Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 5/18/2011
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   5/18/2011

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Bids.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2011 budget_ Actual performance through April 2011.pdf
  • Emergency response to April 27 - 28 tornado, Washington and Smyth counties.pdf
  • CSX and the Port of Virginia.pdf
  • 1. Financial Report

  • 2. Financial Update

    • DRPT quarterly financial update.pdf
  • 3. Corridors of Statewide Significance Prioritization Process

    • Corridors of statewide significance prioritization process.pdf
  • 4. Tornado Briefing

  • 5. Dynamic Mobility Grant to the Cooperative Systems Pooled Fund Study

    • Cooperative Transportation Systems Pooled Fund Study project update.pdf
  • 6. I-73 Henry County Alternative

    • Interstate 73 Henry County alternative environmental assessment_reevaluation.pdf
  • 7. Revenue Sharing Update

    • Fiscal Year 2012 Revenue Sharing Program update.pdf
  • 8. Rail Update

    • Rail update.pdf
  • 9. MPO Performance Measures

    • Regional performance measures.pdf
  • 10. CSX- Virginia Project Update

    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:01
      Again, everyone, I'd like to welcome you to this morning's work session, the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:07
      First presentation, Mr. Lawson, come up here and tell us some good news.
    • 00:00:11
      If it's bad news, we don't want to hear this.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:00:14
      No bad news today.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:16
      Yeah, next month.
    • 00:00:17
      That's when we hear the bad news.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:00:20
      I want to start off this morning with some good news.
    • 00:00:24
      The first of three planned $600 million issuances of transportation capital projects revenue bonds were sold last week on May the 11th.
    • 00:00:33
      This is the first step in Governor McDonald's plan to invest nearly $4 billion in roads, rail, and transit during the next three years.
    • 00:00:41
      It was the second issue of the PPR bonds.
    • 00:00:44
      As you recall, the first issue was done last May, $473 million.
    • 00:00:48
      The bonds were highly rated.
    • 00:00:50
      They were rated AA+.
    • 00:00:52
      by both Fitch and Standard & Poor's and AA1 by Moody's.
    • 00:00:58
      We did sell competitively and we received seven excellent bids.
    • 00:01:03
      Wells Fargo submitted the winning bid at 4.025, the true interest cost of 4.025% and the bond sale will close next week on the 25th.
    • 00:01:20
      Moving on into the monthly update.
    • 00:01:23
      April state revenue collections were strong.
    • 00:01:25
      Revenues were 6.9% over April 2010, raising the growth rate for the year to 1.2% over the official forecast.
    • 00:01:35
      Motor vehicle sales continued to outpace last year, but they're still below fiscal year 2003 levels.
    • 00:01:43
      A big surprise for the month was motor fuels.
    • 00:01:46
      April motor fuel sales were 7.3% greater than April 2010.
    • 00:01:53
      Sales through the fiscal year are now only trailing the official forecast by a tenth of a percent.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:00
      Do we have any idea why?
    • 00:02:01
      I mean, because last month we actually started drifting, going down, and it's back up.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:02:06
      Yeah, we were kind of having a lull over the winter months, and it just, you know, I haven't gotten a good explanation from taxation, but it
    • 00:02:14
      There just seems to be tied to the slow recovery of the economy.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:24
      Mr. Chairman, it might be because of how long it takes to get up 95.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:30
      We're down 64.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:31
      Or 64 or 81, we can handle it.
    • 00:02:36
      Go ahead Mr. Lawson, next one.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:02:38
      Moving right along.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:02:40
      This chart provides a comparison of the fiscal year-to-date state revenue collections for 2011 and 2010.
    • 00:02:46
      As mentioned, motor vehicle sales and use tax and the licensees are the top performers, both of which are exceeding the growth required to meet the official forecast.
    • 00:02:58
      While still lagging behind the official forecast growth rate, the retail sales and use tax are improving, and we are actually starting to close that gap.
    • 00:03:08
      from where we were a month or so ago.
    • 00:03:15
      Federal revenues, which are dependent upon work performed, held at $145 million above fiscal year 2010 through April.
    • 00:03:24
      The strong increase we're seeing here is still largely driven by the work related to the ARRA recovery projects.
    • 00:03:38
      Total spending for the year continued to reflect our efforts to accelerate projects and other work activities, having spent nearly $200 million more than we had at this time last year.
    • 00:03:49
      Maintenance spending is up $73 million, and as I mentioned, our spending is up by over $100 million from last year, which accounts for most of that $200 million increase.
    • 00:04:03
      We'll point out, though, that
    • 00:04:04
      With 83% of the year complete, we've only expended 65% of the operating budget, which at this point is likely to lead to some large unspent balances at year end.
    • 00:04:25
      I actually believe that the projection has them spending at some point through 2015.
    • 00:04:31
      Some of those projects do extend outwards.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:40
      Mr. Traver, can you go back to your previous slide?
    • 00:04:51
      Maybe I was reading something when you said this just now on the slide.
    • 00:04:56
      I'm just trying to understand if we're 200 million greater than last year and maintenance and construction spending through April are nearly equal to last year.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:05:11
      Perhaps my slide there is misleading.
    • 00:05:14
      What I'm saying by nearly equal is they are both in terms of spending.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:05:18
      They're nearly equal to each other.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:05:19
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:05:20
      And actually, on this next slide here, you can see this does compare year-over-year growth or year-over-year values of the spending.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:28
      So you're saying that we're substantially ahead of last year, but we're substantially behind our budget?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:05:35
      That is correct.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:36
      There were 65 with 83% of the year gone, so we're at 18 points behind our budget right now.
    • 00:05:45
      If we spent the same amount of money we expected to budget, the rest of the year we'd be 18 points behind.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:05:51
      If our spending were on track to consume the full budgeted amount, that is correct statement?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:59
      It would be 18% behind, but at this point it's $200 million it had last year.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:06:05
      Yes, and you can see from this slide clearly maintenance and construction spending are considerably higher than they were last year.
    • 00:06:11
      Again, my nearly the same comment was that they're both at just over a billion dollars.
    • 00:06:19
      Comparatively to here, you can see administrative spending is actually down from last year.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:23
      Well, as a follow-up, without me trying to get in here and figure that slide out, as a follow-up, I'm generally more interested in budget than what we did last year because the budget, in theory, incorporates that into its thinking and what we expect to do this year.
    • 00:06:40
      So is there some sort of explanation
    • 00:06:47
      of why we're at 65 on 83.
    • 00:06:50
      You know, why is that and what are we doing to fix that?
    • 00:06:56
      And obviously that's been some of our problems in the past.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:06:59
      A good portion of that is the maintenance program that we've been talking about and that's balanced there.
    • 00:07:05
      And while we expect, and we have said so all year, to have a pretty sizeable balance at the end of this year, all the work that we've put on contract and the efforts that we've put in place,
    • 00:07:16
      We do see that balance coming down by the end of 12.
    • 00:07:19
      So it's kind of a working process right now, bringing those balances down.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:24
      I guess I would just opine that if we're expecting, and I know we've been talking about this, but if we're expecting that we're not going to be able to spend that money, but it's in process, that I'd like to not see it in the budget so that we're always behind.
    • 00:07:39
      The budget should be what we expect.
    • 00:07:45
      If we don't reach it, then we've not met our expectations.
    • 00:07:51
      If we didn't expect to meet that, then it shouldn't be in the budget for this year.
    • 00:07:56
      It should be in 2012.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:07:58
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:07:59
      Understood your comment.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:01
      We sort of set ourselves up to not meet our goals.
    • 00:08:05
      If we set our goals beyond what we expect to be able to meet.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:09
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:08:10
      Mr. McCarthy.
    • 00:08:12
      Is this a variable throughout the year type of result, i.e.
    • 00:08:18
      by June 30th are we going to in fact meet the budgeted expenditures or do you expect it will still be some percentage under?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:08:29
      We will be some percentage under.
    • 00:08:30
      The program outside of maintenance and construction will come very close to their budgeted targets.
    • 00:08:38
      Maintenance and construction are always the variables.
    • 00:08:42
      in terms of how the work gets planned and the work actually gets executed based on the use of the allocations that were provided for the year.
    • 00:08:58
      Turning to the maintenance program, as I mentioned just a moment ago, the maintenance spending is up $73 million above last year.
    • 00:09:06
      It's about an 8% ahead.
    • 00:09:09
      This chart does illustrate the spending and the budget amounts from 11 to fiscal year 10.
    • 00:09:17
      The $73 million increase is really greater than that when you factor in the fact that the snow cost for fiscal year 11 were $77 million less than they were a year ago.
    • 00:09:29
      So you're really looking at about a $150 million delta.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:33
      Not to bring up shades of last meeting, but is this all funds?
    • 00:09:37
      We have that whole issue of whether it was
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:09:39
      This is a direct comparison between the funding provided to the maintenance program
    • 00:09:52
      and the spending in the maintenance program.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:55
      So I'm not getting into the needs component where I'm saying this is what the needs are and... No, I'm referring back to the last meeting where we were talking about, okay, we're spending this much but here's what our need is.
    • 00:10:04
      We're really spending more.
    • 00:10:06
      It was just this much out of this program.
    • 00:10:09
      Is this all programs or is this just one?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:10:11
      This is just maintenance.
    • 00:10:12
      This is just the maintenance funding and just the maintenance spending.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:18
      So all maintenance...
    • 00:10:20
      Whether it was... Can I follow up, Mr. Sterling?
    • 00:10:22
      Yeah, all maintenance.
    • 00:10:24
      Is there anything we're going to do that has to do with maintenance?
    • 00:10:26
      It would be in the maintenance budget is reflected in these figures.
    • 00:10:29
      That's correct.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:29
      Okay, well, so we're right now at the burn rate.
    • 00:10:38
      Where will we be in two months?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:10:42
      We are expecting at this point to probably end the year with a balance somewhere between $450 and $500 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:52
      And the reason I want to ask that is how much were we planning to transfer from the TTF over to the HMOF in the next fiscal year?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:11:06
      In 12, it's about that same amount.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:10
      The question is, is that why are we transferring those types of balances?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:11:15
      Well, again now, the balance we're talking about now, we intend to bring down to about $100 million by the end of 2012.
    • 00:11:23
      So if you did not make that transfer, then you wouldn't have the funding to carry the program at that size next year.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:30
      So what will the balance be at the end of next fiscal year?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:11:33
      Expect it to be around $100 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:35
      So with the transfer, we'll get to $100 million?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:11:38
      Yes, sir.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:39
      Now, as we're looking at the maintenance spending, we are ensuring that it's really going for projects that aren't needed.
    • 00:11:48
      Yes.
    • 00:11:53
      Okay.
    • 00:11:53
      And we're not just burning money to burn money.
    • 00:11:55
      That's all I want to get to.
    • 00:11:57
      Mr. Layne.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:11:58
      Sure.
    • 00:11:58
      Along those lines, if my recollection is correct, this delta is less than it was last month.
    • 00:12:03
      We were further ahead in spending year to date.
    • 00:12:06
      Last month or now, it may have been explained by, you said, the snow removal in that regard, but the question begs is, I mean, operation, are we really gonna be able to do that?
    • 00:12:20
      Do you see signs that the project, I know the weather's getting better, that we're really going to actually see that?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:27
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:12:28
      Yes, I do see signs that we are improving.
    • 00:12:32
      We still have some hurdles.
    • 00:12:34
      In terms of the paving area, I think there's another slide to come up very soon.
    • 00:12:40
      You'll see a dramatic jump in the number of contracts that we have let and put on the street.
    • 00:12:47
      And our contractors are gearing up.
    • 00:12:49
      to actually do that work.
    • 00:12:51
      That work is going to come in the months of April, May, and June, but it's also going to be in July, August, September.
    • 00:12:59
      So you're going to see a big part of that expenditure hitting the next fiscal year, and that's why we believe our balance is going to be down to 100 million.
    • 00:13:08
      The other piece is that there are two components.
    • 00:13:12
      One is our expenditures or investments in the assets.
    • 00:13:16
      That's more the paving area.
    • 00:13:18
      And you'll see those contracts.
    • 00:13:20
      The next piece is the services.
    • 00:13:23
      How are we doing and getting the services done?
    • 00:13:27
      Whether it's mowing, that type of work.
    • 00:13:32
      So I'm saying that is going a little slower than what I would like.
    • 00:13:38
      And a part of that reason, as I dived into that, is because we let some of those service-related contracts go a couple years ago, or a year ago, and we are now, when we're trying to crank up and gear up to do the services component,
    • 00:13:56
      We'll have to go back and re-establish and re-procure for some of that type of work.
    • 00:14:03
      So there is a little slow down on the service component as well, but we will gear that up.
    • 00:14:09
      And get those contracts in place.
    • 00:14:11
      And I see those expenditures really gearing up in the FY12.
    • 00:14:17
      And that's why I've always predicted that our balance will still be somewhere in that 400 million range in June 30, 2011.
    • 00:14:28
      But June 30, 2012, I expect it to be in the 100 million range.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:14:31
      So by the first quarter of our next fiscal year, we should know if we're really going to, the weather would have been good, the program, we're gonna know if we're gonna really get there.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:44
      We should see those expansions really cranked up.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:14:47
      We should be spending a lot ahead of last year, okay, so that's something to do.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:51
      And obviously with that, then changes in our, meeting our standard or our goals.
    • 00:14:58
      Yes, yes, absolutely.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:00
      Thank you.
    • 00:15:01
      Mr. Chairman, this is not my last time.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:05
      Perhaps I'm sort of confusing budget and expectation with the word allocation.
    • 00:15:13
      I guess what I'm looking to see as a board member is that we have a plan.
    • 00:15:19
      This is how we're doing against the plan.
    • 00:15:22
      And if we're better than the plan, then why?
    • 00:15:25
      If we're worse than the plan, why?
    • 00:15:27
      And what are we doing about it?
    • 00:15:30
      And so when I look at this and I see an allocation number, perhaps that's an allocation, not a plan.
    • 00:15:37
      Maybe it's not a budget, maybe it's not an expectation.
    • 00:15:42
      It looks like it's money we've been given, not necessarily money we thought we could spend this year, but money that's available to be spent this year.
    • 00:15:50
      And what I'm really trying to get my hands on is, that's one component of it, but the other component of it is, what did we expect to do?
    • 00:15:58
      Are we meeting that expectation?
    • 00:16:01
      If we're not, why?
    • 00:16:03
      And if there is a why, what are we doing about it?
    • 00:16:06
      And when I look at this, I can't see that here.
    • 00:16:10
      I can see that our balances are, that we're doing better than last year.
    • 00:16:14
      I can see that we are behind our allocation by $4,500 million at the end of the year.
    • 00:16:20
      But is that our plan?
    • 00:16:22
      Do we expect to be that?
    • 00:16:23
      You're sort of suggesting, somewhat cheapestly, that perhaps
    • 00:16:27
      We expected that, so it's good news, if you will, in some respects.
    • 00:16:32
      But it'd be helpful to me and probably the rest of my colleagues if we sort of have that information.
    • 00:16:39
      And we've got to clean that out in these meetings and ask questions and belabor the point.
    • 00:16:43
      I don't really want to do that.
    • 00:16:44
      So that's the problem.
    • 00:16:46
      Okay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:46
      Don't we... Mr. Commissioner, welcome to you, Mr. Sterling.
    • 00:16:51
      Commissioner, why don't you respond to that?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:52
      What we can do is we do have a plan of work for our maintenance program and these financial statements that you're looking at is really the expenditures compared to the allocations and we do try to project on a cash flow basis what we expect to expand every month and every quarter.
    • 00:17:16
      and we monitor against that.
    • 00:17:18
      In addition, we do look at what are we accomplishing as a result of the work.
    • 00:17:24
      So we will try to take that question and think about the next presentations when we do the maintenance to figure out how we answer those questions.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:34
      I think it's important because I think you could come away from this saying we're not doing very well.
    • 00:17:40
      And what we're sort of saying is we're digging out of a hole
    • 00:17:44
      We're doing as we expected to do, and we think that's pretty well, pretty good.
    • 00:17:50
      And so, as a commissioner, I'm saying, okay, you know, we have a problem.
    • 00:17:54
      We have a plan to fix it.
    • 00:17:55
      We're fixing it.
    • 00:17:56
      We're on course to fix it.
    • 00:17:58
      It's coming down as expected, but when you look at this presentation, that doesn't come out of it.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:03
      Mr., on this, I'm trying to get, we're going to have money that we've allocated,
    • 00:18:11
      We're obviously not going to expend it all during that.
    • 00:18:13
      I mean, projects that we approve for expenditures that get approved next month, the chances of expending that money are somewhere, well, they're not very likely.
    • 00:18:24
      You've always got to carry over.
    • 00:18:25
      So that's the part I'm trying to, sort of the year of money type issue.
    • 00:18:29
      If this is FY $11,
    • 00:18:32
      Page 1 of 2
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:48
      Well, isn't it extended?
    • 00:18:49
      Well, it's both that as well as some that's already, we already have under contract.
    • 00:18:54
      We just haven't expended it, right?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:57
      Yeah, that's what I'm getting at.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:58
      Yeah.
    • 00:18:59
      You know, what I would, maybe, we mentioned this some time ago.
    • 00:19:02
      Maybe what we should do is to maybe carve out some time right before one of these meetings
    • 00:19:10
      And the reason I say that is because we do have a cash flow model that we look at and project the cash flow every month and every quarter based upon the commitments and contracts that you've approved.
    • 00:19:31
      And we also then compare those actual expenditures to a budget.
    • 00:19:37
      So we're managing a couple components.
    • 00:19:39
      One, you're managing your cash from a cash flow perspective.
    • 00:19:44
      And we have a separate process that would do that.
    • 00:19:47
      Then we're looking at expenditures as it relates to budget.
    • 00:19:52
      and we have a process to do that for your major programs.
    • 00:19:58
      And then we also look in particular in the maintenance program, how do we expect to spend that money for each district?
    • 00:20:08
      And what are the various components that they will be spending that money on?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:13
      But don't you, you have an obligation, I mean, here's an expenditures today.
    • 00:20:17
      Don't we have obligations today?
    • 00:20:19
      And when you sign a contract, my assumption is that's the point at which money is obligated.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:24
      When we sign a contract, we have committed resources.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:27
      Right.
    • 00:20:28
      So if we were to look at, instead of expenditures today, obligations today.
    • 00:20:32
      I mean, is that another factor we should just look at that might answer the question on how we're doing?
    • 00:20:38
      When you obligate the money, you still want to see that you're not just obligating and the contract sits there for two years, but the money's being spent, but it also shows the extent to which contracts are being pushed out of the door.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:47
      I think Mr. Lawson's going to show you that in a few minutes.
    • 00:20:50
      Okay.
    • 00:20:51
      I think the point is that we are a billion dollars higher in our commitments at this point in the year compared to last year.
    • 00:21:02
      I think we can show that on a couple slides later.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:21:06
      Mr. Commissioner, Mr. Chairman, I think to Mr. Miller's point though, what we're looking for, Jeff, correct me if I'm wrong, but a tighter number of the budget process
    • 00:21:22
      So the carryover number year to year is tighter.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:25
      Yes.
    • 00:21:26
      Really what I'm looking for, Gary, is we've got a backlog, okay?
    • 00:21:31
      We've got a backlog.
    • 00:21:32
      Every year we get an allocation.
    • 00:21:34
      And that increases or that adds to the backlog category.
    • 00:21:39
      And we've got a plan on how we're gonna spend that money, whether it's money that comes in this year, whether it's backlog money, whatever.
    • 00:21:47
      Our backlog is a billion dollars.
    • 00:21:49
      And this year we're going to get $800 million.
    • 00:21:52
      And we're going to spend a billion.
    • 00:21:54
      So we're going to eat $200 million into that backlog.
    • 00:21:56
      And the backlog ought to be $800 million at the end of the year.
    • 00:22:00
      How are we doing?
    • 00:22:01
      That's all I want to say.
    • 00:22:03
      So we've got a backlog.
    • 00:22:04
      We can simply show it coming down.
    • 00:22:08
      And we can see the budget of actual expenditures that ought to be spent.
    • 00:22:12
      Not just obligated, but spent.
    • 00:22:14
      Or you could do obligations
    • 00:22:16
      as well.
    • 00:22:17
      So we're going to spend in the illustration $800 million.
    • 00:22:21
      We spent $800 million.
    • 00:22:23
      So we hit our number.
    • 00:22:24
      Our backlog came down as expected.
    • 00:22:26
      And if it doesn't, if we're not getting there,
    • 00:22:28
      Then what happened, why did it happen, and what are we doing?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:32
      That's what I'm looking for.
    • 00:22:35
      Mr. Chairman?
    • 00:22:37
      I would just want to put my two cents in and agree with Shep.
    • 00:22:40
      I think that information would be extremely helpful.
    • 00:22:43
      We do have a statutory obligation, as I understand it, where maintenance must come first.
    • 00:22:49
      Can we say to the public that we, all of our bridges and our roads and our other facilities,
    • 00:22:58
      are in proper order before we start other spending.
    • 00:23:04
      Can we say that?
    • 00:23:05
      I think that is the statute, am I correct?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:09
      The statute, Mr. Chairman, is that it's maintenance first.
    • 00:23:15
      Maintenance first.
    • 00:23:16
      And we will be making a presentation to you next month.
    • 00:23:19
      We will point that we adopted some goals being that on the interstate and primary that our roads would be in 82% and bear a good condition.
    • 00:23:34
      We tried to establish a target secondary system that we would not really get any worse than what we were, I believe it was, in 2007.
    • 00:23:45
      I'll have to go back and get the notes on that.
    • 00:23:49
      We will be giving you a presentation next month to suggest that by June 30th, 2012, that on the interstate system we will be meeting that target.
    • 00:24:04
      By June 30th, 2013, on the primary system, we will be meeting that target of 82%.
    • 00:24:13
      On the secondary system, you will see a slight improvement
    • 00:24:17
      but not where we were in 2007.
    • 00:24:20
      A big part of this is that when you leave the $500 million on the table and not put those dollars to work, you're not expending resources to meet your target.
    • 00:24:38
      As we become more aggressive in putting that work on the street, we will be meeting those targets.
    • 00:24:44
      I feel pretty comfortable
    • 00:24:45
      On the secondary, I'm not as comfortable.
    • 00:24:48
      Interstate and primary, I think we will be there.
    • 00:24:52
      And on the secondary, I think you will see some improvement, but not where we need to be.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:59
      So we'll be in compliance with the statute in the future.
    • 00:25:02
      So right now we're really moving toward that goal of maintenance first.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:08
      The statute did not identify a number.
    • 00:25:11
      Right.
    • 00:25:12
      This was a target that was presented to the board probably, I think it was 2007, I'll have to check.
    • 00:25:21
      And that's what we've been working towards to continue to meet that goal.
    • 00:25:25
      We were meeting those goals and then we dropped off and that gave rise to those balances which now we need to spend down and I think that when we get that balance down, spend those resources in the proper way
    • 00:25:43
      Weiser, I think you'll see those numbers coming into compliance.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:51
      Dr. Davis?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:52
      Greg, the problem in the secondary area, to feel that we're not going to be as successful as perhaps we would like to be, is that because of the complexity of the
    • 00:26:13
      delivery system for getting that work done, the fact that it's a lot of small projects and it requires a lot of diversity of the approach for contracts and for who does the work, is that the difficulty of trying to make an improvement in that area as opposed to interstate?
    • 00:26:32
      I know we approve an interstate project, it's 30, 40, 50 million dollars at one crack.
    • 00:26:37
      Secondary projects might be a few hundred thousand dollars in many cases.
    • 00:26:42
      Is that the problem?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:44
      I think the bigger problem is the allocation of resources to secondary systems.
    • 00:26:49
      I think that's the biggest issue.
    • 00:26:50
      Now, I do have a delivery issue problem in delivering some of my projects because some of the projects are much smaller.
    • 00:26:59
      and on the secondary system and it requires the same effort to get a primary project procured as it does a secondary.
    • 00:27:08
      But that's something that we actually have had some sessions on this week trying to wrestle with how do we get those projects started and some of those on secondary.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:18
      On the allocations side, Mr. Chairman,
    • 00:27:21
      Is that our problem?
    • 00:27:23
      That we have not allocated sufficient funds to help you move ahead on the secondary?
    • 00:27:29
      Is that where we are?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:31
      Well, a little bit.
    • 00:27:33
      I mean, it's a money issue.
    • 00:27:35
      It's also a focus issue.
    • 00:27:37
      Yes.
    • 00:27:38
      The Commissioner, in fact, is it going to be next month, will bring the maintenance?
    • 00:27:43
      Yes.
    • 00:27:43
      For the whole overview.
    • 00:27:45
      Very good.
    • 00:27:46
      Thanks.
    • 00:27:46
      And one of the things in there, Dr. Davis, is I think it's
    • 00:27:50
      It's pretty clear that under the current program that the Commissioner and his staff put together, this year we'll reach the standard for the interstates, next year we'll reach the standard for the primaries, and then the year after we should be getting near the standard for the secondaries.
    • 00:28:12
      So with the focus on, and the money now being spent down,
    • 00:28:17
      I think we'll be good on the interstates.
    • 00:28:20
      We'll be able to get to the primaries next year, reach all the standards, but then turn to the secondary standards.
    • 00:28:28
      So by year three, we should be at the secondary standard.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:34
      Is that correct?
    • 00:28:36
      We will make an improvement towards getting to that target.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:28:44
      Moving on to the construction program.
    • 00:28:47
      As I mentioned earlier, the major increases in construction spending this year are related to the R program.
    • 00:28:54
      We've spent $164.5 million of R-related work this year, which has tripled the amount for this time last year.
    • 00:29:03
      The Interstate Construction Program, just want to point out here, is the larger component of the construction system.
    • 00:29:11
      It represents 31% of the program, and our spending is about 18% ahead of where we were this time last year.
    • 00:29:22
      Commissioner mentioned this earlier.
    • 00:29:24
      When we look at our contract work, you can really see how we have put a tremendous amount of work out on the street.
    • 00:29:33
      This chart shows the value of the outstanding construction and maintenance contracts and the unspent balances.
    • 00:29:41
      You can see that there's been significant increases in the maintenance contracts over the last two months.
    • 00:29:47
      This chart just shows you the activity of this fiscal year since last July.
    • 00:29:53
      When you go back and actually compare this to May of 2010, a year ago,
    • 00:29:58
      The total contract value is over a billion dollars greater than it was a year ago.
    • 00:30:06
      That's about $400 million greater in construction and about $600 million greater in maintenance.
    • 00:30:13
      The unspent contract balances, which total $1.5 billion, are about double where they were this time last year, and the largest increases
    • 00:30:23
      In that area is maintenance, the unspent maintenance contract balance.
    • 00:30:27
      It's $739 million compared to $287 million this time last year.
    • 00:30:33
      So as you can see, we have definitely put a lot of work on the street, but as the work is commenced, we'll spin down those balances.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:30:49
      On the construction spending, Mr. Lawson, we compared on maintenance expenditures to allocations, but on construction we compared expenditure to expenditure from last year.
    • 00:31:04
      Are we okay on our allocation basis in construction or do we have the same backlog there that we do in maintenance?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:31:13
      Construction spending, I mean, in terms of being within our budget, we're good.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:31:18
      But I'm just saying, have we left the contracts?
    • 00:31:21
      Do we have a time lag between letting that contract, do we have a similar issue there that we do in maintenance?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:30
      We do have a balance on contracts in construction, just like we do in maintenance.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:31:36
      Is that more than we expected, or are we on target there?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:40
      We're on target in construction.
    • 00:31:43
      Now, what I do expect in construction, if you look at that line for the construction balance, I believe is the top line.
    • 00:31:52
      I'm expecting this time next year, you will see that line even go up.
    • 00:31:59
      Okay, because we're going to be putting a lot of contracts on the street for the construction.
    • 00:32:05
      So you're going to see, just like you saw the big increase in the maintenance line, the contract balance line, there was a strong focus in October, November, and December to put those contracts on the street.
    • 00:32:18
      You're going to see a similar focus in July, August, and September
    • 00:32:25
      When you adopt the program,
    • 00:32:34
      You have a lot more projects in that program.
    • 00:32:38
      And we're going to be pushing those contracts.
    • 00:32:40
      So you're going to see that line go up as well.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:32:43
      And I would request that we do the same type of analysis Mr. Miller brought up so we can see where we are on that scene for the construction side.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:51
      And as those contracts go up, your expenditures will go up.
    • 00:32:56
      So when you start comparing now those expenditures, the budget, where before you saw, well, we are
    • 00:33:03
      80% of the year gone, but 60% spent.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:06
      You can see that gap in there.
    • 00:33:10
      Mr.
    • 00:33:12
      Keen, and I'll come back to Ms. Ellis.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:14
      Ms. Lawson, in the comparison for secondary construction, 10 versus 11, the 20 difference there, those constructions on spin 11 are primarily from what category?
    • 00:33:32
      And the question, does that include the revenue sharing percentages that the locals keep answering?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:33:44
      Revenue sharing is typically reflected in that second line dedicated in statewide construction.
    • 00:33:49
      Your primary, secondary, and urban, mostly your formal distributed dollars.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:56
      These are forming?
    • 00:33:57
      So, we would expect even the 85 to go away as we move forward as we see less and less funds going towards the secondary system?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:34:08
      I think the reductions you're seeing there are reflective of the no monies going through the formula.
    • 00:34:14
      There are small amounts in the systems that are from the discretionary federal dollars
    • 00:34:19
      So it wouldn't totally go away, but clearly I look in those categories without a formal distribution is going to be smaller.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:28
      Yes, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:34:29
      Yes.
    • 00:34:30
      So here we have, and a point to my colleagues and to those that may have concern, we have 37,000 miles, the biggest majority
    • 00:34:41
      That's part of our system that needs various types of construction projects for improvement that may not fall in the maintenance category or even improvements in certain areas that certainly would be construction that we're not going to be able to handle under the presence of that because we don't have secondary funds to do that.
    • 00:34:58
      Plus the fact when we look back at the maintenance side, as pointed out by Dr. Davis, we had a decrease of 23.2%.
    • 00:35:07
      And it appears that we really are going to have to begin to look at the biggest part of our system in terms of maintaining it.
    • 00:35:17
      57,000 miles we've got.
    • 00:35:19
      You know, the majority of it is secondary roads.
    • 00:35:24
      And so I'm really concerned on the trends that I see there
    • 00:35:27
      In maintenance and in those projects that we're beginning to pay less attention to the secondary system.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:35
      Mr. Chairman, I would say that in the draft six-year program we have made
    • 00:35:42
      Sizable investment in the secondary system.
    • 00:35:46
      I think it was maybe $100 million more than what we had done previously.
    • 00:35:51
      Not saying that it's going to get us all the way where we need to be, but we did recognize that, and that is in this program that you're currently looking at.
    • 00:36:00
      And we're going to look at the secondary maintenance as well when we're developing our
    • 00:36:07
      Thank you.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:20
      The presentation you're going to bring, I would have an interest in looking at how we're doing secondary maintenance and are we doing it in-house anymore and is all of that contracted out?
    • 00:36:32
      As part of that analysis, you don't have to get into it now as we look at that because I'm seeing out there very, very few projects and very little being done and I wonder with all the cutback that we've had, are we capable of doing it ourselves?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:47
      Mr. Chairman, we have lost some of our ability to do the work on the secondary, or some of the work to do to work on the road.
    • 00:36:59
      But we also have a law that limits the amount that we can do ourselves.
    • 00:37:05
      I believe that amount is $600,000.
    • 00:37:07
      Is that the right amount?
    • 00:37:11
      I'm not sure, sir.
    • 00:37:12
      It was $300,000.
    • 00:37:13
      I don't know if Rick is here.
    • 00:37:16
      But we were once limited to $300,000 and was raised to $600,000.
    • 00:37:19
      But from a construction standpoint, we cannot take projects that are in excess of that amount.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:29
      Ms. Ellis.
    • 00:37:29
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:37:30
      Mr. Lawson.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:31
      Just one quick question, and this may have been discussed when the R projects first are initiated, but when do these funds run out, or when do they have to be expended by?
    • 00:37:42
      What's the last fiscal year that we have that we can use them all?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:37:47
      I believe they run through 2015.
    • 00:37:48
      I mean, we've got several years in which those funds can be expended.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:53
      This graphic is just one we started a few months ago where we show in addition to the construction and maintenance the other
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:38:18
      Contract work that we have outstanding related to consultants and to our PPTA or P3 design-build type projects.
    • 00:38:28
      The consultant contracts, you already questioned before the composition of that and over half of that is related to design consultants.
    • 00:38:37
      Another two-thirds or another third of that is related to inspection and operation.
    • 00:38:42
      So you can see most of that is directly focused to maintenance and construction.
    • 00:38:51
      In terms of cash, cash balance.
    • 00:38:56
      In April, it's just down slightly from March.
    • 00:39:00
      The cash balance is 147 million less than it was at the beginning of the fiscal year.
    • 00:39:04
      Most of the balance changes in the CPR bonds, as we've been spending them down over the course of the year, currently have about $15 million balance remaining of the CPR that haven't been expended.
    • 00:39:19
      I do want to point out that given
    • 00:39:22
      The fact that we just sold bonds, we'll be collecting those proceeds later this month, and with the current spending patterns, we are looking at a year-end balance of probably about $1.7 billion.
    • 00:39:37
      You have to remember a large portion of the bond funds that are coming in the door are not planned to be spent until next year.
    • 00:39:51
      In summary, we watched cautiously the revenues as they continue to track slightly above forecast.
    • 00:39:58
      As you've seen, the efforts to put work on the street have resulted in significantly greater contract balances than at this time last year.
    • 00:40:05
      The outstanding maintenance contract amounts more than double, committing the available resources.
    • 00:40:13
      Contract paving work is getting started and is expected to ramp up quickly as we move towards summer.
    • 00:40:19
      Your imbalances are largely dependent, and we've said this before, upon how fast or how aggressive the industry executes those contracts.
    • 00:40:29
      And as always, we will continue to monitor and report to you the status of the finances.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:38
      I was waiting until the presentation was finished to ask a couple of questions.
    • 00:40:45
      One is on this that we talked about with allocations and all,
    • 00:40:49
      Just so that I'm clear on this, when we make allocations on our budget, are we anticipating a certain list of projects and the cost associated with those projects to be accomplished during the year?
    • 00:41:04
      For example, the maintenance area, for example, do we have a list of things we hope by prioritization to get accomplished with X number of dollars?
    • 00:41:14
      The reason I'm asking that is that if, with the economy being a downside right now, if we're getting contracts coming in better than what we anticipated and we have excess dollars,
    • 00:41:26
      Do we have another listing of projects ready to go that we can use that excess money that we've got to kind of keep it moving along?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:36
      For maintenance or for construction?
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:39
      Maintenance is just an example.
    • 00:41:41
      I mean, you can do it in any of the areas, but I mean the same concept.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:44
      I think it's for both.
    • 00:41:46
      And one of the things that obviously with the Six-Year Plan, I'll just touch on the construction.
    • 00:41:50
      At least internally, when we put out the list of projects,
    • 00:41:56
      We've identified which projects that you could end up putting some right-of-way engineering money on that will put them in the position that as prices come in lower, hopefully will come in lower, we can then take those savings and put them right up against another project that's been moving to assess them.
    • 00:42:15
      You also then have maintenance projects that you all have the same
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:20
      So to make this project, when you approved an allocation, you approved $1.3 billion.
    • 00:42:28
      It is my expectation that we would spend pretty much that entire $1.3 billion in that year.
    • 00:42:36
      Now, we got off.
    • 00:42:39
      I'll kick you back to 2006.
    • 00:42:41
      In 2006, we had only $5 million left on the table.
    • 00:42:46
      In other words, every dollar you pretty much
    • 00:42:49
      Authorized us to spend.
    • 00:42:52
      We spent.
    • 00:42:55
      We just got off site and it grew.
    • 00:42:58
      And we're going to get back to that point where pretty much everything you approved that year, and maintenance is an annual program, we're pretty much going to spend all of that.
    • 00:43:09
      Now, I can't promise you $5 million balance.
    • 00:43:12
      That was pretty darn tight.
    • 00:43:16
      But we will be pretty much spending everything that you authorized in the maintenance program.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:24
      The only thing that does concern me, obviously, a little bit about maintenance is we have these numbers regarding pavement condition, which we can go out and measure.
    • 00:43:37
      But it's all the other, and then there's the issue on looking at bridges, which is a good and bad in this year because I mean we have the, they can be structurally deficient and also operationally deficient.
    • 00:43:54
      And obviously there's a difference between the two.
    • 00:43:57
      But once we get past those two things, we don't really have standards per se that we can measure.
    • 00:44:02
      I mean whether people want to do guard rails, culverts,
    • 00:44:07
      I don't know how much that is for the program, but it's probably a pretty big chunk.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:12
      We actually have worked for the guardrail in both the Makers Inn and the construction program.
    • 00:44:18
      And the issue there on the guardrails are as we use federal money to assist on the guardrails, we have to bring them up to the federal standards.
    • 00:44:31
      And then add to this complexity, just to throw that in as well, is I've always been struck by the fact that you can go out and look at some of this bridge work
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:53
      Some of it will be called maintenance.
    • 00:44:57
      We'll pay for it out of the maintenance pot, and others will be considered construction, depending on who's paying for it, where the money's coming from.
    • 00:45:05
      In some cases, we're calling it maintenance, and it's really a reconstruction.
    • 00:45:10
      In others, it's being called construction, when in reality, it's probably just maintenance.
    • 00:45:16
      Is that correct?
    • 00:45:19
      I've actually seen a couple of these projects where we were reconstructing a bridge almost entirely that came out of the maintenance pot.
    • 00:45:26
      We had another one where it came from the federal.
    • 00:45:30
      All we did was replace the deck and that was called new construction.
    • 00:45:36
      So some of the stuff on maintenance, I mean, this is where I think we have to get a much better grip on some of these, what we're considering maintenance and understanding a little bit more about when you start to drill down past these numbers.
    • 00:45:51
      Because again, it's one of these things where what we think in our minds is maintenance or construction may not be so based on whether it's a federal,
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:02
      One question, Mr. Lawson, on your final budget comparison schedule sheet at the back, there's a lot of different anomalies here, but the one that stands out for me is the other financing used as transfers to other state agencies and general funds.
    • 00:46:29
      That used to be a 35-40 million dollar item.
    • 00:46:32
      It was budgeted at 54 and your figures show it's at 171 million now.
    • 00:46:38
      Could you include an analysis of that at our next discussion of the budget like what that is?
    • 00:46:44
      And for now, is there a simple explanation about why that number is so big?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 00:46:48
      Yes sir, most of that is to transfer a bond proceeds on DRPT.
    • 00:46:55
      Okay.
    • 00:46:55
      We manage the CPR funds so that they actually submit to us their requisition and we transfer the funds to them.
    • 00:47:01
      So that's the difference that you're seeing between what you would have expected and abnormal support.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:06
      I just, Mr. Chairman, I was a little surprised to see a number jump that big and the board not sort of know about it, what it was.
    • 00:47:15
      So if you'll break that down for us next time, like what those things are, we could pay attention to them a little bit more.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:47:20
      Certainly.
    • 00:47:21
      One last operational question.
    • 00:47:25
      This struck me when you thought about it here.
    • 00:47:28
      You say your imbalances are largely dependent upon how aggressively the industry executes the contract work.
    • 00:47:34
      Don't we put performance standards and execution dates in the contracts?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:40
      Mr. Chairman, we have not put those performance standards in the maintenance related contracts.
    • 00:47:52
      We thought about doing it this year and we didn't.
    • 00:47:56
      There's a lot of discussion on that in terms of how do you get the best price for your money.
    • 00:48:10
      And if we give the industry some flexibility, we tend to get a bit better prices without giving them a hard, fixed date.
    • 00:48:23
      I don't have data right now to tell you that actually we're getting better prices as a result of that, but that's the theory, and we have not set a hard date.
    • 00:48:34
      Generally, you can expect that if we let a contract in October or November or January, we would generally spend 20% of that contract value
    • 00:48:50
      in the fiscal year in which it was left.
    • 00:48:53
      The remaining eight years will be spent in the following fiscal year.
    • 00:48:58
      Now that's for maintenance.
    • 00:49:01
      That's generally how the theory works there.
    • 00:49:05
      And that is tracked pretty closely.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:49:08
      Well, with what the secretary brought up about what we put in maintenance and construction and how they cross over and stuff, I would encourage us to look at performance standards.
    • 00:49:18
      I mean, sometimes you get what you pay for, but I'm not suggesting that's the case, but it seemed like with our backlog, that would be one thing we could do to maybe give us a little more definitive
    • 00:49:32
      And of course we could always test to see if we find out we're not getting the prices.
    • 00:49:37
      I'm sure there's a way we could look at that.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:50:03
      Thank you Chairman, Board.
    • 00:50:06
      I thought it prudent in light that VDOT's been providing y'all financial updates that we begin doing a similar presentation to y'all.
    • 00:50:17
      If you look in your packages, you should have a report that has a cover page like this.
    • 00:50:25
      And essentially in that package is a statement which I call resources and a commitment statement which is
    • 00:50:33
      It's not quite a balance sheet, but for a private sector thinking, that's sort of what it is.
    • 00:50:40
      And then also there's a budget to actual statement and then a little bit of analysis on the resource commitments page.
    • 00:50:48
      But I just want to take a moment and I guess as we go through this, I'm planning on doing this quarterly.
    • 00:50:53
      If you want it done more often, you have to let me know.
    • 00:50:56
      And this is what I put together for y'all.
    • 00:50:58
      If y'all want more information, more details, or less information, you'll have to give me that feedback also.
    • 00:51:04
      And you're welcome to contact me, tell me here, contact me by email, however you so choose.
    • 00:51:11
      With that said, I'll just talk about the resources and commitments of our agency.
    • 00:51:15
      Essentially, what this does is it takes all the resources that are coming in that have been programmed into our six-year program
    • 00:51:25
      which is in revenues for the current year receivables that we have for prior year or that we're receiving funds from other sources like John mentioned we are getting transfers of bond funds because they actually administer the bond funds so the funds are transferred so we have a receivable for that.
    • 00:51:46
      And then it also takes a look at all our commitments on projects that we've allocated in the Six-Year Plan for the current year and all years prior that are ongoing.
    • 00:51:56
      And it compares those two, and ultimately what this does is this second bullet, it provides the net effect, which is funds that are available to actually put to use.
    • 00:52:08
      And this month is, and I guess this quarter is probably, two items can be done.
    • 00:52:15
      First, we can use those funds off-cycle grants, but then second, we take those funds and we put them back in the Six-Year Program.
    • 00:52:23
      And I guess we're at the point in time of the year now that we've taken the majority of the balances you'll see on that page and rolled them back in.
    • 00:52:31
      Certain, you have a lot more detail than I'm going to show on the next slide, certain of those balances have rules related to the fund that they actually rest in, code provisions that
    • 00:52:45
      limit their use for certain activities.
    • 00:52:48
      So when you see there's 30, I think there's 37 million, 39 million dollars of what I call available funding, some of it has strings attached to it, so it's not just available for any project.
    • 00:53:05
      And then finally, also this statement helps us manage our assets, our cash, our accounts receivable, and our revenues.
    • 00:53:14
      This is a summarized version of what you all have in your package.
    • 00:53:20
      And as I said before, the available balance at the bottom to me is for managing from a high level is the key item because it's really what funds it on an ongoing basis, what funds we have available because we're constantly, we have 1,100, 1,200 products we're managing.
    • 00:53:40
      Well, some of those projects come in under budget.
    • 00:53:43
      Some of them never go forward.
    • 00:53:44
      So constantly, on a daily basis, projects are closed out and those balances are moved to being available.
    • 00:53:51
      So it's a lot of work involved because you're talking 1,200 projects to reconcile.
    • 00:53:56
      So if you'd like for this to be done monthly, it's going to be a lot of work.
    • 00:54:02
      And I don't know that I can get the books closed in time to get it to you monthly.
    • 00:54:06
      It still may be a month lagged.
    • 00:54:08
      So we can go there if y'all would like, but that bottom line to me is what I think y'all should focus on, because if you have a project that you think should move forward, that's the balances that are available.
    • 00:54:21
      That's what I think internally we look at also.
    • 00:54:24
      But for today, most of that $38.6 million has been rolled into the Six-Year Program.
    • 00:54:33
      That said, before I leave here, I also want to talk about the accounts receivable.
    • 00:54:39
      This number used to be a very large number, about $30 million, but we've got that under control.
    • 00:54:45
      It's down to $3.8 million.
    • 00:54:49
      and then other than that we have some bonds receivable which is from VDOT.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:53
      Mr. Chairman, what is VR from?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:54:58
      The accounts receivable?
    • 00:54:59
      It's probably actually receivables from VDOT for projects that, some projects VDOT gives us the money up front, other projects we have to bill them after we pay for it using our available cash.
    • 00:55:13
      So that's, I'll make a note to give you the exact detail but
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:21
      No, we don't provide direct service, so no.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:55:30
      This slide, so I'm going to talk a little bit about cash and a little bit about our revenues.
    • 00:55:34
      John covered that already because essentially our revenues flow through from VDOT, but on our cash balances, what you're going to see, this is the last 12 months and then as of May 12th when I put this together, and I guess what you'll see here is
    • 00:55:51
      Because rail has a lot larger cash balance than transit.
    • 00:55:57
      And you can see where it's trending.
    • 00:55:59
      Transit's trending between 20 and 55 million dollars.
    • 00:56:03
      And then rail's generally just been increasing slightly.
    • 00:56:07
      With that said, here's a little bit of analysis of those balances.
    • 00:56:10
      I guess what we've decided is we're trying to come up with what we should have on hand as a working cash balance in the agency.
    • 00:56:19
      And for transit,
    • 00:56:20
      We chose to take 60 days or two months.
    • 00:56:24
      For rail, we chose 90 days, three months.
    • 00:56:28
      And the reason for rail being different is rail has fewer projects, but a lot more complex projects.
    • 00:56:36
      And the dollars are a lot larger, and they're a lot harder to negotiate those projects.
    • 00:56:41
      So obviously, if you have fewer projects, if one of them or two of them hit a bump in the road, it's gonna have a lot bigger impact
    • 00:56:49
      When you're looking at averages, whereas you've got 1,000 projects, one or two hit a bump in the road, it still smooths out.
    • 00:56:57
      But anyway, we may, as we go forward over the next year, we may determine that the 60 days and 90 days may need to be adjusted.
    • 00:57:07
      I don't really want to go below 60 days.
    • 00:57:09
      I think that would not be prudent.
    • 00:57:15
      Also cash management, transit is below that target.
    • 00:57:20
      I'll go back real quick.
    • 00:57:22
      The average cash balance, the working cash needs is 60 days for transit is $60 million is what it comes out to if you take our budget.
    • 00:57:31
      So we took our budget, divided it by 12 months and then said for two months we'd need $60 million.
    • 00:57:37
      Did the same thing on the rail side except we factored in for three months and you can see
    • 00:57:43
      Transit is well below actually the working cash needs, but it has not been an issue for us.
    • 00:57:50
      A year or so ago we had a cash flow issue and VDOT helped us with loans, but it was related to the bond issue.
    • 00:57:58
      But rail, as you can see, actually has a large cash balance and as Commissioner Whirley indicated, we want to get that money to work.
    • 00:58:07
      So we've been working internally.
    • 00:58:09
      The second bullet here is
    • 00:58:12
      At the bottom, you know, we've allocated in the six-year plan.
    • 00:58:15
      We're moving more to, Mr. Louderback, you asked earlier, you know, how the allocations are made.
    • 00:58:20
      We're moving towards making our allocations based on cash flows as opposed to the revenues we get and we're going to allocate it more.
    • 00:58:30
      It's going to be based more on when we're actually going to spend the funds.
    • 00:58:33
      It's not a simple thing to just take a six-year program and turn it overnight, so we're working through that.
    • 00:58:40
      I know in the current six-year plan, Kevin Page and myself have worked through that process, so hopefully the cash outflows will mirror the allocations as we go forward.
    • 00:58:51
      We're also working to close out projects quicker on the rail side.
    • 00:58:55
      Once again, it's more complexity there, and there's projects, so it's not quite as simple as closing out a bus purchase.
    • 00:59:04
      On the transit side, we were obviously within the target, and the balance we had is sufficient.
    • 00:59:12
      The next thing I'll just- Mr. Chairman?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:14
      Ms. McCartlin.
    • 00:59:15
      Steve, what do you mean when you say close out projects that are not advancing?
    • 00:59:20
      Can you give me an example of what that might be?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:59:22
      Well, I guess I have at the end of this slide where I'm going to get to the budget actual, and rail hasn't spent as much money this year as we thought we'd spend, and some of that is because
    • 00:59:33
      the recession that projects we made allocations to and then the rail companies are not quite seeing the business that they thought when the allocation was made that they aren't sure that now it's a go for the project.
    • 00:59:48
      And I guess what I'm saying there is we have to look closer at that.
    • 00:59:52
      Do we close the project out and then when it is a go make them come back later for funding?
    • 00:59:59
      So that's what that gets at.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:02
      Well, if it affects anything from Norfolk to Richmond to Washington, I'd like to hear about it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:10
      Mr. Chairman?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:12
      You said push for quicker final billing.
    • 01:00:17
      Is that from somebody that's doing work for us?
    • 01:00:23
      The obvious question is if my vendor isn't billing me,
    • 01:00:31
      and I'm sitting in cash in an account making something on it or using it for cash flow.
    • 01:00:39
      Why do I care?
    • 01:00:40
      Well, I kind of like those kinds of vendors in my business.
    • 01:00:45
      I agree.
    • 01:00:47
      That's sort of their problem.
    • 01:00:49
      I mean, it maybe makes you track the bill a little longer, but if they want their money in 180 days instead of in 30, I'll do that all day long, so I didn't really understand.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:01:00
      I guess I'll say to some degree there's a cost to us having to keep tracking the project and keep going back to them.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:07
      So then it also- It's called AP vendor A.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:01:17
      Well, it's managing the project also.
    • 01:01:20
      I mean, our program administrators are going to, they do a quarterly update.
    • 01:01:24
      But I get what you're saying, but the flip side of that is in VDOT's audit,
    • 01:01:29
      A lot of the criticism was a $1.5 billion cash balance that that needed to be put to work.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:36
      Well, this isn't money that can be put to work.
    • 01:01:38
      This is money that's sitting there collecting a little interest, and that's a good thing.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:01:43
      I agree.
    • 01:01:44
      The statistics, when you put them on paper, though, can make certain people think otherwise.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:51
      I understand.
    • 01:01:52
      Thank you.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:01:54
      With that, revenues, John hit this, we're well within target, we should be about 25% remaining and rail was actually, the rail enhancement fund, the vehicle rental tax is actually exceeding the estimate through the end of March.
    • 01:02:10
      The transit related revenues are right on target.
    • 01:02:15
      The last thing I want to talk about is the budget to actual statement and this takes the budget that was adopted back last June and it's
    • 01:02:24
      Just giving you feedback on how we're performing towards that budget.
    • 01:02:29
      And this is a summarized version of what you have in the package.
    • 01:02:33
      But you'll see essentially on the smaller items at the bottom, I'm not really gonna get too much into that detail because the dollar amount's not large enough to take the time at this moment.
    • 01:02:45
      But you'll see really we're on track except for in rail as I alluded to.
    • 01:02:50
      And really what's going on in rail is there's four large projects.
    • 01:02:55
      that Mr. McCarthy, as I told you, it's like Notesville to Calverton.
    • 01:03:02
      That was a project Norfolk Southern wanted to do, but for economic reasons, you know, the recession, now they're not sure it makes sense to do it today.
    • 01:03:12
      And so we're sort of sitting in this mode of, you know, do we just leave it on the books?
    • 01:03:18
      Do we say we'll come back later and reapply?
    • 01:03:22
      We're sort of caught in that mode right now.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:24
      And when and who, when does that position get made and who makes it?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:03:31
      Well, it's really, it's negotiation between us and Norfolk Southern, the department, Kevin.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:37
      We've got some projects I'd love to see extra money put to work on.
    • 01:03:42
      You know, we probably all do to some degree, but we know we've got needs.
    • 01:03:48
      If somebody doesn't want the money, we have plenty of resources for it.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:03:51
      And that's why I put the bullet on the earlier slide, is we as an agency have to look closer at when do we close out a project and say, if you're not ready to move forward, you're gonna have to come back later when you are ready.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:06
      Yeah, I think, Mr. Chairman, I think you've made it very clear over the last year or so, the idea is to get money out of the store.
    • 01:04:15
      You know, the equivalent of dirt flying, whatever that means, for rail.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:04:20
      And Kevin, I'll add, Kevin's going to be given an update, so if any of these specific items, like the next item is the Norfolk Train project.
    • 01:04:28
      And that's just taken longer for us to get the agreements underway.
    • 01:04:31
      And I believe we may have the CSX agreement signed now.
    • 01:04:35
      So, Norfolk Southern has begun this spring, so that billing will start to happen.
    • 01:04:40
      There's a lag in the billing.
    • 01:04:42
      So that was just us, we just misjudged the allocation and the cash flow.
    • 01:04:48
      That's what the problem there is.
    • 01:04:50
      It's just we thought we'd get it going a little quicker than we did.
    • 01:04:54
      There's no other issue going on.
    • 01:04:57
      FRA, I think we've talked to y'all numerous times, the difficulty we're having with them getting the $75 million under award.
    • 01:05:07
      And then Bearville Elton was a, it's a Crescent Corridor project on I-81 for Norfolk Southern.
    • 01:05:13
      It's similar type issues.
    • 01:05:15
      where they wanted to change some of the projects that were funded and look at putting some of the funds in Roanoke and then also they're not quite ready to move forward from an economic standpoint.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:28
      To go back to Mr. McCarthy's point, I'd like to, so how long, let's say, has this $22 million been parked against that notes filled account?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:05:39
      I was looking at Kevin.
    • 01:05:40
      I think it's a 09, is notes still a 09?
    • 01:05:48
      In the draft program?
    • 01:05:52
      So we have pushed it out then.
    • 01:05:57
      But in the year we're in, so I think Kevin's talking about in the draft program, we realize it's not ready to go, so now we've taken those
    • 01:06:06
      Allocated Resources and said now they're going to be allocated in 12 and 13.
    • 01:06:11
      So now in, did you say 12 and 13?
    • 01:06:19
      But what you're looking at is a year ago, we thought we would have spent this fund.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:24
      But, all right, I understand that.
    • 01:06:27
      So when you set this project back further,
    • 01:06:31
      We took the funds that are available now and are using them on another project or are we just letting the balance build up?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:38
      Well, since Kevin says I don't have the number in front of me, since he said it was 12 and 13, the balance for 12 we are using now in essence.
    • 01:06:50
      We put it in the draft to be used starting July.
    • 01:06:55
      The 13 balance probably got programmed to other projects that was available today.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:03
      Like if you look at our draft six-year program- Wait, I'm looking at your other numbers and it shows your balances are growing.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:07:10
      But I think that's where I was saying earlier, you got to look at our draft six-year program and look at the rail page and I don't think there's any unobligated balance and maybe $200,000.
    • 01:07:20
      So we've taken all available funds and programmed them in 12, they're either prior program, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:31
      And Steve, I think, Mr. Secretary, another good example is the Elliston project, where last year we pushed that back to 13-14 because we can't move ahead with that.
    • 01:07:41
      So hopefully we'll know something and then we'll know how we move those funds.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:07:45
      If you look at FY12 and the draft six-year program, it shows only $200,000 is available, I think is the rollover balance.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:54
      No, but I mean, the real question is, is that yes, all right, Steve, set these projects back, but then are we advancing other projects
    • 01:08:01
      to use that cash.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 01:08:02
      And I'm sorry, when we get to transit, that's pretty much turn and burn.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:28
      The money as it comes in goes out the door just as quick.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:08:32
      I think we're less than 60 days.
    • 01:08:34
      I don't think we should try to push it to 30 days.
    • 01:08:40
      That's pretty much coming in and going out the door.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:08:43
      Follow-up with Secretary Drake.
    • 01:08:46
      What is the status of the Allison project?
    • 01:08:49
      Is it being held up in the courts?
    • 01:08:50
      Is that what the problem is now?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:51
      It's going to be heard during the month of June.
    • 01:08:53
      And so when we push that money back, we took the month of June and put it on the Norfolk train so that we would be starting that.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:09:01
      But courts are what's holding up Allison right now?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:09:06
      Yes.
    • 01:09:06
      I think that's what I said earlier.
    • 01:09:07
      You know, rail has so few projects comparatively speaking
    • 01:09:11
      They're large, they're complex, so when one of them hits a problem, it's going to show up in this data.
    • 01:09:17
      So the next six months, with the Norfolk train moving along, I expect that cash balance to come down pretty significantly.
    • 01:09:24
      Will it make it into the 90-day range?
    • 01:09:26
      I don't, I'm not quite sure of that, but it won't be at four times what we say we need.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:37
      Okay.
    • 01:09:37
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:09:38
      Yes.
    • 01:09:38
      Before we leave this topic, and we're talking
    • 01:09:42
      about large rail projects and various expenditures that were made or not made in relation to DRPT.
    • 01:09:51
      I wanted to bring up the subject and ask Steve and possibly the director to think about if there's a need for more reporting to this board in this arena, particularly since beginning of July we will not have the rail advisory board.
    • 01:10:10
      And the Rail Advisory Board was a quarterly meeting where about all of these large projects were examined, vetted pretty fairly.
    • 01:10:19
      And at the same time, we got reports from the Class A railroads that were bringing reports on the progress and that type thing.
    • 01:10:27
      And we had representatives on the Rail Advisory Board that was in somewhat, was in tune with all the projects and where some of the funding was going, this type thing.
    • 01:10:36
      It appears to me that possibly we need to consider some type of quarterly reporting on these projects to this board from DRPT and possibly involve those partners that we're responsible for approving these funds to go through because we just don't have that involvement from a board perspective.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:10:59
      Yeah, I think Kevin is going to be providing somewhat what you're asking for, Mr.
    • 01:11:04
      Keen, I think in a couple of presentations.
    • 01:11:07
      So we'll just make a note that maybe quarterly is what we'll, because like you say, the rail board is no longer, so.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:13
      And that's what you felt comfortable with anyway, was quarterly?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:11:16
      Yeah, I mean that's, so we can just make it a financial and a rail project update.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:27
      Okay.
    • 01:11:30
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:11:32
      Okay.
    • 01:11:35
      Here's a topic no one seems to care about.
    • 01:11:38
      Corridors are statewide significant.
    • 01:11:40
      Mr. Tyeryar, come on up.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 01:11:46
      Am I driving or are you driving?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:11:57
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 01:12:09
      I want to talk to you about the corridors of statewide significance and a prioritization process for those.
    • 01:12:18
      Two times ago I was in front of you and I told you about allocating our annual budget in the Office of Intermodal Planning and one of the questions
    • 01:12:25
      that you asked was when are we going to start getting recommendations from the Office of Intermodal Planning, and so today is one of those first recommendations.
    • 01:12:35
      Here you can see on the slide what the Office of Intermodal Planning is supposed to do.
    • 01:12:40
      Designating corridors of statewide significance is one of those things, and we don't do that in isolation.
    • 01:12:46
      We do that in concert with other transportation agencies within the secretariat and with the localities.
    • 01:12:54
      We are supposed to coordinate the study of those corridors and then come back to you with corridor master plans.
    • 01:13:02
      What we have discovered in the process is that there are 11 corridors crisscrossing the state and to study any given corridor in its entire length is not a manageable process.
    • 01:13:14
      Certainly you can understand the needs of 460 between Grundy and Kentucky are different than those between Grundy and Blacksburg or difference between
    • 01:13:21
      Richmond, and Suffolk.
    • 01:13:23
      So we're going to talk to you about breaking those down into smaller segments.
    • 01:13:27
      This is what a corridor of statewide significance is supposed to do, connect activity centers, promote movement of people services and good, and promote the economy.
    • 01:13:39
      The last time I was here, not the time before that, I went through the state report card
    • 01:13:44
      And one of the things we discovered is that we were not doing very well in economic activity as it related to transportation so we'll deal with that as well as part of this presentation.
    • 01:13:54
      Here you can see the 11 corridors and I said they crisscross the state.
    • 01:13:57
      You can look at 58 and 460 across the south and see how long they are.
    • 01:14:03
      Certainly 81 from the Tennessee border to the Maryland border is 300 plus miles so again they become very
    • 01:14:12
      It's difficult to manage in their entirety, so what we're going to talk to you today is about breaking those down into smaller segments, and this is the process that we're going to go through that's on your slide in front of you.
    • 01:14:22
      Let's take a data-driven approach.
    • 01:14:25
      We'll link the prioritization process to the governor's multimodal strategic plan that was unveiled at the transportation conference in Roanoke.
    • 01:14:34
      And then we'll go through and we'll come up with some corridor master plans.
    • 01:14:36
      Again, based on the guidance of the CTB, those are supposed to preserve the operating capacity and the efficiency of the corridors and again be coordinated with the local stakeholders.
    • 01:14:49
      And then at some point, they have to be implemented and when it comes time to implement, it probably goes beyond the Office of Intermodal Planning and has to go off into the Six-Year Plan or into one of the district offices.
    • 01:14:59
      Really in the Office of Intermodal Planning, we're supposed to only be involved in advanced studies
    • 01:15:03
      And when you get the implementation, that's beyond advanced studies.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 01:15:08
      So here's the purpose of the corridor master plans.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:15:10
      Again, I won't read those to you, but locating entrances, intersections, median cuts, et cetera.
    • 01:15:18
      And the primary function of the corridor is to carry traffic some distance.
    • 01:15:22
      So we're not talking about folks who jump on and jump off using them for local travel, although certainly some of our major thoroughfares, including our interstates, do get used for local travel.
    • 01:15:34
      So this is the methodology that we've chosen.
    • 01:15:36
      Certainly this is here for your review.
    • 01:15:40
      We've taken the corridors of statewide significance and broken it down by the PDC boundaries.
    • 01:15:46
      You say, why PDC boundaries?
    • 01:15:47
      Because PDC boundaries are known.
    • 01:15:49
      You know, you could have said take it from a US highway to a US highway, but then it becomes much more subjective.
    • 01:15:54
      The PDC boundaries are divided.
    • 01:15:56
      So we've done that.
    • 01:15:57
      We'll collect the data.
    • 01:15:59
      We're going to organize the data by the strategic plan goals.
    • 01:16:02
      The attributes associated, we took
    • 01:16:05
      within five miles of the roadway corridor and then we're giving greater weight to the economic vitality goal and then if you approve of this process that I'm unfolding in front of you, we will leave the room immediately, run the model and come back to you this afternoon before we make a decision on another corridor and show you what our top ten are and the reason I'm going to show you ten
    • 01:16:26
      is because we think we can get two every six months, not in their entirety, but enough for you to have some idea of what's going on.
    • 01:16:33
      We get two the rest of calendar 11, two and 12, and two and 13, so we would get this now.
    • 01:16:40
      So here's what it looks like when you take the corridors and you break it down into the planning district.
    • 01:16:45
      You end up with 49 of them.
    • 01:16:46
      You'll recognize the names of the corridors.
    • 01:16:48
      You should recognize the names of the planning districts.
    • 01:16:50
      It just allows us to manage the process a little bit more simply.
    • 01:16:56
      Here are the goals from the governor's strategic plan.
    • 01:16:59
      Multimodal system that moves people.
    • 01:17:01
      These are the attributes that will add weight to the corridors.
    • 01:17:06
      Again, I won't read those to you.
    • 01:17:13
      Promote economic activity.
    • 01:17:15
      You see the attributes there.
    • 01:17:17
      Again, when we get to the model, we'll actually double the value.
    • 01:17:19
      We'll count these twice.
    • 01:17:21
      Number of projects that are underway.
    • 01:17:24
      Let me come back to you this afternoon.
    • 01:17:26
      The list of our priorities will show you the projects that are already underway in these segments, and it may be that you say to us at that point, well, we don't need to study that segment anymore, move on to something else.
    • 01:17:39
      Here's another one on sustainable and financial support.
    • 01:17:41
      We've identified the public-private facilities and the toll facilities as well.
    • 01:17:48
      The innovation and environmental get lumped together for purposes of this exercise, and you can see
    • 01:17:55
      Those attributes.
    • 01:17:59
      Customer focus in terms of congestion and state of good repair.
    • 01:18:04
      Again, customer focus.
    • 01:18:07
      Safety.
    • 01:18:09
      So when it waits, it's going to wait something like this.
    • 01:18:13
      The seamless and multimodal with its attributes, all of them except for economic activity will count 11, the financial support, the safety.
    • 01:18:21
      The customer focus, the technology and environmental protection and the collaborative planning.
    • 01:18:25
      And then when we get to supporting and promoting economic activity, we're actually going to double the weight of that in helping to address when we were here last time in our performance report card, we were failing on economic activity.
    • 01:18:38
      So one way to start to reverse that trend is to double the weight of these values.
    • 01:18:43
      So the thing that we come back with this afternoon will look something like this.
    • 01:18:46
      It will have the goals and the values.
    • 01:18:49
      And we will rank all of them from one to 49, but what you will be focusing on, at least I hope I can get you to focus on, is the top 10.
    • 01:19:00
      So in terms of where we are, if you like this process that I've unfolded in front of you, we will go immediately and start to prioritize it.
    • 01:19:07
      Again, we will come up with corridor master plans.
    • 01:19:11
      Here are the circles of the corridor master plans.
    • 01:19:20
      So we will do all of these activities and we will come back to you every six months.
    • 01:19:23
      I will bring you these results because I know you have another agenda on your item, another item on your agenda related to corridors of statewide significance that you want to deal with this afternoon.
    • 01:19:33
      And before we deal with that issue, I wanted to let you know where we stood in terms of the existing corridors.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:19:42
      How does this fit in with Mr. Koelemay's
    • 01:19:45
      Subgroup, and his report.
    • 01:19:48
      If anyone, is this, was that just the 29, but we also had a few others, didn't we?
    • 01:19:56
      And where's this?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:58
      Sure, go ahead, Mr. Koelem.
    • 01:19:59
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Peake, after our initial designation of Carters of Significance, we ran into some problems of specificity, particularly with the Highway US 29 corridor.
    • 01:20:13
      So we actually formed a subcommittee to look at that in more detail, which we did with your predecessors and then when you came on the board as well.
    • 01:20:20
      So at least the recommendations of the study process, for example, are consistent with our work at that time.
    • 01:20:29
      And it's almost like this, it was a test case for what it would look like to attempt
    • 01:20:37
      to arrive at a master plan for a specific corridor or a section.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:20:41
      This is kind of absorbing the work that we did in the subcommittee
    • 01:20:47
      which was related to 29 mainly, but we also wanted to set that up for a statewide process.
    • 01:20:52
      And this kind of adopts that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:55
      Well, what it does is it adds, it definitely adopts the process that we envisioned and it begins to put the data points to it to be able to support the decisions that we're going to make.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:21:07
      And it also takes the lesson learned from taking a corridor that crosses the entire Commonwealth and saying that that's just a process that's not
    • 01:21:14
      If you take 29 and you think of it from its northern termini at Gainesville down to somewhere, Culpeper, Warrenton, Charlottesville, then from there to Lynchburg and Lynchburg on to the North Carolina border, the attributes of those corridors are significantly different and to study them with one group just becomes not manageable and that's why we've broken it down into segments.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:39
      I'm missing a few pages on this, but I'll get to this.
    • 01:21:43
      I don't think we ought to rush this process.
    • 01:21:47
      I don't see how we're ready to vote on this meeting until we've digested this whole matter.
    • 01:21:55
      On Route 29, by the way, that was supposed to come up.
    • 01:21:58
      That's been pending for how long?
    • 01:22:00
      What happened to that?
    • 01:22:02
      I was told that that would come up this week.
    • 01:22:06
      Where are we?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:07
      I think it's going to be up in the next meeting, Jim.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:09
      One thing to note on 29 is that there was a central point that we all seem to agree on that would apply to the entire corridor, and that was to try to cut back on the traffic signals.
    • 01:22:24
      So there are universal issues that apply to an entire corridor.
    • 01:22:29
      In fact, I think we identified that was probably one of the most viable things we could do.
    • 01:22:38
      In the past, you mentioned stakeholder involvement.
    • 01:22:44
      and so forth.
    • 01:22:45
      In the past, when these things were designated, there was quite a bit of stakeholder involvement, as I understand it.
    • 01:22:52
      With the local governing bodies, businesses, at least on 29, we had a full panoply.
    • 01:22:58
      This is closer to your microphone.
    • 01:23:00
      Oh, sorry about that.
    • 01:23:01
      We had a full panoply of stakeholders involved when we designated these corridors.
    • 01:23:07
      Just wasn't done rather quickly without talking to the counties or the towns or the cities or the businesses.
    • 01:23:14
      or the universities, all the stakeholders had quite a bit of input in the designation.
    • 01:23:20
      Isn't that correct?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:23:23
      In the designation of the corridors?
    • 01:23:24
      Yes.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:25
      Yeah.
    • 01:23:26
      So we just didn't do it.
    • 01:23:28
      We talked to all these people.
    • 01:23:29
      Right.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:23:29
      And that's what we're doing here.
    • 01:23:30
      We're taking the existing corridors from the VTrans 2035 plan and we're saying, because of the lessons learned on 29, that studying them in long segments that crisscross the state
    • 01:23:42
      makes a process very unruly and takes a long period of time.
    • 01:23:46
      If we could break it down into smaller segments and to study those in smaller segments, then we could get information back to the CTB, which is one of the things that you told me you wanted when I was here and asked you about, you said, when are we going to start getting information from the Office of Intermodal Planning?
    • 01:24:02
      And we can get that information to you faster if we can break these long corridors into segments.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:07
      Well, I don't know how we can really have any lesson discussions on Route 29 when we haven't had the presentation on Route 29.
    • 01:24:13
      I've been asking for it for four or five months.
    • 01:24:16
      So I think that doesn't make sense.
    • 01:24:20
      What are the total results from 29?
    • 01:24:23
      We're still waiting for that.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:25
      Mr. Chairman, I have a question.
    • 01:24:28
      In order, I was trying to remember from our work we did previously on the corridors,
    • 01:24:33
      Was there a requirement that to be classified a quarter that it had to begin at Virginia's border and end at Virginia's border?
    • 01:24:42
      Or can a quarter within the Commonwealth not do that?
    • 01:24:47
      Because as I study this and reflect on the years, the time we spent working on this before, there are at least a couple of these that don't do that, and it seems strange to me
    • 01:24:59
      If we're telling them a corridor through Virginia that they don't connect, and obviously the Northern Virginia 66 corridor doesn't connect, and if you look at the blue, I guess it would be called the coastal corridor, it doesn't connect.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:25:15
      There was never any criteria that it had to go border to border.
    • 01:25:19
      It had to involve multiple modes and exist beyond a single region, beyond an individual region.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:26
      But doesn't it make sense that if it's a statewide corridor that it would connect?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:25:31
      Well, I don't know that it's a statewide corridor.
    • 01:25:33
      It's a corridor of statewide significance.
    • 01:25:35
      So a corridor can be a very short distance and still have a significant impact when it's moving people or commerce within the Commonwealth.
    • 01:25:43
      I don't think it has to stretch border to border to meet that.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:46
      Mr. Chairman, when I look at the map, it's quite obvious that they all do, except for two.
    • 01:25:51
      And they're in the two of the most controversial areas, obviously, to try to connect.
    • 01:25:57
      But I think it's something that we should pay attention to because if you look at that small neck at the top of Virginia, you see that they don't take you out of Virginia except into D.C. or up 81.
    • 01:26:10
      And it's a problem.
    • 01:26:14
      It's a bottleneck problem that needs to be addressed in some way.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:26:18
      Yes, just to further on what the other criteria were, it needs to connect regions or major activity centers.
    • 01:26:26
      provide high volumes of transport, whether it be freight or passenger, and then it needs to address unique statewide goals, whether evacuation or security or tourism or a unique truck route.
    • 01:26:42
      Those are the criteria for being a corridor statewide.
    • 01:26:44
      These are the 11 that emerged from a public process.
    • 01:26:49
      Certainly, as we went and met with PDCs and MPOs and citizens groups in assembling these 11, there were certainly more than those.
    • 01:26:56
      So when we apply the criteria to them, that's a filter that you can run them through to get them to this point.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:02
      Mr. Tyeryar, I appreciate that.
    • 01:27:06
      I just need to understand something.
    • 01:27:08
      I'm looking at all these and every one of these corridors is essentially following an existing road.
    • 01:27:17
      Is that correct?
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:27:18
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:20
      And then the question is, is that, I mean,
    • 01:27:24
      Where is in this process that you were talking about this data that if you want to look at new corridors that don't follow an existing road, how do you factor that in?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:27:38
      Well, you would be looking to address, I wouldn't necessarily say that, yeah, this one ended that way, they followed existing roads, but looking at the, if you're trying to move between two major
    • 01:27:53
      Economic Engines.
    • 01:27:55
      Our two latest economic engines are Dulles International Airport and the ports.
    • 01:28:01
      So if you're trying to connect them to somewhere else, an existing road bed or rail bed wouldn't have to work if you were trying to connect the economic engine.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:10
      All right.
    • 01:28:11
      So I guess follow along with that.
    • 01:28:15
      So we get to the chicken or the egg.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:28:18
      Okay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:18
      All right.
    • 01:28:20
      So where are these processors suggesting?
    • 01:28:23
      Do we then look at the fact that the closest, the fastest way between two points may be a straight line that may not have an existing road or rail or transit?
    • 01:28:38
      We don't have a process for that right now.
    • 01:28:41
      We do not.
    • 01:28:43
      And then when I look at some of the requirements that say, you know, land use and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, that's in the statute, I'm looking at that going,
    • 01:28:53
      Well, why does it say that if we're following right now every existing corridor that we have is already an existing road, roadway, interstates, or primary roads?
    • 01:29:12
      You understand what I'm saying?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:29:13
      I understand perfectly what you're saying and two projects that, one, the board has already taken action on is
    • 01:29:21
      is 460 to advance multiple providers through a next phase of providing alternative access to one of our, an additional access, not an alternative access, an additional access to one of our major economic engines in addition to providing an evacuation route.
    • 01:29:38
      In the north, we have Dulles International Airport which lacks a true north, a southern connection.
    • 01:29:47
      Right now to get to the airport,
    • 01:29:50
      essentially go up 95 and around the Beltway and out the Dulles Toll Road.
    • 01:29:58
      If you know the area, then you can find your way there through one of the back routes.
    • 01:30:03
      If you look at the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance's last website posting, for lack of a better term, where they put all the engineering studies out there, you'll see that most of the corridors in Northern Virginia
    • 01:30:18
      that involved getting to the airport are very clogged.
    • 01:30:21
      So there is still that one piece to that economic engine yet to be developed or to be built or to be studied even.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:29
      Well, but I just want to go back to, I want to make sure I understand this.
    • 01:30:32
      I mean, you're presenting about how we go ahead and prioritize these existing corridors, but we right now, even with what you're suggesting, don't really have a process or even have to set forward a process on how we look at
    • 01:30:48
      New corridors where there may not be existing transportation facilities.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:30:53
      Correct.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:54
      Not one that is as involved as this.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:30:57
      We have the surface transportation plan which is pretty much staff driven is not the public outreach that this process has.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:05
      So if we were to adopt a new corridor, then we could start the public process in looking at that corridor and how it fits.
    • 01:31:17
      where there may not be an existing road, but right now the whole process is geared towards following essentially existing roadways, not even following existing railways.
    • 01:31:29
      When I look at these corridors, they really follow roads and they don't really follow looking at rail, looking at the port, look at aviation facilities or any other things.
    • 01:31:42
      That generates significant statewide economic activity and transportation activity.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:31:48
      And that's one of the reasons I wanted to do this presentation this morning was to show you how these would shape up before you made a decision on another corridor this afternoon.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:59
      So it's clear then that there's no criteria or authority to add a new corridor right now, unless we try to come up with something.
    • 01:32:10
      In the past, we've done it without a lot of bureaucracy.
    • 01:32:13
      When we built I-66, we built it with, I guess, in accordance with the six-year plan, right?
    • 01:32:18
      When we did it over the normal process, with the public hearings, all of that.
    • 01:32:24
      understand that you're telling me that these corridors should not be within one particular area or district.
    • 01:32:31
      In other words, if you try to do a corridor just within the Culpeper District, that would not meet the criteria.
    • 01:32:38
      It's supposed to go beyond the district.
    • 01:32:41
      That type of thing.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:45
      Okay.
    • 01:32:45
      Mr. Chairman.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:46
      Mr. Miller.
    • 01:32:47
      I'm trying to understand, Mr. Cryer, the relationship between the
    • 01:32:52
      The corridor master plan and the statewide transportation plan and the corridors of statewide significance.
    • 01:33:00
      And as I read the couple pages that you have, it sort of summarizes, I guess, the statute.
    • 01:33:07
      This isn't actually the statute.
    • 01:33:09
      I think it's a summarization of the statute.
    • 01:33:12
      Yes.
    • 01:33:12
      I don't understand that linkage.
    • 01:33:15
      That's my first question.
    • 01:33:16
      I have another one if you can help me with that.
    • 01:33:19
      So we have some legislation that requires the CTB working with our staff and the Office of Intermental Planning to have a statewide, have a comprehensive review to come up with a statewide transportation plan.
    • 01:33:31
      We've done that.
    • 01:33:32
      Correct.
    • 01:33:33
      We did that pre-me, but some time ago.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:33:36
      And we called it VTrans 2035.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:38
      2035.
    • 01:33:42
      And within that process, we designated some corridors and state boxes.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:47
      Yes.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:47
      Eleven of them.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:48
      Correct.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:50
      And we did that in sufficient detail when we identified them so that the local jurisdictions could place them in the comprehensive plan.
    • 01:33:59
      Correct.
    • 01:34:00
      Whatever that means.
    • 01:34:00
      Whatever that level of detail means.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:02
      Correct.
    • 01:34:03
      Although they obviously have to be in their comprehensive plans because they're existing roadways.
    • 01:34:09
      That's the point I'm making.
    • 01:34:12
      I wasn't here when this all came up originally, but it's sort of goofy.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:34:22
      It's the chicken and the egg, as you described.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:24
      Yeah, that's goofy.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:34:25
      Not to interrupt you, we sent letters to all jurisdictions saying that Corridor X has been identified as a corridor of statewide significance within your locality and
    • 01:34:39
      According to state law, you should address it in your next comprehensive plan update.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:43
      And it might change how they would look at it in their comprehensive plan, although it's already in there because it's part of their system, but they may look at it differently.
    • 01:34:52
      Right.
    • 01:34:52
      So that's sort of what that talks about.
    • 01:34:54
      But then you just mentioned on page three, in summarizing 2.2, that projects identified as priorities in the CMP, which I presume is the quarter
    • 01:35:08
      will be considered as priorities for funding by us.
    • 01:35:11
      So where is the CMP versus the statewide transportation plan versus the corridor of statewide significance?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:35:21
      The CMPs with the exception of Route 29 have not been developed yet.
    • 01:35:25
      That's what I'm talking about today is to try to give us in the Office of Intermodal Planning some guidance so that we can go about developing corridor master plan.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:36
      So you're saying this would, we have the Court of Statewide Significance, an existing list anyway.
    • 01:35:42
      Yes.
    • 01:35:44
      You would go through a process in which to develop the CMP?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:35:48
      Yes.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:49
      And the process is the one you've laid out here?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:35:52
      The process is the last page, but that involves the public input and the pre-activity study and the corridor vision and the community input.
    • 01:36:02
      The process that I laid out until we get to this slide is how we would select
    • 01:36:05
      Number one, number two, all the way from one to 49 because we don't have the capacity to do them all at one time.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:15
      I'm sorry, number two.
    • 01:36:17
      I know I'm from an urban region, but I'm sort of overwhelmed by this presentation in terms of saying, yeah, that's a great process, have at it.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:36:27
      I am not suggesting that it's a great process, have at it.
    • 01:36:30
      I'm putting out there as an opportunity for us to go and run it
    • 01:36:35
      and say, these are one to 10, we advise you decide.
    • 01:36:40
      No, you don't like the results that came here or, but it gives us a jumping off point.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:46
      I guess I'd be more comfortable if I got comfortable with the process that you're never gonna run the model on.
    • 01:36:52
      And then when you got the model back, I'd say, well, does it sort of marry up with what I expected out of that sort of process?
    • 01:37:00
      And I could say, yeah, accept it or reject it.
    • 01:37:02
      But to sort of start with having no concept of what the process is and then go two or three steps down the road, then I got to come back to me as I do things like one step at a time and I'm not that good.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 01:37:15
      Simply stated, we've taken the corridors of statewide.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:37:18
      I'm not criticizing.
    • 01:37:19
      No, I'm not taking it as criticized.
    • 01:37:20
      I'm trying to oversimplify something here that I've overcomplicated, which is to take the corridors of statewide significance, mesh it up with the governor's transportation plan,
    • 01:37:31
      and saying what attributes would give it, which attributes would give that corridor value in the governor's transportation plan and that's what we do.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:40
      I guess what threw me a little bit was when you said if you all approve this process, I don't know how we approve it in this session, but if you approve this process, I'll go run the model and I'll bring it back and show you what the result is.
    • 01:37:51
      And I can do that.
    • 01:37:52
      So immediately I said, well, what process?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:55
      How do you do that?
    • 01:37:55
      We haven't even seen it.
    • 01:37:56
      Right.
    • 01:37:58
      This is all a database driven thing and we can plug it in.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:07
      I think the legislative history for this as well as the CTB history
    • 01:38:16
      Try to emphasize both in VTrans 2025 and to a somewhat similar degree in 2035, the multimodal nature of this whole idea.
    • 01:38:30
      It is not a road-building plan.
    • 01:38:33
      It may turn out to be that way if that's the best solution here and there.
    • 01:38:38
      You're not going to put in transit on the Coalfield Expressway, for example.
    • 01:38:44
      That's a needed road, I'd say.
    • 01:38:46
      So other forms of transportation out there don't make as much sense as a new road.
    • 01:38:53
      But in most of the other corridors, a multimodal approach is not only what was intended, but probably is, at least from my point of view, something that seriously needs to be examined, evaluated, and presented to the board in the form of various options.
    • 01:39:10
      That said, and without
    • 01:39:14
      I would like to have an opportunity for the board to look at this waiting process you have here because I only saw it ten minutes ago and I think it deserves more than a cursory review by the board.
    • 01:39:31
      Maybe a committee of the board would look at it if that were the chairman's wish but I think to say go ahead and do it based on a ten minute
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:39:41
      I agree with that, but the second thing that I would say is, Coalfield Expressway will, because of pedestrian movements and trails, have a multimodal component to it.
    • 01:39:55
      It's not the multimodal that we think of of rail and bus.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:59
      and Mark D. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:20
      I think there's a very good idea about having, I mean this is the first time everyone's had the opportunity to actually see this and walk them through the model and the numbers.
    • 01:40:39
      I mean whether it's individually going around to the members before the next meeting or a subcommittee, but I think
    • 01:40:47
      The waiting, to me the waiting is the issue.
    • 01:40:51
      And I hate to say this, in certain areas, in certain of these corridors, you might have different waits for what's there, like the coal fields.
    • 01:41:01
      You know, I just, I think there's a lot of different opportunities that we haven't had the opportunity to go through.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:07
      Gerald.
    • 01:41:10
      Obviously, I think we'll all be very supportive of this as long as
    • 01:41:13
      Our areas are in 1 through 10.
    • 01:41:18
      I look at some of the things that are identified.
    • 01:41:21
      Local transit services, I'm assuming based on the chart that, okay, if you've got a local transit service, you get a point.
    • 01:41:29
      Greyhound station, you get a point.
    • 01:41:30
      Amtrak station, you get a point.
    • 01:41:32
      Go through and you can get 11 points that way.
    • 01:41:34
      Some of the others, crash rate, 3.667.
    • 01:41:37
      I'm not sure how that weighs into it.
    • 01:41:41
      probably would make at least me more comfortable.
    • 01:41:44
      Is there a descriptor on how each one of these factors in?
    • 01:41:48
      If I'm making some assumptions on, like say, the local transit services, can that be distributed to everybody that says, look, this is what crash rate means?
    • 01:41:56
      The higher it is, the more you get on that 3.667?
    • 01:42:01
      Yes.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:42:01
      Well, let me just address your first point.
    • 01:42:06
      If we're going to try to get 10 in the next 30 months, not everybody's going to be
    • 01:42:12
      represented intuitively.
    • 01:42:14
      Intuitively though you can kind of figure out where safety and congestion and mobility economic development opportunities are and you can almost kind of figure out what it's going to look like and I don't know that all are going to be represented.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:34
      I'm just trying to get an idea of what some of the measures when we're looking at it like crash rate
    • 01:42:40
      Road, whether, how you, I mean, just having a crash, does that automatically give you a 3.667?
    • 01:42:45
      I don't think so.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:42:46
      No, it's a rate on a, it's a per mile crash rate.
    • 01:42:50
      Oh, and that's kind of what I'm looking at.
    • 01:42:52
      It's just undescriptive.
    • 01:42:53
      So you need a glossary, essentially.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:54
      I'm sorry, Mr. Koelemay?
    • 01:42:57
      Mr. Terry, thank you.
    • 01:42:58
      When the CTB was given the authority to designate corridors,
    • 01:43:04
      One of the main charges that we've got in the legislation really directs us to assist localities and regional authorities functionally to get beyond some of the parochialism that exists at those areas.
    • 01:43:18
      In other words, that particular corridor, as Mr. Sterling said, in my area works for me, but I don't really care about whether it works at the next piece over.
    • 01:43:30
      So I'm worried about number nine on your slide nine,
    • 01:43:34
      If we actually divide the cost evaluation into 49 different sections
    • 01:43:41
      How do we get that back together so that a corridor actually functions as a corridor even though the characteristics in 49 different places may be different?
    • 01:43:52
      The PDCs aren't necessarily used to working closely with one another on these problems.
    • 01:43:58
      It seems to me that we may be chopping this into actually too many pieces to be able to put it back together.
    • 01:44:06
      What would be an alternative that would be less than 49 but more than 11?
    • 01:44:11
      I mean would it be two PDC districts at least have to be involved so that you're able to get a whole segment done as opposed to simply pieces within each PDC or I mean how did you arrive at sort of cutting it up that many ways?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:44:28
      I cut it up because the geographical boundaries of the PDCs
    • 01:44:31
      were known and it was something you could draw on a map and you could say that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:35
      Well, what a functional definition rather than a geographic one might be better.
    • 01:44:39
      I mean that, for example, a rail line is really the point.
    • 01:44:44
      It's not the point about where the rail line jurisdictionally is because you can pull those jurisdictions into the discussion regardless of how you slice it out, right?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:44:56
      Yes, we could do that.
    • 01:44:57
      What we would do essentially is
    • 01:45:02
      You'd have to take the attributes and say where do we have rail congestion or where do we have AM peak or PM peak congestion.
    • 01:45:08
      You could take the attributes and say but then at that point you'd have to rank the attributes and you'd have to say the rail congestion is more important than so that you would go and look for the places that had rail congestion and study that first.
    • 01:45:21
      So you'd go and look for the places that had AM peak mobility issues or AM peak
    • 01:45:25
      connectivity issues, so you still have to come up with a ranking system before you can study.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:30
      If you use challenges or problems, that would give you also a solutions-oriented process as opposed to a jurisdictional-oriented process, which I think the legislation wanted to get us away from.
    • 01:45:42
      This isn't supposed to simply be an extension of the locality or a regional authority.
    • 01:45:47
      It's really meant to be larger.
    • 01:45:49
      The second point I wanted to make was this.
    • 01:45:51
      One thing we learned from the 29 subcommittee is that along the corridor, you know, half the people involved are quite willing to have the corridor split into pieces so that Lynchburg just worries about Lynchburg and Charlottesville and just worries about Charlottesville and so forth.
    • 01:46:07
      But the other half are actually saying, look, the problem is we need to look at it as a whole, not as pieces.
    • 01:46:13
      Pieces are what got us into the fixed rent.
    • 01:46:16
      where somebody has their piece doing it the way they want that's totally at odds with the other pieces on either side.
    • 01:46:22
      So I just want to be aware that's really the challenge for us and I think the CTB's role is to actually try to keep the corridors together as much as possible as opposed to splinter them into smaller pieces.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:46:35
      I'd like to second that because clearly
    • 01:46:39
      Northern Virginia, Richmond, Hampton Roads is a quarter.
    • 01:46:43
      I mean, it clearly is.
    • 01:46:44
      When you talk about rail or whatever you want to do, it is.
    • 01:46:47
      And so under your scenario, it would break those up, maybe not in terms of studying them.
    • 01:46:52
      And I do believe that Mr. Koelemay bringing it out makes a lot of sense.
    • 01:46:57
      The second thing is, we talked about polarization, Mr., that we brought up.
    • 01:47:04
      Hampton Roads went through the polarization process for their project.
    • 01:47:06
      It took them 18 months to determine the weighting.
    • 01:47:10
      So I would hope that we could get through it quicker than that in this and here.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:16
      Mr. Koelemay talked about challenges.
    • 01:47:19
      Let me throw out a challenge.
    • 01:47:21
      I think we're kind of in Alice in Wonderland here.
    • 01:47:23
      Funding reality.
    • 01:47:25
      Is any of this connected to the funding reality?
    • 01:47:27
      We're giving half of our trust fund budget for maintenance.
    • 01:47:33
      So we've got to be very careful about how we spend money.
    • 01:47:37
      We can't just take on everything without being grounded in the financial reality of the situation.
    • 01:47:45
      And frankly, I'm not ready to vote on anything until I have some technical advice from VDOT and some of the regional transportation experts on what really works.
    • 01:47:57
      Because we can spend money on stuff.
    • 01:47:59
      In any of our districts, and if it doesn't work, it's a total waste of money, and we have to be accountable to our commuters and our taxpayers.
    • 01:48:11
      For example, in Northern Virginia, we've got a metro system that's about ready to fall apart.
    • 01:48:15
      You can get killed on the thing.
    • 01:48:16
      People have been.
    • 01:48:17
      People are injured.
    • 01:48:19
      I mean, we've got existing facilities that are in total disarray.
    • 01:48:23
      So let's get back to some sense of financial reality as to what we can do before we start adding things or say we're going to do X, Y, or Z with no money.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:48:34
      Well, let me address that.
    • 01:48:35
      The Office of Intermodal Planning has a budget that is set aside by state code and it is to be used for advanced studies to address issues.
    • 01:48:48
      I will be in front of you later this afternoon to go over the MPO performance measures that again are required by state code and you will see that it becomes a mix and a match as to what works in each region to come up with.
    • 01:49:06
      Maybe I have broken it down into too many segments but to consider a segment that begins in Springfield and extends through Richmond and on to Norfolk and thinks that there is
    • 01:49:15
      A singular set of solutions or a singular set of criteria would be tough, not impossible, would be tough.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:29
      You're going to have to go back and do a little work on your side of this, okay?
    • 01:49:34
      I mean, I think you've got to sit down.
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:49:36
      Do you want to have a little subcommittee?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:38
      Do you want to... Why don't I just make the rounds?
    • 01:49:40
      Just go to make the rounds.
    • 01:49:41
      Go around and walk everybody through this.
    • 01:49:43
      There's a lot of stuff.
    • 01:49:44
      Just waiting.
    • 01:49:45
      It'd be very interesting to understand how the waiting came together.
    • 01:49:47
      and you know essentially, and I realize you're sitting there saying the top 10 but I'm looking at least the way we've originally presented this thing we have only have 11 corridors right now so I realize you want to break it up but I'm very concerned about this breaking it up issue as well because
    • 01:50:06
      I mean, the whole reason, going back to Ms. Koelemay's concern, and that is, I mean, we're at the state, we're up here, and we're trying to look at macro, what's happening across the state, and where we've always run into trouble is this issue of localities, maybe not supporting, not putting comprehensive plan, MPOs, whatever.
    • 01:50:30
      We have examples of that throughout the Commonwealth right now.
    • 01:50:34
      That's the issue of trying to look at corridors in moving people and goods efficiently up and down them in and out of the state.
    • 01:50:44
      In fact, it was interesting, the study, the freight study, we didn't do a presentation yet on the freight study, did we?
    • 01:50:54
      I mean, I thought it was fascinating when you looked at 40% of the freight
    • 01:50:59
      freight on, in the Commonwealth of Virginia, 40% is actually passing through the state.
    • 01:51:05
      I hate to say it, part of me wants to say, you know, it's things like that where these corridors are imperative.
    • 01:51:11
      It is, but it's also, we're looking at statewide corridors as well as looking at how do you connect regional economic centers, activity centers, generators, and how do you serve those into the future, which is
    • 01:51:26
      I think the statute is trying to do both.
    • 01:51:29
      So could you go back?
    • 01:51:32
      Go around every board member and walk them through this.
    • 01:51:35
      I think it would be very helpful.
    • 01:51:37
      And then maybe it would be helpful just giving where you're going anyway, show them how the numbers would end up gearing up for their corridors and their areas.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:50
      I can do that.
    • 01:51:51
      All right, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:51:52
      Yes, Dr. Davis.
    • 01:51:53
      I've been sitting here reflecting on the service
    • 01:51:57
      on the committee that looked at this the last time.
    • 01:51:59
      And there's some people on here who probably looked at it even before that, Jerry and others.
    • 01:52:04
      And as I did, I've always looked at this differently, perhaps, than the way some members of the CTB, based on the questions asked today, are looking at it.
    • 01:52:17
      I don't see it as an allocation of funds process.
    • 01:52:23
      It really is
    • 01:52:24
      A top-down look at the whole state of Virginia as to how you get from one place to another and how you take advantage of our major economic development opportunities in the Commonwealth and basically how you improve the quality of life of citizens in the Commonwealth as they move around while you also consider the traffic that just flows through Virginia one way or the other, rail, car, whatever.
    • 01:52:51
      And in that conversation we had about how to do that, we kind of stopped thinking about our districts and whether or not we want more red lights or less red lights.
    • 01:53:03
      And we talked about how should it really work.
    • 01:53:07
      And that's why I think we were talking about there were some disconnects here that we aren't talking about because people don't want to talk about them because they're controversial and difficult.
    • 01:53:17
      Twenty-nine being the best example when we tried to talk about it.
    • 01:53:21
      Instead, we started talking about Culpeper or 29 and Gainesville or wherever it was.
    • 01:53:27
      So I'd like for us to keep this process focused on the big look and forget about the funding part of it for a little while because it's going to be real enough right away when we start talking about, well, if that really is the right quarter and the right way, we're going to have to come down now to the Six-Year Plan and talk about how are we really going to do this.
    • 01:53:47
      And the balance between rail, whether it's passenger or freight, or cars, or using the airports more effectively, really do need to be talked about in that macro sense.
    • 01:53:59
      So I hope we won't get down to having to talk about formulas for how many crashes and this and that and whatever else.
    • 01:54:07
      It really is what would be best for the Commonwealth of Virginia for these corridors.
    • 01:54:12
      I hope we can keep it at that level and not get it down into all that detail.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:16
      Very good point for Dr. Davis.
    • 01:54:20
      I would also say, having been on the initial board subcommittee or whatever we called it for the E-Trans 2025, the most significant advance in transportation planning that came out of that approach
    • 01:54:40
      and the Carters were in there, they had a different name at that point but the idea, the most important idea was to make the land use transportation planning connection between state transportation planning and local land use planning.
    • 01:54:56
      If you want to talk about disconnects, that's where the biggest disconnect that we saw several years ago existed and all of this corridor planning has at least one outcome intended
    • 01:55:09
      The notion that we do a better job of eliminating that disconnect and having better collaboration and cooperation.
    • 01:55:17
      And there were several pieces of legislation that were subsequently adopted by the General Assembly by almost unanimous consent in some cases.
    • 01:55:26
      So I don't think we shouldn't forget that as one of the driving forces.
    • 01:55:31
      One of the reasons we did this
    • 01:55:33
      is to try to rationalize a system that is going in two different directions without accountability for each other's decisions and that's the trick because no one wants to give up its control over land use nor does the state and the CTB
    • 01:55:52
      wants to give up its control of transportation financing nor does it want to waste transportation funding on things that might be frustrated by local land use decisions or even vice versa.
    • 01:56:04
      So please, as you go forward, bear that concept in mind because unless you want to change it, which is of course your prerogative if you get the General Assembly to go along with you, that's one of the driving reasons we're doing this in the first place.
    • 01:56:20
      I would love us to get to the point
    • 01:56:21
      where we make the connection between all of this planning and actual Six-Year Plan allocation of funds, but we're a long way from that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:31
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:56:32
      Thank you.
    • 01:56:35
      We will get to Mr. Russell, talk about the tornado briefing.
    • 01:56:39
      Great job by everybody out there, nothing but positive for all the working people, actually across
    • 01:56:45
      across the state.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:56:50
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'm here to talk to you about the tornado occurred in Bristol District late on April 27th and early in the morning on April 28th.
    • 01:57:01
      Three tornadoes touched down in the district ranging from an ES0, which is winds from 65 to 85 miles per hour, to an EF3 in the town of Lade Springs,
    • 01:57:12
      with winds ranging from 136 to 165 miles an hour.
    • 01:57:14
      This is the general pattern of the storm.
    • 01:57:19
      It's a little hard to see on the slide.
    • 01:57:21
      We've just got the town of Abington right there just to the left of the EF0, southern Washington County, and then the storms move to the northeast through the town of Glade Springs.
    • 01:57:30
      Could you turn your mic?
    • 01:57:36
      This is an illustration of the exit 29 off of I-81 at Glade Spring.
    • 01:57:41
      The area shaded in red is where the heaviest damage was sustained.
    • 01:57:44
      I'll have some photos of the damage in this area here in just a couple slides.
    • 01:57:48
      We've got some major businesses in the area, Gates Manufacturing, Utility Trailer, and Petro Truck Stop in the area, all sustained heavy damage.
    • 01:57:57
      A little further north, Chill Howie in Smith County, one of our contractors, W&L, had their offices destroyed along with several homes in the area.
    • 01:58:06
      I'll just run through quickly some of the photos of the area.
    • 01:58:09
      This is actually right on I-81 right away, just north of exit 29.
    • 01:58:16
      This picture really kind of tells a story, just the scale of the damage.
    • 01:58:20
      You see several tractor trailers overturned in the background.
    • 01:58:23
      This is also the location of the Incident Command Center that was set up, just off to the left of the picture.
    • 01:58:31
      Really scary right here.
    • 01:58:32
      A tractor trailer, the red one in the upper right, loaded at 45,000 pounds, lifted completely off the ground, slammed into the truck on the left, which then turned into the restaurant in the background.
    • 01:58:42
      It's the truck stop.
    • 01:58:46
      More photos here, completely overturned tractor trailers.
    • 01:58:50
      Nothing like I'd ever seen before.
    • 01:58:54
      These are businesses just to the north of this interchange, across the interstate from the truck stop, just completely destroyed.
    • 01:59:01
      Several homes along Stagecoach Road.
    • 01:59:04
      This is also just directly across the interstate from the truck stop as you're getting into the town of Glade Springs.
    • 01:59:13
      These are homes along Route 11, just basically on the southern side of I-81.
    • 01:59:19
      Similar damage for quite a good ways up Route 11 to the north.
    • 01:59:25
      More of the VDOT infrastructure damage traffic signal at the intersection of 91 and Route 11 was destroyed, but you can't see the uneruptable power supply.
    • 01:59:35
      It's still working.
    • 01:59:36
      The light's still on.
    • 01:59:38
      The sign's in the background there.
    • 01:59:39
      It's kind of hard to see in the photo on the right, but we did sustain damage to a SALT facility at the Glade Area headquarters, which is right in the small area.
    • 01:59:49
      Again, more damage.
    • 01:59:50
      This is apartment complex for at least one of the deaths I know of occurred.
    • 01:59:54
      There are four total, three during the storm and one in an accident shortly after in the morning of the 28th.
    • 02:00:02
      Businesses that are damaged here, this is Gates I showed you on the earlier photo, over 100 employees at this location.
    • 02:00:10
      This is the W&L office and some storage buildings there in Shilhowee.
    • 02:00:14
      Again, W&L is one of our contractors who's really key in the Bristol District.
    • 02:00:17
      They're really one of our only paving contractors doing our paving schedules.
    • 02:00:23
      Response for VDOT officially began about 2 o'clock when our CHAMS coordinator and duty officer got a call from the Traffic Operations Center.
    • 02:00:31
      Actually, when they called crews out, they found them already on scene because weather reports were calling for the storms very early on.
    • 02:00:38
      I personally talked to one of the operators who thought his truck was going to go similar to the tractor trailer.
    • 02:00:44
      He was pretty shook up.
    • 02:00:47
      Incident Command was established in accordance with National Incident Management System, or NIMS.
    • 02:00:54
      Tam's contractor called TME, who's our interstate maintenance contractor, to find that they were unable to get on site.
    • 02:01:01
      So he directed them to actually start clearing Route 11 and 91, which fed the interstate.
    • 02:01:07
      There's several overturned tractor trailers in the area, as you can see, as well as multiple storage containers that you see there in the lower part of that photograph actually thrown completely across the interstate.
    • 02:01:17
      So we pulled crews in from the north at the Chilhowie area and from the south at the Abbotts area to actually clear 81.
    • 02:01:24
      It was reopened around 5.30, but congestion was very heavy throughout the rest of the day.
    • 02:01:30
      Most of the roads were open that following day with the exception of the ones that were still being worked on by the power company.
    • 02:01:36
      That was one of our biggest issues.
    • 02:01:39
      This is a list of equipment here, close to 150 maintenance crew members out there working, including contractors.
    • 02:01:46
      Seven excavators, eight loaders, well over 56 dump trucks, and some specialty log handling loaders.
    • 02:01:53
      You'll see some pictures of those here shortly.
    • 02:01:56
      Again, I mentioned response issues is primarily related to the power lines that were down.
    • 02:02:00
      Also, working in confined areas, we had narrow two-lane roads.
    • 02:02:04
      We really couldn't get multiple crews in there, and one crew had to get in there and clear it out.
    • 02:02:10
      There was some looting reported in the area, so the state police did establish a curfew, and they also restricted the area to residents who basically could not get into the area unless you have permanent.
    • 02:02:21
      Here's some photos of our debris removal operations, some of the specialty equipment you see there that are contractors.
    • 02:02:26
      We rely heavily on them to provide that type of equipment.
    • 02:02:32
      And this is TME helping to clear out 91.
    • 02:02:34
      This is in the very early morning of the 28.
    • 02:02:40
      We've got crews in Glade Spring working to clean the roads.
    • 02:02:43
      This is getting into more of the community area of Glade Spring.
    • 02:02:48
      Just a photo of our disposal facilities.
    • 02:02:50
      We've got a total of five that we're using, one shared with Washington County.
    • 02:02:56
      Just another assessment here, looking at close to two and a quarter million dollars in costs and over 52,000 cubic yards of debris to be removed.
    • 02:03:07
      The interstate is approximately 60% complete with the majority of the work being assigned, guard rail, and fencing to be replaced.
    • 02:03:15
      Secondary is about 40% complete with, again, the roads are open.
    • 02:03:18
      We're just going back now and cleaning the right of way, and that's going to be an ongoing effort.
    • 02:03:23
      Homeowners are pulling debris to the right-of-way in coordination with Washington County and their contractors as to the actual cleanup effort there.
    • 02:03:31
      We're coordinating real closely with them on that effort.
    • 02:03:34
      We are planning an after-action review internally and hopefully with the CDEM and the local governments as well.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:41
      Russell, great job for everyone out there.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:48
      The Governor was very impressed, everyone else was out there.
    • 02:03:51
      Nothing but very complimentary things for everything you guys did.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:58
      Is the benefit that being declared a federal disaster area that we get some reimbursement for some of our spenders and so forth.
    • 02:04:07
      I'm having difficulty looking at all you showed me and having dropped by in lady one, understanding how this doesn't qualify as a federal disaster area.
    • 02:04:20
      And we didn't get that.
    • 02:04:22
      I think there was an application made so far.
    • 02:04:25
      Are you privileged to any information why
    • 02:04:27
      Disqualified or anything like that?
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 02:04:29
      Just what I've read in the paper, which is that process is tied to how the number of uninsured homes versus the state's ability to recoup the cost.
    • 02:04:38
      I will say that all of our efforts to date have been going down a path that should that declaration be made that we would be in a position to be reimbursed.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:49
      Any other questions?
    • 02:04:51
      Ms. Russell, great job.
    • 02:04:52
      Thank you.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:52
      Thank you very much.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:55
      We'll do one more, Dr. Gomez, on dynamic mobility grants, and then we'll just break for a grab lunch.
    • 02:05:06
      Is that good?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:05:06
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:05:07
      Mr. Secretary, Dr. Gomez is new to his position.
    • 02:05:15
      He's been appointed as the research director probably a couple months ago.
    • 02:05:21
      and he's been with the department over 18 years, did a lot of work in research in the bridge area and a real dedicated employee and I've never seen anyone so gung ho about his job.
    • 02:05:37
      I've asked him to do a couple things today just to give a brief overview of some of the things that we want to do in the research area, some of the audit points that came up,
    • 02:05:50
      Just to let you know that Dr. Gomez is focusing on those and then to give you an overview of the initiative to improve safety and mobility to have our vehicles communicate with each other and the infrastructure.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:06:17
      Thank you for the opportunity.
    • 02:06:24
      I'd like to give you a brief overview of just some of the things we're doing at the Research Council and the first opportunity for me as the director to speak for you all.
    • 02:06:35
      As you all are aware, research division went through a review last year.
    • 02:06:40
      The most important recommendation from my view was that we were, it was recommended to retain the collaborative VDOT research business model.
    • 02:06:50
      And overall, that is my goal, which is to build and maintain a strong internal research staff, to build and maintain a strategic contract research program.
    • 02:07:00
      and also to partner and seek partnerships for external grants funding to enhance our research program and the VDOT mission.
    • 02:07:11
      Specifically, there were recommendations from their review that specifically dealing with implementation, commissioner has authorized up to $10 million in implementation funds to put our product out there
    • 02:07:28
      in the system, whatever that product may be, whether it's high-performance concrete, corrosion-resistant reinforcing steel, enhanced operating systems operations, et cetera.
    • 02:07:41
      We are working with the commissioner.
    • 02:07:42
      We have, at this point, have committed funding for quiet pavement and some additional studies.
    • 02:07:51
      And with that, the recommendation to enhance, to improve upon our research advisory committee program, specifically with implementation.
    • 02:08:03
      We had, as you all know, since the inception of the research division in 1948, the strength has been a tie to the department, to the folks in the field with our research advisory committees.
    • 02:08:15
      We have always asked them to participate, to bring their research problems, issues to us.
    • 02:08:24
      We are asking them now to also serve to help us implement the research findings from our research program.
    • 02:08:31
      And that's a key point, to bring them in as champions for the research program leading to implementation.
    • 02:08:39
      We are, part of the study was to include multimodal focus and we are increasing our multimodal focus.
    • 02:08:46
      We are establishing a multimodal research scientist position.
    • 02:08:51
      Once that position, once that person's on board, I want to establish a multimodal research advisory committee.
    • 02:08:57
      We've worked with DRPT, Ms. Drake and her staff in establishing the position.
    • 02:09:02
      As well, I've asked her and the staff to also help us in establishing research advisory committee.
    • 02:09:09
      From that, I'm going to look at universities who may have multimodal surface transportation components to their research programs to look at potential partnerships.
    • 02:09:20
      I want to get on board the person, the advisory committee, the program that we want, and then ask the universities if they can help us.
    • 02:09:30
      Another review recommendation was to strengthen our academic partnerships.
    • 02:09:37
      We have very obviously, you all know, strong partnerships with the University of Virginia, Virginia Tech and VTTI, the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute.
    • 02:09:45
      We have reached out to universities, Old Dominion University, George Mason.
    • 02:09:53
      My plan is to meet with them.
    • 02:09:54
      I want to invite them back to our research advisory committee meetings in the fall.
    • 02:09:58
      in those areas where they have expertise or interest that they can understand our business, how our processes are in place to enhance the research programs.
    • 02:10:09
      We are working to reestablish the Graduate Research Assistantship Program with UVA.
    • 02:10:14
      That's a program where we have fund graduate students to work with our scientists
    • 02:10:21
      with the divisions, with the district directly on research projects in all aspects of our research program.
    • 02:10:31
      It's provided many, many professional people that go into the field either working for VDOT or working with VDOT in the consultant world and we are reestablishing that program with UVA.
    • 02:10:42
      Part of that also is our summer internship program that we're starting again.
    • 02:10:48
      Think of that as our minor league.
    • 02:10:50
      That's where we get undergraduates who have an interest in research and transportation, whether it's in materials research or traffic engineering.
    • 02:11:02
      We bring them on board.
    • 02:11:03
      They work with us.
    • 02:11:05
      We seed our graduate program that way, and so we are re-establishing that program this summer.
    • 02:11:13
      Those are a few of the highlights and I hope to report back to you with many others as we progress in this first year.
    • 02:11:19
      Thank you.
    • 02:11:21
      Onward to the matter of business.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:11:22
      Any questions?
    • 02:11:26
      Yes, Ms. Koelemay.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:27
      Thank you.
    • 02:11:28
      Do you have established already some priorities in terms of functional areas, for example, material science or construction techniques or...
    • 02:11:38
      Yes, sir.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:11:38
      ...system management or...
    • 02:11:42
      We have non-research advisory committees in place now.
    • 02:11:45
      Those non include Concrete Research, what we call the CRAC, which is an awful name, but the Concrete Research Advisory Committee, the acronym.
    • 02:11:53
      We have BRAC, the Bridge Research, Asphalt.
    • 02:11:59
      We have Geotechnical.
    • 02:12:00
      We have Environmental.
    • 02:12:01
      We have Traffic Engineering.
    • 02:12:05
      We have Operations.
    • 02:12:08
      Those are our nine core areas of research and those are our nine core advisory committees.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:21
      Can you tell us are you looking at things like value engineering and maybe a related topic is context sensitive design whereby we could save a lot of money as well as still providing adequate transportation facilities.
    • 02:12:37
      Are you looking into those areas?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:12:40
      As far as value engineering, we have not specifically on board right now there is not a research project in that area.
    • 02:12:49
      That's not to say it can't be, but we certainly can.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:55
      We can certainly start one at any time, but there is not one currently.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:05
      I think the commissioner wanted to answer.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:07
      Chairman, we do have a value engineering program within the department.
    • 02:13:12
      We do look at our projects and look for ways we can cut costs through that program.
    • 02:13:20
      And it's a pretty formal program.
    • 02:13:22
      Maybe what we can do in another meeting is give you an overview on our value engineering program.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:30
      That might be helpful.
    • 02:13:30
      Thank you.
    • 02:13:32
      Mr. McCarthy?
    • 02:13:34
      Congratulations Dr. Gomez.
    • 02:13:36
      The last time we saw you I think we were visiting the center up in Charlottesville and I remember you gave a very, very excellent presentation to us about structural engineering and bridges and things of that sort which I think was very helpful to us in our understanding of why the bridge problem is so widespread around the state and why it should be a priority.
    • 02:14:03
      I would recommend, Mr. Chairman, if you start thinking of making short trips outside of Richmond, taking the board up to hear what the research group is doing would be a good use of the board's time.
    • 02:14:15
      It's a really fascinating place with a lot of wonderful work underway that should be informing a lot of what we do.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:25
      You know, Mr. McCarthy, it's funny you said that.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:28
      I was thinking the same thing.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:30
      I mean, one of the things, obviously, we've been trying to limit is the cost of the CTB and having the meetings here because there's so much staff support that's necessary.
    • 02:14:39
      And so that means trying to avoid overnights.
    • 02:14:43
      But, you know, what is the Charles bill?
    • 02:14:45
      It's just around two hours, which is driveable.
    • 02:14:48
      Actually, a lot of the members, I mean, there might be the possibility to actually host a
    • 02:14:52
      CTB meeting up there on the UVA campus.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:14:55
      We hosted a board meeting about five years ago, sir.
    • 02:14:58
      There's a presence for that.
    • 02:14:59
      We did that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:00
      I think it's a very good idea.
    • 02:15:01
      I think, actually, at least there would be an opportunity where, I mean, I would not envision that the cost would be very high for us to do that.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:15:11
      And obviously, anybody more than welcome to come visit, I would love to show you our laboratory facilities and the things that we do.
    • 02:15:17
      Mr. Coley, back to your question.
    • 02:15:21
      We are into so many things.
    • 02:15:22
      It's surface transportation related, whether it's a piece of concrete or a piece of steel or it's a traffic signal.
    • 02:15:29
      There's a piece of research there somewhere.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:37
      A lot of things that you're talking about are things that when I first came out there and I think you were the one to talk the most other than Dr. Allen.
    • 02:15:45
      And particularly this whole focus on getting your research and applying the research into our field units in our procurement system is critical to making you guys essentially the tip of the spear for us.
    • 02:16:03
      The second thing is the multimodal side and I keep on stressing it.
    • 02:16:07
      You all have the opportunity really to help us do our jobs better and all the agencies better by looking at multi-modal and helping us find alternatives where transit or rail could end up having more of an impact on
    • 02:16:24
      Dr. David A.
    • 02:16:26
      Young, Dr. David A.
    • 02:16:31
      Young, Dr. David A.
    • 02:16:41
      They were eliminated, which essentially was, they were being, almost all being paid off of research grants on projects.
    • 02:16:49
      It wasn't as if this was, we were saving any money by doing it.
    • 02:16:54
      In fact we lost money because once you lose that capability, you lost the opportunity to go and compete for grants because your staff is how many people?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:17:03
      We have about 25 scientists who control the program, so we're not very deep, and that gives us a significant depth, gives us very talented worker bees.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:14
      At your high point, how many research assistants did you have?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:17:17
      At our high point, my time there, we had 16 research, graduate research assistants, and probably that many undergraduates at the time.
    • 02:17:25
      Our halls are full.
    • 02:17:27
      Labs are busy.
    • 02:17:28
      They still are, but it's just, the problem is it takes away the scientists
    • 02:17:33
      The scientist is breaking cylinders collecting the data when they could be going out and implementing or starting another project for the department and having the GRA be doing that work.
    • 02:17:44
      So we're getting it back, sir.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:46
      We're very glad with the work that yourself and the commissioner has been doing on this as well as your staff.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:17:51
      Thank you.
    • 02:17:52
      I remember your comment about you said
    • 02:17:56
      The Skin in the Game, and The Skin in the Game is that $10 million implementation fund because your other comment was how did we get those two projects in Prince William County so quickly.
    • 02:18:05
      It's because we had implementation funding.
    • 02:18:07
      So thank you very much, sir.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:08
      So you remember, somebody listens to me.
    • 02:18:13
      I told you I like this guy.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:18:22
      Now, matter of hand, just to update you all,
    • 02:18:26
      on a project and a pooled fund study that has been in place and just to give you an update because it leads to a much bigger project in essence.
    • 02:18:42
      I'll give you an overview of what is a connected transportation system and specifically what is this pooled fund study.
    • 02:18:51
      Connected Vehicle is a national initiative to improve safety and mobility by enabling communications between vehicles, infrastructure, and devices.
    • 02:19:00
      Basically, in this world of wireless technology, connecting everything up, connecting up our operation centers with vehicles and vice versa.
    • 02:19:08
      The vehicle connectivity provides a bi-directional ability in a vehicle to vehicle, vehicle to infrastructure, vehicle to device.
    • 02:19:16
      and this gives the user significantly more ability to communicate and or take data from our traffic operation systems, for instance.
    • 02:19:28
      This is basically what this schematic of what this program is.
    • 02:19:32
      It's a transportation system whereby all the users are connected, all the management of the users are connected.
    • 02:19:40
      You've got vehicles talking to vehicles, you've got vehicles getting data or talking to signal
    • 02:19:46
      phase and timing information.
    • 02:19:49
      You've got vehicles talking to or receiving information from our transportation operation systems.
    • 02:19:55
      Everybody's connected and that's what the focus of this pool fund is.
    • 02:20:01
      The pool fund represents a partnership of transportation agencies.
    • 02:20:04
      I'll give you a slide in a minute of who those partners are who've come together to establish a program to facilitate and evaluate the possibilities for connected vehicle applications.
    • 02:20:16
      The program will prepare states and local transportation agencies to adopt and deploy these technologies in their systems.
    • 02:20:28
      The panel member or the paying members of the field as you see there, we are VDOT and we are also lead agency which gives us administrative and technical requirements that we have to meet.
    • 02:20:40
      We run the program basically.
    • 02:20:43
      We have 10 member states, Virginia, California, Florida, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Texas, Washington.
    • 02:20:49
      Maricopa County DOT, and I didn't do my homework.
    • 02:20:53
      I'm not sure where Maricopa County is, I'm sorry to say.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:20:57
      Sir?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:20:58
      Oh, thank you.
    • 02:21:00
      And also with Federal Highway.
    • 02:21:02
      We have some nonpaying partners and some additional members who are interested in this.
    • 02:21:08
      We've completed three projects.
    • 02:21:11
      Basically, the first project was looking at the potential applications for having the signalized systems connecting with the vehicles and communicating back and forth.
    • 02:21:22
      That was the first project.
    • 02:21:24
      The second project was looking at data coming back from these vehicles to evaluate the pavement system by looking at rideability.
    • 02:21:33
      Something that we do all the time, so there's information back to help manage our pavement systems.
    • 02:21:41
      There's a third project completed that is looking at developing the algorithms necessary for our traffic control systems to communicate or to take data from the vehicles and operate the systems.
    • 02:21:53
      In other words, have a system whereby the vehicle can tell you that the intersection is red, it doesn't need to be red, march on.
    • 02:22:02
      The following projects will be completed in the next 12 months and this is where we're getting to deployment.
    • 02:22:08
      There are two, these two projects really address for the state and the localities.
    • 02:22:14
      The specifications, the certifications, what's necessary for them to be able to procure both software and hardware which is very important because there are only 10 states participating but there are going to be certainly significantly more states, more localities who will jump on this when they see the applications.
    • 02:22:32
      So this first project is going to look at how they can get certification leading to specifications so they can get the hardware and the software on board.
    • 02:22:42
      The second is something that Krishna talked about this.
    • 02:22:45
      He and I are in agreement.
    • 02:22:46
      We drive a car until it's about dead, and neither one of us have any equipment on our vehicle right now to be able to communicate.
    • 02:22:53
      This project's looking at what's called aftermarket connected vehicles and the equipment that would be necessary for the vehicles that we own to be able to communicate, to get on this connected vehicle program.
    • 02:23:07
      And then from that,
    • 02:23:09
      We are going to look at and develop specifications for those pieces of equipment.
    • 02:23:17
      Now, the matter at hand, we are asking VDOT has negotiated with the USDOT Research and
    • 02:23:25
      Technology Administration, RETA, to receive up to $2 million in USDOT research funds to enhance this pooled fund study.
    • 02:23:37
      Basically, they're looking at ultimately deployment, which I'll get to in a second, but this initial project is going to tie everything together in a simulation scenario.
    • 02:23:48
      It's going to tie the vehicles to the traffic systems.
    • 02:23:51
      et cetera.
    • 02:23:52
      And that project through this grant will provide that research.
    • 02:23:59
      And here's where we're going with this and I think it's a very interesting process.
    • 02:24:05
      USDOT is going to be soliciting for an agency to take the lead on actual deploying these technologies in the field.
    • 02:24:16
      We're putting together in this pooled fund
    • 02:24:19
      various pieces of this to occur.
    • 02:24:23
      We've been working with operations here in central office, working with traffic engineering.
    • 02:24:31
      We've been working with Virginia Tech, VTTI, and the University of Virginia to position ourselves to be able to respond to the RFP
    • 02:24:40
      for deployment when that hits the street.
    • 02:24:42
      And so we feel like we're in a good position being a part of this, being the lead state on this pool to find study to get this deployment possible.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:52
      So that's, in a nutshell, I'm... Dr. Gomez, the reason why that you're doing this presentation is, at the regular meeting, what's going to happen?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:25:04
      Sir, I'm sorry, repeat that question.
    • 02:25:06
      As an update to inform you all, the memorandum of agreement that we thought we needed to seek, actually the Commission has that authority in place.
    • 02:25:19
      October of 2007, the Board gave the Commissioner that authority to enter into any memorandum of agreement that involved research with various and all entities.
    • 02:25:30
      So the Board action was to give the Commission that authority
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:36
      Dr. Robert Jones Jr., Dr. Robert Jones Jr., Dr. Robert Jones Jr.,
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:52
      So you threw me off, so you lied to me during my update.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:25:56
      Is that true, Dr. Gomez?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:57
      No, sir, that is true.
    • 02:26:00
      Oh, it's those lawyers.
    • 02:26:02
      Just blame it on the lawyers.
    • 02:26:03
      The lawyers look better.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:26:04
      A lot of this wrong work, sir.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:06
      All right, Dr. Gomez, I just want to make sure.
    • 02:26:08
      So this is like really cool cutting edge stuff, right?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:26:12
      It is cutting edge.
    • 02:26:13
      It's putting the vehicles out there.
    • 02:26:15
      What it's going to do, sir, is it's going to put
    • 02:26:18
      It's going to reduce congestion by better traffic management.
    • 02:26:23
      We've got the vehicles connected to our operating system, operation centers.
    • 02:26:28
      It's going to make the roads safer.
    • 02:26:30
      If there is an incident, it will
    • 02:26:32
      We'll be able to alert the drivers.
    • 02:26:33
      They will have real time data, real travel time data to make a decision.
    • 02:26:37
      You know, take this next exit, do this, do that in real time.
    • 02:26:41
      It's all based on the fact that we have wireless technology everywhere we go and that communication option.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:49
      Okay, and why was Virginia selected to be the lead on this?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:26:53
      Virginia was selected to be the lead because we have the reputation to implement.
    • 02:27:01
      Honestly, and the fact that we work with, it wasn't any, it wasn't research, it was research with operations working together.
    • 02:27:10
      as we always do to bring this.
    • 02:27:13
      And that's why Virginia is the league.
    • 02:27:15
      They know we can get it done.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:18
      Any other questions?
    • 02:27:19
      Yes.
    • 02:27:20
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:27:21
      I mean, this to me is the most important thing of the morning for me.
    • 02:27:27
      It shows that what we're doing is moving to use the technologies, the systems development, the operational knowledge that VDOT has, but also
    • 02:27:36
      The tools that really are distinguishing Virginia from other states.
    • 02:27:40
      I mean, we have this industry potentially located here, and there's really no reason that this can't be a major economic development initiative.
    • 02:27:49
      Smart facilities, much better operations, complex systems management and development.
    • 02:27:55
      I mean, these are things that our tech companies do.
    • 02:27:58
      So I see this as a major step forward, and it's
    • 02:28:03
      It's a major focus for you, I know, and I'd like to see it continue to go forward as quickly as we can make it go forward.
    • 02:28:11
      We have other resources you'll be able to draw from as you get more sophisticated.
    • 02:28:15
      The Modeling and Simulation Center in Hampton Roads is a perfect example of another partner for you, and so I just want to applaud your initiative, but also the way that we've kept this going.
    • 02:28:26
      This was a good set of board direction here.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:28:32
      I got on board after this, so I'd love to take the credit, but there are a whole lot of folks, two of which are sitting here, who really got this going, really got this going.
    • 02:28:40
      And I agree.
    • 02:28:42
      The thing that I also, we're right in the backyard.
    • 02:28:45
      Probably people that work at Rita, the research division, live in Virginia.
    • 02:28:50
      You know, location is everything.
    • 02:28:51
      We can, you know, the big piece of this, the implementation piece down the line.
    • 02:28:56
      I really feel like we're in a great position to really do something there to get that going and that will play well.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:29:08
      Are there any additional members that may be coming on board as the program progresses, such as the automobile manufacturers or like modeling and simulation?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:29:18
      They are on board the Dynamic Mobility Program funded by Rita through USDT.
    • 02:29:27
      Their initial focus was getting the automobile industry connected, getting those technologies in the industry.
    • 02:29:33
      The pooled fund study came about because
    • 02:29:36
      The various DOTs said, wait a minute, we need to make sure that not only are their vehicles connected, they're connected to us and we're connected to them.
    • 02:29:43
      And so there is that initiative in place, that's been in place.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:49
      Other questions?
    • 02:29:50
      Just one quick one, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:29:52
      What is the degree of interaction with UVA?
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:29:56
      We've been located on the grounds of the university, not the campus, the grounds of the university in Virginia.
    • 02:30:04
      We've been there since 1948.
    • 02:30:07
      We have faculty who come work with us, GR graduate research assistants, undergraduates.
    • 02:30:16
      Many of us go down the hill and teach a class.
    • 02:30:18
      So there's a strong, very strong connection there that's been since 1948.
    • 02:30:23
      We've reached out and have equally a strong connection with Virginia Tech.
    • 02:30:29
      It's just harder to get there.
    • 02:30:32
      They would love to have the opportunity to do the same kind of things.
    • 02:30:35
      And we do share resources.
    • 02:30:36
      We've had their faculty come and take sabbaticals here at the research division.
    • 02:30:42
      And so we are well connected to both.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:46
      You know, I would just put a plug out.
    • 02:30:48
      I had the opportunity to go out to George Washington's campus out there in Loudon, and they're doing some great research as well, transportation.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:30:57
      We partnered with them a few years back.
    • 02:30:58
      We didn't get the funding, didn't get the project, but we've worked with them.
    • 02:31:02
      They have some very good, particularly structures, folks.
    • 02:31:04
      Yes, sir?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:05
      and of course The University of George Mason University.
    • 02:31:09
      It's the new The University.
    • 02:31:13
      Any other questions?
    • 02:31:14
      Dr. Gomez, thank you very much.
    • 02:31:15
      Congratulations.
    • 02:31:17
      Just while we take a break, grab lunch.
    • 02:31:19
      We'll start back up at the... Are we ready?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:31:23
      Can I ask everyone to please take your seats?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:27
      That includes the Richmond Times dispatch, Mr. Peake.
    • 02:31:38
      These reporters, I mean, they come in here.
    • 02:31:45
      We now have I-73.
    • 02:31:46
      Mr. Collins.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:31:52
      Chairman, members of the board, you're with me while I stand up.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:58
      Thank you all.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:32:03
      I'm here today to give you a presentation related to Interstate 73, more specifically a portion of Interstate 73 located in Henry County and some analysis that the departments performed.
    • 02:32:19
      All right, back in December of 2009, the Commonwealth Transportation Board asked the department to perform a number of studies related to a change in the approved location of Interstate 73, commonly referred to as the Henry County Alternative or HCA.
    • 02:32:34
      And that resolution is in your packet for those of you who are interested in reading what the specifics are.
    • 02:32:38
      But the short version of that is I-73 had been approved for a number of years, and there was a desire to look at a shift in the alignment
    • 02:32:48
      In Henry County, it's approximately 20 miles long, and to seek the approvals that would be necessary to advance that change.
    • 02:32:55
      The department's done that, and that's why we're here today.
    • 02:32:58
      The form that study took was an environmental assessment.
    • 02:33:00
      It was prepared pursuant to NEPA in cooperation with the Federal Highway Administration, and that marries up well with the status of the approvals we had already received for the project.
    • 02:33:10
      So today's presentation will include a summary of the environmental impacts.
    • 02:33:13
      It'll also include a summary of the public input that we received through that process.
    • 02:33:19
      A little bit of project history for you and in the interest of saving some time, this project has a very long history dating back to 1991 when it showed up in I.C.E.T.
    • 02:33:27
      Some of that history is also included in your packet and a presentation that we gave previously.
    • 02:33:32
      My history for today picks up in 2006 at the point at which we received Federal Highway Administration approval of the original EIS.
    • 02:33:39
      In March of 2007, the Federal Highway Administration issued a record of decision completing the NEPA process and granting us our federal location approval.
    • 02:33:48
      Not long after that, we were the subject of a lawsuit filed in October of 2007.
    • 02:33:54
      About six months later, eight months later, we received a request from Henry County to evaluate an alternative alignment in Henry County.
    • 02:34:03
      And please understand, that's not the entire I-73, that's just the portion in Henry County.
    • 02:34:08
      You can see the rest of the dates on here.
    • 02:34:09
      The federal case was heard and we received a favorable ruling in August of 2009.
    • 02:34:15
      October of 2009, an appeal was filed.
    • 02:34:18
      It's kind of two paths you can see progressing here, the lawsuit and at the same time some additional information on the Henry County Alternative.
    • 02:34:25
      The department provided a report to the Commonwealth Transportation Board in November of 2009 on the Henry County Alternative.
    • 02:34:32
      And that brings us back to where we started, December of 2009, when the board directed the department to conduct the necessary analysis of the HCA.
    • 02:34:39
      And that's what we've done.
    • 02:34:40
      After we were directed to do that, we settled the appeal with the plaintiffs and the lawsuit was closed.
    • 02:34:46
      February 2011 brings us to this year when we received the approval from the Federal Highway Administration for a draft environmental assessment.
    • 02:34:53
      That approval granted us the ability to go to the public, make the document available, and solicit comments, which we did in March 2011 at a public hearing.
    • 02:35:04
      Mr. Chairman, with your permission, I would like to have Angel Deem come forward.
    • 02:35:07
      She managed the study for us, and she'll present the technical aspects of the study.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 02:35:16
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:35:18
      Mr. Chairman, board members, what you have in front of you is the graphic, which shows the Henry County portion of I-73.
    • 02:35:27
      So the gray line to the right is the approved location for I-73.
    • 02:35:33
      We refer to that as the ALC.
    • 02:35:35
      You'll see that throughout the presentation.
    • 02:35:37
      The line in red is the Henry County alternative, and that's what the subject of the EA is that we studied.
    • 02:35:46
      If I could summarize the purpose and need for the Henry County Alternative, the study that we just are in the process of completing.
    • 02:35:53
      It is to improve access to existing and developing industrial areas in the county and to enhance economic development in Martinsville and Henry County.
    • 02:36:06
      Now I want to zoom you in a little closer.
    • 02:36:08
      This is a portion of the corridor just in the middle around Fisher Farm Park.
    • 02:36:13
      and the reason I'm doing this is for the next slide.
    • 02:36:16
      The Henry County alternative shown here in blue was drawn specifically to avoid the park completely and so that's the line in blue.
    • 02:36:24
      As we embarked on the study, we looked at that and in concert with FHWA, we decided to investigate a shift in the alignment through the park because while the HCA originally avoided the park, that alignment incurred two railroad bridges
    • 02:36:40
      and also some additional displacement shown in yellow there.
    • 02:36:44
      So we thought it was a good idea to investigate looking at the park alignment.
    • 02:36:50
      This is the western portion of the park which is wooded and we in concert with FHWA felt that this shift through the park would not impact the features, activities or attributes that protect the park under Section 4F.
    • 02:37:05
      The technical term for this is a de minimis 4F impact.
    • 02:37:09
      We're investigating that and did so through the document.
    • 02:37:14
      So I pointed that out because of this slide.
    • 02:37:16
      You'll see that the impacts are presented here and the Federal Highway Administration asked us to separate out that modification to the alignment so it was clear what the impact to the park would be and so the public and others could provide input in that regard.
    • 02:37:33
      So here we have a list of the categories of impacts that we looked at.
    • 02:37:38
      This is in no way everything that we investigated.
    • 02:37:41
      Most of the categories that aren't on this slide are those that were zero all the way across.
    • 02:37:48
      So here we just have a comparison for you of the HCA versus the approved location corridor.
    • 02:37:54
      The numbers for the ALC were taken directly from the FEIS.
    • 02:38:03
      As part of NEPA, we had a public comment period which extended from February 26th to April 8th with the public hearing being held March 29th.
    • 02:38:13
      We had 120 persons in attendance.
    • 02:38:16
      Throughout that comment period, we received approximately 98 comments and those came in the forms of letters, emails, and input on the public hearing comment sheet.
    • 02:38:26
      One of the questions we posed on that comment sheet was, what is your opinion of the HCA?
    • 02:38:31
      So we were able to tabulate those responses and you see the numbers there and of course there were others that didn't fall neatly into one category or the other.
    • 02:38:40
      In addition to that, we have some other input that came as part of that public outreach, some being from the federal agency.
    • 02:38:52
      The three federal agencies that commented on the document are listed here and we've just summarized their input.
    • 02:38:58
      The Environmental Protection Agency felt that the HCA had significant impacts in regard to residential displacements and proximity to water resources.
    • 02:39:08
      The Fish and Wildlife Service asked for endangered species surveys.
    • 02:39:12
      However, we did not find endangered species as part of the study, but they've asked for some surveys.
    • 02:39:17
      They also asserted that a supplemental EIS should be prepared.
    • 02:39:21
      The Corps of Engineers expressed their concerns regarding public water supply, but they did indicate that that concern exists for both the ALC and the HCA.
    • 02:39:32
      And they reiterated their longstanding assertion that a Route 220 alternative should be investigated.
    • 02:39:41
      In addition to those agencies, we had input from many others, and we've given you a sampling of that here.
    • 02:39:48
      U.S. House Representative Griffiths supports the HCA, citing economic benefits.
    • 02:39:55
      The I-73 Committee, which is comprised of area businesses, supports the HCA.
    • 02:40:01
      The Mayor from the City of Martinsville,
    • 02:40:03
      stated support for the ALC citing environmental justice concerns and the proximity to the city's reservoir.
    • 02:40:12
      The city manager for the city of Danville stated support for the ALC.
    • 02:40:19
      The Danville-Pittsylvania County Chamber of Commerce stated support for the ALC and asked that the board reaffirm its support for the original alignment.
    • 02:40:28
      and Andrea Furster on behalf of Virginians for Appropriate Roads, Virginia Forest Watch and the Sierra Club sent in a letter stating there were significant impacts associated with the HCA and asserting that a supplemental EIS was required.
    • 02:40:42
      This individual was added here because she did represent the plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
    • 02:40:48
      And since completion of this presentation, actually just yesterday we received a letter from the Martinsville-Henry County Chamber of Commerce
    • 02:40:57
      So that didn't get included here, I apologize.
    • 02:40:59
      I'll just read you a statement from that letter.
    • 02:41:02
      It says, our concern is that the interstate be built utilizing the route that results in the most expeditious completion of this project.
    • 02:41:11
      Martinsville-Henry County's economy cannot risk any unnecessary delays in the construction of this vital infrastructure, or worse, the abandonment of the project in its entirety.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:22
      That's the input we received there.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:41:28
      So potential outcomes for you all today.
    • 02:41:30
      One would be to take no action on the Henry County alternative.
    • 02:41:35
      Then the ALC would remain the approved location for I-73 as it has been since 2007.
    • 02:41:42
      Another potential outcome would be to approve the HDA and thereby change the location decision for I-73.
    • 02:41:49
      And of course, federal approval would be needed in concert with this change.
    • 02:41:55
      And finally, some considerations for you all.
    • 02:41:58
      We met with FHWA at the close of the comment period to review all those comments that we just summarized for you.
    • 02:42:05
      And they have told us that before they will consider taking an action, if they need to do so as a result of this board's action, they would like us to complete the list you see there.
    • 02:42:16
      They would like to see us complete the two endangered species surveys that the Fish and Wildlife Service asked for.
    • 02:42:22
      They would like for us to look
    • 02:42:24
      into additional minimization, mitigation measures around the park, additional analysis at the interchanges, looking at cumulative impacts, and also commitment to enhance mitigation around the reservoir.
    • 02:42:38
      We estimate the cost there, 200, $250,000 for just the first three bullets, because of course the fourth one is a commitment that would be looked at and designed.
    • 02:42:49
      There's also the potential for additional litigation,
    • 02:42:54
      and also the potential for supplemental EIS.
    • 02:42:57
      We can't tell you today whether one will or will not be required.
    • 02:43:01
      We estimate the cost of that at approximately 2.2 million.
    • 02:43:05
      We don't know the scope of the supplemental EIS should we have to do one, but in general we would say perhaps a three-year time period to complete that study.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:16
      What is the Fisher Farm Park?
    • 02:43:21
      Is that a state park?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:43:22
      It's owned by the county, Henry County, yes sir.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:26
      And the route, the HCA route, would that go through the recreational portion of it?
    • 02:43:33
      No sir.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:43:35
      It's hard to see in the graphics there, but the reason we pursued looking at an alignment through the park is because this alignment would not impact the recreational area of the park that afforded protection under section 4F.
    • 02:43:48
      So in the upper portion of the park near
    • 02:43:51
      Marybone Creek, that's where the rec field resides.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:58
      The one element I'm not seeing here is the overall cost between the two alternatives.
    • 02:44:04
      I know that you're looking at the ALC versus CHCA, two new interchanges if you go to the HCA, those aren't cheap.
    • 02:44:12
      You've got a couple miles, but you've got about 63 additional homes displaced, that's not going to be cheap.
    • 02:44:18
      Do we know what the increased cost of the project would be?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:44:21
      So we discussed cost and whether we would include a cost analysis as part of this document and decided in concert with FHWA that we would not, that the cost would be neutral.
    • 02:44:33
      You do have the additional interchanges, but you also have discrepancies with displacements.
    • 02:44:40
      The cost that was developed for the EIS we would have to use as a comparator, and that was done some time ago.
    • 02:44:46
      So the cost wasn't deemed as necessary for making a decision.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:44:51
      It wasn't, I mean, from my standpoint, we've only got limited funds.
    • 02:44:56
      It's a pretty critical aspect here.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:44:58
      Our assessment is the cost would be virtually the same for either route.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:03
      Even with all these differences, because there is quite a bit of difference between what it does.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:45:07
      There are two additional interchanges on the HCA, but it also utilizes a portion of the existing Route 58 bypass, so you have some offset there.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:19
      Any other questions?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:45:35
      We're asking you to look at the Henry County alternative in its entirety.
    • 02:45:39
      The board has the choice of if you want to support the Henry County alternative, you can be specific in this area or not.
    • 02:45:47
      We can't guarantee you that we'll secure the approvals to go through the park.
    • 02:45:51
      We also can't guarantee, on the other hand, that we'll secure approvals to impact those homes.
    • 02:45:56
      The homes to the left, or to the west, excuse me, of the railroad.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:46:00
      Both of those are differences of changes, and then we'd have to pick a change to HPA alternative, and then we'd have to pick either of those to correct.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:46:09
      Not necessary.
    • 02:46:12
      Because we haven't gotten through the process with the agencies to know if we can secure approvals through the park or through the mobile home community that's to the west of the railroad.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:46:22
      And then how did this proposal come about, who's pushing it, the Henry County alternative?
    • 02:46:29
      What is the reason for the alternative?
    • 02:46:33
      I wasn't here when it started.
    • 02:46:34
      Okay.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:46:36
      Would you like to speak to that?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:41
      It's germinated with citizens, poor business owners and citizens in Henry County.
    • 02:46:54
      Back, I suppose, before my tenure on the board began, or at least very close to that time.
    • 02:47:03
      And it's found that in their opinion and analysis that it actually began with the thought of
    • 02:47:16
      Why build when you already have interstate grade railroad existing in the back half?
    • 02:47:22
      But apparently quickly the emphasis became the economic impact, future economic impact.
    • 02:47:31
      And to be more precise, the alternative route
    • 02:47:35
      provides for exits at two important centers, one being the Patriarch Center Industrial Area and the other being Martinsville Speedway.
    • 02:47:45
      And I have mentioned before the value there.
    • 02:47:49
      Now, the Martinsville Speedway
    • 02:47:51
      I cannot say how much of an impact this property had, but it did get its second date secured for the next five years.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:48:00
      That's how I remember it.
    • 02:48:01
      It gives you access to the industrial park, which is something that's new, and the speedway to help the tourists.
    • 02:48:07
      Is that correct?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:08
      Yes, and indeed, it became revenue neutral as opposed to positive because of the interchanges.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:19
      Just a question.
    • 02:48:20
      I mean, this resolution was done in 2009.
    • 02:48:24
      Didn't that speedway exist before then?
    • 02:48:28
      I mean, and didn't the industrial park exist before then?
    • 02:48:33
      I mean, why wasn't that planned in when we looked at the route to begin with as opposed to going back now and going through this to incur the extra funds to change this route when both of those existed when this road was being contemplated?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:47
      Now that I cannot answer because the HCA preceded my tenure on the board, so that I don't know, I told you pretty much all that I do know of the foundation for them asking.
    • 02:49:06
      And I'll concede to you that in much the same thought pattern that you just expressed orally,
    • 02:49:13
      When I was first approached about bringing this to the board, that was like the first or second question in your mind.
    • 02:49:21
      Over time, the amount of consideration and the analysis that's gone into this has actually set that aside, in my mind anyway.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:32
      And the only other question I have on that is, since it wasn't planned for at that time,
    • 02:49:37
      I assume that they, as it mentions, it has at least two interchanges, one for each one planned into the original route.
    • 02:49:46
      Is that correct?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:49
      I'm sorry.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:50
      Wasn't there an interchange or an entrance or whatever on the original route for each one of those industrial parts?
    • 02:49:59
      No.
    • 02:49:59
      How far is it that it doesn't show it on the map?
    • 02:50:02
      How far is the speedway
    • 02:50:04
      and the Industrial Park off the original proposed route.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:11
      It can't be too far off because those things essentially spread the difference, the existing existence of the interchange that is the improvement, not the geographical location to it.
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:26
      The point is, I mean, instead of going back through and going through all this, maybe there's farther along than what I'm aware of and so it's not a big deal,
    • 02:50:34
      It seems as though you could almost look at getting access to those two areas off the original road at less cost with maybe less disruption of people, houses, and everything else than to try to reroute the whole road to do that.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:51
      And I'm not going to assume professional expertise that I don't have.
    • 02:50:57
      I will say that the proposed alternative did get good support in determining, well, the staff here or the staff in Salem District did have input into that sort of consideration.
    • 02:51:19
      but I don't want to by any means suggest that this is the staff's plan or suggestion but the HCA, I'm sorry, the HCA group did get the input from professionals in Salem District about that sort of issue.
    • 02:51:38
      Mr. Chairman.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:51:40
      Mr. Miller.
    • 02:51:44
      The suit that was brought originally that now has been resolved or at least temporarily resolved, who brought that suit and what was sort of the basis, what was that suit all about?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:51:56
      The suit there was essentially a NEPA suit turned on the National Environmental Policy Act and some of the more visible or prominent issues were selection of alternatives and principally looking at a different alternative than the one the board selected and looking at a broader range of alternatives.
    • 02:52:11
      That issue is close.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:13
      Based on environmental... That's correct.
    • 02:52:15
      Exactly.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:52:16
      The opportunity to bring the suit came under NEPA and the APA.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:20
      Would we expect that if we selected an alternative that that would be environmentally okay with the same sort of groups that were concerned about the ALC or the
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:52:35
      Well, so that's a prediction I'm not willing to make, but I'll give you a little background.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:40
      I mean, it's sort of like, the only people that are going to win in this whole damn thing are the lawyers.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:52:45
      Yes, what happened in that?
    • 02:52:48
      The issue there in the... Go get litigated one way or the other.
    • 02:52:52
      And I think that's the distinct possibility, to answer your question directly.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:55
      Well, let me ask you another question.
    • 02:52:58
      It's sort of, as I look at the group of folks that are sort of lined up on one side or the other,
    • 02:53:05
      I think the Chamber of Commerce in, was it the fiscal, no, it was the Markville Chamber of Commerce said, we just don't want a delay, which I presume translates into using the one that's already in the plan.
    • 02:53:19
      I mean, that's the only way I can interpret that.
    • 02:53:23
      I don't think it makes any sense for them to say, I don't want a delay, meaning, let's go find a new route.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:29
      I mean, that doesn't follow.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:31
      The mayor of Martinsville wants the old route.
    • 02:53:35
      The city manager of Danville wants the old route, which means, I would imagine, that the council wants the old route and the board of supervisors.
    • 02:53:46
      Or I guess it's the council.
    • 02:53:47
      Because the city manager isn't going to write a letter without the council's support.
    • 02:53:52
      The Chamber of Commerce for
    • 02:53:58
      Danville-Pittsylvania County also wants the old route, and yet sort of the rationale that I heard, which is why we looked at the alternative, was for economic development.
    • 02:54:12
      That's what I heard in the very beginning.
    • 02:54:14
      It was economic development issues.
    • 02:54:17
      So I'm saying, well, wait a minute.
    • 02:54:19
      Both chambers want the other route.
    • 02:54:21
      The mayor wants the other route.
    • 02:54:23
      The Council of Danville wants the other route.
    • 02:54:26
      They're all about economic development, certainly the two chambers are.
    • 02:54:30
      So what am I missing here?
    • 02:54:34
      We've got Morgan Griffith and the committee, the committee which is by definition biased because they were formed to advocate for the other route.
    • 02:54:42
      So I don't know who's on that committee or what they really represent.
    • 02:54:47
      And by the way, this is in the corridor of statewide significance, so we can... Not yet.
    • 02:54:55
      Not yet.
    • 02:54:56
      2011.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:58
      You can add it to the resolution later on.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:01
      Mr. Terry, would you like some illumination?
    • 02:55:05
      Please.
    • 02:55:05
      Please, Mr. Martin.
    • 02:55:07
      Mr. Miller, diplomatically,
    • 02:55:15
      The presentation tells you that the city manager of Danville prefers the old route.
    • 02:55:23
      You have to infer what you stated.
    • 02:55:26
      The fact of the matter is the documentation shows that the mayor of Danville, or city manager of Danville, included a resolution from 1997.
    • 02:55:39
      What we do not have access to in any official documentation
    • 02:55:45
      is the fact, this is not anecdotal, but it is a true matter that the chamber, both chambers actually declined to take a stand opposing the HCA.
    • 02:56:01
      The City Council on Martinsville, well I'm not going to say for sure, for my knowledge,
    • 02:56:08
      The mayor in Martinsville is speaking as an individual but it is entirely possible that the council made me on record.
    • 02:56:18
      Danville and the Board of Supervisors did not, deliberately or consciously did not oppose the Henry County alternative.
    • 02:56:31
      One of the things that is,
    • 02:56:35
      Those people who are distant, the difference, you know, that makes it like walking distance closer to Danville, of Pennsylvania County anyway.
    • 02:56:49
      Now, what reasons they would have for opposing, I cannot speculate about.
    • 02:56:55
      Well, Tom, thank you.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:58
      I guess my point, and I'll let somebody else
    • 02:57:02
      I would try to make a decision, one, based on what makes sense from a transportation planning thing first.
    • 02:57:14
      What's going to serve the area best in terms of congestion, in terms of people getting
    • 02:57:18
      In terms of economic development, all the criteria that we put in transportation.
    • 02:57:22
      Number two, what's the cost?
    • 02:57:25
      Which we're saying is neutral.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:57:28
      It's the same cost, that's what Jim suggested to us.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:32
      And then three, obviously, what do the localities think about it?
    • 02:57:36
      And I have no clue what the localities are thinking about it.
    • 02:57:42
      given the presentation and given sort of your additional information.
    • 02:57:49
      So, there's a huge difference between not opposing something and being in favor of it politically.
    • 02:58:03
      Any other questions?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:58:13
      My recollection is when we took this up in 2009, it had to do with the inductive park.
    • 02:58:32
      and that the county wasn't ready to develop them when the first one went through the industrial park.
    • 02:58:37
      They had found the funds or were able to do so and also the speedway was negatively impacted and that's what I think what my recollection was that caused this to be considered after that.
    • 02:58:53
      So I think it was economic.
    • 02:58:55
      development that caused them to ask for this.
    • 02:58:59
      That's my recollection.
    • 02:59:00
      I think she made something about it.
    • 02:59:02
      Pretty humble.
    • 02:59:03
      That's what they, when they presented it to us, that's what they said.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:06
      That's quite accurate.
    • 02:59:08
      Mr. Secretary.
    • 02:59:11
      Yes, Mr. Martin.
    • 02:59:12
      And people, I'll just tell you, I hate
    • 02:59:15
      I'm choosing to think like a lawyer.
    • 02:59:17
      My first wife was a lawyer.
    • 02:59:19
      That's a personal problem.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:59:22
      I hear this all the time.
    • 02:59:23
      A lawyer has done a lot of good for this country and wrote the Declaration of Independence and our Constitution and things like that.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:34
      I want to add more nuances to the presentations we've heard and in no way integrate the information you have in front of you to my best of luck.
    • 02:59:48
      I can tell everything in there is true.
    • 02:59:50
      And accurate, and it's like the things I pointed out before, the second, well, the endangered species had not shown up as an item.
    • 03:00:00
      If I understand correctly, one of them is a log perch fish.
    • 03:00:04
      Is that the name of that thing?
    • 03:00:05
      That's correct.
    • 03:00:06
      It's a log perch.
    • 03:00:08
      And the other is a flower, which we're not yet sure is in the alternative corridor, but bottom line is
    • 03:00:18
      Those are not new issues.
    • 03:00:19
      They're not, those are universal issues.
    • 03:00:22
      They're not simply a part of the HCA.
    • 03:00:25
      The HCA simply means we have to verify for sure that we're not affecting law approach again.
    • 03:00:32
      Two miles away, well not even two miles.
    • 03:00:35
      The environmental issues are universal.
    • 03:00:38
      There, to me anyway, and I'm trying not to be biased, is perhaps a conspicuous absence of general public opposition.
    • 03:00:47
      I'm close to the situation.
    • 03:00:49
      I don't know how large guys get to look at everything globally.
    • 03:00:53
      District people have to hear and go to public hearings and see.
    • 03:00:59
      And the general public wants the thing built.
    • 03:01:04
      Realistically, if I felt
    • 03:01:07
      If the committee felt, those people who were promoting it in the past with yours, that it felt it was going to jeopardize or cause an untenable delay on the highway, they wouldn't push it.
    • 03:01:19
      I would back off.
    • 03:01:21
      If we get to a point where there is money and
    • 03:01:25
      This request has become the reason that we're not being able to use the money.
    • 03:01:30
      That becomes a whole different issue.
    • 03:01:33
      Where I see it now is an opportunity to do what the people who have to deal with it have determined is best for them.
    • 03:01:41
      For example, the presentation does not and should not go into long-term view on certain economic impacts.
    • 03:01:50
      The Henry County alternative
    • 03:01:52
      takes the road around where existing water and sewer is today.
    • 03:01:57
      The ALC takes it to where future development would require putting in water and sewer.
    • 03:02:06
      Well, which one indeed is going to lead you to more economic development in the near term or any term?
    • 03:02:14
      In reading, we see that we have
    • 03:02:18
      Two favorable comments versus seven added on.
    • 03:02:23
      We had 54 favorable versus 22 at the public hearing itself.
    • 03:02:29
      And indeed, six of those seven that are opposed added on are from outside the area.
    • 03:02:41
      Now, opponents,
    • 03:02:42
      are going to oppose regardless.
    • 03:02:46
      I don't know who.
    • 03:02:47
      If they can find a way to oppose, they are going to do it.
    • 03:02:51
      My position is make them oppose doing the best thing for the people.
    • 03:02:56
      Make them oppose us doing what makes the most sense economically for the states and the citizens who are involved at the point where we are right now.
    • 03:03:07
      The only money available for I-73 is airmarked for I-73.
    • 03:03:12
      It can't be spent on anything else.
    • 03:03:16
      I'm not trying to make a fool out of you if we spend it on the alternative.
    • 03:03:21
      We won't have it to spend for something else later.
    • 03:03:23
      However, the amount that we do have is not going to make that much difference later.
    • 03:03:28
      So we can make some progress at this point if we have the funding to do it.
    • 03:03:34
      And next month,
    • 03:03:36
      I don't know if you'll hear from anybody else, but I will still be advocating that we take the Henry County alternative and ask
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:45
      I'm having a hard time reconciling your map of the details on page six with that map and wondering where this fits into that and where the speedway and where the industrial park are.
    • 03:04:09
      Can you come around and even point?
    • 03:04:11
      Anything would be helpful.
    • 03:04:15
      Well, you know, your detailed map, I don't know where this is on that map, and I don't know where those two facilities are on that map.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:04:25
      What's the best way to point to the park on this map?
    • 03:04:28
      There's a pointer on the screen now.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 03:04:35
      Fisher Farm Park is in this area.
    • 03:04:40
      Just about in the middle.
    • 03:04:41
      The environmental assessment, the document has certainly more graphics available on VDOT's website.
    • 03:04:49
      It shows you proximity to the industrial parks and the speedway, et cetera.
    • 03:04:53
      We just didn't include an additional map here.
    • 03:05:00
      There is an industrial park.
    • 03:05:02
      I can find my pointer.
    • 03:05:04
      Up in this area, you see that's where one of the additional interchanges is, the speedway.
    • 03:05:10
      Down here where there's an additional interchange proposed.
    • 03:05:16
      Fisher Farm Park is approximately in the middle.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:18
      My third question, Mr. Chairman, was what you said the suit by the Sierra Club and others was settled but you didn't tell us how.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:05:47
      First, the Department prevailed, the Department of FHWA prevailed, and an appeal was filed.
    • 03:05:53
      And the appeal was settled with a settlement agreement.
    • 03:05:56
      And the settlement agreement indicated that if a supplemental EIS, the short version, and I can get you a copy if you want to actually read the settlement.
    • 03:06:02
      The short version is if a supplemental EIS is required, the plaintiffs can raise their issues again.
    • 03:06:08
      If a supplemental EIS is required in the future, another EIS, that the plaintiffs could raise their issues again.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:15
      if a supplemental EIS, and why would a supplemental EIS be required?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:06:21
      There are a number of reasons.
    • 03:06:22
      There are almost limitless number of reasons, but this approving, the board approving this alignment and asking the department to seek a federal approval from FHWA may result in a supplemental EIS.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:32
      And that would result in delight.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:06:34
      It certainly would, a supplemental EIS would certainly result in delight, certainly.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:06:38
      Thank you.
    • 03:06:39
      Mr. Chairman.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:40
      Dr. Davis.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:41
      I'll try to be fair.
    • 03:06:43
      and was what I remember as this came forward.
    • 03:06:47
      I-73 is one of those projects that there's enthusiasm for in certain quarters and no enthusiasm in others and no funding currently.
    • 03:06:58
      But when this came before us, there was a huge sympathy for the city of Martinsville and Henry County because it suffered one of the worst dislocations in the industry and business of any place in the Commonwealth probably in the last several years.
    • 03:07:12
      And as a result, I think all of us felt strongly that we wanted to do what we could to best help Henry County and Martinsville.
    • 03:07:20
      And as we listened to this, we were all saying, there's no money for this project in the foreseeable future, in a list of priorities that falls way down the list.
    • 03:07:30
      But if anything can be done to help Henry County and Martinsville, and they really wanna do this, move it closer to the racetrack and closer to an industrial development park, and the cost is not gonna be that much more, why not do it?
    • 03:07:43
      And I think that was the vote that was taken pretty much within the CTB to say, all right, let's see if it's going to cost a lot more money or not, or if it's going to be opposed.
    • 03:07:52
      If it is, just like the Henry County Board of Supervisors.
    • 03:07:55
      Nobody wants to see this, the possibility of this delayed any more than necessary, and yet you'd like to do it the way that would best benefit the community if you possibly can.
    • 03:08:05
      I hope that's a quick summary of how we got where we are.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:09
      Okay, yes, Mr. Bowie.
    • 03:08:13
      I'm sorry, I just gotta make sure.
    • 03:08:15
      There's no money at all.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:08:17
      No sir, there is some money left on the project.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:19
      No, but I mean like money to like build, I mean... No money to build.
    • 03:08:22
      In case I ever want to go to Detroit...
    • 03:08:23
      Not that I'm having any planning on doing a vacation there, but there's no money at all to build this, and none in the foreseeable future.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:08:32
      The allocations we have now aren't sufficient to perform the design work, let alone build it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:37
      Okay.
    • 03:08:38
      The design work, how much money do we have on it?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:08:40
      Actually, it's in my folder.
    • 03:08:42
      See if it's sitting up here.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:43
      Just a round number.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:44
      I'll get it for you.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:08:50
      Let's see here.
    • 03:08:52
      Where's my sheet of paper with that number on it?
    • 03:08:56
      Funds remain for I-73, $3.9 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:59
      $2.9 million to... $3.9, sir.
    • 03:09:02
      What's that?
    • 03:09:02
      $3.9.
    • 03:09:02
      $3.9 million to do preliminary engineering.
    • 03:09:08
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:09:09
      Yes.
    • 03:09:09
      Okay.
    • 03:09:11
      We'll burn through that in how long?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:09:13
      If we were required to prepare a supplemental EIS, we would use potentially all of that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:19
      Mr. Bowie.
    • 03:09:20
      Mr. Bowie.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:09:23
      Is that just one of the UPCs?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:09:25
      I think it's more, I think for around 12 million.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:09:28
      That's great.
    • 03:09:29
      That's one UPC.
    • 03:09:29
      That's the UPC we'd use for the study.
    • 03:09:31
      12 million.
    • 03:09:32
      That's great.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:32
      Just to kind of put it in comparison, we're doing just the engineering on the route 7 wide
    • 03:09:39
      up in Fairfax and Loudon, and the engineering on that is costing $40 million.
    • 03:09:46
      Okay, so, Mr. Bowie, and we just, I just want to move this on.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:54
      I'll just add to what Dr. Davis said.
    • 03:09:58
      He did summarize the consensus board at the time, but in addition, the speakers from Martin and Henry County and the rest of the board
    • 03:10:08
      talked about the ALC being a bypass, not coming close enough to Martinsville to provide economic development opportunities.
    • 03:10:20
      And when you look at that map,
    • 03:10:23
      and see the distance, it would make a difference being closer to it.
    • 03:10:29
      Access to Martinsville and from Martinsville would certainly be an economic development factor in favor of Martinsville trying to overcome the economic depression they've had.
    • 03:10:42
      And that was a strong point that they made, not wanting it to bypass Martinsville but provide access to Martinsville.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:51
      Outstanding.
    • 03:10:52
      Well, thank you very much.
    • 03:10:53
      Great presentation.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:10:55
      Yes, Mr. Peake.
    • 03:10:57
      Sorry.
    • 03:10:57
      In this packet that you put out, it's attached and it has one through ten.
    • 03:11:02
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:11:03
      And on page ten, there's agency recommendations.
    • 03:11:06
      Are those old agency recommendations?
    • 03:11:07
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:11:08
      They are.
    • 03:11:09
      Okay.
    • 03:11:09
      And is there any agency recommendation on the current?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 03:11:12
      The agency recommendation on the current?
    • 03:11:16
      From a purely technical standpoint, which is how we come at this, we're not making the change.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:25
      Mr. Martin, that's okay by you.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:27
      Did not make the change?
    • 03:11:29
      No, I would ask that we proceed with the Henry County alternative and ask for the change.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:40
      All right.
    • 03:11:40
      Well, that may have come to the board in some future.
    • 03:11:43
      I could look forward to this discussion at the next board meeting.
    • 03:11:46
      Thank you.
    • 03:11:47
      Revenue sharing.
    • 03:11:48
      Mr. Espies.
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:11:52
      Sir, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:55
      I'll try to jump right into this.
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:12:01
      Is it okay, Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:02
      Yes, please.
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:12:03
      And I won't spend a lot of time on the first two slides.
    • 03:12:06
      I'll simply say that they
    • 03:12:08
      should look familiar as we've discussed in the last couple of months.
    • 03:12:10
      So, pleasure to show reviews, the letter of intent that we did last fall with the second slide talking about the legislative changes out of the recent session.
    • 03:12:20
      And the one thing that we're going to spend a little bit of time on in a couple of slides would be under the priority tiers eliminated as a reminder
    • 03:12:27
      The priority by law, by the law that was changed this last session, the board has to get priority projects that accelerate projects through either the Six-Year Improvement Program or the Localities Capital Plan.
    • 03:12:38
      We'll talk about that again in a minute.
    • 03:12:40
      And as a reminder, the board did adopt guidelines for this program last month.
    • 03:12:44
      And we'll talk about a little bit how those work with the applications.
    • 03:12:48
      We worked very aggressively, our staff, with district staff and local governments to get the applications in, I guess I'd say in an expedited manner.
    • 03:12:57
      We called for applications back in March, came in in April.
    • 03:13:01
      We had 68 localities submit applications and go back to the letter of intent from last fall.
    • 03:13:07
      That's 68 compared to 62 that put in letters of intent.
    • 03:13:11
      So again, I think it was a good showing for the spring.
    • 03:13:15
      Total requests, a big number here, 131.5 million showing the popularity of the program.
    • 03:13:21
      I will say that if you look at the 50.4 million in requests up to 1 million for locality,
    • 03:13:27
      That was the parameters that we sent out in the letters of intent, and we received about 45.2 million in letters of intent, so you can kind of compare the numbers there pretty even with what we expected and what we shared with the board in previous months.
    • 03:13:41
      Just for your information, I won't spend a lot of time on here, but I always like to kind of show this by district to give you a feel for the participation.
    • 03:13:49
      But what I will show you is I like more of a visual approach, and hopefully you can kind of see this
    • 03:13:56
      It shows those 68 localities that put in applications, the geographic variety.
    • 03:14:01
      I guess I'd say this distribution around the state is quite good, I think, for this program.
    • 03:14:07
      And what the next slide would be is an overlay of that where you can see every locality.
    • 03:14:14
      There are 27 localities that requested the million dollars or more, and that's with those red dots that you're seeing right there.
    • 03:14:21
      The mayor is that geographic disbursement of the regular applications.
    • 03:14:25
      I think as Mr.
    • 03:14:26
      Keen and Mr. Bowie talk to this group, you can really see in Southwest the use of the coal money.
    • 03:14:31
      You can see even some of the Southside localities who are willing to put up local funds to match it with state dollars.
    • 03:14:40
      Now we're getting to the nuts and bolts of what I would like to talk to you about today.
    • 03:14:44
      What we did is, if I go back to the prioritization that's set in law and what we asked
    • 03:14:50
      The board to do last month was to look at those applications up to a million dollars first that accelerated projects in either a six-year plan or capital plan.
    • 03:15:00
      So you've got kind of a hierarchy now of prioritization.
    • 03:15:04
      So you've got the first priority that we're talking about is those that are less than a million, a local government that asks for less than a million, and the projects accelerate an existing project in a six-year plan or capital plan.
    • 03:15:14
      Then you go to those ones that are over a million, they accelerate an existing project
    • 03:15:18
      Then you have to go back to the ones under a million that aren't accelerating and those over a million that aren't accelerating.
    • 03:15:24
      The story on this slide basically is the majority of the 131.5 million is in those first two realms.
    • 03:15:31
      It's pretty hard to, and we work quite diligently with local governments.
    • 03:15:36
      When you're providing additional money to projects, it's pretty hard not to make the case you're accelerating the project.
    • 03:15:40
      And that's kind of the way we approach this in the majority of the way we looked at it.
    • 03:15:47
      What I want to do is talk about our proposal that we'd like to bring back to the board as part of the six-year plan and budget approval next month.
    • 03:15:55
      And I'd like to give credit to the commissioner and to the secretary for encouraging this and suggesting an approach kind of unique to this program.
    • 03:16:03
      As you know, in the past months we've talked about a $50 million budget for fiscal year 12 and fiscal year 13 for this program.
    • 03:16:10
      We've had a lot of discussion as to how or if we could up those allocations.
    • 03:16:17
      A suggestion was made that we try to look at lumping FY12 and FY13, that $100 million that was already budgeted, and see if we could take care of the lion's share of the request over a two fiscal year approach.
    • 03:16:30
      And the stats here in front of you tell you that we can do an awful lot with those two fiscal years with the request.
    • 03:16:38
      And what we can do with that is, if you look at the 68 local governments that requested money, we can fully fund
    • 03:16:45
      of the eligible projects, 57 of those 68 local governments requests, substantial percentage.
    • 03:16:53
      That represents about 167 out of the 188 projects requested.
    • 03:16:58
      So again, a huge amount of allocations for those projects.
    • 03:17:02
      That leaves seven localities that requested five million or more that would not see the full request.
    • 03:17:08
      I have to back up a little bit to explain how we got to the $105 million amount.
    • 03:17:13
      We did several analysis to try to figure out what could we get the most bang for our buck, look at those projects and localities that could benefit.
    • 03:17:20
      And we came up with a suggestion that if we could fund everyone up to five million, we're going to get the lion's share of the projects.
    • 03:17:28
      So the proposal in front of you is to fund everyone's requests that are eligible up to that five million per locality.
    • 03:17:33
      And what I'm showing is only seven localities out of the 68 requested more than five million.
    • 03:17:40
      And those seven localities are Chesterfield, Fairfax County, Harrisonburg, Prince William County, Spotsylvania County, Stafford County, and Virginia Beach.
    • 03:17:49
      And we've already begun outreach with those counties and cities to kind of get a feel for their reaction to that.
    • 03:17:55
      And quite frankly, I think the lion's share of them are going to say five million.
    • 03:17:59
      We're thrilled with that opportunity.
    • 03:18:02
      I do say the
    • 03:18:03
      Downside of not fully funding the entire 131.5 million requests.
    • 03:18:09
      There are some that aren't going to be eligible because they're not accelerating and couldn't document accelerating that.
    • 03:18:15
      And we've boiled that down to only four localities that aren't going to be eligible.
    • 03:18:19
      And I'm going to tell you those.
    • 03:18:22
      Alexandria, Manassas, Martinsville, and Washington County.
    • 03:18:25
      And our staff has extensively tried to reach out and continues to try to work through some of those issues.
    • 03:18:30
      But tentatively, those are the four localities.
    • 03:18:32
      out of the 68 that would not reap the benefit of the program.
    • 03:18:37
      So that's the facts gentlemen of the board and our proposal again for next month is to come to you and ask for a culmination or a combination of two fiscal years towards these applications.
    • 03:18:50
      And I think an important point to leave as we look at beyond that is next year's program.
    • 03:18:56
      We will be coming as we've been talking about the last few months much earlier to get a better feel for how much requests are out there.
    • 03:19:02
      So we can make these decisions early on the budget cycle.
    • 03:19:06
      By taking and utilizing $50 million FY13, the law does limit the total program at $200 million.
    • 03:19:14
      So we are going to be, in effect, limiting FY13 at the $150 million mark for what you can consider as a board.
    • 03:19:22
      Mr. Chairman, I'll turn it back to you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:24
      Again, this is just one way for us to try to, I mean, we changed the process so we can get obviously the, at least an idea about who's going to apply early so we can get in the Six-Year Plan.
    • 03:19:37
      Obviously, we want to give them the benefits, the local governments the benefits of the lower prices we're seeing now as well.
    • 03:19:44
      That's the part I wanted to get to.
    • 03:19:55
      The $50 million, that's 13 money.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:06
      I'm assuming that that money doesn't flow in 12, that that would sort of
    • 03:20:11
      That's not really a big deal because when you're talking about these projects, it's like the PE right away and construction that takes a couple of years.
    • 03:20:17
      Am I correct that the first 50 million roughly that we have this year is what would flow in 12, 50 million goes towards these projects, but guys you'll get that in 13 money?
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:20:29
      Excellent point.
    • 03:20:30
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Sterling, that's exactly what, if we have a nod that this is an okay concept from the board, we're beginning to discuss that internally.
    • 03:20:40
      with our financial folks of how we get through that.
    • 03:20:42
      It's really a cash flow issue.
    • 03:20:44
      Like you said, a lot of these projects are new projects.
    • 03:20:46
      We're not going to be able to spend that full $100 million in FY12, and we think we can go about an approach to keep these projects moving, get them on the street, get them moving, and still be able to, I guess, to your point, be able to keep these projects moving without having to look at, are they all fully funded in FY13?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:05
      If the money's coming, then they can continue on the process.
    • 03:21:08
      The other question is a senior transportation official in the state on Monday night identified that when we sold those bonds we yielded more than we otherwise would have gotten, about $50 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:21
      They're still running those numbers now.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:23
      Oh, so we couldn't factor that into potentially using for this program?
    • 03:21:27
      Okay.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:28
      Mr. Chairman, we're going to be taking applications next year.
    • 03:21:33
      I'm confused on this.
    • 03:21:36
      This is a $50 million program this year.
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:21:39
      I'll walk back to that again.
    • 03:21:41
      What we're doing is we have applications that came in right now that we're looking at FY12.
    • 03:21:47
      We had $50 million in our budget for FY12.
    • 03:21:50
      We've gotten those applications for $130 million.
    • 03:21:52
      We've come up with somewhere, what can we do with $100 million?
    • 03:21:55
      So we're kind of borrowing from the future for FY13, pulling that $50 million that was budgeted, because if you remember from Rita's and John's presentations, for the six-year planning process, they put $50 million each year.
    • 03:22:08
      So what we've done is we've said, well, we're going to accelerate the use of that $50 million of FY13, for lack of better words.
    • 03:22:16
      We're going to also still have an FY13 program,
    • 03:22:20
      and based on the law, we can have a $200 million program as our cap.
    • 03:22:25
      We're already earmarking, for lack of better words, $50 million of that out of FY13.
    • 03:22:30
      We have $150 million left that we can discuss with the board next round when we go out for applications in the fall.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:37
      Okay, is there anyone?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:39
      Mr. Chairman.
    • Michael A. EstesLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:22:39
      Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:42
      Mr. Justice, I'm going to support your proposal when the time comes, but
    • 03:22:49
      I would like us to sort of think as a group as we go forward that it's somewhat arbitrary to sort of say, let's take projects that are five million and below and fully fund those and ones that are five million and above.
    • 03:23:06
      We don't.
    • 03:23:08
      In my view, what we ought to be doing, and it's obviously harder.
    • 03:23:12
      and it's more political and so forth and so on is what's the most important projects to fund?
    • 03:23:17
      And fund them and get on with them.
    • 03:23:19
      And that's what I would be, I'm gonna support this one, but next year, that's what you're gonna hear me say.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:26
      Mr. Chairman, may I help Shep a little bit?
    • 03:23:31
      Yeah.
    • 03:23:31
      Dr. Davis.
    • 03:23:32
      I really don't think there's any unfairness at all.
    • 03:23:34
      As a matter of fact, what's most important is what these localities think are really important.
    • 03:23:39
      They're putting up their money to match this
    • 03:23:41
      And they're moving ahead projects that are important to them.
    • 03:23:44
      And that's the most important thing rather than us trying to decide what's most important for them.
    • 03:23:50
      That's the beauty of this project.
    • 03:23:51
      It is a local-based program that causes them to spend money in addition to the money that's coming from the state.
    • 03:23:58
      So your question shouldn't bother you at all that we're doing the best thing.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:01
      No, I would disagree with you.
    • 03:24:03
      What I'm saying is there's seven projects or seven localities that chose their project
    • 03:24:09
      and they say this is a good project but it costs more than five million dollars.
    • 03:24:13
      And we put an arbitrary cap because we can get most of them in and said if you're under five million we'll fully fund you.
    • 03:24:19
      Well how about the folks in Chesterfield that ask for seven?
    • 03:24:22
      Why is their seven less important?
    • 03:24:25
      Why is their seven less important than Patrick County 103?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:30
      Mr. Miller, this is just for this year because of the fact.
    • 03:24:33
      And so this is just the one year, we're just doing this.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:36
      I agree with the local concept.
    • 03:24:39
      I can speak for one of the seven.
    • 03:24:40
      We're fine with five.
    • 03:24:42
      I mean, that's four more than otherwise would have been there.
    • 03:24:45
      And this is the big, when you, kind of getting to Dr. Davis's point, when you realize the reductions that have taken place, localities used to get through the secondary road system, that's largely, well, I won't say largely, I haven't gone through each of the projects, but my bet is this is largely going to the secondary road system, which had to cut.
    • 03:25:04
      Localities are putting up money,
    • 03:25:06
      They're doing it based on their priorities, their local priorities, the states matching that.
    • 03:25:10
      I think it's a win-win.
    • 03:25:13
      Would you like to get more?
    • 03:25:14
      You bet.
    • 03:25:15
      But I can guarantee they're not going to complain at the five.
    • 03:25:19
      I understand that.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:25:20
      All I'm suggesting to you, and I'm going to shut up and go away.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:25:26
      Don't go too far.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:25:27
      We've got the rest of the agenda.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:25:29
      What we're doing is we're putting an arbitrary number and capping people so we can get more people in.
    • 03:25:35
      And for me, that should not be our priority.
    • 03:25:38
      But a priority ought to be is look at all those projects, they put them up, and we fund the ones that we think are most important to the Commonwealth.
    • 03:25:46
      They put them up.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:25:48
      But the legislation does that.
    • 03:25:50
      They set it at 10.
    • 03:25:51
      So what if a project or what if a locality had a $20 million project?
    • 03:25:55
      Make them more money than we do.
    • 03:25:57
      They get paid.
    • 03:25:58
      But this program, by law, is caped in.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:26:01
      So we just really don't like it.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:03
      All right, Ms. Estes, we look forward to this.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:06
      Outstanding.
    • 03:26:07
      Mr.
    • 03:26:07
      Page, get up here quick.
    • 03:26:08
      Unanimous consent.
    • 03:26:09
      Get up here, Page.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:26:13
      Mr. Chairman, I have a slide seven, so does that help?
    • Allen L. LouderbackMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:18
      I started eight.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:26:21
      Thanks for working them over, Mike.
    • 03:26:24
      Help me out.
    • 03:26:25
      All right, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, it's great to be up here before you today.
    • 03:26:28
      Mr. Pittard, our chief financial officer, in his update kind of queued me up for this, and now I'm going to queue up Mr. Kendall, who's going to talk a little bit about CSX and where we're moving with them.
    • 03:26:38
      Just to bring the board up to speed, I know you've probably seen this slide before many times, but just to remind you of where we are kind of in our present passenger rail operations for inner city and commuter rail here in Virginia and also where we're headed in the future.
    • 03:26:50
      You know, it's good for us to always concentrate on what we are capable of doing today and functionally within the six-year program and then also how we're looking out more into the longer leads, which are the dotted lines you see on the map here before you.
    • 03:27:02
      Kind of the follow-on to that, this is where we are today with what we call the Amtrak Virginia Regional Passenger Train Service.
    • 03:27:09
      You know, where we're headed with the dark blue lines of services that the Commonwealth Transportation Board has already worked with Director Drake and the administration to go ahead and start and initiate, which has been working extremely well.
    • 03:27:20
      What you see in kind of the plunk color is our bus extension to Roanoke as we move out further into the network of our future plans.
    • 03:27:28
      for passenger rail in Virginia.
    • 03:27:30
      And also the green line is that Newport News Service that is very important to us because that's part of the regional network that currently serves the Hampton Road region as well as the yellow line, which is alternative one with part of the high-speed rail quarter route, the extension to Hampton Roads, as well as our Norfolk train service proposal that we're working with Norfolk Southern and CSX on today.
    • 03:27:47
      Very importantly, to point out to the board today, you know, all of the transportation functions here in Virginia dealing under this, under the Secretary of Transportation, we are working to develop a transportation network that is coincides with the VTrans population of PTC, maximum population available.
    • 03:28:04
      What we're trying to do here is put inner city passenger rail out where we feel it's most practical and appropriate in Virginia to move forward to being part of the transportation solution for the future of Virginia, especially with its higher population areas.
    • 03:28:16
      The state-funded Amtrak service, as I kind of touched on a little bit earlier, has been very successful.
    • 03:28:20
      We finished up the Lynchburg service our very first year.
    • 03:28:23
      Just for the record, it was the highest performing state-funded passenger train in the entire Amtrak system.
    • 03:28:29
      I think that says something.
    • 03:28:31
      We came to this board with a recommendation for the Lynchburg service.
    • 03:28:34
      We felt that it was a good quarter.
    • 03:28:36
      We did start out with Lynchburg being the terminus of the beginning of that train service because we felt it was very effective.
    • 03:28:40
      The Richmond ridership has come on board.
    • 03:28:42
      We started that service last year.
    • 03:28:44
      We aren't finished with our first year of the Richmond service yet, but it continues to grow and climb.
    • 03:28:48
      Remember, this is a very mature service area where we have five trains that run up through Virginia out of both Richmond and Hampton Roads that run up through the service district as well.
    • 03:28:57
      One of the important pieces to talk to this board about, because we'll be crossing this bridge when we talk about Section 209 probably in another month before the board,
    • 03:29:04
      is that we combine all of our Amtrak Virginia services under one contract agreement.
    • 03:29:10
      That way if the Lynchburg service is performing quite well and the Richmond service is performing well but still is requiring a subsidy, we can make sure that if we have positive proceeds on one side of the railroad, we can offset those through the contract itself to minimize the amount of state subsidy that is required.
    • 03:29:26
      Under our original contract negotiations with Amtrak, they wanted to keep the services separate, but we said, what if the Lynchburg train performs well?
    • 03:29:33
      What would happen to that excess revenue?
    • 03:29:35
      And of course, Amtrak felt that they should be the recipient of that.
    • 03:29:39
      This is a state-funded service.
    • 03:29:41
      This service exists today because of the Commonwealth Transportation Board program and these funds and the department contracting with Amtrak to move forward.
    • 03:29:48
      Our 2011 intercity passenger rail operating fund was created.
    • 03:29:52
      I want to make that point before moving to the next slide.
    • 03:29:55
      Having an understanding of that in 2013, this board in the state of Virginia is faced with a federal requirement called PREA Section 209, where all regional services of train service under 250 miles becomes a responsibility of the states.
    • 03:30:10
      So I want to make that point very clear to the board is that you'll find in our six-year program, which we have a public hearing here for the Richmond District tonight, in that program we have $109 million of unfunded need identified as to how we will work forward with this federal requirement.
    • 03:30:28
      We now are going to talk just a little bit about the Norfolk Service.
    • 03:30:31
      This is very important to us.
    • 03:30:33
      It's important to the Hampton Roads region.
    • 03:30:35
      Remember this board adopted alternative one for the high-speed rail corridor alternatives under the EIS to move forward with the high-speed corridor up to 90 miles an hour to Norfolk.
    • 03:30:47
      This service today does not exist.
    • 03:30:49
      What we are doing by bringing up intercity passenger rail service on an incremental approach is that we are now positioning this corridor to be what's referred to as an emerging high-speed rail corridor.
    • 03:30:58
      This puts us in a better state and a more appropriate process as to how we in the future will develop higher speeds for this corridor development and also fare better with the federal program as we work to develop this corridor and bring it up for intercity service.
    • 03:31:12
      We're very fortunate.
    • 03:31:14
      Norfolk Southern stepped up in December 15th.
    • 03:31:17
      We executed an agreement with them to start the necessary improvements.
    • 03:31:21
      Norfolk Southern has also taken on all of the General Contract Administration in building these projects for us, with the exception of the Norfolk Train Station.
    • 03:31:29
      The City of Norfolk, as you know, the Department of Rail and Public Transportation has a policy that we will work to bring intercity service across Virginia to localities, but the station development itself is a local land use and also a local option.
    • 03:31:42
      So the development of that station is being developed and built by the City of Norfolk and we appreciate what they're doing there.
    • 03:31:47
      We have started a website, web link.
    • 03:31:50
      It's also available on your piece of paper there before you in the presentation, hard copy.
    • 03:31:54
      I encourage you to go to that as well because we are providing very close updates on that.
    • 03:31:59
      I want to also point out that in addition to the Norfolk Southern Agreement, CSX, we're going to let Quint Kendall talk a little bit about that.
    • 03:32:05
      That agreement is down in Jacksonville right now.
    • 03:32:06
      We feel that's been finalized, but Mr. Kendall will speak to that during item 10 of this agenda today.
    • 03:32:13
      as well as we've also finalized the agreement and executed it with Amtrak to provide the technical services to move forward with developing that train service.
    • 03:32:21
      We also had in 2011, I'll talk a little bit more in detail about this in a minute, but we did have the Appropriations Act allocate funds to the City of Roanoke.
    • 03:32:29
      The General Assembly put $150,000 in the Appropriations Act for the beginning initiation of one year of the bus bridge to actually start that service.
    • 03:32:37
      The bus connection service from Lynchburg to Roanoke and also that will connect to the Roanoke to Blacksburg service as well.
    • 03:32:44
      So students from as far away as Virginia Tech and hopefully Radford will be able to get on a bus, come all the way across to Lynchburg to be on that connection as well.
    • 03:32:53
      Changing gears a little bit, talking about the federal process.
    • 03:32:56
      Obviously, there's a lot going on here in the quarter development.
    • 03:32:58
      We have state-funded projects, Amtrak working with us on those, and also we have the high-speed program, which has kind of been that fantasy bandwagon that a lot of people have been on, a lot of advocates and all of us, as we move forward on the development of high-speed rail in America.
    • 03:33:14
      We've wrapped up the, you know, just kind of in bringing you up to speed.
    • 03:33:17
      2002, we got the Tier 1 record of decision.
    • 03:33:20
      We did put in for the $1.8 billion.
    • 03:33:22
      We did not receive that from Richmond to Washington.
    • 03:33:24
      We did receive the $75 million.
    • 03:33:25
      I'll give you a little more detail on that in just a minute and also received $45.5 million during FY 2010 to do that Richmond to Washington Tier 2 EIS.
    • 03:33:34
      That's the go to build the project environmental clearance document as well as we also received funding to do an Appomattox River Bridge, Choke Point River Bridge design as well as CSX as coupled with the Department of Rail and Public Transportation on some of the local match on both of those projects.
    • 03:33:51
      Arcandale, that was great.
    • 03:33:52
      I know the board's heard about this project.
    • 03:33:54
      This was our Track 1 project under the federal program.
    • 03:33:57
      January 28, 2010, we received the Notice of Intent for Award.
    • 03:34:01
      We still continue to work with FRA with hopes that we can move this project forward.
    • 03:34:06
      We did have, as you can see here, a couple of meetings with FRA, and we continue to, again, try to work through that in understanding the performance and the railroad agreement that's necessary to move forward with that project.
    • 03:34:17
      Also in the federal program, we have $45.5 million of the federal fiscal year 2010 program.
    • 03:34:22
      October 28, 2010, $45.5 million was awarded to Virginia for those two projects I mentioned earlier, the Richmond area and Washington, D.C. preliminary engineering and environmental work for the Tier II EIS, as well as the $1.2 million grant to do the choke point of the Appomattox River Bridge.
    • 03:34:39
      As you can see, month and date almost later, April 28th, we did have our first kickoff meeting with FRA.
    • 03:34:48
      There's been some challenges at FRA.
    • 03:34:50
      You know, they're metamorphosizing from a regulatory agency to a grant funding agency.
    • 03:34:54
      You know, we kind of allowed our patients on them as they've also made three major grant announcements during the duration of trying to bring a program up from scratch as they move forward.
    • 03:35:04
      So they've been on a fast track as well.
    • 03:35:06
      Richmond and Hampton Roads, a final environmental impact statement, wanted to bring the board up to speed on that as well.
    • 03:35:11
      Back in December of last year, we forwarded that document to the FRA in its final form, and we met with them on April the 28th, 2011.
    • 03:35:21
      Finally got some initial comments out of them, we're waiting for general counsel to move forward out of FRA, also to give us comments so we can move that project onto a record of decision.
    • 03:35:30
      We're hopeful that that's going to occur very soon as we work through those comments.
    • 03:35:35
      We also have the Richmond to Raleigh Environmental Impact Statement Tier 2, which has been going on for some time.
    • 03:35:41
      The Department of Rail and Public Transportation and NCDOT have worked collectively on this project for many years now.
    • 03:35:48
      We also worked together on the Tier 1, which was a record decision of 2002.
    • 03:35:52
      We turned right around a year later and actually started that process.
    • 03:35:55
      So just to kind of paint a picture for the board, a lot of people have said, well, why is it taking so long in your, kind of your schedule for Richmond to Washington Tier 2 EIS?
    • 03:36:04
      Remember, we started the Tier 2 from Richmond to Raleigh in 2004, so that kind of gives you an idea.
    • 03:36:11
      That's a real-time, real schedule that the Board can see as we've been working very ambitiously with North Carolina DOT on.
    • 03:36:18
      To complete that project, $4 million of additional funds was necessary.
    • 03:36:23
      NCDOT, who I mentioned earlier is the lead on this project, applied for federal funding and was awarded that funding on May the 9th of this year, so we'll see the funding come to NCDOT on that project.
    • 03:36:34
      That starts in Richmond, Virginia, by the way.
    • 03:36:36
      It goes down to Petersburg and then over on a totally on-rail alignment right now.
    • 03:36:41
      It's an all-new alignment that uses about 40% of an old abandoned right-of-way called the S Line to Raleigh.
    • 03:36:47
      Having said that, we in the Norfolk service, again, trying to plan for the future, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, is that as we brought the Norfolk train alignment up, we made sure that Norfolk Southern worked with us and CSX in a collaborative way to understand that the alignment to Norfolk
    • 03:37:04
      It can be achieved, that curve at 45 miles an hour, so it's the fastest we can get out of that alignment based on the land.
    • 03:37:09
      And also we set the adjustment at Collier so that the third track, which is the high-speed quarter track to Raleigh, will also be accommodated in this construction.
    • 03:37:18
      That way we don't have to go back and recut the hillside and make an adjustment for when that high-speed quarter is built.
    • 03:37:24
      So there we are with, as we move forward with those projects.
    • 03:37:29
      Now, the Board may also be aware that we do have a Virginia-North Carolina high-speed rail compact.
    • 03:37:36
      The compact is a bi-state compact that was ratified by both Assemblies of Virginia and North Carolina and also by Congress.
    • 03:37:42
      It's one of the few bi-state compacts for high-speed rail in the United States, and in its rarity, we've had two meetings.
    • 03:37:49
      And we are working forward, Director Drake is working with Senator John Watkins who is the Chairman of the Compact to have a Virginia Members Only workshop starting this summer.
    • 03:38:01
      One of the challenges that we've put before the compact members, as you can see down here in this workshop, is that we need to talk about defining the high-speed corridor, the affordability of that corridor, and how does it get paid for.
    • 03:38:13
      You know, now at the 100% money of error funding, error stimulus funding, that $8 billion is gone, how are we going to develop that 20% matching requirement, how we share those costs, sequencing of the individual projects, how we phase this corridor.
    • 03:38:24
      As this board may remember, this starts in Washington, D.C., comes from Richmond.
    • 03:38:28
      The high-speed corridor also adds an extension to Norfolk.
    • 03:38:31
      and also continues on down to Raleigh.
    • 03:38:33
      In 1994, all of the states as far south as Florida from Virginia also signed on because they're all part of the southeast quarter.
    • 03:38:41
      It's all worked collectively in the development of this quarter.
    • 03:38:44
      We have $2 billion between Richmond and Washington alone to make this quarter reality, but it will be to the benefit of all riders that come from the South.
    • 03:38:53
      So there's a lot of hard discussion and contemplation as to how we develop this quarter and how we partner with the other states to get these improvements through Virginia developed so that Virginia does not have to pay 100 percent for those costs.
    • 03:39:06
      I want to talk a little bit about the Rail Enhancement Fund.
    • 03:39:09
      CFO Pittard mentioned earlier that we've had projects move forward and some others have been reracked as well.
    • 03:39:14
      I want to kind of give you some of the highlights and I'll be happy between the end of this meeting and the beginning of the public hearing this afternoon to sit down with any of the board members to kind of just chat with them about any updates that they may need and greater than this.
    • 03:39:25
      Norfolk Southern has completed the Manassas Front Royal Project.
    • 03:39:29
      Let's move forward very well.
    • 03:39:31
      We're also developing, moving forward with Berryville, Elton, and the Roanoke Terminal improvements.
    • 03:39:35
      We'll talk about that in just a minute.
    • 03:39:37
      CFX is working to advance the National Gateway Project.
    • 03:39:40
      National Gateway is a larger multi-state project that received Tiger Grant funds to go from Chambersburg, Pennsylvania on out to Toledo to CSX's big intermodal yard at the western terminus of the National Gateway.
    • 03:39:53
      There are two other major phases that need to be developed, one of which is the Virginia Avenue Tunnel, which is in Washington, D.C., but it's a huge choke point for the access of double stack intermodal clearance, excuse
    • 03:40:05
      That's very critical for us in Virginia because in order to have two railroads compete for the containerization of our port,
    • 03:40:16
      They have to have a good double stack clearance.
    • 03:40:18
      We have the Crescent and Heartland Quarters for Norfolk Southern, the National Gateway, which right now is kind of bogged down with the Virginia Avenue Tunnel at the Federal Olympics.
    • 03:40:26
      It's a large big ticket project.
    • 03:40:28
      We are continuing to work with Norfolk Southern on their projects, but we're very focused on the fact that we need to get National Gateway up and running as well.
    • 03:40:36
      VRE continues to advance its design of the Manassas to Gainesville Haymarket.
    • 03:40:39
      I know there's some members of the board here that are very attuned to the Gainesville Haymarket study.
    • 03:40:44
      That's moving forward.
    • 03:40:46
      We understand that Norfolk Southern and VRE have come to terms on their agreement as to what those two parties will do when we're moving that project in advance as they have worked to agreement.
    • 03:40:56
      VPA still works with us on the Rail Enhancement Fund Grant on the Craney Island Connector and also the NIT Marshaling Yard.
    • 03:41:02
      Two critical pieces, again, for us to remain competitive in the global marketplace for port development.
    • 03:41:09
      And also, I think it was mentioned earlier by Director Draker, who could have been CFO Pittard, about the Supreme Court.
    • 03:41:14
      We'll hear our oral arguments this summer on the Roanoke Intermodal Terminal project.
    • 03:41:20
      For those projects that weren't moving forward, this board may remember
    • 03:41:23
      And recall back in September of last year, we reracked the six-year program, moving out a lot of the Norfolk Southern projects and also in July of last year, we adjusted some of the CSX projects.
    • 03:41:33
      So we took that cash and actually put it on the Norfolk improvements.
    • 03:41:37
      And that allowed us to advance the Norfolk improvements for the intermodal train service that we're starting.
    • 03:41:45
      And we've moved those other projects into the out years of the Six-Year Program to when I think we feel that they're going to be more realistic in timeframe.
    • 03:41:51
      So we're going to make good use of that cash while we have it on hand.
    • 03:41:54
      We have a bonded project that's coming in to the Six-Year Program.
    • 03:41:59
      One of the accelerated bond projects is going to be VRE will build the third track from Hamiltons, which is just south of Fredericksburg, to Crossroads.
    • 03:42:07
      It's just under three miles.
    • 03:42:08
      A very critical link to bring Spotsylvania County service
    • 03:42:11
      up and running from the Crossroads Yard area.
    • 03:42:14
      That's a very critical project.
    • 03:42:16
      It's very important for Spotsylvania County as well as Fredericksburg and areas north.
    • 03:42:20
      It helps alleviate some of the congestion of commuters going into Fredericksburg and further north to Brook and Leland to those stations as well as helping Spotsylvania County grow economically by having commuter rail service directly in their community.
    • 03:42:33
      We could not have moved this forward if it weren't for the $4.4 billion government McDonald's proposal to accelerate bond revenue.
    • 03:42:39
      So this is a very good project for us.
    • 03:42:40
      Our short-line railroads continue their upgrade and rehabilitation programs.
    • 03:42:44
      As this board may recall, our short-line railway preservation and development fund, while it's a small fund of money, it helps us keep about 479 miles of track in Virginia up and running that currently today would probably not have that economic opportunity and viability that it does without this program.
    • 03:42:59
      Our inner-city past real operating capital program, again, is in the six-year program, and we need to identify, you know, keep focus on those unmet needs as we go through that six-year program.
    • 03:43:10
      Changing gears, talking about the Appropriations Act.
    • 03:43:13
      As you all know around this table, our General Assembly hands this project sometimes with funds identified and little special efforts that need to go on.
    • 03:43:22
      There are some good projects in here today I'd like to go through.
    • 03:43:25
      One of which I mentioned earlier is the $150,000 of rail enhancement funds off the top of the program that will go to the City of Roanoke for the bus bridge.
    • 03:43:34
      I want to point out this board is that we've got to see if really technically if Roanoke is a good market we've got to start stimulating some type of inner city connectivity and I think this possible this bus demonstration project will help us better identify the market that we'll be serving when and if we ever get the train service down to Corona.
    • 03:43:52
      We also have $325,000 that's been set out to develop a siding with the Army in Caroline County.
    • 03:44:00
      I think this board has probably heard through the press and other reports that the Virginia Railway Express Operations Board has sold an entire train set, a surplus train set of older equipment.
    • 03:44:09
      They were retiring to the Army, and the Army will actually move its troops, which currently today move over Interstate I-95, and then I think it's Route 307 over to Boulder Green to Camp AP Hill.
    • 03:44:20
      That project will allow them to, 37 weeks a year, actually move their entire troops that they move twice a week by rail instead of by highway.
    • 03:44:29
      They use a charter bus program now today, it's about 27, 28 buses that make this move twice a week.
    • 03:44:36
      So this project will move forward as well.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:38
      I'm sorry, just to make sure I understand this, so the state government is now subsidizing the federal government's operations?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:44:43
      That is correct.
    • 03:44:44
      To answer your question, the Rail and Access Fund has been marked for the starting development for the Army Train Service, which will be operated by the Army.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:53
      I just want to make sure we're helping them out.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:44:54
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:44:55
      That is correct.
    • 03:44:56
      I hope I answered that appropriately.
    • 03:44:57
      Thank you.
    • 03:44:58
      All right.
    • 03:44:59
      The other piece has been very beneficial, I think, for the Fredericksburg area.
    • 03:45:05
      Every time that we get an automobile and turn the key, we have not only gasoline and carbon, we also have a product called ethanol.
    • 03:45:13
      This product helped replace an additive that was banned in gasoline
    • 03:45:21
      several years ago.
    • 03:45:23
      Ethanol is 10% by volume.
    • 03:45:24
      If you have 10 gallons of gasoline in your tank, you've got one gallon of ethanol that potentially came off of a facility by a rail tank cart.
    • 03:45:32
      Ethanol is not shipped by pipeline like petroleum products are.
    • 03:45:36
      It has to be shipped by tank cart because it's an alcohol.
    • 03:45:39
      And there is an unloading facility in the Fredericksburg area as well as some other commodities that have been brought to the attention of some members of the General Assembly.
    • 03:45:48
      And how we dealt with that, we're going to deal with that, is how the General Assembly is handed down to us.
    • 03:45:54
      And that is there's been some funds identified in the correct language as to how CSX and the Department of Rail and Public Transportation will work together with the communities
    • 03:46:01
      to build some additional track to move these materials away from a more high density residential area and how we move forward with also some additional capacities off site of that yard as to how we can store those ethanol cars and some other products that actually move down to Milford, Virginia.
    • 03:46:18
      So we'll continue to work through this.
    • 03:46:19
      As you can see at the bottom of the slide there, we do have some reporting requirements back to the General Assembly and we've already had our first meeting with CSX and Quintin Kendall is available later to answer any questions on this.
    • 03:46:31
      that I might not be able to answer, but we are moving ahead with this project very ambitiously and CSX and DRPT have already come together and we have a letter of no prejudice moving forward to start this project.
    • 03:46:42
      I will point out to the board, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, this particular item did require a CTB approval by the language of the code, so I will be coming back to you.
    • 03:46:50
      This is your 30-day advance notice.
    • 03:46:52
      I'll be coming back to the board with Thelma Drake's recommendation for approval of a resolution that will move this money forward for these two projects.
    • 03:47:01
      Additional federal high-speed rail funding that came out in March, as you all may recall, Florida turned back almost $2 billion worth of funds to the federal government, which FRA then turned back out on the street in a very abbreviated process between March 11th and April 4th.
    • 03:47:19
      The states had to come together and again, once again, compete with each other for additional federal funding to advance high-speed rail in America.
    • 03:47:27
      Our department, the Department of Rail and Public Transportation worked very hard and viciously with CSX.
    • 03:47:33
      We pulled our team together.
    • 03:47:34
      We reevaluated where we were on the Track 1 and Track 2 applications.
    • 03:47:41
      Track 1 was funded.
    • 03:47:42
      How we went to develop the corridor and then
    • 03:47:44
      Based on, as I talked to you a little bit earlier about the long lead times of getting FRA to get us under contract, we, working with our consultants and with the railroad, felt that the earliest we could complete a project was 2021.
    • 03:47:56
      The federal program, as you know, is a 2017 program where the $1.6 billion of 100% funding was available.
    • 03:48:04
      We, the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, did not have the 20% match, so we would have had to have gone for the 100% funding.
    • 03:48:10
      And to move that forward, we could not take the risk of not being able to achieve that project within their timeframe.
    • 03:48:15
      The risk is payback.
    • 03:48:16
      The risk is failure to perform and potential default of a contract that we could not see ourselves going into at this time.
    • 03:48:24
      So the Department of Rail and Public Transportation opted not to apply.
    • 03:48:27
      We felt it was the best that we could do at this point.
    • 03:48:29
      We could not achieve the project in the timelines that were set forward.
    • 03:48:34
      So therefore, we notified the Federal Railroad Administration that we opted not to apply at this time.
    • 03:48:39
      Having said that, the most recent allocation of funds and awards gives you the map that you see before you today.
    • 03:48:46
      As you see, FRA and their Intercity Passion Rail Fund have moved forward with the development of certain corridors, but it's been a little bit shot blasted on how they've moved forward with these projects.
    • 03:48:57
      It's very important for the board to kind of watch this map as I go to the next slide, so you might want to keep this map in front of you, to kind of give you the queue-ups
    • 03:49:07
      As you can see, we contacted the Federal Railroad Administration and asked them, well, can you give us a list of individual states as to how the states have fallen out in an all-encompassing one-sheet list?
    • 03:49:20
      And they referred us to this volume here.
    • 03:49:22
      We asked for a one-page list like this slide, and this is the best we could get out of them.
    • 03:49:26
      So what we have done is we have boiled down the information that's been provided by the Fed on the allocations and awards and given you slide 19.
    • 03:49:34
      One of the strong points I'd like to point out in slide 19, looking at your map, the Chicago cluster up in Illinois has been a recipient of $2.542 billion, plus or minus.
    • 03:49:46
      So that's 25% of the $10.023 billion that's been allocated today has gone to the Chicago cluster.
    • 03:49:52
      If you look over in our quarter, you'll see that North Carolina has had a good recipient of full funding of their quarter as they've moved forward, and also the $4 million to move up and advance the Tier II EIS to Richmond.
    • 03:50:09
      Virginia, as you can see in highlight, has received $120 million of announced awards of intent.
    • 03:50:14
      $75 million of that is still hung up with the railroad agreement and FRA's performance requirements as we move forward on that.
    • 03:50:24
      So where are we with the Federal High-Speed Intercity passenger rail program?
    • 03:50:28
      What we're finding with this program, and again I've mentioned it's an evolution process, it's been somewhat challenging to us here at DRPT and other states as well as we move forward.
    • 03:50:38
      I'm kind of giving you a couple of little quick examples here.
    • 03:50:41
      When North Carolina submitted its application and its project to move forward, they were working on a 90-mile-an-hour platform.
    • 03:50:50
      They finally went under agreement with Norfolk Southern and the North Carolina Railroad for a 79-mile-an-hour project with a planning goal of a 90-mile-an-hour railroad at the end.
    • 03:50:59
      We submitted, for our Track 1 project, the 70 mile an hour project, and therefore I came back and it required us, which we've done, to redesign the project to meet 90 miles an hour, and also we're being required to build the roadbed to meet 90 miles an hour, which means that all the culverts on the insides of Kurtz had to be extended, which means we're buying creek, streambed, and wetland credits that we otherwise would not have had to have purchased probably if we had only done the 70 mile an hour project.
    • 03:51:25
      In addition to that, FRA is required as a condition in our negotiations to also add an additional crossover at Arkandale, which this board may remember.
    • 03:51:34
      We just did the Arkandale crossover under one of the six MOU projects.
    • 03:51:38
      So we're now having to add an additional crossover on a universal crossover.
    • 03:51:41
      The FRA worked hand-in-hand on us with just a few, not more than four years ago as we built out those MOU projects.
    • 03:51:49
      Environmental clearances continue to be a challenge with FRA.
    • 03:51:53
      North Carolina DOT basically came forward and is building out their corridor with the environmental assessment process.
    • 03:52:00
      They've got about just under 30 EAs up there, where we're being told that we have to do an entire corridor-long EIS, which under tier two takes years longer than if we had done an EA process.
    • 03:52:11
      We're continuing dialogue with FRA.
    • 03:52:13
      I want the board to know that we're continuing to push back and use what they've allowed other states to do as examples where Virginia needs to move forward with the same level playing field.
    • 03:52:23
      Having said that, I think this slide 21 is kind of the end of my presentation, but I think it's food for thought for the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 03:52:35
      We have been providing our Virginia-North Carolina High-Speed Rail Compact thoughts to consider in our presentations, and I felt with Director Drake that this would be an appropriate slide to walk through before the discussion begins.
    • 03:52:49
      And that is, what is the policy for passenger rail development in Virginia?
    • 03:52:52
      You know, we do have a state of Virginia rail plan.
    • 03:52:54
      We have a rail resource allocation plan.
    • 03:52:57
      This board has taken some very ambitious goals and set forward an Amtrak passenger rail service in Virginia as we join the 15th state with Amtrak to develop an intercity passenger rail service.
    • 03:53:09
      You know, what is the affordability of that incremental service?
    • 03:53:13
      This board is seeing how much more cost effective we can bring conventional Amtrak service up versus
    • 03:53:19
      And that's usually 79 mile an hour service, by the way, versus a 90 mile an hour service, which is 11 miles an hour faster, how much more that cost is per mile.
    • 03:53:29
      And what is the, in our short distance corridors, is that extra 11 miles, what is the cost and what is the benefit?
    • 03:53:37
      The federal program, for example, requires a 20% capital match now.
    • 03:53:41
      It has a 20-year maintenance requirement to the states, and it also has a 20-year performance requirement.
    • 03:53:47
      I may point out that the administration and the federal administration has said we want 80% of the population served in 25 years.
    • 03:53:54
      But I'm drawing you back to the commitment of this program ends in 20 years.
    • 03:53:59
      So if you were grant funded this year, you would only be available to, required to run that service for 20 years.
    • 03:54:06
      So the federal program has a 20-year lifetime.
    • 03:54:08
      So I wanted to point that out to the board as we move forward.
    • 03:54:12
      That means at the end of the 20 years, you have to go back to the railroads and renegotiate for the high-speed rail corridor use.
    • 03:54:18
      So as we move forward, that's a very strong point that I wanna point out to the board as well.
    • 03:54:24
      Again, talking about risk and payback.
    • 03:54:26
      What is the risk of the federal program and the performance and the payback and where your relationship is with the serving railroad?
    • 03:54:34
      And what happens if there's a failure of that service or due to a service interruption, how does that fall into play?
    • 03:54:42
      The other is, so what is the definition of the Southeast High Speed Rail Quarter?
    • 03:54:46
      Washington to Richmond is very critical for us.
    • 03:54:48
      Richmond to Petersburg and Norfolk is very critical for us.
    • 03:54:52
      And Virginia, that's an extension of the southeast quarter, which came after its original designation.
    • 03:54:57
      Then we have basically the Richmond to Raleigh services.
    • 03:55:00
      We move forward on down south with the other states to Florida.
    • 03:55:04
      Again, I'll mention that MOU of 1994, where all the states came together and said we'll develop this quarter and how we will develop that incrementally is still a discussion topic even today.
    • 03:55:15
      So where do we stand as the Commonwealth Transportation Board, the Department of Rail and Public Transportation in sequencing the individual projects and also giving guidance to the regions of Virginia as to how they will move forward to work with us in development of these corridors and also passenger rail in Virginia in general and also our freight program?
    • 03:55:35
      So having said that, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, that concludes my presentation.
    • 03:55:40
      I'm certainly open for any comments or questions.
    • 03:55:42
      I know Thelma Drake might have some as well.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:55:44
      Mr. Layne.
    • 03:55:46
      Mr.
    • 03:55:46
      Page, first of all, thank you for your hard work on the train service to Norfolk.
    • 03:55:51
      Director Drake, looking forward to that in 2013, and hopefully we'll get more than one as we work through that.
    • 03:55:59
      Your topic as to, this is a topic that I've had on my mind, what is our role at CTB in guiding
    • 03:56:06
      train development, high-speed rail, whatever in Virginia.
    • 03:56:11
      As you know, in Hampton Roads, we have a lot of projects going on.
    • 03:56:16
      There's some competing ideas down there.
    • 03:56:19
      So my question was going to be, is it, and then Mr.
    • 03:56:23
      Keen brought this up a little bit later, a little earlier with the not having a rail advisory board anymore.
    • 03:56:29
      So what is the role of the CTB?
    • 03:56:31
      Is it like we have in passenger cars or with VDOT, do we actually set those allocations?
    • 03:56:38
      I mean that's really, and if so, why wouldn't we be taking that up so we could give guidance so that we efficiently spend our monies across the state?
    • 03:56:49
      And so I guess I would add my voice to the support, but I think that's a conversation this board needs to have.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 03:56:56
      I think as well, if I could follow on, Mr. Chairman, with Mr. Lane's comment, it's very similar to the quarters of statewide significance for highway systems.
    • 03:57:04
      We should, I think, be having that same conscious discussion around the table as to how that quarter is a transportation quarter, what rail quarters are of statewide significance as to how they move forward, and then the incremental process, I think, is a guidance that needs to be discussed, very similar to how the COSS is being discussed.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:57:23
      And when I say guidance, I don't mean,
    • 03:57:24
      I think part, Mr. Secretary, of what you might be referring to, Mr. Layne, is that
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:37
      We talk about the conventional speed that we're bringing up, the 79 miles an hour, but we also have the federal program, which is 90 to 110, and then we have a vision plan in Hampton Roads that's been worked on.
    • 03:57:49
      So it becomes confusing to the public, and how do they all fit together so that we're not doing one thing, working incrementally, but then not using that funding.
    • 03:57:59
      I mean, what is it that we want to see?
    • 03:58:01
      Just like in our rail, when we didn't apply for the federal money, we didn't have the authority to commit the Commonwealth to pay back that money if we couldn't meet the date.
    • 03:58:11
      But if all of you and the Assembly had said we wanted it any cost, then we would have applied, because we'd have known that was your commitment.
    • 03:58:19
      But we haven't had those discussions, and that's part of why we want to start that now.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:24
      Mr. Chairman, I think one thing this points to some of the value that the rail enhancement fund brings to the table and the oversight committee that was the advisory board offered that opportunity
    • 03:58:41
      For the railroads to come and give performance reports gave an opportunity for the department to be closely connected with their performances and it had that connection there.
    • 03:58:52
      The disconnect here is that will no longer happen.
    • 03:58:55
      So this vacuum we're talking about, we would have actually explained that.
    • 03:59:00
      There would have been public statements in a meeting why we can't live up to these standards as far as applying for these
    • 03:59:07
      These times, even though we do make those statements, but it draws groups together and we consider those things.
    • 03:59:14
      Moving forward, there are some very important questions here that we would have discussed in those meetings that that forum no longer exists to vet some of these projects and to have that communication.
    • 03:59:25
      So it's probably very important that we take a look at this because there's a separate six-year plan here
    • 03:59:31
      We're very guilty as board members of really knowing what's in the six-year plan as far as roads are concerned.
    • 03:59:38
      And the six-year plan from rail, a little bit new.
    • 03:59:41
      We probably are not as up to date on that one.
    • 03:59:45
      We're not getting as many questions, at least in my part of the country, pertaining to the six-year rail plan.
    • 03:59:51
      It's an important thing that we need to get a handle on, I think, moving forward.
    • 03:59:56
      And it requires some thought.
    • 04:00:00
      and how do we go about developing this policy for passenger rail and other questions that are arising out of this.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:09
      Any other questions, comments?
    • 04:00:14
      At this point.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:16
      Quick question, Mr. Secretary.
    • 04:00:18
      Your reference to the bottleneck at the Appomattox Bridge, is that because the bridge is old?
    • 04:00:23
      Is it a tight turn with a slow speed to cross it?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 04:00:26
      No, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Koelemay, it's a very good question.
    • 04:00:30
      It's a single-track bridge on a double-track railroad.
    • 04:00:33
      And it's a very congested point because it's the only place south of Richmond before you get to the largest yard, one of the largest yards in Virginia is called your yard.
    • 04:00:42
      It's the longest storage track so they can stack trains.
    • 04:00:45
      So what happens is that trains are fleeted north and south of the Atmax River.
    • 04:00:50
      It's kind of like a one-lane highway bridge, and the railroad at Grey Cross is north and south of that river.
    • 04:00:55
      They get blocked very frequently.
    • 04:00:57
      In order for the department not only to bring up the Norfolk service, you know, we have three train slots.
    • 04:01:03
      We're contemplating three round-trip trips out of Norfolk.
    • 04:01:06
      But also that bridge itself is very congested to bring those trains up so where we have been in a collaborative way with CSX, having been able to bring that train up, the one train from Richmond to Petersburg up with the interchange project only.
    • 04:01:22
      with the agreement to move forward on the choke point for trains two and three.
    • 04:01:27
      We've got a lot of choke point issues at Avmax River and also some capacity issues between Richmond and Petersburg.
    • 04:01:33
      For those of you who have ever gone down the RMA Expressway with a few places besides the median rail in Virginia where you actually have a highway and the railroad runs down the middle of it.
    • 04:01:41
      You'll see that CSX parks trains there as well because they're trying to get trains into Accoyard.
    • 04:01:47
      So many times over you'll see a southbound train parked on the RMA Expressway or on the James River Bridge because it's actually waiting for time that it could get down and cross the Appomattox River.
    • 04:01:56
      So it's a very big choke point for us.
    • 04:01:57
      So we have the Appomattox River Bridge and Virginia Avenue Tunnel, believe it or not, Virginia Avenue being in Washington, D.C., that has an impact on us all the way to Richmond on the quarter.
    • 04:02:07
      So that's a one-track tunnel, excuse me.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:02:11
      Yeah, Mr.
    • 04:02:12
      Page, is that track or is that tunnel the one that's in DC itself?
    • 04:02:18
      Yes, sir, it is.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 04:02:20
      Right.
    • 04:02:20
      Just for the board's information, our MOU projects start actually at a place called L'Enfant.
    • 04:02:27
      Virginia Avenue Tunnel is just around the curve from L'Enfant.
    • 04:02:30
      So we have three tracks, almost 15 miles of three tracks.
    • 04:02:33
      We're trying to build a third track all the way from D.C. to Richmond.
    • 04:02:36
      We have 15 miles built today.
    • 04:02:38
      We're about to build another 2.6 miles with VRE.
    • 04:02:41
      The Virginia Avenue Tunnel, unfortunately, is the only freight tunnel
    • 04:02:44
      through Washington, D.C. for all the traffic that comes out through Richmond and on north.
    • 04:02:48
      So it's a single-track tunnel, unfortunately.
    • 04:02:50
      That's a big choke point for both CSX and also moving trains.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:02:54
      And also, too, I assume you're still working to get that switch taken care of and ETRIC, the switch between CSX and all sorts of others?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 04:03:04
      Yes, sir, that's correct.
    • 04:03:05
      And that agreement is in Florida right now, in Jacksonville.
    • 04:03:10
      And I'll let Mr. Quintin Kendall, Vice President from CSX, will have a report on that in just a minute.
    • 04:03:16
      Thank you, though.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:18
      Any other questions?
    • 04:03:20
      Thank you very much.
    • 04:03:21
      Thank you.
    • 04:03:22
      I'm going to ask Mr. Kendall if he'd like to come up.
    • 04:03:25
      Actually, it makes more sense to have his presentation now.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 04:03:39
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, thanks so much for the opportunity to be here.
    • 04:03:44
      The main thrust of my presentation today is going to be lay out several challenges that you all as transportation policy makers have to deal with now and the future and describe perhaps how the ongoing partnership between CSX and the Commonwealth of Virginia are going to help you address these challenges.
    • 04:04:02
      Now I think you all are probably aware of the partnership, the existing partnership between CSX and the Commonwealth
    • 04:04:08
      on passenger rail issues.
    • 04:04:10
      CSX hosts 30 VRE trains every weekday.
    • 04:04:14
      We host the state sponsored Amtrak service, regional service that runs from Newport News and Richmond as well as long distance service trains that run through Virginia.
    • 04:04:26
      And today, real proud, real excited to announce that CSX and Virginia have finalized an agreement to initiate one daily round trip train between Norfolk and the Northeast Corridor to start next year.
    • 04:04:39
      This is a real exciting development.
    • 04:04:42
      We're happy to be part of this.
    • 04:04:44
      And Mr. Secretary, if I may, just an editorial comment here.
    • 04:04:48
      In 2009, President Obama announced
    • 04:04:52
      A unprecedented federal funding of passenger rail.
    • 04:04:57
      It's something that got a lot of states very, very excited about moving out on 220 mile an hour Japanese style bullet trains.
    • 04:05:07
      A lot of these states started scrambling to develop rail programs that hadn't existed before or coherent rail programs.
    • 04:05:15
      Here in Virginia, y'all didn't need to do that because you already had it.
    • 04:05:19
      There's a very, very good, well-thought-out passenger rail program here.
    • 04:05:26
      I think you've all been following what's coming out of Washington if you look at the high-speed rail issue.
    • 04:05:32
      A lot of transportation experts have been critical of FRA about their administration of the program.
    • 04:05:37
      They say it hasn't run real well.
    • 04:05:38
      As a result, you're seeing Congress actually looking to perhaps defund this program going forward.
    • 04:05:48
      So those states that jumped on this high-speed rail bandwagon back in 2009 are facing a very uncertain future.
    • 04:05:56
      Here in Virginia, thanks to the leadership of Governor McDonald, Secretary Connaughton, and I would say especially Director Drake, next year, next year you will have new passenger rail service to one of the largest, most vibrant regions of our state for the first time since the late 1970s.
    • 04:06:15
      And don't let anyone tell you that's not significant.
    • 04:06:18
      You can look at the pie-in-the-sky dreamers, but you're gonna have real people getting on real trains in downtown Norfolk and going to New York and Boston next year.
    • 04:06:27
      And I'd venture to say there's not another state out there that's gonna say that, and that's thanks to the work and the support of this board and the leadership of the governor, the secretary, and the director.
    • 04:06:39
      But today, I wanna talk about freight and the production and movement of goods
    • 04:06:44
      It drives our economy.
    • 04:06:45
      It creates jobs, but without multiple viable rail options, it can also make our highway commutes even more difficult than they already are.
    • 04:06:56
      Discussions about freight tend to get conceptual when people don't know what all this means, so let me just really boil it down.
    • 04:07:05
      We're talking about stuff.
    • 04:07:06
      It's stuff.
    • 04:07:07
      It's stuff we as Americans want
    • 04:07:10
      use and consume frequently.
    • 04:07:13
      Today the stuff that I'm going to be talking about primarily is consumer goods.
    • 04:07:18
      Big screen TVs, toilet paper,
    • 04:07:21
      Cat Toys, you name it.
    • 04:07:23
      Anything that you can buy at Target or Home Depot can and does move by rail.
    • 04:07:30
      But think about other things that are goods, that stuff that we need.
    • 04:07:36
      Kevin mentioned ethanol that we put into our filler tank up with every day.
    • 04:07:40
      You think about chemicals that are used to keep our drinking water clean, coal that's used to power your home or business, and even grain that's used to feed livestock that ultimately ends up on our kitchen table.
    • 04:07:52
      So this slide tells you one of our biggest challenges here is that people want stuff.
    • 04:07:58
      We all want it.
    • 04:07:59
      We all need it.
    • 04:08:00
      And more people is going to mean more stuff that has to move.
    • 04:08:05
      According to the Federal Railroad Administration National Rail Plan, each American requires 40 tons of stuff each year.
    • 04:08:14
      And if you look at Virginia's population growth over the next two decades, this equates to over 100 million more tons of stuff that will need to move to meet the needs of our citizens.
    • 04:08:26
      So the challenge here I see is to move these higher volumes while making sure that commutes get easier or at least don't get worse, the air gets cleaner or at least doesn't get worse, and the statewide infrastructure that we have supports
    • 04:08:43
      Growth and Competitiveness that's required here in the Commonwealth.
    • 04:08:48
      Our second challenge, more stuff is coming our way here to Virginia.
    • 04:08:54
      After the Panama Canal expansion is complete in 2014, you're gonna have ships that carry three times more cargo than they do today being able to move through that canal and call on East Coast ports, including Portsmouth.
    • 04:09:09
      As a result, the Virginia Port Authority
    • 04:09:11
      expects an immediate 20% boost in cargo at the ports of Virginia, and some maritime analysts predict that 25% of all cargo that currently calls West Coast ports will shift to the southeast.
    • 04:09:28
      And frankly, that's good news.
    • 04:09:30
      At CSX, we believe that the Virginia Port Authority is uniquely positioned to gain a large share of that increase, which means more revenue,
    • 04:09:39
      More economic development and more jobs.
    • 04:09:42
      But the challenge is, how do we move this stuff to market effectively, keeping the cost to consumers low and without overburdening our already congested highways?
    • 04:09:55
      The challenge number three, which I want to address here today, is from a rail perspective, Virginia is at a disadvantage to its east coast port competitors at this time, at least as it relates to CSX.
    • 04:10:09
      Virginia is served by two strong class one railroads.
    • 04:10:13
      But at CSX, we are still only single-stacked out to the Midwest United States, which is one of the largest domestic consumption markets in the country.
    • 04:10:22
      You can take a look at the map, and there's a big hole right there in the middle.
    • 04:10:26
      We run double-stack out of New York, we run double-stack out of Savannah, but not here out of Virginia.
    • 04:10:31
      Now we're the route double stacked.
    • 04:10:33
      We have that efficiency there.
    • 04:10:35
      We can move twice as much stuff on the existing number of trains, making the movement more efficient and alleviating the highway and rail congestion.
    • 04:10:45
      And I think from Virginia's perspective, the key here is securing more discretionary international cargo that's bound for the Midwest.
    • 04:10:54
      The railroads don't decide what ports the shipping companies call.
    • 04:10:58
      CSX customers will generally call the port that can most efficiently and cheaply run their freight to the Midwest.
    • 04:11:07
      And right now, that's not necessarily Virginia.
    • 04:11:10
      So to be truly competitive in the fast-growing international container market, double stack rail, and in this case, double stack redundant rail is key.
    • 04:11:22
      It's going to create competition among the railroads, and it's going to drive rail prices down.
    • 04:11:26
      So when it costs the same to move a container from Portsmouth, Virginia to Chicago as it does from New York to Chicago, that makes Virginia's ports much more competitive.
    • 04:11:38
      And that's where the National Gateway comes in.
    • 04:11:42
      So the solution is relatively straightforward.
    • 04:11:44
      Let's add Virginia to the CSX double stack network and create a win-win situation.
    • 04:11:49
      You'll see an outline here in purple of where we're filling in that hole that currently exists.
    • 04:11:55
      The National Gateway is going to accomplish this.
    • 04:11:58
      What we're looking to do is clear 61 overhead obstructions from here to our distribution center in northwest Ohio.
    • 04:12:05
      So by raising or removing old bridges and lowering track, we'll get the 21-foot clearance we need to ship two containers on top of each other for more efficient and cost-effective movements.
    • 04:12:18
      And additionally, we're going to build new and enhance existing terminals along the way, which will help create new markets for goods coming in to Virginia ports.
    • 04:12:31
      The end destination is our state-of-the-art intermodal facility in northwest Ohio, and it's going to serve as the hub of a hub-and-spoke freight distribution network that's going to reach, frankly, all across the country.
    • 04:12:43
      This terminal opened on February 23rd.
    • 04:12:46
      Director Drake was out visiting last April when it was still a work in progress, would I say.
    • 04:12:53
      And Mr. Specter, I think your counterpart from Ohio is going to be reaching out to you about a visit.
    • 04:12:57
      Governor Kasich was there recently and was so excited about this.
    • 04:13:01
      He said, who do I need to come out here to show this?
    • 04:13:05
      Because they're excited about the possibilities.
    • 04:13:08
      But the opening, even without the double of this terminal,
    • 04:13:12
      Even without the double stack clearance is paying dividends for Virginia in terms of increased service frequency and shorter transit times.
    • 04:13:20
      Now when the National Gateway is complete, Virginia's access to new markets is going to be nearly limitless and it's going to allow freight to bypass the choke point in Chicago so containers can quickly and efficiently be distributed to their final destination.
    • 04:13:36
      This is, I mean, it's an amazing facility in terms of efficiency and being environmentally friendly.
    • 04:13:42
      Everything from optical scanners at the gate to reduce truck idling time to efficient sodium light bulbs and even steel ties that are made from recycled material that can be recycled after the end of life.
    • 04:13:57
      So you can see why CSX is so excited about connecting here in Virginia to APM
    • 04:14:04
      The most technologically advanced marine terminal in North America and connecting it to our equally advanced intermodal facility in the Midwest.
    • 04:14:15
      So where are we on the National Gateway?
    • 04:14:20
      CSX and its state partners, as well as numerous other businesses and organizations, two of which are represented here today, the Hampton Roads TPO and the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance have been strong supporters of this project.
    • 04:14:34
      We're real pleased that last year we received $98 million in federal tiger discretionary grants, which has allowed us to begin the first phase of this project from the Northwest Ohio Terminal to another CSX Intermodal Terminal in Pennsylvania.
    • 04:14:49
      The projects that are underway are represented by the green dots on the map.
    • 04:14:54
      But to capture all the benefits inherent in this project, it's imperative that networks reach the mid-Atlantic ports, including Portsmouth.
    • 04:15:03
      So thanks to the assistance of the Commonwealth, public-private funding has been secured for the clearances along the I-95 corridor, which are represented by the yellow dots, as well as
    • 04:15:14
      a marshaling yard in Kilby which will help us build the trains and handle the increased traffic that's coming in.
    • 04:15:22
      The red dots on the map here unfortunately show the clearance projects that until today have not been funded which essentially leaves the Port of Virginia locked out of CSX's double stack network and leaving the challenges that we discussed earlier unanswered.
    • 04:15:38
      Before I get into the announcement I just want to point out these pictures again
    • 04:15:42
      Another place that Director Drake has been.
    • 04:15:44
      She tromps around our railroad quite a bit.
    • 04:15:46
      Pictures you see here are the Virginia Avenue Tunnel.
    • 04:15:49
      This is the biggest key to unlocking Virginia's access to CSX's double stack network.
    • 04:15:54
      A hundred year old tunnel, single stack, single track, running through Southwest D.C.
    • 04:16:01
      It's a major rail bottleneck identified by the Federal Railroad Administration as long ago as 1999 and the I-95 coalition has also identified as something that needs to be done.
    • 04:16:15
      Basically, that tunnel right there keeps Virginia out of the double stack network.
    • 04:16:21
      So today, just real, real excited to announce that CSX has committed an additional $160 million
    • 04:16:28
      of our own funds to clear the Virginia Avenue Tunnel and complete the network from the Port of Virginia to the Midwest.
    • 04:16:35
      So this increases our overall financial commitment to nearly $600 million of the project, $850 million total cost.
    • 04:16:43
      Money is one thing, but as we saw in the presentation from Mr. Pittard about the balance and the rail funds, when are you going to get started and start spending the money?
    • 04:16:53
      I also want to let you know that the official federal lead agency for this project has been determined.
    • 04:17:01
      The Federal Highway Administration will lead the NEPA process and will allow the project to get started much, much sooner than we had anticipated, even just six months ago.
    • 04:17:13
      So connecting the Port of Virginia to the CSX double stack network is commercial imperative for CSX.
    • 04:17:19
      That's why we're making this decision.
    • 04:17:20
      We don't just
    • 04:17:21
      Wake up one day and say we're going to spend $160 million more.
    • 04:17:25
      We strongly believe in the growth potential of your port, and we believe the National Gateway is going to provide substantial benefits in addressing the Commonwealth's transportation and economic development priorities.
    • 04:17:37
      And we thank you all for your partnership, commitment, and support.
    • 04:17:41
      And without it, today's announcement probably would not be
    • 04:17:45
      possible.
    • 04:17:46
      So this is what it looks like right now.
    • 04:17:48
      We're going to assume two-thirds of the cost of this project.
    • 04:17:52
      I think that's significant, as you know, in this time of limited public funding for transportation.
    • 04:17:58
      We as a company believe it's important to make these type of investments in infrastructure that improve our national freight network.
    • 04:18:05
      In fact, between now and 2015, CSX is going to put in, reinvest about 18 percent of its revenues into its infrastructure, which has benefits all down the line.
    • 04:18:18
      And by all measures, the public sector investment, the amount of money, including the 42 million that Virginia has put forth to this, is a good one.
    • 04:18:25
      For every public dollar invested in the National Gateway, $35 in public benefits are expected to be delivered.
    • 04:18:33
      And these are how these benefits break out.
    • 04:18:35
      Significant diversion of trucks from all of Virginia's highways.
    • 04:18:39
      You're going to see particularly 81, 95, and 64, but it'll be seen on all the highways.
    • 04:18:45
      We've determined that the freight growth is coming, and investing in the necessary rail infrastructure now is going to help alleviate the effect of the growth on our highways.
    • 04:18:55
      Additionally, greater use of rail is going to reduce the wear and tear on our highways, offsetting the need for additional highway maintenance funds.
    • 04:19:03
      Rail, of course, is one of the most environmentally friendly ways to move freight, so additional CO2 emissions are going to be avoided by this.
    • 04:19:12
      And of course, good paying construction jobs, which are much needed at this time, are an added bonus.
    • 04:19:17
      So I'm really proud to be able to share this announcement with you.
    • 04:19:21
      I want to thank you all at the Commonwealth for your support up to this point.
    • 04:19:25
      I think this development generated by the strong partnership between the Commonwealth and CSX will prove to benefit as we move forward.
    • 04:19:35
      So, Mr. Secretary, members of the board, thank you very much for your time and happy to take any questions.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:19:40
      Mr. Kendall, thank you very much.
    • 04:19:42
      It's outstanding.
    • 04:19:44
      The great partnership we've had with CSX over the years and also this announcement's a great
    • 04:19:50
      It's going to be a great project for Virginia.
    • 04:19:52
      It's really going to help out our port and our economy and also deal a lot with possession and trying to get great off of our roads in Virginia and up and down the 95 corridor.
    • 04:20:02
      So great news and appreciate all your work.
    • 04:20:04
      I don't know, Director Drake, did you want to say anything?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:06
      Well, first of all, thank you, Mr. Secretary, but thank you, Quintin, for being here today to make this announcement.
    • 04:20:11
      I know it's been announced nationally just this afternoon and you were here to do it in Virginia.
    • 04:20:16
      We're very glad to be a partner, and as Kevin said, this Virginia Avenue tunnel also is a choke point for our passenger service, so it's going to make a big difference all the way around.
    • 04:20:24
      Thank you.
    • 04:20:25
      We enjoy working with you.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:26
      Absolutely.
    • 04:20:26
      Well, thank you.
    • 04:20:27
      It's great to be here.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:28
      Any other questions or comments?
    • 04:20:31
      Kendall, thank you very much.
    • 04:20:33
      Thank you.
    • 04:20:33
      Great stuff.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:33
      Thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:20:38
      Next, we have Mr. Tyeryar.
    • 04:20:39
      He's going to go over the MPO performance measures.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 04:20:45
      Good afternoon again.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:20:54
      I want to talk to you a little bit about the regional performance
    • 04:21:15
      Measures required for the Metropolitan Planning Organizations and representatives from the five areas with the largest populations are here.
    • 04:21:27
      Rob Case, Dwight Farmer, and Camelia, I will not venture your last name, thank you, from Hampton Roads, Dan Lisi and Lee Yoltin from Richmond, David Lee and Andy Wapel from Fredericksburg.
    • 04:21:43
      Noelle Dominguez from NOVA and Joe Bench from Tri-Cities are all here and they've all been involved in this process for the last several months.
    • 04:21:52
      This is a legislatively required exercise on the part of the Office of Intermodal Planning and is required for the allocation of RSTP funds.
    • 04:22:02
      I'll talk to you a little bit about the coordination effort, the measures, what the MPOs have come up with and then our next steps.
    • 04:22:09
      This is the legislation itself.
    • 04:22:12
      Suppose to develop quantifiable and achievable goals pursuant to the code section in transportation and land use performance measures and then talk about and report back on an annual basis on the state of the regional efforts.
    • 04:22:27
      This is our first time in front of you with actually identifying the measures that we'll put in front of you that you'll have a resolution to adopt next month.
    • 04:22:38
      There you can see beginning in July 11,
    • 04:22:40
      To allocate regional RSTP funds in the urbanized areas, you have to have a set of performance measures.
    • 04:22:49
      This has been our process.
    • 04:22:51
      We've identified those five areas.
    • 04:22:52
      Roanoke is not involved, at least at this point.
    • 04:22:56
      We're still waiting on the results of the census data.
    • 04:22:59
      The cusp of the requirement is not my term.
    • 04:23:01
      That is a term that they use.
    • 04:23:03
      It provides, and I will talk to you about this in a few minutes, a matrix of performance measures based on statewide goals.
    • 04:23:10
      The VDOT goals from our annual performance, or all of transportation's goals from its annual performance report, put those out in the MPOs, started looking through those and choosing some for themselves, and then choosing some that were in addition to that.
    • 04:23:29
      We finalized these documents on several, it's been a very iterative process, but
    • 04:23:35
      The guidance on performance measures came to us in the Office of Intermental Planning in January.
    • 04:23:41
      We've been working with them ever since.
    • 04:23:43
      We actually started some of these conversations last fall before the transportation conference.
    • 04:23:50
      You can see what's going on there.
    • 04:23:51
      They've all had resolutions of adopting the measures and forwarding to them or in the case of Roanoke, actually sending a letter that says we're in the process but because we're not legally required, we're not going to adopt measures.
    • 04:24:02
      And you can look at those areas and that's been the topic of conversation.
    • 04:24:06
      Kevin Page talked about it.
    • 04:24:08
      CSX talked about it.
    • 04:24:09
      We talked about it this morning, this area of growth and identification of measures and transportation investments.
    • 04:24:18
      You see it starting in Northern Virginia coming down 95 to Richmond and then east towards Hampton Roads.
    • 04:24:24
      This is going to be much of our conversation over the coming months and the coming years.
    • 04:24:29
      These are the areas that the requirements
    • 04:24:31
      The legislation sets forth requirements to have measures in each of those.
    • 04:24:35
      As I go through the table, you'll see that some of these are more germane to certain areas than others.
    • 04:24:44
      Again, putting together the statewide performance report, we already had much of this data available.
    • 04:24:49
      There were a few gaps and identified their access to transit and pedestrian facilities and the percentage of freight moved by rail.
    • 04:24:57
      The MPOs have come up with some ways to address those gaps.
    • 04:25:01
      And as this process unfolded, this was an iterative process and Katherine Graham, who did a lot of this work for us, is here as well and was kind of our go-between between the Office of Intermodal Planning and the MPOs.
    • 04:25:15
      So the MPOs, as much as possible, have adopted the same set of measures so that A, the data tracking is easier, but B, we can start to identify funding that addresses the same set of measures.
    • 04:25:29
      And this is what it looks like in each of those categories identified by the law.
    • 04:25:32
      In congestion reduction across all five major areas, all five urban areas with populations greater than 200,000 you can see hours of delay and annuals of gallons of fuel off to congestion, unanimous across all areas.
    • 04:25:47
      In safety you can see vehicle miles traveled, transit crashes, and passenger miles traveled across all agencies.
    • 04:25:58
      Then when it gets to aviation, it gets a little bit more or a little less generic or a little less broad-based.
    • 04:26:04
      You can see that Hampton Roads, Fredericksburg, and Nova have that data.
    • 04:26:08
      The other areas do not.
    • 04:26:12
      In the area of transit uses, again, it's unanimous across all five areas.
    • 04:26:16
      Trips per capita, revenue miles, transit revenue miles, passenger miles traveled.
    • 04:26:23
      HOV usage, not so much.
    • 04:26:27
      64-95 corridor that we talked about a lot this morning.
    • 04:26:30
      You can see that all of those areas, all of those regions are concerned about HOV usage.
    • 04:26:35
      Richmond, Tri-Cities, not as concerned.
    • 04:26:38
      And again, you can see persons per hour, park and ride lots in spaces, and the occupied park and ride spaces per population.
    • 04:26:50
      And the jobs to housing ratio, a little bit more scattered.
    • 04:26:54
      Two of those measures are agreed to or agreed upon by all areas, and that's the households and the inter-regional commuting data.
    • 04:27:05
      The rest is a little bit more scattered, the ratio of jobs and the mean travel time to work.
    • 04:27:11
      Again, as we talked about this morning, the more dense the population, the more congestion.
    • 04:27:17
      You can see certain goals being important to certain areas, even though all five of those areas
    • 04:27:22
      Our metropolitan planning organization is greater than 200,000.
    • 04:27:26
      You can see the areas of concern to those areas.
    • 04:27:31
      The items of concern to those areas are not unanimous across all five.
    • 04:27:36
      Access to transit, number of households in the transportation zones and the number and the percent of employment served by transit, again, across all areas.
    • 04:27:48
      Jobs and housing access to pedestrian facilities, again,
    • 04:27:52
      Certain areas of the state it's important to, certain it is not.
    • 04:27:56
      In air quality, a much different approach.
    • 04:27:59
      Everyone seems to agree that the annual number of days when ozone levels are above eight is significant and they all have agreed to track that.
    • 04:28:08
      The others, greenhouse gas emissions, VOC, not as important to some areas or not as available.
    • 04:28:17
      Movement of freight, just talked about that.
    • 04:28:19
      Truck and rail modes share by value and by tons.
    • 04:28:22
      Important to everyone, percentage of freight transported by rail or barge.
    • 04:28:28
      One has to do with availability and the other has to do with need.
    • 04:28:32
      Again, if you're moving from Hampton Roads west and alleviating traffic on 64, moving freight by barge is important too.
    • 04:28:41
      And daily vehicle miles traveled per capita, that's available to everyone with that data we collect.
    • 04:28:47
      And then you can see on the next two slides that Richmond and Tri-Cities, because they're co-located, have a set of measures that are unique to them and they will introduce into the process instead of some of the ones that were agreed to by all others.
    • 04:29:00
      And then you can see that Hampton Roads, because of their unique position and some of the unique industries that are there and some of their unique problems, or I should say challenges, not problems, some of the unique challenges have agreed to track some measures that the others have not.
    • 04:29:17
      So that's where we are in terms of unanimity, for lack of a better term, on the measures.
    • 04:29:24
      I'll just scroll through them quickly again and give you some time to digest those.
    • 04:29:30
      Just to let you know, we'll bring you a resolution in June, and it's important that we get that resolution passed in June because these are supposed to be in place before we can allocate our STP funds for fiscal 12.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:47
      I understand this is in relation to MPOs and we're talking about 200,000 and we're to measure the performance of MPOs in those areas.
    • 04:29:59
      Is there a need and has there been thought or suggestions that those areas of the state that are not under an MPO need an evaluation as well and they're part of the total transportation program and planning in the state as well?
    • 04:30:18
      I just almost feel a disconnect on the area, a big section of the state that's left out, I guess, when we're measuring performances.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:30:25
      It's an interesting point.
    • 04:30:31
      This is a process that we undertook because it was required by the allocation of funds.
    • 04:30:35
      So you take the needs, the requirements of the funding stream, RSTP, and say, well, it impacts, it's allocated to metropolitan areas greater than 200,000, so what do we need to comply?
    • 04:30:47
      It was kind of a back to the front approach and I understand what you're saying about moving the other direction and I think we will get to some of that based on this morning's conversation as we start to talk about the hierarchy of challenges or the hierarchy of things that we will address on a statewide basis as we look at the corridors.
    • 04:31:12
      I think that some of those performance measures
    • 04:31:16
      will come into play across the state.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:20
      That was really the point of the question and the next question is going to be is this to replace the funding formulas that we have in the state of Virginia and if we are going to replace these funding formulas there's certain sections and segments are not represented in these types of measures that need to be represented if we're going to look at that.
    • 04:31:39
      And you know that seems to be the trend and where things are leading because there's certain
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:31:45
      I don't know that I agree with what you're saying, but I'm not so sure it's as much about people who have and people who haven't as making sure that we have the right data before we make allocations on the scarce resources that we have.
    • 04:32:14
      have spent a great deal of time in your part of the state in the last eight months, and I understand the issues there.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:32:22
      Any other questions for Mr. Koelemay?
    • 04:32:24
      Mr. Secretary, the reference to an area that's on the cusp of the requirement, in this case is Roanoke, does that mean that as people cross the threshold they participate, or does it mean that we might begin to lower the threshold as we gain more experience with the larger units?
    • 04:32:43
      to get at the problem that Mr.
    • 04:32:45
      Keen talked about.
    • 04:32:46
      In other words, we've got a set of criteria.
    • 04:32:49
      We're beginning to use common data.
    • 04:32:54
      A smaller area wouldn't have the same types of data, for example, a transit program, but they would have some of the others.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:33:03
      The way we've interpreted this thus far is we would wait on metropolitan planning organizations to break the threshold of 200,000.
    • 04:33:11
      We wouldn't dilute the requirements of the legislation.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:16
      Mr. McCarthy?
    • 04:33:18
      So you're proposing that we would adopt these performance measures, is that right, next one?
    • 04:33:26
      Yes.
    • 04:33:27
      Okay, so how does, where are you in developing quantifiable and achievable goals?
    • 04:33:35
      What's that all about?
    • 04:33:36
      I understand the performance measures, but where are the goals for it?
    • 04:33:39
      What are the performance measures
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:33:42
      Well, we have the data of the baseline, so we know in each of these goal areas from the work that we've already done how much, where we are.
    • 04:33:55
      So then we would have to go back to the MPOs and talk about how incrementally we move.
    • 04:34:02
      Now, to get funding, it's not a requirement.
    • 04:34:04
      It's only a requirement that these measures be in place.
    • 04:34:07
      To allocate RSTP funds, there is no requirement that the MPOs actually
    • 04:34:12
      Well, now, but help me out here, because if you're quoting this legislation, all I can do is read what you're giving it.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:34:31
      It says to develop quantifiable and achievable goals.
    • 04:34:36
      So who's going to do that?
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:34:38
      We are going to work with the MPOs to do that.
    • 04:34:40
      We are already in the process of identifying the set of goals, but that's the extent.
    • 04:34:47
      I mean, that's important for everyone to understand that we're going to meet with the MPOs and we're going to talk about objectives or strict objectives as you may prefer to call them.
    • 04:34:56
      But there's nothing in the law that says we come back here next April in the process of putting together the six-year plan.
    • 04:35:02
      And because Area A didn't meet their goals, there's no carrot and stick like that with funding.
    • 04:35:09
      This is develop them, see what we can do to achieve them, and report back on an annual basis.
    • 04:35:19
      And there's a requirement to track them, and there's a requirement to set goals, and there is a requirement to report back.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 04:35:24
      David, I just want to make sure I'm clear that the participating MPOs in conjunction with your office developed and agreed on these standards of performance.
    • 04:35:45
      I see these are what we want to be judged by.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:47
      Is that correct?
    • 04:35:51
      Yes.
    • 04:35:51
      Mr. Ellis.
    • 04:35:52
      Yes.
    • 04:35:52
      You're going to have that ready for us.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 04:35:54
      I'm going to have a resolution to say that this set of measures is that piece of information that puts us in compliance with the law.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:07
      This process has been about eight months getting us to here, so I would say another
    • 04:36:25
      Two to four?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:27
      I just want to throw it out to his colleagues who wouldn't expect something else.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:33
      How agreeable everybody is.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:36
      Anyone else?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:37
      Excellent.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:40
      Okay.