Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 6/15/2011
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   6/15/2011

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Bids.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2011 budget _ actual performance through May 2011.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2012 - 2017 Commonwealth Transportation Fund Six-Year Financial Plan recommended Fiscal Year 2012 CTF and VDOT budgets.pdf
  • Rail Industrial Access Program application briefing.pdf
  • Intercity passenger rail PRIIA Section 209 national nolicy update.pdf
  • 1. Financial Report

  • 2. FY12 VDOT Budget

  • 3. Maintenance and Operations Program Budget

    • Maintenance and operations program Fiscal Year 2012 budget.pdf
  • 4. FY12 Six-Year Improvement Program

    • Proposed Final Fiscal Years 2012 - 17 Six-Year Improvement Program.pdf
  • 5. FY12 DRPT Budget and Six- Year Improvement Program

    • DRPT SYIP Update FY 2012 – FY 2017.pdf
  • 6. PRIIA Section 209 National Pricing Policy for Regional Amtrak Trains

  • 7. Rail Industrial Access - Carmeuse Lime & Stone of Northern Virginia

  • 8. VDOT Business Plan

    • VDOT business plan.pdf
  • 9. Report and Recommendations of the Route 29 Subcommittee

    • Report and recommendations of the subcommittee on the Route 29 Corridor.pdf
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning, everyone.
    • 00:00:00
      I'd like to welcome you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:03
      I can't hear you.
    • 00:00:05
      Is this on?
    • 00:00:06
      Yes, it is.
    • 00:00:07
      Thank you.
    • 00:00:07
      I'd like to ask everyone to please take your seats.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:09
      There you go.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:10
      Good morning.
    • 00:00:11
      I'd like to welcome you all to this morning's session of the work session, the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:16
      I'm going to ask everyone to please stand for the pledge of allegiance.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:20
      Thank you very much.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:39
      I appreciate everyone being here.
    • 00:00:40
      This is sort of a historic day.
    • 00:00:42
      We're going to be adopting the six-year plan, but also this will be the last meeting of the Richmond District Commissioner, Jerry McCarthy, who's been on this board since, like, we still had horses.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:56
      We still had horses, parishes, that sort of stuff.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:00
      But, Jerry, we appreciate very much your service all these years on the CTB and to the Commonwealth.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:06
      Mr. Chairman, I'd just like to echo what you just said.
    • 00:01:09
      I think this is the perfect public service and hold integrity and be thoughtful and we'll really miss you.
    • 00:01:21
      Thank you very much.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:30
      We'll wait until they actually get to the real meeting.
    • 00:01:33
      I know you probably want to speak for several hours or whatever.
    • 00:01:40
      We'll have the opportunity to give Mr. McCarthy a few moments at the end of the meeting to say a few words.
    • 00:01:48
      With that, we're going to go right into our agenda.
    • 00:01:50
      The first is the Financial Reports on Mr. Lawson.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:01:59
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 00:02:01
      I want to give you my normal monthly update.
    • 00:02:08
      The year is moving along.
    • 00:02:09
      It's hard to believe that this month has gone by, this year has gone by, and it's June already.
    • 00:02:15
      We're looking just around the corner into 2012.
    • 00:02:19
      Revenues have continued to do well.
    • 00:02:23
      We are forecasting
    • 00:02:24
      Our revenues are continuing to trail just a little ahead of the official growth rate of 3%.
    • 00:02:30
      Our strong performance continues to be the motor vehicle sales and use tax collections.
    • 00:02:38
      19 consecutive months now, they've continued to grow.
    • 00:02:42
      We're currently about almost 14% above where we were last fiscal year, which is double what the
    • 00:02:53
      Forecasted growth rate was expected to be.
    • 00:02:57
      Motor fuel taxes seem to be going up and down.
    • 00:03:01
      As you recall, they were up last month year over year.
    • 00:03:04
      They're down slightly this month year over year.
    • 00:03:07
      We're still holding at about 2.5% annual growth rate compared to an expected growth of about 3%.
    • 00:03:15
      So motor fuels are trailing slightly.
    • 00:03:19
      Motor vehicle registration fees are also increasing.
    • 00:03:23
      It's one of our stronger performance in terms of rate of growth.
    • 00:03:31
      This is the chart you're used to seeing by now that shows the revenues by category.
    • 00:03:39
      As I mentioned, you can clearly see the increases or the growth that's being experienced in
    • 00:03:46
      Motor Vehicle Sales and Use, and the licensees.
    • 00:03:50
      The state sales and use tax, the retail sales tax, that component is not quite at the annual growth estimate yet, but it is inching its way there.
    • 00:04:02
      It's down from 3.9% last month and down to 3.3 this month.
    • 00:04:08
      So it is headed in the right direction, and there's some big collections that come in at the end of the year in June.
    • 00:04:20
      Federal revenue continues to exceed last year in terms of year-to-year collections.
    • 00:04:29
      Obviously, the growth in the federal revenue is very largely attributable to the growth in spending that we have experienced this fiscal year.
    • 00:04:38
      The majority of the growth, as you can see in the chart at the bottom, is related to the ARRA spending, the project on ARRA.
    • 00:04:46
      We spent $60 million last year through May versus $180 million this year.
    • 00:04:53
      The maintenance program has also seen an uptick in federal collection activity.
    • 00:05:04
      Turning to spending, we have expended
    • 00:05:08
      $3.1 billion through May of this year, which is a little over $300 million ahead of where we were through May of last fiscal year.
    • 00:05:20
      That does represent about 73% of our operating budget.
    • 00:05:24
      And when you look at what the spending is on, about 38% is related to VDOT maintenance.
    • 00:05:31
      And if you include the maintenance payments to localities,
    • 00:05:36
      Thank you.
    • 00:05:37
      This is the chart, the year-over-year comparison by program of spending.
    • 00:06:02
      Again, you can see kind of the
    • 00:06:03
      Looking at the top portion of the chart, the significant growth that we've experienced in the spending in the construction and maintenance program.
    • 00:06:11
      In the very top of the chart, you also see where we have been able to reduce or constrain our administrative spending.
    • 00:06:23
      Looking to maintenance.
    • 00:06:27
      We had a fairly good month of May.
    • 00:06:29
      We spent $131 million, bringing our total to the year to just under $1.2 billion compared to just over a billion dollars last year, about a 14% increase.
    • 00:06:42
      The chart below here gives you that illustration that I've been showing you the last few months of the comparison year to year based on the budgetary service areas in which the funds are provided.
    • 00:06:56
      I think for comparison purposes, it may be helpful to look at it this way.
    • 00:07:02
      When we talk about what we're doing with maintenance, the amount of funding going to investments versus the amount of funding being spent on services, you can see here that through May, we've expended 95 percent of the funding provided for services.
    • 00:07:18
      So we have done a very good job of putting those funds to work.
    • 00:07:24
      You also will note, though, on the investment side, which is most of our contract work, we've only spent about 40% of those funds.
    • 00:07:34
      While we have not spent all those funds, it's really important to notice, though, that we have put that money out on the street.
    • 00:07:43
      You've seen this chart before.
    • 00:07:47
      Commissioner had used this chart in talking about the audit and how we have
    • 00:07:52
      If you notice a year ago, at the end of last year, we had a huge $200 million spread between the maintenance contract balance versus the allocation balance.
    • 00:08:20
      The current year, y'all are probably looking at this screen, you can see the $318 million was the contract balance versus the, moving slides, versus the $529 million expanding allocation balance that was last June.
    • 00:08:46
      Now, this is only through May, so we haven't
    • 00:08:49
      That's obtained the final expenditures for the year.
    • 00:08:52
      But you'll see that when you look at the June 2011, which is a June 1 date, we have nearly closed the gap.
    • 00:09:02
      And we do anticipate, you know, while that number is higher than we want it to be, that by the time June ends, that number, those two values should come very close together to where the extending maintenance allocation
    • 00:09:17
      and the outstanding contract balances should be pretty close to being the same.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:26
      Mr. Chairman, if I could make a comment.
    • 00:09:30
      It's important to note that at the last meeting we talked about contracts and when the work would be done.
    • 00:09:38
      There are dates in our contracts and those dates for the work to be completed will be December 1 and we've met with all of our industry representatives and we've been assured that we're on track to meeting at December 1 date to get the work done so if you think about
    • 00:10:02
      This being the prime season for getting work done, we have July, August, September, October.
    • 00:10:11
      You can see a lot of expenditures hitting during that time, and you can see these balances really dropping.
    • 00:10:17
      So I think we made a lot of progress in terms of closing the gap, as John had mentioned, between the allocation balance and the outstanding contract balance.
    • 00:10:28
      But if you look at our contracting for this June,
    • 00:10:33
      We'll have about a billion dollars more on the street than what we had last June.
    • 00:10:39
      So I think we made a lot of progress there, and I feel pretty good that we will meet the date for December 1.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:10:53
      Just a few comments about maintenance spending.
    • 00:10:56
      As the Commissioner mentioned, our contract work really is accelerating.
    • 00:11:01
      This is the time of the year where that work is really moving forward.
    • 00:11:06
      Internally, we're taking all the steps we can to make sure we record all expenditure activity that was recorded in this fiscal year, actually gets recorded in this fiscal year so that we minimize that outstanding balance.
    • 00:11:20
      I do have to note, though, that in order for
    • 00:11:26
      Us to have an allocation balance comparable to last year, we will have to have a very strong month of June.
    • 00:11:33
      But again, as we've shown in the previous slides, that the balance that may exist has been committed and is under contract.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:44
      Mr. Chairman, just one quick thing.
    • 00:11:47
      I appreciate the aspect that we're trying to get as much money out there and projects going, but are we also making sure that we are overseeing these projects to make sure we're getting the best work out?
    • 00:12:03
      The reason I'm saying that is in my area on secondary roads, a technique that I haven't seen employed before is being used now where there
    • 00:12:11
      Dumping asphalt off the back of a dump truck using a grader to grade it out and roll it.
    • 00:12:18
      And I'm getting a lot of complaints in my area with people saying the road's in worse condition now than it was before.
    • 00:12:23
      They've been better off leaving.
    • 00:12:25
      Some of these techniques, if we're just, our effort is to try to put the money out.
    • 00:12:30
      I'm hoping we're doing it for the best, you know, for the best result, not just to be spending the money.
    • 00:12:36
      So that's just one small example of something I've come across.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:12:45
      Just before we move on to that too, I know we've got a lot more money on the street, but if you look at interstate maintenance, we spent about the same this year we did last year actually spent.
    • 00:12:57
      So what we're saying is we're going to have a whole lot going on now in November.
    • 00:13:02
      I guess the proof will be in the pudding as to see what we spent.
    • 00:13:05
      Yes.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:05
      All right, moving on to you.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:10
      Mr. Chairman, do you know how much do we spend on a per lane mile for maintenance?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:13:15
      I don't have that number right off, sir.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:22
      I didn't bring that with me, but we do have the information by lane for both interstate and primary and secondary as to what the projected cost would be.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:13:34
      Unfortunately, I didn't bring that with me.
    • 00:13:38
      All right, moving on to construction.
    • 00:13:40
      It's continued along kind of the same path it has all year.
    • 00:13:44
      As I mentioned earlier, the R spending has really grown over the year as those projects are in place and underway.
    • 00:13:53
      We have spent in total about, we've spent $93 million in the month of May bringing the total maintenance, excuse me, construction program expenditure to $1.1 billion.
    • 00:14:08
      This is your contract comparison chart that we've been looking at for the last few months.
    • 00:14:13
      I did go back and add June of 2010 on the far left so that you can compare that to June 11 on the far right.
    • 00:14:23
      And as the Commissioner was saying and as we've been talking, we've gone from a maintenance contract balance of just over $300 million to a contract balance here
    • 00:14:38
      of almost $700 million.
    • 00:14:42
      And you can see, as we talked about the contract cycle, how it's ramped up in here and then it's actually started to burn down as the work is starting to get underway during the summer months.
    • 00:14:55
      As we said earlier, we've got about $900 million more contract value on the street, and that comparison of outstanding maintenance contract work is 122 percent greater than it was a year ago.
    • 00:15:15
      Looking at total contracts that work, as we look at the picture that includes the other
    • 00:15:21
      items not on that previous slide, and we have a total outstanding contract of about $5.6 billion of which about $2.5 billion is unspent.
    • 00:15:33
      Of course, the maintenance and construction, the first two columns were what we were looking at in the previous.
    • 00:15:39
      And of the consultant contracts, only about 5% of that relates to nonprofessional services.
    • 00:15:49
      The cash report, much larger than it was a month ago, and this reflects the sale of the CPR bonds, so we're looking at a balance of just over $1.8 billion at this point as we start to have received the proceeds from the $600 million sale.
    • 00:16:09
      I do anticipate with the expenditure activity that is ongoing this month, as well as the revenues that we anticipate collecting this month, the end of year balance into June will probably be very similar to the balance you see here at the end of May.
    • 00:16:32
      And just kind of in summary,
    • 00:16:35
      As we've talked, we're likely to end the fiscal year with a large maintenance allocation balance very similar to last year.
    • 00:16:43
      But we've done a great job of getting the contracts on the street and getting the work committed, and it's just going to take some time for it to spin down as the summer progresses.
    • 00:16:56
      We are still on track to bring that balance down to less than $100 million likely by the end of fiscal year 2012.
    • 00:17:04
      Mr. Miller.
    • 00:17:07
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:10
      It would be helpful to me, I think I've said this before, and I commend you all's hard work in trying to get this problem wrestled under control, but if we sort of had at the board level
    • 00:17:28
      You talked about the end of 2012 and we tracked to that.
    • 00:17:40
      That would be helpful to me to sort of say we're on course as opposed to a snapshot of this is where we are without sort of the goal.
    • 00:17:50
      If I'm playing football, I'm trying to get into the end zone and I don't know where the end zone is when I look at this.
    • 00:17:57
      because it's not on that piece of paper.
    • 00:17:59
      So it's retracting, whatever goal it is we have, in this case, getting this money spent timely, if we have what we're trying to get to on the same piece of paper as where we are today, then we know if we're getting, if we're making good progress or not.
    • 00:18:15
      So in the presentation it would be helpful to me anyway to sort of see that.
    • 00:18:20
      And that applies pretty much for whatever we're doing, but certainly in this situation.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:18:30
      I'm going to ask one more question on Schedule 7 and I will stop.
    • 00:18:33
      Back to what Shep was talking about, if we look at the allocations, I'll take Interstate Maintenance in 2010.
    • 00:18:39
      It was $444 million.
    • 00:18:43
      And we spent $202 million in 2010.
    • 00:18:47
      I guess this is apples and apples, right?
    • 00:18:52
      Correct.
    • 00:18:52
      Do the interstate maintenance allocations of $571 million in 2011 include the $444 million of allocations in 2010?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:19:07
      The 570 of allocations in 11 would include the new money provided in 11 as well as the carryover balance, the unspent portion of the 444 and from 10.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:19:25
      So if you add 202 and 238, which are the expenditures, I mean, that's basically we've spent, we completed 2010.
    • 00:19:35
      Now, I know there's mixes, but I mean, that's basically what we're saying, because we have a different fiscal year.
    • 00:19:41
      Right.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:41
      Correct.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:19:42
      Then, so really, are there any allocations from previous years we haven't finished besides 2010?
    • 00:19:48
      In other words, is our gap really the half billion dollars?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:52
      No, it's 2010 carryover is in the FY11 number and that's it.
    • 00:19:58
      So your point is if you look at the level of expenditures between the two years, which is May to May, like 11 months, we have amassed $500 million of expenditures compared to a budget of $444,000 in 2010.
    • 00:20:16
      So we've kind of completed that work and now you're beginning to work on the FY11 with the resources we have in FY11.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:24
      I don't understand that.
    • 00:20:27
      When there be in FY 2010, wouldn't some of that $202 million that we spent in the expenditures today have to do with $2,000 in non-allocation?
    • 00:20:42
      Yes, it could be.
    • 00:20:43
      Okay, so I mean obviously, so if we look at, back to Aubrey's point, if we look at 202 and 238 as the expenditures for 10 and 11, which totals the allocations for 444,
    • 00:20:55
      To sort of say we've spent the 2010 allocation would ignore the fact that we actually had some rollover from 2009 that we probably spent in 2010.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:07
      So it's a cycle.
    • 00:21:12
      The 2010 number, 144 million, includes carryover probably from 2009.
    • 00:21:22
      So we've expended $202 million against that 444.
    • 00:21:30
      So now we've carried over the 2010 balances into 2011, which is included in that 570.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:39
      If I could just interject and make sure I'm clear.
    • 00:21:43
      The $202 million that we spent in 2010, I assume
    • 00:21:50
      would be a combination of allocations for 2010, which was 444, and previous allocations.
    • 00:21:59
      And since we're spending at least on these two years, about 200 million a year, it would be safe if that trend had been that way before, then we would have spent half of the allocation for 2010, meaning half would be in 2011 or later.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:17
      And so if that's the case and we're still $200 million or so behind having fully spent where we are today, that's... No, I agree with you and the issue and the point is that after FY11, we really have to ratchet up those expenditures.
    • 00:22:39
      Well, and that goes back to my sort of the...
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:42
      Here's what we're trying to get to.
    • 00:22:44
      Here's where we are.
    • 00:22:45
      When we look at it in this format, you can't really see that.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:50
      It's not giving you a pure picture of this.
    • 00:22:52
      I agree with you, Shep.
    • 00:22:54
      I think you're trying to get something that makes sense in where we are in the big picture.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:01
      and try to avoid the look.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:03
      Because this catch up is hard to track all the time.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:06
      Yeah, and obviously the administration's inherited an issue they're trying to deal with.
    • 00:23:11
      So for us as commissioners in this administration period, as we look at the pent up money or the unspent money and we think we can get that spent by X date, then I want to see how we're doing against that money as well as the new money
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:31
      So why don't I give you a projection starting from FY12 and you have a budget amount for FY12
    • 00:23:42
      And I can give you a projection of what we plan to spend month by month in order that our allocation balance at the end of June 30-12 is going to be, I'm not going to say, and we have projected what we would like for that number to be perfect.
    • 00:24:01
      So I can give you that projection and we can do that for fiscal year 12.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:06
      And then I will have, well, I shouldn't say that.
    • 00:24:09
      We'll have too many questions.
    • 00:24:12
      But yeah, I mean, that would be very helpful, thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:16
      So, you know, I just want to go back to this issue about the balances.
    • 00:24:21
      So, I mean, it does beg the question for us.
    • 00:24:27
      I recognize it's really, we're only, these numbers only reflect
    • 00:24:31
      Two months of the maintenance year, per se.
    • 00:24:36
      But it does beg the question as to whether we should start to put in there mandatory deadlines as when they finish this work.
    • 00:24:44
      I just, particularly this year, where, I mean, on one level, I mean, I kind of look at these
    • 00:24:52
      The balances, unspent balances are higher, but since we have it on the contract, we at least have just eyeballing as around 93, 94% of the balance, actually balance is actually under contract.
    • 00:25:09
      Whereas last year, we were only around 60%.
    • 00:25:14
      So I mean just 300 or 500.
    • 00:25:18
      So it does,
    • 00:25:20
      Chairman,
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:45
      So what we have are contracts that cross the fiscal year.
    • 00:25:52
      The contractors begin their work, I'm going to say maybe March, they'll end their work maybe October, just reuse that timeframe.
    • 00:26:04
      We have generally projected
    • 00:26:07
      that between the period of March and June 30th that there should be about 20% of the new contracts that are issued in January of, let me just pick a date, January of 12.
    • 00:26:23
      Let's assume we're in 12.
    • 00:26:26
      So I issued contracts in 12.
    • 00:26:28
      We would expect a contractor to at least do about 20% of that contract value by June 30th.
    • 00:26:37
      Then the remaining 80% would be done in the next fiscal year, starting July.
    • 00:26:46
      So, but the key date is December 1 is when they're supposed to finish this work.
    • 00:26:54
      So what I would propose is that let's look at where we are in the month of July, August, September, and potentially October.
    • 00:27:09
      Because during that period, we should have all of those balances basically done.
    • 00:27:17
      That work will almost be done, the chart that you're looking at.
    • 00:27:21
      That shows that high balance of 700 million.
    • 00:27:29
      Basically that work will be completed by December.
    • 00:27:37
      But in October we would have a real good feel for where we are.
    • 00:27:41
      And the reason I picked October is because that's when we started going out with new contracts.
    • 00:27:46
      The October, November, and December timeframe.
    • 00:27:49
      And I think that if we haven't made the progress, you might want to consider dates.
    • 00:27:57
      But if we made the progress, you may not need the dates at that time.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:04
      But it also, I just have a little bit more of a discussion on this.
    • 00:28:10
      Go back to some of the discussion that's occurring with Mr. Miller and the other gentlemen.
    • 00:28:15
      is that it's this issue of maybe it's not always necessarily dates, but it's also how we focus on what we do interstate or what we do maintenance on.
    • 00:28:29
      I mean, sometimes I always question, you know I always question about this issue about why do we break down interstate maintenance by district.
    • 00:28:38
      To me, interstate maintenance should be a central function
    • 00:28:43
      That we end up making sure that 90% of interstate pavement is kept to the highest.
    • 00:28:50
      That's my number.
    • 00:28:53
      Pull that out of the districts and focus on interstate maintenance.
    • 00:28:56
      That should be our highest priority.
    • 00:28:57
      That is the road system, that's the system that ends up
    • 00:29:02
      carrying the vast majority of the vehicles and our freight and everything else.
    • 00:29:07
      I mean, this problem is not resolved.
    • 00:29:11
      I mean, these numbers, we're good on the contracts.
    • 00:29:16
      I mean, obviously, we got 93, 94% of the balance under contract.
    • 00:29:24
      That means that work is gonna occur.
    • 00:29:26
      But I'm also very cognizant of the fact that we just talked about it on July 1st,
    • 00:29:32
      Two billion dollars is going to part of that fund, right?
    • 00:29:36
      And with the actions of this board today, we're going to put another two billion more into the gas thing.
    • 00:29:42
      Don't want to have this problem again next year.
    • 00:29:46
      Recognizing this has been a difficult year because of so much money that was caught in the pipeline.
    • 00:29:51
      So we have still, it's going to take us some time to clean up the fact that we've had such a backlog of maintenance projects.
    • 00:30:00
      More importantly, maintenance money that was stuck in the pipeline that's coming out.
    • 00:30:05
      We got another contract, we just got to figure out a way to make it better where we see the work being done immediately.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:15
      Mr. Chairman, I'm sure, although I can't cite this myself, but other states that have a much shorter maintenance season than we do actually have much tighter schedules, and people know how to work with those.
    • 00:30:31
      I think the former commissioner brought some of that
    • 00:30:33
      That was one of his strengths is he understood, you know, Idaho did it differently than Virginia and Minnesota had to do it differently than Virginia and so forth.
    • 00:30:41
      So I don't think the board would be against the idea of putting some dates against these things.
    • 00:30:48
      They wouldn't have to necessarily be too tight.
    • 00:30:50
      They wouldn't have to be restrictive.
    • 00:30:52
      They would simply be instructive because I think there is an expectation, as you've raised,
    • 00:30:57
      that we're going to spend the money.
    • 00:30:59
      The idea is not for us to hold the money.
    • 00:31:01
      The idea is for us to actually make the transportation system work more efficiently and better.
    • 00:31:06
      So, I definitely think we should find some best practice about how dates are instructive.
    • 00:31:15
      I'm sure they exist in other venues.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:18
      No, I guess, you know, and there's a carry along with that.
    • 00:31:21
      I mean, in my mind, I mean,
    • 00:31:23
      Staff has done an exceptional job of getting us all on the contract.
    • 00:31:27
      I mean, if you look at the numbers, we got almost $700 million in maintenance contracts right now.
    • 00:31:34
      The issue is 671.
    • 00:31:36
      I mean, now that we've gone to that point, so you all have done an exceptional job in getting on the contract.
    • 00:31:46
      Now the issue is about execution.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:31:50
      I would like to hear from the operational people as to how this system works because we put a lot more down on them and even though they're contract they got to have people there to oversee the work and if they don't have I don't know how they do it is my point and so that's another reason to look at some type of tightening to help them administer the projects.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:19
      Well, I think part of me continues to say it's our contractors got to go out and do the work.
    • 00:32:29
      They got the contracts.
    • 00:32:31
      They've all been complaining and screaming and yelling about this.
    • 00:32:34
      Now it's up to our contractors to get out there and do the work.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:39
      I don't know what our contracting regulations and legalese allows us to do, but in my business, and I do a lot of government contracting, and it's time sensitive sometimes, but if a customer comes to me and says, I need to have this done by this date, and it's difficult for me to get it done by that date without spending more money,
    • 00:33:06
      I give them a response that if you want it by this date, it's going to cost X.
    • 00:33:12
      If you want it by this date plus two months, it's going to cost X plus.
    • 00:33:17
      And I let them make a decision as to what they want me to do.
    • 00:33:21
      And by that methodology or by a similar methodology, we could get some sense of what the tightening of our schedules or deadlines
    • 00:33:32
      due to us in terms of the effectiveness of the money that we're spending.
    • 00:33:36
      And I understand that sort of, we've got a certain amount of capacity.
    • 00:33:41
      The more you get things done more quickly, generally, the more they cost.
    • 00:33:46
      How much is that?
    • 00:33:48
      Is there capacity to do it?
    • 00:33:49
      I mean, this board really doesn't necessarily have a good sense for that.
    • 00:33:53
      But if we could have that sort of process, then we could come back and say, well listen, it costs us 20% more
    • 00:34:02
      To speed this up by X amount of days, is that what we really want to do or not?
    • 00:34:09
      I don't know how much pressure that puts on the industry, and not only the industry, but to Mr. Lane's point, to our ability at VDOT to handle the oversight, which is a critical piece, going back to my seatmate's comments about some things he's been saying.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:32
      I love deadlines.
    • 00:34:34
      So, Mr. Chairman, there are a couple of points.
    • 00:34:38
      Number one, we're looking at the maintenance program, but we also have the construction program.
    • 00:34:47
      And many of the contractors, they
    • 00:34:52
      That do work on the maintenance side, could also be doing paving work on the construction side.
    • 00:34:58
      So we don't want to get into a process where we're bidding one company, one fund against another fund.
    • 00:35:05
      So that's one point.
    • 00:35:07
      The second point is on the construction side, we do have dates and we have a very rigorous process on what happens if we don't get to a certain date, but we also do have a date
    • 00:35:19
      on the maintenance side, but it's geared to be symbol one.
    • 00:35:25
      So we do have that date, but we haven't tried to put a date in that says by June 30th, I want you to get X done.
    • 00:35:37
      And the reason we are focused on June 30th is because that's the snapshot in time that we look at the end of our year.
    • 00:35:46
      And this year, yes, our balance is high, but we've put everything under contract.
    • 00:35:55
      Now, I am expecting that when you get to next year, the end of FY12, you will see a totally different picture.
    • 00:36:05
      because the backlog will be gone and you can see we're a reasonable balance sitting there.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:14
      Thank you.
    • 00:36:14
      Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:15
      Yes, Mr. Garczynski.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:17
      Chef, addressing to your question, I think when we go to the strategic planning session in September, some of the questions you're raising here border on
    • 00:36:30
      More operational than just oversight, and I think that's something that we have to wrestle with as a board that we really haven't addressed yet, because that's what you're getting into.
    • 00:36:42
      What about incentivizing the contracts further?
    • 00:36:47
      You know, what type of operations are going on on the maintenance?
    • 00:36:51
      There's a lot of questions that, you know, we're not here to run VDOT.
    • 00:36:56
      We're here as oversight to help VDOT.
    • 00:36:59
      And if we're going to delve into that, I think it takes more than just
    • 00:37:03
      You know, the questions at this meeting to really get into.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:06
      I don't want to get too deep into it, so that's not our job.
    • 00:37:09
      I agree with that.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:10
      Mr. Chairman.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:11
      Yes, Ms. King.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:12
      Along that line, there is, I think, a little bit of a void or a gap in our connectivity to the planning and prioritization and allocating of funds on the maintenance program for the districts.
    • 00:37:29
      in the primary and the secondary system.
    • 00:37:32
      We've got this on the construction side, but when it comes to prioritization of projects, some people actually know the need for some of the heavy maintenance that needs to be done.
    • 00:37:44
      But it's just, it's left somebody out there using some model some way to determine what maintenance projects gets the attention first.
    • 00:37:54
      And I think there's probably some,
    • 00:37:57
      Some value in the board being involved some way with this maintenance budget in the district level.
    • 00:38:07
      It's never been, I've never been involved in it in the nine years I've been here, to the extent that we get very involved in the maintenance.
    • 00:38:16
      And I don't think we get into the microsite either, but I believe there could be a lot more.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:20
      No, there's somewhere there's that balance we're looking for.
    • 00:38:23
      There's a disconnect there.
    • 00:38:24
      We need to really discuss that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:27
      And again, also cognizant of the fact there's massive layoffs in the industry.
    • 00:38:34
      They sold equipment.
    • 00:38:36
      They terminated.
    • 00:38:39
      Don't have as many resources, so it's going to take them a little time to get up and going, so I recognize that.
    • 00:38:46
      But in that vein, we need them to do this work.
    • 00:38:51
      And if we're not successful in getting these balances down, I mean, again, I think from the VDOT side, you've done what you needed to do, and that is got the contracts out.
    • 00:39:04
      Now the issue is the industry now has to follow through and execute those contracts.
    • 00:39:11
      And if they don't execute the contracts, what the board is really saying is that we're going to have to look at general policy things to change maybe the terms of contracts, how we look at some of these programs to ensure that this work is done on a timely basis.
    • 00:39:28
      Now this again may be just simply a flip because we have a lot of money coming out.
    • 00:39:33
      Industry that really was on its knees.
    • 00:39:36
      They let people go.
    • 00:39:38
      They sold equipment, equipment on the leases that they've turned back in.
    • 00:39:43
      They let go of, you know, they have less facilities.
    • 00:39:48
      And so it's going to take a little time to gear up because a lot of these contracts really didn't go out until probably right near the end of the year, the calendar year at the end of it.
    • 00:39:58
      So it's going to take them several months to get up, but the thing is that this year is one thing, next year we're going to have to come back and take a look to make sure
    • 00:40:09
      And we're at the numbers that those contracts are executed or we're going to have to look at different ways to mandate this maintenance is done in a timely fashion.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 00:40:22
      Alright.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:27
      We have some, actually it was since we, the Commissioner just pointed out we have a few of the contractors here.
    • 00:40:33
      Is anybody?
    • 00:40:35
      We have Mr. Branscombe.
    • 00:40:37
      Anyone else like to maybe say a few words since we have you here?
    • 00:40:41
      I see you, Mr. Branscombe.
    • 00:40:42
      I don't know how I always pick you out in the audience.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 00:40:46
      You usually have a target on me.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:48
      That's when you turn around.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 00:40:52
      Yes, my name is David Branscombe.
    • 00:40:53
      I'm Vice President of Branscombe Paving Company, Northern Virginia, but I'm also the current President of Virginia's Asphalt Association.
    • 00:41:00
      This is a very lively topic, it appears.
    • 00:41:04
      One thing, the balances that we have now, we would have loved to have in FY10.
    • 00:41:10
      In Prince William County, in FY10, laid zero tons of asphalt.
    • 00:41:16
      So again, the funds have, in the backlog, have created a swell, but the industry is in position to get this work done.
    • 00:41:26
      We do have our deadline.
    • 00:41:27
      We have liquidated damages occur if we're not done December 1st.
    • 00:41:32
      I can attest to VDOT does have a hammer and they know how to use it and they do use it on the contractors.
    • 00:41:40
      Right now there was some carryover from last year up to 20% on certain contracts.
    • 00:41:45
      We ran through that 20% that had to be done June 1.
    • 00:41:48
      That was completed.
    • 00:41:50
      Historically, with our contracts, like the commissioner said, we run between, by June, we run in between 20 and 30% complete on our work.
    • 00:41:59
      Right now, we are at that point with the increase in the contracts.
    • 00:42:03
      I feel confident that on December 1, I can't say for 100% of the contracts will be complete, but I say we'll have a high A of the work will be completed on December 1.
    • 00:42:14
      Our industry, again, like the chairman said,
    • 00:42:19
      We have been on our knees for a couple of years.
    • 00:42:21
      We have had layoffs, and we are gearing up, so we do have our challenges.
    • 00:42:24
      However, it's also created an opportunity for us.
    • 00:42:29
      In 2010, we only ran our asphalt company in North Virginia.
    • 00:42:35
      We ran at 20 percent capacity.
    • 00:42:37
      This year, we're running at near 40 percent capacity with the increase, but we still have capacity available.
    • 00:42:43
      And we've been able to subcontract out to some of our other smaller subcontractors, so the striping guys, everybody's been benefiting from this work.
    • 00:42:55
      It's important also when we do our hiring to maintain a March to December
    • 00:43:03
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:43:11
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:43:32
      about as you compress the restrictions, the price, the more restrictions alters the price.
    • 00:43:39
      I think, and historically, the commissioner can attest, there are, by the maintenance, because we do have the flexibility, we finish up some construction projects early spring.
    • 00:43:51
      During the summer, we can go out and get this maintenance, so by allowing the industry flexibility,
    • 00:43:57
      The department and the citizens and the taxpayers of Virginia get a good price on the work that we're doing.
    • 00:44:04
      So there is a cost benefit to that.
    • 00:44:06
      But at the same time, we're very keenly aware that December 1, and that's our target.
    • 00:44:11
      And if we have to go out and get additional resources, I mean, that target date is fixed and set, and we're going to meet those target dates.
    • 00:44:23
      for the industry.
    • 00:44:24
      So again, the Commissioner's saying as September, October roll around, I think even July, the June expenditures should show an increase in work that was beginning done.
    • 00:44:38
      Personally, our company, we're at 38% complete for our work, so we're way ahead.
    • 00:44:44
      We've elapsed about a little less than 30% of our time, so we're ahead of schedule.
    • 00:44:49
      As an industry, we've polled our industry, we've polled our members.
    • 00:44:52
      We're historically right where we've been, you know, 22 to 28 percent complete on our work.
    • 00:44:58
      So we're on schedule as far as the industry goes where we've been historically, and again, meeting the deadlines of December 1.
    • 00:45:04
      Those six dates we will meet.
    • 00:45:07
      We'll meet those dates.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:10
      Thank you.
    • 00:45:10
      Are there any questions?
    • 00:45:14
      Anyone else from the industry out there?
    • 00:45:16
      Anyone from BPCA?
    • 00:45:18
      No?
    • 00:45:19
      Tom, you want to say anything?
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:45:31
      Thank you.
    • 00:45:32
      My name is Tom Wynn.
    • 00:45:33
      I'm the Engineer Director of BTCA.
    • 00:45:35
      Thanks for the opportunity to speak.
    • 00:45:36
      I think David did an excellent job in outlining the situation.
    • 00:45:41
      I think the message that hopefully came across is that the industry is certainly in a position to complete this work.
    • 00:45:49
      Will there be some challenges?
    • 00:45:51
      Absolutely, but there's no question in my mind and no indication from any of our members that there are any problems in meeting the demand.
    • 00:46:01
      It's a very aggressive group.
    • 00:46:05
      As Chairman Connaughton mentioned, the industry has been, I guess the words were complaining and crying for more and more work over time.
    • 00:46:17
      It certainly has been the case, only based on their ability to actually prosecute that.
    • 00:46:24
      I think it's important, some of the discussion earlier we talked about, it was mentioned,
    • 00:46:29
      I think working with a specific date for some of these maintenance contracts, certainly that's something that could be explored over time.
    • 00:46:38
      I would encourage the board to put very careful consideration into making those changes.
    • 00:46:44
      The process that's in place now as far as the flexibility that's given in the maintenance contracts.
    • 00:46:50
      is something that's developed over years and years of experience and there are certainly benefits so I think any adjustments to that we have to carefully consider any kind of unanticipated impact on making those changes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:10
      So you're telling us we shouldn't trust you?
    • 00:47:12
      You're from the industry?
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:47:13
      Absolutely.
    • 00:47:14
      We're from the industry.
    • 00:47:15
      How's it go?
    • 00:47:17
      We're the industry and we're here to help you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:21
      I noticed Mr. Southern sent you here.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:47:22
      It was very evident to myself as well.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:27
      Mr. Rich?
    • 00:47:27
      I've got a question.
    • 00:47:28
      It might be good to get some fresh viewpoint from the eyes of the private sector that you all are on the ground so you see our infrastructure.
    • 00:47:37
      And it seems to me that Interstate is in pretty good shape.
    • 00:47:42
      But I keep reading things.
    • 00:47:43
      Are you kidding me?
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:47:45
      Come on.
    • 00:47:46
      I'll take a break.
    • 00:47:48
      All right.
    • 00:47:49
      But at least.
    • 00:47:49
      In all honesty, it's not.
    • 00:47:51
      Okay.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:52
      It sounds like that needs work.
    • 00:47:53
      But I hear constantly, if you go around the Commonwealth, we have severe deficits in maintenance for primary and secondary roads.
    • 00:48:05
      What is this, how does the private sector, how do you view the state of our maintenance?
    • 00:48:12
      Do we need more funding?
    • 00:48:15
      This is mainly a General Assembly question.
    • 00:48:16
      I know we're dealing with the funds we're given, but from what I'm seeing from my folks, they're telling me that the roads really are not that good a shape, especially secondary and primary, and we could, if we got more funding, we could put it to good use.
    • 00:48:34
      Is that your view?
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:48:35
      Absolutely.
    • 00:48:36
      I agree with that.
    • 00:48:37
      And I think one of the things that we've seen over time with the way the funding has been allocated and the sacrifices that have been made in the secondary systems particularly, I will go as far as saying that there are smaller contractors in the industry that have been hit perhaps extra hard because that's their specialty and that work has effectively dried up.
    • 00:49:00
      I do believe that if you go around that there's certainly indications that just because there's not money being put in that area, as you know, it's not because there's not a need there.
    • 00:49:13
      So I think the industry certainly, there's no doubt in my mind that
    • 00:49:17
      There's some capacity there that isn't being used at this time.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:23
      So we're really not totally meeting our maintenance needs at the current time.
    • 00:49:28
      That's what I'm hearing from the general public.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:32
      I would agree with that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:36
      I want to thank you for allowing these two gentlemen to speak because I think it definitely has enriched our discussion here.
    • 00:49:44
      I just see a great continuity of policy funding and private sector response and that's a challenge that we continue to face is not how to level things out at some level just because you want that balance but clearly the volatility of our funding
    • 00:50:04
      Our decision-making on the policy side, the private sector's ability to staff up and ramp up to do things, a better balance of those things, a continuity of effort that we can all expect, it just works better for everyone.
    • 00:50:20
      So I'm hoping that the new initiatives we brought forward, the bond sales, other things,
    • 00:50:25
      We can look at additional initiatives in the out years, particularly the Six-Year Plan, that keep this volatility from being the characteristic of our transportation response and instead give us a continuity effort that helps our mission but also obviously helps the private sector execute.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:50:45
      I just want to point out, Mr. Rich, if we go back to Table 7, we spent $120 million more on secondary maintenance than we have on interstate maintenance this year.
    • 00:50:55
      And they are not in good shape, and that's why I keep bringing it up.
    • 00:50:58
      We look like, well, anyway, we're in agreement we don't have enough money.
    • 00:51:03
      We're in total agreement.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:04
      We just need to do more maintenance all over, across the board.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:09
      Anyone else from industry?
    • 00:51:11
      Olsen, do you want to say anything?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:51:18
      I'm Wilson Whitehurst, President of Whitehurst Paving and also the current President of Old Dominion Highway Contractors.
    • 00:51:24
      And I just want to, I agree with what my friends have said here.
    • 00:51:28
      I just want to add one thing.
    • 00:51:29
      I would caution contemplating too much restriction on the industry to do this work.
    • 00:51:38
      I do surface treatment work on secondary roads.
    • 00:51:42
      I end up doing about more than half of the program for the state every year.
    • 00:51:47
      And I have like a program year where I never know what I'm going to end up with.
    • 00:51:54
      But I do know my deadlines.
    • 00:51:56
      And so I may not even start in a district till mid-season, but I've worked in others.
    • 00:52:01
      And I look at the whole thing and I always get it done.
    • 00:52:04
      And if we start putting too many deadlines, intermediate deadlines, it's going to be difficult.
    • 00:52:10
      And prices will, you know, reflect that.
    • 00:52:13
      So I would just caution that part of it.
    • 00:52:16
      But I do echo everything that's been said.
    • 00:52:19
      There needs to be more money.
    • 00:52:20
      I work on the secondary system.
    • 00:52:22
      It's in terrible shape, so thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:27
      General, thank you very much.
    • 00:52:29
      Since it's still early in the day, maybe you can get out and do a little bit more work and get these numbers up.
    • 00:52:37
      Next presentation, Mr. Lawson, VDOT 2012 budget.
    • 00:52:46
      All right, as I mentioned, 2012 is upon us.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:53:09
      What I'm going to do this morning is give you a little overview of what we call the Six-Year Financial Plan.
    • 00:53:17
      Then I'll talk about the fiscal year 2012 budget for the Commonwealth Transportation Fund and then VDOT's budget.
    • 00:53:25
      And I think Mr. Pittard will talk about the DRPT budget a little later.
    • 00:53:33
      The Six-Year Financial Plan,
    • 00:53:35
      It is an air tool for identifying and allocating all the revenues available to transportation for highways, transit ports, and aviation.
    • 00:53:46
      These are the funds that are basically at your disposal for distribution.
    • 00:53:54
      This is the basis.
    • 00:53:56
      This process comes up with the basis of identifying the funding that is available for maintenance and construction work.
    • 00:54:03
      For the six-year period, 2012 through 2017, we have a total funding of just shy of $27 billion, about 17 percent above last year's 11 through 16 plan.
    • 00:54:18
      The basis of this plan is a state revenue estimate from the
    • 00:54:23
      Official State Forecast from last December, which does incorporate the bond funding provided by the Governor's Omnibus Transportation Funding Package, as well as our estimate of federal revenues.
    • 00:54:40
      As you well know, we don't have any federal authorization yet.
    • 00:54:45
      So at this point, the most reliable, really the best thing we have to go on in terms of looking to the future is the last fiscal year's worth of federal money, which was federal fiscal year 10.
    • 00:54:57
      And we use that data and project forward since the federal revenue is largely or predominantly based on fuel tax, we escalate the growth of that revenue based on what the Department of Taxation is forecasting in terms of
    • 00:55:13
      fuel consumption growth within the state of Virginia, which is estimated at just a shy 2%.
    • 00:55:21
      And clearly there's uncertainty about where the transportation, federal transportation funding will go, and if significant efforts take place that dramatically impact this, certainly we would be back to the board to seek revisions.
    • 00:55:39
      And as I mentioned, the first year of the plan does represent the funding for the CTF and VDOT budgets.
    • 00:55:50
      Are you all pretty familiar by now with the funding that was provided by the Governor's transportation package?
    • 00:55:57
      I just wanted to very quickly touch on that.
    • 00:56:00
      In the 12 and 13 of this financial plan, we do have $600 million in each of those two years
    • 00:56:07
      identified for CPR bond sales.
    • 00:56:11
      The first sale was done in May, so that was done in this current fiscal year.
    • 00:56:16
      We also have plans, $1.1 billion worth of Garvey bonds to be used to support major projects that you'll see outlined in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 00:56:31
      The issuance schedules you see here are based on
    • 00:56:34
      This chart gives you the depiction of the roughly $27 billion of revenue that are available to transportation in the upcoming six years.
    • 00:57:03
      About 60% or 66% of the funds are in the state transportation revenue box you see at the top, which also does include some local revenues.
    • 00:57:14
      Federal revenues represent about 24% of the total, and the bond program is about 10% of the total.
    • 00:57:23
      You'll notice that the
    • 00:57:26
      The value of each year trends downward from 12 on out and out as you get away from the significant amounts of bond revenues that are anticipated.
    • 00:57:40
      This just gives you kind of a graphic look of our major revenue sources.
    • 00:57:45
      As has been the case for many years, federal revenue remains our single largest source of revenue in the program.
    • 00:57:52
      Motor vehicle fuel tax is our second largest
    • 00:57:55
      This chart gives you an illustration of the planned use of those funds.
    • 00:58:08
      Major category, kind of in order really of priority in terms of spending.
    • 00:58:17
      It does reflect the modal distributions of the transportation trust fund monies to transit ports and airports.
    • 00:58:25
      So what you see here is that distribution.
    • 00:58:30
      Clearly the big number here over the period is maintenance.
    • 00:58:39
      Looking at it from that perspective of where the money is actually going, over the six-year period, about 43 percent of the total is directed to maintenance, and that is maintenance in terms of VDOT maintenance and maintenance payments to localities combined.
    • 00:58:54
      Construction represents about 28 percent of the total funding, and if you were to look at debt service,
    • 00:59:01
      Over the period, we're looking at debt service expense of about 8.6 percent of the total funding.
    • 00:59:07
      So it's still a pretty small amount in terms of the percentage of the total funds.
    • 00:59:12
      And you can see from the...
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:13
      I have a quick question on that.
    • 00:59:14
      Some of the new money that's coming in from the governor and the general assembly, that's going into maintenance, too, isn't it?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:59:23
      The new funding from the governor's package, the bonding, is all construction dollars.
    • 00:59:27
      All construction and some of the bond funds go to transit rail, but it's not maintenance.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:59:32
      But the other billion that you guys found in reserves and stuff, the 600 million, as I recall, went directly into maintenance.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:45
      Thanks for that.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:59:50
      Turning to the Commonwealth Transportation Fund budget, and you should have that document as well as the VDOT budget document at your seat.
    • 01:00:04
      The total budget for the CTF for fiscal year 2012 is just shy of $5.3 billion.
    • 01:00:12
      That's a 41% increase over the 2011 budget.
    • 01:00:18
      It does include, as I mentioned, the bond funding provided by the government's plan, the portions that we plan to actually sell and allocate in 2012.
    • 01:00:28
      Supporting these numbers is about just shy of 3.5% year-over-year growth in state revenue forecast.
    • 01:00:37
      The strongest, as I mentioned before in the monthly update, is motor vehicles sales and use tax.
    • 01:00:43
      That continues to be the strongest performer of about 5% growth.
    • 01:00:48
      and the motor fuel tax growth in 12 is only estimated to be about 1.3% over fiscal year 11.
    • 01:01:00
      You can see here in the chart and in the table below that the actual distribution or actual categories of which those revenues will be coming in.
    • 01:01:12
      This chart gives you that
    • 01:01:15
      Big picture look at the distribution of those funds.
    • 01:01:19
      Just looking at 2012, again supported by the bond funding from the governor's package, about 43% of the 12 budget is dedicated to construction.
    • 01:01:31
      Maintenance still receives about 34% of the total and you can see from this chart the distributions to the other programs and other agencies.
    • 01:01:48
      VDOT specifically, VDOT's budget is about $4.8 billion which is about a 43% increase over the current year $3.3 billion budget.
    • 01:02:04
      Again, as the trend continues, this big infusion or big increase is largely driven based on the increased inclusion of the CPR bonds and the planned sale of the direct garbage.
    • 01:02:19
      In the budget, just from a couple highlights, in addition to the construction money that
    • 01:02:25
      From the bond, we did include $10 million for the implementation of research initiatives and $10 million in funding to help support pre-scoping activities as recommended by some of the audit findings.
    • 01:02:41
      $50 million in capital for the Transportation Partnership Opportunity Fund.
    • 01:02:46
      It's a bond program that's been in place since I think 2005 that at this point has lent out or granted out all the funds available.
    • 01:02:56
      And we did provide $50 million for the revenue sharing program as discussed.
    • 01:03:04
      And again, with the ability to raise that number much higher in the future, clearly we'll be looking at that for next year's update.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:17
      This is a question.
    • 01:03:19
      Would you remind me what's in the earmarks and specials fund that $1.5 billion
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:03:26
      Yes, the one and a half, you're back here?
    • 01:03:35
      Yeah, most of what is in there are the bond funding.
    • 01:03:41
      All the bond funds are being spent as a dedicated statewide regional category.
    • 01:03:46
      So instead of showing up in the systems, you're seeing all the funds there.
    • 01:03:52
      We also have revenue sharing, for example, shows up.
    • 01:03:55
      as a special financing category.
    • 01:03:57
      We don't consider it to be primary, secondary, or urban funds.
    • 01:04:00
      They're dollars that are just held in kind of a state-wide perspective.
    • 01:04:10
      The infrastructure bank is not here as a budgeted item.
    • 01:04:16
      The capitalization is from prior year funding and the loaning of those dollars is a balance sheet entry.
    • 01:04:24
      It's not actually an expenditure.
    • 01:04:25
      So it's not actually showing the budget as an expenditure item.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:30
      What about the public-private stuff?
    • 01:04:32
      Is that outside of this as well?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:04:34
      The PPTA funding?
    • 01:04:36
      Yeah.
    • 01:04:37
      That is largely coming out of the bond funds.
    • 01:04:39
      So the funding supporting those projects are for the most part in that earmarks in special finance.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:45
      Okay.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:46
      Thank you.
    • 01:04:47
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:04:47
      Ms. Lawson, am I accurate?
    • 01:04:52
      When we look at this budget, is this reflective of allocation or is this reflective of expenditure?
    • 01:04:59
      This is reflective of allocation.
    • 01:05:01
      So when we look at the 41% increase, which obviously, I'm getting operations, but obviously
    • 01:05:11
      Any organization that's going to spend 41% more than they spent the year before, you know, it drives lots of questions.
    • 01:05:22
      We're not saying that we're going to spend 41% more.
    • 01:05:24
      That's just what we're going to allocate.
    • 01:05:26
      We certainly will probably spend more.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:05:28
      I would expect spending to be significantly more, but the funding, as you'll see later in the six-year program, you know, the funding isn't being put on construction projects.
    • 01:05:39
      and it will depend on the construction project schedule to start spending down those dollars.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:44
      So again, we're looking at allocations and some of this money will be spent, some of it won't be spent until later.
    • 01:05:50
      That's correct.
    • 01:05:50
      But this is the allocation.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:53
      Mr. Chairman, I have a follow-up question to that.
    • 01:05:56
      The reason the issue, Chef is saying, you know, obviously we have more money to deal with.
    • 01:06:01
      I'm looking at the budget for administration.
    • 01:06:06
      It says tools, administration and other programs
    • 01:06:09
      FY 2011, $350 million, and then $356 million for 2012.
    • 01:06:20
      Now this contains all of the staff at VDOT at the district level?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:26
      That's the administrative staff.
    • 01:06:28
      You still have your maintenance crews are part of the maintenance program, the construction crew.
    • 01:06:35
      Projects and staff working on construction projects are charged into those projects so they would be included in the construction program.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:42
      But not in this figure?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:43
      They would not be in that figure.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:46
      Okay.
    • 01:06:48
      Do we have enough staff to administer all this new money?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:51
      I think the Commissioner has spoke to that before and we believe that between the staff that we have and the contractual work that we have, the contractor staff that we can bring on to the consultants that we are prepared.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:06
      Okay.
    • 01:07:08
      Thank you.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:07:12
      This chart just gives you kind of a little more of a detailed look at the revenues for VDOT specifically.
    • 01:07:21
      You see the different categories that are providing for the $4.8 billion to transportation or to VDOT.
    • 01:07:31
      Included in this, you'll also notice that the very bottom line
    • 01:07:35
      The crossover number, as it's referred to, we're looking at a transfer of construction revenue to the Hollywood Maintenance and Operating Fund in 2012 of about $448 million.
    • 01:07:54
      This chart gives you a snapshot of what the budget looks like broken out by the budgetary program.
    • 01:08:02
      Give you the year-to-year comparison of 12 to 11.
    • 01:08:06
      And as you can see, the real differences and change are in the construction and in the maintenance area.
    • 01:08:15
      The other areas are very much constrained and very similar to what you saw in 2011.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:26
      I'd like to follow up the point that Mr. Rich just made about the administrative side, perhaps that's you, John, but also the Commissioner.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:37
      If administrative and support services are actually declining in dollar terms, what does that mean in terms of actual full-time positions, perhaps changes in the allocation of your resources?
    • 01:08:50
      Are there some pieces of that we ought to understand better?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:55
      You're referring to the administrative and support services, the 215 and 217?
    • 01:09:03
      You know, we have reduced staff in the administrative area.
    • 01:09:10
      That was a part of our blueprint process that we went through.
    • 01:09:16
      So you will see some of that cost going down, but we've also been looking for efficiencies
    • 01:09:22
      For example, we have been consolidating a number of our rental space.
    • 01:09:27
      Lee Space, I'm sorry.
    • 01:09:30
      Because we've lost staff, we've been consolidating more people into these three buildings here.
    • 01:09:37
      And we're looking for additional areas that we can reduce.
    • 01:09:42
      For example, we have identified a process of automating some of our build paying related to continuing power bills or Dominion Power.
    • 01:09:52
      Where we used to take a number of staff to key in those invoices, we automated that process from electronic transfer directly from the power company to VDOT, looking for different ways to save administrative costs.
    • 01:10:10
      So we have been purposely trying to reduce the administrative side for purposes of putting money back into the program, into the Makers Architecture Program.
    • 01:10:21
      But I will say that from the standpoint of having the manpower to administer the program, that's come up a couple times, between the staff that we have and the
    • 01:10:32
      How we supplement our staff with the private sector, we do believe we have the right controls in place to be able to manage the program.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:41
      Mr. Chairman, am I correct that we actually are well below our authorized full-time equivalent
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:48
      Yes, the full-time equivalent staff is 7,499.
    • 01:10:56
      We are at slightly below 7,000 I think in terms of actual strength.
    • 01:11:03
      We are about 6,900 plus.
    • 01:11:07
      So we are trying to still hire up, but hire in the right places.
    • 01:11:16
      When you have such a massive reduction in staff the way we did in the last couple years, you want to make certain that when you, I'm sorry, we had a massive reduction of over a thousand people.
    • 01:11:29
      But on top of that, we had a huge layoff, I mean a huge retirement.
    • 01:11:35
      And that really shrunk our staff way below the 7500 level.
    • 01:11:40
      So when we're hiring staff back, we want to make sure that we're hiring in the right places because our organization has changed.
    • 01:11:47
      We're doing things different ways.
    • 01:11:50
      Customer service center, we have one customer service center, and so we're staffing our area headquarters a bit different.
    • 01:11:58
      So we're trying to make certain we're hiring the right people as we fill these positions.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:05
      Mr. Chairman, one final comment.
    • 01:12:07
      The last couple of weeks I had picked up, and perhaps my colleagues have too, a couple of references to some of the reductions in the functions that issue permits.
    • 01:12:20
      In other words, that there was beginning to creep in some delay and some difficulty in
    • 01:12:25
      having experienced personnel who were familiar with the types of exemptions and special circumstances as well as the traditional permitting.
    • 01:12:33
      So I think we all have in mind that we really don't want to see those types of things slowed down at a time when industry is trying to sort of step up its investment development and growth is occurring in our communities.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:47
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to follow up on that too.
    • 01:12:50
      I think it's great that we're shoveling it out the door quick.
    • 01:12:53
      That's important.
    • 01:12:54
      But we have to make sure that there's a staff to make sure it's being done right.
    • 01:12:58
      And scarce funds are being spent in the most cost-effective way.
    • 01:13:02
      And one of the interests I have is in innovative, cost-effective designs.
    • 01:13:07
      and value engineering, whatever you want to call it.
    • 01:13:12
      I want to make sure we have enough staff there that we can do new things, that type of thing.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:21
      Chairman, I did promise at a future board meeting we would have a presentation on the value engineering program.
    • 01:13:27
      I wanted to do it this time, but we'll have it on the next.
    • 01:13:32
      Thank you, General.
    • 01:13:33
      Thank you, sir.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 01:13:35
      All right, I'm just kind of wrapping up.
    • 01:13:38
      The VDOT budgets, as we've talked, kind of represents their planned use of available resources to advance VDOT's program.
    • 01:13:45
      It does include the funding from the government's plan.
    • 01:13:48
      I do want to point out that while there's a large increase in the construction program,
    • 01:13:54
      That increase is supported by the bond programs, and it's not funding that's available for allocation through the construction formula.
    • 01:14:03
      I think you'll be hearing from Ms. Busher shortly to talk about the details of the construction side through the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 01:14:12
      And Ms. Rell, I think, is following me to talk about the maintenance program.
    • 01:14:17
      I do want to make one comment about the VDOT budget itself.
    • 01:14:20
      It follows the same form that you saw last year, but at the very end of it, we did add a summary that looks just like the monthly budget report that we provide you.
    • 01:14:30
      So that will be the basis of the reporting as we get started for 2012.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:38
      Okay.
    • 01:14:38
      Thank you.
    • 01:14:39
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:14:40
      Yes, Ms. Lauterman.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:41
      One quick point and looking at the budget, I know this is probably not something we're not going to be covering today in particular, but with the changing demographics in transportation with hybrid vehicles and electric cars and all the other technologies coming forward,
    • 01:15:02
      Our current system of collecting taxes, and I'm not a big fan of taxes, but I do believe in fairness for all people using the roads.
    • 01:15:11
      Has there been discussion, or I'm sure there has been discussion, but what types of things are we looking at as a way to balance out future revenues?
    • 01:15:22
      Tolling is not going to be the answer because you can't toll every road.
    • 01:15:25
      I've seen some states talk about miles traveled.
    • 01:15:29
      I don't know how you're going to be able to get everybody's mileage as to what they're traveling every year.
    • 01:15:34
      I mean, it's a really very difficult issue to deal with, but I'm trying to think of how we're going to move forward in the future to have stable funding for our future transportation needs.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:47
      Do you want me to give you an answer?
    • 01:16:05
      Our biggest challenge going out here.
    • 01:16:08
      In fact, again, you just keep on looking at the numbers.
    • 01:16:13
      You can see even just in Virginia, look at vehicle miles being traveled are up.
    • 01:16:19
      The number of cars registered in our state is up.
    • 01:16:22
      Gas tax revenues are down.
    • 01:16:24
      This is something that we're going to be focused on for the next session.
    • 01:16:28
      Yes, Mr. Peake.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:16:34
      You touched briefly on this about the large increase in construction funding.
    • 01:16:39
      The limited state of transportation revenues do not support the distribution of funds through the allocation formula.
    • 01:16:45
      Are we going to discuss this at some point in the future?
    • 01:16:48
      When do we anticipate we will have funds to go through the construction formula?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:54
      Is that just something that we're going to... Well, you know, actually I think...
    • 01:17:00
      We were heading in that direction and then the revenues fell off while it's put on the gas tax.
    • 01:17:07
      So there may be an opportunity next year in the six-year plan if revenues do continue in the right direction.
    • 01:17:16
      But we will continue facing challenges from all our revenue sources that go into the TTS and allow the allocations to occur.
    • 01:17:28
      And one of the other big things as well is the massive transfer of the TTF funds over to the maintenance fund.
    • 01:17:36
      If you just look at that as just simply a, it's a black hole that continues to grow in our capital account and we need to figure out how to fill that hole.
    • 01:17:49
      If that is, I mean you're thinking about, just think about what 500 million dollars would do
    • 01:17:54
      In the TTF, if we could stay in the TTF, you would see that formula grow.
    • 01:17:59
      I mean, the allocation and the distribution will grow pretty dramatically.
    • 01:18:05
      I guess we would like some kind of an update or a prognostication, yeah, a little bit more detail what's going to happen, what's funding with it.
    • 01:18:16
      Nothing's going to flow through the construction allocation formula.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:19
      How are we going to make sure it's evenly distributed?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:24
      I think it's one of the things that...
    • 01:18:29
      I just like to think about Fairfax County getting their thousand dollars last year.
    • 01:18:33
      It was evenly distributed.
    • 01:18:36
      But it raises some other issues.
    • 01:18:37
      I know some are concerned even about how we allocate the maintenance dollars.
    • 01:18:42
      The urban localities and the two counties, Kenoico and Arlington,
    • 01:18:49
      Obviously get dramatically more money per lane mile than the counties that may be there adjacent.
    • 01:18:59
      But we can come back and show you what the revenues would have to be at before the formulas start to flow, but the problem is
    • 01:19:08
      For it to flow to a number that actually makes an impact, it has to be fairly dramatic because it is distributed by the formula.
    • 01:19:20
      So you're going to end up seeing 10 million, 30 million distributed statewide, which means people get $1,000 checks.
    • 01:19:29
      And also begs the question as to whether it makes more sense for us to start to focus the limited dollars on real projects to get them done versus just sending out money like this.
    • 01:19:40
      Mr. Wayne?
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:19:41
      Yeah.
    • 01:19:42
      Along those lines, this will be the third budget I'll have.
    • 01:19:45
      I know we're mandated to have a balanced budget, but it seems to me that we never show
    • 01:19:51
      You know, what we're not doing.
    • 01:19:53
      In other words, if I were doing this budget and I would be looking at what, if there's real estate where I have to do and then I would then see what the revenues are needed.
    • 01:20:03
      We do it backwards.
    • 01:20:04
      We say, okay, we get these revenues and this is all we can do and it seems to be somewhat accepted.
    • 01:20:09
      How can we put with the budget what we are not doing?
    • 01:20:14
      In other words, what, get that in front of the General Assembly because,
    • 01:20:18
      You know, I hear, well, you balance it every year.
    • 01:20:20
      Well, of course, we balance it every year because we're mandated to do so, but we're not showing our unfunded liabilities.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:28
      Well, we have a difficult time identifying what our
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:20:32
      How do we, when we present this, and I know we were going to attempt last year at taking a look across the state and all the projects we had and what we weren't funding and stuff, but there seems to be, to us, to me, a comment upon us to show at least our job, whether they vote for it or not, is up to them, I guess.
    • 01:20:57
      Our job is to say this is what the ramifications are.
    • 01:21:00
      I know you guys do it, but I mean if it was in black and white, along with this budget, it would seem to me something that couldn't be ignored.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:09
      Well, we started, Mr. Chairman, we started down that road when I first got here with the resolution that was being debated and I think we sent to the General Assembly and we were, as I recall, we were not specific in numbers
    • 01:21:23
      I'm not clear whether that's our role or not, but I certainly think it should be that we say we're placed here to make sure that the state has a good road system and that we spend the citizens' money wisely.
    • 01:21:40
      To the extent that we're not able to provide that, how clear should we be, how clear is helpful to say
    • 01:21:49
      We've got this amount of unfunded things that we believe that we need to do and keep that front and center.
    • 01:21:58
      And I guess we could debate whether that's our role or not, but certainly I think it's incumbent on us because legislators have a tough, they're in a tough position.
    • 01:22:13
      Citizens want everything, and I include myself in that, and we don't want to pay for it.
    • 01:22:19
      It's helpful.
    • 01:22:21
      Often we don't want to pay for them.
    • 01:22:23
      It's helpful for us, I think, as a sort of independent body to be able to say this is what we see, this is what needs to be done, and to the extent that you don't want to do it, that's your decision, but we're going to keep telling you what's out there.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:40
      Mr. Chairman, I just wanted to second that.
    • 01:22:43
      I think that's extremely important, especially in the maintenance area.
    • 01:22:46
      We don't want to wait until people are falling down in bridges or something.
    • 01:22:50
      And we need to have the unvarnished stuff on maintenance where it may not be pretty.
    • 01:22:55
      But we need to take her to the General Assembly and say, look, here are the bridges that are going to fall in.
    • 01:23:02
      Here are the other problems that affect safety and the well-being of folks in the Commonwealth and lay it out there.
    • 01:23:11
      I think we owe it to the taxpayers and the general public.
    • 01:23:17
      Now, if there's not political will to deal with it, that's okay, but we've done our job as transportation folks of laying it out there, and I think, especially in the maintenance area, there's less
    • 01:23:33
      I don't think there's any kind of room to argue.
    • 01:23:35
      You can argue about the construction of a new project, whether that really makes sense or not, but it's hard to argue about maintenance if the bridge is going to fall down.
    • 01:23:44
      I mean, it's pretty objective.
    • 01:23:46
      So I think we maybe need to start there and maybe let's send a report over and lay it out.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:01
      Carrying their commitment to local governments is difficult.
    • 01:24:06
      Earlier this year, I told Fairfax County Board Chairman Sharon Guiloba that I did have her secondary road money, and it was in my wallet in one.
    • 01:24:17
      So we laughed about it, but it was unfortunate, obviously, that when you look at the six-year plan, you're talking about that that continues.
    • 01:24:26
      I do think that we
    • 01:24:27
      We do report to the General Assembly both on the vision side with our 2035 planning, for example, our state plan, so forth.
    • 01:24:36
      We are required by them to give them updates on needs.
    • 01:24:41
      Terrell has briefed us on that, that September report that says here's what's being undone.
    • 01:24:47
      But I think Mr. Layne is probably correct.
    • 01:24:49
      We don't necessarily capture that in our own budgeting process.
    • 01:24:54
      Now, part of this is
    • 01:24:55
      I think it's an unconstrained thought, but most of it is constrained.
    • 01:25:00
      It's what we can see readily available in terms of revenues based on current conditions and so forth.
    • 01:25:10
      Perhaps we ought to discuss this further, and you would have judgment about it whether unsolicited reports that we choose to give the assembly as opposed to simply meeting their reporting requirements, whether that would be a useful device.
    • 01:25:26
      Obviously, your judgment about that would be very important as well as the governor's, but I do think we have a story
    • 01:25:32
      to tell and that the public understanding of great unmet needs and the need for, as we talked about earlier, a sustained effort over time is really part of that.
    • 01:25:45
      The public sees what's being done and it's interesting, when they see an improvement, it sparks their interest in additional improvements because they see how it really does work to make their commute or their freight routing or whatever easier.
    • 01:26:00
      I was having the vision, has to answer that question that Mr. Peake brought up with, if I give you more money, what are you going to do with it?
    • 01:26:09
      If there's no understanding about how the money is going to be used, of course.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:14
      It's like somebody said, would you give me 20 bucks?
    • 01:26:16
      The first question is for what?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:18
      And so if there's not a for what that people can understand, then there's that reluctance to participate.
    • 01:26:23
      So somehow we, I think there's a, we're not chomping at the pit to be the legislature by any means, but I think there's an energy level here that we're willing to
    • 01:26:33
      To add something more to the process if it would be positive.
    • 01:26:37
      I think we all understand the last thing that's needed is a bunch more people whining about it or complaining about it or attacking each other about it.
    • 01:26:44
      We've got a bunch of those people at home and here in Richmond already.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:49
      Mr. Chairman.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:50
      Mr. King.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:51
      I think there would be some value just to the board in knowing where we are with bridges in particular if we wanted to take that topic.
    • 01:26:59
      And we have to have made some improvements because we've written a lot of contracts and spent a lot of arrow money on bridge improvements.
    • 01:27:08
      So from the time that we were talking about all the deficiencies and inefficiencies we've had on bridges, we've made improvements.
    • 01:27:16
      We probably, it would be well, we do have a nationally recognized bridge expert in our organization that other states rely on for bridge analysis and so forth, so it may be time for us to understand what is the status
    • 01:27:33
      A bridge is just as a special analysis for us to understand it as well.
    • 01:27:38
      And then when we have that report, if there's something very imminent coming out of it, then it will probably rise to the level of getting other people's attention.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:56
      On agreement with the comments, I think one of the things that we are, you know, this year's transportation conference which will be held in December in Norfolk, we will be focused on the maintenance issue and the funding and how the money, where the money comes from.
    • 01:28:23
      And so I think before we get to that we'll have the opportunity to walk through a whole bunch of issues with the board on the challenge we're facing.
    • 01:28:37
      One thing I think everyone has to maybe just keep in mind is that
    • 01:28:44
      The numbers, I mean sometimes I hate to say this to you, when we started running some of the numbers about this deficit issue, it's too big.
    • 01:28:58
      First off, it's hard to validate.
    • 01:29:00
      The second thing is that you start kicking around $18, $19 billion.
    • 01:29:07
      Pretty much everyone just starts to get glossy.
    • 01:29:10
      It's too big for us ever.
    • 01:29:14
      Just like dealing with when you've got a sandwich in front of you, you take one bite at a time.
    • 01:29:20
      And so obviously this year we looked at trying to infuse the program with capital to take advantage of what's happened in the market right now.
    • 01:29:31
      And we have outlined a strategy internally on where to go next year.
    • 01:29:39
      So we will have, I think September, we set aside maybe spending a day and then what we'll do for the board to spend a day going through some longer vision
    • 01:29:50
      Well, thank you very much, Ms. Lawson.
    • 01:29:58
      You did a great job.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:30:06
      All right.
    • 01:30:07
      Ms. Sorrell, maintenance.
    • 01:30:17
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:30:30
      The purpose of this presentation is to give an overview of the maintenance and operations program budget.
    • 01:30:37
      for the coming fiscal year.
    • 01:30:38
      So briefly, we're going to talk a little bit about the investment side of the budget, what some of the performance targets are for that side of the budget, some of the services, and then the proposed budget, including the process for how we put that budget together.
    • 01:30:56
      So as you may recall, the maintenance and operations program is broken into two subgroups, investments and services.
    • 01:31:05
      An investments arena is that area where we try to maintain and extend the useful life of core assets, including our pavements, bridges, emergency incident management technology, and traffic and safety attributes that are a part of the road system.
    • 01:31:23
      So under services we have the day-to-day housekeeping, emergency services and incident management work we do, the roadway work including pothole patching and safety and other types of things in terms of proposing signs.
    • 01:31:41
      doing safety studies.
    • 01:31:43
      Roadside work includes mowing grass and drainage, other types of off the pavement types of work and then the facilities including rest areas and all our administrative costs.
    • 01:32:00
      So just to give you a little bit sort of recap of where we are with paving.
    • 01:32:06
      As you know, we talked quite a bit about paving this morning, so I think that just from a mileage standpoint, it's very important to see the output that you're buying with all that additional money getting through the system and getting out the door, so you can see particularly
    • 01:32:23
      Not only is there an increase in interstate work from 2009, 10, and 11, but also significant increases in the primary and almost double the amount of work on the secondary system that has been under contract for this year.
    • 01:32:42
      So I think we will continue to see some good improvements in those areas.
    • 01:32:48
      Some time ago, the board adopted the following performance targets, which we've talked about, that at least 82% of the interstate payments be ranked fair or better, and also the same for the payments for primary, and that no less than 92% of our bridges be rated not structurally deficient.
    • 01:33:08
      In 2010, at the beginning of that biennium, we advised the board that we would meet the interstate performance target of 82 percent, excuse me, anticipated performance of interstate pavements at 82 percent, primary pavements at about 78 percent, and bridges at 91.5.
    • 01:33:27
      So, due to increased maintenance funds and including funding from ARRA and some six-year plan funding, we will meet the interstate pavement performance target of 82 percent by the end of June 2012.
    • 01:33:40
      We will have primary pavements at 80 percent.
    • 01:33:46
      So a little more of an improvement than what we had initially thought and that we will maintain the condition of secondary roads and we will meet 91% of the bridges not being structurally deficient.
    • 01:34:00
      So we are also saying that by June 30, 2013, we will meet our primary system pavement target and we are increasing our focus on improving the condition of secondary pavements.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:14
      Kai, I just want to make sure I understand that we are significantly, almost doubling
    • 01:34:24
      The second, the maintenance of the secondary system in 2011.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:34:32
      Yes, this really is the calendar year.
    • 01:34:35
      These are related to the contract.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:37
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:34:38
      It would be nice to note that that represents 37,000 miles off the roadway of the 57 that we have in the state.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:34:48
      Is that correct?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:49
      I'm sorry, there's about 80, 30, 37,000 miles of the 57,000.
    • 01:34:54
      Yes, of the centerline miles.
    • 01:34:56
      Yeah.
    • 01:34:57
      Yeah.
    • 01:34:58
      So by and large, more of the mileage is in the secondary system.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:35:04
      Yeah.
    • 01:35:04
      Of the centerline miles.
    • 01:35:05
      Thank you, Mr. K, that's a good point.
    • 01:35:06
      Yes, thank you.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:08
      Clarify that more.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:35:09
      Yes.
    • 01:35:10
      This is a chart of where we have been with our performance measures in the program and where we're headed.
    • 01:35:23
      This does show you the predicted values of where we expect to be in 2012 to meet the interstate target and in 2013.
    • 01:35:33
      The numbers for the 2011 payment ratings are not yet in, so they should be in by the end of July, and I should be able to come back and give you some better information about the secondary system in about the next 30 to 45 days.
    • 01:35:55
      So the next chart is just a chart of where we stand with our bridge performance.
    • 01:36:02
      And so you can see we've made, we're holding steady, we've made some very small incremental improvement, but we're right at the 82% target.
    • 01:36:13
      So just to talk very briefly about the other side of the maintenance house.
    • 01:36:20
      The services side of the house includes snow and ice, responding to floods and other weather related emergencies, pothole patching, mowing, cleaning pipes, ditching, operating the tunnels and the ferries, and our safety service patrols too mentioned
    • 01:36:34
      Just a few of the many things we do, and we have approximately 3,200 staff in the field that are performing these services, along with hired equipment and contractors.
    • 01:36:45
      And just to give you a little data about some of the work we've done, in FY 2010, our maintenance forces recorded over 200,000 work orders, and 64,000 of those were directly in response to citizen calls.
    • 01:37:01
      In 2011 through May 3 was still a couple months left to go.
    • 01:37:07
      We've already recorded 256,000 work orders that we've performed and 81,000 of those were in response to citizen calls.
    • 01:37:17
      You may remember we did a little marketing on our 1-800 telephone number for the call center and so we got some more business as a result of that marketing and more people know how to reach us.
    • 01:37:27
      And just to give you some of the top requests that citizens call us about, animals removal is one of them along with pothole patching and drainage problems and trees and limbs down in the middle of the road.
    • 01:37:42
      So pretty normal set of phone calls that we typically get.
    • 01:37:48
      The next slide shows you a little bit about the budgets from, it shows you what the 2010 carryover was, about $530 million.
    • 01:38:00
      We've been discussing that quite a bit.
    • 01:38:01
      And then the 2011 budget itself was $1.3 billion.
    • 01:38:05
      There were a number of adjustments due to some additional revenues.
    • 01:38:11
      And the final allocation is $1.8, $1.9 million.
    • 01:38:17
      So the 2012 allocation for this year, for the proposed budget for this year is $1.4 billion.
    • 01:38:25
      And I would point out that there are increases in all the payment categories as well as I would note that
    • 01:38:35
      Under the traffic and safety investment area, much of that money goes to the contracts for paving.
    • 01:38:42
      The numbers you see here are just the numbers for the asphalt portion of the contract.
    • 01:38:48
      The other portion of the contract that has to do with traffic control, striping, signing, guard rail is in that traffic and safety number.
    • 01:38:59
      All of that together adds up to the contracts that we are putting out for pavement improvement.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:05
      Mr. Chairman, could you tell us approximately what the carry forward will be for Twin Quill?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:39:18
      Yes, at this point it looks like it will be more than $500 million.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:23
      Okay, so do we have a projection
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:39:30
      Yes, we do have a projection, and we've been looking at that, looking at the expend plans by quarter, and we have that for the coming fiscal year.
    • 01:39:47
      We were off somewhat this past quarter because we really expected the industry to do a little more, and so we were thinking up until this last quarter that the balance might be down in the $400 to $450 million area, but it looks like it's going to be over $500 million again.
    • 01:40:07
      But based on the contracts being out and the work being done by December, we are projecting that at the end of 2012, it'll be down around $100 million, so we will have
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:17
      Just to make sure I'm clear, we're allocating for 2012 in this chart, I mean, a billion-four, and we have about 500 million that would be- In the carryover, yes.
    • 01:40:29
      It would be about a total of a billion-nine- Probably, yes.
    • 01:40:32
      That's authorized or whatever we call it.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:40:33
      Yes, and the difference between the budget, which is the 1.4 number, and the allocation, which includes the crossover, so the total allocation would be that 1.9.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:44
      The 1.9, right.
    • 01:40:46
      So of the 1.9 that we have available to spend in 2012, what's the projection of what we'll actually spend in 2012?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:40:56
      At this point, about 1.8.
    • 01:41:01
      We're going to get through this gut.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:03
      So that's what I think we ought to sort of be...
    • 01:41:07
      That's the real deal.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:41:09
      Yes, it is.
    • 01:41:10
      It's the real deal if you finally haven't gotten out on the street the backlog of contract funds.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:18
      There was an earlier slide in John's... You'll spend almost all your 2012 money.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:41:25
      and you'll spend all the rest of all of your of your 11 that's that's the plan that's perfect yes that's the plan good job thank you is that we have a good news just most of all of those contracts are get are out there so if we get that contract work done that really will be set up so that we have we're spending the money in the in the year in which we need to have it budgeted and we don't we won't have this backlog again
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:54
      That's the goal.
    • 01:42:12
      When you look at the maintenance budget, it's not doing that well just because most of our roads are secondary.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:42:20
      We don't have as many interstates.
    • 01:42:28
      Mr. Secretary, if I could just respond to that when I get to that.
    • 01:42:31
      I appreciate that.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:33
      That's good.
    • 01:42:34
      One other general question.
    • 01:42:36
      I mean, you've heard the private sector here say, you know, we've got serious problems out there, and I'm reading documents.
    • 01:42:43
      I don't have any independent analysis of whether they're accurate or not, but we have serious bridge problems, and we have serious maintenance problems.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:42:52
      Yes, that's part of the reports that are due to the General Assembly and we're working with the Secretary and his staff to get that information to the Board.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:17
      Do you think the observations of the private sector are pretty accurate on that?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:43:21
      Well, I think we know exactly where we stand in terms of what the pavement conditions are.
    • 01:43:26
      That shouldn't be a surprise to anyone.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:31
      What about bridges?
    • 01:43:33
      How do you look at bridges?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:43:35
      I think that we really ought to look at that data separately, just to say that we're doing okay now, but in the future, we need to look at what we need to be doing in the future, so that should be part of that report.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:47
      Mr. Chairman, I know that Mr.
    • 01:43:51
      Keen wanted a presentation on bridges.
    • 01:43:54
      I thought we could schedule that.
    • 01:43:57
      His comment was, what have we done over the last couple of years and kind of what's the trend?
    • 01:44:03
      And I thought we could schedule that as a separate presentation to the board to address the bridges.
    • 01:44:10
      Our target was 92, but at 91.7.
    • 01:44:13
      And we also have a breakdown by individual districts.
    • 01:44:19
      So we can get more into that in another presentation for the board that focuses just on bridges.
    • 01:44:26
      That would be very helpful.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:29
      Just want to get a clarification on what Mr. Rich was talking about.
    • 01:44:35
      The secondary system, the primary system, the interstate system,
    • 01:44:39
      We don't have a failing grade on those if we're saying we're 82 percent are fair or better or 92.
    • 01:44:50
      It's not that we're focusing on a calamity right now.
    • 01:44:54
      It's an improving process.
    • 01:44:55
      So I want to make sure in my mind that's what I'm hearing.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:44:59
      Yes.
    • 01:45:00
      Well, the 82% when it was set was thought to be sort of a national best practice.
    • 01:45:05
      It was where we were at that time, four or five years, five or six years ago, I believe it was when we set that number.
    • 01:45:12
      You know, that continues to be our target.
    • 01:45:15
      And the secondary system just continues to be an issue.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:18
      Well, should we be looking at a higher target, though?
    • 01:45:22
      Is that number still viable as a ranking?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:45:26
      Yes.
    • 01:45:27
      We think it is.
    • 01:45:28
      We've been doing some more work in that area as well.
    • 01:45:31
      So, you know, I've also had people ask the reverse.
    • 01:45:34
      Sure.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:35
      How do we really know?
    • 01:45:36
      I mean, that bridge fell down in Minneapolis.
    • 01:45:39
      I guess that wasn't an adjustment.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:45:40
      Well, the chief engineer tells me we close them before we let them fall down.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:51
      Well, I mean, the Minneapolis bridge actually never showed up as being structurally deficient.
    • 01:46:02
      No, it didn't.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:04
      I think back on secondary roads, it's just kind of a hit or miss analysis, as I understand.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:18
      They come out and look at every bridge.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:25
      Every bridge gets inspected thoroughly every three years.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:46:31
      We do have an analysis process that I have talked about before.
    • 01:46:36
      We can do something about coming back to the board and demonstrating what we do to rate pavements and how we determine what the condition of the system is.
    • 01:46:45
      It's very analytic and it's been reviewed by the auditor public accounts.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:49
      On the secondary system, we do look at about 20% of the roads and do an actual inspection of that and project the results to the population as a whole.
    • 01:47:04
      I think you can see through the budgets, we were trying to put more emphasis on the secondary system.
    • 01:47:12
      And in addition to that, in the six-year program, we did put more money, and you'll see that in a later presentation, about $100 million more into the secondary road.
    • 01:47:23
      So we recognize that we need to improve.
    • 01:47:27
      We are trying to hold ground.
    • 01:47:29
      We've lost some ground.
    • 01:47:30
      So now what we're doing is trying
    • 01:47:32
      to hold ground on the secondary system while improving the interstate and primary and then to focus real hard on bringing those secondary roads, the conditions up.
    • 01:47:46
      So that's kind of the strategy right now and you'll see that throughout the budget.
    • 01:47:51
      You'll see this year's budget is increased.
    • 01:47:54
      So hopefully we'll start seeing that change in the future.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:58
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • 01:48:02
      Ms. Sorrell, I was thinking about Mr. Layne's sort of response or reaction to Mr. Rich's comments earlier about interstates and he was referring to, I know, partly referring to interstates and Hampton Roads because
    • 01:48:20
      If you look at 64 and 264, they can be in pretty bad shape a lot of the times.
    • 01:48:29
      When we look at this 82 number, it's obviously a statewide number, and you could have a scenario where one place was 100%, and the other place was 50%.
    • 01:48:42
      So how do we sort of, in our analysis, in terms of getting the 82, I might make the case that everything
    • 01:48:51
      should be 82 or better.
    • 01:48:53
      Every section or however you would divide it up should be 82 or better and the fact that overall we're 82% is not necessarily, which should not necessarily be the goal.
    • 01:49:08
      Maybe the goal should be
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:49:09
      I can tell you that when I took this job back in 2005, there was a pretty large disparity between districts in their pavement conditions.
    • 01:49:27
      And over the last six years, we have worked very hard to try and provide to those districts that were in the state of greater despair, they were the ones getting the increases and other districts were being held to their budgets.
    • 01:49:44
      And so, over those five or six years, we have almost gotten to the point where we are at almost every district being at 82%.
    • 01:49:50
      One of the difficulties in Hampton Roads, I do think there are some fairly large contracts that are
    • 01:49:57
      Schedule II go out, and in Hampton Roads, it's not always just the number of miles that are deficient, but the type of pavement in Hampton Roads, the last of some of the worst concrete pavements, which are extremely difficult to maintain.
    • 01:50:14
      Once they start going bad, they just go bad in a big way.
    • 01:50:21
      We have done an annual payment report and it shows where each district stands on each system.
    • 01:50:28
      I think that would be very instructive.
    • 01:50:30
      The report is on our website.
    • 01:50:36
      The report that's there now has the data from the last year's analysis.
    • 01:50:42
      We're getting in the last report late September, early August, so we should have some better information.
    • 01:50:49
      I could be one of those people that would call in to the number and tell you where it is.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:51:07
      Therein lies the issue of the pavement at Hampton Roads because is it a construction project or is it a maintenance project?
    • 01:51:22
      And because the roadbed or the cement I am told is so deficient, that is why there has been reluctance to pavement, yet the road continues to deteriorate.
    • 01:51:32
      And that's where, you know, that I was coming from about the interstate maintenance, you know, is where are we going to address it?
    • 01:51:39
      I mean, it costs a lot of money, you know, but it doesn't matter.
    • 01:51:44
      It's still the roads going away.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:51:46
      Yes.
    • 01:51:46
      Well, I think that the difference between, you know, we don't rebuild bridges in the maintenance program.
    • 01:51:51
      And so when there are major roadways that have become so structurally efficient that they need to be reconstructed.
    • 01:51:58
      then that really is where they belong is in the construction program and under Mr. Whirley and the Secretary's leadership I think it was two years ago we started putting money I believe beginning in 2015 to address those major reconstruction projects that ought to be in the construction program there rather than trying to do those figure out how to do those programs with the maintenance funds that we have available.
    • 01:52:24
      So there are some funds.
    • 01:52:26
      I got it.
    • 01:52:26
      I'm just saying that as you do that, the roads are getting worse and worse.
    • 01:52:33
      Yes, that's an excellent point.
    • 01:52:34
      And so moving along, just the next slide, number 11, 12, excuse me, is just a very quick slide to give you an overview of how we develop the budget.
    • 01:52:44
      First of all, we have our goals in terms of maintaining and extending the useful life of core assets with our performance standards.
    • 01:52:52
      And then we also have goals around our really first primary call is being able to respond to emergencies, to be able to handle incident management and responding to citizens and performing the ordinary maintenance that we know contributes to the everyday safety of motorists on the road.
    • 01:53:11
      So in looking at the budgets and looking at our analysis that we have from pavements and bridges and other analysis we have about other inventories and their conditions, we work with district and central office program managers to develop a budget scenario to try and meet the needs and the categories to the extent that we can.
    • 01:53:31
      and then the districts are given a budget allocation and they actually go through and build a detailed budget to show where their money, where they think the money ought to go.
    • 01:53:42
      We do a review of that compared to the scenario and to make sure that the money really is being budgeted where the needs are and then the proposed budget is approved by myself, the deputy and the commissioner for presentation today.
    • 01:53:56
      So there have been a tremendous number of eyes and all the districts
    • 01:53:59
      have been intimately involved in the development of these budgets and so they have an opportunity to come and make a case of what they need and where they need it and we listen to those requests and do the allocations based on that.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:19
      As I understand what you've explained is they make an appeal for an allocation.
    • 01:54:26
      And they give you a list of things they'd like to do, but can you give them an allocation at next dollars and then they go back and develop the plan?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:54:33
      Yes, and then if they have an issue that they've got a particular problem that they can't resolve within that proposed allocation, then we go back and look to see whether there are any adjustments that need to be made.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:44
      So, as we vote on this tomorrow, there's really not a budget in place in each district on how they're going to spend this money for today's vote.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:54:54
      Yes, they've had these draft budgets for over 30 days, 45 days, something like that.
    • 01:55:01
      I mean, we've been working on these budgets since last January.
    • 01:55:03
      So they have a draft budget.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:07
      We'll be approving it with this vote.
    • 01:55:09
      Yes, they know exactly what it is.
    • 01:55:11
      And each district then has that budget.
    • 01:55:15
      Yes.
    • 01:55:15
      Okay, they've had input.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:17
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:55:17
      None of that's why.
    • 01:55:19
      Yes.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:55:20
      Yes.
    • 01:55:21
      And so the next slide just shows you how much money is going to interstate, primary, secondary to break out to show that there are increases.
    • 01:55:31
      Because of the amount of increase that we got for this fiscal year, we've done significant increases in interstate primary, secondary, and operations, and we decreased management and direction substantially.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:47
      So... Mr. Chairman, I was getting to my question.
    • 01:55:50
      I've seen that these were listed, but my question really centers around any local input in this maintenance.
    • 01:55:57
      budget development in terms of anybody other than just a local staff.
    • 01:56:03
      I don't think the board members are involved or any review of any request or any involvement in here's what we need specifically on the maintenance side.
    • 01:56:12
      We do on the construction side as having input on what might really should get attention in a
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:56:19
      This has been the district and the district administrators and their staffs being involved in this, so happy to talk more about that.
    • 01:56:37
      So in slide 14, you'll see for each of the districts what their allocations were in June of 11 and what the allocations that are proposed for today are.
    • 01:56:51
      In response to Mr. Rich's question about Culpeper particularly, Culpeper is a very small district.
    • 01:56:58
      It has about half of the number of
    • 01:56:59
      area counties that most of the other districts have.
    • 01:57:04
      Culpeper and Fredericksburg are both much smaller in geographic area and mileage than most of the other districts.
    • 01:57:12
      And I would say Culpeper also had some of the best pavements in the state.
    • 01:57:16
      So from an interstate primary segue, they have very good pavements.
    • 01:57:23
      And I can show you that report, district by district.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:25
      There's a little different story from the private sector that's out on the ground.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:57:29
      Yes, they definitely would like to have more work.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:57:33
      Mr. Secretary, along with Mr. Rich and my folks in Lynchburg, the same situation and then we have a pretty large geographic district.
    • 01:57:43
      We went to the meeting in Salem and they just held up, some of my contractors held up the packets of Bristol.
    • 01:57:52
      and then ours, and just the thickness is dramatic.
    • 01:57:59
      And that's part of the money not flowing through maybe the formula, however, and I know maintenance doesn't, but to make sure it's more evenly distributed.
    • 01:58:10
      Lynchburg, and the Salem District gets a lot of money as well.
    • 01:58:15
      We have a very active group who's very concerned about the disparity and how the money is being spent.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:58:21
      Yes, I'd be happy to, I think it would be very instructive to see the payment reports conditions district by district and system by system to see how they compare.
    • 01:58:30
      So a big driver of the budgets, particularly the investment budget, are the payment conditions.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:37
      Well, we've got people in good shape.
    • 01:58:39
      Yes.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:58:40
      Yes.
    • 01:58:40
      Well, your district has done a very good job.
    • 01:58:43
      Good job.
    • 01:58:43
      Yeah.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:44
      Mm-hmm.
    • 01:58:45
      Mr. Chairman, there isn't some of this because most of these are secondary roads in our two districts.
    • 01:58:49
      We don't have a lot of interstate.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:58:51
      Well, Lynchburg has no interstate.
    • 01:58:53
      Right.
    • 01:58:54
      So...
    • 01:58:54
      So... Yeah.
    • 01:58:55
      And you have a small amount.
    • 01:58:57
      A small amount.
    • 01:58:58
      Yeah.
    • 01:58:58
      So we've got tons of secondary.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:00
      Yeah.
    • 01:59:00
      So you're getting the message.
    • 01:59:01
      Yeah.
    • 01:59:01
      I can show you.
    • 01:59:03
      Yeah.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 01:59:03
      Good.
    • 01:59:03
      Yeah.
    • 01:59:04
      I hear it.
    • 01:59:05
      The next slide is very instructive.
    • 01:59:10
      If you look at the $366 million that go to the cities that are in each of the districts and you add that to their budget, you see the total picture of funding going to maintenance of $1.7 billion.
    • 01:59:27
      And so one of the things that obviously sticks out is that Hampton Roads, because of the
    • 01:59:33
      A lot of the money goes to cities for city street maintenance payments in Hampton Roads.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:45
      That's the end of my presentation.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:00:01
      Mike, can I ask everyone to please take your seats while the board is eating.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:12
      We've got quite a few other presentations going through and then obviously the main meeting.
    • 02:00:16
      So we're just going to go ahead and Mr. Sherr, sorry to catch you, but are you, you're up next on the six-year plan?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:24
      Which item am I, am I for or on here?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:00:50
      I can't tell.
    • 02:01:02
      Okay.
    • 02:01:03
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, we're bringing back today the proposed final six-year improvement program for fiscal year 12 through 17.
    • 02:01:17
      This first slide you've seen before.
    • 02:01:20
      It's been updated this time.
    • 02:01:23
      with showing the draft and then the final.
    • 02:01:27
      There is approximately a $200 million increase here and I'll talk about that going forward.
    • 02:01:36
      A large component of that is revenue sharing, the additional money we placed in revenue sharing which also includes the match from the locality.
    • 02:01:48
      So we've gone from approximately $10.4 billion
    • 02:01:53
      compared to last year's 7.8 to 10.6 billion in the final.
    • 02:01:59
      As it breaks down by system, interstate, primary, secondary, and urban, we've seen a slight increase in the primary and the secondary.
    • 02:02:12
      Again, that's coming from revenue sharing for the most part, and the rest of the balances are the same as in the draft.
    • 02:02:21
      We actually make very few changes other than revenue sharing between the draft and the final.
    • 02:02:30
      I had this slide in the draft presentation in April.
    • 02:02:35
      The only thing on this slide that has changed was the additional CPR bonds that we programmed from the May bond sale where we received an additional $48.6 million and VDOT was a recipient of approximately
    • 02:02:55
      The priorities for the development of VDOT six-year programs
    • 02:03:14
      These haven't changed.
    • 02:03:16
      I just show them again to highlight them.
    • 02:03:20
      Funding deficits, underway projects, maximizing federal funds for federal strategy, keeping project phases underway, and focusing on deficient bridges and pavements, as you all have been discussing earlier today.
    • 02:03:35
      We did, as I said before, put some additional money in preliminary engineering to start some shelf projects, and we have funding in here related to, from the governor's program, the bond proceeds that we're showing for the development of PPTA.
    • 02:03:54
      We're trying to accelerate existing projects and looking at redirecting inactive balances on projects as we go forward.
    • 02:04:08
      As I indicated before, we did program the Federal Revenue Reserve for all six years, and we have talked about that being a little over $500 million.
    • 02:04:19
      We're no longer using CPR bonds to match federal dollars.
    • 02:04:25
      We're doing that with a toll credit, or what is commonly known as soft match.
    • 02:04:31
      We did program the CPR bonds and the GARVEE bonds over the
    • 02:04:36
      The six-year program, each of those bonds will be issued in three-year series.
    • 02:04:43
      Again, the state construction formula allocation continues to be suspended based on lack of available state funds.
    • 02:04:54
      At this time, we're not representing anything for the Virginia Transportation Infrastructure Bank.
    • 02:05:04
      that the proceeds for that is actually will be represented in previous dollars allocations prior to 12 through 17, but that hasn't been established yet.
    • 02:05:17
      Okay, the specific changes that relate to from the draft that I presented in April to this final.
    • 02:05:26
      Some things that changed related to public hearing activity.
    • 02:05:32
      Discussions with some CTB members and some federal strategy items.
    • 02:05:39
      And the number one dollar change is we actually funded revenue sharing projects totaling 103.4 million between
    • 02:05:53
      fiscal year 12 and 13 and we also showed 103.4 million match.
    • 02:06:00
      So we used the budget allocation of 50 million from 12 and 50 million in 13 and we redirected an additional 3.4 million to get a total of 103.4 million from VDOT and 103.4 million in match.
    • 02:06:21
      And as I said, we were beneficiaries of some of the PPR bond premiums from the sale in May, and we allocated that to the PPPA initiative, UPC, and that was approximately $36.8 million.
    • 02:06:39
      The balance went to DRPT.
    • 02:06:42
      We also received the final information on residue parcel funding and programmed that in the final, about $1.1 million.
    • 02:06:55
      We finalized our work on the C-MAX programming submitted by the MPOs based on the CTB guidelines, so we were able to finish that between the draft and the final.
    • 02:07:10
      One of the public hearing projects was UPC-81-642.
    • 02:07:16
      Bass County had allocated some funding on their drainage improvement project and we finished funding that project.
    • 02:07:27
      That was actually on the governor's list that wasn't able to be funded in the first round and they put
    • 02:07:34
      About $350,000 on that, so we balanced that project out in the final for construction.
    • 02:07:42
      There was also a project that came up in the, I think it was the Richmond Public Hearing about the replacement of the Amelia Street Bridge in Blackstone and the locality put some of their funding on the project and so we completed
    • 02:08:04
      That project as well.
    • 02:08:06
      What we ended up putting on that was about $600,000 on that project.
    • 02:08:13
      We also funded the I-66 multimodal study project, and that was a bonus to our federal strategy impact.
    • 02:08:25
      The FHWA didn't allow us to use the earmark that we had originally set aside for that study, so we found the funding for that between the draft and the final.
    • 02:08:37
      Another governor's project.
    • 02:08:41
      related to the route 277 project on the governor's list.
    • 02:08:47
      We had to end up doing an interchange relocation study at exit 307 on 81 and we included that in the final as well.
    • 02:09:00
      And another item from public hearings and it was on the governor's list was a reconstruction of a route 619 in Wythe County.
    • 02:09:11
      We also funded the debt reimbursement on two projects, one in Winchester and one in Fredericksburg.
    • 02:09:21
      They were holdovers from when the debt that was to be paid back through urban allocations.
    • 02:09:29
      We believed it was appropriate to go ahead and take care of those debt reimbursements since the urban allocation.
    • 02:09:37
      probably won't be occurring for a year or two into the future.
    • 02:09:44
      Then we made some minor estimate changes that we covered.
    • 02:09:48
      There were minor estimate changes that we covered on some projects that were already in the program and we benefited from that for help to increase our strategy.
    • 02:10:02
      That in a nutshell is
    • 02:10:04
      Where the final six-year program is, I'll be happy to answer any questions.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:10:21
      It's fair to say then that the changes were basically additions.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:10:25
      Well, not additional funding except for revenue sharing funds were in the budget, but until the projects were assigned, then they were added to the program along with the allocations.
    • 02:10:38
      But these projects, it was not new money, it was money that was shifted in the program, but they were additions.
    • 02:10:45
      Actually, some of these projects were already in the program as well.
    • 02:10:49
      They just, we completed the funding on the construction phases.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:10:53
      I mean, but there were no reductions in funding.
    • 02:10:55
      Absolutely, no.
    • 02:10:56
      These are all additions, and that's why I wanted to get to that point.
    • 02:10:59
      No.
    • 02:11:00
      Good, very good.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:02
      I'm sorry, I just want to, the revenue sharing then, we don't actually include those in the six-year plan, or do we?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:11:07
      We do, we do.
    • 02:11:09
      The reason it wasn't in the draft is because of the timing of the approval of the project.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:14
      Why not?
    • 02:11:15
      But the other $50 million in additional projects, that is now, they've all been...
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:11:21
      They're all in the program.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:23
      Yes, Jeremy Koelemay.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:25
      Ms. Busher, you mentioned one of, at least in one case, the locality had increased its contribution to a project.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:11:32
      They moved it off another project that was complete and put it on this project to help move it forward.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:38
      Okay, so that wasn't then a trend that if a locality stepped forward to put some additional funds in sort of the importance of the project.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:11:46
      I don't believe so.
    • 02:11:47
      I think both of those were
    • 02:11:50
      Thank you very much.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:01
      Thank you.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:12:09
      The Commissioner may want to add to my initial comments, but as we negotiate the contracts with each of the private sector partners and we reach our financial arrangement and the comprehensive agreement,
    • 02:12:29
      Then those subsidies will be finalized and actually transferred from the PPTA initiative, UPC, which is a holding pot, if you will, to the specific project.
    • 02:12:47
      Those would be transfers that would come back to the CTB.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:53
      Any further questions?
    • 02:12:57
      Mr. Chairman?
    • 02:12:57
      On the PPTA, there's a figure in there.
    • 02:13:04
      What is our view of what that figure stands for now as far as projects?
    • 02:13:08
      We had to have some idea of what that was to make the direct profit of what those projects would be.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:17
      Mr. Chairman, we have
    • 02:13:21
      We identified a number of projects.
    • 02:13:25
      The primary projects, the key projects that we were looking at was the Midtown Tunnel Project, the 495 Project, and the tunnel.
    • 02:13:42
      Elizabeth River, Connaughton.
    • 02:13:46
      So those were the primary ones that we were looking at, but we had a part of it be cold field.
    • 02:13:52
      But it's a little bit fluid because we're trying to make certain that we're using the bond money, the CPR bond money, and the GARBE bond money correctly.
    • 02:14:05
      But those are the major projects that we actually have done.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:08
      So if you put all those in there, maybe 460 or something, that would give them all the money.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:12
      I'm sorry, I should have mentioned Force Base Area as well.
    • 02:14:15
      That will be in there and we'll try to work out exactly how much from each one of those projects would be needed.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:23
      They're all pretty big projects, so there probably wouldn't be anything left over, correct?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:27
      They're big projects, and the money that we have identified, it will be challenging to meet all of the needs.
    • 02:14:38
      But we are looking at a number of techniques to do that.
    • 02:14:43
      We have been working with the Secretary on our infrastructure bank.
    • 02:14:46
      We're still working through that process.
    • 02:14:49
      There is the ability to leverage money there.
    • 02:14:52
      That we haven't finalized at this point, which would probably give us a little bit more flexibility, but we're still working through the details.
    • 02:15:01
      Then you have the 1.1 billion, I think it's 1.1.
    • 02:15:06
      Thank you, sir.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:09
      I've got two other quick questions.
    • 02:15:15
      One, on the revenue sharing, what if you have a situation where they can't meet the match?
    • 02:15:22
      How long do you keep that sitting there so it moves on to something where you can actually do something?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:15:30
      There is a timeline associated on the revenue sharing in terms of how long the funding can be sitting there and that's reviewed by staff and then they would look to move that to another qualifying project.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:48
      Do you know what that time period is?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:15:50
      I think it's three years.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:52
      They have three years to tie it up though?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:15:55
      Yes, but when they apply for those funds, they've indicated that they would have the ability to match it.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:06
      Do we have a lot of those funds just sitting there waiting on the three-year period?
    • 02:16:11
      Do we not?
    • 02:16:12
      Maybe you could, you may not know now.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:16:14
      I don't know that today.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:16
      Can you let us know?
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:16:18
      Yes.
    • 02:16:18
      That would be helpful.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:20
      Yeah.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:16:21
      And my colleague has a follow-up question.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:23
      Sure.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:24
      I apologize.
    • 02:16:26
      I can address part of that, or at least in specific cases, is the money's going to be sitting there, but when a lot of communities are going to apply for revenue sharing,
    • 02:16:35
      that initiates the project, you've got to get through your design, get your approvals right away.
    • 02:16:40
      So three years is actually a pretty accelerated pace for any, I mean, look at the projects that are in here now.
    • 02:16:47
      If you're just starting one of these projects that we funded, just the general projects, not revenue sharing, you get them done within three years, we're going to go good.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:59
      I understand you ought to do PE and all that, but how do we detect situations like we had an enhancement situation where they just don't have the money?
    • 02:17:08
      It's just not coming forward.
    • 02:17:10
      Do we zero in on that somehow?
    • 02:17:12
      Obviously, they've got to have time to do PE.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:17:14
      Well, there's ongoing communications between district staff and local assistance with the recipients of those grant funds.
    • 02:17:24
      I would assume that that locality would be sharing that they're in a bind in terms of the match and those particular projects would normally be communicated with a CTB member in that area to determine if it needs to be moved or put on another project.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:43
      I don't remember.
    • 02:17:45
      I don't know that that's a prevalent issue at all.
    • 02:17:55
      We do program a big state match.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:18:10
      I'm sorry, I didn't hear the question, but I'm coming up anyway.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:19
      I'm waiting.
    • 02:18:20
      I'm buying time.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:21
      I'm buying time until the person who knows the answer can get here.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:18:26
      But Mr. Rich, if we do the project, the local government is required to pay the money over to us before we even start the project.
    • 02:18:33
      And then if they're doing the project, it's on a reimbursement basis.
    • 02:18:37
      And we provide, there is a three-year period in which they can, you know, construct the project.
    • 02:18:42
      But usually most of those projects, now occasionally there'll be some that they'll ask to deallocate and move the money to another project.
    • 02:18:50
      But we have very few instances where they're sitting on that money.
    • 02:18:55
      Okay, that's good to know.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:57
      Mr. Garczynski?
    • 02:18:58
      Secretary, separate question.
    • 02:19:00
      So I know Rita has this right off the top of her head.
    • 02:19:03
      The I-66 Multimodal, what's the number?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:19:10
      4 million.
    • 02:19:11
      4 million, okay, thank you.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:13
      See that, I knew she had it right on top of her.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:19:18
      Some of the projects that were originally identified as an illustrative list didn't make it into the plan.
    • 02:19:25
      Is there a process in place or do we have a process that how those monies become available, how they're going to be put in the plan?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:19:35
      Well, we have those projects obviously from the original list and as we save funding on construction projects or other areas of a project with good bids
    • 02:19:49
      We'll just, and it depends on what system it's on, we may try to go by system, but we have projects on the list that we'll
    • 02:20:02
      Look at, depending on how much money is available at what time and actually it will be when the project is ready.
    • 02:20:10
      So it will be very much dependent on the schedule of the project that we would like to move that surplus to.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:20:17
      So basically the staff, you guys will say we have money and this is an appropriate project?
    • 02:20:22
      In conjunction with the district.
    • 02:20:23
      Yeah, with different places.
    • 02:20:24
      So it's safe to say we should ask our, if the people are interested, they should keep their projects moving along.
    • 02:20:29
      More shovel-ready they are, the better.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:41
      Pusha, thank you very much.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:43
      DRPT.
    • 02:20:43
      This will be a fast one.
    • 02:20:46
      I couldn't tell what this thing is.
    • 02:20:47
      I saw it on the stand by.
    • 02:20:49
      Heartland Corridor Project.
    • 02:20:51
      What is that?
    • 02:20:53
      Well, that's perfect.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:20:54
      That's perfect segue.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:20:58
      Pusha, thank you very much.
    • 02:21:03
      Was there a question?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:04
      I'm sorry.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:15
      What did you want to know?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:21:18
      What is it?
    • 02:21:19
      It was a double stack container for a freight railroad from the port all the way out through Ohio for north and southern.
    • 02:21:28
      Yeah, it's completed and operational.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:30
      Okay, thank you.
    • 02:21:31
      Appreciate it.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:21:33
      And I'm going to, the Chairman, if I may, I'd like to take a moment in Director Drake's absence to introduce our new Chief of Public Transportation.
    • 02:21:44
      His name is Bob Wilson.
    • 02:21:48
      He's sitting right here.
    • 02:21:50
      He's joined us last Thursday.
    • 02:21:52
      He has over 20 years experience in the transportation field.
    • 02:21:57
      Most recently, we took serious
    • 02:22:00
      The Chairman's push to work with our MPOs and most recently he is Executive Director of the George Washington Regional Commission which handles the planning activities in the Fredericksburg area and surrounding counties.
    • 02:22:15
      Before that he was the Executive Director of a Planning Commission in Stamford, Connecticut and prior to that he was Executive Director of a Commuter Assistance Organization in Long Island.
    • 02:22:27
      He currently resides in Fredericksburg with his family and
    • 02:22:31
      At this time, I'd like to welcome him aboard.
    • 02:22:33
      I'm definitely happy to have him.
    • 02:22:35
      I think he's going to be a great asset for us.
    • 02:22:37
      Bob.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:43
      Thank you, Steve.
    • 02:22:44
      Gentlemen, I just want to tell you I'm looking forward to working with all of you in the years to come, and I look forward to getting to know you.
    • 02:22:51
      So please don't hesitate to call me or email me at DRPT.
    • 02:22:55
      I don't know how long it'll be before I can actually tell you something that's of any value, but it's being day five today, but I'll work on that, so thank you very much.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:03
      So this point forward, we can forward all calls and emails from you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:07
      Yes, correct.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:23:22
      All right, I'm going to take a moment to just give a brief update on a six-year improvement plan for DRPT and then have a few slides on our budget, both items that are recommended for y'all's approval later today.
    • 02:23:37
      And a lot of these slides are repetitive from what we looked at two months ago, so I won't spend a lot of time, but these are the sort of three big points on our six-year program.
    • 02:23:49
      We do show an unfunded
    • 02:23:52
      need for our passenger, intercity passenger rail operations of $110 million.
    • 02:23:57
      Mr.
    • 02:23:59
      Page is going to be giving you all an update on the Section 209 PREA requirements, which is a big part of that unfunded item there after this presentation.
    • 02:24:11
      So we're still deliberating a little bit on that number and trying to work with
    • 02:24:18
      Amtrack as far as what that dollar amount will be exactly but that's our best guess right now and that's what we put into the plan.
    • 02:24:25
      We did get a fund established but the fund doesn't have a permanent source of funding so it's something hopefully in the next General Assembly session we can focus on.
    • 02:24:34
      We do have a revenue uptick of about 17% and that also resulted in our operating share
    • 02:24:42
      Moving up from a historical low last year of 14.5% to 17.5% this year.
    • 02:24:49
      We didn't see the recovery in recordation tax and gas prices went up quite a bit earlier this year.
    • 02:24:56
      They've come back down a little bit.
    • 02:24:59
      If they go back to that $4 range, we don't think that we didn't quite see in the application process this year the full impact.
    • 02:25:07
      at that $4 level.
    • 02:25:09
      So next year we have that concern looming of the impact of the gas prices.
    • 02:25:14
      Yes?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:15
      Your first bullet up there and the elements within are kind of concerning.
    • 02:25:18
      We've got $110 million funding gap.
    • 02:25:21
      No revenue source.
    • 02:25:23
      What's our plan?
    • 02:25:24
      We need to come up with a plan, otherwise we're going to stand around passing a cup around this table and I don't have $110 million.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:25:31
      It begins in 2013 and then it kind of escalates for a couple of years.
    • 02:25:36
      What's our plan?
    • 02:25:37
      We really don't have a plan.
    • 02:25:39
      The code allows taking some funding off the top, but that's taking money from VDOT, and it's not really, to me, a good plan.
    • 02:25:48
      So the plan is we've got to get a funding source in this coming General Assembly session, such as... Well, we... Don't you say nothing.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:59
      Okay.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:26:00
      We did do a study, I guess, that...
    • 02:26:03
      That's out there that people can look at.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:04
      This is, I mean, we obviously asked for the establishment of this fund.
    • 02:26:11
      Now we're working through what the actual needs are going to be because we're not quite sure what the number is from Amtrak and or whether there will be modifications to the federal law.
    • 02:26:24
      Because we're like the only state that seems to be getting ready for this by even establishing this fund.
    • 02:26:32
      So there is some conjecture out there that they may not, that Congress may set back the date.
    • 02:26:38
      We don't know.
    • 02:26:40
      We want to be ready.
    • 02:26:41
      We established the fund.
    • 02:26:43
      We're looking at options to make recommendations to the General Assembly regarding this.
    • 02:26:49
      That will come from the Governor's office.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:52
      Do I understand then that this is all the result of the federal government pushing on to us this funding responsibility?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:57
      Yes.
    • 02:26:58
      This is all about under the statute essentially if we want regional service, at least these are trains that would not otherwise stop in Virginia, to stop in Virginia.
    • 02:27:11
      that we're going to have to pick up a certain amount of the capital costs and certainly operating as well.
    • 02:27:18
      Operating is the majority of it actually.
    • 02:27:20
      So this is all the federal government's one way to get the burden of Amtrak off their back is to put it onto ours.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:31
      And I'm willing to bet we have no ability to change the rates of Amtrak in order to fund this.
    • 02:27:37
      We've got to come up with a source on that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:39
      We've got to come up with our, I mean again, we've established the fund, a big step forward and we always as a CTB have the ability if there is a major problem to move funds, a certain amount of funds anyway within the CTF.
    • 02:27:56
      Steve, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:07
      These are the lines that we have to take over at a certain date, lines specific.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:28:19
      It's the two train, it's the Lynchburg train, and then it's the
    • 02:28:24
      Richmond Train, which will be extended to Norfolk hopefully in a year, year and a half, plus four trains that currently, two start in Hampton Roads, Newport News, and two start in Richmond.
    • 02:28:36
      So it's taking over those four, plus it's, to some degree, it's the two we started.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:41
      There's a date certain right now, though, right, that that has to happen.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:28:45
      Yes, and I don't, Kevin is going to give a very detailed presentation on section 209, so I don't know the exact date.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:52
      Yeah, but I think I remember you guys talking about that.
    • 02:28:55
      Thank you.
    • 02:28:55
      Mr. Chairman, isn't it correct that the instrument train pays for itself?
    • 02:29:01
      Is that an accurate statement?
    • 02:29:04
      It's sort of.
    • 02:29:04
      It's sort of.
    • 02:29:05
      It's sort of.
    • 02:29:05
      We're actually using some of that money to subsidize the original train.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:29:09
      That's the way the contract was written.
    • 02:29:10
      If you put in the capital costs that were incurred
    • 02:29:14
      I would say as a finance professional it isn't paying for itself.
    • 02:29:20
      So we spent some money outside of operations.
    • 02:29:24
      Operationally is covering its funding gap but there are capital costs that are going to come up and that has to come from somewhere.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:42
      But in summary, the plan to answer the original question is that you expect to go forward
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:51
      Well, the executive branch, the governor's office would look to potentially go forward with its recommendations, which is separate from this one.
    • 02:30:20
      I'm not quite sure where we'll be.
    • 02:30:27
      I think obviously, well, this is a separate entity that, you know, I mean, we are, the governor's office, I'm in the governor's office and the governor makes its own recommendations to the General Assembly.
    • 02:30:46
      Part of that are agency bills, that this could potentially be something under that, but then even the agency bills are clear to the Governor's Office.
    • 02:30:56
      The CTB, I don't believe has the ability to actually send its own recommendations to the General Assembly.
    • 02:31:07
      We have the First Amendment.
    • 02:31:09
      You always have the First Amendment, you're always welcome to see, obviously they're your legislators.
    • 02:31:14
      But under the Constitution, obviously, the governor has the ability to even introduce bills on his own, as well as to fund sponsors for bills and whichever.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:26
      But I think my central point is that we hope to solve this problem in the next session of the agenda.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:31:32
      And I'll add, Mr. McCarthy, through negotiation, as the chairman pointed out, that's ongoing right now with Amtrak.
    • 02:31:39
      I think we feel it's going positive as far as that number goes.
    • 02:31:46
      It's all the trains that start in Virginia.
    • 02:31:55
      It's all the regional service.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:31:59
      Yeah, without getting into the details of maybe Mr.
    • 02:32:02
      Page will, but wouldn't it be this board, it seems to me if I'm out there running a train now, and I have this unknown, it seemed like to be able to comment upon us to say that we're going to keep that train service.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:18
      Okay, we have a whole separate presentation to go on this.
    • 02:32:22
      He's not, he knows, why don't we wait for Mr.
    • 02:32:24
      Page to come up and we'll come back to this and we'll save all the, you're writing all those questions down, Mr.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:32:31
      Page?
    • 02:32:31
      Okay.
    • 02:32:31
      That's a great idea.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:32
      All right, back to this.
    • 02:32:33
      And you'll see the trains and which ones, because they're not all the same trains.
    • 02:32:37
      I mean, there's certain trains that we're paying for.
    • 02:32:39
      These are other Amtrak trains where right now we have no involvement in, other than the fact that they stop at our stations.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:32:45
      The last bullet here on the first slide is we do have a blended rate of our capital match of 56% when you take all our different projects and put them together.
    • 02:33:07
      We have a priority on replacing rolling stock as we did last year.
    • 02:33:11
      and we did have a category this year that a couple of grantees won't accept federal dollars and we chose to give them 50% funding in that case.
    • 02:33:24
      There's a couple of entities that we have federal dollars that we offer to put on projects
    • 02:33:35
      at 80 percent.
    • 02:33:38
      And they don't want, I guess, to deal with the administrative work to take federal dollars.
    • 02:33:45
      And so if we gave them 80 percent federal funding, then we'd be giving them 80 percent of the remainder, which would be 16.
    • 02:33:53
      So we'd be putting 96 percent of the money into that project.
    • 02:33:58
      And they're saying, no, we don't want that.
    • 02:34:02
      We kind of looked at that, that that's not fair to people that do take that money and do administer those funds.
    • 02:34:07
      And so we chose to cap our participation at 50 percent.
    • 02:34:17
      The next slide just is our three-year comparison.
    • 02:34:20
      Last year, we had the $50 million PREA match for WAMAKA.
    • 02:34:26
      That was the increase.
    • 02:34:27
      In the current year, we have the revenue uptick that Mr. Lawson spoke about earlier, 17% year-over-year, 11% over the six years.
    • 02:34:38
      Recordation did show a slight uptick, but that percentage is constant throughout year-over-year and over the six years, and all the other sources are flat.
    • 02:34:50
      This slide, you've seen a lot.
    • 02:34:52
      The bottom slide is the
    • 02:34:53
      Participation of the state and total operating costs last year were at a historical low of less than 15%.
    • 02:35:00
      We did uptick this year to 17.5%, so at least it's moving in the right direction.
    • 02:35:06
      We'd like to get back above that 20% level where we sort of had been before the recession hit.
    • 02:35:16
      I'm not going to go into a lot of detail here.
    • 02:35:18
      These are the same assumptions that we had earlier.
    • 02:35:21
      The only item that really changed, well the top item changed, we did have a slight adjustment in the revenues and we found some more deobligated funds that we added into the operating funding.
    • 02:35:37
      So we moved that up to $19 million increase and then the last bullet
    • 02:35:42
      It shouldn't say estimated now because it is actual in our budget.
    • 02:35:47
      We are taking 2.3% off.
    • 02:35:49
      When we were back here in April, that was estimated to be 2.5%.
    • 02:35:53
      So we finalized the budget and now the amount of money we have to take off the top to administer our programs is 2.3%.
    • 02:36:01
      These are just some of the highlights of what's funded, what we had before, so I'm not going to go through those.
    • 02:36:12
      Rail assumptions, once again, we've belabored the operating issue already.
    • 02:36:21
      Similar items here, just once again, the one difference being the amount taken off the top of Rail Enhancement and Rail Preservation Fund being 2.3% being the final number versus 2.5 when we were with the draft program.
    • 02:36:38
      And this last slide is just gives, I'm not gonna list all the changes, because the last bullet here, there were lots of technical corrections with grantees coming back and adjusting an application, a minor amount in the estimated funding for cost of a project, or somehow maybe an amount was picked up at net, not gross.
    • 02:37:03
      So there was lots of little technical corrections, but the three major ones I'll point out was
    • 02:37:08
      Alexandria had an application in for six expansion buses that we didn't include in the draft originally because they could not commit the local funding that was required at that time.
    • 02:37:21
      Since that time they've had a board meeting and they've made that commitment that needed to be made.
    • 02:37:26
      So that item went in and it did require an additional $1.3 million of bond funds that we have available under the $60 million level that we set.
    • 02:37:40
      And same thing for the next item.
    • 02:37:42
      There was an error when we did the calculation earlier of the WMATA capital funding.
    • 02:37:46
      This is the funding that's not the PREA match.
    • 02:37:49
      And it involved essentially the amount of federal dollars that are allocated to Virginia by WMATA.
    • 02:37:56
      It was just misinterpreted.
    • 02:37:58
      And this resulted in an extra $2.7 million being allocated, which once again, both of these items being added, we're still under our 60 million annual cap that we kind of set.
    • 02:38:10
      And finally, a couple of projects, as we said, we're putting federal dollars that we control on certain capital projects.
    • 02:38:19
      And a couple of grantees we thought would accept federal dollars.
    • 02:38:22
      They do in other cases.
    • 02:38:25
      But for these particular projects, for certain reasons, some of them being they had already started a process of planning and they weren't following all the federal regulations.
    • 02:38:38
      So they weren't going to be able to comply with accepting federal dollars.
    • 02:38:42
      So we took our federal money back off and changed the funding mix on a couple of projects.
    • 02:38:50
      And that's all I have on the six-year program.
    • 02:38:52
      If there's other questions, I'll gladly answer them.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:00
      My question is related on this slide number four, which is the share of state operating costs.
    • 02:39:13
      You said you want to get that up above 20%, but there's no indication of what your plan actually does to achieve that goal.
    • 02:39:25
      Do you have budgeted to go up in the six-year plan?
    • 02:39:30
      The state share of total operating expenses?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:39:33
      There's two ways for us to get that above 20%.
    • 02:39:36
      It's either for the revenue to increase, the existing revenue sources, or
    • 02:39:41
      to have the cost decrease.
    • 02:39:44
      And, you know, we're a funding partner, so you have to kind of wait and see what happens.
    • 02:39:53
      Our reach on the cost side is limited.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:01
      That just seems like an odd six-year plan, wait and see what happens.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:08
      We are authorized to go up to 41%.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:40:11
      We're authorized to go to 95% of eligible, but eligible is another 10-minute discussion.
    • 02:40:20
      I remember that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:23
      The revenues are whatever the revenues are.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:40:27
      We haven't been near 95% eligible.
    • 02:40:35
      All right, I'll just take a few minutes and take you through our budget.
    • 02:40:39
      You all should have this document in your package.
    • 02:40:42
      It's just our annual budget.
    • 02:40:44
      It is prepared on anticipated cash outlays for fiscal year 12.
    • 02:40:50
      It's going to vary from what we have for fiscal year 12 for the Six-Year Improvement Plan because there are some differences, the major ones being
    • 02:41:00
      We allocate certain federal funds that we don't receive, that our funding partners, the transit providers, they actually receive them directly.
    • 02:41:09
      So a six-year plan has those dollars.
    • 02:41:12
      Our budget's not because it's not going to go through our financial system.
    • 02:41:16
      We have a capital project development lag.
    • 02:41:19
      For a lot of our transit capital projects, it can be a two to two and a half year cycle.
    • 02:41:25
      And then finally, there's projects that are allocated in the VDOT six-year program.
    • 02:41:30
      that end up being handled through our, you know, we manage the project and then the actual expenditures go through our books.
    • 02:41:39
      The next slide details those differences.
    • 02:41:43
      We have a budget of 481 million at the bottom.
    • 02:41:46
      The six-year plan for fiscal year 12 is 423 million and then I won't go through all that detail but it shows the various differences.
    • 02:41:57
      The next slide is,
    • 02:42:00
      Our budget broken down by service area, public transportation being the largest item, rail programs, the next largest at $111 million, and then we have several other programs, smaller amounts.
    • 02:42:14
      We have the Metrorail project with the remaining $11 million of the $125 of bonds that was allocated in 2009 that should be expended in FY12.
    • 02:42:30
      I'll just talk a little more detail about a couple of those.
    • 02:42:32
      Public transportation, the operating assistance program is up about $18 million over the last year due to the additional TTF revenues we spoke of on the six-year plan side.
    • 02:42:46
      It's also, we have a $25 million increase in our capital assistance, which is really the maturing of our bond allocations that began in 2008 with a small amount and then
    • 02:42:59
      The subsequent years we put larger dollars and now that two and a half year lag I spoke of on capital projects is finally maturing so we have an increase due to that.
    • 02:43:09
      And then also the CMAQ and RSTP projects that we have out there.
    • 02:43:14
      We're sort of, we're seeing hopefully with the language in the appropriation act and the work that Mr. Sterling's doing that
    • 02:43:23
      On the rail side, we're showing $111 million.
    • 02:43:35
      It is an increase over the prior year, and last year's budget, we had a large amount of money for the Norfolk train.
    • 02:43:43
      It didn't get going as quick as we wanted because we had to go through a lot of detailed contracting issues with Norfolk Southern and CSX.
    • 02:43:52
      So that funding is in this year's budget to be spent.
    • 02:43:57
      That's the reason for the increase because the majority of that project should get done during that time frame.
    • 02:44:04
      The Metrorail, as I said, that's the final payment on the allocation made in 09.
    • 02:44:10
      That will be sent to MY, we predicted this current fiscal year.
    • 02:44:15
      And finally, I just wanted to talk about our administrative budget.
    • 02:44:20
      This is the combined project management and administrative overhead type budget.
    • 02:44:28
      2%, basically that total $481 million or $9.4 million.
    • 02:44:34
      It does represent an increase from last year, about $600,000, which is partly due to the 5% raise that employees will be getting July 1 due to the VRS conversion.
    • 02:44:48
      And then also we have increased the field positions from 38 to 43 in our budget.
    • 02:44:56
      The agency has a maximum level, we talked about that earlier, our agency has a maximum level of 53.
    • 02:45:03
      So we're going into the year with 43 is sort of the level we're going to have employed and 53 is our maximum.
    • 02:45:12
      And finally, this is funded through HMO funding, highway maintenance funding off the top of that fund for $5.1 million and then, as I mentioned earlier, the 2.3% off of our funds off the top.
    • 02:45:27
      And the last slide just shows the $480 million budget where the actual sources of revenue are to pay for that.
    • 02:45:37
      With that, I'll entertain any questions.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:45:40
      Any other questions?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:41
      Just one real quick one.
    • 02:45:43
      There's a really efficient transit group called John.
    • 02:45:47
      Is that being funded?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:45:50
      Yes.
    • 02:45:51
      It's operating funding and capital funding.
    • 02:45:56
      I can show you in detail all their items if you'd like.
    • 02:46:00
      Not right now.
    • 02:46:00
      Okay.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:00
      I think the other board members might shoot you.
    • 02:46:02
      Okay.
    • 02:46:03
      That'd be great.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:05
      No problem.
    • 02:46:07
      Okay.
    • 02:46:08
      Mr.
    • 02:46:08
      Page, come on up.
    • 02:46:10
      Thanks, Steve, for warming up.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:46:18
      Rick, listen to all these questions while you're running out of people to call them.
    • 02:46:24
      Let's see here.
    • 02:46:24
      Let me get my item number up here.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:28
      Six.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:46:31
      All right.
    • 02:46:35
      Waiting on the computer.
    • 02:46:40
      Okay, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I hope I'm going to be able to walk through all the questions that came up earlier.
    • 02:46:44
      So if I missed a couple of those, please call them to my attention.
    • 02:46:48
      But my intention today is we have been given updates to the Transportation Board on Section 209 since PREA was enacted in 2008.
    • 02:46:56
      We're getting very close now to the final negotiations round of our national transportation policy for the costing and allocation
    • 02:47:05
      of the Regional Train Service, better known as Regional Services under Section 209 of PREA.
    • 02:47:11
      If you look at the map today, the color coding might be a little bit hard to read from a distance, but on your handouts before you, you'll find that the red train routes in Virginia as well as the green train routes in Virginia are all impacted Section 209 services.
    • 02:47:29
      As you can see, they're sprinkled all across the nation.
    • 02:47:31
      There are about 36 different routes that are impacted by the Section 209 of PREA.
    • 02:47:37
      In Virginia, for example, calling your attention to our slide three, as you can see the two blue routes are the routes that Lynchburg service and the Richmond service routing that have the two trains that Virginia actually subsidizes at its cost through the six-year program and under the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 02:47:57
      The green route you see are the two trains to Newport News that Mr. Pittard talked about earlier that we'll be picking up under Section 209 because again they're under 750 miles of distance as well as two trains from Washington to Richmond that will eventually, the plans are for all three of the trains that overnight today, the Virginia train we fund now plus the two we pick up under Section 209.
    • 02:48:18
      will go to Norfolk one within two years and the other two trains within a ten-year window as improvements are made in the system between Richmond and Petersburg.
    • 02:48:30
      Kind of as a little bit of a history lesson, and I think it's very important for the Commonwealth Transportation Board to know this and be aware of it, is that the Pageant of Rail Investment Improvement Act of 2008 was a big game changer.
    • 02:48:42
      It was almost as big a game changer as the Transportation Act of 1920 when the United States government gave the railroads back the railroad's authority.
    • 02:48:51
      Under the War Act of 1917, all the railroad's operations and controls had been seized by the government and then were given back by that Act of Congress in 1920.
    • 02:49:00
      Following that, the Interstate Commerce Commission was created and strengthened in a greater way, including the provisions of providing passenger rail service and also freight service as an interstate commerce common carrier good throughout the nation.
    • 02:49:15
      It wasn't until 1971 under the National Rail Passenger Service Act that Amtrak was created and railroads were given a little bit of relief.
    • 02:49:25
      from the passenger rail burden that they were claiming that they were losing an enormous amount of funding on and they were on the brink of bankruptcy.
    • 02:49:35
      It wasn't until the Staggers Act of 1980 that interstate commerce was opened up for railroads.
    • 02:49:40
      They didn't, at that time, fill out from under the rate structures from the federal government.
    • 02:49:44
      And in 1995, the Surface Transportation Board was created by the termination of the Interstate Commerce Commission under the ICC Termination Act.
    • 02:49:52
      That meant that all laws under the ICC and powers that were granted to the states through the ICC were then preempted by the Surface Transportation Board's creation.
    • 02:50:00
      I bring you kind of to that point today because PREA in 2008 did not have any of the deliberations to the extent of all of these other federal efforts at Congress.
    • 02:50:10
      PREA kind of slipped through because what it did was it took a national transportation system, dismantled it, and then pushed off to the states.
    • 02:50:19
      The Section 209 service, which is the under 750-mile service,
    • 02:50:23
      Through the definition of the Amtrak system under 201, Section 212 was created as well, which is the Northeast Quarter Commission.
    • 02:50:31
      Basically what happened was we still have a national transportation system providing rail passenger service, but now it has been disjointed to the point where you have long distance trains, regional trains, and northeast quarter trains that all work commingled, especially here in Virginia.
    • 02:50:46
      That's been one of our biggest challenges
    • 02:50:49
      In dealing with Section 209, and it was very important that Virginia be represented in the state working group I'll talk about in just a minute, where five states that have unique characteristics came together with AASHTO and with Amtrak to sit down and try to determine what would be the best national policy for the allocation of costs that are delegated to the Commonwealth and all other states that receive services by no later than October 13 of 2013, October 30, excuse me, October 1.
    • 02:51:16
      Having said that, as Mr. Pittard and I talked about earlier, we have six trains we'll be paying for under Section 209, and through the state's working group, we sat down with Amtrak with the understanding that the federal law asked and directed the state's
    • 02:51:33
      and the mayor of the District of Columbia to come together and fully allocate the cost of Amtrak on these regional services.
    • 02:51:40
      So we started out with a 100% route cost initiative.
    • 02:51:44
      We then, as the state's working group, rejected that and felt that Amtrak had some costs that they could have soared because they do run still the northeast quarter and the long distance trains as I talked about earlier.
    • 02:51:54
      So when we pushed back Amtrak proposed back to us a 90% of total allocated cost plan which the state working group again rejected and then the board came back to Amtrak board with policy B.
    • 02:52:05
      Instead of going down they went up to 91%.
    • 02:52:08
      So the state working group we pushed back extremely hard and said we need to understand the fundamentals of Amtrak.
    • 02:52:13
      The books were open and we had the opportunity to sit down and work with Amtrak basically pulling apart all the costs of its system.
    • 02:52:20
      The system costs have been created through APT, which is the Amtrak Performance Tracking System that had been developed with the Volpe Center on how to fully allocate the costs of the Amtrak system.
    • 02:52:31
      Up until that time, it was somewhat questionable as to how Amtrak allocated their costs, but under PREA, that forced us to now sit down and look at that.
    • 02:52:39
      Under APT, our state working group then went forward with an understanding that we needed to develop a policy that not only was easy to understand but was fair and equitable to everyone.
    • 02:52:51
      You know, obviously the state working group, as Thelma Drake said to the Amtrak board last week when she and I gave presentation about our concerns about Section 209 to the Amtrak board, we expressed the fact that we the states want the best value and we understand that Amtrak wants the best value as well.
    • 02:53:07
      So how do we come to a fairness deal?
    • 02:53:10
      So how we set it up was very similar to how this board is aware of how normal contracting operations and maintenance and other contracts are set forth.
    • 02:53:19
      Instead of pulling through and culling through hundreds of pages of the APT system, we settled on 100% of route costs.
    • 02:53:27
      Any costs that are directly attributed to a route, that is train and engine crew labor, the people that actually run the trains is 100% attributed.
    • 02:53:35
      And as you can see on this slide six, we also talked about how we deal with the support fees that needed to be added on that.
    • 02:53:43
      So there was an additive fee approach that was addressed as to how the supervisors to those crews and others can be allocated across the system.
    • 02:53:51
      In addition to that, general administration costs were capped at 2%.
    • 02:53:56
      And we also looked at direct third-party costs like the access fees paid to the railroads, fuel for locomotives, and also maintenance and weight costs that are also attributed to the route that are paid to the railroad as well.
    • 02:54:07
      So as we came to the bottom of that, less revenues, you come up with what's referred to as the state contribution.
    • 02:54:14
      What it will cost the Commonwealth of Virginia to operate those six trains under the policy that's been developed by the state working group and adopted by Amtrak as we move forward.
    • 02:54:26
      We remain critically concerned about this.
    • 02:54:28
      You know, as I said, Thelma Drake and I went up last week.
    • 02:54:32
      We met before the Amtrak board and had a great discussion with them as well.
    • 02:54:36
      But what we also talked about was, you know, the Federal Railroad Administration has proposed a concept.
    • 02:54:41
      And on that concept of PREA, there's an 80-20 program for capital costs.
    • 02:54:45
      But then again, there was no program for operating costs that were being pushed off to the states.
    • 02:54:50
      The Chairman mentioned just recently in our dialogue and comments today that many states are not prepared for Section 209.
    • 02:54:59
      It has been found that Virginia is on the cutting edge of this and understanding the importance of being prepared for this initiative when the federal law, provided it is not changed, takes effect.
    • 02:55:09
      And I think we've been very responsible as the Commonwealth Transportation Board and the Six-Year Program to at least acknowledge that there is a cost for 209 and this program has been created.
    • 02:55:19
      Having said that, we move forward with then dealing with revenue.
    • 02:55:25
      And what I want to show you is somewhat alarming.
    • 02:55:28
      As Mr. Pittard said earlier, we have a contract with Amtrak today that was based on negotiations between Virginia and Amtrak.
    • 02:55:34
      We found that every state that contracts with Amtrak, which are 15 states, all have different costing methodologies that they had negotiated.
    • 02:55:43
      Henceforth, that's why PREA called for a new policy on the costing and recovery of those costs of trains.
    • 02:55:50
      Under the Lynchburg service, we negotiated 79% of through revenue into the Northeast Corridor.
    • 02:55:56
      So if you have a patron that rides from Virginia on the Lynchburg train into the Northeast Corridor, 79% of the revenue comes back to Virginia for their ride in the Northeast Corridor.
    • 02:56:06
      We get 100% of the revenue for that ride in Virginia.
    • 02:56:09
      Now, if you look on the table here under the current policy that we have under contract, that shows that, and as someone asked earlier today from the board, doesn't the Lynchburg train pay for itself?
    • 02:56:21
      Well, the last rolling 12 months, as you can see, the net state payment or credit from that railroad operation for Lynchburg was $1.8 million positive.
    • 02:56:30
      That's positive, operating positive.
    • 02:56:32
      Under what Amtrak has proposed,
    • 02:56:35
      As their revenue policy, we only get 100% of the revenue or what they call passenger seat mile revenue.
    • 02:56:43
      So if a patron gets on in Lynchburg, we only get the revenue now to Washington, D.C.
    • 02:56:48
      Anything in the northeast quarter is Amtrak's revenue to split with the Section 212 states or Amtrak work to allocate it within the system.
    • 02:56:56
      We've pushed hard on that.
    • 02:56:58
      We've pushed hard back to the Amtrak Board.
    • 02:57:01
      We are a result of extensions of the Northeast Corridor trains into Virginia.
    • 02:57:07
      All six of these trains that we're talking about are Northeast Corridor trains.
    • 02:57:11
      We share in the cost of those trains.
    • 02:57:13
      We share in the capitalization of those trains.
    • 02:57:15
      We've been good business partners with the Northeast Corridor.
    • 02:57:18
      I was with Delaware and Maryland yesterday in the Delmarva Freight Summit and brought up 212 as a concern as well.
    • 02:57:26
      The states in the Northeast Corridor are going to have to work with the states that feed the Northeast Corridor, like Virginia and North Carolina.
    • 02:57:34
      The Carolinian is impacted by this as well in North Carolina.
    • 02:57:37
      So as you see this moving forward, we are continuing to push hard to say that we need a sharing of that revenue.
    • 02:57:45
      The other piece is the Newport News train is on slide nine.
    • 02:57:47
      It's very important to show that the Richmond train service today is running at a deficit of 1.9 million.
    • 02:57:56
      If you combine those revenues and costs together, you can see that the Lynchburg train service is recovering a considerable amount of the losses or subsidy of the Richmond train.
    • 02:58:07
      As you see the 5.964 million number on the policy, we are picking up four additional trains, so that's a total of five trains now that we will be seeing under the Newport News Service.
    • 02:58:20
      Having said that as well, continuing to the next slide, 10, there's also a cost that's associated, again, that's part of the fully allocated cost of operating the trains, so there's a capital cost that's also associated with this train service.
    • 02:58:33
      As you can see Amtrak has provided some estimates as to what the capital cost can be in a combined total of $1.48 million for the first year.
    • 02:58:41
      Now remember we're not starting up until October 2013 and understanding that this board knows that the October fiscal year is a federal fiscal year, we begin July 1 so there will be a reduction of that.
    • 02:58:54
      Also, I'm pushing hard that we get credit for the $8 million that this board approved and invested in two train set rehabilitations for the Richmond and Lynchburg service.
    • 02:59:02
      We need to get recovery for that.
    • 02:59:04
      There's still a value left on those train sets, so we should get a recovery credit for that as well.
    • 02:59:09
      So as we move forward with the process,
    • 02:59:12
      If you look at the $110 million that's an estimate approximated in the six-year program, I'm pushing very hard.
    • 02:59:19
      Thelma Drake is working hard as well.
    • 02:59:20
      We as an agency are pushing to be stewards to find the best deal possible for our trade service.
    • 02:59:28
      Right now we're looking at about 43 percent of the total cost of that $110 million, but yet then again, all of the states have not approved this policy yet.
    • 02:59:37
      So right now I think that we're negotiating the best policy that we can plus the cost of recovery that we can as well.
    • 02:59:43
      So as we move forward, the state's working group has sent to all of the states in the union the new proposed policy.
    • 02:59:52
      We're working through that.
    • 02:59:54
      We'll be working with Thelma Drake next week to give comments back to the state working group.
    • 02:59:58
      And then a final policy will be adopted by the Amtrak board and then redistributed to the states for their designees for approval and sign off, including the mayor and the District of Columbia.
    • 03:00:10
      So that's where we are right now.
    • 03:00:12
      Mr. Secretary, members of the board, if we do not have all of the states sign on, we are looking at two implementation potentials.
    • 03:00:21
      One is the states that sign on will move forward with the project and the states that don't sign on will go to the Surface Transportation Board to try the case through the STV.
    • 03:00:31
      If that's not taken in that incremental approach method, we might find that the entire policy goes to the Surface Transportation Board for approval by the no vote of just one state or the District of Columbia.
    • 03:00:42
      So that concludes my presentation.
    • 03:00:45
      Mr. Chairman, I hope that answered most of the questions we had earlier, and I'm more than prepared to address any as they come about.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:00:52
      I just want to make sure, so I got the nut we have to crack here, or the state has to crack.
    • 03:00:58
      In 2012, that nut is zero.
    • 03:01:00
      Is that correct?
    • 03:01:01
      Because we still have the same funding, and so there is no money needed.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:01:05
      Right.
    • 03:01:06
      Mr. Chairman and to Mr. Layne as well and the members of the board, the answer is 2012 looks good, but it's been the outstanding performance of the Lynchburg train that has led us to not need money in FY12.
    • 03:01:21
      When we started into this, we thought we might need money for FY12, but due to the cost recovery and the revenue positive of Lynchburg, it has just continued to outperform any other train in the regional system of Amtrak.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:01:35
      In 2013, if I read your graphs correctly, we would need 6 million plus the Norfolk train sets, is that correct?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:01:55
      See, I did some math here.
    • 03:01:56
      I think you're getting close there.
    • 03:01:58
      Let me see if I can find my numbers.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:01:59
      Now, it looks like six, right?
    • 03:02:00
      Because it said the rates were six million short now between Lynchburg and the Richmond service on that graph.
    • 03:02:11
      Right.
    • 03:02:11
      Plus whatever Norfolk costs.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:02:13
      Right.
    • 03:02:14
      If I were adding to some chisel problem on the column, I'd look at the 1.5 plus million, 5.964 million.
    • 03:02:21
      That comes up to about 7.5 million.
    • 03:02:23
      And then you have a capital charge on top of that for the first full year of about 3.5 million.
    • 03:02:28
      So you're at 11 million and some change.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:30
      Right.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:30
      Where's the 1.5?
    • 03:02:31
      I lost you.
    • 03:02:32
      Yeah, I lost you on that, too.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:02:34
      That is on slide number 8.
    • 03:02:35
      Let me pull this up for you.
    • 03:02:37
      It's $1,551,177 under the new Amtrak Policy 2.
    • 03:02:43
      So we have a sweep of $3.3 million.
    • 03:02:46
      We go from a positive operating train of $1.8 million to a negative operating train of $1.5 million.
    • 03:02:52
      And this is the critical importance, Mr. Miller, of us trying to preserve the three revenue credit, the sharing of the riders that go into the northeast quarter.
    • 03:03:00
      They would not be riding in the quarter if it were not but for our trains.
    • 03:03:03
      So it's 75 plus the capital?
    • 03:03:05
      Yes, sir, that's correct.
    • 03:03:06
      3.5 million, first full year.
    • 03:03:10
      So 11 million.
    • 03:03:11
      11 million, yes, sir.
    • 03:03:12
      Thanks, and that's about 43% of what we're looking at right now in the six-year program.
    • 03:03:15
      We had the best numbers we could up until just a couple of days ago.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:19
      Mr. Secretary?
    • 03:03:20
      Yes, Mr. Garczynski?
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:21
      Yes, Kevin, question for you on the subsidization of the Richmond Trades.
    • 03:03:28
      When is it a critical mass or a standard of performance where you say you can't subsidize the Richmond train anymore, it's just not viable?
    • 03:03:39
      I mean, how long a time frame do you have before you make that decision as a department?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:03:45
      What typically happens, and thank you for your question, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, usually, and I want to explain a little bit about intercity passenger rail service, this board has been making some critical investments over time to purchase train slots.
    • 03:04:00
      And what we will be picking up in the four trains that two run to Richmond and two to Newport News is that we've made no investments for those slots.
    • 03:04:08
      They came in under the original Rail Passenger Act of 71.
    • 03:04:13
      If in 12 months that operation ceases and does not reactivate, that capacity is gone.
    • 03:04:20
      That means that we will have to go back to the serving railroad at some point to make major investments to regain that capacity.
    • 03:04:28
      So the answer is we probably would look at 12 to 18 months time window.
    • 03:04:32
      We'd have to sit down, look long and hard at ridership and recovery and also opportunity lost.
    • 03:04:38
      You know, many times over, what I tend to find, I'm from the mass transit industry plus, you know, I used to be a transit operator before I came to the agency in 93.
    • 03:04:48
      One of the challenges you have is that you have a direct operating recovery, short-term loss, but what is the long-term benefit of the continuation of the operation and how it contributes to the system?
    • 03:04:58
      And part of that is the opportunity cost of what we may lose if we stop one train and need that capacity to go somewhere else in the system on that line.
    • 03:05:06
      That's a very good question.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:08
      There comes a time when you have to make that.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:05:11
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:05:12
      We have to make that.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:13
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:05:14
      Mr. Miller.
    • 03:05:17
      Kevin, do we have an idea of how much per ticket is the right way to look at it?
    • 03:05:28
      This is $11 million.
    • 03:05:34
      It's coming up, and I guess that sort of is a number that continues.
    • 03:05:40
      There's no reason to believe it would inflate particularly, increase particularly fast, other than inflation.
    • 03:05:48
      It's sort of a stream of 11 million dollars that it would require.
    • 03:05:53
      And the revenue coming in now, through all trains, through all services that we've been capturing, off ticket sales would be what?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:06:03
      Well, if you're looking now to answer your question, it would be, if you look at the revenue credit, $16.4 million on the Richmond, all five of the Richmond-New Bernoulli trains combined.
    • 03:06:13
      Plus, on top of that is the revenue credit of, under the, this is the future revenue credit, another $4.4 million for Lynchburg.
    • 03:06:21
      Now, if you look in the column on slide eight.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:23
      That's $20 million?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:06:24
      Yes, sir.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:25
      So if you said you're subsidizing $11 million and you collected $20 million, then it's basically a 50% increase in the ticket price.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:06:34
      That is correct.
    • 03:06:35
      It would be a surcharge for a Virginia service owner.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:38
      So a ticket price to Washington from Richmond would typically be today.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:06:45
      You could buy them depending on time because remember it's all revenue driven.
    • 03:06:49
      Let's see, $40, $41, $42.
    • 03:06:50
      So $60 is $40.
    • 03:06:51
      Yes, something like that.
    • 03:06:55
      Depending on the time you buy it.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:57
      That gives us some perspective of what we're talking about.
    • 03:06:59
      Number two is more of a statement I guess.
    • 03:07:07
      Certainly we're subsidizing these trains.
    • 03:07:10
      We're putting taxpayer money in the trains.
    • 03:07:13
      We put taxpayer money in the highways every day.
    • 03:07:16
      And we don't sort of say, well, is that a subsidy or is that just the cost of being in the land that we're in?
    • 03:07:30
      So I would urge us, and I understand what Mr. Porzinski was saying,
    • 03:07:37
      Whether it's in a train, or whether it's in a bus, or whether it's in a road, or whatever it's in, at the end of the day, we're just trying to move people and freight, and it has to be cost effective, has to be the most cost effective, or should be the most cost effective, in the long term.
    • 03:07:55
      I sort of look at the elasticity of train travel, and I'm not riding the Richmond to Washington train a lot, but if it was $55 versus $40, I'm not sure that changes my
    • 03:08:07
      I'm not sure that's a real elastic demand situation.
    • 03:08:12
      So there might be some way to recapture some of that.
    • 03:08:14
      But regardless of that, we're spending billions on roads, so we're spending $11 million on train.
    • 03:08:22
      What's that per mile?
    • 03:08:25
      What would that do if we shifted all those people back to roads and got rid of the trains?
    • 03:08:30
      And then my last question would be, I didn't understand when you said if we abandoned it, we'd lose the capacity in 18 months.
    • 03:08:39
      That is correct.
    • 03:08:40
      What is that?
    • 03:08:41
      Is that a legal thing?
    • 03:08:43
      Is that a physical thing?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:08:44
      Currently, if I can, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, just give a brief history of how the Amtrak service came about in 1971.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:08:55
      All of the railroad
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:08:56
      Railroads that had passenger rail service when the National Rail Passenger Service Act was passed came together and signed a memorandum of understanding as well as part of the deliberations of that act that the railroads would allow train service at the level of service that it was upon the time Amtrak was created, the National Railroad Passenger Corporation, that they could continue operations on the capacity from whence it was at the time they started service.
    • 03:09:25
      On top of that, they have two different operating instruments.
    • 03:09:28
      One is an on-quarter agreement and one is an off-quarter agreement that Amtrak has with the Class 1, Class 2, Class 3 railroads.
    • 03:09:35
      That's the agreement for them to run their trains over their railroad, them being Amtrak over the Class 1 or whatever railroad.
    • 03:09:43
      If that capacity was there and it's not owned like the investments Virginia has made, we actually have train slot agreements through our framework agreement.
    • 03:09:51
      If it's not owned by a state, and it was there in the beginning, when that train ceases to operate, and Amtrak's been challenged with this already with the railroads.
    • 03:10:01
      They can't come back very easily and say, we want to run that train two or three years down the road.
    • 03:10:05
      Now you're subject to the railroad saying yes and no.
    • 03:10:07
      That's correct.
    • 03:10:08
      You're totally subject to the railroad under negotiations, which means millions of dollars of capital investment, most likely, to recover the train slot that has been there since 1971 and no improvement cost to the railroad.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:21
      So you could certainly make the case that it's critical to maintain
    • 03:10:25
      That is correct.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:10:33
      The elasticity there is the willingness of the board to put money into or this Commonwealth to put money into a project for the continuation of rail operations for the future.
    • 03:10:43
      In the case where it's a railroad line that's just not carrying it.
    • 03:10:46
      But then there's also a network gain of what passengers do, low ridership lines and opportunities create for the entire system.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:58
      Thank you.
    • 03:10:59
      Page, just want to clarify one point.
    • 03:11:00
      Go back to your map.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:11:04
      The Virginia or the National?
    • 03:11:06
      The National.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:07
      So the current train services, like the Decrescent train, whatever, runs in New Orleans or whatever, those trains are uncovered by this.
    • 03:11:18
      Those trains that are through trains that still stop in, let's say, a bridge.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:11:23
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:11:23
      They stop.
    • 03:11:24
      If I can, I know exactly where you're headed with this.
    • 03:11:27
      Amtrak will continue to receive federal.
    • 03:11:29
      I'm going to read your mind, Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:11:32
      I want to, I think it's important that I get this one out.
    • 03:11:35
      All right, go ahead with your question, but I know where you're headed.
    • 03:11:39
      I'm sorry, I felt like Rick Walton there for a minute.
    • 03:11:46
      Sorry, Rick, you're an easy target today.
    • 03:11:50
      Go ahead, sir, I didn't mean to cut you off.
    • 03:11:51
      It's important to note, I think where you're headed is, we have two challenges in Virginia.
    • 03:11:58
      One is that we're a state that has long distance lines on the same quarters that we operate.
    • 03:12:02
      We'll be operating under 209, our trains are.
    • 03:12:05
      I'll call them our trains because we'll be subsidizing them.
    • 03:12:07
      We have no control over their ticket prices.
    • 03:12:10
      None.
    • 03:12:11
      We have no control over the fact that they will continue to receive, Amtrak will continue to receive federal subsidy for long distance lines.
    • 03:12:19
      They will continue to receive that subsidy, where under PREA Section 209, the states are solely responsible for the allocated cost of the operations, and we have an 80-20 capital opportunity that not yet has been funded through the federal budget.
    • 03:12:35
      So I'm sorry if I cut you off, Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:12:38
      I felt like you were headed that way.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:40
      But you made me sound brilliant.
    • 03:12:42
      Yeah, thank you.
    • 03:12:43
      But I just want to make sure, I mean, part of that, I mean,
    • 03:12:48
      This is a sort of a back-the-doorway for us to not just simply assume some of the costs of running these trains, but in the cost of this other issue, the longer distance trains, we may end up actually subsidizing the rest of Amtrak's operation.
    • 03:13:05
      Because they're gonna essentially say, these are our costs, we don't have a choice.
    • 03:13:10
      I mean, we can't switch over to another train operator.
    • 03:13:14
      So they're gonna just give us a number,
    • 03:13:16
      And then we're going to have to pay it.
    • 03:13:19
      And that number may actually be used to actually support their longer distance trains.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:13:26
      Yeah, and that's where you are brilliant because we had that same discussion as the state working group.
    • 03:13:35
      I want the board to understand that the state working group, although they were very cordial and professional discussions, we certainly packed a bag of rocks and empty Coke bottles to throw at everybody when we got together.
    • 03:13:50
      And one of our challenges was, remember I said Board Policy A and Board Policy B of Amtrak was, you start at 100%, we got down to 90% and 91%.
    • 03:13:57
      Well, today, even without any overhead costs or GNA, we're paying around 80%, 82% today on our trains.
    • 03:14:05
      So we've gotten them down to 85%, but it was that exact comment that you just made is what led us down to the 85%.
    • 03:14:12
      We're not going to have you push off the cost of the national system trains onto the states.
    • 03:14:17
      And we made them, for example, at the Richmond train station.
    • 03:14:21
      That was a great discussion, great example.
    • 03:14:23
      We have five regional trains,
    • 03:14:26
      Six counting the Carolinian because North Carolina actually provides a train through Virginia under 209 at no cost to us, at least we hope it stays that way.
    • 03:14:36
      But then again we have three long distance trains.
    • 03:14:38
      We have the Palmetto, the Silver Star, and Silver Meteor that stop in Richmond.
    • 03:14:41
      We were not going to absorb 100% of the Richmond Amtrak's cost at Staples Mill Station because there are three of their trains there.
    • 03:14:48
      So we could not have that pushed off on us.
    • 03:14:50
      They also receive revenues from a vendor at the Richmond Station.
    • 03:14:53
      They were not going to credit us out of proportion for it.
    • 03:14:57
      So we've had to go all the way back nationwide to every regional train station and pull apart, this working group, all of the revenues for real estate holdings that Amtrak has as well.
    • 03:15:07
      If we're paying a station capital and operating cost, we want a share of the revenue that comes out of any rental property or vendors at those locations.
    • 03:15:15
      That's how definitive and intense these conversations have been because we're trying to get the best value for us because exactly what you said, Mr. Chairman, we don't want to be subsidized in the national system while we try to work to subsidize and continue our own train service.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:31
      And the one thing about this map, which is another issue for us, is really when you look at it and you look at the services that
    • 03:15:41
      The states are going to have to pick up some of these costs.
    • 03:15:47
      I just eyeball it.
    • 03:15:48
      It's about less than 20 states, including the District of Columbia, who are impacted by this legislation, which is going to make it even more difficult.
    • 03:16:01
      I mean, some of the bigger states, whether it's New York, California, a little bit of
    • 03:16:05
      Some of them in Illinois, but for the most part, there's just a limited number of states that are being impacted, which goes to reinforce this issue of how we're potentially going to be used to help support the entire system.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:16:18
      That's a very good point.
    • 03:16:19
      Thank you.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:20
      Okay.
    • 03:16:20
      Next slide.
    • 03:16:21
      Great.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:16:22
      Thank you.
    • 03:16:23
      Let me get out of this and we'll go to the next one.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:26
      Have we contacted our delegation, Mr. Chairman, about this?
    • 03:16:30
      They are aware of it.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:16:35
      Director Drake cannot be with us today.
    • 03:16:38
      Chairman Laika is making an announcement about the northeast quarter and potential privatization.
    • 03:16:43
      I so understand.
    • 03:16:44
      One of the challenges I want to also point out to this board, Mr. Chairman, if I can have one more second about the northeast quarter.
    • 03:16:51
      Remember, all six of our trains come and go out of the northeast quarter.
    • 03:16:54
      If the Northeast Corridor is privatized, then that means we won't be dealing with Amtrak through system trains.
    • 03:17:00
      We'll be dealing with a private operator north of Washington, D.C.
    • 03:17:03
      Totally different contracting arrangement, totally different labor arrangement, and that will be somewhat challenging for us as well.
    • 03:17:09
      I think those are some of the points that Ms. Drake is going to try to make today in her comments at Congress.
    • 03:17:16
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'd like to bring to you today an application briefing and then we'll have potential discussion after that.
    • 03:17:24
      This is a Carmoose, Lyman & Stone of Virginia project.
    • 03:17:27
      This project is located in Frederick County, Virginia, and Carmoose & Lyman is a limestone and coring company that has holdings and quarries at Clearbrook, Virginia, at this location at Middleton, Strasburg, and they also are all the way down to Buckhannon near Roanoke.
    • 03:17:44
      with the old James River operation down there, James Riverstone.
    • 03:17:49
      This project is, I'll give a little bit of history about this project.
    • 03:17:53
      The application came into us originally, we were contacted back in November of 2009 by Carmuz about this project.
    • 03:18:01
      It's a good project for us.
    • 03:18:03
      I mean, it's a 2,600-car load project where you take, you know, you have to multiply that by four so you understand the truckload equivalents.
    • 03:18:12
      If you look at the loadouts of this quarry by rail, it's 10,400 empty trucks and loaded trucks, so it's 20,800 trucks if they had to short haul this to one of their other quarries in the area to outbound by rail.
    • 03:18:24
      It's a significant amount of track and investment made by Carmoose as well.
    • 03:18:28
      We as an agency projected the first application when it came in because the policies and procedures adopted by the board only allow projects to move forward that the costs are incurred and paid after the resolution and agreement are
    • 03:18:42
      So in working over the last year, we've been working with Kermuz and also with district representative Dr. Davis and Frederick County to get a better understanding of this project and the importance not only to the locality but to also
    • 03:18:59
      The importance of not only the development to the county but also the truck equivalents that we will be taking off the road and also Interstate 81 obviously is right adjacent to this as well.
    • 03:19:10
      The second application came into the board.
    • 03:19:12
      We briefed your Stanton district representative.
    • 03:19:17
      We went through the evaluation process.
    • 03:19:19
      It did score well and we basically went back again to the county and said, okay, where do you all stand at the county level?
    • 03:19:28
      On this project, for the board's information, the Rail Industrial Access Program, the CTB, passes down to the local government the option of saying yes or no by having the board resolution of endorsement as part of the requirement of an application to move forward at this board.
    • 03:19:44
      Frederick County went back to Dr. Davis and said we do want to move forward with this project.
    • 03:19:48
      We think it's very important to us.
    • 03:19:50
      As we've moved forward, as again, the policies and procedures do not allow the department to make recommendations, but we can bring this project to the board for a board member or members.
    • 03:20:01
      to move forward to take action on this project, understanding that they're waiving the fact that the project did start just briefly before the project was actually applied for and funds granted by the department.
    • 03:20:14
      Today with us is Bob Carter.
    • 03:20:16
      He's a project leader of logistics from Kermis.
    • 03:20:19
      Mr. Carter?
    • 03:20:20
      He's available on site here as well in case there are any questions the board may have at this time.
    • 03:20:25
      This is a project as we would normally have brought it to you if we caught it in time with the applicant.
    • 03:20:32
      We would be bringing this forward with a recommendation for approval because it is a good project.
    • 03:20:36
      However, due to the policies and procedures adopted by the board, the department works by.
    • 03:20:40
      We're bringing this forward at a recommendation saying that the policies prohibit us from moving forward with this project unless the board takes exception to the fact that the project began construction before award.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:49
      Dr. Davis called me in relation to this project and in support of it and asked that I make an appeal on his behalf that we move the project forward because it's very valuable.
    • 03:21:04
      It's one that's recommended by the department.
    • 03:21:08
      And then there is, as you very well know, a little bit of a lag in the
    • 03:21:12
      application process, I don't know how long it takes us, two months, three months, something like that.
    • 03:21:17
      I can understand the fact that an industry needs to move forward and can't wait because they may have to go borrow the money or do something to complete the project, but I'm going to support the project and we'll move unless he has someone else making the motion to approve his project and we'll make that recommendation to the board.
    • 03:21:40
      Okay.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:41
      Mr. Chairman, Mr.
    • 03:21:42
      Page.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:43
      Yes.
    • 03:21:44
      Do we ever do, when you do your scoring to get to 50% or 50 or whatever, as a percentage, the number 50, 50 points, plus 50%, do you try to quantify in dollars
    • 03:22:01
      What the reduced impact is on highways and roads?
    • 03:22:06
      You're doing it strictly on, forget all the other things, but just strictly
    • 03:22:13
      Mr. Miller, under our rail enhancement program, we actually quantify because there's a public benefit calculation that falls into that.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:22:35
      Under the Rail Industrial Access Program, there are component evaluations, more of an economic development tool is what this project's used for.
    • 03:22:42
      However, I will tell you that 8.7 cents per mile is what we use for wear and tear on the roads that's avoided.
    • 03:22:49
      Per truck mile.
    • 03:22:49
      Per truck mile, that's correct.
    • 03:22:51
      And that came from the ESAL, which is what the equivalent single axle load study that was conducted by the VDOT Research Council, what, about two or three years ago, Connie?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:03
      So the 2,600 carloads annually would be about 10,000?
    • 03:23:10
      400 trucks annually.
    • 03:23:14
      Yes.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:23:15
      Times the number of miles.
    • 03:23:17
      That's correct.
    • 03:23:17
      Times nine cents.
    • 03:23:19
      Times nine cents for 15 years.
    • 03:23:20
      It's a 15-year program.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:22
      So what would the number of miles be?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:23:25
      I'm not that good at math.
    • 03:23:34
      If you had to ship it to one of your other quarries, what is it about 10 or 12 miles to the next quarry if you had to load out at another location?
    • 03:23:43
      Yes, the WS-5 would be more than that.
    • 03:23:46
      Probably I'd say 15 to 20.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:48
      So it would be 200,000 miles.
    • 03:23:51
      Correct.
    • 03:23:52
      Okay.
    • 03:23:53
      Annual.
    • 03:23:54
      Right.
    • 03:23:54
      For 15 years.
    • 03:23:55
      Times nine cents a mile.
    • 03:23:59
      Okay.
    • 03:24:00
      So that would be another 20 grand.
    • 03:24:05
      Right.
    • 03:24:06
      20 grand times 13 year would be impact just on the road itself.
    • 03:24:10
      Just the road itself.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:11
      Three or four thousand.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:24:13
      And that did not count bridge structures, that's just pavement surface.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:20
      Anything else?
    • 03:24:21
      Mr.
    • 03:24:21
      Chair.
    • 03:24:22
      Ms. Hollis.
    • 03:24:24
      Yes, sir.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:24
      Page, one quick question.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:26
      Has any alignment or anything been determined on this, exactly how the rails are going to run in or what exactly, what improvements are actually going to be done?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:24:35
      Yes, I can answer that.
    • 03:24:37
      I apologize.
    • 03:24:37
      I think I can bring the plan sheets over for you, but as you come off the CSX right-of-way and enter the Kermit's property, there's 10,000 feet of track similar to what we've set up in Pounding Mill Quarries, which is another project.
    • 03:24:50
      It usually goes out into a marshland yard that has the loadout, and then you shove into the hole, so to speak.
    • 03:24:54
      So you can build the entire unit train that way and then pull it out.
    • 03:24:57
      I'm not certain exactly where all of this lime is going, but I will tell you that when we deal with unit trains of lime, especially high calcium lime, the contracts are usually with power plant providers that burn coal.
    • 03:25:10
      So every time, like for example, the Pound and Mill Quarries Project was a Duke Power contract at that time where they were pulverizing the high calcium lime and injecting it into the firebox of the coal-fired power plant to neutralize the flue gases.
    • 03:25:27
      So these projects I see as not only a value to us in Virginia for not only getting the trucks off the road and using rail and the economic development, but also gives an opportunity for power plants to continue to burn coal and try to burn it a lot cleaner.
    • 03:25:41
      And a lot of times we like for that to say that's Virginia coal they're burning.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:25:46
      Okay, Kilpatrick.
    • 03:25:48
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:25:49
      Thank you.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:26:04
      Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 03:26:07
      I'm here this afternoon to give you a brief briefing on the VDOT business plan.
    • 03:26:14
      You should have a full copy of the business plan.
    • 03:26:17
      I want to go through some highlights this afternoon about how the plan was developed and some of the action steps.
    • 03:26:24
      You'll see what I would describe as an aggressiveness in this business plan that it really does focus on our core business of
    • 03:26:32
      Building, operating and maintaining our roadway system in Virginia.
    • 03:26:36
      There's some very clear action steps and clear things that we are going to be doing over the next year and years into the future as well as some clear responsibilities for the executives within the department as far as responsibilities and reporting back.
    • 03:26:55
      So the purpose of this business plan, first and foremost, is in support of the Governor's Multimodal Strategic Plan, and you'll see that the format very much follows that plan.
    • 03:27:07
      It's to align the business activities, to become a high-performing, back-to-basics organization, to unite the policymakers and practitioners, to continue transparency, and to be a nimble business organization.
    • 03:27:23
      A lot of the discussion today about
    • 03:27:26
      about some of the challenges, our financial challenges, our challenges with a larger construction program, with less in-house staff.
    • 03:27:36
      We have to be a much more nimble and organization that can quickly move and change in order to address our business needs.
    • 03:27:48
      This pyramid kind of, it shows the cascading of the VTrans 2035 and the Governor's Multimodal Plan that flows down to our VDOT plan and ultimately down to how we do our day-to-day operations.
    • 03:28:05
      So the strategic assessment that we did, it really focuses on a number of areas here and I'll just, I'm not reading them but I'll highlight some points.
    • 03:28:16
      about the importance of continuous learning and improvement, about sharpening our business practices, about focusing on a few key things, about increasing and improving our external communications, about meeting established asset conditions, and you heard some about that this morning, to get the money on the street.
    • 03:28:38
      We had a lot of discussion this morning about that very important point.
    • 03:28:43
      to staff up to our full maximum employment level of 7,499.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 03:28:47
      Mr. Chairman, this is an excellent plan and something that's been needed for a long while.
    • 03:29:00
      A minor point, but the phrasing, the staffing up to 7,500 positions, I think sends a message that's a magic arbitrary number.
    • 03:29:10
      In fact, it's a legal limit.
    • 03:29:13
      But I would suggest that some language like staffing up to optimum staffing for maximum efficiency and effectiveness, not to exceed the legal limit rather than setting out a number
    • 03:29:27
      Like we need to hire more people because we need to get that magic number, 7500.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:29:32
      That's a good point, Mr. Bowie, and part of our evaluation and our moving forward will be making sure that we put those personnel resources into the right locations where it can meet our business needs, not simply we need to fill chairs.
    • 03:29:49
      We need to fill the right chairs with the right people.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:29:54
      Just one comment on that from Mr. Bowie.
    • 03:29:58
      We saw that in reverse the other way when they were mandated to get to a certain level and it disrupted operations so significantly.
    • 03:30:06
      So I think that's an excellent point you make.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:30:10
      And then finally in the area of technology is really to take advantage of new technology and we've been making some real strides in that area.
    • 03:30:21
      So the summary of the goals, and you'll find these eight goals follow the Governor's Multimodal Plan, and that's why they're written in the fashion that they are.
    • 03:30:31
      But again, I'm just going to hit some highlights of some things, some action items that we're going to be taking in conjunction with this.
    • 03:30:40
      The very first is a very important one, and that is to rebuild our shelf of projects by
    • 03:30:48
      We're not injecting 10 to 15 percent of our construction program into preliminary engineering.
    • 03:30:53
      You've heard a lot about we cleared our shelves off with Aura and other projects and we really don't have projects ready to go like we need to.
    • 03:31:03
      So this is an important step for us to, again, maintain an inventory of projects as funding becomes available to put projects out on the street.
    • 03:31:15
      In accelerating projects, we are going to continue to look at design-build as well as some other contracting methods to deliver projects.
    • 03:31:24
      Importantly, to refocus our 24-month advertisement project delivery meetings, we will be meeting monthly with each of the districts to ensure that we are looking ahead over the next 24 months to make sure that we are able to take those design projects
    • 03:31:44
      and put them out the contract as we have planned it.
    • 03:31:48
      We have had some difficulty in the past in meeting those targets and again this is a very deliberate focus.
    • 03:31:59
      The second goal is about supporting economic opportunity, includes a commitment to some of the major PPTA projects in Virginia.
    • 03:32:09
      and to deliver not just those projects but all projects on time.
    • 03:32:16
      Also, it's important for us to communicate to the Commonwealth Transportation Board and the General Assembly and our stakeholders the benefits of these key projects in the Six-Year Plan and so we'll be responsible for providing updates both to this body as well as the General Assembly.
    • 03:32:35
      Goal 3 talks about a collaborative transportation planning process.
    • 03:32:43
      and in that is greater outreach to the MPOs and PDCs and that was one of the several audits that were conducted over the last year, talked about an increased need for interaction and cooperative efforts with the MPOs and PDCs.
    • 03:33:01
      To evaluate all of our programming procedures, again going back to looking at how we deliver these projects and ensuring that our processes and our programming
    • 03:33:12
      meets our newer business model.
    • 03:33:16
      Also to support localities in land use decisions and land use planning.
    • 03:33:25
      Goal four talks about sustainable and stable financial support.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:33:30
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:33:31
      Yes.
    • 03:33:31
      Go back to goal three a little before we move on in this planning and implementation process.
    • 03:33:41
      One of the things that I look at as the meeting calls for a planning and programming session with MPOs and PDCs
    • 03:33:50
      I think we need to look at the level of the ability of the PDCs to participate very much along these lines.
    • 03:33:58
      I think they're really handicapped with staff and with resources to be a major player, at least some are in my region, to have any significant input to the information, the data, and the planning that takes place.
    • 03:34:14
      And so as I see more and more emphasis placed on relying on the PDCs, I'm more and more concerned because we don't have a broad input from those rural regions whenever we just rely on them.
    • 03:34:29
      So I think we need to look at that and examine that a little bit.
    • 03:34:32
      And the other part that I would suggest is that we go back to district hearings on six-year plans.
    • 03:34:39
      And the thing that's involved there is some of the hearings are held, you know, three and a half hours away from some of the people that would normally attend.
    • 03:34:49
      And I can understand cutting back when we didn't have funds that could actually impact a maintenance project or a construction project in certain regions.
    • 03:34:58
      But now that we have a six-year plan that does include some monies going through various projects out there, I would be in favor of going back to maybe not each district but a system of rotating or trying to involve the public some more and educating on what we're trying to do and this type of thing.
    • 03:35:17
      So, you know, going back to the district hearings, I know it's difficult for the staff and I know that it's an important function.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:35:24
      And thank you, Mr. Keenan.
    • 03:35:26
      Part of our, as you'll see through the plan, is continued improvements in relationships with stakeholders, with local government, with general assembly, with special interest groups, so a point well taken, sir.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:41
      Yeah, I'd like to second what Mr.
    • 03:35:42
      Keen said.
    • 03:35:43
      We need to go back to these districts so our people can get there.
    • 03:35:47
      I think that's essential, and if we can't afford that, we can hang it up.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:56
      One, Mr. Chairman, we will hear more about the need, you know, that gap in understanding the needs.
    • 03:36:03
      When you hear it from all those districts and when it's held in a place that they can all get there, you're going to have a good demonstration of what the needs are with the projects and concerns that they bring to those meetings.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:36:18
      Thank you.
    • 03:36:22
      Goal four talks about, again, sustainable and stable financial support.
    • 03:36:29
      One of the things, and you've already seen this, it's an ongoing activity, is reviewing our spending activity at each CTB meeting, working with Federal Highway Administration to streamline the obligation of federal funds.
    • 03:36:43
      That is a fairly complicated and labor-intensive process that we go through, again, working with them to better streamline that process.
    • 03:36:53
      Another important aspect, and we talked about it this morning, was ensuring that the maintenance allocation year-end balance is under $100 million by June 2012.
    • 03:37:03
      Again, that was a subject of much discussion today, and it's first and foremost on the minds of our districts and our maintenance, both central office and field maintenance staff.
    • 03:37:15
      They very clearly understand the importance of getting the work out there on the road.
    • 03:37:24
      The establishment of the implementation of VTIB is another important aspect and we're continuing to work through that process and also the issuance of the CPR and the GARVEE bonds.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:37:40
      Charlie, how are we going to structure that with CTB input?
    • 03:37:45
      Are we going to have some workshops or something on that bank?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:37:50
      Regarding the VTIB?
    • 03:37:51
      Yeah.
    • 03:37:52
      I think that Mr. Lawson and others are continuing to develop that
    • 03:37:59
      How that bank will act in the formation, you should expect that briefings back to the Commonwealth Transportation Board regarding that.
    • 03:38:08
      But again, we're working to maximize the benefit of that bank to the Commonwealth.
    • 03:38:15
      But yes, you should expect briefings back to the board.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:38:19
      Do you have any idea on timing on that?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:38:21
      I do not.
    • 03:38:25
      Moving on in Goal 4, we talked earlier about meeting our target condition assessments on pavement and bridges, and you see that reference there.
    • 03:38:50
      There's also a need to reevaluate some of the classifications of some of our roadways.
    • 03:38:57
      That's been a discussion at previous board meetings regarding some high volume secondary roads, especially in some of our urban areas.
    • 03:39:07
      Also under Goal 4, examining the fee structure on some of our key services as well as continuing to work with Federal Highway to obtain approval as a total of I-95 in Virginia.
    • 03:39:25
      Goal 5 relates to technology and environmental protection.
    • 03:39:29
      One of the couple of those to highlight is the implementation recommendations from the research audit and really reinforcing the need to put our research to work on the roadway.
    • 03:39:40
      Some great research we've done.
    • 03:39:42
      In addition is the re-establishment of the Technology Investment Committee.
    • 03:39:46
      I chair that committee and the intent of that is to ensure that our information technology, our business solutions, our computers are really focused on what's important to deliver service.
    • 03:39:58
      and that we're not spending resources and dollars on systems that maybe do not provide the maximum benefit to the Commonwealth.
    • 03:40:11
      Continuing on, evaluating the cost effectiveness of our traffic operation centers and also the function of those operation centers.
    • 03:40:23
      That's one of the key areas where we can provide
    • 03:40:26
      Better information to the motorists in Virginia, provide them opportunities for work around some, there's a lot of technology that we were working with in that area.
    • 03:40:35
      And included in that is an investment of $15 million to upgrade a number of our overhead dynamic message signs.
    • 03:40:42
      We have a number of those signs that either are inoperable or obsolete throughout Virginia.
    • 03:40:48
      Some are the old-style green panels that flip over, and we are in the process of actively upgrading those and integrating those so, again, we can provide better traveler information.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:41:00
      Mr. Chairman, let me make just one brief comment.
    • 03:41:03
      I think you got a call a couple of weeks ago from one of our favorite legislators who was
    • 03:41:12
      Press Conference that the governor had down in our neck of the woods.
    • 03:41:16
      And I would tell you, I would just pile on, I guess, that the signs in Hampton Roads might as well not be there because they're not effective because they're not accurate.
    • 03:41:29
      And that's based on me driving there since they were built.
    • 03:41:33
      I'll tell you it's a five-mile backup and it's zero.
    • 03:41:39
      I'll tell you it's no backup and there is one.
    • 03:41:42
      They're either not kept up, Tommy, or something.
    • 03:41:45
      There's some operational problem that's sort of endemic to them there anyway, and I'm not an expert across all of them.
    • 03:41:54
      And Hampton Roads, they're just not.
    • 03:41:57
      They're not useful.
    • 03:41:59
      In fact, they're counter useful.
    • 03:42:01
      Because you've got this great indecision.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:42:04
      What do you do?
    • 03:42:06
      We've made some physical changes, but sometimes you still can't read them, even if they were accurate.
    • 03:42:13
      You couldn't read them because the lighting is not such that all the letters show up.
    • 03:42:17
      It's a frustrating thing because you want to rely on them, honestly.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:42:20
      Absolutely, and I think that this is one of the many areas of us to return some focus.
    • 03:42:29
      We are currently in the process of replacing the guts on a number of those boards, mostly on the peninsula.
    • 03:42:35
      that are either, again, inoperable or obsolete to get those message boards working and talking to each other.
    • 03:42:42
      I got that same phone call, so I know exactly the discussion and I shared, legislators, some of the things that we are doing and really the need to continue to make significant improvements in that area with our message boards, our highway advisory radios,
    • 03:43:03
      our 511 system, those things that we have got to get ourselves in a position where the public can rely on that information that's being put on those systems that is accurate and that is timely.
    • 03:43:19
      As an aside to this, we are actively working on a project to provide travel time along some corridors and Hampton Roads.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:43:27
      I was in Florida recently and the signs worked well as far as I can tell.
    • 03:43:32
      I don't spend a lot of time there, but it would tell you how long it's going to take you to get from A to B, and I was there for a few days, and that's how long it took me.
    • 03:43:41
      I had just a short amount of information, and that's always dangerous, but I kind of liked it.
    • 03:43:47
      It didn't tell me what the backup was.
    • 03:43:49
      It told me how long it thought it was going to take me to get there, which was really all you want to know at the end of the day.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:43:56
      We have a couple of projects underway both in Northern Virginia and in Hampton Roads to make some significant improvements and to start posting travel times later in the summer and early fall in Northern Virginia and by the end of the year in Hampton Roads.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:12
      Does that include the installation of real-time
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:44:18
      Virginia participates in a contract that the I-95 Court Coalition has where we are actually buying real-time traffic information from INREX.
    • 03:44:38
      A company that does that and that we are supplementing our own data with that and we've already developed the algorithms and tested them for their accuracy.
    • 03:44:48
      At this point we're just trying to get all the equipment in good working order to be able to start posting.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:01
      We don't have messages to go through.
    • 03:45:11
      If you ever notice what happens, I've actually seen accidents and backups occur because when it's two messages, it's like
    • 03:45:18
      Accident in the head, blah, blah, blah, and it stops.
    • 03:45:22
      It goes and continues to the next one.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:25
      People then stop and look.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:28
      I've seen more accidents.
    • 03:45:31
      In fact, I see it up in Northern Virginia, particularly where I live, 234.
    • 03:45:37
      You have the truck scales, you have 234 entrance, and you have a sign right there.
    • 03:45:43
      People coming on, they don't realize they're stopping to look as trucks are trying to go over the way scale.
    • 03:45:48
      I've seen more rear ends, and it's just sort of the thing where people just naturally, they want to see what the sign says, and sort of two messages.
    • 03:45:57
      Now, in defense, by the way, of that telephone call, I just have to clarify the record about that telephone call on that message being wrong.
    • 03:46:04
      If anything, it showed that we don't have backup systems to our signs because what had happened was the power went out.
    • 03:46:12
      That scene was one of the other little storms.
    • 03:46:14
      The power went out to the sign, so it locked into a certain message and then they couldn't unlock it because there's no power, but we didn't have a backup power.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:46:24
      That's correct.
    • 03:46:26
      While we have backup power to certain systems, we don't have backup power to all of our systems.
    • 03:46:32
      And as the Secretary commented, it knocked the system in the head, and so it brought up the last message it knew.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:43
      And so it... Well, you know, you can't...
    • 03:46:45
      It can't be a hundred percent, I understand that, and I only use that particular circumstances illustration because he was heated and the players were all in the room.
    • 03:46:55
      Yes, sir.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:56
      W.P.O.P., Traffic and Weather on the 8th.
    • 03:46:58
      In Virginia, that's what we use.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:47:01
      There's a call that has traffic information.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:47:03
      I'll tell you that generally, you know, I look at my GPS as opposed to the signs.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:47:08
      And that's sort of a, you know, that's sort of like a...
    • 03:47:12
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:47:13
      But you can afford a GPS.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:47:19
      No, no, you're fine.
    • 03:47:22
      I'll just breathe, breathe.
    • 03:47:24
      Let the record show that I'm pressing forward.
    • 03:47:28
      Also, in technology and systems management, an important point is increasing the number of park and ride lots.
    • 03:47:38
      specifically referenced here is on the I-95 corridor.
    • 03:47:42
      We recognized in the, especially in the Salem area, there have been some discussions also about some improvements between Christiansburg and Roanoke.
    • 03:47:52
      In the environmental protection area, again, it's 100% compliance with our environmental reports.
    • 03:47:58
      And what that means is that doesn't mean that we won't have a erosion sediment control issue on a project.
    • 03:48:04
      What it means is
    • 03:48:06
      That when an issue comes up, we will address it 100% of the time.
    • 03:48:11
      So again, and that's been a dashboard benchmark for some time.
    • 03:48:17
      Goal 6 focuses on customer service and developing a comprehensive public awareness communication plan.
    • 03:48:26
      We recognize that we've got to do a much better job of communicating with the public.
    • 03:48:31
      evaluating customer service operations center for effectiveness and efficiency.
    • 03:48:37
      As you know, most phone calls from the public now come into our customer service center, and we need to continue to improve that system to provide good information, good service, and timely feedback.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:48:52
      Mr. Chairman, I have a quick question there.
    • 03:48:55
      When we talk about communicating better with the public,
    • 03:49:01
      In my area, and I think in other areas, people don't like when we have these hearings.
    • 03:49:07
      They like the old-fashioned town hall hearing where a presentation is made for everybody.
    • 03:49:13
      They can all hear the same thing, except where you just wander around and there's no focus.
    • 03:49:18
      They feel that it's confusing.
    • 03:49:20
      And some people say they heard something from a VDOT staff, and another person said they heard something different.
    • 03:49:27
      They're not all hearing the same thing.
    • 03:49:29
      But remember when we used to have the hearings, we're all in one room.
    • 03:49:33
      And you had a VDOT staff, I guess, conduct it.
    • 03:49:37
      What we're having to do in my district is having to come back since the initial hearings really didn't work and people were confused.
    • 03:49:43
      We've had to come back and set up a task force and actually do that hearing like the old-fashioned town hall hearing.
    • 03:49:52
      So it's something to consider.
    • 03:49:53
      Now do the districts have discretion as to what type of hearing they have?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:50:01
      I believe so.
    • 03:50:02
      And the challenge that we've had over the years is the balance between providing good consistent information and giving everyone the opportunity to speak or to have their questions answered in the format where there's a presentation and people come to the podium one after another.
    • 03:50:20
      There sometimes tends to be a, some folks feel intimidated by and not comfortable with their ability to really ask the questions and learn about the project.
    • 03:50:32
      It becomes again in some cases more of a point counterpoint and not so much as a good information sharing.
    • 03:50:40
      So I think there's a balance that we need to continue to work in that area.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:43
      With a good moderator you can control that stuff.
    • 03:50:47
      Just the point that I'm hearing in my area.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:50:51
      Also regarding in the area of incident reduction, improving and increasing our safety service patrol presence.
    • 03:50:59
      That was one of the areas we cut back significantly a year ago and recognized the value of those patrollers on our interstate system for quick incident clearance as well as maintaining traffic flow.
    • 03:51:16
      And then you'll see there the display of real travel time in major Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads corridors and that again is a commitment of ours.
    • 03:51:29
      In the area of improved safety is to develop a plan to improve our signs in our corridors of statewide significance.
    • 03:51:37
      Again, we have some older sign structures and maybe not the most informative signs for working in that area as well as improving our HSIP program.
    • 03:51:47
      is a program where we do a lot of projects large and small.
    • 03:51:51
      Right now we have a lot of small projects that are draining some of the resources.
    • 03:51:56
      We're looking towards getting some larger projects, some high-impact projects around the state to get some safety features on our system.
    • 03:52:08
      And then finally goal eight focuses on employees and promoting and enforcing a workforce safety plan, improving our safety conditions to develop technical training for our staff and for, again, there's another reference to streamlining
    • 03:52:27
      Processes, one of the things that I think we can make a life much better for those 7,499 employees is to ensure that our processes are effective and not overly burdensome or they preclude good decision making.
    • 03:52:49
      As I finish up, there's also coordination with the movement of the Inspector General, which will be effective July 2012.
    • 03:53:04
      So finally the next step is to develop a plan for each of these action items which we have done to implement the plan and monitor the progress which is underway and again to provide quarterly updates back to the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 03:53:19
      As I said at the beginning, this is a plan that has true action steps and activities and things that you should expect to see within VDOT and in the delivery of our services.
    • 03:53:32
      So thank you very much for giving me the time this afternoon.
    • 03:53:42
      P. Freeze.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:44
      All right, well you're doing good.
    • 03:53:45
      You're doing much better than I was.
    • 03:53:48
      Thank you.
    • 03:53:49
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:53:50
      Yes, Ms. Light.
    • 03:53:51
      I had one question, Charlie.
    • 03:53:52
      Well, Patrick, wait a minute.
    • 03:53:53
      Where you running off to?
    • 03:53:54
      Come on back.
    • 03:53:56
      I almost made it.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:53:59
      On goal one, one of the, you know, you currently agreed with, we're gonna start allocating a portion of 10 to 15% of the construction program for PE.
    • 03:54:07
      Do you have any idea what's been going to that in the last few years?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:54:12
      The percentage of the total six-year plan that's gone to engineering, I don't have that and I don't know if Mr. Curley has stepped out.
    • 03:54:27
      What have we done in the past as far as the percent of our allocation that we've really dedicated towards preliminary engineering?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:34
      No, we've never really had a set percentage that we're dedicated for PE.
    • 03:54:40
      and we quite frankly funded at two lower levels in the past.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:54:46
      This is an increase because we've been darn short of getting things ready and keeping the pipeline going.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:51
      Right, so what we're doing is after this six-year program is approved there will be a schedule that focuses only on preliminary engineering and from that schedule we will be looking at the start dates of all design work and from that I'm trying to accelerate
    • 03:55:09
      Those design projects, so I got about 10 to 15% of design work going on this fiscal year so that I can get designs on the shelf and ready to go.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:55:24
      I guess you'll evaluate that percentage over time to see if it needs to be tweaked up or down.
    • 03:55:28
      The whole idea is to keep projects flowing in the plan.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:55:33
      That's the idea.
    • 03:55:34
      And there's a balance there.
    • 03:55:36
      You want to maintain an inventory of future projects
    • 03:55:39
      We also want to be smart about those projects that we're not inventorying projects that can go stale.
    • 03:55:45
      So there's certain types of projects that tend not to do that.
    • 03:55:49
      Some interstate projects where you're not buying right-of-way if you're within an existing right-of-way.
    • 03:55:55
      Major rehabilitation, whether it's bridge or pavement.
    • 03:55:58
      Those kinds of things are projects that we can really
    • 03:56:02
      What you don't want to do is spend a lot of money, and I'll use examples of secondary improvement projects where there's a project in Stafford County that's underway that the original design was done in the mid-'80s.
    • 03:56:21
      and so it's been over 20, close to 30 years from the original design to when it went to advertisement and it basically required a complete redesign so you want to be careful not to create obsolete plan sets also.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:56:38
      I just want to thank Charlie for a really great presentation.
    • 03:56:42
      I think there's a lot of good things in this.
    • 03:56:46
      I've talked to the commissioner and the chief engineer for design about this whole idea of value engineering.
    • 03:56:55
      trying to prevent over-engineering with context-sensitive design.
    • 03:57:00
      Also, maybe looking at best practices nationally and internationally.
    • 03:57:06
      You know, a lot of the OECD countries, the more developed countries, you go around and you don't see any of these old-fashioned intersections that are signals.
    • 03:57:16
      They're all roundabouts.
    • 03:57:17
      They're cheaper, they're safer, you don't pay a dominion for the electricity, and they're cheaper to build.
    • 03:57:26
      We need to have that, I think, as a component, working with Muhammad and to try to build that into it.
    • 03:57:35
      I think we save a lot of money when we have these types of cases.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:57:40
      It is important with us moving forward that we maintain the best way to describe it is a balance between good engineering but also the flexibility in addressing the public's needs so that we're not always forcing a strict engineering solution that may not be economically or socially acceptable.
    • 03:58:11
      Thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:12
      Runway again?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:58:13
      I'm running.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:14
      All right, 29.
    • 03:58:16
      It's Koelemay.
    • 03:58:20
      Here we go.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:38
      Good afternoon.
    • 03:58:40
      I'm here to talk about a term that strikes fear in the hearts of many people.
    • 03:58:46
      I'm going to say corridor out loud.
    • 03:58:49
      No, this briefing this afternoon is simply meant to catch you up on the work that we've done in studying this corridor 29.
    • 03:59:00
      As we designated our initial corridors of statewide significance, it became clear that at least on US 29,
    • 03:59:08
      There were a lot of outstanding issues that simple designation as a corridor of significance really didn't solve.
    • 03:59:16
      This corridor, as you know, extends all the way from Northern Virginia down to North Carolina, so it's one of the major arteries north-south in the state.
    • 03:59:26
      It connects three major metropolitan areas.
    • 03:59:28
      It involves a highway service, obviously, but also rail service.
    • 03:59:32
      It's a major freight corridor.
    • 03:59:34
      and is now increasingly a major commuter route as well.
    • 03:59:39
      Those multiple needs showed that we needed to do some additional study of this corridor based on the work that the CTB did in designating the corridors in the first place.
    • 03:59:50
      So we put this together as part of the acceptance of the report on corridors that a subcommittee should be appointed to continue the study and focus on some specific objectives.
    • 04:00:03
      The CTB at the time accepted the consensus that was put together about US 29, but also said there's additional information, additional interests, additional positions, additional concerns that are up and down the corridor in the various jurisdictions and planning agencies.
    • 04:00:22
      The CTB directed both VDOT and DRPT to work with a subcommittee of the board, which was then constituted
    • 04:00:31
      to put together a draft process of how to go forward.
    • 04:00:33
      In other words, the Carter Statewide Significance designation created a skeleton, but there was no flesh on the bones.
    • 04:00:43
      The direction was pretty specific.
    • 04:00:44
      You can see the four areas we were asked to focus on, including a prioritized list of intersections, a plan to improve mobility and accessibility in and around Charlottesville,
    • 04:00:56
      A plan to improve mobility and accessibility in what's known as the Buckland region, Gainesville Haymarket area, a little further north.
    • 04:01:04
      And then a plan to minimize the number of traffic signals in the corridor, which we're increasingly beginning to cut down on the connectivity and the ability to move through the corridor as opposed to stop and go within the corridor.
    • 04:01:17
      It also said that we would authorize a review program for the corridor once a new blueprint is approved
    • 04:01:25
      And we term those corridor master plans, which is ultimately the goal of designating the corridor.
    • 04:01:32
      And the master plan is meant to bring back, bring together all the interest within the corridor and make sure that people arrive at a consensus view of the future for the corridor and therefore has much better understanding of the implementing steps that are required, whether they're transportation investments or land use decisions.
    • 04:01:50
      As you can see, service on the committee immediately turned into a way that you could get parenthesis around your names.
    • 04:01:58
      So I stand here as the sole survivor of the original subcommittee.
    • 04:02:04
      I hope some of the recommendations of the subcommittee last longer than some members.
    • 04:02:08
      But I will say this.
    • 04:02:10
      Butch Davies was very, very helpful, obviously, in his understanding of the Charlottesville issues.
    • 04:02:16
      Peter Schwartz brought extraordinary
    • 04:02:19
      insight into the nuances of the Buckland-Gainesville Haymarket area. Sharon Pandack, who is relatively new to the board, really brought a great legal understanding of the interplay between the jurisdictions and the Commonwealth on these matters. And finally, Ken White was really the diplomat who was able to have everyone still talk to one another and keep us on track. so I appreciate all the work they did and it was great to be their chairman.
    • 04:02:48
      When Jim Rich, Mark Peake, and now Gary Garczynski were added to committee, I also enjoyed working with them.
    • 04:02:54
      They brought a fresh set of eyes to the work that we had already done, and they not only helped us polish up what we had done, but they made us review it again and make sure we weren't just going with the most plausible answers out of the box.
    • 04:03:07
      I will say that a couple of the other members also attended regularly some of the additional subcommittee meetings, so we had a pretty good transition of the original committee
    • 04:03:17
      Sub-Committee and the new members who are here.
    • 04:03:19
      In presenting this report, though, I wouldn't presume to speak for any one of them individually.
    • 04:03:25
      They all have their own ideas about exactly how important and what should go forward here.
    • 04:03:30
      So I want to leave that open for them to give their own opinion about it.
    • 04:03:34
      But our consensus is what I'm going to present to you now.
    • 04:03:38
      The report matches up with the specific tasks that we were given by the CTB.
    • 04:03:46
      First of all, we needed to work with the others, and secondly, we had these specific work and studies.
    • 04:03:52
      Let me just go through these very quickly.
    • 04:03:55
      You can read them here.
    • 04:03:56
      We went through the additional specific work and study.
    • 04:04:00
      This fourth step is this corridor master plan presentation for board review and approval today.
    • 04:04:06
      The cost was of the consultant continued, but that's an accounting thing.
    • 04:04:11
      Who cares about that?
    • 04:04:13
      Okay.
    • 04:04:15
      First of all, we did prioritize a list of intersections that we thought could be replaced by grade separated intersections or interchanges as traffic and freight and other things grew on 29.
    • 04:04:28
      Got this kind of prioritized list.
    • 04:04:30
      Safety and congestion relief really are the main criteria, and we have this list for your consideration by the board.
    • 04:04:39
      Second, we looked at how we could improve mobility and accessibility north of Charlottesville, evaluating various alternatives that have been presented over time, but we didn't want to limit ourselves to those prior proposals, most of which have a lot of for them and against them that come attached.
    • 04:04:58
      The fact is there's been new solutions that have emerged both for technology reasons and land use decisions that have been made.
    • 04:05:05
      So what we've proposed in this case is that we begin a series of cross-jurisdictional discussions with leaders from the Charlottesville area, but also include those from the immediately adjacent areas in Lynchburg and Danville.
    • 04:05:21
      After all, we're trying to deal with a corridor here, not just a subsection of the corridor.
    • 04:05:26
      And we developed a proposal for facilitating these discussions that we would like the board to consider.
    • 04:05:34
      The key for this type of exercise is that people not bring their for and against or their I like that proposal or I don't like that proposal.
    • 04:05:44
      It's really to start back at the beginning in which people and jurisdictions can state their interests and what's going to happen because by stating interests you can come up with different alternatives than necessarily have hardened into for and against in the past.
    • 04:06:01
      Similarly for Buckland, Haymarket, Gainesville area, we also see discussions between local leaders as being the starting point.
    • 04:06:11
      We do think we can help facilitate those discussions, but the fact is the very different views that jurisdictions have, Prince William, Fauquier, Haymarket, and so forth, need to be in the room from the beginning so that everyone feels like they are having an equal presentation of their interests and concerns.
    • 04:06:32
      D. was how do we minimize the number of traffic signals in the corridor?
    • 04:06:36
      First of all, we obviously needed a plan that takes into consideration the transportation objectives both locally and in the corridor itself.
    • 04:06:46
      So we proposed the development of a master plan on Route 29 and other corridors of statewide significance that would better control access and congestion and ensure safety by limiting the number of traffic signals.
    • 04:06:59
      Now the corridor system is a resource of the state.
    • 04:07:03
      So that's because the corridor plans help preserve the Commonwealth's interest and investments in preserving transportation resources.
    • 04:07:12
      In other words, the ability to move throughout the state as opposed to just within certain local jurisdictions.
    • 04:07:19
      And a lot of commercial entrances, curb cuts, traffic lights, other things cut down on that ability to actually move people and goods.
    • 04:07:28
      So our master plan and process that we are generally recommending would preserve that function as a corridor, provide guidance for localities and other jurisdictions so that they can design access in a way that doesn't jeopardize the throughput of the corridor itself.
    • 04:07:50
      We require or are suggesting that corridor master plans be developed jointly with the local jurisdictions and that they become an element of the local comprehensive plan.
    • 04:07:58
      It doesn't mean we tell the localities what to do.
    • 04:08:01
      It just means that once as a group we determine what the plan is that we incorporate it into our decisions and localities incorporate it into theirs.
    • 04:08:11
      We recommend a pilot study to develop this corridor master plan proposal.
    • 04:08:16
      An appropriate segment on Route 29 would be a good place to start.
    • 04:08:20
      But there's other corridors in the Commonwealth who face some of these same challenges.
    • 04:08:25
      So our recommendation for local corridor master plans as a part of the corridor statewide significant process is also included in the resolution.
    • 04:08:35
      This is a difficult chart to read on the board.
    • 04:08:38
      It's a little difficult to read even in your handout.
    • 04:08:41
      But as you can see, it's a multi-faceted process.
    • 04:08:44
      It involves all the potential players right from the beginning.
    • 04:08:49
      It's meant to be very transparent and ongoing and arrive at a consensus view and a consensus plan that both the localities and the state and regional authorities, the private sector, all can incorporate into their plans going forward.
    • 04:09:06
      So that's my report, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:09:08
      I'd be glad to take any questions people may have or, alternately, any comments my fellow subcommittee members might have.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 04:09:18
      Mr. Coleman, I just want to thank you for a very well-run subcommittee from the time I got on it.
    • 04:09:26
      Thank you.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:09:37
      Thank you for your participation, too.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:09:40
      Comments, questions?
    • 04:09:41
      Mr. Chairman, I would like to second what Mr. Peake said.
    • 04:09:44
      I appreciate your service, Doug, and the members that were serving before I got on.
    • 04:09:49
      You all have done most of the work.
    • 04:09:51
      There's a lot of good things in this proposal.
    • 04:09:55
      I think if we all work in good faith on this, we can get something done.
    • 04:10:00
      We really emphasize this by trying to cut down on the packaging and the curb cuts, as I recall.
    • 04:10:08
      We knew right on that we can't afford to build bypasses through all of 29.
    • 04:10:14
      and so we have to be distant from there, maybe enter into MOUs with the localities after we have a full and complete discussion of how to deal with all of this.
    • 04:10:28
      I would say recently in the Charlottesville area I've had some very, very good meetings with the county and the city and the business community that all sat down and provided a list of about five projects
    • 04:10:43
      It could be done, but everybody could agree on it.
    • 04:10:47
      And recently the city just gave up jurisdiction over a major project, what we call the best buyer ramp, where the 29 goes into 250.
    • 04:10:57
      It's a huge backup.
    • 04:11:00
      But they wanted to control the project, but I think VDOT and the county, and I myself, it might be better administered by VDOT.
    • 04:11:13
      And so even though they had the legal right to manage that on their own, they realized the significance of this not only for the city but for the county and for people going through and they gave up the jurisdiction so VDOT could administer it.
    • 04:11:30
      So I'm starting to see a great level of cooperation and if we can build on that type of thing, everybody's pulling in the same direction, I think we can make a lot of progress.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:11:42
      Did I understand one of your slides?
    • 04:11:49
      They're not numbered so I can't tell you which one it was, but it had to do with corridor master plans must be incorporated into local comprehensive plans.
    • 04:11:59
      Is that an act?
    • 04:12:00
      No, that is correct.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:02
      The Carter Master Plans are only arrived at as a process that involves the localities and the regional authorities.
    • 04:12:14
      adopted a McCarter Master Plan without the localities approval.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:18
      So it's meant to- The consultation and actually facilitation of meetings and so on.
    • 04:12:24
      Exactly.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:25
      In other words, it has to be a joint effort.
    • 04:12:27
      It's not meant to impose the state's power on the localities.
    • 04:12:32
      It's the opposite, in fact.
    • 04:12:33
      It's to put the Commonwealth and the localities and regional authorities in the same process
    • 04:12:39
      So that whatever the answer is, everybody shares in its creation and shares in the implications for their investment decision.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:45
      So you wouldn't get to an answer if everybody actually agreed?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:50
      That is correct.
    • 04:12:52
      That is correct.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:54
      Mr.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:56
      Chair?
    • 04:12:56
      It sounds good sort of philosophically and on paper, but that means that one locality can hold all others hostage.
    • 04:13:03
      Well the practicalities still remain to emerge of exactly how this is implemented but we saw number one
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:32
      We need to put forward a good faith effort at the beginning.
    • 04:13:36
      So if people come into the process with bad faith, we do have to figure out how to deal with that.
    • 04:13:41
      The second is by giving the Carter Master Plans some priority within our own deliberations at the CTB and by giving the Carter Master Plan some priority within the Comprehensive Plan by including it,
    • 04:13:58
      You're hoping that you can induce the positive behavior you want.
    • 04:14:02
      In other words, there are carrots that you get by facilitating this process and coming to a decision.
    • 04:14:08
      You would be more likely to be able to carry through your own comprehensive plan as well as get the needed transportation investments from the state because there is this master plan that both parties or all parties are working from.
    • 04:14:22
      In the absence of that, it would become more difficult.
    • 04:14:25
      It's unclear where the transportation investment might fit.
    • 04:14:30
      There might be the same kind of wrestling matches that go on now between who has the say-so at a particular location about land use or development.
    • 04:14:38
      So I think we see the process as being a positive force that would help people want to reach an agreement because the potential for additional investment and more rapid development would be possible.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:50
      I guess I'm a little nervous.
    • 04:14:52
      We've got state now which is mandating these urban development areas, which is largely a land use issue, which has been a local responsibility.
    • 04:15:01
      And now we're basically, in this context, we'd be putting a transportation decision subject to a local, which has largely been a state responsibility.
    • 04:15:12
      The lines are being not only blurred here, but put in such a way that we might not see much progress being made for the Commonwealth as a whole, and I'm just a little nervous about how that works out in the end.
    • 04:15:23
      Granted, if everybody operates in good faith, that works well, but one person's definition of good faith could be quite different than another person's.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:15:33
      Well, part of our discussion is actually, obviously, once you get off specific situations,
    • 04:15:39
      And in general, I think what we all realized was neither localities nor the Commonwealth, certainly not as we heard earlier today, even the federal government, will ever again have all the resources at their disposal to do everything they can think of in terms of transportation.
    • 04:15:58
      So it really becomes very important to figure out which of the things that are priorities to do that give us the greatest congestion relief or the biggest bang for the buck
    • 04:16:09
      Because those are the things we're going to be able to afford, and there's no extra money to go back and do the other thing if you choose poorly.
    • 04:16:16
      I love that Indiana Jones quote, he chose poorly.
    • 04:16:23
      So we realize that.
    • 04:16:24
      Localities are in that same situation.
    • 04:16:26
      So the idea that I don't have to find out what VDOT's going to do, I can just plan this over here.
    • 04:16:32
      And the same thing for us.
    • 04:16:34
      Well, we're just going to do this rail line, and we don't really care what Lynchburg's going to think about it.
    • 04:16:38
      Those kind of days are over.
    • 04:16:40
      We can't not have these things connected any longer.
    • 04:16:44
      I agree with you, Cord.
    • 04:16:46
      Some of the connections we're trying to make between land use and transportation investment are a little bit awkward.
    • 04:16:54
      And I mentioned to Aubrey earlier this afternoon, I said the conclusion that the federalist system really works is probably premature.
    • 04:17:02
      These are huge questions that have to be worked out.
    • 04:17:05
      But I do think this is a mechanism and a piece of a process for us that allows us to put a tool in that is transparent, that does invite and in fact requires local and regional participation right from the beginning, not at some future time.
    • 04:17:21
      and that potentially this can be one of those things that helps build trust as well as build competence in the area.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:17:31
      Mr. Secretary, Doug, I want to ask you where do we go, what is the specific recommendation for taking this to its next step?
    • 04:17:45
      Is it the establishment of another
    • 04:17:48
      Subcommittee, is this something that's going to come under David's auspices as he looks at all the corridors and tries to focus on smaller pieces of them?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:00
      Yeah, I think our recommendation has two pieces.
    • 04:18:03
      One is if it's the wisdom of the CTB, we could proceed with one of the two subsections of this corridor that we identified as having unique circumstances.
    • 04:18:17
      or obviously the CTB could obviously designate another corridor to choose to begin to implement this process instead, perhaps one that's less contentious or shorter or less complex in some way, in other words, just to get the model rolling.
    • 04:18:34
      I don't have a personal view about that.
    • 04:18:36
      I don't think the committee necessarily saw it inevitably.
    • 04:18:39
      It had to be the follow-on of its own work on 29, but that certainly is a possibility and probably makes some sense.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:47
      Chairman, if I could comment on that.
    • 04:18:50
      I think, unless I have the wrong recollection, the committee seemed to want to proceed with the subcommittee with the involvement of the members who were
    • 04:19:02
      along the corridor that we just proceed to try to make some progress.
    • 04:19:08
      There's no guarantee that we will, but unless we try, we never will.
    • 04:19:14
      So we'd like to just go forward and just see how far we can go.
    • 04:19:18
      I never thought I could see, for example, the city of Charlottesville and the county sit down and the business community, which is also extremely important, sit down and agree on five major projects.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:19:31
      Well, I'd just like to conclude by saying I think Mr. Kilpatrick's presentation earlier and this one really are sharing a set of common characteristics and that's that
    • 04:19:53
      People do expect transparency.
    • 04:19:55
      They do expect a reflection of their views and needs.
    • 04:19:59
      They do expect the system to be responsive.
    • 04:20:04
      They do expect to participate.
    • 04:20:07
      And then they expect to be able to evaluate it according to their own terms.
    • 04:20:11
      So this is a process that potentially opens up a much more interactive way to arrive at some common decisions, less one-way street, more participation.
    • 04:20:22
      and it's an inclusive process.
    • 04:20:24
      So it is a process, however, no particular outcome is guaranteed and it does rely on the good sense and trust of the people that are involved, so.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:40
      Any other questions?
    • 04:20:42
      Great job.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:42
      Thank you very much.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 04:20:43
      Okay, at this point we're going to open up