Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 9/16/2014
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   9/16/2014

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Proposed revision to the DRPT SYIP and budget.pdf
  • 1. Proposed Adjustment to the 2015-2020 SYIP, CTF and VDOT Budgets

  • 2. FY 2015-2020 Six-Year Improvement Program

    • Proposed adjustments to the Fiscal Years 2015 - 20 Six-Year Improvement Program, Commonwealth Transportation Fund and VDOT budgets.pdf
    • Draft revised Fiscal Years 2015 - 20 Six-Year Improvement Program.pdf
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:00:01
      Good morning everyone and welcome to the September workshop session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:08
      Please rise and say the Pledge of Allegiance.
    • 00:00:14
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • 00:00:27
      A couple of quick announcements before we start.
    • 00:00:31
      The microphones are very sensitive, so if you don't want somebody to hear sorry, I would suggest you don't say it.
    • 00:00:39
      A. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:00:58
      And what I plan to do is after the presentations is continue this attractive, smaller discussion, just go through really what we're trying to accomplish with House Bill 2.
    • 00:01:14
      and talk about some particular projects because this is a transition, a transition period going from the way we did it to where we're going and there has to be some judgments made and we'll talk about those as we go through.
    • 00:01:30
      So when you finally vote, you'll have hopefully
    • 00:01:36
      The same information that we've had over the last few months, getting this information together and making the decisions as to how we would recommend that we move forward with housekeeping.
    • 00:01:52
      So, with that, first of all, welcome everybody.
    • 00:01:56
      I see most of you had a great dinner.
    • 00:01:58
      Thanks to our hosts,
    • 00:02:01
      Mr. Fralin last evening, it was a nice time, and we looked to replicate that this evening, wherever we are, but it was a great time last evening, so we appreciate that.
    • 00:02:14
      And then, of course, tomorrow, after our formal session, we'll get into working with Mr. Bruehl on allocations related to our, some other findings.
    • 00:02:29
      That will start our work session.
    • 00:02:32
      I guess we have Laura.
    • 00:02:34
      Good morning.
    • 00:02:35
      Good to see you today.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:02:41
      Good morning, everyone.
    • 00:02:42
      My name is Laura Farmer.
    • 00:02:43
      I'm the Director of the Financial Planning Commission at VDOT.
    • 00:02:47
      We're a component of the Chief Financial Officer Directorate.
    • 00:02:50
      This morning, I'm going to give you an overview of the proposed adjustments to the 15 through 20 Six-Year Improvement Program, the Commonwealth Transportation Fund budget, and the VDOT budget.
    • 00:03:05
      Since House Bill 2313 was passed in 2013, which is about 18 months ago from where we are right now, our revenue forecast updates and the actions that have been associated with signing a budget have resulted in a loss of just over a billion dollars to transportation.
    • 00:03:22
      The majority of that impact has been felt by highway construction and the mass transit programs.
    • 00:03:28
      B. Dott.
    • 00:03:29
      While most of the revenue reductions were applied to the highway maintenance and operating fund, our crossover has increased to ensure that we maintain our funding for the maintenance program.
    • 00:03:41
      We've also implemented some agency actions to reduce the impact on core programs internally.
    • 00:03:47
      I'll get into a little bit more detail about that later.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:03:49
      Is that $1.2 billion for the whole
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:03:52
      Yes sir, including from the revenues updates we got last December, that is including fiscal year 14 all the way through fiscal year 20.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:04:04
      Our revenues, like the general fund, have been declining, at least the projections, I won't say the revenues because the actual revenues are higher because obviously we passed 2013, but the projections
    • 00:04:19
      of what we hoped would happen, continue to decline. Initially, it was the price of gasoline. Most recently, it is economic activity related to reduced vehicle sales, and we'll go through here. I want to, you mentioned about crossover. At this level of funding, it's important to know that crossover does not go away. Ever.
    • 00:04:44
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:05:04
      That's one thing we need to consider as we get money back to O'Callaghan's.
    • 00:05:11
      That impacts that formula with our CTB formula.
    • 00:05:16
      That's really a significant hit going forward because crossover does not disappear.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:05:29
      Thank you.
    • 00:05:30
      The results of our actions today in terms of what we need to embed in the new Six-Year Improvement Program and the associated budgets is $129 million that affects the formula, the amount that's available for distribution through the CTB formula.
    • 00:05:46
      Of that amount, $95 million is in the current fiscal year.
    • 00:05:52
      I'd like to talk briefly about the factors that require this update.
    • 00:05:56
      In June, you adopted our six-year financial plan, the Commonwealth Transportation Fund budget, the DRPT budget, and the VDOT budget, who were all based on assumptions that we knew about mid-June.
    • 00:06:08
      Well, in late June, the Governor and the General Assembly finalized the biennial budget.
    • 00:06:13
      We had incorporated some pending items that we thought may impact transportation at the time.
    • 00:06:19
      We also experienced some unknown items that came about through the waning days of that development process and are now incorporating those.
    • 00:06:32
      So the largest items that impact transportation from the biennial budget are enumerated on this slide.
    • 00:06:39
      The General Assembly has asked that $30 million be transferred from the HMOF to the General Fund in the current fiscal year and they plan on returning that in next year.
    • 00:06:49
      the plan yes exactly so we are counting on that for the time being there is a transfer to the general fund of transportation trust fund dollars
    • 00:07:06
      We are providing some additional support to the Commercial Space Flight Authority for the unmanned aircraft system test range of $5.8 million in the first year and some planning and preliminary engineering work for dredging the Norfolk Harbor Channel for the fourth authority in each fiscal year.
    • 00:07:25
      So the combined impact of these four actions is a $70 million reduction in the first year
    • 00:07:31
      with about $27 million of that returning in the second for a total impact of the loss of $43 million.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:07:38
      This does not include any adjustments that may come out of the budget that the Governor and the Speaker announced yesterday, so there could be additional items for us to consider when that is adopted.
    • 00:07:56
      In fact, as it stands today, there will be a significant couple of items we'll have to consider.
    • 00:08:03
      We don't know exactly how the next one will work,
    • 00:08:06
      Martin, John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr.,
    • 00:08:23
      We don't know if we have some other things coming back the other way, some different things, but we know that is going to be part of the cycle.
    • 00:08:33
      So it will happen.
    • 00:08:35
      Maybe next time we'll give you another update on some other adjustments.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:40
      Mr. Chairman, so we've got a decrease in revenue, so we're going to decrease revenue further?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:08:50
      We had a decrease on our revenues.
    • 00:08:53
      The general fund also was looking to plug about a $900 million budget.
    • 00:08:59
      So the general fund, part of our revenues come from the general fund.
    • 00:09:04
      the sales tax, and so they have, in 2313, moved it up, I don't have the exact numbers, but it was, I think an 8.075%, I believe, or the increments going up to get us to a higher level coming from the general fund.
    • 00:09:23
      They have delayed that.
    • 00:09:24
      In our projections, we had put in there that we would be getting these additional monies.
    • 00:09:29
      So they're not delaying the tax increases scheduled to take place?
    • 00:09:31
      No, they're just delaying it.
    • 00:09:33
      They're taking the money?
    • 00:09:33
      They're taking the money, that's right.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:35
      They're not giving it to us.
    • 00:09:36
      In addition to the $60 million they've already taken one year after the tax increase?
    • 00:09:41
      That is correct.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:09:45
      If I could just clarify, the tax increase for January 1st is fuel tax on gasoline.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:50
      The transfer that the secretary is referring to is the sales tax resale transfer for what was committed to the general fund that was expected to come to transportation. I'm not sure I understand that. Sure. If the, my understanding was, if the internet sales tax did not take place in Congress, that the
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:10:15
      Hulshale tax on gasoline was to go up a certain amount.
    • 00:10:20
      That's right.
    • 00:10:21
      But that's not a part of our condition.
    • 00:10:25
      We never projected marketplace equity.
    • 00:10:30
      That never happened.
    • 00:10:32
      We never projected any increased revenues for marketplace equity.
    • 00:10:38
      Now, to replace what they were anticipating with that, they increased about 40% wholesale sales tax on gasoline.
    • 00:10:49
      But that's non-general fund revenues that we collect.
    • 00:10:52
      Those projections are not a result of the marketplace equity act.
    • 00:10:57
      It's simply a result of price of gasoline being down and economic activity.
    • 00:11:03
      So that's the biggest part of this billion dollars.
    • 00:11:06
      If we had got the Marketplace Equity Act, we may have had a few more revenues, but we never projected we would get it done. So in our projections, we didn't do that. But in addition to that, there's a part of the sales tax, as Laura was pointing out, on general goods.
    • 00:11:27
      We get a small percentage. That's right. And that was anticipated to increase to give the money to us. The tax increase, they're just not giving the money to us anymore. Gotcha. Secretary? Yes. So the bottom line to this board though is that there's still a finite amount of dollars that we're going to get.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:50
      But it's fluid, and we have to just deal with the cards that we're dealt. I mean, we can't. In the general economic picture, there's nothing this board can get bothered. We can just do with what the monies are given to us at that point. That's what we're faced with. Some of these transfers we did not support.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:12:10
      during the process, but they were approved anyway in that regard. But the general decline in revenues is a result of economic activity that there is no control. I will say this, not trying to be a total pessimist, but at the general fund level, the economists are saying this year will probably be the best of the next three or four.
    • 00:12:37
      So they're indicating that they expect that there could be future reductions related to, even though they put them in there, but related to the sequester.
    • 00:12:48
      Most of the general fund revenues are a direct result of reduced defense spending in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads.
    • 00:12:57
      and I suspect we're feeling the spinoff from that coming down because of car sales and economic development activity around that.
    • 00:13:06
      The diversion is this whole thing, I mean, the lessening on the revenue is one thing.
    • 00:13:11
      It takes some of the economy, but we can't offer that satisfaction because the pilot diversion is out of us.
    • 00:13:17
      It's always been made so hard for us to raise taxes on gasoline for transportation.
    • 00:13:21
      Everybody says, we're just going to take it down to the front.
    • 00:13:24
      It's exactly what they did the first time out of the shooting.
    • 00:13:27
      And so now you don't really have to worry about the production.
    • 00:13:30
      You're going to have to, somewhere in your mind, calculate the likelihood of an abrasion like this.
    • 00:13:35
      Next year's going to be worse than this year, aren't you?
    • 00:13:37
      Or are they going to not continue this abrasion, perhaps an abrasion?
    • 00:13:41
      It'd give you no guarantee that they won't.
    • 00:13:43
      I think exactly.
    • 00:13:44
      It's time to forecast, and that's a tough one.
    • 00:13:47
      I know.
    • 00:13:47
      The administration did not support some of these transports, but it was a negotiation.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:13:58
      So to step further into the impacts of transportation, on August 15th, the Governor provided an update on the Commonwealth's revenue to the Joint Money Committee.
    • 00:14:10
      There were also related updates to transportation revenues at that time.
    • 00:14:14
      Those ranged from a low of 0.4% in fiscal year 18 to a high of 3.3% in 15 in these represented reductions, funding available.
    • 00:14:25
      There are also in addition to reductions that we've already talked to you about in previous meetings and what you considered in your Six-Year Improvement Program that was adopted in June that included almost $800 million in state revenue and $123 million in federal revenue that were lost and those items were considered in the previous program that you adopted.
    • 00:14:47
      These adjustments also impact all six years of our financial plan and they necessitate revisions to our budgets, particularly because there's so much of a reduction in the current fiscal year that we need to deal with it now.
    • 00:15:01
      So the combined reductions of the biannual budget items that I enumerated earlier, those four items that came out of the biannual budget, as well as these August revenue updates, range from a low of 0.4% in 2018 to a high of 5.6% loss in fiscal year 2015.
    • 00:15:21
      I'd just like to highlight some of the major changes in the updates that we received.
    • 00:15:26
      The leader being license fees of loss of $61 million.
    • 00:15:30
      Much of this was anticipated because the hybrid freight went away last session.
    • 00:15:35
      followed by the motor vehicle sales and use tax with their substantial reductions in the first two years for a total of 59 million over the six year window.
    • 00:15:47
      Followed by recordation taxes, a reduction of about 46 million dollars.
    • 00:15:52
      This area primarily impacts DRPT and Steve may touch on that a little later.
    • 00:15:58
      So in summary, the total impact is just shy of $167 million over the six years, and it also provides the impact by funds, the maintenance fund, as well as the transportation trust fund.
    • 00:16:10
      In addition, we saw some increases in the funding available through insurance premiums.
    • 00:16:15
      Those funds are dedicated to the priority transportation fund and are used for debt service, primarily on our CPR bonds today.
    • 00:16:24
      I'd also like to note that the regional revenues for Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia, those estimates were not updated in this August update we were provided, so we do expect those to be updated in December.
    • 00:16:40
      So the impact by agency, of the 43 million I talked on briefly about the, excuse me, for the biennial budget, as well as the August revenue updates of 167, the total impact is just shy of $210 million.
    • 00:16:55
      The pie chart just demonstrates the share in terms of who those reductions belong to with VDOT and DRPT having the brunt of those reductions.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:06
      One thing I want to point out from this slide that shows it very well is that the reductions are largely column-front loaded.
    • 00:17:14
      You're seeing the greatest reductions in the earlier parts of the Six-Year Plan.
    • 00:17:20
      Conversely, House Bill 2313 was this ramp-up that the revenue started low and would rise over the preceding six years.
    • 00:17:30
      You have these things kind of working against each other.
    • 00:17:33
      You started out with low revenues that were growing, and in this case we're taking the biggest hit to the program early on now.
    • 00:17:42
      Laura and John and her folks have been doing a lot of hard work balancing and making things, moving things around as well as the programming staff.
    • 00:17:50
      But it's important to note that this $209 million you see that well over half is in the first year.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:17:59
      Yes, just one quick one.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:01
      It'd be interesting if we had left, if we had not had 2313, where would we be?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:18:09
      Yeah, we'd be a lot worse off.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:18:12
      We'd be interesting to see exactly what that would impact.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:18:14
      But two things to Charlie's comment.
    • 00:18:16
      One is that the likelihood of revisions in future years if the trend continues is obviously high.
    • 00:18:26
      Because I have to suspect the initial projections, what we don't suspect, we now know, are unrealistically high of global money. So, the second is, and we're going to get to that in the next presentation, this directly impacts the monies available for House Bill 2, the prioritization process.
    • 00:18:46
      We'll get into that because those are the monies that would go into this and if they're reduced because of the transition we're in in the early years, I mean those monies are obligated.
    • 00:19:00
      So the point is that virtually we're getting to the point if there are new projects, that means something has to come off another project.
    • 00:19:09
      There is, you know, our capacity pretty much is used up.
    • 00:19:14
      The only real monies left to make significant decisions are in Northern Virginia and Hampton County and the regionals.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:25
      Can I ask a question about that?
    • 00:19:28
      I was going to wait a few slides and see it coming up.
    • 00:19:31
      The Northern Virginia and Hampton Road Regional monies, is that all construction money or is there any, does that help us any with crossover or not?
    • 00:19:39
      Does not.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:19:40
      It does not impact the state monies at all.
    • 00:19:42
      Is that in code or is that in practice?
    • 00:19:46
      It's in law.
    • 00:19:47
      It was intended not to supplant their statewide allocation.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:52
      So as they build more
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:19:54
      McPherson Jr., John C. McPherson Jr., John C. McPherson Jr., John C.
    • 00:20:24
      both the way was, that's fiercely guarded because in fact that's why the monies are separated so that that region can determine that it was not being negatively impacted because the additional monies they raise, these are not, these are additional monies in the areas.
    • 00:20:41
      So they are fiercely in addition to the law.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:44
      I'm sure but we've just established monies funded for them.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:20:50
      They can stay what?
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:52
      I want to say, do you realize those monies are always raised in those regions?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:21:01
      But that's always right.
    • 00:21:04
      I mean, we continue to see the reductions in the current years, and yet the after years are still being projected as, you know, I have no confidence that we won't be back here again.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:15
      Well, in truth, it's not really true.
    • 00:21:16
      I mean, because we don't have that possibility to be built yet to the maintenance.
    • 00:21:20
      I mean, you're talking years in the future.
    • 00:21:23
      That's right.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:21:24
      P. Griswold, John F. C.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:21:41
      Thank you.
    • 00:21:42
      Slide eight just provides a preliminary snapshot of what the revenue picture looks like with these adjustments as well as some agency actions that we've taken in order to help ensure that we have as much money going to construction and maintenance as possible.
    • 00:21:59
      The total of the revenue reductions as well as the adjustments that we've made is a $41.7 million impact over the six years compared to what you approved in June.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:22:11
      This budget doesn't include in our planning the marketplace fairness.
    • 00:22:19
      It doesn't include the increase in the wholesale price of tech.
    • 00:22:24
      So is that already embedded in this budget?
    • 00:22:26
      It's not as if we could expect more money coming in.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:22:29
      No, what it does is it replaces, in other words, but the real hit will be to
    • 00:22:35
      S. Mitchell's Department, because the way the monies come through on marketplace equity, more were designated to transit as they flowed through the normal formulas, less gets allocated to transit.
    • 00:22:55
      We have a significant fiscal funding clip for transit in 2017 unless we're able to replace it working on legislation for reauthorization of CBR bonds and different things.
    • 00:23:07
      But that would have been a very positive thing for transit had the Marketplace Act with the Act.
    • 00:23:16
      You guys probably know as well, we had little chance of that passing.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:23:25
      Slide 9 provides you a picture of the preliminary allocations of the impacts of the revenue adjustments as well as adjustments that we've made.
    • 00:23:33
      Highlighted are maintenance and operations, rail and public transportation, and construction.
    • 00:23:39
      The slight change in maintenance is really just an administrative item that we set aside for potential employee benefits that did not come to fruition in the biennial budget, and so those dollars were removed.
    • 00:23:49
      Otherwise, the maintenance would continue to be fully funded as expected.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:55
      Yes, a question.
    • 00:23:58
      All of us in the next 30 to 45 days are going to be having public hearings on a six-year plan.
    • 00:24:06
      I think it would be appropriate, and I don't know how we go about this, but to make sure that the comment from the public is aware of what we're faced with, as opposed to them coming in with a grander wish list that there needs to be a serious dose of reality.
    • 00:24:24
      I don't know if it's the night of the meeting where we get that out through the districts and through a public awareness effort, but I think it should be done.
    • 00:24:34
      I don't want to be sitting there until October 16th, you know, hearing about do this and do that, and they don't know about what the reality is.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:24:45
      We have a press release, I've noticed there's no press here today, or whatever there were, because we want to highlight a couple things, but we'll have a press release about the meeting, but highlighting this, and I don't know if Laura's going to get into it, but
    • 00:25:04
      VDOT and DRPT and the transportation agencies are participating along with other state agencies in reducing their administrative budgets five percent this fiscal year and seven percent next fiscal year.
    • 00:25:20
      Now in our case, that means the monies go back into programs.
    • 00:25:26
      A. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:25:43
      again the money stayed within the six-year plan it's just that our administrative fees have been cut in that regard.
    • 00:25:51
      But we wanted to highlight that too because with our declining revenue of course as you know their budgets are based on a percentage of the revenue so their budgets go down anyway from overhead.
    • 00:26:02
      and the administration of the revenues go down.
    • 00:26:05
      In addition to those, we're actually looking at other things to help cushion the blow of some of these monies going to the general fund.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:26:17
      Yes, sir, I will get into that briefly.
    • 00:26:19
      While the impact of the current year adjustment is made in these numbers, we need a little more time to implement the 7% and 16 and we'll have those done in the 16 through 21
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:31
      F. Kennedy Jr., John F. Kennedy Jr., John F. Kennedy Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:26:55
      and they'll be provided as part of the biennial budget process and we can make those available to them in December but I don't get any indication that tax will provide that any sooner.
    • 00:27:06
      But thank you for asking.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:27:11
      I'd like to pick up a little bit on what Mr. Garbinsky said with regard to preparation
    • 00:27:20
      I think we really do need at that meeting at the beginning of that meeting to have a detailed explanation
    • 00:27:40
      Martin, John F. Kasprowicz Jr., John M. Martin, John M. Martin, John M. Martin,
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:28:01
      And I think it's also important to get that message out because we've pointed out that our General Assembly friends will continue to look our way.
    • 00:28:24
      And that's why we've been pretty vocal in these budgets about
    • 00:28:32
      W. W.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:28:47
      Slide 10 provides a preliminary look at the revised budget for the Commonwealth Transportation Fund.
    • 00:28:55
      We'll have this for your consideration at your November meeting when you are also reviewing the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:02
      That meeting, one thing that might be helpful here is to show the revenue here versus the revenue we had planned on and then the allocations here versus the allocations we had planned on.
    • 00:29:16
      So we can see exactly what categories and where, for example, if this crossover in the construction activity is going to be hit not just by the amount of reduction but by crossover too.
    • 00:29:27
      So it would be interesting to see what
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:29:29
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 00:29:49
      McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:30:14
      So the shift focus just to VDOT, we've taken some internal actions to mitigate the reductions that would be experienced in the construction program.
    • 00:30:22
      We have released some previous committed funds.
    • 00:30:25
      Those are balances available from FY14 that would generally be brought forward into 15 per use, the largest share being in information technology.
    • 00:30:34
      We also apply a reduction to our admin programs in the current fiscal year based on the share of the reduction.
    • 00:30:41
      So in construction management, which is a small component of our construction program that's used to support the administrative arm of construction,
    • 00:30:49
      It's a 0.6% reduction in an administration, 5.6%.
    • 00:30:54
      The combined reductions equate to 7% in the current year, and these are also in addition to everything that we brought forward for the snow revision that we made in April of last spring.
    • 00:31:07
      There were some significant sacrifices in order to sweep the corners and ensure that we could deploy every available resource for maintenance activities.
    • 00:31:17
      We also reduced amounts in 15.
    • 00:31:20
      Those reductions, as you'll see in the table at the bottom, those grow.
    • 00:31:24
      They affect the base, and so they will affect the subsequent five years in the six-year window.
    • 00:31:30
      So, in total, we have identified $37.5 million over the six years.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:31:37
      So Laura, what do we have, or maybe Charlie I have a question for you, what do we have in these fiscal years up for snow?
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:46
      What have we budgeted?
    • 00:31:48
      We spent $350 last year.
    • 00:31:49
      What have we budgeted this year?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:50
      Laura, maybe I thought it was approximately $150 and I see the chief engineer's back there, that outright was $150.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:57
      Off the top of my head it's $157, $160.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:32:01
      So, the weather forecast is to have a similar weather
    • 00:32:06
      W. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:21
      Well, Mr. Chairman, one of the things we talked about last year was I guess one day when we found that unicorn thing, we got plenty of money and we don't have to worry about this, but we ought to be banking some of that money so that we smooth those peaks and valleys out.
    • 00:32:40
      And I understand that was done before, and the previous board of administrations decided that they were in a tough spot and they would spend every minute of their handling.
    • 00:32:51
      Which I understand, because I think we might be in a situation where there's a lot of danger in making money.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:57
      We sort of do that, and I'll let Charlie explain how we do it.
    • 00:33:00
      We do, one of the things that Aaron and his team have been working on is trying to
    • 00:33:08
      I'll probably pull back on some potential range-related projects until we get a better view of things around February.
    • 00:33:17
      By February you get a pretty good picture, in you get a big storm in late February, in March it goes away pretty quick.
    • 00:33:24
      So we're looking at the potential of holding some
    • 00:33:30
      Martin, John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin Jr., John M. Martin
    • 00:33:54
      B. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:34:14
      I mean, a reserve that's notated, these projects won't be left until we know where we're headed.
    • 00:34:24
      Because we thought about that, about putting a reserve, but the problem is with everybody going through looking at our monies, we were afraid that would make the use of a car again.
    • 00:34:37
      That's exactly right.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:34:43
      So as the Secretary mentioned earlier, I'd like to briefly address crossover so that you understand the chainness that we've experienced and what crossover was expected to be.
    • 00:34:54
      Before House Bill 2313, in the program that was 13 for fiscal year 18, crossover was well over $450 million by the end of the six-year window.
    • 00:35:08
      St. Paul, P.A.
    • 00:35:15
      House Bill
    • 00:35:29
      In the program that you adopted this past June, as well as with the December 13 revenue updates, the last time we'd gotten state revenue projections, crossover was greater and returned and never went away again.
    • 00:35:43
      And with the current adjustments that we've made, because we deployed some additional federal resources in the maintenance programs, crossover does dip slightly in the first year.
    • 00:35:54
      However, it returns and now it's slightly more than it was projected to be in June.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:00
      I think folks understand the term crossover.
    • 00:36:04
      Very fundamentally, we're taking funds from the Transportation Trust Fund, the construction side, we're transferring them to the maintenance side, and we grow maintenance each year at TPI, so that's the rate of inflation that we apply.
    • 00:36:21
      to the main program each year. Now that doesn't really talk in future meetings, we'll be talking about infrastructure preservation and some of the needs that we have. We call them infrastructure preservation or capital replacement, not capacity improvement, but replacement for systems. And we'll be talking in future meetings about some of the steps that we're taking to ensure that we're not seeing that clip either. In other words, we're not, we're not...
    • 00:36:50
      Rejuvenating and bringing and extending the life of our, we have to extend the life of our facilities.
    • 00:36:56
      We'll be talking about that in the future.
    • 00:36:58
      But again, what this does is, as Laura said, crossover does not go away.
    • 00:37:05
      And it's not projected to ever go away at this point because of the ongoing maintenance.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:37:13
      EPI is pretty low.
    • 00:37:16
      So you can see our revenues are very issue.
    • 00:37:19
      And for Mr. Fralin's point, as we continue to add to the network, that will increase the burden on maintenance.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:37:32
      So after we consider what we've done internally at VDOT, to summarize, the impact to VDOT over the six years is $167 million, of which 118 or so is in fiscal year 15, the current year that we're in today.
    • 00:37:47
      With the actions that we took internally to mitigate those reductions, we were able to find $37.5 million over the six years, about 23 of that being in year one.
    • 00:37:57
      So the impact to what's available for the CTB alternative formula for distribution and construction is $129.5 million over the six years, the greatest impact being in the current year of just over $95 million.
    • 00:38:15
      The table at the bottom of the slide just summarizes what those dollars looked like in June when you adopted the six-year program, the reductions across the six years, and then the total of what's still continuing to be available for distribution.
    • 00:38:30
      You can see the largest impact, of course, is in year one, and the impacts are smaller in the out years.
    • 00:38:39
      And this last slide just gives you a preliminary outlook of what our VDOT budget will look like with the impacts as I've described them today and the total reduction in cost of programs from an allocation perspective is $66 million.
    • 00:38:52
      And I'll be happy to take any additional questions you might have.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:57
      At the bottom, the increase in support to other agencies, that was actually the $30 million transfer that you talked about at the very beginning.
    • 00:39:08
      That's why it shows we're increasing the support to other agencies.
    • 00:39:12
      That was the budget action that occurred a couple of months ago.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:39:20
      O. I'm not sure I understand the question.
    • 00:39:38
      In addition to what they're suggesting, I think we have to have a remedial sort of program to educate our constituents about HB 2313 and the various revenues.
    • 00:39:51
      that supported me and how my revenues, my economy, my taxes, and my family were affected.
    • 00:40:02
      I mean, if repealing the hybrid tax would take us down $1,500,000, I guarantee you that these two gentlemen can speak more expertly than I can.
    • 00:40:10
      There's going to be, I imagine, a bill in the next session and we're going to work here.
    • 00:40:16
      The gas fund will be laying against us.
    • 00:40:18
      I think this is going to probably have just four.
    • 00:40:24
      I think they may have a very good chance of passing.
    • 00:40:26
      I just think we need to educate people.
    • 00:40:30
      Because what I'm hearing in my district, I think they're pondering where everyone comes out, and people are saying, I'm not going to vote for it, but 2313 took care of transportation.
    • 00:40:41
      And even on its, probably its best if 2313 didn't take care of all our funding.
    • 00:40:44
      And so now, I think they're going to have this mixed message and be very angry when some of these properties aren't being funded.
    • 00:40:53
      So, I'd like to take us back a little bit further.
    • 00:40:59
      I don't have a tutorial for you.
    • 00:41:00
      In my ear, it's fine to open them.
    • 00:41:01
      I'm flat-footed, 8 foot 4 inch, now 23-13 inches.
    • 00:41:05
      Some of these actions have been refreshed me a little bit.
    • 00:41:10
      I think we just need to go back and educate people about how transportation works and how transportation finally works in the state of Virginia.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:41:17
      I've been on the board for five years, and if you're successful in that, we'll support you.
    • 00:41:25
      I'm not trying to be pessimistic, but I think it is really a matter of people are paying more taxes than what it is.
    • 00:41:34
      I have found that we have done that extensively and will continue to do it.
    • 00:41:40
      I'm not trying to be pessimistic, but all they know is that they are paying more taxes.
    • 00:41:46
      I'm with you.
    • 00:41:55
      I'm all about that.
    • 00:42:01
      I do it.
    • 00:42:02
      But I think we've got a very big job ahead of us.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:42:06
      Oh, I don't disagree.
    • 00:42:07
      I think it's continuous.
    • 00:42:10
      I don't even quit.
    • 00:42:11
      I do things that people are going to have to realize.
    • 00:42:15
      You know, what the state of reality is, as far as transportation is concerned.
    • 00:42:22
      And if I frankly, if we want to do something in our area, we've got total authority.
    • 00:42:26
      We've got total authority in the past, you know, something a couple of years ago.
    • 00:42:32
      We might want to dust that off.
    • 00:42:33
      I don't know.
    • 00:42:36
      We might want to look at other ways to fix our district problem, our regional problem, rather than waiting richly for anything to happen.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:42:45
      I think that is the message is that and Northern Virginia seems to be further ahead as localities planning in their budgets for transportation I think that's really the message because either at the federal or state level I don't see any more increases in transportation at the state level for a long time and I do believe we'll continue to get
    • 00:43:11
      We will get this out.
    • 00:43:16
      We'll hear you loud and clear.
    • 00:43:18
      We have been doing that.
    • 00:43:21
      Nick Donohue's in the back.
    • 00:43:24
      I know he's met many times with legislators explaining them, particularly in the impact of House Bill 2.
    • 00:43:32
      When we get into that presentation, you're going to see there's not a whole lot of money left.
    • 00:43:36
      For that, because that's what they are under the impression, oh gosh, all these projects were promised to get the votes done? And so there's a perception out there that all these projects are going to be flowing through and all this money is coming in. At its best state, it was going to be revenue neutral at the state level.
    • 00:44:00
      And it's, you know, at the regional level, that's where the big two, you know, North Virginia, Hampton Roads, that's where you look at House Call 2313, that's where the only increases will have been.
    • 00:44:12
      Statewide revenues are about even with where they would have been before, particularly now with these reductions.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:20
      Chairman, taking what I was saying a step further, some of the other words that I've been on,
    • 00:44:27
      Those in leadership positions and unclassified, all of our at-large and district representatives in that case, it might be beneficial for us to have talking points.
    • 00:44:41
      And they could be tailored to district, but general talking points about what's just happened, so that we're all singing from the same songbook, telling the same story,
    • 00:44:52
      I think it's a very important point of how these cuts and reductions in revenue have impacted us and where they are.
    • 00:44:59
      I found that in the past to be very useful as a speaking from a leadership position to have those talking points and they're kind of unified across the CTB.
    • 00:45:15
      I know, I personally would like to see it.
    • 00:45:24
      I'm assuming that the fraud vault says that the crossover calculations are using the same revenue updates that we talked about earlier in your presentation.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:45:35
      But would it be fair to classify that as kind of a best case scenario as forecast?
    • 00:45:44
      Hey, based on where we've been going, I don't see them, well, as you act, but I don't see we're going to get an estimate that's going to freeze right away. In understanding that, is anyone taking a look to say, where is the crossover? likely to be a more realistic picture. Just trying to understand based on where we had been in 2013-18.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:46:13
      Sure.
    • 00:46:15
      It's important to point out in this August update that we got from the Department of Taxation, they did not touch fuel tax estimates and recent activity.
    • 00:46:24
      I just reviewed August activity this morning and fuel tax estimates, the collections are down.
    • 00:46:30
      whether we see that in the December update or not has yet to be determined.
    • 00:46:37
      We haven't made our own assumptions about where state revenue is going to determine what crossover would look like later on.
    • 00:46:44
      We generally just rely on the taxation estimate and try to balance the books as best as possible.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:46:52
      So we could accept politically puts VDOT in a pretty tough situation that you say we don't believe with
    • 00:47:00
      E. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:47:23
      Withholdings on last year's withholdings, which saw a half a million dollar increase go up. Why? Because of the increased tax at the federal level. People sold their businesses and those withholdings that came due this time a year ago were being paid. While we would ever base our future on that one anomaly going forward, that's another question we have to ask taxation.
    • 00:47:49
      But now we've reverted back to where we were before everybody took that action to offset what was anticipated with the capital gain taxes going up.
    • 00:47:59
      So, Roger, I agree with anybody that thought that would have been a sustainable level. I don't know how politics get involved in those past minutes. I don't know how that all works. I'm sorry. Thanks for that.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:48:24
      I've been looking through the 95 million that you had in your highlights.
    • 00:48:30
      Could you identify exactly where is that in the numbers that we see at the end of the day?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:48:40
      In the table at the top, the impact of VDOT in the first year, it is just shy of $118 million.
    • 00:48:49
      Okay, that's the 95.
    • 00:48:50
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:48:51
      Once we identify the 22.6, then the 95.4 is the first year impact.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:48:57
      But in the next slide, we are showing a decrease of $66 million.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:49:05
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:49:06
      That's based on some ins and outs.
    • 00:49:09
      So, I'll highlight the third row into the VDOT programs, Highway System Acquisition and Construction.
    • 00:49:15
      The $95.4 million is a component of that $100.8 million.
    • 00:49:20
      The remaining difference is accounts receivable revenue that we were expecting from the Port Authority related to the Route 460 project.
    • 00:49:29
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:49:49
      Those support to other agencies are mandated by law, in other words, their legislations to say an X percentage of revenues goes to anything.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:50:01
      Mr. Chairman, I just want to follow up on what Gary said about the talking points, but also from a timing perspective, but just to get on the radar screen, in Northern Virginia, one of the things we're actively engaged in right now is the development of a capital funding fund that involves all the various jurisdictions.
    • 00:50:26
      The timing on that is critical because it went back to the McDonough plan that the model had as far as planning and calling jail cars for the actual system.
    • 00:50:41
      We need to be able to identify problems by August of next year up there in that agreement.
    • 00:50:45
      And so to an extent, we've got this financial situation that we need to be connected with others.
    • 00:50:48
      That's a fact, because I know you're supposed to come down and repeat it too.
    • 00:50:52
      I just want to come up and talk a little bit about that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:50:54
      They are, and we'll get to talking for it, but the fact of that matter is, unless we're going to get CT or on reauthorization or some other thing, it's going to be hard to momentum where it needs to help to get that done.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:13
      Okay, let's go.
    • 00:51:14
      If you think about it for a team of 200,
    • 00:51:16
      On fiscal year 2016, we go from $95 million to $2 million.
    • 00:51:23
      That I assume presupposes that we get paid back from $15 million.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:51:27
      Yes, the 30 million coming back to us in the end.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:33
      We accept it.
    • 00:51:34
      In terms of our budget, we put it in there, but we also understand that that 30 million likely will come up in this upcoming session.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:45
      I think that, I don't know if my other ex-general is going to talk too briefly, but we've got to be a little bit careful about
    • 00:51:58
      McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson Jr.,
    • 00:52:15
      I think that will resonate, and I think they're two different issues.
    • 00:52:23
      And I don't know if our revenue estimates going forward into 17-18 and 19 included in flavor for the gas tax or not, or whether they presuppose a static level, but I understand that that is, you know,
    • 00:52:44
      Dababable about where that's going to be?
    • 00:52:47
      Probably unpredictable?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:52:48
      The good thing is about the point that there wasn't.
    • 00:52:50
      And that's what we projected before.
    • 00:52:53
      Okay.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:53
      So, I think when we go to the General Assembly, we can say these are the numbers as they look now, they might look better.
    • 00:53:01
      Because I agree, there's not going to be any fixes.
    • 00:53:03
      Nobody will come in and say, you know, we can't take them.
    • 00:53:05
      So, we've got to live with these numbers for the future.
    • 00:53:09
      So we need liberty, but you can't.
    • 00:53:13
      If you take the money back, you just took a tough vote to take money and give it to somebody else.
    • 00:53:19
      That doesn't make any sense.
    • 00:53:21
      The biggest barrier to ever breaking the tax clause, the naysayers, saying you're going to divert the money from the general fund.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:53:28
      As soon as you get it, we're like, no, we're going to do this, we're going to have a house, we're just going to do it.
    • 00:53:32
      First year out of this year. And unfortunately, I know some good, honest people sitting in the room and they had to work this out, work it out. Unfortunately, they're happy about it. I'm sure it's not balanced, but it's... Well, what we do, to Mr. Connors' point, is we do, what we try to do to make the motion, we just say, these are the consequences. I mean, in other words, this is the consequences. But the issue that came up then, one of, well, this project needs to be done before that project.
    • 00:53:59
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:18
      At least partially because of the reduction in the revenue that we had anticipated because of the budgetary of what your euthanism was for.
    • 00:54:26
      It was very, very close.
    • 00:54:29
      The budgetary rate as well.
    • 00:54:31
      These are the projects in the Salem District, for example, that we had scheduled to start preliminary engineering on that we're now not going to do that.
    • 00:54:45
      And for a legislator to see
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:54:49
      actual stuff like that. I mean, I think we're gonna take the truth. Well, let's get into the next president. Because I think that I think that's gonna that that comment, right? I don't cut this off at all. I mean, that's you're right. That's what we're gonna get in.
    • 00:55:12
      Well, we might deal with it sooner than later.
    • 00:55:14
      That's one of the things we'll have to go through with House Bill 2 is we're going to continually get push that no monies are going back to the counties.
    • 00:55:26
      We're continually getting push for that.
    • 00:55:28
      So we've been looking at ways as to how we can help them.
    • 00:55:33
      The first thing is we've got to find out what House Bill 2 is.
    • 00:55:36
      Martin, John F. Kasprowicz Jr., John M. Kasprowicz Jr.,
    • 00:55:58
      I'm just saying that there's going to be some discussion as we go through House Bill 2 and the implications of that.
    • 00:56:09
      So we've got a lot of moving parts now.
    • 00:56:10
      The first thing though is to get House Bill 2 sort of defined of what the impacts are going to be and then we can see how those monies flow back and whether or not there's some other adjustments we want to make into account.
    • 00:56:23
      That would be right, because all these are indications that we're losing flexibility and less and less are going directly back to localities.
    • 00:56:39
      That's right.
    • 00:56:43
      Okay, let's go more here.
    • 00:56:45
      I guess we'll have Charlie come up and suggest this.
    • 00:56:48
      Oh, Steve, Steve.
    • 00:56:49
      I'm sorry, Steve, can you come up a bit?
    • 00:56:52
      Yeah.
    • 00:56:52
      Yeah, more bad news for Aubrey.
    • 00:56:54
      It's your move.
    • 00:56:56
      Okay.
    • 00:56:57
      That's Steve here.
    • 00:56:58
      Thank you.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:56:59
      You got it right, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:57:01
      Unfortunately, more bad news.
    • 00:57:04
      Maybe a little bit of good news at the end.
    • 00:57:07
      But anyway, I'm going to focus on
    • 00:57:11
      The change from HB 2313 with respect to 2015 as compared to the most recent estimates I guess has been talked about previously.
    • 00:57:25
      We have the out years in the six-year program.
    • 00:57:27
      There's a lot of uncertainty over those estimates.
    • 00:57:29
      So I'm really
    • 00:57:31
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:57:50
      To begin with, we'll have a year differential.
    • 00:57:53
      So I'm just going to focus on that one.
    • 00:57:55
      And I'm also going to talk about the change from June, the six-year program we all approved in June, and then the revenue estimate came out in August, and the impact of the six-year program, the revisions we were proposing.
    • 00:58:09
      And then finally, deal with our administrative budget cuts as the chairmen of the program.
    • 00:58:15
      With that said, this is just sort of a high-level slide
    • 00:58:20
      also, percentage impacts, the first bullet there since HB 2313 passed and put that into place in the 14th six-year program back in June of 13.
    • 00:58:35
      So here we are 14 months later and the revenue level and we're anticipating we're 9% below that.
    • 00:58:43
      So that sort of gives the history of we will hopefully be at this point and 14 months later we're almost 10% lower.
    • 00:58:53
      Then for the change from our June six-year program to August we have about a 4%.
    • 00:59:01
      decrease with our revenues that we have to deal with in our program and in the revised program that we're looking to November to take action and that adds up to 13.7 million dollars. In addition to those percentages, and you'll see in the next slide we'll get a little more detail, for 2014 our actual revenue collections were 14.2 million dollars short of the estimates that we base the 14 place. I am the one.
    • 00:59:31
      and actually made allocations based on.
    • 00:59:34
      So we have this $14.2 million shortfall that we're also contending with for 2015 and whatever we're not able to contend with in 2015 will be pushed to 2016.
    • 00:59:46
      And then finally, as the Chairman mentioned earlier, I don't want to dwell on this, but there is uncertainty
    • 00:59:56
      O'Brien Jr., John C. O'Brien Jr., John C.
    • 01:00:16
      So that being said, these next few slides just provide more detail of the actual funding sources and the actual percentage decreases related to those funding sources.
    • 01:00:27
      And this is taken back from June of 2013 when HB 2313 first went into action and then through August.
    • 01:00:37
      And showing those declines.
    • 01:00:38
      And as I said before, it totals 9%.
    • 01:00:40
      And when you add that shortfall, we have 14.
    • 01:00:43
      We're looking at 13% that the revenues are off from where the planned level was.
    • 01:00:52
      And you go through the detail.
    • 01:00:54
      It's across the board.
    • 01:00:56
      I know Laura, in her slides, talked about recordation.
    • 01:01:00
      And you'll see on my next slide, if you look from
    • 01:01:04
      June of 13 to August of 14, recordation looks like it's going up. If you go from June of 14, our six-year program, to August of 14, there's a decrease. And that's just, I think earlier someone alluded to taxation, I think it was the secretary again, alluded to taxation and their estimating process for withholding and using what was done in 13 or 14 to estimate the next year. I think it's something similar that happened with recordation. in the estimates.
    • 01:01:33
      that we used back in June was just grossly off.
    • 01:01:38
      There's no other way to play.
    • 01:01:40
      With that said, you can see the different percentage changes here.
    • 01:01:44
      Vehicle rental has had a significant decrease.
    • 01:01:49
      The HD2313 sales and use taxes are down 7%.
    • 01:01:53
      And then just the special session from 1986, all the blended funding with a lot of gas tax
    • 01:02:02
      V. Miller, purchase taxes and fees.
    • 01:02:07
      You can see those are well off too.
    • 01:02:09
      This next slide takes just the 45-day window from June to August 15th's new estimates.
    • 01:02:20
      And for our six-year program, we need to address this $13.7 million loss of revenue.
    • 01:02:28
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 01:02:45
      We're going to deal with that shortfall throughout this year.
    • 01:02:49
      As we talked about numerous times, our program has numerous grants, numerous projects with outside partners.
    • 01:02:57
      A lot of times those projects come in under the balance that we've allocated.
    • 01:03:01
      So throughout the year we're finishing projects and balances become available.
    • 01:03:07
      So our first hope of that $14.2 million is during 2015 some balances will become available and those will be used to address this shortfall.
    • 01:03:19
      The next step in the process of dealing with that is to take the shortfall from the prior year to the next six-year program that we perform.
    • 01:03:29
      Whatever balance we don't cover, we push to the 2016 revenue estimates, so I think a message I wanted to get out here was that I think 2016 is going to be worse than 2015.
    • 01:03:43
      I think we're going to have a declining operating share.
    • 01:03:46
      We're probably maybe looking at potential declining capital share.
    • 01:03:51
      which is unfortunate because when the 2313 revenues came in we went through our piss-back process and we tried to set up a percentage of the capital that were level that people could rely on those and plan.
    • 01:04:06
      Our partners could plan out for years and unfortunately with these revenue reductions it's looking like we can't get back that stability that was looked for.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:04:18
      Just to remind you all, the way that we distribute funds is a little bit different from VDOT in that we give out our money to others and to transit agencies and so right now they're all in the process of developing their own budgets for next year and so we are trying to get the word out as much as we can that next year is going to be worse most likely than it is this year although we don't have any revenue
    • 01:04:43
      We'll talk a little bit about this later when we get to the operating formula, but it ties our hands a little bit in terms of the options that we have available to mitigate some of these.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:05:02
      So with that, I guess I'm going to move into the second area, which is the impact on the current six-year program, the 2015 part of our program, which we talked about $13.7 million.
    • 01:05:14
      And in this slide details the different programs within the DRPT agency that are impacted.
    • 01:05:22
      And as you can see, the largest impact is transit operations.
    • 01:05:27
      And I'm going to touch more on that in a slide or two.
    • 01:05:32
      I guess from here I think the other thing I wanted to mention was our capital transit capital transit special programs and our rail programs those changes are small enough that between
    • 01:05:45
      May, when we cut off for the June Six-Year Program, and it's the end of August, we've had enough unobligated funds come available that we can use those balances from projects that ended with funds remaining to cover those items.
    • 01:06:03
      And then finally,
    • 01:06:05
      The Transit Reserve, which is similar, Mr. Fralin, you talked about having a reserve balance.
    • 01:06:12
      That was the idea just a year and a half ago that we were going to establish this reserve to help us when we had these bad times to continue at the funding levels that we had put out there to our grantees or partners.
    • 01:06:28
      Unfortunately, a lot of that reserve is going to probably have to be used to cover the shortfall from 2014.
    • 01:06:35
      The reserve is only $3 million currently, and we're going to add $3 more million in 2015.
    • 01:06:43
      Obviously, that doesn't even cover the whole shortfall.
    • 01:06:47
      Great theory, but when revenues decline, it doesn't help a whole lot.
    • 01:06:53
      And finally, the last thing, the project management budget file, I'll get to that at the very end of my presentation.
    • 01:06:58
      The next slide takes that same $13.7 million and it breaks it down to the different actions that we're going to implement in the revised six-year program.
    • 01:07:10
      And as I spoke of in the previous slide, we have the obligated balances that are in a
    • 01:07:14
      B. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 01:07:23
      So if the revenues have declined, the transit reserve by default has to decline.
    • 01:07:28
      The amount we can set aside for that reserve has to decline.
    • 01:07:32
      That's the point six.
    • 01:07:34
      For that, I just want to go now into the operating impact because this is really kind of a major item with respect to 2015.
    • 01:07:44
      We did find the $1.6 million of deobligated balances from projects that helped with the $9.7 million, but the other $8.1 million
    • 01:07:53
      You know, we need y'all to take special action.
    • 01:07:57
      It's special action that's allowed in the Code of Virginia.
    • 01:08:01
      And basically what that special action will do is it allows you to take our Mass Transit Trust funds are divided between operating capital and special.
    • 01:08:12
      72% operating, 25% to capital, 3% to our special programs.
    • 01:08:17
      And that's code stipulated.
    • 01:08:19
      However, the italics here is in the code also that allows you all to find special need to take some of that capital allocation and move it to operation.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:08:31
      What the issue is, you guys, is that you don't want to ask the operators to pass the bill.
    • 01:08:37
      You have the ability to take the capital, have the ability to sit and go back to the overall, give you operations, give us money back.
    • 01:08:44
      We don't think that's fair.
    • 01:08:45
      So they're asking you to take $8 million of transfer from the capital to operate.
    • 01:08:51
      It's just cutting through, but that's really what we don't have to go ask people back.
    • 01:08:56
      The beginning of the year, they looked and say, this is going to be the percentage we can give you.
    • 01:09:00
      Everybody made their budgets.
    • 01:09:01
      We didn't think it was fair to go back and ask and put the money back.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:09:05
      Well, it's actually a very similar process in terms of having to transfer capital operating.
    • 01:09:14
      We do expect, this is just for this year, there will be additional impacts for next year as well.
    • 01:09:19
      I do want to point out that many of you have heard and seen presentations on our Capital Cliff.
    • 01:09:24
      This does bring that capital clip just a little bit closer, so it doesn't help in our overall capital situation, but this year we will think it's the most prudent alternative to mitigate.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:38
      Just to read it.
    • 01:09:40
      Jen, to follow up on that, I understand doing it this year because we've given out new
    • 01:09:47
      Allecated the money to the different transit agencies locally.
    • 01:09:53
      For next year, are you telling them that the numbers are not going to be what they were so they can plan accordingly and not be back here asking for another special allocation next year?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:10:07
      Yes, we are, and just to remind everybody how we allocate our funds are essentially, we do it by formula, and there's new performance-based aspects of it, but essentially everybody gets the same percentage match across the board.
    • 01:10:26
      So what will happen next year is that the percentage load that they're going to get is actually going to go down.
    • 01:10:31
      So they need to be able to plan for that because they need to fill the gap with local funds.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:10:37
      I just wanted to follow up, so if we were to transfer the capital funds to Aubrey, does, so we're not actually cutting particular projects when we do it, we're just cutting across the board the percentage that we would be contributing to them?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:56
      Actually, if you look at the last bullet, we're going to transfer mass transit, trust fund capital.
    • 01:11:04
      K. Kasprowicz Jr., John K. Matney,
    • 01:11:14
      So it's really just a shift of funding.
    • 01:11:15
      We're not going to reduce anybody's capital projects.
    • 01:11:18
      It's really what Jennifer said.
    • 01:11:19
      It's moving forward or cliff.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:11:22
      It does reduce the amount of capital funding available in labor years.
    • 01:11:27
      For projects that we know are coming.
    • 01:11:30
      And for capital needs that we know exist.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:11:33
      But the immediate impact is not that certain projects will be cut.
    • 01:11:36
      It's a matter of human capital.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:11:38
      So hopefully in the future we lost an opportunity to fund something in the future.
    • 01:11:42
      A.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:11:44
      B. C.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:12:02
      is a big topic.
    • 01:12:05
      The localities are choosing to not fund it, reduce the funding.
    • 01:12:10
      And so that's one of the reasons why they've proved not to do it this year.
    • 01:12:16
      But transit funding is an issue
    • 01:12:20
      McPherson Jr., John M. McPherson Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:12:41
      This is a very significant issue for local governments across the state.
    • 01:12:47
      Frankly, it's less of an impact in places like Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads where they have the ability to shift other funds around.
    • 01:12:55
      It's a huge impact in our rural areas and small urban communities where they don't have other sources of revenue to fill this gap.
    • 01:13:04
      We're very concerned that in those areas is where they're really going to start making major service cuts, stop buying new buses, we're going to have the liability issues, safety issues, and that's frankly where we're very concerned.
    • 01:13:19
      It's not just in the big urban areas.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:13:23
      Mr. Chairman, I think one of the issues too when it comes to this is when you talk about the different smaller urban areas, etc., I think the folks who rely on transit in the smaller areas is a different group that relies on it, say Northern Virginia, just taking mass transit to work.
    • 01:13:42
      So this has been a struggle, I know, for the local bus company around here. I think the locality is subsidizing it to the tune of only a half a year, as is. And it's a constant struggle between cutting peak service, cutting bus routes. And in areas like this, you're having, I mean, it's not just going to get you a game or get somewhere to get to work and get home. Some of those cuts occur because of the trickle-down effect through the economy, too. So, it's...
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:14:11
      S. Whitworth, M.T.P.F.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:14:21
      The Mass Transit Trust Fund, we essentially, as the Director said earlier, we distribute all of those funds.
    • 01:14:27
      Now, from a cash perspective, obviously we put money on capital projects that we don't pay out until the grantee or our partner actually delivers the project.
    • 01:14:37
      So, there's a cash balance, but as far as committed, it's pretty much full commitment.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:14:42
      So the $8 million is already committed that we would have money to pull in from our bonds, etc.
    • 01:14:46
      Correct.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:14:54
      All right, with that, I just did want to touch on the other changes to our six-year program that when we do our revision in November, you'll see there.
    • 01:15:04
      First, on the VRE Potomac Shores project, we had hoped to do some
    • 01:15:11
      We did preliminary engineering work on some platforms involved with that project in our larger Richmond area to Potomac EIS project that you all heard a lot about.
    • 01:15:22
      But unfortunately we weren't able to work that out with the Federal Railroad Administration.
    • 01:15:27
      We've gone back to VRE and CSX and incorporated that work in this project to get that done.
    • 01:15:36
      So that was $143 million more rail enhancement funds.
    • 01:15:40
      And on the rail side, we talked a lot about trains.
    • 01:15:43
      On the rail side, there are some available anomalies and balances.
    • 01:15:48
      Also, on VRE, they had, back in the program in June, they had an expansion rail car purchase item.
    • 01:15:56
      There was just an error in the way they filled out our application and then the way we also read their application in a different area.
    • 01:16:05
      They did actually explain what they were trying to do and so they came to us after the program was out and we worked through that and essentially we needed to get them to the 68% level of capital funding for rolling stock replacement.
    • 01:16:21
      and we're going to use Federal Flex, available Federal Flexible STP funds to make that up to them.
    • 01:16:28
      The Christianburg Park and Ride Line project, don't want to alarm anybody, just want to make sure that it's going to come out of the DRPT Six-Year Program because it's going to be now managed completely by VDOT.
    • 01:16:39
      So the project's still there.
    • 01:16:41
      It's just going to be removed from our program.
    • 01:16:45
      And then finally, the one bit of good news I was mentioning real early on was
    • 01:16:50
      We did recently sign our two-year contract for our regional passenger Amtrak service.
    • 01:16:57
      And compared to the estimates that we were using back in June, our six-year program, we did come in $3.1 million over the six years less in cost for that.
    • 01:17:11
      So one good item that we did actually was to reduce some
    • 01:17:15
      And in other than that, there are minor technical adjustments as far as wording.
    • 01:17:20
      And then, as I've mentioned, we found more on obligated balances.
    • 01:17:23
      So where we detail those out, those numbers are changing.
    • 01:17:26
      But nothing else related to the topics.
    • 01:17:30
      And finally, I just want to speak briefly on our administrative, our project management, our project compliance administrative budget.
    • 01:17:39
      We have, through the Governor's initiative, looked through our budget, including back in June, and we're reducing it by 5%, which is $522,000.
    • 01:17:48
      And what we're going to do is there's certain initiatives that we had hoped to accomplish this year, and we're going to either try to get those done internally,
    • 01:17:59
      reduced the scale of what we're doing and what put them off.
    • 01:18:03
      For instance, we were going to look at our document management system internally, and we just decided to put that project off.
    • 01:18:10
      It's just not quite enough right now.
    • 01:18:13
      The other item, which is about $140,000, was the Appropriation Act, as Ms. Farmer talked about, the Appropriation Act passed after we did the Six-Year Program.
    • 01:18:23
      It passed, I think, June 3rd, it was signed.
    • 01:18:25
      I think June 23rd, I'm sorry.
    • 01:18:27
      Anyway, on June 23rd, that Appropriation Act removed what was in the original budget, a 3% bonus for all the state employees.
    • 01:18:38
      So we had to budget for that bonus when we did the budget back in June that we approved.
    • 01:18:44
      Well, when it was removed June 23rd, now there is not going to be a bonus.
    • 01:18:49
      I think it's going to be November.
    • 01:18:50
      So that $140,000 we're able to remove.
    • 01:18:54
      We also have planned for an additional 2% for 2016 and this last bullet just shows you that in total our budget for the year that we'll come back to you to revise in November for your approval went down by that $500,000.
    • 01:19:13
      With that I'll gladly field any questions.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:21
      Okay, Mr. Chairman, maybe an update on the real run-up project?
    • 01:19:28
      Right down the track here?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:19:32
      So we've been working on the preliminary engineering and
    • 01:19:37
      We have sent over draft plans to the city and we are in the abstract and we're waiting on comments back on that and I believe that we're planning to have a call with everybody in the next week or so just to kind of make sure everyone's on the same date for the design.
    • 01:19:55
      The city is also, we understand
    • 01:19:58
      McPherson Jr.,
    • 01:20:16
      We're hoping that that may even coincide with the timing of the Governor's Conference.
    • 01:20:22
      So there's still a few more approvals that have to occur.
    • 01:20:25
      I think everything is moving forward as planned.
    • 01:20:28
      Probably the one thing we're tracking very closely, as well as the work that the City is doing, is they're responsible for providing the stations for this.
    • 01:20:39
      And I don't know if, Tori, if you know anything else about that.
    • 01:20:41
      But that, I believe, is moving forward.
    • 01:20:42
      I'm not sure what the status is of writing the acquisition on that.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:20:45
      Right now, I think that before the engineering and before the culvert and teamwork occurred, we had to make sure that we would be a precise alignment of the platform.
    • 01:20:55
      So, the city has budgeted several three million dollars in capital plans.
    • 01:21:01
      It was ready that we didn't work.
    • 01:21:03
      It's going to use a similar
    • 01:21:05
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:21:26
      It's scheduled for 2017, so we are always looking at ways to accelerate that, and I know that Norfolk Southern has actually indicated that they're willing to allow us to, once construction of some major key elements are in place, they will be willing to start services ready, perhaps even earlier, but a lot of it, again, will depend on the station.
    • 01:21:51
      We may be able to even start a service without a station, to be honest, but I think
    • 01:21:56
      You know, right now it's still scheduled for 2017, but we hope to accelerate that if we can.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:22:01
      And those are some of the things about staging it, but locations are being identified.
    • 01:22:05
      The issue is does the city want to bring stations where you try to attract a private developer to a parking lot you have and have them build it, and you use the back areas.
    • 01:22:15
      So that's all being worked on right now.
    • 01:22:17
      I would say that the city will be ready whenever the train is ready.
    • 01:22:23
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:22:24
      Martin, Martin, Martin, Martin.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:22:41
      Okay, Mr. Kilpatrick is going to give a fairly short, high level overview of the changes to the picture and the different projects.
    • 01:22:53
      And then after that, we're going to go through some pretty specific items and point out why we need to do the House Bill 2.
    • 01:23:03
      Charlie, the first one for you.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:04
      Thank you.
    • 01:23:06
      As the Secretary just spoke, and as you're all aware, we're getting ready to go into an out-of-cycle update of the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:23:17
      Frankly, these are the reasons.
    • 01:23:19
      We're calling a revision to the 15-20 Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:23:23
      In the past, in the fall, we would have public meetings that solicited input regarding future projects.
    • 01:23:30
      But in this case, this actually is a public hearing process that we've undertaken.
    • 01:23:35
      So why are we doing it?
    • 01:23:36
      We need to transition the full implementation of House Bill 2 by July 1 of 2016.
    • 01:23:42
      And so we're already working through that process.
    • 01:23:45
      We need to make adjustments on revenues available for construction.
    • 01:23:49
      You heard from Laura the adjustments that we know but just yesterday we have some additional information and we'll need to incorporate some of that.
    • 01:23:59
      It is not in the draft updated six-year plan.
    • 01:24:03
      So the draft updated six-year plan which will go out and there are full copies of that do not incorporate the announcement yesterday by the Governor.
    • 01:24:11
      So again we're working through some of that.
    • 01:24:14
      House Bill 2 eligible funds were not added to non-exempt projects.
    • 01:24:17
      I think that's another important point.
    • 01:24:19
      So House Bill 2 funding, it does not change the allocation of funds.
    • 01:24:25
      That discussion came up earlier about the CTB formula, the old 40-30-30 formula.
    • 01:24:31
      House Bill 2 does not address that.
    • 01:24:33
      We recognize that we'll need to look at that and ultimately it will require legislation if there's going to be a change.
    • 01:24:40
      Funds that must be prioritized include state and federal highway funds and the legislation
    • 01:24:46
      McPhee Jr., John M. McPhee Jr., John M. McPhee Jr., John M. McPhee Jr.,
    • 01:25:10
      Again, in terms of the project specifically, they were exempted from prioritization.
    • 01:25:16
      We talked in the previous slide about various fund types that are specifically excluded by code.
    • 01:25:22
      Projects that were fully funded and NEPA complete may be exempted by code.
    • 01:25:28
      And then projects that are asset management in nature, and I would call these capital replacement types of projects were excluded in the legislation from going through prioritization.
    • 01:25:39
      But again, to reinforce, our paving program and our bridge program are clearly, it goes to a data-driven prioritization process.
    • 01:25:47
      We don't simply say, we're gonna pave this amount in this district and this amount in the other.
    • 01:25:52
      It is truly based on the needs.
    • 01:25:56
      Candidate projects.
    • 01:25:58
      Allocations were adjusted on projects in a six-year plan that did not meet the exemption.
    • 01:26:03
      Again, this is so you're gonna see 62 projects
    • 01:26:07
      with a value over the six years of about $416 million.
    • 01:26:13
      The funding available, now you're going to go into an update in next spring.
    • 01:26:19
      You'll add the seventh year will become the sixth year of the plan, and that will likely show a significant amount of money available to go through prioritization, but that money hasn't been allocated at all.
    • 01:26:31
      So while it's $416 over six years,
    • 01:26:34
      We don't have that number for you today.
    • 01:26:37
      It's a pretty sizable amount of money that would come in in year seven that would be available for prioritization.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:26:43
      Well, that's assuming we don't have another reduction in revenue.
    • 01:26:47
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:26:47
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:26:49
      That's what we're projecting now, but seven years in the future.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:54
      And the last bullet, again, how unrealistic that might be, additional revenues, whether it's federal, if the federal government
    • 01:27:03
      takes action to change or increase the funding.
    • 01:27:06
      If just general revenues go up, it actually improves the bucket for House Bill 2 projects.
    • 01:27:16
      The next steps, we have nine hearings over the next about 45 days.
    • 01:27:22
      We begin in Lynchburg and Hampton Roads next week.
    • 01:27:26
      Then you can see how this is going to go through the process and then in November our November meeting we will consider the final six-year plan and I believe that meeting will actually be here probably in the same room in November that's the first day of the Governor's Transportation Conference.
    • 01:27:45
      A couple of takeaways that I heard around the room very important I think are some talking points for members and we will get those together.
    • 01:27:54
      In addition, looking at sending some correspondence to MPOs, counties, cities, towns, reinforcing what we're doing here, as well as giving them realistic expectations regarding funding.
    • 01:28:14
      The other area that I mentioned, we're continuing to work on the adjustments that
    • 01:28:21
      are part of this bill that was actually dropped yesterday in the General Assembly, so we're working on any adjustments that might occur as a result of that action.
    • 01:28:33
      With that, I'd be glad to answer any questions.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:28:39
      Rough numbers, how many?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:44
      About 4,000.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:28:46
      This is $400,000,000 out of a $13,000,000,000 plan.
    • 01:28:53
      So you can see in House Bill 2, while you'll prove it, that's a small piece that will grow in the future, but it's a relatively small piece of the six-year plan.
    • 01:29:06
      So most of the six-year plan goes forward because of what Charlie mentioned, either exemptions or projects that are not meant to disagree.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:18
      So I have this handout here that says HB2 Adjustments in the Salem District.
    • 01:29:23
      Are these the ones that came off the plan?
    • 01:29:26
      Or got put on the plan?
    • 01:29:29
      That's correct.
    • 01:29:30
      It wouldn't be put off, got cut, not taken off.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:29:34
      So what you've seen is that money has been removed so everybody has their list removed.
    • 01:29:42
      And put into a total amount.
    • 01:29:45
      You go to the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:29:48
      We verified yesterday.
    • 01:29:49
      There's $416 million dollars sitting in it.
    • 01:29:53
      And it says, it came off of these projects, and I don't want to talk a little bit about the projects, but it came off of those.
    • 01:30:00
      These projects will go through House Bill 2, and their money may go back on them.
    • 01:30:05
      But that's physically how you'll see it.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:09
      On the Six-Year Improvement Program revised working draft,
    • 01:30:15
      Is there a summary in here that tells me which projects have been recommended to come off?
    • 01:30:25
      Or do I need to go through and look?
    • 01:30:27
      I've got a bunch of things here in the previous allocation, and then I've got zeros and fifteenths.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:30:32
      Does that mean they're not?
    • 01:30:34
      Not necessarily.
    • 01:30:35
      That project list should be the one that you'll now go in there and see in the six-year plan.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:43
      I don't think we didn't create a specific list to remove projects.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:04
      That's more on our, I'll call it a balancing act that we try to do in terms of adjusting when money flows year after year.
    • 01:31:12
      The projects that are subject to House Bill 2 are flagged in your, actually there's a designation for each one of them, but those projects have not been removed from the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:31:22
      The funding has been put into this balance account.
    • 01:31:25
      Those projects still exist in the Six-Year Plan, and what they would show is a balance to complete equal to the amount that was removed.
    • 01:31:33
      Except for, there may be some other projects that the balance to complete was off the end of the Six-Year Plan, but again that's generally how it shows up in the balance to complete area.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:42
      I just think it would be helpful if we had that list instead of having to go through a project or a project throughout last month versus this month.
    • 01:31:51
      If we can generate that list.
    • 01:31:53
      By district.
    • 01:31:55
      Yeah, by district.
    • 01:31:56
      Yes.
    • 01:31:58
      We'll make that happen.
    • 01:32:02
      That's important.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:32:04
      Mr. Malamud.
    • 01:32:07
      Obviously, what I'm hearing is there's real money in now years with construction.
    • 01:32:13
      How does that impact our planning moving forward in terms of when we're updating this plan on a regular basis?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:22
      Well, as I mentioned, year seven, when you all vote next May or June, year seven becomes the last year of the plan.
    • 01:32:33
      Let's say in big numbers, that's about a billion and a half dollars of construction money.
    • 01:32:38
      based on our current revenue forecasting, about a billion and a half worth of projects will come on to the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:32:45
      Some of those are existing projects where it's getting additional funding and some will be new projects.
    • 01:32:51
      So again, in terms of in-the-out years of funding, every year you drop the year you're
    • 01:32:59
      and you add another year and it's about in big numbers by the time you get to year six about a billion and a half dollars that will come on.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:33:08
      But remember you're adding new projects all along so that money's being used up because all along you're adding projects.
    • 01:33:17
      So we'll still be adding projects?
    • 01:33:19
      Yes.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:33:19
      The gap may close with more crossover and lack of funding.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:33:28
      Yes, or how many, let's say we put one of these projects on now, and they say, well that may go into your scheme, that may go out there and use some of that money.
    • 01:33:38
      In other words, so, you know, we're trying to get a pipeline where you see it on this year, and the project's on there, it's been scored, it's defunded, and it doesn't come off.
    • 01:33:49
      So every four years, we don't go through another iteration of something we worked on, but the new governor says, this is not my priority.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:58
      And in general terms, the plan is that the ideal condition of the plan is one where the funding in year six comes on, or year seven comes on to year six and it's doing a combination of finishing out the funding on existing projects and it's adding new projects.
    • 01:34:18
      I think one of the things folks maybe sometimes lose track of when we update the six-year plan, generally speaking, we're not dropping money on year one.
    • 01:34:27
      And so now a new project that comes up all of a sudden doesn't get funded in year one.
    • 01:34:33
      Now that does happen in some cases, in certain types of projects, depending on the type and the type of funding, they do tend to get funded earlier in the six years.
    • 01:34:41
      But kind of over the general program, and this is where I think we need to continue to reinforce to the public, when money comes on, when a project gets funded, a new project
    • 01:34:53
      Traditionally, or under normal conditions I call, the funding will be in the outer years of the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:34:59
      Not that we're going to start design on that project today.
    • 01:35:02
      We've got a new project and in year one, we've got money on it and we're going to start designing and building it.
    • 01:35:08
      That's just not how the program works.
    • 01:35:10
      We're doing a lot of things internally to stabilize this and back to House Bill 2, this will really help us in having a stable platform.
    • 01:35:19
      We've prioritized the projects and we're working the plan.
    • 01:35:23
      Instead of projects coming on and off and on and off, which is very disruptive to our operations.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:32
      So we're rolling out these zeros and it's got previous allocation and it's got zeros all the way through.
    • 01:35:40
      If you don't have an FME, put it this way, it's easy to get a project on a six-year plan.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:35:44
      It's hard to get it funded.
    • 01:35:46
      Yeah, it has been if you don't see it.
    • 01:35:49
      If the next two years didn't have funding, it didn't mean you're going to have it.
    • 01:35:52
      That's right.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:53
      What's the time for bringing these 62 projects back through?
    • 01:36:02
      When and how are they going to happen?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:36:06
      I'm going to defer to my partner here.
    • 01:36:10
      Mr. Chairman, these projects, along with other projects that were solicited from local governments, will be considered in the fall of 2015.
    • 01:36:19
      And then the scores for all of those projects, these 62 and any other that have met the screening process will be brought back to the board as we develop the FY 17 Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 01:36:29
      Would you repeat that please?
    • 01:36:31
      These projects along with other candidate projects that will solicit from local communities will be scored in the fall of 2015.
    • 01:36:38
      After the board has voted on the prioritization process, we'll use that process
    • 01:36:45
      In the fall, we solicit projects, then we're going to evaluate them late winter and early in 2016, a list of projects with their scores using whatever range you all decide on, one to ten, one to a hundred, will be provided to the board.
    • 01:37:00
      We will then discuss the funding that's available for the various projects and the next program for capacity expansion will be based on those scores and the input from you all.
    • 01:37:10
      and all these projects will be projects that will get screened and if they make it through the screening process will then be scored along with any other successful candidate projects at local governments.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:37:24
      Now, it'll be up to you to do what you want to consider to be screening.
    • 01:37:31
      That could be working, where the planning has a screening process.
    • 01:37:35
      So, I mean, it's not just going to be, you know, I don't like that where I can put this.
    • 01:37:39
      I mean, it's going to be a process that you go through, and this board will determine what that process is to screen.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:49
      Mr. Cole?
    • 01:37:51
      Commissioner, is it possible on the HB2 adjustment list to have dollar values assigned?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:37:56
      I know we can calculate it going back through the schedule, but I think it would be helpful just to have a little more column.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:03
      Absolutely, we can do that.
    • 01:38:05
      One of the other things I wanted to reinforce in terms of these projects, we wanted to, I guess a good way to describe it, bring them to a logical point in their development.
    • 01:38:16
      So some of them have some funds left on them.
    • 01:38:20
      What you didn't want to do is just lift the pen off the table if you were in design or in midstream and moving utilities or whatever that might be.
    • 01:38:29
      That again is very disruptive.
    • 01:38:31
      But we wanted to make sure that we didn't proceed on
    • 01:38:36
      Beyond what we would consider just reasonable business until it went through prioritization. So, again, I think it's an important piece. People say, oh, they stopped all work. Well, what we've done is we're bringing it to a, we're stopping the work at a point that makes sense, not just, again, lifting the pen or the paper.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:38:57
      Yeah, it's 400 million out of 13 things.
    • 01:39:00
      I mean, this is not a significant amount today through our construction.
    • 01:39:05
      So I don't want to hear everything.
    • 01:39:08
      I'm with you guys.
    • 01:39:08
      That's what I'm hearing.
    • 01:39:09
      We're starting off construction.
    • 01:39:11
      That's not true.
    • 01:39:12
      Mr. Whitley.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:39:12
      Well, Mr. Chairman, if I could just add to that.
    • 01:39:15
      If you look in the miscellaneous section of the statewide portion of the six-year program, you'll actually see the years in which the funds have come off projects.
    • 01:39:25
      90 plus percent of that funding is in 17 on and so if you actually look at the impacts here the impact from money that was going to be spent in this current fiscal year even the next fiscal year is very low.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:39:38
      What I'd like a little better understanding is the purpose of the public hearing.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:40:07
      Each of these localities will have a public hearing and I assume at that point everyone attending will have seen their respective adjustments.
    • 01:40:23
      And I assume that the purpose of this public hearing is really to address or to allow our constituents to address those specific adjustments.
    • 01:40:35
      Is that correct?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:37
      Yes, I think that the purpose of public hearing, there's some education that needs to go on in terms of our ability to provide information to the public about House Bill 2.
    • 01:40:53
      There's some other things about the broader VTrans update.
    • 01:40:56
      It's about updating people on where we are.
    • 01:40:58
      I think the point here that we do need to do a brief presentation on sort of budget impacts so people understand the table that's set in front of them.
    • 01:41:08
      It does give folks an opportunity to say, I've got these projects that
    • 01:41:13
      We would like you to consider moving forward with the Six Year Plan, but I think again it's important that we reinforce that reality that while a jurisdiction or region may bring forward, I'll call it a new project, it needs to be grounded in the fact that we have very limited resources.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:41:31
      Well, it's that latter part that I think there is, certainly I'm receiving questions on, is we are saying we have a comment period for these proposed drafts and there is an implication that something could change with these things.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:41:53
      That's right.
    • 01:41:53
      Nothing's willing to change.
    • 01:41:54
      The law reports.
    • 01:41:55
      This is law.
    • 01:41:56
      These projects will not go to business.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:41:58
      It's not going to come back with 60 or 58.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:42:02
      Let me talk a little bit about this transition period, because that's what we're getting at.
    • 01:42:13
      This is not us making, this is the law.
    • 01:42:17
      The law says that even if you score it low, you may choose to fund it.
    • 01:42:23
      The law doesn't say you line them up one to a hundred and you line them down.
    • 01:42:27
      It says you score them all
    • 01:42:30
      and then you choose the ones you want this board choose the ones but you explain why you did that so in other words it doesn't mean that you're only going to do the 90s but it says if you do a 40 before you do a 90 you got to explain why you chose to do that so first of all this this fact that well if it scores low it never gets funded that's still your decision that is still the CTB decision
    • 01:43:00
      But that's after you go through HB2.
    • 01:43:02
      That's correct.
    • 01:43:02
      I'm talking about the 62 projects.
    • 01:43:05
      Well, so let me go through that.
    • 01:43:06
      So, what the law says is that they haven't been through defund.
    • 01:43:10
      You know, and they're not under construction, they're not fully funded, they gotta get scored.
    • 01:43:15
      It doesn't say may get scored, it says shall be scored.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:43:19
      And I think that's an important point then.
    • 01:43:22
      These 62 projects were not discretion, at anybody's discretion, they were there.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:43:29
      They were just on a deadline of 35.
    • 01:43:32
      Mr. Chairman, if that is correct, a lot of times when we are developing this process and I was talking to legislators or MPO folks, they say, well, can you tell me exactly what districts these projects are located in?
    • 01:43:42
      Actually, I can't.
    • 01:43:43
      I can tell you the criteria that are being used by staff to identify these projects.
    • 01:43:48
      But candidly, it was just based on whether or not they met certain criteria.
    • 01:43:52
      And those are the ones that were listed by the chairman.
    • 01:43:55
      They are not fully funded.
    • 01:43:56
      not through NEPA and that's why a lot of this money again that you'll see in that holding account is in the outer years because these were projects that aren't currently underway and are in those outer years.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:44:06
      And to me that's the most important thing to communicate at this hearing.
    • 01:44:11
      I mean it would be nice to hear comments, but the fact of the matter is the purpose of this hearing is to communicate over as there are 62 projects here that didn't meet the criteria.
    • 01:44:23
      Not that they were selected by the deputy of transportation,
    • 01:44:26
      because he thought we needed to come up with $400 million.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:32
      Yeah, let me, look, there is, Mr. Brown, I think, I think we've got to be, what, what, what Dickson was saying is, I think, really clear.
    • 01:44:40
      We've got to be really clear about what is coming off because we can't afford it and what's coming off because we're scoring.
    • 01:44:47
      That's got to be really, really clear.
    • 01:44:50
      And, you know, in the purpose of these public hearings,
    • 01:44:54
      You know, I think people are going to look at them as just an extension of what the public hearings we have on the Six-Year Plan every year.
    • 01:44:59
      So, you know, what we do in May and June, you know, whenever we do it.
    • 01:45:03
      And they're going to come in with their wisdom.
    • 01:45:06
      And so we've got to be clear that this is not what this is.
    • 01:45:09
      This is about HB2.
    • 01:45:12
      Now, one thing we could do, if we wanted to, is get public input on what the criteria ought to be under HB2 and how we should weight those six criteria.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:45:23
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:45:44
      We want them to start thinking about what are types of candidate projects they might submit and what are the benefits they think those projects provide so that when we have these hearings and future discussions with them, we can start to understand what they think are beneficial projects and ensure that our measures, to the extent practicable, can capture those types of benefits moving forward there.
    • 01:46:04
      So I do think that would be a helpful discussion to have with the folks at these fall meetings and is one of the things we're hoping to accomplish.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:10
      I just want to be clear what we're going to receive.
    • 01:46:13
      We're going to have this list updated, which is the projects that did not meet the exemptions and have to go through HB2 with dollars assigned to them.
    • 01:46:25
      That's one.
    • 01:46:26
      Number two, we're also going to receive a list by district
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:46:30
      W. Dyer Jr. Jr. Jr.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:55
      I think it's an important point to point out that these are draft proposals by staff of what the Six-Year Plan ought to be.
    • 01:47:06
      We get to vote on that in November, right?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:47:10
      You make the final decision, that's right.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:12
      Now I want to put the final question on my side.
    • 01:47:16
      Does the CTB or the administration going forward have the ability to designate projects that are of statewide significance that supersede HB2 or is everything after HB2?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:47:32
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Garczynski, the way the law has drafted capacity expansion projects regardless of their statewide, regional, or
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:47:41
      O'Brien, John C. O'Brien Jr., John C. O'Brien Jr., John C. O'Brien Jr., John C.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:48:10
      That's what staff talked about earlier, and that gets kind of cut in half if you look at the CTB formula.
    • 01:48:16
      So half of that is for repair projects, and the other half of that is for capacity expansion projects.
    • 01:48:22
      What we, I believe, staff did, and we can confirm this with the list that we can provide to you all in the coming days, is that with regard to the projects that were subject to House Bill 2, that half that had to come out of capacity projects, that list is the same.
    • 01:48:36
      It overlaps completely.
    • 01:48:37
      On the repair side, a lot of what happened was funding in outer years.
    • 01:48:42
      You had projects that were fully funded in the beginning for pavement or bridge rehab, and those are now more stretched out with their funding sources in the years.
    • 01:48:49
      Again, we'll work with staff on that, but I wanted to really explain that for the HB2 list, for that half the money that comes out of capacity projects, those overlap fully.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:59
      Well, that's tricky.
    • 01:49:03
      That's tricky.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:49:03
      That's not my type of script.
    • 01:49:06
      We don't think we took, there's not many, that coming off because of reductions.
    • 01:49:11
      It reduced the pot for, in the out years, for the- I'm just looking through here, I just went through the summary.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:20
      There's some coming down, so maybe I'm not reading that right.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:49:26
      That's what I was getting to.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:28
      There's some $90, $90 that you're basically spending and don't change the six-year plan.
    • 01:49:34
      I don't know how you do that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:49:36
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:49:59
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 01:50:19
      And those are all distributed based on the CTB's tiers that you all agreed upon last year.
    • 01:50:26
      So those funds are not part of each other.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:29
      When I was referring to Jen, you know it's a topical conversation already.
    • 01:50:33
      For instance, funding momentum, which we made a commitment on, or funding the Columbia Pike light rail,
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:50:43
      There's commitments made on those that they're not scored.
    • 01:50:49
      The Columbia Pike is all before 2017, so it doesn't require to be scored.
    • 01:50:56
      Let me just talk to you about the practical issues here.
    • 01:51:01
      Remember, again, the point is the bill says they have to be scored.
    • 01:51:07
      It doesn't say that's what you have to fund.
    • 01:51:10
      The whole purpose of the bill is to say, guys,
    • 01:51:14
      This political process that we've got going on, you know, we need to put in line today why this project gets funded and this one doesn't.
    • 01:51:22
      That's what the real purpose of the bill is.
    • 01:51:25
      You gotta score.
    • 01:51:26
      Let me take Route 630, which seems to be, you know, getting a lot of press now because a former board member and he's out there, how this is a political process.
    • 01:51:36
      June 13 of last year, June the 30th of last year, that project had $50 million, $47 million off.
    • 01:51:44
      Last year, you know, not coming before the board, I mean, after all gets done, 150 million gets transferred to that project, on the project.
    • 01:51:56
      Now, you end up voting on it, but I mean, you know, it's not all vetted out here in the whole, but 150 million gets put, I'm saying it's not a good project.
    • 01:52:04
      But I'm saying, I don't know, not that project is any better than maybe somewhere else, but it's all relevant.
    • 01:52:10
      And then, all those monies are in the out years.
    • 01:52:13
      But then, they have about 10 million on for right-of-way, but it's going to cost about 50 million for right-of-way, but to lock it up, they start buying right-of-way.
    • 01:52:25
      So now, all of a sudden, this is getting a lot of publicity.
    • 01:52:27
      It shouldn't be scored under House Bill 2.
    • 01:52:31
      All we're saying is, why not?
    • 01:52:33
      Why shouldn't it be scored under House Bill 2?
    • 01:52:36
      Now, that's one, that's the way the process sort of worked before.
    • 01:52:42
      about you know everybody would come in and lobby and the whole bit but the issue is is that that may be a great project but we reduced our plan a billion dollars 180 million dollar project we've reduced it a billion dollars and now we have this scoring situation
    • 01:53:00
      that this project would have clearly been under it, except not a special exemption was to buy right away.
    • 01:53:06
      So this didn't come out for political.
    • 01:53:08
      It popped out because it was $150 million transferred right before we're getting ready to do this.
    • 01:53:15
      Now, what we've done is gone back and look at this, and quite frankly, we're going to make a recommendation that we reduce the project from $150 million to about $180 million to $130 million, because the scope of the project
    • 01:53:29
      would not have probably scored well under House Bill 2.
    • 01:53:33
      No, but that's one of the House Bill 2 things is you really get the good bang for your buck.
    • 01:53:38
      So that project, we're going to recommend going forward, but not at the level it was before in that regard.
    • 01:53:45
      Not at the level it was before.
    • 01:53:47
      Notwithstanding all this about everything's supposed to be political.
    • 01:53:50
      That's why we got to do House Bill 2.
    • 01:53:52
      That's what was happening before.
    • 01:53:54
      Why wouldn't you take it back and score it?
    • 01:53:56
      Well, we are going to take it back and score it, but we're going to recommend we fund it.
    • 01:53:59
      We're going to recommend we fund it because the right-of-way started and all that stuff.
    • 01:54:04
      We're going to recommend, but we're going to score it.
    • 01:54:06
      Now I don't know how it's going to, it's probably going to score okay, but we're going to fund it, but we're still going to score.
    • 01:54:12
      We have to score.
    • 01:54:14
      The law requires we have to score in that regard.
    • 01:54:17
      I'll throw in another political thing as it started from the papers.
    • 01:54:21
      The stuff we got on 29.
    • 01:54:24
      Technically, I mean 29 is going to have to be scored.
    • 01:54:26
      We're moving forward with contracts and all.
    • 01:54:29
      It's going to be scored.
    • 01:54:30
      You know, but we thought that, and working through with the board here, we thought that was the best thing to do to leave those money to address something that happened in 40 years.
    • 01:54:39
      So in other words, these people saying, well, you know, this is a political process.
    • 01:54:44
      They're going to be scored.
    • 01:54:44
      We just choose to recommend to you to fund in that regard.
    • 01:54:49
      I'm not going to explain these, because it's transition period.
    • 01:54:51
      I mean, some of these are pretty clear.
    • 01:54:52
      There's nothing coming along for a few years.
    • 01:54:55
      You know, there's really no choice.
    • 01:54:57
      These are some in there.
    • 01:54:58
      The other thing is, we're not going to eliminate Governor's running on platforms, and they say they want light rail somewhere, and he wins the election.
    • 01:55:10
      Well, my guess is that we're still going to get pressure to put that in, in the future, although a lot of them give it up.
    • 01:55:16
      But the issue is, it'll be school.
    • 01:55:19
      It'll be scored.
    • 01:55:20
      It says, well, yeah, this is what we recommended to fund.
    • 01:55:23
      Now, that means you have to fund it.
    • 01:55:25
      So that's the point of this.
    • 01:55:26
      What I'm getting across to you guys is that it doesn't, you make the final decision.
    • 01:55:32
      At the end of the day, you make the final decision.
    • 01:55:36
      But what it says is that when you make that decision, we're going to have, hopefully, some type of consistent scoring process.
    • 01:55:44
      That puts in light a day why that decision was made, not because Senator So-and-so had influence or a CTB member had influence and talked with Charlie and the Secretary into doing something.
    • 01:56:02
      I'm not being critical of them.
    • 01:56:04
      I mean, that's, you know, that's, you know, or getting direction for doing it.
    • 01:56:08
      That's what it is.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:56:09
      So this does not, in fact, it puts more power more than ever in the CTB.
    • 01:56:14
      All it says is, though, is we're trying to put in the light of day how these projects stack up.
    • 01:56:20
      And while we're gonna have a lot of issues about getting the criteria, the main thing is, as long as they're consistently applied, you know, then you have a relativity.
    • 01:56:30
      You know, if they're consistently applied, they may not be exactly right, but your direction will be right.
    • 01:56:36
      That's what House Bill 2 is.
    • 01:56:38
      So, yes, there are some transitional things in here.
    • 01:56:43
      The two that come out are 630 and the 29 projects.
    • 01:56:45
      But they're going to get scored.
    • 01:56:48
      Even though we're going to have to request that they get funded.
    • 01:56:54
      But they're going to get scored.
    • 01:56:56
      That's been getting back to our original conversation about the tightness of the money, why this is so important, because if we fund one, it's necessarily not new money, it's taking something from something else.
    • 01:57:12
      Because all the monies are committed in that. So, you know, I'm not trying to oversimplify the process or what have you, but it's becoming already people are pushing back because they don't like the fact that their project is going through this. It doesn't mean it won't get funded. It means it has to get schools. Chairman will lose 29 contracts to be awarded before we ever even start running. They will because they want the commitments have already been made.
    • 01:57:41
      That was, quite frankly, the governor's decision.
    • 01:57:48
      By the way, that's pretty much it.
    • 01:57:55
      Most governors won't have, from this point forward, they've got to be scored.
    • 01:58:01
      And when I've just talked with you, I've talked to Speaker Howell about it, and I've talked to the Appropriations Chair about it, Chris Jones.
    • 01:58:11
      So they know, before we put this in, they know all of what this is.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:24
      I understand exactly what you're saying Aubrey.
    • 01:58:26
      I think that's 100% correct.
    • 01:58:27
      I also think that if you let me pick the scoring criteria, I can pick the project.
    • 01:58:33
      So we've got to be consistent about it and this board is going to have what I would consider in the history of the Commonwealth Transportation effort an opportunity to set those criteria first.
    • 01:58:49
      If I say they won't be adjusted,
    • 01:58:51
      I'm not clear on what our plan is for when that's going to take place, how we're going to do that, when all this sausage is going to get made, because that's really making the sausage.
    • 01:59:05
      It's not pulling them off.
    • 01:59:08
      It's putting them back on.
    • 01:59:09
      So what are we doing on it?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:59:12
      Dave, do you want to?
    • 01:59:14
      We haven't got a word at the preliminary stages to come to you.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:59:20
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, what we've been doing right now is conducting initial public outreach to all the communities as required by law to really talk about this and understand, get, help them understand how the process is intended to work and get some initial feedback from them on things that they're concerned about or things should be taken into account in the discussion.
    • 01:59:39
      So, for example, some of the issues, and I'll be updating the board at the next meeting in more detail on this, but folks are kind of saying, make sure you don't just look at future conditions.
    • 01:59:48
      As you're quantifying the benefits of projects, make sure you look, or not current conditions, excuse me, that you look into the future, particularly looking at economic development and other benefits that may come.
    • 01:59:57
      In some parts of the state, they're very interested in how would co-funded projects be scored.
    • 02:00:02
      And so right now, we're identifying kind of the list of issues.
    • 02:00:05
      As I talked to the board in May in Charlottesville about, we do have staff working groups moving forward, evaluating different measures.
    • 02:00:13
      And once they've conducted their initial evaluation, we're going to come talk to the board
    • 02:00:17
      about those types of measures so you can provide input on them and explain what we think the benefits and shortcomings are of different measures, but it will be an iterative process.
    • 02:00:26
      So I understand, Mr. Chairman, if you've got all the money to be going on a CTB formula.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:38
      So the CTB formula is going to have a prioritization, and we're going to have disagreements about what that
    • 02:00:47
      Now, also, if there's anybody left over that starts falling through the 40-40-30 formula, each, the way I read the law, each construction district will have its own set of problems.
    • 02:00:59
      For example, the idea was that in Gary's district, it might be congestion, and in John's district, it might be economic development, and they'll be weighted differently.
    • 02:01:08
      So we've gotta have two, if I read the bill right, we've gotta have two weighted priorities.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:01:15
      Mr. Fralin, you're right that there would be if funds fall into the 40 30 30 formula there would be funds prioritized at the construction district level because those primary funds through the funding allocation formula could only be used in that district but even in the CTB formula as we weight the factors in the different areas of the state they're going to be different even though we're going to be comparing projects on a statewide level which is to say there may be a project in your district
    • 02:01:45
      And one of Mr. Garczynski's that both scored an 80, but his got to 80 mostly on congestion and yours got to mostly on safety.
    • 02:01:51
      So the weighting... That's important for people to understand.
    • 02:01:54
      That's right.
    • 02:01:55
      And the weighting would be the same in the primary as well as the statewide level, it's just the allocation of funds would be slightly different.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:02:01
      And you, this board will determine whether it's a rural or it's a urban project.
    • 02:02:07
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., James W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:29
      How you don't make that number one and that's hard to deal with.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:02:35
      It comes off the top.
    • 02:02:37
      Mr. Fralin, we do two things with safety.
    • 02:02:40
      First, there's a specific federal program that was recently doubled in size called the Highway Safety Improvement Program funds and that's about 60 to 70 million annually in the Commonwealth.
    • 02:02:52
      Those funds are exempt and so there's always going to be a rolling set of safety projects
    • 02:02:57
      That are prioritized across the Commonwealth without regard to the House Bill 2 process, and then there are going to be discussions that we're going to have to have as we weigh the different factors for the capacity-expanding projects with regard to how safety is treated vis-a-vis congestion, economic development, and other factors.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:13
      That's a good point, but even at that level, I didn't know about that, but even at that level, there are going to be some projects that are going to be more expensive than that.
    • 02:03:20
      Like, for those of you who are driving back up to 81, the Arcadia Curve is probably the most dangerous place when there's an 81 in any state.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:03:27
      W. Whitworth Jr., John W. Whitworth Jr.
    • 02:03:45
      A. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr.,
    • 02:04:03
      So this had nothing to do about the validity or the worthiness of the project.
    • 02:04:08
      It was simply a definition.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:04:11
      The scoring will determine the validity of the project.
    • 02:04:14
      Correct.
    • 02:04:14
      So that's why they're there.
    • 02:04:17
      If you move faster, you can move faster.
    • 02:04:18
      Exactly.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:04:20
      My quick question is, there are a number of factors.
    • 02:04:23
      I mean, the fact that right now, 62 projects, a very small percentage of all of our work is actually going through the process.
    • 02:04:31
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:04:53
      Over time, the amount of money will grow significantly.
    • 02:04:56
      Right now, because projects that are underway that were fully funded and through NEPA were exempt, you have a lot of allocations of funds that would otherwise run through this process in the current six-year program that aren't going to run through because they're on a project that's underway.
    • 02:05:10
      I know the Commissioner said he didn't have the exact number and we don't but I expect that the amount of money in FY21 and the next update that will be added to that hoarding account will be between $300 and $500 million dollars and each year after that it will be amount around that that will be put into that hoarding account and so if you look at that in the future years it is going to be a significant amount of money on an annual basis and so it could be when we have a six-year program that's fully in the out years has no funds that are exempt you could have
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:05:40
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Valentine, that fund would be exempt from the HB2 process.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:05:58
      It may not rise to the level that you guys think of safety enough, but it's not a good process.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:09
      When the new funding for transit was legislated in 2013 as well, one of the ways that we went about deciding how to distribute
    • 02:06:39
      was an advisory committee made up of all of the players, VTA, VACO, VML, all of those folks.
    • 02:06:48
      And while at the end of the day, DRPT and the CTB made the final decision, it was extremely important to get the input of those folks on an ongoing basis.
    • 02:07:00
      It was tedious.
    • 02:07:02
      Steepe will tell you, I don't know, I guess we had 13 or 14 meetings.
    • 02:07:07
      But at the end of the day, there was buy-in by the vast majority of folks.
    • 02:07:12
      Are we thinking about doing anything of that nature of actually seeking representatives from ACO, PML?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:07:19
      They're going to have a lot of skin in the game.
    • 02:07:22
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Cole, the process we've been moving forward with is we found a higher level of interest in this process and I think was expressed with the TIST Act
    • 02:07:31
      I think what we'll be looking towards is regional workshops that are held more than once in different parts of the state where we invite even a broader set of stakeholders in to provide input.
    • 02:07:41
      The other thing that we've committed to the PDCs and MPOs as I've gone out there to talk with them is that we will come back out to talk to them in their own boardrooms and other places to get that input throughout this process as there's more information and as the board, as the board's briefed on various issues.
    • 02:07:57
      So I think we are looking at doing something
    • 02:07:59
      P. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:08:16
      D. Smith Jr.
    • 02:08:33
      The definitions and all that, so when we come to you, say, here are some parameters for you to decide.
    • 02:08:39
      Instead of us sitting around and you determining, well, I think this is a rural project and this one ought to be, you know, in other words, we're trying to give you some parameters.
    • 02:08:52
      And that's why we're having a two-day, we're having another two-day meeting in October in Richmond.
    • 02:08:58
      And we'll get a more and more expansive review on where we are with House Bill 2.
    • 02:09:02
      He and I haven't had any same conversations and we thought that instead of just getting you involved right now where we're just discussing what we're doing we'd actually have a lot of staff work, we've got consultants working and putting parameters around things so when Nick presents it these are sort of our guidelines that you can start to deliberate from.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:09:27
      And Mr. Chairman, I would just say, Mr. Cole, if there's folks that are saying that we're not getting out to them, please let me know.
    • 02:09:33
      If we put thousands of miles in the state car, I look forward to putting more on them.
    • 02:09:38
      Just on Thursday, we went to the TPO in Hampton Roads, and then we went to Lynchburg that afternoon, and then to Northern Virginia for some meetings there the next day.
    • 02:09:45
      So we really are committed to getting out, to talking to folks in their part of the state.
    • 02:09:49
      We're not making them come to Richmond to come talk to us.
    • 02:09:52
      We really do value and want this input.
    • 02:09:55
      from the folks across the Commonwealth.
    • 02:09:57
      And so if there are folks that we're not reaching that we need to be, please let me know, and I would want the Secretary to know, and I'd be more than happy to make sure we get out there as soon as we can.
    • 02:10:07
      Mr. Kasprowicz.
    • 02:10:07
      Secretary, good question.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:09
      When we revise this project sheet with dollar amounts, can we also see an estimate of the dollars required to bring it to hold the period, whatever that logical holding point is, and then the timing associated with that as well?
    • 02:10:24
      My concern is these projects in Northern Virginia, in the middle of it all, they're all visible, but if we have continued work going on, for instance, right away, relocations, I'm sorry, utility relocations, on a project we've identified being on hold, then the options of that are questionable.
    • 02:10:40
      So you can look at not only the timing to bring the project to a logical hold, but an estimate of the cost to keep it available.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:47
      In general terms, I think you're not going to, I'd say with utility relocations, this is like a physical action going on in the field.
    • 02:10:55
      I won't say 100%, but it's unlikely that we would have a project when we set out for a logical conclusion.
    • 02:11:02
      We're probably, if we're moving utilities,
    • 02:11:05
      It's been, it's not going through prioritization because it's that far along, it's through need, but it was fully funded.
    • 02:11:13
      We don't typically begin moving utilities until a project is fully funded.
    • 02:11:18
      So most of the dollars will bring it through a whole year?
    • 02:11:21
      In general terms, there may be some right-of-way, but more likely it's in the engineering area, doing the preliminary engineering work.
    • 02:11:29
      But there might be right-of-way acquisitions as well?
    • 02:11:31
      Potentially.
    • 02:11:32
      And would they continue?
    • 02:11:33
      The part that gets volatility, you made an offer on a property, we're in a negotiation phase on a particular parcel, do you stop and then pull back or do you close out in that acquisition process?
    • 02:11:54
      and Frank, a lot of that comes down to very specific details on a specific project.
    • 02:11:59
      You don't want to buy right-of-way that you ultimately may not use, but at the same time, you don't want to, again, you're in the middle, it's going to be a project-by-project basis, and we're trying to bring these to a
    • 02:12:14
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:12:29
      That's Charlie's point about the biggest issues we're dealing with now on projects is where we have done equal work that is more than three or four years old and we can't lose focus and we've got to redo it.
    • 02:12:44
      That's another thing that this process is we've got to get something going when we start a project we continue on.
    • 02:12:51
      W. W. W. W. W.
    • 02:13:07
      I mean, it really is.
    • 02:13:09
      Is it going to still be political?
    • 02:13:11
      Oh yeah.
    • 02:13:12
      And is it you have to ensure, does that mean, you know, you're not going to line them up, but at least you're making a value judgment.
    • 02:13:18
      You're saying, why?
    • 02:13:19
      Is the statewide significant?
    • 02:13:21
      I know that score is 70, but you know, when you can take into consideration these other two, we, this is why we should do that nowadays.
    • 02:13:28
      You know, so that's the type of discussion.
    • 02:13:30
      Right now, it's, look, quite frankly, it's pretty much the Secretary,
    • 02:13:36
      sets down with the commissioner and says, I'm all on these projects.
    • 02:13:42
      Not quite that simple, but I mean, that's the overriding thing that has been particularly with the limited amount of funds, right?
    • 02:13:54
      Because it becomes very, very political.
    • 02:13:57
      And that's the last, ever since I've been on the board, that's
    • 02:14:00
      I guess it's 2008 really.
    • 02:14:04
      In terms of when we started losing money, that's what it's become.
    • 02:14:08
      There's some attempt at equity, but quite frankly, it's pretty much what the governor's transportation policies are.
    • 02:14:19
      That's pretty hard to run programs with these guys every four years.
    • 02:14:25
      You know, project and funding you see out there, all of a sudden that's not in the next.
    • 02:14:32
      Guys, if you would have seen, I know it's, no one, if you dropped on the moon, and you saw how the projects were allocated under 2313, you know, I would dare say, all of you would say, you know, that's not the way that they would be allocated.
    • 02:14:49
      W. W. W. W. W.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:15:13
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 02:15:31
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:15:55
      W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 02:16:08
      I'm not trying to menace them, but you pretty much hit them.
    • 02:16:12
      I mean, you just said what they were.
    • 02:16:13
      I mean, we are dealing with the line revenues and House Bill 2 and the exemptions and what we've talked about here.
    • 02:16:20
      I mean, as far as the process, we don't have the detailed process.
    • 02:16:26
      That's good.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:16:27
      I mean, just as long as you set expectations, that milestone, we don't have all the answers, but at this point, we're going to be doing it.
    • 02:16:35
      At this point, about next year at this time, we'll have
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:16:38
      Well, that's what the October meeting is, so if we'd set aside to lay out, would we be targeted then as to what the plan would be, at least in broad and broad terms, as to how to get these in?
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:52
      Well, I think transparency is what I hear Pat saying.
    • 02:16:55
      We all speak the same, from the same book.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:17:00
      Whatever goes with that.
    • 02:17:03
      Let's have that transparency.
    • 02:17:05
      Who's going to be doing the talking points, Charlie?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:08
      Yeah, what we'll do is Tamra and staff will work with Rick on those problem points.
    • 02:17:15
      Again, we're also, I think, a letter to the county cities and the NPOs in advance of the public hearings beginning next week to help set expectations.
    • 02:17:25
      I also think that will be helpful.
    • 02:17:27
      We'll work on that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:17:28
      So what would we have then at the end of this week?
    • 02:17:30
      Absolutely.
    • 02:17:31
      So, in your hands before the call, the hearing is started.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:34
      Oh, absolutely.
    • 02:17:35
      We'll work to get those out before he closes the business Friday, maybe sooner.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:17:41
      And, Deborah, are you going to be around the next two days?
    • 02:17:46
      Yes.
    • 02:17:46
      Okay, so if you've got comments, guys, you can all talk and work it out.
    • 02:17:56
      All right, we can continue this discussion.
    • 02:18:00
      I think the buses are here.
    • 02:18:07
      We anticipated you'd have these type of questions because quite frankly what we've been doing with them and what we've been trying to do is put some structure around them so when we present them to you that you can have some meaningful discussion in that.
    • 02:18:23
      So the rest of the afternoon will be at the SMART road.
    • 02:18:27
      We have a few action items tomorrow and then of course the Jennifer's workshop.
    • 02:18:32
      But the October meeting will be, it's going to be two days and it's going to be fairly intense.
    • 02:18:39
      It will be a lot more detailed.
    • 02:18:41
      I hope they're grimacing.
    • 02:18:44
      But that's what we'll be talking about.
    • 02:18:46
      We'll have that.
    • 02:18:47
      We'll have repeat recommendations.
    • 02:18:50
      that we'll be talking about in that regard.
    • 02:18:54
      So that's why we decided we're going to make that a two-day meeting.
    • 02:19:02
      When is that again?
    • 02:19:03
      It's going to be October 15th and 16th.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:09
      That's Wednesday.
    • 02:19:09
      Wednesday, 30th and 15th.
    • 02:19:10
      15th and 16th.
    • 02:19:11
      If I can help one suggestion.
    • 02:19:13
      I don't want to put too much on Nick.
    • 02:19:15
      I would tell you this from
    • 02:19:18
      E. Smith Jr., John C. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 02:19:31
      Because of what I just now understand is how we're going to set these criteria.
    • 02:19:36
      In other words, each score, each construction district will have their own scoring criteria.
    • 02:19:40
      The points will be, you know, if I have a project that will get scored according to the same district criteria and if Dixon has a project that will be scored with the same criteria, it would be very important for us to have input into Nick as to what we think
    • 02:20:01
      McPherson, John F. McPherson Jr.,
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:20:16
      at that regional level as well so we can bring to you all kind of the input from your communities and what they think is important.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:20:23
      That's part of the dialogue as well.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:37
      W. Smith Jr., Timmy P. Deadlines, and we're going to have something done by X.
    • 02:20:41
      We're going to keep talking.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:20:43
      And that's what we're going to give you in September.
    • 02:20:46
      Now, let me tell you one other thing.
    • 02:20:50
      Let's take Hampton Road.
    • 02:20:52
      You may have to determine if each construction district may have rural and urban projects.
    • 02:20:59
      In other words, so it won't be led by the
    • 02:21:01
      No, it won't be. It'll be in the line. In other words, it could be in Hampton Roads they have both urban and rural projects. It'll be in that construction district how you want it weighted depending on whether it's an urban or rural project. So so brought up city would compete and be scored projects around city before the same
    • 02:21:24
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 02:21:47
      W. W. W. W. W. W.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:07
      I mean, we've got different sizes of cities.
    • 02:22:10
      I mean, I've got the city of Bedford, right, where I was turning now into a town.
    • 02:22:16
      But there's cities of that size all around.
    • 02:22:18
      And that's urban, right, because it's a city, right?
    • 02:22:22
      That's the kind of stuff we need to get done.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:22:26
      So Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, at the next meeting we're going to walk through the deadlines for how it's supposed to be processed and moving forward to get your input and your concurrence on that.
    • 02:22:36
      We're also going to talk, not about the specific weighting for a given district or region within a district, but concepts about how that could be done.
    • 02:22:45
      So for example, in some of the discussions we've had, I've heard similar things from Lynchburg and Rona.
    • 02:22:50
      And those things are more alike than they are from some of the feedback I've gotten from other parts of your district.
    • 02:22:55
      And so there's things where perhaps those two areas within those different districts may have a similar weighting criteria, while the more rural parts of those two districts may have a similar weighting criteria.
    • 02:23:07
      And again, that is going to be a decision for this board.
    • 02:23:10
      The staff are going to discuss ways we could look at that.
    • 02:23:13
      We're going to take your feedback and then we're going to go follow your direction.
    • 02:23:17
      That's how we further develop that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:23:21
      It firmly goes along with where I hear it's by district.
    • 02:23:24
      I mean, it's going to be one center.
    • 02:23:25
      It's a way, right?
    • 02:23:27
      It's going to be a rural project across the county level, going this way, or an urban project.
    • 02:23:32
      That's what this was at the time.
    • 02:23:34
      I would hope so.
    • 02:23:36
      That's correct.
    • 02:23:38
      But you determine if it's an oral route or an oral, right, rural project.
    • 02:23:44
      I'm hesitant to get back in here.
    • 02:23:47
      The road set.
    • 02:23:49
      That's right, by construction district.
    • 02:23:52
      But by construction district, I think either by urban or urban, in other words.
    • 02:23:59
      But the intent is, you got urban projects ought to be compared across the state.
    • 02:24:08
      Rural projects compared across the state.
    • 02:24:10
      At the construction district, you determine if it's urban or rural.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:24:16
      And Mr. Chairman, the thing I would just say to members of the board is we'll have much more details, graphics, slides, and other things that can really structure this discussion more in October.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:24
      Well, and that's great.
    • 02:24:25
      I do think that in October we all should approve the timeline and put some deadlines and figure out exactly where we're going to have to place this.
    • 02:24:35
      As you can see, just from this board, there's a lot of interest.
    • 02:24:37
      But as Dixon was saying, you talk to contractors, you talk to me, everybody across the transportation spectrum knows that these criteria are really, really important.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:24:49
      Well the idea is to prepare a project, just keep going overall, to prepare a project, whether it's a small district, a rural project in rural Bristol, a very large district on a project in Northern Virginia, and have a way to prepare to say what is the next incremental dollar that ought to be spent.
    • 02:25:07
      W. W. W. W. W. W.
    • 02:25:29
      Mr. Cole, that is a decision for the board of directors.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:25:58
      And the staff will come back with some discussions about structures.
    • 02:26:02
      The law, as Mr. Fralin knows, does have some parameters around that, but those decisions rest with this body.
    • 02:26:09
      The staff, based on the feedback that we're getting, are going to come to you not with specifically how it should be done in various areas, but different constructs under which we can do that to get your feedback on it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:26:23
      Yeah, but the idea is not for you to figure out how to best play the score and continue to get your body up.
    • 02:26:29
      That's the truth.
    • 02:26:32
      The idea is to be a consistent call for confidence.
    • 02:26:36
      That's what the idea is.
    • 02:26:38
      But I mean, pathetically, if you have an urban project, theoretically, they ought to be scored separately.
    • 02:26:45
      If you have a rural one, theoretically, they ought to be scored separately.
    • 02:26:48
      That's really what it's all about.
    • 02:26:55
      And by the way, remember at the end, it still doesn't mean if it doesn't score an act that you can't fund it.
    • 02:27:04
      You run the risk of defending.
    • 02:27:07
      That's right, you run the risk of defending.
    • 02:27:08
      That's exactly what it is.
    • 02:27:10
      It still comes down to get seven votes to the secretary or eight votes.
    • 02:27:16
      And if it's a two and that's what eight people want to do, that's what gets funded.
    • 02:27:20
      So this is, again, not... Then there'll be another bill that says you shall.
    • 02:27:25
      Well, we're dealing with that in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:27:30
      But that's not the intent.
    • 02:27:31
      I think if we basically...
    • 02:27:34
      Look, it's like our disclosure laws in the state, which we, to adage them, have had to deal with the last few months.
    • 02:27:41
      The issue is for the public to understand how we're validating these monies.
    • 02:27:47
      Just like how it's in Florida.
    • 02:27:49
      How we're doing with these monies.
    • 02:27:51
      That's what Whalley House Bill 2 is trying to do.
    • 02:27:54
      It's not meant to be, take all the thought out of it and you put it in a computer and you spit these out.
    • 02:28:00
      and you say, well, that's what we're doing.
    • 02:28:03
      No, you will come down and there's going to have to be some equity.
    • 02:28:06
      I'm sure there's a lot of judgment calls, but the issue is to say how you went through the process and this is how we, why we decided.
    • 02:28:15
      That's really what it's trying to do.
    • 02:28:18
      Okay, with that enlightening discussion, Jennifer, you want to give us a break to tell us what our logistics are the rest of the afternoon?
    • 02:28:25
      Is that Jennifer?
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:28:28
      All right, quick logistics.
    • 02:28:30
      When we leave this room, we're going to go down the stairs and through the big glass doors.
    • 02:28:35
      There's buses there that are ready to take you to the smart road.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:28:39
      There's no restroom on the bus.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:28:41
      You're going to go to the smart road.
    • 02:28:44
      You're going to have a tour of the smart road facility.
    • 02:28:48
      Lunches will be brought out there for you to have on the return trip.
    • 02:28:52
      For those of you that are
    • 02:28:53
      taking tours this afternoon with our group, either the bus tour, the walking tour, or the bike tour.
    • 02:29:00
      Those tours leave at 2 o'clock, and they also leave in the area that you're going to go meet the bus and go to the SMART right.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:29:06
      That's two of us, we'll get back, 5-5, and then the evening logistics, we're going to meet our bus transportation to the reception in the same place where you're going to get the bus transportation in just a few minutes.
    • 02:29:19
      They'll take us over to the transportation museum, and that's where our reception is tonight, the loss of which are us.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:24
      If you get lost, you're supposed to be, if you get on that bus at what time?
    • 02:29:28
      5-30.
    • 02:29:28
      5-30.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:29:28
      5-30.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:29:29
      Why don't we give everybody ten minutes?
    • 02:29:32
      I think we can take our red tile.
    • 02:29:33
      It's 11.02.
    • 02:29:34
      Why don't we see 11.15 at the bus in the lobby?
    • 02:29:38
      I think this afternoon is casual.
    • 02:29:41
      If you want to take your ties on, you've got to enjoy your room and whatever.
    • 02:29:49
      Oh, yes, everybody's coming back.