Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 2/16/2011
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
2/16/2011
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Bids.pdf
Fiscal Year 2011 budget _ Actual performance through January 2011.pdf
Development of the Fiscal Years 2012 - 17 Six-Year Improvement Program.pdf
Disposing of surplus property.pdf
VDOT 2011 legislation update.pdf
1. VDOT’s Financial Status Update
2. Commonwealth of Virginia, Transportation Performance Trend Report – 2009
2009 performance report.pdf
3. Enhancement Program FY 2012 Application Update
Transportation Enhancement Program Fiscal Year 2012 application update.pdf
4. Kick-off of the Six Year Program
5. Revenue Generated by Disposal of VDOT Property
6. Legislative Update
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:04
Good morning, everyone.
00:00:05
I'd like to welcome you to the February meeting of the Transportation Board.
00:00:12
I'd like to first start by if we can ask everyone to please stand and we'll say the Pledge of Allegiance.
00:00:21
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
00:00:41
Thank you very much.
00:00:42
We'll go right into the agenda.
00:00:45
We have our workshop, and the first is VDOT's financial status.
00:00:49
Mr. Lawson, come on up.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:00:51
All right, I'll spend a few minutes with you this morning just walking you through kind of where we are in terms of our physical performance so far this year.
00:01:20
Looking at activity through January, on the positive note, our state revenue picture is improving.
00:01:28
As we look at the total state revenue collections in the Commonwealth Transportation Fund through January, revenues are up about nearly 5%.
00:01:37
Motor fuel tax collections up a little over 2% compared to last year this time.
00:01:45
While that's definitely an improvement, it's still trailing
00:01:48
The 3% that the forecast is expecting in terms of end of the year, obviously the spring, summer months are the better performers in terms of motor fuels collections.
00:01:59
Motor vehicle sales and use taxes are surprising us.
00:02:03
We're looking at collections there up about almost 13% from a year ago, which is exceeding our forecast, the state forecast of about 7%.
00:02:15
While that sounds great,
00:02:17
When you put it in perspective, though, we're still at about 2,002 levels in terms of motor vehicle sales.
00:02:26
Looking at the state retail sales and use tax, we're up about 2 percent compared to last year when you take into account the transfers and the appropriation act related to that source.
00:02:40
To meet, while everything is looking up and looking better, to meet the revenue forecast, though, for the
00:02:47
For the Ranger of the Year, we're going to have to see a stronger second half than we have first half.
00:02:55
This chart just gives you a picture by the main revenue sources.
00:03:01
This is actually as it's reported by Department of Accounts for the Commonwealth Transportation Fund.
00:03:07
You'll notice the third line, motor vehicle sales tax.
00:03:09
You can see how that is a performing forecast at this point.
00:03:14
On the fifth line, the motor vehicle sales.
00:03:16
And I also want to point out the recordation taxes.
00:03:19
Line 7 is also doing a little better than anticipated at this point in time.
00:03:28
Federal revenues as you know are based, federal revenue collections are based on actual work that we are performing.
00:03:35
It's not a grant program, it's based on expenditure activity and with expenditure activity up
00:03:41
We're also seeing an increased level in our federal revenues, about almost $124 million ahead of where we were last year.
00:03:49
And you can see from the chart on the bottom of the slide there that the two real increases areas there are in the construction arena and in the auto spending.
00:04:06
This chart just gives you that kind of a picture from a
00:04:11
An illustrative picture, when you look at the Highway Maintenance and Operating Fund, the Transportation Trust Fund, and the Federal Fund, all three of the major groups there are performing in terms of revenue collections ahead of where they were last year, about a 7% increase in total there, at this $1.9 billion that we've collected so far this year.
00:04:34
Turning to expenditures for activity,
00:04:38
Our expenditure activity for 2011 is continuing to outpace fiscal year 2010.
00:04:45
This is a good thing and it reflects our efforts that we have put into place to get more contracts on the street and to better utilize the funding provided to the programs.
00:04:59
You'll see here that
00:05:01
We are at $160 million ahead of last year.
00:05:04
This does represent only about 48%, however, of our operating budget.
00:05:11
We still are trailing somewhat in catching up with our activities within the maintenance arena and some of those other programs.
00:05:19
I'll speak more to that in just a little bit.
00:05:23
Important to note here that of the total spending, about 70% of the total spending
00:05:28
is just on our pure maintenance and construction programs.
00:05:34
This gives you an illustration, a graphic illustration of the spending by program.
00:05:40
And you can see clearly on this, the top one, the maintenance program, spending is definitely ahead of where it was last year.
00:05:47
Construction is pretty consistent.
00:05:50
I also see that ARRA is up, and I want to also point out that the administrative program there in the center of the page is actually down.
00:05:58
were reflective of our reduced workforce.
00:06:05
And this is just a more detailed view of the spending by program.
00:06:10
I won't get into the specifics here, but it does kind of just highlight to you how our spending of $2 billion, just over $2 billion is comparing to just shy of $1.9 billion last year.
00:06:28
I thought I would give you a little different picture on our spending this month to kind of show you where spending is actually occurring and how we are paying for our, where the dollars are going.
00:06:40
We talk about what we spend.
00:06:42
When you look at spending through January, about 76 percent of our spending is actually related to vendor payments or payments to localities.
00:06:54
The remaining
00:06:55
26% is really VDOT labor and debt service payments.
00:07:05
Important to note here, personal services expenditures are only about 15% of our total.
00:07:11
And you can see on this chart is a comparative chart of spending by category between this year and last year.
00:07:18
And you can see how the personal services cost has dropped
00:07:23
from about 18% to about 15%.
00:07:26
That's reflecting our staffing position of about 8,300 a year ago to a current position of about 6,900.
00:07:34
We also note that the very first bar on this chart that the plant improvements which is our main contract expenditure work for maintenance construction is up from last year.
00:07:54
Looking a little more specifically at the maintenance program, we are spending greater, have greater spending in the maintenance arena this year than we did last year.
00:08:06
We're up, spending is up about 15% from about $100 million from 644 to 742.
00:08:14
Most of that spending is in the, in our state funded program and you can see in the chart below
00:08:21
Most of all of the maintenance programs, interstate, primary, secondary, and operations, are seeing an increased spending activity.
00:08:31
Some of that is due to snow activity, I'll talk about in a moment, but also important to note that the program management and direction area has gone down.
00:08:40
Again, more reflective of staffing reductions and a greater focus of the funding on core program work.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:08:50
Mr. Chairman, it's a good time to ask a question on a point of interest here is while it's good to talk about and it's positive, I think we've reduced that area because we now have fewer people and that makes up a smaller percentage of the expenditures.
00:09:12
I guess the question is this.
00:09:15
Is it always a good thing, and is it a good thing in this particular case, since we've reduced staff, do we know the impact on our ability to prepare projects, have them ready to go to bid, and do we have the right people in place that impacts our overall program?
00:09:34
And project development, installation, and having things ready is a very important aspect of it.
00:09:40
So I wonder because I hear some of the things in the districts about staffing changes as a result of the footprint and these people are not in place to do this type of work.
00:09:51
Do we know that?
00:09:53
Is there an effort to get an analysis of that?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:57
Mr. Chairman?
00:09:58
Yes, Mr. Corey.
00:09:59
I think that we have the resources to get the work done, projects out, but it's going to be a combination of using in-house staff and
00:10:10
and probably increase use of consultants to get all of our projects ready.
00:10:15
There are some of the processes that we have in place are going to need to be tweaked because some of them are not as efficient as they need to be.
00:10:24
We're still going through that process.
00:10:28
But in terms of having the resources to get the contracts out, I think between the combination of existing staff and consultants, increased use of consultants, we will be able to get the projects out.
00:10:41
The next issue then leads to the question of whether that's the most efficient way to do it by using the consultants.
00:10:52
And that's what we will have to be continuing to do some analysis of those areas.
00:10:57
To determine the most effective way to get those done.
00:11:01
At this point, I have to deal with the hand that I have, but then as we go along and start moving projects, we're going to have to go and analyze our delivery of those projects.
00:11:14
Are we doing the most efficient way?
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:16
Mr. Chairman?
00:11:17
Yes.
00:11:18
I guess that's a point.
00:11:19
It's really not, if you look at personal services reduction, it's really not a trigger reduction.
00:11:25
Yes, I mean, clearly your staffing is a balancing act, as the commissioner once pointed out there.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:11:47
We are all looking at, you know, our current staffing structures and how they blend with their program.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:55
Mr. Chairman, has the combined percentage of personal services plus contractual services remained fairly constant?
00:12:05
It looks like it's about 30% of the budget.
00:12:09
In other words, are you making those adjustments within the overall 30% range, or is that percentage going up or down?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:12:19
Well, you're looking at just a total of those two.
00:12:22
There's still an increase this year on the
00:12:25
on the contractual side.
00:12:28
So while we're only down about three percentage points or so in personal services, I think that 76% number I mentioned in total was down around 70% previously, and I can get you more specific there, but we are seeing an increase.
00:12:44
It's not just a pure shift.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:46
Mr. Chairman, since we exceeded our anti-icing and snow removal budget already by 21 million, do we have a rough projection of what we think it might be before the end of the year?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:13:02
You just got ahead of me here.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:04
Oh, I'm sorry.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:13:06
No, sir.
00:13:06
Mr. Chairman, at this point, we're hoping for lots of weather like today, and as we look forward to the rest of the winter,
00:13:15
Can you guarantee that, Mr. Lawson?
00:13:18
I said hoping.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:19
Hopefully.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:13:21
No, I can't control the weather, unfortunately.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:27
Before you go to Dr. Davis's question, could you go back to your chart?
00:13:31
Yes, sir.
00:13:33
Okay.
00:13:33
All right.
00:13:34
We use so many different terms.
00:13:37
It's everything.
00:13:37
Our allocations, we've gone out to bid.
00:13:44
Here we're saying expenditures.
00:13:46
So explain to us what this chart really is.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:13:49
Okay.
00:13:50
What this chart is showing you, the allocations are the budget.
00:13:55
That is what has been provided to those areas in terms of what they are authorized to spend this year.
00:14:02
So maintenance has a current budget of $1.9 billion, which includes the unspent balance from last year.
00:14:09
The expenditure column is what has physically been expended
00:14:14
This year, checks written, payments made.
00:14:18
So we've expended, actually paid out the door, $742 million worth of expenditure activity.
00:14:25
So the difference between the two is what's remaining to be spent.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:31
But could you do me a favor in the future reports on this chart, could you just show us then what is under contract?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:14:42
Certainly.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:44
Okay.
00:14:44
Because that's the key, particularly when you come to the maintenance.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:14:48
Right.
00:14:49
And we'll get to the later graphic in here that shows the contractual commitments related to the program.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:57
Yeah.
00:14:57
Because, I mean, you all have kind of beaten me into submission and understanding about the whole issue on allocations, advertising, what's going out for advertising.
00:15:09
and then what's actually under contract versus then what's under what we've actually expected.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:16
So what this really...
00:15:17
I'm trying to hear what you're asking.
00:15:20
The expenditures to date then does not include contracting or does include contracting?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:24
No, well, the issue here is just, so even though it says we've only expended 26.5%, what is important, maybe even more important due to the fact
00:15:36
is how much we actually have under contract that will actually start next month or whatever.
00:15:43
It's the, I mean, you have to look at all, in my mind, you have to look at them all as part of, to get a clear picture about where we are because we've, obviously by, just in December, you all put out like 400 million, 500, 600?
00:16:01
So we put out four or 500 million in contracts
00:16:06
Actually went out to advertisement with four or five hundred, meaning that they're now putting, they're going to actually have them under contract January, February, and then the work will actually begin in the springtime, and then the expenditure levels will shoot right up until June 30th, and then we'll go right back down again when the new pot of money comes in.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:16:30
We would expect to see expenditure activity, I just mentioned starting up,
00:16:35
and probably the April time period and be heavy through November really as you go through the whole summer construction maintenance season.
00:16:45
Looking ahead as you kind of add spending of that 1.9 billion funding amount, the budget, we are looking based on current projections to end the year with an allocation or a budget balance of about 450 million.
00:17:03
Still higher than we want it to be, ended last year at 530, but it is coming down.
00:17:10
And as we are really seeing the benefit of these contracts that are going out, when we look a year further down the road to the end of fiscal 12, June 30, 2012, we're expecting that balance to be down more in the neighborhood of $150 million.
00:17:25
So we're...
00:17:26
But we should be getting to... We're getting there, absolutely.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:30
So just to get a clear picture, Dr. Davis, I think the issue here is this relates to the board understands that the expended number is really just number, I must hate to say it, looking back as to how much we spent versus how much we're about to spend in a month or two ahead.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:17:51
Absolutely.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:52
And that's what we need to see.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:17:59
And again, just a little more detail on the maintenance.
00:18:02
And I'll get to your point here.
00:18:04
We did spend about $200 million so far this year in paving.
00:18:08
We are expecting to expend about $480 million in paving by the end of June.
00:18:15
So we do have a significant amount of paving yet to be done this fiscal year.
00:18:22
Snow removal, as we mentioned, we are
00:18:24
have exceeded our budget in terms of snow removal.
00:18:28
That additional amount we feel that we can cover out of existing reserves or existing contract balances.
00:18:38
In terms of the remainder of the year, again, we're just hopeful that the weather will be good and snow will be small.
00:18:46
I don't know whether Ms. Sorrell is in the room.
00:18:49
She can forecast that we might spend the remainder of the year, but I have not at this point seen a
00:18:55
A projection of what that may be.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:58
Well, Mr. Chairman, because last year there was $100 million of additional expenses, wasn't there?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:19:02
Well, last year's, the big snow activity last year was in the month of February.
00:19:08
And into March.
00:19:16
Turning to the construction program, just kind of a similar look at what's happening there.
00:19:24
We are seeing construction spending is actually slightly less than it was last year, about one and a half percent.
00:19:34
You'll note that expenditures in construction are heavily within the interstate area and we're also seeing the results of the shifts from the formula program to the more
00:19:52
primary-secondary focus to dedicated programs, as you've noticed the spending reductions in secondary and urban really as you compare the years.
00:20:07
Kind of looking at it based on what we're doing in terms of construction, in terms of whether it's preliminary engineering right of way or construction, I want to point out that our
00:20:19
PE work is basically flat with last year and as we pointed out preliminary engineering is key to getting designs on the shelf and having projects ready to move and this is an area that we're looking to focus on and to increase as we move forward to try to accelerate the program and make sure we have projects to support a future program.
00:20:49
In terms of other programmatic areas, I mentioned earlier that the R program, the stimulus projects is more than double in spending than last year as we are well into that program now.
00:21:04
We spent about $180 million in total on the R projects between the two years.
00:21:10
Looking at the administrative area,
00:21:12
How much borrow money do we have?
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:26
How long?
00:21:36
We're about out of our money.
00:21:38
How many years do we get it?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:40
6.99.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:21:40
6.94 was the total that we received and we have through 2015 to spend it.
00:21:49
Alright.
SPEAKER_04
00:21:51
So we're about 230 into it?
00:21:54
About 180 in total.
00:21:55
Alright.
00:21:55
Thank you.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:22:02
This graphic gets to the contracting component that we were kind of speaking to a little bit earlier.
00:22:10
The chart here may be a little busy, but what it's illustrating is the total contract value, and these are our regular normal bid-bill projects where we have advertised contracts in the construction arena of about
00:22:31
A billion-four that's on the street.
00:22:34
We have an outstanding or unspent balance on them of about $800 million.
00:22:40
We have about $500 million worth of maintenance contracts that have been awarded on the street, of which about $300 million or so is remaining unspent on those contracts.
00:22:54
And you can see where, as we've been talking about the efforts here, how that balance has risen significantly
00:23:01
And consistently since August, as we've been advertising and getting these contracts out, and as you can see with the climb and the unspent balances, they're rising as the contracts are going out and then pending the work that we get going in the spring and summer months.
00:23:20
I do want to note that this does not include
00:23:24
Just to give you kind of a look at where we are in terms of cash, I decided to give you a comparison to where we were at the beginning of the year to where we are today.
00:23:55
Highway Maintenance and Operating Fund, which is one of our main two funds, is actually down about $40 million from the beginning of the year.
00:24:04
If you come down to the middle of the page, your other main operating fund is the construction fund you see listed there under the Transportation Trust Fund.
00:24:13
It's also reflecting a reduction of about $55 million since the beginning of the year.
00:24:19
And then the other big difference you'll notice is the very bottom line.
00:24:24
The CPR Bonds, where we are expending the bond proceeds that we received in May from the bond sale.
00:24:32
We do expect to fully utilize the remaining amount of bond funds you see, that $57 million before our next sale that's scheduled in May.
00:24:48
Looking down the road in terms of cash, we do think based on
00:24:54
Our existing revenue forecast and the projected spending that we will probably end the year in highway maintenance and operating funds with a balance around $500 million.
00:25:03
Again, part of that is about $40 million of that is due to an increased revenue forecast that was just done in December.
00:25:15
Those funds won't be budgeted and included in your program allocations until 12, so that's an increase in just pure cash
00:25:23
Not planning to spend until next year.
00:25:26
It also reflects the spending startup that we talked about in terms of the maintenance program and getting the contract work moving there.
00:25:37
Construction activity does look like it will bring down the construction balance by about 120 million from the beginning of the year.
00:25:49
Just to kind of wrap things up, it does
00:25:54
As you can see from the activity here, we are starting to see the effects of the increased contract work that we've been doing, trying to get things on the street.
00:26:05
We are definitely expecting to see the results of that to heighten as we move into the spring and summer months.
00:26:13
Again, the amount of activity that we have
00:26:17
Now that we have the contracts on the street, it's going to become very dependent upon how quickly the industry decides to ramp up and how aggressively they address these or spin down on these contracts.
00:26:31
As we talked, the winter weather has been a little more costly than planned, but hopefully good weather will minimize that as we go forward.
00:26:41
And as we've committed to you, we'll continue to closely monitor
00:26:47
revenue and expenditure activity, and I'll be back next month to give you another update.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:53
Any questions, Mr. Lawson?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:55
Yes.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:56
Mr. Lawson, if you look at the revenues on page three and four, you add them up, it's about $3 billion.
00:27:03
I know you need to add bond proceeds to that.
00:27:04
My recollection is our total budget is about $3.5 billion in revenue collection.
00:27:09
We're planning to spend $4.2 billion this year.
00:27:12
Is that taking reserves down, what that difference is?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:27:16
Yeah, the difference between the three and a half roughly and the four billion is largely the carryovers from prior year balances.
00:27:22
As I said, we brought over $500 million last year from the maintenance program.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:28
As follow-up to that, you pointed out we've done 37% of expenditures to date on maintenance.
00:27:35
And I know you talked about paving, but our budget is about 50%.
00:27:40
So, I mean, my question is, we got a lot, I was just paving the main difference, are there other maintenance projects that have been weather-related to have to start?
00:27:47
Because we've got a lot of the construction, even though it's 25% of our budget, like, the biggest part we're behind on.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:56
Yeah, I, Mr. Chairman, I think that, as John indicated,
00:28:01
We will start seeing some ramp up in the expenditures in about March through June.
00:28:10
We'll see some of those balances coming down, but it's going to take us a while to get our balance.
00:28:17
We're expecting to have a budget balance on the table of about $450 million by the end of June 30, 2011.
00:28:26
Now that's down from, as John indicated, down from 0530 or 530.
00:28:33
But in 012 we're expecting that to be down to the 100 million range.
00:28:38
And it's going to take time for all these contracts to start kicking in.
00:28:43
So I think we'll be okay, but it's, as I mentioned, it's going to be probably to June 30, 2012 before we get it to where we want it.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:57
Mr. Lawson, the figures you've given us are, you have some month-to-month, some year-to-date, so forth.
00:29:07
How does that translate given that our time horizons go beyond annual budgets to six-year plans?
00:29:13
Do these figures feed into a process whereby the six-year plan itself is adjusted based on increased revenues, increased levels of activity, or is this really just a separate accounting
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:29:28
Now the six-year plan that you refer to is the basis of our budgeting process, and the current year budget is just year one off of that six-year plan.
00:29:42
So the revenue forecast that I speak to you here is just the first year of that forecast.
00:29:48
So when we do look at the six-year program, it is reflective of the revenues
00:29:57
The same revenue forecast that this is based on.
00:29:59
So the December revenue forecast that I mentioned earlier that's reflected here is also a driver when we look at the revenues for the Six-Year Improvement Program.
00:30:12
And we are looking at an increased revenue of 75 to 100 million a year in total as we look at the increased revenues as the economy is starting to, and it's expected to rise over the six-year period.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:25
So the changes that may be suggested by these figures is fed in to that six-year program adjustment.
00:30:33
For example, we'll start public hearings in the spring.
00:30:36
Yes, sir.
00:30:36
And so it's fed in into that cycle.
00:30:39
Yes, absolutely.
00:30:39
But it's not adjusted month to month.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:30:40
Correct.
00:30:41
Unless we do a revised budget during the course of a year, it's an annual update.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:48
Mr. Chairman, this is Dr. Davis.
00:30:49
From the administrative point of view,
00:30:53
What is a reasonable balance that ought to be left at the end of the year as opposed to where we are?
00:31:02
It would seem to me that the number should be much lower.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:07
Mr. Chairman, that number should be substantially lower and we were, I had a chart
00:31:17
That showed at one point we were down there's only about 16 million left on the table in the Makers area.
00:31:25
That was running pretty close.
00:31:28
And I would rather to, I mean I hate to use the number, but 75 million, that gives you a little bit more wiggle room.
00:31:38
So I would say that would be a target.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:42
So we have a long ways to go then.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:43
We have a long ways to go.
00:31:46
We knew that starting off, but I think we got the plan in motion now.
00:31:51
We've issued about 400 and 450 million of contracts this year with those to be let in maybe February.
00:32:02
We'll probably have all those contracts signed maybe this month.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:06
It's not an unfair question.
00:32:11
What is our greatest impediment, in your opinion, to getting that money obligated by contract?
00:32:19
Is it fast?
00:32:21
Because we have projects identified in the Six-Year Plan.
00:32:25
I'm just curious.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:29
I think we were a bit conservative in letting out some of those contracts.
00:32:37
We were going through a period of our revenues were falling and we didn't know how far they would fall.
00:32:44
And we were taking an educated guess.
00:32:50
And so we may have been a bit conservative when you guessed Monday morning quarterback, you kind of looked back and you said based upon what happened, maybe I should have not been as conservative.
00:33:03
But once we made that decision to slow down things, it really slowed it down.
00:33:08
Now we've got to try to figure out how to ramp them up.
00:33:11
I believe that what we've done in issuing 450 million in contracts to be signed probably in February, I think it's going to jumpstart it.
00:33:22
We're going to do the same thing, another 450 next maintenance cycle for contracts.
00:33:29
That's pretty much double what we normally would do in any year.
00:33:33
Now, in the 2013 year, you'll probably see our contracts leveling back down.
00:33:39
We could now have to maintain.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:44
Mr. Trevor?
00:33:45
Yes.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:46
I got confused on something earlier.
00:33:49
When I was looking at page 3 and 4, going back to Mr. Lane's question, I see $2.37 billion in
00:33:59
Highway Maintenance and Operating on 3, and then 615 Chain on 4, which would total about $3 billion.
00:34:07
I thought he said $3.5.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:11
Bonds and other things need to be added.
00:34:15
Our total is $3.5, and this doesn't include the bond issuance.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:21
Correct, correct.
00:34:22
So this doesn't show the bond revenue money.
00:34:26
It only shows the Federal and the Highway operating server.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:34:29
What I've illustrated here are the main sources, the state revenues and then the federal revenues.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:35
Okay, so you've got to add $500 million to that.
00:34:40
Is that correct?
00:34:42
In bonds?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:34:43
You have to add, well the bonds, it was about $300 million, I think is what the bond component was.
00:34:49
But you also have to, a difference here, I have to point out, on the revenue side, on the federal revenue,
00:34:56
This federal revenue is based on, I'm showing you what we've collected, not what was budgeted.
00:35:04
Federal revenue is a little confusing in that we budget it based on when it's made available to us by the federal government.
00:35:12
What you see here in terms of a collection is based on what we've actually received in terms of activity that's been incurred because it's a reimbursement-based program.
00:35:23
So you really can't add those two values together to come to a total.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:29
I guess what I'm trying to get to is a snapshot that ties these numbers to what the declining balance is.
00:35:38
And I can't do that with what I have here, I don't believe.
00:35:42
I'm looking to tie these numbers in specific that you've given us to how much we will be down in our balance.
00:35:51
I looked at it earlier, I couldn't really get there.
00:35:56
I didn't have the $300 million.
00:35:57
Now it's $3.3 million and we're spending $4.2 million, so I would expect the balance to come down by $900 million.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:11
You're right, Chef.
00:36:12
We're not going to be $500 million.
00:36:15
We're not going to get to the $4.2 million.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:36:19
I'll work on a better illustration for you.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:23
That's sort of the issue and as I see, I'm sensitive and understand that we're sort of like a locomotive here.
00:36:36
I mean you can't just get going 90 miles an hour all of a sudden.
00:36:40
It takes a while to get up to speed and have that happen.
00:36:43
and the Chairman has been clear to us that there's a lot of stuff in the contracts, which would be helpful to sort of see that along the same time because that shows that momentum's gathering and we're going to get there.
00:36:58
But obviously what we're sort of trying to get at is when's that going to be, how fast do we chip away at that and I know you're still working to get there, I understand that but that's what I'm looking for and I can't get that.
00:37:11
Okay, I'll work on that for you.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:13
One thing I think would be helpful in this is if we get the same presentation each time so that we can track it.
00:37:22
And I would ask that part of that be back to the budget.
00:37:26
In other words, we start with a budget, it would be nice to see every time when we get it how we can relate back to it.
00:37:32
So if we could do that, I think that would be appreciated.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:34
And the budget is changing, but we don't really see that change.
00:37:41
Well, because the federal revenues are...
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:46
Right.
00:37:47
But that would be helpful, I think, and so we're all speaking from the same seat of music.
00:37:52
Mr. Rich?
00:37:53
Okay.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:53
At what point do we get in revenues where we go back to the statutory formulas and allocations?
00:38:00
What point do we have to reach where we have some sense of normalcy, so to speak?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:38:08
That's a complicated question to answer.
00:38:12
Because it's a combination of levels of revenue as well as levels of funding, excuse me, programmatic levels.
00:38:19
So as the needs of the Holly Maintenance and Operating Fund, the maintenance program per se, as it grows, revenue has to grow in order to help address that.
00:38:32
As we look down the road for the next through 17, as we begin to work on the next forecast or in the next six-year improvement program,
00:38:41
Revenues never reach the point that we do have anything available to go through that statutory formula.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:49
Well, no time in the foreseeable future.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:38:51
No, sir.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:52
Mr. Chairman, I think a follow-up on Mr. Rich's question is could we get
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:00
The hierarchy that makes that decision on that formula implementation, could we get a definition of the model and explanation of the model that's used for, you know, we're going to be really in trouble on the secondary side not having any monies out there.
00:39:20
It would be good to have a little understanding of that if it will ever come back or what's going to trigger it.
00:39:27
That would be helpful to me.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:39:29
Okay, yeah, we go back to that graphic illustration that I think we distributed a few months ago that kind of shows how everything flows through.
00:39:36
It kind of graphically shows you where it stops and how that process works, but I can redistribute that to the group.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:46
Mr.
00:39:46
Chair?
00:39:46
Yes.
00:39:50
Looking at it from the federal side of things, we're a donor state.
00:39:55
What is it, 94% of the revenue has come back into Commonwealth?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:39:59
92.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:00
What 92% come back in?
00:40:02
What is, with that 8%, what does that represent on an annual basis?
00:40:06
In other words, instead of how we're dividing up the pie that we get, if we ended up not being a donor.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:40:11
It's 8%.
00:40:11
We're getting about, we get about a billion dollars, so.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:15
The 8% would be 80 million a year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:22
Okay.
00:40:22
Thank you.
00:40:23
Okay.
00:40:23
This is Lawson.
00:40:23
Actually, just one last question.
00:40:24
Sorry.
00:40:26
You're showing the maintenance dollars.
00:40:29
You're comparing 2010, 2011.
00:40:32
How do we ever look back further than that?
00:40:45
At what point does let's say a contract that we may have awarded or maybe allocated money towards in 2009, does that ever become a 2010 or a 2011 project?
00:41:00
I mean how do we, you see what I'm saying?
00:41:04
I mean so like last year when let's just say you go back to the audit we had
00:41:09
$525 million worth of unexpended dollars on June 30th.
00:41:17
Now my assumption is a certain percentage of that was probably some fiscal year 2009 project.
00:41:24
So when we're looking at expenditures, we're looking at actual money out the door no matter what year the contract was, money was allocated or ordered.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:41:39
That the $1.9 billion total that I mentioned for maintenance is a combination of this year's funding plus anything that's carried forward from the prior years and then therefore the spending that you're reporting is reflective of the expenditures of any activity.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:57
So going back to my question before about where we can show allocations, advertisements, contracts, we need to have a separate slide because actually then that, I don't want to put it actually with expenditures versus where we are expenditures because actually that's a little bit of...
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:19
It's a little misrepresented, right?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:22
No?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:22
You see what I'm saying?
00:42:23
Yeah.
00:42:24
We will work on a schedule.
00:42:27
to show some of the previous commitments or encumbrances that we have from previous years.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:36
Yeah, because I mean, a construction contract, I mean, it's overhead, zero in a year, you know, it's year by year.
00:42:45
Construction is tied to a project, so you can, you expect it to be multi-year.
00:42:50
The problem with maintenance, I think, is where
00:42:53
and the entire administration kind of got screwed up in how they were looking at things is that you can't treat them like a construction project.
00:43:00
So they were at least allocating money, maybe even awarding contracts or maybe never actually expending the money.
00:43:11
So on the paper it looked like they were, the money had actually gone out the door when in reality it had not come out.
00:43:18
My issue now is I want to make sure when we say we expended a certain amount of money in fiscal year 2011 that it's 2011 dollars that's being expended versus might have been fiscal year 2010 or earlier.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:33
We will work on a schedule by the next...
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:38
I'm looking forward to making it as transparent as possible so that the CTB knows
00:43:44
But the dollars that was maybe, I mean, let's face it, budgeted were approved in 2009, 2008.
00:43:50
Actually, that's best.
00:43:52
I mean, again, it's easier with a construction project.
00:43:54
We know it's moving through that pipeline, but it's not easy on the maintenance because we just do a lump sum, don't we?
00:44:01
We just simply say, I mean, we just simply say for the most part on the maintenance side, we approve a line item.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:44:10
It's actually a very detailed budget around the maintenance program.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:18
Okay.
00:44:19
Let's keep on evolving.
00:44:21
Certainly.
00:44:21
I appreciate it very much, Mr. Layne.
00:44:23
Sure.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:23
I don't mean to be the dead horse, but is our budget on an expenditure basis?
00:44:28
I mean, when we come in and approve a budget, is that on an expenditure basis that we're going to, or is that cash in, cash out?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:44:37
Our budget is
00:44:38
It's more of a programmatic budget in that, as I mentioned with the federal funds, we are, in order to support the Six-Year Improvement Program, we are basing the budget on the funds that we see being made available to us.
00:44:56
And then we allocate in the budget those funds over the period of time.
00:45:01
So it's not, especially from a construction side, it is not reflective, directly reflective
00:45:08
of the expenditure that we anticipate to incur that year.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:11
Once we have a budget, we make changes to it.
00:45:14
Obviously, we approve changes as we go.
00:45:16
I just would like to see, whatever those assumptions are, when you address us or get a financial update, that budget compared to what we've actually done on that basis, whether it's revenues or expenditures, so that I have a basis to go for them to see how we're doing.
00:45:34
This is very much on our mind, but Hampton Roads, you all know about what's going on with HRT and how they're, and I just want to make sure I can look somebody out and say I know how we're doing to our budget.
00:45:48
And that doesn't seem to me to be, Mr. Chairman, that is impossible.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:53
What we had talked about was maybe
00:45:59
having just a session on some of the finances and we could announce it maybe an hour before the board meeting and we would announce that and the public could come and just explain how we developed the budget, some of the assumptions because we have two different
00:46:26
One of the facets of developing that budget, one is that six-year plan.
00:46:33
And we have to anticipate our revenue and then program our projects based upon that plan.
00:46:43
But at the same time, when we develop the budget that must go into the statewide budget,
00:46:48
It is based upon what we anticipate receiving and what we anticipate expending.
00:46:54
And so we need to kind of explain that to you and I thought maybe we could have a special session before the meeting and just kind of walk through some of the ABCs of developing the budget.
00:47:10
And then we can do that for maybe the next meeting.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:17
sort of ABCs or rather have one, two, threes.
00:47:20
Or the one, two, threes.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:21
Report to us on a consistent basis and that would be it.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:25
Great.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:28
Okay.
00:47:28
Just one more quick question.
00:47:30
Do you think... Lawson, you're never going to... Why don't you pull a chair off?
00:47:34
I'll be too low, man.
00:47:37
He's confident.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:39
Bruce Lee, give us, John.
00:47:43
Some kind of little chart that shows how much money it would take to get back to normalcy with the statutory formulas.
00:47:51
What that would be?
00:47:52
What number that would be?
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
00:47:55
We can do that.
00:47:56
We can show in terms of the way the formula works, what it would take to have a meaningful amount of funding going through the formula.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:04
Okay.
00:48:05
Thanks.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:15
Mr. Lawson, you better run while you still can.
00:48:17
All right.
00:48:18
Thank you.
00:48:18
Thank you.
00:48:19
Next is the Transportation Performance Trend Report, 2009.
00:48:27
Mr. Tyeryar.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:48:51
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the CTB.
00:48:55
I will walk you quickly through the 2009 performance report.
00:48:59
I will just tell you that all 50 measures and all of the narrative associated with them are available online in their entirety.
00:49:08
You can see here the seven categories that we use to assess our annual performance and this is the fourth iteration
00:49:21
of this report, and many of these measures are carried over from year to year.
00:49:26
Just going through the highlights, in terms of safety and security, fatalities decreased to its lowest level in 40 years.
00:49:34
Seat belt usage is up to its highest usage ever.
00:49:39
In terms of prevention and maintenance, you can see the average age of random vehicles here in the Commonwealth are lower than the national average and lower than the guideline for receiving federal funding.
00:49:52
Delftaling with what Mr. Lawson just told you about increased need to transfer money from the Transportation Trust Fund to the HMOF, you can see that our interstates and our primary pavements are much below their targets.
00:50:06
Eighty percent for interstate, seventy-six for primaries are targeted at eighty-two percent as being in fair condition or better.
00:50:13
I would just note, it's not on the slide, but bridges with a target of ninety-two percent are actually at ninety-one percent, so we're pretty close there.
00:50:21
In terms of mobility, connectivity, and accessibility, HOV usage is up, but the volume through the port by railroad barge is down from what it was in 2008, but that is also before our huge rail expansion with the Commonwealth Railroad and also is prior to our taking possession of the APM or leasing the APM facility, which has both Class 1 railroads on it.
00:50:48
at the port, so we expect those numbers to go up.
00:50:53
In terms of environmental stewardship, our emissions continue to decrease and we replace wetland at a faster rate, actually 85% faster than we take them out.
00:51:06
Economic vitality is down and I will talk to you about that in a little bit greater detail in a moment.
00:51:11
We contributed just $8.8 billion to the gross state product in 2009.
00:51:18
In terms of land use and transportation, vehicle miles traveled on a per capita basis are down.
00:51:24
Some of that is related to just the decline in the economy and fewer people going to work but also some of it is related to our more aggressive approach in getting folks off the roads and into other transit opportunities.
00:51:39
And you can see that almost 7% of state workers telework and hopefully with Director Drake's telework credit bill that is now passing its or finding its way through the General Assembly
00:51:48
These numbers will increase for both the public and the private sector.
00:51:53
In terms of on-time and on-budget, 82 percent, that's higher than it was a year before.
00:51:57
Our target is 77 percent.
00:51:59
I'm not sure why our target is only three-quarters of a percent, three-quarters of our projects to be on-time and on-budget, but I will tell you that the 82 percent is an improvement over what it was the prior year.
00:52:09
This is what our grades look like in terms of all categories of our performance report in 2009.
00:52:17
that economic vitality we didn't do very well.
00:52:20
The others are... Mr.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:21
Chair?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:22
Yes.
00:52:22
On that, I mean, obviously it stands out.
00:52:25
Mike brings that home from school and he's got a problem.
00:52:29
How do we measure, because I see in the, when you went through sort of descriptions on it, contributed eight billion under economic vitality, but we got an F. How do we determine if it's a A, B, C, D, or F?
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:52:43
We...
00:52:46
I can go through the scoring for you of how, but I can also tell you what our plan is to rectify that, but let me talk to you a little bit about the scoring.
00:52:56
I guess that's what I'm looking for is the scoring.
00:53:01
Every measure that we have, all 50 measures have a desired trend upward or downward depending on what we're trying to do.
00:53:08
So if we are moving in the positive in the direction that we intend, we get a plus point.
00:53:14
If we're moving in
00:53:16
The opposite direction, we get a minus point and then there are gradations of half points and zeros along the way.
00:53:23
So in terms of all of these items related to economic vitality, in order for us to get an F, you can see them on this slide, we've gone in the wrong direction in all categories.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:36
So number of workers employed by transportation sectors down, transportation sectors contributions down, volume of freight down.
00:53:44
Mr. Chairman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:45
Yes, Mr. Garczynski.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:47
David, I guess following on Court's question, we hear of how well Dulles is doing and the Port is doing, so why are we at an F, though?
00:53:57
They don't seem to match up with the numbers we hear from those two entities especially, which are the two economic engines of the Commonwealth.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:54:06
Well, I can speak to the Port because that's within our secretariat a little bit easier than I can speak to the international
00:54:12
Air Carrier Facilities, which are not within our secretariat.
00:54:15
These are 2009 measures.
00:54:17
So this was at our low point in the recession.
00:54:20
In 2010, a couple of things happened, especially at the port.
00:54:24
We decreased our costs there.
00:54:26
We increased our efficiency, and we now have access to both Class 1 railroads there.
00:54:30
So when these numbers come out in 2010, you will see us start to move above that 600,000 container level at which we were at for this period.
00:54:42
In terms of moving forward, you can see what the measures are, the contribution, the number of workers, the volume of freight, port share of East Coast, and some of the things that I've talked to you about going on at the port, and more importantly, the things that are before us now in the General Assembly.
00:54:56
You can see that the governor's omnibus transportation plan would continue to contribute $6 billion of economic impact and support 48,000 jobs.
00:55:07
Important to this group is probably the protection of the Commonwealth Transportation Fund from transfers
00:55:12
to the General Fund, what we refer to as the Constitutional Lockbox.
00:55:15
A couple of other things that we've been working on and have gotten through both chambers is the Port Volume Tax Credit and the Per Container Tax Credit.
00:55:24
Again, I alluded to Ms. Drake's bill for telework credits will make the Commonwealth a place for people to come and invest in terms of creating jobs.
00:55:35
There are also some bills that have been carried by Delegate Odor and some others that would increase
00:55:40
our airport's competitiveness in the regional and the mid-Atlantic economy.
00:55:46
So we expect as a result of these bills that we are pushing through and the slight recovery in the economy for this economic vitality grade to improve.
00:55:55
Well, it can't get worse.
00:55:55
So we certainly expect it to improve.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:59
Mr. Chairman?
00:56:00
Yes, Mr. Miller.
00:56:03
You threw this one high up, so I'm going to hit it for you.
00:56:13
Program delivery, 82% on time and on budget, target 77.
00:56:19
I'm no engineer, and I don't build highways, but I have some reasonably complex defense contracting projects.
00:56:29
And mine don't, you know, a 77 goal, or excuse me, a 77 target
00:56:38
Can you help me with that?
00:56:40
Because I'm a rookie here, but it just sort of jumps off the page.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
00:56:44
That's a C or a C minus or a D in my world.
00:56:48
Well, when we started this process, that was like stretching objectives because we were in the low 70s to mid-70s.
00:56:53
So as we meet our goal, and now we've exceeded at its next iteration, it would be time to up that percentage, say, to 85 or some greater number.
00:57:02
But if you consider from where we've come to where we are, that's
00:57:05
That's huge.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:06
Well, when my child is parking a subject, I don't give him a goal to get a B. I say, you ought to be able to get a B or B plus if I think you can.
00:57:15
Now, my problem is I don't know what's reasonable, but certainly from a sort of a working public perspective to say our goal is 77 just sort of jumps off the page as that's not real.
00:57:30
It doesn't look good.
00:57:31
I agree with you.
00:57:32
How do we set the goal and what is really, if we were the smoothest running we could ever possibly be, I know stuff happens.
00:57:45
It's not always on time.
00:57:47
It's not always on budget.
00:57:49
But if we looked out across the country and looked at other similar groups, what's a reasonable stretch goal?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:58
And I don't know the answer to that.
00:58:02
Our target on time on budget, have we adjusted what our on time on budget targets are or goals, you know, have we extended the time and have we increased the budget or have we actually performed better in order to meet this?
00:58:19
I think that's a critical question there.
00:58:20
You can meet it both ways by dumbing down what you're
00:58:23
Your budget and your target, your timelines are.
00:58:25
How have we measured in that sense?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:30
Mr. Chairman, we have adjusted the on-time, on-budget goal pretty much every year and we've tried to increase it.
00:58:40
for a while, almost every year.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:43
But I mean, have we increased the length of time?
00:58:45
Let's say originally our on-time would have been to get a project done in one year, but now it's to get it done in two years.
00:58:51
And it would have been, here's the budget, $2 million, now it's $4 million.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:54
No, we've kept to the rumors.
00:58:57
The rules that measure whether you're on time and on budget, we did not change those rules.
00:59:02
In terms of the goals, we did try to inch up those goals a little bit each year, but let me say that when you have a few projects,
00:59:15
You miss one project, you miss your goal.
00:59:21
When you have a number of projects that you're working from, you can miss one and you still got a good shot of making your goals.
00:59:28
What we've been faced with here lately is that we have few projects and it's becoming very difficult to meet the goal because
00:59:38
If something happens on a project, if we couldn't get the right-of-way cleared or we had to add a work order because we found something we didn't expect in the construction of the project, that made us miss that goal.
00:59:55
And that project missed, and because we had a few projects, we probably missed the overall goal.
01:00:02
Our staff has been very dedicated to
01:00:06
Not trying to let the rules drive the project.
01:00:12
In other words, if there's something that needs to be done because of something unexpected, I can ignore the work and move forward and build a project and meet the goal.
01:00:25
But if I add that work order because it's the right thing to do, then I probably miss that goal because it's going to add more time to the project.
01:00:34
And we've stressed that if you see where there's work to do and you need to do it in this good business, then let's do the work.
01:00:43
and we'll deal with the outcome of the goals.
01:00:47
But we do try to ramp up those goals a little bit every year based upon the number of projects.
01:00:55
We anticipate the projects we have for the year and we try to look at those projects and then develop a target both for on time and on budget.
01:01:05
And then we do a combined goal, which would be for the program delivery, both on time and on budget, and we come up with that 82%.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:01:14
The answer, before we move too far, the answer to the question from this side of the room was who sets the goal.
01:01:21
We in the Office of Intermodal Planning, we set the goals for all 50 measures every year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:27
One other question.
01:01:29
As a novice on the board, why is there a lag time?
01:01:32
Here we are in February of 11, and this report is 09.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:36
Is it just compiling the data?
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:01:41
Yes, for the most part.
01:01:42
I mean, we could get this to you maybe a little bit earlier in 2000.
01:01:45
We could have gotten it to you in 2010.
01:01:47
Probably wouldn't have begged the question, but there is a certain amount of time, especially related to the economic data in terms of gross state products and employees.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:54
I thought it was something, David.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:01:57
If there are any more questions, I'll just tell you that we in the Office of Intermodal Planning will be back in front of you in the coming months with other presentations.
01:02:10
The first one will be on the regional performance measures for the MPOs, and you can see them listed there.
01:02:16
And then a topic that has been of great concern to this group, at least since I've been here, is where we are on the corridors of statewide significance, and we will be back to you.
01:02:24
with an update of where we are and then, as promised, a recommendation of how we move forward from there.
01:02:30
And any of this information that I presented today is available in a much greater level of detail at VTrans.org.
01:02:38
You can see all 50 measures and a description and trend lines of those.
01:02:44
That's all I have, Mr. Chairman.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:46
Yes, Mr. Lane.
01:02:48
I want to get back to Dr. Davis' question in the previous session.
01:02:51
Clearly, our ability
01:02:53
Not to push some of these contracts out is hurting our preservation and maintenance.
01:02:58
We are no longer treating maintenance as construction projects.
01:03:01
Is that correct?
01:03:03
In other words, remember we talked about we're not doing that anymore as far as planning and stuff.
01:03:13
We were told at a previous meeting that one of the reasons that construction was being, or maintenance was being slowed is because we were treating the maintenance project with the same rules as construction projects.
01:03:24
I just want to confirm that we are no longer doing that.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:27
We're not doing it.
01:03:28
We're trying to get these construction maintenance projects out quickly.
01:03:33
I think if you look at what we've done the last few months, we've doubled what we've put out for maintenance projects.
01:03:42
and we're going to double that again, or we're going to double the amount that we do next cycle, making a cycle.
01:03:53
So I think we're making progress on that already.
01:03:55
We're getting the projects out the door.
01:03:57
The projects are going out the door.
01:04:03
Mr. Chairman, I would also just bring attention to the quarterly report that's at the desk.
01:04:09
where we have measured some of our on-time on-budget for the maintenance and construction projects.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:20
Yes, go ahead.
01:04:22
Mr. Secretary, I caught your word that said the amendment to stop transfers from the transportation trust fund.
01:04:32
Does that include what is listed in Mr. Lawson's presentation as support for other state agencies, which is about a $42 million item or DMV?
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:04:48
Well, the only transfer that I'm aware of, and correct me if I'm wrong, John's in the room somewhere, is the money that we transfer out to public safety, which is for enforcement of our corridors of safety.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:59
Can we also do DMV?
01:05:03
Is that the transfers you were talking about?
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:05:05
No, I was talking about if you take in a perfect world the formulaic money and then because we are a maintenance first organization, we actually take money from the transportation trust fund that could otherwise over into the highway, the HMOF, as John said, several hundred million dollars a year.
01:05:24
just to keep our maintenance at a reasonable level even though, as I said, even given that transfer from the TTF to the HMOF, we are still below our targets.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:40
Mr. Chairman, this was one of the, one question, of course, maybe on Mr. Whirley's comment, there's all the contracts that we've awarded, or preparing to award, and many that we've got on the agenda today to be approved by the CTB.
01:05:58
Have we had any situations where there's been, the contracts have been held up because of lack of CTB approval?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:07
And Mr. Chairman, we do not have any contracts that have not been approved because we couldn't get CTB approved.
01:06:18
That's not the issue.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:19
And I guess that begs the real question and is part of the legislative proposal in which we're increasing the amount for commissioner to approve the contract from two to five million.
01:06:34
And I saw that as part of the legislative proposal.
01:06:36
package, and I didn't remember any period of time in which we had problems with contracts being awarded because of failure of CTB actions.
01:06:46
I just really didn't understand or know reasoning behind that proposal and the bill to be passed.
01:06:59
I don't know who, I guess, I start with the bill.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:07:01
That benefits the DRPT director and the commissioner, so I'll let them answer that.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:07
I think that, I'm sorry I didn't catch all the questions, but what we're just looking for was just more efficiency in moving out the projects quickly.
01:07:19
It was an efficiency move, not that the CTB was holding up approval of the contracts.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:26
I guess, Mr. Chairman, my follow-up question would be, I wasn't aware that, you know, there was inefficiency built into the system or part of it because that amount, because I think raising it to two million that we did the year before last probably was good.
01:07:42
to the extent of some of the smaller contracts, but then we're talking about moving it now from two to five, and during that timeframe, I'm not aware of any issues or complaints that would have been demonstrating the need for that, and I have difficulty understanding the need for that type of increase, because I mean, if you look at contracts that we've awarded last month, 13 of them,
01:08:08
were awarded, all the 13-9 were under $5 million, which means that would have been signed by the commissioner, would not have come before the board.
01:08:18
I just think that that's less transparent way of doing the business.
01:08:23
So I just bring that in because I know that we were awarded the contracts, and I happen to remember that was part of our legislative package.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:32
Mr. Chairman.
01:08:35
Mr. Miller.
01:08:36
A question I didn't ask when that package was briefed.
01:08:44
In a typical year, if you went back in the last three or four years, say, how many projects would we typically have?
01:08:53
How many would be two million or below, and how many would be five million below, and how many would be in the balance?
01:09:02
The total number of projects, how many were impacted by this proposal?
01:09:06
And to Mr.
01:09:08
Keen's point, and I'm not sure whether it's a good or bad proposal because I'm not here long enough for that yet in terms of my own view on it, but what was the, is there an inefficiency with this board
01:09:23
It's creating that need and I understand efficiency and I commend us for every time we can find a way to be more efficient to do so.
01:09:33
Can you help me with that a little bit?
01:09:36
What percent of the projects would be impacted by the change?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:40
Chairman, I don't have the information with me.
01:09:45
I know we have it.
01:09:47
Keith, I don't know, did you bring any of that with you?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:51
And I don't need an exact number.
01:09:53
I'm sort of trying to fill scope here.
SPEAKER_04
01:09:59
Mr. Chairman, Keith Martin from VDOT's Policy Office.
01:10:02
I believe on average for the last five years it ranged anywhere from 40 to 60 projects you're talking about that falls between the 2 million to 5 million range.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:12
And what percent of, how many projects would we have typically in a year?
01:10:16
I'm trying to look at the impact.
01:10:18
So 40 doesn't mean anything to me.
01:10:21
Is it 50% of the projects now would go forward without us?
01:10:25
Is it 10%?
01:10:26
Did it move from 10 to 20?
01:10:27
Did it move from 10 to 80?
SPEAKER_04
01:10:31
I'm sorry, I don't have the actual percentage, but I do know the actual numbers of how many projects that's included.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:39
Can you give us some idea what that is?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:41
And then what percentage of what dollar percentage is that?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:46
Right, is that it?
01:10:47
Okay.
01:10:47
But we can get that information.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:53
Mr. Chairman, we had referred just briefly to this document earlier.
01:11:02
I was wondering, I looked on the back and I noticed that VDOT land used for truck rest area and maybe I'm missing where this is, but.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:13
It's in the Stanton district.
01:11:15
Pardon?
01:11:16
It's in the Stanton district.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:17
It's in the Stanton district?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:19
I'm pretty sure it is.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:21
I'm sorry, I didn't...
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:23
The trucks go rest area on 66th...
01:11:24
Yes, yes, that's in the Stanton district.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:28
Well, it says it's in the Stanton district, that's true, but it's talking about Interstate 66 in Warren County.
01:11:36
And my point is, my question is, is I drive that road quite often and I don't know of any in the eastbound lanes that's abandoned or unused property, but I do know
01:11:50
Westbound lanes, there was an area where it had been originally set up for a rest area and was boarded up or gated up, and it's not being used.
01:12:01
And I'm just wondering if that is a misprint, should be westbound as opposed to eastbound, unless there's another area that I'm not familiar with.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:06
That's in Fauquier County, I think, that abandoned one.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:10
Well, this is talking about directly Warren County.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:11
Right, right.
01:12:12
But the abandoned one is in Fauquier.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:15
No, there's one in Warren County as well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:18
Maybe it's on the other side of the map.
John W. Lawson
Chief Financial Officer
01:12:30
I think it is.
01:12:31
I have to double check.
01:12:32
I apologize.
01:12:34
I can get that information in just a few minutes and let you have it.
01:12:37
But it was an old rest area.
01:12:42
that had property with a drive but had never been, nothing has ever been constructed.
01:12:51
So it's the request of the County Board of Supervisors.
01:12:54
We are letting it be used for truckers.
01:12:59
There's some port-a-johns and some trash receptacles.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:02
It certainly makes sense and it must be on the eastern side of 340, between 340 and 81.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:13:09
Mr. Chairman, Ms. Laudaback is
01:13:12
As you come in eastbound on 66, as soon as you come off of 81, it's within two miles of 81.
01:13:18
It's basically an old abandoned truck rest area and we're reopening it based on working with the community and the county board.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:28
We just had a report on that from our district administrator and they've been keeping records of the use and I think within the
01:13:39
Short period of time, we'll have a report on whether or not it seems feasible to continue and to make it really useful.
01:13:45
So we should have a report back pretty quickly on whether or not it's going to work.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:49
Mr. Peake.
01:13:50
Since we're talking about rest areas, oh my God, I know we've increased the volume, but they're talking about the use of
01:14:00
Inmate labor to maintain.
01:14:03
Is that something we have addressed or spoken of or approved or not approved?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:14:06
Has it come to forces at all in the General Assembly?
01:14:09
General Assembly.
01:14:10
All General Assembly.
01:14:12
All right.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:12
I'm all in the book, Jim.
01:14:14
The, basically we're asking for, basically we were asking for the, it was interesting though,
01:14:22
The state code allows us to use inmates on state highway system roads and facilities.
01:14:32
And when we looked at it, and the Attorney General indicated that since it does say interstates, it's a separate definition, that technically we aren't allowed to use inmates on interstates.
01:14:43
So that's really what the bill that just got us
01:14:48
It's passed already to the House and Senate.
01:14:51
It's going to be signed by the governor very shortly.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:14:56
Just for those of you who get questions about that, I'll let you go back.
01:14:59
And it's nonviolent criminals who we're trying to mainstream for reentry.
01:15:05
So it's a very, very small group.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:09
These will be state presidents, inmates, correct?
01:15:13
Yeah.
01:15:15
Not local jails.
David L. Tyeryar
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
01:15:17
No, local jails have a separate program, but they do essentially the same thing.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:21
Thank you very much.
01:15:49
We're just going to move the agenda just a little bit up to allow Ms. Busher and Terry Brown to talk about the kickoff of the Six-Year Program.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:15
Good morning.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:16:19
Mr. Chairman and members of the CTB, myself and Terry Brown from DRPT will be talking about the kickoff of the fiscal year 12 through 17 Six-Year Improvement Program and at the end we'll talk to you a little bit about the dates that we're looking at for the public hearings.
01:16:46
The numbers that I'm showing you on this slide provide a small history of where we've been and how we've had to revise our budgets, obviously as our revenue declined in the economic downturn.
01:17:03
So you'll see revised 9 through 14, 10 through 15 last year's program and the proposed resources for this year's program.
01:17:13
Now these numbers come from the Six-Year Financial Plan that John was talking about a little bit earlier.
01:17:21
So it accounts for increase in the TTF and those things.
01:17:28
As you can see,
01:17:30
We've added a couple of informational lines.
01:17:33
We've got the Highway Construction Program at 7.2, Rail and Public Transportation or DRPT at 2.4.
01:17:41
I've included the Garvey Debt Service.
01:17:44
We're looking to issue over three years approximately 1.1 billion.
01:17:49
of Garvey Direct Bonds, and the debt service is approximately $500 million, and we're paying that debt service back with federal revenue, so I've included it here as a separate component of the highway construction number.
01:18:06
And then the VTIB component of the governor's funding package, I'm showing at $400 million at this point, the $600 million that was looking to partially capitalize that program doesn't look like that will come into fruition at this point.
01:18:28
So we're going from $4.8 billion in the 11 through 16 program
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:33
to the 10.5 billion.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:18:46
The only reason I'm separating it, this will actually be shown in the debt service portion of VDOT's budget.
01:18:59
But it's revenue that is the federal revenue is coming from the highway construction program.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:05
But if you go down to the totals it's 7.8 to 10.5 which represents 2.7.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:19:11
Right.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:12
But isn't the program because you've got debt service here instead of or do you have the program the projects whatever you want to call it that that services is that molded in the highway construction?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:19:25
It is.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:27
How much is that?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:19:28
It's 1.1 billion.
01:19:32
Now what you're not seeing in this total, though, keep in mind is a portion of the advancement of the CPR bonds was for previous commitment.
01:19:44
where that money was used for both DRPT and VDOT.
01:19:49
Approximately $600 million was in previous commitment as on projects and to match federal dollars.
01:20:01
To get into the highway program development, the actions that we've had to take to date in the development of the program that we had to deal
01:20:13
to use to deal with the reduction in state revenue since June of 2008.
01:20:17
And you talked about a couple of these a few minutes ago.
01:20:20
Basically, as the state revenue went away, we had to reduce all available state funds from projects.
01:20:29
We restricted funding to project phases that are obligated or planned to be obligated in the current federal fiscal year or underway.
01:20:39
And again, that gets back to maximizing federal dollars to meet federal strategy.
01:20:45
And we suspended the state formula distributions for unpaved roads, primary, secondary, and urban systems.
01:20:54
We also eliminated the distribution of the federal STP formula to individual localities and regions and concentrated those resources on projects centrally
01:21:08
So that they would actually could be used more efficiently and move projects forward instead of distributing them in such small amounts.
01:21:20
that they weren't actually able to fully fund a phase.
01:21:24
So, and we focused those dollars on underway projects, deficient bridges and deficient pavements.
01:21:31
And when we weren't sure when we were able, going to be able to issue CPR bonds, we reduced the use of CPR bond proceeds to federal match at that point.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:45
Have we reached a point now where you might consider unsuspending state formal distributions for unpaid roads, primary and secondary and urban assistance?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:21:58
We are not, and it's not anticipated that we will be in that position for this planned
01:22:04
construction cycle to six years.
01:22:07
I think John mentioned that a little bit earlier that the state revenue increases don't get us to that point during this planning period.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:16
Mr. Chairman, may I ask what the trigger point is?
01:22:21
Because this is an issue that I think needs to be examined as a state policy
01:22:31
And if we've set something in our thinking that says this is not important, it needs to be reversed.
01:22:41
And I don't think, I'd like to hear what the trigger is when we'll be able to go back to making those funds available.
01:22:50
Because the longer we wait, the problems grow by huge proportions.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:22:56
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Davis, I believe John indicated he would provide that information at the next CTB meeting.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:05
Is it possible, Mr. Chairman, to have some discussion about the decision to suspend the distribution of funds for that purpose?
01:23:16
It just seems to me not to be wise state policy.
01:23:20
I think I understand trying to meet federal match is very important.
01:23:25
But I think to abandon your whole philosophy of what you need to do in the Commonwealth with one part of our road system doesn't make sense.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:36
Well, I think that the issue is just how much money flows through it.
01:23:41
The last time money went through the formula, how much money was it, do we know?
01:23:46
Just generally?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:50
It was probably in 09, was it the last time?
01:23:54
It was in 09, and I think in order, and I'm probably shouldn't be stating these numbers, but just to make the formula work at its bare minimum, you're probably going to need anywhere from $150 to $200 million.
01:24:10
Now that's after meeting all of your commitments, whether it's match, et cetera.
01:24:19
You would probably have to have, at just the minimum, 150 to 200 million.
01:24:26
I think that's probably what John is going to come back with.
01:24:29
But then the question becomes, if you run 200 million through the formula, then what does it do when you spread it all out?
01:24:39
And are you able then to create a good project with a small amount of money?
01:24:47
The issue, I think that's the real,
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:24:50
I guess, Mr. Chairman, I'm less interested in the distribution formula than I am addressing the needs of unpaid roads, primary, secondary, and urban system projects.
01:25:08
And if we're not going to have an allocation or distribution, I think we have to have some prioritization of the need for funds in those areas.
01:25:17
We cannot just stop
01:25:19
all work in that particular sector of our road system, and I think that's what we've done.
01:25:24
I'll let Don and Mr.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:25
Chair say it.
01:25:27
Mr.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:27
Chair, I'm going to disagree.
01:25:31
I don't think we've stopped, but please correct me if I'm wrong.
01:25:33
It's just the idea, and this gets back to the Commissioner's comment, 100 million, when you say it, it sounds a lot, divided up amongst all the localities
01:25:43
Next thing you know, the amount that's going to each project in each locality isn't enough to keep up with the inflation costs associated with the projects.
01:25:52
The idea that if it's that low, I don't consider that viable.
01:25:55
You say 100 to 200 might be viable.
01:25:58
I'm not sure that that's viable.
01:26:00
Now, in terms of making sure that we've got a pot of money and there's a part of it that's going to these functions that get identified, so we can go in, finish a project, move on to the next project.
01:26:12
But that way we can put sufficient money towards finishing a project rather than insufficient money to even keep up with inflation on all the variety of projects that we get allocated.
01:26:22
I get very, very concerned about the spreading it so thin that nothing gets done.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:26
As I said earlier, I'm not so interested in the distribution formula as I am in doing something in this particular area.
01:26:32
And I don't have the assurance that we're doing very much in that area.
01:26:35
Because if they're too small to be addressed by the
01:26:39
by the federal maps and the other projects that we're talking about.
01:26:42
As a result, we've abandoned doing anything to speak of in these areas.
01:26:46
Am I wrong?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:48
No.
01:26:48
For new construction?
01:26:49
No.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:50
That's right.
01:26:50
We've abandoned that whole part of our highway system in the Commonwealth.
01:26:55
Mr. Chairman.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:55
And it's not right.
01:26:57
In many cases, Mr. Chairman.
01:26:59
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
01:26:59
In many cases, you know, we've
01:27:03
understood that a project doesn't know whether it's a construction or maintenance project, and we've all heard that before.
01:27:09
In many cases, these funds were expended just to maintain.
01:27:15
A certain project could be called a construction project, but it was really a maintenance.
01:27:20
Now what has happened here, we've got 37,000 miles of the 57,000 we've got that are in this category.
01:27:28
And we're getting down to a situation where a lot of these funds were used for
01:27:32
for drainage corrections and various projects out there in the counties that protected the integrity of many of these roadways.
01:27:41
Now these funds are not coming that way and the infrastructure is crumbling.
01:27:47
It will continue to crumble.
01:27:48
It will do it at a faster pace.
01:27:50
Compounded with the problem that we've eliminated or we've reduced
01:27:55
revenue sharing program and the revenue sharing program where we get a double bang for a buck is just a double whammy on this particular segment of our roads.
01:28:06
I agree with Dr. Davis 100%.
01:28:09
It's an area where we've abandoned and ignored that we really need some attention on.
01:28:14
We need to address it.
01:28:16
And while larger parts, you know, the metropolitan areas have the MPOs that can address things like this.
01:28:24
The planning districts are just not prepared and can't handle those out there in rural Virginia.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:40
My colleagues that secondary roads actually do exist in urban areas as well.
01:28:45
This is not a rural system problem.
01:28:50
But I would remind my colleagues that one of the things that has confounded us in our time of service here is actually the strictures of that funding formula, which actually do not allow us to respond to problems as they appear.
01:29:05
They allow us to respond the way the formula dictates.
01:29:08
And that's the dilemma we're in is there's not enough money flowing down to the various parts of the formula to allow us to move.
01:29:16
But there's two things to keep in mind.
01:29:19
Number one, most of the money that is programmed for transportation actually does not go through that formula.
01:29:25
So we have other ways of doing it.
01:29:27
Second, we do have a second set of allocation
01:29:30
Criteria that we use, including performance measures and other things.
01:29:34
So it's not that we're completely shut out here, but I think the viability of the formula itself is in jeopardy, both from lack of funding, but also because there probably are other allocation measures that will allow us to respond more
01:29:50
Realistically to the challenges that we face.
01:29:53
So we're lamenting something that maybe ought to just wither and go away in favor of something that's much more performance and system-based.
01:30:05
I'm sorry, Mr. Layne.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:07
A practical matter of what's happening in Hampton Roads is if you see cities taking money off some projects and putting it on those that they can get completed or finding alternatives,
01:30:18
Those are the ways to subsidize whether it's through their general fund or other projects but Hampton Roads also has the rural areas.
01:30:26
Those are where I see where those counties have not taken the step or maybe don't have the money to prioritize where I see things not getting done at least in Hampton Roads.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:41
I just wanted to share the concerns of my colleagues, Dr. Davis, Keene, Mr. Layne.
01:30:51
I'm concerned about adequate funding for secondary roads and I think we have to address this.
01:30:58
And specifically with respect to the upcoming Six-Year Plan, I want to know how much is coming into my district and the other districts and why we seem to be at the bottom of the barrel.
01:31:11
I know that they, I don't think they really have any performance standards for secondary roads.
01:31:15
It's just kind of a hit and miss thing.
01:31:17
I think for primary roads, there is kind of a systemized examination of the condition of the roads.
01:31:24
But in secondary, I don't think there is
01:31:26
and we really need to address this problem and I think Dr. Davis has an important point.
SPEAKER_16
01:31:34
Mr. Booth?
01:31:37
I agree with Dr. Davis' approach.
01:31:41
If the formula is to be abandoned or at least modified, I think we need to look for a way, an alternative way to accomplish what that formula formally accomplished.
01:31:56
It seemed to have worked a long time and worked fairly well.
01:31:59
If it's not working now, we need to modify it or replace it, but we need something to pick up the slack.
01:32:12
Next slide.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:14
Dr. Davis, I know you're aware of the problem because you dealt with it some in Prince William as well, but I do think at the least
01:32:33
We should figure out how to have an allocation in our six-year plan budget to meet some of these needs.
01:32:41
And at the least, I think the revenue sharing program was the way that that could be done in counties and cities where they could afford to provide the match.
01:32:52
And by not having at least that, I think we as CTB ought to consider funding
01:33:03
that program again because it had such a positive impact on many of the localities.
01:33:10
There will still be several that will not be able to take care of their needs because they won't have the match but at least we ought to be addressing some of those needs and I'd like to recommend that we ask staff to come back to us with some thinking on how we can address this issue fairly and not just
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:30
This is why in the Governor's package we have in there revenue sharing, bumping the program itself up to a maximum.
01:33:46
Allocation of $200 million a year.
01:33:48
And then just as important, you know, it was a million dollar per project limit.
01:33:55
I mean, the traffic light cost you $600,000, $700,000.
01:33:58
I mean, so we're asking, in fact, it's in both the House and the Senate to go up to $10 million.
01:34:03
So that goes from $50 million a year up to $200 million a year.
01:34:09
A million dollars per project up to, he's writing my cheap notes, up to $10 million per project and that will be in the 2012 budget.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:34:22
In 2012 we're looking at $50 million but the next year, out year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:34:29
So that way what we'll do is we'll start to program that up, Dr. Davis, right up front.
01:34:34
What we're going to start doing is like what we did this year, we'll start asking for what people, what the localities are interested in doing much earlier so we can program it into the budget for the following year.
01:34:50
That's one thing.
01:34:51
The second thing is, I mean, we are going to have to have just general discussions about, it's not just the formula, it's just the way we do things generally.
01:35:03
This year, I think everyone does recognize, I mean the governor is very serious about coming back this year on his package.
01:35:10
was just really one way to jumpstart the program.
01:35:13
We're going to be there next year talking about maintenance, talking about the sustainable funding for construction as well.
01:35:23
But these issues, I mean, it is just because the way the formula though works is that when you go through all these other mandatory
01:35:34
You know, the fact that we have to meet these other mandatory requirements, whether it's debt service, whether it's federal match, whether it's maintenance.
01:35:43
By the time we get down to the formula, we run out.
01:35:47
And so the question is, is how do we start to get the money back to our secondary roads and our urban roads?
01:35:54
How do we deal with this, I think is unsustainable as well, where the urban roads now get dramatically more dollars than
01:36:04
Mr. Chairman, my final comment.
01:36:12
I'd like to let you move on.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:22
It appears that the two areas we have the greatest trouble with the way we're currently doing things
01:36:33
because of the economic conditions and a number of other issues.
01:36:37
We have trouble with the really big projects, tunnels and interstates, I mean 300 miles of 81 and others.
01:36:44
We have trouble figuring out how and where we're going to deal with that.
01:36:47
And then on the very bottom end, our secondary roads and local needs, that's where we seem to have our greatest challenges, thinking either really big or thinking small.
01:36:59
Everything in the middle seems to be, we seem to be addressing them pretty well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:03
I will tell you, if I had my druthers, I personally would like to pull out bridges as a separate category.
01:37:13
If you did that, then at least when you start looking at some of these other issues for the formula.
01:37:19
You're really then focusing on maybe some real good improvements in these different areas.
01:37:25
I do think that even when we looked previously at the formula, what project worked on a lot was bridge replacements that were called new construction or whatever.
01:37:35
I do think that we should end up, we've been having discussions about how you end up having at least a separate item for just bridge replacement.
01:37:44
Go to the top of the list and just every year just keep on putting money in to eat those away.
01:37:49
You know, eat at that list.
01:37:51
Thanks for your patience with this.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:53
Mr. Chairman, one question or point.
01:37:56
You'd mentioned the amount of money that's spent in certain localities on Lane Mile because they've got the road versus what others.
01:38:05
I wrestled with this because, you know, one answer is for other localities to then opt in, take over the maintenance of the road to receive the more
01:38:14
More funding, but that isn't a long-term answer because if every community in the Commonwealth did that, we run out of money real quick and it all goes back to the original amount.
01:38:25
What's the solution there?
01:38:26
How do we get it to where we're able to apply the resources to where they're needed and still do it within the budget that we have before us?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:42
See, I mean, this is going to be something we're going to have to just, you know, one of the things that we've been trying to do last year, we brought on George Mason Public Policy Center.
01:39:02
Essentially, it brought them on to just what if questions, some policy issues for us to be able to maybe talk about.
01:39:11
One of them just looking generally at this relationship to the state and localities and they're preparing just as something for people to think about, looking at the relationship to the state.
01:39:24
I mean, we're on the few states that we control everything.
01:39:28
and how do we make sure we're fair or how do we even look at providing funding in the future for this.
01:39:34
So, it's something we're going to have to discuss as a common law.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:40
Yes, Mr. President.
01:39:42
To address it here and now, do we have the authority to move some funds from primary to secondary?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:48
No.
01:39:49
This is statutorily based, the formula is statutorily based.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:52
Without additional revenue we can't add anything to the secondary?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:56
That's right.
01:39:56
I mean by statute it says
01:39:58
We have to meet death service first, federal match second, maintenance third.
01:40:04
Get through those three.
01:40:06
There ain't much left.
01:40:07
This is generally the other problem when you hit that second tranche, that federal match.
01:40:13
Then what we end up doing is we focus on all the roads that are federal aid qualified roads.
01:40:18
And so you're looking at interstates, your big primaries.
01:40:22
Then you start searching like we did last year for other projects.
01:40:27
That might be federally qualified to put money against.
01:40:31
But then what does that mean?
01:40:32
That means the vast, vast majority of secondary roads in the Commonwealth and urban roads don't qualify for federal aid.
01:40:42
So therefore, you take them off the table, which means, and this is why when you look at where our money is being spent right now, I think I saw the construction numbers that 52% of the state's highway construction money is being spent in Northern Virginia alone.
01:40:57
This is because they have all the federal aid qualified projects.
01:41:04
But that is all statutorily based.
01:41:05
We did talk to members just to get their feel for what if we were to try to come in with a new way to classify the roads.
01:41:14
and how to potentially change the formula and it just isn't the time.
01:41:20
I think next year we're going to have to come back and talk to them about it.
01:41:24
We are going to come to you about talking about reclassifying some of the roads already.
01:41:28
It's something that is in the power of the CTB is to reclassify some roads.
01:41:32
Some roads that are secondary today should not be, should not be.
01:41:36
I think we still call the Prince William Parkways, we'll consider secondary road.
01:41:41
Fairfax Parkway is the secondary.
01:41:44
That's just crazy.
01:41:45
When we started looking at giving the statutory authority to do it, we found that actually the CTB has the authority to change these.
01:41:54
And I think we're going to have to embark on an effort this year to classify the roads for what should have been done a long time ago.
01:42:02
But then also then coming back and looking at how we get money to these roads.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:09
Well, Mr. Chairman, you've laid out as something that we've come to understand over our years on the board is that push comes to shove, we actually have a federally directed highway program.
01:42:21
Yes, that's exactly right.
01:42:23
The state's refusal to generate new revenues for itself limits the state's ability to define its own needs.
01:42:31
and Mark D. Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
01:42:44
constantly discusses state prerogatives in the course of discussion of federalism that raves against states simply becoming administrative units for the federal government, and to not respond to this kind of problem is baffling.
01:43:04
Now, I know academics are going to take that up for us, but that's part of the challenge, I think,
01:43:11
To really understand what's happening here, and that's really the bottom line.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:43:15
And going back to, I think, Dr. Davis, way before one of the previous discussions, and maybe Mr. Lawson or maybe Mr. Tyeryar is up here, about some of the problems with this.
01:43:24
I mean, they did federalize everything to make it all, every project became a federal project, or at least anticipated so that they could swing money onto it.
01:43:37
And once you did it, but it made our situation even worse.
01:43:42
It's going to take us a few years to get out of this, but it's going to take more money.
01:43:46
It's going to take all to work with the General Assembly to get them to look at the money a little bit differently.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:43:54
The proposed highway priorities for the development of the fiscal year 12-17 Six-Year Improvement Program update, some things are changing based on the fact that we do have the proposed governor's funding program and the resulting bond proceeds.
01:44:19
We continue to fund deficits on underway project phases as a first priority, maximizing the use of federal funds to meet federal strategy, funding project phases that are underway or starting in federal fiscal 12,
01:44:35
Again, funding deficient bridges and paving projects as we can.
01:44:40
We are looking to put some increased funding on preliminary engineering phases of projects to get some projects back on the shelf to move forward when additional funding is available.
01:44:58
The Governor's Program, we're setting aside some of the bond proceeds to support the development of the PTTA program and projects.
01:45:08
We're looking in all possibilities to accelerate existing projects using the additional funds, again the bonds, CPR bonds and GARVEEs.
01:45:19
And we're working with the MPOs in terms of allocating funds consistent, MPOs and localities in terms of allocating funds consistent with how they'd be obligated and expended.
01:45:35
In other words, funding the projects by phases.
01:45:38
as the projects develop instead of front loading, funding, especially federal funding and not being able to obligate it timely.
01:45:47
And as we've been discussing, we're related to RCPC MAC but safety projects, enhancement projects and other projects looking at inactive balances and either redirecting or getting those projects moving forward.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:05
On the PPTA element, does that run through the six-year plan?
01:46:11
Those numbers are reflected in here, right?
01:46:15
Okay, thank you.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:46:18
As John talked to you about the revenue picture and the activity this year and provided us with our revenues that I showed you in the first slide for the 12 through 17 update, we are releasing or what I should say allocating on projects, the Federal Revenue Reserve that we were setting aside.
01:46:44
previously, so we are allocating that reserve bounce about $500 million, a little over, and we'll be programming that on projects.
01:46:56
We are taking advantage and we have FHWA approval to use our what we call toll credits or our soft match that allows us to not have to use CPR bonds as match that we can use 100% federal funds on a project
01:47:13
So we can replace CPR bonds on the projects of match and add additional federal money for that 20% match.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:22
Mr. Chairman?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:23
Yes, Ms. Collins.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:25
Back to the first bullet where you're programming the federal revenue, the reserve we had in the 500 million.
01:47:33
That was never distributed to any, it was just set aside as a reserve.
01:47:38
What will be the model for distribution on that as far as how that should be applied throughout projects in the state?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:47:44
Exactly as we would have done before, funding deficits on projects, making sure we can get those funds on projects that need those monies to be obligated timely.
01:47:58
So we would look at the release of the 12 funds in 12 to maximize federal strategy and move project phases that are ready to go forward.
01:48:09
And we'd be looking at deficient bridges and paving projects.
01:48:13
And some of that also may go as the backfill on projects where we're removing CPR bonds as matched so that we can use our toll credits to make a project 100% federal.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:25
Mr. Chairman, so you would say then there's not a model, that there's a prioritization list that there's an approach to it?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:33
Yes.
01:48:34
So you may also state that a portion of the federal revenue would also be going to the MPOs?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:48:45
Yes.
01:48:45
When you look at that federal reserve, about half of it or a little over half is discretionary in terms of VDOT, but there's a portion of it that goes to enhancement, and I think Mike will actually be talking to you about in a few minutes the extra money.
01:49:01
That is now made available to the enhancement program.
01:49:04
We got additional safety funds and the MPOs have been notified of their additional resources for RSVP and CMAQ out of the release of that reserve for programming onto projects.
01:49:16
So a good portion of that is special program funds is what we call it and we will use the distribution methods related to those funds that we already have in place like enhancement and safety to program those funds.
01:49:35
We are also, well that's it.
01:49:42
The program funding from the governor's transportation funding package, the CPR bonds and the Garvey bonds are being programmed over the three years.
01:49:53
Now a portion of the CPR bonds is in fiscal 11.
01:49:57
There will be a sale this May and that's the funding for the previous commitments I mentioned.
01:50:05
Then there will be two more sales in 12 and 13.
01:50:07
The Garvey's will be sold between 12 and 14.
01:50:11
and a good portion of the Garvey's will be sold in 12, about 620 million in 12 and then about 240 in each of the years 13 and 14.
01:50:28
Again, we mentioned the state construction formula suspension.
01:50:32
As the commissioner mentioned and as I think everyone is interested in and sees the benefit for the revenue sharing funding.
01:50:40
We are proposing at this point in our six-year horizon, $50 million each year for the next six years for that program.
01:50:51
But each year that we update the program, that will be reevaluated in that we have a much larger, we're hoping to have a much larger cap once the legislation is approved through the General Assembly.
01:51:05
on that and as state revenue becomes available we will be looking to grow that program.
01:51:13
But for sake of our existing situation we have added it went from the 15 to the 50 increasing 35 million a year.
01:51:22
So I think that's a good start back in that program.
01:51:27
We are not actually at this point programming the VTIB grants or loans
01:51:35
in that they are just that, grants and loans, and we would be working out the program development process for determining how those funds would be dispersed.
01:51:47
But if you'll remember from the illustrative, governor's illustrative project list, we did indicate that we thought that the grant component of the infrastructure bank
01:51:59
should focus on urban and secondary projects for the very reasons you all had the earlier conversation.
01:52:06
That might be an opportunity to move some of those projects that needed some additional funding to complete those and get them going could potentially come from that grant program.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:17
Mr. Secretary, given that we're looking at our three transportation bankers, what we read going on within the General Assembly
01:52:26
Well, it's included in the House budget.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:44
Well, first off, the legislation itself to establish it is very identical to both House and Senate.
01:52:53
So from an authorization and a programmatic standpoint, I mean, there's a couple minor tweaks, but we're working through that.
01:53:04
The issue really is the budget itself.
01:53:07
and the $250 million they're fine with.
01:53:12
And that's really the issue right now we're dealing with is the $150 million from last year's surplus.
01:53:22
By statute, I think we're already quote-unquote guaranteed $36.5 million or $36 or so, 34, 35, 32 now.
01:53:38
So the question we're really dealing with right now is the other 120 million.
01:53:42
So that's all part of the, yeah, so we're- So 250 would be put into- It'll be, it should be 282 million.
01:53:50
Okay.
01:53:51
The question is, is the other 118 million.
01:53:55
Okay.
01:53:56
That we're working on.
01:53:56
So it's still a good corpus to start.
01:54:02
Obviously, the budget has not been approved yet.
01:54:07
We're continuing to work with Secretary of Finance as well as the House and Senate money committees about this issue.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:17
Thank you.
01:54:17
Mr. Chairman, do those funds go through the regular six-year plan?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:22
No, not necessarily.
01:54:25
But the way we're setting this up is that the CTB will have a role in actually determining or actually when projects come forward for somebody who wants to get a loan.
01:54:37
Remember that the issue here is we're going to see localities, maybe some of our public-private partners come forward to us with loan requests.
01:54:51
And then the CTB will have actually a role in
01:54:55
Actually saying whether it's a worthwhile project or not.
01:54:59
And one of the things we'll be looking at is obviously does it fit into our plans.
01:55:04
But then, you know, we'll essentially vote on moving forward on the loan, the project and the loan.
01:55:12
The Virginia Resources Authority is actually going to administer a loan for us.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:55:17
I think that's very constructive to bring the CTB into that, as you say, so that we can kind of match it up with the six-year plan to see that it all goes together.
01:55:24
So I'm really appreciative of that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:55:27
Well, the thing is I just want to caution you is that it's a lot of, you can imagine a lot of it's not going to be six-year program projects.
01:55:36
I mean, because this is one of the reasons when we discussed initially the CTB's role.
01:55:41
I mean, the port projects are going to be eligible.
01:55:43
The aviation projects are going to be eligible.
01:55:46
We've already had some localities come to us due to other changes in Virginia code regarding proffers.
01:55:56
You used to be able to require the proffers be paid up front.
01:55:59
Now they have to be paid as each unit is
01:56:02
So some localities said, well, I got a project.
01:56:05
I need a new road to service this new development.
01:56:09
I got profits coming in.
01:56:12
Can I use that for my payback?
01:56:14
I need a road built.
01:56:15
Now, that's not going to be in our six-year plan program.
01:56:18
And obviously, our six-year program is financially constrained.
01:56:22
But it may be something that is essential to the locality to even service the very development.
01:56:32
In this context, it may be projects of the six-year program.
01:56:37
I will venture that more often than not, they will not be in the six-year program.
01:56:44
So the question will be before us is,
01:56:47
Is the project itself worthwhile and does it make sense when you look at, you know, we'll have to come up with criteria on actually how to administer it and looking.
01:56:56
Everything from economic development, transportation mobility, you know, transit opportunities.
01:57:02
I think what we'll be having a look at is coming up with a program that actually, hopefully can actually get some projects going and make some input.
01:57:12
But again, when you look at only,
01:57:15
The six-year program is either highway or transit or rail.
01:57:19
This is going to be much broader.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:57:25
Next slide.
01:57:26
Just is for me to let you all, remind you all that the federal authorization
01:57:34
or continuing resolution I guess that we have expires in March.
01:57:40
And at this point I don't know if they'll give us 30 days, 60 days or through the end of the federal fiscal year as another continuing resolution.
01:57:51
So it will be interesting to see how that unfolds and we will be watching that with bated breath to see how that might impact our
01:58:03
Overall Obligation Authority for Federal Fiscal Year 11 and onward.
01:58:11
But it'll probably be another 18 to 24 months before there's a new authorization.
01:58:16
But I know they're beginning to work on it.
01:58:20
I just included this slide.
01:58:22
I used it last month.
01:58:24
It just again highlights the three funding components of the Governor's
01:58:32
Program for your use, the Garvey Bonds, the Infrastructure Bank, and the acceleration of the CPR Bond.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:44
The strategy on the Garvey Bonds, it's not a one-time hit.
01:58:47
I noticed we got $400 million in debt service, and then $1.1 billion program.
01:58:54
Is the intent to keep about $1.1 billion out there all the time, or is this a
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:00
The total authorization is 1.1 billion.
01:59:11
At this point, we've only planned for that amount over the six years, but that would be a board decision as to whether or not, once we pay down that amount, that would be a board decision as to whether you want to issue new bonds or not.
01:59:26
The authorization would be there once you pay down the existing debt.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:59:30
That puts us at capacity.
01:59:37
We also presented the illustrative project list last time.
01:59:43
Board Meeting and it does contain some contingency projects or more projects than the Governor's funding package and we hope that if bids are coming in less than anticipated or if there's a project that is not able to move forward for an environmental or
02:00:06
Some other reason that we have the ability to go to the contingency projects or the projects that further down the list that are ready to go and substitute those.
02:00:19
And again, this next page just discusses the criteria that we used and we discussed last month to include projects on the list.
02:00:31
And we received input, as you know, from yourselves, district administrators, some regional entities and localities related to the leak.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:00:51
Well, you'll have that opportunity.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:01:11
We will use those proceeds as part of the update to the Six-Year Program.
02:01:16
So when we present you a program draft,
02:01:19
The projects that we're able to fund based on their schedules and their availability to keep to our window of bringing them to construction as soon as possible, you will see the projects that are in the program using those funds for your review in the April, May timeframe.
02:01:40
And we will then have public hearings for citizens and the MPOs and everyone to look at those as well.
02:01:46
in April and May and then you will adopt in June.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:52
I think there were a few on the illustrative list that were new projects that were not in the Six-Year Plan as I recall.
02:02:00
So I know that isn't a total limitation as I understand it because I may have one that is not in the Six-Year Plan now but we can discuss that later in the Six-Year Plan process, right?
02:02:14
Sure.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:02:19
Well, we'll just have to see how far the funding stretches.
02:02:25
That's the name of the game.
02:02:29
The schedule for the highway program development is February, March, April, May, June timeframe.
02:02:37
The financial information for the six-year program is now available.
02:02:42
We've provided this information to the districts, the MPOs.
02:02:46
and we have called, we've opened the electronic tool that's available for secondary and urban projects to be reviewed and edited as need be and we will be coordinating with the MPOs on the RSVP and CMAC and other special program funding like revenue sharing and enhancements, etc.
02:03:11
In March, we will just be all of us moving forward with the programming and the development.
02:03:19
April, we will look at that board meeting to present to you a draft which then becomes public and there will be a comment period and we're looking to set up four public hearings.
02:03:35
We will have one in Richmond.
02:03:38
Northern Virginia Hampton Roads and Salem.
02:03:40
The Salem would include Bristol, Lynchburg, and Stanton.
02:03:43
The Richmond would include Culpeper and Fredericksburg.
02:03:48
And we right now are looking at probably May 18th for the Richmond public hearing, May 4th for NOVA.
02:04:00
And we'll send these out once the locations are confirmed.
02:04:04
Hampton Roads we're looking at April 27th.
02:04:07
and the Salem area.
02:04:09
The location is still up in the air, so that may change, but we're looking at May 12th, but I'll send this out formally.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:04:19
In the good old days, we used to have these in each district.
02:04:26
and I can certainly understand why we truncated it recently because there hasn't been any money to talk about, frankly, so why do you want to go through it all?
02:04:35
But now that there, we have this, I think an innovative proposal constructed from the government and there's more funding and I'm noticing people in my area have more questions about how this sounds good, how's it going to benefit, how can I get involved with my project.
02:04:55
might we consider going back to having these in each of the districts?
02:05:02
There are not many people in my district who are going to go to Richmond or going to go to Tapping and going to Virginia.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:10
I don't know about the rest of the districts, but I think it might be helpful
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:13
We can take a look at it.
02:05:19
I think one of the things that
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:41
We also have to be cognizant of is that VDOT has a thousand less people.
02:05:49
I'm just trying to point out it's the same people setting up and supporting everyone.
02:05:56
These public hearings are the same people who have to put the Six-Year Plan together and put it to bed.
02:06:05
And there really isn't a lot of folks left.
02:06:10
We're down to bare bones over there.
02:06:12
And I am very cognizant of the fact that we're at an organization now of actually well below.
02:06:18
I mean, in reality, we've laid off a thousand.
02:06:21
But where are you now?
02:06:22
It's doing 6,800.
02:06:24
6,800.
02:06:24
So we're actually down almost 1,200 people.
02:06:32
So I want you all to think about that.
02:06:33
I mean, we are authorized at 7,500.
02:06:37
We're only at 6,800.
02:06:39
That means that over the last two years, we've had a reduction of almost 1,700 people.
02:06:46
And when you look at our planning and programming staff, I think I'm seeing almost all of them sitting out here.
02:06:52
Everyone who's planning and programming, raise your hand.
02:06:55
So I got my four or five.
02:06:58
And we have to be cognizant of the fact that we don't have staff to go out and in.
02:07:07
One of those staff, these things.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:08
But we'll take a look at it and see what we can do.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:12
I know, but they're the same issues there.
02:07:14
I mean, with our district, all of them, I mean, again, we're 1,700 people less than we were a year and a half ago.
02:07:21
And that's central office and also out in the field.
02:07:24
But we'll see about trying to make it a little bit, maybe picking more central location.
02:07:31
I know we've always had the Fairfax City Hall
02:07:34
There's a lovely, lovely location.
02:07:36
Maybe we can mix it up a little bit and try to get more central location.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:07:39
We're actually looking at the Potomac.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:42
Prince William County.
02:07:44
Prince William County is much more central.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:50
There's a couple of alternatives perhaps.
02:07:54
If district members, and one of the things I've been looking at is doing, we'll call it a town hall, it wouldn't be a formal public hearing.
02:08:02
Speaker and others have the district administrator there to go through what's in the Six-Year Plan to address questions in general.
02:08:10
I mean, would it be possible to get representation out of several offices?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:16
Did the A's go out and try to do it like that?
02:08:18
That'd be fun too.
02:08:19
Again, I'm just very cognizant of these folks here.
02:08:21
When it's a formal public hearing, it means that we have to do the notice, we have to keep records, we're
02:08:27
There's a lot more that goes into it than just showing up for the day.
02:08:32
And it's just as important if we end up having, whether or not nine districts, I mean, nine districts, nine hearings, at the same time trying to set them up, staff them, and then do the work that needs to be done.
02:08:46
We're very cognizant.
02:08:48
I'll send you the invitation.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:49
Mr. Chairman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:50
I'll stop on my way home.
02:08:52
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:52
But wouldn't, I'm not in favor of either here,
02:08:57
Just to address Mr. Rich's request, wouldn't that type of meeting, though, be productive in a sense that you're going to have to meet with MPOs anyhow, and you're going to go meet with the planning districts, whereby that if we went to the district with one meeting, we wouldn't have, if you come to Bristol, you're going to have several planning districts that have a meeting.
02:09:19
So it may be that we are consolidating by going to the district more so than we are scheduling additional meetings.
02:09:25
So there's an additional thought there to look at.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:28
There's a lot of ways you can find this.
02:09:31
So, I think, Mr. Chairman.
02:09:33
I wanted to carry on this conversation of transparency and outreach.
02:09:38
Would it be possible to also just have a public hearing, if you will, electronically?
02:09:46
Save staff time, and if there were one date where you could
02:09:50
Get on the web and come in and, you know, in essence, make your comments electronically to the department on the Six-Year Plan would save people a lot of time and would give people an opportunity to use what they're doing every day and that's being on the internet to get their thoughts across.
02:10:13
I think legally we're not allowed to have, are we or no?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:10:17
I think we can.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:18
You have to say we can't have a public, I don't think we're still allowed to have electronic public air.
SPEAKER_01
02:10:29
We would need to set up in each of the nine districts for the electronic links.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:10:52
One of the things that we do
02:10:57
need to take into consideration in terms of the timing of the input that if there's anything that comes up from the communications with the citizens, the MPOs and others and yourselves between the public hearing and the final, we do have to have time to accommodate any changes that are made.
02:11:17
So we do look for the communication and the public hearings to be
02:11:21
earlier or as early as possible after the board meeting in April when it does go public.
02:11:29
So we do try to have the meetings and the outreach at the end of April, the first part of May so that we have time to accommodate any updates or changes that may occur
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:43
and also that could be from the General Assembly as well.
02:12:08
And then we can just conduct that as we see fit so we don't have any guidelines?
02:12:14
Do we have to turn the comments in or maybe we just do our own thing?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:12:19
The clarification would be, is this meant to be a town hall but not a public hearing?
02:12:25
If it's not a public hearing, I think that's a different, I got to let council speak.
SPEAKER_01
02:12:33
I think what we have to do is look at what the purpose is.
02:12:36
If the purpose is to in any way provide input for the six-year plans, etc., there are probably going to be federal rules you'd have to comply with, etc.
02:12:45
So it's really going to depend on what the purpose of the meetings are.
02:12:49
If they're totally, if you want to do something totally outside
02:12:53
All of the meetings associated with the normal approval processes for the budget, etc., or for the six-year plans, you might be able to do something like that.
02:13:05
But again, it would depend on what is the purpose of this meeting.
02:13:09
Well, you know, I don't know that you could do that.
02:13:12
No.
02:13:12
I think you need to have something more formal.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:15
In my case, what I'm thinking of is to discuss transportation in a regional sense.
02:13:20
It would touch on the legislation that's going through and what's there.
02:13:24
It would touch on the program.
02:13:26
It would be broader than just a six-year program, but it obviously provides an opportunity for them to comment on the
SPEAKER_01
02:13:34
Major projects that are funded moving forward that happen to be associated with the Six-Year Plan.
02:13:52
The issues you're going to have to be very careful about is having more than two CTB members at any meeting.
02:13:58
Again, what is the purpose of the meeting and is it intended to fall outside?
02:14:03
We've also got public participation guidelines for the CTB that we'd have to look at, et cetera.
02:14:08
So we can look at it.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:10
I think Mr. Cook had a great idea about consolidating that.
02:14:12
That would say staff, you've got to meet anyway.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:15
Actually, they've been doing the meetings with the PDCs and MPOs via video.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:14:21
Well, we've had two face-to-face and we have been communicating via email and video, so we have been reaching out to the PDCs and MPOs and have received their
02:14:34
Long-Range Priorities as well.
02:14:36
And we will do that prior to the draft being released.
02:14:40
So we will have another session with all the MPOs and PDCs.
02:14:46
And that's partly what this next slide speaks to.
02:14:49
And if we wanted to catch up a little bit of time, I could just turn it over now to Terry Brown with DRPT to start their section.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:15:01
Come on up, Ms. Brown.
02:15:03
As you can tell, we're not an inquisitive group today.
02:15:06
I'm telling you.
SPEAKER_00
02:15:09
I had thought I might be running a little late if I got near 1030.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:15:13
Good afternoon, everyone.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:15:15
I'm sending a message.
02:15:17
What time do you want to leave?
SPEAKER_00
02:15:18
I'm here all day.
02:15:20
I'm fine.
02:15:23
Good afternoon, everyone.
02:15:25
I am Terry Brown.
02:15:26
I'm the manager of financial programming for DRPT.
02:15:30
I just wanted to run through our application process and our funding information.
02:15:37
We are completely different from VDOT.
02:15:42
We operate through a grant application process and we are just now starting to go through our applications that we received from our transit grantees.
02:15:57
and TDM grantees.
02:16:00
We closed our grant cycle this year on February 9th.
02:16:05
Usually it's a couple of weeks earlier but we had a new grant application software that was built by our in-house folks and it proved to be
02:16:17
Quite challenging as so many of the software packages do.
02:16:22
So we are now, our grant managers are going through all of those grant applications.
02:16:28
We receive several hundred every year for our different funding sources and they are going through those and they will soon turn them over to my staff and we will go through all of the approved applications and come up with the Six-Year Plan which we will bring to you in draft form along with VDOT in April.
02:16:48
So our funding sources are we receive 14.7% of the Mass Transit Trust Fund and we're at about $115 million for the last couple of years.
02:17:04
Right off the top we have $1.5 million that goes to Paratransit Human Service.
02:17:09
It is right now 2.5.
02:17:12
We have a bill before the House and Senate to change that to 1.5 because we feel like that's going to meet our grantees' needs better.
02:17:22
If we reduce it to 1.5, we feel like we will be providing them with enough vehicles because that goes directly to capital vehicles, but we'll also have a little bit more money to put to operating.
02:17:36
Then 73.5% goes to our operating needs for our transit grantees.
02:17:44
Twenty-three, excuse me, twenty-five and a half goes to capital and one and a half goes to special projects and that's three different types of projects.
02:17:53
Those are our, we still call the projects demo which is
02:17:58
Under the state code it is anything new and different.
02:18:02
We used to fund some new routes or anything special that you wanted to try.
02:18:08
We are considering going back to the right now we're focusing more on new
02:18:14
ITS, anything new you've got as far as technology that you want to try is what we're trying to focus on.
02:18:24
We also are funded out of this.
02:18:31
interns and because we're trying to lure transit professionals into the field and not people to come in and do scanning.
02:18:40
We actually have people who have to finish an essay to tell us how they appreciated their summer with the transit grantee and let us know that they actually learned something about transit and the other one is technical assistance.
02:18:53
So we have a lot of
02:18:55
requirements before we give our grantees
02:19:10
Construction funds, we get some money for TEAF, which is projects that are for congestion mitigation.
02:19:19
This is TDM, our Transportation Demand Management.
02:19:24
This is rideshare, van pulls, telework.
02:19:27
This is anything that gets cars off the road.
02:19:32
Three million goes to rail preservation, which is capital funding for what we call our short line railroads.
02:19:39
So these are the non-class one railroads.
02:19:44
That's not what I meant to do.
02:19:50
Okay.
02:19:50
The recordation tax.
02:19:52
It has been $23 million annually.
02:19:59
We started getting it in 2009.
02:20:03
I started with the department in 2007 and I noticed that our first
02:20:11
Six-Year Plan, we were anticipating that this number was going to be about 46 million in 09, so of course the ugliness started in the fall of 08, so this right away, even before we got our first dollar of it, was half what we were expecting, so that was unfortunate.
02:20:30
We also have our capital bonds, which help us.
02:20:34
and so this is $60 million of transit capital bonds every year and these are the construction, the CPR bonds that Rita was speaking about plus $50 million which are also coming from those bonds for the WMATA, State of Good Repair.
02:20:51
and those bonds are matching the $150 million from the Feds, $50 million from Maryland, $50 million from DC for a total of $300 million every year and $3 billion
02:21:10
I can't do math while I'm standing up, over the life of the 10-year grant.
02:21:16
Of course, there's a bill in Congress right now to take that away, but I don't think anybody thinks that'll pass.
02:21:22
If they get rid of the federal portion of that grant, then our match would go away.
02:21:29
and then RAF and Rail Enhancement Fund and Rail Preservation also gets $12.9 million of bonds and those are just divvied up as needed per capital as well.
02:21:42
Rail Enhancement is funded with a vehicle rental tax.
02:21:45
And rail enhancement is capital funding for our Class 1 railroads.
02:21:50
And in Virginia, of course, that's Norfolk Southern and CSX.
02:21:56
And so we have quite a few projects on that page of the Six-Year Plan as well.
02:22:03
And then we do have federal funds.
02:22:06
Most of our federal funding that this $40 million represents is
02:22:11
Funding that comes to us and we give it out based upon the applications that we are going through right now.
02:22:19
We have funding that goes to the rural grantees that we apply for and give out through the FTA who is our cognizant agency.
02:22:28
We have planning funds that we give out to the MPOs.
02:22:32
We have all sorts of grant earmarks, federal earmarks that we apply for and give out.
02:22:41
So our funding is different in that it's application-based and we go in and apply for it.
02:22:47
We also have a lot of pass-through funding that we flex from FHWA through VDOT and deal with the grantees that way.
02:23:01
So our major funding concerns, since everybody else has been telling you and you've been asking, one of the big things for us is that we are not very flexible as far as operating costs.
02:23:16
We have got quite a few pots of capital, and by that I don't mean to say that we're comfortable about capital, but we've got federal funds that we can cover capital with and we've got
02:23:29
A couple of different state capital funds and things that we can move around and this last bullet we've been able to address the CTB's stated priorities that the state of good repair is the
02:23:45
Number one priority and we actually have another in-house built system that allows us to do that with our asset management system and we make sure that when our grantees are coming in and asking for replacement rolling stock that they needed and it's met its useful, the stock they're trying to replace has met its useful life and that they're buying what they need and replacing what they should and that sort of thing.
02:24:13
So we're, at this point, we are able to meet those needs at 80% matching funds for capital.
02:24:25
But operating, last year we were at 15% operating funds matching, you know, giving them their state funds.
02:24:34
And that is just
02:24:36
So low, it's our lowest point.
02:24:39
And the problem is that we have what we have for operating.
02:24:43
We have that 73.5%, and that's pretty much it.
02:24:46
Now, as you see, over the last two years we've had some deobligated MTTS funding.
02:24:53
Once it goes through the program, once we've put it through that 73.5, 1.5, and 25%, it has been our understanding from talking to the CTB over the past several years that at that point, once it's deobligated, once it's been given to a grantee and taken off a project because they had a little left over or something, that we can move it around as long as it's still spent on transit.
02:25:18
So we've got dribs and drabs that we've put onto operating.
02:25:23
And then special projects, the way that's written up in the code, we can put 1.5% on special projects, but we're not required to.
02:25:34
We'll have a little bit of that left over, and we've moved it over, but it's not enough to be significant.
02:25:38
So the operating is really our biggest concern, and especially when we have some big boys lurking.
02:25:49
The Tide is coming online down in Hampton Roads next year, and Dulles Phase One will be online the following year.
02:26:03
and then Dulles Phase II maybe three years after that.
02:26:07
That's going to probably triple our operating program and when they come online and start asking us for funding and so without another source of funding, you know, that would be a third of what it is right now.
02:26:23
So at that point, it's pretty meaningless for if we're only giving out 5%.
02:26:27
So that's our biggest concern.
02:26:32
So, SJ297 is asking us to do a study of all transit related issues in the Commonwealth and we're actually, we're very happy about this.
02:26:43
It looks like it might pass.
02:26:46
The calculation for operating, operating is a big pie of money and everybody who comes in gets their share of the pie and so that's why the tide coming online and the two
02:26:58
is going to be a problem.
02:27:00
We're happy about those two systems, but they're going to come in and they're going to take every dollar that they take, takes a dollar away from Blacksburg Transit or GRTC.
02:27:14
We are concerned for the people who are operating.
02:27:17
We're out there doing a good job of advocating for transit, but when they come in and ask for money, we don't want to be saying, well, thanks.
02:27:28
We also feel that the calculation is out of date.
02:27:31
It's been done this way for a while and it doesn't really give any sort of impetus for somebody to run a lean, better organized system.
02:27:43
Also, some of the salaries are specifically excluded from the calculation and we'd like to take another look at that.
02:27:51
Like I said, I've been here for three years, but people who predate me have no idea why they're not included.
02:27:57
There could be a really good reason.
02:27:58
But nobody really knows.
02:28:01
So this is what we're hoping to look at under SJT 97, performance, prioritizing.
02:28:08
Well, we want to prioritize the capital requests by categories, which we've started to do, but we'd like to take it further.
02:28:14
Right now we're required under the MTTF state code that that be evenly distributed.
02:28:21
So we have the capital bonds for right now that we can use to float and give people different percentages, which is what we did last year and what we'll do this year.
02:28:33
But when the bonds are done, we'll be back to MTTF and everybody by state law gets the same percentage, regardless of whether you're asking for a bus shelter,
02:28:43
or shop equipment or to build a facility or to buy rolling stock.
02:28:48
So we would like to have the ability to prioritize the capital request based on your categories you're buying in.
02:28:57
Whether we should hold systems harmless at the existing levels, evaluating whether the 14.7 is enough,
02:29:05
and then the code language allows transit funding up to 95% for capital and operating.
02:29:12
There was talk apparently right before I got here that with the influx of the $40 million
02:29:26
Thank you.
02:29:27
Recordation taxes that we might get to 95% on a couple of our systems, but that quickly went away.
02:29:35
I mean, yeah, so we are now at 15%.
02:29:39
We're not anywhere near 95%, but
02:29:41
You know, God willing, we'll get out of this economy and maybe we'll get close.
02:29:46
And one of the other things that happens is the folks that are out there who are savvy, they know that that language is there and they sort of say, well, you're not funding us up to 95% like you're supposed to.
02:29:57
So we have that conversation way too often.
02:29:59
This is going to help us as far as we would like to say there may be a fare that is appropriate for all transit systems to charge.
02:30:16
If somebody decides not to charge a fare, is it appropriate that they get the same operating assistance as somebody who has decided to charge a dollar?
02:30:27
Basically, we're all paying
02:30:29
their fare down here because they've decided not to charge a fare over here.
02:30:33
So things like that are the questions that need to be answered.
02:30:36
We don't know the answer right now.
02:30:43
Oh, there we go.
02:30:45
That went back too fast.
02:30:47
I don't know how to go back.
SPEAKER_14
02:30:50
What's that?
02:30:51
I know.
SPEAKER_00
02:30:52
I don't know how to go back.
02:31:00
Oh, it's pretty.
02:31:03
Can you help me?
02:31:04
Thank you.
02:31:08
So our rail funding concern is also operating in nature.
02:31:12
Thank you so much.
02:31:16
Our rail funding is also operating in nature.
02:31:18
We have the Rail Enhancement Fund, and it is supposed to be capital.
02:31:24
Thank you.
02:31:25
It's supposed to be capital in nature.
02:31:28
Now, you maybe have to go forward again.
02:31:29
Oh, there we go.
02:31:33
Okay.
02:31:33
Rail enhancement is by statute capital as well.
02:31:38
We have the two trains that we have started up, the train from Lynchburg and the train from Richmond.
02:31:45
and the train from Richmond will soon become the train from Norfolk.
02:31:50
The temporary fix that was put in in the appropriation act last year gave us $6 million from the rail enhancement fund to spend in operating assistance.
02:32:02
So that was great.
02:32:05
It said that we could spend it across three years.
02:32:07
We thought that would only cover one year of operating expenses.
02:32:11
However, the Lynchburg train has been fantastically successful.
02:32:14
and is actually paying for itself and making a profit.
02:32:18
So the $6 million is going to last us.
02:32:21
It looks like it's actually paying for part of the Richmond train now.
02:32:25
So it looks like it's going to last us a little while.
02:32:28
It may be enough to last us into this year a little bit.
02:32:32
We're going to start having to pay money though.
02:32:36
So we're going to run out of that $6 million sometime this year.
02:32:40
We have no other way to pay for the rail operating funds.
02:32:45
This has been in the newspaper recently in the Charlottesville area.
02:32:49
I know I saw it on the news.
02:32:53
If we don't find another source of the operating funds for the rail service, then we won't be able to pay what our commitment is.
02:33:02
In the Six-Year Plan last year, we did indicate that all of this was unfunded, which was unusual in the Six-Year Plan.
02:33:10
We don't usually put in anything under there that's unfunded, but we wanted to make that clear because REF is capital.
02:33:21
So the other thing that's clouding this up is, of course, once it starts running from Norfolk, it's going to be a further operating cost, and that's scheduled for 2014.
02:33:33
And then in 2014 under PREA, we will have to begin picking up the cost of Amtrak trains in Virginia.
02:33:43
So we will have the two trains from Norfolk and from Lynchburg that we started and then the four trains that run right now under Amtrak.
02:33:53
So the full cost of that is $25 million.
02:33:57
which is what we came up with under the study that was done last year for the General Assembly.
02:34:04
And that is a huge concern for us because we have no way to pay for that.
02:34:13
The CTB can allocate up to 10 percent
02:34:17
of the money from the highway fund for anything that will mitigate highway congestion.
02:34:27
So it's possible that you all can give us some of that.
02:34:32
But of course, you have other funding issues as well.
02:34:37
But we just have to come up with something that's going to fund rail operations, or those trains will shut down.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:45
Rita is gone, but she's already mentioned this.
SPEAKER_00
02:34:52
This is the public hearing information.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:55
Any other questions?
02:34:58
Excellent.
SPEAKER_00
02:34:59
I feel so left out.
02:35:00
Is this because I explained it, or is it because lunch is coming?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:04
No.
02:35:04
It has nothing to do with lunch.
02:35:06
But since you mentioned it, why don't we break you on?
02:35:08
Everyone grab.
02:35:09
We'll start off again at 1 o'clock, OK?
02:35:14
Please, Mr. Estes, you're up.
02:35:36
Are you ready for me?
02:35:42
All right.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:35:47
I'm going to try to be as brief as I can and hopefully we'll have some fun with the Transportation Enhancement Program today.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:55
Can we talk about how we allocate the funds?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:02
All right, Mr. Estes, go for it.
02:36:04
All right, here we go.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:36:05
So you guys know this by heart by now then.
02:36:09
So we won't spend much time on the policy discussions we talked about last fall on kind of how the allocations are spent.
02:36:15
I'm going to jump right to the meat, which would be slide three here.
02:36:22
We talked a little bit about revenue projections and redimensioned the reserve earlier.
02:36:26
So we're looking pretty good for our allocation.
02:36:30
The 10-year average, as you'll see here in a minute, is around 19 million a year.
02:36:34
You'll see this is about 27.2 million for FY12, if you take into account the FY11 reserve.
02:36:41
And based on the policy that was adopted last fall, you can see that the 4 million off the top for the statewide initiatives distribute the remaining 75 percent to the district members, and then the remaining goes to the at-large members.
02:36:55
You can see that break down there.
02:36:57
I'll go through in a minute what you have in front of you as a package dealing with that.
02:37:04
When you get to the package and everyone has a folder, looks something similar, hopefully, to this at the table.
02:37:14
And when you get into the scoring criteria or the scoring sheets, you'll see every project that was submitted in the application.
02:37:22
And you'll see a score for when that project was originally scored on the 0 to 100 range.
02:37:26
And you'll also see the priority ranking score, which most of you should be familiar with, we had last year, which basically we consider that a readiness score on a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being that the project is ready for construction.
02:37:41
That additional allocation will bring it to construction.
02:37:43
We look at other things to kind of give you a little bit better feel.
02:37:46
Some of the board members in the past have asked us for additional guidance and input on where the project stood, what the project attempts to do.
02:37:54
I won't spend a lot of time on this.
02:37:55
This is our normal chart that we've gone through before on kind of how the board's allocated money.
02:38:01
I will just simply say that we've focused a lot the last few times on what I would say, again, I'd like to acknowledge the board's efforts last year to focus the money on existing projects.
02:38:12
You can see the stats that I've
02:38:13
I pull out not only focusing on existing projects, but focusing on fully funding projects.
02:38:19
And that third column from the right shows that the board last year, 74% of the requests were fully funded.
02:38:27
Again, a major move, I think, in the positive direction.
02:38:33
That doesn't come as a one-dimensional thing with the policy changes and some of the things we've done over the last couple of years in the program.
02:38:42
Mr.
02:38:42
Keen and I were talking before the board meeting about, again, reminding me on the multidimensional aspect of that.
02:38:50
The board can only do so much from a policy perspective, but we need to make sure we're doing it on our end to support the local governments who are doing these projects and get them through the process.
02:38:59
What we've done to try to help highlight some of that, and I would, I guess, encourage other board members to look at things like Mr.
02:39:06
Keen has done, talk to the project sponsors to see where the hold-ups are,
02:39:10
on their end or on our end and let us know.
02:39:14
He's brought to light quite a bit of good information in the Bristol District.
02:39:18
The district summaries that you're going to have in your packets for the district members, we gave you your district and the statewide list of projects.
02:39:27
For the at-large members, you have the whole state.
02:39:29
And what they represent is basically every project that's received enhancement allocation since the inception of the program.
02:39:36
and they're broken into status.
02:39:38
You can see the allocations by year.
02:39:40
You can see the expenditures.
02:39:41
Again, just another tool to provide the board members a venue to see where the projects stand and how they're looking.
02:39:53
We spent our, Julie Brown spent some time with you guys in December talking about the deallocation of funds.
02:39:59
I'd say the takeaway from this slide is, you know, through this deallocation process that the board endorsed in December,
02:40:06
We've reviewed hundreds of projects.
02:40:10
We've identified almost $13 million for possible reallocation.
02:40:14
And as we've done the last couple of years, your package includes, for the district members, funds that have either been identified for deallocation or funds that have been identified for possible deallocation.
02:40:26
And we'll be working with you to help allocate those funds through the normal process as well.
02:40:31
So that's also included in your package.
02:40:33
I think it's important to note when we talk about
02:40:37
You know, where we are on moving projects and how things are moving along and how the expenditures are going, you know, we have a rolling list of projects that we send out notifications to sponsors and we call them the 45-day letters.
02:40:50
And basically, if we haven't seen an expenditure over a certain amount of time, we haven't seen an agreement sent back to us, we'll reach out and touch those sponsors to make sure they're moving.
02:40:58
And if they're not, as all of the board members, I hope the district members know, we reach out to you and talk to you about the status of that.
02:41:06
So at any given time, we have a handful of those out.
02:41:08
We have about 20 of those in play right now.
02:41:14
What I want to do is, if I could, Mr. Chairman, take a few minutes to walk through the package that you have with you.
02:41:20
And what everyone should have is a summary which, taken with the PowerPoint, basically repeats the same kind of thing about the allocation for members, how the allocations are broken out.
02:41:33
A listing of all the scores.
02:41:36
Again, we talked about the different scores that are in the program.
02:41:38
We've got a copy of the current policy that the Board adopted.
02:41:42
We've got a copy of the deallocation process that Julie went through with you last year.
02:41:47
We talked about the deallocation, reallocation.
02:41:49
We've got this breakdown by district for each district member to consider.
02:41:54
And then the district summaries I just talked about, which again is highlighted
02:41:58
A spreadsheet that gets into a great deal of detail if you'd like to go there with your individual projects.
02:42:05
Probably most importantly, at the end of the packet, in addition to you all know how to get a hold of me, there are the staff members that if you can't get a hold of me or if you've worked with them in the past and I encourage you to work with them in the future, they represent your districts and we are more than
02:42:25
Willing and able to sit down with you individually or on the phone or however you see fit to walk through the applications that you have in front of you and recognizing for the small amount of money we talk about it is quite a cumbersome and extensive process that we go through, but we want to make sure you're comfortable with it.
02:42:45
So with that, from a process standpoint and next steps, today everybody has, again, the applications that came in December 1st last year.
02:42:55
We're asking district members to get us both selections to our staff, to me or to the staff listed on the contact by March 9th.
02:43:05
We'll take that, compile it, and at the March board meeting we'll have a handout for all the members where you'll see the district members' tentative selections.
02:43:15
That'll be out there.
02:43:16
And as we've done in the past, then the at-large members will review those, we'll put together
02:43:21
Staff recommendations based on what we're seeing for help on suggested ways to help close gaps, things that we've done in the past, with the intent to sit down with the at-large members and walk through the final selections, hopefully in April.
02:43:36
We do try to parallel the six-year plan process as much as possible.
02:43:41
We have heard feedback before from the at-large members that it works better to meet at the day of the board meeting, so we might try to do that again in April and then
02:43:48
have something available that we can include with Rita's staff's efforts on the public hearings for the Six-Year Plan.
02:43:56
We'd like to have the tentative selections be a part of that process.
02:44:01
With that, that's a quick go at the enhancement.
02:44:04
I'm sure we have a couple of questions, Mr. Chairman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:08
Any questions from Mr. none at all?
02:44:10
Excellent.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:11
I have one quick thing.
02:44:13
You put up what was getting closed out.
02:44:15
This year we've got it restricted to ongoing programs.
02:44:19
Some of them would be requested at fully funding and if granted at full funding.
02:44:26
How many active projects would remain open versus?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:44:34
I'm not sure, Mr. Chairman, if I could answer that accurately.
02:44:37
If you look at the number of requests,
02:44:44
I guess I'll do the back of the envelope if you don't mind.
02:44:46
That's my back of the envelope.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:53
Thank you.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:44:54
We have $27.2 million plus the deallocation amounts.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:58
Not all projects that are out there that have not yet been fully funded did come in for an application.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:45:06
That would be correct.
02:45:06
I don't have a good feel for it.
02:45:10
And not all of the requests that are coming in for these existing projects complete those projects.
02:45:15
As an example, we looked at some of them are coming in for $300,000 this year, but they anticipate coming to the board again over the next couple of years.
02:45:26
Massachusetts County was a good example.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:28
Yes, sir.
02:45:31
This is an inclusive list now.
02:45:34
This is our list to choose from.
02:45:36
Okay, and then just a quick question.
02:45:39
I know we agreed that we'd refund at least 50% and $200,000, but I just want a clarification.
02:45:46
Someone asked for $300,000.
02:45:48
Are we allowed to fund $150,000 or is it $200,000?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:45:52
Great question, Mr. Chairman.
02:45:53
Mr. Layne, our interpretation would be to fund $150,000 of that request.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:58
Okay, so if the initial is less than $200,000 or less, you've got to go to $200,000.
02:46:02
Yes.
02:46:03
Okay, thank you.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:04
Good question.
02:46:09
It says she'll receive not less than 50%.
02:46:13
Right.
02:46:14
So if they ask for 300, you can give them 200.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:16
Oh, I know.
02:46:17
You can give them 300.
02:46:17
But I'm just looking at it.
02:46:18
I wanted to make sure that when I was looking at it, how I wanted to break it down.
02:46:24
Am I correct there?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:26
Yes, sir.
02:46:27
It's just not less than 50%.
02:46:29
And if it's 200 or less, then you fund the whole thing.
02:46:31
It's got to be 100%.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:46:32
It's 300.
02:46:33
You got it.
02:46:34
We prefer the more on it the better.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:36
My question, Mr. Chairman, the ranking system that you're using, and I'm not familiar, I'm not personally familiar with a lot of these projects, but the one I had a meeting on the other day was the Schooner, Virginia project, and you have the ranking of that, I think it's a three or a four, maybe it's a four.
02:47:02
And I don't understand that ranking because the project is basically completed.
02:47:07
It's being transformed and it's got a lot of debt associated with it.
02:47:12
And what we're trying to do is fill up the debt.
02:47:14
So the boat's in the water.
02:47:16
It sailed around the world or halfway around the world.
02:47:19
And the number four doesn't mean anything.
02:47:22
I mean, I'm kind of like four.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:24
How do you get to four?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:26
Because I'm just looking at your very sort of base value.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:47:30
Right.
02:47:30
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Miller, I'd have to get back to you on the floor.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:34
I can do that.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:36
I just didn't know if I was misreading something or whatever.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:41
That particular project had a major change of focus, based on the audicus, really for fort activities.
02:47:49
It seemed like it would score a little higher, I guess.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:47:52
I would think, but I'm not advocating for it.
02:47:54
I'm just trying to understand it.
02:47:55
Good question.
02:47:56
I will look into that, because like you said, we try to look at ones that haven't gotten
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:01
And how do you, is there, given that we have this process that I'm enamored with, how is it?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:12
We have that pressure, Mr. Chairman.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:14
And I'll keep talking about it until it changes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:16
How do you feel about the outlaws?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:21
I feel the same way that Mrs. Sterling feels.
02:48:23
Just because we did it that way before,
02:48:25
If it's not right, don't keep doing it that way.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:30
That was a CMAC quote, I think.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:41
Is there a geolocation process associated with the at-large numbers, and I didn't see that reflected, so where's that money?
02:49:06
It's the way our deallocation process is, whether it's a product- All the money from the at-large members then goes back to the district members.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:49:17
It goes back to the district members.
02:49:18
That's even more special.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:49:22
So we're even lesser equal than we were before.
02:49:24
And then the last question is, what does an urban at-large member really mean?
02:49:30
What is urban in our state in terms of how you define it?
02:49:33
and I know it's not necessarily every part of every district, but how do we define that?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:49:38
Where should my attention be?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:49:44
My attention should be with the chair, right?
02:49:48
I'm sorry, there's actually a definition in the house because we actually... Roanoke, Lynchburg, Fredericksburg...
02:49:55
The Census Bureau has urbanized areas.
02:49:57
Well, no, no, no, no.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:50:00
There is actually, we went and there is an actual definition that they end up having somewhere in the statute.
02:50:11
We'll get that to you.
02:50:12
I'll tell you why.
02:50:12
Because we actually, when they were looking at the appointments and stuff, they found certain people did not, were not in.
02:50:19
Like, here is considered rural.
02:50:23
But it was like, you know, but Culpeper wasn't.
02:50:26
I mean, it was just very odd the way the thing was being, and I don't know how, but there is an actual definition.
02:50:33
We can get that to you because it's actually, I think the Secretary of the Commonwealth is the one who sits on the criteria.
02:50:39
And the certain counties and certain municipalities that are considered urban, others are not?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:50:45
It's actually a fairly simple definition, Mr. Chairman.
02:50:48
It's the percentage of residents who live in an urban area as defined by an incorporated city, town, whatever.
02:50:59
So you could have a very rural county, but if 90% of people live in Culpeper, it's urban, not rural.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:51:07
It has nothing to do
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:51:23
Any other questions?
02:51:24
Mr. Chairman, just a comment, maybe not necessarily a question, but also a challenge as we look at the changes that the CTB has made to the extent to make this enhance the program, enhance the enhancement program to the point that we're going to see money extended more rapidly.
02:51:45
And we're going to see more progress behind that.
02:51:48
And part of the reason for doing that was the criticism we received for not spending money.
02:51:54
Now that we've made those changes and we're awarding projects and we have projects in the system that are 100% funded, I think the burden will be upon the staff to produce.
02:52:06
And I think that's where a big part of the problem, not necessarily the staff, but the process that they had to go through
02:52:14
was encumbered them from delivering in the past.
02:52:19
And I hope that we've solved that, but I'm not so sure we have.
02:52:22
And the reason I say that, because knowing that we were going to discuss this, a couple of examples came, and I asked of the 53 projects that in 10 that we had fully funded, the one that I asked them to look at from a district level had not even received an administrative agreement.
02:52:43
Now, that was awarded in June, July I guess.
02:52:48
I would think that an administrative agreement, I don't know, but something like a cookie cutter agreement, a generic agreement that could be generated pretty quick.
02:52:58
But that hasn't been done.
02:53:00
And I just, that's one sample.
02:53:01
That's the only one I sampled.
02:53:03
And if we look at some of the projects in the system, it just takes an extraordinary amount of time.
02:53:12
I know there's hurdles in there inherent in the system that may be preventing us.
02:53:17
It's not the staff that's doing it.
02:53:21
All the agencies have got to go through.
02:53:24
All the steps have got to be taken.
02:53:25
And the real question is, can we live up to the expectations of getting this money expended within a couple of years' time after we get it started?
02:53:35
I'm beginning to doubt that we can live up to the expectation because of the system and the process that they have to go through.
02:53:42
And I think I wanted to state that while this is great, this is good, this is good work, and good things that we can look at making improvements, but I'm not so sure that the changes we made in our policy on 100% award has solved our problem.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:54:02
Yeah.
02:54:02
Mr. Chairman, if I could,
02:54:03
I wouldn't disagree with some of the comments from Mr. King.
02:54:06
I think he's brought to light some things that we have to work on on our end.
02:54:09
I think we've always said it's a multidimensional approach.
02:54:12
I think we're up for the challenge.
02:54:14
I think part of the problem was we weren't fully funding all these projects and some of them were laboring through the process.
02:54:22
Now we have a challenge to get those through the process now.
02:54:26
To the agreements, one of the things that we do, I think from a
02:54:30
A proactive standpoint is when the board approves projects, if you look at the chart here, there were 16 new projects that were approved last year.
02:54:40
And what we do is, as you know, when sponsors apply, we have applicant workshops to help those sponsors work through the application process.
02:54:48
Once they're awarded the projects, we have sponsor workshops after the CTB provides money to get those folks on board with how to get those projects started.
02:54:57
And we actually bring those agreements to those sponsor workshops with those localities to make sure they kick those off and get those things going.
02:55:04
So we do a lot of hand-holding with those little governments, trying to help them get through that process.
02:55:10
There's always room for improvement, and I think Mr. King's brought some issues to our attention that we need to look at.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:55:15
Mr. Chairman.
02:55:19
Ms. Miller?
02:55:22
Just scanned through this.
02:55:24
Again, I'm just trying to do this so I understand what these charts and graphs are showing us, the charts are showing us.
02:55:29
On Hampton Roads, page four, it shows Cape Henry Lighthouse restoration.
02:55:35
And it's purple, meaning it's under deallocation.
02:55:39
But when you go to status, the status is completed and under agreement.
02:55:44
So if it's completed, does that mean they just didn't spend all the money, or is that what that means?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:55:49
Is money left over?
02:55:50
You're getting into detail.
02:55:51
It could be purple if, for example, they haven't spent all the money that's on the project, and that's part of that reallocation process each year, is we'll look at projects that are closed out, and then we'll grab that money and put it into the normal allocation process.
02:56:06
That's exactly right.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:07
Yes, sir.
02:56:08
So is it safe to assume that if it's completed,
02:56:12
And we're de-allocating it, and there's just money left over.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:18
Yes, thank you.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:56:23
So the second phase would be a different color, I hope.
02:56:28
When I call you on the other item, we'll walk through that as well.
02:56:31
Thank you.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:34
And more than one member can get the same project?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:56:37
Absolutely, yes sir.
02:56:40
That's part of the process-wise, you know, district members will look at a project, they'll be talking to the at-large members about some of the intent, and then that's why we get together as a group with the at-large, is to kind of bring that to fruition.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:55
Mr. Rich.
02:56:56
No question.
02:56:57
I just wanted to thank Mike for getting all this work and getting this organized for him.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:02
Appreciate it.
02:57:03
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, CTB members.
SPEAKER_14
02:57:33
I just want to give you a little background on disposing of surplus property for capital outlay.
02:57:53
It's what I'm going to talk about, but there is a different code for surplusing right-of-way property.
02:58:02
So I just, on this slide, I just wanted to kind of give you the code sections that relate to right-of-way and to capital outlay, but my presentation will be based on capital outlay.
02:58:17
Currently, VDOT has nine district complexes, 29 residency offices, 248 area headquarters, sub-headquarters, chemical storage lots, and storage lots.
02:58:29
was an original value of about 288 million.
02:58:34
The Appropriation Act, item 457K.1 of the 2010 Acts of Assembly requested us to take a look at our properties.
02:58:44
We had to conduct a study to see if we had anything that was surplus.
02:58:51
We have 48 properties, 33 we identified for disposal, and 15 we identified to lease.
02:59:02
The next slide, this slide tells you where the properties are located by district.
02:59:06
The offices, the equipment, shops, area headquarters, warehouses.
02:59:16
At the December 8th meeting, you requested a hypothetical $1 million sale.
02:59:25
And you wanted to know what would be the difference in the proceeds if we did it or DGS handled the sale.
02:59:34
Both agencies incur expenses.
02:59:39
We all have staff time, appraisal fees, survey fees.
02:59:43
DGS adds another 15% to the actual cost of staff time and appraisal fees.
02:59:50
And there's a 6% commission if they use a broker.
02:59:56
But the bottom line is that if we sell it or if DGS sell it, the main difference is if we use a broker.
03:00:06
Because the cost, the differences and the expenses don't vary that much.
03:00:11
If you look at the wages, the direct hours that they use, our hours are a little bit higher because we do not have appraisal consultants on staff.
03:00:21
But it all sort of kind of comes out to the end that the primary difference is if you use a broker.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:00:28
You don't show us using a broker at all.
03:00:31
Is that because we just wouldn't use a broker?
03:00:33
We would not.
SPEAKER_14
03:00:34
We would not use a broker.
03:00:37
We would use staff from the right-of-way division.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:00:39
We still get the right price?
SPEAKER_14
03:00:41
Yes, sir.
03:00:43
But I would also like to say that we have not sold that many properties.
03:00:47
The last property we sold
03:00:50
I think it was in about 2008 or 2009 and that was an area headquarters.
03:00:57
A lot of our properties are between other agencies or other localities.
03:01:04
No.
03:01:08
To another state agency, yes.
03:01:11
To a locality, there is a fair market value.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:19
Mr. Chairman, have we ever experimented with picking a site and deciding to go and see what happens if we use the broker?
03:01:30
I mean, to try to generate revenue from what's sitting there?
SPEAKER_14
03:01:35
No, I don't think we have, and I see the Commissioner leaning forward.
03:01:40
I'm not aware of any that we've done that way.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:42
Would that be a worthwhile undertaking, Mr. Commissioner, or not?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:47
Mr. Chairman, you know, like Crilla said before, we've sold very few of those properties.
03:01:56
And I believe that when we do sell that property, a good minimum would end up going to localities.
03:02:03
And also, I noticed that, I don't think Crilla got to that part of the presentation, but often when DGS brokers that deal with localities, they do not charge or use a broker at that point.
03:02:17
So we're looking at the volume of properties.
03:02:19
It's just not enough there to really be concerned with.
SPEAKER_14
03:02:24
Yes, the only time DGS would use a broker if it's a private entity that they're selling it to.
03:02:36
Any other questions?
03:02:37
Mr. Miller?
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:41
Yes, Mr. Chairman, I have a quick question.
03:02:44
Back on page three.
03:02:46
We identified total original value of the properties of VDOT as $288 million and recommended 48 properties for disposal.
03:03:00
Of those, do we, the estimated value, is that the original, how does that compare to the original value that was... That estimated is the fair market value and I...
03:03:12
in the town market.
03:03:14
That does not tell us how much we originally paid.
03:03:19
But we do have that information.
03:03:20
I just did not put it in this presentation.
03:03:22
That would be nice to know.
03:03:23
I'd like to know how much we put into these properties that we're now selling, which maybe in some cases distress sales.
SPEAKER_14
03:03:30
I can get that for you, sir.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:03:31
Mr. Chairman, just one point.
03:03:34
You know, you sort of, I guess the comment that often they don't use a broker if it's going to locality.
03:03:41
I don't know if
03:03:55
And we're looking at disposing $12 million worth of property.
03:03:58
That's about $720,000 worth of savings that we could have based on that 6% amount.
03:04:04
And we're sitting here talking about we can't hold a meeting in the district.
03:04:09
We can't come in the night before because of budget issues.
03:04:12
And you add enough $720,000 together, you got some real money.
03:04:17
Certainly could do those things.
03:04:19
that we talked about.
03:04:21
So perhaps the analysis is flawed that I'm using because you basically just took that 6% away.
03:04:28
But if the 6% was there, I think it would be incumbent on us to think real hard why we weren't doing that.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:35
Mr. Chairman.
03:04:36
Yes, Mr. McCarthy.
03:04:40
Isn't it part of the process, and I don't know if it's by law or by habit,
03:04:46
That the property is first made available to other state agencies, and if nobody wants it, then it goes to perhaps the locality in which the property is located, and then after all that, only and only if that does not happen again, it might be put up to sale to a private entity.
03:05:04
Is that about it?
SPEAKER_14
03:05:05
Yes, sir.
03:05:06
It is offered to the state agencies first.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:05:10
They don't pay.
03:05:11
I mean, it's just- That's correct.
03:05:15
A transfer.
SPEAKER_14
03:05:19
But we don't have a lot of transfers and we do not sell a lot of surplus equipment.
03:05:29
There's not a lot of, I don't think there's a great deal of market out there for the 13 properties that we have.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:05:38
As I said, the last time we received any money, I think, was for an area headquarters.
SPEAKER_14
03:06:05
I think it was West Point and it was about $203,000 that we recognized on that and I think that was either 2009 or 2008.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:12
Chairman Swirly, we did abandon some properties when we were going through the blueprint process but we purposely delayed disposing of the properties because we wanted to make certain that everything was working out
03:06:33
And now what we're doing is looking at all the property, making a decision which one we can dispose, which ones we want to lease.
03:06:45
And all of these are really coming from that blueprint process that we went through a year or two ago.
03:06:52
So this is the properties, now we're a process of selling.
03:06:56
But we took a very deliberate approach because we didn't want to sell something and then had to turn around
03:07:03
Re-open an area and have to buy land and build another building.
03:07:07
So these are the properties right now that we abandon and we're selling those.
03:07:11
Some of them we still are not certain, so we're leasing the properties rather than selling them.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:07:18
Mr. Chairman.
03:07:18
Yeah, Dr. Davis.
03:07:19
What are we being asked to consider today with this?
03:07:23
Nothing, this is just somebody.
03:07:24
This was just questions about one last meeting.
SPEAKER_14
03:07:28
It was a December meeting.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:07:29
How do we dispose of property?
03:07:47
But they're there to protect the interests of the Commonwealth and avoid fraud.
03:07:53
And I don't think we need to get any further involved in that other than to know that these properties are being disposed of because we've abandoned them.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:08:02
I think one of the things that really, the questions that came out were two.
03:08:06
One was what happens to the money?
03:08:08
How much money is generated, what happens to it?
03:08:10
And then the whole issue on DGS versus whether VDOT should dispose of them or go to DGS.
03:08:17
The problem is that once you send it over to DGS, they take the cut of it.
03:08:24
So we get less money from DGS disposing of it versus us disposing of it.
03:08:30
But that is where their constant lobbying is paying off because they want DGS to dispose of it.
03:08:38
Mr. Chairman, one other quick question.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:08:57
Looking at page four with the properties to be returned, what type of property is being disposed of area headquarters in Northern Virginia for only $200,000?
03:09:09
I can't imagine that in that market.
03:09:10
I can't imagine too much that small unless it's land.
03:09:17
Where is that?
SPEAKER_17
03:09:18
That's an old area headquarters, a piece of property at Haymarket.
Allen L. Louderback
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:09:23
What is it?
03:09:24
Haymarket.
03:09:25
At Haymarket?
SPEAKER_17
03:09:26
Yes, sir.
03:09:27
Okay.
03:09:27
It's adjacent to a correctional facility also, which I think has always been abandoned.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:09:33
How did we arrive at these estimated values?
SPEAKER_17
03:09:42
We went to the appraisal people in our right-of-way division, who I have great confidence in, and asked them to give us their best guess, looking at assessments and other information that they had as to the value of these products.
03:09:58
And it's their best guess.
03:09:59
It's not an appraisal.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:10:00
Notice, Grindly, here, also, that there's a $2 million warehouse for a central office.
03:10:13
Was that just for storage?
03:10:15
Yeah, it's been written as Fulton.
03:10:19
Okay.
SPEAKER_17
03:10:19
We've got the VDOT has a warehouse at Fulton.
03:10:22
that we have now vacated.
03:10:26
We still have some other buildings adjacent that we're showing used furniture and other documentation and that sort of thing.
03:10:33
But I think it's about 14, 15 acres down there that we said worth about $2 million, we think.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:10:44
Any other questions?
03:10:45
Johnson, thank you very much.
03:10:46
Thank you.
03:10:48
Legislative Report.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
03:10:49
Mr. Martin, come on up.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:10:53
Now, this will be fairly quick because the Board had no questions regarding any of these issues last week.
SPEAKER_04
03:10:59
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman.
03:11:02
Keith Martin from VDOT's Policy Office.
03:11:04
Filling in for Rick Walton, who unfortunately couldn't be here today.
03:11:08
As everyone knows, this is a short session.
03:11:12
We're expecting the General Assembly to conclude business by next Saturday.
03:11:15
There was over 2,500 bills introduced into the General Assembly.
03:11:20
Of that, VDOT is tracking over 240 bills.
03:11:24
I believe Mr. Walton came before the board last month and gave you an update on approximately 16 pieces of legislation that VDOT was tracking.
03:11:32
Of those agency bills, as you can see, the majority of them are code cleanup or they promote some sort of efficiency or streamlining the processes.
03:11:41
Two bills I would mention, however, that Mr. Walton mentioned to you guys last month
03:11:45
They are not moving forward, and that is House Bill 1660, which exempted VDOT's public roads and right-of-way from storm water management fees.
03:11:55
That was incorporated in House Bill 1737.
03:11:57
That still is in existence moving forward.
03:12:01
And House Bill 1496, which allowed motor vehicles to be in a third lane on certain areas of the highway during certain situations, that did not pass out of the house.
03:12:16
As you are aware from last month, I think Mr. Walton advised you about House Bill 1693, which raises the maximum limit on the waiver of appraisals from $10,000 to $25,000.
03:12:30
While it was in the House, the House amended the bill to clarify that the landowner would be told that they are entitled to the full appraisal, even though that limit is waived, but they're entitled to it.
03:12:47
On slide number four, House Bill 223 and Senate Bill 1004 are companion bills.
03:12:53
They relate to the funding efficiencies and cost recovery.
03:12:56
There are four main aspects to this bill.
03:12:59
First thing is that it exempts DDOT and DRPT from paying any fee for digital access to records.
03:13:06
It also codifies what's been in the Appropriation Act since 2003.
03:13:12
regarding what the annual rate of payment is going to be for maintenance to localities.
03:13:19
It also does two other things that are pretty much co-cleanup.
03:13:23
It ensures that the payback provisions that require locality, they have to pay back in regards to locality when it chooses or cancels a project.
03:13:33
That was updated to reflect current processes.
03:13:37
The Fairfax Bonding Authority statutory legislation was amended to
03:13:41
reflect statutory law changes in the federal law.
03:13:45
I would mention that back on page or slide four, this bill was amended to actually state that VDOT will apply the same growth rate to payments to locality's funding levels as it does to the base VDOT maintenance program.
03:14:06
Regarding Senate Bill 1126, this bill would extend the contract solicitation cycle for environmental, location, design, and inspection work on highways and bridges to one initial term of two years.
03:14:20
This bill was admitted in the House, excuse me, in the Senate, to ask that the commissioner appoint a committee composed of road building organizations and representatives of certain surety bonding individuals
03:14:33
to review performance and payment bonding requirements and make recommendations to the Commissioner by December 1 of this year.
03:14:44
House Bill 1825 and Senate Bill 1005 are also companion bills.
03:14:49
They have passed both the House and the Senate regarding the duties of the Commissioner.
03:14:53
This bill has five important parts.
03:14:56
The first is that they change the title of the Commissioner to the Commissioner of Highways.
03:15:00
It eliminates the requirement that there be a person designated with a title of Assistant Commissioner for Environment, Transportation, Planning, and Regulatory Affairs.
03:15:10
It also allows VDOT's commissioner to transfer abandoned and discontinued roads in among the primary and secondary systems in certain situations.
03:15:20
It eliminates the requirement that CTB must declare excess right of way of surplus before VDOT may sell the land.
03:15:26
And finally,
03:15:28
Instead of having five to eight different reports every year, it allows VDOT to have one comprehensive report in the fall.
03:15:35
This bill was amended both in the House and the Senate just to clarify that the information that was provided in the biennial report on the condition of needs is also in that comprehensive report that is in the fall.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:15:51
Mr. Chairman, do you have a question on the sale of land
03:15:56
And the bill requires that the CTB must not declare that surplus.
03:16:02
And that question is, does the CTB still approve the sale?
03:16:06
Does it come for a pre-war?
03:16:07
It just authorizes commissioners to sell.
SPEAKER_04
03:16:11
The commissioner has authorized to sell.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:16:13
Without CTB approval.
03:16:15
Right.
SPEAKER_04
03:16:23
And finally, Mr. Chairman, the last bill just to update the board on House Bill 1758 is a streamlining bill to improve operational processes in three main ways.
03:16:38
First, it provides a mutual policy made decided to assume responsibility for construction of this program by notifying the board by December 31st instead of the current processes of July 1st.
03:16:51
It exempts the Rural Rustic Road Program from the stormwater management regulations and it also eliminates the requirement for a local governing body to hold a public hearing when provided notice that VDOT plans to provide or pave a secondary road within a locality due to an emergency.
03:17:10
Right now, they have up to 30 days to make a recommendation to the commissioner.
03:17:14
Under this proposal, it will be 72 hours.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:17:18
Mr. Chairman?
03:17:19
Yes.
03:17:19
I have a question on what's going on with this last bill, HB 1758.
03:17:25
What's the impetus behind this?
SPEAKER_04
03:17:30
Mr. Chairman, it was just a streamlined effort to improve processes.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:17:33
It wasn't a streamlined explanation.
03:17:36
That doesn't tell me anything.
03:17:40
The reason I ask is because there are taxpayers in my jurisdiction that want to have one, believe it or not.
03:17:47
I wouldn't want to live on one.
03:17:49
They don't want it paid.
03:17:51
So this is going to, and a lot of the counties agree with them, so this is going to be a short circuit notice.
03:17:58
If VDOT runs in there and pays it, the county doesn't want to pay, right?
SPEAKER_04
03:18:04
Mr. Chairman, actually the county does make a recommendation to the commissioner to shorten the time period from 30 days to 72 hours.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:18:13
So you're not going to go in and pave an unpaved road unless the county asks you to tell me that?
03:18:18
That's what the statute reads?
SPEAKER_04
03:18:21
The statute is the same other than it shortens the timeline from 30 days to 72 hours.
03:18:26
Yes, sir?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:18:28
I don't see the need for this, but that's all right.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:18:38
This applies to unpaved roads.
03:18:39
This is not a repaving.
03:18:41
It's an unpaved road.
03:18:43
It's a construction project, and there'd be no public hearing then.
SPEAKER_04
03:18:48
Unpaved road during an emergency situation.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:18:50
It doesn't say emergency, but it does in the rest of the statute.
SPEAKER_04
03:18:54
It does in the statute, yes, sir.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:18:56
What is an emergency in this case?
03:18:58
Yeah, what's an emergency?
SPEAKER_04
03:19:01
Um, I'll have to defer to the Commissioner on what that might entail.
SPEAKER_14
03:19:06
In England, you meant a road blocked out for something like a hurricane?
03:19:11
Oh.
03:19:11
There's a road blocked out.
03:19:13
And the question is, when you go back, you put the road back, and you want to pave it.
03:19:15
And it really should be intended not to have a full load here.
03:19:17
If the locality still has to agree?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:19:20
As long as the locality still has to agree, I'm fine on that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:19:22
But I don't...
03:19:25
Okay.
03:19:27
I get you.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:19:28
Okay, I understand that.
03:19:29
I just don't want VDOT to go in and pave these roads when the taxpayers don't want to pave.
03:19:33
I mean, we'll save money.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:19:34
What the hell?
SPEAKER_04
03:19:35
The statute actually says that they make a recommendation to the commissioner.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:19:39
Mr. Chairman?
03:19:39
Yes.
03:19:40
You didn't mention one that we asked some questions about last month, House Bill 1957.
03:19:45
Is that dead or still alive, or what's going on with that?
SPEAKER_04
03:19:49
The bills that are not mentioned are actually moving forward as is.
03:19:53
This was just an update on changes since Rick Walton presented last month.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:19:57
I think that one had a change too.
03:19:59
That was the one that increased the commissioners' authority to contract some two million five million and eliminated our need to be looked at outdoor theaters and a couple of other pretty minor things that I doubt anyone has a problem with.
03:20:14
But I saw recently that it added another clause or two, which I didn't understand,
03:20:19
I agree with the Commissioner having, and the language was very specific, but without restriction whatsoever in any amount, dealing with some sort of local projects, and I didn't understand what that was about.
03:20:35
It was new language since last month.
03:20:38
Because it wasn't in the draft that we saw last month.
03:20:42
It had to do with projects that we approved funding for in the six-year plan, I think, but then which we would normally approve when it comes time to do them.
03:20:54
And this would say that the commissioner has the authority to do that correctly.
03:21:00
And I'm not sure I did, but I was just wondering where that stood or where that came from.
SPEAKER_04
03:21:04
Those proposals are going forward as is with not very much opposition at all.
03:21:12
I would assume that the changes that were made were made before Rick Walton made the presentation.
03:21:18
Since then, there's no changes that have been made to that bill.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:21:21
Can we get a summary of that?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:21:24
It sounds interesting.
03:21:25
House Bill 1957, just look it up on your computer and you'll see.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:21:34
I'm sorry, I guess I'll just go back to Prince William County.
03:21:38
If we had a state road, even if we paid for it, we would have to come to the CTB and get the contract approved.
03:21:48
I think that's what it feels like.
03:21:50
Is that right?
03:21:52
Even if we paid for it, we administered it?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:21:53
That's a different, that's a different thing, I believe.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:21:58
How many bills you got, Steve?
SPEAKER_04
03:22:00
Oh, we have quite a few this year, sir.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:22:02
Why don't you get a copy of that and then maybe come back and then we can share that with the members.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:22:10
Mr. Chairman.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:22:12
Mr. Chairman.
03:22:16
Yes, I'm sorry.
03:22:17
Mr. Martin.
03:22:18
Are you familiar with the eminent domain, I think it's a joint resolution or something that Senator Giroir was involved in.
03:22:27
I think it's H.J.
03:22:28
693
03:22:29
substantially changed those eminent domain rules and would relate to, so it could have a pretty significant impact on VDOT in terms of compensation paid.
03:22:40
Are you familiar with where we are on that and I understand it went out of committee today on an 8-7 vote perhaps to the floor.
03:22:49
Are we tracking that legislation?
SPEAKER_04
03:22:51
Yes sir, we're tracking that and actually if Mr. Richard Bennett's here, he's the one primarily working on that.
03:22:56
Are we staying out of that fight or what are we doing?
03:22:59
Oh, we are working with the administration on those bills.
03:23:02
There were a few of those.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:23:04
I just don't know what the administration's position is on it.
03:23:09
And it does have significant financial impact to VDOT on any condemnation that we would be involved in.
SPEAKER_04
03:23:17
Every week the bills change, and that's one of them I think they're in constant negotiation with, yes sir.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:23:23
So no real update, and are we supporting that, or is the administration supporting that, I should ask, or do we know?
03:23:32
It depends on what the changes are, right?
03:23:36
Yes, sir.
SPEAKER_16
03:23:37
Yes, go ahead.
03:23:42
Do you know the status of 1957?
03:23:43
Has it passed?
03:23:45
Is it in committee?
03:23:46
Has it been killed?
SPEAKER_04
03:23:48
Oh, it's passed.
03:23:50
I believe it's out of both houses now or we'll be out tomorrow.
03:23:56
It has crossed over, yes sir.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:23:59
Mr. Chairman, I believe you were saying about the storm water management, is it rural, rustic roads that were exempted from storm water management?
03:24:10
Could you just define, you know, give us a definition of how rural rustic roads are defined?
SPEAKER_04
03:24:18
I can be back and ask Julie who administers the program.
03:24:21
Julie, you might kind of explain it.
SPEAKER_01
03:24:29
The rural rustic road program is an option for paving an unpaved road.
03:24:34
Under that concept, basically you don't have to meet a defined standard
SPEAKER_14
03:24:39
You can basically go in, shape the road up, put additional stone down and pave it.
03:24:44
It's really intended to be a very low cost way of paving existing unpaved roads.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:24:50
So it's really just a concept.
03:24:56
That program does save a lot of money and it seems to please a lot of the citizens.
03:25:01
They get our roads but it's not a huge thing and it blends in and we save a lot of money so I think it's a good thing.
03:25:08
One question I had was, I think the speaker had drafted these provisions that have been in law for a while, giving VDOT, not a lot of authority, but some authority on corridor management, that type of thing.
03:25:23
So are you watching these, and are we protecting this authority?
SPEAKER_04
03:25:33
Yes, as I mentioned, we're actually tracking and involved in over 240 bills.
03:25:39
If the Chairman likes, after the Governor's veto session on August 6th, I usually do a report on the transportation bills.
03:25:48
And I can do a report and actually work with DRPT's policy office if you like and do a final
03:25:53
I will report on all the bills that are out there and how they impact VDOT and DRPT.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:25:57
It's important to preserve this authority that we do have to try to preserve the integrity of our roads.
03:26:07
If you all can keep an eye on that, I'm sure the speaker probably is.
SPEAKER_04
03:26:16
Any other questions?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:26:18
Excellent.
03:26:19
SMART, thank you very much.
SPEAKER_04
03:26:20
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:26:21
Alright, well that closes out our work session.
03:26:26
We'll go right into the...