Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 2/19/2014
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   2/19/2014

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2014 budget, actual performance through January 2014.pdf
  • VDOT maintenance and operations update_ Stabilizing and improving the program.pdf
  • Limited access control change request, Route 360 bypass, Amelia.pdf
  • Raleigh Parish Glebe request for limited access.pdf
  • 1. Financial Report ▶︎ 0:49

    • Report.pdf
  • 2. Maintenance Update ▶︎ 26:04

  • 3. Amelia County Limited Access Break ▶︎ 55:09

  • 4. Transportation Alternatives Program FY2015 Application Update ▶︎ 1:22:05

    • Transportation Alternatives Program, Fiscal Year 2015 application update.pdf
  • 5. Legislative Update ▶︎ 1:39:28

    • Legislative update.pdf
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:00:04
      Good morning.
    • 00:00:04
      We'll call the work-stop session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board to order.
    • 00:00:09
      If you'll all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance, please.
    • 00:00:14
      Join me in that.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:00:16
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • 00:00:30
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:00:32
      Welcome, everyone.
    • 00:00:33
      Looks like we'll have, hopefully we'll have a fairly light day, but we'll see as we get into some things in that regard.
    • 00:00:42
      There will be a couple of things, updates on some projects at the end which I'll go through.
    • 00:00:47
      But let's get started.
    • 00:00:49
      I think, Mr. Lawson, you're up with the financial report.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:00:54
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
    • 00:01:01
      This morning I want to give you an update of the financial performance through January.
    • 00:01:08
      I'm going to try to go through this pretty quickly.
    • 00:01:09
      Please, please slow me down and ask me questions you may have.
    • 00:01:14
      As you recall, last month I came to you and presented the impacts of the revised revenue forecast, so I'm going forward with this completely.
    • 00:01:25
      comparison of actuals to forecasts is all now in comparison to the revised forecast from December.
    • 00:01:36
      Revenues through January are just slightly above the forecast, the revised forecast.
    • 00:01:45
      We had 13.5% growth versus 13.2%.
    • 00:01:50
      Federal revenues, as you know, are a product of reimbursement of activities within the programs, and as spending in those programs remains strong, federal collections are following.
    • 00:02:04
      In terms of overall spending, we are slightly behind forecast, but the last month or so has brought in a lot of activity in terms of responding to the winter weather.
    • 00:02:16
      Chief Engineer will be speaking to you a little more later about activities within the maintenance program.
    • 00:02:25
      Again, in terms of state revenues for the CTF, we are slightly above the estimate.
    • 00:02:33
      That estimate of 13.2% is reduced down from the previous forecast of 13.9%.
    • 00:02:41
      Motor fuels continues to perform actually slightly better than forecast, partly because of the, I believe, the lower price of fuel that we have seen.
    • 00:02:55
      Motor vehicle sales and use tax collection remains strong as people are continuing to buy automobiles while slightly below forecast still doing very well and expect it to continue to do well
    • 00:03:09
      and even improved slightly as the year goes along as the revised forecast actually increased, excuse me, slightly increased that growth rate.
    • 00:03:23
      Retail sales and use tax, now our single largest state revenue source is performing well and again the forecast there was slightly reduced based on the slower growth in the economy.
    • 00:03:40
      This graphically just illustrates the main revenue sources, and you can see the changes in the main sources from where we are today and the growth over 2013.
    • 00:03:53
      I mentioned earlier the federal revenues.
    • 00:03:59
      Again, we are looking at about just about 900 million collected this year, just about 90 million less than we were as of January of 2013.
    • 00:04:08
      And again, rental revenues are a product of the expenditure activity in our major programs.
    • 00:04:15
      You'll notice that the major reduction here is in the maintenance area and that is directly driven to the fact that the amount of maintenance funds in a federal funds in the maintenance program this year is much less than in the prior year and that's because of the reduced carryover from the previous year.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:04:37
      This is graphical.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:04:38
      graphically shows the spending through January by major program, and you can see the slight variances between the programs.
    • 00:04:47
      The biggest change you notice is in the financial assistance localities, and that is related to the transfer of the regional monies to Northern Virginia.
    • 00:05:00
      In terms of spending, across all programs, we are about $11 million behind forecast.
    • 00:05:07
      No real major variances in any of the programs.
    • 00:05:11
      I will point out here on the maintenance item, kind of on the middle of the slide, we are now showing the budget and the forecasted spending as the exact same number.
    • 00:05:26
      Because of the spending that has taken place with snow activities over the last month or
    • 00:05:32
      We are now having to look at the maintenance budget and the maintenance program to see how we can stay within budget and again the chief engineer will be speaking a little bit about that following this presentation.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:49
      The administrative support service line, I mean we've been beating on this for years in terms of you know trying to get our
    • 00:06:00
      It's hard for a business guy to want to get his spending up, but we're trying to get money on the projects, obviously, to get that out the door. But we're not necessarily wanting to get our spending up on administrative and support services, assuming we don't need what we don't need. So the 5.6, you know, half of our variance is in that line. Thank you. Thank you.
    • 00:06:21
      Is that money that's going to end up being spent, or is it money that we're going to realize the savings of our forecast, or what is it?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:06:33
      At this point, I think it's largely related to timing.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:38
      We're watching it, obviously, but what would administrative and support...
    • 00:06:43
      I understand the timing thing, but generally administrative and support services aren't
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:06:49
      Well, nearly, well, two-thirds, a third of that, a third of that total is IT support.
    • 00:07:02
      And so you have a lot of timing associated with vendor payments and the consultants in that area, as well as the billings from VITA.
    • 00:07:12
      And typically we have a large share of those costs come in toward the end of the year.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:19
      To see some variance at this time of year is not... And I didn't hear you say what the bond finance project variance was about.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:07:34
      What this is just indicating is that today we have expended more on bond proceeds than we anticipated on the particular projects that they're funding.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:46
      Yeah, but I'm wondering if that is because, I mean, there's no 460 in that, is there?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:07:54
      Some of that 460?
    • 00:07:55
      Some of that is 460.
    • 00:07:56
      Of course, you've got, I mean, 460, Midtown, all the various projects that are funded.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:03
      I'm just trying to understand if it's something that's
    • 00:08:07
      is a good thing or if it's something that's a bad thing.
    • 00:08:09
      Obviously, if we stop 460, we made a decision to do that.
    • 00:08:14
      So we shouldn't hold that against ourselves in terms of getting our projects done.
    • 00:08:18
      So I'm just trying to get to that.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:08:19
      Yeah, this is, I believe, just an indication of work proceeding quicker than we anticipated.
    • 00:08:25
      And again, that's become a global statement as we look across all day.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:29
      You know, your initial question is a good one about these administrative charges.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:08:53
      One of the things that has come up in the budget is that
    • 00:08:59
      Martin, W. C.
    • 00:09:14
      You're probably used to, as I was, on an accrual basis, everything here is on the cash basis, so if somebody doesn't bill us, we don't show it.
    • 00:09:22
      I mean, so that doesn't mean that's our obligation.
    • 00:09:24
      So the question's a good one, but I think they're on top of it in terms of at least knowing what's outstanding.
    • 00:09:32
      But we are continuing to have to watch out for additional charges coming from different agencies to that perception.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:41
      I would just say, for the benefit of our newer members,
    • 00:09:45
      Four years ago we were substantially different picture of getting money that we actually had in hand to the road.
    • 00:09:54
      And we had huge balances that were just sitting around doing nothing.
    • 00:09:59
      And so under, in the last four years I know the staff has worked very hard to push that money because we've taken it from the taxpayers
    • 00:10:09
      Martin, W. J. Peake, Roger Cole, W.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:10:36
      Again, just jumping down to the construction program specifically, we have spent just over a billion dollars this year, which is about a five percent increase compared to where we were this year, and it appears that the majority of the growth or the increase is related to the actual construction, not in the PE or right-of-way areas.
    • 00:11:00
      In terms of maintenance, we expended $134 million in January, just over a billion dollars total year-to-date.
    • 00:11:09
      Through January, we are about $63 million below the anticipated spending through that period of time.
    • 00:11:19
      However, as we know, we've had tremendous efforts put toward the winter weather over the last couple months.
    • 00:11:27
      Mr. Secretary, on to the point you made earlier about the way expenditures are reported.
    • 00:11:33
      Through January, we actually posted snow expenditures of about $107 million compared to the budget of $157 million, but we know that there are significantly more expenditures coming as the vendor payments come.
    • 00:11:47
      And then with the snow that is taking place in February, we have likely far surpassed that budget of $157 million.
    • 00:11:57
      And again, the chief engineer will be speaking to that following my presentation.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:12:01
      Right, he's going to go specifically on that.
    • 00:12:03
      Mr. Cole.
    • 00:12:03
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Lawson, the $157 million, is that the annual forecast for that or is that the January?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:12:10
      The $157 million is the annual budget for snow.
    • 00:12:13
      Okay, thank you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:12:15
      Yeah, because there's been press reports, we've asked the chief engineer to give a detail of what we've incurred and where we're going to end up.
    • 00:12:25
      There'll be a presentation after Mr. Lawson's.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:12:30
      Looking at the, I mentioned the financial assistance piece earlier, looking at the monies collected on behalf of NVTA and Hampton Roads Transportation Fund, you can see we've collected about $145 million so far for NVTA and about $78 million this year so far for Hampton Roads Transportation Authority.
    • 00:12:53
      Again, the Hampton Roads monies are held
    • 00:12:57
      By Treasury and overseen by VDOT until directed to be expended by Hampton Roads, NVTA monies
    • 00:13:07
      as you can see are transferred to them monthly as the revenues are collected.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:13:12
      Mr. Secretary?
    • 00:13:12
      Yes, Mr. Korsinski.
    • 00:13:14
      Mr. Lawson, question for you.
    • 00:13:16
      We have an NVTA meeting tomorrow evening.
    • 00:13:18
      How are we looking on the forecasted revenues for NVTA?
    • 00:13:23
      Do you think they're going to come in at that 270 or can you project at this point?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:13:28
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:13:29
      As part of the, Mr. Secretary, Mr. Korsinski, the revised forecast from December
    • 00:13:36
      only reduced the NVTA forecast by about $2 million, so we are still believing that that will continue on track.
    • 00:13:45
      Okay, thank you, Mr. Lawson.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:13:47
      Yeah, I'll remind the board here, we're going to have a couple of other presentations on something related, but if you look at our six-year plan, particularly with the action we took last month,
    • 00:13:58
      The real increase from the House Bill 2313 are in the regions.
    • 00:14:03
      The actual six-year plan for statewide monies is actually slightly down a little bit.
    • 00:14:09
      So it really was revenue neutral and we talked about it last time about being the cost of gasoline.
    • 00:14:16
      in that regard.
    • 00:14:18
      But just to point that out, it's important that these monies be used wisely because they're really incremental where the monies are in the next at least four or five years, next six-year plan, other than what we already have programmed.
    • 00:14:32
      So, anyway.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:14:34
      Mr. Secretary?
    • 00:14:34
      Yes.
    • 00:14:35
      I would also add, and this would be something for the fellow board members, that we are well into now the modeling of
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:14:44
      The prioritization of spending, I know that's something we'll probably get an update statewide on, but MBTA has started that process right now, and our first list of projects is going to come to the MBTA Board tomorrow.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:00
      Is that a different modeling than you've used for monies in general?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:15:07
      Yes.
    • 00:15:07
      And why would it be different?
    • 00:15:09
      It's based on congestion relief and also safety evacuation.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:16
      There's a lot of factors, but it's a new model.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:15:19
      This is just for NVTA because there was a bill that dictated that's how it had to be done, but this model could well be the precursor
    • 00:15:33
      Or what may happen statewide depending on that one bill.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:40
      I was really interested in the normal state money that's flowing in versus the incremental money that's flowing in.
    • 00:15:47
      And you've got two different models.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:15:49
      Martin, Jr.
    • 00:16:07
      Daines, their model in that, let me get Mr. Sterling, I'll come back to those here.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:11
      There's a number of models, different MPOs use these, have used these models in their particular districts.
    • 00:16:17
      As we're looking at this, what we're going to do statewide, et cetera, can we get some sort of series of briefings on all the models that are being used?
    • 00:16:24
      That's what I was getting at.
    • 00:16:25
      Yeah, because I don't want to be told that we've got to go by Northern Virginia, or Hampton Roads, or Cold
    • 00:16:31
      Let's see what's out there.
    • 00:16:33
      They may all fit together very perfectly, but I think we need to look at the totality.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:16:38
      Mr. Donohue's going to give an update.
    • 00:16:39
      That's one of the things I think he'll touch on, these whole models here.
    • 00:16:44
      We'll point out one thing here.
    • 00:16:48
      The CTB or VDOT has a role in, because of the legislation in Northern Virginia, don't have that specific in Hampton Roads.
    • 00:16:57
      And I think we need to keep in mind, because we've had various conversations, particularly with Ms. Mitchell, in terms of transit money, Director Mitchell.
    • 00:17:06
      Our role in this process is tell them what the benefits and the costs are, cost-benefit relationship.
    • 00:17:15
      It's policy, it's basically compliance and legal and what the costs.
    • 00:17:19
      They are still free to choose the projects.
    • 00:17:22
      In other words, I want to make sure that our role is to say, hey, you've given us this list.
    • 00:17:28
      Here's what we see as the benefits and the problems with it.
    • 00:17:31
      But they will still be determining which projects to pick.
    • 00:17:35
      I know a lot of legislators we've talked to, they think that it's the CTB or us.
    • 00:17:40
      That's not the way the law works.
    • 00:17:41
      And so we're there to advise and say, you know, this is what you get.
    • 00:17:46
      If they choose to do something else, that'll be between them, the legislators, and they may see other actions.
    • 00:17:52
      So I just want to point that out.
    • 00:17:55
      We're not the ones that are selling which projects they pick.
    • 00:17:58
      We're just telling them, approve VDOT.
    • 00:18:00
      Here's what you get if you pick that project.
    • 00:18:04
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:18:05
      I think I just wanted to add for clarification because there is a bill working its way through the general assembly.
    • 00:18:10
      I assume that's what we're going to be briefed on.
    • 00:18:11
      That's right.
    • 00:18:12
      Yeah.
    • 00:18:12
      But, you know, the regional monies and the priorities set forth for the regional monies are different from the statewide priorities.
    • 00:18:19
      And so they should and they should be.
    • 00:18:22
      They shouldn't be the same.
    • 00:18:23
      And congestion relief is a major component of statewide money, but it's not the only component.
    • 00:18:31
      Whereas in some of the regional money, that is the number one.
    • 00:18:37
      So I just want to make sure we're cognizant as we work through this and as we pay attention.
    • 00:18:42
      And we're going to have a little more limited ability to say, based on this bill,
    • 00:18:48
      A. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John L. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:19:09
      I'm sure Mr. Ohio will get into it, but that's right.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:19:18
      We're only talking about out years monies because there's a few things that are exempted from the prioritization and he'll get into that.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:19:29
      All right, my final slide is just the cash picture.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:19:32
      This is the Mr. Miller slide.
    • 00:19:36
      When we developed this, could you talk about the cash balances and what we really could use, and I think your point's well taken, trying to get what we actually have control of.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:19:45
      Yeah, I restructured the slide this month to try to hide some bugs.
    • 00:19:51
      Every line is there that was there before.
    • 00:19:55
      wanted to really identify the type of funding we're talking about.
    • 00:20:00
      And you look at our operating funds.
    • 00:20:03
      The two funds that we work in and out of every day is really just the top two, the HMO and the construction fund.
    • 00:20:11
      And you can see we've been holding a $500 million balance in those two funds.
    • 00:20:20
      In the middle grouping are dedicated funds.
    • 00:20:23
      These are funds that were
    • 00:20:24
      created for special purposes and can only be used for those special purposes.
    • 00:20:30
      So you see that the grouping of those monies totaling about 700 million.
    • 00:20:35
      And then lastly, I showed the bond funds and these funds are held by trustee that we have to requisition the trustee for based on the incurrence of eligible cost associated with those bond programs.
    • 00:20:49
      I just felt like it might be helpful
    • 00:20:51
      to the board to see the cash picture in this light, given that people tend to navigate to the bottom line and think we're setting on X $1.8 billion, but in terms of cash, in terms of an operating program, it is really just the $500 million at the top.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:21:12
      Mr. Lawson, is the infrastructure bank that's dedicated 318, is that what we've committed already to certain jurisdictions on those loans?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:21:25
      The infrastructure bank, that's the cash that's been committed, only a very small amount, about $50 million of that is yet, it's uncommitted.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:21:33
      So that's what we have left right now.
    • 00:21:36
      Correct.
    • 00:21:36
      $50 million.
    • 00:21:37
      $318 million committed.
    • 00:21:39
      Okay.
    • 00:21:39
      Thank you.
    • 00:21:41
      Just as a point here, one of the things been working with John and Mr. Lawson and VDOT on is
    • 00:21:49
      And you'll see it in the planning process, too, is making things a little more easy for us to understand and more transparent.
    • 00:22:01
      For instance, if we have a change, what went out and what came in?
    • 00:22:05
      So I'm cognizant of what you guys, and so we're really working towards what are the main things that this board should have oversight over, making sure you understand it when we take a decision.
    • 00:22:18
      and so just letting you know we'll work through it and this was the first step but as we go through and we go through the six-year plan we'll look for your input as to how we can make it more clear to you guys to us as a board and try to take it out of this total just the programming you know following through so just letting you know that's an ongoing process and we'll look for your input as to how we can make this more transparent.
    • 00:22:49
      The other question, Mr. Cole.
    • 00:22:50
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:22:51
      Mr. Lawson, if I could draw your attention to slide number five, the federal revenue slide.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:22:57
      Two questions.
    • 00:22:58
      Number one, how frequently do we receive guidance from the federal government in terms of what they're seeing, what we can expect going forward?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:23:07
      And number two, this gives us a good perspective from an accumulated year to date.
    • 00:23:14
      What are the trend lines
    • 00:23:16
      Is January's number in terms of revenue versus anticipation?
    • 00:23:23
      Is there a greater delta?
    • 00:23:25
      Is it shrinking?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:23:30
      To your first question, Mr. Cole, we can get federal updates at their will.
    • 00:23:40
      We typically would get them every year as part of the budget process.
    • 00:23:45
      But what we find now is every time there is a continuation or some next step, I'll say, in the process toward a new year or something, we get revisions.
    • 00:23:59
      Whenever they were to process a rescission, we'll get a revision.
    • 00:24:05
      So it's hard to put a calendar on it.
    • 00:24:09
      We did receive one within the last month updating obligation authority emails.
    • 00:24:15
      So it's not something that you can expect on a set schedule.
    • 00:24:22
      In terms of the future here, looking out, again, the revenues we're seeing are based on the expenditures that we are planning to incur.
    • 00:24:33
      And again, for the most part, the R program is phasing out, so that is going to be declining until it's over.
    • 00:24:45
      And again, the big change on the maintenance program is there was only about $5 million of maintenance carryover, federal maintenance carryover into this year, where there was a couple hundred million maintenance carryover into this year.
    • 00:25:00
      So that's the reason you're seeing that number so much smaller than it was last year.
    • 00:25:05
      And as you can see, activity on the construction side is spending well, we do above where we were last year.
    • 00:25:13
      I see the trend to continue with what you're seeing here.
    • 00:25:16
      Maintenance, for the most part, won't change much for the remainder of the years because we collect most of it on the front end.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:25:27
      The Governor and I met with Secretary Foxx this last week.
    • 00:25:32
      This was one of the topics, obviously a sustainable.
    • 00:25:35
      Of course, he's at the mercy of our Congress.
    • 00:25:39
      Their best guess is it's going to be pretty much about what it was in the previous year.
    • 00:25:44
      That's their best guidance right now in that.
    • 00:25:48
      And that's what we've used in our projections going forward, a flat federal revenue.
    • 00:25:56
      Any other questions of Mr. Lawson?
    • 00:25:59
      Okay, thanks.
    • 00:26:04
      Okay, I have a maintenance update from Chief Engineer, Deputy Commissioner, Mr. Moore.
    • 00:26:10
      Garrett, welcome.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:26:11
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary.
    • 00:26:14
      Good morning, members of the board.
    • 00:26:28
      This morning, the main theme of probably what we're going to talk about on maintenance is we've started the turnaround.
    • 00:26:39
      I think there was some discussion this morning about having a large amount of money on the table in years past, and we've worked that down.
    • 00:26:46
      We've also have started a turnaround.
    • 00:26:48
      It's not that things are great, but we're making progress.
    • 00:26:52
      And I'd say that's the general theme.
    • 00:26:54
      So moving along.
    • 00:26:59
      This kind of shows the big picture of what our maintenance and operations budget is, kind of gives you a sense of perspective in our annual budget.
    • 00:27:10
      Big number there on the right.
    • 00:27:13
      And kind of our major things that we're looking at, if you look at the pavements, they've actually been improving.
    • 00:27:20
      There's some good stories in there.
    • 00:27:23
      There's also some ugly stories.
    • 00:27:26
      improved our condition of interstates overall, but we've had some sections of interstate, as you know, in the Hampton Roads area, I-64, 264, some in the Richmond area, 95, 295, 85, and a few other spots throughout the state where we've actually had some pretty bad pavements included in there that we didn't get to, and we're working on those.
    • 00:27:46
      The other part that we need to pay attention to there is on the right.
    • 00:27:49
      Largely, a lot of those dollars went to the interstate and primary at the expense of the secondary.
    • 00:27:56
      A large portion of that's in Northern Virginia because they've got a lot of subdivisions and we're going to have to pay some attention.
    • 00:28:03
      We're making progress.
    • 00:28:04
      We're going to have to pay more attention to the secondaries.
    • 00:28:07
      This is a... Can I ask a question?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:28:10
      Yes, Mr. Fralin.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:28:13
      What are the criteria for the determination of whether we're going to spend it on interstate, primary, or secondary?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:28:19
      There is a model that's worked and it's done by our, we have a pavement engineer here in central office and we actually do a rating system that goes, a vehicle goes around and rates all of the interstate and all of the primary every year and 20% of the secondaries.
    • 00:28:40
      Now it doesn't drive every lane
    • 00:28:42
      It'll typically drive the right lane.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:28:43
      I've seen that, but I'm talking about in terms of allocation between the interstate primary and secondary.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:28:48
      Then that information is taken and by need it goes out to interstate and in the past the secondary has not been funded in some years.
    • 00:28:56
      What we are starting here this past year is funding the secondary to try to bring that up to 65% of it being rather than 82% of it alone.
    • 00:29:06
      So it's based on the need that we're... Well, some of your secondary didn't need any payment?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:29:12
      No.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:29:12
      To answer that question, in the years that we didn't have enough money to do what we needed to do, we cut our hand off so that the rest of the body could live.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:29:22
      My question is does this board have any say in that or is that purely administrative?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:29:28
      The answer is the board does have a say.
    • 00:29:30
      During the years when Secretary Wadden, the board voted to put it on and that we do.
    • 00:29:35
      Now, of course, the CTB formula has allocated a specific amount over and above
    • 00:29:41
      to secondary roads to getting them back up to speed.
    • 00:29:45
      But yes, we do have a say in that.
    • 00:29:48
      VDOT now is working under the previous direction of this board, and that included the CTB formula to get these pavements up to speed.
    • 00:30:00
      There's probably more money going in now, Chris Fralin, that would probably on an ongoing basis, but that's part of the CTB formula to secondary roads.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:30:09
      It is because the money was just applied.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:30:16
      And as you'll see, the target up there to the right is actually lower in overall condition than it is for interstate and primary.
    • 00:30:23
      And it's going to take a while for that to turn around because in some parts of the state they're in pretty poor shape.
    • 00:30:30
      And I don't know if you were on the board when we had some interstate that was
    • 00:30:34
      It's basically failing, and I'll talk a little bit about that.
    • 00:30:36
      We're recovering on that.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:30:39
      It was basically not nearly enough money to go around.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:30:43
      But we have the same challenge in front of us in the secondary, getting to it before it fails on us.
    • 00:30:51
      Did that answer your question, sir?
    • 00:30:53
      Yes.
    • 00:30:55
      Looking at bridges, same thing.
    • 00:30:56
      We're making progress.
    • 00:30:57
      There's some holes in this, but regardless, before the funding was putting in,
    • 00:31:03
      Our districts are doing a very good job, some better than others, in making sure that we were improving the condition.
    • 00:31:09
      And the measure we use is whether it's structurally deficient or not.
    • 00:31:13
      And we've been doing that, we're continuing to do it, and we're continuing to work on it.
    • 00:31:18
      We have money at the CTB's discretion, that money that goes to bridges, and we're looking to continue that in the future.
    • 00:31:27
      The issue that we talked about on losing some of our interstate, last year at this time,
    • 00:31:33
      Early February, I remember getting a call on a Saturday morning just after I'd gotten this job.
    • 00:31:39
      What are you doing today?
    • 00:31:40
      And I said, I don't know.
    • 00:31:42
      What am I doing today?
    • 00:31:43
      And ended up going down to Hampton Roads.
    • 00:31:45
      And frankly, it was a condition of a roadway that we should never allow this to happen as a department or as a Commonwealth.
    • 00:31:52
      Today, all those are under contract.
    • 00:31:55
      I would call this now stabilized.
    • 00:31:58
      I think we're getting some good comments from the
    • 00:32:00
      the folks down there, but they're not in the final condition.
    • 00:32:03
      We made some economic judgments that probably optimize what we're going to get.
    • 00:32:08
      They're not perfect solutions, but we have contracts, three of them down there to work, and they are all awarded at this point and underway.
    • 00:32:16
      So over the next two or three years, not only will you see them stabilized, you'll see those improved where you should get a reasonable design life out of them.
    • 00:32:24
      So that's something that we've started this term because we were, in many cases, losing our infrastructure.
    • 00:32:29
      And it's not fast enough, but we're going to continue that push as far as the dollars will allow us.
    • 00:32:37
      Another thing that we've been able to do that I think is helpful in our dealings with the public is, and again, the Hampton Roads area was a challenge.
    • 00:32:47
      They had about 10, 11 inches of snow out in the beach areas.
    • 00:32:51
      And many of the districts in the western part of the state basically on immediate notice marshaled everybody in about two hours.
    • 00:32:59
      and we're on the road probably in three to four with trucks and equipment and to spend several days there and help them overcome and avoid some of the situations we've seen in other states.
    • 00:33:10
      I mean, they've reacted very, very quickly.
    • 00:33:12
      I mean, you can look at some of the comments from some of the folks down there who felt very good about being able to avoid some of the situations.
    • 00:33:19
      Now, we've had some other situations in the Salem District and I'm probably equally as proud as some of those were the same guys that went out to the eastern part of the state
    • 00:33:29
      did some challenges on 81 with some record snow out there, but they stuck with it through just some tough, tough conditions.
    • 00:33:37
      If you look at it, you can see some of the snowball numbers.
    • 00:33:40
      I would say statewide, this isn't like the 2009-2010, which many people would characterize as 100-year events, but for some local areas, these actually are records, and we will be pursuing
    • 00:33:54
      F. F.
    • 00:34:08
      in Salem.
    • 00:34:09
      That was a long night, Thursday night.
    • 00:34:11
      You probably got some phone calls on that.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:34:13
      They had drifting snow as well.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:34:15
      Yes, snow drifting.
    • 00:34:16
      Sure.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:34:17
      Let me comment on this.
    • 00:34:19
      Certainly, we used Hampton Roads as an example.
    • 00:34:21
      This would have been done whether it was any part of the state.
    • 00:34:24
      I want to give a couple of credit to the governor, his proactive use because typically what happens is VDOT will go and say,
    • 00:34:35
      You know, we're reaching out to the locals.
    • 00:34:37
      Do you want us?
    • 00:34:38
      And they start acting over price.
    • 00:34:39
      We decided we'll get the price right.
    • 00:34:41
      We knew the storms come and get the assets there.
    • 00:34:44
      And we'll figure out the price later.
    • 00:34:46
      And they've been great to work with.
    • 00:34:49
      The other thing the board needs to keep in mind, a lot of this is done by contractors and in Northern Virginia since they are all secondary roads because they're all counties, we have a great deal of equipment there all the time.
    • 00:35:03
      Other parts of the state not as that way.
    • 00:35:07
      We will marshal those depending on the last storm that Garrett talked about.
    • 00:35:12
      It impacted the entire state.
    • 00:35:14
      So we didn't have the ability to just move things.
    • 00:35:17
      We had to stand by.
    • 00:35:18
      But I just want to make sure that people understood that the governor has been very proactive and said do the right thing and then we'll worry about how we settle up afterwards.
    • 00:35:30
      And I think that's been well received right off the top of the wall.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:35:33
      Yes, sir.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:35:35
      Yes.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:36
      I'd like to add on to that comment actually, specifically about Northern Virginia.
    • 00:35:41
      The other jurisdictions around Northern Virginia, D.C. and suburban Maryland had numerous problems that were reported on the news.
    • 00:35:48
      Roads that didn't get plowed, hours were plowed.
    • 00:35:51
      Yes, sometimes the things that don't show up, it's where I tell the guys, we're sort of like linemen on a football team.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:36:14
      You only hear our name if we do something bad, but we can't score unless you're doing a job.
    • 00:36:19
      And that's really, I think kudos to the workforce, both not just our VDOT but the public safety, the state police.
    • 00:36:27
      It's really fascinating and to me very professional sequence that we go through.
    • 00:36:33
      We should take comfort that there is a very good group of people that know what they're doing when these things arise.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:36:42
      The cooperation between the city and the state never really refreshed the city's type of dialogue.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:04
      The last thing is, with all that equipment showing up, it was managed very well.
    • 00:37:06
      It's not a very organized, productive way.
    • 00:37:07
      Kudos to never did the logistics of the management of all that equipment showing up.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:37:10
      Thank you.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:37:17
      We have some great folks out there working this stuff.
    • 00:37:23
      Now for the hard news.
    • 00:37:27
      What's that?
    • 00:37:30
      Well, right now, 60 to 70.
    • 00:37:33
      And these haven't shown up yet.
    • 00:37:34
      The billings are typically 30 to 60.
    • 00:37:37
      You know, the companies go back, bill this.
    • 00:37:39
      So the vast majority hasn't shown up.
    • 00:37:42
      So what we're doing right now is going through budget.
    • 00:37:45
      And if we wait for it to show up and find out exactly how much it is, it's too late because we're hitting the end of the budget cycle right now for 1st of July.
    • 00:37:53
      So what we're doing now is starting some budget reduction bureaus.
    • 00:37:57
      And that drill is, we think the estimate's 60 to 70 million.
    • 00:38:00
      Winter's not over yet.
    • 00:38:02
      The days are getting longer.
    • 00:38:03
      So we probably won't have deep freezes after this.
    • 00:38:07
      But our what if goes out to what if it's as much as $100 million.
    • 00:38:11
      So we're going to go through drills right now.
    • 00:38:13
      The other thing that we have done with the asphalt work is we've pushed that forward about as far as we can against the money.
    • 00:38:19
      So we're starting to back up a little bit on that to make sure we don't go over those numbers.
    • 00:38:25
      This is going to be a hard drill for the rest of the year because this has been a very severe winter.
    • 00:38:31
      And we will see this.
    • 00:38:32
      I'd like to keep it as invisible as we can.
    • 00:38:34
      But there's some things we can do on some of that.
    • 00:38:37
      W. Smith Jr.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:54
      I understand when you look at the budget on your previous slide you may be able to see
    • 00:39:17
      Let me answer it in two ways.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:39:42
      When you have a more severe winter, there generally is more breakup because of the freeze and the thaw.
    • 00:39:47
      And we're seeing that.
    • 00:39:48
      We already had a condition where we had many of these roads had to have more work done to them because they'd been neglected for a long time.
    • 00:39:55
      And that was the turnaround we were talking about with getting secondary money.
    • 00:39:59
      So it's going to be tighter going forward.
    • 00:40:02
      We've gotten money from our elected representatives.
    • 00:40:08
      We've got about $3 billion a year.
    • 00:40:10
      between the construction program, the maintenance program, or not the year, but over the six-year period.
    • 00:40:15
      We're probably, with the revised program, going to have to back off that a little bit to 2.8 or something.
    • 00:40:22
      And we're going through that drill or 2.7 or whatever that number ends up being.
    • 00:40:26
      So that's going to delay getting to some of those roads.
    • 00:40:29
      So from what we thought we had at the end of the, depending on where revenue projections are up or down.
    • 00:40:35
      And what we will do is we will have projects ready to go
    • 00:40:38
      to flex up or down as far as that money will take us.
    • 00:40:42
      But you're right, $100 million will affect us.
    • 00:40:45
      What we will try to do is things like delay equipment purchases a little bit into the next year, but you can only do that so long.
    • 00:40:52
      We will try to do things like if we have contract work, we're already paying for our VDOT employees that we're removing the snow.
    • 00:40:59
      We may say, okay, they'll mow, and we have that sunk cost instead of bringing a contract run.
    • 00:41:05
      So we have some budget reduction.
    • 00:41:06
      We will try not to take those
    • 00:41:08
      At a pavement where we can.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:10
      We don't because we don't look at it annually.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:41:27
      We look at it over the six-year program.
    • 00:41:29
      So this is an up year.
    • 00:41:32
      But we've had some lighter years in the past, so we do not look at it on a year-to-year basis, to answer your question.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:41:39
      The Commissioner wants to respond to you too, Mr. Sterling.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:42
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 00:41:43
      One of the things that Garrett has mentioned here, and I want to really reinforce this, over the six years, we are planning approximately $3 billion worth of pavement work throughout the state, which, again, do the math, it's about $500 million a year.
    • 00:42:01
      Now, we're trying to balance that against some revenue reductions we've talked about, but it is still a significant program statewide in terms of pushing money into our payment condition.
    • 00:42:15
      And, Garrett, we're looking at somewhere in excess of a billion dollars on the secondary system alone.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:42:21
      About a billion over six years.
    • 00:42:23
      We're taking that back with the new revenues.
    • 00:42:25
      We're looking to see how that falls out.
    • 00:42:27
      We're still working that.
    • 00:42:29
      But, no.
    • 00:42:31
      Higher degradation or lower degradation a year isn't, you know, we can only push as far as the money will allow us and that just means it's, we'd like to do it faster but we can only push as far as the money will allow us.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:41
      We talked about the payment rating system which breaks the worst, best to worst.
    • 00:42:47
      So, Mr. Sterling, to your point about these roads that are deteriorating, the likelihood is that the roads that are deteriorating the worst were the worst rated roads in terms of payment ratings.
    • 00:42:58
      So, again,
    • 00:43:00
      You typically won't have a roadway that has an excellent pavement rating all of a sudden come apart on you.
    • 00:43:06
      It just doesn't happen that way.
    • 00:43:09
      So again, in terms of, you're generally doing worst first in terms of the pavement, especially the heavy pavement work that we'll be doing.
    • 00:43:18
      This will be challenging.
    • 00:43:19
      We may need to be looking at moving some resources around in terms of, especially on the secondary and some on the primary system on where
    • 00:43:29
      which roads we are doing first but again in terms of sort of the batting order the ones that you're saying they're in bad shape are more likely the ones that are are have been already rated and are ones we have our eye on so you're saying the incremental excuse me
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:47
      The incremental cost may not be as high as we might think because it was already going to be done anyway.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:54
      To an extent, yes sir.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:57
      To an extent.
    • 00:43:59
      So it's mitigated.
    • 00:44:00
      I'm hoping that's the case.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:01
      But I don't want folks to think that the need will always exceed the budget in terms of these projects.
    • 00:44:12
      We are working aggressively to raise the bar, especially on our secondary system, up to 65% in each of our nine construction districts.
    • 00:44:22
      So with that, that's a big effort on our part to bring up the quality of the pavement on our secondary system.
    • 00:44:29
      We're not going to let the primary or the interstate go at the same time.
    • 00:44:33
      We still have that same high bar district by district on those systems.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:37
      Mr. Chairman, what I was trying to
    • 00:44:40
      I guess what sort of intrigued me or shocked me, if we have a 250 million dollars in money spent this year, somewhere between 60 to 70 over budget of 157 million, so it's somewhere in the 230 to 250 million dollars of standard money, that's a sixth of our construction budget.
    • 00:45:04
      It's a seventh of our maintenance budget, and it's half of our pavement budget.
    • 00:45:11
      Wow.
    • 00:45:12
      Just to get the snow off the road.
    • 00:45:15
      So, you know, I don't know how you mitigate that, other than prayer, but that's a huge percentage.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:45:24
      Last year we had a great year.
    • 00:45:26
      We had a great year.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:27
      And that's a huge percentage of the money that, you know, when you're talking a six-year construction budget,
    • 00:45:33
      or a seventh of your maintenance budget or half of your new pavement budget, half of it is equal to what we're paying just to get the snow off the road in 2013-2014.
    • 00:45:46
      That's a huge number.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:45:49
      Along this line, the chemicals that we're putting down, have we noticed if that is leading to increased degradation of the asphalt?
    • 00:46:02
      I mean, I guess what I'm getting at is, do we do the early studies to find out if there's things that can improve different chemicals being used, and we have less impact?
    • 00:46:12
      I know in some cases, like with bridges and stuff, some of that calcium and everything getting underneath has some impact on the steel, and I'm just wondering if it's anything that's causing the road to break up a little more.
    • 00:46:25
      I know for instance, I've always wondered if that's going to have an impact on asphalt anyway.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:46:28
      I would want to go back, and we've done stuff in the past.
    • 00:46:32
      What we are doing now is, for instance, using brine, in many cases, to pretreat because that is a factor that may have some impact.
    • 00:46:42
      I think it's hard to quantify.
    • 00:46:43
      The bigger impacts are the freeze and thaw with water in there, and that tends to break it up first, and so it's very difficult to separate one cause
    • 00:46:53
      from the other, which is causing it, you can say that yes, we've put more salt down and you might find a correlation.
    • 00:47:01
      As far as saying it's one over the other, I would want to go back and get our research data, but we've looked at it.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:47:07
      And I would think maybe the asphalt companies are looking at some of these things.
    • 00:47:11
      The point being is that if it is a particular chemical that's breaking down the asphalt and having an impact on it, there might be some change in the asphalt mix or through something when you put new asphalt down, it might have an impact.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:47:23
      Temperature has a significant impact.
    • 00:47:26
      If you had salt on the road and it wasn't freezing, it's not going to happen.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:47:29
      And we've made some adjustments to our bridges on the interstates where we're using either stainless and another high use bridges we're using an MMFX steel which is corrosion resistant and it's expensive when you look at the material but it's a marginal increase when you look at the total bridge cost but it's the maintenance future maintenance and lack of having to replace decks or something so we're doing some things on that side
    • 00:47:59
      to also try to expand life and not have to go back in on the life cycle cost on it.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:48:04
      Thank you, Mr. Traylor.
    • 00:48:05
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:48:05
      I'm recognizing that the weather is always difficult to predict and some years are good years and some years are bad years.
    • 00:48:12
      What do we do, if anything, to try to flatten this line out in our budget so that we do have a special account where we can draw down all that?
    • 00:48:21
      I assume we do, but I just want to make sure.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:23
      One of the, you heard a discussion earlier about our condition maybe five years, four to five years ago where we were caring for a maintenance balance of in excess of $500 million.
    • 00:48:35
      A balance, now a lot of that was obligated to projects but again it was still that kind of balance that we were carrying forward.
    • 00:48:44
      We put a lot of effort into getting that balance down and getting the work out on the street
    • 00:48:49
      We've been through a lot of pavement work, bridge work, and a number of things in our maintenance program to reduce that balance.
    • 00:48:57
      We've consciously kept the reserve account fairly small.
    • 00:49:03
      As was mentioned earlier, the last several years we actually have come in within our snow allocation and in at least a couple of years slightly under.
    • 00:49:13
      That money was immediately rolled back into other projects.
    • 00:49:16
      The challenge of adding some amount of additional money for that snowstorm that occurred, last time we had snow like this was four years ago.
    • 00:49:28
      2009, 2010, that was a big year for it.
    • 00:49:31
      So, for us to park money becomes, I think the challenge then is, can you, if the money sits until, let's say we say, well we're okay by the end of February that snow is
    • 00:49:45
      Largely dissipated, we have a pretty good idea of what's left.
    • 00:49:48
      You only have three months to get work done because it had to be billed in that year, so you end up with this balance.
    • 00:49:58
      As Garrett's been talking, and he's going to continue to go through this in terms of how are we going to mitigate this, this is not the first time that this has happened.
    • 00:50:06
      This cycle occurs over the careers of the folks at PDOT.
    • 00:50:11
      have occurred a number of times where we've managed through this.
    • 00:50:15
      One of the things that I think is important is that this is important and something we have to address.
    • 00:50:22
      I don't look at it as a crisis.
    • 00:50:24
      It's part of our business that we have to do.
    • 00:50:27
      We will make adjustments to our expenditures to ensure that we can cover our costs.
    • 00:50:35
      Are there some things that we will defer?
    • 00:50:36
      Yes, likely we will.
    • 00:50:38
      But we're going to do it in a way that I'll call it will not have a knee-jerk impact to the public.
    • 00:50:48
      We are going to continue to pass potholes.
    • 00:50:50
      We're going to continue to do the things that we have to do to maintain a viable system.
    • 00:50:55
      But again, that's kind of the balance is how much do you keep in the account?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:51:00
      I understand, and I understand that the emphasis has been on getting the maintenance money out on the street, and I get that.
    • 00:51:06
      But we're not just talking about once every hundred years.
    • 00:51:10
      It's not the volume of the snow.
    • 00:51:12
      It's the number of times it snows.
    • 00:51:14
      Yes.
    • 00:51:14
      It's also a factor.
    • 00:51:15
      And that, just like any insurance, you can take that over six years and get a pretty accurate number of how many times you're going to have to deal with a snowstorm.
    • 00:51:24
      And I'm just saying, if you do that and try to, I mean, I'm not advocating here.
    • 00:51:29
      It's probably not the thing to do it.
    • 00:51:31
      I was seeing if we did it, and the answer is we don't.
    • 00:51:33
      We borrow, beg, and steal when we have a bad year, and then when we have a good year, we spend the money on maintenance.
    • 00:51:39
      That's what we do.
    • 00:51:40
      That's the plan.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:51:40
      Well, what you do is like in the prior years, we got a few more roads paid that hopefully kept them from deteriorating.
    • 00:51:46
      Well, I'm not saying just throwing the money away.
    • 00:51:49
      Right.
    • 00:51:49
      It's right.
    • 00:51:50
      And the 150 is our historical average.
    • 00:51:54
      That's where they come up with it.
    • 00:51:57
      Mark, I'm here to speak.
    • 00:51:59
      Thank you.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:59
      I remember the last one and we came in and it was way over budget.
    • 00:52:04
      I know when we had the good years, like the last two, probably two or three, when you roll it in the roads, but I don't remember us ever discussing what projects it's going to go into.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:52:15
      Went into paving.
    • 00:52:16
      You're right, you did.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:17
      I know, but we don't, we're never told we have this much money left from snow and we're going to put it into whatever projects.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:52:27
      So you want me to tell you where we're going to pull it from this year?
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:29
      Well, no, I think that's accurate.
    • 00:52:33
      We do have good years.
    • 00:52:34
      I think we should be briefed on how much we pay larger.
    • 00:52:39
      So let's bring back where we're going to get the money and show what projects the paving and what have you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:53:07
      That's a good point.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:53:07
      And this is just to give you some ideas of the things we're looking at in this budget reduction drill for the rest of the year.
    • 00:53:22
      And the rest is just the Governor showed up and the Secretary to look at our folks here in central office, getting some good comments around the state and we're still improving what we're doing everywhere.
    • 00:53:35
      and just wanted to kind of share some of those things that we're trying to always improve our folks are doing some good things out there and very much appreciate the opportunity to present it to you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:53:45
      I'd like to make one comment and not just to the public is that we are we have money so if we have another major source we'll respond the same way just want to make sure everybody understands that
    • 00:53:57
      That is primary one safety and our response to that.
    • 00:54:01
      So just, it's expensive, but that's what we'll do.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:07
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:54:10
      I don't know about the other areas, but I just wanted to mention to Mr. Kaiser earlier, the people of my area have responded back and they're very pleased with the
    • 00:54:20
      Quickness and professional work that's done during these storms and how fast everyone mobilized to get it taken care of.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:31
      It's a pretty good response.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:54:33
      Mr. Fairland made the right point.
    • 00:54:35
      You're going to have to mobilize whether you think it's going to be five inches or 20 inches in that regard.
    • 00:54:43
      Part of it is just the fact of getting it mobilized.
    • 00:54:47
      You're going to spend the money whether you respond quickly or not.
    • 00:54:50
      So we might as well respond quickly and do it right.
    • 00:54:53
      And that's really what we've been pushing here.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:54:57
      And we try to push it when it's powder.
    • 00:54:59
      Some people sometimes think you can save by delaying.
    • 00:55:01
      But if you're pushing ice, if you're spending as much or more trying to get the ice up, we try to get it out quick.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:55:09
      Okay, the next topic is Mr. Moore will stay up here.
    • 00:55:13
      Part of the responsibility of this board is as an arbitrator if we have disagreements with some decisions made by VDOT.
    • 00:55:24
      The next is a decision taken by VDOT and we have in the audit Mr. Ezenhart is in the audience.
    • 00:55:32
      who wants to put before us his reason why he disagrees with the decision made by the chief engineer.
    • 00:55:40
      So, Mr. Garrett Moore will present the decision and then we'll also have a chance to hear from Mr. Eginhart and then determine whether or not it wants to take any action from that.
    • 00:55:54
      So, Mr. Moore.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 00:55:57
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:55:57
      I'd very much like to thank the board for
    • 00:56:01
      Hearing Mr. Easonhart's request for you to review the response that we gave him.
    • 00:56:09
      This is a limited access change request to Route 360 in Amelia County.
    • 00:56:13
      As you recall at the last board meeting we actually brought you a limited access change in another region of the state that we did recommend for approval and there was some discussion about protecting
    • 00:56:26
      the among the board about protecting the the right-of-way and these purchases that have been made by the Commonwealth in the past and so what we put here is the section of code of Virginia and what how it defines a limited access highway and then in the bottom bullet there it talks about the procedures are defined by administrative code so it's something we've acquired to have a certain type of facility
    • 00:56:52
      These generally, or not generally, these do not have commercial and private individual entrances to them.
    • 00:56:59
      They can be grade separated.
    • 00:57:01
      You can have public roads come in at grade, but there's a certain type of facility that's built and are protected and so forth.
    • 00:57:09
      This is an overview of the location, and there's a little star in the center where the change request is.
    • 00:57:17
      And Tom Hawthorne from Richmond District has been working with the applicant on this.
    • 00:57:22
      We'll hear his concerns and where to take that.
    • 00:57:28
      One of the things that we have asked Tom to do is to try to see are there things we can do outside of this to help his situation.
    • 00:57:38
      These may or may not work for him.
    • 00:57:41
      In the past, there has been some issues here about a public road and some economic development.
    • 00:57:48
      These are conditions where if we have the right traffic, we would
    • 00:57:51
      in supporting economic development jobs, we like to do that, but this to us is an individual inference which is not something, which is exactly at cross purposes with limited access.
    • 00:58:03
      So a couple of comments.
    • 00:58:08
      When the request is a break and he has a bed and breakfast there and current access is by a railway and I'll go back there.
    • 00:58:19
      Go back to the drawing, there's actually a railroad kind of difficult to see there, but his access is through Eastman's and several properties, and I denied the request, and we are working some other things to maybe improve the railway there, and we'll know something on that in the next three months, and I would just leave it at that to allow the board to review and see if
    • 00:58:44
      If you believe our actions were correct or not, I very much appreciate your taking the time and his taking the time to present his position.
    • 00:58:53
      Thank you very much.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:58:56
      Mr. E. Hart, would you like to address the board?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:59:04
      My name is Steve Eisenhart.
    • 00:59:10
      I would like to talk with you about requesting the access, limited access to Highway 360 at a location called the Raleigh Parish Glebe.
    • 00:59:28
      There were originally 43 Glebes
    • 00:59:31
      Parrish is in Virginia.
    • 00:59:33
      There are only seven remaining.
    • 00:59:35
      My wife and I bought this Raleigh Parish Glee 25 years ago, restored it with the idea of retiring, opening this as a bed and breakfast for our retiring years.
    • 00:59:48
      What I wanted to talk with you just generally the purpose, some of the technical and economic issues that I've worked with Mr. Hawthorne over the last several months about and I'd like to
    • 01:00:00
      Just to recap some of those, I didn't realize that there were this many people on the commission.
    • 01:00:06
      So I only brought 10 copies of all the correspondence that I've had with Tom over the year.
    • 01:00:13
      It's been almost a year.
    • 01:00:16
      I'd like to request a repeal of the denial of access to Highway 360, as we'll talk about in just a minute.
    • 01:00:26
      I originally made the request for a low volume access only on eastbound lane of Highway 360.
    • 01:00:35
      and only for the purpose of having access to the bed and breakfast.
    • 01:00:40
      The reason for that is because the access that I have now is limited through two easements.
    • 01:00:47
      I do not connect directly to state maintained highway, so it's problematic for me to be able to do any kind of improvements that I need to do to allow visitors to the county to get access to my highway.
    • 01:01:03
      In addition to that, the access is across railroad tracks.
    • 01:01:08
      The railroad tracks that are on the southern side of my property have been a site of, there was a fatality on a very similar access about 10 years ago where a young lady was killed on trying to get across railroad tracks onto 360 to come to work in the morning.
    • 01:01:30
      I found out just two days ago there was another train car collision in Amelia County.
    • 01:01:38
      So it causes me great concern.
    • 01:01:44
      I understand that the denial was based on
    • 01:01:49
      The original construction of the highway in 1964 and the intention to limit siphoning off business from the county areas as it was designed.
    • 01:02:03
      This is the Raleigh Parish Glebe built in 1774 so it's a really old property and is worth preserving.
    • 01:02:13
      The low volume access, I only have five rooms in the bed and breakfast so it would be a very low volume access.
    • 01:02:23
      Currently there's no direct access to a state maintained highway.
    • 01:02:27
      There were previous actions by chief engineers in the last 10 years for industrial development where the chief engineers supported limited access to Highway 360.
    • 01:02:40
      Again, I would only go to eastbound 360.
    • 01:02:44
      I would not intend to have any kind of crossover or any of those.
    • 01:02:49
      This is the proposed access.
    • 01:02:52
      I had the technical studies done and it shows that it's not a technical issue.
    • 01:02:59
      You'll see looking west and looking east from the intended access point that there are no impediments.
    • 01:03:10
      Economic issues, if you look at the, I have two maps that I had sent out.
    • 01:03:16
      The first one was similar to the map that our chief engineer showed.
    • 01:03:22
      This shows some of the growth in Amelia County recently.
    • 01:03:26
      You can see that there's a tremendous amount of clustered business that's away from this area that has been restricted.
    • 01:03:34
      And you'll notice that just in the middle part where I am in the shaded part of the center, there's been no economic activity at all.
    • 01:03:44
      It's been all up on Highway 360 and it's been away from the place where we have this restriction.
    • 01:03:50
      So rather than allowing economic access near the center of the courthouse, it's now up on 360 half a mile in either direction.
    • 01:04:02
      and it is relatively clustered and if you look at the next point, 183 individual accesses to Highway 360 in Amelia County.
    • 01:04:16
      These are at-grade accesses.
    • 01:04:19
      Thirty-six percent of those accesses are private drives.
    • 01:04:22
      They connect directly
    • 01:04:24
      to Highway 360.
    • 01:04:26
      Twenty-eight percent are road intersections or state-maintained roads and then thirty-six percent are industrial development access to Highway 360.
    • 01:04:35
      So if the concern is not clustering the highway with this short mile and a half section, the horse is already out of the barn.
    • 01:04:43
      I mean, this is not going to solve that problem.
    • 01:04:47
      And if you go half a mile in either direction, you'll see that the economic development has been siphoned away from the courthouse area proper.
    • 01:04:58
      And I do have support as listed there, the Board of Supervisors, unanimous support for this limited access.
    • 01:05:07
      The County Administrator and my Congressman and State Senator.
    • 01:05:13
      And on the end of this property, this is former Senator Eva Scott owns that property.
    • 01:05:20
      So there are very few people that actually have land up on this section.
    • 01:05:25
      Economic issues getting us access.
    • 01:05:29
      We have a lot of travelers through Amelia who want to take the route of Lee's Retreat.
    • 01:05:33
      Lee's Retreat, of course, came right through Amelia and actually were bivouacked on my property waiting for resupply from Richmond.
    • 01:05:41
      So it's a historically significant area.
    • 01:05:45
      It is also a Revolutionary War site having
    • 01:05:48
      survived the Revolutionary War.
    • 01:05:51
      This is one of the few remaining houses that can claim that.
    • 01:05:56
      We hope to have not only a bed and breakfast but a restaurant and I've been exploring the possibility of winery and a tap house.
    • 01:06:05
      So that is a possibility there as well.
    • 01:06:08
      So what I'm asking for is
    • 01:06:11
      to overturn the denial of access to 360, this low volume access.
    • 01:06:18
      And the restriction, I understand from Mr. Hawthorne, the restriction was placed to try to limit the cluster or limit the amount of access.
    • 01:06:29
      And this is just one.
    • 01:06:31
      I do not, hopefully, will gain access to 360.
    • 01:06:37
      It will prevent me from having to cross the railroad tracks
    • 01:06:41
      Having to go across these easements is a very difficult thing for me to build into my viable business or make my business more viable.
    • 01:06:52
      And that's it.
    • 01:06:55
      Thank you for your time.
    • 01:06:56
      I know what I've talked about is minuscule compared to some of the issues that you all have talked about today, but I do appreciate the time and opportunity to come and talk with you.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:06
      Mr. Sterling.
    • 01:07:09
      When you purchased this property, when?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:07:16
      About 25 years ago.
    • 01:07:22
      I enjoyed the fact that it was sequestered because I was babbled on one side by the railroad tracks, on the other side by the highway, and I never really considered that I would ever want to open it and have that kind of access.
    • 01:07:36
      And when I talked with my neighbors about
    • 01:07:38
      Coming here today and talking with you all about getting access. They don't want to get access to Highway 360. The only reason that I'm doing this is to support this bed and breakfast. But over the years, I didn't realize that there was this kind of a problem with this. And I may have misunderstood. You said this is for the purpose of this bed and breakfast. Yes, sir. But then...
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:02
      In your later slide, you talked about a winery and a tap house.
    • 01:08:06
      Are you also talking about putting a winery and a tap house there?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:08:09
      That's something that can happen down the road.
    • 01:08:14
      There is 50 acres that I own, basically 50 acres, and I thought that a nice pastoral setting like that would support a winery.
    • 01:08:24
      and, you know, support the bed and breakfast.
    • 01:08:26
      So it would be, again, low-volume business and it would be limited development.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:35
      But it would be not just a bed and breakfast, it would be a bed and breakfast at 10,000 standard wine.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:08:40
      Yeah, possibly, yes.
    • 01:08:42
      But my immediate concern is to do the bed and breakfast.
    • 01:08:45
      Long-term, I think that using the land for farming
    • 01:08:51
      For an agribusiness, I think a winery would be something that I would consider, but I personally don't want to see housing development in there, and I want to protect the sanctity of this old house.
    • 01:09:07
      From the agribusiness standpoint, I thought that would be a possibility.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:09:13
      Mr. Miller's name.
    • 01:09:14
      We can get this up on Google Earth, if the board would like to see this on Google Earth.
    • 01:09:19
      Okay, so could you get this up for us?
    • 01:09:24
      Did you have a question while we're getting it up, Mr. Miller?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:26
      Yes, sir, I did.
    • 01:09:27
      Mr. Eisenhower, I understand what you're trying to accomplish.
    • 01:09:36
      Parcel A, Parcel B, and Parcel C on these maps.
    • 01:09:39
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:09:40
      Are they all owned by other folks other than you and your family or your business partners?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:09:47
      I have the part in the center and then Parcel B, probably.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:53
      Okay, so you own Parcel B and the piece is listed with your name on it.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:09:58
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:09:59
      Al and Charlie are owned by the same person as Ms. Cleaner.
    • 01:10:05
      Okay.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:09
      So in terms of your ingress and egress, you've got to go across partial C, which is right at the end.
    • 01:10:27
      Your ingress and egress is right at the end of the end-of-state maintenance on Route 1015.
    • 01:10:34
      And then you've got a
    • 01:10:37
      A short distance appears to be fairly short distance, maybe about 100 feet.
    • 01:10:47
      About a hundred feet, you've got about 30 yards of right-of-way across a parcel of seed that is impacted, that you feel makes it difficult for you to improve your right-of-way. Don't you have a, I have some right-of-wayish stuff in my portfolio. Don't you have a right to, and maybe I'm not asking the right person, but don't we have rights to maintain right-of-ways to reasonable conditions to begin with? Thank you.
    • 01:11:17
      You've got a right of way over somebody's property.
    • 01:11:20
      I think you've got a road there.
    • 01:11:21
      You've got a right to maintain that road to the standards that were sort of there when you acquired it.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:11:26
      I think when we bought these, I think the Commissioner speaks as to when we bought these, they bought the easements with it.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:33
      No, I'm talking about his easement across parcel C.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:36
      You're talking here's the right of way.
    • 01:11:37
      Yeah, here's the right of way, not always.
    • 01:11:39
      Oh, and he has the right of way.
    • 01:11:41
      Yeah, Mr. Eisenhower has the right of way.
    • 01:11:42
      Yeah, he can't.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:43
      One of the issues here is.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:11:44
      And he can't be blocked off by one of his.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:46
      Yeah, but he also can't not maintain it either.
    • 01:11:49
      Right.
    • 01:11:50
      I mean, if you have 28 ruts in it that are three feet deep, then it's, you know, it's not.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:11:55
      You have the right to go fix it.
    • 01:11:56
      You have the right to go fix it.
    • 01:11:57
      That's right.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:58
      So, in essence, from my perspective.
    • 01:12:00
      Yeah, that's right.
    • 01:12:02
      The thing that you really can't impact one way or the other is the railroad.
    • 01:12:08
      You're not changing the railroad.
    • 01:12:09
      You're going to go across the track.
    • 01:12:11
      That's that.
    • 01:12:13
      But in terms of maintaining the right-of-way, most of that right-of-way is across your own property.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:12:18
      Yes, but it's a dirt road.
    • 01:12:22
      And the house that's right on the end of that road, the porch of that house is right next to the dirt road.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:12:29
      So I can't wipe it.
    • 01:12:30
      I can't improve it.
    • 01:12:32
      All I can do is keep the dirt on the roads.
    • 01:12:36
      And I'm right on the porch of that little house that's right next door to me.
    • 01:12:39
      So that's my difficulty.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:12:40
      I can't even make a two-lane accident.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:12:41
      You can't go on your property and make two lanes?
    • 01:12:44
      Sure could.
    • 01:12:45
      Sure could.
    • 01:12:47
      Yeah.
    • 01:12:47
      That's right.
    • 01:12:47
      We're talking Parcel C. Oh, Parcel C. So the house is on one side.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:52
      It'll help if we get in on that.
    • 01:12:53
      The house is on one side.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:12:55
      Very, very close to the east.
    • 01:12:57
      How about on the other side?
    • 01:12:58
      There's a fence.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:00
      So you're between two albums?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:13:02
      Yes, sir.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:03
      And how wide is your easement?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:13:06
      It's 20 feet.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:07
      20 feet.
    • 01:13:09
      Okay, thank you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:13:10
      Mr. Cole.
    • 01:13:11
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:13:12
      A question I think is relevant.
    • 01:13:14
      Mr. Moore, if memory serves to be correct, 360 in this stretch is carrying about an average daily count of 15,000.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:13:25
      I don't have an exact number, but that's out of context.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:13:36
      Thank you.
    • 01:13:36
      I think that's relevant.
    • 01:13:37
      I think Ms. Tonkin then will come back.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:40
      Just for my own clarification, you've done the property for 25 years.
    • 01:13:45
      How long have you been operating?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:13:46
      Oh, we haven't opened yet.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:13:47
      We haven't opened because I don't have to take any action.
    • 01:13:52
      I should explain to the board what
    • 01:14:08
      Your role is you can decide to take no action and you can decide to make a recommendation to overrule the chief engineer's ruling.
    • 01:14:23
      We can defer.
    • 01:14:24
      We can defer, that's right.
    • 01:14:26
      This is an opportunity for the strides and hard to come
    • 01:14:31
      But there is no action required.
    • 01:14:35
      You can take an action or you can just defer, you know, and say, you know, that's your options here.
    • 01:14:41
      So, but the law requires to have an advocacy to come to override to this board if we choose to the chief engineer's decision.
    • 01:14:53
      Yeah.
    • 01:14:53
      Did you, Ms. Thompson, she was next.
    • 01:14:57
      Okay.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:57
      Yes.
    • 01:14:58
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 01:14:59
      I am going to make a motion to defer, but I want to hear from Mr. Eisenhower.
    • 01:15:05
      What I kind of would not like to have is all 16 of us going through easements and land rights and this and that during the course of our meeting.
    • 01:15:14
      I don't think it's necessarily productive.
    • 01:15:17
      I think it's a serious issue and I understand Mr. Eisenhower's concerns, and I think to the extent that we have specific questions that he can answer,
    • 01:15:25
      We should get him while he's here and then I would probably like to hear some more from Mr. Moore regarding how the Wiley concluded that I don't think necessarily it's beneficial to go through all of this whole routine in front of everybody today but Mike should have some discussions and then vote on it at the next meeting because it is a serious issue.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:15:47
      Mr. Cole.
    • 01:15:48
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:15:49
      I would
    • 01:15:50
      I would not seek any action from the board, you know, with it being in my district.
    • 01:15:59
      As Mr. Eisenhower has said, our district administrator as well as chief engineer have worked
    • 01:16:06
      Through this process for the last year, Mr. Eisenhower has been extremely reasonable.
    • 01:16:11
      We have not exhausted all of the other alternatives, and so I think it would be very premature to take any action, whether it be deferral or otherwise, at this point.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:22
      I don't think you can defer this kind of motion.
    • 01:16:24
      There's nothing to defer, right?
    • 01:16:26
      Yeah, there's nothing to defer.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:16:27
      We just have no action, so we don't need a motion if we just take no action.
    • 01:16:30
      In fact, if we did anything, it would be in the formal session.
    • 01:16:35
      Let me come back to Mr. Ellis, and I'll come over to you, Mr. Fralin.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:16:38
      Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:16:40
      Yes, I concur with Mr. Peake, and I'd like to hear more information than you will speak with the district engineer first before making any contact.
    • 01:16:49
      There are a lot of different issues here.
    • 01:16:54
      We don't know about the background and so forth.
    • 01:16:59
      Before taking any action, there's more information one-on-one.
    • 01:17:04
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:17:06
      I'm sorry we haven't met, but I'm one of the guys that thinks we grant too many of these, so I'm not favorable to it.
    • 01:17:15
      I think, you know, unless we feel like we're going to do this, I think we're kind of prolonging the agony for no reason.
    • 01:17:21
      I mean, I'm fine with putting it off another month and working on it and doing all that
    • 01:17:28
      As far as I'm concerned, I'm willing to make a motion that we defer to the staff.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:17:37
      That would be appropriately made in the action portion of our meeting if we decide to do that.
    • 01:17:43
      Any action we would take would be in that portion.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:17:47
      Is there any more questions?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:17:55
      My understanding is that for me to get access, I would have to reimburse the state for the increased value of my property given I would get the access.
    • 01:18:07
      So in other words, if the value of my property right now is $100,000 and it would be $200,000 with the access, then I would have to reimburse the state $100,000.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:18:19
      Yeah, just when you're up with the actual cost of the improvement would be the VDOT.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:24
      Well, there would be no cost in terms of a commercial entrance, whether it's a low volume or a full commercial entrance is the obligation of the permittee.
    • 01:18:33
      So in terms of the construction part, that would be the permittee's responsibility.
    • 01:18:37
      In addition to that, when we purchased this right-of-way back in, I believe, the 1960s, we purchased that.
    • 01:18:47
      There was a value to that access right.
    • 01:18:50
      Now, today,
    • 01:18:52
      Frankly, if we were to buy this right-of-way today, we would value it differently than we did in the 60s, and it would likely cost us, forgetting inflation and all that, but it would likely cost us significantly more if we were to purchase it today.
    • 01:19:12
      But today, every day, we're purchasing right-of-way, sometimes limited access, and when we do that, we not only pay the value of the property,
    • 01:19:21
      We buy the right away from that particular property owner and pay the damages that goes along with that.
    • 01:19:28
      So, again, I don't know what we paid for it back in the 60s, but I could tell you today, not just the value of the land, but other damages because of changes in the Code of Virginia, we would pay significantly more today than in terms of relative number.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:19:46
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:19:50
      Charlie, on another issue, would this access require a deceleration?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:59
      It really depends on the volume of traffic.
    • 01:20:02
      There's an engineering analysis that's conducted.
    • 01:20:05
      I don't know whether we've even gotten to that point yet in terms of the amount of improvements, whether it's simple taper
    • 01:20:12
      would be sufficient under our regulations or a full term?
    • 01:20:16
      I just don't know that answer.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:20:17
      The reason I ask that question is because of the potential for the winery and that type of thing in the future.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:23
      Sometimes, you know, I know that we have required these things because of that potential.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:20:28
      Well, we typically have a limited access load for a reason.
    • 01:20:32
      And unless we think that reason's changed, you know, we typically don't grant additional access.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:42
      I'm not going to seek an answer today, but if lawyers, as they look at this and provide us information, one of the things that we'd like to know, because we've heard bed and breakfast and we heard winery and tap house, understand that you're not talking about residential development, but can we even put a restriction, if we give a limited, an access on limited access,
    • 01:21:00
      I don't think we can restrict any future development on what would use that.
    • 01:21:05
      So we can't say, well, it's just for these purposes.
    • 01:21:07
      So if the lawyers, as part of that, can let us know what restrictions we need to put on it.
    • 01:21:12
      Otherwise, we could see a...
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:21:15
      There is a zoning restriction nowadays.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:17
      There's zoning at a locality that's not at the board.
    • 01:21:19
      Right.
    • 01:21:20
      We know.
    • 01:21:20
      It meets the zoning requirements.
    • 01:21:22
      I don't think CTB can do that.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:21:24
      Yes.
    • 01:21:25
      Secretary, I would like to suggest that since all of us seem to have
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:21:29
      A. Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John C.
    • 01:21:49
      All right, if there's no more questions from the board here, then we'll, Mr. Cole, we'll leave it up to you if you want to bring this motion, this issue back up before the board.
    • 01:21:58
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:22:00
      Thank you, thank you.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:22:01
      I'd love for your time today.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:22:05
      Okay.
    • 01:22:05
      Okay, we have Mr. Bruehl for our, oh boy, Transportation All-Terms Program.
    • 01:22:11
      The money grab, huh?
    • 01:22:13
      Good morning.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:22:15
      It's time for our annual
    • 01:22:18
      I'll update on the Transportation Alternatives Program, the applications that we've received as part of our annual application process.
    • 01:22:26
      Just to give you a little bit of background, Transportation Alternatives is a federal program.
    • 01:22:31
      It went through some rather substantial changes with the new federal transportation bill that was passed just a couple of years ago.
    • 01:22:38
      But as a refresher, the funding that's available includes Transportation Alternatives Project, Safe Routes to School Project,
    • 01:22:46
      and the Recreational Trails Program set aside that goes to the Department of Conservation and Recreation.
    • 01:22:52
      We have ten eligibility categories that are established in federal law and we have a rather complex selection process that's also established by federal law that we're working within.
    • 01:23:02
      We work in partnership with the MPOs in the Northern Virginia area of Richmond, Hampton Roads and Roanoke.
    • 01:23:10
      As they make selections alongside of us, we have worked with them to have one cohesive application and selection process.
    • 01:23:19
      To give you a refresher on the policy, the board adopted a new selection policy in July of last year based on the changes that were part of MAP-21.
    • 01:23:29
      The board has put a lot of effort into trying to select projects and fully fund those projects to get them through the pipeline and onto construction quickly.
    • 01:23:37
      And as such, the current policy states that selected projects are going to receive not less than 50% of what they request.
    • 01:23:45
      If a project is a small request of $200,000 or less, that request would be fully funded if that amount would complete the project.
    • 01:23:54
      One other modification we made in our last policy update is that we put a requirement that all projects that are selected must be under construction within four years of the first allocation that that project gets, with the emphasis on getting projects funded through the pipeline and out of the system as quickly as possible.
    • 01:24:13
      Next slide just is a refresher.
    • 01:24:15
      These are the eligible categories that we can receive applications for.
    • 01:24:18
      They're set out in federal law.
    • 01:24:21
      We have received, predominantly our applications have been bicycle-pedestrian type projects that fall in those first three categories.
    • 01:24:30
      To give you a summary in terms of what applications we did receive, we received 75 applications requesting a total of $27 million.
    • 01:24:37
      We're anticipating a little less than $19 million to be available statewide after that rip trail distribution to the Department of Conservation and Recreation.
    • 01:24:47
      Those funds are then distributed based on a federal formula.
    • 01:24:51
      The MPO areas that make selections are receiving just shy of $6 million.
    • 01:24:56
      The district members would each receive $1 million for their selections for a total of $9 million and then the at-large member and the secretary would have just over $4 million.
    • 01:25:05
      There is a breakdown in that funding.
    • 01:25:08
      Some of it is based on population and some of it is flexible statewide.
    • 01:25:12
      We're going to take a look at the district selections as well to see if we can maybe switch some more statewide funds into that at-large selection based on some feedback received from Mr. Miller on the last slide.
    • 01:25:26
      In terms of scoring, in your packet, you're going to see a rather thick handout that goes through each of the applications we received.
    • 01:25:34
      We went through an extensive process working with our MPO partners to come up with a scoring process that they could use, that we could use, that would provide a technical score to every application that's received.
    • 01:25:46
      So for all the applications, we've looked at them, we scored them on a 300-point scale,
    • 01:25:52
      focusing on how much funding they're requesting, the concept, whether or not the project improved the overall transportation network.
    • 01:26:00
      We've looked at their ability to deliver a federal project and also at the project's readiness to proceed.
    • 01:26:07
      For projects that have received some transportation alternatives or transportation enhancement funding before, you'll see a second score.
    • 01:26:15
      And that second score is a priority ranking, and that's there to give you an idea of how that project is progressing and really to give you an idea of how quickly that project could use the funds that are being requested.
    • 01:26:26
      We've looked at several indicators to do that, but the bottom line is if you have an existing project and it has a priority score of one, that project is ready to go to construction.
    • 01:26:37
      In terms of program status, just to give you an overall look at the program, we've been making selections for the Transportation Enhancement Program and now TA since 1993.
    • 01:26:47
      We've completed a large number of projects statewide, but through the hard work of this board over the last several years to really tighten up our selection policy,
    • 01:26:55
      We've gone from one of the worst states in the country in terms of our expenditure rate.
    • 01:27:00
      To go back seven or eight years, we had only expended about 43 percent of the funding that we had received for TA, for transportation enhancement at the time.
    • 01:27:09
      Now we're at the other end of that scale, thankfully, with 63 percent, a little over 63 percent, the allocated funds that have been expended.
    • 01:27:16
      So that's why we have that emphasis on getting projects funded and through the pipeline quickly.
    • 01:27:22
      In your packet, you're going to have a summary of the large sheet that's printed in color.
    • 01:27:27
      That's going to give you some information on all the projects that have been selected in your district since the first selections were made in 1993.
    • 01:27:33
      That's going to give you an idea of the current status of any project that may be on your selection list.
    • 01:27:39
      It's also going to give you some feedback on those sponsors to see what they've delivered in the past and how they've done.
    • 01:27:47
      In terms of, over in the notes column, there's a little bit of status over there as well if a project is pending consideration for deallocation.
    • 01:27:56
      As a reminder with deallocation, and Mr. Sterling already asked me about this this morning, for those of you that have been through this process with us before, we typically give you a list of projects for deallocation this time of year, and that kind of bumps up the amount of funding that you have to select projects with.
    • 01:28:12
      One of the other things we did with the policy change last summer was instead of holding those funds for reallocation until July, basically,
    • 01:28:20
      What we're doing is we're now working through those deallocations as they come up through the course of the year.
    • 01:28:25
      So if you have a project in your district that's subject to deallocation, we'll reach out to you.
    • 01:28:30
      You have the flexibility to reallocate those funds within the district during the course of the year.
    • 01:28:35
      So you don't see that in your package now, but as projects come up for deallocation, we'll be in contact with you throughout the year.
    • 01:28:44
      Just in review, in your package you've got a summary page that talks about the program as a whole.
    • 01:28:50
      You have the application listing with the project scores, a copy of the Transportation Alternatives Program selection policy, a copy of our current deallocation and reallocation process that will kind of step through
    • 01:29:04
      How that works, the district summary and a list of the contacts in our office that handle the Transportation Alternatives Program on a statewide level if you need any assistance or have any questions about specific projects.
    • 01:29:18
      In terms of next steps, this month, actually yesterday, we sent the selection information to the MPOs for them to begin their selection process.
    • 01:29:27
      We're providing that information to you today.
    • 01:29:30
      We'd like to receive selections back from the district board members to our office by March the 9th.
    • 01:29:36
      That way we can compile that information, share that with the MPOs that are making selections at the same time.
    • 01:29:43
      And then get together with the at-large members and the secretary probably around the April board meeting to finish out that selection process.
    • 01:29:51
      So those listings can be available for the Six-Year Plan public meetings that are going to be in April and May.
    • 01:29:56
      We can meet that public hearing requirement.
    • 01:29:58
      We would bring the selections to you in June for approval.
    • 01:30:04
      With that, I can answer any questions.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:30:07
      Ms. Fisher.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:08
      I may have missed you saying this, but with the scoring and rank, not the ranking, but the scoring, what's the top possible score?
    • 01:30:15
      What's our scale?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:30:19
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Fisher, it's a 300-point scale, but the top possible score would be 300.
    • 01:30:23
      That's a little different than what we've done in the past, but we wanted to score on that category this time.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:30:29
      I would make one comment.
    • 01:30:31
      Governor McAuliffe campaigned significantly this year on economic development and I would ask that you consider in your selections as we support his wishes to say anything with economic development, just consider that.
    • 01:30:47
      I mean, it's your choice, but that's a theme that we'll be doing throughout the Governor's Transportation Conference and what have you.
    • 01:30:56
      I just ask you to consider that and you make your selections.
    • 01:31:02
      But it's your selections.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:06
      Yes, right.
    • 01:31:07
      Except for the case of the...
    • 01:31:09
      Except for the at-large.
    • 01:31:10
      Except for the at-large.
    • 01:31:11
      And I've crossed over TV.
    • 01:31:13
      I'm not saying anything.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:31:14
      I'm in the at-large now, Mr. Miller.
    • 01:31:16
      I'm on the same side here.
    • 01:31:18
      I'm real about it from your time.
    • 01:31:20
      The big at-large.
    • 01:31:22
      The big at-large, yeah.
    • 01:31:23
      That's right.
    • 01:31:23
      So, anyway, so...
    • 01:31:27
      Okay, do we have any questions, Mr. Poole?
    • 01:31:29
      Yes, Mr. Dickson, Mr. Whitmore.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:32
      In coming to your 300 points, how much of that is based on economic development?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:31:42
      It's kind of buried down in the point category.
    • 01:31:44
      I'd have to go back and look at the actual criteria, but we've got
    • 01:31:49
      In project concept and in projects that improve the transportation level, both of those would have some ties to economic development.
    • 01:31:56
      But we can't speak that it was actually accounted for.
    • 01:32:00
      There's a point value there.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:32:03
      That's why I throw out you would know being in the district.
    • 01:32:08
      So it's really your judgment.
    • 01:32:10
      But it's your pick, Mr. Sterling.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:14
      I've looked at these over the last eight years and sometimes the economic development aspect, I mean what is economic development in the case of a transportation alternative?
    • 01:32:29
      Is it the street scaping, the sidewalks improved,
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:32:35
      Maybe another way to put it is, it is a top one, maybe another way is to say if you were spending your money and you were getting the, you know, using it most wisely, yeah, because I know it's a lot of pressure from to say this is
    • 01:32:57
      My project, I just would ask us to throw a little bit.
    • 01:33:00
      Look, this year, prioritization, all that theme is running through these limited monies we have.
    • 01:33:07
      That's all I'm suggesting we consider.
    • 01:33:11
      It is difficult.
    • 01:33:12
      I agree.
    • 01:33:12
      It is.
    • 01:33:13
      Yeah, Mr. Milburn.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:14
      Mr. Milburn, remind me on slide
    • 01:33:20
      Fogg, which shows the breakdown between the various groups is the, and you see it's a tentative allocation distribution.
    • 01:33:30
      When the law changed and the areas over $200,000 went to NPO, does the law require a pro-rata share of the funds?
    • 01:33:41
      How does that work?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:33:44
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, the way that the federal law is set out is it basically takes
    • 01:33:49
      That $18.8 million and divides it in half.
    • 01:33:52
      Half of it's flexible, which means we can put it anywhere in the state, and half of it's divided up based on population.
    • 01:33:58
      Of the half that's divided up based on population, a portion goes to those areas over 200,000.
    • 01:34:03
      So that goes to the MPO areas for them to make selections.
    • 01:34:07
      And a portion of it is divided up in two categories, population of less than 5,000 and then between 5,000 and 200,000.
    • 01:34:16
      So that's where the at-large members made their selections last year was in that population base, the lower population base.
    • 01:34:24
      We're trying to work mixed in to the one.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:27
      Everything other than the MPO money.
    • 01:34:32
      We're driving the formula in terms of who decides.
    • 01:34:36
      Correct.
    • 01:34:37
      The MPO money is driven by the law and the rest of it is a policy.
    • 01:34:39
      Correct.
    • 01:34:40
      Thank you.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:42
      I'll speak.
    • 01:34:43
      Why do some of these have priority rankings and some of them don't?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:34:46
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Peake, the priority rankings are only provided for projects that are already existing.
    • 01:34:52
      So they've received funding in the past.
    • 01:34:54
      They've had an opportunity to proceed in project development.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:34:59
      One thing to consider there is if the project hasn't moved forward you might ask why do you want more money and then if it is moving forward you might say well this is really going to get done.
    • 01:35:09
      I mean just throw that out as a practical way to look at it.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:35:12
      And that's one of the reasons we give you the district summaries as well.
    • 01:35:15
      If you have a new project and it's administered by a locality that's done projects in the past you can kind of look and see
    • 01:35:22
      How they may have done on that previous contract.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:35:25
      Mr. Sterling.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:26
      The CMA, the MPO, they are on a different timeline than they are.
    • 01:35:33
      We have a request, get your proposals in, all that.
    • 01:35:36
      They end up in a sort of different process.
    • 01:35:39
      How does that work if, I mean, is there really a deadline on those submissions?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:35:45
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, we've worked closely with all the MPOs and with the exception of the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments, pretty much everybody else is on the same timeframe that we are.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:56
      What if they come in late?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:35:58
      If they come in late, we would do the same thing that we did in the last cycle and we would bring that MPO selection to the board separately, which is what we did with WashCOG.
    • 01:36:07
      It's complex for them.
    • 01:36:08
      They're dealing basically with two states in DC, so it's hard to coordinate.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:36:16
      To you new district members, this is a very popular program.
    • 01:36:20
      It's your phone's gonna ring off the hook.
    • 01:36:22
      So just letting you know.
    • 01:36:25
      You'll be lobbied heavily.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:27
      Jennifer, could you send me a visual of the breakdown that we talked about just a minute ago?
    • 01:36:37
      What drives it to 500, less than 5,000 in the morning to morning?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:36:41
      Mr. Chairman, I can actually send that to everybody.
    • 01:36:43
      We had it in the presentation we've given previously that kind of walked you through that breakdown.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:36:50
      Mr. Chairman, I have one question.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:36:54
      Looking through, obviously focusing on the Salem District here, but most of the requests are not for the total amount of what the project costs.
    • 01:37:06
      Does this imply that the sponsoring agency is willing to match to finish this project or is this they want to bank a little bit here and bank a little bit there and bank a little bit more?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:37:16
      Chairman, Mr. Fralin.
    • 01:37:17
      They have to provide a 20% match.
    • 01:37:19
      So the total cost of the project at most is going to be 80% is what they're requesting.
    • 01:37:25
      We've done extensive outreach.
    • 01:37:27
      We've done workshops with local government.
    • 01:37:28
      We've tried to convince our partners that it's important to break those projects down into manageable segments that can be completed with the funding that they're requesting.
    • 01:37:38
      And so what they're asking for should deliver a completed project or phase of the project.
    • 01:37:45
      A. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John K. Matney,
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:38:05
      It's an excellent program and very, very popular in the far southwest and the administration of the program has been advanced substantially in the last few years.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:19
      I was playing with it when I was first on the board and Mr. Brough does an excellent job of taking care of this and I appreciate her hard work on it.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:38:29
      Thank you.
    • 01:38:30
      I'm very fortunate to have very good staff that's sitting behind me right now and I'm glad you said that.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:38:37
      Ah, Mr. Ellis.
    • 01:38:39
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:38:40
      Mr. Brol, just, you may have gone over this before, but why are we showing items on here that were completed years ago?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:38:48
      Just giving you the history.
    • 01:38:49
      Dr. Parker.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:38:49
      Yeah.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:38:51
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Ellis, it's just to provide a complete history of the program and to give you another tool, and if you're looking at a local government that's coming in with a new project, it may give you some additional information to help you with your selection.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:02
      Because if she didn't provide it, we'd ask for it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:39:07
      That's probably right.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:39:10
      Any more questions of Mr. Bruell?
    • 01:39:12
      I'm sure you'll have plenty as your phone starts ringing for people wanting to know who you're making allocations to.
    • 01:39:18
      But I would advise the usual staff.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:39:21
      If we can be of any assistance, please let us know.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:39:26
      Thank you.
    • 01:39:28
      Mr. Donohue, tell us about you and
    • 01:39:31
      Maxwell will tell us about all of what our legislative friends have been doing.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:39:35
      Well, I'll tell you about some.
    • 01:39:37
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 01:39:39
      My name is Nick Donohue, and I'm here to tell you a little about the work we've been doing over the past five weeks with the General Assembly.
    • 01:39:45
      I'm really going to focus on two bills that are moving that are priority, and then JoAnne Maxwell from VDOT is going to get up and provide you with an overview of other legislation that's moving forward.
    • 01:39:55
      But before I get started, I just want to say we're in a pretty good place.
    • 01:39:58
      Right now transportation in the General Assembly.
    • 01:40:01
      There were a whole host of legislation that was introduced at the beginning of session that would have repealed the entire increase from last year, that would have done a ton of other things to it, that would have restricted our ability
    • 01:40:14
      to move forward with public-private partnerships that would have completely restructured this board starting on July 1, and most of all those proposals, with the exception of the repeal of the hybrid fee, registration fee, have been tabled for the year, and we do not expect to come back or gain traction next session.
    • 01:40:32
      With that being said, there are two very, very important pieces of legislation
    • 01:40:36
      That I'd like to talk to the board about today.
    • 01:40:38
      The first is House Bill 2.
    • 01:40:40
      This bill is sponsored by delegate Chris Stolle from Virginia Beach.
    • 01:40:44
      And this bill directs the Commonwealth Transportation Board to develop a statewide prioritization process.
    • 01:40:52
      So earlier we were talking a lot about how do we do this today, what are the differences, and this bill is actually going to make us answer a lot of those questions and firm up the exact process we want to use moving forward.
    • 01:41:05
      However, it's not going to be immediate.
    • 01:41:07
      This is going to take some time for us to develop and move forward, and so the effective date of this bill with regard to the programming of funds for the Six-Year Improvement Program would be July 1, 2016.
    • 01:41:20
      So this wouldn't apply for the current program that we're in the middle of updating or even the program next year but the FY 17 to 22 program all projects with a few exceptions that I'm going to walk through here would need to be run through this prioritization process and we would then select the ones that receive the highest score.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:42
      A hundred dollars in question.
    • 01:41:44
      I know that in the Fredericksburg District, I'm taking what the MPL is requesting, what the communities are requesting, and kind of look at that and have prioritization, what's associated with that.
    • 01:41:54
      Then it goes into this box down there, central office.
    • 01:41:58
      I don't know what VDOT has used in the past, and I'm probably pushing you on the spot by requesting it.
    • 01:42:04
      What is the process we've used historically in establishing this?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:42:09
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, there's been a mix of things that have been used over the past and the one thing I want to say is we are not spending money right now in places where there are not problems that are being fixed.
    • 01:42:19
      Every dollar currently that the board has allocated is fixing a problem.
    • 01:42:22
      I think the question we have to ask is even with the increases that were provided in House Bill 2313 last year, we do not have enough money to fix all the problems and I think what this bill is seeking to get at is what are the opportunity costs if we were to fund lower projects and so
    • 01:42:39
      I can't tell you exactly.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:40
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, it is a mix of factors.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:43:01
      It's one, how severe is the problem that's been identified in the regional travel demand models.
    • 01:43:05
      What is the condition of the roadway?
    • 01:43:07
      What is the local support?
    • 01:43:08
      And I think a lot of times the factor that maybe is unaware of folks outside of those is what's the readiness of the project?
    • 01:43:15
      Because a lot of times there are very significant problems, but we don't have the engineering right of where other things done to advance that at that other level.
    • 01:43:22
      And the Chairman may have a comment.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:43:23
      I just want to comment for Sterling.
    • 01:43:26
      Remember, a lot of the monies that went into the plan were not running through any formula or running through any process.
    • 01:43:32
      They were bond monies.
    • 01:43:34
      So, it has, in the last few years, previously directed a lot by the administration as to where the monies were gone.
    • 01:43:41
      And then, that is not the intent of House Bill 2.
    • 01:43:47
      We've been working directly with the secretary.
    • 01:43:49
      The intent is to put it back through these processes where this board is making those allocations.
    • 01:43:56
      Why?
    • 01:43:58
      More transparency, these were not monies that are, all the bond monies as you recall were pretty much outside of the scope of how they ran through the program.
    • 01:44:09
      And that is not what House Bill 2313 revenues that go through this.
    • 01:44:13
      What we are limited on is, and Mr. Garhi will go through what's excluded, that's not a great deal of money over the next, in the next two or three years because of the committed projects.
    • 01:44:27
      So, but, to answer your question, it's less than what we would like that we actually run through this.
    • 01:44:37
      But, anyway, I'll leave that there.
    • 01:44:39
      I'm just trying to go through a few more.
    • 01:44:40
      Did you have a question, Mr. Miller, before you moved on?
    • 01:44:44
      Mr. Fisher?
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:45
      This bill is basically based on a speaker's performance that we were circulating, I believe.
    • 01:44:54
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fisher?
    • 01:44:55
      The idea of making an objective way statewide to review projects similar to what we've been working on in Northern Virginia, state funds, House Bill 599 from 2012.
    • 01:45:09
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Fisher, that is correct.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:45:17
      This is a bill from the Speaker's package.
    • 01:45:19
      We have, though, worked significantly with him on it, and there is the introduced version of the current substitute that's been adopted by the House and was passed unanimously.
    • 01:45:27
      It has some significant changes, but yes, this does build on the initiative of the Speaker, but also, more importantly, from my perspective, the initiative of the Governor, excuse me, one of his top priorities was pick the right projects.
    • 01:45:38
      We raised taxes last year on citizens, and the administration believes that we need to make sure that we demonstrate results, and that we are going through a thorough objective analysis as we spend these funds moving forward.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:45:49
      The Governor in his opening remarks directed me, and Nick has been heavily involved in this,
    • 01:45:55
      who worked with the speaker's office in developing this criteria.
    • 01:46:00
      So it is a speaker's bill but heavily worked with Doug and Stolle and Nick and myself.
    • 01:46:17
      A less political measure.
    • 01:46:19
      We'll see how objective we get to, but less political.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:24
      Yeah, Mr. Sterling.
    • 01:46:35
      I mean, this is, if we're doing this, it's got to be, I think, congestion relief, safety, those things of that nature are particularly focused on the corridors that have been identified.
    • 01:46:55
      I think that are not political in nature.
    • 01:46:57
      Those corridors are very much, I think, very sound.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:47:02
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, I'll get into that in the next slide down here.
    • 01:47:05
      We have some of those details here.
    • 01:47:07
      The other thing that I do want to say is there are products that are currently fully funded and have been through the environmental review process, and there's language in this bill that would allow us to continue forward with those projects.
    • 01:47:17
      So we're not going to – the passage of this bill, which, you know, it's still in the Senate, does not mean we go in and cancel projects, contracts, and other things.
    • 01:47:24
      We're going to continue forward with those, and that's also why we have this lag time of about two years before this is fully implemented.
    • 01:47:31
      Mr. Sterling, to your point, there are a host of factors that the bill requires the Board to consider as it develops this prioritization process, and this is one of the things we really worked with the Speaker on, is the original bill just said congestion relief.
    • 01:47:45
      And while that may be appropriate for some parts of the state, it's wholly inappropriate for the entire Commonwealth.
    • 01:47:50
      And so one of the things that we've done in this bill is there's at least five factors that will be considered.
    • 01:47:55
      You see them up here on the board.
    • 01:47:57
      Congestion relief, economic development, accessibility, safety, and environmental quality.
    • 01:48:02
      The other thing that's very, very important is they're not going to be considered the same way in different parts of the state.
    • 01:48:08
      And so the board provides
    • 01:48:10
      The direction or the decision, the legislation provides direction to the board to weight these factors differently in different parts of the state.
    • 01:48:16
      So in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads, congestion is going to be the top factor.
    • 01:48:21
      In other parts of the state you might see safety or economic development being the highest weighted factor because congestion quite candidly in some parts of the state is not a present condition.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:31
      If we're talking statewide prioritization, that would tell me that you're looking at, well, are we going to build this in Northern Virginia, or Richmond, or wherever the case may be, versus this in Culpeper or Fredericksburg.
    • 01:48:44
      But you're talking about funds basically being reserved to a district.
    • 01:48:48
      Now let's measure them within the district.
    • 01:48:50
      How do you do that?
    • 01:48:51
      That's district-wide prioritization, not state-wide.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:48:55
      Well, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, it's going to be a mix of those.
    • 01:48:57
      This process is going to have to work within the existing allocations that are in law.
    • 01:49:02
      So 33.1-23.1 lays out how the board can spend the funds and provides allocations to certain categories.
    • 01:49:10
      And so this prioritization does not override.
    • 01:49:12
      Those allocation things.
    • 01:49:13
      So if you recall in 2012, legislation was passed that created a CTB formula that was off the top and takes place before the traditional 40% for primaries, 30% for secondaries, and 30% for urban.
    • 01:49:27
      So within, for example, the high priority category, we have 15% of that 500 million will be set aside for that purpose.
    • 01:49:33
      We would run these different factors in various projects across the state through that and then within that allocation fund projects.
    • 01:49:39
      Now to your point, if we're weighing them slightly different in different districts, we're going to have to think about how that works.
    • 01:49:45
      And I cannot tell you today that we have that 100% solved, but that's also why we've given ourselves two full years to develop this and figure out how that process would work.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:56
      Martin, W. C.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:50:18
      In Northern Virginia, the effort has been very collaborative in terms of elected officials, agency representatives to come together on the prioritization.
    • 01:50:36
      So it hasn't been dictated by any one person or one entity.
    • 01:50:41
      It's our whole MPO coming together and agreeing that these are what we're going to consider in the process.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:49
      But North Virginia is a very unique animal in this because it is that Northern Virginia is an MPO, or is part of that MPO, all of them.
    • 01:50:58
      Do you get any other district except maybe Hampton Roads?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:51:01
      No, Hampton Roads has both rural and...
    • 01:51:03
      Okay, that's different.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:06
      Not all communities are part of these.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:51:08
      I'll let Mr. Daugherty respond and I'll give him a piece.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:51:10
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, the bill actually contains language as well directing the secretary and the board to solicit and to consider input from all the affected stakeholders.
    • 01:51:20
      And so over the next 18 months, we're going to have to have a lot of discussions with the affected local governments, the MPOs,
    • 01:51:27
      The other transportation authorities in those areas.
    • 01:51:30
      And it's going to be a collaborative process.
    • 01:51:32
      At the end of the day, it is the Board's say based on legislation in its current state.
    • 01:51:35
      Remember, this is still legislation that is pending in the Senate.
    • 01:51:39
      Just because it passed unanimously from the House does not mean they'll receive the same consideration from the Senate.
    • 01:51:44
      But the intent of the legislation as currently drafted is that we would move forward in a similarly collaborative process with the affected stakeholders in that district.
    • 01:51:52
      And then at the end of the day, the Board
    • 01:51:54
      would need to vote on the various weightings for the different districts.
    • 01:51:58
      A lot of this though is we're going to have to figure it out.
    • 01:52:01
      We put in place I think a framework within this legislation that can work to allow us to do it, but within that framework we've also recognized we don't have all the answers today, but we're going to put in place a process where all the stakeholders, including the board, will have an opportunity to have significant input in what that final end product is because if we don't do that, this process isn't going to work.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:52:22
      Mr. Fralin?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 01:52:23
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • 01:52:24
      I understand Mr. Sterling's concerns and I think they're warranted.
    • 01:52:29
      I think one of the things I wanted to point out being a recovering politician and legislator that I've been following is pretty close and the substitute is much better than the original bill.
    • 01:52:41
      There's no question about that.
    • 01:52:43
      The other thing I want to commend Nick and his team and the Secretary, they have protected the integrity of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 01:52:50
      What the questions you're getting at are, we get to pick.
    • 01:52:54
      We get to weight these factors the way we want to weight them representing our districts, according to the way I read the bill.
    • 01:53:00
      And that's very important.
    • 01:53:02
      The whole reason we have a Commonwealth Transportation Board is to insulate the decisions based on projects from the political process itself, from actual members of the General Assembly pick and throw projects.
    • 01:53:14
      So this does maintain that integrity.
    • 01:53:17
      And the original one, I think, was starting to go down a path that did not.
    • 01:53:23
      So that's really great.
    • 01:53:25
      The only question I have, and Nick and I have talked about this, is the degree of consultation we need to make.
    • 01:53:32
      And I think you indicated that's been sort of firmed up as more of a consulting role rather than a strict agreement role.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:53:42
      Mr. Chairman, we're currently working on a substitute with Delegate Stolle that will address some of those issues.
    • 01:53:48
      As well as some concerns I'll raise by local government and I expect we'll see that next Wednesday in center transportation.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:53:54
      To Mr. Fralin, yeah, that's our whole purpose in working with this is to make sure nothing, a big purpose that came through that would take this project out of the CTB's hands.
    • 01:54:06
      That's really what the intent was.
    • 01:54:08
      We got a lot of work to do in that regard, but it's putting it where it ought to be, in our hands.
    • 01:54:15
      And that's what this law does and that's what we've been
    • 01:54:17
      making sure we, as originally perceived, it would have been, I think we were headed down a path that would not have been something that could come, you as a CTB.
    • 01:54:29
      gave us results we would not have been looking for.
    • 01:54:34
      So to the speakers and to Doug Stolle's credit, they have understood that.
    • 01:54:39
      But just on the other side, they want to make sure these monies are used wisely, and they're going to hold us and look at us.
    • 01:54:47
      And I'm sure it will take us, that's why we advocated 16 months, because we're going to make some mistakes as we work through this in that regard.
    • 01:54:54
      It's probably
    • 01:54:55
      I'm going to be a committee.
    • 01:54:56
      I'm going to have to sit down and think about the best way to work through all this is.
    • 01:55:00
      But anyway, Mr. Thrasher and I will come back to you, Mr. North.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:05
      Assuming this passes, are we anticipating forming a task force to develop a model?
    • 01:55:10
      I know in Northern Virginia, Mr. Garczynski and I have been working very closely with VDOT to develop a model for how NVTA will pick projects.
    • 01:55:20
      And the development of the model, I think, is crucial to determining whether we score these things properly or not so that we do have an objective measure.
    • 01:55:30
      And once everything gets through that, it's much easier to make decisions.
    • 01:55:35
      Yeah, we'll consider that obviously.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:55:43
      I'll throw one thing out.
    • 01:55:45
      What's being done in Northern Virginia I think is great.
    • 01:55:48
      We haven't seen what the result is going to generate yet.
    • 01:55:50
      Yeah, the pitfall.
    • 01:55:50
      Yeah, I was going to say because we went through some Hampton Roads, they did a model and said, oh, we didn't like that and they changed the model.
    • 01:56:00
      So the real thing is to try to give some objective measure and take the political, as Mr. Fralin put it, put it in some range.
    • 01:56:13
      In fact, I would think one of the things would be we have some very controversial projects in this state.
    • 01:56:17
      Let's score them.
    • 01:56:20
      You know?
    • 01:56:20
      I mean, that sort of puts us in the realm of, you know, but the overriding thing is we wanted to keep it in the Commonwealth Transportation Board's hands.
    • 01:56:29
      So we've got a lot of work to do, but that's not an answer.
    • 01:56:33
      But we haven't seen what some of the results of some of these things are.
    • 01:56:37
      So if we want to go down this path that says you shall do this, it says we will consider, Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:43
      Mr. Donohue, 2313 had a provision that allowed us to set aside a certain amount of money for it.
    • 01:56:49
      Bridgetoff, but didn't require us to do so.
    • 01:56:53
      He just said, we may.
    • 01:56:55
      And we sort of took the position, or the former secretary took the position, that we will, not we may.
    • 01:57:02
      But that's not what the bill says.
    • 01:57:05
      In your slide, where it says, doesn't apply to, maybe I've got to, did I get any?
    • 01:57:12
      I can catch up, sir.
    • 01:57:12
      Y'all take it way too long to get through this.
    • 01:57:16
      So the next slide says it does not apply to the following state funds.
    • 01:57:21
      Is that a reference also to that 15%?
    • 01:57:25
      And if so, is it sort of codifying it as you will as opposed to you may?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:57:31
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, this is a reference to that as well as other capital funds that may be used for bridge repair replacement.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:39
      I think one of the key things- I don't understand that piece.
    • 01:57:42
      Let me just stop.
    • 01:57:43
      I'm getting there.
    • 01:57:44
      So if it applies to the 15% and it says these funds won't go through that process, then it in essence is sort of codifying that the 15% is you will, not you may.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:57:58
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, it doesn't codify that because that would still be a May.
    • 01:58:02
      We actually have the complete discretion, or this Board, excuse me, has the discretion not to set that money aside.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:07
      So if we took that 15% and didn't run it through, whatever it was, and didn't run it through that formula, would it then apply or not apply?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:58:18
      If we did not run the money through the formula setting it aside for bridge rehabilitation, then those funds would be prioritized.
    • 01:58:25
      Now the thing I wanted to stress here is we have set this up because the state has had a long-standing policy that we take care of our existing assets before we expand capacity and so we wanted to ensure that that process is not, the integrity of that process is not diminished
    • 01:58:41
      by this prioritization, and there's also bridge repair funds that we do set aside that are outside of that 25% CTB formula.
    • 01:58:47
      So this would protect that as well as other types of repair and fix-it-first funds that the Commonwealth currently has in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:55
      I was just looking to make sure that flexibility was maintained.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:58:57
      Flexibility was maintained, sir.
    • 01:58:59
      Yeah, but in reference to that, and we do have the discretion to change those percentages if we should, because that's been a hot topic of discussion during this, but both the Speaker and the Governor
    • 01:59:10
      Those projects, those formulas right now is accumulating money that will actually be spent on a project otherwise that would be put in small pots that nothing would get accomplished.
    • 01:59:22
      So I would just say that's the overriding point.
    • 01:59:24
      We can talk about if it's going to the right place.
    • 01:59:27
      But taking that money and making sure something's getting done is both, you know, we found legislatively and administratively, the governor, that's important that we make sure that's considered.
    • 01:59:39
      The intent is not to then say, okay, we run through the formula and we got five million here that sits there for two years.
    • 01:59:46
      Although many localities would love us to do that in that sense.
    • 01:59:51
      Yes?
    • 01:59:52
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Donohue, obviously the devil is in the details.
    • 01:59:56
      To whom does the current legislation
    • 02:00:03
      W. Smith Jr., John L. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:00:21
      In general, I would like to say the authority in this legislation as it's currently drafted rests almost entirely with the board.
    • 02:00:29
      There are a few things that are left to the discretion of the secretary but those are typically in smaller types of areas.
    • 02:00:34
      When it comes to defining how do we examine congestion, how do we examine economic development, safety, accessibility, environmental quality, those things are left to the discretion of the board as this is the policy making board in the Commonwealth when it comes to transportation programming decision for search of transportation.
    • 02:00:51
      A few other things that I think are important here on this slide is there's a host of funds that this will not apply to.
    • 02:00:57
      We've already talked about the repair funds.
    • 02:00:59
      Those will continue to be prioritized using the department's asset management methodology, which we've had in place since I believe about 2007.
    • 02:01:06
      And so that will not change that process.
    • 02:01:09
      It also doesn't apply to the revenue sharing program.
    • 02:01:12
      And the rationale behind that was that if local governments are paying half the cost of these projects, they're pretty high priorities for those regions.
    • 02:01:19
      And when we're leveraging our dollars, you know, one to one, we should exempt that from this process.
    • 02:01:23
      And then there's a whole set of federal programs that have very, very specific rules that would make it difficult to run them through this process.
    • 02:01:31
      One of them is transportation alternatives.
    • 02:01:33
      A.
    • 02:01:39
      to just build ordinary new capacity.
    • 02:01:42
      There's a lot of restrictions on those and the same things with the Highway Safety Improvement Program funds and so we've exempted that.
    • 02:01:48
      We've also exempted the secondary and urban formula funds.
    • 02:01:52
      Now if the Board does recall at the current fiscal forecast there's not going to be any funds in that until 2020 and so at the moment it's kind of a moot issue but until we get to that time those funds are going to be exempted from this process.
    • 02:02:06
      The other thing I really want to stress, this does not apply to the regional revenues raised in Hampton Roads or the regional revenues raised in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:02:14
      Those funds will continue to be prioritized based on what's currently in law and will not be subject to this process.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:20
      It's that last bullet or the last part of that last bullet.
    • 02:02:26
      What is STP funds controlled by an NPO?
    • 02:02:29
      Because any funds expended in an NPO has to be essentially approved by, you can say controlled by the NPO.
    • 02:02:37
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, that's a very good question.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:02:45
      This is not the – under federal law, we cannot spend a dollar within a metropolitan planning area unless the MPO has approved the use of that fund.
    • 02:02:53
      That is not what this reference is to.
    • 02:02:55
      Under federal law and the surface transportation program of which we get about $270 million here annually in Virginia,
    • 02:03:02
      Just like the Transportation Alternatives Program, half of that is completely flexible and the other half is divided into three parts based on population and a portion of that in Virginia goes to the MPOs over $200,000 and on federal law they have complete discretion in how they spend that funds.
    • 02:03:19
      It's about $55 million annually here in Virginia and we cannot by state law override the federal provisions with regard to those funds.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:03:29
      Mr. Matney, what percentage of your current budget do you think will be affected?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:03:35
      That is a very, very good question.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:03:37
      We're trying to get our hands around that.
    • 02:03:41
      And of course, you know, anything that's totally funded now, totally that we've gone through environmental that's in the plan to be excluded.
    • 02:03:50
      This is rough ballpark.
    • 02:03:52
      Looks like maybe $600 million a year is a rough number based on the current funding level.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:03:58
      And Mr. Chairman, we're going to take a look at this more fully.
    • 02:04:02
      We've just done some back of the envelope estimates.
    • 02:04:05
      We also have to look at what projects are vested in moving forward.
    • 02:04:08
      But percentage-wise, a quarter to a third, it looks like.
    • 02:04:11
      The thing I think most folks don't recognize is a significant percentage of our Six-Year Improvement Program is not building new things.
    • 02:04:19
      It's just doing a complete replacement of the existing assets that we have that have reached the end of their design life, and we can't do that out of the maintenance budget because it's just not sufficient.
    • 02:04:28
      So that's the bulk of the funds that are excluded.
    • 02:04:31
      These other ones, once you get past those first two bullets, are only, I think it's two or three hundred million dollars there.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:04:38
      That's a critical point.
    • 02:04:39
      You wrote our construction program.
    • 02:04:41
      It's really major repairs.
    • 02:04:44
      There's very little new capacity in our construction.
    • 02:04:48
      I'm not suggesting there's none, but I mean if you look at it, it's a lot of just putting back together the things that we haven't done in the last 25 years.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:05:01
      And the last point I want to say in this bill before we move on to the next piece of legislation is earlier Mr. Sterling asked, you know, how are we screening the types of projects that will be prioritized?
    • 02:05:10
      And currently the bill has language that says we'll screen them based on whether or not they address a needs assessment identified in the statewide plan.
    • 02:05:18
      And currently the statewide plan has three factors that we're supposed to be looking at, and that's the capacity needs on corridors of statewide significance, the capacity needs on regional networks, and then improvement to promote urban development areas or essentially locally designated growth areas.
    • 02:05:33
      And so those are the three kind of screen criteria that will be used before projects are then prioritized.
    • 02:05:38
      But again, that will come out and be consistent with the long-range plan that we're currently in the process of updating.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:05:44
      One comment that I'll make too, Mr. Donohue is going to be primarily responsible for the Office of Intermodal Planning and this will be a, of course we'll hear from a former CTB member in a little while that's also going to be involved in that, but this will be paramount as we work through those plans, as we're gathering the information that we really need to help us develop this process.
    • 02:06:10
      So it's going to be Cord A. statewide significance.
    • 02:06:15
      If you look at it, we've done a pretty good job of that.
    • 02:06:18
      The other things about considering local planning and other things we haven't done such a good job and that will all come into this process as we help develop this.
    • 02:06:26
      Ms. Fisher?
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:27
      The million dollar question.
    • 02:06:29
      It sounds like we've done a good amount of work in the Secretariat to get this bill to be something that we really want.
    • 02:06:35
      What's the outlook in the Senate and what can we do?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:06:38
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fisher, I don't want to predict the actions of the legislative body, but so far I think we've had very constructive and productive discussions with the members of the Joint Senate.
    • 02:06:51
      All right, moving on, the second piece of legislation that I really wanted to highlight for the board is legislation and there's companion bills that have passed both the House and the Senate that would establish the Hampton Roads Transportation Accountability
    • 02:07:05
      Commission for the Hampton Roads Region.
    • 02:07:07
      And this bill is sponsored by Chairman Jones from House Appropriations in the House and is sponsored by both Senators Wagner and Lucas in the Senate.
    • 02:07:16
      And they passed unanimously from both chambers.
    • 02:07:18
      And the purpose of this commission is really twofold.
    • 02:07:22
      The first is to serve as a financing arm for the Hampton Roads Regional money.
    • 02:07:26
      For those of you who are familiar with the 2313, the regional revenue is going to raise about $180 million or so a year
    • 02:07:33
      But if you look at the top priority projects we have down there, there's several billion dollars.
    • 02:07:38
      And so without bonding authority, it's going to, would really constrain the ability of that region to build a lot of the priority projects that they currently have on their list.
    • 02:07:47
      And so this would take care of that issue.
    • 02:07:49
      The other thing this Accountability Commission would do that's very important is it's going to provide policy oversight for that region, providing them more local control over some of these direct projects that they might not have had had this commission not been in place.
    • 02:08:03
      And I also want to stress VDOT would still play a very significant role in the construction of these projects, but they would be doing it kind of at the guidance of this Accountability Commission.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:13
      Mr. Miller?
    • 02:08:13
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Donohue, what do you interpret the second slash or hash as provides policy oversight for key regional projects?
    • 02:08:26
      What does that mean?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:08:27
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, so what that would mean is this Accountability Commission would be the ones that would actually select which project
    • 02:08:33
      are we going
    • 02:08:51
      If they desired, they could serve as the responsible public entity and negotiate directly with the private sector.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:57
      And they would be developing an annual budget as well as a program.
    • 02:09:06
      methods, i.e.
    • 02:09:07
      public-private partnerships for current money.
    • 02:09:10
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, yes.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:09:11
      Mr. Miller, I'll point out here, this law is controlled by the existing language of what those funds have to be used for, and I would use your language much more.
    • 02:09:21
      The legislature is pretty clear they want these on regional projects that otherwise would not have gotten built, that would probably bring to fruition mega projects that would not have gotten built from statewide plans,
    • 02:09:33
      That's why it references the law in there.
    • 02:09:41
      This is not a duplication of the planning.
    • 02:09:47
      This is getting the projects to fruition on the funding side and making sure that these people, the Hampton Roads, controls those major decisions.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:59
      Not to have this misinterpreted, but it takes the power away from the TPO to a subset of the TPO that includes all the responsible parties as well as four legislators.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:10:15
      Well, another way to look at it, you're right, and we'll talk about the composition, I'm sure Mr. Brown here will talk about it, but it separates the statewide monies and the regional ones.
    • 02:10:27
      So, there's a very good accounting, that's why it's called the accountability commission, that the statewide monies are not being sacrificed, because that was part of the law, that they're not being reduced because they have these, that was part of the law on that, so they'll keep a good accounting, but it is also designed to make sure that the new monies that the taxpayers in that region raise are actually being built on projects that would not always be funded.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:52
      And also satisfies the issue, does it not?
    • 02:10:56
      Martin, Jr.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:11:15
      And just getting to the point that was raised by Mr. Miller, the composition of the board would, depending on whether or not you look at the House or Senate's version, would be between 21 and 22 members, and that's a member from each local government, the chief executive officer, four ex officio members, which are all in this room currently, and then the difference here is there's two House members in most versions of the bill, and in the Senate bill there's two Senators, and in the House version there's one Senator.
    • 02:11:40
      So, you know, they'll have to talk about these issues if they get to conference there.
    • 02:11:44
      There's been a long-standing practice that there's always more House members than Senate, and the Senators respectfully disagree.
    • 02:11:50
      This session, so we'll be having additional dialogue on that.
    • 02:11:53
      But there's also some significant provisions in this legislation regarding what's an affirmative vote of the Accountability Commission.
    • 02:12:00
      And so it's not a simple majority that's necessary to be able to advance projects or toll rate decisions or things of that nature.
    • 02:12:07
      It requires a vote of two-thirds of the members present representing at least two-thirds of the population of that region.
    • 02:12:15
      And so
    • 02:12:16
      They're not going to be able to move forward without significant regional consensus on any of the types of projects that will take place there, and I think that's another very important provision about local control.
    • 02:12:26
      The entire region is going to have a very significant say in how these funds are used, even if it's not directly located within their specific locality.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:12:34
      Secretary, just for the edification of the board, you can look at the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, because that's what this is really patterned as, the bonding authority and the voting rights, etc.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:49
      That's all we have, right?
    • 02:12:51
      In your list of your members, I'm not sure your verbiage matches up with your numbers.
    • 02:12:58
      You say CTB members from the area, don't you mean the district member?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:13:03
      It says a CTB member from the region.
    • 02:13:05
      Actually, that air is an area.
    • 02:13:07
      It could be an urban at-large.
    • 02:13:08
      It's one CTB member.
    • 02:13:09
      Yes, sir.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:10
      That was my mistake.
    • 02:13:12
      Okay, and the second thing is just maybe a point of
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:13:21
      Well, I'm just acknowledging... Actually, quite frankly, I would advocate it being at large because these are regional projects.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:30
      But here's what I'm forgetting for a second.
    • 02:13:34
      I think it's interesting.
    • 02:13:37
      And I like it, I think.
    • 02:13:39
      That we are combining a state elected official and a local elected official to decide how we spend local money.
    • 02:13:52
      And I'm not sure we've ever done that before.
    • 02:13:55
      The legislature spends the state money, the local guy spends the local money.
    • 02:14:00
      Now we've brought the state into the bed.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:14:02
      Unless they made a law before.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:04
      With the local guy and said, or gal,
    • 02:14:07
      and said we're going to collaborate and decide how to spend this local money.
    • 02:14:11
      It's a pretty big step in my mind for the legislature to give themselves authority to vote on local, on the specifics of local money.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:27
      And I think I like it.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:28
      I think I like it because it forces collaboration and everybody gets on the same page.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:14:36
      If you look at the voting, it basically gives the large cities a veto, but it doesn't, because this population is one of the parameters, but it doesn't give them, they have to get collaboration to move forward.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:49
      Well I was going to ask that, that was my next question.
    • 02:14:52
      Because we had lots of discussions in the TPO of weighting the membership.
    • 02:14:57
      So the Board of Supervisors, the Chairman that has
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:15:01
      Miller III, W.
    • 02:15:24
      Washington MPO, they actually have, each member knows, like their vote is worth 32 points or 7.
    • 02:15:30
      Here you've just got to add up to a population, so it's waiting by default.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:15:33
      Let me tell you, the sponsor of the bill that we've worked closely with is very adamant he's not moving off of this.
    • 02:15:40
      because it forces collaboration.
    • 02:15:42
      There may be a movement to try to change this, and the sponsor is not going to change it.
    • 02:15:48
      Actually, we support the sponsors in this.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:53
      The House or Sun Sponsors?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:15:55
      The House.
    • 02:15:57
      Right.
    • 02:15:57
      Yes.
    • 02:15:57
      Good.
    • 02:15:58
      Mr. Dixon.
    • 02:15:59
      I mean Whitworth.
    • 02:16:00
      I don't know why I want to call you Mr. Dixon.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:03
      You're a Mr. Somebody.
    • 02:16:05
      The active fiction members have both, I think is correct.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:16:08
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Whitworth, no they do not, they're ex officio.
    • 02:16:11
      So they will be at the dais, similar to what Director Mitchell is, and they can help inform the discussion there and provide input and other things from a position of authority, but they will not have a vote.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:21
      So when you say 22 members, you're not talking about 22 voting members?
    • 02:16:27
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:16:29
      Only elected officials will vote.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:34
      Does that mean the chief executive officers who make up the vote for this one?
    • 02:16:38
      I'm assuming chief executive officers.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:16:39
      No, no.
    • 02:16:40
      The bill, it's the mayors.
    • 02:16:42
      It's the elected officials.
    • 02:16:43
      The mayors and chairs.
    • 02:16:45
      Yeah, mayors and chairs.
    • 02:16:47
      It's elected.
    • 02:16:48
      We're putting the tenants to put this in elected people's hands that are responsible to the public.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:54
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:17:14
      My second question was, without this process, just so I understand, where were these same decisions made today?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:17:27
      Mr. Whitworth, as the current legislation is set up, the decisions today would be made by the Transportation Planning Authority, but their ability to advance a lot of the key projects would be severely constrained if not completely hindered by the lack of bonding authority.
    • 02:17:42
      that they have there and so you know Patriots Crossing or the High Rise Bridge which are two of the key regional projects there both have a price tag around two billion dollars and if you're only bringing in 183 million a year
    • 02:17:53
      you know we're looking 10 years before you could actually advance that type of project even with tolls or other things and so right now they have that authority but because of the other authority they're lacking their ability to actually deliver a lot of these projects would be in question.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:18:08
      The CTB does not have the authority now.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:18:10
      The decisioning is through two different bodies right now is that correct?
    • 02:18:13
      No.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:18:15
      One.
    • 02:18:16
      CTB has no authority over these funds.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:19
      But you had a taxation without representation problem too because there's two localities that are part of this funding formula but they have no seat at the table for the group that was given the funding to decide.
    • 02:18:34
      So you had a problem with those two?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:18:36
      It was also a federal institution, not a state institution.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:40
      Right.
    • 02:18:40
      So you had a bonding issue, you had two, I think it was two localities that were left out.
    • 02:18:45
      Their citizens were being taxed, but they don't serve on the TPO.
    • 02:18:49
      So they're trying to figure out how to get them in.
    • 02:18:51
      So that's what this is sort of.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:18:54
      We've given up no authority.
    • 02:18:55
      The CTB's given up nothing.
    • 02:18:57
      We never had it.
    • 02:18:58
      I was just trying to understand, but I wasn't quite in for it.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:19:03
      Mr. Chairman, I've already walked through the powers of the authority earlier in discussion with Mr. Miller, but I think it's equally important what's not on this page.
    • 02:19:10
      They cannot impose any new taxes or fees or levy them.
    • 02:19:13
      They cannot raise any existing taxes or fees.
    • 02:19:16
      They cannot sell debt that would be debt of the Commonwealth or encumber the local government revenue streams.
    • 02:19:22
      The bonds they sell can only be backed by the regional revenues or any tolls that might be on a facility that they're improving.
    • 02:19:29
      This is going to be not that that impacts any of the participating local governments or hinders the state.
    • 02:19:34
      I think those are two very very important factors to keep in mind as we move forward and there's been some confusion about that in the legislature due to the previous Hampton Roads Transportation Authority that Mr. Sterling recalls from 2007 where
    • 02:19:48
      For a whole host of issues, we set it up and it has set it back down after the Supreme Court directed us to do so.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:55
      I think it's a great thing and I commend you all for supporting it.
    • 02:19:59
      I will tell you, just to be clear, I don't really care whether my government calls it
    • 02:20:09
      Martin, W. C.
    • 02:20:29
      They can't create tolls.
    • 02:20:31
      You can say that's not a tax.
    • 02:20:33
      The Supreme Court said that, and you can say it's not fee.
    • 02:20:40
      I don't know why it's not user fee, but whatever terminology you want, they have the ability in this group, through tolling, to take money from the citizens if they're not already taken.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:20:53
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, yes, they may oppose until I wouldn't just ask that for purposes of discussing this bill.
    • 02:20:58
      A lot of the other folks have a very, particularly the legislature, have a very strong recollection of the Hampton Roads Transportation Authority, which had the power to impose general taxes and fees.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:08
      Such as a 40-cent graners tax, a $10 vehicle registration fee, and if we start to mix those in between we're really going to create some significant confusion that would harm the health of legislation. Getting to your point about we don't see any. Setting toll rates for toll projects, that's all going to be new stuff. It's not existing state roads that we have, is it?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:21:30
      Mr. Chairman, they could not go into an unimproved state facility and do that.
    • 02:21:39
      However, the high-rise bridges and existing state facility, if they were to choose to do so, they could go in and use their regional revenues with bonds, improve that road, and potentially impose tolls on the improved facility.
    • 02:21:51
      However, they cannot go into an unimproved facility and impose tolls.
    • 02:21:53
      Same thing on the HRB, too.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:21:55
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:21:56
      Absolutely.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:22:00
      Okay, any other questions for Mr. Donahue?
    • 02:22:03
      Yes, Mr. Ellis.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:22:04
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • 02:22:05
      Mr. Donahue, you may have mentioned this before, but go over what the difference was between the House and the Senate before.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:22:11
      Yes sir, there's a very, just a small difference.
    • 02:22:15
      The main difference is that the Senate thought it should have equal representation
    • 02:22:19
      on this board with the House, and so there's two Senate members and two House members.
    • 02:22:23
      The House went with long-standing practice that there's a hundred of them and 40 senators, and there should be more House members on the board.
    • 02:22:30
      And so if both these bills are successful, they'll go to conference and have a discussion, and if I were betting, man, we'll probably end up with something like three and two, you know, along those lines.
    • 02:22:40
      But if you look at the NVTA, there's more House members than Senate members, and that's just been long-standing
    • 02:22:45
      Pratchett, but the Senate shows that long-standing practice didn't have presence at this time.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:22:50
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:22:51
      Mr. Kuzinski.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:22:55
      Yes, Nick, is there anything further I thought of the Secretary earlier about Doug Hugo's bill on the public relations or our ability to...
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:23:06
      He can answer this.
    • 02:23:07
      Maxwell was going to get into it, but Nick can answer it.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:23:10
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Garczynski, we had a whole host of legislation related to activity related to the Bayh County Parkway.
    • 02:23:18
      We had what I would call anti-earmark budget amendments as well as legislation telling us that we could not spend funds to put undue pressure on state or local elected officials.
    • 02:23:31
      While that legislation did not advance
    • 02:23:33
      The budget report from the House does include language saying a department may not expend public funds for the purpose of propaganda or things of that nature.
    • 02:23:45
      and it excludes legally required public notices.
    • 02:23:48
      We're going to talk with them on that particular language, but that language does move forward in some form there.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:23:55
      I think we have to be, I told the Secretary, I believe we should be very sensitive to restrictions placed on VDOT for the purposes of disseminating public information and facts
    • 02:24:09
      B. Smith Jr.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:25
      I mean, you could get a ruling, doesn't matter what somebody in the General Assembly or even us thinks, you could get a ruling out of court that says no more public information sessions where on every major project VDOT has public information sessions and public comes in, facts are presented, answers are given.
    • 02:24:42
      I would hate to have somebody, some judge decide, well, they gave information which influenced the public because they gave facts.
    • 02:24:50
      And therefore that's propaganda and it can't be done anymore because now we're shutting
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:24:55
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Sterling, I don't recall the exact language there, but there are provisions that would exempt legally required things such as public hearing and public notice.
    • 02:25:05
      Again, we're currently taking a look at the budget.
    • 02:25:07
      They gave a whole host of changes, a lot of things related to the remaining balances in the transportation partnership opportunity fund.
    • 02:25:13
      I think we need a few more days before we can really tell the board exactly where we think we are in these things, but we are on top of it.
    • 02:25:20
      We read it all this Sunday.
    • 02:25:21
      We read the additional language that came out yesterday at noon.
    • 02:25:24
      We're aware of that and we're working with the administration to review that and determine our path forward.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:25:30
      Ms. Fisher.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:32
      I realize that you're working on it.
    • 02:25:33
      I'm not going to belabor the point, but in terms of the language, it doesn't restrict advertising, but that's strict advertising for public meetings.
    • 02:25:41
      It could be construed to mean even the contractors that we have that develop the information board at public meetings, that could be construed to be advocacy or advertising.
    • 02:25:53
      I think we need to clean up that language so that there isn't a problem down the road.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:25:58
      I think following up on Ms. Fisher's point is that if we were accused of anything over the last couple of years, especially on the Bye County Parkway, it was lack of transparency or outreach, and I'd hate to see our ability to do that
    • 02:26:24
      Well, let me make one comment.
    • 02:26:27
      We probably did go over the line on some of the things we did on Bicounty, and so I understand the need for that.
    • 02:26:34
      The way we've done this with others, and we'll reach out again, is I will give assurances as Secretary that I will make sure that that will not happen.
    • 02:26:43
      So that's one of the approaches we're taking.
    • 02:26:46
      We did that on several of the bills for PPTA, about keeping them informed.
    • 02:26:51
      And so we'll work through it that way.
    • 02:26:54
      But all your comments are well taken.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:26:57
      We did it.
    • 02:26:58
      And Mr. Chairman, I would just remind the board that language only appeared in one house's subcommittee report, so this is not by any means something that there is consensus in both chambers on.
    • 02:27:09
      So additional discussions, regardless of where we end up on this particular issue, will take place in the General Assembly.
    • 02:27:16
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:27:17
      Okay, it's 1230.
    • 02:27:22
      Do you want to take a quick break for lunch?
    • 02:27:23
      We have a couple more presentations before we get into the work session.
    • 02:27:28
      Do you want to take 15 minutes?
    • 02:27:30
      Ms. Maxwell, does that work with you?
    • 02:27:33
      Okay, we'll take 15 minutes, and so that's about a quarter till we'll come back and continue the work-time session.
    • 02:27:43
      You go through this.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:27:47
      Mr.
    • 02:27:47
      Chair, in the interest of time, I'm going to try to go through and just focus on those bills that have seemingly direct or indirect impact on the CTB itself.
    • 02:27:57
      There's certainly many other bills in this packet that you all have received that address various aspects of VDOT business, et cetera, but in the interest of time, I'm going to try to focus on those that impact the CTB.
    • 02:28:10
      I'm Jo Anne Maxwell from the policy division in VDOT.
    • 02:28:14
      and I am here just to give you a quick synopsis of what's happened thus far in the General Assembly.
    • 02:28:19
      As Nick has noted, we are not quite done.
    • 02:28:22
      None of the bills that you see today have actually been signed into law, so things could still change.
    • 02:28:29
      Nevertheless, we are well into the session and many bills that you see today will have passed or are well on the way to passing both houses.
    • 02:28:37
      One thing I want to do is talk to you very briefly about basically five agency bills that VDOT has.
    • 02:28:43
      I wanted you just to be aware of those bills just in case you hear anything about them so that you'd be aware.
    • 02:28:49
      House Bill 509 is a bill that VDOT asks to be carried for purposes of
    • 02:28:54
      It would allow the agency, the commissioner, to issue permits to specialize construction equipment for contractors that are engaged in doing work, construction or maintenance work.
    • 02:29:05
      It basically is going to help
    • 02:29:08
      with the operations and allow those entities, rather than having to load certain pieces of equipment up on a trailer, they can actually run this equipment across certain VDOT facilities, assuming we've done an engineering study and everything seems to be okay.
    • 02:29:22
      House Bill 854 and Senate Bill 470, these two bills are a long time in the works and have been a long time coming for the Commonwealth.
    • 02:29:32
      What they do is they establish for all unpaved roads in the Commonwealth on the secondary
    • 02:29:38
      A. maximum speed limit of 35 miles an hour.
    • 02:29:40
      Up until our current law is that the speed limit on these roads is actually 55 miles an hour unless there is an engineering study that has changed or reduced the speed limit.
    • 02:29:55
      The current law allows certain localities or states in certain localities the speed limit is 35 miles an hour.
    • 02:30:03
      Or if a locality passes an ordinance, it would be 35 miles an hour on an unpaved road.
    • 02:30:09
      This bill just says, all lefts are off.
    • 02:30:11
      The state is now going to be 30.
    • 02:30:13
      The default speed limit will be 35 miles an hour.
    • 02:30:16
      unless there's a study to determine otherwise.
    • 02:30:20
      So we think it's a good bill.
    • 02:30:22
      We think it's going to enhance safety and probably put the public on better notice of what's going on.
    • 02:30:28
      House Bill 948 SB461, these are bills that were very important to VDOT.
    • 02:30:34
      Last year House Bill 2079 was introduced to basically start a process to revamp the Virginia Public Procurement Act.
    • 02:30:42
      Under that process, what they did in the bill was try to just make some minor structural changes to the Public Procurement Act without making any substantive changes.
    • 02:30:54
      However, inadvertently, a very important exception or exemption that VDOT and both actually VDOT and DRPT enjoyed with regard to certain types of on-call contracts was eliminated from the code.
    • 02:31:07
      And as a result, we would have been basically certain types of on-call contracts such as
    • 02:31:14
      environmental inspection, certain types of engineering contracts.
    • 02:31:19
      Our hands would have really been tied to certain projects.
    • 02:31:21
      We would have been limited to a certain amount for a particular project and we would have had to go back to the well several times for just one project and use different entities to address those types of services for that particular project.
    • 02:31:35
      So this bill, we haven't had an impact yet because the bill from last year was not effective until July 2014.
    • 02:31:41
      So we were okay.
    • 02:31:43
      We've gotten this legislation that looks like it's going to be passed by both houses and signed into law.
    • 02:31:51
      And if that's the case, then we will be fine.
    • 02:31:55
      I'm going to skip 978 for just a minute.
    • 02:31:58
      House Bill 990 was basically a technical change to the law to bring Virginia's laws regarding relocation assistance benefits and payments in the case of property acquisitions for road projects, transportation projects, just to bring our law in conformity with MAP 21, the federal law.
    • 02:32:17
      So it's a very technical bill.
    • 02:32:19
      It seems to be doing fine.
    • 02:32:21
      House Bill 978.
    • 02:32:22
      On its face, this bill does not look like it affects the CTB, but it looks like there is an amendment or substitute in the works and the CTB will be impacted.
    • 02:32:33
      This bill was brought forward or VDOT requested this bill as a result of, I'm sure many of you are familiar with the situation last year when we had a dispute.
    • 02:32:43
      with the Midtown Downtown Tunnel Project, Portsmouth, the City of Portsmouth had several utilities.
    • 02:32:51
      The private entity engaged in a contract, the concessionaire in that PPTA project needed to have those utilities moved and Portsmouth was reluctant and was not cooperating.
    • 02:33:02
      Well, there's a provision in the PPTA today that basically states when utilities have to be relocated specifically and it's only for a PPTA project,
    • 02:33:12
      and there's not agreement between the private entity and the owner of those utilities.
    • 02:33:19
      They can go to the SBC and the SBC will resolve the dispute.
    • 02:33:23
      The SBC has the power to issue an order and, you know, to basically tell the parties, this is how this is going to work and this is how you're going to do the relocation.
    • 02:33:33
      When we, if you all will recall, we took this issue or the private entity, the concessionaire took this issue to the SBC
    • 02:33:41
      and at the end of the day the FCC based on the language in the statute indicated they did not have jurisdiction in this case.
    • 02:33:48
      They said they did not have jurisdiction over utilities owned by localities.
    • 02:33:54
      So as a result we sought legislation basically that would clarify and make it very clear that the FCC would even have jurisdiction over those locality owned utilities in the case of PPPA disputes.
    • 02:34:08
      In the house, on the house side, there was much concern on the part of localities.
    • 02:34:12
      They had very strong concerns and reservations.
    • 02:34:16
      about being made subject or having the SBC have jurisdiction over their utilities, and they expressed concern.
    • 02:34:24
      They agreed to work with us on the bill, and so it made it through the House.
    • 02:34:29
      But in the meantime, we've been working on a modification to that bill.
    • 02:34:33
      And the modification that the parties, all the interested stakeholders and entities,
    • 02:34:39
      to the best of our knowledge anyway have agreed to is that rather than have or submit these disputes to the FCC, they would be submitted to the CTB.
    • 02:34:53
      The CTB currently has authority in Title 33.1 to issue orders regarding utility relocation movement.
    • 02:35:02
      and this basically what this bill the draft the substitute would do would basically say the CTB regardless of the roadway or the particular location of the utility in the case of a PPTA the CTB would have authority over the disputes between the private entity and locality owned or utilities owned by political subdivisions and it's just in those situations.
    • 02:35:31
      That's the language that's been worked out.
    • 02:35:34
      It has not been tested in a committee yet.
    • 02:35:37
      It's being drafted.
    • 02:35:39
      The draft is being finalized, and it will probably go before subcommittee next Monday.
    • 02:35:46
      So I wanted you all to be aware of that.
    • 02:35:48
      And again, this has happened.
    • 02:35:51
      We've run into this situation once, and we're not
    • 02:35:56
      We don't believe that this is something that you would see or would be seen on a frequent basis.
    • 02:36:02
      This was just, you know, a very infrequent issue, an occurrence, but at the same time we felt like the law needed to be fixed so that if it did ever happen again there would not be the kind of confusion.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:36:16
      Willa?
    • 02:36:16
      Could you give us, excuse me, do you know what the thinking was instead of going to the SEC to come back to us?
    • 02:36:26
      What was the basic technique there?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:36:28
      Mr.
    • 02:36:28
      Chair, Mr. Miller, it seems to be a strong reservation on the part of localities of having any, they are subject to certain, or to the jurisdiction of the FCC on very limited situations.
    • 02:36:43
      There's also a constitutional, the Constitution basically says that the FCC does not have jurisdiction over localities unless the General Assembly enacts laws.
    • 02:36:55
      They feel like it's a constitutional issue at the end of the day, and the more they can steer away from the SEC's jurisdiction, the better.
    • 02:37:04
      That's my understanding.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:37:08
      It just seems to me that since we are involved in PPTAs, that if we approve the PPTAs, we're going to approve the utility relocation if somebody resists.
    • 02:37:21
      So if I was a mentality, I would say, well, that's sort of like...
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:37:25
      Mr. Chairman, I think the Department is incredibly bureaucratic at the SEC.
    • 02:37:31
      It's a true judicial body.
    • 02:37:34
      And so when you file that, you've got briefs, you've got hearings, you've got all kinds of stuff.
    • 02:37:39
      I think that's the point.
    • 02:37:40
      I think that's why they want us to have it, so that we can make a decision efficiently and quickly.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:37:50
      Well, and Mr.
    • 02:37:50
      Chair, Mr. Miller, sometimes the disputes may not be over move or not move, but maybe how or where and timing, so.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:38:02
      You know, in the case that this came out, it was not a physical issue, it was a political issue that kept us all from moving forward.
    • 02:38:13
      And we've worked it out and it's, you know, moved on.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:38:18
      Moving right along, what I've tried to do on this slide is, these slides, is highlight those in yellow.
    • 02:38:27
      You don't have them highlighted on your copy.
    • 02:38:29
      House Bill 1183 is another bill that indirectly impacts the CTB.
    • 02:38:38
      This changes is currently a legislative body joint committee called the Joint Transportation Accountability Commission.
    • 02:38:47
      They have changed the name of that commission with this legislation.
    • 02:38:50
      and while they changed the name that's not that significant but what they have changed was they've added a new duty to this body and they've indicated that this body is to provide advice or to advise the CTB on matters pertaining to transportation policy, transportation innovation and technology, traffic congestion relief strategies.
    • 02:39:12
      Again, it's only an advisory.
    • 02:39:14
      role, but it is somewhat unique in that this body before they constantly were looking at various issues. Oftentimes when bills were problematic, they sent them to the Transportation Accountability Commission just to have them work out some issues. But this is somewhat of a unique role and a new role for this body. Again, it's...
    • 02:39:40
      It's staffed by, I think it's General Assembly members, I want to say it is, I think six
    • 02:39:55
      Delegates and maybe four senators and then one member, one person from JLARC.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:40:01
      What I think you see here is that it's the General Assembly filling as far as it possibly can without actually making the decisions.
    • 02:40:11
      That's really been pushing up against.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:40:15
      Mr. Chairman, if I don't put you on the spot, I don't know if the Governor is taking a decision on this bill or not, but this is a fundamental change.
    • 02:40:25
      This is a big deal.
    • 02:40:28
      This is not looking at it seeing how we've made decisions and making sure we're making good decisions and that we're spending the money wisely and stuff that they appropriate to it.
    • 02:40:37
      This is a little different.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:40:41
      The Governor, there is no position on the bill, but the Governor also reserves the right to veto things when it comes to him.
    • 02:40:50
      He has the last look.
    • 02:40:51
      So, we'll see how this ends up.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:54
      I don't understand.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:40:56
      Do you understand the problem?
    • 02:40:58
      No.
    • 02:40:58
      Help me.
    • 02:41:00
      To have members of the General Assembly advise us of matters pertaining to transportation policy, transportation innovation, and technologies, and traffic congestion relief, basically has the legislative branch doing what the executive branch is supposed to be doing and through the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 02:41:16
      So the Commission on Transportation Accountability and Solutions Working Group is a legislative?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:21
      It's a legislative commission.
    • 02:41:24
      Okay.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:41:24
      So there are a lot of things.
    • 02:41:29
      We should start these whole by saying that this session is the governor campaigned on Medicaid.
    • 02:41:38
      There's a lot of things that are going to be going back and forth over the next few weeks as that plays out.
    • 02:41:45
      So there is this thinking that you don't need to play all your cards until, you know, but anyway, Ms. Brown, we certainly understand your point.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:42:01
      There are several bills under the funding revenue tax-related legislation that I wanted to point out.
    • 02:42:08
      They are House Bill 1048,
    • 02:42:11
      House Bill 1095 and SB 518 and those three bills are significant because they impact the 500 million alternative CTB formula that was enacted in 2012 and they do it in a couple of different ways.
    • 02:42:28
      House Bill 1048 does two things.
    • 02:42:31
      As you all probably are aware, in that formula, in the $500 million alternative allocation formula, there's 25% of those monies that are allocated go to primary and interstate.
    • 02:42:46
      There was a group of folks primarily from local government cities who felt like that language needed to be broadened or to be clarified.
    • 02:42:59
      In the past or at this point VDOT had been our impression or understanding that those funds were allocated only to roads maintained by VDOT in VDOT system.
    • 02:43:13
      There was another group that felt that these roads actually, the intent was to also include roads on the primary system that went through cities that were what we call primary extension.
    • 02:43:26
      And so legislation was put in to make it clear that those roads are also eligible for this funding.
    • 02:43:33
      It doesn't mandate
    • 02:43:34
      A. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 02:43:45
      House Bill 1048 also decreases the threshold for vehicles per day on unpaved roads.
    • 02:43:53
      In that formula there's also five percent I believe that's dedicated to paving unpaved roads and that threshold today, the road in order to be eligible, that unpaved road has to have, enjoy 200 vehicle per day traffic rates.
    • 02:44:09
      D. This bill would reduce that to 50 per day, which will arguably allow for more spending on those roads.
    • 02:44:18
      House Bill 1095 is another bill that impacts the CTB formula.
    • 02:44:25
      What that bill does is it creates a new fund entitled Innovation and Technology Transportation Fund.
    • 02:44:34
      That fund is funded by, among other things, the 5% allocation that this board makes pursuant to the CTB allocation formula for Smart Road Technologies.
    • 02:44:49
      There were some concerns at first that this bill might impact the funding and the allocations that had already been made, but the way they structured the language, the way they set this bill up,
    • 02:45:01
      is basically the uses for which this transportation fund can be used or this technology and transportation fund can be used are exactly the same reasons that the smart road technology or it's defined in the same way as the smart road technology.
    • 02:45:17
      So basically, this bill is not going to impact any current allocations or any current plans or projects to spend money on that particular part of the program.
    • 02:45:31
      518 is the same as House Bill 1048, only it does not address the unpaved roads.
    • 02:45:45
      And moving right along.
    • 02:45:48
      The hybrid taxes, I think there was mention of this a little bit earlier that for the most part the funding from Munich mentioned, I think, that the transportation bill from last year remained untouched with the exception of the hybrid fee.
    • 02:46:03
      There are two bills, House Bill 975 and Senate Bill 127 that basically will repeal the $64 annual fee for hybrid vehicles.
    • 02:46:16
      Again, that caught a lot of people last year and this year.
    • 02:46:20
      That is the one thing that seems to have to grab hold.
    • 02:46:25
      The impact of that basically is based on fiscal impact statements we've seen.
    • 02:46:31
      FY24, there's also an aspect of this bill where DMV would have to actually pay those fees that have been paid thus far for fiscal year 2015, I believe.
    • 02:46:45
      No.
    • 02:46:48
      For registration years beginning on or after July 1, 2014.
    • 02:46:51
      The bottom line, DMV allows you to pay your vehicle reg fees in advance, so there's going to have to be a refunding component associated with that.
    • 02:47:01
      The impact of that is about $2.2 million.
    • 02:47:03
      Then for the loss in revenues going forward, 2015 is estimated at 6.9 million loss, 2016 7.8 million loss, and that ramps up to about a 10.7 million loss in years 2019-2020.
    • 02:47:17
      So just so you're aware.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:47:26
      The next bill is
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:47:29
      has been a significant effort or represents a significant effort on the part of VDOT as well as legislative services and the code commission.
    • 02:47:38
      Every so often the General Assembly or the Code Commission feels it's time to recodify titles in the Code because they've either become obsolete or they're no longer consistent with the structure that they're using for new codes.
    • 02:47:53
      And that's what's happened over the last two years.
    • 02:47:56
      We've been working with the Code Commission, and the Code Commission is the entity that decides when it's time to do this.
    • 02:48:02
      We did not solicit or ask that this be done, but this is something strictly under the purview of the Code Commission.
    • 02:48:08
      They thought it was time to recodify Title 33.1.
    • 02:48:12
      So over the last two years, we've been working on recodification efforts.
    • 02:48:18
      Basically, recodification is not intended to change the law substantively.
    • 02:48:23
      It's only intended to be a restructuring of the law.
    • 02:48:26
      In some instances, it will change the law substantively if there are obsolete provisions in the law that just no longer apply.
    • 02:48:34
      So that's what we've been working on.
    • 02:48:35
      A couple of things that are unique about this particular recodification, we're bringing title, the new title will be 33.2.
    • 02:48:43
      We're bringing in other aspects of other titles and in particular what's probably most significant is the PPTA will now be brought under Title 33.2 where it was in a different title.
    • 02:48:54
      So it will now be under Title 33.2 more closely associated with transportation law.
    • 02:49:05
      We had a couple of reports or studies that you might want to be aware of.
    • 02:49:11
      There was one, SJR 46, and again this will not impact the CTB, but those members who are representing Hampton Roads District may hear about this.
    • 02:49:23
      Basically, SJR 46 requires us to study the location of the Regional Hampton Roads Office on Route 460 in Suffolk and look at whether or not there might be better locations for that facility.
    • 02:49:36
      We are to report our findings, I believe it's at the beginning of November or December of next year, before the next session anyway.
    • 02:49:44
      That is an effort we will be working on as soon as this legislation passes.
    • 02:49:50
      S.J.R.
    • 02:49:51
      30, well now S.R.
    • 02:49:54
      32.
    • 02:49:54
      This bill has an interesting history.
    • 02:49:58
      There was a House joint resolution and a Senate joint resolution that addressed I-73 and basically the intent of these resolutions were to have studies performed to see how I-73 construction could be sped up, how we could actually get I-73 going and up and running.
    • 02:50:20
      And on the House side, the House joint resolution, again, because the joint resolutions, both sides have to pass the resolution.
    • 02:50:28
      The House resolution failed.
    • 02:50:30
      And so the Senate knew that there was no way, if they sent this resolution over to the House, that it would survive.
    • 02:50:36
      So what they have done is they have taken this Senate joint resolution, converted it to a Senate resolution, which means only the Senate has to pass it.
    • 02:50:47
      And basically the bill is now saying, rather than there being a joint committee to study both houses,
    • 02:50:54
      Now there will just be a Senate committee to study the I-73 project and ways to get it going.
    • 02:51:00
      At this point, it looks like it is going to consist of three members from the Senate Transportation Committee and three members from the Senate Local Government Committee.
    • 02:51:14
      Again, there seems to be, based on the discussions in committee,
    • 02:51:20
      just a strong feeling on the part of at least the local legislators from those areas that I-73 needs to move forward.
    • 02:51:35
      I should say, too, I believe this study is supposed to take place over two years, and
    • 02:51:46
      There will be two reports, one in 2014 and another one in 2015.
    • 02:52:05
      Technology, I'll just briefly note that many of the speakers' bills, or many of the bills this year, and in particular several of the speakers' bills, strong emphasis on technology, VDOT and the Secretary are to implement measures that emphasize technology and ways to enhance transportation through technology.
    • 02:52:24
      SB 156, this bill
    • 02:52:28
      will require VDOT to develop and implement a plan to eliminate the maintenance of use associated with electronic toll collection transponders no later than September 1, 2014.
    • 02:52:38
      One last
    • 02:52:44
      This is a carried over bill, by the way, so it is not coming to fruition, but the fact that it's carried over may mean it may come back.
    • 02:52:52
      There were a couple of bills this year that would have required studies in the equity of transportation funding and just have everybody look at how transportation funding is being handled now.
    • 02:53:03
      I think part of the rationale here, they would have J-Law do this.
    • 02:53:07
      One of the reasons for not doing it was J. Locke was just too swamped.
    • 02:53:11
      They didn't have enough room for study.
    • 02:53:12
      The other I heard was that there was some sentiment that we've just gotten those funds from 2313, so maybe we should give it a little more time.
    • 02:53:21
      And then finally Senate Bill 606.
    • 02:53:25
      This is a bill that would have made evolution payments to Chesterfield.
    • 02:53:31
      Based on the description of the locality in the bill, the only entity that would have qualified would have been Chesterfield.
    • 02:53:39
      That bill was carried over as well, kind of the same reasoning.
    • 02:53:43
      There was a significant fiscal impact.
    • 02:53:45
      There were concerns that perhaps Chesterfield was not ready to take over its own road system.
    • 02:53:50
      And finally, thirdly, you know, the thought was VDOT has just, we've come into these 2313 funds, perhaps we should give it a little time.
    • 02:53:59
      And that, Mr.
    • 02:54:00
      Chair, is it.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:54:01
      Thank you.
    • 02:54:02
      Any questions?
    • 02:54:05
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:54:05
      Okay, a couple more things before we move into the formal session.
    • 02:54:11
      First of all,
    • 02:54:13
      He'll be no stranger to you, and the reason I saved him for now is to make him set through what he's missing here on CTB.
    • 02:54:20
      Doug Coulomay has been named the Director of the Public-Private Partnership Office, the P3 office, and Doug, why don't you come on up here for a second?
    • 02:54:31
      And we are, State's very fortunate.
    • 02:54:35
      I'm extremely pleased that Doug, he saw the salary, he thought of his chair, and then
    • 02:54:40
      came back and said yes, so we're glad to have you here and just want to make sure, of course you know many of these people, but some of you don't, so welcome.
    • 02:54:49
      Well, Mr. Chairman, thank you very much.
    • 02:54:52
      Indeed, I have served on the board with at least eight of you, I believe, and of course Ms. Mathis, thank you very much for keeping us all together from month to month.
    • 02:55:02
      But I will say this, the offer from the Secretary to consider this position and the comments and my discussions with the Governor about his expectations just made it a good challenge to pick up.
    • 02:55:15
      So I'm looking forward to rejoining the team and helping us build even further in the direction that many of you helped contribute to over the last few years.
    • 02:55:25
      Some of you will remember, the CTB actually stood up the Office of Transportation Public-Private Partnerships four years ago.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:31
      We wanted it to have the attention it deserved.
    • 02:55:34
      We wanted to be a great advocate for this type of finance and project delivery.
    • 02:55:40
      And we quite frankly wanted it to kind of be on its own so it could be creative and imaginative in the way it approached things.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:55:48
      One of the biggest reasons I decided to take the job was that success that we've had over those last four years.
    • 02:55:57
      Our business model is simple.
    • 02:55:59
      We want to create attractive investment opportunities that enhance our transportation service delivery and we want to look for opportunities in all directions.
    • 02:56:09
      We want to build on the success and experiences that we've had over the last few years.
    • 02:56:13
      We want to strengthen the institutional support within state government and public understanding of how public-private partnerships really work and not only help extend the financial capacity of the Commonwealth, but actually help us deliver projects more quickly, more imaginatively, and with an eye toward the value that's really created when we make these investments.
    • 02:56:36
      We want to strengthen and broaden the relationships that we have with all others in this area and then finally we want to refine our analytics so we're always smarter about what we've actually done with the return on the investments we make are.
    • 02:56:51
      And we can be guided going forward.
    • 02:56:53
      So those are kind of some broad goals that I've talked with my own office about.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:58
      We're looking forward to developing them further with a strategic exercise with the larger, wider transportation family, and that includes you.
    • 02:57:07
      So thank you very much, and I look forward to working with you month to month and year to year.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:57:14
      Glad to have you back.
    • 02:57:17
      All right.
    • 02:57:19
      I'm going to do a couple updates on some major projects in the state that have just recently come to fruition, some areas that I know I wanted to form a board about.
    • 02:57:31
      First of all, start with Route 460.
    • 02:57:34
      As you know, we are in the process of trying to obtain the permit from the Corps of Engineers.
    • 02:57:41
      That process has taken longer than anyone projected, and that risk of getting that permit rests with the state.
    • 02:57:51
      Governor McAuliffe has made clear that he does not want to risk any more monies on the project until we get the permit.
    • 02:58:01
      He understands the importance of the road, but being good fiduciaries, that we should not continue to move forward with anything other than getting all the efforts on the permit.
    • 02:58:11
      You recall the 460 Funding Corporation, VDOT, and our partners, 460 Mobility Partners, fully had a comprehensive agreement.
    • 02:58:22
      So I've worked with them over the last few weeks, and we've been able to reach an agreement on a negotiated contract modification.
    • 02:58:31
      And I want to point out our partners, 460 Mobility Partners, were just great to work with.
    • 02:58:36
      They understand what's happened.
    • 02:58:38
      So all the contract will now be modified to say over the next, and I want to say six or eight months, but it may be longer than that, the only money being spent on 460 by contract will be in support of getting the permit from the Army Corps of Engineers.
    • 02:58:56
      So I just wanted to bring you up to speed on that.
    • 02:58:59
      That will cause a delay in the delivery of the project, but we were going to have that delay anyway based on that.
    • 02:59:07
      And so I'm very thankful to our partners for working with us and putting that in, and I believe we have the best case now for taking this project forward into the future in that.
    • 02:59:19
      So we're all lined up, and I wanted to bring the board up to speed as to what was going on there.
    • 02:59:26
      Mr. Kilpatrick, the commissioner, believes we'll get the permit in six to eight months.
    • 02:59:32
      I'm a little more, I'm going to be a little more, maybe a year.
    • 02:59:36
      And hopefully, I hope he's right.
    • 02:59:38
      But as we work through this process, we believe that this is the best way to move the project forward.
    • 02:59:44
      And we'll be working now, we've hired outside consultants, working with the Army Corps of Engineers, looking at the alternatives to bring this road to fruition.
    • 02:59:52
      So that's 460.
    • 02:59:54
      The second is the Route 29 bypass.
    • 02:59:58
      I'm going to have Carol pass out a letter to you that the Commissioner received yesterday from the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 03:00:09
      It is regarding the revised environmental assessment for the Route 29 bypass.
    • 03:00:13
      As you all know, we were waiting for that decision to come.
    • 03:00:17
      Based on the Federal Highway Administration's review and upon advice of their Council, they have informed the Commissioner that VDOT should update the purpose and need for the project and reopen the process for the consideration of alternatives.
    • 03:00:32
      They have basically said that they could not issue a finding of no economic impact or environmental impact with the existing alignment and has directed VDOT to look at alternatives for moving forward there.
    • 03:00:46
      In speaking with the Commissioner, he and I both agree we need to focus on the future, not the past, and we're going to look at how we're going to mitigate congestion in the Route 29, Salzburg area in the future.
    • 03:01:00
      I can only deal with where we are now and how we've gotten there.
    • 03:01:05
      So we are committed, the Governor has made clear two things that we're committed to fixing mobility in the area, but also being good stewards.
    • 03:01:15
      So I have instructed the Commissioner to have VDOT develop a plan to move forward and to consider potential alternative solutions to addressing the Route 29 corridor in the Charlottesville area.
    • 03:01:27
      Now I'll also point out that I have spoken personally with representatives from Charlottesville and from Albemarle, they have met with them here, and they have all told me they are committed to a solution.
    • 03:01:38
      They may not have agreed with what was on the books, but they have told me they are committed to a solution.
    • 03:01:43
      The administration is committed to a solution.
    • 03:01:46
      So the answer to do nothing is just as unacceptable to us as maybe this finding is to some others.
    • 03:01:54
      So we will be moving forward.
    • 03:01:56
      I don't know exactly what that process will be.
    • 03:01:59
      I know many of you may have questions as to the timing.
    • 03:02:03
      That's why I've asked the Commissioner here to put together a time frame as to how we were to move forward on the project and working to develop a solution of how we're going to increase mobility and lessen travel times in the area.
    • 03:02:18
      So I just wanted to make sure you guys, there's no action required today, but I wanted to let you know where we stood on the projects and how we were moving forward on both of those in there.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:30
      Ms. Fisher?
    • 03:02:31
      I have just one quick question.
    • 03:02:32
      I understand that we're pretty close to the limit on the right of ways that we've purchased on that.
    • 03:02:37
      What happens to all of that?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:02:38
      When you say the limits, you mean...
    • 03:02:42
      But the time limit before we have to start constructing or return?
    • 03:02:46
      All right, Nick, he's been doing the research, but that's not going to be a factor that's going to restrict us in our decision.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:02:54
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fisher, in some discussions with USCOT late last night, they indicated that the right-of-way could be sold as long as the
    • 03:03:02
      Martin, W. C.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:21
      But now they're telling us the environmental process that they led, they decided against it.
    • 03:03:27
      And if I heard what Nick just said, and let's sell off the right-of-way, so that whole project, there may be some alternative out there, but it's not going to be the alternative.
    • 03:03:36
      They'll come to books, and they'll spend on the books.
    • 03:03:38
      That is correct.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:03:43
      Because of our inability to move forward, they determined that the need and purpose was not met because of the passage of time.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:03:55
      So it's really not, this is pretty clear if you read the letter what their position is.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:04:00
      So, fortunately, I'm not going to do anything with the right-of-ways, because we're going to look at all the alternatives up there, but they would be sold back at the original pricing on there, if it happens.
    • 03:04:29
      But, again, that action has not been determined.
    • 03:04:34
      If we look at alternatives, I'm not sure exactly what right away would be needed up there.
    • 03:04:40
      But I want to reiterate, we are committed to doing something in the quarter.
    • 03:04:45
      And I have told the Commissioner I'm not interested in studying it the next two years.
    • 03:04:49
      But we have to get federal monies.
    • 03:04:51
      We have to go through the process.
    • 03:04:53
      In 460, I mentioned that the state had taken the risk of providing that permit.
    • 03:05:03
      By contract, our partners could have held us responsible even though we couldn't produce the permit.
    • 03:05:13
      We were able to reach a negotiated position with them to continue forward.
    • 03:05:17
      That is not the situation we have here on Route 29.
    • 03:05:21
      The contract had a condition to notice to proceed.
    • 03:05:25
      We'll work with our contractors.
    • 03:05:27
      It's determined what we build up there.
    • 03:05:29
      In that case, we'll work with them.
    • 03:05:31
      But there is not a significant penalty for that phase of the contract.
    • 03:05:37
      But what is important is that we get the issues associated with mobility.
    • 03:05:45
      I've had personal meetings, again, with the localities, with the commitment that they will work, and I've made it clear to them that the answer is to do nothing.
    • 03:05:55
      The answer will not be acceptable to do nothing.
    • 03:05:57
      That was not going to be an acceptable answer, and we'll work, and as long as we're working through that, we'll all work collaboratively to try to get this situation addressed.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:06:08
      I have one question now.
    • 03:06:10
      How much money is in the six-year plan for that, and are we going to reallocate it now?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:06:18
      Approximately $200 million, and as of right now, there has been no deallocation of those monies, and until we determine how we go forward, that's a little premature to talk about that.
    • 03:06:33
      Our intention is to solve that issue that we have.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:37
      Yes, Mr. Secretary, in looking at this, everything had been approved and there was supposed to be an environmental assessment.
    • 03:06:52
      And in looking at this letter, nowhere in this letter
    • 03:06:56
      Does the U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration say anything about the environment in this letter?
    • 03:07:04
      It's bizarre.
    • 03:07:06
      What they say is, we don't like it, and go look at it and make sure the localities agree with it, and they say absolutely nothing about any kind of environmental impact.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:07:17
      You can address that, but the purpose and need is a big part of the environmental assessment.
    • 03:07:21
      You can address that, Mr. Kilpatrick.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:23
      Fundamentally from the letter.
    • 03:07:26
      We had been working through what's called an environmental assessment, an EA.
    • 03:07:31
      At the end of that process, if you look at the federal environmental process, the largest or the most comprehensive document culminates in a record of decision, which we have on this particular project.
    • 03:07:46
      We've actually had more than one record of decision over the years.
    • 03:07:52
      The record of decision is the decision that takes into account
    • 03:07:57
      The environmental impact, how the project meets the purpose and need, and there's a series of elements to the purpose and need.
    • 03:08:06
      But again, back to the environmental process.
    • 03:08:08
      In this case, the EA that we had been in the process of going through on behalf of the Federal Highway Administration, because that is not Virginia's document.
    • 03:08:18
      That's an important point, that this is a federal action.
    • 03:08:23
      A record of decision is a federal action.
    • 03:08:25
      A finding of no significant impact is a federal action.
    • 03:08:29
      Now the state of Virginia and VDOT specifically provides the staff work that develops the study, but ultimately it goes to the Federal Highway to make that decision because they are the federal agency.
    • 03:08:44
      In this particular case, what they are saying here is that they do not believe that the EA that we had drafted and were presenting to them
    • 03:08:52
      would result in a finding of no significant impact.
    • 03:08:56
      And that's why they're directing that a supplemental environmental impact study, which is part of a more comprehensive review, is being required.
    • 03:09:07
      And that's, again, fundamentally what they're saying here is that because of the factors that they've put in here, that a FONSI for the EA process, which is a less comprehensive process, is not adequate.
    • 03:09:23
      Now the, to the, less comprehensive than that is what's called a categorical exclusion.
    • 03:09:29
      Those typically are done on very simple projects typically within the existing right of way prison.
    • 03:09:35
      So what they're saying here is that the EA was not sufficient in terms of addressing, reviewing the impact based on today's environment.
    • 03:09:46
      When I say environment, I mean simply the environment in terms of ecology
    • 03:09:50
      but the overall environment in the region.
    • 03:09:53
      So that's what all of these words, that's what they come to say is that a more comprehensive document is required and again they go on to say that it needs to look at alternatives and to relook at the purpose and need.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:10:09
      Yes, Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:10
      But they also say, I guess, and I'm just saying, what I heard you say, Charlie, was that
    • 03:10:18
      The information provided in the EA was not going to be sufficient to make a determination, so do some more stuff.
    • 03:10:25
      But it also says, based on our EA analysis, our knowledge of the project and FHWA's involvement, and going back to the late 1980s, it is expected that a reassessment of the purpose and need will find that it's no longer adequate.
    • 03:10:42
      Martin Luther King Jr., John F. Kennedy
    • 03:11:00
      as to what they expect.
    • 03:11:01
      So it's not just it's all, you know, you didn't give us everything we needed, tons have changed, look again.
    • 03:11:07
      They've already told you what they expect the answer's going to be, which is no.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:12
      They have predetermined an outcome on this.
    • 03:11:14
      You're right.
    • 03:11:15
      They have said, you know, if we go out and say this is our preferred alignment before you go through the EIS, everybody screams your violation.
    • 03:11:21
      It's a predetermination of an outcome.
    • 03:11:23
      They've predetermined an outcome.
    • 03:11:25
      And I understand what you're saying about what all these words mean.
    • 03:11:28
      What all these words mean is that after two EISs, an EIS, a supplemental EIS, two EAs, three records of decisions, all those times saying this is what to do, they're now saying study further.
    • 03:11:40
      Oh, by the way, if you study this, we're going to deny it because we've predetermined an outcome.
    • 03:11:45
      This is my federal tax dollars that weren't paying for this.
    • 03:11:48
      This is ridiculous.
    • 03:11:49
      When the citizens of Virginia, the taxpayers of Virginia are sitting in congestion, they can call Federal Highways and they can let them know, thank you very much, we'll study everything to death and get nothing done because you guys can't make up your mind.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:12:02
      Well, that presumes that they would resolve that this would actually improve the situation.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:12:08
      I understand what you're saying.
    • 03:12:09
      I'm as frustrated as you are.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:12:10
      But what they're saying is they don't believe this road will improve the situation.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:18
      They are pre-determining it.
    • 03:12:19
      They're doing it before their new study, after four others did it.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:12:23
      Well, they're telling us to go back.
    • 03:12:25
      I understand.
    • 03:12:26
      But they're going to go back in the suit and look at other alternatives.
    • 03:12:30
      And so that's our choice if we want to move forward.
    • 03:12:33
      You can liken it to what we're dealing with on 469.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:37
      Well, the practical matter, I mean, I hear you, but it's a practical matter.
    • 03:12:42
      It might as well, if they decided what the answer is and they're going to tell you in advance, I'd rather them do that than, of course, them do the block list.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:50
      You got a point there.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:12:51
      It's a little unfair for them to change the rules, the federal rules in this process that they've done.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:12:57
      Mr. Krosinski, do you have a... Mike, I share the concerns in life.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:13:01
      I look to our Bi-County Parkway, which has also been studied for 20 years, is in the hands of the Highway Administration soon, and if we get another letter like this on the Bi-County
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:13:16
      That really raises my eyebrows in concern.
    • 03:13:20
      We don't have a rod yet, right, Charlie said.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:13:23
      We don't have a rod, and let me also point out to, I would suggest to you there was some calculated issues taken, determined to go down a certain path on these two projects, and we have now found that they did not work.
    • 03:13:42
      The best way forward from my perspective is to address these issues and move forward.
    • 03:13:49
      I think we've been down the path the other way.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:52
      I would agree with that.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:14:05
      Just one thing following on this.
    • 03:14:07
      I think this illustrates quite frankly the problem we have with developing road projects in a timely fashion because 20 years does
    • 03:14:17
      Martin, W. J. Peake, Roger Cole III,
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 03:14:42
      I saw what I'm saying.
    • 03:14:44
      Twenty years by the time you have it.
    • 03:14:46
      But you have environmental issues and all these things that drag down the timelines on road projects.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:14:53
      And that is the ironic part about this because it turns around and bites you.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:14:58
      I think it shows a couple things.
    • 03:15:00
      One is we need to get buy-in up front if we're going to move forward, and I assume some things we have, but also that it is the process and the best way
    • 03:15:15
      is to get the most efficient way through that process.
    • 03:15:18
      Now I want to say, Mr. Rinder, we did four things and they also reference political situations in there.
    • 03:15:29
      But from our perspective, I will not put the Commonwealth at risk by moving forward until we get a solution
    • 03:15:38
      who moved the same way on 460, same way on this.
    • 03:15:42
      Until we have authority, we will not continue to spend money on construction or anything.
    • 03:15:48
      Having said that, I believe that is the quickest way forward on both of these projects to get through these processes and get them to fruition.
    • 03:15:56
      That's where we are.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:15:59
      Mr.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:15:59
      Chair, as I read the letter, they're saying the purpose of the EA was to determine whether a supplemental EIS was necessary.
    • 03:16:08
      And they're also saying there's no reason to do the EA.
    • 03:16:11
      They know the supplemental EIS is going to be necessary.
    • 03:16:14
      That's right.
    • 03:16:16
      Is it our intent to move forward then with the supplemental EIS?
    • 03:16:20
      That's what I've asked the Commissioner.
    • 03:16:22
      We want the quickest way to a solution.
    • 03:16:26
      That, you know, when you open up, you bring all the baggage in that you had before.
    • 03:16:32
      It may be quicker to just say, we want to do this, and just open up a new thing.
    • 03:16:37
      In other words, that's the question.
    • 03:16:39
      I can't answer, Mr. Cole, but I've directed the commissioner to work with his people to say, what is the quickest way forward?
    • 03:16:47
      And I'm coming from the standpoint that I've had all the parties tell me they are committed to moving forward.
    • 03:16:55
      On a, yeah, not on this solution, but, let me say, solving this traffic issue.
    • 03:17:03
      Now, I'm sure there's a precedence, one, Mr. Garczynski mentioned, by Kenny Cartway, but is there a precedence, not for this action, but for the history that we've seen there, the project
    • 03:17:20
      evolves over a 20-year period or three decades.
    • 03:17:24
      Do we have a history?
    • 03:17:26
      We've got a couple.
    • 03:17:27
      We have 460 where we run into a similar situation.
    • 03:17:33
      It's not exactly the same, but it's still the risk.
    • 03:17:36
      We don't have a permit.
    • 03:17:37
      In that particular case, Federal Highways supported 460.
    • 03:17:43
      Army Corps of Engineers, not a Federal Department, said no.
    • 03:17:47
      Charlie, you may have more history in that regard, but...
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:54
      There are, around the state, there have been projects that have stretched on for decades, literally, this being one of them.
    • 03:18:02
      There have been several others that have several reasons.
    • 03:18:07
      It may be the region, it's a priority and then it becomes less of a priority.
    • 03:18:15
      funding challenges that come up over the life of a project.
    • 03:18:20
      We've had several projects that have gone through a series of lawsuits.
    • 03:18:27
      So is this unique to the 29 and Charlottesville bypass?
    • 03:18:33
      The answer is no.
    • 03:18:34
      Do we have a lot of them?
    • 03:18:36
      No, but in terms of the type of projects that tend to create this type of
    • 03:18:43
      Churn is typically their Greenfield projects, projects on new locations.
    • 03:18:49
      They typically are a balance between, again, going across new ground versus improving an existing corridor.
    • 03:18:59
      And this repeats itself in a number of places throughout the state.
    • 03:19:02
      So it's not, it is not unique.
    • 03:19:05
      This particular project, the original record of decision included three elements.
    • 03:19:11
      which talked about first of the widening of 29 and that was done I recall 1994 to 97 somewhere in that time frame we actually widened 29 from I believe this is from hydraulic to the Ravenna River it was four lanes widened to eight and ten lanes a second piece of that was great separation several intersections along the existing 29 corridor and then the third element of the original ride was the
    • 03:19:38
      Martin, W. J. Peake, Roger Cole, W. John M. Martin, John M. Martin,
    • 03:20:05
      Once we decide a project needs to move forward, we get the input from the region and we move forward with diligence on the project.
    • 03:20:17
      This project, because of the length of time, a lot of development has occurred.
    • 03:20:22
      A lot of things have changed along the corridor that has made it most difficult.
    • 03:20:27
      And we were pretty far along in this process in terms of right-of-way acquisition.
    • 03:20:31
      But that right-of-way was acquired a number of years ago, in some cases 10 or more years ago, that that right-of-way was acquired.
    • 03:20:38
      And then the project went largely fallow for a number of years.
    • 03:20:43
      And that, again, that's the struggle on a facility like this.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:50
      Yes, Mr. Powell.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 03:20:51
      I'm relieved to hear that we do not have to reverse any time.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:20:57
      Well, that's what we believe.
    • 03:21:00
      We don't know that for sure, and quite frankly, I think that's all going to hinge on how we move forward.
    • 03:21:07
      I mean, in other words, we want to get a solution, and this is not about penalizing anything, so I'll make that clear, but I think we have to find a solution for what's going on here.
    • 03:21:18
      And so that solution is wrapped up in how we go about doing all this.
    • 03:21:23
      But you're right.
    • 03:21:24
      We don't think so, but that's not necessarily the case.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:28
      So that would be the icing on the cake.
    • 03:21:29
      Hey, we're canceling your project.
    • 03:21:30
      Oh, by the way, reimbursing for the cost.
    • 03:21:32
      Right.
    • 03:21:32
      I understand.
    • 03:21:33
      I understand.
    • 03:21:34
      The way they do the same thing.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:21:36
      Yeah.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:21:36
      In talking with the Secretary, he's asked that I come back to him within 30 days with at least a preliminary half-mast forward.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:06
      So that we can talk about what's a viable path forward, and I'm confident that we can do that with looking at options that can move a project forward that can relieve congestion in the 29 corridor.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:22
      Oh, I'm glad that doing nothing is not going to be a concern, that you're committed to before solving the congestion issue.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:22:37
      I don't, Mr. Krasinski, I don't necessarily, I understand what you're saying, President, I don't necessarily see in this, in the, this period in the Bi-County Parkway, I think it just tells us we need to really assess what, what our risks are and what we can deliver before we sign a contract.
    • 03:22:56
      It just causes me caution, right?
    • 03:23:00
      Our fate on the Bi-County will eventually be in the same hands.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:05
      Didn't this really point out to the fact that it's just sort of common sense.
    • 03:23:12
      You start a project 20 years ago because you're trying to sort of plan beyond tomorrow.
    • 03:23:20
      And you've got all these hurdles you've got to go through, including finding the money.
    • 03:23:25
      So you go through hurdle after hurdle after hurdle after hurdle, and you finally find the money.
    • 03:23:31
      And then you get ready to pull the trigger, but conditions have changed.
    • 03:23:34
      You know, 20 years is a heck of a long time when you're not in a green field in the middle of nowhere.
    • 03:23:42
      And, you know, it's sort of like the process in and of itself.
    • 03:23:45
      And in fact, you remember, if you recall, I questioned some of that, not having a long history with the project when I was, when I voted on it.
    • 03:23:54
      I said, well, like, some of these studies are 20 years old.
    • 03:23:59
      You know, there's a lot of changes in 20 years.
    • 03:24:03
      I'm not happy about this, but it points to the problem of the process that takes that long in a growing area.
    • 03:24:20
      Because if it takes you that long, particularly if you don't have the money, the only thing we really control in this, other than our work to jump through these hoops, which we have to control a piece of that, is do we have the money now?
    • 03:24:32
      So it really puts you in a boat where you better not start planning and wasting your money, which is common sense because conditions are going to change 15 years from now and it's not the same situation.
    • 03:24:44
      So my question would be how do we deal with that going forward?
    • 03:24:49
      Because I understand it, but what do we do?
    • 03:24:53
      And I guess the answer is you better not be spending too much money
    • 03:24:57
      If this is going to be day or year, you better not be spending too much money on things.
    • 03:25:01
      They're going to take a long time to get there because you're at big risk.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:25:06
      And I'll come back to it, but part of it is this did lay fallow a long time.
    • 03:25:13
      That's my point.
    • 03:25:14
      It laid fallow.
    • 03:25:15
      In other words, it's not like we were going forward with a project, working with everybody,
    • 03:25:20
      This lay fallow, all of a sudden it's back on.
    • 03:25:23
      Because of money and political will.
    • 03:25:24
      Political will and money.
    • 03:25:27
      Of course that political will has changed locally since this too.
    • 03:25:31
      I'm not suggesting that's right or wrong, it did.
    • 03:25:33
      So, I mean, I don't know what that is.
    • 03:25:36
      You know, I'm troubled a little bit about the political nature, but the bottom line is that I think it laid fallow so long.
    • 03:25:44
      And I think that's a little bit different than some of the other projects that we've pushed.
    • 03:25:49
      and continue the process and got them done, but I don't know specifically.
    • 03:25:54
      And Mr. Chairman, one other thing, too, I think, a project like this, too, it's the local government, if they're not fully engaged to properly plan ahead, they can cause a project not to be viable in a few years, because you have to, obviously, make sure that development doesn't occur in the area where you want to do things.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:13
      I mean, it's going to create problems that you didn't anticipate.
    • 03:26:16
      So a lot of that is local planning as well, and by way of value and then some other things happening, that's what happened with this project, I believe.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:25
      Martin, John C.
    • 03:26:41
      Don't delay with study after study, let's wait, let's drag this out for 10, 15, 20 years, get in, get it done, and move on.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:26:50
      And that's why I'm committed to, Commissioner here, what is the shortest way to getting a solution for this issue?
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:57
      I won't belabor it, but I can't tell you how disappointed I am.
    • 03:27:04
      to look at this letter and see this project haunted.
    • 03:27:08
      And Secretary, you talked about this line from the community.
    • 03:27:11
      This was bought in.
    • 03:27:13
      This was bought in 25 years ago from the North Carolina line to get to these things to protect the United States Route 29 and United States Highway.
    • 03:27:24
      There was a bypass around Danville starting at the North Carolina line.
    • 03:27:29
      That was done.
    • 03:27:30
      then around Amherst.
    • 03:27:32
      That was done.
    • 03:27:33
      The next step was Charlottesville and all three of these governments, local governments, bought into this project when the money was appropriated.
    • 03:27:42
      There's probably been half a billion dollars of Virginia taxpayer money spent on the rights-of-ways and the bypasses around Danville and around Madison Heights and the bypasses bought in Albemarle County to get around Charlottesville.
    • 03:27:56
      We're half a billion dollars into this project.
    • 03:27:58
      And their governments changed, and they decided, I don't like this.
    • 03:28:04
      And so then they started developing along that to help, you know, you didn't get it done right away when you did step one, you did step two, now it's phase three, and y'all hadn't gotten it done, so we're gonna change everything, and we're gonna zone, we're gonna fill that in, we're gonna fill it in, and we're gonna get our
    • 03:28:20
      Martin, W. C.
    • 03:28:42
      We're out half a billion dollars trying to protect this corridor of statewide significance.
    • 03:28:47
      It's now shut down again.
    • 03:28:49
      And the reason they're telling us is because the local governing boards don't want it.
    • 03:28:54
      And so the Federal Highway Administration is saying those local boards are now telling us they don't want it.
    • 03:28:58
      I don't care if you spend half a billion dollars.
    • 03:29:01
      Taxpayers are out of luck.
    • 03:29:02
      And I know, I've talked to the secretary and I know he's committed to making something happen.
    • 03:29:07
      I guarantee you, you will not get an approval from Albemarle, from the city of Charlottesville, from these other counties.
    • 03:29:14
      They come in here, they've been fighting for years.
    • 03:29:18
      Oh, we want to get something done.
    • 03:29:19
      Oh, forget the western bypass.
    • 03:29:20
      Now, we want the eastern bypass.
    • 03:29:22
      Oh, we want to do this.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:29:23
      I want to see some agreement.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:26
      And they got a meeting tonight.
    • 03:29:27
      I want to see some agreement from them where they want
    • 03:29:30
      What do they want done in the next year that's really going to help?
    • 03:29:34
      United States Route 29, Cord A.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:29:38
      It is frustrating.
    • 03:29:40
      I can understand the emotions from my position as Secretary.
    • 03:29:44
      The Governor's made it clear we're going to get projects that get the need done.
    • 03:29:51
      I think there is a clear question whether or not this project solved the need.
    • 03:29:54
      I agree with you all about all the issues, but there's a clear question.
    • 03:29:58
      That's why, without this approval, we cannot move forward.
    • 03:30:02
      We couldn't move forward anyway, but without it.
    • 03:30:04
      But we are committed to solving it.
    • 03:30:06
      Now I understand
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:08
      I can't wait to see the clear line that they're going to give us, where they all come in agreement and say, let's build the road right through here, because this is exactly how we want to do it, and let's see what happens in the next six months to a year.
    • 03:30:19
      I've been working quite 30 or 40 agreed upon projects from all of those localities saying, let's do this.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:30:26
      I want to see it.
    • 03:30:27
      Well, we'd like to say it.
    • 03:30:28
      Can only go forth from where we are.
    • 03:30:31
      What we're dealing with here is we cannot proceed as to what we have.
    • 03:30:35
      That's pretty clear.
    • 03:30:38
      We've been down that process and only moved forward and cannot obligate the state on a process that is not going to lead us anywhere.
    • 03:30:53
      Are there any more comments?
    • 03:30:55
      I wanted to update the board.
    • 03:30:56
      I suspected it was going to be... Did you want some more comments?
    • 03:31:01
      No, I think I've had quite a few.
    • 03:31:04
      I want it to be really right.
    • 03:31:07
      I don't see something.
    • 03:31:08
      Look, it's not good or bad.
    • 03:31:10
      It is what it is.
    • 03:31:12
      We've got to deal with it.
    • 03:31:13
      That's what I'm going to concentrate on.
    • 03:31:15
      That's what the Governor has instructed me to concentrate on, moving forward with how we get this solution squared away.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:31:22
      And that's what we're going to do.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:31:26
      I wanted you to understand where we were, and as we work, the next time we come, we'll have more detail as to how we need to proceed on this project.
    • 03:31:39
      Okay, if there's nothing else, that concludes the workshop session.
    • 03:31:45
      Why don't we take five minutes and then we'll run right into public comments.