Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 12/8/2010
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   12/8/2010

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Bids.pdf
  • Roanoke Valley Area Metropolitan Planning Organization.pdf
  • Charlottesville-Albemarle Metropolitan Planning Organization.pdf
  • Transportation Enhancement Program overview and proposed policy changes.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2011 budget _ actual performance through October 2010.pdf
  • Governor’s Multimodal Strategic Plan.pdf
  • Updated PPTA program implementation manual and guidelines overview.pdf
  • 1. Roanoke Valley MPO

  • 2. Charlottesville-Albermarle MPO TBD, Executive Director

  • 3. Transportation Enhancement Policy Update

  • 4. State Noise Abatement Policy Update

    • State noise abatement policy update.pdf
  • 5. Finance Presentation

  • 6. CMAQ/STP Presentation

    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Welcome you to this session of this meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:06
      Obviously, we're in a somewhat different environment than we normally meet, but it's outstanding to be up here in Roanoke today and appreciate all the board members coming up here as well as all those in attendance.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:19
      I'm going to ask everyone, do we have an American flag?
    • 00:00:22
      Well, we'll just go and fake it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:24
      I'm going to ask everyone to please stand.
    • 00:00:26
      We'd like to always start the meetings with the Pledge of Allegiance.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:30
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:47
      Thank you all very much.
    • 00:00:49
      At this point, we're going to go right into our agenda.
    • 00:00:52
      We actually have a fairly busy agenda before the start of the actual transportation conference.
    • 00:00:57
      I'm going to ask first, we have
    • 00:00:59
      Our ongoing series of briefings from the various metropolitan planning organizations and PDCs as well as transit continuing today.
    • 00:01:07
      And so today we're going to have Rono Falle, MPO, with Dr. David Trinkle, the chairman, Wayne Strickland, executive director, and Mark McCaskill, senior planner here to do the presentation.
    • 00:01:22
      Gentlemen?
    • 00:01:24
      Anyone have them?
    • 00:01:25
      Are you saying they're the ones who are the locals and they're linked?
    • 00:01:28
      They can't complain about traffic.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:30
      Okay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:33
      How about the folks from Charlottesville?
    • 00:01:35
      Are they here?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:38
      Excellent.
    • 00:01:38
      All right.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:39
      You're now number one.
    • 00:01:40
      Congratulations.
    • 00:01:43
      We'll go to the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO and Stephen Williams, the Executive Director.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:01:50
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:01:51
      Good morning, members of the board.
    • 00:01:53
      My name is Stephen Williams.
    • 00:01:54
      I'm the Executive Director of the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO.
    • 00:01:58
      I'd like to introduce to you this morning some members of the MPO Policy Board that are here with us.
    • 00:02:04
      Would you gentlemen mind standing so I can introduce you?
    • 00:02:08
      On the aisle we have Satrinja Huja who represents the Charlottesville City Council.
    • 00:02:15
      Next to him Dennis Rooker of the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors and Rodney Thomas also of the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors.
    • 00:02:23
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:02:24
      I wanted to talk to you this morning.
    • 00:02:27
      about the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO, about our, give you some background information on the MPO, introduce you to our major projects, and focus on the direction that we're taking in trying to meet the transportation needs of the Charlottesville Albemarle region.
    • 00:02:46
      Just some background information, you can see on the map the location of the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO,
    • 00:02:53
      The gray area is the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission of which the MPO is a part.
    • 00:03:00
      The orange is the actual MPO.
    • 00:03:03
      We estimate the population of the MPO at this point to be about 117,000 people and we have just short of 70,000 people employed in the MPO area.
    • 00:03:12
      We're expecting the population of the MPO to grow to 160,000 by 2035 and our employment in the area to increase to 101,000.
    • 00:03:23
      Some of our major transportation priorities are improvements on U.S. 29, what we call U.S. 29 North in the region.
    • 00:03:33
      That would be the portion of U.S. 29 North of the U.S. 250 Bypass.
    • 00:03:40
      We also have proposals for several projects that parallel U.S. 29 and we hope will help relieve local traffic on U.S. 29, including what we call Burkhart Drive extended.
    • 00:03:52
      and also the Hillsdale Drive which is not in that list but I'm going to be talking about in a few minutes.
    • 00:04:02
      We have prioritized some improvements on U.S. or excuse me Interstate 64 at several interchanges within the region, improvements on U.S. 250 east of Charlottesville in what we call the Pantops area.
    • 00:04:18
      and also some improvements to our transit system through the establishment of a regional transit authority, some improvements to bike and pedestrian facilities, some transportation demand management measures and intelligent transportation system measures and some other roadway improvements within the region and the replacement of a major bridge in Charlottesville.
    • 00:04:43
      The goal of the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO
    • 00:04:47
      is we want to have a transportation system that provides safe, sustainable and efficient and attractive multimodal transportation choices that support the movement of people and goods and services and protect the environment, our communities and quality of life while addressing both regional and statewide transportation needs.
    • 00:05:07
      The strategy that we have adopted at the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO is what we refer to as a transportation demand management strategy.
    • 00:05:17
      We recognize that there are severe funding limitations that are facing both the state of Virginia and our local governments.
    • 00:05:26
      And that in this limited funding environment that we have to figure out ways to meet our transportation needs in the most efficient way we possibly can.
    • 00:05:37
      And so in our transportation demand management strategy, we're really focusing on three approaches to dealing with the transportation needs of our region.
    • 00:05:47
      The first one is strategic investment in new construction to provide increases in capacity and to improve safety using both public and private resources.
    • 00:05:58
      The second is to work on the land use side of the transportation land use equation to try to reduce the demand for transportation facilities in our region through land use transportation coordination and various transportation demand management measures.
    • 00:06:17
      And finally, we are also trying to increase the role of transit, bike, and pedestrian modes in our region to relieve the need for new cars on our crowded roadway systems.
    • 00:06:30
      In terms of strategic investments, I want to talk about several examples.
    • 00:06:34
      The first one is in the area of Hydraulic Road US 29 and US 250.
    • 00:06:43
      We have, I think, a very innovative program underway at this location to add some lanes.
    • 00:06:50
      What's innovative about this program is the funding approach that we are taking here.
    • 00:06:54
      We have, going into the improvements that I'm going to be showing you in a moment, contributions coming in from City of Charlottesville, Albemarle County, a private developer from state sources and from the federal government to try to bring together sufficient funds and other resources
    • 00:07:13
      to fix what is the largest existing bottleneck on US 29 in the region.
    • 00:07:19
      What's most interesting about this project is that a developer is funding some lane additions on US 29 and hydraulic and also that developer, although the development that he is doing is in Albemarle County, has committed a million dollars on a proper towards improvements that are going to take place
    • 00:07:39
      within the city of Charlottesville.
    • 00:07:41
      And this is one of the only cases we know of where proffers from a development in one jurisdiction are being used to make improvements in another jurisdiction.
    • 00:07:51
      The total cost of all these lane improvements are going to be about $5.2 million.
    • 00:07:56
      And on the right-hand side of the slide, you can see the contributions that are being made from all the different sources, the city of Charlottesville, the developers' proffer,
    • 00:08:06
      revenue sharing, state contribution, and a federal earmark that we are receiving for design of the project.
    • 00:08:16
      This is the actual layout of the project.
    • 00:08:18
      There are actually five improvements that are going to be taking place here, starting from the north or the top of the map that you can see.
    • 00:08:26
      The purple on the map there is an addition of a lane.
    • 00:08:34
      A continuous right turn lane on US 29 north of Hydraulic Road.
    • 00:08:40
      The orange that follows Hydraulic Road going off to the northwest is an additional lane to allow traffic to merge onto Hydraulic from US 29.
    • 00:08:51
      The red or fuchsia that goes from Hydraulic Road down towards the interchange you can see at the bottom is the addition of a continuous turn lane on US 29 from Hydraulic Road down to US 250.
    • 00:09:03
      At the very bottom of the slide, at the interchange, you can see a light blue segment, which is a two-lane ramp from US 29 southbound to US 250 westbound.
    • 00:09:16
      For any of you that have ever driven through there, I'm sure you know that the ramp that exists there is one lane, and due to the geometrics, is very constrained.
    • 00:09:25
      And then finally, in the green, going off the map to the west,
    • 00:09:29
      You can see an additional merge lane on US 250 westbound.
    • 00:09:32
      This is a major safety concern because there has been a merge conflict between traffic coming on from 29 and the traffic that's going through on US 250.
    • 00:09:43
      One of the other strategic investments that we're working on in the region is the Hillsdale Drive.
    • 00:09:49
      Hillsdale Drive is a roadway that will parallel US 29 immediately north of the 250 bypass and hydraulic road.
    • 00:09:58
      It will connect from Hydraulic Road all the way up to Greenbrier Drive and beyond.
    • 00:10:06
      The total construction cost that's expected for the project is about $9.3 million, of which the first phase is actually done.
    • 00:10:15
      And you can see the first phase in blue on the right-hand side of the diagram at the bottom.
    • 00:10:20
      Utilities are going to cost about half a million dollars.
    • 00:10:23
      There's $15.5 million of right-of-way cost on this project.
    • 00:10:27
      But the right-of-way is being donated for this project.
    • 00:10:31
      And so that really helps to move the project forward.
    • 00:10:36
      Total cost is about $25.3 million.
    • 00:10:39
      But as I said, about $15 million of that is donated right-of-way.
    • 00:10:43
      And again, revenue sharing is a very important part of this project and is one of the things that has allowed City of Charlottesville to move forward with this project.
    • 00:10:53
      Phase one, which is shown in the light blue, has been completed.
    • 00:10:56
      and is actually open now.
    • 00:10:59
      Phase two is in the design phase and the first public hearing on that project was held here in mid-November.
    • 00:11:07
      The third example of strategic investments that we're making in the region are a series of linked improvements that connect downtown Charlottesville with the northwest part of the region at Rile Road.
    • 00:11:21
      And there are really three projects here.
    • 00:11:23
      The first one is a new interchange on the US 250 bypass and McIntyre Road.
    • 00:11:31
      McIntyre Road is the main access point to downtown.
    • 00:11:35
      And this interchange will allow traffic to flow much more smoothly through this area at the peak hour where it is currently very congested.
    • 00:11:44
      Total cost on this interchange is expected to be about $33.4 million.
    • 00:11:49
      with the great majority of that money coming from either local sources or a federal earmark and we're estimating the construction is going to start on this project in the summer of 2011.
    • 00:12:02
      Moving north from that location, we are proposing or we are going to extend McIntyre Road, that access to the downtown through McIntyre Park at a cost of about $9.8 million with
    • 00:12:18
      Most of that money coming from state sources and some local sources.
    • 00:12:23
      Again, we're proposing to start that in the summer of 2011.
    • 00:12:26
      Finally, the Meadow Creek Parkway, which is mostly completed and was actually used for about five or six weeks here in the fall as a bypass as part of the construction project.
    • 00:12:41
      It has been closed now for the finishing touches to be put to it, and it's expected that it will be completed in October of next year.
    • 00:12:50
      As I mentioned earlier, we're also working on land use transportation coordination.
    • 00:12:55
      As we see it, our transportation systems are the supply, but land use is really the demand that creates the need for our transportation systems.
    • 00:13:08
      Both City of Charlottesville and Albemarle County
    • 00:13:10
      have been very proactive in working in their comprehensive planning processes and their site development processes to change the way they're approaching that to improve coordination between transportation and land use.
    • 00:13:24
      One of the major projects that has been taking place in the region for about five years to improve land use transportation coordination is Places 29.
    • 00:13:33
      Places 29 is the master plan.
    • 00:13:36
      for areas along US 29 corridor north in Albemarle County.
    • 00:13:41
      The transportation element of the Places 29 plan was funded and developed through a cooperative effort with Virginia Department of Transportation as well as the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO.
    • 00:13:55
      The challenges that are being addressed in the Places 29 transportation planning process are to balance competing state, regional, and local traffic
    • 00:14:05
      on US 29 and also to address the backlog of needed roadway improvements that are required on US 29 whether or not the Places 29 plan is ever adopted.
    • 00:14:20
      The concepts and strategies that are the focus of Places 29 are to address transportation needs and we're doing that or Albemarle County is doing that by encouraging a pattern or form of development
    • 00:14:33
      that lessens the need for vehicular travel and also by implementing a robust multimodal transportation system by enhancing transit and improving bike and sidewalk facilities in the area.
    • 00:14:49
      The approach is to create parallel and perpendicular street system as is shown in the graphic at the bottom to better distribute local traffic and improve access, hopefully taking pressure
    • 00:15:03
      off of US 29 and allowing land use development to take place without creating additional local trips on 29.
    • 00:15:13
      There's also a plan in place to manage and plan for access and traffic flow in the 29 corridor and strategic improvements to US 29 that both maintain traffic volume and flow and also serve both regional and local needs.
    • 00:15:31
      We're also working at expanding transit in the Charlottesville region.
    • 00:15:36
      Although I don't think it's widely recognized, Charlottesville has an extremely high level of transit use.
    • 00:15:43
      Charlottesville area transit, the city of Charlottesville's transit provider that also serves some areas of Albemarle County, provided about 2.2 million transit rides during the course of fiscal year 10.
    • 00:15:56
      Our university transit system, which serves the University of Virginia and also coordinates with our other transit providers, served about 3 million riders during the course of the last school year.
    • 00:16:09
      And our rural and paratransit provider, Jaunt, served about 304,000 transit riders last year.
    • 00:16:18
      That's about 5.5 million transit rides in an urbanized area of about 117,000 people.
    • 00:16:25
      That is about the fifth highest transit ride per capita level in the entire country.
    • 00:16:33
      We also have Amtrak rail service.
    • 00:16:37
      You're probably aware, I know Thelma Drake is very aware of the Lynchburg train.
    • 00:16:42
      About almost 42% of the riders of the Lynchburg train
    • 00:16:47
      boarded or debarked at the Charlottesville station.
    • 00:16:50
      Charlottesville is the fifth highest station in the Amtrak system here in Virginia and about 94,500 riders boarded or debarked at Charlottesville during the course of fiscal year 10.
    • 00:17:05
      One of the things that we're trying to do to expand transit in the Charlottesville region is to establish a regional transit authority.
    • 00:17:13
      Our purpose for the formation of the Regional Transit Authority is to promote the development of truly regional transit systems and to provide travelers with an attractive alternative to driving on increasingly congested roadways in the Charlottesville Albemarle area.
    • 00:17:30
      We intend to do that by breaking down jurisdictional barriers that will allow transit service to spread throughout the Charlottesville Albemarle area based on need rather than based on
    • 00:17:41
      the jurisdiction that happens to be operating the transit system.
    • 00:17:46
      The thing that we need moving forward with the Regional Transit Authority project is we need enabling legislation for a local option tax that can be dedicated to establishing and operating that Regional Transit Authority.
    • 00:18:01
      One of the other things that we're working on in the region that the members of the MPO Policy Board are very excited about
    • 00:18:09
      is the University of Virginia Transportation Demand Management Plan.
    • 00:18:14
      University of Virginia is one of the largest employers in the state of Virginia and the grounds and associated facilities have a daytime population of about 40,000 people.
    • 00:18:26
      The travel to the grounds by faculty and staff in particular is one of our largest transportation issues and creates
    • 00:18:36
      Many of our largest transportation needs.
    • 00:18:39
      The goal of the University of Virginia TDM program is to improve multimodal transportation systems to offset demand for additional parking, road enlargements to allow us to preserve historic elements and maximize land use efficiency and economic investments.
    • 00:18:58
      In partnership with the city and county,
    • 00:19:01
      The University of Virginia is trying to reduce the environmental impact associated with university-related transportation, including both emissions and congestion.
    • 00:19:12
      And this illustrates the direction that we hope will achieve or the results that will be achieved through the implementation of the University of Virginia Transportation Demand Management Plan.
    • 00:19:24
      Right now, today, at the beginning of the process for implementing the TDM plan,
    • 00:19:30
      About 78.1% of faculty and staff members, about 10,700 folks drove alone to UVA on a daily basis.
    • 00:19:41
      Only about 10% or about 1,350 people carpooled.
    • 00:19:45
      And about just short of 12% used other modes to get to the university.
    • 00:19:52
      By 2015, through the implementation of the
    • 00:19:57
      TDM Plan.
    • 00:19:58
      The university is hoping to reduce the percentage that drive alone to about 70% while increasing carpooling to almost 18% and keeping the other modes the same.
    • 00:20:12
      And by 2020, reducing the drive alone percentage down to 64% and the carpool percentage up to 24%.
    • 00:20:21
      This shows some of the projects that are going to be implemented by University of Virginia in the next 10 years to help achieve the ambitious goals of the TDM plan.
    • 00:20:36
      Several of these have already taken place.
    • 00:20:38
      The University Transit System and Charlottesville Area Transit System already have a fair reciprocity program in place so that any faculty, staff, or student from the university
    • 00:20:50
      is able to simply show an ID card and ride the Charlottesville area transit system anywhere in the region that they want to go.
    • 00:20:57
      There's also an occasional parking program that encourages folks to carpool.
    • 00:21:04
      There's a guaranteed ride home program, again, to allow folks to carpool and not worry about not having a ride home.
    • 00:21:13
      There is carpool for preferred parking and also a Zipcar program
    • 00:21:18
      has been started at the university.
    • 00:21:21
      Moving forward from this point, the university is going to be hiring a transportation coordinator who will work across the university to improve transportation coordination.
    • 00:21:32
      The university is also working hard at encouraging carpooling and is starting a program to bring potential carpoolers together.
    • 00:21:42
      There is a flexible work schedule policy that is being implemented
    • 00:21:46
      There's also a commuter survey that is going to be done to help identify where folks are commuting and help identify the types of things that would help encourage them to get into carpools rather than driving alone.
    • 00:22:02
      There's going to be a marketing budget set aside for this purpose in 2012, some parking permit price increases to help encourage folks to find other ways to get to the university.
    • 00:22:14
      In 2013, there's a proposal for a 50% carpool subsidy and finally for some in-house carpool matching.
    • 00:22:24
      Some conclusions, some things that we would really like you to take away from this presentation today.
    • 00:22:30
      The first is that at the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO, we're working very hard at meeting the transportation needs of our region in the most cost-effective manner possible.
    • 00:22:41
      We're well aware that there is not money out there
    • 00:22:44
      to build new capacity or to develop major expansions of our transportation systems.
    • 00:22:52
      And so we're trying to use the systems that we have in the most effective manner possible and use local, state, and federal funds in the most efficient manner possible.
    • 00:23:04
      We believe that the revenue sharing program has been a very important program
    • 00:23:10
      For the Charlottesville-Albamore area, it has enabled us to move forward with key transportation improvements in some very difficult times.
    • 00:23:19
      One of the things that we need is legislation that will allow localities and regions to expand funding options that would help us meet our needs.
    • 00:23:28
      We know that you're not members of the legislature, but we hope that there might be some way that you could influence the members of the legislature to move in that direction.
    • 00:23:39
      We believe that only with adequate revenue and the approaches outlined in this presentation can we meet our transportation needs and deal with our share of the state's transportation needs.
    • 00:23:51
      So that concludes my presentation this morning.
    • 00:23:54
      I certainly appreciate your attention and I would be happy to attempt to answer any questions that the members of the board might have.
    • 00:24:00
      Mr. Williams, thank you very much.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:02
      Thanks for the presentation and thank you for being here.
    • 00:24:05
      Are there any questions?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:24:06
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:07
      I think we know what he's going to ask you, by the way.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:12
      I'm Mark from the Lynchburg District, and I think you're aware we are very interested in your 29 bypass.
    • 00:24:21
      Am I correct that what we've referred to over the past 20, 30 years as the western bypass of Charlottesville
    • 00:24:29
      It hasn't been removed from the plan.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:24:46
      The right-of-way is still in the plan.
    • 00:24:49
      Our focus for the 29 corridor is maximizing the movement of traffic in the existing corridor.
    • 00:24:57
      And so our policy is to maximize the existing corridor.
    • 00:25:00
      We think that's the most cost-efficient way to deal with the whole issue.
    • 00:25:06
      And then once the existing corridor and parallel roads have been maximized, then we move on and look at the bypass as a next alternative.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:16
      Are you looking at the western bypass?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:25:19
      That is the one that is addressed in our policies and plans at this point.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:25
      And then it's my understanding that about
    • 00:25:28
      More than a year ago, at some point last year, there was a study done by VDOT to look at the bypasses for Charlottesville, and one included the western bypass, and then one included an eastern bypass that would go through parts of Orange County and various other areas.
    • 00:25:45
      Are you familiar with that?
    • 00:25:47
      Conception, I'm familiar with the concept, yes.
    • 00:25:50
      The Charlottesville, and then that was going to be presented to the board back in December of last year, and then both of those bypasses were removed.
    • 00:25:58
      Did the Charlottesville MPO weigh in on that and request that they be removed?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:26:02
      The Charlottesville MPO did not take a position on any of the projects on 29.
    • 00:26:09
      As far as I know, Albemarle County took a position on the eastern bypass, as did Louisa County in our region.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:26:17
      And they both objected?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:26:19
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:22
      Thank you.
    • 00:26:22
      Ms. Lane, did you?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:24
      No.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:25
      Yes, Dr. Davis.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:26
      Yes, I'm curious if you would characterize the work that you described to us as being balanced or perhaps skewed more in favor of local needs than state transportation quarter significance.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:26:44
      No, I think it is a balanced strategy.
    • 00:26:48
      What we recognize is that as a small MPO working with local governments, what we primarily have access to is funds related to the local systems.
    • 00:27:03
      However, we would very enthusiastically support investment by the state of Virginia in capacity improvements in the major corridors of statewide significance in the region, which are Interstate 64.
    • 00:27:17
      and US 29.
    • 00:27:18
      I think we would want to work with the Virginia Department of Transportation and this board to evaluate the investment strategies related to US 29.
    • 00:27:32
      As I mentioned a moment ago, we believe that there are a number of things that can be done in the US 29 existing corridor to help meet the transportation needs.
    • 00:27:43
      We think that the
    • 00:27:45
      projects or the ideas we have for the 29 corridor would serve both state and local transportation needs better than a bypass and also be less expensive.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:59
      Mr. Rich.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:00
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:28:01
      Thank you all for being here from Charlottesville and Albemarle.
    • 00:28:06
      What percentage of traffic on 29 in your area is local?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:28:11
      The most recent origin and destination studies have estimated that at least 85% of the traffic on 29 in the Charlottesville Albemarle region is local traffic, that there's only between 7,000 and 9,000 through trips that actually proceed from north to south through the Charlottesville region on a daily basis, as opposed to 65,000 to 70,000
    • 00:28:40
      Local Trips that are on the corridor.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:48
      The design we hope will start next year.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:29:03
      As I mentioned in my presentation, we believe that we're going to be receiving an earmark
    • 00:29:10
      that will help pay for the design process and allow us to start immediately.
    • 00:29:15
      The earmark is in the transportation authorization that has gone to the U.S. Senate for approval and we've been told that in all likelihood that that will move forward.
    • 00:29:28
      Once... Who told you that?
    • 00:29:30
      Who told you that one?
    • 00:29:33
      Our senators.
    • 00:29:34
      What we've been told is that the way the... generally the way the earmark process works
    • 00:29:38
      is that if you get through the House side of the budget appropriation process that the Senate side usually moves forward with relatively little problem and we understand that that is proposed to move forward.
    • 00:29:54
      before the end of this session.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:56
      I would suggest that these are unusual times, and that's not the process the Congress is going through right now.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:04
      Are we talking about appropriations or authorization?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:06
      Authorization bill.
    • 00:30:08
      What you're talking about is transportation authorization bill?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:30:10
      No, what I'm talking about is the actual appropriation, the budget appropriation.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:14
      They're looking at a continuing resolution, in fact, being floated without earmarks.
    • 00:30:21
      I wouldn't count on the revenue.
    • 00:30:22
      They may show up.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:23
      That's right, and that is where the right of way is going to be coming from.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:30:48
      I don't think any of the City of Charlottesville staff members are here this morning that have the specific information on the proffers.
    • 00:30:57
      I'm sorry, but I can get that to you.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:59
      But you're totally contingent upon getting the proffers, obviously, right?
    • 00:31:03
      Because of the cost there.
    • 00:31:04
      That's right.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:31:05
      That right-of-way is the major cost on the project.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:08
      Can you let me know about that?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:31:10
      I'd be happy to, sure.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:11
      One of the things that also I think will improve things is the Meadow Creek Parkway.
    • 00:31:16
      And as I see it, the county has completely finished their job.
    • 00:31:20
      And I've driven down there.
    • 00:31:22
      It's a great parkway.
    • 00:31:25
      It's a good transportation facility.
    • 00:31:27
      And it also is context-sensitive and fits into your beautiful area.
    • 00:31:32
      I don't think the city is dragging their feet at all.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:31:40
      They are in the process of finishing up the environmental and the permitting process.
    • 00:31:45
      The cultural and historic resources study that was required has just been completed and accepted by the city and so they are now in a process where they can move forward with
    • 00:31:59
      They are still waiting, I understand, for the 404 core permit, and then they'll be in a position where they can move forward with the bid that they have for McIntyre Road extended.
    • 00:32:10
      They're also completing the environmental process for the interchange and are preparing to move into the design processes for that project.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:20
      So there's no roadblock coming from the city at all, as you can see?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:32:24
      Not as I understand it, no.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:26
      Would you give me a prize to find?
    • 00:32:28
      I'd be happy to.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:32:35
      There was an agreement that it wouldn't be opened for permanent use until such time as the entire suite of three projects were completed.
    • 00:32:45
      It was opened the short term when you were able to use it to facilitate part of the construction project and it's since been closed again.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:54
      Would you please tell the city that I'm extremely interested in having this thing work?
    • 00:32:59
      Can you give me an update on this?
    • 00:33:01
      I'd be happy to.
    • 00:33:04
      Also, I want to commend you all on trying to work with land use and transportation.
    • 00:33:09
      Our 29 task force looked at that and said, really, that's the number one priority, to try to keep all of these cuts and all of these traffic signals coming in.
    • 00:33:19
      And I noticed, you know, north of town into Greene County, we're having one signal after the other.
    • 00:33:24
      and we don't have the money to bypass the whole 29 so I hope you all will really be serious about that and see if we can't do something about all these cuts.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:33:35
      I believe there's a high level of commitment on the part of both the elected officials and staff at Albemarle County to deal with access management issues.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:45
      One of the major motivations for the Regional Transit Authority project that I described in my presentation
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:34:12
      was to improve coordination across all the transit systems, allow the transit system to expand into the 29 corridor and certainly the increased coordination between University Transit System and Charlottesville Area Transit is an important part of that.
    • 00:34:31
      The University ridership is the fastest growing segment of the CAT system ridership
    • 00:34:38
      and we think increased coordination and use of that system by the university is definitely one of the best things we can do in the region.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:34:47
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:34:51
      Question, Mr. Raznick, I believe, was a consultant on the 29 study for the board last year and there's supposed to be a continuation of investigation and bypass
    • 00:35:04
      by, I'll call it a committee of local officials on the two members of the CTB.
    • 00:35:12
      Is that still in play?
    • 00:35:13
      Is that going to happen?
    • 00:35:14
      I think that was the recommendation that came out of the study suggested, 129 last year.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:21
      Yeah, in fact, Mr. Khoury was involved with that and I think we had to... Is that still going to happen then?
    • 00:35:31
      I think, well, yeah, I mean, what's the status of that?
    • 00:35:35
      Because obviously Mr. Koelemay is not here.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:35:37
      So I, you know, Mr. Chairman, I know that Mr. Koelemay had asked me to participate on behalf of, as an urban at large, and I think the two of us were going to mind show that.
    • 00:35:52
      And I just want to know what's going to happen.
    • 00:35:54
      I mean, that's my basic question.
    • 00:35:57
      Yes.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:58
      I think what we have is that we finished up our meetings with the subcommittee and Mr. Raznick sent out that draft of the report which I thought Mr. Koelemay was going to present to the CTB for adoption today.
    • 00:36:14
      Yes.
    • 00:36:14
      And so we're going to adopt that draft that we reviewed.
    • 00:36:17
      That's the recommendation.
    • 00:36:18
      That's the recommendation to begin that process again.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:23
      But Mr. Koelemay obviously isn't here so we're going to probably do it in January.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:36:28
      I just didn't know if it was an exercise in futility.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:32
      Well, that's been my...
    • 00:36:33
      Excuse me.
    • 00:36:34
      Yes, it is.
    • 00:36:35
      And it has been in dealing with the Charlottesville album model.
    • 00:36:39
      Folks, they have fought at every step to proceed with the bypass.
    • 00:36:44
      That's a different issue, not for Mr. Williams.
    • 00:36:46
      So we're going to take this up in January, Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:48
      Yes, we are.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:49
      Okay.
    • 00:36:50
      Thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:50
      At least looking at the recommendations of this report.
    • 00:36:53
      Mr. Lane.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:54
      By the way, Mr. Chairman, I have higher hopes for this area.
    • 00:36:57
      This is the area where Thomas Jefferson came from.
    • 00:37:00
      There's enlightenment that's all around, so I have hope that we'll come up with something.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:07
      Thank you, Mr. Rich.
    • 00:37:08
      Are you drinking coffee over there?
    • 00:37:12
      Mr. Layne.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:37:13
      This is just a general follow-up to a lot of the questions that have been had.
    • 00:37:16
      You mentioned that there was going to be, you had some ideas how to make it a better thoroughfare.
    • 00:37:22
      Can you expand on that?
    • 00:37:23
      Because all I see is continued development
    • 00:37:25
      And so what are the ideas you have to make it a better thoroughfare without the bypass?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:37:30
      Well, there are several things that we're looking at.
    • 00:37:33
      Certainly, one of the greatest needs is in the area of the 250-29 interchange and also hydraulic road.
    • 00:37:43
      This is, as I mentioned, the biggest area of congestion at this point.
    • 00:37:47
      The lane additions project that you heard me describe this morning,
    • 00:37:53
      will help us deal with the immediate needs but probably only gives us additional capacity to deal with five to ten years worth of growth and traffic.
    • 00:38:03
      What we're hoping to do is implement that short-term project and then we would love it if the state would commit sufficient funds to do the specific study to identify the future build-out design for the interchange at 29 and 250.
    • 00:38:22
      and also at Hydraulic Road.
    • 00:38:26
      North of that point, the roadway, although there are a number of signals, actually flows pretty well and provides a reasonable level of service at this point.
    • 00:38:37
      And so the next priority that we see is actually at what we call the north end of the corridor, north of the south fork of the Ravenna River, where the roadway necks down from an eight-lane cross section down to a four-lane cross section.
    • 00:38:53
      This is resulting in a level of service F in that area and it also includes a number of safety issues and so we think that should also be a priority is looking at the way to improve that section to at least a six-lane cross section with improvements to the intersections and also to the grades.
    • 00:39:16
      Once those two projects are completed, we believe that then would be the time to address the center section of the corridor from Hydraulic Road up to the South Fork at the Ravana.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:31
      I actually have a couple of questions.
    • 00:39:33
      First is the, you had the one slide that showed the several different transit providers.
    • 00:39:39
      Can people use, can somebody on your one system
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:39:43
      Yes, there are direct transfers between all of the three transit systems.
    • 00:39:53
      There are contracts between the three providing for ridership across the systems.
    • 00:39:59
      And in many locations, particularly in the university area and the surrounding parts of Charlottesville, they actually share bus stops.
    • 00:40:08
      And so you can
    • 00:40:09
      Debark one bus and then wait and board, you know, debark from CAT and get back on to University Transit System as an example.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:19
      But can people have, let's say, a uni pass that allows them to go from one to the other or no?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:40:24
      For the university students and faculty and staff members, they can do that without any kind of limitation at all.
    • 00:40:33
      Frankly, the members of the public I don't think are supposed to ride the university transit system, but nobody stops you when you get on.
    • 00:40:42
      I ride it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:45
      Can I ask you, so this issue about establishing your transportation commission, so have you gotten a sponsor?
    • 00:40:53
      I'm sorry.
    • 00:40:55
      Is legislation specifically needed for you to create one or is there just overall?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:41:00
      For the regional transit authority?
    • 00:41:02
      We sought legislation during the 2009 session and the authority was granted to form the Regional Transit Authority.
    • 00:41:16
      What was not granted was the authority for some sort of revenue enhancement, local option sales tax or some other measure like that.
    • 00:41:27
      And so that is the specific legislative need we have at this point.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:32
      So I'm sorry, I guess I just have more question for, I don't know if the lawyers are here.
    • 00:41:37
      I mean obviously up in Northern Virginia we have the transportation commissions and they pass the, is it the 2 cents, 2% gas tax which goes to paying for things like VRE and commuter, Boston Rail, and then also to a certain extent Metro.
    • 00:41:57
      That's not standing authority, I guess,
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:42:01
      Such is my understanding, and also what I understand is that the specific approach that we tried to use the last time was one that had been used by other areas of the state and was subsequently struck down by the state Supreme Court.
    • 00:42:25
      And so there's probably really two needs here.
    • 00:42:27
      One is to identify
    • 00:42:30
      An approach that passes muster with the Supreme Court and then the second is actually to get the legislation passed.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:39
      And I'm sorry, you had a list of projects at the very beginning of your presentation.
    • 00:42:45
      So as you went in, you started providing a little bit more insight on a couple of projects.
    • 00:42:50
      But does that list, though, have how much you're asking from the state in each one of them?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:42:58
      There were costs on those.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:01
      Yeah, it was for a few of the highlights, but not all that entire list.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:43:05
      Yeah.
    • 00:43:07
      Yeah.
    • 00:43:07
      The Interstate 64 interchanges improvements were about $64 million.
    • 00:43:13
      The improvements to US 29 North was about $53 million.
    • 00:43:21
      A parallel roadway
    • 00:43:23
      that we call Berkmar Drive extended that would significantly decrease local traffic on 29 North of the South Fork of the River would be about $45 million.
    • 00:43:33
      And then you heard my presentation on Hillsdale, which was also one of the major roadway improvements.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:43
      Okay, excellent.
    • 00:43:43
      Any other questions?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:45
      This is just a hypothetical.
    • 00:43:50
      Let's say all the reasoning came around the issue that maybe a bypass releases on the books now really wouldn't work.
    • 00:44:01
      Could we use funds from the right-of-way acquisitions for other projects like some of the ones that you have...
    • 00:44:09
      Well, I'm certainly not an expert on right-of-way law in Virginia or under the federal law as it pertains in this particular case.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:44:37
      I think
    • 00:44:39
      Certainly, the MPO Policy Board would like to see the investment that's been made used in the most productive fashion possible.
    • 00:44:49
      And if it were possible, I think there would probably be support for that.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:53
      Mr. Chairman, that would probably include helping several of the other districts as well.
    • 00:44:59
      Mr.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:59
      Pink.
    • 00:45:02
      Mr. Rich, under the state
    • 00:45:06
      When we purchased it in condemnation, whatever we did first right away, it's my understanding that we have to offer it back to the landowner at the price that we paid for it.
    • 00:45:21
      So if they sold it 20 years ago for $300,000, it now may be worth $10 million, they get first right of refusal at $300,000.
    • 00:45:31
      So we are not going to get any windfall by selling it right away.
    • 00:45:36
      The landowners would get the windfall.
    • 00:45:40
      So we cannot sell this right away, use that money to buy another right away.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:46
      So it would be a tremendous loss on a tax payer's time.
    • 00:45:49
      Rick will give us some kind of an opinion on that.
    • 00:45:53
      That's the appropriate time.
    • 00:45:54
      Not right now.
    • 00:45:54
      We don't want to call him up right now.
    • 00:45:57
      Is that your understanding?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:58
      All right.
    • 00:45:59
      We have other persons.
    • 00:46:00
      Williams.
    • 00:46:01
      We should have started with you last.
    • 00:46:05
      I'm sorry.
    • 00:46:05
      Appreciate very much you being here today.
    • 00:46:07
      We're going to move on.
    • 00:46:08
      We're going to go back to the first one.
    • 00:46:10
      That was Roanoke Valley MPO, Mr. Strickland, and Mr. Trinkle, and Mr. McGaskill.
    • 00:46:22
      I was joking that you guys got caught in traffic.
    • 00:46:25
      That's right.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 00:46:39
      Good morning.
    • 00:46:41
      Sorry we're late, but I think it's always good to let Charlottesville go first.
    • 00:46:49
      Well again, good morning to the members of the CTB, Mr. Secretary, officials of VDOT, VDRPT.
    • 00:46:56
      On behalf of the Roanoke Valley MPO, I want to welcome you to the Roanoke Valley.
    • 00:47:00
      I'm Chair of the Regional Commission and the MPO and Vice Mayor here of the City of Roanoke.
    • 00:47:06
      We're glad the governor is holding this transportation conference in Roanoke and that you're having your December meeting in conjunction with this conference coming up.
    • 00:47:15
      As you visit our region over the next few days, we hope you'll see all that we have to offer during your stay in the region, including our numerous museums and cultural attractions just across the bridge from this hotel.
    • 00:47:28
      I want to start by saying that our region is truly in a time of transition as we move from a historically industrial-based economy to an economy that has a good diversity of business activities, a new medical college, and a state-of-the-art medical research institute just up the road from our downtown area.
    • 00:47:46
      Our regional transportation goals are also in transition.
    • 00:47:50
      Highway improvements are very important for us to ensure that people and freight move safely and efficiently through the region.
    • 00:47:57
      But we have also more aggressively moved to promote alternative transportation options for our citizens, such as the development of many miles of our greenways and trails, which also are right out of the doorstep of this hotel.
    • 00:48:11
      Another alternative transportation element we are very dedicated to having is passenger rail service returned to the Roanoke Valley.
    • 00:48:19
      Passenger rail would provide an excellent alternative to traveling I-81 and I-66 to Washington DC for business related activities and leisure.
    • 00:48:28
      The importance of rail service is supported by the fact that there are over 60,000 university students within a 60-mile radius of the Roanoke Valley who can take advantage of passenger rail instead of using their individual cars for travel to various areas in the Northeast.
    • 00:48:43
      Passenger rail service will provide safe travel opportunities to places in the Northeast.
    • 00:48:49
      Additionally, our region has a fairly high percentage of citizens over the age of 65, approximately 16%, and these folks could use passenger rail to accommodate their needs to travel to Washington, D.C. and beyond.
    • 00:49:02
      Our desire to look at various transportation modes is part of a larger interest in our community.
    • 00:49:07
      and in our region to pursue green initiatives.
    • 00:49:09
      This is evidenced by the fact that both the city of Roanoke and Roanoke County are participating in the national organization called Local Governments for Sustainability.
    • 00:49:20
      Additionally, I want to note that I'm very proud that our region was one of 45 regions in the country to receive a HUD, USDOT, and EPA Regional Sustainability Communities Grant, which will allow us to embark on a three-year process to develop the first-ever region-wide effort to link transportation, economic development, environmental concerns, and housing issues into one comprehensive plan.
    • 00:49:45
      The Roanoke Valley has a solid reputation in leading our state in many green initiatives which are often modeled by other communities.
    • 00:49:53
      Just as our economy is in transition, our transportation planning is in transition as well.
    • 00:50:00
      Our MPO region is on the cusp of becoming a TMA MPO once the Census 2010 results are official.
    • 00:50:07
      The MPO understands it will have significant responsibilities as a TMA MPO and we look forward to working closely with VDOT
    • 00:50:14
      and VDRPT to help us assume our new responsibilities.
    • 00:50:18
      The transition to TMA status will also be an opportunity for the MTO to strategically consider its future, its skills, its current level of staff and a host of other opportunities and challenges that will no doubt come with this transition.
    • 00:50:31
      I want to thank you for this opportunity to discuss the work of the Roanoke Valley area MPO and we look forward to working with you, VDOT and VDRPT in the future.
    • 00:50:41
      We hope you enjoy your stay in the Roanoke Valley and please come back soon.
    • 00:50:44
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:50:45
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:50:53
      Mr. Secretary, members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board, we're glad to have you in Roanoke.
    • 00:50:56
      As our chairman said, that's the kind of people that would let Charlottesville go first.
    • 00:51:03
      We're pleased to have you here and thank you for coming to Roanoke.
    • 00:51:06
      I wanted to hand out first some briefing notes that show some of the projects that have been funded recently in this area.
    • 00:51:15
      We appreciate your support of these projects and also list our highway, bicycle, pedestrian, freight, rail and other projects.
    • 00:51:26
      We're going to talk more about highways today.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:33
      You'll see on that list a number of highway related projects as I said.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:51:36
      We're going to talk, as the Chairman said, about how our organization in the region is in transition.
    • 00:51:43
      First, we're going to highlight a bit about the service area.
    • 00:51:47
      Page up.
    • 00:52:02
      First, the service here at the Roanoke Valley area NPO, then we're going to talk about some upcoming challenges.
    • 00:52:16
      All of you are aware of the changes in the ozone standards.
    • 00:52:21
      Mark McCaskill, Senior Planner, will talk about the fact that we formed an early action compact a few years ago under EPA's
    • 00:52:30
      Permission, and we were able to control our ground level ozone, but now, as you know, things are changing.
    • 00:52:37
      We'll talk a bit about our TMA status and the possibility of expanding the area for the MPO.
    • 00:52:46
      We're also going to talk about some recent projects we've been involved in and some innovation related activities we've been pursuing lately.
    • 00:52:55
      First, the study area of the MPO is the urbanized area.
    • 00:52:59
      and of course the study boundary, the 2035 study area boundary includes more than just the immediate Roanoke Valley.
    • 00:53:07
      It includes the city of Roanoke, the city of Salem, the town of Benton, portions of Bedford, Botetourt and Roanoke County.
    • 00:53:14
      Now in 2000 when the census was released we were a population in an urbanized area of about 197,000.
    • 00:53:23
      We suspect that after the 2010 census information is released we will be
    • 00:53:28
      over the number needed to be designated as a transportation management area.
    • 00:53:35
      Of course, we understand it's going to bring some changes to our organization and to the work that we do.
    • 00:53:42
      And then, of course, the 2035 study area population is already over 220,000 now.
    • 00:53:51
      I'm going to let Mark go ahead and discuss some of the challenges that we are facing.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:53:58
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary, members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:54:07
      Let me extend the welcome to the Roanoke area and also to further build on this concept of transition.
    • 00:54:17
      And we as an MPO are moving from what the state would
    • 00:54:20
      For decades we would have considered a small MPO and likely over the next several years could move in to have a lot of the same roles and responsibilities that MPOs that are typically much larger, the MPO around the Richmond area or Hampton Roads typically fulfill.
    • 00:54:39
      The first challenge is the ozone challenge and I want to be very clear that I am distinguishing what I am calling a challenge is the traditional non-attainment process, the regulatory process that you're all familiar with where when MPOs are traditionally non-attainment there are different types of air quality conformity processes and planning processes
    • 00:55:04
      that go along with the TIP and the long-range plan.
    • 00:55:08
      That's what I'm calling a challenge.
    • 00:55:11
      I'm distinguishing that from actual improving air quality and cleaner air which has been happening over the last decade here in the Roanoke Valley and will continue to happen regardless of what our traditional non-attainment status turns out to be.
    • 00:55:30
      Early on in the early 2000s when
    • 00:55:33
      The Federal EPA changed the one-hour ozone standard to an eight-hour average standard.
    • 00:55:40
      We were one of those areas that had been in compliance with the one-hour standard, but it looked like we were going to have trouble with the new eight-hour standard.
    • 00:55:49
      And a protocol called the Early Action Plan came out, and we were one of two areas in Virginia that followed that protocol.
    • 00:55:56
      And it was successful.
    • 00:55:57
      That protocol was successful.
    • 00:56:00
      At the end of that, our data was clean and complied with the eight-hour average.
    • 00:56:07
      Then in 2008 and 2009, the eight-hour standard was further reviewed and tightened.
    • 00:56:13
      And at that point, our data was still clean.
    • 00:56:17
      We didn't have to try to pursue another early action plan or anything like that.
    • 00:56:22
      And it wasn't clear that anything like that would have been allowed.
    • 00:56:26
      already complied with the new Titan standards at that point.
    • 00:56:29
      So it was continued success.
    • 00:56:32
      And then the EPA has called that review, the 2008-2009 review, has called that into question and is re-reviewing the standards.
    • 00:56:43
      And the last word we have is that there will be a final decision made by December 31st of this year and that a new standard will be somewhere between 60 parts per billion of ozone
    • 00:56:55
      and 70 parts per billion.
    • 00:57:01
      Just to put this into context, this graph shows you the number of days of eight-hour ozone exceedance refactored for the current 75 part per billion standard.
    • 00:57:14
      So you can see in the late 90s before the one-hour standard changed that we had a lot of trouble with code orange and code red days.
    • 00:57:25
      And then there has been a steady, over the years, steady success into the current time.
    • 00:57:34
      This graph shows you the actual three-year average.
    • 00:57:40
      And that small red line is the 75 parts per billion that we're under.
    • 00:57:45
      So you can see, including this last summer of 2010 for three-year average summers of
    • 00:57:50
      2008, 2009, and 2010.
    • 00:57:54
      We are not only under the 75 parts per billion, we are under the upper end of the 60 to 70 parts per billion range in the high 60s.
    • 00:58:07
      So there is a potential challenge that we face.
    • 00:58:12
      Data shows that if the federal EPA chooses 70 parts per billion, we would already comply with that standard.
    • 00:58:20
      If they choose 65 out of that range, depending on the years they choose, if they choose to allow a few future years for compliance, we may have a fighting chance to actually get air quality below 65 parts per billion.
    • 00:58:36
      If they choose 60 parts per billion, we and probably most places in the United States with a monitor have little chance in actually immediately complying with 60 parts per billion
    • 00:58:48
      and have a difficult chance of complying with that in the future.
    • 00:58:52
      So the challenge is that this MPO may be, may go into the traditional non-attainment process for ozone.
    • 00:59:02
      Another challenge that was already mentioned is our pending TMA status.
    • 00:59:07
      In 2000, we thought that there was a chance that we would become a TMA MPO at that point, but it turned out that the Census Bureau reported our urbanized area was at 197,000.
    • 00:59:21
      Current federal regulations, as has been observed in the previous presentation due to the trends and challenges in Congress, it's unlikely that current federal regulations
    • 00:59:36
      and transportation laws will change the TMA status from 200,000 before Census 2010 is certified.
    • 00:59:45
      So we are very likely when the Census 2010 results are finalized to become a TMA MPO.
    • 00:59:51
      And we'll be looking to you as we go into that process, into that formal TMA process to work with you the way that the MPOs around Richmond, Hampton Roads, Northern Virginia area work with you.
    • 01:00:07
      Another upcoming challenge that may be a possibility are the addition of new localities.
    • 01:00:14
      At the end of the 2000 census, a small portion of Bedford County was added to our MPO due to some contiguous population densities.
    • 01:00:22
      That is a possibility for Franklin County and Montgomery County in our area.
    • 01:00:30
      We do not know yet.
    • 01:00:31
      It may or may not happen, but it is a possibility that very small sections of either Franklin County
    • 01:00:37
      Montgomery County, or both, small sections of possibly less than 1,000 people will be added to our MPO.
    • 01:00:44
      No matter how small the sections of these neighboring localities, if they are added into our MPO, we will have to seek representatives from those localities on our policy board, and we will have that policy board dynamic to work out over the next couple years.
    • 01:01:03
      So in summary of our transitional challenges,
    • 01:01:06
      is that the most challenging scenario would be all three of these things happen within two or three years.
    • 01:01:12
      And we have to accommodate all of them simultaneously.
    • 01:01:16
      Moderately challenging would be any two of the three happen within two or three years.
    • 01:01:23
      To transition from painting a picture of the challenges and transitions we face, we'll transition to focusing on some recent projects of note.
    • 01:01:36
      Now we purposely left out the long-range plan, the TIP, the normal planning processes that all MPOs do to focus on other types of the projects and partnerships with other agencies that we've had recently.
    • 01:01:51
      One is a 419 corridor study that was a joint project with VDOT, the VDOT Salem District here locally, VDOT Central Office, VDOT's on-call consultant, and our staff.
    • 01:02:01
      And it was very successful and well received by the localities.
    • 01:02:06
      Another recent project has been the Roanoke Valley Greenways Master Plan update.
    • 01:02:11
      Recent ongoing projects that our board and stakeholder look to us for are regional bicycle planning.
    • 01:02:18
      Last year, we did a staff report on the bus connector concept for passenger rail that working with some local stakeholders and statewide stakeholders got the concept rolling
    • 01:02:32
      for the larger study that's going on now with the DRPT and their consulting for the bus bridge concept.
    • 01:02:39
      And we've tried to branch out to initial traffic simulation work with Synchro and corridor planning and looking at these different corridors as staff resources allow.
    • 01:02:53
      Give you an example of some of the greenway planning.
    • 01:02:55
      We have been trying as our responsibilities and roles and evolved, we've been trying to move
    • 01:03:03
      From the planning role toward looking towards some of the monitoring and data collection to try to see how planning concepts are actually bearing in the field.
    • 01:03:16
      So with the Greenway Master Plan update, we have been instrumental in the role of establishment of a bicycle advisory committee for this area.
    • 01:03:24
      Implementation tracking, which you'll see in a little bit for the Greenway system.
    • 01:03:30
      encouraging local adoptions of the Regional Greenway Master Plan and also being instrumental in actually deploying and capturing data from trail counters and trail counts so we can continue to monitor usage and come up with information to report to localities about the success of things like greenways.
    • 01:03:55
      Here is the Roanoke Valley Greenway status map.
    • 01:03:58
      Now the concept in this area
    • 01:04:00
      is that along the Roanoke River, the Roanoke River Greenway will serve as a spine going from west to east, east to west.
    • 01:04:09
      And that other greenways primarily going from north to south and south to north will come in and connect with this spine, kind of like vertebrae on a spine.
    • 01:04:20
      So here's one of the status maps that we try to keep track of.
    • 01:04:27
      The areas that have been completed, the areas that have been funded, the areas where funding is needed to complete sections that have already been funded and or completed, and future plans after that.
    • 01:04:44
      Okay, there's a photo on here that seems to have been lost.
    • 01:04:49
      There it is.
    • 01:04:50
      Okay, this is, for example, that Roanoke River Greenway that's the central spine.
    • 01:04:55
      The goal, that will be 18 miles.
    • 01:04:58
      The goal is to complete those 18 miles within, by 2013.
    • 01:05:04
      Of those 18 miles, 8 miles are already built, 6 of the 18 are funded, leaving, leaving 4 more miles, $4 million for $7 million approximately, looking toward around $4 million from government sources and $3 million from public, private and other sources.
    • 01:05:28
      Similarly, in bicycle planning, we've been over the years trying to focus on getting information out to the public and encouraging bicycle use.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:39
      This $4.1 million, $7 million stretch
    • 01:05:54
      Would you say that's your most important priority for finishing this Greenway Trail?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:06:00
      Well, we happen to have the Roanoke Valley Greenways director in the audience, Liz Belcher.
    • 01:06:07
      She would probably be able to better specifically answer that question.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:11
      Liz Belcher, I'd be delighted to hear what she says about that, especially since it was my organization that initially funded the start of this about 20 years or so ago to get it going.
    • 01:06:23
      Hi, and we thank you.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 01:06:34
      The answer to your question is yes.
    • 01:06:36
      That is our highest priority.
    • 01:06:38
      We now see that we can get finished for the Greenway section in Salem by 2012.
    • 01:06:43
      We can get these eight or nine miles in the city of Roanoke finished by 2012, and then we have this little gap in the middle.
    • 01:06:52
      That's four miles, and so that seven million is our priority.
    • 01:06:56
      Renwick Valley Greenway Commission and the localities are just launching a fundraising campaign to raise private funds to match government funds on construction of this piece.
    • 01:07:08
      This is where our enhancement applications are focused, and so yes, it is our highest priority to finish the Renwick River Greenway, the core part that's in the urban area.
    • 01:07:18
      Thank you.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:19
      Thank you very much.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:07:22
      So similarly with bicycle planning, we've been collecting data and implementing it in geographic information systems and other ways on Google Maps to try to get data into the hands of end users to encourage more use of bicycle facilities that are already here through online mapping and online information distribution.
    • 01:07:43
      And this highlights a partnership that we have with our local transit demand management agency, Ride Solutions, that is
    • 01:07:51
      also co-located in one of the other programs staffed by the Regional Commission along with the MPO.
    • 01:07:58
      So we are really trying to integrate TDM planning and information in with the MPO planning.
    • 01:08:06
      And here is a collage of images that shows you the range of topics and approaches that we have been trying to take over the last few years in preparing for this transition.
    • 01:08:17
      Up in the top left is some visualization work that we did just to try to
    • 01:08:21
      put a visual image on a concept of a contraflow center lane in Interstate 81.
    • 01:08:27
      Should that ever enter the discussion about Interstate 81, the idea would be to have some sort of managed lane in the middle of Interstate 81 where you could reverse the direction of flow on, say, a Virginia Tech game day one direction or the other direction depending on traffic needs.
    • 01:08:47
      Down in the lower left is
    • 01:08:49
      One of the many public meetings with greenway and bicycle planning has been successful over a couple years.
    • 01:08:56
      Up in the upper right is the current Winston Lake Museum and historic passenger station and likely location should passenger rail come back to Roanoke and then the Roanoke River Greenway and bicycle planning.
    • 01:09:15
      We've also tried to be innovative.
    • 01:09:18
      I've already mentioned that we have a strong partnership with our regional rideshare agency.
    • 01:09:23
      To the tune that that program director actually authors and our draft Long Range Plan 2035 has authored a chapter about integrating travel demand management long range planning that he is working on through DRPT with the MPO planning and where those two planning processes integrate with each other.
    • 01:09:42
      And we've also pursued a partnership with the University of Alabama at Huntsville that was brought to us by the Appalachian Regional Commission.
    • 01:09:50
      They had employed a specific freight planning profile technique where that revolves around the interview of business stakeholders around the mobile MPO area and they're looking for MPOs outside of Alabama to test their procedures so we're partnering up with them.
    • 01:10:10
      to have this MPO be a test case of their methodology.
    • 01:10:16
      And also as mentioned before, it's not on this slide, we now have the opportunity with the USDOT, EPA and HUD grant, sustainability grant to really integrate the MPO and transportation planning into the larger picture over a three-year process.
    • 01:10:40
      And that's it for our presentation.
    • 01:10:42
      We'll be happy to take additional questions.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:47
      Explain to me again this issue on the trail counter.
    • 01:10:52
      How does it work and how is the data being used?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:10:58
      There's a colleague in the office that does a lot more of that than I do.
    • 01:11:01
      But it's my understanding it's similar to what a lot of businesses have where there's a concentrated light beam that can be interrupted.
    • 01:11:10
      and the trail counter is in a housing and it counts interruptions in a similar way as large businesses would count people entering a store in a similar manner across the trail at various strategic points so that you can get an estimated trail usage and it also has a timestamp on it to look for trends, time of day trends at various strategic parts along the trail.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:40
      And you all, I'm sorry, a lot of other places obviously use a real person out there.
    • 01:11:45
      The data isn't corrupted.
    • 01:11:47
      I mean, obviously, when you're outside like that, you don't know whether it's a dog or a person or a deer or something, not a bear.
    • 01:11:56
      He's from Virginia Beach.
    • 01:11:57
      He's not used to seeing animals out there run around, except on the side of the road, right, Mr. Lynch?
    • 01:12:04
      So I'm just kind of intrigued about the numbers.
    • 01:12:07
      You are installing the counters in how many different locations?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:12:12
      I don't have that number off the top of my head.
    • 01:12:18
      I believe it is in the range of between five and ten different locations based on discussions around the office, but I don't have the exact number off the top of my head.
    • 01:12:26
      They do, even though the specific staff members are not here to answer specifically, when we have discussed this in the office, they do try to
    • 01:12:37
      Get a handle on the data as best they can by comparing different locations and also when different events are happening on the Greenway and someone from staff is actually there at the event looking at data from that day versus what people have personally observed.
    • 01:12:57
      And they try to correct as much as possible for anomalies through the time.
    • 01:13:04
      But there will be no way that they could
    • 01:13:07
      completely eliminate an animal or something like that going across?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:12
      No, I'm also intrigued about your chart you had about the exceedance on the eight-hour ozone standards.
    • 01:13:23
      I can't help but notice, but after 2002, you dropped off dramatically.
    • 01:13:28
      Now, do you attribute that to the closing of any major industries in this area, or do you contribute it to
    • 01:13:37
      I mean, what do you contribute to that drop?
    • 01:13:40
      Because you were up fairly high, you know, up and down for the several years before that, and also in this process.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:13:48
      I think there were a number of things, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:13:50
      I think part of it was the federal rules and requirements for trucks and trying to eliminate the air, you know, improve air quality by, I guess, enhancing the overall
    • 01:14:06
      And it all kind of fit together.
    • 01:14:11
      It all worked very well for us in terms of our air quality.
    • 01:14:17
      Interesting enough, 50% of our air, our ozone comes from outside of the Roanoke area.
    • 01:14:24
      But we did work very hard with our local governments like Roanoke County and Roanoke City and they adopted a number of
    • 01:14:30
      I said on the Washington MPO and I think we estimated in the Washington area was I think 40% of our ozone
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:00
      was actually coming from outside the area we had no control over.
    • 01:15:03
      And so this is the crazy thing about where the EPA is these days.
    • 01:15:08
      I mean, I almost seem to think it's make work because if they don't, if everyone keeps on meeting the standards, then why do we need this massive bureaucracy that we have with the EPA?
    • 01:15:18
      So they keep on lowering the standard.
    • 01:15:19
      We see it, at least we see it with water quality standards.
    • 01:15:23
      We'd spend billions of dollars on sewage treatment plants and then all of a sudden they changed the standard once we met it.
    • 01:15:28
      And this whole issue on the ozone, I mean, this is something.
    • 01:15:33
      We sent a letter into the EPA raising our concerns about where this is all going.
    • 01:15:38
      And we'll see where they go.
    • 01:15:41
      But I appreciate that.
    • 01:15:43
      Also, I mean, one of the things that gets me about some of these issues is that some of these standards have essentially forced some very important industries to close shop out of Virginia and other areas.
    • 01:15:58
      Leading to some of these problems we have with sprawl, because whereas these manufacturing facilities were in urban areas, are forced to move out, which causes, you know, there to be degraded dispersal, or moving into industries overseas.
    • 01:16:15
      So, that's just my...
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:16:16
      I mean, we're very concerned about it being, coming to non-attainment, as you know, those of you who represent non-attainment areas, you have all kinds of issues, not just highway related.
    • 01:16:26
      transportation issues, but economic development issues as well.
    • 01:16:29
      And as you know, Western Virginia has always traditionally been the manufacturing region for Virginia.
    • 01:16:38
      So we are very concerned about it, and I assume that the Commonwealth will move forward to express its concern about if they are indeed going to lower the standard down to 60 parts per billion.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:51
      Who knows?
    • 01:16:51
      This is maybe a novel idea, but maybe Virginia might sue the EPA.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:16:55
      Over the years and starting with the early action plan, and I have to give credit to the local governments, we didn't know ahead of time when that opportunity was brought to us how the local governments would react.
    • 01:17:11
      And they reacted with enthusiasm, let's get going early, let's get going with an early action plan.
    • 01:17:17
      So we have, over the last decade, we have been very cognizant of the
    • 01:17:24
      idea of separating, improving air quality as a goal from people's positions on regulation and the regulatory regime.
    • 01:17:35
      And we have consistently followed the idea of let's get a coalition together across the spectrum to actually improve the air quality and let the regulation, we'll deal with the regulation when it's decided.
    • 01:17:51
      And we still want to continue that focus of improving the air quality and not really getting into the traditional regulation part because we've seen from bigger areas that the traditional attainment process has a way of distracting the process instead of creating the focus on actually improving things necessarily.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:16
      Gentlemen, thank you for, oh, Ms. Lonnbach.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:18:19
      Secretary.
    • 01:18:21
      Quick question.
    • 01:18:22
      What was your upcoming challenges on new localities?
    • 01:18:26
      Would the addition of Franklin and Montgomery County, although increasing the population and putting you in a different category, would that area help you on your 60 to 70 PPV?
    • 01:18:37
      Because you're looking at the whole region then, right?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:18:45
      Throughout this last early action plan process,
    • 01:18:49
      It is our understanding that the actual parts per billion reading have to do with the monitors that we have physically located in this area.
    • 01:19:00
      So the addition of those localities wouldn't help on that front.
    • 01:19:05
      For an example, if you're up in the Northern Virginia area or even in the Richmond area, a lot of those areas have I think seven plus and in the case of Northern Virginia probably over ten monitors.
    • 01:19:19
      If any one of those monitors is in non-attainment, the entire region is non-attainment.
    • 01:19:25
      So the addition of monitors doesn't average the result.
    • 01:19:31
      It's if any monitor fails, the whole area being non-attainment.
    • 01:19:34
      It makes it worse.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:34
      The more monitors, the worse.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:19:36
      In our area, the monitors are placed down by a couple of our industrial plants, downwind from them.
    • 01:19:42
      We tried to convince EPA to allow us to put a monitor in Craig County up toward the National Forest
    • 01:19:48
      and said, we would buy it.
    • 01:19:50
      And they said, no, we're going to keep our monitors where they are.
    • 01:19:52
      And they're all downwind of industrial sites.
    • 01:19:55
      And that's, as Mark said, one goes, that's all it takes.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:20:00
      So is Franklin and Montgomery County interested in joining?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:06
      I don't know.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:20:07
      I mean, because it seems to me like they might be drug into a situation where they're going to have to comply with something.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:20:12
      Well, Franklin County, the area we looked at, and in fact, the Commonwealth concurred with,
    • 01:20:16
      was the metropolitan area of Roanoke.
    • 01:20:18
      And Franklin is already part of the metro area.
    • 01:20:22
      And so they're already there.
    • 01:20:25
      And by the way, Franklin County didn't used to be part of our regional commission, but they petitioned to join, so they are already at the table, so to speak.
    • 01:20:35
      I'm not sure about Montgomery.
    • 01:20:38
      Bedford County, I think, was surprised when they were added to our MPO.
    • 01:20:42
      And just because of the far western end of it.
    • 01:20:46
      But they have no recourse if indeed the Office of Management and Budget prepares them as part of the urbanized area.
    • 01:20:52
      I think the Federal Highway Administration would say now you've become part.
    • 01:20:56
      We would love to see it though because we have a number of relationships with the New River Valley and it's not only 460, it's our airport and of course we have an intermodal facility that I know that Secretary Connaughton is working on very hard to make sure that it's built down there with the
    • 01:21:14
      as a part of a Heartland corridor, the Norfolk Southern.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:16
      At least you guys aren't suing me.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:21:18
      That's right, we're supporting you.
    • 01:21:23
      But there are, I think, a number of things that could happen if they were at the table when we talk about transportation.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:30
      Mr. Secretary.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:31
      Yes, Mr. Secretary.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:33
      And I do not facetiously actually thank you for perhaps rendering my initial question a little bit redundant if I can
    • 01:21:43
      I read that we really don't have an answer to when non-attainment standards were first set was there always an intention to make them incremental to get down to a goal level or along the way as science as it does given us a new specific reason for like what the new critical mass should be or what the new trigger point should be
    • 01:22:11
      Well, Mr. Moore, I don't know if there's a real they're actively trying to to say we want everyone to be non-attainment
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:22:38
      But apparently their standards were going to be set at 70, 75, and then I believe the EPA, someone sued or is going to sue EPA to bring it down even lower because of the issues of effect on health for older people and children.
    • 01:22:57
      Because we're very actively involved in a partnership with our chapter of the American Lung Association, the asthma group here in Roanoke, so we're all
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:06
      That is part of the discussion.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:23:25
      Historically in the late 60s, early 70s when the Clean Air Acts and other acts like that came in,
    • 01:23:32
      It was established at that point that every five years they would review what the standard is based on science and for a long time the standard wasn't necessarily changed or reviewed every five years and within this last decade there have been a lot of groups that have challenged the EPA on that so that's why you see the flurry of reviews within the last decade because they go back to the original legislation and say well you need to review every five years
    • 01:24:01
      And so on either side of that debate, they're both using science of human health to say the standard needs to be reviewed and the discussion is what the standard needs to be set at based on not only people your age but also children and people with asthma, based on those type of human health standards.
    • 01:24:24
      In other words, Mr. Martin, they're making it up.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:26
      Oh, excuse me, Mr. Secretary, I take exception.
    • 01:24:29
      I know you do, Ms. McCarthy.
    • 01:24:32
      To listen to this argument, you would think that somebody in EPA woke up yesterday morning and said, you know what?
    • 01:24:38
      Let's change the standard.
    • 01:24:40
      That is not the way the regulatory process works.
    • 01:24:43
      So let's eliminate that notion.
    • 01:24:45
      There is a lot of science out there that justifies some of what they're doing.
    • 01:24:51
      I can't speak to whether it ought to be 60 parts per billion or
    • 01:24:54
      or whatever it is, or 70.
    • 01:24:57
      But it's not just because somebody is being arbitrary and capricious.
    • 01:25:01
      And in fact, the other side would argue that those that are suing the EPA, which we've threatened to do here this morning, those who are suing it for the opposite reasons, saying EPA isn't doing its job.
    • 01:25:15
      So let's let the scientists and the courts eventually sort this out, but it is not arbitrary and capricious.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:23
      Well, Mr. McCarthy, let's just get it out on the table here that they are going around the rulemaking process by filing suit against the EPA, getting into a settlement that essentially gets a court order that mandates this in the regulatory process.
    • 01:25:41
      That's what's happened here.
    • 01:25:42
      That is what's happening in many other regulatory areas.
    • 01:25:45
      It doesn't give the public any opportunity to comment.
    • 01:25:48
      It doesn't give science any opportunity to provide data.
    • 01:25:52
      These people constantly get in there.
    • 01:25:54
      What's happening with the EPA, and we're dealing with it on numerous different areas, is that they're suing, they're entering into settlement negotiations behind closed doors, they go into court, they get a settlement agreement, and then they end up mandating it across the country.
    • 01:26:11
      And that's what's happening here, and this is one of the challenges we face because it is undermining our entire public participation process.
    • 01:26:22
      That's my perspective and unfortunately I know you've been on one side and unfortunately for me I've been on the other side and all we see in things like this is we have little to no ability to influence these even with the data that we provide because they turn around and say we're responding to a court order.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:26:43
      From the regional perspective, I guess what people say about
    • 01:26:49
      Politics Being Local, and the original early action plan, we had people enthusiastically come to us from all sides, from business groups to environmental organizations.
    • 01:27:03
      So locally, we've had a broad cross-section of partners working toward this, actually
    • 01:27:13
      Working towards success in the early action plan and getting our air quality to where it would comply or be better.
    • 01:27:21
      Now in the future when a new standard is announced we'll have to see how that impacts us specifically.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:29
      Great presentation.
    • 01:27:30
      I appreciate you guys being here.
    • 01:27:32
      And we'll now move on to enhancement grants.
    • 01:27:35
      Ms. Julie Brown.
    • 01:27:39
      Our transportation enhancement policy update.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:27:44
      Okay.
    • 01:27:57
      We've been talking about changes to the enhancement policy for several months at our October CTB workshop.
    • 01:28:04
      My guest has provided an overview of several changes we'd like to make to the enhancement policy.
    • 01:28:10
      We ask for your feedback.
    • 01:28:12
      And today I will summarize the program, the feedback we received, and our final recommendations.
    • 01:28:21
      Just as a reminder, the program, it is a satisfied program.
    • 01:28:25
      These funds can only be used for enhancement projects.
    • 01:28:28
      Historically, we've received 150 to 200 applications per year.
    • 01:28:32
      This year, of course, is different.
    • 01:28:35
      Based on the policy approved in November of last year,
    • 01:28:39
      This year we were only accepting applications for existing projects.
    • 01:28:44
      That application deadline was December 1, and just as an FYI, we've done a quick tally on what we received, and we did receive applications for 97 existing projects, and those 97 existing projects have requested just about $45 million.
    • 01:29:03
      So a lot of projects out there that need additional funding, so hopefully we'll be able to make a lot of progress this year.
    • 01:29:09
      and funding some of those existing projects.
    • 01:29:14
      There are 12 eligible categories for the enhancement program.
    • 01:29:19
      This is another major aspect of what's being proposed as a change in this year's policy.
    • 01:29:26
      Last year, there was a provision placed in the policy that would restrict the eligible categories that would be considered starting next year.
    • 01:29:38
      So looking at this list of 12, if no change is made to the existing policy, next year we would not consider applications for Category 4, scenic or historic highway programs, including tourist and welcome centers, or Category 6, historic preservation, or Categories 9 through 12.
    • 01:30:02
      Categories 9 through 12 have not traditionally had a lot of projects.
    • 01:30:07
      But one of the main reasons that we are recommending changes this year is that some of their statewide initiatives that are being promoted that promote both economic development and tourism do fall in categories that would be eliminated without a policy change, particularly the scenic or historic highway programs.
    • 01:30:30
      The other reason that we are recommending a change is that there will probably always be a little confusion
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:36
      If FHWA is promoting 12 categories, then we're restricting that to six.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:30:46
      The current policy would restrict that without a change.
    • 01:30:55
      This year's policy is recommending that we eliminate that provision that would restrict those categories
    • 01:31:03
      And just open it up to all 12, and really it comes down to your preference on which ones are selected.
    • 01:31:08
      So a recommendation, that's within the current policy, is that starting next year, we would restrict it to only six categories, and that category would be one of those that would be eliminated.
    • 01:31:22
      The current proposal is to not do that and allow all 12 to be eligible next year.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:26
      Was there a reason to eliminate that sixth one?
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:31:30
      There were six that were eliminated.
    • 01:31:32
      And initially, the intent was to focus on those categories.
    • 01:31:38
      Let me go back.
    • 01:31:40
      To focus on those categories that were more closely related to transportation.
    • 01:31:46
      And so it focused on your bicycle pedestrian facilities, some of your street scaping.
    • 01:31:52
      And I would say that there's probably just a slight change in focus.
    • 01:31:55
      And this year, there's more of a focus on statewide initiatives and those projects that also help support economic development and tourism.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:04
      I'm just trying to understand this because you just contradicted what you said.
    • 01:32:13
      If you were supporting tourism and whatever to eliminate welcome sites and these scenic highway programs, you seem to be going contrary to what you said was your reason for eliminating it.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:32:24
      And what I'm saying is that based on the focus on tourism and economic development, this year we're saying let's not restrict any.
    • 01:32:33
      and next year we would consider all of them.
    • 01:32:35
      If we do nothing, the next year scenic or historic highway programs would not be an eligible category for a new project.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:47
      I guess I agree with Dr. Davis.
    • 01:32:58
      I think if we're emphasizing tourism and scenic
    • 01:33:03
      sites and battlefields and stuff like that, then this Category 4 ought to stay in.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:09
      This year, next year, whatever, she's recommended that.
    • 01:33:13
      Yeah, it was around the barn, wasn't it?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:16
      Last year, it was recommended that starting this year, those would be out.
    • 01:33:20
      She's saying, let's get rid of what we did last year and go back.
    • 01:33:23
      I'll work for that.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:33:24
      Next year may change.
    • 01:33:26
      I won't try to.
    • 01:33:28
      Yeah.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:29
      But I mean that is in terms of what's eligible but in the selection of processes still we've got the discretion for those individuals who like to focus on keeping it as transportation related as possible can exercise that judgment in the selection process.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:33:46
      I mean there certainly has been some opposition to adding the six back primarily from your bicycle, pedestrian, facilities proponents but historically this board has selected more of those projects than any other type project anyway.
    • 01:33:59
      And that probably would not change whether you were considering six or twelve categories.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:06
      We're still doing those maps that show the 25 wins, right?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:34:11
      Yes.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:13
      Curious, I don't know if you did the number.
    • 01:34:16
      You said 97 have been submitted.
    • 01:34:19
      If we weren't to change the policy and the six that were going to be eliminated are eliminated, where's that number?
    • 01:34:26
      Is it 95?
    • 01:34:26
      Is it 24?
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:34:28
      That that provision would be in effect starting with FY 13, so it would be in effect with applications that would be received December 1, 2011.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:34:39
      Next year, so it doesn't apply to the 19th.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:34:41
      It does not apply to anything.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:43
      Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:44
      Yes.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:45
      Julie, on the list that we received dated December 2, 2010, that's a list of all the existing projects.
    • 01:34:54
      So the 97 applications that you've got,
    • 01:34:57
      Correct.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:35:00
      That list was based on a request we had to provide a listing by locality so you could get a quick picture of every project a given locality had and what their performance had done over time on those projects.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:17
      It shows most of those projects that haven't been completed but it shows some under construction, some under agreement.
    • 01:35:25
      Well, under construction is great.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:35:33
      That means the project is under construction.
    • 01:35:35
      Hopefully, that will be completed shortly.
    • 01:35:38
      If it's under agreement, they may be in preliminary engineering phase, doing some work.
    • 01:35:43
      If agreement is pending, that means we still have not received a signed agreement.
    • 01:35:49
      And hopefully, if it has agreement pending, it's a fairly new project or one that received funding just in the last year or two.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:55
      In all of those cases, we can assume it's 100% funded because they would not be working toward an agreement if they didn't have the funding.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:36:02
      Well, I wouldn't assume it's 100% funding, but it's received some funding based on their prior request.
    • 01:36:10
      It should have a cost estimate and the amount we've allocated so you can hopefully see how close they are to having that project fully funded.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:21
      This slide you've seen several times before but again just a quick overview of the allocation history over the last ten years and again another huge aspect of this year's policy revision
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:36:48
      is their statewide initiative.
    • 01:36:49
      We are recommending that $4 million be set aside for these type activities.
    • 01:36:54
      We have several of these right now.
    • 01:36:55
      One of those is to promote our Scenic Rogue Program.
    • 01:36:59
      And basically, we're working with the Virginia Tourism Corporation to provide a multimedia device that citizens can stock at any tourist center and basically get information about historic and scenic sites
    • 01:37:13
      Close to that area.
    • 01:37:14
      So this is the type of project that we're talking about with our statewide initiatives.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:19
      And again, this project is an example of one that qualified under that Category 4.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:37:37
      I mean, they have been a recipient of enhancement funds over the years, and so, you know, there is an existing project, and I'm not saying that that completely funds their funds, but they do have an enhancement project that is used to provide some of those funds.
    • 01:38:07
      This is the same chart that Mike showed you at the last meeting, kind of summarizing air distribution and allocations in the past and what's proposed with the new policy.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:38:36
      Could you tell me the reasoning behind the 75-25 split between district members and at large?
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:38:46
      Excellent question.
    • 01:38:47
      I was getting ready to explain it.
    • 01:38:53
      The goal was, and I was going to say, we had five comments we received from CTB members.
    • 01:38:57
      One of those specifically asked that question.
    • 01:38:59
      But after the $4 million was pulled off the site,
    • 01:39:04
      And that would be for statewide initiatives.
    • 01:39:08
      The goal behind 75% for the district members was to try to keep the district members' allocation somewhat level to historical levels, recognizing a goal of having a set amount in every district.
    • 01:39:25
      So it was trying to ensure that we still had geographic distribution and could still have that $1 million
    • 01:39:32
      Just over one million in every district.
    • 01:39:36
      The at-large members historically have focused more on statewide regional projects.
    • 01:39:40
      There's already $4 million that will be used for similar type projects.
    • 01:39:44
      And so the five at-large members would receive approximately $700,000.
    • 01:39:49
      But when you look at the $4 million and the $3.5 collectively, and I'm using numbers that we were assuming having the same type of allocations we've had in the past.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:02
      Over the course of the last several years as an at-large member once you did the peelbacks of things that let's just say the secretary allocated some off the top or however you wanted to state that.
    • 01:40:20
      But that's about what an at-large member in the past had.
    • 01:40:25
      At the end of the day, when we sat at the table, at-large members generally had about 700,000 to 800,000 each to allocate because some relatively large chunk had already been identified as a priority for some at-large type activities, including the sign that was referred to earlier.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:40:44
      Mr. Chairman, the following on that, one of my concerns is based on point three of the resolution.
    • 01:40:55
      Funds allocated collectively to at-large members will focus on projects of regional significance and completing funding of projects selected by district members.
    • 01:41:04
      The Secretary and at-large members will collectively prioritize the allocation of these funds.
    • 01:41:11
      So my only concern in being a new member, not familiar with what has happened in the past, is that, first of all, the $4 million that's pulled off
    • 01:41:22
      So there's no at-large allocation or determination in that $4 million as to how we prioritize that collectively.
    • 01:41:40
      However, the collective funds will be determined and prioritized for all the at-large members.
    • 01:41:46
      The point being is that
    • 01:41:49
      I do not intend to take anything away from the district representatives, but if the at-large has had minimal significance as to what we allocate our funds for, there's not a whole lot of use to have at-large members.
    • 01:42:03
      We just as well allocate it all jointly among four of the nine district members and let the secretary have the four million coming off on the top.
    • 01:42:12
      That's just the way I would do it.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:42:13
      And there was a slight revision to the resolution, and it was slight, but it was intended to try to address your comment.
    • 01:42:20
      What you just read was that the at-large allocations would focus on certain type projects.
    • 01:42:26
      The prior language indicated that it would be used for, and the intent was there might be some recommendations, but it really is, you do have the discretion to decide how those at-large funds are being used.
    • 01:42:38
      When we say collectively, it's always been the assumption that
    • 01:42:42
      The at-large members kind of meet as a group and they're talking kind of statewide because we do have statewide projects.
    • 01:42:48
      We do have districts that may have difficulty putting 50% on their projects and so it's intended to be a discussion with the at-large members meeting and that's why that's worded that way.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:00
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:43:02
      Mr. King.
    • 01:43:02
      I think the proposal that's being made here by the staff is a workable solution to some of the issues that we've
    • 01:43:09
      One is to prioritize some of the statewide funds so that we can focus on some major projects.
    • 01:43:16
      And what it amounts to is basically taking a $250,000 of the statewide, which is intended for statewide anyhow, it takes about $250,000 of each of us that are statewide representatives and puts it in that pool and accomplishes that goal.
    • 01:43:33
      We're left in with $750,000
    • 01:43:35
      to consider those statewide projects, many of which you're going to find statewide projects in the locale where you live.
    • 01:43:42
      So I think what he's talking about here, meeting with the Secretary, we do have that statewide meeting.
    • 01:43:49
      We've come together with the Secretary and or his representative in the past to look at the statewide emphasis.
    • 01:43:56
      And we will have statewide projects potentially in each and every district.
    • 01:43:59
      So I think this is a workable solution
    • 01:44:03
      We generally meet, as Mr. Sterling has indicated, we come to an agreement and a discussion and you can have your input on projects that you have priority on and you can sell your project.
    • 01:44:15
      You might even get some funds from another statewide member to help you with that particular project in your district.
    • 01:44:20
      We worked that way in the past.
    • 01:44:23
      I have been fortunate in receiving funds from other districts, other statewide representatives to help us with projects in districts that I had of interest but I wasn't able to fund it.
    • 01:44:32
      and they were able to do it.
    • 01:44:33
      So I think it's a workable solution when you come together as statewide representatives for those of you that haven't been there before, I think you'll understand that it's probably a pretty good policy and I would support them in this proposal.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:44:46
      Mr. Lane?
    • 01:44:47
      We probably spent more time on this $15 million if not more than half the projects that will impact across the state, but having said that, we're all members, we're all
    • 01:45:01
      My understanding is we all represent the state.
    • 01:45:03
      We may have a district, we all represent the state.
    • 01:45:06
      So speaking from a member from a large district, I would say, why don't we determine what we want to go to statewide and just divide the rest equally across the members?
    • 01:45:15
      I mean, it seems to me that's what we really are about.
    • 01:45:18
      And we do everything else that way.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:23
      And to go along with that, I just, well, first I have to apologize.
    • 01:45:27
      I mean, it's to a certain extent,
    • 01:45:30
      You know, the existing policy we've had to revise to deal with the issue that I have to deal with.
    • 01:45:35
      And that is the 150th anniversary.
    • 01:45:39
      That's much easier for her.
    • 01:45:41
      I mean, quite honestly, we have very limited funds throughout the state to be able to promote this as a major tourism event.
    • 01:45:53
      And so, since most of the activities we're talking about here, I mean, all of the activities I'm talking about here really support that.
    • 01:46:00
      This is one way, and this is really when you look at transportation enhancement, this was one of the things that was supposed to generate, quote unquote, positive revenue.
    • 01:46:08
      So I do apologize that we had to take this step, but it is something that's important to the state and our economy and our jobs.
    • 01:46:16
      All that being said, you know, I do want to just keep something in everyone's back, everybody's mind is that, I mean, one of the things we've got to, whether it's statewide or local,
    • 01:46:29
      is the fact that, I think at our last report, less than 50% of the money, whether we're statewide or local, was actually spent.
    • 01:46:40
      And so the thing is is that, I mean, I think what we've got to get together about is looking for projects that really are going to happen, that we have people putting in matches, and that this money is really utilized to
    • 01:46:58
      for the purposes this program was established.
    • 01:47:00
      And I think when we get through that, I hate to say this, a big part of me says that we're going to throw a lot of projects off the list just simply from the fact that most of the private or other public partners will not be able to make the match in any sort of timely fashion.
    • 01:47:22
      And maybe that should be again one of the biggest criteria all the time is
    • 01:47:26
      Getting this money on the street as quickly as possible, because this is imperative time for us to get money on the street.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:34
      On the issue, and kind of the way that this is formally being presented, in reality, the allocations are really no different than they have been in the past.
    • 01:47:48
      The stated policy was every member got an equal share
    • 01:47:52
      Then those who were at large, we would receive an email sometime through the process that the secretary has decided or the governor has requested that we fund these projects and they'd be statewide and they'd come out to about $4 million be done out of the at-large, which then leaves all of the at-large chairs or at-large members with a share of X dollars to do.
    • 01:48:20
      What would happen if you were to take that at-law or that statewide off the top and then divide it is you would be in effect reducing the amount that went into the district shares.
    • 01:48:32
      This is in effect, Mr.
    • 01:48:34
      Keen will verify that, this is in effect no different than what we have been practicing.
    • 01:48:40
      It just puts it more codified, it's not law, but it puts it more in paper as the way it has happened and that was to
    • 01:48:47
      The district shares are to ensure that there's projects around the state so everybody is getting something they understand, that there's a popularity to it, but it also makes sure that some of the statewides are done, that those high priorities that are being identified by the governor or by the secretary and others, it focuses that element as well.
    • 01:49:08
      So I would submit that we're really not changing an allocation process here at all.
    • 01:49:13
      We're just more putting on paper the way it's been practiced.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:49:17
      And I understand that, and I quite frankly agree with how we want to do it.
    • 01:49:21
      However, if you look at that, a million dollars in one district is not a million dollars in a smaller district.
    • 01:49:28
      In other words, there's not a weighing population.
    • 01:49:31
      And all I'm suggesting is that we all are state representatives, and we all got the same, decided we were going to take it off the top.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:39
      And to do for the state that we all got equal shares, I mean, I can't believe we wouldn't work together to see how it would come.
    • 01:49:44
      But I hear what you're saying.
    • 01:49:45
      Yeah, I'd suggest that a million dollars even in the smallest district doesn't go very far.
    • 01:49:49
      Right, I understand.
    • 01:49:50
      But I'd also like to take from what the Secretary said.
    • 01:49:54
      One of my frustrations that I've seen on this is the execution element.
    • 01:50:00
      And when I was an at-large, you didn't really see the execution and what happened.
    • 01:50:05
      When I became a district rep and I got the list, here are the projects and
    • 01:50:09
      So-and-so or such municipalities asking for an extension.
    • 01:50:14
      It was an eye-opener at how poorly some districts.
    • 01:50:17
      I've got one community who has two projects that are over 10 years old.
    • 01:50:22
      And we get a VDOT audit out there that says that VDOT's sitting on all these funds that have been allocated for a purpose but not executed.
    • 01:50:29
      And I've got individuals from even that locality that are going, see, VDOT's not executed.
    • 01:50:35
      And in reality, it was that
    • 01:50:36
      A community that's sitting on a lot of that money that they have not been executing.
    • 01:50:40
      Of course, I've told them they're not eligible.
    • 01:50:43
      They can submit a grant if they request, but until they demonstrate that they can execute on the projects that are before them, that they're not going to, that they are going to be uncompetitive.
    • 01:50:52
      They're eligible, but they're going to be uncompetitive going forward.
    • 01:50:55
      I agree.
    • 01:50:56
      Execution has to be one of the key elements here.
    • 01:50:59
      It doesn't necessarily need to be in the selection, but I will tell you again, my evaluations
    • 01:51:04
      If they're not executing, if they have a poor history of execution, they're not going to be very competitive for selection.
    • 01:51:11
      I agree 100%.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:51:12
      And just a reminder, last year we implemented a new ranking criteria where we're basically providing you that information that is giving you information about how well that project is progressing because the goal really is to select those projects that are moving forward.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:28
      You talk about projects, I'm talking about the community, because it's the community that has to execute it, and they may be, you know, if it's a new project or it's only a year old, oh, that doesn't look bad, but if they've got projects on the list that are ten years old, then the community that's supposed to execute it has got a poor history of execution.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:45
      Mr. Miller, then Mr.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:47
      Keen.
    • 01:51:48
      Mr. Chairman, I agree with Mr. Layne in terms of we spent a lot of time on something that's not real big, but
    • 01:51:54
      Since I raised the issue last time, I'll just make my case one more time and then I'll shut up.
    • 01:51:59
      I bring greetings from Virginia Beach without tie or socks.
    • 01:52:03
      Notice the only two people in here.
    • 01:52:10
      That's right.
    • 01:52:13
      Perhaps that's symbolic of this discussion.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:15
      Is it that warm in Virginia Beach right now?
    • 01:52:19
      I think next year we'll have the conference over there.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:24
      I heard Mr. Sterling's comments, and I don't have the benefit of history.
    • 01:52:30
      All I can do is read what's on the paper.
    • 01:52:33
      At our last meeting, you opined, I believe, if I heard you correctly, that you didn't even need the $4 million, and I was curious about that.
    • 01:52:44
      No, you heard something very wrong with that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:52
      Just remember, I'm just the tool in the machine, Mr. Miller.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:57
      I'll use any of this myself.
    • 01:53:00
      We're just a hand on the tool is all.
    • 01:53:03
      But in any case, I don't see in the policy where
    • 01:53:09
      where it sort of directs us as statewide members, or not statewide members, but at-large members to look at statewide.
    • 01:53:16
      I don't see that in the studies, the work that I've looked at so far.
    • 01:53:21
      I think we were just selected to represent the urban areas statewide or the rural areas statewide.
    • 01:53:27
      So theoretically, even though I represent the entire state like everybody else here, I represent Northern Virginia, and I represent Richmond, and I represent Hampton Roads at least.
    • 01:53:39
      So I've got more demand on me than other people that represent one district, theoretically.
    • 01:53:46
      And I can tell you that demand's already started, because I've already been hearing about this from people in different places.
    • 01:53:52
      So it's not theory to me, it's real.
    • 01:53:56
      Under the current, or the 2011 plan, each member, including the secretary, received 6.66% of the funds.
    • 01:54:09
      That was 15 divided into 15 shares, 15 equal shares.
    • 01:54:17
      On the current plan, and I heard Mrs. Sterling's point about some sort of practice.
    • 01:54:21
      On the proposed plan, the secretary would get 18%, the district members would get 8.33%, and the at-large members would get 5%.
    • 01:54:31
      And I have no problem with sort of looking at the big picture of the state.
    • 01:54:35
      I think that ought to be allocated to the secretary who has the big picture of the state, whether that's $4 million or $5 million or whatever the number is.
    • 01:54:44
      But after that, I don't understand the inequity between the members.
    • 01:54:49
      You're treating the different members differently, and I would make the case to you that if you want to make the case that
    • 01:55:01
      We're supposed to be looking statewide, then I have more demand on me as a statewide member or as an at-large member than a district member does.
    • 01:55:11
      So it's sort of in reverse.
    • 01:55:13
      I could make the opposite case.
    • 01:55:14
      Perhaps the at-large members don't have more money because they have more demand.
    • 01:55:19
      So I would ask you all to think about that, and I'm going to vote no to the policies.
    • 01:55:25
      It's recommended because of that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:30
      Ms. King.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:33
      First of all, I want to emphasize that this is just as important and it deserves to share time that we're getting to as far as I'm concerned because it provides major improvements for a lot of places in rural Virginia and they're very interested in it and the reason you've got 79 applications here is because there's that need out there.
    • 01:55:53
      There's more need than we're able to supply and so it's a good program and it deserves their attention.
    • 01:55:59
      However,
    • 01:56:00
      When we're making the changes, and I think most of the changes are I'm in agreement with and I support this policy, but we can't let VDOT off the hook on the administration of this thing on the local levels in the districts because while Mr. Sterling found that the localities had some issues and poor response, I submit to you they couldn't go to bid until they got the thing properly funded.
    • 01:56:24
      See, the localities did not have the funds available that they could go out and make a commitment
    • 01:56:29
      to face $750,000 on the project when they only held $500,000 and they only got that $500,000 over the last five years.
    • 01:56:39
      So, there's an issue there that made that to be ten years on the books.
    • 01:56:44
      But also, I found in looking at projects in Southwest, a lot of these projects were not administered effectively, I would term effectively, with VDOT in terms of proper follow-up
    • 01:56:57
      and coordinating it with the localities because it becomes a locally administered thing.
    • 01:57:01
      It doesn't get the attention and it's not on the radar screen.
    • 01:57:04
      I think that's changing.
    • 01:57:05
      I noticed that that is changing in the district because of the emphasis that we've placed on it.
    • 01:57:10
      And I think you will see more effort by VDOT to make sure that these don't lay on the table and they don't get to the top of the pile in a three-month timeframe.
    • 01:57:19
      And I think that has happened.
    • 01:57:21
      So we're going to have, I think, some improvements here in this area.
    • 01:57:24
      And I'm going to support this proposal.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:57:27
      I've got one clarification.
    • 01:57:29
      I very much think it's an important program.
    • 01:57:31
      I just think we spend a lot of time on how we divvy the money up.
    • 01:57:34
      That's my one point.
    • 01:57:35
      And I don't see the difference between an at-large or a district member in terms of how we put this money.
    • 01:57:43
      I think the criteria that Mr. Sterling has talked about is how it's executed is much more important than whether we divvy it up at 5%, 6%.
    • 01:57:52
      So I'm very much in favor of the program as needed.
    • 01:57:56
      I just think we ought to be more equitable in how we allocate it to frontline members.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:04
      Ms. Choad, I think we ought to hear the rest of the report.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:09
      Well said, Dr. Davis.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:58:11
      Quick summary of what the current proposed modifications to the policy are.
    • 01:58:16
      Our current proposal is still the allocation distribution would be $4 million set off aside for high priority statewide initiatives.
    • 01:58:24
      75% of the remaining funds provided to district members split nine ways, 25% remaining allocated to the at-large members, and again, some slight change in language to indicate that there's a focus for the at-large members, but it really is their discretion how those funds are spent.
    • 01:58:43
      Propose of the eligible category.
    • 01:58:45
      The proposal is that we would keep all 12 eligible categories instead of limiting those starting in FY 13.
    • 01:58:52
      And the deallocation process, again, that's a process that's been in place for three years, but the CTB has never officially approved it.
    • 01:59:00
      So we've added a line to the resolution that you will approve that.
    • 01:59:05
      We did ask your comments on one conflict we had between the policy and the deallocation process, and that was who should grant extensions.
    • 01:59:13
      Those that responded back had a preference that that extension be granted by the district CTB members, which has been our practice for the last few years.
    • 01:59:22
      With that, next steps.
    • 01:59:24
      This is on the action agenda for today.
    • 01:59:27
      If the policy is revised, our next step, of course, would be to communicate that change policy.
    • 01:59:33
      And then we'll go through a normal process of providing you the list of applications we received in February, our selections in July, and our next application deadline of next year.
    • 01:59:46
      Any other questions?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:47
      It's a federal reimbursement so they actually spend 100% of whatever costs are associated
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:00:15
      They submit a reimbursement request.
    • 02:00:18
      We submit it through FHWA to get 80% reimbursement.
    • 02:00:21
      So VDOT actually has no funds in any enhancement project.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:26
      Is that working well, though?
    • 02:00:27
      I mean, do they have to get bank loans and we're not taking too long to reimburse them, that type of thing?
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:00:33
      Once we get the reimbursement request, they should be moving pretty quickly.
    • 02:00:36
      But I'd say it's an issue for some of your smaller sponsors.
    • 02:00:41
      But yeah, it's one of the things that we try to emphasize is that you have to have some capital to work with up front.
    • 02:00:49
      I'm not familiar with how most of them, I mean a lot of them are getting donations and they're trying to get community support for funding because they have to have 20% no matter what.
    • 02:01:01
      So they have to have some working capital of how they're going to usually.
    • 02:01:04
      And probably the ones that have the most difficulty are those that
    • 02:01:08
      are planning to use in-kind match so they don't actually have cash.
    • 02:01:13
      And that's still allowable with this program.
    • 02:01:15
      And we do have some project sponsors that are relying on either a donation of land as their match and may not have relied on as much cash.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:25
      And actually, Mr. Rich, from my experience in local government with this, this is one of the few areas where they seem to be very quick in reimbursements.
    • 02:01:34
      Yes.
    • 02:01:37
      I haven't heard of any major problems.
    • 02:01:39
      If it was legitimate, if it was approved, I mean, essentially, it's already gone through the obligation.
    • 02:01:44
      The feds have already approved it.
    • 02:01:46
      All you got to do is show the expenditure and it's fairly quick.
    • 02:01:51
      And Virginia, the VDOT and our other agencies' credits, they, we bill daily.
    • 02:01:59
      Do we bill daily?
    • 02:02:01
      We bill daily to the federal high of some.
    • 02:02:05
      You know, some states do it monthly or weekly.
    • 02:02:07
      We do it daily, so there's always a turn of, I mean, they're pretty quick.
    • 02:02:12
      Is that right, Ms. Busher?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:14
      Yeah.
    • 02:02:14
      If you don't have to go through the local governing bodies first, though, I mean, we set it to the local governing bodies?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:19
      Well, whoever the sponsoring, we set it to the sponsoring.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:02:22
      Yeah, we require all projects to have a sponsor, and that sponsors use of the locality.
    • 02:02:28
      So air payment is going back to the locality.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:30
      But not all of them.
    • 02:02:31
      I mean, some of them like this, what the Civil War Preservation Trust, if they're an established sponsor, and we send it to them if they're the sponsor of it.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:02:42
      All right.
    • 02:02:43
      Well, I'm looking forward to the vote.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:46
      OK.
    • 02:02:48
      Noise abatement.
    • 02:02:49
      Mr. Long, Stephen Long from VDOT.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:02:54
      Good morning.
    • 02:02:56
      Let me sign this presentation here.
    • 02:03:23
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:03:25
      I'm Steve Long.
    • 02:03:26
      I'm the state environmental administrator for VDOT.
    • 02:03:29
      I want to come to you today to talk about a noise policy update for the department.
    • 02:03:34
      Studies have shown that noise and highway traffic noise is one of the most pervasive issues we have today in our environment.
    • 02:03:42
      In compliance with federal regulations, we've had a noise policy in place since 1989.
    • 02:03:47
      The last time we came to this board was in 1997 to update this policy.
    • 02:03:53
      In response to new technology and industry practices, FHWA's proposed changes to the federal regulations on noise policy.
    • 02:04:04
      Those proposed rulemaking came out last September and VDOT provided 18 comments to the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 02:04:13
      Three major ones we did, we request they establish a national cost effectiveness criterion.
    • 02:04:18
      The other was we request they establish a land use, special land use calculation nationwide
    • 02:04:23
      So everyone was using the same number.
    • 02:04:25
      And we requested federal funding to do a noise barrier inventory of all the noise barriers we have.
    • 02:04:34
      None of those three comments out of the 18 that they listened to.
    • 02:04:38
      So things aren't going to be very consistent nationwide.
    • 02:04:41
      The final rule was the effective date of the final rule will be July 13, 2011.
    • 02:04:47
      We have to have a draft policy and guidance manual to Federal Highway by January 13.
    • 02:04:53
      The current noise policy was approved in 1998.
    • 02:04:56
      It was updated in 1996 as his Administrative Process Act exempt.
    • 02:05:02
      Due to the scope of the changes, the current policy will be repealed and a new policy update will be recommended.
    • 02:05:09
      The new policy will set out statements on applicability, federal highway resources, General Assembly mandates, administration policy, and create a companion document to cover the details instead of one document that covers it all.
    • 02:05:24
      One thing I do want to bring to your attention is the Code of Virginia requires that we look at noise mitigation.
    • 02:05:30
      We also look at other factors than just the typical found walls you see.
    • 02:05:35
      We look at landscaping.
    • 02:05:39
      We can look at other things, look at distances, look at materials.
    • 02:05:43
      One thing you will start hearing about that we've just started studying is pavements, low noise pavement materials that are reduced, called quiet pavements, and Virginia's just started research in that.
    • 02:05:54
      and that's going to be an ongoing process for the next number of years.
    • 02:06:00
      Some changes, some big changes in the policy.
    • 02:06:02
      Right now we use $30,000 per receptor and a receptor is a home, an apartment, that's a receptor.
    • 02:06:11
      We're proposing to change the dollar amount to a square footage amount and that would be 1,600 square feet.
    • 02:06:19
      The dollar amount is not inflation protected.
    • 02:06:22
      We propose
    • 02:06:24
      30,000 receptor now, we build the road.
    • 02:06:26
      We're frozen at that amount.
    • 02:06:27
      When we build the road 10 years from now, the cost could be a lot more.
    • 02:06:30
      So it doesn't really protect anyone.
    • 02:06:33
      A square footage is more fair to people.
    • 02:06:35
      It insulates you from different regional costs for noise barriers.
    • 02:06:40
      A receptor is an individual home or an apartment, an apartment and apartment building.
    • 02:06:51
      We have a lot of apartments.
    • 02:06:53
      They'd all be individual receptors.
    • 02:06:55
      The receptor is a housing unit.
    • 02:06:59
      It's probably the best way to explain.
    • 02:07:06
      I'm using the federal definition.
    • 02:07:09
      And I did bring along Paul Kohler today.
    • 02:07:13
      Paul's our state noise engineer, and he's my technical expert on all of this.
    • 02:07:18
      He knows all the federal rules and regulations.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:21
      That's the receptor determiner.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:07:24
      He's the receptor determiner and does all the engineering and his studies and keeps us out of trouble.
    • 02:07:39
      This just points out the changes in the proposed policy.
    • 02:07:42
      Right now $30,000 going to 1,600 square feet, which is about $57,600.
    • 02:07:49
      This figure was based on
    • 02:07:51
      The 57-6, if you would base it on what it's cost us to build barriers on primaries, secondaries, versus interstates, interstates were a lot cheaper to build.
    • 02:08:02
      And the 1,600 square feet's about what we do on average now.
    • 02:08:06
      If you figure what we do on secondary, primary roads, interstates.
    • 02:08:10
      Interstates are a lot cheaper.
    • 02:08:11
      You have a lot more receptors, a lot easier to build.
    • 02:08:13
      The right-of-way's a lot simpler than going down the street with a lot of houses, a lot of driveways, and a lot of other items.
    • 02:08:20
      Reasonableness criterion, the current policy does not address that.
    • 02:08:24
      Again, reasonableness is one of these Federal Highway terms that are confusing.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:28
      I want to make sure I understand correctly.
    • 02:08:31
      Are we saying it's reasonable to spend $57,000 per receptor?
    • 02:08:36
      Benefit of receptor, yes sir.
    • 02:08:38
      So, if it's an apartment or a house, whatever, a dwelling unit, it's reasonable to spend that much per for sound abatement?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:08:47
      For the average cost of the barrier.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:08:50
      Mr. Secretary, the federal regulations did not prescribe a range or a method.
    • 02:09:02
      They provided some suggestions on how states should approach the reasonableness criteria.
    • 02:09:09
      As part of reasonableness, it goes beyond cost or square footage, maximum square footage.
    • 02:09:14
      It also has a few other options in there, including the desires of the public.
    • 02:09:18
      Do they really want the sound wall or not?
    • 02:09:20
      So we looked at, like Steve said, we looked at the historical data.
    • 02:09:24
      We see that the trends in construction costs have gone up, and the tenures of data we looked at really support this 1,600 square feet.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:34
      Just out of curiosity, what is the average cost per dwelling unit across the Commonwealth?
    • 02:09:50
      I mean, are we spending as much on sound abatement or 50% of the average dwelling unit cost?
    • 02:09:55
      Right now we're using 30,000, and if you look at the historical data, it rolls in around $50,000.
    • 02:10:02
      In other words, as a share of the cost of a house or an apartment, a receptor.
    • 02:10:11
      We did not look at it from what it would cost.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:13
      We don't know what that would be.
    • 02:10:15
      In fact, can I just make, I mean, I just want to point out, they put in the budget amendment, this down wall on the Dulles Connector Road.
    • 02:10:23
      That, if I sat there and did the math, and that was several months ago,
    • 02:10:29
      That was mandated by the, you know, obviously put in our Appropriations Act.
    • 02:10:33
      I think it was, I figured out it would have been cheaper for us to go and buy all the houses in the backyards where the sound wall would be than it would be to actually put up a sound wall.
    • 02:10:46
      I'm just destroying it.
    • 02:10:47
      Mr. Chairman.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:48
      Yes, Mr. Miller.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:49
      I'm trying to get up to speed here.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:52
      If I've got a road I'm building past a 20-story building, apartment building, and I've got
    • 02:11:00
      200 receptors in that department building.
    • 02:11:04
      Are you telling me it's reasonable to spend based on the 200 receptors in that 20-story building or whatever story it is?
    • 02:11:19
      How do you abate noise to a 20-story building?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:24
      Well, no, I'm sorry, but all you're doing in this calculation would be whether it's
    • 02:11:29
      Given that there are that many units in that, how many people would it put positively in that?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:36
      We can build 1,600 square feet of abatement for each unit.
    • 02:11:40
      So 1,600 square feet times 200.
    • 02:11:44
      Obviously you're not going to do that because you're not going to build a wall that high.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:50
      No, it's still a standard size, right?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:11:53
      We would look at the feasibility and the reasonableness of the wall.
    • 02:11:56
      If we can build it
    • 02:11:58
      to 200 feet, it just wouldn't be feasible to construct for a 20-story building.
    • 02:12:04
      So we're looking at barriers on the average of 20 to 30 feet tall because we start to lose the ability to abate noise at different heights.
    • 02:12:18
      So the way the models work, there are formulas that we're not going to be building walls to 200 feet.
    • 02:12:26
      The foundation on the walls themselves would require us just to take the building next to it.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:31
      I guess what I'm wondering, pardon me for being new and stupid, but as you drive along an interstate and you have noise abatement, they're not like gaps in the walls.
    • 02:12:42
      I mean, the wall goes the whole way.
    • 02:12:43
      It's whatever it is, what it is.
    • 02:12:46
      If my lot is three times bigger than the guy next door, you're not going to give me 1600 feet.
    • 02:12:52
      You're going to build the wall all the way down my lot.
    • 02:12:55
      If this lot is a third smaller, you're going to build a wall all the way down this lot.
    • 02:13:02
      Wouldn't it be, it's got to be ten feet tall, or it's got to be eight feet tall, and it's got to go down the whole lot line?
    • 02:13:09
      I don't get sort of the standard, whether there's some artificial number of square feet per receptor, it just doesn't mean anything to me.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:13:18
      The entire wall would be averaged
    • 02:13:21
      The entire wall would be averaged amongst all the receptors.
    • 02:13:24
      So if we had a linear length of homes that we had 30 homes, and half acre, quarter acre, half acre, quarter acre, that doesn't really matter from that standpoint.
    • 02:13:34
      We would say all 30 homes, if they were receiving the feasible reduction and method design goal of seven decibels of noise reduction, we would average the wall based on all 30 homes.
    • 02:13:49
      Now if we had 15 homes in the front,
    • 02:13:51
      and 15 in the back and only the 15 homes in the front were receiving the feasible reductions and method design goals that well would be designed for them.
    • 02:14:01
      We wouldn't build it to 30 feet tall just to try to get the visual or the noise reduction to the back receptors.
    • 02:14:10
      It would be built to 16 to 18 feet for just those front row receptors.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:15
      I guess I would have expected the standard, I won't belabor it, I'll try to figure it out later, but I expect the standard to be something about, or the policy to be something about the noise level.
    • 02:14:25
      You debate to a certain noise level, just like you debate to a certain ozone level, or a certain whatever level, and whatever you have to do to get there is what you'd be required to do to get there.
    • 02:14:37
      About 1,600 feet or 50,000 feet.
    • 02:14:40
      I don't understand sort of substituting a foot
    • 02:14:45
      or Price to a noise level.
    • 02:14:48
      Tell me what the noise level is.
    • 02:14:49
      Is it seven dBs or is it 10 dBs or whatever it is, I gotta bake to that level and what it costs is what it costs.
    • 02:14:57
      I'm not advocating that, but that would seem to be a reasonable way to look at a noise abatement standard, not something arbitrary, which is the cost of it or the length of it.
    • 02:15:09
      So yeah, it just doesn't make a lot of sense to me, but a lot of it.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:14
      Mr. Chairman, I find myself in complete agreement with my colleague from Virginia Beach.
    • 02:15:20
      I find this sort of a wrong-under-the-telescope way of looking at it.
    • 02:15:24
      I mean, suppose, to take this example further, you had, as you do in Northern Virginia, stretches of road with apartment buildings one after another, and then a mile or two away, you have a house every 60, 80 feet or so.
    • 02:15:42
      The two situations are the same in terms of noise abatement, but they produce a very different calculation according to this methodology, it would seem to me.
    • 02:15:54
      So again, what is the noise abatement you're trying to achieve, and what does it take to achieve that noise abatement level ought to be the standard, not
    • 02:16:08
      I mean I think this is a good case of bureaucracy totally not only using the English language badly but not even doing the right kind of calculation to say what the object is here which is to reduce noise levels not to say there's a bunch of apartment buildings here so according to that if I understood it right and I don't think I don't know that I do you're going to get 57,000 on average per
    • 02:16:35
      Apartment and there's lots of apartments for that mile versus 30 houses for that mile or some such number.
    • 02:16:42
      It doesn't make sense to me.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:16:45
      One thing I'd like you to spell is this number is not a design goal to meet.
    • 02:16:50
      We're not going to build 57,000 or 1,600 square foot for a receptor on every project.
    • 02:16:56
      That would be the upper limit that we can take it to for federal approval on our part.
    • 02:17:02
      Now you're correct that your calculation for multi-dwelling units versus single-family homes are going to be different, but that doesn't mean that we're going to be building different sized walls for these two units all the time.
    • 02:17:16
      We are putting into the noise policy that we're trying to achieve at least 7 to 10 decibels of noise reduction.
    • 02:17:23
      We chose 7 decibels of noise reduction to err on the conservative side, and we tried to build our walls to produce at least 10 decibels of noise reduction, which is about half the noise level they would be experiencing.
    • 02:17:37
      So there are more factors into it than just the square footage and the cost, but we are evading the noise levels as well.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:45
      And I'm sorry, but the one thing I do, I shouldn't probably say this, but the one thing I do take a little bit of comfort with the higher number is at some point, these alternatives, which the General Assembly and others have pushed, whether it's designing so we go further down or different types of pavements or more trees and other types of foliage, at some point they start becoming more
    • 02:18:15
      As of right now, we don't have the right way space along the major corridors to do the required amount of landscaping for proper noise reduction.
    • 02:18:40
      I drive along these projects and see as we kill all the damn trees to put these sound walls up.
    • 02:18:49
      I mean, it's crazy.
    • 02:18:52
      I mean, we drive along and it's like, oh, look, there was a beautiful forest.
    • 02:18:58
      Now I've got a beautiful graffiti attractor.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:01
      So we have receptors, now we have some graffiti.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:19:07
      Welcome to the latest and greatest federal technology.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:11
      One other odd thing is that, and I'm sorry, the one thing I, again, this is one of the great benefits in local government is when we start to put these sound walls up, we start having sound problems where we never had sound problems before.
    • 02:19:24
      I mean, I remember we put up sound walls along the 234 bypass.
    • 02:19:29
      The next thing you know, we have the Manassas Speedway.
    • 02:19:32
      And next thing you know, I'm getting complaints from
    • 02:19:35
      The middle of my county miles away because people, the sound is hitting that wall and it's bouncing and it finally lands maybe half a mile away depending on what, or a mile away depending on what the atmospheric conditions.
    • 02:19:50
      How do we take that into consideration when we're doing this stuff?
    • 02:19:52
      We don't.
    • 02:19:53
      We just worry about the adjacent parts.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:19:55
      Actually, all of the sound barriers in Virginia, I would, let me back up, 95% of our sound barriers in Virginia are actually absorbent material.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:02
      They said that about the stealth aircraft too.
    • 02:20:06
      They said that about the stealth aircraft and the Iraqis were, whatever, I'm sorry.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:20:14
      We don't take into consideration future developments of racetracks, other areas that are outside of VDOT's control.
    • 02:20:22
      We are trying to evade noise for the highway transportation project that is going through that area.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:20:29
      But to get back on track a little bit, cost is just one of the many factors that included, that's probably the most among this group controversial.
    • 02:20:39
      We have to get a certain amount of noise reduction to make these reasonable and feasible.
    • 02:20:44
      And as Paul spoke, the seven for exterior noise levels and one of the dinot wall for a 10 decibel loss.
    • 02:20:51
      The other thing, a couple changes we have, right now we have to send letters out to the receptors and ask, what do they think about this wall if we propose it?
    • 02:20:59
      The current policy says 50% or more of the notified receptors have to write back and say, yes, they want the wall.
    • 02:21:06
      Well, a lot of areas where these walls are, people are really transitional.
    • 02:21:11
      Northern Virginia people move all the time.
    • 02:21:15
      To get 50% back was positive, was hard.
    • 02:21:20
      So we've gone back to 50% or greater of the people that decide to respond.
    • 02:21:23
      A lot of people just throw the letter in the corner and don't respond, it's from the state.
    • 02:21:27
      but they don't pay a lot of attention to it.
    • 02:21:29
      So we want to change that from 50% of the greater who we notified to 50% of the ones that respond back saying yes or no.
    • 02:21:41
      We send it to the property owner of record.
    • 02:21:45
      But a lot of places are vacant, people don't get the mail.
    • 02:21:48
      I know down north at Virginia Beach a lot of Navy people move around and things and the landlords don't respond.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:21:56
      Are you looking at the lots?
    • 02:21:59
      Is it just adjacent to the wall or is there a certain criteria?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:22:02
      Do you have to have what the federal regulation defines as a receptor?
    • 02:22:06
      So it has to be that squishy receptor word defined under federal regulation.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:22:12
      I know I live about
    • 02:22:14
      I can almost see the Interstate 64 from my house even if it wasn't for lots behind where a new wall was going in and I don't ever recall getting... No, you would have the benefit of receptor which is right in the line of that wall.
    • 02:22:27
      Is this where new construction is going to take place?
    • 02:22:30
      Let me give you an example of Northern Virginia.
    • 02:22:34
      If we resolve the situation in Arlington and the hot lanes are at it, will that criteria, will those standards have to be then looked at along the 395 corridor
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:22:49
      As of right now, there's not formal guidance for re-evaluation of environmental documents.
    • 02:22:56
      My indication would be that we would be operating under the old policy versus the new policy.
    • 02:23:02
      So we would have to present that to FHWA to get a final ruling on that.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:23:09
      I'm sorry, Ms. Lang.
    • 02:23:11
      Technically, so this cost would go into the Six-Year Plan?
    • 02:23:15
      I mean, this is built into the cost of the road?
    • 02:23:17
      Part of the PE cost.
    • 02:23:18
      Part of the PE cost, so you build that in.
    • 02:23:19
      Part of the PE cost.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:23:20
      Well, part of the PE and part of the construction cost when you get into the construction part.
    • 02:23:24
      The design part would be PE.
    • 02:23:25
      Construction would be part of the construction cost.
    • 02:23:28
      Thank you.
    • 02:23:29
      Feasibility criteria, five decibel noise reduction.
    • 02:23:32
      The new cost would be 5% reduction at 50% of the greater of the impacted receptors.
    • 02:23:39
      A different one, Exterior Area Frequent Use.
    • 02:23:42
      Right now it's the outdoor ground floor.
    • 02:23:45
      The new federal policy kind of ties us into this.
    • 02:23:48
      When no outdoor area exists, balconies are to be considered an outdoor usage area, and that's still undefined, and no barrier height was defined.
    • 02:23:56
      So that's really a big undefined area right now that the feds have to define.
    • 02:24:03
      When undeveloped lands are considered,
    • 02:24:07
      Now we'll call them permitted before when the zoning had changed to a residential criteria prior to when the board acted on approval of the alignment.
    • 02:24:17
      That land was considered developed and you had to consider the noise abatement now to be defined as building permit issuance in that area because we've had land set approved for development that has set vacant and you go in and put a wall up and then the people down the road go, why did that vacant piece of land get a wall versus a development that the first building permit has been issued.
    • 02:24:37
      Third party funding right now, if you can add money if you're a receptor to bring, if that criteria was above $30,000 for your wall at your area, say it was $32,000, you could give $2,000.
    • 02:24:54
      The feds have encouraged us to go away from that because some areas and some communities, people have more money to do that than others in economically depressed areas.
    • 02:25:02
      That will only be used third party funding for aesthetics.
    • 02:25:05
      and I think the city of Virginia Beach does some of that now for aesthetics on their walls.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:11
      Are you saying that if somebody wants to give you some money to make the wall better you can't take it anymore?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:25:18
      We will not under the new policy.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:25:20
      That's just absurd.
    • 02:25:22
      What's the reason for that?
    • 02:25:23
      Mr. Sterling.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:26
      Federal environmental justice.
    • 02:25:28
      If somebody wants to donate money
    • 02:25:31
      Make it more static.
    • 02:25:32
      No, they can do it as static.
    • 02:25:34
      Just to fill the wall.
    • 02:25:35
      What if they make it more effective in attenuating noise, then you can't.
    • 02:25:44
      Why don't you guys pull up a theme and let's chat a little bit more.
    • 02:25:49
      You really thought this was going to be an easy one.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:25:51
      No, sir.
    • 02:25:53
      Right now, if we have a wall and we do our calculation and it's above $30,000 receptor, let's say we have 10 homes, it's $35,000 receptor, those 10 homes could contribute $5,000 to build a wall for noise reduction.
    • 02:26:07
      Now, under the new policy, we will not be allowed to do that because it's considered an environmental justice issue.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 02:26:12
      and environmental justice.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:16
      They would contribute $5,000.
    • 02:26:18
      Who determined that?
    • 02:26:19
      Some bureaucrat in Washington or I hope it wasn't us in Richmond?
    • 02:26:24
      Mr. Walton, did you determine that?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:26:29
      No, Mr. Secretary, I don't take credit for that.
    • 02:26:31
      Environmental justice is a huge issue for the federal government.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 02:26:34
      Because minority neighborhoods, low-income neighborhoods have sued over environmental justice because they don't get the same as the wealthier neighborhoods.
    • 02:26:42
      So because of that issue.
    • 02:26:43
      Wait a minute.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:44
      Let me ask you a question.
    • 02:26:45
      I'm the charitable foundation for noise attenuation in poor neighborhoods.
    • 02:26:52
      I want to donate money so they can put up a wall.
    • 02:26:54
      You're telling me we can't take the money and put up a wall to protect the poor neighborhood from sound because it's donated money.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:00
      Correct.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:01
      I mean, is there a court case on this?
    • 02:27:02
      I mean, do we have to do this?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:27:04
      I'm not aware of a court case on Noisewall, but there are a number of cases dealing with environmental justice.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:09
      So is this our interpretation to make sure we don't have... No, this is Federal Highways.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:27:15
      This is there.
    • 02:27:15
      You will not have a third party funding.
    • 02:27:18
      That's part of their regulation.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:19
      I would recommend Federal Highways if there's a representative from Federal Highways here, which there generally is, has made a gross mistake in this particular area.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 02:27:27
      If I could explain the point of many federal regulations, I'd be extremely wealthy.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:41
      If you've been threatening to sue them, can you sue them on everything?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:47
      I'll sue them on everything.
    • 02:27:48
      I'm ready to go.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:27:50
      What's the penalty if we do it?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:27:52
      No federal funding.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:27:54
      That's a pretty big one.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:58
      A spending clause routine.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:04
      Everybody shh.
    • 02:28:06
      Okay.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:10
      Yes, this is Sterling.
    • 02:28:12
      The hot lanes.
    • 02:28:14
      Part of that includes that the company that's building the hot lanes is putting up sound walls on some of these where they're going to impact.
    • 02:28:22
      Last I heard, these companies are third parties.
    • 02:28:24
      Are we now not going to be able to get sand walls on the pot lanes where it's a third-party involvement?
    • 02:28:28
      No.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:28:28
      They have to comply with federal funding.
    • 02:28:30
      They have to comply to the same regulations we would.
    • 02:28:33
      They're third-party as far as the constructors.
    • 02:28:37
      They're not third-party as far as the recipient of noise mitigation.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:40
      So in this case, they're not considered third-party.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:42
      It's just if a neighborhood wants to do it, the company can.
    • 02:28:51
      I know I must have misinterpreted so I'm going to have to clarify for me why I'm mistaken that you cannot contribute to a barrier because of social justice issues except for aesthetics, but wouldn't people contributing for aesthetics be much less likely to be disadvantaged?
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:14
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:29:14
      Usually aesthetics are localities.
    • 02:29:17
      Virginia Beach does some aesthetics.
    • 02:29:19
      On the look of the wall, they'll contribute towards buying the mold that maybe makes it look like it has waves on the wall.
    • 02:29:26
      I don't know if you've been to Salt Lake City, but you see the Wasatch Mountains outlined on their barriers and the seagulls.
    • 02:29:32
      It's kind of a local identity that this would allow localities to contribute to have a wall that kind of identifies a locale.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:41
      I'm interpreting that as yes, that more advantaged people can contribute.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:29:48
      No, sir, this would just be for the looks of the wall, not for the wall itself.
    • 02:29:52
      You'd still have the wall.
    • 02:29:54
      It would have no effect on having the wall or not having the wall.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:01
      They would be more likely, people who are going to pay for aesthetics are much less likely to be disadvantaged to start with.
    • 02:30:08
      Okay, so it kind of runs counter to the social justice reason for
    • 02:30:15
      Okay, to wrap up, we have to have our policy and guidance met on the Federal Highway by January 13th.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:30:32
      Concurrently, there were review both at Federal Highway Headquarters and Division Office in the resource centers.
    • 02:30:38
      They're trying to get some consistency nationally.
    • 02:30:43
      You can see some dates here.
    • 02:30:44
      January 13th they'll review it.
    • 02:30:45
      It comes back to us for comment.
    • 02:30:48
      Federal Highway will approve it by April 13th.
    • 02:30:51
      Then we will come back to this board probably in May with the new policy for adoption.
    • 02:31:00
      VDOT will follow all procedures.
    • 02:31:01
      This policy needs to be effective by July 13th.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:08
      We have to pass this today.
    • 02:31:10
      No sir, not today.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:31:11
      We will bring it back to you in May.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:14
      This is just a briefing today.
    • 02:31:15
      Alright, but what we, it's quite obvious there's a great deal of concern among the board members about this.
    • 02:31:23
      Could you guys also bring us back a resolution for us to send to the Federal Highway Administration, raising our concerns?
    • 02:31:32
      At least let's get on the record for what we think are some fairly absurd
    • 02:31:38
      I recognize her federal regulations, but at least let's just get it.
    • 02:31:46
      Let's bend our spleen.
    • 02:31:47
      Let's get it out.
    • 02:31:48
      But I do think people don't start complaining about this stuff.
    • 02:31:51
      I mean, the cost involved in these town walls, it's just astronomical.
    • 02:31:56
      I mean, when you do look at the cost of building any sort of capacity these days for our transportation system, the construction of the actual
    • 02:32:08
      Road is the cheapest part of it now.
    • 02:32:10
      It's the sound walls, it's the right-of-way, it's the consulting, the engineer, all the stuff that goes up front.
    • 02:32:20
      I think it's quite obvious that the board does not feel very comfortable with some of these things in here.
    • 02:32:25
      Maybe we're going to have to massage it because there might be different views on this, but I think we should raise things like if somebody privately wants to go and contribute money, other than aesthetics,
    • 02:32:37
      I mean, it seems to, as Mr. Martin was pointing out, seems to completely run contrary to what they say they're trying to do.
    • 02:32:47
      So again, just something for us to go and send to the Federal Highway Administration in Washington about our concerns.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:54
      The resolution provided, we also communicate that to the delegation, the congressional delegation.
    • 02:32:58
      I think maybe they need to be aware of what the individuals within the agencies are doing on this.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:33:03
      We have had situations where developers have built sound walls on their property and many places people think it's a VDOT constructed wall but it's not.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:33:16
      So I mean to the extent that a neighborhood or someone wants to put up a sound wall they will be able to, they just need to reserve some property on their side of the boundary.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:33:34
      And Mr. Garczynski, the people of Prince William County, welcome.
    • 02:33:39
      Thank you very much for those great sound walls you bought for people.
    • 02:33:43
      But the thing is, I mean, there's some point this stuff is getting, it's such a catch-22.
    • 02:33:48
      And I mean, there are instances, I mean, right now, I know at least three or four different places in Northern Virginia, but I keep on getting contacts from people where there's gaps in the walls.
    • 02:33:59
      and they were asking, in fact one was actually saying that the neighborhood would kick in the money and I think we've already told them that we couldn't do it because the other problem was the right-of-way.
    • 02:34:13
      So they would build the continuation in our right-of-way and we told them that we would not be able to accept the money to do it.
    • 02:34:19
      So I think it's just important that we start to get on record some of our concerns.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:34:26
      Okay, Artie?
    • 02:34:26
      Yes?
    • 02:34:27
      One final question.
    • 02:34:29
      How do you determine the linear length of wall that you're actually going to construct based off the receptors?
    • 02:34:36
      Because I know all the criteria seems to be in depth, but I think that would answer some of the questions about that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:34:44
      The noise model helps us determine that, but a good rule of thumb is three times the distance in length from the furthest receptor back.
    • 02:34:52
      So if your furthest impact of receptor is 50 feet, we would go 150 feet beyond it.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:34:58
      How much out of the six-year plan is spent on these things?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:35:07
      Do you have any idea?
    • 02:35:11
      It's just all part of the whole project cost.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:13
      You wouldn't say it's significant?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:35:15
      I wouldn't say it's significant.
    • 02:35:17
      I would say it's a good amount, but I don't like that cost.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:19
      Is it for interstate and primary?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:35:22
      Mainly, but you'll occasionally have it on secondary, but usually your driveways and things are too concentrated.
    • 02:35:28
      Oh, Fairfax County Parkway Secondary?
    • 02:35:32
      You went on some of these special secondaries.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:34
      But if it has federal money against it.
    • 02:35:36
      Right.
    • 02:35:37
      You have to study it anyway.
    • 02:35:38
      If it has federal money, that's the case.
    • 02:35:41
      We have to study it.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:35:42
      And most times it's not reasonably feasible because of the driveways or cost or a lot of other factories can't get you noise reduction.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:50
      And most of our federal dollars are going towards already existing roads.
    • 02:35:55
      One of the problems you all have is that
    • 02:35:57
      We then have to go back and retrofit what were old walls into the new standards, is that right?
    • 02:36:04
      In different places.
    • 02:36:05
      Because right, the old walls were different, don't meet some of these standards?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:36:10
      The only time we address old walls, we physically touch them with our project.
    • 02:36:15
      Right.
    • 02:36:19
      All right, listen, we're going to have to, we're way behind.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:36:31
      Appreciate it very much.
    • 02:36:36
      Why are we so lively?
    • 02:36:37
      We should hold more meetings up here at Roso.
    • 02:36:40
      Actually, we're going to wait for Mr. Lawson.
    • 02:36:46
      Right now we're going to have Rita.
    • 02:36:48
      We're going to bring you up, Ms. Busher.
    • 02:36:50
      We're going to talk about CMAC RSTP.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:36:53
      Now that we're all warmed up.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:37:03
      Okay, Mr. Chairman, members of the board,
    • 02:37:17
      The purpose of this presentation is to first answer some questions that came up at the last board meeting when there were hybrid vehicles presented as an amendment CMAC project to the six-year program from the Northern Virginia MPO.
    • 02:37:39
      So we want to talk about that.
    • 02:37:42
      Since we were going to bring this forward,
    • 02:37:45
      We thought we would also talk a little bit about the language in the Appropriations Act that relate to the obligation and spending of CMAQ and RSVP funds and then provide some recommendations on moving forward to implement the appropriation language and the rules.
    • 02:38:10
      First, on what qualifies projects for
    • 02:38:14
      CMAQ eligibility.
    • 02:38:19
      There are four categories, capital investment, operation assistance, mission reduction planning and project development.
    • 02:38:27
      Now when it comes to capital investment, basically CMAQ funds can be used to establish new or expanded transportation projects or programs that reduce emissions
    • 02:38:40
      including capital investments and infrastructure, congestion, relief efforts, diesel engine retrofits, or other capital projects.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:49
      Yes, you have.
    • 02:38:51
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:38:53
      The one thing that I've been seeing this, what is actually which generates the CMAQ funds?
    • 02:38:59
      Like with enhancement program, we know that's 10% of surface transportation.
    • 02:39:03
      The amount of CMAQ funds that come into a Commonwealth that are divided into the MPOs, localities,
    • 02:39:09
      Where does that come from?
    • 02:39:10
      What is that model?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:39:12
      It relates to the non-attainment and maintenance areas.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:16
      So is it a dollar per person in the non-attainment area?
    • 02:39:20
      What generates the money?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:39:24
      It's federal funding based on the severity of the non-attainment area and some other factors.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:29
      So the PMAs that we were talking about is specific to PMAs, not the non-TMA areas?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:39:37
      It just so happens in Virginia that the TMAs are non-attainment areas.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:41
      That's not always the case.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:39:49
      We can also use CMAC funds for operation assistance that's limited to new transit services, intermodal facilities, travel demand management strategies, and incremental costs of expanding existing
    • 02:40:03
      Transit Services.
    • 02:40:05
      Now the concept of using CMAQ for operation assistance is that it's basically seed money and eventually permanent sources will be found for the operation of a facility and it is limited to three years of operation assistance on one project.
    • 02:40:24
      The emission reduction obviously is what it sounds.
    • 02:40:29
      CMAQ invested projects that reduce the
    • 02:40:34
      The emissions that are taken into consideration for determination of non-attainment areas.
    • 02:40:41
      And then planning and project development, studies that are part of a project development pipeline under the National Environmental Policy Act or NEPA are eligible for CMAQ support.
    • 02:40:57
      General studies fall outside of specific project development
    • 02:41:02
      Qualification, so it has to be related to a specific project.
    • 02:41:08
      Where CMAQ funds can be used, as we were just mentioning, in all non-attainment and maintenance areas or in proximity, a locality that's in proximity to a non-attainment and maintenance area is that the air quality benefits will be realized within the non-attainment or maintenance area.
    • 02:41:30
      Basically, EPA designations of non-attainment areas are only based on violations of national air quality standards for carbon monoxide, lead, nitrogen dioxide, ozone, particulate matter, and sulfur dioxide.
    • 02:41:46
      And please don't ask me any details about either of those items.
    • 02:41:51
      Now, we only to date have one non-attainment area.
    • 02:41:56
      That's in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:41:57
      We have three
    • 02:41:59
      Maintenance areas, the light blue, the lime green, and the orange on the map on the slide.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:42:09
      When you say that's the planning area, is that following what are the planning organizations or are those actual maintenance areas that you recognize?
    • 02:42:20
      Is there a subset of those?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:42:22
      I think there are subsets.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:42:25
      Because it's got the whole district.
    • 02:42:27
      To me, it looks like it's reflecting planning districts rather than maintenance areas or attainment areas.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:42:33
      Boundaries for non-attainment and maintenance areas are determined based on a lot of factors.
    • 02:42:38
      In Virginia, for the most part, they coincide with the MPO boundaries, but that's not always the case.
    • 02:42:47
      So the boundaries you see there are still MPO.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:42:48
      But is the maintenance areas supposed to be your non-attainment areas supposed to be based on the amount of pollutants in the air, et cetera?
    • 02:42:54
      I'm pretty sure that pollutants don't stop at the county lines as I'm looking at them up here.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:42:59
      No, generally when EPA designates an area, there's a desire to have a whole jurisdiction designated rather than a small portion.
    • 02:43:06
      It makes implementation of regulations easier in the non-attainment area.
    • 02:43:12
      It prevents inequity.
    • 02:43:15
      Gas stations on one side of the line have to use a certain kind of gas versus on another side of the line.
    • 02:43:22
      It's just easier to implement the regulations that way.
    • 02:43:24
      So that's typically how it's done, but not always.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:43:27
      I guess the point, like we were saying before in the Roanoke presentation, you know, where the monitors are placed throughout the entire area, you know, the maintenance area.
    • 02:43:37
      However, if one monitor goes off, you know, then it affects the whole area.
    • 02:43:42
      So you may have a rural area way out, you know, that wouldn't have a zone problem.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:48
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:43:49
      Right.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:49
      But I think some rural areas are listed on here.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:43:52
      That's right.
    • 02:43:53
      If you go out to the western side of Isle of Wight, you're not going to have a problem there.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:43:58
      Northern Gloucester, you know, that you would, let's say, at Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel, but because of the maintenance area, it affects the whole region of it.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:44:11
      If that's correct.
    • 02:44:12
      Some examples of CMAC projects that we have in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 02:44:17
      Major Investment Study in NOVA for Alexandria, Potomac Yard Transit Analysis, Commuter Preference Studies of Richmond, a new marketing campaign to educate users about transit technology, modal market surveys, one in Fredericksburg, a transit master plan in the NOVA area, and alternative fuels and vehicles, which is the hybrid vehicles.
    • 02:44:45
      and that is a qualifying project for CMAQ funding and there are many others and we've left a document at your seat that shows a longer list of those.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:12
      I guess it could be either.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:45:20
      CMEK projects, programmatic requirements, they must be included in the planning and programming documents, both for the MPO and for VDOT, so these projects
    • 02:45:40
      Now, your specific question was if you have the ability to deny an amendment to add a CMAQ funded project to the Six-Year Improvement Program as requested by an MPO.
    • 02:46:01
      The answer is yes.
    • 02:46:04
      You can be more restrictive in your guidelines
    • 02:46:08
      In the federal regulations, you just can't be less.
    • 02:46:13
      So in this regard, if this board wanted to establish a policy that they determined they liked some categories of federal funding type projects using CMAQ, you could limit it or recommend to the MPOs to submit those types of projects.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:37
      The question that came up at the meeting was, who's got responsibility and authority in this particular case?
    • 02:46:44
      And it's my understanding that in CMAC, the state really is the one that's responsible and has the authority, but delegates that to the MPOs.
    • 02:46:52
      Is that correct?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:46:53
      Well, I'm just getting to that.
    • 02:46:54
      Yes.
    • 02:46:55
      Yes.
    • 02:46:56
      That's correct.
    • 02:46:59
      Part of what we wanted to bring back today, and I'll get to that part of it,
    • 02:47:04
      You all received the letter, I think, from the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority was addressed to the Secretary and you all were copied.
    • 02:47:14
      They indicated that the CTB had in fact delegated the ability to allocate for themselves, they were referring to the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, that we had delegated to them the authority without preconditions
    • 02:47:33
      to provide recommendations for the use of CMAQ projects and that they just needed to follow the federal regulations.
    • 02:47:42
      What the authority is asking of the board is that if there are to be conditions placed on the use of CMAQ funds for projects that weren't there before, that the board adopt a policy with those more restrictive conditions
    • 02:48:03
      So that they know that prior to them submitting a project, and they would follow our guidance in that regard, as would the other MPOs in the state that receive CMAC funding.
    • 02:48:14
      They just would like to know up front, because prior to this actual decline in their hybrid vehicle submission, we had been approving those type of projects.
    • 02:48:28
      Before we actually get to that topic, because we're looking at CMAQ funding and the fact that that is something that as a policy VDOT has chosen to pass that project allocation process to the MPOs, we'd like to provide you with some additional information on how the CMAQ and RSVP funding is being spent by the MPOs.
    • 02:48:56
      This chart shows the CMAQ allocations by MPOs.
    • 02:49:01
      You've got FAMPO, HRTPO, NOVA, Richmond, and Tri-Cities.
    • 02:49:08
      The total MPO allocations previous to the program you just adopted and through the 11 through 16 program you adopted in June, total MPO allocations is approximately 300.7 million.
    • 02:49:27
      Total MPO unprogrammed balance is 190 million, about 63 percent unprogrammed to projects today.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:41
      This is the six-year plan and any previous allocations, funding that was allocated prior to 11.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:49:57
      Is this part of the audit?
    • 02:49:59
      We're looking at those numbers.
    • 02:50:00
      Is this part of that?
    • 02:50:02
      Whoever, I don't know if you can answer that.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:04
      Yes, some of this was.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:50:06
      It could be, yes.
    • 02:50:10
      There are a couple of things we've done.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:12
      We had looked at all these balances before trying to identify inactive balances, but a portion of these could be considered as inactive balances, not necessarily all of them.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:50:27
      Actually in addition to this, we have another slide that shows actual money allocated to projects that are inactive and that had no expenses even though they've been allocated.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:39
      So the audit really looked backwards at what has not, that was money from previous years or even this year that has not been allocated and was spent.
    • 02:50:49
      This is essentially looking in our six-year plan looking out where 63% of their dollars
    • 02:50:56
      You have different methods that the different MPOs employ.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:51:07
      For example, if you look at FAMPO, what they've done is they've only allocated FY11 because their full allocations for 12-16 are still unprogrammed.
    • 02:51:19
      But you look at Hampton Roads, this year for the first time of the 11-16,
    • 02:51:25
      They programmed or allocated to projects for 11, 12, 13, and 14, and 15, a good piece of their allocations.
    • 02:51:38
      But they didn't allocate anything in 16 to projects yet.
    • 02:51:42
      Prior to that, they were doing it one year at a time, one or two years at a time.
    • 02:51:46
      And we had met with them and recommended that they try to program all six years and plan
    • 02:51:53
      The allocations based on project development schedules.
    • 02:51:56
      NOVA only does one year at a time.
    • 02:51:58
      Richmond is kind of a mix.
    • 02:52:02
      They did four years, and they didn't do 15 and 16, and Tri-Cities did four, sort of, but they left a half a million each year.
    • 02:52:14
      I mean, yes.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:52:16
      Yeah.
    • 02:52:17
      What is their reasoning for not wanting to program?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:52:21
      Making decisions, they tend to look at the request for one year and what they do then is they fully fund or front load the funding for a project which is going to take years to spend.
    • 02:52:35
      So what happens is even when they allocate, they're not spending and then they still have to do the PE, if there's right-of-way they have to do the right-of-way, then they get to construction but they may be sitting on seven or eight million dollars in ten or nine
    • 02:52:51
      as they're working through the development of the project.
    • 02:52:55
      We're meeting with the MPOs.
    • 02:52:56
      We had two meetings yesterday and we're starting to explain a better method of allocating based on project schedules and estimates.
    • 02:53:06
      That way you leverage your money each year across more projects and you get phases moving.
    • 02:53:13
      But I think the concern historically has been a locality wants to see all the money.
    • 02:53:19
      that then they feel like they're safe, they're comfortable, that project's funded, then we'll look at something else later and we'll move a project forward.
    • 02:53:27
      So.
    • 02:53:27
      Yeah.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:28
      And to kind of go along as someone who sat there and on NPO, I mean, when I saw what would happen with this money was we would either buy, I'm going to say buy things like buses or municipal vehicles or we would use the money to fill gaps
    • 02:53:47
      on projects that maybe were not fully funded but might be eligible for CMAQ.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:53:51
      The local allocations through the construction formula for primary, secondary, and open.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:56
      And then I got to tell you what the worst part was, was that, I mean, we did divvy it up.
    • 02:54:00
      We sat there with the MPO and said, here's Prince Williams, here's Stafford, here's whatever.
    • 02:54:06
      And that's...
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:54:07
      There's that happening as well.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:08
      Yeah.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:54:09
      And they do it one year at a time.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:11
      But that's just NOVA.
    • 02:54:12
      The rest, I mean, this money is supposed to be being used for congestion mitigation, air quality, and instead it's sort of where are we that near?
    • 02:54:20
      What do we need that year instead of looking at long-term to try to find ways to reduce congestion mitigation.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:27
      Mr. Sorrell.
    • 02:54:27
      Mr. Church, your last point that, and I've seen this happening where, you know, the purpose of the program is congestion mitigation, improving air quality.
    • 02:54:38
      I see the same thing where the decisions are really made politically.
    • 02:54:41
      What is, you know, they divvy it up amongst whatever the localities are, here's your share, here's your share.
    • 02:54:46
      It may not go to the best priority within an area.
    • 02:54:50
      It may not even go to the best priority within that locality, but hey, it's their share and they're going to spend it on some project.
    • 02:54:56
      If this is something we have responsibility for, we have the authority for, but we delegated it, I think we need to have policies that are focusing these
    • 02:55:07
      on the higher priorities, whether we have policies or whether we reclaim that delegated authority, I think that's a decision that has to be made.
    • 02:55:14
      But at the very least, we need to have some kind of policies that make this not a political decision, but an actual congestion, mitigation, air quality decision.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:25
      I agree with that wholeheartedly.
    • 02:55:27
      I mean, this is big money.
    • 02:55:29
      And as I understand it, we can use the CMACs under the real project
    • 02:55:33
      So we have these same jurisdictions.
    • 02:55:35
      I've seen them on the morning news saying, cascadating commonwealth, they're not providing any money, they don't have any money for this or that.
    • 02:55:44
      And so, it might be wasted on the news when we can't really focus this.
    • 02:55:51
      Let's keep going.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:56:08
      This next slide is the RSVP allocations by MPO.
    • 02:56:12
      Now this is based on distribution to the TMAs and we do not
    • 02:56:18
      have the authority to pull back in the allocations of RSTP.
    • 02:56:23
      But we have some other authority that recent legislation has given to us that I want to talk about.
    • 02:56:29
      But first let me give you the similar statistics for the RSTP allocation.
    • 02:56:34
      Total MPO allocations prior to the 11 through 16 program and including the 11 through 16 program is $434 million.
    • 02:56:46
      They've only
    • 02:56:47
      They have not programmed 278 million.
    • Mark J. PeakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:53
      Regional Surface Transportation.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:57:01
      There is other STP funding, but it's not designated specifically for the TMAs.
    • 02:57:08
      It's something that we, it's a statewide distribution that VDOT is making.
    • 02:57:13
      We've pulled that in as well.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:15
      There's a loaded question.
    • 02:57:18
      How's this money generated?
    • 02:57:20
      How's it identified and allocated to the variance?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:57:24
      It's population-based.
    • 02:57:26
      It's the 200,000 and above.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:29
      I don't know the answer to that.
    • 02:57:33
      It's created somewhat of a little problem in the area in which I live.
    • 02:57:39
      Yes, it is.
    • 02:57:39
      This is money that's been allocated according to the PMAs that are $200,000 or more.
    • 02:57:45
      But it's being spent outside of the areas where it's being generated in some cases.
    • 02:57:52
      And this is a legal issue as to nobody's really certain whether or not there's various interpretations on that loss.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:58:00
      I think FHWA, though, has indicated that as long as the two
    • 02:58:07
      There's agreement among the parties, and that agreement is restated to that effect.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:58:14
      In one case, there's no agreement that's even been reached on that particular issue.
    • 02:58:17
      Right.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:58:18
      Right.
    • 02:58:19
      So there is that issue.
    • 02:58:21
      But this in and of itself is similar in that their approach to programming these dollars has been similar.
    • 02:58:30
      It's been, you've got a tremendous amount of money sitting.
    • 02:58:35
      Especially in the Hampton Roads and the Nova Enrichment Area.
    • 02:58:42
      Is it correct?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:58:43
      The purpose is to correct congestion or, I'm going to call it congestion, problems in the urbanized area to address the most critical needs in those urbanized areas where the money is being generated and allocated?
    • 02:58:56
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:58:58
      The money's not being generated.
    • 02:59:00
      It's being allocated.
    • 02:59:02
      Right.
    • 02:59:02
      Right.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:59:03
      And this is about a 64% ratio as well in terms of what's been programmed and what has not.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:10
      Mr.
    • 02:59:10
      Keen, then Mr. Rich.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:12
      Rita, the planning districts are not involved here.
    • 02:59:17
      Do we have a similar situation with the planning districts?
    • 02:59:20
      No.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 02:59:20
      No.
    • 02:59:21
      Now, keep in mind what is happening as the Roanoke Valley
    • 02:59:26
      MPO presented to you today as populations change and as a new census comes out, there could be new areas identified as TMAs.
    • 02:59:37
      And with the new EPA regulations that was also spoken to you about by the Roanoke Valley MPO, there could be more non-attainment areas.
    • 02:59:53
      So Virginia could be in the near term receiving more RSVP and CMAC funds, but probably not enough for the regions that currently get it to be held harmless when we get new areas.
    • 03:00:12
      So some new areas of the state can be receiving some new RSVP and CMAC, but some of the others that are getting it now will lose a little bit in the midst.
    • 03:00:22
      So there is that likelihood coming down in the near term.
    • 03:00:28
      And that's a bigger reason for us to also be concerned about how this money is being programmed timely.
    • 03:00:37
      And we have to meet federal strategy.
    • 03:00:39
      And that's our major issue here is without these hundreds of millions of dollars, we're having a hard time meeting federal strategy.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:46
      And this money is not match money either, right?
    • 03:00:49
      Excuse me?
    • 03:00:49
      This is not match money.
    • 03:00:51
      This is 100 percent federal.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:00:52
      No, it is.
    • 03:00:53
      We match these funds.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:56
      But who provides the match?
    • 03:00:57
      VDOT.
    • 03:00:58
      Of the 20% here.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:01:01
      We chose to do that.
    • 03:01:03
      It could be local match.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:05
      Mr. Rich, then Mr. Miller.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:07
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:01:10
      There was a list of criteria
    • 03:01:13
      for expenditures for CMAQ.
    • 03:01:15
      Is there a list for this RSTP?
    • 03:01:16
      Is it in here?
    • 03:01:17
      Is it in the bank?
    • 03:01:19
      So it's a different list.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:23
      The FTP funding, federal funding is one of the most flexible kinds of funding you can use it for.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:29
      We figured that out.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 03:01:30
      Yeah, and we can get you the same kind of listing for that, but it is one of the most flexible types of federal funding.
    • 03:01:37
      You can add capacity with RSTP where you can't do that with CMAQ.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:01:42
      Turn Lanes, you could use it for transit activities, you can use it for planning studies if you really wanted to.
    • 03:01:52
      It's very flexible.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:54
      So like the metro system that needs a lot of work, they could be putting some of this money to metro?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:01:58
      I do believe they could.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:59
      Safety issues and other...
    • 03:02:02
      I see.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:02:03
      I can get you a similar printout for STP funding.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:07
      This is amazing.
    • 03:02:08
      We're matching 10% of them.
    • 03:02:12
      Twenty.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:14
      You know, and I've got to say, one of the problems is certain communities, obviously, like Prince William, Louden.
    • 03:02:22
      I mean, we had a Transportation Department, so we could use this money.
    • 03:02:28
      Others didn't have it.
    • 03:02:29
      I saw a couple use it for curb and gutters.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:37
      My question is sort of fundamental but I think I already know the answer but I'll ask anyway.
    • 03:02:44
      It would be possible for us to change the rules of the way this money is allocated to the MPOs
    • 03:02:53
      and hold them more accountable with timeframes within which it has to be spent or it gets refunded back to us to be reallocated?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:03:01
      I think I'm two slides from that.
    • 03:03:04
      We want to talk about that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:06
      Why don't we speed this up a little bit?
    • 03:03:08
      I apologize.
    • 03:03:09
      It's not your fault.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:03:15
      This slide here talks about inactive CMEK and RSVP projects.
    • 03:03:20
      What we deem to be inactive, this is
    • 03:03:22
      This is VDOT is when you have allocations and obligations on projects, but nothing has been spent on those projects.
    • 03:03:30
      So no money has gone out the door.
    • 03:03:32
      We haven't received our reimbursement from FHWA.
    • 03:03:35
      Now this is as of the adoption of the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 03:03:41
      CMEK and RSVP had been allocated about $167 million on projects that had an estimate on those projects totaling a little over $300 million.
    • 03:03:52
      Only $16.5 million of that has been obligated, and nothing has been spent today.
    • 03:04:01
      So not only do we have unallocated money on projects, we have inactive projects, which is similar to what you were discussing earlier, which is luckily administered.
    • 03:04:13
      Some of these, though, are VDOT administered on behalf of the locality.
    • 03:04:18
      where localities aren't spending enhancement, they're not spending the RSVP MAC, they're not spending safety monies but this in particular is RSVP and CMAC.
    • 03:04:33
      A tangent of this in that there was discussion in the Cherry-Becker audit about inactive projects
    • 03:04:43
      But it's so to it in terms of the fire release report, which is if you have allocations and the projects are obligated, but there are no expenditures within a certain time frame, the FHWA comes to you and says, why isn't this project moving?
    • 03:05:02
      You haven't spent any money.
    • 03:05:04
      What's your justification?
    • 03:05:06
      Has there been a unique situation in a project?
    • 03:05:09
      You having trouble with it right away?
    • 03:05:12
      Can't explain why this project has not moved forward timely.
    • 03:05:17
      They will release the obligation.
    • 03:05:19
      So then what we have to do is re-obligate it.
    • 03:05:23
      So we're touching that money two and three times.
    • 03:05:26
      And it increases the amount that we have to obligate each year because it just brings prior obligations, releasing them, and we have to find new projects or resubmit them on a project for
    • 03:05:41
      Now speaking to the situation in terms of a legislative mandate, the previous administration had put language in the appropriation act that said
    • 03:06:07
      Federal funds referred to as CMACs shall be selected as directed by the CTB.
    • 03:06:13
      Such funds shall be federally obligated within 24 months of their allocation by the CTB and spent within 48 months of such obligation.
    • 03:06:26
      If the requirements included in this paragraph are not met by such agency or recipient, in this case MPOs, then the CTB could use these federal funds, pull them back,
    • 03:06:35
      and use them on other eligible projects.
    • 03:06:38
      In other words, you yourselves as the board could allocate these funds to projects.
    • 03:06:46
      And that's in the Opioid Appropriations Act for CMAQ.
    • 03:06:50
      There's also similar language for RSVP except the catch on this one is federally we're not allowed, federal regulations will not allow us to pull it back in to be administered centrally, if you will.
    • 03:07:04
      but it allows, if they're not obligating within 12 months of allocation and are not spending by 36 months of allocation, we can remove the match.
    • 03:07:18
      Now, think about that a little bit though.
    • 03:07:21
      The first paragraph makes it retroactive backwards from fiscal year, well I may have it mixed up.
    • 03:07:29
      One of them, the bottom one is fiscal year 10 back
    • 03:07:32
      and the top one is fiscal year 11 forward.
    • 03:07:36
      Well, we have a lot of money sitting out there backwards, if you will.
    • 03:07:46
      For CMAQ, it's about 12 million previous and then what's left in 11.
    • 03:07:54
      And RSTP, we would just be pulling the match but that's on about 32, 33 million dollars.
    • 03:08:02
      We have some staff recommendations related to that.
    • 03:08:06
      If you would like, we're recommending that perhaps a CTB subcommittee be formed perhaps with board members that represent sections of the state that have MPOs that receive RSVP and CMAQ.
    • 03:08:25
      And then what we would do as a recommendation is we would bring to you
    • 03:08:31
      We would report periodically or at least initially with a little bit more detail on the inactive projects in each of the regions and then we would ask the MPOs for a periodic update on the status of those.
    • 03:08:45
      Now part of that has to do with if you continue to give them the ability to allocate CMAQ.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 03:08:53
      And also we would look, we would want you to consider maybe amending
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:08:59
      The actual appropriation act language.
    • 03:09:03
      And what we're looking at is consider programming the FY12 CMEK allocations centrally by VDOT and DRPT with input from the MPOs.
    • 03:09:18
      And we could implement this policy change in the update of the program we're looking
    • 03:09:25
      and it would facilitate more expeditious use of the funds and the allocation of the funds consistent with your priorities.
    • 03:09:41
      It's legislated.
    • 03:09:44
      What we'd like to do is potentially this year amend the code sections to actually indicate that we are pulling it back
    • 03:09:54
      and programming it centrally so it will no longer be legislation that applies to the MPO for CMAC.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:02
      If you're looking for participation in the subcommittee, I'd be more than happy to participate in that subcommittee.
    • 03:10:11
      Following on also to Dr. Davis' question, the
    • 03:10:15
      The delegation of these funds is a legislative delegation?
    • 03:10:19
      No.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:10:20
      No, but because it is, the legislation pertains to the penalty to those to which we delegated.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:25
      So it's our decision on the other aspect.
    • 03:10:28
      But yeah, I agree on this because I think that we've got to take a real careful look at policies and priorities associated with these funds we're responsible for.
    • 03:10:37
      And that is quite a bit of money in that we're not, we just really haven't been paying attention to it.
    • 03:10:42
      It's like, hey, that's their money.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:10:44
      There are a couple of ways to go.
    • 03:10:46
      If you don't want to pull it back in yet but you want to make them more accountable and come forward and make us or have us as staff go ahead and look at the penalties about pulling it in, we would like to make that forward, not backwards.
    • 03:11:05
      So we need to amend the legislation for that component.
    • 03:11:11
      So if you don't want to pull it back in like we were saying on the last slide, the other option is to help us help the MPOs by aligning the timeframes.
    • 03:11:21
      Because if you saw the language, one has obligating within 12 months, and one has it within 24 months, one has it being spent in 36 months, and one has it being spent in 48 months.
    • 03:11:36
      It would be more helpful to the MPOs if they were working
    • 03:11:40
      towards the same timeline for all of those funds.
    • 03:11:46
      And then so aligning the timeframe, eliminating the retroactive implementation so we can work with them forward, and inserting language to provide the locality with an opportunity to address a breach with regard to that language
    • 03:12:06
      And if there is extenuating circumstances, not automatically pulling the money back, but understanding that they're in a situation that will take more time, whether it's a federal issue, a NEPA issue, or a right-of-way issue, or something.
    • 03:12:25
      And you could also set up guidelines of policy for
    • 03:12:34
      What you want them now to spend CMEK on and limit that.
    • 03:12:38
      So there are a combination of things that we could look at through the subcommittee and then bring that back to the board.
    • 03:12:47
      Our request would be to do that quickly because we'll be starting the programming of the six-year program in January.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:55
      Okay.
    • 03:12:55
      All right.
    • 03:12:55
      So the recommendation is to select to create a subcommittee?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:12:59
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:00
      I mean, I would suggest that if the board wants to do that, then we take the four implicated regions, Northern Virginia, Fredericksburg, Richmond, and Hampton Roads, take those members who are representing those areas and those MPOs, be the ones who form that subcommittee.
    • 03:13:23
      I think that would be good.
    • 03:13:24
      And, you know, also I think that the issue for us is I think
    • 03:13:32
      People complain about not trusting our program.
    • 03:13:36
      I'm just talking about the overall program.
    • 03:13:38
      It's stuff like this that just blow you away.
    • 03:13:40
      I mean, we're sitting on hundreds of millions of dollars that they haven't spent or don't plan to spend, and they're going to just spend it, you know, year by year instead of looking on planning for these purposes.
    • 03:13:53
      These dollars have to be planned and programmed and put out there as quickly as possible, so.
    • 03:13:58
      I'm sorry, Dr. Davis and Congresswoman Miller.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:02
      I know that projects that abate air quality issues or the kind of thing that this is to address are expensive.
    • 03:14:12
      And they oftentimes are amorphous in terms of really knowing for sure what you're going to get for what you spend.
    • 03:14:19
      But it would seem to me to make a lot more sense for us to pull back substantially these dollars and focus it on something that we know will make a difference.
    • 03:14:31
      such as high-speed rail between these corridors.
    • 03:14:36
      We know if we did that, we know we get cars off the road, we know we improve things and this would be a huge down payment if we were to do something like that and we could only do it if we pull this back and have the debate, have the MPOs come and tell us what better idea they have and then allocate this money to really making a difference.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:14:58
      We would like to reduce the number of projects on which these funds are allocated.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:02
      It seems to me that would make infinite good sense that we look at that.
    • 03:15:06
      We may not want to pull everything back, but I think pulling back substantially these dollars would give us a huge kick start on high-speed rail between these borders.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:15:19
      It could also somewhat mitigate what the
    • 03:15:23
      What the Secretary was talking about on the local level that happens where it just gets divvied instead of setting our sights higher.
    • 03:15:33
      So I think I'm going to agree with Dr. Davis.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:36
      Mr. Miller.
    • 03:15:39
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • 03:15:40
      Ms. Busher, you said early on that you had met with the Hampton Roads NPO and encouraged them to do better planning and they did that in the
    • 03:15:51
      We've done that with each of the MPOs.
    • 03:15:53
      Is that our policy to do that with each of the MPOs?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:15:55
      No, I just, they wanted a presentation when we were going through the loss of state revenues.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:02
      Would we like to do that with each of the MPOs?
    • 03:16:06
      Yeah.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:16:07
      Secondly... Well, I'm sorry for interrupting.
    • 03:16:09
      No, no, no.
    • 03:16:09
      Part of the meeting agenda that we had with some PDCs and smaller MPOs yesterday, we had two sessions.
    • 03:16:19
      was this very thing on looking at the six-year horizon of allocating their money based on project development schedules and being proactive in selecting projects, perhaps selecting fewer of them and moving things forward.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:39
      I guess what I'm saying is that sort of policy would be across the board?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:44
      Yes.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:44
      Okay, secondly, Northern Virginia said that we allocated the CMAQ, basically the CMAQ authority to them.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:16:53
      No, no, it's to all of them.
    • 03:16:55
      Their letter was just speaking to themselves regarding their... That's what I'm saying, that's what they said.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:01
      Yes.
    • 03:17:01
      We did that to everybody?
    • 03:17:02
      Yes.
    • 03:17:04
      Okay.
    • 03:17:05
      And lastly, can you give me some understanding, I mean,
    • 03:17:11
      Why, what are the barriers to these MPOs spending this money?
    • 03:17:15
      I mean, obviously, most governmental agencies like to spend money.
    • 03:17:20
      So, they got the money sitting there.
    • 03:17:23
      It's available to be spent as I understand it.
    • 03:17:25
      So, I understand the pulling back piece.
    • 03:17:28
      I think I'm in favor of that, but I'm trying to figure out, if I went to my locality or an MPO and they said, I said, why this thing?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:36
      I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
    • 03:17:53
      They spend 10 years of just thanking that money until they get the money.
    • 03:17:56
      Of course, inflation overwhelms it.
    • 03:17:58
      It's the money they wait until they're sure they've got the money before they apply.
    • 03:18:05
      That tends to be one of the problems that's out there.
    • 03:18:08
      The other does get into just not able to excuse it.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:18:11
      A second one is they tend to get a lot of these projects and their public work staff, if you will, that would be locally administering them.
    • 03:18:21
      They don't have large shops or maybe some of the skill set.
    • 03:18:25
      They hire consultants to do and implement some of the work and that adds time to the project development.
    • W. Sheppard Miller IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:32
      My last question is are we following the policy that we currently have with the law that we currently have?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:18:39
      We have not chosen at this point to pull it back in.
    • 03:18:47
      The new RSTP component of this was implemented in the 9th General Assembly.
    • 03:18:55
      And we were losing a lot of, we had no state funding going through the construction formula for primary, secondary, and urban.
    • 03:19:05
      So this was still local project money, if you will.
    • 03:19:10
      We did not implement that.
    • 03:19:12
      Now part of the CMAQ,
    • 03:19:15
      legislation, one of those, that one has been out there for longer than that.
    • 03:19:22
      Basically, we were just, had gotten to a point of trying to work with each of the MPOs.
    • 03:19:29
      We've reconciled Tri-Cities, Richmond, we've talked to Hampton, and worked with them individually on their projects and finding available funding.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:39
      Yeah, I'm sorry.
    • 03:19:39
      I know I'll be here, Mr. McCarthy.
    • 03:19:41
      Go back, Mr. Keene.
    • 03:19:43
      Rita.
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:19:45
      Yes.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:46
      My understanding of the use of these monies was always that they were to be for regional projects.
    • 03:19:53
      And my question is, is there any federal definition of what regional means?
    • 03:19:58
      Because technically, you could read it as they've been spending it.
    • 03:20:03
      These are monies sent to a region that they then divvy up among their teensy little projects and bank them for years on end.
    • 03:20:11
      or you could interpret it as it should only really be spent on regional priorities or even as Dr. Davis suggested, corridor priorities.
    • 03:20:21
      Is there any federal guidance on that?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:20:23
      I think it's based on the MPO's owned prioritization processes.
    • 03:20:31
      Not all MPOs have those and they're not all the same.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 03:20:36
      Can you speak to
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 03:20:38
      Any additional information?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:20:40
      I think it's just based on the NPOs, what's in their tips and their steps and their constrained long-range plans in terms of projects and... Well, it has been a complaint of some of you standing that, in fact, from people outside who criticize us that we're not spending this money as intended by Congress to do regional
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:05
      Clean Air projects and congestion mitigation and regional surface transportation projects.
    • 03:21:12
      And, you know, if you look at the definition of regional that way, you'd have to say you're right, if that's not the way the money usually gets spent.
    • 03:21:19
      And so I guess then my second question would be, in the absence of federal guidance, can we write a policy that says if we wanted to, that 50% or whatever, 100% or 20%
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:21:32
      We have the ability to set more restrictive policies than the federal regulations but not less.
    • 03:21:46
      So we can narrow the focus on the types of projects that we use these funds on if we pull it back or that they use these funds on.
    • 03:21:58
      They still come to you for approval.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:01
      Okay, I'm sorry, we're gonna have to end this.
    • 03:22:04
      We're really well behind schedule.
    • 03:22:06
      And 3.30, the conference starts.
    • 03:22:09
      Three o'clock, the conference starts.
    • 03:22:12
      And we have lunch waiting, so we're gonna break it here.
    • 03:22:15
      First, there's one mayor polled, the board, everyone's okay about forming this small subcommittee.
    • 03:22:20
      Look at this.
    • 03:22:21
      And the half-BDOT staff start to work off the mechanism.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:22:24
      Chairman, one other thing.
    • 03:22:25
      On the letter from the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, given the fact that
    • 03:22:30
      We certainly pushed this issue to the forefront on change of policy, but given that the policy that they were operating on when they awarded the hybrid, can we take that up this afternoon?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:43
      I believe we can, right?
    • Reta BusherChief of Planning and Programming
    • 03:22:46
      We don't have a resolution prepared, but I assume we can.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:49
      Well, we'll take it on to new business, if that's what you'd like us versus.
    • 03:22:53
      Okay, so we're going to stop on this one.
    • 03:22:56
      Why don't we take a, we'll come back, it's 1225.
    • 03:23:01
      1245, we're going to start right back up again.
    • 03:23:04
      We have lunch for the board set up right across the hall, right out here.
    • 03:23:09
      I ask that the board members can go grab something to eat.
    • 03:23:13
      Come on back.
    • 03:23:15
      We're going to continue the board meeting.
    • 03:23:16
      We've got three more presentations.
    • 03:23:18
      And then getting right into the board session itself.
    • 03:23:20
      Thank you all very much.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:23:23
      We're not doing very well.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:35
      Actually in the room, even if they're still chatting.
    • 03:23:40
      And at this point, we're going to get back to our agenda.
    • 03:23:44
      I'd like to welcome up Mr. John Lawson,
    • 03:23:47
      and he's going to talk about the fiscal year 2011 budget, actual performance through October 2010.
    • 03:23:54
      Mr. Lawson.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:24:08
      Thank you Dave.
    • 03:24:08
      Now you can maybe hear me.
    • 03:24:10
      As I was saying, I'm going to try to hit the hot spot to move us along through this and then if
    • 03:24:16
      If any of you want to talk with me further at another point, I'll be more than glad to do that.
    • 03:24:23
      I'm just going to quickly give you just a quick snapshot of our revenues from this, at this point in this year.
    • 03:24:28
      I can actually give some good news.
    • 03:24:32
      Our revenue forecast through, the actual revenue collections through October are tracking ahead of forecast in all of our major sources.
    • 03:24:41
      both in the Highway Maintenance Fund and in the Transportation Trust Fund.
    • 03:24:45
      Federal revenues as well are running in our collections are a little bit higher than they were by prior fiscal year.
    • 03:24:55
      And I'm going to spare you the details and just skip across to this one chart and talk a little bit about our actual spending this year as it compared to fiscal 2010.
    • 03:25:05
      This chart illustrates for you by each of our major programs
    • 03:25:11
      Put the budgeted amount versus the year-to-date expenditure for both fiscal year 11 and last year fiscal 10.
    • 03:25:20
      You'll see that in terms of spending, the maintenance program, if you look at that middle of the chart, has been expended about $414 million through the end of October out of a better $1.9 billion budget, about 22% expended.
    • 03:25:37
      Construction has spent $435 million
    • 03:25:41
      Just not quite half, but 43% of its annual budget.
    • 03:25:47
      When you look at these things kind of cumulatively, you see notice that maintenance in terms of total spending of this $1.1 billion total spending, the VDOT maintenance as well as the financial assistance to localities cumulatively represent about 45% of the total spending of the budget.
    • 03:26:10
      As you can also notice just looking at this chart that the spending for 2011 across the board is pretty much on par with 2010.
    • 03:26:19
      And I'm going to skip right to the kind of a wrap up on the end here and again if any of you want to talk with me further about this I'll be glad to either here at the conference or if you'd like to schedule some time later I'll be glad to talk to you.
    • 03:26:39
      As I mentioned, spending so far this year is pretty much on track with what it was last fiscal year.
    • 03:26:47
      But we've done a lot of work.
    • 03:26:49
      There's been a lot of efforts made to get work on the street.
    • 03:26:52
      By the end of this month, we'll have advertised about $400 million more worth of maintenance contracts than we had... Well, we will have advertised about $400 million in maintenance contracts, which is about double the amount we had done last year.
    • 03:27:09
      There's a lot of work going on to get construction contracts out.
    • 03:27:13
      So there is a significant effort going on to put work on the street, but it's important to note that this work, the actual spending of these monies associated with these contracts, won't start until spring.
    • 03:27:25
      So the actual expenditure associated is going to be lagging a bit.
    • 03:27:32
      We do have large balances to date, and we do
    • 03:27:37
      have some concerns about where our balances will be at the end of the fiscal year.
    • 03:27:41
      But again, those balances are going to be very largely dependent upon how aggressive the construction and the paving industry go after our contract work.
    • 03:27:52
      If they start early and work the current contracts hard and have heavy expenditures out of the 2011 schedules early in the year, then our balances could be lower than they were last year.
    • 03:28:05
      But if that doesn't happen, we could be looking at balances in the same neighborhood we were in the previous year.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:28:14
      Is that dependent on them or is that dependent on VDOT getting stuff to them?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:28:21
      Once we put the contract out, it has a window of time for them to execute the work.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:28:26
      Would that indicate that the real job then is for us to get it out there with the timetable so that we get equipment?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:28:33
      So the contracts will go out, but again, they have the opportunity to start the paving work in April, May, but they could also delay it not starting until July, as long as they complete the work within the timeframe.
    • 03:28:51
      Just, I guess, kind of a wrap-up.
    • 03:28:53
      I continue to watch the expenditure activity, and I'll keep you abreast of what's going on periodically, and again, if there's any
    • 03:29:03
      Details you'd like me to go over with you, I'd be more than glad to.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:07
      With the ARA funding, which was allocated to the MPOs, I'm curious if they're having the same problem spending that money that they're having spending the other.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:29:21
      Well, I may want to turn back to Ms. Busher, but in terms of spending, the spending on our projects are up significantly from last year.
    • 03:29:31
      We only spent about 20
    • 03:29:32
      7 million, I believe, last year through October, and we spent almost 70 million this year through the first quarter.
    • 03:29:40
      So the work is out there, and the spending is starting to occur.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:29:45
      Mr. Chairman, with the expenditure on our projects, they are going up.
    • 03:29:51
      But we do have some issues that we're working on.
    • 03:29:55
      And we've obligated some of our money to projects.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:58
      And having moved as quickly as what it should move,
    • 03:30:01
      And quite frankly, some of those projects could hit an inactive status.
    • 03:30:06
      And what we're doing is working on that now to try to figure out, to get them off that inactive status and get those projects moved.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:30:13
      So we do have some issues, similar to what we talked about a little earlier, and we're trying to work on that to get it straight.
    • 03:30:24
      Do we have, you know, just two questions.
    • 03:30:27
      The revenues are a little bit ahead.
    • 03:30:29
      Do we have contingency plans to program those?
    • 03:30:32
      In other words, do we know where they're going?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:30:35
      The revenues, any revenue in the excessive forecast is directed by the law, by VTE 2000, to be dedicated to the priority transportation fund.
    • 03:30:54
      The actual performance of revenues that we are seeing will also be considered by the Department of Taxation in their forecast.
    • 03:31:02
      So if they happen to revise the forecast to address that, any additional funding made available to us, we would program as part of 12.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:31:13
      And just to follow up, I noticed you had a note in here that labor expenditures are down 172 million versus 205.
    • 03:31:19
      So is that intentional or are we understaffed?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:31:25
      We are both, the expenditures are down partly because we have our staffing level down lower than what we're authorized to be.
    • 03:31:38
      We're authorized to be a 7500 for probably the 6900 range in terms of strength.
    • 03:31:45
      And then when you compare the actual expenditures to last year,
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:31:48
      The salary cost for the last year could be higher than this year because we have a small salary base this year because we're late on.
    • 03:31:58
      So we're bringing people back and trying to get those positions?
    • 03:32:01
      We're trying to rehire to the 7500 authorized level.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:05
      Thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:08
      So Mr. Lawson is going to be, this is one of the things that came out of the audit is that really trying to get better transparency
    • 03:32:19
      Not just in how we plan and program, but actually how we actually expend the funds.
    • 03:32:27
      And so Mr. Lawson will be coming back fairly regularly, and we're going to do once a month?
    • 03:32:32
      Or no?
    • 03:32:32
      You want to do once a month?
    • 03:32:33
      How often do you want to do it?
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:32:36
      Once a month?
    • 03:32:36
      Once a month is perfectly fine if that's what you would like.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:38
      Once a month.
    • 03:32:39
      He'd love to do once a month.
    • John W. LawsonChief Financial Officer
    • 03:32:41
      Not more than once a month, but preferably.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:43
      Once a month, it is.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:47
      But Mr. Lawson's going to be a regular, giving us updates, making sure that we keep these cash balances down.
    • 03:32:53
      We're getting real contracts advertised, money on the streets, projects really underway.
    • 03:33:01
      And I appreciate very much you being here.
    • 03:33:04
      It's hard not to lay all this out.
    • 03:33:06
      Obviously, we still got challenges.
    • 03:33:07
      We have some major challenges here.
    • 03:33:09
      But obviously, we started pretty high on the hill here, trying to get that thing down.
    • 03:33:13
      Absolutely.
    • 03:33:14
      And so it's going to take a little time to do that.
    • 03:33:16
      But I appreciate all the work that you and your staff and actually all of the VDOT staff has done to try to get this money on the street.
    • 03:33:23
      We just announced what you're going to be advertising 300 and how many, just this month alone?
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:33:29
      This month alone will be about 500 million on December the 7th.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:33:38
      December 7th, $268 million, December 14th, $279 million, and December 28th, $29 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:03
      So the thing is obviously this is a lot of projects can impact
    • 03:34:07
      everywhere in the Commonwealth, and again, that's done a great job.
    • 03:34:11
      Yes?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:34:13
      Maybe it's what I asked before, but we're putting a lot more money out to work, and we got less people.
    • 03:34:19
      So are we comfortable?
    • 03:34:21
      We're controlling it, and it's all being done, and we're not just causing us problems that are going to end up a few months down the road.
    • 03:34:28
      We don't have control or something.
    • 03:34:32
      We have been actually supplementing our staff.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:35
      We're consultants.
    • 03:34:36
      They come in and help us get things ready.
    • 03:34:39
      And also on the inspection side, as we put out more contracts, we are probably going to need more consultants to help us do the inspection work.
    • 03:34:50
      We have, I think we call them a CEA contract, inspection related contracts, on call.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:34:56
      And we call the consultants in to help us inspect the work.
    • 03:35:02
      How about you're comfortable.
    • 03:35:03
      You're on top of it.
    • 03:35:04
      Yes, sir.
    • James E. RichMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:05
      Mr. Rich, they are more than ready.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:20
      They are screaming.
    • 03:35:30
      Since last year, Mr. Whirley and I have spent a lot of time with these contractors and they are screaming for this money because of the massive layoffs that they've had to make, particularly on this region out here where a lot of the resource facilities are and a lot of the people that do construction are actually from out here.
    • 03:35:52
      So they keep on telling us they're more than ready and we keep on throwing them projects and get things moving.
    • 03:35:59
      They said they're ready now.
    • 03:36:02
      Any other questions?
    • 03:36:04
      Excellent.
    • 03:36:05
      Awesome.
    • 03:36:05
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:36:06
      Next we're going to go to just a review of the strategic plan as Mr. Tyery is going to be going over this during the conference in a few hours.
    • 03:36:19
      But I just thought it would be important for you all to just hear some of the highlights of that prior to the start of the conference, Mr. Tyery.
    • David L. TyeryarDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:36:29
      Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary and ladies and gentlemen of the board.
    • 03:36:31
      I will be brief but not too brief so at least you have a basic understanding of where we're going if you stay and listen to this later this afternoon.
    • 03:36:41
      As you can see from this slide, these are the folks who participated on the strategic plan team and we will have a booth in the exhibit hall so that if you have specific questions about what we've been up to, you can come by and ask us.
    • 03:36:54
      These are the six agencies in the Secretary of Transportation that have been working on this
    • 03:36:59
      The strategic plan, I won't read this to you but this is our multi-modal vision and this was developed at our spring retreat when all of the transportation agencies gathered at the library in Richmond and this was the vision that resulted that day.
    • 03:37:20
      We've been working on this since the spring.
    • 03:37:23
      We've been meeting twice a month and as I said earlier, everyone has been participating from all agencies
    • 03:37:29
      The important thing as I go through this, this is a resource constrained strategic plan.
    • 03:37:33
      We'll talk in a minute about how it dovetails with VTrans 2035, which is a vision document and is not a resource constrained plan, but it was our intent from the get-go on this to make sure that whatever we put in the strategic plan, we could achieve with the resources that we had that wasn't contingent on resources coming.
    • 03:37:54
      Why did we choose resource constrained?
    • 03:37:57
      I wanted to set goals that we could achieve whether funding levels changed or whether they didn't.
    • 03:38:04
      And it becomes, as you can see, the emphasis is on transportation policies and administering programs, so the transparency, the expeditiousness of the program, moving it faster without accepting too much risk as has been discussed here in the last few minutes.
    • 03:38:20
      And to be effective, whether we have funding level change or not.
    • 03:38:23
      and that's the beauty of a strategic plan.
    • 03:38:25
      It takes something like the VTrans 2035 which is a vision document and starts to give it a laser-like focus on a few things.
    • 03:38:32
      This is kind of a visual of how it works.
    • 03:38:34
      You have the vision, you set the goals, we have measures of success.
    • 03:38:38
      You see your measures trending the wrong direction.
    • 03:38:41
      Then you come back and you tweak your programs and your policies and you start the process all over again.
    • 03:38:46
      So there's that check and balance built in there in that programming and policy square on the screen.
    • 03:38:54
      This is the VTrans 2035 goes on the left and the strategic plan goes across the top and this is a chart or a matrix if you will of how they intertwine.
    • 03:39:05
      The VTrans 2035 is the parting gift from the previous administration and as we were putting this together it was important to me and it was important to the rest of the staff that we weren't going in a direction that was different than the vision document so this is kind of
    • 03:39:21
      This is the chart that gives us the grounding that makes sure that our strategic plan is moving towards the vision.
    • 03:39:30
      These are the goals on the left.
    • 03:39:32
      I won't read them to you, but you've heard many of these themes before.
    • 03:39:35
      Seamless multimodal economic opportunity, return on investment, increased use of technology, better planning processes, a customer-focused program,
    • 03:39:49
      And on the right you can see the measures of success, intermodal facilities, cross training of staff, which I will speak to at the conference in much greater detail, but to start to move away from the stovepipes that have occurred and to have the planning staff from all of the agencies within transportation start to think about every project, not as if you're doing it, but as we are doing it.
    • 03:40:12
      Incident response time, travel time reliability,
    • 03:40:15
      You can see the state of good repair.
    • 03:40:17
      There are corridors of state-wide significance which have come up in this room.
    • 03:40:21
      On several occasions, you can see many of the usual goals and you can see the measures of success.
    • 03:40:28
      And again, we think we can achieve these measures of success if we change our processes and our policies a little bit and be able to do that within existing resources.
    • 03:40:39
      Here's a list, not the chart, a list of the goals and the measures of success and how the measures of success support the respective goals.
    • 03:40:50
      You can start to see which ones are, they aren't ranked in terms of importance, but the ones that are gonna generate the most energy and the most concentration, you can see by the numbers of checks in a row or checks in a column.
    • 03:41:03
      So you can see the cross-training of staff is important.
    • 03:41:06
      Looking across the line or a state of good repair is important or accessibility and looking down the columns you can see that safety is very important to us, increased use of technology is important to us, things that we gain in this theme of being able to do things within existing resources.
    • 03:41:24
      I said earlier that we have tools in place that the trends or particular success measure are trending the wrong way and here's a table that says
    • 03:41:32
      Which way is the desired trend?
    • 03:41:33
      And in the other column it says, do we have absolute control over that or do we just have influence?
    • 03:41:38
      Again, I will go into this in much greater detail this afternoon, but it's here for you so that you can see what the measure is and whether it should be something we're trying to, all of them we're trying to improve.
    • 03:41:48
      You can see here whether success is determined if it increases or if it decreases.
    • 03:41:55
      I talk a little bit about change levers, and that was real important in this strategic plan process that when we chose the measures, we could actually influence the measures, that if we saw the measure trending in a direction that wasn't the direction we wanted it to go, that we had something available to us other than additional resources that we could actually go in and make the corrective action and reverse the trend on the measure.
    • 03:42:23
      The rest is detail on
    • 03:42:25
      This is what I will say this afternoon.
    • 03:42:28
      I will walk through the specific measure and then I will talk about the change levers that are available to us.
    • 03:42:33
      I will not go through that level of detail with you for right now in the interest of time because I will do it again this afternoon and many of you will be there.
    • 03:42:43
      But this is the way it will lay out.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:42:46
      With that, I will take any questions.
    • 03:42:55
      is multimodal, all the agencies, those covered by the CTB and those not covered by the CTB.
    • 03:43:04
      And so what we're trying to do is, I'm going to say it for the first time, get all the agencies from an administrative standpoint and administration standpoint, all the agencies to work better together, whether it be aviation, whether it be VDOT, whether it be our ports, start to marry
    • 03:43:25
      Our objectives together to try and budget towards those objectives, measure that.
    • 03:43:32
      So the CTB is part of that, I'm going to say, process in that it tells some of the programs that agencies oversee, how we spend money, where we spend it.
    • 03:43:43
      But the biggest thing for us is to try and now we have this VTrans.
    • 03:43:49
      This is another step for us to make sure we start to match our programs, all our programs,
    • 03:43:55
      This does not have to be adopted by the board, but we did want you to be aware of this, because from the administrative standpoint, this is going to be the thing that we're going to start really trying to keep track of what we're doing, how we're doing among all the transportation agencies, so when we make better decisions across the board.
    • 03:44:20
      Any questions?
    • 03:44:22
      Mr. Turner, thank you very much.
    • 03:44:24
      Well, you know what?
    • 03:44:24
      I've now realized that we should feed everyone.
    • 03:44:30
      Everyone's so quiet.
    • 03:44:33
      You put salt feeder in that meat, didn't you?
    • 03:44:39
      The next and last presentation is on the PPPA program.
    • 03:44:43
      Any implementation?
    • 03:44:45
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:44:45
      And Mr. Kilpatrick and Mr. Holcomb are going to give us an overview.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:44:53
      Well, good afternoon.
    • 03:44:55
      I wanted to start.
    • 03:44:56
      We're going to give you a briefing on the PPTA implementation manual as well as the startup of the PPTA office.
    • 03:45:06
      I will be the director of the PPTA program for VDOT, and Dusty Holcomb, who's here with me, will be the deputy director.
    • 03:45:16
      And he and his staff will do all the heavy lifting.
    • 03:45:18
      They'll be responsible for
    • 03:45:20
      the policy, the project development, project management, and I will be providing oversight and direction.
    • 03:45:28
      So Dusty, we'll go through the PowerPoint here and if you've got any questions afterwards.
    • 03:45:34
      Again, I think you folks know pretty well the PPTA Act of 1995.
    • 03:45:38
      We've used that in a number of cases on medium and mostly large projects in Virginia and we're looking forward to continuing to utilize this
    • 03:45:50
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 03:45:52
      The presentation that we have today is associated with really two elements of a review that was done or an audit that was done in March of this year, and they're focused in on the PPTA office and the PPTA implementation guidelines.
    • 03:46:21
      What I'll do, I'll have a quick introduction, talk a little bit about the assessment recommendations that came out of the audit, show you an organizational structure of the PPTA office, go a little bit, I've got a couple slides on the implementation manual overview and the project delivery framework, and then just give you an idea of what the next steps are for the office.
    • 03:46:44
      Obviously, the PPTA is an important tool for the bringing of infrastructure
    • 03:46:49
      for all the transportation agencies within Virginia itself and also delivering the governor's transportation priorities.
    • 03:46:56
      Review occurred, like I said, in March of 2010 that resulted in the development of some recommendations for the Commonwealth and its PPTA program.
    • 03:47:08
      Some of these recommendations, and I'm going to highlight two of them really here, is the establishment of a separate multimodal PPTA program office with leadership and decision-making authority
    • 03:47:17
      and the second one I want to really highlight is the revision of the existing PPTA implementation guidelines.
    • 03:47:25
      This is the organizational structure.
    • 03:47:27
      The PPTA office is really a combination of what used to be the PPTA program under innovative project delivery and elements of financial planning.
    • 03:47:37
      So we're bringing the procurement arm and the financial arm together into one PPTA program office and obviously as
    • 03:47:45
      Mr. Kilpatrick noted he will be the program director and I will be the deputy director of the office.
    • 03:47:53
      The focus of the office is really in two work streams, one programmatic, which will focus in on the guidelines on the selection and prioritization process that I'll talk about a little bit later, and the second work stream will focus in on the management of the projects themselves, including the existing projects that we have in place and any new projects, whether they be solicited or unsolicited, that come into the program.
    • 03:48:16
      What you'll see on this organizational chart that's a little bit different is the PPTA program steering committee.
    • 03:48:21
      It is a committee of ten members which is chaired by the Commonwealth Transportation Commissioner and each of the directors or commissioners of the five transportation agencies are on the board.
    • 03:48:35
      It includes the Deputy Secretary of Transportation, the Chief Deputy Commissioner for the Virginia Department of Transportation,
    • 03:48:42
      Three members of the Virginia Department of Transportation, including the chief engineer, the chief of programming and planning, and also the CFO.
    • 03:48:53
      And one final note about policy guidance.
    • 03:48:55
      We're going to be working closely with the secretary's office on the development of any of the policies that are associated with the program and working with the commissioners and the directors of each of the programs for the development of different projects and selection of different projects.
    • 03:49:10
      Now for the manual itself,
    • 03:49:12
      The focus of the manual was, it's seven chapters and several appendices that focus a little bit wider than what you see of the existing implementation guidelines.
    • 03:49:22
      Those guidelines are focused on the procurement.
    • 03:49:24
      This one focuses on really the policy of the program itself, which includes the responsibilities and roles of the PPTA office and the PPTA team that we put together.
    • 03:49:34
      It certainly encourages development and participation by the private sector and solicited proposals that we really want to drive forward.
    • 03:49:41
      It was prepared in conjunction with the other sister transportation agencies, the Office of the Attorney General and also external advisors.
    • 03:49:50
      We had a webinar through the process itself where we solicited comments from the public and solicited comments from the private sector.
    • 03:49:58
      We received 140 of those comments and certainly considered those in the development of the manual.
    • 03:50:05
      There are four key phases associated with the project delivery framework, project identification,
    • 03:50:11
      On the programmatic side, here's where we're going to coordinate with the planning departments at each of the agencies.
    • 03:50:18
      We're going to focus with the MPOs and other stakeholders along the corridors that we're interested in to try to identify different projects.
    • 03:50:25
      We're going to work with them on their vision plans or with the CLRP to try to identify different projects that have our potential PPTAs.
    • 03:50:33
      And then there's a selection and prioritization process which uses high level and detailed level screening criteria.
    • 03:50:39
      that we've put in place within the manual itself and really the focus of this is to prioritize the different projects, try to identify whether they're short-term, medium or long-term projects that we can start working on and really start investing our dollars in.
    • 03:50:53
      And then we go over to the project development side where we start maturing the projects and writing them for procurement and that includes conducting NEPA, traffic and revenue studies, trying to identify
    • 03:51:07
      Through a value for money analysis, whether the investment that we're making on each of the projects is worth moving them forward.
    • 03:51:13
      And this is obviously to prepare for a very streamlined procurement process, which is the final step in the delivery framework that we've put together.
    • 03:51:21
      It's a two-stage competitive process, and our goal is to streamline that process.
    • 03:51:26
      When the private sector comes in, streamline the process and finalize and award a contract as quick as possible.
    • 03:51:34
      This is a chart that shows really the path that either a solicited or a planned project and an unsolicited project will go through as it goes through the four phases.
    • 03:51:46
      The four phases are shown on the right-hand side.
    • 03:51:48
      And the key part about this is that we have decision points.
    • 03:51:51
      And in those decision points, either the steering committee or the agency directors are making decisions on whether to invest more dollars into the project itself.
    • 03:52:02
      And we've tried to create these decision points where we truly show that there's a justification to move forward and there's a value for the Commonwealth to move forward for each of the decision points.
    • 03:52:16
      Now for the implementation process.
    • 03:52:18
      It says on here, Friday, December 10th, we're going to start all this.
    • 03:52:21
      The Secretary asked us to start today so there'll be a notice put out, a press release put out that the PPTA office and the implementation guidelines are available on
    • 03:52:32
      both VDOT's website and our sister agency's website and also on the transportation secretary's website and those two websites are noted here and with that both Mr. Kilpatrick and I can take any questions that you may have.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:47
      Welcome, thank you very much.
    • 03:52:48
      I appreciate all your work on this.
    • 03:52:49
      Any questions?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:53
      Ms. McCarthy.
    • 03:52:56
      Would you remind me how this fits into or does it fit into our six-year planning process and all the other
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 03:53:02
      Yes, as you see on the organizational structure, the oversight board is a part of the organizational structure and each of the PPTA projects that will utilize either state or federal funds will have to go into the six-year program.
    • 03:53:22
      So the oversight board has a role in the authorization of those funds into the six-year program.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:30
      And where does the CTB fit in?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:53:32
      The CTB, it says oversight board and that is because some of the other agencies have other governing boards.
    • 03:53:40
      But that, when you look at the chart, that is the CTB as it relates to VDOT projects and DRPT projects.
    • 03:53:49
      So again, you will be, the CTB will put these projects in the Six-Year Plan through the Six-Year Plan process.
    • 03:53:59
      The delivery of them
    • 03:54:01
      The delivery mechanism, the contracting method may be the PPTA process.
    • 03:54:07
      So if you look at that, that's largely what this is.
    • 03:54:11
      It's a type of procurement.
    • 03:54:12
      The projects themselves are prioritized by the CTB, but the actual procurement is the PPTA process.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:21
      So if we follow Dr. Davis' example and we round up all this money we talked about before lunch and want
    • 03:54:27
      PPT-8 project for high-speed rail that would go through this process, let's say.
    • 03:54:33
      Just kidding.
    • 03:54:33
      I just want to get it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:35
      If it's in the six-year plan.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 03:54:37
      Yeah, if it's in the six-year plan, and certainly any of the PPT-8 projects would like to take any funding that's available, and we can certainly move them forward.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:46
      And I just want to add to that.
    • 03:54:48
      So the office is going to have two purposes.
    • 03:54:52
      One is it is about project delivery.
    • 03:54:55
      and making recommendations regarding funding of a project that we've already identified.
    • 03:55:02
      But also the office is going to also start to look at the Six-Year Plan and maybe even beyond the Six-Year Plan for opportunities for PPPAs that, you know, because we've gotten in ourselves right now and I'd say we've become reactive.
    • 03:55:19
      We get unsolicited.
    • 03:55:21
      versus us actually going out and identifying where they may make sense and putting out the proposals in that regard.
    • 03:55:30
      So the office is going to, you know, it's things we have in the Six-Year Plan or things that they may come to us and ask to put into the Six-Year Plan.
    • 03:55:40
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:55:43
      And by the way, this is one more area where there's issue on this infrastructure bank.
    • 03:55:47
      Again, there's a funding mechanism for things in the Six-Year Plan or something where other types of projects that are not in the Six-Year Plan.
    • 03:55:55
      We've already identified the project.
    • 03:55:56
      This is just ways to finance things we've already said are and should be pursued.
    • 03:56:03
      I'm sorry, somebody else have questions over there?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:56:06
      Oh, Ms. Layne.
    • 03:56:07
      Two points.
    • 03:56:08
      First of all, on the organizational chart, the PPTA program steering committee, that's all internal staff.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickChief Deputy Commissioner
    • 03:56:15
      Internal to Virginia government, yes sir.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:56:20
      And back to the oversight, but I hear this, you said if it involved state or federal funds, the CTB would be involved, but if it didn't involve federal funds, do I assume we're not involved?
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 03:56:35
      Well, you're not involved in the authorization of funds associated with the project itself.
    • 03:56:39
      We're still going to be briefing the CTB on the development of the project itself.
    • 03:56:43
      Consistent with the PPTA law, we would come to the CTB in advance of any signing or execution of a comprehensive agreement to provide you with the major business points associated with that document, whether it be an interim agreement or a comprehensive agreement.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:56:57
      Okay, but would we have any authority or is that all rested with the administration?
    • 03:57:03
      If there were no federal, and I'm trying to get to who makes the decision,
    • 03:57:09
      I'm thinking of a served case, you decide to do one of the bridges and there's no federal state monies and the tolls are gonna be what and do we have a say in that or is that strictly all the administration?
    • 03:57:21
      In fact, I'm not saying there's any administration in that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:23
      You'll have two bites at the end.
    • 03:57:25
      Okay.
    • 03:57:25
      Or three bites, all right.
    • 03:57:27
      One is the identification of the project to begin with.
    • 03:57:30
      Right.
    • 03:57:30
      The second one is you, Mr. McCarthy,
    • 03:57:34
      To speed up this IRP, every time everyone wrangles their hands over picking members, whatever, we're essentially going to be going to, when the project has been identified, we're going to go right to the CTB members in that area, we're going to go to the MPOs,
    • 03:58:02
      and PDCs, whatever, in that area.
    • 03:58:03
      They're automatically going to be part of the review panel.
    • 03:58:08
      So what you and Mr. McCarthy are experiencing right now is going to be, I'm going to say, the normal course of business in the future.
    • 03:58:15
      You're supposed to be already on the public representatives.
    • 03:58:18
      We're going to put you, you know, you're going to double your pay and we're going to double the responsibility.
    • 03:58:26
      And then obviously, then when the project itself is finally, let's say we,
    • 03:58:31
      We decided on a contractor and a potential way to fund it.
    • 03:58:36
      They will come back again and then the board itself, depending on what the type of project is, say yes or no.
    • 03:58:46
      Thank you.
    • 03:59:00
      All right.
    • 03:59:01
      At that point, we will end the work session, and we'll gavel into the actual meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.