Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 5/16/2012
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
5/16/2012
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Route 460 Corridor Improvements Project brief.pdf
Fiscal Year 2012 budget _ actual performance through April.pdf
1. E-Z Pass Marketing Speaker – To Be Determined
E-ZPass retail and marketing update.pdf
2. Route 460 Update
3. I-95 Update
4. Virginia Transportation Infrastructure Bank Update
Virginia Transportation Infrastructure Bank update.pdf
5. Federal Transportation Grant Anticipation Revenue Notes (GARVEES), Series 2012B
Federal Transportation Grant Anticipation Revenue Notes (GARVEEs) Series 2012B.pdf
6. Financial Report
7. Economic Development Access Program
Economic Development Access Program.pdf
SPEAKER_02
00:00:00
Jim Bowie, from the Bristol District, right here where we sit, out in Bristol.
00:00:08
James Keen, formerly large, from Trenton.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:13
Jim Rich, from Baltimore District.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:18
Greg Worley, Commissioner for VDOT.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:00:21
Thelma Drake, Director, Department of Rail and Public Transportation.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:26
Doug Kooler, Northern Virginia District.
SPEAKER_02
00:00:30
Aubrey Layne, Hampton Roads District, Mark P. Lynchburg District, I'm Chuck Miller, an urban and large member, and I live in Norman, and Roger Cole from the Richmond District.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:45
Thank you very much.
00:00:46
At this point, we'll get right into the agenda for the workshop, starting with Easy Pass Marketing.
00:00:52
Ms. Johnson?
SPEAKER_02
00:00:59
Good morning, Mr. Secretary and Commissioner, Director Drake, board members.
SPEAKER_01
00:01:05
I am very pleased to be here.
00:01:07
I am representing a collaboration between communications and financial planning.
00:01:17
I am the lucky one who gets to go over an easy path this month, but I have a colleague, John Lawson,
00:01:26
and our farmer who has promised that if I get stuck with any question, they'll be very quick to jump up.
00:01:34
This morning, the presentation will address the following.
00:01:37
We'll talk about our goals, the key roles, toll facilities, transmonters, the types, the quantity, status, acquisition, retail locations, easy paths on the go, and our marketing efforts.
00:01:54
We're going to start with our goal.
00:01:57
ECPAS is expanded to support the opening of new total facilities beginning with us.
00:02:03
We want to raise awareness, provide convenience and availability, and create attention.
00:02:12
Key roles.
00:02:13
This is a very important thought.
00:02:16
We will provide the transponders, the retail program, and related customer service.
00:02:23
While the operators will promote the facilities and toll users.
00:02:27
Our partners will deploy paid units.
00:02:31
And if you look at this slide, it tells you what VDOT and our contractor, which is Faneuil, what they will provide and what the toll facilities will provide.
00:02:43
and, you know, we do the transponder and we'll find regional locations, websites, customer service centers, in-store marketing materials, urns, media, newsletters, the easy pass.
00:02:55
But the toll facilities would have the heavy lift.
00:02:58
They would be paying for the radio, print and TV advertising, billboards, incentives, promotions, events, marketing materials.
00:03:11
and the new toll facilities that we have coming on board.
00:03:14
Jordan Bridge, that's in the Hampton Roads area, opens July 2012.
00:03:19
Anticipates 7,000 EZ-Pass users.
00:03:26
495 Press Lane, opens December 12, 2012.
00:03:29
225,000 users.
00:03:32
EZ-Pass collects users along with the standards.
00:03:40
EZ-Pass.
00:03:41
Elizabeth River Crossing, that's in downtown, midtown.
00:03:44
Is it okay?
00:03:45
It's mansion.
00:03:46
Towing begins January of 2014.
00:03:49
The facility will not open in 2014, but the towing will begin in 2014.
SPEAKER_02
00:03:55
Mr. Chairman, I have a question.
00:04:00
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
00:04:00
These are additional user passes that were, how many do we have now?
00:04:05
How many users do we know?
00:04:06
How many user passes do we have in the state now?
SPEAKER_01
00:04:08
For the Jordan Bridge, they're anticipating 7,000.
00:04:31
We have those in stock already at the Clifton Forge Customer Service Center.
00:04:36
We anticipate opening the Chesapeake DMV location, June 1st, Target.
00:04:42
We're gonna co-locate with the Jordan Bridge office starting June 1.
00:04:48
Retail location, we have not secured any retail locations as of yet, but things will pick up with the anticipation of the start for the downtown, midtown, town.
00:05:00
You do know that to get retailers to engage in selling easy pass transponders, it is a business proposition.
00:05:09
And we feel relatively certain that once downtown, midtown comes on board, it will be a lot easier to secure retail businesses in the Hampton Roads area.
00:05:19
Promotional activities, Jordan Bridge, they're having activities every other Saturday.
00:05:24
They're planning a bridge opening event.
00:05:27
They have radio, print, and online advertising, direct mail, and they're doing that June through July, and then the earned media.
00:05:40
495 Express Lane, this is the one that's been getting quite a lot of attention.
00:05:44
We have been working very closely with Transurban.
00:05:47
As a matter of fact, Transurban came in and they sat down with our contractor's manual, and we discussed how we were gonna handle our marketing plan.
00:05:58
They need 100,000 flex responders by June 30th, and we're well on our way to accomplishing that.
00:06:06
Another 125 will be delivered through 2012 on a monthly basis.
00:06:11
Our Titans who are on a DMV will open July 16th.
00:06:15
We are looking at other locations, but we have firm commitment to July 16th for the DMV location.
00:06:21
On retail locations, I'll get into that in the next slide, I'm going to do in-store marketing, PR activities, online, print, and of course, there will be a procrastinator campaign because you know, even though they may start selling them on July 1st, they're going to be those folks who are going to wait until November when the facility opens and these servers to get their transplant.
00:06:49
Downtown Midtown MLK, Luther River Crossing, they're anticipating 100,000 and 100,000 transponders, 90% are already in stock.
00:07:00
We are anticipating opening a DMV location in Norfolk and Portsmouth in fall of 2013.
00:07:06
But as I said, under the Georgia Bridge line, we do have a DMV that will be opening in Chesapeake in June.
00:07:14
We're going to do in-store marketing, community outreach, earn media, ERC will have those centers.
00:07:24
Now this is the types of trends.
00:07:26
We're going to have the EZ-Path standards which we can use on all of our total facilities.
00:07:31
You will be able to use the standard EZ-Path on the 495 display right here.
00:07:36
Then you have the EZ-Path flag.
00:07:40
And that's primarily for $4.95 and will be due to the $95 express line when they open.
00:07:47
Now the transponders include an HOV mode switch which you can switch from for the $3 plus options because you will be able to ride $3 if you have $3 plus.
00:08:02
Now this is a slide that we got a lot of conversation about the last time, but this is just to assure you that we will have the appropriate amount, number of transponders when the facility's open.
00:08:16
When Joint Bridge opens, we've got their set of sizes they're gonna need.
00:08:20
When Transurban starts their marketing quiz July 1st, we will have their flex transponders and their standard transponders.
00:08:28
and we will have what they need to get through their first wave domain.
00:08:37
How can you get a transponder?
00:08:38
How can you find it?
00:08:39
Acquisition.
00:08:40
You can apply online 24-steps at the website.
00:08:45
Over 60% of our customers are paying their easy pass online and 92% replenish their easy pass online.
00:08:55
We have toll-free numbers from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.
00:08:59
And when you use the toll free or call or do go online, they're shipped within two days.
00:09:07
We have three existing customer service centers, Coles and Customer Service, Northern Virginia and the Virginia area.
00:09:16
We're doing a large stage of work.
00:09:20
For the DMV facilities, we're opening the Chesapeake June 1st, hiding in the corner July 16th, Norfolk employment target is 2013, and we're exploring other DMV locations.
00:09:37
Retail distribution.
00:09:38
We have three major retailers whose agreements are in their legal department currently, and we anticipate having signed agreements within a couple of weeks or so.
00:10:02
We have one major change that has 40 locations in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads.
00:10:08
So I said earlier that we did not have any retail locations for Hampton Roads, but this major chain will open in Northern Virginia and then they will then start servicing Hampton Roads when the downtown midtown comes up.
00:10:22
We have one large gas station which services 300 customers a day.
00:10:26
They have about 200 for gas and about 70 repairs a day.
00:10:32
and as Transurban Transit Company.
00:10:35
If you're familiar with the Subway commercial when you have, I can't think of the guy's name, but he's the one who lost all his weight and he's the biggest person who represents Subway?
00:10:48
Jerry.
00:10:49
Jerry.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:50
Thank you.
SPEAKER_01
00:10:51
Well, this gas station owner is the Jerry the Transurfer.
00:10:55
He approached them and he was very excited about them.
00:10:58
We also negotiate with 14 other outlets that have facilities in Northern Virginia and they have facilities in Hampton Roads.
00:11:07
We have initiated discussions with 15 other large retailers.
00:11:13
We have reduced the minimum order from 1,800 to 200 transplants.
00:11:18
That is the biggest thing where this lies.
00:11:21
And that was to encourage retail.
00:11:24
Because it was kind of daunting for them to get $1,800 at one time, but with two kinds of trans models, you'd think they'd be able to use their sales.
00:11:35
And this comes to the front part.
00:11:37
How does this work?
00:11:41
If you're familiar with the lottery balance, and the storm limit,
00:11:47
This is what will be in the tour.
00:11:51
And this will indicate that you can purchase your easy pass.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:58
I feel that man alive.
00:11:59
Can I buy a battle?
SPEAKER_01
00:12:01
That will be in the tour.
00:12:04
And the fifth will be a fifth place.
00:12:09
That will be in the tour.
00:12:11
One side will be the other.
00:12:15
And this is a video about Tuesday at a dirt pack and the apartment thing.
00:12:32
You know you walk up and you get a car and then you take the car out and the customer goes.
00:12:36
Well, what you will have here is you will have cars at your desk.
00:12:41
You have a black car and you have a standard car at your seat.
00:12:46
And they will be empty slots.
00:12:50
You pick up one and you lock the customer service.
00:13:01
When you go to customer service, you will get an easy pass on the dog pack.
00:13:06
This is how the black will look after the purple.
00:13:12
And this is the same in the gray.
00:13:16
What's the difference in the cost between the standard and the standard?
00:13:20
35 dollars, no difference.
00:13:29
No difference in the cost.
00:13:30
And the package will read the instructions on how to activate your easy pass.
00:13:36
When you walk out of the store, you will have $15 already on the transplant.
00:14:02
And then you have to go online, call, or go into a customer service store to activate an additional $20.
00:14:13
This is just a copy of the website page.
00:14:18
And I will conclude by saying that this presentation, like the opening of my new facility, was a joint collaboration.
00:14:26
Transurban, ERP, and the Joint Bridge
00:14:31
And now we'll go to questions.
SPEAKER_02
00:14:43
Do you have any idea at this point when or if North Carolina will be added to the list?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:14:58
When North Carolina is not looking to join the U.S. Network as a new direct member in Virginia, isn't what North Carolina is looking at?
00:15:14
The U.S. has recently created a new messaging category called a national affiliate.
00:15:16
Thank you.
SPEAKER_02
00:15:39
Yes, go ahead.
00:15:41
This is, 495 is open road polling, right?
00:15:44
So if you enter without an E-ZPass, it'll take your license plate.
00:15:49
Now, I've got an E-ZPass flex, and I've turned it off.
00:15:53
Is it sophisticated enough to know that I have an E-ZPass I've turned off that doesn't take my license plate picture?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:01
It's turned off.
00:16:02
It's turned one way or another way.
SPEAKER_02
00:16:05
In other words, so it knows not to build it.
00:16:06
It knows that I shouldn't be building it.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:16:08
The flex tag is not a hang-off switch.
00:16:12
It always operates.
00:16:14
What the HOV nomination does is it tells the system that you have three passengers, so don't build them.
SPEAKER_02
00:16:23
I just want to make sure.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:26
I just want to make a point that I made before.
00:16:28
In other areas, you can use a credit card.
00:16:31
I don't see why we haven't looked into that more carefully.
00:16:35
I think we need to make these
00:16:37
In my rural district, if you told the folks they had to buy a plastic box from the government to get on the road, their Second Amendment rights would come out.
00:16:49
I think we ought to consider credit card use.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:03
Richard Holton, okay, tell us.
SPEAKER_07
00:17:06
Thank you, Ms. Johnson.
00:17:07
A couple of questions.
00:17:08
Does the retailer pay for the initial employment board at $200?
00:17:12
Yes.
00:17:12
And pays what?
SPEAKER_01
00:17:13
Well, if you had to pay within a third day... How much does he pay per unit?
SPEAKER_07
00:17:22
$39.
00:17:22
$39.
00:17:22
So he's making $4 on the transaction.
00:17:25
Are there any residual benefits that, you know, as the transponders were planning?
00:17:32
It's a pretty low-margin transaction for a fair amount of money.
00:17:44
Have you all received any negative response from retailers?
SPEAKER_01
00:17:48
There are a couple of retailers who want a larger profit margin.
00:17:51
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:56
Miss Ellis, that was my question.
00:18:00
So can we go back to slide 11?
SPEAKER_01
00:18:03
Excuse me, sir?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:04
Slide 11.
SPEAKER_02
00:18:08
How do you verify?
00:18:10
When they switch to three or more, you use the total ID to verify that they have three or more.
00:18:16
If they switch to three or more and really only have one, what is their penalty?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:18:23
So, what do you say to me?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:29
I'm trying to remember everything, but it actually is not lost.
SPEAKER_02
00:18:32
Thejurian Services, on the same page, helped do the HOV enforcement.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:18:52
And after the state police call us, they are, as a state board, will have new equipment that will actually be able to know, the trooper will know, if they're not, that part of the tribe will have the transplant set and the HOV limit.
00:18:59
Yes, Mr. Secretary?
SPEAKER_01
00:19:16
All right, so we're six weeks out.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:27
From your saying July 1st.
00:19:29
Right now we don't have any retail contracts.
SPEAKER_01
00:19:35
Correct, sir.
00:19:36
But I assure you that we will have contracts.
00:19:41
Transurban is helping us with some of the negotiations.
00:19:44
They've made a few phone calls.
00:19:46
It is a collaborative effort and I feel very confident standing here telling you, sir, that we will have contracts.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:54
So when you're back up before us next month, you're going to...
SPEAKER_01
00:19:58
When I stand here next month, I will be able to give you the names of the companies that we're negotiating with and those who signed contracts.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:08
Okay.
00:20:08
Thank you, Ms. Johnson.
SPEAKER_01
00:20:09
You're welcome, sir.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:13
Can't wait to see you again, Ms. Johnson.
SPEAKER_01
00:20:16
As you told me last night, free the transponder.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:20
Free the transponder.
00:20:21
Let them run, run out on our highways.
SPEAKER_10
00:20:24
Any other questions?
00:20:26
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Secretary, I wanted to know, do you guys have cardboard signs just in case they don't come?
SPEAKER_02
00:20:32
We'll be standing out in the highway selling them?
00:20:35
Well, I do.
SPEAKER_01
00:20:36
Maybe I could get you all to assist me at the rest area.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:42
I think Mr. Miller would be excellent at that.
SPEAKER_01
00:20:48
No sir, we are working together collaboratively and I can't call out the names because you can't negotiate and tell the companies that you're working with but no sir, we will have signed contracts and if not, Mr. Secretary,
00:21:05
Never pick on a woman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:29
When my backup plan is the questions I got too hard, I'll come cry.
SPEAKER_10
00:21:42
But thank you very much.
00:22:06
Thank you.
SPEAKER_10
00:22:26
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, board members.
00:22:28
I've been asked to give two updates today, project briefs, one on the 460 project, one on the I-95 Hautenage project in Northern Virginia.
00:22:37
I'll start out with the Route 460 project.
00:22:39
I have Chris Lemons with me in the audience to answer any legal questions associated with the structure that we're going to go over on the Route 460 projects.
00:22:56
The first two slides will talk about some background information on the project.
00:22:59
You've heard this before.
00:23:00
We have three offers on the project.
00:23:02
Central Infrastructures, 460 Partners, and Multimodal Solutions.
00:23:06
We had meetings, proprietary meetings with each of the proposers last week to talk about this structure.
00:23:12
They were very productive meetings.
00:23:13
The commissioner met with each of the proposers one-on-one and talked to them.
00:23:18
And from what I got from it, and certainly the Commissioner Whirley can bring anything up, but certainly I thought they were positive meetings, and I think all are going to stay in under the procurement process that we have in place.
00:23:30
We have a competitive procurement.
00:23:32
The award is going to be based on the lowest present value of the public subsidy.
00:23:37
In other words, all three are going to be looking at the financial structure.
00:23:41
Theyíre going to bring financing to the project and theyíre going to bid the lowest public subsidy towards the project.
00:23:48
Each of the financial proposals will be investment, have an investment grade rating on the project.
00:23:54
The funding that they're bringing to the project, the cost of the project is going to be a fixed price, fixed date design-build cost, which will range anywhere between $1.5 and $2 billion.
00:24:05
We're hoping the competitive environment that is brought about by the three proposers will even reduce that more and reduce the public subsidy on the project.
00:24:15
This is just a picture of the corridor.
00:24:16
You've seen this many times.
00:24:18
A 55-mile corridor, a four-lane divided highway.
00:24:22
There are going to be seven interchanges and then the two terminus.
00:24:25
It goes from Suffolk to Petersburg coming out of the Hampton Roads area and coming south out of the Richmond-Petersburg area.
00:24:35
What I want to do over the next few slides is set a stage.
00:24:38
This is a different type of project.
00:24:41
A lot of projects that we've talked about in the past are concession model type projects, like the 95 Expressway, 495 Expressway, Midtown Tunnel.
00:24:49
Those are concession type models.
00:24:52
This one is going to be a design-build-finance type model.
00:24:56
And I'll get into a little bit more of the structure of what a design-build-finance is in a couple slides.
00:25:01
But there are some reasons that we're implementing a design-build finance approach on this one.
00:25:06
The total revenues in the early years are going to be very, very limited.
00:25:11
We just don't think the traffic is going to be there first, but we think it's going to grow over time.
00:25:15
For example, in 2018, when we think the facility is going to be on board, there will be about $14 million worth of revenue generated on the project.
00:25:22
Increasing over time, where in 2020, 18 million, 2030, about 28 million.
00:25:27
So increasing over time.
00:25:28
We think the traffic is going to come.
00:25:30
We think the growth along the corridor is going to come.
00:25:32
It's going to be there and we think the revenues are going to be higher.
00:25:35
But in the early years, the revenue is going to be pretty low.
00:25:39
It's going to be a greenfield project, which a greenfield project means it's going to be a new facility.
00:25:44
It's not an established facility like the Midtown Tunnel or 495.
00:25:48
And the risk of a greenfield-type project from the private sector's perspective is very high.
00:25:56
We're going to be creating a financial structure that looks for the cheapest type of debt, and I'll go through that a little bit later of the structure that we have that's looking for that cheapest type of debt that doesn't affect the Commonwealth's debt rate.
00:26:10
In speaking with Commissioner Whirley and others at VDOT, VDOT wanted to take a greater role because of the increased contribution that they're putting towards the project.
00:26:18
They want a greater role in setting the tolls over the term of the contract.
00:26:23
They want a greater role in setting the toll escalation parameters.
00:26:28
If there are rewards associated with the revenues that are being generated in the later years, they also want to be a part of that because of the contribution that Commonwealth is making for it.
00:26:38
And we're looking for a shorter term on the project.
00:26:40
Hopefully it will be no greater than or up to 40 years.
00:26:44
Our goal and hopefully with the revenues coming in that will be even less than the 40-year period.
00:26:52
Continuing with setting the stage of the project, again we're looking for the least expensive method to build the full scope of the project.
00:27:00
We looked at some alternative scopes of the project to try to reduce the cost.
00:27:03
We looked at two lanes, we looked at three lanes, we looked at a combination of the two, and really when we looked at the financing of the project,
00:27:11
It just wasn't worth it.
00:27:12
The revenues that fall off because of the lower scope just doesn't make the project worthwhile.
00:27:20
So Commissioner Whirley asked us to move forward and try to put a structure together that is full scope for the project.
00:27:26
We're looking at tax exempt debt for a 6320 corporation and you'll see a little bit later on I'm going to go through the structure for that 6320 corporation.
00:27:35
We're not looking for the private sector to bring any equity because we know with the type of risk that is on the type of Greenfield project the equity is going to be pretty high so another way of reducing the cost of the project is bringing no equity to the project itself.
00:27:52
So a combination of the public subsidy and the taxes and debt is the way we want to try to move forward with the structure.
00:27:58
VDOT is going to be taking on the long-term operations of the facility itself.
00:28:03
We found that going through an analysis.
00:28:06
VDOT is obviously very good at operating facilities.
00:28:09
The facility is going to be built new.
00:28:11
So in the early years, the first 20 years, we don't think there's going to be a lot of costs associated with the operations and maintenance of the facility.
00:28:19
So we wanted to take that out and have VDOT take on that goal.
00:28:23
So the two things that I really want to talk about and actions that will be in the June time period for the CTB is the formation of the 6320 non-profit corporation and providing a line of credit through a VTIV loan.
00:28:37
And I'll get into a little bit more of that when we go into the slides.
00:28:42
I'm going to skip over this slide because I think the benefits need to be explained a little bit after the structure itself.
00:28:50
This is the slide I think is going to be a good discussion point between the group itself.
00:28:55
What I want to try to do with this is first talk about the entities that are within the structure itself and then talk about the relationships.
00:29:05
The 6320 Corporation is something that we've done in the past.
00:29:10
We did it on the 495 Capital Beltway Project, and we've done it on the Pocahontas Park Road Project.
00:29:15
So it is something that the Commonwealth has done in the past on P3 projects.
00:29:20
And it's a non-stock, non-profit corporation organized under the Virginia Non-Stock Corporation Act.
00:29:28
The 6320 Corporation really is the centerpiece of the structure that we have here.
00:29:34
The other entities are obviously VDOT, the design-build contractor, or the offer of the private sector coming in.
00:29:41
You'll see on here the circle.
00:29:44
Who are the owners of the 6320 non-profit?
00:29:47
Well, there will be board members established by the sponsor, which is the Department of Transportation.
00:29:55
So along with the private sector and the Department of Transportation, there will be corporate board members.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:02
Okay.
00:30:02
Who do you anticipate that will be?
SPEAKER_10
00:30:05
Those corporate board members have not been identified.
00:30:08
We'll work with Mr. Whirley and the secretary cannot identify those and also with the private sector.
00:30:14
Certainly Chris can come up and identify the structure but it's usually about 80-20.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:23
I'm more interested in sort of what the roles and responsibilities are, what the power is, what the authority is.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:32
So we have one on 495.
SPEAKER_10
00:30:33
We had one on 495.
00:30:36
It's no longer in 495 because it was specifically for the reinvestment of the bonds after commercial growth.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:45
Could you just talk about that in Pocahontas, how the board members were selected?
00:30:49
Because actually, I don't know.
SPEAKER_02
00:30:50
That was before I was here.
00:30:53
Mr. Chairman, Chris Lemonsby, Attorney General's office.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:55
The board members of the second 220 corporation are selected at the outset and are typically included in the work of the corporation and non-stop corporation.
SPEAKER_02
00:31:16
There can be as few as one or as many as is determined appropriate.
00:31:17
They can be constituted in the universe of the closely affiliated public transportation board.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:19
For the Route 460 project, we are in the process of evaluating the next number that will be appropriate.
00:31:37
Some of this is wrapped up into questions related to accounting treatment of the actual debt that will be issued by the City of Greenville Corporation, and how closely are the seats you would want the floor members to be in.
00:31:42
So that's an open area of the facilities that we're taking right now.
00:31:43
But as Dusty mentioned, the 6320 Corporation is an entity that is a product of Virginia Corporation law, particularly the Nonstop Corporation Act, and IRS revenue rule of 6320, which allows for information that's necessary to conduct services, activities, including the issuance of tax and debt on behalf of this public purpose.
00:32:08
The roles and responsibilities of the board members?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:29
Yeah, the roles and responsibilities of the board members are set forth in the articles of the corporation, and it's really just to assert the tendency of women to be shared meetings of board members in law.
SPEAKER_06
00:32:35
Really what the... and that would be... What does that mean?
00:32:36
It would be to...
00:32:36
No operational.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:56
Okay, that's what the question was.
SPEAKER_02
00:33:03
Will be at VDOT.
00:33:05
Toll charging, that would not be a responsibility.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:09
And would you anticipate, I know you said you had suggested the proper mix, would you anticipate and would it be allowable to have functionally state slash VDOT control of the board?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:30
I mean, whenever you're asking one board to create another board, then, you know, we have roles and responsibilities with this board.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:49
Obviously, the secretary has roles and responsibilities with the commissioner.
00:33:53
And you set up another board, you know, the import is
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:58
What can they do and what could they do that we wouldn't want them to do?
SPEAKER_10
00:34:28
Thank you.
00:34:36
We have a question.
00:34:38
Continuing with the structure itself, you see the 6320 collaboration VDOT is going to be a key player in the development of the 6320 corporation and the administration of it.
00:34:44
You have the offer of the private sector coming in.
00:34:47
You see the lines of contract service and cash flow three above the 6320.
00:34:54
Certainly the users and the tolls
00:34:56
The whole revenue generated coming to the 6320 Corporation.
00:35:10
The VTIP loan, which I'll talk about a little bit later, is a credit enhancement to the revenues generated for the 6320 Corporation and the Packington debt.
00:35:17
The total operations will come out of the 6320 Corporation level in the Community Department of Transportation when it takes the 6320 Corporation, once it's really passed through the corporation.
00:35:21
So the operational control will rest with VDOT?
SPEAKER_02
00:35:35
So the administrative control, we got that.
00:35:38
But who would make the ultimate decision on how much the toll would be?
SPEAKER_10
00:35:43
VDOT will maintain when to raise the tolls, so VDOT will be making that, that's my question.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:01
And ultimately, this board's role
00:36:08
in terms of approving the structure and or funding it.
SPEAKER_10
00:36:14
Can you, well, somewhere in your presentation I'd like to get to that.
00:36:23
Right, I think there'll be several roles for this board.
00:36:32
One is to give approval to the Portland 632 corporation.
00:36:33
The second is to move forward with a 10 million dollar VTIP loan, this credit enhancement program itself.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:38
And certainly any funding that goes to the property coming into the Six-Year Plan will be disclosed through it.
00:36:42
And with the VTIP loan, the
00:36:44
Subordinated to the tax exempt debt repayment.
SPEAKER_02
00:36:50
Just one more question.
00:36:51
VDOT's doing the tolling.
00:36:53
That authority rests with them.
00:36:56
I'm just trying to get to it.
00:36:57
So you legislatively can do the tolling.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:00
We could do it or you could do it.
00:37:21
That's an interesting dilemma for us.
SPEAKER_10
00:37:35
The sole authority.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:44
So what?
SPEAKER_10
00:37:47
The Virginia Harbor Transportation is a responsible public entity as defined in the UTA law as allowed to develop a feature.
SPEAKER_02
00:38:00
Allowed to develop a what?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:03
The public private transportation act enables Virginia Harbor Transportation to enter into a comprehensive agreement that says user fees for the use of transportation as a
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:14
And we, because I heard something a little differently, or I interpreted it a little differently from what the chairman said.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:21
Is there opportunity for conflict there?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:45
Or is it either war?
00:38:48
You know, what if VDOT didn't want a call and we did?
00:38:53
You said no call.
00:38:54
Christmas said no call.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:38:56
And CTB said, yeah, we want a ten-cent call.
SPEAKER_02
00:39:08
I think it's a practical matter that it would be something that would have to be worked out before the leadership would play on it.
00:39:13
It would go to different parties.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:17
In some areas, whenever we have co-authorities or dual authority, you know, what happens when you don't agree?
00:39:26
In this area, the guidance may be an invitation to struggle.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:39:30
Yeah, that's a good way to put it.
SPEAKER_10
00:39:33
And I would suggest that both the chairman and vice chairman of the board members were reasonable representatives.
SPEAKER_02
00:39:40
Yeah, I expected sort of backup of the board, I guess.
SPEAKER_10
00:39:43
All right, some of the business terms, we can talk about this financing through the 6320 Corporation.
00:39:53
We'll have a debt service reserve account set up.
00:39:57
The private sector will also have the opportunity to do a ramp up reserve account utilizing some of the public dollars that are on there.
00:40:04
So we talked about operations and maintenance.
00:40:06
VDOT will retain that responsibility.
00:40:08
Tolling operations will go through the 6-320 Corporation, those will be paid by VDOT.
00:40:12
Comprehensive agreement will be a three-party agreement between the private partner, the 6-320 Corporation, and Virginia Department of Transportation.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:21
As I said, the term is going to be no greater than 40 years.
SPEAKER_10
00:40:25
Really what the term is, depending on the financing structure that comes in from the private sector, will be tied to when the debt is paid.
00:40:32
The structure that we had looked at before was a 99-year term, so the reason that we put this structure together was certainly some information from your office to try to reduce the number of years for this term, and again, after the term, it becomes
00:40:56
I've been trying to figure out exactly what the benefit of having a private partner in this project is.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:18
The state owns it, VDOT's going to operate it, and yet we've got a private partner.
00:41:25
I'm curious, what are the advantages of having a private partner in this?
00:41:28
Is it just to have somebody else take the heat for borrowing the money rather than having Commonwealth do it?
SPEAKER_10
00:41:33
Well, we certainly like that as part of it, but the private sector brings anywhere between, we're estimating between $400 and $600 million to pay the project to bring the private financing in to bridge the amount and reduce the public subsidy that the department has to pay.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:51
And they're willing to put up $400 million and not own the project and not operate it.
00:41:59
I'm trying to figure out the incentive for that.
SPEAKER_10
00:42:02
Well, the incentive really is associated with the design and build aspect of the project.
00:42:06
So you have a $1.5 billion design and build element of the project, and they're going to be able to see profit in there.
00:42:13
They're going to be able to see profit in the work that they're doing, putting the financing together.
00:42:18
So there are some areas where the private sector can see some profit.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:26
Thank you.
00:42:27
I wanted to follow up where Dr. Davis was because your slide three lists the risks for the private sector, which is why this project is being considered in a different way.
00:42:42
And I just wonder if the strength of the Public Private Transportation Act is to actually take signals from the private sector about what makes good investment to their conclusion that equity is risky here?
00:42:56
That there is a free road that parallels it.
00:42:58
I mean, why isn't that a similar signal to the public sector that this may not be the best way to go?
00:43:05
And then finally, I understand why the Commonwealth, particularly given the current climate, might want to have a bigger say-so in the setting of tolls and particularly the escalation of tolls going forward.
00:43:16
But as we found out, that carries its own set of risks.
00:43:19
I mean, currently the climate about tolls us pretty negative.
00:43:23
And I'm just wondering if we haven't missed a signal or two from the private sector, like you're determined to go ahead, fine, but the normal private sector interest that we would bring to a project of this kind, we're actually going to limit our own risk and step back.
00:43:41
I realize that this project also came forward in a different manner.
00:43:46
You know, it wasn't really a proposal.
00:43:50
It didn't fit a neat pattern.
00:43:51
I mean, there's been a, I think maybe that probably some of that history would be useful to some of the newer members particularly.
00:43:57
So I just wanted to get further comments about that.
SPEAKER_10
00:44:01
Well, it certainly is a different structure.
00:44:03
The economics of the project make it a very tough project to advance, whether it be a P3 or whether it be a design bid bill or a design bid.
00:44:13
And what we've tried to do really over the last four or five years in working with the private sector is try to identify a structure that meets the needs of not only the private sector, because they certainly want to be a part of this, but also the public sector.
00:44:30
And meeting, obviously this is the governor's top priority of the project and we recognize that.
00:44:35
Some of the other objectives of the project are creating an evacuation route, creating a route where economic development along the corridor can increase, creating access from the ports to the
00:44:51
So there are certainly ancillary reasons for us to advance this project.
00:45:05
The economics, the structure that we put together, we think is the best form of the economics of the project itself.
00:45:13
But you're right, there are other structures.
00:45:15
The private sector has talked to us a lot about
00:45:18
How much of a contribution we ought to make and the structure that they feel.
00:45:22
It's just over time we've tried to work on this structure and make this project move forward.
00:45:28
And it may not be the best economical structure, but we think with the long-term view of development of the project and the potential revenues that are generated for it, it's a positive thing.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:42
So the three, you expect to get three good
SPEAKER_10
00:45:45
And you know, I just want to say thank you very much for your time.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:15
We have a certain amount of money, and we all recognize that there needs to be improvements to mobility, east-west mobility.
00:46:35
We want to have a certain amount of money.
00:46:38
If we were to try and make improvements in 61, we're probably looking at close to $10 billion.
00:46:46
between adding a tube on either the Emperor's Bridge Tunnel monster.
00:46:51
I think that on the list of P3 on the Emperor's Bridge Tunnel was 5.5 millions.
00:46:57
Then we're doing the total widening just by one, maybe two lanes on 64 in the peninsula.
00:47:06
That's trying to come out to about 3,000.
00:47:07
Now let's just say, then we still have to make the perfect top 64 in the lower, in the eastern part of the peninsula to deal with, if we were to make the current reserve.
00:47:18
We don't have anywhere near the funds available to do either one of those projects.
00:47:23
We have a project over here that's about 1.5 million.
00:47:27
We maybe have half, maybe a little bit more, whatever, after we work out with the flooring stuff.
00:47:32
And the issue is, though, is that we don't want to build this thing where it's not an attractive nuisance, where we have the toll rates because of a traditional P3.
00:47:47
First off, it's a great deal.
00:47:48
And right now, the P3 community is very leery about 3 million meals.
00:47:53
We don't have any real data on tractors.
00:47:57
So they're going to have to make much higher rates of return from us for their investment.
00:48:02
And so then we have to step back and go, well, that means that to get that higher rate of return, we're going to have much higher tolls, which then defeats the whole purpose of going forward with the project because people are not going to spend some of the number of tolls that they're talking about because they have 64 particularly to go off.
00:48:21
So this is, they're come up with a creative way where we can
00:48:25
It's actually built to create a four-lane interstate grade 55-mile road with 1.5 million or so that fits quantically and generally in our budget, increases mobility, and we can keep the toll rates low enough that people will use it.
00:48:46
So that's generally why they're coming down to me, but I keep on pointing out this thing
00:49:10
If we're going to do anything to Hampton Roads right now, this is the only way to give the world money so we can get something done that actually will make it successful.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:21
Mr. Chairman, in terms of the private sector, were they sending signals and maybe we should step back.
00:49:31
They were willing to invest in the project.
00:49:33
They are willing to put equity in the project.
00:49:36
But it's how much do they want for that?
00:49:38
As the Secretary mentioned, the rates were up.
00:49:41
But they also wanted an upside.
00:49:43
They also wanted to share in the long-term revenue of the project.
00:49:49
So if the revenue 20 years out was more than what I needed to pay the debt service, then they wanted a share of that revenue.
00:49:59
They also wanted a long-term, beyond 40 years, in the nine-year range, an agreement.
00:50:08
So they'd be sharing in that revenue for 40 years, when your debt is already paid off.
00:50:15
And in my view was, if we're putting X amount of money into this game,
00:50:22
That's why we structured the way we did.
00:50:28
So quite frankly, they did want to put some equity money in the game.
00:50:33
But I just felt it cost me too much long term.
00:50:37
So we went with the 63-20 to look to more of the debt financing.
00:50:43
And we felt this was a better way to come with the state control.
00:50:49
Dusty, my question is kind of a follow-up to Dr. Davis and Doug's.
SPEAKER_02
00:51:05
What are the principal bogeys here for the Commonwealth?
00:51:09
If the 6320 moves forward, where's the downside to this?
00:51:15
Is it the exposure of not generating the revenue and we have to make it up?
00:51:19
in the future.
00:51:21
Is that the principle one or I just want to know, you know, we've heard all the plus sides and I certainly support that and what the governor wants to do and support Hampton Roads, but I want to also know it's our responsibility to know a downside to this and where's the exposure to the Commonwealth.
SPEAKER_10
00:51:39
From a financial perspective, the 6320 Corporation takes exposure for the tax credit.
00:51:46
I think the exposure for the department is, if the revenues do not show up, then certainly we'll have the VITA's loan that is out there as a credit to have.
00:51:58
We'll have the Tom Wells contribution during the design-build part of the construction of the project.
00:52:06
And I would suggest, hopefully, I would see the design-build contract shifting risk of the design-build over to the private sector itself.
00:52:15
But we'll have risks associated with that.
00:52:18
There's a risk-sharing that will be a part of the right-of-way acquisition.
00:52:21
Fifty-five miles of right-of-way acquisition certainly has its risks associated with it.
00:52:25
We have a risk-sharing regime in the contract itself, but the department, after an up and down of 10% on the inverse allowance that we have, we'll take the risk from part of that.
00:52:35
So there are some risk elements of both the design build and of the financing, similar to what you would see on one other piece of the budget.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:44
Okay, thank you, Dustin.
00:52:45
And I just want to point out, I know you're right about the $6,320, I mean, unfortunately, because
00:52:52
There is no recourse to us or the Commonwealth Board, the bond ratings when we want that.
00:52:58
I will point out that we have a 6320 on electronics and the issue is that we have the opportunity once the thing is up and operating.
00:53:19
The issue right now is getting over this
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:21
But we did, you're right, the rest is in the revenue.
00:53:27
I should say it's the rest in the long term.
00:53:30
But we mitigated that risk by looking at the traffic and parking study.
00:53:34
And we only used a very conservative amount in terms of linking that to the debt.
00:53:40
In other words, we didn't take 100% of that revenue to see what debt could be raised off of it.
00:53:45
We took a conservative amount.
00:53:47
So that mitigates some of the risk.
00:53:50
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:51
Mr. Chairman?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:57
Yes.
SPEAKER_02
00:53:58
All right.
00:54:01
How much money are we talking and when?
00:54:04
Did we have 500 million kind of set aside in the governor's budget plan, the transportation plan?
00:54:14
Then how much more and where's the new money coming from and what are we looking at in total for us?
00:54:18
Thank you very much.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:19
We haven't set anybody aside.
00:54:25
What we have is bonds and charges.
00:54:32
That's what's been set aside right now within the six-year plan.
00:54:39
But the amount we have to put in will all depend on what the design, build, and finance years come past that.
SPEAKER_02
00:54:50
Well, we think it's one and a half to two billion dollar project.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:55
Well, there might be less.
00:54:57
But again, we don't know what our numbers are going to be.
00:54:59
But you all have the opportunity to come back.
00:55:04
So they're going to come back.
00:55:08
What essentially is going to happen is this proposal is going to go to the three, all three bidders, and they're going to come back in whatever is the best deal.
00:55:29
I've got a hole here, Dusty, I need you to help me fill.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:55
The 6320 would be an entity that we would create.
00:55:59
There's no recourse on the tax exempt debt except to the 6320 which doesn't own anything other than the tolls, the tolling revenue.
00:56:09
The VTIB is a credit enhancement loan to the 6320 with no recourse back to the state.
00:56:17
Is that, is that, is that, is the only way to get that loan paid back or the only recourse tolling money?
SPEAKER_10
00:56:24
Yes, the total revenue is the only funds that are going in, besides the initial.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:30
It's the only recourse.
00:56:32
So if, let's just use the worst case scenario, no car ever drives down until there's zero toll revenue, the 6320 goes into default on its tax exempt debt and its VTIP one, and the people who bought the debt are out, and the VTIP is out,
00:56:50
Go for it.
SPEAKER_10
00:56:51
That would be a very bad scenario.
00:56:53
Well, of course.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:54
I'm trying to use the worst one to just sort of get a ground zero.
SPEAKER_10
00:56:57
The B2 is a credit in hand.
00:56:59
In other words, under your scenario, if no car shows up in the first year, there's a debt service that has to be paid.
00:57:10
There'll be a debt service coverage ratio that's first hoped into, ramp up reserve that's put into.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:16
Do they own the road in default?
00:57:18
I mean, what do they get?
00:57:20
If the revenue does not cover the debt service?
SPEAKER_10
00:57:26
Each of the reserves.
00:57:28
Each of the reserves will first be put into to try to cover that debt.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:33
And the reserves are created by what funding mechanism?
SPEAKER_10
00:57:38
Well, the lenders will require both the debt to service coverage ratio and the grant money.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:46
But in my illustration, we never had any revenue.
00:57:49
So if your revenue is funding your reserve, that doesn't exist.
00:57:57
So the reserves are built up within the tolling revenue stream, we're pulling some out of the reserves, assuming we're making our debt payments and so forth and so on.
00:58:06
Okay, so I get that.
00:58:08
Now, the private partner, back to Dr. Davis' question, the private partner,
00:58:17
who's going to get this design-build contract.
00:58:21
They're going to make us an offer and we're going to say yes or no.
00:58:27
And in their offer they're going to say I'm going to build this road to these standards for a billion and a half dollars.
00:58:34
Okay?
00:58:35
And we're going to pay them
00:58:36
A billion and a half dollars to do that, is that correct?
00:58:40
That's correct.
SPEAKER_10
00:58:41
Okay.
00:58:42
A combination of the financing brought by the private sector and the public contribution sector.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:46
Where is the financing brought by the private sector?
00:58:49
Is that the, is that the 6320 debt?
SPEAKER_10
00:58:53
Yeah, that is the, if you look at the, going back to your... That's where I am.
00:58:58
That's the tax agent debt.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:00
And with the credit enhancement behind it.
00:59:02
That's true.
00:59:03
Okay, so that comes in to pay the, to pay the contract.
SPEAKER_10
00:59:05
Pay the contract, yes sir.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:06
And what else?
SPEAKER_10
00:59:09
You said it was a combination of the... What, the 6320 Corporation will also be paying for the tolling operations.
00:59:16
They're going to be passed with the Department of Transportation will pay for the tolling operations.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:21
And would the design-build contractor run the tolling operations?
00:59:25
Maybe, maybe not.
SPEAKER_10
00:59:27
Yeah, we, I don't think the design, but the design of a contractor will not work around the total.
00:59:31
Okay, so we're going to pay.
00:59:32
There must be another entity that is secured to run the total.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:34
That's fine, so it's a separate beast that will basically outsource the towing operation to somebody, the payment fee to collect it.
00:59:42
Right.
00:59:42
So the design-build guy, let's say, it's a billion five.
00:59:46
We fund it with a tax-exempt debt and the VTIP enhancement, and I presume that that raises
00:59:54
This is where I broke down.
00:59:59
Here's where I broke down.
01:00:06
Okay, so we got the contractor who built the road.
01:00:10
We paid them the money.
01:00:12
Their risk is they got to deliver the project for the amount of money that they shed, given the specs we gave them and so forth and so on.
01:00:20
Then there was some mention, either by the secretary or somebody,
01:00:24
If they could have as much as $400 to $600 million in the deal.
SPEAKER_10
01:00:28
That's the tax-exempt debt.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:30
The tax-exempt debt isn't the zon-bill contractor's issue, is it?
SPEAKER_10
01:00:35
It's the 6320's issue.
01:00:36
Yeah, that's correct.
01:00:38
It's the 6320 corporation's issue for the tax-exempt debt.
01:00:43
But that's the $400 to $600 million that is the tax-exempt debt that the private sector is bringing into the 6320 corporation.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:52
So are you telling me that in this chart, the design-build contract slash offeror, what's their relationship to the tax exempt debt?
01:01:03
There is none in this chart.
SPEAKER_10
01:01:04
I would see, and certainly the Commissioner can clarify this, but I would see the private sector's financing people being financed by... Talk about the design-build contractor, because it can be different private sectors.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:18
I'm looking at the contractor that's going to build the road.
01:01:21
The three that you listed here, they're gonna make us an offer.
01:01:25
Are they bringing debt?
SPEAKER_06
01:01:26
They are bringing... Or equity?
SPEAKER_10
01:01:29
No, they're not bringing any equity.
01:01:30
There's no equity.
01:01:31
No equity at all.
01:01:31
Are they going and securing debt?
01:01:33
They are going out and securing commitments for debt, and those debts will be transferred over to the 6320 Corporation.
01:01:40
So I would see the price sector, as much as a financial advisor, bringing in the debt for the 6320 Corporation and also the design bill coming up.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:51
And so they're going to have to be compensated for that activity, not just the building, but they're going in and identifying the debt, securing the debt, transferring the tax-exempt debt, if you will, to the 634.
SPEAKER_10
01:02:02
And that will be all in the cost, the upfront cost that they provide to the department as the lowest public sector.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:10
Okay.
01:02:10
So let's say that's a billion and a half, back to the model.
01:02:16
You suggested that the debt piece
01:02:19
What I heard, that they would raise and transfer, is $600 million.
SPEAKER_10
01:02:25
We've estimated the $3.4 million.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:27
Okay, pick six, because that's the better number in the illustration.
01:02:31
So it's $600 million that they're going to go secure and dump into the $6,320, which functionally is going to pay back to them, but it costs $1.5 billion.
01:02:40
So there's $900 million that we haven't paid for yet.
01:02:47
Okay, we haven't given to design-build people yet.
01:02:52
So, where does that come from?
01:03:00
So, we put the public, so in this illustration we have to inject 900 million dollars.
01:03:09
I presume that's paid during the contract period, not over some
01:03:13
So functionally what we're doing is we're creating an entity that will hold some debt non-recourse to the rest of us.
01:03:29
We're getting the contractor and their team to build it and go find the $600 million in debt and transfer it over to the entity.
01:03:37
Then we throw in $900 million
01:03:39
and we control the rest of it northward.
01:03:52
I presume when you were talking about the toll revenue that was coming through in your illustration, I think you used 14 million and 18 million and 20 million, what tolling rate and what
01:04:07
What volume were you using to get to those numbers?
SPEAKER_10
01:04:12
Are we looking at a tolling rate of anywhere between 7 cents to 10 cents per mile?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:19
So it's 55 miles, let's get it on the...
01:04:22
Okay, so it's dependent on the exit you get off?
01:04:26
It's variable depending on the exit you get off?
SPEAKER_10
01:04:28
The distance that you go.
01:04:30
It'll be a closed distance, so there'll be gantries at each of the exits.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:35
So if you went the whole way,
01:04:37
So you're thinking that given this model, we can do it for ten cents a mile?
SPEAKER_10
01:05:00
Well, I'm giving you now.
01:05:05
Okay, we'll do the 10.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:07
Pick the 10 and everything you do better.
SPEAKER_10
01:05:09
It'll do better for the project.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:14
Okay, last question.
01:05:16
The non-tolling O&M TAMS contract, is that another?
01:05:21
So, in theory, we could have three private sector partners, the one who builds it and secures the financing, the one who runs the tolling operations, and the one who does the O&M.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:39
So, Mr. Chairman, the TAMs, the maintenance police, is like any other contract that we do now to maintain interstate roads, so I wouldn't classify them as a partner on this project.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:52
Well, same with the tolling operations in a sense.
01:05:55
They're just a vendor.
01:05:57
So the risk, back to my illustration, or my earlier question, the risk that the design-build partner has is that they've got to bring the contract in on budget, on time.
01:06:12
They have to provide the debt at whatever level was in the agreement.
01:06:19
I presume.
01:06:20
If they don't get the debt at whatever number that is, the amount and the rate, is that risk on them or is that risk back on us?
SPEAKER_10
01:06:30
Well, to have a compliant proposal, they will have to bring the committee.
01:06:35
The committed debt to the proposal.
01:06:37
At an investment rate rate.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:40
Thank you.
01:06:42
Mr. Chairman.
01:06:42
Mr. Rich.
01:06:42
I'm just a little confused.
01:06:45
Dusty, you told Chef we'd have gone up with $900 million, right?
01:06:49
Well, the illustration I used was 900, so where did that come from?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:16
Are we all living in that up here?
SPEAKER_10
01:07:31
Whatever the number is, I don't care if it's 500 million, 30 million, or not in a way, it's basically going to be garbage.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:45
So the whole thing will basically be borrowed money, whether it's taxes and debt brought by the private partner into the 6320s, or whatever our contribution has to be, our contribution will come through Garvey Bond Debt.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:01
The V-TIP loan won't be used as a credit.
SPEAKER_10
01:08:08
It's a $8 million credit enhancement.
01:08:18
Most of it, the public contribution will be coming from Garvey's.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:22
And you have here, we're going to vote on the BTIP loan in June?
01:08:31
Really?
01:08:31
I thought we wouldn't come before November.
SPEAKER_10
01:08:35
We'll put an application in for the BTIP loan.
01:08:38
We'll seek your permission in June to move forward with the BTIP loan so we have that credit enhancement in place as we move forward with the private sector.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:47
I guess the local skin of the game is the court.
01:08:51
As you know, in Northern Virginia, we're asking the counties to pay for Dulles Air Force.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:55
And you have Route 28, we've had the taxpayers and the local counties paying for Tyson's corner people.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:01
Are there any businesses along this route that are contributing to this?
01:09:07
The local skin of the game is a board, essentially.
SPEAKER_02
01:09:13
Dusty, given the fact that we've got corridor improvements along that route between Patrick and Rayl coming online and so forth,
01:09:24
Does the model give you any discomfort in the revenue predictors or the revenue on tolls to meet this debt support?
01:09:32
It seems to be a little bit fluid as we look at bringing that rail service online.
01:09:38
It's going to take some cars off the road, obviously.
SPEAKER_07
01:09:41
I would imagine that the model will be variable.
SPEAKER_10
01:09:45
Certainly the timing of those improvements have been input into the model itself.
01:09:49
We don't think it's going to have a significant impact.
01:09:52
We see a large growth in the trucks, the heavy vehicles on the facility itself go into the distribution centers and they won't be using the rail, the high-speed rail, the transit element.
01:10:06
So we don't see a big hiccup associated with that.
01:10:11
Certainly there will be a little bit of diversion off the roadway associated with that.
01:10:17
We don't see that.
SPEAKER_07
01:10:18
Mr. Cole.
01:10:20
Mr. Chairman, one quick question.
01:10:22
Assuming that your modeling didn't suggest the Sheppard Miller scenario of zero traffic, what does it suggest 10 years out, traffic levels?
SPEAKER_10
01:10:32
From a revenue perspective?
SPEAKER_07
01:10:34
Well, no, from an actual traffic count.
SPEAKER_10
01:10:37
I would say that 10 years out, it's probably going to be about 13 to 15,000 vehicles a day.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:44
How many is that a year?
SPEAKER_10
01:10:47
Well, under our scenario, under our financial model, we think on day one it's going to be about 8,100 vehicles a day.
01:10:57
So you're discounting off the current, it's about 10,000 now on?
01:11:02
On existing 46, there's 11,500 on existing 46, so we are discounting the use of the pre-altitude.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:11
Do you have a sense of, forget the trucks, let me ask you a few questions.
01:11:21
How much of this do you think in the short term is commercial traffic, meaning truck traffic that's sort of going through, versus automobile traffic?
01:11:32
And I presume the rates are going to be, the $550 for the whole trip is probably for a car, not a truck, or is it the same?
01:11:38
So, the difference in time for the trip, for the length, versus the alternative next to it.
01:11:55
The alternative is
01:11:57
55 miles an hour for 80% of the trip, and it's 30 miles an hour for 20% of the trip.
01:12:06
What's the time savings for, you know, not calculating accidents and all that, but just regular throughput?
SPEAKER_10
01:12:13
We think that there's going to be about 15 to 20 minutes of time savings utilizing the new facilities.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:20
Thank you.
SPEAKER_10
01:12:22
Over 55 miles.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:22
Over 55 miles.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:24
The whole route.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:26
And it gives you an alternative, and it gives you more throughput, and it gives you economic development opportunities.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:32
And it runs through, let me just lay out the other issue here, and that is, it will run through two megabytes.
01:12:43
Two megabytes?
01:12:43
Two megabytes.
01:12:45
We have right now dial point and that's 1,800 acres under their control.
01:13:04
That's 1,500 acres under their control.
01:13:05
That's my second time on the rail.
01:13:06
And it will be my second time on the rail.
01:13:07
There will be the only true megabytes of cataracts that will have road and rail access, which has been one of our biggest challenges.
01:13:31
We lost caterpillar for this one.
01:13:31
It was not one acceptable cataract check that that caterpillar would find.
01:13:33
If we had this up and right, we would have gotten caterpillars.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:37
Mr. Secretary, is there a way once these megacenters get going that they can help pay for this?
01:13:42
I'm sorry?
01:13:42
Is there a way once we get this thing going that the megacenters can help finance?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:47
Well, that's one of the reasons we asked in this General Assembly session for the ability at the state level to do an aspect of the finance system.
01:13:57
Right.
01:13:57
And this is one of the reasons we asked for it, so that as we build the LLCs on this road, in other ways that are having to correct that comment, develop an impact, put that in the role of the conference
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:17
Despite my earlier questions, Mr. Chairman, I wanted to make a positive comment.
01:14:23
Number one, I'm very encouraged that the leadership of VDOT and your leadership, but also VDOT, has become much more entrepreneurial and much more sophisticated in the last five years.
01:14:36
I mean, we would not have been even talking about this type of structure then at all.
01:14:42
And I think this is what our times requires.
01:14:45
The sophistication of flexibility to do deals that are possible.
01:14:49
You made a very good point, Mr. Secretary, which I wanted to second.
01:14:55
Positively or negatively, we're going to be building from this point on what we can afford, and we need these type of instruments that are slightly different to be able to do that.
01:15:05
But we also need to be very honest.
01:15:07
I mean, these sophisticated structures are necessary to accommodate the limits on state cash and state borrowing capacity.
01:15:17
And so we are doing something that extends our reach a little bit further than we traditionally have thought about it.
01:15:24
And it's going to be up to us to make good decisions very early in these processes to make sure we don't get ourselves out on limbs.
01:15:32
In this case, I think the questions today has helped me understand this a lot better.
01:15:37
And I want to be encouraging to this particular process, but also the larger process of being smart, sophisticated, and flexible as we go forward.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:48
And after this presentation, before this comes back in June, I want to tell you if you can reach out to all the board members and go see them and talk to them and walk through any questions.
01:16:05
You know, you're right on.
01:16:07
We are really going to have to do things.
01:16:12
We've gone past the issue of just something we haven't, you know, a page ago on building capital projects, giving them where the revenue streams are, and we have to figure out ways to get done while we do what the hell we can.
SPEAKER_02
01:16:27
Is there a 5% borrowing limit for roads and does this not count against that because of the 6320?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:46
What do you anticipate the rate would be on the part of the loan or on the debt?
01:16:56
Given it's not recourse, it's all polling revenues, so there's risk in that.
SPEAKER_10
01:17:02
I would hate to speculate on the markets with all the different parameters that are part of it, but I would say we're sort of anywhere between 4% to 5% on the tax season.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:13
Well obviously that's factored into what we think this project's going to cost and what we think the toll would have to be, and you know, so 4, 5%.
01:17:23
And it would be debts for a halfway period of time?
SPEAKER_10
01:17:26
Well, that will be part of the financial package that comes back with a number greater than 40 years.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:40
I'll just point out that you should have $7,000 on all the caps.
01:17:42
That'll get us a triple B-minus, and we've got a 4.5, 3.5, 5.5.
01:17:44
5.5.
01:17:44
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:45
All right, so we'll be coming back to this in June.
SPEAKER_10
01:17:52
We talked a lot about it, $8 million in credit.
01:17:57
My office will be submitting the application for it.
01:18:00
I will be working with the Department of Transportation, VRA, and VTS advisory panel to complete the process and turn it back to you as we explore and action the outcomes.
01:18:13
Key Milestones, Associated Public Outreach, certainly we made some commitments to the General Assembly or if we want to be as transparent as possible.
01:18:22
Of course, the detail proposals and then this will go out on May 25th.
01:18:26
Prior to that, we'll be doing some public notice.
01:18:29
Outreach to the DA members, today's CTB presentation.
01:18:32
Moving forward with the selection of offers, we'll be back here in front of this board making sure that you know the main business points and what folks came in on.
01:18:41
Certainly execution of the contract will put public notice out there and make sure that the comprehensive agreement and all the other documents are available as published.
01:18:49
These are just the next steps.
01:18:51
June formation of the 6320 Corporation and the VTIP loan in front of this roof.
01:18:57
In September, they offer to submit their detailed proposals to go through an evaluation and selection process.
01:19:01
We'll come back to those in this audience and talk about the business points.
01:19:05
Go to commercial financial closing in the December time period.
01:19:08
Construction begins in 2013.
01:19:10
and construction completed five years later, only begins at that same time period.
01:19:16
And with that, any other questions?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:18
Mr. Chairman, I was just curious, the 5320th code section, is that what it's called?
01:19:22
Yeah, IRS code section.
01:19:23
I was trying to figure out what the match was and why it didn't add up to 100.
SPEAKER_02
01:19:27
Does this project include 58 getting out of the port?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:36
It doesn't pick that up, does it?
01:19:39
It does not.
SPEAKER_10
01:19:39
The scope of this project starts right at 58 in Suffolk and goes to a few.
SPEAKER_02
01:19:45
So we may have to come back and deal with that?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:47
I think that that certainly is just a project that we should look at.
01:19:55
Okay, 95.
SPEAKER_10
01:19:57
95?
01:19:58
Anybody seen this slide before?
01:20:00
It's the same scope as we've talked about in the past.
01:20:03
This is a 9-mile extension, 14 miles of expanding existing HRV, 6 miles of operational improvements on the 95, and certainly some access improvements.
01:20:14
Another slide that we've seen before, concessionary party consistent with the 495 is Florida Transurban, joint venture is Florida Lane.
01:20:22
The term of this project will be three years of construction and 73 years operating period.
01:20:27
The reason that we did that, we wanted to make it co-terminus with the 495 project.
01:20:32
The time bill possibly fixed price, fixed date, the time bill possibly anticipated and negotiated an amount of $620 million.
01:20:41
Some of the major things that have emerged is to get the packages secured in the different time periods, given the business points, for finalizing the elements of the comprehensive agreement.
01:20:57
FTU has gotten underwriters for the federal aid process with the draft version of the comprehensive agreement.
01:21:03
In December, we received a TIBE grant of $20 million, which equates to about $150 to $260 million.
01:21:10
We were just recently able to afford a grant.
01:21:15
The ability to submit an application for a TIFIA loan, we've combined those two processes.
01:21:22
We've been working with USDOT and the TIFIA office to combine those two processes to create a $300 million loan that will come through the TIFIA office.
01:21:34
We just recently received notification from the USDOT that we do have access and allocations of the private activity bonds that are $450 million.
01:21:44
That's positive towards the financial end of the project.
01:21:47
And we're working with the WHWA to make the tolling degree submitted back in February.
01:21:53
It's at their headquarters right now.
01:21:56
We talked a little bit about the funding itself.
01:21:59
The project, we're looking to close in the July time period for a commercial financial close, but the TIFIA loan, because of the process that it has to go through, will not close until the October time period.
01:22:10
So there's a delta between the financial close and what we call refinancing of the TIFIA or part of the TIFIA dollars.
01:22:18
FTEU is expected to raise $656 million in private funds for $3,293 million in equity.
01:22:26
That $656 million will raise to about $840 million when the TIFIA loan goes forward.
01:22:35
Right now, our contribution is $92 million.
01:22:38
The tipia delay at the financial close in July is going to be a commitment of equity and additional activity of $117 million dollars and it's common hope for $83 million dollars.
01:22:52
We hope to never use those dollars because we feel confident that the tipia is going to be out for the time being.
01:22:57
Those commitments need to be in place just in case TIFIA doesn't come about.
01:23:02
But like I said, we're very confident that TIFIA is going to come in in the October time period and the way that we structure the financing on the project, those dollars will not be used until later in the construction process so that we can make sure TIFIA is in place.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:21
One more question.
01:23:23
We think that we will use zero of that then, right?
SPEAKER_10
01:23:26
We use the 92 billion, which is an upfront contribution, but we do not believe that we'll be able to use the $183 million.
01:23:34
We will need to commit it to the project to go to financials.
01:23:37
But we won't use the sound of it.
01:23:39
If the TIFIA comes in, which we're very confident about, we will not utilize the commitment.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:44
If it doesn't, we will.
SPEAKER_10
01:23:46
If it didn't happen, that's what it would have been.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:24:05
The Garvey's are, generally we're using it for the large projects.
01:24:23
And this would be whether it's one of the large projects.
01:24:27
Right now, the 92 million would be for already coffee.
01:24:28
So the issue is, right now we're tied to this project.
01:24:30
So if they get tibia, well, when we get tibia,
01:24:31
Mr. Chairman, two questions.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:24:48
You told us that basically the $183 million is the offset until we get to the tip here, but there's a $33 million difference between
01:24:57
The TIFIA application in 183.
01:24:59
It's 150 versus 183.
SPEAKER_10
01:25:02
The TIFIA will be $300.
01:25:06
It's a combination of the grant that we received and the TIFIA.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:12
So the TIFIA will be $300.
01:25:13
Second thing, and this is more generic, I remember when we were talking about tolling on 95 and 81 and we sort of looked at 81 and said, we can't ask for both at the same time or they didn't want us to ask for both at the same time.
01:25:26
So we were looking at one versus the other.
01:25:29
How does this sort of project impact that ability to look for, does it have any impact on that?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:36
No, so we're still moving forward on the 95 tolling project.
01:25:41
But we made it clear that the tolling of the 95 would not be to the south.
01:25:49
So the 95 express lanes run right now from Springfield to Massa Pines.
01:26:00
So the tolling or straight tolling without the express lanes is from miles post zero to 26.
01:26:10
But we have asked for, and this is obviously still working with the Federal Highway Administration, that even if we collect tolls south of 126 to allow us to potentially use those funds for improvements north of 126.
01:26:30
Since it's most likely people driving north of 126 are also going to end up potentially going south and paying them.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:36
And if we wanted to, ultimately, to look at a toll on 81, when would we be allowed, under the regulations or the guidelines,
01:26:47
So look at that, since we're sort of not allowed to look at two at the same time.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:53
Well, so you have two birds.
01:26:55
The first is, there is this pilot program for the 95 tolling, which allows only one interstate in three states, and one interstate in three.
01:27:08
So it's three different states can apply for it, and three different interstates.
01:27:15
The other challenge we have is on 81 there is a General Assembly that passed the law when the STAR Solutions project was proposed that essentially said that this General Assembly specifically had to pass any sort of toll on anyone.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:41
So right now we're working the 95 project under the under the pilot and there's only three states and each state can do one interstate so unless they do another pilot or come back with some other program there is nothing to look at 81 and there's a restriction by the assembly.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:58
But you could do 81 under other federal programs.
01:28:06
So there are other federal programs such as that allow
SPEAKER_10
01:28:14
Mr. Chairman, just the last two slides, we always like to talk about the benefits of the project.
01:28:29
Certainly the 95 project is going to add the capacity to manage congestion along the corridor, expand the connectivity of the HOV corridor with the 495 Express, I-66,
01:28:42
We fixed that major bottleneck at Dumfries with the nine mile extension working with Director Drake on the transit component to the corridor itself and obviously significant job creation.
01:28:55
Next steps, we're going to finalize the comprehensive agreement and the exhibit is pretty soon.
01:28:59
The ongoing early works, which I came to this board with last month about, is moving forward.
01:29:06
Complete FFBA review this spring.
01:29:10
We talked about the July commercial and financial flows, concurrent flows.
01:29:15
to start construction in the August time period, make construction in 2015 and begin the tolling of the corridor of the 9-5 Express Lane in 2015 time period.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:27
Is that any questions?
01:29:29
So basically, I just want to make sure, we're going to be asking to be able to do code of early close.
01:29:39
Normally we wait for the tip here.
01:29:43
We'll lose the construction site.
01:29:45
And also we have the potential to lose the design build criteria that was submitted.
01:29:51
So what we'd like to do is go to early close.
01:29:54
We have already reached out to the highway.
01:30:05
They're okay with this approach.
01:30:07
And so we close in July.
SPEAKER_10
01:30:07
We'll see them out there starting construction almost immediately on the extension of the HOV lanes, pass it on for us again.
01:30:16
From a design build cost perspective, we think we're saving anywhere between $38 to $60 million.
01:30:19
Getting this thing done and getting this construction season, it just started in this construction season.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:23
Well, we have not really programmed in the GARVEE sense.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:37
So the GARVEEs again, you don't, we have not programmed into the Six-Year Plan the GARVEE sense.
01:30:49
Not yet.
01:30:51
Once we commit to the project, then we go ahead and put it in.
01:30:57
Right now, we have authority for $1.2 billion and we've done around $400 million for the Midtown Tunnel Project.
01:31:12
We'll be $100 million for the 495 express lanes and then we still have authority for another $700 million for the airpods.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:28
And that's the kind of, you'd find that in the megaphone section?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:32
They're just penciled in.
01:31:33
It's really, quote unquote, really not a megaphone.
01:31:36
It's just simply an RV authority.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:40
So then what are we doing with that fund?
01:31:41
We have that megafund line item which is going to be reflected in there?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:49
It's not a fund.
01:31:51
It's just your authority.
01:31:54
We call it that, but it's just if you sold bonds, you would have that amount of money.
01:31:59
Because it's based on the bond, the ability to sell bonds.
01:32:04
But all that's reflected in that one line, I don't know, right?
01:32:07
Because it's not money, it's not real money.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:11
Yeah, I know it's reflected something, but I just want to find out where it's being reflected.
01:32:16
Where do I find it?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:18
Four hundred went to Midtown, right now I'm looking for this.
01:32:22
So then you will still have approximately $700 million in authority to sell heartbeat pumps, of which some of it's $460 million.
01:32:39
And everything depends on the sales and what the projects are.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:45
It's not in the Six-Year Plan until we
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:47
No, we have not.
01:32:51
Garvey's are specific on to the projects.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:54
When we sell the bonds, it says this is Garvey money that's the funds that are sold for specifically the council.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:13
What you're saying they're only used for larger projects and not for other major projects?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:19
I have not used GARBIES.
01:33:22
FRANS, they use FRANS for those, but we no longer have authority to FRANS.
01:33:28
GARBIES are project specific, although if something happens to a project, there is latitude and they allow you to move it onto another federally authorized project.
01:33:37
But it has to be a federal project as it is specific to that project.
01:33:44
All of our construction projects now are federal, right?
01:33:55
No, actually, you know, I would say with the 3202 bonds, we have state projects that are state bonds.
01:34:04
I don't need the ball for this one.
SPEAKER_02
01:34:07
Yes, that's correct.
01:34:11
Once we use them, how often, how quickly do they regenerate?
01:34:14
Is there any concern that we're putting all our garbies in right now?
01:34:18
I know that's kind of, we wanted to get the money out on the street, but once we've got it out on the street, how quick before we get them back and can use them again down the road?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:34:27
They're 15 years.
01:34:28
They're generally 15-year funds.
01:34:30
And how much do we have?
01:34:33
1.2?
01:34:35
Right now, after 95, after Midtown, we'll have around $700 million.
01:34:43
That's alright.
SPEAKER_02
01:34:44
And that's not counting the approximately $500 million we may use or whatever on 460?
01:34:49
Right, so that'll be down to $200 million.
01:34:52
And then it's going to take us 10-15 years before we've got garbage to use?
01:34:56
That's right.
01:34:57
Is there any concern that we're using all our garbage this fast?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:35:01
Yeah, I gotta tell you, we sold the garbage for 3%?
01:35:08
Yes.
01:35:09
3%?
01:35:11
And the prices we're getting, as you saw with the 29-5 pass, are...
01:35:16
So we want to get them out there as fast as we can.
01:35:20
The issue is against many projects.
01:35:22
Because if you think about it, just look at the 460, any of these projects take 45 years.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:35:29
Mr. Chairman, is there any chance we could lobby a little bit for an 81 project for a couple hundred million of those garbage funds at some point?
01:35:45
Is that out of the question?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:35:47
No.
01:35:47
In fact, listen, I've been trying to pencil in how we do an 81 project.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:35:52
I'd really love to see some effort to start at least on
01:35:58
It's just going to be harder and harder to do.
01:36:03
Every time I drive down it, I think, how in the world are we going to do construction when you have as much traffic as you have on it?
01:36:10
That's just going to get harder and harder.
01:36:12
I would certainly urge you to take every look to see what sort of project we could start, even if it's in the 100 to 200 million range.
01:36:21
It would be a huge benefit.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:24
And this is something we've been leading to because that's why we've kind of taken control of this 80% coalition, sort of these outreach efforts.
01:36:32
And as you know, it's difficult to get the census out here also.
01:36:36
Yes.
01:36:37
As to, I mean, it really is going to involve having to add length.
01:36:41
And unfortunately, there does seem to be a great deal of opposition to that at different times.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:47
There appears to be, Mr. Chairman, a fairly strong consensus on adding a lane on each side.
01:36:57
There are people who are opposed to that in certain portions of the run, but that appears to be the one area where there is consensus on the project.
01:37:07
And we had a little bit of opposition to the climbing lanes in one jurisdiction, but when we suggested we'd move it to another jurisdiction, they went away very quickly.
01:37:16
And I think it could be managed to have a project that would add the third lane on a significant run of 81, particularly in areas of high congestion.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:29
That would be a good project.
SPEAKER_02
01:37:35
Mr. Chairman, one of the areas of discussion today would be that overlap of 7781 is going to be a prime area that we need to look at for some immediate relief that can be a major improvement from particularly 77 North meeting 81.
01:37:58
One last question for Dusty.
01:38:23
A funding tied up just in process, or is that a part of the highway bill that doesn't exist?
SPEAKER_10
01:38:29
It's a process.
01:38:30
Just a process.
01:38:30
It's a process.
01:38:31
It's getting the riders, getting the credit rating, going through the process.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:35
Thank you.
01:38:35
Basically what's happened particularly is now OMB, so we deal with and work with Federal Highway, Farm Administration, the state office, funding office,
01:38:49
They have all their own rules, and then they have to go to the O&B, and since it is a credit, it is a loan, it takes some time.
SPEAKER_02
01:39:00
Yes?
01:39:01
Just a general comment, Mr. Chairman.
01:39:03
Back to what Mr. Koelemay was saying to others here.
01:39:05
I do applaud us.
01:39:08
We are much more entrepreneurial.
01:39:09
We are making lots of headway.
01:39:12
But I hope it doesn't mask the fact, to some of the outside people looking at all that we're doing, that we're still out of money.
01:39:19
I mean, and I've heard this criticism from other members, well, you didn't give any money, but look what you're doing.
01:39:26
And I just would like to, this is in the vein, to say, yes, we're doing this, but these are, you know, great, we've got this efficient, and we should continue to do this, but it's not the answer down the line.
01:39:38
We've got to have additional revenue.
01:39:40
So I'd just like to have that known as anything else this board can do, other than what we're doing, let people know, yes, we're making lemonade out of lemons,
01:39:49
but it's still a long ways from what we're not gonna have any lemons left here pretty soon.
01:39:55
So I just would like for our public to know that we get it and we're good stewards of the money but the money's fast on the way.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:04
Mr. Lawson.
01:40:07
Can you tell us about easy stuff?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:40:17
Good morning, members of the board.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:20
It's been a few months I've talked to you about VTIP.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:40:24
I thought it would be a good time to kind of give you a status update and just talk a little more about some of the VTIP upcomings that you already heard about this morning.
01:40:37
Just to kind of in brief and to catch everybody back up, the infrastructure bank was created by the 2000s.
01:40:47
and the 2011 General Assembly Session by Chapters 830 and 868.
01:40:50
It is a non-reverting fund, revolving loan fund within the Transportation Trust Fund.
01:40:57
And being non-reverting, that just means that whatever balances remain at the end of the year do return or stay with the fund and are able to be used in the following year.
01:41:11
The VTIP was initially capitalized with about $283 million
01:41:15
A mixture of about $33 million in general funds from surplus and about $250 million in funds from the Commonwealth Transportation Fund.
01:41:26
The program is administered in terms of policy and programmatic aspects by yourself, the CTB, and DRA serves as the financial advisor.
01:41:37
The program guidance was approved by yourself in September and we began accepting applications shortly thereafter.
01:41:46
As you recall, the first loan application received was for the Dominion Boulevard project in the City of Chesapeake.
01:41:56
That project is a 3.8-mile improvement from Cedar Road to Great Bridge Boulevard, which includes the replacement of an existing two-lane drawbridge for the four-lane fixed span.
01:42:07
The request was for a $152 million loan for a total project value of about $412 million.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:15
Go back just for one quick second.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:21
So $250 million came from the Six-Year Plan essentially that could have been used for other projects on the primary or whatever, right?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:42:30
They were funds that were identified through the audit process that we put toward the bank.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:36
Those are funds that are not available for other projects in our districts, correct?
01:42:42
Correct.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:42:44
The project will be done as a toll road.
01:42:49
The city will include plans to issue or create a Chesapeake transportation system that will include Minyon Boulevard as well as the existing Chesapeake Expressway, and they will sell about $230 million in toll revenue bonds to support the project.
01:43:08
The VTIP monies will kind of fill the funding gap between the toll revenue bonds that they'll be issuing
01:43:13
and the fiction for the money that have been provided to the project.
01:43:18
The loan, what you approved the loan in January and with an interest rate of about 3.3%.
01:43:25
We are continuing to work with the city.
01:43:28
The city has retained all of their approvals through city council and we are looking to go to actually close the loan this fall.
01:43:40
Our second application was received in January by the IDA of Loudoun County.
01:43:47
The original loan request was for a $60 million loan, an interest subsidy, or a project as a collaborative effort.
01:43:57
I guess the application today was a collaboration between Jincora, Dallas Real Estate, and Investor LLC, and the IDA.
01:44:05
Kincora is an early-stage, 400-acre mixed-use development located in the southeast quadrant of the intersection of Route 7 and Route 28.
01:44:15
A community development authority was proposed to collect a special assessment on multifamily residential units to repay the loan.
01:44:25
After some review and discussion with the RA, a revised application was submitted in February
01:44:32
requesting a loan for $80 million.
01:44:35
This $80 million loan would be repaid by special assessments on both residential and non-residential property.
01:44:44
This map, how many of you are familiar with the area?
01:44:49
It's a little small, but right there kind of in the center you see the dark green that represents the Concord development.
01:44:57
As mentioned, as part of this agreement, the proper agreement with Loudoun County, the developer is required to construct a four-lane extension of Pacific Boulevard, connect to Russell Branch Parkway, and to extend Gloucester Parkway from the intersections of Notes and Pacific.
01:45:15
Following a standard build-out, development build-out, this process would probably take 10 to 15 years to actually build these road improvements.
01:45:28
The project would be done really in kind of three phases.
01:45:32
It would be funded by the VTED loan.
01:45:35
Phase one is about 5,900 foot extension of Pacific Boulevard north towards from its point at Gloucester Parkway.
01:45:49
Phase two is about a 3,600 foot extension
01:45:53
of Gloucester Parkway west from its intersection with Pacific Boulevard to Louden County Parkway, and phase three, the 2,300-foot extension of Pacific Boulevard north at its existing terminus to Russell Branch Parkway in a 1,700-foot extension south to Severn Way.
SPEAKER_02
01:46:13
Mr. Chairman?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:46:15
Yes, Mr. Lawson?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:17
I'm trying to correlate the names with the numbers that are on the map, because I don't find the names.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:46:23
This one actually shows the segments.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:39
If you go back to the first map and you show the project area or any of these roads on here, the ones you're talking about in the next slide, Gloucester Parkway, Pacific Boulevard,
01:46:50
or are they internal and we can't see them on this map?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:46:55
The 607 you see, if I'm correct, is Louden County Parkway.
01:47:02
And the others are smaller and you can't see them.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:06
Okay, we'll just continue, I can't see them.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:11
This map, which is 607, this cut right down the middle, it's a connection to
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:47:21
I can look at them later.
01:47:36
Phase II is the Gloucester extension, which is the third group area, and this blue is where we added it.
01:47:52
And then the red section, the two red sections, are the Pacific, which stands for Hollingsworth.
SPEAKER_02
01:47:58
Are those totally new, the red ones, or are they improvement?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:02
They're just immune.
01:48:03
Okay, thank you.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:48:05
We have members here from Pecora and Loudon County both that can answer more detailed questions than necessary.
01:48:17
Just a little bit about the project.
01:48:21
The project is a local transportation priority and it will serve to reduce some congestion or severe congestion on Route 7 or Route 28 in Waxpool Road.
01:48:34
In addition, the project provides a strong potential for economic development within the area.
01:48:40
The three phases of the project could not be built in the near future without innovative financing such as what can be provided by the infrastructure bank.
01:48:50
Accounting has competing debt finance infrastructure needs at this time and doesn't have the capacity to put toward the project.
01:48:58
The VTIB loan assistance for this project would be 100% financing for the project.
01:49:04
We have had district staff look at the project and look at the construction schedule and believe both to be reasonable and achievable.
01:49:16
Phase one has all its approvals and permits in place and is ready to move to construction.
01:49:21
Phase two is scheduled for construction to begin in March of 2013.
01:49:25
The design work is currently underway and the right-of-way permits need to be obtained.
01:49:34
Phase 3 is a little further out with design and still needed to be completed as well as the right-of-way permits obtained.
01:49:45
The current schedule would have the one-segment Pacific to Southern Way beginning construction in September of 2013 with the upper and the northern segment beginning construction in December of 2013.
01:50:03
We are continuing to move forward with the application review and with CNCORA.
01:50:12
A draft term sheet was provided to CNCORA on May 9.
01:50:16
They are reviewing it now and we are planning follow-up meetings within the next week or two to finalize the terms with the RA.
01:50:24
Once that is done, we are looking to have the detailed advisory panel to meet and consider the application.
01:50:33
We have plans to have this completed in order to present this application to you in opportunity for your possible action based on the recommendations of the panelists.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:47
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
01:50:49
When you talk about the interest subsidy,
01:50:52
Can you sort of flesh that out a little bit for us?
01:50:54
Should we bind down that interest rate through this process?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:50:59
The original work application is connected?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:02
Well, yeah, you talked about it a couple of times in the presentation.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:51:06
When we refer to an interest subsidy with the details, if you recall in the guidelines, it's kind of the methodology for determining the interest rate, which is tied to MMD.
01:51:19
and what...
01:51:21
It's tied to what?
01:51:23
The municipal market data.
01:51:25
Right.
01:51:25
Interested scenes.
01:51:26
Right.
01:51:26
Published data.
01:51:28
And when we looked at these loans, if they request a loan that is below that base rate would be to some status.
01:51:38
The original
01:51:40
Dominion Loan, they had sought a subsidized rate of 3%.
01:51:44
After we went through the negotiation, they actually paid what we sought to be the standard rate of 3.3, which fit our criteria.
01:51:52
The original loan...
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:55
So by using that terminology, you're really reflecting, you're really telling us that
01:52:03
It's a bull market.
01:52:04
It's just a bull market interest rate that we're providing or that they're asking for.
01:52:08
That's correct.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:09
Thank you.
SPEAKER_02
01:52:14
Mr. Secretary.
01:52:14
Yes.
01:52:14
I think I'm going to have some serious issues with this.
01:52:16
This is the first loan we did.
01:52:19
It's an opportunity.
01:52:20
The transportation infrastructure thing is what I call, we were doing to help out communities, localities who needed help with their roads, their construction projects.
01:52:30
They needed to borrow money to help out
01:52:33
their particular transportation issues.
01:52:35
The first project we did, $152 million City of Chesapeake, is a road and a bridge, redoing a bridge owned by the City of Chesapeake.
01:52:45
And we gave them money to help finance that, their road, their street.
01:52:50
It looks like what we're doing here is giving an $80 million loan to a private company to create a subdivision.
01:52:57
And that to me is not what the BTIB was intended to do.
01:53:02
It was to give it to localities who didn't have money, because we're not giving them money, to do construction projects.
01:53:09
And this is going to Kincora to build a mixed-use residential development.
01:53:15
Is that who the loan's going to?
01:53:16
It's going to an IDA, but it's going to a private company who's going to profit on this.
01:53:24
And what is the purpose of VTIP under our guidelines?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:31
The purpose of VTIP under the law is to provide loans to projects to advance them where we're going to get paid back and create revenue streams and then be able to invest in other projects.
01:53:48
So when this was created, we had in mind things like Dominion Boulevard.
01:53:57
which is a state we own, but they are managing this project for us and so we're giving them a low interest loan which enables them to complete their financing and to keep the big rates.
SPEAKER_02
01:54:14
And that seems like what we're supposed to be doing.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:16
The City of Chesapeake building a state road, you know, and their bridge seems perfectly what we were trying to do.
SPEAKER_02
01:54:22
They can't core off giving the loan to a private developer to build a subdivision
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:28
It does to me seem like what VTEP is intended to be.
01:54:36
In the counties, how most of the road transportation infrastructure is built is the developers provide the proffers to build these things.
01:54:57
Now the situation here is that the developer is still years off from building this infrastructure.
01:55:08
And so the county, Loudoun County, is Loudoun actually going to be the supply?
01:55:16
Loudoun County, who wants this, because if you could just go back to your slide, and I'm going to ask Mr. York and Mr. Scott if they want to come up here.
01:55:25
Right there is sort of, this project is sort of interesting because of the traffic counts that were involved here.
01:55:39
I mean right now that intersection of Route 7 and Route 28 are extremely, very, very high volume areas.
01:55:46
It is a major commercial area and when we build out just the connection between Gloucester and Route 28, what's the traffic count on that?
SPEAKER_06
01:56:02
Mr. Peake, the difficulty that we're having right now is Black's Pool Road is carrying
01:56:20
Part of that is because we have a $4.80 toll rate on the Greenway and people are diverting from using that and going up north to Gloucester to come back south down to the toll road.
01:56:35
So when the developer came in, the Board of Supervisors, when they approved it, decided to forgo the proffers for capital improvements such as schools and fire and rescue centers and they asked that it be all used for the transportation network in here.
01:56:55
So we had I think the contribution, Mr. Scott, was around 32 million dollars in proffer.
01:57:03
The challenge that we have
01:57:05
is that we need improvement to Waxpool Road yesterday.
01:57:11
This segment that is being proposed for Gloucester will reduce about 10,000 daily trips off of Waxpool.
01:57:20
It gives us what is only our second connection from Route 28 into the Ashburn area in between Route 7 and the airport, which is south on Route 28.
01:57:35
and of course Pacific will also provide a great deal of relief and give a connection for those folks that may be north on Ashburn to go up and around.
01:57:49
This particular project includes two bridges that go over the Broad Run, one at Gloucester and the other at Russell Branch as Pacific curves up and around.
01:58:03
We don't take advantage of the infrastructure bank.
01:58:07
We're talking, I don't know, 10 years to 12 years before we get this improvement.
01:58:14
And we just simply can't wait any longer because of the growth.
01:58:19
And so what the board had asked the Kincora folks to do is to apply for use of the infrastructure bank so that we could get the money up front and the
01:58:34
The infrastructure in place so we can provide the relief to the citizens.
01:58:39
Please understand why these roads do kind of go through the Kincor project.
01:58:45
This is about providing relief for a lot of folks that live east of, excuse me, west of Loudoun County Parkway.
01:58:55
In the evening time, Route 28 packs up.
01:58:58
from the Waxpool 28 interchange almost all the way down to the toll road in Route 28.
01:59:09
And a lot of it is because of the amount of traffic that is getting off of 28 on the Waxpool Road.
01:59:15
Then in the morning, Waxpool Road is a parking lot because of the amount of traffic coming out.
01:59:21
So I would ask, respectfully, support for the application to provide the relief to Act School Road.
01:59:30
Mr. Chairman?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:31
Yeah, Mr. Rich?
01:59:32
I think this is a very reasonable proposal and makes a lot of sense.
01:59:35
We've got a county trying to get out in front of the mess.
01:59:40
Otherwise, you're usually waiting, trying to do a catch-up game.
01:59:45
The taxpayers of Loudoun County are going to end up paying for this thing.
01:59:49
28 is an extremely important corridor for the economic engine of the Commonwealth.
01:59:59
The taxpayers paid a lot of those interchange improvements on 28 to major north-south routes, and we're alleviating significant congestion there and also on Route 7.
02:00:13
So I really think this is a very commendable project and would recommend that we go forward with it.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:00:22
I think part of the problem also is the General Assembly passed legislation prohibiting getting the progress up front.
02:00:32
The General Assembly did pass legislation that used to be able to maybe get proffers up front before they built.
SPEAKER_06
02:00:39
Now you can only get them when they... Yeah, you know, it's a negotiation.
02:00:49
We want, first of all, we want the projects to be able to pay for themselves, but we also have to make sure that the
02:00:56
The developer is able to move forward with the project and if we were to get all the funds up front, in a manner of profit, it would be very difficult for the project to get off the ground.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:15
But I think legislation has been adopted as such that we have to wait in the rears to get this attached properly.
02:01:18
Yeah, I'm Mike Scott with the development.
02:01:22
Yeah, in terms of the phasing and the development, two things happened.
02:01:27
The Pacific leg of the project actually benefits directly the mixed-use development, which lies to the north end of the property.
02:01:38
And so under our phased-proper approach, we would not get to Gloucester until last, which is unfortunately the road the county needs.
02:01:47
So this allows us to do it, we basically as developers undertake the burden of basically mortgaging our entire property for this road infrastructure which completes it with 28 and a parallel road network and in exchange for that we effectively because of the attractive interest rate
02:02:09
These are roads that will be owned by the Commonwealth and we own the roads that we're improving or adding to now.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:02:35
If you want to bar money in some traditional
02:02:39
So really what we're doing is we're expediting some roads that we think we need.
02:02:57
We're creating some opportunity for some economic development in the county.
02:03:04
I guess the only question I would ask sort of is
02:03:09
Is the subsidy, what is the subsidy anticipated to be Ms. Lawson?
02:03:18
The interest rate subsidy.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:20
There's no subsidy in this one?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:24
And my question is related.
02:03:26
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:26
Mr. Chairman, I can add to that just real quickly.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:29
Not only are we building these needed roads, looking ahead, but we're augmenting 28 and 7.
02:03:35
I mean, we're concentrating horribly in this existing road.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:40
Mr. Secretary.
02:03:41
I'm sorry, Mr. Cole.
SPEAKER_07
02:03:43
Thank you.
02:03:43
Mr. Lawson, what's the proposed repayment schedule?
SPEAKER_02
02:03:48
Point.
02:03:49
Thank you.
SPEAKER_02
02:03:50
To maybe alleviate some of Mr. Peake's concerns, the Chairman has spent considerable time with the developer over a number of years to try to come up with a solution for what is one of the worst traffic situations in Northern Virginia.
02:04:10
And I think when we made the infrastructure bank available, it was just a matter of them getting their application together because I know
02:04:19
The Chairman talked to Doug and I last year about being one of the first applicants, so I think this is, you know, we fully support it from the Northern Virginia side.
SPEAKER_06
02:04:31
Can I just add one thing?
02:04:34
I think Loudoun County would have really looked at helping out and actually been the ones to do the bonding and move forward with the project.
02:04:47
The difficulty for us is that we just simply don't have the capacity just to give you an understanding that since 2000 to 2010,
02:04:55
And we've built six high schools, eight middle schools, and 21 elementary schools.
02:05:00
And we still continue to build because of the growth coming in, and we just don't have the capacity up front to be able to do this.
SPEAKER_02
02:05:07
All right, gentlemen, thank you very much.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:14
Ms. Lawson, finish off your presentation.
02:05:17
Thank you.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:05:21
All right, I think the next couple slides can go pretty quick.
02:05:24
Dusty covered the 460 application pretty closely.
02:05:29
I want to make you aware that we also are looking to have a third application come to us to provide for an $80 million credit to support the 6320 corporation related to Route 460.
02:05:46
Just to kind of wrap up with a picture of the bank.
02:05:52
As we talked earlier, we capitalized the bank with $283 million.
02:05:57
There was an additional $29 million of surplus funds that had been provided through the 2012 session, a total for the bank of $312 million.
02:06:09
With the processing of the Dominion loan and the two we talked about today, that will have fully consumed the funds within the bank.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:22
Mr. Chairman, I just want to pile on to Mr. Layne's earlier comments.
02:06:27
And obviously we don't decide here what our source of revenue is other than some of these creative things we've been able to do, nor do we decide how much revenue that is.
02:06:37
But as I've been, as I've said a number of times in the Hampton Roads area, you know, the governor and administration and with the legislature's approval have done all the smoke and mirror things that we can do.
02:06:56
We've done the Garvey's.
02:06:57
We did the bank.
02:06:58
The bank's now at zero.
02:07:01
The Garvey's, assuming the numbers that you threw out on the 460 project are at 200.
02:07:07
And we know we're out of money from the Transportation Fund of 2017.
02:07:13
So that's it.
02:07:15
We're done.
02:07:17
And, you know, let's help them change this.
02:07:20
Unless you find some other great program or some creative method, we're done.
02:07:28
And that, you know, the legislature needs to embrace that and our citizenry needs to embrace that and decide what they want to do.
02:07:38
And I know what I want to do, but I don't get to vote other than for my legislators.
SPEAKER_02
02:07:43
Mr. Chairman, now to add to Mr. Miller's suggestions there or comments, he didn't mention the $450 million deficit in the maintenance side that looms every year in front of us and actually that's from the amount of money that's available for us to do these projects.
02:08:02
So that's high on our list of leads as we talk to legislators and those that can fund important projects in Virginia.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:13
Mr. Lawson, do you expect an incremental, some incremental funds to come from FY13 budget surplus?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:08:30
I'd say we can't assume anything there.
02:08:34
There's money dedicated, a portion of the surplus is dedicated to transportation.
02:08:40
It would be incumbent upon the governor to decide whether or not, how he wants to direct it to those folks.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:48
So at this point, Mr. Lawson, we have, once the banking is exhausted, that's it.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:08:55
We have no, we are re-blinching anything in there at this point.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:07
It's the intent of the Governor to continue to push the money to be put on every surplus, which up to this point, if they hadn't rated it again this year, it would have been another $65-70 million.
SPEAKER_02
02:09:27
And on that topic like that, on the whole circle here, the only direction they've really gotten from the legislature after all this is devolution, but take a look at it.
02:09:40
So that's really the action that was all boiled down with all the legislative agenda the government put forth, the only action they've really given us is to study devolution.
02:09:50
And that's the fact of the matter.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:52
We were having such a great trip and so you guys kind of made it a bummer.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:00
Mr.
02:10:00
Keen, I think appropriately brought up the maintenance issue.
02:10:03
We haven't had a briefing on maintenance.
02:10:06
Maybe we could have one next time.
02:10:08
I don't know where we are on that.
02:10:10
It seems like that's particularly the problem.
02:10:13
I think this can go pretty fast given that we had a significant discussion about the Garvey program earlier.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:10:43
Just by way of overview and refresher, the Garvey's were authorized by the 2011 General Assembly.
02:10:52
They have a successor program to the FRANs.
02:10:55
The FRAN program was effectively sunset by the Garvey legislation.
02:11:00
The Garvey Program retained the $1.2 billion revolving authorization that was provided for the FRANs.
02:11:09
Over the course of the ten years or so, eight years that we had the FRAN program in place, we had issued $1.1 billion in FRANs.
02:11:19
At this point, only $176 million remained outstanding.
02:11:25
And that amount will be fully repaid by 2015.
02:11:31
As you recall, the first Garvey sale was done just a few months ago back in February.
02:11:37
It was a sale done to support the public subsidy for the Midtown Tunnel Project.
02:11:43
It was a 15-year term bond with a true interest cost of 2.4%.
02:11:51
Today we'll be talking about seeking in the action meeting your approval to move forward with the second sale.
02:11:58
The second sale will be seeking funding for two projects, an additional $50 million for the Midtown Tunnel project to support the delay in tolling to July of 2014, as well as the
02:12:13
Thelma D. D.
02:12:35
From a statutory perspective, again, the chapters 830 and 868 of the 2011 Acts of Assembly established the Garvey program.
02:12:46
The program is very similar to the Frans, with the exception that the term lengthened.
02:12:52
The Frans were 10-year notes.
02:12:55
The Garvey program can be as long as 20 years.
02:13:00
All their plans failed for 15-year terms.
02:13:04
In addition to the federal legislation, the state legislation that authorizes the garbage, we have a memorandum of agreement in place with some highway that we executed last December that sets forth the responsibilities of the two parties and explains how we will administer the program.
02:13:22
It's kind of an evergreen agreement in that we don't have to amend the agreement other
02:13:28
Add to the Approved Project List.
02:13:31
We've already had discussions with some colleagues related to the I-95 project, and the list will be amended to include the project.
02:13:44
There was some discussion earlier about the authorization.
02:13:49
As mentioned, we have a Bill 2 revolving authorization.
02:13:53
The first thing we have to look at, though, is the outstanding friends.
02:13:57
If you look at the garbage that are outstanding from the first sale and the planned sale of $150 million, these are available authorization of just shy of $600 million.
02:14:11
And as I mentioned earlier, the $176 million of France will be repaid in 2015.
02:14:17
The debt service on the garbage
02:14:25
It is also a little different structure than the FRANDS.
02:14:28
We call the FRANDS what we call an indirect guard reason.
02:14:31
They were just paid for out of general federal revenues.
02:14:35
With the guard reason, they are specifically tied to a project.
02:14:39
So the revenues that are received specifically to midtown tunnel, or in this case, I-95, would be those revenues that would be used to support the debt service.
02:14:49
Air Garvey Program is also strengthened by added security of revenues from other legally available sources of the Transportation Trust Fund and any other funds that may be designated by the General Assembly.
02:15:05
The two Garvey issues combined, one for Midtown in February and this issue combined will have an annual debt service of about $40 million.
02:15:15
Just to put that in perspective, the total revenues collected in the interest of the year 2011 were about $1.1 billion.
02:15:28
This just gives you a little snapshot of some recent Garvey transactions.
02:15:32
They continue to trade very strong.
02:15:35
In fact, New Hampshire had an issue yesterday that the spreads were within about 30 basis points of AAA NLD.
02:15:43
So they continue to trade very strong.
02:15:46
As you can see here, air rating is the first one that represents the sale from February.
02:15:53
Because of the added security, you can see the rating in the notch above the others, and the combination of the enhanced rating as well as good timing in the market, you can see how our interest rates were much lower than the other issues.
02:16:16
Again, we are looking to go to sale.
02:16:19
With a pricing in the June-July period and for about $150 million dollars with 15-year maturity, we do expect to get the AA rating as obtained on the initial sale.
02:16:35
This just gives you kind of a schedule that we plan to work through.
02:16:40
We will be updating the project list as part of the MOA with our holiday this month.
02:16:46
We'll be seeking rating requests in June as well as we'll be able to go to the Treasury Board next month to obtain their approval.
02:16:54
We'll do pricing and sales late June, July, with the closing in early July.
02:17:00
Just all in.
02:17:01
It's time to support the July closing of the N95 project which the Dusty has got to throw at us.
02:17:08
I've got, Officer Anderson, Bond Council is here also if you have any questions.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:17:14
Just a real quick, Mr. Chairman.
02:17:16
Where is this $150 million going that we're on?
02:17:19
Can you just tell us where it's going?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:17:21
The $150 million of it will go to the wards in downtown Midtown, California.
02:17:27
And the other $100 million is this lady over there.
02:17:30
We're covering the $92 million that Dusty talked about earlier as a subsidy for the $95 million.
02:17:36
Thank you.
02:17:37
Okay, um...
02:18:03
April was a pretty good month in terms of revenue.
02:18:06
We've seen a little bit of an uptick in what we've been seeing in the previous months.
02:18:12
Revenues are about 3% ahead of where they were prior fiscal year, which is also good in that it's slightly above the forecasted growth rate of 2.2%.
02:18:26
Motor vehicle sales continue to be strong.
02:18:29
Thelma D. D. D. D.
02:18:45
I can't say better than initially forecasted.
02:18:48
Initially we had forecasted a growth of about, just shy of 3%.
02:18:52
It reduced that expected growth to a decline of 1.4% in December.
02:18:59
We're currently at about a 1%.
02:19:00
At least we're doing a little better than most recent forecasts.
02:19:06
And sales and use tax are just very slightly behind the forecast, 5.4 versus 5.8.
02:19:17
This chart, you can see it every month, just gives you the details about revenue source, comparing the amounts of estimates, the collections through April, for both the year 12 versus 11, and then the comparison between the actual change and the forecasted growth.
02:19:41
Federal revenues are also running above fiscal year 11 levels.
02:19:47
We're about $51 million ahead of where we were last fiscal year.
02:19:53
The majority of that growth, actually all of that growth, is attributable to that work done in the maintenance program.
02:20:03
Looking at spending through April, collectively across all programs, we've spent
02:20:11
Nearly $3.2 billion, which is almost $400 million, ahead of where we were last year.
02:20:18
Forty-four percent of the spending relates to the VDOT's maintenance program.
02:20:21
When you look at maintenance spending collectively to include payments to localities, it could represent 53% spending.
02:20:30
Construction spending represents about 34% of the total.
02:20:37
This graphically gives you the year-over-year comparison of spending.
02:20:42
As you can see, most of the programs are very similar to prior fiscal year.
02:20:49
You can see the slight growth in construction and considerable growth in maintenance.
02:20:59
Speaking of maintenance, we expended $123 million in April.
02:21:04
About $1.4 billion spent to date.
02:21:07
That's a 34% increase over where we were at this time last year.
02:21:14
Anticipate spending about $1.7 billion by the end of the fiscal year.
02:21:20
While we're today, we're at about $100 million below our spend plan, and we think we'll end the year just over $200 million below this.
02:21:31
I have an allocation balance of just over $200 million.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:37
You just corrected yourself on spend plan versus allocation.
02:21:43
Well, you change your terminology.
02:21:45
And what I've been always trying to pull out of this, as you know, is one thing about how much money is coming in from knowing about what our real plan is.
02:21:55
Old money, new money.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:21:57
And they were two separate statements.
02:21:59
Right.
02:21:59
Are we about 100 million behind where we thought we would be?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:04
On our spend plan.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:22:05
In terms of allocation, unspent funding, where we think we'll end the year as of now.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:11
And how much is the total spend plan variance at the end of the year?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:22:24
The spend plan variance at the end of the year would have been at about $100 million.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:29
At the end of the year.
02:22:31
So there's $128 million in additional money that was not in our spend plan, that is in our balance.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:22:38
In terms of construction, I've extended up about $1.1 billion this year, which is about a 5% increase over last year, and the actual spending is about $20 million above forecast.
02:23:02
You can see here that the spending kind of varies as to where it is, the greater increase and really the main increases taking place within the primary and urban systems.
02:23:21
In terms of anticipated spending, this just gets back to what we were talking about just momentarily a minute ago there.
02:23:29
You see it shows the operating budget compared to the original forecast versus where we are at forecast is today.
02:23:37
The big increase there was in the construction arena.
02:23:40
Then you look at forecasted spending today versus the actual expenditures today.
02:23:45
In terms of cash, you can see there's a change here in cash position for the major programs year over year or since the beginning of the year, I should say.
02:24:03
When you look at cash in grand total, we're only about $35 million globally.
02:24:09
We began the year, but you have to take into consideration
02:24:12
It's raised over $60 million in the Proteus Carbon Prosie that came in additional.
02:24:19
There's some significant spin down, you can see, in the Highway Maintenance and Operating Fund, as well as in the CPR proceeds.
02:24:31
Just kind of summarizing, our CTF revenues are ahead of forecast by almost a percent.
02:24:39
And current contract value on an existing contract totals $2.7 billion, which is almost $500 billion greater than it was at this time last year.
02:24:52
We're definitely putting out contracts to move forward.
02:24:56
fiscal year to date expenditures as you saw from that graphic most programs are fairly much in line with their forecasted activity and good news, good news I think is that the unspent balance of the 228 million that was mentioned earlier in the maintenance program is less than half of what it was in the last fiscal year or two.
02:25:17
That number, if you were over 500 million, go back two years, came down to 485 last year, and then we're looking at this year being slightly above 200.
02:25:28
That's what door was for.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:25:31
Mr. Koelemay, this is Dr. Davis.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:25:34
Mr. Lawson, can you go back to slide 8?
02:25:37
I just have a quick question about why there's a significant difference in the program management direction hurdles.
02:25:46
Is that the nature of the contracts?
02:25:48
Is that locality?
02:25:49
Is the PPTAs managing contracts?
02:25:51
Is it efficiencies?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:25:53
Last year, when we developed the fiscal year 2012 budget, we made a very concerted effort to streamline construction management.
02:26:03
There's also a significant amount of construction engineering inspection funding, which I actually provided on the project.
02:26:11
So that was a very intentional action that we made last year in budget development to constrain construction management.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:26:24
Well, congratulations.
02:26:28
Is there a reasonable expectation if the Commonwealth spends $250 million on infrastructure more in one year than did the previous year of the impact that that has on the Virginia economy?
02:26:41
I know it's positive, but I was just trying to figure out if there's a reasonable expectation that we could talk about that would say, because we got $250 million more out this year than last year, it had this impact on the Virginia economy.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:26:57
We have various studies that we've done, some of them on bigger numbers, but we have
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:27:07
It's just a general observation, but I've noticed in areas of the Commonwealth where we have accelerated and have major projects underway, there appears to be improving employment, improving economic activity, and it should be a pretty clear message that infrastructure investment in the Commonwealth is a very positive thing.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:27:34
Mr. Chairman, I mean, I think you would typically say, an economist would say, it's about two to two and a half times the amount you spend is what the impact would be.
02:27:43
So if we spend 250 million bucks, you're talking, you know, five, six, seven hundred million dollars of GDP into the state economy, which is significant.
SPEAKER_02
02:27:56
I just wanted to make a comment and commend the commissioners and staff.
02:28:05
This is the Hampton Roads District.
02:28:07
They're doing a very good job of communicating road closures, getting out.
02:28:11
I've had lots of positive comments about people.
02:28:14
I'm not happy that the roads are closed, but they're happy that they've been communicated to.
02:28:19
So I just commend you for that informational campaign.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:28:25
Mr. DeBruhl, Economic Development Access Program
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:28:34
Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
02:28:37
The presentation I have for you today is directly tied to our business plan, which the Chief Deputy Commissioner and Commissioner presented to you previously.
02:28:46
What we're going to talk about today is Objective 5.3, which is improving access to multimodal facilities and major employment centers over the next three years.
02:28:55
We're looking to do that with modifications to our Economic Development Access Program.
02:29:00
Just to give you a little background and a summary of our existing program, Ford has a policy which was last revisited in 2010 when we increased the maximum allocation available under the program to a total of $650,000 per project which is inclusive of design and construction.
02:29:19
We have two types of projects under the EDA program.
02:29:22
We have regular projects.
02:29:24
That's where you have an existing, located industry that's standing, much like the project we had last month in the city of Virginia Beach, where you know that they're there, you know what they're doing.
02:29:34
or a new industry coming in that's been named that qualifies for the program.
02:29:39
And those projects are the most clean and straightforward.
02:29:43
We also have a number of bonded projects.
02:29:45
Those are the types of projects where we don't have a qualifying industry that's been named where the naming of that industry is still kept in secret.
02:29:54
In those projects, the locality that's applying for funding is required to provide a bond or a surety.
02:29:59
to VDOT and there's a five-year time frame that that locality has to establish that qualifying establishment investment in that facility.
02:30:09
Five-board policy, our capital investment to program project cost ratio is five to one.
02:30:15
Our qualifying capital investment is pretty well defined by the board's policy in that only private investment is currently eligible, and our qualifying establishments are also defined by that policy they're listed on the screen, but things like government installations, public facilities, commercial establishments, they do not qualify for Economic Development Act this funding.
02:30:38
We work on those eligibility determinations very closely with the Economic Development Partnership and they coordinate and consult with the Virginia Department of Business in doing those evaluations.
02:30:49
The next few slides of my presentation actually come from the Virginia Economic Development Partnership.
02:30:55
As indicated, we work pretty closely with them.
02:30:58
And they shared with us that we've missed, as Commonwealth, we've missed some opportunities over the last few years where if we had sites that had better access and were more ready for development, we would have had other opportunities to bring economic development to Virginia.
02:31:14
And the next slide.
02:31:30
Two essential ingredients that we've learned working through VDP for having a successful outcome in economic development and attracting major investments to Virginia are having well-documented site plans, including construction-ready road plans, and having pre-existing infrastructure on the site, including completed road facilities.
02:31:52
Those major investors, those major economic developments that were on the other slide are looking for sites that they can have ready and have their facility up and running in 18 to 24 months.
02:32:05
If you don't have those plans ready and you don't have the facilities in place, it's very difficult to accommodate them.
02:32:14
The Code of Virginia defines a major employment and investment project as one that has a capital investment exceeding $250 million and creating more than 400 new full-time jobs.
02:32:27
The Virginia Economic Development Partnership has developed an initiative for strategic properties, or what they refer to as mega sites, based on this definition, and theyíve been working with localities and economic development authorities across the state to identify sites that provide opportunities to attract these types of projects.
02:32:44
The seven sites that are listed on the slide are the ones that are currently identified by VEPP to meet that criteria.
02:32:52
And each of those sites currently has an adequate access to public roads.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:32:59
Mr. Bull, if you went back to the essential ingredients, one of which is the access, how about the workforce solutions, the site development plans, and the other infrastructure,
02:33:13
Do these ones that you have listed here, these seven, do they meet those criteria as well?
02:33:25
I guess my point is, it's one thing for us to put some money into a place to create the access, but if the other essential elements aren't there, we're just parking money where it doesn't need to be parked.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:33:37
The EPP is working aggressively with those seven sites to make sure that all the ingredients are in place.
02:33:44
We're partnering with them on the roadway access, but they're very actively engaged with those localities and those sites to get those industries there.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:53
So obviously the sort of takeaway would be, at least my opinion would be, that I would be happy to do that as well as the other essential ingredients were there or we're going to be there in a short amount of time.
02:34:06
Okay, thank you.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:07
As Chairman, I noticed there's no site along 460 megasite.
02:34:13
Why is that?
02:34:15
We don't have the road access.
02:34:20
It's not really developed enough to get on this list yet.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:25
It will be certified megasites.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:34:29
These seven sites are already
02:34:31
Very well developed and advanced in terms of having site plans in place.
02:34:36
Some of them, Progress Park in the county has already got a number of phases that have been developed.
02:34:40
So they're a little bit further down the road.
02:34:42
That's why the wording is pretty careful in the slides because these are the seven sites that are currently identified.
02:34:47
That's not the only seven sites that could be.
02:34:52
So working with the EBP,
02:34:55
We wanted to know how the existing Economic Development Access Program could be made more flexible for the megasites and for other economic development sites across the time as well.
02:35:06
In working with them, we pulled together a number of stakeholders, basically spent a day with them talking about their issues with the program, what we could do to make the program more flexible and more beneficial to their economic development efforts.
02:35:18
That dialogue resulted in a number of recommendations that I'll walk through quickly with you now.
02:35:25
First recommendation for megasites, the focus group suggested that we implement a separate funding room or separate funding opportunity for the planning phase.
02:35:35
Right now I mentioned in an earlier slide they have one chance to come to us for an allocation that covers the planning and the construction.
02:35:42
So what they would like us to do is to fund the design and the construction of these access rigs to two distinct projects.
02:35:50
The megasite facilities are much more complex than our typical access project.
02:35:54
The planning phase is much more detailed than our typical access project.
02:35:58
And staff agrees that this is a needed change that would help advance this project.
02:36:05
And having those road construction plans ready to go on the shelf and the project is shovel-ready is certainly something that makes the site more viable for the project.
SPEAKER_02
02:36:13
Mr. Chairman, how was the focus groups selected and organized?
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:36:19
The focus group members were identified by the Virginia Economic Development Partnership, and so they represent the seven megasites, but all those localities are also very active in our regular EVA program.
02:36:34
Now, due to the greater length of access roads in the megasites, the focus group also identified a need to increase the maximum allocations for these types of projects.
02:36:44
Staff is recommending allowing an allocation of up to $1 million per year for a megasite project with a local match of a half million and allowing those localities to come back in a subsequent year for another allocation of up to $1 million with a local match of a half million.
02:37:01
So this formula will provide them with a multiple year total of up to $2 million in state allocations matched with up to $2 million in local allocations with a total of $3 million.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:37:11
Mr. Chairman?
02:37:12
Yes.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:37:12
Mr. Buhl, relative to your previous comment about breaking the planning from the construction, and then you used the words in this $1 million focus group suggestion of road construction but not planning.
02:37:28
Is that a separate deal here?
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:37:31
They would still be able to come to us for a separate allocation for the planning phase.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:37:35
Which would be still at $650?
02:37:38
So we keep the planning, we break them apart, we keep the planning numbers where they are now, but then they could come back for an additional two million dollars, one million at a time, for construction.
02:37:54
So ultimately we would move from six fifty
02:37:58
to $2,650,000 as a limit with more match, of course, but that's what would come out of our coffers at the highest.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:38:08
Right, and as an example, we actually have on your action agenda today an allocation for one of these mega site locations in Carroll County.
02:38:17
As an example with that one, they can only ask for $650,000 right now, but the road construction alone on that project is well over a million dollars.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:38:28
In your recommendation, do you tie the gap in terms of time between the planning and the construction of some sort of, is there some criteria for that?
02:38:41
I mean obviously,
02:38:43
We wouldn't really necessarily want to do a planning 650 if we thought construction was going to be 12 years from now.
02:38:50
We might wait on that.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:38:51
What we're looking at is that having the plans ready so that the road construction can be shovel ready is so important on these sites.
02:38:59
What we would do is have them bond the planning phase until the road plans are complete and approved for construction by VDOT.
02:39:07
Then we would release the bond.
02:39:09
We would have a separate bonded period for each of the construction phases.
02:39:13
We also talked about the EDA program in general and asked them for some suggestions on what we could do to improve for the more routine projects.
02:39:30
And one thing that the focus group suggested to us was government facilities are not currently eligible as a qualifying establishment.
02:39:38
And they recommended that we consider allowing both federal government and nonprofit development and investment to count towards that qualifying investment in the project.
02:39:48
Staff recommendation is to open that qualifying establishment up to government facilities and make that change in the policy.
02:39:56
We did not include the nonprofit in our first policy.
02:40:01
I think this program has been around for a while.
02:40:08
We've made a number of changes over the past few years.
02:40:11
Not knowing how that's going to change the complexion of the program, we figure we take one step with the government installations and can change that nonprofit in the subsequent year.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:26
I would have expected it to be reversed.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:40:31
Focus groups seem more focused to me on the government installations.
02:40:35
That was a bigger issue for them, but we can go back and look at that.
SPEAKER_02
02:40:41
That's something people are watching.
02:40:42
That precludes our major universities and colleges, though, then, right?
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:40:46
Right now, those types of public facilities are not eligible.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:49
You see, and they're on the cutting edge of a lot of things that could create jobs in the Commonwealth.
SPEAKER_10
02:40:55
I speak for knowing that at George Mason and I'm sure UVA or Tech or Shenandoah will be the same situation.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:41:04
That seems incongruent in what we're trying to do.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:41:18
There was a lot of discussion related to BRAC and military facilities and having sites that are open for that type of investment.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:41:27
I can see, Mr. Chairman, there is going to be another round of BRAC, but there also is going to be a round non-military BRAC, if you want to call it that, as the federal government's spending plans change and they're faced with consolidating
02:41:45
Operations, headquarters, offices, just like everybody else.
02:41:50
So this may be something that has a little more urgency than it would appear.
SPEAKER_02
02:41:56
That's sort of what Mr. Miller was talking about, the non-profits looking at him.
02:42:02
A lot of hospitals are non-profits.
02:42:05
And so I don't see the real, I mean, it seems like to me if we open up for one, we ought to open up for both of them.
02:42:10
I mean, if it's economic development, I mean, it's warm over substance, right?
02:42:14
I mean, so I would encourage the staff to take a look at opening up also for non-profits.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:42:20
Mr. Chairman, I think there's a prejudice against non-profits for fear that you're not going to be paying taxes
02:42:26
And it's a little bit true for governments as well unless they have impact fees that are off our time space.
02:42:31
But I take the example of what's happening here in Southwest Virginia with the law school and the pharmacy school could be greatly benefited by being able to also access these funds, open up sites for those educational facilities.
02:42:48
But I do understand the prejudice that they are against nonprofits because of the local tax issue.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:42:55
I think one of the items that concerns staff a little bit is there's only 5.5 million dollars a year that comes into this fund for economic development access and rail industrializing.
02:43:06
And over the past few years, we haven't had as many requests, but we've had funding built up in that fund.
02:43:12
But if we open it too broadly, we could very quickly burn down what money is available and be turning that away.
02:43:18
So it's a matter of priority.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:19
We want to spend it?
02:43:20
Yeah, we want to spend it.
02:43:22
We want to create the job.
SPEAKER_02
02:43:25
Dr. Bibbitt, we make too many jobs.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:43:28
We can look at that.
SPEAKER_02
02:43:29
I'll get it.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:31
Mr. Chairman, let me elaborate a little bit.
02:43:35
You know, to Dr. Davis' point, I understand the real estate tax piece, but obviously that's not what it's all about.
02:43:42
It's not totally what it's all about.
02:43:44
There are other things that come out of any entity, whether it's
02:43:49
We have these funds here to Mr. Layne's point for a reason and to create more value by spending them than by keeping them.
02:44:09
I mean, if we don't want more of it, then we ought to send it all back and do none of it.
02:44:16
The more of this we can do, if we can spend two dollars and make six, that's what we want to do.
02:44:22
So I don't really care whether it's a private sector, a public sector, a non-profit sector, I don't care what it is, if I can spend two and get six or two and get four, I want to do that.
02:44:35
And as far as I'm concerned,
02:44:37
Everything else being equal, which perhaps it's not, but everything else being equal, you know, first come, first served, it's sort of like a project.
02:44:45
Let's get it done.
02:44:47
Let's get the job created.
02:44:49
Let's get the economic development happening.
02:44:52
And if it's the government versus the private sector versus whatever, as long as they're spinning off more value to us than it costs us, then I think we want to do that.
02:45:02
We want to spend it as fast as we can.
02:45:05
If we weren't getting the value, then we should spend none of it.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:45:12
All right, a couple more recommendations.
02:45:15
One of the things the localities on a focus group recommended was that we allow them to get credit for the locally funded public infrastructure that they're putting into these sites.
02:45:24
A lot of the localities are buying the land, they're constructing shell buildings to attract business to the site.
02:45:29
Right now, that doesn't count as part of that qualifying investment credit, and we're also concurring with that recommendation and it includes that language in the policy.
02:45:41
Another suggestion from the focus group was to allow reimbursement of design costs incurred prior to CTB approval as it stands right now.
02:45:48
Anything a locality does before you take action and allocate funding is not eligible.
02:45:54
Staff are in a new change in policy on that right now.
02:45:57
Most of, based on our project and our project history, we're not fully funding projects to start with, and so this would further dilute how much money there is.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:06
Mr. Chairman?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:08
Yes.
02:46:08
What about your previous suggestion?
02:46:12
If local government is going to do something and we do it for them instead, I'm not sure that's a good thing for us if they're going to already do it.
02:46:30
In this suggestion of giving credit for locally funded public infrastructure improvements to attract economic development,
02:46:40
How do you sort of justify that?
02:46:42
Are you suggesting they wouldn't do this?
02:46:44
Or are you suggesting we're just going to help them after they've done it or help them more?
02:46:51
I mean, it's sort of like, I don't want to fund it if they're already going to do it.
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:46:54
You're not, in this situation, you're not funding it.
02:46:57
What you're allowing them to do is for those bonded projects where the locality doesn't have its named industry.
02:47:03
They've got five-year time periods to qualify investment that offset how much you've allocated.
02:47:09
In some cases, we get to the end of that five-year period and the locality has to repay the amount that's been allocated from the economic development access fund.
02:47:17
What this would allow them to do is if they don't have a named industry, they get at least some credit for their investment on the site to reduce their bonded repayment.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:28
But we're still paying it because otherwise we'd get it back.
02:47:31
So you can use whatever word you want, but we have less money at the end than we otherwise had.
02:47:40
And I guess my concern is we want the local government to have some skin in the game when they're coming to us asking for the access funds to do this project in the sense that they've got some skin, they've got some risk.
02:47:58
And some, I don't know how much,
02:48:01
Obviously, we want them to be aggressive and we want to help them because at the end of the day, we want it to be successful.
02:48:08
But if we take all their skin out of the game, I'm afraid we're going to get to a point where there's no reason not to ask because there's no risk.
02:48:18
And I would be that as it would play out.
02:48:23
You just ask every time because you may win and you may not, but if you have no risk,
02:48:28
It's like playing the lottery, but it doesn't cost you anything.
02:48:32
Why would you not do it?
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:48:34
There's still pretty significant risks on the localities, and that transitions into my next slide.
02:48:40
In October of 2010, this board established a bond moratorium for projects that were approved by the board between 2005 and 2009 based on the economic downturn.
02:48:50
A lot of projects were having a hard time attracting that industry because the economic development just wasn't coming into the state.
02:48:55
That's a risk on the localities for having to repay those bonds.
02:48:59
That bond moratorium schedule should expire July 1st of this year.
02:49:05
There's concern that the economy hasn't bounced back to the level that can really attract the kind of business that they need.
02:49:13
And we have four projects that we would have to call bonds on in July if that bond moratorium is not extended.
02:49:20
So that's going to be recommended by resolution next month that we extend the existing moratorium and then put a moratorium in place for those projects.
02:49:28
The bond would expire between July 1st of this year and July 1st of 2014.
02:49:33
to extend their bonded period that would cover six projects.
02:49:37
So we're talking about a total of ten projects statewide.
02:49:42
Last recommendation comes from staff, and this is to set aside up to 1% of the EDA funds per year, that's up to $55,000, for program administration to allow us to be more aggressive in what we do in terms of outreach and communication with the economic development community, working with the Virginia Economic Development Partnership to bring more of these projects to reality.
02:50:07
In terms of next steps, we're going to bring you two items at next month's CTB meeting for consideration.
02:50:13
One is the policy change, which you have to draft in your package.
02:50:17
And the second is the extension of the bond moratorium.
02:50:20
That would be by resolution as well, with the intent of us coming back to the development community with the revised program and economic development access guidelines that you've achieved.
SPEAKER_02
02:50:31
Is your consideration to expand that focus group to maybe some of those outside the mega projects?
Jennifer DeBruhl
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:50:37
We had a broader focus group in 2007 when we made some changes based on code.
02:50:42
That was the policy change prior to the 2010 change.
02:50:45
So we had a much broader focus group at that time.
02:50:48
Because this was focused more on the strategic properties initiatives, working with the EDP, we had the smaller focus group at the time.
02:50:54
But we welcome input from anybody in the development community that has suggestions on that improvement program.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:51:03
Thank you very much.