Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 1/19/2011
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
1/19/2011
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Bids.pdf
Fiscal Year 2011 budget _ actual performance through December 2010.pdf
VDOT 2011 legislation.pdf
CMAQ sub-committee.pdf
1. Governor Harry W. Nice Memorial Bridge Improvement Project
Gov. Harry W. Nice Memorial Bridge Improvement Project.pdf
2. Central Virginia Metropolitan Planning Organization
Central Virginia Metropolitan Planning Organization.ppt
3. Revenue Sharing Program Update
Fiscal Year 2012 Revenue Sharing Program update.pdf
4. Financial Report
5. Legislative Briefing
6. CMAQ/RSTP Subcommittee
7. Illustrative List of Projects for Governor’s Funding Package
Illustrative List of Projects for Governor’s Transportation Funding Package.pdf
8. Supplemental Guide Sign Program- Update on Hospital Signs
Supplemental Guide Sign Program update on hospital signs.pdf
9. Route 460 Independent Review Panel Recommendations
Route 460 Corridor Improvement Project Independent Review Panel briefing.pdf
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:01
Good morning, everyone.
00:00:02
I'd like to welcome you to this morning's work session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:08
After I've gotten everyone to sit, I'm going to ask everyone if they could please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:15
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:29
Thank you very much.
00:00:32
We are, well, welcome to the first meeting of 2011 for the CTB.
00:00:38
I would just also like to just point out that the Commissioner is up, as we all recognize, the General Assembly is in session.
00:00:49
Lots of
00:00:50
transportation related issues and comments and concerns are going on and the commissioner is up I believe up at the General Assembly right now.
00:00:59
We are, I just need to say that we're going to probably likely try to move this meeting along.
00:01:04
I know we last few meetings we've had an excellent opportunity to discuss a lot of issues and points.
00:01:12
One problem we have is at four o'clock is the Senate Finance Subcommittee on Transportation.
00:01:19
And yours truly and the Commissioner have been asked, politely asked to come and testify about the Governor's proposal.
00:01:26
So we anticipate that that will be up there for some time.
00:01:29
So we're going to try to make sure we're complete with our agenda a little bit before four.
00:01:35
So with that, we're going to start with our first presentation.
00:01:39
That is on the Harry Nice Bridge and the Bridge Improvement Project.
00:01:44
We have Glen Smith who is the Project Manager from the Division of Capital Planning from the Maryland Transportation Authority.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:52
Mr. Smith.
SPEAKER_11
00:02:03
Thank you very much.
00:02:04
My name is Glen Smith.
00:02:06
I'm the project manager for the Maryland Transportation Authority.
00:02:09
I would like to briefly go over the Governor and ICE bridge improvement project.
00:02:13
We're addressing safety and capacity needs.
00:02:16
The Maryland Transportation Authority is an independent state agency.
00:02:20
We receive no funds from the Transportation Trust Fund.
00:02:23
We receive all of our funding from our tolls.
00:02:26
We own and operate all the toll facilities in Maryland.
00:02:39
I would like to give an overview of the project, the project's history.
00:02:45
I'll touch on the purpose and need, describe the existing conditions, identify the authority's preferred alternate, as well as potential project impacts and the next steps.
00:03:00
Now we are following the NEPA process, the National Environmental Policy Act process, for mainly two reasons.
00:03:06
Although historically, the authority does not receive federal funds
00:03:10
We are following this process in the event that federal funds do become available and ultimately if the construction of a new bridge does occur we would need a permit from the Coast Guard which constitutes a federal action which triggers NEPA.
00:03:25
This project is currently funded for project planning only and it is all Maryland transportation funding at this point.
00:03:32
The Federal Highway Administration is the lead, and as we are working in two states, the Federal Highway Administration from Maryland has taken the lead, although we are coordinating very closely with Virginia as well as Virginia agencies.
00:03:48
The project was initiated in 2006.
00:03:54
King George County in Virginia, as well as Charles County in Maryland, have provided a joint resolution
00:04:00
to our Secretary of Transportation requesting capacity improvements on the bridge.
00:04:05
We then initiated project planning.
00:04:09
We developed an environmental assessment which Federal Highway signed in July of 2009.
00:04:13
In September of 2009, we held public hearings in both states.
00:04:19
We had over 100 people attend.
00:04:21
We received over 160 comments.
00:04:24
at that time via testimony, comment cards, emails, and we've also established a project webpage.
00:04:33
We had reached consensus from all the stakeholders for a bill of alternate at that point.
00:04:37
Everyone was requesting that we do a capacity improvement.
00:04:43
We worked very closely with VDOT on this project as we were tying to Virginia.
00:04:48
and the staff of VDOT, Nick Neese has been very cooperative in providing coordination with public involvement data collection as well as coordination with the elected officials.
00:05:04
The purpose of this project is to eliminate the bottleneck existing to bridge support traffic for the projected growth in 2030, address safety needs not only on the bridge but as well as the approach roads
00:05:16
Minimize travel delays on the bridge during maintenance.
00:05:19
Currently, if there's a wide load, we have to close the bridge to get the wide load across.
00:05:24
On either side of the bridge, for anybody that's familiar with it, you have a four-lane divided section.
00:05:30
The bridge is a two-lane undivided, so it creates a bottleneck.
00:05:35
It also, it's an important in public military transportation element as it connects the Dahlgren Naval Facility on the Virginia side with the Indian Head Facility in Maryland.
00:05:46
And also, we've heard a pretty strong message from a lot of the locals about an evacuation route out of Washington, D.C. As I said earlier, US-301 is a four-lane divided.
00:05:59
It's on the National Highway System and on the Strategic Highway Network.
00:06:03
That requires us to build to the best typical section possible.
00:06:07
The nearest crossing is approximately 25 miles away, which is at the Woodrow Wilson Bridge over the Potomac River up in Washington.
00:06:21
As we went through the project planning phase, we developed six build alternates, as well as maintaining a no-build alternate.
00:06:29
As we went through the process, based on comments we received from the major stakeholders, which were the local elected officials, the Navy facility, all the major employers in the area, and the citizens, the preferred alternate is to construct a new four-lane bridge to the north of the existing bridge, just to the north of it in the same location,
00:06:51
That will include a two-way bike path on the south side of the bridge, and we would remove the existing bridge.
00:06:57
The cost range for this is about $805 million to $885 million.
00:07:02
A quick step back.
00:07:06
The funding right now is funded for project planning only.
00:07:09
The remaining phases of the project, engineering, right-of-way acquisition, construction, are not funded at this point.
00:07:16
This next slide gives you a graphic representation of where the new bridge would be located, the connection between the two states, as well as a typical section that it describes.
00:07:26
It would be a four-lane barrier separated, and also on the south side we'd have a barrier separated two-way pedestrian bicycle passage.
00:07:40
The next slide just gives an aerial view of how the northern alternate would come in and impact, in particular, which are your sensitive resources on the Virginia side, the two parks on the wayside, and Barnesville Park, as well as the Gateway Welcome Center, which is currently closed.
00:08:07
The key factors in identifying the modified alternate 7, it best met the purpose and need of the project.
00:08:14
It avoids the naval support facility at Dahlgren.
00:08:17
They had come to us very early in the project and said that any impacts to our property would impact our mission and to go to the north.
00:08:26
It also incorporates the majority of the stakeholder comments.
00:08:30
and it minimizes our resource impacts as well as it provides lower cost and life cycle costs and these are projected costs to maintain the existing bridge.
00:08:40
The next chart identifies environmental impacts and with regards to the Virginia impact, you would go down to the last block on the bottom and there's where you're impacting
00:08:58
The resources that I mentioned earlier, the impacts associated with each of those resources and potential mitigation measures.
00:09:07
We are currently involved in developing a memorandum of agreement with all the affected agencies there and the intent of this agreement is to identify the transfer of property process and would demonstrate the authority's commitment to mitigation as well as it provides recognition for us to follow the federal impacts with regards to park lands.
00:09:32
The next steps in the project, we're presenting here today.
00:09:35
In the spring, this spring, we'll be finishing our final environmental document, which is currently being addressed, is being reviewed by Federal Highway Administration.
00:09:46
Once we get a signed final environmental document, which is anticipated this spring, the project will become a candidate for programming, for funding for the later phases, the design right away and the construction.
00:10:01
The last slide is my contact information and also our project web page if you want additional information on that.
00:10:09
And so hopefully this provides a little overview of what the project, the purpose of the project was, where we are with it, and where we're going with our next steps.
00:10:18
If there are any questions, please feel free to ask.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:22
Any questions, Mr. Smith?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:24
Mr. Chairman.
00:10:25
Yes, Ms. Coleman.
00:10:26
Thank you for being here.
00:10:27
How does this project fit in with other improvements in the 301 corridor in Maryland?
00:10:33
Is this really being viewed as a stand-alone improvement at the moment?
SPEAKER_11
00:10:37
Yes, it's a stand-alone project that's simply addressing the needs at the bridge itself.
00:10:42
A little further north, maybe 15, 20 miles to the north, there's a 301 Walmart bypass that's in project planning with the State Highway Administration.
00:10:50
But it's serving a different purpose in our project.
00:10:53
We have been coordinating with that project.
00:10:55
There are a lot of environmental issues associated with that project, but this is an independent project.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:01
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Smith, how would you rate this in terms of the priority list for the state of Maryland?
00:11:08
Is this top ten?
00:11:09
Is this top five?
SPEAKER_11
00:11:13
It's what it does, it competes with all the other Maryland Authority projects for priority and I really couldn't tell you what that priority is.
00:11:23
We have a wide variety of projects underway right now, the ICC in particular, Section 100, it would just have to compete with that and we're managed by a chairperson and eight board members and they would decide where that money would go.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:40
Any other questions, Mr. Smith?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:43
It's really for you Mr. Chairman, I thank you for being here sir.
00:11:48
What's the impact, what's the economic impact or the financial impact that I'm trying to get at to us?
00:11:57
What's our responsibility?
00:11:58
I read the recent word, the brief.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:00
Well, I think you all are paying for the entire thing.
SPEAKER_11
00:12:03
Yeah, currently all, it's entirely being funded by the Maryland Transportation Authority and we're reimbursing VDOT for any staff time that they're using.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:11
So, on the Virginia side of the project, obviously there's something that's going to change.
00:12:15
If you look at the map, so is that, you're saying that's the responsibility of the project, meaning all, even on the Virginia side?
SPEAKER_11
00:12:24
Yeah, the construction of not only the bridge, but the approach within Virginia at this time is going to be funded by the authority.
00:12:30
Now, working with Kingsbridge County, they are viewing this as a potential economic impact because of the capacity improvements.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:39
Thank you.
00:12:39
Just one of those unique, well, I guess- Unusual.
00:12:42
Well, I think most of our bridges, the Cap and John Bridge, I mean, I'm sorry, you're only familiar with the MTA bridges.
00:12:49
I was just thinking about some of the other bridges that cross between Maryland and Virginia.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:54
Well, this is sort of, I mean, I'm not sure about all the lines, but the Maryland line is right against the shore there, which I'm not sure that's the way it is other places.
00:13:06
So we're sort of like not even part of it until it gets to the land.
00:13:11
And that's sort of unusual, right?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:14
Ms. Smith, I'm sorry, so right now, we vote on this in February, and alright, so then you move forward, but really right now you have no money for real design engineering.
00:13:26
Correct.
SPEAKER_11
00:13:28
We anticipate getting a signed environmental document this spring, and then after that,
00:13:34
The authorities try to identify additional funds, but right now our revenue projections, we are unable to afford the remaining phases.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:44
And then I'm sorry, so you are just responsible for the bridge itself.
00:13:49
The follow-up on Mr. Koelemay's questions, the rest of 301 is actually Maryland DOT's responsibility.
SPEAKER_11
00:13:58
Yeah, once you get into Maryland, 301 becomes state highway administration.
00:14:03
When you get into Virginia, it's VDOT.
00:14:05
And we're working very closely with that.
00:14:06
But ultimately, it would be VDOT's responsibility once we construct the, realign the approach for it.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:13
I'm just talking about the improvements itself, the 301 in Maryland.
00:14:17
That is actually the highway department.
00:14:19
Correct.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:21
Any other questions?
00:14:23
Mr.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:23
Chair?
00:14:23
Yes, Ms. Ellis.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:25
Are you looking at the same elevation
00:14:27
Any other questions?
SPEAKER_11
00:14:34
Ms. Smith, thank you very much.
00:14:42
I appreciate you being here.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:48
Thank you.
00:14:58
OK, we have next is the Central Virginia MPO.
00:15:02
We have Gary Christie, the executive director, and Bob White, the deputy director.
SPEAKER_15
00:15:09
Good morning.
00:15:10
Gary Christie from the Region 2000 Local Government Council.
00:15:16
I'm going to talk about how our MPO fits into the regional economic development program in our area.
00:15:23
And my colleague, Bob White, will talk about the specific transportation issues
00:15:28
that are going on in the Lynchburg area.
00:15:33
In Lynchburg and surrounding area is Region 2000, Appomattox, Amherst, Campbell and Bedford Counties, about 250,000 people growing at a slow but manageable rate.
00:15:47
Now Region 2000 is a brand, an economic development brand.
00:15:51
We have six organizations as part of that regional economic development brand.
00:15:56
The local government council provides the planning district commission roles as well as staffing to the Central Virginia Metropolitan Planning Agency.
00:16:06
But we also do direct services for our communities.
00:16:09
For example, we run a landfill that carries about 236,000 tons of trash each year and we provide a variety of consulting services
00:16:21
such as various comprehensive plans and other economic development planning activities.
00:16:27
We work right alongside with the Economic Development Council which is the recruiting organization that goes out and solicits businesses as well as cares and takes and feeds the local businesses to help them grow.
00:16:43
Part of our organization also includes the Center for Advanced Engineering Research
00:16:48
A advanced learning facility which will open in April but $9 million operation just over in the Bedford County area that will connect our local businesses to graduate level studies at Virginia Tech and UVA and other research facilities that will take ideas, transform them into marketable products and innovations.
00:17:14
The Technology Council is a service organization
00:17:17
for our technology businesses, young professionals of Central Virginia markets to attract and retain our bright talent that we need for our technology businesses.
00:17:28
And the Workforce Investment Board is an organization to help train existing workers and to help displaced workers find their new skills.
00:17:40
Altogether, this is our economic development program, each with their own job to do.
00:17:47
but still our specific niche in our various markets.
00:17:53
We're a diverse economy and that diverse economy has helped keep our head above water during this recession.
00:18:01
We still manufacture things as you see we're almost 15% of our jobs are still in the manufacturing business.
00:18:08
That is a decline but it's still a major part of our economy.
00:18:14
You'll see familiar names.
00:18:16
Corporations Energy, Technology, Pharmaceuticals, Food Service, but it's still a very advanced manufacturing technology-bent community.
00:18:27
That technology and manufacturing has come together in our area, so it's not surprising that the very light car was developed in Lynchburg, which won the X Prize for going 100 miles a gallon on a gallon of gasoline.
00:18:41
There were over 140 applicants.
00:18:44
Only one finished the competition, the Edison II team.
00:18:49
So transportation is important to us for moving our people around and moving our goods in and out of the region.
00:18:57
And at this point, let me call on Mr. Bob White to talk about specific transportation issues.
SPEAKER_20
00:19:06
Thank you, Gary, and thank you, Mr. Secretary and board members.
00:19:11
for this opportunity to talk with you today.
00:19:21
The Central Virginia MPO consists of the City of Lynchburg in the urbanizing areas of Bedford County, Campbell County, and Amherst County in the town of Amherst.
00:19:31
It comprises about 354 square miles of Region 2000 square miles.
00:19:37
and also the MPO planning area holds about 134,000 of our 247,000 residents within our community.
00:19:46
Our board consists of 11 members, typically an elected official from each of our jurisdictions, our chief administrative officer, as well as Rob Carey, the district administrator in our area.
00:20:03
A primary task of our MPO is the maintenance and update of our long-range transportation plan.
00:20:09
We just completed the most recent update to this document this past October, and I wanted to highlight some of the key issues from this update and related efforts because I believe they reflect some of the important challenges we're facing within Region 2000 and within the Central Virginia MPO.
00:20:30
Funding ultimately drives most considerations, most discussions related to transportation, and in our area that's no different.
00:20:38
As we went through our planning process, we identified that we're going to have approximately $97 million in projected revenue through 2035, the horizon for our planning effort.
00:20:51
That's $50 million less than what we had the last time we updated our plan in December of 2005, a significant difference.
00:21:00
Along with that, we understand that we're going to have approximately $1.6 billion available for maintenance through 2035.
00:21:08
Clearly, like just about everyone else in Virginia, the central Virginia areas in their transportation program is very much a maintenance operation at this point and not a construction operation.
00:21:20
And in fact, the projects that we have identified in the constrained element of our long-range plan and the programs identified there
00:21:30
are essentially identified currently in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
00:21:33
We're not looking to advance any projects beyond what we're already looking at within that program.
00:21:40
The primary emphasis for us for the foreseeable future to a large extent is going to be on bridge and safety projects.
00:21:47
And in fact, we do have examples within our constraint plan where a project or projects we have identified, we're not actually having money for construction.
00:21:57
We only have money for preliminary engineering and right-of-way.
00:22:01
In contrast to the approximately $97 million that we have identified in our constraint plan within the vision plan, the unfunded portion of our planning document, we show 60 projects totaling well over $300 million.
00:22:16
And I think that shows part of the challenge that we have as we move forward in meeting our needs.
00:22:26
This graphic illustrates the projects identified within both our constrained and our vision plans.
00:22:32
I show this not to describe each project but to highlight the fact that only one project shown is actually new construction and that is actually shown in this graphic in the lower right hand corner with the blue line work and this is actually the extension of the 29 bypass around Lynchburg that we hope to accomplish at some point in the future.
00:23:03
All the other projects, including all the projects we actually expect to have funding for, are targeted to maintaining and extending the life cycle of our existing system.
00:23:13
At this point in time, we have come to realize that the transportation system that currently serves our region internally is what we'll be having for the foreseeable future.
00:23:26
To this end, a significant amount of the effort that our MPO has put forward in recent years has been directed to strengthening the connection between transportation and land use planning.
00:23:36
Working with our localities and our district staff, we've examined key corridors, most of the key corridors, actually all the key corridors within our region with a principal focus on looking at developing an access management program for each of those.
00:23:51
We work closely with our localities in doing this and
00:23:56
For all, in most cases, if not all cases, we've been able to incorporate a lot of those recommendations into the comprehensive planning documents, which for us is a significant success, a significant effort.
00:24:10
We've also accomplished in the past what we refer to as the Regional Action Plan for coordinating land use and transportation planning.
00:24:17
This document is an examination of means to better relate transportation and land use planning within Region 2000.
00:24:27
Most recently, as we updated our long-range transportation plan, we took advantage of a scenario planning approach for this.
00:24:40
And in doing that, we took advantage of a lot of the findings that came out of that initial regional action plan.
00:24:48
Through this effort, we will be working with our localities to try to advance a lot of those recommendations in the coming months and the coming years.
00:24:59
Additionally, we've been active with the City of Lynchburg and its planning and engineering staff.
00:25:04
We recently completed a multimodal connectivity study.
00:25:08
This effort related to looking at the street system, the transit system, our sidewalk inventory, as well as our bike and trail systems.
00:25:18
Looking for opportunities to strengthen the linkages between them.
00:25:23
This study will continue to evolve and we believe it will go a long way to assisting the city staff and influencing their capital improvement program in the future as well as taking advantage of such programs as Safe Routes to School initiative.
00:25:42
We have also begun examining key commercial corridors within the City of Lynchburg, trying to determine opportunities to employ access management to much greater effect than they have in the past, and we hope to be successful with some of that in the coming years.
00:25:55
This is all being done to strengthen the transportation and planning connection and to extend the investment and life cycle of our existing system.
00:26:07
The second critical transportation challenge our region is facing is maintaining and strengthening our inter-regional connectivity.
00:26:20
In fact, this concern was not only highlighted during our long-range plan update,
00:26:25
but it's also being raised as we develop a comprehensive economic development strategy for the federal EDA funding programs, a separate effort that relates more to our economic development efforts but relates too to transportation.
00:26:42
And the concern has also been strongly emphasized as we have been undertaking an evaluation of our regional economic development practices and programs and we do that periodically.
00:26:54
In fact, interregional transportation is considered the number one issue for our local economic developers.
00:27:02
Over 70% of the business leaders that we have been surveying point to this as something that we need to be constantly concerned with and emphasizing.
00:27:14
In front of you are some typical comments that we have received from our business community.
00:27:19
The first one relates to the 460 corridor and the fact that if we could strengthen the linkage between the port and region 2000, this would have a tremendous impact on our economy and our local businesses.
00:27:33
We're also very much concerned with our ability to move in and out of the Lynchburg area as effortlessly as possible and unfortunately what has happened most recently is one of our key CEOs has actually moved to Charlotte because of easier access from Charlotte to other markets that they have to be sensitive to.
00:27:56
and once you start losing your corporate leadership within your community that can be a serious blow to you.
00:28:03
And then the last comment I have there is our roadways are bad and it's difficult to get to D.C. either by air or highway without a bypass around Charlottesville.
00:28:12
The 29 issue continues to be something of importance to us.
00:28:27
I need to mention one of the stated objectives for the comprehensive economic development strategy effort that we're currently working on.
00:28:41
And this is simply to promote the completion of the southern tier of the U.S. 29 Bypass around Lynchburg and construction of the Charlottesville Bypass.
00:28:49
Again, I showed this slide to you previously, but I just wanted to highlight the fact that the work that project extending the 29 bypass is the only new construction project requiring new construction or a new facility that we have identified for the foreseeable future.
00:29:15
With currently programmed dollars, the access management improvements to the US-29, US-460 corridor remains a priority within our region.
00:29:27
Principally, this is to ensure safety and efficient movement to destinations north and south of us.
00:29:33
We continue to invest our limited dollars to strengthen our regional connectivity, and we believe this needs to be a priority for the Commonwealth as well.
00:29:45
On the bright side, and there is a bright side, there's a lot of good things happening in Winchburg as it relates to transportation, and in particular the Northeast Regional Train with Winchburg-Skempers Street Station as its southernmost terminus
00:29:59
has been an overwhelming success with ridership far exceeding expectations.
00:30:03
I believe it's exceeding 160% of that expectation.
00:30:08
The investment that this board has made in the renovation efforts to the Kemper Street Station as a mobile facility has and we believe will continue to bear fruit.
00:30:21
I'd also like to take a moment and just mention some recent efforts and successes of the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company or GLTC as we refer to it.
00:30:31
Public transport as provided by GLTC provides an important part of the overall transportation solution for our region.
00:30:40
GLTC's 40 bus fleet transports nearly 3 million passengers annually
00:30:46
and 2 million of those are college students associated practically with Liberty University but also a smaller group with Lynchburg College.
00:30:55
GLTC's 12-bus paratransit fleet transports over 25,000 customers with disabilities annually and they've been showing a 20% growth rate annually over the last few years.
00:31:10
GLTC's college partnerships have
00:31:19
GLTC's college partnerships have encouraged a modal shift from a single-occupant vehicle to bus transport, alleviating serious congestion problems on the campus of Liberty University, as well as in the area around that, in particular Wards Road and Campbell's Mountain, two of the most congested areas within the City of Lynchburg and within Region 2000.
00:31:42
GLTC's core urban service provides an essential transportation solution for citizens who do not have access to an automobile and actually it provides a sustainable transportation choice for those that do have an auto.
00:32:01
GLTC services increasingly
00:32:09
is increasingly seen as an integral component of the city's ongoing sustainability initiatives and improves the region's quality of life.
00:32:17
A recent economic impact analysis of GLPC and the bus service by Jack Fawcett and Associates accomplished this past year so that for every dollar that's invested in transit in the Lynchburg area that returns seven dollars to the community as a whole.
00:32:34
To properly manage the system's ongoing growth, GLTC has recently completed a transit development plan and a comprehensive operational analysis.
00:32:44
The results of these two efforts and some other planning programs or initiatives that the transit company has taken on
00:32:54
has shown a need to expand their or actually relocate their transfer station and actually they're looking to relocate that to the Kemper Street Station area adjacent to where both Greyhound and Amtrak have their facilities.
00:33:10
And they're also looking to build a new maintenance facility and administrative center.
00:33:16
As they move forward with these efforts, they're going to need ongoing support from both FDA and DRPT to attract funding for it.
00:33:24
The expected cost is about $35 million.
00:33:28
If they can stay on track, they hope to have those projects complete within the 2012-2013 timeframe.
00:33:38
And finally, I just would like to mention this board has been very supportive of enhancement projects within the Region 2000 area in the past.
00:33:48
My staff has put forward three project applications this year.
00:33:52
All of them are continuing efforts of past projects that have been supported by you all.
00:33:59
Two, our street-safe programs within the town of Brookfield and the town of Alta Vista, they are integral to, in both those communities, they're part of a larger effort related to their downtown revitalization efforts and we'd ask for your favorable consideration of those applications.
00:34:18
We have also
00:34:20
This is part of an overall implementation effort for our regional green waste program, and we would also ask you to give some favorable consideration to that project.
00:34:39
At this point, I'm more than happy to entertain any questions or comments, but I do thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:51
Talking about the 29 south of Lynchburg, leaving Lynchburg going towards Danville, what is being done to protect that corridor and is Campbell County, that's all in Campbell County, are they working with the NBO to protect that corridor?
SPEAKER_20
00:35:09
They have, actually Campbell County has over the last few years took on a number of planning studies looking specifically at identifying opportunities for access management techniques along that corridor, realizing that what they really need to have is the bypass extended, but that's not going to happen for quite some time.
00:35:32
But they have looked at access management techniques and actually have
00:35:39
adopted within their zoning ordinance a lot of those considerations so as that corridor continues to develop and you have seen it develop over time we'll be able to look at driveway spacing, cross access, all those types of things to help with the safety of that corridor and maintaining the through movement of traffic.
SPEAKER_09
00:36:03
Mr. White, thank you for your presentation.
00:36:06
I am clearly familiar with your district because I have family-owned land up in Amherst County.
00:36:11
And I was impressed with the Amherst County bypass.
00:36:13
And I know you said with your major projects that you have bypass around Lynchburg.
00:36:20
Do you keep traffic count statistics on that bypass?
00:36:25
And are we averaging what we thought we would average or more based on the traffic through there?
SPEAKER_20
00:36:31
We do, and I say we, we work closely with the district staff.
00:36:36
But my understanding, it is tracking pretty much as they expected, and I don't know if Mr. Perry has any better information for that, but it's viewed as a very successful project for us, and we just need to move it further south.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:56
Yes, Ms. Garczynski?
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:58
Yes, I have a question for you on that coordination of land use and transportation on a regional basis.
00:37:06
Is it a concept of a regional comp plan for all the counties or how are you trying to coordinate?
SPEAKER_20
00:37:12
I've just been arrested for that.
00:37:15
It's a tough nut to crack to be honest with you.
00:37:18
We work very hard at maintaining good and constant relations within the professional planning community and the planning commission community within region 2000.
00:37:30
We meet on a regular basis talking about not only transportation type issues but planning issues in general.
00:37:36
And through that ongoing dialogue, we're able to continually promote various concepts like increasing the density within the urban core, promoting traditional neighborhood development type projects in certain areas of the region where it makes sense.
00:37:55
So we maintain a constant dialogue along those lines.
00:37:59
Because of that, we've been able to influence, as I mentioned,
00:38:04
When we go through these corridor studies and all, we're actually talking as we go through that process about how we're bringing it forward into their comprehensive plans.
00:38:11
So that constant dialogue, that ease of relationship amongst the community goes a long ways to help us do it.
00:38:20
But quite honestly, like I think
00:38:22
everywhere Americans are typically problem solvers and fortunately we have not been seeing the difficulties that you see in other parts of the state.
00:38:31
So it's difficult to make those cases as a matter of fact.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:36
But it's a dialogue amongst the community.
00:38:38
It's not a regional conflict.
SPEAKER_20
00:38:40
It is a dialogue.
00:38:42
We do have regional planning efforts and we incorporate those considerations but we haven't got to that point.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:48
Any other questions?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:49
Chairman?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:50
Yes, Sir Richard.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:51
Can you please tell me, Mr. White, and thanks for being here.
00:38:53
You've got a beautiful part of the country.
00:38:55
I go to Lynchburg every now and then.
00:38:57
It's a beautiful city, a vibrant city.
00:39:00
And you've got Jefferson's Popular Forest over there in Fedster County, which is an amazing place.
00:39:05
What percentage of your goods move by rail out of your area?
SPEAKER_20
00:39:10
I don't have an answer for that, but I can get that for you.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:14
Is there significant feedback?
00:39:15
Yes.
SPEAKER_20
00:39:16
We have both CSX and Norfolk Southern.
00:39:20
Griffin Pipe uses it, Big Island uses it, Georgia Pacific paper in Big Island area, so we have significant users of rail in our area.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:34
Do you know what percentage of goods go north versus south?
SPEAKER_20
00:39:42
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:56
Mr. Christie and Mr. White, I simply wanted to congratulate you on your Lynchburg train service.
00:40:01
Be our first state-sponsored service and to be up only a year and to be the number one state-sponsored service in the Amtrak system I think is quite an accomplishment.
00:40:11
I simply wanted to congratulate you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:14
Any other questions, Mr. White?
00:40:17
I actually have two questions.
00:40:18
First off, you're looking at the 29 bypass around to the east.
00:40:23
Have we got any sort of scoping about what the cost of that will be?
SPEAKER_20
00:40:27
Not in any meaningful way to this point.
00:40:33
There's been discussions about the eastern route, the western route.
00:40:40
The Campbell County folks have, in a very broad brush sort of sense, taken a look at some of those considerations.
00:40:49
The issue we find is if you go too far down the road trying to identify
00:40:55
locations or corridor, where does that put you relative to when you're actually going to be constructing and taking control of property?
00:41:07
And the timing of it is such that it becomes quite a difficult nut to grasp.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:15
Also, I don't know if you know, there seems to be controversy up on Charlottesville on 29 and a bypass.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:24
I've heard rumors.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:25
You've heard rumors about that.
SPEAKER_20
00:41:27
By the way, I like Charlottesville.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:33
If you had discussions, how often do you discuss that specific issue with the Charlottesville folks?
SPEAKER_20
00:41:41
A number of our localities as well as folks from our regional group participated in the most recent 29 corridor study efforts and I think generally they were pleased with how those discussions proceeded and some of the I guess original thinking or unique thinking that went into a lot of that study and a lot of the analysis.
00:42:10
I think the major concern most people have is one, just to get this thing settled one way or the other.
00:42:17
Two, this inter-regional connectivity issue is something that is very important, not just to the county fathers, the city fathers type of thing, but within our business community.
00:42:30
So that topic comes up a lot of different ways, not necessarily talking about Charlottesville,
00:42:35
talking from the standpoint of being able to get to different markets and different regions within the United States, but also globally.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:43
So one of the things that we're going to try to do is maybe sponsor a meeting between yourselves and the folks up in Charlottesville.
00:42:52
We were trying to do something like that back in the fall, but we will be coming back to you about seeing what we can do.
SPEAKER_20
00:43:00
If there's anything we can do to help facilitate that, please let us know.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:04
Thank you.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:05
Mr. Rich and Mr. Ellis.
00:43:07
Can you tell me about your flow of traffic going north?
00:43:12
How much traffic is on 81 as far as commercial traffic versus 29?
SPEAKER_20
00:43:19
It is difficult to move over to 81 from our area.
00:43:24
You have to either move up 29 to go over 64 or you take
00:43:30
A very difficult route over 501 north up to the Lexington area, through Buena Vista and then this side of Lexington.
00:43:42
So it's not an easy movement to get from our area to 81.
00:43:47
Part of what has been discussed from time to time is 81 gets more and more difficult
00:43:51
The sense is we're going to see more of that traffic actually pretty much in 29.
00:43:57
Time will tell how that works, but there's only so many north-south corridors going through the Columbia Wealthy through this part of the country, so we do see it's not unrealistic and expected.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:08
A little bit of traffic on 29 just because of congestion on 8 o'clock.
00:44:12
As you know, Mr. Colmay has been leading a task force on about 29 and might become a little bit of a sit-on to try to get a hold of some of these issues and Mark is on there and Gary and others.
00:44:25
So we're trying to work this out.
00:44:27
But one thing, as someone who's familiar with the 29 area north, don't think you're home free after Charlottesville.
00:44:34
I mean, northern Albemarle,
00:44:36
There's severe pressure there for more traffic signals.
00:44:40
You go into green, you know the due traffic signals coming in at green.
00:44:46
I'm told that there's severe pressure in Madison and Culpeper for more signals.
00:44:51
You get into Fauquier, you're stopped dead at the Lawrence and Bypass with a stoplight.
00:44:59
Then you get into Gainesville,
00:45:02
You go further north in Gainesville, and you're a complete gridlock.
00:45:05
Nobody can move.
00:45:06
So it's a district or a quarter-wide problem.
00:45:12
And it's more than just one bump in the road.
00:45:15
Unfortunately, there's many bumps in the road.
00:45:18
And we're trying to get a hold of that on this task force.
00:45:20
But thanks again so much, Jim.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:23
Mr. Chairman.
00:45:24
Yeah, Ms. Collins.
00:45:26
What do you feel the demand is on this western leg of 29 bypass over the 460?
SPEAKER_20
00:45:33
It'll be a similar demand to what we see with the Madison Heights bypass, and we'll see that continue to grow.
00:45:40
The area, the Ward's Road area of the city moving south,
00:45:47
29th South in the Campbell County is one of our key commercial quarters right now.
00:45:54
It has been for a number of years and continues to grow.
00:45:59
That's not going to stop for the foreseeable future.
00:46:01
In fact, with the growth that we see with Liberty University that's having a significant impact
00:46:11
The travel arrangements through that area, so it's not gonna get better, it's gonna continue to be more difficult.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:19
I noticed too, you're showing the upgrade of 501, you know, that you were just talking about.
SPEAKER_20
00:46:25
Yeah, 501, actually I've mentioned the 460, 29 corridor, I mentioned the 29 as a whole.
00:46:35
The 501 corridor is just as important to us as 460 and 29.
00:46:41
We actually have a 501 coalition that is consistently, constantly working to promote improvements along that corridor.
00:46:52
It's a difficult road to deal with.
00:46:54
And actually, when we're talking about 501, we're talking about North Carolina all the way up to 81, if you will.
00:47:03
And that is just as important as these others.
00:47:07
That's my perspective.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:08
I don't believe this.
00:47:09
Is there anything in the six-year plan, Mr. Chairman, in regards to improvements on 501 to Buena Vista?
00:47:18
You looking at me?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:19
I don't have my plan in front of me so I can't look, you know.
00:47:24
Ms. Busher, where's Ms. Busher?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:26
There she is.
00:47:31
I could have said that.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:40
They're constantly working on the curves and that type of thing.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:03
All right, Mr. White, thank you very much.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:08
We appreciate it.
00:48:10
Mr. Christie, thank you very much.
00:48:12
We appreciate both of you having an excellent presentation.
00:48:16
Revenue sharing program update.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:48:18
Mr. Estes, welcome back.
00:48:20
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:21
Good to be back.
00:48:21
How would you like the fresh air out there instead?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:48:26
It was a very enjoyable time.
00:48:27
I appreciate the opportunity to go to Stanton.
00:48:31
It was a great opportunity for me and I appreciate the support from Dr. Davis and Mr. Louderback while I was there.
00:48:43
Put us back to local assistance business today.
00:48:46
I have a really short presentation on the revenue sharing program and the bottom line is going to be the next chart.
00:48:54
Basically this board asked us to go out and reach out to localities early part of last fall to ask early on in the game what would be the participation or the interest from local governments on the revenue sharing program, trying to help us get a feel for what type of budget numbers we should look at for the next year.
00:49:13
So we asked for letters of intent basically, nothing too formal from local governments.
00:49:18
In fact, to be due in December.
00:49:21
And we had response from 60 localities saying they would request, again, tentatively up to around $45 million.
00:49:29
So the one thing I will highlight on that slide that I think is important, as you know, there's several things being discussed.
00:49:36
We heard about this in Roanoke under the governor's legislation, looking at revenue sharing program as well.
00:49:41
When we did send out the letter, we put it under the purview of the current code, getting rid of the tiers, potentially, that we've talked about here at the board,
00:49:48
but looking at continuing the cap at $1 million.
00:49:51
I think it's important to note that the numbers that I'm presenting today kind of have that assumption behind that.
00:49:57
There's discussion of removing that cap and that's being discussed in the session currently.
00:50:03
The next chart is just kind of a breakdown by district so you can see where it is for your district.
00:50:08
These numbers, if you want to look in relation to last year, we had 53 localities requesting funds
00:50:17
of about $37 million last year.
00:50:20
So you can see we're up a little bit from what we had in request last year.
00:50:24
And as a reminder, last year, the board allocated only 15 million, so we had to prorate that down, those requests.
00:50:32
So with that, we're kind of obviously have our eyes set on the General Assembly and what action will come out of there.
00:50:38
There are three other bills in the session right now dealing with revenue sharing.
00:50:42
I have a variety of different takes on that right now.
00:50:45
So based on what comes out of the session, we'll reach back out to local governments and we'll go through the more formal application process.
00:50:53
But again, this response from local governments gives us a pretty good idea as to what locals are willing to participate if that million dollar cap is still on there.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:06
Is our request a 15 million deal or is it open as to what it might be during the session?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:51:15
Well, I do think that that topic will be part of the session as far as to how the budget comes out from the Appropriation Act and other discussions.
00:51:24
I do think that part of, and I won't speak for the Chairman, part of the reason for asking for this is so the Board can discuss how much the Board would like to see budgeted regardless of what the General Assembly action is towards the program.
00:51:36
So we're trying to get that ahead of the curve before we get into that discussion.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:40
James, so I understand then there is some discretion on our part as to how large that might be in addition to the Governor's budget and whatever the General Assembly does.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:48
Yeah, the intention was that we would sort of restructure the program to long what we're doing now.
00:51:55
Go out early, see what the interest is so we have a ballpark idea and then we can make a decision then about how much actually to set aside in the six-year plan.
00:52:05
And again, the main issue behind this was just simply looking at the fact that if we have the opportunity to turn one state dollar into essentially two dollars worth of project, let's do it.
00:52:18
And this is great though, just for this year, I mean obviously,
00:52:22
Unlike last year where we ended up only setting aside a certain amount, that we ended up having dramatically more applications for, was it last year where we only set aside like $15 million and we actually had?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:52:35
We had about $37 million worth of requests and we only had $15 million available.
00:52:40
Yeah.
00:52:41
Again, through the budget process, depending on what comes out of the session, you know, the current, if you go back to the way it was last year, the General Assembly would set aside that $15 million through the Appropriation Act and then
00:52:52
There was the opportunity to use the 3202 revenue bonds, CPR bonds, to backfill that.
00:52:58
And that was some of the discussion to the budget development.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:01
So now we have an idea.
00:53:02
We're going to try to put this into the six-year plan.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:53:04
Yeah.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:04
I was going to say, it's relatively a 20% increase in requests already in just your preliminary look.
00:53:12
So the $15 million, if we stayed constant, we'd be behind from what we did last year for local government, right?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:20
Yes, sir.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:22
Yes.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:26
Is there a possibility that we would see an increase in interest if we did something with this tiering situation and this could be a lot more request from the locals?
00:53:35
Is that a possibility?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:53:36
Yes, sir.
00:53:36
Mr. Chairman, Mr. King, I do think and we tried to express that in our letter when we sent it out that that was some things that we were proposing and I do think that obviously the tiering is the focus of
00:53:49
Two, if not three, of the revenue sharing bills that have already been introduced.
00:53:53
So I do think we're going to see an increase in participation or requested participation based on the tiering going away.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:01
That's great because just like the Secretary said, instead of awarding $44 million in contracts, we would be awarding $88 million, which has direct impact.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:12
Mr. Chairman, this is an unfair question to ask both to you and Mike.
00:54:17
At this stage of the game, would a resolution from the CTB be helpful in the session as guidance to the legislators as far as appropriation, or would it be wiser for us to let that work its way through and then take our action independently?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:37
Yeah, I think we're going to have to sit down and if this passes, and this obviously would be for next year, it'll be July 1st,
00:54:47
We're going to have to sit there and really come up with a policy and a process on how to evaluate the projects.
00:54:55
There is some concern among some members of the General Assembly if you take off the caps and well that means some jurisdictions that maybe might be wealthier than others will come in and try to push and maybe take a lot of the capacity out.
00:55:10
We're going to have to be fairly robust, and if this does happen and how we make sure that doesn't happen, then we try to be as fair as possible.
00:55:18
So at this point, doctors, I don't know if it's going to be helpful.
00:55:21
I think we're going to have to sit there.
00:55:23
We are going to have to figure this out.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:27
In the early discussions with Clay Yaffe and others, as this program sort of took hold, it appeared that
00:55:37
We were hesitant in their minds to say what we thought the benefits of it were.
00:55:42
I don't know whether that's still true or not.
00:55:44
I have not been a part of any discussions recently.
00:55:47
But it would appear to me that we would want, Al you might remember, we might want to be sure there's no misunderstanding that the CTB believes this is a significantly positive program and we are anxious to
00:56:06
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:27
Whatever you like to do.
00:56:28
I mean actually it was interesting too, if we should go back one slide.
00:56:33
I think it's sort of interesting as you just look at.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:36
I think Bristol and Stanton are more rural areas that in some ways responded more positively because they see that as the only way to get some of the projects in their area underway and they're small enough that they fit within this and can be done.
00:56:55
So if you take the cap off and you start getting three, four, five million dollars, I think it will discourage then some of the smaller jurisdictions to ask for funds to do projects that have not been able to be done through the secondary funding program.
SPEAKER_09
00:57:16
A follow-up to that, Mr. Estes, are these funds actually being obligated and spent, or do we have a similar situation here that we have in CBAC and SDI?
00:57:27
I mean, are these funds really being utilized?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:57:32
Let's see, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Lane, I don't have the numbers in front of me.
00:57:35
We've obviously looked at that, and there's a heavy attention to that matter, as we've discussed on many of our programs.
00:57:43
I do think
00:57:45
This is state dollars.
00:57:47
I think it's one thing to remember versus most of the other things we've had problems with have been on the federal program side and getting through some of that federal process.
00:57:53
So I would say, without looking at the numbers in front of me, I think this is less of a problem in the revenue sharing program.
00:57:58
I still think there are a lot of locally administered projects within this program.
00:58:02
There's still a lot of folks who go through some of the learning curve to get through some of the project development process.
00:58:08
But this is more of state funds.
00:58:11
A lot of the rural counties, they use this to do things.
00:58:15
to upgrade dirt roads and rehab roads that are a little bit easier to get through the process than some of the other federal projects.
SPEAKER_09
00:58:24
Although I will confess in my old jurisdiction that what we used to do
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:39
Get every year applied for the million and accumulate until you had enough money for a bigger project.
00:58:44
So, but we would divide it up.
00:58:46
They'd divide it up among the seven magisterial districts, which you know, it's 50,000 people a piece.
00:58:52
And end up figuring out how to divide and build it up.
00:58:57
Every year in the county budget, we actually used to set aside for every magisterial district an amount to match the state match until they got big enough to do entire roads.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:59:08
I will say that until the code changed a couple of years ago, there wasn't some teeth behind some of that.
00:59:17
We've been discouraging local governments from doing that more recently because there wasn't a lot of teeth again in the law or CTB policy that said you had to spend the money down in a certain amount of time.
00:59:29
The law was changed a couple of years ago to where now
00:59:32
The funds have to be expended or begin to show expenditure within three years of the allocation of the board.
00:59:39
So there is, again, some of that coming forward now, and I can report on that back to the board.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:45
Thank you.
SPEAKER_09
00:59:48
Are we finding any reluctance, or I'm not saying reluctance maybe, but I know that we've increased with the number of requests, but if locality has been commenting anything about
00:59:59
The lack of revenue as a result of the economy the way it is now is somewhat of a reluctance to get into projects that they know they can't maybe raise some money for.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:00:11
Absolutely.
01:00:11
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Lauterbach, I definitely have heard personally feedback from local governments who would like to participate more.
01:00:17
If the economic climate wasn't what it was today, I think they would participate more.
01:00:24
They're really just trying to look at the different
01:00:26
Eris and the Quiver to try to see where they can leverage the resources to get some of these projects done.
01:00:31
But there are definitely local governments who would like to participate more and take larger advantage of the program that aren't financially able to do that right now.
01:00:39
A good example in Southwest right now, they have a unique situation where they can use coal-feverance and other local revenue type things to help leverage that, where in some other parts of rural Virginia, they don't have that other resource to help leverage this money.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:57
What is the percentage breakdown as far as the local match and the revenue share?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:01:06
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Ellis, the numbers you're seeing here are assuming it's a 50-50 match.
01:01:16
That's what the law is set up for right now.
01:01:18
A couple of years ago, one of the tiers, we talk about tiers a lot, gave priority to local governments who brought more money to the table.
01:01:27
And so several years ago when the board made an allocation, instead of 50-50, there were larger jurisdictions that were bringing substantial amount of money to make sure they got priority for this funding.
01:01:38
So the percentage was much heavier on the local side than it is currently on the 50-50.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:48
Any other questions?
01:01:51
Thank you very much and welcome back.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:01:52
Thanks, sir.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:54
Next we have the financial report, and this is going to be given by Laura Farmer, who just was named division administrator for the financial planning division.
01:02:03
Congratulations.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:02:26
Thank you all very much.
SPEAKER_13
01:02:46
My name is Laura Farmer and I'm the new division administrator for financial planning.
01:02:50
It's my second day on the job so please be easy on me.
01:02:54
Just to give you a brief recap of the VDOT fiscal year 2011 budget, our annual budget for the year as approved in June totaled $3.32 billion.
01:03:24
58% of those supporting revenues are from state sources and federal revenues represent 27% of the funding.
01:03:32
The remaining 15% are from other sources such as bonds and other local revenue that we include in the budget.
01:03:39
1.7 billion or 50% is allocated to maintenance operations including locality maintenance payments.
01:03:46
$1 billion or 30% of that amount is allocated to construction.
01:03:51
However, our current operating budget includes carryover of prior year maintenance balances, our stimulus balances left over from the initial award, any new federal grants that we've received as well as bonus obligation authority and other miscellaneous adjustments, bring our working total to $4.2 million.
01:04:13
This slide is a brief overview of our major revenue sources.
01:04:17
As you can see,
01:04:19
The HMO Fund and the TTF Fund are tracking ahead of where they stood in fiscal year 10.
01:04:25
However, each of them is slightly below the revenue estimate forecast.
01:04:32
But again, all major sources are up from the previous fiscal year.
01:04:39
Year to date, the Commonwealth Transportation Fund revenues are up 4.1% and that includes transfers directed by the Appropriation Act
01:04:47
This is due to the accelerated sales tax of the previous fiscal year.
01:04:51
Our motor fuels tax collections are up 2.5% year over year, but they're currently lower than the expected annual growth of 3.1%.
01:05:02
Motor vehicle sales and use tax collections are up 12.3%.
01:05:05
This is exceeding the estimated 6.9% of growth that is required due to the revenue estimate, but I'd also note that collections through December
01:05:15
are 13.3% lower than the same level through the same period of fiscal year 2008.
01:05:23
So sales are improving slowly, but the Department of Taxation has indicated that they're not expected to reach a normal volume until early 2013.
01:05:35
Our year-to-date sales tax collections have increased by 1.7% when we include those transfers due to the accelerated sales tax.
01:05:44
and that's performing better than the estimate of 2% reduction.
01:05:51
Our spending through December, VDOT has spent $1.81 billion through the end of December.
01:05:57
This represents 43% of our operating budget through 50% of the year.
01:06:03
Our spending is $161 million greater than where we were at this point last fiscal year.
01:06:10
And our labor expenditures are down 256 million compared to 292 million through the same period of the prior year.
01:06:17
I'd also like to note that we are 618 less bodies in terms of full-time classified employees than we were a year ago.
01:06:27
Our maintenance spending is up 90.8 million dollars and we have significant increases in our stimulus projects as expected.
01:06:37
They're up 52 and a half million dollars.
01:06:42
This chart illustrates that spending, basically construction spending is up about 2%, that excludes the stimulus projects, and the summary is provided here.
01:06:58
As you can see through the graph, expenditures through December by program, construction spending is slightly greater than during the same period in fiscal year 10.
01:07:09
Our maintenance spending is up 17%,
01:07:12
and our administrative expenditures are down as expected and our spending activity with the stimulus projects is double what it was in the previous year.
01:07:24
A brief overview of our maintenance program.
01:07:26
We've spent $622 million through December, most of that being state at 491 million.
01:07:34
In comparison to the previous year, our total expenditures were 531.
01:07:39
with 405 million state and 125 million of that federal.
01:07:44
This represents a 17% increase over fiscal year 10.
01:07:48
Most of that increased spending is in state-funded work.
01:07:51
It also includes an additional 12.2 million more snow operations costs than through December of the prior year.
01:07:58
But what I'd like to note is that most of our snow spending last year occurred later in the winter than in December, so this was expected.
01:08:06
For our snow operations, we spent $44.9 million through December.
01:08:18
The December final budget as repair of our system's operations director reported that our spending through December is about $44 million less than expected through the maintenance spend plan, or 6.7%.
01:08:33
Ending the year on target with the spend plan would result in approximately a $400 million balance.
01:08:39
Our actions taken to reduce this unspent balance include we increased the 2010 contract paving work that's expected to be completed by June 1 by about $70 million.
01:08:50
And by the end of December, about $490 million worth of contracts for the fiscal year paving season were advertised.
01:08:57
That's more than double the amount this time last year.
01:09:02
If we assume that the industry starts working on these contracts in the spring, spending in the last quarter of fiscal year 10 is anticipated to be very high.
01:09:10
Historically, our fourth quarter activity related to these contracts is between 20 and 25 percent of their value.
01:09:17
So with that on target, we should spend about $98 to $123 million of paving work in the current fiscal year.
01:09:26
If spending on these contracts falls short of this estimate, the year-end balance could be a little bit higher in the maintenance program.
01:09:36
This graph depicts the contract work underway in comparison to the contract values.
01:09:42
This reflects the awarded projects and the balances on those projects month to month as we progress through the fiscal year.
01:09:55
This is a depiction of our cash balances.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:57
I'm sorry, could you explain this one under way?
01:10:00
Oh, this is actually contracts under way.
01:10:02
Yes, sir.
01:10:06
Which is a good thing, the chart.
01:10:08
It's getting higher.
SPEAKER_13
01:10:10
Yes, it sure is.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:15
Mr. Chairman.
01:10:18
Yes.
01:10:19
You're saying you're shooting for the target on the spending, which is the budgets, but
01:10:24
Right now you're under that.
01:10:27
Have you extrapolated what the plan, the presumed actual may really be?
01:10:31
Forget about Target.
01:10:34
Have you done that yet?
01:10:35
I mean, I know you have in two days, but will you be doing that?
SPEAKER_13
01:10:40
I think so.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:41
Do you see what the delta really may be?
SPEAKER_13
01:10:44
Yes, we continue to monitor the maintenance activity to
01:10:51
Understand how that is going with the question to their spin plan.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:58
Is there a particular impediment to being at budget on maintenance work at this point?
01:11:06
Because I think everybody's been trying to get the money out in order to create jobs and opportunities.
01:11:12
I was just curious if there is some impediment that's preventing that from happening that you or someone else might comment on.
SPEAKER_13
01:11:23
No, sir, I'm not aware of anything.
01:11:26
I think that the staff has put the work on the street as best as possible in terms of what VDOT and the industry can handle, and I'll let Connie speak to that.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:11:34
Let me just add that because the construction season doesn't start until the spring, there are two differences.
01:11:41
What we projected is we think that to get the $500 million balance of cash that we had from last year down,
01:11:49
Most of that work was under contract.
01:11:51
It just wasn't expended.
01:11:53
So the money will be on contracts committed, but we think that there's still going to be somewhere in the neighborhood of $325 million.
01:12:04
That's going to be not able to be expended by the contractors unless they decide to do historically a lot more work than they have done.
01:12:14
So obviously with the economy being not quite as robust as it was in the commercial world where they do a lot of work, they might decide to do more work.
01:12:23
which could help bring that balance down further.
01:12:27
So that's.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:28
If they have the production capacity.
01:12:29
Yeah, so that's.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:12:30
A lot of them.
01:12:31
Some of them are gearing up obviously to be able to do greater production because this is far more work in a single season that they have done in many years.
01:12:40
So that really is so.
01:12:43
All the contracts are out.
01:12:44
Now it's really up to the industry to move the money.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:49
Move the.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:53
I'm sorry so I mean actually the one thing I didn't want to point out where we were up on our maintenance balance of well over 500 million you've been getting it down to a much more you know I'm gonna say manageable 250 to 260 million looking at this chart um looking at this chart of contract work underway no you have maintenance balance that's a little black line with a little x's
01:13:22
This is the snapshot of our cash balances as of the end of December.
SPEAKER_13
01:13:43
The current cash balances by funds.
01:13:47
The HMOF, the first line, and our construction fund under transportation trust funds represent our major operating funds, and the other funds are dedicated to specific programs.
01:13:59
For reference, we're about in the same place we were at year end, fiscal year 10, and so as that work gets underway, our cash balances should react the same way accordingly.
01:14:15
For our cash outlook,
01:14:17
Highway maintenance and operating fund began the year at $440 million based on spending through December and our current projections will end the year with a similar balance without significant spending of new maintenance contracts by the paving industry.
01:14:30
So as that work comes to fruition, we'll better see how those payments out affect our current cash outlays.
01:14:39
The construction fund also began the year at $480 million and is forecasted to end down nearly $120 million.
01:14:46
This reflects our anticipated reimbursements of the CPR bond expenditures.
01:14:50
That's part of the package that was issued last May.
01:14:53
And the projections also don't include the use of unspent construction funds as recommended by the audit.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:59
I'm sorry, before you leave that chart.
01:15:01
So the 440, I mean, we're going to continually try to push that number down.
01:15:06
Is that right?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:07
Yes, sir.
01:15:10
Mr. Chairman, did we do that by approving new projects?
01:15:15
That's the idea.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:17
Yeah, I mean, the problem with that balance is that's, you're saying what will be potentially, but the number will be at June 30th, which you need to have some balance because you have projects, the contracts coming out.
01:15:33
But the thing is, is that it should be lower than that.
01:15:39
You actually have a contract at least awarded, so you can continue through the summer doing the work.
01:15:44
Because on June 30th, July 1st, we put in another $1.82 billion into HMOF, right?
01:15:54
So we need to get that balance down as low as you can.
01:15:58
Well, not as low as, at one point it went down to $30 or $40 million back about a decade ago.
01:16:05
It should be about $100 million.
01:16:08
That's what we're shooting for?
01:16:09
What are we shooting for?
SPEAKER_13
01:16:10
We're working on it, and the timing of the fiscal year as opposed to the season of contract work.
01:16:17
So we should pick up.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:19
Well, I think the issue is that's what they're trying to figure out is what should the number be.
01:16:25
At one point, the commissioner should catch it.
01:16:27
It got down to 40, 50, 60 million, somewhere in there, which is way too low, just in case something happened.
01:16:37
But it should be a little bit higher than that.
01:16:39
but obviously well below the 549 we had last year.
01:16:46
Ms.
01:16:46
Bunch.
SPEAKER_09
01:16:47
I understand there'll be some in there but if we're putting in 1.8 billion a year, I mean wouldn't cash flow, big time, I mean using those funds, I mean if we got down to zero, understanding what you're saying could happen but we presumably could adjust later on in the year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:02
Yeah.
01:17:04
Well, there's just, I think that the issue here is just simply
01:17:09
for the actual spending on contracts that were already awarded.
01:17:15
So in many ways, if you think about this, the fact that you have 500 million that has not been spent means by the time we actually spend it, it's either at the end or may not even get actually done while the construction year is going on.
01:17:36
So you want to end up having it back to, because you want to continue to have projects, or going out to advertisements.
01:17:44
So 100 million or so, or I don't know what number you all were looking at, but it should be something like that, to continue for that first month or so while you're still advertising projects for the rest of that construction.
SPEAKER_09
01:17:58
A minimal amount to keep the thing going.
01:18:00
Yes, yes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:03
The problem is, I think,
01:18:06
You correct me if I'm wrong, I know you're something, but obviously we have our fiscal year is different than our maintenance and construction season.
01:18:16
And so we need to make sure that the money is actually on that street.
01:18:20
Most of that maintenance money should be out in contracts and hopefully underway being spent come the spring and then at that point the middle of the summer.
SPEAKER_13
01:18:32
Yes, sir.
01:18:32
As Connie said, yes, that is the plan.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:35
You're going to do great, Ms. John.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:39
Yes, Ms. Miller.
01:18:41
Does the way the money flow works, assuming we get $1.8 billion for next fiscal year, is that whole $1.8 billion available to us on day one of the fiscal year?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:53
No.
01:18:54
That rateably, if we... Oh, I'm sorry, for the
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:58
You used the term 1.8 billion as the new money that's going to come in and my question is do we get that rateably or is the cash available on day one?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:11
I mean you can plan it and program it and you can advertise.
01:19:18
You have enough monies in your reserves to cover it.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:21
That's what I'm asking.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:19:22
I'm asking about the cash.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:23
But it's not all, it doesn't all plop down all at once.
01:19:27
I mean, essentially, you know it's coming in.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:30
So you couldn't have a scenario, in fact, I'm just trying to understand how the money flows, back to Mr. Layne's question.
01:19:37
If I spent all my money, if I was down at zero, not 100 million, not 50 million, not 30, but zero,
01:19:45
And I had 1.8 million that I was bidding, or had on the street, as of July 1.
01:19:51
Did I have enough, in that work we're starting, do I have the cash there to fund that or not?
01:19:56
I'm just trying to find out how the money flows.
01:19:59
Not really.
01:20:00
Because obviously the earlier you have the money, unless you need the money from the previous year to sort of tide you through.
01:20:08
for projects that come online.
01:20:12
So I'm just trying to understand relative to this question how the money really flows, how the cash flows.
01:20:18
Ms. Busher.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:20:19
Chairman, Mr. Miller.
01:20:22
The General Assembly appropriates the funds based on the official revenue estimates and forecasts.
01:20:29
We then allocate those funds to our programs when we adopt the budget for the next year.
01:20:35
We then can use those allocations and it flows with money that we currently have as projects.
01:20:44
We're continuing, it's a continuing process and movement of money from year to year.
01:20:49
We can start contracts, we can start projects, we can put things out to bid.
01:20:54
And then the cash flow comes to us periodically.
01:20:57
Some comes in quarterly, some comes in monthly, and that goes into our VDOT cash flow.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:08
That's what keeps us going.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:21:17
And what we were saying is some of the estimates that we're looking at are based on a fiscal year.
01:21:23
Our construction cycle isn't convenient to work out as a fiscal year.
01:21:28
It's at different points during the year for different types of projects.
01:21:31
So cash is available as you go through and as money's coming in the door, money's going out the door.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:41
I think, Chef, to answer your question, the operating budget and the cash flow budget are related, but they are not necessarily handled exactly the same way.
01:21:52
The Commonwealth assets would fund, if necessary, a cash flow situation.
01:21:58
But you don't exceed your budget.
01:22:01
The budget is the mandated part.
01:22:02
How the cash comes in and out is a Commonwealth issue, not a single department issue.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:09
And one of the things is that when we look at these cash balances, that doesn't mean that a contract hasn't been awarded.
01:22:17
So there's just this enormous liquidity in our funds.
01:22:24
But the thing is we have to take these pictures.
01:22:25
One of the problems I think is that we were not taking these snapshots and trying to keep track of it on the trends.
01:22:36
Now I'm sorry, before Ms. Busher, maybe, I mean one of the issues that came up during the presentation that's not in here per se,
01:22:46
But where are we on our federal obligation authority?
01:22:50
Because obviously one of the things the audit was showing was that we were, you know, going through essentially the first six months of the federal fiscal year with only five or ten percent of our
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:23:01
We are further along this year than we were last year and what we are doing to continue to monitor the projects that we have included in our federal strategy for this federal fiscal year.
01:23:18
We are meeting every two weeks with the Federal Highway Administration making sure that what we submit to them is getting approved for federal authorization timely.
01:23:28
We are also meeting with all the districts every two weeks
01:23:32
to make sure they're meeting their scheduled dates for activity on projects to make sure that if it's that the add date that they've provided us which is the date we can obligate and pass that project over to FHWA that they'll meet those dates and so we're doing that regularly but we have a formal list of projects for which our federal
01:23:57
That will help us make our federal strategy and we're all working from that same list.
01:24:03
The beginning of the year we did have to deal with initial fire releases which is when projects are not moving timely from the date of the original obligation.
01:24:16
They release the obligations, and then we have to reobligate them.
01:24:19
So that sort of puts us in a negative position at the beginning of every federal fiscal year.
01:24:24
We are beyond that, and now we're actually programming new obligations and modifications to agreements for projects, project phases moving forward.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:24:36
I'm sorry.
01:24:37
Before we leave, there was, you all were having discussions with the Federal Highways about
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
01:24:43
We're looking at that in the maintenance arena for things like picking on a corridor on the interstate or primary where we're looking at guardrail replacement or rumble strips and we'll say we're going to go from this milepost to this milepost.
01:25:06
They approve that program for those replacements.
01:25:10
and then when we submit individual projects for a certain section of that from milepost to milepost and say we'll break it up into four pieces for procurement purposes, they won't have to go back and approve those segments that we actually put out for bids.
01:25:27
We're not quite there in terms of working out the logistics but we are in discussions for that to happen hopefully before too long.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:37
Two quick questions.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:40
One, can you help me understand this one revenue chart a little bit more for FY 2011?
01:25:47
Are there any extrapolations in that or is that the hard number for what's come in?
SPEAKER_13
01:25:53
No, sorry, it just reflects the adjustment for the accelerated sales tax transfer.
01:25:59
But other than that, there's no...
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:00
There's no extrapolation there.
01:26:03
These are the numbers?
01:26:04
That is the number.
01:26:04
Yes.
01:26:05
The other question is that I found out in asking a question about how one project was funded.
01:26:12
I didn't know this before.
01:26:13
I understand that the Commonwealth is being penalized by the federal government 3% of federal funds because we don't have a so-called open container law.
01:26:23
Are we looking into trying to, is that something we ought to address?
01:26:27
Will we get more money?
01:26:29
What is the story on that?
01:26:31
I never knew that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:33
Well, when we're done, Mr. Rich, if you'd like to go down and talk to them about it, you're more than welcome.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:38
So it's just something, a political thing that they don't want to pass.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:41
General Assembly's never passed it.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:45
Okay, but we're losing 3% of federal money.
01:26:48
I guess it's recycled into some kind of...
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:51
I don't think technically... We don't lose it actually.
01:26:53
It just doesn't go to...
01:26:56
I'm sorry, come on up.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:57
...or something instead of... That's right, sure.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:59
And we don't technically lose it.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:01
Because of safety programs.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:02
Because of safety programs.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:04
So we couldn't use it actually to build a road or something.
01:27:08
Is there any effort to try to go back to the General Assembly again or are they adamant on this?
01:27:18
I need that up to you Mr. Chairman.
01:27:22
You're more adept at that than I am.
01:27:25
I was just kind of surprised.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:29
One last question Mr. Chairman.
01:27:34
The bullet up here, the third bullet says our year imbalances are largely dependent upon the aggressiveness of the industry.
01:27:43
That sort of implies something different than the capacity of the industry.
01:27:49
It sort of implies that they have the ability to be aggressive.
01:27:53
And so if that's the implication, I guess my question is what strategies do we use to encourage them to get aggressive?
01:28:01
If we want our balances to go down and we're sort of at their, sort of at their pleasure, at least that's what the polling implies to me.
01:28:12
Do we have strategies or are there incentives?
01:28:16
Obviously capacity is capacity.
01:28:18
You can change that, but you can't change it rapidly.
01:28:20
You don't want to change it, but so much because you can't go up and down like that.
01:28:25
It's not a good business.
01:28:26
When I read that bullet, it just sort of jumped out at me as who's driving the train here?
01:28:33
Am I misreading it?
01:28:36
I'm sorry, which one?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:37
Well, because it's the third bullet.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:40
Where our balances are largely dependent on how aggressive the industry executes the work.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:45
Mr. Chairman, I would share with Chef, for several years of looking at this, if you're not careful, you see the bid prices start to increase and your balance disappears for the wrong reason.
01:28:57
In the marketplace, that's the way it works.
01:29:00
If they have excess capacity, you cost me less.
01:29:04
When they have full capacity, their price begins to accelerate.
01:29:08
And we're going to experience that if we're not careful.
01:29:11
So I think being very careful how hard we push this issue is very important.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:29:15
We have been meeting with the industry for some time even through the fall of this year.
01:29:25
We were trying to do some things to encourage them to help increase some of their capacity by providing work orders on existing contracts.
01:29:32
to help do needed work that could be done by work order.
01:29:36
Also a way to get some of the balances down.
01:29:40
For the maintenance types of contracts, typically they have not had strict schedules to adhere to because the theory is we get better prices when they have more flexibility to do the work in between the commercial paving work that they do.
01:29:56
So we don't have any restrictions on them to say that they have to do X amount of work by certain dates.
01:30:04
But we certainly have been encouraging them.
01:30:06
And one strategy has been rather than just having a set date, let's say April 1st to start, if temperatures are warmer and they can start doing work on March the 15th, we would allow them to start sooner.
01:30:20
So those are some of the kinds of things we're trying to work with the industry.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:24
to help them be able to get the work done.
01:30:53
So is this slide saying this is good news?
SPEAKER_13
01:30:57
No.
01:30:58
Only slightly.
01:31:02
You are going to do really well in this job.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:07
It takes to say it's better news than last year but not as good as we hoped.
SPEAKER_13
01:31:11
Yes sir, I think that's a valid statement.
01:31:13
Yes, the revenues are obviously tracking ahead of where they were the prior year but they are slightly below the anticipated revenue estimate.
01:31:21
that we would anticipate at this point in the fiscal year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:25
Okay.
01:31:26
And that's what the little percentage is are.
01:31:33
Yes.
01:31:33
Thank you.
01:31:34
Okay.
01:31:34
Excellent.
01:31:34
Any other questions?
01:31:35
Thank you all very much.
01:31:38
Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_09
01:31:39
Okay.
01:31:39
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:40
Legislative briefing.
01:31:41
I know Mr. Strader is not here, but Mr. Walton, I've seen you out
01:31:45
Did he leave also?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:31:46
I know I'm not that small.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:50
Oh, there you are.
01:31:51
You're looking good.
01:31:52
Come on.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:31:53
I'm stealth with my stealth costume today.
01:31:58
Okay.
01:32:01
Carol, where am I?
01:32:07
Okay.
01:32:10
Good morning.
01:32:12
It's that time of year again.
01:32:14
The legislature's been in town as of today, a week.
01:32:19
As the secretary mentioned, Matt hopefully will be here later.
01:32:23
There is a presentation later on in the agenda where I believe several of the slides talk about the governor's financial plan.
01:32:31
But I was gonna go through VDOT's legislative proposals for the year.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:38
And are we using this, Carol?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:32:43
Okay.
01:32:44
We have 16 pieces of legislation, six are code cleanup bills, five promote government efficiency and streamlining, and five we call omnibus bills that have a number of issues, several of which came out of the governor's commission on government reform.
01:33:00
As far as code cleanup legislation, some of you may recall when George Allen was governor, Disney came to us and wanted to build a theme-related park up in the
01:33:11
Chairman's neck of the woods did not go over well, but at the same time, we did pass a lot of legislation, one of which was the I-66 Economic Development Program, which would provide funding for improvements in the I-66 corridor.
01:33:28
There's another provision dealing with turnpikes that's never been used.
01:33:34
Provision dealing with capital stock, dealing with turnpikes and ferry corporations, again, no longer necessary.
01:33:41
And finally, legislation dealing with the establishment of the Mariners Museum, which has now been established and no longer need to have that legislation to code.
01:33:52
So all four of these have already passed out of Senate transportation.
01:33:57
I believe they may have been passed out of the Senate.
01:33:59
We'll be going over to the House.
01:34:02
Again, more code cleanup, but dealing more with substantive matters
01:34:09
The first one is a misplaced semicolon, probably the shortest bill in general assembly this year.
01:34:17
The way the law reads now, you can drive a golf cart on a 55-mile-an-hour highway.
01:34:22
That was not the intent of the legislation, and the semicolon got placed in there, so we're going to remove that.
01:34:29
to make it clear you cannot drive a golf cart on a 55-mile-an-hour highway.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:34:33
Until July.
01:34:34
Are they still considered golf carts if they're at that point?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:34:38
We have until July, Mark.
01:34:39
That's right.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:34:40
Until July, you get in your golf cart and get out there and drive down the highway.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:34:46
I've actually hit them in a medium strip a couple times.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:34:50
Well, every year there are golf, just up there this morning there was a golf cart build at DCR.
01:34:56
wants to be able to drive golf carts throughout all the parks, drive on the highway.
01:35:02
The next bill is a vertical clearance bill.
01:35:05
It actually came out of the city of Charlottesville about four or five years ago.
01:35:08
A truck hit a railroad bridge, got stuck underneath a railroad bridge, and it turned out that neither the railroad or the city was responsible for signing the bridge.
01:35:18
It turned out the commissioner was responsible even though the bridge was in the city of Charlottesville.
01:35:22
So this clarifies that
01:35:24
that cities are responsible for signing the bridges that are less than 14 feet of clearance.
01:35:33
So again, we consider it more of a code cleanup, but it is somewhat of a substance of change.
01:35:38
Truck restrictions, as many of you know, trucks are prohibited from the leftmost lane of a highway that's two or more lanes in each direction.
01:35:48
We see it on 81, somewhere here in the Richmond area in Northern Virginia.
01:35:53
The Research Council did a study, actually has done two studies, the most recent in 2009, which indicates that there are greater crash rates when we limit the trucks to just those two lanes in high volume areas.
01:36:09
So because of this, we've offered this legislation where the truck restriction in the leftmost lane would only be in those areas where the daily traffic is 10,000 vehicles or less.
01:36:22
So you can see on the slide the three interstates and the number of miles that where trucks now would be allowed to travel in all three lanes instead of just the center and the rightmost lane.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:36:37
Excuse me.
01:36:38
What's the rationale for that one?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:36:41
Crash rates.
01:36:42
The research council study showed there was a greater crash rate in high volume traffic areas where the trucks were restricted only
01:36:51
to the center and right lane and align them to go also in the left lane would reduce crashes.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:00
The logic of that one has a bit of a problem for me.
01:37:08
I would like to have that explained a little better.
01:37:11
I just don't think that crash data by itself determines what we should decide as far as
01:37:21
restricting the lanes of traffic.
01:37:22
Three tractor and trailers side by side on a road cannot be safer than two as far as visibility and a whole list of things that logically one would think about.
01:37:36
I don't understand this.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:37:40
Mr. Chairman, Dr. Davis, I think the issue is when they're restricted to the two most lines in the volume of trucks, it creates a wall.
01:37:50
in that rightmost lane and people trying to merge off the highway or get on the highway, there's not as much opportunity.
01:37:57
So it's an opportunity to spread the truck traffic out among the three lanes so you don't have that same wall effect of people trying to get on off the highway.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:10
Mr. Walton, how would truckers know this?
01:38:13
Would there be special signage?
01:38:14
There's signage today.
01:38:16
Three lanes open for trucks or?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:38:18
Well, actually today it restricts, where the trucks are restricted from the left lane, there are signs, black and white signs that restrict the trucks from that lane.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:27
Mr. Chairman?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:38:28
Yes.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:29
Would this apply to mountainous terrain where you would have three lanes of traffic, you would begin to permit the truck into the left lane, which to me
01:38:38
explains what Dr. Davis is talking about.
01:38:40
You've got three trucks backing up traffic for an extended carrying distance, and they're creating more congestion and more probability of an accident.
01:38:49
So I'm gonna get in the same ball field with Dr. Davis.
01:38:53
I'm really having a problem with that concept.
SPEAKER_09
01:38:56
It doesn't really matter.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:38:58
It defeats the purpose of the truck climbing way.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:00
Wait, wait, wait.
01:39:03
Please, please.
01:39:04
Look at the bottom.
01:39:05
It only applies to these three sections, right?
01:39:08
The next bill deals with certified mail.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:39:26
Several years ago there was a provision added to the code that requires us to send all notices to property owners when we go up on their property to appraise it, survey it, do any environmental research to send
01:39:37
A certified letter to them notifying them that we're coming upon their property.
01:39:42
We've had many instances where a lot of these letters are returned because of the information that we have.
01:39:50
People move a lot, particularly in the more urbanized areas.
01:39:54
We weren't aware of a problem with VDOT when we were sending it by regular mail before.
01:39:59
I think the problem was with others who have them as the main authority.
01:40:03
and so we actually had several delegates approach us last year asking why we were doing this and so this year we've asked the General Assembly to remove that requirement of certified mail.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:21
Having been in this boat before myself and sharing another authority that does a lot of condemnation
01:40:33
You know, the certified mail thing is sort of a, I mean, what does it cost us?
01:40:39
If it's not going to get there by certified mail, it's not going to get there by regular mail.
01:40:43
So the extra funds to send something certified to try to get notice of somebody seems to me to be well worth the cost and the harassment to say we did our best as a government
01:40:56
to notify these people that were coming on their private property to survey it or appraise it or something else.
01:41:04
I have a lot of problems with my own situation in Norfolk and I would never think about doing that because I'm going to say, well, we spent too much money on certified mail.
01:41:18
What's my rationale?
01:41:19
I'm lost there.
01:41:22
It seems to me that the legislature is pushing back the other way.
01:41:28
We ought to at least notify, do our best to notify people when we're coming on their property
01:41:34
We look at it for taking it.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:41:36
We do notify landowners when they're coming up on their property, and there's a lot of it.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:41:41
By regular mail.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:41:43
But we've done that for years, and we were not aware.
01:41:45
The problem wasn't VDOT's problem.
01:41:47
The problem was with utility companies.
01:41:50
But everything got lumped in together.
01:41:55
Well, since we weren't aware of a problem, we actually had legislators who questioned why we were doing this.
01:42:00
They didn't think it was a good idea, they didn't think it was worth the expense, and it turned out that a lot of the letters were coming back undeliverable because of people moving.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:10
So, it was- What was the regular mail come back undeliverable?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:42:13
Probably as well.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:14
I mean, no difference.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:42:16
But we're not spending $50,000 a year to do that, so that was the reason for this was the cost savings.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:42:25
I just have a general question.
01:42:28
You can see with some of this legislation, some of my colleagues have some expertise to add or some questions.
01:42:38
I frankly don't like the full process that this was brought to us after the fact.
01:42:43
Before this stuff is sent over to the General Assembly, the CTB should be briefed on this stuff.
01:42:49
There's some people around the room that have some pretty good experience, and maybe the benefit of the view should be considered before it's sent over, especially with respect to any changes in the authority of the CTB.
01:43:02
We'll get to later in here.
01:43:03
But as I see these questions arise, I just think from now on,
01:43:07
I'd like to have this briefing before the General Assembly meets, and I think the benefit of some of the wisdom in this room could be presented at that time.
01:43:18
So I just don't like the way this is being done after the horse is out on the barn.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:43:23
Well, these are administration pieces of legislation, and they go through the process through the Governor's Office.
01:43:33
And so, and I understand, but you have to understand that these are the administration's approved legislative package.
01:43:41
And a lot of the stuff is tied to the government reform initiative and the commission that obviously the governor approved.
01:43:49
And so when you see these different issues in here,
01:43:52
There were items that were identified, either discussed or specifically identified by that reform commission.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:43:58
So maybe we could add a little bit to that and provide some more insight to make that an even more enlightened discussion before the fact.
01:44:09
Maybe we should have been more keyed into the government to pull out an effort and have these kind of discussions prior.
01:44:16
But I hope next year we don't have this after the fact.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:44:21
Mr. Walton.
01:44:23
Yes, McCarthy.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:44:25
One other question about those truck restrictions that affects the Richmond District.
01:44:36
Did anybody else weigh in on that?
01:44:38
Like, was that run through the MPO or anybody in the Richmond area for consultation as to whether anybody else thought this was a good idea?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:44:49
Mr. Chairman, Mr. McCarthy, I don't know the answer to that question.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:44:52
So the answer is probably no.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:44:54
I would assume that is correct.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:44:56
Well, I think there's a procedural problem with that, because at least as I read what you told us, the major effect of this is on the Richmond District, and clearly the legislature can do what it wishes about this, but this is, I have some sympathy for what Mr. Rich was just saying, because this is something that affects the Richmond District
01:45:19
Mr. Wall, I'm sorry.
01:45:31
Weren't all of these
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:45:44
I can't speak to sending them to the CTB, but most of these were on the Reform Commission, were on the website that the Reform Commission put out.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:01
I am fairly sure that every one of these items was sent out to the entire CTB during last summer and fall.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:15
Mr. Chairman, if I could comment on that.
01:46:16
I mean, I think that's great, but nobody was, we should have a workshop on it.
01:46:21
Nobody was afforded the opportunity to hear and exchange ideas on it.
01:46:25
Just sending it out doesn't mean anything.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:28
So when I'm sending things out to you and asking you for your comment, that we're then supposed to then, when we don't hear anything from you, assume that we should have also a work session on that as well.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:40
I think we should have a work session on certainly anything that affects the CTB.
01:46:46
I don't sit here knowing all the answers.
01:46:49
I'd like to hear what Gary says or what Mark says.
01:46:55
I think we do have something to add to this process.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:00
And that's why we sent it out to you, Mr. Rich.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:03
All right, now, not once, but several times.
01:47:05
I sent back some comments.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:07
I know, and we've incorporated, you know, as many folks' comments.
01:47:10
I just don't know how many more times we can put stuff out and be, I mean, this process for these pieces of legislation.
01:47:18
We're extremely transparent.
01:47:20
We've made this available to everybody.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:22
I know.
01:47:23
You sent them out, but we ought to have the collective brain power.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:27
Mr. Chairman, I think we should move on to the next issue.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:31
Okay.
01:47:31
I just want to hear from my colleagues in person.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:47:36
Mr. Chairman, the next proposal is on the use of inmate labor at rest areas.
01:47:42
Again, today the code does not allow for the use of inmate labor at rest areas, so this bill would
01:47:47
allowed the Department of Corrections and VDOT to enter an agreement addressing the use of inmate labor for providing maintenance at rest areas.
01:47:58
The next one deals with stormwater utility fees.
01:48:02
Again, just clarifying the code to make clear that the entire area that was acquired in the right-of-way process would be subject to waiver of any local stormwater utility fees.
01:48:19
An appraisal waiver, again, this is to make Virginia law consistent with federal regulation, which allows for us to waive doing a full-blown appraisal if the value of the property is $125,000, but allows the property owner to ask for an appraisal if the value is between, estimated value is between $10,000 and $25,000.
01:48:42
Again, it's identical to federal regulation today.
01:48:49
One of the omnibus bills deals with the powers of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
01:48:56
The first item up there, it was the recommendation of the Attorney General's Office to make it clear that the CTB controls its system, but it's not responsible for location decisions involving urban roads or roads and the secondary systems that are in localities that have accepted full responsibility.
01:49:17
for constructing and maintaining their system.
01:49:21
It increases the contract value for which the director of DRPT and the commissioner may award contracts from two million to five million the next two bullets against you.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:32
Mr. Chairman, on that issue there, did we just get through last year or the year before last, increasing that from one million to two million at that time?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:49:43
Mr.
01:49:44
Chair.
01:49:44
The two million was put in the code, I want to say four or five years ago, it was put in as two million.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:52
As I understood, it's kind of an impediment to the Commissioner or the Department to be able to award contracts or something at that time.
01:50:00
But as I look at it, you know, I think the creating authority that created the CTBs put some value on awarding contracts and charging that responsibility to CTB.
01:50:12
And as I looked at this and counted it, we'll be awarding
01:50:16
13 contracts today, there's only four of them over the five million dollar threshold.
01:50:23
That means that nine of them would have been awarded by the commission.
01:50:27
Now I see that there's a disconnect to some degree with commission awarded contracts because we're not familiar with them, we're not aware of it, we don't have that connectivity back to the district on what's going to be done in the next few weeks and so forth in the next time frame.
01:50:45
So I see there is, and I feel like there's still value in that award process.
01:50:50
And to me, you know, I don't know of any, I think the question that Ms. Sorrell answered Dr. Davis this morning, that there wasn't any impediment in getting this money out that she was aware of, at least she didn't mention this as an impediment.
01:51:04
So I just, again, I make that statement and ask, you know, why is the change there recommended?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:51:13
Mr. Chairman, Mr.
01:51:14
Keen, again, it's part of the reform commission streamlining of less contracts going to the board.
01:51:22
This board is only required to meet four times a year.
01:51:26
The board meets monthly.
01:51:27
It gives opportunities that the board need to meet monthly, would allow for these contracts to move forward.
01:51:33
The board has decided the board wouldn't be meeting on a monthly basis.
01:51:36
So again, it's just a matter of streamlining operations.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:41
Chairman, I have the same concerns that Jim has on this one.
01:51:46
This doesn't quite make sense to me.
01:51:49
We need to have some kind of an input on these contracts.
01:51:54
Can I back up to the first one?
01:51:58
It was also described in another way, it says, amend the powers and duties of the CTB by clarifying that local roads in counties outside the secondary highway system are local roads and not part of the state system.
01:52:13
What does that mean?
01:52:14
What are roads, local roads in counties outside the state's secondary highway system?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:52:20
Arlington and Ryco County control their own road system.
01:52:25
There is a provision in the code that allows any county
01:52:28
to come in and take over its road system if it so desires.
01:52:31
So this would make it clear that the CTB does not play a role in making location decisions regarding the local road network.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:38
And it completely takes away the CTB authority over the urban system?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:52:43
Correct.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:44
Is that correct?
01:52:45
What's the reason for that?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:52:48
Because urban areas control the maintenance of their roads.
01:52:54
There's ten jurisdictions that now control the construction of their roads.
01:52:58
Again, this just deals with location decisions, locating roads.
01:53:02
It still doesn't impact the board's decision as far as allocating money for urban projects.
01:53:08
This is only dealing with, if a city decides they want to build a new road from Spring Street to Main Street, I mean, today, arguably, they gotta come to the CTB to get approval of the location of that road.
01:53:20
This clarifies that they can.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:24
I'll give you one example in my district.
01:53:29
We've got a major roadblock on 29.
01:53:32
We're trying to resolve on Route 29 as it comes together with the bypass on 250.
01:53:37
That's classified as an urban project.
01:53:40
Well, the answer is correct.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:53:59
I think that's idiotic.
01:54:06
Well, arguably you don't have jurisdiction over it today, but the Attorney General's Office said we needed to clarify whether you have jurisdiction over that road today.
01:54:18
So that's the reason for the proposed statutory amendment is to clarify that the Board doesn't exercise control over the location of roads in those areas.
01:54:28
Maybe we should.
01:54:34
Last bullet there, again, eliminates an outdated section dealing with regulating of outdoor theaters, which can be done through access management today.
01:54:45
The first bullet on this page is something that the governor's particularly interested in.
01:54:53
Today, the law provides for an updated statewide transportation plan every five years, which means their food and material administrations will never have an opportunity to do that.
01:55:04
So this takes it back to every four years and actually provides that the next one will be due in 2013.
01:55:09
Then finally, it removes a provision of code regarding the Board appointing special policemen since the Board no longer enforces traffic rules and regulations.
01:55:22
There's an omnibus funding bill.
01:55:24
One would exempt the Department and DRPT from paying fees to promote access to land records.
01:55:31
Today, each clerk can charge $600 and with the number of clerk's offices, the total amount that we could save is a little over $160,000 a year.
01:55:42
The next bullet on this slide basically takes language that's in the Appropriation Act today and puts it into general law dealing with annual maintenance payments to municipalities
01:55:58
The first bullet on this slide, again, under funding, amends the payback provisions in the code.
01:56:06
Today, if a city cancels a project, after we've started spending money on it, they're required to pay that money back.
01:56:13
This would make the same applicable to counties, so the counties would be treated the same as cities if a county decided to cancel the project that's in the Six-Year Program after funds have been spent on that project.
01:56:26
And then finally, we're eliminating an old code provision dealing with refunding bonds that stated you could not refund it until three years before maturity.
01:56:37
Federal law now allows for one refunding and we did not want to tie a local government's hands on when that would occur.
01:56:44
Again, another cleanup.
01:56:46
There's a procurement act provision, again, dealing with our professional services contract, special engineering contracts that would extend the time period
01:56:56
on what we call our on-call contracts and would also allow us to have term extensions for five million each.
01:57:06
Today the total amount of the contract can only be five whereas now the initial term can be five and then the two additional one-year terms can be five million each.
01:57:18
Duties of the VDOT Commissioner would change his title from Commonwealth Transportation Commissioner to the Commissioner of Highways.
01:57:27
It eliminates a specific position that is referenced in the code.
01:57:32
It just happens to be my position.
01:57:35
I'm sure everybody will vote unanimously for that.
01:57:43
It, again, from an operational standpoint allows the chief engineer or recommend to the commissioner when we construct new sections of the primary and secondary system that we can administratively abandon or discontinue sections that are no longer needed because of the construction of the new section of highway.
01:58:02
It also eliminates the requirement that the board declare excess right-of-way surplus before VDOT may sell the land.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:10
Now what's the reasoning behind that one?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:58:12
Again, Mr.
01:58:13
Chair, Mr. Rich, it's just a matter of streamlining the disposition of surplus properties.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:20
In some cases, people, there's concern about whether or not it really is surplus.
01:58:27
And I think the knowledge of this board on that would be helpful.
01:58:32
You may say it's surplus, but maybe it's not.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:58:39
Mr. Chairman, we have a process we go through, we identify the properties, we put them out for bid.
01:58:45
It's usually the adjoining property owner who approaches us about buying a piece of surplus property.
01:58:52
And then finally, there's a number- One more question on that.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:56
Let's say, you know, they decide to sell some residency property, a VDOT property itself, does that provision apply here?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:59:02
No, this is right of way.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:04
This is just right of way?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:59:05
Yes, this is by capital outlay.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:06
Okay, so they still have to come back to us if they're going to sell off a residency office or something like that?
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:59:13
That's correct.
01:59:16
And the final thing is the number of reports we have to submit annually would now put them all in one annual report.
01:59:24
Again, the first bullet on this page is just a change from July 1st to December 31st, the time in which a
01:59:33
A city that wants to take over its urban construction program needs to notify the board.
01:59:39
The second bullet deals with the Rural Rustic Roads Program and would eliminate certain requirements, specifically storm water management requirements, which would probably hinder the development of a rural rustic road.
01:59:56
And then finally, we want to eliminate a requirement
02:00:01
of a locality holding a public hearing in order to pave an unpaved road.
02:00:08
I mean, concurrence within us, forget it.
02:00:14
I was trying to read that one.
SPEAKER_09
02:00:23
One thing that troubles me is that I noted in there that
02:00:38
It was not just around the Richmond area.
02:00:43
It's 64 miles north, which includes all the way from Richmond to Caft.
02:00:49
And with that, with trucks traveling at three lanes on that, it gives me a little bit of trouble because of the fact that we've now increased
02:00:57
The speed limit in sections of that to 70 miles an hour.
02:01:00
So now we've got trucks changing lanes in three lanes traveling at 70 miles an hour.
02:01:05
And I do not see how that is safer for the traveling public than what we have now.
02:01:10
And I just want to throw that out.
02:01:12
I don't know if there's any other logic behind that.
02:01:16
But to me, I just have a problem with that, especially on that stretch of 95, having trucks in the fast lane
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:23
I would suggest that the 70 miles might in some cases or is in most cases forcing them to slow down a bit at least based on what I've experienced on 95 going north so it's not necessarily I'm not concerned with that element
02:01:43
I've got to agree that these have been out there and I know that MPOs have, at least I've seen them get briefed on what some of the elements were, so I'm sure concerns that they had had them would have been expressed.
02:01:56
I've received none.
02:01:58
Nobody's come to me on any of the recommendations with concerns regarding what is in there and how it's in there.
02:02:04
On this particular one, to me it's almost seamless.
02:02:08
Yes, I do recognize that two of those lanes, I do understand, particularly when some of the trucks get backed up, the desire, I've tried to get off the freeway before and if those trucks are backed up, you know, quarter mile or whatever the case is, because I misjudged and I thought there would be an opening.
02:02:24
I understand the concept.
02:02:26
I'm not quite sure that I'm convinced that the model or whatever was used is accurate, but I'm not in a position to disagree with it either.
02:02:37
This goes up 95.
02:02:38
I travel a lot.
02:02:39
I'm not concerned, and I haven't seen anything that would cause the concern, at least at this point.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:02:48
I have a question, Rick, on page 13.
02:02:53
The exemption from paying fees for access to land records, is that part of a larger initiative to have these local governments and state government agencies reciprocity access to each other's records, or is this really
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
02:03:07
No, there's a provision in the code that there are certain Attorney General's Office, Division of Debt Collection, several others that are exempt from having to pay the clerk's annual fee.
02:03:18
And we're just asked to be added to that list of entities that can get these records for free for our title searches and all the real estate related searches that we do.
02:03:27
We can do it remotely and not have to have somebody physically at the courthouse but also not have to pay the fee.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:37
Mr. Chairman, just one thing.
02:03:42
I don't think, since I was a late-arriving commissioner, I had an opportunity to see this when you sent it out this summer, but notwithstanding that, I think we ought to support changes that make sense and that streamline our government so we're not involved in things we don't need to be involved in.
02:04:01
I would particularly, though, urge caution when the transportation commissioner or this bot, not the CTB, but the governmental bot, if you will, recommends changes in the powers of the CTB itself.
02:04:18
I think that you may find yourself setting yourself up for CTB to be lobbying against what you want, and that wouldn't be a good situation.
02:04:28
Change our powers as this board, it would seem we would use a fair amount of caution to talk to the board members first and sort of get their, force their input, if nothing else, to sort of Mr. Rich's point.
02:04:42
The other ones are less, I think, less impacted in my logic than that is, but when you start recommending a change in the powers of this body, then I think you are.
02:04:57
Well, Mr. Miller, I mean, if there's ever, I mean, we have been so transparent on this whole, I know, I know, but I'm just sitting here going, God, we have
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:25
sent out to everybody within the CTB, every stakeholder group, we asked for comments, we posted on websites.
02:05:34
When we got a better list, we sent them back out to everybody and said this is what we were looking at.
02:05:39
We sent them to the Reform Commission.
02:05:41
They picked up some, sent back others.
02:05:43
I mean, I don't think we've ever seen legislative development more transparent and open than we've done here.
02:05:51
And we're going to continue trying to do it that way, including, again, sending it to this body more than once, and in fact, even briefing this body at one or more workshops.
02:06:03
But I do need to just make sure you understand one slight issue, and that's this.
02:06:08
The CTB is, to a certain extent, separate from the executive branch, an executive branch to which VDOT works for.
02:06:17
We have the general planning and programming authority here, and I'm going to say execution of those plans and programs from a money perspective.
02:06:30
The executive branch, which I am a member of, 99.9% of the time, are going to make recommendations that they aren't going to clear for anyone other than the executive branch.
02:06:45
And every one of these proposals have ended up being developed and cleared through the governor's office and the policy office.
02:06:57
But there's always going to be that little bit of a friction, which is a good friction.
02:07:01
It's what democracy is all about.
02:07:07
And Walton, anything else?
02:07:08
Any other questions?
SPEAKER_09
02:07:11
All right, Ms. Drake.
02:07:13
Thank you.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:21
Thank you, Mr. Secretary, Members of the Board.
02:07:24
First of all, DRPT is tracking several bills, not only bills that are administration bills.
02:07:32
First, of course, we're watching all the bills that do any sort of increased funding for transportation.
02:07:38
We don't have a position either way on the bill, but our focus is we want them to stay for transportation purposes if additional money were to be passed because each district is different and there might be a different need rather than to be specific for one thing.
02:07:53
We're also tracking a bill that would add an additional appointment to the Northern Virginia Transportation Commission and add both a principal and an alternate member
02:08:06
to the WMATA board to represent Virginia's interest.
02:08:10
That's when I've passed out the chart for you and you'll see today the Commonwealth is as a funding partner for WMATA is we're the major funding partner for capital and operating costs
02:08:25
We are more than double any of the other funding provided by the next largest contributors.
02:08:31
So those two pie charts will show you including fare box and then the second one takes out fare box.
02:08:38
And I do want to point out to you that the regional gas tax of 2.1%
02:08:43
is always calculated as part of local share.
02:08:47
It is not calculated on the state side.
02:08:51
For fiscal year 2011, the Commonwealth's contribution to WMATA is $129.8 million.
02:09:00
We have committed, and you're well aware of it, the $50 million a year for the next 10 years as our $500 million contribution
02:09:10
for capital improvements that match the federal $1.5 billion.
02:09:16
This funding, the $50 million, is in addition to the $75 to $80 million that we've been providing annually over the last few years now to WMATA.
02:09:26
We have no representation on the WMATA board of the four seats that are currently appointed by NVTC.
02:09:36
We're also tracking the bill that consolidates the transportation organizations in Northern Virginia, NVTC, NVTA, and PRTC into one organization.
02:09:49
And I know I've frequently been asked who, yes, Mr. Peake.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:54
I'm a bit lost.
02:09:56
What are we talking about here?
02:10:01
What's WMATA stand for?
02:10:03
I'm sorry.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:03
WMATA is Washington Metro Area.
02:10:09
What's the rest?
02:10:11
This is the metro rail system and the bus system in the DC, Maryland, and Northern Virginia area.
02:10:19
Sorry about that.
SPEAKER_09
02:10:21
We just got the handout.
02:10:22
Right.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:23
And I'm sorry.
02:10:24
We're good at talking in initials.
02:10:27
So I hope that helps to show you who contributes what and that Virginia is now contributing 54% of the capital and operating cost for this system, for the Virginia share of this system.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:40
And the reason why this is important is that they don't seem to acknowledge at all that these numbers are these numbers.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:48
No, because they will add farebox into operating subsidy, which is not an acceptable method.
02:10:56
FTA does not allow that.
02:10:58
Neither do any of our 59 other transit systems do that.
02:11:01
It's considered revenue for farebox and parking, not local subsidy.
02:11:06
So what we're talking about is when we go in and pull out Virginia dollars or they use Fairfax or not Louden, Arlington or Alexandria dollars is what we're showing you.
02:11:17
But oftentimes they put the farebox and parking into that.
02:11:21
We also are tracking bills that give more flexibility in our rail programs.
02:11:26
Our rail industrial access program currently has a cap of 25%
02:11:32
until May and then we can open it up to look at applications if we haven't had applications for that money.
02:11:39
So what that's caused over time is to have to go to the Rail Enhancement Fund to look at funding a project because it's bigger than what the 25% would be.
02:11:50
The number I'm going to use for that program is one and a half million dollars.
02:11:54
So you would currently cannot get more than 25%.
02:11:57
We've also had issues where we haven't been able to commit
02:12:01
This is an economic development tool and when a business is trying to locate in an area we can't give them an answer as to whether we can fund their industrial access project or not until May.
02:12:14
So this would raise that.
02:12:16
We're actually going to amend that bill because it says disproportionate share and of course that no one could have more than a disproportionate share.
02:12:27
So we're either going to define the word or put a dollar cap on it.
02:12:31
We're talking to the patron like 50 percent rather than 25.
02:12:34
I think that would be easier than defining it.
02:12:38
We also have a bill that we're watching and it's an administration bill, of course, is to use the rail enhancement funds as match to federal funding.
02:12:51
We have several projects you've heard about them that are so large
02:12:55
We wouldn't be able to do them with the rail enhancement fund that we have in place today, which is about 21 to 23 million dollars a year from rental car tax and 12.9 right now from the bonds.
02:13:07
It also puts us in a position that we would not be able to apply for federal high-speed rail funding if we don't show that we have the match for those funds.
02:13:16
Current programs are 80 federal, 20 percent state, and in the two awards that we received last October,
02:13:24
For DC to Richmond and the Appomattox River Bridge, CSX joined us with that match.
02:13:31
Without CSX's help, we would not have been able to apply for those two grants.
02:13:35
So it's a statement to the FRA that Virginia is interested in applying and it also gives us the ability to move forward.
02:13:44
That same bill also contains the provision to eliminate the Rail Advisory Board, which was a component of the Reform Commission.
02:13:53
The Rail Advisory Board has been in a place about five years now.
02:13:57
It is an advisory board to me.
02:13:59
The authority over DRPT rests here with all of you, and our projects come to you, as you're aware.
02:14:08
We're also tracking the bill that provides an employer tax credit for allowing employees to telework.
02:14:15
Of course, this is done to try to help get cars off the road.
02:14:19
The bill is $1200 per employee.
02:14:24
over a two-year period back to the employer, a max of $50,000 per employer over that two-year period and a cap of $2 million over the two-year period, $1 million a year.
02:14:36
This is a tax credit only.
02:14:38
It is not carried over and there is no cash back to the employer, although in our telework programs,
02:14:45
Northern Virginia, Richmond, and Hampton Roads, we do have funding to help an employer.
02:14:50
And studies that we're looking at, one that's very important to all of us is the study of Route 1 to look at transit and to help the anticipated congestion problems that are the result of BRAC and the military personnel that are along that Route 1 corridor.
02:15:10
Thank you, Mr. Secretary, for finding funding to help us with that program.
02:15:17
Another study-related issue is a transit study.
02:15:20
This is Senator Yvonne Miller's bill.
02:15:23
Last year she did our rail operating, looking at rail operating funding in Virginia, and this year she's doing one that would look at, are we doing it right with transit, or should there be things that we look at, like rewarding transit operators for their performance?
02:15:40
Funding categories to capitalize on prioritizing what our funding needs are, creating a stability in our match, and also looking at the current funding formulas.
02:15:55
We're also watching the Governor's proposal that would dedicate a portion of sales tax in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads to transportation.
02:16:04
And we are hopeful that the Assembly will find a way to deal with our rail operating in capital.
02:16:11
And again, thank you to the Governor for building that into his bill as well.
02:16:15
That would be funding to do our state-operated service, the Lynchburg train,
02:16:19
also the Richmond 7 a.m. service and that is the train that will originate in Norfolk when that service starts as well as the four Amtrak regional trains that in 2013 will have to pick up.
02:16:33
But we continue to monitor all bills that have any impact on transportation at all.
02:16:39
Any questions?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:40
Any questions, Director?
SPEAKER_09
02:16:42
Director Drake, what percentage does Virginia provide of the total amount of funding?
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:48
54% because of the $50 million.
02:16:51
Now, it was not that high in the past.
02:16:54
In the past, it was $75 to $80 million.
02:16:57
But now, it is 54% because of our commitment of the $50 million.
02:17:01
And that, that and all of the safety issues, and the Secretary's been so heavily engaged in, they even meet quarterly to talk about safety issues with this metro system.
02:17:12
But that $50 million really made people say, $130 million a year is a lot of money.
02:17:18
We need to do something differently.
02:17:20
We do serve on the board of Hampton Roads Transit, several other boards, not all of them because we don't have the personnel to do that, but a lot of them.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:17:29
Yes, Mr. Koelemay.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:17:31
Mr. Chairman, are there any impediments to the Commonwealth of Virginia?
02:17:39
from our code or our own structure here that would keep us from participating more actively in WMATA governance?
02:17:45
I mean, do we need to make any adjustments on our own?
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:17:48
We could do one appointment to the WMATA board very easily because those people are, the board members are selected from the NVTC membership.
02:17:58
Currently, I serve on NVTC as the designee of the secretary so they could very easily
02:18:04
select the secretary's designee to be that board member.
02:18:08
It would not be me, it would be somebody with very much a transit background and expertise to serve in that role.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:18:15
But they up to, they refused to designate anyone, even though we are now the largest contributor.
02:18:23
They're just simply rotated among Fairfax, Arlington, and Alexandria.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:18:27
And just for the record, Mr. Chairman, when she, when
02:18:32
Thank you for that correction and currently it's two seats to Fairfax County, one to Arlington and one to Alexandria.
02:18:50
Set of questions surrounding Metro's governance structure is now underway.
02:18:56
And quite frankly, at the time, the Northern Virginia jurisdictions took on the burden more directly.
02:19:03
The Commonwealth's interest was not as well defined.
02:19:07
or as large as it is now.
02:19:08
Northern Virginia was not almost half of the gross state product at that time and so forth.
02:19:14
So I think it's a natural change that needs to occur and Virginia really should be, without the Commonwealth of Virginia being represented on the board, I think the Metro board is weaker and less able to respond to the challenges of not just building a system but now operating a mature system over time.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:35
Ms. Koelemay, obviously the system is facing an enormous number of challenges.
02:19:43
We recognize that.
02:19:44
We have the resources that they can't necessarily devote to it.
02:19:50
We just had a very difficult time even getting them to acknowledge that we give $130 million a year.
02:19:56
They won't even acknowledge that even though we can show them the receipts.
02:19:59
and we send it to them for the most part and they just don't accept even that we give them that type of money.
02:20:08
Well, and that's, you know, it's just one of these things.
02:20:12
It's been a very difficult issue.
02:20:15
And the thing is, is that initially the state was minimally involved in it in WMATA.
02:20:22
It is now really critical to, as you said, critical to the region in Northern Virginia or Washington, D.C.
02:20:32
It's critical to the Commonwealth.
02:20:34
And, you know, right now the system is obviously
02:20:36
Facing so many different challenges, financial and safety, that we cannot continue to do what we're doing.
02:20:43
Which is why the Governor himself, working with the Governor O'Malley and Mayor Gray now, previously Fenty, of all, you know, personally, each one of them got involved in this and we've had several conference calls and meetings among those three principals to discuss this issue.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:00
Mr. Chairman, I want to make sure I understood the answer to Mr. Layne's question, Director Drake.
02:21:08
The chart shows us that the Commonwealth, after eliminating the fare box appropriately, is doing 55% of the Virginia funding to WMATA, but there's other funding that goes to WMATA from the district and from Maryland.
02:21:24
I think his question was
02:21:27
What percent is Virginia Commonwealth to all the funding?
02:21:31
Or you could extrapolate it.
02:21:33
What part does Virginia give versus Maryland give versus DC?
02:21:36
Thank you.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:37
I think the number, and maybe the Secretary knows specifically, but I think we're in the low 20s, like 22, 24 percent is the number that I believe I've seen.
02:21:47
If that's wrong, I'll certainly get that to you.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:49
Of all Virginia or the Commonwealth?
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:51
No, of the compact, of DC, Maryland, because we have smaller
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:55
I'm sorry, I forgot he was here.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:00
28% is Virginia's share between the other.
02:22:05
I'm sorry, I didn't realize that was a question that you were asking totally.
02:22:12
We always talk in terms of Virginia.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:14
Yeah, and they, in each jurisdiction, obviously, they look at everything from the number of stations you have, there's a very complex formula, but that's why there's about 20 of them.
02:22:27
And our number will go up, obviously, when the Silver Line goes in, because we'll have, what, seven stations, I guess six or seven stations, which will mean our numbers will go up dramatically as well.
SPEAKER_09
02:22:38
So is our seat that we're asking for come from one of the current seats held by
02:22:43
There are two things going on.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:52
The first is we're asking for one of the current seats.
02:22:55
So right now, Maryland and D.C., you know, they don't divvy up their seats.
02:23:02
Under the compact, Virginia seats come from the Northern Virginia Transportation Commission.
02:23:09
So we are a member of the NVTC, but we've never served as either a primary member or an all-time member.
02:23:17
So that's one of the seats we're seeking.
02:23:19
There's also been an agreement to seek a compact change, to change essentially the entire governance of Metro to reflect the current realities, because essentially the compact was signed almost 50 years ago.
02:23:36
The system is a very different system today.
02:23:39
The Washington Board of Trade and the Council of Governments of Washington made fairly comprehensive recommendations to change the structure of governance, make it much more accountable and much more like a business.
02:23:59
Two governors and the mayor have all agreed to implement those.
02:24:03
It will ultimately be a compact change, and an interstate compact means that all three jurisdictions have to pass it.
02:24:10
And our goal right now is to have legislation to the General Assembly next year.
02:24:14
And then it will have to be submitted to Congress for their approval.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:24:20
Thank you.
02:24:21
So it's lengthy to do the compact change.
02:24:24
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:24:28
Mr. Strader is not here, is that right?
02:24:31
Okay, we'll then, we'll just simply go into CMEK, RSTP, subcommittee, Mrs. Sterling.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:25:20
Mr. Secretary, Director, Colleagues, I appreciate the opportunity to talk today and go through what we've come up for with recommendations regarding the CMAQ program, particularly
02:25:41
I'd like to thank you for putting me right before Rita will be briefing us the $4.3 billion in projects.
02:25:47
I'm sure your attention will be very focused on me and my presentation and not wandering to the next topic.
02:25:54
As you remember, CMAQ issue became somewhat of a debated issue at the last meeting and the meeting before that, largely as a result of some of the execution within the program, as well as some of the projects that were brought forward coming out of the specific regions.
02:26:11
In particular, we had some concerns regarding one of the communities wanted to put in some electric vehicles, was requesting the use of funds for that purpose, and there were members that felt that that was not the intention of where the board would want to go, as well as we did see some problems with the obligation of the funds that were being done.
02:26:30
Today, the CTB has delegated the authority for CMAQ to the relative MPOs.
02:26:38
We receive approximately $70 million per year.
02:26:42
That's both what we get from the federal government as well as what we put in in terms of matching funds.
02:26:47
The funds must be spent in air quality non-attainment areas on eligible projects as determined by what are in the federal guidance.
02:26:55
We have delegated that authority to the respective MPOs that have the non-attainment areas.
02:26:59
These are CMAC-qualified MPOs.
02:27:02
In particular, that includes Northern Virginia, FAMPO, Richmond,
02:27:07
as well as Hampton Roads.
02:27:10
CMAC projects, they must be included in the Six-Year Improvement Program and the transfers must be approved by the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
02:27:18
VDOT and DRPT have outlined that they have some concerns with the ability of the MPOs to effectively manage these.
02:27:24
This is in large part because of what we saw on the execution of those projects.
02:27:30
RSTP, another regionally, it's Regional Surface Transportation Program, it is done by the MPOs
02:27:37
This is one where we also saw some problems primarily in this particular area with the execution and there was some concerns regarding some of the legislation that was out there that would require us to recoup those funds and apply them to other projects if they're not spent within a specified time period.
02:27:53
One of the challenges is unlike CMAQ where the CTB had delegated that to the respective MPOs, RSTP by federal law does go to those MPOs and we are required essentially to approve
02:28:05
their recommendations or their request to this board for the use of those funds.
02:28:11
In terms of the CMAQ allocations, I want to get into a little bit on what we see in terms of the allocation and the programming of those funds.
02:28:19
This was one of the first areas that was identified by the staff and we did see as a result of the audit that was performed on VDOT when we saw all these funds that were not being programmed and they were not being executed on projects.
02:28:32
You've seen this chart before.
02:28:33
It outlines the various MPOs, the allocations that they receive over the six-year period, and what they've programmed.
02:28:40
In many cases, you will see that some of the MPOs do not program past the first year, which makes effective planning somewhat difficult.
02:28:49
RSTP, we see some similar activities here, where the amount of funding that they are allocated is not programmed and not planned over the six-year period.
02:29:01
In terms of the inactive CMAQ and RSVP projects, this sort of, I think, captured where everybody got very concerned with the project execution as we saw it coming out of the MPOs.
02:29:13
The projects and the dollar value of those various projects that are before us totals $306 million.
02:29:20
The allocations that have currently been applied towards those is $167 million.
02:29:25
That's what's coming out of the MPOs and approved and then approved.
02:29:28
However, the obligations on those projects is only 10% of that, $16 million.
02:29:33
Expenditures on the projects, zero.
02:29:39
In the Virginia Appropriations Act, and this is how it applies to CMAC, state projects funded and whole or apart from federal funds, CMAC shall be selected as directed by the board, this body, and this is where we've delegated it in the past.
02:29:52
Such funds shall be federally obligated within 24 months of their allocation by the board and expended within 48 months of such obligation.
02:30:00
If the requirements included in this paragraph are not met by such agency or recipient, then the board shall use such funds for any other project eligible.
02:30:09
This is one of the challenges we've reached and we're informed that we haven't exactly been applying this particular requirement and recouping those funds as they pass the 48-month mark.
02:30:21
Further, the funds that are made available to the MPO for RSVP for urbanized areas greater than $200,000 each fiscal year thereafter shall be federally obligated within 12 months and expended within 36 months such obligation.
02:30:35
Requirements included in this paragraph are not met by the recipient and the board shall rescind the required match for such federal obligations because we cannot rescind the RSVP funds.
02:30:44
They are not, although we approve them in their totality as part of our program,
02:30:49
They're not really under our direct control, our authority and responsibility.
02:30:53
However, the matching funds that we do put in are, and so this would have required us to recoup those.
02:30:58
Funds made available to the MPO known as RSTP for urbanized areas for fiscal year 2010 preceding fiscal year shall be federally obligated within 12 months from the effective date and extended within 36 months.
02:31:12
Again, trying to get these expended, yet we have not been holding them to that.
02:31:17
The options that we looked at in order to reflect the concerns I think that were presented by various members of Commonwealth Transportation Board at the last meeting where we looked at status quo just going about the way we have gone through this process where the MPOs develop their list.
02:31:33
They submit their list and we just essentially rubber stamp that.
02:31:37
We could go with the status quo with additional guidance.
02:31:40
There were some concerns with where they were applying the funds, again, with the inclusion of the electric vehicles.
02:31:46
There was also the concerns about whether we could put additional guidance on the expenditure of funds.
02:31:51
Also, we looked at could you do a competitive application process, very similar to the enhancement program, probably as it has been noted, one that gets a great deal of oversight by this board, more so on a dollar-per-dollar basis than just about any other program.
02:32:05
But there are some problems on the execution side of that as well.
02:32:09
We could centrally select projects where, as you see with the surface transportation program as a whole, we would get those recommendations coming out of Richmond, the central office programming staff.
02:32:19
And finally, projects that would be selected by the CTB district member in consultation with the MPO and VDOT DRPT staff.
02:32:27
The funds would be programmed or administered centrally by VDOT staff.
02:32:34
There would be legislative changes that would be required and they'd be required with any of these options in order to bring all the various states in alignment.
02:32:42
The subcommittee is recommending the fifth option, fifth option for a couple of different reasons.
02:32:50
The first is it will bring into alignment the priorities not only of this body but of the localities, the regions, the members that represent those MPO areas know what those districts are looking at.
02:33:01
They can, working with the MPO boards,
02:33:04
identify the projects that are the highest priority for that particular region, but they can also do it with the mind towards what the priorities of this board and the Commonwealth as a whole have.
02:33:15
It also would help in terms of the improved project execution by bringing the execution of that to the central office instead of them going back and forth with the MPO staff trying to get all the approvals whenever funds are moved between projects, but we'd be able to do that here.
02:33:32
Increased accountability.
02:33:34
The members, myself included, who represent these districts will now be accountable to this entire body.
02:33:41
So if there's something in these projects which we're bringing forward as a recommendation and you don't approve of it, you won't hear from us, well that's what the MPO wanted and that's what we've got to do.
02:33:52
We will have to defend that project.
02:33:53
We will have to be vested in the project.
02:33:55
We will have to tell you why we think it's of value.
02:33:57
We will defend those priorities and we will do that by working with the MPO.
02:34:02
and then finally the improved planning which will allow, that will be executed and achieved through putting in the six-year funding rather than year to year doing the planning on this.
02:34:12
I think what this does achieve overall, again, it is the alignment of priorities between this board and the MPOs because there will be the active involvement between the members that are representing those districts and that MPO board.
02:34:24
It will, I think it'll get more focus of this board on these projects.
02:34:29
I can speak for myself only that
02:34:32
When we're told that CMAQ funds, RSVP funds are done locally, that they're done by the regions, we tend to forget them or at least push them to the side as something that we don't have a great deal of influence over.
02:34:43
Therefore, there's not something we focus on.
02:34:47
And I can tell you, we probably don't even, working with our district administrator, say, what's the status of this particular CMAQ project?
02:34:53
All too often, what has happened in the past and whatever, they're doing that.
02:34:57
They've decided to put the funds in that particular area.
02:35:01
Oftentimes it won't be fully funding a phase, a project.
02:35:04
One of the things we are recommending as part of this, and you'll see it in the resolution as we come forward, is that we will, part of the requirements, 100% of a particular phase will have to be funded at each stage.
02:35:15
That way you won't see funds sitting on executed, accumulating over a large period of time while a project is not moving forward.
02:35:24
Move to a project, get it done, move to the next project.
02:35:29
And with that, if there's any questions.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:34
Yes.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:35
When you had your subcommittee, did you have a lot of input from the MPOs and the like?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:44
Both Northern Virginia and Richmond MPOs sent representatives who outlined what their concerns and their desire to see continued MPO involvement in the process.
02:35:55
And I think that what we've done is we have achieved that by
02:35:58
I mean, they're an active involvement in terms of identifying what those priorities.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:03
That was one of the concerns that Mr. Zimmerman from Arlington had raised at the NVTA, that taking that authority away, they might as well not even exist.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:13
I think he made that statement.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:15
So that's just something for consideration that was said publicly.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:21
I think what we're trying to do is achieve a very active partnership between this body and those local transportation authorities to make sure the regional priorities are resolved.
SPEAKER_09
02:36:39
These parties' recommendations develop a way to make sure that we don't forget about the project.
02:36:44
We're going back to somebody asking, and Mrs. Busher has assured us with these programs, with now this reconciliation and these recommendations, that they now have a process in place to give us feedback and to make sure these projects are going forward.
02:36:59
While we seem to have accounting issues across the state in lots of different reasons, it looks like, at least from this perspective, we'll be able to get good feedback to keep these projects on track.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:37:12
So we're shooting for Mr. Miller.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:37:15
Any questions?
02:37:19
Yes.
02:37:19
I think it's excellent, actually.
02:37:21
It would help us a lot in terms of achieving some of the goals we had.
02:37:26
My question goes to what is the role of the outreach member in this process now as it's recommended?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:37:35
The, it's the district members that have those MPOs or CMAQ MPOs within their district.
02:37:41
They represent that particular area.
02:37:43
They would have an active role in bringing the recommendations and advocating them for them at the board.
02:37:49
Every member of this board still has a role in examining them.
02:37:53
And voting in favor or in opposition.
02:37:56
Now I would hope that this would be, and it did come out, that it would be a collegial process where we're not taking bats to each other, but essentially if you have some concerns or questions regarding any project that is within a member's recommendation that you would consult with that member and identify it.
02:38:11
Also if there's projects that you think should be included within a list, working with that member and that MPO and making sure that that's taken into account.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:38:20
Understand, I guess I would opine like I did last month, the same sort of situation, is you're carving out, when you do these things in my opinion, you carve out your at-large members as having a different role, even though as an at-large urban member, I'm theoretically responsible to a number of urban areas.
02:38:38
As well as the entire state.
02:38:41
But no longer do I have real access or real involvement at that level.
02:38:50
I stood at a different level.
02:38:51
Same thing if you were an at-large rural member.
02:38:54
So, you know, I like the recommendation.
02:38:59
I don't like treating our members differently.
02:39:02
And I understand the need for a district representative appointee, if you will, to be involved.
02:39:11
I sort of question, the bigger question is, okay, I accept that, what's the role of the at-large member?
02:39:18
And if the at-large member's role is just to sort of be
02:39:23
Overall, but not really at-large urban or at-large rural, and we're sort of defining our own role here, and I'm not sure that's appropriate.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:39:32
And in this particular case, the CTB as a whole is going to have a more active role in this program.
02:39:39
The individual members will be bringing those recommendations, they'll be selecting and advocating for them, so you will, the at-large members will have an increased role.
02:39:47
It won't be the same as those particular districts, nor will districts that don't have that CMAQ application necessarily have as active a role as, you know, certainly Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia, which have the most CMAQ funds coming into them, will be the most active.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:03
Yeah, I think it's a good recommendation in general.
02:40:06
I just, you understand my philosophical sort of problem.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:09
I will tell you when the accounting issue came up and the kind of how we central office looks at programs and where they are in various stages and where
02:40:17
The districts and the MPOs look at them and that we need to bring that together.
02:40:21
There was a recommendation that the Secretary appoint a committee of the at-large members to deal with the accounting department because none of us are accountants and we didn't want to do it.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:35
I sent everybody that's talked to me about the enhancement fund, I gave them your cell phone number.
02:40:39
And I told them to call you because I told them I was out.
02:40:43
I had no power in that role.
02:40:46
Mr. Chairman.
02:40:46
Mr. Garczynski.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:48
Another question for you.
02:40:50
Did the subcommittee consider if we're going to take on this responsibility
02:40:55
that there be in place a prioritization mechanism in each of the MPOs that when it comes to us we know where the priorities are and that's uniform throughout the Commonwealth.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:41:11
I would say that we've left the flexibility in it so that the MPOs and there's going to be specific things that one MPO places at a higher priority because of the regional demands in that MPO.
02:41:23
That we've left that flexibility in there so that the MPO working with the CTB member, whatever list they bring would be prioritized.
02:41:31
If what you're saying is that across the Commonwealth and all the MPOs that there be a specific focus, I would suggest we might want to give this a year or two, see how these are coming in.
02:41:42
And if we think that there's a problem, then that should be addressed.
02:41:47
But if maintaining the flexibility I think is an important aspect here.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:41:51
Yeah, I was just getting at, when something would come to us, if it were coming from Hampton Roads, I'd like to know that they had a mechanism that prioritized the three or four things that their district rep might bring, as we would in Northern Virginia.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:42:07
And I don't think that exists right now.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:42:09
It's kind of, you know, you get lists, but you don't get a prioritized list all the time, and it's not uniform.
02:42:17
So, this is a suggestion, and I can hold that for a year or two down the road.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:42:21
In the Richmond District, this is not going to change a whole lot.
02:42:27
We do have a good working relationship and our NPO does, as Northern Virginia does, create a list of priorities.
02:42:34
So this will just reinforce what seems to be working.
02:42:39
It will add to the district members' workload.
02:42:42
There's no question of that, but that depends on the level of trust and activity between the two parties.
02:42:50
So I think it's not going to be much of a concern, but I agree with Cord that we ought to give it a year or two and see if there are issues that need to be regressed.
02:42:59
At the moment, I think this is a good balance between the fact that the state is ultimately responsible, this board is responsible for allocating these funds, but the knowledge of the local knowledge resides in the MPOs and the localities.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:16
There's a resolution.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:30
I don't think it's in final form as yet, or it may be, but it hasn't been passed out.
02:43:35
That's up to the secretary and the board.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:37
I think you all just came up with this.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:42
Let me start or finish or somewhere in between.
02:43:47
I need to thank Mr. McCarthy.
02:43:49
I need to thank Mr. Koelemay and Mr. Layne for coming down this morning.
02:43:54
We started at 8 o'clock and Rita and her staff.
02:43:56
We started early to get this done today.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:00
Going back to issues raised before, to be above board and transparent, I think before we do anything, we need to
02:44:09
Reach out to the five MPOs and tell them we're heading down this path.
02:44:14
So I think, if anything, before we pass a resolution, we're not getting any legislation in this year.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:19
It doesn't require, since it's already under our legislative authority.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:24
So if everyone's okay with this game plan, then I would suggest the next step be, let's set up either a meeting or at least write to all of the five affected MPOs and say,
02:44:39
Because of the problems we see here, and we're the state and we're responsible, this is the path we're heading down, and we'd like to get together with you to discuss it.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:44:51
If I may, as it happens, we have a meeting with them Friday.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:55
Excellent.
02:44:56
So let's sit down with them and walk them through.
02:44:58
We'll hear the screaming.
02:45:01
Are you having that meeting?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:03
Yes, there were a couple.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:05
I have them from Richmond.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:06
I will hear them from here.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:08
Both Richmond and Northern Virginia were in attendance.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:10
But again, I mean, when you look at these numbers, this is completely unacceptable.
02:45:15
I mean, completely unacceptable, looking at these numbers.
02:45:17
I mean, actually, as Mr. McCarthy says, I give a lot of credit to Richmond.
02:45:20
They're pretty much right on it.
02:45:22
I'm looking.
02:45:23
I'm looking at Virginia.
02:45:25
I mean, looking at some of these numbers, it's sort of shocking.
02:45:31
You know, one year out, I mean, we're only six months from next year, next fiscal year, and they haven't programmed a single dollar in CMAQ money or a single dollar in RSVP money.
02:45:43
And that's just how you end up planning.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:47
Some would say that that's a problem with communication where they didn't understand and they were never, they will say they were never told.
02:45:53
That they had to program those funds for the six-year period, that they just do the one year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:45:58
They just sent us a piece of paper because we think it's fine.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:06
Part of it is actually making decisions on the money they could actually spend that year after all the uncertainties of the system were finished.
02:46:15
Like what is the state going to do?
02:46:16
What's the federal dollars?
02:46:18
What is the appropriations bill?
02:46:20
When is the continuing resolution?
02:46:21
I mean, there's just a lot of
02:46:23
Yes, so North Virginia's programmed it year to year as opposed to programmed it over a six-year period, just giving those uncertainties.
02:46:33
I was on the MPO.
02:46:35
No, I'm sorry.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:35
No, but I will say this.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:37
I mean, at our result of our questions, they've said the transition to programming it over a six-year period is not difficult.
02:46:47
I mean, they sort of mentally are doing that now.
02:46:49
It's just they're
02:46:50
They've been obligating year to year based on real things that could be done.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:56
Is there kind of a general feeling that these ought to be real concrete projects too and not vehicle giveaways or just spending money for regular city or municipal expenses?
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:12
I can speak only for myself that that's what I'd be looking for.
02:47:16
If I've got to come before this body and defend projects, a list of projects, I'm going to make sure I can defend them.
02:47:22
Even if they are electric vehicles, I'd make sure I could defend them.
02:47:27
I think given the tone of the meeting in Roanoke when this was discussed, I don't want to speak for the other members of this board.
02:47:36
I got the impression that that was sort of where the board as a whole was thinking as they had to be concrete.
02:47:43
But again, retaining the flexibility because there may be reasons
02:47:48
for a project to be in there that we're not thinking of today.
02:47:52
I could tell you electric vehicles to supplement a municipality's, basically their fleet, not for public transportation purposes, but for employee purposes, I can't see a value there.
02:48:05
But electric vehicles for purposes for clean air, electric buses, things of that, I could see a value there.
02:48:13
So we want to retain the flexibility.
02:48:15
But from my standpoint, I certainly am not going to make a project here that I can't defend.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:19
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:21
OK. Well, listen.
02:48:22
So if everyone's OK, we're going to proceed as recommended, starting with the outreach.
02:48:27
And then we're going to have to develop essentially a little process.
02:48:31
A resolution will come back to us.
02:48:33
And then it will have to be until next year.
02:48:35
We get the latest life changes.
02:48:37
So we'll do whatever we can.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:39
On the legislative changes, that's applying to a substantial part of when we would have to recover.
02:48:45
I mean, are we going to enforce the 36 months that we've got to do that?
02:48:49
It doesn't apply to how we would allocate funds, but it does apply to how we would enforce the process.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:55
Okay.
02:48:56
All right, listen, why don't we take 10 minutes?
02:48:59
One o'clock, we'll start back up if we can get everybody to grab their meals, and we'll continue on.
02:49:08
Can I ask everyone to please take their seats?
02:49:12
We'll resume the agenda.
02:49:16
The next item is, and I will stress this, the illustrative list of projects for the Governor's funding package.
02:49:25
We have Rita Busher and Steve Pittard.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:49:45
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
02:49:48
Today we'll go over the components of the governor's transportation funding package as it relates to the illustrative list of candidate projects.
02:50:00
Then we'll talk about that list.
02:50:02
I'll give you some examples.
02:50:04
Each of you have received a copy of that list last Friday.
02:50:10
and we'll talk a little bit about the selection criteria and Steve Pittard, I'll talk about it from the VDOT perspective and Steve Pittard will talk about it from the DRPT perspective and then we'll talk about the next steps.
02:50:38
Ah, but we were working.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:50:40
They were working not only Monday, Friday, but Monday too.
02:50:45
We appreciate that very much.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:50:49
As you all have heard and there are three funding, possible funding opportunities in the governor's transportation package and I've summarized them here.
02:51:01
The Garvey Bonds, the governor is looking to get
02:51:07
legislation changed or approved to issue direct grant anticipation revenue GARVEEs.
02:51:12
These are direct GARVEEs which means the difference from France is these will be paid back with federal, future federal dollars and we actually, when we sell the bonds must be specific as to the projects for which we're selling bonds.
02:51:31
Before we could sell the bonds and then select the projects as we went forward.
02:51:37
This project financing that uses debt financing involving the payment of future Federal-aid highway funds to retire the debt.
02:51:44
The second component is the creation of the Virginia Infrastructure Bank.
02:51:48
We call it VTIB.
02:51:50
We would be looking at low interest loans and grants to qualifying transportation projects throughout the Commonwealth to help leverage the dollars that are already available for transportation.
02:52:02
Currently there's plans for initial capitalization of approximately $400 million.
02:52:08
We hope to grow that to $1 billion over the next three years.
02:52:13
And then third, we are looking to accelerate the sale of approximately $1.8 billion in previously authorized capital project revenue bonds.
02:52:22
We call those the CPR bonds that were authorized in House Bill 3202.
02:52:28
The $1.8 billion would relate to
02:52:32
Increasing the annual bond sales cap from $300 million a year, as House Bill 3202 allowed for, to $600 million cap per year, and the $1.8 billion would
02:52:47
the sale in this year and the next two years at 600 million apiece.
02:52:54
These bonds could, proceeds could fund and will fund at least initially the previously committed projects with CPR bonds that are in the program that have the bond proceeds as match, matching our federal dollars.
02:53:11
If you may recall, we also lost
02:53:15
There was some revenue in the TPOF program and the General Assembly replaced that with debt.
02:53:22
There was approximately 180 million two years ago that they pulled back and then gave us debt capacity to replace that 180 million in cash.
02:53:34
Also, we would be looking at using the accelerated sale of the CPR bonds to fund project phases
02:53:43
to accelerate project phases that are in the six-year program with actually putting CPR bonds on those projects as new allocations.
02:53:52
So that would be above and beyond any match.
SPEAKER_09
02:53:56
The infrastructure bank, is that for loans only to localities?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:54:06
It could be loans to localities or to
02:54:12
project partners such as PPTA.
SPEAKER_20
02:54:16
But it would not in any event be loaned to the state itself.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:54:20
No, it would not.
02:54:22
Yes, sir.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:54:22
On that, Frederick and Spotsylvania have the George Washington Coal Road Authority and they're looking at putting in a project.
02:54:29
I'm trying to get using that as my frame of reference.
02:54:34
How large of projects are we talking about would be eligible and how would that particular
02:54:40
Well, okay.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:54:45
Obviously, what's going to drive us initially is how much capitalization we get and for this to be successful, it's key at the beginning to have as many projects as possible that produce revenue.
02:55:06
because that then provides that foundation of revenues and more importantly reduces the risk that any one project could actually stop there from being revenues coming in.
02:55:23
So the initial one, if we get to $400 million, we'd obviously like to have maybe four or five projects potentially being paid for, or at least loaned at that.
02:55:33
That produces the revenue that then allows us to leverage to the next level.
02:55:37
So it could be, I mean, as much as at least initially $100, $150 million.
02:55:44
We're looking for some smaller projects as well.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:55:46
So $100, $150 million total now.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:55:49
If we have $400, for the beginning, for the $400 million.
02:55:52
So as we get more money, as soon as the General Assembly passes ABC privatization, we get the additional $300 million?
02:56:01
That then will enable us to do even more.
02:56:04
And actually, the more money that goes in, the more ability to do bigger projects.
02:56:10
The smaller amount, the smaller the more we're going to look for more smaller projects.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:56:15
So the loan repayment will refresh the fund for future loans?
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:19
Chairman, is that a separate independent body of board of directors who would run the bank?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:24
Yes.
02:56:25
Again, this is going to be multi-modal.
02:56:29
It will potentially even pay for projects outside of this board's purview.
02:56:35
It may end up actually providing funds to projects in this body's purview.
02:56:40
But the intent is that we look for, I mean, try to treat it as an infrastructure bank and try to leverage it as much as possible.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:48
Mr. Chairman?
02:56:49
Yes, Mr. Richard.
02:56:50
If I could just take one comment on that.
02:56:53
I think it's important that the CTB have a role in the prioritization of these projects so that it's coordinated with the other six-year plan funding and that we
02:57:06
Watch out for the taxpayers and make sure these funds are being spent properly and that, you know, we stick to these strategic corridors that we've identified.
02:57:15
Something could pop up that, I'm all for free enterprise, I'm a capitalist, but some of these projects could pop up, maybe that it looks good to conceivably make some money for a certain entity, but maybe it doesn't fit in the priorities for the taxpayers.
02:57:35
We need to make sure that we stand up for the taxpayers and the needs of the coordinated
02:57:47
There's a way I'd like to bring the entire board into this.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:14
Is this risk getting myself in trouble would this be a good area and would it be viable for this body to have a representative sort of one of the members of this bank infrastructure bank be from this body or two members whatever it is to bring that link between what a six-year plan plus the bank
02:58:40
Be good for an at-large member.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:44
An at-large member.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:46
Well, right now in the legislation that the governor's office has put in court, you actually have three members, me, him, and her.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:56
You're the three members of the infrastructure bank?
SPEAKER_09
02:59:02
Mm-hmm.
02:59:03
The next question?
02:59:05
The next question?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:06
Thelma looks like a banker.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:10
So we're working through the processes, so right now there are bigger issues with statistics established.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
02:59:18
Given the fact that the funding sources we were just talking about are different in requirements and amounts and some are debt, some are not, the illustrative project list includes more projects than can be funded by the Governor's proposed transportation funding package.
02:59:42
so that there are contingency projects which could be funded in the event that another project on the list can advance based on circumstances surrounding that particular project.
02:59:54
That bids come in below project estimates.
02:59:56
I hope that continues for us for a while longer or if changes need to be made to individual projects.
03:00:04
Now the list draws from projects already in the Six-Year Improvement Program
03:00:10
previously adopted the 11-16 approved program that would not, projects that would not have advanced without additional funding.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:00:31
There seem to be three or four projects on there that have long since been completed.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
03:00:37
You may be referring to the 64 paving project.
03:00:41
That is part of an example of the type of projects that are on the list that relate to bond, CPR bond match.
03:00:51
That is on the list because in FY11 backwards,
03:00:56
We were using CPR bond proceeds to match federal dollars.
03:01:01
That project was a federal project.
03:01:03
So that project has bond proceeds as the revenue source.
03:01:08
But we have not yet sold the bonds that will fund or pay VDOT back for that completed project for that funding source.
03:01:18
So that's why we were indicating there are two project types that the CPR bond sales, the 1.8 billion could cover.
03:01:27
Projects that we are paying ourselves back for where we fronted the cash to complete those projects that have bond match as a revenue source and then the next issue will pay those funds back and then projects that the funding would not be, CPR bonds would not be matched for but would actually fund the project outright and those are projects forward.
03:01:59
The selection criteria, we were looking at projects already included in the approved six-year improvement program that lacked sufficient funding to complete.
03:02:12
Again, we were still looking at projects related to bridge and safety and improving those structurally deficient structures.
03:02:23
We also took into consideration local and regional priorities.
03:02:28
We asked for your input and the district's input from projects in the program that were of a priority nature for the regions.
03:02:39
We were also looking mainly for construction phases, projects that were not funded, the construction phases were not funded.
03:02:48
So we were looking to be able to start the construction for those projects within three years.
03:02:56
And we also needed to, we wanted to look across the state and look at various types of projects because of the various types of funding sources.
03:03:05
So we were looking for projects that might be eligible for a loan or a grant through the infrastructure bank.
03:03:12
And in those cases we were looking for projects
03:03:15
that were small in nature related to the secondary and urban systems since funding has not been going through the formula for their formula allocations for the last several years.
03:03:27
And we were also keeping in mind not adversely impacting our federal strategy.
03:03:34
So the Garvey bonds will need to be federal.
03:03:38
Any money that we use there would need to be federally eligible projects.
03:03:42
The grants could be on non-federally eligible projects, that sort of thing, and so could CPR bonds.
03:03:50
So we needed to have a mix of projects to accommodate the funding types, but also not adversely impact our federal strategy.
03:04:00
So we tried
03:04:01
to make sure we kept projects that were obligated or planned to be obligated in this federal fiscal year as federal projects.
03:04:12
I used some examples from the list that the governor used in his press conference for showing some of the projects across the state, various nature, whether they're
03:04:31
Large or small various areas of the state.
03:04:34
Widening of I-66 for Gainesville to Haymarket as well as the installation of an active traffic management system on I-66 to dynamically control lanes to reduce congestion in Nova.
03:04:47
There were several interchange improvement projects on 64, 81, and 95 in Frederick, Augusta, Stafford, and Louisa.
03:04:56
Widening Route 7 in Loudoun County, rebuilding the Route 460 Southgate Avenue intersection in Montgomery County, some widening projects in the Hampton Roads area, Route 28 widening in Fairfax and Prince William Counties, some light rail and other transit projects including VRE funding in Spotsylvania County,
03:05:24
Some major projects along Route 58, which is not a federally qualifying project list.
03:05:32
And then possible advancing of PPTA projects that are on the board, Dominion Boulevard in Chesapeake, the Downtown Midtown MLK project, 95395 in Northern Virginia, the 460 expressway between Suffolk and Petersburg,
03:05:50
and a portion of the Coalfields Expressway in Bristol.
03:05:53
That one was the possibility of the pound connector project.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:02
I'll turn it over to Steve Pittard to talk about the DRPT project.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
03:06:32
On the CPR bonds, we do believe that the PTF revenue, the insurance premium dedicated revenues will cover the advancing or speeding up of those bond sales.
03:06:56
So we believe we can handle that debt service.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:07:02
Yes, Mr. Speaker.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:07:04
Mr. Busher, I talked a little bit with my district supervisor.
03:07:09
It looks like the Lynchburg district is getting approximately 1% of all the funds that are being appropriated in this.
03:07:19
Is there any
03:07:20
The process where we're going to look at this, and I know one of the things the governor said is to help get people to work at this time was one of the reasons he wants to get the $4 billion out the door.
03:07:31
And that 1% in our district, is there any way that we can look at this and make it a little more equitable as to how we break it up among districts and localities?
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
03:07:41
As you may recall, on the criteria, we were looking for projects that could go to construction within three years and we were looking for projects that were already in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
03:07:51
Lynchburg didn't have a lot of projects in the program that were at that stage and were ready to go.
03:08:00
We picked up some smaller projects in that district
03:08:05
related to possible urban and secondary projects that could get possible funding or grant opportunities depending on the funding source and that's all to be determined.
03:08:17
But we were trying to keep the projects in the Six-Year Improvement Program because we wanted to fund those projects.
03:08:23
that were already in the program that couldn't advance because they needed additional funding and to keep to those criteria that limited the project selection in the Lynchburg District.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:08:40
The builders, asphalt people, road builders, all of them in my district have been contacting me, starting back in November, talking about our six-year plan.
03:08:50
Now there really are no projects in our six-year plan, and no monies have been spent in our district.
03:08:58
I think seven percent, and I don't want to get in trouble, very low percentage over the past several years, far under other rural districts even, and wondering why that is,
03:09:10
and what, specifically, what am I doing wrong that we're not getting along the way.
03:09:15
That's exactly what the point is.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:09:18
What am I doing wrong as a CTB member that no money's being spent on my business.
03:09:31
Most of the projects on this list are projects that were in the six-year plan, had fallen off the table, and we did the cutbacks,
03:09:39
Now we're going to be back on, as well as projects that are being advanced.
03:09:43
It's going to open up in the years three, four, and five, a lot of clinical capacity.
03:09:51
One of the problems that we saw in the whole audit is that our pipeline process really is broken.
03:09:56
And this is really where the opportunities for the CTB to go out and start to identify projects like you have with the
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
03:10:07
And in a separate effort, we're looking at starting some PE phases of projects that are in the program that aren't fully funded that would get a project to a point where
03:10:29
when additional funding is available for those to move forward.
03:10:32
So we are looking to initiate some new projects and some projects in the program to initiate those PE phases for future on the shelf projects.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:10:45
Certainly.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
03:10:49
Thank you Rita, Chairman, members of the board,
03:10:58
I'm just going to take a few moments and go through the same project list and give you all a high-level overview of process DRPT used for the projects that are in the list.
03:11:10
I guess to start out, I think I want to reiterate, to add on to what Rita has said, that really this isn't new revenue.
03:11:19
It's taking existing revenues and speeding up, accelerating.
03:11:24
Utilizing those revenues to take advantage of one, a favorable financing climate of today, and then two, a favorable contracting climate that we have today.
03:11:34
So I think when everybody's thinking about the projects and putting money on projects, you have to go back to that first thing I said.
03:11:42
It's not really a new revenue source here.
03:11:44
It's accelerating existing revenues to be utilized today.
03:11:49
So there wasn't a lot of new money to spread around to a lot of different
03:11:53
That being said, I think for rail and transit, one of the key points for us is on the CPR bonds, we were, in the legislation, we were given a minimum of 20% for transit and a minimum of 4.3% for rail.
03:12:13
And over the course of the first three years, by having a project, the Dallas Metrorail Project received,
03:12:21
$125 million allocation, and then, as Rita pointed out, the WMATA State of Good Repair effort was funded out of CPR bonds also at totaling $500 million over a 10-year process.
03:12:36
And when you take those two things into account, transit and rail essentially are at about 45% of that $3 billion authorized.
03:12:46
And that authorized level, once again, isn't changing.
03:12:49
The ceiling, we're just speeding up the actual issuance of that funding.
03:12:54
And for us, in this process, we're gonna maintain that 45% level.
03:12:59
So for us, that was a very important item in this that we have a 10-year commitment to provide this $50 million a year.
03:13:07
We have to still make that commitment when year nine and 10 come around.
03:13:12
And we've been assured, we've worked it out with VDOT that we'll have that funding.
03:13:17
With respect to RAIL, it's a total of $80 million projects on the list.
03:13:23
Similar to what Rita said about VDOT, essentially we're taking projects that are in the six-year program.
03:13:29
And in the case of RAIL, it does allow us to advance some projects that are actually ready to go.
03:13:36
Primary one being Kilby Yard improvements in Suffolk.
03:13:39
It's a project CSX has actually been pushing us to get moving on.
03:13:44
We have a program I think in 15 and 16
03:13:47
And with this, if this goes through, we'll be able to move that project up and go ahead and get it done.
03:13:54
On the transit side, there's a total of $422 million in the list.
03:13:59
Essentially, what this is is the current Six-Year Improvement Program for 2011, and then we've taken 2012, 2013, and 2014 and projected what $60 million a year of CPR bonds would go to, and basically,
03:14:17
In doing that, we took some general classifications rather than trying to go through all our transit provider partners and determine in three years from now exactly how many buses they'll be applying for.
03:14:31
We essentially classified those into these three large groupings of facility construction improvements, rolling stock acquisition, and then all the other miscellaneous equipment, you know, shop equipment, bus stop shelters, bike racks, et cetera.
03:14:48
Additionally, I think another point to point out, and it gets a little bit to some of the questions asked, all these projects have to proceed through the normal six-year program process.
03:15:01
So I think Rita had VRE extension to Spousal Vein.
03:15:05
We still need to get an application for that project, and we need to take a look at that application, put it through our normal analysis before it
03:15:14
It will become finalized.
03:15:15
And that's why I think we've stressed the word illustrative numerous times here.
03:15:19
So there is opportunity for this list to change.
03:15:24
An example is Richmond Bus Rapid Transit Project.
03:15:26
And for us, us, on that in particular, for us in particular, all of our projects, rail and transit, are really partnerships.
03:15:34
They aren't projects, we aren't the people that go out and build them.
03:15:38
It's really our partner that goes and builds them.
03:15:40
So we need them to come to us
03:15:42
to do the project.
03:15:45
And finally, along the lines of the next steps, we will be incorporating feedback from the MPOs and citizens, board members, et cetera.
03:15:58
We'll work that through the hearing process coming up for the six-year program.
03:16:03
The plan is to, when we get to the draft program in April,
03:16:09
have the project list finalized and go ahead and program these funds at that point and then in turn we would be looking to adopt in June at that point we would know also as far as whether this legislation has succeeded or not so it may be a busy May for us because we're going to go down one path of an assumption of this going forward and then we may have to shift but when once again we stress here that project readiness
03:16:37
is a key, and then also we have a lot more projects there in case, as we have been seeing the past two years now, the projects are coming in a lot under bed, under what our estimates are, so we wanna have some projects for contingency.
03:16:56
With that, myself, Rita, I'm glad to answer any other questions y'all might have.
03:17:02
Any other questions?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:17:04
Excellent, thank you very much.
03:17:07
Supplemental Guide Sign Program, Hospital Signs.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:17:50
Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
03:18:00
This will be a short presentation, hopefully.
03:18:04
Back in May, we had a couple of hospitals who were anxious about some signing issues.
03:18:13
One in the Culpeper area, one in the Fredericksburg area.
03:18:16
Since that time, we've both resolved
03:18:18
We've resolved both of those issues but the Virginia Hospital Association has now weighed in on this issue and so I want to bring to you a short update on what's going on with hospital signs.
03:18:38
So earlier we had a request for some exemptions from some hospitals to participate in supplemental guide signs rather than the
03:18:48
International H that they use.
03:18:52
Back in 2004, this board adopted a comprehensive signing policy document that VDOT goes by to standardize the various signs and to also provide clearer guidance about how to obtain signs that would require fewer exceptions.
03:19:11
The process included an advisory committee of stakeholders made up mostly of people from the travel industry because they are mostly the people who have lots of sign issues.
03:19:23
And there was significant public participation that was obtained during that process.
03:19:29
During that time, the federal government started to use a lot of international signs in their guidebook.
03:19:37
And so across the 50 states there are a number of these signs.
03:19:41
Probably one of the most prominent ones is H. If you're on the interstate or a limited access highway and you need a, you have a medical emergency, it's not one that maybe requires you to stop and call an ambulance, but to drive yourself or a member of your family to the nearest hospital, the H sign is an internationally recognized sign and it gets you to the hospital closest to where you are.
03:20:07
In the event that there is more than one facility, there are signs that give the names of the facilities and directions on which of the two facilities.
03:20:21
Signing can be very clearly seen in the Fredericksburg area most recently where there was a new hospital that was built there close to an existing hospital and also a standalone emergency center that is now there.
03:20:33
So there are signs that give the names of those facilities because you do have some choices on that one interchange that you would get off at Massaponics.
03:20:45
So the name of the hospital under the H sign is generally not permitted by FHWA unless you have this conflict because you really don't need to know, you know, and their rationale is you don't really need to know the name of the hospital.
03:20:58
If you need a hospital,
03:20:59
You need the one you can get to the quickest, the closest to where you are.
03:21:04
So the CTB policy did grandfather in about 16 institutions, hospitals I should say, that had hospital funds from way back when.
03:21:15
Mary Washington Hospital, Martha Jefferson,
03:21:20
and a few others.
03:21:22
I think the McGuire's Veterans Hospital out of the 95 south of here has one of those 16 hospitals that has one of those signs.
03:21:33
Exemptions to the policies can be granted by either the commissioner or the CTB can change those policies.
03:21:39
So I talked a little bit about the signs up in Spotsylvania where the two hospitals had requested special signing and so we've got that
03:21:49
situation I think resolved.
03:21:51
They're very happy.
03:21:52
And Culpeper was a situation where there's only one hospital but they've become affiliated with the University of Virginia Hospital.
03:21:59
And they wanted a sign that said that they were an affiliate.
03:22:02
And so then we begin running up against the advertising question that the federal government doesn't particularly want to approve advertising signs.
03:22:11
If you need a hospital, you don't
03:22:12
It's really necessary to know who it may or may not be affiliated with if that's the only hospital in town.
03:22:19
So because of the UVA hospital facility there, they have qualified for a sign because of their satellite location to the university.
03:22:32
So I think we had that situation resolve their satisfaction.
03:22:36
We're just waiting for them to give us the wording on the sign.
03:22:40
So these are pictures of the typical types of signs.
03:22:45
And so one of the things that in working with these facilities we did see that across the state we haven't been very uniform in the placement of some of these H signs particularly.
03:22:56
They're different sizes of them depending on what the
03:22:59
But the hospital association still would like to see every hospital in the Commonwealth have a big brown sign on the interstate or wherever on the primary that says the name of their hospital.
03:23:18
And they think that this policy is unfair, that there were some that were grandfathered in and that every hospital, hospitals are so important, that every hospital ought to have a sign with its name on it.
03:23:30
And so we got a letter on December the 20th asking, well the secretary got the letter asking that each hospital have a sign, an H sign with their name on it.
03:23:43
And so we went back to them and talked about how we might do that.
03:23:46
And they've since written another letter that came in at four in the afternoon yesterday that they really do want the supplemental signs.
03:23:53
So the bottom part of this slide just tells you how many of these supplemental signs are already installed across the state.
03:24:02
This is not just for hospitals, but all the various
03:24:07
institutions, organizations that have them.
03:24:10
There are almost 6,000 of these signs around the Commonwealth, 1,300 of them on the interstate, 4,500 on primaries and secretaries.
03:24:18
There are 145 hospitals that qualify for the age signs, 16 have their grandfather's signs, 55 signs are on the interstate.
03:24:30
Most facilities, most hospitals have about three and a half or four signs.
03:24:34
per facility today coming from the different directions.
03:24:38
So there are 781 H signs that are installed on right away today.
03:24:44
helping to trail blaze right to the hospital to get you to the location.
03:24:50
And you can see the breakdown of how many there are out there.
03:24:56
So after we reviewed the policy, we basically offered the hospital association an example of what you see here, a sign so that when you get to an intersection, when you're driving down the interstate, you see the big H sign, and when you get down to the ramp, it would give you the name of the hospital.
03:25:14
and then it would just continue to trailblaze you but without the name but they want both they want the big signs and they also want these trailblazers with their names on them all the way through to the locations so based on the letter that came in at four in the afternoon we were going to hold off on the commissioner taking this proposed action to just grant them this
03:25:38
and to talk to them a little bit more.
03:25:39
But the one issue that we have with trying to even think about putting them back into the Supplemental Brown Guide Sign Program, which basically has been closed down back in 2004, is that the signs that are allowed under that Supplemental Guide Sign group
03:26:03
are restricted by the federal government in terms of how many can be at any one interchange.
03:26:07
And most of the interchanges that we have, the restriction is two sign locations with two names on each sign is the restriction.
03:26:17
And if you can think about all the interchanges that you're involved in, we are oversubscribed in almost every location already.
03:26:25
So any additional sign that gets put up has to have the federal government approval.
03:26:30
So it's a difficult process.
03:26:35
So at this point, I just wanted to give you this briefing and suggest that we could still try and meet with the hospital association if you want to try and see if there's any other thing that could be possible.
03:26:51
But this, to us as a staff, seems like the most reasonable, quick approach to
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:27:00
Okay, so just to be clear, their request, I mean, what they presented to me and what they have in these letters is that, hey, if they have the opportunity to put up their name, they pay for it and everything, they'd like to do that.
03:27:23
We're going to allow that to happen, but they still want to be on the Interstates and we can't do it because the feds say we can't.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:27:30
Right, and because those big signs that they want on the interstate, we're already oversubscribed in the number that we can have at most locations.
03:27:40
So that's the problem.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:27:41
So we can explain that to them, but then off the interstate, on our roads, if they want to pay for that.
03:27:48
We can work with them.
03:27:52
We will allow them.
03:27:53
If they want to walk in, get off the interstate, and actually put their little name next to the H, the commissioner is going to allow that to happen as long as they pay for it.
03:28:02
Yes.
03:28:04
Is everybody okay with that?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:28:06
Many of them are for profit, Mr. Chairman.
03:28:09
Perhaps this is a way to capitalize the infrastructure bank.
03:28:17
What do you think, a million, personally?
03:28:18
How much does that probably work?
03:28:20
If we got back into the billboard, now we ban them for everything else.
03:28:24
We could get back into that business even.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:28:27
No, you know, the drive-in theaters.
03:28:30
Sorry, Mr. Wharton.
SPEAKER_09
03:28:31
It seems like a slippery slope to me.
03:28:33
I mean, you get to have, these are four props, many of them.
03:28:36
I mean, do we have any other institutions besides hospitals where we've allowed this?
03:28:42
Are we gonna have anybody else come in?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:28:45
Well, there are a number of organizations like universities that have their names on signs.
03:28:57
There are some old signs that also relate to museums and other features.
03:29:03
In fact, here in the Richmond area, about 15 years ago, we worked with the federal government to try a
03:29:10
A pilot program because we had about 18 different organizations that qualified for these big brown signs.
03:29:18
But in downtown Richmond, because of the slopes being so shallow, sharp, that there are just not many places actually to put signs.
03:29:31
And so one of the things we tried to do was to come up with an attraction signing program, like a logo program.
03:29:37
and in fact the Medical College of Virginia, the Science Museum, the State Capitol, the State Library, none of them have these brown signs in the Richmond Quarter and we went to sort of a logo type program and we thought that's been very successful and that actually was what led to the federal government having this attraction sign with the logo program.
SPEAKER_09
03:30:01
That's correct.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:30:03
Some are and some aren't.
03:30:05
I mean, the ones that are out there are not for profit.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:30:08
Stop for a second.
03:30:09
I mean, we do.
03:30:11
I mean, let's just think about it.
03:30:13
We have the little signs on the interstate that say McDonald's with their little logo.
03:30:18
When they get off on that ramp, McDonald's that way, Burger King, you know.
03:30:24
That's correct.
SPEAKER_09
03:30:24
Correct.
03:30:25
They pay for that?
03:30:26
Yes, they do.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:30:27
They pay for that.
03:30:27
But the thing is, once you pull up there, it'll say H.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:30:31
Well, Mr. Chairman, the thing that's happened in the healthcare industry, one of the things is that brands do matter now.
03:30:39
I mean, we all learn that from our insurance companies.
03:30:41
They don't necessarily let you do what you want to do anymore.
03:30:44
So knowing where your doctors practice, knowing what's covered, knowing where to go to get certain services, particularly since it's not simply a standalone hospital anymore.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:30:55
Yes, you're going to sign for the oncology center, the Massey Cancer Center versus the main hospital and the eye hospital, which is across the street.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:31:10
Furthermore, our economic development plans for the state really include development of this as an industry, healthcare industry.
03:31:17
By definition, you're going to begin to build clusters, which will require signage because you'll have hospital-looking places
03:31:25
And we have signing policies that cover that today.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:31:31
If there are multiple hospitals, they get these signs to direct them to the various locations.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:31:47
That's actually the way people get directions now.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:31:49
Do I understand we have a recommendation that we need to approve on this?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
03:31:56
Actually, this is informational that the Commissioner has the authority to make this exception.
03:32:04
So if the Board is happy to let the Commissioner make this exception, we just wanted to make you aware of it.
03:32:10
There may be legislation concerning this.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:32:12
Any further inquiries?
03:32:14
And his number is?
03:32:17
I have his home number.
03:32:19
Would you like to take it now?
03:32:21
804.
03:32:23
Chairman?
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:32:24
Yes, Rich.
03:32:25
This is a really complex issue to sign.
03:32:29
I don't know how Connie deals with it.
03:32:32
I'm starting to get all kinds of calls from members of local governing bodies, citizens about time.
03:32:39
It might be good if we could schedule a workshop on the overall issue.
03:32:44
People are telling me they're seeing too many regular VDOT signs saying in 50 feet you're going to have a stop sign.
03:32:51
They're saying they must have too much money because they're putting signs up everywhere.
03:32:56
Then there's a program called TODS where anybody can just kind of put a sign up for some private sector thing.
03:33:04
that could violate the county's own ordinances.
03:33:08
So I have counties calling and saying, what's going on here?
03:33:13
And one supervisor said, I don't know if you all have stink bugs in your section of the Commonwealth, but we have stink bugs.
03:33:20
And they're popping up like stink bugs.
03:33:23
I'll be happy to work with the Secretary to schedule that or meet with any individual member who'd like to discuss it.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:33:48
My favorite subject.
03:33:49
Let's get to the main event.
03:33:53
I hope I'm not the main event.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:34:04
That's right.
03:34:05
Go ahead.
03:34:07
Good afternoon.
03:34:08
I am here today representing the independent review panel.
03:34:13
And who are you?
03:34:16
And I am Charlie Kilpatrick, Chief Deputy Commissioner of VDOT.
03:34:21
I'm here today to make a presentation regarding the 460 quarter improvement project and the results of the independent review panel.
03:34:31
Before I get started, I wanted to thank two people.
03:34:34
Margie Ray is the project manager, works in the PPTA office, did a tremendous job both putting these together as well as a lot of technical details related to the project, as well as Dusty Holcomb, who's deputy director of that office,
03:34:50
Again, those two folks, not only did they manage the project, they managed me and they hope that I can get through this successfully today.
03:34:59
So again, I'll go through the briefing as well as the recommendations.
03:35:04
In your package, you should have a project map as well as some summary sheets about the three individual proposers, the list of the independent review panel members, the impact of jurisdictions,
03:35:16
and the proposal project priorities.
03:35:22
So this is an overview map of the 460 corridor essentially from 295 at the 460 interchange to the 58, 460 area in the city of Suffolk.
03:35:38
The proposed project contemplates seven interchanges spread throughout the project
03:35:46
with this facility being a limited access four lane with a 70 mile an hour design speed, essentially built to freeway or interstate standards.
03:35:57
Some of the project objectives to improve travel safety along the corridor, create a westbound emergency evacuation route for Hampton Roads, accommodate the increase in freight movement along the corridor, and improve military access.
03:36:14
In addition, this project addresses some roadway improvement needs, reducing some traffic delays coming in and out of the Hampton Roads area, especially potential future delays.
03:36:30
It also meets a legislative mandate, which I'll mention later, and some economic development opportunities.
03:36:37
This is an overview of sort of the background of where we are today.
03:36:43
It goes back at least into the early 90s with a study that extended from West Virginia to Hampton Roads related to access to the poor facilities.
03:36:53
And again, you can go through this list.
03:36:55
Some of the highlights.
03:36:57
In 2003, VDOT began its environmental study of this corridor.
03:37:01
Also in 2003, the General Assembly passed legislation requiring VDOT
03:37:07
In 2005, the draft EIS and public involvement process was completed and the CTB selected corridor CBA-1, which is the corridor, the map that I showed.
03:37:29
In 2008, we finished the final environmental impact statement and received federal highway record of decision regarding that project.
03:37:40
In 2008, we issued a request for detailed proposals that was suspended in
03:37:50
in early 2010, changing economic conditions, and then again early in 2010, we went out for a new procurement.
03:38:03
So we went out for a new procurement in, I believe it was in May of 2010.
03:38:09
We received three conceptual proposals, and you'll see the offers, and again, more details can be found in your notebooks.
03:38:17
After a quality control phase, the Secretary appointed an 11-member panel called the Independent Review Panel.
03:38:28
The charge of that panel was to conduct public meetings, to receive comment, and to evaluate the proposals that we received.
03:38:38
We had a total of three public meetings.
03:38:41
Two of those included public comment.
03:38:44
We had approximately 430 people in attendance at those meetings.
03:38:49
We received 37 public comment and about 45 written comments, both from individuals as well as groups during the process.
03:39:02
I would say during the public comment period,
03:39:06
A lot of the discussion related to the location of the project and some specific design details including the tie-down points at the ends of the project as well as interchange locations, severing local roads and some of that.
03:39:24
And you'll see some of those recommendations at the end related to that.
03:39:28
There were also a number of comments from residents who were directly impacted by the project.
03:39:34
which is not uncommon in a public hearing setting where you're impacting individuals and businesses.
03:39:46
The purpose of the independent review panel is highlighted here.
03:39:49
If we were to evaluate the conceptual proposals, if we were to consider the input from the jurisdictions as well as input from staff, the offer, and the public,
03:40:02
And to determine, and this is one of the keys, if these offer teams were qualified to advance to the next phase of procurement, which is a request for detail proposal.
03:40:12
So again, that was our charge.
03:40:14
And to develop any recommendations for consideration that are necessary or desirable to implement the project.
03:40:24
So this chart gives you kind of a overview of the things that we looked at during the review process.
03:40:32
as the three offer teams submitted both written documentation as well as made presentations.
03:40:40
I want to note at the bottom, and this is an important point, that through the process the IRP did conclude that none of these proposals was financially viable without a sizable public contribution.
03:40:53
And that contribution, the three proposals were very different, very different approaches to how they would proceed with the project.
03:41:02
Went from a straightforward contribution by the Commonwealth to a provision that was sort of a backstopping provision.
03:41:11
In other words, if a facility didn't generate sufficient revenues that the Commonwealth would stand behind that.
03:41:19
And in all of those cases that represents a potential
03:41:23
Now out of the meetings we came up with a list of ten recommendations and later on this afternoon there is a resolution that we will ask for your consideration but again if I go through these
03:41:49
The first one being to establish the maximum amount of Commonwealth contribution as we proceed forward with the request for detailed proposals.
03:42:00
You heard a few minutes ago from Ms. Busher that part of the Governor's package, there is a part of this overall package is an opportunity for funding for the PPTA projects
03:42:15
in Virginia, including this particular project.
03:42:18
In addition, the board would need to allocate funds through the Six-Year Plan process.
03:42:23
So again, that's the first bullet.
03:42:27
We do also recommend that all three move forward to the detailed phase.
03:42:33
We felt that all three demonstrated that their offer team had the qualifications and the ability to deliver projects such as this.
03:42:44
and that by moving to a detailed proposal we'll have a greater opportunity for competition as we work towards a single recommendation.
03:42:58
Again, with the notion that there is a public contribution to continue to work with the offerors to find ways to lower the overall project cost.
03:43:09
As part of it, and I mentioned the request for detailed proposals,
03:43:12
What we look to do is to develop a draft commercial document that will tighten up the detailed proposals.
03:43:23
Right now we have three very different proposals and it's difficult to say, to hold them up next to each other.
03:43:29
So part of this process will be to really refine what's okay and what's not okay as far as this project moving forward.
03:43:38
features that we would consider and ones that we not both as far as physical improvements but also some financing techniques as well as bringing in other facilities.
03:43:54
Again, the next bullet restates again the importance of developing a scope that reduces the cost to the public in response to the concerns that we heard
03:44:07
during the process.
03:44:09
Again, some specific concerns related to the tie-down points and improving the connectivity at 295 as well as at the Suffolk end.
03:44:21
In addition, we wanted to make clear that these offers could not essentially toll or tax or consider the Port of Virginia as their funding source.
03:44:36
We thought that was important.
03:44:37
At least one of the offerors made some indication of that during our process.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:44:43
Does that mean anything coming out of the Port of Virginia?
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:44:48
As far as from the offerors, it's unclear.
03:44:51
We wanted to make clear that that's the Commonwealth of Virginia's money.
03:44:59
In other words, the Port of Virginia is owned by the Commonwealth and the resources and the revenues coming from the port
03:45:06
That's commonwealth funds.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:45:09
But if somebody picks up a load at the Port of Virginia, gets on the road, pays a toll, that... That's right.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:45:20
We're not saying you can't toll a truck leaving the Port of Virginia.
03:45:24
It really goes to placing a levy on cargo coming through the port, and there's various forms that that can take.
03:45:33
You can't apply a direct levy to everything that comes through the Port of Virginia, but not at all to restrict a truck coming from the port through the facility.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:45:43
Yes, sir.
03:45:43
You said that there was not enough information, I pose this question to Aubrey, to make a decision on one of these rather than having all three advance.
03:45:55
I mean, do one have more holes in it than another?
03:45:57
That's what I was trying to get to a prioritization of the three.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:46:04
One of the three proposals was what I would call very straightforward in that it was
03:46:12
We believe the road will cost this much.
03:46:14
We need this much in state contribution and then we will deliver the project.
03:46:19
The other two are very different variations that have other concepts of funding as well as assignment of risk.
03:46:29
So again, the initial request for proposals
03:46:34
It's really about the qualifications of the offer of teams and not the detail portion.
03:46:39
So we think it's really important now that we've heard from the three teams that we draw in and say, okay, this is what's okay and not okay as far as the detailed solicitation.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:46:51
Do you still think the three teams will stay aboard, Jeff?
03:46:55
I don't know.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:46:55
It is and that really is a decision that each of those offer teams will need to make.
03:47:07
Representatives from all three teams are here in the audience today and frankly we hope that they do proceed forward because again I think they are very different
03:47:18
uh... concepts of how to deliver the project but but again to the point we do believe that all three or were had viable concepts.
SPEAKER_09
03:47:28
Mr. Kilpatrick referred to the note on the previous stage that the IRP didn't take any of the proposals for financial feasible at their current stage and if one would have I think we may have made a difference to talk to the whole board if one would have knocked this out and said oh this one we can get it done none of them
03:47:51
Thanks.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:47:54
To again continue with the recommendations, this next recommendation deals with the existing 460 corridor and how impact as far as safety and traffic.
03:48:07
One of the discussions that came up was to try to encourage truck diversion off of the existing 460 corridor.
03:48:15
If you're not familiar with 460, it's a four-lane undivided rural section.
03:48:19
I would say it's sort of similar to US-1 heading north towards Washington or Route 11.
03:48:28
Again, not the best alignment and limited safety features.
03:48:39
One of the other comments that came up during the process related to high-speed passenger rail or higher-speed passenger rail and the CTB
03:48:50
A couple of years back now, I actually endorsed a corridor that the Department of Rail and Public Transportation had gone through an environmental process to provide passenger rail service
03:49:05
to Hampton Roads along this corridor.
03:49:08
This is just to continue to recommend that that move forward, but not as a median rail facility.
03:49:18
As we went through this discussion, we think there's some significant issues with actually putting the passenger rail in the median of this proposed project.
03:49:29
Really relates to a lot of geometric issues, clearance, maintenance of the track and things like that.
03:49:35
We do think that the rail corridor is important, but again, just not in the median of this particular project.
03:49:44
That we should continue to work with the local jurisdictions.
03:49:48
I mentioned access management, the interchange points, the secondary roads that we were severing or relocating.
03:49:55
We did go through a location process, but again, that was five years ago, and I think there's some important things that we can continue to look at.
03:50:05
We should continue the public involvement process and continue to allow the public to see this project as it moves forward.
03:50:13
There would be public meetings regarding the final design as the offers move forward.
03:50:20
And the last one is to restate again about the project termini.
03:50:25
We do think there's a better way to tie in this project to preserve the high-speed components of the project.
03:50:35
Since you don't take it into a substandard facility at the end.
03:50:42
With that, again, there is a resolution in your package for this afternoon, but I'd be glad to answer any questions.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:50:49
Any questions, Mr. Kilpatrick?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:50:54
Mr. Chairman, thank you.
03:50:59
Back on project objectives.
03:51:01
You've got four of them there.
03:51:03
Which is the top priority?
03:51:05
Improvement or is any of the others?
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:51:11
Well, I don't think that's something that I could answer on my own.
03:51:15
I think that there's a, you have both short and long range needs in the Hampton Roads area.
03:51:23
We have issues of freight, of being able to move freight out of the Port of Virginia, both in its current state and with the expansion.
03:51:32
I think the board has had briefings before about
03:51:35
The great opportunities for the Port of Virginia with the expansion of the Panama Canal, and we have one of the few facilities that can accommodate the largest cargo ships.
03:51:46
So there is a freight need there.
03:51:50
There is a, and some of that freight will take rail, but some of that freight will frankly, will need to use service transportation.
03:52:00
We also are very restricted now with
03:52:03
with access to and from the Hampton Roads area.
03:52:06
You're essentially, you have the existing 460, you have 64, and then you have 58.
03:52:14
Much of the population is traveling through the crescent from Washington to Hampton Roads, and so there's some limitations there, and this provides an additional access point, especially the south side of Hampton Roads.
03:52:28
I don't think I could say which one is most important.
03:52:30
I think they're all important.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:52:31
The reason I mention that is
03:52:33
At least on my time on the board, it's been the expressed priority of the board to address the freight problem and that the other problems exist many places in the Commonwealth.
03:52:45
Also, I'm not sure that a PPTA is going to go to try to solve an evacuation, a military connection, or a set of safety problems in a corridor.
03:52:56
And that's a core mission here.
03:52:58
So as far as I'm concerned, I'm going to be listening to this and the discussion of what we should do, really from the great perspective.
03:53:08
I think that captures the essence of the project for me.
03:53:12
And if the project needs to be considered more narrowly in that sense, that would for me be the core of it.
03:53:19
So I'm just beginning to lay that out.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:53:21
And I'm quite honest, you know, from my perspective.
03:53:26
This is all about freight mobility and about economic development.
03:53:32
We are seeing with this project already enormous interest.
03:53:39
One of the reasons Savannah has overtaken us as the second largest port on the East Coast is that they pursued a distribution center strategy.
03:53:54
They actually went out and started providing corridors for the distribution centers, which are key to the movement of cargo going out of that port.
03:54:06
We, because of where our port is and the fact that it is surrounded by already developed urban areas.
03:54:13
We want to go to, you know, first off we're investing billions to get us up to, you know, six million, essentially three times the capacity we have today.
03:54:23
And we are already seeing enormous interest in distribution centers along this corridor.
03:54:29
And the corridor is actively supporting those efforts.
03:54:33
The second thing is just from another perspective,
03:54:37
Just cost effectiveness.
03:54:39
I mean, I'm looking at these prices here for adding four lanes.
03:54:44
We, for double the price, can add two lanes onto a tunnel over the Hampton Roads Bridge.
03:54:51
For two and a half times the same amount, we can add just two lanes to the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
03:55:00
And we haven't even gotten to the issue about how much it's going to cost us to widen 64 from
03:55:05
Newport News, all the way up to Richmond.
03:55:08
So from that perspective, just adding capacity, this in many ways is the cheapest alternative.
03:55:14
I just throw that out.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:55:18
Yes.
03:55:19
We approved the potential location of the right-of-way.
03:55:24
Will there be another opportunity to make some tweaks to that or are we in a situation where that's going to be difficult?
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:55:36
If I could at least start the answer to that, I think that as we discussed, we have had a location public hearing and we have an environmental document.
03:55:44
I think we recognize, though, that even with that environmental document, we are going to have, there is a need to make adjustments along this corridor, not to the extent of taking it, picking the road up and putting it to the other side, but the tie-down points, I keep going back to that,
03:56:04
Trying to make sure that we don't shortchange ourselves with our tie-down points at 295 in the west and 58 on the east, as well as some opportunities for interchange locations.
03:56:21
The secretary mentioned the economic development opportunities.
03:56:26
We have some of the advantage to this particular corridor.
03:56:29
We do have Norfolk Southern has a freight rail line
03:56:34
adjacent to 460 which is part of the Heartland corridor which allows for double stack trains coming out of the port.
03:56:42
So there's a great opportunity for intermodal activity.
03:56:47
You have the port, we have our rail system, and again we have our surface transportation system.
03:56:53
So I think we need to look as we go to more detailed design with whoever the successful offer is after the detailed proposals are received
03:57:03
to look at those types of things and really make sure we're getting the best product that we can.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:57:09
I think there are some little minor tweaks that need to be considered and I don't want us to keep voting to approve something that takes away the potential to respond to some very small changes that would make the public a lot happier and probably not detract too much from what we're trying to accomplish.
03:57:33
And as we get further and further into this, it gets harder and harder to do those things if we don't set up a procedure as quickly as possible to get that done.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:57:42
I think the challenge we all are facing is that that corridor is the corridor you approved and the environmental documents and all are based on that corridor.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:57:55
Yes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:57:56
So if there are any tweaks to it, they'll probably have to come after the fact.
03:57:59
And once they start to do design and engineering.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
03:58:02
And Mr. Secretary, that's an excellent point that we are sort of, as this moves forward, a recommendation, the CTB would make a recommendation to the commissioner.
03:58:15
As the chair of the IRP, I will also make a recommendation to the commissioner to go forward with a request for detailed proposals.
03:58:23
So as we're negotiating with the three offers, I think that we want to be careful not to reintroduce the environmental process.
03:58:32
So I think that does a lot of things to complicate the procurement.
03:58:38
But once an offer is selected, we have significant opportunities to work through the details of the project.
03:58:48
We're doing that now with Elizabeth River Tunnels,
03:58:51
with the 395-95 project.
03:58:54
So we continue to have opportunity as we negotiate with that single offer.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:59:00
That's what I wanted to hear, that we would have that opportunity.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
03:59:04
Mr. Chairman?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:59:05
Yes.
03:59:06
Two questions.
03:59:07
One is, or sort of, I guess one's a point, one's a question.
03:59:12
Certainly the rail, freight, whatever you want to call it, whatever it moves on, whether it's road or rail, is critically important for the Port of Hampton Roads and for the state in general.
03:59:27
The growth in the port is on the other side of the river from Laughlin, whether that's Portsmouth, Craney Island, Portsmouth, or wherever it is.
03:59:37
That's where the growth is.
03:59:39
We're more or less sort of maxed out
03:59:42
on the Norfolk side, Newport News has its own deal up their interstate.
03:59:48
The sort of evacuation piece, let me cut to the point, no matter what we do to 460 in terms of road traffic, you cannot get there right now from our side of the river
04:00:03
and you still won't be able to get there from our side of the river when there's a congestion time, whether that's evacuation, whether that's just five o'clock on Friday or whatever.
04:00:14
Now, obviously the MLK Portsmouth Tunnel, Norfolk Midtown Tunnel is gonna help that, but there's seven lanes out right now and we're just slammed
04:00:27
Every day at four o'clock and you cannot get to 460 people use it now I use it if you can get there and people coming from Richmond or from the west use it because it's not backed up coming in it's only backed up going out it's the same problem we have with the monitor Merrimack 664 you cannot get to that bridge tunnel from Virginia Beach
04:00:52
Most of Chesapeake and Norfolk at the peak times because you can't get through the choke points to get there.
04:00:58
So no matter what we do to 460, if we don't do something to be able to get to 460, it doesn't solve the military problem, the evacuation problem.
04:01:09
We just have more throughput once we get through the choke point and that doesn't help yet.
04:01:14
I'm not against this project, but I would tell you if we're looking at it from those angles,
04:01:20
You gotta do something to get there to make the whole system work.
04:01:23
If you're looking at it from the angle of let's move rail and freight and truck traffic out of the expanded port, then you got something.
04:01:34
So understand that, that's the point.
04:01:36
The question is, the resolution and the recommendation speaks to establishing the maximum amount that would be provided by the commonwealth.
04:01:46
Does the resolution imply that we would do that first?
04:01:51
before we would go to these other points in the resolution since it's listed first or does it not?
04:01:58
And I would always say obviously if it's substantial, and I don't know what substantial is but I know substantial means a lot of money, that we would sort of wrestle with that issue whether it's the executive branch, the legislative branch, or us to sort of wrestle with that issue and come up with that number
04:02:20
I mean, you know, at least it's uncommon to spend a lot of time and energy and money of everybody else's to get there.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:02:27
I mean, if we look at it from that perspective.
04:02:35
I can't help but notice whenever any public entity has ever said, this is our ceiling, that's where it ends up being.
04:02:52
Even when you can potentially get it.
04:02:55
It's not less than that.
04:02:56
It's not less than that.
04:03:02
When you put a number on there,
04:03:05
In any context, that does become that number.
04:03:10
And if you look at these three proposals, I mean, the public contribution is all over the place.
04:03:20
And some of it's very contingent on, you know, potentially TIFIA or maybe even an infrastructure bank loan.
04:03:26
So I'm personally just very leery about right now setting a max.
04:03:31
I think maybe when we started the six-year plan process,
04:03:34
If you notice when we did the illustrative list, we were very nebulous.
04:03:40
We have sparked essentially looking at these various PPTA projects.
04:03:52
We essentially estimated what the overall cost of the projects were.
04:03:55
and then just put a general pool of money, not saying specifically what any one of them, because we were very concerned about this issue.
04:04:03
We talked about it a lot.
04:04:04
We went back and looked at examples and things that have happened.
04:04:08
And when you put that number out, even when you can get it potentially cheaper, that's where they start.
04:04:14
They start to say that's the bottom line.
04:04:17
I would suggest that maybe we do the resolution and let's come back in the six-year plan, particularly if we can get this stuff through on the governor's proposal.
04:04:29
It gives us a lot more latitude.
04:04:31
If we don't get the governor's proposal, it doesn't matter how much we save the maximum.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
04:04:40
And I would say from staff, we're not prepared to give you a number today because we are continuing to look at
04:04:46
refining the terms of this.
04:04:49
So we're not prepared to give you to say that this would be the maximum subsidy.
04:04:57
As the Secretary mentioned, they are so different, the proposals, that we really need to bring them together into an easier way to follow and categorize
04:05:10
What's the best project for, what's the best team for VDOT and for the Commonwealth?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:05:19
But we would definitely come because if we don't get the government's proposal, I just don't know how, because it's going to suck up so much capacity, no matter how much we, you know, is hit here.
04:05:33
I mean, the whole secure plan would disappear.
04:05:37
I'm sorry, Ms. Koelemay?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:05:39
Two questions.
04:05:40
Is the legislative requirement to procure this project from the PPTA still in effect, the one that was listed here as having been imposed in 2003?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:05:51
I'm not sure.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
04:05:54
I would have to confirm that.
04:05:56
The answer is I think so, that that legislation remains in effect, that the procurement of this would have to be through the PPTA.
04:06:04
I don't have to memory the details of that statute.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:08
If I remember correctly at that time, that was one way to jump a project to the top of a list where potentially additional money may come from.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:17
Second is...
04:06:18
I should point out who sponsored that legislation.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:21
You should?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:22
Well, I don't need to.
04:06:24
He's not in the legislature anymore.
04:06:26
That's the good news.
04:06:28
He's in another job.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:29
But go ahead.
04:06:32
The second question is do the circumstances that existed in 2010 that had us initiate the new procurement still exist and are those on a positive trend or
04:06:46
or have circumstances changed again in 2011?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:52
Well, I think part of it depends on how you look at this then.
04:06:56
I just want to tell you one thing, Ms. Koelemay.
04:07:02
I can't share with you some of the discussions I've had about the port and this issue, but I will tell you that these are some south side, has a lot of communities that are experiencing some real economic issues, and I am actually been really pleasantly surprised to see the number of approaches we've already had
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:07:24
The reason I ask that, Mr. Chairman, is because one of the things I do think we owe the offerors is some indication of whether this remains important to us.
04:07:38
Is it growing in importance or is it lessening?
04:07:41
We are asking them to make an additional step, and I think we need to reassure them that there's, you know, we're trying to stay on a positive track as opposed to, ah, we're just trying to see what's going on.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:07:53
I think from the administration standpoint for a number of different reasons this is a critical project and again I'm going to go back to this is the most cost effective project and capacity to where we see the biggest growth
04:08:10
population-wise, which is south of the James.
04:08:14
And then secondly, it's the only project really that's ready to go, that can add capacity to and from the Hampton Roads region.
04:08:27
I mean, we're looking now at the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
04:08:31
That just alone will take us three years, two and a half, three years just to do the EIS.
04:08:35
We're looking at the 64 widening.
04:08:38
Another two to three years, EIS.
04:08:41
We're looking at now the Patriots crossing.
04:08:44
That's 18 years to do a new EIS.
04:08:50
This is about the only, this and Midtown Tony, the only big projects that we could probably see in this board's lifetime happen.
04:09:00
That could actually help.
04:09:02
with capacity down in the Hampton Roads region and help the economic issues.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:09:12
The reason that we put in a cap was because several of us on the panel felt that without a cap we wouldn't be able to move forward because we agreed that there is a sizable state contribution required to make any of these proposals viable.
04:09:32
But then there's a value judgment about how important it is to us relative to all the
04:09:37
And frankly, our experience with one PPCA project some years ago that was brought to this board as a zero state dollar investment project.
04:09:55
and which has now grown to several hundred million dollars worth of state dollars investment, also argue for putting some kind of a prudent cap, cap being the operative word, not the lowest level but the maximum level.
04:10:12
So it seems, at least to me, I won't speak for anybody else on the panel, but having
04:10:17
A sense of what we think we might be able to afford, assuming any money is worth coming, would be both fair to the Commonwealth and fair to people who want to proceed with this project to say we are serious about it and we would like to give you a sense of how serious we are because they are going to have to spend an awful lot of money to go through this next phase.
04:10:44
And then finally I would say, and this is part of my real, maybe you could help me out here, but it seems to me we're putting a little bit of the project cart before the financial course.
04:10:57
We don't have money for this project at this moment.
04:11:02
We might get money for it in two months or more.
04:11:05
And we have an existing CTB policy that says we don't advance
04:11:09
projects until we know exactly where the money is coming from.
04:11:13
So that's where I have some concerns about moving forward until we know with more certainty whether we have the money.
04:11:22
And honestly, I'm not sure whether it matters a couple of months until we find that out.
04:11:27
If we have the money in hand or promised, if the Governor's full plan is passed, or whatever part of it gets passed, and we decide that that's a priority,
04:11:36
is a priority that I think we can honestly deal with that.
04:11:40
But right now, I don't know that, and nobody knows that.
04:11:45
So I guess I'm having a hard time saying we ought to proceed with this when we don't know whether we can afford it, are willing to put a cap on it, and don't know if the money will show up.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:12:02
The money for this isn't going to come from anything that's going to happen in the General Assembly this time, is it?
04:12:08
Yes.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:12:09
Well, yeah.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:12:11
It's not in the $4 billion, is it?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:12:13
Yes, it is.
04:12:14
There's a certain amount of money set aside for P3 projects in there.
SPEAKER_09
04:12:19
How much?
04:12:21
That's the discussion.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:12:22
We've set aside $1.45 billion
04:12:26
for P3 projects.
SPEAKER_09
04:12:29
Mr. McCarthy, I came at this from different angles.
04:12:41
This is all about Port of Virginia.
04:12:44
I make the same mistakes as Port of Hampton Roads anymore, so Port of Virginia.
04:12:47
And because of the tolls involved, this would not make any sense other than for economic development, getting the trucks and the goods out of Hampton Roads.
04:12:56
So that's why I'd like to see the project move forward.
04:13:00
Now whether or not that relates to when you tell the offers, how much money it is, all that strategy,
04:13:11
I can see both sides.
04:13:13
However, I would have not have voted for this proposal at all that I've been for the port because none of them made any financial sense to me based on the way they were presented.
04:13:25
But didn't want to stop the project because I think it is critically important to the port and that's why we've reached consensus I think to move forward to give you the latitude to see if there was a deal to be made there.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:13:35
When that's, I mean, again, I'll go back to, it's, there are, I mean, primary issues behind this that went through, the other one being just simply, I mean, honestly, from an air quality,
04:13:51
And a congestion issue about trying to divert the trucks.
04:13:54
We've been having lots of discussions separate that will have to come back with the port separately from that we needed to get this to the point that we can sit down with them to talk about everything from finding ways to get the truckers, because we're trying to get the truckers out of the two bridge tunnels in Office 64.
04:14:20
and get them onto something that will be diverting that traffic over there.
04:14:25
We need to move this forward.
04:14:27
There's no other reason just simply to get us to develop the proposals to see which one will make the most sense and also to start to engage support.
04:14:42
in these processes as well.
04:14:45
Again, I keep on telling people, the ports right now, we are investing billions of dollars to turn this port from two million a year, two million TEUs a year, to six million TEUs.
04:15:02
This is now one of the largest
04:15:05
Economic Development Drivers in the Commonwealth and if we don't have a way to move that cargo out of there we will never ever see the economic benefits of making that type of major investment.
04:15:20
350,000 people currently in the Commonwealth have their jobs somehow tied to that port and
04:15:28
You know, when I'm looking at the military, what's going to happen with the military budget, the government budget, and we're the only port in the United States with a major expansion that's been permitted right now, 50-foot clearance, no overhead issues.
04:15:47
This sucker, if we make some of these investments on the shore side, we've done it on the rail.
04:15:52
But even with doing the rail, that's only, even with all the capacity improvements they've made on the rail, it's only going to mean that 30% of the cargo will move by rail.
04:16:03
70% go by truck.
04:16:06
We can't get them out of Portsmouth, or Craney Island, or Norfolk.
04:16:13
You know, it's gonna be wasted money.
04:16:15
So I really would encourage you to move forward.
04:16:17
Yes, Chris?
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:16:18
I still, I'm trying to get Bridge back to
04:16:21
Mr. McCarthy's statement, which I don't think is an unreasonable one, and looking at it from both the public side that we're trying to do here, but also on the private side, are we asking the three proposers to operate in a vacuum if they don't know the answer to the funding question yet?
04:16:42
It's not a long time.
04:16:43
It's a short session.
04:16:45
We're going to know, hopefully, if the governor is successful
04:16:48
And doesn't that give the three originators a better opportunity to then judge whether they want to move ahead rather than operate in a vacuum with the big question mark there?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:17:01
It's not a question mark, Mr. Garczynski.
04:17:03
I mean, really, it's not a question.
04:17:05
If you look, the bigger question mark is that they've been asking for TIFIA.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:17:10
Right.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:17:11
That's a bigger question mark, you know, and that will drive also what the economic, I mean, yeah, there's a lot of what ifs here, but we can't get to an answer to the what ifs if we're not able to really get down to and come up with a project
04:17:32
The financial model that gives us some sort of number with or without TIFIA, with or without a contribution.
04:17:39
There is other opportunities here that I need to, again, involve the court and others.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:17:50
I understand that.
04:17:51
You mentioned Savannah.
04:17:52
South Carolina, as you know, right on the other side of Savannah River is trying to
04:17:57
Get their port authority rolling in that same port of Savannah.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:18:01
In fact, their building facility in Jasper County.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:18:04
Right, Jasper County.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:18:06
It's essentially in South Carolina to go after the port of Savannah.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:18:14
I kind of share the comments of Gary and Jerry about this, some type of certainty, both for the proposers and also mainly I'm concerned about the taxpayers.
04:18:26
What kind of safeguards can we give them so we don't end up like the big bank bailouts?
04:18:34
We have to be careful here with the taxpayer money.
04:18:38
How do we protect them?
04:18:40
If we have no idea of what it's going to be and it could continue on and on, what do we do?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:18:54
We can't get to that answer until we go to the next step.
04:19:08
I mean, the bottom line is the ability to go to the next step to essentially answer those questions.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:21
Yes, Mr. Peake.
04:19:23
It's not costing us any money to go to the next step, is it?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:26
No.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:27
They're just continuing with their study and they're going to make a proposal to us.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:31
They're going to make, everything is a proposal first to the commissioner.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:35
So right now, we vote yes on this resolution.
04:19:38
They start working and we don't spend any money.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:40
That's correct.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:41
Mr. Chairman.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:42
Yes.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:43
Yeah, I mean that sounds really wonderful, but stop and think for a second.
04:19:49
If you listen to what the secretary is saying to us and what we've heard several times, how important this is to the Commonwealth.
04:19:57
Why don't we sit down with our staff and do our estimate of what it would cost to do what we're talking about and use that as the guidance for working with the private sector to do the project?
04:20:11
I think we're being foolish not to go ahead and do all of our due diligence on the project in case they can't come up with a way to do it, because I don't think the Commonwealth can sit by and not allow this work to be done in the very near future
04:20:26
in terms of the benefits that will accrue to the citizens of the Commonwealth.
04:20:31
I'm not worried about anybody taking advantage of the taxpayer here.
04:20:34
I'm worried about our being so hesitant to do something that we absolutely know should be done and not go ahead and invest some money and being sure we know what it will cost and then go to all these creative sources to try to use them if it makes sense.
04:20:50
So I think the two have to go hand in hand and I don't think, I'd like to see the CTB step up and say,
04:20:57
We honor what the Governor is saying.
04:20:58
We recognize the value of this.
04:21:00
Let's find out what it costs, and let's figure out how to get it done.
04:21:04
That's where I am on it.
James E. Rich
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:21:06
Chairman, what I hear about the taxpayer, I mean, I kind of agree with Jim.
04:21:10
I mean, if this is this important, let's fund it.
04:21:13
But if we're going to call it a PPTA project, where we're telling the taxpayers it's a private matter,
04:21:19
But then down the road, they're going to be coming in for millions and millions.
04:21:25
I think we're doing them a disservice, is what I'm trying to say.
04:21:29
I mean, if it is a private sector thing, let it be a private sector thing.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:21:32
But it isn't a private, I mean, and I understand.
04:21:34
The problem we're all living with is that PPTAs in many ways have been miscommunicated to the public and to
04:21:50
There is no PPTA that has been built, successful PPTA, where there hasn't been some public involvement.
04:22:03
However, when money was cheap five, six, seven years ago,
04:22:09
Everyone was running around saying we could end up doing all types of things.
04:22:13
We could send, you know, we could build roads, we could add transit, we could do all these things and it won't cost the public sector a penny.
04:22:21
Now that we've cleared the dust and those people are all bankrupt or in jail someplace, we now see that on average for every, you know, every successful P3 involves public involvement,
04:22:39
Generally around 25%, so for every dollar the public puts in, the private sector with whether equity, private activity bonds, or through tolls, pay all back, put in about the other $3 worth.
04:22:57
Let's get it back to reality.
04:22:59
That is reality.
04:23:00
That's why when we put this package together for the first time, trying to do something we, you know,
04:23:07
had not done previously, and that is set a pot of money over because no P3 is free.
04:23:16
Maybe we'll get a tattoo, P3s aren't free.
04:23:21
And I think we'll say it three times real fast.
04:23:25
But we can't figure out what that 25% is until we figure out exactly what project is really able to go forward.
04:23:33
Mr. Gerson.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:23:34
Mr. Chairman, do we have any degree of confidence that given the uncertainty that we're dealing with here that the three originators are willing to go forward?
04:23:47
Because I wouldn't want to be here supporting the recommendations of the task force and then find out
04:23:53
All three of them have backed off.
04:23:54
Then where are we?
04:23:56
That's the confidence factor I think I'm looking for.
04:23:58
Is there a degree of confidence in that kind of commitment?
04:24:04
Because we're wasting time if all three say, hey, without a little bit more known, we're out of here.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:24:12
Mr. Chairman.
F. Gary Garczynski
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:24:13
Yes, Mr. Bowie.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:24:14
Some awfully wise remarks from all sides of this issue.
04:24:18
Is it not time to put this on the action agenda and take a vote on it?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:24:23
It is for this afternoon.
04:24:26
It's already actually in the agenda.
04:24:29
Again, this is a recommendation that will go to the commissioner.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:24:34
Well, we're still in the work session.
SPEAKER_09
04:24:40
One comment we haven't mentioned is that the NCI is saying exactly what you're saying.
04:24:49
So there is something to call about for competition in a bid process.
04:24:52
And we don't think we have any guarantee that any of these guys will go for it or not go for it.
04:24:58
But like I said, none of them in their present form gave us what we needed.
04:25:04
I think is the answer to that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:06
So the issue is let's go to the next step and let's get it to where we actually can have something that we can make a decision.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Chief Deputy Commissioner
04:25:16
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:17
Thank you.
04:25:18
Okay.
04:25:21
Any other questions, issues?
04:25:25
All right, we'll get right to, do you want to take up meds break or no?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:30
We'll talk finance committee.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:32
Excellent, excellent.
04:25:33
I was hoping that we might be delayed, but all right.
04:25:36
At this point, we'll close out the work session.
04:25:38
Go right.