Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop Meeting 3/17/2010
Auto-scroll
Workshop Meeting
3/17/2010
Attachments
Workshop agenda.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Bids.pdf
2009-2010 snow storms report.pdf
1. Richmond Metropolitan Planning Organization
Richmond Area Metropolitan Planning Organization overview.pdf
2. Greater Lynchburg Transit Company
Greater Lynchburg Transit Co. report.pdf
3. I-64 Express
64 Express.pdf
4. Snow Response and Pothole Update
5. ARRA and Federal Update
ARRA funding project update.pdf
6. Development of the FY 2011-2016 Six Year Improvement Program
Development of the Fiscal Years 2011 - 16 Six-Year Improvement Program.pdf
7. Legislative Update
SPEAKER_08
00:00:00
Good afternoon, everyone.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:13
I would like to welcome you to this afternoon's meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:21
We're just about five minutes late, so we will start the meeting off right away.
00:00:25
I do want to wish everyone a
00:00:28
Happy St. Patrick's Day, and this would have been my mother's 88th birthday today.
00:00:36
Unfortunately, she passed away, but this was always a big day in the Connaughton household.
00:00:41
And so I couldn't think of any better way to celebrate it than having a CTB meeting.
SPEAKER_08
00:00:46
So with that, I'd like to ask everyone to please stand to say the Pledge of Allegiance.
00:00:51
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:09
Thank you all.
00:01:10
I would just want to thank the VDOT staff again on this morning's reopening of the Dinwiddie safety rest area.
00:01:23
We had the governor come out and do the ribbon cutting on that rest area as well as obviously today with the reopening of eight altogether.
00:01:33
and we only have a few more to open on April 15th.
00:01:38
I want to again thank Commissioner Whirly, Acting Commissioner Whirly, Connie Sorrell, all the VDOT staff who's out there in the field and our contractors.
00:01:49
I want to thank Jeff Caldwell for his work in setting up this morning's ceremony.
00:01:53
It was very interesting to me, and I just want to just pass this on to the CTB, that we ended up having some comments already submitted by traveling public.
00:02:05
I thought that was the most interesting thing of it all, people who were there during the soft openings of this west area.
00:02:13
And we already had just a few days, maybe about 10 or 15 comments from people.
00:02:18
Every one of them thanking us for reopening the rest stops, commenting about the fact that they were disappointed when the rest stops were closed, and appreciated that they were being reopened.
00:02:31
So I thought that was maybe the best comments at all that came out today, across other than the comments that the governor ended up saying.
00:02:40
With that, we're going to turn around.
00:02:42
We have a fairly busy work session.
00:02:44
And so I'm going to ask, this is the first of our MPOs who are coming in.
00:02:49
And this is the Richmond MPO.
00:02:51
And we have Dan Lysky, who's the executive director of the Richmond MPO.
00:02:55
We'd like to thank you, Dan, for coming in and doing a presentation about you and your priorities.
00:03:01
Thank you.
SPEAKER_05
00:03:31
Good afternoon, and thank you for providing us this opportunity to come speak to you today.
00:03:38
I'm Dan Lysy, Director of Transportation with the Richmond Regional Planning District Commission, and we also serve as the lead staff for the Richmond Area MPO.
00:03:47
And I understand, as Director Connaughton just said, that there will be others MPOs coming to talk to you later, so we will request to provide with you some background information, sort of MPO 101.
00:04:00
So I hope this will be helpful to you.
00:04:03
There's one other handout.
00:04:06
I'm sure CT members, you're very used to getting a bunch of paper in front of you, but one of those items is a map of the state of Virginia and it shows all the MPOs across the state as well as planning district.
00:04:23
So there's an MPO near you.
00:04:30
Basically, a summary of today's presentation, we're going to go over the MTS organization background, our process for planning and programming, our long-range plan and TIP, transportation improvement programs, priority projects, current studies and activities and upcoming initiatives.
00:04:53
So basically what is an MPO?
00:04:56
The MPO serves as a forum for cooperative transportation decision making in a region.
00:05:01
They were first established under the 1973 Federal Aid Highway Act and there is an MPO for all census designated urbanized areas across the country.
00:05:11
That is those areas of 50,000 or greater in population.
00:05:16
MPOs are charged under federal law to develop a regional transportation plan.
00:05:21
And they are also charged with authorizing the obligation of federal transportation funds.
00:05:27
For our region, our MPO also serves as the spokesman for our region's priority projects.
00:05:35
How is MPO organized?
00:05:38
MPOs are established under cooperative agreements by participating in state and local governments and regional agencies.
00:05:45
The MPOs voting member organizations are established by a letter of designation by the governor with the concurrence of all the area local governments.
00:05:57
MPOs operate under a memorandum of understanding and outlined in this slide are the various sections of our MOU.
00:06:07
We also have an established set of bylaws which we use for conducting meetings and taking actions.
00:06:13
This slide shows our organizational structure.
00:06:16
One of the important parts of the MPO is our advisory committees, the technical advisory
00:06:23
Thelma and the Elder and Disabled Advisory Committee, they're important in bringing the information and the programs that we have that go forward to the MPO.
00:06:36
And it's also important to note as part of our MPO process, I just mentioned that we have local governments and agencies participating in this process.
00:06:44
Thank you to our Citizens Advisory Committee CTAC and Illinois Disabled Advisory Committee.
00:06:49
We have other groups and organizations in the community that participate in the process.
00:06:55
So we're able to do some good outreach to these groups and organizations and get their input as part of our process.
00:07:04
This slide shows our voting member organizations.
00:07:08
You can see that we have a large board that involves all of our local governments and our region's transportation agencies.
00:07:16
Each local government must have
00:07:19
At least one local elected official on the board and at least half of each of their voting membership must be a local elected official.
00:07:31
What area we cover is known as the MPO study area.
00:07:35
It's the area that's currently the urbanized area plus the area that's projected to be urbanized within the next 20 years.
00:07:42
It also includes the area designated by EPA as being a non-attainment or maintenance status for air quality standards under the Clean Air Act.
00:07:52
And I believe our region is currently designated as a maintenance area for ozone air quality standards.
00:08:12
Thank you.
00:08:13
I am not very technologically capable so I appreciate this.
00:08:35
Thank you.
SPEAKER_05
00:08:38
So this slide shows the
00:08:41
The area that we currently have established is our MPO study area.
00:08:45
It's also based on Planning District 15, which their planning districts are also through coverage in Virginia, and they generally serve as staffs for most MPOs, I think the exceptions being
00:09:00
Montgomery County, Roxbury, Christiansburg, which is Montgomery County, and Northern Virginia, which is part of the Washington Council of Governments Transportation Planning Board.
00:09:17
This slide shows our planning and programming process.
00:09:23
Work conducted in our long-range plan and other planning studies that result in proposed projects and programs then go into the Six-Year Improvement Program, which the CTB is charged with approving.
00:09:41
Then when funds are allocated for projects or programs, it comes to the MPO,
00:09:46
So I'd like to talk a little bit about the two major components of our process, the long-range transportation plan and the TIP.
00:10:03
Basically, this shows what's covered in our long-range plan as a 20-year horizon.
00:10:10
It's updated every four years.
00:10:11
It's multimodal, financially constrained, considers air quality requirements.
00:10:18
It involves an environmental justice assessment to ensure that we're not discriminating against minority and low-income groups in our process, and it provides for early and continuous public involvement.
00:10:35
A major part of our long-range plan is that it must be financially constrained.
00:10:42
The current one, which is our 2031 long-range plan, was approved by the MPO in August 2008, and it's based on financial projections that VDOT developed in November 2007.
00:10:55
And you're all well aware of where revenue has gone since then, so our next long-range plan will probably be substantially reduced.
00:11:08
And this is what our current long-range plan, the one approved by the MPO in August 2008 shows.
00:11:15
We had an estimated projected funding level of $9.2 billion.
00:11:21
You count first for maintenance cost of $6.5 billion.
00:11:26
At least $2.7 billion for projects.
00:11:29
Our initial list of projects that we developed came up to $4.7 billion, so there was a $2 billion shortfall even at that time.
00:11:38
Our financially constrained long-range plan that we ended up with had 533 projects.
00:11:45
at an estimated $2.5 billion and we put other remaining projects basically in our vision list which is by no means a complete list but that came up to 166 projects and at that time when we're considering light rail or bus rapid transit we had preliminary engineering accounted for that but we didn't go beyond that so that's a significant cost that's not included.
00:12:16
So we've looked at the long-range plan.
00:12:18
This slide shows basically a bullet point or a target, the way projects proceed from the long-range plan into funds allocation and then to the TIP.
00:12:39
The Transportation Improvement Program, TIP, is a prioritized listing of projects and programs.
00:12:45
It's a four-year program.
00:12:49
It comes from projects and programs with funds allocated in the six-year improvement program.
00:12:56
And then the TIP
00:12:58
Just a little background on our TIP.
00:13:28
TIP, since they're so fluid and they represent an obligation rather than kind of a complete list of projects such as the Six-Year Improvement Program does.
00:13:41
Maybe one of the best ways to look at it is to look at the annual list of obligations.
00:13:47
And in our region for the last three years, I've put up that information.
00:13:52
In FY07, we were at $80 million actually obligated.
00:13:57
FY08, we went down to $22.2 million.
00:14:00
In FY09, we jumped back up to $64.9 million.
00:14:08
Major project that we had coming forward in FY07 and FY09 on interstate work and it also shows that we have $19.2 million in stimulus funds obligated in FY09 and we appreciate the board work that you all have done to move these projects forward for us.
00:14:32
Regional Surface Transportation Program and Congestion Mitigation Air Quality Program.
00:14:39
These two programs were begun under ICT, the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act of 1991.
00:14:51
The MPO has lead authority in allocating RSTP and CMEK funds and we provide you with that input in the six-year improvement program.
00:15:03
The RSTP funds are very flexible to cover highway and transit capital projects.
00:15:10
CMEK funds are
00:15:15
are meant for projects that are basically non-capacity, highway capacity expansion or improvement projects.
00:15:24
They're meant for covering
00:15:27
Those projects and programs that can improve air quality.
00:15:32
Also operating costs are eligible to some degree under CMAQ.
00:15:38
Ride Finders, which is our regional ride sharing agency, relies very much on CMAQ funds and it's an ongoing process.
00:15:45
And later today you'll hear about the 624 Express Marine Highway Project, which has utilized CMAQ funds for start-up purposes.
00:15:56
To give you some idea of what that entails for our region, when the program first began
00:16:08
Our latest year, fiscal year 10, we're up to about $19.4 million now.
00:16:13
In making the decision on allocating RSTP and CMEK funds, our region relies really heavily on funding existing projects first.
00:16:24
Priority is given to those projects that are ready to advance.
00:16:29
and new projects are considered last.
00:16:31
So we try to use our RSTP and CMEK funds for moving projects along and getting things done.
00:16:44
One thing that's recently happened is that we've worked with VDOT, Richmond District staff, to initiate the closeout for completed projects.
00:16:55
We've basically been going through a three-year process looking at 56 closed-out projects, and we had $5.8 million reallocated to the MPO as a result of this.
00:17:06
This is basically the funds that were remaining after these projects were closed.
00:17:11
And again, because the MPO has the lead authority in allocating
00:17:16
RSTP and CMEK funds, it's the MPA's decision on allocating those funds and we do that in cooperation with VDOT staff and advise the CTB of that as well.
00:17:27
Right now there's a pilot process being developed for the VDOT Richard District to formalize that process.
00:17:36
Another important aspect of our MPA's process is regional priority projects.
00:17:42
We annually come before you to share that list with you and we hope it helps to provide you guidance in giving you our region's priority on what's important for our region, where we would like to see funds allocated.
00:17:58
It's also been used by our local governments and agencies such as GRTC to help secure congressional earmarks.
00:18:06
Much of the funds that have gone to Main Street and Station have been through congressional earmarks and our MPO has been instrumental in helping the City of Richmond secure those funds.
00:18:17
And I'm not going to go through all this.
00:18:20
We have a list before you today of our recent priority projects.
00:18:24
But just very briefly, the current list that we have two years ago when the revenue situation was starting to turn up.
00:18:41
Make sure that previously fully funded projects remain fully funded.
00:18:46
So doing what you all can to help move those forward since they were so close at that point.
00:18:51
So that was our number one priority in their variety of projects.
00:18:56
Six projects up there now still remain.
00:19:01
Then our second through seventh priority-ranked projects are shown here.
00:19:07
And then we had a number of unranked projects that were added in 2008.
00:19:10
That's when we had adopted our long-range plan and had a recent completed mass transit study.
00:19:18
One of the significant projects on here, which I believe John Lewis came to you all last month and talked about, was the bus rapid transit project along the long-range transit plan.
00:19:30
Just, I'm getting close to wrapping up now, so to give you a little background on some of the current studies and activities that we have underway.
00:19:39
We have a wide range of transportation planning studies and work activities.
00:19:44
We have a Route 5 multimodal corridor study, which is just starting in Richmond and RICO.
00:19:51
We are finally becoming involved in
00:19:54
VDOT provides technical assistance and support.
00:20:03
I might say you all have a wonderful central office staff working for regional travel demand models and I really appreciate the help they give us.
00:20:12
They're a really good group.
00:20:14
We're developing socioeconomic data and forecasts which are a vital component for the regional travel demand model.
00:20:23
It's also extensively used by local governments and others in planning efforts.
00:20:29
We're beginning work on updating our regional bicycle and pedestrian plan.
00:20:34
We have an intermole strategies and action study that's wrapping up, and we hope to see you soon on updating on our inventory of paratransit operators in our region.
00:20:47
And one significant project that I'd like to bring to your attention that you'll hear about later today is an initiative by our NPO to establish a freight barge service on the James River.
00:20:58
Planning for this project started in November of 2007.
00:21:04
Service on this project started December 1, 2008.
00:21:07
I don't think there are too many projects that you often think of that went from conception to service in about one year's time.
00:21:15
So we're real happy with the progress and the partnership that we have with Virginia Port Authority and others in making that a reality.
00:21:24
This park service will remain terminal in Hinton Roads with the Port of Richmond.
00:21:31
It's a public-private partnership involving our MPO, Virginia Port Authority, Norfolk TUB, and the Port of Richmond Commission.
00:21:39
The project is funded with CMEK funds for three years to test and develop this program.
00:21:47
The first year service benefits is just over the year service.
00:21:52
We basically have weekly service with some additional ones during the week, which is not enough.
00:21:57
We're trying to build that.
00:21:59
But that itself has removed 6,400 trucks from the highway, an estimated 35 gallons per trip.
00:22:07
So we multiply that by 6,400.
00:22:10
And it's also a good market opportunity that we have for
00:22:16
And our project in 2009 won the American Association of MPOs National Award for Innovative Transportation Plans.
00:22:34
And I might add that it began really in about October 2009.
00:22:42
III, John T. Connaughton III, John T. Connaughton III,
00:22:59
Okay, some upcoming initiatives and staff proposals that we had in this year's work program.
00:23:07
We're partnering with Sustainable Transportation Initiatives of Richmond Group, which includes TRTC and a few others, excuse me right now, but we're trying to start a dialogue really in the Richmond area on getting more involved in sustainable transportation initiatives and efforts.
00:23:27
Part of that included us getting to ride Segways up and down the canal off, which was kind of fun.
00:23:38
Also, we're going to be looking at the Virginia Association of MPOs.
00:23:43
That is something that I think a report was just recently given to the General Assembly on that.
00:23:51
All the PDCs basically in the state are for that and it's something we would like to talk to you further about and we'll be working to try to establish that association for our state.
00:24:08
So I want to again thank you for providing us this opportunity to come talk to you today and if you'd like to address any questions.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:16
Dan, thank you very much.
00:24:16
I appreciate you being here.
SPEAKER_05
00:24:17
Are there any questions?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:20
Thank you very much for the briefing.
00:24:26
One of the things about MPOs is they work
00:24:29
out of a consensus that's built carefully over time.
00:24:33
Obviously the financial constraints that are in the system now threaten not only individual projects but potentially that consensus.
00:24:41
How are you dealing with that?
00:24:42
Are you meeting more often or are you consulting with the localities in a different way?
00:24:49
And finally are you using VDOT as you mentioned earlier as an additional resource to help you sort of work through some of those reprioritization problems?
SPEAKER_05
00:24:58
That's a good question.
00:25:02
We are not doing enough, I would say, on the end of looking at revenue sources and how to deal with the shortfall in revenues.
00:25:13
I guess we've flipped largely to the state for that.
00:25:17
I know a lot of our local governments advocate and we have
00:25:21
I think we did pass a formal action to say that there is a need for more revenue at the state level.
00:25:40
The state is the one charged with coming up with that.
00:25:44
Regional Transportation Authority has tried it and that didn't work because again their ability to, I believe,
00:25:54
It was okay to set up the transportation authorities, but there was a question on their ability to pack or come up with funds.
00:26:02
So again, it goes back again to the state being the one responsible for coming up with the revenue.
00:26:08
On the programming side of what we're dealing with, we have our program, our process set up such that projects that do have funds that are ready to move forward, we try to put what funds we have to leverage that
00:26:20
and move those projects forward.
00:26:24
We do have some of our larger local governments, for example, Chesterfield County with 295 Meadowville Interchange, I think they're able to take advantage of some partnership, transportation partnership funds through the governor's office.
00:26:41
They're, I think, making a commitment to provide some local dollars as well.
00:26:45
But those are really
00:26:48
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:04
Well, when we work through our long-range plan,
SPEAKER_05
00:27:26
Our work is largely coordinated on developing the long-range plans for our local governments.
00:27:31
So we work through what they have in their comprehensive plans to address coordination of land use and transportation.
00:27:41
So a lot of that is kind of built into the process of having their involvement.
00:27:47
One thing that I'm looking forward to is with our
00:27:52
are finally getting into looking at the regional travel demand model and having that staffing capability.
00:27:58
We really need to do some scenario planning of looking at, okay, your comprehensive plan shows that you're going to have this type of build-out or this type of development in this area.
00:28:10
Let's run that through the model.
00:28:13
We'll project what the travel patterns are.
00:28:16
And then when you see all these red lines with roads way over capacity, you may want to rethink some of your land use, but it has to be an iterative ongoing process, so that's something we're working towards.
00:28:33
The transportation land use connection is key, and we do need to be doing more in that area.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:45
We should have a couple questions.
00:28:47
I'm not familiar.
00:28:48
What is the Richmond Metropolitan Authority?
00:28:51
What do they do?
SPEAKER_05
00:28:52
The RMA is established under state code, I believe.
00:28:59
They are basically the toll road authority for the downtown expressway and the Poway Parkway up until Chippenham Parkway at which point
00:29:10
It becomes the Hawaii Parkway and it's under VDOT.
00:29:15
We kind of have several toll roads in the region area.
00:29:19
The Richmond Metropolitan Authority, other than maintaining and running those toll roads, they also run the diamonds, which is the ballpark for our area.
00:29:29
They have a couple of parking garages over the 195.
00:29:34
They have a small parking deck in
00:29:37
Kerrytown area, and they also have the Boulevard Bridge, the Nickel Bridge, which is a quadruple nickel bridge.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:48
And on behalf of the city of Richmond, they run the Main Street Station.
00:29:53
They're the general manager of Main Street Station.
00:29:57
Gotcha.
00:29:57
I'm on the board of the RNA.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:00
Are you a board member because you're over Richmond District, CTB member?
00:30:10
So is Vampo up and running or is that?
SPEAKER_05
00:30:14
No, it's still a concept.
00:30:17
There was a legislation introduced in the General Assembly session and I think the report came out in December on having the Planning District Commission and the National Capital Area Council
00:30:33
Excuse me, Transportation Planning Board, Washcock, worked together to investigate the establishment of an association of MPOs and that's something I guess that we're going to be exploring this year.
00:30:50
From our standpoint, the staff's standpoint, it's something that's really needed.
00:30:54
It's a good way to have dialogue and interaction with the design staff, DRPT staff, our MPOs and planning commissioners.
00:31:03
on just working together, working things through, and a good professional association and relationship.
00:31:12
It's something that we're working on, that all our Planning District Commissions, I should say, will be working on.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:19
Yeah, because I saw there was a reference in it, to it, in some legislation regarding a study here off in the General Assembly, but then there was nothing, it actually had in there the newly created
00:31:33
But as far as we knew, there was no such thing created yet.
SPEAKER_05
00:31:38
I don't believe it was created yet.
00:31:39
It would have to be something that once all the planning commissions get together this year, I believe, and come up with bylaws and
00:31:48
I'm not really entirely sure of the process you go about for creating such an organization, but it's something that would be created through the Planning District Commissions and then all the PDCs and MPOs would buy into.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:08
Do you know what they want to try to do with the organization then?
SPEAKER_05
00:32:12
I think it would serve as an advocate for MPOs.
00:32:16
It would serve as a forum for MPOs across the state to talk to each other about how we do things, how we can do things better.
00:32:27
It would be I think an effective way for us to interact with VDOT and
00:32:34
And I think VDOT's participation would be key in this too because you're an important partner in the MPO process.
00:32:46
It's an association that advocates on our behalf.
00:32:50
That's appropriate, I guess.
00:32:53
I guess we'll know when we get there.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:55
No, the only thing I said, and obviously one of the reasons
00:32:59
We're asking you all to come in to get us a little bit more integrated.
00:33:03
This would be my concern if the organization then ends up
00:33:11
I don't see it that way.
SPEAKER_05
00:33:22
The federal requirements are requirements, but what we want to make of it, what we want to do, how we want to work together, that's our business, and I think it's something we can all work together on.
00:33:43
Our primary funding sources are the Federal Highway Administration's PL funds.
00:33:50
PL funds are a drawdown of 1.25 percent of, I think there are about five or six various federal aid programs, interstate, equity bonus, NHS, etc.
00:34:08
And 1.25 percent of that is set aside for under Federal Highway Administration for PL funds which are distributed by formulas to MPOs.
00:34:18
We also receive
00:34:19
W. Smith, Michael A. Smith, Michael C. Smith, John C. Smith,
00:34:37
And so for you wearing your PDC hat, state funds and local funds pay for that, but for you wearing your MPO hat, it's really all federal funds.
00:35:05
Right.
00:35:07
It's basically an 80-10-10 split.
00:35:10
We have to provide 10% local match.
00:35:13
VDOT provides 10% match as well.
00:35:15
And then the 80% is either PL or 5303.
00:35:20
And we basically view ourselves as one organization.
00:35:27
We've tried.
00:35:28
We really have an integrated board in terms of our MPO board and our planning commission board that
00:35:36
There are a lot of the same people.
00:35:37
We have our PDC meeting, then they take off their PDC hat and they put their MPO hat on.
00:35:43
So we are helpful in one way.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:48
Is that unusual?
00:35:49
I'm coming from a Northern Virginia background where the PDC was very different from the MPO.
00:35:55
Is that unusual?
SPEAKER_05
00:35:56
Yeah, in Northern Virginia, their PDC is not staffed to the MPO.
00:36:03
The Washington Council government serves as the TPD Transportation Planning Board staff, so it's a little different animal there.
00:36:12
I believe in Northern Virginia with the
00:36:15
VDOT Construction District up there.
00:36:17
I think the PDC works pretty closely with them.
00:36:21
They have a transaction 2030 plan that they developed and a lot of that I think works into the PPD plan as well so there's more coordination as well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:35
You mentioned before about your priorities.
00:36:38
You gave us a handout with those.
00:36:41
Traditionally, how have you inputted those priorities into our six-year plan updates?
00:36:49
Is this simply coming to the hearing?
SPEAKER_05
00:36:53
It's primarily been through asking for the CTB for those funds.
00:36:59
Our regional surface transportation program, RSTP and CMAC funds, we don't feel are substantial enough for us to move forward on some of those projects, although we have made some effort through that.
00:37:13
But really it's a case where we say these are our region's priorities and we come ask the CTB for funding for those projects.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:23
But the only way you come in input, that input really only comes through the hearings or do we ever sit down with you on an annual basis and do that?
SPEAKER_05
00:37:34
We talk occasionally to Jerry, but it's no other real formal process other than that.
00:37:41
It probably would be better for us to have more interaction on that level than hopefully, absolutely about that.
00:37:48
No.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:50
Any other questions?
SPEAKER_08
00:37:52
Mr. Secretary, if I may?
00:37:54
Yes, yeah.
00:37:54
I think that is a very critical issue.
00:37:58
Very critical issue.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:03
Mr. Lisky, appreciate very much you being here.
00:38:05
That was great.
SPEAKER_05
00:38:05
I appreciate the opportunity.
00:38:07
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:08
I look forward to working with you.
SPEAKER_08
00:38:10
If I may make one follow-up comment, not a question for him.
00:38:15
He talked about the PIPs and the STIPs and the SYPDs and multiple different claims, and I can't even imagine how many budgets fund those multiple claims.
00:38:30
I wonder if part of the governor's initiative to
00:38:38
I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
00:39:03
I wonder if that's something we might put on our to-do list to see if there's some opportunities to simplify this a little bit.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:13
Well, if you have any ideas, you can put it down in writing to us.
SPEAKER_08
00:39:16
That'd be great.
00:39:18
Okay.
00:39:19
Duly noted.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:21
Is that a yes?
SPEAKER_05
00:39:22
In fact, do we have a motion and a second?
SPEAKER_08
00:39:25
No.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:27
No, seriously.
00:39:27
I would
00:39:29
Welcome your ideas about how we end up making these ideas about, and this is one of the reasons we're bringing them in.
00:39:36
So if you've got ways that we can potentially start to implement changes to our processes so we make sure the MPOs who are out there doing this day in, day out, that we give them a little bit more of an opportunity to work with us and just simply at the six-year plan hearings
00:39:58
I know all of our district administrators sit at the MPOs, but it's making sure that they're included in the deliberations of the CTB.
SPEAKER_04
00:40:11
I'm not going to help you with your project, but one follow-up to that is the different time.
00:40:18
One's a six-year, one's a five-year, and so I know that's a lot of the confusion that I have.
00:40:24
talking with the MPO is that which plan year are they talking about and when it's not between us and the Fed, so that's another thought.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:35
Well, in reality, they're one-year plans, either way.
00:40:41
I mean, what happens in the years three, four, five, and six are... babies.
00:40:48
...conjection.
00:40:50
Yeah.
00:40:50
I mean, that shouldn't be that big of an issue, except for the fact that I don't think they constantly update it like we do.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:58
Right.
00:40:58
That's right.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:59
Because theirs is a plan, and ours is a plan that's actually tied to numbers.
00:41:05
So it's... Is that correct, Mr. Whirley?
00:41:10
I mean, our plan, our six-year plan, really is tied and being updated constantly because we're actually putting numbers against the plan.
00:41:17
Where there is a five-year plan where there's, except for the CMAQ and RSTP money, there really is money being placed against it, which is where I think sometimes a real disconnect occurs.
00:41:32
But from at least a planning perspective, we should make sure our priorities in these different areas are there, or match up with theirs.
00:41:42
Okay, next presentation is the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company.
00:41:46
This is Michael Carroll, General Manager.
SPEAKER_02
00:41:58
Good afternoon, members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board, ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Secretary, Madam Director.
00:42:05
Thank you for inviting us today to provide you an overview of GLTC services in Lynchburg, Virginia, sort of a small snapshot of a small urban area public transportation system.
00:42:27
One of the things we did this year in response to submitting a proposal to the American Public Transportation Association was sort of a brief, hopefully this will work, a one minute video clip, sort of a 30,000 foot view of DLTC.
00:42:41
Let me try it and see if it works here.
SPEAKER_00
00:42:51
For 35 years, the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company has been providing safe, affordable, and high-quality transportation to Central Virginia residents.
00:43:00
Every day, GLTC buses serve 11 fixed routes, while seven paratransit buses help the elderly and disabled connect with the system.
00:43:09
GLTC's popular new shuttle service has helped reduce traffic congestion on the campus of Liberty University, where students have pushed the bus company's total ridership to more than 3 million boardings a year.
00:43:21
A revitalized maintenance program has reduced road service calls by 88 percent, and Lynchburg was among the first Virginia cities to use greenhouse-friendly hybrid electric buses.
00:43:32
By next year, more than half the GLTC fleet will be hybrid electric.
00:43:37
GLTC's Volunteer Board of Directors and its well-trained staff of operators and mechanics are committed to providing Central Virginia with the highest quality public transportation.
SPEAKER_02
00:43:57
That was basically, if you will, a 30,000-foot view of GLTC services, and I'm going to get us down a little closer, not in the weeds, but down to maybe about a 15,000-foot view, if you will.
00:44:07
Also joining me today, I don't know if I mentioned this, is my board chair, President Lisa Dibble, and she will probably have a few things to say, too, in this presentation.
00:44:16
We'll try to make them short, okay?
00:44:19
A little history of GLTC.
00:44:22
Like many small urban systems and also larger urban systems in the Commonwealth, we go back to the last century, 1890, when the Lynchburg Traction Company was created to establish a streetcar service in the city of Lynchburg.
00:44:35
Streetcars were operated in Lynchburg until World War II, the 1940s, and at that time they were replaced with diesel-powered or gasoline-powered rubber-tired buses.
00:44:45
They continue to operate as a private transit company, for-profit company, like many transit systems around the country until the 60s and the 70s when various demographic and regulatory and economic changes occurred at the global level and the company basically was forced into bankruptcy at that time.
00:45:04
In 1973-74 timeframe, the former private transit company advised the city of Lynchburg that they would be going bankrupt and ceasing operation.
00:45:14
The city at that time decided that mass transit was important to the citizens of Lynchburg and working together with the federal government, then the urban mass transportation program decided to seek capital funding to continue mass transit services in the city.
00:45:29
So they created a non-profit public service corporation to continue the operation of transit services.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
00:45:36
It's owned by the City of Lynchburg.
SPEAKER_02
00:45:38
It is governed by a volunteer board of directors who are appointed by city council, and Ms. Dibble is one of those members.
00:45:45
We actually employ a management firm to provide day-to-day management expertise, and I actually am an employee of First Transit.
00:45:53
Our employees in Lynchburg, like many transit systems in the Commonwealth, are actually unionized, and they are employed by a subsidiary company of the management firm.
00:46:04
They're not really direct city employees because of various state labor laws that we have, but are actually seen as contract employees to the city.
00:46:12
and in a similar fashion Alexandria, Virginia, Richmond, Virginia, and Roanoke, Virginia are organized in the same way as is Greater Lynchburg Transit Company.
00:46:23
In 2009, we celebrated our 35th year of service to the community as a public nonprofit corporation.
00:46:31
And also, as I mentioned earlier, in 2009, GLTC was named as one of three outstanding public transportation systems in North America by the American Public Transportation Association.
00:46:42
And I know this last year, this board recognized us for that achievement, and we are appreciative of that resolution.
00:46:49
So thank you very much.
00:46:51
Over the last year, we've increased transit boardings by over 20% on the fixed route side.
00:46:58
We pressed it over 3 million passenger boardings.
00:47:01
And we also saw a nearly 40% increase in paratransit service.
00:47:05
And of course, paratransit service is a specialized, if you will, origin to destination service that complements the fixed route service.
00:47:13
It's designed for those folks who have a disability.
00:47:16
who cannot use the regular fixed route service.
00:47:19
It's mandated by the Americans with Disabilities Act and is actually seen under the federal code as a civil right.
00:47:28
Our service, as mentioned in the video, really has two components anymore, the traditional city service and also the new service delivered to University.
00:47:35
Even last year, our city service saw an increase in 20% ridership to over a million passengers.
00:47:42
Our Liberty University service, which is provided under contract with Liberty University, we also saw an increase of 20% from 1.6 million to almost 2 million passing awardees and that service continues to grow.
00:47:55
We provide a very high density level of service to the campus of Liberty University.
00:47:59
They really approached us several years ago to try to address their transportation congestion problems on the campus.
00:48:06
I think when they trusted over 10,000 students, somebody finally said, you know, this idea of letting students drive their cars without any sort of restriction or restraint just isn't working anymore.
00:48:17
There's got to be a better way.
00:48:19
And that better way was public transit, including students on buses.
00:48:22
And it really has worked very well to reduce the number of car trips on the campus of the university.
SPEAKER_08
00:48:29
Very much so.
SPEAKER_02
00:48:31
The other demand is for parking on the campus and the next part of the process is to reach out into the community and expand transit services into the community to encourage students who live off campus to use public transit to get to campus again to reduce the demand for on-campus parking and also the number of single-occupant vehicle trips on the campus of the university.
00:48:53
Paratransit services and accessible services are critically important for those folks who through no fault of their own are never going to be able to drive a single occupant vehicle.
00:49:03
As I mentioned, our paratransit service boardings increased by almost 40% last year and that's been a double-digit increase for the last five, six, seven years.
00:49:13
and also we're seeing a dramatic increase of passengers boarding our fixed route service who are using mobility devices and we had over 2,300 boardings last year by folks using wheelchairs on the fixed route service.
00:49:27
Our staff has really worked hard over the last several years to address some operational concerns, really striving to make sure the service is on time to reduce interruptions to service, and I think we've done that, but we're going to continue to strive to drive those numbers down to a very smaller margin.
00:49:44
We've also been working very hard to address customer concerns and comments.
00:49:49
We addressed each one of those and I think that's reflected in the data over the last year.
00:49:53
We continue to be concerned a customer-driven, customer-focused organization.
00:49:58
Related to that is our maintenance department.
00:50:01
Maybe if you followed me several years ago, GLTC really was struggling with an old fleet at the time.
00:50:07
We had a number of maintenance concerns, and we really reinvigorated our maintenance program.
00:50:12
And that's reflected in the numbers by what are called road calls, when a mechanic has to go out and repair or fix or deal with a problem on a bus, a mechanical problem on the bus.
00:50:23
And we've really driven the number of road calls down.
00:50:25
and also really worked hard to reinvigorate our preventive maintenance program because that really is the key to driving down those road calls and improving the reliability of service.
00:50:36
We've worked real hard on financial stewardship.
00:50:39
We know that we have limited funds.
00:50:41
We've really almost doubled the service over the last three or four years, but we've not increased our administrative staff.
00:50:47
Worked very closely with the board of directors who provides oversight for my team.
00:50:52
and also worked with the Federal Transit Administration, had a successful triennial review this last year and we also eliminated a structural deficit that we had in our operating budget this last year and completed FY09 with a balanced budget.
00:51:08
I mentioned earlier in the presentation that we've been working hard to replace our fleet.
00:51:14
This summer we will retire the last of our buses that are passed through useful service life.
00:51:18
We have buses that were designed for 12 years service life that are now 15 and 16 years old that are performing daily service as I speak.
00:51:26
We will be replacing those buses this summer.
00:51:28
We've been working hard to shift over to hybrid technology in our fleet.
00:51:33
We've also been replacing our paratransit fleet, which has actually been growing because of the demand and service.
00:51:38
And again, paratransit service is mandated by the federal government, and whatever the demand is, transit systems must meet that demand.
00:51:47
We cannot plea financial hardship and deny that service to the disabled in our community.
00:51:53
Now, some of the buses we're receiving this summer, we're using ARRA funds, working closely with the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, so that's 100% federal money.
00:52:02
We have seven of those that are on order that will be delivered later in July and August of this year.
00:52:08
We've also worked very closely with the department to implement Google Maps, Google Transit to provide scheduling information and other tools to try to improve our customer focus and provide quality information to the customers to ease the transition, if you will, of using public transit.
00:52:29
This last year, too, we implemented a new computerized rosary rescheduling system.
00:52:34
This is using some capital funds to actually realize operational savings, and we were able to realize by using this computerized system in savings in payroll costs.
00:52:44
And we plowed those savings back into operations and actually restored a route that was cut at the beginning of this last fiscal year because of financial constraints that we had.
00:52:53
So we were able to take capital funding and realize operational savings, put it back on the street to provide more service to our customers.
00:53:02
And we think that's critically important.
00:53:04
Also related to our RF funding program, we're in the process of securing real-time information, so not only do you use Google Maps to schedule your transit trip in Lynchburg or anywhere in the Commonwealth, but in Lynchburg, hopefully in the next year, you'll be able to stand at a bus stop, dial in the number, and find out when that bus is coming.
00:53:23
That the next bus will be arriving in six or seven minutes or ten minutes or three minutes or whatever it is.
00:53:29
Some systems in the Commonwealth have already utilized this service and we think it's critically important to try to encourage more riders for public transportation, particularly riders of choice.
00:53:40
We've worked with the City of Lynchburg staff as well.
00:53:42
We've developed a television program.
00:53:45
So we air weekly to provide information for our customers.
00:53:51
And I must say that really our successes are due not so much to the staff and to me, but really to our employees.
00:53:59
They've worked really hard over the last year.
00:54:01
We have 91 bus drivers and paratransit operators, 22 service technicians, and only 9 members of the administrative staff.
00:54:09
So we've really put the money into service on the street.
00:54:13
Now, we had some challenges over the last year as many transitions.
00:54:18
We, I think, took maybe two steps forward in the last four or five years with the department to try to increase public transportation funding and then, bam, the recession hit us hard, all of us, and I know you're well aware of this as it impacts the transportation program in Commonwealth of Virginia.
00:54:35
It also impacts public transit providers.
00:54:37
We have been dealing with cuts in state funding for the last several years.
00:54:41
We have another one coming.
00:54:43
Hopefully, and I think at this point our city is committed to provide level funding for GLTC next year so that will minimize those cuts.
00:54:51
We look at operational efficiencies to reduce those cuts so we are very hopeful that we'll have to minimize any service reductions that we will have to do in the coming year.
00:55:00
But I just got back from a national conference in D.C., the Apple Legislative Conference, and throughout the room transit systems in the country, not just Virginia, are dealing with cuts at the state and local and even federal levels in funding, and of course that is reflected in the service on the screen.
00:55:16
It's unfortunate, but that is the economic reality apparently that we're confronting today.
00:55:22
Now we do realize that public transit provides many benefits.
00:55:25
It provides benefits obviously environmentally with a sustainable culture and sustainable goals that we have in our community today.
00:55:35
I think it's more and more important.
00:55:36
I think we're on a new reality.
00:55:39
I think the era of cheap petroleum products is over and I think transit has a critical role to play in that.
00:55:45
We also realize that public transit provides an economic boost.
00:55:48
We just recently completed an economic impact study which suggests that for every local dollar the City of Lynchburg invests in public transit we return $7 in economic growth to the community.
00:56:02
One of the things we're also doing this coming year is we have some serious facility needs and I'm going to turn it over to Lisa and she'll address those now.
SPEAKER_11
00:56:12
Well of course in doubling your service you are really not also doubling your facilities and so operations and maintenance facility is way past replacement time.
00:56:24
Also our transfer center is located on property that we do not own and the property owner has indicated that they would like for us to vacate that as soon as possible.
00:56:34
And so we've been working with them to try to find another spot.
00:56:39
But there's not enough land on the property that they own to relocate on that property.
00:56:44
So we're facing two huge projects all at one time.
00:56:49
And it's a very exciting time for us.
00:56:51
We've just concluded the first step which is our site selection process.
00:56:57
And we're very fortunate because there were a number of properties that we were able to consider for both of these.
00:57:05
And we have narrowed down and selected two, one for the transfer center and one for the operations and maintenance facility that we think will meet our needs adequately.
00:57:15
The operations and maintenance facility is located in an area that's filled with warehouses and industrial parks and would utilize a building that's been standing vacant for a number of years and it would be a good reuse of that building.
00:57:29
And because there is a building there that's acceptable, we believe,
00:57:32
for what we'd like to put there.
00:57:34
That will hold the cost down some for us.
00:57:37
The Transfer Center, we're also very excited about.
00:57:41
The land piece that bubbled to the top for that one is adjacent to the Kemper Street Station, which is where Amtrak has its facilities and Greyhound Bus also.
00:57:53
So we will have a multimodal facility.
00:57:56
And the city is very excited as well about this.
00:57:59
There's some additional land available
00:58:01
or that could be acquired next to what we're looking at that would provide additional parking because right now parking is at a premium for the Kemper Street Station.
00:58:11
I know Christian who's with us also, another board member and I rode up on the train that is new for Lynchburg, the second train from Lynchburg to DC this weekend and we're very excited about the ridership there.
00:58:25
But I know when my husband went to drop me off, I was so glad he was dropping me off and I wasn't trying to find parking places.
00:58:32
So we feel like this is a really exciting time for us at a very bad time with the economy.
00:58:39
But we're also talking with our senators and other legislators to begin to prepare them for what our financial needs will be and we're going to need everyone's support to be able to further these projects.
SPEAKER_02
00:58:54
I think that basically summarizes some of the exciting things for us that are happening in little old Lynchburg, Virginia.
00:59:02
I know if Mr. White were here today he could probably chime in with some personal information and he sent his regrets to me and I'm sorry that he was not able to join you today.
00:59:10
Again, I'd be glad to stick around if you have any questions.
00:59:13
And I'd like to make the comment that I think a lot of what you see in Lynchburg probably would be reflected in many of our transit systems throughout the Commonwealth.
00:59:21
But we appreciate the support of the CTB and look forward to working with you and certainly our partners with the Department of Rail and Public Transportation.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:30
Thank you.
00:59:30
Great.
00:59:30
That was excellent.
00:59:32
Don't go anywhere.
00:59:33
Do we have any questions?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:36
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
00:59:37
Mr. Carroll, thank you very much.
00:59:38
I have a question related to your IT services and your upgrades there.
00:59:44
Is that a set of proprietary software that's been specifically created for you or is it an off-the-shelf package that's available to transit systems?
SPEAKER_02
00:59:54
It was procured competitively.
00:59:57
There are several vendors that provide that sort of software package.
01:00:01
And we went through the competitive procurement process.
01:00:05
So it would be available to any transit system.
01:00:10
These vendors generally will try to customize it to your particular operation.
01:00:14
They had to go through and deal with a lot of various labor rules that we have to try to make sure to recap those efficiencies and still comply with the contract.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:24
Again, Mr. Chairman, in terms of procuring a location information system, is that a part of that suite of services, or are these kind of add-ons as you go?
SPEAKER_02
01:00:35
It's a little bit different animal, but we're trying to make sure that they're all talking to each other, and that's one of the requirements of the RFP.
01:00:41
Again, there's a host of vendors that provide that sort of range of services out there for the real-time information system.
01:00:48
And we're right in the process.
01:00:50
When I get back, actually, I'll be holding interviews this month with probably about five different vendors.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:56
Final question, Mr. Chairman.
01:00:58
Is that an independent procurement by you or done in combination with the city or with VITA at the state level?
SPEAKER_02
01:01:05
We try to make sure to coordinate but it ultimately is an independent procurement decision by the agency but again we consolidate or coordinate with the department and we try to make sure that when we issue an RFP that we include options for other printing systems to buy off of as well.
SPEAKER_04
01:01:24
With the new train service coming to Lynchburg, have you seen any changes in your operation or had to adjust for that working together with them?
SPEAKER_02
01:01:35
At the moment, no.
01:01:36
One of the problems is the traditional Amtrak service hours fell outside of our service span, so there wasn't a good fit.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
01:01:43
Now, the new train that was just added this last year does fall within our service span.
SPEAKER_02
01:01:47
We've not really seen any direct impact, but we think that there could be more going forward if we more closely tie ourselves to that facility at chemistry.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:01
How much funds do you receive from the state?
SPEAKER_02
01:02:06
Our operating budget is about $7 million, and I want to say that the state operating assistance we receive is in the neighborhood of about $1 million.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:18
How much do you think will go down when you mentioned?
SPEAKER_02
01:02:22
I think we were advised to expect about a 10% cut in FY11.
01:02:27
We've undergone two rounds of cuts mid-year.
01:02:30
Now this last year we had the good fortune working with the department to cushion the mid-year cut by using some of the ARRA funding which was allowed under the revision of the federal code.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:47
I'm very impressed by these numbers.
01:02:50
What is the population that's served?
01:02:52
What's the size of it?
SPEAKER_02
01:02:54
Lynchburg itself, the city of Lynchburg is about, I want to say 75,000 maybe.
01:03:00
That's probably a little high.
01:03:01
That's probably a little generous.
01:03:02
Let's say 70,000 maybe with the university, the total population.
01:03:06
The service area is probably a little broader than that, maybe about 85,000 if I remember my NPD data correctly.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:12
So you have down here about the number of
01:03:16
Actually, people getting on board.
01:03:19
So how many actual individual people is that?
SPEAKER_02
01:03:23
That I don't really have a good handle on.
01:03:27
I like to think of transit in a similar way that we count cars on the road, for example, not necessarily counting individuals behind the wheel, but moving of people.
01:03:35
So we're counting boarding.
01:03:37
So I may board a bus two or three times a day.
01:03:40
Somebody else may board five or six times a day or somebody may board once every week or something like that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:47
No, I'm just trying to think.
01:03:49
Your population isn't that big and these are very impressive numbers.
SPEAKER_02
01:03:52
Well, thank you.
01:03:54
We've had a history, I think, of having a pretty extensive transit service in Lynchburg.
01:03:59
And then, of course, with the new partnership with Liberty University, that's been a big win for us.
01:04:04
And really, that's been the most significant service expansion that I've experienced in my 15 years in Lynchburg.
01:04:10
And it was really due to the fact that Liberty stepped forward not only philosophically, but financially.
01:04:16
They have been funding the service that we've been providing to them.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:20
And we're going to ask you about this paratransit because it's something you mentioned that you required no matter what the cost is.
01:04:32
Do you have an idea?
01:04:32
How much do you spend on paratransit?
SPEAKER_02
01:04:38
I would probably say paratransit cost is about
01:04:44
I'm going to say about 5% of my total operating budget currently, but it's growing.
01:04:51
And that's been the challenge for us is to accommodate that growth.
01:04:54
We're looking at actually adding vehicles.
01:04:55
We've been adding drivers to meet the demand.
01:04:59
Paratransit service under federal law, as I understand it, is kind of like hand in glove.
01:05:03
It follows the fixed route service.
01:05:05
It follows both where it goes and when it goes.
01:05:08
And whenever the fixed route service is offered, you've got to provide the paratransit service.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:14
The director Drake and I were meeting recently and this issue came up and I was really surprised with the numbers, the growth in paratransit demand in the Commonwealth and it was fascinating about the numbers that she and her staff provided was that it was the rural areas.
01:05:36
It wasn't the Northern Virginia or Hampton Roads we saw major increases.
01:05:41
It was systems like yours.
01:05:44
and the impact it's starting to have on the finances where you're serving a limited size population but it's becoming a bigger and bigger part of your construction.
SPEAKER_02
01:05:54
One of the challenges we have in our region is we actually don't have true public transit service in some of the adjoining counties.
01:06:03
We're certainly willing to work with them and we have the legal authority to do so but it's a matter of trying to develop that relationship and work out the funding arrangements.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:13
What is the enrollment at the university?
SPEAKER_02
01:06:19
I believe it's about 11,000 actually on campus and they have a number of what they call distance learning or students participating through the internet, but on campus it's 11,000.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:30
That's what I wanted to know.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:34
Any other questions?
01:06:35
Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_08
01:06:36
We appreciate your being here.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:39
Mr. Payne, I said hello and send my regards.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:44
Thank you.
01:06:46
Let's get to the I-64 Express.
01:06:49
Mr. Keever, Jeff Keever for the Virginia Port Authority.
SPEAKER_09
01:06:53
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
01:07:01
Thank you very much.
01:07:02
I appreciate the opportunity to be here and members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
01:07:06
I want to talk about what we call the 64 Express.
01:07:11
The James River Barge Line, the 64 Express offers a cost-effective, environmentally-friendly, congestion-relieving, and reliable alternative to all truck
01:07:21
of freight shipments to and from the Port of Virginia.
01:07:24
The Port of Richmond is Central Virginia's domestic and international multi-modal freight and distribution gateway on the James River serving waterborne, rail, and truck shippers throughout the mid-Atlantic states.
01:07:37
64 Express allows direct and convenient access to shipping lines calling at the Port of Virginia.
01:07:43
And of course, the Port of Virginia is a tremendous gateway to the world, accessing the Commonwealth and the Mid-Atlantic region to the global connections across the globe.
01:07:57
This is a public-private partnership.
01:08:00
It's owned by the James L. Rabard Line and Norfolk Tug Holdings.
01:08:04
It is a green transportation solution.
01:08:06
I'm curious who wanted to talk about green initiatives on St. Patrick's Day, but we appreciate the opportunity.
01:08:12
And this is a picture of the barge moving up and down the James River.
01:08:17
This just outlines the road, the Interstate 64 connection versus traversing James River.
01:08:29
We indicate we have 12,000 truck trips that were eliminated.
01:08:32
You saw in the previous presentation by Dan, they referred to 6400 container moves.
01:08:39
That's because to get a container to or from Richmond, it's actually two truck moves to and from the port.
01:08:44
So we're really relieving congestion.
01:08:46
by double that amount and again we are emphasizing overweight and heavy containers and freight to relieve the impact on the transportation infrastructure and of course this was funded initially by the Richmond MPO which we are truly grateful.
01:09:05
The economics of this haven't quite worked out, and so that grant has allowed this to be successful.
01:09:12
We exceeded our goals in the first year.
01:09:14
It began operation December of 2008, and we were 60% above where we thought we would be at the end of the first year.
01:09:22
And of course, it was a very, very difficult year to begin any type of new operation in international trade.
01:09:29
This just gives you an overview of the Port of Virginia.
01:09:33
You know the James River is up in the upper left-hand corner.
01:09:36
These are the marine terminals.
01:09:37
Norfolk International Terminal is our largest, Portsmouth Marine Terminal, and the APM Terminal in Portsmouth.
01:09:43
The James River, the 64 Express calls it all three terminals depending on where the freight is, twice a week.
01:09:51
It has proven to be very, very effective.
01:09:54
We at the Port Authority own NIT and PMT and we have figured out ways to make the cost of this operation more effective at our facilities and have encouraged the Port of Richmond to do the same.
01:10:08
You can see that the tugs burn ultra-low sulfur fuel.
01:10:14
The operation reduces hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxide emissions and you can see the significant difference of emissions of truck versus rail and of course barge.
01:10:26
This just highlights most of the port gateways.
01:10:29
throughout the nation.
01:10:32
Virginia is well positioned going forward here in the future with a growth opportunity not only with barge service to Richmond, but you can see there's a blue line going up to Baltimore because we do have barge service up there as well.
01:10:47
And I think ultimately this Marine Highway concept takes a stronger foothold in our country as it has in Europe.
01:10:56
And we have greater opportunities serving other East Coast markets.
01:11:02
Some of the challenges we face, obviously transportation should enable trade which helps
01:11:07
of our economy grow.
01:11:09
Again, we've talked about the reduction of emissions and you can see from 1990 to 2003 greenhouse gas emissions increased more than twice that of any other sector and of course the cost of fuel has risen and of course it's increasing again.
01:11:26
A single inland vessel
01:11:30
Thelma
01:11:51
and then 413 miles for rail, so it's much more efficient on the consumption of fuel and inland transportation by water is by far the safest versus truck or rail.
01:12:04
While we call this the 64 Express, I didn't have any pictures of Interstate 64.
01:12:08
There are no hills out there yet.
01:12:10
We'd like to see that, but this is I-81 in the western part of Commonwealth.
01:12:17
Obviously, funding continues to be a difficult issue moving forward and affecting infrastructure.
01:12:25
The 64 Express provides an alternative to ship trucks from the congested highway system and to use what we think is a very effective means of moving freight to and from the Port of Virginia.
01:12:38
We're planning to begin an intra-harbor barge.
01:12:41
within the next year to shift freight from terminal to terminal.
01:12:45
There are about 5,000 trucks per year from Newport News Marine Terminal to Portsmouth and over 100,000 truck moves from NIT to Portsmouth.
01:12:55
So we think we've got the volume there to make this work.
01:12:59
It's obviously the economics of handling the box multiple times with the labor at the Marine Terminal.
01:13:05
But we hope that this barge service to Richmond could be expanded ultimately to a daily service because it simply moves the Port of Virginia 100 miles closer to Inman Market.
01:13:18
And the opportunity of turning Richmond into basically an Inman Port facility, similar to what we've had success out in the Front Royal area as an economic development tool for that area,
01:13:31
We've seen warehousing distribution grow and flourish in that area with huge private investment.
01:13:38
So we think that's the real opportunity for the region in Richmond to benefit from this and having the connectivity to global connections.
01:13:48
Obviously the Port of Richmond, I think, served its time earlier.
01:13:52
The draft restrictions getting ships up there is certainly something that James River is not going to get any deeper, and this gives you just great connectivity.
01:14:03
I'd like to highlight here the Environmental Defense Fund recognized the 64 Express in a case study recently and recognized the environmental benefits associated with this.
01:14:15
Again, in concluding,
01:14:18
I would like to highlight the opportunities for growth and new opportunities for trade in the Richmond area.
01:14:27
The intra-harbor barge is something that we, again, hope to start.
01:14:30
We're talking to some other shippers that are located on waterways, not only in Virginia, but in other states that we think we could move their freight to and from the Port of Virginia without ever getting on a city's highway.
01:14:42
It has been an economic engine.
01:14:44
Thank you for the opportunity and I hope we will continue to see this project move forward and capitalize on Virginia's Marine Highway.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:14
You mentioned also that you might use the Chesapeake Bay as well, am I correct?
SPEAKER_09
01:15:19
We currently have service up to Baltimore now.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:23
Is the Rappahannock too shallow?
01:15:26
That's not a possibility.
01:15:29
I'm just curious as to how many of those
SPEAKER_09
01:15:32
I don't think the Rappahannock is too shallow.
01:15:34
I'm not familiar with the depth right away.
01:15:37
I think that the important piece is access to larger, broader markets because getting from that area, there's not the population density there, I don't think.
01:15:51
But we're certainly interested in exploring any type of opportunities along all of the waterways in Virginia.
01:15:57
I know there was some discussion in the West Point area some time ago about an intermodal park in that area to supply by barge.
01:16:04
So we're certainly open to that.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:07
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:08
Yes, Ms. Koelemay.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:10
Thank you.
01:16:10
Ports have to be actively maintained and actively redeveloped on a regular basis.
01:16:18
What about rivers?
01:16:19
Are there any particular infrastructure issues that are related to increasing barge traffic on the James or it's just a natural highway as it is?
SPEAKER_09
01:16:28
I believe the depth of the James River currently is 22 feet and so that doesn't present a problem for these container barges.
01:16:36
But maintaining the channel depth is something that has to be considered, certainly on the Rappahannock or any of these other rivers in Virginia.
01:16:46
And then, of course, you need to have sufficient docking and berth capability as well as the cranes for that.
01:16:54
And then, of course, access, again, to the highway network.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:59
And that type of facility development at the Richmond Inn would be part of the Port Authority's responsibility as well.
SPEAKER_09
01:17:05
Well it's currently owned by the City of Richmond and we're working in partnership with them right now and right now this operation is working.
01:17:16
I think there's some possible discussions that may ultimately go in that direction but currently it is a city-owned facility.
01:17:27
Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_01
01:17:29
Yes.
01:17:30
Your handout talks about environmental benefits
01:17:35
and says the service runs at night with a lower emissions ground level zone.
01:17:43
You're not saying you run on at night, are you?
SPEAKER_09
01:17:46
This operation does run at night, but we can run during the daylight as well.
01:17:51
It just makes it more... Why do you not run through daylight?
01:17:55
Because we get the freight to Richmond for morning delivery.
01:18:00
I mean, it's just a more efficient
01:18:05
Larger ships are not allowed to transit the James River at night, only in daylight passage.
01:18:12
These barges can run at night, and again, it just makes it more efficient to have the freight available for morning delivery.
01:18:19
Just curious, in the time of transit, how long it takes to get from Richmond to the ports in Hampton Road?
01:18:24
It's between 12 and 14 hours.
01:18:27
And in the supply chain logistics, that's really something that is easily adapted to for freight.
01:18:36
I mean, obviously it's not.
01:18:37
There are some hot boxes that have to move and make a cut off, but if you plan for it in your supply chain, that's a non-issue.
01:18:46
It runs every day.
01:18:47
It does not run every day now.
01:18:49
Ultimately, we'd like to get it there.
01:18:51
Again, we're 60% ahead of where we thought we would be after the first year.
01:18:56
We have a couple of shippers that are anchor tenants, if you will, on the barge.
01:19:05
That's key to making this grow.
01:19:08
We're constantly looking at new opportunities.
01:19:13
The trucking has worked forever.
01:19:16
And if it's not broken, why do you need to fix it?
01:19:19
It's a matter of educating people and making them aware that this is a reliable service that they can count on.
01:19:27
The 64 Express has partnered with a number of trucking companies to ultimately deliver the freight to the door of these importers and exporters.
01:19:36
So over time, we believe we're going to get there, sir.
01:19:39
Thank you.
SPEAKER_08
01:19:40
Yes, the cost differential between the truck trip and the barge trip is?
01:19:45
It's competitive with trucking.
01:19:48
It's competitive with trucking.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:51
Keever, actually, so, I mean, one of the things that, I mean, here you can make a very easy comparison.
01:19:58
Look at your, like a second or third page that shows that obviously the James, for the most part, runs parallel to 64.
01:20:07
And the issue for us is trying to intercept those trucks before they start going down the peninsula and get them to drop it off here.
01:20:17
And what's sort of key to that is strengthening this relationship with the Port of Richmond here.
01:20:24
I mean, one of the things that made the Inland Port and Front Royal a success is that, I mean,
01:20:31
The truck drops it off there.
01:20:33
It essentially, it's treated as if it dropped it off at the gates at NIT or PMT.
01:20:40
Correct.
01:20:41
And we're not there yet because there's a different relationship with the Port of Richmond.
01:20:45
And if we could ever get to the point where dropping it off down here up in 95, which is just incredible.
01:20:52
I mean, you look at, you know, we were just driving down
01:20:56
I was trying to look at it, but Mr. Whirley was trying to pass me while we were driving along.
01:21:04
But, you know, you drive and you see that port, and obviously it's really underutilized right now.
01:21:10
And the question is, can we get it to the status of being like the Inland Port?
01:21:18
Trucker comes right off of 95 and drops in at that port.
01:21:22
It is as if they pulled right up and dropped off inside the gate at NIT or PMT.
SPEAKER_09
01:21:29
Absolutely.
01:21:30
I mean, the concept you describe would be one that would be very beneficial for a shipper, the trucking community, and I think the ocean carriers with seamless operation.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:44
Yeah.
01:21:44
And then, you know, obviously economic benefits for the city of Richmond and the city environment and the environmental benefits and the relief.
01:21:57
Congestion relief.
01:21:57
On the congestion relief, I mean, there's no cheaper way for us to get this type of capacity added on to a 64 or something else.
SPEAKER_09
01:22:05
Absolutely.
01:22:06
I think if you look at the private investment at the Inland Port and the number of jobs that have been created there, it's about 7,000 new jobs from distribution, warehousing, and some light manufacturing.
01:22:19
Chairman?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:20
Yes.
01:22:21
Is it at all clear to anyone yet what it would take to get to the goal that you're talking about?
01:22:28
Because some of the
01:22:29
The business at the Richmond port has declined over the last decade rather than going forward, and I think it's a great goal, but I wonder who's in charge of developing the plan to make it.
01:22:42
Is that CTB or the Port Authority or Richmond or who?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:47
Well, that's funny.
SPEAKER_09
01:22:48
I think that was directed at you, sir.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:51
Did I just open a can of worms or something?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:53
No, no you haven't.
01:22:56
There's only right now, other than this barge service, there's only a bi-weekly stop by a small shipping company going up to Iceland.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:13
I think that's it now.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:16
And we think it's beneficial to the city and then to the state for a whole host of reasons we just talked about if we can strengthen the relationship with that port.
01:23:31
I happen to be meeting with the executive director of the port this week, and then I'm planning on going to meet with the mayor as well.
01:23:47
It may be useful if you'd like to participate in those discussions.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:52
If I can, I will.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:54
Mr. Chairman, it occurs to me that one of the reasons that the people would use the barge would be if there was an advantage in the rates.
01:24:04
And what I heard him say is that it was competitive and that the time frame for delivery is somewhat longer.
01:24:12
So I don't know that the incentive on the rates to make, you could buy gasoline, you check the price.
01:24:18
And so similarly here, if you're going to buy our service, you check the price.
01:24:23
Is that something that
01:24:24
I don't think the rates are that big of a difference.
SPEAKER_09
01:24:36
It's a matter of convincing a shipper that they just need to add another day into their logistics chamber.
01:24:45
Once they've overcome that hurdle and we're doing it sort of one company at a time and it's a
01:24:53
It's a very challenging undertaking to say the least.
01:24:56
Just changing the, again, this is supported with a grant and to reduce the rate even more means we're burning through the grant money a lot faster.
01:25:05
So we need to be very cautious about the pricing of it because we want that grant to last us through the cycle that it's intended for.
01:25:12
So we're being very cautious about that idea.
01:25:16
A greater buy-in by the ocean carriers that the Secretary I think is alluding to with sort of the bigger picture of this would I think ease that issue that you raised, sir.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:27
Yeah, and I think also a critical difference would be it's one thing if it's we're looking at the truck to the barge to the port, but if the truckers and the shippers act
01:25:44
I mean dropping it at the Port of Richmond was as if they came up to Norfolk.
01:25:50
We then would be the ones who would be assuming the cost.
01:25:55
If you want to look at it that way, it's part of the bigger transportation costs.
01:25:59
And so that's a big difference.
01:26:01
And again, I think most truckers and carriers, the sooner they can drop that box off into Mr. Keever's hands, the better it is for them because they just turn it and move someplace else.
01:26:16
But there are issues with this.
01:26:18
But I mean, our biggest thing is for right now, and we are putting some money into the service right now.
01:26:24
I forget how much we know.
01:26:27
Mr. Keever, do you know how much?
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
01:26:29
I think it's 2.3 million for a three-year commitment.
SPEAKER_09
01:26:35
I thought the state put in either 400,000 and 500,000.
01:26:38
I think it was 400,000.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:41
You know, right now you've seen an enormous success.
01:26:43
I mean, if you just look at such a bad economy, you've already had this many, quote-unquote, truck trips avoided on 64.
01:26:51
Right.
01:26:52
The question is that, I mean, this is probably
01:26:55
From a transportation perspective, probably it's a heck of a lot cheaper than adding a lane mile.
01:27:01
And then you get all these other benefits with this, environmental benefits, and then potentially economic development benefits for the city of Richmond and the central region.
01:27:15
So it's just some things we have to think about.
01:27:20
I just want to start having this conversation with the city.
01:27:27
I think there are some opportunities.
01:27:29
Thank you for presenting this to us.
01:27:36
That was very interesting.
SPEAKER_08
01:27:43
And I just wanted to point out that it's another example of how the Port of Virginia impacts the rest of the Commonwealth of Virginia.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:55
Is the Port here in the city
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:58
I don't know, but I would assume, I don't know what the finances are, but it's an extremis when you look at the fact that this is a downturn in the number of companies serving here.
01:28:20
Ms. Keever, do you know?
SPEAKER_09
01:28:21
I think with the loss of the ocean carrier service earlier this past year, they have a new operator in Richmond currently, and then this small Icelandic carrier.
01:28:35
I think it's a negative cash flow there, but you may find out about that more later in your meeting.
01:28:41
But we have not been involved in the operations of it at all.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:48
Other Port, actually in the Commonwealth, right or no?
01:28:52
Yes, sir.
01:28:55
This is a private, I mean, it's a few private facilities, but this is the only one that, as far as I'm aware, that is actually still owned by a city or, yeah.
01:29:05
And if there's ways we can all benefit from this, I think this is a good opportunity.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:11
Mr. Chairman, it reminds me a little bit of the fact that a lot of municipalities used to operate power plants.
01:29:17
Yeah.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:18
Any other questions?
SPEAKER_08
01:29:25
Thank you very much.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:28
Okay, Ms. Sorrell, let's talk about snow response and potholes.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:29:37
Well, the good news is we've filled over 55,000 potholes as of today.
01:29:42
Excellent.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:42
You know, I'll tell you something.
01:29:43
I was joking with somebody that my new title is not Secretary of Transportation.
01:29:48
It's been changed from Secretary of Transportation to the P3 Secretary.
01:29:52
That's plows, potholes, and potties.
SPEAKER_08
01:29:55
It's hard to talk about snow when the weather is as beautiful as it is outside today.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:30:20
I'm going to give it a shot.
01:30:22
Hopefully this will be short and sweet.
01:30:25
Please feel free to ask any questions.
01:30:27
I want to talk just a minute about the weather report.
01:30:30
Help you remember the four major snow storms we had.
01:30:34
A little bit about some traveler information and what we've done to try and communicate to the public about those things and what kind of service we're providing.
01:30:41
A little bit about our budget expenses to date in responding to snow and then a couple things on pothole patching, which is what we're vigorously involved in today.
01:30:53
And just touch on the after action reviews we're doing to see how we can be better.
01:30:59
I've got a few pictures scattered in here of some places like Charlottesville, Loudoun County.
01:31:07
You might find interesting in the background floating around.
01:31:11
This is one of our storage facilities domed with salt.
01:31:16
Between December and February, we had four major snow storms.
01:31:21
December 18th, 19th, January 29th.
01:31:24
Two big ones in February, one right behind the other.
01:31:29
In addition to that, it's been snowing since November in Highland County.
01:31:34
And I think it stopped snowing there today.
01:31:36
But I do remember some time ago back in March, we had a 24 inch snowstorm in March in Northern Virginia, not too many long years ago.
01:31:45
So knock on wood, here's hoping that we'll get through the rest of the season without having any more.
01:31:51
Just to give you an idea of some of the totals of snow around the state of Virginia back in December.
01:31:59
Lynchburg, Nelson County, 30 inches.
01:32:02
Salem, Botantot County, 30 inches.
01:32:04
Culpeper, Madison County, 23 inches plus.
01:32:10
Move on to the January storm.
01:32:12
There are a few pictures from Route 29 out in the Charlottesville area.
01:32:17
You can see, just for the fun of it, we had the snow forecast.
01:32:21
The forecasters that worked for us got pretty close, although in Stanton it looked like they were hedging their bets.
01:32:27
They forecast one to eight, we got six to nine.
01:32:30
Dr. Davis for you.
01:32:32
About 12 inches, not horrible.
01:32:40
February, things start getting a little worse again.
01:32:44
The forecast was for 16 to 22 inches in Culpeper, and we got up to 32 inches in some areas.
01:32:51
In Northern Virginia, the forecast was up to 22 inches, and we got 34 inches.
01:32:57
Fredericksburg even got 14, so you can see.
01:32:59
Down in Bristol, they missed it a little bit.
01:33:03
They said we might have 4 inches.
01:33:04
We actually got anywhere from a trace to 14 inches.
01:33:08
That picture in the background is a snowplow out in Loudoun County that was, I think it was a snowblower that was actually borrowed from the Salem District to help move some of the very deep snow.
01:33:23
The February 11th snow, as you can see, I'm going to just point out Northern Virginia, another 13 inches.
01:33:31
In some areas in Northern Virginia, we got actually 40 inches of snow in a five-day period.
01:33:38
It was a rather mammoth task, to say the least, to move some of that.
01:33:44
Here's one of our employees out in Loudoun County.
01:33:48
That was one storm.
01:33:50
Then after the second storm and some high winds and big drifts.
01:33:55
We've had drifts in excess of 15 feet in some areas, trying to get some places open.
01:34:01
Delivered a baby or two and dug out a lot of people and lots of other heroics from our employees.
01:34:08
So the total is for all four stores.
01:34:13
Stanton won the prize with 77 inches.
01:34:17
And Northern Virginia was right in there at 74 inches.
01:34:21
And in the Northern Virginia area, the greater Washington metropolitan area, I think the accumulations at this time up to that point, in 1898-99 the record for accumulations was 62 inches.
01:34:36
So that gives you sort of a magnitude of kind of winter we've had.
01:34:39
This was a century storm or century winter in terms of the total accumulations of snow we've had in the area.
01:34:47
And so these are just a few of the days we keep track of all the calls, not only the 511, but to our highway hotline.
01:34:56
And you can see on some of those days in December, on the 19th and 20th, the calls jumped up to more than 60,000 calls on one day, 55,000 another day.
01:35:08
So we were answering a tremendous number of calls from citizens wanting to know if it was safe to travel, asking information about conditions of roadways is primarily what people call about.
01:35:20
And then we do have some people calling us letting us know about crashes or incidents or road blockages that help us.
01:35:27
And you can see in the rest of the storms we had anywhere from a low day of about 4,000 people calling to as many as 12, 13, 14,000 people in a day.
01:35:38
This is a representation of what each district has for their snow budget for the year.
01:35:47
We usually set snow budgets on about three to five year average for how much and as you can imagine we've had some very mild winters over the last several years so we had budgeted just under 80 million dollars for snow and to date
01:36:00
Ms. Busher says she's not opening the emails I sent to her anymore about what today's number was, and I have to tell her it's painful for me to answer those.
01:36:23
Intently working with the district and the central office staff to comb through all of our budget to see what we're going to do to cover these costs between now and the end of the fiscal year.
01:36:37
And the next slide is on to the screen and March may come in like a line and go out
01:36:45
It's like a lamb, but right now we're heavily working on pothole patching, and that's a picture of one of the pieces of equipment that's known as the pothole killer.
01:36:56
Our friends at Dominion Patching and Stealing own that particular piece.
01:37:01
We have a few of them, and some of our TAMS contractors, we own or lease them.
01:37:05
And so we've had, well this number says 43, but actually today's count is 55,000 plus.
01:37:15
And there's the latest slide on the number of just over 10,000 on the interstate, 13, almost 14,000 on the primary and over 30,000 on the secondary that have been filled today.
01:37:26
And we have lots more to fill.
01:37:28
The good news is as soon as April comes and the weather gets warm enough, we'll have our regular paving schedule going to work and doing permanent repairs.
01:37:41
for many of the roads, many miles of the Commonwealth that will finish off the pothole patching blitz.
01:37:48
So I just wanted to talk for a minute.
01:37:51
We do have extensive after action reviews.
01:37:55
These are some pictures in a Fairfax County subdivision that we took one day.
01:38:03
I believe when the secretary was up visiting some of our work forces.
01:38:07
And these are some of the categories that we look at.
01:38:11
Obviously we look at communications internally and externally, how well we're communicating with the public about what's passable and what's not passable, what the driving conditions are, as well as our internal communications within VDOT and with our contractors.
01:38:26
We also look at materials.
01:38:27
We had quite an issue this year with salt, where the salt suppliers actually were rationing the amount of salt we could get any one day, and we were doing a lot of moving of salt from one area to another to make sure that everybody had enough salt.
01:38:43
to get through the next storm and trying to get replenished.
01:38:46
So those were some major things that took up our time in terms of managing the snow.
01:38:53
Equipment was another challenge.
01:38:55
You can imagine with snow this heavy and this deep, we had a lot of equipment issues and everything from just having enough chains for tires.
01:39:03
to hydraulic pumps, just not having enough hydraulic pumps that were breaking because of the heavy use that they were getting and some of our other equipment challenges and getting equipment repaired.
01:39:17
Pam's contractors, we were working very extensively with them.
01:39:21
Obviously, they had some challenges in some areas for some of the storms in clearing some of the major interstates and we actually stepped in and helped them with some of their work.
01:39:34
We also had crashes and incidents that created problems.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:40
Do we have a process whereby under that TAMS contract we get some reimbursement for that?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:39:46
Yes sir.
01:39:48
We do have a way to recover our cost and then there are provisions in the contract related to performance so if they don't meet the performance standard we have a way to deduct from their payments for our cost as well as performance which we are in the process of doing in some contracts.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:07
I think there's probably a little bit of a lesson for us in what happened in December and January as far as snow removal is that those contracts will not actually totally fulfill the need and VDOT is going to have to step in on occasion as they had to do in the Stanton District and some other areas or those roads will not be cleared under the contract.
01:40:36
I hope we'll take a look at that and be sure that we're prepared when it reaches a certain point that there is an automatic kick in for that support because I know out in the area they couldn't deal with us on several occasions.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:40:53
We do have that and we've also been reviewing that to see how we can even do that better and also potential contract changes.
01:41:00
So we're looking at the point, the whole point of these after action reviews is to go down through and in fact we've talked with the state police.
01:41:07
I was going to mention them in our partnerships.
01:41:09
So obviously when we do have bad weather and we have crashes and incidents, the faster we can get them cleared.
01:41:16
the easier it is for snowplows to move and to be able to keep the roads clear.
01:41:21
We actually had some bad situations on 81, I'm sure you recall.
01:41:27
Duty officers is a reference just to our own command and control structure of how we manage our crews and the whole process.
01:41:34
Last but not least, we do have a lot of partnerships with state and local agencies from the Virginia Department of Emergency Management to the state police who are tremendous partners for us, probably our two top partners.
01:41:47
And we had an extensive after action briefing with all the captains of all the divisions of state police and their management in terms of looking at how we can strengthen our partnerships.
01:42:00
And we have an excellent one with them and we're going to just continue building on it.
01:42:05
So there are a number of issues.
01:42:08
I won't go through all the details, but I just wanted to let you know that we certainly have done this.
01:42:12
In summary, this was the worst winter in a century.
01:42:23
It took many creative actions by our employees and our contractors to fight these storms and we worked with VDM, VSP, the Virginia National Guard and local governments in responding and so we have spent quite an extensive amount of money and the December storm was declared by FEMA as well as the other storms were.
01:42:48
So all together we have probably close to $100 million we're looking at in hopes of being able to seek some reimbursement from FEMA for the four storms, but we probably won't see that until at least next fiscal year.
01:43:06
We hope that there's no more winter weather in store through the end of the month, but if there is, we're ready.
SPEAKER_04
01:43:13
Comment about materials, and that is I know after the storms there was a large outcrop in the public about the potholes and an effort was made to get them filled quickly.
01:43:27
Exactly in Hampton Roads, you had every TV station out there following you guys around.
01:43:31
But the cold patch, which is one thing you can't apply in certain temperatures, has caused some issues on the interstates, particularly where you have higher speeds.
01:43:42
because it doesn't adhere and it's caused some of the rocks or the parts to come up and actually hit cars during all this.
01:43:49
So I'm wondering if there's a review of how we can better, you know, whether it's not simply bending to public outcry to get something done or if there's a better material because it really did cause dangerous conditions.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:44:01
Yes, we are always looking for new and better products.
01:44:07
And one of the things we're always doing is balancing the product and the cost of the product against what we have to work with.
01:44:16
So particularly in the Tidewater area, pothole patching is particularly difficult because of the old concrete pavements.
01:44:26
And so they just don't last but so long, particularly when there's a very high volume of tractor-trailer truck traffic.
01:44:33
So that's something that we have to really keep after and that's something we'll be reviewing with our TAMS contractor who works on the interstate in that area, definitely.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:44:45
Ms. Carter.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:44:47
As the old story goes, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
01:44:49
You ain't through yet.
01:44:53
I was out with the Braceburg DA yesterday, and of course we were starting in Northern Virginia, and then we came on the staff at our venue at Colonial Beach.
01:45:02
And the trees that are down, tremendously.
01:45:07
And so we have to bear the expense of removing them, am I correct?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:45:14
You are, I didn't mention this but in the first storm in December down in the Bristol District we had basically almost some tornado kinds of conditions and I think there was over five million dollars worth of debris work.
01:45:27
for downed trees as a part of that very first storm.
01:45:30
And we've had some enormous tree damage in Fredericksburg, Culpeper, the western part of Richmond, and some other places around the state that add to the snow cost.
01:45:41
Absolutely.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:45:42
Yes.
01:45:43
And you know, we don't see that all the time when I think about the cost.
01:45:48
You think about the cost of removing the snow, but it's the aftermath.
01:45:52
That's so tremendously accost to us like that.
01:45:56
And I also would like to say that the reason we were in Northern Virginia, during the snowstorm and I was watching TV
01:46:05
And I saw the call centers of whatever.
01:46:09
And I was just amazed.
01:46:11
I was amazed at what was happening.
01:46:14
And so I stated to the First Ward DA, I want to visit that.
01:46:18
I want to see.
01:46:19
And I think it was certainly
01:46:22
It would be a great opportunity if we could sometimes take a trip with the CTB to visit that area when you could have the VDOT in the same building and then you have the state police and you have 9-1-1 and it's all working together.
01:46:40
I was just amazed and it's wonderful and I said to Mr. Elliott, you know, in some localities there's a CIT
01:46:50
to build new buildings for maybe the Sheriff's Department, et cetera.
01:46:54
And I think that it would certainly be an opportunity that maybe we could go in and combine some of these areas that we need to look at and that we could work more closely together with something of this sort.
01:47:10
It's a wonderful setup that they have.
01:47:13
As I stated, I was amazed.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:15
It was great.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:47:17
Fairfax County, you're talking about the McDonald Public Safety Transportation Operations Center which was a joint project between VDOT and Fairfax County and I believe Fairfax County Industrial Development Authority actually built the building and are helping to pay it through fees.
01:47:36
It was a tremendous, it is a tremendous partnership.
01:47:38
So you have fire and rescue from Fairfax County.
01:47:41
State Police, local government, and the VDOT all in that same building on the same operating floor.
01:47:50
So it's a fabulous facility for emergency operations for the Northern Virginia region.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:57
Yes.
01:47:58
And I'll tell you how dumb I am.
01:48:00
But anyway, I went in one room, there was no one there.
01:48:03
But it had all these whatever jackets, you know, that they put on and certain.
01:48:09
And I looked and it said, planning.
01:48:11
Well, of course, me, you know, in local government, planning was planning.
01:48:15
Why are you going to build your next subdivision?
01:48:17
I said, what in the world are we doing with planning there?
01:48:21
All of these people come together during that time.
01:48:24
and they planned out their strategy in other areas.
01:48:27
It's just amazing.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:28
It's wonderful.
01:48:29
It's a very impressive facility.
01:48:30
Absolutely.
01:48:31
Yeah, the secretary has been there.
01:48:32
Maybe when we have our Northern Virginia hearing.
SPEAKER_08
01:48:36
It's not too far, but we're going to have May 26th.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:40
The six-year plan?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:48:41
Yes.
01:48:41
In fact, the new district office building, which is going up, is right across the street.
01:48:45
Yeah.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:45
Well, maybe we can end up gliding everything.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:48:48
Yes.
01:48:48
It would be a great tour for Northern Virginia.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:50
Any other questions?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:53
Just a quick comment, Mr. Chairman.
01:48:56
At the end of the second day in my neighborhood of the first storm when a plow showed up, people were out shoveling and there was spontaneous applause.
01:49:06
And it was pretty good.
01:49:06
The driver wasn't totally coming to us by the time, so he actually waved.
01:49:11
It was wonderful.
01:49:13
But really what I was impressed with was we couldn't, there was so much snow we couldn't simply shove it aside.
01:49:18
It had to be taken out of the area.
01:49:21
And the redeployment of equipment and manpower from other parts of the state to do that was tremendous.
01:49:28
I mean, it would have shut us down for another several days if that hadn't happened.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:49:31
It was the largest scale redeployment of equipment we've ever done in my 25 years here.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:35
And I appreciate that.
01:49:36
And I think people understood that this was an extraordinary effort that VDOT was making at the time.
01:49:42
And it was very much appreciated.
01:49:44
I know that you're getting the specific and detailed comments from the jurisdictions about what else could have been done.
01:49:50
But the final thing was the way the ice had built up on some roads and it was difficult to get off.
01:49:57
You could really bounce in a few places and my daughter came up with the phrase here in the Olympics, it was mogul driving.
01:50:04
And if you're familiar with that, it's a really small thing.
01:50:07
But you all did a great job and I think it taught Northern Virginia
01:50:10
and other parts of the state, several lessons, which is we do need to have the overflow capacity.
01:50:17
You can't short investments in this area or capabilities.
01:50:22
I think if you run the cost-benefit analysis, it's huge.
01:50:25
The cost of shutting down business industry, the federal government, on and on.
01:50:30
So I hope
01:50:31
I hope it's helped us reconnect transportation with all the other things that we do, that it's not a separate thing, it's an essential part of all those things, and it showed again in this case.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:44
Is there any other questions?
01:50:46
Okay, well I've got a few.
01:50:49
First off, I think VDOT did a great job.
01:50:55
I mean, essentially you had four storms, two major ones in
01:51:02
in 10 days, particularly hitting some of the most populous areas of the state.
01:51:08
It was just incredible, the response.
01:51:12
In fact, it was interesting, the Rasmussen runs a poll, and they did a poll of what people think about the
01:51:19
The state's response, they did a poll in Virginia with the state's response to snowstorms and 64% of the people responded and said good or great, which I think says a lot about the hard work of the VDOT and the folks that they have contracted for.
01:51:38
The one thing I do want to raise, and I've asked Mr. Whirley to look at this, some localities were not completely satisfied with some of the subdivision work.
01:51:53
And given that we've seen this tremendous spike this year in the cost, I think it might provide an opportunity for us to offer to those localities if they want to
01:52:06
Take over our contracts.
01:52:11
And I don't mean this facetiously.
01:52:14
I do mean that they want to where we can act like the TAMS contractors and say we're going to give you a million dollars a year.
01:52:21
This is whatever our budget was going to be for your locality during that time period.
01:52:26
And for the most part, you're going to probably come in below that.
01:52:30
But there's going to be years like this when you're going to be above.
01:52:32
If you want to control your snow removal, I think we should give them the opportunity to control their snow removal.
01:52:41
And essentially, in my mind, it would be no loss to us.
01:52:46
And it would make it easier for us to budget because we simply say, to a Fairfax, we're going to put a million or two million or five million a year.
01:52:55
If it comes in below that, you get to keep it and use it for other transportation related activities.
01:53:03
If it's above it, then you pay for it.
01:53:06
So I think this is something we should be exploring with all the localities that are showing a great interest in snow removal in their areas.
SPEAKER_08
01:53:14
I'd wait a year to ask him.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:22
I want to give them the opportunity.
01:53:25
I'm fascinated about potholes.
01:53:28
What is happening in Stanton?
01:53:31
Is Dr. Davis out there personally putting these in?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:35
The condition of the pavement and the secondary roads especially, if you looked at the number of potholes in the secondary road system,
01:53:43
And it's going to get worse, I'm sorry.
01:53:44
They're coming apart.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:53:50
Yeah, obviously some of this reporting is still coming in and it is something of an estimate, but we don't have a performance standard for secondary payments because we haven't been able to really afford the
01:54:08
thinking we could meet it, but secondary pavements now statewide are 31% deficient.
01:54:14
In some regions of the state, it's much more than that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:17
I mean, it's just dramatic, 13,000.
01:54:19
I mean, here is Nova.
01:54:23
I can't believe, I mean it's only 3,000.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:25
Mr. Chairman, if you like, it's also the cost of the snow removal for the 72 inches in the Stanton District compared to the 70 inches in the Northern Virginia area.
01:54:34
If you look, the Northern Virginia's graph is here, Stanton is the cost is here.
01:54:39
It's the difference in subdivisions versus secondary roads and whatever.
01:54:44
Although some of those are classified secondary roads and urban secondary roads.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:54:48
We may just not have all the Northern Virginia numbers then.
01:54:52
We just got the numbers that we had reported to us and we still have some to get in.
01:54:59
But it's a good snapshot in time of where we are.
01:55:03
Of course, remember there are only three or four counties in Northern Virginia District and there are 14 or 15 counties in Stanton District.
01:55:12
So there's a tremendous difference in the secondary road mileage that has much higher traffic volumes on it.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:55:18
You also have greater fluctuations in temperatures out in the Stanton District than you do because it's right along the ridge of the mountains.
01:55:26
The reason they had that variation for predicting snow
01:55:30
It's because we're right on the edge of the snow line for the Allegheny Mountains, and if it comes across the mountain, we get a bunch.
01:55:39
If it hits the mountain and stops, it stays on the other side, and it's really hard to tell what's going to happen.
SPEAKER_04
01:55:45
I was just going to mention the way the roads are scraped are also a component of why we have potholes, because some contractors who, any hole you put is going to cause a hole later.
01:56:00
And when they come down and scrape and if they hit and pop some of that cement or concrete to start with, it causes the mud.
01:56:08
And we had some of those issues in Hampton Roads where the scraping itself and the second storms came caused issues.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:56:16
Now once you have ice bonding to the pavement and you go in and you try and you need a motor grader to cut it off, it can cause some damage particularly in secondary roads.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:56:27
Mr. Chairman, I know we're in a very difficult position with funding, but on this secondary road issue, we know that we have a coming, a huge crisis in secondary road maintenance because of the decisions we made.
01:56:40
We, I didn't like it, but we made those decisions to not fund secondary roads basically going forward.
01:56:49
And so it's really, I think it's going to become a crisis.
01:56:54
I think that's just one example that's possible.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:56:57
I have a question, Connie, and maybe Secretary as well.
01:57:05
Obviously, that's a much bigger number than we had budgeted for.
01:57:09
What are the options?
01:57:10
I mean, does the CTB need to come back now and make a different decision about resource allocations, or will that be included in a broader budget review, or is it just coming out of the same set of accounts and we're going to figure out not to do something else later?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:57:27
We think we're probably coming back in May with some amendments for the budget to address the issues for the old ones and the small ones.
01:57:37
So probably May in the May meeting.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:57:40
And we should bring our lawnmowers then.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:57:44
We are looking at everything that we possibly can in terms of what we can do to identify savings and deferred costs to balance the year.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:57:57
And the thing is, too, is that because we're going to get, I think the federal government will potentially give us back 75 percent.
01:58:06
Is that what the number is?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:58:07
Yes, we could get...
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:09
So we may get, at the beginning of this new year, take it in the shorts.
01:58:13
At the end, we may end up getting a lump of cash.
01:58:16
So the question is, is that just
01:58:18
I mean, we've got to work very diligently to get the feds to at least commit that we're going to get the money so we can plan for it.
01:58:27
But I mean, we have the potential that you're going to see $75 million or $80 million actually, maybe more than that, probably $90 million potentially coming back in.
01:58:40
And we're not quite sure.
01:58:43
The number you have there may not be the final number either, right?
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
01:58:45
No, it's not.
01:58:46
It's not.
01:58:48
Unfortunately, it's not.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:52
It's always good news seeing you.
SPEAKER_08
01:58:54
Thank you so much, Mr. Secretary.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:58
There's one last thing.
01:58:59
That's an after-action issue.
01:59:01
To come back to something Dr. Davis mentioned, it is, I think, would be prudent for us
01:59:10
Not specifically in these afteractions, but I do think, Mr. Whirley, I'm looking at you and Ms. Sorrell.
01:59:18
What is the, I'm going to say, latent in-house capability that we need to maintain to ensure that we always have the ability to fill in and respond?
01:59:36
Because sometimes I do think you're correct, Dr. Davis.
01:59:38
People in Ms. Koelemay and Ms. Dickens all mentioned this before, that VDOT is an emergency responder.
01:59:48
Whether it's snow or flooding or other types of natural man-made disasters that we need to understand.
01:59:56
And I've never actually seen us articulate what is the minimum manning staffing that we need and capability to provide those types of emergency response functions.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:00:09
Mr. Chairman, we spent quite a bit of time looking at that when we were reducing residencies and providing equipment and whatever.
02:00:17
And we listened in public hearings up in the Stanton District, I know, to a lot of the areas over along the mountain in Highland County and places where it snows about four or five months of the year, that they honestly felt that we had to keep equipment right in those areas in order to be able to get it there to deal with the problems a lot of times.
02:00:34
And I think a lot of good decisions were made to try to position
02:00:38
So that we could at least get equipment to the crisis, and that's true in the Bristol District too probably.
02:00:45
That if you don't have equipment and people in the area, they can't actually deal with it because they can't get there.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:00:54
Well I think one of the things that came out
02:00:58
And will we actually have a comprehensive interaction?
02:01:01
Because I think that would be useful for us to take a look at.
02:01:04
I mean, one of the things that, you know, I'm aware of, and I spoke to Mr. Whirley about, and he, you know, chatted about this was, you know, this number of monitors for, sorry, Northern Virginia, where we do use a lot of contractors.
02:01:16
Well, that does mean that we have to monitor them.
02:01:19
and the numbers of in-house personnel needed to do that, not to actually do the response, but at least to make sure that the people we hired did the response.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
02:01:27
Well, in the Northern Virginia District, for example, we would use right-of-way agents, materials engineers, location and design engineers, survey party people.
02:01:36
We use every person that is there in the district office to help fulfill some of those requirements during the winter.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:45
In fact, I was impressed when I went up and met with people at the residency in some of the area.
02:01:51
Everybody was in.
02:01:52
Everyone was doing.
02:01:53
It didn't matter what your job was.
02:01:55
If you were a VDOT employee, you were working the storms in some capability.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
02:02:01
Yes.
02:02:01
There were some of our own people, just as a note, who worked 77 days in a row, 12-hour shifts.
02:02:09
They're a very dedicated group, so they deserve our thanks.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:02:15
Great job.
02:02:15
And I will mention that the Governor is very appreciative of the work.
02:02:22
On Friday, Monday, he's going to come over and meet with some of the crews and all.
02:02:28
He wanted to come over and personally say thanks to people.
02:02:31
So we're going to be bringing people in from the different districts to meet with the Governor and to let him say thank you personally.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
02:02:40
We thank you for all the support.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:02:42
Mr. Chairman, Ms. Sorrell, I certainly add my thanks and congratulations and thank goodness we still have enough people to do the job that's assigned to us because in the last analysis we are an emergency response team and when the weather is nice and we don't have storms the contractors make money and they stay in business and they can do their job but when push comes to shove I think part of our
02:03:08
Analysis is going to show that they were not up to the job.
02:03:11
And I think if that's the case, we need to know why and what it would take to have them be up to the job.
02:03:18
And if that can't be done profitably, then who knows where that leads.
02:03:22
But I do think the whole concept needs a bit of reevaluation and discussion because we really didn't discuss this whole idea.
02:03:31
This was forced upon the board several years ago, as I recall.
02:03:36
And I don't know whether any study went into this way of doing things.
02:03:41
And maybe now that we have a little experience with it, pro and con, I'm hoping we will see something before this gets too stale, maybe before the end of the fiscal year, anyway, to have an evaluation.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:58
Mr. Chairman.
02:03:59
Mr. Warlick.
02:03:59
As part of the after-action report, we can
02:04:02
This includes some information about the minimum staff that we need to be ready for emergencies.
02:04:10
When we did the area headquarters study before, we had used the number of about 3,200 maintenance staff that we needed and that we kind of always held that level because that's what we needed for emergency response.
02:04:27
In the latest blueprint round, we upped that number some.
02:04:30
They could move in at maybe 3,400.
02:04:33
I'm not quite sure.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
02:04:34
I think what we did was we tried to stay at the 3,200.
02:04:36
Yes, sir.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:04:39
So we will look at that and then also look at the equipment and the location of that equipment and give some of the statistics that we used in saying how far you should be away from
02:04:55
How far truck can travel during that type of bad weather?
02:04:59
Some of those factors that we use in determining where the area headquarters should be positioned.
02:05:05
We'll include some of that in the after action report.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:10
Any other questions?
02:05:11
Ms. Sorrell, thank you very much.
Constance S. Sorrell
Chief of System Operations
02:05:12
Great job.
02:05:13
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:15
Next we have the ARRA and federal update.
02:05:19
Ms. Busher and Mr. Pittard.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:05:29
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
02:05:48
This is just a brief update by Steve Pittard and myself on the activity related to the projects that were funded with the RF funding.
02:05:59
I actually have a slide in here on the federal reauthorization, but I'd like to wait and speak to that in the next presentation, which is the update of the Six-Year Program.
02:06:15
So the highway project, as you know, on February 24, the state fully obligated our ARRA project for VDOT that was $576.7 million.
02:06:34
Fifty-three projects out of the 68 that were obligated have been advertised for a total value of $514 million.
02:06:44
Forty-two projects have been awarded to date for a total value of about $288 million.
02:06:52
We continue to get projects ready for advertisement and get our bids in and start the work related to those projects.
02:07:02
As I said, all of the $577 million has been obligated.
02:07:08
What we're doing, as you're aware, our bids have been coming in
02:07:12
Very good.
02:07:14
Low bids.
02:07:15
And we continue to have a requirement to obligate those funds that we put on projects.
02:07:25
Now that the bids have come in low, we have to take
02:07:27
The fund, extra R funding on those projects and putting it on another project and get that fund obligated and advertised.
02:07:36
So we do have some backup projects.
02:07:39
We still are getting courthouse Route 50 project ready to go.
02:07:44
We've got a Project 164 medium rail, I-66 paving, Elm Avenue, and active yard.
02:07:50
And these were projects we brought to you during the process of you approving the selected project.
02:07:58
They just didn't get through by February 24th, but we're hoping to get some of those with the savings.
02:08:06
And we have to be fully obligated to the penny by September 30th, which is the end of the federal fiscal year.
02:08:16
The MPOs were also responsible for $117.8 million of ARRA funding through the five large MPOs.
02:08:24
They also obligated all their funds.
02:08:28
They have eight projects that have been advertised to date for a total value of $33 million and 12 projects that have been awarded for a total of $11 million and were focused very heavily on the MPO projects to make sure
02:08:44
I believe we reported last month that all the paperwork in support of getting those projects to ad has been received by VDOT, so we're processing those through and we'll get those out the door over a period of time.
02:09:05
This is just a quick status by MPOs, talking about the number and the amount advertised by the individual MPOs themselves for your reference.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:17
Mr. Chairman.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:09:18
Yes.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:20
Back on the stakes, you said the report shows eight projects have been advertised.
02:09:26
But you say all the paperwork is in order for them to advertise all the projects?
02:09:31
Yes.
02:09:31
The reason I say that, that seems to be a low number in response in comparison to what the department has done with the monies that we have in the aircraft.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:09:40
Their projects are much smaller in dollar value and quite a few of them.
02:09:49
So it's just taken a little bit longer to process those through one at a time to
02:09:55
through contracts for VDOT and with FHWA approval.
02:10:00
But we're working those through.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:03
I guess part of the criticisms of being slow and commitment that the state has would include the slow response that we've got right here as well.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:10:15
I will say for the MPOs though, they did not have the same deadline for obligating their funding that we did.
02:10:27
So they were able to work through their selection process.
02:10:31
What we are ready to do, and we sent
02:10:34
One email or letter from the Secretary to the MPO prior to the obligation date to make sure that we made that deadline and we're getting ready to send another letter out from
02:10:49
The commissioner outlining for the MPOs the need for contingency projects when some of their bids come in over the next couple of months, come in low, that they're ready to jump on another project to get the cost savings obligated by the end of September.
02:11:11
So we're putting out another letter reminding them of that deadline.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:19
Mentioning is, when people kept on pointing out that of the 600 whatever million dollars that we had not, we have received, and they kept on pointing out that we had not obligated a fairly large number of it.
02:11:33
Something like 20% of the number, overall number, was actually because the MPOs hadn't obligated it.
02:11:40
In fact, I think right before, when it was a fairly negative article about the fact that we had not obligated the funds,
02:11:49
It was out of the 117, I think at the time, the MPOs had only obligated like $6 million.
02:11:56
So it was at least 20% of the funds that Virginia received had not been obligated and it was like 18% of it was actually the MPOs not obligated.
SPEAKER_04
02:12:10
Yeah.
02:12:11
Why was there a different time between, you mentioned
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:12:14
We had an interim obligation to fund 50% of the dollars by June 29th that they did not have.
02:12:31
But we both had an obligation to finish obligating.
02:12:36
We had a requirement to finish obligating by March 2nd.
SPEAKER_04
02:12:45
I got it.
02:12:47
It just seems very bureaucratic, I guess, if I'm trying to figure through that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:53
You know, this is the government, isn't it?
SPEAKER_04
02:12:56
Got it.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:59
Just do I need to remind you of that?
SPEAKER_04
02:13:01
No, sir, I got it.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:03
And this is the federal government we're talking about, too.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:13:08
Right.
02:13:08
I'll turn it over to Steve Pittard from GEOC.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:13:16
Mr. Secretary, members of the board, just to give you all a brief update on where we're staying with the transit rail ARRA funds.
02:13:25
As Ms. Busher has pointed out, there's two keys, our obligation, and then after that, the next point of emphasis was actually expending the funds.
02:13:35
So that's going to be the point of emphasis in a few slides I have here.
02:13:40
If you all recall, we had two rounds of applications for the transit ARRA funds, which totaled $30.5 million.
02:13:49
We've been through those applications.
02:13:50
We made recommendations to you all.
02:13:53
You all made allocations.
02:13:57
We also elected an option that came up at the federal level was to move 10% of these ARRA funds into the operating activities for our transit providers.
02:14:11
And as Mike Carroll mentioned earlier from Raven Lynchburg, we did elect that.
02:14:16
You all did recommend it and approve it.
02:14:19
And that has gone forward.
02:14:20
And now we're actually starting to get reimbursement requests in from our grantees under those funds.
02:14:27
which helped the cuts that we all went through during the first six months of the year.
02:14:33
And I guess as far as obligation status, we've met, there was a preliminary deadline and to add to the bureaucracy, Mr. Lane,
02:14:43
FHWA has certain deadlines and dates, and they're pretty close with our Federal Transit Administration, but there's been slight differences.
02:14:52
I know they had a March 2nd deadline, we had a March 5th deadline to meet 100% obligations.
02:14:58
The good news in all this is we did meet the deadline to get everything 100% obligated.
02:15:04
We also had a portion of these funds were allocated to our small urban providers, which essentially means that we, for lack of a better term, flex those to these providers and they contract directly with the FTA.
02:15:20
So we had that sort of coordination going on with those small urban providers.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:15:24
Forgive me if I don't remember this, but do any of these funds go through the MPOs?
02:15:34
No.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:15:38
Well, they have to end up in the tip.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:15:44
So sooner or later they wind up being considered in the MPOs plan.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:15:49
Well, I think there was, if you recall back to last March, April timeframe, that was one of our timing dilemmas in making this first September 1 deadline was getting all the MPOs.
02:16:06
One up front, we sort of made the allocations and then getting all the MPOs to adopt that recommendation into their tip.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:14
It's part of the confusion that has always existed for me, even after all these years that we're ultimately trying to serve the people of Virginia, moving them in goods and providing services.
02:16:28
And we have all these different inflows of money and rules and agencies.
02:16:32
And, you know, looking at the Richmond metropolitan area, I'm trying to encourage a balanced transportation system of road, rail, and transit.
02:16:44
and anything else innovative we can come up with, and yet the balancing act is frankly complicated by the following the money.
02:16:51
It gets very distorted in a hurry, and the incentives for one set of money are very different than the incentives for another set of money.
02:17:01
I don't know if you want to really get into this, Mr. Chairman, but if we're going to get into working better with the MPOs, I think we have to look at what somebody referred to as the 30,000-foot picture.
02:17:14
as well and follow the money in all these different courses that they run through to eventually produce a result.
02:17:21
I mean this morning the Governor was really good in his remarks at the rescue but one of the things that I'll bet you see tomorrow in the papers or the reports is that he kept talking about results and I think that's going to be a very interesting measure
02:17:36
of whether we're able to channel all these monies in ways that actually produce better results for people in goods in any particular place.
02:17:46
And that's why I ask that I don't quite get the connection of how all this is integrated and turned into a result yet.
02:17:52
And I know DRPT is only one piece of it, but if the MPO does have a say-so in it,
02:17:58
And we've got a pretty good one here in the Richmond area in the sense that it understands the land use transportation connection and the rail and transit and road connection.
02:18:09
It might be fun to have a pilot project somewhere to see if we could do this.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:18:15
Although, tell me if I'm wrong, but I thought when they do their tip,
02:18:26
Its real focus is on, I'm going to say, new construction, new facilities versus current operations and expansion of operations.
02:18:40
I mean, I'm just trying to remember.
02:18:42
I mean, on a tip, do we end up saying that we're going to put $100,000 into double with bus service on a specific line?
02:18:53
For operations?
SPEAKER_08
02:18:54
Yeah.
02:18:55
No.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:18:55
No, we don't.
02:18:56
I know that's the difference.
02:18:59
I mean, the TIP primarily focuses on we're going to start up a new service.
02:19:06
We're going to build, you know, it's capital stuff.
02:19:10
And even when you say you're going to start up a new service, the capital focus is on buying, you know, it's still capital focus is buying
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:19:19
And when you say new, there's a distinction there, replacement buses versus expansion buses.
02:19:30
But it's still a capital item.
02:19:32
So we do put replacement buses
02:19:35
But that's what the TIP itself focuses on, really on capital, right?
02:19:40
From DRPT's perspective, yes.
02:19:43
We really don't have federal operating funds that we're pushing through.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:46
But from the MPO's perspective, does it have more?
02:19:52
I mean, when they put the TIP together, does it actually specifically talk about operations?
02:19:58
I'd have to find that answer out.
02:20:01
When you do a TIP, do you?
SPEAKER_05
02:20:06
Sorry, I didn't catch all that.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:20:08
Well, the question is, so this goes back to the question that McCarthy's raising, and that is, you know, the coordination of money going into the MPOs and its actual allocation.
02:20:26
And my question is, when you do, when we say we go to give money to
02:20:36
to a transit operation in, let's say, Richmond.
02:20:42
Does the TIP have in there the, I mean, is it mostly the TIP is really on capital, right?
SPEAKER_05
02:20:50
Well, the TIP programs with capital and operating funds.
02:20:55
Yes, right, it has GRTC, Ride Finders, any federal funding source for FTA or Federal Highways is in the TIP.
02:21:05
I think you're right, the emphasis on TIP appears to be capital operating is buried in there as well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:13
Because I'm just thinking about even discussions that we had with, as I used to be involved with PRTC and let's say VRE, the fact that we would increase service, we never checked with the MPO, as far as I remember, or changed service or did whatever, we just went and did it.
02:21:31
Although the service was generally recognized in the TIP, the actual details of the service.
SPEAKER_05
02:21:39
Yeah, the TIP is,
02:21:41
It does not have a lot of details when it comes to the terms of the project.
02:21:45
We have a project number that refers to a grant that refers to a bunch of other documents, so you're right, the detail is really not in there.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:55
They do other things too.
02:21:57
Dan, stick around because remember how long ago was it?
02:22:01
Four years ago or something, we started this regional transit planning analysis that the PDC did with some state money and local money.
02:22:12
And then the GRTC was also doing an operations analysis or something like that and the whole idea was to try to have the state and the MPO on the same page with respect to how do you build a transit system for the 21st century in the Richmond metro area and it was largely their responsibility to do that.
SPEAKER_05
02:22:32
And I'm not sure where all that wound up yet, but... One of the results of that was GRTC now moving forward with its Broad Street willow lawn to Rocket's Landing... To BRT, yeah.
02:22:47
Yeah, that was the Conference of Operations Analysis, which GRTC
02:22:52
That focused on a lot of operating aspects.
02:22:54
They're addressing still the transfer center issue on its location.
02:23:01
It moved a lot of projects forward.
02:23:06
The regional mass transit study that we did, I don't think it was all we wanted it to be or should.
02:23:15
It had some good input into our long-range plan.
02:23:18
I think it just generally raised the profile for mass transit in the region.
02:23:24
Some earlier projects, I know that you were involved with the Chesterfield County.
02:23:28
We were able to use some CMAQ funds for
02:23:34
Park and Pride Lock Service out to Chester Hills County.
02:23:39
So, we've had various initiatives.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:23:44
You know, just one of these things where, you know, I hate to say this, it's, we, the state and how we do things here at the CTB, we have our own box.
02:23:57
And then the federal, on its way of doing things with the MPOs,
02:24:03
And the state.
02:24:04
It's its own box.
02:24:06
And sometimes I think what gets lost in the middle is levels of service, mobility, congestion relief.
02:24:13
Because we're both sets of both structures and laws governing those structures end up looking at very different things.
02:24:22
It used to drive me crazy when I was on the MPO up in Washington as to some of the goofy things we would do.
02:24:29
Because we were really driven by being in a non-attainment area.
02:24:34
And so we would put money into things that really didn't do much to help with congestion or mobility but gave us credits under air quality.
02:24:46
But that's because that's where the federal box drives you is towards air quality versus mobility.
SPEAKER_05
02:24:53
There are some silos in the way the process is structured and the end result is that you look at these various results or conforming the analysis and whatever, determining air quality improvements and you showed small measurable gains but you missed the bigger picture of how is that reducing overall congestion and really improving air quality and other mobility and quality of life and so on.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:25:18
I'm sorry, Richmond is entertainment, right?
SPEAKER_05
02:25:21
We are officially now a maintenance area where... Is that because of the new standards?
02:25:31
Based on the new, well no, it's based on the old standard.
02:25:35
Under the new standard, if the data holds that
02:25:39
And this is one thing I'm not certain of, but I believe we've, based on the data that we have now, we will be a non-attainment area, but we've also had, I think, two different numbers in a row, so it's kind of a three-year moving target, and things move so slowly.
02:25:55
If it moves slow enough, we might be a maintenance area.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:26:01
And that's crazy.
02:26:01
I mean, the way they've done things, I mean, it just, they took what was a very good idea and turned it into monstrosity.
02:26:10
because I mean now it's, what is it, two or three days over 365?
SPEAKER_05
02:26:18
I think it's four or more violations over a three-year period at any of the air quality monitoring stations that are in the region.
02:26:30
Our region has four monitoring stations.
02:26:32
I know Northern Virginia has a lot more.
02:26:36
So I think it's four or more over a three-year period.
02:26:43
and they've moved it down to 0.75 parts per billion for ozone air quality standards.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:26:55
So you're looking at over a thousand days, if you have four instances, not even a day, if it's just one point during four days over those thousand days, you hit that
SPEAKER_05
02:27:07
The old standard was a one-hour period.
02:27:11
Now it's an eight-hour average period.
02:27:13
So if it's for an eight-hour period of time and it's over this lower standard, .75, then yes, you exceed the standard and you're in violation.
02:27:29
For those, you get four really hot summer days with your out-of-attainment board.
02:27:36
And in fact, they want to lower the standard today.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:27:49
In fact, Ms. Carter has discussed.
02:27:52
We're sitting here at the copy of the resolution that the George Washington MPO just passed about their concerns about the new standard that the EPA wants to propose.
02:28:04
or is proposing because essentially Fredericksburg will always be out of compliance.
SPEAKER_05
02:28:11
There's no way you can, I mean this is not enough sources other than people.
02:28:23
Thank you
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:28:35
All right.
02:28:36
So where were you?
02:28:39
Well, I think that's a great question.
02:28:41
I mean, it's something that I've seen a lot too.
02:28:44
And to me, it's sort of in this case, it's like the funding was driving the planning for these projects instead of the other way around, planning.
02:28:52
We ought to plan where we're going and then decide how to fund it.
02:28:56
I think with the deadlines that were cast with some of them, these are funds that kind of had to happen the other way around.
02:29:03
There were a lot of amendments done on the tips very close to the deadlines.
02:29:08
But anyway, we've met the 100% obligation requirements.
02:29:13
As of March 4th, I think was the day we finally got the award documents from FTA, and so did all of our smaller and transit grantees that actually applied directly.
02:29:27
But we did check on them to make sure and help them with the assistance they needed to ensure that they got their awards, too.
02:29:35
This is pretty much the same information as I showed you last month.
02:29:40
Expenditures have gone up a little bit, and as Mr. Carroll said earlier, we do have, I think this summer, we're going to see a significant increase in the actual expenditures.
02:29:51
One, we have those operational funds, about $3 million that will go out the door in the next two to three months.
02:29:57
You have quite a few people that were able to expedite the procurement process.
02:30:02
They just needed an 18-month, a two-year process to get a bus.
02:30:12
A lot of people were able to do that.
02:30:13
You know what else?
02:30:14
They were able to jump the gun.
02:30:15
So I think over the summer we'll see the expenditure part that everybody else is interested in.
02:30:20
So you'll see that actually ramping up also.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:24
Mr. Chairman, just one question.
02:30:27
Do we have a total number of the buses purchased?
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:30:32
Under these funds?
02:30:33
Yes.
02:30:34
I can get you that.
02:30:35
I have it off the top of my head.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:37
My curiosity is, are we really stimulating our economy or someone else?
02:30:42
The follow-up question is, will they manufacture in the United States?
02:30:47
Which would be very important to me if we were making those types of decisions.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:30:51
They are manufactured in the United States.
02:30:54
I know a lot of these vehicles are smaller pair transit type vehicles and a lot of them are purchased through a company called Sunny America which is in Virginia.
02:31:10
I can't give you 100% assurance that it's helping just Virginia, but good fortune.
SPEAKER_08
02:31:16
And I'll get you the number of actual large buses and then air transit vehicles also.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:31:27
And I guess back to that slide, the very bottom, I told you last time in our grantees, essentially, they don't have the funds to go out and go ahead and begin procurement thinking they're going to get funds allocated to us.
02:31:40
And so the second round that just got awarded, most of those have just begun the procurement process.
02:31:46
But I did hear before I came over here today that Green County Transit actually did go ahead.
02:31:52
at their own risk and begin the procurement and they are actually in the process now finishing procurement basically a week after getting the rewards.
02:32:03
Finally, the rail update.
02:32:05
Once again, we received a $75 million award under our Track 1 application.
02:32:11
FRA has contacted us and they want to work with our department to be the first agency to actually go through the award process and get those funds obligated.
02:32:23
I'm not sure if that's
02:32:24
A positive or a negative, but it sounds like we're going to go first.
02:32:30
From last indications with them in the next week or two, they want to just come down and stay for about a week and work out the agreement.
02:32:38
So that process hopefully will be moved along by the time we meet again.
02:32:44
Once again, we still plan on submitting once we get the guidance from FRA under the $2.1 billion, I believe it is, that's in the President's budget.
02:32:54
They just haven't come up with that guidance yet.
02:32:57
We're getting discussions, but no specifics yet.
02:33:01
But our plan is still to apply for both Hampton Roads, Norfolk, and then also potentially our existing projects that were not funded under the Track One application.
02:33:16
And with that, I guess the deadline, I guess I'll throw out the deadline.
02:33:25
That should not be an issue.
02:33:28
With that, I'll take on the other questions.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:34
Does it appear more likely that we will now get some reauthorization of basic transportation programs at the federal level through the end of the year rather than a second round of our funding?
02:33:48
It's too early to tell.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
02:33:50
I couldn't tell you.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:54
You're asking about the reauthorization?
02:33:57
We were just up there this week, Corey Hill, our transit chief, and myself, and very clearly it will not be this year.
02:34:04
Their target date is spring of next year.
02:34:07
Secretary LaHood was very clear.
02:34:09
They would like to do the bill, but they don't have the funding for it, and so everything is on hold.
02:34:13
We also met with Chairman Overstar yesterday, who has a bill all ready to go.
02:34:18
It's this thick, and he is very distressed that the bill is not going to move this year.
02:34:25
Now he has funding sources in his bill, but a big part of that is gas tax increase and so they really, it's going to be next year.
02:34:37
Very distressing to everyone.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:39
And they just passed, I guess, the Senate?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:34:42
What they just passed will fund us through December of 2010, so that will give us an idea.
02:34:54
We'll look at the bill and the information and look how that impacts VDOT for the 10 federal revenues because as you all will remember, we created a federal reserve in anticipation
02:35:08
So we'll analyze this bill related to our reserves and see if we need to do any adjusting.
02:35:19
to that reserve going forward.
02:35:21
We have spoken to Jack Basso, and I think this gives us comfort, obviously, for 10 in the first quarter of 11, but until they go beyond December of 2010, we're still unsure how 11 through 16 will play out, so we're probably looking at maintaining that reserve, but we want to review it as we get the details of the bill.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:50
Any other questions?
02:35:52
Thank you very much.
02:35:53
I appreciate all the work that you all did to get all the money obligated on time.
02:36:02
Okay, we have the development of the Six-Year Plan.
SPEAKER_08
02:36:06
Ms. Busher again.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:36:19
This again will be a tag-team between Mr. Pittard and myself.
02:36:26
We'll talk about the 11-16 Six Improvement Program and I'll talk to the highway portion and Steve will cover rail and public transit.
02:36:36
Just to refresh your memories,
02:36:39
Though you probably don't need to have your memory refreshed it was so recent in December we did amend the 10 through 15 program for one more revenue reduction of a little less than a billion dollars and so right now we're at 7.4 billion for the 10 through 16 program.
02:36:58
We have no revenue adjustments except the review of
02:37:04
of what this latest bill will do for us from the federal side, but from the state side at this point we don't have another revenue reduction that we're looking at in the development of the 11-16.
02:37:20
As we mentioned, what we were working on when we prepared this PowerPoint was that there was a short-lived freezing of federal funding from FHWA, as you recall, and they actually had a couple of days furlough, but that's been resolved and we're moving forward on everything.
02:37:44
Nothing stopped in terms of VDOT.
02:37:46
We continued our programs.
02:37:47
We got things ready for ads, et cetera.
02:37:50
So I am thrilled that we aren't going month to month for a while that we'll go through until December.
02:38:00
As I mentioned, we started in the update or the revision of the 2009 through 14 Six-Year Improvement Program.
02:38:09
We decided we needed to cushion ourselves so we weren't over-obligating.
02:38:15
In that we did not know for sure what our federal dollars would look like for 9 or for 10.
02:38:25
So we created a federal revenue reserve in 10 through 14.
02:38:31
We updated and continued that federal revenue reserve in the 10 through 15.
02:38:37
And I would say right now we will continue it through 16 in the update, but we will review the impact for current 10 and the first quarter of 2011 and make adjustments accordingly.
02:38:55
As you may recall, when we did the 10 through 15 updated program and the revised 10 through 15 program, we set some principles for the evaluation and the funding of projects over that six-year period.
02:39:13
And as usual, we cover our project deficits first.
02:39:19
especially estimate increases on projects underway, project phases underway.
02:39:28
We also made a top priority, the maximization of federal dollars to meet federal strategy and funding projects in the update of the program to help us meet federal strategy.
02:39:45
In ten, that was the federal fiscal year ten,
02:39:48
Mr. Chairman, just a question.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:39:57
When we made that decision, that's the point where we actually decided we could not fund secondary
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:40:09
No, actually that was when we phased the $2.6 billion state revenue loss in the 9-14 update.
02:40:25
Two things have happened since then.
02:40:28
We did not have enough state revenue as a result of that combined reduction with the billion dollars we reduced for the original 2014.
02:40:39
So at that point we were facing 3.6 billion combined revenue reduction and we were not able to put state dollars through the state funding formula down to primary, secondary, and urban.
02:40:54
Then in the original 9 and 10 through 15 program and again in the update of the 10 through 15 program with an additional loss of almost a billion dollars in state funding and as well as the unknown federal funding we to meet federal strategy we pulled back in the STP funds
02:41:20
through the federal formula and instead of allocating those to localities based on population to put on projects, we programmed it centrally so that we could make sure that we could obligate it all to meet federal strategy to maximize federal dollars.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:41:42
Mr. Chairman, we had our first reality test last night up in Clark County.
02:41:47
They've been working on a high school there for five years.
02:41:51
It's their fault that they don't have it well underway and able to move ahead, but when they realized what the next several years hold as far as secondary road funding that would let them do the road work that's required for that high school, they came to a reality check, half a million dollars short.
02:42:09
And they've been planning and working and negotiating now for three or four years on this thing, but it was the first time that one of the localities started looking out three or four years
02:42:19
for their funding and realize it ain't there.
02:42:22
And I think we're going to start hearing that more and more as we work with our localities.
02:42:28
The second question I had, as we look at the third priority there, and you haven't gotten to it yet, I apologize, but while I'm speaking I'll share it.
02:42:37
We made a decision again to fund bridges and paving projects, but we also agreed that if we didn't back up a little bit and put some planning money into bringing projects along,
02:42:48
that we weren't going to be ready to take advantage of any future stimulus program and I wonder if we as a board need to put a revision there to say that we need to go back and not only fund bridges and paving projects but we need to put some planning money in for high priority projects to keep moving them forward so they're ready to be done when we do get money.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:43:11
You're absolutely correct and we as staff at VDOT with Commissioner Whirley have been talking about and searching for dollars to put on PE phases.
02:43:27
Actually we are identifying dollars that are on PE phases already to fully fund the phase
02:43:32
that isn't obligated or hasn't moved forward, we want to see what we can do to move those forward.
02:43:38
So we're actually meeting with each of the districts to look at finding some of those projects that already have some money to work on that and find potential additional dollars to do more than that.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:54
I know my district submitted the list for that and I was just wondering if we need to say that
02:44:01
anything beyond what we've already said that that should be a priority along with bridges and the pavement.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:44:09
We will amend that.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:44:13
Thank you.
02:44:15
Mr. Chairman, I have made a note to ask later, but I think it may be appropriate here.
02:44:20
Clearly, what you've alluded to is that in a year, demand has increased tremendously, partially because we haven't been able to meet a past year's demand or the year before.
02:44:34
And it makes me wonder whether there are other underlying factors that we ought to review
02:44:38
about not just these priorities but even about the reserve, for example, that surely those factors have shifted somewhat from what we were very hopeful of happening last year is that somehow the economy would right itself a little bit more quickly and the revenue picture would improve.
02:44:55
Well, I don't know that that's occurred, so I'm not sure the role we would play in that review, but I'd love to have
02:45:02
Let's go back to zero again and see if we have to do this now from the beginning that we actually look at it not just as an extension of what happened last year.
02:45:12
What concerns me, Mr. Chairman and colleagues, is that we've attempted on a month-to-month basis, both as a department and as a board, to adjust to what are basically long-term changes in the environment.
02:45:28
I think we need to have a little deeper look now after a year and a half, almost two years, quite frankly, of reducing, reducing incrementally, hoping something would happen.
02:45:40
And now we realize it probably isn't going to happen.
02:45:42
There's not a magic something that's going to happen.
02:45:46
My own view is that my priorities would be very different if I'm looking at the longer term, more modest means as opposed to a shorter term adjustment.
02:45:57
I don't think it's an adjustment anymore.
02:46:00
I think we've, you've heard me say this before, it's not a dynamic economy anymore, it's a volatile one.
02:46:05
Our revenue sources that used to be predictable aren't predictable now.
02:46:09
Changes in behavior happen much more quickly.
02:46:12
There's more actors, there are more information points that change reality very, very fast.
02:46:17
I mean we discovered that not only in the private sector, but now we've discovered
02:46:21
So much of what we're doing is based on this idea of steady state, a rough balance between expenditure needs, revenue sources.
02:46:33
In a short term, month to month, we fill the gaps, bridge the gaps, hollow things out a little bit and wait for the next month or the next year.
02:46:42
But I think we're in a different situation and just because the economy improves
02:46:49
Mr. Chairman,
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:47:05
It's also a situation where in meeting those federal requirements we've really shifted a lot of money.
02:47:12
I think we've recognized that from certain parts of the state in some rural areas to the larger projects which basically have gone to metropolitan areas in this type of thing, to the Northern Virginia districts and so forth.
02:47:26
Is that an accurate statement?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:47:29
If a rural project was underway, we would continue to fund it.
02:47:33
If any project anywhere in the state was underway, that was a priority to keep funded.
02:47:40
So now you may be recalling that to make strategy in nine
02:47:48
We went through previous interstate dollars that were sitting and pooled money that was accruing on projects that were not moving forward and brought them together.
02:48:04
and funded the rehab of the 1195 bridges in Richmond and quite a lengthy $40 million paving project on I-64.
02:48:17
That was, in fact, a strategic project.
02:48:20
We still use existing state monies on projects.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:39
that we moved off of projects in order to move them to projects where we could match federal dollars.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:48:45
We've pretty much pulled all state dollars except for matching on the interstate and some matching on CMAQ and RSVP out of the construction program and as you may recall we're matching with bond dollars.
02:49:04
I'm sorry I'm not sure I'm getting to your question.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:49:09
Well, it all leads to a major concern that I have, and Dr. Davis has hit on it, with the 31% deficiency rate in the pavement that we have on the secondary roads.
02:49:21
And I know the desire, we're not going to give any, you know, we're not going to give any more money for any improvements to those secondary roads.
02:49:29
We're probably going to do some maintenance on them and that type of thing.
02:49:33
The real serious thing there is, is that it is going to be an orphan.
02:49:39
The orphan part of that is that the counties and the local agents have no way of raising money.
02:49:46
They have no money.
02:49:48
And they don't have the power to raise the money because it rests with the legislature.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:49:54
Your point is to match federal dollars, not every, not all the roads in the secondary system qualify for federal funding.
02:50:03
So in fact, we are directing it to roadways on the NHS system and primary and interstate dollars because those are available and qualify.
02:50:15
So there is limited money going to secondary and urban if they don't qualify.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:50:30
I guess I need a reality check and maybe I'll show my naiveth hammer.
02:50:35
If we don't have enough money and we have these principles, when we get a list of possible projects, are they going to be linked to these principles?
02:50:44
Are we down through only
02:50:46
Are we going to have anything that shows us how the project fit into these principles, or do we have to sort of figure that out?
02:50:59
Because if we're only down to half of number three, then is there really a principle that we're using?
02:51:09
If that's all the money that we have to use, are we prioritizing?
02:51:13
No, I mean, is this a priority in terms of listing or is this a general fund?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:51:20
It's a combination.
02:51:22
It's a combination.
02:51:23
The SVP funds help with funding deficits or moving project phases forward to meet federal strategy.
02:51:34
So, bridges and paving projects that might be ready to go or deficient are safety and we can use STP or bridge dollars or and combine construction dollars with maintenance dollars and some of the paving projects.
02:51:48
So, they're all being looked at at the same time depending on what the need of the project is or the price of money.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:51:57
So, how would I know that when I see the list of projects that go to public hearings?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:52:03
We're not looking to add projects, so the projects that we're continuing to work on have been in the program for a while, but we're looking at and we need to do a better job of taking planning priority projects and carry those through.
02:52:25
One of the things we're looking at is projects that have been identified or safety projects that have been identified through STARS program that seem to be low-hanging fruit
02:52:48
And we get about 30 million dollars a year of federal safety money, so we're looking
02:52:59
Thelma D. D. D.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:53:22
So if somebody comes to us and says, we really think you ought to support this project, and we don't have enough money to cover everything, which is what I assume is the case, will we be able to say, ah, we ought to do this because it's in 106, or will we not know where that project is?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
02:53:43
We'd have to determine if it's a project already in the program.
02:53:48
If it's a new project, what kind of money would help it move forward?
02:53:53
Is it federal money?
02:53:55
Does it not qualify for federal money?
02:53:58
Could we use
02:54:01
What Ms. Pandak is asking is you can't figure it out by looking at it.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:54:13
I feel like to some extent I don't add any value by being at these public hearings and making a decision because I can adopt these principles but I don't know how the principles match up with any of the projects.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:54:25
You can't.
02:54:26
I mean it would be one thing if we had every code.
02:54:28
Let's say
02:54:28
This was A, B, C, D, and E with each one of the quirky dots and you go, this project isn't A, B, D, and E. But you can't figure it out.
02:54:39
The staff ends up doing it.
02:54:41
I think, I mean, they do go through an analysis and there isn't that sort of transparency that you're asking about.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:54:51
Mr. Chairman.
02:54:51
Yes, Mr. Park.
02:54:52
I don't know.
02:54:53
I'm pretty sure the other district members do this but I know for me it's always worked very well to work with the district administrator and his staff and then have an ongoing dialogue with the central staff and I mean I know if you're an at-large member it may not be as obvious but there's nothing preventing at-large members from meeting with district representatives and having them explain all this to you because
02:55:20
At least in my district, I have an administrator who can make the most complex funding formula and project selection process look pretty darn easy so that even I can understand it.
02:55:32
And that's worked pretty well for us.
02:55:35
And it is possible.
02:55:36
It is not impossible.
02:55:37
It just seems that way until you get into it.
02:55:40
And then it works out pretty well, at least in my district.
02:55:45
And then all this stuff, which is important, but there's a list of criteria.
02:55:51
It really is important.
02:55:54
And what you try to do is optimize the use of those funds to get as many things done as possible within the priority criteria that you have established.
02:56:04
That's what we've been able to do so far.
02:56:06
And with half the money we had five years ago, that's been no small accomplishment to do that.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:56:14
The only thing I would add to what Jerry is saying, however, is that we are making policy decisions for the long term based on meeting short term federal requirements for use of federal funds.
02:56:30
And it really troubles me that that's necessary in order to take advantage of the federal dollars that are available.
02:56:36
I don't have a better answer right now exactly how to deal with it, but I just know that it is shifting
02:56:43
funds across the Commonwealth in a significant way.
02:56:47
One example, and I'm not being critical because this was, it happened based on the way we did things.
02:56:53
Northern Virginia did not suffer any reduction at all in funding in the last go around, but my district took like a 30 million dollar cut and Bristol took a 30 million dollar cut.
02:57:03
It was because those projects in the other areas were ready to go, we didn't have any ready to go.
02:57:08
And we don't have any planning money to get anything ready to go, so it's going to accelerate the movement of money across the Commonwealth to satisfy this philosophy that we adopted is not in the best interest of the Commonwealth in my view.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:23
Well, the problem, one of the challenges you face is actually most of these principles are actually statutory.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:30
I know.
02:57:31
I agree.
02:57:31
I agree.
02:57:32
There's statutory and there are also our decision that we made to set those priorities that we need to do that, but it doesn't make me feel good that it's a good policy for the Commonwealth of Virginia.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:43
Oh, yeah.
02:57:44
No, I understand.
02:57:44
It just that and it goes back to some of these issues on, you know, looking at reform proposals to address, I mean, to address some of these issues.
02:57:55
But, I mean, the bottom line is I think when I look at these of the
02:58:00
five quirky dots here.
02:58:04
Actually, I guess the first two are actually in statute that says that's where we must put our money.
02:58:12
But I'm just saying there's no flexibility on one and two.
02:58:20
And once you get past one and two, there ain't a lot of money we're talking about.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:28
Mr. Secretary?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:30
Yes.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:30
Thank you.
02:58:31
I certainly agree with Mr. McCarthy.
02:58:33
I work very closely with our district administrator.
02:58:38
And that, I mean, working together with him is just a positive
02:58:43
I mean, like you just said, stated a few minutes ago, Mr. Secretary, I could sit here and I'm not going to figure it out.
02:58:50
I know that.
02:58:50
I know I can't do that.
02:58:52
But however, with the district administrator, yes, yes I can.
02:58:58
And, but that's where we as CTB members, I think, play a major role in representing our district.
SPEAKER_08
02:59:06
Thank you.
02:59:08
Thank you, sir.
SPEAKER_04
02:59:09
Ms. Lane.
02:59:10
Mr. Secretary, I have some thoughts with Ms. Pandak.
02:59:13
In reality, the first two items are action items when working in our district.
02:59:17
And the other three items down below are things that we consider in the first two items.
02:59:22
In other words, you don't get to where you're just funding a bridge or a paving project if it doesn't meet the federal match.
02:59:29
At least that's the way it's working with our district administrator.
02:59:33
So that's the only way I've been able to figure it out working with them is that
02:59:37
First two items are action items and the other three are guidelines and those first two.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:41
I think you're fortunate, Mr. Chairman, that he has most of his projects who qualify for federal funds, where in other districts there's a lot that do not qualify for federal funds.
02:59:52
Just one other illustration.
02:59:54
On 81, there are a number of interchange projects that really need attention badly.
03:00:00
They were all at the stage just a few years ago where they were ready to go to planning.
03:00:06
and what we had to do, we had to pull all the money out of planning.
03:00:09
So there's not a single one of those interchange projects that are really moving along now to be ready and they run anywhere from 30 to 75 million dollars, every one of them as a project.
03:00:20
And it's leaving us in a very difficult position on 81.
03:00:25
I was asked by Senator Byrd, former Senator Byrd last night, what are we doing on 81 as far as funding this year?
03:00:34
And I had to tell him really about the only thing we're doing is maintenance and the climbing lane project that's funded with about 70 million dollars.
03:00:42
And hopefully eventually the one in sales.
03:00:45
And that was sad to say that that's all we are doing to look at what we know to be a huge growing problem along the corridor.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:00
This is, again, one of the issues where, I mean, unfortunately, a lot of what's driving, I mean, revenues are driving us, but also restrictions that are placed on us by the federal money and where it can go and how we can use it.
03:01:19
I would suggest, though, I think it's rather late for us to be able to change all this at this point.
03:01:30
The question is, do we come up with other principles that start early next year so that we can give staff a different set of criteria?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:44
I don't have an easy solution.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:01:47
That's why I'm asking.
03:01:48
If you all want to go back, and again, you have your statutes that's layout one and two.
03:01:54
I forget what, three, if I remember correctly,
03:02:00
So when you do maintenance, federal match, and funding construction that's over, that we don't have enough money for, that we were already underway, we're not talking about a lot of money.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:30
Do you know whether, and I don't know, so I'm hoping somebody does, is there an effort underway in the rewrite of the next transportation legislation to give states some more flexibility in how to use that?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:45
No, Director Drake can speak to this, but the, I mean, the OpenStar bill will make things dramatically worse, dramatically worse.
03:02:59
I mean, they're trying to take almost all the flexibility out on the use of federal money and trying to drive it honestly into, you know.
03:03:12
In fact, I was at a presentation at AASHTO with one of the congressional, I think he's the chairman of one of the subcommittees for House Appropriations who essentially said there will be no money.
03:03:26
We're trying to drive all federal money towards urban areas.
03:03:30
and there will be little to no money for anything outside of specifically urban areas with MPOs and large urban areas, not even, they made it sound like MPOs such as Richmond were not going to be, it would be the Washington region let's say and questionable whether Hampton Roads would meet the way he was talking about large urban areas, so.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
03:03:55
I will tell you that Secretary LaHood was very clear that there was no determination yet what would be in the bill.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:22
So it sounded like they've not even started looking at that.
03:04:26
He did not reference the Overstar bill as a model he wanted to use.
03:04:30
He said they would be sitting down to talk about the components of the bill.
03:04:35
So I think it's just way too early to know what's going to be in that bill.
03:04:41
But it didn't sound to me like Secretary LaHood was going to go with the Overstar bill.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:47
I used to be with the administration and Congress never listened to us anyway.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:55
Well, it did sound like they were going to play a part.
03:04:58
They were going to play a part in what was in that bill.
03:05:00
It was the loud, clear message.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:05:03
I'd be interested if you want to form a small subcommittee and start looking at revised principles for the next six-year plan.
03:05:14
Something to think about?
03:05:22
Okay, we'll sign a subcommittee.
03:05:25
I think I might know who might be on it, Dr. Davis.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
03:05:29
Alright, from this point I'll turn it over to Mr. Pittard.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
03:05:41
I'm going to give you all a brief overview of the DRPT Six-Year Improvement Program process and feel free to jump in at any point with questions.
03:05:55
There is a point here I guess y'all spoke about earlier about the district administrator.
03:06:00
The district administrator is a speed eye.
03:06:03
They really don't understand our six-year program, no offense to them.
03:06:08
We tried to make a point in the past to get out and this year talking with Mr. Hill, we definitely this year would like to get out and meet with everybody.
03:06:20
Maybe a rail meeting and a transit meeting so each gets their due consideration.
03:06:27
One interest doesn't cloud the other.
03:06:30
That's a bullet here, second bullet.
03:06:34
Sometime late April when we have a program ready, recommended program, we want to get out and take you all through that program and explain to you how the allocations are made.
03:06:44
I think what you'll find out is a lot of those allocations are made based on formulas from 1986 that don't necessarily
03:06:56
In my opinion, don't necessarily make sense maybe today.
03:07:00
Maybe they did at that point, but they don't necessarily drive what I would consider equitable distribution.
03:07:07
They don't really allow us to exert the state's policy interest in those allocations.
03:07:14
So we can't necessarily reward good behavior and punish bad behavior.
03:07:18
So anyway, just to add on to the discussion that was being had,
03:07:23
Y'all are probably pretty familiar or should be familiar at this point.
03:07:28
December 1st we open up applications each year to our grantees both rail and transit.
03:07:35
It's a two month period for eligible applicants to put in or request for funding.
03:07:43
This is both operating assistance on the transit side and capital and then on the rail side for capital funding.
03:07:50
At that point, February through April, we analyze all the applications we receive and a lot of y'all have been on the board and you know that in the last three years we've put in place a lot of different techniques and tools such as our asset management system where we're
03:08:07
comparing the needs the asset management system is showing for buses, so to speak, compared to an application from GRTC, for example, for point buses.
03:08:17
We can look and see, based on the average age of the fleet, what their needs are.
03:08:21
And in the case of Mr. Carroll earlier, he was saying he had buses that are 15 years old.
03:08:27
Our goal, eventually, would be to say to him,
03:08:30
We need to go on and replace those because it is driving up your downtime and your breakdown as opposed to keep trying to stretch it out.
03:08:38
I understand why that's happening, but our goal is to get everybody replacing the buses when they need to be replaced.
03:08:45
So it's not just that someone would ask for more buses than they need.
03:08:48
They may be asking for too few buses because maybe they don't have the local funding.
03:08:52
So it's to try to get things on a steady state.
03:08:56
But anyway, we do all that analysis basically from February through April.
03:08:59
We do a little bit of it in the fall with comparing capital, six-year capital budgets of our grantees to the actual needs and the asset management systems.
03:09:10
But there's a lot of work going on today.
03:09:14
At the same time, once the public transportation and the rail sections provide to my group, they're recommended approved applications, and we program the available funding to those.
03:09:25
And then at that point, we just come and meet with y'all.
03:09:28
So I expect myself, Corey Hill, or Kevin Page to be contacting y'all to try to set up meetings, because we do.
03:09:37
We feel our program has grown quite a bit in the last three years, funding-wise and stature-wise.
03:09:46
We sense that y'all are more interested in our projects now, so we really would like to get out and meet with you.
03:09:51
So if we can find a mutual agreeable time, we'd definitely look to do that.
03:09:56
At that point, then early May, with VDOT, we put together a six-year program.
03:10:01
We'll get that out.
03:10:03
I think the release will be the May CTB meeting, and then at that point we'll have our hearings as usual, and the last slide will touch on the dates and the timing of the hearings, and then finally June, the Constitution program, which is required by law that by June 30th each year we must do that.
03:10:24
Just some key points for our program for the current year.
03:10:30
As mentioned, there's time to forward transit operating funds.
03:10:35
Capital with the allocation of bond funds has done really well in our program for transit the last three years.
03:10:45
But operating funds at the same time, the state shares continue to decline.
03:10:52
In the budget, the Appropriation Act, there's language that's included that will allow the CTB at its discretion to shift up to 20% of the available capital funds, not the bond funds but the normal mass transit trust funds, to shift that over.
03:11:11
It's a plan, any decline in the amount available for operating funding.
03:11:17
Looking at the revenue estimate, we see that there's going to be about a $3 million decrease in the amount that was available and distributed in December in the revised plan to what we're predicting for 11.
03:11:32
Currently, we have discussed internally and we're going to probably recommend that we, to some degree, try to think up for that decline in the operating funds.
03:11:43
This is assuming that it's passed General Sunday today in the budget bill, so I'm assuming the government is fine.
03:11:52
There's still a chance it could be changed.
03:11:55
So assuming that passes, we're looking to do that.
03:11:59
Another item.
03:12:01
That we need to address is the amount of bond funds that we allocate to transit.
03:12:10
We basically had our bond fundings lined up and we weren't able to actually issue bonds the first two years of the program like we had hoped to.
03:12:22
The issue has arisen, to some degree, do we continue to make the full level of allocation, which is about, on average, $60 million a year for transit, or do we not actually do $60 million, maybe we do a $40 million.
03:12:37
I don't think y'all recall, but last year we had $60 million available, we allocated $32 million.
03:12:42
So it doesn't mean those funds go away.
03:12:45
They're still there.
03:12:46
They'd be used in a later year.
03:12:47
So it's the level of funding of using CPR bonds and transit that's a subject of debate.
03:12:56
Also, there's
03:13:00
Rail Enhancement Fund projects, we do have some language also in the Appropriation Act that would allow, hopefully you all are familiar now, Rail Enhancement Fund.
03:13:11
We have a private matching provision and we have a cost-benefit provision that must be met.
03:13:19
There's some language now that would allow service from Norfolk to Richmond, Amtrak service, similar to the Lynchburg train and the Richmond train.
03:13:28
That would allow that project to move forward without that match being available.
03:13:34
If the public benefits from that, that 30% match requirement would be waived.
03:13:42
Now that being said,
03:13:45
As an agency, we hope that a station would be developed locally, and that would count to some degree towards match.
03:13:51
That's not to say we're not pursuing match.
03:13:54
And one of the railroads, or both of the railroads would be involved in this, but it may actually cross both of them, Southern and CSA.
03:14:02
So we're going to certainly seek to get that level of participation.
03:14:06
It just may not be at the 30% level.
03:14:09
And finally, as I mentioned earlier, we continue to take the tools that, if you all recall, we did a lot of change in a short time and all those things don't necessarily happen perfectly the first time you attempt to use them.
03:14:25
So, as I mentioned, the asset management system is figuring out exactly how that fits in the process and several of the other tools that we developed.
03:14:34
2-3 years ago.
03:14:36
It's getting those refined, figuring out what's working well, what's not working well.
03:14:39
So we're still in the process of doing that.
03:14:43
And finally, the hearings themselves, looking at four hearings, one in Northern Virginia, Richmond, Hampton Roads, and Salem.
03:14:53
The dates May 19th to June 2nd.
03:14:57
I don't know the exact dates down there, but shortly we'll put out the exact dates, but this is the general plan as of today.
03:15:10
And with that, this is a brief overview to have more specific questions.
03:15:16
I'd love it.
03:15:17
We really want to get in front of y'all and explain how our six-year program works and how the funds are allocated.
03:15:25
I think for years it's been just sort of a formula and just no input, but I think there is a little, with these bond funds, there's a little bit of wiggle room with respect to pushing down necessarily a board's policy and have what direction they want.
03:15:42
So it's not all driven by those.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:15:47
Any other questions?
03:15:53
Would it be helpful to just add one other maybe meeting?
03:15:58
Should we bring the MPOs in?
03:16:01
This is a separate meeting.
03:16:05
I'm just going to raise that.
03:16:07
I think ultimately that would work.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
03:16:17
I don't know if this year, just because of where we're at, timing-wise.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:16:24
We're essentially at this point where we're made most of it.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
03:16:29
We're programming fun now, where we're at, and I'm guessing it's where you all are at.
03:16:36
But to me, y'all touched on it to me as a big issue.
03:16:39
A lot of times we have a large urban grantee that wants to go to contract for some funding, and they have to work through us because the match is being provided to say it's an RSTP fund.
03:16:53
Well, for whatever reason, that project hasn't gotten into the TIP, and one of our requirements to do the contract isn't being the TIP.
03:17:03
and I'm not sure where the disconnect is.
03:17:06
I don't know if it's the local transit provider not working with the MPO.
03:17:11
I don't know if it's our responsibility, but you've touched on that in our agency definitely there is an issue there of coordination with MPOs.
03:17:20
There's legislation for looking.
03:17:23
Yeah, there's legislation to actually look at it.
03:17:26
So I don't know if that's been approved or not.
03:17:29
Which legislation?
03:17:29
That performance or audit.
03:17:34
VDOT and DMT and then it gets into the MPI with the coordination.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:17:41
It's the $2 million of your money.
Steve Pittard
Chief Financial Officer
03:17:46
That's it.
03:17:46
That touches a lot on that.
SPEAKER_08
03:17:48
That may or may not be true.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:17:55
Well, for Dr. Davis' ...
03:17:59
I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_08
03:18:01
I don't know if, Dan, if you had... You're our resident MPO.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:18:07
Why don't you come up here and sit with us?
03:18:15
I mean, the question is, is how, I mean, this goes back to when Dr. Davis shares the subcommittee, looked at revising our principles, and we want to get in there somewhere about the MPOs, getting their inputs, and the local governments.
03:18:31
versus just how in your mind could we do it better to get your inputs upfront so we can consider them in a six-year plan versus now you're showing up at the public hearing
03:18:46
giving us input, and let's just face it, by that point, except for minor modifications, it's difficult.
03:18:52
How would you, I mean, you don't have to answer it now.
03:18:55
Maybe just think about it.
03:18:57
What's the best way for us to start to get your input sooner and make sure it's part of the discussion as we move forward?
SPEAKER_05
03:19:05
That's the key, sooner too, because by the time you're down this far along the road, a lot is so much said already, I believe.
03:19:16
Also, what's really driving the process is what you have in place already to begin with, so it's kind of hard to turn that battleship.
03:19:23
You have a lot of projects, and I think a lot of people are focused on
03:19:29
If it's earlier on in the process and you can take account, take stock of the various projects and options and other things you have on the table, it's easier I believe for everyone to focus in on what the various parties' priorities are and try to pick and choose those earlier on.
03:19:56
But I've got to say you all are really between a rock and a hard place given the downhill nature of the funding stream that we have.
03:20:07
And you're doing everything possible to capitalize on your federal fund strategy to keep those projects coming forward because you can have a $100 million program of which $80 million is federal and $20 million is state.
03:20:24
20 million dollar state now.
03:20:28
That's a choice, I guess, but what are you going to say?
03:20:33
What are you going to do?
03:20:35
Because the federal funds drive a lot of what your decisions are.
03:20:39
I was listening to Mr. Davis' comments earlier, and I really take to heart what you're saying about the secondary road program going on, but those are state funds, basically, so you end up on the short end of the step, I hate to say.
SPEAKER_08
03:20:53
We know that.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:20:56
Well, Mr. Chairman, we've been a federally driven program even before the current revenue difficulties.
03:21:02
I mean, this has been a priority ever since I've been on the board, and we've set a lot of priorities based on the availability of federal funding for certain things in certain categories, and it caused us trouble three years ago or four years ago as well.
03:21:17
But I would say this, the point I alluded to earlier is the complexity of the system
03:21:26
as well as being driven out of the budget side of it instead of the planning side of it has, I just feel like we've been responding in slow motion to events that are actually moving more quickly than that.
03:21:41
MPOs now are in the position of translating some of the cuts we made probably a year and a half or two years ago into changes in their plans because their own cycle doesn't immediately respond to what we do on a year to year basis.
03:21:55
Even our own cycle doesn't respond year to year.
03:21:57
We have this rolling six years.
03:22:00
But I can think of a handful of projects in Northern Virginia that will go forward under these kind of criteria.
03:22:07
But quite frankly aren't necessarily the projects you would build if that's the only money you're going to have over the next five years of buildings because they are part of a continuum of effort that now is going to be cut.
03:22:17
It's like you increase the mobility of four lanes something and then you just stop.
03:22:25
Well, you're not going to get the benefits of that project until it's followed through all the way through.
03:22:31
You're right.
03:22:32
The strategies of continuing what we're doing don't necessarily make sense, even though from a budget perspective they do.
03:22:40
You have contracts, you have expectations, you have teams in place, all that sort of thing.
03:22:44
But if that's the only thing you're going to do, you might pull that back instead.
03:22:52
And I think that's what we fail to factor in.
03:22:55
And perhaps the MPOs could help us do that now that they're sort of in the soup where we are now.
03:23:01
They're all going through this act because of, wait a minute, we have this careful consensus that we've built up over years and we realize we're only going to be able to do half of this stuff.
03:23:11
And in my case, for example, the adjustments that we've made, say, by sitting down with Prince William County and saying, of the six projects, we're only going to be able to do five and that works.
03:23:23
But when you say Prince William, we're only going to do three and we need to move the money to Fairfax.
03:23:27
The other money to Fairfax, well, that sets off all the alarm bells
03:23:31
and all of a sudden the consensus starts crumbling very quickly about what the regional solutions are on things.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:23:40
I guess I'm prepared to volunteer to join your subcommittee.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:23:52
I would like to say since Dan Lysy is much too modest a guy to say this himself that
03:24:00
For the years that I've been on the board, I haven't had any difficulty understanding what the MPO's priorities are.
03:24:10
They've let me know early and often and annually and semi-annually and in written form and email form.
03:24:19
And if you look back over your priorities six, seven years ago and see where we are today, you see that most of the ones from those years have been ticked off.
03:24:28
Thelma
03:24:47
10 jurisdictions out of 30 or more jurisdictions in the district.
03:24:52
So it doesn't cover anywhere near the whole and I have a lot more rural district than I have urban district in terms of land area and needs and I feel this secondary road problem acutely in those places.
03:25:08
But anyway, the point is they have a process for developing priorities.
03:25:13
They've been very good about keeping up to date on what those priorities are.
03:25:17
And I have tried to be very good about fulfilling their hopes and dreams and getting the board to approve those priorities.
03:25:24
So even if we were to start today a month earlier on how they provide input, the fact is it's year to year to year and an ongoing process that is much more valuable than whether we start a few weeks earlier one way or another, which I'd certainly encourage.
03:25:43
In the long run, I think it's the ongoing dialogue and communication that makes most of it.
03:25:48
And I hope you agree with that.
SPEAKER_05
03:25:50
Certainly.
03:25:51
And I think one thing that is also very key is having early dialogue in the process.
03:25:58
If you're getting all the parties to the table and you put all the cards on the table and you try to get buy-in from the various parties involved, then they become
03:26:09
And then they have ownership of the projects that are moving forward and they may feel some responsibility in helping things get done, although local governments are in bad shape or worse than you all are today too.
03:26:23
It's really hard to speak from a local government perspective.
03:26:29
trying to move these things forward.
03:26:31
And again, Virginia is a state where it's really run through the CTB for administering, maintaining, building.
03:26:44
There's still that mentality, I think, I guess I'm trying to reflect.
03:26:52
And it's contradictory, too, in a way, because I really see Chesterfield, Hanover, and right in our region, they've come forward with bond projects of their own, with their own funds.
03:27:05
Chesterfield does a lot working with developers.
03:27:08
Don't worry, the General Assembly took that authority away.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:27:25
But to not contradict, but here's to kind of bring this, I think, back full circle.
03:27:35
What Mr. Koelemay is mentioning and Dr. Davis, I think, are the fact that, okay, we have these principles that are also in statute that say maintenance and federal match first.
03:27:47
Now, when you do that, you may have on your tip, and more importantly, your constrained long-range plan, projects that may or may not qualify under those principles.
03:28:03
So, what they're trying to point out is, okay, we have these principles, now how do I take your constrained long-range plan
03:28:16
And now that I have these principles, match them.
03:28:19
Because I only have a limited amount of money, and that limited amount of money has restrictions on it.
03:28:24
But then, to go with something that you said during your presentation, you have not updated your constrained long-range plan since we've done all these cutbacks.
03:28:35
So it's a catch-22.
03:28:36
It goes along with what you're saying.
03:28:40
Everyone's agreeing.
03:28:41
It's just that we're all picking out elements of it.
03:28:43
Yes?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
03:28:43
You had indicated that theirs was approved in 2007 for 2008 through... November 2007, with the Friends of Estes.
03:28:53
Correct.
03:28:54
We've just done some
03:28:56
A couple of months or months, an updated long-range financial plan that takes into account the $4.6 billion in budget reductions forecasted out 30 years for them to use to update their constrained long-range plans.
03:29:16
The next one.
03:29:17
But there are some MPOs who are starting that.
03:29:22
So their constrained long-range plans will in fact be severely impacted by those forecasts.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:29:32
And then the question becomes then how does that reflect it in our six-year plan?
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
03:29:37
Well, our impact is that the six years, we've adjusted it before they have.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:29:43
I know, but we trust them based on our own principles, which are different than their principles.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:29:49
And that's all I think we're... Mr. Chairman, it's easy to talk about, too, our priorities and easier to talk about, let's say legislative committee priorities for transportation.
03:30:01
Because I really wonder if the members of the General Assembly understand fully that
03:30:08
In order to spend federal money and to meet legislative statutory requirements, we don't have any money left to do half of our transportation network and take care of half of our transportation network in Virginia.
03:30:22
I really wonder if they understand that and if they believe that's in the best interest to come up for the long term, I think they have to somehow or another come to grips with that.
03:30:32
What we're doing is we're doing policy that we are able to do.
03:30:37
But they really have to understand that.
03:30:39
I'm curious if you've talked to them enough where you think they understand what's actually happening.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:30:45
Yeah, I think everyone starts on that.
03:30:50
I think everyone understands.
03:30:52
I think you are seeing, I mean, there is, I believe, a growing consensus out there that something has to be done.
03:31:01
Okay, now the questions are is what is it we do?
03:31:04
I mean, and now that's where we're going to have to, you know, let's, we deal with these issues here that we must deal with, given the current reality.
03:31:19
But then we have to
03:31:22
start to focus on, and I always keep on coming back to this, some structural changes to law and then looking also separately at just some of the funding options that may be available.
03:31:35
And over the next seven to 12 months, we'll be having the opportunity to lay those out and find a consensus
03:31:47
You know, I think it's like many other things in life.
03:31:52
You got to first find all the, let's find all the points we can agree with and set them all aside and all those points everyone disagrees with.
03:31:59
And then let's focus on trying to resolve the ones that we haven't mixed back.
SPEAKER_05
03:32:04
And that's going to be the charge over the next really on the next six months.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:32:09
So there has to be some fundamental shifts.
03:32:12
And I think everyone's starting to realize that.
03:32:15
I think you're hearing it in the public, you're seeing it in local government, you're seeing it in the public at large, and we've got to move forward on doing something.
SPEAKER_08
03:32:26
Yes, Mr. Stanton?
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:32:29
I absolutely agree with you, and I guess
03:32:34
Let me backtrack to say that I think when the surface transportation plan, when they began to show how streams of entities made decisions and money came in, that was the start, that little graph that was on the front of the plan.
03:32:49
But it seems to me that what we need to do to add in to increase the knowledge out there, which is where I think ultimately my concern is, is the public doesn't understand
03:33:01
When we go to these public hearings and someone phrased it to me as the 7-11 information approach that if you can't explain to somebody who's in line in front of you at the 7-11 what a particular concept is, they're not going to get it.
03:33:20
And so perhaps if we could look at also something visual that shows that there's this amount of federal money that we likely are going to have or reserve or whatever.
03:33:31
This chunk goes off, and this is the way, in very sort of graphic, bold graphic terms, how the money comes in goes out.
03:33:41
Because I will tell you that until I was on the CTB, I had no beginning understanding of this at all.
03:33:47
And I think most of the public out there doesn't
03:33:50
And I dare say that a lot of the legislators don't understand that that's not a lot of money that has flexibility to it.
03:34:00
It looks like a lot of money, and if you think you have a lot of money, then it's very hard to sort of come up with additional funds.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:34:07
Well, I'll just tell a little story about Ms. Busher here.
03:34:13
We were up at, I started hearing, and she got asked what appeared to be a very simple question.
03:34:20
And there's no simple answer when it comes to some of these funding streams and the restrictions, limitations, and the potential uses of it.
03:34:33
And it's hard to articulate.
03:34:36
It was sort of funny.
03:34:39
It was funny with you, not funny at you, Ms. Busher.
03:34:42
But it was just one of these interesting things.
03:34:46
You can't boil this stuff down, at least the way
03:34:50
The state deals with it right now, in particular the way the federal government deals with it.
03:34:56
I mean, there's so many pots of money, you know, sometimes I sit there, I just, I need one of those little acronym books just for the way, you know, where all the federal pots of money and what they can be used for.
03:35:07
And, but I think at least from the stuff that we can, that we have within the state's purview,
03:35:16
I do think there's an opportunity to try and provide better transparency and better, I'm going to say, nomenclature so people understand the linkage.
03:35:28
I do think one of the problems we face, and I always come back to the structural issue, and I call it that, but it's the way our transportation laws are formed and organized and the way that they deal with some of these
03:35:46
The challenges we have is that people just don't understand it.
03:35:52
And if they don't understand it, then they don't trust it.
03:35:56
And that means that we have to figure out ways to take essentially a code that was written in the 1930s.
03:36:06
And we've kept in that box, in my mind.
03:36:10
We've kept in that 1930s box everything that has grown from it.
03:36:14
And how do you start to pull it up, especially starting to pull it up with the recognition that we have growing interest in transit systems, rail systems, that many, or you know, today, marine systems, large systems that could provide transportation options at a lower price that potentially move, you know, a great amount of people and freight that really our code doesn't really know how to deal with.
03:36:46
What do you think, Dan?
03:36:48
Sure you want to sit up here?
SPEAKER_05
03:36:51
I think when I first, a few weeks ago, I said either congratulations or my condolences.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:36:59
These were opportunities, Dan.
03:37:02
But, you know, we would be very interested, just from your own perspective, and maybe talk to some of the other MTOs, to give some input into Dr. Davis' group as to how do we get you guys and some of your thoughts
03:37:16
Mr. Secretary.
Mary Lee Carter
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:37:45
We sit here and it's not all VDOT's fault, okay?
03:37:48
You all do a great job.
03:37:50
But however, also our MPOs have got to come together, not all as Ms. Pandak stated a few minutes ago.
03:38:01
MPOs sometimes they change members so often that they do not realize the policies that they should be abiding by.
03:38:11
And then you walk into MPO and this locality says, well, I want this and this locality says this, I want that.
03:38:18
It's not solved during that meeting.
03:38:20
So they come back to another meeting and that time has gone by, okay?
03:38:25
And then that same thing goes on and shaking your head yes, absolutely.
03:38:30
And this happens and I know, unlike Ms. Pandak, I served on MPO, but I didn't understand.
03:38:38
Until I became a CTB member.
03:38:41
And then I started to go to the NPO meetings also.
03:38:44
And I stated that every day, late term, you all can sit here and argue with just all you want, but you're letting time slip by and you're not going to get your funding.
03:38:57
You have to have that point in there.
03:38:59
And that's coming along better now.
03:39:02
And however, but this is what happens sometimes.
03:39:06
It's not all, they sometimes would like to say it's a state.
03:39:10
No, it's not.
03:39:12
Thank you.
03:39:13
I'm shaking your head yes.
03:39:15
This is a problem.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:39:18
Mr. Chairman, I'd like to follow up on Ms. Pandak's suggestion because when I joined the board, I was handed a flow chart of how the money flows.
03:39:26
And it was very, very valuable.
03:39:28
And it's changed a half a dozen times since then so that I don't have a current one.
03:39:34
But if you're probably the best person to hand it out, it would be nice to see.
SPEAKER_08
03:39:40
John did a great job.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:39:48
Well that's great because it's been a while since we've seen one and it's gotten only more complicated in the years since then.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:39:54
Is that same formula summarized in your bond information that we read from time to time about where all the revenues come from?
03:40:05
Like in the bond thing that we've got in today's action where you're selling bonds and that revenue stream that's summarized in there, is it similar to that?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:40:16
It's difficult on the federal because it's the difference between allocations and obligations, right?
03:40:40
We're learning that.
03:40:42
And then obviously our revenue streams are constantly changing.
03:40:46
So I can't get that detail.
03:40:51
Or I'm going to say point in time.
03:40:53
You can get a point in time, but it's only good for the second it came off that printer.
SPEAKER_05
03:41:04
All right.
SPEAKER_08
03:41:05
Excellent.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:41:07
I can't wait for the hearings.
03:41:10
And the report from Dr. Davis is up.
03:41:14
The last item on the work session is the legislative update.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
03:41:26
Good afternoon.
03:41:28
Happy St. Patrick's Day.
03:41:30
I think Scottish is the only day that I'm nice to the Irish.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:41:34
I do know that the Scottish originally came from the Irish.
03:41:38
It is true.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
03:41:40
Last month I made a presentation on a number of pieces of legislation that passed both houses.
03:41:48
This month I want to give you an update and mention several of those, several of which were amended or substitutes were offered since the last meeting.
03:41:58
But primarily, and what Carol is handling, are you handing this out or is this already there?
SPEAKER_08
03:42:03
No, this is already there.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
03:42:04
This is already there.
03:42:05
The first couple of pages, what we didn't have last month, are the budget amendments that have been offered or actually have been passed by the General Assembly.
03:42:16
And so I'll just go through those real quickly.
03:42:18
The first one is a perennial that we have regarding sound walls along the Dulles Toll Road connector.
03:42:26
between the Dulles toll road and I-66, the continuing requirement for the secretary to provide for the funding of those along with the rail project, the metro rail project.
03:42:40
The second item is something new that was added this year and has the Secretary reviewing VDOT's vegetation management policy.
03:42:50
The purpose is to limit mowing and vegetation control.
03:42:54
There's a report that will be
03:42:57
made by the Secretary to several committees to force a view of concurrence as far as the change in our vegetation policies.
03:43:07
The purpose behind this is to actually limit the amount of mowing and vegetation control that VDOT performs today, that that should be only to provide a safe environment
03:43:19
I would imagine a number of local governments may have issue with it because I'm assuming that we will be getting phone calls if this goes into place from local governments going out to cut the grass in areas that is growing fairly high.
03:43:38
The next item actually strikes language that was in the budget.
03:43:42
It's a DRPT-related matter.
03:43:44
That would require the CTB to develop criteria for grants for new transit service or expansion of existing transit service with priority for projects that also include land use commitments or located within urban development areas.
03:44:02
So this language is being stricken in this budget.
03:44:06
The next item is something that Steve Pittard mentioned in his presentation.
03:44:10
It allows the CTB and the adoption of a six-year program to allocate up to 20% of the Commonwealth Mass Transit Fund that is dedicated for capital purposes to transit operating assistance.
03:44:25
There's a general law that has also passed House Bill 421 that provides the same 20% allocation.
03:44:35
On the next page, again, a DRPT bill which allows for the waiver of the 30% matching requirement for the funding for improvements for the Richmond-Hampden Roads passenger rail project between Richmond and Norfolk.
03:44:52
It also authorizes up to $6 million, again, without the matching requirement to be utilized for the operation of the Amtrak Virginia three-year demonstration project.
03:45:04
The next item also deals with DRPT and it allows the CTB to provide an assessment or requires the director to provide the CTB with an assessment of anticipated ridership and funding required to support a pilot project with daily bus connector service.
03:45:26
from the Roanoke Valley to the Kemper Street Station in Lynchburg as part of this same ongoing three-year passenger rail demonstration project.
03:45:36
On the next page, beginning with VDOT budget amendments, the first one is a fairly significant budget amendment which requires the Secretary to undertake an analysis of the potential to substantially reduce the size and scope of the Virginia Transportation Research Council.
03:45:53
to more effectively utilize funding available for transportation.
03:45:57
There are a number of items that will be considered in this analysis with a recommendation from the Secretary on how to implement budget reductions of 25, 50 and 75 percent of the budget at the Research Council.
03:46:15
That will be due to various money and transportation committees by October 15th of this year.
03:46:21
The next item caps revenue sharing at $15 million per year.
03:46:27
As you'll recall, in the past, we had the $15 million in the general law, and historically, that had been appropriated, but the Board was given the authority to use up to $35 million in bonds, so there'd be a $50 million.
03:46:40
The General Assembly has now removed the ability to use capital appreciation and capital bonds for that purpose and has capped the revenue sharing at $15 million per year.
03:46:51
The next item is what we always see every year, a particular project.
03:46:57
This one is Route 193, Georgetown Pike.
03:47:01
This is called Land Here, Neck of the Woods.
03:47:03
Essentially would allow for context-sensitive design solutions for any improvements to that project.
03:47:11
And then finally, on the next page, it provides that the Secretaries of Transportation and Administration, along with the VDOT Commissioner,
03:47:21
and the DGS Director are to conduct an assessment of properties owned by VDOT that are not in active use to identify facilities that could be returned to private use.
03:47:33
Mr. Davies also provides for the sale of the Culpeper Residency, specifically mentions that and if no contract has been issued by December 1st of this year to sell that facility, the Commissioner has to report to the Chairman
03:47:50
of Appropriations and Chairman of Finance on the status of that property.
03:47:55
The next couple of bills are VDOT-related bills we talked about the last time, so I won't go into any detail on those.
03:48:03
On the next page is the bill, which takes the, what is now the jury system for end of the main proceedings and takes it back to either commissioners or a jury.
03:48:14
And if you go to the history of end of the main proceedings, for years it was commissioners, then it went to commissioners or juries, then it went to juries, and now it's going back to commissioners or juries.
03:48:26
The next item, again, is what I mentioned previously, Mr. Pittard had mentioned, is the general law
03:48:32
That allows the CTB to allocate 20% of capital funds to transit operating assistance.
03:48:41
The next bill is a governor's bill that you probably read about that provides for 70% of any revenues and royalties paid to the Commonwealth from offshore drilling to go into the Transportation Trust Fund.
03:48:55
The next bill deals with handbills.
03:48:57
For years, the General Assembly just added a jurisdiction or two every year, and that was done again this year.
03:49:04
There were about four jurisdictions, County Herndon, I can't remember all the rest, but at least three or four.
03:49:11
Finally, someone said, well, why don't we just make it applicable to all jurisdictions?
03:49:17
So that provision is now applicable to all jurisdictions.
03:49:21
Next bill, House Bill 197.
03:49:24
The next bill deals with outdoor advertising signs in Fairfax County.
SPEAKER_02
03:49:36
We have not been able to reach an agreement with Fairfax County because of the funding
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
03:49:41
And the present law which requires that 50% of the penalties go to VDOT.
03:49:45
This bill would allow 100% of the penalties to go to Fairfax County.
03:49:50
So hopefully they will now enter into an agreement with us to assist us in removing of the popsicle signs in the county.
03:49:58
Again, this law doesn't prohibit VDOT from doing it, but allows us to also enter an agreement with Fairfax to do it as well.
03:50:06
The next bill, House Bill 222, is the Titans Corner Bill that we mentioned last month.
03:50:12
The only change that was made is the original bill, the bill that passed out of the House, had the new development standards to be developed by and enforcement later than December 1st of 2011.
03:50:28
That's now been changed so that the standards developed by the parties
03:50:34
As required by this section, I will be submitted to VDOT for final review and approval at least three months prior to the jurisdiction's anticipated implementation date.
03:50:45
On the next page, the golf cart bill, again, only applicable to the account of Exmore.
03:50:53
I don't believe it has application anywhere else.
03:50:56
The next bill, Historic Route 1, started as being only in Chesterfield County, ended up being the entire state.
03:51:04
Went from Chesterfield, actually Colonial Heights was added, and then it was decided to name the entire section of Route 1 in Virginia Historic Route 1.
03:51:16
The next bill again deals with regulation of the top single signs.
03:51:20
In the highway right away was a compromise bill between Vaco, VML, the realtors, VDOT was involved in it as well, will allow the county volunteers to continue to remove these signs, but requires that these volunteers be trained and must comply with the requirements of this section.
03:51:41
There was concern with signs that were legally on private property being taken.
03:51:47
Actually the Chairman of House Transportation had pictures of one of his signs being taken off of private property.
03:51:56
So this was a compromise to address concerns with the proliferation of these signs.
03:52:03
House Bill 1159 deals with the move-over law, which was only applicable to police and rescued fire vehicles.
03:52:11
It's now applicable to tow trucks and VDOT vehicles.
03:52:15
So amber light vehicles on the shoulders of the highway drivers are required to move over.
03:52:22
House Bill 746 is a total payment penalty bill to do with all electronic tolling.
03:52:32
The future is all electronic tolling, no manual collection, the gantries.
03:52:37
This would allow for the photo enforcement of all electronic tolling.
03:52:44
Between the bill's introduction and what I talked to you last month, there was a provision added, an amendment to require notice
03:52:52
of the potential tripling of the toll if you do not have a transponder and the notice has to be in advance or give you the ability to get off the facility so that you will not have to pay this tripling of the toll.
03:53:09
There was also a working group established that would be looking at the mechanism for collecting these unpaid tolls.
03:53:19
One of the concerns presently in Northern Virginia, there are 13,000 pending cases dealing with toll collection.
03:53:27
We're overwhelming the courts with these, so let's see if we can come up with another mechanism to lessen the burden on the court.
03:53:37
The following bill deals with HOV lane use by military personnel.
03:53:42
It was originally only on the south side of Virginia Beach and Norfolk area.
03:53:46
It was expanded to include the peninsula.
03:53:48
So it's all active military duty members in uniform on 264 and 64.
03:53:55
It does require Federal Highway Administration approval before it goes into effect.
03:54:00
On the next page we get an HOV bill.
03:54:03
Every year we get a bill to extend the hybrid exemption on HOV lanes in Northern Virginia.
03:54:11
That passed this year, but Senator Barker also had a bill I believe along with Senator Colgan.
03:54:16
where we are going to grandfather and cap the number of hybrids on I-66 because I-66 is becoming a problem with the number of hybrid vehicles using that facility.
03:54:32
So vehicles will be now three sets of plates for clean fuel vehicles.
03:54:37
There will be one set that you can go anywhere, one set that limits those on 95-395 and then one set that will limit those on I-66.
03:54:47
So enforcement should be fun.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:54:52
Mr. Chairman, this is the first cap and trade system in the United States.
03:54:57
The license plates have their own value now.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:55:01
In fact, believe me, I know people who have sold their cars and those plates
03:55:06
It's a
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
03:55:22
As we all know, when Hot Lanes comes online, there will be no special except for HOV3.
03:55:31
So if you have a hybrid with three people, you'll be like everybody else, but if you're hybrid with one, you'll be paying.
03:55:38
Delegate Rust and Senator Herring have a bill dealing with the Dulles Access Highway because of concerns with those folks who aren't going to the airport that like to use the access road and make a U-turn and come back out.
03:55:50
This now takes what we have today as photo enforcement of toll violations and now taking photo enforcement to the next level, which is to traffic law enforcement.
03:56:00
But again, it's only limited to the Dulles Airport Access Highway.
03:56:04
On the following page of House Bill 402 is Delegate Oder's bill.
03:56:09
He's had it for the last two years.
03:56:12
This year it passed, which provides for VDOT to accept unsolicited proposals for the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
03:56:21
The next bill, House Bill 1309, increases from two to five million in the amount of all projects
03:56:28
In one contract dealing with environmental location design and inspection work, under the Procurement Act we can put multiple projects in the same RFP.
03:56:39
Cities that have population more than 80,000, the limit on their contract today is 5 million, so this just puts VDOT in the same category as those larger cities.
03:56:49
We'll save those procurement costs by having to constantly go back out to procure these services.
03:56:54
House Bill 564, Delia Patterson's bill is in response to the requirements of the TPOC, the TPOC grant that VDOT is going to be providing for 20 million dollars for this project which requires that the project be built as a design-builder PPPA project.
03:57:14
Virginia Beach was concerned that FTA may not prove such a contracting mechanism so it allows any procurement mechanism that FTA gives a blessing to to be used for that particular project.
03:57:29
It was mentioned earlier on the next page, House Bill 42, Senate Bill 201 is Transportation Program Performance Audit.
03:57:38
It is focused on the planning and programming functions within VDOT and DRPT principally focusing on the relationship with the MPOs and the MPO process and the recognition of the role of the MPOs.
03:57:56
The next bill deals with the privatizing of rest areas.
03:57:59
It's two studies, one in the House and one in the Senate.
03:58:02
The Research Council will be undertaking that study to look at alternatives to public funding of our rest areas.
03:58:11
Senate Bill 553 requires the Secretary to make an annual report to the General Assembly on action taken to promote transit use and to reduce highway congestion.
03:58:21
And then the final two bills, SJR 63 deals with funding of high speed passenger rail service.
03:58:30
And the final bill is the speed limit bill which provides for the raising of the speed limit to 70 miles per hour.
03:58:35
And I'll be happy to answer.
03:58:37
And there was a number of other bills passed which indirectly impact VDOT.
03:58:44
Most of those were on handout this last month if you have any questions.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:58:49
Any questions?
03:58:50
Mr. Chairman, I have one question about the budget amendment related to the Research Council.
03:59:01
Is that a result of some problem that we don't know about, or is that just a budget-driven view of a particular function?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:59:14
I'll answer the question.
03:59:21
There were some concerns raised regarding the research program and the, I'm going to say the time of the research and actual, the results of research into actual operations by, and usage by transportation.
03:59:43
So the issue was raised and we work with the,
03:59:52
The delegates and senators concerned and so we'll be having a third party come in and take a look at our program and you know have a report prepared and maybe with recommendations on how we end up showing that the research that we're conducting out there and the money that we're getting it because a lot of it is actually federal grants and others and actually how then we're taking that actually utilizing it in
04:00:18
improving our transportation programs.
04:00:21
But there was a concern, and I think part of it is just transparency.
04:00:30
Any other questions?
04:00:31
I just do want to mention one thing, that some of these bills have not been signed by the governor.
04:00:35
We've taken, unless the governor said anything publicly about them, there's no position until they're signed.
04:00:44
But there is a very strong possibility that some of these bills, there may be modifications.
04:00:50
just like any other bills that have been hanging out there.
04:00:57
Okay.
04:00:59
Do you want to take a quick break or no?
04:01:01
Do you want to just keep on going?
04:01:02
Sorry, 4 o'clock.
SPEAKER_04
04:01:03
Just one thing.
04:01:04
At your suggestion, I handed out a small, some comments on the Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel.
04:01:09
Do you want to do that now?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:01:11
I'm going to do it to our new business under CTB.
04:01:13
You want to do it now, whichever?
04:01:15
Listen, I just want to pass out to everybody.
04:01:17
We have
04:01:19
The new pins, the Governor of the McDonald Administration new lapel pins, one for everyone.
04:01:28
Take those ones out, we'll have a little ceremony.
Thelma D. Drake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:01:36
Here are yours, if I wanted to please take one.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:01:50
And since it's already four o'clock, do you mind if we just adjourn the work session, go right into the meeting?
04:02:03
Is that okay with everybody?
04:02:04
We'll wait for Ms. Carroll to come back.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:02:11
And I got one for you as well for all your hard work.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:02:16
Okay, with that we're going to...
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:02:21
Yes.
04:02:23
Don't scratch it too much.
04:02:25
Actually, what's interesting about it, I hope you look in the back to see if the Governor's signature is on the back.
04:02:30
That's what I thought he did.
04:02:32
Alrighty, we're going to adjourn our work session.
04:02:34
At this point we're going to...