily, two in the AM and two in the PM to increase transit availability in the corridor.
05:17:07
Looking at cost, what does it cost to do that or what are our options?
05:17:12
We think that we would have up to maybe three and a half million dollars to help support transit in the corridor using tolls.
05:17:20
There's a capital cost associated with adding those routes, additional vehicles, and then an ongoing operating maintenance cost.
05:17:28
We do see that it would be beneficial to add additional routes.
05:17:32
We do have some additional modeling and data analysis that's going in there, but
05:17:37
Just taking a very high-level look, we think that adding those additional trips and making that connection between the South Side and Newport News Shipbuilding, which is a major employer on the peninsula that is very supportive of transit, will bring benefits to congestion in that corridor and what is certified on the hotlines.
05:17:57
So in terms of next steps, we're going to work over the next few weeks to complete that technical analysis, make sure that we've got
05:18:06
Everything lines up to come back to you with a final recommendation on what services we think would be most effective using those toll revenues.
05:18:14
We're also working on developing an agreement that would guide the use of that funding modeled off of I-66 inside the guideline that would include some performance metrics, allow monitoring and reporting on an annual basis to the Commonwealth Transportation Board, and we would be bringing that back to the CTB for approval later this year.
05:18:35
How can we answer any questions?
05:18:47
The services that are already in place, it is an impressive number of riders.
05:18:56
It's a real strong connection, particularly with the ferry between Portsmouth and Norfolk.
05:19:01
And we expect that to increase now that we have the Otterside District that's been developed.
05:19:13
That's what we really want to hang in on the benefits for these two routes that we're looking at to make sure that we've got that ridership number correct.
05:19:40
Right now we're doing some basic calculations to get into ridership for these services that would be in the 64 corridor.
05:19:47
We actually think that by looking at modeling and more of the origin and destination of the trips specific to those routes, we'll actually have better data and we'll see better benefits of what we're seeing thus far.
SPEAKER_07
05:20:12
At this point, none of the money that's raised by the regional, the Hampton Bridge region can be used for transit, right?
SPEAKER_03
05:20:22
None of the regional monies can be used to support transit.
05:20:26
Right.
SPEAKER_07
05:20:26
And I just wonder, you know, if people were to see these figures and the number of people choosing transit.
05:20:33
To me, it really shows how important it is.
SPEAKER_03
05:20:43
I think in the foreseeable future the BIM monies are all booked up on specific projects.
05:20:52
The whole benefits to these programs is using the current infrastructure
SPEAKER_06
05:21:16
Shorty just christened a new ferry within the last couple of months.
05:21:20
It's helping out.
SPEAKER_03
05:21:25
OK.
05:21:26
Cool.
05:21:26
Thank you very much.
05:21:27
You now are going to do the vanpools for us?
SPEAKER_06
05:21:29
I'll do the vanpools for you.
05:21:30
Another very brief presentation.
05:21:39
So efficient that I can't come.
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
05:21:44
Here we go.
SPEAKER_06
05:21:45
Hurry.
05:21:46
Next item for you is an update on our Vanpool VA implementation.
05:21:51
If you'll recall last September when you were in Fredericksburg, we first briefed you on a statewide Vanpool initiative that we were putting together based on some budget language that set aside funding for two years of just shy of $2 million a year.
05:22:08
out of DRPT special programs to create a VAMPLE program that's dedicated to increasing the number of people we meet through the most congested borders in Commonwealth through enhancing VAMPLE.
05:22:19
And the whole idea behind the program is for it to become a self-funded initiative after these two years of startup funding by basically turning those VAMPLE operating miles into revenue miles that are reported to FTA and increase the transit funding that comes back to the Commonwealth.
05:22:37
And so we've been working, we had worked for a few months before that presentation, but we've continued to work since then with commuter assistance agencies, transit providers, and with the actual operators around the Commonwealth to refine that program.
05:22:51
And we are giving you an update today because we're actually ready to make our first allocation under the program.
05:22:58
As a reminder, we really have three key components that we're trying to accomplish with the program.
05:23:02
The first is to expand or to increase
05:23:06
The vanpool subsidy, different programs around the state use a subsidy for vanpool.
05:23:11
Basically for vanpool providers, it's an incentive for them to report on their ridership, report on the miles that they operate, only in exchange for getting a subsidy to reduce their operating costs for their riders.
05:23:23
We get that data and then turn it into transit funding when it comes back to support more vanpools.
05:23:29
Another item that came up in our development of the program was more branding and marketing statewide.
05:23:35
and developing that brand, we are working on that now, as well as improved ride matching with longer commutes and commutes that really cross across multiple metro areas.
05:23:47
There's a need for an improved ride matching system and we're working actually with the Roanoke Valley MPO to help put together that ride matching platform and software.
05:23:58
So the real big update for you is that we've been working
05:24:02
Here in Northern Virginia with VANFUL Alliance, that is basically a partnership between the Northern Virginia Transportation Commission, Potomac-Rappahannock Transportation Commission, and the George Washington Regional Commission.
05:24:17
So just thank everything from Fredericksburg, one up through Northern Virginia.
05:24:21
They have a really robust VANFUL program that's been in place for a number of years.
05:24:26
Their program has their current stipend for that data set at $200 a month.
05:24:32
We've been working with them to brainstorm a little bit about how can we get more van pools in the corridor.
05:24:39
There's so much congestion on 95.
05:24:41
We have the express lanes.
05:24:43
How do we use this more effectively to get more people on ridesharing arrangements?
05:24:48
So working with them, we've come up with a little package where they would increase their stipend for new van pools from $200 to $400 a month.
05:24:57
That reduces that cost for the folks that are participating in the van pools.
05:25:01
But we did work with them to put a kind of a stop gap on there.
05:25:04
Van pools tend to be a little cannibalistic.
05:25:07
If somebody sees that there's a better deal, they go hop on a different van pool.
05:25:11
So in order to qualify for this program, that new van pool that qualifies for that stipend would have to have 75% new riders to the program in order to qualify.
05:25:21
So we don't want to just create new van pools that won't be equal riders.
05:25:24
We want to bring new people into ridesharing agreements.
05:25:31
So PRTC has a, they maintain a really detailed database, and so when you register to be part of one of their van pools, they know who you are.
05:25:40
And so they're able to track folks, is it 100% foolproof?
05:25:45
It's probably a few that are going to slip through the cracks, but I think they're pretty good at monitoring that to make sure that those van pools would be actual new van pools in order to qualify for those.
05:25:54
So PRTC will collect that data.
05:25:57
They'll report their VANPL data, which they are already doing and seeing a really good return to the region with FTA funding.
05:26:04
Then it takes about a two-year lag before you see that data have a corresponding increase in 53 or 73 allocations.
05:26:13
So this funding of $1.4 million will help offset that two years until they're
05:26:19
The data would go in and then they would see that much or probably more come back in the increased transit revenues.
05:26:28
In addition to working with PRTC, which we'll have an action item on tomorrow's agenda to approve that allocation, the major line item for this vanpool initiative is in the Six-Year Program, but the breakout to PRTC is not.
05:26:41
So that's what we have for you tomorrow as an action item.
05:26:44
But we've also been working on some other Vanpool Virginia activities
05:26:50
under the guise of the program, but without touching those funds that were set aside.
05:26:56
We had already been working with Hampton Roads Transit on enhancements to their handful.
05:27:00
We've had a grant agreement that just hadn't been executed yet.
05:27:04
And we've actually negotiated very similar terms to what we're doing with PRTC into the Hampton Roads Agreement.
05:27:11
So we're pursuing the same types of activities in Hampton Roads.
05:27:15
And as I mentioned already, we are also working with the Roanoke Valley Allegheny Regional Commission or the Roanoke MPO to develop statewide ride matching tools that will be available to everybody statewide.
05:27:26
So we're partnering with one MPO, but we're actually going to have a platform that's going to be available to everybody to help with that statewide ride matching.
05:27:36
In terms of next steps, we're still doing a lot of outreach and coordination.
05:27:41
To implement the program, we're working with those regional commuter assistance agencies and vanpool operators to get more folks involved and increase ride sharing around the Commonwealth.
05:27:51
We're still working on the development of some statewide branding and some marketing tools.
05:27:55
That's one thing that we've heard pretty much universally from everybody.
05:27:58
The more that we can give them in terms of tools to help with marketing and help with that outreach, that really helps their programs advance and succeed.
05:28:07
And then we're also working on some data tools.
05:28:10
to try to streamline how that data gets from that vanpool operator back to the commuter assistance agency or the transit agency to get reported.
05:28:19
So in some cases that's done electronically and others it's done on paper.
05:28:24
So we want to try to make that easy so that we can account for all those miles and bring more transit funds to the state.
05:28:31
With that, I'm happy to answer any additional questions.
SPEAKER_03
05:28:40
All right, great programs.
05:28:42
Thank you very much.
05:28:44
Mr. Latimer, I want it to be known that because you are presenting Jeremy and Mr. Williams did not come.
05:28:57
This is his favorite rail industrious.
SPEAKER_10
05:29:00
Yes, this is a rail industrious.
05:29:02
Good to see you.
05:29:10
We received a Rail Industrial Access application from Steel Dynamics in Roanoke.
05:29:16
They are located on the north and southern line.
05:29:21
This is an expansion of the facility, and they will be investing $28 million into the expansion.
05:29:26
Right now they have a melt facility, so they received a lot of recycling materials by rail car.
05:29:33
They melted down, and then they have a rolling mill.
05:29:35
Right now the rolling mill outpaces the melt facility, so they're having to shut down operations.
05:29:45
So that is an integral part of the expansion.
05:29:47
It'll be shipping the rebar to industries and service centers across the United States, Canada, and Mexico.
05:29:56
And rail traffic is expected to increase about 2,000 rail cars within the first year.
05:30:02
It's a 40% increase from what they do now.
05:30:06
The application is for $450,000.
05:30:08
Again, the total capital expenditure on this overall project will be $20 million.
05:30:13
Cost overruns on the rail project and 450,000 will be the responsibility of the applicant.
05:30:20
They will bring along 12 new jobs at this facility.
05:30:22
40% of the overall shipping inbound and outbound will be by rail.
05:30:28
And the application score is 64 out of 100 points.
05:30:31
So it's a pretty strong application.
05:30:33
The way our revised policy works, they have to make a minimum threshold to maintain their above 50 points.
05:30:39
And so that minimum threshold
05:30:40
will be at least 100 new rail cars, so they plan to fire and see that.
05:30:46
With that, are there any questions?
SPEAKER_03
05:31:15
Thank you, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
SPEAKER_17
05:31:36
It's not something magnificent, it's just that I have
05:31:41
Potentially three and a half more months left and the Commissioner wanted to make sure that I got before this Board at once in this current role, but I do want to make everybody aware that I have presented to the Board before, not just in this role.
05:31:55
It was memorable, I could tell you.
05:31:57
Yes, it was, sir.
05:31:58
It was very memorable.
05:31:59
Another one of those things I'll take with me the rest of my life.
05:32:09
The purpose of this briefing is to make the Board aware of and seek your approval for VDOT to enter into an Energy Performance Contract to replace several roadway lightings along our roadway in commuter parking lots and rest areas.
05:32:29
Make sure I know how to use this little thing here.
05:32:33
All right.
05:32:35
Some background, VDOT currently has
05:32:37
approximately 50,000 roadway lighting fixtures. And the majority of these lighting fixtures are high pressure sodium light bulbs. They basically will last approximately five years. And our goal is to move to LED lights. LED lights consume 50% less energy and they can last as much as three times longer than the conventional light bulbs. Things that are all out.
05:33:08
A few things that are helping us move towards that is the 2017 Appropriations Act requires agencies to move to LED lighting where they deem it to be cost efficient.
05:33:22
In addition, Executive Order 31 requires state agencies to seek ways to reduce energy consumption and to use energy performance contracts.
05:33:33
And I'll talk a little bit more about what those energy performance contracts are.
05:33:40
Based on this, the department developed a three-prong strategy to move towards these goals.
05:33:46
The first was that any future roadway projects that had roadway lighting, we would move to using LED lights on those projects.
05:33:57
We would also begin to move towards replacing existing lights with LED lights through attrition.
05:34:06
This means if we have
05:34:08
E. Scott Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine
05:34:32
So what is an energy performance contract?
05:34:35
These are energy saving improvements that are financed outside of the agency's normal budgeting process.
05:34:43
So basically this is where the department will receive a loan and the loan will be paid back through the savings approved through the energy savings.
05:34:55
These contracts are being administered through energy service contractors.
05:35:02
And they're the ones that are responsible for coming in and evaluating opportunities for providing energy savings.
05:35:09
They do that through an audit process.
05:35:12
If we agree that that's a reasonable approach, then what we do is we move into negotiations with the contractors to come up with what we believe is a reasonable price and scope of work to be performed.
05:35:26
And then finally, the ESCO contractor, they're responsible for
05:35:31
Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
05:35:52
This program is administered through three different agencies.
05:35:57
First, the Department of General Services is responsible for procuring the ESCO contractors.
05:36:04
And then once they procure, the Department of Mines, Mineral, and Energy is responsible for managing the program.
05:36:10
And Treasury works with agencies on ensuring funding is provided.
05:36:17
Some examples of some energy performance contracts.
05:36:22
Since 2001, over $760 million in energy performance contracts have been implemented throughout the Commonwealth.
05:36:30
One of the more recent ones is the Department of Motor Vehicles got some renovations in their headquarters, and those renovations cost about $6.9 million, and under normal circumstances, their budgeting process would not have allowed them to make these improvements.
05:36:47
and they were guaranteed a $284,000 savings annually on these contracts.
05:36:55
Not only are these being used here in Virginia, these are being used throughout the nation.
05:37:00
For example, North Carolina just entered into a ESCO contract with a train who is the vendor that we will be entering into a contract with and it was a pretty large contract similar to the one that we were
05:37:19
A little background and timeline on this.
05:37:21
We began negotiating with Trane in late 2014-2015 time period.
05:37:27
This initially started off at looking at our facilities, our two central office buildings, to see if there were opportunities to think about energy efficiencies in those buildings.
05:37:38
Trane did an evaluation of the buildings and through that evaluation, they determined that there were savings, but the savings would not
05:37:47
P.A.
05:37:47
for the cost of the work that was required to upgrade our facilities.
05:37:52
And based on that, we moved from looking at our facilities to looking at opportunities in our way-to-way lighting, and that is how we got here.
05:38:01
So what we'll be doing is we'll be seeking CTB approval, and I apologize.
05:38:07
Normally, we come to the CTB the month prior to us asking the CTB to take action.
05:38:12
But due to time constraints as it relates to this contract and vehicle, this has to be finalized by the end of this month in order to take advantage of the current contracts that are out there.
05:38:26
So we will be looking for CTB approval tomorrow during the action meeting.
05:38:32
And after that, then we would have to then move forward with getting approval
05:38:39
from Treasury, and then finally from the Governor's Office before the end of this month.
05:38:52
The scope of this project is basically to upgrade over 9,600 lights along our roadways and our rest areas and our commuter parking lots.
05:39:05
This includes putting, also installing a
05:39:08
control system, and this control system will allow us to monitor the energy savings, and also it will allow us to bring about further energy savings by being able to adjust the lighting based on time of day to ensure that we are not using any more energy than we need to. And this was a 15-year contract that was financed over 15 years, and so this will be monitored and managed over the next 15 years.
05:39:39
The cost of this project, the total cost is a little over $20 million.
05:39:43
$15.9 million is for the cost of construction.
05:39:47
There is a million dollars for the measurement and verification of energy usage throughout the life of it, and then $3.4 million in interest that would be paid back on the money.
05:40:00
The projected savings is a little over $27 million, where $18.3 million
05:40:06
E. Scott Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine
05:40:32
went through a very extensive process to ensure that the savings that were being projected, we felt comfortable with those savings and we felt that we would be able to achieve them and that the price for the construction was a reasonable price for the work that we would perform.
05:40:50
And based on that, and when we look at that, we look at what the department would have had to do, this process will allow us to have this work completed much sooner
05:41:03
And again, if we were to take this on, we would have to take money from our maintenance program to finance this.
05:41:10
This has no impact on our current budgeting and budgeting process.
05:41:14
And so based on this and the anticipated savings that we anticipate seeing with this project, we would be seeking CTBs approval.
SPEAKER_03
05:41:29
Before we open it up, how guaranteed is guaranteed?
05:41:36
What are the outs that say we don't get this?
05:41:41
What are the contractors outs?
SPEAKER_17
05:41:45
You mean as far as the contract or the savings, anticipated savings?
SPEAKER_03
05:41:48
I'm assuming the savings are you've done due diligence and good work.
05:41:53
But let's assume for whatever reason they don't happen.
05:41:57
And you say they're guaranteed by the lighting contractor.
05:42:01
I'm saying, in what cases, if we don't get it, does the contractor have an out to not guarantee these savings?
SPEAKER_17
05:42:08
I'm not aware that basically the contractor would be responsible for paying any difference between the savings that are being documented through the Department of Environmental Energy.
SPEAKER_03
05:42:19
Well, OK, I got that.
05:42:20
But I mean, let's say installation.
05:42:22
Can they claim it and install it right now?
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
05:42:32
There is a fundamental challenge of dissolving how much we spend on energy on our roadway lighting because of the nature of how roadway lighting has been installed.
05:42:53
There's a number of, sometimes they're collective meters, sometimes it's unmetered surfaces.
05:42:58
Frankly, these things have been developed over the last 50 years.
05:43:02
E. Doolittle Jr.
05:43:31
Yes, sir.
SPEAKER_17
05:43:37
I'm comfortable with our ability to quantify that.
05:43:44
And the other part of this is that the contract, if there's a wiring, the contract is to replace the fixtures on the existing poles that we have.
05:43:54
And should there be a wiring issue, then the department would be responsible for paying for the cost of fixing the wiring or any issues that are there.
05:44:02
So part of this contract, there's a half a million dollar contingency in the project to help offset any of those anticipated costs that may be occurred.
05:44:12
Quinn, are we comfortable the contractor will be around 15 years from now?
05:44:18
It's Trane, and so I would hope Trane would be around for the next
05:44:35
The way this process works is the energy performance contractors are procured through the Department of General Services.
05:44:50
So there's a list of contractors that they have that are approved.
05:44:54
What we did is we sat down and went through each one of the contractors, met with them,
05:45:00
And from that, we selected the contractor that we believe would be best at meeting our needs as far as reducing our energy costs.
05:45:11
That component of it was at the beginning.
05:45:16
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_04
05:45:18
Before you even knew what you were going to be replacing.
05:45:24
Yes, ma'am.
05:45:25
Mr. Secretary, I have no issue with the basic economics of this.
05:45:29
I did have a chance to get a briefing from Mr. Elgate before today's presentation and found that it's anticipated that the light fixtures that would be used in this contract are in the 4,000 Kelvin color rendering range.
05:45:45
I guess it's not obvious, but I think embedded in making a financial decision, which is a serious public health decision that we've been making as well.
05:45:55
And it's not well publicized because it's
05:46:07
I'd like to read pieces of because I think they're important.
05:46:12
I'll start with the first paragraph.
05:46:13
It says, a groundbreaking report recently released by the AMA Science and Public Health Committee affirms the suspected impacts to health and the environment caused by light emitting diodes that emit excessive amounts of blue light.
05:46:31
It further states that the board or the committee unanimously
05:46:36
approved by representatives of the association, supports concerns raised by at least a number of other organizations as it relates to the health issues associated with LED lights. The second part I think is even more compelling. It says that while the AME report supports the use of LED lighting in order to reduce energy consumption, almost like we're discussing, the use of fossil fuel, it recognizes that some LED lights are harmful. Thank you. Thank you.
05:47:05
F. Kupferberg Jr., John Kupferberg Jr., John F. Kupferberg Jr.,
05:47:27
that they make specific recommendations and says that these include requiring property issues with outdoor lighting considering adaptive controls which this project has and limiting the correlated color temperature of outdoor lighting to a maximum of 3,000.
05:47:47
This is a controversial issue.
05:47:49
It's very much in the technical realm at this point.
05:47:54
But I think to make a decision for a 15-year period of time
05:47:57
That would lock us in to 4,000 Kelvin fixtures based on findings from the AMA, which are just about a year old now, is the decision that we need to give serious consideration to.
05:48:10
This is available online.
05:48:11
I can circulate it if you'd like to look.
05:48:13
There's a huge body of knowledge that's developing on this, and I think it's been fairly conclusive in the 4,000 Kelvin range and above
05:48:25
So I just bring this to the table because I think this isn't a financial decision we're making.
05:48:34
When we vote on this, this is really a public health decision that we'll be making.
05:48:38
It's a serious one.
05:48:40
The AMA took this decision and the recommendations very seriously and published them urgently because the issue is so relevant in today's world.
SPEAKER_03
05:48:53
Is the rating required for safety?
05:49:00
In other words, 4,000.
05:49:03
Is that what you guys need for the alone?
05:49:08
Is it necessary to light the roadway?
SPEAKER_17
05:49:11
Yes, sir.
05:49:12
Yes, sir.
05:49:13
And we have looked at with the American Medical Association.
05:49:18
And in addition, the US Department
05:49:23
that doesn't quite concur with them.
05:49:27
And so this is a topic that is still being discussed and being debated.
05:49:33
While that's being debated, some of the things that we're going to try to make sure that we're not going too far down this path is in our commuter parking lots, what we are going to do is install the 3,000 because those are near residential areas or could be near hotels where people are sleeping.
05:49:53
The other thing that we do is we try to shield that light from spillover from our roadway networks.
05:49:59
In addition, if we see locations along our roadway where these lights look like they could be near residential areas, we are going to try to move to those 3,000 Kelvin lighting systems.
05:50:14
The challenge that we have is, again, there's a certain amount of aluminum.
05:50:18
This contract is just to replace the fixture on the existing poles.
05:50:23
And in order for us to make sure that we got the appropriate lighting, if we go to a 3000, it may have an impact on that and we may have to go back and look at whether this would require additional poles to be placed to ensure that we got proper spacing.
05:50:38
I'm not sure, I mean, we will continue to look at this and even through this contract, if there are opportunities, we will do that at the same point that if it requires us to install additional poles, that is not part of this contract.
05:50:52
It would require the Department to either come up with the additional revenues or if we determine or the decision is made to move forward with $3,000, we may have to go back and renegotiate this contract.
SPEAKER_03
05:51:07
Is any other part of the state or the other contracts the state has signed, have they been in the $4,000 range or are we the only because of our necessity?
SPEAKER_17
05:51:15
I'm not aware of anyone going outside lighting under this.
05:51:19
Most of it has been done in Charlotte.
SPEAKER_04
05:51:26
I have to read it again because I think it's important that we not rush this decision.
05:51:48
It implicates exposure to Blue Ridge's 4,000 Kelvin lights to increased risk of cancer, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.
05:51:58
This is a much bigger decision than just the financial savings that we might benefit from.
SPEAKER_03
05:52:04
Clint, did you discuss this with the contractor at all?
SPEAKER_17
05:52:07
We have not had a chance to discuss this with the contractor.
05:52:11
I was made aware of it last week sometime, I think, after you met with Ellen.
05:52:18
have not had a chance to discuss with the contractor.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
05:52:23
I think Mr. Kasprowicz, the American Medical Association report, and there's others that have signed on, but unfortunately from a Department of Energy Federal Highway Administration who have sort of oversees the world of roadway lighting, National Academy of Sciences, they have not come out
05:52:47
I'd like to say this issue with the light spectrum.
05:52:51
That's sort of a challenge for us as we're delivering lighting within certain lighting standards.
05:52:59
I think we can and are going to look at what is the impact of a different light in terms of spacing.
05:53:07
Are we going to meet the necessary lighting standard at 3,000 Kelvin?
05:53:12
We have to go through that analysis.
05:53:14
But again, the difficulty here is for us, and you and I have
05:53:18
We see the report.
05:53:25
We're also guided by the Department of Energy and Federal Highway Administration who have not come out and said we need to be moving to a 3,000.
05:53:36
And I understand your point about the American Medical Association, but some of this is driven by the standards that we have in place.
SPEAKER_04
05:53:46
It is an optional decision.
05:53:50
We don't have to make it at this point.
SPEAKER_07
05:53:54
What would happen if we deferred on this to next month?
SPEAKER_17
05:53:58
Basically the contract that's through the Department of General Services expires at the end of this month and we would have to go back through that whole process once they go through the re-procurement then we would have to renegotiate with whatever vendors that they select under the new contracting process.
05:54:17
It could be a potential as much as 18-month delay moving forward with this contract.
SPEAKER_03
05:54:24
If we could do this, I'd like to not hear that.
05:54:30
I want to hear what the rest of them say.
05:54:34
I'm not sure how many the rest of them do.
SPEAKER_08
05:54:39
I actually have kind of firsthand on the ground experience with this.
05:54:46
I would say that after the streetcar, this issue of the Calvin of the streetlights was the second most contentious topic in the eight years I've served on Parliament. We started out with the 5,000 Calvins, people couldn't sleep at night, and eventually we dialed it down to 3,000 in the neighborhoods.
05:55:11
And it was not only that people couldn't sleep.
05:55:14
It had to do with how animals were behaving.
05:55:16
It affected a lot of different things in our community.
05:55:20
So while I appreciate that our roads aren't out there, you know, always going through places where people are.
05:55:26
In fact, it affects birds and it affects animals too.
05:55:32
My question would be, Quintin, I know you said adaptive controls were going to be installed, and that's where Arlington ended up with, was the building to basically dial it down.
05:55:45
And that's one of the questions I have, is that adaptive control going to let you dial it down to 3,000?
SPEAKER_17
05:55:52
It will allow us to adjust the level of lighting, and I would assume that it will allow us to take it down to 3,000, Mr. Secretary.
SPEAKER_04
05:55:59
It will not.
05:56:00
I just tell you, it will not.
05:56:02
The adaptive controls allow you to attenuate the movement output but not the public scale in this particular picture, or in this particular application.
SPEAKER_08
05:56:12
To me, the key is if this contract really locks us in to 4,000s for the next 15 years, either because we would have to add more poles to add consistent lighting or whatever, then I really do wonder whether that's the right move.
SPEAKER_03
05:56:30
So this contract came through the Department of General Services and as you know they put out the order and it did put some time constraints in terms of us our ability to work with small contractors but already others in this this is not something that's proprietary we couldn't do on our own in that and
05:56:59
I know that VDOT worked very hard because they just didn't let it be pushed down their throats, quite frankly, which sometimes happens when these types of things come.
05:57:15
So Mr. Kilpatrick is talking.
05:57:17
I think he made a good suggestion.
05:57:21
But this really came as a directive from Executive Branch.
05:57:28
not put VDOT in the middle of this.
05:57:31
So what Charlie suggested is he's going to go and talk to the contractor now or before tomorrow and whether or not what 3,000 does to the contract.
05:57:48
I think we agreed 3,000 and below would be more comfortable moving forward.
05:57:54
So do that and to the extent
05:57:57
There is something, Charlie, that you can work out in your central local department.
05:58:02
And that means financially and all that.
05:58:05
If you get that worked out, then we'll have this briefed again tomorrow at that.
05:58:10
Otherwise, if you can't get it that way, Charlie, you're not, because you simply don't have the time or the briefing, I'm not going to let this come up for a vote.
05:58:21
I don't want to put that on VDOT.
05:58:22
That'll be on me and my role as secretary and administration.
05:58:27
and I don't want to put the agency in that.
05:58:45
So that's what I would ask you to do.
05:58:48
I think there's enough uncertainty here and quite frankly I'll be honest with you, I'm not all that
05:58:55
Excited about what the savings are going to be anyway, quite frankly.
05:59:00
I don't mean that to be, to say it's not a good thing, they are a guarantee, but this is not a critical infrastructure piece that we have to move forward on.
05:59:08
It'd be great if we were able to move forward on it.
05:59:11
I was unaware of this potential development, and I understand that there's guidance, but we've gone through this with guardrails early where
05:59:22
You know, the federal authorities were late in reacting in different things.
05:59:26
I think Virginia has a history of making sure it gets things right and goes its own way.
05:59:31
So I'll leave it up to you.
05:59:33
If you feel comfortable tomorrow that you've got to resolve your satisfaction, then we'll bring this up for a vote to 3,000.
05:59:41
If not, so be it.
05:59:43
I'm not going to bring it to a vote with these uncertainties regarding the health.
05:59:48
It's not that significant an item.
05:59:51
and I'll take the responsibility in talking with the policy people in that regard.
05:59:59
This is not coming from VDOT.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:00:01
Yes, if I could just, people get some sense of what we're really talking about here.
06:00:08
Very warm colored light is 2300 K, warm white light is 300, neutral light is 4000 K, and the cool white is at 5000 K. Really what it has to do with, it's really the
06:00:21
I think the blue, in the color spectrum it's the blue that's in the, that's the issue here with this 4000 kelvin light. It has a greater, I don't know what the right term is, it has more blue light in the light spectrum. So if you're thinking about, again, the yellower the light is, the lower the kelvin is. That's really what we're talking about. These lights will be very white compared with the old one.
06:00:51
high-pressure sodium, and a yellowish color.
SPEAKER_14
06:00:57
Yes, Mr. Whitworth.
06:00:59
Is this a topic or a discussion that has anyway been vetted through the Secretary of Health?
SPEAKER_03
06:01:13
I don't know.
06:01:13
That was going to be one of my questions.
06:01:16
That's why I asked the question.
06:01:17
We're the only ones that have reached the
06:01:20
I'm going to call Dr. Hazel.
06:01:46
Any other questions?
06:01:47
Scott, I want to thank you for bringing that up in that regard.
06:01:53
Quintin, other than Doug, so you're 0 for 1.
06:02:01
I get it right, very exhaustive.
06:02:06
I want to point out though that VDOT did do its due diligence in a lot of this and was
06:02:15
This is not something they just came out of, so we need to do this.
06:02:19
We are responding to your request.
06:02:24
Unfortunately, we may have to make a couple of calls with Mr. Kilpatrick tonight and renegotiate this, but I do think it's pretty clear we cannot get resolved using that level that we're not going to put on this report.
06:02:39
Thank you, appreciate it.
06:02:40
Well, you know, that's why I think
06:02:44
All right now we don't have this plan, but I mentioned to you earlier today, I've had this room.
06:03:03
Oh shit, what was it?
06:03:20
I couldn't remember, somebody was talking one night and couldn't have us remember the word ovation and he tried about four times and he said oh I'll have you just got all up and clapped.
06:03:39
So Mr. Donohue, welcome back up here.
06:03:42
I've had Nick go through this issue on 81 and just sort of briefing the board on what has happened and where we stand.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:03:54
So Nick, thank you for doing this on a short notice.
06:03:57
Yes, thank you Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
06:03:59
Again, this is something I put together today, so this is not all-inclusive, but this has been in the news, particularly in the standing district, but also in some other parts of the corridor there.
06:04:08
We did just want to get out into the public record some of the issues and things that are going on currently in the 81 corridor.
06:04:16
We provided a presentation back in January to this board as well as to a group of legislators.
06:04:21
But again, the longest center state corridor in Virginia carries the highest amount of traffic.
06:04:27
And by traffic, we don't mean the amount of vehicle miles traveled by trucks.
06:04:32
There are 2,000 crashes a year on this corridor.
06:04:36
McPherson Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr.
06:04:49
Williams Jr., John M. Brown, John M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown
06:05:16
It's actually on 81, so there is really no parallel route to I-81 and that's really between Lexington and I think Rome over there.
06:05:24
And then other areas 11 through there's a two-lane kind of road.
06:05:27
In some places it is a four-lane divided road and you can better handle the overflow.
06:05:31
That tends to be like near Harrisonburg and some of the other cities and towns, but in other places it is just a two-lane facility that parallels the interstate.
06:05:41
The other thing that I think is really unique and important to consider about I-81
06:05:45
is it has 48 miles where the grade is 3% or greater.
06:05:50
And when you see those types of grades, it has a significant impact on how trucks behave.
06:05:55
So the average train takes up to a space of about one and a half cars.
06:05:59
When you hit that mountainous terrain, that increases to almost five years.
06:06:05
And so that's why a lot of the issues that you hear people talking about 81 of the trucks, it's not just that they can be unpleasant to drive next to at times.
06:06:13
When you hit these steep grades, because of the differential in their ability to catch up to speed, when you're on those types of trains, they take a lot more space than a passenger vehicle.
06:06:24
So sometimes the traffic volumes may not be as high in certain portions of A1, but when you're in those steep areas that have high truck percentages, the capacity of the roadways is beaten up by a lower amount of vehicles being on there.
06:06:38
However, we aren't doing things on 81, so we have had several meetings with legislators in that corridor.
06:06:45
We actually held the first one, I think it was Doug Landis who actually made the formal request to the secretary back in August of 2015, really sitting down with the legislators in the corridor and saying, you know, what is our goal?
06:06:58
Kind of moving forward.
06:06:59
And I think the last time there was a broad discussion about I-81 was really the star solutions prior to this time.
06:07:05
Star Solutions back in the early to mid-2000s, where we would do a public-private partnership and add two lanes to all 325 miles by 66.
06:07:13
At one point, there would be truck-only toll lanes that would be separated from the existing general travel lanes, which would build new intersections, or interchanges, excuse me.
06:07:24
And it was very, very disruptive, very, very costly.
06:07:27
And ultimately, that was withdrawn by the private sector, I believe, in 2006 or 2007.
06:07:34
They formally withdrew that.
06:07:36
But we did meet with all the legislators in August of 2015 and really said, here are the issues that we see in I-81.
06:07:43
It really dealt with safety issues, interchange pinch points, and then dealing with trucks and these steep grades.
06:07:50
I think the general consensus coming out of that is we need to come up with a set of pragmatic, implementable solutions on the 81 corridor to address these key issues because we don't have the resources to do what STARS solutions have to upgrade to I-61 and I-81.
06:08:06
I think the cost of STAR Solutions back in 2004 was $8 to $10 billion.
06:08:12
To put it in perspective today, that is $15 or so billion, which is the entire Six-Year Improvement Program.
06:08:21
To put that kind of in perspective there, we met again with all those legislators in the beginning of this year to update them on
06:08:31
McPhering, and all meetings in that corridor.
06:08:33
And then we've also had, and I have seven plus on the slide, but I think it's an additional one.
06:08:37
I think it's actually more than 12 meetings where we sat down with the staff in that corridor on a staff level and talked about the needs and recommendations of the VTrans, which really did a lot of discussion on I-81 in a lot of those areas.
SPEAKER_03
06:08:51
So what's going on in here?
06:08:53
Let me add one more thing.
06:08:55
Nick, I remember we also, not only meeting with Alexa, but we
06:08:59
I just want to make it clear that there are numerous meetings one-on-one with legislators
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:09:21
Smith Jr., and the statistics that you're currently reading in the Winchester Star and the Lawrence Sensible and other things actually came from that VDOT report that we provided
06:09:34
There isn't any work going on in 81, and that's just simply not true.
06:09:38
There's over $600 million in the existing Six-Year Improvement Program that's allocated to that corridor.
06:09:44
I'm not saying 600 is the right number or the wrong number.
06:09:46
I'm just saying there are things going on.
06:09:48
On I-81, $600 million is a lot of money.
06:09:51
It may not be the right amount, but it is a fair amount of money.
06:09:54
There's 180 that's been allocated in the first two rounds of SMART SCALE to the corridor, and that's both Interstate 81 and Route 11, where we're upgrading it to help handle the traffic.
06:10:04
from 81.
06:10:05
There's another $110 million in the State of Good Repair program that's now in the last two years in bridges and pavements.
06:10:12
And then there's $310 million, which was allocated prior to the start, really, or money that wasn't subject to SMART SCALE or State of Good Repair that is out there, including interchanges and also replacing bridges and reconstructing pavement along that corridor.
06:10:26
So again, that's $600 million worth of work.
06:10:28
The project's fully funded in the Six-Year Program today that will be moving forward in the 81 corridor in the next
06:10:34
Some of these are under construction.
06:10:36
Others will be moving forward with construction in the coming years.
06:10:39
Again, this is things like a $41 million rebuild on exit 310.
06:10:44
In the Winchester area, there's another $60 million wide, $91 million in the Roanoke region.
06:10:51
There's another $40 million, I believe, in exit 14 in the Bristol district, along with $9 million on exit 19 and $17 million on exit 17 in the Bristol district.
06:11:01
And so there is money throughout the corridor there.
06:11:03
But there's still leads on the score.
06:11:05
And we're still working on things moving forward.
06:11:08
And one of the key things we did was, actually, this past session, VDOT participates in this committee called, very creative, the Transportation Incident Management Committee.
06:11:18
Its purpose is clear.
06:11:19
And it has 16 different members.
06:11:21
It's chaired by the state police.
06:11:23
And really, it's everyone who's involved in dealing with incident management.
06:11:27
It's the towing industry, insurance industry, state police, VDOT, and other interested parties
06:11:33
And they really came up with, I think, a really good piece of legislation to help address incidents.
06:11:38
Again, incidents is one of the biggest problems on 81 because of the lack of parallel routes, the inadequate parallel routes at times.
06:11:45
You have trucks, and when they crash, they block the road more often than a sedan or an SUV crash in the United States impact.
06:11:53
And so what this bill really is aimed at doing is reducing the amount of time that land is closed from an incident
06:12:00
helping our first responders get to that incident quicker and then essentially getting everything out of the way and then there were people rubbernecking faster so that there's less delays and secondary crashes related to these incidents.
06:12:14
Again, with a lot of these incidents when they're longer term and you're on hilliers or with curves, secondary accidents can be just as bad as the primary.
06:12:22
So you have a queue where maybe there's a single vehicle accident or two vehicle accidents, and then there's
06:12:29
When does that stop and you're coming around a curb or up or down a hill and then you're around the corner and boom, there's a bunch of people and you have a secondary accident.
06:12:36
Those can really exacerbate those situations.
06:12:39
So what the law does through the three key provisions is it now requires drivers, if your vehicle can be driven and no one was injured, you've got to drive out of the road.
06:12:51
Today, it's this you should if you wanted to.
06:12:55
Once this bill was passed, it's now in a funded requirement on the driver.
06:12:59
It's called the clear law.
06:13:00
I think in South Carolina, they have 10% reduction in incident related delays and trust retained place.
06:13:06
This thing will change here.
06:13:08
The other really important change is it allows VDOT and some safety service patrols and its towing contractors where you're sitting there and you haven't been injured.
06:13:18
We show up.
06:13:19
We are going through a group of people.
06:13:21
We're just going to get out of the way there, open the road back up to traffic,
06:13:25
We also let VDOT's contractors now use shoulders and medium crossovers.
06:13:30
They did not have that full authority, particularly the contractors prior to this law being in place.
06:13:35
And so very simply, they can now get there faster.
06:13:38
And once they're there, if no one was injured, we're clearing the road.
06:13:41
We're going to put the road back into service for the rest of the travelers that are in that area.
06:13:46
We're hopeful that this can have a significant impact on reducing delays
06:13:53
over the next few years.
06:13:54
This change of law just went into effect on July 1.
06:13:58
It was adopted unanimously by the General Assembly and it was carried by the Chairman of the House Transportation Committee, W. W. So this can really have a policy type issue that we think can't have a significant impact on the incidents in the area.
06:14:53
My understanding, and Garrett Moore standing behind me, will come up here very quickly.
SPEAKER_00
06:15:00
If I say it correctly, it's yes.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:15:05
Who's coming up here?
06:15:08
I've told them basically to push it aside.
SPEAKER_17
06:15:11
Now there's some things we need to do before we do that.
06:15:14
If it's a hazmat, we've had to close ID 1 when I was out in Stanton for 24 hours.
SPEAKER_03
06:15:22
We had an unclackarded paper doing it illegally and we found an EPA got involved. So those things happen, but really the hazard of leaving them there is if the decision is raised and this enables us to have a little more leeway in doing that. So we tell them to try and push it aside. Easier said than done, you've got to get stuff out there, you've got to get it cleared, but we're getting much more aggressive than that. I think that livestock issue is cut and dry.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:15:51
The legislation, Nick, I want to make sure I remember this correctly, actually extended some liability protection to our contractors.
06:16:02
We already had some protection against suit for clearing the roadway, but it didn't extend to our contractors that work under our direction.
06:16:13
The interstate today, most of the work we do is through contract work.
06:16:17
It is going to take some time and there's a balance where you're trying to find a tin can and hope the contents doesn't spill out of it as you're trying to flip it over.
06:16:30
Sometimes we have ruptured the box trailer and make it even worse.
06:16:37
So that's kind of the challenge, but it is going to take continued emphasis in this area
06:16:55
McRae, and it's a road hazard and you need to be clear.
06:16:58
But it's going to take some time there because I think there is still sometimes just reluctance to damage the cargo.
06:17:07
But in many cases, especially in areas like produce and things like that, once the vehicle, once the container is ruptured, it's not soundable anyway.
SPEAKER_11
06:17:19
This I really think is particularly
SPEAKER_14
06:17:31
I don't feel like we've done a very adequate job of educating our traffic public about moving the vehicles out of the roadway.
06:17:56
I think we can do a much better job, especially
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:18:00
I think you've actually seen something on the west coast that was more directive and
06:18:29
The other thing that probably has brought this to the forefront, certainly in my district it has, and it's becoming almost a daily
SPEAKER_14
06:18:59
We had experience in the Stanton District, but we're doubling fatalities from I-81 pressures. And we are experiencing over two incidents a month where there are more than four hour legs. They don't take long.
06:19:29
for this to garner public passion, especially during election time.
06:19:37
So my guess is this subject is going to stay with us.
06:19:42
And I understand we can't manufacture money
SPEAKER_03
06:19:55
And I agree with that.
06:19:57
That's why we're having this.
06:19:58
It's been public interest for us.
06:20:01
But we're going to get to one of the choices.
06:20:05
And I think that's exactly the type of conversation that should be had.
06:20:10
And right now, I've seen it's a problem.
06:20:12
Fix it.
06:20:13
No resources.
06:20:15
And that's why I wanted to have this discussion.
06:20:18
I mean, in other words, having established and pointed out what are the resources necessary
06:20:23
that would be required to do this.
06:20:25
And so we wanted to lay out today what are those choices that we could have that conversation through.
06:20:31
Yeah, Mr. Kasprowicz.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:20:32
Does this apply to all Virginia Rotaries or just industry?
06:20:36
The incident management applies to all Virginia Rotaries.
SPEAKER_03
06:20:39
It applies to all Virginia Rotaries.
06:20:43
Well, it's helpful when they, not only in 81, but 64.
06:20:45
Sure.
06:20:45
Rich, Donald, and stuff like I said, yes.
SPEAKER_04
06:20:48
Sorry, Ms. Rosen will come back to you.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:21:05
I think perhaps we can do Mr. Rosen's and Mr. Whitworth's point and start to track the before and after the law.
06:21:19
Maybe we want to show progress and then also understand if we're seeing more progress in Bristol and less in Salem, is there more education we need to do with one district or another, so I think we can certainly
SPEAKER_07
06:21:39
I think the education piece is important, especially when it affects all of our railways.
06:21:47
How was, when the move over legislation was passed, how was that put forward to the public?
06:21:55
How did they learn about that?
06:21:56
Because a lot of times people did not move over when the consequences were fairly severe.
SPEAKER_04
06:22:03
Some of them went about getting tickets.
SPEAKER_07
06:22:05
Yeah, so you weren't getting tickets.
06:22:07
And so somehow I think people have learned to be good with it.
06:22:13
Do you know that?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:22:14
I believe it was mostly through signage.
06:22:16
It was the main thing.
06:22:17
And I think as Garrett said, we're working on putting those signs up there.
06:22:22
I think it took a while with the move over.
06:22:23
I don't think we'd have a quicker update.
SPEAKER_03
06:22:27
I think it was, it was that, but it was also the tickets.
06:22:30
I mean, that's more easily, the police was there to don't move over and they caught me full.
06:22:35
I mean, that's really what it is.
06:22:37
And that's why I mentioned public safety.
06:22:39
They've got to be, we can put the signs up, but it's really when an incident occurs, it becomes a public safety issue.
06:22:49
And I know there's rule with when the public police take over and stuff like that, when the police take over.
06:22:55
That's part of it too, making sure we have that coordinated.
SPEAKER_07
06:22:59
I was thinking that's the public hearings that we're having coming up to bring this legislation, you know, bring this up.
06:23:06
So maybe it would have picked up in the papers as we're talking about, you know, the all-public hearings.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:23:14
Mr. Walton made a very good point that he thinks the DMV also probably put it into their grab sites and stuff.
06:23:21
That might be something
SPEAKER_13
06:23:25
I'd like to ask for my own education that 81 cannot be told by statute.
06:23:35
That's right.
SPEAKER_03
06:23:36
We're going to get to that.
06:23:37
We've got all this laid out.
06:23:38
It cannot.
06:23:38
That is why there is.
SPEAKER_13
06:23:40
But, and I know the enormity of the task of the 300 and some odd miles is overwhelming, but if the legislature would revisit, I'll call it incremental improvements
06:23:54
That could be told a certain distance.
06:23:59
Why isn't that on the plate?
06:24:00
We're going to give you something.
SPEAKER_03
06:24:02
We're going to get to that.
06:24:04
In fact, I've had, that was one of the discussions with legislators, throwing outcomes in that, and that was one of the suggestions.
06:24:14
We wanted to just tell you where we are, what's been done, what we've offered as suggestions.
SPEAKER_13
06:24:20
I agree with Mr. Brown, it's not going away.
SPEAKER_03
06:24:26
But it's not going to be a problem solved without resources.
06:24:30
And that's where we have to find the political will, or given the latitude, to do so.
06:24:35
Some of the things that have been said not only are inaccurate, but are inaccurate comparisons in terms of how projects have moved forward in the Commonwealth.
06:24:49
We understand how Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia have congestion.
06:24:54
But yes, it's being resolved through tolls and regional monies.
06:24:58
It's not state monies that are moving this way.
06:25:00
But we're going to get to that.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:25:01
But that's what we want to go through.
SPEAKER_03
06:25:04
So we have a really intelligent conversation to get to an answer instead of just political rhetoric in that.
06:25:11
So speaking of recent.
06:25:13
Oh, I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_04
06:25:13
Mr. Kasprowicz.
06:25:14
Quick question.
06:25:15
Is there enforcement associated with this if you fail to clear it?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:25:18
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Kaskowitz, there is not a specific offense in your statute for that.
06:25:26
However, there is a general provision that if you blindly
06:25:30
In terms of getting to clearing the roadway, if the vehicles are immovable or pushable,
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:26:00
I've tried to trigger that type of thing.
06:26:02
It's overturned.
06:26:03
It's really under the direction of the state police.
06:26:06
Once the fire department, once the injured or removed, any injured or removed from the scene, and the fire department says that the scene is stable in terms of hazardous material or fire hazard, then it goes to the state police in terms of clearing the roadway.
06:26:24
So we've been working very closely with Colonel Flaring and his team
06:26:28
I'm really pushing this issue out to our staff.
06:26:32
From a VDOT perspective, our safety service controllers, they know if they can get to the scene of an incident and can push the vehicle if there's not injury, they can push the vehicle clear of the roadway or have them drive off the roadway, they will do that.
06:26:48
And again, we work very aggressively to do that.
06:26:51
Downtown Richmond is probably
06:26:53
The issue, I guess, when we try on 81 is the trucks.
06:27:05
It is, it is, and it doesn't, you can't push them out
06:27:27
The problem we're doing more and more in these incidents is dispatching a loader either from our contractor or from our area headquarters when we have a cargo spill.
06:27:38
So that loader takes time to get out to the interstate to get it rolling just as we did with our instant tow wrecker services that we were pushing around the state, dispatching a wrecker immediately and dispatching crews immediately to end up being
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:27:55
There's also some other things related to this that I think would be probably for a future briefing where they're looking at changing how we pay the towers where today they're paying the amount of time it takes them to clear a vehicle and perhaps we want to pay them more if they clear it quickly.
06:28:07
Another thing to that nature is that the department's been working on some innovative procurement strategies there that aren't fully implemented yet but hopefully will be in the coming months.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:28:18
We called it in point clearance incentive basically.
06:28:21
If they can clear a scene
SPEAKER_14
06:28:22
just to show you the enormity of this issue just in the Stanton District for the last five years the average incident duration has been over an hour but this year in 2017
06:28:52
We had 156 tractor-trailer crashes and 441 big crashes.
06:28:59
That relates to a lot of down time with traffic.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:29:09
So the Secretary mentioned additional resources.
06:29:11
We're not just, you know, we're deploying the resources that are available at the state level, but we're also trying to scare up more resources with a few avenues available for us in this corridor.
06:29:22
And so the real option we have at the moment is Discretionary Federal Grants.
06:29:25
As you all may recall, we received the largest Discretionary Federal Grant in the first year of the Fast Lane Grant Program with 165 related gateway.
06:29:34
We did submit a second Fast Lane Grant for the A1 corridor, trying to get $25 million for a $128 million package of improvements.
06:29:43
That was put out in late 2016, and it's always risky to start a grant program, and that would
06:29:48
Fennishit, when there was a turnover in administrations.
06:29:50
And so that solicitation was canceled by the new administration.
06:29:54
And they put it back out under a new name, now it's called Infogram.
06:29:58
It's not fascinating anymore.
06:30:00
Same program, law hasn't changed.
06:30:02
They've updated some of the policy requirements.
06:30:04
But we are working on a revised application for the 81 corridor for that grant program.
06:30:10
What we're really focusing on there is we're looking at the incident delay as well as the safety issues, monetizing those costs,
06:30:17
And we're focused on what are basically the top three or four problem areas on whole 325 miles.
06:30:24
And we're planning to probably submit something that really goes in in a targeted way to address those key areas.
06:30:30
Again, that's going to leave a lot of the corridor untouched.
06:30:33
But hopefully, if we get some of the worst areas, we can show some of the improvement to folks.
06:30:37
But again, this is a very competitive program.
06:30:39
There's $850 million for the entire country.
06:30:42
So take SMART SCALE.
06:30:44
H. T. Smith Jr.
06:30:46
So the next thing I want to talk about is, you know, what are really our options for moving forward with large-scale projects?
06:31:01
So right now, every two years, you know, SMART SCALE is around $800 million to a billion dollars over projected moving forward.
06:31:09
With the current funding formulas in law, the maximum amount of funding, and I mean,
06:31:14
W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
06:31:43
The Northern Virginia District has the highest percentage of district grant program funds at 20.9%.
06:31:49
And so if you add the 450 plus the Northern Virginia District grant program together, you get about $600 million.
06:31:57
That is the maximum amount of money that could ever, under the laws that currently govern how transportation is programmed in Virginia, put on a single project.
06:32:08
That's, you know, I saw our solutions as multi,
06:32:16
It's not a choice that you all have made.
06:32:18
Those are the resources that are available based on the taxes the General Assembly has provided and the laws and formulas that they have also decided to be appropriate to operate on.
06:32:26
That's the law.
SPEAKER_13
06:32:27
Mr. Chairman?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:32:28
Yes.
SPEAKER_13
06:32:29
Well, when we were in Weard Green, I guess, last month, we had a discussion along these lines of every district, especially in the Crescent
06:32:44
and Hampton Roads, and 81.
06:32:48
There are probably a list of 12 to 15 major projects that we talked about that I think it's incumbent on us to number one, try to prioritize those if that's possible.
06:33:04
And number two, as Nick is saying, how do we come up with solutions for those that go above and beyond what NDTA or Hampton Roads can do?
06:33:15
or any other special tax district that's created because of the enormity of the projects.
06:33:21
We know 81.
06:33:22
We know in Northern Virginia that one way or another the American Indian Bridge has to be addressed.
06:33:29
The Roslyn Stations, the Long Bridge, the Third Crossing, you name it.
06:33:36
You can go around the state and what Hampton Roads needs and what Richmond may need or what we may need down in the Roanoke area.
06:33:44
They exist and we've got to find a way and fairly young wise, limited resources have consequences.
06:33:59
I think we have to do that this coming year as a board.
06:34:04
Identify, prioritize, and then try to match up what can we do and how can we do it.
SPEAKER_14
06:34:16
I don't think we need to go through the process of making people aware that these are major projects that aren't going to go away anymore.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:34:32
It actually should say 545 million, not 630, I apologize.
SPEAKER_03
06:34:37
I had a map error earlier.
06:34:39
It must be 545 to 150 million under the currency area.
06:34:46
and that's not, we have taken the approach to use every nickel we can to move projects funded, but I mean Gary's quite the only project, but I hear this, you've heard it in the previous one, well why aren't you doing the other side?
06:35:01
You got 20 miles on 64 that you haven't identified funding for.
06:35:06
I mean, there's every one, and it's because we're moving the ball forward incrementally.
06:35:10
Don't get me wrong, we've got more cones and more construction,
06:35:14
Now we've got in the state's history, but so I made a good point about this money is six years in the future.
06:35:23
Even that we're putting off, we're still six years, five or six years out.
06:35:30
So at least from what we want to put out here is how these large scale, how we've gotten them done.
06:35:38
And there's this misconception that it's state money that's moving.
06:35:43
And state money is helping.
06:35:44
That is not what is the primary curing arm that's moving these projects forward.
06:35:52
It's other revenue sources.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:35:55
So these are some of the biggest projects going on in the state right now.
06:36:00
We have a $625 million widening of 21 miles of assets in Hampton Roads.
06:36:05
Again, that $625 million exceeds what we would run on a single project around the SCART scale.
06:36:11
We got $145 million from SmartScale.
06:36:14
The rest is coming from additional taxes imposed at the regional level.
06:36:18
Again, Hampton Roads has a 0.7% retail sales and use tax and an additional 2.1% wholesale tax on our fuel.
06:36:27
The I-64 High Rise Bridge and Southside Widening of I-64, $600 million.
06:36:32
When $100 million is coming from SmartScale, the remaining $500 million is coming from Hampton Roads Regional Funding.
06:36:39
That's an additional regional tax imposed in Hampton Roads that is not imposed outside of that area.
06:36:46
And that goes with funds used in that area.
06:36:48
Transform 66 outside of the belt works, only $3 billion.
06:36:51
We are using zero on SMART SCALE.
06:36:55
It was allocated 10% to the $300 million.
06:36:57
We ultimately didn't need it there.
06:36:59
But you can say it had kept the $300 million.
06:37:03
That would be $300 million in a $3 million project there, with the rest of that being financed by tolls.
SPEAKER_03
06:37:09
The extension of the 95 express lanes, that's why tolls paid out of Northern Virginia.
06:37:15
You call it a tax or a toll, but it's paid out of Northern Virginia.
06:37:19
It's a toll for constitutional purposes.
06:37:22
My point is whether you're raising it through revenues of additional taxes, we're asking consumers in those areas to pay more.
06:37:33
It is not statewide dollars that are moving it forward.
06:37:37
We're asking them to pay more.
06:37:40
I wasn't trying to get to the definition.
06:37:44
My point is that it is the community that's paying.
06:37:49
It is not the statewide pocket.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:37:52
We're extending the 95 express lanes 10 miles south from Garrisonville to route 17, exit 133.
06:37:57
That's $100 million.
06:37:58
We're paying $115 million of that through the federal fast lane discretionary grant we received.
06:38:05
The remainder is financed by tolls, which is, again, a choice for users
06:38:09
In that corridor, these are not all the biggest projects we have going on, but I think this is four of the six largest projects currently underway in the Commonwealth.
06:38:20
Had I put the other ones up here, it would have just been redundant.
06:38:24
They either involve regional financing, tolls, or both, or discretionary federal grants along with tolls or regional funding here.
06:38:32
And I think, as Mr. Whitworth asked earlier, Mr. Garczynski, we are prohibited by law
06:38:38
from imposing tolls on any lane, including new lanes of I-81.
06:38:45
We passed a tolling policy bill in 2016 that the Secretary worked on with Chairman Chris Jones of House Appropriations.
06:38:52
And in that law, we made a very clear distinction that new lanes could be tolled on every interstate.
06:38:58
However, when it came to Interstate 81, that corridor and its representatives were very clear.
06:39:03
They didn't want a single lane, new,
06:39:05
whether it was new or existing to be told without a specific law passing the General Assembly.
06:39:10
So that item was discussed directly during the 2016 General Assembly session, and they ultimately at that time came down saying they did not want even new lanes to be told.
SPEAKER_03
06:39:22
So I'm going to put this out because I think, and I'm going to say just a misunderstanding, nothing any more than that, but there's that somehow we're paying attention only to
06:39:35
The reason those big projects are moving forward is because that's where the resources that we have available to move.
06:39:47
This is not because of, you know, I would love to be paying attention to other areas if we had the resources, but when you take what Nick pointed out, the allocations that are going, unless those allocations are changed,
06:40:02
This is what we're dealing with.
06:40:06
So it's not good or bad, but I think I do want to push back somehow that we were not considering the fact that we put every nickel we could, and I don't think there's a nickel in the Commonwealth that we have an obligation in the district.
06:40:24
So that's the point I want to put out.
06:40:26
I think Mr. Werkberg, I know, pushed back a little bit.
06:40:29
This problem is very real.
06:40:31
It's going to get worse.
06:40:32
But it's not going to be fixed without resources.
06:40:39
We could go through and I don't know what the next slides are, Nick.
06:40:42
But let's think about, one is that we could get federal monies.
06:40:51
And I think that's something we should continue to push.
06:40:54
We heard this on the monitor.
06:40:55
We need to get federal monies.
06:40:57
Well, don't you think we've been up there asking
06:41:00
W. Boggs, John W. Boggs Jr.
06:41:31
There was no talk about finding billions of dollars on a stand-alone project.
06:41:39
They were all levered incremental dollars.
06:41:42
Whether it was a public-private partnership, a tiffy alone, whatever.
06:41:46
That's what we heard there.
06:41:48
So, yes, we should continue to advocate and push for federal dollars.
06:41:53
And maybe, maybe that will all change with tax reform, although what I'm seeing is a reduction
06:42:01
in taxes collected.
06:42:03
So maybe repatriation.
06:42:06
I'm pointing out it's good to talk about that.
06:42:09
I don't see where that money's coming from in the federal court.
06:42:14
In fact, that's one of the things we requested.
06:42:16
Give us some definition, because we're trying to make procurement decisions.
06:42:21
Even if we don't like it, we'd like to know what it is.
06:42:24
So we can make discussions.
06:42:25
So that's number one we're going to continue to pursue.
06:42:28
I don't think that's going to be something that we're going to say we can actually get this done, which we've got to pursue.
06:42:34
Now, we're back to state resources.
06:42:37
What are our choices?
06:42:40
We can start identifying which projects, if we want to pick one project, and we can start identifying what projects we're going to cancel.
06:42:49
Because all monies in the next six years, which Mr. Kilpatrick has pointed out, have been obligated
06:42:57
Frankly, many of those have been put on pilot time procurement.
06:43:02
But we can start, so in the whole 13, at some point, we can start canceling projects and putting others out there.
06:43:09
But that would require a lot of agreement here to say which projects we're gonna cancel going forward.
06:43:19
We could then look at other revenue sources.
06:43:22
And that falls into two areas.
06:43:26
One is tolling.
06:43:29
It would require legislation on 81.
06:43:30
Even spot tolling, which I think makes a lot of sense.
06:43:33
We should look at that it's going to require legislative change in that.
06:43:38
The models would be a little different.
06:43:40
I mean, it's mostly truck traffic.
06:43:42
That's what's really driving it there versus our other interstates.
06:43:46
But I'm sure we can get through that and come up with and determine what revenue that would raise in that.
06:43:55
But that's one option.
06:43:56
Parnell, or the second option is, again, additional revenues raised through taxes.
06:44:02
So all of that requires legislative approval.
06:44:09
I don't think we've looked at incident management.
06:44:13
We've looked at spot improvements.
06:44:15
We're putting them on, moving as quickly as we can.
06:44:19
So I agree the problem's not going away, but we're not going to solve it by saying let's look at it and I'm going to fix it without telling us what the answer is.
06:44:27
That's what I'm trying to point out.
06:44:29
And I think we need to have this conversation because the residents in that area do and should expect us to do something, us being mistaken.
06:44:40
But we can't do it alone.
06:44:44
And that's really what I want to get across.
06:44:48
is that, it should be pointed out, but it's unfair to say that we're not paying attention to that.
06:44:56
That's just not true.
06:44:59
It's a math issue, that's how I should put it.
06:45:05
And there may be some that think we're being offensive, I don't think so.
06:45:09
I think we're being as brutally honest as I can as to what we need to look at, but we have done a lot of transportation.
06:45:17
moving them all forward at 2313 made a heck of a lot of difference.
06:45:21
SMART SCALE makes a lot of difference and all that.
06:45:24
But to say that we've done everything we need to fix transportation is not happening.
06:45:32
And that's, I think we have tried to, for the last four years, have proven we like to get more efficient, but it's pretty efficient.
06:45:41
You know, we can pick different projects, okay, smart scale, I think, if we're accepted.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:45:47
I mean, which ones we should have done, we didn't do, you know, in that regard.
SPEAKER_03
06:45:50
So, that can feel very comfortable that we can say we are putting forth the best we can in terms of it.
06:45:58
But, this doesn't mean that we've got enough resources to solve it all.
06:46:03
So, I want to be a part of the solution, not just be part of, you know, continuing our discussion.
06:46:09
That's what I thought.
06:46:10
The best thing to do is, we said, let's use everything we got efficiently.
06:46:15
Because the best way to get more money is to show what we've done.
06:46:19
I think we're pretty much there.
06:46:22
I think we show what we can do with the money.
06:46:24
It's all obligated.
06:46:26
It's not perfect.
06:46:27
But it's not going to be enough to say, if we've given more money here, we can fix the problem that they want.
06:46:36
So I want to be part of the solution working
06:46:42
and we need to be realistic with education with the public is that's what it's going to require.
06:46:50
Unless you guys got any other ideas that I'm not aware of.
06:46:54
Mr. Kasprowicz.
SPEAKER_04
06:46:55
I'll go back to 81 for just a moment.
06:46:58
I found Dixon's statistics on 156 truck accidents in 2015.
06:47:04
And given the, let's say, bleak picture of funding options for doing a major upgrade to 81,
06:47:11
I wonder, and I think the legislation that attempts to clear traffic accidents more quickly is beneficial, but I wonder if there's not another step you could take in the context of reducing accidents.
06:47:25
So, I don't drive a quarter often, but I will tell you anytime I'm on that road, I would estimate the average speed is in the low 80s.
06:47:33
and the low ages and sometimes high ages.
06:47:37
And I know that speed control and speed enforcement is out of our purview as a board, but safety is not.
06:47:43
And so I wonder if there's not a mechanism that we could employ to monitor average speeds on sections of that highway and at least provide visibility on the safety aspects of excess speed.
06:47:56
I'm not a traffic accident expert.
06:47:59
I would guess there's a fairly strong correlation
06:48:05
I don't know what that is, but if we could reduce traffic accidents by 10% or 15% or 20% through better enforcement or control of speed, I think in the short term that may be the most meaningful thing to do is to avoid the accidents and when they do appear to change them up more quickly.
06:48:25
So I guess my question is do we have
06:48:35
as a safety concern on the 81 quarter in particular.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:48:41
And this is something we need to check with our operations and graphics.
06:48:45
I think our continuous count, gravity stations and town volume, I believe they count so that they can measure speed also.
06:48:54
But again, I'm not sure we need to check that, whether or not we have real-time speed data.
06:49:01
You have kind of an enriched type of data, but you're really talking about more precise data in terms of what's it, prevailing speed, or average speed, or whatever that speed threshold is that Quintin or Gary, are you aware of, or Rob, do you know if those, do they actually track, can you get actual speed at our continuous count stage?
06:49:28
So that is an area that, let us follow up on that regarding
06:49:31
Smith Jr.
06:49:33
I do have a feeling when I drive 81, I do feel like I'm driving actually faster just staying with the tempo of the traffic on the road.
06:49:58
I do believe that we can pick up speed data
06:50:27
A real-time was from me and we could even say what time of day or day of the week.
06:50:33
Can we get some speed data on Israel?
SPEAKER_13
06:50:37
Oh, I'm sorry.
06:50:38
Please do.
06:50:40
The speed box is a little over there.
06:50:45
Oh, yes.
SPEAKER_07
06:50:47
This morning in the rep committee, we went over the rail study.
06:50:50
And we were looking at all the corridors, including the freight corridors in Virginia.
06:50:55
And as part of the crescent corridor,
06:50:57
Northwick Southern has railed at once parallel to 81.
06:51:04
And the issue is truck traffic in many instances, it's not most.
06:51:09
And I think part of what feels scary about driving an 81 is the fact that it feels very close to the end of the car at all the speed of these eight-tracker trails.
06:51:21
Is there a way, or how do we approach perfect southern?
06:51:25
I mean, is there something we could do to move some of the truck traffic onto the ground?
06:51:30
You know, with the diminishing returns on coal, I just don't know if there's a business opportunity.
06:51:36
I don't know if some people are laughing, but is there a way to shift some of this joy?
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
06:51:47
I mean that's the entire objective of all of our rail programs is to, and I would say that over the past 10, 12 years or so, DRPT has actually invested quite a bit in the Crescent Corridor.
06:52:00
I'd have to find out exactly how much, but I know that a number of the projects that DRPT has funded in recent years
06:52:10
has specifically been in the crescent border to help take trucks off I-81.
06:52:16
And it's, you know, not all of the traffic is from origins and destinations that are served well by rail, but yeah, certainly I think the more that we can try to shift- I just don't know that, you know, looking at a multi-modal approach on 81, I don't know how deliberately we've been, and I don't even know
SPEAKER_07
06:52:39
and Morgan Southern's business model about this.
06:52:41
But to me, it could be an opportunity.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:52:44
So the sidebar conversation you saw on this one that I have is there was this, after the Star Solution proposal kind of went away to a certain extent in early 2006, there was this other concept that was input for, and this was eight years ago, so I'm going to screw up part of this off my recollection, but there was this concept called rail solutions, and there was actually language both in the board resolution as well as in the
06:53:09
State Appropriations Act, directly to DRPT and VDOT to do an 81 study, which took two to three years to complete.
06:53:16
It was finished in late 2008 by Paul.
06:53:18
And the thing it was focusing on was the maximum amount of divertable truck traffic.
06:53:23
And as Ms. Mitchell was getting at, what we really focused on there is where were the trips kind of over 500 miles long and where were they kind of either not starting or stopping in Virginia so that we could kind of
06:53:35
You need an intermodal facility to kind of make that transition and switch over there.
06:53:39
And so we were looking at it.
06:53:41
And it turns out the amount that met some of that criteria unfortunately was a much lower percentage of the overall truck volumes on I-81 than I think people either thought or were hoping that they were.
06:53:52
That may have changed.
06:53:54
You know, good movement is a dynamic thing.
06:53:57
So I'm not saying that the findings of the 2008 study are accurate today.
06:54:00
I'm sure that was something that they looked at
06:54:04
I do think some of the investments that were made in the domestic corridor was about $60 million invested in the 2007 Transportation Initiative to add additional sidings and double-track on certain North Excel routes to help with some of that diversion.
06:54:19
I think they just ultimately found that you couldn't divert the level of trucks that people were hoping to be able to divert to change the general feel of the roadway.
06:54:29
So you might get truck traffic from
06:54:30
I would consider the competitive aspect of those businesses.
SPEAKER_13
06:54:54
Just go to your TV sets today and you'll see one of the major railroads
06:55:00
talking about how much freight moves and you see the guys multiply the employees.
06:55:05
And then you go on the radio and you'll hear how much truck traffic delivers most of the freight that we have in the country today.
06:55:13
So we do have that dynamic of the competition between those two.
06:55:18
It's not always as easy as just saying we can convert.
SPEAKER_07
06:55:22
And I completely agree.
06:55:23
I just wonder if it's a discussion.
06:55:25
It's been eight years.
06:55:27
I just wonder if it's a discussion with Norfolk
SPEAKER_03
06:55:32
I've had recent meetings with them and we had this talk, I don't know what was that, Jennifer, but both Norfolk Southern and CSX have pulled back significantly in capital expenditures because of corporate reorganizations.
06:55:49
They've left Norfolk Southern, left Railroad, operate CSX with their new tech management.
06:55:57
While I'm happy to talk with them, I would suggest to you that
06:56:01
They'll be willing to do it if we pay for it.
SPEAKER_07
06:56:05
But I think what I'm saying is that it could be part of their business model because they're having to fund a new business to move on their tracks because of coal.
06:56:16
You know, and maybe that they've already determined that it's not eatable.
SPEAKER_03
06:56:20
I would say we can tell you up to date.
06:56:22
I'm not happy to talk to them.
06:56:23
I just want to say what they have identified and met with them all their opportunities.
06:56:27
It's really going to be customer driven.
06:56:29
If their customers tell
06:56:31
I'm not trying to be clippant, I'm just saying that's the way the model works.
06:56:49
Same issue with the inland port.
06:56:52
They said, sure, if the state wants to build it, we'll be happy to do it.
06:56:57
But until our customers tell us that's a place for us to be,
06:57:01
then we're not interested in putting infrastructure there.
06:57:04
So I'm not suggesting to you they won't.
06:57:06
I'm just, I want to put out to you that they really were not, they were not, at least I remember, that they were not if they were the STARS program, the building, the track there.
06:57:19
But it could have all changed since then.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:57:21
Rail Solutions, they were not a fan of that one because that actually involved literally basically pulling all the trucks over and anyone with the concept and Bristol
06:57:31
I'm not trying to shoot it down.
SPEAKER_03
06:57:39
I'm just saying that that's a long-term process.
SPEAKER_04
06:57:46
In the context of getting trucks on rail, the longer the haul, the better.
06:57:54
I would think that other states, Pennsylvania, Tennessee,
06:57:58
I want to ask you about the discussion of rail something that needs to
SPEAKER_03
06:58:28
Well, it really gets down to the cost comparison of what it would be to ship, just like Gary was saying.
06:58:35
Is it less expensive to go rail or to a truck?
06:58:41
And I will tell you, the fuel has worked against the series in terms of, you know, the trucking industry because of the fuel being less expensive.
06:58:51
I mean, it just moved in that regard.
SPEAKER_07
06:58:56
I would just suggest that they do that, but I'm happy to have the conversation.
SPEAKER_03
06:59:18
I don't want to come away with saying something simplistic
06:59:23
But saying it's something that can happen and everybody put in that regard.
06:59:28
I think it's got to be one of the options in there.
06:59:31
But this has been what's going to drive that decision is if either we pay for it or business, their customers say in that.
06:59:40
So we should follow up to see where they are.
06:59:46
Sorry, Nick.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
06:59:49
That was my last slide.
06:59:50
I was just standing here.
SPEAKER_03
06:59:53
So, Charlie, one of the things that mentioned was, I think we provided all the information we've done on analysis of the quarter.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:00:04
There's some additional analysis I think we can provide in the future.
07:00:08
We're doing it for our infrared now and what we're really identifying is from a
07:00:14
We're monetizing basically the cost of incident delays and also overlapping that with the cost of fatalities, severe injuries, and other injuries from incidents in that corridor and really putting those together to understand what segments and interchanges are the worst from a combined perspective of delays related to incidents and the impact of humanity from the incidents there.
07:00:38
So I think we'll have something in the next few weeks
07:00:41
W. Conley, to put out and provide to folks on there, there will be some new information.
SPEAKER_03
07:00:45
What about, I mean, one of the things that Senator Ovechaine called for an additional study of incidents in there.
07:00:53
I mean, is there additional work they can do if we need something you can provide Charlie on that?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:00:59
Okay.
SPEAKER_03
07:00:59
So I ask you what we're putting together.
07:01:01
Yeah, okay.
07:01:02
Then I'm going to ask, you know, if you and Charlie all work together and specifically take that data and give to the legislators in that.
07:01:11
What we're also seeing though is a continuation of the increase of volume.
SPEAKER_14
07:01:40
Harrisonburg, Winchester, Rathine, the numbers go from 10 to 17% increase since 2012.
07:01:48
So there's no reason to think it's going to decline.
SPEAKER_03
07:01:52
It would be interesting to look, I don't know if we have, we might have this in a phrase study as if that's just traveling through the state.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:01:59
We have the resources through street lights and other data sources to be able to look at the orders of the destinations along the corridors in detail.
SPEAKER_03
07:02:07
So that will go into the solution.
07:02:09
I mean, I can tell you from an economic development standpoint, I mean, stuff passing through the state has a different merit in terms of attracting capital than it is interesting in moving business into the future.
07:02:25
So that's why, again, it sort of leads itself to a federal response in that regard.
07:02:33
I just don't see any guarantee that that's going to happen.
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:02:45
During the rail studies back in 2000, I believe it was 60% of truck traffic I think went through the state.
07:02:54
And I may have that mixed up.
07:02:55
But we can pull that information up.
07:02:57
I do think, again, traffic trends are trends until they're not trends.
07:03:01
So when we did the OEIS in 2004, it said traffic was going to grow at 3% every single year.
07:03:07
It actually stayed flat for several years.
07:03:09
It started growing in 2012.
07:03:11
And so there's ups and downs.
SPEAKER_03
07:03:14
So what can we do in terms of something, given that, is there anything we can start doing to look at in terms of spot polling?
07:03:23
I mean, is there data that we have showing that we can start looking at that?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:03:27
I think we could put some things together with regard to options that could be available for the legislature to consider.
07:03:33
I think I would say we might want to put out to them to understand what, if any, receptionists they have to that processing.
SPEAKER_03
07:03:42
I just know that was one.
07:03:44
It did say all options should be on the table, and so I think that's, I mean maybe you're right about making the recommendation, but saying here are different options that could generate revenues.
07:03:56
I mean as much the same as we've done for the other, the advisory committee, what can we do to put together just some options as to how we could do it in the past, in addition to what we're already doing,
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:04:13
So I will talk with Charlie and also with Ben Mennell who is doing a lot of work and team PD.
07:04:20
We will be communicating with Mr. Whitworth as well as the secretary about what we can put out and when we can provide that to the folks in Florida.
SPEAKER_03
07:04:28
I truly want it to be part of a solution or helping.
07:04:34
Again, I just want to make sure that we don't raise expectations without saying that somehow
07:04:43
This part of the state is not being looked at.
07:04:47
Quite frankly, again, it's just showing how these big projects are moving elsewhere.
07:04:51
It's not state revenues.
SPEAKER_04
07:04:56
One last question.
07:04:58
Given Dixon's comments on road and traffic, are we in a position to predict when that roadway actually breaks down and stops functioning as a roadway?
07:05:07
Is it three years?
07:05:08
Is it five years?
SPEAKER_03
07:05:16
much like we have in the interstates in North Virginia.
07:05:20
You understand what I'm saying?
Nick Donohue
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
07:05:22
No, I'm not saying yes.
SPEAKER_03
07:05:23
The answer, I mean, of course, this is really an incident.
07:05:30
As long as the traffic is small, capacity is not the major issue.
07:05:36
As long as when something breaks, there's no recovery because there's no parallel with those now.
07:05:42
So unlike North Virginia,
07:05:47
Kappas, this has got plenty of room until it stops.
07:05:53
But then, is it right?
07:05:54
You're right, it takes four hours.
07:05:56
That's what you know.
07:05:57
And there's no, you got 11, right, Charlie?
07:06:00
Pretty much it.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
07:06:01
But in many cases, Route 11 either doesn't, in some cases, there is no Route 11.
SPEAKER_03
07:06:07
In other cases, it runs through Lexington or Harrisonburg.
07:06:13
So it's like, I mean, I've got
07:06:16
So yes, we can.
07:06:44
I think it's more not so much a failing for traffic, it's failing now when we have an exit.
07:06:52
I think that's the best way to put it.
07:06:56
In many cases, they're pretty narrow shoulders.
07:06:59
Very narrow shoulders.
07:07:00
Inclines, and so, I mean, look, the road was just not designed to carry this load of traffic.
07:07:06
This could be, I guess, like a truck.
07:07:09
A truck track.
07:07:10
But it is what it is.
07:07:13
So I would direct all the information we can.
07:07:18
So we'll make sure we want to reach out to them and get them all the information that we have.
07:07:36
Happy to give them all the information and updates as to
07:07:40
W. Smith Jr.
07:07:42
I do believe it has to do with the availability of revenues.
SPEAKER_15
07:07:50
Okay.
SPEAKER_03
07:07:53
Well, I wanted to just have that because I agree with what's right.
07:08:03
I got to read the articles too.
07:08:06
It's very topical and I want to make sure we
07:08:10
We're part of the solution and not just a lot of revenue.
07:08:18
All right, so I think we're down to our items from Mr. Kilpatrick.
07:08:24
I have a couple of items.
07:08:26
One, and these are in your package.
07:08:28
You have a list of agreements executed pursuant to the delegation.
07:08:33
These are largely programmatic and project-related agreements.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
07:08:51
Just to your attention, this program, the NS4 program comes out of EPA down to the Department of Environmental Quality, and there are a couple of different aspects to it.
07:09:05
One is on new construction, you have to reduce the total maximum daily load, which is basically the pollutant load.
07:09:23
I think that's what we're talking about, right?
07:09:57
I want to bring this to your attention.
07:10:10
It is a great opportunity for us in the Potomac Basin to meet our requirement for
07:10:27
Rick up to 20, what was it, 25, almost 10 years to meet the requirement with a single project.
07:10:36
As far as a large project, it would cost approximately $20,000 over four years.
07:10:43
It's being funded through our environmental programs and it's built into our budget.
07:10:47
Fundamentally what the
07:10:51
We already have an existing contract.
07:10:53
We came to a lesson.
07:10:54
They said we had this opportunity to sell stream credits, or I'm sorry, DMBL credits for about $4,750 per pound.
07:11:07
We paid as much as $18,000 per pound to sell.
07:11:13
And just to give you sort of a context, I just figured it out.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
07:11:16
A pound of gold, I think I got on the map where it's $15,700.
07:11:21
So this is very expensive to address, but this is a good project for us.
07:11:28
And again, I just wanted to bring it to your attention because this is one of the things that's not just on new projects, but federal regulation requires us to go back and improve water quality.
07:11:39
There are a number of municipalities and states that have been fined by EPA.
07:11:45
We're not the one.
07:11:46
It's the EMSO standard.
07:11:49
They have been out.
07:12:04
also you have the quarterly report and just a couple of highlights I wanted to reinforce
07:12:29
and you can see there's still a decent amount of projects that are late in terms of project development that's largely driven because we have not some of these projects we have not updated the schedule and we're not frankly not built a schedule because they may be projects that are old projects and are now going into production when I say in the next couple of years so once we scope these projects we anticipate they will all come back within the
07:12:59
We continue to do trend improvements in terms of on-time and on-budget and a reminder in that area
07:13:29
On time for us means we put a fixed date completion on our contract when we awarded them.
07:13:37
And it doesn't matter what the reason was, you don't meet that date you were late.
07:13:41
So we don't extend the date for additional work or adverse weather or any other condition as well as on budget.
07:13:49
If the project exceeds the 10% of the contract award amount,
07:13:55
It's considered over budget.
07:13:56
Even if we consciously decide at work, it takes it above 10%.
07:14:01
So it's a pretty strict standard and doing very well in that area.
07:14:05
And then last two things.
07:14:07
I don't have a delivery date yet, except we have a number of projects that will be delivered this fall.
07:14:13
But two, I want to highlight what we call the tail on the threat act in Fredericksburg.
07:14:20
Next, the 95 express lanes and two and a half mile
07:14:24
A number of other projects down in Salem, the X-150 we're going to the roundabout,
07:14:58
Just a quick update, I think it's well before we
Jennifer Mitchell
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
07:15:26
We're working with Secretary Ray LaHood to honor the review of the motto which is, we're required to do by an enactment clause in our Metro Safety Commission legislation.
07:15:38
So we expect he has, we had a meeting that many of you have read about with Governor Caulif and Governor Hogan and we had a meeting in DC a few weeks ago where this was a topic of conversation and there was some discussion about potential
07:15:56
He's not released any, there's no report at this time, he hasn't released any final recommendations, but he said that he expects to roll something out later in October. So we'll be sure to keep you updated on that. This is Tri-Transit week, I just want to let everybody know. This is a week where we run a number of promotions, including some contests, and it's a way for DRPT to try to Thank you.
07:16:24
I did want to mention as well hopefully you have all received an invitation to the opening for the train and I do hope that you all will be able to join us or if you have any questions about the logistics let us know we're actually the train's going to be loading up people in Lynchburg and then we're going to be going
07:16:52
to Roanoke.
07:16:53
The governor will actually be joining us on the train.
07:16:57
We'll be getting on closer to Roanoke.
07:16:59
And we'll have a celebratory event there on the platform.
07:17:04
So our team's working very hard at getting that going.
07:17:06
And thanks to court, it's been really helpful, as well as working with the city on that.
07:17:10
So again, that's on October 30.
07:17:13
And I do hope that you all will be able to hear what we're saying.
07:17:19
Well, very quickly as well, a lot of the discussion that we've been having just now about the rail plan and some of the issues of trade or morale of major corridors.
07:17:29
For those of you not on the rail committee, we're going to be bringing the full rail plan.
07:17:34
We'll be doing a briefing on that at the workshop in October.
07:17:38
We'd like to get an action on it in enforcing the final plan in December.
07:17:42
And a thank you to the rail committee who's been working with us on that for many months.
07:17:49
And that's all I got.
SPEAKER_03
07:17:52
Any questions for Charlie or Jennifer?
07:17:56
I just got a couple things.
07:17:57
A follow up to our last meeting, we got a retreat.
07:18:02
One of the things that I've asked Mr. Donohue and Mr. Walton to look at the policies and call the board has enacted over the years are things that are no longer should be in place.
07:18:18
So we will have that action done before the end of the year where we'll come to you and I don't know if the formula will take, whether we get rid of them all and just re-enact the ones that we recommend to stay or however, but nonetheless we're going through a cleanup of all the policies of the board because some are just outdated.
07:18:37
It's been many years since that's been done.
07:18:40
Second thing is there's been a lot of talk in the news in regards to monuments and roads and the naming of them.
07:18:48
We've had some inquiries for the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
07:18:51
As you know, we typically can name roads primarily for those that have been deceased.
07:18:58
It's been our policy and honor if we get a resolution from one of the localities in that regard.
07:19:07
Whether or not we have the right to rename roads is something I'm not going to revisit.
07:19:13
And we've had some inquiries as to whether or not some of those roads should be renamed
07:19:18
I think any of those decisions are for elected officials, and only if directed by an elected body by the General Assembly would I bring anything to your attention.
07:19:31
I do not believe we've spent many years to assess politics and those things, and we're moving transportation forward.
07:19:37
So I just want to let you know, as chairman, that's what I plan to do.
07:19:47
That will be nothing coming in front of the board in that regard.
07:19:52
I'll just let you, because I know that some of you may get questions in that.
07:19:56
I don't view that as our role in terms of that issue.
07:20:02
So, nonetheless, I think that's all the updates that I have unless you have any questions for us.
07:20:13
Okay, Ms. Sperbo has been sitting back there quietly for a while.
07:20:17
We've got a few minutes and I know you've got a few slides.
07:20:20
Are you prepared to take a few slides?
07:20:24
Let's go to Northern Virginia quickly and then we'll... Not much has gone on up here.
SPEAKER_05
07:20:31
So Northern Virginia is a very diverse region as you all know.
07:20:36
On the western part of Northern Virginia we have farmland, gravel roads, lots of wineries and those kind of things.
07:20:43
On our eastern side, we do have a very urban area with dense populations.
07:20:49
They rely heavily on multi-modal.
07:20:51
And multi-modal here can be sluggers, metros, VREs, bike share.
07:20:57
Some of our trails have several thousand people a day using them.
07:21:02
So we use every mode we possibly can to get our people around.
07:21:05
We have five cities in 14 towns along with Fairfax, Louden, Prince William, and Arlington County.
07:21:11
And we have over 13,000 lane miles for our 2.4 million citizens.
07:21:17
We have 1,400 traffic signals.
07:21:19
That's about half of the traffic signals in the state.
07:21:23
And we have 24 parking rides for those sluggers to coordinate and gather any van poles out of.
07:21:28
So we are very multimodal.
07:21:31
We really rely critically on that.
07:21:33
And so we can't emphasize enough how important that is to our region.
07:21:39
At any given time, we have about $600 million worth of construction contracts underway.
07:21:44
That's using federal funds, state funds, MPA funds, local funds.
07:21:49
We administer projects that are partnerships and work very closely with our localities to accomplish them.
07:21:56
Those are just our regular design good build and design build.
07:21:59
That doesn't count our mega projects.
07:22:01
That's a completely different category.
07:22:02
And last fiscal year, we were 98% on time.
07:22:06
40 out of 41 projects were done on time.
07:22:08
We're very proud of that with the amount of work that we have and the congestion we have.
07:22:13
Bill Cutler did a great job in our region.
07:22:17
Some projects we just recently are wrapping up is in the 66 Route 15 in Haymarket area, we did a divergent diamond.
07:22:25
This was a design build that didn't start out as a divergent diamond, but the contractor and his designers
07:22:30
I really looked into it and convinced us that that was the way to go.
07:22:34
And it has worked very, very well for that region.
07:22:37
And it's very nice to have a road that's not separating the area.
07:22:41
It's at grade and allows people to get to one side to the other very conveniently without blocking and being a major structure.
07:22:50
We also have 28 spot widening that MBTA funded in coordination with Fairfax and Loudon.
07:22:56
And so we completed some work on that corridor.
07:23:01
Loudoun County, we're in partnership with Metcalfe in Washington Airport for me, Loudoun County in VDOT, we have a $113 million project.
07:23:07
It's about a five mile project that really connects 7 to Route 50.
07:23:12
It's a huge, huge change for that region.
07:23:15
A lot of congestion, a lot of homes have been built in that region, so there's been roads have been catching up.
07:23:20
That's been a major, major endeavor, and we did open the urban cutting the other day and opened a major link in that project.
07:23:29
We do care about our bicyclists and pedestrians, but we've done some work recently.
07:23:33
We have a great separated interchange that we just opened up to separate the bicyclists on the WNLD trail from the traffic.
07:23:41
We are patching and we are picking some of our trails because Fairfax County Parkway and Richmond Parkway have a pretty significant trail users, so we're trying to get that up to date so that they don't fall further into disrepair.
07:23:53
And we're doing some things at Route 7 and Dulles Toll Road near the Metro to make sure that the pedestrians and the bicyclists can get across and don't get into cars, they get on their bikes or they walk.
07:24:04
A major project, SMART SCALE, we have Route 7 corridor, it's about a seven mile project.
07:24:08
It's a very large project that's out for RFP.
07:24:12
So we're excited about that, getting that underway hopefully next year.
07:24:15
We're working with Fairfax County on Richmond Highway where they're working on a bus rapid transit
07:24:21
We are doing the road project and leaving the median open for the BRT. So we are working very closely with them to accomplish some improvements that we are at one quarter. I won't go into the major projects, I think everybody is pretty familiar with the major projects. And we are working very hard to bring our secondary roads up to Snuff. We have 13,000 lane miles. Thank you.
07:24:45
And the secondary system is far behind in what we'd like to see as far as grading it.
07:24:50
And so we're working very hard, using whatever money we can to improve that revenue network.
07:24:55
And that's it for the meeting.
SPEAKER_03
07:24:58
Thank you, Helen.
07:25:01
Any particular questions of Helen?
07:25:03
We didn't have tours, I think, over the years.
07:25:05
We've had lots of tours.
07:25:08
And we're going to be out on site Wednesday for those of you attending with the governor.
07:25:15
Great size.
07:25:16
I want to thank Mr. Malbon and Mr. Rosen came last night to the open house, besides Mr. Kasprowicz's tail.
07:25:28
I'll take it from last night to the town hall, which is pretty well attended.
07:25:35
I want to thank you for all that you do, Charlie.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
07:25:52
W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
07:26:22
In terms of mileage, we maintain the third largest in the country behind North Carolina and Texas.
07:26:35
Texas is one, North Carolina is different than the third largest.
07:26:40
Again, one of the things that we're doing in Virginia is a tremendous amount of secondary mileage.
07:26:47
And we call them secondary
07:26:50
All these four-lane roads that you see around us here are secondary roads.
07:26:55
Very few of the roads here in Reston are on the primary system.
SPEAKER_03
07:27:08
They have about a thousand more.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
07:27:10
That's pretty close.
07:27:12
North Carolina's got a million more people, and I wonder if there's something about 10% larger than the rest of the road.
SPEAKER_03
07:27:20
McPherson Jr., John F. McPherson Jr.,
07:27:49
Okay, is there anything else in the workshop?
07:28:12
I think Mr.
SPEAKER_04
07:28:24
I guess this evening is casual this evening.
SPEAKER_03
07:28:28
So I'll give you about a couple of hours of some free time and we'll have some entertainment this evening.
07:28:35
I don't know if you can turn on the view control today.
07:28:38
We're going to have the pressure on, but we'll see if we got that.
07:28:41
It is done live, so if I can get a look at that.
07:28:47
I can see all you all putting that down right now, except we're not doing 7 o'clock.
SPEAKER_13
07:28:50
So anyway, so.
07:28:51
I'm moderated by Chuck.
SPEAKER_03
07:28:53
It should be a good fact.
07:28:56
All right, well, with that, we will...