Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 5/19/2010
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   5/19/2010

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Bids.pdf
  • Fiscal Year 2010 budget revision_ Addressing snow removal costs.pdf
  • The George Washington Region.pdf
  • Downtown Tunnel_Midtown Tunnel_MLK Extension PPTA Project recommendations.pdf
  • 1. Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel Commission

    • Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel 2010 overview.pdf
  • 2. Rail Industrial Access – Greensville County

    • Rail industrial access, Wood Fuel Developers LLC, Greensville County.pdf
  • 3. FY11-FY16 Six-Year Improvement Plan Recommendations

    • VDOT Draft Six-Year Improvement Program Fiscal Years 2011 - 16.pdf
    • DRPT Draft Six-Year Improvement Program Fiscal Years 2011 - 16.pdf
  • 4. Revised Fiscal Year 2010 Annual Budget

  • 5. ARRA Update

    • ARRA funding project update.pdf
  • 6. Supplemental Guide Sign Program Hospital Sign Briefing

    • Supplemental Guide Sign Program hospital sign briefing.pdf
  • 7. Speed Limit Briefing

    • Interstate speed limit changes.pdf
  • 8. The Process for Studying Corridors of Statewide Significance Route 29 Subcommittee

    • Process for studying corridors of statewide significance.pdf
  • 9. Midtown Tunnell PPTA

    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning, everyone.
    • 00:00:01
      I'd like to welcome you to this morning's work session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:08
      This is going to be a long day.
    • 00:00:09
      We have a work session, a regular meeting, and tonight we have our first of the Six-Year Improvement Plan hearings held here starting at 6 o'clock.
    • 00:00:20
      So we're just going to get right into the agenda.
    • 00:00:22
      I'm going to ask Bill first if everyone please stand as we say the Pledge of Allegiance.
    • 00:00:27
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • 00:00:46
      Thank you.
    • 00:00:47
      I do know that Ms. Pandak will be out, so I know the other board members will get here shortly.
    • 00:00:52
      I do want to introduce, we have a new representative from the Lynchburg District, and where is he?
    • 00:00:59
      To speak, would you like to just introduce yourself?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:01:03
      Good morning, I'm Mark Peake, from the Lynchburg District, Ken White.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:09
      Got down a little early, so I've been appointed to come out to determine if I live in Lynchburg, and I'm looking forward to working with everybody.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:16
      Excellent to speak, thank you very much, appreciate you being here, appreciate you taking on this responsibility.
    • 00:01:22
      With that, we're going to go right into our first item.
    • 00:01:25
      That's the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel Commission, and we have Jeff Holland here.
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:01:33
      Jeff.
    • 00:01:33
      Good morning.
    • 00:01:35
      Good morning.
    • 00:01:35
      Jeff Connaughton and Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:01:37
      We appreciate the opportunity to give you a brief overview of the Chesapeake Bay Bridge and Tunnel District.
    • 00:01:42
      Commissioner Layne does an excellent job in communicating the work of the CTB to the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel Commission, and we appreciate the opportunity to reciprocate this morning.
    • 00:01:54
      Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel, as you probably are well aware, is a complex system of simple steel spans approximately a mile and a half, half a mile of a fracture-critical true truss, 28 miles of low-level trestles,
    • 00:02:09
      five miles the tallest way and two miles of transverse decorated tunnels.
    • 00:02:15
      The Chesapeake Channel Tunnel actually goes under the Chesapeake Channel ingress and egress into Baltimore.
    • 00:02:24
      The Thimble Soul Channel Tunnel crosses under the Thimble Soul Channel which provides the important ingress and egress into the ever-growing Port of Hampton Roads.
    • 00:02:34
      What you see here is an aerial shot looking north to south.
    • 00:02:39
      Prior to the existence of the fixed crossing, not unlike many bridges and tunnels,
    • 00:02:46
      Around, under, and over major waterways, the Chesapeake Bay was crossed by a ferry system originally operated beginning in 1933.
    • 00:02:56
      In 1954, the Chesapeake Bay Ferry submission was enabled by the General Assembly for the purpose of providing the crossing of the 17.6 miles of open water between Little Creek, Virginia and Kipski, Virginia.
    • 00:03:11
      The approximate crossing time was an hour and 45 minutes.
    • 00:03:16
      Loading and loading can take approximately on average 30 minutes.
    • 00:03:19
      So thankfully visionaries in 1956 approached the General Assembly for the purpose of receiving the funding for a fixed crossing.
    • 00:03:29
      The General Assembly at the time widely stated that they would enable a separate political subdivision for that purpose, would not provide any assurance for the bonds because in the end they did not want to take the risk
    • 00:03:43
      of in any way, shape, or form, diluting the assurance that was provided with the rating at the Commonwealth at the time, which was very strong, very analogous to today.
    • 00:03:53
      This crossing is very comparable to an active ferry service crossing, the Kate Mae Lewis ferry to Delaware Bay.
    • 00:04:02
      Interestingly enough, the actual charges to cross a passenger car to occupants
    • 00:04:09
      The first thing we say is we're there to still be a ferry crossing you could expect.
    • 00:04:25
      The toll is to be seismically larger than they currently are.
    • 00:04:29
      For a car with as many occupants as are in the vehicle today, the crossing is $8.50 if that car qualifies for the 24-hour round trip race.
    • 00:04:43
      So in 1956, the Commission was enabled by the General Assembly to build the crossings.
    • 00:04:49
      The revenue bonds were issued in August of 1960.
    • 00:04:52
      At the time, it was the largest bond issue in the history of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:04:56
      The original crossing construction after 42 months was completed in April of 1964.
    • 00:05:03
      Thereafter, from 1964 to 1995, the system was operated with the two lanes there on the left as you can see across the
    • 00:05:15
      17.6 miles of open water, and after receiving the approval from the General Assembly to complete a parallel crossing for a variety of reasons, safety sensitive reasons, level of service reasons, and to build capacity to accommodate future traffic growth, the Commission received authority to have a parallel crossing in its entirety built.
    • 00:05:39
      The parallel crossing was separated into two phases.
    • 00:05:46
      The first phase was all of the parallel crossing with the exception of the tunnel.
    • 00:05:50
      The second phase would be the parallel tunnel.
    • 00:05:53
      The parallel crossing itself took 48 months.
    • 00:05:56
      was completed in 1999 and the second phase of the parallel funnel currently in our 30-year capital plan approved by the Commission is actually estimated for the design and permitting to begin in 2020 and the parallel funnel construction to begin thereafter in 2026.
    • 00:06:17
      Here we have a picture of Chesapeake Channel Tunnel.
    • 00:06:20
      It shows the hydrographic tumultuous nature of the facility.
    • 00:06:25
      Arguably, the Chesapeake Bay Bridge and Tunnel is located in one of the most tumultuous marine environments of any transportation system in the world, definitely the United States.
    • 00:06:35
      The commission, the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel Commission, who was appointed gubernatorially by the governor, takes very serious as fiduciary duty, just as you do, respectively, with your duties.
    • 00:06:46
      to make certain that the facility is protected and operates as safely as possible.
    • 00:06:51
      Toll revenues.
    • 00:06:52
      Where do the approximate 46 million in toll revenues go?
    • 00:06:56
      This is just a pie chart to quickly depict.
    • 00:06:59
      37% debt service principal and interest.
    • 00:07:01
      Our average true interest costs on our outstanding bonds is 4%.
    • 00:07:06
      We actually are paying down the principal at approximately 12, 12.5 million per year.
    • 00:07:10
      Bridge and tunnel preservation, 24% of the total 2009 revenues were utilized for preservation expenses.
    • 00:07:18
      We're in the minority of 1% of transportation systems across the United States that have adopted the modified approach to infrastructure reporting.
    • 00:07:26
      What does that mean?
    • 00:07:27
      We do not utilize depreciation when accounting for our infrastructure.
    • 00:07:31
      We utilize the modified approach whereby we tie our capital planning to very regimented inspection standards that are executed by a third-party independent firm that is procured every four years.
    • 00:07:46
      Currently that's Jacobs Engineering Group who provides the inspection services for the facility.
    • 00:07:52
      If there are any components of the facility that are rated at a level of seven or less across the whole infrastructure system by component, that component is identified as in need of capital improvement, and then that triggers the inclusion in our 30-year capital plan of the replacement if necessary, the retrofit if necessary, and will lead into some of the capital projects I'm going to tell you about fairly quickly today.
    • 00:08:21
      18% of total revenues are utilized for payroll.
    • 00:08:25
      We actually, four years ago, were at a compliment of 170 FTEs.
    • 00:08:30
      We have reduced that by approximately 12% down to 148 for the purpose of making certain that we run as efficient an operation as possible.
    • 00:08:41
      15% future capital project funding.
    • 00:08:44
      Parallel tunnels to complete the parallel crossing are estimated to cost $1.3 billion.
    • 00:08:50
      We estimate that up to that $1.3 billion price tag that's escalated at 3.4% compound escalation factor per year at $650 million will be paid from investments on hand in the year approximately 2025-2026 and in the remainder to be funded from bond proceeds
    • 00:09:09
      4% other reciprocal non-table related operating expenses there in the light blue, and then the 2% in the orange insurance.
    • 00:09:18
      We are not self-funded.
    • 00:09:19
      We go out and we manage the catastrophic risk due to exposure to hurricanes and tropical storms by procuring insurance in the marketplace.
    • 00:09:30
      We currently have a $225 million policy that's in place with Lloyd's and in the recent, thankfully, the recent two-year health insurance market that we've experienced have claimed very positive savings on our procurement.
    • 00:09:45
      We do offer EVPAS.
    • 00:09:47
      Everyone here is well aware of EVPAS.
    • 00:09:49
      It stretches to Maine.
    • 00:09:50
      West Illinois will stretch into North Carolina with the inclusion of the Triangle Expressway completion over the next year.
    • 00:09:58
      This shows our plaza infrastructure.
    • 00:10:00
      Three years ago, the electronic hold system was implemented at the facility.
    • 00:10:08
      We're quite unique in that we're not a commuter facility.
    • 00:10:11
      We have approximately, give or take, 90 to 100, which we refer to as commuters fairly loosely, per diem during the week.
    • 00:10:19
      Over 50% of our revenues are derived from out-of-state vehicles.
    • 00:10:23
      Easy pass penetration is approximately 35%, as we had expected it would be when we designed our electronic toll collection system.
    • 00:10:31
      And so we ended up, instead of an open road tolling system,
    • 00:10:35
      Which typically is going to be found in areas where the penetration for electronic tolls is approximately 75 to 80 percent.
    • 00:10:42
      We ended up with a hybrid whereby because of the weather delays that we experienced and the traffic restrictions we have to convey on average 35 to 40 times a year with the high winds that we experienced across the tumultuous ocean environment of the mouth of the Chesapeake Bay.
    • 00:11:00
      We have a system whereby those passenger cars and light trucks that utilize our two left lanes are able to proceed at approximately 15 miles an hour through the E-ZPass automated lanes and in the manual collection lanes of the three right lanes that are catered to any other traffic that does not have E-ZPass or commercial traffic, which works well, serves as an input station, if you will, as well, as far as the public is concerned.
    • 00:11:26
      One thing that I will mention,
    • 00:11:28
      The Commission has been very sensitive to make certain that even though this is only three years old that we really maximize the technology that's available.
    • 00:11:36
      We have recently assessed the potential of open road tolling.
    • 00:11:40
      We have relied extensively on the assistance
    • 00:11:43
      of IVI, which is currently the Toll Consultant for Virginia Department of Transportation through its Innovative Finance Division, and in working specifically with the Toll Consultant, Jeremy Siviter, who has been very helpful to the Commonwealth.
    • 00:12:00
      He identifies the fact that open-world tolling, due to our very, very, in comparison, limited amount of ECPAS penetration, is not a good idea.
    • 00:12:12
      We are tied in with the state's 511 system.
    • 00:12:15
      The 70 hands shall finish here locally.
    • 00:12:18
      Hands and legs are very helpful in that regard.
    • 00:12:20
      We reach out, we try to partner with the neighboring localities with the Eastern Shore comprised of the Countings of Akimak and Northampton.
    • 00:12:30
      The Commission enables that our rest area facility that's being retrofitted also will provide via long-term lease an area for the Eastern Shore Community Tourism Commission to operate a welcome center.
    • 00:12:41
      It's been a very palatable partnership.
    • 00:12:43
      Thelma D. D. D.
    • 00:13:00
      In much the same way, the Commission said that it was time to retrofit the restaurant on our number one island via a request for proposals recently awarded three months ago to Virginia Originals LLC.
    • 00:13:17
      It's a LLC comprised
    • 00:13:19
      of a long-term restaurant operator, The Savittis, as well as in combination with former Congressman Owen Pickett to actually provide restaurant and retail services at our number one island facility.
    • 00:13:33
      In the end, what will be enabled and executed is a unique stop for the customer of the CBPTA and what we like to say as unique to the customers as we are a facility.
    • 00:13:45
      It's going to provide Virginia Originals, which they hope to be, this to be the inception, their number one store that then would potentially be duplicated for retail items across the Commonwealth along with the Chesapeake Grill.
    • 00:13:58
      So we look forward to its opening in mid-June.
    • 00:14:01
      These are renderings, if you will, of the interior.
    • 00:14:05
      We'll have formal dining, casual dining.
    • 00:14:07
      We'll have outdoor dining and a unique mix of retail components.
    • 00:14:11
      Capital plan in regards to the modified approach to infrastructure reporting.
    • 00:14:15
      This summer we'll be completing the three-year substructure repair project whereby we have installed approximately 210 cathodic hot jacket protection systems on various components of the substructure for the purpose of retrofitting the substructure so that it sits as good as new without getting into all the technical foundations of the work.
    • 00:14:38
      Interestingly enough,
    • 00:14:40
      Anything that we do that's fairly innovative, we do on a pilot project basis.
    • 00:14:44
      I must tell you that one of the things we did with this project was it was originally designed to actually have three pieces of a jacket that were formed together, provided two seams after approximately a month and a half of thankfully only one jacket being installed.
    • 00:14:59
      The jacket started to rip away like a banana peel.
    • 00:15:02
      What had happened was the seam was designed to be too low to the average water depth and was being ripped apart by the many recreational fishermen who utilized the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel as a quarry.
    • 00:15:14
      So this project was redesigned to provide two parts, only one seam that's approximately 10 feet above the average water depth.
    • 00:15:22
      It has worked very well, and in the end, this system and this project was awarded the Award of Excellence by the International Concrete Repair Institute 18 months ago.
    • 00:15:33
      So very pleased with the progress.
    • 00:15:36
      Precon construction was the winning bidder in this regard, a company from Chesapeake, Virginia.
    • 00:15:42
      This shows, when possible, any work we do to the facility given the location with the waves, with the various tumultuous weather we experience, as well as with the, thankfully, high volumes of shipping traffic that cause, you know, wakes, if you will, of approximately three to five feet depending on the speed of the vessel.
    • 00:16:05
      We do all of the work to try to get all the work completed as much as possible from the jack-up rigs and stay out of the water.
    • 00:16:12
      Tunnel retrofit, we just completed tunnel retrofit of both our tunnels.
    • 00:16:16
      This is the interior tunnel retrofit whereby we're extracting all of the oxidized steel out of the tunnels for our own worst enemy in many cases and that our transverse ventilation systems bring the salt air into the tunnels.
    • 00:16:28
      It causes accelerated oxidation, so we actually have gone in and we have ripped out all of the steel that is not structurally necessary.
    • 00:16:38
      We're structurally necessary.
    • 00:16:39
      We have taken a replacement stainless, and in the end, it's all the work because we only have two lanes in our tunnels.
    • 00:16:46
      We have lane closures every night during long projects such as this.
    • 00:16:51
      In total, it took 28 months for the boat's tunnel retrofit to be complete.
    • 00:16:56
      We do proactive awareness to the public for the well-aware of your traveling between 9 p.m. and 6 a.m. You're going to be delayed for the purpose of making certain that we have the aging tunnels, in this case approaching 50 years of age, as modern and as technically proficient as possible.
    • 00:17:12
      There's the finished project as far as the tunnel retrofit is concerned.
    • 00:17:15
      Scour remediation, given the hydraulic volatility of the bay, we do inspections at the bay bottom every year to make certain that we are at the original design bay bottom elevation.
    • 00:17:29
      This chart actually depicts 69 vents.
    • 00:17:32
      And we can see by the red line this is the accepted bay bottom depth areas such as these vent locations where I'm pointing the laser.
    • 00:17:40
      They have in fact experienced a volatile amount of hydraulic movement, erosion or scour.
    • 00:17:47
      We actually designed a project whereby we go in and around those specific vent locations
    • 00:17:53
      We placed rock dikes that in the end through tidal movement fell out to provide an area that was a cause for concern that was detected by the hydrographic surveys, turned that weakness into a strength in that area.
    • 00:18:06
      We had to do the hydrographic inspections constantly given 17.6 miles of open ocean that we span and the amount of time that it takes to do the hydrographs well.
    • 00:18:21
      We finished, along with the tunnel restoration project, our pump installation project, whereby we replaced all of the pumps in our tunnels, all were aging to 50 years.
    • 00:18:29
      We're glad to have that project complete and provide additional control.
    • 00:18:32
      Very quickly, we evaluate ways that we can be economically sensitive, save money, and we have evaluated wind energy along the facility, realizing that being in the midst of a migratory bird path, the main Atlantic coastway migratory bird path, it would be very, very challenging to receive positive
    • 00:18:54
      Thelma D. D. D. D. D. D. D.
    • 00:19:16
      Civil Engineers and Civil Engineering Program.
    • 00:19:19
      At this time, that is not cost-beneficial.
    • 00:19:22
      One thing that we're very enamored by is the potential of LED light installation across the facility, not just for the purpose of the savings it would provide in regards to less power consumption, approximately 50%, but also the labor savings of not having to go out and replace the high-pressure sodium lights.
    • 00:19:40
      The pilot project for this has not gone well candidly.
    • 00:19:50
      We've had oxidation occur within three to four months in our first four rounds of the assessment of the LED lights.
    • 00:19:56
      We are still continuing to look at this and will hopefully find a winning solution working together with the manufacturers.
    • 00:20:04
      Stay linked to the CBBT.
    • 00:20:07
      We have a very active website.
    • 00:20:09
      We provide an iPod guide for those who are crossing the facility so they're well aware.
    • 00:20:13
      You know, where does the total money go?
    • 00:20:15
      This is a very, very, as I mentioned earlier, we explain to customers, very, very sensitive facility given its location.
    • 00:20:23
      Make sure we pour that money back into the facility so that it's safe and is from a modified approach perspective as well and maintained as possible.
    • 00:20:31
      I want to finish up by saying that if we could accommodate any of you individually or as a group or your respective staff for a tour, we would love to provide the opportunity.
    • 00:20:43
      Are there any questions?
    • 00:20:44
      I wanted to make sure I kept it brief to get you off on a good start.
    • 00:20:46
      This morning, sir.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:47
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:20:48
      That was excellent.
    • 00:20:49
      Are there any questions from Stalin?
    • 00:20:52
      Actually, I have a couple.
    • 00:20:54
      The second tunnel, so obviously,
    • 00:21:00
      You've built the bridges and the trestles on both sides of the existing tunnel?
    • 00:21:07
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:21:07
      So now you just have to build the new tunnel?
    • 00:21:10
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:21:12
      Tell me, so what prompt is it?
    • 00:21:14
      Is the demand that high?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:21:15
      In 1989, in coordination with the assistance of the Virginia Department of Transportation, an assessment was done.
    • 00:21:23
      Is there any parallel crossing?
    • 00:21:26
      The resulting response to that was due to the fatalities.
    • 00:21:30
      Especially, it was almost known as the second suicide strip compared to the 58 of old.
    • 00:21:35
      The fatalities that occurred due to head-on collisions with folks trying to pass and not that they should not, unfortunately began to average four to five per year, not to mention serious incidents.
    • 00:21:48
      Also, level of service, 50% of our traffic is derived in four months.
    • 00:21:53
      where it's utilized as a completion to the coastal corridor.
    • 00:21:58
      Folks from the northeast are continuing to utilize this coastal corridor for the purpose of getting to Virginia Beach and getting to Point South of Virginia Beach as opposed to taking the 95-64 corridor.
    • 00:22:11
      The level of service-wise, the assessment that was done independently
    • 00:22:14
      and a very, very important ingredient to what was presented to the General Assembly, indicated that by the year 2020, were there not to be a sufficient completion of the parallel crossing, the level of service would average E4F approximately 65% of the time between May and September.
    • 00:22:33
      October through April goes without saying, everything is much more solid from a level of service perspective.
    • 00:22:40
      Maintenance, anything that has to be done maintenance-wise, you have to close down the lane prior to the parallel crossing phase one on all the facilities, post parallel crossing phase one in the tunnels.
    • 00:22:50
      We have approximately
    • 00:22:52
      Unfortunately, 1,100 hours of lane closures in the tunnels per year due to oversize loads, due to accidents, due to incidents, and due to maintenance.
    • 00:23:03
      Some of that's self-induced because we've got to get in and maintain the facility, in this case, the tunnels.
    • 00:23:09
      So it's a combination of many variables.
    • 00:23:12
      And one unique thing that I think we probably stress very extensively today is when you look at all the marine crossings in the Hampton Roads area, every crossing has an alternative.
    • 00:23:24
      With HRBTs backed up, you have the Monitor Miramax, Monitor Miramax backed up, you have other ways to get into South Hampton Roads, 460, etc.
    • 00:23:32
      When it comes to the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel, if there is a loss of one of these tunnels due to a major accident or incident, the round trip for an individual that's trying to make it from the Eastern Shore of Virginia to Southampton Roads or vice versa is approximately seven hours around the Maryland Bay Bridge.
    • 00:23:50
      So there is no alternative in the context that we're there to be a major situation.
    • 00:23:55
      So a variety of variables, sir, and it certainly provides a lot more in-depth information if you would like to see it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:03
      Tell me, is your debt, debt of the Commonwealth, or no?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:24:06
      No, sir.
    • 00:24:07
      That debt by the original enablement is the debt of the Chesapeake Bay Bridge and Tunnel.
    • 00:24:12
      The revenue bonds and the primary lien are the total revenues of the facility.
    • 00:24:17
      It's not a geo bond whereby it's general obligated by the infrastructure.
    • 00:24:21
      It's actually a revenue bond that has first lien against the revenues.
    • 00:24:24
      And our covenant rates are very conservative, and our actual realized whole covenant ratios currently are approximately two and a half to three times as conservative rates.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:38
      I'm sorry, so what is your bonds now being rated at?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:24:42
      Total aggregate value, $135 million.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:46
      I'm sorry, so what is also the relationship that you mentioned about VDOT doing that study, so what is the relationship between you and VDOT?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:24:54
      VDOT is the reporting entity through which all of our bridge inspections are reported as any other locality as any other political subdivision of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:25:04
      We report to the Hanson Roads district specific bridge as far as the bridge rates and then that has been reported to FHWA.
    • 00:25:14
      If we have equipment that can be utilized by the Virginia Department of Transportation, we do so.
    • 00:25:20
      We keep a very favorable relationship with the Hampton Roads District and the sewer.
    • 00:25:25
      As I mentioned earlier, Stephanie Hanshall from being tied into the state's 511 system.
    • 00:25:29
      This facility, because of its tumultuous nature, speaking on behalf of the General Assembly from the 50s and the 60s, wanted to make certain that the tolls that were derived on this facility were in fact utilized to maintain this facility because of its tumultuous location.
    • 00:25:46
      And in the end, I would say that based on the analysis that was completed by JLR, Joint Legislative Order Review Commission, originally in 2002, updated 04-06-08, has assessed it independently as the way this facility needs to be operated long term to keep the distinct separation given its location.
    • 00:26:08
      We have external audited financials.
    • 00:26:12
      Currently, the auditor is KPMG and it works well, we feel, to be a great role model for transportation to work in the company.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:23
      And this board has one representative on your board?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:26:26
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:26:26
      Commissioner Layne.
    • 00:26:28
      That was a statement, not a question.
    • 00:26:36
      It communicates well the work of the Commonwealth Transportation Board and is very active in regards to not just our general commission meetings, but also it serves
    • 00:26:47
      on our property evaluation committee for property that we own, that we derive lease income from, and is very active in that regard as well.
    • 00:26:56
      So we're fortunate to have him.
    • 00:26:57
      Thank you for his appointment.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:00
      So you guys would host us for a CTB meeting?
    • 00:27:03
      We would love to do so.
    • 00:27:04
      Yeah, we'll go out there in the new restaurant, right?
    • 00:27:06
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:27:07
      We'll play.
    • 00:27:10
      Any other questions?
    • 00:27:10
      Ms. Layne.
    • 00:27:11
      One comment on that I mean it's pretty evident from serving with on this board how they have used their facilities where I suspect we can in terms of ancillary revenues from restaurants or our community efforts with the local
    • 00:27:28
      It's important for us to be a strong partner, and I didn't mention it should have.
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:27:46
      We actually worked out a long-term license with the City of Virginia Beach in the new restaurant retail area, which is going to be enhanced from a square footage perspective.
    • 00:27:55
      Virginia Beach is going to have a welcome center.
    • 00:27:57
      So that it in fact provides a place on the ground to entice those that may otherwise be heading to the Outer Banks or heading to point south to the Outer Banks to stay at the beach so those revenues can be derived in the Commonwealth as opposed to outside the Commonwealth.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:14
      Any other questions?
    • 00:28:15
      Yes, Jim.
    • 00:28:15
      Go ahead.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:16
      I'd like to hear your presentation.
    • 00:28:18
      The ocean isn't the only thing that can be tumultuous and corrosive.
    • 00:28:23
      I wonder, given the current structure, whether or not it's an appropriate time to look at things like changes in governance going forward.
    • 00:28:36
      I don't have ideas that I will put forward this morning, but I wonder if the way that we've done this in the past is really the way we should continue to do it and whether you have any ideas in that regard.
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:28:48
      What I will say is that that was the charge of the Joint Legislative Order Review Commission.
    • 00:28:55
      I think anything I would say would be swayed as wanting to stay independent.
    • 00:28:58
      But what I can tell you objectively is that Jay Lark will utilize the acronym of evaluated the long-term operation of the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel District.
    • 00:29:08
      And part of our enablement clause is that, as passed by the General Assembly, is that upon the bonds being paid,
    • 00:29:16
      that we would revert to the Virginia Department of Transportation from a long-term public policy governance perspective.
    • 00:29:22
      J. Lark came out and stated that it was their opinion that this facility needed to continue to be operated, maintained, and governed by a separate Chesapeake Bay Regional Commission as opposed to reverting to the Virginia Department of Transportation.
    • 00:29:38
      Because of the many variables, you're correct, there are many tumultuous variables that are risks and those things have to be addressed proactively.
    • 00:29:48
      Were it to remain independent, then that independent body can be held accountable for this independent 23 miles of infrastructure as compared to it being a subset of a larger entity, whether it be CTB or whatever else the case may be, that attention may in fact not be off of it.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:06
      Mr. Chairman, my question is really predicated by I think we are going to face some similar situations where individual projects or objectives actually may function better outside the total system than inside.
    • 00:30:21
      This is a policy question that we ought to try to seek some consistency on, I think, as we go forward.
    • 00:30:27
      This may be a model for us to do other things or there may be other models that would work here as well.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:34
      Any other questions?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:37
      I apologize I don't know this, Jeff, but the tolls on the tunnel completely pay for this chart that you've given us?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:30:46
      We received no funding from the federal government, from the state government, or from any locality.
    • 00:30:57
      We are completely self-funded, and in the end, all net proceeds are then utilized for capital projects, albeit those that are preservation expense related, or in the end, those projects that would be capitalizable
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:13
      Is that the way it's always been or was there initial capital put in by the state to create it and then you took over?
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:31:25
      Great question.
    • 00:31:26
      No initial funding was provided by the Commonwealth.
    • 00:31:32
      When the original bonds were issued, they were issued in conjunction with the needs for administrative funding until the facility was opened.
    • 00:31:40
      So the $200 million bond issue at the end of the day, 140 million went towards the original construction that was completed in 64.
    • 00:31:49
      The rest was the actual accumulated interest on the bonds from the issue date in 60 to 64, plus the administrative cost.
    • 00:31:57
      Now, from 64 through 2007,
    • 00:32:03
      The facility received State Lane Mall assistance payments, just as other localities in the Commonwealth have received.
    • 00:32:10
      And as a result of this board wanting to phase out those payments to toll entities, our last payment was received in 2007, may have been the first part of 2008.
    • 00:32:22
      And at the time, that was 1.1 million.
    • 00:32:25
      And since that time, we received no assistance from the Commonwealth.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:30
      Thank you very much.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:31
      Any other questions?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:33
      Holland, thanks.
    • 00:32:35
      That was a great briefing.
    • 00:32:37
      I've had the opportunity many times to drive over your facility and navigate in and around your facility and actually was on a vessel that hit one of your breakwaters once, which was not a great experience.
    • 00:32:53
      Given the damage to the vessel, I think we should have brought an insurance claim against you.
    • 00:32:58
      But no, I very much appreciate you here.
    • 00:33:01
      And also, I want to apologize.
    • 00:33:02
      I'm sorry.
    • 00:33:03
      I had to sign $500 million worth of bonds while we're sitting here.
    • 00:33:07
      But I was listening to your presentation.
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:33:08
      Congratulations on that issue.
    • 00:33:10
      True interest cost on that was?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:11
      3.2, 3.3%.
    • 00:33:13
      Excellent.
    • 00:33:15
      So.
    • 00:33:16
      Great timing.
    • 00:33:18
      Yep.
    • 00:33:18
      That was great.
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 00:33:18
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:33:19
      Appreciate it.
    • 00:33:19
      Appreciate it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:20
      And we look forward to accommodating you for it toward the future.
    • 00:33:22
      Thank you.
    • 00:33:23
      And we'll look at maybe keeping Mr. Layne going on out there.
    • 00:33:27
      All right, Rail Industrial Access Program application for Greensville County.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 00:33:39
      Mr.
    • 00:33:39
      Page.
    • 00:33:40
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:33:40
      This is Item 2 in your CTB workshop agenda.
    • 00:33:49
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'm bringing it to you today for informational purposes on the pre-briefing for an action item that will come before the board at the next action meeting next month.
    • 00:33:58
      And this is a project down in the location and proximity of Jared, Virginia.
    • 00:34:05
      ITAC Wood Fuels Development LLC facility site is a wood pelletized manufacturer that has chosen to locate adjacent to a Rainier chip mill that this board has approved funds for the Rail Industrial Access to serve the chip mill as well.
    • 00:34:22
      This is a wood fibers company that will be, obviously, maximizing the opportunities with rayon air being next door, is that when rayon air is not chipping, they will be able to also sell fiber over to the fuel developers, LLC, to keep forestmen in the fields and in the trees and forests still employed as the paper mill and rayon air service is up or down depending on the volume.
    • 00:34:48
      This project cost as proposed is a $450,000 project as requested from the Rail Industrial Access Program.
    • 00:34:58
      Total track project cost is around $617,800.
    • 00:35:02
      This project has been supported by not only the local government, which is Greenville County, but also the Economic Development Partnership.
    • 00:35:10
      Greenville County, by the way, is the applicant on this project and will be the recipient of the award of the funding at next month's meeting.
    • 00:35:19
      Rail service will be provided by CSX, as well as this represents an $18.7 million project in the creation of 39 jobs in Greenville County.
    • 00:35:28
      Rail access will enable basically 400 carloads of shipments, which equates to, as the industry estimates, about 680 truckloads per year.
    • 00:35:37
      This is the evaluation criteria that I share with the board every time we do give this project a briefing, and feel free to ask any questions on that, and I'll go to the next slide.
    • 00:35:47
      which basically puts in summary it's a $617,000 rail industrial access development.
    • 00:35:53
      This development is built onto an existing rail industrial access site that we as a Commonwealth have participated in that economic development.
    • 00:36:02
      So it does show that the program continues to renew itself and also provide access to other pieces of property in industrial parts, and in this case, in the Jared area.
    • 00:36:11
      The $300,000 will be at no match, an additional $150,000 match in accordance with the program policies and procedures.
    • 00:36:18
      Mr. Chairman, I'll turn the floor back over to you for any questions from you or the board.
    • 00:36:21
      Thank you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:22
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 00:36:23
      Page.
    • 00:36:23
      Any questions?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:25
      Yes?
    • 00:36:26
      As I'm looking at it, I see what the benefits are outlined in terms of the number of jobs, things of that nature.
    • 00:36:31
      But what exactly are we buying?
    • 00:36:32
      Is it a mile worth of tracks right away?
    • 00:36:35
      What is this program doing?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 00:36:37
      If you go back to the slide and I can show you very quickly.
    • 00:36:39
      If you see the red line, if I could draw the board's attention to the slide number two, the red line.
    • 00:36:45
      The red line itself is actually the Virginia Railroad right-of-way, which was the former Virginia Railway, which was operated by Norfolk Southern.
    • 00:36:54
      That line was abandoned over time.
    • 00:36:55
      Where you see the yellow line begin on the right-hand side of that photo all the way to the end of the red line is the development that will be purchased as an improvement and funded through that project.
    • 00:37:06
      Currently today there is a two-track railroad that serves the Rainier Mill.
    • 00:37:10
      This will extend that track further into, over into the site, which is the Wood Fuel Developers Facility, and also leave enough opportunity so that the other tracks can be developed as the rail access moves further into the park.
    • 00:37:22
      Greensville County has been very successful.
    • 00:37:24
      They have Greensville Inductible Park just south of Jarrett, which is another project development location that has two rail customers as well and is built upon by investments through the Rail Access Program.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:36
      Again, though, I'm not getting a sense just from the scale, and I apologize.
    • 00:37:40
      How much track, how much access in terms of flight?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 00:37:44
      I'll give you an exact number of feet.
    • 00:37:46
      Excuse me a second.
    • 00:37:47
      It's 3,000 feet of tracks.
    • 00:37:49
      That's tracks, tides, ballast, and also an encasement over the Virginia Beach water line.
    • 00:37:53
      Okay.
    • 00:37:54
      Okay.
    • 00:37:54
      Thank you.
    • 00:37:55
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:37:55
      Thank you.
    • 00:37:56
      Any other questions?
    • 00:37:58
      Is there anybody here from Greensville County?
    • 00:38:04
      No?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:04
      We were just down here this week.
    • 00:38:07
      All right, we'll move to the next item.
    • 00:38:09
      That's a Six-Year Improvement Plan.
    • 00:38:11
      Recommendations, Ms. Busher from VDOT.
    • 00:38:33
      I'll get there.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:49
      I don't see it later.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:56
      Oh, yeah
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:39:15
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, this is a draft of the Six-Year Improvement Program and this is VDOT's presentation.
    • 00:39:25
      DRPT will present theirs in the next PowerPoint.
    • 00:39:31
      This is a summary of the entire draft six-year program, including rail and public transportation.
    • 00:39:39
      We are at approximately $7.7 billion.
    • 00:39:43
      The revised 10-15 program that was done in December was $7.6 billion.
    • 00:39:50
      The small increase basically
    • 00:39:52
      It's just the result of dropping off fiscal year 2010 and adding fiscal year 2016.
    • 00:39:59
      There were no revenue estimate changes from the 10 through 15 revised program to this draft program from 2015 to 2015.
    • 00:40:11
      We do anticipate revenue estimate changes in the October-November timeframe.
    • 00:40:20
      Let me do that in the next budget.
    • 00:40:25
      As we mentioned last month, the principles for the draft of the 2011-2016 Six-Year Program for highways is to fund the deficit on underway project phases.
    • 00:40:38
      That has to do with estimate changes or increases.
    • 00:40:41
      We also very much are focused on maximizing the use of our federal funds to meet federal strategy.
    • 00:40:49
      And with regard to that, we're funding and looking to fund, keep funding underway project phases as well as project phases that start in federal fiscal year 2011.
    • 00:41:01
      And again, projects that do rise to the top in terms of funding are the deficient bridges and paving projects that we've been trying to maintain our existing infrastructure in the downturn period of the economy with the funding available.
    • 00:41:21
      The highway program development since 2008,
    • 00:41:27
      The program adopted for fiscal year 2008 through 2013.
    • 00:41:32
      We've had to reduce all available state funds from projects.
    • 00:41:38
      We've restricted our funding to projects obligated or going to be obligated, as I've just mentioned, for project phases underway.
    • 00:41:48
      We have eliminated state formula distributions for unpaved roads, primary, secondary, and urban systems.
    • 00:41:57
      We have eliminated the federal STP formula distribution.
    • 00:42:02
      to individual localities and regions, and we've concentrated those STP funds on underway projects, bridges, and paving, and those have been allocated and obligated by the CTB.
    • 00:42:18
      One of the last items we did was the elimination of the bond component of revenue sharing, and that begins in 2012.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:29
      Mr. Chairman?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:30
      Yes, Dr. Reed, I was curious.
    • 00:42:33
      I was trying to follow the impact on the Stanton District of what was being done and it was my impression that we were about 11 million short and I was trying to figure out why and I couldn't figure it out.
    • 00:42:47
      Do you know if that's the case or?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:42:50
      Eleven million left.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:51
      Short of what was in the original six-year projections?
    • 00:42:56
      Maybe I'll talk to you individually, Donna.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:42:59
      I was going to say, let's look at the details.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:01
      I couldn't figure it out.
    • 00:43:03
      My numbers didn't add up, so I'll talk to you.
    • 00:43:05
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:09
      Mr. Chairman?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:10
      Yes.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:11
      One question.
    • 00:43:12
      Rita, what about the last bullet?
    • 00:43:15
      What does it take to keep
    • 00:43:17
      The revenue sharing program in place because it's going to be eliminated in 2012.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:43:23
      We're not eliminating the revenue sharing.
    • 00:43:26
      We've eliminated the additional funding from bond proceeds that we had proposed to go with it.
    • 00:43:35
      We will continue with $15 million in revenue sharing which is what we had in the program prior to the House Bill 3202 authorization of bonds.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:45
      So we had increased it to 50?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:43:48
      We did.
    • 00:43:48
      We put 35 million in bond proceeds, but with our inability to sell bonds and to keep within the revenue that was available for debt service, we had to remove, we're removing bonds from that program as well on individual projects for highways, and the major focus is to use those proceeds for federal match.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:13
      Mr. Chairman, the impact of that investment is doubled because of the local sharing, which is a very important program for that region of the state, simply because we're not seeing any money being distributed to the secondary system.
    • 00:44:30
      So it's an area that I would urge that we examine closely going forward.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:40
      Lisa Fisher, you always do a great job, thank you so much.
    • 00:44:44
      But I also have a concern on the revenue sharing.
    • 00:44:47
      That is the one opportunity that localities really have to
    • 00:44:52
      I participate with VDOT in the state to improve the road system and what is needed in the localities.
    • 00:45:02
      And I would certainly hate to see that be done away with, because of that especially.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:09
      Well, Ms. Carter, I appreciate that.
    • 00:45:10
      I think one of the things, Ms. Busher, correct me if I'm wrong, I mean, what was done was switch from bond proceeds to, quote unquote,
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:45:20
      There was always a $15 million allocation of state funds to that program.
    • 00:45:35
      We had wanted to grow that program and that was a funding option for House Bill 3202, but it was the fourth or fifth priority down in the use of those funds.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:48
      Okay.
    • 00:45:49
      But then one of the reasons that the lower number was, isn't it also the issue was localities weren't using it?
    • 00:45:56
      I mean, because they were having a hard time coming up with their match as well.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:46:01
      We, the last application process, we had $50 million including the bond proceeds, and we only had Project Works West totaling $40 million at that time.
    • 00:46:12
      So there was
    • 00:46:14
      So I think the issue is going to be for us is to figure out what the right number is.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:24
      I'm sorry, Mr.
    • 00:46:26
      Chair, I couldn't hear you.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:27
      I just hear a buzzing in my ear.
    • 00:46:30
      Now, I've been saying that I think we all recognize the importance of the program and the question is going to be trying to find the right number to put against it where actually the money is going to be used.
    • 00:46:41
      So we had allocated more money to it.
    • 00:46:45
      However, localities, given the current financial situation, couldn't.
    • 00:46:50
      Thelma D. D. D. D. D. D.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:11
      So we'll come back on that.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:18
      Did I understand you said the money that would be used to match federal funds?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:47:25
      The bond proceeds in general?
    • 00:47:27
      That's the major use of those funds for highway at this point.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:30
      The money that we're not using here will be used to match, which is a pretty critical use of money too.
    • 00:47:38
      It kind of costs a lot in our place here.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:40
      Well, that is right, isn't that in the statute that that has to be the top priority of the bond proceeds?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:47:46
      Rail and public transportation and matching federal funds, yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:51
      I'm sorry, yes, this is Ms. Quarantine.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:52
      What is the schedule for when the next round, like for fiscal year 2011, when will this program, you know, be active?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:48:02
      The application process, Mike?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:13
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. McCarthy, the next round of revenue sharing applications is due mid-June.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:18
      And then when will they be decided upon?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:48:23
      Typically several months after that we'll go through the eligibility of the project and bring the draft version to the board for consideration.
    • 00:48:30
      So typically it's in the fall.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:32
      Well, perhaps after that is done or maybe in conjunction with the recommendations this year, Mr. Chairman, we might consider a review to see how the application process went, how many funds were requested.
    • 00:48:46
      If we get 50, 60 million dollars worth of applications, that tells us one thing.
    • 00:48:53
      12 million, that tells us something quite different.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:56
      So I'm sorry, the applications are due when?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:59
      Mr. Chairman, the applications are due around the middle of June.
    • 00:49:02
      We should know around that time or shortly before about the ballpark for the number of requests, dollar amounts.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:09
      Yeah, I think that's, and we'll be meeting when our next meeting is the 16th of June.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:14
      Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't we come under last year from what was projected?
    • 00:49:19
      In terms of individual communities, I thought we were under prescribed except some communities requested multiple.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:26
      Right, I think Sterling, I think what we talked about earlier was we had about 40 million worth of requests out of the 50 million available.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:35
      Yeah, so that's a good point though.
    • 00:49:37
      When we meet on the 16th and we can walk into that meeting with an idea about what the application numbers are for a year.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:49:49
      One thing that I did want to highlight in this program update, as you'll recall, we set aside in the 2009-2014 Six-Year Improvement Program a federal revenue reserve.
    • 00:50:05
      And that was to prevent us from over-programming federal dollars during the uncertainty of the economy and the lack of a new authorization.
    • 00:50:12
      And at that point they were trying to figure out what to do and through the first part of 10 they were doing 30-day continuing resolutions.
    • 00:50:22
      Very iffy at that point.
    • 00:50:24
      In the fiscal year 10-15 Six-Year Improvement Program, that Federal Reserve for the six years was $627 million.
    • 00:50:34
      We have indicated that we would revisit that Federal Reserve as we updated the 2011-2016 program and we did that and as you'll recall,
    • 00:50:50
      Congress approved a continuing resolution through December 31, 2010, which was an excellent thing and that carries us through the first quarter of federal fiscal year 11.
    • 00:51:03
      So what that did for us was solidify the federal revenue for 10 based on funding levels from federal fiscal year 9.
    • 00:51:16
      They also rescinded
    • 00:51:19
      8 billion in rescission across the country that had occurred when Safety Loo had expired in September 30, 2009.
    • 00:51:30
      What that did for us was give us additional flexibility in apportionment.
    • 00:51:40
      All said and done, what we were able to do is release the $103 million that was reserved, federal revenue reserved for fiscal year 2010 and we looked to program it or have proposed programming that in 2011.
    • 00:52:00
      And what we did with releasing the Federal Revenue Reserve for 2010 was we were able to put funding to partially fund the remaining ARRA contingency projects, as you'll recall and I'll speak to in a little while.
    • 00:52:17
      That had to do with the I-56 paving, the I-581 at Elm Avenue,
    • 00:52:22
      And Route 50 Courthouse.
    • 00:52:25
      So we have used part of that revenue reserve as well as what we're anticipating are ARRA savings from advertised projects to fund those remaining contingency projects.
    • 00:52:39
      We also placed a portion of VDOT support and project development costs on the midtown tunnel PPTA, which we'll be hearing more about this afternoon.
    • 00:52:53
      And funding for the 164 median rail project that's administered by the Virginia Port Authority
    • 00:52:59
      What it also did, part of the Federal Reserve included some additional funding for the enhancement program, some CMAC and RSVP, which the NPOs will receive and be able to program in the coming year.
    • 00:53:18
      We also, with the adding, dropping of fiscal year 10 and adding fiscal year 16 to the program, we set up a strategy of putting aside interstate bridge funding in fiscal year 16 from interstate paving.
    • 00:53:38
      funding in fiscal year 16 and some primary bridge and paving funding in 16 as well.
    • 00:53:48
      And we're working on the priorities of planning outwards for deficient bridge projects and deficient paving projects.
    • 00:53:59
      And some of these will be looking at projects more than, for paving in particular, more than overlay.
    • 00:54:05
      Some reconstruction efforts.
    • 00:54:08
      The maintenance program is looking at the paving projects that need to be done that are not reconstructed in nature, and the six-year program we're looking at some more expensive, if you will, paving projects, and continuing to work away at the deficient bridge list that Mal Curley is so fond of working on.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:34
      How will those be selected?
    • 00:54:35
      Just by their structural deficiencies?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:54:37
      Yeah, we're starting at the top of those projects, at the top of the list, and they'll be, the deficient pavements will be worked through the assessment, the pavement assessment program and identifying those pavements in terms of the various categories of structure needs.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:58
      I almost lost a tire driving down 95 this morning, just as an editorial note.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:55:05
      Now, some other things that we've been working on.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:12
      We'll give you the information.
    • 00:55:14
      Now, a couple of the other things that I did want to touch on.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:55:27
      We're looking at all nooks and crannies for federal funding that we need to move.
    • 00:55:34
      to help us with maximizing our federal funding and completing our federal strategy.
    • 00:55:42
      And we're looking at unobligated balances on HSIP funding, federal funding, which is for safety projects, and RSVP and CMAC projects that are allocated to the NPOs across the state.
    • 00:55:57
      And we're looking at the balances on projects, allocated to projects, and those projects are not underway and not obligated.
    • 00:56:05
      And we're reaching out to the localities on those projects and to the district.
    • 00:56:11
      Many of those are locally administered.
    • 00:56:13
      And some of those are administered by the district.
    • 00:56:16
      So we're working with the district to move those projects and giving them some timelines to get their proposals back to us on how to move those, hopefully many of those in the August, September timeline.
    • 00:56:30
      And so one of the things that we're doing in that regard is looking at restructuring the safety program and the application process itself.
    • 00:56:42
      And that would begin in fiscal year 2012 and looking at raising the cap or eliminating the cap on those projects.
    • 00:56:52
      Previously we were looking at a million dollar project or less.
    • 00:56:56
      Some of those were to be quick fixes on safety in areas that have accidents and other statistics that show they were high crash areas.
    • 00:57:14
      So we're looking at bringing those in and looking at them centrally and funding projects of a little bit more significant nature.
    • 00:57:23
      We're also looking at
    • 00:57:25
      bringing the CMAC funds back in and programming those centrally.
    • 00:57:31
      We do have that capability by the federal government guidelines for CMAC funding.
    • 00:57:38
      They would still need to be spent.
    • 00:57:40
      in the containment areas and we would need to work on the prioritization with the localities and the MPOs.
    • 00:57:51
      But we want a better handle on getting those projects funded and moving and getting those obligated timely.
    • 00:58:00
      So that is something we're looking at and we'll be discussing and bring back to you at a later date.
    • 00:58:09
      In summary, this just is a slide we show that shows the changes by highway program, not significant.
    • 00:58:21
      You can see that interstate, primary, secondary, urban, pretty much the same, a little bit more money for federal maintenance.
    • 00:58:31
      That's where we have put money onto, into the maintenance program for those maintenance projects that are really qualifying.
    • 00:58:43
      And that's our presentation for the timely program.
    • 00:58:49
      Do you have any questions?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:51
      Any other questions?
    • 00:58:54
      Yes, Mr.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:56
      I guess sobering would be the
    • 00:58:57
      probably the best word to describe.
    • 00:58:59
      As you were going through it, and I was also looking through the Six-Year Plan as it is, although I think if you can go back to your last chart where we're looking at the overall program and we see figures like Interstate 1.4 billion, when you go in and you look at the 2016 is the year, whether you're looking at Interstate, primary, secondary, or otherwise,
    • 00:59:22
      There's a lot of zeros.
    • 00:59:24
      Those things which are included are obviously what you talked about in terms of a pool of funds to replace bridges that are deficient, pavement that's deficient.
    • 00:59:35
      What most people would consider maintenance, very large-scale maintenance because it requires essentially a rebuild of those particular areas, but nonetheless not new capacity.
    • 00:59:47
      And as I've gone throughout it and granted this
    • 00:59:50
      Somewhere around a thousand page document, I haven't been able to go through every page.
    • 00:59:54
      I don't see a lot of new capacity or I don't even want to say new capacity that's in the middle of nowhere, but addressing current levels of service deficiencies where we already have capacity that doesn't meet the needs of what the requirements are.
    • 01:00:10
      I think we've been hoping, we've been praying, I don't know what the right word is in this case, that additional revenues would show up to fix those
    • 01:00:17
      capacity deficiencies rather than what I'll call structural deficiencies.
    • 01:00:21
      But it appears we're not able to get there yet.
    • 01:00:26
      We may be doing another round in October.
    • 01:00:29
      I guess we're all hoping that that's to the plus side rather than what we saw last year to the negative side.
    • 01:00:35
      But I think what I'm trying to get at is we're going to have to completely change our thinking if this is going to be the continued problem.
    • 01:00:42
      looked earlier through one of the briefs the MPO will be providing with a chart on lots of levels of service failing because of the capacity issue.
    • 01:00:53
      We're not going to be able to address those with programs the way the program and the revenues currently are.
    • 01:00:59
      So I don't know how, when this body is going to have to sit down and sort of tackle the issue, but we're not going to be able to address the growth problems that we're facing right now given what we're looking at here.
    • 01:01:13
      So I guess it's more in the way of comment.
    • 01:01:16
      I know that certainly nothing you can address.
    • 01:01:19
      We're looking at toll roads and everything else to try to address this.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:23
      Any other questions?
    • 01:01:36
      You mentioned about the possible revisions coming later.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:01:39
      Do you have any inside information about what the federal allocations, do you expect those to maintain or go down?
    • 01:01:50
      Do you have any indication?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:01:53
      I would say you know as much as I know at this point.
    • 01:01:59
      I really can't say a lot of things are being talked about, but I think they've really postponed a detailed discussion on a new authorization for a period of time.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:11
      There was an interesting article just in the last few days about Chairman Overstar and the House and his sort of frustration he can't get the White House to move forward on
    • 01:02:21
      Thelma
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:39
      We've got a lot of moving parts here.
    • 01:02:42
      And to add to the complexities, unfortunately they've been having to dip into general revenues to even keep the Federal Highway Program funded.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:02:54
      And they're talking about moving transportation back into the general funds to compete with education, health and public safety as well.
    • 01:03:02
      That's very disturbing.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:05
      So the most recent extension of the current Federal Highway Program is until December 30th, I guess.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:03:15
      December 31st, and that only carries us through the first fiscal year, first quarter of the Federal Fiscal Year 11.
    • 01:03:22
      So that doesn't give us much information on how to, what our revenue plan would like for the entire Federal Fiscal Year 11.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:29
      So Happy New Year.
    • 01:03:30
      And as Mr. Sterling pointed out, one of the problems, I think, is that the administration's never put forward its own bill.
    • 01:03:41
      And so I think, particularly Chairman Overstar is trying to figure out what their position is.
    • 01:03:49
      And this is very difficult.
    • 01:03:52
      I mean, as you all point out here is that some of these out year numbers are sort of
    • 01:03:58
      I think the estimate is even too strong of a word as to how much money will be out there from the federal government.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:10
      Any other questions?
    • 01:04:10
      Yeah, Mr. Chairman, on a different note, we talked earlier about getting the MPOs more engaged in these planning processes.
    • 01:04:19
      I'm wondering what engagement we had with the MPOs when this plan was put together.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:26
      I think this plan pretty much is the plan that you, given the time constraint, we haven't gotten to really setting up the process yet.
    • 01:04:38
      This plan is in essence the revised plan that you all agreed to last year.
    • 01:04:47
      So this is more like a five and a half year plan versus a six year plan.
    • 01:04:53
      So we haven't gotten to the processes.
    • 01:04:56
      As we're working through this, we're going to have to figure out how we really much more get them involved.
    • 01:05:02
      First part was kind of getting them in here to begin with and start to introduce them to us and vice versa.
    • 01:05:09
      And then the next part is actually how do we start to reach out for really next year's six-year plan.
    • 01:05:17
      Because unfortunately, again, I look at this plan essentially as nothing.
    • 01:05:20
      Given that you just, you passed this one in what, December?
    • 01:05:23
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:25
      and given where the revenues are, there really aren't any opportunities to change what's in there.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:31
      We're also talking about centralization of some of the budgets.
    • 01:05:38
      Is that something we will talk about more or is that going to...
    • 01:05:47
      Yes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:47
      Yes.
    • 01:05:47
      Any other questions?
    • 01:05:49
      Sure.
    • 01:05:49
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:05:50
      And again, just tell everyone again what the hearings are tonight.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:05:54
      Okay, so tonight here in Richmond, right here, Fairfax City, City Hall, Hampton Roads,
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:21
      June 2nd, that's in Chesapeake.
    • 01:06:27
      And then June 3rd, we're in Dublin.
    • 01:06:31
      In honor, you picked it because my Irish heritage, right?
    • 01:06:36
      Absolutely.
    • 01:06:36
      Okay, thank you.
    • 01:06:37
      So we'll be in Dublin on June 3rd.
    • 01:06:41
      And I think the press release just went out with the schedule as well as the link for people who would like to go and take a look at the Six-Year Plan.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:50
      Okay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:51
      Move to the next item, and that is DRPT's Six-Year Plan recommendations.
    • 01:06:58
      Mr. Pittard, Mr.
    • 01:07:01
      Page, Mr. Hill.
    • 01:07:03
      Mr. Hill.
    • Corey HillChief of Public Transportation
    • 01:07:18
      All right.
    • 01:07:20
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, Members of the Board.
    • 01:07:22
      Corey Hill, Chief of Public Transportation for DRPT.
    • 01:07:26
      Kevin Page, Chief of Rail and Steve Pittard, our Chief Financial Officer, are going to walk through the DRPT side of the Six-Year Program for you this morning.
    • 01:07:35
      We're going to hit on a lot of the same issues, I think, that you just heard from VDOT.
    • 01:07:39
      So there's issues that cross both sides of the aisle here for us.
    • 01:07:44
      To start with,
    • 01:07:45
      DRPT is now supporting a little over 300 customers.
    • 01:07:49
      It's a six-year program we're going to be talking about.
    • 01:07:52
      These are the folks that we're supporting out there every day.
    • 01:07:54
      A little over 60 transit systems, human service operators.
    • 01:07:59
      The TDM agencies are the folks that are out there promoting carpooling, vanpooling, and transit.
    • 01:08:03
      The MPOs we'll talk a little bit more about as well.
    • 01:08:07
      The railroads, and we've got again a very innovative public-private partnership program, our Telework Virginia program that is one of the top programs in the nation for telework.
    • 01:08:16
      So a lot of folks out there that we're supporting.
    • 01:08:20
      In terms of the programs that make up our side of the draft, a six-year program, there's 21 state and federal programs
    • 01:08:28
      The bulk of the funds that we're going to be talking about today are really in the areas of operating, capital, and rail.
    • 01:08:41
      And three quick issues on those programs.
    • 01:08:44
      Number one, when it comes to operating,
    • 01:08:47
      The match ratio we have for operating this year is the worst it's ever been, period.
    • 01:08:52
      The revenues have been in decline while the services and the demand for services have been going up, and so we're seeing a smaller and smaller slice of the pie for those 60 transit operators that I just spoke about.
    • 01:09:07
      Furthermore, we've got bigger programs that are continuing to come online.
    • 01:09:10
      We've got rural transit systems that are starting service in this program.
    • 01:09:14
      We've got Norfolk Light Rail Project coming online next year.
    • 01:09:18
      We've got the Delos Project coming online in 2013.
    • 01:09:21
      So the trend is going to be continued pressure on our operating program and our ability to keep the service on the street and put more choices out there for everybody.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:30
      On the capital side... And, Corey, could you be specific that that's transit only, that there is no operating for rail?
    • Corey HillChief of Public Transportation
    • 01:09:36
      And I'm going to do that exactly.
    • 01:09:37
      I'll get to that in two seconds.
    • 01:09:39
      On the capital side for transit, the match ratio, Steve will point out to you, is
    • 01:09:44
      Absolutely frenetic.
    • 01:09:46
      It's up one year.
    • 01:09:47
      It's down the next.
    • 01:09:48
      It's up one year.
    • 01:09:48
      It's down the next.
    • 01:09:49
      It's completely unstable and unpredictable.
    • 01:09:53
      It makes it impossible for anyone that is relying on our funding to actually budget, not knowing any idea are we going to be high matched this year or a low matched the next year.
    • 01:10:03
      So that's a major problem for us there.
    • 01:10:05
      And then just as Thelma pointed out, when it comes to rail, our big issue there, which Kevin's going to talk about in more detail, is that there is no operating source
    • 01:10:14
      So there's a big push for passenger rail in the state.
    • 01:10:18
      Everyone is very interested and excited about the trains that Kevin's gotten started.
    • 01:10:23
      There's a big project he's going to talk about with respect to Norfolk, but if we don't get operating sources funds for rail, passenger rail, it's going to be a major issue.
    • 01:10:32
      So those are the three things we ask you to really keep an eye on as we go through this.
    • 01:10:38
      Question that we've continued to kind of get is how is the planning connecting to the programming?
    • 01:10:43
      And this slide just kind of walks through it step by step.
    • 01:10:46
      First thing that we're looking at when we put together the program is planning to maintain.
    • 01:10:50
      As Rita was talking about, making sure that you're dealing with state of good repair, taking care of the assets that are already out there is a top priority.
    • 01:10:59
      We do that for an asset management system.
    • 01:11:02
      It's a comprehensive system.
    • 01:11:04
      One of the first of its kind, frankly, in the nation for a state DOT.
    • 01:11:08
      FTA is actually looking at going towards this very trend at the federal level and have been talking to us about how we've accomplished what we have and we think it's going to be a model for states all around the country here very soon.
    • 01:11:20
      Planning for the future though, the thing about asset management that's great is it tells you when you need to replace the assets that are already out there today.
    • 01:11:29
      What it doesn't tell you is what additional choices and services need to be out there in the future on top of what you've already got out there today.
    • 01:11:37
      So we have a number of planning efforts, transit development plans, statewide plans that we conduct in order to get that information.
    • 01:11:45
      and make sure that we've got a good comprehensive view of what the needs are and when the funding is going to be needed to put those needs into service.
    • 01:11:57
      Now the next step is a critical one as well which again Rita was hitting on and that's planning to implement.
    • 01:12:02
      We are very serious about not banking money, about not letting money sit around.
    • 01:12:07
      Thelma has gone through it in great detail with us where we've got a little over 1,100 grants on the transit side of the house right now.
    • 01:12:14
      Money does not sit on those grants.
    • 01:12:16
      We're out there every quarter making sure that the projects are moving forward.
    • 01:12:20
      A big key to that is cooperation with the MPOs to make sure that the programming of all the funds are going through the processes in a timely manner.
    • 01:12:29
      And again, we're not sitting around waiting for things to happen.
    • 01:12:32
      Lastly, planning for the stakeholders and the public, always important.
    • 01:12:35
      We serve on boards and committees at all levels.
    • 01:12:38
      But also we've got a transit service design guidelines document that's out there that helps educate the public on what is transit, how do you start it in your community, and really is kind of a nice step-by-step guide to make sure everyone understands, you know, you don't just go start transit, you've got a plan for it to make it happen.
    • 01:12:56
      All that planning really comes into the bottom level here as to how we put the program together.
    • 01:13:02
      From those planning studies, our customers identify projects they need.
    • 01:13:06
      We've got a guidance document that's got very strict criteria, not about eligibility.
    • 01:13:11
      It's about justification for the project.
    • 01:13:13
      It's about the schedule.
    • 01:13:14
      It's about the budget.
    • 01:13:15
      It's about their technical capacity to deliver.
    • 01:13:18
      It's about are you truly ready to go this year.
    • 01:13:21
      That guidance document walks them through that.
    • 01:13:23
      From there they can then decide whether or not to apply for one of our programs and if so which one.
    • 01:13:29
      And then of course we do our evaluation and we get to where we are today which is the draft program.
    • 01:13:35
      In terms of our goals, again, we take the planning studies and the efforts that have come together over the culmination of a couple of years now and really try to focus on what are those planning studies actually telling us and how are we matching the programming to those needs that are identified through the planning process.
    • 01:13:53
      So what we've got in terms of the transit and the rail side to some degree are key issues that we think the programs need to be focusing on.
    • 01:14:01
      That state of the repair, capacity expansions, Mr. Sterling's point, we've got capacity limitations in the urban areas.
    • 01:14:08
      How are we providing more capacity out there?
    • 01:14:11
      The systems are packed with riders and they need more capacity to serve additional ridership.
    • 01:14:16
      New capacity in the rural areas where there is no service
    • 01:14:20
      We've got four jurisdictions that have come to us and asked us to start service for them.
    • 01:14:25
      After a good comprehensive planning effort, we're ready to bring them online and more will be coming in the following year.
    • 01:14:30
      Security enhancements, always a critical topic for us.
    • 01:14:34
      Transit is a big target of domestic and international terrorism.
    • 01:14:38
      We need to make sure our systems are safe and secure.
    • 01:14:41
      Technology improvements is a rather obvious one as well.
    • 01:14:43
      We need to make sure we're taking advantage of technology and leveraging it at all possibilities.
    • 01:14:48
      And then coordinating services, making sure that human services are maximizing the use of vehicles so that, again, we're being as efficient with the investments and spending as we possibly can.
    • 01:15:00
      In addition to that, again, making sure that we're going to incur expenses in the year for which funds are programmed, not letting money sit is a big goal for us, and obviously maximizing federal funds.
    • 01:15:10
      So real quick, in terms of how we did this year of meeting those programming goals, when it comes to state of good repair, we've got almost 100 replacement buses and locomotives in the program.
    • 01:15:21
      When it comes to capacity expansion, we've got 50 buses to help with capacity expansions.
    • 01:15:27
      Mainly in the urban and small urban areas.
    • 01:15:30
      We've also got the Delos Project, the Norfolk Light Rail Project, and a new transitway in the Arlington area.
    • 01:15:36
      New capacity, as I just mentioned, Bradford, Fort Pickett, Alta Vista, Rockbridge, all coming online this year.
    • 01:15:43
      Craig County and Southampton have asked to start the planning efforts so they can come online hopefully next year.
    • 01:15:48
      So the demand has never really been stronger for us.
    • 01:15:51
      Security enhancements, again, cameras on buses, facility cameras, risk assessments, all important things to be done, technology, real-time bus arrival information projects, and then coordinated services, both in the human service area as well as the carpool, vanpooling, and transit areas as well.
    • 01:16:08
      We're hitting on all the goals which we're really happy about.
    • 01:16:11
      The problem is just trying to make sure that we can advance all the programs and meet the demand that's out there.
    • 01:16:19
      One last note on oversight before Kevin jumps in here is we do have a strict oversight program.
    • 01:16:24
      As I mentioned, we sit down every single quarter
    • 01:16:28
      With every single grantee and go through every single one of those 1,100 grants and find out exactly where it is, what's moving, do you need any help keeping it moving, making sure that everything's going exactly as it should.
    • 01:16:42
      In addition to that, we've got a compliance review program, which is almost an internal audit program at this point as well, where Steve's group is checking to make sure the money did get spent, where it was supposed to be spent, how it was supposed to be spent, and that we as staff made sure that it happened on our side as well and made sure all the rules were followed.
    • 01:17:00
      At the federal level, there's a triennial review program so the feds make sure their money is spent right and then we're going to add a couple additional oversight programs to target major projects such as facilities and things like the Norfolk Light Rail and Dulles Project.
    • 01:17:13
      So there is a comprehensive oversight program where we are constantly and vigilantly making sure that the funds are moving and they're going where they should be.
    • 01:17:22
      So with that, I'm going to then turn it over to Kevin who's going to walk you through the rail side of it.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 01:17:29
      Sure, thanks Corey.
    • 01:17:30
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'll now run you through the rail programs that we have over at DRPT that are included in the Six-Year Program, also one which is brought to the board on a case-by-case basis.
    • 01:17:41
      Just in our review of the railroads in Virginia, we have two class one railroads in Virginia, which the board is very familiar with, CSX and Norfolk Southern.
    • 01:17:48
      We have nine class three short line railroads.
    • 01:17:51
      Just recently, within the past 20 months, we went from ten short lines to nine short lines when the Buckingham Branch Railroad took over the Virginia Southern Railroad, which runs from Keysville, Burkeville to Keysville and down to Clarksville.
    • 01:18:03
      Our two passenger rail operators are Amtrak operating under federal authority for intercity passenger rail and the Virginia Railway Express operating commuter rail services in Northern Virginia.
    • 01:18:13
      We have three very creative and, shall we say, public-private partnership programs that have been a national pacesetter, all three of them have.
    • 01:18:23
      I'll begin with our Rail Enhancement Fund, which has a dedicated revenue source, the first one ever in the history of the Commonwealth of Virginia, and one that has not been very well paralleled by other states.
    • 01:18:34
      And that is the Rail Enhancement Fund utilizes tax revenues from rental cars from your airport and other rental car revenues that come in.
    • 01:18:42
      We get three of the ten cents of that revenue per share for the project uses under rail enhancement.
    • 01:18:50
      It's approximately a $33 million annual funding.
    • 01:18:53
      That's including our bond funds.
    • 01:18:55
      As you all may recall under House Bill 3202, a minimum of 4.3% of bond fund revenues were available for allocation to be shared with the Rail Enhancement Fund and the Rail Preservation Fund.
    • 01:19:08
      Which takes me to the Rail Preservation Fund.
    • 01:19:11
      The Rail Preservation Fund is a short line fund that supports and funds projects for the continuation of rail service in Virginia.
    • 01:19:18
      Typically class one railroads spun off or abandoned or truncated or retired, small branch lines and short pieces of railroad that actually served industries that were very important to the economic development and viability to especially rural areas of Virginia.
    • 01:19:34
      Like the Virginia Southern Division that was just taken over by the Buckingham Branch
    • 01:19:37
      has two customers, a chip mill that serves Stone Container Company and also the cogeneration plant, which is down in Clarksville, which is at the tail end of a 56-mile railroad that provides electrical power and other resources to the localities in that rural area for economic development purposes and sustainability of life.
    • 01:19:55
      Rail industrial access is a case-by-case program, as I just briefed the board just recently in this earlier presentation.
    • 01:20:04
      That project produces about $450,000 available to each locality on a case-by-case basis.
    • 01:20:12
      It's actually funded by the board when it comes about.
    • 01:20:14
      It's a true economic development incentive program that provides economic funds for the development of rail facilities
    • 01:20:20
      As you all well know how the road access program works, the rail access program brings the rail into the back gate and the road into the front gate with the road program, which helps lay a good framework for transportation purposes in Virginia with both rail opportunities and truck opportunities as we move forward with our transportation solutions.
    • 01:20:39
      The Rail Enhancement Program's funding and program goals, we follow those nine basic policy goals that were adopted by this board back in 2005.
    • 01:20:50
      That runs forward with just hitting the highlights.
    • 01:20:55
      Projects, we started with a case-by-case jumpstart project process, which led us into a longer range transportation quarter development program of projects.
    • 01:21:03
      As you all may recall, we came to the Commonwealth Transportation Board back in 2005 with SPOT projects and then led the board through the process in our 2008 rail plan, rail resource allocation plan as to how we would move forward in the corridor development programs.
    • 01:21:19
      As you look at the Six-Year Program as it's developed today, you will find that our rail enhancement programs are broken down into quarters like the I-81 corridor, the I-95 corridor, Hampton Road, Port.
    • 01:21:32
      Those projects follow from our rail plan to our rail resource allocation plan to how we program and develop projects for funding and those projects become a reality.
    • 01:21:42
      So we can follow now under our rail planning initiatives from the rail plan all the way through program and project development through our processes we have today.
    • 01:21:51
      It's very important to point out to this board that we do have a benefit cost ratio that has to be equal to or exceed one or the better known as the investment of the commonwealth's funds in our project.
    • 01:22:02
      We have a very rigorous benefit cost analysis.
    • 01:22:05
      That was developed by the department and is run by an economic analysis company now to give us an unbiased presentation and analysis of the public benefits as they are brought about through our projects.
    • 01:22:18
      The diversion of trucks and automobiles to rail is obviously part of the benefit-cost analysis.
    • 01:22:24
      Some of the highlights talk about reduction in road maintenance costs, reduction in pollution and accident costs, as well as the fact that we also have a value for inventory as it's economized by movement by rail.
    • 01:22:37
      Priorities given to projects that are part of a larger initiative to benefit the Commonwealth.
    • 01:22:41
      You know, again, we're talking about a quarter development program.
    • 01:22:44
      If we have an opportunity, as this board may recall back in 2009, we, the Commonwealth of Virginia, through the CTB's action, the department entered into a framework agreement with both CSX individually as well with Norfolk Southern individually as to how we would go about this quarter development program and how if we had opportunities to share
    • 01:23:02
      Joint Benefits, where we have a freight program project that would have a passenger rail benefit that we could move forward with sharing those benefits under one investment.
    • 01:23:11
      And it's been very, very successful today.
    • 01:23:14
      Just to talk a little bit about some of our projects as we move forward, one of our key and highest priority projects we have right now is the Richmond-Hampton Road passenger rail to Norfolk.
    • 01:23:24
      As this board knows, we started into an agreement, an initiative, a three-year demonstration project with Amtrak to start a train to Lynchburg as an extension of the Northeast Corridor, as well as a train start for Richmond, which will be July the 20th.
    • 01:23:39
      For those of you who are interested, our first inaugural train for the Richmond service will leave Staples Mill Station at 7 a.m. on the 20th, and we will now
    • 01:23:49
      worked to extend the Richmond train to Norfolk under an initiative that was allowable through the Appropriations Act where the Department, through the Commonwealth Transportation Board, can allocate up to 100% funds for the development of passenger rail between Richmond and Norfolk.
    • 01:24:05
      It's the largest metropolitan area not currently being served by passenger rail and once we've done a lot of this today, we will have touched now some major population points in areas through the Commonwealth and provided them with a rail passenger alternative to driving their automobile.
    • 01:24:20
      We also have another initiative I want to point out to the board is the operating cost for passenger rail.
    • 01:24:25
      Again, in the Appropriations Act, the General Assembly allocated $6 million for the support of the Virginia program, the three-year demonstration project.
    • 01:24:33
      Gave us another year to operate through the subsidy base of the program.
    • 01:24:38
      In the Six-Year Program, it's very clear, and I think we briefed most of the members of the board on this already, there's a $41 million gap of funding that is necessary in order to continue passenger rail subsidy operations under the program and projects as we're moving forward with our initiatives to continue the Lynchburg and Richmond service and also start the normal service in the later years of our Six-Year Program.
    • 01:25:01
      In addition to that, we have the I-129 passenger rail initiative where we continue to move forward under the commitments that we made jointly with Norfolk Southern as to how we will make improvements between Alexandria and Manassas for the continuation of both commuter rail and intercity passenger rail as well as the Knoxville to Calverton double tracks project is continued in this picture program as we move forward.
    • 01:25:24
      These are two very critical and key necessary points that I want to break.
    • 01:25:27
      to the board's attention that this also adds fluidity to the corridor and allows our commuter rail operator, VRE, to continue operations at the existing track speeds in which they're operating between Manassas and Alexandria.
    • 01:25:40
      Yes, sir.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:42
      Thank you.
    • 01:25:43
      I-8129, what's the I-81 connection?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 01:25:45
      The I-81 connection is that this sets us up with the capacity improvements to move forward with the extension down the 81 corridor, which would be Roanoke and Onward.
    • 01:25:54
      Thank you for that question, Mr. Davis.
    • 01:25:56
      Any other questions before I move on?
    • 01:25:59
      Okay, thank you.
    • 01:26:01
      Now, I didn't want crescent quarter improvements as this board has been familiar with the great briefing that Norfolk Southern gave at the last meeting.
    • 01:26:08
      The crescent quarter as it moves forward with its initiative with Norfolk Southern is an investment that the Commonwealth has been making now for some time.
    • 01:26:16
      The 81 Crescent Quarter Improvements was in the Six-Year Program through 2015 as four signing projects on the Shenandoah Valley Line.
    • 01:26:25
      This initiative went back, we went back to Norfolk Southern in the process, Mr. Davis, to write to your attention, in this process of evaluating those four signings and our joint framework agreement and our initiatives as we've been working with Norfolk Southern on as to how we will eventually extend down the 81 corridor to get to Roanoke
    • 01:26:45
      Norfolk Southern came back to the department in the application process under the Rail Enhancement Fund applications this year and said we would like to set aside two of the four sidings and do improvements to downtown Roanoke which will assist not only Norfolk Southern in their Crescent Quarter initiative, so all of the commitments on this project, all of the public benefits will be achieved as great benefits
    • 01:27:08
      With Norfolk Southern openly acknowledged by moving this project it will assist in our getting the extension of the Lynchburg train to Roanoke because right now the tracks don't combine and cross over very well at Randolph Street which is right in front of what will be the potential Roanoke train station.
    • 01:27:24
      This will allow better fluidity of train movements and also for the passenger train to work better into the Randolph Street or the Link Museum station site that we're working with Norfolk Southern on.
    • 01:27:35
      I want to be very clear to the board, there is no additional cost to the Six-Year Program, it's just a reallocation of the funding under the four projects, two projects, and one major Randolph Street interlocking initiative that will assist us, not only for freight continuity and opening up the Michigan Valley line,
    • 01:27:54
      for that movement right up that corridor for intermodal but also allow us an opportunity to not have to make this improvement which would potentially be necessary as well for our Amtrak train when we get to Rona.
    • 01:28:07
      The Port of Hampton Roads is another, again, developing the national, as we work now, we're all focused on the Panama Canal improvements and also how Virginia will position itself as a port of international significance and continue to grow.
    • 01:28:24
      This project, the Port of Hampton Roads, continues our investments that we've been making as a partner to extend tracks down from the median rail project, which is in the thralls of being completed and put in service, on up to Craney Island.
    • 01:28:37
      This starts that next very important step as to how we continue to bring rail access landside to the Craney Island proposed port facility.
    • 01:28:47
      As well as we also are continuing to work over at the Norfolk International Terminal side on the, what was referred to earlier as the Norfolk Porcelain Beltline Marshalling Yard improvements, where the Port of NIP will have the opportunity now to build longer trains adjacent to their site, which allows them an opportunity again to build a train to the Midwest or to the Northeast.
    • 01:29:09
      That will leave from that facility and not have to stop until it gets to the next terminal.
    • 01:29:13
      So this is a very effective opportunity and investment that the Commonwealth can make as to how we develop landslide solutions for transportation rail logistics as to how we get containers on rail, get them off the terminal without having to be drained by road or highway to another terminal facility to actually go on rail at that point.
    • 01:29:34
      The National Gateway Project is not a new project to this board as well.
    • 01:29:38
      This project is very similar to the Crescent Quarter, Heartland Quarter as combined by Norfolk Southern.
    • 01:29:44
      The National Gateway Project begins down in Wilmington in North Carolina and runs all the way to the Eastern Seaboard through Virginia.
    • 01:29:51
      Connecting to our port at the CSX connections at Portsmouth and Suffolk and then making that connection further north and tipping west of Baltimore all the way out to near Toledo to a large global facility that CSX is developing there.
    • 01:30:07
      This project did receive some FRA stimulus funds.
    • 01:30:10
      The project timing is critical to us as to how we go about developing the National Gateway Program projects within our Six-Year Program based on a realistic schedule of when the programs and the projects will be developed and completed in Virginia.
    • 01:30:26
      We as an agency, I think Mr. Hill mentioned earlier in his comments earlier in this presentation,
    • 01:30:31
      is that we continue to work more viciously with the fluidity of the cash flow that we have available to us.
    • 01:30:37
      We want to make sure that our programs and projects are programmed as a six-year program at or about the time in which the costs are incurred will be paid out by the Commonwealth.
    • 01:30:45
      Therefore, we don't end up with a lot of reserve balances carried over from year to year that are under obligation to contract to move forward.
    • 01:30:52
      Again, this is a double stack intermodal service corridor.
    • 01:30:55
      I do want to point out that the investments made by this department, this Commonwealth Transportation Board of authorizing that.
    • 01:31:02
      Back in 2005, it was called the connection track to the Commonwealth Railway for CSX, as well as the Suffolk Type Clearances Project.
    • 01:31:10
      We'll go in service in January of 2011, and this opens up double stack access
    • 01:31:14
      Southward to Atlanta, which CSX will then be able to open up the Port of Hampton Roads to the southern tier of the United States and the Atlanta market west with their connections to some of the western roads, railroads that is, that operate and connect with them in Atlanta and points west.
    • 01:31:31
      I want to talk a little bit about our passenger rail service.
    • 01:31:34
      I've given you some pretty key highlights as well.
    • 01:31:37
      But just kind of in a graphic here, I'd like to just show the board how we are now completing through the Norfolk service that southern tier of Hampton Road and that connectivity there with our Richmond train in blue and the connection to Norfolk as well as we move to extend and have that in service by three years into the Six-Year Program.
    • 01:31:58
      This board may recall that Norfolk Southern made a presentation and proposal to DRPT under the Hampton Roads Public Hearing for the Environmental Impact Statement and also CSX has come in a very collaborative way to the table with us as an agency, DRPT, Norfolk Southern, and CSX.
    • 01:32:16
      have all worked together very viciously and collaboratively as to how we will have these train track improvements, necessary improvements up to speed and in operation within three years and in practice working with the department through a grant agreement we're negotiating now as to how we will do the service development plan in order to start that train.
    • 01:32:35
      So it's been a very, very successful program.
    • 01:32:39
      Our Lynchburg Train, as you see running down, which has that opportunity for later connectivity to RONA, has been an extremely high performer.
    • 01:32:48
      It is a very high national performer.
    • 01:32:51
      I want to be very clear to this board that this is kind of an anomaly when it comes to intercity passenger rail, but the performance financially of the Lynchburg train has been very successful for us and has given us the ability to also
    • 01:33:11
      I'll try not to burden the Six-Year Program as we move forward with that frame, but I want the Board to understand that intercity passenger rail typically is going to cost a lot more in some quarters than what it's costing us today.
    • 01:33:23
      Mr. Chairman, you're in the Lynchburg Board.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:26
      I might ask at this point, how much short does the revenue come on that section to support, keep the system open beyond the three years?
    • 01:33:37
      What's the subsidy we've got to have to keep the operating?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 01:33:42
      Right.
    • 01:33:43
      Realistically, we've tried to put forward under the Lynchburg train subsidy.
    • 01:33:48
      We've had to calculate in, you know, for the coming years, the $2.9 million, but I want to make it clear to the board at this point, through the six months, rolling six months of operations and revenue, we have exceeded the cost and subsidy of that train service.
    • 01:34:04
      So I want to be clear to the board that we are being good stewards and budgeting funds within the Six-Year Program to realistically show you what our obligations under contract are to Amtrak.
    • 01:34:17
      But I want the board to understand that right now we are, through the first six rolling months, we are in a positive cash flow.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:34:25
      Mr. Chairman, I don't know if this is the right time or if you're the person to answer this question, but I at some point would like to know the cost of maintaining that rail line versus the cost of repaving and maintaining roadways.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:34:40
      So, as someone, I don't know who's...
    • 01:34:41
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 01:34:53
      If I can speak to Mr. Peake's question, if I may.
    • 01:34:57
      It's a very good question.
    • 01:34:58
      We do have an access fee that is paid to the railroad company.
    • 01:35:02
      and in that annual access fee is calculated out.
    • 01:35:07
      Some of that is for right-of-way maintenance and upkeep and deferred maintenance and the other is dealing with the operations side, the costs of the dispatchers and unapproved people that are associated with that.
    • 01:35:17
      I can provide that to you.
    • 01:35:19
      You will find that the improvements that we have made under rail enhancement, those improvements have to be maintained by the railroad company at no cost to the economy.
    • 01:35:29
      So what we're paying is covering all the railroad maintenance lines.
    • 01:35:34
      It's covering the incremental cost of the train that will be using the tracks.
    • 01:35:39
      It's not 100% of the total maintenance of the railroad.
    • 01:35:41
      But what we paid in the train company then maintains the railroad.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:45
      That's correct.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:46
      Yes, sir.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:35:47
      The first three years, I believe, were some of the reasons we paid that much access.
    • 01:35:57
      That's correct.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:57
      So the first three years were sort of not paying that access, but then it will, or slightly not paying that access.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:36:01
      Any idea what the access is?
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:05
      What I anticipate and want you all to come back to me with is the fact that what we pay to keep this rail line is a whole lot cheaper than what it costs to pave a road.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 01:36:27
      If my name is Karen, I'll go to the Rail Preservation Fund.
    • 01:36:30
      Thank you.
    • 01:36:31
      The second rail program that's actually in the Six-Year Program is our Rail Preservation Fund.
    • 01:36:38
      The Rail Preservation Fund began back in 1990 with just one or two short-line railroads that had been created.
    • 01:36:46
      Those of you who have ever followed the history of railroading in America through the 1980s following the Staggers Act, our U.S. railroads were given the opportunity to start to function more like a business with fewer ties to regulatory directed service to rural areas and other pieces of track that did not warrant the profitability that the railroads were looking for.
    • 01:37:08
      Having said that, at the same time, the local rail freight assistance program that the federal government had moving forward ceased to exist and therefore there were no funds available for fledgling short-line railroads as they came about through the 1990s.
    • 01:37:24
      Again, I said we had nine short-line railroads in Virginia.
    • 01:37:27
      Seven of the nine actually are in the Six-Year Program with projects as we move forward.
    • 01:37:32
      Again, these railroads serve the economic development of the area and the shippers.
    • 01:37:36
      The continuation of railroad operations to rural areas like Buckingham County or Clarksville, Virginia.
    • 01:37:43
      Our most recent initiative that we've worked through with the rail preservation program has been the Buckingham Ranch's long-term lease of the Richmond-Allegheny subdivision of CSS.
    • 01:37:54
      CSX felt that the Richmond, Charlottesville, Stanton, E. Clifton Forge line did not warrant a high enough return on investments of operations in capital maintenance to continue operations, and it actually filed for abandonment of one section here in Richmond, which was the connection to this critical piece of railroad.
    • 01:38:14
      As we moved forward, CSX and the Buckham Branch were able to come to terms and move forward with a program of projects.
    • 01:38:20
      Which also now, under this long-term lease, the 130 miles and the 200 miles of railroad actually has Amtrak structure.
    • 01:38:27
      So the Cardinal today operates in the Stanton District, the Culpeper District as well, the Northern Virginia District, because of the fact that it still has the connectivity over the Buckingham Branch from Orange, Virginia to Gordon's Field and Gordon's Field all the way close to Ford's.
    • 01:38:41
      So this is a very critical piece of railroad, not only for freight movements in Virginia, but also it keeps passenger rail operations operating out in that area.
    • 01:38:49
      We have projects that deal as well, respectively, with time replacement, rail replacement.
    • 01:38:55
      Remember, railroads are typically engineered and built for 100 years of life.
    • 01:38:59
      Shortline railroads are picking up the little branch lines and sidelines that really weren't maintained as well as they probably could have been if they were mainline railroads, so we have a lot of major bridge infrastructure that we need to work on.
    • 01:39:11
      This board may remember in the early days of the rail preservation program being a six-year fund,
    • 01:39:16
      We actually brought those heavy axle loadings up to 286,000 pounds.
    • 01:39:20
      That was critical for the short line railroads because they had to be competitive and make interchange of the heavy axle cars because that was the new national standard for the weight of a freight car.
    • 01:39:28
      We also do Act Grey Crossing upgrades.
    • 01:39:31
      I do know that VDOT has the Section 130 Grey Crossing Safety Program, but we also have, through this program of projects, any VDOT facility that we run through with a rail preservation program, as we're doing tracks, ties, and valves, we also do the Grey Crossing services as part of this program and project.
    • 01:39:48
      I just wanted to let the board know that in the event that the 130 fund is not paying for grade crossing upgrades, we have a maintenance project, you know, that project runs through one of the VDOT facilities, and we also deal respectfully with that improvement of the highway as well.
    • 01:40:02
      Kind of project performance, I just want to run through these very quickly, just like Corey did with the transit program.
    • 01:40:08
      We do deal specifically with contract negotiations.
    • 01:40:12
      I will say that Ms. Drake hit the ground running and has found that every single rail project has its own idiosyncrasies and also has its own longevity in negotiations.
    • 01:40:23
      We do move forward with that.
    • 01:40:24
      We do protect the public's investment and we do look very critically as to what the Commonwealth gets for its investment and how that fits into the overall transportation program that we're trying to move forward as an agency and as a Commonwealth as a whole.
    • 01:40:38
      We do require monthly reports with the projects as we move forward as well as the rail enhancement fund requires an annual performance report back that has a recovery cost associated with it because again we are purchasing a public benefit with that program so therefore we have to protect the investment and seek recovery for failure to perform.
    • 01:40:58
      As well as the Rail Preservation Fund, under the Rail Preservation Program projects, the Commonwealth actually retains an ownership interest in the facilities it's made improvements to, so therefore it's retired over time and does require an annual performance report as well from that program.
    • 01:41:14
      Rail access is a two-year job performance, five-year carload performance that has a stream that runs out to 15 years as part of that contract as well.
    • 01:41:22
      I'll now turn the floor over to Mr. Pittard, if there are no questions, or you can hold your questions until the end, whenever it suits you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:41:29
      And Mr. Pittard will run us through your financials.
    • 01:41:30
      Thank you.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:41:32
      Thank you, Kevin.
    • 01:41:33
      I just want to start out by saying thanks to all the board members for giving us the opportunity to come out and meet with you all in the past couple of weeks.
    • 01:41:40
      That was hopefully very informative for you all, and it was very good to have a sit-down, face-to-face meeting with all of you.
    • 01:41:48
      With that being said, I'm going to try to keep this at a high level and just focus on really a lot of the highlights that Corey and Kevin have already put out there before you all.
    • 01:41:58
      Overall, the program before you is consistent with where we were back in December when we did the revised fiscal year 10 program.
    • 01:42:07
      That is about a 10% reduction from where we were last June.
    • 01:42:12
      And that's the same guidance we provided to our operators with respect to their planning for their budgets.
    • 01:42:20
      The impact of the recordation tax has been mitigated due to the decline in revenues.
    • 01:42:26
      When that was put forward as an additional revenue source for our transit operations, we had done an analysis and anticipated getting in the 55 to 60 percent range of those eligible costs.
    • 01:42:39
      I'll just take a moment and just find eligible versus later on I use a percentage of total cost.
    • 01:42:45
      In the Code of Virginia, we're only allowed to fund eligible costs for operations in transit.
    • 01:42:51
      And essentially, what it does is it eliminates mechanics and drivers' wages from state participation in funding, which is a large expenditure.
    • 01:43:02
      So when we talk different percentages of transit operations, we talk eligible, which eliminates mechanics and drivers'
    • 01:43:11
      Salaries and Benefits, and then we also talked the total cost of transit.
    • 01:43:17
      And what we hoped with recordation tax is we'd be at 55 to 60%, with 95% being the maximum allowed in the Code of Regency.
    • 01:43:27
      And that just hasn't happened.
    • 01:43:30
      As you'll see, we're at 36%.
    • 01:43:33
      The state's blending match on the capital side is at 56%, which is a relatively good matching percentage from a historical perspective.
    • 01:43:41
      We still see that the capital match is going up and down.
    • 01:43:45
      There's no consistency to that matching percentage.
    • 01:43:50
      We also, as Kevin mentioned, on the rail operating subsidy, that's a big point.
    • 01:43:55
      In addition to what Kevin mentioned, we have, Kevin you can correct me if I'm wrong, a 2013-2014 range.
    • 01:44:03
      I think federal legislation is requiring us to take over all regional trains via subsidy for the ones that currently Amtrak is supporting.
    • 01:44:15
      I forget the number.
    • 01:44:17
      How many trains?
    • 01:44:22
      Five?
    • 01:44:22
      In addition to the three that we start.
    • 01:44:25
      The three we have are showing a $41 million unfunded balance.
    • 01:44:28
      But in 13-14, the federal government is looking to us to pick up the subsidy on those four, five trains in addition to that.
    • 01:44:37
      So it's not just an issue with the trains we're starting.
    • 01:44:39
      It's also the trains that already exist today that start in the region.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:43
      I want to make sure I understand.
    • 01:44:45
      The federal government has told us, congratulations, you now have to provide the subsidy for these particular rail lines.
    • 01:44:53
      Correct.
    • 01:44:54
      And have you sent us a lot of money to go along with that?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:44:57
      Incorrect.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:58
      Steve, and that was in PREA, but it doesn't hit until 2013, 2014, so we're hoping we can get that changed.
    • 01:45:08
      We're working on that.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:45:10
      I bring it up mainly because as part of the whole, you know, operating subsidy issue for rail that we're hammering on here today, that's another issue that's just a couple of years out looming.
    • 01:45:22
      Finally, I think the other point to be made is that we have a rail resource allocation plan that you all have all seen.
    • 01:45:29
      As Kevin said, we follow that plan with respect to our allocations, but there had to be some adjustments due to the lack of receiving the stimulus funds.
    • 01:45:40
      We applied, you all have been briefed before, for $1.7 billion and we ended up getting $75 million.
    • 01:45:45
      That did cause us to change to some degree our planning with respect to allocations.
    • 01:45:52
      The next slide just provides a high-level total for our six-year program for the last four years and essentially from last year to this year there's a slight increase but that is essentially caused by
    • 01:46:08
      Six full years worth of the $50 million match for the WMATA State of Good Repair Program is included whereas last year it was only five years before it starts in 11.
    • 01:46:19
      And last year, so this year it's 11 through 16 versus 11 through 15 last year.
    • 01:46:25
      And then $28 million more in transit bond allocations.
    • 01:46:28
      Once again, last year we had
    • 01:46:32
      30 million dollars in ARRA funding which allowed us not to allocate the full 60 million dollars that was available of the transit bond capacity.
    • 01:46:41
      And also there was some issue we hadn't issued bonds at this point last year and so to some degree we're being conservative and didn't want to keep making allocations without knowing we were going to be able to issue those bonds.
    • 01:46:54
      The next point there is the Dallas Metrorail project continues to tail off the funding there as that project transitions to EMWA, the Air Force Authority.
    • 01:47:04
      And then otherwise, as I mentioned earlier, the revenues are pretty much flat.
    • 01:47:09
      Some slight increases in the out years.
    • 01:47:24
      The next slide is a chart of our operations funding and as I was describing the eligible versus the total cost.
    • 01:47:45
      You have two lines.
    • 01:47:45
      The top line is the eligible one.
    • 01:47:50
      shows the trend that I think is a big point for us today that basically operations funding the state's providing has been trending down the last really eight years.
    • 01:48:00
      But in particular, what's alarming is the addition of $20 million, $22 million of recordation tax revenues in 09.
    • 01:48:09
      We didn't get the uptick that we thought we'd get.
    • 01:48:12
      We actually got
    • 01:48:13
      a downtick, and it wasn't caused by the recordation, it was just the loss of all the other revenue.
    • 01:48:18
      At the same time, the service has been increasing, especially in those 708 gas prices surging.
    • 01:48:26
      So we're sort of caught in a conundrum where we thought we'd be going this direction, instead we're going the opposite direction.
    • 01:48:33
      The other line here is the total cost of transit operations, and it shows that historically we'd been in a band of about 20 to 22 percent,
    • 01:48:43
      And currently we're at about 14.7% I think is the number.
    • 01:48:50
      So once again the same trend is with the eligible share.
    • 01:48:54
      Our internal goal is to hopefully figure out a way to try to get us back to that 20%.
    • 01:48:59
      And for our providers, what they would like is a standard level of commitment from the state as opposed to varying levels.
    • 01:49:09
      You don't see it quite as dramatically here as you will with capital, but the disturbing part is the downward trend.
    • 01:49:16
      The next slide is a chart that shows, once again, our operations funding and it breaks down the total cost.
    • 01:49:25
      by Fair Box Recovery.
    • 01:49:29
      Also it breaks down federal funding that's included and it includes local funds and the state share.
    • 01:49:35
      And you see here the bottom part of the chart.
    • 01:49:39
      I'm assuming you all have color slides.
    • 01:49:42
      It's sort of a darkish blue.
    • 01:49:44
      Fair Box Recovery, that's one way to
    • 01:49:48
      I don't know how that happened.
    • 01:49:51
      Did you do that, Carol?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:59
      Hit it again, Steve.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:50:00
      Will it move one more time?
    • 01:50:05
      Anyway, farebox recovery is at 45% for the current year.
    • 01:50:09
      National average, the last data that we have from the national transit database was 34%.
    • 01:50:15
      Corey and I both believe that's a little low as far as the national average.
    • 01:50:19
      We think it's closer to 40, but the point is we are above the national average for farebox recovery.
    • 01:50:26
      So that is one avenue to get more funding, but we're already above national.
    • 01:50:31
      The other point from this chart is you'll see that as our percentage share has declined, the localities essentially are the ones that are making it up the top part of the chart.
    • 01:50:43
      The next slide is a capital, is a chart of our capital matching share and this is where the chart actually goes up and down while it swings based on receiving one-time funding a lot of times in the past from general funds and then also last year we had ARRA funding so we had 30 million dollars to supplement our funding last year so
    • 01:51:07
      And same point here, I think for our providers, they have to prepare budgets and know how much money they need, but they don't really know from us how much we're going to provide.
    • 01:51:18
      So that being said, I think for us an internal goal is we're trying to get within the current confines of Code Section 2, somehow trying to provide that consistency.
    • 01:51:31
      And one of the things on the next slide that I'll talk about,
    • 01:51:36
      is the overall allocation assumptions.
    • 01:51:39
      And the first one, well, I'll skip down to the second bullet.
    • 01:51:44
      What we did with capital this year that's different in past years is in the past two years, three years, we took all of our bond funding and any project that qualified for that funding, we gave it 80% matching share.
    • 01:51:59
      And then all the other projects that qualified for mass transit trust funding, basically it's just strict
    • 01:52:06
      Well, this year, what we said is, you know, we talked about maintenance of assets as being a core principle that we support.
    • 01:52:17
      So we said, what's the core asset of our transit providers?
    • 01:52:21
      That's, you know, rolling stock.
    • 01:52:23
      So any application we had for replacement rolling stock, we chose to fund that at an 80 percent level.
    • 01:52:30
      All the other items that qualified for bond funders, because we didn't have enough funds available, all the other items that qualified for bond funding, we merged together with the Master Transit Trust Fund and funded them to where they came to an equal share, which was 53%.
    • 01:52:48
      And we had given guidance previous to our providers that we thought we'd have a matching share of at least 50%.
    • 01:52:53
      So we were able to meet that.
    • 01:52:55
      That's one item that's a little bit different this year.
    • 01:52:58
      We've given training to our grantees the last two weeks, and we haven't heard any negative feedback.
    • 01:53:05
      We think it's a positive step.
    • 01:53:07
      They want to see some consistency in what they can expect from us.
    • 01:53:16
      The first bullet here is our operating funding and we did have to exercise a few items at our discretion to get the operating amount of funding provided this year to equal what we gave in the revised draft.
    • 01:53:31
      which is $102 million.
    • 01:53:34
      So what we did is the General Assembly provided in the Appropriation Act the ability to move some of the Mass Transit Trust Fund capital funds to make up that difference.
    • 01:53:45
      We did that.
    • 01:53:46
      They allowed up to 20% of that pot of funding.
    • 01:53:50
      We took just a small amount.
    • 01:53:52
      I think it was about $6 million.
    • 01:53:53
      We could have moved $880,000.
    • 01:53:57
      We also had deobligated funds, as Corey mentioned, from pushing grantees to push projects along of $1.76 million to projects either that didn't go forward or they came in under budget that we put towards this.
    • 01:54:12
      And then we also, as we did last year, we took a portion of the special projects funding and put towards closing that gap so that we gave out the same amount of dollars for operating we gave out back in December.
    • 01:54:26
      The third bullet here is the blended share I mentioned with, well same thing I was talking about the capital, the blending of the 53% between the bond, the non-rolling stock replacement bond eligible projects with the mass transit trust fund projects.
    • 01:54:43
      And then, as I mentioned earlier, the drop in the capital match is due primarily to the ARRA Fund.
    • 01:54:51
      We had $30 million in 100% funding last year, which we don't have this year.
    • 01:54:56
      And then the next item is, as y'all are aware, we do pay for a portion of our cost to administer these projects and do planning.
    • 01:55:06
      We do pay for that.
    • 01:55:08
      We're allowed to take up to 3% off the top of the Mass Transit Trust Fund, the Rail Enhancement Fund, and the Rail Preservation Fund.
    • 01:55:15
      So three specific funding sources out of the 15 or so that we have, we can take a portion of.
    • 01:55:23
      And this year, we're looking at a budget of about taking 2.5%.
    • 01:55:29
      The next slide gives the RAIL allocation assumptions at a high level.
    • 01:55:34
      As I said earlier, we had to shift priorities due to lack of getting stimulus funds.
    • 01:55:39
      We've talked about the passenger rail operations, the $41 million balance.
    • 01:55:46
      Also, Kevin mentioned we got a $6 million in the Appropriation Act.
    • 01:55:52
      The Appropriation Act basically supersedes the code, so with the Appropriation Act we were able to get $6 million of rail enhancement funds.
    • 01:56:01
      Earmark, for lack of a better word, that they could be utilized to fund the subsidy needed for Lynchburg and for the Richmond train.
    • 01:56:10
      And that's not enough.
    • 01:56:12
      The $17.2 million was the estimate for the three years, but at least it gets us a year and gets us to where we can respond to Senate Joint Resolution Number 63, which is requiring us to study this whole funding of passenger operations.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:27
      Mr. Chairman, if I may interrupt, where are we with S.J.
    • 01:56:31
      63?
    • 01:56:31
      What's the status of S.J.
    • 01:56:33
      63?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:35
      We're pulling information together right now, and we've already started the process in talking with legislative service and getting ready to have all of our information to start having meetings on that.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:47
      That's going to be internal?
    • 01:56:50
      Is that correct?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:51
      It's within DRPT, but we intend to involve legislators, Yvonne Miller, when we're collecting information.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:57:02
      And I guess the other item Kevin noted earlier that we did also in the Appropriation Act to get authority to waive the 30% matching requirement as required by the Rail Enhancement Fund for the Richmond to Norfolk service.
    • 01:57:20
      The other provisions of the Rail Enhancement Fund, such as the cost benefit that Kevin spoke on, still do apply to that project.
    • 01:57:27
      And finally, once again, as noted in the other slide, the two and a half percent from the Rail Enhancement Fund, the Rail Preservation Fund.
    • 01:57:35
      And this is just a slide that details out the dates of the public hearings.
    • 01:57:40
      And obviously the draft is going to be out today.
    • 01:57:42
      We have the hearings in action on the 16th.
    • 01:57:46
      There is still a draft document in this book.
    • 01:57:50
      And with that, we'll entertain any questions y'all may have.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:55
      Any questions?
    • 01:57:57
      Ms. Carter.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:57
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:57:59
      And I just want to say thank you for your department and Mr. Drake and for sending Mr. Hill, Mr. Corey, Mr. Pittard out to meet with, especially myself and I know others, and the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 01:58:16
      Their information was certainly a great benefit as a process that I certainly believe the Commonwealth needs to use more of.
    • 01:58:26
      And it's like a comprehensive plan that localities review every, well no, they rewrite every five years and I believe they have to review them every two years.
    • 01:58:38
      And knowing and being educated on the transit areas that we can reach
    • 01:58:46
      into is very important, I believe, in comprehensive planning.
    • 01:58:51
      And especially at this time when there's going to be urban areas that are certainly going to be identified.
    • 01:58:57
      And I know that's a process in quite a few of our areas.
    • 01:59:04
      And I don't know how we do this.
    • 01:59:07
      What we can do
    • 01:59:08
      But along with the MPO and localities, we need to reach out more, I believe, because the information that you all have and the way that you present it, I don't believe is heard as it should be over the Commonwealth.
    • 01:59:24
      And especially in the larger areas that continue with growth at this time.
    • 01:59:30
      Transit is very important, and it's certainly important to
    • 01:59:36
      If we want to have economic development and we want to have success in that area, we need transportation.
    • 01:59:45
      And it's not building lanes because we know that we can't do that.
    • 01:59:48
      We can't expand but so much into lanes.
    • 01:59:52
      So how do we utilize the transportation system that we have with transit and whatever?
    • 01:59:58
      And I really did appreciate you all coming.
    • 02:00:00
      And I hope that maybe in with our localogist and NPO,
    • 02:00:05
      in our area that we can have assistance from you all that will certainly help.
    • 02:00:13
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:00:14
      Thank you.
    • 02:00:16
      Ms. Carter, sorry, Director Trent.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:18
      I just want to say thank you for that and I know within the agency we have thought that has been very, very important over these last few weeks to meet with everyone and really go over everything and we're available if you need us in your
    • 02:00:31
      area, you call us and we'll be there.
    • 02:00:34
      So we think that communication and understanding what we do is critically important.
    • 02:00:40
      Thank you.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:42
      Any other questions?
    • 02:00:45
      One of the issues that's starting to keep me up at night but certainly creates some concern is the pending transition of VRE operations.
    • 02:00:55
      The control of that, no new contractor will take over.
    • 02:00:59
      How we've had that up there is one of the principal activities, rail activities, passenger rail capabilities we have.
    • 02:01:09
      How confident, I'm reading reports, I'm not, that the individuals who currently work for the system may not be joining the new employer.
    • 02:01:18
      Do we have a, not only a sense of where that's going, but a contingency plan?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:24
      That is not something for Mr. Pittard to be responding.
    • 02:01:29
      Mr. Sterling will be very happy to have a conversation with you separately.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:35
      Yes, Mr. Coleman.
    • 02:01:36
      Mr. Chairman, Steve, in the Six-Year Plan that you've outlined here, is there any change in the ratio of state and local
    • 02:01:49
      interest being the drive wheel of the program.
    • 02:01:52
      A large part of the program, obviously, is with local requests and so forth.
    • 02:01:57
      Do we lose the ability to affect this sort of strategic planning because we are not going to have the funds to really respond in that way?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:02:06
      Yeah, I think some of the message with the operating funding, you get to a certain.
    • 02:02:12
      We add Dulles, as Corey mentioned, and we add the Norfolk Light Rail system.
    • 02:02:17
      Ultimately, if we get down to single digits of funding, to a degree, someone starts to say, well, you've got a lot of rules for the amount of funding.
    • 02:02:29
      And as you all recall, under Director Tucker and then Mr. Badger, and then now it's great.
    • 02:02:35
      We have stepped up that level of oversight.
    • 02:02:40
      But unfortunately, at that time, our level of funding on the operating side certainly has diminished.
    • 02:02:46
      I don't know.
    • 02:02:47
      We're sort of in the reform mode.
    • 02:02:53
      We're sort of in a conundrum that probably about half of our funding is tied back to motor vehicles, either in gas tax or DMV fees, et cetera, on the sale of new cars.
    • 02:03:07
      And that our job is really to try to minimize the amount of gas that's utilized and minimize the number of cars out on the road.
    • 02:03:16
      In a way, we kind of work ourselves out of business in a way.
    • 02:03:22
      I don't know if that answers your question.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:27
      Any other questions?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:03:28
      I did have one more thing on the Lynchburg train.
    • 02:03:32
      Kevin said it's been really successful.
    • 02:03:36
      I just wanted to give him props.
    • 02:03:39
      We have exceeded, in six months, the passenger estimate for a year.
    • 02:03:44
      Six months, we got 56,000 riders.
    • 02:03:48
      We thought the estimate for a year was 51,000.
    • 02:03:50
      That's what we based all this.
    • 02:03:52
      In addition to that, the revenue has followed right with it because Kevin was able to negotiate with Amtrak.
    • 02:04:01
      If you get on a Lynchburg and you ride all the way to Boston, quite frankly, a lot of the riders, I won't say the majority, but a big percentage are going to New York and Philadelphia.
    • 02:04:12
      If you go all the way to Boston, New York, Philadelphia, we get 79% of the total ticket
    • 02:04:18
      So it's not just the 140 miles in Virginia prorated over that 500-mile trip, which is maybe 33%, let's say, just throwing percentage out.
    • 02:04:29
      We're actually getting 79% of that through his efforts of negotiating.
    • 02:04:34
      So it has done really well.
    • 02:04:36
      I share that mainly because we don't want to hold that up as the example.
    • 02:04:42
      When is that contract up?
    • 02:04:48
      With the Amtrak contract it's negotiated every year.
    • 02:05:06
      So, but Kevin assures me that we'll be right back at 79.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:05:09
      I don't know what we'll be at.
    • 02:05:18
      Can I just follow up on something that Mr. Dickens raised before and then Ms. Carter.
    • 02:05:25
      Can we end up directing the staff to both DRPT and VDOT and end up holding a conference call slash briefing for all the MPOs and PDCs?
    • 02:05:39
      VDOT Walkthrough
    • 02:05:57
      Yes.
    • 02:05:58
      No, in fact, I'm saying, right, you know, before, I mean, the sooner the better before we get to finalizing this, definitely.
    • 02:06:07
      I mean, the issue is this one easy way to use technology, get them all essentially on and walk them through, get them the materials, and you can at least then brief them all at once and tell them what we're doing and start to get some input.
    • 02:06:26
      Is that okay with everyone?
    • 02:06:27
      That will go along with both of you.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:06:30
      You won't be able to do that before the Richmond meeting, obviously.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:34
      Well, why not?
    • 02:06:36
      You've got six hours.
    • 02:06:38
      We can try.
    • 02:06:39
      No, I mean, get them all prior and don't rush this thing.
    • 02:06:43
      But I do think this brief you just went through was excellent.
    • 02:06:47
      I think VDOT could do the same thing, add a little bit more meat to the bones on the VDOT brief on some of the issues.
    • 02:06:54
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:07:23
      We've only done four items, so we're a little bit beyond schedule.
    • 02:07:27
      So what I'm going to ask is have lunch for the board.
    • 02:07:30
      The board can grab lunch, and then we'll start up again at 12.30.
    • 02:07:35
      And then we'll eat through lunch.
    • 02:07:37
      I'll apologize to those presenters, but we're going to keep on eating during that.
    • 02:07:42
      12.30, we'll start.
    • 02:07:43
      We'll take a 20-minute break.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:52
      Can I ask everyone to please take your seats?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:09
      We still seem to be experiencing some operating difficulties with the computers, so they're back there checking on what the issue is, what the problem is.
    • 02:08:19
      I will still go ahead and start with the next presentation.
    • 02:08:22
      That's the revised fiscal year 2010 annual budget.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:08:34
      And Mr. Chairman, members of the board, we are proposing to revise the fiscal year 10 budget again.
    • 02:08:46
      We revised it in December and we need to revise it again.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:50
      Can I just point out, everyone, you have that presentation here.
    • 02:08:53
      There's really good news in there, right, Ms. Busher?
    • 02:08:57
      Actually, we broke the machine on purpose.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:00
      Go ahead.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:09:05
      The first slide discusses the reason for the budget being revised is directly related to the significant cost that we experienced this winter for snow removal.
    • 02:09:25
      It does not change the bottom line of the annual budget.
    • 02:09:30
      It remains at $3.378 billion.
    • 02:09:33
      It will be revised in December, which is the chart on the first page, just summarizing it by program.
    • 02:09:42
      On the second page, I start to discuss
    • 02:09:47
      The snow related expenditures exceeded $263 million.
    • 02:09:55
      A review of the administrative and other operating programs was done so that we could
    • 02:10:07
      identified funds that could be made available to be transferred to the maintenance program to help offset these extreme costs.
    • 02:10:16
      In fact, we found almost $21 million of available funding that was identified in the administrative and other operational programs.
    • 02:10:26
      Approximately $8 million of that was personal services savings that
    • 02:10:36
      In some ways related to impact and other employee changes.
    • 02:10:43
      About seven and a half million were non-personal budget amounts that were identified that could be released.
    • 02:10:50
      They became available due to delayed procurement.
    • 02:10:54
      and the reassessment of our needs in these areas at the time.
    • 02:11:00
      And we did reduce the capital outlay program by another $5 million.
    • 02:11:10
      More specifically, to talk about that $20 million, approximately $3.5 million of that came from the Environmental Monitoring and Evaluation Program.
    • 02:11:22
      And that was largely delaying the purchase of some wetland credits and some consultant procurement until the next fiscal year.
    • 02:11:32
      We also identified 2.4 million from planning in that we had reduced land development activities, so we had unspent funds in that program.
    • 02:11:45
      Under construction management, we did have a little bit of cost savings related to reduced staffing levels.
    • 02:11:57
      And in the administrative and support services program,
    • 02:12:01
      We had savings, again, in personal costs, and we didn't end up using as much of the severance funding, severance cost funding that we had allocated due to the various layoff stages.
    • 02:12:18
      And again, you can see the five million for capital outlay.
    • 02:12:22
      So that again summarizes and totals about 20.6 million dollars.
    • 02:12:29
      And I'll show you how that fits into the revised maintenance budget on the next slide.
    • 02:12:36
      Basically we
    • 02:12:38
      spent $263.3 million in snow expenditures.
    • 02:12:44
      The fiscal year 10 snow budget was $79.7 million.
    • 02:12:50
      So we were short $183.6 million.
    • 02:12:55
      Given the magnitude of that cost,
    • 02:12:59
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:13:20
      funding to mitigate the $183 million shortfall.
    • 02:13:26
      So that's on the left, that summary on the left of slide five.
    • 02:13:30
      And to the right of slide five, we talk about how we accomplished that.
    • 02:13:37
      The $20 million I just addressed really came from outside the maintenance program and was transferred to the maintenance program.
    • 02:13:45
      The rest of the funding came from some central office maintenance savings.
    • 02:13:53
      For example, the amounts provided from the statewide maintenance funds included statewide maintenance reserves.
    • 02:14:01
      We had approximately 20 million in reserves for major infrastructure failure and that sort of thing that we decided we would put towards
    • 02:14:15
      In the past, given the fact that it was close to the end of the fiscal year when we had no, we had not had those funds.
    • 02:14:27
      The next is a program project that needs some management and we think of about 20 million in that and that's also a typical need of programming already and that's actually where we have specified about $2 million that we call safety initiatives related to technology and other things that we don't want to be doing and some other things that we should be focusing on and working to do.
    • 02:14:55
      In the maintenance division, central office divisions also looked within their budgets for savings or procurements that could be postponed given the fact we were near the end of the fiscal year.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:15:13
      So within the central office statewide maintenance fund, we have another $40 million.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:15:20
      Then we looked within the districts themselves for contributions to the budget deficit.
    • 02:15:31
      Item
    • 02:15:32
      I would call that a maintenance project.
    • 02:15:36
      We found about $69 million when we looked through a series of the maintenance projects.
    • 02:15:44
      What we found were some unneeded allocations.
    • 02:15:47
      Again, we're getting good bids on some of our maintenance work in our contract, so we pulled those funds and moved into the snow budget.
    • 02:15:57
      Also projects that are complete that had savings.
    • 02:16:01
      We moved those funds.
    • 02:16:03
      And we actually did delay a few projects until the next fiscal year.
    • 02:16:09
      And we'll pick those up.
    • 02:16:10
      So that was just a few months delays on some projects.
    • 02:16:15
      The next 30 million, or approximately 31 million, we looked within the assets, maintenance, and services budget of the districts.
    • 02:16:25
      And what we did was we postponed and did away with some expenditures related to some of the things that we weren't doing as we were shoveling snow for several months.
    • 02:16:40
      I want to preoccupy some things that we might have done during that time frame we didn't get to or didn't need to get to, such as looking at shoulder repairs, some unpaved shoulders that we would want to repair, dust control on unpaved roads,
    • 02:17:00
      Some fencing, some mowing on the roadside, some drainage projects, and some traffic and engineering studies.
    • 02:17:08
      So we pretty much looked in all the corners and all the various areas of the maintenance budget and came up with a district contribution of about $100 million.
    • 02:17:21
      So you add that to the picture that we had already found.
    • 02:17:27
      We came up with 160.
    • 02:17:31
      Then we had 23 million more that we had to find in the last couple of months.
    • 02:17:36
      And basically we took that on a percentage basis from the district based on their budget and funding.
    • 02:17:46
      Thelma D. D. D. D.
    • 02:18:06
      The 20 million from programs outside of maintenance and transfers it into maintenance, which is what this first slide shows.
    • 02:18:16
      It doesn't change the bottom line, but you can see the redistribution of the 21 million.
    • 02:18:21
      And the rest of it just within the maintenance program itself, but we felt the significance required us to come back and show you how we managed to pull out of the program to this winter.
    • 02:18:36
      And I'll be happy to answer any questions.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:40
      Any questions?
    • 02:18:40
      Yes, Ms. Lynch.
    • 02:18:41
      Do we expect any reimbursement from FEMA?
    • 02:18:44
      Where are those money going to come in?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:18:47
      Yeah, we have put together some information on costs that would qualify for reimbursement.
    • 02:18:55
      That usually takes a good year or so to receive any reimbursement on that.
    • 02:19:02
      But it's not
    • 02:19:04
      I'm sorry, is that all, I thought it was, they would cover 80% or 90% now?
    • 02:19:21
      No, there's a percentage share between what they'll cover and what we end up having to contribute, but that's on qualifying costs.
    • 02:19:31
      So it does depend on what qualifies.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:19:34
      One of the aspects of the FEMA reimbursements was that it only qualifies where there were historic levels of snow.
    • 02:19:41
      The total accumulation could have been historic, but per storm, which ones were historic and which ones were declared?
    • 02:19:59
      I'll be happy to provide you a list later.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:02
      So they have already said that the only eligible for us is 40 million?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:20:13
      No, we've submitted more than that, but there are qualifying costs and there are restrictions on which jurisdictions qualify based on how much each of the jurisdictions have.
    • 02:20:27
      For example, Fairfax would qualify, but Caroline County might not.
    • 02:20:34
      I'd be happy to put in more detail on what the requirements for FEMA reimbursements are.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:42
      Bob, I just, yeah, actually I would like to know because it almost sounds like we're being penalized because we took a statewide approach to this versus breaking it down in jurisdiction.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:20:51
      Well, we did have the cost by jurisdiction, so we are able to put together the applications based on that.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:58
      Yeah, but what I was saying is that we ended up moving statewide assets into the jurisdiction.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:05
      If we moved assets to one of those qualifying jurisdictions, that cost would be picked up and eligible as a part of it.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:21:20
      That would be a cost in the jurisdiction where the equipment was working as opposed to their home jurisdiction.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:28
      But if their home jurisdiction had snow and they responded to that, we get zero.
    • 02:21:32
      We left it there.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:21:34
      Well, most of the equipment we moved was we were able to move it because we were not in such a difficult situation.
    • 02:21:42
      But we can, we'll be, I'm happy to provide in detail.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:46
      I think the primary principle for the refunding as I understand it is based on historic levels in different jurisdictions.
    • 02:21:55
      Staten District, for instance, has historically high levels.
    • 02:21:58
      It takes a pretty high level for us to qualify.
    • 02:22:03
      That doesn't get to know if they get five answers.
    • 02:22:08
      I think that's the principle.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:10
      So it's all your fault.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:12
      We thank you for sharing with us.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:15
      Any other questions?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:22
      Mr. Chairman, Rita, you obviously have moved around a lot of money here.
    • 02:22:27
      Are you doing that under a general approval that the board gives you to manage the programs?
    • 02:22:35
      Or are there different rules, for example, when capital expenditure is involved versus administration?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:22:42
      We can make money within the program areas, and as long as we're not affecting bottom line programs, we can do that, administratively.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:58
      I have a couple of questions, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:23:01
      One, congratulations on finding $180 million or so.
    • 02:23:05
      I mean, that's serious compared to like the little bit of money you needed to find for reopening the rest areas.
    • 02:23:11
      And it suggests, you know, maybe we ought to look a little harder in the coming budget to keep the rest areas funded because clearly we've got money that we could potentially use for that.
    • 02:23:23
      But number two, when do we, this is the current budget, right?
    • 02:23:31
      Yes.
    • 02:23:33
      The budget that starts on July 1st, where's that?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:23:37
      June 16th, we'll provide you a full briefing on the fiscal year 11 budget.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:44
      Do we have to vote on it that day too?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:46
      So we get 14 days.
    • 02:23:48
      Mr.
    • 02:23:49
      Chair?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:50
      So the, but can I ask you, so this, due to the, this quote unquote, overspending on the snow this year, it has no impact on next year's budget?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:24:03
      I think that's correct.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:06
      All right.
    • 02:24:06
      But as soon as you get the, we have a presentation on the budget.
    • 02:24:10
      We should get that out to the board.
    • 02:24:11
      Sure.
    • 02:24:12
      We'll wait obviously right up to the end there.
    • 02:24:15
      But I just want to make clear, this is all adjustments to the 2010 budget.
    • 02:24:21
      The 2011 budget will not be impacted at all by the snow from last year.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:29
      That's correct.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:29
      Mr. Chairman, the left.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:31
      Dr. Davis.
    • 02:24:31
      The reimbursement comes.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:32
      Mr. Chairman, just two things.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:44
      The first is to make up this deficit about $2.5 million came out of planning money and I would just make a plea to the extent we do get some portion of this reimbursed that a good candidate for restoration
    • 02:25:01
      The localities are critically short
    • 02:25:16
      The urban development area requirements of HB 3202 something that if they do properly should make our life and our job easier here so I would just put in a plea that to the extent we get some of this back that perhaps that's an area where this could be restored.
    • 02:25:34
      The other thing I just wanted to let everybody know because maybe you'll rest easier is I went out and bought my own motor grader last month with a 10 foot snow blade
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:45
      on it.
    • 02:26:04
      Mr. Chairman, just to follow up on Mr. McCarthy's comments, and it's not like we're finding all of this money.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:19
      There are some actual projects and utilization of these funds would have been in the maintenance of our roads through maintenance projects and asset management
    • 02:26:32
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:26:45
      Thank you.
    • 02:27:00
      There's actual management practices taking place here that's shifting it to the emergency need that we had.
    • 02:27:06
      So that would be the first conclusions one could draw by looking at that and it's definitely not the case.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:14
      In fact, if you just, I hate to say this, but this is one of the benefits for having a fiscal year that's July 1 when you have a situation just like this and that
    • 02:27:30
      Maintenance that was supposed to occur in the spring is now going to occur in the summer and fall for the next fiscal year.
    • 02:27:38
      But the problem is that we're going to quote unquote be fiscally sound and whole, but there will be maintenance that will not be occurring this summer and fall that should have been occurring.
    • 02:27:53
      It's now going to be set back to next year.
    • 02:27:59
      Any other questions?
    • 02:28:03
      Ms. Busher, thank you very much.
    • 02:28:06
      We will now go to, oh, Ms. Busher again.
    • 02:28:08
      The Steve and Rita show, yeah that's right.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:28:17
      This is the era update.
    • 02:28:37
      This is our monthly update for the art project in process.
    • 02:28:48
      and I'll start with the highway program and then I'll let Mr. Pittard talk about DRPT.
    • 02:28:58
      The status of our project, we did a little bit different first slide.
    • 02:29:04
      We showed that six-year projects have been obligated and we are at the maximum obligation level of $576.7 million.
    • 02:29:16
      Approximately $498 million.
    • 02:29:20
      And we've awarded $333.4 million.
    • 02:29:25
      Now, what's happened over this time is we've brought to you a great bid from the marketplace.
    • 02:29:33
      We have saved approximately, I guess, combined 78-some million dollars, which is $66.5 million.
    • 02:29:44
      We've actually applied to other projects and advertised those projects.
    • 02:29:50
      And if you'll remember, we had a list of contingency projects that we were drawing down on and that you had approved based on the fact that the bids from the very beginning were coming in less than what our estimates were.
    • 02:30:08
      Now we still have approximately 11.7 million savings that we haven't allocated to the other contingency projects and advertised yet.
    • 02:30:19
      But we're getting to that and as we get this back in from those items that are out currently for advertisement, we will hopefully add to that balance and along with a portion of the Federal Reserve that we released, we will fully fund all the projects.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:30:38
      So obviously if we have an award of the projects or advertise them
    • 02:30:50
      We only know we have savings.
    • 02:30:52
      Is this projected savings?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:30:54
      Yes, our experience has been...
    • 02:30:56
      Okay, so you've had other similar jobs.
    • 02:30:58
      ...based on the experience we've had recently.
    • 02:31:01
      And the competition is very clean.
    • 02:31:05
      We're getting 670 bids on the project, so we're very comfortable in saying we believe we'll have some more.
    • 02:31:13
      We don't know exactly what we'll have.
    • 02:31:16
      Thank you.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:31:18
      Just to let you know that we were fully obligated at March 2nd, which was the federal deadline in the recovery act, but any savings or any
    • 02:31:33
      The savings from projects that are advertised have to be re-obligated by September 30th.
    • 02:31:41
      So every dollar of our funding has to be accounted for by September 30th.
    • 02:31:48
      And at that point, if the state has not obligated everything, the balance can be reduced.
    • 02:31:58
      The MPO project status, they had 117.8 million.
    • 02:32:04
      They are fully obligated.
    • 02:32:06
      They have 77.7 million advertised and 24 million awarded.
    • 02:32:14
      Now, what I'll tell you is we have a lot of their projects coming up for advertisement and award between now and August.
    • 02:32:23
      So it would be a tight
    • 02:32:26
      This is, again, satisfied just by the five MPOs that received the $817 million allocation
    • 02:32:55
      And that's my summary.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:33:08
      We'll quickly take out through an update on the DRPT funds under the R program.
    • 02:33:16
      First, I'll talk about the RAIL program, and a lot of this is
    • 02:33:20
      Information that y'all have seen before.
    • 02:33:22
      So I'm going to try to get to it real quick.
    • 02:33:25
      $8 billion was set aside for the rail program.
    • 02:33:29
      We applied for $1.7 billion.
    • 02:33:31
      $75 million under Track 1, $1.7 billion under Track 2.
    • 02:33:37
      And unfortunately, all the funds were reported under Track 1 program.
    • 02:33:42
      So we did get full funding on our Track 1 program with $75 million, but we didn't get what we had hoped to get.
    • 02:33:50
      Additionally, we're working currently with FRA to get those funds obligated by the September deadline.
    • 02:33:56
      A lot of that is them putting together their rules for administration.
    • 02:34:01
      They didn't previously have funds, so a little bit of it is waiting on guidance from them.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:34:07
      And then additionally, there's two and a half million dollars of appropriations available with FRA.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:34:14
      But right now, we don't have funds available.
    • 02:34:17
      Those funds will require 20% match.
    • 02:34:20
      Right now, we don't have the funding available to provide that match.
    • 02:34:23
      So we're not planning currently to apply for any of those funds.
    • 02:34:28
      This is just a representation of the one project that was funded, the $75 million Cherry Hill project it does.
    • 02:34:38
      Health chairman?
    • 02:34:40
      Yes, doctor.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:34:41
      Was that done with General Assembly's knowledge that these funds would be available and we were not going to be able to apply?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:34:49
      I'm sorry?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:34:51
      I said, was the General Assembly aware that this money was going to be available and that we did not have money to match to apply for these funds?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:00
      No, this is, this high-speed rail is no match requirements, all right?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:35:04
      Yeah, there are funds and then I'm just, I guess I'm putting there, there's an appropriation in the current year of two and a half billion at FRA.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:13
      There's another program that they have that the capital investments grants,
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:35:18
      Dr. Davis, I'm just trying to get out the point that right now we don't have funds available to meet the match.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:49
      We have some ideas, but we're not there yet.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:52
      Okay.
    • 02:35:52
      The only reason I raised the question, I think if we know this is going to happen and we don't have the money to match with the need we have in real, I think it would be incumbent upon this board to make sure the General Assembly does know that if they don't make available funds to help us, we're going to pass up
    • 02:36:11
      a good opportunity to acquire additional rail funds.
    • 02:36:14
      That's my main point.
    • 02:36:16
      That was exactly what I wanted you to get.
    • 02:36:18
      I guess I'm asking the question, do we need to do anything to be sure that happens or will we be assured that it will happen, that they will be informed, the money committees of the General Assembly so that they can take that into consideration?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:36:36
      We'd like to keep you updated on the status of this and what we're going to be able to do.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:36:42
      Is there going to be a deadline for those funds?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:36:49
      We don't know.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:36:50
      Eventually there will be, but nothing right now.
    • 02:36:54
      It just hasn't been laid out yet.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:36:57
      The issue is that they've gotten money but there's no program.
    • 02:37:02
      So they haven't even come out with regulations or with a policy or any guidelines?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:37:08
      But we do know it's an 80% fund.
    • 02:37:11
      Okay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:37:11
      And then we have to put projects against it.
    • 02:37:14
      So we could even end up using rail enhancement or rail preservation funds as our contribution to it.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:37:21
      Well, I think that's the point.
    • 02:37:23
      We've utilized the rail enhancement fund to their full extent in the next three years.
    • 02:37:30
      And that's the point of my bullet is looking for that funding to be the match could be an issue.
    • 02:37:41
      So, we don't have the, when you apply you have to certify you have the matching funds.
    • 02:37:48
      You may not be able to certify.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:37:49
      But we have no idea when they're going to come out with anything.
    • 02:37:52
      Because right now this is now what, over a year?
    • 02:37:56
      Kevin, this summer.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:37:59
      And if I understand it correctly, we can actually apply and we got the private sector to say that they would give us the cost share.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:23
      Is that correct?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:25
      Correct.
    • 02:38:26
      We think.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:26
      Which we think if the guidelines come out the way we think they might come out.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:38:34
      Kevin said this summer.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:36
      Okay.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:38:37
      Mr. Chairman.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:38
      Yes.
    • 02:38:38
      Mr.
    • 02:38:38
      Carver.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:38
      Do we have a list?
    • 02:38:39
      What's that?
    • 02:38:40
      Do we have a list of projects that we would want to apply for funds for?
    • 02:38:45
      It would be.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:46
      Mr. Chairman, I think it would be the ones we failed to get in the second round might be able to be renewed.
    • 02:38:52
      Some of that effort.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:53
      But this is an ARRA funding?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:55
      Well, this is an ARRA funding.
    • 02:38:56
      Well, this is sort of ARRA funding, right?
    • 02:38:59
      This is the general appropriation and their transportation appropriation.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:02
      Mr. Secretary, our $1.7 billion application is actually 17 separate projects, so they can be broken into any of those components.
    • 02:39:14
      We've had those discussions with FRA, too.
    • 02:39:18
      Yeah, so that, all that's laid out that we know what they are.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:39:21
      Getting the private companies, you know, those were high-speed rail passenger initiatives.
    • 02:39:27
      They weren't freight initiatives.
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:29
      Right, they were high-speed rail.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:31
      Is the 2.5 that you've outlined here, boy, your bullet just has really created some questions.
    • 02:39:36
      Is that all high-speed rail 2.5 billion or is that just rail 2.5 billion?
    • 02:39:43
      I mean, what is the parameter of even the appropriation?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:45
      I don't know.
    • 02:39:46
      And Mr.
    • 02:39:46
      Page, why don't you come up here and...
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:50
      But again, we don't have guidelines yet.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:52
      No, but did they just say $2.5 billion for rail projects or passenger rail?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:39:57
      Right.
    • 02:39:57
      The $2.5 billion is an appropriation under the passenger rail program.
    • 02:40:01
      So it would be for our conventional high, higher speed rail.
    • 02:40:04
      That leads to the development of a high-speed corridor development program.
    • 02:40:11
      And the other challenge, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, is that the initial conversations on the program guidance that FRA is in the process of developing, I think Karen Wray, deputy FRA administrator, who many of you may know, as well as being the former director of DRPT, she's been very clear that they will discount the freight benefits that they can measure or determine as part of a project.
    • 02:40:33
      So that means that that would even further drive down the availability of potential grant funds for a project, because it would be discounted on the freight benefit that could be achieved during that project as well, which is somewhat different than the $8 billion allocation.
    • 02:40:46
      It was all high-speed rail, and it was 100 percent funding with no discount for freight benefits.
    • 02:40:53
      Thank you.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:56
      So that's all clear.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:40:57
      This chart just does get more detail, the one project that was funded, Cherry Hill, third-track project.
    • 02:41:15
      Next, I'm just going to take you through the public transportation.
    • 02:41:19
      $8.4 billion available in that nationwide.
    • 02:41:22
      There were three major programs.
    • 02:41:25
      Transit Capital Assistance Program, which essentially, for the most part, was formula-driven.
    • 02:41:31
      We did get the $30.5 million that the board has in expression of those allocations, which was for rural areas, rural and small urban areas.
    • 02:41:43
      But also there was a $100 million set aside for the Tigger grant program and Arlington was able to apply and get a $1.5 million award from those funds which they will receive directly.
    • 02:41:59
      All of this same stipulation has to be allocated within a year or it's going to be redistributed.
    • 02:42:07
      The other program is the Godway Infrastructure Investment Program, a formula program.
    • 02:42:12
      LaMotta got $17 million and Virginia Beach got a small corner of $37,000.
    • 02:42:18
      And finally, the Capital Investment Grants, which is a discretionary program.
    • 02:42:24
      And the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority did apply for and received $77 million for the Metrorail project for that program.
    • 02:42:36
      These are some of the formula amounts that were given to larger providers in the Commonwealth.
    • 02:42:44
      And then the funding that we administered, we've gone through the past year.
    • 02:42:51
      We had two application sites for these funds.
    • 02:42:54
      All of the funds, the CTB made allocations.
    • 02:42:59
      We met all of our obligation deadlines with the FDA.
    • 02:43:03
      If you all recall, we did exercise.
    • 02:43:07
      legal authority granted to ship 10% of these funds from capital assistance to operating assistance by the federal government.
    • 02:43:16
      We did recommend that to the board, and y'all approved doing that, so that $3 million was approved to help operating assistance in the past year.
    • 02:43:26
      That was actually the current year we're in, fiscal year 10.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:29
      Mr. Chairman, can we back up the slide to the 6.9 billion slide.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:36
      Are those first three or four, the big numbers, are they all awarded yet or is that still open for possibility?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:43:47
      The first, the 5.4 billion, the biggest number is a formula grant.
    • 02:43:51
      So that's when you get to the next slide.
    • 02:43:54
      This is what people got from that.
    • 02:43:56
      It was all driven by formula.
    • 02:43:59
      Now, if people don't make the deadline in September, it's a possibility that we can go back on the signed case lines.
    • 02:44:06
      But the first deadline, I think everybody met the 50% deadline.
    • 02:44:11
      There wasn't anybody that did not meet that deadline.
    • 02:44:15
      So we're not anticipating there being a lot of funds available after these deadlines.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:44:25
      The 600 million is the money that we got.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:44:34
      It was a formula driven, but the state controlled the allocation.
    • 02:44:38
      And then the 680 was once again formula driven, so it's all been parceled out.
    • 02:44:44
      And the 100 million was discretionary in Arlington.
    • 02:44:53
      And then the next important thing is project status.
    • 02:44:58
      A total of 148 projects were awarded by the CTB.
    • 02:45:04
      The FTA does require that the expenditures all be made before September 30th of 2015.
    • 02:45:12
      We have expended 2.6 million of the 30 million through the end of April.
    • 02:45:18
      Ninety-eight projects are under contract.
    • 02:45:21
      Seven are out for bids.
    • 02:45:23
      It's held over 100 vehicle purchases, which does normally take about 18 months, as I've told y'all before, so there is going to be a lag between the signature funds and when we've made these awards to our grantees.
    • 02:45:41
      And then I was just talking with Mr. McGregor from BRT.
    • 02:45:46
      He was here earlier, and he is.
    • 02:45:47
      We're going to receive a large number, I think about 39 vehicles that he was able to piggyback on existing tracks with bus manufacturers.
    • 02:45:57
      So those 39 vehicles he said he's received, I think 14, and then the other 39 in the next two months will be coming in.
    • 02:46:04
      So there will be a little bit ahead of that 18-month curve.
    • 02:46:09
      And the other point here is on the R reporting requirements for my staff's sake.
    • 02:46:14
      There are numerous and quite onerous requirements to report back to the federal government.
    • 02:46:22
      Seems like at least once a week we're preparing to report back to them on the status of the project.
    • 02:46:30
      And finally, there was the TIGER program, which was $1.5 billion, and it was discretionary allocation.
    • 02:46:40
      And DRPT did work with the Northern Virginia jurisdictions in cooperation with DC and Maryland.
    • 02:46:49
      And an award was received of $58.8 million, $30.4 million, which applied to projects in Virginia.
    • 02:47:00
      and that's the update.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:02
      Any other questions?
    • 02:47:06
      Did you, I'm sorry, I didn't pick up, did you mention there is Tiger II and we anticipate putting in applications for that, is that correct?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:47:16
      Correct, I think both VDOT and us would be looking at that program.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:20
      Okay, are there any other questions?
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:22
      Yes, Dr. Davis.
    • 02:47:22
      It's a question and it's a qualitative question, I think.
    • 02:47:27
      Do we have adequate help and staff to aggressively pursue these funds at this stage, or are we struggling to keep up with taking advantage of the opportunity?
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:43
      If I could answer that, I'd say it is a top priority of the agency to go after these funds.
    • 02:47:50
      As you know, we're very small, but this is a top priority, and other things can get squeezed,
    • 02:47:55
      Mr. Koelemay was asking about, you know, but it's a top priority.
    • 02:48:01
      We look for money everywhere.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:04
      Commissioner Whirley.
    • 02:48:06
      We do have the resources needed, whether that would be in-house or we would have to contract for those resources.
    • 02:48:14
      We will have the resources available to go after those funds.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:18
      That's what I wanted to hear.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:20
      Any other questions?
    • 02:48:21
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:48:22
      The ACCA money, has that been squared away?
    • 02:48:27
      I know there were some questions about whether it would be highway or rail and the... No, we're still...
    • Thelma D. DrakeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:35
      The director tried to answer the status of ACCA.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:48:40
      I think we're still working with VDOT to get that ironed out right now.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:51
      We're not going to lose it.
    • 02:48:57
      Okay.
    • 02:48:58
      Well, thank you very much.
    • 02:48:59
      I have to compliment Ms. Busher, Mr. Pittard, because they got through this presentation at 20 minutes.
    • 02:49:06
      I gave the same presentation to the House Appropriations and it took me, it was well over, I think, an hour on Monday when I gave the same presentation.
    • 02:49:15
      So I compliment you on knowing how to make it much more shorter.
    • 02:49:20
      Okay, we will then get to the next presentation.
    • 02:49:23
      That is a guide sign program for hospital signs.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:49:28
      Mr. Sorrell.
    • 02:49:51
      The purpose of this presentation is to bring to the board an issue that's arisen that the department's been asked to grant exceptions for a couple of hospitals who recently have requested exemptions from just being able to put up the H sign, the International High School sign.
    • 02:50:11
      to be able to set up larger signs that have their names on them, which could be commuted to include part of advertising rather than just a guideway sign.
    • 02:50:22
      But anyway, the board in 2004 had a major study and evaluation of a number of
    • 02:50:29
      I hope that I can articulate that.
    • 02:50:42
      We are reluctant to make this exemption because of the large impact it will have on a variety of other hospitals and also other entities who would like to have these particular kinds of signs.
    • 02:50:56
      So I want to try and give you a very quick review of the sign programs and what happened back in 2004 and what we've been doing with them since and a couple of recommendations for you to consider.
    • 02:51:08
      It's just a briefing, there's no action on the board agenda for tomorrow but if you should decide you want to take some action to change the board policy somehow then that would be the instructions I guess from the board to the department to pursue it.
    • 02:51:29
      With that little introduction, we call this program the Integrated Directional Signing Program, which of course we always have to have acronyms.
    • 02:51:39
      Some of them are three letters, others are four.
    • 02:51:41
      So this one is IDSP.
    • 02:51:44
      There are several federal requirements that guide these signs because most of them are on the federal interstate or arterial programs.
    • 02:51:53
      In 2004, we developed and the board approved a comprehensive program to standardize a variety of guide signs and informational signs.
    • 02:52:04
      These signs are particularly for directing motorists to services, the logo program, which you're all I'm sure very familiar with was a part of this.
    • 02:52:13
      The goal was also to provide clear guidance on how to obtain signs and require fewer exceptions.
    • 02:52:19
      The process for developing this program included a large committee of stakeholders from the travel and tourism, hospitality industry.
    • 02:52:28
      So there was about a six-month effort by a large group of individuals.
    • 02:52:33
      that was led at that time by an assistant secretary on making these changes.
    • 02:52:40
      In the policy, it does allow that an exemption can be granted by the commissioner or of course the CTB can always change their policy.
    • 02:52:49
      But because some of these signs involved fees, it went through the APA and was quite an extensive process.
    • 02:52:57
      So there are basically four types of sign programs within this integrated program.
    • 02:53:02
      The Logo Program, which you're very familiar with.
    • 02:53:05
      An example here on exit 45, all the different kinds of gas stations that are available there.
    • 02:53:12
      A program we call tourism-oriented destination signs that you would see typically on the primary system.
    • 02:53:18
      Here's an example of a couple of things that would help to direct motorists to things like a golf course or a walking trail or a skiing trail or something like that.
    • 02:53:28
      The supplemental guide signs are the ones that some of the hospitals are interested in having.
    • 02:53:37
      These are typically brown, although sometimes they're green.
    • 02:53:43
      There have been a number of facilities that were grandfathered into this program, but after 2004 we're saying we're not going to put any more of these up.
    • 02:53:54
      largely because the places that they would go have been filled up with signs and so there's really very limited room to put many of them and I'll talk a little bit more about that.
    • 02:54:04
      And last but not least are just some general motorist signs that we use, these international symbols which I'm sure all of you all are familiar with and the hospital sign is one of those, the VH.
    • 02:54:18
      So here's an example of some of them.
    • 02:54:20
      that we have currently in the program.
    • 02:54:24
      And so when there are two or more hospitals along the same route, resulting in a diversion, the hospital names have been added underneath H signal.
    • 02:54:34
      And this is the only exception that we've granted since 2004 to
    • 02:54:39
      The IDSP criteria specifically lists hospitals and medical facilities on the site to be excluded from this supplemental sign program.
    • 02:54:54
      Prior to this program in 2004, there were some hospitals that had been allowed to participate in the Guidance Signs, and there were, I believe, 16 of them that were grandfathered into the program, and here are some examples of some of those signs.
    • 02:55:12
      Since that time, there have been no exceptions granted to hospitals and there really have only been one or two.
    • 02:55:20
      There are many, many other facilities that would come under the signing program and one of the very few exceptions of signing
    • 02:55:30
      has been granted since 2004 as a sign for the U.S. Marine Corps Museum on 64.
    • 02:55:36
      So there basically wasn't any space, but an exception was granted for that museum because of its significance.
    • 02:55:49
      So just to give you a little background on hospital signs, there are over 5,800 of them that are installed, 1,300 on interstates, 4,500 on primaries and secondaries.
    • 02:55:59
      There are 145 hospitals throughout the state that would qualify for these eight signs.
    • 02:56:05
      Sixteen hospitals were grandfathered, as I indicated, and those 16 hospitals have 55 signs, or about three and a half signs per facility.
    • 02:56:15
      So there are 749 eight signs that have been installed since 2004 and as you can see there's a breakdown of how many are in the interstate and other highways.
    • 02:56:28
      So if the request is made to modify it, it will require the CTB to really provide some modification rather than just
    • 02:56:43
      allow, you know, having us to grant an exception to one or two places.
    • 02:56:47
      I think if we did that, then the other 130 facilities who don't have signs would want signs.
    • 02:56:55
      So some of the concerns is that if we go a little further, Federal Highway Administration guidelines call for one structure displaying two messages for direction on the interstate today.
    • 02:57:11
      VDOT exceeds that recommendation.
    • 02:57:13
      Almost at every interchange while allowing two structures displaying four messages, most of these structures were in place before 2004 due to high demand for signing.
    • 02:57:24
      Minimum spacing of about 800 feet is required really for people to be able to drive by and read them.
    • 02:57:30
      So we think the H sign is an international sign.
    • 02:57:33
      It's widely recognized if people are out on the interstate or on even a major primary and they have an emergency and they need to get somewhere.
    • 02:57:41
      They just need to know where the hospital is, whichever one is the closest one, not so much that it's one hospital versus another hospital, to know the name of it.
    • 02:57:51
      And we currently have not had any complaints of any kind that have come into our office
    • 02:57:56
      over the lack of the name of a hospital being assigned when a motorist needed a hospital facility.
    • 02:58:05
      So some of these points I've already covered.
    • 02:58:10
      So we've turned down numerous requests over time that have come in over the last six years.
    • 02:58:17
      And I would mention that if we were to make a change in the policy, there would be a review by FHWA about that as to whether or not
    • 02:58:26
      they would perceive the change in the policy to be advertising as opposed to guidance concerns.
    • 02:58:32
      So with that the staff comes with basically two recommendations and that is one to suggest that hospitals pursue possibly
    • 02:58:43
      out for advertising signage outside of the VDOT right away, which would be allowed under certain federal requirements.
    • 02:58:53
      There would be smaller signs, but there could be some signs that could be pursued under permits.
    • 02:59:00
      But at this time, we recommend that the existing policy not be changed.
    • 02:59:07
      So any questions, I'd be happy to try to answer.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:09
      Are there any questions, Ms. Sorrell?
    • 02:59:11
      Yes.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:12
      Would the chairs lead?
    • 02:59:14
      My initial inclination is that outside of emergency situations, motorists won't really care much about the name of our school or whatever.
    • 02:59:24
      But the question I have is, are there many instances, or you have a feel for how many instances are there where the distance
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 02:59:34
      So a hospital can have these signs within 15 miles, and what you would do, for example, you could have a series of signs that would
    • 03:00:04
      basically guide you to the facility.
    • 03:00:07
      So if you had to make two or three turns, if you were on the interstate and you had to make several turns to get to that hospital, it would include the guidance signs to get you there.
    • 03:00:17
      So that's why some of these, in fact we have one request for a hospital that's now pending and I think they wanted something like 26 signs and we sort of negotiated down to 12 to get you from the interchange to that facility.
    • 03:00:35
      Does that answer your question, Mr. Martin?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:37
      Well, I think I'm taking it away that we don't really know of any situation where it's going to help the motorists know which one is closer.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:00:46
      Yes.
    • 03:00:47
      In that particular instance, I believe that they were about the same distance.
    • 03:00:52
      But typically, there's one hospital, whichever one is the closest one, that's how we're signing.
    • 03:00:57
      And if there is more than one, then...
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:58
      So it's either rare or moot point?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:01:01
      It's less, it's infrequent, let me put it that way.
    • 03:01:05
      I wouldn't say necessarily rare, but it's infrequent.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:08
      Ms. Carter?
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:10
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:01:11
      And Mr. Sorrell, thank you for the work that you've done on this, but I don't agree with that.
    • 03:01:19
      Let me say this, that I'm, like I said to Mr. Hill and Mr.
    • 03:01:26
      Page and all, if you hadn't come to me, I would not have known all of what's out there.
    • 03:01:31
      Well, if you were to come in the area now, you would probably understand why I'm saying this.
    • 03:01:38
      We have in our area at the present time, and I guess I would have never thought about this unless my eyes are viewing this, because we have a hospital sign, but it's not the hospital that's the closest that put this sign there, that was allowed to erect this sign.
    • 03:02:01
      And so I guess there's about six or seven of those signs, and it just says hospital.
    • 03:02:07
      Well, it's not directing the people and the citizens or whomever that would need to go to the hospital because it is an emergency room.
    • 03:02:17
      It's an emergency area, not a full fledged hospital.
    • 03:02:22
      But the hospital that put these signs there, erected these signs, that's on down the road about four or five miles.
    • 03:02:30
      And the other hospital is almost directly at where these signs are located.
    • 03:02:37
      So if there's not allowed a name under the hospital sign that this other hospital needs to put up, then no one, everyone would be confused.
    • 03:02:49
      And not only, this is a safety issue.
    • 03:02:51
      I mean, it really is.
    • 03:02:53
      95 is one of the biggest borders that we have in the United States.
    • 03:02:58
      I mean, it's just that.
    • 03:03:00
      And so therefore, there's H, and that's all you see.
    • 03:03:05
      And where are we going with this H, you know?
    • 03:03:08
      There's no direction.
    • 03:03:09
      I noticed on one of these signs, and if you go back to slide five,
    • 03:03:25
      There's a name of a hospital there and it also says use exit 124.
    • 03:03:31
      That's an excellent direction for motorists or patients or whomever would want to go to, need to go to a hospital or need that facility and so therefore
    • 03:03:50
      I certainly would not like to adopt this policy over.
    • 03:03:53
      I think that this policy should be reviewed.
    • 03:03:57
      And I'm in areas, especially as I'm stating to you at this time.
    • 03:04:02
      And then I noticed that on the one before that, on four,
    • 03:04:10
      You have a hospital sign, and I don't know where these are, but other people say names, but you've got an arrow pointing to the right and an arrow pointing to the left in that direction.
    • 03:04:22
      Now, when we come to a situation that we have in the Curtisburg area, even something of that sort, you know, with health, and that's not more signs being added, that's more of the direction
    • 03:04:37
      It's a safety issue that I believe that we need to address.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:04:41
      Well, certainly it sounds like that there's a situation we need to review what signing is in the area that you're particularly talking about because obviously some of the signing is older, a facility may have been relocated or whatever.
    • 03:04:54
      So I'd be happy to take a look at that particular incident area and let's do that.
    • 03:05:03
      I would like to use that.
    • 03:05:05
      It's hard to read them, but actually this is just in advance of an intersection.
    • 03:05:11
      So what you would do is if you wanted to go to the Inova Leesburg Hospital, you could take a left or there's another one that you would take that would go to the right.
    • 03:05:20
      So both of those hospitals are on 15 in those directions, not too far from where these signs are.
    • 03:05:25
      So certainly we need to take a look at the particular situation that you're referencing.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:31
      Yes.
    • 03:05:33
      Because there's signs on the interstate, signs at the intersections, signs on the primary road, and it's just an H. And I would like you to call me so that we can review that, please.
    • 03:05:47
      It's just not what our citizens of the Commonwealth need.
    • 03:05:52
      And also the motorists who are traveling 95.
    • 03:05:55
      I want the motorists who are traveling 95 to have a safe journey also.
    • 03:06:00
      And if it's a direction going to a hospital, we can save a lot of it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:05
      Thank you.
    • 03:06:05
      Elaine?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:06
      I realize it may be a slippery slope, but the example you used of the Children's Hospital of the King's Daughters, we have, that's in Norfolk and Hampton Roads, we have people from all over the country come to that facility because it was prenatal, certainly all over the state and the area.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:06:23
      So, there is a consideration, there is a difference between that hospital and the other hospitals in the area.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:29
      So, just one thing to echo what Ms. Carter said, you know, again, I realize it's a slippery slope, but that one is completely, is significantly different than just directing someone to a hospital.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:06:43
      16 out of the 145 that do have the grandfathered signs.
    • 03:06:48
      So there's no move to do anything to change any of those.
    • 03:06:54
      So there is a requirement just to follow up that they do have to be 24-7 facilities.
    • 03:07:00
      They have to have emergency facilities.
    • 03:07:03
      There's several criteria in order to qualify as a hospital because we've had a whole other issue around.
    • 03:07:10
      Mr. Davis.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:14
      Mr. Chairman, I think there is a concern among some of those in the healthcare business that the H sign is small, especially for limited access highways that have higher speed limits.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:31
      The request that I have heard from in my district
    • SPEAKER_20
    • 03:07:34
      have been to get single signage at the interchange to get people off and then let the small age where the speed limit is lower serve as the directional signs.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:47
      One of the challenges I think that we face, this was looked at about six years ago when I was on the CTB and we talked about some of these issues.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:58
      One of the things that I think we need to remember is that there are significant changes occurring in the healthcare industry.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:05
      There are consolidation of hospital facilities.
    • 03:08:09
      There are new facilities.
    • 03:08:10
      Many hospitals are updating facilities.
    • 03:08:13
      Relocating signage is important for major medical centers.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:20
      It might be appropriate, Mr. Chairman, for the Chair to appoint a
    • 03:08:24
      A committee that would look at the issue getting representatives of the hospital association and maybe representatives from local government who have to deal with local zoning issues with signage and directional issues to take a look at the issue and revisit it.
    • 03:08:41
      I do think there is some legitimate concern about the proliferation of signage, but I also think that we're facing a situation where we're going to get a number of requests for waivers simply because we don't have adequate directional signage in existence now as we face some of the new challenges with the relocation of hospitals and the
    • 03:09:07
      and the emergence of, quite frankly, a number of consolidated facilities.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:13
      Mr. Davies, maybe just to modify your request a bit, my impression is that this issue is more acute in three different regions right now and that's Northern Virginia, Fredericksburg and Culpeper and that's primarily because there's new medical facilities that are showing up
    • 03:09:37
      I'm just looking at you had, Justin Fredericksburg, two new hospitals open up in just the last two years.
    • 03:09:44
      Northern Virginia I think has had four or five.
    • 03:09:48
      And you all have a couple that are going up.
    • 03:09:50
      I think maybe what I suggest is instead of a committee looking at this across the Commonwealth initially,
    • 03:09:55
      Maybe we ask the district board members to get together with their district administrators and with Connie Sorrell's folks and then reach out to the hospital and local government where we know there's problems.
    • 03:10:11
      I mean, I think with Fredericksburg, I mean, with the brand new hospital that just got
    • 03:10:16
      and the one that's up at Stafford now that's been built.
    • 03:10:20
      I know in Northern Virginia there's been in Loudon I guess two new hospitals built.
    • 03:10:25
      There's a new one going up at Prince William.
    • 03:10:28
      And I think you all have, and we saw it that way to see if, because things are, I mean for so long things were always I want to say static when it came to hospitals and now it's just amazing what's happening.
    • 03:10:41
      Start there and let's go where we know the problems are and if it's something that we have to take statewide then we can bring it back.
    • 03:10:52
      So what we'll do is the district members, district administrators, Connie Sorrell's staff and the hospital folks and maybe local government folks could get together and see how to maybe resolve this.
    • 03:11:05
      It's interesting, I know that the new hospital hasn't opened up in Fredericksburg yet but
    • 03:11:10
      Speed limit.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:11:27
      This is just a very short briefing.
    • 03:11:32
      It's short and fast and this is to let you know the legislature passed a couple of bills that were the governor's bills to allow the department and the commissioner to raise speed limits in certain areas from 65 miles an hour to 70 miles an hour.
    • 03:11:50
      So listed here are the miles of interstate
    • 03:11:54
      that are currently at 65 miles an hour, about 1,100 miles, and also some reversible HOV lanes and some other limited access roads to which this would fly.
    • 03:12:06
      So the Commissioner does have the statutory authority to act on the speed limit recommendations.
    • 03:12:12
      And as we
    • 03:12:13
      Presented to the legislature, we would study these from a safety perspective and make sure that there wasn't any inherent safety problems with making the switch from 65 miles to 70 miles an hour.
    • 03:12:26
      So we've prioritized that 1100 miles into three phases, starting with the areas of the interstate that have the least significant levels of crashes and congestion.
    • 03:12:38
      where it would be probably the easiest to make those changes and then break them down into other areas where there are more moderate crash levels or higher levels of congestion.
    • 03:12:49
      And so there is a map in your presentation that shows you which phase these various areas of the interstate fall.
    • 03:13:00
      So we do have an on-call consultant that's contracted to help us get all these engineering studies done on these 1,100 miles.
    • 03:13:08
      Work has already started.
    • 03:13:09
      And we hope to have the phase one studies completed by the June 30th.
    • 03:13:14
      We are also meeting with the Virginia State Police.
    • 03:13:16
      We've already held one meeting with them to coordinate our study efforts and get their input.
    • 03:13:20
      So we're also sending letters to local elected officials and law enforcement letting them know of these studies and requesting any input they have.
    • 03:13:29
      And there's also a website under development which will provide the public with some information in the forum for comment.
    • 03:13:34
      So we've done two studies already, the first one on Interstate 295 here east of the city of Richmond from the
    • 03:13:42
      64 interchange out by the hospital down to Petersburg, which is about a 28-mile stretch of Interstate 295, and we have a recommendation to increase that speed limit to 70 miles an hour.
    • 03:13:55
      The law becomes effective on the 1st of July, so those signs will go up and the speed limit will be changed if the commissioner has no objection, which I assume he won't.
    • 03:14:05
      The next study that we conducted was on Interstate 95 basically from that junction of Petersburg down to the North Carolina line.
    • 03:14:14
      It's about 46 miles.
    • 03:14:15
      There are some substandard shoulders and some need to replace and improve some rumble strips, guard rail, raised pavement markers, and other safety features.
    • 03:14:25
      before we take that mileage up to 70 miles an hour.
    • 03:14:29
      So that's where that study stands at this time.
    • 03:14:34
      The commissioner will be receiving it shortly to review.
    • 03:14:37
      So all the studies will be completed by October the 30th of this year.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:43
      So, just to summarize, so we have one piece of payment, 295, that we're good to go for July 1st.
    • 03:14:52
      And we're doing the studies on, well, we've done the study for south of Petersburg on 95, which is about $9 million worth of safety improvements.
    • 03:14:59
      And I should point out that already 85 is already 70 miles an hour.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:15:06
      Yes, it's not one section of it.
    • 03:15:11
      The legislature had specifically carved out an Interstate 85 to be 70 miles an hour if engineering studies supported that, and I think about 30 of the 60 miles are currently at 70 miles an hour, but we needed to do some other improvements, and those are underway to make the rest of it 70 miles an hour.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:32
      What's the initial impression of 81, the large yellow line?
    • 03:15:37
      I think that's the space too.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:15:42
      So the colors in that chart just indicate whether it's going to be studied in June or August or October.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:51
      Is there any preliminary indication of problems there, major problems?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:15:56
      At this point, I couldn't say.
    • 03:16:02
      I am familiar that the high crash levels on
    • 03:16:06
      on 81 are the couple of areas that we designated the highway safety corridors and then particularly where interstate to interstate overlaps are.
    • 03:16:17
      So we're 64 and 81 overlap.
    • 03:16:20
      We're 77 and 81 overlap and there are a lot of weaving, emerging motions going on there.
    • 03:16:26
      Those are typically where
    • 03:16:28
      Those areas might be a little more problematic than some of the other long stretches.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:40
      Obviously the studies include the cost of the improvements, the safety, maintenance.
    • 03:16:55
      The studies include the speeding fines
    • 03:16:58
      Do the state police expect more or less?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:17:03
      That I don't know.
    • 03:17:04
      I just don't really have any clue about that.
    • 03:17:10
      All the speeding times do go into the literary fund to help build schools.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:19
      So there are no other questions.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 03:17:28
      That concludes my presentation.
    • 03:17:30
      Excellent.
    • 03:17:31
      All right.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:33
      Next is the process for studying corridors of statewide significant House 29th subcommittee.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:38
      And we have one of our own, Doug Koelemay.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:45
      It's cool when I set you up there.
    • 03:17:46
      Would you mind swearing on to a Bible?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:49
      I have a few questions I want to ask you.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:19
      Mr. Chairman, I hope to speak only in French.
    • 03:18:22
      Thanks very much, and I'll go as quickly as I can.
    • 03:18:27
      First of all, let me express my thanks to my colleagues, Ms. Pandak, Mr. Davies, and Mr. Schwartz, who joined me on the subcommittee.
    • 03:18:35
      which was appointed by the board in December.
    • 03:18:39
      To do four things, look at a plan to improve mobility, separate interchanges, number of traffic signals in the corridor and also to refine the 29 process of the corridor by significant study process.
    • 03:18:59
      You can see that obviously these are the Carters that the Board approved and it's VTrans 2035.
    • 03:19:05
      Route 29 was the first of the Carters to be studied and as we know from our past experience, we had both positive and negatives in the study and that was one thing the subcommittee was looking to make more consistent and more useful.
    • 03:19:22
      We were working from a resolution that was adopted in December, and you can see the mission and so forth.
    • 03:19:29
      But we also got the imperative to take into account the lessons that we learned from the 29 study, what worked well and what did not, and to come up with recommendations for future corridor studies that would make them both more relevant, more flexible, and less contentious.
    • 03:19:48
      Secretary Connaughton appointed the subcommittee in February.
    • 03:19:52
      We've met four times on these directives and the process includes the CTB's direction to position the board to lead in developing consensus among the affected localities and other key state boards.
    • 03:20:05
      Obviously that's one thing we talked about many times going forward.
    • 03:20:09
      We will be collaborators with local governments as well with the private sector and the way these projects go forward.
    • 03:20:16
      Several things that we wanted to make clear in our report we have for you.
    • 03:20:23
      First of all,
    • 03:20:25
      Technical process is critical in and of itself.
    • 03:20:28
      You can't skip steps.
    • 03:20:30
      There is data that has to be developed.
    • 03:20:32
      There are specifics that have to be developed going forward.
    • 03:20:35
      Secondly, how the study is developed and who's involved in the process are critical questions that need to be answered up front as opposed to simply proposed through the process itself.
    • 03:20:47
      And then finally, effective engagement of local governments is critical for these several reasons.
    • 03:20:51
      First of all, to make sure that statewide goals are translated into actual land use and local decision making.
    • 03:20:58
      And secondly, to ensure that the local objectives regarding access and mobility and so forth are also represented.
    • 03:21:06
      This is the mark of a collaborative process.
    • 03:21:09
      Here's the graphic that sort of lays that process out.
    • 03:21:13
      You can read it probably more easily in the paper handout.
    • 03:21:17
      But as you can see, there's a new emphasis on pre-study activities that include some planning so that the process can reflect really the realities of each corridor as well as the personalities and challenges that are inherent in each one.
    • 03:21:31
      Secondly, that we reinforce the Carter-wide vision, which we hope will help local officials and local governments, stakeholders get beyond some of their purely local interests to see that we're talking about the entire Carter region.
    • 03:21:46
      The technical analysis is important, as we know, because it has to work.
    • 03:21:51
      It's not just a plan.
    • 03:21:52
      It actually has to be a workable plan to produce the benefits.
    • 03:21:55
      And then finally, the last two steps, basically reaching some consensus on conclusions and then translating those into front-end activities.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:05
      This is step one.
    • 03:22:07
      You can read for yourself.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:09
      One of our key recommendations is to establish a steering committee right up front to guide the study.
    • 03:22:16
      And that's important because you begin to identify the stakeholders right at the beginning as opposed to bringing them in willy-nilly as the process goes forward.
    • 03:22:24
      It lays the groundwork and a professional facilitator as part of the study team is a new wrinkle that we determined was very important to help people work past the interests that they already have.
    • 03:22:42
      It's that old saying that people who are so sure that they know something because they can't hear anything else and we're all guilty of that and particularly in this case where you've had long-standing discussions and perhaps disputes about things, a professional facilitator can help break things down and move people forward.
    • 03:23:01
      The second thing is to make sure that we actually are bringing the stakeholders together.
    • 03:23:05
      and in a sense helping bring them through their own processes, not just our process.
    • 03:23:12
      Local governments do have the system making structures and timetables and budgets and we need to be aware of those as well.
    • 03:23:18
      And then finally to make our process mirror local processes as much as possible so we're proceeding in sync.
    • 03:23:26
      The technical analysis, clearly VDOT and DRPT have a lot of that.
    • 03:23:31
      There may be a need for special expertise for their special challenges and certainly the need for more detailed analysis for their specific geographic problems are unique challenges.
    • 03:23:44
      In the 29 study, we obviously identified a couple of those that needed further work.
    • 03:23:49
      Finally, we need to work through these things with local governments and with, again, the use of a professional facilitator, capture all the input and the objectives, not just the public policy positions and the past positions that people may have.
    • 03:24:06
      The emphasis is on reaching a consensus solution as opposed to setting off another advocacy proceeding and getting results that's accidental and arrived at by argument.
    • 03:24:17
      And then finally, how these things are adopted and translated into projects is a critical step.
    • 03:24:24
      Right now, we have different processes for master plans, comprehensive plans, six-year plans, VTrans plans, and so forth.
    • 03:24:33
      So it's important that all those things sink and move ahead and that we're aware of the need to make sure the proper steps are being taken at the local level as well as the state level in this project, advance, and implementation.
    • 03:24:48
      Key issue, this is something that we arrived at easily.
    • 03:24:52
      We need to make a clear linkage between the successful studies in these corridors, our planning process, the local planning process, and future investments.
    • 03:25:00
      That's part of the carrot and stick that needs to be here, that the better coordinated and better planned these things are, the more likely they actually are to happen.
    • 03:25:09
      Second is that VDOT and DRPTs should encourage local governments to include these study recommendations as we arrive at them in their local comprehensive plans.
    • 03:25:19
      This both makes it congruent, but it also gives them the benefit of the expertise of our process as well to help guide some of their decisions.
    • 03:25:28
      And then finally, local officials should collaborate with other stakeholders and each other in facilitated workshops and charrettes.
    • 03:25:37
      Local officials from different localities can actually compare notes and arrive at solutions that are both useful and proper.
    • 03:25:49
      If they're successful, we say the studies will engage local officials throughout the process, particularly at key points, that it'll remain a flexible process as responsive as possible to the unique characteristics within each corridor and the consensus that's built in each corridor.
    • 03:26:06
      And then finally, it'll maximize constructive cooperation on common ground.
    • 03:26:12
      And that's it.
    • 03:26:14
      I'd be glad to answer questions if you like or other committee members certainly could too.
    • 03:26:19
      We'll have a resolution before you a little bit later this afternoon that we hope will allow us to adopt our findings here and move ahead.
    • 03:26:27
      The final caveat is there still are outstanding questions, obviously, about the future of the 29th charter.
    • 03:26:33
      The subcommittee determined we can't solve those particular challenges through the process that we're in now, but we hope by application of the process that we're recommending that we'll be able to get at those more subsequently.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:46
      Mr. Chairman, forward.
    • 03:26:49
      Ms. King.
    • 03:26:49
      Mr. Coburn, excuse me.
    • 03:26:51
      What would you say is the biggest improvement
    • 03:26:54
      I think there's two main points.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:05
      The first point is that we definitively tie the results of this process
    • 03:27:12
      to its implementation.
    • 03:27:13
      In other words, this is meant to inform a set of things that are going to happen and not simply be a study.
    • 03:27:18
      The second is the facilitation by a professional to help us get over what we know are distinct challenges that exist in every locality and help us identify sort of new and different and innovative solutions to problems.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:33
      I'm sorry, so Mr. Koelemay, so we passed this resolution this afternoon.
    • 03:27:37
      Are you then, those on the 29th committee are going to, we're then going to turn around and apply this process to the 29th corridor study?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:46
      Well, I think we'd have to discuss that next step.
    • 03:27:48
      We don't have a recommendation about that yet.
    • 03:27:50
      There's still a couple of small pieces that we need to recommend to you later this next month.
    • 03:27:55
      For example, the intersections that have current traffic signals and governance and then particularly recommendations that give us the state of play on the Buckland, Gainesville, Prince William, Fauquier area and on the Charlottesville.
    • 03:28:11
      Seven questions.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:28:12
      Shouldn't we use you all?
    • 03:28:14
      I mean, if we pass this today, turn around and then do what you recommend for that entire corridor.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:28:21
      I think using the subcommittee would be one of the options.
    • 03:28:25
      Perhaps you as the secretary being a convener of some of the facilitated meetings might be another.
    • 03:28:31
      We haven't discussed exactly the steps that we might take, but yes, there clearly is a next step to apply the process to the 29th.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:28:45
      It gives us a process and a way to essentially take a step forward in looking at the entire corridor versus let's say district by district or MDO by MDO or local government by local government and then making that linkage to our six-year plan which we're finding is not always linked to what our long-term plan is.
    • 03:29:11
      So if we adopt this, my suggestion then would be that we go corridor by corridor to exactly what you're laying out here.
    • 03:29:22
      You all are already appointed.
    • 03:29:25
      We might just bless you and let you go.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:28
      Well, I told them I was from the Northern Virginia District and they did not want me to come down there.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:36
      It had nothing to do with you being from Northern Virginia.
    • 03:29:39
      One of the things we talked about... Maybe they got to know you a little bit, Mr. Cooley.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:44
      One of the things we talked about and emphasized was the need to be flexible as we went through these corridor studies.
    • 03:29:54
      For example, the character of 29 almost lends itself to a northern part of the corridor and a southern part of the corridor.
    • 03:30:02
      The problems are not exactly the same in both places.
    • 03:30:05
      On the other hand, there was a suggestion that perhaps the first corridor we actually applied this process to in more detail be one that was less large and less complex so we actually could see how the process worked in a place that wouldn't necessarily quite have the same challenges.
    • 03:30:25
      So I think it's something that we ought to discuss as a group.
    • 03:30:29
      Definitely we want the first time we use this process to give us the success that we can build on it.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:34
      Well, I mean, I guess I do understand a little bit of that sentiment for 29, let's say, north of maybe Warrenton, which is a commuter route, or 29 north of 66.
    • 03:30:50
      But
    • 03:30:53
      It is, I mean, when you look at one of the few roads that runs through central Virginia, that's essentially for the most part four lanes divided.
    • 03:31:04
      I mean, I couldn't think of a better place to start than this corridor.
    • 03:31:10
      from, let's say, Warrenton or even Gainesville, which, let's just say Warrenton, all the way south to essentially North Carolina.
    • 03:31:22
      This is a sort of a perfect place to start looking at this.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:31:27
      Well, the subcommittee is a creature of the board and can take additional direction from the board on what the board wishes it to do.
    • 03:31:36
      I think we are certainly open to whatever the next step should be.
    • 03:31:40
      We'll probably discuss that next week at our next meeting and perhaps have a series of recommendations for you, at least from our own point of view.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:31:49
      Well, again, I'm sorry, I don't want to sound like I am putting you on the spot, but the thing is that you all developed the process and this would be a good opportunity of walking through one of these corridors since you're already in place, you've laid out the process, trying to
    • 03:32:06
      You all taking a shot at actually being the first to put the process into motion would be helpful in refining this as we move forward.
    • 03:32:16
      And this corridor is one that actually, I'm going to say, in some ways we have a little bit more ability maybe to, you know, more flexibility in dealing with some of the issues, although some of them are very deep and intractable.
    • 03:32:34
      We've got to find ways to solve them, particularly, as we all know, issues around Charlottesville and whichever.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:39
      And I know the subcommittee would welcome the participation of our newest member as well who's an important part of the corridor and has certainly some expertise to bring.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:32:49
      Well, we were going to actually appoint him at the end of the resolution today.
    • 03:32:55
      Mr. Peake, right?
    • 03:32:56
      This is the enthusiasm we have from our board members.
    • 03:33:03
      I'm sorry, are there any other questions?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:33:08
      More of a comment.
    • 03:33:14
      I want to make it clear we have not discussed this.
    • 03:33:17
      I'm not being self-serving at all, but I want to commend you for the concept of professional facilitation.
    • 03:33:26
      So many times I know that the entities all over the state have spent more money and gone through far more consternation.
    • 03:33:34
      That was necessary simply for the last, almost like an Occam's Railway situation.
    • 03:33:39
      Professional facilitation will save us so much money and effort and get us to the goal that we started out in.
    • 03:33:48
      I can't believe it's just been missing all this time.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:33:51
      Mr. Chairman, I too would commend the committee for that.
    • 03:33:55
      We established an alternative dispute resolution mediation center 30 years ago.
    • 03:34:01
      at the University of Virginia, which has an excellent reputation.
    • 03:34:04
      You might, I'll talk to you more about it if you're interested.
    • 03:34:09
      And they have resolved any number of complex multi-party disputes over time.
    • 03:34:15
      I think they've usually started from scratch rather than picking up on one that has a history to it already, which could be problematic in this case.
    • 03:34:25
      But if you want to pursue it, let me know.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:30
      Any other questions?
    • 03:34:32
      Great job Mr. Koelemay.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:34:36
      Mr. Peake looking forward to working with you.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:42
      My understanding is that there was something was going to come before the committee or the Transportation Board at the June meeting regarding 29, but it may be postponed for public study.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:34:58
      My predecessor is anyone familiar with that?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:00
      Is there anything on 29 coming before the board?
    • 03:35:03
      I don't think so.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:35:04
      This issue.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:09
      Just the raising of this issue seems to cause a lot of interest.
    • 03:35:18
      The next presentation is from the Frederick Sperrick Area Metropolitan Planning Organization.
    • 03:35:24
      That's Matt Kelly and Lloyd Robinson.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:35:29
      Thank you very much for the invitation for us to come forward to the CTB and kind of talk about the issues facing the George Washington region and what the MPO is doing to deal with those issues.
    • 03:35:40
      I'm going to let our executive director, Lloyd Robinson, walk you through the presentation with help from Andy Wapol, and I'm going to reserve my comments to talk about where we are and where we would like to go as an MPO in the ongoing discussions of transportation after they're concluded.
    • 03:35:54
      So I would like to present Lloyd Robinson, our executive director.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:35:59
      Thank you, Matt.
    • 03:36:01
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, Ms. Carter, Mr. Sterling, thanks for having us here.
    • 03:36:09
      I'll just walk you through this presentation.
    • 03:36:13
      It's really the story of Fampol and the George Washington region, our case, if you will.
    • 03:36:21
      So without further ado, if I can get this right.
    • 03:36:23
      That is our region.
    • 03:36:25
      I-95 runs through the middle of it.
    • 03:36:29
      Three of the municipalities, Stafford County, Spotsylvania County, and the City of Fredericksburg are members of the MPO.
    • 03:36:35
      Voting numbers have been since 92 when the MPO was created.
    • 03:36:40
      The other two counties,
    • 03:36:43
      King George and Caroline are non-voting members.
    • 03:36:47
      There's been some discussion recently, particularly on the issue of air quality of whether Caroline County may join the NPO.
    • 03:36:56
      That's a decision to be made in the federally prescribed manner in the future.
    • 03:37:06
      Our story is certainly one of rapid growth.
    • 03:37:11
      In this slide, you have a couple of charts which demonstrate that growth.
    • 03:37:17
      Between 1960 and 2006, our population increased about 400%.
    • 03:37:24
      It was a rural, horse country, agricultural area.
    • 03:37:29
      Today, it's a burgundy, urbanized area.
    • 03:37:32
      You can see from the upper right-hand side that chart that our region was by far the fastest growing region in Virginia between 1960 and 2006.
    • 03:37:46
      The bottom chart there
    • 03:37:51
      shows our growth projections as compared to other urbanized areas in Virginia through 2035 and you can see that the growth pattern which did hold will hold in the future so we remain the fastest growing region in the Commonwealth.
    • 03:38:14
      If our past land use policies are a guide
    • 03:38:20
      Then our future growth is likely to be somewhat low density and largely suburban, but I want to talk more about that.
    • 03:38:27
      Land use is a huge concern for us.
    • 03:38:33
      Transportation issues with that level of growth and making the transition from a largely rural area to an urbanized area
    • 03:38:40
      We've encountered problems and one of the biggest problems we've encountered is congestion on our surface transportation system.
    • 03:38:52
      This map is 2035 without a lot of the improvements that we need.
    • 03:38:58
      It's a congestion map and on this map we've invented a new class called F- which is in blue.
    • 03:39:04
      and then you'll see F's and E's and then A through D's.
    • 03:39:08
      You can see I-95 which is not just something that serves our region, it serves the Commonwealth and it serves the United States of America on the Eastern Seaboard is F's and F minuses in 2035.
    • 03:39:19
      That's unacceptable.
    • 03:39:20
      That is unacceptable.
    • 03:39:21
      Moreover, the principal arterials, US-1, US-17, Virginia Route 3, and others, are also F-minuses and F's.
    • 03:39:32
      And you can see that the failing surface transportation system in our region in 2035 on this map is not just the arterials and the interstate, it's the collectors.
    • 03:39:44
      It's the collectors, so it's a region-wide phenomenon, and that phenomenon is largely due to the land development patterns that we have.
    • 03:40:02
      In addition to need, we have funding issues, which are obviously connected.
    • 03:40:07
      Our 2035 long-range plan, which we adopted in January of last year, identifies $10 billion in multimodal transportation needs, $10 billion between roadways, transit, and bicycle and pedestrian.
    • 03:40:24
      But using the federal rules for
    • 03:40:26
      Forecasting our revenues, we can identify only $2.5 billion of available revenues during that same period.
    • 03:40:33
      Ergo, we have a $7.5 billion shortfall.
    • 03:40:37
      So many of our highways remain congested, fewer bicycle and pedestrian facilities, less transit service, and fewer TDM programs will result that are needed.
    • 03:40:50
      Our future policy choices for development and investment, you can see on the right of your screen, is a crossroads.
    • 03:40:57
      That was the finding in our 2035 Long Range Plan, that our region is indeed at a crossroads.
    • 03:41:03
      I've pointed out that we have these needs, we have insufficient funds,
    • 03:41:06
      to meet future transportation needs and our current development policies, if they are perpetuated into the future, will create further and exacerbate sprawl.
    • 03:41:18
      And I think everybody here knows that if you continue to develop at the suburban fringe, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy because even if you had all the money and if there was no pushback to all the roadway widening in a generation or two, you would reproduce the problem further out.
    • 03:41:35
      We recognize that, and so we see in our region that we have three distinct directions that are available to us, and they are, of course, to depend on state and federal funds and to continue to develop as we have in the past.
    • 03:41:49
      The second is to identify additional transportation funds so that we can begin to help ourselves in partnership with you all.
    • 03:41:57
      with the state and federal governments.
    • 03:41:59
      And finally, the third choice alternative we have is to pursue those additional funds and also to pursue higher density, smarter growth regional land use development policies, recognizing that land use is a local government prerogative.
    • 03:42:19
      In our 2035 plan, option three is what we selected as a way to go.
    • 03:42:26
      So for regional funding initiatives, how have we been trying to help ourselves?
    • 03:42:31
      Well, last week, Spotsylvania County voted 5-2 to form the George Washington Toll Road Authority, which was authorized by the General Assembly and signed into law by the governor.
    • 03:42:43
      The City of Fredericksburg, which Mr. Kelly represents, is due to take that up and vote on it in the very near future, the next couple of weeks.
    • 03:42:52
      All three of the MPO localities in our region are now VRE members with Spotsylvania having recently joined VRE.
    • 03:43:01
      Spotsylvania and Stafford County have in the past several years floated significant local roadway bond programs in order to begin to help solve some of the problems on their secondary systems.
    • 03:43:15
      Finally, the municipalities in our region
    • 03:43:19
      So we took the first part of our option, and we're taking that fairly seriously.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:43:29
      We're trying to help ourselves be a better partner financially with the state and the federal government.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:43:43
      Sorry, goes without saying but you're right.
    • 03:43:47
      Profers and private sector construction of roadway facilities, transportation facilities in our region outpaces what the state and federal funds are doing today.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:43:57
      It's an excellent point.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:43:59
      Also, would you just give me an update?
    • 03:44:01
      I'm sorry, you and I have met, talked about the issue on this whole road.
    • 03:44:05
      Last, I had gotten word about it.
    • 03:44:08
      We were dealing with the Federal Highway Administration about trying to
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:44:12
      The short answer to that is we're getting excellent cooperation with our partners at VDOT and FHWA.
    • 03:44:30
      And we have identified a preferred alternative and want to pursue that preferred alternative and expect to issue an interchange justification report at IJR in the next couple of months.
    • 03:44:52
      Land use planning, development planning, what the MPO did as a result of the long-range plan option that we selected was we funded land use scenario planning on a regional basis as a major regional initiative working in partnership with the local governments.
    • 03:45:10
      I'll just quickly run through these bullets.
    • 03:45:12
      This process is not intended to supersede local land use controls or policies.
    • 03:45:17
      It lets us participate in and explore the what-ifs of the region's future.
    • 03:45:23
      It allows people to understand and consider the trade-offs between different growth scenarios and policy decisions, provides a forum to reframe ideas and questions on growth, provides the information to help answer
    • 03:45:34
      The what, where, when, and how growth should occur to meet a shared vision.
    • 03:45:37
      And finally, it allows localities to see how their land use decisions impact their neighbors and vice versa.
    • 03:45:49
      This is just a graphic of it.
    • 03:45:51
      You take the base year, which is the existing policies that we have, which basically is in our long-range plan is 2006.
    • 03:45:59
      And then depending on what people would like to see as policies, as initiatives, as alternatives, there are different outcomes.
    • 03:46:07
      And people can then see what those outcomes are with a fairly simple modeling program.
    • 03:46:13
      So we're in the middle of this.
    • 03:46:15
      This is due to be reported out in January.
    • 03:46:19
      And our new methodology is that every time we finish a long-range plan update, we intend to go into land-use scenario planning.
    • 03:46:26
      And that's the new process.
    • 03:46:27
      So we're trying to wed land-use planning and transportation planning in our long-range activities.
    • 03:46:37
      I want to talk about regional cooperation.
    • 03:46:39
      I know it's important to all of you here.
    • 03:46:42
      It's certainly important to us.
    • 03:46:43
      We try and work together as a region.
    • 03:46:45
      It's not always perfect harmony, but we do try and work together as a region.
    • 03:46:48
      In the past several years, we've been successful and the MPO has been successful.
    • 03:46:56
      in developing multimodal projects, a multimodal project prioritization methodology so there's a little less, a little more objectivity, maybe a little less subjectivity in the project prioritization functions that we do.
    • 03:47:11
      MPO, the MPO is now getting into, wants to help get into as a partner with the local and state government design-build projects.
    • 03:47:20
      We want to move in that direction.
    • 03:47:21
      We think that's probably a win-win for the taxpayers and for efficiency.
    • 03:47:25
      We've collaborated, the local governments and the MPO and others have collaborated on various major roadway projects which have been funded and I'll show you a few of those.
    • 03:47:36
      There's one there in the picture that's the US-3 widening as a stimulus project.
    • 03:47:42
      The MPO and the PDC, working with human services agencies, have gotten into the regional human service transit business, I think, successfully.
    • 03:47:53
      The MPOs formed partnerships, successful partnerships, with FRED, our local bus system, VRE, PRTC, and MBTC, our neighbors to the north.
    • 03:48:02
      We're working with Caroline County to develop their train station and the environmental documentation for that.
    • 03:48:08
      We're doing a region-wide commuter parking lot expansion study in cooperation with the local governments and VDOT.
    • 03:48:17
      And finally, we're working on trails throughout the region with our partners.
    • 03:48:22
      So regional cooperation is at the top of our list for what we ought to be doing.
    • 03:48:27
      Here are some examples of that cooperation.
    • 03:48:30
      The top slide on the left is the Courthouse Road Route 60 overpass crossing over the CSX tracks.
    • 03:48:40
      That's a funded project.
    • 03:48:42
      The next one is the Garrisonville-Onville intersection.
    • 03:48:46
      As you probably know, Onville will be the new gateway to Quantico.
    • 03:48:50
      and Quantico is undergoing significant growth as a result of BRAC.
    • 03:48:55
      Next one is the Stafford Borough Commuter Lot, which is over capacity on Route 610.
    • 03:49:01
      We're looking to expand that.
    • 03:49:03
      Virginia Central Railway Trail on the bottom, another project.
    • 03:49:07
      Spotsylvania Parkway over I-95 just completed in Spotsylvania County.
    • 03:49:13
      It's due to be Ms. Carter.
    • 03:49:16
      I think the ribbon cutting is coming up.
    • 03:49:18
      It's pending on that project.
    • 03:49:20
      And finally, one that I participated in the groundbreaking on is the Spotsylvania Courthouse Road bypass.
    • 03:49:28
      Phase II, which is also a stimulus project.
    • 03:49:32
      So these are significant projects where regional cooperation has paid off for us.
    • 03:49:39
      We have missing critical links.
    • 03:49:41
      We have this rapidly growing region, and we have missing critical links in our surface transportation system.
    • 03:49:48
      In addition to US 17 and US 1 and the BRAC-related improvements that are needed in our region,
    • 03:49:57
      The interstate in our region has three interchange projects associated with it which we feel are critical not just to us but to the Commonwealth and to the country.
    • 03:50:09
      The integrity of I-95 is at stake.
    • 03:50:13
      The first of these, the number one interstate priority in the region is the 630 interchange in Stafford County.
    • 03:50:23
      The history of this interchange dates back to 1992 when VDOT and FHWA signed an agreement for the reconstruction of this interchange.
    • 03:50:31
      This is our number one priority and we think it needs to move forward to complete design and then be cashed out.
    • 03:50:38
      The IMR, Interchange Modification Report, is due to be issued on this by VDOT in the near future.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:45
      The next one?
    • 03:50:46
      I'm sorry, is this a six-year plan or no?
    • 03:50:48
      Yes.
    • 03:50:49
      The design money is in the six-year plan.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:50:51
      Yes, design money, $10.2 billion, I believe.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:55
      Why did that ever drop down initially?
    • 03:50:57
      Do we know?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:50:59
      Why did the overall project, or why did it take so long to get moving forward?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:03
      Yeah, because that's the only interchange that essentially hasn't been rebuilt, right?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:08
      I can't say it's the only one that hasn't been rebuilt, but it just had not moved forward for, what, 20 years almost.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:14
      Obviously, you know, quiet.
    • 03:51:15
      You have your center port.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:17
      Yeah, center port.
    • 03:51:18
      Right.
    • 03:51:19
      17 is a little bit newer, a little bit better shape.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:22
      A little quiet, yeah.
    • 03:51:23
      So, I mean, this is the only interchange that has not been installed at Old Dinky.
    • 03:51:28
      Yeah.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:29
      It just never moved forward.
    • 03:51:31
      It's not that it dropped out.
    • 03:51:32
      It just never moved forward.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:51:35
      The next, just moving south, the next interchange is the so-called restary access.
    • 03:51:40
      Mr. Secretary, this is the one you brought up before.
    • 03:51:43
      Taking a look at the right-hand part of your screen, if I can make this little dot work here.
    • 03:51:48
      Not very well.
    • 03:51:50
      Oh, there it is.
    • 03:51:51
      That's the 17th interchange on I-95.
    • 03:51:54
      That's north.
    • 03:51:56
      There is the Rappahannock River, there is the Welcome Center, the Virginia Welcome Center there, and there is Route 3 interchange there.
    • 03:52:05
      What this project will do is reconstruct the Route 17 interchange and new capacity I-95 mainline, four new lanes across the Rappahannock River on two new structures.
    • 03:52:18
      Complete a T interchange here at just north of the Welcome Center and then some transitional improvements, I-95 to the south.
    • 03:52:32
      What happens?
    • 03:52:34
      This has a transformational impact in I-95.
    • 03:52:38
      This interchange is failing today, will fail in the future.
    • 03:52:41
      That's 17 on the U.S. primary system.
    • 03:52:48
      And this brings that interchange up to a level of service.
    • 03:52:52
      In addition, the 20 to 30,000 vehicles a day which take this new route, this shortcut here, which I'll show you,
    • 03:53:03
      Come off of this interchange, so that interchange goes from failing to sufficient as well.
    • 03:53:08
      So this solution fixes two major I-95 interchanges in Virginia.
    • 03:53:16
      It fixes two of them.
    • 03:53:18
      In addition to those improvements, what you see in green is a new arterial that runs off to the southwest.
    • 03:53:25
      to Route 3 in the vicinity of Gordon Road, and this is just the extension of that here.
    • 03:53:31
      That's Gordon Road, and there's an interchange there with 3.
    • 03:53:34
      This is to be built as a toll road facility, and it's the subject of the George Washington Regional Toll Road Authority, which the General Assembly authorized and the governor signed.
    • 03:53:49
      Again, a major project.
    • 03:53:52
      Next slide.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:53
      Okay, so do you need state money or no?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:53:55
      Just a pinch, sir.
    • 03:53:57
      Just a pinch.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:59
      A pinch?
    • 03:54:00
      Just a pinch.
    • 03:54:01
      Talk about the economics of it.
    • 03:54:02
      Wait a minute.
    • 03:54:03
      So your pinch and my pinch are different pinches.
    • 03:54:05
      So are we going to get a number at some point?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:07
      We don't want to be left in a pinch.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:10
      Oh, okay.
    • 03:54:12
      That means we better move on to the next one.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:54:15
      I can talk to you about the economics of the project if you'd like to.
    • 03:54:18
      It's a 250 to 300 million dollar project, although if we could build it today we'd probably get it for 60 cents on the dollar.
    • 03:54:26
      But it's a 250 to 300 million dollar project.
    • 03:54:29
      That toll road that I talked about and its interchange is roughly half that cost.
    • 03:54:36
      The tolls can support that.
    • 03:54:38
      But all those improvements in I-95 and all those public improvements, congestion measures, and increased capacity, we need a partnership with the state and federal government
    • 03:55:00
      The third interchange project, and this is just a conceptual drawing here, but just to get to where you, that's the rest area interchange and that toll road we just described right there.
    • 03:55:12
      That's Route 3.
    • 03:55:14
      One alternative is to extend that toll road down here, which is really alternate five of the outer connector.
    • 03:55:20
      And then the interchange project under consideration is right there.
    • 03:55:24
      That's the so-called Jackson Gateway, just south of the existing Massaponics interchange, which itself is failing.
    • 03:55:32
      This will require
    • 03:55:35
      Approvals by the Spotsylvania Board of Supervisors, by the MPO, and certainly by our partners at VDOT and FHWA if this concept is to prevail.
    • 03:55:45
      So this is very early in the IJR process, and it's simply a concept.
    • 03:55:49
      But the Jackson Gateway improvement is one of the critical I-95 undertakings in our region, and we wanted you to be aware of it.
    • 03:56:01
      Complicating factors going forward.
    • 03:56:03
      PRAC actions, not just at Quantico, but certainly at Dahlgren and potentially at Fort AP Hill, are going to be complicating factors in the future.
    • 03:56:13
      We know that for a fact.
    • 03:56:15
      And it's going to add to the activity in the region, not take away from it.
    • 03:56:19
      We're virtually certain of this.
    • 03:56:21
      The state recently passed UDA law revisions, so-called House Bill 1071, where two of our counties will be affected, Stafford and Spotsylvania, where any UDA, their density requirements will go from four units per acre to eight.
    • 03:56:38
      And I'm putting that up there as a complicated factor, not a good thing or a bad thing.
    • 03:56:44
      Density's neither a good nor a bad thing, but it is, in our planning, a complicated factor.
    • 03:56:49
      EPA has proposed what some would consider draconian ozone rules recently.
    • 03:56:56
      We see those as a complicating factor.
    • 03:56:58
      If for no other reason than whereas there's 75 or 80 counties today that are non-attainment, that will run the number to over 600 and yet the CMAQ money that's there to help solve those problems is not going to increase.
    • 03:57:14
      And finally, as has been pointed out by everybody, the lack of adequate federal and state funding for transportation infrastructure is a complicating factor and at this time it's a negative.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:25
      And Mr. Robinson, I appreciate that you forwarded to me your comments on the EPA rules.
    • 03:57:31
      We submitted comments as well in raising those concerns.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:57:35
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:57:37
      I reviewed your comments, sir.
    • 03:57:40
      Finally, in closing, I'd like to close on a positive note, and that's the improving institutional climate in the Commonwealth, at least as I see it personally, I think we see it.
    • 03:57:49
      There is a new Commonwealth Transportation Secretary, that first bullet there, Mr. Secretary.
    • 03:58:03
      Oh boy, okay.
    • 03:58:06
      There's new leadership at FHWA, and not only nationally, but I think people here know in the state, and Irene Rico and I have met several times, and I think that's an excellent change there.
    • 03:58:18
      There is not yet new leadership at VDOT, there will be.
    • 03:58:22
      I hear rumors of names all the time.
    • 03:58:24
      There is new leadership at DRPT, Ms. Drake.
    • 03:58:33
      I'm certainly glad to have you.
    • 03:58:36
      I heard MPOs mentioned several times today, which is refreshing to me to hear them mention this venue.
    • 03:58:43
      As most of you probably know, there was a resolution that was passed.
    • 03:58:46
      to create a Virginia MPO Association.
    • 03:58:50
      That organization has its doubters, some of whom serve on my board, but we will be moving that forward to the extent that we can.
    • 03:59:00
      And finally, I think that there's a legitimate desire for
    • 03:59:03
      Reforming the project development process statewide in Virginia.
    • 03:59:07
      I think that's a legitimate quote that's shared by all.
    • 03:59:11
      We certainly share that and want to work with you.
    • 03:59:13
      So I'll end on that positive note that we see a very positive effect.
    • 03:59:18
      Mr. McCarthy.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:19
      I cannot pass up the opportunity in the midst of all this happiness to reject the note of reality.
    • 03:59:26
      I would love the slide where you quoted Albert Einstein.
    • 03:59:31
      And yet all I'm getting from you is the same kind of thinking that got us into the mess is what you're projecting going forward.
    • 03:59:40
      I don't hear a lot of innovation and I hear air quality as a complicating factor rather than as an opportunity.
    • 03:59:48
      I don't hear energy mentioned at all and water quality issues.
    • 03:59:53
      All of these things that we have discussed at some length on this board and put in the 2035 VTrans
    • 04:00:00
      that we spent a lot of time discussing, you seem to be unaware of.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:00:07
      Mr. Chairman, I'm not, let me take that.
    • 04:00:11
      I'm not sure.
    • 04:00:13
      I'm unaware of them.
    • 04:00:16
      I had a limited amount of time, Mr. McCarthy, to make my presentation.
    • 04:00:21
      Perhaps I didn't do it very well.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:24
      I got the wrong impression.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:00:26
      Okay, and the point of talking about land use scenario planning and doing business a different way in our region was just I think what you're referring to is that we see that if we continue the land use development policies in the past we're doomed to repeat
    • 04:00:44
      The MPO has no particular power over land use at all.
    • 04:00:59
      It's really a local government decision, but that's the direction that we've staked out.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:05
      I just wanted to comment.
    • 04:01:08
      You mentioned the air quality is a complicating factor.
    • 04:01:10
      I think the complicating factor that Mr. Robinson was indicating associated with air quality was if this is expanded to include so many other communities and the pool of funds available to mitigate this.
    • 04:01:21
      The problem is not likewise expanded.
    • 04:01:24
      That means left at each locality to address those problems.
    • 04:01:28
      Where CMAQ in this particular region has been used, he talked about the expanding commuter parking lots to get cars off the road in order to improve air quality, things of that nature.
    • 04:01:39
      If that pool of funds is spread so thin that the best we can do is, I guess, do studies rather than building commuter parking lots, then that's going to truly be a complicating factor in terms of air quality.
    • 04:01:51
      We won't solve air quality.
    • 04:01:53
      We'll just continue to study it, but in more jurisdictions rather than those with the principal problems.
    • 04:01:59
      In terms of the presentation, I was pleased to see that in those complicating factors,
    • 04:02:06
      One of the things that was indicated was the new UDA law.
    • 04:02:09
      And while that has been, in many cases, seen as one of the ways in which to address some of the transportation challenges that are out there, and it does when you look at primary and secondary roads, or at least it certainly should, I think when you look at this particular region, it actually becomes a complicating or potentially negative factor in that the communities, whether it's Stafford where I reside, spots of anywhere Ms. Carter resides, or even Fredericksburg,
    • 04:02:38
      The way that law is drafted, it seems to not take into account the use or the ability to use the rail line.
    • 04:02:46
      There's no incentive, there's no indication that these UDAs should, to the extent possible, be centered around commuter rail stops.
    • 04:02:56
      Certainly not all of them, but some of them.
    • 04:02:58
      The fallback of that is when an earlier comp plan was put forward, it put all the development right there on the interchange.
    • 04:03:06
      And where the Secretary mentioned earlier the challenges with the 630 interchange, that was certainly going to be one, but you heard 17, you heard the other interchanges that were identified as being in a very failing level of service.
    • 04:03:21
      We were going to be dropping those 300,000 people that he had indicated earlier would be the new residents over the next couple of decades.
    • 04:03:29
      would all come crashing down not only on those failing interchanges but also on I-95 they would be commuting north using the road rather than the rail.
    • 04:03:40
      And we saw from his earlier, I think that was a model you ran that showed the failing level of service on I-95 going north.
    • 04:03:48
      You would have that complicating factor.
    • 04:03:50
      So one of the things that I'm hoping and I understand that individuals within the General Assembly are now looking at is greater reliance upon commuter rail or focus on commuter rail within the UDA legislation that Delgado has been moving forward and we'll call it transforming from year to year in order to do this.
    • 04:04:11
      But there are some real, I think Mr. Robinson articulated a lot of the challenges that are out there.
    • 04:04:18
      I think that the Fredericksburg MPO has been doing a pretty good job of trying to get their arms around it, but I think some of the problems of the past and things that have been out there have truly made this a difficult road ahead, and it will continue to be so for some time.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:04:35
      Well, and since Mr. McCarthy has ruined this happy slide that we had, I will just want to make a point about the EPA, which is very disconcerting.
    • 04:04:47
      You know, and someone had to deal with this in local government in Prince William where we were always part of the
    • 04:04:53
      Washington Metropolitan Air Quality Management District was, you know, it's sort of like that, you know, that phantom.
    • 04:05:03
      You're almost always there.
    • 04:05:05
      The EPA sets these standards.
    • 04:05:07
      You get an entire region and everyone to buckle down and figure out how to finally get and meet the ambient air quality standards.
    • 04:05:15
      And just as you get there and we get to essentially ozone attainment, they change the standard again.
    • 04:05:23
      and then we all rush and we end up going and doing sort of supplies and I'm going to tell you crazy things that have no impact on their quality but according to the EPA we get credits for them and you're finally just about to get there and they move the goalposts again.
    • 04:05:41
      I feel like, you know, when I deal with the EPA on these issues particularly in how they treat the states and localities and, you know,
    • 04:05:49
      and how they deal with these environmental issues like this.
    • 04:05:51
      You feel like, you know, Charlie Brown and finally this is going to be the chance where finally he's going to let loose.
    • 04:05:56
      He's going to let him kick the ball.
    • 04:05:59
      And we're the Charlie Brown and we're always, you know, I'm dating myself here.
    • 04:06:03
      I tell my kids Charlie Brown.
    • 04:06:05
      They look at me and go, who?
    • 04:06:06
      What?
    • 04:06:06
      And I go, okay.
    • 04:06:08
      But this is, here they go again.
    • 04:06:10
      And we're, in fact, last year was, I think, one of the best air quality years we've ever had.
    • 04:06:16
      So what are they going to do?
    • 04:06:17
      We're going to change the standard again.
    • 04:06:19
      Because now we've made the standard.
    • 04:06:20
      And if we don't keep on violating the standard, all these programs that they've ended up coming up with go into limbo.
    • 04:06:28
      So we've got to keep those programs going.
    • 04:06:31
      So that's just my two cents worth.
    • 04:06:32
      Since Ms. McCarthy put me in abandoned mode now, I am going to end up getting this off my chest.
    • 04:06:38
      I'm sorry.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:06:39
      We have Ms. Carter.
    • 04:06:40
      Yes.
    • 04:06:41
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:06:43
      And thank you, Mr. Robinson, a great presentation.
    • 04:06:47
      And I want to thank you, Mr. Secretary, because when you mentioned proffers, you're exactly correct.
    • 04:06:54
      And we do work together on that.
    • 04:06:57
      And I will say that about seven to eight years ago when I served on the board, we received a $30 million proffer, maybe a little more, on a parkway.
    • 04:07:08
      Therefore, the new bridge that you saw going over to the hospital and across over 95, that connects to that parkway.
    • 04:07:17
      So that's the planning that we do as a region.
    • 04:07:20
      And so that parkway is, I mean, that bridge is being paid for with CDAs, am I correct?
    • 04:07:27
      What is it?
    • 04:07:28
      I believe so, yes.
    • 04:07:29
      Re-tax and district.
    • 04:07:30
      In other words, the state will not have to pay for that bridge.
    • 04:07:34
      And this is an initiative, I think, that all localities that we have to take
    • 04:07:38
      is Crawford's and as he stated, our region is growing and that's why I'm also interested in transit.
    • 04:07:48
      is because of what we see that's happening in this terrific area there, Stafford, Fredericksburg, and Pennsylvania.
    • 04:07:57
      I mean, it's just going to grow, leaps and bounds.
    • 04:08:00
      And so we look forward to working also with you, Ms. Drake, to help us in the transit.
    • 04:08:06
      And, Mr. Secretary, I know you're familiar with private, so you can help us with that.
    • 04:08:11
      But that's very necessary that we do that
    • 04:08:14
      I will applaud the area also for the bonds that they have gone after.
    • 04:08:19
      We have to be creative.
    • 04:08:24
      The toll road has to pay for itself.
    • 04:08:27
      There's no other way.
    • 04:08:28
      This is the initiative that we have to take.
    • 04:08:30
      It's certainly great to be partners with George Washington.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:36
      I have to say, I was really startled by Jerry's comment, but mainly because I'm usually the one who jumped at your throat, not Jerry.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:44
      You're ruining our day too, aren't you?
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:50
      I have to tell you, I thought your presentation was very good, and I can tell by what you said that you get it.
    • 04:08:57
      And you understand the magnitude of the problem here and some of the disconnects that are involved.
    • 04:09:03
      And in your response, I think you put your finger exactly on the point, which is the MPO can only do so much.
    • 04:09:11
      You can be a cheerleader for sanity.
    • 04:09:15
      You can be an educator for sanity.
    • 04:09:19
      But at the end of the day, we're seeing behavior by local governments, localities,
    • 04:09:24
      And hey, I'm a local elected official, and our hands are not clean in Fauquier County either.
    • 04:09:31
      But we have a statewide problem, which is the localities are not stepping to the plate, Mr. Secretary, to do their share of the heavy lifting to address this problem.
    • 04:09:45
      I use this 1795 interchange every time I come down to one of these meetings.
    • 04:09:52
      and it really puts me in a bad mood because I see what's happening from a land use standpoint that aside from the aesthetics of it and the functionality of it on a local level, I look at it as horribly and completely degrading the commonwealths, the taxpayers of the commonwealths
    • 04:10:18
      investments in these arterials and road systems by the type of sprawling development that's occurring.
    • 04:10:27
      And Mr. Robinson can do everything that he's empowered to do perfectly, and the NPO can do everything that it's empowered to do perfectly.
    • 04:10:40
      But until the Commonwealth, I think, can get itself to the point where it's prepared to say to the localities,
    • 04:10:48
      Either you stop making these decisions to degrade our investments or you're off the syringe, frankly, we're going to continue to have the problem.
    • 04:11:01
      Profers can only do so much.
    • 04:11:06
      I spent 25 years in the real estate development business.
    • 04:11:09
      But sitting on this side of the table, I will tell you that proppers can be a deal with the devil.
    • 04:11:16
      Nobody on the real estate.
    • 04:11:18
      Investment side provides money for roads unless they see a return on it.
    • 04:11:25
      That's how the private sector works.
    • 04:11:27
      We all know that.
    • 04:11:28
      And the problem is that sometimes the developments that occur with these proffers actually put you further behind, because they put so much pressure on the improvements, even the improvements made with the proffers, that they can't function the way
    • 04:11:47
      Court's point about the UDA law is a very, very good one.
    • 04:11:55
      It is a shortcoming of what in my view is otherwise a very, very good
    • 04:12:01
      Initiative, and I've got the highest respect for Mr. Athey for what he's been trying to do there.
    • 04:12:08
      Maybe as a board, we ought to help him, others on his committee, with a recommendation as to how the UDAs could be focused where there is significant passenger rail.
    • 04:12:27
      around those passenger rail nodes.
    • 04:12:31
      That might be a really helpful thing for us as a board to do, which indirectly and perhaps even directly really protects the investments in transportation, even in road transportation that we're supposed to have responsibility for.
    • 04:12:46
      And I should, I think somebody else already referred to it, but one of the key sort of mega investments listed
    • 04:12:57
      If I remember correctly in VTrans 2035 is further passenger rail on the I-95 corridor.
    • 04:13:09
      So to the extent your MPO planning could directly embrace that and to the extent the UDA law could perhaps be amended in the next General Assembly session to facilitate UDA planning around transit nodes
    • 04:13:26
      You know, maybe we all get on the bandwagon of something that would be very, very helpful.
    • 04:13:33
      But, you know, I can tell from your presentation, you, your MPO, you fully understand the problem.
    • 04:13:41
      Somehow or another, we have to figure out as a board, as a Commonwealth, how to get local governments, local boards of supervisors, local town councils,
    • 04:13:53
      through judicious application of both the carrot and the stick to make the admittedly very tough land use decisions that still aren't being made.
    • 04:14:05
      That's what Jerry, I understand you see the little bit of the rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic problem going on here, but the key will be to figure out a way to get local governments in line.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:20
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:14:23
      I just want to say that without our VA office that we have in the Fredericksburg District, we would never accomplish what we did.
    • 04:14:32
      It takes teamwork, and we will do it.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:14:34
      Thank you.
    • 04:14:35
      I didn't put a plug in for Quentin Elliott.
    • 04:14:38
      I need to do that.
    • 04:14:39
      It's excellent, excellent teamwork.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:42
      You want to speak closer to the mic?
    • 04:14:43
      I think he's out in the audience.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:14:47
      And Jamie.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:14:48
      Robinson, thank you.
    • 04:14:49
      I'm just going to add a few remarks that come in from an Irish politician, but I will try to keep it brief.
    • 04:14:55
      Wait, wait, wait.
    • 04:14:56
      Which side of the Irish are you from?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:58
      Mr. McCarthy's side or my side?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:15:03
      The Irish, everybody loves the Irish, there's no signs in here, right?
    • 04:15:06
      Wait, wait, wait, do you know what Bloom's Day is?
    • 04:15:10
      Bloom's Day?
    • 04:15:12
      For one, if I remember correctly, there is a day that was the flowers in the garden.
    • 04:15:17
      No, no, no.
    • 04:15:19
      He didn't read James Joyce.
    • 04:15:20
      No, I didn't.
    • 04:15:23
      I want to build upon a few things here with regards to what we've achieved at our MPO, expand a little bit on the relationship within the jurisdictions of the MPO and where we would like to see this go.
    • 04:15:38
      On the issue brought up about water quality and things like that, there are other issues and other aspects of this beyond transportation.
    • 04:15:44
      We have, as the City of Fredericksburg and the staff at Spotsylvania, Orange, Rockier, and everybody else, just put a large 20-plus miles of the Rappahannock River under conservation easement, which is a big water quality issue.
    • 04:15:56
      The City of Fredericksburg just passed one of the more innovative LID ordinances for future development.
    • 04:16:01
      In every development deal we've made right now with the silver companies, which is the biggest one, they have to use LID as part of the project.
    • 04:16:08
      So we are working on that front.
    • 04:16:10
      But at the end of the day, we've talked to our elected officials, we've talked to the press, we've talked to the public.
    • 04:16:17
      The understanding is this.
    • 04:16:19
      Under the current development patterns for our region, there is no chance in hell we are ever going to meet the transportation needs of that development.
    • 04:16:32
      Ain't gonna happen.
    • 04:16:34
      So there is going to have to be a fundamental shift in how we approach development in the region.
    • 04:16:41
      Everybody talks about transit and transit is great and wonderful and it is.
    • 04:16:45
      I've served on the VRE board as well as PRTC and every other regional transportation board I can think of.
    • 04:16:51
      I'm on there.
    • 04:16:52
      The fact of the matter is, under the current development patterns in our region, we have great north-south opportunities for transit.
    • 04:17:00
      We have VRE, we have transit services going up and down between Richmond and Washington.
    • 04:17:06
      But to the east and the west, it's not conducive for transit right now.
    • 04:17:11
      It's kind of a sprawled out area.
    • 04:17:12
      We don't have the nodes that you need to make transit workable.
    • 04:17:17
      So we are going to have to, I'm saying as a local elected official, I know how the state likes to come back to its local elected officials and say, it's all your fault.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:17:27
      That's a local elected official telling you that.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:17:30
      It is.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:17:31
      I used to say that.
    • 04:17:33
      Now I say that.
    • 04:17:34
      I used to say it's all Richmond's fault.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:17:37
      But the fact of the matter is, we do get
    • 04:17:41
      And with regards to the MPO itself, I think it's important to know how strong the working relationship is between the jurisdictions that are involved in our MPO, including King George and Caroline.
    • 04:17:53
      Lloyd went over a little bit about we prioritize projects.
    • 04:17:57
      We spent months debating, coming back with ways to prioritize transportation projects in our region to the point of how much
    • 04:18:08
      traffic doesn't move what's the environmental impact how much traffic mitigation is involved in the project and we have rated the projects based on those priorities which not a lot of people do from the electric side we all have our things that we want to do.
    • 04:18:21
      Because we want to take what few dollars we're going to get, and we understand the realities of the game.
    • 04:18:26
      I'm not going to sit here and say, we need more money, give us more money, give us more.
    • 04:18:30
      I'll take it.
    • 04:18:31
      I'm not saying that.
    • 04:18:32
      But at the end of the day, sitting here begging for more money defies reality.
    • 04:18:35
      It's not going to happen.
    • 04:18:36
      We understand that.
    • 04:18:37
      And we need to make what dollars we get go as far as we possibly can, that every dollar spent is having an impact on traffic.
    • 04:18:43
      And we are doing that with Stafford and with Spotsylvania.
    • 04:18:47
      Right now VDOT is working on a project and I want to first before I say this echo Lloyd's comment about Quentin Elliott.
    • 04:18:54
      Quentin has been a great asset to VDOT in our district.
    • 04:18:58
      We have gone from no you can't do that, no you can't do that, no you can't do that, no you can't do that to well maybe we can't do it this way, let's look at other ways to do this and see what we can do which is a great shift in attitude for VDOT and we really appreciate it.
    • 04:19:12
      But the fact of the matter is we have less than a mile of Ragg Road being expanded between Route 3 and the city line.
    • 04:19:21
      And it stops at the city line.
    • 04:19:24
      And I don't know how long that project has been on the books being looked at, checked on, looked at 20 times over, and finally being built now.
    • 04:19:33
      And the fact of the matter is, unless the city, which we did through our work with the Silver Companies, were able to get properties to expand our section of Ragg Road,
    • 04:19:40
      We're still running into a two-lane bridge over I-95, which means we still got a bottleneck.
    • 04:19:47
      So the attitude of we build projects based on localities and where the county lines are is frankly not the best way to spend time and effort.
    • 04:19:59
      We have, with Spotsylvania County, gone forward on the Lafayette Boulevard quarter, which is another major quarter coming in, and we are planning it from downtown Fredericksburg all the way out to Route 1 as one project, working with Spotsylvania County to get it done.
    • 04:20:19
      And as Lloyd has said, we are also looking at numerous different ways to do things differently, to get the job done.
    • 04:20:26
      And frankly, during that process, we've gotten a lot of scrapes and bruises down the road.
    • 04:20:32
      That toll road authority, we had a big battle with Richmond to get that done.
    • 04:20:40
      We started down the road of transit and wanted to do a transit study to finally look at transit.
    • 04:20:45
      We ran into at that time, this is, I want to make it clear, this was before Clinton got here.
    • 04:20:50
      The issues of VDOT procurement which almost dropped that project and now I think we're one few MPOs that has our own procurement policy because through after that fiasco we changed over and developed our own procurement policy which has now been adopted.
    • 04:21:07
      We are looking at the possibilities of taking some of our funding at the MPO and basically getting on-call engineering services to provide for our member jurisdictions
    • 04:21:20
      We're all tight for money right now, we understand that.
    • 04:21:22
      And the thought pattern being, there are smaller projects that we can do in our jurisdictions, that if we can get to the pre-engineering stage and have them sitting on the shelf ready to go, I mean, from a bridge over 95 on Falhill Avenue, to intersection improvements, whatever it is to move traffic, we'll be ready to go, and let's face it, we all know money's flying in and out of here left and right, and you gotta be in a position to grab it as it comes by.
    • 04:21:46
      And we wanna do that.
    • 04:21:47
      And guess what we ran into?
    • 04:21:49
      We've run into the procurement policy again.
    • 04:21:51
      And we just got the letter from the Attorney General that we can't do it.
    • 04:21:56
      That we're going to have to probably go through our elected officials to get changes done.
    • 04:22:02
      I'm happy to hear that the Governor and the Secretary of Transportation and DRPT and everybody is going to be getting together and are going to be talking about transportation and how we need to change transportation.
    • 04:22:14
      I've got to say two things on that.
    • 04:22:17
      Secretary Connaughton, you were talking about, well, why is 630 taking 20 years?
    • 04:22:21
      And by the way, Cord, yes, it is our number one priority project for interchange.
    • 04:22:27
      We've asked a big question, and that's why we're not sitting down and waiting for another 20 or 30 years for the other interchanges and other projects that are necessary in our region.
    • 04:22:37
      So that's why we're moving forward as innovatively as we can.
    • 04:22:40
      The problem is we are running into
    • 04:22:44
      The State Bureaucracy and How We Do Things.
    • 04:22:46
      And I think they do need to fundamentally change.
    • 04:22:50
      Projects shouldn't take as long as they do, especially secondary road projects.
    • 04:22:54
      Some of the time we've had to waste on secondary road projects is basically insane.
    • 04:22:58
      The amount of money that's been spent on Route 630 Interchange Project, which has been engineered, I don't know how many times it's been engineered, but quite a few million dollars that could have been spent elsewhere went into engineering.
    • 04:23:11
      So we understand the dynamic.
    • 04:23:14
      I think we've got a region, and I think you're looking to talk to most MPOs.
    • 04:23:17
      We're willing to do what it needs to take, but we're going to need a lot of help from you all at the state level in getting this done, one.
    • 04:23:23
      And two, I applaud the comments that were made about the MPOs about giving us presentations and things, though I am a little nervous when somebody said the state wants to take back and look at CMAC funding.
    • 04:23:34
      As a local elected official and a member of the MPO, whenever money gets sucked back to the state, it makes me cringe.
    • 04:23:40
      Sorry about that, but that's the reality is the way it is.
    • 04:23:43
      The fact of the matter is at the end of the day, while it's great that we're going to be referred to and we're going to have the presentations, we would rather be sitting at the table at the beginning of the discussions and not be told, oh, by the way, here's what we're planning on doing.
    • 04:23:58
      This is where we're going.
    • 04:23:58
      I've got Secretary Connaughton that you can now talk about this six-year plan.
    • 04:24:02
      It's pretty much set in stone, pretty much there.
    • 04:24:04
      But next time we would like to sit at the beginning of the discussions in those as opposed to waiting to the very end.
    • 04:24:10
      And that also goes, and I've got to say, with the UDAs.
    • 04:24:15
      UDAs is a classic example of good concept, pretty much bad execution.
    • 04:24:20
      Why would you go ahead and start making plans at the state level on UDAs arbitrarily picking density levels
    • 04:24:29
      without even consulting, and as far as I'm aware, never even consulted, let alone the MPO, the local governments, on how that was going to go down.
    • 04:24:37
      And again, we're starting the process of looking at the big picture and how we need to change.
    • 04:24:42
      We need to be in that table.
    • 04:24:43
      The other issue has been brought up here proffers, and Secretary Connaughton, you brought it up.
    • 04:24:47
      There's still an ongoing debate in Richmond on proffers and whether or not we're going to do impact fees, yet you're going to require local governments July of next year to go ahead and establish UDAs, and you haven't even established the ground rules yet.
    • 04:24:59
      So I think there needs to be an understanding that, first off, we get it.
    • 04:25:05
      We're working towards making the changes that you all say we need to make.
    • 04:25:08
      We're just asking you to bring us in the conversation on the front end instead of the back end.
    • 04:25:12
      Basically, I talked to two of my local elected officials.
    • 04:25:15
      It's time for us to take the training wheels off the bicycle and let us ride a little bit and get involved in this process.
    • 04:25:20
      Thank you very much.
    • 04:25:21
      I'll answer any questions if you have any.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:25:23
      Mr.
    • 04:25:23
      Chair, I'd just like to comment that Mr. Kelly is one of the more shy and retiring local elected officials in the Fredericksburg region.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:25:30
      He's obviously from Northern Ireland.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:25:34
      Wait, Mr. Kelly, I just want to make a couple comments.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:25:42
      The first is, you all actually, when you see definitive problems in our processes,
    • 04:25:52
      Give us a list.
    • 04:25:53
      I mean we are looking for changes that we need to make administratively and particularly right now where there's this time where obviously there's been a major reduction force and change in the structure or field or structure and then with it the relationship between the central office and the district office, administrators.
    • 04:26:17
      We're looking for these issues and problems.
    • 04:26:20
      We really encourage you all to give it to us in writing and it will become part of the package we're putting together to try to make reforms.
    • 04:26:31
      The second thing, I just want you to not misunderstand what we're trying to do on the CMAC issue and other issues.
    • 04:26:38
      is that what we're finding is that we're sitting on tens of, if not hundreds of millions of dollars that have been allocated to projects that have been sitting out there for years, not just in CMAC, but I'm looking at, in fact, Ms. Busher mentioned it during some of the six-year plan issue, safety money.
    • 04:26:56
      I mean, we're looking at a sizable amount of money that's been sitting there that we have not expended.
    • 04:27:01
      And, you know, in fact, Director Drake and I were having a conversation about some projects
    • 04:27:07
      that she's responsible for where we're looking and seeing tens of millions of dollars on projects that, they're good projects but they're not moving forward.
    • 04:27:17
      We don't have the luxury of just parking money all around.
    • 04:27:21
      And so the issue is how do we get that money moving and get it on the projects that are moving.
    • 04:27:26
      But no, we appreciate very much everything you guys are doing.
    • 04:27:30
      We need to, and we're very sincere about trying to get you in the loop at the beginning and work together to have plans that are realistic, that end up meeting everyone's expectations within fiscal restraints, but that our state process and the federal process end up matching.
    • 04:27:52
      Now, I'm going to give you one criticism now.
    • 04:27:56
      No, and listen, I love you guys.
    • 04:27:58
      I mean, I'm a Prince William guy, but one of the problems I always really encourage you to look at is that still something like 65% of your workers go north every day.
    • 04:28:14
      And so, and it goes back to some of the issues on, you know, it is about how do we look, the region isn't, quote unquote, the MPO, the region is, you are a part of the Washington region,
    • 04:28:26
      And believe me, as someone who lives right off the 95 corridor of Prince William, even at 5 a.m. in the morning when I leave home to drive down here, the backup is already started.
    • 04:28:49
      And the issue is, as I always encourage you, as we're reaching out to you, you need to reach out more to the folks up in Northern Virginia.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:28:57
      Again, I serve on the BRD board.
    • 04:28:58
      I think rapid transit and rail is the wave of the future.
    • 04:29:02
      But the fact of the matter is, we'll be able to tackle a little bit of that, but there's always going to be basically a move north from our general area.
    • 04:29:10
      We are part of the National Capital Region.
    • 04:29:11
      I wish we were part of that.
    • 04:29:12
      One of the things we're trying to work on is get Stafford County, Spotsylvania County, and the city recognized as being a part of the National Capital Region.
    • 04:29:19
      which would give us better opportunities to frankly bring businesses or government agencies down where we don't have to get on the road.
    • 04:29:26
      Uncle Sam doesn't think we're part of that.
    • 04:29:28
      I know you think we are, but right now Uncle Sam doesn't think we are part of the National Capital Region.
    • 04:29:32
      If you can help us out on that one, we'd really appreciate that.
    • 04:29:34
      I think we need a big group hug.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:39
      Alrighty, we can move on.
    • 04:29:41
      I'm sorry, we're way behind.
    • 04:29:41
      Ms. Kelly, thank you very much.
    • 04:29:42
      Mr. Robinson, that was great.
    • 04:29:44
      That was outstanding time.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:29:45
      Yes.
    • 04:29:46
      Can you just indulge me for one second?
    • 04:29:48
      First of all, I agree with Matt's points about the need for the localities to be at the table
    • 04:29:55
      At the beginning, the infamous James Carville once said, to quote him very loosely, it's the zoning stupid.
    • 04:30:07
      The reality is that they're going to have to be significant zoning changes in order to accomplish the kinds of functional land use patterns that Mr. Robinson dreams about at night.
    • 04:30:23
      and so do I.
    • 04:30:27
      When I said the problem resides with local governments, that was of course too simple.
    • 04:30:33
      The reality is in every one of these localities, there are some people who get it.
    • 04:30:39
      And there are others who don't.
    • 04:30:40
      And it's always a struggle on every single board of supervisors on every town council.
    • 04:30:46
      If we, the Commonwealth, want to empower the folks who get it and who understand the need to adapt their land use policies to protect our transportation investments,
    • 04:30:58
      One way to empower them to do that is to give them the ability to say to their colleagues that, guys, if we don't do it, when it comes to the six-year plan, we get a big fat goose egg.
    • 04:31:12
      And that's stated very dramatically for effect, but I do think that the carrot and the stick are both going to have to be judiciously
    • 04:31:22
      applied if we're going to achieve the kind of goals that Mr. Robinson was talking about.
    • 04:31:28
      Thank you so much.
    • 04:31:28
      Thank you.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:29
      If I could just follow up from a urban side.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:31
      Sterling.
    • 04:31:32
      And then this is the last comment.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:35
      There still is the challenge.
    • 04:31:36
      You have buy-write land development.
    • 04:31:40
      In some communities, there has not been major re-zonings in 10 years.
    • 04:31:47
      It actually is part of the challenge because that has encouraged some of that sprawl into the outer areas.
    • 04:31:54
      So you do have that.
    • 04:31:55
      Now in terms of the carrot and the stick and telling them how much is your community going to get in that six-year plan,
    • 04:32:03
      We know that that is right now a big goose egg, so it's not much of a threat to a local community telling them if they don't do it, they don't get money.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:32:12
      That is a problem.
    • 04:32:13
      Okay, well, Mr. King, Mr. King.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:32:18
      Could I summarize one thought here?
    • 04:32:21
      And that is this.
    • 04:32:23
      If we have the best
    • 04:32:24
      Land Use Plan implemented here and the Best Environmental Plan, I think I still heard 2.5 billion identified revenue with a shortage of 7.5 billion in that 2035 plan.
    • 04:32:39
      So we haven't talked a lot about that, but I wonder can we reach some of these goals that's been established with the 2.5 billion revenue that they've identified?
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:32:52
      I'm going to take that as a statement, not a question.
    • 04:32:54
      Okay.
    • 04:32:56
      We are moving on to the final workshop item, the Midtown Tunnel PPTA.
    • 04:33:03
      Can you stand by yourself, sir?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:04
      Oh, Mr. Whirley.
    • 04:33:06
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'd like to give you an update on the downtown tunnel, midtown tunnel MLK extension.
    • 04:33:15
      This is a PPTA project.
    • 04:33:17
      This is an update.
    • 04:33:18
      There's no action that's required on the part of the board.
    • 04:33:24
      There are several agenda items that we will cover, project description, the status of the CTB recommendations, the interim agreement, the phase one project deliverables, and the VDOT comments and recommendations.
    • 04:33:38
      What I'd like to do, Mr. Chairman, if that would be okay with you, I would like for Dusty Holcombe, who's kind of shepherded this project through the department, to give the first part of the presentation, and then I will come up and give the recommendations.
    • 04:33:55
      And at that point, we would be answering the questions that you may have on the project.
    • 04:34:01
      Thank you, Mr. Whirley.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:34:05
      Chairman, Board Members, in accordance with the PPTA law, we're going to be as efficient as possible so that we can move things forward.
    • 04:34:13
      We've really talked about the agenda items.
    • 04:34:17
      We're going to do a quick project description because we have a couple of new members around and we're just going to give them a brief update on the project itself.
    • 04:34:24
      There are four major elements in the project.
    • 04:34:27
      I'm going to go to the map here.
    • 04:34:29
      You'll see in the upper right-hand corner Norfolk, lower left is Portsmouth.
    • 04:34:35
      Midtown Tunnel is the major element of this.
    • 04:34:37
      It's going to be a new immersed tube tunnel, two lanes.
    • 04:34:41
      It's shown in orange on the map itself.
    • 04:34:43
      There will be upgrades to both the midtown and the two downtown tubes, and those are fire life safety upgrades.
    • 04:34:52
      And then the final element, which is shown in green and blue on your map, will be the extension of the MLK and a new interchange on I-264 and upgrades to the efficiency of that interchange itself.
    • 04:35:10
      Some of the key milestones that we've had, VDOT solicited a project in May of 2008.
    • 04:35:16
      We received one submission on that in September of 2008, and that was from Elizabeth River Crossings.
    • 04:35:21
      You'll hear me call them ERC throughout this process.
    • 04:35:26
      It is a joint venture of both Scamska
    • 04:35:28
      In the February and June time period, we had the IRP meetings or the independent review panel meetings which were chaired by Mr. Dickens.
    • 04:35:44
      After that, the CTB in July provided recommendations and I'll talk for a few minutes in a couple of slides about the recommendations and the status of those recommendations.
    • 04:35:53
      We executed an interim agreement in January of 2010, and then within that interim agreement itself, submittal of phase one deliverables was April of 2010, which was met by ERC, and we're currently working on the decision to advance to phase two.
    • 04:36:11
      If we advance to phase two, the anticipated commercial or financial close of this project to be the summer of 2011, and a four-year construction period, so that would be 2011 to 2015.
    • 04:36:23
      I draw your attention to a handout that you have about the status update for the CTB recommendations that were made in July of 2009.
    • 04:36:34
      There were 16 recommendations made by the CTB.
    • 04:36:38
      I'm going to identify a couple of those recommendations, but you do have a handout, and if you have any questions on those later, I can certainly answer those.
    • 04:36:46
      You asked us to pursue public and private sector funding.
    • 04:36:50
      We have done that in a couple of ways.
    • 04:36:53
      We attempted and put an application in for a TIGER fund grant.
    • 04:36:57
      That was denied by FHWA.
    • 04:37:00
      We are working to put a TIGER grant, too, for discretionary grants.
    • 04:37:05
      That application is going to be going in pretty soon.
    • 04:37:08
      We also put a letter of interest with ERC, put a letter of interest in for a TIFIA loan, which is a major component of the financial plan.
    • 04:37:17
      That was put in by the March 1st deadline.
    • 04:37:19
      We have not heard from FHWA.
    • 04:37:21
      We hope to hear from over the summer.
    • 04:37:23
      And as we go along in what you'll see in your briefing, there are other ERC recommendations towards the development of different types of dollars that can be used towards this project.
    • 04:37:35
      Another recommendation that you have to look at is to work with the cities to lessen the impact to some of the properties, especially along the MLK, and to identify opportunities to advance contact sensors and design solutions in those areas.
    • 04:37:49
      We have met with the City of Portsmouth already.
    • 04:37:51
      Paul Holt has given us a list of items that he would like us to look at as we develop the MLK within the City of Portsmouth.
    • 04:38:01
      We are meeting with the City of Norfolk on June 4th to talk to them about some of the improvements that will be on the Norfolk side of the Midtown Tunnel.
    • 04:38:09
      We are also developing a communication and outreach, public outreach plan, both with ERC, Jeff Siegel of ERC and Shannon Marshall, chair of that committee and
    • 04:38:21
      On that committee, we're going to be looking at different ways to bring communication to the cities themselves, to the jurisdictions, to the citizens, update them on the projects as the projects move along, both during the development of phase two and also during construction.
    • 04:38:39
      So the community outreach and public communication plan is a very important component to getting this project moving forward.
    • 04:38:49
      You also asked us to form collaborative working groups.
    • 04:38:52
      We've done six working groups.
    • 04:38:55
      As you'll see on the slide, there's communication, technical, environmental, financial, OEM, and commercial working groups.
    • 04:39:01
      Those working groups have been working closely with ERC.
    • 04:39:05
      One of the key items that I want to stress here in our technical working group, we have just hired a project manager down in the Hampton Roads area that will be the technical lead for the project.
    • 04:39:17
      Frank Fabian brings 30 years of experience from the private sector and he's going to be a benefit to the project itself.
    • 04:39:25
      We also asked us to accelerate the project procurement process.
    • 04:39:28
      That was done with the interim agreement.
    • 04:39:31
      The interim agreement was signed on January 7th and over the next two slides I want to give you a little bit more information about the interim agreement itself.
    • 04:39:41
      There are two phases associated with the interim agreement, and this is what we talked about in November when I gave that briefing.
    • 04:39:48
      The first one is the feasibility determination, which we're going through right now.
    • 04:39:52
      If we advance to phase two, it'll be focused on project development, and that's what I identify as the digging into the details about the project itself.
    • 04:40:01
      That's where we'll start to talk about the conceptual design.
    • 04:40:03
      We'll talk about traffic revenue studies.
    • 04:40:06
      We'll start to develop a financial plan on the project itself.
    • 04:40:09
      We'll do project development plans which look at the environment, look at the communication plans, different project development plans for the project.
    • 04:40:19
      And then this is the key part.
    • 04:40:20
      We'll start negotiating the comprehensive agreement and we anticipate negotiations for the comprehensive agreement to start around the August, September time period.
    • 04:40:30
      Over the next few slides, I want to talk about Phase I project deliverables.
    • 04:40:33
      There were four deliverables that were provided by ERC in accordance with the interim agreement, the scope of work, the work plan, the risk matrix, and finally, the project feasibility assessment report.
    • 04:40:47
      The first one is the scope of work, and that defines the scope of services that are going to be provided by ERC during the construction and development of the project.
    • 04:40:55
      Those services include financing, design, construction, operations, security of the project itself, and maintenance.
    • 04:41:03
      It focuses in on the community and outreach plan that we will have focused in and on the public at hearings.
    • 04:41:11
      The DVE and SWAM requirements and many other issues that we want to get out to the community and talk to the community about as we move along.
    • 04:41:21
      Within the scope of services, there were key components that were described, including the tunnel cross section, the ventilation system, and the maintenance boundaries.
    • 04:41:29
      But those maintenance boundaries, it's not only just the operations and maintenance, but the snow removal and the asset grouping for the boundaries itself.
    • 04:41:40
      Our evaluation of that document was that it adequately identifies the scope of services.
    • 04:41:47
      It does define the O&M boundaries.
    • 04:41:48
      We're still working with our O&M group and ERC to finalize those.
    • 04:41:53
      We're going to be putting them on aerial photography so that there's no ambiguity between who has responsibilities along the corridor itself.
    • 04:42:02
      And then the final version of this document will show up as an exhibit in the CA.
    • 04:42:09
      The next document is the work plan, and really what the work plan does, it focuses on the schedule that's going to be for phase two.
    • 04:42:16
      And as you see from the slide, there's 188 work packages.
    • 04:42:21
      I talked a little bit about some of the work packages before, but it'll be focused on the conceptual and preliminary design of the tunnel and of the MLK.
    • 04:42:31
      We'll have our engineers looking at those documents.
    • 04:42:34
      Project development documents include the O&M plan, the rehabilitation plans,
    • 04:42:39
      Environmental Mitigation and Permitting Plans, DBE Slam Plans, and obviously the communication plan that I've talked about.
    • 04:42:48
      Some of the major dates that were included in ERC's work plan, their date of commencement is June 2nd.
    • 04:42:55
      I talked about initiation of the comprehensive agreement negotiations in the August time period.
    • 04:43:00
      Execution of the comprehensive agreement and financial close are going to be in late May, early June time period.
    • 04:43:08
      Our evaluation of it is that we believe that it adequately defines the path forward under the CA to develop a cost estimate and to develop, to get us to financial closer.
    • 04:43:18
      It allows coordination of not only ERC's resources but also the department's resources so that we can make sure that we meet our obligations under the IA and that we focus in on getting us towards a
    • 04:43:33
      Good negotiated comprehensive agreement.
    • 04:43:36
      One thing that we've done in advance of the date of commencement is some early start activities.
    • 04:43:43
      ERC asked us to look at six early start activities which were a part of the work packages under the work plan.
    • 04:43:50
      We got that approved by FHWA and we're moving forward on those along with ERC and we hope that that's going to make the time period from the
    • 04:44:00
      June 2010 or 2011 time period, try to make it more efficient to us getting there.
    • 04:44:09
      The next one is the risk matrix.
    • 04:44:12
      Back in February 2010, ERC and VDOT met for two days and talked about risk on the project.
    • 04:44:19
      ERC defined to us what they think are some of the major risks and we defined ERC what we thought were some of the major risks on the project, both commercial and technical risks.
    • 04:44:28
      I thought it was a very good meeting.
    • 04:44:30
      It gave us a lot of information for us to do our risk analysis, and my hope is that it gave ERC a lot of information for the development of their risk matrix, which they provided to us prior to the April 1st date.
    • 04:44:44
      In that risk matrix, they identified what their view of the risk allocation is on the project.
    • 04:44:51
      ERC identified several risks for permitting.
    • 04:44:54
      Different site conditions, right-of-way acquisition.
    • 04:44:58
      Their expectations on several of these is that they would want schedule relief and compensation relief on these.
    • 04:45:04
      The department's evaluation of those is that we still have a lot of negotiating to do on those.
    • 04:45:10
      We have sort of a different view of how the risk should be allocated on those, but that's one of the purposes of phase two on this project is to nail down those uncertainties that were identified in their risk matrix and our risk matrix and identify mitigation ways to try to reduce both the cost of the project, which ultimately will reduce the tolls on the project itself.
    • 04:45:35
      The last part of the, or the last deliverable was the project feasibility assessment report.
    • 04:45:42
      It was a 66-page report.
    • 04:45:44
      which talked about traffic and revenue, it talked about financing, toll reduction initiatives that were identified by ERC, risk allocation and base case assumptions.
    • 04:45:56
      Over the next four slides, I want to try to talk about some of the input that was put in to the base case that was developed by ERC and then you'll see some of the output that was developed by ERC on the base case.
    • 04:46:10
      One key to remember here is that we're very early in the stage of development of this project.
    • 04:46:16
      A lot of the information is preliminary.
    • 04:46:18
      We want to make sure that we keep this body briefed and the citizens briefed on how we're moving forward with it.
    • 04:46:24
      And so we want to make it as clear as possible that it is preliminary, but we want to put it out here for your consideration.
    • 04:46:30
      Some of the key assumptions that ERC made in their base case, no upfront public subsidies for ERC on the project.
    • 04:46:39
      One of the CTB recommendations was for the O&M subsidy.
    • 04:46:44
      In the base case, we asked them not to put the annual and O&M subsidy in there so that we could see what the differences were if it was ultimately put in the project itself.
    • 04:46:53
      We would start tolling, or within the base case, we would start tolling beginning nine months after financial close.
    • 04:46:59
      That means that we would have tolling during construction.
    • 04:47:02
      There'd be a post-tax equity IRR or internal rate of return of 14%.
    • 04:47:08
      Tolls escalated annually as CPI or the consumer price index.
    • 04:47:13
      It would be all electronic tolling technology, and one thing that we want to stress there would be that there would be no toll booths on it.
    • 04:47:19
      It would be all electronic tolling.
    • 04:47:21
      Financing package would have both TIFIA and private activity bonds.
    • 04:47:26
      Risk allocation in the base case, anyway, is consistent with ERC's risk maintenance, and it would be a 50-year term concession fund.
    • 04:47:35
      This slide shows the estimated project cost as put out by ERC.
    • 04:47:40
      These are preliminary estimated costs.
    • 04:47:42
      They're updated to 2010 dollars.
    • 04:47:45
      Some of the key areas that you see, the construction costs are 1.393 million dollars.
    • 04:47:51
      The rehabilitation costs, 41 million.
    • 04:47:53
      Operating costs for the project itself are 158 million.
    • 04:47:58
      Some of the key areas, interest expense, 174.
    • 04:48:00
      The TIFIA subsidy, 32 million.
    • 04:48:03
      Our hope is that
    • 04:48:04
      When the TIFIA application, if the TIFIA application is approved, FHWA will not put the $32 million subsidy on there and that's one way that we think that we could be able to lower the tolls if we can work with FHWA and not have that subsidy.
    • 04:48:22
      This chart shows the base and peak toll rates for both cars and trucks on the project.
    • 04:48:30
      The error is in brackets, as you'll see in the notes below.
    • 04:48:33
      If you're going through the toll, either at the tunnel or at MLK, and you do not have a transponder, that is the cost that would
    • 04:48:44
      Before you're going through the toll itself, and what that is, it's look-up fees, it's administrative costs, it's the toll itself.
    • 04:48:51
      So, for example, the base toll for the cars for the Midtown Tunnel would be $2.17.
    • 04:48:55
      If you went through the tunnel without a transponder, your cost would be $4.34, which would include the toll in that $4.34.
    • 04:49:06
      These tolls are shown in 2012 dollars and are escalated at the consumer price and the peak periods will be from 6 a.m. to 9 a.m. and from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m. on all of the facilities, downtown, midtown, and MLK.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:49:22
      Are they, Dusty, are they one-way tolls or two-way tolls?
    • 04:49:25
      They are one-way tolls.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:49:31
      This slide shows some of the initiatives that we have to vote.
    • 04:49:37
      Our goal is obviously to decrease, but some of the areas where it could increase the toll.
    • 04:49:41
      For example, I talked a little bit about the VDOT O&M subsidy.
    • 04:49:46
      If we were to put that, it could reduce the toll by 14 cents, collection charge savings, and what that is, the DMV lookups.
    • 04:49:54
      If we could work with DMV and try to reduce the cost of some of those and get some savings from there, that could be 4 cents.
    • 04:49:59
      the Norfolk portal integration what that is it's optimizing the throughput at the Brampton and Hampton Boulevard interchange and working with the city of Norfolk to try to optimize their signals on Hampton Boulevard and on Brampton Boulevard to try to get as much traffic through the facility as possible.
    • 04:50:17
      The next one is 100 million risk allocation construction.
    • 04:50:20
      That's where I get involved and I start negotiating the components of the comprehensive agreement.
    • 04:50:25
      That's where we work on the risks that have been identified and try to find mitigation measures for them.
    • 04:50:31
      And that's where we try to answer some of the uncertainties that have been identified early on.
    • 04:50:37
      If we can work that down, again, that could be up to another 13 cents decrease in the toll.
    • 04:50:43
      That certainly is our goal.
    • 04:50:45
      Some of the increases that, and we did this so that we could just see where the effect on some of the increases would be.
    • 04:50:52
      I talked quickly about, before about construction during, tolling during construction.
    • 04:50:58
      If we weren't to do that, then 34 cents would be added to the total.
    • 04:51:02
      If we weren't able to get the TIFIA funding, then we believe 38 cents would be added to the total because of the increased cost of debt if we didn't get the TIFIA one itself.
    • 04:51:13
      That decreased video surcharge.
    • 04:51:16
      If we were to decrease the video surcharge to a dollar, then it would cost us, it would cost 19 cents on the toll itself.
    • 04:51:23
      And currently the video surcharge in the base case is $2.17 for the tunnel and $2.13 for the tunnel.
    • 04:51:32
      Excuse me.
    • 04:51:32
      Yes, sir.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:34
      How much money are we talking about with the TIFIA funding?
    • 04:51:38
      The total, the amount of funding, I'm assuming we're buying down tolls.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:51:42
      Well, with the TIFIA funding itself, it would be part of the financial plan itself.
    • 04:51:52
      And then there's some other options that are presented by ERC.
    • 04:51:56
      such as nominal gross domestic product instead of CPI.
    • 04:51:59
      There is modifications to the CPI escalations for different periods of time.
    • 04:52:06
      There could be a fixed percentage of escalation over the term of the contract.
    • 04:52:10
      There's some different things that we're looking at and evaluating with ERC to try to see how we can try to reduce the toll as much as possible.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:52:20
      Dusty, in the total $1.9 billion budget that you showed, how much contingency
    • 04:52:34
      is billed into that budget.
    • 04:52:36
      Is there contingency?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:52:37
      There is contingency.
    • 04:52:39
      My understanding of reading the document itself, it's $132 million in contingency set up for ERC, which is consistent with the contingency that the department has looked at, too.
    • 04:52:51
      We're about the same range in contingency.
    • 04:52:53
      So I would say that's a reasonable contingency.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:52:56
      And if that contingency is not used, does that reduce the project budget and therefore potentially reduce the tolls?
    • 04:53:11
      Or does that contingency get shared with the contractor as sort of an incentive?
    • 04:53:18
      Or has that been decided yet?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:53:20
      Well, it hasn't been decided but what we've seen in the past and what we've done in the past is that we approach this for a fixed price contract itself.
    • 04:53:29
      So with the fixed price contract, the contingency or the premium, whatever you want to call it, is built into the price that the contractor or in this case, the concessionaire would give us.
    • 04:53:37
      So if the contingency wasn't realized, then they would benefit from it because of the fixed price and that all goes
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:53:44
      Mark J. Peake III, Mark J. Peake III, Mark J. Peake III
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:54:03
      And with that, I'll hand it over to Commissioner Whirley to finish the presentation.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:54:09
      I think Dusty did an excellent job going through the project, but we believe that this project is technically and operationally feasible.
    • 04:54:20
      The project costs appear to be reasonable.
    • 04:54:22
      We've compared that to some of our own estimates.
    • 04:54:26
      The final toll will result from our negotiation efforts when we begin that in Phase 2.
    • 04:54:34
      Our goal is to have a toll in the range of $1.50.
    • 04:54:42
      That's a good goal for us, but it's going to be a challenge getting to that point.
    • 04:54:47
      The ERC project costs do not include B.O.C.T.
    • 04:54:51
      costs and contingency costs, the scores that you were identifying a few minutes ago.
    • 04:54:57
      We will have to build that into our budget.
    • 04:55:01
      That number could be anywhere from 200 million or more.
    • 04:55:06
      My recommendation, I'm advancing this project to phase two of the interim agreement.
    • 04:55:16
      By doing that, we'll be able to negotiate the comprehensive agreement.
    • 04:55:20
      We'll be able to continue to develop a strategy to mitigate the project, reduce the project risk.
    • 04:55:27
      advanced project development to create a fixed price commitment that Dusty had talked about and identified additional options to reach our goal of the $1.50 on the total.
    • 04:55:43
      That's my summary, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:55:46
      I would very soon, I believe I have one more step to take care of with FHWA, and then I will be moving this to the second stage of phase two, and at that time we'll be commencing negotiations.
    • 04:56:05
      We hope to have that done in the latter part of this month, the first of June.
    • E. Dana Dickens IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:56:14
      Mr. Dickens.
    • 04:56:14
      Mr. Chairman, a couple of quick comments.
    • 04:56:17
      First, this is a must-have project for Hanson Roads.
    • 04:56:23
      That tunnel is the most heavily traveled two-lane road west of the Mississippi and is a huge, has a huge impact on the fort, which is a major economic engine in the Commonwealth of Virginia, probably the major economic engine in the Commonwealth.
    • 04:56:38
      It also has a major impact on the military, which is another huge economic engine for the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 04:56:47
      And the region has said that a goal of $1.50 is the right number for the toll.
    • 04:56:58
      And I would submit that if we can't get that $1.50, there was a number of suggestions from the Innocence Review Panel
    • 04:57:06
      This is not meant as anything other than a question.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:57:29
      Who is helping the department?
    • 04:57:32
      In the real estate business, you make the deal on the buy and it seems to me it's very important we get this right and this is an expertise that appears to be something the
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:57:54
      involved with every day.
    • 04:57:55
      So who is helping us in that regard?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:57:58
      We do have a number of people helping us on the financial side.
    • 04:58:02
      We have our KPMG.
    • 04:58:05
      That's an international firm who specializes in this type of work.
    • 04:58:11
      And they've been helping us along the way in coming to this point to move this to phase two.
    • 04:58:18
      And they will be very involved as we move into the negotiation phase.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:58:24
      And I should point out when we say they're helping us, they're helping us for a fee.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:58:30
      Right.
    • 04:58:31
      They are.
    • 04:58:31
      And we have Nosman as our legal counsel.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:58:37
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Commissioner, am I the only person who's worried about a certain inequity in a citizen from South Carolina or Tennessee
    • 04:58:51
      Having their toll doubled simply because their transponder is incompatible, and I understand Connecticut you all don't care about, but even our friend from Southwestern Virginia who would have no call to have a transponder to have their toll doubled, I sincerely believe it might be more reasonable to do something like, or once it's outside a two or three hundred mile radius,
    • 04:59:19
      to simply charge them what the toll would have been.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:59:24
      Thank you.
    • 04:59:25
      We will take a look at that, but this is going to be a very difficult issue.
    • 04:59:30
      It's an open road concept, and we do not have an opportunity to place structures in there to collect tolls if you don't have a transponder.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:59:41
      I understand that, but you have a facility that's charging double if they didn't have a transponder, so I'm saying that certain people have to be charging single if they didn't have a transponder.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 04:59:51
      Under the feasibility report, ERC has indicated that they believe that about 50 percent of the people will have transponders when it starts and after six years it will be up to 80 percent.
    • 05:00:02
      Our goal is to work very closely with ERC in our communication plan and get out in the community and get as many people as possible to have transponders.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:12
      Those people live on 100 mile range.
    • 05:00:14
      I'm talking about people who have no need to have a transponder or that one other than being there.
    • 05:00:21
      and the abject inequity in governing the toll on this.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:26
      You know, to go along with that, I mean obviously part of the negotiations and discussions would be whether, you know,
    • 05:00:34
      People can buy, if you can buy a throwaway cell phone, why couldn't you buy a throwaway transponder?
    • 05:00:44
      Those are the things you've got to look at when you go through a negotiation.
    • 05:00:47
      But I really recognize, I mean, most of the people going through here are commuters.
    • 05:00:51
      It's just what it is.
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:54
      And to follow up, Mr. Martin, there will be a lot of signage on the road to let folks know of the upcoming polls, so that will help the situation.
    • 05:01:04
      It won't prevent your concern, but it will at least help you.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:09
      Now, yeah, if they have the option to not go through there, that's mitigating it a lot.
    • 05:01:15
      That's the problem, maybe not.
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:16
      Any other questions?
    • 05:01:18
      Yes, Mr. Schwartz.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:20
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 05:01:21
      Of the $1.1 billion budget, what amount of that is anticipated to be equity rather than debt?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 05:01:34
      Right now, ERC is showing $457 million as equity, which is 24% of the project itself.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:40
      And under the agreement, that would be their responsibility to make that investment or to raise the money for that?
    • 05:01:46
      Yes, sir.
    • 05:01:46
      And where did the 14% after tax IRR come from?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 05:01:51
      That was put in ERC's base case model itself.
    • 05:01:56
      It is certainly a negotiable component.
    • 05:01:59
      What has been seen in the market in general is for a project like this with a risk potential like this one is anywhere between, I would say anywhere between 12 to 14, 15 percent.
    • 05:02:11
      But that is a negotiable component of it and our goal is to work closely with ERC to
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:17
      Mark J. Peake, Mark J. Peake, Mark J. Peake
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:34
      Mr. Chairman, I have a question.
    • 05:02:36
      Mr. Commissioner, obviously the risk mitigation is one approach to controlling costs and, you know, if you did maintenance instead of subsidizing something else, you know, so forth.
    • 05:02:49
      But what I would say is we're in the habit of thinking about economic development and economic activity, therefore public funds, that justifies expenditure of public funds.
    • 05:03:00
      The benefit of this project, however, comes back to the public sector only indirectly and fairly inefficiently through, say, taxes or fees or other things.
    • 05:03:10
      I would ask that you thoroughly investigate a way to link this more to the specific value chain that's being created right there in the region.
    • 05:03:23
      I know in Northern Virginia what we've realized is that employers already give benefits to their employees, for example, parking,
    • 05:03:29
      MetroCard, transit benefits and so forth.
    • 05:03:33
      The ability to tie this to that value chain, I think, gives you a better longer term future.
    • 05:03:38
      Employers could bundle their tunnel toll benefit with parking travel, the tide rides, transit and other expenses and benefits, and more closely capture the benefits that's actually being created for the commuter or for the employee that's actually moving.
    • 05:03:58
      That's a more direct link directly to landowners, commercial real estate, and large employers particularly.
    • 05:04:06
      But more important, given the uncertainty in the state funding system, it actually is a better link for the long term because it ties directly to the economic activity that's going to be created as opposed to who knows what we're going to be able to do with that indirect amount of money.
    • 05:04:22
      I think it also takes the pressure off
    • 05:04:25
      The idea that somehow that we'll subsidize and buy down the rate, in fact, what we're going to do is hook it up right to where the value is being created.
    • 05:04:33
      So I'd like, if you could, to really investigate that more thoroughly.
    • 05:04:37
      And then, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to say, at this point, this is one of the, both the strengths and weaknesses of our PPTA process, is that once the CTB gets a broad level of approval, we basically don't have input after that.
    • 05:04:53
      And I don't mean that we should be the experts who did the input, but clearly on these questions about ongoing subsidies and allocations of risk, those are expert decisions, but they're also policy decisions.
    • 05:05:05
      And at some point, I think we have to have some kind of
    • 05:05:08
      We have to have some kind of additional step the CTB ought to take to validate the process going forward instead of leaving our professionals out there sort of on their own.
    • 05:05:17
      Good luck.
    • 05:05:18
      Hope you come up with a good deal that works.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:05:25
      If ever there seemed to be a no-brainer project, this one is probably the best I've ever seen.
    • 05:05:30
      Still, I have to ask, how confident are you at the $1.50 toll level that you're actually going to see user use levels that justify that?
    • 05:05:44
      I mean, are you confident in the traffic projections that you're getting here?
    • 05:05:50
      Or how much confidence do you have?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:05:53
      I'll have a better feel for that once we start the negotiation process, but as I mentioned earlier, it will be a hard road getting to the $1.50, but I think it is a reasonable goal, plus the shoot for.
    • 05:06:10
      I hate not to answer your question directly.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:12
      So you don't really have the traffic and revenue projections here?
    • Gregory A. Whirley Sr.Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:15
      Well, we do have some traffic and revenue projections,
    • 05:06:19
      If you get yourself fit to go, we would have to take advantage of some of the options that you saw on the slide, and probably some others that we would have to identify.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:31
      I mean, I want to be clear, especially with my colleagues who represent that area, I think this is the kind of place where PPTA makes the most sense, and I hope you can get to a place where it also makes sense to the
    • Sean T. ConnaughtonChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:47
      and Michael A. Smith.
    • 05:07:08
      That must have been taken at like 6 a.m. on a Sunday morning.
    • 05:07:14
      I've never seen it like that.
    • 05:07:17
      I think actually when you get to see it in real life, especially during rush hour, it gives you a better idea about people I think would pay anything to get through there.
    • 05:07:32
      Board wants you to go forward.
    • 05:07:34
      I really encourage you to move.
    • 05:07:36
      I see the dates on completion of this getting to a final agreement.
    • 05:07:41
      It seems to be slipping somewhat.
    • 05:07:45
      I think you're going to know much sooner than that whether this thing can move forward and it can get a comprehensive budget and the private entity knows whether they get the financing.
    • 05:07:55
      We've already been able to move up by several months the original agreement deadlines and this will encourage you to move those other dates forward.
    • 05:08:07
      This is something that the region
    • 05:08:11
      Thanks for joining us today.