Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 10/17/2012
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   10/17/2012

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Bids.pdf
  • Update on light rail.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2013 budget _ actual performance through September 2012.pdf
  • Budget comparison schedule, special revenue fund for fiscal year to date, September 2012.pdf
  • Department of Rail and Public Transportation public transportation funding study - SJR 297.pdf
  • The commonwealth's investment in public transit, SJ 297- A helpful overview.pdf
  • Study of transit-related issues in the commonwealth.pdf
  • Proposed Fiscal Years 2013- - 18 SYIP transfers and amendments.pdf
  • Route 460 Funding Corporation of Virginia toll road senior lien bonds, Series 201260.pdf
  • 1. Concrete Paving: Opportunities for Virginia ▶︎ 7:22

    • Concrete paving_ Opportunities for Virginia.pdf
  • 2. Hampton Roads Transit ▶︎ 31:28

  • 3. Financial Report ▶︎ 1:01:27

  • 4. Quarterly Financial Update ▶︎ 1:14:01

  • 5. A Review of Principal Arterial Routes on the National Highway System for Map-21 ▶︎ 1:29:26

    • Review of principal arterial routes on the National Highway System for MAP-21.pdf
  • 6. Criteria for Secondary to Primary System Transfers ▶︎ 2:00:06

    • Criteria for secondary to primary system transfers.pdf
  • 7. Virginia Strategic Highway Safety Plan ▶︎ 2:17:28

    • Virginia Strategic Highway Safety Plan.pdf
  • 8. SJR297 Report Briefing ▶︎ 2:40:48

  • 9. Route 460 Corridor Improvements ▶︎ 3:23:09

    • Route 460 Corridor Improvements Project major business term.pdf
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      I ask everyone please take your seats.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:08
      Good morning everyone.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:15
      I'd like to welcome you to October's meeting workshop of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:20
      I ask everyone please to rise and join us in the Pledge of Allegiance.
    • 00:00:26
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • 00:00:47
      Good morning, everyone.
    • 00:00:48
      Again, I'd like to welcome you to this morning's session of the CTB.
    • 00:00:53
      We have several new members with us this morning who are joining us, some for the first time.
    • 00:01:00
      Others, I guess they were able to join us in Winchester for our meeting up there last month or with us.
    • 00:01:07
      I would like to maybe ask the CTB members, the new ones, maybe just introduce themselves and tell us a little bit about themselves.
    • 00:01:16
      And for the old-timers, if they can just at least give them one and also just tell the new members a little bit about themselves as well.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:28
      Sonny Martin, President of Powwow National Bank in John Philip, Virginia, served on the board from 1996 to 2002.
    • 00:01:35
      Thank you.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:38
      Thank you.
    • 00:01:39
      And I'm Roger Cole from the Richmond Transportation District.
    • 00:01:43
      I've been on the board for just about a year now, approaching my one-year anniversary.
    • 00:01:47
      We'll skip the next one.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:49
      Go right there.
    • 00:01:51
      I'll be last.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:53
      I'm using to clean up the mess.
    • 00:01:56
      Go ahead, Allen.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:57
      No, no, no.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:59
      Never forget it.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:00
      My name's Sheppard Miller, and I'm a big target from Norfolk, Virginia, and I serve as an urban at-large member
    • 00:02:07
      What you all will come to know is sort of a second-tier member.
    • 00:02:11
      We wander aimlessly and humbly throughout the Commonwealth, but I'm pleased to be here and I'm pleased we've got some new blood to help us do our hard work, particularly Mr. Martin who can teach us a little something from a few years back.
    • 00:02:25
      So that's my story, Mr. Chairman, and I'm sticking to it.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:31
      I'm Allen Louderback, representing, well, rule at large.
    • 00:02:35
      So I guess I've got everything country-wide, statewide.
    • 00:02:39
      But as Chip says, in urban areas, he doesn't get any respect.
    • 00:02:43
      In rural areas, we've got a second tier as well.
    • 00:02:48
      But I have been in the legislature in the past.
    • 00:02:52
      I'm a businessman from Page County, and serving my second, almost going on third year.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:00
      I'm Mark Peake.
    • 00:03:01
      I represent the Lynchburg District.
    • 00:03:02
      I'm from Lynchburg.
    • 00:03:04
      I'm a lawyer there, and they talk about how bad their districts are, or their spots are.
    • 00:03:09
      I represent Lynchburg, and you'll soon find out that we get the least money of any district in the Commonwealth.
    • 00:03:15
      I'll mention that a time or two as we go through.
    • 00:03:18
      Welcome, and I'm glad to have you all on the board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:22
      Hi, I'm Aubrey Layne.
    • 00:03:23
      I'm the
    • 00:03:24
      District Member from Hampton Roads, and I would say I'm on the A-Team then if they've done that, but no, we are the largest district by landmass.
    • 00:03:34
      I know a couple of guys in rural Virginia have more people, but contrary to what Mr. Miller says, you'll find that he is definitely on the A-Team too as our conversations go on.
    • 00:03:44
      So welcome to all the new members.
    • 00:03:45
      We could use all the help we can get, so thank you.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:49
      Thelma Drake, Director of the Department of Rail and Public Transportation.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:53
      Whirley, Commissioner for VDOT.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:57
      Sean Connaughton, Secretary of Transportation, but also Chairman of the CCB.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:02
      Carol, you're the most important one.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:11
      My name is David Martin.
    • 00:04:13
      I represent the Salem District.
    • 00:04:18
      I'm specializing in cultural competency for law enforcement professionals and cultural competency on the CTB is a skill I sorely need.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:33
      My name is Court Sterling.
    • 00:04:35
      I represent the Fredericksburg District.
    • 00:04:37
      When I started on the CTB, I was an urban at-large member, so don't believe what Jeff said.
    • 00:04:42
      That has its own sets of challenges and rewards, which I found very good.
    • 00:04:46
      As a Fredericksburg District rep, I will say we have the most challenges in terms of funding for how we're stretched out, with both an urban area as well as a rural area, the needs we have.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:00
      I'm Gary Garzynski and I'm the Northern Virginia Representative, freshly minted.
    • 00:05:05
      I used to be an urban outlaw.
    • 00:05:08
      Shep, you remember that, don't you?
    • 00:05:10
      She deserted us.
    • 00:05:12
      And as an occupation, I'm a real estate developer and I also serve on the Board of Directors of the Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:22
      My name is Jim Rich.
    • 00:05:23
      I'm privileged to represent the most beautiful and historic district of the Culpeper District, the home of Thomas Jefferson and Madison.
    • 00:05:31
      I'm retired from the Shell Oil Company, and this is my second go-around on the board.
    • 00:05:37
      I also served under Governor George Allen before this.
    • 00:05:40
      Good to have the new members.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:43
      John Matney, representing the Bristol District, and real estate development in Virginia.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:51
      Dixon Whitworth, this is my second meeting.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:56
      I represent Stanton's history, the side in Winchester, Virginia, and I'm a retired banker.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:06
      And I'm Fran Fisher.
    • 00:06:10
      I guess that makes me the newest member of the party.
    • 00:06:11
      I am the urban at-large representative that replaced Gary as he moved up and I'm from Washington, Virginia.
    • 00:06:21
      I own a small business in the farm.
    • 00:06:23
      I have a digital management firm.
    • 00:06:24
      I just use mine to become a platform for that function agency.
    • 00:06:28
      Very small and fair-backed.
    • 00:06:31
      Welcome to all the new members and welcome back all
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:53
      The old-timers, and by the way, you all aspire to be Mr. Morgan, because there is a method to the madness in how you sit, in that the most junior members sit on the aisle, and they keep on moving closer and closer.
    • 00:07:05
      Great feat of power.
    • 00:07:07
      Then you become the senior member, and you become the secretary of the CTB.
    • 00:07:11
      On the left hand of power.
    • 00:07:16
      With all the privileges.
    • 00:07:17
      He gets to sign things, and he gets to get to, like,
    • 00:07:22
      First presentation, concrete paving, opportunities for Virginia.
    • 00:07:28
      Mr. Long, where are you?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:07:36
      Good morning.
    • 00:07:38
      Secretary Connaughton, Commissioner Whirley, Director Drake, members of the board, and guests.
    • 00:07:44
      I apologize in advance.
    • 00:07:45
      I don't think I can swivel enough to face both directions.
    • 00:07:49
      My name is Bob Long, and I'm the Executive Director of the American Concrete Pavement Association Mid-Atlantic Chapter located here in Richmond, Virginia.
    • 00:07:56
      And indeed, it's my pleasure today to talk to you a little bit about concrete and the concrete paving industry here in Virginia and highlight what I think are some opportunities that the board can realize through the inclusion of concrete paving.
    • 00:08:11
      So with that, I'll give you a little bit of background about our industry, starting with what is importance of concrete.
    • 00:08:19
      Portland cement concrete, as is seen in this slide, is a very durable, long-term material that's been around since before the Roman times.
    • 00:08:30
      Some of those are concrete that are still in service today.
    • 00:08:34
      It is an engineered product.
    • 00:08:36
      It's a combination of four materials, cement, the gray material you see in the front here, coarse aggregate, fine aggregate, and water.
    • 00:08:45
      When they're mixed together, they harden through a process called hydration forming Portland cement concrete.
    • 00:08:52
      Of the materials used to make concrete, the only manufactured one is Portland cement.
    • 00:08:57
      We have a major production facility here in Virginia down in the Roanoke area.
    • 00:09:02
      I'll talk a little bit more about that facility in just a little bit.
    • 00:09:06
      It is a locally produced material with local ingredients.
    • 00:09:10
      And quite frankly, they're readily available.
    • 00:09:12
      They're rocks.
    • 00:09:13
      Cement is made from clay, limestone, shale, selenite, slag.
    • 00:09:20
      They're all burned together into a molded material, cooled down, and then ground into that powder you see there in the front.
    • 00:09:27
      That material is then mixed with the water and the aggregates to form Portland cement concrete.
    • 00:09:34
      We have, as I mentioned, one major cement production facility down in the Roanoke area in Troutville.
    • 00:09:41
      We have 79 ready-mix concrete plants.
    • 00:09:45
      Those are the plants that produce the concrete you see being delivered throughout the Commonwealth in ready-mix trucks with the rotating drums on the back of the trucks.
    • 00:09:54
      We have 11 cement terminals locations that are used for the distribution of cement and seven cement companies serving the market here in Virginia.
    • 00:10:04
      We employ more than 58,000 Virginians.
    • 00:10:08
      The industry has an annual payroll of about $649 million.
    • 00:10:13
      The estimated contribution to the Commonwealth economy is over $5 billion, and we pay about $234 million in local, state, and federal taxes.
    • 00:10:27
      Here's that cement production facility, a fairly recent picture.
    • 00:10:30
      This is Titan America's Roanoke Cement production facility down in Troutville, Virginia.
    • 00:10:36
      It went into production in 1951.
    • 00:10:38
      It has been through six modernizations over its life, the most recent of which was a five-year endeavor beginning in 1996.
    • 00:10:47
      Starting in 2007,
    • 00:10:50
      This facility has earned every year since 2007 the prestigious Energy Star Award presented by the U.S. EPA and Department of Energy, recognized as a good neighbor, a good neighbor company down in that area.
    • 00:11:09
      Okay, well we've talked about cement, we've talked about concrete, we've talked about our industry.
    • 00:11:13
      Let's talk about our concrete pavements here in Virginia.
    • 00:11:18
      On the interstate and primary system, we have just over 1,500 lane miles of concrete pavement.
    • 00:11:25
      There are some concrete pavements on the secondary system, a relatively small amount.
    • 00:11:29
      The typical age of our concrete pavements currently in service ranges from 2 to 72 years, with an average of about 35 years.
    • 00:11:39
      Historically, over the past five years, calendar years, 2007, 2011,
    • 00:11:45
      VDOT has spent about 7.6% of their paving dollars on their concrete pavements.
    • 00:11:50
      Those dollars represent typically rehabilitation work, not new construction.
    • 00:11:56
      Through June of this year, only 2.9% of VDOT's paving dollars have gone to concrete.
    • 00:12:03
      And in the last 10 years, there have only been, 10 years through the middle of this year, there have only been four concrete paving dollars in the state.
    • 00:12:14
      When we think about concrete pavements, I want everybody to remember that they are 100% recyclable.
    • 00:12:21
      The concrete can be crushed into aggregate and reused, and certainly any steel that may be embedded or part of the pavement can also be recycled.
    • 00:12:30
      For those of you down in the Hampton Roads area, if you were out in the Chesapeake area during the reconstruction of Battlefield Boulevard,
    • 00:12:37
      You probably saw stockpiles of material like that in this medium where they actually had removed the old pavement at Battlefield Boulevard on 64, crushed it up, and put it right back into the pavement structure out there on the interstate.
    • 00:12:51
      It is recyclable and we are recycling it.
    • 00:12:53
      I'm going to spend the majority of my time and the remainder of my time talking about what we consider to be some opportunities the use of concrete paving can afford the Commonwealth.
    • 00:13:04
      And as I listened to your introduction, certainly there were concerns about needs and how we had more needs than we had resources to take care of them.
    • 00:13:13
      And we'd like to think that we may have some things that we can offer to help with those needs.
    • 00:13:18
      Stretch those transportation balance.
    • 00:13:20
      That's what you hear to help the Commonwealth do it.
    • 00:13:23
      And hopefully you will consider some of these options.
    • 00:13:25
      For example, include concrete paving alternatives.
    • 00:13:29
      Use a balanced pavement portfolio, and I'll explain what that is in these other subsequent slides.
    • 00:13:35
      Additionally, use alternate bidding to encourage competition and utilize new technologies that we can see expand our options when it comes to paving and rehabilitation work.
    • 00:13:48
      Opportunity number one, include concrete pavement alternatives.
    • 00:13:53
      This next slide really kind of gets at maybe why concrete pavements weren't included before and why we should include them now.
    • 00:14:01
      This is a graph showing the pricing of competitive building materials starting in 2004 going up through 2009.
    • 00:14:12
      And if you look at the left-hand side of the graph, you can see that that and before 2004 is probably the reason
    • 00:14:20
      The concrete pavement alternative was more routinely considered and that was concrete pavements were a little more costly first cost in the range of 10 to 15%.
    • 00:14:29
      Although recognized that life cycle cost benefits for concrete pavements, they were not considered as often as they would because of overcoming that difference in initial cost.
    • 00:14:41
      What we're seeing now from pretty much 2006 on and certainly 2008 and beyond is
    • 00:14:47
      Now concrete pavements, because of price differences in materials, are no longer at a competitive disadvantage for first cost.
    • 00:14:53
      They are equivalent and competitive in a first cost basis.
    • 00:14:59
      What does this really mean?
    • 00:15:00
      Well, it means that if you're going to deal with just one material and you have price fluctuations like that, it's going to significantly impact your purchasing power, make it more difficult to get the work done that needs to be done.
    • 00:15:14
      I don't know if anybody in here has seen something that I haven't seen, but I don't think there's much indication that we're going to see oil prices return to the level of 2005.
    • 00:15:23
      So we should be able to expect the difference in pricing to continue for the foreseeable future.
    • 00:15:28
      So if you think about concrete payments being now competitive on first cost, as well as accepted advantages at life cycle cost, hopefully this makes a case for consideration of concrete payment alternatives moving forward.
    • 00:15:43
      Opportunity number two, balanced payment portfolio.
    • 00:15:47
      This is a fairly simple concept, but it is very difficult to explain.
    • 00:15:51
      I'm taking the tack of calling this a balanced portfolio, just like you would balance your personal portfolio of investments with short-term, mid-term, and long-term investments.
    • 00:16:02
      So should you do the same with your investments in payments, and don't be confused.
    • 00:16:07
      Payments are indeed an investment.
    • 00:16:09
      Now I'm going to explain this with a hypothetical 3,000-mile pavement system of which you inherit 1,000 miles or a third of it that needs to be fixed or rehabilitated in five years.
    • 00:16:21
      You have to have another third that needs to be rehabilitated in 10 years.
    • 00:16:26
      Then you have another third that you're either going to reconstruct or is going to be new construction and you have a choice as to the service life you put on that third.
    • 00:16:34
      For purposes of this discussion, we'll say that an asphalt pavement has a service life of 15 years.
    • 00:16:39
      A concrete pavement has a service life of 30 years.
    • 00:16:44
      You have two systems, the option where you would go in with asphalt or concrete or a 15-year fix or a 30-year fix.
    • 00:16:52
      There's the 15-year for that third of the system.
    • 00:16:56
      There's a 30-year for that third of the system.
    • 00:16:58
      Then there's some calculations done to tell you what is the remaining service life.
    • 00:17:03
      In other words, if you put that mix of pavements together, how often do you need to fix those
    • 00:17:10
      And with the 15-year fix, you're going to need to fix the pavements on average every 10 years.
    • 00:17:15
      And by using that 30-year fix, you're going to increase the amount of time between need of service by 50% to 15 years.
    • 00:17:24
      Federal Highway Administration recognizes this technique of looking at the health of a pavement network, and they further go on to say that using a mix of fixes or treatments
    • 00:17:36
      can meet the needs of your pavement network in a much lower cost than maybe more traditional methods, and they recognize that the remaining service life method, which is what I kind of went over in the previous slide, is a good way to do that.
    • 00:17:53
      Use alternate design, alternate bids, and increase competition.
    • 00:17:56
      Many of you may have heard about that.
    • 00:17:58
      We have been talking with the secretary and the commissioner and others about that, and there are movements within VDOT to
    • 00:18:06
      Consider this more regularly.
    • 00:18:08
      Alternate design, alternate bid is very simply putting alternate designs out for bidders to choose from.
    • 00:18:14
      It increases competition, and if you think about it, if you have two different pavements to bid, for example, then you're going to have two different industries bidding, so that's automatically going to increase the number of bidders you have at the table, and that increased competition and number of bidders will subsequently lower the prices.
    • 00:18:32
      It simplifies the pavement type selection process.
    • 00:18:35
      If you're, as an owner, you can decide, I'm happy with this pavement or this pavement, it's gonna give me equivalent performance, why not let the market decide exactly which pavement you go with?
    • 00:18:45
      And that's really the principle behind alternate design, alternate bid.
    • 00:18:48
      Fluctuations in the market will dictate which pavement is selected.
    • 00:18:53
      Alternate bidding eliminates the need for mitigating materials price fluctuations.
    • 00:18:59
      If you're just bidding one product, use of price adjustment clauses
    • 00:19:04
      may make sense to, by reducing risk, you may see lower prices.
    • 00:19:09
      However, if you're bidding competing materials against each other, there's no need for the owner to take that risk.
    • 00:19:15
      It's up to the bidders to take on that risk.
    • 00:19:18
      And finally, what we'd like to see is this lead to a healthy two-payment system for the Commonwealth and see better pricing and spur innovation in both industries.
    • 00:19:29
      Alternate bidding is something that prior to 2008 was only being used in three states.
    • 00:19:36
      As of March of last year, more than 21 states are now regularly using or experimentally using alternate bidding in delivering their highway projects.
    • 00:19:46
      It's interesting that the point of reference there is 2008, if you will remember that previous graph, that's where you saw the huge spike in difference in pricing, which drove many states to wanting to look for alternate ways of putting their contracts out.
    • 00:20:00
      I also work in West Virginia.
    • 00:20:02
      West Virginia incorporated alternate bidding in 2008.
    • 00:20:06
      Since then, they've put forth 12 different alternate bid projects where they've had alternate designs.
    • 00:20:13
      Of those 12, six of them were what I refer to as pretty much purely paving projects where the bulk of the cost of the project was the cost of the paving.
    • 00:20:22
      And on those six projects alone, alternate bidding has saved the citizens of West Virginia $16 million over the low asphalt bid.
    • 00:20:30
      And these were first-cost bids.
    • 00:20:33
      They've also seen an increase in the number of bidders, as they had hoped to.
    • 00:20:35
      They were typically seeing two to three bidders per project.
    • 00:20:38
      Now they're seeing five to six on each job, as many as eight.
    • 00:20:43
      The secretary and his staff and the DOH staff over there are very pleased with the results they've seen.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:49
      And healthy competition.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:20:52
      You should have a handout on this in front of you that it gets into a little more detail of what this is.
    • 00:20:57
      But this is a plot of weighted unit prices for DOTs for both concrete and asphalt.
    • 00:21:06
      And across the bottom, you see what percent of the spending is being spent on concrete.
    • 00:21:12
      In other words, 0% over here is all asphalt, and here you have some competition with more of a mix
    • 00:21:18
      of how you support your projects.
    • 00:21:20
      What this shows, and these are actual states, what this shows is that the more spread you've got or the more you're equitably spending between products, the lower the prices.
    • 00:21:31
      If you don't have that competition, the pricing goes up.
    • 00:21:35
      Anybody want to guess where we are in Virginia?
    • 00:21:39
      Right at the 85 range, right there.
    • 00:21:42
      So, hopefully competition would bring down both the asphalt crisis and the concrete crisis moving forward.
    • 00:21:50
      Utilize new pavement technologies.
    • 00:21:52
      This is something certainly through the Research Council and the Department of Transportation that they look to do.
    • 00:21:58
      We'd like to see, obviously, specific focus on using new concrete pavement technologies.
    • 00:22:03
      I'm pleased to say that VDOT is currently looking at different alternatives for fixing concrete pavements.
    • 00:22:10
      You see right here an example of an old concrete pavement that's down on Route 58 in South
    • 00:22:16
      As I mentioned before in the previous slides, you're looking at a typical age of our concrete pavements at 35 years.
    • 00:22:23
      Not one of those 35-year-old pavements was designed for more than 20.
    • 00:22:27
      So they do have needs and are in need and prepared, and we're looking at doing different things.
    • 00:22:32
      Instead of coming in with fixes we currently use, VDOT is evaluating to use a concrete overlay.
    • 00:22:39
      on our existing concrete and that's what we did down on Route 58.
    • 00:22:44
      We actually went in on part of the project and put down what we call a separator layer.
    • 00:22:48
      We put an inch of asphalt down and then built a new concrete slab on top of it.
    • 00:22:53
      And that's what you see taking place right here.
    • 00:22:54
      Here's the separator and then the new pavement being placed right on top.
    • 00:23:00
      And here's a picture of that finished product.
    • 00:23:02
      This project just finished last month.
    • 00:23:07
      We also took another part of that and said, well, there's another thing we can do, and that's let's just glue more concrete to what's there.
    • 00:23:14
      So we went in and prepared the existing surface, did repairs to it, cleaned it with shot blasting, and literally came in and glued more concrete to the top four inches in this case.
    • 00:23:25
      And there's the finished shot of that particular project.
    • 00:23:30
      I was at the Virginia Center for Transportation Innovation Research last week.
    • 00:23:35
      and the researchers gave some preliminary findings from this project.
    • 00:23:40
      Foremost of which were the fact that these can be built, they can be built quickly and under traffic.
    • 00:23:46
      And they also have done some preliminary cost information on just construction, just construction.
    • 00:23:52
      And found that there's an asphalt overlay job being done over here and these two overlay jobs being done with concrete.
    • 00:23:58
      And just construction costs, the construction costs were less for the concrete options than they were for the asphalt options.
    • 00:24:05
      So again, something to consider.
    • 00:24:08
      Now, we're at a point because of these materials price differences where concrete is now first cost competitive.
    • 00:24:14
      But we don't want to forget the hallmark of concrete pavements and that's longevity.
    • 00:24:23
      They are built and they last a long time.
    • 00:24:25
      Certainly here in Virginia we have a number of examples of the longevity of concrete pavements.
    • 00:24:30
      VDOT's oldest concrete pavement is Route 316 over in Acomac County off of Route 13.
    • 00:24:36
      It was built in 1940 at 72 years old.
    • 00:24:39
      It was repaired twice in that 72 years so far.
    • 00:24:44
      And by repair, I mean oil change, new tires, not new engine, okay?
    • 00:24:48
      And it's scheduled for its third oil change in the spring of 2013.
    • 00:24:56
      And here's a picture of Route 316 in Acomac County as it is now.
    • 00:25:04
      Okay, I want to conclude with a summary and challenge to the board to support competition for your paying dollars.
    • 00:25:12
      You're all businessmen and women and I know you recognize the value of competition out there and I encourage that to be incorporated in how your dollars are spent.
    • 00:25:23
      Implement alternate bidding both on new construction and rehabilitation.
    • 00:25:27
      The Route 58 work clearly shows that alternate bidding would have been appropriate for the way to fix Route 58.
    • 00:25:33
      Encourage that two-pavement system.
    • 00:25:36
      Let's move our points on that graph more to the right and lower those costs.
    • 00:25:42
      Use lifecycle costs with real costs that incorporate the total cost for your options to guide your pavement investment.
    • 00:25:50
      The bottom line is don't be satisfied with the status quo when it comes to the Commonwealth's pavement system.
    • 00:25:57
      Challenge VDOT to take advantage of the opportunity that we think the country can bring to the Commonwealth.
    • 00:26:04
      Thank you very much, and I'd be happy to answer any questions you may have.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:08
      Thank you very much.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:26:08
      Any questions?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:09
      Mr. Miller.
    • 00:26:10
      I'm not really sure I totally understand your alternate bidding suggestion, but let me ask the question this way.
    • 00:26:18
      Everything else being equal.
    • 00:26:20
      Wouldn't I just want to consider life cycle costs, including the disruption that occurs when we redo stuff, and I don't think we include that generally, but from an economic modeling standpoint, wouldn't I just say
    • 00:26:34
      Whatever the life cycle cost is, whichever is the least life cycle cost, I don't care what it is, everything else being equal, including the disruption, some factor for the cost of the disruption when people can't get places and there's congestion, etc.
    • 00:26:52
      Shouldn't that drive my selection of what kind of pavement I want to get?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:26:58
      Absolutely.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:59
      And why would I care whether that, everything else being equal, why would I care whether that is asphalt or concrete or whatever it is?
    • 00:27:08
      So all these things I sort of followed and got, but at the end of the day for me, I just want to know what the life cycle costs.
    • 00:27:14
      Now that begs the question, can I pay for that?
    • 00:27:18
      Why?
    • 00:27:19
      But at the end of the day, we're going to pay for it one way or the other.
    • 00:27:22
      We're either going to pay today, we're going to pay tomorrow with interest on it, or whatever.
    • 00:27:26
      So Sam and I have the cash to do it the right way the first time, which I push for doing because that's the least cost over time.
    • 00:27:37
      Then just give me the least life cycle cost and I move on.
    • 00:27:40
      Whatever that ends up is what it ends up.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:27:43
      Do you disagree with that?
    • 00:27:43
      Oh, I absolutely do agree with it.
    • 00:27:45
      And if I may, that is currently what is taking place within the department's payment type selection process.
    • 00:27:53
      They go through an analysis of life cycle costs.
    • 00:27:57
      But when the life cycle costs get close, which is what they're finding, then they're, and that's the case in West Virginia too, when the life cycle costs get close where it's really difficult to tell the difference, that's when they go to alternate bidding.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:09
      But you're exactly right.
    • 00:28:11
      And that's fine.
    • 00:28:11
      And I also understand the need to, as these technologies gyrate and their costs move up and down, we don't want to get in a situation which is prevalent in the defense industry that I'm in.
    • 00:28:23
      We don't want to lose your base, your ability to create asphalt or your ability to create concrete.
    • 00:28:28
      So if they're close, I understand the need to sort of keep them both in the game so that when they get disparate, they're both still in the game.
    • 00:28:37
      I understand that constantly.
    • 00:28:38
      But otherwise, life cycle costs, totally full-loaded life cycle costs is what's going to drive my decision.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:28:45
      Right.
    • 00:28:46
      Well, and the other thing, too, that you mentioned that's very important but also very difficult is factoring in the disruption to traffic or what we refer to as user cost, user delay cost.
    • 00:28:56
      We rarely factor that into our models.
    • 00:28:59
      Exactly.
    • 00:28:59
      But that's in order to really evaluate the impact when you agree you have to put that in.
    • 00:29:05
      Oh, absolutely.
    • 00:29:07
      I was involved when they were first developing life cycle cost analysis, and what happens is in heavily traveled areas, user cost
    • 00:29:14
      Thank you, Mr. Long.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:25
      Piggybacking on the traffic disruption issue, is there a significant difference in the actual construction term between asphalt and concrete?
    • 00:29:37
      Not in terms of the life expectancy, but in terms of the project itself.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:29:42
      It depends on whether or not we're talking new construction or rehabilitation.
    • 00:29:45
      In the case of new construction, concrete paving is actually faster if you think about it.
    • 00:29:51
      Because a concrete pavement, we start at one end and pave the full thickness to the other end.
    • 00:29:55
      With an asphalt pavement, you put down multiple layers.
    • 00:29:58
      So you go over it three or four times.
    • 00:30:00
      So new construction, concrete can be faster.
    • 00:30:03
      Now, it depends on what the rehabilitation alternative is.
    • 00:30:06
      Obviously, a thin mill in the place for asphalt is going to be faster than we can do some of the things we can with concrete paper.
    • 00:30:14
      It depends on which choice we make.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:18
      Chairman?
    • 00:30:19
      Yes.
    • 00:30:20
      You know, we have a wonderful research facility in Charlottesville, Virginia.
    • 00:30:24
      Do you work with Dr. Gomez there to look into new technologies with concrete?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:30:31
      Absolutely.
    • 00:30:32
      As a matter of fact, that's where I started my career.
    • 00:30:34
      Really?
    • 00:30:34
      Yeah.
    • 00:30:34
      That's a great...
    • 00:30:35
      I started my career in the research camp.
    • 00:30:38
      Virginia Center for Inter-Transportation Administration.
    • 00:30:41
      I have, as a matter of fact, two of his top researchers are working on that route, 58, so I guess I do indeed do that.
    • 00:30:49
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:30:50
      Any other questions, Mr. Long?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:52
      So, Mr. Long, I'm just a little confused.
    • 00:30:54
      The asphalt guys were here last month, the month before.
    • 00:30:56
      They said that they're great.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:31:02
      Well, you know, isn't there a place for both?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:06
      Mr. Branscombe, Mr. Branscombe out here?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:10
      Mr. Long, thank you very much.
    • 00:31:18
      We appreciate that.
    • 00:31:25
      Very informative.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:28
      Hampton Roads Transit, Mr. Harrell.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:31:34
      Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 00:31:37
      It's my pleasure to be here.
    • 00:31:39
      And instinctively, I feel like I should be here requesting money for Dominion Boulevard.
    • 00:31:44
      But that was certainly in the priorities.
    • 00:31:46
      You got all that.
    • 00:31:47
      That's all done.
    • 00:31:47
      And you guys funded that.
    • 00:31:49
      Terrible.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:50
      We didn't see any of the sponsors running on that.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:31:52
      But one of the reasons, it is my pleasure to be here as President and CEO of Hampton Roads Transit.
    • 00:31:58
      And certainly, one of the reasons I decided to take on this task is clearly
    • 00:32:03
      We believe based on the data and the work of the Hampton Roads Planning District, I see Camilla is here today, transportation and traffic congestion in Hampton Roads I believe threatens the economic vitality of the region and certainly Hampton Roads is one of the many economic engines that are part of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:32:24
      So we think the array of services being provided by Hampton Roads Transit isn't
    • 00:32:30
      All of the answers, but it's certainly part of the answer in addressing this issue.
    • 00:32:35
      We provide services in bus, ferry services between Norfolk enforcement, light rail.
    • 00:32:41
      We also have a car pooling program and van pooling, so we have an array of services.
    • 00:32:47
      I will begin by just giving a short overview of our light rail system, which has been wonderful.
    • 00:32:53
      It's a 7.4 mile starter line with 11 stations.
    • 00:32:58
      Four park and ride locations with close to 800 spaces where people are able to park free and to be able to access the various locations throughout the system.
    • 00:33:11
      As you well know, the construction project was a difficult one.
    • 00:33:15
      Former VDOT Commissioner and former President and CEO Phil Shetet came in at a very difficult time.
    • 00:33:21
      and was able to bring that project under control.
    • 00:33:25
      Certainly the CTB was very significant in its allocation of $20 million additional funding during that difficult construction period.
    • 00:33:33
      And as you know, 10 million of that was returned to the Commonwealth based on the resolution of that project.
    • 00:33:40
      But certainly I was wise to come in when I did after construction was completed.
    • 00:33:46
      In terms of ridership, and I think this has certainly been
    • 00:33:49
      A significant data point that we're very proud of, the FTA modeling as you can see addressed 2900 average weekday riders and we're seeing well over 5000 and in fact we're beginning to see signs of 6000 people or riders a day with the system.
    • 00:34:11
      We recently completed a survey in terms of
    • 00:34:17
      Where people were going, destinations of trips, as well as their feel for the service.
    • 00:34:24
      And essentially there was a significant customer satisfaction with the services being provided.
    • 00:34:33
      The biggest concerns were, you know, where is the next destination?
    • 00:34:37
      Will it be the naval base?
    • 00:34:38
      Will it be Virginia Beach?
    • 00:34:39
      That seemed to be a significant concern.
    • 00:34:44
      What we're showing here is the fact that
    • 00:34:47
      The majority of those get a riding during the week, as most of us know, would be going to work or back home.
    • 00:34:54
      What we're also seeing is an increase of what we in the industry call choice riders.
    • 00:35:00
      As you know, generally on bus systems and Hampton Roads Transit is no different.
    • 00:35:05
      About 70% of those that ride our bus service are transit dependent.
    • 00:35:10
      That means they don't have a vehicle and without transit services, they wouldn't be able to make those trips.
    • 00:35:16
      What we're finding out on light rail, many of those riders, as you can see, have a vehicle and they're choosing to ride.
    • 00:35:24
      We're seeing a very different demographic and what we're excited about is that this really has the ability to address the issue of congestion.
    • 00:35:33
      We have additional data here on trip purpose.
    • 00:35:36
      I'll move very quickly.
    • 00:35:38
      I know you have a fairly robust agenda today.
    • 00:35:42
      The next slide, I do want to just take a moment to address
    • 00:35:45
      What we're seeing on the Tide is the fact that 66% of our local bus riders are over the age of 30.
    • 00:35:54
      But we're seeing a much younger demographic, 45% of Tide riders are under 30.
    • 00:36:00
      And as you will recall, we implemented a Go-Pass 365 program in which the universities, as well as corporate entities,
    • 00:36:09
      have the ability to pay a set fee for students and workers and they have the ability to use any of our services.
    • 00:36:16
      In fact, Old Dominion, Norfolk State, and Tidewater Community College are riding so much we're having to re-evaluate that program to increase the fee a bit because they're certainly taking advantage of that and we're certainly excited about that.
    • 00:36:32
      Certainly, when you look at the busiest station that we have at this point,
    • 00:36:37
      is certainly the Newtown Road Station is certainly a significant one and 60% of those who are parking in Newtown live in Virginia Beach.
    • 00:36:49
      So we're hoping as Virginia Beach considers going forward with an extension that certainly that will be a consideration as they consider extending the service.
    • 00:37:01
      As I indicated earlier, in terms of feedback on the system, as you can see, there's a significant interest of those customers that we surveyed in terms of extensions to Virginia Beach and the Naval Base and certainly Old Dominion University is very interested in the extension of the time.
    • 00:37:25
      As you know, the FTA has funded a study
    • 00:37:30
      to look at the Virginia Beach Transit Extension.
    • 00:37:34
      We have petitioned FTA to proceed with that.
    • 00:37:38
      They requested a delay of a year so that we could look at the current ridership numbers.
    • 00:37:43
      So we anticipate that moving forward shortly.
    • 00:37:47
      We have a timeline of the project and we
    • 00:37:50
      essentially anticipated a decision being made by the Virginia Beach City Council in 2014.
    • 00:37:56
      Originally you will recall that deadline was December of 2013 based on that timeline, but the City of Virginia Beach has requested that the study look into additional alignments through the Alaskan Roads area and that will extend the study some.
    • 00:38:15
      The next slide shows some of the 2%, and I want to emphasize, 2% engineering study that was done.
    • 00:38:25
      You've seen these numbers published before in terms of getting to the town center, essentially about $254 million, and you see those preliminary numbers for extension to the oceanfront.
    • 00:38:38
      It's also important to note, I think sometimes
    • 00:38:41
      It hadn't been picked up on the media.
    • 00:38:43
      In addition to the fixed guideway, we're also looking at the bus rapid transit as well in terms of alternatives to provide additional service to Virginia Beach.
    • 00:38:56
      One of the points that we want to make, and we're going to talk in a moment just about J.R. 297, which is reforming how potentially how transit funds are distributed in the Commonwealth, but we just wanted to make sure you were aware
    • 00:39:11
      For some time, we have been focusing on key indicators to determine the level of performance that we're making there.
    • 00:39:19
      We really encourage transparency and a lot of what we have on our website gives up-to-date information in terms of ridership and operational performance, which we think is absolutely key for the cities that are stakeholders of the system.
    • 00:39:35
      One of the things that we implemented in 2011 was the service efficiency study.
    • 00:39:40
      Where we really wanted to weed out some of those routes that were underperforming.
    • 00:39:46
      And we were also at that time trying to hold off a fair increase.
    • 00:39:51
      We anticipate that we will have to reevaluate that as part of our next budget year.
    • 00:39:57
      But certainly we cut out a significant amount of service that was underperforming with the ability of showing that we can be a very efficient system.
    • 00:40:07
      And I'm certainly proud of the performance that we've had there.
    • 00:40:10
      In terms of Senate Joint Resolution 297, I certainly want to thank Director Drake.
    • 00:40:16
      We met just last week to talk about that program, and I know she and Kevin Page have been receiving feedback from the stakeholders.
    • 00:40:25
      While we are, you know, upbeat about the whole issue of performance being a criteria in terms of distribution, we're hoping that there can be some
    • 00:40:35
      Some safeguards put in place so that as we budget each year, there's a certain level of funding that you can anticipate.
    • 00:40:44
      We've suggested some things such as caps be placed on the amount of fluctuations in funding.
    • 00:40:50
      We've thrown out some ideas there.
    • 00:40:52
      I know the VTA has also offered some additional information.
    • 00:40:56
      We think stability is absolutely important.
    • 00:41:00
      While there will be a performance piece, there will also be a formula-driven piece
    • 00:41:04
      And perhaps the percentages can be adjusted to give some stability to the operating entities.
    • 00:41:10
      But we're hopeful that some of that will be incorporated.
    • 00:41:13
      But we certainly thank Director Drake for her help in listening to us on that issue.
    • 00:41:20
      So without further comment, I certainly want to thank each of you for giving me the opportunity to be before you.
    • 00:41:27
      I can certainly address any questions.
    • 00:41:29
      And hopefully I have an opportunity to come back to you and talk again, because
    • 00:41:33
      One of the challenges we have is our current funding model is one of cost allocation, where we get federal and state allocation, but our city, our six Hampton Roads cities that are part of Hampton Roads Transit actually fund a significant bulk of the service.
    • 00:41:50
      And with the municipal challenges that they've had, we really believe that a dedicated funding source for transit will absolutely be essential in terms of addressing this issue of congestion for the Commonwealth.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:03
      Thank you so much for coming up and presenting us to us today.
    • 00:42:11
      I want to just, first of all, I should note that I am not a disinterested, this question is not from a disinterested bystander.
    • 00:42:19
      I have been heading an advocacy group called Move Hampton Roads to advocate for the passage of a light rail referendum in Virginia Beach.
    • 00:42:29
      But I want to ask you a question about the construction costs, although you did put the caveat that it was a 2% study.
    • 00:42:35
      You pointed out that Norfolk was $43 million a mile, where we tore up old streets and encountered all kinds of problems.
    • 00:42:45
      And now we're going to go possibly to Virginia Beach, where we're going over an existing railroad for most of the way.
    • 00:42:54
      And these costs appear to be three or four times as expensive.
    • 00:42:57
      Would you explain
    • 00:42:59
      that these are based on projected costs in the future discounted back and that that is not necessarily what the actual costs are that are incurred on getting this in place.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:43:14
      Sure.
    • 00:43:15
      One of the things that we're required to do as part of the FDA analysis is to not only look at those costs in tomorrow's dollars, if you will, but we also have to include those ancillary facilities
    • 00:43:28
      That are critical in terms of the overall operation of the facility.
    • 00:43:32
      We have several maintenance facilities that are being added.
    • 00:43:36
      In addition to that, when you get off of that alignment and begin to move into some of the corridors, there will be other utility costs that will have to be considered as well.
    • 00:43:46
      So we feel that the fact that the majority of the line, and depending on what Virginia Beach decides, will be in a right-of-way where I think you will have a greater control
    • 00:43:57
      In terms of subsurface conditions, so I think we feel that the actual cost can be very competitive and certainly I think perhaps below the Norfolk numbers that were projected earlier.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:10
      Right, I understand you can't advocate because of your position but I think that's one thing that might be made more clear and particularly in the region and of course in Virginia Beach where we're voting because
    • 00:44:24
      When first glance, it appears that those are fairly unrealistic cost assumptions.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:44:30
      Right, and again, I emphasize everywhere I go, we're talking about 2% numbers.
    • 00:44:35
      As you get into the alternative analysis where you refine those numbers, I think we'll get a more realistic feel for what those actual costs will be.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:43
      Thanks, Mr. Holmes.
    • 00:44:44
      I'm sorry, higher or lower?
    • 00:44:46
      We're hoping lower.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:44:47
      Well, it depends now.
    • 00:44:49
      The last option, I think, as you
    • 00:44:52
      Go in the hilltop area, I think, because of potential conflict, that certainly could impact the cost per mile, but that's what that study is all about, to identify the cost.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:02
      Because your slide has almost double per mile than what you spent in Norfolk, where I think it's a little bit more difficult.
    • 00:45:11
      I mean, it's like 254 million for three miles for the first leg of the town center.
    • 00:45:20
      And you spent about $43 million per mile?
    • 00:45:24
      Yeah, that doesn't make any sense.
    • 00:45:27
      And I should point out the CTB gave Virginia Beach the money.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:32
      Mr. Chairman, my office is located right in that corridor, right on that line, and it's a rail bed that was in use not that long ago.
    • 00:45:50
      There's nothing in the way.
    • 00:45:53
      The crossings are still there, or parts of the crossings are still there, so I don't understand.
    • 00:45:59
      I'm not an engineer, but I don't understand that.
    • 00:46:01
      I think what we can do certainly is provide just some additional information on that.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:46:24
      HDR, who is the consultant on that, built in a fairly significant contingency.
    • 00:46:30
      You know, I think
    • 00:46:32
      They threw pretty much everything in there wanting to make sure that there was appropriate consideration of the alternatives, but I think we can provide that information in greater detail.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:47
      Mr. Harrell, I appreciate the presentation.
    • 00:46:50
      I'm also very appreciative of the fact of your business attitude toward running this operation in transit law in general because I've noticed where you've analyzed routes that aren't as productive and making some changes to those.
    • 00:47:05
      Following on that, what revenue, what is your total revenue compared to your expenses?
    • 00:47:11
      I'm not talking about state and federal subsidies or anything that might be applied to that, but your ridership revenue, what is that per year as compared to your expenses?
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:47:22
      You know, based on our funding profile, we're getting right now about 20% of our revenue right now is coming from the fare box.
    • 00:47:30
      What we've recently analyzed is the fact that our rates have been consistent since 1999.
    • 00:47:37
      So I would anticipate as we come forward with our budgeting this coming year that we will actually have to evaluate a rate increase because of just the overall increase of various costs to include fuel.
    • 00:47:52
      So the industry
    • 00:47:54
      standards are generally anywhere from 15 to 30 percent fair box, depending on what system.
    • 00:48:01
      Twenty percent, we're right in there, but we feel like we're going to have to increase that funding.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:06
      Mr. Chairman, a follow-on question.
    • 00:48:08
      I understand the industry standards might be between 15 and 30 percent, but shouldn't we be striving for something higher than that, I mean, in the sense that
    • 00:48:18
      Government subsidies, whether state, local, or federal, a lot of those funds are being hit by other demands as well.
    • 00:48:25
      And if we want to try to make this a viable and sellable type project, not only in this area, but other areas of the state, then we have to try to achieve a little bit better return so that the localities and the state and federal government is not chipping in as much.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:48:43
      Yeah, absolutely.
    • 00:48:44
      We think with the changes that are coming forward with MAP 21, clearly we're not anticipating any increase in federal funds, the deficit situation, who knows where that will end up.
    • 00:48:58
      Certainly with the state, we're not clear there.
    • 00:49:01
      And the municipalities that fund about 30% of our operating budget are saying, hey look, we're feeling pinched.
    • 00:49:08
      So we made it very clear that one of our business objectives was to be as efficient as possible.
    • 00:49:13
      I think you're going to see more trimming of the routes.
    • 00:49:16
      The over 20 million that we're getting through the fare box, we're going to have to increase that percentage.
    • 00:49:22
      I think you're absolutely right.
    • 00:49:24
      That's going to be essential to the long-term fiscal sustainability of Hampton Roads Transit.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:30
      Thank you.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:31
      Mr. Miller?
    • 00:49:31
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:49:32
      Mr. Harrell, to Mr. Lauterbach's point, I agree with him.
    • 00:49:36
      We've got to be a little bit more efficient and get higher.
    • 00:49:40
      Higher amounts out of our fare box, but I would say we also in the equation need to consider that if we don't do those sorts of things, what does that mean for highways and roads?
    • 00:49:52
      You know, it's been interesting as we've talked about tolls in Hampton Roads and you said we're subsidizing these things or subsidizing light rail as if the roads are free somehow.
    • 00:50:02
      We come off pace for those too.
    • 00:50:05
      The air quality issues and so forth.
    • 00:50:07
      So when you look at the whole picture,
    • 00:50:08
      I think it's important we look at the whole picture in terms of what's the return of transit.
    • 00:50:13
      We get cars off the highways, which means we need less roads, we need less maintenance, air quality is better, etc., etc.
    • 00:50:21
      We ought to factor all those things in as best we can.
    • 00:50:24
      What I wanted to make my point on though earlier, I don't know if you can go back to your boarding station slide.
    • 00:50:31
      And this is really sort of a Hampton Roads thing Aubrey, that's probably good for you and some of your advocacy as well as mine.
    • 00:50:39
      What you see here, these boarding stations are literally as they're laid out from one end to the other.
    • 00:50:45
      And you can see the Newtown Road, that's actually right at the border of Virginia Beach on the eastern terminus of the rail line now.
    • 00:50:53
      And what this shows you is that, well, you ought to know one that Norfolk is a huge job, geographic job engine.
    • 00:51:02
      We have as many people coming to Norfolk to work every day that live there.
    • 00:51:06
      So all these folks are coming from Virginia Beach and Chesapeake and they're stopping at Newtown, parking their cars, getting on the ride, getting on the tide, and coming into downtown Norfolk and coming to the medical center.
    • 00:51:21
      The further that's out,
    • 00:51:24
      The more places it can go, two things happen.
    • 00:51:26
      One, more people can come in because it's more convenient for them.
    • 00:51:29
      Once you get in your car and you've got to get out, you know, there's a convenience factor there.
    • 00:51:34
      But two, the people going the other way, trying to get to Virginia Beach and trying to get Chesapeake right now, we can't do that.
    • 00:51:41
      So you're not going to see, if I'm going to Virginia Beach, I can't drive to the Eastern Virginia Medical College and get out of my car and get in light rail and get out of Newtown because they've got nowhere to get and I can't go anywhere else.
    • 00:51:52
      I'm dead.
    • 00:51:53
      I'm done.
    • 00:51:54
      So once that gets extended, I think you get the ridership from the west that you're not getting now, and that ought to be part of what you look at in terms of the total ridership.
    • 00:52:04
      So the people that live on the front of Norfolk like I live, the light rail's pretty much getting to downtown, and it doesn't make as much sense as it makes if I can really get somewhere.
    • 00:52:15
      The people coming from out of town because of the, out of the city, because of parking costs and congestion and so forth, they're the ones driving these numbers.
    • 00:52:23
      But there's a lot of pent-up demand to go the other way, and we are not capturing that yet.
    • 00:52:28
      So as we talk about light rail in Hampton Roads, Aubrey, and the beach, you know, these numbers should go up, and it should be a lot more accessible by everybody.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:52:38
      Yeah, if I could just say very briefly, I talked to some customers who were parking in downtown Norfolk that were paying $80 or more a month.
    • 00:52:46
      That now can park at Newtown Road and get in, but you're right.
    • 00:52:51
      Without a multi-modal concept, the current alignment truly is a starter line, and I think it was always envisioned to be a regional system all the time.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:53:02
      Yes, Miss Harrell, thank you for the presentation.
    • 00:53:05
      Since it's in your slideshow, I'm going to ask you a question about 297.
    • 00:53:10
      Okay, with what the tide's done so far and then talking about
    • 00:53:14
      expanding of the service, and we have a similar situation that could be happening up in Northern Virginia with Dulles Rail and what expansion that means.
    • 00:53:24
      Today, as you stand here in front of us, with that expansion in mind, what 297 as it's being presented, and I know Thelma's got something a little later, what would that mean to you if it was adopted just as is with this hybrid
    • 00:53:42
      50-50 and a cap only for I think 50% and then it disappears.
    • 00:53:48
      What does that mean to Hampton Transit if it gets adopted that way as suggested by the study?
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:53:54
      Well, currently, and that's what we are evaluating at this point, I think part of what is envisioned is that there will be various peer groups that will essentially compete to some degree in terms of dollars with 50% of the allocation coming that way
    • 00:54:10
      and the other 50% going through a straight, I guess, allocation process with that being done over a three-year period.
    • 00:54:19
      I think our preliminary numbers indicate that we're competitive.
    • 00:54:24
      We may get a little more money based on the numbers we've seen, but we just want to make sure things are fair because we're concerned about all of the transit agencies and we think there has to be a level of stability in terms of as we budget and
    • 00:54:40
      to be able to count on a certain amount of funding from the state.
    • 00:54:45
      We think perhaps one of the most significant issues is the fact that the pilot for transit isn't necessarily addressed there.
    • 00:54:52
      I think it needs to be grown, and certainly I'm in that position, obviously, to suggest that.
    • 00:54:58
      But I think part of what we're doing now is the industry is trying to sort out what impact it will have on us.
    • 00:55:05
      I think, relative to your question, I think new service
    • 00:55:09
      and how that will be judged will be critical because you're not going to have, you know, the ridership on a starter line and to some degree, I think, yes, I think it will be just to hurt you on the performance side.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:25
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Mr. Garczynski and Mr. Harrell.
    • 00:55:28
      Just to add to that, today in doing our funding based on operating expenses, it's based on two-year-old data.
    • 00:55:36
      Under the new proposed model it would be based on his budgeted data and today with new service starting up it takes at least 18 months to be able to get funding from the Commonwealth, a year's worth of service and time to have that audited where he would be able to put that in his budget and get funding.
    • 00:55:55
      So I think there is a real benefit to our transit companies to be able to work with budgeted expenses
    • 00:56:01
      In our model, and because of what you've heard from Mr. Harrell today of what they started doing in 2011, he is one of the peak performers, efficient performers, and would gain money under the model.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:56:13
      I think another key piece of that is the fact that the transition fund to help bridge to a new system will absolutely be key for the providers.
    • 00:56:23
      I don't believe that's funded yet, but I think there's the attention.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:25
      It's a recommendation.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:56:27
      Right.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:28
      I just had a quick follow-up to Mr. Miller's point about the ridership.
    • 00:56:32
      One specific item is, yes, Town Center, Virginia Beach has noticed a reduction in activity because of people being able to ride in Newtown and go into Norfolk, but a lot of that has to do, I talked about the cost and how they seem to be askew, but a lot of the ridership, we've noticed that the numbers that we use for the Norfolk is exceeded by double, and a lot of that has to do with
    • 00:56:56
      You only allow full-time jobs in the ridership number.
    • 00:56:58
      For instance, if the city of Virginia Beach is considering putting an arena in that may draw thousands of people, they're not included in the ridership number.
    • 00:57:06
      So just because that's the federal rules, they don't allow them in.
    • 00:57:09
      So it appears that both on the cost and the revenue side, things are very, very conservative in that.
    • 00:57:17
      So I'll make that point.
    • 00:57:18
      And the last point I would just make, I updated the rail subcommittee this morning
    • 00:57:23
      It appears, where we stand today, that if the referendum were held today, it would pass.
    • 00:57:28
      And we've got a few weeks to go, but the poll- That's early voting in Virginia, right?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:31
      Yeah.
    • 00:57:33
      I've got that one issue.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:35
      But anyway, it appears it is, and this is really not just a regional issue, but also a state issue, because it's considered the last mile component of bringing conventional rail, and eventually high-speed rail, into the area.
    • 00:57:50
      That's why I've been such an advocate and raised because it's not just Virginia Beach, it's our entire system and it impacts all of us doing commerce, particularly with the military component coming from the Navy base, the air base, and the Pentagon.
    • 00:58:07
      I mean, we have got to be able to offer alternatives to those individuals besides getting on
    • 00:58:12
      the interstate and not being able to determine how long it's going to take them to get to where they're going.
    • 00:58:17
      So, anyway, just throw that out.
    • 00:58:19
      It just seems that we make it a tougher sell because our numbers are so daggone conservative.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:58:25
      And certainly yesterday I had the opportunity to speak with the Senate Finance Committee
    • 00:58:30
      It's subcommittees on transportation, economic development, and natural resources.
    • 00:58:34
      I mean, this is a key issue for the Commonwealth.
    • 00:58:38
      And we certainly appreciate the support of this board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:41
      Well, the true cost of capacity planning is there's not much difference between light rail or rail capacity and roads when you look at the true cost.
    • 00:58:51
      And that message, thank you for doing that tomorrow.
    • 00:58:53
      We got a good report on that.
    • 00:58:54
      But that message needs to get out because
    • 00:58:56
      A lot of people don't understand it's really an alternative.
    • 00:59:00
      If we don't spend this, we're going to save all this money.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:02
      Anyway.
    • 00:59:04
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • 00:59:05
      Mr. Harrell, just for a point of reference, the 5100 weekday ridership represents what percentage of capacity, and I understand that's probably a hard concept to use because you've got so many different stations, but do you have a sense as to where that is?
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:59:23
      In regards to capacity, I can talk to our staff and send something back to you.
    • 00:59:29
      I don't want to speculate on that.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:30
      Yeah, just wondering, in terms of the economics, where they are today, what kind of upside is there, based on capacity?
    • 00:59:38
      Yeah, we'll be happy to send that back to you.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:40
      I would tell you, it's sort of my field, and obviously there's capacity given how many engines you have and how many cars you have today.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:59:51
      But that line has got a lot more capacity than it was.
    • 00:59:58
      Right, and the way you would address that is there as an extension is adding cars and increasing frequency.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:03
      Looking like a true at-large guy.
    • 01:00:06
      That's right.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:07
      Any other questions?
    • 01:00:09
      Carol, thank you very much.
    • 01:00:10
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:00:11
      I look forward to, so I'm sorry, this vote is November 7th.
    • 01:00:16
      Kevin, six, and I'll make sure I'm clear so that vote is actually...
    • 01:00:21
      It's a vote to say whether they should even look at it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:25
      Yes, the vote is not that they will build it.
    • 01:00:27
      It gives the city council the opportunity to make an informed decision, although the opposition is praising it.
    • 01:00:34
      Coaching it in terms that a vote for yes means we're going to build it, and that's just not accurate.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:39
      It's advisory only.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:41
      That's right.
    • 01:00:41
      But we had one in the year 2000 that was negative, and that's why the mayor and the city council members have asked for it to be on the ballot.
    • 01:00:51
      Your ridership showed overwhelmingly younger people support it.
    • 01:00:55
      Obviously with the national election, hopefully that will be favorable for the referendum.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:03
      So, in other words, they're voting so they can consider it?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:09
      No, it's an advisory referendum to pursue light rail.
    • 01:01:13
      To test the mood of the public.
    • 01:01:16
      They could go forward with it.
    • 01:01:17
      If it was no, they could not go forward if it was yes.
    • 01:01:20
      Right.
    • 01:01:21
      They're taking a poll.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:23
      Thank you, Mr. Harrell.
    • 01:01:25
      I'll just leave it at that.
    • 01:01:26
      That's great.
    • 01:01:27
      Alright, Mr. Lawson, come on up and get us some good news.
    • 01:01:31
      Lawson, is there good news or bad news?
    • 01:01:40
      Good news, sir.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:52
      Good morning, everyone.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:02:09
      We do have some good news to give you this morning as we continue to look at the revenues and the spending activity of VDOT fiscal year.
    • 01:02:36
      Year-to-date, our revenues are doing fairly well.
    • 01:02:40
      We are looking at about a 7% increase year-over-year from last fiscal year.
    • 01:02:48
      The forecast revenue growth is about 2.2%.
    • 01:02:51
      So at this point in time, we're doing well.
    • 01:02:56
      Motor vehicle sales, as we talked last year, are continuing to be strong.
    • 01:03:01
      We're seeing growth through September of just over 8%, while taxation is actually expecting that to trail off to be about flat this year.
    • 01:03:12
      I'm pleased to see that motor vehicle fuels or motor fuel taxes today has grown about 4% over the last fiscal year and that is about double the 2% expected growth rate for the fiscal year.
    • 01:03:30
      Sales and use tax also are strong at about 10%, a little over 10% this year as compared to a forecast growth of about 4%.
    • 01:03:45
      Looking at federal revenue, you can see here that our federal revenues for the year are also a little stronger than they were last year.
    • 01:03:54
      We are a bit ahead.
    • 01:03:57
      A large component of this big growth here we're seeing here.
    • 01:04:02
      It's 200 million in extra growth.
    • 01:04:04
      It's kind of a two-part component.
    • 01:04:07
      One, it's largely, it's driven by some agreements, modified agreements we did on the maintenance side of the park last time, where we kind of accelerated the collection of federal funds based on activity done, eligible activity last year, as well as we've seen some additional growth in the construction spending as related to the new projects that we brought online.
    • 01:04:34
      Spending, we spent just over a billion dollars through September, about 120 million more than we had for this time last year.
    • 01:04:45
      The profile of the spending is pretty consistent with where we've been.
    • 01:04:50
      About 44% related to VDOT's maintenance, and we include six straight payments.
    • 01:04:56
      You can look at total maintenance spending at about 52% or so.
    • 01:05:00
      Construction continues to be about 39% of spending.
    • 01:05:06
      We're looking at our outstanding contract values of our maintenance and construction projects that we're holding pretty consistently at about a $1.2 billion level.
    • 01:05:19
      Looking to maintenance specifically, we've expended $178 million in September, bringing our year-to-date spending to just over $500 million.
    • 01:05:29
      That is pretty close, about 5% higher than where we were this time last fiscal year.
    • 01:05:34
      We had, as you know, talked a lot about the efforts we've taken to bring down the spending balance or the allocation balance within the maintenance program.
    • 01:05:44
      And based on where we stand today, we are projecting to spend about $1.6 billion this fiscal year, which will leave us with an unspent balance of just over $20 million.
    • 01:05:56
      So we definitely have made significant progress over the last two years.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:01
      Hear that, Mr. Miller?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:03
      Loving it.
    • 01:06:08
      In terms of construction spending,
    • 01:06:10
      We've spent just over $450 million through September.
    • 01:06:15
      That's about almost a 20% increase over last fiscal year.
    • 01:06:20
      The largest component of this increase are bond-funded expenditures related to the Midtown Tump.
    • 01:06:31
      This graphically just shows you the major spending on each program.
    • 01:06:36
      You can see the year-over-year comparison.
    • 01:06:39
      Again, with the exception of construction and maintenance, the other programs are fairly in line with the last fiscal year.
    • 01:06:49
      In terms of anticipated spending, our spending is running pretty much on track.
    • 01:06:58
      You can see from a grand total perspective, we're just short about $6 million.
    • 01:07:03
      We actually spent about $38 million more.
    • 01:07:07
      On the construction side, from what we anticipated, and spent about $35 million less in terms of maintenance.
    • 01:07:14
      So those two, amongst everything else, are pretty much a wash. Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:20
      Yes, Mr. Garza.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:21
      Mr. Lawson, that money that we got from the states, the other states that didn't use their federal allocations,
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:07:28
      In terms of cash position, you can see we are
    • 01:07:54
      In growth, grand total, very close to where we began the year.
    • 01:08:00
      We have spent down some of the highway maintenance and operating funds that we have gone through the maintenance cycle and continue to move funds from construction into maintenance to support the crossover.
    • 01:08:14
      We have not made as many crossover payments as we had originally planned.
    • 01:08:19
      At this point in the year, because of the acceleration of the federal revenues, that will pick up as we go toward the end of the year.
    • 01:08:31
      You can see here down toward the bottom of the page, the spending related to the CTR ball.
    • 01:08:38
      Of course, we have a slight increase shown in Garvey.
    • 01:08:41
      That's because of the also failed in July.
    • 01:08:47
      And just kind of wrapping up, as I mentioned, we are looking at state revenues as performing forecasts at this point in time, about 5%, 7% versus 2%.
    • 01:08:59
      As you can see, our expenditure activity through September is pretty much in line with what we had forecasted.
    • 01:09:07
      And again, I can't say enough that staff have done such a tremendous job on working with the maintenance program and we are on track to meet our business plan goal of having that balance down below $100 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:26
      Thank you.
    • 01:09:27
      Questions for Mr. Lawson?
    • 01:09:29
      Chairman?
    • 01:09:30
      Mr. Richard?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:30
      I've got three questions.
    • 01:09:32
      One, I see the administrative and support costs are up a little bit for this fiscal year.
    • 01:09:40
      What's the reason for that, John?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:09:42
      We have some additional staff that obviously have raised that a little bit, and we also have a pre-payment related to some insurance payments that came earlier than before.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:55
      Another question I have is, of the 2013 expenditures, how much of that is debt financed, the expenditures so far?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:06
      You can see here, like the fourth line down, that is the bond fund activity.
    • 01:10:15
      We've got about $80 million of spending that's been paid for at a bond proceeds this year.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:21
      As far as payment back of the debt, what is that?
    • 01:10:26
      The debt service itself?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:27
      Yeah.
    • 01:10:28
      So far, in the cycle, when we only picked the very last bottom row, we spent $13 million in debt payments.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:36
      Not the payments, but paying back the principal, you know, the big picture.
    • 01:10:41
      What percentage of our expenditures are financed by debt overall?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:48
      I can't do the math that quick in my head, but again, of the $1.18 billion we've expended so far this year, $80 million of that was expenditures supported by debt.
    • 01:11:14
      Again, $13 million of that $180 million is related to debt payments.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:19
      The other question I have is, last time we had a little discussion about the debt, just where are we on the debt limit?
    • 01:11:26
      I mean, I think we all thought last time there was no more money available as far as our debt situation, but now I've learned a couple days ago we've got $300 million more that was sitting around there somewhere.
    • 01:11:41
      So where are we now?
    • 01:11:43
      Assuming we spend this additional $300 million, is that the end of debt for new projects?
    • 01:11:51
      Or is there still more in some barrel somewhere that we don't know about?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:11:58
      Obviously, we are working with two series of bonds.
    • 01:12:01
      The CPR bonds, which have a fixed $3 billion authorization, are fully committed.
    • 01:12:07
      Where the additional funding you're talking about is related to is the GARVEE pro bon?
    • 01:12:14
      The GARVEE authorization is a rolling authorization.
    • 01:12:19
      It's limited to 1.2 billion outstanding at any one given point in time.
    • 01:12:23
      So as you look at it a year further every year, there's
    • 01:12:28
      But how does that fit in with our overall debt ceiling, debt limit?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:53
      For the Commonwealth?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:12:54
      The garbage as a revenue bond backed by federal funds do not impact Commonwealth.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:00
      They don't impact that?
    • 01:13:02
      Not factored into it.
    • 01:13:03
      Thank you.
    • 01:13:04
      That's helpful.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:05
      I'm sorry, Mr. Miller, did you have something?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:07
      No, I just was trying to make sure I was on board.
    • 01:13:10
      The garbage that we've issued so far are not going to free up.
    • 01:13:16
      A lot of principal, a lot of additional capacity is not going to be freed up in the near future.
    • 01:13:21
      So the $1.2 billion that is our cap is not going to change.
    • 01:13:27
      We're not going to have capacity in the next four, five, six years to speak of.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:30
      We're going to be on the ceiling for a while.
    • 01:13:32
      Exactly.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:32
      That's what I was trying to get at.
    • 01:13:34
      We're done for a fair amount of time.
    • 01:13:36
      Is that right, John?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:13:37
      We looked out to about 2018 for our lifetime.
    • 01:13:43
      Without additional revenue.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:44
      Yeah, I'm just trying to find out the whole picture where we are.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:51
      Think of all the ribbon-cuttings you guys are going to be going through.
    • 01:13:58
      For three more years, three more years.
    • 01:14:01
      Alright, Mr. Pittard.
    • 01:14:02
      I'm off.
    • 01:14:05
      Yeah, then we jump off.
    • 01:14:06
      That's right, then we get to jump off.
    • 01:14:16
      Well, we did.
    • 01:14:18
      Here you go, boys.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:14:25
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members.
    • 01:14:31
      Just want to give you all a brief update on DRPT financial status.
    • 01:14:36
      We got a few new members today, so I might go into a little bit more detail than normal with some of these items.
    • 01:14:46
      I gave all of you all a report.
    • 01:14:48
      Um, earlier at your table, so you should have this.
    • 01:14:51
      It may not be on the system because we were a little bit late getting, uh, finished, getting the month closed out.
    • 01:14:59
      And I guess, I just, basically I want to take y'all through this report real quickly.
    • 01:15:04
      And what you'll find is the first statement there is a statement we call Resources and Permitments.
    • 01:15:11
      It's similar to a balance sheet but it's not a full, accrual balance sheet.
    • 01:15:15
      And what that report does is it takes, you know, as an agency we make a lot of agreements.
    • 01:15:22
      We allocate funds to projects.
    • 01:15:24
      And then over time we make agreements with the grantees and recipients, contracts with them, and then we participate sort of as a partner in building these projects.
    • 01:15:36
      And then we also provide operating funding for our transit providers and for passenger, intercity passenger rail activities.
    • 01:15:45
      So this first statement, essentially what it's doing is it's taking all the assets we have, the revenue enclosed, our receivables,
    • 01:15:55
      Our cash balance and it's comparing it to all those commitments we've made in the current FY13 six-year program those allocations plus all the past allocations so that's on this page you see we have around six hundred and twelve million dollars of commitment so currently in our DRPT we're managing six hundred and twelve million dollars worth of projects where we've committed balances as a partner for those projects
    • 01:16:23
      And then the top part of this is showing where the funds are going to come from to fund that $612 million.
    • 01:16:30
      And then the net, which is, I think, if y'all have been with us the past year when I've been doing these updates, that net is sort of what I've been focusing y'all to look at as available balances at the bottom there.
    • 01:16:43
      And I did add this time the June 30th balance, comparing it to September 30th, and you'll notice there's some big items that change.
    • 01:16:52
      One of those is estimated revenues, which estimated revenues are for 13, this is the amount of revenue that we're expecting to receive that we've allocated out to projects.
    • 01:17:06
      So at June 30th, that's already been received and it's a final number.
    • 01:17:12
      So there is no more estimated revenue to be received at June 30th.
    • 01:17:15
      But then when you start a new year, there's obviously a new balance there.
    • 01:17:20
      So with that, I just,
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:22
      It's brief history for that statement.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:18:22
      All right.
    • 01:18:22
      Well, this next slide is taking where I've been pointing you all as board members to the slide that's probably the most important part of what I'm going to talk about today is unobligated balances that we have, balances of funds or resources that are coming in that aren't committed to projects currently.
    • 01:18:41
      And before we go running and think, oh, we got $90 million, we can go do whatever we want with, some of these, there's obviously different categories here, and some of those categories do have certain legal restrictions in the code or in the Appropriation Act.
    • 01:18:56
      So they do somewhat have some limitations, but these are the balances that are not on projects currently.
    • 01:19:08
      The next sheet is basically taking a look at our cash balance and what we do here is we're taking our annual budget and then we assume for our transit side of our shop we need two months worth of working cash and then on our rail side we need three months because rail is a lot larger projects and as you'll see the timing of the expenditures is harder to predict.
    • 01:19:34
      And anyway, this shows the average cash balance for the last six months.
    • 01:19:39
      And on transit, we're fairly close.
    • 01:19:41
      We're a little bit high.
    • 01:19:43
      On rail, we're about five times over that amount.
    • 01:19:48
      And as we move forward, I'll explain that.
    • 01:19:50
      And this is just the graphical depiction of those balances for the past 18 months.
    • 01:19:55
      And probably the biggest thing you'll see is both items have had a blip up the last four months.
    • 01:20:02
      In rail, we got some one-time general funds at June 30th, literally the last day of the year.
    • 01:20:09
      The General Assembly allocated some money for our passenger rail operations.
    • 01:20:15
      And then in transit, we've had the issue with our Northern Virginia WMATA jurisdictions that we were working through the contractual relationship with them over the past few months, if you all recall back to July's CTB meeting.
    • 01:20:29
      And since we were working through those,
    • 01:20:32
      This is essentially just what I just said.
    • 01:20:42
      In rail, I will add that we have the Norfolk passenger train project.
    • 01:20:49
      In that project, I'm not sure why the railroads, but they bill us very slowly.
    • 01:20:58
      The project is supposed to begin December 12, will begin December 12.
    • 01:21:03
      So we expect the billings to escalate then, but there is more work to this project after that December 12th, which is putting in the signaling system, which is a large part of that $110 million for that project.
    • 01:21:18
      But what we expect is that should be done by May of 2013.
    • 01:21:23
      So the hope is by the end of the year, the majority of that comes through and that balance in rail will actually come on down, like I've been telling you.
    • 01:21:33
      And last thing I had to talk about is every quarter I present our budget that y'all approved back in June and then just show current year actual to the budget.
    • 01:21:47
      Taking a three month snapshot and then comparing it to actual and you'll see that
    • 01:21:52
      For the same reasons that I've explained on our cash, we're behind on our spending here.
    • 01:21:59
      And I guess one other item, and I'll just call it out the very bottom, we're also, we have a $50 million contribution to the Dulles project that we're working through that contract currently also.
    • 01:22:14
      So with that, I'll open the floor to any questions.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:17
      Any questions?
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:20
      What was the slide before, the $28 million one time from the General Fund?
    • 01:22:28
      This one?
    • 01:22:30
      Yes, the last slide.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:22:32
      What is that?
    • 01:22:32
      That was last year, the General Assembly and the Governor, there was a General Fund surplus from 2011, I believe, and so in last year's session,
    • 01:22:47
      They took a portion of that general fund surplus and dedicated it to the intercity passenger rail fund.
    • 01:22:53
      So it's there, when next year we've talked a lot about, we have our two trains, Lynchburg and Richmond, which is gonna go to North, but then next year we're gonna have to take on four more trains.
    • 01:23:06
      So when that happens, we need some source of funding to cover the subsidy for those trains.
    • 01:23:11
      They're all not as successful as Lynchburg.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:13
      We don't have that funding, do we?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:23:15
      Well, yeah, we've actually received that in cash.
    • 01:23:19
      That $28,700 is going to cover it.
    • 01:23:21
      It's already, we already got it.
    • 01:23:23
      Okay.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:23
      But it doesn't, because you were suggesting the funding for the future trends.
    • 01:23:28
      For the future, yeah.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:23:28
      We don't have that.
    • 01:23:29
      We don't have it for the future, do we?
    • 01:23:31
      Well, that $28 million is sitting there to help us in the future.
    • 01:23:34
      But we do not have a permanent source of funding.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:38
      Exactly.
    • 01:23:38
      How much, how long will that $28 million cover?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:23:42
      Off the top of my head, I don't know.
    • 01:23:45
      In our six-year plan, there's a page where we estimated the cost and how long before.
    • 01:23:52
      I want to say, Kevin, it was maybe three or four years after PREA kicks in.
    • 01:24:01
      Yeah.
    • 01:24:02
      Is that about right?
    • 01:24:03
      Would you say so?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:04
      Maybe 2016, 2017?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:24:11
      I want to say 26, but I'll make a note to get all y'all that answer.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:20
      But the thing is, please understand that the Lynchburg service will not be profitable after.
    • 01:24:28
      We've already kicked in with the new CRIA.
    • 01:24:34
      So once that happens and they change how they allocate the cost, we're actually going to have to pick up more of the 10.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:41
      And four other trains that we don't pay for today.
    • 01:24:45
      That's the big kicker.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:46
      That's correct.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:25:04
      In fact, of the five jurisdictions that that issue involved, two of them have sent the agreements in.
    • 01:25:11
      Either the funds have been paid out to those entities.
    • 01:25:15
      This is in October, so it's not reflected in my numbers, or they're in process of being paid out.
    • 01:25:20
      And the other three, I think it's just the formality of working through their respective boards to get us the necessary contractual paperwork.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:31
      The Lynchburg train that goes through my district too in Charlottesville, it seems to be a very important facility.
    • 01:25:38
      What's going to happen?
    • 01:25:39
      I mean, we can't lose that.
    • 01:25:41
      Is the only recourse more money from the General Assembly or we lose that service?
    • 01:25:49
      Is that true, Thelma?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:52
      Mr. Chairman, do you want me to answer that?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:55
      What's that?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:56
      Did you want me to answer?
    • 01:25:57
      Yes.
    • 01:25:58
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:25:59
      Mr. Rich, and Kevin's standing up because this is near and dear to his heart.
    • 01:26:03
      Our goal is that we not lose any of our train service because if we do, it would cost us hundreds of millions of dollars to reinstate it down the road with what the railroads would require to bring up passenger rail.
    • 01:26:14
      And that's why we've been talking about this issue of funding source for IPROC, Intercity Passenger Rail Operating and Capital Fund, which
    • 01:26:22
      The Governor built into his budget for two years, and Senator Watkins also got us access to some money.
    • 01:26:28
      So we have a little more time on it, but we still think it's very critical to know that we have the funds to operate those trains.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:35
      But we could also take the funding out of the six-year plan, right?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:38
      Oh, you have the ability to provide funding.
    • 01:26:41
      We just keep talking about creating a dedicated revenue source because remember,
    • 01:26:46
      Rail is the only mode of transportation that is not in the Transportation Trust Fund because at the time we didn't run passenger rail.
    • 01:26:55
      So it probably needs just a thorough looking at.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:58
      How much more time do we have before we leave the train?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:01
      Well, it goes into effect in October 1 of 2013, so a year from now, but we do have money.
    • 01:27:08
      We have three years' worth of money.
    • 01:27:10
      to be able to run it.
    • 01:27:12
      What that does do though because we can't do any capital expenditures not knowing if we'll have funding for operating and we can't start any new service until we know we have the money to run what we have today.
    • 01:27:24
      So down the road we may have capital money because we get an operating source.
    • 01:27:29
      But right now we just have to sit and wait and not bring up any additional service.
    • 01:27:33
      So Norfolk was very lucky.
    • 01:27:34
      They were at where they were when all of this became such a big issue.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:39
      So, Steve, I guess my question, following up with what Mr. Rich said, is that Judgment Day for CTB could be coming at 2016 as to wither the Lynchburg and four other lines.
    • 01:27:57
      The General Assembly really takes action.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:01
      Unless there is some funding for us to pay the subsidy.
    • 01:28:05
      Here's the example.
    • 01:28:06
      Lynchburg today, my old numbers are 1.8 million that they're in the black and I believe Kevin would tell you that they're running better than that now.
    • 01:28:15
      And it's going to go to a loss of one and a half million overnight.
    • 01:28:19
      So that's over three million dollar swing.
    • 01:28:22
      Three to four million dollar swing.
    • 01:28:23
      So we've actually asked if they would delay PREA for a couple of years and allow us to continue to bank money, which would let us run the services longer.
    • 01:28:32
      But that doesn't appear to be coming either.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:28:35
      Thank you.
    • 01:28:36
      Any other questions?
    • 01:28:37
      Discuss that.
    • 01:28:39
      2016, Kevin did have a six-year program.
    • 01:28:43
      It is 2016.
    • 01:28:44
      And then the other, Mr. Rich, you asked of the CTB,
    • 01:28:48
      Have the ability, and I'm not so sure it's that clear that you have the ability to fund these passenger rail lines.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:57
      There's some language, but it's, you know.
    • 01:28:59
      Could somebody research that, the Attorney General's office, and let us know?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:29:03
      Yeah, I think it's some language in the VDOT section, and I think John would disagree that there's funding there to do so.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:11
      So we couldn't use Garvey Bonds, maybe, or?
    • 01:29:14
      We don't know yet.
    • 01:29:15
      Okay.
    • 01:29:16
      Well, somebody should let us know so we know what we can do and what we can't.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:19
      We're on the shielding with the Garvey Bonds.
    • 01:29:21
      I know, yes.
    • 01:29:22
      Okay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:26
      Ms. Busher, a review of the principal arterial routes on a national highway system for map 21.
    • 01:29:33
      Thank you.
    • 01:29:37
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, good morning.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:29:55
      What I'm presenting to you today is actually an update from the information that I provided you at the last board meeting where I had indicated that we had a directive from FHWA on September 5th that we had to respond to
    • 01:30:14
      on September 20th related to which principal arterial roads would be taken into the NHS system effective October 1.
    • 01:30:25
      And that related to MAP 21 and the changes that MAP 21 did in terms of consolidating some funding programs and NHS routes.
    • 01:30:38
      will be funded through the NHPP funding program, which is new.
    • 01:30:47
      Previously, before MAP 21, the NHS route was capped at 160,000 miles, and Virginia
    • 01:30:59
      prior to October 1 had 3,441 miles of that 160,000.
    • 01:31:05
      MAP 21 eliminated that cap which allowed for the expansion of the NHS system and the legislation indicated that states could bring in the remaining principal arterials into the NHS.
    • 01:31:25
      So there are already some principal arterials
    • 01:31:27
      Mainly the interstate system in the NHS.
    • 01:31:36
      We did our quick due diligence.
    • 01:31:43
      We are currently in the process of updating the federal functional classification and
    • 01:31:52
      That's basically we do that every 10 years due to the changes provided by the 2010 census.
    • 01:31:58
      And we are scheduled to complete that in February 2013.
    • 01:32:03
      When we received the directive from FHWA September 5th, we accelerated a portion of that review and developed a list of roads to be added to the principal arterial classification.
    • 01:32:17
      We submitted that list with a request
    • 01:32:21
      The FHWA grant conditional approval of the additional mileage pending our input from the MPOs and PDCs and localities.
    • 01:32:31
      That's the standard process.
    • 01:32:33
      If we were dealing with a short turnaround time related to MAP21 funding going into effect October 1, when we change a functional class or bringing a road into a different functional class, there's a process we go through where it's done
    • 01:32:50
      Together with input and discussion with the MPOs and PDCs and localities involved.
    • 01:32:57
      So FHWA did in fact conditionally approve the listing, adding the changes to the principal arterials functionally classified as NHS.
    • 01:33:08
      Now these roads will, well effective October 1, are now eligible for NHPP funding.
    • 01:33:18
      This map, just to give you a perspective, and I'll provide you another one in a few minutes that shows the new, the increased mileage into the NHS system.
    • 01:33:27
      This is as it was prior to the approval of Map 21.
    • 01:33:31
      Now, to give you a little bit more background on the impetus behind the functional class updates.
    • 01:33:41
      As I said, generally every 10 years we look to update the roads
    • 01:33:46
      And look at any reclassifications necessary based on population changes in the census.
    • 01:33:53
      But also in 2008, FHWA updated their guidance on functional classification of highways.
    • 01:34:01
      With that update, they no longer required a change at the location of urbanized boundaries.
    • 01:34:09
      In other words, going from a rural class to an urban class.
    • 01:34:13
      So there's no longer the rural and urban designation.
    • 01:34:19
      And functional classifications should be assigned based on the actual functional criteria rather than the location of an urban or rural boundary.
    • 01:34:31
      Some existing principal arterials did not meet the suggested characteristics of the principal arterials such as trip length and travel density characteristics indicative of substantial statewide and interstate travel and providing an integrated network without sub-connections or connectivity.
    • 01:34:52
      So those are some of the things that we looked at when we did our accelerated review based on the MAP-21 deadline that we received.
    • 01:35:01
      And as I mentioned a moment ago to summarize, the MAP-21 changes removed the mileage cap which allowed for the expansion of the NHS system.
    • 01:35:14
      It established the NHPP funding category, which is actually a combination of what used to be called interstate maintenance or IM funding, bridge on system funding, and the NHS funding into one category.
    • 01:35:31
      And what will be coming forward through guidance from the federal government are performance-based information on maintaining and improving the NH system.
    • 01:35:45
      So we're a few months away from receiving any guidance in that arena, but we will be under the directive to maintain our performance measures.
    • 01:35:57
      Now, we have started the communication with the MPOs and PDCs.
    • 01:36:02
      We are holding two seminars or webinars this week.
    • 01:36:07
      Actually, we had one yesterday with the MPOs and PDCs to talk about MAP-21 and some of the changes and discussing some of the principal arterial information.
    • 01:36:21
      We have another one Friday.
    • 01:36:25
      The methodology that we used to do the accelerated review was reviewing the existing arterials and minor, principal arterials and minor arterials through the use of the GIS system.
    • 01:36:43
      And we had a parallel review going on by our consultant, which is Michael Baker Corporation, who's actually doing the federal functional classification update based on the census.
    • 01:36:55
      And we reviewed what the current non-NHS principal arterial facilities and recommended which facilities we would like to add to the NHS as well as facilities that we would like to not add to the NHS as principal arterials.
    • 01:37:13
      And we reviewed the minor arterials and actually a few collectors to reclassify.
    • 01:37:20
      We did notify our district planners of the
    • 01:37:24
      The accelerated review in the October 1 deadline for the new principal arterials becoming NHS and the district planners did in turn notify the MPOs and we did submit our changes September 20th conditional to our ultimate review and analysis with the MPOs and PDC.
    • 01:37:47
      This is a summary of the activity and the changes that we recommended and were transferred to FHWA on September 20th.
    • 01:37:57
      Now, I'll start with the mileage that would have automatically gone into the NHS.
    • 01:38:03
      So we had 779 miles of already classified principal arterials.
    • 01:38:11
      We wanted to upgrade some minor arterials to principal after our review, and that was 455 miles.
    • 01:38:20
      We did identify five miles of collectors that we wanted to upgrade to principal arterials based on the changes in the 2008 guidelines.
    • 01:38:33
      We did, in fact, recommend some downgrading of principal arterials, and to clarify, we
    • 01:38:40
      We did not eliminate any principal arterials that were already in the NHS system.
    • 01:38:47
      What we did was determine that principal arterials that were not previously in the NHS would not move forward as a principal arterial.
    • 01:38:57
      And because of the funding rules for NHPP, they couldn't stay principal arterials.
    • 01:39:04
      They had to be changed to minor arterials.
    • 01:39:07
      Now those roads are still qualified for federal funding and there won't be any change in maintenance payments based on that change.
    • 01:39:18
      The maintenance payment is based on the concept of arterial, not whether it's minor or principal.
    • 01:39:26
      So, when we take the proposed downgrade, you get to a net change of 917 miles.
    • 01:39:38
      When you add that to what we currently had in the NHS, we, of 3400, we're now at a new NHS mileage of 4358 miles.
    • 01:39:50
      To give you an idea from what would have gone over with an automatic update without the review would have been 779 miles.
    • 01:40:01
      With our changes, we've actually increased that by 138 miles to a 917 addition.
    • 01:40:10
      And again, all of this, we have the ability to go through the normal review process with the MPOs and PDCs.
    • 01:40:19
      To finalize this list, we do that every time we want to change a functional class of a road and we will do that and then update or make any changes that come out of that review to the NHS list and send that to FHWA for their approval.
    • 01:40:41
      Some of the things as we were doing our review came up that we took into consideration when we were looking at changes.
    • 01:40:50
      One of the things we looked for was what we called eliminating the island of principal arterials created in the urban clusters.
    • 01:41:01
      And there's an example on the slide, if you can see it, it's the town of Pulaski with an urban cluster.
    • 01:41:07
      That's showing that there's really no connectivity and the reason that was changed to a principal arterial from a minor was simply because of the urban boundary and that's changed.
    • 01:41:22
      The guidance has changed in that area.
    • 01:41:25
      Also, we looked at eliminating what could be called redundant principal arterials that are parallel to existing NHS facilities.
    • 01:41:36
      And what that means is within a half a mile.
    • 01:41:40
      We also looked at reducing the number of intraurban principal arterials in smaller MTO areas and urban clusters.
    • 01:41:52
      And one of the things we looked at is maintaining the intraurban principal arterials in larger MTOs to allow for greater regional mobility in highly congested areas.
    • 01:42:06
      Continuing, we also added facilities that provided for long distance travel in areas that were not served by an existing NHS facility.
    • 01:42:23
      I'm going to ask staff to be able to answer your questions.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:28
      What's an NHS facility that we're at?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:42:32
      This is the area, I can't answer specific questions.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:42:36
      Good morning, I'm Ben Manella, I'm with the Transportation Planning Division here at VDOT.
    • 01:42:40
      NHS is primarily made up of the interstate highway system in Virginia, as well as select other principal arterials.
    • 01:42:49
      Not all of the principal arterials, as Rita Busher kindly informed me this morning.
    • 01:42:54
      But there's also what's known as the strategic highway network.
    • 01:42:59
      These are roadways to provide connections to defense facilities throughout the state.
    • 01:43:04
      And the strategic highway network connectors, these are lower classified roads, sometimes
    • 01:43:09
      Is that what the facilities are?
    • 01:43:31
      That is what the current definition of the National Highway System is.
    • 01:43:36
      What Federal Highways and MAP-21 has changed is they're now bringing in all principal arterials, whether or not they were on the NHS before or not.
    • 01:43:47
      Principal arterials typically carry a higher volume of traffic, longer distance travel, serve primarily for mobility, higher speed.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:59
      I'm looking at this
    • 01:44:00
      It says, adding new facilities that provide for, what facilities?
    • 01:44:07
      Roads.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:44:09
      Roads.
    • 01:44:13
      Roads.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:13
      We're talking about new roads.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:44:22
      I'm sorry for that confusion.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:24
      He's looking for a house or something.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:44:26
      One of the other things we were looking at is also the consistency of the functional class of our roads.
    • 01:44:45
      at the boundaries of the state borders with other states.
    • 01:44:49
      We did actually make some changes based on that from our review with our neighbors.
    • 01:44:56
      Okay, I've mentioned some of this previously, some of the implications.
    • 01:45:07
      of all of this is that all NHS facilities will become eligible for NHPP funding.
    • 01:45:15
      So the funding programs that we now have with MAP-21 is the NHPP stands for National Highway Performance Program.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:24
      There's no more money in the overall law umbrella.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:45:36
      What they did was they consolidated interstate maintenance, NHS was a program for NHS routes, federal funding, and then bridge.
    • 01:45:46
      They put those together and
    • 01:45:48
      But she said there was no impact on funding if you weren't in this program.
    • 01:46:08
      The roads that if you're seeking say specifically that something was a principal arterial and did not go to NHS, it is still federally qualifying and the locality will still receive maintenance payments based on that road being an arterial.
    • 01:46:28
      Now what changed was the program in which the funding would be used for the different highways.
    • 01:46:38
      So NHS routes, funding and bridges on NHS routes and interstates will come from that larger consolidated plot.
    • 01:46:50
      So you have the NHPP now, you have the Surface Transportation Program, which is STP, as we had before.
    • 01:46:59
      That's population-based with some discretionary funding included.
    • 01:47:04
      Safety, which has increased by about a third.
    • 01:47:09
      Highway Safety Improvement Program, they did, one of their focus with performance measures is on crashes and fatalities.
    • 01:47:16
      And then CMAC, which you all know.
    • 01:47:19
      And CMAC and STP from the regional STP is still with the MPOs as before.
    • 01:47:29
      And then there's planning funding.
    • 01:47:31
      So you no longer have a separate category for
    • 01:47:34
      Interstate maintenance and bridges, and actually bridges are split between NHPP and STP.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:40
      So I guess the root of my question is- So there's more in that one category.
    • 01:47:45
      There's more in one category, but it comes from somewhere else because there's not more in the overall font.
    • 01:47:49
      That's correct.
    • 01:47:49
      And I don't care if you label a road National Highway System, just a regular primary, secondary, a regular bridge.
    • 01:47:58
      We have roads, facilities for my friend.
    • 01:48:03
      We've got to maintain things and the federal government may have rearranged the deck chairs but the Titanic is still going down in terms of the infrastructure.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:48:12
      The biggest change is the performance measures that will be placed on those on the mileage that's included in the NHS category which is funded through the NHPP.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:26
      Okay, so if it gets more, where does it come from?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:48:30
      The population of the NHS population has gone up.
    • 01:48:38
      To the elimination of a separate category for interstate, which was IAM, and a separate category for NHS at the reduced mileage of the 3400 that we did have.
    • 01:48:53
      And actually, SCP has reduced slightly, but is picking up off-system bridges.
    • 01:49:00
      And safety got increased, so somewhere some of that money came from IM to safety and went into NHPP.
    • 01:49:09
      Bottom line, same money.
    • 01:49:10
      We've grown the category and the funding pot for that category.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:15
      We called it MHPP but now we've added performance measures for all of those categories.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:36
      I think Rita should get some kind of an award or raise for dealing with a federal bureaucracy.
    • 01:49:46
      She's able to understand it, but I can't.
    • 01:49:48
      Just one quick question.
    • 01:49:49
      On the bottom line, this pot of money, does most of it go to maintenance, or is it, what percentage goes to maintenance?
    • 01:49:56
      This is construction funding.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:57
      This is all construction.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:49:58
      Now, some of it is, we do have maintenance activities that qualify for federal funding.
    • 01:50:05
      We still have the definition of which pot of money can fund which kind of project.
    • 01:50:12
      So we still have federal funding that will fund a portion of our maintenance program each year.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:21
      Will you give us a list of which facilities are now in the new deal?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:50:28
      We can provide you, when we finish the final review going through the discussions with the MPOs and the PDCs and we finalize what's changed
    • 01:50:39
      to an NHS route and what didn't, we can give you a list of those.
    • 01:50:47
      It really won't be until about the February timeframe when we finish the classification update.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:55
      Rita, how long is MAP-21 going to stay in place?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:50:59
      24 months.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:01
      And this was an attempt by the federal government to streamline the system?
    • 01:51:07
      Yes, it was.
    • 01:51:08
      Thank you.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:09
      You're new here.
    • 01:51:11
      Mr. Chairman?
    • 01:51:13
      Yes.
    • 01:51:14
      Ms. Busher, two questions.
    • 01:51:17
      Do you see that there are positive consequences to MAP-21 for the Commonwealth or negative or none?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:51:24
      I think they're positive.
    • 01:51:26
      I think the flexibility of having more money perhaps in one pot so that it's not separate rules and separate requirements for more categories of funding.
    • 01:51:44
      Performance measures will definitely come into play.
    • 01:51:48
      As I said, we would receive federal guidance
    • 01:51:52
      For a period down the road, there is a time for us to get the performance measures in place to show our ability to meet those performance measures before they come in and analyze those.
    • 01:52:05
      So that's several years down the road.
    • 01:52:07
      But the performance, if we don't meet those performance measures ultimately, they will help guide our funding project choices for the areas or performance measures that we didn't meet.
    • 01:52:21
      And also, we would lose a portion of our, or get a reduced federal state match.
    • 01:52:30
      In other words, it's currently 80-20, it could drop to something less than that if we don't meet our performance measures.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:38
      And second question, what is the mechanism for adding a principal arterial that doesn't exist today that might exist, i.e.
    • 01:52:47
      460?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:52:49
      And you're talking about the new 460.
    • 01:52:53
      That would be a planned project and typically when we do a functional classification update, any project that is included in our program that has construction funding on it would be eligible to be included on the map as a principal or chair.
    • 01:53:08
      As soon as we're aware of it and it's moving forward, we begin a process with Federal Highways to get that approved and included into the system.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:53:18
      and changes through development or projects that would change how a road was used from last year to the fourth.
    • 01:53:30
      So two types of changes.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:34
      I will be happy to see those when we get them.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:53:45
      And the reason I say that is, MAPS 21 is a 24-month federal funding authorization.
    • 01:53:53
      We won't receive guidance from UNCOT on their performance measurement goals for 18 months.
    • 01:54:01
      Then we have 12 months to develop
    • 01:54:03
      Our particular targets related in Virginia to those performance measures and coordinate those with the MPOs and then get those accepted by USDOT before they're actually in place.
    • 01:54:19
      So we're many months away from actually finalizing what they will be.
    • 01:54:30
      I'm not following.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:54:49
      H.B.
    • 01:54:50
      599 statistically requires an evaluation of the 25 projects in the Northern Virginia region for congestion impacts or improvements to congestion and I believe Homeland Security evacuation.
    • 01:55:04
      I believe the performance measures that are probably going to be coming out of federal highways related to the National Highway Performance Program are going to be more related towards pavement conditions, structure conditions, and there probably will be a mobility component.
    • 01:55:16
      We just don't know what it's going to be.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:19
      All right, so I'm going to try to get clear on this.
    • 01:55:25
      We're supposed to meet targets that haven't been developed, that won't be developed for 18 months, and yet there might be projects that we have ongoing during that period of time that might be impacted by these targets which haven't been developed yet, and we're going to get federal guidance if we don't meet those targets after we do them.
    • 01:55:47
      After we do it, and then they're going to require a state match to something that we didn't do because we didn't know what we were supposed to do.
    • 01:55:55
      Is that kind of summarized?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:57
      And there's no functional difference by doing this.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:02
      Mr. Chairman, as far as we're going with ridiculous onboarding questions, is Millwood Avenue impacted by this anymore?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:14
      That should never last long.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:16
      This may be an incredibly naive question, but have we ever considered sitting down with our federal delegation and saying, let's just give the states a block grant and let us do all this without all this nonsense?
    • 01:56:40
      That would never happen, right?
    • 01:56:43
      I mean, is that crazy?
    • 01:56:45
      Can't we have some kind of reform where more discretion is given to the various states?
    • 01:56:54
      Should we sit down with the delegation and say, can't you try this?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 01:56:57
      What I will share with you is MAP21 is giving the state an opportunity to provide comments and preferences and look at the information that we are already doing for other reporting purposes to FHWA using that same data collection process and the statistics that we already have in place, such as pavement condition,
    • 01:57:25
      We collect bridge conditions and we collect the crash data, fatality data.
    • 01:57:31
      That information that they're looking at for the maintaining of the National Highway Patrol.
    • 01:57:38
      We're having webinars.
    • 01:57:39
      We're providing questions and comments in an electronic fashion.
    • 01:57:46
      AASHTO, of which we participate, is also putting together performance information to provide to USDOT prior to the guidance being finished in the next 18 months.
    • 01:58:00
      We are taking the opportunity to communicate to the various
    • 01:58:08
      Through the various options, whether it's in written form or online, to offer our wishes or guidance and hope for something that in the beginning is not looking for us to collect and spend a lot of time and money on new information, but the best way of using the information we already have.
    • 01:58:31
      So we are looking at that.
    • 01:58:32
      And I think in some regards, Map 21,
    • 01:58:35
      did consolidate a lot of programs.
    • 01:58:39
      We just have to get our arms around it in terms of what it means for us.
    • 01:58:45
      This slide is the new NHS and the colors, and we'll get you something that you can, much larger for you to see.
    • 01:58:58
      The blue on this map is the existing NHS, red.
    • 01:59:02
      Our principal arterials that we didn't move forward, green are the principal arterials we did, and orange are other facilities that could be upgraded.
    • 01:59:16
      As I mentioned, next step is completing our federal functional classification update.
    • 01:59:25
      Through that process we will be meeting with all the MPOs and PDCs and localities.
    • 01:59:31
      We will be waiting for our performance measure and information, but the outcome from our functional class update and our communications with the localities and the MCOs and CDCs will be used to update our final changes to the, or our changes at this point to what we had drafted for the October 1 deadline in terms of
    • 01:59:57
      The principal arterials being added to the antigen.
    • 02:00:01
      And that concludes my presentation.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:03
      Excellent.
    • 02:00:03
      Any other questions?
    • 02:00:04
      No.
    • 02:00:05
      All right.
    • 02:00:06
      Criteria for secondary to primary system transfers.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:00:24
      Good afternoon.
    • 02:00:25
      My name is Robert Hofrichter.
    • 02:00:27
      I'm from the Transportation Planning Division of the Virginia Department of Transportation, and I'm here today to talk to you about criteria for transfers of secondary highways to the primary system.
    • 02:00:38
      Why am I here to talk to you about that?
    • 02:00:40
      Well, we've had some recent activity in that area.
    • 02:00:42
      Last year, the CTB took a look at 48 miles to be transferred into the primary system from the secondary, and at the February meeting, approved those transfers.
    • 02:00:52
      That was for routes 3,000 in Prince William County and 7,100 and 7,700 in the Fairfax County.
    • 02:00:59
      Then again, after July meeting, we looked at route 863, Pennsylvania County, for transferring to the primary system.
    • 02:01:07
      In addition to that, VDOT's business plan has this as a recurring activity again for the 2013 business plan to look at roads across the state and see if there are any that should be considered for transfer to the primary system.
    • 02:01:23
      The authority for these transfers occurs under 33.1134 of the Code of Virginia, requires CTB approval for non-project transfers, and those are limited to 50 miles each fiscal year.
    • 02:01:36
      The current criteria were adopted in 1998 and meet a majority of these criteria as a requirement.
    • 02:01:46
      And they included things such as a link between interstate or interstate highways, serving different kinds of sites, connecting county seats, minimum traffic volume of 2,000 vehicles per day, percentages of trucks, trip lengths, as criteria.
    • 02:02:07
      There are nine of these.
    • 02:02:08
      They are essentially the same as criteria that were adopted in 1973.
    • 02:02:13
      Except for a change in traffic volume, which went up to 2,000.
    • 02:02:19
      The problem with these, there are things that sort of triggered a look at these criteria.
    • 02:02:26
      Number one was cost.
    • 02:02:28
      A license plate study can cost over $40,000, and that's required to get the out-of-state percentage.
    • 02:02:33
      Origin and destination studies cost over $500,000.
    • 02:02:37
      Very variable in terms of cost.
    • 02:02:39
      They do a significant
    • 02:02:41
      Impacted the traveling public to get the data, and those are required for tripling.
    • 02:02:46
      Consistency of the data.
    • 02:02:48
      When we did the studies on the routes in Fairfax County, we found that our data varied considerably from what Fairfax County had gathered on those facilities.
    • 02:02:58
      We wanted something that was more consistent, and it didn't matter on who was collecting the data.
    • 02:03:04
      Relevance of the data.
    • 02:03:06
      You know, when you're looking at freight movement, tractor trailers count.
    • 02:03:09
      But do pickup trucks with two tires on each end in the back count?
    • 02:03:15
      Is that really something that matters in terms of freight movement?
    • 02:03:19
      So we're looking at something that had more impact in terms of what is a primary highway versus what is a secondary highway.
    • 02:03:27
      In addition, in the current criterion, there is not one that is a requirement.
    • 02:03:32
      In other words, it's all meet a majority of, and that's it, which can present some problems.
    • 02:03:40
      Once again, current criterion listed up here on the table, and our reasons for why maybe something should be done with it.
    • 02:03:48
      Link between highways, good criterion, except it's not a requirement.
    • 02:03:52
      It's a must-meet, best-of, so it allows a disjointed network.
    • 02:03:58
      Syphostenic and historic interest, that leaves out other locations.
    • 02:04:02
      I mean, for instance, assuming bush gardens are things to me that wasn't already served by a primary, they wouldn't count.
    • 02:04:09
      Connex County Seats, once again these are major activity centers, 2,000 vehicles per day.
    • 02:04:16
      That was chosen in 1998, since then there has been significant growth in all systems on VDOT's highways, 2,000 just as a relatively low threshold for these.
    • 02:04:27
      Seven percent more out of state, once again we're going to leave that as expensive to gather, so it's harder to get.
    • 02:04:33
      And what is the relevance to something being a primary highway?
    • 02:04:38
      20% or more light, medium-duty trucks.
    • 02:04:43
      That's where we get to the consistency of the information.
    • 02:04:45
      Fairfax County counts versus our counts, things like that.
    • 02:04:49
      Plus, what is that relevant to with regards to something being a primary highway or not?
    • 02:04:55
      2% or more tractor-trailers.
    • 02:04:57
      The percentage used in that penalizes commuter routes.
    • 02:05:01
      There's something that held 200 trucks, 200 tractor-trailers, and if it carried 50,000 cars a day on it, like Braddock Road and Fairback, that does not meet this threshold.
    • 02:05:12
      Yet one that carries significantly less cars, but a lot of tractor-trailers would.
    • 02:05:16
      20% of trips at 25 miles per hour, 25 miles or more, and 5% of trips over 100 miles.
    • 02:05:24
      Once again, things that are very difficult to get in terms of getting actually hard numbers on those and expensive to get.
    • 02:05:33
      So the question is, is there something that we could use that's better?
    • 02:05:38
      We've put a team together, evaluated the different information sources out there, and came up with these recommendations to eliminate the light and medium duty truck percentage, to eliminate percentage of trip lengths and percentage of out-of-state vehicles.
    • 02:05:53
      to modify the minimum traffic volume to raise it.
    • 02:05:57
      Tractor, trailer, bus, change the tractor, trailer, and bus percentage to a volume so it sets a minimum bar.
    • 02:06:04
      And providing service to activity centers, not only historical, scenic, and county seats.
    • 02:06:10
      In addition, to add something requiring system continuity.
    • 02:06:14
      In other words, it's not a criterion.
    • 02:06:16
      It's you have to have this before you move on to anything else.
    • 02:06:20
      Functional classification is a factor.
    • 02:06:22
      In 1973, when these things were adopted, functional classification was relatively new.
    • 02:06:27
      We've had many years of experience with it now, and it does take into account things like the length of the trips, the speed of the trips, and things like that, which most people think makes sense with regards to whether something's a primary highway or not.
    • 02:06:41
      NHS designation, we just had a presentation on that.
    • 02:06:44
      Once again, if a highway is important to the country, and to the extent that it's probably kind of important to the state, maybe it should be a primary.
    • 02:06:54
      Here's the specific changes that we recommend.
    • 02:06:58
      Required connection to a primary or state highway.
    • 02:07:01
      That is a requirement.
    • 02:07:02
      Make that a requirement and not just a meet the majority of.
    • 02:07:07
      Connects to activity centers not already connected.
    • 02:07:10
      In other words, military bases, major commercial centers, airports, cities, towns, urban development areas.
    • 02:07:18
      And make it only count if there's not already primary highway service in that general cardinal direction right now.
    • 02:07:27
      In terms of the volume criterion, raise it up to 10,000.
    • 02:07:32
      The current criterion of 2,000 means that there are approximately 3,200 secondary highway segments eligible.
    • 02:07:39
      If we ratchet that number up to 10,000, that cuts that number down to about 840 segments, makes it more of an actual threshold criterion rather than just about anything connected.
    • 02:07:51
      200 more tractor-trailer buses per day.
    • 02:07:54
      Once again, set a hard number instead of a percentage, so that way you deal with actual freight movement.
    • 02:08:00
      Functional classified as arterial is the recommendation.
    • 02:08:03
      We base this on looking at other states.
    • 02:08:06
      Most of the states, if a highway is an arterial with its principal or minor arterial, it tends to be a primary highway.
    • 02:08:13
      It's less than that.
    • 02:08:14
      It's less than a minor collector.
    • 02:08:16
      It tends to be in the local system.
    • 02:08:19
      That seems to be a good break point.
    • 02:08:21
      It's consistent with what other states are doing.
    • 02:08:24
      Once again, designation is an NHS facility.
    • 02:08:28
      It's important for the country, should be important for the state too, and meets current design standards.
    • 02:08:33
      When people get on something that's designated as a primary highway, they tend to have an expectation that it meets certain standards, and if we're going to move something in from one system to another, it would be best if we look and see if it does meet those standards.
    • 02:08:46
      And that's it.
    • 02:08:48
      This is just for your discussion and information and in the future maybe bring a presentation to you asking for an actual change in the criteria which you would have to adopt and would become part of VDOT's operating procedures.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:02
      Any questions?
    • 02:09:04
      I've almost gotten out.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:07
      I just wanted to confirm that what I just heard that the impact would affect
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:09:21
      Mr. Carson,
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:51
      Yes, my question is why wouldn't you move forward on this?
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:54
      I mean, I like the logic and the progression.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:59
      Why bring it back later on or sometime in the future as opposed to date definitive?
    • 02:10:06
      I think it just makes a lot of sense that this is a better criteria than we had while we're moving secondary to primary.
    • 02:10:14
      So I guess I'm questioning why just put it off in the future?
    • 02:10:18
      Why not bring it back
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:10:20
      Well, it would be probably in the next couple of months.
    • 02:10:24
      The reason I said in the future is because you guys are meeting next time in December in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:10:29
      I don't know what the schedule would look like for that meeting.
    • 02:10:32
      This may not be that quickly.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:34
      Okay, so we'll be in the short term.
    • 02:10:36
      Yes.
    • 02:10:36
      Okay, thank you.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:37
      Do you consider, as you were doing the evaluation, doing some kind of a vehicle line, doing some kind of an adjustable level as conditions of traffic and number of vehicle miles increase so that we don't have to read it again in another ten years?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:11:02
      We did look at that, actually.
    • 02:11:04
      The problem is, especially with, say, the way the economy is going and things like that, it was sort of difficult to say, okay, let's peg it on vehicle mileage growth statewide or something like that, because secondary mileage doesn't necessarily grow at the same rate as interstate mileage does and things like that.
    • 02:11:21
      And we couldn't really come up with a very easy number process to peg it on that we could make those changes.
    • 02:11:28
      But that said,
    • 02:11:30
      This change is the first change in 14 years.
    • 02:11:36
      It's probably not that big a burden in terms of coming before the board and saying, hey, we want to change this again.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:47
      We're not proposing to make any changes in that.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:12:05
      The reason is, I'm trying to be very careful how I explain this because I don't want anyone to get the wrong idea.
    • 02:12:16
      A policy set by this board which controls what VDOT can bring to you for you to consider to move to the primary system.
    • 02:12:24
      There is no such set policy for going in the other direction.
    • 02:12:29
      Just like in secondary roads, there is the secondary street acceptance requirements for taking things into the secondary system.
    • 02:12:36
      For moving things out, there's a separate law that basically lays out in general terms, here's what it is, but we don't have a specific
    • 02:12:45
      Number, criterion, whatever that we use.
    • 02:12:49
      It's, does it make sense?
    • 02:12:52
      It's the same thing here.
    • 02:12:54
      Does it make sense to move something?
    • 02:12:56
      Because once you've provided people a kind of service, they tend to expect it.
    • 02:13:02
      And we don't want to go in there and disrupt it unless there's a very, very good reason to do so.
    • 02:13:08
      On the other hand, what we also don't want to do is move something to a category where they expect that higher service,
    • 02:13:16
      Mr. Miller,
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:44
      I don't know what Mr. Whitworth thought about that, but that makes me uneasy.
    • 02:13:49
      I think the, you know, just because somebody's in, if the criteria, if they no longer meet the criteria, they no longer meet the criteria.
    • 02:14:00
      I mean, if I'm working somewhere and drawing a salary, but I no longer work there, I no longer get the salary.
    • 02:14:05
      I mean, it's sort of
    • 02:14:09
      I'm uncomfortable with the concept that because we've been doing something for somebody and the situation changes, we're reluctant to not continue to do that for them.
    • 02:14:23
      I'm uncomfortable with that as a philosophy.
    • 02:14:25
      I think if you get into a system because of X criteria and you no longer meet the criteria, then you're no longer in.
    • 02:14:35
      And that's sort of the way the cookie crumbles.
    • 02:14:38
      By the same token, if you don't meet the criteria to get in, you don't get in.
    • 02:14:41
      You don't get that benefit.
    • 02:14:44
      So I would want to see our policies in alignment so that you don't have to have one set of criteria to get in, but if you don't meet them anymore, there's a different set of criteria to get out.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:57
      That doesn't work for me very well.
    • 02:15:08
      It's helpful that you were able to identify the number of segments that were eligible for the 10,000 and the 200.
    • 02:15:16
      Are you able in any way to identify how many segments would qualify under four of the six?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:15:25
      The problem is a lot of those other criteria aren't strict volume criteria, especially like serves a county seat, that sort of stuff.
    • 02:15:35
      That would require looking at a map, determining are there any second, are there any primaries going that direction, things like that.
    • 02:15:41
      We don't have a real easy, quick way of doing that.
    • 02:15:44
      It would have to be on a case-by-case basis.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:46
      Do you have a sense as to what you might be dealing with?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:15:53
      It would be really difficult to say just overall.
    • 02:15:56
      I think as a criterion, I think it narrows the field down even more because for instance, and I'll go back to 863 that was looked at the last time CTB looked at it.
    • 02:16:11
      That facility served a city.
    • 02:16:17
      and connected that city to another city in North Carolina.
    • 02:16:23
      The city of Virginia was not a county seat.
    • 02:16:27
      So technically speaking, by that approach, it sort of didn't need it.
    • 02:16:33
      But the county seat was further north than the county.
    • 02:16:36
      If you go down 29 and then cut across, then it would serve it.
    • 02:16:41
      It was a very sort of amorphous kind of definition.
    • 02:16:46
      The new definition means it directly has to serve that, and no other primary has to, no other primary can serve it in that same cardinal direction, which is a little bit more specific, so it would narrow the field.
    • 02:16:59
      I can't tell you how much.
    • 02:17:01
      It would have to be, once again, on case-by-case basis.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:03
      And then just for clarification's sake, must the segment meet four sixths or four sevenths, including the required
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:17:16
      The required is not part of the Musqueam majority.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:19
      Okay, so it's a four out of six.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 02:17:21
      So it's four out of six, basically two-thirds.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:22
      Thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:25
      Okay, excellent.
    • 02:17:26
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:17:28
      We will now get to the Virginia Strategic Highway Safety Plan.
    • 02:17:32
      Ms. Sorrell.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:17:36
      Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary, members of the board, and let's see if I can
    • 02:17:45
      Ladies and Gentlemen,
    • 02:18:07
      I'm pleased to be here to talk a little bit about what a good job we've done over the last several years in improving highway safety in Virginia and what our plan is to continue to improve it, to drive down deaths and drive down serious injuries.
    • 02:18:23
      So just a very brief history.
    • 02:18:29
      The Strategic Highway Safety Plan is a multi-agency comprehensive plan for how to improve safety, highway safety, across the Commonwealth.
    • 02:18:39
      And we were first required to do this under the Safety Loo legislation, and we had a plan back in 2006, and it covered the last several years, and now we're updating it for the next six years.
    • 02:18:52
      So as you can see at the bottom of the page there are lots of logos.
    • 02:18:56
      These are just some of the agencies, not all of them because they wouldn't all fit on the page, of our safety partners including the Department of Motor Vehicles and the Department of Health, the Federal Highway Administration, the Department of Education and the Department of Fire Services and the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration and just a few of our
    • 02:19:19
      State and Federal Partners.
    • 02:19:21
      They're also local partners and partners like the Virginia Association of Chiefs of Police who have been very instrumental in helping put together this plan.
    • 02:19:32
      So just to give you a very brief background, in 2006 we created, based on data, four primary emphasis areas and you can see under that emphasis area there were lots of other lists of categories that were sliced and diced to try and
    • 02:19:51
      come up with a variety of strategies, but overall the goals were to reduce deaths by 100 and to reduce injuries by 4,000 between 2006 and 2010.
    • 02:20:01
      And so I'm very happy to report that we actually realized double that amount or 23% fewer traffic deaths over that time and 45% reduced severe injuries even though BMTs actually were going up during that time.
    • 02:20:17
      We saw decreases in alcohol deaths and injuries, young driver deaths, and other speed-related deaths.
    • 02:20:25
      So, all great things, in large part due to the cooperation and coordination of the various agencies across the Commonwealth, from educators and driver education,
    • 02:20:39
      and health professionals, EMS folks, and of course our enforcement partners in making these improvements happen.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:48
      Mr. Jordan?
    • 02:20:50
      Yes, Ms. Lott.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:52
      Connie, quick question.
    • 02:20:53
      Going back to your previous slide on page three about special users, it's got limited English proficiency.
    • 02:21:00
      I don't think we're in a position to be able to change all the signs in the state to be able to take care of some of these needs, and I guess my question, maybe I'm coming from the wrong point, but should that be a function of DMV to make sure the persons that are getting a license to drive in the state have the proficiency to read our signs?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:21:22
      It was, and it is.
    • 02:21:23
      This really related to licensure, the driver's licensure and making sure people who may be from foreign countries and who may be driving know enough about how to read signs and what the rules of the road are.
    • 02:21:40
      So that was back in the first plan we ever did.
    • 02:21:43
      And so there were things in here.
    • 02:21:45
      Some of these things were done by DMV.
    • 02:21:47
      Some of them were done by state police, others VDOT less.
    • 02:21:52
      So there were a whole combination of strategies, included things to say improve the graduated driver's license program to help make younger drivers safer.
    • 02:22:05
      So as you can see, we had seat belt usage increase.
    • 02:22:10
      and of course there were lots of other things that we did including improving child and passenger bicycle safety and we also VDOT funded a project with DMV to do a major upgrade of our traffic record system and also Department of Transportation
    • 02:22:30
      State Police and even the court system were all a part of doing that because there are many, many users of this highway safety information and we had a very old system and now we've got a really great new system and we're getting more up-to-date information and that's going to help us be able to see trends sooner and be able to respond to those needs.
    • 02:22:54
      So just as a snapshot, you can see that some overall over the last decade we've definitely made improvements and that there have been serious increase in annual deaths even though
    • 02:23:09
      More than 700 a year still is not a good record, even though Virginia has one of the top transportation safety records in the country.
    • 02:23:16
      700 people a year dying on Virginia roads is still too many.
    • 02:23:22
      You know, if they were in airplanes and they fell out of the sky, hundreds of them at a time, it would be a national outcry, unfortunately.
    • 02:23:29
      You know, they happen one or two or three a day.
    • 02:23:34
      and we don't seem to have the same sense of shock about losing 700 people a day in automobile crashes or having 10, 12,000 people seriously injured, not just injured, but really seriously injured in crashes every year.
    • 02:23:51
      So this little map is just a depiction of geographically how they're distributed.
    • 02:23:58
      So I wanted to just share with you that
    • 02:24:01
      One of the reasons why we do the State Highway Safety Plan is so that we help this direct how we are going to spend our highway safety improvement dollars.
    • 02:24:11
      In the last few years we've been getting about 30-some million dollars a year.
    • 02:24:14
      Now we're going to be getting about 60-some million dollars a year, specifically related to improving safety on the network.
    • 02:24:21
      And so one of the things you'll see here is that there are 20 jurisdictions in the state of Virginia that represent 40% of all the deaths and severe injuries.
    • 02:24:31
      So you might be surprised, you think that Fairfax County people don't go very fast.
    • 02:24:37
      There can't be so many crashes or deaths in Fairfax County, but actually they have one of the highest combined rates.
    • 02:24:44
      And so even places like, it's interesting, Bedford, Frederick, Fauquier, Spotsylvania, Hampton, Augusta, Chesapeake, join the list along with the Richmond metropolitan area and
    • 02:24:56
      Most of all, Northern Virginia and many of the areas and cities in Hampton Roads.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:02
      In funk here, it's the deer.
    • 02:25:03
      We've got too many deer.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:25:04
      That could be.
    • 02:25:07
      That could be.
    • 02:25:08
      So, in looking at the data, where we've come and where we're going, we had a steering committee made up of these agencies and came up with seven
    • 02:25:20
      So those are the emphasis areas that we decided that we would recommend to our agency heads and the Secretary to guide us over the next several years.
    • 02:25:30
      So I'm going to just quickly go through some of these.
    • 02:25:33
      You know, I'm sure there's a lot more detail if you'd like to read the whole plan.
    • 02:25:37
      We're getting ready to submit it to the Federal Highway Administration for their approval.
    • 02:25:41
      The Secretary will sign it and send it on behalf of the Governor.
    • 02:25:44
      So just the vision is towards zero deaths so that we should, that's obviously our overall goal but we've actually set us the goal to reduce deaths and severe injuries in half by 2030 so over the next six years we hope to reduce it at least two to three percent a year.
    • 02:26:02
      So this team had meetings, we had, we set up meetings all over the state of Virginia and we had lots of local
    • 02:26:08
      emergency and health professionals and teachers involved in identifying strategies and we selected action leaders for each of these areas so DMV knows which ones are theirs to be the lead of and the state police has theirs and we actually have set up some measurable objectives.
    • 02:26:28
      So in the emphasis, each one of these emphasis areas has a couple of slides.
    • 02:26:33
      So I'll just quickly go through them.
    • 02:26:35
      Since I'm probably standing between you and lunch.
    • 02:26:40
      Obviously this is what we've been doing in speed and depth and strategies include implementing engineering countermeasures, developing a special speed campaign involving the media, enforcement, education and evaluation and implementing other speed management measures.
    • 02:26:58
      So these are just some of the examples of multitudes of strategies that each of the various agencies have developed.
    • 02:27:04
      So, young drivers is another emphasis area and as you might guess, some of these overlap.
    • 02:27:09
      People who are young drivers may also be speeding and maybe also the people who have run off the road accidents or may have alcohol involved.
    • 02:27:17
      While these factors are separated out in these seven categories, they often are combined together in the same crashes.
    • 02:27:25
      So young driver objectives, these are particularly for DMV in terms of looking at and continuing to tweak the graduated driver's license law and working with the State Department of Education and the community colleges in four-year institutions in terms of
    • 02:27:42
      Really getting to young drivers between 16 and 24, which is really the key category where we have the most deaths and injuries.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:50
      Mr. Chairman, can I ask Connie one question?
    • 02:27:52
      Honey, in this with the young drivers, any push for non-texting?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:28:00
      Well, there is already a non-texting law for under 18, I believe it is.
    • 02:28:07
      Well, I think the General Assembly has been wrestling with that issue, and it wouldn't surprise me to see it back before the General Assembly again this year, but so far it's just been a restriction to young drivers.
    • 02:28:33
      Except if you really want to see the effects of some of it, you know, Virginia Tech did a big study about the 100 car driver study and you can go out on the web and see that study.
    • 02:28:42
      It's now a 4,000 driver study nationwide.
    • 02:28:44
      But they did video tape for a year of people driving, and it's amazing what people do in their car, young people and old people, multitasking.
    • 02:28:54
      Quite serious.
    • 02:28:56
      Really, distracted driving is a very serious problem.
    • 02:28:59
      So, I won't read through all of these.
    • 02:29:01
      Occupational protection, obviously, is an important thing.
    • 02:29:05
      State Police running the click-it-or-ticket programs, for example, and helping people understand how to put child car seats in their car and make them safe.
    • 02:29:15
      It's sort of amazing that it's not as maybe easy as you might think it is for some folks.
    • 02:29:20
      Impaired alcohol, driving, we still have quite a big problem.
    • 02:29:25
      It's kind of surprising how many people still are out there
    • 02:29:29
      So we shouldn't give up on continuing education and training and strengthening our DUI enforcement.
    • 02:29:38
      Roadway departure, we still have a lot of run-off-the-road crashes.
    • 02:29:41
      Unfortunately, they're very random in nature, so it's not that easy to just say that there are a few spots and we can make particular changes and stop them.
    • 02:29:51
      So a little more difficult, although we are always trying to look to see if there are blind curbs and things we can do.
    • 02:29:59
      And last, intersection objectives, obviously reducing the frequency and severity of crashes and intersections and developing consistent and coordinated incident response programs is also a part of the program.
    • 02:30:16
      Last but not least, the strategy is to
    • 02:30:19
      continue to improve the data that we have and make sure that we're keeping it up to date and using it to improve the programs and continue to improve safety.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:32
      So... Mr. Chairman, one just... two brief comments, one on intersections.
    • 02:30:37
      I think the studies show that if you have roundabouts at various intersections, it reduces the severity of the crashes.
    • 02:30:45
      And around the world in other jurisdictions, they're more apt to put these in than we are.
    • 02:30:51
      We're getting better.
    • 02:30:52
      But when you have a crash and a roundabout, it's not one of these T-bone things.
    • 02:30:57
      It's a fender bender generally.
    • 02:30:59
      So I think the department, if they can look more and more into that.
    • 02:31:02
      The other thing I get a lot, you and I have talked about this before, in my area people are complaining about proliferation of signs that they find distracting.
    • 02:31:12
      More and more signs are going up and now you have these big signs that are digital and illuminated and I don't know if we should look into that to see if they cause problems or not.
    • 02:31:22
      Obviously you need some signs.
    • 02:31:24
      But I think just like any other thing, too much of a good thing is not good.
    • 02:31:30
      Those are just some of the comments that I had.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:31:32
      I appreciate it.
    • 02:31:33
      The department has endorsed the use of roundabouts in many areas and they can be very effective in the right place.
    • 02:31:44
      There have been any number of them built and they are in our design manual for designers to use those as strategies for safety improvements as well as congestion and moving traffic.
    • 02:31:57
      So, last, I'll just talk for just a second about implementation.
    • 02:32:03
      Obviously, we have to do an annual report to the federal government, but we're going to be doing an annual report to the secretary and the agency heads about how well we're progressing.
    • 02:32:11
      Are we implementing these strategies?
    • 02:32:13
      Are these strategies having a difference and continuing to identify problems and create solutions?
    • 02:32:22
      So, you know, this is also part of traffic,
    • 02:32:26
      Nat 21 with the safety requirements for reporting as well.
    • 02:32:31
      So we'll be keeping an eye on that.
    • 02:32:34
      So that's the end of my presentation.
    • 02:32:37
      I just hope that we will continue to make the good progress that we've made in the last several years.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:46
      I still have some dismay that we are stuck with the paradigm of knee-jerk speedings up at the top of the list.
    • 02:33:04
      We can go back and forth because I can pull out statistics.
    • 02:33:09
      We even had to acknowledge the work zone safety laws statistics in the past.
    • 02:33:17
      Bottom line, there's only currently three reasons for a traffic accident.
    • 02:33:23
      Exemplary weather, equipment failure, driver behavior.
    • 02:33:27
      And as long as we're in need here, assuming speeding is the cause everywhere.
    • 02:33:33
      We're never going to consider that if people would not block the left lane, not follow too closely for conditions, and not drive beyond their competence.
    • 02:33:45
      I would like to recognize Ray Corey, the State Traffic Engineer, and Steven Reid, our
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:34:02
      A state safety traffic engineer for the work that they did and their staff in putting this together.
    • 02:34:08
      It's been about a six or eight months process working with the other state agencies to develop the plan.
    • 02:34:14
      They've done a really outstanding job.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:34:17
      Any other questions for Mr. Worley?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:34:20
      Connie, before you leave, to the members of the board, Connie has been with state government about 40 years.
    • 02:34:28
      She's been with the
    • 02:34:30
      Virginia Department of Transportation, 30 years, and she's just announced her retirement.
    • 02:34:37
      Connie began her career in 1982 with VDOT, working in our management services division, and then from there she went to the Richmond district, serving as the district administrator for about nine years.
    • 02:34:56
      She came back working in the central office again, I believe,
    • 02:35:00
      Chief Policy and Organizational Development.
    • 02:35:04
      And then she took on, I believe it was in 2004, she took on an assignment to go to the Hampton Roads District to serve as the interim district administrator in Hampton Roads.
    • 02:35:19
      And I think she stayed there about nine months.
    • 02:35:23
      And she had a change in district administrators there and there at that time.
    • 02:35:28
      And Connie went there to kind of settle the
    • 02:35:30
      Operation Down and did a great job and after that she returned to the central office in the role of Chief of Systems Operation where she remains today.
    • 02:35:42
      Connie has had a lot of accomplishments throughout her career but as the Chief of Systems Operation you've seen some of the work that she's done with the
    • 02:35:58
      reached the beach signs and some of the automation that we put on the road and I believe later on today we'll be talking about the active traffic management system that's in northern Virginia.
    • 02:36:10
      So she had a lot of accomplishments in moving transportation forward in Virginia and she's also had a number of assignments as chairs of committees in AASHTO and TRB and
    • 02:36:23
      A number of organizations promoting Virginia, and we will definitely miss the kind of service with the department.
    • 02:36:32
      So I wish you'd join me in congratulating Connie on that.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:36:49
      Thank you.
    • 02:36:50
      I'd just like to say a couple of short thoughts.
    • 02:36:54
      First of all, thank you for just a tremendous career.
    • 02:36:57
      I started back in 1972 working for the legislature for seven years and saw the other side of the executive branch and decided to join it and worked at the governor's budget office back during the Dalton administration.
    • 02:37:10
      How long ago was that?
    • 02:37:12
      It seems like yesterday, but it's been a tremendous trip.
    • 02:37:17
      You know, I helped see the construction of the 295 and the Burana-Ina Bridge and
    • 02:37:23
      One of my first assignments at Richmond District was to take down the Richmond-Petersburg Toll Pike Authority facility.
    • 02:37:30
      So, you know, we ripped out the toll booths and my family was so excited.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:37:33
      Did you leave them laying around anyhow?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:37:37
      Yeah, well, you know, at that time we were making about $35 million a year.
    • 02:37:40
      That was back in 1992, but of course we built 295, which made it a nice little roundabout trip, so we thought we wouldn't get too many quarters after that.
    • 02:37:50
      One of the most exciting things really in my career has been working in the field and working in projects and supporting the tremendous employees who do such an outstanding job for us every day.
    • 02:38:04
      You know, the hurricanes, the blizzards, the snow storms, the ice storms, the things that, you know, driving around and seeing them do their jobs and helping find the right support for them to make sure that they have the tools
    • 02:38:18
      and the equipment and the supplies to really do their jobs and be effective because they really are the heart and soul of the department.
    • 02:38:25
      So it's really been my pleasure to have been a small part of it.
    • 02:38:30
      And, you know, really I'm very excited that this being my last meeting that the item that's on the last part of the agenda is here.
    • 02:38:38
      Over the last few years I've had the privilege of representing AASHTO being one of three states on the ITS America Board of Directors.
    • 02:38:47
      And I've been able to go to some different countries and see traffic operations.
    • 02:38:54
      And one of those trips and the information I was able to be exposed to because of being at that national level was all of this sort of European style active traffic management.
    • 02:39:06
      And so we came back and I had staff work together to put together a proposal for us to apply for a TIGER grant.
    • 02:39:15
      And the secretary obviously submitted that.
    • 02:39:17
      It didn't get selected, but then when the governor put together his $4 billion proposal, it was the secretary who remembered that project and put it in the list to put it in the six-year plan.
    • 02:39:29
      And it's an exciting project to build a whole new traffic management system on I-66 from the Potomac River almost to Haymarket.
    • 02:39:41
      I mean, not Haymarket.
    • 02:39:47
      And so I think that it's going to be a showcase project, not only in Virginia, but in the nation.
    • 02:39:53
      There are a couple of small projects around the country like it, but there won't be anything like it here.
    • 02:39:57
      And of course, having it be a showcase in the capital region for Congress to think about some transportation technology improvements that we could make in our system to help move traffic is really exciting.
    • 02:40:09
      So thank you so much for the pleasure and the privilege of being able to serve at Commonwealth.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:24
      It is 1245.
    • 02:40:25
      We're going to take a 15-minute break.
    • 02:40:28
      I'm going to ask the CTB if you can grab your box lunches.
    • 02:40:30
      We'll start back up at 1 o'clock.
    • 02:40:32
      We still have a fairly hefty agenda on the workshop agenda before we get to the meeting itself.
    • 02:40:39
      So at 1 o'clock, we will start back up.
    • 02:40:45
      Everyone, please take your seats.
    • 02:40:48
      We're now going to have SJR 297 report briefing by Ms. Director Drake.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:02
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:41:03
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, Senate Joint Resolution 297 is a comprehensive analysis of transit.
    • 02:41:11
      The current system that we have for funding transit
    • 02:41:14
      It dates back to 1986, and I believe that if you were creating a funding system for transit today at the CTB level, that you would not select the way that we fund transit today, which is based only on operating expenses and rewards those who spend the most money.
    • 02:41:35
      The goal of the study is to create the 21st century funding model for public transportation.
    • 02:41:42
      We looked at performance, prioritization, stability, and allocation.
    • 02:41:52
      The funding study advisory committee consisted of transit operators, MPOs, local government officials, transportation and management representatives, and other interested parties.
    • 02:42:06
      Existing funding allocation models
    • 02:42:10
      We looked at as well as a best practice peer review and an analysis of nationwide trends.
    • 02:42:17
      We looked at options for the distribution of state operating and capital assistance, identified data needs, conducted needs assessment, and developed recommendations.
    • 02:42:31
      These are the dates of meetings and different events that have taken place along the way.
    • 02:42:35
      This was the 2011 General Assembly resolution.
    • 02:42:41
      We did do an interim report last year and it finished up this year.
    • 02:42:46
      The current operating assistant is based on one factor and that is operating cost.
    • 02:42:52
      He who spends the most money receives the most money and there is no ability to reward performance.
    • 02:43:01
      We looked at operating assistance, and operating assistance is proportional to all transit providers' expenditures.
    • 02:43:11
      All agencies, regardless of size, receive the same amount percentage of operating expenses based on the funding that we have available.
    • 02:43:23
      There is no direct link to the CTB policy goals.
    • 02:43:28
      And the funding allocation is based on two-year-old data, as I mentioned when Mr. Harrell was here.
    • 02:43:33
      There are ineligible versus eligible expenses, which really adds complexities to the formula.
    • 02:43:40
      Every time that we speak to you about what our operating percentage is, we always talk in terms of total expenses.
    • 02:43:48
      This year we are at 20% of total expenses.
    • 02:43:53
      Ineligible expenses are
    • 02:43:55
      Drivers, mechanics, and labor costs are ineligible.
    • 02:44:00
      Eligible are things like administrative costs, fuel, tires, maintenance.
    • 02:44:07
      If we were to talk only in terms of eligible, we'd be in the range of 40 to 44%.
    • 02:44:13
      But we also believe that it takes all of those things to run a transit system, and again, I've only talked in the terms of the 20% total expenses, and think that that is something
    • 02:44:24
      That is really outgrown its time.
    • 02:44:26
      The data can be verified in the system.
    • 02:44:29
      Now, recommendation on this was to look at a hybrid allocation approach, and this has come from the discussions over these 18 months.
    • 02:44:39
      We did decide, we thought it was best not to go cold turkey to a strictly performance model.
    • 02:44:45
      So we broke it into two.
    • 02:44:46
      50% of it based on ridership, which we thought was what is the outcome of what we're trying to achieve, and that's people riding the bus.
    • 02:44:57
      And then the other part of that 50% based on the current way we fund operating expenses.
    • 02:45:04
      So you show up, you get 25%.
    • 02:45:07
      The other 50% was based on recognizable industry standards, customers per revenue hour, customers per revenue mile, net cost per revenue hour, and net cost per revenue mile.
    • 02:45:22
      So we have the six performance metrics that we're using.
    • 02:45:26
      It's also important to point out to you that there would be periodic reviews by the CTB, which would include public comments.
    • 02:45:34
      So that there is a way for people to continue to weigh in on this performance model.
    • 02:45:41
      The new model, we formed peer groups, you can see them up there and on your screen, for our transit companies so that they would be compared based upon their own peer groups.
    • 02:45:53
      Today, the tiniest transit companies in Virginia, such as Chincoteague, are in the same funding pot with WMATA.
    • 02:46:00
      There is no differentiation.
    • 02:46:02
      Wanted to give you a couple models.
    • 02:46:03
      First, in this example, bus one and bus two, you'll see the cost to rider and the state subsidy for riders is much higher for bus two.
    • 02:46:16
      In the current system, the more you spend, the more you get, where in the new model, the higher cost gets less state funding and encourages transit companies to be more efficient.
    • 02:46:30
      In the second model,
    • 02:46:31
      This one will show you that the cost per rider and the state subsidy per rider is very similar.
    • 02:46:38
      In the current system, and what's important in this chart, is this bus three has generated much more money in agency generated non-tax based revenue.
    • 02:46:50
      They get no credit for doing that.
    • 02:46:53
      Under the new model,
    • 02:46:54
      Agency generated revenue decreases net cost, so the new model would reward that practice.
    • 02:47:03
      Current capital assistance, because we always talk in terms of operating assistance and capital assistance, we have $30 million annually from the Mass Transit Trust Fund.
    • 02:47:14
      It's allocated based on non-federal share of a project compared to total of all projects.
    • 02:47:20
      It is an application driven process.
    • 02:47:22
      There is no flexibility to prioritize funding, and all capital items are funded at the same blended rate as bonds at approximately 50%.
    • 02:47:33
      Now the Mass Transit Capital Fund, which is another fund that we have, our bonds will be exhausted in 2018.
    • 02:47:39
      This is also an application driven process, but we do have the flexibility to prioritize funding.
    • 02:47:47
      So we have the ability to fund what we call state of good repair, which is rolling stock, buses, overhauls of that type, at 80%.
    • 02:47:57
      Now, that's 80% of the state share because in this model, the federal government pays 80%, Commonwealth would pay 16%, and the local match would be 4%.
    • 02:48:09
      We have the ability to fund other capital items at a blended rate of 50%, and that would be things like
    • 02:48:15
      Bus shelters, sidewalks, landscaping, things of that nature.
    • 02:48:21
      In the recommended allocation model, we would continue with an application driven process but allow flexibility to fund with a tiered approach so that your bus replacements and overhauls would stay at that 20% of total cost, the 80% of the non-federal back to the 80, 16, and 4 I just explained.
    • 02:48:43
      Bus shelters, this is just an example of what was thrown out there, bus shelters and bike racks at 10% commute computers and landscaping at five, just to put the most of the money and the most important asset which would be the rolling stock.
    • 02:48:57
      Again, you would revisit the priorities in a window of every three to five years and we would allow capital funds to supplement operating assistance which does not happen today.
    • 02:49:09
      Frequently we're in a situation where we have capital funds left over because our transit company may not have the local match to be able to pull down those funds and we are not allowed to flex them over to operating.
    • 02:49:22
      Some of our recommendations on the performance side to revise the Code of Virginia to implement a hybrid formula.
    • 02:49:29
      Not a specific formula, but a hybrid formula that would have those discussions taking place
    • 02:49:35
      We would prioritize to allow that your capital investment decisions are reflected in our transit system stability, the request of transitional assistance to minimize the impact of this new system.
    • 02:49:50
      The new system would, under the proposal, would go into effect in fiscal year 17, but in fiscal year 15, we would request that there be 100% funding, that nobody would be funded differently than they are today.
    • 02:50:04
      in fiscal year 16 to drop that to 50% and the model go into effect in fiscal year 17 so that it gives our transit companies this window of time to look at their systems, look at what they're doing, see how they can become more efficient.
    • 02:50:19
      We would also propose establishing a reserve fund to stabilize match ratios for both capital and operating expenses.
    • 02:50:28
      Possibly this is a fund that could be used for what Mr. Harrell spoke about.
    • 02:50:32
      How to make sure that people aren't dropping more than a certain amount.
    • 02:50:36
      Our original thought on this is probably about a 5% amount of money.
    • 02:50:41
      In regards to allocation, capital and special program funds would also be able to be used to supplement operating funds and all of our programs would require a local match.
    • 02:50:55
      Capital and operating needs, since we want to document the gap between transit needs
    • 02:51:00
      and funding as part of the statewide transit and TDM plan in order that we can show do we or don't we need additional funding in transit and to be able to make the argument in the case as to the value of a transit system to maximize the capacity of our existing system.
    • 02:51:20
      I personally believe we need a new message and that the message for the 21st century would be the emphasis on the value of transit
    • 02:51:28
      Not only to maximize infrastructure but to deal with highway congestion, reducing the number of single occupant vehicles, giving commuters additional choices and to bring up what we call choice transit.
    • 02:51:41
      You've heard a little bit about that today.
    • 02:51:43
      Our transition assistance, we talked about 100% in 15, 50, and 16 and funding the model going into a place in fiscal 2017.
    • 02:51:55
      That would require an $18 million amount of money that we certainly would ask people to look at that just to make sure that there's time for people to acclimate for the new model.
    • 02:52:08
      Where we are now is we'll be holding stakeholder workshops in both October and November.
    • 02:52:12
      We have put on your desk the draft report for 297.
    • 02:52:17
      It has been posted on our website as well.
    • 02:52:20
      And we will do the final report to the General Assembly in November.
    • 02:52:26
      So the study recognizes that there is a need for stability with regard to funding.
    • 02:52:31
      The current system, in my opinion, is a decreasing revenue source for our transit companies because of the size
    • 02:52:40
      of the systems that are waiting to come online.
    • 02:52:43
      Norfolk Light Rail came on last summer, so we're just over a year into that.
    • 02:52:47
      The Dulles One project will be operating in early 2014, but we have our pod of transit funding, which simply is sliced into smaller pieces as these larger systems come online.
    • 02:53:01
      We also are looking at a tiered approach to state match ratios and a performance-based approach to provide an incentive for efficient service
    • 02:53:10
      as well as the formula-based component to ensure year-to-year stability.
    • 02:53:15
      Again, the creation of a reserve fund and a three-year transition period.
    • 02:53:21
      297 was asked for to evaluate Virginia's current transit funding practices and to be a comprehensive evaluation of public transportation capital and operating needs.
    • 02:53:36
      Local governments and local transit operators will continue to make their own decisions.
    • 02:53:43
      And I think with this model in place and people striving to be more efficient, to bring down more state dollars, that it will actually be better decisions that are made at the local level based on a wider array of facts and an awareness of what's taking place.
    • 02:53:58
      The current funding model again creates winners and losers.
    • 02:54:02
      Transit companies that spend the most money
    • 02:54:05
      received the most money and state aid is dispensed on one factor, operating costs regardless of size, efficiency, or the type of transit service provided.
    • 02:54:16
      One of our local transit workers, employees, this week made a comment that they welcome performance metrics because they want people to see what a very good job they're doing and how efficient that that particular system is.
    • 02:54:32
      We believe that the criteria for evaluating the success of a new funding model is not whether agencies receive different amounts of funding, but whether the source of that differentiation is consistent with the goals and principles of the funding entity.
    • 02:54:51
      Average change in total operating funding is 5% of total budget.
    • 02:54:56
      Public transit agencies that operate efficient service will now be rewarded.
    • 02:55:01
      Recommended approach is consistent with the policy goals of the CTB and also MAP 21 that you've heard a lot about in the presentation by Rita Busher is also requiring performance metrics for federal funds to be brought down.
    • 02:55:17
      Virginia, because of these 18 months that we've been working on this, even prior to MAP 21, is a little bit ahead of the curve on this and certainly I would hope that we would be a national model.
    • 02:55:27
      Currently, funding is based, as I said, with William Harrell on that two-year-old data.
    • 02:55:31
      Under the new plan, it will be based on the current year budget and also makes it easier to bring up new service because of that.
    • 02:55:38
      We did use six industry performance metrics that were identified.
    • 02:55:44
      I've gone over those for you, and they're up on the chart.
    • 02:55:47
      But the goal is to reward and incentivize our transit system to be more efficient, to
    • 02:55:54
      To have performance metrics in place so that public taxpayers who are paying for the system who are demanding accountability from government understand and feel that things are being done well and to establish that accountability.
    • 02:56:09
      So Mr. Chairman, I'm happy to answer any questions and I want to really thank the staff at DRPT.
    • 02:56:15
      There have been several people and several of them are here today.
    • 02:56:19
      who have really engaged over these 18 months with our community, with our transit community, with the members of the advisory committee to work through this model.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:30
      Director Drake, that was such a positive and upbeat presentation.
    • 02:56:34
      My assumption is no one will have any problems with us doing it.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:37
      Well, Mr. Chairman, as you know, change is always hard and the unknown is always very frightful.
    • 02:56:43
      There are people who do not agree with the model, and I'm hoping that as we're able to explain it and to meet with people, and I am reaching out to everyone that I hear from or that I haven't heard from yet, to be able to explain this not only in more detail to transit companies, to local government, and to make sure that, as with Mr. Harrell, he mentioned that I went last week and sat down and talked to him about some of his concerns, and I think there's good ideas out there.
    • 02:57:10
      This isn't an etched-in stone.
    • 02:57:12
      This is the way it's going to be.
    • 02:57:13
      But it is a performance-based model that we'll all be working together on into the future.
    • 02:57:18
      You didn't want such a long answer, but I had to do it.
    • 02:57:20
      Sorry.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:21
      Any other questions for the directors?
    • 02:57:25
      Yes, sir.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:25
      And I agree, a large part of this is going to be sort of the communications element and I'm trying to get my mind sort of wrapped around it.
    • 02:57:34
      You have the current formula which is performance-based metrics.
    • 02:57:36
      I'm looking on slide 11 where it talks about various examples.
    • 02:57:43
      As people ask me, how will this affect whatever the transit service is?
    • 02:57:49
      I'm trying to come to my mind so I can explain it to them so I can stutter my way through it as I am now.
    • 02:57:56
      We're going to give a certain amount per rider, a certain amount per mile that is driven.
    • 02:58:02
      Some of these, I've seen lines, quite frankly, that had nobody driving on them or nobody riding on some of these transits except for maybe five people in a day.
    • 02:58:12
      We eliminate the line, and yet you get all these howls of protest.
    • 02:58:15
      How can I best explain to people what these metrics, what the performance-based metrics ultimately will mean for a group that covers everything?
    • 02:58:27
      I don't necessarily want to say, this group will get this, this group will get that.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:58:35
      Well, they start with a percentage that comes from their current operating expenses, budgeted year, not two-year-old data.
    • 02:58:42
      So that's one benefit to them.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:58:44
      So their current operating expenses, a million dollars.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:58:47
      A million dollars.
    • 02:58:48
      So they would get 25%, $250,000 for operating expenses.
    • 02:58:53
      Then they would be compared in their peer group at their ridership levels, and they would get a percentage of ridership.
    • 02:59:00
      Please correct me if I'm wrong, because they're the ones that have worked very closely.
    • 02:59:03
      in doing all of these numbers, and then we would use the other four metrics, all six of which are industry standards and accepted by the work group that these are industry standards.
    • 02:59:14
      That doesn't mean they all said these were the ones we want to use, but they do accept the fact that these are industry standards.
    • 02:59:20
      We can sit down with them and we can show them where they are, but the really important thing to this, because some transit companies today know that they would receive additional funding
    • 02:59:31
      Under this particular model because of the way they're running their system today.
    • 02:59:34
      So if the ones that are not really need to look at what are we doing?
    • 02:59:40
      Why is someone else in my peer group doing so much better than I'm doing?
    • 02:59:44
      What are they doing that I'm not doing?
    • 02:59:47
      And as we said in July when we did the preliminary report on this, the local government may make the decision that they want to run a route that is not cost effective, but it may have another component to it.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:59
      The 25% of the current operating expense is the easy one.
    • 03:00:06
      How does 25% of ridership, 12.5?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:13
      How do you work through the waterfall?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:14
      How do you work through all the percentages?
    • 03:00:17
      The ridership is based on statewide ridership numbers.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:00:23
      It's our money guy.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:00:28
      Yeah, I guess probably the best, it's still the same pot of money as today that's going to be distributed to the same, I think it's 39 entities.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:38
      So by percentage of ridership that your particular transit authority has, that's where that gets distributed?
    • 03:00:46
      Of the whole.
    • 03:00:46
      So 100% is sustained.
    • 03:00:49
      If you have a transit authority that covers 50% of that ridership, you get 50% of the
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:00:54
      of 25% of the total that were distributed.
    • 03:00:58
      And then the same methodology for operating expense, which is the current methodology acceptance for all of the buckets.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:06
      Customers per revenue hour.
    • 03:01:09
      And we look at the entire Commonwealth for revenue hours.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:01:13
      And the four performance, when you branch off to the performance, then you're put into a peer grouping.
    • 03:01:20
      and you're weighted, first of all your size is weighted because there are size differentials within the peer groups and then you have a performance factor that's the four items listed and you're compared against the people in your peer group.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:39
      I'm prepping for my meeting or what will be an MPO meeting where Al Hart will be hitting me with these questions so you understand where I'm coming from.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:46
      Thank you, Mr. Commissioner.
    • 03:01:53
      Thelma, I have probably a series of questions that kind of lead one to another.
    • 03:01:58
      Since we represent the 800-pound gorilla in the Commonwealth, the Lamada, we really have to have concern in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:02:09
      Is this going to have a prejudicial effect against the large system?
    • 03:02:17
      Because when I ask that, because when I look at the hybrid, the 50-50, it seems to me that it does.
    • 03:02:26
      And I'd like to hear your response to that, number one.
    • 03:02:31
      And number two, there's a reserve fund mentioned.
    • 03:02:35
      How is that going to be funded?
    • 03:02:37
      And the whole harm was just over two years.
    • 03:02:42
      That doesn't seem like a long time before
    • 03:02:46
      There's another challenge, and that's my big concern, and what are the peer groups saying?
    • 03:02:51
      And I guess there's only one peer group for WMATA.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:54
      WMATA is in a peer group with VRE and Norfolk Light Rail, six guideway system.
    • 03:02:59
      So that's their peer group that they're in.
    • 03:03:01
      That's their peer group.
    • 03:03:02
      There are bus services in a bus peer group, so they're not in just one peer group.
    • 03:03:08
      They're split up between the two.
    • 03:03:10
      We recognize that Ramada is a huge issue regardless of which funding model we use because of the new system that's coming on as well.
    • 03:03:23
      Well, I just want to go on records.
    • 03:03:28
      That's going to be the challenge.
    • 03:03:30
      One of the things that you will find in the report is that we're asking that people need to really start looking at a dedicated revenue source for WMATA in addition to the gas tax that you have in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:03:42
      And there's actually been some discussions taking place about that because it is a huge
    • 03:03:47
      Right now, the Commonwealth of Virginia is doing $154 million a year to WMATA.
    • 03:03:53
      $50 million of that is PREA money.
    • 03:03:55
      The rest is $104 that comes out of our Mass Transit Trust Fund funding that we spread around the state.
    • 03:04:00
      But they have that $104 million.
    • 03:04:02
      So they certainly are the biggest recipient.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:04:05
      But they would be put into this.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:06
      Remember too, Mr. Garczynski, that there is time for us to be looking at this particular model.
    • 03:04:13
      and I think when you talk through it that you would agree doing it just based on operating expenses isn't the best model either.
    • 03:04:21
      So to look at that and to put some industry standards in place and have some time and to have the periodic CTB review that you'll be looking at those standards, getting public comment and hopefully tweaking this to where it is a much better model.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:38
      I just question that about that 50-50 balance
    • 03:04:42
      I'm all for performance standards.
    • 03:04:44
      We all know if we read the Washington Post or look at our local television stations, the challenges that WMATA faces almost every day in terms of delivery of their service and performance.
    • 03:04:57
      And I know their current chair is working hard to that effect, but it is unique and I think that's the one thing I have to put on the table to my brethren is that there is nothing like really the WMATA system right now.
    • 03:05:11
      I know hopefully Aubrey and Sheppard say someday Norfolk will be like that but it isn't now and like you said we're offering probably within the next year when Dulles One opens a lot of new service lines feeding that
    • 03:05:26
      That line too, and you know I was concerned about that when I asked the question this morning of Hampton and expanding their service.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:33
      And looking at the map that we've done, Wamata Rail actually has an increase in funding because they do move a lot of people.
    • 03:05:42
      So they've got high fare box and a lot of ridership.
    • 03:05:45
      So they actually increase funding under WAMATA.
    • 03:05:53
      Thank you, Mr. Commissioner.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:02
      I'm all about the philosophy here because it makes absolutely no sense to just fund people based on their costs.
    • 03:06:11
      That's part of the problem we have in government at many levels.
    • 03:06:15
      So I applaud you for tackling this.
    • 03:06:19
      I'm curious, because you have different
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 03:06:23
      levels are peer groups.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:27
      I don't think I've heard how much of the money percentage-wise is assigned to each peer group because that's what's going to drive these percentages at the next level or the percentages are going to be driven off that.
    • 03:06:45
      We haven't heard any of that yet that I'm aware of.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:49
      According to Steve, it's based off their operating cost.
    • 03:06:52
      The percentage of the pot that would go to them is based on, to that peer group, is based on the operating cost of that peer group.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:59
      So we're starting with a factor then in performance that goes back to the criteria we didn't like to begin with.
    • 03:07:06
      So why do we do that?
    • 03:07:09
      I mean, if the performance isn't, if operating cost is not the best way to go,
    • 03:07:17
      And we go to performance.
    • 03:07:19
      Well, on one side we've got operating expenses, which is a half of that formula.
    • 03:07:26
      And on the other side we start with operating expenses.
    • 03:07:29
      So everything that keys off of that is going to be highly influenced by the operating expenses to begin with.
    • 03:07:36
      By size.
    • 03:07:36
      No, by expense.
    • 03:07:38
      Not size, by expense.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:39
      You could use ridership to do that.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:42
      Well, I would certainly, I mean, I haven't,
    • 03:07:45
      I haven't spent a lot of time with this model yet.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:47
      Well, that's why it's a draft report with public comment.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:50
      But, I mean, the first red flag goes up when we're using it at the top of the waterfall, to use the expression we used earlier.
    • 03:07:57
      We're using exactly what we don't like at the top of the waterfall, and everything that comes out of that is going to be tainted by our influence, impacted, whatever you want to call it, by that criteria we don't like to begin with.
    • 03:08:10
      So, I'm sort of having some trouble with that piece of it.
    • 03:08:14
      Mr. Martin and Mr. Layne
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:23
      Director Drake, as one who's been accused of whining when I say that people living south and west of Charlottesville have to be more superstitious simply because of physical reality that has been thrust upon us.
    • 03:08:42
      It amazed me when my junior colleague expressed the same concern
    • 03:08:48
      That I heard from my constituency that the small markets were going to be disproportionately affected by this.
    • 03:08:57
      So to me, I believe you actually did on it.
    • 03:09:00
      The operative thing, the key thing is that this is a draft if indeed it should turn out that the small market, small operator is really going to be losing a lot more money.
    • 03:09:14
      It is an ongoing model, even once a model goes into place, which would not be immediate anyway.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:41
      Every three years you're going to be reviewing, under our proposal, every three years you're going to be reviewing it more frequently if you decide the need for it, but it really does put the performance metrics under the CTB for you to be able to watch it and make sure that we're not harming our transit companies.
    • 03:09:57
      The goal is to incentivize our transit companies to be more efficient and more accountable and to show the public what they're doing.
    • 03:10:04
      Our legislators, our taxpayers,
    • 03:10:06
      And to show why it works and the value of transit systems and in the end goal to grow our transit systems.
    • 03:10:13
      We would say to you that the small systems are hurt even more by the larger systems as they continue to grow and the amount of money that comes out of the pot.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:10:22
      There's so much less is left.
    • 03:10:24
      For those small ones.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:25
      And some of the very small ones, just by the formula, some actually would receive less money and some would receive more.
    • 03:10:33
      So they're not all losing money.
    • 03:10:35
      Some of them actually do considerably better.
    • 03:10:37
      Some are better.
    • 03:10:39
      And some lose money.
    • 03:10:42
      So they don't all, they don't all lose because they're small.
    • 03:10:45
      It's a matter of how you run your system and the decisions that you make.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:48
      Mr. Layne, Mr. Cole.
    • 03:10:49
      Mr. Fisher had her hand up before me.
    • 03:10:51
      She should go with you.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:52
      I would like to add something to what Mr. Hersey said.
    • 03:10:57
      I think more than Virginia is unique, not just by size, but by the fact that we have multiple jurisdictions that are running them on it.
    • 03:11:06
      Even with our additional Virginia board members, it's still not only Virginia's purview to
    • 03:11:11
      How is that going to be taken into consideration in looking at all systems?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:19
      Well, we're also putting their bus service, because most of them, other than Falls Church, have their own bus service, so they'll also be in a peer group to be evaluating their bus service.
    • 03:11:30
      Again, Lamada Rail grows under this model, because I'm sure it's miles traveled, it's ridership numbers, all of those things factor in, and they have a very high fare box in comparison to a lot of the systems.
    • 03:11:49
      So, but certainly we want to be very sensitive to Northern Virginia because you move the most people in the Commonwealth through transit services.
    • 03:11:58
      And the goal of this is to be able to hopefully make the argument to increase funding and to make sure that our systems are sufficient.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:10
      I'm just going to add that just quickly that I think it's going to come down to the peer groups.
    • 03:12:15
      I mean that's where I think
    • 03:12:17
      Mr. Arzenstian and Ms. Fisher have been saying is that obviously they have made a good case for why is that even in a peer group and I guess that's really back to Chef's comment about if we're using operating expenses, really who are we comparing them to?
    • 03:12:33
      That's where most of the questions I've gotten is
    • 03:12:35
      There are weighted factors within that peer group as well.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:44
      Some of the systems will have union labor, some don't, so there's a weighting of those factors in there as well to try to make it as neutral as possible.
    • 03:12:54
      And to just give them someone to compare themselves with and to be asking those questions, why are we doing well?
    • 03:13:00
      And someone else, why am I not doing well and someone else is?
    • 03:13:03
      Or what are the decisions
    • 03:13:05
      At the VML meeting, one of the presenters who stood up and spoke about this from one of the transit companies said that in 1984, 1985 timeframe, the state required them to go out and do performance metrics.
    • 03:13:18
      And he was very concerned about funding for his system and he went out and got a local college and provides their transit system service to this day.
    • 03:13:27
      So he was able to become a very efficient system because he made the effort to go out and increase the revenues that he collects
    • 03:13:35
      and he said he would not have done that had the state not pushed him to do it.
    • 03:13:39
      So we're not trying to punish anyone, we're trying to have people make good decisions and for the local electives who are responsible for that service and have to pay the gap in funding to feel they have good information on how the system runs.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:53
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:13:54
      Mr. Caldwell.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:55
      Director Drake, I applaud the new look at funding of our transit systems
    • 03:14:03
      As a service provider at the end of the day, that's what we are, a service provider.
    • 03:14:08
      The best way to serve the constituency is through efficient processes and whatnot.
    • 03:14:16
      One of the metrics that I haven't heard any mention of or haven't seen anything is how will the dependent transit rider be impacted?
    • 03:14:25
      What's the likely impact?
    • 03:14:28
      Well again, all transit decisions are local decisions, so the local government is going to make that decision if this is a route they want to continue
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:55
      to run or not, same as today.
    • 03:14:57
      You heard Mr. Harrell say in 2011 they went out and started looking at routes that were not successful.
    • 03:15:04
      My thoughts on it are the more we can do to bring up choice transit for riders, such as what IHRT is doing with the light rail, the more service you provide for your transit dependent.
    • 03:15:15
      Now there are ADA
    • 03:15:17
      service that's required.
    • 03:15:19
      If you run a bus route within three-quarters of a mile of that, you've got to provide service to people that live within three-quarters of that route.
    • 03:15:27
      Some local governments choose to expand that radius and that would be a decision that they would probably still make today, but they would be making it knowing, number one, can I go out and generate more revenue?
    • 03:15:38
      What can I do in order to increase my efficiency or is this something that I want to pay for through another way?
    • 03:15:46
      What HRT did
    • 03:15:48
      They went out and sold those go passes that you heard about.
    • 03:15:51
      The two employers, colleges and such, and this year they're going back and they're raising the price on those things because they did it to get people started using the service and now they know they can raise the price on it.
    • 03:16:02
      So there are different things that they can do to increase that ridership and increase their revenue.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:07
      I think that's good as long as we are cognizant
    • 03:16:11
      We don't get to an unintended consequence of leaving the dependent rider on his or her own and having a system that works for the choice rider.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:25
      Director Drake, something picked my ear other than just the operating costs.
    • 03:16:31
      You talked about the union, some union systems versus non-union systems.
    • 03:16:36
      Is the only union system, LaMotta?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:39
      No.
    • 03:16:40
      There are other systems that are unique.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:45
      So now we've got a, we have 25% on operating costs.
    • 03:16:51
      We start the performance based on operating costs.
    • 03:16:55
      And we have an additional measure that takes into consideration whether the drivers or the employees are union or non-union.
    • 03:17:04
      Is that what you're telling me?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:08
      Is that what I heard?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:09
      Because frankly, I mean, that's...
    • 03:17:14
      I'm not sure that we should be making our decisions based on those factors.
    • 03:17:21
      WMATA's different, and I'm sensitive to the fact that it's not all within Virginia, and Virginia doesn't control it, and the laws in Maryland and D.C. are different than the laws in Virginia, and I'm sensitive to that.
    • 03:17:35
      I understand what my colleagues are saying.
    • 03:17:38
      But in the rest of the state, that's a different issue.
    • 03:17:42
      And what I heard you say was that there was some factor in there, not just, I mean, you're going to see that already in operating costs, in period.
    • Kevin B. PageChief Operating Officer
    • 03:17:54
      Mr. Chairman, if I may, Mr. Miller, Ms. Drake's comments earlier, is that when you get into the peer groups,
    • 03:17:59
      There is a sizing factor for total expenses.
    • 03:18:03
      That's all it is.
    • 03:18:04
      There's nothing, no checkbox of union versus non-union.
    • 03:18:07
      For example, Petersburg, Lynchburg, for example, are in the same peer group.
    • 03:18:12
      Lynchburg has a union as the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company.
    • 03:18:15
      Petersburg is actually an operating enterprise division of the City of Petersburg.
    • 03:18:19
      So collective bargaining occurs in Lynchburg because it was actually part of the Lynchburg traction and bus company in the old days.
    • 03:18:26
      So when it was taken over by the city, it's actually like Greater Richmond Transit Company that's also unionized under UTU.
    • 03:18:32
      There's a labor differential there that has been in place since the inception of the bus company itself.
    • 03:18:39
      So what we try to do when we do the separation of peer grouping is that we base the sizing on expenditures, total budget expenditures, instead of fuel-inspired labor and administration, which we cover in the current model today.
    • 03:18:53
      So we're doing total system costs.
    • 03:18:55
      I want to be clear.
    • 03:19:00
      I'm applauding what you're doing.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:09
      I like the direction you're going in, but the devil's in the details.
    • 03:19:14
      And I don't think we ought to, at this body,
    • 03:19:18
      I like getting away from the cost side of the equation and going to performance metrics, and yet we keep getting dragged back into things that relate to cost.
    • 03:19:33
      Some cost is controllable, some cost isn't.
    • 03:19:37
      But notwithstanding that, I'm a performance-based guy.
    • 03:19:40
      So we're seeing the top of the model or parts of the top of the model.
    • 03:19:44
      It would be really nice to see the whole model as it exists today.
    • 03:19:49
      Obviously, it's for discussion and for amendment.
    • 03:19:54
      And as the Director pointed out, we can come back and amend it again.
    • 03:19:57
      But I need to see the rest of it.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:03
      I see that the performance-based allocation is very good.
    • 03:20:14
      It occurs to me that there's another element of performance that is not there that's the element of quality safety.
    • 03:20:26
      Is there any thought given to include a safety or quality performance in Turner and Patrick?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:33
      Yes, I don't think it was part of the discussion with the transit, with the advisory group.
    • 03:20:40
      They looked at these that were industry standards.
    • 03:20:43
      Is safety?
    • 03:20:44
      You would think safety is an industry standard.
    • 03:20:46
      You think it was?
    • 03:20:48
      Oh, Amy.
    • 03:20:58
      That those were more that people could agree around.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:03
      Okay, Mr. Rich.
    • 03:21:06
      Thank you Director Drake for this research and your staff too.
    • 03:21:11
      I think a laudable thing that I heard that you were going to try to coordinate transit policy with overall CTB policy and maybe even with the roads section.
    • 03:21:19
      You and I last week or last month talked about a problem whereby the MPOs will come to you with kind of a defective proposal and then you'll say no.
    • 03:21:31
      And then they'll come around and put it on our transfer sheet as a CMAQ project where it really isn't a viable project.
    • 03:21:43
      And then I think we need to try to resolve that.
    • 03:21:46
      I know Rita was talking to me about that as well, that we don't allow that end run for those types of projects that you have found really not acceptable.
    • 03:21:56
      Then they come around and take it out of the highway funds.
    • 03:21:59
      And I think we've looked at that with some of these proposals with alternative vehicles where the MPOs have done the same thing.
    • 03:22:08
      They have, and I'm all for alternative vehicles,
    • 03:22:11
      For the use of the general public fleets.
    • 03:22:14
      When they come around and try to use that money for their own private fleets, I think that's wrong.
    • 03:22:19
      They ought to pay for that out of their own budgets.
    • 03:22:22
      And Cord led a subcommittee on that.
    • 03:22:24
      And this came up last month, I think.
    • 03:22:27
      We have the authority to stop that.
    • 03:22:29
      And our policy right now, our policy right now is that we're going to grandfather this, as I understand it.
    • 03:22:37
      If it was already in the works, we'll let it go through.
    • 03:22:40
      But in the future, you've got to use for these fleets, you've got to make sure that they're for the general public and we're just not buying vehicles and trucks for various municipalities.
    • 03:22:56
      So I think that's good that you're trying to kind of make all this kind of work together.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:00
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:04
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:23:06
      Okay.
    • 03:23:09
      We now have the 460 project and we're supposed to start with Mr. Kilpatrick, but we will start.
    • 03:23:16
      We have a special guest, the Chairman of the 6320 Corporation.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:24
      And the King.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:26
      And McCain.
    • 03:23:27
      Oh, we do.
    • 03:23:28
      Wait, before you get into that, we want to hear about Neptune.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:32
      Come on up.
    • 03:23:33
      It's over with.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:35
      Why do you still have your beard?
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:36
      You're in shape.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:39
      Why aren't you in shape?
    • 03:23:42
      I have to go to Christmas for you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:43
      Can you tell the new members why you have a beard?
    • 03:23:46
      I'm going to take a few minutes.
    • 03:23:51
      I don't have it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:54
      Just take a few minutes and talk about
    • 03:23:56
      The 460 Project, what it means to our region and talk a little bit about how it fits into the transportation plan not only in Hampton Roads but in the state.
    • 03:24:08
      And also then spend a few minutes on structure because I know Charlie and his group are going to come up and go through a lot of the details.
    • 03:24:15
      But we do have some new members and I thought it would be appropriate, just take a few minutes to just give you a general overview.
    • 03:24:21
      First of all, this is a 55-mile project that goes from Norfolk
    • 03:24:26
      Northwest of Petersburg, not in the existing right-of-way of 460, but in the dedicated right-of-way that was come about 10 years ago.
    • 03:24:37
      The project was first started in 1994, believe it or not, so it's been on the books a long time.
    • 03:24:44
      Governor McDonald's administration came in, there was an independent review panel out, and the project was sort of bogged down.
    • 03:24:49
      That was stopped, and a new independent review panel was put in place, and it brings us to where we are today on that.
    • 03:24:59
      How it affects Hampton Roads and the state, first of all, you guys know Hampton Roads is the largest natural harbor in the world.
    • 03:25:07
      And as a result, much of our economy is based on the maritime interests.
    • 03:25:12
      The two largest employees are the Navy, Department of Defense, and of course then our port.
    • 03:25:18
      And both of those have had problems with the transportation woes in Hampton Roads.
    • 03:25:24
      In fact, the Navy has suggested to us
    • 03:25:26
      They will no longer bring any more assets to the area without us dealing with transportation.
    • 03:25:33
      And of course, we all know that we're going through an efficiency review at the port and how the infrastructure around other ports, particularly down in the Savannah area, have led to some of the issues we're dealing with here, not only in Hampton Roads, but the region.
    • 03:25:50
      Of course, both of those are not just economic generators in Hampton Roads.
    • 03:25:54
      Obviously, the Department of Defense,
    • 03:25:55
      with our ties with the Pentagon, enrolled in Virginia, back and forth and defense spending in the urban crescent areas through Richmond, and also with our port, one in eight jobs in the state is supported by the Port of Hampton, the Port of Virginia now.
    • 03:26:13
      where we not only have imports but exports and obviously the primary export is coal coming out of the southwest part of the state.
    • 03:26:20
      So this project is part of an effort to address some of those issues.
    • 03:26:27
      I'll remind the group that we've had two projects come before us that have started to look at this and the first one was the downtown midtown tunnel project.
    • 03:26:36
      It was the number one ranked project in Hampton Roads, the most heavily trafficked
    • 03:26:41
      Non-Interstate Road east of the Mississippi.
    • 03:26:44
      That project was put in place.
    • 03:26:47
      We put aside those monies last year and that should be going to construction hopefully sometime in the next 12 months.
    • 03:26:54
      The next project that was put in place was Dominion Boulevard where it's taking the truck traffic and going south out of the region.
    • 03:27:04
      And then the third part to this would be the 460 Project where it would be taking truck traffic not south but west out of the region as an alternative to Interstate 64.
    • 03:27:17
      The reason I mention all those is because they both, when you ask the question about transportation, are you trying to sell congestion or are you trying to sell the movement of goods and services?
    • 03:27:26
      And really what these projects are focused on is the movement of goods and services and our competitiveness not only in Hampton Roads but across the state.
    • 03:27:34
      The downtown-newtown tunnel allowed us to get trucks out of Hampton Roads from the port area.
    • 03:27:42
      Obviously, hopefully it will help congestion with our Navy traffic going through the various installations around South Hampton Roads.
    • 03:27:49
      Dominion Boulevard with the military installations south of it, and of course the southbound truck traffic.
    • 03:27:56
      And 460 is in that, but with one exception.
    • 03:27:59
      I think 460 is more of a potential.
    • 03:28:02
      It's more of an economic driver for us.
    • 03:28:04
      There are 21 distribution centers in the 460 corridor.
    • 03:28:08
      And what this road will allow us to do is to help that develop into an intermodal corridor where we're able to get the trucks out and hopefully make us more competitive in dealing with the opening of the Panama Canal and having that increased cargo come through our ports.
    • 03:28:26
      So that's a little bit about
    • 03:28:28
      The project, there'll be more details, but generally how it fits into the Hampton Roads area and to our transportation plan.
    • 03:28:35
      Just a few minutes about structure.
    • 03:28:37
      We had a conversation a little while ago talking about, we've had a lot of conversations about the shortage of money we have, not only for construction, but for the maintenance of our various facilities across the state.
    • 03:28:54
      But I'll remind everybody, when Governor McDonald came into office,
    • 03:28:57
      One of the things that he was committed to was the 460 Project.
    • 03:29:04
      In fact, a large part of his initiative was setting aside about 1.5 billion dollars for public-private partnerships.
    • 03:29:14
      and of course 460 was one of those.
    • 03:29:17
      Dominion, excuse me, the downtown midtown project was one and we put monies on that and of course the hot lanes in Northern Virginia was another and of course we're dealing with 460 and the Colesville project is in that batch of monies also.
    • 03:29:33
      So that's where these monies are coming from.
    • 03:29:35
      Now, one of the things that Governor McDonald did is he put more money in transportation than any governor in the last 20-some years.
    • 03:29:44
      So while we do have some long-term deficits to deal with, I know all across the state we're seeing transportation for maintenance and other construction projects going on.
    • 03:29:56
      We just had a report last month about how many roads are closed across the state because of all these projects.
    • 03:30:03
      One of the ways we've been able to leverage those funds
    • 03:30:05
      has been through the Public-Private Partnership Act.
    • 03:30:09
      In fact, led by Secretary Connaughton and Commissioner Whirley and the staff at VDOT, we've been able to take the money set aside for these large projects and leverage them.
    • 03:30:19
      First of all, downtown-midtown tunnel project, we put in roughly $400 million on a $2 billion project.
    • 03:30:26
      We were able to track the private investment and get that project done, a five-to-one leveraging of our money.
    • 03:30:31
      Dominion Boulevard, we've had the Virginia Transportation Infrastructure Bank where we were able to loan $150 million, a $450 million project.
    • 03:30:40
      We leveraged our monies three to one.
    • 03:30:42
      Both of those projects had historically good numbers for traffic counts.
    • 03:30:47
      So they were actually projects that should have been done years ago.
    • 03:30:50
      They were responding to a crisis.
    • 03:30:53
      460, on the other hand,
    • 03:30:54
      is taking the opportunity to look at our ability to become more successful in attracting business to the state and developing that quarter as I said before for our port and the opportunities that it has.
    • 03:31:08
      But it also does give us some relief from congestion and certainly gives us another alternative in case there was a major evacuation needed in the Hampton Roads area.
    • 03:31:20
      The good news about all those three projects, the PPTA, they're all entrepreneurial in nature.
    • 03:31:25
      All the ways we finance them have been a result of looking at what the projects needed and then able to put the monies on them through the governor's transportation plan and the work of the secretary and the commissioner.
    • 03:31:37
      One thing in common with all of those projects is that once our state investment is made, then we have no more obligations.
    • 03:31:45
      We will have the roads built, but we will have no more obligation for the state.
    • 03:31:49
      If in the event of a negative impact, we still have the road built.
    • 03:31:53
      So I think it's been a good leveraging of our monies.
    • 03:31:56
      And I'll leave it on this before I turn it over to Charlie.
    • 03:32:00
      There is a cost for doing nothing.
    • 03:32:02
      And we're experiencing that cost, I would say across the state, but certainly in Hampton Roads.
    • 03:32:07
      Again, our military has told us that if we don't do some things and they fully support this project,
    • 03:32:13
      that they're not going to continue to move assets into the region.
    • 03:32:16
      So there is a cost for doing nothing and I thank my fellow CTB members for all the support we've gotten on these other projects and look forward to answering your questions or anything about that after the presentation.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:28
      So thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 03:32:31
      Mr. Lane, thank you very much and thank you for all your work on this as well as taking on the chairmanship of the 6320.
    • 03:32:38
      Mr. Kilpatrick.
    • 03:32:41
      I'm trying to put our hands on the presentation.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:32:50
      Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
    • 03:33:01
      I'm here today to present the major business terms for the U.S. Route 460 Corridor Improvement Project.
    • 03:33:08
      My presentation today will be sort of a combination of a little bit of history, and we have a number of new board members here today, as well as discussing the business terms of this procurement and steps moving forward.
    • 03:33:26
      So again, where we are today, the technical proposals were received from the three offeror teams.
    • 03:33:32
      We had three teams competing for this project.
    • 03:33:35
      It was a competitively bid process.
    • 03:33:37
      All three teams met the requirements of the request for detailed proposals and passed the evaluation criteria.
    • 03:33:46
      And so the three teams are U.S. 460 Mobility Partners, previously known as Sentra, 460 Partners, and Multimodal Solutions.
    • 03:33:57
      All three of these teams were deemed to be responsive
    • 03:34:00
      and were evaluated past both the technical and the financial phases.
    • 03:34:04
      So we had, as we've gone through the proposals, we have three qualified bids and bidders.
    • 03:34:12
      And based on the evaluation criteria, which was the lowest public contribution to the project, US 460 Mobility Partners has been, is the successful offer.
    • 03:34:27
      So this gives you a high-level review of sort of the nuts and bolts of this project.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:35
      Mr. Chairman, I don't want to drive this out too long today, but going back to that previous point about the lowest amount of local contribution.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:34:47
      Public contribution, yes sir.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:48
      My understanding is that this was not the lowest bidder.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:34:53
      Is that correct?
    • 03:34:55
      As far as the design-build cost or as far as the total cost?
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:59
      As far as the total cost.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:35:01
      No, this bidder was the lowest total cost to the public.
    • 03:35:05
      In terms of, and again I will go through that step-by-step to show how the process evaluated the three teams to select the team with the lowest public contribution.
    • 03:35:19
      So I'll go through that Mr. Louderback.
    • Kevin B. PageChief Operating Officer
    • 03:35:21
      Okay, thank you.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:35:22
      So this is, again, fairly high level that goes through the process.
    • 03:35:27
      The 6320 Corporation, which is known as the Route 460 Corporation of Virginia, is going to commit financial close to finance the design and build finance project at a cost of $1.396 billion.
    • 03:35:41
      Now this is where the cascade of funds come from.
    • 03:35:46
      The Commonwealth will provide $1.18 billion
    • 03:35:50
      During the construction period, later on I will break that down even further.
    • 03:35:54
      The funding corporation will issue tax exempt bonds to be financed from project toll revenues to fund $216 million of project costs.
    • 03:36:05
      So that's, these are the, you take the 1.396 and you subtract $216 million and that gets you to the 1.18 and again I'm going to give more detail later on in the presentation.
    • 03:36:18
      We have also applied for
    • 03:36:20
      A TIFIA loan.
    • 03:36:21
      TIFIA is a federal loan through the Federal Highway Administration and the U.S. Department of Transportation.
    • 03:36:28
      It is a low-interest loan that we have used on a number of projects in Virginia, including the downtown-midtown tunnel.
    • 03:36:35
      We expect to close on the 95 Hot Lanes project by the end of this month.
    • 03:36:40
      The 495 project had a TIFIA loan.
    • 03:36:43
      Pocahontas Parkway had a TIFIA loan, and I may be forgetting one.
    • 03:36:48
      Those projects, again, the projects I've named and the P3 projects that we have done over the last several years have all been supported by TIFIA alone.
    • 03:36:58
      We expect to execute the comprehensive agreement by the end of this year and also go to financial close.
    • 03:37:04
      We will immediately go into the design, the right-of-way acquisition and permitting processes in 2013 and expect to begin construction in 2014.
    • 03:37:17
      This gives a little bit of a timeline.
    • 03:37:19
      As you can see, Mr. Layne mentioned this project was actually conceived back in the 90s on a number of long-range plans and studies.
    • 03:37:27
      The first request for solicitation was in 2006.
    • 03:37:31
      That particular solicitation was suspended in October 2009 and was reinitiated in May of 2010.
    • 03:37:39
      And since May of 2010, we have been going through a process of public meetings, reviews by the independent review panel, reviewing the offeror's initial proposals, now detailed proposals, and moving forward to the point we are today.
    • 03:37:57
      I wanted to note that in May of this year, we briefed the CTB on a different mechanism than we've been working in the past, this design-build-finance structure, and introduced the use of the 6320 Corporation as part of the process.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:38:19
      So this is a...
    • 03:38:24
      How has this been different though just from an outreach effort from the OTP3 regarding we published up front all the documents.
    • 03:38:35
      We have done an enormous amount of outreach.
    • 03:38:37
      Could we just make a comment on that?
    • 03:38:39
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:38:40
      One of the complaints we've had previously is that people didn't know what was in the comprehensive agreements.
    • 03:38:44
      All that has been on the website for how long?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:38:48
      The short answer is years.
    • 03:38:53
      We have been, as we have moved along in the process, the documents are posted, once they are reviewed and become public documents, they are posted, whether it's a proposal from an offeror or the draft of the comprehensive agreement that lays out the terms of the agreement, as drafts of the agreements are updated, those also are posted.
    • 03:39:17
      on the website and made available to the public.
    • 03:39:19
      So Mr. Secretary, as we have gone through this process, we've been very conscious of having that information available for public consumption and public review.
    • 03:39:30
      In addition to that, there have been a number of scheduled public meetings as well as outreach to the municipalities, whether it's a town or a county or a city along the route.
    • 03:39:42
      Different from other
    • 03:39:45
      P-3 projects, this was a competitively bid process.
    • 03:39:49
      So those documents, those contract documents both in the draft and the final form are visible for all to see as we're putting that procurement out.
    • 03:40:00
      And then it comes back as a, again, as the lowest public contribution is that common denominator that we select the team from.
    • 03:40:11
      And the FPOs have been briefed often?
    • 03:40:14
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:40:15
      We have two MPOs that are represented.
    • 03:40:18
      The Tri-Cities and the HRTPO represent the two ends of this project and then there's a Rural Planning District for a piece in the center.
    • 03:40:29
      A number of meetings, it is in both of their constrained long-range plans and we're continuing to move forward with updating those plans as we move to financial close.
    • 03:40:41
      So this is again a piece of background on the project.
    • 03:40:44
      It's approximately 55 miles long, four-lane divided, limited access highway between the city of Suffolk and Prince George County, Petersburg area at I-295.
    • 03:40:57
      Again, links to 58 on the 58 bypass on the east side and to 295 on the west end.
    • 03:41:07
      proposing seven interchanges in addition to the two endpoints, and these are the names of the routes that are the proposed interchange locations.
    • 03:41:17
      It will be designed for speed limits of at least 70 miles an hour, again, to the same standard that we can drive the interstate in Virginia today.
    • 03:41:28
      So this lists some of the critical needs of the project.
    • 03:41:31
      We've talked before, and Mr. Layne spoke about safety in reducing the vehicle conflicts with local traffic and heavy truck traffic and providing an alternative to other, going through the small towns along the 460 corridor.
    • 03:41:48
      For those that are not familiar with 460 today, it's a four-lane road, undivided,
    • 03:41:53
      With the number of small towns along its length, the speed limit varies between 25 and 55 miles an hour, and you will travel some distance at high speed and come upon a small town fairly rapidly.
    • 03:42:07
      For those that are, again, have not traveled this route, US 1 through Virginia, very similar design road, lot of rolling terrain, limited site distance, and limited lane with limited shoulders, and so on.
    • 03:42:22
      Providing hurricane evacuation capability.
    • 03:42:26
      The existing 460 does flood, especially the Blackwater River.
    • 03:42:30
      It's had a history of flooding in a number of tropical events and other storms.
    • 03:42:36
      So this provides a clear and clean means of egress from Hampton Roads without relying on either of the harbor tunnels.
    • 03:42:47
      It accommodates a freight movement, and we spoke some earlier about that or heard about
    • 03:42:51
      The importance of the Port of Virginia and the ability to have an alternative access to the Port of Virginia.
    • 03:42:57
      460 parallels the Norfolk Southern line.
    • 03:43:00
      It's in close proximity to a CSX line.
    • 03:43:03
      So those, it's served, this region is served by the two major railroads.
    • 03:43:09
      And again, it provides opportunities to move port traffic out of Hampton Roads, again, without the use of HRVT or Monitor Marymount Bridge Tunnel.
    • 03:43:20
      Improves military strategic connectivity.
    • 03:43:22
      Again, the Department of Defense has concerns about having essentially a single access to the largest naval base in the world, as well as large Air Force bases.
    • 03:43:32
      All branches of the service have large presence in Hampton Roads.
    • 03:43:37
      This provides another connection and actually provides excellent connectivity to the Fort Lee area, which is one of their military's logistics centers.
    • 03:43:48
      Supporting economic development, it creates an opportunity for jobs and economic development over the short and long term in an area that has high unemployment and underemployment rates.
    • 03:43:59
      It's a tremendous opportunity there.
    • 03:44:01
      And again, what's not highlighted here, but should not be forgotten, this provides a high standard, high quality, high speed facility linking the Hampton Roads region with the rest of Virginia.
    • 03:44:17
      So to talk about the term of the contract and the parties in the contract, there's three parties that will execute the comprehensive agreement, the Virginia Department of Transportation, the Route 460 Funding Corporation of Virginia, again, that is the 6320 Corporation, and the design-build contractor, Ferrovial Agramon and American Infrastructure, that is their joint venture.
    • 03:44:42
      The term is up to 40 years from financial close, including five years for construction.
    • 03:44:47
      And what that means is the 40 years is the term of the bonds.
    • 03:44:52
      So when the bonds are retired, the term of the contract is up.
    • 03:44:59
      And so when it says up to 40, there are provisions for being able to retire those bonds earlier.
    • 03:45:06
      I won't go into a lot of detail.
    • 03:45:07
      There's lots of intricacies in paying off debt early.
    • 03:45:12
      But again, that's why it says up to 40 years.
    • 03:45:15
      The cost of the project is a fixed-price design-build contract, again, of $1.369 billion.
    • 03:45:25
      Some other aspects of the project.
    • 03:45:26
      An important aspect was the toll rate.
    • 03:45:29
      In the original procurement, toll rates as high as 14 cents a mile for vehicles was being considered in order to support the project.
    • 03:45:39
      We are, as part of the contract, the initial toll rate will be
    • 03:45:43
      $1.067 or 6.7 cents per mile.
    • 03:45:48
      So if you travel the entire length in a car in 2018, you would pay $3.69.
    • 03:45:54
      The rate per truck is three times, or again, $11.72 to travel the full 55 mile.
    • 03:46:02
      Again, if you look back at the earlier procurement, at 14 cents a mile, the toll rates were more than double.
    • 03:46:11
      So we have set, we, the Commonwealth of Virginia, VDOT has set the toll rate at this rate which we believe is somewhat less than what we could have gotten to optimize the toll rate.
    • 03:46:24
      We thought it's very important to make this project a project that will draw traffic,
    • 03:46:30
      and we'll again draw business to move people to and from the Hampton Road area.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:37
      I have a quick question about that.
    • 03:46:39
      Don't we have a parallel road that will not be toll?
    • 03:46:43
      How are you going to get people on a toll road and when there's a free road right next to them?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:46:48
      He's getting there.
    • 03:46:50
      A couple of things.
    • 03:46:50
      Very simply, I'd made mention that the road existing 460 posted speed limit is between 25 and 55 miles an hour.
    • 03:47:01
      And so what you have is you have a series of stoplights.
    • 03:47:03
      You have kind of stop-and-go conditions as you travel down through there.
    • 03:47:08
      This facility, again, as an interstate standard roadway, will move traffic without any fear of slowdowns.
    • 03:47:17
      It's likely the distribution centers will focus their
    • 03:47:21
      There are access routes to this facility and not towards 460.
    • 03:47:25
      I'm not talking about the existing, but I'm talking about new facilities.
    • 03:47:29
      And again, I think it goes to the reliability of travel, Mr. Rich.
    • 03:47:33
      You'll be able to travel at high speed, uninterrupted.
    • 03:47:37
      It will be an open road tolling project.
    • 03:47:40
      So you get off at 295 and you get off at 58 and
    • 03:47:47
      Shouldn't have to apply the brakes through that entire trip.
    • 03:47:55
      During the original environmental process and the environmental document there were three alignments considered.
    • 03:48:02
      An alignment north
    • 03:48:04
      If you look to widening the existing 460 as I mentioned
    • 03:48:28
      There are six or eight towns along that path.
    • 03:48:32
      So then you have to reach a decision point.
    • 03:48:34
      You either essentially eliminate the town because of the impact of building a modern facility straight through town or you build bypasses.
    • 03:48:46
      In addition, the existing route is not access control.
    • 03:48:50
      There is really no access control at all.
    • 03:48:52
      What I mean by that, you can have entrances,
    • 03:48:55
      As close together as you can fit them, except today under our permit requirements we have some spacing limitations, but this road has been there since probably the 20s.
    • 03:49:06
      You have entrances everywhere, you have houses everywhere, and so what you would need to do then is build an additional road to provide for your local traffic so that you didn't mix the local again with the high speed traffic.
    • 03:49:20
      That's a fundamentally difficult thing to do to create a high-speed roadway and still allow kind of that local driveway access because all the conflicts that that creates.
    • 03:49:35
      So yes sir, it was considered and deemed that that was not the avenue that would provide the facility that we needed for the future.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:49:43
      Which proposal would be cheaper?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:49:47
      Mr. Rich, I wasn't here during the environmental process, but I don't remember, in looking at historic data, the all-in costs of widening on the existing alignment.
    • 03:49:57
      I don't recall that being less expensive than building it on new alignment.
    • 03:50:03
      Again, there's a lot of collateral work that has to be done.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:08
      So we should have that number, should we?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:50:10
      Mr. Rich, during the environmental document, there were
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:14
      One of the attributes of the current 460 dimension is that it may be the most heavily policed roadway in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:50:35
      Yes, sir, it is, in a fairly high accident frequency.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:40
      So, I want to speak now to regarding the toll commencement.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:50:47
      The road will open in 2018, so that's five years from now.
    • 03:50:54
      When it opens, the toll rate again, I've already described the toll rate, it will escalate at three and a half percent per year.
    • 03:51:02
      The next line, toll rate covenant test, what this is, this is a protection in the event that the toll revenue is insufficient to meet debt.
    • 03:51:13
      Now there's a whole series of what I'll call backstops, including the VTIB loan that is in place, the line of credit on this project that is backstopped against toll revenues coming in less than projected, and there are other protections in place.
    • 03:51:30
      But again, this is a provision that allows for the 6320 Corporation to increase the toll rate if they're not meeting debt service.
    • 03:51:39
      And again, that will be based on an independent traffic and revenue study because the other part of that is if you increase the toll rate, you may have a tendency to drive users away.
    • 03:51:53
      So that's a very careful process that's done.
    • 03:51:56
      This is a very unlikely scenario.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:00
      So, Charlie, when I read this in this slide, because I understood differently, where you say the annual toll rate increase will be 3.5%, that's not what you're really saying.
    • 03:52:12
      You're saying it could be up to 3.5, is that correct?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:52:15
      No, I think that the toll rate, the toll rate escalation, the planned toll rate escalation is 3.5%.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:22
      But if revenues were higher,
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:52:24
      And that's the third test.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:26
      The revenues were higher.
    • 03:52:28
      The total rate doesn't need to be 3.5% than it wouldn't be.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:52:32
      That is correct.
    • 03:52:33
      That is correct.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:34
      So it's not will be.
    • 03:52:35
      It's projected to be.
    • 03:52:37
      It couldn't be more than that.
    • 03:52:38
      Could it be more than that?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:52:40
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:52:41
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:52:42
      But I think that's an excellent point to make.
    • 03:52:44
      So I've described what the escalation of 3.5%.
    • 03:52:48
      If revenue
    • 03:52:51
      does not come in to support the retiring of the debt.
    • 03:52:56
      That is a provision that allows the toll rate to increase.
    • 03:53:01
      If the project outperforms the projected revenue and it's the base case over a three-year period, if it's consistently above, then the toll rate may be held constant.
    • 03:53:18
      And so with the 6320 Corporation, their role is to manage the debt of this project.
    • 03:53:26
      And so that is where they would say, wait a minute, our revenues are coming in above projection consistently.
    • 03:53:34
      We do not have to increase the toll rate by 3.5%.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:38
      And the recourse, I think it's important, and I don't think it's in the printed piece of your PowerPoint, the recourse
    • 03:53:47
      For not being able to satisfy the bonds is totally to the 6320.
    • 03:53:52
      That is correct.
    • 03:53:55
      So there's no recourse to the Commonwealth.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:53:58
      That is correct.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:58
      Or anybody other than 6320.
    • 03:54:00
      So at the end of the day,
    • 03:54:03
      Aubrey's got to pay the bill if it doesn't come in, right Aubrey?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:06
      That's pretty much it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:08
      You're right.
    • 03:54:09
      That's what I said.
    • 03:54:09
      There's no more contribution required from the state.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:12
      Mr. Chairman, I've got a question.
    • 03:54:15
      How can we say that the Commonwealth has 1.8 billion in this?
    • 03:54:21
      It's going to build the road anyway.
    • 03:54:23
      What if the road's halfway done?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:26
      We've got performance contracts.
    • 03:54:29
      We have insurance contracts, performance contracts.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:54:32
      Mr. Rich, the tolling will not commence until the road is complete, so it won't be open in phases.
    • 03:54:39
      During the construction period of, again, from today to five years from today when the road will open, the funding for that, the bonds will be sold, and the public contribution will be made, the contractor will make draws against that as they move forward.
    • 03:54:57
      As with any of our contracts, we have performance security to ensure that if a contractor is unable to perform or defaults on their project, we can call on their surety to complete the project.
    • 03:55:11
      And this project, like all of our projects, we don't pay the contractor up front, we pay as work goes for certain phases of work.
    • 03:55:21
      So in other words,
    • 03:55:22
      You haven't, the state hasn't laid out that entire amount of money and then the contractor may not be able to complete the work.
    • 03:55:31
      So it's paid as it goes.
    • 03:55:33
      There's a security in place.
    • 03:55:35
      If this contractor, any contractor on our contract defaults,
    • 03:55:40
      We first have, we have two things.
    • 03:55:42
      We first of all have that amount of work that's been done and typically they have done more work than we've paid them for because we do pay in arrears.
    • 03:55:50
      Again, you have to complete the work that gets accepted and then we pay for it.
    • 03:55:54
      And then we also have performance.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:55:56
      What backs up the bond?
    • 03:55:57
      I mean, who's gonna buy this bond?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:56:00
      And what rate?
    • 03:56:01
      The toll revenue.
    • 03:56:02
      The toll revenue is what backs up the bond.
    • 03:56:06
      As I spoke before,
    • 03:56:08
      The VTIB loan provides a line of credit that backstops the revenue in case of a shortfall.
    • 03:56:15
      So there's that $80 million in line of credit that could be called on should the revenue come short.
    • 03:56:22
      So there are a number of backstops.
    • 03:56:25
      The backstop I just mentioned here about being able to increase the toll rate.
    • 03:56:30
      That's another backstop.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:56:31
      But you can't always increase that.
    • 03:56:32
      There's a point where people are not going to pay that.
    • 03:56:35
      So what happens, I mean, if I'm going to go out and buy a bond,
    • 03:56:39
      You know, what would this be rated at?
    • 03:56:42
      I mean, I don't see total safety here if I'm a bond buyer.
    • 03:56:47
      I mean, what would this be?
    • 03:56:48
      I mean, what would be the bond rating on this kind of thing?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:56:54
      I think if we go through the presentation, a lot of these questions will be answered.
    • 03:56:58
      Okay.
    • 03:56:59
      And we do have indicative ratings from the rating agencies on these bonds.
    • 03:57:05
      So if you go through that, I think you'll start seeing more of the answers.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:12
      Just one quick thing while we're on this, Charlie.
    • 03:57:17
      You mentioned that if it outperforms, then you could hold it steady, but on the other hand, if you would, is it possible to use the total increase to pay off the bond earlier because you made some point about that earlier?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:57:33
      The answer to that is yes.
    • 03:57:35
      There are
    • 03:57:35
      The bonds will have certain call provisions, and if a bond is, certain types of bonds are called too quickly, the penalty or the call provision is fairly large.
    • 03:57:48
      To answer your question, yes.
    • 03:57:51
      Revenues greater than anticipated could be applied to reduce the debt.
    • 03:57:58
      Yes, sir?
    • 03:57:59
      As I mentioned earlier, this is an open road toll facility using the EZ-Path system and license plate detection.
    • 03:58:06
      And one of the comments that Mr. Rich, I believe, has made previously, as well as the Secretary, is there some manual ability that is not currently programmed here, but again, this road will open for tolling in five years.
    • 03:58:20
      The technology will exist five years from today in the tolling world.
    • 03:58:25
      We frankly don't know what that looks like.
    • 03:58:27
      and may well be the ability to do some sort of one-trip pay somehow to go offline from the facility to do that.
    • 03:58:36
      Again, it's something that we're conscious of.
    • 03:58:41
      Because of the nature of this project, there could be areas to do that where at other facilities, the hot lanes, the downtown midtown tunnel, the physical constraints made it difficult to put kind of a pull off.
    • 03:58:54
      So again, I wanted you to know that we're continuing to evaluate that as we move forward.
    • 03:58:59
      And in tolling world, five years is a long time.
    • 03:59:02
      That technology, we expect to change considerably.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:06
      Mr. Kilpatrick, it would be fair to say that the revenue estimates that you used for the debt service covenants are also conservative enough to provide yet another backstop.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:59:25
      Absolutely, and I think that again in this slide I can talk a little bit more to that question and it may help answer Mr. Rich's question also about
    • 03:59:35
      The conservative nature of the debt that will be raised.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:41
      Who's responsible for the tolling operation?
    • 03:59:45
      Is it the private partner or is it the state?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:59:48
      The 6320 Corporation will be responsible for the tolling operation, for the insuring of the collection of the tolls.
    • 03:59:57
      The operation of the facility, the maintenance of the facility, Commonwealth of Virginia will continue to own and operate the facility.
    • 04:00:05
      We will operate it under contract with 6320 Corporation.
    • 04:00:11
      It's unlikely you're going to see VDOT trucks doing the maintenance.
    • 04:00:16
      It will be similar to our other interstates where in most cases they're maintained by contractors either as a package or as pieces.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:24
      I'm more considering the operation of the state, the operation of the toll line.
    • 04:00:30
      Kind of the back office toll line.
    • 04:00:31
      We have all read about
    • 04:00:32
      If you ask people on American, because their inability to collect tolls that are not just handling the normal license plate anyway, have we made, probably to early make plans, but have we thought about, for example, especially if someone's using license plate recognition, conditions in an easy path, how to go about getting paid for what they're supposed to be getting paid.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:01:00
      That will be part of the development of that package.
    • 04:01:07
      We have a lot of experience in Virginia, the easy pass, the transponders, and a lot of that back office is actually handled by VDOT now.
    • 04:01:16
      and would continue to be that easy pass collection process is done to a contractor that works for VDOT.
    • 04:01:26
      The license plate selection part is part that working with a vendor that will, again, in support of the 6320 Corporation, we will, VDOT will manage that contractor for the 6320, but it will be a contractor of the 6320 that will collect that, but we will manage them.
    • 04:01:46
      This slide gives a summary of how you get the $1.396 billion.
    • 04:01:53
      It also has the far right column that talks about the potential of a TIFIA loan.
    • 04:02:00
      So again, if I can go through the first column by the financial model without TIFIA, as I mentioned before, the
    • 04:02:08
      The public contribution of 1.18 is made up in two parts.
    • 04:02:12
      $930 million in what we are calling VDOT public funding and $250 million from VPA, Virginia Court Authority, in public funding.
    • 04:02:24
      The net private sector tax exempt bond value is $216 million.
    • 04:02:31
      Zero dollars in TIFI alone and you can see the map cascades and that gives you the total of 1.396
    • 04:02:38
      I'm sorry, it says million.
    • 04:02:41
      Well, it's 1.396 billion dollars for the project.
    • 04:02:49
      If I could go to the third line about the tax-exempt bonds.
    • 04:02:53
      Part of the requirement, and this to Mr. Louderback also, the offer team was based on design-build costs,
    • 04:03:02
      Subtracting out the debt that they could commit to, and we have security for that too.
    • 04:03:11
      In other words, it wasn't simply, oh, we think we can raise a particular amount in order to win the bid.
    • 04:03:17
      There's some very tight constraints on the requirements of the committed debt that they could raise.
    • 04:03:24
      And so you take the design-build cost, you subtract the committed debt, and then you get the public contributions.
    • 04:03:30
      And so the team with the lowest public contribution is the team that is selected.
    • 04:03:37
      In talking about the debt itself, the debt is based on an investment grade traffic and revenue study that we produced, that the department produced as part of the procurement.
    • 04:03:48
      All three teams received this traffic and revenue study.
    • 04:03:52
      They were required to go to at least two rating agencies.
    • 04:03:55
      to get bond ratings for this project.
    • 04:04:02
      The traffic and revenue study that we generated was frankly a conservative study to begin with.
    • 04:04:09
      In addition to that, the rating agencies took an additional reduction in the value of that revenue in terms of 20 to 30% reduction off of what was projected off the study.
    • 04:04:23
      So you have a conservative study,
    • 04:04:25
      They've given that study a 20-30% haircut as a basis for establishing the bond value.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:04:32
      What is the reason for that haircut?
    • 04:04:34
      If we were conservatives, I can see if a bond rating does it because they thought we were overly optimistic and so they back out a number because they're accounting for it.
    • 04:04:42
      But if we're conservative, what is their justification for saying, thanks for being conservative, now we're going to be more conservative?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:04:50
      Well, I'm way out of my league talking about how rating agencies decide.
    • 04:04:56
      Except to tell you that that was not unanticipated, that in today's market they would do that.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:05:02
      Then why didn't we go more robust knowing they would back us to our, what we would consider a conservative party?
    • 04:05:10
      Cavalry's coming.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:05:13
      Declan McManus from KPMG Financial Advisor to Commonwealth on this project.
    • 04:05:26
      Declan McManus from KPMG Financial Advisor to the Commonwealth.
    • 04:05:30
      It is very much a standard practice in working with the rating agencies for them to apply anywhere from a 20% to a 40% haircut on traffic and revenue estimates.
    • 04:05:42
      So this was certainly not unexpected.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:05:46
      But my question is why were we so conservative if we knew they would do that to get us even more conservative to put it simplistically?
    • 04:05:54
      Why didn't we just go with a, we'll call it a non-conservative.
    • 04:05:58
      I'm not saying a liberal number, but yeah.
    • 04:06:01
      And then just let them then do their 20% definite.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:06:04
      We allowed for the bidders to go away and maximise what they could do each with the traffic and revenue study that they were provided.
    • 04:06:16
      So we allowed for the competition between the three bidders for them to work hard with the rating agencies to get the best deal that they possibly could and the results are frankly, yes I think we all agree that they are conservative but it's a prudent approach.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:06:34
      Mr. Chairman?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:06:37
      So we're talking about investment grade rates.
    • 04:06:40
      This is not a junk bond.
    • 04:06:41
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:06:42
      Yeah, the indicative writing letters from all three bid is provided in investment grade.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:06:47
      Okay, thank you.
    • 04:06:48
      I don't see any skin in the game from the private sector at all.
    • 04:06:53
      This is not a PPPA, right?
    • 04:06:55
      We don't have the private sector really putting anything in this game.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:07:00
      You are correct that there is no equity.
    • 04:07:02
      There is no equity contribution to this project.
    • 04:07:06
      One of the fundamental differences, though, without equity, there is no upside to, as we've talked about, we believe, our conservative revenue estimates.
    • 04:07:17
      There's a number of things, if revenue is above the estimates, again, it can reduce the acceleration of the tolls.
    • 04:07:23
      We believe that in gross dollar values over $600 million in excess revenue will be generated from this project over the 40-year term.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:07:36
      Why didn't we try to get the private sector?
    • 04:07:38
      Would nobody touch this or what?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:07:40
      It's too risky?
    • 04:07:42
      This is a Greenfield project.
    • 04:07:44
      Too risky?
    • 04:07:45
      This is a Greenfield project that
    • 04:07:47
      Mr. Richards, as we started this procurement, the first procurement and then began the second, it was going to be a 99-year concession where they would fully own and operate the facility.
    • 04:07:59
      What we found that because it was a Greenfield project and the uncertainty of the traffic and revenue, two things were happening.
    • 04:08:08
      The toll rate was as much as 14 cents a mile and the amount of debt that they could raise
    • 04:08:15
      was fairly small.
    • 04:08:16
      And so what it was doing is it was creating a large public contribution over an extremely long term, 99 years, where the department was, the Commonwealth of Virginia was getting no upside or very limited upside to the project.
    • 04:08:31
      The way we have framed this today, there is no equity, so there is no
    • 04:08:37
      rate of return other than what would be a normal overhead and profit that any contractor would get in a competitively contracted situation.
    • 04:08:49
      So that's the profit that would go to the private sector, simply however they built into their competitive bid, their profit margin, and their overhead component.
    • 04:08:59
      We will receive the benefit of revenue in excess of what's required to de-fees the debt.
    • 04:09:06
      And at the end of 40 years, it's the Commonwealth of Virginia's facility.
    • 04:09:12
      Any toll collection that continues from that point on, 100% of that revenue comes to the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:09:18
      But in the past, we were trying to leverage the private sector.
    • 04:09:21
      So we'd have more dollars to go around, but that just isn't going to work in this case.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:09:27
      Well, again, what happened is it became a project.
    • 04:09:30
      The amount of public contribution became so large for the equity that they could put into the deal.
    • 04:09:38
      It just got it so far out of balance.
    • 04:09:40
      Again, because of the size of the project and because it being a new facility, a greenfield facility, where the toll revenue had less certainty than say
    • 04:09:51
      Thelma, 95 or the downtown Midtown Sun or one of our other told facilities.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:09:57
      The private sector is just not going to risk it.
    • 04:09:59
      Why did we use the Spanish entity for the financing?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:10:04
      There were three firms or three teams that were proposer teams.
    • 04:10:11
      which, Centro Ferrovial American Infrastructure, was one of the teams.
    • 04:10:16
      And so that team came in with the lowest public contribution of the three teams that competed.
    • 04:10:23
      And so that was the team that was selected.
    • 04:10:25
      Again, as we talked earlier, they've gone to the rating houses in New York and gotten indicative ratings from, they were required to take the lower of two ratings, is that correct?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:10:37
      They had to have two and they had to take the lower of the two?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:10:41
      They had to have two investment grade ratings as part of this.
    • 04:10:45
      So that was part of what we were requiring them to do to establish that they could in fact raise the debt.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:10:55
      In terms of the companies, we did an extensive vetting of all the companies.
    • 04:11:00
      We were very comfortable with the members on the team that they could perform these jobs.
    • 04:11:06
      So we were very comfortable with the team members.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:11:11
      Also, I just want to make a comment.
    • 04:11:14
      Mr. Kilpatrick is going to get to this in a moment, but the big driver in this project is
    • 04:11:24
      to provide an attractive alternative to 64.
    • 04:11:30
      I think as everyone knows if you're trying to go into Hampton Roads most people coming from the western or northern parts of the state take 64 and obviously we have major problems on 64 both on
    • 04:11:48
      The sections from Newport News to 295, as well as then getting to the bridge tunnels.
    • 04:11:56
      The cost of those, and Mr. Kilpatrick will show you, the cost of actually doing anything to make improvements on 264 are just
    • 04:12:07
      Beyond anything we'll be capable of for some time.
    • 04:12:13
      So when the original P3 proposals came forward and we saw the total amount that would have to do to the risk, people would not take this road, truckers would not take this road.
    • 04:12:26
      And so we can
    • 04:12:30
      pursue this project that will provide that relief because people, I think many people will pay 360 to avoid the uncertainty of what your trip will be down 295.
    • 04:12:45
      and I'm going down to 64.
    • 04:12:49
      And truckers, I think the same thing.
    • 04:12:50
      I think when you look at the cost now, it will become, I'll call it an attractive nuisance.
    • 04:12:55
      It will become something that people will use because they know that the time period that they get on it, the time period they get off of it is going to be very, very consistent.
    • 04:13:05
      Whereas taking 64, you just don't know what you're going to hit when you go down that road.
    • 04:13:13
      So a big driver of this was
    • 04:13:15
      We started down the traditional P3 route, and we saw where the costs were, the public involvement, essentially public participation would be, and then the total amount.
    • 04:13:29
      We did not get to our end goal of making this an attractive alternative to 64.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:36
      Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:37
      Yes.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:37
      Can I pile on a minute?
    • 04:13:40
      Yes, sir.
    • 04:13:40
      Could you get back to slide four, please?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:44
      And you'll see there's another slide, 14, that's pretty good.
    • 04:13:48
      It illustrates some of this, but particularly for the new numbers.
    • 04:13:52
      If you sort of look at Hampton Roads, we often describe ourself as a cul-de-sac.
    • 04:13:58
      And all you have to do is look at 64 in the ring around Hampton Roads and understand that 58 is not a limited access.
    • 04:14:08
      It goes through bunches of towns.
    • 04:14:10
      If you look at current 460,
    • 04:14:13
      It's a nice little rural road that does get up to 55, but there's Ivor, Zuni, Wakefield, Waverly, Disputana, and there's one other I think I forgot.
    • 04:14:25
      Windsor.
    • 04:14:27
      And it's a place where you drive 55 when it says 55 because if you don't,
    • 04:14:32
      You're going to contribute to the local economy.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:36
      Well, soon you're driving 55 when they drop it to 35.
    • 04:14:38
      Yeah, that's what it gets you.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:42
      So the reality is, the second largest economic engine in the state, and the only way to functionally get to 95 north, easily, or limited access, or to 85 south or to 95 south is to go up
    • 04:15:03
      He's either go through a rural road with lots of little towns or you go 64 and you take your chances and you got to go across the bridge tunnel.
    • 04:15:11
      It's usually okay up until about Jefferson Avenue where the airport is and then you're slammed back down to two lanes to try to get out.
    • 04:15:21
      And the Defense Department, particularly the Navy, has been extremely clear that they're not building anymore, they're not bringing anymore an offer for that area until we do something to fix it.
    • 04:15:34
      The port, we just invested a bunch of money in the midtown-downtown tunnel to try to get out of the port over to this area.
    • 04:15:42
      But even when you get over to this area, the only place you can go now, limited access, is on that roundabout and cross over another bridge tunnel and get back to 64 and you're slammed again.
    • 04:15:53
      So this is, and not to talk about hurricane preparedness and so forth, and the economic development potential by giving us another
    • 04:16:02
      real exit out of our cul-de-sac is huge.
    • 04:16:07
      So the Navy's been clear.
    • 04:16:08
      The port has struggled with access.
    • 04:16:13
      Hurricane is sort of tertiary on my list.
    • 04:16:16
      It's important, but hopefully that's not gonna come to pass.
    • 04:16:20
      But without that, we're stuck with a very congested one way out.
    • 04:16:24
      And even if we were able to, and the numbers are gonna show this in a few slides,
    • 04:16:29
      Even if you subscribe to the concept that we ought to just expand 64, which I don't subscribe to because I don't believe in one option.
    • 04:16:39
      One option, if you make it six lanes and you have an accident, your option's at zero.
    • 04:16:45
      It doesn't matter whether it's six lanes or four lanes or how big that tube is, when you have an accident and it's shut down.
    • 04:16:52
      I came home the other night from Northern Virginia from Washington on Sunday night,
    • 04:16:58
      It was about 9, 9.30 and we were doing some construction.
    • 04:17:04
      It was a 45-minute delay.
    • 04:17:06
      It's Sunday night at 9.30, 45 minutes for some construction.
    • 04:17:11
      So that's what we're living every day in Hampton Roads and this gives us a real option, and you'll see in a slide a little later in the presentation,
    • 04:17:22
      Sort of divvying up the numbers in terms of minutes, how long each would take.
    • 04:17:27
      But it's a real option.
    • 04:17:29
      People take it now.
    • 04:17:31
      Okay, they take it now.
    • 04:17:32
      But it's not as easy because you've got seven towns to go through and you're up and down.
    • 04:17:36
      And certainly Mr. Cole will tell us that his truckers, you know, it's a whole different deal than when I'm in my little zippy car.
    • 04:17:44
      If you're in an 18-wheel truck, gear down and gear up and gear down and gear up.
    • 04:17:49
      So, we're in a hell of a fix there.
    • 04:17:52
      We've got a cul-de-sac, and this is one way, and it gets us to 95 South, it gets us to 95 North, it gets us to 64 West, and it gets us to 85 South.
    • 04:18:03
      And nothing else does that.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:04
      Was there any thought of rail?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:07
      Yeah, but I don't, I don't, my car doesn't ride on the rail.
    • 04:18:10
      70% of all traffic out of the truck, out of Portis Truck.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:14
      We've made significant improvements.
    • 04:18:16
      We've invested in the rail for double, for help with the passenger rail.
    • 04:18:20
      There are rail improvements.
    • 04:18:22
      Could you just go with us?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:18:22
      We're already, yes sir, along your, or right on the 14th.
    • 04:18:27
      Go to 14.
    • 04:18:28
      Let me say one last thing, Mr. Rich.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:34
      I hear you, and we've had lots of conversation about it.
    • 04:18:37
      There's 1.3 million people.
    • 04:18:40
      They don't ride on the ramp, including the Navy.
    • 04:18:44
      No, they can't, including the Navy.
    • 04:18:47
      And we've got to be able to get them in and get them out and keep the commerce flowing, which when we went up to the inland port a couple of weeks ago, a month ago,
    • 04:18:59
      The economic corridor from Hampton Roads to Northern Virginia is producing the vast majority of the GDP, 80% of GDP of the Commonwealth.
    • 04:19:14
      And we just found out, was it three weeks ago, we were downgraded from the best or second best business state to do business in America down a few levels and what did they cite?
    • 04:19:27
      Congestion,
    • 04:19:29
      and Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia.
    • 04:19:32
      So we're either going to fix the problem or what's going to happen is that roof is going to continue to leak and the second floor is going to go, then the first floor is going to go, and then we won't have the engine to drive the economy of the Commonwealth.
    • 04:19:45
      So I look upon it as something, you know, I sort of came late to the party on this project a little bit.
    • 04:19:51
      I didn't like some of it to start with.
    • 04:19:53
      The toll is reasonable.
    • 04:19:55
      It gives us a critically needed second
    • 04:19:58
      And the Navy, the Department of Defense has been clear
    • 04:20:06
      And we know our port needs it, so for me, I just got to sort of suck it up and do it.
    • 04:20:11
      I'm not a toll guy, you know that, but it's the only way to get it done and it's the best way to get it done.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:16
      But you saw how the Inland Port in Front Royal took all that traffic off of 66 and 395 because we put the freight on rails.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:24
      Well, I understand that, but if you go talk to the people in the port, we're doing as much of that as we can when we continue to do that.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:20:31
      This slide demonstrates the miles and travel time on what we consider the two options.
    • 04:20:51
      We use the center of Richmond as the starting point and the center of Norfolk as the end point.
    • 04:20:56
      It's 94 miles, taking I-64, and again, we didn't break down which tube you go through, but going through one of the tunnels, either Monitor, Merrimack, or HRVT, versus traveling 295 down to 460, and on it, the answer is 102 miles.
    • 04:21:13
      You look at the travel times of today, and these are assuming traveling at the posted speed, which is... Why did you look at me when you said that?
    • 04:21:25
      So today it's an hour and 43 minutes, assuming you have no delays.
    • 04:21:31
      And U.S. Route 460 is two hours and five minutes.
    • 04:21:35
      So about 20 minutes longer today, taking 460.
    • 04:21:39
      With the completion of this project, we're shaving up again that 20 minutes off travel time and expect the travel time from essentially here to downtown Norfolk will be the same.
    • 04:21:50
      Again, the big assumption here is absent traffic.
    • 04:21:55
      And I think we all know the impacts of traffic on I-64, especially the area between Williamsburg, all the way down and through the tunnels, and even on the south side on I-64, and even getting into as you approach downtown Norfolk.
    • 04:22:11
      So again, we talk about another reliable path, same travel time, but a more reliable travel time using this route.
    • 04:22:23
      A significantly more reliable travel time than traveling down the peninsula through the HRVT or the Monitor Merrimack.
    • 04:22:32
      So the question has come up, why build 460, why not improve I-64?
    • 04:22:45
      Again, these numbers are, these are planning-level numbers.
    • 04:22:49
      You should look at one of two options.
    • 04:22:50
      Either you improve I-64 to six lanes from Richmond to Hampton.
    • 04:22:54
      Again, today it's four lanes.
    • 04:22:56
      So you have additional lane in each direction, and you improve either the HRBT, and the current proposal is to go from four lanes to eight lanes, or you build the Patriots Crossing Project, which is another tunnel across the mouth of the Elizabeth River, ties into Monitor Merrimack and up the peninsula.
    • 04:23:15
      Again, both those scenarios, the rough cost is between $9.5 and $10.5 billion with a B.
    • 04:23:23
      This project is at $1.396 billion.
    • 04:23:27
      So again, to give you sort of an idea of do you put all your effort in I-64, this is the type of money that you would be looking at in order to build those facilities.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:23:45
      There's a residual, too, though, right?
    • 04:23:50
      I think we've talked about in the past the economic development opportunities along the new corridor, which are kind of a bonus.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:23:59
      Absolutely.
    • 04:24:00
      Absolutely.
    • 04:24:01
      When we take into account the traffic and revenue study, we don't build into that model a large increase in economic development.
    • 04:24:10
      So that in itself is what you call a bonus to the project.
    • 04:24:15
      The conservative nature, again, of this traffic and revenue study doesn't say, well, you say it'll come when we don't know that, we investors in the debt.
    • 04:24:25
      So there's a tremendous opportunity there.
    • 04:24:27
      To the rail portion, Norfolk Southern parallels this facility.
    • 04:24:32
      That's going to be the track that will take the rail service, the Amtrak service from Staples Mill down to Norfolk.
    • 04:24:41
      They are making upgrades, Norfolk Southern is.
    • 04:24:43
      Norfolk Southern owns property along this corridor.
    • 04:24:46
      CSX owns property near this corridor.
    • 04:24:48
      So you will have the intermodal switching facilities to take vehicles on and off trains.
    • 04:24:56
      taking those containers, putting them on trains, taking them off trains.
    • 04:25:01
      As the Secretary mentioned, we've improved the access to rail line running into APM.
    • 04:25:07
      We now have two tracks running into the APM facility that were paid for largely by the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:25:14
      Yeah, Mr. Rich, let's get to your point.
    • 04:25:17
      The road again will parallel, for the most part, the north and southern mainline, which will open up the opportunity for intermodal facilities as well as passenger rail because we are going to start running.
    • 04:25:29
      We put in a lot of money on $114 million in improving this for passenger rail, that line for passenger rail.
    • 04:25:39
      This road combined with the freight combined with the mega sites where they're owned by Norfolk Southern, Isle of Wight is also a big private developer.
    • 04:25:49
      It's all going to be opening up major opportunities for there to be economic development as well as potentially passenger services as well.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:26:00
      Yes, sir.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:26:00
      Mr. Chairman, can I just summarize my issues with this?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:26:06
      I really want to defer to my colleagues in Hampton Roads and also some very intelligent people who support this project who are not in this room.
    • 04:26:18
      The only concern that I have
    • 04:26:21
      is the way this thing is being funded.
    • 04:26:24
      I'm not a big debt person.
    • 04:26:26
      We talked about last time, for the last fiscal year, over three billion of the four billion was debt.
    • 04:26:36
      We're starting to go toward the Washington way of doing things.
    • 04:26:39
      That concerns me.
    • 04:26:41
      Another thing that concerns me is we're kind of
    • 04:26:44
      getting out of the transparency process with the Six-Year Plan.
    • 04:26:49
      I mean, we're making material changes to the Six-Year Plan, hundreds of millions of dollars without any public input.
    • 04:26:57
      And what concerns me is there are other priorities within the Six-Year Plan, the Dulles Rail, the Midtown Tunnel.
    • 04:27:05
      the Dulles Loop, improving 66 and 28 all this is coming out of the same pot so we haven't had you know we've got to balance all of these needs and I guess a major concern is for my colleagues on that are new we had a pot of funds called the mega project funds
    • 04:27:28
      Set aside, that was what, for 58, for 460, it was the Midtown Downtown product, it was the Hot Lanes, and it was Coldfield Price Expressway.
    • 04:27:41
      But, we took 250 million dollars out of that, for a road to nowhere, in my district that my district does not want, and are squandering that money,
    • 04:27:55
      That money should have been left in the mega funds project so that we could use for these types of things and not have to borrow so much.
    • 04:28:02
      So that's what we got.
    • 04:28:03
      That's what really concerns me.
    • 04:28:06
      This is for a so-called Charlottesville bypass that the engineers will tell you in private will not work.
    • 04:28:11
      So these are some of my concerns.
    • 04:28:12
      I think the underlying concerns that you've laid out, this project could benefit Hampton Roads, but we've got to prioritize our funding.
    • 04:28:22
      And stop this borrowing and use the funds that we have instead of diverting them for projects that will not work.
    • 04:28:30
      But that's my major concern.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:28:32
      But Mr. Rich, just unlike Washington, we have limits on our debt.
    • 04:28:38
      We have funding, so we don't ever use debt for operating, which is what the federal government does.
    • 04:28:45
      We only use debt for capital infrastructure, which is what you should be using debt for.
    • 04:28:53
      We have a dedicated funding source for every one of our debt issuances, which is unlike the federal government.
    • 04:29:00
      And we have identified this project and have, you know, I believe you have voted with it step by step all the way through and we appreciate that.
    • 04:29:10
      This project now is finally after 20 something years.
    • 04:29:15
      Similarly to the 29 bypass in Charlottesville, that if we had gone ahead and did it in 20 years... Do you mean they're similar as far as effect in moving traffic?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:26
      Are you going to make that statement?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:26
      Well, I'm just saying if we did that 20 years ago, it would have cost us a boatload less than it is today.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:31
      Would it have worked?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:32
      And this is now a project.
    • 04:29:34
      We've finally gotten it here.
    • 04:29:35
      We've identified the funding.
    • 04:29:36
      We've gotten the tolls into
    • 04:29:38
      A box that we think is very affordable, very attractive for people and truckers to use.
    • 04:29:45
      The decision point we're at today is finally we're here.
    • 04:29:52
      It ain't going to get any cheaper.
    • 04:29:55
      It ain't going to get any easier.
    • 04:29:56
      And we have the ability to move forward and I think years from now as we move forward on this project that we'll see that the many, many future generations will thank the CTB for their great vision and support.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:30:11
      Mr. Chairman, I just want to add one thing.
    • 04:30:13
      I'm going to vote for this project, but I'm going to give you all another opportunity to put that money on a road to nowhere back into these projects that are worthwhile.
    • 04:30:23
      We cannot spend a quarter of a billion dollars on a road to nowhere.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:30:27
      I'd like to make one point.
    • 04:30:31
      Well, I'm certainly appreciative of the great support for the project from our friends in the Port of Virginia area.
    • 04:30:38
      It's not just a project about Port of Virginia.
    • 04:30:41
      You know, there is a western terminus of this, and it is in Prince George and Petersburg and Dinwiddie and Sussex, and those are areas that have been as hard to hit as any region of our Commonwealth during the recession.
    • 04:30:56
      They're extremely supportive, and it will be, you know, from an economic development standpoint, logistics, distribution, warehousing, all of those things, it's important.
    • 04:31:06
      So I didn't want any, particularly our new colleagues, just feeling this was just all about the Port of Virginia.
    • 04:31:12
      It's critical of them, but it's also critical of the South Side.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:15
      Yeah, Mr. Cole, I just want to, I mean,
    • 04:31:19
      Just point out one thing, and one thing as we look out for a competitive edge for the Commonwealth.
    • 04:31:26
      You know, the new manufacturing centers of the South are down the 85 corridor.
    • 04:31:33
      The building of this road and looking at the long-term terminuses, you know, at the 295 and how it gets into the 85.
    • 04:31:43
      If you run the Times, I mean, for the first time, we'll only be a few hours difference from the Port of Virginia to Spartanburg than it is from the Port of Savannah to Spartanburg.
    • 04:31:56
      And if it gives us reach for our port, we're quite honest with you, we have little to no reach today.
    • 04:32:03
      And this is going to, again, provide another opportunity for us to increase the competitive edge of the Commonwealth.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:32:10
      This is the same funding model.
    • 04:32:12
      One of the things I do is the CTB rep is set on the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel, which I am chairman of that.
    • 04:32:19
      It's the same model that we use for running the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel.
    • 04:32:25
      The same model.
    • 04:32:26
      So to somehow think it's risky or whatever, I mean, we have $200 million in bonds on a billion-four project.
    • 04:32:35
      12%.
    • 04:32:36
      Yeah, 12%, a billion-four.
    • 04:32:38
      I believe this is going to be a model for delivering transportation projects in the state.
    • 04:32:45
      I would just point out, I'm fully supporting this project.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:13
      I think when you look at the port, it is one of the keys to the Commonwealth's future and its continued vitality.
    • 04:33:23
      I am, like Mr. Rich, deeply disturbed at the state that our transportation system is going to be in going forward.
    • 04:33:33
      I agree with Mr. Miller.
    • 04:33:36
      I think the
    • 04:33:37
      What he was referring to was the U.S. News & World Report study that came out this summer.
    • 04:33:43
      We were first in the nation in business.
    • 04:33:46
      We fell to number three.
    • 04:33:48
      The main reason we fell from first to third was that our transportation system went from tenth to thirty-third.
    • 04:33:57
      And it's because of congestion in Hampton Roads and congestion in Northern Virginia.
    • 04:34:02
      As Mr. Rich said,
    • 04:34:04
      We're borrowing, but I think this is it.
    • 04:34:07
      I think this is the last chunk of money we have to borrow.
    • 04:34:11
      This is it.
    • 04:34:12
      And we're pulling in a couple extra hundred million maybe from TIFIA that we didn't even know we had to borrow.
    • 04:34:20
      We've used it, this is it, for a number of years, with no new sources of income coming in.
    • 04:34:26
      And this is for your new members and everyone else.
    • 04:34:29
      Y'all coming in at the tail end, we spent every nickel we got.
    • 04:34:32
      We got $4 billion from this governor, and this is the last vote for the last bit of money.
    • 04:34:39
      that you're probably going to see for your term on this board unless something dramatic happens and new money comes in.
    • 04:34:52
      I believe it's 2016, every penny is going to maintenance and nothing to new construction and we've borrowed everything we can borrow.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:00
      Well, Mr. Peake, I appreciate it, but it's not exactly that accurate, but I just need to point out one thing.
    • 04:35:07
      I mean, remember one of the reasons we were even pursuing
    • 04:35:10
      Some of these projects now, it's just the prices.
    • 04:35:15
      We're pushing stuff out because we have the ability and on top of it we have these issues on what sorts of prices we're getting.
    • 04:35:25
      The thing is that unless there are additional revenue sources,
    • 04:35:32
      Coming from the General Assembly, obviously the ability to do big projects is greatly curtailed.
    • 04:35:38
      We'll still have our projects.
    • 04:35:40
      We still have the ability to do them as any small, some medium.
    • 04:35:45
      But the mega projects that are underway right now and will give us the edge into the future, the ability to do those is going to be very, very curtailed.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:58
      And then we're going to be left with Mr. Rich,
    • 04:36:01
      Coming after the $200 million for the Route 29 bypass.
    • 04:36:06
      And then the people who are paying for the, they took $200 million out to subsidize the tolls for the Midtown Tunnel.
    • 04:36:15
      They wanted $200 million.
    • 04:36:17
      And it's just going to be back and forth.
    • 04:36:19
      Little chunks here, little chunks there, and the people that are going to lose are the people in the Culpeper District, the people in the Lynchburg District, and the Royal At-Largest, because we don't have any way to support anything with tolls, we don't have the traffic, we don't have the money, we don't have the population.
    • 04:36:35
      And so that's what needs to be addressed.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:37
      By the way, all the new members, we do have professional therapy that we'll be able to use to help you a lot.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:42
      I'm sorry, Mr. Garth, this is you.
    • 04:36:45
      This is getting to the benefit of the new members.
    • 04:36:49
      The governor was here today.
    • 04:36:51
      He was saying one word, jobs.
    • 04:36:54
      And that's what this is about.
    • 04:36:55
      And I'm supporting this because the Commonwealth has two economic jewels.
    • 04:37:01
      One of them is the Port of Hampton Roads.
    • 04:37:03
      The other is Dulles Airport.
    • 04:37:05
      And I'm hoping that in my lifetime on this board, I can come back and ask for a PPTA, at least, that supports the north-south corridor that
    • 04:37:14
      promotes and enhances Dulles Airport just as this is going to do with Fort Hampton Roads.
    • 04:37:21
      We've got to protect those if we're going to move up to that ranking of number one again.
    • 04:37:25
      Let's pay for Dulles.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:37:27
      And I just want to point out, one of the projects that's been left out, the mega project, is Cole Fields.
    • 04:37:34
      That's fully funded and we're good to go with that.
    • 04:37:36
      So Cole Fields PTTA is still going forward as well as PTA and all that stuff.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:37:44
      I couldn't let Mr. Peake's obituary necessarily be the last word.
    • 04:37:49
      Dana and I have been here and we've watched the funding go up where we were able to add projects.
    • 04:37:54
      It's gone down where we were cutting projects for our new members.
    • 04:37:57
      There is that cyclical aspect.
    • 04:37:59
      It's not rosy, I will admit that.
    • 04:38:01
      We do have structural problems where we've got to get more funding.
    • 04:38:06
      That's been true the last four years.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:38:13
      I was in 2009.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:38:24
      This administration came in.
    • 04:38:34
      And we have $4 billion.
    • 04:38:35
      I understand it's borrowed and
    • 04:38:37
      The Governor will tell you the first thing.
    • 04:38:39
      He understood that because what you said, getting these projects out and done.
    • 04:38:43
      So, you know, I guess we know where the numbers add up.
    • 04:38:46
      Let's hope our legislative people will know where they add up and they'll take proof now.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:38:50
      Just remember what Margaret Thatcher said, eventually you run out of spending other people's money, and that's about where we are.
    • 04:38:57
      Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:38:58
      Mr. Chairman, I think you all have done an excellent job.
    • 04:39:02
      I'm pleased with where you are.
    • 04:39:04
      I am, I think we, which Charlie I think pointed out, you got him to point out, we've done some things differently than were done with the previous project that came before us on the downtown midtown tunnel.
    • 04:39:23
      One of the great sort of criticisms of that
    • 04:39:27
      was that there was an equity return that some people thought, a potential equity return that some people thought was excessive.
    • 04:39:34
      There is no equity return here.
    • 04:39:36
      We don't have that issue anymore.
    • 04:39:39
      I will say at the end of the day, back to Mr. Peake's comments, we find ourselves as the administration and as the CTB here with a structural problem that Mr. Sterling calls it.
    • 04:39:56
      And the structural problem is we don't have enough revenue to do what needs to be done to keep the Commonwealth moving forward economically.
    • 04:40:08
      And as I told the speaker the other day, I don't care what you call it.
    • 04:40:14
      I don't care if you call it a tax.
    • 04:40:17
      I don't care if you call it a toll.
    • 04:40:19
      I don't care if you call it a fee.
    • 04:40:21
      I don't care if you call it a license.
    • 04:40:23
      I don't care what you call it.
    • 04:40:25
      When you take $10 out of my wallet, it's $10.
    • 04:40:28
      It just doesn't matter to me what you call it.
    • 04:40:31
      So we sort of, in the political world, and I understand this, we sort of
    • 04:40:35
      dance around that issue.
    • 04:40:39
      And the bottom line is, it's $10.
    • 04:40:42
      So I don't care what you call it.
    • 04:40:46
      And the situation we found ourselves in, this governor's found himself in, and this board has found themselves in, is the only way that we have to do these kinds of projects today.
    • 04:41:00
      Because the entire government hasn't acted to give us ability otherwise is to use tolls.
    • 04:41:09
      And so Hampton Roads is not particularly excited about having to build its projects which basically fund the economies of the rest of the Commonwealth along with Richmond and along with Northern Virginia.
    • 04:41:22
      We're funding the economies already and then to continue to fund those economies we have to charge ourselves
    • 04:41:28
      money to drive from point A to point B.
    • 04:41:32
      That was critically important with the downtown-midtown tunnel because unlike 460, there wasn't an alternative.
    • 04:41:41
      So those folks now, in order just to get to their work, to get to their jobs, have to pay about a thousand bucks out of pocket and people that are making $25,000 a year, a thousand bucks out of pocket to get to the hospital to be an orderly is a tough deal.
    • 04:41:59
      The Governor didn't put us in that situation.
    • 04:42:02
      He has made some suggestions about some revenue increases.
    • 04:42:06
      The General Assembly did not help us out on that.
    • 04:42:09
      And at the end of the day, we're not going to get anything more done on a mega project basis until and unless the General Assembly acts and says, we're going to do something.
    • 04:42:21
      And we can't let them off the hook from pretending
    • 04:42:24
      That that toll that takes $10 out of my pocket is any different than a tax that takes $10 out of my pocket.
    • 04:42:31
      And I think we have a responsibility as board members if we believe that to continue to advocate and to urge and to push our elected officials to do what we believe they need to do in order to fix these problems.
    • 04:42:45
      So this is the best way
    • 04:42:50
      It's the only way, but it's that because of the situation that we're in.
    • 04:42:55
      It's not the best way and the only way if we were in a different situation.
    • 04:43:00
      Unfortunately, we can't change that here.
    • 04:43:02
      Mr. Martin, then Mr. Fisher
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:20
      We have millions of drivers in various parts of the state for whom a transponder is subject to the Jerry Springer Show.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:34
      Who's Jerry Springer?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:35
      I would ask you to make the same commitment that the Midtown Tunnel vendor made, that people who live a certain distance from the entrance to the open road tolling, for example, those living in Lynchburg, Salem, or Bristol districts, but regardless, that those people not be subject to a penalty for their first two infractions.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:05
      Yes, sir.
    • 04:44:06
      Definitely.
    • 04:44:06
      This is Mr. 6320.
    • 04:44:08
      And for Mr. Fisher?
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:11
      Well, of course.
    • 04:44:12
      Since our conversation here is way off-base from when we started... Not really.
    • 04:44:16
      It's not really.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:16
      Sort of usual, Mr. Fisher.
    • Fran FisherMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:19
      To break up the gloom and doom, there is a lot of talk that there is political will for this upcoming session of the legislature that
    • 04:44:27
      I think everybody around the state realizes that we're at a critical point and that something may be done and we can all push for that.
    • 04:44:37
      In addition to the whatever you call it, the etc., obviously big words are revenue neutral and I've heard a couple of different proposals that have been made to the business community that
    • 04:44:48
      could be workable and produce a dedicated funding source for transportation.
    • 04:44:54
      A lot of people realize that it's not just Northern Virginia or Hampton Roads that's having great solutions at that level.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:45:04
      So where were you, Mr. Kilpatrick?
    • 04:45:06
      I think I was right here.
    • 04:45:07
      Any questions?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:45:10
      I think I was the question.
    • 04:45:13
      I think it's important just to mention again that the first column is the column that we've been talking about today.
    • 04:45:20
      We are actively pursuing this TIFIA loan.
    • 04:45:23
      While we do not believe that there's very little likelihood of a TIFIA loan closing at the end of this year, like zero probability,
    • 04:45:32
      There may be, we may hear before the end of the year whether we'll be invited to, and that's the process, we'll be invited to apply for the loan.
    • 04:45:41
      Once you're invited, there's a strong likelihood of receiving a loan.
    • 04:45:45
      We should get a response to that this year.
    • 04:45:48
      What that effectively does is it reduces the public contribution between both, and what we've done is prorated that contribution with support.
    • 04:45:57
      with VDOT.
    • 04:45:58
      It reduces it, again, rough numbers between $100 and $175 million less public contribution.
    • 04:46:06
      It also impacts the amount of tax exempt debt that's sold.
    • 04:46:11
      But again, this is under a scenario, this is a fairly conservative scenario of a TIFIA loan.
    • 04:46:18
      With that, I'm going to jump to the last slide, which just talks about moving forward.
    • 04:46:24
      Again, we are continuing to review the proposal of the offer team as well as the two other proposers because if the first proposer is unable to perform, it's kind of like the Miss America cannot perform for any reason, then we do have, it's important for us to have the first runner-up and frankly the second.
    • 04:46:48
      So I don't, again with that, we are, we're continuing to look at the detailed proposals
    • 04:46:54
      In November, we'll be doing the Federal Highway Review and approval and affirming the investment grade rating and an important thing that Secretary Connaughton has directed us as part of this continued outreach and open dialogue with the community regarding this project.
    • 04:47:12
      We will be holding
    • 04:47:14
      A public information and question and answer session in November.
    • 04:47:19
      We're tentatively looking at November 14th, somewhere along the corridor where we will have an opportunity for the public to come in again to see for another time the documents, the displays, ask questions of our staff.
    • 04:47:35
      As well as a question and answer period where we can answer questions from the community.
    • 04:47:42
      We're looking to have a panel of individuals and we will likely call on our CTB members from the two districts to participate in that.
    • 04:47:52
      We think that's another opportunity again to receive comment and to be able to be forthright and open with the public as we move towards financial close.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:48:01
      In December, I will come back to this. At November date, it's mid-November, we haven't locked in on that date.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:48:08
      Yes sir, yes sir. Again, the date we are circling is somewhere around that third week in November. We have not locked that date down at this point, yes sir.
    • 04:48:22
      In December, I will come back to the CTB at your December meeting and update you on the TIFIA loan, the work on the debt that's being raised.
    • 04:48:31
      as well as feedback from the public meeting.
    • 04:48:37
      We'll release the preliminary official statement to raise the debt.
    • 04:48:43
      We'll price the senior debt.
    • 04:48:45
      We will execute the final comprehensive agreement and go to financial close.
    • 04:48:51
      In January, we will immediately begin with a notice to proceed to the contractor and they will initiate their design, their right-of-way and their permitting work
    • 04:49:01
      Working with us as well as the communities as we go through the numerous design details and efficiencies that we believe we can find in the final design project on this project.
    • 04:49:12
      Again, we have an alignment that has been established, but there are a number of things that we believe we can do to optimize the facility and minimize the impacts as we deliver this.
    • 04:49:26
      Construction is anticipated to be completed in 2018, and the road opening to the public and tolling at that same time.
    • 04:49:34
      And with that, Mr. Secretary, I think I'm done.
    • 04:49:40
      I'm sorry, one last thing, and I'm not gonna name all the folks involved, but we had a tremendous team of folks, both VDOT employees as well as consultants that have spent, some of them, six, seven, eight, nine years
    • 04:49:53
      on this project in bringing it to this point today, especially the Office of Public-Private Partnerships.
    • 04:49:59
      Tony Kinn is the director, and Dusty Holcomb, the deputy director.
    • 04:50:05
      He and his staff, Orteza Parjan, who is the project manager today, and Margie Ray before, done a tremendous job in bringing this forward to this point.
    • 04:50:15
      Again, we got a lot of smart people behind me, and they outsmarted me because they said for me to come up and do the presentation, and not them.
    • 04:50:24
      So, sir, with that, unless there are additional questions, Mr. Lawson, I believe, is going to come up.
    • Roger ColeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:29
      I think Mr. Butcher and then Mr. Lawson.
    • 04:50:33
      One last question, and you may have mentioned it.
    • 04:50:36
      I probably lost it in the fog of depression following Mr. Peake's comments.
    • 04:50:42
      Your request to TIFIA was for $422 million, but in your projections, you're suggesting that amount will be between $240 and $340.
    • 04:50:53
      How does that work?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:50:53
      This is sort of like asking Declan an engineering question.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:00
      So I think the commissioner might be able to... Mr. Cole, what we were doing, we did a plot for $422 million.
    • 04:51:09
      But again, in order to be conservative, a lot of times when you apply for these loans, you don't get all of what you asked for.
    • 04:51:15
      So we had a conservative amount down.
    • 04:51:18
      And so we believe that the amount will result in the contribution going from 930 to 750 for VDOT and from 250 to 202 for the ports.
    • 04:51:32
      It is possible if we got more, we could restructure the debt in a way that we could take advantage of more if it came.
    • 04:51:40
      But that was just a conservative view of what would happen if we got a typical loan.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:46
      And Ms. Cole, what's interesting about this is New Map 21, which we had lots of discussion about earlier, they have in there a very specific set-aside for rural P3s.
    • 04:52:00
      And we looked at the list of so far submissions that came in.
    • 04:52:06
      I think we're the only one that meets the criteria for rural P3s.
    • 04:52:11
      So this may be an opportunity for us to assist the federal government in meeting their statutory obligations to award TIFIA money for the rural people.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 04:52:23
      And the rural TIFIA, I believe, is roughly half the interest rate of the regular TIFIA loan.
    • 04:52:28
      So again, it's a substantial savings which allows us to raise additional debt.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:52:33
      And when you look at all the other projects that so far have applied to TIFIA, I believe they're almost all urban projects.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:52:40
      Mr. Secretary, this presentation we kind of broke it out separate from what we typically do where we talk about transfers and amendments in the program.
    • 04:52:55
      We did this just for 460 because we didn't want to mix it up with the other presentations.
    • 04:53:02
      So this is only about the adjustments in the program related specifically for 460.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 04:53:10
      Okay, Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, as the Commissioner indicated, based on the previous presentation on the major terms for Route 460, amendments and transfers will be necessary to this fiscal year 13-18 Six-Year Improvement.
    • 04:53:32
      Program, which is standard business practice as we move funding from one place to another in the program.
    • 04:53:42
      New UPCs for the construction of the project and for the payment of debt service on the bond proceeds to be used on the project need to be added to the six-year program as project amendments.
    • 04:53:56
      Read it for our new members.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:54:03
      Can you identify UPCs?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 04:54:06
      It's what we call the project number for a construction project.
    • 04:54:12
      It's the identifying number that's in the system to find the project in the six-year program.
    • 04:54:27
      Funds must also be transferred to the new and some existing UPCs to show the funding, the complete funding for the 460 project.
    • 04:54:37
      As you are aware, some of the resources will be transferred from the PPTA initiatives UPC or project and the GARVEE
    • 04:54:48
      On your action agenda, as I indicated, we'll be asking you to review and approve the transfers and the amendments for the 460 quarter improvement project.
    • 04:55:04
      First of all, I'll review the UPCs that are currently in the six-year program.
    • 04:55:10
      The first one is
    • 04:55:12
      UPC 56638, this is where we set up the funding for the preliminary engineering location and environmental study.
    • 04:55:21
      And just as the title will tell you, it's the cost for the environmental study for the 460 PPT-8 project.
    • 04:55:30
      Also we have two projects, one for project management, costs associated with the procurement and project development.
    • 04:55:39
      Now, we also need to amend
    • 04:56:07
      Two new UPCs.
    • 04:56:15
      We need to create a UPC for the construction of the project and that will show the estimate of $1.396 billion and it will be the combination of the two
    • 04:56:28
      216 million from the private funding corporation, which is the 6320, and the 1.18 billion, which is the public contribution.
    • 04:56:39
      And that consists of Garvey bonds, PPR bonds, court authority funds, and some PTF funds that I'll describe a little bit more in a minute.
    • 04:56:52
      and also a Garvey Debt Service, UPC.
    • 04:56:57
      And this captures the federal funds paying the principal and interest for the Garvey bonds allocated to the Route 460 project.
    • 04:57:05
      Garvey bonds are paid back principal and interest with federal funds.
    • 04:57:16
      Okay, the transfers.
    • 04:57:18
      I'm going to go through a series of transfers and talk to you, summarize where the funds are coming from and where they're going to.
    • 04:57:27
      And then I'll summarize it on the slide with everything to get down to the total of $1,396,000.
    • 04:57:35
      The first transfer moves to $150,000,000.
    • 04:57:39
      in CPR Bonds from the PPTA initiatives account that was set up when the General Assembly approved the bonding authority in the Governor's 2011 Transportation Funding Package to the 460 Construction UPC.
    • 04:57:58
      and approximately 22 million PPS funding that was placed in the PPTA initiative when it was determined these funds were not needed to pay for debt service on the CCR bond.
    • 04:58:12
      So it's just a small amount of state funding that is freed up to put in the PPTA initiative's account for the mega project.
    • 04:58:22
      And we're putting 22 million onto the 460 construction project.
    • 04:58:27
      We're also transferring approximately $331 million of GARVEE bonds in the GARVEE bond balance entry project that was also established from the bonding authority that was approved with Governor's 2011 transportation funding package to the 460 construction project.
    • 04:58:49
      The $250 million in Virginia Port Authority funds is actually being transferred from the project management UPC where it was placed when the Port Authority approved the contribution to the project.
    • 04:59:07
      These funds were added to the six-year program in the 2013 through 2018 program update.
    • 04:59:16
      and those funds will also be transferred to the 460 construction account.
    • 04:59:22
      The last item is a transfer of 300 million in Garvey bonds from the I-95 construction UPC to the 460 construction UPC.
    • 04:59:35
      These bond proceeds were placed on the I-95 project in anticipation
    • 04:59:42
      of receiving the TIFIA loan for 95.
    • 04:59:46
      This was to move the project 95 project forward.
    • 04:59:50
      It allowed for the financial close and the TIFIA loan should actually be finalized in the next two weeks, probably the last week in October.
    • 05:00:00
      And that will allow for this transfer to go through to the 460 project.
    • 05:00:09
      The first bullet on slide six actually is not referencing a transfer but instead is recognizing on the 460 construction you can see the 216 million in revenue bonds that the 6320
    • 05:00:27
      funding corporation will put into the construction pot for 460.
    • 05:00:33
      These allocations are not in VDOT's budget and no action needs to be taken on those.
    • 05:00:39
      What it does is allows for us to show the full financing cost of the 460 project for the federal financing documentation and the approval of a TIF and STIF amendment.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:51
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Lawson, CTB, John Lawson will be coming up a little later discussing the issuance of those bonds in the next presentation.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 05:01:06
      The next item is the transfer of $167.1 million of federal funds for the GARBI debt service from the debt service balance entry UCC to the 460 PPTA debt service account that's being set up for this purpose.
    • 05:01:30
      The next item is a transfer of $222,000 in federal funds, which is in the PPTA initiative account, and we are planning to move that to the project.
    • 05:01:44
      oversight project for 460.
    • 05:01:48
      This is just a small amount of federal funds remaining on the PPTA initiative and the project oversight.
    • 05:01:57
      UPC seemed like the logical place to put that for federal obligation purposes.
    • 05:02:07
      The last item on the slide is the use of an additional $161.9 million in additional GARVEE bonds that have not yet been programmed.
    • 05:02:18
      They will be programmed in the update of the 2014 through 2019 Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 05:02:27
      These bond proceeds were not originally in the GARVEE balance entry UPC.
    • 05:02:36
      But as was mentioned early with Mr. Lawson and his discussion of the financial update, there was the understanding that the Garvey Authority
    • 05:02:50
      can be rolling $1.2 billion.
    • 05:02:56
      So as debt service drops off from payment in the early years of issuing GARVEE, that allows capacity to open up.
    • 05:03:06
      So in 2017, we will be able to use $161.9 million to complete the funding of the 460 construction project with GARVEE bonds.
    • 05:03:21
      127 million of the 161 actually goes to the construction EPC and 34.9 million on the project oversight EPC.
    • 05:03:34
      Now, let's recap.
    • 05:03:38
      The amendment is to create a construction project
    • 05:03:45
      For the GARBE bonds, the CPR bonds, the DPA funds, and PTF funds that are being used for this PPTA project, the route 460 quarter improvement.
    • 05:03:57
      As was indicated, 1.18 billion is the public contribution and 216 million revenue bonds from the 6320 corporation.
    • 05:04:07
      The transactions I summarized would be to move from the PPTA initiative, the 150 million
    • 05:04:15
      The 22 million from the PPTA initiative, the PTF surplus.
    • 05:04:21
      And then the GARVEE proceeds that we would be looking at.
    • 05:04:24
      The 331 million from the GARVEE bonds balance entry.
    • 05:04:29
      300 million from the 95 project which will be replaced with the TIFIA when we close that loan at the end of the month.
    • 05:04:39
      And 127 of fiscal year 17 GARVEE bonds.
    • 05:04:45
      We've reflected in this account the 250 million from the Port Authority and in the 216 which is a no-post but reflects the funding from the bonds of the 6320 Corporation to get us to the billion 396 and that's how we're funding 460.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:05:05
      I just want to really thank Rita for this presentation because it's completely transparent, which is the way we should get the information at this board.
    • 05:05:15
      I want to speak particularly to the new members.
    • 05:05:17
      When I talked about the six-year plan and this impact,
    • 05:05:21
      This shows the dollar, real dollar impact to your districts.
    • 05:05:24
      Some of this money could have gone into your districts for projects that are high priority.
    • 05:05:32
      We all have to make, you know, value determination, but at least we know what we're doing here.
    • 05:05:38
      and go in with both eyes open.
    • 05:05:42
      So there's less money going into NOVA and Culver District and everything else, but we have to make these, I'm not arguing against this, because I'm going to vote for it, but we need to know that there are serious impacts to our districts when we approve all of these funds, including PPTA funds, and this is not a PPTA project, are going into this particular district, just so we know what we're doing, but I really thank you for laying it all out for us.
    • 05:06:08
      It's actually two districts.
    • 05:06:10
      Right.
    • 05:06:11
      Absolutely.
    • 05:06:12
      Absolutely.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 05:06:13
      All right, to summarize the project oversight, there was an existing UPC that had $49 million on it, and we transferred some additional funding for the oversight of the project, the $222,000 from the PPGA initiatives and a portion of the 2017 Garvey bond issue of 34.9, for a total of 84.9, and that's approximately 6%.
    • 05:06:42
      of the project cost which is actually less than you might imagine it would be to maintain a project of this magnitude or to monitor and follow a project of this magnitude.
    • 05:06:55
      And then last but not least, the transfer of $167 million to the new UPC for the 460 debt service to be repaid with federal funds for the Garvey bond.
    • 05:07:12
      The next steps will be completing the TIF and STIF amendments necessary to obtain federal authorizations prior to the financial close in December.
    • 05:07:24
      We will be requesting TIF amendments from the Hampton Roads TPO and the Tri-Cities MPO in November.
    • 05:07:32
      The two MPOs have been briefed.
    • 05:07:35
      We have the meeting scheduled and we'll be introducing the TIF amendments on
    • 05:07:41
      November 7th in Hampton Roads and November 2nd in Tri-Cities and their policy board should approve the TIP amendments November 15th and November 29th
    • 05:07:57
      And then when those are approved, we take that approval, prepare the STIP amendment, forward that to the FHWA and they approve the STIP amendment.
    • 05:08:06
      And then the full value of the project is in the Six-Year Program to go forward for building of the project.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 05:08:30
      Good afternoon.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 05:08:44
      I'm Act III.
    • 05:08:48
      As we talked earlier, you've heard that as part of this project we created for 6320 to issue tax exempt debt to support the project.
    • 05:08:59
      Just to recap, at your July meeting, you approved the purposes of the 63-throughout 460 funding corporation, as outlined in the article of the corporation.
    • 05:09:12
      And the second thing that you approved was for the 63-20, as established, to be able to issue the tax-exempt bonds
    • 05:09:23
      With one contingency, that we have to come back to you for approval of the maximum amount of debt that would be needed.
    • 05:09:31
      As presented in the best value proposal that you heard from Mr. Kilpatrick, the amount of debt that is expected in the proposal in gross terms is $286 million, which generates the $216 million in proceeds that you have heard being contributed toward the construction of the project.
    • 05:09:53
      Just as kind of a review, the 6320, we refer to it as the Funding Corporation, short for the U.S. Route 460 Funding Corporation of Virginia.
    • 05:10:04
      It was incorporated as a non-stock, non-profit corporation on August 27, 2012.
    • 05:10:09
      The Incorporated was John O'Neill, Huntley Williams, and he's here with us today.
    • 05:10:15
      If you have any particular questions about the corporation itself, it was organized.
    • 05:10:21
      For the purpose of financing the design, development, construction, and maintenance future tolling operations of the 460 corridor improvements project.
    • 05:10:35
      The funding corporation held its first meeting, which was its organizational meeting last Friday, October the 12th, and the board formally approved the bylaws and elected its officers.
    • 05:10:48
      Just to remind you that the board, as we laid out for you, in July contained seven members, two of which are ex officio, the VDOT CFO, and the Director of Debt Management from the Virginia Resources Authority, and one member placed by the Virginia Port Authority, and then four to be appointed by the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 05:11:13
      You see here the list of the initial members, myself,
    • 05:11:17
      Sean Crumliss from L.A., Mr. Lane, who has graciously agreed to be the chair of the corporation, Rodney Oliver, who is the interim executive director from the Port Authority, will be vice chair, Ron Tillett, the managing director of Raymond James Morgan Keegan, and you may also remember Mr. Tillett from his previous service at the Commonwealth as
    • 05:11:43
      Secretary of Finance and Treasurer, and in other roles, he will serve as Secretary-Treasurer.
    • 05:11:50
      Also, the remaining two members on the board, William Johnson, he's the City Manager of Petersburg, he brings a lot of financial management experience as well, as well as Jeffrey Holland, he's the Executive Director of the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel, and obviously he brings not only
    • 05:12:08
      financial management, business management experience.
    • 05:12:11
      He did serve as CFO at the tunnel before taking the executive director position, but he also brings the tolling background that will be helpful to the corporation as we run the project once it's built.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:27
      John, this is Dr. Carey.
    • 05:12:28
      Poll 1 says board members by CTB.
    • 05:12:31
      Did I miss something when you were here at the last meeting?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 05:12:34
      Charlie, do you have a problem with Mr. Lane being on it?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:57
      I think we should interview him.
    • 05:13:00
      I want a lot of probing questions.
    • 05:13:03
      I think that's a wise interview.
    • 05:13:05
      Mr. Rich wants to know how he feels about the 29th.
    • 05:13:07
      Yeah.
    • 05:13:12
      What's the term?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 05:13:13
      Mr. Chairman, I have one comment.
    • 05:13:14
      Do you want to deal with the term?
    • 05:13:16
      The bonds?
    • 05:13:18
      No, the term of the, yes.
    • 05:13:20
      Mr. Layne's term.
    • 05:13:22
      Mr. Layne's term.
    • 05:13:24
      I don't remember each by person, but they are staggered initially.
    • 05:13:33
      Again, the first two ex officios are there by way of position.
    • 05:13:38
      The five that are appointed, they are staggered, some having initial term being three years, some being four years, some being five years, so that they don't all roll at the same time.
    • 05:13:48
      And then once the initial period is over, they will all serve a four-year appointment.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:13:52
      Just want to make one comment.
    • 05:13:54
      This is a private, not stock corporation, but we intend to run it, Mr. Rich and just for others, as if it's a public, you know, all transparent the whole bit.
    • 05:14:06
      So just getting that point out on the table.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 05:14:12
      All right, moving forward, this week we intend to start talking with the investment group and beginning to plan for the issuance.
    • 05:14:30
      Within a couple of weeks, we'll need to be getting back with the rating agencies to start our discussions with them as we kind of finalize the structure of the offering.
    • 05:14:39
      Working on the preliminary statements to go out early part of November, and you can just see here kind of the schedule as we work through fairly aggressively toward having a pricing the first week in December with a hopeful close prior to Christmas.
    • 05:15:06
      What we are
    • 05:15:07
      As I mentioned earlier, in July, the CTB did approve the issuance of bonds from the corporation, but we do need the maximum principal amount of the bonds to be approved today.
    • 05:15:22
      The funding corporation is recommending the authorization of up to $425 million in senior lien revenue bonds.
    • 05:15:32
      What the increase represents over the $286 million is the potential for us to take advantage of more favorable market rates.
    • 05:15:42
      As part of the structure that was built, we used a 5% interest rate, and current market trading is probably 50 basis points less than that.
    • 05:15:54
      We also want to make sure we have further maximized the structure to its greatest extent in going to market.
    • 05:16:02
      Any increased bonds that we can sell above the 286 or the net 216 would just be a result in a reduced public subsidy.
    • 05:16:12
      And as it's been said before, and I have to reiterate it again, these bonds are not a debt of VDOT, the CTB, the Commonwealth, or any political subdivision of the Commonwealth.
    • 05:16:24
      They are purely non-recourse bonds and only, you know, with stoning
    • 05:16:30
      records of the bond are on the total revenue.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:16:34
      Any other questions?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:16:35
      I have one question, Mr. Secretary.
    • 05:16:38
      I want to get it from the budget expert.
    • 05:16:40
      We've heard that in 2017 there is no more bonding debt available.
    • 05:16:47
      Is that correct?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 05:16:49
      In 2017, we will have used all of our bond authority as of that point in time.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:16:55
      As of that point in time.
    • 05:16:56
      So, I won't get three days notice that we've got another $300 million to spend, right?
    • 05:17:01
      Until 2017.
    • 05:17:02
      That's correct.
    • 05:17:04
      All right.
    • 05:17:04
      Thank you.
    • 05:17:05
      Now, one caveat.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 05:17:06
      One caveat.
    • 05:17:09
      If the federal government decides to give us a lot more money, then that number goes up.
    • 05:17:12
      Do you think that will happen?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:17:15
      That's an unfair question.
    • 05:17:17
      I withdraw the question, it's unfair.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:17:19
      Well, thank you very much.
    • 05:17:23
      Know the questions, Alice, Sam, Dan, Mr. Miller.
    • 05:17:26
      I'm sorry.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:17:29
      I probably shouldn't even ask.
    • 05:17:30
      I'll ask this later.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:17:31
      Excellent, excellent.