Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 3/14/2012
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
3/14/2012
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Bids.pdf
VDOT Fiscal Year 2012 budget _ actual performance through February 2012.pdf
General Assembly report.pdf
1. E-Z Pass Virginia Operation Overview and Challenges
E-ZPass Virginia operational overview and challenges.pdf
2. 495 Express Lanes Marketing Plan
I-495 Express Lanes education and marketing.pdf
3. Downtown Tunnel/Midtown Tunnel/MLK Extension Project Marketing Plan
Downtown Tunnel _ Midtown Tunnel _ MLK Extension Project presentation.pdf
4. I-95 HOT Lanes Updates
I-95 HOV_HOT Lanes Project early works.pdf
5. Financial Report
6. Legislative Update
7. VTRANS 2035 Update
VTrans2035 update.pdf
8. Jolly Pond Dam Discontinuance
Jolly Pond dam.pdf
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:01
Can I ask everyone please take your seats.
SPEAKER_15
00:00:05
Good morning everyone.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:14
I'd like to welcome you to this March meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:21
I ask first if everyone could please stand and we will do the Pledge of Allegiance.
00:00:26
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
00:00:43
Thank you all very much, and we'll get right into the workshop items, the first being Easy Pass, and the Virginia Operation Overview and Challenges.
00:00:53
Mr. Lawson.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:00:58
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
SPEAKER_15
00:01:03
I think I had to get around all this technology this morning.
00:01:16
First one?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:22
Yeah.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:01:26
Good morning.
00:01:27
Last month there was a request that we provide kind of an update or overview on E-ZPass and how we're looking to address the oncoming new facilities in the Commonwealth.
00:01:41
So what I thought I would do this morning is start off by just kind of giving you an overview and an update of just E-ZPass in general and how
00:01:50
It operates within Virginia and some of the challenges that we're looking forward to and how we're looking to address them.
00:02:00
First off, E-ZPass is a large network.
00:02:05
It's not anything specific to the Commonwealth.
00:02:10
It is participated by, or E-ZPass is an association of 24 different total agencies.
00:02:17
Across 14 states, the toll group was created to form an interoperable network of toll agencies.
00:02:28
It is the largest toll organization in the United States.
00:02:33
It currently is processing over 2.4 billion E-ZPass toll transactions a year, collecting over $5 billion in revenues.
00:02:45
Virginia joined the E-ZPass group
00:02:48
or the Interagency Group as it was called at that point in 2003.
00:02:52
And even before then, Virginia was collecting electronic tolls under the name of fast tolls starting in 1996.
00:03:05
Starting in 2004, Virginia actually was accepting transactions through the E-ZPass network, taking advantage of the brand recognition, the customer satisfaction that comes along with E-ZPass network, and really supporting the E-ZPass network, which has become the world leader in total interoperability, with more than 21 million E-ZPass transponders
00:03:35
in use today.
00:03:40
This slide just kind of graphic kind of illustrates for you the footprint of the E-ZPass network.
00:03:46
All the purple states you see colored here are the states that have toll facilities that are operating under the E-ZPass network.
00:03:57
The gray states that are intermixed do not have electronic toll collection.
00:04:03
And the blue states you see down toward the south have their own electronic toll networks.
00:04:12
I'm happy to report that E-ZPass is doing all they can to continue and to support interoperability and have just established a new membership category called a national affiliate to allow other entities such as the states that you see here, North Carolina, Florida,
00:04:32
To be able to join into the interoperability that comes with E-ZPass without becoming a full-fledged E-ZPass member having to discard their own existing networks.
00:04:51
In terms of E-ZPass within Virginia, E-ZPass is accepted for electronic tolling on all the facilities
00:04:59
within the Commonwealth.
00:05:00
You see the full list here including the two that are managed by VDOT, White Parkway Extension and the George P. Coleman Bridge and all the other facilities that are managed by the others across the Commonwealth.
00:05:16
Virginia has the sole membership into E-ZPass for the Commonwealth and all the other facilities fall kind of under an umbrella membership
00:05:27
are members through the Commonwealth through VDOT.
00:05:36
The E-ZPass operations within the Commonwealth is handled by VDOT through a contractor.
00:05:44
We currently have a contract with Faneuil Incorporated, which is a Hampton based company, to provide the back office and the customer service center operations.
00:05:54
We currently have about 560,000 accounts, ECPAS accounts, and about 900,000 transponders in service.
00:06:05
In calendar year 2011, we processed nearly 130 million electronic toll transactions, collecting almost 190 million in tolls.
00:06:20
In grand total, and I'll explain the differences on the next slide, we processed nearly 140 million electronic toll transactions and over 220 million in toll revenues for the facilities within the Commonwealth.
00:06:39
As part of the interoperability that comes with E-ZPass, we also process what are called away agency transactions.
00:06:47
We process transactions for
00:06:50
Virginia account holders that use facilities in the other participating states as well as we process transactions for account holders in the other states that use Virginia facilities.
00:07:08
During 2011, we processed, or we received almost $36 million, excuse me, we sent about $36 million
00:07:20
Revenues from Virginia accounts to other account agencies within the easy pass network.
00:07:29
And the back flip side of that is, and this was kind of a surprising number to me, is of all the transactions on the Virginia facilities, approximately 11% of the transactions and about 18% of the total toll revenues
00:07:48
Process on the Virginia facilities came from E-ZPass account holders in the other states.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:08:00
So the difference between the 11 and the 18 is suggesting it's where what facilities are being used because they have different rates.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:08:12
In terms of account management, again, as I mentioned, we do have a contractor, Fangland Incorporated, that
00:08:41
manages our E-ZPass network.
00:08:44
They provide for the back office as well as the customer service centers and the database management inventory control, the full suite of activities associated with E-ZPass.
00:08:57
The account sign up, which is I guess we're talking about a lot as we're looking for the new facilities and being able to prepare for additional facilities
00:09:09
Currently we have several methods to do that.
00:09:13
We have, obviously you can mail an application into the customer service center and the main office is in Clifton Forge.
00:09:22
There's a toll free number which you can call to address your account, set up a new account or attend to your account.
00:09:30
We have a dedicated website, easypassva.com where you can log on to
00:09:37
Create an account, again, to manage your account.
00:09:40
We have three walk-in centers presently, one at Coleman Bridge, in Gloucester Point, one in Herndon, and one in Richmond.
00:09:50
Interesting statistics of all the new account activity, 68% of new account activity is handled through the online web application.
00:10:05
That activity has been growing significantly in terms of just simple account maintenance.
00:10:11
Web activity has grown nine times since 2008, becoming the predominant means by which people are interacting with us.
00:10:20
In terms of the walk-in centers, the most rural location, the Coleman Bridge, Gloucester Point location, is actually the busiest of the three customer service centers.
00:10:39
In terms of the way we manage our accounts or manage the transponders, we do not sell the transponders to the customer.
00:10:48
They remain the property of VDOT and will be replaced through warranties, through just normal utilization.
00:10:56
The batteries have a life expectancy and they have to be replaced.
00:11:00
So that's all done.
00:11:03
through Air Contractor as part of VDOT's cost.
00:11:07
The current cost for obtaining a transponder is a minimum prepaid total of $35 plus a $25 security deposit.
00:11:20
That security deposit, however, is waived if the customer chooses auto replenishment through a checking or savings account with a credit card backup.
00:11:30
It's important to note that 92% of all accounts today are set up to auto replenish.
00:11:44
Looking to the future, we see tremendous growth happening in the E-ZPass arena within the Commonwealth.
00:11:53
We have three new facilities scheduled to come online before the end of the calendar year.
00:11:58
You see those listed below, Jordan Bridge, Downtown Midtown Tunnel, and the 495 Express Lanes.
00:12:05
And all three of these facilities will be all electronic tolling.
00:12:11
There will be no toll booths to collect cash.
00:12:15
With the activities coming from these additional facilities, we potentially could see a doubling in E-ZPass accounts over the next several years.
00:12:26
And in addition to the
00:12:28
This is just the increased volume of accounts.
00:12:30
We'll be introducing a new type of transponder called the EZ-Pass Flex or Hot Pass which will be used to support the express lanes.
00:12:41
What the new transponder does is allow you to identify yourself as an HOV-free rider versus a toll-paying hot lanes customer.
00:12:55
To support this activity,
00:12:58
We have really reached out to our partners to assess the need, the anticipated volumes of accounts and transponders that will be needed to support these efforts.
00:13:11
We've identified kind of a schedule of transponder needs over the next 12 months between now and March of 2013 and we've worked with the manufacturer
00:13:24
to kind of place a tentative order to say this is the volumes of transponders we'll be needing over this next year.
00:13:32
We're looking at moving over 200,000 standard transponders and equally as many of the new E-ZPass Flex transponders.
00:13:44
Distribution of these transponders or the acquisition of these transponders will
00:13:49
To distribute all the additional transponders, we've been looking at means of enhancing air
00:14:09
existing distribution channels and thinking down the road in terms of additional customer service accessibility as we move down the road.
00:14:22
As mentioned, we have two major facilities coming online this year and in those areas we're looking at opportunities to expand or provide for additional walk-in centers
00:14:36
As well as we've been working with the Department of Motor Vehicles to partner with them to be able to provide E-ZPass services from within a DMV location.
00:14:49
And then we're also looking to implement E-ZPass On The Go, which is a retail distribution program.
00:14:58
E-ZPass On The Go is in place in several of the northern states.
00:15:03
In essence, what it does is allows a retailer to be able to sell a prepackaged live transponder to a customer.
00:15:12
We are working through Air Contractor Faneuil and their marketing firm to put this in place.
00:15:19
They are in the midst of negotiations with the vendors today.
00:15:26
What they have found thus far is they've been most likely retailers
00:15:32
To do this would be grocery, big box retailers, potentially drugstores.
00:15:39
We are planning and on track to have these arrangements finalized by the beginning of June with the plans of having the transponders available for retail distribution at the beginning of July.
00:15:54
Following with what we're doing with our current transponders,
00:15:58
We are looking not to sell the transponder.
00:16:02
It would still remain VDOT property and the customer would be obtaining the transponder by buying $35 in prepaid tolls to encourage the customer to
00:16:23
Register their transponder to set up their new account, we would limit the availability of the toll to $15 until the account is registered, and at that time, the remaining $20 of prepaid tolls would become available.
00:16:39
By taking this approach, the retailer is not put in a position where he has to capture any personal information related to the customer to set up the account.
00:16:51
about getting the transponder in the person's hands, and then the person then would, through the web, through the phone, through a walk-in center, would be able to then establish the account.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:05
So I go into Best Buy, and I say I need a transponder.
00:17:14
And they hand me one, and I pay $35?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:17:20
Yes, sir.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:21
and I've got $15 on account.
00:17:25
$15 on account.
00:17:28
So I have your transponder, you don't know who I am, I've got $15 prepaid and then I walk down the street and I go to another Best Buy and I say, give me a transponder.
00:17:39
How does that work?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:17:42
Then you would have to.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:43
Okay, I won't ask any more questions.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:17:50
Just to follow up on that.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:53
The point is I get $15 worth of tolls without any accountability and how do you control that when you're doing that 50 times?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:18:05
The thing you have to remember is that you've paid $35 for that $15 of tolls.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:10
I'm paying you $35 because we didn't get into that part.
00:18:12
I pay the retailer $35, but I only get $15.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:18:17
The 20 only becomes, the remaining 20 becomes available once you register your account.
SPEAKER_15
00:18:21
But a follow-up on that, Mr.
00:18:23
Chair.
00:18:23
Yeah.
00:18:24
Who's, is the Commonwealth losing money, making money, or breaking even on these deals?
00:18:31
Who's making money?
00:18:32
Is it costing us to operate these and pass, or is it becoming?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:18:37
Okay.
00:18:37
If you guys have been taking the next couple slides, we'll answer your question.
00:18:45
All right.
00:18:45
To support these increasing numbers, we've also done some, are doing some improvements within the back office.
00:18:55
We are enhancing our computer network and beefing up the processing capabilities to support it.
00:19:03
We are looking at, you know, we talked about earlier having additional walk-in centers.
00:19:08
We are making sure we have sufficient customer service support.
00:19:11
Faneuil currently has 81 staff working on E-ZPass, so it is a fairly large operation and those numbers will be increased as needed to provide the services.
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:29
Mr. Chairman?
00:19:29
Yes.
00:19:29
Mr. Lawson, going back to your earlier question, currently you pay $35 and a $25 deposit.
00:19:35
Are you saying that under the new program to be sold at
00:19:40
One last question.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:19:46
I think I saw in here where the replenishment program would be
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:07
Right now, I don't think that's the way it works.
00:20:20
I just have a primary credit card with them.
00:20:22
There's no checking account involved.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:20:24
Right.
00:20:25
The incentive before was to use, if you use the checking account with a credit card backup, you would waste the deposit.
00:20:34
You do not have to have a checking account connected to auto replenish.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:39
You can do it directly.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:20:52
Correct.
00:20:57
In terms of cost,
00:21:00
The annual operation of the Customer Service Center is about $10 million a year, and it is intended to operate on a break-even basis.
00:21:09
It's not a money-making operation, nor is it an operation to be subsidized by the Commonwealth.
00:21:17
Currently, the cost associated with this operation is recovered through transaction fees.
00:21:24
The fees today
00:21:25
are based on a two-component fee.
00:21:28
There's a fixed fee that's computed every year, currently is just over four cents a transaction that is passed on to the toll facilities.
00:21:38
And then there's a revenue fee of about just a shy of 2% that's associated with the bank fees and the fees that we pay to the other interoperable agency, all the E2PAS agencies related to the volume of revenue.
00:21:57
The fixed fees, just to kind of explain it, the components of the fixed fee include the cost of the customer service center, annual dues as part of E-ZPass.
00:22:08
We have a management consultant that helps support the activity as well as we amortize the cost of the transponders that we purchased as well as the back office operations, the total system itself.
00:22:22
And again, the revenue fees cover the transactional
00:22:26
looking to the future, some of the next steps we're looking to take.
00:22:36
We're pushing hard to develop and implement the retail program.
00:22:41
Again, we fully expect to have that in operation come July 1.
00:22:48
We are also looking very hard at the need for additional walk-in centers in certain areas to support
00:22:57
areas that need that.
00:23:00
Again, as I mentioned earlier, our most rural location in Gloucester is the busiest of our customer service centers.
00:23:08
So we have to keep that in mind as we are trying to place these things and look to the communities that may be more of that type.
00:23:16
And then it's very important that we continue to work with our partnering facilities.
00:23:21
We are planning to have EGPAS presence at marketing events that they put on.
00:23:28
We will want to have some temporary distribution locations as we get closer to the facilities coming on board and we will support their marketing campaigns.
SPEAKER_15
00:23:44
John, quick question.
00:23:49
I noticed you said it was $10 million at the cost of the operation center and you're charging a transaction fee to the tolling facilities?
00:23:57
That's correct.
00:23:58
That's the contractor operating the tolling facilities?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:24:01
Correct.
SPEAKER_15
00:24:02
Do they have that on top of the tolls or are they just pulling that out of the tolls?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:24:08
In existing facilities today, that is all part of their toll.
00:24:12
It comes out of the toll.
00:24:14
It's not an addition to.
SPEAKER_15
00:24:15
Okay.
00:24:16
There's $5 billion being collected total.
00:24:19
Did I remember that correctly?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:24:21
The $5 billion is E-ZPass Network, all 24 agencies.
SPEAKER_15
00:24:25
What is the total operating cost?
00:24:27
I know $10 million is more than that.
00:24:29
What's the total operating cost to get that $5 billion?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:24:35
I would not know that.
00:24:36
There's 24 different agencies that participate in 14 different states, of which we're just one of the 24.
SPEAKER_15
00:24:44
Okay, but I'm talking about just the state of Virginia, I'm not worried about Florida.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:24:48
No, these are the easy pass, you know, if I go back here, see all the purple states make up the easy pass network, and that's the area that generates the 5 million.
SPEAKER_15
00:25:00
I just used Florida as an example, I'm not talking about other states, I'm just talking about what it costs to operate the state of Virginia.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:25:06
Ten million dollars is VDOT's operating cost, which generates about 200 million in revenue, collects about 200 million in revenue.
SPEAKER_15
00:25:20
Just a comment and then a couple questions.
00:25:26
I suspect the utilization rate is going to vary by facility because I can tell you the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel, it's a much higher penetration.
00:25:33
Probably over 60% of the people who use the facility use E-ZPass, a lot of them coming from the north.
00:25:40
On the transaction fees, I know you just answered that it was inclusive of the toll.
00:25:46
But is that the fee that the toll operator will pay to you?
00:25:52
In other words, are there additional fees that he is charged over and above that for transaction for the bank's processing them?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:26:00
Well, that was the two components of the transaction fee.
SPEAKER_15
00:26:03
The final thing I would put out is that
00:26:07
We're expecting at the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel an increase in traffic because of preponderance of new transponders moving through the area.
00:26:17
And if there's a way that we can participate and help in the marketing, because we're already doing it, throw that up there.
00:26:23
I know you've got to get them out there, and we've already got a network developed.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:26:28
If I could just add, you asked a question about penetration.
00:26:33
For the Commonwealth, all facilities, we're at about 65%.
00:26:37
The highest ones are, I think, Greenway with over 80%.
00:26:43
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:45
Mr. Chairman.
00:26:46
Yes.
00:26:47
Yes, this is Lawson.
00:26:48
Yes, sir.
00:26:49
For the prepaid transfunders who sell in the big box stores,
SPEAKER_09
00:26:54
Now, once the customer activates the account, does it remain prepaid, or do they have to go to a credit card or checking account?
00:27:02
Or do they just go back to the big box and say, well, give you $20 and cash towards the total?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:27:09
When they establish the account, we hope they will set it up to auto replenish with a credit card.
00:27:17
But they do not have to do that.
00:27:18
Again, we have about 8% of our accounts today.
00:27:21
They manually replenish.
00:27:24
You would not be able to go do that at the big box store though.
00:27:28
You would have to do the account maintenance per se at a walk-in center or either online or by phone.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:35
It's really the $15 is just really a one-time shot and until they use 2.9% account activated.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:27:43
Correct.
00:27:44
The big box store, though, again, the E-ZPass on the Go program is purely to facilitate distribution.
00:27:52
It will not handle customer service or any account maintenance.
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:59
Thank you.
00:28:00
Mr. Chairman?
00:28:01
Yes.
00:28:02
Mr. Lawson, a couple of questions.
00:28:04
I think early in your presentation you suggested 68% of the transactions are now occurring online.
00:28:10
Correct.
00:28:11
Do you have a breakdown or do you know what the purchase of the new transponders or the possible purchase of the deposit and whatnot, what percentage of that kind of activity is happening online versus a walk-in?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:28:27
Well, again, the 68% number I used earlier was new account set up.
00:28:31
68% of new accounts are set up online.
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:36
Second question, as you get closer to the polling of Interstate 95, have you considered strategies that will sell at retail level close to the North Carolina border as most of that traffic will not be familiar, not likely to be customers of E-ZPass?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:28:58
We have not at this point, but as we continue to develop the tolling program for 95, we will certainly be looking at those opportunities.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:09
Mr. Chairman?
00:29:12
Yes.
00:29:14
Regarding the waiver of the $25 fee and replacement, clearly the checking account or credit card does nothing to prevent
00:29:28
loss or theft.
00:29:31
Am I correct that the real purpose of that is to, you simply take the $25 once it's lost?
00:29:40
Then why do you need both checking and credit card?
00:29:43
Can you just take it as easily from one?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:29:47
In terms of the, I mean today, the reason we had asked for the checking to be the primary is that it's
00:29:57
Mr. Chairman, just a quick question.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:10
When you travel around Europe on the roads that have tolls, the big roads,
00:30:26
They have their form of easy pass, but also you can just pull out a Visa card and stick it in there.
00:30:32
There's no attendance, and you have that infrastructure that's already there with the banks, and it worked fine.
00:30:39
Why don't we do something like that?
00:30:41
It makes it easier for the consumer.
00:30:45
Do we have that type of thing?
00:30:46
Have we thought of that?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:30:48
This truly gets to a facility specific question.
00:30:53
Obviously we're moving to all electronic open roads that don't slow down to have to pay a toll, to reduce congestion purposes, just keep traffic flowing.
00:31:04
But we do have, I know on Pocahontas at least, I'm not sure what other facilities, they do have unmanned booths at ramps where you can swipe a credit card.
00:31:17
We do have the technology to allow that to take place, but not from a main line, all electronic perspective.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:24
It makes it easier for the consumer who may not have all these devices, especially for tourists.
00:31:28
We have a $19 to $20 billion tour of the industry.
00:31:32
They're not going to have all these little devices, I don't think.
00:31:36
In Europe, it works fine.
00:31:37
They have lanes where you can just go right through, and then they have a couple lanes or maybe one where you can just put your credit card in and go to.
00:31:45
I didn't see any backup.
00:31:48
This is in Italy or France or anywhere.
SPEAKER_15
00:31:53
We did an exhaustive study at Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel and it's about a third more in transaction costs for the credit card.
00:32:00
And that's why we're offering them but we don't market them because we're waiting to see
00:32:04
The number of transponders that are going to be now proliferate across the state because of that, but it is about a third more expensive to accept the credit card versus the transaction fee on the transponder.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:32:22
Okay, I think the next two presentations will help fill you in a little bit on that one.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:30
Just, Lawson, before you go, you're not going to ask us.
00:32:33
I mean, so how many transponders are we estimating we're going to have to issue in the next year?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:32:39
We, over the next 12 months, we would anticipate issuing about 400,000 transponders, which would be a combination of new facilities and just normal replacements.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:52
So how many have been in, are in, how many do we have currently registered at the state?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:32:58
We currently have 900,000 transponders.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:01
So we're going to look like essentially a 50% increase in just a year.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:33:08
We'll probably go from 9 to a billion U2, let's say, because of the new sweat switch outs.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:14
And even with 900,000 existing, we're still going to have to, because of the HOT stuff, the express lanes, people are going to be coming in
00:33:24
And potentially swapping out of the new switch bullet.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:28
That's correct.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:30
Now my issue is, who do we have a contract with right now to do retail?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:33:38
There's no one on contract today to do retail.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:42
How are we going to get this done in the next six months?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:33:46
We are, as I explained, we are working through our contractor's annual.
00:33:51
We are on track to have our retail arrangements in place by the beginning of June to have retail functioning beginning of July.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:00
So we have actually reached out and met with, how many different retails?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:34:06
I don't have those details, sir.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:09
There's enough angst about the whole issue to start with, and if we don't execute when it starts, I share your... it's going to be a very difficult situation.
00:34:36
I trust the secretary and the commissioner and the staff, but... June is way too late.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:46
I mean, then we're looking at potentially midtown, downtown.
00:34:50
September?
00:34:51
October?
00:34:54
I just...
00:34:58
Yes, a lot of them.
SPEAKER_15
00:35:00
John, if someone, let's just say in the state of Virginia, doesn't travel that much and they've got to take the family on vacation, do they have to, how do they go about getting a transponder?
00:35:13
I mean, are they, how easy is that going to be for them to pick up one or find one or whatever?
00:35:18
I think it becomes very much a facility specific question.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:35:35
What road is it that they will be needing to use?
00:35:40
Existing facilities today have cash options where they can pay toll at a toll plaza.
00:35:46
The new facilities coming online.
00:35:50
You know, if you don't have a transponder, they do have alternate means that they will toll you through invoicing process, and I think you'll hear some of that from the next two presentations.
00:36:00
So it's not like you can't use the road unless you have the transponder, you know what I mean?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:11
So who are we, I mean,
00:36:16
This is really, I mean, I'll continue to press you guys on this.
00:36:20
I'm very concerned that we don't necessarily have these contracts in place and we don't have a true outreach and marketing plan in getting these things sold.
00:36:34
What do we need to do to shake this loose?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:36:37
Sir, I believe it is fully underway.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:42
were in March, and you don't have a single contract with a single retailer.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:50
So, Mr. Chairman, we had a meeting the other day with all of the operators, and I'm pretty convinced that we have this plan to get the retail operations in place.
00:37:05
There was a concern raised that the negotiations could take longer than we anticipated, but at this point we believe we're on track to make it, to have those vendors online in June.
00:37:19
They're in the negotiations with the vendors right now.
00:37:24
We also are looking at ways to mitigate the issues.
00:37:28
that we could have.
00:37:30
Number one, we do have, citizens can come online to get their transponders.
00:37:36
Sixty-some percent of all people use online to get their transponders.
00:37:42
Number two, we are working with identifying other locations that we can establish a physical presence to distribute tolls, I mean transponders so that people can walk in and purchase them.
00:37:56
We're also working with DMV and we are working with DMV to be able to sell transponders in the DMV facilities.
00:38:07
So we're looking at those issues as ways to mitigate any problems that we have with retail.
00:38:14
I think retail is one component of how we distribute transponders and not the only way to distribute them.
00:38:22
So I do believe that we have a process in place that will mitigate some of the concerns in issuing transponders, but it will be a significant challenge for us to get those many transponders out to citizens.
00:38:41
But we are working aggressively on getting the retail operation in place.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:48
So April,
00:38:50
I'd like to have a report back here next April.
00:38:54
I mean, this April, I want you to come in here and tell me where we are, how you've progressed from this meeting to the next meeting.
00:38:59
In fact, every month, I want reports to the CTB about where we are, because I mean, to go back to what Mr. Miller said, I mean, if we don't get this right from the get-go, you know, it is going to be a true black mark on the entire program.
SPEAKER_15
00:39:17
Yes, sir?
00:39:18
What is our role at CTB?
00:39:22
No, no, this is more of a, we get the opportunity to beat up VDOT.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:35
Honestly, at this point, I mean, this is a gun called ministerial action.
00:39:39
We already have the policy.
00:39:41
This is really implementing what's already been, you know, obviously the overall program.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:50
Mr. Chairman, I just want to reiterate, I still don't see why we just don't use the private sector.
00:39:56
We use the visa cards.
00:39:58
I mean the banks do all the infrastructure.
00:40:01
They're there.
00:40:01
They do that all the time.
00:40:03
And we're setting up a separate big bureaucracy with our own little devices that people may or may not buy.
00:40:09
So I just don't understand at all.
00:40:11
That's the facility decision, not ours.
00:40:15
We're giving them the money, though, aren't we?
00:40:17
Can't we kind of nudge them a little bit?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:20
Well, this is, I mean, in fact, the last two years ago when we were looking, I mean, we're caught up.
00:40:28
I mean, there's two issues, Mr. Rich, and I think that the first one is
00:40:31
This issue on the credit cards is a very good one.
00:40:34
The problem is that the cost of a credit card, you have to pay those transaction fees.
00:40:42
The facility pays it, so then it drives up the cost even more.
00:40:47
So it is the issue of the facility making that decision as to whether to accept credit cards.
00:40:55
The biggest thing I will tell you that the federal government is pushing us to do as much open road tolling as possible so that we don't have the congestion points at the toll booths.
00:41:06
The other thing though is I just got to, I mean there is a good thing and bad thing about having easy pass.
00:41:13
The good thing is it's convenient and now accepted in so many different states.
00:41:18
The bad news is that it's difficult for us to change things
00:41:25
Because it's essentially to keep that thing uniform and to be interoperable up and down the East Coast, it means that we have to quote unquote maybe surrender a certain control over even more advanced technology.
00:41:44
I mean actually now the technology is such that in different parts of the world, you don't even have a transponder anymore.
00:41:49
You just have something in your car that just reads, you know,
00:41:55
I think Mr. Rich, though, has a point.
00:42:17
In fact, we're all caught between these generations of technology as we go forward.
00:42:23
But also, I would suggest to Mr. Rich, Mr. Rich, we're caught in our own organizational structure, which has set these toll facilities up one at a time.
00:42:33
I know the administration's discussion of whether or not to have a central tolling authority, part of that was based on the ability to reconcile differences and put us on the same footing regardless of where the facility was and so forth.
00:42:47
So, you're right, in terms of technology,
00:42:51
and the information.
00:42:53
Credit card companies have it.
00:42:55
You're more likely to update your address with them than with VDOT or anybody else.
00:43:00
I mean, it's something that you do on a monthly basis.
00:43:03
The transaction, on the other hand, for a transponder is a one-time, it's a $35 transaction when you renew one time as opposed to a series of small transactions each time you move through a booth, so you're right about efficiencies.
00:43:17
On the other hand, at some point, automobiles will tell.
SPEAKER_15
00:43:21
We'll tell the toll facility who it is, and it'll all be built in.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:25
I mean, these things are all coming, so it is a little bit inconvenient, a little bit inefficient at times.
00:43:34
But I think we're all discovering that tolls are, people are paying attention now a little bit more to what tolls are.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:39
I don't want to belabor the point, but overseas I did not find the cost prohibitive, and there were no backups with this system, this dual system of easy pass and credit cards.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:50
Okay, 495 Express Lanes.
00:43:56
Ms. Aument.
SPEAKER_07
00:44:05
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, Mr. Commissioner.
00:44:08
My name is Jennifer Aument and I'm with the investor and long-term operator on the Express Lanes project, Transurban.
00:44:14
And it's really my pleasure to be here along with VDOT to talk to you a little bit about our communications and public education efforts that is underway in advance of the opening of express lanes later this year.
00:44:25
A bit of housekeeping to start off.
00:44:29
For those of you not aware, we have changed the name of the project.
00:44:32
It used to be the Capital Beltway Hot Lanes Project.
00:44:35
It's now called 495 Express Lanes Consistent with Federal Guidelines.
00:44:40
A quick refresher on the project for those of you who are not spending time sitting in congestion on the Beltway right now.
00:44:48
We are building four new lanes on the Capital Beltway between the Springfield Interchange and just north of the Dulles Toll Road.
00:44:54
Those lanes will be high occupancy toll lanes that will use dynamic toll pricing to provide travelers with a faster and more predictable trip on the Capital Beltway.
00:45:04
The express lanes will be open to HOV-3 and to both private and public buses free of charge.
00:45:10
And they'll also be available to other customers who choose to pay a toll from time to time when they want that faster, more predictable trip.
00:45:18
Experience on other hot lanes across the country is that toll-paying customers tend to use the lanes maybe a couple of times a week when they really need them.
00:45:26
I'm very pleased to report the construction of the facility is going extraordinarily well.
00:45:30
We have an unparalleled safety record.
00:45:33
It's on time.
00:45:33
It's on budget and on schedule to be able to open at the end of this year.
00:45:40
Just a little context around the communications and marketing program.
00:45:44
Every element of the program that you'll see today is based on five years of research with our customers and with travelers in the Northern Virginia region.
00:45:52
We've had a robust communications program in partnership with VDOT around this project for more than five years now and have done both formal qualitative and quantitative research studies
00:46:02
As well as countless opportunities for informal interaction with our customers through what has been more than 750 community-based meetings to provide the public information around these projects.
00:46:12
So customers have really had an opportunity to inform this communications program.
00:46:18
Give you a quick snapshot of the program overview and the wheel here.
00:46:23
The objectives of this program are quite simple.
00:46:27
With the express lanes opening this year, you're going to see changing traffic patterns in the Northern Virginia region.
00:46:32
You'll see a new travel tool that's really not in place in the region or anywhere in Virginia.
00:46:37
Travelers won't be familiar with how the hot lanes will work or how the express lanes will work, what the signs will say.
00:46:43
So first and foremost, our task here is to educate the traveling public so they'll know what to expect.
00:46:49
Second, we've got to get them equipped.
00:46:50
As we've discussed this morning, that means getting an E-ZPass or the new E-ZPass flex for carpools in traveler's vehicles on the Capital Boatway.
00:47:00
And finally, we want travelers in Northern Virginia to get excited and motivated to use this new travel option as part of their commute, whether that means being prepared to use the toll option as a backup plan when they need to be somewhere on time or to be thinking about carpooling and finding ways to take advantage of those new travel options as well.
00:47:21
If we move down the wheel here, I'll just give you a quick tidbit of some of the strategies that will be underway throughout 2012 to prepare the traveling public to use the facility.
00:47:30
First, destination-based.
00:47:32
We're taking our program to the places that we know our customers go to work every day.
00:47:37
That means hosting major employment events at places like FDIC, which Mr. Koelemay has been a fantastic partner for us, and also having a very strong presence at Tysons Corner Center,
00:47:49
Where we know that more than 26 million of our customers shop and eat every day or every year.
00:47:55
So the big part of our program is going to where our customers are.
00:47:59
Pervasive coverage.
00:48:00
Our program will include extensive paid advertising and outlets like the Washington Post and WTOP.
00:48:06
We'll also be using some non-traditional tools.
00:48:09
We actually have a fleet of nearly 100 trucks
00:48:12
Delivery trucks that are already traveling the Beltway Corridor that we'll wrap and brand with ExpressLanes.com website so our travelers will get information on how they can get the lanes.
00:48:21
If you get gas in Tyson's Corner in the morning, you'll see our information actually at the pump so you'll know where you can get information on the lanes and how to get an E-ZPass and be prepared to use the road.
00:48:32
Speaking of E-ZPass, as John mentioned, we're working in partnership with VDOT.
00:48:35
on what will be an extensive E-ZPass incentive and promotion program starting in May of this year.
00:48:41
That program will intensify throughout the year and the aim of it, particularly in the early days, is to get as many customers to get an E-ZPass early as we possibly can to help VDOT manage that rush at the end of the year.
00:48:54
We know that people pay their taxes on April 15th.
00:48:57
They do their Christmas shopping on Christmas Eve.
00:48:59
We're realistic and want to have plans in place to deal with procrastinators
00:49:03
We also want to provide as many incentives as possible for people to get that E-ZPass early.
00:49:08
In our case, we're looking at programs like offering toll credits for those who sign up early and even looking at a car giveaway to try to incentivize travelers to get an E-ZPass in their vehicle.
00:49:17
You cannot open a toll road today in 2012 without tweeting it.
00:49:22
So we will have an extensive digital brand program as part of this program.
00:49:25
Obviously, the website will be the anchor of every strategy that we use.
00:49:29
We'll have Facebook, Twitter, and really make every effort to drive people to our website and, of course, to VDOT's website to sign up for their easy pass.
00:49:38
Transurban has opened a lot of toll roads, and I'll tell you, despite best-laid plans, there are always bumps in the road in the early days, and we are very realistic about that, and we'll have a plan in place for rapid response for our customers, for travelers in the region, and for other key stakeholders, so we ensure in those early days that the region is making that transition.
00:50:00
We are prepared to quickly meet customer needs and make that go as smoothly for the region as possible.
00:50:08
Moving into stakeholder management, presentations today are as an example of the kind of stakeholder engagement program that's always been around this project and will continue as we partner with our law enforcement partners, elected officials and others in the region in opening the express lanes.
00:50:23
And finally, last and actually not least, is our special user group program.
00:50:28
There is a whole spectrum of travelers on the Beltway from taxi cabs, federal law enforcement officers,
00:50:34
small delivery trucks and of course our priority carpool and transit customers.
00:50:40
So we have targeted marketing programs that all of those various customers to understand that they know the rules of the road.
00:50:45
Those kinds of programs include working with the American Motorcycle Association so they're pushing information out to their constituents and they know what they need to do to use the express lanes and we had a fantastic meeting.
00:50:57
Just last week the Department of Rail and Public Transportation was kind enough to co-host a meeting with us
00:51:02
with every major transit operator in the Washington, D.C. region.
00:51:06
So that now, nine months out, we're ensuring whether you have a thousand vehicles in your fleet or one vehicle in your fleet, you have the information you need and have time to prepare to be able to utilize the new lanes.
00:51:18
And of course, as part of this program, safety will be a core element of every message that we have, every strategy, every program, every event, safety will dominate.
00:51:29
Give you a sense of the timing for the year.
00:51:31
The road is now expected to open on time in December of this year.
00:51:34
You'll see we have a number of major elements of the program that are already underway, but a few highlights.
00:51:41
Our E-ZPass Incentive Program for early adopters, including the car giveaway, is expected to begin in the May timeframe.
00:51:47
If you're in the Northern Virginia region at any festival, fair, or event, we'll be out there to equip you with an E-ZPass this summer.
00:51:54
We also have a paid advertising program to really start seeing this on the airwaves about the September timeframe, and that will intensify through the end of the year and after the lanes open.
00:52:04
You see the other elements of the program underway throughout 2012.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:07
So where do the little wind-up cars fall under?
SPEAKER_07
00:52:13
The little wind-up cars, Mr. Chairman, you'll embarrass me now because I didn't bring them for this group, but most of the people that work at the Virginia Department of Transportation have wind-up express lanes cars on their desks.
00:52:25
And we've done that with some of our key stakeholders to remind people that this express lane is not hot lanes and to keep it top of mind in your planning.
00:52:33
So I'll have to bring them back for the Commonwealth Transportation Board as well.
00:52:45
To give you a sample of some of that breakthrough creative, other than the small wind-up cars
00:52:50
You'll see some of the sample creative there.
00:52:52
We have very busy commuters in Northern Virginia, so we're taking a very bold approach and helping people think outside the box.
00:52:58
It's time to change lanes is our tagline.
00:53:00
You'll see that everywhere in Northern Virginia this year.
00:53:02
Customer friendly tools.
00:53:04
It's really interesting.
00:53:05
All the research that we've done in and around these lanes, one of the things that we know resonates most with travelers in Northern Virginia is they want some sense of control, controlling something in this big massive congested area.
00:53:18
So you'll see that all of our tools are very centered around taking control of your commute and taking control of your travel.
00:53:24
So we have very consumer-friendly tools, 495expresslanes.com.
00:53:27
You can welcome to go on and check them out for yourself where people can start planning their trip.
00:53:32
They can get used to seeing the signage and what that's like.
00:53:34
They can become familiar with the payment method, familiar with the new entry and exit points on the express lanes through our usual customer-friendly approach.
00:53:45
You can see our delivery trucks there.
00:53:47
We are launching this road in the middle of a major national election.
00:53:51
My advertising team loves that, but it's a very crowded space.
00:53:55
So again, we're looking at very creative opportunities to break through that, whether you're on the road or sitting at home reading the newspaper or listening to the radio in your car, we'll try to grab you.
00:54:06
Examples of some destination-based marketing in Tysons Corner Center, a great partner for us.
00:54:11
I have a lot of presence in Tysons Corner Center this year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:14
I like the truck, but why aren't we seeing signs going up on the construction site?
SPEAKER_07
00:54:24
You'll see them actually go up this week on the construction sites.
00:54:31
We're working with VDOT and VDOT has been a very supportive partner on this front.
00:54:37
Because we're dealing with an interstate highway, there's always a balance in making sure that we promote the safest traveling conditions possible and also get driver information out there and that's always a tricky balance.
00:54:49
For us, distracted driving is our signature safety issue so we don't want to put anything out there.
00:54:52
So where is that then?
00:55:15
The signs are going up in the construction site right now.
00:55:18
You'll see all the construction vehicles have ExpressLanes.com on them.
00:55:21
The signs are going up in the construction zone.
00:55:24
Mr. Drexler, we're working with your team on the next steps in terms of going a little bit farther in terms of signs on the Beltway utilizing DMS and other tools to be able to get that information out there.
00:55:34
I have to make a note here because particularly with Director Drake here, the Department of Rail and Public Transportation
00:55:42
And all of the TDM agencies at the local level in Northern Virginia have just been fantastic partners in helping us get information to particularly the carpool community, the vanpool community, and others.
00:55:53
And so what we've tried to do is make, you know, there's nobody better at communicating to these constituencies and these groups.
00:55:59
So what we've done is try to prepare tools for them to make it as easy as possible for them to get that information out.
00:56:05
We have microsites available for these professionals where they can go on, they can download web copy,
00:56:09
Download ads, put their brand on them, shoot them out, and their constituents can get that information in a way they're used to getting it.
00:56:16
So it's been a very effective tool for us and appreciate that partnership with DRPT.
00:56:21
Again, just to give you a little feel for the ground game, 750 community-based meetings associated with the 495 express lanes over the last five years.
00:56:30
It's a program that's been very effective for us to be in a very personal, hands-on role with our customers and our communities, and we'll continue that throughout this year.
00:56:39
Measuring success, very research-oriented organization and it's important for us as well to ensure throughout 2012 that the strategies that we have out there are indeed reaching customers and meeting their information needs.
00:56:50
So we're going to measure the success of this program in two distinct ways.
00:56:54
The first is a customer engagement metric.
00:56:57
We're targeting 400,000 customer engagements between now and March 2013.
00:57:03
That's measured by website visits, attendance at our events, the results from ongoing benchmarking survey that we'll be doing throughout the year to ensure that we're reaching the traveling public with our message.
00:57:15
The second metric that obviously you'll be following as well along with us this year is the uptake of E-ZPass.
00:57:22
We are targeting 100,000 net new E-ZPass in the Northern Virginia region between now and March of 2013, and we'll continue to measure and track against that.
00:57:30
If we're not getting that penetration, we'll be able to be flexible and move our strategy so that we are seeing that uptake on E-ZPass.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:39
I'm sorry.
00:57:39
Before you go back to that slide, please.
00:57:43
You're essentially saying you're getting out to 400,000 people in order to be able to have 100,000.
SPEAKER_07
00:57:52
That's right.
00:57:52
There's really two goals associated with the 400,000 mark.
00:57:56
We do have a need to get easy passing vehicles.
00:57:58
We have about a 50% penetration among beltway travelers right now, so that's a very critical goal for us.
00:58:04
But we also have a need for all of the traveling public, including the hot lanes customers, our express lanes customers, to inform them and make sure they understand how to use the road as well.
00:58:13
So we're measuring both.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:14
But to go back, I mean, this whole presentation is about outreach.
00:58:18
You aren't selling the transponders.
SPEAKER_07
00:58:22
We are not.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:23
We're working with...
00:58:24
Pointing them to who?
SPEAKER_07
00:58:27
That's right.
00:58:27
The relationship between the express lanes and E-ZPass is similar to Macy's and Visa.
00:58:34
E-ZPass is a payment method that you use to buy our product.
00:58:38
And so we are partnering with VDOT to do everything we can to promote E-ZPass, but we actually send people through our tools to VDOT's website for them to get their E-ZPass, and VDOT actually manages that customer relationship.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:53
So why haven't you all
00:58:55
Can you become a retailer?
SPEAKER_07
00:58:58
We're exploring that option with VDOT right now.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:01
Is that another one of these contracts we'll get in June?
SPEAKER_07
00:59:05
Well, we already have a robust contract in place with the Commonwealth, so we have a solid foundation there, but we are exploring that with VDOT right now, the possibility of whether or not we may be able to play, at least in the short term, a retail support role to help get E-ZPass out the door.
00:59:21
I think we're aligned in making sure that we're doing everything we can to make it convenient for people to get an E-ZPass.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:30
I mean, we're not doing any marketing.
00:59:32
Is that right?
00:59:33
I mean, we really aren't doing marketing.
00:59:35
They're the ones doing the marketing.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:37
They're primarily doing the marketing.
00:59:38
We will have some marketing support.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:43
So what needs to happen for you?
00:59:45
Since you're doing the marketing already, what needs to happen to have you become a retailer?
SPEAKER_07
00:59:52
Well, we would need to work with VDOT so that we have an easy pass on the go product that we could use.
01:00:00
For instance, if we are in Mr. Koelemay's lobby at SAIC on a major commuter transportation fare,
01:00:08
And we have customers that come up and want to get an easy pass.
01:00:11
We would want to work out arrangements so we have an easy pass and a package that they could take and then register online and then be ready to go.
01:00:17
And again, we just had a great discussion just a few days ago with VDOT on how we might be able to partner with them to play that role if necessary.
01:00:28
But we've been assured that their retail program is moving forward quickly.
01:00:32
And we hope that that will address that need, but we are certainly able to support in being a retailer if that's something that we can do.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:40
Well, I mean, again, you're showing pictures of being out and about at public places, and I mean, it sort of makes sense.
01:00:50
Since you're putting the money out to make this happen, the outreach, why can't they do the transponders as well?
SPEAKER_07
01:00:58
Well, we certainly are working with them in partnership to do that.
01:01:02
Whether that means the VDOT personnel is there to offer the E-Z Path, whether it means we have them in a package, you know, we're working through that now and want to make it as convenient as possible.
01:01:11
But again, we're the retailer, you know, Macy's to Visa, so we've partnered with VDOT and reassured that they are working with us to try to make it convenient.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:22
If I may, let me ask the Commissioner.
01:01:27
So the contractual relationship is actually with VDOT for the transponder?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:36
With the customer.
01:01:37
Is that what you're talking about?
01:01:39
Yes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:39
Okay.
01:01:40
It's not with the individual toll facilities.
01:01:42
That's correct.
01:01:42
So you have individual agreements with the toll facilities that are part of the existing E-ZPass program already.
01:01:49
Yes.
01:01:49
With the facilities, yes.
01:01:51
Because there's only one, right?
01:01:53
So we are the representative, VDOT is the representative for E-ZPass.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:58
For the whole state.
01:01:59
For the whole state, which is
01:02:02
Somewhat unique, many other states, it's the actual total facility operator.
01:02:07
Each facility represents themselves at the E-ZPass meetings.
01:02:14
But when Virginia did it right, when they first started E-ZPass, it was supposed to be the state belonging to E-ZPass, and you pay one fee.
01:02:24
Virginia's about the only state that does that.
01:02:27
and they wanted us to change and we refused to change because the founding principle of EZAPAS was to have one state, one voice and representing the Commonwealth of EZAPAS and we are doing that.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:43
Could you, maybe the Commissioner, just review again the time sequence here in terms of when do these
01:02:54
Transponders get into the public's hands.
01:02:58
When do they have to be on the market to where somebody can buy them?
01:03:02
Are you telling, or is it September?
01:03:04
Because we've got, these are opening at the end of the year, right?
SPEAKER_07
01:03:09
That's correct.
01:03:09
And our actual E-ZPass incentive promotion program will begin in mid-May.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:14
Mid-May.
SPEAKER_07
01:03:15
Mid-May, correct.
01:03:16
And right now, the early focus of that program...
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:18
Put the transponder in somebody's car, to put it in my car.
01:03:22
When is that going to happen?
SPEAKER_07
01:03:25
Customers need to have that E-ZPass in their vehicle by December.
01:03:28
By December.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:29
But you already, if you have your existing one, you can use it.
01:03:33
That's right.
01:03:34
But a new customer.
01:03:35
Right.
01:03:35
A new customer and or if you are going to use them for the HOV-3, then you'll have to have the new switchable.
SPEAKER_07
01:03:46
That's right.
01:03:46
We have a little different dynamic in that we have everyone is required to have an E-ZPass,
01:03:51
You either have a standard easy pass, if you have one today you can use it, or if you're a car puller you need an easy pass flex that will be available this summer.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:59
That's one of the questions, Mr. Secretary.
01:04:01
During your outreach, have you been queried about the hot lanes extending from the Woodrow Wilson Bridge?
01:04:12
Because I get people asking me from time to time, because of all the work being done everywhere in the Beltway,
01:04:20
There's a thought group out there that thinks it's starting at the Wilson Bridge.
01:04:26
Does that happen?
SPEAKER_07
01:04:27
Yeah, we get that a lot actually with the Telegraph Road project.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:34
I just asked that question because people are asking it.
01:04:39
I think you have to make that clear, which it looks like you're doing in your print and your website.
SPEAKER_07
01:04:46
You're right, we're reminded every day, we talked to a gentleman yesterday who travels from Great Falls to over the Woodrow Wilson Bridge every day and he wasn't aware of what was going on with the construction and so we are reminded that we have a big education effort ahead of us and that's why we're making it quite a substantial investment to get out there without information.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:06
Because they think they're seamless, you know, they see all the construction gone.
01:05:11
completing from the Wilson Bridge project and what you're doing, and they don't see the difference.
01:05:17
They think that's all one big project.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:20
Well, then also add to it, I mean, the Wilson Bridge, in fact, there's another lawsuit involving a project on the Wilson Bridge, and one of the issues on that one was the fact that, you know, the Wilson Bridge is, quote unquote, overbuilt.
01:05:38
It has the quote unquote express lanes built into it with the anticipation at some point it was going to be HOB or HOT and or transit was going to run across it.
01:05:51
So we got sued there because I was on the TPB then to because it was saying it was too high of a price.
01:06:00
Although cheaper to build those lanes now than it was to then try to retrofit it as a future day.
01:06:09
Got it, yes?
SPEAKER_15
01:06:10
While we're talking about timing and I know we're concerned about execution, do we have any contractual timelines we have to make to the facilities?
01:06:20
Or is this just, I mean we're concerned, we want to execute because I think Mr. Moore is exactly right, but I want to make sure we don't have any
01:06:28
Is it more than, I mean, do we have contractual obligations?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:32
John, did you know there's a line in there on that?
SPEAKER_15
01:06:38
So, it doesn't seem that we have a contractual... What I've read, I haven't seen it, but I just, I mean, it looks like if they're going to collect money, they've got to have it going.
01:06:47
And so, it seemed like a reasonable...
01:06:50
If you could just verify that, you know, I think that would be good to have.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:57
Thank you.
01:06:58
The new switchable tag is currently being
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:07:25
Produced, and will be available beginning of July for distribution.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:32
What was that?
01:07:34
Was that another June?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:07:35
No, I said July, sir.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:36
All right, do we need an update on that?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:07:41
Certainly.
SPEAKER_09
01:07:42
Make sure we're still on that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:51
I'm sorry, I just want to start with the helmet.
01:07:53
So I want to make sure we all understand.
01:07:56
So we have told our transponder folks to have the potential for 400,000 easy passes ready to go.
01:08:04
That's not a problem.
01:08:06
You sure?
01:08:07
You got that in writing?
01:08:08
Have you gone to the warehouses?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:10
Have you gone out there and touched them and looked at them?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:14
You don't have to touch and look at them unless you're like this.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:08:20
Sir, as I mentioned, we have just given CAPS, who is the manufacturer of the transponders, required order of supply over the next 12 months to cover the volumes that we've anticipated needing and they have committed to meeting those volumes.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:40
So, and the second, as Chairman, I just want you to know that VDOT was working very hard with the EASIPAS group to make these switchable transponders work.
01:08:52
In fact, it was through our contracts that we were able to even test
01:08:56
These types of transponders and we're getting these things done.
01:09:01
So we have been really aggressively pushing to get these new types of transponders done and tested through some of our contractors and VDOT to make this happen.
01:09:14
But we have not been sitting on the sideline.
01:09:16
We have been aggressively
01:09:18
Well, we've placed the order.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:09:31
They're finalizing the testing now.
01:09:33
And I'll have to say that Transurban has been very instrumental in working with us in designing and working through the testing process.
SPEAKER_07
01:09:45
I'll just add before I close that in the case of the express lanes, the E-ZPass transponder system is really requiring that mandatory E-ZPass is really critical to our enforcement regime, which is important on that facility because we do have HOV and transit customers who will rely on that facility.
01:10:03
So being able to keep those violators out and well below what we've seen on other HOV facilities is a key priority for us.
01:10:10
And customers may pay for the credit card on our system
01:10:13
If they've missed a toll, so because we are fully electronic tolling, open road tolling, people will be entering our facility at 55 miles an hour, so they won't be able to pay with a credit card on road, but if they've missed a toll and they want to pay that toll online, they can certainly do so with a credit card.
01:10:30
The bottom line is, you know, Transurban and VDOT have put a tremendous amount of work and funding in place to be able to make this project a reality.
01:10:41
But it won't be a success unless our customers are informed, they're equipped, and they're motivated to use the facilities.
01:10:47
So this is a part of the program in advance of the opening that
01:10:50
We, along with VDOT, are taking very seriously, and it's an important investment for us.
01:10:55
We think it's a robust program, a measurable program, and hopefully you'll see the fruits of that program throughout 2012 and into 2013.
01:11:03
We do have close coordination underway with DRPT, VDOT, our local partners, and actually now a dialogue as well with some of the other major projects in other parts of the state, so we can share information and lessons learned with those partners as well.
01:11:16
and of course convenient access to E-ZPass when that retail program is available.
01:11:20
We look forward to that.
01:11:22
Convenient access to E-ZPass online and in person we think is a critical part of this effort.
01:11:27
Thank you for your time and any questions.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:31
In your system, if the customer misses a toll and has to pay by credit card, is there a penalty attached to that payment?
SPEAKER_07
01:11:39
They'll have to pay a fee.
01:11:40
Again, we're a mandatory E-ZPass system, so you'll need to have an E-ZPass, but if you forgot your E-ZPass and you go online, you know, for a small admin fee, you can pay, conveniently pay your toll online.
01:11:50
With a small admin fee?
01:11:51
Yeah.
01:11:51
We just want your toll and the cost to collect that toll.
01:11:54
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:57
Do you know what the default rate is?
01:12:01
I won't say the default.
01:12:02
Let me use two different questions.
01:12:04
How many people, what's the percentage of people that drive through, whether it's the hot lanes or whatever tolling facility you're operating, that drive through and don't have a transponder and they get their picture taken, what's that percent?
01:12:19
Then what percent of that group do you never get the money from?
SPEAKER_07
01:12:26
Well, I defer to Mr. Lawson to talk about VDOT facilities statewide and what their leakage rates are.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:33
I'd like to hear what your, what Transurban's experience is.
01:12:36
I heard from Macquarie years ago what their experience was.
01:12:41
I'm interested in your experience.
SPEAKER_07
01:12:42
Yeah, this is a number one, a very important priority for us to limit that leakage.
01:12:47
And on Transurban's assets in other parts of the world, we maintain that leakage rate well below 5%.
01:12:53
We believe that the leakage rate on Beltway in the early days will be well below 5% of the customers.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:59
Does the 5% include your cost of collection?
SPEAKER_07
01:13:02
The 5% of the customers are used at the facility of that revenue.
01:13:06
5% of that revenue is leakage.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:08
I understand that, but there's a cost to collect the revenue that's leaking.
01:13:14
Yes, that is not included in that number.
01:13:16
It doesn't include that cost.
01:13:21
No.
01:13:22
That their leakage rate was 20-something.
01:13:26
For where?
01:13:27
I'm sorry.
01:13:27
That was their experience.
01:13:30
Was 20-something.
01:13:31
That was before, that wasn't the ultimate leakage rate.
01:13:34
That was the beginning leakage rate.
01:13:36
Right.
01:13:36
Meaning the amount of people that drove through that didn't pay the toll and now the picture's taken.
01:13:41
And they were actually trying to get some laws changed in Virginia that allowed them to collect easier because it's hard to collect.
01:13:49
So I was just interested in you.
SPEAKER_07
01:13:50
It's an ongoing struggle for any manager of a toll road.
01:13:53
And I think what you'll find is a long-term operator, as glamorous as that is, transit when we operate toll roads for a living, that's what we do.
01:13:59
And so, you know, enforcement is a big part of our internal expertise.
01:14:02
And I'll tell you, in even developing the strategy with VDOT,
01:14:05
on how people would pay the toll in the first place on the express lanes, enforcement was the foundation of all of that planning.
01:14:12
So requiring that mandatory easy pass, all of those have been designed to try to minimize the leakage on the facility.
01:14:18
And that's important for us from a revenue perspective, but it also has a very important public policy objective because unlike a traditional toll road, you know, we have an HOV in transit customer base that depend on that road as well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:30
Which is going to make the enforcement interesting because it's
01:14:35
Of course they're gonna have to enforce whether they got, if they have to flip on for HOV-3 for free.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:42
I would be interested, Mr. Chairman, in sort of knowing what our experience is and what we project going forward, whether it's Transurban that's operating it or whether it's the hot lanes or wherever it is on our toll facilities, what the ultimate, what I'll call the ultimate leakage rate is, which would include the cost of collection.
01:15:01
Because obviously the cost of collection is part of the whole issue.
01:15:04
You have higher costs.
01:15:07
If your cost is seven times your leakage rate, then your true leakage rate is different.
01:15:12
And so what, at the end of the day, do we get 80, do we get 85, do we get 90 after any ends of the conference?
01:15:19
That would be an interesting number.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:22
And they, we have those numbers because actually in developing some of the comprehensive agreements, you know, obviously that better the enforcement rate, the less you want to quote.
01:15:33
The risk.
01:15:34
So that's one of the issues is always to make sure that the enforcement.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:39
And of course that doesn't in any way take out the external costs or factor in the external costs like courts and bailiffs and people and violence and all that.
SPEAKER_07
01:15:49
You still find a good portion of our actual operations costs are aimed at enforcement and express lines of state troopers, their vehicles, the technology in their vehicles, all those things as well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:59
How many are you hiring?
01:16:00
How many will you be funding for state troopers?
SPEAKER_07
01:16:04
Well, it's an easy question that will vary on the 495 express lanes as needed.
01:16:09
So in terms of how many vehicles will be out there at any given day.
01:16:12
So we'll have some days we'll have more vehicles out there than others.
01:16:14
But the project is funding extensive state police troopers, their vehicles, their shields, everything associated with enforcement of the lane.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:22
I thought there was actually a number that you were providing funds for.
SPEAKER_07
01:16:28
I'll have to check on that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:32
I know that they put the slots up in Northern Virginia.
SPEAKER_07
01:16:36
We're operating a little bit differently than the Greenway in that we won't have the state troopers and advisors, that we won't have a dedicated staff of state troopers, so Mr. Smith won't be on our facility every day like they've done on other roads, so we'll swap people in and out, but there are new positions associated with express planes and certainly can get you that number.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:57
Any other questions?
01:17:02
Ms. Alma, thank you very much.
01:17:03
Thank you.
01:17:04
Very disappointing if you didn't bring any wind-up cars for CTB members.
01:17:11
The next presentation is on some project called Midtown Tunnel, downtown tunnel.
01:17:20
Here we got Mr. Woodshall.
SPEAKER_08
01:17:48
Thank you, John.
01:17:49
Thank you, Mr. Secretary, Commissioner, Board Members, for this opportunity to speak to you about the Elizabeth River Crossings and our partnership with VDOT for the downtown tunnel, midtown tunnel, and the MLK Extension Project.
01:18:05
As the Secretary mentioned, my name is Greg Woodsmall.
01:18:08
I am the interim CEO for Elizabeth River Crossings, and I have for the past 10 years
01:18:16
I have extensive experience here in Virginia with the operations and maintenance of roadways as well as the tolling of facilities.
01:18:25
And specifically for the last three years I've been part of the ERC development team for this specific project.
01:18:33
Now we're pleased to be here today and have the opportunity to speak about this project and the progress with our partner, VDOT, and how we are planning for and preparing for the future.
01:18:47
Okay.
01:18:48
First of all, I'd like to just recap a little bit about where we are today and what the project includes.
01:18:55
Now, the project includes the continued operations and maintenance for the downtown and the midtown tunnel.
01:19:02
It also includes the construction of the new midtown tunnel as well as the fire life and safety improvements to the existing tunnels.
01:19:11
Also included is the extension of the MLK from London Boulevard to I-264.
01:19:18
and the interchanges on the project in the Norfolk and Fort Smith area.
01:19:23
Now, also there is an annual subsidy to improve the bus service to the highest levels and this will increase the frequency and the connectivity and will give commuters an alternative to driving.
01:19:39
Benefits of the project are significant.
01:19:42
Safety will be improved with the elimination of the two-lane traffic in the Midtown Tunnel
01:19:48
Fire life and safety improvements will be made to the existing tunnels.
01:19:53
Emergency evacuation routes will be improved.
01:19:57
And the extension of the MLK will provide a regional connectivity and provide choices for users between an opportunity to select the use of either tunnel.
01:20:07
Now, to the points of the slide here, as you're probably aware of, that we entered into a comprehensive agreement with VDOT back in December for this project.
01:20:17
That agreement outlines the key business terms and the obligations we have as well as the oversight and the ownership that VDOT retains.
01:20:28
Keynote in the terms of this contract is that it is consistent with the recommendation of the public process involving the independent review panel as well as the recommendation from this board.
01:20:42
Now, ERC, we are currently headquartered in Norfolk
01:20:45
And we're looking forward to co-locating with VDOT when the renovation is completed at the Penners Point facility.
01:20:52
Currently, our work largely focuses on developing the deliverables that are required by the Comprehensive Agreement.
01:21:00
And this is necessary activity required to demonstrate thorough and responsible approach to the key activities that will enable us to begin tolling.
01:21:14
Now also, we've been working on a number of other things and that has to do with the tolling mobilization activities.
01:21:20
There was an early works agreement that was developed that allowed us to proceed on this part of the project.
01:21:26
To date, we've developed the design, the software, procured a number of the components of the system, have designed the actual civil works, and are preparing for the installation of the facility.
01:21:40
From an operational and maintenance standpoint,
01:21:42
We've been developing our operations and maintenance plans, our organizational policies, as well as our standard operating procedures.
01:21:51
We've also, as a requirement of the CA, developed a tolling strategy and marketing plan, as well as a public information and communications plan.
01:22:01
Those plans have been developed, submitted to VDOT for review, and we are currently revising those plans to reflect those comments.
01:22:10
Now, as we go forward, there's a couple of key dates we need to keep in mind.
01:22:14
And the first one of those dates is the financial close.
01:22:18
And as we move forward, as announced last summer, tolling will start on the downtown and midtown tunnels third quarter of this year.
01:22:30
In advance of the tolling, ERC will assume the responsibility for the operations and maintenance
01:22:38
as well as the continued 24-7 incident management response service for those facilities.
01:22:44
Now looking forward, in 2016, the MLK extension will be completed and that facility will be told at that time.
01:22:56
Now as I mentioned before, we've been working collaboratively with VDOT and its partners as well as our vendors and our providers for the last 18 months
01:23:06
I think you've heard in the last couple of presentations the need for this collaborative effort and we certainly have gone down that path.
01:23:12
As I mentioned earlier, there was an executed early works agreement that allowed us to progress with a number of the activities associated with the tolling system and that also includes the acquisition and fabrication of the actual roadside equipment.
01:23:28
We've also been able to accomplish the actual back office testing.
01:23:32
And we plan to proceed with that testing associated with the roadside facility next week.
01:23:40
Much of the hardware itself and the gantries have been ordered and again much of the offsite testing has been completed.
01:23:49
We are progressing with the necessary authorizations to enable the construction.
01:23:55
We are planning for signage.
01:23:57
I think we heard earlier the need for signage.
01:23:59
On this facility, there will be a need for many decision point tolling signs to keep the public advised.
01:24:06
And importantly for the public, we are planning for the proper customer service and resources for drivers.
01:24:13
We also have been working with the Department of Motor Vehicles and establishing the necessary interfaces associated with the tolling system.
01:24:24
And for this project, we've heard a little bit about payment of tolls for this project
01:24:29
There will be two options for payment.
01:24:31
One will be easy pass or one will be pay by plate.
01:24:36
Now, of course, the easy pass enables the lowest rate.
01:24:41
The base rate has been established at $1.59 and the off-peak rate of $1.84.
01:24:46
These rates reflect a 40% reduction since the conceptual proposal was submitted.
01:24:55
And this is through a lot of hard work with our partners
01:24:58
at the cities of Norfolk and Portsmouth, and with VDOT on issues related to the project scope, financial planning, and the addition of the public contribution from the Commonwealth.
01:25:12
Now, as John mentioned before, associated with E-ZPass,
01:25:16
It's a very reliable product.
01:25:18
It's been in service for many years.
01:25:20
In fact, back when John said it was implemented in 2003, I actually was an employee of VDOT and was on that implementation team at the time that VDOT actually implemented E-ZPass in Virginia.
01:25:32
It's widely accepted.
01:25:35
And again, to address the concern over here, one of the main things for us associated with all electronic tolling is that drivers need to maintain speed
01:25:48
And so there's no need for stopping because with this project, there will be no toll booths.
01:25:55
Okay, for those drivers that in this all electronic environment that have the E-ZPass, there'll be equipment on the gantries that will read that device.
01:26:04
And for those individuals that do not have the E-ZPass device, there'll be the associated equipment on those same gantries that will read their license plate and provide us the necessary information to invoice those customers.
01:26:20
Now, we talked a little bit about it here in the last couple of presentations, the need and the number and the quantities that need to be out there associated with the tolls.
01:26:31
For us, again, the downtown tunnel will start tolling somewhere in the third quarter of this year, and the main device that we hope to get into customer hands as the main method of payment will be the E-ZPass device.
01:26:47
It is our goal that the majority of the customers will be paying using the least expensive method, which is the easy pass.
01:27:00
And again, we've been working collaboratively with VDOT for some time now, identifying the quantities that we will need to have in place for the opening or the tolling commencement for this project.
01:27:13
Okay, so one of the things that we've done in analyzing this is that we've had a toll working group that was formed back during the development phase of the project.
01:27:26
That toll working group included members of VDOT's financial planning staff, their back office operator, their integrator, ourselves easy pass, our integrator, our proposed back office operator,
01:27:41
Their consultants, our consultants, so we've had a full team looking at this.
01:27:47
And what we've identified is with the estimated 120,000 transactions on day one for this project, our goal is a 50% penetration.
01:27:59
And with that, we believe that of these transactions, so if we view this as 60,000 trips, we believe that 40,000 users will develop those trips.
01:28:11
And such we believe if you use an industry standard we heard four to one.
01:28:16
We are a commuter road and we believe that to be less.
01:28:20
We're estimating two to one.
01:28:22
So our estimate is that on day one for 50% penetration we'll need somewhere in the order of 80,000 transponders in customers' hands.
01:28:31
Now we do know that there is a certain level of penetration in the area currently.
01:28:35
There was a study done back several years ago that indicated there was somewhere between a 10 and 15 percent easy pass penetration in the region.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:48
Could you go back for your numbers again in terms of since they're not on the slide?
01:28:53
Correct.
01:28:53
I haven't seen these before.
SPEAKER_08
01:28:55
Help me again with the numbers.
01:28:59
Okay.
01:29:00
What we believe is this is going to be largely a commuter road.
01:29:04
And so being a commuter road, if we look at the day one traffic of 120,000 transactions and each of those transactions, a good portion of those will be a trip, which would include two transactions.
01:29:17
So our target is 60,000 transactions of penetration.
01:29:21
60,000 trips.
01:29:23
Trips.
01:29:23
Well, transactions.
01:29:27
If you're a commuter, you pay going in the morning and you pay going in the evening.
01:29:31
So you're looking for 120.
01:29:33
Right.
01:29:33
Total transactions.
01:29:34
Total transactions.
01:29:35
And with a 50% penetration, the goal would be 60,000 transactions.
01:29:40
Okay.
01:29:40
And so what we believe is, is that because we know... That relates to the E-ZPass.
01:29:45
Correct.
01:29:45
60,000.
01:29:47
Right.
01:29:47
Then the other 60,000 would be the pay-by-play.
01:29:50
So what we believe is the fact that it's a commuter road, that 40,000 users will generate those 60,000 trips.
01:30:00
And as such,
01:30:01
To get the industry standard is whether it's two to one or three to one, there's a multiple that you need to get into the customer's hands and so we're using a two to one multiplier to come up with the need for 80,000 transponders.
01:30:20
Our understanding is that VDOT has allocated 100,000 transponders for this project.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:27
or just on order.
SPEAKER_08
01:30:29
On day one, I'll continue on it and try to address that.
01:30:37
Our goal, I think I mentioned earlier as our goal
01:30:41
Because this is the cheapest form of payment for a customer, we want them to have an easy path.
01:30:49
Unfortunately, what we've seen in other projects in North America that our sponsors have participated with, it's unrealistic to get that level of penetration on day one.
01:31:02
And in fact, one of the things that we're looking at, though, as that being our day one goal, as we'll see on another, the next slide here, we talk about when that actually, that take-up occurs.
01:31:17
And so I'll address that when we get there.
01:31:20
So...
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:20
But customers do like choices.
01:31:22
Obviously, you know that.
01:31:24
If you're trying to be responsive to customers, they like choices as a method of change.
SPEAKER_08
01:31:28
Absolutely, absolutely.
01:31:30
But we want them to also be able to take advantage of the lowest price to use the facility.
01:31:35
And the easy pass is the lowest price.
01:31:38
That's the published rate of $1.59, $1.89.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:42
We'll be in loco parentis, take care of it.
SPEAKER_08
01:31:53
Okay, again, based on what we know, we feel like the quantities are on order, if not delivered yet.
01:32:00
And so I've mentioned on a couple of times what we know about the user is that they're largely commuters.
01:32:07
And it's a regional movement.
01:32:12
And we also recognize that there's different audiences that we need to approach there.
01:32:19
That includes the military.
01:32:21
And we've already had several meetings with those folks and plan to participate in all of their annual events.
01:32:30
Tourism to the community is vital.
01:32:34
And what we've heard from the board before, and we agree, we must not tarnish the region's attractiveness to this.
01:32:41
And we will communicate with industry groups in advance, and we will give tourism customers the opportunities to pay the E-ZPass rate.
01:32:51
I'll share a little bit about our incentives, and that'll sort of talk about how we want to drive to the E-ZPass customers on the next slide.
01:32:58
We know that there's temporary residence.
01:33:00
as well as commercial fleet services having unique needs.
01:33:05
And we know the E-ZPass organization and the back office facilities are already geared up to handle these types of commercial account sign-ups.
01:33:15
And that will be an important part of our outreach.
01:33:19
And lastly, we're sensitive to the unbanked, underbanked and unbanked.
01:33:24
These individuals who do not have credit cards
01:33:28
We will make options available for them, and you'll see about that in the next slide.
01:33:37
We recognized and make it easy for the drivers to obtain this E-ZPass, and we are clear about why it's important and how we can save the drivers' money.
01:33:51
E-ZPass will enhance the ways in which drivers contain the E-ZPass.
01:33:55
I think John shared with you a little bit more about the earlier with the retail distribution program.
01:34:00
He also talked about the option of additional customer service centers.
01:34:06
We too will have customer service centers.
01:34:08
And one of the ideas that we've been exploring with VDOT is to co-locate in those customer service centers.
01:34:15
Because we will also have a back office facility
01:34:18
that will handle the account management of the pay-by-plate customers.
01:34:24
We will also have a staff of ERC customer service representative and these employees will be based at our back office in one of our storefront facilities that we're proposing in the Portsmouth area.
01:34:44
What we believe is that the greatest
01:34:48
take up or told folks to obtain a transponder.
01:34:53
While it's realistic to try to get those transponders out here well in advance, it's a tough sell to charge a deposit and a prepayment in advance of the use of that device.
01:35:06
So what we've experienced on other projects
01:35:11
as well as the marketing and public relations consultant that we brought on board on another project out in Washington is the heaviest month for transponder distribution is the month before and a couple of months afterwards of the tolling commencement.
01:35:27
So that's what we're targeting is that timeframe to allow us to achieve that 50% penetration is that three-month window around the tolling commencement.
01:35:39
So for us, with the tolling commencement plans in the third quarter, we see our heaviest demand from the June to the September timeframe.
01:35:51
Now we talked about the alternative.
01:35:54
That's the pay-by-plate.
01:35:56
This is a standard technology in other locations around North America.
01:36:02
With this, pay-by-plate customers,
01:36:06
We'll have the option to pay on their account at our storefronts in the region, as well as we would encourage them to also, at that time, to convert to E-ZPass, because again, that's the cheapest form of payment.
01:36:21
But for whatever reason, some folks may not want the E-ZPass, so we're providing a level of option for those individuals, and that's the pay-by-plate mode.
01:36:31
Under the pay-by-plate scenario, we have a registered user
01:36:35
and a non-registered user.
01:36:38
And so one of the things that we are considering is having a different fee associated with those two different types of accounts.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:54
I don't understand what that really means, the processing fee not to exceed 318.
SPEAKER_08
01:37:02
It happens to be double the... What does that mean?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:11
Does that mean I was going there one time to do that?
SPEAKER_08
01:37:14
Is that every time?
01:37:17
Every transaction could be subject to a $3.18.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:20
Let me ask you a question first.
01:37:23
Every transaction, if I'm an EZPass user, if I'm a Paybot Play user... No, that's the difference there.
SPEAKER_08
01:37:30
And that's why we're going to push folks to EZPass.
01:37:33
Go ahead, sir.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:35
I'm trying to understand if I'm a non-EZPass user.
01:37:38
Right.
01:37:38
I'm a Paybot Play user.
01:37:40
I'm a Paybot Play user.
01:37:42
And I go in and I pre-fund an account.
01:37:46
I'm a registered user.
01:37:47
I pre-fund an account and I give you $25 or whatever it is.
01:37:50
And you charge me $318 in order to do that.
01:37:54
So every time I come back in as a $318, it's unclear here how the processing fee works.
01:38:01
Unclear to me anymore.
01:38:02
Okay.
01:38:03
So I'm just looking for you to walk me through.
01:38:04
Yes, certainly will.
SPEAKER_08
01:38:06
And that's part of where I will get to just in a bit on incentives, but I'll go ahead and address that right now.
01:38:11
But no, it's good that we address that and draw some clarity to that.
01:38:15
So again, there's two types of customers.
01:38:17
There's the E-ZPass customer that will pay the $1.59 and $1.84 rate depending on peak and non-peak, okay?
01:38:24
There is the video pay-by-plate customer.
01:38:27
And on the video pay-by-plate customer, our back office system has the capability of establishing a registered account or a non-registered account.
01:38:37
And one of the things that we're entertaining is if somebody wants to be a registered account, that it be less than the 318.
01:38:45
But that is per transaction for a pay-by-plate transaction.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:49
So if I came in weekly, I'd be paying that weekly?
01:38:51
If I came in daily?
SPEAKER_08
01:38:52
You would be paying that every transaction.
01:38:55
And that's why individual... Every time I went to the tunnel or every time I made a deposit?
01:38:59
Every time you went to the tunnel.
01:39:01
It's a transaction fee.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:02
So I'd pay the toll plus 318?
SPEAKER_08
01:39:05
Correct.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:06
So if I was a pay-by-plate user, instead of paying $1.59, I'd pay three times that?
SPEAKER_08
01:39:10
You absolutely would.
01:39:12
Potentially.
01:39:13
Potentially.
01:39:15
Again, some of the incentives that we're looking at is if you want to be a registered account, you're an infrequent user.
01:39:21
You don't want to give your information.
01:39:23
You don't want to have this unit in your car.
01:39:24
For whatever reason, you don't want to be an E-ZPass customer.
01:39:29
You can be a registered account with us.
01:39:31
And you'll pay the toll, the $1.59, and we're looking at some range of a processing fee, but the maximum could be $3.18, you're correct.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:41
So if I was a commuter, and you say this is a commuter road, it's a commuter system, if I'm a commuter, I've got to be an idiot to pay three times what I can pay one time.
01:39:58
I would probably agree with you.
SPEAKER_08
01:40:06
Well, we haven't calculated that.
01:40:08
I mean...
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:09
I'll tell you what the number is.
01:40:10
It's about $3,000.
SPEAKER_08
01:40:11
Yes.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:12
I've heard folks say in the $1,000... Just take $1.59, multiply it by it twice, times five, times 52, and it gets your answer.
01:40:19
It's about 900 bucks.
01:40:21
Multiply that by three, it's $2,700.
SPEAKER_08
01:40:25
You're following the right track of what our goal is in incentivizing individuals to take advantage of the least
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:32
And so if you hope for 50% penetration in the beginning.
SPEAKER_08
01:40:41
Right.
01:40:41
We'll certainly take more.
01:40:43
The more the better.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:45
What do you hope for at the end?
01:40:48
I mean 60 years from now.
SPEAKER_08
01:40:51
Our goal at the end of five years is 90%.
01:40:53
So somewhere between tolling commencement in the five year when the new tunnel is complete
01:40:59
We're hoping for a 90% penetration.
01:41:03
What we've seen on some other roads, one of our sponsors just opened up a road in Montreal and their goal was 50% and within a year it was 85%.
01:41:11
Mr. Chairman?
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:41:15
Yes, just call.
01:41:17
Mr. Whitswall, do you have an idea of what your cost to administer the unregistered pay-by-plate
SPEAKER_08
01:41:24
Well, we haven't established that.
01:41:28
Well, I mean, we have an idea that we've put into our model, okay?
01:41:31
First of all, there's a DMV lookup, okay?
01:41:34
There's additional systems that you have to take the picture.
01:41:38
There has to be some human intervention for some quality assurance associated with that.
01:41:43
So there's an administrative factor associated with that.
01:41:46
And depending on how the account is set up, whether it's a prepay or postpay, that makes a difference.
01:41:53
Those transaction fees that we heard about earlier, if you're not a prepaid and we have to do a postpaid environment, there's additional transaction fees for every time we have to bill you for that.
01:42:05
For the customers who want invoices, there's a mailing associated with that.
01:42:10
And so there is a lot more administrative cost associated with that.
01:42:14
And again, per the terms of the comprehensive agreement and what's provided by code,
01:42:19
Is that the maximum it can be is that fee can be two times the base total.
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:26
So how much of that cost in your mind percentage-wise would be fixed, asset cost, cameras, things of that nature, versus ongoing costs?
SPEAKER_08
01:42:35
I don't have those figures, but we certainly could...
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:38
The only reason I ask is, you know, at some point, if you get out the 90% E-ZPass, 10% pay-by-plate, and 2% of the 10% is unregistered, does it even make sense to go after it?
SPEAKER_08
01:42:52
Well, one of the things that we've done in our preparation for opening our back office, we've outsourced that responsibility because of the
01:43:02
Staffing ramp-up associated with the changes in customer patterns here, and so we don't have that responsibility.
01:43:08
We've put that on a contractual arrangement with our contractor, okay?
01:43:12
But what you, when we were, some discussion here earlier about violation rates, actually in the toll facilities in Virginia, up to 50% of the actual violators are E-ZPass customers because there's something associated with
01:43:30
What we have is tag waivers, those folks that don't like to mount them.
01:43:34
And so we're able to capture some of those things and not have to actually treat them as a pay-by-plate.
01:43:42
What we have is what we call video tolls.
01:43:45
And so if we know who the account number is and we can match up the license plate with that, we can actually charge them through this VTOL process.
01:43:53
And that's an arrangement that we'll be entering into with VDOT.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:43:57
I admire Madison Avenue as much as the next guy.
01:44:05
Pay by plate is clearly a euphemism for photo enforcement.
01:44:10
And my point remains that Joe Frank, simply because he lives west and south of Charlottesville, should not be subject to paying $5 or $2 toll when he had no option
01:44:26
But to use the toll and show us not to create an accident or a death and go ahead and do that, obviously the back office has the ability.
01:44:39
Somewhere there needs to be some motivation that our citizens, west and south of Charlottesville, who maybe left the transponder that they bought for vacation at home, otherwise have no need for transponder, do not pay excessive, onerous penalties.
01:44:55
When they get stuck down there.
01:44:56
And it's such a small percentage of those who are going through that it's well worth the effort to make sure that happens.
SPEAKER_08
01:45:04
Right.
01:45:04
And that's a good point.
01:45:05
And one of the incentives that we're considering is that if you happen to use this whole facility, you recognize that as you point, you're not from the region.
01:45:15
You just went through.
01:45:16
So within some time frame, we have showed 72 hours here, whether it's 96 hours or within a week's time frame, if you call us,
01:45:25
We want to provide you with that E-ZPass rate.
01:45:28
That's one of the things that we're considering right now as part of our operating business rules.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:45:34
You said provide with an E-ZPass what?
01:45:36
You said you'd provide with an E-ZPass?
SPEAKER_08
01:45:38
You would be able to take advantage of the low rate, the E-ZPass rate.
01:45:42
Okay.
01:45:43
Yeah.
01:45:43
So for those types of customers, we are considering those types of options.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:45:48
That is an option well worth not just consideration but implementation.
01:45:52
Right.
01:45:53
Mr. Chairman.
01:45:54
Can I just ask you something?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:45:55
Now, Maryland.
01:45:58
Does Maryland, I have the impression for the ICC that Maryland is actually allowing you to buy a prepackaged E-ZPass that didn't have the loading, the $20 or whatever.
01:46:13
Do you know, I mean, couldn't, why can't we just simply do
01:46:17
Somebody comes in and buys a prepackage.
01:46:20
I know I'm going to be down there for a week.
SPEAKER_08
01:46:23
So a prepackage on the EZPass account or our video account?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:27
EZPass.
SPEAKER_08
01:46:28
Okay, I would have to ask Mr. Lawson.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:30
I'm just sort of, I'm just wondering, I'll just ask Mr. Lawson, understand what is Maryland doing?
01:46:39
I thought that they, I saw some advertisements that they were doing something
01:46:44
You can go into a 7-Eleven by a prepackaged $10, $20.
01:46:47
That's all I'm saying is somebody else coming into the area.
01:46:55
Is that true?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:46:56
Maryland is doing the E-Z Path on the Go program like we are trying to implement now, where they are selling the transponder from retail establishment that's ready to be used upon when you walk out the store and you still would have the value on it
01:47:12
The thing to remember is the transponder has an eight-year life.
01:47:15
It's not a disposable product.
01:47:17
You don't want people just to buy it and throw it away.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:20
I'm not sure if I'm getting ahead of you or not, but let me ask you a couple of questions.
01:47:37
How many outlets do you think you need to have
01:47:41
Okay, good question, and I'll have to call upon some of the statistics that John had presented to us earlier.
SPEAKER_08
01:48:06
That we're hoping that we do achieve that 68% or higher with the website.
SPEAKER_15
01:48:13
And so we... July 1?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:18
The total comes on October 1.
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:22
Third quarter.
01:48:23
It says July 1?
SPEAKER_08
01:48:30
Within the third quarter.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:32
We just went from beginning to within.
01:48:35
Somewhere between July and September?
01:48:38
Correct.
01:48:38
Okay, I used September 1.
01:48:40
Maybe I was taking my birthday.
SPEAKER_08
01:48:42
So, as I mentioned earlier, our experience is
01:48:46
That the majority of the folks, it's just their nature, they're going to procrastinate, and they're going to wait until the last minute.
01:48:52
And again, for the other reasons I said, with the current mechanism for obtaining an E-ZPath, it costs you $60 on day one, unless you have the ACH and a credit card backing, where it is just the $35 prepaid amount.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:06
I'm trying to find out how many outlets you have, or they'll come online.
SPEAKER_08
01:49:11
We're going to have two storefronts of our own.
01:49:17
And what we've heard from John is they're also exploring potential opportunities for storefronts.
01:49:22
And as I said earlier, we would hope to co-locate in those locations.
01:49:26
Because after commencement, I also shared with you, we see a window that is two weeks after tolling commencement, there's going to be much activity
01:49:36
And we believe with that colocation, both at storefronts and back office operators, it provides the best seamless environment for the customer.
01:49:45
So when they convert from our play-by-play customer to an EZPass customer, it's a seamless customer experience.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:52
Right now we have two.
01:49:53
Where are they going to be?
SPEAKER_08
01:49:54
We're looking at one in Portsmouth and one in Norfolk.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:57
Somewhere?
01:49:59
Yes.
01:50:00
You're not sure yet?
SPEAKER_08
01:50:01
Well, we're pretty specific on the one in Portsmouth.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:04
And however many John's going to get to tell us each month about from now until whenever that date is, he'll be letting us tell where there's other locations.
SPEAKER_08
01:50:13
Correct, correct, correct.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:15
Second question.
01:50:18
You're very familiar now with the sort of the terrain, the territory, and the roadway system.
SPEAKER_08
01:50:23
A bit.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:26
Let's pretend that I live in Port Norfolk, or I live in Old Town Portsmouth, or I live in Churchill.
01:50:33
And I'm going to one of the four biggest employment centers in the region, whether it's downtown, the Naval Base, EVMS slash Sentara Medical Complex, or ODU, or Norfolk State.
01:50:49
What other way do I have to get there if I don't come through the Martin Luther King to downtown, or the Midtown, or the Jordan Bridge?
SPEAKER_08
01:50:58
Well, I'll have to confess when I said I'm familiar with the area, I wasn't responsible of the team on the traffic and revenue study, but I would say certainly we could get that information for you that was addressed in the traffic and revenue study.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:15
Well, I'll answer it for you if somebody's lived there for 54 years.
01:51:18
Okay.
01:51:18
There is no reasonable alternative.
SPEAKER_08
01:51:22
My understanding is without additional time and expense.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:26
Substantially.
01:51:28
My next question is, when we did all this work, and obviously the companies like yours, or the Macquarie's and the Skanska's and so forth are sophisticated, smart entities,
01:51:42
Did we do any demographic analysis of the people that would be using the tunnels?
01:51:46
Demographic meaning financial analysis, economic analysis?
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:50
And what did that tell us?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:54
How would we sort of, what's our, the commuter system told us.
01:51:59
So what's the typical commuter that's using it now?
01:52:02
What is their economic or demographic profile?
SPEAKER_08
01:52:06
I don't have that information available.
01:52:08
We certainly can get that for you.
01:52:09
But that was determined.
01:52:11
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:13
So, I'm sorry, what is the point?
01:52:15
I'm trying to understand.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:18
I'm just trying to look at the impact.
01:52:20
So the impact, and back to Mr. Martin's comment, which I agree with, but I would say to Mr. Martin, the people in Portsmouth might ask you why they have to pay a toll to go to work every day, and they don't really care if you're coming from Charlottesville and you gotta pay a little extra, because you ain't paying it every day, they are.
01:52:37
That's what they would tell you, whether you agree with that or what you don't.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:40
But I mean, obviously, I mean, this issue, whatever.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:51
Okay.
SPEAKER_15
01:52:57
Mr. Chairman, I want to support Mr. Martin's comments and thoughts.
01:53:02
It's not that we don't want to pay that toll, and the toll should be the same.
01:53:06
We're trying to get out of the penalty.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:07
Well, and they would tell you, this is a philosophical debate, it's not really part of this presentation, but since we're into it, they would say, why do I have to pay a toll if I live there to get to work, and if I live in Charlottesville, I don't have to pay a toll to get to work?
01:53:23
Why is that?
01:53:25
That's the fundamental question that they're going to ask you.
01:53:29
I agree that it ought not to sort of discriminate, but the system discriminates by definition from the beginning.
01:53:37
Whether you agree it's fair and equitable or whatever, or whether it's the right thing or the wrong thing, I'm not opining on that.
01:53:45
I'm telling you what they would say there, what they are saying there.
01:53:49
Why do I have to bear that burden?
01:53:51
when most of the other people in the Commonwealth don't have to bear that burden.
01:53:56
And it's not a situation where I'm going sort of, you know, it's not a throughput situation, it's a commuter situation.
01:54:06
It's a fundamental commuter situation which is what we've heard this morning.
01:54:10
So that's what the complaint would be.
01:54:12
How you assess that and whether it's, you know, reasonable or not is a whole different issue.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:22
What's the situation you have today in that crossing?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:26
It's a mess.
01:54:28
You know the situation.
01:54:29
It's a mess.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:30
Okay, so the situation is right now it is in fact it takes on average three times longer for people to get through the downtown and midtown tunnel than it does the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
01:54:45
It's level F plus.
01:54:48
In fact, the average speed going through the downtown midtown tunnel is six to nine miles per hour.
01:54:58
No, no, no.
01:54:59
I understand that, but I live it every day.
01:55:02
I'm there every day.
01:55:04
Okay, so right now, conservatively,
01:55:09
If we build this tunnel and build the Martin Luther King extension and rehab, we're going to cut at least 30 minutes off commute.
01:55:21
So there's obviously time associated with that, as well as the fact that, I mean, right now- I'm not arguing against this.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:55:27
I'm just telling you what the folks are going to ask, the questions they're asking.
01:55:31
You're out in front of me.
01:55:34
I'm not saying it's not the right thing to do.
01:55:36
It's not a good thing to do.
01:55:37
It's not that it doesn't save time and commuting and all that.
01:55:40
I'm telling you, I've lived here for 54 years.
01:55:43
on both of those tunnels, so I really don't need anybody else to tell me what's happening there, because I live, I don't live the 495 every day, but I do live downtown, the midtown, and the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:55:56
I would tell you that if you're telling me that at peak time, it's three times longer to get through the Hampton Roads, I mean the downtown and midtown tunnels than it is the Hampton Roads tunnels, you need to get your analyst to go back and take another look.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:56:09
That actually comes from the TPL?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:56:11
I fundamentally disagree with you.
01:56:14
It backs up 7, 8, 10 miles every day at the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel, past Warts Corner, and now directly to Drake, who's lived there since then.
01:56:24
And it's a half an hour at least to get to this time.
01:56:28
It's not an hour and a half to get to the downtown to make $1,000.
01:56:31
It's a long time.
01:56:32
It's a half an hour.
01:56:33
Sometimes it's an hour.
01:56:34
It's a bad situation.
01:56:36
We need to fix it.
01:56:37
I thought that we're trying to fix it.
01:56:39
I'm just telling you what the people would say in response to Mr. Martin's performance.
01:56:44
is that that's fine, we need to fix our problem, but when we fix some other people's problems, we don't necessarily put tolls on them to do it.
01:56:54
And so why is it us, not them?
01:56:56
And that's not to say we don't have tolls in Richmond, we don't have tolls in Northern Virginia, because we do.
01:57:02
This is a unique situation in the sense that there is no alternative that's reasonable.
01:57:11
There are always alternatives, but there is no alternative that's reasonable, and it's commuters.
01:57:16
It's not people going to the Outer Banks, Don Chesapeake Expressway.
01:57:20
There's no other way to get there.
01:57:23
It's not I-95.
01:57:24
I applaud I-95.
01:57:26
We're going to capture a lot of people that blow through the Commonwealth and pay nothing to use the roads.
01:57:32
That's a great thing, but that's not a commuter road.
01:57:35
For some of it it is, for certainly people going from Fredericksburg, it's a commuter road.
01:57:40
But large sections of 95 have a lot of throughput traffic on them.
01:57:47
This is not.
01:57:48
And so those people, rightly or wrongly, that's their, that's their bitch, if you will.
01:57:54
That's their gripe.
01:57:55
That I have no alternative and to get to work.
01:57:59
I've got to spend $1,000 a year just to get to work and I'm making $15 an hour to do the math.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:08
So what's your alternative?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:10
I could give you lots of alternatives but they're not.
01:58:13
But what is the alternative?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:14
I'm just intrigued.
01:58:15
I'm intrigued.
01:58:15
What's the alternative?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:17
The alternative is for the Commonwealth to get in the game and raise the revenue in a centralized way and say we're going to fix our transportation problem.
01:58:25
That's the alternative.
01:58:26
But we all know that for decades they've refused to do that.
01:58:30
So as a practical matter, you're absolutely right.
01:58:33
As a practical matter, there is no other alternative.
01:58:37
And that's why those of us who support this
01:58:41
I support it because it practically speaking is the only alternative.
01:58:45
I applaud the administration, I applaud the secretary, I applaud VDOT.
01:58:53
They're not the ones that put themselves in this boat though.
01:58:56
That's the problem.
01:58:59
The problem is the government, the legislature, and previous administrations for years and decades have not done what they needed to do, and so now there is no alternative.
01:59:13
So we're forced to take the medicine, which sometimes can be worse than the cure, or worse than the disease.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:22
But I will point this out as well.
01:59:26
If you look at the history of just this project, this has been discussed for 20-something years and had several fits and starts.
01:59:35
And now if you look at the price of this because we sat around for 20 years and now...
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:41
I'm applauding.
01:59:43
I just think that we've been dealt a bad hand as an administration and as a citizenry.
01:59:52
And we've done it to ourselves in some respects.
01:59:55
But we dealt ourselves a bad hand.
01:59:59
Now we gotta take the medicine.
02:00:00
And the medicine isn't necessarily equitable, and it's not necessarily good, but it's all we got.
02:00:05
So yeah, I'm not against this.
02:00:09
I'm saying that we shouldn't be in this box we're in.
02:00:13
There were plenty of reasonable solutions.
02:00:16
We didn't do our job for decades.
02:00:19
And now we're having to take the only practical solution we have.
02:00:24
And it's all hindsight.
02:00:26
But a lot of people have been saying this for a long time.
02:00:29
And I don't see any movement going forward to change the problem.
02:00:34
And it's unfair to this administration, it's unfair to you, it's unfair to us, it's unfair to everybody.
02:00:39
Somebody needs to step up that's in a position to make the decision and there's 140 of them that can say, we're going to change it.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:00:47
And the thing is to keep in mind is delaying this project, the prices aren't going down on this project, they're going up.
02:00:56
And so the issue is that any delay on this project makes the situation even worse.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:03
I'm all on board.
Roger Cole
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:04
Mr. Colton.
02:01:05
Mr. Chairman, does this discussion suggest that we may want to turn up the marketing and communication of the benefits of this project?
02:01:15
Can I ramp up that initiative so that at least the user understands the benefits of the project?
02:01:23
Because it sounds as though the project to them means $1.59 to $1.84 more per truck cost.
SPEAKER_15
02:01:33
Mr. Miller's comments are what a lot is being said.
02:01:51
This project is the top-ranked project in Hampton Roads, needed by not only our citizenry, but our military, our courts, for its dominance.
02:02:01
It's got to be done.
02:02:02
And I believe that inaction is a lot more costly than the action we're taking.
02:02:08
But it is, as Mr. Miller states, this is what we are confronted with.
02:02:14
And from a publicizing standpoint, I think we have a lot of the press here.
02:02:19
I think it's all gotten out there.
02:02:21
We've had informational meetings.
02:02:24
It has now gotten to the point where you simply have people who don't want to pay any calls.
02:02:28
I'm not suggesting we don't continue to do that.
02:02:33
That's not answered, Roger.
02:02:35
I agree with you.
02:02:37
But it really is.
02:02:40
We're forced with the decision as to whether this is better to move forward or not.
02:02:45
I firmly believe it is better to move forward.
02:02:47
with where we are, and that I do not believe citizens ought to be treated differently, and the rest of the state, across the facility, they should be treated just like everybody else.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:00
I'm sorry, listen, and I appreciate, we'll have some more opportunity later on to chat about this.
02:03:06
We're only on the presentation, we're two hours in.
02:03:10
Any other questions regarding DRC, specifically about them?
02:03:16
Can I just add?
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:17
Yes.
02:03:17
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
02:03:18
I think the thing we have not done well, you know, DRPT is involved with the Elizabeth River Project is to talk about carpool and fanpool, the transit subsidy that's in place, so that people right now don't think there are any options.
02:03:34
And there are options.
02:03:35
Hampton Roads has been very successful working through traffic on carpools and pools and I think if we can start talking more about that and us being more aggressive, it may help because everyone agrees doing nothing has certainly got a tremendous cost.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:50
Chairman?
02:03:51
Yes, I agree that this project is extremely important and we need to go forward with it and I certainly support it.
02:03:59
I think it was great that we went, you brought the whole board down into Tidewater so we could see what a mess it is.
02:04:08
But I do think we need to spend the revenues that we have very wisely.
02:04:12
We moved $240 million out of the mega project fund into the Charlottesville thing that would operate at a level F. We maybe need to keep some of that money to draw down the toll rates for this project and some of the others.
02:04:25
Just bear that in mind.
02:04:27
that we shouldn't be moving money out of these mega project sources of funding.
02:04:33
Excellent point.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:04:34
Okay.
02:04:34
Any other questions?
02:04:35
Thank you very much.
02:04:36
We'll move on to...
SPEAKER_08
02:04:37
I really wasn't finished because I wanted to address a couple of the concerns of these last comments.
02:04:42
But if you want us to conclude here, we really haven't talked about our marketing efforts.
02:04:47
And I think that addresses some of these concerns right here.
02:04:50
For us, this takes place during the timeframe when we believe folks will be wanting to sign up for an account.
02:04:57
And so we have currently, as has been mentioned here, we're looking at new ways
02:05:03
That we can market the project so folks have a clear understanding the benefits of the project.
02:05:08
All about the tolling about the project, the potential jobs that will be created, the subcontractor opportunities, and again, so a cut to the chase about some of the incentives that we're looking at because we're going to embark upon a major advertising campaign in the spring for this project associated with the timeframe that we believe that folks will be looking for that easy pass.
02:05:30
A couple of the incentives that we're considering right now is free trips for if you sign up in advance of a certain target date.
02:05:38
And so we do that in advance of the tolling commencement, as well as we would utilize that strategy going forward once the facility opens up.
02:05:45
Also mentioned, the 72-hour rule, whether it's 72, 96, we would afford the opportunity for infrequent users the opportunity, if they went through the facility, pick up the phone, give us a call, and we can have that straightened out and get you to the E-ZPass toll.
02:06:00
As I also mentioned that we believe the two months following tolling commencement are going to be very important for us to market the easy pass product.
02:06:09
And so what we're considering right now is significant waiving of these pay-by-plate fees during that period of time if you will sign up for an easy pass.
02:06:20
So we think with the first
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:23
I was going to start out with good morning, but good afternoon.
02:06:51
Q.
02:07:10
Thank you, sir.
SPEAKER_05
02:07:11
Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary, board members.
02:07:14
Today I want to try to talk to you, give you a little bit of an update on what's going on on the I-95, HOV, HOT lanes projects and project activities that are going on since the discussion and presentation that Deputy Commissioner Kilpatrick gave in December.
02:07:28
And I also want to make a request that John Lawson will give to you a little bit later, but a request for funding from the toll facilities revolving account to do the early works.
02:07:37
You heard from the ARC presentation that
02:07:40
Early works was done there.
02:07:41
We're still focusing on 995 HOV project for some early works, too.
02:07:48
You've seen this slide before.
02:07:50
This is the project.
02:07:51
Obviously, it's the nine-mile extension from Dumfries down to Garrisonville, two- to three-lane expansion for 14 miles from Prince William Parkway to Edsel Road on I-395, some operational improvements for a six-mile section, and added new improvements to access points.
02:08:10
Some of the project activities that have been going on over the last three months, Commissioner Whirley signed a toll agreement with FHWA.
02:08:18
It is currently up at FHWA headquarters.
02:08:20
It's given its final review and signature.
02:08:22
We're hoping this week or the beginning of next week that'll be finalized.
02:08:26
We have been working closely with our private sector partners to finish compiling the comprehensive agreement.
02:08:33
The presentation in December was focused on the major business points, using that as the basis for now we're putting the comprehensive agreement together and all the exhibits associated with that.
02:08:43
We've also submitted a letter of interest for TIFIA and a
02:08:48
Pre-application for a TIGER grant.
02:08:50
We received a $20 million TIGER grant from FHWA.
02:08:54
We're looking to supplement that $20 million with some additional funds either through TIFIA or through the TIGER program.
02:09:01
The focus of the presentation and the remaining slides will be focused on the early works.
02:09:06
And really what the early works are
02:09:08
There's a time period between now and financial close that we want to try to capture some activities with the private sector and most of those activities are focused on preliminary engineering to prepare ourselves for and to get right into construction when we go to financial close.
02:09:25
Some of those early works include the initiation of some designs and long lead item designs such as bridge design, geotechnical analysis and survey.
02:09:34
Other things that will allow us to go immediately to construction is making sure that we have our maintenance of traffic planned together, making sure we've got erosion sediment control, some of our development plans together, and those would be part of these early works that we're working with the private sector with.
02:09:48
Some technical activities, data collection, traffic collection, geotechnical analysis along the corridor, looking at the risk of some of the soils down, especially through the southern section, utility coordination,
02:10:01
Traffic and Toll Management Systems, working with ERC to make sure that we've got the tolling systems in place when the project is implemented.
02:10:11
Some of the benefits of this, obviously, we want to be able to start construction, and if we can start construction right when we get to financial close, then we're able to keep the design-build price that we negotiated with FTU and also get the construction season for 2012.
02:10:28
These activities will allow FTU to hit the ground running when we do get to financial close, and financial close, as you'll see on the next slide, is estimated to be this summer.
02:10:40
And obviously the funds that we're requesting through the toll facilities revolving count will reduce the Commonwealth's contribution.
02:10:46
Originally in December it was shown as 97 million.
02:10:50
It's a little bit lower now.
02:10:51
Some of the interest rates have gone down.
02:10:52
But the funding that we use here will reduce that 97 million.
02:10:58
Schedule, obviously, we want to get the early works.
02:11:00
There's an amendment that we've created to the interim agreement.
02:11:04
We'll have that signed as soon as possible, get the early works initiated here in March.
02:11:10
Our targeted commercial close is the April-May, focusing really on April of 2012.
02:11:16
Our targeted financial close is July-August, focusing again on July 2012.
02:11:21
And then construction can begin right away.
02:11:23
Because of these early works, because of the funding that's put in place now, we can get construction going right away.
02:11:30
Now, the action that we're requesting of you obviously is requesting a maximum of $45 million out of the toll facilities revolving accounts.
02:11:38
The CFO, John Lawson, will provide a resolution and a meeting that you're going to have after the workshop.
02:11:46
And the reimbursement is anticipated to come through proceeds from the Garvey bonds and other such funds as may be available to CTB.
02:11:53
We anticipate at financial close it will be a repayment element within the financial close structure that will replay the total facility employment account.
02:12:02
And with that, I'll take any questions of the board or Mr. Secretary.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:08
Dusty, how traffic mitigation, and that's going to be the biggest concern, you know, what 95 is like when Fredericksburg going up.
02:12:17
What are your plans?
02:12:18
How bad is it going to get before it gets better?
SPEAKER_05
02:12:20
Well, you know the construction that's going on on the Capitol Bell River right now.
02:12:24
A lot of that construction is because there's a lot of changes in the general purpose lanes.
02:12:28
There's not as many changes in the general purpose lane.
02:12:30
A lot of this will go in the HOV lanes, and the southern section will be in the median itself.
02:12:35
So our hope is that there will be limited lane closures on the general purpose lanes focusing in on it.
02:12:40
But we do have some studies that we're putting together.
02:12:44
We're going to be doing some mitigation.
02:12:46
We're working on some parking rides as part of it to try to enhance the HOV usage along the corridor itself.
02:12:51
So there are some different things.
02:12:53
We've put some money in the budget to focus in on creating some opportunities for transit and for other uses along the corridor.
02:13:02
So our hope is that, at least in the general purpose lanes, the effect won't be as much.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:07
At the bottom of the page there, we're talking about reimbursement, and that last item kind of gets into this board's statutory authority.
02:13:21
Where are you expecting these funds to come from?
02:13:24
Do you have them identified?
02:13:27
And how much are we talking about?
SPEAKER_05
02:13:28
Well, we're estimating the early works to be about $43 million.
02:13:32
We believe that working with FHWA that about 25 to 26 million of those dollars are federally eligible so we can get reimbursement through the Garvey Program and the rest of the dollars will first come from the toll facilities revolving account and then be reimbursed by the private sector when we go to financial close.
02:13:50
So the toll facilities revolving account will be reimbursed for the full amount that we utilize to a maximum of $45 million.
02:13:57
John, you're certainly here to talk about the funding part of it, but again, the funds are at risk.
02:14:14
With the total facilities revolving account, the funds that we put out that aren't federally eligible will be at risk to the Virginia Department of Transportation.
02:14:23
So we would, if we didn't go to financial close, we would have to identify through the program the repayment of those funds through identifying which projects could move forward.
02:14:35
To reimburse those funds.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:36
So you're saying that obviously this would affect the six-year plan and possibly as the other projects funds might be diverted to pay for this.
SPEAKER_05
02:14:46
Our focus is to get to financial close and have the private sector reimbursement, but if we do not get to financial close, yes sir, that is correct.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:53
I would like to know maybe later where you think these funds might come from and what other projects in the complex may be affected.
02:15:01
I don't think we can give blank approval just to defend those funds without this board knowing those questions and voting on them, frankly.
SPEAKER_05
02:15:13
I can certainly work with Commissioner and Mr. Lawson to try to address that question if we need to, Mr. Secretary.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:15:22
Just to address that, I just want to reiterate what Dusty was saying.
02:15:27
There's no risk or no need for additional CTB funds unless the project fails to go to close.
02:15:35
So right now we've got the $97 million that is already air contribution planned for the project.
02:15:42
which will be provided for at a Garvey's.
02:15:44
We haven't sold the Garvey's yet.
02:15:46
That's the reason we need to seek and to use these total sort of revolving funds in advance.
02:15:52
As soon as the Garvey's are sold and we go to close, then the Garvey's will repay the federally eligible components.
02:15:58
The components that are not federally eligible will
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:14
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
02:16:32
Yes, absolutely.
02:16:37
I mean, the only way funds can be provided to projects are by way of the program, which you approve.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:17:01
The request is actually on the toll road revolving account and that is to advance the project and then it will be repaid once we sell the Garvey's for this project.
02:17:18
In the possibility that there isn't a
02:17:22
Project, we don't go to closed and somehow we have to reimburse the toll road revolving account.
02:17:31
Correct.
02:17:33
And we would have then probably plenty of opportunities to be amended because we really probably wouldn't amend a six-year plan per se because we still have the Garvey's and we would probably put on another project that we could then reimburse the toll road revolving account.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:17:52
Absolutely.
02:17:53
Because the galleries would then be made available to something else, as you said.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:17:56
Now, if the project were to tank, we would probably be one of the first people to know about it.
02:18:04
Would that be correct?
02:18:07
Yes, sir.
02:18:08
Yes, sir.
02:18:10
Okay.
02:18:10
So we have plenty of time then.
02:18:12
We would then have the opportunity then to have a discussion as to how we reimburse the toll road revolving accounts.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:18:21
Absolutely.
02:18:22
All right, Mr. Rich?
02:18:28
All I would do is at the end of this where it says, be it further resolved, at the last part of that sentence, were such other funds made available at the discretion of the Commonwealth Transportation Board?
02:18:42
Just make sure that we're involved.
02:18:44
Probably it's not going to happen.
02:18:47
Mr. Whirley.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:18:51
Mr. Chairman, I would be okay with that adjustment there.
02:19:07
But the bottom line is when we make any adjustments to the projects, they come back to the six-year, I mean to the CTB for approval, whether that's transfers, whether that's during the six-year development process.
02:19:21
So the control point has not changed.
02:19:24
The control point for you to approve any changes in our program or any changes in our project would come back to this project.
02:19:32
And that's policy.
02:19:33
And that's policy.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:35
I just want to make it clear, as a lawyer, you read this stuff, and one resolution can overrule another, and so no one has a concern about it, so that's what we have.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:45
It just reinforces the fact that it has to come back.
02:19:49
But it has to come back anyway?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:51
Yes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:54
Maybe, unless it's overruled, unless the policy is overruled by a subsequent resolution like this.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:20:00
So anyhow, it's no big deal.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:20:03
Okay, any other questions, Ms. Tull?
02:20:05
All right, good afternoon.
02:20:28
Y'all are getting tired of me today, aren't you?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:20:33
Okay, I'm going to give you a quick update on performance through February.
02:20:41
Be mindful of time here and we'll try to go through this pretty quickly.
02:20:44
In terms of revenue, our state revenue collections this year are carrying on about where they've been.
02:20:52
We are running about just shy of 3% ahead of where we were prior year.
02:20:57
and slightly ahead of the forecasted growth of 2.2%.
02:21:00
In terms of motor vehicle fuel sales, excuse me, motor vehicle sales and use tax collections, it still continues to be the strongest performer of the state revenues.
02:21:12
We're looking at growth rates still running above 9%.
02:21:16
In terms of motor fuels tax collections, we are running about one and a half percent behind where we were at this time last year.
02:21:26
which is slightly behind forecast.
02:21:29
The forecast is our decline of 1.4%.
02:21:34
In terms of where we go between here and the end of the year, there is hope and expectation that the spring will come additional driving, additional fuel consumption.
02:21:45
However, we are concerned with the rising fuel prices and whether that will have a chilling effect on additional consumption.
02:21:53
Sales tax collections are up just over 5% from last year, just very slightly behind forecast.
02:22:03
And you can see the detailed items illustrated on this chart, the top three being motor fuel tax, motor vehicle sales and use tax, and the state sales and use tax are all
02:22:18
Well, the top motor fuel tax is the only one of the three that is not performing.
02:22:27
Turning to federal revenues.
02:22:30
We are maintaining a constant flow there.
02:22:34
We are about $27 million ahead of where we were at this time last fiscal year.
02:22:41
That net increase is kind of offset by an increase of about $66 million related to maintenance spending as we have a much more robust maintenance program this year.
02:22:52
And we are down about $32 million in the construction program.
SPEAKER_15
02:22:58
The deficit in the construction site is primarily what, John?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:23:04
This is a comparison just of federal revenues associated with the federal program are less this year than they were a year ago.
02:23:11
It's not necessarily a deficit and it's just reflective of the projects that are underway at this point in time and how the federal revenues are associated with those projects.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:23:23
Both of these charts are in thousands,
02:23:28
In terms of spending,
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:23:49
We've expended about $2.6 billion through the end of February.
02:23:55
That's over $300 million ahead of where we were last fiscal year, and the majority of that spending is related to maintenance activities.
02:24:03
In terms of maintenance, 53 percent of the total spending is related to maintenance when you include payments to localities.
02:24:11
Forty-five percent is associated with just VDOT's maintenance program.
02:24:15
and the construction program represents about 34% of spending.
02:24:23
This graphic just shows you the year-over-year change between the major programs.
02:24:28
You'll notice that most programs are very much in line with where they were last year with the exception of the maintenance program which is significantly greater.
02:24:42
In fact, maintenance is about 34% ahead of where they were last fiscal year.
02:24:47
We've expended just shy of $1.2 billion through February, compared to about $860 million through February of 2011.
02:24:58
Looking forward, we are expecting to spend about $1.7 billion out of the $1.9 billion allocations
02:25:11
indicating that we would have an unspent allocation balance at year end of about $200 million.
02:25:17
You can see here on this chart, in looking at current spending to date, we had forecasted a spending of about 1.26 compared to the 1.16.
02:25:28
So we're about $100 million short of where we thought we would be as of this point in time.
02:25:37
Of that $100 million, a positive note to say is that we have spent about $60 million of $125 million that was budgeted for snow.
02:25:51
So that in and of itself represents a very large portion of that variance.
02:25:59
In terms of the construction program, we have spent about $870 million this year, of which that represents about $130 million of that is based on our program and our projects.
02:26:15
The actual expenditures are about $16 million ahead of air forecasted spending.
02:26:21
I think that's largely attributable to the warm winter months that we had and the lack of bad weather.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:26:29
This is the anticipated spending chart for all the major programs.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:26:54
I'm already going to hit the highlights related to the major programs.
02:26:59
All in all, we're about $95 million behind their forecasted spending.
02:27:09
Cash balance, you'll notice that we have a significant increase in cash balance reflected over the last month.
02:27:18
This reflects the very bottom line you see on the chart, the $350 million received in GARVEE proceeds.
02:27:24
Again, these proceeds
02:27:25
were sold in anticipation of the closing on the downtown midtown project.
02:27:37
And just to kind of wrap up, from a contract perspective, we do have about $2.5 billion outstanding, which is about $500 million more than we were last year with balances, unspent balances about 19% greater than last year.
02:27:52
As you saw from the previous slides, their spending for most programs are pretty well in line with forecasted spending.
02:28:01
We are watching maintenance.
02:28:04
Spending is lower than forecast, but as I mentioned, we think a lot of that is related to the lack of snow expenditures, and we talked before about some of the contract that didn't finish early and will be finished in the beginning of this season, and we are looking at
02:28:22
Unspent Allocation Balance in the Maintenance Program of just over $200 million at the end of the year.
02:28:31
Answer any questions?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:28:33
Yes, Mr. Richard.
02:28:34
Can you give us a little enlightenment on the state budget mess and how that may be affecting our funds and also do we have any clear picture of federal, the situation of the Federal Highway Bill?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:28:47
Well, in terms of Federal Highway, you know, they're still
02:28:50
You know, playing with bills and then trying to figure out how they can move that forward.
02:28:55
I think it's likely at this point that there will be another continuation with the current resolution expires into this month.
02:29:02
So I expect we'll see another continuation that will likely carry us into next year.
02:29:08
In terms of the state budget, that obviously is still up in the air to be revisited, I guess, on the 21st when they come back to town.
02:29:20
There's not a lot else to say related to that at this point.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:29
The real warning sign is this issue on the gas tax receipts.
02:29:34
As the prices go up, we'll continue to see the drop in our receipts, right?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:29:41
That is a very real possibility, yes sir.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:45
Mr. Lawson, did you see, by the way, they just put out that the states
02:29:50
Receipts were up almost 17, they just put out now, it's up almost 17% year over year.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:29:59
From the general fund perspective, yes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:01
So that impacts our sales tax?
02:30:04
So that continues to go up?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
02:30:07
Correct.
02:30:07
Our sales tax are tracking very close to the forecast, which is about a 5.5% growth over the last year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:19
All right, any other questions?
02:30:21
Great.
02:30:23
What's late of update?
02:30:24
Ms. Maxwell.
SPEAKER_06
02:30:31
Good afternoon, Mr.
02:30:32
Chair.
02:30:33
Carol, which one is this?
02:30:39
Just to start, you all have basically a document that consists of the various bills right now demonstrating or showing their various statuses.
02:30:49
On the document on the right-hand corner, if you see status, if you see a chapter number, that means the bill has been signed by the governor.
02:30:57
It is law or will be effective come July 1 unless it has emergency enactment.
02:31:02
Any other status?
02:31:04
If it's pending legislation, that means it's been passed by the House and the Senate.
02:31:08
It's been presented to the governor, but the governor has not yet taken action.
02:31:12
Just a point of clarification.
02:31:14
Just very briefly, we're going to do another presentation probably at the next meeting in April.
02:31:20
A reconvened session is April 18th, so we'll do our best to provide you with information as to what has the final outcome.
SPEAKER_07
02:31:29
First of all, just a quick update on the eminent domain bills.
SPEAKER_06
02:31:32
All of the pieces are in place for a constitutional amendment.
02:31:38
We have the referendum, the language for the questions that will be going to the public in November.
02:31:44
We have now the second enactment of, in essence, the bill containing the constitutional amendment language.
02:31:52
And finally, we have the bills that have defined lost profits and lost access.
02:31:58
I would note that
02:31:59
Since our last meeting, the bills defining lost profit and lost access have been significantly modified so that the language is certainly less broad than it was before.
02:32:10
So now we're estimating, and again these are very rough estimates, that the impacts would be, had the bills been in place
02:32:18
For the last three years, the impact would be approximately $12.4 million a year or basically $37.5 million for three years.
02:32:30
Again, just to give you a sense.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:32:33
Just one question on that.
02:32:35
Where did VML and VACO end up where they are now?
02:32:39
Are they supportive at this point?
02:32:42
Are we still getting feedback from local government that it's too open-ended and really
02:32:48
is a big concern for counties.
SPEAKER_06
02:32:50
Mr.
02:32:51
Chair, I don't know that I'm in a position to speak for VML or VACO.
02:32:54
I think there might be some representatives here, but I can certainly find out.
02:32:59
We can certainly find out for you.
02:33:02
Thank you.
02:33:03
So that's the status of the eminent domain bills.
02:33:05
Again, they've not yet been signed, but they have been passed by both houses.
02:33:11
HOV bills, use of hybrids, another interesting bill.
02:33:18
has taken, or a modification to the law has taken place this year.
02:33:22
Bottom line, it looks like they're going to be eliminating the sunset for use of hybrid vehicles on HOV lanes, but they have, it looks like the focus now is going to be on federal legislation, infinity at point in time,
02:33:37
HOV usage by hybrids is not permitted by federal law that will eliminate their usage in the Commonwealth.
02:33:47
The bills will also require VDOT to report to the House and the Senate transportation chairs just basically advising that whether there's degradation in any particular facility to again enable them to make decisions in the future.
02:34:07
Another bill of interest, and the bills that I thought you might find particularly interesting are highlighted.
02:34:13
The eminent domain bills are green, the others are yellow.
02:34:18
House Bill 466 was a VDOT bill that was passed by both the House and the Senate on its way to the governor.
02:34:25
House Bill 545, again, that was a VDOT bill that would authorize VDOT safety service patrols.
02:34:33
to drive off the roadway or on the shoulders without the direction of law enforcement, again a congestion mitigation effort.
02:34:47
This is a bill that you all might have some involvement in and I thought you might be interested in reading about.
02:34:53
Basically House Bill 599 is a bill that would require VDOT to look at
02:35:00
projects and evaluate projects in a slightly different manner than is done today.
02:35:04
Bottom line, the idea is VDOT is supposed to look at bills in the Northern Virginia region or look at
02:35:13
projects slightly differently by focusing on the amount of congestion mitigation as well as enhanced mobility in the event of a Homeland Security event.
02:35:26
While the bill seemed to require significant change in how we look at things,
02:35:33
Bottom line, there's still a lot of flexibility in this bill.
02:35:37
VDOT is to do these evaluations only to the extent funding is available.
02:35:41
The CTB is to, the projects were to look at significant projects and only those projects that really have been identified by the CTB as significant, et cetera.
02:35:51
And the CTB has given quite a bit of discretion in how it identifies what are significant projects.
02:35:58
Again, there's a Senate version that's exactly the same as SB 531.
02:36:03
That was Senator Morrison's bill.
02:36:06
Again, those bills have been enacted by both houses on the way to the governor.
02:36:17
House Bill 646, VDOT bill.
02:36:19
It was a bill just basically designed to enhance and improve our outdoor advertising permitting process, particularly for billboards.
02:36:27
Bottom line, that's now been enacted.
02:36:29
It's going to help us streamline the program.
02:36:32
It's going to hopefully help us raise more revenues and bring the expenses or the revenues more in line with the cost of administering.
02:36:42
Overweight vehicle permits and fees bill.
02:36:45
That legislation, while it was a DMV bill, I just wanted to bring it to your attention because what it will do is probably bring about, we anticipate, maybe $4.5 million each year to the HMOF.
02:36:56
It increases the overweight fees for overweight vehicles.
02:37:00
Again, we'll give you a little more detail next month's meeting.
02:37:07
Performance and Payment Bond Bill, the HB 945, that was the VDOT bill.
02:37:11
Again, the idea was to increase the thresholds for transportation construction projects for bonds.
02:37:19
Originally the bill would have allowed us to waive bond requirements for construction projects that were valued at greater than $500,000.
02:37:29
The bill has undergone significant change so that now we can, the threshold for those projects or for bond requirements has been limited to, they've been increased for only performance and payment bonds from 250 to 350.
02:37:47
And then the contractor or the bidder has to show that they've been unable to get a bid bond.
02:37:53
So the bill has undergone significant change.
02:37:56
Again, it's been passed by both the House and the Senate and it's now in front of the Governor.
02:38:10
House Bill 1248, Senate Bill 639, those were the Governor's transportation funding bills.
02:38:17
Again, they've undergone significant transformation.
02:38:25
The transportation share of the surplus is still 67%.
02:38:31
What's interesting is they changed the definition now of non-recurring funds.
02:38:36
Right now, one-third of the surplus is dedicated to non-recurring funds or expenses.
02:38:42
They changed that definition so that now it can include transportation projects.
02:38:46
So that's, I think, somewhat of a creative way to potentially provide for more transportation funding to come out of the surplus.
02:38:55
The bill would authorize the naming.
02:38:59
We discussed this last time.
02:39:01
What the CTB and or VDOT is going to have to do is establish guidelines for naming facilities and guidelines that will establish the fees for naming transportation facilities.
02:39:14
The bill also is going to require more coordination between local planning and the CTB.
02:39:22
Again, the details are here and we'll go into those in more detail or those specifics into more detail next time.
02:39:29
Revenue sharing, there's a new aspect to revenue sharing.
02:39:33
This has managed to survive the governor's bill pretty much intact, bottom line.
02:39:38
Revenue sharing can now be used five million
02:39:42
Right now, our locality can get up to $10 million pursuant to the revenue sharing program.
02:39:48
Now, if this bill ultimately is signed, they can use up to $5 million for maintenance projects.
02:39:58
A couple of other interesting changes.
02:40:02
There's a two-year limit.
02:40:04
If a project has not expended at least some of its revenue-sharing funding within two years of allocation, the CTB can deallocate those funds.
02:40:16
That time period has now been shortened to one year, again, with the idea to speed these projects up and get the ball rolling.
02:40:26
There's also a provision that says basically if we haven't expended all of the revenue sharing program funds in any given fiscal year, a locality can actually exceed the amounts that are set forth in the statute.
02:40:41
But again, there will have to be provisions that basically say that can only happen if we've not expended all of the revenue sharing funds for that year.
02:40:59
There are a couple of, as you all know, there currently is no budget bill, but a couple of interesting provisions in the version of the House bill that did pass the House.
02:41:10
There's a Northern Virginia MPO, there's language in the House bill that would establish
02:41:15
or have the Secretary convene a work group to study the feasibility of creating a separate Northern Virginia MPO.
02:41:25
There's also a provision that would direct the Secretary to convene a work group to study potential options for devolution of secondary roads in large jurisdictions.
02:41:35
And finally, there's a provision that would direct the Secretary of Transportation to
02:41:42
work with the Transportation Accountability Commission to study VDOT's SWAM program, small business program.
02:41:49
Each of these items are to be reported back or would have to be reported back October 2012.
02:41:54
Let's see.
02:42:02
We've already talked about HOV.
02:42:08
Incident management is just a Senate bill.
02:42:10
ABC is the same.
02:42:15
And I think that's it.
02:42:20
There were a couple of bills that were carried over that you might be interested in hearing about very briefly.
02:42:25
As you all are aware, there were the CTB composition bills.
02:42:29
Right now, it's our understanding the Senate, basically in Senate transportation, they pretty much just carried those bills over with the expectation, I think, that we're going to look at the issue over the next year.
02:42:40
Study CTB composition, you know, how to best
02:42:43
select members and again one of the biggest issues in those was whether to tie CTB membership to congressional districts.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:42:50
Mr. Chairman, I think that's a very interesting bill that's kind of tries to reduce alchemy whereby they think they can get more money into the transportation system by shifting the chairs in this room even though we have no power to appropriate the money.
02:43:04
So I thought that was a very amusing bill.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:08
The chairs are important.
02:43:10
I can't hear you.
02:43:11
I have a question about the allocation of the scarce resources.
02:43:15
One last bill that might be of interest again, this is carried over.
SPEAKER_06
02:43:36
Amy Inman, Charles A. Kilpatrick
02:43:50
maintenance funding for primary and secondary highways and basically the focus is to look at achieving a minimal level of disparity among highway construction districts based on performance or asset management performance standards.
02:44:06
So that in a nutshell is where we stand right now.
02:44:09
Reconvene session is April 18th.
02:44:12
Both houses, the House and the Senate, are coming back on March 21st at 3 p.m. arguably to address the budget.
02:44:22
Right now, they're both showing as the meetings are showing as pro forma, so we're not really sure what that means.
02:44:28
But at this point, that's where we stand.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:31
Excellent.
02:44:32
Thank you very much.
02:44:33
Mr. Tyeryar.
SPEAKER_15
02:44:41
There's Mr. Stoltz on the diagram.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:10
Are you over here?
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:45:17
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen of the CTB.
02:45:21
We'll move quickly in light of the hour.
02:45:24
Just give you our regularly scheduled VTrans update.
02:45:28
This is the enabling legislation that tells us what we're supposed to do.
02:45:33
As you know, we've talked about this many times, that legislation was changed last year so that every governor gets a chance to produce a VTrans report.
02:45:41
The next one on a 25-year increment would be the VTrans 2045, excuse me, would be VTrans 2040 produced in 2015.
02:45:49
So we're taking this opportunity to do a VTrans update.
02:45:53
It is also an opportunity to shift to what we call performance-based planning, which is a fancy way of saying things need to be prioritized because resources are limited.
02:46:03
So it does provide a unique opportunity for us in this update in light of the conversation that's been taking place in this room for the last few hours.
02:46:11
This is where we are in the process.
02:46:13
We started our outreach in the fall and we're in the middle of three phases and we'll be coming back to the board with these regularly scheduled updates.
02:46:23
We still have a few bit more.
02:46:25
We've met with stakeholders and interest groups at this point.
02:46:28
There'll be some more public meetings and then we'll start to wrap it up.
02:46:41
Just what we've heard so far, the vision is fine, the goals are fine, but in order to acknowledge that there are limited resources, we need a mechanism for prioritizing amongst investment, prioritize, in other words, a way of ranking those.
02:47:01
That's one of the things we've been talking to the user groups about.
02:47:04
You can see the rest of the comments there.
02:47:06
As a result of breaking the priorities out from the investment strategies, you end up with a four-tiered approach instead of a three-tiered approach.
02:47:12
You have the vision, the goals, the priorities, and then the strategies are the things that would actually achieve the priorities, as I said.
02:47:19
Amongst those priorities, there will have to be some sort of ranking.
02:47:23
What else?
02:47:24
And then we went on to the second phase of meetings.
02:47:26
Again, public outreach, public opportunity to participate in the process.
02:47:33
Again, you see some items there, add tourism as a part of economic vitality, sharpen the focus of investment, address all modes where appropriate.
02:47:45
So this is what the process, unless you tell us differently, this is the process we're going to proceed with.
02:47:52
Identify those investments that can move the needle and in essence improve performance measures, improve the performance standards that we talk about here every so often and then within that,
02:48:03
Which ones are the most affordable?
02:48:04
We can have some great opportunities to make huge investments, but we may not be able to afford them, so we need to proceed with the ones that are affordable.
02:48:14
Which ones can we do quickly?
02:48:15
In other words, where can we move?
02:48:17
We can do a $15 billion project that takes 20 years to get through environmental and construction, or we can do a $1 billion project that can have a pretty quick return on investment and make things better for a particular region, and we need to identify those opportunities.
02:48:32
The first three you see there are stated in the positive.
02:48:35
The last one is actually an assessment tool in the negative, and that is a downside risk if we don't proceed.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:42
Mr. Chairman?
02:48:42
Yes, Mr. Kilman.
02:48:44
Mr. Secretary, are you using this in its linear fashion, sort of one assessment at a time, as was suggested here, or are you looking at each of these factors simultaneously?
02:48:54
Simultaneously.
02:48:55
So the affordability wouldn't necessarily be any bigger than the risk, or?
02:49:02
and so forth.
02:49:07
My concern, Mr. Chairman, was in our 2035 plan we broke out some key goals and project priorities as having projects of significance that if we didn't do them we would be at risk.
SPEAKER_15
02:49:29
For example,
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:49:32
At this point we would not undo anything that's been done.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:49:44
We may run them through this for an FYI, but we would not undo anything that's been done.
02:49:53
So in the process of breaking the actual strategies out from the priorities because they were all one big list,
02:49:58
You see what happens and we've discussed this with the groups that we've met with so far.
02:50:04
You have an investment priority which is sort of broad and then an investment strategy is what you were just referring to, this particular investment or a particular project.
02:50:13
And as you can see, this is still in the draft and development stage and we've been discussing this with our stakeholders and our groups as we've been going through and we'll continue to do so through the end of the summer.
02:50:27
I won't walk you through those in the interest of time.
02:50:29
I'll just conclude by saying that we do in this process acknowledge that resources are limited and that there has to be a way of prioritizing investments.
02:50:40
And some priorities will be more important than others just because.
02:50:46
It's not that we like it that way.
02:50:49
It's just an acknowledgement, as I said, of limited resources and something has to be more important than something else.
02:50:54
And if you look at the last VTrans reported,
02:50:56
Very wonderfully done document with all things standing on equal footing, but if you want a calculator tape on the entire thing, it wasn't affordable and we wanted to change that a little bit and this provided us an opportunity to do that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:51:10
Any questions?
02:51:13
Thank you all very much.
02:51:14
Let's hear about Jolly Pond.
02:51:24
This is the non-tool part of the objective.
SPEAKER_09
02:52:08
Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, and Board Members, it's my pleasure to be here today.
02:52:19
My name is Robert Middaugh.
02:52:20
I'm the County Administrator for James City County.
02:52:22
I'm here to provide you some background on a discontinuous you're considering for a small section of Jolly Pond Road, Route 633 in James City County.
02:52:30
I do fully appreciate the special significance of being last on your agenda.
02:52:34
I will be extraordinarily
02:52:36
I've been joined today by the Chairman of my Board of Supervisors, Mary Jones.
02:52:39
She's behind me.
02:52:40
Board member James Eisenhower, also behind me, and my Director of Development Management.
02:52:45
I don't think Hogy is here, but she's been following us very closely as she expressed her support of our issue.
02:52:53
First up, we'll show you just briefly an orientation.
02:52:56
I have a larger copy for those who are visually impaired, like me.
02:53:01
But if you look at that area map, you'll see on the bottom right, the city of Williamsburg, immediately above it, York County, coming from right to left, Interstate 64, Route 60, Route 199.
02:53:15
And going to the far left of the map, you see the entirety of Jolly Pond Road highlighted in orange and in red.
02:53:22
Strategically, at that intersection where we'll start, that is the dam and that is the point of discontinuance that we're seeking your approval on for today.
02:53:31
You'll notice that just the geography of that particular point makes it extremely difficult for general access for the citizenry down in the neck of the woods.
02:53:42
There's several hundred folks who live very near that dam, as well as our emergency services and just general services to get to that part of our county.
02:53:53
This is a timeline prepared, I won't go through all of these, that just shows you that we've been at this for several years.
02:53:59
What I will note is that we've done engineering analyses of this dam in 2007, 2008, and as recent as 2011.
02:54:08
In that same time period, there have been 44 significant rainfall events, inclusive of a hurricane, which is 6.7 inches in our part of the world.
02:54:17
And in that entire time, the other thing we take from this engineering reporter analysis is that
02:54:22
There's been very little change, very little degradation or deterioration of the structure even with that passage of time.
02:54:29
It's been around for somewhere in excess of 100 years and still survives today quite well.
02:54:36
The structure in that time has never been overtopped and there's never been any, like I said, further deterioration.
02:54:42
From all of the analysis, we know that the dam is classified as low hazard.
02:54:46
There's basically nothing downstream that would be impacted by a breach.
02:54:51
The impounded area itself is also relatively small and the lake is again relatively shallow so it's not a large source of water that might go in the event of a breach.
02:55:03
We are fully aware that the dam as it is now situated does not meet the Department of Conservation and Recreation dam safety standards.
02:55:12
That is precisely why VDOT had to close the road and cease its function because they have to recognize that.
02:55:18
It is not up to standard because the spill we designed did not pass a 100-year storm.
02:55:25
We've also done, just as we look at respective use, a vehicle count to assure that the number of vehicles per day, which is less than 400, still keeps it in the low hazard threshold.
02:55:37
And again, that's one of the things we've tried to evaluate and tried to understand what liability or what risk might be associated with us.
02:55:46
We also fully understand that at some point in the future, DCR may take it upon themselves to undertake an enforcement action.
02:55:53
We don't think it's highly probable, but it can happen, and in the event it does, the private dam owner would have to deal with that.
02:56:00
We do not own the dam itself.
02:56:03
Our responsibility is the road surface, your responsibility, hopefully soon ours, going over the dam.
02:56:09
We have evaluated, we think, very carefully any of the risks associated with the road and the dam.
02:56:14
We find them both to be very minimal and acceptable.
02:56:19
In the event we receive your approval, the things that we will do going forward to ensure safety of the traveling public is, one, implement a weight restriction program.
02:56:29
We've talked to your engineering staff, and we believe that around the 18th
02:56:34
An eight-ton vehicle limit would be appropriate, and we may need to tweak that, but that's just what we're thinking now.
02:56:41
We will have a stringent monitoring program, both for normal weather conditions, perhaps on a weekly basis, as well as in the event of inclement weather, a nor'easter or hurricane, something of that nature, which would increase the frequency of inspection and also probably and most likely do road closures until the event had passed.
02:57:03
We are prepared to undertake any repairs to the structure in the event there is any degradation associated with leakage or seepage, but our engineers have told us to this point in time it's not necessary because the few leaks that are in, and there's a couple, really haven't done anything to deteriorate the structure and it's not necessary at this point in time, but we are prepared to do it if it's required going forward.
02:57:28
I respectfully ask for your approval of this discontinuance and it's my pleasure to answer any questions you might have.
SPEAKER_15
02:57:33
Any questions?
02:57:34
Yes, Ms. Williams.
02:57:34
I'll review this with the district administrator.
02:57:37
Essentially we're removing the road from us to the liability of James City County and the administrator there approved such and I would hope that you would support the resolution this afternoon to approve this discontinuous.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:50
Any other questions?
02:57:51
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
02:57:52
Mr. Middaugh, this might be a big question for Dennis, but what traffic count was on the road before the closure?
SPEAKER_09
02:58:00
We believe it's similar to what you saw in the background material in the vehicle count.
02:58:07
We had to go back to historic records to look at what the vehicle counts were, and we came up with a 400 per day.
02:58:13
As going forward with the way of restriction, it should be even less than that.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
02:58:19
You haven't seen any, I guess, changes in traffic pattern on any of the surrounding facilities?
SPEAKER_09
02:58:26
Since it's been closed, yes, but no.
02:58:29
We've had the addition of some schools way up on the, let me go back to the map here.
02:58:38
You see where the Jolly Pond Road makes a little bubble to north.
02:58:42
There's some new schools that are added up there, but the access to that is equally good at the top end as opposed to from the bottom end.
02:58:51
So we don't think there's significant impact to that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:55
Any other questions?
02:58:56
All right, thank you very much.
02:58:58
Most welcome.
SPEAKER_15
02:58:59
Thank you for your attention.
02:59:04
Just briefly guys, in front of you I put the annual report for the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel for your review.
02:59:10
You know I'm the CTB representative on that.
02:59:14
And really, I'm going to issue an invitation.
02:59:16
I'm chairman this year, and we have OpSale 2012 in Virginia starting, or in the Norfolk area, starting on June the 8th.
02:59:26
Mike, I'll give you an invitation to come out and be our guest at the first aisle of the Chesapeake Babers Tunnel to watch the tall ships come through the channel, the parking and everything.
02:59:35
So I'll be getting with you.
02:59:37
If you see that, I'd love for you to come attend.
02:59:39
Do we have to pay the toll?
02:59:40
No toll.
02:59:41
I'm in the toll.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:42
You, especially.
02:59:44
You're going to pay for all of us, Mr. Miller.
SPEAKER_15
02:59:50
Personal parking and front row stadium seats watching the ships coming in.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:55
All right, Mr. Layne, I got to ask you this.
02:59:57
How much cash you guys got over there?
SPEAKER_15
03:00:00
We have unrestricted assets of about 200 million.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:00:08
I just wanted to ask the commissioner while we've got the commissioner here, it seems like this
03:00:13
What's been happening over at the General Assembly has been kind of hard on you and your staff and disruptive as you try to plan.
03:00:21
Has this caused you a lot of expense and time with staff to try to deal with contracts when we don't have a budget?
03:00:29
I mean, it's kind of disconcerting that you all have to go through this as you try to move money out.
03:00:35
I mean, we've been trying
03:00:36
I think the question was, if we do not have the budget, how will that impact the operations of the staff?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:00:54
We have not started feeling the pinch yet, and it will probably be in April we're going to start sending out letters at that point to all of our contractors.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:07
April 15th.
03:01:08
Tell them why April 15th.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:11
We have to do it April 15th, and I have to give them a 60-day notice per the contract, a 60-day notice to shut down any contracts.
03:01:19
And then we give ourselves a cushion because once the project is shut down, we then have to have 30 days to pay all of the bills.
03:01:29
All bills must be paid by June 25th, I believe it is.
03:01:34
Because after July 1, we will have no authority to spend at that point.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:39
Will we incur fees and penalties because of this?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:45
There will probably be some penalties or claims related to delayed claims, shutting down the project, additional costs.
03:01:56
At this point we have not quantified exactly how much all of that will be.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:11
What's our deadline?
03:02:13
If they don't act by a certain period of time, when does it really start kicking in and hurting us on May 1st?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:20
On April 15th, we'll start sending out notices, and in the first part of May, we'll start saying, stop preparing to shut down your projects.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:27
So this whole thing can really damage our transportation system, really, if they don't get on it?
03:02:32
Yes, it will shut down our projects.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:35
Damage our reputation?
03:02:36
Yeah, absolutely.
03:02:37
And the add to it is, I mean, once you shut down, you said it will remobilize the problem.
03:02:43
We'll lose that, we'll lose the season.
03:02:45
So it's not just simply, we'll start back up.
03:02:48
I mean, it's essentially projects will be put on.
03:02:49
We'll set the project back to lay in.
03:02:51
Yeah, that's bad news.
03:02:53
Ms. Drake, Director Drake, did you mention where you all, did you have different timelines?
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:58
Well, we're very similar to VDOT in that we would have to send out notices because if our transit companies are going to shut down service,
03:03:05
They're going to have to start doing that and telling people during the May timeframe.
03:03:10
So we have the same thing that we will have an earlier timeline in order to get invoices in so that we can pay them.
03:03:18
We would be contacting our local governments very early May to say are you going to fund the service even though we wouldn't be able to provide state funding or for those that we do federal funding for we wouldn't be able to do that.
03:03:31
and we also do not expect to be able to run our passenger trains.
03:03:34
So all of that is kind of in a similar timeline to Greg's although not exactly the same and we also will have start-up and shut-down costs on construction projects that are going on now.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:03:47
So it will be a big hit.
03:03:49
Gary.
03:03:49
Could we get into a situation, hopefully not, but like the federal government we're operating on continuing resolutions.
SPEAKER_15
03:03:57
We don't have that authority.
03:03:59
Stop against the law.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:00
So listen, if you don't hear from us, the July meeting's canceled.
SPEAKER_15
03:04:06
I have one caveat to my answer.
03:04:08
The 200 million is unrestricted, but set aside for the Pimple Shoals Channel.
03:04:13
Start that in 2007.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:15
We've got some great projects if you'd like to invest in.
03:04:17
The forward closure, Mr. Layne is now the chairman.
03:04:20
and there is a chairman's bond.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:24
That's a great deal of equity putting in that midtown tunnel contract.
03:04:28
That's how we got the sheets, the front row sheets.
03:04:31
I can guarantee that.
03:04:32
Good point.
03:04:33
Alrighty, this ends up the workshop.
03:04:35
We'll break for about 15 minutes and then we'll kick into the regular meetings.
03:04:42
We'll start off at 1.20.