Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 3/18/2015
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   3/18/2015

Attachments
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Agency performance management.pdf
  • Fiscal Years 2016 – 2021 Outlook Preliminary Six-Year Financial Plan Strategies for the Six-Year Improvement Program.pdf
  • Broad Street Bus Rapid Transit Project.pdf
  • House Bill 2 update.pdf
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:00:01
      Oliver, go ahead.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:00:17
      Welcome, everyone, to the March workshop session.
    • 00:00:22
      We are going to have just one day of meetings today.
    • 00:00:24
      So the workshop will start just in a few minutes, and then we will have a formal action meeting after that.
    • 00:00:32
      But as we do always, if you all please stand and stay, our pleasure will lead us.
    • 00:00:37
      Thank you.
    • 00:00:47
      I do know, I did receive word from both Mr. Connors and Mr. Cole
    • 00:00:58
      That for personal reasons they will not be attending today, but I think we have more like many I guess Sonny's not here too, but I think
    • 00:01:11
      I did receive from Mr. Dyke, he's watching and I assume he'll be texting Mrs. Dyke.
    • 00:01:38
      So anyway, we do have a quorum.
    • 00:01:41
      We decided to have one day-to-day.
    • 00:01:44
      We've been going at it pretty strong, but I think from here on out you can expect two days.
    • 00:01:50
      But the one exception, we do not need an office if we have one break, but there will be two days.
    • 00:01:55
      I also want to apologize to the board.
    • 00:01:58
      Some of the stuff got to you later than I would like.
    • 00:02:04
      There's nothing in here that we're going to vote on today.
    • 00:02:07
      All this information will be useful to you for votes you'll take.
    • 00:02:10
      Next time, in terms of, we started looking at the plan.
    • 00:02:15
      So, we planned to not have make this, but with the session lining up, the legislation and all, we sort of got behind the eight ball a little bit.
    • 00:02:24
      But, nothing is going to be voted on if you haven't, whether you're going to be, you know, this information, particularly Mr. Lawson's 60-slide presentation, will not be voted on anything today.
    • 00:02:37
      The other thing we will do in addition to the agenda and the workshop, there's a couple of other topics that probably need some discussion that we may talk about and some of the legislation that actually got passed.
    • 00:02:51
      I know Mr. Lawson had a little bit in his presentation, but I would ask you to continue a deep discussion on that maybe afterwards if you want in that regard.
    • 00:03:00
      I want to update people on where we are on 66, the project.
    • 00:03:04
      We did announce inside the beltway this past week, of course, outside the beltway, so I want to make sure people understand where we are, what path we're going down with that.
    • 00:03:17
      And then I think, truly, Mr. Kilpatrick, we do have, in relation to that, there may be some monies we may need to move around to get the planning going on that.
    • 00:03:29
      It's not critical we want to vote on it.
    • 00:03:30
      We'll brief you.
    • 00:03:31
      If you don't want to vote on it until next time, that's okay.
    • 00:03:33
      But it's pretty administrative in nature.
    • 00:03:35
      But as we go through that discussion, we'll bring that up.
    • 00:03:38
      So that's what our plan is today.
    • 00:03:40
      Carol will let us know when it's time to eat.
    • 00:03:43
      And we'll take a break on that.
    • 00:03:46
      But with that, we'll call up our first
    • 00:03:49
      in character, I'm sorry, participant, and we have Chief Engineer Garrett Moore and he's going to talk a little bit about some of the things we talked about last time, our performance and how we're aligning our money.
    • 00:04:02
      So welcome, Mr. Moore.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:05
      Mr. Connors is online too.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:04:06
      Okay, so thanks for him for joining too.
    • 00:04:10
      So, Garrett.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:04:12
      Thank you, sir.
    • 00:04:12
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 00:04:15
      Last month we talked about state of good repair and tried to give you a policy overview of where we think we need to go and Mr. Cole had brought some issues up about how does performance work into that and so what I'm going to try to do today is give you all a glimpse because once you get below the policy level into the execution level there's a lot more detail to it but give you some samples of what we do in our performance management so it's not meant to be complete
    • 00:04:43
      Because we could spend all day on this, but it'll just give you a glimpse and kind of see what we're doing when we are executing the policy that you all give us.
    • 00:04:54
      And the first thing that is available to you and actually to the public is our external dashboard.
    • 00:05:01
      And our external dashboard is something that we are graded publicly on, and it has many of the things that are our core thing.
    • 00:05:10
      You can see safety is down there, condition,
    • 00:05:12
      And there's a lot of drill-downs in these things and also it talks about projects on time and on budget.
    • 00:05:18
      And this is something we've been measuring for over a decade, all of these things in here.
    • 00:05:22
      It's changed a little bit over time, but it's something that's been measured for quite a while.
    • 00:05:27
      And you can go on the website and your district engineer should be briefing you on some of these things and kind of letting you know where things go.
    • 00:05:35
      But it's out there and it's available and you can see the actual website is there if you ever want to go in there.
    • 00:05:40
      and my father used to actually, before he passed away, would actually go in there when I was a district administrator, a resident engineer and look and see what I, it was like a report card.
    • 00:05:49
      So it was one of these things that, and yeah, I didn't always like what the report card said, but you knew what was there and you knew what you needed to improve.
    • 00:05:55
      So it's something I think within the field of VDOT and certainly I as a, coming up through certain levels of leadership, we embraced it and I think it's pretty firmly embraced by our folks.
    • 00:06:06
      It's a good tool.
    • 00:06:08
      One of the things that we have done over time with this within the engineering director in the field is we have done several things in how we measure.
    • 00:06:18
      And the first is that it's outcome based.
    • 00:06:21
      This doesn't measure how you get there.
    • 00:06:23
      It measures outcomes.
    • 00:06:25
      Was it on time or not?
    • 00:06:27
      Is it this condition or not?
    • 00:06:30
      And those things are pretty objective.
    • 00:06:31
      There's very little subjectivity to those things.
    • 00:06:35
      And that way it's an outcome and we're not measuring
    • 00:06:38
      You know, Rube Goldberg type of processes, we're measuring what does it look like in the end.
    • 00:06:43
      The other is that it's objective in those.
    • 00:06:46
      And then the other thing we've tried to do is make sure that they're simply and easily measured.
    • 00:06:51
      It may be that it would be better for us to measure something else, but it's too hard to do.
    • 00:06:56
      So we might have something else that tracks it and there's a few indicators of that.
    • 00:07:00
      And we've also, there might be five things we like to measure, but we measure one because that might be an indicator of all of them.
    • 00:07:08
      The other thing that's important is these are very mature and they have clear and defined business rules.
    • 00:07:15
      And you can see the last one with data integrity, I'd say that's very good as well.
    • 00:07:19
      Now data integrity is never perfect.
    • 00:07:21
      You know, we're always sitting there asking the question, you know, should you measure it this way or should you...
    • 00:07:26
      But in recent years, we have not been changing the business rules on these very much.
    • 00:07:30
      They've stabilized.
    • 00:07:31
      We know what our core business is.
    • 00:07:33
      And that's a good thing because then you can have a baseline in the last few years that you can measure against.
    • 00:07:38
      So that's the things we do.
    • 00:07:40
      But moving right along, there's a few things I'd like to point out.
    • 00:07:44
      And this is going down into just one area, project delivery.
    • 00:07:47
      And that on there, if you look at up there, it's got my name for the state.
    • 00:07:54
      And next to it, it's got Terry Bates, the state construction engineer.
    • 00:07:58
      And as a former commissioner, Shookette used to say, that's the one net.
    • 00:08:02
      So I'm responsible for this stuff statewide.
    • 00:08:06
      Kerry Bates is the State Construction Engineer, and I'm on three or four of these things, he's on one, but that way you know who to reach out to statewide, who is responsible for it.
    • 00:08:16
      I think that's important, and recently we just put the division name on there too, to show their ownership to it, and that's very important.
    • 00:08:25
      The other thing that it does with things like this is it develops credibility.
    • 00:08:29
      If you go to the upper right hand corner where it's got project delivery, and you look at 2000, 2001,
    • 00:08:35
      We were delivering 27% of our projects on time and about 55% on budget.
    • 00:08:41
      And people used to say trade time for money.
    • 00:08:44
      And what that did in those days is we had something called a calendar day project.
    • 00:08:50
      And somebody would bid that, but then they'd get weather time or delay time.
    • 00:08:53
      And so we would tell a county or a locality or the state, this project's going to be done on this day, and then it's not done until 18 months or two years later.
    • 00:09:04
      Our credibility was terrible with this.
    • 00:09:06
      And so what we find, you know, three or four or five years later, once we start measuring it, and what we also did is we went to fixed-date contracts.
    • 00:09:15
      In other words, the contract completion date was the contract completion date.
    • 00:09:19
      And we set goals in the high 70s or low 80s.
    • 00:09:22
      We didn't set them at 100 percent because we didn't want to push people to cheat or to make the wrong business decision because there are exceptions where you've got to do that.
    • 00:09:31
      But we found that we stabilized
    • 00:09:32
      Up there in the high 70s, high 80s, some districts get higher than that and you can see the budget is 91%.
    • 00:09:41
      One of the things that happens is we use incentive more.
    • 00:09:45
      That helps us.
    • 00:09:46
      We have less people riding the jobs anymore so we hit that point where we're trying to finish them as quickly as we can but at the same time and resourcing that way but not so quick as to impede traffic or make it
    • 00:10:03
      So that it's too difficult to move while you're building it.
    • 00:10:06
      That's kind of a tension on developing the time a project should be.
    • 00:10:10
      You want to make it as quick as you can, but you don't want to make it so quick that the people can't use the road.
    • 00:10:15
      And that's a friction that we, a tension that we work all the time.
    • 00:10:19
      The other thing is that we use incentive more for early completion.
    • 00:10:23
      That works very well.
    • 00:10:24
      It's not a race to the bottom.
    • 00:10:25
      That's changed some of the ways things happen.
    • 00:10:28
      And the other thing that I'm kind of proud of is in Virginia, if you're a minute late, the project's late.
    • 00:10:33
      There are some states that they count, and I can think of one state where they had 599 to 600 projects that were on top, and I said, who's kidding who?
    • 00:10:42
      But what they do is if there's any sort of weather problem, they give them an extension, and that to us was just a recipe for disaster, not disaster, but to pencil whip this thing.
    • 00:10:53
      So we've said in Virginia we're going to have a very strict standard on ourselves.
    • 00:10:57
      If we're a minute late or a day late, we're going to be late and just count it that way.
    • 00:11:02
      If you have to make a business decision, it happens sometimes, we're going to be late because the conditions were different and we really need to take care of this.
    • 00:11:10
      Just bite the bullet and we'll be 95% instead of 100%.
    • 00:11:14
      And that's kind of the way that we approach that in doing it.
    • 00:11:17
      This is not an excuse to make a bad business decision on the project.
    • 00:11:20
      And we tell our folks, you don't get to use that excuse either.
    • 00:11:24
      You've got to be on time.
    • 00:11:26
      a certain amount of the time above that goal and do it consistently year to year and you have to make the right business decision.
    • 00:11:36
      But I think this has really helped with our credibility with the localities.
    • 00:11:40
      It is very fairly rare now that we have a project that's late and even with one being late, it's usually a matter of days or weeks and it's usually not that visible to the public.
    • 00:11:50
      So it makes it very easy for them to plan and helpful for us
    • 00:11:55
      The other thing it does is it puts discipline there in what we do, you know, on time, on budget, and that's something that our organization continues to work on.
    • 00:12:04
      The other thing, and I'm mainly showing this, this happens to be Stanton District, and the main reason I'm showing this slide is if you look at the upper right-hand corner, it's got Randy Kaiser, as Mr. Whitworth works with, and so for every district that you go to, the district administrator, his name is on there, and he owns that, and we're proud of that because to the public, that's our report book.
    • 00:12:25
      In many ways, it's overtaken our written performance evaluation because it's out there and from the public.
    • 00:12:32
      And again, it's our report card that we're proud of.
    • 00:12:35
      That's all to the public and it's on our core items.
    • 00:12:39
      There's some other things that we do internally that I'm just going to show you some portions of it because we measure some things that we show to the public.
    • 00:12:48
      There's a lot of other internal stuff that we measure that is not necessarily all core stuff.
    • 00:12:54
      But it's important in what we do.
    • 00:12:56
      And there's even more than this because we can tell if things are trending up or down.
    • 00:12:59
      And this is what is known affectionately in the department as the bingo car.
    • 00:13:06
      And this is, if you can see, if you're green on there, you're doing well.
    • 00:13:09
      And I think this is actually a few months old or maybe earlier in the year.
    • 00:13:13
      If you're doing red in an area, you're not doing so well.
    • 00:13:15
      And if you look up there, there are one, two districts that are all green.
    • 00:13:23
      There's a couple of others that have one red, and it is very difficult to hit all green with this.
    • 00:13:32
      There are three districts that have hit it for a certain period of time, and generally it's very difficult to stay there.
    • 00:13:39
      But if you hit green and you stay there for a few months, you're doing very, very well.
    • 00:13:43
      So, and I'll throw the plugs out to them because there are tremendous staffs there that have done it.
    • 00:13:48
      Stanton, Goldpepper, and Lynchburg have hit.
    • 00:13:51
      Aubrey, Lynchburg, and Stanton have done it multiple times.
    • 00:13:55
      And it's something that, like I said, that takes to be, to do it in all those areas.
    • 00:14:01
      And that doesn't mean others aren't doing well because some of these are legacy things that they're improving over the years.
    • 00:14:06
      But it's, I can show you the next slide, or a couple slides from now and you'll see why that's important.
    • 00:14:13
      I have a quarterly performance meeting where the district engineers and the central office engineering staff, others are invited, but I also bring in the residencies and the staff by video.
    • 00:14:24
      And we do this once a quarter, and we focus on these things, the core areas, the areas that we talked about like in State of Good Repair, but it also includes safety, both internal safety, worker safety, and traffic safety.
    • 00:14:36
      And we are making progress in bringing traffic deaths down.
    • 00:14:41
      A lot of that's to the auto industry, but we're working at it too.
    • 00:14:44
      The other thing that I haven't put on there is congestion.
    • 00:14:47
      We're working on that too.
    • 00:14:48
      You know, speed of travel and so forth.
    • 00:14:51
      Those are the focus areas in that quarterly presentation.
    • 00:14:56
      And they brief about six minutes, and everybody in the state knows who's doing what.
    • 00:15:01
      And the whole idea there is to get everybody, even the people that aren't in the engineering director, focused on what our core goals are, focused on progress, and seeing how they
    • 00:15:11
      How they're part of the effort supports that.
    • 00:15:14
      The other thing, this is one of the drill downs and we have several in there, I'm not going to show them all, but this is the one on bridges and you can see there's a number of different areas and it's not everything, but one of the things we do is we track our progress on whether we're improving structurally deficient bridges and you can see over time that we are doing that and the bottom line is
    • 00:15:36
      has the culverts in there.
    • 00:15:37
      The top line is, I'm sorry, the top line has the culverts in there.
    • 00:15:40
      Bottom line has bridges only, which is the larger structures.
    • 00:15:44
      We are improving both of them.
    • 00:15:47
      As I've said in the last brief, a lot of that is low-hanging fruit.
    • 00:15:51
      We're getting up to 57 structures in the interstate.
    • 00:15:53
      We're getting up to some hard lines that we're going to have to think differently and work some things to do that.
    • 00:15:58
      But this shows some of the drill-downs we can do.
    • 00:16:01
      You also can drill down, if you go back to the dashboard,
    • 00:16:04
      your district engineer can show you how to drill down within the district how they're doing and track their progress so we do this down to that level and at one time you could even do it to the residency not this line but show the difference and again very important stuff and something that again you just have visibility that's out there not everything in here can you get but you can see the status of bridges by district on the top but this this lower chart
    • 00:16:32
      It's not exactly the same, but you can track that by district and track the progress.
    • 00:16:41
      This also is very similar in that it's more drill downs that we do, and if you go to the lower right-hand corner, one of the things we track is the difference between how many bridges came on structurally deficient and how many came off, and we can do that by district.
    • 00:16:58
      We can also track the PMs.
    • 00:17:00
      So that they're doing the preventive maintenance.
    • 00:17:02
      And again, I don't mean for you to go through all of this, but it just shows you the kind of detail.
    • 00:17:07
      We do similar things in safety, similar things in pavement and so forth.
    • 00:17:14
      And one thing here is that it shows that we've used the small bridge program basically to replace small bridges with state forces at generally 60% of cost.
    • 00:17:25
      It saves us design costs.
    • 00:17:27
      It saves us often right of way.
    • 00:17:29
      and it saves us an awful lot.
    • 00:17:30
      The construction industry does much better and much cheaper at medium and large structures.
    • 00:17:36
      We do it cheaper at small structures and it's just, you know, it's just got us to the right place where we can get the right money and the most cost effective way to do what we need to do because we don't have a lot of room for error on this.
    • 00:17:48
      And this was not done in all the districts, you know, eight or ten years ago.
    • 00:17:53
      And what they've done is started copying each other on what's successful.
    • 00:17:57
      And not every district's the same.
    • 00:17:59
      I mean Hampton Roads has an awful lot of large water crossings.
    • 00:18:03
      They can still do some of this, but it's not as much as you would in the western part of the state where you're at the headwaters and most of the bridges are smaller.
    • 00:18:10
      So there are some differences in the districts, but this is one way that you can get some results.
    • 00:18:16
      The reason we wanted to show the bingo card is this goes again to the what is measured gets done.
    • 00:18:22
      And this isn't all of them.
    • 00:18:24
      Like I said, this is just a sampling, or maybe it does happen.
    • 00:18:27
      But if you can see from 2012, and the reason we picked that to 2015 is there has not been a lot of change in how we look at these things.
    • 00:18:35
      But you can see that we've gone from red to green from 61 reds to 23 reds in February of 2015.
    • 00:18:44
      So when people are looking at it and they're comparing it, and I don't even think it's so much me coming in and saying, you know, you've got a
    • 00:18:51
      You've got to fix this.
    • 00:18:53
      It's almost, it's pure competition.
    • 00:18:56
      Nobody wants to be the guy with the most reds.
    • 00:18:59
      And that's a good environment to be in as long as it's positive.
    • 00:19:02
      I mean, people aren't pulling the rug out from each other, but they are looking and trying to make sure and watching it all the time.
    • 00:19:08
      The other thing that it does is there's a tendency to always have urgent things come to you.
    • 00:19:16
      You get a citizen call, you get a political call, you get this or that.
    • 00:19:19
      But the real important stuff that sometimes prevents those calls from happening gets ignored because this brings everybody back to our poor business.
    • 00:19:29
      So you have to review this and do it.
    • 00:19:31
      And that, I think, helps us out with the citizen calls because if we have better payment, we have less potholes and we get less calls.
    • 00:19:39
      If we don't close bridges, we get less calls because the bridge is cold.
    • 00:19:42
      And you bring that into a tighter condition
    • 00:19:45
      where we're not handling the urgent stuff as much because we've paid attention to what's important.
    • 00:19:53
      I bring this one up because this is less mature and I'm not as directly involved in this, but since Quinton's taken over as the Chief Deputy Commissioner, he has instituted the same, a similar bingo card to the business areas and how they support executing the job.
    • 00:20:09
      This is not mature, and that's the reason we're not showing a lot with it.
    • 00:20:13
      The data integrity is probably not there yet.
    • 00:20:17
      But even though this is less than a year old, maybe nine months old, we took one thing out here, and that's the phase closeout for closing the books.
    • 00:20:29
      And we've actually found that even though we haven't settled on everything, once we started looking at it and measuring, very quickly the closeouts went from
    • 00:20:38
      What in the nation probably isn't very good, it's not just our state, but probably not as good as it should have been, to we're becoming one of the leaders in the nation about closing out our flux.
    • 00:20:48
      We've got a ways to go, but immediately we started seeing progress, and Quentin and the financial guys, they've really done a good job, and the programming guys on doing that over a matter of three to six months.
    • 00:20:58
      The measure may not be completely flushed out, but just the idea of looking at it,
    • 00:21:02
      You know we've seen progress and probably maybe three years or four years from now to be mature enough that we'll just track it, track it to month to month or quarter to quarter.
    • 00:21:11
      And again this is, that's the brief and again the key to us is getting everybody focused on the long-term consistent improvement of the important stuff and we need to do the urgent but we need to not let it take over from what's actually important and that's kind of how we manage and then that fits up to meeting your
    • 00:21:31
      policy goals that you give us.
    • 00:21:33
      And that's it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:21:34
      Thank you, sir.
    • 00:21:36
      So just a comment on this.
    • 00:21:37
      Part of this is to show as we move from the legislation and aligning our pots of money that we have the procedures in place for VDOT to perform.
    • 00:21:46
      And obviously, you know, you're not going to be responsible looking at all these.
    • 00:21:51
      But we do want to make sure that we translate that all the way through to execution.
    • 00:21:57
      This really gets back to
    • 00:21:59
      You know, how many times VDOT has been reformed over the years?
    • 00:22:03
      Every time there's a new administration, there's a reclamation.
    • 00:22:06
      We chose governance and execution over reformation.
    • 00:22:10
      In other words, quit talking about it, let's do it.
    • 00:22:12
      And I think under the TILC Act, Chief Bishop of Conscious Leadership, and Garrett and the others, that's what we're focusing on.
    • 00:22:20
      Not doing another study as to
    • 00:22:22
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz Jr., John K. Matney Jr., John K. Kasprowicz Jr.,
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:22:45
      We go over them quarterly at a minimum.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:50
      We do them more often than that.
    • 00:22:53
      In fact, monthly.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:22:54
      But I'd say quarterly, they don't go over them monthly unless there's something that sticks out.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:23:01
      This is information for us as CTB members, because the line of responsibility is obviously VDOT, but for us then to go over quarterly with our district engineer would be
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:15
      Absolutely, absolutely.
    • 00:23:20
      We have been doing this for about four years now.
    • 00:23:25
      Commissioner Whirley, when I came back as the chief deputy commissioner, one of the things he wanted to re-institute were regular meetings with the district to go over their performance, which had not been done prior to Commissioner Whirley.
    • 00:23:39
      So we began this process and this came together pretty quickly.
    • 00:23:45
      One of the important things is, Garrett showed the change in red to green.
    • 00:23:49
      We didn't change the grading scale and this is something that we've been very conservative and strong on that we're not going to ease up on the grading scale.
    • 00:24:00
      If anything, we've actually raised the bar, especially in some of the pavement areas.
    • 00:24:04
      We set the bar a little bit higher because we believe we should be doing better.
    • 00:24:07
      And so the way we've measured it over the period of time is a consistent measurement and it's showing a positive trend.
    • 00:24:16
      But absolutely, this is something that I know the district engineers would be glad to go over, district specific.
    • 00:24:23
      And even this dashboard, that's the first screen you start clicking and you can really get into the details.
    • 00:24:32
      A. Kasprowicz Jr., John Malbon, John K. Matney,
    • 00:24:48
      They take this very seriously and it's a healthy competition.
    • 00:24:54
      We also are very strong on we're not gaining the system.
    • 00:24:59
      Back to the point of if it's one day late, which drives me crazy by the way, because my feeling is probably if it's a day late that we should have done something from months prior.
    • 00:25:11
      Don't do your homework the night before it's due.
    • 00:25:14
      So anyway, they don't get a pass for that.
    • 00:25:21
      So this is an excellent tool for the board just to get a feel for how things are going on in the district and at a corporate level.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:25:29
      I know Troy's speaking, but we're doing similar stuff at DRPT, working through, again, focusing on execution, not doing studies on reform.
    • 00:25:40
      And so, again, we don't have responsibility here.
    • 00:25:45
      The Port of Virginia, same type of thing we're going through.
    • 00:25:49
      So, again, I think that's really from, I think you're right, you guys should know
    • 00:25:55
      If you see something, obviously try to keep it responsible, but you ought to know what's going on.
    • 00:26:01
      I think what we can do is incorporate this into, I know Scott and I and Jim have monthly
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:26:08
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz, Steve Pittard Jr., John K. Matney, Steve Pittard Jr., John K. Matney,
    • 00:26:32
      We've used with citizens boards everybody to go, you know, it's a transparent thing that's out there that people can look at.
    • 00:26:38
      They don't that much anymore.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:26:44
      Just as a matter of interest, does our state compensation policy allow for merit adjustment based on performance?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:57
      Yes, there are provisions that allow for pay increases and for bonuses for performances that we have used.
    • 00:27:16
      Do we use it as extensively as the private world?
    • 00:27:20
      No.
    • 00:27:20
      This is kind of the structure of our government.
    • 00:27:24
      We don't have that flexibility.
    • 00:27:25
      We don't use it to the extent that I was used to it in private business.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:27:31
      Yeah, think about having a private business, there's a legislature, how many people it can have and how much money it can take.
    • 00:27:38
      So, it is utilized, we're trying to go through and of course, again, if you were asked that question before, the answer is much more because it's not, it's inhibited by some of the rules, but that's what we're really trying to do, execution and performance.
    • 00:27:55
      Tied together.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:27:59
      At what point does the clock start ticking on the project delivery?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:28:06
      I don't know if this answers the question, but most of these are tied to the fiscal year.
    • 00:28:14
      So 30th of June, any project that was completed in that fiscal year would count late or not, and then it starts over again for the projects that would finish the next fiscal year.
    • 00:28:24
      The safety ones are not necessarily that way because
    • 00:28:28
      Some of the systems that are external to VDOT that are nationwide for tracking fit out, they'll be calendar year, but most of these are fiscal year and for completion dates,
    • 00:28:39
      We score the projects that are, the contract completion date is within that fiscal year.
    • 00:28:45
      Then the clock starts again for the ones that would complete.
    • 00:28:48
      Does that answer the question?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:50
      And the completion date is the, it's not substantial completion, it's completion date.
    • 00:28:56
      So in the vertical world you use a term where you're basically completing, you can move in.
    • 00:29:01
      In our world, the punch list is complete for it to be complete, so we measure it differently.
    • 00:29:06
      When we say it's complete, there's a form that's called a C-5, a construction division form 5, which says the project is done, the punch list is done, we're preparing the final estimate.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:29:23
      Okay, Mr. Moore, thank you very much.
    • 00:29:27
      Very informative.
    • 00:29:28
      Mr. Lawson and Mr. Pittard,
    • 00:29:30
      We'll assume you'll go through these 60 slides relatively at a stage.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:29:38
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 00:29:39
      How are you feeling about today?
    • 00:29:40
      I'm getting there, slowly by slowly.
    • 00:29:42
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary and members of the board.
    • 00:29:47
      It's been some time since we have come to you with what I would call a transportation finance
    • 00:29:58
      Paulson Jr., John F. Kasprowicz Jr., John F. Kasprowicz Jr.,
    • 00:30:13
      At this point in time, Steve and I would typically come to you and just talk about what the funding looks like for the next six-year program.
    • 00:30:23
      We felt like this was a good opportunity just to take a short step back and just kind of reiterate how the revenues are determined and the programs are sized.
    • 00:30:36
      As the Secretary mentioned, I'm going to skip through this pretty quickly.
    • 00:30:39
      Hopefully you'll see this stack of 57 slides as a takeaway to help with understanding the process, and I'll certainly be glad to talk to you about any of this specific detail, and it may even point to things that you would like more specific discussion about at other meetings.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:31:01
      Just one comment on that.
    • 00:31:02
      This is my only comment about
    • 00:31:05
      You guys really should take this because this will be the basis of the Six-Year Plan.
    • 00:31:09
      I mean, we talk about projects all the time in the Six-Year Plan, but I want you to really understand how the monies flow in, what the ramifications are into the Six-Year Plan.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:31:21
      All right.
    • 00:31:23
      We prepare in VDOT what we call a six-year financial plan.
    • 00:31:27
      They're in total for determining or identifying the revenues that are available for programming to the transportation agencies over the upcoming six years.
    • 00:31:40
      We base it off of the official tax estimates or state revenues.
    • 00:31:46
      We use the best data we can get from some highway to do the federal revenue estimates
    • 00:31:51
      And then we look to the policies and the objectives of the agency heads and the board to determine how we allocate those programs within the parameters of the laws.
    • 00:32:07
      We also then, based off of the resources that are determined to be available from the Six-Year Financial Plan, we both do a Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 00:32:16
      This is the actual list of projects that we plan to fund over the six years.
    • 00:32:22
      We identify the timing of the projects, the funding that's being provided to the projects, and right down to the type of funding that will be used.
    • 00:32:37
      In terms of the plan in this upcoming cycle, the 16 through 21, this is really very much a transitional period.
    • 00:32:52
      The 2313 revenues are just getting fully implemented.
    • 00:32:57
      We are looking to HB2 prioritization.
    • 00:33:00
      As you know, we started with a revision last November to start pulling monies off of the HB2 eligible projects.
    • 00:33:09
      And then we're looking at now the new structure, the revenue structure and the program structure that's been implemented or will be implemented by 1887.
    • 00:33:20
      starting now, but not fully implemented until 2021, which is the last year of this upcoming program.
    • 00:33:32
      points related to 1887, and we've talked about 1887 on and off during sessions, but I just want to point to some of the key aspects of it in the bill as it was enrolled. As you all know, it increases the independence of this body. You are now, can only be removed by cause, and...
    • 00:33:54
      Obviously that puts you in hopefully a position to where you are more able to speak your thoughts and question as you should.
    • 00:34:05
      The bill also is aimed at addressing funding to transit capital.
    • 00:34:14
      It restructured some of the key programs within the construction side of the house.
    • 00:34:20
      For the first time, statutorily dedicating monies to the state of good repair, as well as creating two programs for capacity type improvements, one constrained at a statewide level and the other being monies to local governments through a district grant program.
    • 00:34:44
      1887 doesn't create new revenue.
    • 00:34:48
      We've been building off of the successes of HB 2313 that did create additional revenues for transportation.
    • 00:34:56
      But what was done with 1887 was kind of a re-look at how those revenues are being used.
    • 00:35:02
      And it was determined that there needs to be a greater focus on the transit side of the house.
    • 00:35:07
      So you will see that there were some kind of three things within the 1887 that redirects portions of existing tax revenues
    • 00:35:18
      K. Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine, L. C. One other thing, another thing that was done by the bill was, it certainly doesn't rank up there in the magnitude of the other issues, but it does take the revenues that are previously provided to be told with a revolving account
    • 00:35:47
      and redistributes them to Transportation Infrastructure Bank and to the Partnership Opportunity Fund.
    • 00:35:53
      Just by way of a little history, the total solar revolving account was created back in the mid-'80s and it's funded by the interest earnings on the major highway account and the intent of this fund was to be able to support start-up toll facilities.
    • 00:36:12
      VDOT would own and operate.
    • 00:36:17
      It has facilitated Coleman Bridge, Ballot Parkway, and others for years, but it was believed that we really reached the point in time where VDOT startup tow facilities are probably not likely to be very frequent, and that the monies would be more beneficial
    • 00:36:36
      If they were included in the infrastructure bank or the partnership opportunity fund to support governments and the private sector bring forward transportation solutions more affordably and quicker than they would otherwise.
    • 00:36:53
      I mentioned earlier there were three new programs created for the highway construction formula.
    • 00:36:59
      The 40-30-30 primary-secondary urban formula will be phased out as of 2021.
    • 00:37:05
      It does not exist and it will be replaced by a formula that would distribute, as I mentioned, monies to those three categories.
    • 00:37:16
      And I'll speak a little more to each of those a little later.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:37:19
      Just a question.
    • 00:37:21
      It's about $11 million a year that runs through the total facilities account.
    • 00:37:26
      Yes, so about December 8th is going to go to the BTIF, which we never had a dedicated funding source before, in which we make decisions on what we being the Board has to allocate monies for loans and stuff.
    • 00:37:39
      The other three million or so into the Opportunity Fund from the Governor is, you know, everything's got to go through House Bill 2.
    • 00:37:47
      This allows if we get a very significant Economic Development Act, a new mobile plan or something like that, we need two or three million dollars to get a road in or we have the money to do it without having to come and go through House Bill 2 and take it in that regard.
    • 00:38:05
      So that's what the thinking is there behind John mentioning that it's not anticipated VDOT is going to be in the tolling business in the future.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:38:13
      Yes, how much in there now, John?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:38:17
      How much in the account now?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:38:18
      There's 10 million or so of unallocated dollars.
    • 00:38:23
      Right.
    • 00:38:24
      There's some significant monies that are committed that haven't been spent.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:38:28
      Right.
    • 00:38:28
      About 130 million.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:38:29
      About 130 in total in cash.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:38:33
      It depends on what goes with those projects.
    • 00:38:35
      That may be freed up, but we'll bring that to your attention as to what the recommendation would be to do with those monies.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:38:45
      So with that backdrop, turning now to just looking at the upcoming six-year plan.
    • 00:38:50
      The six-year financial plan identifies about $33 billion of total revenues and other financing sources.
    • 00:38:58
      These sources are a combination of state taxes and fees, which is about 60% of the total. We have the regional taxes and fees, which is about another 10% of the monies, and then federal apportionments, and then we have a contribution from the issuance of bonds. Thank you very much. Thank you.
    • 00:39:19
      I have a slide on the totals a little bit further into the slides.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:39:26
      On the regional state taxes and fees under HB 2313, my understanding was we don't program that money.
    • 00:39:36
      So why is it as part of our funding?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:39:43
      Chairman, Mr. Fralin, because they are a state tax,
    • 00:39:48
      They are forecasted by the Department of Taxation.
    • 00:39:53
      They are collected as a state tax revenue and as the, I call it the liaison agency.
    • 00:39:59
      VDOT, the monies are appropriated through the budget bill, the appropriation act, to VDOT as a pass through, in essence.
    • 00:40:08
      And then we will pass the monies on to...
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:40:11
      It's just a pass through on our books.
    • 00:40:13
      We show up coming in and then we show when they're programmed projects through the local weight when they put them back on.
    • 00:40:23
      Thank you.
    • 00:40:23
      Yeah, we have, but you were right, we have no, I shouldn't say no control, we, how they're spent, we certainly control the facilities they're spent on.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:40:32
      That's one of the things you want to link to later in the meeting.
    • 00:40:34
      Yes, that's right, yes.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:40:37
      It is.
    • 00:40:37
      It's a good point.
    • 00:40:38
      We don't, we don't make the decision as to how those products, those money are spent.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:43
      And it does show up on our, as he said, it passes through our books as part of the budget process.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:40:49
      I just wonder is there any downside to doing that because I don't understand how it works with the federal government and it makes our transportation budget, our state transportation budget look larger than it is and I don't know of any downside to that but it just does.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:41:07
      Well it's still state transportation budget.
    • 00:41:10
      It's just not available for statewide usage.
    • 00:41:14
      So in other words, I understand what you're saying, but it's not a state, it's still part of our state, both those regions are part of a state.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:41:23
      Of course they are, but... You're talking about control versus...
    • 00:41:27
      Exactly, exactly.
    • 00:41:29
      And my understanding was they had to set it up that way or the taxes would be unconstitutional.
    • 00:41:35
      Right.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:41:36
      No, the General Assembly had to levy the taxes, which they did.
    • 00:41:41
      And therefore, we're their collection agent and their administrator.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:41:45
      It's probably a distinction with that difference.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:41:47
      I don't think it has any impact on federal revenues in that regard.
    • 00:41:54
      But that's why it's on there.
    • 00:41:56
      But it's a revenue and expenditure
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:42:00
      In terms of the major revenue sources or state revenue sources, I highlighted the top five here.
    • 00:42:19
      You can see the retail sales and use tax is now the largest.
    • 00:42:23
      Martin, John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr.,
    • 00:42:36
      We tell sales and uses has become their largest single revenue source, and you can see the other categories here that make up those major components.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:42:45
      Mr. Chairman, I don't want to be pedantic or belabor the point, but in these numbers, $6.7 billion, does that include the regional revenues?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:42:54
      It does not.
    • 00:42:54
      It does not.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:42:55
      See, that's, I mean, why not?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:42:58
      That is the retail, the numbers you see here
    • 00:43:01
      B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:43:17
      You could put them in there.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:43:19
      I'm just worried about consistency, that's all.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:43:22
      You probably should be.
    • 00:43:24
      It just makes that sales and use tax even larger.
    • 00:43:27
      Correct.
    • 00:43:28
      But there are sales and use tax gaps in there.
    • 00:43:30
      But the key here is that
    • 00:43:33
      This has an implication, I'll tell you why.
    • 00:43:35
      Because we've gotten several requests from reporters saying that, oh, Virginia raised their gas taxes because they're not going to have federal money.
    • 00:43:44
      Absolutely not.
    • 00:43:45
      I don't think anybody who voted for 2313 thought they were taking the place of federal money.
    • 00:43:53
      But it should show that the federal dollars are becoming a lesser percentage of our overall budget because they haven't raised them since 1993.
    • 00:44:01
      D. R. P. T. But the intent is not to take what Virginia's done and say that's taken the place of our federal dollars.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:44:14
      That's a perfect segue.
    • 00:44:16
      As we talk about federal funds, we really are looking at federal funding from two sources.
    • 00:44:21
      So, highway administration, we think of mostly, say, three sources, but DRPT also is a recipient
    • 00:44:29
      F. T. A. and F. R. A.
    • 00:44:31
      Dollar, Southern Railroad, and Southern Transit.
    • 00:44:33
      Looking at, in terms of the entire $33 billion program, it's about 17% of the federal.
    • 00:44:42
      If I look at the core construction type activities, we're up to 35% of the total.
    • 00:44:50
      If you were to exclude the bond funded component of our budget, that number rises to over 40%.
    • 00:44:58
      So even though
    • 00:44:59
      That we mentioned, federal is less than 20% of the grand total budget.
    • 00:45:04
      It does provide about 40-ish percent of the capital-related funding to the program.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:45:14
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:45:15
      Oh, yes, Mr. Williams.
    • 00:45:16
      John, does the federal allocation, does it increase as we increase spending?
    • 00:45:23
      No, sir.
    • 00:45:24
      It's a flat, how much we're going to get?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:45:28
      You're reading ahead for me.
    • 00:45:32
      Appreciate it.
    • 00:45:32
      Oh, I'm sorry.
    • 00:45:32
      No, it's perfect.
    • 00:45:34
      Perfect question.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:45:34
      We wish it did, but it's not in-depth to our spending.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:45:37
      Exactly.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:45:39
      We wish it did.
    • 00:45:40
      I was reading the eligible project list.
    • 00:45:43
      I just wanted to clear up whether if we do more eligible projects, are we getting more?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:45:49
      No, sir.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:45:50
      It would just be less of a percentage.
    • 00:45:54
      The funding for the most part is apportioned.
    • 00:45:57
      to the states based on numerous formula, but it's obviously based upon their roads, etc.
    • 00:46:06
      It doesn't change unless there's more money available to be distributed.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:46:11
      Two points on that.
    • 00:46:12
      We're a donor state.
    • 00:46:14
      We only really receive about 93% or less, and this with VDOT, Mr. Walton, they've done a good job of getting bonus every year where other people around the country don't use
    • 00:46:25
      In fact, I think we found maybe one last year.
    • 00:46:29
      Yeah, we used it, but I'm just saying that's one of the issues we've lobbied for is it ought to be somehow proportional to how we spend and index to either inflation or something, but right now it's not.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:46:45
      Virginia shares about two and a half percent of the total pot, and for the purposes of this program, MAP21 is expiring.
    • 00:46:55
      As it's currently in law, it will expire at the end of May.
    • 00:47:01
      So there is nothing that would indicate the program will grow.
    • 00:47:06
      In fact, you could look at this and say it could fall.
    • 00:47:11
      Because if something isn't done to provide additional funding, there could be reductions.
    • 00:47:16
      In fact, the House GOP Budget Committee yesterday released their budget, which had about a 14% reduction
    • 00:47:25
      transportation related funding so we've taken the position in this program that transportation funding will be flat and we hope it will be better and at that time obviously we will recognize those monies and be able to plan to use them.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:47:41
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to make a quick point and then ask a question. The point being...
    • 00:47:49
      That if Washington cuts our money, our six-year plan is out of balance and we've got to go in and start cutting projects.
    • 00:47:55
      So I think the public needs to know that, needs to be aware of that.
    • 00:48:00
      The second question I've got is there's a perception out there that the feds fund 90% or 80% of interstate projects.
    • 00:48:12
      And that's just something I hear out there.
    • 00:48:15
      That's not true either.
    • 00:48:16
      They give us a flat number
    • 00:48:19
      That doesn't vary.
    • 00:48:20
      If we decided to build, I don't know, say 73.
    • 00:48:23
      They're not going to pay 90% of the cost.
    • 00:48:26
      We're going to have to figure out how to pay for that based on our federal allocation already.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:48:31
      That's something that people in my area do.
    • 00:48:34
      That's right.
    • 00:48:35
      We could choose to limit where we put federal money.
    • 00:48:39
      We could do that.
    • 00:48:40
      In fact, that's one of the things...
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:48:41
      But it's not a matching program.
    • 00:48:43
      It's not a matching program.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:48:44
      That's what I'm trying to... That's right.
    • 00:48:46
      In fact, one of the strategies that we've spoken of is potentially, and we can't do it now to take some time to look into it, is
    • 00:48:53
      Maybe we should just say this is going to be more of a federal project, so if we do have a cut, we don't cut lots of projects, we cut several projects. No, I agree with you, I mixed the questions. People need to understand that it's real money and that just because it's a federal road and a federal highway...
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:15
      That doesn't mean they're paying 90% of the cost. We don't get extra money. There is no extra money. We have programmed flat the federal allocation over the next six years. The only what we would call extra money is when we pursue what we call bonus obligation authority and that's a hit or miss.
    • 00:49:35
      There are some very limited grant programs, TIGER, the ARRA program, which is not, you know, is winding down now, but beyond that, there is no extra money from the federal government.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:49:47
      Because the perception is, it's like Medicaid.
    • 00:49:49
      The more you spend, the feds match it.
    • 00:49:51
      That's no incentive to spend money.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:49:54
      No, we have absolute dollars.
    • 00:49:56
      You'll see 900, whatever, millions, that's it.
    • 00:49:59
      Let me tell you something else while I wouldn't come back to this later too.
    • 00:50:02
      When I was testifying up there, another perception you made too, another one, that private money can fill the hole.
    • 00:50:11
      Absolutely not.
    • 00:50:12
      It's part of it, but it can't fill it all.
    • 00:50:14
      Private money is not going to fill when you're redoing a bridge without capacity.
    • 00:50:22
      McPherson,
    • 00:50:42
      They do not replace our federal dollars.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:50:44
      You mean there's not a lot of private money when we pay secondary roads?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:50:47
      Yeah, that's another perception out there.
    • 00:50:51
      The Cato Institute, all this money is going to come in, that's just untrue.
    • 00:50:56
      It's part of our procurement, and it's going to play a central role to our procurement, but only when it makes sense.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:05
      If I can add just one quick point which isn't covered here in John's slides but on the transit side there's actually one thing that's not covered because it's not actually part of the Transportation Trust Fund but is basically federal funds that go to expansion of transit projects and it's called the New Starts and Small Starts Program.
    • 00:51:25
      Sometimes these are ranging from $25 million a year to $50 million a year like the Broad Street BRT project or they can be major capital projects like
    • 00:51:34
      Delos-Rail.
    • 00:51:36
      That fund is actually funded out of general fund revenues at the federal level.
    • 00:51:41
      It doesn't actually receive gas tax revenues.
    • 00:51:43
      So that program itself is always on the chopping block every year at the congressional level.
    • 00:51:49
      It's a discretionary program.
    • 00:51:51
      It's not formula-based like the rest of our transit funds, but what it means is that for our local transit operators that are competing for federal funds, they're competing with projects all around the country for a pot of money that's limited and getting smaller and smaller every year.
    • 00:52:06
      Because it's not based on gas tax revenues, it comes out of the general fund.
    • 00:52:12
      It's been sort of on the chopping block every year.
    • 00:52:15
      The reason that's important for you all to recognize is that it's raised a lot of significant challenges to advance fixed guideway projects around the state.
    • 00:52:27
      E. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 00:52:43
      So that's another program that's getting more and more competitive that's requiring us at the state level to step up more of our transit dollars.
    • 00:52:51
      Our transit capital fund isn't designed to handle big projects like that.
    • 00:52:55
      We often have to rely on flexible funds that we, you know, work with VDOT to have those allocated as well.
    • 00:53:01
      But I just want to make sure, you know, there's another piece of this in the transit side that isn't reflected here, but it really does affect, you know, VDOT as well and sort of resources we have statewide to advance major projects.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:53:13
      So when John mentioned earlier that we were putting more money, we're not putting more money in transit, we're trying to address so we don't have to reduce the offerings we do in transit.
    • 00:53:21
      He is right, we're coming out of this hot, but I mean in terms of we don't have a bunch of expanded transit options.
    • 00:53:28
      I don't want people to think, oh $40 million a year, we're just trying to keep in place what we have.
    • 00:53:36
      Yes, just a footnote.
    • 00:53:39
      John, what's the latest on the continuing resolution of the federal government?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:53:45
      When does that expire?
    • 00:53:47
      Is that the crisis again in the summer?
    • 00:53:50
      As far as NAP-21, in demand.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:53:55
      And you mentioned that the President's plan is significantly different than the plan offered by the Congressional
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:54:05
      Republicans, I mean, and, you know, we'll see if they find, my guess is, is what they've done since 2008, they'll come out and let's don't do anything to get to the next election, so they push it down the road 10 or 11 months. Mr. Chairman, the federal fund, is that 100% gas tax or is there other revenue? Right now, mostly it's a bit.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:54:30
      It's all the collections of the gas tax, but because it's been short, there have been federal general fund appropriations that have gone in to keep the apportionment.
    • 00:54:41
      In other words, if we were just since 2008, I think it's almost $60 billion, a little bit more from general fund revenues.
    • 00:54:47
      Because the gas tax hadn't been raised since 1993.
    • 00:54:51
      So, to answer your question, it primarily is, like the sole thing, is the gas tax.
    • 00:54:58
      But since 2008, Congress has taken federal general fund money's appropriations and added to it to sort of keep the appropriations coming to the state, which John mentioned earlier.
    • 00:55:10
      So, it's a mix right now, but in terms of truly collections, it's the gas tax.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:55:16
      Martin Luther King Jr. Jr. Jr. Jr.
    • 00:55:35
      That revenue stream is smaller.
    • 00:55:38
      Just to put it in perspective, the federal program we're operating under now is about $48-49 billion a year, and the revenue stream is about $36-37 billion a year.
    • 00:55:50
      So it is not sustaining itself at the moment.
    • 00:55:54
      As he mentioned, we're continuing to make general fund contributions to keep the program at the current level.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:56:00
      Mr. Chairman, I know that we have a
    • 00:56:04
      the liaison with the state government and the Capitol.
    • 00:56:07
      And I assume that they're working, you know, I think if there was going to be anything other than a patch of the highway bill in May just to carry it forward, we would be hearing about it now because that's a lot of work to do between now and May.
    • 00:56:20
      Maybe so, maybe not, but I just want to confirm you guys are working closely with
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:56:26
      Our Senators and our Representatives up there to try to figure out what... As of Monday at the Cabinet meeting, and Nick lives up there, Nick says, Nick Donohue, our Deputy Secretary, we understand there's some policy being worked on, but there's no agreement as to how it's going to be funded yet.
    • 00:56:45
      And that's similar to what we had last August.
    • 00:56:47
      Mr. Kilpatrick got a letter.
    • 00:56:49
      I suspect we're going to get one here pretty soon from Secretary Foxx, telling him to prepare for curtailments of our apportionment.
    • 00:57:00
      So, I mean, we're coming up on it.
    • 00:57:02
      And again, just think about this.
    • 00:57:05
      We're just getting ready to gear up our summer construction.
    • 00:57:09
      That's why I made the right decision last year not to stop our construction because we had some closing.
    • 00:57:15
      That really resulted in getting the extra allotment because other people did.
    • 00:57:21
      You know, we're getting close.
    • 00:57:22
      We're going to have to sit down and say, you know, what do we do?
    • 00:57:26
      I'm going to, right now, roll in the head.
    • 00:57:28
      We're going to be able to just, you know, we're going to roll us out in there.
    • 00:57:34
      But I will say this, several other states have already stopped.
    • 00:57:38
      Those states that rely primarily and only on the federal monies have stopped.
    • 00:57:47
      We have not.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:57:52
      As I mentioned earlier, we do supplement the transportation program with bond funds.
    • 00:57:58
      We've been using bond funding in the Commonwealth, I think back in the 50s.
    • 00:58:04
      Largely it was intended, it was just specific statutory legislation authority to issue bonds for a specific facility.
    • 00:58:12
      The two programs that we currently have active is the GARVEE program and the CTR program.
    • 00:58:20
      Both of those were authorized.
    • 00:58:23
      The GARVEE is the $1.2 billion revolving program and the CTR is a fixed authorization.
    • 00:58:33
      Currently we've got about just over $3 billion of outstanding debt and in this current program we have about $1.7 billion of additional bonds intended to be issued to support the program, which is about 5% of the total program.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:58:51
      A small portion of the GARBI proceeds that are in the
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:59:14
      H.B.
    • 00:59:14
      2.0, I'll call it, but everything else as mentioned is committed to projects.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:22
      And John, so we don't confuse folks with kind of the Northern Virginia alphabet.
    • 00:59:27
      Northern Virginia Transportation District, those bonds are not the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority.
    • 00:59:35
      These are the bonds that were issued under the whole program. It gets real confusing sometimes which NBT is. This $500 million is not the current program going on in Northern Virginia. It's a past program. Those projects are largely completed. that program is largely complete yet. It's only about twenty million in unissued bonds out of that authorization and the projects that could be completed with those
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:00:05
      We've talked a little bit about the regional revenues, and I won't belabor this, but they're both the in-air program.
    • 01:00:24
      We do show the flow-through of the state's revenues dedicated to the region in terms of
    • 01:00:35
      stability, I'll call it, of these revenue streams.
    • 01:00:39
      Hampton Roads, it has the disadvantage of having this new sales tax on fuel that has no floor.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:00:49
      Yeah, I want to point that out.
    • 01:00:50
      Unlike the statewide revenues, there was the 2313, I think everybody thought it had a floor in the region, but it did not.
    • 01:00:58
      Right.
    • 01:00:59
      And when we were looking at
    • 01:01:01
      Why are we going down so much quicker in Hampton Roads?
    • 01:01:05
      Because it's primarily, Northern Virginia doesn't have floor here, but it has other taxes.
    • 01:01:10
      And we discovered that there was no floor on the regional revenues.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:01:16
      In Northern Virginia receives the 2.1% sales tax on fuel as well, but half for many years and is not considered part of the regional revenue source.
    • 01:01:27
      So while they are subject to the same fluctuations,
    • 01:01:31
      You don't see it in our numbers because it's not part of what comes to us at all.
    • 01:01:35
      It's truly a local tax.
    • 01:01:41
      A chart with a lot of numbers.
    • 01:01:43
      This is the forecast for the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:01:47
      You can see the revenues by, and we kind of grouped them up into major groups.
    • 01:01:51
      You see the top third is the state sources, about $25.5 billion.
    • 01:01:57
      D. D. D. D. D.
    • 01:02:21
      It's the middle of the page, we have about 100 million dollars above where we were, but that does, you know, you're looking at dropping off 15 and adding 21, and 21 is higher than 15, so it kind of masks the effect of some reductions.
    • 01:02:37
      In fact, there was about $165 million in reductions in state program in that overlapping time period that had been adjusted.
    • 01:02:46
      The regional areas also reduced, had about $115 million reduction, about $90 million Hampton Roads, $24 million or so in Northern Virginia.
    • 01:03:01
      The numbers in the grand total show where it shows the $350 million increase.
    • 01:03:06
      It includes $400 million in 20 for Route 58 bonds.
    • 01:03:12
      I think it was two years ago now that the authorization for 58 was increased to enable the completion of lovers' league and some of the sections, the remaining sections of Route 58.
    • 01:03:24
      And dedicated monies to the program starting in 2020.
    • 01:03:27
      It won't be until 2020 that we have sufficient funds to make the debt services.
    • 01:03:33
      That was the reason there was a delay really until 2020.
    • 01:03:37
      So we have put that in the program to indicate that it will be there to support the projects and we'll actually be looking to that as we get closer and we'll be issuing the bonds as needed from a cash perspective to support
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:03:50
      Mr. Chairman, this is important in the southern part of my district.
    • 01:03:57
      This 58 is an important piece of this lover's leaf.
    • 01:04:01
      So the 58 money, the special tax money is still being collected?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:04:09
      If I may, there's $40 million really taking off the top of the recordation taxes statewide.
    • 01:04:15
      as a proxy for the area.
    • 01:04:18
      It's not directly connected to the facility itself, the corridor itself.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:04:24
      So the General Assembly said we're going to raise the recordation tax for everybody in this state?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:04:31
      When this was done in the 80s, I guess, the legislation said it's going to take $40 million off of
    • 01:04:40
      of the first, basically the first 40 million of recordation.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:04:44
      My question is, does that money flow into infinity?
    • 01:04:47
      In other words, is it until they change that, that keeps flowing?
    • 01:04:50
      Until it's changed, the money's coming.
    • 01:04:51
      And what we're trying to do is accumulate enough of that money to be able to issue bonds for the lovers' leap?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:04:59
      The way that it was structured, we had the $40 million a year from the general fund or recordation taxes, and then the CTB, or the transportation dollars,
    • 01:05:10
      was required to kick in additional money, if necessary, to make debt service on the bonds.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:05:16
      Why would we have to kick in extra money?
    • 01:05:17
      Why don't we just wait until we've got enough?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:05:19
      Well, in order to move it, and the way it was structured, we were able to do this, and the decision time was made.
    • 01:05:27
      We've done 10 or 12 million a year of state transportation dollars in addition to the 40.
    • 01:05:34
      So the debt service has been about $52 million in that program.
    • 01:05:40
      In 2020, when we looked at this a couple years ago now, it's when the debt service would drop back down within the $40 million range.
    • 01:05:52
      And the decision was, and the way the legislation was written, is that we are now being required, you are being required, to provide $20 million a year, starting in 2020, to add on top of that $40 million to make the debt service, which enables the sale of another $400 million
    • 01:06:09
      In depth to complete the quarter.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:06:16
      Okay.
    • 01:06:16
      No more of that.
    • 01:06:17
      We don't help that part.
    • 01:06:19
      I'm just kidding.
    • 01:06:19
      It's called the fill pot.
    • 01:06:22
      But we are essentially when we get the money to issue bonds.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:29
      As I mentioned, the CPR program, the numbers that you saw on the previous slide are trailing off.
    • 01:06:35
      You see the last issue being done in 2020 that completes the
    • 01:06:39
      E. Smith Jr., John F. Smith Jr., John F. Smith Jr., John F. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:07:02
      This chart, I just wanted to give you a perspective of where the money is going.
    • 01:07:07
      Here's the $33 million just broke up by agency, so you can see where it's going.
    • 01:07:13
      It does reflect an addition of $153 million across the six years in this program, a net that is going to DRPT for transit purposes as directed by HB 1887.
    • 01:07:29
      And it also, what you don't see here, and mention some of what Director Mitchell mentioned earlier, is there are monies in the VDOT number, as it's listed here, that once we get through the six-year programming process, may well be identified for transit or rail activities.
    • 01:07:52
      Just real, I'm going to hit this fast because I'm running longer than I had hoped.
    • 01:07:57
      We operate under two major funds, the Highway Maintenance and Operating Fund and the Transportation Trust Fund.
    • 01:08:04
      The HMO is all VDOT and continues to support maintenance and administration.
    • 01:08:09
      The Trust Fund is where it was really created in 1986, has the mobile distribution to the four major modes.
    • 01:08:17
      There are also a few other special programs that are used to support story specific priorities or programs.
    • 01:08:25
      This is the recommended allocation as we are going into the program development based on the preliminary numbers.
    • 01:08:32
      This shows you the picture of where we expect the $33 billion to be distributed.
    • 01:08:40
      We cover debt service first and other things.
    • 01:08:42
      I'll speak to those very briefly as I flip through the next few slides.
    • 01:08:47
      As I mentioned, debt service comes first.
    • 01:08:49
      We are making debt service on those core programs I mentioned earlier.
    • 01:08:56
      The debt service is about two and a half billion dollars over the course of the six years.
    • 01:09:06
      You also see here that the dedicated revenues for these, garbage come from federal revenues, CPRs, and the other programs have their own specific revenue sources that are used for those debt programs.
    • 01:09:21
      We provide a significant amount of money to other state agencies.
    • 01:09:26
      McPherson, James W. McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson Jr., James W. McPherson,
    • 01:09:52
      We talked quite a bit about maintenance.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:09:54
      Why do we give the Department of Taxation 18 million dollars?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:09:57
      That is considered trust fund management.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:09:59
      Trust fund management.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:01
      To manage our money?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:10:02
      To manage our money.
    • 01:10:05
      Yeah.
    • 01:10:05
      It's legislatively required.
    • 01:10:09
      You might ask why we get Chesapeake Bay 44 million because it's legislatively required.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:10:15
      So we're taking about 150 million dollars annually and spending it on stuff that ain't do it building roads.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:10:23
      You're required by law to do so.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:10:25
      Just checking.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:27
      Well the numbers you see out of space flight are over the six years.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:10:30
      Ah, this is over six years.
    • 01:10:32
      Yes sir.
    • 01:10:32
      Much better.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:10:35
      Well, no, for a mission assessment, oh yeah.
    • 01:10:39
      Yeah, yeah, yeah, you're right.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:42
      As I mentioned, we've talked quite a bit about maintenance over the last couple of sessions, so I won't speak much to that other than we've got nearly $10 billion a year for maintenance and operations.
    • 01:10:54
      Related to VDOT, there's another $2.3 billion associated with maintenance payments to localities, so all in total about $12.5 billion in total funding distributed to
    • 01:11:09
      Do want to make note that at the bottom there you see that of that twelve and a half we are supporting their support there from places other than the highway maintenance and operating fund which originally was intended to support all of these purposes.
    • 01:11:26
      So we've got about a billion for coming from federal highway dollars that previously would have been used solely for construction purposes.
    • 01:11:34
      and about $1.2 billion in highway construction dollars, state funds, which is what we tend to refer to as cross funds.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:11:41
      Chairman, can John just spend just a second explaining the Arlington and RICO appropriations?
    • 01:11:50
      He can probably do it in a couple of seconds.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:11:52
      Certainly.
    • 01:11:53
      Arlington and RICO are the two counties in the Commonwealth that maintain their own secondary system.
    • 01:11:59
      So as part of the legislation
    • 01:12:02
      A. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr., John K. Matney Jr., James W. Smith,
    • 01:12:22
      The system is how we determine the amount that is.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:12:25
      Is there a way to measure what we pay them versus what we pay Roanoke and Newport News?
    • 01:12:31
      Oh yeah, we did a whole subgroup on that two or three years ago and happy to bring that information forward but this is back from when actually the 30s when remember that all the counties used to localities and
    • 01:12:48
      McPherson, John M. McPherson, John M. McPherson, John M. McPherson,
    • 01:13:05
      How that compares to the real cost, but it's factually done.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:13
      John, the formula for Enrico and Arlington are, it's a lane-mile calculation, it's a moving lane model.
    • 01:13:25
      How is it different than Ryan Oak, sir?
    • 01:13:27
      So the rate is different.
    • 01:13:30
      The rate is different and I think Frank would measure it and Jennifer is nodding her head.
    • 01:13:36
      It's lane miles for cities.
    • 01:13:39
      It's moving lane miles for the two counties.
    • 01:13:44
      It's moving lane miles for the cities.
    • 01:13:47
      E. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr., John K. Matney Jr., James W. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:14:08
      So, there's more obligation to maintain at the city level for those two counties, but the rate is actually higher, I believe, on a mileage basis for the two counties.
    • 01:14:21
      There's always been a perception that it's a sweet deal.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:14:23
      Well, last I looked, and I think recall this was in key, I think Ken Reico, we were getting a bargain, and it wasn't the case.
    • 01:14:32
      I don't mean in terms of how the rest of the state, I'm not saying it's not worthwhile, but if you look, interactive was getting a little less than they might have gotten if we'd done the state formula and it was getting a little more had we done the state.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:46
      But if we apply the same formula to every jurisdiction,
    • 01:14:51
      How we allocate our maintenance money, we couldn't afford it.
    • 01:14:55
      We couldn't afford to allocate money under the formulas that are used for Arlington and Henrico for the remaining counties.
    • 01:15:03
      We would take every dime and then some.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:15:06
      Mr. Chairman, I think this is very helpful.
    • 01:15:08
      One other thing, we've been talking about perceptions out there.
    • 01:15:13
      Another thing I think we need to make clear is we're going to take 2.6 billion dollars
    • 01:15:19
      Over six years that we could have spent for construction and spend it on maintenance, despite the fact that we've had an increase in revenue. I think that's a very good point. And so we still are not...
    • 01:15:35
      In a situation where we're fully funding our maintenance out of our state dollars and able to use the money in construction like we would like to.
    • 01:15:44
      And it's important.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:15:45
      I think that's right.
    • 01:15:46
      It's two-fold.
    • 01:15:47
      We've had conversations with the Commissioner.
    • 01:15:49
      One is, are we getting the biggest bank for our maintenance dollars?
    • 01:15:53
      And so we're going through that.
    • 01:15:55
      And I think we may ultimately, you know, Derek talked about performance, but ultimately prioritization or something in that.
    • 01:16:04
      And the other is I think 87 we do recognize state of good repair will help that because you know we had been a lot of that sort of bled over too in that regard so hopefully we'll start attacking that but no I think that is accurate we are spending quite a bit trying to catch up for many years of not maintaining our current system.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:27
      And our system, it grows every year, especially on the secondary side.
    • 01:16:33
      It ebbs and flows depending on the economy, but we still add a couple hundred miles a year on the secondary system, mostly in Northern Virginia, mostly, and some other parts.
    • 01:16:45
      The other thing, frankly, is that our primary, all of our roads are getting older every day.
    • 01:16:50
      But the big push of the 50s, 60s, and into the 70s of the lighting of the primary system and the construction of the interstate system, these facilities are now 50 plus years old and they're beyond a paint job.
    • 01:17:04
      So the cost of maintenance is going, of maintaining those facilities is, it becomes more difficult.
    • 01:17:12
      We don't grow, we are growing our maintenance program only at the PPI, is that correct?
    • 01:17:18
      That's how we're growing our maintenance program at that rate.
    • 01:17:25
      We haven't driven more money to it, but just that growth rate is taking that level of crossover.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:17:38
      Just some of the other things that obviously we have to fund before we get to what's remaining for construction.
    • 01:17:47
      We have what we call a group of administration and other.
    • 01:17:51
      It's 2.6 billion, seems like a big number, but 85% of that is probably personnel.
    • 01:18:01
      Of your program management category at the top, about 85% of that is staffing, and then the other programs are tied to services or other areas, such as Capital Light and Light.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:15
      This is over six years.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:18:16
      It is over six years.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:17
      I just want to make sure people are real clear on that.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:18:19
      Yes, absolutely.
    • 01:18:20
      In all fairness, I mean, we're looking hard at this, and VDOT's been really working hard at how to do this in that regard.
    • 01:18:29
      We're not saying that we're just suggesting that we're not.
    • 01:18:34
      I really commend the VDOT staff for looking at how they're operating and what things we do in-house, what things we do out-of-house and trying to get that, TAMS contracts for instance, how we restructured those.
    • 01:18:47
      We've taken a look at how we administer ourselves.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:18:52
      You know, the typical complaint we get is staffing levels and things like that.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:18:56
      There's so many people.
    • 01:18:57
      How many of them are yellow-torched people out there?
    • 01:18:59
      And I used to use an analogy to explain to people that if you laid everybody off in VDOT, you couldn't build a good-sized intersection with them.
    • 01:19:07
      On an annual basis.
    • 01:19:08
      On an annual basis.
    • 01:19:09
      It's not worth the money.
    • 01:19:10
      It's a good use of money, not necessarily the staffing levels or anything like we're wasting at VDOT.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:19:16
      Just to your point, Mr. Secretary, we have over the last several years seen continuous reductions in the administrative areas.
    • 01:19:25
      We did almost 10% last year.
    • 01:19:27
      We've planned for another 7% this year.
    • 01:19:30
      And when we make these adjustments, we make them to the base so that they carry out and not just one-time adjustments.
    • 01:19:36
      So we're actually putting the squeeze
    • 01:19:39
      really put me in a squeeze on the agency to make sure we are very deliberate in what we have to spend on administration so that we can maximize the dollars that are going to the corporate emergency.
    • 01:19:55
      I mentioned motor distributions.
    • 01:19:57
      I won't go through that, but we mentioned earlier that the Transportation Trust Fund was set up.
    • 01:20:01
      And we have a core set of revenues that are dedicated to it, and then statutorily they are distributed to highways, mass transit, port, and aviation.
    • 01:20:11
      And with that, I'm going to turn it over to Mr. Pittard to let him talk a little bit about the transit and rail side of the house.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:20:20
      Thank you, John.
    • 01:20:21
      And a lot of this, as John said earlier on, a lot of this is for all's information, so I'm going to kind of go through it pretty quick.
    • 01:20:28
      This is sort of a subset of the Transportation Trust Fund and what I wanted to do was just show you the 16 revenues to give you a feel for where those revenues come from and then I'm going to take each of those sources that go to transit and then also I'll break the rail program down and kind of give you a little bit of information about those sources.
    • 01:20:48
      So the goal, as John said earlier, is really for y'all to take this and sort of have the deck of information to reference over time and then come back and ask us more specific questions.
    • 01:21:02
      So the first revenue source is the modal distribution that John just mentioned, the 14.7% that goes to the Mass Transit Trust Fund.
    • 01:21:12
      And in each of these slides I'm putting the code reference in case someone wants to look deeper.
    • 01:21:17
      In that code section, it dictates to us how those funds will be split up, 72% to operations, 3% for our special programs, which includes our transportation demand management programs, and then 25% for transit capital projects.
    • 01:21:37
      The next large revenue source is the recordation taxes.
    • 01:21:42
      We got a piece of recordation tax in 2007.
    • 01:21:45
      And then again with 1887 we're going to get a little bit more beginning in 2017.
    • 01:21:53
      And basically they're just taxes on recording real estate transactions and we're going to go from the two cents per hundred that we're currently getting to three cents when we start 17.
    • 01:22:07
      And that new penny is dedicated to transit capital.
    • 01:22:12
      To address that transit capital issue that we've been talking about in the past few years.
    • 01:22:18
      As John talked a little bit about the bonds, when these were authorized back in 2007, both transit and the rail programs looked at it and we didn't have needs to take the 20% for transit and the 4.3% that were dedicated
    • 01:22:40
      to Roehl and those were minimum dedications.
    • 01:22:43
      We didn't have the needs though at that time.
    • 01:22:46
      So we looked at it and said we would take those bond funds and spread them out over a 10-year period.
    • 01:22:52
      And so, you know, with VDOT, they've used their funds, put them on projects, allocated them out.
    • 01:22:58
      We've been allocating them out over that 10-year period which is ending in 2018.
    • 01:23:04
      Additionally, there is
    • 01:23:07
      When I said there was a minimum of 20% to transit, the language allowed the VDOT portion, the other 75.7 different allocations.
    • 01:23:19
      One of those was for matching the federal dollars, so a large portion of this funding, $650 million a year for 10 years was taken to dedicate to
    • 01:23:33
      match federal funds that went to a state of good repair program for the WMATA system and both Maryland and D.C. put in similar funding to match those federal dollars.
    • 01:23:43
      Also, some of the funding of the discretionary use was also put on the Dulles Metrorail Extension Project.
    • 01:23:55
      In the 2013 session, we were dedicated retail sales and use tax and as John mentioned earlier,
    • 01:24:02
      Over the years, the retail sales and use tax has become actually the biggest revenue source for transportation.
    • 01:24:11
      It goes to the same split on the transit side as the Mass Transit Trust Fund, the 72, 3, and 25.
    • 01:24:21
      The motor vehicle fuel tax, this was part of 1887, the current session, and a lot of it was dedicated to fix the transit capital
    • 01:24:32
      The problem we have coming up with that loss of those bond funds.
    • 01:24:36
      But there was, in part of that, there were small dedications of the motor fuel tax that were made to both operations and to the special programs fund, which was sort of designated, that special programs fund was a significant amount of money considering 72% operating, 3% special, so if you look at that division, it's not
    • 01:25:02
      3 million and 2 million is not that same split and that was by choice to try to prop up those special programs in particular the TDM Transportation Demand Management programs that really have been at a flat level of funding for a long time and those are the programs you know ride sharing etc.
    • 01:25:20
      that you know we really have as an agency are pushing and I think for both both agencies it's a program that needed to grow so.
    • 01:25:33
      And finally, on the transit side, just touch on the federal revenues.
    • 01:25:37
      And these are, you know, Director Mitchell spoke of discretionary programs.
    • 01:25:42
      These are actually the formula funds that we do receive.
    • 01:25:47
      And part of those are from our flexible SDP funds that is a pot of money and a portion of it is carved out from, I guess you could say, from the VDOT budget and given dedicated to transit.
    • 01:26:01
      And that's about $25 million a year.
    • 01:26:03
      And then the Federal Transit Administration formula programs, we get about $30 million a year.
    • 01:26:09
      And I just want to touch the two largest programs are our 5311 program, which is funding for our rural providers.
    • 01:26:18
      And then we also have a program called the Governor's Apportionment Program.
    • 01:26:23
      It takes the FTA 5307 funds.
    • 01:26:27
      and dedicates those or allocates them to small urban providers.
    • 01:26:33
      And for both the small urban and the rural, these programs are critical.
    • 01:26:38
      Without them, most of the rural programs would probably cease and the small urban would probably reduce almost 50%.
    • 01:26:50
      That brings us to the rail programs and this once again is just a chart to give you a breakdown of the revenues and where they're actually coming from and going into a little more detail each of those in 2005 we were dedicated the rental tax on vehicles to set up establish the rail enhancement fund which was established to fund both freight and passenger rail projects.
    • 01:27:16
      In 2017
    • 01:27:19
      Of the 3% of that tax we were receiving, 1% is going to be dedicated to the State of Good Repair Program as directed in 1887.
    • 01:27:29
      I think it's also prudent to mention that we're working with the rail subcommittee as directed by the General Assembly to take a look at the Rail Enhancement Fund.
    • 01:27:42
      It's been 10 years since this was set up.
    • 01:27:45
      I think it was time to take a look at it and we're coming back I think in November to the General Assembly with recommendations from the board.
    • 01:27:59
      On the bond side here, same as the transit except it's a smaller percentage and I think here we also wanted to mention once again the portion that 75.7%
    • 01:28:15
      We're still using the rail funds, we're still using the transit funds, but the remainder has already been allocated, so we don't want people thinking that there's a pot of funds there from our bond, the CPR bonds.
    • 01:28:30
      and once again with 2013 retail sales and use tax were used to set up the inner city passenger rail operating and capital fund which basically gave us a source to pay for our six regional trains that the state operates through using Amtrak which prior to that time we didn't have a source to pay for that we were just fortunate that the Lynchburg train
    • 01:28:56
      made enough money to support the two trains we were running at that time.
    • 01:29:00
      So, anyway, that's where that comes from, and it's .05% of the retail sales and use tax.
    • 01:29:10
      And with that, unless there's questions, I'll certainly be available for questions later, but I was going to hand it back to John.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 01:29:19
      Let me ask you just a quick question.
    • 01:29:20
      What is the percentage of the rental tax?
    • 01:29:24
      Is it 9%?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:29:26
      I believe it's ten percent and we get three.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:29
      And we get three percent.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 01:29:32
      Okay, so the tax itself is ten percent.
    • 01:29:36
      Okay.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:29:36
      I just wanted to clarify that.
    • 01:29:37
      Just for you, in the book we gave you earlier on the subcommittee, there's a detail of all of the taxes.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 01:29:45
      Of all the breakouts.
    • 01:29:46
      Thank you.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:29:49
      Okay.
    • 01:29:52
      All right, just moving into construction.
    • 01:29:55
      We kind of walked through this in the order we had showed the programs on that initial slide.
    • 01:30:01
      In terms of funding for construction, the two big categories, or three main categories at this point, are the motor distributions, which is about half of the total construction funds.
    • 01:30:16
      I mentioned earlier federal funds represent 30-35% or so of this program, and then the
    • 01:30:24
      Small amounts from telecommunication fees, which are provided directly to the counties, and then there are local contributions for participation on specific projects.
    • 01:30:35
      Before we get to monies available for that construction formula distribution, there are a number of special programs.
    • 01:30:42
      There are federal programs that are restricted for their use or purpose, such
    • 01:30:49
      P. Dalles Jr., John C. Dalles Jr., John C. B.
    • 01:31:16
      Revenue Sharing, as you know, is a program that requires a 50% match.
    • 01:31:24
      It is by code.
    • 01:31:26
      It requires to be at least $15 million.
    • 01:31:30
      It can be funded to as much as $300 million a year.
    • 01:31:34
      That program has been growing, as you know, over the last two years.
    • 01:31:39
      With the HB2 and with 1887,
    • 01:31:44
      We're now looking at that as part of the program development to see whether or not we need to right-size that program in order to get more money into these other programs, specifically the district grant program, which will be available for the localities to compete
    • 01:32:02
      on through the HB2 selection.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:32:05
      I'd like to comment on that.
    • 01:32:06
      I mean, that five years ago, the revenue sharing was $15 million a year from the 185 primarily because there were no other sources of funds for the localities.
    • 01:32:16
      And so when John mentioned right-sizing, what we're looking at is with the new formula flow, you know, what's the right percentage of having revenue sharing because the state of good repair and district grants are going to be automatically pushed down.
    • 01:32:30
      So we'll be looking at that over the development of the plan.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:32:33
      Mr. Chairman, as we're doing this, could we do, as we've talked about with HB2, could we kind of get examples of how this would look in the real world?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:32:41
      Because I know for cities in particular, revenue sharing is basically the only source of revenue to fix $15 million bridges where you're having to pay $7.5 million.
    • 01:32:51
      B. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:33:08
      I think the program was meant for is to really get those things, not a state good repair.
    • 01:33:14
      So yes, as we go through we'll try to, you know, right side that I think it's the right time.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:33:19
      I just imagine that there are a lot of jurisdictions who are going to see this and get a little nervous about what this means for them.
    • 01:33:26
      So as long as we can explain how this money will still get to those cities who have fantastic bridges.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:33:31
      So hopefully they don't worry about fixing the ridge anymore.
    • 01:33:35
      It's fixed.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:33:36
      We take credit for that.
    • 01:33:37
      To your point, that's the whole purpose of the state of good repair.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:33:40
      That's the whole purpose, too.
    • 01:33:41
      That's what we went out and looked at.
    • 01:33:42
      I can't tell you how many small bridges.
    • 01:33:44
      The only thing they had was revenue sharing.
    • 01:33:47
      I mean, what was won out itself?
    • 01:33:49
      They were so proud.
    • 01:33:50
      They saved up almost eight, nine years to get a $16 million bridge.
    • 01:33:54
      The project probably grew from $16 million while they were saving up.
    • 01:33:58
      But that should have been fixed.
    • 01:34:02
      Thank you.
    • 01:34:02
      So it should be a very big benefit.
    • 01:34:06
      Thank you.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:34:08
      As far as the construction program, the CTB formula as it was put in place, as you see here, will continue to be utilized through 2020.
    • 01:34:20
      What we have done, as you know, the board has the ability to hold, to provide up to $500 million through the CTB formula.
    • 01:34:30
      What we have done, again, transitional as we're working towards
    • 01:34:34
      H.B.
    • 01:34:35
      2 in 1887, as we have tried to hold the CTB formula with up amounts at the same place they were in the revised program from last November.
    • 01:34:47
      We did, because of funding availability, we would have suffered a loss in 16 if we hadn't, excuse me, in 17.
    • 01:34:58
      As mentioned earlier, HB 1887 goes fully into effect in 2021, funding the state of good repair, the opportunity projects program, and the highway construction district grant program.
    • 01:35:22
      And in the interim, between now and 2021, monies that are not
    • 01:35:26
      I'm not going to go through the details of these programs, but as you know, 45% of the funding is to go to state of good repair, and then the remaining
    • 01:35:54
      is distributed 27.5% to the High Priority Projects Program and to 27.5% to the Highway Construction District Grant Programs.
    • 01:36:04
      Again, both of those projects will be selected through the HB2 prioritization process, first on a statewide basis, the district grant program on a district basis.
    • 01:36:17
      Another chart with a lot of numbers, and I'm not going to walk through it, but basically what it just shows here is if you look at the
    • 01:36:24
      The total construction pool, the portion that is in what we call the special programs, the things that are funded before you get to the formula, the Garvey program, the amounts that are in that CTB formula distribution, and you'll see notice the bold line, the $412 million is as high as it goes, so we'd have to reach $500.
    • 01:36:45
      The amount of new monies that would be available for the 50-50 distribution, as well as what
    • 01:36:54
      B. Doolittle Jr., John C. Doolittle Jr.,
    • 01:37:17
      The projects as funded in the November program.
    • 01:37:21
      So that's what we're reflecting there.
    • 01:37:23
      The three lines noted as reserved for HB2 are the $416 million that we showed you last November.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:37:34
      So obviously this is a transition, guys, as we're going from the old formula to
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:37:39
      This is an indicative illustration of what 2021 will look like.
    • 01:37:47
      You see here the $657 million, how it would be distributed to the three programs, and an indicative look of what the distributions to the districts for the state of good repair and to the districts for the grant program.
    • 01:38:05
      It's important to note that the percentages you see here are based on what we knew today.
    • 01:38:09
      And as we get closer to 2021, obviously the variables will change and the numbers will be updated accordingly.
    • 01:38:18
      Just very briefly, I want to speak to the actual program development.
    • 01:38:22
      Over the last several years, we've had a fairly static list of priorities that we've used.
    • 01:38:29
      I think you're probably very familiar with these.
    • 01:38:33
      What we wanted to do, or looking to do this time,
    • 01:38:36
      because of this transitional period and transitional nature of this program is to kind of refine what we're doing.
    • 01:38:45
      We're really focusing on the transition to HB2, not looking to add new projects that would be subject to prioritization.
    • 01:38:53
      We are following the CTB formula through 2020.
    • 01:38:58
      Again, it had its purpose.
    • 01:39:01
      Again, a lot of it was for payments and bridges.
    • 01:39:03
      We have to make sure we keep our underway projects funded and moving forward.
    • 01:39:08
      We've got an ADD fund still in place to support the work already underway in that corridor queue and other places out in the Appalachian area.
    • 01:39:19
      We talked about redirecting the inactive balances that may be available on projects, unneeded projects, to be able to minimize any kind of impacts upon the 416 that we set aside for HB2.
    • 01:39:36
      And as always, we are trying to make sure we fully utilize our federal funds.
    • 01:39:45
      Again, the CTB formula remains the same.
    • 01:39:49
      Actually, I say the same, it's about a million dollars off.
    • 01:39:53
      You look at it across the six years.
    • 01:39:55
      We do look to delay project schedules or use any available funds to address any kind of cost.
    • 01:40:02
      The estimate increases and we are looking to support the early implementation of the Construction District Grant Program and the High Priority Program.
    • 01:40:12
      By taking these monies that are not programmed to projects and being able to distribute them to the two programs which thus then be distributed through the prioritization process.
    • 01:40:26
      We already talked through the formula that will be used in 2021.
    • 01:40:29
      We are setting those dollars aside in the program.
    • 01:40:32
      Obviously at this point we haven't initiated the HPT prioritization and are not in a position to be selecting projects, but we'll be
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:40:41
      Martin, John K. Martin, John K. Martin,
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:40:59
      Depends on year.
    • 01:41:03
      Would you question what percentage of our funds?
    • 01:41:06
      Well, other than the ones, when we get fully out there, other than those special projects, all of them are.
    • 01:41:16
      In other words, the special thing that Don enumerated.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:41:18
      The state of good repair, 45% to state of good repair obviously is
    • 01:41:23
      Martin, James W. Martin, John K. Matney Jr.,
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:41:37
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz,
    • 01:41:55
      The rest of that money is either dedicated for very specific purposes by the federal program, is used for crossover, or is used to fund the replacement of bridges or charge admission payments.
    • 01:42:06
      So it's a third of the overall money, but it's basically 100% the flexible money that we have in construction.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:42:17
      And that will grow as we go through and transition out.
    • 01:42:22
      And hopefully revenues go up.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:42:26
      Thank you, John.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:42:31
      And I guess I'm going to close out the presentation, just briefly talk about some of the highlights for this year's Six-Year Improvement Program that we'll be bringing back to you all in April.
    • 01:42:43
      And I guess I've broken this once again down by transit and rail and so just started with just showing the revenues for the next six years and have them broken down by the programs
    • 01:42:56
      For the transit side and the two things I'm not going to go much detail here but the two things I will point out is as I mentioned earlier you'll see the increase in 17 in our special programs due to the 1887 we do think that's important and much needed and then also the other category because there's always you know somebody puts an other category out there people want to know what that is so other is
    • 01:43:24
      Certain items are required by the Appropriation Act by the General Assembly to be taken off the top of our funding.
    • 01:43:32
      And one of those is we have a paratransit program for a million and a half dollars a year.
    • 01:43:37
      We also have to fund the new transit service in the I-95 corridor due to the hot lanes construction.
    • 01:43:46
      We have to fund that off the top.
    • 01:43:48
      and then additionally the way DRPT pays for its administration and project management is we take a percentage of the revenues off the top and it's legislatively a ceiling of three and a half percent.
    • 01:44:08
      So those are the numbers that are in that other category.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:44:11
      Let me point out one thing because it came up earlier with the 40 million transfer.
    • 01:44:14
      I want you to see there's not any huge increase in the total going to transit.
    • 01:44:19
      We're plugging a hole.
    • 01:44:20
      So I know everybody keeps saying we're moving all these, all we're doing is plugging a hole.
    • 01:44:25
      Partially.
    • 01:44:26
      Partially, I mean we got a lot more to do but my point is here is that this whole thing came because
    • 01:44:34
      We didn't pass marketplace fairness equity.
    • 01:44:37
      That was projected to fill this hole.
    • 01:44:41
      It didn't happen.
    • 01:44:41
      There was a reversion provision in the statewide to increase the gas tax from 3.5 to 5.1 percent.
    • 01:44:52
      Every other program got funded because it runs through, you know, other formulas.
    • 01:44:56
      It got a windfall.
    • 01:44:58
      Transit, all we did was take the windfall and put it over the transit.
    • 01:45:02
      In other words, absolute dollars every program goes up each year.
    • 01:45:07
      So this is not like we're taking money from another program and people keep, I know they don't mean to, but I just want to point out this is not an increase in transit.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:18
      What this doesn't reflect also, and Steve will talk a little bit about matching rates, but because we actually match local funds, or we provide matching dollars to local transit agencies, this does not reflect all of the local money that goes into transit and transit programs.
    • 01:45:34
      I mean we only provide a small, you know,
    • 01:45:37
      If I had to guess, I don't know what it is on an aggregate basis between probably a third and half of, you know, funding for transit needs across the state.
    • 01:45:46
      So whatever the state doesn't provide has to be made up by local agencies.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:45:51
      Yeah, we haven't talked about, we have a significant clip coming in the CPR box.
    • 01:45:56
      I mean, you know, they mentioned it, but I mean, I just want
    • 01:45:59
      I appreciate you making that point.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:46:13
      And to Director Mitchell's point, I guess just on this chart on the top line, the biggest
    • 01:46:26
      You know, line on the chart, we're providing about 20% of the total.
    • 01:46:30
      So the 1.1 billion over six years is 20% of what the actual total is.
    • 01:46:39
      So it's what, seven, six, seven billion total when you add in, you know, the local share or the federal share that the locals are going and getting.
    • 01:46:52
      And I just wanted to touch on a few highlights.
    • 01:46:55
      And we've been through this over the past couple years where we implemented, we got the new funding in 2013.
    • 01:47:01
      We implemented a performance metric approach to allocating our funding or at least a portion of our operating funding.
    • 01:47:10
      So a portion is still done in traditional methodology which is based on your total expenses compared to everybody's added together.
    • 01:47:19
      And then there is a portion, and that amount is set.
    • 01:47:23
      It doesn't change.
    • 01:47:24
      It's going to be that amount.
    • 01:47:26
      And as revenues grow over time, hopefully, the performance-based formula will get more and more funding running through it.
    • 01:47:34
      And it uses those three metrics that you as the board have approved in the past.
    • 01:47:39
      And as John mentioned, we also do everything we can to maximize, get as much federal funding as we can, and then to maximize the use of that funding.
    • 01:47:49
      Also on the capital side and once again through that effort from the 2013-2013 additional funding, we were required to put in place a prioritization process in our capital allocation.
    • 01:48:07
      Martin, John K. Matney Jr., John K. Matney Jr.,
    • 01:48:29
      E. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:48:48
      The subcommittee, the transit service delivery advisory committee, so there will be a review done coming up in a year or a year and a half.
    • 01:48:57
      I'm not sure of the exact timing where potential recommendations could be made to change these tiers.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:49:03
      I think the point here too often here that we don't prioritize transit that's not a true statement we do transit capital everybody always here well why don't you do we do it's just a different way because of the nature of what we're doing the reimbursement I want to make it clear we do every capital thing now with house bill 287 and what we did in his act before on transit everything is prioritized before it's reimbursed for funding
    • 01:49:33
      That's just a different way we do it under transit.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:49:38
      And with that, this next slide is our rail program for the next six years.
    • 01:49:44
      And I'm not going to go into the details except once again on the other, that is the management.
    • 01:49:51
      In this case, it's just the DRPT management administration costs.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:49:57
      Mr. Chairman, can I ask a question?
    • 01:49:59
      On this slide, is this the money we're spending to help freight rail?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:50:05
      Well, when you go down this slide, I guess it's kind of broken up by the different programs, so freight rail program, yes, is the top line, the rail enhancement line.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:50:14
      The rail enhancement money is the freight rail?
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:16
      I-PROC is the acronym, that's the passenger rail, so that's what's funding major passenger rail projects.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:50:27
      Well, and I'll add all our passenger rail projects are on freight rail lines, so generally those are also benefiting freight rails.
    • 01:50:36
      Paulson.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:50:38
      Are the improvements to the tracks, the freight railroads required in order to get an agreement with Amtrak, does that money come out of IPROC or out of rail enhancement?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:50:53
      Most of it is coming out of IPRC but when we did the Norfolk extension there was appropriation act language to
    • 01:51:00
      Iprock didn't exist.
    • 01:51:02
      It allowed us to take it out of the rail enhancement fund.
    • 01:51:16
      And on the rail side, basically the rail allocations are a discretionary-based program.
    • 01:51:24
      There's a lot, I'm not going to go into all the details, there's a lot more to it, but
    • 01:51:28
      At a high level, it's discretionary based on the department's work and recommendations to y'all and y'all's decisions.
    • 01:51:36
      And some of the highlights for the current year, we want to continue to develop the passenger projects in key corridors.
    • 01:51:44
      And obviously we want to continue supporting our short line program, that last mile program, and then
    • 01:51:51
      As I mentioned earlier, due to General Assembly language in the back of both 1887 and also in the Appropriation Act, we're doing a review of our rail programs currently.
    • 01:52:06
      And just a few other items for y'all to be thinking about when we bring you the draft program.
    • 01:52:14
      We are this year, in the past we have shown some needs data for our transit capital for the future.
    • 01:52:21
      This year we're actually going to go ahead and allocate funding to those projects for those five out years, so that's a change.
    • 01:52:29
      We're also going to segregate out those capital projects, whether they're state of good repair projects or they're expansion because I think when we talk about the amount of funding and bond cliff, etc., I think
    • 01:52:46
      A lot of people don't realize most of our core transit capital funding goes to essentially state of good repair projects.
    • 01:52:54
      We're not, as Director Mitchell mentioned earlier, we really don't have the funds in that line to fund the Dulles Metrorail Project or a Virginia Beach Light Rail extension.
    • 01:53:06
      The next point here is, and we talked about this back September, October, November, we had a loss from 2014 of about $12 million.
    • 01:53:19
      And we dealt with that loss by allowing operating funding to stay the same level it was in the year we're currently in.
    • 01:53:27
      But obviously now we have to deal with it in this coming six-year program.
    • 01:53:32
      Fortunately, revenues are up.
    • 01:53:34
      The projections are up.
    • 01:53:37
      With those increases in revenue projections, we're only going to be down about 3% year-over-year, 15 to the 16th program we're putting together.
    • 01:53:49
      So we have to think about what do we want to do with that?
    • 01:53:51
      Do we want to use transit reserves and deobligated balances to make up that 3%?
    • 01:53:56
      Do we want to live with the 3% decline?
    • 01:53:59
      We've been talking about it and we've warned that this was coming so that's a decision y'all will have to make and we'll come back with the director making a recommendation.
    • 01:54:09
      And then finally obviously our admin level, the three and a half percent off the top.
    • 01:54:16
      And these last two slides are really just a schedule
    • 01:54:21
      For putting together the six-year program, and I think the highlights are really in April, we're coming back with the draft program, then we'll have our hearings throughout May, and then in June, obviously come back with budgets and final six-year plan for y'all's approval.
    • 01:54:40
      With that, I'll gladly entertain any questions.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:43
      Just one more thing I want to add and this refers back to the slides that Steve had about the funding allocation formulas and the prioritization that we do on the capital program.
    • 01:54:55
      Many of you were not here when the previous, the CTB in 2012
    • 01:55:00
      approved this distribution formula.
    • 01:55:04
      There were some concerns among many of the stakeholders around the state about winners and losers, so the CTB at the time asked us to let a year go by, then do a review of our FY15 allocations to see if there were any disproportionate impacts on providers in one part of the state versus another part of the state.
    • 01:55:25
      So we are finishing up that review right now.
    • 01:55:28
      We're going to bring it back to the Transit Service Delivery Advisory Committee.
    • 01:55:32
      And in late April, and my intent is to bring, depending on what the TISDAC recommends, my intent is to bring that, the findings of that analysis back to you all in May, so that if there are any changes that we need to fold into our six-year plan, we can do that at that time.
    • 01:55:49
      So I just wanted to, while we're all talking about the allocation formulas, let you know that, because many of you, a few of you were here then, but not all of you were.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:56:00
      Yes, it is.
    • 01:56:04
      Any other questions for Mr. Pittard or Mr. Lawson?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:56:15
      Mr. Whitworth.
    • 01:56:17
      Mr. Secretary, just so that I understand, can we go back a minute to slide 44?
    • 01:56:27
      And maybe that's to me kind of the most critical slide of understanding this thing.
    • 01:56:36
      It's my understanding that under the district grant program
    • 01:56:43
      Then each of those projects that each of the districts would have, those projects will still go through an HB2 process.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:56:52
      At the district level, that's correct.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:56:53
      But they will be competing against only those projects that are in that district.
    • 01:56:59
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:56:59
      Is that correct?
    • 01:57:00
      Yes, at the district level, that's correct.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:57:03
      And under one of the earlier slides showed
    • 01:57:08
      up to $25 million would be allocated for unpaid roads.
    • 01:57:16
      Is that money part of the dollars that are shown there?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:57:21
      No, that's insane.
    • 01:57:21
      It is.
    • 01:57:22
      It is.
    • 01:57:23
      But, I mean, that's our decision.
    • 01:57:25
      That's it.
    • 01:57:25
      We don't think VDOT is making their progress.
    • 01:57:29
      We're allowed to do that.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:31
      This board will have to vote.
    • 01:57:32
      Yeah, I think the question on the unpaid road is, is it a corporate decision or is it a district by district decision?
    • 01:57:40
      In other words,
    • 01:57:40
      Can one district say I want to allocate to unpaid and another not?
    • 01:57:44
      I think it will be our decision to grant that at a statewide level and then we would push it out through the unpaid growth formula.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:57:55
      I think that's correct.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:57:57
      On the other side, on the state of good repair, those percentages and dollars
    • 01:58:06
      We're based upon existing situations, is that correct?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:58:10
      With a floor and a maximum.
    • 01:58:13
      No more than 17 and a half percent I think is a maximum and a what is it five and a half percent floor and that was based on working with VDOT and what they were doing and there is one caveat to that this board has a discretion if a major bridge falls down
    • 01:58:29
      And we need to do something, or if there's some major catastrophe, you have the discretion to override that, to take care of that.
    • 01:58:38
      But only in extreme emergencies.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:58:39
      But that's the state of repairs today, as we see it, as we evaluate it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:58:44
      It evolves every, basically it's been evaluated each year.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:58:49
      In 2021, that could be entirely different.
    • 01:58:53
      Based on their recommendations.
    • 01:58:54
      And once again, is each district
    • 01:58:57
      competing within itself for those dollars.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:59:02
      It's not competing based on the recommendation of VDOT staff in the district with the district board.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:59:07
      The prioritization is competing, that's what I meant, within itself.
    • 01:59:11
      One project over another.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:59:13
      Mr. Harrington?
    • 01:59:15
      Yes.
    • 01:59:15
      Your Honor, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Whitworth, to your point, the dollars you see there for the static wood repair program are dollars that must be used within that district.
    • 01:59:24
      What the Chairman was talking about is there are other requirements in House Bill 1887 and after my presentation today I think we're going to walk through some of the other nuances within this legislation.
    • 01:59:34
      This Board is charged with developing a priority ranking system that then the Commissioner is going to be using to help identify projects within each of these districts based on the funds that are provided to each district to fix some of these bridges as well as the primary and interstate pavements.
    • 01:59:50
      And so you will have a hand in shaping that policy in the commission of the action?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:59:54
      That's not a House Bill 2 competition.
    • 01:59:56
      That is an asset management division that will be working with VDOT.
    • 02:00:01
      Mr. Chairman, does that answer your question?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:00:06
      Well, I'm not sure I understood that last part.
    • 02:00:09
      Any of the projects will have to go prioritization, right?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:00:12
      State of Good Repair is not a House Bill 2.
    • 02:00:16
      It is an asset management program, which they do very well going out and telling us which are the bad projects.
    • 02:00:23
      Thank you, Court.
    • 02:00:24
      Mr. Rosen's comment about these bridges out there, those, no matter who owns it, they get fixed now.
    • 02:00:31
      So it's not House Bill 2, it's VDOT through its asset management, whatever that determines it to be, or a bridge maybe, they say this is the most significant asset that needs to be taken care of.
    • 02:00:45
      The district is a House Bill 2, the district grant is a House Bill 2 contract.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:00:50
      This kind of, I think, helps screen the whole program to me.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:00:56
      Right, so what happens is the court's issue is that no more are they saving up, that bridge is determined to be bad and that's the worst one in the district.
    • 02:01:06
      VDOT and the district working together, that's where it gets funded.
    • 02:01:10
      Now, if the district gets grants and there's competing projects, it goes through House Bill 2 in their district, it comes to us, and the CTB determines in that district when it gets funded.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:01:25
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:01:26
      That's why we're, because you saw it's going this way, we want to bend that curve back up and each day, and every district has
    • 02:01:33
      On the floor, there was a big discussion, the floor of the house, and it was Doug Watts.
    • 02:01:42
      We really, if we wanted to, we take every bit of our money and put it into good repair.
    • 02:01:48
      We've got a lot to catch up with, but we thought this was the right amount, 45% was negotiated, was the right amount to bend that curve up because we do have growth in the system as Mr. Kilpatrick has pointed out and that's through the House Bill 2, but that's right.
    • 02:02:02
      That's what it was meant to do is to target that state of good repair.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:02:06
      So these percentages tell you in a picture that
    • 02:02:09
      Where one percentage is higher than the other, there is more disrepair that needs attention right now.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:02:16
      That's right.
    • 02:02:17
      That could change over time.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:20
      That could change over time.
    • 02:02:21
      I practically expect it to change over time because we are, our facilities are deteriorating, but we're also working to improve them.
    • 02:02:30
      And some of these districts are, we frankly expect them to trend upward over the next six years.
    • 02:02:37
      And so the needs in a particular district may go down.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:02:40
      But remember, the law has a floor and a minimum.
    • 02:02:45
      So it's going to change, but nobody's going to double for us.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:02:48
      I'm sorry to hold you up.
    • 02:02:49
      That's alright.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:02:50
      Mr. Chairman, I know I think that's really, really good questions.
    • 02:02:53
      And I think one thing we need to point out here is the 40-30-30 formula, or whatever it is, is gone.
    • 02:03:01
      That's right.
    • 02:03:02
      So the cities are no longer going to get
    • 02:03:07
      The money for construction.
    • 02:03:10
      They're going to be in a pot with everybody in the district under the district grant program to compete.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:03:17
      That's correct.
    • 02:03:18
      City and town.
    • 02:03:19
      City and town.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:03:20
      City and town.
    • 02:03:21
      But, exactly.
    • 02:03:23
      But before, cities got a certain amount of money that they could spend on construction.
    • 02:03:27
      Counties were
    • 02:03:30
      B. Dotting Jr.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:46
      The way that it worked, the resident engineer worked with the board, but the board said the county board set the priorities.
    • 02:03:55
      I'm not aware of a circumstance in recent history where the county board went this way and the resident engineer went that way.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:04:02
      It was agreed upon.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:04:04
      In the state of good repair, we would expect a whole lot of cooperation, a lot of cooperation, between the two developing the plan.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:04:12
      Once the House Bill 2 criteria are calculated for the district grant program and 9.6% of that money goes to Salem and that number is calculated, who makes the decision, because House Bill 2 is not, it's not
    • 02:04:29
      This board still makes that decision.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:04:32
      They come to recommendations from the district, but the board, you don't advocate your decision.
    • 02:04:39
      But it is a district-wide competition.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:04:42
      So this board will spend under these categories
    • 02:04:47
      The high priority projects will compete on a statewide basis and this board will make a determination and use the House Bill 2 score to help make that.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:04:56
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:04:57
      Under the highway district construction program, the same thing except there's a limited amount for each district.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:05:04
      They're competing only against those in each district.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:05:07
      And the good repair is a formula set up based on what the state of good repair happens to be in that district and will fluctuate.
    • 02:05:14
      That's right.
    • 02:05:15
      Last question.
    • 02:05:16
      How were the percentages for the district grant program set?
    • 02:05:23
      Was that set in legislation?
    • 02:05:25
      It was set in legislation.
    • 02:05:26
      I thought it was, but okay.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:05:28
      So Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, the way the percentages that were determined for the distribution of the district grant program is those are based on the existing or old formulas for the primary, secondary, and urban formulas.
    • 02:05:42
      So if that formula existed today,
    • 02:05:44
      On aggregate, the Bristol District would have received 7% of the total funding running through the old 40, 30, 30.
    • 02:05:51
      And so what we tried to do was make sure with what was going back to the district, everyone was held harmless.
    • 02:05:57
      A hundred percent of people.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:05:57
      Now, as lane miles are added, that's a self-adjusting formula over time, just like the old 40, 30, 30.
    • 02:06:03
      Right.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:06:04
      And as lane miles are added, and as particularly as lane miles are added in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads because they're going to have more money to spend, it's going to change this number.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:13
      That's correct.
    • 02:06:14
      That's correct.
    • 02:06:15
      A population also changed.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:06:16
      A population changed it too.
    • 02:06:18
      It's a self-proportional.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:06:20
      Right, I get it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:06:21
      I understand.
    • 02:06:23
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:06:24
      It's very helpful.
    • 02:06:26
      Mr. Chairman, a high priority project
    • 02:06:31
      That is really a decision of this board without really recommendations from the district as to what is a high priority project.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:06:44
      Statewide implications, corridors, statewide significance, etc.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:06:49
      Yes, you can still get recommendations from that's the part of this is a project may be chosen to compete in its district and also at the statewide level.
    • 02:07:01
      But it is, I think you're right generally, I think that's what the monies would be used for.
    • 02:07:09
      But there is no restriction against putting the project in.
    • 02:07:12
      I want to compete against statewide funds too.
    • 02:07:15
      In that regard.
    • 02:07:17
      That's our description.
    • 02:07:19
      This board's description.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:07:21
      And Mr. Chairman, I would say there's discretion at the high priority as to whether or not we follow some of the things we talked about previously in House Bill 2 where we would solicit from the MPOs and the local governments.
    • 02:07:32
      And the Board has discretion to choose to do that under high priority or to choose other courses.
    • 02:07:37
      Under the Construction District Grant Program, because that kind of is seen as replacing the secondary and urban funds, the Board is required by law
    • 02:07:45
      to take projects only from local governments within that district that are nominated and supported within that area.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:07:52
      So they are recommended from the district level?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:07:56
      It is a grant program of the local government.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:07:58
      We're not putting the projects in.
    • 02:08:02
      It's not left up to us.
    • 02:08:05
      It's got to be supported locally or statewide.
    • 02:08:08
      Somebody put it in.
    • 02:08:09
      Now we may reserve the right to put in one if we think there's a glaring need that's missed, but the whole intent is they are developed from the ground up.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:08:20
      I still have seven more questions.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:08:23
      Okay.
    • 02:08:27
      It's his presentation, by the way, he's going to go through.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:08:29
      I understand.
    • 02:08:30
      I understand the House Bill too, but the question is
    • 02:08:34
      Say a locality thinks that this big road is really important.
    • 02:08:42
      And they say, we want to put our district grant program in there.
    • 02:08:47
      And we want some of the money to come from the statewide program.
    • 02:08:51
      And that's okay?
    • 02:08:52
      Sure.
    • 02:08:53
      Why not?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:08:54
      It's going to be scored.
    • 02:08:58
      One's going to compete against districts in its own district and one's going to be across the statewide.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:09:04
      I would also say that one of the things that I'm going to talk about in today's presentation as they talk about is we have a process now that you still would like to have modifications about how we score a project and create a scored list of projects for the board to evaluate.
    • 02:09:20
      What we're going to have to work on in the coming months is how do we go from a list of 50 projects with a number next to them to a list of projects you're funding.
    • 02:09:28
      And I think there's a lot of things that we need to discuss and I think House Bill 1887 has some implications
    • 02:09:33
      into that, but that is something that staff don't have recommendations yet for the board on, but know that we need to come to the board with in the coming months to really facilitate this type of discussion as to how do programs work in tandem, how do they work with the other programs, and how are we really going to help you all as staff move from that list of evaluated projects into potential programs that could be funded.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:09:56
      Right, and we're going to have a discussion about this, but what this could turn into is a leverage.
    • 02:10:00
      Okay, good.
    • 02:10:01
      I agree.
    • 02:10:02
      I hope it does.
    • 02:10:02
      Put some of your state money in here, some of your money, and then maybe we'll do it.
    • 02:10:06
      Let's take your discussion on 81.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:10:07
      People have different amounts of that.
    • 02:10:09
      We'll take 81, but if you decided to take every bit of state of the district money on 81 and say we want to put it on that and also compete at the state.
    • 02:10:19
      What would we care if they did that?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:10:21
      We wouldn't, but what I would care about is to say, hey, you want an 81 project, put some of your money on it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:10:26
      Well, that's a different issue, and it may be the same issue we talked to the Regents about, because you get back to scoring.
    • 02:10:35
      Okay, good talking to you.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:10:37
      A mine is not HB2, but on the state of good repair, Mr. Rovers, I think that was really a very good clarifying question that you asked.
    • 02:10:45
      So in Bristol, $34 million, you've identified projects within the Bristol district that for state of good repair.
    • 02:10:53
      We already know that's $34 million.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:10:55
      We know they need more than $34 million with the money.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:10:57
      Right, but I'm saying you've identified those projects.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:59
      We haven't actually identified the project.
    • 02:11:01
      It's based on the percent of deficient bridges and deficient pavement.
    • 02:11:07
      It's aggregated.
    • 02:11:09
      We haven't identified the specific products at this time.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:11:13
      But you have an idea of where the deficient assets are.
    • 02:11:17
      Absolutely.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:18
      Based on the two areas of payments and bridges, we know the percent and we frankly know the
    • 02:11:23
      I know the location today of the fish and pavements.
    • 02:11:26
      Six years from now my list will be completely different because over that period of time I'll be repaving and things will deteriorate.
    • 02:11:34
      So when you see those percentages don't think of them in terms of we've got projects identified.
    • 02:11:40
      We have at the programmatic level these are the general areas.
    • 02:11:45
      I can be confident in telling you those numbers in 2021 and those percentages will not be the same because what will happen over time is we'll be improving and... You're assuming you don't do it evenly.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:12:00
      I think he's right, but my point is that we shouldn't prejudge, but they probably will.
    • 02:12:08
      It really depends.
    • 02:12:09
      We'll know if we're bending that, what Mr. Bragorski put out.
    • 02:12:13
      I mean, I think you're right, John.
    • 02:12:14
      I think they will.
    • 02:12:15
      But we could spend every dollar for the next 10 years in this state on a good repair.
    • 02:12:20
      And my point is that there's plenty of projects.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:23
      Absolutely, and we're doing everything we can to drive the percentage of deficient pavement and deficient bridges and pavement, we want to drive them down, which if we're doing them exactly equally with those numbers said, saying the answer is probably so, the reality of how it works doesn't work that way.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:12:45
      So that was really my question, you know, to come up with the $34 million for Bristol, how did you do that and just knowing that you have a sense of, you know where all the deficient projects are in Virginia, what, where our priorities should be, and so, but we haven't developed the exact, we haven't set those priorities yet.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:05
      No, this is a future looking snapshot which is a bit challenging to do because again you're taking a picture six years out of where we think the percentage would be.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:13:18
      And you know in the broader scope of this though there was the feeling that the only money that was definitely going to come back to your district was the grant money.
    • 02:13:26
      Well this is actually showing right because we were saying you can compete in every bucket with this new formula.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:32
      In the area of State of Good Repair, you are guaranteed, each district is guaranteed a minimum of five and a half percent
    • 02:14:00
      And no more than 17.5%.
    • 02:14:01
      So no district can receive more than 17.5% in a year, nor less than 5.5%.
    • 02:14:08
      Again, there's that exception for what I'll call extraordinary circumstances.
    • 02:14:13
      But again, the district can rely on receiving at least 5.5% in state of good repair.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:14:21
      But if you look at, just numerically, there's only three districts that could double.
    • 02:14:26
      It's 17 and a half percent.
    • 02:14:27
      There's only three districts that hit less.
    • 02:14:30
      My point is, Mr. Whitworth, it's going to change, but it's not going to be all of a sudden all going one way or the other.
    • 02:14:36
      You're going to see a percentage here and a percentage there, but it's not going to be this because you're limited by a floor and a maximum.
    • 02:14:44
      So that's really where I was getting to.
    • 02:14:46
      So it can't be to the extent all of a sudden one area is going to be getting all the money sent to the repair.
    • 02:14:53
      And the point is, maybe this board 10 or 12 years from now we've done such a good job that maybe we reduce the amount of money that goes in the state of good repair, but that's a long way down the future based on where we've been.
    • 02:15:11
      We're going to go through, I think, he's got some more questions, I know.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:15:20
      So, we're going to do House Bill 2.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:15:24
      Now, the food is here.
    • 02:15:27
      What do we do, Broad Street BRT?
    • 02:15:30
      Do you want to do that?
    • 02:15:32
      No, I just meant that's the next one.
    • 02:15:34
      How long do you think that will take?
    • 02:15:35
      Do you have an idea?
    • 02:15:37
      Okay, well why don't we do that and then that way we can break and then we can have House Bill 2 after lunch.
    • 02:15:48
      And you'll have to forgive Charlie and myself, Jennifer and Nick.
    • 02:15:57
      We've been living this a while so forgive us if that's not the intention.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:16:04
      Carol, did this last presentation for John, that was not in the...
    • 02:16:11
      I understand.
    • 02:16:12
      Can you mail it out to everybody, please?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:16:15
      Okay, so, Ms. Inman, why don't we go through that?
    • 02:16:19
      And I understand they have a name for this now.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:22
      Yeah, while we're getting that set up, I'll just mention that the GRTC has actually, their board has selected a name for the project, I think it's called.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:16:30
      GRT Pulse?
    • 02:16:31
      Thank you.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:32
      Yeah.
    • 02:16:33
      Pulse.
    • 02:16:33
      They'll be releasing more information about that.
    • 02:16:36
      Oh, GRTC.
    • 02:16:37
      GRTC, yes.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:16:38
      The Pulse, yes.
    • 02:16:39
      That was just announced, I think yesterday.
    • 02:16:43
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:16:45
      We really appreciate having this opportunity to talk with you this morning.
    • 02:16:49
      about the Broad Street BRT project.
    • 02:16:52
      This project really is one that will be probably Richmond's primary project over the next many years.
    • 02:17:00
      It's something that's going to be transformational for the Richmond region.
    • 02:17:06
      Bus rapid transit will integrate the systems of facilities, equipment, services, and amenities that improve the speed, reliability, and identity of bus transit.
    • 02:17:16
      However, and I think what's worth noting for you all is it's going to maximize the capacity of the existing rights of way that we've been investing in right here in Richmond.
    • 02:17:25
      We did receive a categorical exclusion from the Federal Transit Administration, so we will not be going outside of the existing right of way.
    • 02:17:32
      So we really are maximizing the rights of way within Broad Street and onto Main Street.
    • 02:17:40
      The project partners, and really this has been a very collaborative effort over the last many years.
    • 02:17:46
      between the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, the City of Richmond, Henrico County, the Federal Transit Administration, and GRTC to advance this project.
    • 02:17:56
      What's worth noting here, and as Director Mitchell mentioned earlier, we were seeking the Small Start funding from the Federal Transit Administration, which is their capital program for advancing transit projects.
    • 02:18:10
      and as she mentioned it is a very competitive pot of money and you compete for those funds with projects across the United States.
    • 02:18:22
      However, we were in a position, in a really good position when the TIGER program came out earlier last year that allowed for $600 million worth of funding.
    • 02:18:34
      They received billions of dollars worth of requests
    • 02:18:38
      This project, thanks to this administration, this was the governor's number one project, which allowed us to go and we were able to get 50% of the funding, which was $24.9 million to fully fund this project.
    • 02:18:57
      DRPT, we're putting in 34% of the funding.
    • 02:19:00
      The City of Richmond will put in 15%, and Henrico County will be putting in
    • 02:19:04
      We will be working with VDOT and they will be doing the permitting and GRTC will be the owner and operator of the system and they are advancing the project through project development and construction.
    • 02:19:21
      We do have a very robust stakeholder and public involvement program.
    • 02:19:26
      We have a policy advisory committee that is comprised of the directors and administrators from the localities.
    • 02:19:33
      We have the technical advisory committee which is the engineers and the planners that attend those meetings and then we have a very robust community involvement as well because we want to make sure that this service is not only maximizing the investments that we're making but it's going to be a huge benefit to the community.
    • 02:19:54
      We've already had two public meetings that were held in January and there will be public meetings that are held throughout the project through construction.
    • 02:20:03
      This is a map of the alignment.
    • 02:20:07
      It's a 7.6 mile alignment from Willow Lawn to Rockets Landing.
    • 02:20:12
      We will be having dedicated bus lanes from Thompson to Adams that will be in the median.
    • 02:20:18
      We'll also be using dedicated lanes on the curb.
    • 02:20:22
      We'll have 14 stations total.
    • 02:20:25
      There will be five center stations, nine curbside stations, and we'll also be consolidating some of the stations with the local routes to really maximize the capacity not only of the street but also of the service that we'll be feeding into the BRT.
    • 02:20:41
      Some elements of the BRT, the running way, this is just an illustration of what the dedicated guideway will look like in the median.
    • 02:20:50
      We'll have faster service, the stations will be very robust.
    • 02:20:53
      We'll have nice vehicles, there'll be branding and of course the technology.
    • 02:20:58
      As I mentioned, the stations, they're not just any stations, they're going to be very nice stations, and actually the graphic that you see there on the bottom, that is the station design that GRTC has selected.
    • 02:21:13
      It's very nice, it will have off-board fare collection, there will be level boarding, the lighting, there will be public art amenities that will be able to be incorporated into the station itself.
    • 02:21:27
      The BRT vehicles, they'll be low floor, they'll be branded so that folks know, hey, this is the BRT, this is the pulse, running from little lawn to rockets landing and it'll have its own identity, it'll have sliding doors.
    • 02:21:42
      GRTC is in the midst of converting their fleet to clean natural gas and these vehicles will also be CNG.
    • 02:21:49
      The technology
    • 02:21:51
      We will have the real-time passenger information, which is very critical to folks.
    • 02:21:56
      We'll also have the transit signal priority, and this is something that it's not like preemption like what the emergency vehicles have, but it will allow the VRT vehicles to have priority through the intersection, so it will delay the light on a green signal.
    • 02:22:13
      It will have the closed circuit TV for security.
    • 02:22:17
      It will have emergency phones and again as I mentioned it will have the off-board fare collection system which will provide more efficient service and decrease the dwell times at the actual stations.
    • 02:22:29
      The service plan, they are looking at 5.30 to 11.30 p.m.
    • 02:22:33
      on weekdays, weekends from 6 a.m. to 1130.
    • 02:22:36
      They're currently working with their board right now to possibly extend the evening hours on the weekends to 1 a.m.
    • 02:22:44
      It'll have 10-minute peaks and 15-minute off-peak service.
    • 02:22:48
      It will have a 65% increase in bus speeds, which again is a critical element to the bus rapid transit.
    • 02:22:59
      The ridership
    • 02:23:00
      And these are very conservative estimates.
    • 02:23:03
      3,000 daily boardings with 500 new daily riders.
    • 02:23:08
      This fare will stay the same.
    • 02:23:11
      So there will not be a premium charge for the service.
    • 02:23:15
      The benefits of BRT, we did do an economic impact analysis for this project and it'll increase the bus fees by 65%.
    • 02:23:24
      It's going to reduce the travel time by up to 40%.
    • 02:23:28
      Riders who switch to the BRT will save 36 hours per year.
    • 02:23:32
      The new riders will save $400,000 per year in the transportation costs.
    • 02:23:39
      The total savings for all riders equals $1.5 million per year.
    • 02:23:43
      The increase in property value is 12% or 1.1 billion years over a 20-year lifespan, over a 20-year time period.
    • 02:23:52
      It will increase the property tax revenues by $4.9 million over the 20-year time frame.
    • 02:23:57
      reduced crashes because we're actually going to have the buses in the dedicated lane that can accommodate the buses, unlike what's out there today, which the buses actually spill over the dedicated lane and there's actually quite a few crashes right now or incidents that occur because of that.
    • 02:24:16
      There will be 406 jobs created during the construction of the BRT.
    • 02:24:21
      Now, with the project,
    • 02:24:25
      There will be some parking loss, some on-street parking loss.
    • 02:24:29
      However, there will not be any parking loss between the Fushi and the 4th Street, which is the downtown business area.
    • 02:24:36
      Actually, we're going to be adding parking back into that area.
    • 02:24:40
      Likewise, on Main Street between 14th and Rockets, we will not be having any parking loss as well.
    • 02:24:47
      We'll actually be working, traveling within the mixed
    • 02:24:51
      McRae, John M. McRae Jr., John M. McRae Jr., John M. McRae Jr.,
    • 02:25:15
      And they do have some strategies that they're looking at right now to hopefully reduce any of that on-street parking loss.
    • 02:25:24
      However, the parking on the corridor is represented 9% of the total parking that's actually available adjacent to the corridor.
    • 02:25:35
      So it's a fairly small amount of parking that would be removed from Broad Street and as a result of this project.
    • 02:25:46
      As I mentioned earlier, we have 50% of funding coming from the TIGER money, which is the transportation investment generating economic recovery.
    • 02:25:57
      funding.
    • 02:25:59
      We also have 34% coming from DRPT and then 16% coming from both the City of Richmond and Henrico County.
    • 02:26:08
      The major project milestones, so we received the notice of the TIGER grant award in September of last year.
    • 02:26:17
      We're currently working to get to 30% design by July and right now GRTC has
    • 02:26:25
      A request for proposals out to obtain a construction manager at risk which will be the mechanism to actually implement and construct the project.
    • 02:26:39
      By April of next year we'll be at 60% design and by September of next year we'll be into 90% design and ready to go into construction with a projected date of operations beginning in October of 2017.
    • 02:26:56
      So we're very excited about this.
    • 02:26:58
      This project really has been one that has been very collaborative.
    • 02:27:03
      And again, I think just yesterday we were meeting with Secretary Foxx's staff on the ladder of opportunity.
    • 02:27:11
      They came down very interested in this project to understand how does this help folks to improve their quality of life, provide access to jobs, and it's an exciting project, not only for the city of Richmond, but for this country.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:27:31
      I just have a question, Amy.
    • 02:27:34
      The genesis of this idea on Broad Street
    • 02:27:37
      Was a light rail system or trolley system ever considered and what was the decision making of going to the BRT?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:27:48
      There has been some consideration for rail and streetcar.
    • 02:27:53
      However, given the characteristics of this particular corridor, the bus rapid transit was the best foot forward for this region.
    • 02:28:02
      It's a very costly
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:03
      A effective way of providing a premium type of transit service, and the ridership and the densities would support a BRT, so it's a really good first step forward for them. One of the things that we've talked about, I know Amy came a few months ago and presented on our multimodal guidelines about, typically when we do a study to evaluate alternative technologies like bus rapid transit or light rail.
    • 02:28:33
      Often the decision may lean one way or the other based on population density.
    • 02:28:39
      That's why in Northern Virginia or Hampton Roads, you may see places where light rail is often the most appropriate technology.
    • 02:28:47
      In a place like Richmond, we don't necessarily have the population density here to support the kind of ridership and the kind of development patterns that you would get around light rail in other places.
    • 02:29:02
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine, L. C.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:29:20
      Similarly to Broad Street, the Columbia Place.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:23
      Yes, I figured that's where you're going.
    • 02:29:24
      Right.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:29:25
      No, and that came up the other day at the fourth rate, and that's I think a misconception that ERT and light rail are mutually interchangeable.
    • 02:29:36
      Yeah.
    • 02:29:36
      They're not.
    • 02:29:37
      Yes.
    • 02:29:37
      Chairman.
    • 02:29:38
      So, anyway, let's see.
    • 02:29:42
      Mr. Wager.
    • 02:29:43
      Having attended a couple of them with public hearings, and
    • 02:29:48
      Martin, John C. Kasprowicz Jr., John K. Matney,
    • 02:30:08
      Martin, John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr.,
    • 02:30:28
      So prohibitive.
    • 02:30:29
      We would have never gotten anything.
    • 02:30:30
      I think this BRT is going to work.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:30:32
      It's going to work well.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:30:33
      If it ever gets all the way to short pump, it's really going to be something.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:30:39
      I note in the major project milestones, you have the construction manager at risk to select it.
    • 02:30:45
      Is it a different construction technique than we may have used in the past?
    • 02:30:49
      I understand it hasn't benefits from an efficiency perspective, perhaps project speed.
    • 02:30:54
      How and why was it selected?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:30:55
      Well GRTC, you know this will be their first time obviously implementing something of this nature so transferring the risk to a party that will be able to assume some of that and be able to deliver the project on time I think was one of the factors of going with this particular delivery method and it's a very
    • 02:31:21
      A. Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine, L. C. I would imagine there will be a premium for that, however we have a fixed budget.
    • 02:31:42
      and GRTC, they know that they're not going to be able to go over that budget, so whoever they select is going to have to construct the project in a manner that's acceptable to us and within our budget.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:01
      W. Smith Jr., John K. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 02:32:16
      They're using a program manager in addition to an extension of their staff in addition to bringing on a CMAR contractor.
    • 02:32:25
      That was a decision that they made based on their risk profile and their experience constructing projects and that's what they felt was the most appropriate procurement method for this type of project for them.
    • 02:32:39
      Drpt's role in this is going to be one of oversight.
    • 02:32:42
      We're actually going to be staffing up and probably bringing on some additional resources so that we as the state, because we are, as you saw, we're funding a percentage of this project.
    • 02:32:52
      So if there's any, we do actually bear some cost risk if there is any potential overruns in this project.
    • 02:32:58
      So we are going to be taking on a much bigger oversight role than we traditionally do in a lot of projects.
    • 02:33:04
      So that will be something we're going to be ramping up for over the next month.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:33:10
      It's so exciting to hear about this.
    • 02:33:15
      You mentioned that the total savings to riders is $1.5 million and $400,000 for new riders.
    • 02:33:20
      How did you come up with these numbers?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:33:22
      Those were based on the cost associated with your time.
    • 02:33:30
      When we did the economic impact analysis, those were some numbers that are
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:33:35
      Is it a formula that's used?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:33:38
      Well I mean there's a cost associated with your time and they were able to say well you have this much travel time savings like today there's you know it takes you an hour to get through and there's going to be a travel time savings of you know 15 to 20 minutes so there's a cost associated with that and that's how they're able to derive those those figures.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:33:59
      Okay, any other questions?
    • 02:34:01
      Very exciting project.
    • 02:34:02
      We're looking at the completion date.
    • 02:34:05
      We're starting to get a little close, but it's not still big here.
    • 02:34:10
      It's already accelerated.
    • 02:34:14
      Also, Mr.
    • 02:34:16
      Guy, I would like to make a comment about the Arlington Street Club.
    • 02:34:20
      I'm still waiting on their bus proposal.
    • 02:34:22
      They were talking, they had it all lined up.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:34:24
      That's why I was asking.
    • 02:34:26
      I hate to see Columbia Pike just forgotten because the light rail's not on.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:34:31
      That was the, they had a better alternative.
    • 02:34:34
      I'm waiting to see it.
    • 02:34:36
      If you can encourage them to get to me, we'll be happy to look at it.
    • 02:34:40
      What we'll do is take a recess, it's about twenty till one, so at one-fifteen we'll probably be back in here, so we'll go to the hospital too, and then a couple other things and we'll go through the intercessions, so we'll take a recess at about one-fifteen.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:11:44
      Paul.
    • 03:11:45
      Me too.
    • 03:11:46
      I'm supporting this guy.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:11:47
      Where's my brain?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:11:49
      Can you use this for a week?
    • 03:11:52
      Bush.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:11:53
      Are you really?
    • 03:11:55
      Best chance of the week.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:11:56
      Put this on your sleeve or something I guess.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:12:41
      The armband is something you can look at.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:13:08
      It's an armband.
    • 03:13:08
      It's an armband.
    • 03:13:08
      You wear it up here.
    • 03:13:09
      I guess we can shorty become the armband.
    • 03:13:10
      We think it's a great idea.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:13:10
      I'd say he'll be Mr. Charlie.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:13:12
      We'll have everybody take their seats, please, and we'll call the work session back into order.
    • 03:13:26
      What we have left on the agenda is House Bill 2 implementation with Mr. Donohue, but we will have a few minutes, I hope, to talk about the bill and a couple of other things, too, before going to formal session.
    • 03:13:39
      So, Mr. Donohue.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:13:42
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 03:13:44
      I'm here today to give you your latest update on the House Bill 2 implementation process.
    • 03:13:49
      Before I get started with my presentation, I want to note that each of the board members has a copy of the House Bill 2 policy guide.
    • 03:13:57
      As we talked about in our previous meetings, staff has spent countless hours
    • 03:14:03
      putting down the intimate details of exactly how we're proposing this process would work.
    • 03:14:08
      This document within the hour will be available at VirginiaHB2.org for all the public and others to take a look at.
    • 03:14:16
      And as I've said earlier, we're going to leave this document unchanged in between now and the May meeting.
    • 03:14:21
      We'll be working on revisions based on the public feedback that we get at the spring six-year improvement hearings as well as some of the feedback we've received over the last few weeks.
    • 03:14:29
      But I want to highlight this walks you through
    • 03:14:32
      The entire process from beginning to end, it tells you exactly how we will analyze a project in the given measure factor areas and also tells you how we'll translate that into a score that will be available for a project.
    • 03:14:45
      And so I just wanted to note that each of you should have a copy of this, a hard copy at your desk.
    • 03:14:51
      With that, Mr. Chairman, I just kind of want to remind the board where we are in the House Bill 2 process.
    • 03:14:57
      And so over the last three weeks,
    • 03:15:00
      Myself and staff have been to all nine districts where we've held regional stakeholder meetings, some of which have gone as long as four and a half hours to walk really through this process and get feedback from the local constituents about what they thought was a good idea, what they thought we needed to reconsider, and then just other suggestions on how this process could work better for the area that we're in that day.
    • 03:15:22
      Today, we're releasing this policy guide to the public for their review and comment for the next two months.
    • 03:15:29
      Myself and staff are going to be working to take the comments that we receive as well as feedback we received to date to change and enhance this process over the next two months and it's our hope to come back to you in May with a revised policy guide and also a presentation to really walk through what has changed and then come back to this body in June for your consideration of that process as it is presented to you in May.
    • 03:15:54
      What's not shown on this slide but it's something we are doing and is in response to the board's
    • 03:15:59
      Questions at previous meetings.
    • 03:16:01
      At the April meeting, we hope to bring to you approximately 40 projects that have been evaluated using the HP2 process as it's outlined in this policy guide.
    • 03:16:14
      We're working on that very diligently now.
    • 03:16:16
      I want to say that that process is going to be very close to what's called for in this guide.
    • 03:16:21
      There may be instances where because of just the time constraints and
    • 03:16:25
      We're evaluating past projects.
    • 03:16:26
      We don't have all the information we might have had from a project sponsor that we may have had to make some assumptions.
    • 03:16:32
      But we are going to be able to come back to the board and show you how different types of projects in different parts of the states would be evaluated and would fare under this scoring process.
    • 03:16:42
      So Mr. Chairman, what I'm going to do today is I'm going to start a little bit with some of the feedback we've heard just kind of generally at the nine district meetings we held.
    • 03:16:50
      And then what I want to do with the board is walk you through the process that's outlined in the policy guide
    • 03:16:55
      And where there was stakeholder feedback that we received in the nine district meetings can also highlight that for the board so you can consider those issues as we move forward.
    • 03:17:04
      So I think far and away the largest issue we heard everywhere we get was, is this fair for urban versus rural?
    • 03:17:12
      And there's a lot of consternation in the different communities about whether or not this, and this is also in urban as well as in the rural communities.
    • 03:17:20
      It's not just in the rural or just in the urban, but everyone wanted to know
    • 03:17:24
      Will this work for me?
    • 03:17:25
      And more importantly, will I be able to compete equally with my peers across the state?
    • 03:17:32
      There was also concern about whether or not this was overly weighted towards highways, and in other places there was concern about whether or not this was maybe tilted in the direction of transit.
    • 03:17:41
      One of the other things that we've heard is the Board has stressed a song preference to have as few weighting frameworks as possible in our previous discussions.
    • 03:17:53
      I would say that
    • 03:17:54
      The feedback we've received from a lot of the stakeholders is they'd like additional waiting frameworks.
    • 03:17:59
      Some places said they wanted their own and they wanted to be able to create it themselves.
    • 03:18:03
      I think that would really start to get a little too far afield from the point of the House Bill 2 evaluation process, but there is just generally consternation about the waiting frameworks and whether or not the ones that exist today are appropriate for a given region or the assignment that we've made.
    • 03:18:21
      whether or not they like that.
    • 03:18:22
      So for example, there was one district who was in category B and they said, we got to be in A.
    • 03:18:27
      There's no way that we should not be in category A.
    • 03:18:29
      And similarly, we just got a letter yesterday from a group in category A that says, please don't do this.
    • 03:18:34
      We need to be in category B.
    • 03:18:36
      And so we're going to be taking all these things into account.
    • 03:18:38
      We're going to be compiling these comments and bringing them back to you.
    • 03:18:41
      But that, I think, is one of the key.
    • 03:18:42
      Those are the two issues we heard at every single meeting, which is really, is this
    • 03:18:47
      The urban vs. rural, the highway vs. transit, and is the waiting framework I'm in the one I should be in, and can I create a new one?
    • 03:18:55
      Some of the other just kind of smaller comments really tell me exactly how this is going to work.
    • 03:19:01
      So when you say person throughput on a corridor or reduced person hours of delay on a corridor, what's your corridor?
    • 03:19:07
      How are you going to determine exactly how that corridor is defined, and is that going to be the exact same for every single project?
    • 03:19:13
      And so we're still working on some of those issues, but
    • 03:19:15
      Folks really wanted to make sure they knew exactly how this process was going to play out and that they knew all kind of the devil in the details, if you will, about each of the different measures and how they would work.
    • 03:19:27
      And then the last thing, Mr. Chairman, is a little bit to staff's surprise, there was interest expressed by a fair number of areas under 200,000 to have the transportation land use measure or factor area, excuse me, apply to different PDCs and MPOs.
    • 03:19:45
      Before we get started, I just wanted to remind the board, you know, as we move through this, House Bill 1887, as Mr. Lawson talked about earlier, has been passed by both the House and the Senate, and as we think about House Bill 2 moving forward, remember, about 50% of the money is going to be at the statewide level, where it's a statewide competition, and the other 50% is going back to the districts, where each district will have its own House Bill 2 competition.
    • 03:20:12
      What you see here is the anticipated annual cycle for House Bill 2 and what we've tried to do is really incorporate the existing Six-Year Program cycle and process and modify that to make it work with the House Bill 2.
    • 03:20:28
      So as you look up here you'll see kind of let's start with June.
    • 03:20:32
      Let's move from there and assuming the board acts in the affirmative in June, what will happen after that is VDOT and DRPT staff will be available to assist local governments and regional entities to identify potential projects, help them with schedule, cost and scope issues so that they can refine and enhance their potential applications.
    • 03:20:52
      We're going to start accepting applications this August.
    • 03:20:56
      That application period will be open until October 1st.
    • 03:20:59
      At that point, staff will take all the applications in-house.
    • 03:21:05
      We will screen them walking through the process I'm going to talk about here and a little bit consistent with the law.
    • 03:21:10
      And then we're going to evaluate each of these projects and then convert the evaluation into a relative score based on the cost and the weighting framework for a given region.
    • 03:21:20
      It is our goal to have those scores available for the board in January.
    • 03:21:25
      At its January meeting, I do want to just to manage expectations, say this first go around, we might end up being February, just as we work through some of the kinks in the system, but it's our hope to have that then in January.
    • 03:21:36
      And this goes, the next step goes to some of the issues that Mr. Fralin raised during the earlier discussion at the end of Mr. Lawson's presentation.
    • 03:21:45
      We then are going to have to work through a process where the board takes this list of scored projects,
    • 03:21:50
      both with the statewide pot of money and each district's pot of money and we move from that list of evaluated projects into a discrete list that the board wants to consider for funding.
    • 03:22:02
      And I do think we need to come back to you all with some additional recommendations and guidance on how that process could work for your feedback and input.
    • 03:22:10
      But that would take place between February and April.
    • 03:22:13
      In April, a draft of the program based on House Bill 2 would be released.
    • 03:22:17
      We would go out in May and do the spring six-year improvement hearings
    • 03:22:21
      have a revised draft at the May CTB, and then in June, as you do today, you would consider the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 03:22:28
      And so we really, again, try to take just kind of piggyback on the existing Six-Year Improvement Program process.
    • 03:22:37
      So just walking through how this would work and how the process is laid out, I want to go through several different things that are kind of on the front end of how do you get a project in, who can submit it, and some of the feedback that we've received on that.
    • 03:22:50
      So this slide here walks through the different types of entities that would be eligible to submit projects and talks about the types of projects that they could submit.
    • 03:23:00
      One of the things I want to talk about is this does vary from the previous recommendation that staff made to the board.
    • 03:23:06
      In our earlier recommendation, we had said that MPOs and PDCs would be the only people eligible to submit projects on corridors of statewide significance.
    • 03:23:16
      We heard very loud and clear from the local government community almost immediately that they had significant concerns about that and they wanted to be able to have an avenue to submit projects as well for those corridors of statewide significance, particularly in a lot of areas where they see that corridor as kind of both their main street as well as their entry and exit point to a region.
    • 03:23:37
      And so what we're proposing is that an MPO and a PDC would be able to submit a project that meets a need on a corridor statewide significance or within a regional network or kind of metro area.
    • 03:23:48
      Remember there's 14 of those in the Commonwealth.
    • 03:23:51
      A local government would be able to submit a project that addresses a corridor statewide significance but only with the concurrence.
    • 03:23:57
      of the applicable MPO or PDC and then they would be able to submit projects on a regional network or one that helps promote growth within an urban development area or locally designated growth area.
    • 03:24:09
      And then we are proposing that transit agencies would be able to submit projects for quarters of statewide significance and regional networks but again only with the support of either the MPO, PDC or local government there.
    • 03:24:22
      The reason regional entities and the transit agencies cannot submit projects for the urban development areas
    • 03:24:28
      is the high priority project program is not intended to support those locally designated growth areas.
    • 03:24:34
      It's intended to focus on the corridors of statewide significance and the metro areas or regional networks.
    • 03:24:41
      And then under the district grant program, the law states that only a local government can apply.
    • 03:24:47
      So our previous recommendations were in effect superseded by the legislation that the General Assembly has passed.
    • 03:24:57
      So once an eligible entity sends in an application, what staff are going to do with that?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:25:02
      Back to Mr. Fralin's question earlier.
    • 03:25:07
      So if a locality wanted to submit something to the statewide network, they would have to get concurrence with the MPO that they're in.
    • 03:25:20
      So that's going to limit some of where you put it and what you don't because we're looking for the MPO to tell us that yes, it really has statewide significance.
    • 03:25:31
      So it's not as wide open as just anybody can just pick a pot.
    • 03:25:39
      Let me ask a question on that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:25:42
      I'm assuming this is true and I shouldn't do this.
    • 03:25:45
      We can submit projects.
    • 03:25:48
      Or do we have to go to the MPO and say, hey, we want you to submit this project.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:25:52
      Yes, we think we generally said, and we can decide, the intent is for us not to submit projects and then approve them.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:26:01
      We are the judge.
    • 03:26:04
      Not any one of us can approve a project.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:26:06
      I understand, but the intent was that we heard loud and clear that the project should be developed and we judge it.
    • 03:26:15
      So who's going to present projects of statewide significance?
    • 03:26:20
      I think you're going to have MPOs that do that just the way they do now, the regions and stuff.
    • 03:26:26
      That's where they mostly come from now.
    • 03:26:28
      We said we would reserve what, one or two?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:26:30
      This previous staff recommendation is that for the high priority projects concept that the board would reserve the right to submit one or two projects.
    • 03:26:41
      Staff talked with a lot of folks across the state.
    • 03:26:43
      about switching to this evaluation process, they thought it would be appropriate to have locals and staff concur with this and regional entities submit the projects and then a different entity who didn't nominate projects would be the one who evaluates and selects them.
    • 03:26:58
      Some folks saw the board put in all the projects that would be evaluated and the locals got to put in the projects that they didn't see what the effort would be with because if you put in all the projects you wanted, you probably weren't going to fund theirs anyway.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:27:10
      So that means you could work with your localities and your regional MPO if you wanted one submitted.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:27:18
      But for a true project of statewide significance, in other words, this is going to apply across several transportation districts.
    • 03:27:27
      Say you want to build, say we, say Congress comes to our census and we get enough money and we start building roads, seriously building roads again.
    • 03:27:37
      If there is a planned intersect that we want to build, say between Roanoke and Greensboro, okay, I got to go to the MPO and say, hey, we're going to do that or not?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:27:49
      We have not said that.
    • 03:27:52
      And I said on an exception basis, I think it's, like I said, I've always said this doesn't make us give up our brain.
    • 03:27:58
      But on an exception basis, I think that's a case that can be made.
    • 03:28:01
      But it will not be, I do not believe it should be the rule, or neither does the rest of them.
    • 03:28:06
      We are the ones, since we are prioritizing them and are governing them, we are the ones that are submitting projects.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:28:15
      I just disagree with that.
    • 03:28:17
      I think on a statewide significant project that, first of all, if we don't support it, it's not going to get passed anyway.
    • 03:28:26
      Okay, so it seems to me that on those projects where we can, and maybe we say you've got to have two or three of us together to put one in the hopper or something, but it seems to me that if this isn't a policy board that's going to make decisions about what roads are going to be considered, we're just going to do the consideration.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:28:50
      I think that's a problem.
    • 03:28:52
      Well, you have the other side is that we have projects that have no support.
    • 03:28:58
      So I think there is a very, if you have a, I kind of think of a, I have a conceptual project that I think ought to get done.
    • 03:29:10
      Right.
    • 03:29:10
      You know, and I can't get the MPO to think it's worthwhile.
    • 03:29:15
      I mean, that's the other side of it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:29:17
      MPOs only got a certain amount of money.
    • 03:29:19
      No, no, no.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:29:20
      You're talking about for screening.
    • 03:29:21
      In other words, we're talking about for submitting.
    • 03:29:24
      We haven't made the funding decision yet.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:29:26
      I understand, but where I'm going with this is I think unless we, when we get to the funding piece, unless we change what we're doing, we're going to be trying to leverage the state money against the MPO money.
    • 03:29:40
      In terms of the 188 money or whatever whatever that bill number is and so we're going to say We're going to score this differently if you put your money on it
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:29:50
      Well, you're making an assumption.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:29:52
      And maybe so.
    • 03:29:52
      That I don't know that we've made yet.
    • 03:29:54
      Okay.
    • 03:29:55
      I mean, I've made that.
    • 03:29:56
      But I do think we did reserve, like at the NVTA, we had about three projects that were labeled from the CTB represented.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:30:08
      So I think there's some usefulness to say on an exception basis that
    • 03:30:12
      Let me ask one more question and I'll be quiet.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:30:15
      Say the NPO is Arlington and Arlington has a seat on NPO, not picking on Arlington, and say 66 is the project and Arlington says we're not supporting that project because we don't want to widen 66.
    • 03:30:25
      Therefore, you can't get the NPO to recommend it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:30:28
      Well, then where are we?
    • 03:30:30
      But the NPO is not one entity.
    • 03:30:33
      Well, say they got no votes to keep it down, but everybody else in the state thinks it's a good idea.
    • 03:30:38
      Well, if you don't get it in their long-range plan, we can't fund it anyway.
    • 03:30:44
      If they don't recognize it, we can't get federal funding on it.
    • 03:30:48
      I mean, that's the other side of this.
    • 03:30:51
      We have this all the time.
    • 03:30:52
      So, I don't think that's any different than we have now, because if we don't have them to put it in their plan.
    • 03:31:01
      We're dealing with this on Hampton Roads.
    • 03:31:02
      They don't put the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel in their long-range plan.
    • 03:31:08
      We can't make them put it in their plan.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:31:16
      I think what the chairman is talking about is there are some other, this was also developed taking into account some federal rules that we cannot, you know, modify or have, we have no discretion over here at the state level and one of the most basic ones is that if an MPO does not include a project in its long constrained, long range plan, constrained,
    • 03:31:33
      I get that.
    • 03:31:36
      Let's say PDC.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:31:37
      The PDC went to it.
    • 03:31:45
      You're right.
    • 03:31:45
      We can't spend any federal money unless the NPO approves it.
    • 03:31:48
      I get that.
    • 03:31:48
      I don't like that.
    • 03:31:49
      I think we're setting ourselves up for the same rule with PDC.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:31:52
      So that's why I say I think on an exception basis but I put your, I try to put myself on the other side too.
    • 03:31:59
      You know are we gonna you know we're saying we're going to make all the projects and like it or not that's what we're going to fund.
    • 03:32:06
      That's what we heard from all the localities.
    • 03:32:08
      That's our job.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:32:09
      And we still have to score.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:32:12
      Not if you believe the decision-making is best made from the local level up.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:32:17
      Well, that's true on local roads.
    • 03:32:19
      On roads with statewide significance, I think it's better made at the state level and I think that these roads will have to be scored and compete just like anybody else put one up would have to be scored.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:32:28
      Don't we have a process to determine what a road is in terms of being a statewide significance?
    • 03:32:36
      There's a process that has to go through.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:32:38
      It's not subjective, it's objective.
    • 03:32:40
      No, it is subjective.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:32:41
      I'm trying to think through this, but let's just say that the Richmond MPO and the MPO and Hampton Roads don't want 460.
    • 03:32:51
      I'm just going after real life, let's assume they don't want, we're going to say we're going to continue to build 460.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:33:00
      If the MPO doesn't put on a long range plan, we can't do it.
    • 03:33:05
      I get that.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:33:06
      That's a bad example.
    • 03:33:08
      That's a state line significant.
    • 03:33:10
      We've got more than one.
    • 03:33:12
      I don't see us building anything if we can't get, if there isn't a regional support.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:33:18
      Let me give you an example.
    • 03:33:19
      Say we want to build 295.
    • 03:33:21
      Say 295 is not there.
    • 03:33:23
      We decide we want to build it.
    • 03:33:25
      and the, well, all right, I get it, I get it, but say all the MPOs are in agreement, all the localities are in agreement, except for the PDC that covers, what's the, Emporio.
    • 03:33:48
      And they say no.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:33:50
      But it meets the criteria. Can we still build it? Yeah, the other ones have submitted it. You've got it now and one for the other ones. We're talking about just being to be able to consider it. All right. I think I answered that right. We're not saying if you've got one that's going to sponsor it, it can be considered. I'm sorry. Mr. Chairman, after this discussion, I'm not clear. Have we made a decision that we can, as a board, submit projects? Or is that yet to be made?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:34:15
      As yet to be made, we have said there would be very limited fees.
    • 03:34:21
      Well I would just suggest that we do that given the conflict of interest potential that there would be some criteria that are pretty well identified up front.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:34:29
      And let me just speak so the board members are clear on where we are in this process.
    • 03:34:33
      What you have before you is a draft document that we will revise based on feedback from the public and the board.
    • 03:34:42
      So when I say
    • 03:34:43
      The process is this.
    • 03:34:45
      That's what is proposed in a draft document staff have created that has no actual bearing on the final process except for the degree to which it remains intact as we move forward over the next few months.
    • 03:34:56
      So what I'm referring back to are the things that we have put together as staff based on feedback from the board and from the stakeholders across the Commonwealth moving forward.
    • 03:35:05
      And so based on what we've heard in our previous discussions with the board, the recommendation was to
    • 03:35:12
      limit the number of projects that could be submitted by the board to try and build and gain trust with the local communities who are now getting ready to go through a competitive process understanding that the board's VTrans long range plan still serves as kind of the screening process and so that only projects that this board thinks serve some value would actually move through and end up being evaluated.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:35:34
      Let me ask a question on a real world example and then maybe that will satisfy.
    • 03:35:39
      I believe that we need to fix the S-curves at Arcadia on 81.
    • 03:35:45
      I believe that's a place that we've had numerous wrecks, people killed.
    • 03:35:50
      I think it's not safe.
    • 03:35:52
      I don't know what it's going to score, but I feel like that's something we ought to do.
    • 03:35:57
      I have been able to get the preliminary engineering number on the six-year plan.
    • 03:36:02
      Under this scenario, I've got to go to what, the town of Buchanan or Botetourt County and see if they agree with that before we can address that?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:36:13
      The way the process would work as it's proposed by staff is that you would need to go to the Roanoke Valley Allegheny Regional Commission and ask them to submit that project as a candidate project for evaluation under the high priority projects or under the district grant program.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:36:29
      Okay, just want to make sure everybody understands that.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:36:32
      I'm going to the real world example Phil's looking for.
    • 03:36:36
      At NVTA, we did submit three projects.
    • 03:36:41
      They had to be scored.
    • 03:36:43
      Right.
    • 03:36:43
      So, you know, that's the ultimate equalizer.
    • 03:36:46
      They had to be scored.
    • 03:36:48
      However, two of them made it into the top eight of the scoring of the 40 or 50 projects.
    • 03:36:55
      But yet they weren't considered by the MPO to be as significant as their score ended up reflecting them.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:37:04
      So that's kind of a little bit of the dilemma we run into that that opts me to say we should have some flexibility on a limited basis to support some statewide projects.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:37:19
      Well, in your case, you're right.
    • 03:37:22
      You've got the energy to support it.
    • 03:37:25
      I mean, that's, you know, so I guess I don't see if it's such a good idea.
    • 03:37:31
      All we're talking about is getting it scored.
    • 03:37:35
      Well, Mr. Chairman, we came to submit it.
    • 03:37:36
      There's no skin off over not to submit it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:37:38
      And we're hashing this out, and this is good.
    • 03:37:40
      This is what we're supposed to be doing.
    • 03:37:43
      There's a reason we're not politicians sitting on this.
    • 03:37:46
      Okay, what you're asking is to say before you, and there's a lot of areas in the state that aren't in an NPO and aren't in a PDC.
    • 03:37:54
      Well I guess they're all in a PDC.
    • 03:37:56
      So what you're saying is we've got to go to a PDC which is appointed by the local governments to get them to approve a road that we think is statewide significant but they may not want in their backyard.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:38:09
      I think that's exactly right.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:38:11
      And I don't think that's a good transportation plan.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:38:13
      There are a lot of examples like that, Phil.
    • 03:38:16
      And certainly if it's safety issues, an example you have, that should be safe.
    • 03:38:25
      But on the other hand, you know, we're not transportation players either.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:38:28
      We've got a whole bunch of them around here.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:38:32
      I think to follow up with that, not to beat it up for us, I think the difficulty with this is you take it, William, if you're thinking versus Roanoke Valley MPO, you know, you've got folks who are urban, you've got folks who are representing rural areas, so if you've got a project that is specific to say Arcadia, which is specific to one locality that is considered more urban, or I'm sorry, more rural,
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:38:55
      B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr.,
    • 03:39:15
      and then rural areas outside of that, why are they going to vote for that money for buses?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:39:19
      I mean this to me is very similar and I feel like this is where the real world problems, the practical problems are going to happen when the rubber meets the road.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:39:29
      Well we've tried to make the point too that HB2 is not supposed to substitute for the local planning process or the regional planning process.
    • 03:39:37
      Anything eventually for it to get funded is going to have to be in the region's long range plan.
    • 03:39:43
      Even a project with a quarter of statewide significance is going to have to go through a planning process that's going to involve some level of local outreach, extensive public outreach, local approvals.
    • 03:39:56
      There may not always be 100% consensus from all the parties there, but by the time, hopefully, by the time something actually gets to the HB2 rating process, it's got some level of planning.
    • 03:40:08
      Consensus behind it. Now I know that won't always be the case, but I think that's what we've been trying to go to, especially as we've talked about issues like project readiness and when a project is eligible to be scored to. Mr. Chairman. Yes. I assume that VDOT comes with a recommendation.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:40:29
      You know, the roads and defecates, and they still have to be stored by House Bill 2.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:40:36
      VDOT will work with the localities.
    • 03:40:38
      That's the way they do it now.
    • 03:40:41
      They work with the localities.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:40:42
      Well, the first VDOT may recognize that a road may need to be built or expanded or so on, and then go sell it to the localities in some cases because you're never going to get 100% consensus.
    • 03:40:53
      And Mr. Chairman, I'm telling you, there's a difference between working with them and going to them and getting consensus.
    • 03:41:00
      We're saying you have to approve it and you can stop it.
    • 03:41:04
      It's different.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:41:05
      But we have that now.
    • 03:41:08
      Not, not sure.
    • 03:41:09
      We get sued all the time.
    • 03:41:10
      I mean, in other words, we find if we don't get consensus,
    • 03:41:14
      That's where I'm having a little bit of difficulty with is assuming we're going to build something we don't have local input and local consensus.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:41:27
      Say you get a PDC that votes 7 to 11 against a project that the rest of the state thinks is really significant.
    • 03:41:37
      But they're not going to submit it because they go to 11-7 against them.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:41:40
      But if it's a statewide snippet, maybe the other PDC or the other place it runs to, they've got it submitted.
    • 03:41:47
      I mean, the example they're going to have employers stop 95 doesn't work because it can be submitted from the other jurisdictions on 95.
    • 03:41:56
      It's not a vote.
    • 03:41:58
      You're only talking about getting it scored.
    • 03:41:59
      It's not a vote of whether or not you stop the project.
    • 03:42:03
      All we're talking about is getting it into the plan to be scored is all I'm saying.
    • 03:42:09
      The politics of it though could be you could have a road in a particular MPO that you know is going to score high, but the political dynamic of that MPO won't allow it to be scored.
    • 03:42:24
      Then what do you do? Then you're stuck. Well, if you don't have political support, I don't know how you build a road. But yet the numbers would say it should be built. That's assuming that's logic and all. We've got many things out here.
    • 03:42:44
      I won't mention a couple of them we're dealing with right now that would say logic would be we would have done maybe something different but we're not there I mean so I guess that's where I'm at we don't have local support to even get something scored how are we ever going to get it built
    • 03:43:02
      I mean, I think that's too practical in that regard, but I mean, that's, you know, fun.
    • 03:43:11
      This is just a, I think it's a good discussion.
    • 03:43:13
      This is a draft, and here's part of it, and this is unfair to many of you.
    • 03:43:20
      We've been bannering this back and forth internally, and you're just having these discussions, and so part of it is, we shouldn't comment at all, because you need to work through, on the other hand,
    • 03:43:30
      I think the discussion is helpful for staff.
    • 03:43:32
      Yeah, for staff in that regard, but it is.
    • 03:43:39
      I mean, there are very little clear-cut and I had to get over the fact to think that logic, I don't mean that to be flippant, but we don't have public support.
    • 03:43:53
      We typically cannot get the roads done.
    • 03:43:57
      And whether we think they're right or not, and I'm having difficulty on a one-up statewide against multiple jurisdictions.
    • 03:44:05
      If every jurisdiction didn't think it was any good, that would be unusual.
    • 03:44:10
      But as long as one-up thought we got, then it would make the scoring process.
    • 03:44:15
      But I'm sure we haven't thought through every one.
    • 03:44:17
      Mr. Merritt.
    • 03:44:19
      Yes.
    • 03:44:20
      Mr. Martin.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:44:21
      Now, wasn't part of the purpose of HB2 to take politics out of this?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:44:26
      Well, it is, and I can see it both ways.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:44:29
      I mean, what Mr. Fralin said, you know, sometimes... And Mr. Fralin's comments are introducing the political potential in the product.
    • 03:44:38
      You know, he's a professional politician.
    • 03:44:40
      He knows what... No!
    • 03:44:42
      What I was, sir, was a part-time public servant.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:44:46
      So I think this has been a very helpful discussion.
    • 03:44:52
      I think the way we as staff saw this working is the instance that was referenced by Mr. Fralin and Mr. Garczynski, again, it's not likely to happen on the bulk of these projects.
    • 03:45:01
      So it would be an exceptional outcome.
    • 03:45:04
      And if the board agreed that those projects where there was the rare instance of the MPO or the PDC for some political issue breaking down, that the CTB would have the discretion
    • 03:45:16
      to submit one to two projects in a given cycle if a majority of the board members agreed that that project was pressing enough to kind of circumvent the local and regional planning process.
    • 03:45:28
      But as a general rule, we would work with the regional and local planning processes to develop these on a ground up so they work with the local economic development and land use plans in a given region.
    • 03:45:39
      That was kind of where we were coming from.
    • 03:45:41
      So we thought some of the issues that are currently being raised were addressed
    • 03:45:46
      within that framework, which is not to say they are to the board's desire, but that was where we were coming from, is we did not see that being something that would happen on a regular basis where a project and a quarter statewide significance would be so controversial that would have run into such regional opposition that you couldn't get the regional planning body to submit that.
    • 03:46:07
      And so we thought that exception.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:46:08
      Chairman, we do need to move on.
    • 03:46:09
      I get it.
    • 03:46:09
      I think one thing to consider, Nick, from the staff support, it's not just
    • 03:46:14
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz Jr., John K. Matney,
    • 03:46:34
      You may not be able to do that.
    • 03:46:35
      I think we need to think about that and escape that.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:46:40
      I think we should do the same thing.
    • 03:46:41
      I don't think it would be a rule, but I think there are times.
    • 03:46:44
      We're going to vote today on a high-rise bridge where at the end of the day, we have to be responsible for the state roads.
    • 03:46:55
      I couldn't agree more.
    • 03:46:59
      The only thing I was suggesting is that had we tried the under approach and then we stepped in, we'd probably have a credibility in terms of what we're doing.
    • 03:47:13
      But all good discussion.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:47:17
      I suspect we'll have a little bit more as we get through this.
    • 03:47:21
      So once an eligible entity submits a project, what would then happen is the staff are going to take these projects and they're going to look at the VTrans multimodal transportation plan, which is currently in the process of being developed for the needs assessment right now.
    • 03:47:36
      We're working with a lot of local communities, regional entities, as well as both VDOT and DRPT to develop that plan.
    • 03:47:43
      And by law, that plan needs to look at transportation needs on corridors of statewide significance.
    • 03:47:49
      regional networks which is kind of the travel within some of the metro areas again there's 14 of those in the Commonwealth and then also look at what are the improvements that are needed to support locally designated urban development areas and growth areas there and so we'll grab a project on the application the entity would have selected which type of need they thought they addressed and they'll have the long-range transportation plan to look at we'll go back through and confirm that it does address a need that was identified and
    • 03:48:17
      In that long-range plan, and if it does, it will move forward in the evaluation process, and if it doesn't, we'll go back to that applicant to work with them to submit maybe a revised or slightly different project in the next evaluation round for House Bill 2.
    • 03:48:33
      It is our intent, and we are working towards this, to have an application process that is as simple and straightforward as possible.
    • 03:48:41
      As we kind of have thought about how should this work,
    • 03:48:46
      The real rule has been make sure it's not as complicated as the USDOT TIGER grant program.
    • 03:48:53
      We submitted two successful TIGER grant applications last year in the Commonwealth, one for the Broad Street BRT project that the Board just heard about and the other for the Port's Norfolk International Terminal's Northgate project.
    • 03:49:05
      Both the Port and the DRPT had to hire consultants to draft those TIGER grant applications, which is to say it's been thousands of dollars.
    • 03:49:14
      We did get millions back, so it was a winning
    • 03:49:16
      We're not going to make the local governments, PDCs and MPOs in Virginia do something similar to that.
    • 03:49:23
      We didn't think that would be fair.
    • 03:49:25
      And so what we're proposing is an online application process that will have drop-down menus and maps and other things where local government staff can go in and very quickly fill in the information.
    • 03:49:38
      They may need to attach some documents as supporting material to back up some of the factor.
    • 03:49:43
      One of the other things that we have really put a lot of attention into is we're going to make sure that the VDOT and DRPT staff are available to help support our local and regional partners in developing this.
    • 03:50:07
      We are the transportation agencies.
    • 03:50:09
      We handle the bulk of these types of work and so we're going
    • 03:50:13
      We're going to try and create a process where essentially a local entity or regional entity can request support for VDOT or DRPT to help develop portions of their application where they may need help.
    • 03:50:23
      So a few key things that we're going to need from every single project to be able to evaluate it and then help the board consider which one should be funded in a given year is really the scope.
    • 03:50:33
      What are you doing?
    • 03:50:35
      Where does it start?
    • 03:50:36
      Where does it stop?
    • 03:50:36
      What is it?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:50:38
      Is this going to be incorporated into the dashboard?
    • 03:50:41
      Well, I'm just being serious.
    • 03:50:43
      What a great place to access it for people that are getting used to using it and find it highly effective.
    • 03:50:50
      You watch all the curves since we instituted it and everything goes up.
    • 03:50:54
      And since that thing came into play, I just wonder if there's a process you can do.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:50:58
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Williams, we do have a process and a graphic user interface tool that's similar to the dashboard that we're planning to use for this.
    • 03:51:06
      We've actually contracted with a group known as Decision Lens.
    • 03:51:10
      And more importantly, you all will have access to that and you'll be able to go in and look at the district profiles, the statewide projects, you can see how they compare against each other and within the weighting framework since there will be
    • 03:51:23
      Some visual tools that will be available in particular for the board but also to the general public to really see what a project is expected to do and be able to compare that against other projects.
    • 03:51:33
      I expect either in April when we show you those example scoring projects, so that's when we'll first show you how that tool could work.
    • 03:51:41
      I do want to say it's a pretty impressive tool.
    • 03:51:43
      It's currently used by the Army and several other private companies.
    • 03:51:47
      It's been used by large transportation agencies to undertake similar efforts to what we're doing here.
    • 03:51:53
      So in addition to scope, we'll be working with them on the schedule and understanding how ready a project is or maybe whether it needs some additional pre-development before it could be funded, which might influence whether you fund it with some of the early year money or out of year money.
    • 03:52:06
      And then most importantly, we'll be working with them on the cost.
    • 03:52:09
      What is it going to take to build this project so as we go through and determine that relative cost at the end, which will serve as the basis for the score, we have a number that is generally agreed upon as an accurate number and that nobody's kind of low balling
    • 03:52:23
      Before we move on, I think we're going to go into that, just back to this topic.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:52:28
      As Mr. Kilpatrick and I have been talking, really coming from the perception, we think we're going to have more projects to be scored that may not score very well.
    • 03:52:50
      In other words there's another side to the point too because people want money and there's going to be a whole lot of projects and we're thinking you know through that and there's a discussion that he had on you know do we actually let them be scored or I mean the whole screening process so it's an interesting you know point that you raised about the ones across because we've been more or less thinking it's going to be the other way
    • 03:53:16
      B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr., John W. B. Smith Jr.,
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:36
      I think the Secretary and I have spoken.
    • 03:53:45
      There will be a lot of folks that want to apply to try and get their projects.
    • 03:53:51
      The Six-Year Plan, I believe, will actually shrink in terms of the number of projects in the Six-Year Plan.
    • 03:53:58
      And the reason for that is
    • 03:54:00
      Once a project is in the Six-Year Plan, it is on the path to construction and open to traffic.
    • 03:54:09
      We have over, long before I started VDOT in the 90s, we've had projects that have been in the Six-Year Plan on and off for an extended period of dozens of years.
    • 03:54:22
      And so I think what you're going to see is through this screening process, what we're going to say is that project is worth building and VDOT and DRPT program the money now
    • 03:54:33
      to program it out and deliver that project.
    • 03:54:37
      So the number of projects I believe in the Six-Year Plan will shrink somewhat.
    • 03:54:42
      I've used the term thinking about your project.
    • 03:54:44
      We won't have that $100 million project where we drop a million dollars on it for planning knowing that we're not, it's going to be very difficult for us ever to get the $99 million to finish it.
    • 03:54:57
      So I don't think you're going to see those kinds of projects.
    • 03:55:00
      This really to me becomes a
    • 03:55:02
      A much stronger delivery program of our capital improvements.
    • 03:55:08
      Products in the Six-Year Plan, we're going to fund it as rapidly as we can to get it done within all of the levers that we're pulling to fund that money.
    • 03:55:18
      But it's not going to be sprinkled over dozens of years.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:55:23
      Make sure we don't get a federal earmark in there.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:55:26
      You may mention of our April meeting when we look at the definitive process.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:55:50
      Would it be helpful, it seems to me that sometimes a picture is worth a thousand words,
    • 03:55:55
      If we would take two or three programs that we have already done, completed, and put it through the process and let us see how those would have scored out and the information that would have been before us, it may be helpful in seeing how this would be useful in the future.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:56:19
      And Mr.
    • 03:56:20
      Chair and Mr. Whitworth, what we're planning to do is, I think,
    • 03:56:23
      almost that and I think we'll tweak it to make sure it is in fact that.
    • 03:56:26
      But what we're going to do is we're going to take 40 projects that are either under construction or open already, real projects in Virginia and we're going to score them.
    • 03:56:35
      So then we're going to try and present as much of that information to you all in April and try and understand what is helpful, what is not helpful as we present that also to make sure are these measures we have working the way we thought they were going to work.
    • 03:56:47
      So we are going to be trying to do some of that in April and maybe I'll touch base with you offline to see if some of the stuff we're bringing goes in line with what you were talking about there.
    • 03:56:57
      That's what we're hoping to do in April is to do, I think, what you were talking about.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:57:01
      Well, a completed project would help you to judge whether or not, in fact, it was successful.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:57:08
      It did do the things that we wanted it to, thought we were going to do for it.
    • 03:57:12
      Lots of assuming we would have built a beginning.
    • 03:57:16
      Yeah, in other words, we might find we've got a lot of things we've built and scored very well.
    • 03:57:23
      But we still get to the same place.
    • 03:57:25
      That's right.
    • 03:57:28
      We might not like what we see.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:31
      You can't pull the money off now, right?
    • 03:57:32
      That's right.
    • 03:57:33
      No, no, no.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:57:33
      We're not doing that.
    • 03:57:34
      But I mean, yeah.
    • 03:57:36
      Yeah.
    • 03:57:37
      There is some, we thought about this, there is some downside for discussions that aren't done and they come back and they go, well, why are you, you know,
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:57:45
      That's what I'm saying, use ones that are complete.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:57:50
      Absolutely right.
    • 03:57:51
      And that is, we were not, any project we bring to the board that will be evaluated will be either open to construction or very, is it complete construction or is well on its way to being there.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:58:03
      Make it an older board.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:58:08
      And so once a project moves through this kind of pre, this process here,
    • 03:58:13
      We're going to then evaluate based on the measures we talked about the last board meeting.
    • 03:58:17
      What I want to try and do right now is really tell the board some of the feedback we heard on the measures as we went across the state.
    • 03:58:23
      And so remember, under safety, we have two proposed measures.
    • 03:58:27
      One is the number of fatalities and severe injuries on that facility or the reduction, excuse me, on that facility on a raw number basis.
    • 03:58:34
      And the second measure is the reduction in the rate of injuries or severe injuries and fatalities on that facility.
    • 03:58:41
      Some of the feedback we heard from the local partners as we talked through this process was there was a lot of folks who said, why are you limiting it just to severe injuries and fatalities?
    • 03:58:52
      And where we are coming from at the staff level is those are the types of crashes that really create economic issues for the Commonwealth and have the most severe impact on our motorists and taxpayers as well as our visitors.
    • 03:59:05
      It also falls more in line with some of the federal requirements.
    • 03:59:09
      that are coming online for the Highway Safety Improvement Program where we're going to be required, regardless of what we do in this process, to track the number of severe injuries and fatalities as well as the rate across the Commonwealth as a part of the federal MAPS 21 performance management rules.
    • 03:59:25
      But we did hear this in several of the different districts about really should you expand this to look at kind of all crashes.
    • 03:59:33
      I think part of that was also based on
    • 03:59:36
      The things in a lot of districts where they see fender benders that are creating unreliable traffic conditions.
    • 03:59:43
      So I think one of the things is, and we give this in the congestion thing, is whether or not the issue there has to do with safety or trying to find a way to capture reliability issues on some of the roadways.
    • 03:59:55
      One of the other things we heard was concern that the transit projects wouldn't, we weren't actually capturing the safety benefit of transit projects.
    • 04:00:03
      In some of the districts, they said transit is the safest mode of transportation.
    • 04:00:08
      It has a significantly lower fatality and severe injury rate compared to the other modes.
    • 04:00:13
      And they weren't sure of the way we were intending to capture that, really took that into account.
    • 04:00:19
      And just to remind members of the board, the way we're proposing you would do that is you would look at the amount of people that switch from driving or riding with someone else in that roadway in a car to the bus or rail system.
    • 04:00:32
      And then we reduced the amount of driving on that roadway by that to come up with a number of fatalities that are not happening because there's less driving on that roadway.
    • 04:00:41
      And so there was some concern about that.
    • 04:00:43
      And then the last one is people were generally familiar with the concept that we had crash modification factors, but they don't know what they are.
    • 04:00:53
      And they said, if you're going to really use these and these are going to start determining whether or not we get money, please publish a list of these.
    • 04:00:59
      online so we know that a roundabout reduces severe injuries and fatalities by 80%.
    • 04:01:05
      Don't make me send in a left-hand turn lane when I could have done a roundabout and gotten the money.
    • 04:01:10
      And so they really wanted to really understand what those were and what types of solutions helped reduce the number of severe injuries and fatalities.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:01:20
      On the congestion factor, there was a, remember we have two measures... Do you want to ask questions per factor or do you want to wait for the... On the safety measure, Nick, it's the number of annual crashes, which is obviously going to be weighted for a road that's used more, because it's a raw number.
    • 04:01:43
      The more cars on a road, the more likely there is to be a crash.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:01:47
      There will be a greater number generally, not always, but yes.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:01:51
      But this isn't a weighted number, it's just the raw number of annual crashes on this road.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:01:55
      Well, so there's two factors, Mr. Fralin.
    • 04:01:57
      One is just the raw number, the other is the weighted, or the rate factor, which would take into account the number of severe injuries and fatalities compared to the amount of driving on that roadway.
    • 04:02:07
      So, I-95, for example, there's a hundred fatalities and severe injuries, but there's a million people driving on that, that would have a rate of
    • 04:02:16
      I'm doing my math right.
    • 04:02:18
      If I'm not, don't tell me.
    • 04:02:19
      And then on another road, say 220, where there's maybe 10 crashes, but there's only 100 people driving.
    • 04:02:28
      That's the same rate, even though that number's much lower.
    • 04:02:31
      So that's what I mean.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:02:32
      On the second factor, it's injuries per 100 million vehicle miles traveled.
    • 04:02:39
      And I just don't have any idea what that means.
    • 04:02:41
      I mean, you use 220.
    • 04:02:43
      Are there 100
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:02:45
      So, Mr. Chairman, 100 million vehicle miles traveled is a national standard, and so on roadways where they don't have that, we would adjust the rate upwards.
    • 04:02:58
      So say there's only 50 million VMT, we would multiply that rate times two to get it up to a kind of equalized rate so we compare it across facilities.
    • 04:03:11
      So in the congestion factor, we have two measures.
    • 04:03:16
      Again, one is the reduction in person hours of delay along the corridor compared to the facility at a level of service E. We picked level of service E again to focus on the severe congestion, really the stop and go.
    • 04:03:28
      One of the things we were hoping to not take into account, there are lots of instances where a project may improve a facility from a level of service say C to B.
    • 04:03:39
      But the actual change for someone driving on that roadway may be five seconds.
    • 04:03:44
      And so if you multiply that, say, on a roadway with 100,000 people, we can get upwards of 26,000 hours of delay reduced.
    • 04:03:51
      And people think that something's really going to change on that roadway, but it's just five seconds.
    • 04:03:56
      And so we really wanted to make sure when we capture changes in delay, we're really capturing in areas where the congestion is at a level where it's creating an inconvenience and it's real hindrance.
    • 04:04:05
      to the daily kind of user and the freight and other goods moving on that roadway.
    • 04:04:10
      The second measure was the increase in the person throughput along that corridor and that was just with the improvements we're proposing how many more people do we expect to move through kind of a given corridor recognizing that that's one of the key things we need to enhance on a lot of the corridors in the Commonwealth.
    • 04:04:28
      So some of the main feedback we heard from folks is
    • 04:04:31
      In certain parts of the state they were concerned that a focus on level of service E may exclude some of their areas.
    • 04:04:38
      And they said, hey, we're not sure we have a lot of roadways that have level of service E. And I think they're correct in the areas where that was raised.
    • 04:04:46
      I also think that it's likely the congestion factor would be weighted pretty low in some of those areas where they don't have a lot of level of service E roadways.
    • 04:04:56
      And so remember last time when I presented to the board
    • 04:04:59
      I think there will be very few projects that score very high in all five or six of these factory areas.
    • 04:05:05
      I think most projects are going to do well in one or two areas and we try to, as we are developing these different measures, make them work for the areas where we thought they would be weighted highest.
    • 04:05:15
      So, you know, for example, I'm not sure the economic development measure that we put in place is the one that Northern Virginia developed their own economic development measure that they would select
    • 04:05:25
      But we developed it based on the areas that we thought would end up using economic development, taking into account the types of issues that we often heard raised by them as we did our outreach meetings earlier in 2014.
    • 04:05:35
      And so again, the congestion metric here, we did tailor this more to some of the larger urban areas where we did expect it to be weighted higher, particularly in the person hours and delay concept.
    • 04:05:47
      I think all areas can compete equally under the person throughput measure.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:05:52
      Well, Mr. Chairman, I want to ask a question about that because this is a philosophical point because you're right, in category C or D, even if it's just 10%, if they don't have any service level E's, the likely score there is going to be zero.
    • 04:06:09
      So the max they're going to be trying to get is, they can't get any points for that.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:06:15
      Well, remember, that's half the congestion factor, so they can still get five points.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:06:22
      So they can only get five percent.
    • 04:06:24
      But they're reduced by that.
    • 04:06:26
      By the same token, help me if I'm wrong, on the
    • 04:06:30
      Economic Development Factor or Environmental Quality Factors, I don't see where any of these other categories are going to be zero. For example, I think that there's going to be some economic development activity that you would be able to contribute to almost any. I'm a little concerned about that. We're just talking among friends here. I'm concerned about that. that.
    • 04:06:53
      The other piece that I'm worried about in the congestion is it's the peak hour, which to me matters to commuters.
    • 04:07:04
      And I think what this ought to be titled is commuter congestion mitigation because the other thing that we're not measuring here is throughput of goods.
    • 04:07:15
      There's transportation of goods through a corridor.
    • 04:07:20
      And this comes to the 81 question, right?
    • 04:07:24
      Yes, we may not be moving as many people down 81 as they're moving down 95 or up 95, but I promise you we're moving more freight.
    • 04:07:35
      And those are bigger, they take more room, they damage the roads more, all those factors come into play and I'm really concerned about this congestion piece only talking about people.
    • 04:07:50
      And we've had this discussion and I guess now is as good a time as any.
    • 04:07:56
      For those of us that have 81, I'm really worried how 81 is going to score on this.
    • 04:08:00
      I think that I need you all to put your thinking caps on and help me understand because that is an extremely important economic engine for the western half of the state and for the eastern half of the United States.
    • 04:08:16
      And we've got to make sure we're paying attention to it.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:08:21
      And I'd actually like to just jump to the last bullet under congestion because I think that gets at the issue Mr. Fralin was just raising.
    • 04:08:26
      And that's really the lack of the reliability of travel on a lot of our key corridors was something we actually heard in all parts of the state.
    • 04:08:36
      Why aren't you measuring this?
    • 04:08:38
      At staff level, it's actually something we do want to measure.
    • 04:08:42
      We tried earlier and we were unable to come up with some metrics.
    • 04:08:46
      I think
    • 04:08:47
      I'm hearing pretty clearly from Mr. Fralin you want us to go back and try again, and we will do that.
    • 04:08:52
      We do think reliability is an important metric, and I think it could apply statewide.
    • 04:08:57
      And I think we need to talk about which factor area of reliability metrics should go in.
    • 04:09:02
      I'm not sure if congestion is the right one.
    • 04:09:04
      Economic development might actually be a better one for that, but that's a discussion if we figure out how to incorporate that.
    • 04:09:11
      But staff does have a very, very strong desire
    • 04:09:14
      to be able to capture reliability because I do think that's one of, particularly in the areas, in all areas of the state, but also in areas where they don't have congestion, that's a big issue both for goods movement and for passenger travel.
    • 04:09:27
      The tough part, just so that the board understands where we're coming from at the staff level, is we can figure out where a lack of reliability exists today or where there's unreliable travel.
    • 04:09:37
      What we need to spend some time looking at is how do we determine the degree to which a project
    • 04:09:44
      will make roads more reliable.
    • 04:09:47
      Often the things that improve reliability the most are operational types of improvements like having the Safety Service Patrol come pick up and tow drivers out of the way so they're not blocking two feet of Atlanta traffic so people keep swerving over and everyone's jamming on their brakes.
    • 04:10:02
      There are capital improvements as well that can help with reliability and so we are going to go back, take a look at that, see if there's some analysis and correlation we can come up with to look at that issue
    • 04:10:14
      But that's the issue we're struggling with is how do we say what a project or given improvement does for reliability?
    • 04:10:23
      Because there aren't a lot of metrics and really any that we found so far that tell you how capital improvement will change that aspect.
    • 04:10:31
      But I think we will go back and look at it as something we wanted to have initially.
    • 04:10:35
      We just struggled the first time around.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:10:40
      Nick, on consistent definition of project corridor, Mr. Weiner, I'm assuming that we are presenting that to the applicants and telling them these are the criteria for identifying the corridor.
    • 04:10:53
      It seems to be a potentially highly controversial issue.
    • 04:10:55
      How are we moving towards resolution?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:10:57
      So Mr.
    • 04:10:58
      Chair and Mr. Kaskowitz, we are still working on a definition towards that and what the concern was again is that
    • 04:11:06
      We had initially proposed that the project applicant would kind of tell us this is what they saw as the corridor.
    • 04:11:11
      There were some folks, particularly in the Northern Virginia region, who were nervous about how some of their peers, and I think even their peers in Northern Virginia, might define the corridor.
    • 04:11:21
      So, you know, if you're doing an improvement on Route 7 and you reach all the way down and grab Route 866, all of a sudden your numbers can really go through the roof with regard to the benefits you might be providing.
    • 04:11:31
      And so we at the staff are going to come up with some explicit guidance
    • 04:11:36
      It's not in the current policy guide that you have but some guidance that will be hopefully clear to all the applicants as to what can be in that project corridor and what cannot be so this is applied in a kind of uniform way across the state because we did hear a fair amount of concern about this at the Northern Virginia meeting and it was raised in other meetings so the bulk of the consternation came from the Northern Virginia District meeting.
    • 04:12:02
      On the accessibility factor, again, we have three measures under this.
    • 04:12:06
      One is the cumulative increase in the number of jobs within 45 minutes due to the project and any land use changes it may have.
    • 04:12:13
      The other was the cumulative increase in access to essential destinations within 30 minutes.
    • 04:12:20
      And the final one was the increase in access to multimodal options.
    • 04:12:24
      A few things we heard as we went across the state was whether or not 45 minutes was the right threshold.
    • 04:12:30
      for the access to the number of jobs.
    • 04:12:32
      When we were in Fredericksburg, they thought that probably was an insufficient amount of time.
    • 04:12:37
      The Fredericksburg region has typically the longest commute time, so that wasn't a surprise that we heard that issue there.
    • 04:12:43
      And then in some of the rural areas of the state, they said, well, we can basically reach anywhere around here in 45 minutes, so we're not sure what more is going to pop up.
    • 04:12:52
      I think in both those instances, the tool that we're developing is not limited by
    • 04:12:57
      some type of geographic boundary so it doesn't start stop counting jobs that may not be in say the city of Roanoke County or Roanoke City it will look out
    • 04:13:05
      into Botetourt, into Amherst and into those other counties to capture those additional jobs someone might be able to access because of the improvement in travel speeds or changing land use from a project.
    • 04:13:16
      Similarly with the Fredericksburg region, they were really concerned about capturing DC.
    • 04:13:22
      I think that's the wrong focus.
    • 04:13:24
      What we need to look at is how many more job opportunities can someone reach.
    • 04:13:28
      And this tool, again, will look beyond the Fredericksburg region.
    • 04:13:31
      into Fredericksburg, the Pentagon, and other areas and understand whether or not more people can reach those job areas even if a lot of people today go to DC.
    • 04:13:39
      It's a little bit what the opportunity is and how that's enhanced.
    • 04:13:44
      Another concern that we heard was what's an essential destination?
    • 04:13:49
      And we had some of that discussion at the board meeting last time when we talked about these measures.
    • 04:13:54
      Some folks, you know, want that tourism particularly in the Hampton Roads region.
    • 04:13:58
      They said, hey, you know, are we looking at
    • 04:14:00
      You know, destinations for tourists and other things of that nature.
    • 04:14:03
      In some other parts of the state, Northern Virginia, they said, shouldn't we look at activity centers there and some of their locally designated kind of destinations, which is slightly different from the concept that we ran into.
    • 04:14:15
      And then in some other parts of the state, they said, I'm not sure this is important.
    • 04:14:20
      Should the state actually be looking at this and should we be making investments to kind of change the access to essential destinations?
    • 04:14:28
      And then the last concern we heard was with the increase in access to multimodal options where in some of the rural communities they've expressed concern that while they may have access to some biking and sidewalk and in certain cases rail options, they didn't really have the extensive bus service or rail transit that some of the more urban areas have.
    • 04:14:52
      On the environmental quality factor, again we have three measures under this one.
    • 04:14:57
      The first measure is the likelihood of the project to improve air quality or reduce greenhouse gas emissions, which is weighted at 50%.
    • 04:15:05
      And then we have the disadvantaged population accessibility, access to jobs and access to essential destinations, with the jobs portion being weighed 40% and the essential destinations being weighed 10%.
    • 04:15:16
      One of the things we heard is they were kind of wanting to know why we weren't looking at things like wetlands impacts.
    • 04:15:26
      Why we weren't looking at storm water quality and things of that nature.
    • 04:15:29
      And the intent was that we didn't want to try and give points for things that would be captured through the permitting process.
    • 04:15:38
      It's because at that point are we just giving every project a certain slug of points because you can't get a permit if you have substantial environmental impacts that can't be mitigated.
    • 04:15:48
      I think some folks thought that that was too narrow of a view.
    • 04:15:52
      and that there are some projects that do actually improve, for example, water quality where you might add a component to a project to reduce the storm water runoff or other things and so they ask that we go back and revisit that.
    • 04:16:06
      Another thing that we heard is with the non-auto access for disadvantaged populations, we heard from several different districts that they felt that in their part of the state,
    • 04:16:20
      disabled, the low-income and the elderly often got rides from other people or had, you know, friends come pick them up and so they weren't sure if that measure should be limited just to the non-auto modes.
    • 04:16:32
      And so I think we're going to go back and take some, you know, look at that to see if there's research nationally that gets to that issue.
    • 04:16:39
      And then again, people just wanted to make sure we had a very clear definition of what a disadvantaged population was.
    • 04:16:45
      Currently we're proposing to rely on the Title VI
    • 04:16:48
      definition which again is in the federal code and is something that we're required to do through the NEPA process.
    • 04:16:54
      I think that's something we'll continue to work on over the next two months to determine whether or not that's the appropriate definition to use as we move forward.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 04:17:04
      Nick, I just have a quick question on the accessibility, the measuring of access to jobs.
    • 04:17:13
      When is it beneficial to look at not just the number of jobs but the percentage as well on the application?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:17:24
      I think we can definitely take a look at it.
    • 04:17:26
      The reason we did the number is because at the end we're dividing all the projects by the cost.
    • 04:17:32
      And if we do percent, there could be one project that, say, costs $500 million and increases the cumulative jobs that can be reached.
    • 04:17:39
      The increase in that could be, say, 100,000 jobs, which might be 10% increase.
    • 04:17:46
      And then you could have a $10 million project that increases access to 1,000 additional jobs, which is also a 10% increase.
    • 04:17:55
      And when you divide that by the cost at the end, we felt that that might disadvantage some of the larger projects.
    • 04:18:02
      So it was more to try and keep a fair benefit-cost score is why we thought we needed to use the aggregate number rather than the percentages.
    • 04:18:10
      Because when we did some analysis ourselves, we found that using percentages, the smaller projects tended to get an unfair advantage in our opinion.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:18:21
      Derek.
    • 04:18:23
      Yeah, I'm working.
    • 04:18:23
      Nick, is there a component of all this
    • 04:18:27
      Mr. Williams, I think all regions have unique
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:18:55
      And things that impact their ability to deliver a project.
    • 04:18:58
      So in Northern Virginia, the maintenance of traffic and the right-of-way are different than they are in certain parts of the state.
    • 04:19:03
      I also, when we get to the project cost, staff are recommending that we use the HB2 eligible cost, which might be a mitigating factor for different parts of the state.
    • 04:19:13
      But I don't want to get too much into that particular aspect yet, but I think no is the short answer to your question.
    • 04:19:19
      We're not giving any special treatment to any part of the state.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:19:23
      I wasn't asking about special triggers.
    • 04:19:26
      I was asking about punitive measures that could impact an area like Camden Roads because of the cost of construction is just so much higher because of the geography.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:19:35
      Well, and we hear the same thing in Mr. Matney's part of the state where they say the mountains.
    • 04:19:39
      I think everyone, Mr. Williams, has indicated they have some special thing that increases the cost in a given area.
    • 04:19:47
      In Northern Virginia, it's the right-of-way.
    • 04:19:48
      In Bristol, it's the mountains.
    • 04:19:49
      In Hampton Roads, it's the water.
    • 04:19:51
      So I think what we're doing is we're not in special treatment.
    • 04:19:56
      I wasn't trying to imply that we're going to inflate them.
    • 04:19:58
      I'm just saying everyone's treated the same way.
    • 04:20:00
      The cost is the cost is what we're proposing.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:20:05
      I might have to work on that.
    • 04:20:06
      Thank you, Gary.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:20:07
      Go ahead.
    • 04:20:09
      All right.
    • 04:20:10
      So on the economic development factor, just a reminder to the board, there are two members, measures, excuse me, that we're proposing to use there.
    • 04:20:19
      The degree to which the project can help support a local economic development strategy and the second is the kind of freight and intermodal efficiency measure.
    • 04:20:28
      The first one is weighted 70% and the second is weighted 30%.
    • 04:20:31
      We had a lot of discussion about this measure as you might imagine particularly in like the Lynchburg, Stanton, Roanoke and Bristol districts.
    • 04:20:42
      One of the things we heard again and again is
    • 04:20:45
      Please don't use the DHCD Enterprise Zone designation.
    • 04:20:49
      And one of the reasons for that is there were some localities who said, I've applied for this three times and I get turned down every single time by DHCD.
    • 04:21:00
      And they felt that that would be unfair where they were taking steps to really apply.
    • 04:21:04
      But for reasons they weren't quite sure of, DHCD would never approve their Enterprise Zone applications.
    • 04:21:11
      Another concern we had is we were proposing that you would get points if a project was in line with a locally adopted comprehensive economic development strategy, which is something that needs to be approved by the Economic Development Administration at the federal level.
    • 04:21:25
      We recommended that measure because it puts some parameters around what is a local economic development strategy.
    • 04:21:31
      It has some parameters again about you must go through these steps to prove that there's some amount of analysis backing that strategy up.
    • 04:21:40
      Some PDCs said, well, we don't have this yet.
    • 04:21:43
      We might be able to have it in the future.
    • 04:21:46
      If we have some reasonably adopted strategy that maybe hasn't been approved by the EDA, can that count at least for these first few rounds of HB2 evaluation so we're not negatively impacted because we didn't know we needed to do this in advance?
    • 04:22:02
      There was some concern about the chicken versus the egg and how we were proposing to give points.
    • 04:22:07
      to projects under this measure.
    • 04:22:09
      So again, remember, you get points if they're consistent with the economic development strategy.
    • 04:22:14
      You get points if plans have been submitted.
    • 04:22:17
      You get points if utilities are in place.
    • 04:22:19
      A lot of folks said, well, we can't get the plan submitted until someone knows we're going to have the transportation facility.
    • 04:22:27
      On the flip side, we were trying to make sure we didn't end up funding a lot of projects where it says, build the road and they will come.
    • 04:22:33
      And we end up with a lot of roads where no one came.
    • 04:22:35
      And so I think as staff we're going to go back and look at that.
    • 04:22:39
      I'm not sure there's an easy way to address that issue, but it is a concern we heard in a few of the districts.
    • 04:22:46
      And then finally, when I presented last to the board, I told you we were struggling as to what should be the scaling factor or how do we determine the magnitude of the development.
    • 04:22:57
      We asked everyone in all nine districts and we got no consensus.
    • 04:23:01
      So we're still kind of where we were before, but we're going to keep working on that.
    • 04:23:06
      People threw out jobs, wages, property taxes, square footage.
    • 04:23:10
      We heard everything.
    • 04:23:12
      And so, unfortunately, there was nothing that really rang out more as a suggestion for understanding the magnitude of development than others.
    • 04:23:21
      And so we're just going to have to keep looking at that issue and keep coming back to the board with any additional progress we've made on that.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 04:23:29
      Mr. Whitworth.
    • 04:23:32
      What there was consensus I take it then that the proposed DH3D Enterprise Zone is not acceptable?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:23:40
      I think it's fair to say that there was a lot of concern about that in the district.
    • 04:23:44
      We didn't hear it in every district, but we heard it in the majority.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 04:23:49
      Yes, what came out of the meeting, the stakeholder meeting in Lynchburg as we were discussing this because in districts like mine it's such a critical factor is that to develop that so that the more comprehensive, the more things that a project could check off as being complete or in development, in process, all of those things
    • 04:24:15
      A. Whirley Sr., John K. Matney Jr., John K. Matney,
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:24:33
      I think we got a mix of feedback on that.
    • 04:24:36
      I think people like the kind of checklist concept that we're trying to put forward.
    • 04:24:41
      And I think some people like the idea that you had to demonstrate progress towards the development coming online.
    • 04:24:48
      To be in complete candor to the board, there were also a few areas, though less of them, where they said, hey, we're not sure we can get
    • 04:24:55
      To that place of being further down the line until you commit the money for the facility upgrade to us.
    • 04:25:02
      I think as staff we would recommend strongly to the board that you stick to that checklist where the further along you are the more like you are to get money.
    • 04:25:11
      We think we can also work with some of these local PDCs and others to help them understand how this process could work and we also have planning grants where we can try and help them advance maybe some of that work further along.
    • 04:25:23
      Well, we do want to stick in this economic development measure to projects where we know there's a strategy and where there are projects that are further along and you know what type of industry you're trying to get to or even if someone submitted plans that those projects would get more points.
    • 04:25:39
      Right, at least initially.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 04:25:43
      And one of the points that was brought up in the meeting that I thought was very good concerns square footage, that with expansion you may not have as much square footage, but sometimes with industry expansion you can actually create a greater economic impact.
    • 04:25:59
      And so that was one of the concerns about how we would actually include that on the checklist.
    • 04:26:04
      I just wanted to make that point because I thought it was made very well.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:26:09
      We have just gotten the word that the plane has to be in the air by 4 o'clock this afternoon or we do not policy to take our people home.
    • 04:26:21
      So I think we can do that.
    • 04:26:23
      That will give us about an hour and 15 minutes here left to do unless you gentlemen want to stay the evening.
    • 04:26:33
      I'm not riding the plane back.
    • 04:26:36
      That's some bad news.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:26:40
      I just have one more area I need to inquire into.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:26:43
      I guess what I'd like to do is we've probably got about a half an hour of the workshop.
    • 04:26:47
      I'd like to go to the session at 3 to 3.15.
    • 04:26:50
      I think we can get through it in a half hour to 45 minutes.
    • 04:26:54
      And the final factor is the transportation and land use coordination area.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:27:16
      And what we heard here, I think the most prevalent kind of comment was we're not required to use this, but should we?
    • 04:27:24
      And it was interest, but not necessarily a commitment.
    • 04:27:27
      So we heard that in Charlottesville.
    • 04:27:29
      We heard that in Winchester.
    • 04:27:30
      We heard it in Lynchburg and Danville.
    • 04:27:33
      Some folks were more inclined to say, let me use that.
    • 04:27:37
      Others kind of said, well, help me understand whether or not this may help me or may hurt me on my project score moving forward.
    • 04:27:44
      And so I think this just kind of goes along to why, in the previous weighting framework, we had the land use measure in two
    • 04:27:50
      of the categories so that areas even those that didn't want to be in with Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia and that category with congestion being weighted the highest would have the opportunity to use this factor.
    • 04:28:02
      So Mr. Chairman, once we run the projects through the different measures, we then need to take those kind of values and go through a quality assurance, quality control process and also turn that into a score that the board can then use to compare that against other projects and that's what I want to walk through now.
    • 04:28:20
      So the first thing we're going to do is we are going to have a technical evaluation team that's going to do the actual screening and evaluation.
    • 04:28:29
      And I want to say that we're still examining whether or not this should be several teams, whether this should be staff, whether this should be consultants, or whether this should be a mix of both staff and consultants.
    • 04:28:40
      I personally think there's a lot of value in having multiple teams and having a few projects scored by more than one team to make sure they're getting the same score when they come out the back end.
    • 04:28:49
      And then one of the things we heard from the peer panel that we put together last November is it's very helpful to kind of have an external review group made up of the stakeholders sending in projects who have a chance to review the process.
    • 04:29:05
      And so we're proposing that we put in place what we're calling the external peer group that would have local governments, MPOs, PDCs, and other stakeholders who get to take a look at what we've done and make sure that we're doing it in the way they thought we were going to do it.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 04:29:24
      I know the application process is intended to be simple without consultants being required, but granted there are public areas around the state that have more sophisticated modeling tools, maybe more staff.
    • 04:29:40
      How are we going to put it all on a level playing field so that the applications are evaluated equally for areas that may not have those types of resources or modeling works?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:29:54
      That's a very good question, Mr. Thompson.
    • 04:29:56
      The first thing we do is we're going to undertake the burden at the state level of doing all the modeling when it comes to scoring the project.
    • 04:30:03
      So no local government is going to have to undertake that burden unless for some reason they want to do it in advance to understand what the outcome might be.
    • 04:30:11
      The second thing we're doing is we are, Commissioner Kilpatrick and Director Mitchell are going to be making their staffs available.
    • 04:30:18
      to the local governments and all of the districts to really help them with the project application development upfront before they get submitted.
    • 04:30:29
      So there will be several months each year where their staff are really going to be reaching out to local governments to see if they can be of assistance to help with some of those matters.
    • 04:30:37
      And then finally, once we have a final process, we're going to put a lot of the information online.
    • 04:30:45
      Just like with a crash modification factor.
    • 04:30:46
      So you can go there and understand what it would do, what a given solution will do for severe injuries and fatalities on a roadway.
    • 04:30:55
      You will have kind of the accessibility tool to kind of understand where there's good and bad access to jobs and things of that nature.
    • 04:31:02
      So we're going to put a lot of that up there so folks can go tinker with it and play with it to try and understand where there are problem areas and where they might be able to really develop some high scoring projects.
    • 04:31:16
      So once we develop the measures, we then have to run them through each of the relevant or applicable weighting framework.
    • 04:31:25
      And just to remind the board, here are the proposed weighting frameworks.
    • 04:31:29
      We have not changed these since the last meeting.
    • 04:31:32
      We got a fair amount of feedback on them, and we're getting letters that feels like every other day from a PDC or an MPO on this.
    • 04:31:40
      And so we wanted to wait until we got all of that feedback before we adjusted that.
    • 04:31:44
      Some of the feedback that we heard when we went out to the districts is, again, the urban areas were concerned about whether or not it was fair for them to compete against the rural areas where economic development was weighted and safety were weighted highly because they thought congestion was a more costly thing to address.
    • 04:32:02
      And a lot of the rural areas were uncomfortable competing against Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads whose needs they saw was just so dramatic.
    • 04:32:11
      And I think that's just going to be an ongoing tension
    • 04:32:14
      throughout this process and I think as staff we're going to do our best to try and put forward what we think is an objective process that works for all parts of the state but I think at the end of the day this is always going to exist in this process and we just have to try and minimize the consternation to the degree possible.
    • 04:32:32
      As I mentioned earlier there are folks who wanted to really understand and I think wanted us to tell them whether or not they should use the land use factor and that's
    • 04:32:40
      That's a decision that they're going to need to make.
    • 04:32:42
      I think we can explain to them how it might work, and then they can go back and look at their policies and plans and try and determine whether or not they want to use that, but that's going to be their decision.
    • 04:32:52
      I think a lot of folks wanted to know, are these going to be the measures you use before you make me pick a weighting plan?
    • 04:32:59
      So they know we have these proposed set of measures, but I think in a way they wanted us to kind of lock those down before they had to say whether or not they wanted to be in category D or category B.
    • 04:33:09
      And then also, there were some folks who said, can we make some of these weighted really low?
    • 04:33:18
      So in Hampton Roads, they asked if they could get environmental quality to be, could that be 5%?
    • 04:33:23
      Does that really need to be 10%?
    • 04:33:26
      In the Richmond area, they said transportation and land use.
    • 04:33:31
      Can that just be 5%?
    • 04:33:32
      Does that really need to be 10?
    • 04:33:34
      We've tried to put forward a package where every factor area is at least 10% so that folks will consider it and think about it as they move forward, but that is something that we heard in a few places across the state.
    • 04:33:47
      What I want to walk through now is something that we haven't discussed with the Board in detail, but it's how do we go from a project reduces 900 hours of delay to a score?
    • 04:34:00
      And so staff are recommending that we have a kind of the ability before you divide by cost to get up to 100 points.
    • 04:34:07
      And I want to walk through how we're going to propose that's done for a given project.
    • 04:34:12
      And these are made up numbers.
    • 04:34:14
      These aren't real projects.
    • 04:34:15
      These are just inputs.
    • 04:34:16
      So let me say that before I get started here.
    • 04:34:19
      You're receiving 100 points.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:34:21
      Yes sir?
    • 04:34:22
      So the max score for the urban areas category A would be 35 points for congestion mitigation.
    • 04:34:31
      Correct.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:34:34
      And so what we're proposing is that within each measure area we normalize the scores based on the highest performing project in a given year.
    • 04:34:45
      And what we mean by that is in this example there's three projects that we're evaluating
    • 04:34:50
      for under the congestion mitigation.
    • 04:34:52
      Project 3 reduces the person hours of delay by 900 hours.
    • 04:34:58
      Project B reduces 500 hours of person delay and Project 1 reduces 10 hours of person hours of delay.
    • 04:35:06
      Because 900 is the most and is therefore the project that has the greatest benefit, it becomes kind of the top score and every other score is proportional in relationship to that score which does mean year to year
    • 04:35:20
      The same project might have a different score and I think that's okay because we actually have different projects to pick from every year and while you may be the fifth best project one year, you might actually be the best project the next year or vice versa just depending on what's been submitted.
    • 04:35:38
      So in this, Project 3 would have 100 and Project 1 would have 1.1 because 10 divided by 900 is 1.1.
    • 04:35:50
      We would then, to convert that into kind of the congestion score, you know, we have two measures.
    • 04:35:57
      We'd walk that through for person throughput as well, convert that, and we'd multiply them, you know, by 50% to get to kind of what is in the congestion factor is your score.
    • 04:36:07
      And within each measure, we're doing this to 100.
    • 04:36:09
      And so, again, because on the person throughput, Project 1 is an 8, and Project 3, you know, had 15,000, so they're 100.
    • 04:36:21
      You get those different scores, and so you divide 8 by, multiply 8 by 50%, and you get 4, and you take 1.1, and you multiply it by 50%, and you get, I'm going to screw up the math, but you get something that adds up to, you get 0.55.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:36:37
      Mr. Chairman, Nick, are you worried that if you take, it's good like a two-person score, 15,000 seems like a drop in the bucket, you know, I don't know.
    • 04:36:50
      Are you worried that you will have a bunch of projects in Northern Virginia or Hampton that score really high on congestion and that's the 100 mark and then you've got to go way down to the bottom before you start getting into any projects in any other district so their score is going to be 0.5 or 0.2 or I mean just really off the scale from
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:37:18
      So Mr. Fralin, I think we'll need to take a bigger look at that when we come back to you in April.
    • 04:37:27
      My gut response is no, I'm not worried.
    • 04:37:30
      And the reason I'm not worried is all of these are going to be divided by cost at the end of the day.
    • 04:37:35
      And that project, and I know we're going to get to that issue here in a little bit and you have some comments for me, but what I was just saying is the projects that increase the throughput by 15,000
    • 04:37:48
      hopefully would cost, or I assume would cost a lot more than the projects that only increase person throughput by 1200.
    • 04:37:55
      And so for example, in the NVTA-599 congestion rating process, when you looked at the raw score, I think the highest scoring project was the Fairfax County Parkway, and then the Glebe Road ITS project was number 17 out of 37.
    • 04:38:12
      When you divided by cost, the Glebe Road ITS project had the highest score by a factor of two.
    • 04:38:18
      And the Fairfax County Parkway project fell from number one to number nine.
    • 04:38:22
      And so don't worry about, if your benefits are lower than another project, worry about whether your benefits are high relative to your cost.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:38:34
      Which, Mr. Chairman, goes back to my discussion about how to level the playing field on cost.
    • 04:38:41
      I mean, yes, Mr. Matney's region is probably just as expensive as Anthony Rose, but other regions aren't as expensive.
    • 04:38:53
      I don't know, when you're competing for the statewide dollars, when you're internal in the grant program, it doesn't matter, because we're all measured skin.
    • 04:39:00
      But surely VDOT's developed enough mathematical history with consideration costs to know, to sort of somewhat come up with a factor that, hey, it costs this much more in the Bristol District than it costs in the Lynchburg District.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:39:16
      P. L. A. Mott, or Hampton Roads, versus...
    • 04:39:20
      Primarily the right-of-way acquisition is the real difference.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:39:24
      I understand that's the last thing we do is divide by money and we're competing statewide for some of the monies for the statewide significant projects.
    • 04:39:32
      It puts reasons like that at a disadvantage.
    • 04:39:35
      When the last thing you do is make that division by, if your lane miles are historically 60% more to construct than it is in the Lynchburg District, then that's a biggie.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:39:47
      Just like you said when they did Glebe Road, it went from 18 to 1.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:39:52
      If the benefits are 60% more, there's no impact.
    • 04:39:57
      You still got to do the last thing you do.
    • 04:40:00
      No, it's the numerator, but to get there you have a numerator and a denominator.
    • 04:40:05
      The theory is that your argument is correct if there are constant benefits in every district to building the road.
    • 04:40:18
      But at the end of the day, you plan all of them to divide by the number.
    • 04:40:23
      Yeah, but let's take lane models.
    • 04:40:24
      You're comparing a district that the benefit may be, let's say it's 200,000 cars per day versus one that's 50.
    • 04:40:35
      So they're going to get a much higher numerator to divide the higher cost.
    • 04:40:40
      But they're mitigating that in the formulas.
    • 04:40:44
      The only one they're not mitigating that I understood was that last stroke of the pen when you divide by the cost.
    • 04:40:52
      There's no mitigation for that based on the stroke.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:40:56
      Am I wrong?
    • 04:40:57
      So Mr. Williams, I don't think we know whether or not you're right or wrong.
    • 04:41:01
      I think you're raising it.
    • 04:41:03
      I certainly don't know.
    • 04:41:06
      And I think it all depends on where you're sitting as to whether or not you're right or wrong.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:41:10
      So you're going to get back to me, right?
    • 04:41:12
      I will do my best to get back to you.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:41:15
      If I could offer, I think that as to what regions cost more or less than others, the Secretary mentioned right away that's a big factor.
    • 04:41:25
      The other thing that we do have good information on is asphalt.
    • 04:41:30
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz Jr., John K. Matney Jr., John K. Matney Jr.,
    • 04:41:49
      I know we keep talking about this ratio as being my cost, and maybe I'm jumping ahead here,
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:42:16
      What it actually is, is the funding.
    • 04:42:19
      It's the amount of funding that we are seeking from HB2.
    • 04:42:22
      So if you look at it as benefit, and sorry, I'm stealing, it's sort of a benefit based on the dollar that you're using.
    • 04:42:30
      Whether that's, as from the state's perspective, it doesn't matter whether it's a dollar in Lynchburg or a dollar in Hampton Road, it's still a dollar of state funding from a limited pool of resources.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:42:40
      So think about it.
    • 04:42:42
      I would agree that that's the ultimate goal.
    • 04:42:44
      As a statewide urban representative, that's probably how I should look at it.
    • 04:42:49
      But if you think from the regional perspectives, and I guarantee you from the delegates and senators,
    • 04:42:54
      They don't see themselves based on their region being put at a disadvantage because their construction costs are higher or because they're being at an advantage because their construction costs are lower.
    • 04:43:06
      So from a statewide perspective, I agree with you.
    • 04:43:10
      You describe it perfectly.
    • 04:43:11
      It's like the best use of the dollar and that's the bottom line.
    • 04:43:15
      But when you jump in a pool that can compete for statewide projects,
    • 04:43:19
      I think we're hearing and hearing the same prejudices and biases and assumptions that we heard all across and I think that's what we're all coming from a point of view.
    • 04:43:42
      I think that's what we're going through while we're hearing.
    • 04:43:45
      So moving on with the 12 minutes left before I'm pulled off the podium
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:44:15
      What we're then going to do is we're going to have that score.
    • 04:44:20
      So if you look at this table here, you have the weight of each factor area.
    • 04:44:24
      You have that factor score.
    • 04:44:26
      And then we're going to multiply the factor score by that weight.
    • 04:44:29
      And again, the highest you can get in each factor score is 100.
    • 04:44:31
      And then we'll multiply it by the weight.
    • 04:44:33
      And so under congestion mitigation and category B, the highest you can get there is 15 points.
    • 04:44:38
      We're going to add all that up.
    • 04:44:40
      And that's your project's raw score.
    • 04:44:42
      And again, the scale there is going to be 0 to 100.
    • 04:44:45
      This example, it's 62.
    • 04:44:49
      What staff is recommending is that that project's raw score then be divided by the House Bill 2 funded cost.
    • 04:44:57
      So that excludes local revenues, that excludes
    • 04:45:04
      The state regional taxes that are imposed in certain areas and so in this example say the project's cost was 30 million dollars but the HP2 funded portion of that cost was 15 we would divide 62 by 15 which would give it a cost effective score of 1.4.
    • 04:45:23
      We also have heard clearly from the board that they would like for staff to also provide what is its relative benefit compared to its total cost.
    • 04:45:31
      And so we would also let you know that that's 2.1 in this instance.
    • 04:45:35
      The reason we recommended using the HB2 funded portion of the project's cost is because we want to try and encourage local communities and regions to bring their resources to bear on these projects that have benefits and leverage them into the state projects that we're looking to construct.
    • 04:45:58
      And we thought that using this would create incentive
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:46:01
      For those local communities to bring those additional funds they may have
    • 04:46:19
      And the first reason is because the new revenues that were enacted and are paid by the citizens of Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads were designed to help them build roads that weren't being funded by the state, not designed to help them leverage that money
    • 04:46:42
      to get more money out of this, which is exactly what this would do, because in the example you used, they're taking $15 million off the denominator.
    • 04:46:55
      That's going to take and score that project higher than everybody else around the state that doesn't have access to that money and doesn't have the ability to put that money on a project.
    • 04:47:05
      The second thing it's going to do is it's going to allow the regional entities to manipulate that denominator.
    • 04:47:11
      Who's going to decide whether they put 15 million on this project other than them?
    • 04:47:16
      Maybe they could have put 10.
    • 04:47:18
      Maybe they could have put 25.
    • 04:47:19
      And therefore, they're going to be able to manipulate that score based on the denominator.
    • 04:47:28
      And the last piece is, it's not just those regional monies, those two areas.
    • 04:47:33
      There's a lot of different sources of money.
    • 04:47:36
      Are we going to say, well, you've got to put your revenue sharing money in this?
    • 04:47:39
      And we'll count that.
    • 04:47:40
      Well, are we going to go 50-50?
    • 04:47:42
      Well, no.
    • 04:47:42
      So nobody's going to put it in unless they're willing to put 50% of it in.
    • 04:47:47
      You know, I think we are more, and I understand that part of the deal under this legislation that passed to increase the taxes was to balkanize a little bit in the state how we fund roads.
    • 04:48:01
      I get that.
    • 04:48:03
      But what we're getting ready to do is completely balkanize how we do everything because
    • 04:48:10
      It's going to be very difficult for, and I wish Roger was here, take a Richmond for example, okay?
    • 04:48:19
      How are they going to compete with Northern Virginia or Hampton Roads?
    • 04:48:22
      They don't have this extra money from these other bills.
    • 04:48:24
      Granted, their citizens aren't paying it, but they don't have the ability to do that.
    • 04:48:29
      So, I've got a lot of concerns about this.
    • 04:48:32
      I know that you guys are working on it, but it's a significant issue.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:48:40
      Just a comment.
    • 04:48:42
      The view you take would be completely not agreed to in the other regions.
    • 04:48:46
      The reason being because the law said it did not limit them getting their otherwise statewide money just in the code.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:48:53
      So they ought to be treated like they're not spending any money.
    • 04:48:57
      Because that's what the statewide money is available.
    • 04:48:59
      It's not limited them, but they're not getting an advantage.
    • 04:49:02
      But it wasn't enacted with the understanding that it could only be used for projects that VDOT wasn't funding.
    • 04:49:09
      I don't disagree with that.
    • 04:49:11
      I thought you stated that.
    • 04:49:12
      No, no.
    • 04:49:13
      I think in terms of the scoring of the projects,
    • 04:49:17
      I don't think, I think we're always going to use whatever sources we can use, but I will tell you that people in rural Virginia that when the legislature didn't vote for this thinking that they were going to give money to Northern Virginia to be able to use to leverage to get more money out of state.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:49:36
      I don't know how you said that, because we basically said we hope that they use every nickel they could everywhere to leverage money.
    • 04:49:46
      That was the whole idea of the law, is to... Well, the law passed when?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:49:50
      The law passed before you were Secretary.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:49:53
      No, no, no, no.
    • 04:49:53
      It passed this time.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:49:55
      Well, but I'm talking about the law authorizing the expenditures.
    • 04:50:00
      Now, HB2, the HB2 in the calculations is we were very focused in HB2 on the numerator.
    • 04:50:10
      You could assume whatever you wanted to assume for the denominator, whether it was total cost or whether it was your regional cost or whether it was not defined.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:50:18
      Not in 1887.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:50:19
      Well, I don't think it's defined in the law or we wouldn't be having the conversation.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:50:23
      No, but they wanted, we wanted regional money so they'd have monies to use because every district has monies now.
    • 04:50:30
      There's nothing that says the district couldn't use their monies also.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:50:33
      Well, Mr. Chairman, that goes to my earlier point about if we're going to count that money too,
    • 04:50:39
      K. Kasprowicz Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:50:58
      Well, that's assuming that the project would be applicable statewide.
    • 04:51:04
      Now, I mean, I get what you're saying, and I think that, and I'm not saying I agree well, I'm just pointing out the other things that we've heard as we've gone through here, but that is a consideration as to what the cost that is used in determining.
    • 04:51:24
      F. Kennedy Jr., John F. Kennedy Jr., John F. Kennedy Jr., John F. Kennedy
    • 04:51:42
      But that's exactly the pressure points that we're talking about is what was used as the denominator.
    • 04:51:49
      Exactly those points.
    • 04:51:51
      The other view is they've got so many more projects that they'll be disadvantaged if they don't use them.
    • 04:51:59
      They've got so many to do in there and they're paying extra taxes, why should they be penalized, but they want to use it for that.
    • 04:52:05
      So there's, I got it, there's a, there's, so that's really the key.
    • 04:52:09
      That, that is exactly the philosophy of MBTA, that we not be discriminated against because we're collecting more tax money, but that we could also use the funds to leverage to get as much roads and transit that we can.
    • 04:52:24
      Bill, that's, that's the reality of the MBTA philosophy as I sit here as a member of that board.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:52:30
      No, I get it, I get it, but, but all I'm saying is
    • 04:52:33
      This board is going to have to make that decision because we're going to decide what that denominator is.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:52:39
      And at the staff level, we had as vigorous if not a more vigorous discussion about this.
    • 04:52:45
      This was one of the last issues that we were going back and forth on and I think we even discussed the idea of having, you know, taking that 4.1 and 2.1, adding together and dividing them in half so 50% was based on the HB2 funded portion and 50% was based on the
    • 04:53:02
      Total cost to kind of compromise between the two bookends of the potential position.
    • 04:53:09
      When it came to just what it boiled down to at the end of the day for staff was we should encourage people to put funds on the projects that they would like the state to invest in and that was where the staff came from.
    • 04:53:23
      Just trying to explain our rationale with regards to some of the regional monies, some of the things that we talked about is if they have a bad project,
    • 04:53:31
      They could just fully fund it with regional revenues instead of putting half the money in and risking that this board may or may not fund it and then put in their good project with not a single dollar in it.
    • 04:53:43
      And that could then still just get funded.
    • 04:53:44
      And so I think this situation could play out in a number of ways and I think it's all going to depend on the personalities of the members of this board when we hit that situation and the personalities of a regional entity or local governing board as to
    • 04:54:00
      How people participate or, you know, their accuracy.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:54:04
      On 66, Nick, okay, Winding 66, that's going to be scored, right?
    • 04:54:09
      What's going to be the cost?
    • 04:54:11
      Is it how much the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority decides to put in?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:54:16
      B. Smith Jr., John B. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 04:54:39
      I get both sides and I think that's why we need to discuss and it may be that we need to run through different scenarios to see how it would impact things.
    • 04:54:56
      Seems to me some type of weighting of those monies may be a good compromise, but we've got to get through that as we go through it.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 04:55:05
      I don't know, you're right, I think we do need to get some examples to see how this actually works out.
    • 04:55:12
      But I do believe at this point that keeping on the table the total cost, whether or not that's the exact figure or factor that we use, but knowing the total cost I think is going to be helpful to us as a board making some of our decisions.
    • 04:55:26
      So I think that is an important factor for us to know.
    • 04:55:30
      And to keep in mind and to find out how much of it is actually leveraged.
    • 04:55:35
      And there are some areas of Virginia that do not have the resources to put in a lot of their own money to projects.
    • 04:55:44
      And I think we need to take that into consideration as well.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:55:48
      And Ms. Valentine's staff are trying to come up with a host of different ways to provide you more information than just one number at the end of the day with no context because candidly 4.1
    • 04:55:59
      doesn't tell you anything in a vacuum.
    • 04:56:01
      When you have all the projects next to each other, it will tell you how they relatively scored, but we still think you need to see the raw, you know, safety benefits, the raw congestion changes.
    • 04:56:12
      And then also, because the board did say you wanted to see the relative benefit with both total and leverage cost, this is not the prettiest of charts, as Mr. Fralin and I discussed this yesterday.
    • 04:56:23
      But a better version of this or some variant of that is something that we think should be put together
    • 04:56:28
      For the project, so you can see both how a project does on its relative cost, which is the north-south or y-axis, and then also be able to compare that to its relative benefit with its total cost, which you see on the x or east-west axis there.
    • 04:56:43
      So you can see that project got a 12.
    • 04:56:46
      Again, these are just make-believe numbers.
    • 04:56:48
      That was just, it didn't leverage any money, but its benefits are very, very high.
    • 04:56:53
      And you can see some projects leverage
    • 04:56:55
      their leverage funds so that their HB2 funded relative cost was much higher than their total cost relative benefit was and so we are trying to work on some tools like this and other things to provide to the board I don't think if we just came to you and said it's 4.1 what do you want to do that that would really be fair or responsible for staff and so we are and that's some of the stuff we're working on for the April meeting
    • 04:57:21
      And I'm not going to have it all at the April meeting either.
    • 04:57:23
      I think we're going to show you some stuff.
    • 04:57:25
      You're going to tell us what's helpful, what's not helpful, what you think is missing.
    • 04:57:29
      And we're going to keep refining that.
    • 04:57:30
      But we're going to have to provide, I think, the board with a host of information.
    • 04:57:37
      There's got to be one official score because the law tells us there's got to be one official score.
    • 04:57:42
      I think the board can take all sorts of information into account as it decides what it is that it actually wants to fund.
    • 04:57:49
      And I don't think it's just going to be that in number you see.
    • 04:57:52
      I think that's going to be a piece of the information that's digested by this body as you figure out what you want to fund.
    • 04:58:00
      But I expect there are going to be other things you want to know, geographic equity and other things of that nature.
    • 04:58:05
      There's going to be other discussions.
    • 04:58:07
      So kind of moving forward, as I said earlier, we're going to come back to you in the coming months with some recommendations about how we go from a list of 4.1s and 2.1s and other things to a funded program, a project.
    • 04:58:19
      That's going to involve the type of information we give to you.
    • 04:58:22
      It's going to take into account the new programs under House Bill 1887.
    • 04:58:25
      It's also going to look at programs that aren't subject to House Bill 2.
    • 04:58:30
      And then one of the things we also need to start talking about is how often do we solicit projects and score them?
    • 04:58:34
      Do we do it each year?
    • 04:58:35
      Do we do it every two years?
    • 04:58:37
      What's the amount of money we want to try and make available in a given round of solicitation, particularly if we're trying to fully fund projects in an individual round?
    • 04:58:47
      And then in the guide you'll find some components about when a project we're recommending would need to be rescored.
    • 04:58:53
      I'm not going to go through this in detail, but basically if your cost estimate goes up significantly or your scope changes significantly, we're going to recommend that you be rescored so that we don't have people who keep coming in with applications with low-ball cost estimates or scopes they know they're not going to end up building that gives them artificially high scores.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:59:14
      Just a quick question.
    • 04:59:14
      When we get the input back from the MPO,
    • 04:59:18
      On scoring, are they going to have their projects in there and scored under a constrained budget? Are they going to give us 20 projects and we know the budget and we take the top down or don't? How's that feedback going to work? So the constrained long range plans cover a period of 40 years. Right. And so
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:59:42
      In those MPO areas, again, the projects will need to be within that plan, but because it's over a 40-year period, I think there's still an ample pool of projects that could be submitted by local governments or MPOs within those areas that the board could consider.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:59:57
      But, all right, they're going to score them and... We're going to score them.
    • 05:00:01
      Okay, we're going to score them.
    • 05:00:02
      So do we give them back to them and say, here's the scores
    • 05:00:05
      And you're getting $50 million a year out of the pot, so you put the projects back in and straighten them?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 05:00:12
      No, Mr. Williams, the way this is going to work is the agency will submit projects as is proposed.
    • 05:00:18
      Staff will score them, will have a quality assurance, quality control process that involves external stakeholders, will then provide the board scores.
    • 05:00:25
      You as the board select those projects that you think should be funded within the limitations of state and federal law.
    • 05:00:33
      So we're not going to tell the MPO, we've given you an allocation of $20 million because you sent in a few good projects and go ahead and pick the ones you want.
    • 05:00:41
      We're going to tell the MPO, here's $20 million.
    • 05:00:43
      Twelve and a half of it is for Project B and the remaining seven and a half is for Project E. We're not giving you any funds for A, C, and D.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:00:52
      But there's still going to be discretion though once the scores are provided to us that we do not have to strictly go by the score but there is input from every member of this board to sway a decision one way or another.
    • 05:01:12
      So my question goes to that if the MPO really if they had their druthers and didn't have to score they'd be able to do these six projects that's what they would have put in their
    • 05:01:22
      The law says we use this, but at the end of the day, we choose to do something else to this decision.
    • 05:01:37
      We just have to explain why we did it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:01:39
      Mr. Chairman, I think on this scoring piece, it reminds me of the CBO.
    • 05:01:44
      What's going to happen, I suspect, is people that are really advocating for a project,
    • 05:01:48
      We're going to come in and they're going to say, hey, this economic development score is way higher than what your people were saying because blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
    • 05:01:57
      And so I think it's really important that we listen to those people.
    • 05:02:00
      I think it's important we have this advisory committee.
    • 05:02:03
      I also think it's really important that VDOT maintain the integrity of the scoring system.
    • 05:02:08
      And ultimately be responsible for that number.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:02:12
      It may not be because they don't have the resources, but I don't want them being lobbied.
    • 05:02:18
      We may have, we may choose, that's what they talk about, maybe we'll choose the board to have another entity that scores.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:02:26
      Well, okay.
    • 05:02:28
      But as long as it's controlled by this board.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:02:31
      Because, you know, they work with them every day.
    • 05:02:33
      Think about governance.
    • 05:02:35
      Hey, you know, that's, you know, we haven't decided that.
    • 05:02:39
      We've just been saying.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:02:40
      Well, and if you're doing SBCs and MPOs, and this is not disparaging anybody.
    • 05:02:44
      This is just a matter of people trying to do the best for their constituents.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:02:47
      I would expect they would.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:02:48
      But if you allow them to be the only entity that can propose and allow them to score, it doesn't matter what we do.
    • 05:02:56
      They're going to only send us one project and it's going to score really high and we're going to be doing it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:03:03
      So let's don't do that.
    • 05:03:05
      Do you have anything else to wrap up?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 05:03:11
      I just want to say that we haven't made revisions based on the feedback we've got over the last three weeks so we definitely have some work to do on the weighting frameworks and clarifying some of the items on the measures.
    • 05:03:21
      Based on the discussion today we have some other work to
    • 05:03:23
      That we probably need to get on as well, but here's kind of the schedule moving forward.
    • 05:03:27
      We put this document on the website, VirginiaHB2.org.
    • 05:03:31
      We're going to go out and hold public comment at the Six-Year Improvement Program hearings.
    • 05:03:35
      We're also going to be available to stakeholders and we have an email address and other things where they can send comments.
    • 05:03:41
      We're going to come back to you in May with a revised process based on all of these
    • 05:03:44
      things for your consideration and we'll also be here in April with hopefully about 40 projects have been evaluated.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:03:55
      Okay, any other questions?
    • 05:04:00
      Well, I'll wrap up with this.
    • 05:04:01
      Every time I've listened to our discussion and we discuss every point is that it is the only point.
    • 05:04:08
      In other words, and I think we got to keep in mind that it is, you know, there are some points where I'm going to, this guy gets better for these and something.
    • 05:04:16
      It's really the process when we get through, and I think we just got to keep that in mind, but we tend to discuss it, well, gosh, if it's just, that's the only point, and that doesn't work for me, which is very consistent with what we've been hearing around the state, so just throw that out.
    • 05:04:33
      I did want to recognize there are a lot of people, I know Mr. Donohue's the face, but there's a whole lot of people that are working on this,
    • 05:04:39
      You'd stand up.
    • 05:04:41
      I know my Deaf Renique and Grindly and the staff, all the other people.
    • 05:04:48
      There's a whole lot of...
    • 05:04:52
      They've been laughing all up here, but I can see their faces.
    • 05:04:56
      But I want to recognize them.
    • 05:04:58
      As the chief antagonistic antagonizer, I do want to tell the staff
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:05:12
      Y'all have done a tremendous job.
    • 05:05:14
      There are a lot of policy questions we have to wrestle with and you all understand this better than we do and there's no question and Nick you too have put in tons of work in this thing and just because we may not agree with what the ultimate conclusion was or may want to talk about doesn't mean that y'all didn't do a good job.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:05:33
      In fact, I think the quality of the information is allowing us to have these types of discussions and really get into the policy, not worry about if it's a two or a three type of stuff.
    • 05:05:45
      So I really appreciate it.
    • 05:05:47
      I think we, if it's okay with the board, we will do the legislation next time, 86 and 87.
    • 05:05:53
      I think you generally know there was no real specifics.
    • 05:05:57
      But we'll go through it in more detail.
    • 05:06:02
      I will get, Nick, we can give them copies.
    • 05:06:05
      We all actually have the bills.
    • 05:06:07
      So we'll get the bills.
    • 05:06:09
      So we do those and we will go through at the next meeting and review of that.
    • 05:06:14
      Now, one other thing in the workshop before we go, I did mention earlier, Charlie has something, I don't think we're going to vote on it today, but I want him to just briefly tell you about
    • 05:06:25
      A. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:36
      What I'd suggest is again to not be voted on at this meeting.
    • 05:06:41
      The intent of this is for the board to authorize the movement of $5.1 million out of the toll facility revolving account onto the 66 project inside the beltway.
    • 05:06:57
      And the purpose of that will be to develop the contract documents to develop the scope
    • 05:07:05
      So that we can go out with the design-built procurement for the gantry system and the tolling system.
    • 05:07:12
      It is also for the coordination, the consultation, the public outreach, working with local stakeholders both DRPT and VDOT towards developing the project and program of how the funds generated from this tolling operation would be used.
    • 05:07:34
      So again, the 5.1, it's really doing two things.
    • 05:07:38
      It's the preliminary engineering work on the gantry system that would ultimately go out as a design-build contract.
    • 05:07:48
      It would include all of the electronics, the back office support, that piece of it.
    • 05:07:53
      But it's also, and just as importantly,
    • 05:07:56
      How the revenues that are generated, working with the local partners, how we will look at projects and programs, and so that's what that's for.
    • 05:08:06
      The intent of the Told Facilities Revolving Fund is to support future toll projects.
    • 05:08:14
      And again, this is exactly what that fund was set up to do.
    • 05:08:19
      We would expect that these funds would be repaid once tolling operations were commenced.
    • 05:08:24
      We would sort out the term, but again, it would be repaid.
    • 05:08:29
      So that's what this is for.
    • 05:08:31
      I think that to give you all a chance to look at it, the project team, we do have funds available for them to continue to do the work, especially the outreach work that they're doing.
    • 05:08:43
      We're doing traffic and revenue work.
    • 05:08:45
      We're doing a lot of that preliminary work.
    • 05:08:49
      And we'll be able to continue that over the next 30 days and then come back to the board
    • 05:08:53
      I'm here at our next meeting and request an approval to actually make the fund transfer.
    • 05:09:00
      So again, we do have some what I'll call discretionary district-wide money that can be used for the short-term purpose but not for the ultimate purpose of delivering a design-build contract and also that program of how we're going to distribute the project funds and how we're going to deliver those projects and programs.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:09:22
      Just a quick question and if we want to hold questions until we get back at it.
    • 05:09:28
      Why are we segregating 66 into a state project?
    • 05:09:33
      Why don't we let the private sector do all this?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:09:36
      Let me make a comment.
    • 05:09:37
      Let me first of all respond if I'll get to that because I am.
    • 05:09:42
      That's my comment.
    • 05:09:44
      It's directly related to that.
    • 05:09:47
      I want you to consider this also.
    • 05:09:50
      Remember now, 1887 changes the flavor of the total facilities account.
    • 05:09:55
      In other words, for the future, Charlie's right up until now, that's what's been used, but in the future, it's going to go into the VTIP and into that.
    • 05:10:03
      So, just really didn't want you to get confused.
    • 05:10:06
      I mean, there are some funds in there, but they're all going to be inverted eventually into going into the VTIP bank or the TPOC monies in that regard.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:10:16
      Now, is there, first of all, any questions on that?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:10:24
      Yes.
    • 05:10:24
      This is a very high profile covered by multimedia outlets, the inside the beltway.
    • 05:10:31
      And I think for a resolution like this, even though it's spelled out, that 30 days held in abeyance is the right and proper thing to do.
    • 05:10:42
      We have done everything and I want to have plenty of opportunity to comment on anything we've done and that's why we decided, even though we think it's much administrative,
    • 05:10:51
      But I think that's right, Mr. Zinske, that's why.
    • 05:10:55
      Let me make a comment to Mr. Fone's point and in general to have comments with any of you.
    • 05:11:01
      We announced a year ago we would start the procurement of the procurement, the development of outside development, which we have.
    • 05:11:09
      That project continues on track in terms of its development and Jennifer and Mitchell and Charlie have been actively involved in what we want it to look like when we think it will be a multimodal solution.
    • 05:11:24
      Inside the Beltway we announced just this past week and that project we felt like had to be considered as we considered what was happening outside the Beltway as you get people coming in.
    • 05:11:42
      There are many stakeholders involved in these projects, not just the construction companies, not just our citizens, but the politicians and all that.
    • 05:11:51
      So, and including our sister district of the District of Columbia, because hopefully we'll roll those right on in there.
    • 05:11:59
      In fact, I've had several meetings with my counterpart.
    • 05:12:02
      They're very amenable to us doing that.
    • 05:12:04
      So, that's the overall strategy.
    • 05:12:08
      Now, when we announced last year, we did not announce how the procurement would be, but we did say we generally thought it probably would lend itself to a P3.
    • 05:12:20
      But that decision has not been made yet.
    • 05:12:23
      In fact, I've asked the Commissioner and Director Mitchell
    • 05:12:27
      I've been working with their department and our P3 department to give me sources and uses of cash.
    • 05:12:39
      In other words, convince us that this is the way to finance the project.
    • 05:12:45
      We're only talking about how we finance it.
    • 05:12:48
      We are going to have a private sector build it.
    • 05:12:50
      We are going to have a private sector operate it.
    • 05:12:53
      We may have a private sector financing, but that decision hasn't been made yet.
    • 05:13:00
      I'm talking about outside the beltway.
    • 05:13:04
      Inside the beltway, we have made a decision that to meet the political and transportation needs of the quarter, that the monies generated off of that inside the beltway need to be used in that quarter to support multimodal solutions in that particular area.
    • 05:13:22
      We will not begin with right-of-way acquisition or expansion.
    • 05:13:26
      There will be other things done through their first and so we have decided that that is the appropriate use of the funds in that area to have them reinvested in the area and in fact we've identified NDTC as the organization which we'll be working with in that regard, the sponsor organization.
    • 05:13:47
      Outside the beltway is undecided.
    • 05:13:54
      It's going to require a large public sector.
    • 05:13:57
      We have monies to do that.
    • 05:14:00
      We believe that there's available funds that we can raise outside of that between other federal programs.
    • 05:14:05
      So we're trying to identify just how short we are.
    • 05:14:09
      And what the cost of that, if we decide to go a P3 route, what the real cost we're giving up.
    • 05:14:17
      In terms of negotiating.
    • 05:14:19
      Now, I've talked not only the legislation of the General Assembly that requires the Secretary to have to recertify that it is in the best interest of honor and wealth that we go under a P3 procurement.
    • 05:14:34
      But over and above that, the Governor's made pretty clear up front we're going to be good fiduciaries and also we're in a little different position.
    • 05:14:42
      We have monies.
    • 05:14:43
      This Board has monies.
    • 05:14:46
      Initiating tolling in the area is not the risk it was in previous deals.
    • 05:14:52
      Tolls have been introduced in the Commonwealth in both Hampton Roads and in Northern Virginia.
    • 05:14:59
      So the risk associated with those deals, I don't think they're cookie cutter deals.
    • 05:15:04
      That we automatically assume that this worked for the last one, this is the way we ought to do this one.
    • 05:15:10
      So if we go down that it'll be we've decided to make a recommendation to this board that our opportunity costs are better to use private capital.
    • 05:15:20
      and to use that in there.
    • 05:15:23
      So that decision is to be made.
    • 05:15:26
      Hopefully we'll have it ready for you guys.
    • 05:15:28
      Probably not April.
    • 05:15:29
      Probably we'll have to make the decision by the day.
    • 05:15:33
      But I spent most of this general, a lot of this session having the General Assembly want me to buy back rows we've already done.
    • 05:15:45
      changed the laws on P3s we've already done.
    • 05:15:49
      So I think it's incumbent upon us to make gaggle on sure that if we go forward under this scenario that we have looked at all the other alternatives.
    • 05:16:02
      So that's where we are and I want to make sure we may end up, very well may end up being a public-private partnership.
    • 05:16:12
      But we have not made that decision as of yet and that's what we're working through.
    • 05:16:18
      I'd be happy to answer any questions with the board or anybody because I know I've had several conversations.
    • 05:16:26
      The project is moving full speed ahead as far as development.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:16:30
      In that regard.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:16:32
      So it is really how we're going to finance it and what we believe is in the best interest of the Commonwealth taxpayers in that regard.
    • 05:16:41
      So that's what we will be doing and it very well may be a peepery.
    • 05:16:45
      very well may be a P-3, but we don't know that answer yet until we look at different alternatives and once we've decided that that's the case, then we'll move down that route or recommend.
    • 05:17:00
      If we don't, then we'll, I will tell you the board will be fully informed before we ask you to allocate any monies as to why we make the decision.
    • 05:17:10
      You'll be part of it.
    • 05:17:12
      So that's where we are on 66.
    • 05:17:17
      It's a very important project to the Commonwealth and determined to see it to get to procurement.
    • 05:17:25
      And I'll reiterate, the private sector is going to be a big part no matter what we do because somebody is going to build it, somebody is going to operate it, and maybe they'll finance it.
    • 05:17:34
      But I think it'll be on terms that probably are not the way we've done things in the past because I don't think the risk profile is the same as it's been in the past.
    • 05:17:48
      So that's what we're trying to get to work through.
    • 05:17:52
      Mr. Kilpatrick and Ms. Mitchell are leading that.
    • 05:17:56
      They are the procuring agency with the support of our P3 department.
    • 05:18:00
      They will be making a recommendation working together as to what they think the sources and uses of cash are and then we'll make a determination what's the right procurement going forward.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:18:14
      If I could, there's two projects inside the beltway and outside the beltway for some of the board members maybe not as familiar.
    • 05:18:23
      Outside the beltway, I would describe it as an infrastructure heavy project that will likely require significant physical improvements to the roadway.
    • 05:18:35
      Martin, M.D.
    • 05:18:52
      The balance of what we're looking at in terms of how do we move more people on the corridor inside, and again we briefed you last month, is a focus on how do you move more people, not on looking to add more pavement.
    • 05:19:09
      K. Kasprowicz,
    • 05:19:24
      A high occupancy total of three along with alternative transportation means it's going to give us additional throughput on that corridor for some period of time without adding physical pavement.
    • 05:19:41
      It's a very different type of project and the scale in terms of the dollars needed for initial
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 05:19:48
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz Jr., John K. Matney Jr., John K. Matney Jr.,
    • 05:20:11
      But we also believe it's incumbent upon us to make sure that we have presented all the options and that the procurement we chose and I made a commitment to this board that before you would vote to move monies you would know what our recommendation is and how we're proceeding.
    • 05:20:33
      That's what we're going to do.
    • 05:20:35
      I do not think we slowed the project down one bit.
    • 05:20:39
      I want to make that clear.
    • 05:20:41
      It's moving down the path and a lot will have to do as we come over the next, I suspect by the May board meeting, it may happen in April, but probably not.
    • 05:20:55
      For outside the beltway, probably not.
    • 05:20:57
      Dr. Robert Smith, Dr. Robert Smith Jr.
    • 05:21:13
      But what we need to do is to make sure that I stand in front of you, I stand in front of the General Assembly, I stand in front of myself, and it was nice to say this is in the best interest of the Commonwealth taxpayers and the appropriate procurement to go.
    • 05:21:29
      And that's what we're doing.