Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 5/20/2009
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   5/20/2009

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Bids.pdf
  • Additional stimulus project recommendations.pdf
  • VDOT's budget reduction strategies.pdf
  • VDOT budget reductions for Fiscal Year 2010.pdf
  • VDOT service reduction recommendations.pdf
  • VDOT organization and staffing.pdf
  • Rail Industrial Access Program application briefing, Woodfuels Virginia, Louisa County.pdf
  • VTrans2035 policy report, natural and human environment report.pdf
  • Proposed access management regulations and standards for minor arterials,collectors and local streets.pdf
  • 1. ARRA Stimulus Update

  • 2. FY10-FY15 Six-Year Improvement Plan Recommendations

    • DRPT draft Six-Year Improvement Program Fiscal Years 2010-2015.pdf
    • VDOT draft Six-Year Improvement Program, Fiscal Years 2010 - 2015.pdf
  • 3. Blueprint Directions a. Overview

  • 4. Discussion on Future Direction for the Board

  • 5. Woodfuels Virginia, L.L.C. Industrial Access Project**

  • 6. VTRANS 2035 ** a. Transportation Performance Report

    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:00:00
      I want to have a point of order.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:15
      Good afternoon, everyone.
    • 00:00:17
      I'd like to open the May work session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:23
      I think as everyone knows in the room, there are some very consequential presentations today on the agenda.
    • 00:00:30
      So this will be a long meeting, and we will encourage folks to ask questions first and foremost.
    • 00:00:38
      But there are really two major items for folks, particularly those in the audience, to pay attention to.
    • 00:00:45
      The first is an update on the stimulus program and some additional projects that we'll be asking for approval tomorrow.
    • 00:00:54
      That's a very important program, not only for transportation but to support our highway, bridge, and rail contractors who
    • 00:01:05
      If they don't get to work, they can't stay in business.
    • 00:01:07
      And so that's a very important undertaking for those two reasons.
    • 00:01:11
      The second major set of issues is the Commissioner's presentation on his final recommendations with respect to the Six-Year Program.
    • 00:01:21
      And we've been in the business of cutting programs.
    • 00:01:23
      We know how to do that rather well.
    • 00:01:26
      But our financial situation is such that we have to go beyond that this year.
    • 00:01:30
      And these are not one-time cuts.
    • 00:01:33
      And the commissioner's final recommendations to this body will be taken up in a voting fashion at our business meeting during June when we adopt the final six-year program and when we adopt the final budget.
    • 00:01:48
      And so the presentations today by the commissioner include not just a draft six-year program by his staff, but the commissioner's personal recommendations with respect to reduced services,
    • 00:02:02
      and also with reduced staffing.
    • 00:02:07
      And both of those sets of recommendations have very significant long-term consequences, not just for VDOT but for the citizens, the way that they are able to drive on the highways, how it will look, how it will feel.
    • 00:02:23
      And as I indicated, these are not one-time cuts to get through a one-time budget shortfall.
    • 00:02:31
      In many respects, when you see these recommendations, what you will see, this is the beginning of a transformation of the agency in several directions.
    • 00:02:40
      The budgetary recognition, what we have to do, continue to do, to simply maintain what we already have.
    • 00:02:47
      The consequences for that in terms of staffing and the services will be rather visible and so again these are very important discussions and at the end of the Commissioner's presentation I want to go around the table and ask for comment as we go forward on and I would appreciate it if each member would take some time to comment not only how this will affect their individual district or region or assignment
    • 00:03:17
      But any recommendations that you might have for the formal budget adoption, again, that would be for the June business meeting.
    • 00:03:26
      We need to get that all out on the table in a public and transparent setting in order to set the stage for that final adoption in June.
    • 00:03:33
      Are there any questions about process?
    • 00:03:36
      Okay, if not, we're going to start with the initial presentation on the stimulus update, and we have Mr. Pittard and Ms. Busher giving us a quick overview.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:03:48
      Welcome, Ms. Busher.
    • 00:03:51
      Good afternoon.
    • 00:04:15
      This presentation, a number of the slides you have seen before, but what we're trying to do is keep this as a package presentation and update it as we move forward and finalize the decision on the projects to be funded.
    • 00:04:30
      So a lot of these slides you've seen previously, so I will go through them rather quickly.
    • 00:04:38
      As we've indicated before,
    • 00:04:41
      Nationwide, the stimulus program or the ARRA program was a total of $47.9 billion.
    • 00:04:55
      And transportation was 6.1% of that total.
    • 00:05:06
      The discretionary grant program, as we've mentioned before, was $1.5 billion, and I believe the requirements for that program have been released for comment or feedback from the state.
    • 00:05:35
      Just to recount, with the Governor's website, $466 billion in Virginia projects were submitted on the Governor's website, approximately $194 billion in transportation projects, or about $41.66 billion in total value submitted.
    • 00:05:55
      Total projects submitted a little over $9,000, and 1,800 of those were transportation related, or about 20% of the total projects.
    • 00:06:06
      The Recovery Act Highway priorities, the federal project priorities, one, we have to meet all the normal, regular federal requirements.
    • 00:06:15
      Fifty percent of the funding had to be obligated in 120 days, which is June 29, 2009.
    • 00:06:23
      They preferred projects that would be completed within three years, and they wanted us to give priority to projects that would be in economically distressed areas.
    • 00:06:33
      For the Commonwealth, we had priorities going into this, looking at structurally deficient bridges, deficient pavement.
    • 00:06:42
      We had highlighted several BRAC requirements or needs.
    • 00:06:46
      We looked at the cancelled and delayed highway and rail projects from the revised 9-14 Six-Year Improvement Program, and then we looked at the citizens' suggestions from the Governor's website.
    • 00:06:59
      Just as a quick review, we have approximately $1 billion in immediate interstate and primary pavement needs and this graph shows the deficient, the very poor condition in red, the roads in red across the state.
    • 00:07:20
      The next slide shows the deficient bridges, and if we were to try to read them all today, it would take about $3.7 billion to replace the deficient bridges throughout the state.
    • 00:07:31
      And again, they're represented here across the track.
    • 00:07:36
      We had to go through quite an extensive consultation process.
    • 00:07:40
      We started with getting some education and understanding from USDOT and FHWA.
    • 00:07:48
      We've made several presentations to the congressional delegation and the General Assembly, the House Appropriations, and the Joint Commission on Transportation Accountability.
    • 00:07:57
      We have been communicating with the MPOs to obtain PIP amendments.
    • 00:08:02
      and we communicated with localities and various advocacy groups.
    • 00:08:09
      It's also a lengthy allocation process.
    • 00:08:13
      We start with the citizens' recommendations on the Governor's website.
    • 00:08:17
      We looked at VDOT, DRPT and the NPO recommendations.
    • 00:08:22
      We brought to you project proposals for approval.
    • 00:08:28
      And we're looking for amendments and those are happening over a period of time from the MPOs.
    • 00:08:34
      The governor then certifies the project list to USDOT.
    • 00:08:38
      Then we're able to obligate the funds and then award and execute the project.
    • 00:08:45
      As I mentioned previously, the Discretionary Grant Program of $1.5 billion is competitive, and eligible projects can include but aren't limited to highways, bridges, rural collectors, transit, passenger, freight rail, and Ford infrastructure.
    • 00:09:06
      B. Doolittle, John C. Doolittle, John Doolittle, John C. Doolittle, John Doolittle, John C.
    • 00:09:25
      direct FAA funding to Virginia Airport.
    • 00:09:29
      We're looking at the Dulles Runway at $15 million, Franklin Runway at $2.15 million, and a Mobile Rescue Trainer at $2.4 million.
    • 00:09:40
      In rail, there was $9.3 billion for nationwide.
    • 00:09:44
      $8 billion was for high-speed and inner-city rail corridor program.
    • 00:09:49
      And $1.3 billion was for Amtrak Capital Grants.
    • 00:09:54
      These are the high-speed rail corridor designations that are in place today, just for your information.
    • 00:10:07
      Public transportation, $8.4 billion nationwide, $6.9 billion is for urbanized area formula grants, rural area formula passes through
    • 00:10:21
      700 million for growing states and high density programs allocated to states based on formula.
    • 00:10:31
      50% must be obligated within 180 days whereas highway was 120 days.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:38
      And the remaining 50% must be obligated within one year.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:10:43
      750 million was set aside for rail modernization grants and 750 million in rail new start and small start grants.
    • 00:10:57
      For transit, the urbanized formula grant, we're looking at the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority at 202 million for facilities, buses, and equipment.
    • 00:11:09
      For Virginia Rail Express, 9.8 million for locomotives.
    • 00:11:14
      for Potomac and Rappahannock Transportation Commission, $3.9 million for bus and capital replacement.
    • 00:11:22
      The Greater Richmond Transit Company, $13.8 million for the transit center and paratransit vehicles.
    • 00:11:29
      And the Hampton Roads Transit, $24.1 million for facilities, buses, and equipment.
    • 00:11:37
      Now the transit small urban and rural grants, we received $30.5 million for this category.
    • 00:11:45
      And in April, you had allocated $17.3 million in initial grants.
    • 00:11:50
      For small urban, about $13.5 million and rules $3.8 million.
    • 00:11:55
      And in early, late summer, early fall, they'll bring back the next recommendation for the remaining $13.2 million.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:05
      Down the highway to 27.5 billion nationwide, Virginia will receive 694.5 million.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:12:14
      That breaks down by 20.8 million for enhancement.
    • 00:12:18
      Approximately 30% or 208 million that would be distributed based on the surface transportation program formula, which is population-based.
    • 00:12:31
      And then the discretionary statewide dollars represent about 57% or $455.3 million.
    • 00:12:39
      And again, 50% of the discretionary funds must be obligated within 120 days.
    • 00:12:51
      Just a small caveat.
    • 00:12:54
      When we put together and bring to you the project for approval, the estimates are at that point, or the project costs are changing.
    • 00:13:02
      So some of these will be changing, and in particular what you'll see this afternoon
    • 00:13:08
      III, and Byron Coburn percent for award, several of the advertised projects, we've gotten good bids on pavement projects that we've advertised.
    • 00:13:21
      At the April meeting, you approved approximately $328 million in initial paving, bridge,
    • 00:13:29
      The five large urban metropolitan planning organizations will have received $118 million directly and they're reviewing projects currently.
    • 00:13:51
      We have about $250 million.
    • 00:13:54
      in ARRA funds remaining to be allocated from the VDOT perspective.
    • 00:14:00
      And what I'm going to show you on the next several slides is some projects that we're bringing to you through Google tomorrow.
    • 00:14:10
      They're color coded in orange.
    • 00:14:14
      You've already approved the 20.8 million in enhancement projects.
    • 00:14:19
      This slide is just a reminder of the projects that were approved.
    • 00:14:28
      The BRAC project also totaling about 96 million you approved last time, about 11 million for Fort Lee.
    • 00:14:36
      60 million for Fort Belvoir, which is the Fairfax County Parkway Phase III and IV, and Fort Euchas with 24.5.
    • 00:14:50
      The structurally deficient and functionally obsolete bridges
    • 00:14:55
      Last meeting, we approved a perhaps type of $66 million in bridge projects that was approximately 119 small, structurally-efficient bridges in seven design-build contracts.
    • 00:15:10
      We've added the Robertson Bridge in Danville, and on Route 61, the Narrows Bridge, and Route 630 of the CSX crossing.
    • 00:15:23
      and these total 116.1 million.
    • 00:15:32
      We also brought to you last time 110,000
    • 00:15:37
      M. Nillion in Deficient Pavement.
    • 00:15:42
      That's where the pavement index is 53 or less for most of the segments.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:48
      It accounted for about 430 lane miles of interstate and primary highway paving and overlay.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:15:54
      We're adding to that a Mercury Boulevard pavement project in Hampton for 3.6 years.
    • 00:16:03
      Of the original 110, this is how it broke down by lane miles and dollar value in each district.
    • 00:16:15
      We had also gotten your approval for an additional list of pavement projects, given the fact that the bids were coming in below our estimates to make sure that we have enough, $110 million worth of deficient pavement approved.
    • 00:16:37
      So between the combination of the two lists, we would be able to reach that number.
    • 00:16:44
      The rail project, last time you had approved Route 164 rail relocation enforcement.
    • 00:16:51
      We're proposing the NIP central rail yard in Norfolk, and the AFI yard, the PE on that project, Richmond Henrico, and the Route 28 Manassas rail grade crossing.
    • 00:17:05
      I am presenting these projects on behalf of DRPT to keep it in one presentation that they
    • 00:17:18
      On the highway construction, we're looking at $122.9 million between the next two slides.
    • 00:17:26
      The one that you had approved last time was the route through widening in Spotsylvania.
    • 00:17:32
      We are also proposing Princess Anne Road widening in Virginia Beach, Fort Republic Road in Harrisburg, Fair Lake Center change in Fairfax, and I-64 safety improvements in Allegheny.
    • 00:17:48
      To continue, we've also added I-64 exit improvements in Charlottesville, the Courthouse Road interchange in Arlington, German School Road in Richmond, and Wichita Road widening in Virginia Beach.
    • 00:18:09
      We still have a small list of additional potential ARRA projects, construction projects that are listed on this slide, and we will be reviewing these and making final recommendations.
    • 00:18:23
      Thank you.
    • 00:18:29
      In summary, the CTB is used for $328 million on April 16th.
    • 00:18:38
      The Governor certified May 12th our first ARRA project list, totaling $160.2 million, the bulk of that being pavement and bridge projects.
    • 00:18:50
      FHWA has obligated $120.2 million, and we have advertised $177 million today.
    • 00:19:00
      And the total of the projects that we bring to you tomorrow is $204 million.
    • 00:19:06
      It would be a four-inch project that we just made.
    • 00:19:11
      Steve Pittard and I would be happy to answer any questions.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:19:23
      I have a general question relative to the higher speed rail.
    • 00:19:29
      Could somebody give us a three-minute synopsis of where we are with higher speed rail relative to Washington to Richburg and the corridor, what's funded, what's not funded, what we're trying to include in the stimulus package,
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:46
      I'm going to ask Chip to fill in a little bit but in summary we have a statewide rail plan and remember it is high speed and intercity rail is the nature of the stimulus package and so the emphasis both in the budget and in this program has with respect to those higher speed corridors has been in the 95 and 64 corridors so there's a list of projects
    • 00:20:15
      have been approved previously by this body and those are what are moving forward in that process.
    • 00:20:21
      And that's following a more traditional state-led process now with the advent of additional money for high-speed rail and intercity rail.
    • 00:20:32
      There's a major environmental study underway and I'm going to ask Mr. Badger to update you on that.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:36
      Certainly, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:20:38
      In terms of the federal level, the Federal Railroad Administration has issued their strategic plan that sets out the policies and the general framework for how they're going to go forward with the $8 billion program.
    • 00:20:50
      They're going to be providing the guidelines for applying for the funds in June.
    • 00:20:55
      In the meantime, they are holding a series of workshops and our chief of rail transportation is down in Charlotte this afternoon attending that at the request of FRA.
    • 00:21:04
      We have a list of projects, certainly for I-95, that we have been working on as part of the rail plan.
    • 00:21:13
      We've been working with the Federal Railroad Administration, Amtrak, DRE, Norfolk Southern, and all our partners on potential projects that we think are ready to go.
    • 00:21:22
      As soon as we get the guidelines, we'll be ready to submit an application.
    • 00:21:27
      For I-95 in particular, we're developing a corridor development plan.
    • 00:21:31
      It's going to set out the projects that we think need to be done, some priorities and preliminary cost estimates.
    • 00:21:39
      So we're in pretty good shape.
    • 00:21:42
      We feel like we're going to be in a very good position to compete for these funds and we'll be ready to apply as soon as we get some instructions on how to do it.
    • 00:21:50
      With regard to the Washington to Richmond
    • 00:21:52
      Rail.
    • 00:21:53
      We have a draft EIS that is being reviewed right now by the Federal Transit Administration.
    • 00:22:00
      As soon as that review is done, we will release it for public comment.
    • 00:22:03
      We will hold public hearings later this summer or early this fall and then hope to get a record of decision from the Federal Railroad Administration on whatever improvements will go forward maybe by December.
    • 00:22:15
      At that point in time we would be in a position to actually apply for grants for preliminary engineering or design or whatever type of work needs to be done for the project that emerged from that environmental study.
    • 00:22:29
      So we are ready to go to submit applications between Washington and Richmond.
    • 00:22:35
      We're wrapping up the environmental work between Richmond and Hampton Roads.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:22:40
      So on the Washington to Richmond piece of it,
    • 00:22:44
      in a position to apply for and accept stimulus funds to work on that project.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:51
      That's correct.
    • 00:22:51
      We still need to get those guidelines.
    • 00:22:54
      We are consulting with the railroads and FRA.
    • 00:22:57
      We're very close to reaching a list of consensus projects.
    • 00:23:02
      And then depending on which projects fit with the guidelines, we should get a position to actually submit applications.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:23:07
      And what do we think our cost, roughly, is going to be for that to complete that
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:14
      The total cost for all the improvements we've identified are in the billions, so we have no shortage of assets.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:21
      These all eight billion?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:22
      Not quite eight, but realistically we have several hundred million dollars worth of projects we could apply for immediately.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:23:31
      From Richmond to Raleigh?
    • 00:23:33
      I mean Richmond to Washington.
    • 00:23:35
      That's correct.
    • 00:23:36
      A hundred billion?
    • 00:23:37
      No, several hundred million.
    • 00:23:41
      So we could conceivably get money enough to complete that leg of the quarter, is that?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:49
      No, the cost, not the complete, we can make substantial progress.
    • 00:23:55
      All of the projects that we've identified, and this would include
    • 00:23:59
      A possible new bridge over the Potomac River into Washington, D.C. are, like I say, in the billions.
    • 00:24:06
      So to do everything that we think needs to be done is going to require more money than we have any realistic expectations to get.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:17
      In light of that, I think it would probably, because of the interest, probably worthwhile at our next work session, time permitting, to have an overview of these.
    • 00:24:25
      There are so many overlapping studies.
    • 00:24:27
      I think a lot of people are confused by the differing studies.
    • 00:24:32
      That, I think, would be beneficial if that's something, Chip, that your staff can accommodate.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:24:39
      If I may make one follow-up comment.
    • 00:24:41
      There is a message that I would like to deliver from Hampton Roads, and that is they don't want to get left out of the hot-speed rail or higher-speed rail equation.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:58
      And I do think on that note that one of the things we tried to do with the Virginia rail program is to broadly reach, so if you look at the passenger rail initiatives,
    • 00:25:14
      I'm going to Lynchburg, going to Richmond, and then on from Richmond to Point South, on from Lynchburg to Point South.
    • 00:25:23
      And those programs are scaled, so we've done a lot of homework, and I think we're better positioned than a number of other states.
    • 00:25:30
      It's important to remember, though, that this program and the guidance that they sent out just late last week is to say high speed and intercity rail.
    • 00:25:40
      And so funds that we can compete for very capably may not be for 120 or 150 mile an hour train, but having reliable, high quality and relatively frequent rail service is a very, very worthy goal for our major
    • 00:26:00
      Urban Centers.
    • 00:26:01
      And what we have to do is find that market niche, as we did in Lynchburg and are in the process of doing enrichment.
    • 00:26:08
      Where do the lines intersect in terms of affordability, ridership, and where does it make sense?
    • 00:26:15
      And they're going to be asking those questions at the national level.
    • 00:26:17
      We're going to be very, very self-interested in how we approach that.
    • 00:26:22
      And Hampton Roads has a very important role
    • 00:26:27
      in the development of rail, both on the peninsula and south side.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:26:31
      There's 1.7 million people there that would be good customers, so just pass that information along to them.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:38
      Thank you, sir.
    • 00:26:39
      If we could just go back, are there any other questions on the stimulus?
    • 00:26:42
      Does everybody understand from the presentation the projects that are illustrated in the gold color are the new decisions, and you'll be asked to vote on those tomorrow.
    • 00:26:50
      Are there any questions about those additional projects?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:54
      Will we have another round of projects to be selected and what's that schedule?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:01
      Ms. Bush was there about $45 million on allocated.
    • 00:27:06
      So my guess would be at the next meeting we will complete the project designations.
    • 00:27:14
      If there are some savings and we're seeing this afternoon bids coming in lower than estimated, that number may be a little bit more than $45 million.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:27:24
      Oh, Ms. Pittard, come on up to the microphone, please.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:34
      And those are for the small, urban, and rural transit grants.
    • 00:27:40
      We did half last time and are in the process of soliciting additional grant requests as we speak.
    • 00:27:47
      Okay, Ms. Gordon.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:48
      Following up on that question on phase two, and do you have a list
    • 00:27:54
      of the potential allocations where they would maybe go that we might review.
    • 00:28:03
      When I speak of that, I believe it was a phase two and we were speaking one time about 208 in Spotsylvania County.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:10
      Oh, if there's a list of potential additional projects, I don't know if they're included in this presentation or not.
    • 00:28:19
      Yes, they are.
    • 00:28:20
      And I don't believe that that project is on there.
    • 00:28:24
      If you look at the balance between the Route 630 bridge and the Route 3 project and the Fredericksburg
    • 00:28:31
      I think there are some other districts that probably deserve a place a little bit higher up in line.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:36
      But I believe that the 630 Bridge is very, very important in Stafford County, absolutely.
    • 00:28:42
      But I believe that came under the stimulus for the bridges separate from the transportation issue that I'm speaking of on the 208.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:51
      It's all the same pot of funding, Ms. Carter.
    • 00:28:55
      It is?
    • 00:28:55
      Yes, ma'am.
    • 00:28:56
      It's the surface transportation program you can use for highways, you can use for rail, you can use for transit, new construction maintenance.
    • 00:29:03
      It's a very flexible funding source.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:06
      So I'm assuming then that the comment that I received yesterday that the funding that was to go to the 208 project is going to Stafford for the bridge in 630, is that true?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:23
      Well, no, that funding had never been designated.
    • 00:29:27
      The Route 208 courthouse bypass was an eligible project.
    • 00:29:34
      It still is potentially an eligible project, given its cost, given the other allocations, it's not a strong candidate at this point.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:42
      And we'll discuss the reason later.
    • 00:29:44
      Thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:44
      Yes, ma'am.
    • 00:29:45
      I mean, please bring it up.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:47
      I will.
    • 00:29:47
      Okay.
    • 00:29:48
      Thank you.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:50
      Mr. Chairman, I'm just curious, since with the paving projects, we're getting a better deal in lower unit costs, and if some of these
    • 00:30:00
      Say the VRE or any of the other projects that they are actually getting more dollars or more value for their dollars.
    • 00:30:09
      What happens to the balance?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:15
      I'm going to let Ms. Busher handle that one.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:30:18
      I'm not sure all projects will come in under, so it's going to be, as we advertise an award, we're just going to be keeping a running tally, and then at the end, we'll see where we are, and we've got, as the Secretary indicated on this list, and I'm sure DRPT would have some opportunities to spread those dollars on other projects that qualify.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:46
      And this money then is on a reimbursable basis.
    • 00:30:49
      In other words, Hampton Roads Transit, if they could build their facility for $20 million, they would only be compensated for $20 million.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 00:31:04
      Those funds are actually going to be received directly by Hampton Roads Transit, this body that was really passed before we allocate them.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:15
      And in that instance, they were allocated $24 million.
    • 00:31:19
      So if the project comes in low bid, they have some additional money.
    • 00:31:22
      They need to know relatively soon, though, by the end of next federal fiscal year, whether or not they can obligate additional funds on other projects.
    • 00:31:33
      Okay, any other questions or comments?
    • 00:31:36
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:31:38
      The next item on the agenda, Ms. Busher and Mr. Pittard, while you're still there, is the presentation on the, how should we characterize the Incredible Drinking Six-Year Improvement Program?
    • 00:31:52
      And I think some of the bar charts will illustrate that point
    • 00:31:57
      If you go back to the last several presentations, there are really three legs to the stool that have been laid out for meeting our budget targets which are vastly lower than where they were even a year ago.
    • 00:32:14
      And if you look at those targets,
    • 00:32:18
      About just shy of three-quarters of the budgetary reductions are going to be taken in the highway construction program.
    • 00:32:25
      And that's what's being reflected in this presentation.
    • 00:32:29
      Transit and rail is undergoing some revenue reductions, but in the grand scheme of things, really holding their own compared to other agencies of state government.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:32:40
      Welcome, Ms. Busher.
    • 00:32:46
      There's a VDOT portion of the secure program.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:49
      Excuse me.
    • 00:32:50
      Can folks in back here?
    • 00:32:52
      No.
    • 00:32:54
      Rita, can you speak into the microphone and can somebody adjust the sound?
    • 00:32:58
      Maybe play with that a little bit.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:33:01
      Can you hear me now if I speak up?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:03
      Is that any better?
    • 00:33:03
      A little bit better.
    • 00:33:05
      Lift up the microphone.
    • 00:33:06
      You have to be real close.
    • 00:33:07
      These are...
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:33:09
      Okay, I'll give it a shot.
    • 00:33:11
      I'm going to deliver the VDOT portion of the program and Mr. Pittard will deliver the DRPT portion after I finish and then we'll both be happy to answer any questions.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:27
      You have your notebooks in front of you.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:33:29
      What is new in the notebook is a section in the back or near the front actually I believe.
    • 00:33:38
      A separate section showing the stimulus projects that have been allocated to date.
    • 00:33:50
      The total draft provides Six-Year Improvement Program for fiscal years 10 through 15 including rail and public transportation is $7.4 billion.
    • 00:34:05
      As you can see,
    • 00:34:08
      The Six-Year Improvement Program has been declining over the last several years as a result of the economic downturn and the loss of both state and federal revenues.
    • 00:34:21
      The draft 2010-15 program totaled $7.4 billion down from the $8.9 billion in the 9-14 revised program, by the way, which we revised just three months ago, a decrease of approximately $1.5 billion.
    • 00:34:41
      Now, much of the decrease from the highway construction perspective is the result of dropping off the 2009 fiscal year and the 2015 fiscal year and some of the reductions in funding as a result of that and I'll talk in a little bit more detail on that in the next few slides.
    • 00:35:09
      This was an extremely difficult program in terms of the development.
    • 00:35:17
      As everyone is aware, we reduced the highway program by two billion in the revised 9-14.
    • 00:35:27
      and we are still facing some serious programming issues for the 10 through 15 update.
    • 00:35:34
      A state revenue reduction in the fall is still a potential as well as federal revenue reductions above the reserve.
    • 00:35:43
      As you recall, we're reserving about a little over 100 million a year until we find out what the 10 federal funding will be.
    • 00:35:58
      The revised 9-14 program incorporated reduced funding on 808 projects or project phases, and the bulk of these cuts were on the secondary and urban systems.
    • 00:36:15
      In the development of the 2010-15 program, we were forced to review previous project allocations on the interstate to help us fully fund
    • 00:36:29
      Federal qualifying projects and obligate all of our federal dollars for federal fiscal year 2009.
    • 00:36:38
      In other words, we moved previous interstate allocations, that means from fiscal year nine back, from all districts to one district.
    • 00:36:51
      And we did that to fund two projects specifically for federal strategy or to use all of our federal dollars for fiscal mind.
    • 00:37:01
      And I'll show you that in a little bit.
    • 00:37:05
      When we talk about the 10 through 15 program, we're still talking about whether our Six-Year Improvement Program is sustainable going forward.
    • 00:37:15
      Let me just outline briefly some of the things that we're proposing and some of the things we've already instituted in terms of changes in the way we've had to do business.
    • 00:37:26
      We have in fact reduced all available state funds in the construction program.
    • 00:37:33
      Our ability to issue the $3 billion in bonds authorized by House Bill 3202 has been compromised with the reduction in the state revenue.
    • 00:37:45
      We've restricted our funding to projects that are...
    • 00:37:51
      As I've mentioned previously, given the reduction in the insurance premium revenues from the PTF fund, which is our dedicated resource to pay back bonds, principal and interest, that reduction in that revenue source is not allowing us to issue $3 billion in bonds over a significant period of time.
    • 00:38:15
      We're looking more along the lines of a little over $2 billion.
    • 00:38:20
      That we would be able to authorize and sell.
    • 00:38:24
      So we just have to manage, stay within our available resources from the insurance premiums to sell bonds.
    • 00:38:31
      We have to live within our means of the reduced revenue source.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:34
      It means less.
    • 00:38:36
      That's what I thought.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:38
      I just wondered how much less.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:41
      It's only a billion.
    • 00:38:42
      About one-third less.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:38:46
      As I said, we've restricted funding to projects already obligated for federal funds or projects that are going to be obligated this federal fiscal year because the phase is already underway and we have to cover increases in estimates.
    • 00:39:05
      As you know, in the revised 1914, we eliminated the state formula distributions for unpaid roads, primary, secondary, and urban systems.
    • 00:39:18
      We are also now proposing that the surface transportation program federal formula funding by population that we no longer distribute it by locality, but we have it programmed by the CTB and we're looking to start that in fiscal 2011.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:39
      All right, now let's pause right there and understand this is a very, very significant step.
    • 00:39:47
      and understand what this means.
    • 00:39:49
      This is not a healthy program and these are some of the things that you have to do to maintain a semblance of fiscal accountability.
    • 00:40:00
      But since the mid-1990s, there have been federal STP funds that have to be allocated on a population formula and essentially those have been dumped into the allocation formula so they come back to cities and towns and counties in the secondary and the urban and the primary allocation.
    • 00:40:22
      There is so little left in those accounts that you cannot aggregate those into a meaningful project.
    • 00:40:29
      This is the Alan Witt issue that Mr. Witt has been telling us about for a number of years.
    • 00:40:34
      And so what is going to be occurring, except for projects where there are committed funds and they're obligated, they're going to roll up into a statewide program.
    • 00:40:45
      Again, have to be allocated on a population basis, but that will be done essentially at a district level
    • 00:40:52
      This is a very significant step and this comes on top of last year we took all of the state formula dollars out of those allocations.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:15
      Mr. Chairman, the previous bullet might require a little bit of elaboration.
    • 00:41:20
      Eliminate state form of distribution for unpaved roads, primary, secondary, and urban systems.
    • 00:41:28
      That means that there's no CTB meeting to allocate funds to projects.
    • 00:41:33
      We just do away with public hearings and meetings and
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:41:38
      This is the 40-30-30 allocation through state formula to primary, secondary, and urban and a piece of paved roads.
    • 00:41:48
      When we had to reduce total state, or the available state funds in the construction
    • 00:41:56
      It basically eliminated the, we had no funds left at the end of the distribution series and that's on the bottom to put in that formula.
    • 00:42:08
      So that just went away.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:13
      and what this means in practical terms.
    • 00:42:15
      The state funds that are referenced here, those are already gone.
    • 00:42:19
      Those were taken out when we did the revised six-year program in February.
    • 00:42:22
      What we're taking out is the next bullet, which is the federal funding.
    • 00:42:26
      And the secondary, as you know, is controlled by the counties.
    • 00:42:29
      They hold the public hearings and do project selection.
    • 00:42:32
      The urban done by the cities, what that means for the CTB is essentially there is no
    • 00:42:41
      traditional formula money going to primary highways.
    • 00:42:45
      And I would suggest to you that the process for the next update of the Six-Year Program, I won't be here, hopefully most of you will be here, is gonna look a lot more like the stimulus process, where there is a single statewide pot of money and there are specific criteria for the worst pavement, worst bridges, economic development, maybe.
    • 00:43:08
      That's where we are.
    • 00:43:10
      And what that means, for example, to a growing locality such as Spotsylvania County, trying to do the courthouse road interchange that Ms. Carter was talking about earlier, there is no money that is under the control or even the influence of the locality to bring to bear on that project.
    • 00:43:30
      So we by attrition are arriving at a statewide program and the code does not really prescribe an easy way to do that so it is up to the Commonwealth Transportation Board to develop internal rules of both fairness
    • 00:43:49
      and effectiveness, and I do think we've broken some ground with the stimulus in terms of choosing the worst pavement and bridges, but it's a lot harder when you start thinking about how do you weigh the Courthouse Road bypass versus the Witch Duck Road widening in Virginia Beach.
    • 00:44:08
      Those are much harder choices and don't lend themselves necessarily to simple numbers.
    • 00:44:14
      So this is a very, very important step.
    • 00:44:17
      We're losing essentially firewalls that send specific revenues to specific regions and specific localities that has been in place since 1986 and it is gone.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:44:33
      This item on the list is a proposal to eliminate the bond component of the revenue sharing
    • 00:44:41
      We have bonds allocated through 11th, so we have to wait until 2012.
    • 00:44:56
      So what that means is a $50 million revenue sharing program will be reduced to the $15 million that is state funding.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:07
      Mr. Chairman, is that consistent with what legislative intent was on that?
    • 00:45:21
      Or it seems to me that maybe I should preface what I said.
    • 00:45:27
      It was my understanding that this was a clear mandate from the General Assembly that they wanted the revenue sharing program to go forward.
    • 00:45:37
      They may or may not have designated the bond money as part of that effort.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:42
      Did they designate the bond money as part of that effort?
    • 00:45:47
      The bond money and the program was premised on not just $3 billion worth of bonds, but
    • 00:45:54
      But if my memory serves me well, about $400 million a year in annual state revenues to pay for maintenance and operations of the highway system and operational funds for transit.
    • 00:46:09
      Most of those went away with the court decision.
    • 00:46:13
      In addition, the size of the bond program has shrunk dramatically by about a third.
    • 00:46:19
      And the way the bond program is laid out, it's a hierarchy.
    • 00:46:22
      So the first draw of the bond funds is to match federal dollars.
    • 00:46:26
      The first draw is for transit and rail capital.
    • 00:46:30
      The second draw is to match federal dollars.
    • 00:46:32
      The third is for revenue sharing and then by chance if anything is left over the CTB gets to pick.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:37
      We're just moving up a notch.
    • 00:46:39
      We're moving up a couple of notches.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:46:41
      What we made is the bottom tier.
    • 00:46:43
      We're left with after 2011 there will be only federal bond money matching.
    • 00:46:49
      We have no more bonds on projects and the next is revenue sharing.
    • 00:46:54
      The butcher is becoming very clear.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:00
      This happened with the Colorado River, didn't it?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:04
      Yes, it did.
    • 00:47:05
      It's an apt metaphor.
    • 00:47:07
      I would jump ahead a little bit on this very issue of the bonds.
    • 00:47:11
      One of the things that Ms. Busher and Mr. Pittard are looking at is the long-term viability of that bond program.
    • 00:47:17
      With a bond program, at some point you fall off the cliff or you're still paying debt service, but you have no more bond proceeds.
    • 00:47:23
      And I think it is a fair and open question to consider whether or not in these timeless, scarce resources we can even afford the luxury of a bond program.
    • 00:47:32
      And that's for a later discussion, obviously.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:38
      Would you explain what you just said again, how we get to the jumping off point?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:46
      The premise was that we would be able to issue $300 million a year in bonds for 10 years and that there were adequate revenues to support that.
    • 00:47:57
      Well, now we know there is only about $200 million a year but not any for the first two and a half to three years of the program because of the weakness.
    • 00:48:08
      And so what you have is a situation where you have ongoing programs
    • 00:48:15
      that are, if it's a discretionary program like revenue sharing, it's one thing.
    • 00:48:20
      If it's another thing like you're matching federal dollars after year 10 when you can no longer sell bonds, how do you match those federal dollars?
    • 00:48:31
      And you don't want to find yourself in a situation of falling off that cliff not having available funds to match federal dollars in year 11, for example.
    • 00:48:42
      That's one of the things that will be part of more of a long-range forecast for those revenue sources, but it presents very, very challenging situations for the VDOT staff to manage.
    • 00:48:58
      And ultimately, what it means is a smaller six-year program in the interest of simply trying some way to find enough state dollars to match federal dollars and to pay maintenance, which is basically all we're doing today.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:12
      So, excuse me, so the $200 million that we would sell in the bonds would go to... May I?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:49:19
      $2 billion.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:21
      The $2 billion you would sell in the Six-Year Program would go to financing the three components, but you... Oh, I'm sorry.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:49:32
      The bonds... How much of it will go to the federal match?
    • 00:49:38
      $120 million a year, approximately.
    • 00:49:44
      But we started this in 2008, and we won't be able to sell to 2010.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:58
      There's no share left for revenue sharing, which is a real drastic part of this thing, because we're getting a double bang for our buck, and the localities are having to come up with their share of that $50 million.
    • 00:50:09
      It's a $100 million problem, which is what we're talking about.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:14
      Again, the legislation is very clear in terms of hierarchy, rail and transit first, matching federal dollars, which is a four to one match, and then matching local dollars, which is a one to one match, and then anything left over can go to a priority of the CTB.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:50:37
      The last item on the list is what I talked about is something that we've done in the 10 through 15 draft, which is
    • 00:50:43
      Redistributing interstate previous dollars to projects to use our federal dollars, what we call federal strategy for federal fiscal nine.
    • 00:50:55
      And I'll get into that in a couple of slides.
    • 00:51:01
      This next slide is a little bit more detail for highway, the highway program showing the proposed 2010 through 15
    • 00:51:10
      by several categories, interstate, primary, secondary, urban, and three other categories for the total of $5.4 billion.
    • 00:51:19
      So as you can see, in the last, in three years, we've gone from $8.6 billion to $5.4 billion.
    • 00:51:28
      And this equates to approximately a $650 million reduction.
    • 00:51:37
      And that reduction breaks down like this.
    • 00:51:40
      About 75 million on interstate, about 300 million on the primary, 100 million on the secondary, urban 130, and then various smaller programs, about 43 million.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:56
      There is no addition in this program proposal, correct?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:51:59
      Correct.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:52:02
      I prefer the orange to the red ink too, by the way.
    • 00:52:05
      I prefer the orange ink to the red, by the way.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:52:11
      And to give you some of the larger categories for where the resource side of the $650 million comes from, $225 million is the loss of the state formula funding.
    • 00:52:27
      When we had to reduce, starting with the 9 through 14 program, run out of state dollars for the state 30-30 formula, in the 10 through 15 this equates to $225 million in reduction.
    • 00:52:41
      We also, Safety Loo runs out at the end of fiscal, federal fiscal 09.
    • 00:52:46
      So there were earmarks up through 09.
    • 00:52:50
      So when 09 becomes previous, the 10 through 15 no longer has Safety Loo earmarks until we get notified by FHWA that some of those may in fact be out there, but we haven't been notified of that yet.
    • 00:53:06
      And as I mentioned, in the 9 through 14 draft, we had four years' worth of federal revenue reserve, federal funding that we chose not to program in anticipation of federal revenue reductions.
    • 00:53:24
      And at this point, we're not certain we've reserved enough, but it's a little over 100 million a year.
    • 00:53:30
      So part of the reduction from 9 through 14 to 10 through 15
    • 00:53:35
      is that there was only four years of reserve in the previous program and there's five years of reserve in this program.
    • 00:53:42
      So that's about 138 million reduction there.
    • 00:53:46
      Some reduction on projects related to total revenue, TIFIA loan program on the airport connector that just dropped off from nine.
    • 00:54:00
      and some accounts receivable revenue, which is revenue from local government for their share of some construction projects.
    • 00:54:07
      We just happen to have less of that in 10 through 15.
    • 00:54:11
      And then where we have cut bonds to get CPR and MDTD bonds and some other bonds, the MDTD and local bonds just naturally
    • 00:54:26
      fell off the CPR bonds we consciously had to reduce off projects.
    • 00:54:34
      This slide is the amount of dollars that we have transferred from various districts, from all the districts if you will, to actually the Richmond District to fund the 95 bridges, 11 bridges on Interstate 95, and the I-64 paving, which is
    • 00:54:55
      So we're talking about a $100 million project in terms of the $120 million on the 95 bridges.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:03
      And I believe it's $40 or $50 million on the paving.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 00:55:07
      So we have moved on the interstate program only from nine allocations backwards, $97.8 million that was sitting on projects either accruing or those projects were not underway
    • 00:55:24
      and those dollars were not obligated so that we could obligate for the federal fiscal nine federal funding year those two projects to help us meet federal strategy.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:38
      Mr. Chairman, I know the choice between Interstate 81 and Interstate 95 is a tough choice.
    • 00:55:48
      But as I look, it looks like
    • 00:55:53
      $25 million came off of I-81 to go to 95.
    • 00:55:58
      And I guess I questioned a little bit that priority.
    • 00:56:06
      Could we have a little more explanation for why 95 was prioritized to that extent to take $25 million out of 81?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:15
      Sure.
    • 00:56:17
      And I'll take a stab at it, Rita, when I make a mistake.
    • 00:56:20
      Please correct me.
    • 00:56:22
      The project's on 95, and I want to preface this because Mr. McCarthy, when we get to, or when- I'm not going to argue about the paving on 64 because I just drove across it a half an hour ago.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:36
      Okay.
    • 00:56:36
      I was afraid I was going to disappear instead of the pothole.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:38
      Right.
    • 00:56:40
      Mr. McCarthy easily could have raised an issue on the stimulus funding.
    • 00:56:44
      The Richmond District got a very small percentage of that, the stimulus funding, because of the recognition
    • 00:56:51
      of what we needed to do in the Six-Year Program.
    • 00:56:55
      Okay, so the two are put together, you know, to achieve some level of fairness among the districts but recognizing our priorities and our needs first and foremost.
    • 00:57:05
      The needs in the Richmond District are not for a new interchange which is where most of the monies on the I-81 project came out of.
    • 00:57:13
      They are simply to repair existing infrastructure.
    • 00:57:15
      So there are 11
    • 00:57:17
      structurally deficient and functionally obsolete bridges in the I-95 corridor that are among the oldest assets in the interstate system in Virginia and then there's the pavement on I-64.
    • 00:57:27
      It was really not a hard choice taking care of what you already have.
    • 00:57:31
      We have bad numbers on them versus something new that probably is beneficial for economic growth.
    • 00:57:38
      We are in such a state though of disrepair and increasingly so if we, the further we
    • 00:57:45
      We got behind, unfortunately, on our paving.
    • 00:57:47
      I think that's evident to anybody who drives the roads in Virginia.
    • 00:57:50
      We are very lucky to have the stimulus funding to help us do some catch-up.
    • 00:57:55
      The second thing we know is, just like pension funds, our bridges, most of them are built after, right after World War II, they're approaching retirement age.
    • 00:58:07
      And so we have several in the 95 corridor.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:10
      The only comment I'll make, I don't disagree with what your analysis is on the need for the repairs on those bridges on 95 and the paving.
    • 00:58:20
      I worry, however, that projects on the interstate take three to five years to bring to fruition.
    • 00:58:27
      An interchange, for instance, discussion is probably ten years, five to ten years.
    • 00:58:35
      And if you can have just enough planning money
    • 00:58:38
      to get the designation of the location of the ramps and the other requirements.
    • 00:58:44
      In proffers, we can get almost all of that donated.
    • 00:58:49
      And I have one example that I've talked to Rita about that right now we can get everything for free to finish this interchange.
    • 00:58:58
      The county will support that effort.
    • 00:59:00
      It costs $2 million.
    • 00:59:03
      Without that $2 million, we will not do it.
    • 00:59:06
      and those lanes will cost us, in my guess, $10 to $20 million in five years.
    • 00:59:13
      It just seems foolish on our part not to somehow spend enough money to go ahead and get the location of some of these interchange roads so that we can avoid that cost to the Commonwealth in the future.
    • 00:59:30
      And I understand the federal match.
    • 00:59:33
      I understand the age of those bridges.
    • 00:59:35
      but I do think some consideration should be given to preserving the opportunity to set aside these right-of-ways to avoid the cost of having to buy them.
    • 00:59:47
      And I think it'll have to be done on an individual basis probably where there appears to be a real opportunity to make that happen.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:54
      Yes sir, and that's why we have draft program.
    • 00:59:57
      I know Mr. Sterling had the exact same situation throughout 630 interchange, Ms. Carter in Stafford County.
    • 01:00:04
      where we could not afford to carry forward those balances but there was enough to do a serious location in preliminary engineering design.
    • 01:00:13
      So that's the kind of thing.
    • 01:00:14
      That's very valuable information to get back to staff to see if there's a way to accommodate that.
    • 01:00:21
      Mr. Witt.
    • Alan S. WittMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:23
      Mr. Chairman, representing the district that probably or does have the largest number in this column
    • 01:00:32
      Certainly in Hinton Roads we have a lot of different projects, but I want to applaud what you're doing.
    • 01:00:37
      We have no choice but to pool these funds, get something done, not parse them out.
    • 01:00:46
      Instead, take a focused approach.
    • 01:00:49
      This is our new tomorrow and even two million dollars for some new road someplace
    • 01:00:57
      I think it's going to be a long time before we're there.
    • 01:01:01
      So you'll hear me say this multiple times this afternoon.
    • 01:01:05
      I think we have to preserve what we have, stop the deterioration of what we have, and recognize that our tomorrow does not include building anything.
    • 01:01:20
      You talk about that a new interchange will cost $10 million six years from now.
    • 01:01:25
      We're not going to be building that interchange six years from now.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:28
      Mr. Chairman, good friends and colleagues can disagree.
    • 01:01:32
      I think we have to keep our future in mind and we have to think about the future while we do what's going on today.
    • Alan S. WittMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:40
      Mr. Chairman, we will let what we have deteriorate to the point where we can't maintain it.
    • 01:01:46
      That's the difference as to where we're at.
    • 01:01:48
      I don't think we have the choice to be building for tomorrow.
    • 01:01:52
      We have to repair what we built yesterday.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:56
      As I said, good colleagues can disagree.
    • 01:01:59
      Absolutely.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:59
      We're going to have that on the Sunday morning talk show.
    • 01:02:02
      Okay.
    • 01:02:03
      Any other questions or comments of Ms. Busher?
    • 01:02:07
      I want to acknowledge, I know everyone does, Commissioner, the great work of Ms. Busher and the programming staff, what they've been asked to do with stimulus, with the February revision.
    • 01:02:19
      Now with this is really extraordinary and it's always great, high quality work and deeply appreciated.
    • 01:02:25
      I know, Commissioner, you probably want to add a couple of words as well.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:02:30
      No?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:32
      All right.
    • 01:02:32
      Mr. Chairman?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:35
      I did have one question.
    • 01:02:37
      I don't need details per se, Ms. Busher, but what kind of revenue assumptions really underlie this
    • 01:02:45
      program in the trust fund area particularly.
    • 01:02:51
      Are you seeing simply a leveling at current lower revenue
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:02:57
      I'm looking at John.
    • 01:03:00
      I think our biggest dip was in ten, or was it in nine or ten?
    • 01:03:07
      Ten that we had an increase, which we're not, and then a leveling.
    • 01:03:14
      A very small increase over time.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:17
      The reason I mention that, Mr. Chairman, is we're seeing, there was an interesting article in the Washington Post today about trying to judge
    • 01:03:25
      The effect of gas prices now versus a year ago, total number of trips seem to be down, vehicle miles traveled in our region, but not on certain segments, you know, Route 7, Interstate 66 and so forth.
    • 01:03:39
      So trying to make projections about actually what's going to happen, what's going to be needed, look like they're going to be more difficult going forward.
    • 01:03:46
      So you see a slight recovery and then sort of a leveling off.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:03:51
      But I will tell you the
    • 01:03:55
      Secretary of Finance presented to House Appropriations and I believe there was an article in the newspaper that they are seeing a reduction below what they've anticipated.
    • 01:04:07
      For the general fund, they were looking at 7.3 percent but realizing 8.8.
    • 01:04:12
      to date.
    • 01:04:13
      So we are also experiencing about a 2% reduction in transportation revenue below the formal estimates in 09.
    • 01:04:24
      So we will have to deal with that as we close out 09.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:29
      And that also applies to local governments who get a piece of the sales taxes.
    • 01:04:34
      Absolutely.
    • 01:04:36
      Thank you.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:36
      Mr. Chairman, the bond issues are predicated on insurance premium funds.
    • 01:04:43
      I suppose it could be the wisdom of the next legislative session to find additional revenue to support those bonds or are they set up very specifically to be supported?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:59
      There would need to be an earmarking of a specific revenue source and that would compete against other general fund revenue.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:05:11
      From a financial perspective for long-term funding, we really need to not rely so much on debt, especially in terms of matching federal dollars.
    • 01:05:25
      That's something we need to be able to do every year and not just do bond options with Butch, because we pay back that debt over 20 years, but we need to match federal revenue every year.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:38
      It might be helpful, Ms. Busher, if you or your staff could send around the CTB the line-by-line revenue estimates that underline that I think would be very illuminating and actually if you could even go back a couple of years and then forward for the six
    • 01:05:58
      You know, we have a revenue base that is built, number one, on gas tax, number two, sales tax on automobiles, and number three, on insurance premiums that are levied on the value of houses and cars.
    • 01:06:12
      This is not a revenue base that anyone would willingly choose.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:06:16
      here in the first part of the 21st century.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:06:35
      Okay.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:37
      The next presentation, and Mr. Dickens will get you while Mr. Pittard is getting set up, is the DRPT, which is not nearly so bleak, not great, but not bleak presentation.
    • 01:06:48
      Mr. Dickens.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:06:48
      Ms. Connolly's comment brings to mind a question, sir.
    • 01:06:51
      Has these numbers been shared with the money committees in the drill assembly?
    • 01:06:58
      I don't know.
    • 01:06:58
      Are we?
    • 01:06:59
      Yeah.
    • 01:06:59
      Do they understand how dire
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:03
      Ms. Dickens, you know that's a great question.
    • 01:07:08
      I'm before Senate Finance talking about some unrelated issues.
    • 01:07:12
      I fully intend to take advantage and bring extra copies of these presentations so that they know not just the numbers but the practical impact.
    • 01:07:23
      And one simple way to characterize the change on the highway side is that we are eliminating local governments from the business of transportation.
    • 01:07:33
      Unfortunately.
    • 01:07:35
      And if we're serious about integrating transportation and land use, we need to have transportation funding that goes to the local level.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:07:45
      Mr. Pittard.
    • 01:07:46
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 01:07:49
      I'm going to briefly take you through the DRPT section of the Six-Year Program.
    • 01:07:59
      First, I'll talk a little bit overall about the program, then get in a little more detail about public transit, and then also the rail section, and then there's a few housekeeping items that I need to address at the end of my presentation.
    • 01:08:21
      This first slide is basically a comparison of our combined program from 2008 and then the revised 2009 and then the current
    • 01:08:51
      Projected program that's in front of y'all for approval in June.
    • 01:08:56
      As you see, we do show a decline, but it's primarily due to the removal of the Dulles Metrorail project that's now being managed by the airport reporting, the removal of the local funds that were on that project and the federal funds from our six-year program.
    • 01:09:15
      Also there is a slight decrease for transit and rail which reflects what Ms. Busher was relaying with respect to the bonds in that in the out years we are showing some smaller allocations of bonds to reflect the actual availability of the ability to issue those bonds.
    • 01:09:39
      That actually is going to be pushed out further into the future.
    • 01:09:44
      Overall, operating funding from the state is pretty much at a level, pretty much flat level from prior years.
    • 01:09:56
      I do want to point out that we got the recreation tax in 2007.
    • 01:10:02
      And at that point we were hoping to now be seeing a larger share of state participation in operations, but that just hasn't happened with the reductions in both the transportation trust fund as well as the recordation tax revenues.
    • 01:10:20
      One of the bright spots today is the state's blended capital match.
    • 01:10:26
      It's highest in my tenure and highest in well over a decade at 78%.
    • 01:10:33
      So the bond and the stimulus funding have had the desired impact with our capital match program.
    • 01:10:43
      Another bright spot is the funding of our passenger rail demonstration project from both Lynchburg and Richmond to Washington.
    • 01:10:52
      That's for three years beginning in the year that we're approving for fiscal year 10.
    • 01:10:59
      The allocation of rail projects continues closely following the rail resource allocation plan that's been presented before this board.
    • 01:11:10
      And as I noted on the first slide, essentially the large decrease was due to the Dulles project transitioning the management of that project.
    • 01:11:23
      The next slide shows public transportation in Virginia and looks at the operations and the sources of funding for operations.
    • 01:11:34
      And before I get into detail, I just want to point out, I noticed before I came up here that the first two years, the percentages don't add up to 100%.
    • 01:11:45
      So please ignore those.
    • 01:11:47
      Essentially the trends are the same and I'll fix those and we will get
    • 01:11:52
      to Carol, I'll get corrected slides later.
    • 01:11:56
      So I apologize for that.
    • 01:11:57
      So ignore the percentages on those first two columns.
    • 01:12:01
      But essentially what's showing here is the operating revenues fair box recovery is pretty much the percentage of the total has stayed relatively right around that 43, 44%.
    • 01:12:13
      And then state funding, as I said, has been fairly stable and federal funding the same
    • 01:12:22
      with both of those having slight decreases which in turn are having to be made up at the local level.
    • 01:12:32
      One point I do want to make that's in the box to the side here is without the recordation tax revenue, we would be at 14%.
    • 01:12:41
      So that, even though we've shown a slight decrease in the state share, it would be quite drastic without those recordation tax revenues.
    • 01:12:53
      This is another graphical representation of the transit operating state share and I think this better illustrates the relative flatness of what the state has been putting into transit operations across the Commonwealth.
    • 01:13:10
      The blue line represents
    • 01:13:12
      The state share of eligible operating expenses, certain expenditures are not eligible to receive state funding, which has ranged from 45 back in 03 up to about 50 in the last couple of years, right around 40%.
    • 01:13:29
      And then the bottom percentage is the estate share of overall operating revenues from two years prior, which is how the calculation is actually performed during the distribution.
    • 01:13:43
      And that's been ranged from 22 to 18, and that's pretty much a tight band there.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 01:13:51
      These are some bullet points on the operations funding.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:13:54
      We did have a slight decrease in the amount of funds.
    • 01:13:56
      We're allocating about $4 million.
    • 01:14:00
      That was caused by primarily when we did the revised program back in February.
    • 01:14:07
      Took some deobligated funding and applied that to our operations transit formula, about $5 million.
    • 01:14:18
      And then that is part of the reduction.
    • 01:14:22
      And then we did offset the reduction.
    • 01:14:26
      We have chosen to put before you all
    • 01:14:30
      V. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III, Michael A. T.
    • 01:14:44
      I, James A. Davis III, John C. Davis III, John C. Davis III, John C. Davis III
    • 01:15:06
      And we are proposing to shift one percent of that one and a half.
    • 01:15:12
      So that would only leave a half a percent for special projects.
    • 01:15:16
      And there were no, along those lines, there were no special projects that were denied as a result of us doing this.
    • 01:15:23
      And it did essentially shift 1.2 million dollars that we're able to give towards operations.
    • 01:15:30
      The next bullet is essentially once again talking about the state match, where we would be without the recordation tax, which this is of eligible expenditures, we'd be at 33%.
    • 01:15:44
      And then I think it's important to note back in 2007 when that legislation passed, the revenue projections for both recordation tax and transportation trust fund.
    • 01:15:56
      had us at about a 55% share of eligible expenditures.
    • 01:16:01
      So getting the recreation tax has helped to keep us level and constant, but it didn't quite get to the bump that we had hoped for.
    • 01:16:13
      The next slide shows, like I said earlier, one of the real bright spots today is the capital match blended of 78%, which is a blending of the bond funding
    • 01:16:24
      and our traditional mass transit trust fund, capital funding.
    • 01:16:31
      As I said, this is the highest max it's been in well over a decade.
    • 01:16:40
      Investments that this six-year program will actually produce are obviously large projects.
    • 01:16:47
      We're funding the Dulles Metro Rail Project, the Norfolk Light Rail Project.
    • 01:16:52
      We have bus rapid transit service here in Richmond that we're finishing an analysis on that service.
    • 01:17:01
      We're starting some new service in Haymarket, Virginia.
    • 01:17:06
      Some new locomotives for VRE.
    • 01:17:09
      That's one of their most significant issues, the downtime of their locomotives.
    • 01:17:15
      So we're able to fund that.
    • 01:17:17
      And finally, the Metro Matters program, the aging infrastructure, we're able to address that with some bond funding.
    • 01:17:27
      Purchase of 185 buses is being funded.
    • 01:17:31
      About 150 of those are replacement vehicles.
    • 01:17:35
      30 of those are either expanding upon existing service or actually new service.
    • 01:17:41
      Investments in security improvements for our transit properties, and then finally investments in marketing and outreach campaigns for our community services activities.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:54
      in our rail programs.
    • 01:17:56
      Question, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:17:59
      How much is marketing and outreach cost?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:18:03
      We fund the actual ride share administration programs of about $2 million and within that, Mr. McCarthy is a portion that's marketing and outreach.
    • 01:18:19
      A big portion of the ride share of our ride finders is marketing outreach.
    • 01:18:23
      I'll have to get you the exact figure.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:26
      Where I'm really going, I guess, is how do we know whether it's working or not?
    • 01:18:32
      Is there any measurement of its effectiveness?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:18:34
      We're in the process now of actually requiring performance feedback.
    • 01:18:39
      We're building a website or a process of doing that where we're asking them.
    • 01:18:45
      Traditionally, what has been reported is the number of people that call.
    • 01:18:48
      So how many people called and there wasn't follow up with did that person decide to take the bus or did they decide?
    • 01:18:58
      Right, but they just make a phone call.
    • 01:18:59
      Right, so you didn't really know whether it was effective.
    • 01:19:02
      So we've put in measures now and we've worked with those ride share administration programs to actually do follow up to find out are the phone calls and
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:15
      Do they change their programs periodically or is it the same stuff every year?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:19:22
      It doesn't seem to me like they do but I'm only in one market so I don't know what else is going on.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 01:19:37
      We do work very closely with the TDM operators.
    • 01:19:40
      It is a constant effort to improve the marketing and to try to change it up and form new partnerships as much as possible.
    • 01:19:47
      Another evaluation tool you may recall last month when I spoke about the State of the Commute Survey, that's another one of our evaluation tools to see if the marketing programs are working or not.
    • 01:19:56
      And one of the things we discovered was
    • 01:19:58
      That while we were doing a good job of getting the message out there about transit and TDM saving money and saving gas and things of that nature, we weren't doing such a good job in other areas.
    • 01:20:08
      So we bring that kind of information from the evaluation programs every year back to the TDM program so that we can make the adjustment in the market.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:17
      Thank you.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:20:21
      The rail programs, rail enhancement fund, we have $217 million over the six-year period.
    • 01:20:29
      It's 14 discrete projects that includes both freight and passenger rail needs.
    • 01:20:35
      These are largely defined by quarters, the I-95, I-64, and the I-81, Route 29 corridor, and then we have, on the freight side, we have the Crescent Corridor Initiative, Norfolk Southern,
    • 01:20:51
      National Gateway Initiative with CSX that are both funded partially.
    • 01:20:57
      And also we have intercity passenger rail that is funded within the program.
    • 01:21:03
      Port related projects with respect to movement by rail.
    • 01:21:10
      VRE commuter rail has some funding provided.
    • 01:21:13
      And finally there is some study funds provided for high speed rail initiatives.
    • 01:21:21
      Rail Preservation Program.
    • 01:21:24
      Once again, it actually serves both passenger and freight needs, short line operators funding.
    • 01:21:33
      And primarily, these funds go to maintain, preserve the existing rail beds that these short line operators operate on.
    • 01:21:44
      They do, as the second bullet points out, Amtrak service does run over some of these
    • 01:21:51
      So there is some benefit for passenger rail needs here and also there are certain segments in the Hampton Roads area that to get from the port to get freight out of the port via rail, there are certain segments that go over lines that are operated or owned by short line operators.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:15
      Mr. Chairman, again, on the Rail Enhancement Fund, is that a limited amount per year?
    • 01:22:23
      It is, and where does that, what's the source of that again?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:26
      The Rail Enhancement Fund is a dedication of the state tax on automobile rentals, and it's still about $26, $25, $26 million.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:22:35
      About $23 million.
    • 01:22:37
      It used to be more.
    • 01:22:39
      Yeah, exactly.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:40
      Okay, thank you.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:22:42
      Yeah, we don't actually get all of that source of tax.
    • 01:22:49
      I believe it's 8% and we get 3%.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:54
      The balance goes to localities, yeah, the host localities.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:23:00
      This is a graphical representation of the rail enhancement and rail preservation projects, and you can see they're spread out throughout the Commonwealth, but obviously they have to follow rail beds.
    • 01:23:10
      I don't think we're going to see new rail beds being created anytime soon.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:19
      Mr. Pittard, could you go back to that slide?
    • 01:23:21
      What's the north-south red line that terminates and looks to be Richmond?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:23:27
      That is the southeast high-speed rail line going to Raleigh.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:33
      Mr. Chairman, that designates our participation in the tier two environmental work for the southeast high-speed rail line.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:40
      And is that the one that is looking at a potential spur to Hampton Roads?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:47
      I wouldn't have used that terminology.
    • 01:23:48
      No, we are doing our own environmental study of Richmond to Hampton Roads.
    • 01:23:52
      That is a separate
    • 01:23:54
      Separate effort, but obviously they tie in together in Petersburg and then Edwards.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:00
      Well, now I'm puzzled, sir.
    • 01:24:02
      Me also.
    • 01:24:03
      Let's get a presentation on that.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:24:05
      There are two lines from Hampton Roads.
    • 01:24:08
      There's one north of the river, one south, and that's what we're in the process now of studying to determine which route to take.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:17
      Understood, but I had always understood it was the Federal Railroad Administration that was looking at the Hampton Roads spur
    • 01:24:24
      as part of the overall Southeast High Speed Rail corridor.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:27
      It is, Mr. Chairman, it is considered, we are doing a separate EIS, a separate draft environmental study of Richmond and Hampton Roads.
    • 01:24:36
      We are participating with North Carolina on the Southeast High Speed Rail, which is showing up there.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:44
      And I don't want to prejudge, but this is obviously a sensitive issue.
    • 01:24:48
      The map that we show in all of the presentations has shown
    • 01:24:53
      A link of the rail to Hampton Roads, my working assumption, I think Mr. Dickens and a number of local officials in the region and state elected officials has
    • 01:25:05
      That consideration was part of the overall southeast high-speed rail study?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:10
      It is.
    • 01:25:11
      That's considered a part of the southeast high-speed rail network, but it is a separate study from the ones being done in North Carolina.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:20
      And is it being managed by the Federal Railroad Administration?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:22
      Federal Railroad Administration.
    • 01:25:24
      Both ultimately will be submitted to the Federal Railroad Administration.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:25:32
      So, if I may,
    • 01:25:35
      There's money being spent between Raleigh and North Carolina.
    • 01:25:39
      I thought earlier our emphasis was on Richmond to Washington.
    • 01:25:46
      So are we not spending any money there?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:51
      We are.
    • 01:25:51
      That money was previously allocated.
    • 01:25:53
      All this shows is that
    • 01:25:54
      The program from 10 through 15 includes money to do the southeast high speed rail piece.
    • 01:26:01
      The money for the Richmond to Washington was previously allocated.
    • 01:26:05
      That study is rapid now.
    • 01:26:07
      So that work is further aloft.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:26:09
      I would hate to think we were going Raleigh to Richmond instead of Richmond.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:26:15
      I think it's also the graphical representation of a study that's showing the whole line versus some of these other items are just showing an exact object.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:30
      What might be helpful to clarify would be a simple spreadsheet and it's probably here in the Six-Year Program, but where are the rail enhancement
    • 01:26:39
      That's in there.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:43
      For projects that haven't been completed, yes, they're in there, but there may be projects that were previously funded that are no longer on the list.
    • 01:26:54
      Mr. Chairman?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:55
      This might be another good topic for an update because I, for example, would get emails once or twice a year from this Raleigh to Richmond, Southeast Regional
    • 01:27:07
      I have no idea what it's about and I have meetings a couple of times a year and I guess because I represent a district in the study area I get an email about it now and then but that's about the extent of my knowledge of the subject unfortunately and it's certainly relative to our priorities I mean Hampton Roads spur at the press conference a couple of weeks ago here in Richmond that was mentioned about as often
    • 01:27:32
      as in fact every time someone said high-speed rail to Washington they said of course with the Hampton Roads spur on it and I think that's what's in the plan but you know I'm not really sure so I'd like to maybe get it and I know we're trying to do the Trans Dominion Express as well and we've got these two experimental temporary three-year services to Lynchburg and
    • 01:27:56
      and in the 95 corridor and it might be nice to get an update on all that stuff again and maybe where this Raleigh thing fits in because I've been on the board a while now and that's all I've ever seen about it is the occasional email.
    • 01:28:10
      It seems like it's been going on since Rick Van Winkle fell asleep or something and I don't know what's happening with it.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:28:25
      And finally, another bright spot of the program is the funding of the demonstration passenger service from both Lynchburg and Richmond to Washington.
    • 01:28:36
      In FY10, there's $5.4 million of Commonwealth transportation funds provided for this subsidy.
    • 01:28:44
      And it is important to note this is a demonstration service.
    • 01:28:47
      So at the end, we get to year two and in year three, we're going to have to do an analysis of how well the services work.
    • 01:28:54
      and make a determination to continue the service and hopefully that's where it goes because that's what our analysis showed before we started.
    • 01:29:05
      But at that point we will have to find a permanent source of funding because the source we're using now is not a permanent source.
    • 01:29:13
      We've been cobbling together, I would say, commonwealth transportation funds to get us through this demonstration period.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:22
      Can you remind me again real quick on that, is it Amtrak will operate them, is that correct?
    • 01:29:28
      Okay, so we're subsidizing Amtrak though will conduct the service, we're not creating a new operation.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:29:34
      Correct.
    • 01:29:36
      This is just a map of that service from Lynchburg and Richmond, Washington.
    • 01:29:45
      And then finally a few housekeeping items for the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:29:50
      In the Chapter 879 to 2008 Act of Assembly, we were directed by the Governor and General Assembly to incorporate principles of asset management, public benefit, maintenance of effort, and transit sustainability into our six-year improvement plan process.
    • 01:30:11
      And I'm going to report that we have done that in the current year.
    • 01:30:15
      We've taken our asset management data that we've collected over the past year from our grantees
    • 01:30:20
      We compared that against the applications that came in to determine the age of the fleet and the vehicles that were being requested to make sure that that aligned with what the actual capital needs demonstrated.
    • 01:30:34
      Public benefit has been completed, the model's been completed, and we did perform
    • 01:30:40
      A review of one project that qualified under our procedures to take a look at that public benefit and it did produce a public benefit greater than one.
    • 01:30:52
      Maintenance of effort, we have procedures as you all have been briefed on prior to today in place but obviously with revenues declining there was no maintenance of effort position for the current year.
    • 01:31:05
      and finally, once again, Trained Sustainability.
    • 01:31:07
      Those policies and procedures have been implemented as we reach all on fire.
    • 01:31:13
      Another item is the R funding.
    • 01:31:16
      As Ms. Busher talked about, we're going to be back in October.
    • 01:31:19
      We did a 09 supplemental allocation.
    • 01:31:22
      We'll be doing a supplemental allocation to the program that's before you today and we're planning in the October timeframe right now.
    • 01:31:32
      Another item to note is we do have an allocation off the top of our revenues for the Mass Transit Trust Fund, the Rail Enhancement Fund that is allowed for project management, project development, project administration, compliance activities.
    • 01:31:49
      Last year that was at 2.4%, and this year we were able to go back through those items and reduce it to 2.3%.
    • 01:31:58
      And finally we had the hearings coming in June, and as a result of feedback from the hearings, and then also other minor technical corrections, there will be some slight adjustments to the program that we'll put before you in June.
    • 01:32:16
      And finally, my last slide is really just once again another map of the large projects and rail projects in the state that rail and transit has provided funding to.
    • 01:32:29
      With that, I'll be glad to answer any questions.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:32
      Mr. Martin.
    • 01:32:33
      Mr.
    • 01:32:34
      Chair, as you said that after three years, the Lindbergh-Washington line rail will have to find a source of permanent funding.
    • 01:32:45
      What should we then infer about what that means for adding the Lynchburg Roanoke segment to that?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 01:32:55
      I would infer that once again there would be a subsidy there and once again we would have to find a source of funding for it also.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:06
      Thank you.
    • 01:33:08
      If one were an advocate in that corridor, one probably would say, let's get the row notes sent.
    • 01:33:19
      Any other questions for Mr. Pittard?
    • 01:33:22
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:33:24
      Even though you don't have quite the difficult choices within VDOT, it's a very impressive program to be kind of holding steady.
    • 01:33:34
      Overall in the grand scheme of things as well as these major initiatives shown on this final map and I hope the board is as proud of that as I know Mr. Badger and his staff are and I know the governor is as well.
    • 01:33:47
      Okay, the next item or set of items is the commissioner's final proposals with respect to the budget reductions and let's see, how are we doing on time?
    • 01:34:05
      My guess is we will not get past these items.
    • 01:34:08
      So if there are any folks here for the items after this, we're going to push these over until the morning meeting tomorrow.
    • 01:34:15
      It's very important that we all focus on this.
    • 01:34:19
      And the folks want to take just a brief two-minute break, a five-minute break.
    • 01:34:25
      And sorry to interrupt, Commissioner, but I think this is going to be a long issue, and I think it would help people to focus on your presentation if we're able to take a short break.
    • 01:34:32
      So we'll come back in five minutes, and that'll give you time to queue up.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:34:36
      I think it's strong.
    • 01:34:44
      I'm well, dude.
    • 01:34:47
      I'm fine.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:53
      It's good.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:34:53
      I'm glad you clarified the Trenton Roads training.
    • 01:35:07
      I had no idea which one.
    • 01:35:14
      I'm glad we're back there.
    • 01:35:16
      We want both sides of the road.
    • 01:35:16
      We want two trains.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:35:17
      I wonder what that bridge is.
    • 01:35:18
      All the way down the middle.
    • 01:35:19
      You know, it probably would be a lot more expensive than a 75-lane board.
    • 01:35:21
      Who's that guy who dives the freighter?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:35:25
      Maybe there's some of those old style guys.
    • 01:35:30
      Yeah, we'll have a presentation.
    • 01:35:34
      Together?
    • 01:35:36
      Uh, you know, I had an idea that I was going to... Yeah, I just got through this one meeting going into another one in the street.
    • 01:35:46
      My guy was pretty good.
    • 01:35:50
      What was that?
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:53
      Just across the room.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:35:54
      What?
    • 01:36:11
      What do you want?
    • 01:36:11
      Who?
    • 01:36:12
      Yeah, why?
    • 01:36:12
      Yeah, he'll be back tomorrow.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:27
      I mean, I'll be back tomorrow.
    • 01:36:34
      He's trying to get his food.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:36:37
      We did everything we could to get the operating order back.
    • 01:36:49
      We didn't need a drink out of the bank.
    • 01:36:54
      Have you looked at her homework yet?
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:01
      That leader, so you can look at your pain and see what leader that is.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:37:05
      All right, I'll call you after a while.
    • 01:37:24
      Oh no, I don't know what I wanted to do.
    • 01:37:47
      Almost unhappy.
    • 01:38:04
      Question.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:22
      Which was your college?
    • 01:38:22
      Did you then see that I was taking me to a university?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:38:24
      No, we actually all think that when you try to stay in the county.
    • 01:38:25
      I know that, but I would think that they were talking about it, but they didn't think so.
    • 01:38:27
      They didn't have a business.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:27
      Quinton asked me yesterday about what did he say when somebody was saying money was being taken from, somebody was saying that there was a lobbying effort to take money to the Interchange Committee.
    • 01:38:49
      Oh.
    • 01:38:49
      Oh my gosh.
    • 01:38:50
      Did you mean to say MPO?
    • 01:38:50
      Well, the MPO politics on the Interchange Committee is hilarious.
    • 01:38:52
      Alright, so which one of your colleagues?
    • 01:38:53
      I'm not saying him because I know it's him.
    • 01:38:54
      I was complaining, alleging that I was taking money from a spot that you're ready to go towards the surgery.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:39:11
      So I've not done so.
    • 01:39:11
      That'd be interesting to hear, if that is the belief that one county in the region should get $47 million in his funds.
    • 01:39:14
      O'Brien, John C. Smith III, John C. Smith III, John C. Smith III
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:39
      See, when we did the update, we took what was...
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:39:49
      That was definitely funny.
    • 01:40:03
      Quick thing, too.
    • 01:40:04
      We were late, Project.
    • 01:40:08
      Project is ready to go.
    • 01:40:09
      Yeah.
    • 01:40:09
      Exactly.
    • 01:40:09
      We got it in our back pocket.
    • 01:40:11
      You're looking for a bonus obligation.
    • 01:40:12
      Yeah.
    • 01:40:12
      I'm looking for bonus obligation, money for that.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:40:13
      This is what this looks like.
    • 01:40:14
      Plus, plus.
    • 01:40:14
      How are you doing by the way?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:40:15
      I have my calendar with me, so I can't help you.
    • 01:40:38
      What is the total?
    • 01:40:38
      There's like $6 million.
    • 01:40:39
      Maybe $22 million more, but you can't make the fund.
    • 01:40:40
      So is that $22 million?
    • 01:40:40
      No $22 million.
    • 01:40:40
      I'm sure we'll be very proud of that.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:05
      Yeah, say 1145, and send me a note to the police, something like that.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:41:06
      That way we'll be sure to get a table.
    • 01:41:07
      I ask questions sometimes.
    • 01:41:22
      I just keep everybody awake.
    • 01:41:23
      All right, thank you Mike.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:42
      He knows me, but he won't face me.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:41:43
      I have abdicated fixing that bridge.
    • 01:42:02
      The only other two projects in the general Indian zone can be done in the Indian zone.
    • 01:42:04
      I don't think there's anything else we're going to do.
    • 01:42:21
      We'd have to, we'd have to, we should not, we should finish in three years.
    • 01:42:23
      III, Michael A. Estes, Steve Pittard, John W. B.
    • 01:42:42
      George W. Bush, George W. Bush III, George W. Bush III
    • 01:43:05
      James A. Davis III, Charles M. Martin, David S. Ekern, James L. Keen,
    • 01:43:23
      What was it?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:48
      Do you have two of these now?
    • 01:43:48
      One's working, one's county, state, kind of cell phone.
    • 01:43:49
      How are you doing?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:43:50
      Now that April 15th, notice you are gone a little bit.
    • 01:43:51
      I emailed Carol.
    • 01:43:51
      We're going around three-thirty. Five-O, and then we're going to drive on the line to K-1, and then we're going to drive right through the touch house. Right through the road. Those who are not finding those in the parking lot, might as well buy them. If they can. Because I'm going to use the subject whenever they go. and then we're going to go over to K-1. And then we're going to go over to K-2.
    • 01:44:18
      And then we're going to go over to K-3. He wants to be in Charlotte. He wants to be in the world. He's living there, Dave. I know, I know. He's living there. He's probably going to be in the hospital. I think that's after Dana. He keeps scheduling those things. I'm out of town.
    • 01:44:40
      I'll be there.
    • 01:44:53
      I'm scheduled for the IMU.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:53
      That is clear on the show.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:44:54
      That's right.
    • 01:44:54
      This is the first one.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:17
      I can't remember.
    • 01:45:17
      This is the...
    • 01:45:18
      I'm looking at the...
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:45:18
      III, Michael A. H. Taylor III, John W. B.
    • 01:45:46
      J. Michael A. Doolittle III, John C. Doolittle III
    • 01:46:09
      I was at a conference there, not there, but nearby, I'm sure as far as you can get an option to go get the tutors there.
    • 01:46:37
      Right.
    • 01:46:37
      James A. Davis III, George W. Bush, George W. Bush III, George W. Bush III, George W. Bush III, George W. Bush
    • 01:47:05
      We have several of these found out in London.
    • 01:47:27
      It's a very expensive D&D, so you can try to survive with it.
    • 01:47:29
      It's easier than all of them, but it's a very compelling way, very posh.
    • 01:47:30
      It's pretty fun to gather.
    • 01:47:31
      It's a great place for us.
    • 01:47:31
      What law in a couple of parlors do you like to represent?
    • 01:47:32
      I can't even speak of Richmond Hill.
    • 01:47:33
      I can't even speak of Richmond Hill.
    • 01:47:34
      I can't even speak of Richmond Hill.
    • 01:47:35
      It's kind of a very real Instagram.
    • 01:47:57
      It's really a very nice day here on the other side of the track.
    • 01:47:58
      You know, it's like if the airport is up here on the hill, and you're going down, and you're going all the way down town a couple of miles, then you cross the river and you go back up again to Minnesota on this hill over here.
    • 01:48:02
      So it wasn't easy to get through.
    • 01:48:03
      It wasn't easy.
    • 01:48:04
      You need a place to stay so I don't care about money.
    • 01:48:21
      I just have a nice dinner.
    • 01:48:39
      I don't know what it's called.
    • 01:48:39
      I don't know what it's called.
    • 01:48:40
      I don't even know what it's called.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:48:44
      We are eight minutes away from the event.
    • 01:49:05
      It is one and one between New Year's
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:49:07
      I don't think I'm going to say that because we're all going to get a chance to face off, apparently.
    • 01:49:33
      That would be a very good point to make.
    • 01:49:34
      I don't know if you've been out there listening to this, but I think it's a good point to make.
    • 01:49:36
      Let's go between you and your coach.
    • 01:49:36
      We have a chance to meet them in a couple of minutes.
    • 01:49:52
      Robert A.
    • 01:50:09
      Brown III, Michael A. Smith III, Michael A. Smith III
    • 01:50:10
      Still ready for a visit next week?
    • 01:50:29
      Yeah.
    • 01:50:29
      Where you been to?
    • 01:50:31
      I'll send you another note, but we're on for, say, the next week.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:56
      Uh, no.
    • 01:50:56
      Oh, I take it back.
    • 01:50:57
      I have ten o'clock.
    • 01:50:57
      Oh, yep, right here.
    • 01:50:58
      That's what that 10-8 means.
    • 01:50:58
      Okay.
    • 01:50:58
      Ten o'clock.
    • 01:50:59
      Okay.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:50:59
      I got it.
    • 01:51:28
      I just thought it was pretty sweet.
    • 01:51:29
      Okay.
    • 01:51:29
      E. J. Martin III,
    • 01:51:54
      Interesting, interesting work.
    • 01:52:22
      Okay, the third item, which has four subparts on the work session agenda to be led by Commissioner Ekern,
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:49
      are the blueprint.
    • 01:52:50
      And the blueprint is the Commissioner's strategy since last fall to meet our declining revenue targets.
    • 01:52:58
      I hope everyone pays very close attention to the Commissioner's presentation, his overview.
    • 01:53:03
      And then Ms. Busher is going to give us a brief, another really rosy picture of the budget.
    • 01:53:10
      And then I think the things that are of most interest and import here are the service level recommendations
    • 01:53:17
      and the update on organization and staffing.
    • 01:53:21
      And when this body votes on the VDOT budget next month, these recommendations will be embedded in that budget recommendation.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:34
      Commissioner.
    • 01:53:36
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, good afternoon.
    • 01:53:38
      Thank you.
    • 01:53:39
      The secretary has indicated in what we will do with you this afternoon is provide you as much time as you would like to discuss
    • 01:53:50
      Really three topic areas.
    • 01:53:54
      First, I want to talk to you a little bit about an overview of where we've been and what we anticipate the schedule to be for procedural steps.
    • 01:54:06
      Then Ms. Busher will spend a little bit of time with you.
    • 01:54:10
      The board asked at its last meeting for both a little bit of education around the maintenance dollars and where they go and how they get spent, what the draw is, and a little bit of the outlook now as we start to firm up our fiscal year 10.
    • 01:54:27
      and therefore set the stage for the SIP adoption of the maintenance funding for fiscal years 10 through 15.
    • 01:54:37
      Then I'll come back and visit with you, specifically following up on the update I gave you last month on the service area, recommendations that we're making, and our response to that public process, and then lastly I'll finish up with a status report for you on organization and staffing.
    • 01:55:00
      In each of the slide packets that you have for the three remaining sections, you will find that they have a consistent set of materials in their front end.
    • 01:55:13
      We did that on purpose and so that you would be able to have a constant reference for whether it's service areas or whether it's our organizational update, you have a constant front end to that.
    • 01:55:27
      So that you're able to say, this is why we're doing what we're doing.
    • 01:55:32
      And so I'll start us with that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:35
      And then as we get into the details of the other sections, I may not spend as much time covering that information.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:42
      Clearly the blueprint was driven and has been established around this slide and what we are facing as we move forward.
    • 01:55:52
      One, the sharply declining revenues.
    • 01:55:54
      Two, the total impact over the six years
    • 01:55:58
      of accommodating a $2.6 billion reduction in state and federal revenues.
    • 01:56:05
      We've recognized that about $2 billion of that has been accommodated in the construction program and the construction program updates that you've dealt with in February.
    • 01:56:17
      And as is the case in all budget discussions,
    • 01:56:22
      The first dollar is the easy dollar to find.
    • 01:56:26
      The last dollar is the hard dollar to find.
    • 01:56:29
      And that is the real discussion around the next two parts of the blueprint dealing with our services programs and our organization and staffing.
    • 01:56:43
      And we will continue to remind everyone that our state and federal revenue estimates are going to change.
    • 01:56:54
      I included this slide for you so that you would be able to have a constant place where you could look to and refer to the timeline and bring you up to where we are today.
    • 01:57:08
      We started, as you know, last August and September with briefings to the board on revenue outlook.
    • 01:57:14
      The formulation of our internal work in the department to look at potentials for a strategy to address that declining program.
    • 01:57:27
      When we briefed you in October and December, I want to remind everyone that this state, this administration, took a conscious step to look at this as a long-term
    • 01:57:42
      sustained and structural issue to be dealt with.
    • 01:57:47
      We consciously did not take an approach with a quick fix and say, now we've got it solved.
    • 01:57:56
      That has framed our work through December and February.
    • 01:58:01
      In December, obviously, we started that update process on the Six-Year Plan.
    • 01:58:08
      And we began briefings with the General Assembly in January.
    • 01:58:14
      put together your final six-year plan in February and commenced our outreach and work with employees in February as we started to prepare the agency for the organizational and staffing part of the Blueprint.
    • 01:58:31
      March, we are all aware of the 11 meetings you participated in on the service piece which brings us to April and what I gave you last month at the board meeting which was the appropriation act language which memorializes the blueprint in the budget for fiscal year 10 and beyond.
    • 01:58:55
      This is a quick slide for your use that summarizes that budget language that I gave you last month.
    • 01:59:02
      and sets priorities as well as directions for the blueprint now.
    • 01:59:09
      One, ensuring that maintenance and operations, our core elements, are focused on emergency response, pavements and bridge repair, and replacement and congestion.
    • 01:59:20
      I'm working on multi-syllable words today.
    • 01:59:26
      Congestion mitigation.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:28
      That's all practiced at together.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:30
      It also put in place that direction around organization and staffing as you look at the reduction and consolidation of our number of our facilities, our divisional restructuring here in the central functions of the department, our residency offices and our equipment repair sites, setting a benchmark at 30%.
    • 01:59:57
      It also put in place a piece of language which I briefed you on in our goals to achieve management restructuring in the department thinning the layers of management.
    • 02:00:10
      That is a necessary stress and sets a benchmark of no more than five layers from the commissioner to line staff.
    • 02:00:21
      It reinforced the direction that this board has established for us in all our decision making, an objective methodology for decision making, and a transparent approach.
    • 02:00:34
      It also put in place the goal of no more than 7,500 filled positions by June 30th of next year.
    • 02:00:45
      Lastly, it installed a requirement for the Department to provide to the Governor, the Chairman of House Appropriations and Senate Transportation and Finance Committees, and this should also say House Transportation, I apologize for this, oh it does say House Appropriations and Transportation, Senate Transportation and Finance Committees, our plan
    • 02:01:09
      and then a quarterly reporting requirement on top of the monthly requirements that I'm meeting for the Transportation Board here.
    • 02:01:22
      I wanted to take that next step and I kept this slide in for everyone's reference because as we launched in December the work around the blueprint, this is the characterization of what you see in code plus what has been embedded in our plan in terms of what is VDOT in 2016.
    • 02:01:47
      Both in its focus, its scaled services, a business approach driven by rapid deployment of research technology and training, recognizing the future of construction funding and what it will need to be focused on, and lastly an agency that is smaller and providing its services differently and proportionally differently.
    • 02:02:12
      Those are the themes that are embedded in the blueprint and are being lived as we bring action steps before you.
    • 02:02:22
      The blueprint does have three parts.
    • 02:02:25
      It is the six-year program part, it is the services and programs element, and it is an organization and staffing element.
    • 02:02:35
      The little graphic that I've included on the right-hand side of the slide, proportions over the six-year period are current thinking about where you will see that visited from a budgetary standpoint.
    • 02:02:51
      About 72% of the needed blueprint is focused at the construction program.
    • 02:03:00
      about 13% at our maintenance and at our administration and support programs and about 15% at maintenance programs.
    • 02:03:10
      Now, there's going to be a little bit of confusion in terminology because no terminology as it's used either in the code, in practice, or in our manuals lines up perfectly.
    • 02:03:24
      But in general terms, as you look at what you see here, the terminology on the right fairly well reflects budgetary terminology.
    • 02:03:34
      And it is relatively close to working in business practice within the department.
    • 02:03:41
      So when I talk about organization and staffing overall, I'm talking about administration and support program.
    • 02:03:48
      So that's the rough translator that you need to look at.
    • 02:03:52
      And I also highlighted on this slide the two key points that will drive the agency's actions in terms of organization and staff.
    • 02:04:06
      Lastly, I want to, as we step into the next parts of the presentation, we'll find everyone, as I have done consistently since October.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:17
      On the journey we are on,
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:20
      No plan is perfect.
    • 02:04:22
      As we move forward in each step, we are going to adjust what we learn.
    • 02:04:28
      You will see that today throughout the presentations.
    • 02:04:31
      We have uncovered, we have clarified, we have brought greater focus to several elements of the plan over the last 12 weeks.
    • 02:04:42
      Consequently, we are adjusting it as we move forward.
    • 02:04:46
      We are on an implementation track that is now reduced from 18 months to 12 months.
    • 02:04:53
      So we are intending to implement all recommendations within the plan, all directions, over the next 12 months.
    • 02:05:01
      And we continue as we work forward to ensure that nothing is left off the table.
    • 02:05:09
      If I discover something through staff discussion,
    • 02:05:12
      that automatically gets on the table and we start to ask the question, is it an opportunity and is it something that we should attack as we streamline and focus what we're doing?
    • 02:05:25
      Going forward over the next two months, in June, we will submit our implementation plan to the Governor and the General Assembly.
    • 02:05:34
      You will consider the FY10 budget for VDOT operations and maintenance.
    • 02:05:41
      We will begin implementation, full implementation of the plan in July.
    • 02:05:46
      So this month of June is where we're doing the budgeting, finalizing a variety of the mechanisms that will implement the plan.
    • 02:05:55
      Ongoing, we will focus on the monthly updates to the CTB and the quarterly progress reports as we begin implementation elements of the plan.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:04
      Please permit me a quick interruption on slide seven.
    • 02:06:09
      I'm truly not being picky.
    • 02:06:11
      Does not replicate every function.
    • 02:06:14
      Should that be does not replicate any function or are intentionally some going to be replicated?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:18
      No.
    • 02:06:19
      In slide seven, when I talk about an organization that does not replicate every function every place, tangible examples of that would be our transportation operations centers.
    • 02:06:32
      We do not need nine transportation operation centers.
    • 02:06:36
      Our technology allows us to do that from five locations.
    • 02:06:39
      So we're capitalizing on that as a part of this plan.
    • 02:06:42
      So that's the example of a non-replicated nine times or ten times every place in town.
    • 02:06:51
      Other questions?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:54
      Commissioner, if you could just turn back again to that slide seven.
    • 02:07:00
      I want to make, if I may,
    • 02:07:03
      It's the one with the pie chart.
    • 02:07:14
      Just two comments before we get into the substance of these presentations.
    • 02:07:19
      The first is that the Commissioner's final recommendations are based on 11 public hearings around the state at which over a thousand people turned out and I think we acknowledged last time
    • 02:07:31
      That's a real measure of public sector courage to go out and talk about these things openly and to make a pitch and also to listen.
    • 02:07:40
      So you'll see the benefit of some of that listening and the Commissioner's recommendations, but I hope folks will acknowledge and recognize that.
    • 02:07:47
      The second thing is when we get to discussion at the end, and I want to ask each and every board member when we get to the end for some commentaries to remember this pie chart.
    • 02:07:56
      If there's something that you may not like in the proposed cuts and you would like to see that added back in, we're going to ask, okay, which projects come out of that 72% or which services are restored in the 15% or which in the administration or support services are cut?
    • 02:08:24
      We have a fixed pot.
    • 02:08:25
      And we don't have the luxury of referring to a larger budget in the General Assembly or in Washington, the ability to print money.
    • 02:08:34
      And these are very tough choices.
    • 02:08:36
      I don't think anyone would argue that this is a perfect set of recommendations, but they are realistic and they're based on a great deal of public participation.
    • 02:08:47
      So, Commissioner, next.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:49
      Thank you.
    • 02:08:50
      We'll move on to our next budget piece.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:56
      Welcome again, Ms. Busher.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:09:08
      Thank you.
    • 02:09:19
      Presentation is a little bit of a precursor to the budget presentation that I'll present in June.
    • 02:09:30
      I go from a big picture but I narrow the focus down to maintenance which is what the rest of the blueprint discussion will discuss part of it in terms of funding the services or the service level reduction and staffing reduction.
    • 02:09:51
      I'd like to say that while transportation funding exceeds three billion dollars annually, state laws, federal regulations, and policies largely determine how we can use our funding.
    • 02:10:10
      And some of those
    • 02:10:18
      I've listed here some of the things or some of the documents that do provide the guidance that we have to live by with regard to how we spend our resources.
    • 02:10:29
      The Code of Virginia, the Appropriation Act specifically, any transportation related bills such as ETA 2000, House Bill 3202, a large component of what we're
    • 02:10:44
      We'll be dealing with going forward since we really are reduced to a significant level of federal funding in what's left of our budget.
    • 02:10:54
      We have the federal law and regulations which included safety lieu up through nine and we're not exactly sure where we'll be in ten forward.
    • 02:11:04
      And then last but not least, the CTB policy guidance and decisions.
    • 02:11:14
      With regard to those various regulations, obviously off the top, we must deal with our debt service.
    • 02:11:21
      For any bonds outstanding, we must pay the principal and interest on that debt off the top, including any potential future sales related to what I call the CPR bonds from House Bill 3202.
    • 02:11:40
      We also by law support or in the Appropriations Act support other state agencies and it is limited by what the required support is whether it's the state police or DMV and that sort of thing.
    • 02:11:56
      and it's required by code or the appropriation act and that's set.
    • 02:12:01
      The maintenance budget, the code establishes highway maintenance as the first priority for spending which is intended to be funded from HMOF but as you know, supplemental funding from the construction fund has been provided since fiscal 2002 and federal funds since fiscal 2006 and that's been increasing since that point.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:24
      Mr. Chairman, the question would be, have we got a percentage of the construction fund that's being diverted?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:12:33
      About 11% of the maintenance budget is being funded with federal dollars.
    • 02:12:39
      So I'm kind of looking at it from that side.
    • 02:12:41
      I don't know exactly.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:42
      I'm talking about monies that would have gone to construction.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:12:46
      John?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:12:49
      We'll get that for you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:52
      That's a very important number, and so if we could please get something sent out to the CTB that shows the transfer from construction to maintenance in each of the six years.
    • 02:13:03
      I'm assuming that's a growing number.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:13:06
      Yes, it is.
    • 02:13:07
      Yes, it is.
    • 02:13:09
      We'll get that to you.
    • 02:13:11
      We also have maintenance payments to localities, the statutory payments
    • 02:13:15
      for localities to maintain their local roads.
    • 02:13:18
      And our current policy is to provide the same growth rate for the localities maintenance payments as we have been doing for our own VDOT maintenance program.
    • 02:13:29
      But you'll recall in the 9 through 14 revised or the FY09 revised budget, we've reduced that from 4% to 3% growth rate.
    • 02:13:45
      We also have toll road revenue, which is in the budget, but that's not a, that resource or those revenues generated on toll roads are used to pay for the operations of those toll roads specifically.
    • 02:14:02
      Then we have the administration portion of the budget, the general management and direction, computer services, the maintenance of fiscal plan, employee training and salaries and development.
    • 02:14:17
      So this is one of the areas where the agency could shift resources, but in a minute I'll show you that that portion of our budget is down to six percent.
    • 02:14:29
      which I think is a reasonable.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:31
      Quick point about these toll roads.
    • 02:14:35
      I serve on a toll road board and we learned yesterday at our meeting a very important point and that is whenever things are starting to decline, when the revenue starts to decline, the automatic position is to say, okay, what do we need to do to raise the revenue to maintain our operations?
    • 02:14:55
      And somehow that principle which seems like a fine one to me,
    • 02:14:58
      is lost in what we're stuck with here.
    • 02:15:02
      The CTB can only talk about cutting things out of the program.
    • 02:15:07
      There is apparently no requirement in state law to maintain programs and services and I think that's a little ridiculous.
    • 02:15:15
      So maybe we could put that on somebody's list to balance out the demands and needs with the revenues that need to be made available because toll roads have to do it to stay in business with their bondholders
    • 02:15:28
      But our bondholders, they're going to be out of luck if we run out of money to pay them.
    • 02:15:33
      And we're not going to let that happen, but we have to let the programs and services and people go to you know where in a handbasket because there's absolutely no requirement to put up the money to sustain this program.
    • 02:15:48
      And I think that's a big serious problem that we're trying to struggle with, but it's a problem because there's no requirement that anybody do anything about it.
    • 02:15:57
      The comparison to the toll roads just makes it starkly clear to me the difference in our philosophy.
    • 02:16:03
      The General Assembly has no problem setting up toll road programs and making sure that they operate sustainably.
    • 02:16:11
      But when it comes to the rest of the transportation system, there seems to be no interest in providing sustainable revenues that match the needs that are out there.
    • 02:16:21
      And I think we need to point that out to somebody.
    • 02:16:23
      So thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:26
      Thank you, Mr. McCarthy, and as usual, well said.
    • 02:16:30
      It's not for lack of trying.
    • 02:16:31
      I understand that.
    • 02:16:32
      Three regular and two special sessions have been devoted to this very issue.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:16:39
      The next slide is the big picture view of the VDOT program funding and this is a slide that we show each year when we're putting the draft budget in front of you.
    • 02:16:51
      This was the slide that we presented in February when we had to reduce the budget and the six-year program for the reduction in state revenue estimates provided by the Department of Taxation at that time.
    • 02:17:07
      What you see here
    • 02:17:10
      is the difference between the revised budget in nine and the approved budget in nine of $347 million.
    • 02:17:21
      The construction budget at that time was reduced by $146.7 million for the revised
    • 02:17:33
      and is now looking at another decrease in 2010 of 233 million and that's in this version.
    • 02:17:46
      The maintenance program went from original nine from a billion 349 to a billion 186 to a billion 370 in this version.
    • 02:18:01
      Since we're updating the 10-15 program and we're bringing to you next time the fiscal year 10 proposed budget, we have changed the revenue picture for 10 slightly.
    • 02:18:18
      And what we are looking at is now approximately a budget of 3.347, a preliminary 10 budget of 3.347 versus the total on the previous page of 3.4355.
    • 02:18:36
      So this is the 10 budget that we compared to what we just revised it for in 9.
    • 02:18:45
      to the preliminary 10 budget for 10 through 15.
    • 02:18:50
      Now, that reduction is about 88 million and that now includes the elimination or the deletion of the Dulles Toll Road since we transferred that to EMWA.
    • 02:19:07
      It also is a slight revision in the federal revenue estimate that we received for 10 so far from the federal government and revisions of internal VDOT
    • 02:19:23
      Revenues that are not part of the HMOS and the TTF.
    • 02:19:27
      So there's an $88 million fluctuation between the 9 through 14 revenue estimates for 10 and the 10 through 15 revenue estimates for 10.
    • 02:19:40
      So if you work from that perspective and look at our budget as preliminary for 10 as $3.347 billion,
    • 02:19:51
      Again, as I mentioned in the previous slide, we take debt service, 8% of that off the top.
    • 02:19:58
      We take the support to other state agencies, which is about 1%, but at this point, 45 million is a lot of money.
    • 02:20:08
      We take off the toll facilities operations for 10, which is about 2%, but it's revenue coming from the toll facilities.
    • 02:20:17
      Then we look at
    • 02:20:21
      The federal program's funding, and that's about 24%, where we are, they're telling us how we need to, where to spend our money.
    • 02:20:37
      We have the earmarks and special funding programs that are federally funded.
    • 02:20:44
      We have the federal funding for assistance construction,
    • 02:20:48
      The federalized portion of the maintenance program and some other smaller programs.
    • 02:20:54
      The next section is the match for all of those federal dollars.
    • 02:20:59
      Then we also go down to the local funds that are in the budget.
    • 02:21:06
      on projects, and that's about 3%.
    • 02:21:09
      Then you get down to bonds and dedicated programs.
    • 02:21:14
      So at this point, you're down to a billion six of the 3.3 billion.
    • 02:21:22
      So then you look at what's made up of that 7% of the budget.
    • 02:21:28
      The revenue sharing, which is 50 million state, 35 million bonds,
    • 02:21:37
      $17 million in 10 is still on dedicated projects related to bond funding.
    • 02:21:44
      Then we do have the Access Program, the Recreation and Industrial Access Program, which is state funded of $10 million.
    • 02:21:56
      I want to point out that $68 million in state dollars is dedicated to paying VITA for IT services.
    • 02:22:07
      Then we have state planning and research dollars, $25 million, environmental divisions, $11 million, facilities management, $12 million, employee training, $11 million, capital outlay, and then government services.
    • 02:22:24
      From the industrial access down are state dollars.
    • 02:22:31
      Then you get to the
    • 02:22:33
      So you're down to a billion six.
    • 02:22:35
      Then you get into the locality maintenance payments, which is 11%.
    • 02:22:39
      So you're down to a billion three.
    • 02:22:44
      Then you actually get into the VDOT state funded maintenance program at a billion one.
    • 02:22:53
      And then the last component of that budget is $184 million for General Administration, so only 6% of your whole budget is for General Administration.
    • 02:23:04
      This just gives you some idea that of $3.3 billion, a little over 60% is not very flexible.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:23
      In general, excuse me, Mr. Chairman, in the general administration, is the $68 million for VITA included in that percentage?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:23:33
      Excuse me?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:34
      Or the general administration's $184 million.
    • 02:23:36
      It doesn't include the $68 million to VITA?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:23:39
      It does not.
    • 02:23:40
      That's the remaining portion.
    • 02:23:42
      What's in general admin would be the remaining portion of the technology budget?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:47
      VITA is another state agency, so it's really paid to another agency?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:23:53
      Yes.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:54
      Are they under the same crunch that we are as far as cuts?
    • 02:23:58
      No.
    • 02:24:01
      Target opportunities.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:24:03
      No.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:24:05
      They receive their resources from other state agencies through fees for maintaining the computer system.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:18
      I have a question to understand better the support to state agencies.
    • 02:24:25
      I understand that's DMV, state police, possibly others.
    • 02:24:28
      Those are mandated services under the law.
    • 02:24:33
      You said that at some point they decided it would come out of a transportation budget.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:24:38
      They have paused over the years from various things.
    • 02:24:43
      There is a page in our budget.
    • 02:24:47
      I didn't actually bring it with me today.
    • 02:24:49
      I'm sorry.
    • 02:24:50
      I'll have that at the next meeting.
    • 02:24:52
      It's about ten of them.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:55
      Well, I was just going to say that I'm not trying to be flip, but if the budget guidance is center line out, those things would be kind of far from the center line, I think.
    • 02:25:07
      I mean, I don't say they're not valuable.
    • 02:25:09
      I'm just saying that the idea that somehow the trust fund could support other people's operations I think is probably over.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:25:16
      The Appropriation Act does indicate, shows these funds coming from, is it H.M.O.S.
    • 02:25:27
      and we received those revenues and through us they go out to these other agencies for various things.
    • 02:25:35
      So DMV would be losing $11 million which they can't afford to lose.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:40
      But they have a fee structure of their own that they can get their own revenues.
    • 02:25:46
      State Police have a few structure of their own that they can recapture.
    • 02:25:50
      That's what I'm saying is in the old days when the trust fund was nice and robust, you could load some things in and it didn't really matter, but I think it probably matters now and one of my suggestions is that we ought to take a look at that.
    • 02:26:01
      I don't expect you to answer that now, but the other question was about environmental matters.
    • 02:26:08
      Do we have a whole separate set of environmental requirements that is apart from the Department of Environmental Quality?
    • 02:26:16
      or potentially are we duplicating some services in another department that... You mean separate from the other state agency?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:26:25
      Yes.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:25
      Yes.
    • 02:26:25
      In other words, are we paying... that's a cost to ourselves or are we paying them to do that work for us or... Our cost.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:26:32
      Our cost.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:33
      So we have a separate set of stream monitoring
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:26:36
      We have federal requirement, we have a...
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:42
      Okay, so we have like a junior environmental department.
    • 02:26:45
      We do.
    • 02:26:45
      Department of Environmental Quality.
    • Alan S. WittMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:52
      Okay.
    • 02:26:52
      Thank you.
    • 02:26:53
      You said that we have six percent left for general administration.
    • 02:26:56
      How does that compare to prior years, two years in the school year?
    • 02:27:00
      What percent do we have left?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:27:01
      We made some cuts in 09 that we're carrying forward to help balance the year, balance 09 that we will carry forward.
    • 02:27:12
      I'll have to go back to the prior year to get that percentage, but we cut security costs
    • 02:27:19
      furniture purchases, contract services, I'll get that for you.
    • 02:27:34
      The next couple of slides talk about from the three legs of the stool some of the things that we've been doing or proposing to do to balance.
    • 02:27:47
      with the budget reduction.
    • 02:27:49
      And I'm not going to repeat myself because most of the things on this construction slide we've talked about in what we've done and what we're proposing to do in the six-year program.
    • 02:28:01
      And this is the 72% portion of the commissioner's pie.
    • 02:28:08
      From the maintenance and operations perspective, our focus will be, and you'll see this
    • 02:28:14
      significantly displayed in a chart a little bit later.
    • 02:28:19
      The focus will be on investing in pavements and bridges to preserve the infrastructure and meet the performance requirements we talked about a couple of board meetings ago.
    • 02:28:29
      The 18% deficiency rating on interstates and primaries, the bridge deficiency performance measure, that sort of thing.
    • 02:28:42
      We're also, as we just mentioned, prioritizing services from the center line of the highway out to the edge of the right-of-way.
    • 02:28:51
      We have reduced the average annual growth rate for ourselves and localities for the maintenance of roadways from 4% to 3%.
    • 02:29:04
      The Commissioner will talk about a little later the facility consolidations that are being proposed.
    • 02:29:11
      and the update of the service level standards.
    • 02:29:14
      So he will cover that in more detail in the next presentation.
    • 02:29:20
      In organization and staffing, the reductions related to the implementation of the blueprint, organizational and staffing changes, the transfer of the Dole's toll road to Emwah, reductions in facilities repairs, furniture, equipment, security, training, and environmental services.
    • 02:29:39
      Those are some of the things that we reduced in the admin portion of the budget.
    • 02:29:43
      and we've had to set aside, the Commissioner will talk about a little later the facility consolidations that are being proposed and the update of the service level standards.
    • 02:29:57
      So he will cover that in more detail in the next presentation.
    • 02:30:02
      In organization and staffing, the reductions related to the implementation of the blueprint, organizational and staffing changes, the transfer of the Dulles toll road to Emwah, reductions in facilities repairs, furniture, equipment, security, training, and environmental services.
    • 02:30:21
      Those are some of the things that we reduced in the admin portion of the budget.
    • 02:30:25
      and we had to set aside some funding for a reserve for severance costs related to the layoffs.
    • 02:30:37
      Now this budget, the maintenance budget, I'm narrowing the focus to maintenance for 10.
    • 02:30:43
      What you have here on this slide shows you the original and revised 09 and they're proposed for 10.
    • 02:30:52
      Now the way this chart is set up is it shows that we've compartmentalized the maintenance budget into two large categories, asset investments and services.
    • 02:31:06
      And where you see the significant change is you see a hundred million dollar reduction in services from 2010 to the original 2009.
    • 02:31:19
      2009.
    • 02:31:21
      And you've seen an increase of 112 million in pavement.
    • 02:31:27
      This is where we're turning the focus to maintaining existing infrastructure.
    • 02:31:32
      And you'll see a slight increase in bridge and the other asset investments are of a smaller list of items and the Commissioner can speak to that.
    • 02:31:45
      But we've reduced services
    • 02:31:48
      to accommodate the increase in infrastructure maintenance.
    • 02:31:54
      So the total again, and this matches to the previous slide, we've gone for maintenance from $1,349,000,000.
    • 02:32:00
      You know, nine revised, it was a matter of balancing.
    • 02:32:06
      So we just, at the time of year that we had to reduce the budget and adopt in February, we were basically just finding where we could save money anywhere we could save it.
    • 02:32:18
      So the program dropped to a billion 186.
    • 02:32:20
      In proposed 2010, we're at a billion 359.
    • 02:32:27
      This is with additional federal funding to offset the loss of state revenues for maintenance.
    • 02:32:35
      So we've moved more federal dollars into the maintenance program for what can be federalized.
    • 02:32:41
      And it's at about a level of 11 percent, I mean 14 percent.
    • 02:32:45
      Previously in 09 it was 11 percent.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:54
      I'm curious if it's not possible to consider at this stage before we get to the June vote on this budget a slight shift from moving $100 million to maintenance to backing off that commitment slightly and be able to preserve some of these essential services that we've been talking about for one more year
    • 02:33:21
      While we look for some solutions to providing those services through other means, it seems to me, and I know I've said this already, but I'll repeat it one more time, to put a barrier up at these rest areas on July 1 and do nothing to remove the pavement and the buildings, to do nothing to provide additional parking for
    • 02:33:49
      trucks and RVs and other vehicles on the interstates, it does not seem to me to be wise to make that big a shift in one year with such short notice.
    • 02:34:04
      I think I could accept this, I know I could, a year from now if we had really tried to make clear to members of the General Assembly and others what is going to happen, that we are going to actually
    • 02:34:19
      Ask for money to tear down the bathrooms and take up the pavement and restore these areas to natural areas.
    • 02:34:28
      We're going to convert them into truck parking and do whatever is legal as far as any charges or whatever that might support that, even if we get no support for it.
    • 02:34:39
      The need for it is huge.
    • 02:34:43
      Why can't we consider not making that big a shift and
    • 02:34:48
      back off and pick up some of these essential services for one more year while we try to impress upon the General Assembly the fact that we believe it's not in the interest of the Commonwealth to take all of those actions.
    • 02:35:02
      I can accept the fact that 125-mile separation between rest areas is probably smart.
    • 02:35:08
      What I cannot accept at this stage is that we're just going to put up a barrier
    • 02:35:12
      and say, and not spend any money to fix those areas and to make, help people understand, especially all the visitors that come to Virginia, why we're doing it.
    • 02:35:26
      They don't know about our budget situation.
    • 02:35:28
      Every state you travel, and I rode the interstates for the last two weeks between here and Florida, and I can tell you those rest areas are hugely important, all up and down that corridor.
    • 02:35:40
      And there is varying quality.
    • 02:35:43
      in different states.
    • 02:35:45
      But nonetheless, their importance is clear.
    • 02:35:48
      And in all the hearings, my other commissioner got an earful and I thank him for doing everything that he did to listen to people.
    • 02:35:55
      I have not heard a single person come to me that says they want these rest areas closed.
    • 02:36:03
      And I try to explain that 30 or 40 miles apart is probably not good policy currently, that some will have to be closed.
    • 02:36:10
      But I think the way we do it is really crucial.
    • 02:36:13
      And as I see this shift of $100 million in one year, I just don't think it's wise.
    • 02:36:20
      I think it ought to be done over a couple of years rather than one year.
    • 02:36:23
      So that's my say again before we get to this June vote where I can't support this action the way we currently have it constituted.
    • 02:36:32
      And I feel badly because I know we have to balance this budget.
    • 02:36:36
      And I'm willing to be part of that.
    • 02:36:38
      I just don't like the priority that we've set for doing it.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:36:44
      I'm sure others, Mr. Sterling wants to comment.
    • 02:36:50
      You're welcome to make a specific proposal with respect to that that staff can consider at the end when we go around the table, but I would say this.
    • 02:36:58
      We have adopted performance measures on pavement.
    • 02:37:01
      We've gone backwards on that due to increased cost, weather conditions, and age of our infrastructure.
    • 02:37:07
      And in some parts of the state, you drove in on I-64 today, you see how terrible it is.
    • 02:37:13
      That is something that is irreversible if we continue in that decline.
    • 02:37:20
      By code, by the Appropriations Act, by our own internal policies, the adequate maintenance of our pavement and bridges is our first responsibility, and after that are the things
    • 02:37:30
      So that's how the Commissioner has developed this budget and these recommendations is in reflection of those priorities.
    • 02:37:39
      But if you want to, again, keep in mind that pie chart, want to make a recommendation, we'll have that discussion.
    • 02:37:46
      It ought to be very specific.
    • 02:37:49
      When we get to the end of these presentations, but I think it also, in fairness to the Commissioner,
    • 02:37:56
      You need to hear what's being recommended with respect to mowing, safety service patrols, rest areas.
    • 02:38:04
      He's done a good job explaining this.
    • 02:38:06
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:38:08
      Okay.
    • 02:38:08
      Ms. Sterling.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:38:09
      This may be one of those areas where colleagues can disagree.
    • 02:38:13
      It's not necessarily the merits of having the rest stops or maintaining all the rest stops or not.
    • 02:38:19
      But we're in a situation where it's a very tight budget environment.
    • 02:38:23
      It gets tighter every year.
    • 02:38:25
      And I understand the idea or the concept of hoping for another year that somebody, one of the elected officials, whether it be at the state, general assembly, or up in the federal government will take action either to provide more resources or to give us certain authorities.
    • 02:38:40
      But I've found that nothing crystallizes their ability to make decisions so much as something that stares them right in the face.
    • 02:38:48
      And while you've got another year,
    • 02:38:50
      That's not staring them right in the face.
    • 02:38:53
      That's not forcing a decision.
    • 02:38:54
      That's not saying, here is the consequences.
    • 02:38:57
      It's a couple of words on a chart or in a letter or even spoken on the phone.
    • 02:39:04
      But if we're going to get to this point because the authorities don't exist or because the funding doesn't exist, then I think we should do it now.
    • 02:39:11
      If they determine they don't like that, then we can continue to advocate that those authorities or that revenue become available or be made available.
    • 02:39:20
      If they don't like the rest areas closed, then they'll know.
    • 02:39:23
      They'll see it.
    • 02:39:24
      I mean, as long as we're just telling them this is what's going to happen, I can tell you that they're going to look at, well, that'll happen later.
    • 02:39:30
      I'll deal with that later.
    • 02:39:33
      I mean, there's a lot of funding constraints that they're making some choices.
    • 02:39:39
      As long as you're kicking this down the road, they're going to continue to kick it down the road.
    • 02:39:43
      So if we want action to be taken, this is the time to take it.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:47
      Mr. Chairman, I'd just simply say to my colleague,
    • 02:39:51
      potholes that are a foot wide or three foot wide in the road and no paving will get their attention as quick as closing a rest area.
    • 02:39:58
      So all I'm saying is balance, and I don't think there's any balance here.
    • 02:40:02
      I think the ferries definitely, a couple million dollars will take care of that problem, and probably five to eight million dollars will take care of some of the rest area challenges for a year, maybe ten million dollars.
    • 02:40:14
      Out of this total of a hundred million dollars, to me it's worth considering, and I will at the proper time
    • 02:40:21
      present some ideas for how we try to do that.
    • 02:40:25
      Okay.
    • 02:40:25
      Ms. Busher.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 02:40:27
      The last slide I have and up on the screen it's a little difficult to see, but this shows the 09 original budget by district broken down by the asset investment services and reserves.
    • 02:40:43
      The middle section of the chart is the proposed
    • 02:40:47
      Cuts and these are at the level that were originally proposed so these will change with whatever budget decisions the CTB makes and then the ten draft proposed budget again by district so you've gone this is by district the total to get you to the billion three fifty nine for ten again by asset investment and services.
    • 02:41:12
      It was just another way of showing the slide previously with the cuts identified.
    • 02:41:23
      That's all I have.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:27
      Any other questions of Ms. Busher?
    • 02:41:30
      Okay, the next scintillating presentation will be made once again by Commissioner Ekern.
    • 02:41:36
      Welcome back, Commissioner.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:46
      I'll pick up from this and now add a little bit of detail for discussion this afternoon.
    • 02:41:53
      Again, this now will deal specifically with the five service areas that we placed on
    • 02:42:02
      The table for consideration and took to public meeting.
    • 02:42:05
      Again, I won't recover this slide that I used in the introduction.
    • 02:42:10
      This is strictly, hopefully brings you to the fact that we're talking about the 13% or the, I guess my colors don't match up, the 15% of the pie.
    • 02:42:22
      You know, it's always this impressive when you look at your presentation in real life after you've been working on them for a week.
    • 02:42:30
      And this is a set of talking points for you as we talk about that 72, 15, and 13 and gives you the highlights of where that focus is at.
    • 02:42:44
      Again, the appropriation direction.
    • 02:42:51
      and now picking up from the status report that we gave when we initiated the hearings in March.
    • 02:43:00
      There are essentially 18 service areas that you look at and if you think about it from that center line to the edge line.
    • 02:43:09
      I have highlighted on this slide for you two key points, one or actually three key points.
    • 02:43:18
      One highlighted in orange
    • 02:43:20
      are the service areas specifically that we had proposed for reduction and or elimination.
    • 02:43:30
      Secondly, I put a noted point under snow and ice control so that
    • 02:43:35
      We remain perfectly focused on what was on the table versus what we heard a lot of comments about in a lot of areas across the Commonwealth.
    • 02:43:47
      And that deals with we are not changing snow and ice control standards and we are not instructing districts to change any practices that they have been employing.
    • 02:44:01
      Very frankly, I think you would have detected those changes as a result of the closure and consolidation of the area headquarters back in 2006.
    • 02:44:12
      We've gone through two winters now.
    • 02:44:14
      We eased our way into that back in 2006 and actually transitioned so that we're fairly confident that our practices in the field remain consistent even though the core where you would have expected it to change was consolidated back in 2006.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:44:37
      What's the vegetation control and mowing services?
    • 02:44:40
      I'm trying to get an idea.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:44:42
      Vegetation control and I've had to do a little bit of lumping.
    • 02:44:46
      Vegetation control really deals on the TAMS side of the, Interstate Maintenance side of the contract.
    • 02:44:52
      And when you look at those categories it really starts to deal with what are you doing for brushing, tree trimming versus just grass mowing.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:03
      If I could
    • 02:45:04
      I want to make two comments before you get into the individual service areas.
    • 02:45:08
      On slide four, the outlook by program, if you could just back up for one second.
    • 02:45:16
      The very last point on this slide, average annual growth in maintenance payments to cities and counties also reduced from four percent to three percent and then went above it, reduced average annual growth from four to three percent in the maintenance program.
    • 02:45:29
      That is not addressing me.
    • 02:45:31
      And so even with the one-time infusion of money into payments, we are not keeping up with our long-time estimated necessary growth rate of 4%.
    • 02:45:45
      Some years it's more, some years it's less.
    • 02:45:48
      That is a very, very significant change and over 20 years that one percentage point makes a huge difference.
    • 02:45:56
      But I point that out to you because that is a major change in a way
    • 02:46:00
      that we have operated since 2002 when we made an estimate of on balance what it would take to keep up with the inflationary costs associated with the maintenance program.
    • 02:46:11
      We know 3% is not adequate.
    • 02:46:13
      It is what we can afford.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:17
      Mr. Chairman, so from a year ago when we saw rapidly escalating asphalt prices and so forth, this year we're seeing certainly a dramatic moderation of some of those things.
    • 02:46:27
      So this doesn't just reflect
    • 02:46:30
      a lower rate of increase in materials.
    • 02:46:33
      This is actually deciding we don't need that many legs and so we'll just have one less.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:40
      It's just decided all we can afford is three.
    • 02:46:44
      And so there is a big question mark over even this what looks to be very significant increases in the maintenance program.
    • 02:46:56
      is still not a needs-based maintenance program.
    • 02:46:59
      And when you factor in bridges, obviously, that .
    • 02:47:02
      .
    • 02:47:02
      .
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:02
      Well, Mr. Chairman, isn't that not just bad business, but isn't that fundamentally dishonest, just pretending like we don't need something so we don't have to have it in the budget?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:16
      What you will see either June and July is a long-term forecast of
    • 02:47:21
      What we need, we're very confident about the ability to meet some targets in the Six-Year Program for pavements and for bridges and one of the things that the commissioner is doing is saying we're going to meet those targets, but the services are going to continue to get squeezed.
    • 02:47:38
      That's the dynamic that is being set in place.
    • 02:47:41
      The same is occurring at the local level when we're only going at 3%.
    • 02:47:46
      So this is a very important but big change in a way that we've operated since 2002.
    • 02:47:53
      Second point to make is the commissioner is not talking about this rest area here or mowing that there.
    • 02:48:01
      He is establishing statewide standards for these services, whether it's safety patrol, whether it's ferry,
    • 02:48:09
      et cetera, et cetera.
    • 02:48:10
      And so when we talk about budget reductions, we need to talk about changing standards as opposed to individual facilities, a residency, a ferry service, an area for mowing.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:24
      Mr. Chairman, could I go back to six and the traffic operations slash, it's SSC for the safety patrols?
    • 02:48:34
      Yes.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:35
      That's essentially the motorist assist element is all I've looked at.
    • 02:48:38
      Right, right.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:39
      But it still includes traffic operations as well which in our urban areas is congestion mitigation measures.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:49
      That's correct.
    • 02:48:50
      Mr. Chairman, what is the service that has to do with sound barriers?
    • 02:48:55
      Does that maintain them?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:57
      As we look at it, that's the physical maintenance of them that you need to do.
    • 02:49:02
      Periodic repairs, those kinds of activities.
    • 02:49:06
      As we were trying to capture our assets that you take care of from the center line out, that's a physical asset that you need to take care of.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:15
      And while we're at a couple of other clarifications, what is fence management?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:20
      Same thing.
    • 02:49:21
      You've got interstate fences that need to be repaired, so we keep that on the list for our maintenance staffs.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:28
      And sidewalks and trails?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:29
      Sidewalks and trails are in our subdivisions and in our secondary streets programs where you have sidewalks that are part and parcel of your facility.
    • 02:49:39
      So some of our districts are in fact having to repair sidewalks within the right of way.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:49:45
      I have no idea.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:47
      Boy, that ought to go.
    • 02:49:50
      Mr. Chairman, could I ask, are those budgets significant for sidewalks and sound barriers or are they tiny?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:59
      Mr. Chairman, if you, and I thought about your question because it dawned on me this morning about the question of, the natural question of, what are the high value items that are in here?
    • 02:50:10
      We picked the high value items that did not affect emergency response in that first category and in the second category.
    • 02:50:20
      and the third category.
    • 02:50:22
      So what we tried to get was, if I'd have picked, as an example, if we'd have gone out and said, tell you what, we're not going to maintain noise walls, you wouldn't have been able to find it in the budget per se.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:36
      So that's the key.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:47
      Now let me run you down the details of the story that starts from what we proposed.
    • 02:50:55
      What we heard that we briefed you on last month and what I recommend is the resolution.
    • 02:51:02
      On the left-hand side for Interstate Maintenance Services, otherwise known as TAMS, you've got the brief snapshot again, $78 million annually, 13 contracts, four companies, and they focus around the routine maintenance services such as mowing, litter control.
    • 02:51:19
      We had proposed a $10 to $15 million reduction.
    • 02:51:24
      We are continuing to pursue the scope change of those contracts.
    • 02:51:30
      We are in negotiations with the companies now.
    • 02:51:36
      And as future contracts, as these contracts come due, we are going to look to consolidate and permanentize those scope changes in future contracts.
    • 02:51:49
      So at this stage in negotiations, we are at about $8 million that we can count on in terms of what we think we will achieve against that $10 to $15 million goal.
    • 02:52:04
      We will complete negotiations by June 1st, and we are able to implement whatever changes we finally agree to with the partner companies July 1st.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:18
      Are these contracts by districts or are they overall?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:22
      No, they were set up on 13 different segments so some districts may have two or three different contracts within their boundaries and that's why as we move forward one of our learning pieces has been to say there may be a smarter way to do that contract but at the time we deployed them they were deployed in a way that we felt would attract good business from the contracting industry.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:50
      Thank you.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:53
      The second service area was then the roadside management, roadside services.
    • 02:52:59
      I tried to find 40 titles for you, but the majority of this is mowing on the primary and secondary systems in which we're investing about $42 million annually.
    • 02:53:12
      Our proposal was to reduce spending by $20 million.
    • 02:53:16
      We have established in the next slide in your slide set shows you the mowing standards that we have been pursuing.
    • 02:53:27
      Statewide mowing practices are adjusted to that which guarantees three mowings per year.
    • 02:53:34
      What we have changed is instead of right-of-way to right-of-way width in those mowings, now we'll narrow the swats down to the ditch bottoms essentially, and we will move to a pattern in which you will see full right-of-way mowing, but probably on a four-year rotation instead of every year.
    • 02:54:00
      We are also installing and authorizing and would authorize the districts within their budgets to move that standard.
    • 02:54:11
      In other words, if you need to mold more frequently in an urban area for a reason and you can trade that off within your budget, we'll be glad to do that would be authorized.
    • 02:54:21
      We are in the process and have had bids out for our bid contract mowing.
    • 02:54:28
      I'm getting good reports.
    • 02:54:30
      It turns into about mowing half the acreage on those bids by acreage across the Commonwealth.
    • 02:54:37
      So it tells me we're on track to achieve that $20 million reduction.
    • 02:54:42
      There's a side light note in here in the wildflower program investment.
    • 02:54:49
      We are recommending to limit that to the funding generated by the license plate program that supports that program.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 02:54:56
      How much is that?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:57
      That's about $100,000 a year.
    • 02:55:00
      We've been subsidizing that with an additional $500,000.
    • 02:55:03
      So you'll see an impact on wildflower management.
    • 02:55:10
      Mr. Chairman,
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:11
      It's harder to see them when they're not motor-round.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:13
      That's a good comment.
    • 02:55:22
      About every fourth year.
    • 02:55:28
      The slide that I've included here will give you what that mowing standard would be.
    • 02:55:35
      This is not a potentially new standard, but we are, this is not a new standard, but we are uniformly applying it across the Commonwealth.
    • 02:55:43
      So you will feel tension in urban areas.
    • 02:55:47
      And again, I'd like to highlight that the districts do have the ability and the authority to adjust based on local condition.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:56
      We've got two areas where you're just talking about cool weather, not warm?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:08
      They're trying to describe the turf species that we would use.
    • 02:56:12
      These are charts from our agronomist staff.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:16
      So because you have different turf in those areas, that's the reason?
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:20
      That's why you bury your mowing time.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:25
      But your point is well taken.
    • 02:56:27
      These are professionally driven standards and so these have emerged from department professionals, experts in these areas.
    • 02:56:41
      The third area that we took to hearing and service reduction was the safety service patrol.
    • 02:56:46
      Again, the background and what we had proposed in terms of reconfiguring the service to save, in essence, about $2 to $5 million against an annual $10 million investment.
    • 02:56:58
      This does not take out the TOCs.
    • 02:57:00
      It only talks about the on-road motorist assist service.
    • 02:57:05
      We're proposing now and recommending
    • 02:57:08
      We would achieve, and I'll show it to you on the next slide, a service level that we generally had in about 2001 in terms of areas.
    • 02:57:17
      We would reduce to only providing the service in two areas, Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia.
    • 02:57:26
      In Hampton Roads we are predominantly, we are doing that by contract today.
    • 02:57:32
      So we would reduce that by about 12 contract positions and cover less mileage.
    • 02:57:40
      In Northern Virginia, that service would be scaled to the existing in-house staff that we have.
    • 02:57:47
      And we would eliminate then the contract provided safety service patrols in all the other districts.
    • 02:57:53
      That estimate now will achieve about a six and a half million dollar reduction as opposed to the initial estimates that we had at two to five.
    • 02:58:05
      This chart, while it is a little bit small and hard to read, is very telling and gets you the specifics
    • 02:58:12
      by area and district of the state.
    • 02:58:16
      If you look at the fourth column over, you will see the total mileages that are currently covered by the program.
    • 02:58:26
      This third column from the left will show you the interstate where those services are provided.
    • 02:58:32
      You will get a sense from the next two columns that will give you our reduction and what we would achieve in terms of savings estimated for that individual segment.
    • 02:58:44
      And at the end you see in the fourth column, or in the next to the last column, the actual mileage of coverage in the Hampton Roads area.
    • 02:58:53
      It would be reduced from about 113 miles of coverage to about 48 miles in Northern Virginia and the 95 Lake coming down into Fredericksburg.
    • 02:59:05
      You'll see a reduction, and somebody will have to add those up for me because even my bifocals don't work on these numbers, but you'll see that in Northern Virginia we'll retain the same mileages of coverage.
    • 02:59:19
      What you will see change is the frequency at which you would see a Safety Service Patroller passing a particular point.
    • 02:59:26
      As a general rule of thumb, today you see a Safety Service Patroller pass a point on the freeway at about 20 minute increments.
    • 02:59:36
      We would expand that increment in the actual time.
    • 02:59:42
      We haven't worked that fully through the system yet since we haven't finalized the recommendations.
    • 02:59:49
      That will bring the total mileage of coverage back to about 190 miles if I read that last number down at the bottom about right.
    • 02:59:58
      And that's about where we were in 2001.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:01
      I have a question.
    • 03:00:05
      So in the Richmond District, is it all contracting services now provided?
    • 03:00:13
      No VDOT employees?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:15
      That's correct.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:15
      And it will, the contract people are eliminated then?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:19
      That's correct.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:20
      So where does, how do you provide emergency coverage if there isn't anybody dedicated to it?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:25
      That's our maintenance workforce.
    • 03:00:27
      Those are the normal, these are safety service patrollers who are roving and so we go from a roving
    • 03:00:34
      Directed System to a, now you use your duty officer, your TOC, and you contact your area headquarters or your TMS contractor to respond to the issue.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:47
      Well, as someone who has benefited from the service, I can say it's a valuable service and I just, I don't know, I've got to do some thinking about some of these things.
    • 03:00:58
      Based on what I'm hearing when I talk to people in the coffee shop, I tell them, or I ask them really, what do you think about this?
    • 03:01:04
      What do you think about that?
    • 03:01:06
      And they see it a little differently than we insiders tend to see it.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:11
      I appreciate that.
    • 03:01:12
      That's a very valid comment.
    • 03:01:13
      I get emails and letters constantly from people who have gotten a gallon of gasoline or five gallons of gasoline.
    • 03:01:22
      General Assembly members have received the service.
    • 03:01:26
      They are clearly
    • 03:01:30
      A great face for transportation when you provide that service.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:38
      Commissioner, is there not also, though, a state police service, motorist assistance?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:44
      There is a limited service here in the Richmond area that is provided through the state police.
    • 03:01:52
      They have a motorist assist program.
    • 03:01:55
      You'll generally recognize them as a car rather than our truck.
    • 03:01:59
      and it has a motorist assist and they do not provide the same kinds of services that our people were providing.
    • 03:02:06
      So there is a little bit of a differentiation but that was the predecessor in the Richmond area.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:12
      Every time I, I mean, set aside the fact that, you know, they can't do a police officer or state trooper can't give the full range of services, I've never seen somebody that ran out of gas on the side of the road, the trooper couldn't help.
    • 03:02:25
      I mean, don't they help in a situation?
    • 03:02:27
      Really, what would be missed there?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:34
      In the high-volume areas, in the congested areas, the whole impetus for this program nationwide was twofold.
    • 03:02:42
      One modeled a lot around the Chicago Minuteman Program, where they have a very aggressive, heavy equipment, and the authority for the Chicago DOT
    • 03:02:55
      to move in and clear vehicles with their equipment and restore service.
    • 03:03:03
      The second piece of that which most states were looking at is in this motorist assist because we know that every time you have a stalled vehicle on the side of the road that has an impact downstream on traffic, the Gawker effect.
    • 03:03:20
      and so if you can clear those that will help with congestion.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:25
      But I'm trying to get an idea.
    • 03:03:28
      If it's a flat tire, most people, not everyone, have a spare tire or a jack.
    • 03:03:32
      They have the means of doing that.
    • 03:03:34
      They can be assisted.
    • 03:03:35
      I'm trying to get an idea of what would be the total scope, not just identifying, well, you won't have this or this, but in terms of its usage.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:45
      I'm working very hard not to answer the question the way I would normally answer it, which is the hard policy question outside the congestion piece.
    • 03:03:55
      Is this a service?
    • 03:03:57
      that I should be performing that has alternatives to it.
    • 03:04:01
      And that's the question you're asking.
    • 03:04:03
      Is there AAA?
    • 03:04:04
      Is there someone else that can be providing those services now that we have cell phones and vehicles?
    • 03:04:11
      Yes, you can if you subscribe to AAA.
    • 03:04:16
      So there are all kinds of examples that we'll argue either way for the service.
    • 03:04:27
      Building to the two most popular services that were debated and discussed is first the ferry services.
    • 03:04:36
      Here was what we proposed, a reduction in the service and an elimination of one of the services.
    • 03:04:44
      Annual cost for these services was about $12 million and we were looking for $2 million.
    • 03:04:50
      We obviously got an awful lot of feedback from the public on this particular service area.
    • 03:05:00
      Our recommendation is going to be, and obviously a strong direction, Jamestown, Scotsman.
    • 03:05:08
      We will maintain 24 hour, 7 day a week service.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:14
      As a course, and very frankly as a part of that public meeting, we heard from the customer.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:21
      that there were things that we ought to look at that could reduce and achieve that same cost savings.
    • 03:05:28
      So the district and our operations staff are in the discussion now in streamlining some of our internal operations and properly scoping and adjusting the scope of our security plan on the ferry as it services across Jamestown.
    • 03:05:47
      And they are in active discussion working with the Coast Guard.
    • 03:05:50
      We believe that the combination of those two or three items will achieve us about a $1.1 million reduction as opposed to eliminating one of the hours of operation or eight of the hours of operation.
    • 03:06:06
      That is a work in progress and we think we'll have that resolved by the 1st of June for implementation July 1st.
    • 03:06:14
      We are recommending elimination of the Hatton Ferry and we have, as you'll see noted in those slides, adjusted the schedule for both the Mary Point and the Sunnybank Ferries
    • 03:06:28
      to achieve our originally targeted 50% savings in operation.
    • 03:06:33
      While not a lot in absolute dollars, it is a recognition that we are dealing with that whole issue.
    • 03:06:44
      And it probably reflects more accurately what those ferry services are providing in those three other locations.
    • 03:06:52
      That will get us about 1.2 or 1.3 million dollars in savings.
    • 03:06:56
      Additionally,
    • 03:06:58
      The public was very attuned to the fact that our fleet is aging at Jamestown, SC.
    • 03:07:06
      So we are actively pursuing funding for a replacement ferry.
    • 03:07:13
      We submitted to the Federal Highway Administration last week an application under ERA
    • 03:07:20
      For a unique piece of, there's a unique program, $60 million for ferry replacement.
    • 03:07:28
      So we have sent in our application as a first step to seek funding for that anticipated $30 million replacement.
    • 03:07:36
      They're promising a rapid turnaround.
    • 03:07:41
      I'm not sure how fast that would come.
    • 03:07:45
      But the service, the changes that we're making here, we are able to implement July 1st as we've indicated.
    • 03:07:52
      So our implementation to take effect for this 1.3 million would start July 1st.
    • Alan S. WittMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:59
      Mr. Chairman, to my fellow board members,
    • 03:08:05
      These public hearings on the ferry were, the commission did a great job and people were very angry and upset and concerned but I'm really glad to hear about looking for this alternative because what I ended up saying to the group was we're dealing with a recommendation today and the fact of the matter is this situation is just going to be exacerbated a few years down the road.
    • 03:08:31
      Our ferries are very, very old.
    • 03:08:35
      Exhausted a useful life, or close to it, nearly to a state of where you're not going to be able to repair them through another cycle.
    • 03:08:46
      And if we don't get this plan, we're applying for $30 million out of a total of a $60 million bucket.
    • 03:08:52
      Is that what I heard you say?
    • 03:08:55
      If we don't get this, we're going to be faced with this problem in the near future.
    • 03:09:02
      We have no construction money, no ability
    • 03:09:04
      to put in new ferry service, a number of people, a whole region area on the Isle of Wight ferry side of the water that relies on this and we have no money to replace the equipment.
    • 03:09:17
      So all I'm offering here is a good job, we've solved the problem for today, we're trying to solve the problem for tomorrow, but boy is this a haunting prospect.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:28
      As a little bit of a highlight, I get almost daily updates from the Hampton Roads District staff now.
    • 03:09:35
      Because our fleet is aging, one of the boats is constantly, or ships is constantly in
    • 03:09:43
      Drydock, having something done to it.
    • 03:09:46
      We're supposed to put three boats into service this weekend.
    • 03:09:51
      We may or may not make it because we got one of the boats back yesterday and they discovered problems as they were fitting it out and getting it ready to put back in service.
    • 03:10:01
      And so the staff is really doing yeoman duty trying to put that boat into service this weekend for Memorial Day weekend.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:08
      Chairman, I know this is one of the most vexing of the problems, but clearly committing to a solution that involves new capital expenditure, we're also committing to a solution that involves ongoing operating subsidies.
    • 03:10:29
      I think we just have to weigh all these things together.
    • 03:10:32
      Everybody's got important things that need to be done.
    • 03:10:35
      It's hard to see
    • 03:10:38
      I don't know.
    • 03:10:39
      It's very difficult for me to see how we promise things we don't have.
    • 03:10:44
      And when you buy new equipment, you're basically promising somebody's going to operate it, and I'm not sure where that money is.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:51
      I think what the Commissioner, though, has presented here is the savings are achieved by reducing security on there.
    • 03:11:00
      The Coast Guard requirement saves about a million and one, and that's the annual operational subsidy.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:05
      Replacement Boat, that's 100% funding under the stimulus program.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:25
      The last area that we put into the public hearing process for service reduction was the rest areas and welcome centers.
    • 03:11:37
      Again, the snapshot that we started on the left, proposal to close 25 rest areas with an annual $12 million operational savings as a result.
    • 03:11:49
      You see on that left-hand column the criteria that we used in establishing the original closure list.
    • 03:11:57
      We added a filter as a result of the public meetings that were held.
    • 03:12:02
      It was very evident that a 300-mile spacing was a little bit draconian on the part of the public's belief of where we ought to head, recognizing
    • 03:12:14
      That if we had to do something, this was a little bit over.
    • 03:12:19
      And I'm the first one to admit that you bet.
    • 03:12:23
      If somebody comes with a plan and says we've got another way to look at this, we did that.
    • 03:12:29
      We added the filter and moved to a 120-mile spacing generally.
    • 03:12:35
      May be 125.
    • 03:12:37
      Unfortunately, my predecessors didn't plant these things at the right spacing to give me increments of 60 and 120.
    • 03:12:45
      So I'll take that.
    • 03:12:47
      Our proposal now is we are adding back six restaurants, four in the 81 corridor and two in the 95 corridor.
    • 03:12:58
      They are shown in the map on the next slide and we'll come to that quickly.
    • 03:13:04
      Let's flip to that one.
    • 03:13:07
      I've circled them in green and you have a list there on I-81.
    • 03:13:13
      Northbound we would restore or put back in the Ironto facility at mile point 129, the New Market facility at 262 that's on the northbound approaches of 81.
    • 03:13:29
      Southbound we would reinstall Radford at 108 and Fairfield at 195.
    • 03:13:36
      On 95, the circle that you see there, there's a complex of four facilities there.
    • Charles M. BadgerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:43
      They are both car and truck.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:46
      We would restore the truck rest area on both north and southbound at mile point 154.
    • 03:13:54
      That's the way the proposal is now modified.
    • 03:13:59
      In addition,
    • 03:14:00
      We heard quite a bit of comment about the loss of truck parking.
    • 03:14:06
      So in the next slide, and the audience can't read this, but this gives you a full list of all 42 rest areas that were under consideration.
    • 03:14:19
      Those above the line are the ones that would remain.
    • 03:14:22
      The ones below with that gray box off to their right are the ones that we would now be closing.
    • 03:14:30
      The staff did just an absolutely fabulous job of reanalyzing where we're at with 700, we've provided today totally, about 783 spaces.
    • 03:14:43
      We were going to lose about 225 with the closing of 25 restaurants.
    • 03:14:49
      783, we were closing, 25, that loses 225.
    • 03:14:54
      They went back and reanalyzed our parking patterns.
    • 03:14:59
      at each of the sites.
    • 03:15:02
      And this slide illustrates what that parking pattern looks like now as it's proposed.
    • 03:15:08
      They in fact, those red and light blue represent trucks and adjusted parking utilizing interior space and shoulders within the existing rest areas.
    • 03:15:24
      Now you take that model and they've actually modeled every site that would remain open
    • 03:15:30
      And you go back to this chart and you are able to tell how many truck spaces at each site they can reinstall by doing that kind of analysis.
    • 03:15:41
      The number comes to 225 minimum.
    • 03:15:45
      So in essence, what we are doing is re-establishing the 783 parking spaces that we currently provide
    • 03:15:55
      Back in the corridors where they were originally placed.
    • 03:16:00
      That's the shortest way I can figure out to explain complex math.
    • 03:16:05
      But we get back to 783 and may be able to squeeze a few more.
    • 03:16:11
      The other piece that we picked up at the public hearings was a concern about parking restrictions.
    • 03:16:19
      Today we have a two-hour parking restriction at all the facilities for truck parking.
    • 03:16:25
      As we have reviewed the record, the only requirement we have is that we not allow overnight parking.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:37
      What is the reason for these restrictions originally?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:41
      Well, you've got to look back in history a little bit and across our history there's been a couple of motivations for two-hour parking.
    • 03:16:50
      Part of it had to do with crime prevention.
    • 03:16:52
      Part of it had to do with making sure that there was turnover at the sites so that somebody didn't take up the whole site for 24 hours.
    • 03:17:04
      So over time, various states have implemented various kinds of practices.
    • 03:17:08
      Over that same period, we've improved lighting.
    • 03:17:12
      We've improved the quality of the facilities.
    • 03:17:17
      We've done a lot to deal with those issues that were crime prevention kind of issues.
    • 03:17:24
      Many states, including us, have installed offices at each of their sites so the state police have a place to be.
    • 03:17:32
      The two-hour restriction is probably, if you think about it, a part of making sure that you have turnover in the sites.
    • 03:17:46
      Prior to when private sites were available, I mean, we've got, if you look at the corridors in total, we've got over 6,000 truck parking sites along those corridors.
    • 03:17:56
      So I represent about a little less than 7% of the total available parking in these same corridors.
    • 03:18:04
      So we're going to propose a removal of that two-hour restriction.
    • 03:18:10
      And just enforce no overnight parking.
    • 03:18:13
      That's currently what is in rule for the Commonwealth.
    • 03:18:17
      So that's a quick move.
    • 03:18:21
      Also, we have, we'll propose and the board has already adopted a resolution to pursue commercialization aggressively and reauthorization.
    • 03:18:33
      So that will continue to be a position.
    • 03:18:35
      The discussion is about to start in Congress over the reauthorization.
    • 03:18:40
      So as we move into the fall, that will be a critical point.
    • 03:18:44
      Failing that, and that's point six, we will consider and bring a proposal back for responding to what Dr. Davis has talked about in terms of raising the sites and not leaving them as an eyesore and would begin that process in 2011.
    • 03:19:06
      We will achieve, as a result of this change, about $9 million in reductions as opposed to our original targeted 12.
    • 03:19:16
      In total, when you look now at the services, our goal initially had been in the $45 to $50 million range in reductions in these selected services.
    • 03:19:29
      Currently, we're looking at about $44.1 million, so we're relatively close to the low end of what we thought we could achieve.
    • 03:19:38
      Not all in exactly the same places that we thought it was going to be, but pretty close.
    • 03:19:44
      Questions on where we're at.
    • 03:19:47
      And these recommendations will, I'm sorry, let me move forward.
    • 03:19:51
      Last slide on rest areas and welcome centers.
    • 03:19:56
      Contractor notifications would occur.
    • 03:19:58
      This is our way of making sure that everybody knows we can achieve and implement these reductions July 1st.
    • 03:20:06
      Sites will be decommissioned.
    • 03:20:08
      We've got to shutter some plumbing, do some things like that for buildings to winterize them.
    • 03:20:12
      for the decommissioned sites, and we would get them the permanent traffic barriers placed at the sites in this fall coming into the winter.
    • 03:20:28
      Additional questions on services?
    • 03:20:30
      Mr. McCarthy.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:31
      Well, it's more of an observation.
    • 03:20:34
      Could you put the map back up again?
    • 03:20:40
      Well, it's hard to read,
    • 03:20:42
      Poor little old Interstate 85, I rise to speak on its behalf.
    • 03:20:50
      There is a rest area, a rather nice one, at the line as you come from North Carolina into heaven in Virginia.
    • 03:21:01
      There is a lovely rest stop and then between there and Petersburg there are two more which are proposed in the Commissioner's plan to be eliminated
    • 03:21:12
      There is also one in Goochland just west of Richmond proposed to be eliminated.
    • 03:21:17
      There is also one in Caroline just north of Richmond proposed to be eliminated.
    • 03:21:22
      The net effect on the traveling public who are rushing from one place to another is when they come into Virginia, if they skip the rest stop on I-85 at the border,
    • 03:21:36
      The next opportunity they will have is somewhere around Fredericksburg, which I believe is more than 120 miles north of the border from I-85's start in Virginia.
    • 03:21:49
      Or if they're heading towards Charlottesville, the next opportunity is west of Charlottesville, which again is more than 120 miles.
    • 03:21:58
      So you're not going to have any public rest area between
    • 03:22:06
      The North Carolina line going 85 up through 95 to Fredericksburg or 85 up to 64 past Charlottesville, that strikes me as not providing adequate service to the traveling public and I hope you can at least reconsider that.
    • 03:22:25
      And I'll have it suggested later if you want Mr. Chairman as to where we might find the bucks to do that because it's about $250,000 a year for the Dinwiddie one.
    • 03:22:35
      To think that we're talking here about nine million dollars in savings out of a three point something billion dollar annual budget to close all these rest areas, there is something fundamentally screwy about what's going on here that we've been put in that position.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:55
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:22:57
      I'm sorry, Ms. Connally and then Ms. Carter.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:59
      I have gotten a lot of communication about the Welcome Center in Manassas.
    • 03:23:06
      And I would like to inquire just if the Department of Tourism, have they weighed in on any of these closures particularly of the welcome centers and were they not willing to, did they ever offer to put some money on the table or has that discussion ever taken place?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:27
      In the course of the public hearings and since the announcements in February, I personally, or as a Commissioner, have received no formal proposal that proposes some alternative funding mechanism.
    • 03:23:41
      I don't know if the Secretary has received some.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:43
      They don't have money.
    • 03:23:44
      These welcome centers are essentially supported by VDOT.
    • 03:23:46
      This is another one of those services that comes out of the trust fund to other agencies.
    • 03:23:52
      I have communicated the original
    • 03:23:54
      as well as the revised draft of the Secretary of Commerce and Trade.
    • 03:23:57
      This is not a surprise to the tourism folks.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:02
      And they again have never initiated some kind of a collaborative approach toward keeping...
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:12
      They're in the same posture of every other agency in state government.
    • 03:24:15
      They're contracting rapidly.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:17
      Mr. Chairman, I would say the agency hasn't responded but the
    • 03:24:22
      Tourist attractions have responded aggressively saying that they want their agency to speak up and they want to find revenues to keep at least some of these rest areas open.
    • 03:24:33
      I'd like to applaud the commissioner for this.
    • 03:24:35
      I had not seen the last part.
    • 03:24:38
      He had told me, but I just hadn't seen it as clearly.
    • 03:24:41
      I still believe that there is a basis for a discussion among our board to see if we can agree or disagree.
    • 03:24:51
      for delaying this action for one year.
    • 03:24:53
      And I really believe it's important to consider that rather than putting up barriers, temporary barriers, and telling our external public coming through Virginia, and they come through Virginia by the thousands on Interstate 95, 81, 85, 64, that it's not a welcome place.
    • 03:25:18
      The welcome centers are beautiful.
    • 03:25:21
      I applaud State for that.
    • 03:25:23
      But these rest areas are really important to people.
    • 03:25:27
      And I would agree that I think we can close several of them.
    • 03:25:32
      And I think the 125, 130 mile is reasonable.
    • 03:25:37
      But then you've got properties that are going to sit there to be vandalized and to be a serious eyesore problem.
    • 03:25:44
      And in one year,
    • 03:25:46
      I think we could approach the General Assembly with the governor's help to say we don't want that to happen.
    • 03:25:52
      We do want to reduce the number of rest areas we have.
    • 03:25:56
      We want to make them more functional for trucks and campers and other things that need to stop.
    • 03:26:03
      And I was delighted that New Market, for instance, was added back in because if the traffic got off at New Market and went into that little town, the trucks
    • 03:26:12
      It would be a disaster because there's a sharp turn there.
    • 03:26:15
      There's no place for trucks to go, no parking.
    • 03:26:17
      That's a good example of a good common sense decision.
    • 03:26:21
      The rest could be evaluated, and I believe some of them could be closed, are converted to parking.
    • 03:26:28
      I'd like to suggest that we approach the General Assembly, if we could, as a board, saying we would like your support for closing some of these properly, that is funding the sum of $20 million will probably be required
    • 03:26:41
      to tear down the buildings and clean up the pavement and restore a natural look.
    • 03:26:45
      So it doesn't look like we're putting up clothes for business.
    • 03:26:51
      That would be one consideration.
    • 03:26:53
      I'd like to suggest that we support funding, ask them to support funding for the DMV, State Police and these others other than from the trust fund so that those funds can be available.
    • 03:27:05
      They may say no.
    • 03:27:06
      But I think we ought to ask for that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:09
      Dr. Davis, can we get through this presentation because commissioners, you're getting off onto a larger discussion and the commissioner has another presentation because I will tell you one of the tradeoffs here are facilities versus layoffs.
    • 03:27:21
      And I have some personal opinions about that.
    • 03:27:23
      I'd like to get to other people and then we'll come back to your budget.
    • 03:27:25
      Can I finish?
    • 03:27:26
      Just one second?
    • 03:27:28
      No.
    • 03:27:28
      You're making a large budget proposal.
    • 03:27:29
      We're going to go around at the end of that after the Commissioner's had an opportunity to make his entire presentation.
    • 03:27:34
      Very good.
    • 03:27:34
      Thank you.
    • 03:27:35
      I'm okay.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:36
      Ms. Carter?
    • 03:27:36
      I'm okay.
    • 03:27:37
      Okay.
    • 03:27:38
      He can continue because Dr. Davis is on what I want to do.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:42
      We're not giving the Commissioner the due he deserves.
    • 03:27:45
      That's right.
    • 03:27:45
      Okay.
    • 03:27:46
      He needs the ability to make his entire presentation.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:49
      I don't want to be accused of not giving his dues because he's done his work very well and I apologize if I have intruded on his time.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:59
      Mr. Chairman, as the final step away from this set of services as they're proposed, the fiscal year 10 anticipated impact is about $45 million.
    • 03:28:13
      When you extend that out, and I've approached these as permanent changes,
    • 03:28:17
      fiscal year 11 through 14, the estimates are around $180 million for this portion of the service reduction.
    • 03:28:30
      With that, I'll give you an update on status on organization and staffing.
    • 03:28:44
      This is a little bit different in that we're on a trajectory that is doing some work.
    • 03:28:51
      Some of these decisions are not decisions that will roll to the board per se, much like all the service decisions will.
    • 03:29:01
      I won't belabor the initial set of slides that are still there to keep integrity, but I did want to point out
    • 03:29:09
      That we are continuing in our organizational and staffing approaches a journey that is not new.
    • 03:29:16
      It has its seeds prior to the beginning of the 21st century.
    • 03:29:22
      It was highlighted in a series of JLARC studies done in 2001 and 2002.
    • 03:29:29
      And since 2002, we keep reminding
    • 03:29:33
      Everyone who will listen, VDOT is a vastly different place than it was at the turn of the century.
    • 03:29:42
      It has not finished getting where it's going.
    • 03:29:46
      But what is happening now is we are accelerating that pace of achieving that organization that was envisioned through all of these discussions.
    • 03:29:58
      So you have seen the organization shrink from 10,500 to 8,600.
    • 03:30:06
      We have adopted, and in the quarterly reports that you will get tomorrow or have at your places,
    • 03:30:13
      We are achieving and sustaining on-time and on-budget focus for the agency.
    • 03:30:21
      We have, in fact, consolidated our area headquarters back in 2006.
    • 03:30:26
      At the same time, we consolidated sign shops from seven locations to one here in the Richmond area.
    • 03:30:33
      And we have taken the first steps at functionalizing the department when we, in the 2004 time frame,
    • 03:30:41
      changed our construction focus from the residency location to be managed from a district location and introduced 50 PEs into our business at that same time.
    • 03:30:57
      So as you look at the principles that drive the organizational and staffing dynamic, they continue that philosophy and business approach that the department has been on.
    • 03:31:12
      I'll flip past this and get to a status report on the staffing.
    • 03:31:18
      As you saw in the legislation, obviously, our target organization size is 7,500.
    • 03:31:24
      by July of 2010.
    • 03:31:27
      I included this slide for a couple of reasons.
    • 03:31:32
      One, I wanted to show you what our staffing level was July 1 of 2008 when we were at 8,472 classified employees.
    • 03:31:46
      We had about 1,320 employees in our central functions.
    • 03:31:52
      And I made a subtle change here.
    • 03:31:55
      I want you to be very clear about that.
    • 03:31:57
      We talk about central office, but in reality, central office functions are all over the state.
    • 03:32:04
      The Virginia Transportation Research Council is technically a central office function, but it is in Charlottesville.
    • 03:32:13
      So that is why I've changed the terminology that you see here from office to functions.
    • 03:32:22
      You see the classified field staff at 7151 and our wage or temporary employee compliments and we only take these in snapshots at 520.
    • 03:32:31
      The significance of the September 1st column is that is the benchmark against which I am implementing the blueprint on organization and staffing.
    • 03:32:43
      from the staffing side so that you can see what the benchmark measurement is.
    • 03:32:50
      It's 8,464 total classified employees last September.
    • 03:32:56
      Today, we are at 8,233.
    • 03:33:00
      That's telling you, and that's all through hiring freeze and attrition.
    • 03:33:06
      So it tells you that people are continuing to retire.
    • 03:33:09
      Our rates are at about 20 to 25 a month.
    • 03:33:13
      We anticipate and project that in July of this year, we will be through attrition at about 8,190 total employees classified.
    • 03:33:25
      If that were to continue, and the point of this graphic is to show that through attrition alone, by July of 2010, we'd be at about 7,800.
    • 03:33:38
      That's our best guess.
    • 03:33:40
      Against a target of 7,500.
    • 03:33:43
      with the mix as you would see it here.
    • 03:33:46
      We also have implemented and are implementing June 6th the reduction of our wage and temporary workforce and we announced that last month as you're all aware.
    • 03:34:02
      Reducing the remaining 232, we will have a staff of wage employees at about 106 across the department.
    • 03:34:11
      And those are on a review schedule because they were exceptions that were granted for particular purposes as we move forward through the year.
    • 03:34:26
      We have been, since 2005, actively managing the workforce to move to an organization.
    • 03:34:35
      A staff ceiling, a 6% vacancy rate below our authorized complement was initiated in 2005.
    • 03:34:42
      That was done at the time to make room for the consolidation of the area headquarters, which we did in 2006, and help manage that transition.
    • 03:34:53
      We installed last September a critical hire process in a freeze so that we could manage all the vacancies in the department.
    • 03:35:01
      That is proving to be very successful.
    • 03:35:04
      And we have continued to monitor the attrition and retirement trends.
    • 03:35:09
      What I'm highlighting for you in that slide is, in fact, the three mechanisms that we are using to get to 7500.
    • 03:35:20
      But it's a 7500 of a differently proportioned organization and differently focused organization.
    • 03:35:29
      So what I've done in this slide is simply show you that no one tool by itself will achieve the goal that we are targeted to achieve.
    • 03:35:42
      But as we move into implementation in July, all three tools working together will achieve the 7500 and we'll get it positioned and get our people positioned where they need to be to achieve the direction of the Blueprint, which is an organization focused on maintenance and operations first, construction and program development second.
    • 03:36:12
      That's a recognition of the change in the business that is going on across the country.
    • 03:36:18
      So if you look at us in July of 2010, our bulk will be in maintenance and operations.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:36:28
      And we will be using different business practices in proportion differently for construction, delivery, project development.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:36:37
      And those are the principles that I have briefed the board on prior to this meeting.
    • 03:36:51
      As we move now into adding that piece and the technical term we have to use is involuntary separations, we have adjusted our plan and we have adjusted it in two respects.
    • 03:37:05
      First, you can see by these statistics our wage and staff augmentation implementation and rather than to then have three stages
    • 03:37:18
      of reduction within the department.
    • 03:37:21
      We are collapsing that into two stages.
    • 03:37:24
      The first would be implemented July with anticipated separation of the identified staff in October.
    • 03:37:33
      That number will vary, but our estimate at this time is about 450 employees.
    • 03:37:41
      That number will be adjusted because
    • 03:37:43
      of the attrition and the retirement that is going on.
    • 03:37:49
      I have listed for you the functions in stage two, as we call it, that are being focused at.
    • 03:37:57
      You can see our public affairs group, VRTC, our right-of-way function, equipment shops, location and design, bridge, traffic engineering, environmental construction, inspection, and materials.
    • 03:38:10
      Exactly what you would expect with a reduction in the program in the magnitudes that we're dealing with.
    • 03:38:18
      You will also see in this stage two piece following July a consolidation of several of the divisions and we'll be able to begin implementing that consolidation from 31 to 22 divisions.
    • 03:38:34
      For this stage, and what you see is our anticipated reductions, spending reductions as a result.
    • 03:38:43
      I wanted to share that with you in our best estimates at this point with the mix of employees.
    • 03:38:50
      Our wage and augmented staff services that we're reducing for fiscal year 10, we anticipate about $15 million in reduction, and over the 11th through 14th,
    • 03:39:03
      Because we see these as permanent, they carry forward, so that will achieve another $60 million in that slice.
    • 03:39:12
      The estimate around our Stage 2 of classified employee impacts is about $30 million during fiscal year 10 and extended out through 11 through 14 would be about $132 million.
    • 03:39:28
      There is a note at the bottom of the page and Ms. Busher identified that note as a part of her presentation in the budget.
    • 03:39:36
      There is a cost for workforce transition or severance for those people.
    • 03:39:43
      Our current estimate for fiscal year 10 would be in the magnitude of $11 to $16 million.
    • 03:39:50
      So we have reserved that as a part of this process.
    • 03:39:55
      Beginning in December, you would see then the last stage of the consolidation and the units that would be affected with notification in December anticipated first quarter or March separation dates.
    • 03:40:17
      And that would affect potentially another 400 positions.
    • 03:40:21
      And I've listed, in addition to the Dulles Toll Road, the functions and the groups, the divisions actually, that you would see affected by those changes.
    • 03:40:38
      Because these reductions would occur late in the year, obviously the salary impact is much less, about 6 million for fiscal year 10, but extended out turns into about 125 million in fiscal years 11 through 14.
    • 03:40:56
      The plans and the process
    • 03:41:00
      By which we are dealing with our people, as I have explained at our previous meetings.
    • 03:41:06
      We have a specifically targeted workforce transition team or people transition team who is managing the process.
    • 03:41:14
      We have held almost 300 sessions with employees across the Commonwealth, making them aware of what rights, what benefits, what programs, how to plan for this kind of an effect on them.
    • 03:41:30
      We have tried to maintain communication as frequently as we can to keep them informed of the status.
    • 03:41:38
      And as we move into the June and July time frame now, the real hard work of specific employee notification
    • 03:41:48
      And that starts then a process described in code and by rule which causes a time frame that takes us out to October for actual separation.
    • 03:42:01
      That allows for substitution of employees, it allows for job search and placement, all of those services that we provide to our affected employees differently than in a private sector model.
    • 03:42:17
      And you will verify that if you talk to any of the employees in the department who have worked in the private sector, been affected by workforce involuntary separations and how that occurs versus the process that we're using in the department.
    • 03:42:36
      That's our people snapshot as we move forward.
    • 03:42:39
      The next piece I've got for you to finish off this afternoon deals with where we are with the consolidation and looking at our facilities across the Commonwealth.
    • 03:42:50
      This is the overhead slide that shows you our fleet of 189 area headquarters is not being affected.
    • 03:42:58
      They are being maintained and will be fully staffed at the end of the day.
    • 03:43:03
      We are consolidating and have validated our 44 residency consolidation to 29 or closer.
    • 03:43:15
      The 73 shops, equipment shops reduced to 37.
    • 03:43:18
      The consolidation of our operations center here in the Richmond area, so we'll reduce from six to five.
    • 03:43:26
      And our materials laboratories being consolidated
    • 03:43:29
      from 8 to 5 across the Commonwealth.
    • 03:43:32
      I'll pick on, I'll show each of those in detail here in a second.
    • 03:43:38
      I did want to make one note, you'll see a footnote on your slide that talks a little bit about NOVA and as you look at the residencies.
    • 03:43:46
      Back in about 2004, the NOVA district
    • 03:43:50
      implemented a system or a management structure that in fact eliminated their residency structure.
    • 03:43:59
      And they have been transitioning to that for the last four years.
    • 03:44:02
      So when we talk about 44 to 29, it's really a clarified number.
    • 03:44:08
      The perhaps more accurate characterization would be from 40 to 29, given the change in the management approach that NOVA has used.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:18
      Mr. Chairman, could you explain a little bit more what Northern Virginia is actually doing?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:23
      Northern Virginia went to a functionalized approach, much like we're talking about for maintenance and operations back in about the early 2000s, 2003, 2004.
    • 03:44:36
      Their maintenance engineer directs directly the maintenance operations through their headquarters structure.
    • 03:44:44
      So they have superintendents in the field.
    • 03:44:47
      Their residency, because they were out of the construction business, transitioned away and they are now using community liaisons more directly.
    • 03:44:55
      So that's the personal contact piece for each of their counties.
    • 03:44:59
      So that's why you see the numbers vary a little bit and it also illustrates for you why we're striving to get a consistent organizational approach within the agency because as you have differing organizational approaches it makes it very difficult to respond to either growth or reduction and so we're trying to stabilize that.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:24
      We heard a lot in the hearings about
    • 03:45:27
      And this regional thing is always a problem, but we heard a lot of criticism that the plan was not affecting Northern Virginia, but it was affecting everybody else.
    • 03:45:35
      So you're saying in effect that
    • 03:45:38
      There is an answer to that question even though on paper it appears that there's no reduction in maintenance and residencies are in equipment centers in Northern Virginia that there really is?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:51
      That there is.
    • 03:45:52
      That is correct.
    • 03:45:53
      But it's a time sensitive picture so you get a snapshot.
    • 03:45:56
      Because we heard that over and over.
    • 03:45:57
      That's absolutely correct and while I understand the criticism
    • 03:46:01
      You will see impacts throughout the department, including Northern Virginia, both on the personnel side and on the facilities side.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:12
      I think, too, having been in local government when residency was closed in Prince William County, it was a tough transition.
    • 03:46:19
      But essentially what the commissioner is recommending that the rest of the state look more like what occurred a decade ago in Northern Virginia.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:30
      Let's see, the residency consolidation, and so what I've tried to give you here now is the final directions that we're pursuing with our residency consolidation.
    • 03:46:42
      This again, like the previous slide, was our start.
    • 03:46:46
      both from the organizational side, the target organization of 7500, consolidation of business functions, functionalizing the department, reducing our residency structure by about 30% from current levels,
    • 03:47:04
      We're expanding span of control for supervisors.
    • 03:47:08
      And then we evaluated the proposals to ensure that no given residency, which will now have a primary maintenance and operations focus, primary maintenance and operations focus, is balanced by population, lane miles, square miles served, and number of area headquarters managed.
    • 03:47:29
      So our analysis that we provided previously shows that we maintain as good a balance as we can across that kind of an organizational design.
    • 03:47:45
      This is the map then that would show you the residencies to be closed.
    • 03:47:51
      I've highlighted the one change that we are making from the original proposal.
    • 03:47:57
      It is in the Hampton Roads district where we have switched
    • 03:48:03
      The closure from Williamsburg, which was first proposed to close, that will be retained and Waverly will be closed in place of it.
    • 03:48:17
      We've tried to give you an estimate in that square on the right-hand side of non-personnel system-wide operating reductions
    • 03:48:27
      that we think will accumulate as a result in the range of about a million and a half to two million a year.
    • 03:48:34
      That's all the support functions that go along with those residencies, whether it's utilities or the other kinds of services that we pay for to support any one of those given services.
    • 03:48:47
      And our first anticipated closing that we believe will occur around December.
    • 03:48:55
      Questions on residents.
    • 03:48:57
      We did have appeals and requests to review two other residency locations.
    • 03:49:02
      I reviewed those against the business case analysis and I could not justify those switches.
    • 03:49:12
      For your use, this is the detailed list.
    • 03:49:16
      It gives you not only the district title but it shows how many residencies they started, how many maintenance areas they will have, and what counties will be served through those maintenance areas.
    • 03:49:33
      The second area that we will address or deal with this afternoon is then the closure of our equipment shop across the Commonwealth.
    • 03:49:47
      We have validated that a reduction of 73 to 37 is feasible and can be accomplished.
    • 03:49:56
      We have driven that through the principles you see here.
    • 03:49:59
      We are seeing a downsizing of the fleet.
    • 03:50:03
      And equipment needs that was anticipated as a result of outsourcing of the interstate system and better utilization of equipment as it exists within the Commonwealth.
    • 03:50:18
      So in other words, if you plan better, you can utilize equipment
    • 03:50:23
      We do make an investment in equipment and it is good equipment.
    • 03:50:29
      We try to provide as good equipment as possible to all staff.
    • 03:50:35
      We recognize that there are services we can draw on from the private sector to provide some of the services.
    • 03:50:43
      That would normally be done through an internal equipment shop and we have implemented or will implement fully statewide a mobile operation.
    • 03:50:53
      You'll hear it referred to as either field mechanics or contact trucks.
    • 03:50:58
      The criteria that we used was to ensure that we had no equipment shop further than 60 minutes from any given site where we house equipment.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:10
      Mr. Chairman, I know you had some discussion about the unique piece of geography that's in the Stanton District and that of the three counties west of the mountain and I noticed that
    • 03:51:24
      Allegheny will be maintained but Highland is being closed as far as equipment shops and to get from Allegheny to Highland is a huge challenge and I know you had some discussion about that.
    • 03:51:38
      Do you feel comfortable at this point that you can cover photography with this equipment
    • 03:51:45
      issue because of the mountainous terrain that's between those two locations?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:51:51
      Mr. Chairman, very frankly I do.
    • 03:51:53
      I've been in the business for 43 years.
    • 03:51:55
      I know the success of a contact truck system and I think the district is maintaining a contact truck to serve that area.
    • 03:52:04
      So that covers that piece because we did have that specific discussion.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:10
      Could you describe the contact truck for those who may not be familiar with the concept?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:52:16
      Essentially it changes from you have to bring the problem to your shop as we do with our cars to where you'll see our staff and across the Commonwealth you see this already.
    • 03:52:29
      have trucks outfitted with all the tools they need to repair a truck in the field, short of probably removing and replacing an engine or a transmission.
    • 03:52:41
      With the communication systems that we are fully implementing across the Commonwealth two-way radios, cell phones, all the tools that are available to us now, it's very common to see, at least in my experience, that contact truck operator or that field mechanic
    • 03:52:57
      Routinely visiting each of the area headquarters that they serve, catching all the problems they need to do, doing the preventive maintenance checks that need to occur.
    • 03:53:07
      And if there is a major problem, then you utilize one of your 37 shops and haul your equipment into that shop for major repair.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:16
      Commissioner, is it just coincidence that there seems to be this one-to-one relationship between a number of pieces of equipment and a number of employees?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:28
      Is that the same question you're going to ask me about how many computers have I got?
    • 03:53:37
      Because if you count my computers, I've got two computers for every employee too.
    • 03:53:41
      It's not a fair way to count.
    • 03:53:45
      I apologize for the crassness of the answer.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:50
      And the map that you see is... You know, I would add, Commissioner, unfortunately, I have a little bit of history here, but the goal at one time was to have VDOT as a 14,000 person organization, and that was not so very long ago.
    • 03:54:07
      So there was a whole complement of equipment, of facilities.
    • 03:54:11
      The world was different not very long ago.
    • 03:54:15
      And this is the change that we're seeing in the automobile industry and virtually every other sector is affecting transportation departments not just here but across the country.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:24
      I think you'll also see if it isn't prevalent across the Commonwealth services that we got out of the business of when I was running in Minnesota.
    • 03:54:35
      Instead of trying to change tires ourselves, there are local services that spring up that will service a vehicle very quickly in an on-demand focus.
    • 03:54:47
      So it clearly shows a lighter, more agile and rapid deployed VDOT as you deal with maintenance and operations.
    • 03:54:56
      I think the Secretary's point is well made.
    • 03:54:59
      To be effective in maintenance and operations doesn't mean you have to be heavy in maintenance and operations.
    • 03:55:07
      This map is used just to illustrate where the equipment shops that are closing are located and the ones that will remain open for your reference.
    • 03:55:16
      The last slide I've got here deals with the labs and the Transportation Operations Center so that you get a sense of where we're at in terms of the locations for our TOCs.
    • 03:55:34
      First, you'll see on the list, that will be the five locations.
    • 03:55:40
      We'll have high-tech operations centers located.
    • 03:55:44
      The consolidation is taking the current room that is here in central office and consolidating it at the Richmond facility down in Chester.
    • 03:55:58
      That's a very quick and easy transition to make.
    • 03:56:01
      The technology is there so it's a function of moving people and establishing some revised procedures.
    • 03:56:10
      So we'll have that implemented the first of July.
    • 03:56:13
      The current lab locations that will remain open, you see all eight listed and you see the five that have been recommended for retention.
    • 03:56:24
      We think the accumulated savings for the reductions from consolidation of the TOCs is about non-salary related, is about $700,000 annually.
    • 03:56:35
      I apologize because I have one more
    • 03:56:41
      Autistic, I think, and I hate to do this off the top of my head, so I shouldn't, but I will.
    • 03:56:50
      These reductions taken in totality, salaries plus operational cost reductions for fiscal year 10 amount to about $38 million.
    • 03:57:03
      Extended through 11 through 14, that will rise to about $300 million overall.
    • 03:57:12
      So you can see that this is not a trivial exercise as you do this consolidation and reduction in force.
    • 03:57:24
      Final piece is again where I started this afternoon.
    • 03:57:28
      The plan is going to adjust some as we move forward.
    • 03:57:33
      But as I said in January and February,
    • 03:57:36
      As we move from concept to reality, this is not unlike a design-build project.
    • 03:57:43
      You know what you want at the end, you don't have all the details done before you let the bids, and you do it as you move through it.
    • 03:57:53
      So consequently, that analogy has caused both frustration, but it also adapts and allows us to be flexible as we learn through the transition.
    • 03:58:08
      We will implement the plan over the next 12 months and again, as I said, no function, no activity in the department remains off the table.
    • 03:58:18
      And every day I'm hearing something different or I'll get
    • 03:58:21
      A new piece of analysis that may affect what we're doing.
    • 03:58:26
      With that, I'll stand for questions.
    • 03:58:27
      I appreciate this has been a lengthy presentation for you.
    • 03:58:30
      I know it's a lot of material to cover, but there's an awful lot of work that has gone into this from an awful lot of people in the department.
    • 03:58:37
      So I appreciate your patience this afternoon.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:58:39
      Thank you again, Commissioner.
    • 03:58:41
      If you could go back to one of the early slides just to help us through this slide five, which is the Outlook by Program, I think will help
    • 03:58:48
      Before we get to going around the table and asking for conversations, are there any questions of the Commissioner to clarify his recommendations to understand that?
    • 03:58:59
      Mr. Koelemay?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:01
      Mr. Chairman, Commissioner, all this organizational and staffing
    • 03:59:07
      Expenditures within that $184.5 million that Rita Busher told us is general administration?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:14
      No, that's why I said early on, as you look at this slide, there's not a one-to-one good correlation.
    • 03:59:21
      Some of it is embedded in the construction program.
    • 03:59:24
      Some of it is embedded in traditional administration.
    • 03:59:28
      Some of it is embedded in maintenance.
    • 03:59:30
      So there's no easy way to go through
    • 03:59:35
      So that does make it difficult for us to make up.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:55
      For you to speak and for us to make an independent judgment of sort of the relative costs of labor and staffing and organizational
    • 04:00:04
      versus the service that is actually attached to you.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:07
      That's correct.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:09
      But that wasn't on purpose.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:00:13
      Okay.
    • 04:00:17
      Quick question.
    • 04:00:19
      Of the rest areas that are going to be closed, how many are modern?
    • 04:00:23
      How many are antiquated?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:27
      We have closed no modern restaurants.
    • 04:00:32
      That's the only thing I can guarantee you.
    • 04:00:33
      In other words, when we screened and made sure that of the 19 we're recommending, we had not just invested mega-millions of dollars to renovate it.
    • 04:00:44
      All of them are over-sourced.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:00:48
      Well, that's not really answering my question.
    • 04:00:51
      How many of them need to be redone?
    • 04:00:55
      Oh.
    • 04:00:55
      If we had...
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:00:57
      if we had the capability.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:01:16
      And the rest of them are in good shape, bad shape.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:01:23
      Where I'm going with this is there are some that I remember obviously closed and I'm trying to figure if that's what we're closing or if we're closing some that are in
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:01:53
      I think some of the criteria that informed the Commissioner's recommendation were age of the facility, so the older ones were more likely to be recommended for closure.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:02:09
      and certainly none of the reconstructed ones in there.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:02:25
      Are there any remodeled facilities from that $22 million or general fund money that the General Summit that are recommended for closure?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:02:35
      I think there's one.
    • 04:02:40
      Jake, can you come on up and introduce yourself?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:01
      I think the question was were any of the remodeled facilities
    • 04:03:10
      included in the 19 that are recommended for closure.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:14
      Yes, sir.
    • 04:03:15
      Six.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:03:17
      Okay.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:19
      And those capital costs were less than $3 million out of that 22 million.
    • 04:03:26
      Total.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:26
      Yeah, there was 22 million, there was 20 million that the General Assembly provided, if I remember correctly, and we rebuilt three facilities
    • 04:03:38
      The rebuilt facilities all would stay in place.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:03:55
      There are six that have undergone some renovation over the last couple of years that are recommended for closure here.
    • 04:04:03
      and one welcome center in Manassas is recommended for closure.
    • 04:04:08
      Okay, if we might, what I'd like to do is just point out the pie chart and I know the hour is late but this is a very important discussion.
    • 04:04:16
      And if you can look at that pie chart, you know, in the blue is the 72% that comes from the construction program.
    • 04:04:23
      And one of the things that people say, well, gosh, maybe we can take a little bit more out of there.
    • 04:04:29
      We are so finely tuned there, if you take a dollar of state funds out of there, you're going to lose the four federal dollars matching.
    • 04:04:36
      So we are limited to the 28% that is described as admin and support programs and the maintenance programs for these cuts.
    • 04:04:45
      In round numbers on an annual basis, we're getting $300 million a year roughly out of the construction program, about $100 million a year
    • 04:04:53
      in this other, the smaller slices of the pie.
    • 04:04:58
      So what we and the commissioner has recommended is a budget that does that.
    • 04:05:04
      So that needs to be the focus of our discussions.
    • 04:05:08
      And I'd like to just read to you an email just came across this afternoon from AASHTO.
    • 04:05:16
      And one of the things that needs to be in the back of people's minds, which is what
    • 04:05:20
      Our chief financial officer has just told us, which is that we're 2% below the revenue forecast that are driving these cuts as of today.
    • 04:05:30
      And it says the U.S. Department of Transportation has begun briefing congressional committees on the coming cash shortfall in the highway account of the Highway Trust Fund.
    • 04:05:37
      According to congressional staff, U.S.
    • 04:05:39
      DOT staff have begun informing Congress that a cash shortage may force a notification to states of a slowdown in payments from the highway account as early as August.
    • 04:05:48
      The shortfall could be as much as $4 billion according to DOT.
    • 04:05:52
      And if Congress is to address maintaining the trust fund solvency through fiscal year 2010, it could require as much as an additional $13 billion.
    • 04:06:01
      And you may recall last summer there was a one-time fix of $8 billion just to maintain current funding levels, which we're now talking about as a $13 billion infusion just to maintain that.
    • 04:06:14
      So what we have to do here is to make some hard choices, but also to be prepared for additional cuts.
    • 04:06:22
      So that's one of the reasons that Ms. Busher has put a federal revenue reserve in, in the event that they yanked something back, we're somewhat prepared for that.
    • 04:06:32
      But at $13 billion, you're looking at about a 35% cut in federal revenues, if that does not occur.
    • 04:06:39
      We have the same dynamic occurring with the state transportation trust fund.
    • 04:06:43
      Again, let's go back to what we're based on.
    • 04:06:45
      Gas taxes, motor vehicle sales, and insurance premiums that are based on the value of the car and home.
    • 04:06:52
      So we are not well positioned here, and as the commissioner indicated, this is another step in a journey.
    • 04:07:01
      We're getting there a lot faster, I think, than any of us would like, but we also have to prepare to keep going down this path of continuing shrinkage.
    • 04:07:09
      That said, we're going to be voting next June and so I'm going to start this end of the table and let's just go around and please share with staff and your colleagues here on the board some thoughts on this budget and how we get to this very important set of budget decisions and recognizing, you know, we've got clearly established priorities first of safety and then of asset preservation and after that things kind of fall into place.
    • 04:07:39
      Mr. Dickens.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:07:40
      Well, thank you, sir.
    • 04:07:42
      I'll try not to say a whole lot saving room for others to speak.
    • 04:07:46
      I want to suggest that the staff has done a marvelous job, I think, working in a very difficult environment.
    • 04:07:57
      I'm most impressed with the opportunities they've afforded the public to make comments and the reactions that have been
    • 04:08:06
      made in recognition of public comment.
    • 04:08:11
      I don't like these cuts, but I don't see we have a choice.
    • 04:08:20
      I would like to see some of these things stay.
    • 04:08:22
      I really appreciate the ferries staying.
    • 04:08:26
      I would like to see some of the rest areas stay.
    • 04:08:30
      But having said that, I don't know how we do it.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:35
      Thank you.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:37
      It's really hard to react to it.
    • 04:08:40
      I don't know whether these are all the right trade-offs and the right decisions, but a heck of a lot of work has gone into it, and I'm prepared to accept it as the best shot at addressing a very serious problem, so I'm prepared to go with it.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:57
      Ms. Carter?
    • 04:08:58
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:09:00
      Of course, coming to this job, to me, it was to be a servant.
    • 04:09:07
      And here I am a servant, a little maiden servant with a funding.
    • 04:09:12
      And that's hard, very, very hard.
    • 04:09:16
      The rest areas are certainly of large concern that I have.
    • 04:09:21
      And when I read and said they would be boarded up,
    • 04:09:26
      That would be terrible.
    • 04:09:27
      That would look terrible in Virginia.
    • 04:09:30
      Our state is a beautiful state.
    • 04:09:34
      And as we state, keep our Commonwealth, Virginia, spotless.
    • 04:09:39
      And that's what we want.
    • 04:09:41
      But if we, I don't know what procedure that we would use but to board them up and to have
    • 04:09:48
      Those who would just love to go in right on Boyd's confetti and whatever they wanted to do, I hope that we can do something to help that situation.
    • 04:10:01
      And yes, employees are dear to our heart.
    • 04:10:06
      And they say, well, we want the economy to build.
    • 04:10:11
      And so some of us received some checks.
    • 04:10:14
      Yes, we did.
    • 04:10:16
      And that was good.
    • 04:10:18
      When we have to lay off people, how are we going to build the economy?
    • 04:10:23
      And we talk about if they have time to search, where are they going to search?
    • 04:10:31
      Searching has almost been deleted.
    • 04:10:34
      There is hardly any search right there.
    • 04:10:37
      It's critical.
    • 04:10:39
      And I believe that you stated in my career, I'd like to ask Mr. Ekern a question, that there are 20 to 25 of that are retiring a month.
    • 04:10:59
      That helps me some because I am concerned about those who are losing their jobs.
    • 04:11:04
      How do they feed their family?
    • 04:11:06
      How do they put that loaf of bread on the table?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:11:09
      How do they do that?
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:11:11
      Let's just say it.
    • 04:11:12
      But we can do no more than what we have funds for.
    • 04:11:17
      We cannot allocate, even at home, if we don't have funds to pay our bills, what do we do?
    • 04:11:23
      They have to go.
    • 04:11:25
      And if people don't have money to put a loaf of bread or a gallon of milk on the table for their children, what do they do?
    • 04:11:35
      and it's a sad time and VDOT has always delivered, I believe, the best service that anyone could ask for and I'm proud of Virginia for that.
    • 04:11:48
      And I believe they're going to continue to do that.
    • 04:11:52
      But it's going to be something that's going to be very hard for those who are employees to accept and for us to accept that that will happen.
    • 04:12:04
      And when we talk about the barriers,
    • 04:12:06
      Yes, in the northern neck, there are ferries that are going to be affected by this, but I'm very happy to say that the hours have been evaluated and that the hours of service, I believe, will still serve them.
    • 04:12:25
      When we speak of the ferries, we are also speaking about transit.
    • 04:12:30
      When we speak of the buses, I mean, many of these people use ferries.
    • 04:12:36
      for their transportation.
    • 04:12:38
      And this is just as important to them as we talk about a bus for our city in Fredericksburg or Richmond or wherever.
    • 04:12:50
      But I do commend staff.
    • 04:12:52
      They have done everything I believe that they can possibly do.
    • 04:12:57
      And I'm hoping that the General Assembly members will take hold now.
    • 04:13:02
      and maybe they'll see that some way we have got to do something different in Virginia so that we can serve our citizens of the Commonwealth.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:11
      Thank you.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:13
      Thank you.
    • 04:13:13
      Mr. Witt?
    • Alan S. WittMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:14
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:13:15
      Mr. Commissioner, you've done a good job in your staff and provided a lot of information.
    • 04:13:21
      I probably don't have yet enough information in order to pass judgment
    • 04:13:29
      on whether we're doing the right thing.
    • 04:13:31
      I'm going to sound like a broken record.
    • 04:13:33
      We are at the tipping point.
    • 04:13:37
      When I joined you all four years ago, our pavement was substandard by 18 percent and it's been growing at a percent or more per year and at the blink of an eye, we're going to be at 25 percent.
    • 04:13:52
      Our chief engineer got my attention about bridges a number of years ago and
    • 04:13:57
      Ms. Busher today on a slide said that we will need $3.7 billion to replace all the currently deficient bridges but a year and a half ago we heard that I had a slide that sort of said if you extrapolate at our current replacement rate it would take over 125 years to replace all the bridges and culverts in Virginia.
    • 04:14:19
      And I would argue that most of them were not built to have a 125-year life.
    • 04:14:27
      Whether we like it or not, we have been relegated to the maintenance business.
    • 04:14:34
      I know that Dr. Davis and I probably disagree greatly on this.
    • 04:14:39
      But I can't see from this blueprint how we are adequately planning for the future.
    • 04:14:47
      We're making cuts today in order to make the budget balance, but I'm unclear as to where we're going.
    • 04:14:55
      We should be upset.
    • 04:14:57
      We've been given a job to do, and the General Assembly has not given us anywhere near the required resources to do that job.
    • 04:15:06
      Nobody likes where we are.
    • 04:15:08
      No one likes to see a stagnant program or one that doesn't look forward to the future, but we have to deal with reality.
    • 04:15:17
      And if I've learned anything in the last four years is that hope is not a strategy and new money is not forthcoming and we have to get our hands around what we want to do.
    • 04:15:29
      Mr. Chairman, you said in July we're going to hear about new goals or standards for pavement or, well, when it comes to adopting this budget, this is part of the information that I feel that I'm missing today.
    • 04:15:42
      I don't know what to cut today in order to prepare our organization for tomorrow.
    • 04:15:47
      At what rate are we going to be able to sustain pavement or repair these bridges?
    • 04:15:55
      We talked about the ferry.
    • 04:15:56
      If we don't get that money for that $30 million ferry, I'll tell you, if I was going to spend $30 million on a boat, it would look a lot better than that.
    • 04:16:12
      If we don't get that money, this is just a delayed problem.
    • 04:16:15
      Those folks coming from Surry and Isle of Wight are not going to be able to get across that river because we're not going to have a water transportation vehicle that's going to take them there.
    • 04:16:26
      I know that we're all sensitive to people and their jobs and no one likes to utter the words that more jobs
    • 04:16:37
      No matter where you are in management or oversight of an organization, those are things you want to talk about.
    • 04:16:48
      But our construction budget four years ago was $8.6 billion and we saw today now it's $5.4 billion and I would argue even with the abatement of some of the construction costs,
    • 04:17:00
      There still has been inflation over that period of time and in fact with the 5.4 billion we can only do half of what we were able to do with 8.6 billion four years ago.
    • 04:17:14
      We've cut our staff from 10,500 to 7,500.
    • 04:17:18
      The bean counter says if you're doing half the program you haven't cut half your staff.
    • 04:17:29
      We're not doing half the program.
    • 04:17:30
      We're switching.
    • 04:17:31
      We're not doing construction.
    • 04:17:32
      We need to be a maintenance organization.
    • 04:17:35
      But again, Mr. Commissioner, I'm not sure I understand the model of the organization and how many people we need to do what our new mission needs to be.
    • 04:17:45
      And you've outlined the blueprint, but I'm not there yet.
    • 04:17:54
      I can't get my hands around this.
    • 04:17:57
      And I think as different
    • 04:17:59
      Of my colleagues, they're not going to like this cut or that cut, but I don't think we're sitting here with a comprehensive vision as to where we need to be so that we can either give thumbs up or thumbs down to what's appropriate to do.
    • 04:18:14
      These cuts meet our needs for this year.
    • 04:18:18
      But they don't lay out the blueprint enough for where the organization needs to go.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:18:25
      Thanks.
    • 04:18:25
      And I do, I think a great deal of that work has been done by Dr. Allen and the Commissioner's staff.
    • 04:18:31
      I think there's a lot of detail and we can talk about how to get that out electronically to the board members.
    • 04:18:37
      So I think at least when you talk about the staffing complement, if we're all maintenance,
    • 04:18:42
      essentially what does that look like and I think also too if the focus is on that the construction program increasingly is about bridges and bridge replacement which if you stand back and look at it there's a whole lot of it that is like that.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:19:00
      Well, having personally, having in the past to implement workforce reductions, even in large numbers as much as 600, I don't envy the staff and what they face in terms of facing the people they've got to give a pink slip to.
    • 04:19:16
      And I know there's a transition-type program in place and we need to have patience with that and do everything we can to make that a smooth transition.
    • 04:19:27
      And it wouldn't be wrong to remind the people, even the ones
    • 04:19:31
      that are going to be eliminated, that there have been attempts over the last eight years to raise revenues.
    • 04:19:39
      And the fact that we're in this downturn in the economy is not the main reason that we're having to do such drastic reductions to the program.
    • 04:19:49
      We would have this problem if we didn't have, even if we didn't have this downturn in the economy.
    • 04:19:56
      And so there have been attempts to alleviate it early on.
    • 04:19:59
      In addition to that,
    • 04:20:00
      You very well remember there have been attempts in the General Assembly to change the funding formula for the distribution of funds and transportation and that's failed every time.
    • 04:20:14
      But we're going to turn around as CTB and basically do some of that through the drafting of and the developing of road categories that will have priorities.
    • 04:20:25
      And that will begin to shift maintenance funds to areas for the state where they definitely need it.
    • 04:20:33
      But it will also drain it from rural Virginia to get it to the urban areas with these road categories.
    • 04:20:38
      And we're going to maintain the 20,000 miles by and large
    • 04:20:43
      Thirty-seven, I guess it's left, exist in rural Virginia.
    • 04:20:48
      And they're going to be found in the categories of three, fours and fives primarily, which will not get very much money for maintenance.
    • 04:20:55
      So we're basically going to do for them the things that they couldn't pass in the legislature is look at a redistribution of money to maintain the roads on what money we've got, even though it's a reduced pie.
    • 04:21:07
      We're going to see larger portions of it go into that 85% region, which I feel like is
    • 04:21:12
      It's really where we need to look at this plan and make some adjustments and put some floor on the maintenance money that needs to go to some of the counties and some of these lower categories of roads.
    • 04:21:23
      It's really devastating.
    • 04:21:25
      It's not intended.
    • 04:21:26
      It's a loss of revenue.
    • 04:21:27
      It's devastation to areas that cannot help themselves, that are already hurting.
    • 04:21:35
      My appeal would be as we look to make adjustments to the blueprint is that we've got to make that change.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:21:46
      Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:21:49
      This is tough stuff and many of us have been involved in this and the private sector is sitting on boards and some of us have been involved in the public sector and sitting on local boards of supervisors and so forth.
    • 04:22:04
      I commended the commissioner back when he first rolled out his initial set of proposals because this is tough stuff and it showed a lot of leadership on his part and on the part of his staff and I have admired the way, at least in the public hearing I attended, the commissioner handled all the individual concerns of citizens.
    • 04:22:34
      In my district, I've gotten, once I have sat down with people that had initial concerns about closing of equipment repair facilities and residencies, once we talked it through, I found that folks pretty well accepted what we were doing.
    • 04:22:54
      Now, in terms of rest areas and ferries, I don't have any of those in my district.
    • 04:23:02
      And so I have to defer to my colleagues on the board that do have those facilities and have been close to the citizens' concerns that have been voiced to them.
    • 04:23:16
      But maybe that lets me look at it a little bit more objectively since I don't have any of those concerns in my district.
    • 04:23:23
      I sit here and look at the proposed cuts to the ferry services.
    • 04:23:31
      The amount of money that's to be saved there is peanuts.
    • 04:23:34
      It's $75,000 in one instance and $75,000 in another and I think $21,000 in another.
    • 04:23:42
      There's no way for me to evaluate whether the value of those savings offsets the cutting of the service.
    • 04:23:50
      I just can't do that.
    • 04:23:52
      And so I've got to rely on my friends from the Hampton Roads area and I think there's one in the Culpeper District as well.
    • 04:24:01
      for them to respond to.
    • 04:24:03
      The rest areas, I'm in the same boat.
    • 04:24:05
      127 miles apart sounds reasonable to me.
    • 04:24:12
      But I've got to say, with all due respect, having complimented the commissioner and his staff, I've never seen in my 40 years a budget of $3.5 billion where you couldn't find $9 or $10 million.
    • 04:24:30
      to deal with some of the concerns that members of the board have expressed.
    • 04:24:34
      Now, you know, in the final analysis I will support the budget as it turns out to be, but those are my honest objective, objective as I can be comments at this point, Mr. Chairman.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:24:50
      Thank you.
    • 04:24:52
      Mr. Davie.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:24:53
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to join in commending the Commissioner.
    • 04:24:58
      I think he has continued what was started through attrition with 40-10, but he's refined it.
    • 04:25:06
      And he's had a tougher job because it's no longer just attrition, it's having to directly take the scaffold to the muscle, and that becomes a challenge.
    • 04:25:19
      One of the things that I've heard the most frequently is the concern that by taking that scaffold to the muscle, we are going to deliver less service and the citizens of Virginia are going to be less well served.
    • 04:25:36
      And that's going to be a real challenge.
    • 04:25:42
      The determination that we're going to get this done, well, we may get it done, but it also carries with it some fairly significant risk, both in terms of credibility and in terms, the one thing that I've learned to watch as I've gone through this process, quite frankly, is what
    • 04:26:04
      The legislature does, when it doesn't like what the Commonwealth Transportation Board does, is it simply intervenes and takes other action.
    • 04:26:13
      I am concerned that what we are about to do with the rest areas is to tread into that territory.
    • 04:26:23
      And I think there is some benefit to taking a step back and doing what Jim Davis mentioned, taking a look at it,
    • 04:26:34
      especially if there are rest areas that the legislature has money that it has invested in rehabilitation and we are about to close six of those facilities.
    • 04:26:46
      I think we need to give that some additional thought as we work these funds.
    • 04:26:52
      One of the other things I guess that I've given some thought to, I've been trying to talk to some of the local governments in my region and there is a concern that the seniority rule that we have is going to be implemented and there are going to be people who they have developed working relationships with who have a very strong work ethic who may be younger
    • 04:27:21
      who may not be the ones because of Tynorley who are left in the positions of responsibility and they are concerned that through the process there may be individuals left in place who represent the old guard who are not going to be responsive and we're not going to get that shared vision in the future.
    • 04:27:44
      And I'm hearing that now repeated, and it's getting enough credence that I'm getting calls from local governments saying, listen, I understand this is going to be an issue.
    • 04:27:56
      You need to pay attention to it.
    • 04:27:58
      You know, we have to deal with it.
    • 04:27:59
      You all ought to look at this.
    • 04:28:01
      My assurance to them is that I'm sure that the district administrators are communicating with the commissioner on that issue.
    • 04:28:08
      And it's not one that we necessarily need to be involved with, but it's one we're going to hear about.
    • 04:28:13
      And one other point that I've made a couple of times and that is if we're looking at closing facilities and we are looking at having vacant facilities, we ought to be considering now the utilization of those properties or how we're going to deal with them.
    • 04:28:34
      One of the things that we don't want to have happen is to have them become community eyesores because they're going to be our eyesores.
    • 04:28:43
      We need to look at the utilization of those structures.
    • 04:28:48
      It's amazing how as this progress is made, and I'll use the example in orange, they're closing the shop.
    • 04:28:55
      Well, the shop is directly across from the school.
    • 04:28:57
      The chair of the school board calls me and says, listen, we need an automobile facility for our schools.
    • 04:29:04
      Can we lease it from VDOT?
    • 04:29:06
      Can we buy it from VDOT?
    • 04:29:08
      It's a very small example of an asset that we have that we can turn back into community use and we ought to be looking at that wherever we have facilities.
    • 04:29:19
      The other thing that I think is important is that we make sure that as we stop using facilities, we may want to look at alternate uses.
    • 04:29:31
      It may not be just beneficial to simply cut the utilities and close them.
    • 04:29:37
      We may have other purposes.
    • 04:29:38
      I'm sure district administrators will be looking at that.
    • 04:29:42
      But my point is, as we're doing all this, we haven't had very much discussion
    • 04:29:47
      about our inventory of properties, their location, their value, and their reuse, and I think that ought to be a part of what we're really doing, or at least the next phase of what we're doing with this project.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:30:05
      Thank you, Ms. Connolly.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:30:06
      I would say listen to this wise person.
    • 04:30:09
      I think he's made some very good points, and I'll be very brief.
    • 04:30:13
      But I find the things that I've heard today that two things that disturb me a great deal are the devolve, I mean, reverting to prior to my tenure on the board when we were funding the local maintenance at 3%.
    • 04:30:31
      And we did raise it to a much more realistic, probably not even adequate, but a 4% figure.
    • 04:30:36
      And it really, I think it's a step backwards that we're having to compromise.
    • 04:30:42
      moved back to a 3%.
    • 04:30:45
      And the second one is the, I'm now speaking for, I'm a twofer.
    • 04:30:50
      I'm a female and I'm elderly.
    • 04:30:53
      And there are two areas in which I think that that population cohort needs to be recognized.
    • 04:30:59
      And one is the safety of patrol standards that apparently were moving back to a 2001 service level.
    • 04:31:07
      I think that
    • 04:31:09
      It may be absolutely necessary but it is going to impact the one, the elderly and also women I think more than men in the safety service area and also the rest stops that has an implication there for particularly at our public hearing I heard a couple people talking about the handicapped and their use of the rest areas and all of ours I think are handicapped accessible and I think that's a value
    • 04:31:37
      That does need to be considered.
    • 04:31:41
      So those are my comments.
    • 04:31:42
      It's very worrisome to be moving backwards and although I appreciate the constraints and the context in which these decisions are set.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:57
      It's an ill wind and it blows no good.
    • 04:32:02
      I can envision some of these organizational changes
    • 04:32:07
      effecting a better organization, a more efficient organization, one that can get along better in the future and hopefully in the future we'll have better revenues and better opportunities to do the things that need to be done.
    • 04:32:24
      But it may be in the long run that these changes that were necessitated by the lack of money might turn out to be a good thing.
    • 04:32:35
      Sometimes
    • 04:32:37
      I feel like Southwest Virginia is treated like a red-headed stepchild.
    • 04:32:42
      And I'm sure that all of us have things we want for our district that are not there.
    • 04:32:50
      But, like, we're getting a $38 million cut from 2009 to 2010, whereas Northern Virginia is getting a $32 million increase in that same period of time.
    • 04:33:07
      I feel a real disappointment that we were unable to cut from six residencies to four in our district, rather than six to three.
    • 04:33:21
      We now have every residency, including four counties, which are geographically, space-wise, very, very big counties.
    • 04:33:30
      And I just can't help but feel that that is a mistake.
    • 04:33:36
      But, you know, I'm looking at it from my perspective, and each one of us will look at it from our own perspective.
    • 04:33:45
      If we had said, okay, members of the Transportation Board, you'd come up with a plan.
    • 04:33:51
      We'd have 16 different plans.
    • 04:33:54
      None of them would be perfect.
    • 04:33:56
      None of us would like all of it.
    • 04:34:00
      And probably none of us would like any one plan, just as all of us are not going to like everything about the Commissioner's plan.
    • 04:34:07
      But he knows what he's doing and I don't.
    • 04:34:10
      I yield to his expertise and somebody had to do it.
    • 04:34:16
      It's absolutely necessary that these changes be made.
    • 04:34:20
      And I commend the commissioner and all of the staff that had an involvement in it.
    • 04:34:26
      I think they've done as good a job as could have been done under these very difficult circumstances.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:34:36
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:34:37
      As a couple of our colleagues have already pointed out, this is not easy, but that's why we are in the big bucks, I guess, on this board.
    • 04:34:47
      It is ultimately our responsibility to take the Commissioner's recommendations and try to deal as constructively as we can with them.
    • 04:34:57
      I commend him and his staff as always for being very professional, very thorough.
    • 04:35:05
      But they're certainly not perfect, and I think there is enough wisdom around this table.
    • 04:35:11
      That is what we're here for, to provide policy advice.
    • 04:35:13
      I don't want to run the VDOT forum.
    • 04:35:15
      I wouldn't pretend to know how to.
    • 04:35:17
      But I look at the changes he's proposing in a slightly different way, and I'm going to ask that he and his staff give this some consideration.
    • 04:35:27
      When he talks about the cuts in services, such as the rest areas and the mowing and
    • 04:35:33
      Other things, and then internal cuts.
    • 04:35:36
      I see these as two distinctly different types of services that he is being forced to deal with.
    • 04:35:45
      In the broadest categories, there are two.
    • 04:35:47
      One has to do with internal services, such as, for example, fees or monies paid to Vita.
    • 04:35:59
      Others have to do with
    • 04:36:01
      external services such as things that serve the traveling public such as rest areas.
    • 04:36:08
      To say that those are both services that need to be cut misses to me a very important distinction about who they actually serve.
    • 04:36:17
      And so I'm going to ask that they go back and look carefully at balancing the internal service cuts and the external ones with the bias towards
    • 04:36:31
      serving the external traveling public.
    • 04:36:34
      As Ken White pointed out, and as I think I said earlier, $9 million is not even a rounding error in our budget, and yet that's what it would cost to save, I mean to close the 19 rest areas, of which six, by the way, are in
    • 04:36:55
      District of Richmond.
    • 04:36:56
      You asked the effect on the district.
    • 04:36:58
      Well, there's one.
    • 04:36:58
      We're taking a pretty good hit, although I'm not saying that they couldn't be dispensed with, but one of them between the North Carolina line and the mountains on one side and Fredericksburg on the other side does not seem to be unreasonable to me to the traveling public.
    • 04:37:14
      However, my bigger point is look at the difference between what you have to live with internally and perhaps look there first.
    • 04:37:22
      versus, and I don't mean people, we're already doing enough damage there, I don't want to see one other person have to lose a job.
    • 04:37:31
      But I mean these other services, $68 million a year for VITA, that seems on its face a target of opportunity.
    • 04:37:40
      The fencing, the repairs, that sort of stuff might be another opportunity.
    • 04:37:46
      The difference between what serves
    • 04:37:48
      The internal operation and what serves the public, that to me is a very important distinction and I hope you will look at that.
    • 04:37:55
      Perhaps it might be possible to consider delaying this till January 1st.
    • 04:38:02
      Maybe by then we'll know if there's going to be federal movement on privatizing the rest areas or giving us permission to do that.
    • 04:38:11
      It would also be better time to get maximum exposure for the effects of these cuts on the people who most need to see the effects of these cuts, the real decision makers when it comes to that side of things.
    • 04:38:25
      And I will say it is encouraging to know that some localities have called in their General Assembly delegations and told them point blank that it's time to quit fooling around and raise the gas tax.
    • 04:38:36
      I mean, a dime a day or less, we wouldn't be talking about this at all.
    • 04:38:41
      It's absolutely ridiculous that we find ourselves in a situation where we are literally cutting out the people's ability to use rest facilities because we cannot raise a rather insignificant amount of money over the next few years to pay for maintenance of those kinds of services.
    • 04:39:03
      So I mean I could go on and on but we've got plenty of other people who need to talk and I'll stop.
    • 04:39:08
      I do think the important thing is look at what we're doing to the public and look at what we might be able to do internally in the way of services, the way we run the operation.
    • 04:39:17
      There is bound to be some savings there and I hope that we can do that.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:39:25
      I've a number of times talked to the
    • 04:39:29
      public about this board, my colleague here being, the term I use is non-geocentric.
    • 04:39:37
      And I'm just going by what comes out of your mouth.
    • 04:39:39
      I don't know what's in your heart, but I feel as if we, as a group, collectively look out for the best interest of the state as well as the best interest of our districts.
    • 04:39:52
      And, Gerald, if it was easy, anybody could do it, you know?
    • 04:39:55
      And that's the situation that we find ourselves in now.
    • 04:39:59
      Speaking as the representative of Salem District, for example, the AARA decisions are there.
    • 04:40:11
      I'm happy we got to share in the pavement and got to share in the enhancement with the candidates who would like to see us get some construction money.
    • 04:40:22
      Martinsville-Henry County is the poster child for economically distressed
    • 04:40:28
      But at least now I'm glad I understand what happened to the money for I-73 that was not airmarked with the interstate.
    • 04:40:36
      So nothing is going to be perfect.
    • 04:40:39
      There are things I like for my district, things I would rather have gone differently for my district.
    • 04:40:47
      One of the things in a maximum business that I've always, well since I found out it was true, I've always been a proponent
    • 04:40:57
      The one who is actually closest to the work doing it is the one who best knows how a job should be done and I'm thinking on two levels that the blueprint is going to force that upon VDOT and I would encourage you to just go ahead and acknowledge that right now and I've seen no evidence to the contrary and just start out
    • 04:41:25
      Understanding a new way of doing business, the one who's closest to it knows best how it ought to be done.
    • 04:41:31
      For us, that is symptomatic and we will also have to keep that in mind, for example, with the localities now, decisions that they used to get to do.
    • 04:41:42
      We are going to have to do extra work, make extra effort that we practice that same principle and understanding
    • 04:41:53
      What the one who no longer gets to do it really knows that we don't know.
    • 04:41:59
      And bring that knowledge and perspective back to help us make sure we make the right decisions and help other people make the right decisions.
    • 04:42:08
      The one who's closest to it is the one who is going to know best how it ought to be done.
    • 04:42:14
      The rest areas
    • 04:42:17
      at least a bit justify my defense of VDOT and the administration when people were making you up.
    • 04:42:28
      They were saying some awful things.
    • 04:42:29
      I don't know what your emails look like, but you know.
    • 04:42:33
      And now I can go back and say, see, we can be reasonable and flexible and figure out a better way to do things.
    • 04:42:45
      Well, that can't be a one-time event.
    • 04:42:48
      Reality is changing on us.
    • 04:42:50
      Reality has changed, and no one in the city is going to be the one that's always correct.
    • 04:42:57
      So, actually, all this comes down to, and you all know it, you've said it a lot, Gerald, and said it more eloquently and frequently, but what we're looking at is the collision between political will and public would.
    • 04:43:14
      The political will is to say privatize the rest areas.
    • 04:43:21
      The public would use all the rest areas and keep them open.
    • 04:43:26
      The public would use the safety service patrols and be glad they're there.
    • 04:43:32
      The political will is to not fund them because it means finding revenue.
    • 04:43:40
      The public would
    • 04:43:43
      have a residency in every county.
    • 04:43:46
      The political will is to audit VDOT to look for inefficiencies.
    • 04:43:51
      The public would vote against toxins.
    • 04:43:54
      The political will is to pander to that.
    • 04:43:57
      The public would also reward someone who came with sound, logical, and fair solutions.
    • 04:44:09
      and then more importantly communicated those solutions to the public and to the legislators.
    • 04:44:19
      The political will is to not do that much work or not take those chances.
    • 04:44:27
      That's the reality that is here.
    • 04:44:31
      So it might be time for us to just get all the way out of the box, down under the table or up on top of the table, but to determine what is going to be the new paradigm and start promoting that new paradigm based on what we've got to work with.
    • 04:44:49
      Unless we can find a way to change what we have to work with.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:54
      Thanks.
    • 04:44:54
      Now, Dr. Davis, we're ready for it.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:56
      Well, I apologize a little bit for my combative nature, but it's all done in good spirit, and I do want you to know my respect for my colleagues and the Secretary and the Commissioner and all the staff.
    • 04:45:07
      I offer my full support for the majority of this plan and have taken my hits.
    • 04:45:15
      from members of the General Assembly and from entire boards of supervisors when I have supported closing residencies and a number of other things.
    • 04:45:25
      And I will continue to do that because I believe that we have to honor our commitment to have a balanced budget and to live within the means that are given to us.
    • 04:45:32
      That does not mean, however, I or you have to be happy about that.
    • 04:45:37
      And we should be expressing our opinions forcibly and regularly
    • 04:45:41
      to the broader constituencies that we're not happy with the position we're put in and I hope we can organize to do that more effectively.
    • 04:45:50
      The one thing that still troubles me in all of this is that I really believe there is not a sound plan for the closing of these rest areas that we can live with and I think it needs to be delayed and we need to have that plan and I will support closing a number of these rest areas and revising their purpose because the secretary made me quite aware that
    • 04:46:11
      These rest areas were built for a different day and a different reason.
    • 04:46:15
      I hadn't thought about it in those terms but they've come to be very important to a lot of constituencies who feel very strongly that if we take them away that we're doing a disservice to them.
    • 04:46:28
      They don't relate the business of paying taxes as being related to the closure and we will do great harm to VDOT and to the people who do public service
    • 04:46:42
      by closing them without a good, clear plan for why and what we're going to do with them.
    • 04:46:47
      Because we cannot board up or put up simple barriers for these facilities along 81, 95, even 85, even though it may not be as pretty as 81 or some of the other areas.
    • 04:47:02
      We can't do that.
    • 04:47:03
      And it's going to cost money.
    • 04:47:04
      I mean, the commissioner and I talked about this.
    • 04:47:06
      It's going to be 25 or 30 million dollars just to tear down the buildings and clean up the areas.
    • 04:47:11
      Where is that coming from?
    • 04:47:12
      We can't not have that plan and know how we're going to implement it.
    • 04:47:16
      So I really hope we will delay for some period of time closing these rest areas to come up with that plan and to figure out how to take it out of another area with it doing minimal damage to any other area so that we can do it right.
    • 04:47:34
      And I thank all of you for your patience and listening to me on this, but I got an earful many times on it.
    • 04:47:41
      And I think it's important that I share with you just how much I've heard about this issue from people across the Commonwealth and especially people who travel the interstates so that you'll be as sensitive to it perhaps as I have become.
    • 04:47:55
      So I thank you for your patience and listening to me.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:48:01
      Some years ago, the columnist Ellen Goodman, who some of you may know, turned 40 years old and one of her friends said, wow, you don't look 40.
    • 04:48:11
      She said, honey, this is what 40 looks like.
    • 04:48:14
      Well, you know, there's a certain amount of activity here that's, it's one thing to be unresponsive, it's another thing to be irresponsible, even negligent.
    • 04:48:25
      And I think probably that's where we are.
    • 04:48:28
      This blueprint begins to show the General Assembly, this is what your decisions really look like.
    • 04:48:35
      The decisions
    • 04:48:36
      The irresponsible decisions and the neglect of the last six years in particular looks like this.
    • 04:48:44
      It looks like rest areas.
    • 04:48:45
      It looks like safety patrols.
    • 04:48:46
      It looks like mowing.
    • 04:48:48
      It also looks like layoffs.
    • 04:48:49
      It looks like no construction budget.
    • 04:48:52
      It looks like our inability to keep our promises and our obligations on transportation to ourselves, to localities, to the traveling public.
    • 04:49:03
      I sympathize with
    • 04:49:05
      Your comments, Dr. Davis.
    • 04:49:06
      But the fact is, in the hearing in Northern Virginia there were three big constituencies that were worried about the rest areas.
    • 04:49:13
      There were truckers, there were tourism people, and there were travelers.
    • 04:49:17
      Not one of them offered any alternative to what was being proposed.
    • 04:49:21
      Nobody said, I'd be willing to pay something more.
    • 04:49:24
      They wanted something for free because they've been promised that that's what they can have.
    • 04:49:31
      I'm saying this in general.
    • 04:49:33
      We're not talking about change now.
    • 04:49:35
      We're talking about a transformation of our system.
    • 04:49:37
      And I think you've got your finger on it.
    • 04:49:39
      I think it's difficult to admit that, but we're not just changing some things.
    • 04:49:45
      VDOT is not just going to be smaller and yet still the same shape.
    • 04:49:49
      Our mission is changing, our responsibilities aboard are changing, and they're changing these ways.
    • 04:49:54
      If you move to maintenance and operations as first, increasingly those are decisions that are made by technical requirements.
    • 04:50:03
      They involve quantifiable measurements of where you make investments and why and the return on those investments.
    • 04:50:11
      And with all due respect for my colleague from Bristol, it has nothing to do with equity to each of us as board members.
    • 04:50:18
      It has to do with science and facts and technology and applications that shouldn't be in a room to be divided up in a political fashion.
    • 04:50:28
      That diminishes our role as the CTB.
    • 04:50:30
      You know, the decision we make about construction or about corridors, those are bigger decisions.
    • 04:50:36
      What's a vision of the future decisions?
    • 04:50:38
      Maintenance and operations are not those kinds of decisions.
    • 04:50:41
      So one of the things I'm looking at is we ought to revisit our role as the board and even the size as a board.
    • 04:50:49
      This board is too big if we're just going to administer a maintenance and operations budget.
    • 04:50:55
      Let's have four members from four districts and four members that large, and that's probably enough to do the job.
    • 04:51:01
      Let's look at the way we conduct our business.
    • 04:51:04
      Let's look at the way that the Board is expected to interface with the constituencies and with the people of Virginia.
    • 04:51:12
      I mean, those are what transformation really involves, not fiddling around the edges.
    • 04:51:17
      And I think too many of us are still stuck fiddling around the edges.
    • 04:51:21
      Alan Witt has said it more directly than anybody else, and that's really what we're faced with.
    • 04:51:28
      Now, I applaud the work of the Commissioner and of the Department.
    • 04:51:32
      Extraordinary good work.
    • 04:51:34
      I think it's by establishing standards criteria, quantifiable results in each of these areas, by taking it to the public and hearing really what the public had to say, I think we're on very solid ground.
    • 04:51:49
      But the fact is going forward, VDOT's not going to be the same shape.
    • 04:51:55
      It's not going to be able to perform the same set of functions.
    • 04:51:58
      And until the General Assembly sees the consequences of its inactions,
    • 04:52:03
      It will not make the changes that are necessary.
    • 04:52:06
      Its answer is to cut and paste around the edges because here's the other part of transformation.
    • 04:52:15
      The way the system's set up is what economists call the steady state.
    • 04:52:20
      Gradually increasing revenues each year will match gradually increasing needs each year.
    • 04:52:25
      Well, that hasn't been the case here in transportation for two decades.
    • 04:52:29
      The fact is, Northern Virginia is suffering not just from maintenance and operational deficiencies,
    • 04:52:36
      We need more capacity, but you look at this plan and the budget we're talking about today, there's no money for any capacity.
    • 04:52:44
      It's the same set of questions that the commissioner faced on people.
    • 04:52:48
      You can't just reduce the numbers because you don't have the right people in the right places doing the right things.
    • 04:52:55
      Right now in Virginia, we don't have the right transportation infrastructure in the right places doing the right things, but we have no capacity to move it.
    • 04:53:03
      We're stuck 15 years ago.
    • 04:53:09
      Now I don't mean that we're not making improvements.
    • 04:53:11
      I don't mean that we're not trying hard and I don't mean that the money we've appropriated in the last few years hasn't been used wisely or well.
    • 04:53:18
      The fact is if we can't complete our networks, we don't really get the benefit of those improvements.
    • 04:53:25
      If we can only do a segment of a highway and not the whole highway, we can't get
    • 04:53:30
      the capacity improvements that we need.
    • 04:53:31
      If we can't add the interchanges, if we can't keep the bridges open and so forth.
    • 04:53:36
      So, you know, my conclusion is we're on the right track.
    • 04:53:40
      I would like to see us be even more draconian in the way we attack this, anticipate not just a little bit of reduction in federal funds but a lot.
    • 04:53:50
      anticipate absolutely no remedial action by the General Assembly and really look at how we cut all this down and really be honest about it.
    • 04:54:03
      Okay, that's a lot of points all at once.
    • 04:54:05
      Specifically, I think the rest area methodology is very good and I don't support any delay in those changes.
    • 04:54:13
      I think the methodology on the
    • 04:54:15
      The maintenance of roadways and so forth is solid, even down to the turf grass.
    • 04:54:20
      I was impressed with that.
    • 04:54:21
      I would like a little more information myself about some of the cross-agency agreements that we have with DMV, the state police, because I do think that those need to be renegotiated in some way.
    • 04:54:36
      VITA, I understand a little bit more because I was involved a little bit when it was created and I understand that
    • 04:54:41
      A large part of the savings people anticipate by doing it themselves is basically not paying for seat licenses for all your people, not really using security or software that protects the system.
    • 04:54:54
      So you cut corners so you can save money like we all do at home with our own computers.
    • 04:54:58
      Probably no virus will get me.
    • 04:55:00
      But on those other things, that has to be a part of a larger conversation because what we see is this platform that we have just isn't strong enough to support all these services.
    • 04:55:12
      And quite frankly, you know, if tourism wants welcome centers and so forth and that's a tourist function, there ought to be a way that tourism pays for it.
    • 04:55:22
      The same way with the trucks, if they want additional parking spaces, you know, there's no reason they can't add that $1,834 in taxes paid to be $1,854 paid.
    • 04:55:32
      I mean, that's not gonna make or break their businesses.
    • 04:55:37
      And then finally, people need to be honestly told that if you value something, you have to pay for it.
    • 04:55:44
      And through this process, very complex of tip, sip,
    • 04:55:49
      slip, rip, I mean, it's just, it's too complex, there's too many little hidden ball tricks, and we just need to be much more honest about this.
    • 04:55:59
      In conclusion, I'll just say I think you have been, Mr. Secretary, I think you have been, Mr. Commissioner, and I think, as colleagues, I think we all have been, so that's our strength, tell it straight, let the chips fall where they may, and if those with the power to make a change,
    • 04:56:16
      decide to do it, they will.
    • 04:56:18
      If they don't, well, they need to understand the consequences because, honey, this is what it looks like.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:56:25
      Last words, Mr. Sterling.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:56:27
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 04:56:29
      I have a very long and eloquent speech prepared but given that the hour is late, nobody wants to hear it and much of it has been said before, let me just see if I can summarize where we essentially are.
    • 04:56:41
      There are a lot of wants in transportation.
    • 04:56:45
      There's a smaller subset which are needs, and yet there's a smaller subset still which is that which we can afford.
    • 04:56:55
      We're in the unfortunate position not of being able to decide what of the wants we're going to fund, but what of the needs we're not going to fund.
    • 04:57:05
      That's where we are today.
    • 04:57:06
      That's where we've been for recent history.
    • 04:57:10
      I'm not omniscient.
    • 04:57:12
      If I were, I'd probably come up with a different package than what we have before us.
    • 04:57:16
      But I'll bet it wouldn't be that much different.
    • 04:57:19
      It was put together, as Mr. Schwartz said, with a lot of time, a lot of energy, as others have said.
    • 04:57:25
      I will be the first to say that should an amendment be proposed, I will fairly evaluate it.
    • 04:57:31
      I will vote according to what I think the merits of that amendment should be, what the highest priorities should be.
    • 04:57:38
      But I think it's going to be a very, very
    • 04:57:41
      Steve Hill, the Klein, to be able to make a lot of changes.
    • 04:57:45
      There are things in here, again, that I want.
    • 04:57:48
      There are things that we need.
    • 04:57:50
      But do we need them as much as we need some of the others?
    • 04:57:54
      This isn't a case of making decisions on what will propel us further ahead, what will put us in the best position for the future necessarily.
    • 04:58:03
      But we're deciding on what we're going to keep
    • 04:58:06
      in this project, in this budget in order to prevent us from falling much further behind.
    • 04:58:12
      That's where we are and we've got to recognize whether it's because of the rules that were presented, whether it's the revenue streams coming out of the state, whether it's the federal revenue streams.
    • 04:58:23
      The whole system right now is not geared towards providing the means that are necessary, the resources that are necessary to meet all the needs, let alone all the wants.
    • 04:58:34
      So I think that's what we're going to be faced with and that's what we'll be voting on in June.
    • 04:58:38
      That's what we'll be deliberating on over the course of the next month and I wish us all luck in that process and if anybody's got a sound amendment to put forward some of those things which they think are a critical need, again, I will fairly evaluate everything before voting but it is a steep hill.
    • 04:58:56
      I want to commend the commissioner and the staff and the secretary and staff for putting together what they have done.
    • 04:59:02
      There are a lot of things I'd like to see changed in this.
    • 04:59:05
      All those things are increases.
    • 04:59:07
      There's not a single decrease in here that I would recommend.
    • 04:59:10
      And that's the problem.
    • 04:59:11
      And that's the problem I think we're all going to face when it comes time to amendment.
    • 04:59:14
      So thank you very much.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:59:18
      Okay.
    • 04:59:18
      I want to thank everybody for their attention.
    • 04:59:21
      I would just mention two things.
    • 04:59:22
      One is we're not in the business of micromanaging or running the department.
    • 04:59:27
      So what we will be looking at are performance standards.
    • 04:59:31
      for these areas.
    • 04:59:32
      That's how the budget is being constructed, and that's actually a first for this budget.
    • 04:59:35
      So that's, I think, progress and part of transformation.
    • 04:59:40
      I do think, you know, we all look at these revenue estimates in the eye.
    • 04:59:45
      Where we are today, we know we've not done enough in the way of cuts.
    • 04:59:49
      And the latest estimate of federal revenues is very scary, and I take very seriously Mr. Witt's charge.
    • 04:59:57
      Where are we over the long haul?
    • 04:59:59
      I'm hopeful that we can take that issue up over the fall as we look realistically about what it's going to cost just to maintain pavements and bridges.
    • 05:00:09
      Nobody's done that cumulatively.
    • 05:00:10
      That's a scary number, but it is more than all the money we have of what's left just to do those two things.
    • 05:00:18
      So I think we need to segment this.
    • 05:00:21
      We do have to adopt a budget next month.
    • 05:00:24
      I think the appropriate way to do it and
    • 05:00:26
      And again, I just want to acknowledge the commissioner and the very hard work of his staff.
    • 05:00:30
      What you're hearing is a commissioner debate, but everyone is acknowledging the incredible professional quality of the work that you put together and the thoughtfulness behind it.
    • 05:00:42
      And I think that's the right way to proceed, recognizing that line between policy and administration.
    • 05:00:49
      And so we'll take that up in June.
    • 05:00:51
      I know there'll be a lot more information that staff will be getting out.
    • 05:00:55
      We'll have an opportunity to share thoughts and particularly as information comes out, I will be transmitting the Commissioner's recommendations to the General Assembly on Friday.
    • 05:01:08
      So we'll likely hear back a little bit more on that.
    • 05:01:13
      And I do think, again, just on a personal note,
    • 05:01:19
      I think one of the things we spent so much time discussing rest areas that I don't want to spend any more time on it, but when we're laying off a thousand people and we're worrying about bathrooms, I think we need to think very carefully about the balance and what is important.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:39
      I hope you're not implying, Mr. Secretary, that those of us that are raising that issue
    • 05:01:44
      are not cognizant of that because that's not true.
    • 05:01:49
      What is being said is a suggestion.
    • 05:01:54
      I take that as a rather unpleasant analysis.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:00
      May I finish my remarks please?
    • 05:02:05
      No one is saying that and I've said this in a number of public settings and this is a reflection on public hearings.
    • 05:02:11
      When we talk about three billion dollars of highway cuts
    • 05:02:15
      We talked about a thousand full-time lefts.
    • 05:02:17
      These are not vacancies.
    • 05:02:18
      These are real people.
    • 05:02:20
      When we talked about closing a third of our facilities, when we talked about having no money for economic development, if a cannon walked in the door today, do we have resources to bring that to Newport News?
    • 05:02:31
      The answer is no.
    • 05:02:34
      And I absolutely respect what you're saying, particularly about the aesthetics of the rest areas.
    • 05:02:39
      That's a very real issue.
    • 05:02:41
      But I do think that the debate on this in the public domain, and this is not at all pointed at you, it is how this bathrooms for whatever reason capture the imagination of the media and the public because it's immediate and personal.
    • 05:02:56
      People don't necessarily understand the nature of bridges or economic development, et cetera, et cetera.
    • 05:03:03
      But we have and are in this budget,
    • 05:03:06
      are going down some pathways that are very, very profound.
    • 05:03:11
      And I recall when Mr. Davies and Ms. Connally were in the General Assembly in the early 90s when the Wilder budget cuts came in.
    • 05:03:18
      And I remember Delegate Bob Harris going to the floor saying, ladies and gentlemen, we're fundamentally changing the way we fund higher education in Virginia and didn't get a whole lot of attention paid to it.
    • 05:03:29
      It was 10 years down the road.
    • 05:03:31
      before people started saying, hey, when did we change how we fund higher education?
    • 05:03:35
      And Dr. Davis, you've dealt with that in your career.
    • 05:03:39
      So please don't take my comment in that light.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:03:43
      I just didn't want you to triple that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:03:45
      No, and I'm not because I think the issue there is not so much the direct service.
    • 05:03:50
      I think the point you raise is more about the symbolism, you know, what that means for Virginia as a welcoming state.
    • 05:03:56
      That's an extremely valid comment.
    • 05:04:01
      But I also think that that discussion for a variety of reasons has clouded the very real structural changes that are going on here in transportation.
    • 05:04:12
      Local governments have no money, no money going forward.
    • 05:04:21
      And one of our priorities has been to talk about integrating transportation and land use.
    • 05:04:25
      How do you do that?
    • 05:04:27
      That is as profound a change in transportation as anything that's happened in the last 50 years.
    • 05:04:35
      And so, you know, my sense in saying and highlighting the rest area issue is, yes, it's important, it's symbolic, it's easily understood by the citizens, but the magnitude of the changes that we're undertaking here are very, very profound and will be felt for decades.
    • 05:04:54
      And I fear in a very negative
    • 05:04:57
      in particular the relationship with the localities.
    • 05:05:02
      So I mentioned that in good cheer as colleagues and I hope you'll accept the comment in that fashion.
    • 05:05:11
      But we, there are some very significant issues embedded here and I hope that we take a little bit more time perhaps even tomorrow to discuss some of those further because these are very important.
    • 05:05:24
      Dr. Davies, you're welcome to
    • 05:05:25
      Come back.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:05:26
      Well, the only comment I'll make back to you is this, that a lot of these changes obviously are profound in terms of the impact on local government, in terms of the impact on the general public.
    • 05:05:41
      And we've discussed those, and I think the majority of us have accepted the fact that they're necessary and that we will go to local government and do our job in saying
    • 05:05:54
      We've made these changes because we didn't have a choice and now you're going to live with the consequences of it for a long time unless you decide to do what you're capable of doing of influencing those people that are going to Richmond to set overall policy to begin to change it.
    • 05:06:14
      Because in my legislative career I was a part of the Bliles and Robb administrations when there was hope and willingness to take some really tough decisions
    • 05:06:23
      and raised the revenues to begin to address some of the issues that we dealt with.
    • 05:06:28
      And it can be restored again.
    • 05:06:30
      I'm confident of that.
    • 05:06:31
      That's where Al and I don't, we're not so far apart at all in terms of truth.
    • 05:06:36
      We're a little bit apart maybe in the use of words in terms of what I believe can be possible.
    • 05:06:43
      For now, we have to do the things that we're talking about.
    • 05:06:47
      But that doesn't mean it always has to be that way.
    • 05:06:49
      And we have to be the ones I think who speak up
    • 05:06:52
      and keep saying there is a better day out there, there is a better way of doing this and not be satisfied with it and that's what, to me the rest area thing represents a little bit of that.
    • 05:07:04
      I can't get my hands around the fact that local governments aren't going to have any money for transportation hardly and make any sense for the public but I can tell you when you get down to taking something like a rest area away from people who travel that road regularly, they understand that.
    • 05:07:20
      So that's why I didn't want to trivialize and think that I didn't understand the bigger, broader issues.
    • 05:07:27
      I'm not upset about it.
    • 05:07:28
      I just want to be sure we're all on the same page of being there.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:07:34
      And I think the symbolic value of that is something that is a little more easily understood than bridge ratings.
    • 05:07:41
      I would say, last note, just in terms of aesthetics, there's a sleeper issue in here, which I think is the mowing standards.
    • 05:07:49
      And when you don't mow, it's difficult to get the litter, the trash.
    • 05:07:54
      I think it was Ms. Carter talked about our beautiful state and how clean and green it is.
    • 05:07:58
      That's going to change.
    • 05:08:00
      And in many ways, that may be more profound and more visible and more noticeable to the average citizen than something which today, like the rest areas, is.
    • 05:08:11
      And in my judgment,
    • 05:08:13
      is going to have an equal impact on how particularly outsiders and tourists view the Commonwealth.
    • 05:08:20
      I don't view that as healthy development either.
    • 05:08:23
      Anybody else want to chime in before we go break for dinner as good colleagues and friends on this very difficult issue?
    • 05:08:29
      It is late.
    • 05:08:30
      How are we doing on reservations?
    • 05:08:33
      All right.
    • 05:08:34
      They're waiting for us.
    • 05:08:34
      Everybody know where Acacia is, if not?
    • 05:08:38
      2601 West Cary.