Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 7/17/2008
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   7/17/2008

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Board actions.pdf
  • Climate change and transportation.pdf
  • Draft statewide rail plan.pdf
  • Special session legislative update.pdf
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Welcome, everyone.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:03
      Before we begin our work session, we have a very important piece of business.
    • 00:00:10
      First, I would like to welcome one of our colleagues, the Secretary of the Commonwealth, Kate Hanley.
    • 00:00:18
      Kate, thank you so much for your support, not only for great personnel and appointments in this administration.
    • 00:00:24
      The Secretary of the Commonwealth has the honor and responsibility of swearing in the Governor's appointees.
    • 00:00:45
      Most of you saw the announcement last week where the Governor has reappointed four members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:54
      IV, whose names begin with James, and then there's another J. Douglas in the bunch.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 00:00:59
      But I would like to ask Doug Koelemay, James Keen, and Jim Bowie if you could stand up and raise your right hand and be sworn in by the Secretary of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:01:23
      You are doing great work on how to do better work.
    • 00:01:29
      Raise your hand and repeat after me if you would please.
    • 00:01:37
      I support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Virginia and I will faithfully and impartially discharge all the duties incumbent upon me.
    • 00:01:55
      All of the duties incumbent upon me as a member of the Commonwealth Transportation Board according to the best of my ability.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:16
      While the Secretary of the Commonwealth is finishing out that paperwork, Dr. Jim Davis could not be with us today.
    • 00:02:25
      He's out of the country and will be sworn in at our meeting in September or perhaps even before then if his schedule permits.
    • 00:02:34
      We did find it very appropriate that we had three James's and there was a mad scramble to find out what the J in J. Douglas Koelemay stood for.
    • 00:02:42
      We were hopeful that he was a James also.
    • 00:02:44
      But we found out that it was John.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:47
      I'm changing my name, Mr. Chairman.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:51
      So the path to appointment to those in the audience of the Commonwealth Transportation Board is to be named James.
    • 00:02:58
      I'd like to call to order now the July work session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:03:07
      We have a busy agenda this morning of both work session and a business meeting.
    • 00:03:13
      and is there anyone who is here to speak under citizen's time?
    • 00:03:20
      Is anyone here to speak under citizen's time?
    • 00:03:22
      The reason I say that is that precedes the business meeting so there will be a little bit of a latch between now and when the citizen comment is taken.
    • 00:03:32
      If not, we're going to dive right into the work.
    • 00:03:36
      Oh, there you are.
    • 00:03:38
      Deputy Secretary of Transportation Ralph Davis is going to give us an update on climate change and transportation.
    • 00:03:46
      This is part of a rapidly changing landscape, whether it's energy, infrastructure, transportation, or environment.
    • 00:03:53
      Those things are critically linked at the global, the national, and the state level.
    • 00:03:58
      And so Mr. Davis is here to give us
    • 00:04:02
      I want to say an overview really to start posing some very challenging issues that we'll be dealing with over the next many years in the Commonwealth.
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:04:12
      Thank you very much Mr. Chairman and good morning members of the CTB Board.
    • 00:04:17
      I need to preference my comments or presentation this morning with a few words.
    • 00:04:25
      One, this issue of climate change is a very complex issue.
    • 00:04:30
      It's one that I certainly can't claim to be an expert.
    • 00:04:34
      It's one that over the last four or five months I've been gaining lots of knowledge about.
    • 00:04:41
      The whole idea here with this presentation is to sort of whet your appetite of what climate change is.
    • 00:04:47
      The basic approach that I have here is to try to build the case for climate change
    • 00:04:53
      Based on references from authoritative sources, such as you have at your desk the actual presentation I've made.
    • 00:05:00
      So there are a series of authoritative sources that say climate change is real, and that's generally my approach.
    • 00:05:08
      Once I do that, talk some about the impacts in Virginia, some of the regional and state initiatives, and finally get into some of my observations.
    • 00:05:21
      At this point, the observations are
    • 00:05:23
      Not necessarily final, but it's based on my initial research.
    • 00:05:29
      I do sit on the Governor's Climate Change Commission for Secretary Homer.
    • 00:05:35
      So I have been attending those meetings and getting input and hearing the various expert testimony before that commission.
    • 00:05:45
      You have at your desk, as I said, my presentation.
    • 00:05:49
      Added another piece of information, white piece of paper here that compares Virginia's current goals with those of selected states.
    • 00:06:03
      That was a piece of information from feedback from you that I've supplied and I can discuss that if you would like us to go through this presentation.
    • 00:06:13
      The other comment is that I do not plan to read every bullet in the presentation.
    • 00:06:19
      You do have them.
    • 00:06:20
      So I will be skipping through the presentation just to help it move along.
    • 00:06:26
      I think on the first slide, the most important thing here is that there is a wide trade agreement that the global climate is getting warmer.
    • 00:06:37
      And the other point is that it's caused a large part by emissions from cars,
    • 00:06:43
      Power Plant, and other man-made sources.
    • 00:06:47
      This is sort of like a focal point in the whole climate change issue that man-made sources are causing it and that if left unchecked, it's going to have severe and lasting impacts.
    • 00:06:59
      Probably the most authoritative source is the IPCC group, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which was a group formed by the United Nations.
    • 00:07:11
      In their fourth assessment report in 2007, they pretty much said that climate change was unequivocal and that it was going to happen.
    • 00:07:23
      That was kind of like the final straw, so to speak.
    • 00:07:29
      And this particular report is widely accepted as the consensus of opinion from the scientific community that it is happening, that climate change will happen.
    • 00:07:44
      Another authoritative source and one that I would recommend to you as you, and I imagine each of you are in different stages in terms of knowledge.
    • 00:07:53
      Some of you probably totally familiar with climate change, others may be at a more elementary stage.
    • 00:07:59
      But the Pew Center on Global Climate Change is a good reference source for information on climate change.
    • 00:08:06
      And what you would do is go to your computers and Google in Pew Center on Climate Change.
    • 00:08:11
      And there's lots of information there.
    • 00:08:13
      In their report, Climate Change 101, they say some of the same things that are said by the IPCC group, and they also go on to say to avoid the worst effects of climate change, greenhouse gases need to be reduced by 50 to 80 percent by 2050.
    • 00:08:34
      That's like a magic number, 50 to 80 percent.
    • 00:08:38
      We need to reduce climate change by 2050.
    • 00:08:41
      Most of you probably read that the group of eight, which includes the United States, basically agreed to a 50% goal by 2050.
    • 00:08:50
      There's been a lot of debate in what U.S. policy is on climate change, and in the group of eight they decided 50%.
    • 00:08:57
      So you can see that the, and that is kind of made my eyes, I'm not seeing it, but it is kind of light on the slides, but the global
    • 00:09:11
      The initiative was 20 to 50 percent and a group of eight decided on 50 percent.
    • 00:09:15
      Another group and more along the line of transportation is the Transportation Research Board.
    • 00:09:21
      And they talk some about the impact of climate change on transportation facilities.
    • 00:09:27
      And they also say that we, the transportation, need to incorporate that in our planning and our design and in our transportation system.
    • 00:09:34
      They're going to say it's more than just about roads.
    • 00:09:37
      All transportation systems will be impacted.
    • 00:09:42
      Another group, AASHTO.
    • 00:09:44
      AASHTO is American Association of State Highway Officials and Highway and Transportation Officials.
    • 00:09:50
      AASHTO follows the line and say global climate change that is beyond just the scientific but is political and economic environmental fact of life.
    • 00:10:01
      AASHTO has certain recommendations that they support and I will read through these.
    • 00:10:09
      to reduce oil consumption by 20% in 10 years.
    • 00:10:13
      One of the issues with climate change is not just climate change but energy.
    • 00:10:17
      The fact that we are energy dependent on foreign nations.
    • 00:10:21
      So part of the action is to reduce the dependence on foreign nations for oil.
    • 00:10:26
      To double fuel efficiency of the entire fleet by 2030.
    • 00:10:29
      Most of you have heard of elasticity and elasticity refers to the change in
    • 00:10:36
      and demand for a product based on either price or income or something along that line.
    • 00:10:41
      Now there is something called a unitary elasticity between gasoline consumption and miles per gallon.
    • 00:10:48
      As miles per gallon go up by 1%, the gasoline consumption goes down by 1%.
    • 00:10:53
      So there's what's called a unitary one-on-one kind of link between gasoline sales and growth in miles per gallon.
    • 00:11:00
      To double transit ridership by 2030 and to expand the share of the pasture and freight
    • 00:11:06
      moved by rail to reduce the percentage of commuters who drive to work to 1990 levels.
    • 00:11:14
      And probably I think the one that we need to look at real close is to reduce VMT by the VMT growth rate by 50% and it's by 20, it's not on your slide, but it's by 2055 is what they're saying.
    • 00:11:29
      So VMT growth rate in Virginia over between 2004 and 2006 grew at about 2.7% a year.
    • 00:11:40
      It has slowed recently.
    • 00:11:42
      Over the last five years, VMT has grown at about 1.1%.
    • 00:11:45
      So the last five years, VMT has grown probably by the rate of growth of the population.
    • 00:11:51
      But if you look back in the early 80s, VMT was growing at 7-8% a year.
    • 00:11:57
      It slowed, VMT changes, goes down with declines in the economy.
    • 00:12:03
      My expectation is that we will see lower VMT and everything points in that direction this year with the escalation in gas prices.
    • 00:12:10
      So you see VMT go down.
    • 00:12:12
      But what AASHTO recommends is that we go from a VMT growth rate over 2% to one of about 1% a year.
    • 00:12:22
      And we have to care for interpreting this in that it is talking about the growth rate.
    • 00:12:27
      And what they're looking at is that VMT should grow at the rate of growth of population.
    • 00:12:31
      There has to be room in VMT for growth in population and expansion of the economy.
    • 00:12:37
      Some would go beyond this and recommend that VMT itself go down.
    • 00:12:41
      And we've had lots of discussion about, as far as performance, what kind of measures that we use.
    • 00:12:46
      In general, we're talking about the growth rate or per capita growth rate in BMT.
    • 00:12:51
      This is in line with some of the discussion we have.
    • 00:12:54
      In fact, most of what AASHTO has is in line with a lot of discussion we had in BTrans 2025 as well as what's in the performance report and so forth.
    • 00:13:03
      It's pretty much in line with some things we've discussed as well as programs for both Governor Warner and Governor Kane.
    • 00:13:10
      A final report which was not in the earlier briefing to you but should be and what's at your desk is report by McKinsey and Company done in 2007.
    • 00:13:21
      I think the most important, there's two things.
    • 00:13:24
      Once again, as you look at the experts here, they all will go to the fact that scientists and policymakers recognize that the greenhouse gas emissions growing is occurring.
    • 00:13:37
      I think the important thing here in the McKinsey Report is they wanted to develop an economically sensible approach to reducing greenhouse gases.
    • 00:13:48
      And so what they're trying to do is tie economics to the growth rates.
    • 00:13:53
      That is, look at cost-effective ways of reducing greenhouse gases.
    • 00:13:59
      In their conclusion, they say that greenhouse gases can be reduced 7 to 28 percent levels by 2030 using tested approaches in emerging technologies.
    • 00:14:11
      One of the things in the McKinsey report is that they do not incorporate concepts of changes in consumer preferences or changes in driver behavior.
    • 00:14:25
      What they are talking largely is technology increasing fuel efficiency changes and changes to biodiesels and so forth is their approach, but they do not talk about reducing VMT and they talk 70 to 28 percent reductions using technology.
    • 00:14:47
      The other important thing I think here is that final bullet.
    • 00:14:50
      What's happened is that states have led the way in terms of programs and policies for greenhouse gas reductions, starting with California and other states have led the way.
    • 00:15:04
      From what Mackenzie said, we have a lot of regional efforts.
    • 00:15:07
      What McKenzie says is that it can't be broken down into components.
    • 00:15:14
      It needs to be one broad policy and it also can't be just electric utilities or just transportation.
    • 00:15:22
      It needs to be economy-wide and it needs to be sector-wide as well.
    • 00:15:26
      They kind of pointed to the fact that just one can do it, and it needs to be not just U.S.
    • 00:15:32
      I think a part of grade eight there was discussion about whether all the other countries are participating, so it has to be broader than the U.S., broader than Virginia, broader than California, broader than transportation.
    • 00:15:42
      It has to be all these things working in concert to have the ultimate impact.
    • 00:15:50
      Impacts on transportation.
    • 00:15:55
      The first bullet talks about increases in hot days and heat waves, and you can see what the impacts are, the compromise, the pavement integrity, deformation of rail lines, derailments, and so forth.
    • 00:16:12
      Another important bullet there is rising sea levels.
    • 00:16:16
      This has been a part of the climate change discussion, but the anticipation is from the IPPCC and others is that sea levels will rise from 7 to 23 inches by 2099 and that's a very important
    • 00:16:33
      Point, coupled with some surges and land subsidence, increase in intensity of strong hurricanes.
    • 00:16:43
      So that's most of the likely impacts on transportation.
    • 00:16:48
      Virginia, as we move on to Virginia some.
    • 00:16:52
      This is the start of history.
    • 00:16:53
      Emissions have risen 34% between 1990 and 2004.
    • 00:16:58
      Chesapeake Bay is susceptible.
    • 00:17:02
      changing rain and temperature patterns will have a big impact on agriculture and forestry.
    • 00:17:10
      At the 2008 General Assembly session there was an initiative to incorporate greenhouse gases as a performance measure and part of that was discussion about what are greenhouse gases and this slide kind of tells you what they are.
    • 00:17:26
      The most important thing here is that carbon dioxide is the
    • 00:17:32
      is the majority or the higher percentage of the greenhouse gases.
    • 00:17:35
      About 73 percent nationally, it's 79 to 83 percent.
    • 00:17:42
      So when you talk about greenhouse gases, you're mostly talking about carbon dioxide.
    • 00:17:54
      Why is transportation a part of this?
    • 00:17:56
      Well, this slide kind of tells you.
    • 00:17:59
      It's the second largest contributor of greenhouse gas emissions, contributing about 31 percent, electricity being the largest, that's 38 percent.
    • 00:18:09
      And this is 2005 data that's taken from the Department of Environmental Quality.
    • 00:18:16
      They're charged with developing inventory and they have inventory of greenhouse gases that go back to 2000 and make protections back to 2025 by spectrum and so forth and this is a 2005 data.
    • 00:18:30
      Transportation is 31% of it.
    • 00:18:36
      By vehicle type, as you can see from this slide to your left, highway vehicles contribute 77%.
    • 00:18:46
      Aviation, some questions about aviation and so forth.
    • 00:18:50
      About 1%, I think, the growth kind of stays over the forecast period of 2025.
    • 00:18:56
      Fuel type, most of it is gasoline.
    • 00:19:04
      As I said, most of the initiatives have been state and regional.
    • 00:19:10
      We'll not go through detail on these.
    • 00:19:12
      Summary, the Midwestern goals are consistent with the IPCC.
    • 00:19:21
      They have a target of 60 to 80 percent below the current levels by 2050.
    • 00:19:28
      And the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, I guess the other point is some started as early as 2005, the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative
    • 00:19:40
      To start in 2005, you can see the states that are a part of that initiative.
    • 00:19:45
      Their goal is to recap initiatives at 2009 levels and reduce by 10% by 2019.
    • 00:19:53
      The last bullet there is the climate registry and Virginia is a part of that climate registry.
    • 00:20:00
      That essentially deals with collecting data and a consistent development system for reporting emissions.
    • 00:20:10
      Notable state initiatives, 37 states have some kind of plan in place.
    • 00:20:16
      I note two important facts in looking at this particular slide.
    • 00:20:22
      Some of the states, some of the initiatives are what I call very aggressive.
    • 00:20:25
      If you look at California, California's caps emissions at 1990 levels by 2020.
    • 00:20:34
      Oregon's is similarly, it's more aggressive than California's, it's 10% below 99 by 2020.
    • 00:20:42
      The other point here is that some of these initiatives are legislative.
    • 00:20:46
      Let me see, Washington has a Senate Bill 601, it's a legislative initiative where they have goals stated by legislation, what they would like to, what the goals are.
    • 00:21:00
      The other thing that I've found is
    • 00:21:02
      Specific goals on transportation are rather limited at this point.
    • 00:21:07
      It's very difficult to find out what the goals are for transportation.
    • 00:21:11
      But one could generally conclude that if transportation makes up 31% of the greenhouse gases,
    • 00:21:19
      And if you want to reduce those, then it would seem that you would want to follow the overall goals for reduction that you set globally for transportation would be kind of a conclusion.
    • 00:21:34
      But generally, it's very difficult to find out what states are doing for transportation in terms of their specific goals.
    • 00:21:45
      I've just killed it.
    • 00:21:48
      Virginia's initiatives, back in 2007 in Executive Order 48, and that goes for state agencies.
    • 00:21:57
      Senate Bill, Senate Joint Resolution 385, which is, I guess, the Wagner Commission.
    • 00:22:04
      That was a study on fuel-efficient vehicles and transportation funding.
    • 00:22:08
      And I think the most important thing there are the last two bullets.
    • 00:22:12
      Most of you being transportation officials know this, but this is coming from a Senate committee.
    • 00:22:19
      It says, current methods for funding would not keep pace with the new energy technologies used in vehicles.
    • 00:22:26
      And that's essentially saying as the MPG increases, that gasoline sales will not, gasoline taxes will not keep pace with growth and inflation.
    • 00:22:41
      and the Commonwealth will see a decrease in motor fuel tax revenues and this is a part of the conclusions from Senate Joint Resolution 385 which was chaired by Senator Wagon.
    • 00:22:54
      I have been going through this and maybe you're all waiting for the end for the questions, but certainly if you have questions as I'm going through, feel free to ask.
    • 00:23:04
      The Virginia Energy Plan published in 2007, you can see what the goals there are.
    • 00:23:11
      Probably under the goal, the second bullet, to reduce greenhouse gases by 30% by 2025 is the primary goal, and what that means is
    • 00:23:21
      that greenhouse gas emissions would be at the 2000 level in 2025.
    • 00:23:26
      Part of the Energy Plan recommended the establishment of Climate Change Commission and that's the commission which the Secretary says and I represent him in that case.
    • 00:23:41
      It's comprised of members from the General Assembly, state government, local government and private sectors.
    • 00:23:50
      You can see what the goals of that commission are.
    • 00:23:53
      The commission has met on five occasions and heard testimony from numerous experts, federal, state, and private sector.
    • 00:24:00
      It is divided into four work groups, including a transportation and land use group.
    • 00:24:08
      That transportation and land use group is headed by...
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:15
      I don't remember seeing that study and any work that came out of that commission, you said the Wagoner Commission?
    • 00:24:42
      Was it widely accepted that the current funding methods will not keep pace with new energy technologies used in vehicles?
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:24:50
      That's the reported result.
    • 00:24:52
      I can't say that it was widely accepted.
    • 00:24:54
      There was not a final report from that study.
    • 00:24:59
      You do have to go to the website to find access to it, but it was not a final report printed from that particular commission.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:06
      Dr. Estes?
    • 00:25:11
      and appointee to that commission along with the Secretary of Finance.
    • 00:25:14
      They did not, they chose not to publish a final report.
    • 00:25:16
      They had very interesting testimony and simply said, simply the application of the Federal CAFE standards which was as the mileage fleet standards will have a significant reduction in gas tax revenues.
    • 00:25:31
      They talked about emerging technologies and hybrid vehicles, hydrogen, et cetera.
    • 00:25:37
      And so what the
    • 00:25:39
      While it's not a report, there was a one-page statement that was not broadly distributed.
    • 00:25:45
      But it said, I think in summation, that the motor fuels tax, as is currently structured in Virginia, is not a viable long-term revenue source for transportation.
    • 00:25:58
      And I believe that subcommittee has been continued.
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:26:02
      From what I could tell, it was not continued.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:07
      We'll have to find that out.
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:26:09
      Thank you.
    • 00:26:11
      Back to the Virginia initiatives and the four work groups.
    • 00:26:16
      One of them is transportation and land use, and that's headed by Don Byer.
    • 00:26:22
      I think the goals of that subcommittee are to, one, look at ways to reduce vehicle miles traveled.
    • 00:26:32
      Two, consider more aggressive approaches for tailpipe standards.
    • 00:26:37
      III's encourage more compact developments and so forth, but it kind of lays out the direction that they are looking at going with that particular subcommittee.
    • 00:26:47
      I would sit on that subcommittee for its sector.
    • 00:26:56
      Other Virginia initiatives as part of VTrans, the next long-range plan.
    • 00:27:00
      We will include strategies for reducing greenhouse gases as a component of that report is next year.
    • 00:27:09
      We're looking at next year for that.
    • 00:27:11
      The other thing that's important is we do have the climate change performance measures and goals as a part of our performance report.
    • 00:27:21
      As a part of the environmental goal, a couple of measures of tons of transportation emissions and fuel use for capital.
    • 00:27:30
      As a part of the goal of coordination of transportation and land use, the performance measure is VMT per capita.
    • 00:27:39
      In addition, VTrans reports there is an internal VDOT working team that are technologically looking at initiatives for improving fuel use and reducing gases through internal operations.
    • 00:27:54
      So it's an internal group that's working on climate change as well.
    • 00:28:00
      One final initiative which was not in your original report is the study done by the National Capital Regional Climate Change Report that's out right now as a part for review.
    • 00:28:15
      And this was initiated in 2007 by the Metropolitan Washington Council of Government of COGS with several goals.
    • 00:28:23
      You can see what those goals are.
    • 00:28:26
      This report was presented to the Cog Board July 9 of this year and is currently under review.
    • 00:28:32
      In terms of recommendations, the greenhouse gas reductions of 80% by 20... 80% below 2005 by 2050.
    • 00:28:42
      Now, one of the things that's very difficult in these goals are they don't have consistent base, and that's one of the issues.
    • 00:28:48
      Is 1990 the base?
    • 00:28:50
      Is 2000 the base?
    • 00:28:51
      Is 2005 current?
    • 00:28:53
      They're all over the place, and the sheet that you have is often difficult to even interpret which goal is more aggressive because they all have different dates.
    • 00:29:02
      For Virginia, I don't think we have in our inventory greenhouse gases for 1990, so it's kind of hard to compare
    • 00:29:10
      what our goals are to the United States.
    • 00:29:17
      The final bullet is 30% reduction in transportation emissions by reducing VMT, increasing fuel economy, and reducing the carbon content of fuel.
    • 00:29:31
      This slide here probably exceeds my 15 minutes.
    • 00:29:37
      Strategies
    • 00:29:39
      In the literature, what you will find is that normally we talk about a three-legged stool approach to deal with transportation strategies.
    • 00:29:47
      And those three legs are the increase in fuel economy.
    • 00:29:53
      Basically, National Cafe standards will increase the standards for new light-duty vehicles 35 miles per gallon by 2020.
    • 00:30:02
      As a note, the current efficiency of the entire SCARC, now the difference is new cars
    • 00:30:09
      First, the entire fleet of cars.
    • 00:30:11
      And it normally will take up to 15 years for the new cars to work themselves into the entire fleet.
    • 00:30:18
      But the fleet efficiency is 20 miles per gallon.
    • 00:30:21
      I'll make a note that Europe is 40 miles per gallon.
    • 00:30:25
      They much have smaller cars and so forth.
    • 00:30:30
      And that's sort of a point for us to compare ourselves with national.
    • 00:30:35
      So increased fuel efficiency is one of those strategies that's done by CAFE standards.
    • 00:30:41
      promote use of hybrid and alternative fuel vehicles, whether they're gas, electric, plug-ins, and so forth is another component.
    • 00:30:49
      The final is to reduce VMT, and there are a number of ways.
    • 00:30:53
      A lot of these are things that we have and you have promoted over the last several years, things such as expand traffic, both governors Warner and King have pushed that, promote alternatives.
    • 00:31:06
      These things along the line of what we have recommended
    • 00:31:10
      over time, promotes transit-oriented compact development are the various components of strategy.
    • 00:31:20
      My concluding observations, one is this is a very difficult, complex issue with dealing with greenhouse gases, but we've seen this kind of thing, something similar, probably not just complex.
    • 00:31:36
      We've made good progress with cleaning the air in the past.
    • 00:31:43
      In terms of dealing with volatile organic compounds, dealing with nitrous oxide and carbon monoxide.
    • 00:31:52
      We've seen those things decrease through government regulations, participation, and coordination between state and federal government.
    • 00:32:01
      In 2007, in terms of number of ozone standards, we moved from 17 days, from .5 days in 2002 to 17 days in 2007.
    • 00:32:14
      Another example is volatile.
    • 00:32:16
      In terms of the VOPs, as you'll see,
    • 00:32:19
      We've probably seen about 57% decrease between 1990 and 2000.
    • 00:32:27
      In terms of the nitrous oxide, probably 20-25% reduction.
    • 00:32:31
      So we've made progress, we've dealt with this kind of issue and had success in the past.
    • 00:32:40
      We deal with more complex issues, more difficult issues, but we've had good success.
    • 00:32:46
      In looking at the goals, I think most of the goals are aspirational.
    • 00:32:51
      And by that, I mean that in a lot of cases, there is not the substantiation behind the goals in terms of what are the costs of implementing these goals.
    • 00:33:05
      In a lot of cases, it would appear that the goals, particularly the 2050 goals, that they are not achievable.
    • 00:33:15
      So what happens is that the goals don't really incorporate consumer behavior.
    • 00:33:21
      How are consumers going to reduce their VMT because without some kind of price impact?
    • 00:33:34
      I mean change of VMT with gas price increases.
    • 00:33:38
      The third bullet is that we have to as policy makers
    • 00:33:54
      We need to understand greenhouse gas, that it is happening, we need to understand the risk of it, and we need to incorporate those into our decision makers.
    • 00:34:05
      As far as transportation is concerned, it's really obviously in its infancy in terms of beginning to understand
    • 00:34:12
      The greenhouse gases are happening and we need to start incorporating them into our plans, into our designs and so forth.
    • 00:34:22
      Would be my conclusion in terms of where we are right now.
    • 00:34:29
      In the Governor's Climate Change Commission, the rising sea level is probably cited most often as the greatest concern by the members when you talk about the sea level rising 23 or so inches over the next, up to 2009.
    • 00:34:49
      Now that's, everyone seems to say that's the most important concern that they have.
    • 00:34:55
      The next bullet is that the Commissioner's recommendations will likely include strategies to reduce fuel use in BMT.
    • 00:35:05
      And my final bullet is that there are tensions between
    • 00:35:10
      Greenhouse gas reduction strategies and other goals.
    • 00:35:14
      On the one hand, transportation is about growing the state.
    • 00:35:18
      It's like the veins in the state.
    • 00:35:21
      What causes is a very important element in the over economic growth in the state.
    • 00:35:27
      It's about economic vitality.
    • 00:35:29
      At the same time, we confront it with issue that transportation has to have a role in reducing the greenhouse gases.
    • 00:35:37
      So we have this tension here.
    • 00:35:40
      What role did we play in terms of reducing greenhouse gases?
    • 00:35:44
      We must have a role there.
    • 00:35:46
      And how do we, at the same time, do we have a responsibility of promoting mobility, promoting economic vitality?
    • 00:35:53
      So that's kind of the conflict that we end up with is greenhouse gases are happening and transportation needs to play its role there.
    • 00:36:05
      At the same time, transportation has other roles and goals that it needs to adhere to as well.
    • 00:36:10
      This ends my presentation.
    • 00:36:11
      I've taken a moment.
    • 00:36:13
      I should have.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:15
      One part as we go through here, and you've touched on it in a number of cases, is we still have this disconnect between our funding sources, our revenue streams, the goals in terms of having sufficient revenues to pay for transportation as a whole, whether it's road, rail, or otherwise.
    • 00:36:34
      And the environmental, you know, we want to drive down the use of the, we want to drive down the use of essentially the carbons, gas, et cetera.
    • 00:36:44
      But the more we drive, reduce that by either putting people on rail, putting them in more fuel-efficient cars, then that means we've got less revenues to pay for all these things.
    • 00:36:54
      And it isn't exactly something, well, it isn't something that we as a body can necessarily come to terms with.
    • 00:37:00
      I mean, this is a financial system.
    • 00:37:02
      It's structured around our carbon fuels.
    • 00:37:04
      It's structured around gas consumption.
    • 00:37:07
      We use that.
    • 00:37:08
      We don't just use it for roads.
    • 00:37:09
      We use it for rails.
    • 00:37:10
      We use it for every form of public transportation in terms of subsidizing it through the various mechanisms in order to move further away from that.
    • 00:37:18
      At what time do we have the break, that point which we just can't recover,
    • 00:37:24
      On the financial side, when do we have to take the actions necessary?
    • 00:37:28
      And I mean by we, not this body, but the Commonwealth, the country.
    • 00:37:34
      We've got to shift our revenue streams over there sooner rather than later if we're going to get there.
    • 00:37:38
      Otherwise, we're really heading towards what I see an insurmountable problem if we're not there already.
    • 00:37:44
      So as we're looking out in the future, as we're talking about reducing carbon emissions and we're talking about the consumption going down,
    • 00:37:52
      If that's our revenue stream, if that's how we're funding everything else within the system, when does it become the point of no return?
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:37:59
      Mr. Sterling, I don't know if I have an answer.
    • 00:38:01
      I have not done the analysis.
    • 00:38:04
      There have been national studies that have been done which, and I'm just pulling on memory, that say probably the gas taxes go through 10 years or thereabouts.
    • 00:38:14
      I forget the name of the national study, and then there would be a need to go to some other form of funding.
    • 00:38:23
      As part of VTrans, we did recommend that general funds be used as a funding component.
    • 00:38:30
      The other thing, and there's conflict here, is that there's a big push towards some type of BMT, vehicle miles traveled tax, and the difficulty there is that
    • 00:38:41
      Part of the greenhouse gas initiative is to reduce VMT.
    • 00:38:47
      So it's my own thought would be we probably need to leave gasoline as a base, but there needs to be something on top of it, probably sometime with the VMT type tax and maybe a need for what's been in the current packages is assistance from General Fund.
    • 00:39:10
      But no, that is kind of the issue of how do we sustain a sustainable revenue source.
    • 00:39:19
      But I think most of what you're going to find, a lot of folks are going to be pushing some type of VMT type tax.
    • 00:39:26
      The guess would be, certainly if gas prices stay at the range that they are now, VMT is going to
    • 00:39:32
      The last five years or so from about 2% of Virginia to around the population growth of 1%, 1.1% or so growth in PMT.
    • 00:39:45
      So that's going on slow.
    • 00:39:47
      The other thing that is possible is there's a lot of discussion about indexing of, say, fuel stacks, index it to inflation, index it to growth in construction costs or something along that line.
    • 00:40:02
      So there are options, I think, from what I've read.
    • 00:40:06
      In most cases, it's along the line of VMT.
    • 00:40:09
      Exactly when the crossover, we have to, I think, start pushing the VMT type of taxes now because it takes forever to get that kind of initiative through a legislative body.
    • 00:40:22
      But we have started thinking about and pushing real hard now about some type of VMT type tax.
    • 00:40:28
      The Secretary may have some comments on that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:31
      I just, I think two statistics will help us to sort through this.
    • 00:40:35
      The world is changing and we don't know how.
    • 00:40:39
      One of the aspects of transportation funding over the last two and a half years has been greater diversification of the transportation revenue base just like we do with our retirement savings.
    • 00:40:51
      Simple measure, about 40% of the overall transportation budget in the Commonwealth is based on a penny per gallon gas tax.
    • 00:41:02
      About 85% of the Federal Highway Trust Fund is based on a penny per gallon gas tax.
    • 00:41:09
      And so in many respects, the changes at the federal level will occur more rapidly than at the state level.
    • 00:41:17
      And not a lot of media attention, but there are very important elements in both the House and the Senate Appropriation Acts to patch the disconnect between the Highway Trust Fund and the authorized funding levels.
    • 00:41:36
      and the discussion has been for rescissions or reductions of up to thirty percent in federal funding.
    • 00:41:45
      So that's a live debate and I think rather than us focusing at the state level the more immediate focus because it will be far more pronounced will be on federal funding sources for transportation.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:00
      I mean even today I think it's about four billion dollars whole in the transportation trust fund just for
    • 00:42:06
      That's what I'm referring to, but that is such a large source of our revenue streams, as well as everybody else's.
    • 00:42:16
      There doesn't seem to be that impetus, and you see this as these bills are getting bogged down and not being passed.
    • 00:42:21
      There doesn't seem to be the impetus to actually diversify the funding sources or to come up with the funding sources, and thus we're looking at yet less being done.
    • 00:42:30
      That's where my concern stems from.
    • 00:42:33
      Thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:36
      Koelemay, and then Mr. Connally.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:38
      Deputy Davis, thank you very much.
    • 00:42:40
      I think you've done us a great service by pulling together the information that's available both for our state, for other states and the world, in fact.
    • 00:42:52
      The sci-fi futurist Arthur Clark took a look at the pictures back from space and declared that clearly our planet should be called ocean.
    • 00:43:04
      and I think that's a real problem for us as a coastal state that we can't overemphasize.
    • 00:43:10
      It's not just the health of the bay.
    • 00:43:11
      I grew up in New Orleans and you see what happens when there's partial solutions that aren't continued and something that happens regularly happens.
    • 00:43:23
      On the other hand, you've described a pretty, one of the most complex systems that probably we have in the future.
    • 00:43:29
      At some point, maybe this board becomes the Commonwealth Board
    • 00:43:33
      because all these problems are converging, transportation, energy, the environment.
    • 00:43:37
      And the solution certainly can't occur without being comprehensive.
    • 00:43:45
      I mean, in other words, the piecemeal approach we've had where we have a department of this and there's water quality over here and there's transportation over here and so forth.
    • 00:43:53
      I'm interested in how we organize ourselves going forward and I know the governor
    • 00:43:58
      has already signaled that he will have some significant new initiatives in this area in the session in 2009.
    • 00:44:06
      But I wonder for this body exactly how we can tackle these things
    • 00:44:18
      As we go, even if there's not a comprehensive strategy at the state level, you said some of these things are already entered into our performance measures that we've given VDOT and the Department of Rail and Public Transportation.
    • 00:44:33
      Are those sufficient?
    • 00:44:34
      Do those need to be bulked up?
    • 00:44:39
      I guess I would make two comments.
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:44:51
      I think the performance measures that we have are the right measures.
    • 00:44:58
      The measures that are, and one of the things we have to do is to see if we can get those measures
    • 00:45:04
      And that measure, for example, would be BMT per capita.
    • 00:45:14
      It's a measure that we have.
    • 00:45:15
      One of the things this board would be involved in doing is really setting the goal.
    • 00:45:20
      What do you want it to be?
    • 00:45:21
      I have some recommendations for you in that regard.
    • 00:45:24
      Or whether it's gasoline consumption per capita.
    • 00:45:30
      Some of our contribution to that is to be upfront in terms of setting at least recommending what those goals might be and what the measures might be.
    • 00:45:42
      And we do have them in the performance report of VMT and I think what the board would do is say what it wants as a goal.
    • 00:45:49
      And I think the Astro kind of leads the way there in that regard in that their goal is really setting VMT to the rate of growth of the population.
    • 00:45:58
      So I think the goals that we have are in line with what I've seen.
    • 00:46:04
      It's just that they're not looking at VMT per capita.
    • 00:46:08
      They're talking in general about reducing VMT and the importance that we have is basically VMT will continue to grow as long as it's a growing state.
    • 00:46:17
      and more people come, population grows, Virginia is a growing economy, growing economy have growing VMT and I think the way to deal with that is really to look at
    • 00:46:27
      I think the goals are there.
    • 00:46:36
      The important thing is how do we get that as a component of the whole commission.
    • 00:46:41
      Okay.
    • 00:46:43
      Last question, Ms. Connolly.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:45
      We've got a whole bunch of questions.
    • 00:46:47
      This is the first time we've ever discussed this.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:49
      I understand we've got a busy agenda.
    • 00:46:50
      We've got to move along with two questions.
    • 00:46:52
      Anybody else on this side?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:54
      A dazzling array of information, but also an array of different policies and goals sort of spread all over the Commonwealth.
    • 00:47:05
      And I would like your recommendation on how we could best get our, I think, strongly-felt views about the fact that transportation is such an important deal in this, 31% at a minimum.
    • 00:47:21
      to be sure that we get our feelings into the Climate Change Commission because hopefully they are going to try to rationalize some of all these policies and goals that we have been accumulating.
    • 00:47:34
      And my suggestion might be if you would be able to come back to us
    • 00:47:39
      by at least our September meeting with some recommendations specifically that could be sent on to the Climate Change Commission for their specific consideration about these transportation related issues.
    • 00:47:56
      Would that, as a member of that committee, would that be a reasonable approach?
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:48:02
      I think that's a reasonable approach.
    • 00:48:04
      What happens with the Climate Change Commission, it's an open body, it's open for public comment, and members of the Commission also submit with their studies or whatever, and I think
    • 00:48:17
      And if the board decides that it wants to have a position and make that available to the commission, that would be the appropriate thing to do.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:27
      If I might, we have a very, very busy agenda today, so we'll take all of these things up.
    • 00:48:32
      This is the beginning of a very long conversation that will stretch out over many years, so we'll certainly be back to this.
    • 00:48:38
      Mr. McCarthy, last word.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:41
      Is that an agreement that we have a report back in September?
    • 00:48:44
      Because I could sum up everything I have to say by saying I think some of us want to work with Ralph and suggest some ideas that CTB might consider and forward to their commission.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:58
      I think all of these issues have got to come back in a broad-based way.
    • 00:49:02
      and so we'll think about how to structure that so that, I mean this is a very large issue and we need to make sure that everybody's up to a comparable level of understanding and dialogue on this.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:15
      I will point out, I agree with his conclusions for the most part, there is in the broad scheme of things, the global issue and what can a state do about it, the vehicle miles traveled
    • 00:49:28
      Strategies and actions and carbon reduction associated with that is something that we absolutely do have the power to do something about in this state.
    • 00:49:39
      That would probably be a good focus for how to proceed going forward, like reducing and considering carbon dioxide emissions in our decision making.
    • 00:49:49
      Will this road add health, et cetera, et cetera?
    • 00:49:53
      It all aims at reducing CO2 emissions and reducing vehicle miles traveled and we'll let the legislature figure out how to fund the consequences of that I suppose but if we could look forward to a report and I'll be happy to send further notes and comments to Ralph between now and then but if we can get something back in September that would be very timely because that'll be about when that climate commission is finally going to start talking about what it's going to do.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:20
      And I think we'll need to have additional dollars.
    • 00:50:23
      We have a lot of other things to get to on the agenda, and the purpose of this today is to get this issue introduced to the body.
    • 00:50:30
      I would say in closing that one of the issues around this is to look at things that have worked.
    • 00:50:39
      And if you have worked in the area of air quality, as we have done since the 1990 Clean Air Act in Memphis, there's actually a lot of optimism here.
    • 00:50:48
      If you look at Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia, with constrained long-range planning there since 1990, they've been able to reduce ozone precursors by over 40%.
    • 00:51:01
      This is not a lost cause.
    • 00:51:04
      And what we need to do is look at strategies that have worked in the past, and it was very simple, clear quantitative goals.
    • 00:51:10
      I think what Secretary Davis talked about, what's the base, what's the goal, that's probably the first thing that needs to be rationalized.
    • 00:51:19
      So clear goals.
    • 00:51:21
      And then secondly, incentives and penalties, carrots and sticks, if you will, and dedicated funding sources.
    • 00:51:29
      CMAQ funds were the dedicated funding source to achieve that conformity.
    • 00:51:33
      But we should not overlook the progress that has been made on what is a simpler problem in retrospect, but a very significant effort in that regard.
    • 00:51:44
      So we will not advance hastily and jump to conclusions.
    • 00:51:47
      We're going to learn about this and deliberate as a body and have the hard discussions because I think the most important point that Secretary Davis was talking about is that there is a tension between the goals of mobility, accessibility, economic vitality contrasted against the goals of
    • 00:52:14
      achieving emission reductions in some cases.
    • 00:52:17
      And one of the big unknowns here is technology.
    • 00:52:21
      If you look back on the history of the Clean Air Act, the very significant and rapid advances there was due to cleaner fuels, diesel regulations, and fleet standards.
    • 00:52:36
      So I think
    • 00:52:38
      Again, it is very important in telling that individual states are taking the initiative as is Virginia, but these goals clearly cannot be accomplished without a strong federal partnership and federal leadership, I think at the end of the day.
    • 00:52:58
      Thank you, Mr. Davis.
    • 00:53:01
      The next item is, and I'd like to ask Mr. McCarthy if you would please join Mr. Tucker at the podium as a presentation on the GRTC Transit Company Commendation by the American Public Transportation Association.
    • 00:53:17
      We have the pleasure, oh there's Mr. Lewis.
    • 00:53:21
      Mr. Tucker is going to welcome and introduce Mr. Lewis who received really an amazing award by the American Public Transportation Association and
    • 00:53:29
      Welcome, Mr. Tucker.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:53:31
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 00:53:32
      Chair.
    • 00:53:33
      Good news to report to the board.
    • 00:53:36
      GRTC was recently identified as the top transit system in its category of transit systems that provide between 4 million and 30 million trips on an annual basis.
    • 00:53:49
      Just so you can sort of have that as a context, that's about 100 transit systems.
    • 00:53:54
      So it was not a small pool for which they won this award.
    • 00:53:59
      I think it's very appropriate that we have two of the folks more.
    • 00:54:04
      We have Elders Cole, who is the Assistant General Manager at Greater Richmond Transit Company.
    • 00:54:10
      But I think when you take a step back and look at the success that Greater Richmond Transit Company has had, it's been through the leadership
    • 00:54:16
      in terms of increasing funding for public transportation leadership of the transit system.
    • 00:54:22
      So what I would think it would be appropriate, Mr.
    • 00:54:23
      Chair, with your indulgence is to have Mr. Lewis make a couple of comments along with Mr. McCarthy because I think they have worked closely and in coordination to really help GRTC expanded services.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:35
      Welcome, Mr. Lewis.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:38
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I have a very slight duty here and that is to make sure that John Lewis gets the opportunity to tell you a little bit more.
    • 00:54:46
      You heard from him a couple of months ago outlining his ambitious plans for expanding the system and making it even more efficient, but it really is a significant recognition to be judged number one of its kind in the country and I don't think I could say it more simply than that.
    • 00:55:03
      This is the best right here.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:07
      Welcome, Mr. Lewis.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:55:08
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary and members of the board.
    • 00:55:10
      Thank you, Matt and Mr. McCarthy.
    • 00:55:12
      It's really an honor to be here before you representing over 518 outstanding public servants who make it their mission every day to offer safe, effective, and efficient transportation service to citizens of the Richmond region.
    • 00:55:28
      Three years ago, I sat down with our board to outline a strategic plan on how we can transform public transportation in the Richmond region.
    • 00:55:36
      Moving GRTC, which was a great small bus system operating predominantly in the downtown Richmond, the city of Richmond,
    • 00:55:46
      into a truly regional provider of public transportation.
    • 00:55:49
      With the help and financial support certainly of the CTB and the great partnership we have with VDRPT, Matt and his staff, we've been able to expand service into areas that GRTC did not in the past provide service into.
    • 00:56:04
      Chesterfield, Petersburg, and Fredericksburg.
    • 00:56:06
      And we're really proud of our Fredericksburg service which after a little more than a year of service is offered a new model for us, a new paradigm
    • 00:56:16
      We're making use of private providers to offer transit service under a model in which the fare that we receive from our riders would pay for the service that's provided.
    • 00:56:27
      And as of last month, we have reached 75% of our ridership goals after less than a year.
    • 00:56:33
      And that really is outstanding.
    • 00:56:35
      Four dollar gas certainly helps in that manner.
    • 00:56:38
      But we're moving towards a GRTC, a different model providing public transportation, really focusing on being efficient and financially sound.
    • 00:56:49
      We're also pleased to announce that our new state-of-the-art green LEED certified operations and administration facilities under construction will be complete next year and we're working right now with VDRPT on two very good and great initiatives for Richmond and that's the Downtown Transfer Center which I believe you will probably be hearing more of in concert
    • 00:57:13
      with the statewide rail plan and how we're planning to make that a truly multimodal center with increased rail access, but also making multimodal bus connections with GRTC.
    • 00:57:27
      And finally, our bus rapid transit corridor along Broad Street.
    • 00:57:31
      It's an exciting time to be in public transit right now.
    • 00:57:34
      I think the issues that are surrounding our energy crisis and our oil issue and the price of gasoline certainly is providing opportunities for public transit to provide service to people who in the past probably would not consider public transit.
    • 00:57:50
      but also some challenges and we're looking forward to working with VDRPT and the CTB and the state to move not only the Richmond region but the state forward on the right path.
    • 00:58:01
      Our goal at the end of the day is to make public transit the mode of choice rather than the mode of last opportunity.
    • 00:58:08
      Thank you for this award and I appreciate the recognition on behalf of all the workers and employees of GRTC.
    • 00:58:16
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:29
      Well, just in closing, we'd like to, again, acknowledge, you know, the governor, as former mayor of Richmond, has a particular interest in this transit system, and the governor is one of the staunchest supporters of transit and rail in the entire country, is extremely proud personally and professionally of your achievements.
    • 00:58:52
      So, Mr. Lewis, thank you to you.
    • 00:58:55
      I'd also like to acknowledge the efforts of Mr. McCarthy,
    • 00:58:58
      to start talking about transit in this region as a regional issue.
    • 00:59:03
      And that, I was so pleased to hear, Mr. Lewis, your comments about the Fredericksburg service.
    • 00:59:09
      That's breaking down a paradigm.
    • 00:59:11
      And no one would have thought even five years ago that there would be market demand for that.
    • 00:59:16
      Well, there is.
    • 00:59:18
      And it just, I think, illustrates when we wipe the slate clean and sit back and think about new solutions to old problems,
    • 00:59:29
      Sometimes it works, and you've built that better mousetrap in that instance, and we need to keep doing that in the region and begin the regional planning effort to identify other equivalent services.
    • 00:59:41
      And that's a very good segue into the better mousetrap.
    • 00:59:45
      Item three on your agenda is an update, not an update, but a presentation of the draft statewide rail plan.
    • 00:59:52
      Last night was the first of several statewide public hearings.
    • 00:59:56
      This is the beginning of a process of identifying what is on the ground today, what are long-term projected needs, and most importantly, what are the public benefits that can be achieved by smart investments in a statewide rail system.
    • 01:00:17
      And here to give a brief overview, obviously, is Mr. Tucker.
    • 01:00:22
      I know that he'll want to acknowledge the efforts of his staff as a starting point in this.
    • 01:00:29
      I can't emphasize how important that these public hearings are around the Commonwealth.
    • 01:00:33
      I know all of you will be participating in at least one and some of you in more than one.
    • 01:00:38
      This is a very important effort to culminate with some action items hopefully in the October or perhaps November timeframe.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:47
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 01:00:49
      Chair.
    • 01:00:49
      Just to wrap up the previous discussion about Greater Richmond Transit Company, there is an item on the action meeting approving a resolution to GRTC commending them for their achievement.
    • 01:01:03
      So I'll just touch upon that now so that we can move forward.
    • 01:01:08
      As I begin a discussion about the statewide rail plan, I would start off by commending the staff at DRPT for their hard work in putting this document together.
    • 01:01:21
      And I'll tell you, you know, so many times behind the scenes you look at a study and you really don't necessarily always are able to appreciate the amount of work that went into it.
    • 01:01:32
      And of all the studies that I've ever experienced in my career, I can say without a doubt,
    • 01:01:38
      That this study probably was the most challenging study because I think one of the key discussions that we had as a staff is wanting to make sure that folks really understood how we as the agency responsible for rail go about the process of looking at projects and looking at the relationship that exists between the public sector and the private sector and rail transportation as it fits within the modes.
    • 01:02:04
      So I do appreciate the efforts that Mr.
    • 01:02:06
      Page and his staff have made in terms of developing this plan.
    • 01:02:11
      I'm going to walk through the presentation fairly quickly.
    • 01:02:14
      I will tell you a lot of the emphasis at this stage in the process is not necessarily about the projects from my perspective.
    • 01:02:23
      It's more so about setting the stage and understanding RHEL in the context of all of the modes that we do.
    • 01:02:29
      I'm going to have Mr.
    • 01:02:30
      Page talk briefly through some of the projects prior to me closing, but really what I want to do is spend most of the time that I have with you today, and I'm going to be through in 15 to 20 minutes at max, to sort of talk about the stage of rail and the context of rail as it exists in Virginia.
    • 01:02:48
      Again, if you take a look at this map and you really just focus in on some of the key points that we've identified on the map and how it relates to our transportation system and our rail network, you see obviously the Port of Hampton Roads and the impact that it has on the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 01:03:09
      You see our coal fields.
    • 01:03:11
      You see the inland port at Front Royal, you see the location of Dulles Airport, and you see the capital of our nation identified on this map.
    • 01:03:21
      Very important for you to understand that as well as looking at the context of where the rail lines lay and how they parallel most of our major road corridors.
    • 01:03:30
      So it's really important that you keep that in context.
    • 01:03:33
      To really understand that as we look at this plan, it's really about focusing in on major corridors, how do we manage mobility within the corridors, and at the same time, how do we support future prosperity with continuing to make strategic investments that give our port competitive advantage.
    • 01:03:52
      As you can see by this map, we have two passenger rail operators in the Commonwealth of Virginia, Amtrak and Virginia Railway Express.
    • 01:04:00
      And we have 12 freight railroad operators, two Class 1 railroads, Norfolk Southern and CSX.
    • 01:04:08
      The nomenclature of Class 1 just represents the fact that these are high-end, high-revenue generating railroads as compared to our 10 local short-line railroads, which are designated as Class 3 railroads from a revenue point of view.
    • 01:04:23
      This graph clearly illustrates the amount of rail miles that are owned by the two Class 1 railroads, Norfolk Southern and CSX.
    • 01:04:34
      And it's very powerful in a sense that you really get to see how much rail network in the Commonwealth of Virginia is owned by Norfolk Southern Railroad.
    • 01:04:45
      This gives you the viewpoint of how rail miles compare to highway miles.
    • 01:04:49
      And it also sort of illustrates some of the market trends that have occurred over the last 100 years or so as it relates to the fact that rail miles have actually gone down.
    • 01:05:00
      What this graph doesn't tell you is the impact that technology has had on rail in terms of improving the ability to move freight.
    • 01:05:09
      And I think later in my presentation I'm going to talk about some of the accomplishments which will highlight some of those technologies.
    • 01:05:18
      This slide I think for me is one of the more powerful slides.
    • 01:05:22
      You see the fact that rail constitutes about 20% of the movement of freight tonnage in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 01:05:30
      But the pie chart below that sort of shows you the percentage of traffic that moves through the state of Virginia that's internal, that's inbound and outbound.
    • 01:05:39
      A really significant thing for us as a board to keep in mind, particularly as we start talking about how do we want to manage the movement of freight throughout the state of Virginia.
    • 01:05:48
      And this kind of graph pays key attention and key focus as we've talked about our 81 discussions and how we are able to increase the amount of diversion from truck to rail.
    • 01:06:01
      And as we've discussed in previous board meetings, obviously freight traffic continues to grow and we can clearly see by this graph that we have a challenge ahead of us to manage that growth.
    • 01:06:14
      As we've talked about in the past, a lot of this board's emphasis and time has been spent on managing some of the impacts of truck traffic.
    • 01:06:23
      And a lot of the time that we spent over the last couple of years that I've been part of the Commonwealth of Virginia is the fact that we know that we want to try to reduce or better manage the amount of truck traffic on the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:06:37
      When you take a look at this graph and you look at the annual average LA traffic,
    • 01:06:42
      You see how the 81 corridor sort of falls down on the lower end of the corridors, but when you see with that other graph is the fact that it has the highest percentage of trucks within that corridor.
    • 01:06:55
      And that's reflective of some of the discussions that we've had to sort of manage and reduce the amount of trucks to rail diversions.
    • 01:07:02
      You can also see in this graph as well the impact of what happens along the 66 corridor and what I would call the 95 corridors in terms of the level of activity that occurs on those major corridors.
    • 01:07:15
      This graph illustrates the Port, the fact that there is a lot of planned increase in freight traffic at the Port.
    • 01:07:22
      And that's, again, something very significant for us to keep in mind from a context point of view because we have a couple options with the Port moving it by truck or moving it by rail.
    • 01:07:32
      So that sort of sets the stage for us as we move forward in terms of what our thinking has to be.
    • 01:07:39
      This map gives you sort of the context of rail tonnage in Virginia, and as you can see, the top line is the CSX coal line, the bottom line is the Northwest Southern coal line, seeing that those are the two heaviest coal lines in terms of tonnage for the state.
    • 01:07:59
      This mixed graph shows rail tonnage passing through Virginia, and that's more so of the unimodal traffic moving through Virginia along multi-state corridors.
    • 01:08:13
      And again, just from a practical point of view, 95 corridor and 29 corridor, which essentially from the 29 corridor is a corridor we also define as the 81 corridor from the rail point of view.
    • 01:08:27
      This table gives you again a good percentage breakdown of freight rail tonnage.
    • 01:08:32
      I will comment that when you take a look at the intermodal traffic, the intermodal traffic is where we have spent a lot of our effort.
    • 01:08:39
      Intermodal traffic is typically faster moving than the unit trains and the carload trains.
    • 01:08:46
      It's more time sensitive type of train activity.
    • 01:08:51
      And when we focus with agreements with the private railroads, primarily it has been associated with taking trucks off the road, i.e.
    • 01:09:00
      containers.
    • 01:09:03
      The next slide takes you to a viewpoint of what's happening with passenger rail from a ridership point of view in terms of Amtrak and VRE.
    • 01:09:14
      You can clearly see by this graph within Virginia that VRE carries significantly more folks than Amtrak service.
    • 01:09:24
      At the same time, like all analytical information, it can be somewhat misleading in the sense that the Amtrak service
    • 01:09:30
      In terms of setting the stage for the Statewide Rail Plan,
    • 01:09:45
      You know, we've had quite a few successes that sort of set the framework.
    • 01:09:52
      We were really focused in on the goals that have been established by this board in developing this rail plan and we wanted to make sure that as we move forward that this plan was supportive of our update to the VTrans 2035 document.
    • 01:10:08
      When you take a step back, you know, a lot of times we beat ourselves up and we hear negative things about how we're not doing all we can and should do.
    • 01:10:19
      And we can always do more.
    • 01:10:21
      But if you take a step back and look at Virginia, we are a leader in providing funding for rail.
    • 01:10:27
      If you were to go out and talk to a lot of the folks in the railroad business, they will highlight Virginia as an example of a state who's getting it right in terms of understanding the nature of how rail fits in.
    • 01:10:41
      Take a look at our rail enhancement fund, and time after time that we have been reviewed, one of the things that has been cited as extremely innovative is our rail enhancement fund.
    • 01:10:52
      It fosters public and private partnerships sharing of costs and benefits.
    • 01:10:56
      And I really do think it's important that we do recognize that we're doing some things that are really positive and really on the cutting edge.
    • 01:11:05
      Also from a funding point of view, I'll just also highlight the fact that we've used general funding and special appropriations to support significant improvements on the 95 and the 81 corridor.
    • 01:11:17
      That is something that's been very significant and been very well leveraged in terms of advancing projects.
    • 01:11:24
      This is an example of some of our dollars at work.
    • 01:11:27
      This is a tunnel clearance project for the Heartland Corridor, and this shows work underway to provide significant capacity improvements to allow double-stack training operations from the Port of Virginia to shock Chicago, cutting about a day and a half off of shipping time.
    • 01:11:46
      That's very, very significant and as part of that agreement Norfolk Southern is committed to take 150,000 trucks off the road or they have to pay the Commonwealth of Virginia back with interest.
    • 01:11:59
      Significant.
    • 01:12:01
      The next is the Quantico Creek Bridge.
    • 01:12:04
      The Commonwealth participated in funding to support the construction of that bridge to support improved freight and VRE operations.
    • 01:12:12
      That's another example of a successful project that's been implemented and the operation is underway.
    • 01:12:20
      This train represents an example of the work that's been done at the port as part of the opening of the Marist Terminal, one of the first privately constructed facility.
    • 01:12:33
      We participated in that project to support an on-dock rail facility to again foster the movement of more freight by rail.
    • 01:12:45
      In terms of setting the stage for the rail plan, there are a lot of things that are underway, and I think the Secretary has alluded to a couple of times that the world is changing in some ways that we don't really know, but we do know some things that are currently underway.
    • 01:13:00
      One, we know the airline industry is in trouble.
    • 01:13:03
      And we know that the ability to fly like we've flown in the past may not be there for us in the future.
    • 01:13:11
      Some airlines are going out of business.
    • 01:13:13
      Some airlines are reducing the frequency of travel and frequency to where they're actually going.
    • 01:13:18
      So it's important that we take that into consideration.
    • 01:13:21
      It's also really important that we take into consideration that freight demand is increasing and the desire to increase passenger rail is increasing at the same time.
    • 01:13:31
      We got congestion.
    • 01:13:32
      Northern Virginia is the second worst region, part of the second worst region in the country.
    • 01:13:37
      And we know that our port is continuing to grow.
    • 01:13:40
      So in terms of setting the stage, we have some opportunities as well as some challenges that we have to take into consideration.
    • 01:13:48
      And understanding the context of how freight rail fits into our opportunities and challenges, I think we really have to get smarter in terms of understanding the nature of the freight rail business.
    • 01:14:00
      From an international point of view, it's really important to note that we are the leader in freight movement tonnage.
    • 01:14:09
      We are the leader.
    • 01:14:09
      The United States is the leader.
    • 01:14:12
      And when it comes to passenger rail, we lack.
    • 01:14:15
      Now, when you look at passenger rail from an international point of view, you see that there's a lot of public ownership of rail facilities.
    • 01:14:23
      And the trend or the decision can sort of be summarized is that they made a choice between passenger and freight rail.
    • 01:14:31
      And that's going to be something very important for us as we move forward with our rail plan and our philosophy moving forward for rail that we're going to have to make some choices about what we're going to do.
    • 01:14:42
      We also have to appreciate the fact that freight rail is a very capital intensive industry, much more so than other industries in terms of amount of money that they have to invest to maintain and improve their infrastructure on an annual basis.
    • 01:14:54
      And the bottom line that I oftentimes want to remind people is that rail in Virginia is owned by the private sector industry that is responsible to its shareholders first.
    • 01:15:06
      And you have to appreciate the fact that passenger rail operations is not profitable.
    • 01:15:12
      It requires a subsidy.
    • 01:15:14
      And from a freight point of view, it's a minimum of freightage at least five times more profitable than having a passenger rail track, passenger rail train on this track.
    • 01:15:25
      You also have to appreciate the fact that in terms of railroading, that capacity represents a commodity.
    • 01:15:33
      And what I mean by capacity, it means the ability for them to add additional trains on their tracks.
    • 01:15:39
      It's a commodity.
    • 01:15:40
      It's something that's available to them to make additional revenue.
    • 01:15:44
      And like any private sector interests, or even us personally, we're not willing to give away our assets typically.
    • 01:15:53
      In terms of passenger rail, again mention the fact that it requires a subsidy.
    • 01:15:58
      I don't make a value judgment to say that's negative, but it does require a subsidy.
    • 01:16:02
      Amtrak, through a federal statute, has the right to operate on freight lines, and that's important.
    • 01:16:08
      It's part of deregulation of the railroad industry and the railroad's desire to get out of passenger rail operations.
    • 01:16:15
      They created Amtrak as a national organization, and Amtrak has certain rights to operate.
    • 01:16:21
      that commuter railroads like VRE don't have.
    • 01:16:24
      Amtrak is able to make a decision to expand their service and operate and have that right and protection to do so.
    • 01:16:31
      Commuter rail operators like VRE have to negotiate with the private sector railroads to gain access.
    • 01:16:40
      And what's really important to note, you've heard us talk a whole heck of a lot about third track.
    • 01:16:46
      And I bet most of you are wondering, what the heck is third track?
    • 01:16:49
      Well, that agreement, the premise of that agreement was when VRE was allowed to operate on those lines is that VRE agreed to replace that capacity that was lost due to VRE's operations at no cost to CSX.
    • 01:17:05
      That's very important to note.
    • 01:17:08
      They had to negotiate their agreement and we are responsible for providing the capacity that was lost to CSX as a matter of VRE gaining operations.
    • 01:17:19
      I wish Dr. Davis here, because this was his bullet, he's asked me time and time again about building your own right-of-way.
    • 01:17:28
      Part of the research that's discussed in the rail plan is the fact that commuter rail operators, in large part, in fact I couldn't find anyone who made a decision to build their own, obtain their own right-of-way and build their own rail line.
    • 01:17:42
      The cost of right-of-way acquisition is fairly expensive in urbanized areas.
    • 01:17:48
      And as a fact of matter, too, it would not be mostly cost-effective.
    • 01:17:52
      And let me just spend 30 seconds to explain why.
    • 01:17:56
      Commuter rail operations typically operate during peak periods, AM, morning peak, and evening peak.
    • 01:18:03
      And if you were to build that rail line, you probably would build a double track rail line, which could be fairly expensive.
    • 01:18:09
      And if you think about it, for a double track rail line, we've estimated the right-of-way to be a minimum of $2 billion between Washington, D.C. and Richmond.
    • 01:18:18
      Then you would assume about maybe $12 to $15 million a mile for a double track railroad on top of that.
    • 01:18:26
      Fairly expensive.
    • 01:18:28
      You would also have a lot of capacity or the ability to run a lot more trains that you would never run from a practical point of view.
    • 01:18:39
      So the fact of the matter, most commuter railroad operators and most public sector entities have realized that the value is to make an incremental improvement to a railroad to operate its service rather than building a dedicated line.
    • 01:18:54
      That's very, very important for us to note from a business context.
    • 01:18:58
      That's how we arrive at the point that we are today with this discussion of shared facilities between freight rail and passenger rail.
    • 01:19:08
      Obviously, this board recognizes through its funding commitments of the past the fact that rail has significant benefits in terms of moving people, protecting our environment, and providing economic benefits for the Commonwealth.
    • 01:19:23
      In terms of looking at the potential improvements in the draft statewide plan, I'll start off by saying I don't think there's a whole heck of a lot of surprises in terms of projects that we identify.
    • 01:19:34
      This board has talked about projects over time and I think, again, when you look at the nature of how railroads operate in Virginia where the lines are and the prospects of actually building new lines, it really is not a lot to discuss in terms of the types of projects that you would really focus in on.
    • 01:19:51
      But one of our focus was on corridor management to support diverse needs along major corridors in Virginia.
    • 01:19:57
      We talked about that in detail and I'm going to show you a graph in terms of how funding and potential improvements were identified by corridor.
    • 01:20:06
      We identified improvements throughout the state.
    • 01:20:09
      We wanted to support the future growth in Virginia in terms of population and economy.
    • 01:20:14
      And we wanted to make sure that we
    • 01:20:17
      We took into context the impact of the port and the ability to increase the efficiency of freight movement that will originate and terminate at the Port of Virginia.
    • 01:20:29
      It's really, really important that I emphasize this point over and over again.
    • 01:20:34
      The project cost estimates include the capital component only.
    • 01:20:39
      The costs are escalated in 2008 dollars without an escalation to the potential year of date.
    • 01:20:45
      I won't say that's the case for every project, but as a rule of thumb, just consider that.
    • 01:20:50
      We have not identified the operating or the equipment costs that are associated with it.
    • 01:20:56
      But in the rail plan, we will identify those costs.
    • 01:20:58
      comprehensively as part of project recommendations that may be made for specific projects.
    • 01:21:04
      It has to be taken into context.
    • 01:21:08
      I think this slide sort of sums up a lot of the work that we've done over time in terms of identifying potential rail projects.
    • 01:21:15
      You clearly see that from a rail point of view, we define the 95 and the 64 corridor together and the secretary is looking at me and he's saying, why do you do that?
    • 01:21:26
      And as we get to the project that's called the Urban Crescent Express, and it's an intercity rail project, and what you will note is that the recommendation is that we will have trains originating from Newport News traveling through the Richmond region up to 95 Quarter.
    • 01:21:47
      Why would we do something along that line?
    • 01:21:49
      Because it supports improved efficiency of Amtrak operations and allows us over time should we choose to implement any service to implement service at a much lower cost than if we were to go on a different strategy.
    • 01:22:05
      So for the purposes of this discussion we've identified that linkage.
    • 01:22:08
      And you also have to understand in the context of rail operations as opposed to interstate systems is that that represents the tie-in of the CSX line from the 64 corridor through the 95 corridor.
    • 01:22:22
      The next percentage allocation is the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:22:26
      Now keep in mind that we defined the I-81 corridor from a rail perspective very, very broadly.
    • 01:22:33
      It includes the 29th quarter, it captures the 66th quarter, and it captures Interstate 81.
    • 01:22:40
      And again, that is just based upon the nature of rail operations that occur and the flow.
    • 01:22:48
      Then you see, I think it's about 3% of the funding that's been identified for the port.
    • 01:22:56
      I can't necessarily see the colors really well.
    • 01:22:59
      Again, this graph sort of illustrates the fact that we have potential improvements on a statewide basis.
    • 01:23:06
      I will tell you from a quarter management point of view that when you think about potential projects, we've broken them down in terms of freight projects and passenger rail projects.
    • 01:23:17
      But as you read the rail plan document over the next few weeks or so, what you will see is that within each of the quarters that we talk about, we identify that there are potential opportunities
    • 01:23:28
      for freight and rail benefits, pardon me, and passenger rail benefits.
    • 01:23:34
      That's really, really important for you to keep in mind.
    • 01:23:36
      You may be seeing, hearing us talk about projects from a freight context only, but within the context of the freight improvement that's identified, it may also have a passenger rail benefit, and conversely.
    • 01:23:48
      And really, it's important to note to tie this back to our discussion about intermodal traffic.
    • 01:23:54
      Intermodal traffic has some of the same characteristics
    • 01:23:58
      as passenger rail traffic in terms of the need to have just-in-time delivery and move people faster.
    • 01:24:05
      So I understand the philosophy is to look at where we have commonality and where we can get dual benefits.
    • 01:24:12
      This graph illustrates and summarizes the improvements that are associated with the Class I and Short Line Railroad projects.
    • 01:24:20
      I think it's just again important to note that as I move through these projects that you can see for example the CSX National Gateway Project that this project again is one of those projects that requires
    • 01:24:33
      multi-state commitments in order to affect the type of change that has been identified.
    • 01:24:40
      What's important about this project that it is focused in on allowing CSX to have double stack operations which could have the benefit of reducing the number of train sets that they run through the 95 corridor which could free up capacity for us to run additional passenger rail services.
    • 01:25:02
      The Norfolk Southern Crescent Corridor Project is a project, again, that's focused in on the 81 corridor.
    • 01:25:09
      Again, this is something that we've talked a lot about as a transportation board.
    • 01:25:16
      And again, when you look at this project, you're going to see some synergies and opportunities.
    • 01:25:20
      For example, when we talk about the Transdominion Express, that part of the allotment is captured in the Crescent Corridor.
    • 01:25:27
      But again, I will just emphasize for each of these slides like the Gateway Project, like the Norfolk Southern Crescent Corridor Project, and like the Heartland Corridor Project, that these are all important multi-state initiatives.
    • 01:25:40
      And for us to really maximize the diversions of trucks to rail, we really have to get commitments on a multi-state basis.
    • 01:25:49
      There are some things that we can do to make things better, but in order to get the full and a meaningful impact, we have to have multi-state commitments.
    • 01:26:01
      Norfolk Southern identified a coal corridor project as well as a potential improvement and I'll just make the comment that one of the things that I've talked and shared with the Secretary that in terms of most of our programs we focus first on the transportation benefit and we believe coal is a valuable economic generator for the Commonwealth of Virginia but in terms of our program
    • 01:26:26
      It's one of the first tests from a freight point of view is does it afford an opportunity to divert.
    • 01:26:33
      And since coal is only moved by rail in the Commonwealth of Virginia, it will not score as well.
    • 01:26:41
      And so you will see in our report that we don't evaluate the economic benefit.
    • 01:26:46
      But we don't say that it precludes a coal project from being supported within our program context.
    • 01:26:52
      Because again, there are opportunities for sharing costs and benefits
    • 01:26:56
      That we really focus in on making sure that the Class 1 railroads understand.
    • 01:27:00
      There's opportunities for us to share costs and benefits to do things that leverage what both of us would like to advance.
    • 01:27:07
      This sort of captures our desire to support our short-line railroads through the rail preservation program.
    • 01:27:14
      The map illustrates the short-line railroad network.
    • 01:27:17
      And again, this is funding that we approve on an annual basis.
    • 01:27:20
      You just approved allocation in the six-year plan for the rail preservation program.
    • 01:27:26
      This sort of summarizes the improvements for the class one and short line projects.
    • 01:27:31
      And again, you have time to take a look and give me your comments relative to the projects and the potential benefits.
    • 01:27:38
      The port project, again, I'll just spend one minute to say that the port projects are all focused on supporting continued prosperity of the port and allowing the maximization of movement of freight by rail rather than adding trucks along our roads.
    • 01:27:58
      In terms of passenger rail projects, again, I'll talk about it in the context of commuter rail and intercity rail improvements.
    • 01:28:07
      Within the context of, and I'll move forward to the VRE Gainesville Haymarket extension along 66, if you were to reflect back to the Crescent Corridor project, the Crescent Corridor enclosed the 66 corridor, and what we've clearly identified to NS and even in NS is Norfolk Southern's application
    • 01:28:28
      To support the Crescent Corridor, they actually make reference to the fact that some of their improvements should be coordinated with implementation of expanded commuter rail service along the 66th corridor.
    • 01:28:40
      So again, this is one of those opportunities that's right for us to have dual benefits along a corridor.
    • 01:28:47
      But again, this further expands VRE's reach along a pre-busy corridor.
    • 01:28:54
      The next project I'll just highlight is what I mentioned in terms of the third track improvements, which are essentially associated with adding the additional capacity to support passenger rail operations, VRE, between Fredericksburg and Washington, D.C.
    • 01:29:10
      We've identified quite a few sets of potential improvements to add capacity.
    • 01:29:16
      Sometimes capacity is actual track infrastructure.
    • 01:29:19
      Sometimes it's signal systems.
    • 01:29:21
      Sometimes it's things to improve operations like adding platforms on both sides that give greater flexibility in operations.
    • 01:29:30
      And again, you see the cost for this and one thing I'll just note that this does not include some of the major items like bridges, major bridge projects like the Long Bridge, for example, that when we start discussing are clearly projects that are going to exceed billions of dollars.
    • 01:29:48
      to construct.
    • 01:29:49
      And again, it doesn't include that.
    • 01:29:52
      It includes adding additional capacity everywhere with the exception of major bridges.
    • 01:29:57
      And we discuss it in more detail in the Rail Plan document.
    • 01:30:01
      The Urban Crescent Express
    • 01:30:03
      Again, this touches upon the 64, 95, 295, and 460 corridors.
    • 01:30:09
      And again, this is a project that was prioritized in the bill, the last bill, in terms of asking us to have priority emphasis on the 95 corridor.
    • 01:30:21
      This quarter represents the best opportunity in terms of passenger rail ridership in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 01:30:29
      It's obvious.
    • 01:30:31
      If you take a look at it, I think greater than 60% of the Commonwealth's population lives along this corridor.
    • 01:30:37
      So it's really important to understand the potential of this corridor.
    • 01:30:41
      The bottom line is all of us know that this corridor has underperformed over time because we don't have a lot of service.
    • 01:30:48
      The service that we do have is not at the right time to support commuters that want to move.
    • 01:30:54
      And I think the biggest issue is that if you're going to have service, it has to be service that's going to be reliable.
    • 01:31:00
      And a big issue for us is making sure that if we want to move forward with a project along this corridor, that we secure an agreement that ensures that we're going to be able to
    • 01:31:10
      perform at a high level of reliability.
    • 01:31:12
      The bottom line is people won't ride passenger rail if they can't count on it getting from point A to point B.
    • 01:31:20
      The Trans Dominion Express, and again, we've discussed the Trans Dominion Express over time.
    • 01:31:26
      I will just note for the board that we've identified that the Trans Dominion Express would be implemented in phases.
    • 01:31:32
      And we've identified and discussed in detail in the rail plan that the phase one as we see it, which represents the best ridership opportunity, is a train originating from Lynchburg to Washington, DC.
    • 01:31:44
      We talk about additional phases happening over time, triggered commensurate with it being able to meet ridership targets.
    • 01:31:50
      But I think it's really a good approach to take because I would very much doubt that we'd build a 300 and so mile interstate all at one time.
    • 01:31:58
      We'd do it incrementally to get it and maximize the public benefit that would be achieved over time.
    • 01:32:05
      Again, this slide just provides some of the passenger rail project results.
    • 01:32:09
      The last thing that I will touch upon relative to potential projects is the Southeast High Speed Rail Corridor.
    • 01:32:15
      Again, Virginia and North Carolina continue to work to advance this initiative.
    • 01:32:20
      I will just note that in terms of the project that I've identified, the third track improvements in the Urban Crescent Express are projects that overlap the project boundary.
    • 01:32:33
      But when you see this project cost of potentially $1.2 billion, that is an additive number.
    • 01:32:39
      It is not a number that backs out the other numbers that we've talked about.
    • 01:32:42
      And one of the things over time as we talk more about passenger rail, you will really get a good understanding of as you desire to increase and get to higher and higher speeds, how the cost is significantly higher to achieve those speeds.
    • 01:32:57
      So that's something just to keep in mind that that project is out there.
    • 01:33:01
      We're a part of a quarter that's been designated a quarter, a potential high-speed rail quarter.
    • 01:33:08
      This slide summarizes the potential public benefits of the projects that have been identified.
    • 01:33:14
      And as you can see, there's a large number of cars and trucks removed from the highway, significant fuel savings, and CO2 emission reductions.
    • 01:33:25
      Project funding, this always gets us to the fun part of the discussion.
    • 01:33:31
      The potential project costs are approximately $5 billion.
    • 01:33:35
      And I want to just put that in context in a sense to say that most of the projects that we do in our Rail Enhancement Fund, particularly with the private sector, most of the times we are not the primary investor.
    • 01:33:50
      Our dollars leverage projects that are significantly higher or more expensive to construct.
    • 01:33:56
      And so this $5 billion number should not represent something that is insurmountable in terms of delivering the projects that provide the highest public benefit.
    • 01:34:06
      As you can see, our current and estimated available state funding from 2009 to 2035 in terms of funding for rail is $1.3 billion.
    • 01:34:16
      All of our programs foster sharing of costs and benefits.
    • 01:34:21
      That's part of the exercise that we're going to be going through over the next few months is really identifying the appropriate levels of sharing and if we are able to identify willing and able partners to step up to share the project costs and benefits.
    • 01:34:36
      The point below identifies the potential sources of funds, and I will note that the bottom bullet, I think, and I think the Secretary would agree, probably represents the most significant challenge for the passenger rail aspect.
    • 01:34:49
      We don't provide any operating money for freight rail, but from a passenger rail point of view, our major challenge is going to be identifying a source of funds to support the operating costs of the passenger rail that will be implemented.
    • 01:35:04
      This is my last slide, so it's over.
    • 01:35:08
      The key issue is the next steps.
    • 01:35:10
      We've released the draft plan.
    • 01:35:12
      We had our first meeting.
    • 01:35:13
      There are a list of other meetings, and we've sent out notice to you as board members.
    • 01:35:16
      We do encourage you to attend as many of those meetings as possible.
    • 01:35:20
      The rail action plan.
    • 01:35:21
      Let me just clarify.
    • 01:35:22
      The rail action plan, at its essence, is going to be the final executive summary of the rail plan document.
    • 01:35:29
      It will actually take the potential projects that we have identified and make a recommendation regarding funding but will serve essentially as the executive summary document of a final rail plan document.
    • 01:35:41
      But it will answer all of the questions in terms of recommendations from the department associated with what projects should be prioritized and what the funding sources are to move those projects.
    • 01:35:50
      We do anticipate finalizing it in November 2008, and we do plan to do regular updates of the rail plan to make sure that we keep, particularly from a cost estimating point of view, and projects fresh as possible with yearly updates.
    • 01:36:06
      At this point, my presentation is concluded.
    • 01:36:08
      Mr. Chairman, I'll turn it back to you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:10
      Thank you, Mr. Tucker.
    • 01:36:11
      That was an outstanding presentation.
    • 01:36:13
      I know there's a ton of excellent staff work that
    • 01:36:17
      Mr.
    • 01:36:18
      Page and Mr. Badger, Mr. Hill, and others in your staff have worked on as well as Norfolk Southern and CSX, and I hope you'll extend our appreciation to the Class 1 and the short-line railroads who helped you to put that together.
    • 01:36:32
      This is the second major, very meaty presentation, and this is going to be the beginning of a lot of discussions of this body.
    • 01:36:42
      I think the last slide about the action plan getting finalized in September, that's
    • 01:36:47
      That's where the action is for this group.
    • 01:36:48
      This is your responsibility to bring this together.
    • 01:36:53
      And so I encourage you to have those discussions with DRPT so that we can bring forward a consensus document, the action plan that would be incorporated into the final plan for adoption in November.
    • 01:37:08
      Mr.
    • 01:37:08
      Keen, if I might add, ably represents the Commonwealth Transportation Board on the Rail Advisory Board and does require
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:17
      A lot of travel and a lot of work and a lot of education.
    • 01:37:38
      I remember that the director came to us with the identity of some funds that we were going to get through the enhancement funds and the possibility of getting bond funds and this type thing and discovered or was alarmed that maybe his department was needing some reorganization in order to be able to accomplish what would be accomplished what we're beginning to see today.
    • 01:38:01
      And through that reorganization he identified skill sets and various improvements that were to be made at that particular point.
    • 01:38:08
      And the interesting thing to us at that point was that he didn't really have an operating budget to handle that so he went and someone helped him sweep out the corners and he came up with about $10 million to implement this reorganization to harness special skill sets to analyze the status of the rail in Virginia and come up with a plan.
    • 01:38:29
      And I say all of that to indicate that I think we're beginning to see the results of that.
    • 01:38:35
      as we develop this document of proposals that will ultimately become a statewide rail plan.
    • 01:38:42
      And I think it's an accomplishment that we need to not overlook in this particular case as we move forward in developing that plan and begin to give credit and recognize those as you already have for the work that they've done.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 01:39:00
      Mr. Tucker, in preparation for the kind of questions I get, if the double track would run about 12 million a mile, is it fair to think that a single track would run about 8 million a mile?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:18
      Well, what we typically use as a rule of thumb, and rules of thumb can get you in trouble, is five to six million per mile for a single track, but again, that takes into consideration, that makes the assumption that from an environmental point of view, that things are relatively easy to manage.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 01:39:39
      Okay, any other questions that we might be facing next week?
    • 01:39:45
      Could a realistic person,
    • 01:39:47
      James L. Kennedy III, John C. Kennedy III,
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:59
      I think the easy answer to that is that the Lynchburg extension was identified because it requires much less work in terms of rail infrastructure to get it started.
    • 01:40:18
      Of all of the projects that we talked about from a passenger rail point of view, an extension from Lynchburg to DC is the easiest from a rail infrastructure point of view.
    • 01:40:29
      We're working with Norfolk Southern now and they've been just absolutely wonderful partners to do the engineering, to look at what it would take to do the improvements between Lynchburg to get us to Roanoke.
    • 01:40:42
      And I think if you were
    • 01:40:43
      Take a look again at the Amtrak report that was submitted back in 2007.
    • 01:40:49
      They identified that RONA had a lot of potential opportunities for intercity rail ridership.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:58
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to add my congratulations to the progress we're making here.
    • 01:41:03
      Last night we had the first public hearing and it was very pleasant because all the comments were positive and encouraging
    • 01:41:13
      Very appreciative of the fact that we actually are developing now a statewide rail plan with action.
    • 01:41:19
      If I might make just two observations that relate to each other, one is I hope we'll be really aggressive about pursuing the funding for this because, among other things, it will help us achieve the goals of the previous presentation.
    • 01:41:35
      The more money we can spend on rail, the faster we'll achieve carbon reductions and vehicle miles travel reductions and
    • 01:41:43
      It's all about tough choices.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:12
      Mr. Chairman, Director Tucker, I congratulate you and your team.
    • 01:42:19
      I mean, you brought energy and focus to this.
    • 01:42:22
      It's something that we wanted for some time and you've laid it out very well here.
    • 01:42:27
      I also think you have a unique opportunity.
    • 01:42:29
      There seems to be an appreciation of the need here that's shared by the public with
    • 01:42:36
      The way they're riding Metro, they're riding VRE in record numbers now.
    • 01:42:41
      And the capacity constraints are really what we're looking at in the system.
    • 01:42:45
      So there seems to be public support for this.
    • 01:42:49
      Not just in polls but in actual actions.
    • 01:42:52
      So we need to move fast to increase capacity so we're not discouraging the very behavior that we're trying to engender.
    • 01:42:59
      Second is there appears to be some type of consensus in the rail area that doesn't exist in some other parts.
    • 01:43:07
      I think you're the beneficiary of some long-term funding for that reason.
    • 01:43:11
      People do see this as something that needs to be developed and we need to take advantage of that too.
    • 01:43:16
      And then finally, I love the way you've scored things through the plan about vehicles moved off the road, benefits to the environment, fuel savings, so forth, because that's actually a strategic set of trade-offs that we are looking at.
    • 01:43:32
      So I agree with my colleague.
    • 01:43:34
      This is an area where we need to move as fast as we can, and I know that's something that you've made a goal of yours as well, but you'll have my support in that regard.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:43:46
      Excellent, excellent piece of work.
    • 01:43:48
      Question, have we gotten the General Assembly members engaged in this and is there a strategy to move forward with those guys?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:00
      Well, I think again last night was sort of the starting point for a public discussion and I know yesterday during the course of the day that I got
    • 01:44:08
      A couple of emails with clarifications and questions about projects.
    • 01:44:12
      But I think, as the Chair alluded to, I think the bigger issue is the next step, which is the real action plan with the funding.
    • 01:44:20
      Because right now, what we've identified as potential projects.
    • 01:44:23
      And I think that next step of coming back with the specific recommendations and spelling out specifically what needs to be done, the choices that have to be made to move it forward.
    • 01:44:34
      It's probably, from my perspective, the best time to really engage people is when we've answered all of the questions associated with what are the priorities and how do we advance those priorities.
    • 01:44:46
      And that's late September when we release that report.
    • 01:44:49
      Ms. Connally?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:49
      I think this is, again, a wonderful step forward.
    • 01:44:53
      Would you, looking at this $5 billion, would you put that in context?
    • 01:45:00
      In terms of perhaps how much capital outlays both of the private railroads make annually or within the last five or six years, I mean, what kind of an increase?
    • 01:45:15
      Obviously it's going to have to be a cost shared by many parties, but what level of
    • 01:45:21
      Capital spending do those railroads make right now?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:24
      And I guess this won't be that helpful because if you remember in the presentation I talked to the fact that they use about 18% of their revenues towards capital investment and you compare that to some similar sectors, the number is right around 4%.
    • 01:45:39
      But railroads are again as private operators, they're very strategic.
    • 01:45:43
      Their notion of when I make this investment, I know I'm going to get a high return on investment immediately.
    • 01:45:51
      because they are so responsive to their shareholders.
    • 01:45:54
      In terms of the projects, again, I would say to the board I wouldn't focus in on the $5 billion number being necessarily the major challenge for us.
    • 01:46:03
      I think the, you know, in terms of when you look at the projects
    • 01:46:06
      There are going to be opportunities for cost sharing of costs and benefits.
    • 01:46:11
      And from the freight rail point of view, we'll be working through with Norfolk Southern and others to identify those projects to provide the highest public benefit to move forward with those investments at the same time, waiting to see if there becomes a multi-state commitment.
    • 01:46:26
      Our biggest challenge, and I'll just keep beating that drum, is going to be the identification of a reliable ongoing source to support the operating costs of the service.
    • 01:46:37
      Mr. Sterling.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:39
      In terms of the DRE, the way that's currently structured and operated really is a regional authority.
    • 01:46:47
      But it's got some, because of the way that gets funded, the way it gets resourced, that creates somewhat of a problem in that the outlying communities are not, they don't want to join as a result of that funding stream that then, or the responsibility that come on them.
    • 01:47:02
      But we see it as an importance for the Commonwealth as a whole to be moving to this, but we're stymieing its expansion.
    • 01:47:09
      If we're going to move this,
    • 01:47:10
      Do we not need to look at whether or not this should become not a regional program but really a state program that we are running through DRPT so that we can bring the rails further out to those outlying communities without necessarily facing that backlash that otherwise is out there today?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:28
      And let me answer this in the context of my experience in California where we wanted to, I worked in San Jose, and we wanted to bring the heavy rail system that operated in Oakland and San Francisco down to our city.
    • 01:47:44
      And one of the major issues and major debates was the fact that they were asking for two things, core system improvements of their existing network to accommodate additional.
    • 01:47:54
      So in other words, before you even talked about building new lines,
    • 01:47:58
      You're paying for the investment that was made to start up the system and to expand the system and then talking about an ongoing source of funding to support the future expanded operations.
    • 01:48:08
      And I think it's very similar to the discussion we've had about VRE and expanding its services.
    • 01:48:14
      And also within the framework of corridors, one of the things we spend some time talking about in the rail plan is the fact that when you look at those corridors that we have to start managing the resources in the corridor.
    • 01:48:26
      That from a practical point of view is if we start more and more inner city rail is that competing with VRE commuter rail service.
    • 01:48:35
      And so what we do talk about and touch upon the fact is that we do have to talk
    • 01:48:39
      about how we want to resolve those issues and how we want to manage the corridors.
    • 01:48:43
      I'm not ready to subscribe to a specific solution, but I think you're going to have to lay out all of those options to talk about what is the framework that we use to make it cost effective and efficient because at the end of the day, a train that originates in Newport News that goes through Northern Virginia is providing the same type of benefit that you would get from having a commuter rail train that originates from Fredericksburg, assuming that there are seats available for people to get on.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:08
      Part of the challenge is what you're seeing is that the lots that are within the area, the BRE lots that are within those communities that have done it, are now oversubscribed.
    • 01:49:17
      They're filled up.
    • 01:49:18
      People can't get on them.
    • 01:49:19
      The additional costs that are borne by these riders coming from the outlying areas are actually being absorbed or taken over by the costs or by the people that are within those communities.
    • 01:49:30
      It's creating somewhat of a frustration and backlash to where this could pose a long-term problem for the VRE itself unless we can come up with a solution that's going to be able to spread this out and to actually
    • 01:49:42
      to provide the service to everybody and to provide the cost associated with that to everybody that is therefore benefiting from it.
    • 01:49:48
      Otherwise, we're at the capacity that we are because we're just not going to see people within those communities that are currently within it willing to step up to the plate to continue to pay for those people outside.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:03
      Any other questions or comments?
    • 01:50:07
      Again, Ms. Tucker, I want to commend you for really an outstanding report.
    • 01:50:11
      It's a perfect compliment to Deputy Secretary Davis' presentation on climate change.
    • 01:50:19
      A couple of random thoughts here with respect to this, and then what I'm going to do is I'm going to call on the commissioner to make an announcement, a very important and wonderful announcement, and then we'll take a short break.
    • 01:50:34
      But it's important for this body to understand, and I encourage you to go back and read the state code about the Rail Enhancement Fund.
    • 01:50:44
      We don't buy things.
    • 01:50:46
      We buy public benefits.
    • 01:50:49
      We can't say that enough because that is a very difficult thing.
    • 01:50:52
      You're buying a car or a truck taken off a road or a new job opportunity.
    • 01:50:57
      That's essentially what we're buying with the Rail Enhancement Fund.
    • 01:51:03
      We need to educate as part of this public hearing process to educate people what we're doing.
    • 01:51:07
      We're not buying a railroad.
    • 01:51:09
      We're not buying a share in a railroad.
    • 01:51:11
      We're buying the public benefits that come with that.
    • 01:51:16
      Secondly, I think, again, we should recognize the good news here.
    • 01:51:22
      And there is this intertwining fortuitously
    • 01:51:28
      We have this amazing competitive advantage of the Port of Virginia because of its rail access.
    • 01:51:35
      We beat hands down any port on the East Coast by virtue of our rail access and coincidentally it has all these additional public benefits whether they're environmental or economic.
    • 01:51:47
      So this is something we want to continue to build on obviously.
    • 01:51:52
      A third note and really by way of history and unfortunately
    • 01:51:58
      I think Ms. Connally and I probably have a little too much and I wish Ms. Hanley was still here.
    • 01:52:02
      The creation of the Virginia Railway Express, the commitment to quote unquote replace capacity was not an original commitment with the creation of VRE.
    • 01:52:14
      That was a subsequent commitment I believe during the Gilmore administration.
    • 01:52:21
      But the original creation of VRE was back when RF&P Railroad was
    • 01:52:26
      The principal shareholder pushed the Commonwealth.
    • 01:52:31
      And that change in ownership did precipitate a change in that relationship between the public and the private sector.
    • 01:52:39
      So it's important, particularly those of you in the 95 corridor, to understand that history and that change.
    • 01:52:47
      The fourth thing is Mr. Tucker's reference to the action plan.
    • 01:52:51
      And I would encourage, this is where
    • 01:52:54
      The hard choices you have to go through every year in the development of the six-year program, that's where it's going to occur here.
    • 01:53:00
      We cannot afford everything in the statewide rail plan, but we do have some opportunities and some dedicated funds to do some very significant improvements and start down very interesting and creative paths.
    • 01:53:12
      And so between now and the November meeting of the CTB, that needs to be one of your principal focuses.
    • 01:53:21
      I would say
    • 01:53:22
      In August, when the governor goes before the money committees, there are oftentimes, particularly in down economic cycles, there is a potential for a revenue re-forecast.
    • 01:53:35
      And so in that same time frame, when you're looking at these tough choices with respect to the rail enhancement fund and making hard choices among projects and programs, you need to keep that in the back of your mind.
    • 01:53:52
      And I would encourage all of you to, no one knows how the books will close, but that August meeting will be very important both for general funding and transportation fund revenues.
    • 01:54:05
      Second to last point that Mr. Tucker made, we don't reap the full set of benefits of these investments if there is not a federal role in a multi-state effort.
    • 01:54:16
      Last month we approved an I-81 corridor program to allow us to start that process, but
    • 01:54:22
      The harsh reality is we're there because there's not a single federal platform to do that.
    • 01:54:29
      And as I indicated earlier with the decline in the Federal Highway Trust Fund to make these alternative investments work in rail to achieve really significant traction on the global climate change issues, it's going to require federal leadership.
    • 01:54:48
      We can do a lot at the state level.
    • 01:54:50
      And we will proceed.
    • 01:54:52
      But for our investments to succeed and for our climate change and our rail improvements to succeed, we need federal leadership.
    • 01:55:00
      That is so important in this rail arena.
    • 01:55:04
      Last and concluding note, Mr. Tucker repeatedly mentioned operational costs.
    • 01:55:10
      We do have a dedicated source of capital funding.
    • 01:55:12
      We do not have a dedicated source of operational funding.
    • 01:55:15
      That was one of the things that was lost in the special session.
    • 01:55:19
      Governor's bill and the Senate bill did have dedicated operational funding.
    • 01:55:25
      We don't have that right now.
    • 01:55:26
      So we have some very, very tough choices in a declining economic situation.
    • 01:55:37
      And I do think there's an issue potentially of fairness.
    • 01:55:42
      Mr. Sterling mentioned the tensions on BRE.
    • 01:55:45
      And we had this debate a little bit behind the scenes with some of the advocacy groups, some folks saying, well, it ought to be off the top, state-funded.
    • 01:55:54
      If you're one of the founding members of VRE, what is that, you know, if you're a Fredericksburg or an Alexander or Manassas who's been paying into VRE, how do you feel about somebody else getting the same thing for free?
    • 01:56:03
      So there are going to be some very significant equity issues for this body to address between now and November.
    • 01:56:11
      And I'd ask all of you to keep your thinking caps on.
    • 01:56:15
      and keep your minds open.
    • 01:56:17
      Anybody else want to have a concluding remark, Mr. Tucker, on this?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:23
      No, I guess I would just again say that this for us was just sort of the starting point of the discussion to identify the project.
    • 01:56:30
      I do think it's really important over the next couple of weeks if you have the time to really go through and read the report because we really wrote it from the perspective of really helping everyone understand the issues and we learned a lot as we were doing some of the research.
    • 01:56:44
      The other comment that I will make, I'm happy to come out and meet with any of you one-on-one to walk you through any questions that you have.
    • 01:56:51
      And as we move forward in developing the plan, I'd love to get your feedback and we'll make my staff fully available to answer any questions you have.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:59
      Thank you so much.
    • 01:57:00
      What I'd like to do right now is recognize the commissioner for a really wonderful presentation and at the conclusion of that we're going to take about a ten minute break.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:08
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 01:57:10
      I want to continue the theme this morning of the art of change.
    • 01:57:15
      You know, as a person who gets to occupy the position I have and listen, get the guidance from the board, think about the issues that are facing transportation in the future, one of the most important things I have to work on, I believe, is shaping the leadership of the Department
    • 01:57:36
      When that opportunity arises, and I spend considerable amount of time reflecting on those key positions that we fill in the department, particularly as it relates to what our emphasis will need to be as we move forward into the 21st century.
    • 01:57:57
      Where we were and our strengths in the past may not be the strengths that we need in the future.
    • 01:58:03
      And that is no reflection on the past, it is strictly a reflection on what are we going to be facing and where do we believe our strength will need to be in leadership as we move forward.
    • 01:58:18
      So this morning I'm going to recognize three individuals filling
    • 01:58:24
      As we fill two key leadership positions in the department.
    • 01:58:28
      And I believe those selections reflect the importance of managing our system into the future.
    • 01:58:36
      The use of technology as it applies to our system, integrating multimodal perspectives into our decision making and our commitment to transparency and engaging the public in decision making as we move forward.
    • 01:58:54
      That's what I reflected on as I bring forward
    • 01:58:58
      An individual this morning, and I'd like to have Jim join me up here at the podium.
    • 01:59:04
      I'd like to, by the way, that was one of the other key criteria is the first name of this individual.
    • 01:59:16
      It's a real pleasure to introduce to you James Utterback, who will be our new district administrator in Culpeper.
    • 01:59:23
      Jim brings a real career, a real diverse career, and I think you'll see what I'm talking about.
    • 01:59:31
      He joined us in 1999 after a 14-year career with the U.S. Air Force and ITT Defense and Electronics, an engineering and consulting firm.
    • 01:59:46
      Since he's been with us, he has not stayed in one place.
    • 01:59:50
      He has moved
    • 01:59:51
      to get an understanding of the scope and breadth of what the department is about from management services to location and design to innovative project delivery and a stint as a residency administrator in Charlottesville.
    • 02:00:10
      He currently has the rank of Lieutenant Colonel in the U.S. Air Force Reserves.
    • 02:00:15
      He's earned a master's degree in business from Webster University
    • 02:00:20
      and a bachelor's degree in mechanical engineering.
    • 02:00:23
      Unfortunately, it's from VMI.
    • 02:00:27
      No, I didn't.
    • 02:00:32
      As I've gotten to know him and watched him operate, one of the key initiatives that he's been working on with the chief engineer over the last year and a half is streamlining and modernizing our project development process.
    • 02:00:49
      So that it reflects the need for speed, focus, accountability, and responsibility.
    • 02:00:57
      And believe me, that has not been a trivial task.
    • 02:01:01
      So consequently, it's with mixed emotions that I begged him to take Culpepper.
    • 02:01:09
      That was about a two-second conversation, by the way.
    • 02:01:13
      Because we all know Culpepper is the place to be in the Commonwealth.
    • 02:01:18
      Well, it's the second place to be.
    • 02:01:20
      And I'll never tell you what the first place is.
    • 02:01:22
      But it's a real pleasure to introduce Jim to the board.
    • 02:01:25
      The appointment will be effective toward the end of the month, and then we'll be transitioning
    • 02:01:31
      and that leadership into the Culpepper District.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:34
      Jim?
    • 02:01:37
      Mr.
    • 02:01:37
      Chair and members of the board, I appreciate this.
    • 02:01:42
      I want to thank the commissioner, deputy commissioner, chief engineer, chief financial officer, chief operations for this election and giving me the opportunity.
    • 02:01:52
      Looking forward to returning to the Culpepper District in this role and working with Mr. Butch Davies for some of the issues that we've
    • 02:02:00
      I struggled with a couple years ago kind of gradually moving ahead in a favorite county of mine and a lot of the other issues.
    • 02:02:08
      I'm very much looking forward to the opportunity and one of the things I've learned about taking on a new position and that is to be brief.
    • 02:02:16
      So I'm going to be brief and thank you.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 02:02:26
      Welcome Mr.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:27
      Rudder back and I want to say
    • 02:02:30
      I've had the pleasure of working with you since 1999 when you arrived at VDOT, and I think you've worn about a dozen hats in that time period, and each time with that calm demeanor and great analysis, you know, backing up your conclusions.
    • 02:02:46
      I know all of us, not just Mr. Davies, look forward to working with you.
    • 02:02:50
      Thank you.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:52
      Can I have Dave Ogle join me at the podium?
    • 02:02:56
      Because we have a hiatus and the next board meeting isn't until September, I needed to shoehorn in here a quick recognition of someone who is concluding a 39-year career with the department.
    • 02:03:10
      So I sucked Dave down here under all the pretense this morning.
    • 02:03:16
      I actually told him I was going to come and talk to him about a bridge project someplace.
    • 02:03:20
      Dave is concluding his career at the end of September with us after 39 years, 12 years as district administrator for the Fredericksburg district.
    • 02:03:39
      Not an easy task.
    • 02:03:41
      Fredericksburg obviously being one of our districts that is
    • 02:03:44
      Both urban and emerging and retain some of that great rural perspective that the Commonwealth provides to our customers and to our citizens.
    • 02:03:56
      He has lived through quite a bit of change and emerging issues that come along with that economic prosperity.
    • 02:04:04
      The challenges have never been easy, but Dave has always been what I refer to as our classic Virginia gentleman of district administrators.
    • 02:04:16
      And he's always called me commissioner, which is
    • 02:04:19
      Kind of unique.
    • 02:04:20
      Sooner or later I break down most of the staff and they'll call me by my first name.
    • 02:04:26
      Dave has never done that.
    • 02:04:28
      Dave, I just wanted to take this opportunity in front of the board to congratulate you and thank you for the service of the Commonwealth, for the citizens, and for the hard work and all the contributions you've made over the last thirty-nine years.
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 02:04:59
      I honestly believe that's the first standing ovation I got and actually it's 40 years if you go back to 1968 when I worked during the summer on Survey Party.
    • 02:05:10
      I started in the Fredericksburg District and ended up there.
    • 02:05:14
      I really have appreciated all the support that I've gotten in that time and as the Commissioner first started out here,
    • 02:05:23
      I turned around and somebody said, I'm really starting to feel like a dinosaur relative to the comments he was making about the upcoming leadership of the department.
    • 02:05:33
      But I know he didn't really mean it that way.
    • 02:05:36
      I have enjoyed working with the CTB.
    • 02:05:39
      I've not been one who has made presentations that often to the CTB in the time that I've been here.
    • 02:05:48
      But in my career as a Fredericksburg district administrator,
    • 02:05:52
      I've worked with four different CTB members and actually five because Mr. Sterling, while he is an at-large member, we think of him as our own and have treated him that way at least best I have.
    • 02:06:07
      I thought and today that was the reason the commissioner got me down here was that we had a meeting to talk about it.
    • 02:06:15
      There are a number of challenges for transportation in the state of Virginia.
    • 02:06:21
      I commend you on the work that you do.
    • 02:06:25
      All the upcoming leaders of the department have some real challenges.
    • 02:06:30
      Fredericksburg is not like it was when I first came to work.
    • 02:06:33
      in 1968, and it's going to be a lot different in, I think, the relatively dear future.
    • 02:06:42
      But I do say thank you for all the work and effort that you put into it, and the citizens of Virginia do need all that effort.
    • 02:06:53
      I would also say that while the commissioner was very kind in saying I was a Virginia gentleman,
    • 02:07:00
      There are some citizens out there that would probably disagree, but I won't label them here.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:12
      That begs the next question, what happens next in Fredericksburg?
    • 02:07:16
      So I'd like Quentin Elliott to come forward.
    • 02:07:20
      Quentin is another unique appointment and I think also reflective of that kind of forward thinking that I've been talking to you about.
    • 02:07:33
      He started with VDOT in 1985 as a trainee.
    • 02:07:37
      He served as assistant resident engineer in Franklin and Williamsburg residencies and was Williamsburg resident, at that time resident engineer, now we call them residency administrators.
    • 02:07:51
      He's had a career also in the military.
    • 02:07:56
      His is on the Virginia Air National Guard side and he's retired this year so I can get him to focus on only one thing at a time.
    • 02:08:06
      from a civil engineering squadron in the Air National Guard.
    • 02:08:13
      He has done tours on active duty as a part of his guard service.
    • 02:08:22
      He's from Natural Bridge.
    • 02:08:25
      He holds a degree in civil engineering.
    • 02:08:28
      I am not restarting the VMI tradition, but he is a VMI graduate.
    • 02:08:35
      I would guess without looking that is our chief engineer applauding.
    • 02:08:41
      And he, for the last year, has been our acting administrator in the Culpeper district.
    • 02:08:53
      I've gotten to know Quentin in that role over the last year.
    • 02:08:55
      And when I talked about that role of the problem solver and the
    • 02:09:01
      taking a look at an issue and being able to stand up and say, maybe we need to change what we're doing.
    • 02:09:08
      He's demonstrated that for us on three occasions over the last 11 months in the Culpeper District.
    • 02:09:15
      And that takes a real skill and a real heart.
    • 02:09:18
      So I'm really excited about having Quentin being able to succeed Dave in the Fredericksburg District and bring those kinds of values to that district and to the challenges that
    • 02:09:31
      are remaining to be and coming at that district as we move forward.
    • 02:09:37
      Quentin, congratulations and thank you for joining us.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:09:46
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:09:49
      First of all, I'd like to thank the commissioner for giving me the opportunity to do an acting career while I was in Culpeper.
    • 02:09:57
      I really enjoyed it and I'd like to thank Mr. Davies for all his support and assistance while I was there.
    • 02:10:05
      With his support, it really made working there a great challenge for me and it was fun.
    • 02:10:13
      That was one of the things the Commissioner told me I had to do when I went up there was to have fun and I did have fun working there because I love those types of challenges that we came across.
    • 02:10:25
      I am looking forward to working with Mrs. Carter as I transition to the Fredericksburg District.
    • 02:10:31
      And I look forward to serving in the Fredericksburg District and working with the localities there.
    • 02:10:37
      And I will try to continue with having fun.
    • 02:10:40
      But I think he's going to really expect a little bit more out of me.
    • 02:10:43
      And he's going to expect me to work a little bit more.
    • 02:10:44
      So again, thank you for the opportunity to be a part of the team in the Fredericksburg District.
    • Ralph M. DavisDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:10:53
      Thank you so much, Quentin.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:59
      Thank you, Commissioner, and I'd want to say a first to Quentin Elliott.
    • 02:11:06
      Again, I've worked with many years, and you probably have the most challenging district if you stand back and look at the edge issues, and now that the commuting shed of Northern Virginia overlaps with the commuting shed of Greater Richmond,
    • 02:11:24
      You have a lot of people going in opposite directions in this district, and I can think of nobody better qualified to address and grapple with those future challenges.
    • 02:11:36
      I'd also, Commissioner, like to express on behalf of the entire CTB our appreciation for, one, your gracious recognition of Dave Ogle and his many years of service.
    • 02:11:46
      But also two great appointments.
    • 02:11:48
      I think there's a lot of energy and excitement and appreciation for seeing great professionals like that get their due regard.
    • Mary Lee CarterMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:57
      Listen, Mr. Secretary, I have to say something, thank you for allowing me.
    • 02:12:04
      I just want to say, Dave Hoble has been one of the most gracious, and yes, he is the Virginia gentleman, yes.
    • 02:12:12
      We have only disagreed one time, but that's because of the working relationship that we have.
    • 02:12:17
      Even on my front porch, when he said we have a problem, and I said,
    • 02:12:24
      I can't come to your office because I'm not ready.
    • 02:12:27
      I'll be there to your house.
    • 02:12:29
      And we have sat there, and we have resolved many problems.
    • 02:12:33
      And yes, it's very challenging.
    • 02:12:35
      And Quentin, I'm looking forward to all of these challenges of working with you.
    • 02:12:40
      And Dave Overhead promised that he'll be around the corner if we need him.
    • 02:12:46
      He will not interfere, but he knows his district.
    • 02:12:50
      I'm just amazed.
    • 02:12:51
      of when I would call him, and because it goes down in the northern neck area, which is God's quiet, calm country.
    • 02:13:01
      And he is just, he knows that part of it, but he also knows this busy, busy area that we have that we heard a few minutes ago from Mr. Tucker, that from Furtisburg area to the northern Virginia area, it's 70%.
    • 02:13:19
      of the population of Virginia.
    • 02:13:21
      Am I right?
    • 02:13:22
      So we do have quite challenges there to reach out to, but I know that you will tell the world very well that I'm looking forward to working with you.
    • 02:13:38
      But Mr. Ogle, thank you for all that you've done for me.
    • 02:13:44
      Thank you, Secretary.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:49
      Well, I'd like to join in with your comment.
    • 02:13:53
      I can tell you that there are some side benefits.
    • 02:13:56
      It's nice to know that the Commissioner understands that in the region, in the Culpeper and Fredericksburg District, a military background helps.
    • 02:14:09
      The interesting thing is, what's wonderful about it is I've really gotten to know Quentin pretty well since the Commissioner moved Mortisette to Northern Virginia.
    • 02:14:20
      and I told Quentin the one thing that I was concerned about as a member of the CTB, Quentin goes on weekends down to his boat at Urbana and I told him I didn't want to see an area office floating.
    • 02:14:36
      But it's wonderful, Jim, to have you back up in Charlottesville.
    • 02:14:41
      I know you know the problems that are there.
    • 02:14:43
      Quentin can fill you in on the progress he's made
    • 02:14:47
      I've been there six years.
    • 02:14:50
      We haven't gotten the Meadow Creek Parkway built yet, but we've made progress and those challenges now shift to your shoulders.
    • 02:14:58
      Though I regret losing Quentin, I know he's going to a district where he'll serve well and it's nice to have you back in the Culpeper District.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:10
      Any other comments?
    • 02:15:12
      If not, let's take a 10-minute break.
    • 02:15:16
      It's 11.36, so we'll reconvene at 11.45, is that right?
    • 02:15:25
      Okay.
    • 02:15:27
      In the interest of time, I'd like to pick up with the work session agenda.
    • 02:15:32
      We have one last major presentation, which is a legislative update on both the special session and then some legislative summaries from the regular legislative session.
    • 02:15:43
      I think a lot of us have been involved in and followed these issues closely, but I think it's worthwhile to document the efforts and the opportunities that have been missed.
    • 02:15:56
      Let me start with Nick Donahue, who's going to give an update on the special session legislative updates, and then Chief Mark Badger will just give a brief overview of the regular session.
    • Nick DonohueAssistant Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:16:09
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:16:09
      Good afternoon, members.
    • 02:16:11
      Good morning.
    • 02:16:11
      My showtime is now.
    • 02:16:12
      Members of the board.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:13
      Can you wait while we all open?
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 02:16:16
      Can you wait while we all open?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:16:21
      Secretary, there's some correlation between the legislative update and us having to eat.
    • Nick DonohueAssistant Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:16:38
      And as you all know, the governor convened a special session on June 23rd.
    • 02:16:44
      That special session adjourned 12, or excuse me, 15 days later on July 9th.
    • 02:16:50
      Fifty-seven House bills and nineteen Senate bills were introduced.
    • 02:16:54
      They covered a wide range of subjects including various funding proposals with new revenues, rededicating existing revenues, changes to the maintenance and construction allocation formulas, directives for PPTA solicitations, as well as several non-transportation related bills.
    • 02:17:11
      As you know, one of the main goals of this special session was to help address the maintenance funding issue that we face here in Virginia.
    • 02:17:18
      And as this board knows and this chart demonstrates, as the maintenance costs continue to increase, our construction budget continues to decrease.
    • 02:17:27
      And in FY16, when we first begin to lose our ability to match federal funds, and if you'll notice on this graph, at that point, our highway construction program goes to a serious decline.
    • 02:17:39
      And this does impact all regions of the state as you all know.
    • 02:17:43
      There were several proposals or major funding proposals that were considered by the General Assembly during the special session.
    • 02:17:49
      I'm going to go over three of them.
    • 02:17:51
      The first is the governor's proposal which was introduced by Delegate Armstrong.
    • 02:17:55
      This provided approximately $500 million for maintenance funding in FY 13 through new and existing revenue sources.
    • 02:18:03
      It included an increase in motor vehicle sales tax, a rededication of the existing motor vehicle sales and use tax out of construction and into maintenance, and an increase in motor vehicle registration fees.
    • 02:18:15
      It also raised a 1% retail sales and use tax in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads regions to address the regional congestion issues.
    • 02:18:24
      and an eliminated local option income tax in those two areas.
    • 02:18:28
      It also created a new transportation change fund recognizing that while highways are a major portion of solving our congestion problems, they're not the only solution and provided about 150 million annually to dedicated transit, rail operating and economic development projects.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:45
      And then it also built on some of the House Bill 3202 land use reforms.
    • Nick DonohueAssistant Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:18:50
      This bill was considered by the House.
    • 02:18:52
      The Chairman had the pleasure of explaining the bill for approximately three hours for the House Rules Committee.
    • 02:18:58
      The following day it was tabled indefinitely by the House Rules Committee on a vote of four to twelve.
    • 02:19:06
      At that point the focus of the legislative session shifted over to the Senate side where Senator Staslow introduced a bill, Senate Bill 6009.
    • 02:19:17
      This bill
    • 02:19:19
      increased three statewide revenue sources for highway maintenance and transit, and that included a quarter percent increase in the state sales tax, a six cent increase in the state gas tax, which would have been phased in over a six-year period, as well as a half percent increase in motor vehicle sales and use tax.
    • 02:19:35
      When this was fully implemented, it would have raised approximately $500 million for highway maintenance, as well as about $170 million for transit.
    • 02:19:44
      It did reduce the sales tax on food by a half percent,
    • 02:19:48
      It also raised several taxes and fees in Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia regions to address the regional congestion in those two areas and also raised a 1% state sales tax in the Richmond region as well as the Fredericksburg region to address their regional congestion issues.
    • 02:20:04
      This bill passed the Senate on a largely party-line vote of 21-16 and then was considered in the House.
    • 02:20:12
      In the House,
    • 02:20:14
      The gas tax provisions were removed from the bill by amendment on the floor, at which point that reduced the amount of revenue that would have been dedicated or raised for maintenance from about $500 million to about $240, $250 million when fully implemented and reduced the amount of revenue for transit that would have been raised from about $170 million to about $80 million.
    • 02:20:34
      That bill failed to pass the House on, again, a largely party-line vote of 39 for and 59 against.
    • 02:20:42
      One other major funding proposal that was introduced and considered by both houses was House Bill 6055, which was introduced by Delegate Hamilton.
    • 02:20:51
      The original version of this bill, as it was considered in House Committee, raised several state and local taxes in Northern Virginia to address their congestion, as well as several state taxes and a redirection of general fund growth in Hampton Roads.
    • 02:21:04
      On the House floor, a substitute was considered and adopted
    • 02:21:08
      In this substitute, there was no statewide funding to address highway maintenance, and there were no new taxes, either the local level or the state level, to address regional congestion in Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads.
    • 02:21:20
      Rather, general fund growth, direct and indirect, related to Dulles Airport and National Airport in Northern Virginia and related to the public and private ports in Hampton Roads would have been redirected back to those regions for their highway projects.
    • 02:21:35
      And to give the board some idea of what
    • 02:21:38
      It was drafted very broadly.
    • 02:21:39
      So for instance, shoes that could be sold in a Walmart in Stanton, the sales tax on those shoes as well as partial corporate income tax that would have been paid on that if those shoes were shipped through the port would have been returned to the Hampton Roads region for a project in that area.
    • 02:21:55
      And that's a very big shift there.
    • 02:21:58
      Could you repeat that?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:59
      And this is very important because what is being discussed here is approximately $900 million a year of what are today general fund revenues.
    • 02:22:11
      And what the characterization was that this was somehow fees or taxes that would be generated by the airport's reports, but there are things that are programmed into the general fund growth today.
    • 02:22:27
      W. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III, John W. T. Taylor III,
    • 02:22:49
      The partial reality is that those economic projections are all encapsulated in a long-range, just as we do a long-range forecast for transportation, we do the same thing for general fund.
    • 02:23:02
      So what you would be doing under this type of arrangement would be taking money away from schools and healthcare and public safety and putting it into transportation.
    • 02:23:15
      The reality of this type of arrangement, we have been down this road.
    • 02:23:20
      The Virginia Transportation Act of 2000 and just most recently the $500 million one-time surplus.
    • 02:23:29
      It is very, very difficult to program general fund dollars for transportation.
    • 02:23:35
      We have learned that painfully.
    • 02:23:38
      And it is so important because you will be asked about this question in your communities, particularly if you're from Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:23:47
      And understand what this is.
    • 02:23:49
      This is a way of taking money out of the state general fund, away from education, health care, and public safety, and into transportation.
    • 02:24:00
      Any questions on that point?
    • 02:24:02
      Very, very important for everyone to understand that.
    • 02:24:05
      And it was very clear.
    • 02:24:07
      The question and answer, particularly on the floor of the House, most members, and Mr. Dickens was there, you know, saw a lot of this, but most members of the House believed that somehow that these were new fees or taxes that were going to be paid by the court or by the products or commodities coming through the court rather than this simply capturing general fund growth.
    • 02:24:28
      And the suggestion was that, you know,
    • 02:24:34
      A home appliance purchased at Walmart that some percentage of the taxes paid on that Walmart should come back to Hampton Roads because that came through the Port of Virginia or that a job that is indirectly linked to air travel at Dulles Airport that somehow ought to come out of the general fund and back to transportation in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:24:58
      So it was a recommendation, and I think the very narrow vote of passage reflects the controversy on this.
    • 02:25:10
      The governor cut $300 million out of the General Fund budget unilaterally last August.
    • 02:25:16
      He worked with the General Assembly to cut another $1.1 billion out of it during the legislative session.
    • 02:25:23
      And I mentioned that August money committee meeting with the governor and that revenue report.
    • 02:25:29
      So the notion that somehow there's this untapped reservoir of general fund revenues available for transportation and that meets the test of stable, predictable, and reliable is not an accurate one.
    • 02:25:46
      And I hope all of you in your communities explain that to your constituents.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:53
      Well, that relates to another point that was mentioned.
    • 02:25:58
      There was a letter to the editors, one in the Richmond paper, suggesting that the governors and our numbers are all wet on these admittedly maintenance needs.
    • 02:26:08
      Were you asked about that and want to take another opportunity to have another shot at that?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:14
      Well, sure.
    • 02:26:15
      Thank you, Mr. McCarthy.
    • 02:26:17
      The maintenance deficit, all of you have worked with that number for years, so you know the basis for it.
    • 02:26:24
      And I think the simple answer there is in 2007, the governor introduced legislation where he tied the hands of future governors that said the commissioner would each September, every other September submit a report detailing
    • 02:26:44
      Every asset category, what it costs to maintain it, what are the revenues available to do that, what is being done with respect to privatization to maintain it, and to submit it to JLARC, which is the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Committee, chaired by Delegate Kirk Cox.
    • 02:27:02
      The Commissioner sent those materials and actually sent a copy, if you remember, last September to this body.
    • 02:27:07
      It's an excellent report.
    • 02:27:09
      That has been with JLARC since last September without review or action.
    • 02:27:16
      We would be delighted for JLARC, for the Auditor of Public Accounts, for anything the auditor can come and look at and verify those numbers.
    • 02:27:25
      We think that they, we don't think, we know that they will stand up to scrutiny and that may be a useful exercise to go.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:36
      Well, I mean, I don't think a letter like that ought to be left unanswered because it alleges, I won't say the F word, but it alleges that we don't know what we're doing and that these numbers are just, you know, almost made up out of thin air and they're not accurate and so on and so forth.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:55
      And I just don't believe that is the case.
    • Nick DonohueAssistant Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:28:01
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and as the Chairman pointed out, the legislation was drafted very broadly, so it would include all indirect and direct activities related to these ports and airports, and it would include 30% of all state sales, personal income, and corporate income taxes.
    • 02:28:18
      and this could have been up to amount $640 million in Northern Virginia and up to $300 million in the Hampton Roads region.
    • 02:28:26
      This bill passed the House on a mostly party-line vote of 51 to 45 and failed to report from the Senate Finance Committee later that evening from a vote of 3 to 10.
    • 02:28:40
      While no funding proposal bills passed the General Assembly or maintenance allocation change bills passed the General Assembly.
    • 02:28:45
      Eleven bills did pass.
    • 02:28:47
      Several were non-transportation related and there were a few bills that affected transportation.
    • 02:28:52
      House Bill 6016 allows VDOT to make improvements to secondary roads without building them to new road standards.
    • 02:29:00
      House Bill 6027 provides this board with the authority to enter into fixed-price contracts for materials.
    • 02:29:06
      And House Bill 6028 directs the Hampton Roads Transit Authority to study extending light rail into Virginia Beach.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:16
      The first one, HB 6016, is that chief engineer, is that Dave?
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:23
      Who makes the decision as to whether you build it to new design standards or not?
    • 02:29:26
      Do you do that at the district level?
    • Nick DonohueAssistant Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:29:28
      I believe the bills of the department, so that would be at the discretion of the commissioner and the chief engineer.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:33
      So we would, I assume, in that capacity, set up some sort of standard when we would allow that to deviate from the design standards.
    • 02:29:42
      I mean, those are there for a purpose, so.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:45
      We're currently in the process of reviewing the bill and have not made a recommendation to the Secretary or the Governor yet about our opinion.
    • Nick DonohueAssistant Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:29:58
      There are several other transportation funding issues that need to be considered in the interim.
    • 02:30:02
      As the Chairman noted earlier,
    • 02:30:04
      With the economic forecast as well as increasing gas prices, there is a potential for additional reductions in state transportation revenues when the re-forecast is done this August and that's something that the board needs to keep in mind as we move forward in the coming months.
    • 02:30:18
      And also, as the chairman noted and as the board was briefed last December by USDOT officials, there is uncertainty at the federal level in the amount of funding that will be available for states.
    • 02:30:29
      Traditionally, we have relied on the federal government to be a strong partner, and that was reported to the Board in December.
    • 02:30:34
      In this current fiscal year, the federal highway count is expected to experience the first deficit, which will increase significantly based on what was reported in the coming years.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:46
      Any questions?
    • 02:30:47
      Mr. Donahue.
    • 02:30:49
      Thank you, Mr. Donahue, and I want to acknowledge the extraordinary efforts that you and working with the VDOT and DRPT and ports and airport staff, time, all that together this session.
    • 02:30:59
      Thank you very much for your great work.
    • 02:31:01
      Mr. Dickens.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:31:02
      Mr. Secretary, I would like to compliment you on your ability to stay cool under some very adverse circumstances in front of several committees at the General Assembly.
    • 02:31:19
      You did a remarkable job.
    • 02:31:22
      My compliments to you, sir.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:24
      Thank you.
    • 02:31:25
      You grew up in a family with five Irish kids.
    • 02:31:27
      You learned to have a thick skin early on.
    • 02:31:31
      And I do appreciate that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:34
      Mr. Koelemay.
    • 02:31:35
      Mr. Chairman, if I can beg my colleague's forgiveness for speaking with food in my mouth.
    • 02:31:45
      I just wanted to share quickly some of the responses or reactions to what happened that didn't happen from some of my colleagues in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:31:57
      The Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, as you know, was a major initiative of the General Assembly and past governors.
    • 02:32:04
      It didn't give the regions a voice, as well as potentially some revenue and some ability to design and execute projects in their region where you need.
    • 02:32:15
      That may not fit a broad area of statewide need, but certainly were critical.
    • 02:32:21
      The North Virginia Transportation Authority now is considering whether or not to shut itself down.
    • 02:32:26
      The lack of funding has left it with literally nothing to do.
    • 02:32:31
      And at its latest meeting, the comment was made
    • 02:32:39
      That all of its work to date has been a substitute for really what was needed and that's more funds to move ahead.
    • 02:32:45
      Part of the history that was related at that meeting went all the way back to when Pierce Homer worked to get the Transportation Authority put in place as others did.
    • 02:32:56
      But I wanted to share quickly
    • 02:32:59
      A benign comment.
    • 02:33:01
      We're now no better off than we were last year.
    • 02:33:05
      We're the victims of a shell game fostered upon us by the General Assembly.
    • 02:33:11
      This is the most stunning abrogation of responsibility in the history of the General Assembly.
    • 02:33:17
      The message is clear.
    • 02:33:18
      We're not going to get any funding from the General Assembly for transportation.
    • 02:33:22
      And finally, the suggestion that the NVTA should reconstitute itself as a Northern Virginia council on Northern Virginia statehood.
    • 02:33:34
      I don't say that lightly because that's always one of those rhetorical things, but it just goes to show the depth of disappointment that now exists in Northern Virginia about the ability of state government to be responsive
    • 02:33:51
      to a prime need.
    • 02:33:53
      The cost of this session wasn't the piddly little $100,000 plus that was given out in per diem payments.
    • 02:34:01
      It was actually the million dollars a day that project costs increase every day that we wait to address this problem of new revenues.
    • 02:34:12
      But the larger cost was the cost
    • 02:34:15
      In the loss of confidence in state government to be responsible and responsive, the cost is the breakdown in trust between the economic engine of the state and the General Assembly, and it's not a healthy situation.
    • 02:34:33
      The discussions have changed, the tone has changed, the disappointment is deep, the discouragement has set in, and I think it's going to take a lot of effort by all of those, including this body but others, to restore that kind of trust and that kind of faith and that type of confidence that makes a democratic government work.
    • 02:34:56
      So I just wanted to share a few of those things with you.
    • 02:34:59
      So that you understood that in terms of our region, this legislative session was not only a failure, it was a step back.
    • 02:35:08
      And it's not going to be the same politically in Northern Virginia from this point forward.
    • 02:35:17
      Thank you.
    • 02:35:18
      Mr. Sterling.
    • 02:35:19
      Just a quick question, Mr. Chairman.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:21
      The special assembly, or special session was called to
    • 02:35:25
      Raise revenues to fill in those areas where we had holes as a result of the revenue projections.
    • 02:35:30
      So real briefly, can you tell me how much money they've raised in a special session?
    • 02:35:36
      Zero.
    • 02:35:37
      That's what I thought.
    • 02:35:37
      Okay.
    • 02:35:37
      Thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:41
      Any other questions or comments?
    • 02:35:46
      If not, at your place, there is a legislative report
    • 02:35:51
      And if there are questions, I know there are staff here to answer them.
    • 02:35:57
      I don't know if we necessarily need to go into a full-blown presentation on those.
    • 02:36:00
      But I would encourage you to read through there.
    • 02:36:04
      I would especially encourage you.
    • 02:36:06
      I have a lot I could say about the special session.
    • 02:36:10
      I think I'll hold off.
    • 02:36:12
      Much has been said.
    • 02:36:13
      I do think we need to see where we are in August with state revenues and in the early fall with federal revenues.
    • 02:36:22
      That will give us not a pretty picture, but at least a complete picture of where we stand.
    • 02:36:30
      And it's my intuition, this is not based on any facts or any advanced knowledge, but that I think we may have some significant work for ourselves sometime between September and November.
    • 02:36:42
      And the word step backwards I think is that
    • 02:36:45
      There's an apt description.
    • 02:36:49
      We're just going to have to be asking the basic question, what do we have to do to survive?
    • 02:36:56
      And so I hope folks are prepared for some additional hard work in the early fall.
    • 02:37:02
      The next item on the agenda, number five, is a good piece of news, the Cycle Systems Rail Industrial Access Project.
    • 02:37:11
      Welcome, Mr.
    • 02:37:12
      Page.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:37:13
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:37:16
      It's great to come forward today because we've been talking about being green and recycling, and this is truly a recycling project.
    • 02:37:25
      Cycle Systems Incorporated is a family-owned business headquartered in Roanoke, Virginia, down in Mr. Martin's district.
    • 02:37:32
      Cycle Systems has seven facilities currently today in Virginia, and they have submitted application to the department, which we're bringing forward today in a briefing document for action at the next CTB meeting in September.
    • 02:37:44
      This project is a $2 million project where Cycle Systems Incorporated will be developing a recycling center for both ferrous, which is steel, and non-ferrous, which is aluminum and other materials that are all the way down to scrap paper for the Stanton area.
    • 02:38:00
      It's located within the city of Stanton and is also being served by the Buckingham Branch Railroad, which this board may know as one of our newest
    • 02:38:06
      and the longest short-line railroad in Virginia, which is a 200-mile stretch between Richmond up through Charlottesville, Stanton and over to Clifton Forge.
    • 02:38:15
      Cycle Systems, this new facility, will be on the outskirts of Stanton as you come in on US 250 off of 64 headed west.
    • 02:38:22
      It'll be right on the right-hand side behind the grain silos that you see as you come into town.
    • 02:38:26
      The benefits of this project, as I mentioned earlier, this is a recycling center project.
    • 02:38:32
      The project itself will be an 800-foot-long tract that's split into two tracts into the terminal.
    • 02:38:38
      Estimated cost is $190,000.
    • 02:38:39
      It will add 12 new jobs to the area, provide a recycling basin center that is currently not available to the region, and it also increases the tax base for Stanton, excuse me, tax base.
    • 02:38:53
      This project was endorsed by the City of Stanton at their June 26 meeting and has also been endorsed and recommended by the Virginia Economic Development Partnership.
    • 02:39:03
      The total funding request for cycle systems is $190,000 under the terms and conditions of the policies and procedures of this board.
    • 02:39:13
      This project is eligible for 100% funding, $190,000 for the project.
    • 02:39:18
      The department brings forward this briefing and recommendation to the board for its consideration at its September 2008 meeting for enacting and taking board action on this project at the value of $190,000.
    • 02:39:31
      Just as a footnote, Mr. Chairman and members of the board, this is the value of a short-line railway, where the Buckingham Branch has access to not only CSX, but also Norfolk Southern.
    • 02:39:44
      The iron that will be generated at this project will go to Chaparral's in Petersburg, which has connection with CSX off of Buckingham Branch, and also the Roanoke Electric Steel Company in Roanoke, which has connection off of Norfolk Southern at Waynesboro off of Buckingham Branch.
    • 02:39:57
      So this is the value of a short-run railroad having dual access and this is a great opportunity for us in Virginia to enhance our environment as well.
    • 02:40:05
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:06
      Questions, Mr.
    • 02:40:07
      Page?
    • 02:40:10
      Thank you.
    • 02:40:10
      Thank you.
    • 02:40:11
      The next and final work session agenda item is a briefing on the quarters of the future I-95
    • 02:40:18
      Dr. Mary Lynn Tischer will be briefing us on this.
    • 02:40:26
      One thing I would say while Dr. Tischer is laboring over the computer is the Federal Highway Administration has indicated their desire to have something executed during the month of August.
    • 02:40:40
      And so to the degree that there are advantages here, and I think all of us have some reservations about this, there is an action item on the agenda to take this up that will extend signature authority.
    • 02:40:53
      We do have some concerns about the ability of any regional multi-state entity to make any financial commitment without the explicit approval of the CTB.
    • 02:41:05
      And so that is probably an overriding issue.
    • 02:41:08
      There are some potential advantages here in particular.
    • 02:41:12
      to accelerate both the environmental review of the I-95 projects throughout the state and access to some additional bus capital grants that we believe will come to us.
    • 02:41:23
      Dr. Tichen.
    • Mary Lynn TischerSpecial Assistant to the Commissioner
    • 02:41:24
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:41:25
      Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:41:27
      This program called Corridors of the Future was announced by USDOT in September of 2006 and they solicited applications for the program.
    • 02:41:39
      The purpose is to identify
    • 02:41:41
      Multistate corridor investments that reduce congestion and forecast congestion.
    • 02:41:48
      Among their objectives are to illustrate the benefits of alternative financial models that involve private sector capital.
    • 02:41:57
      This is one of the main concerns of this particular administration and this program is part of that interest.
    • 02:42:08
      The 38 proposals were received, three for the I-95 corridor.
    • 02:42:14
      The first was developed by Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, and Virginia.
    • 02:42:20
      And the focus was on adding capacity to I-95.
    • 02:42:25
      The second was developed by the I-95 Corridor Coalition and that focus was on ITS.
    • 02:42:33
      The last was one developed by CSX advancing some improvements in the rail system in the corridor.
    • 02:42:43
      Eight corridors and 14 proposals were selected to advance to phase two including the three for I-95.
    • 02:42:53
      The Phase II applications, however, resulted in the five-state proposal going forward and the I-95 Corridor Coalition going forward.
    • 02:43:05
      This here is a map of the five-states corridor.
    • 02:43:07
      Again, that's focusing on developing capacity, extending capacity along the corridor.
    • 02:43:14
      In September of 2007, USDOT announced that
    • 02:43:21
      Six corridors had been chosen and I-95 was one of the corridors and two of the applications were selected, the I-95 Corridor Coalition application and the five-state application.
    • 02:43:35
      USDOT requires a development agreement and also memorandums of understandings among the states to finalize this agreement.
    • 02:43:47
      So the five states need to sign a comprehensive development agreement with USDOT.
    • 02:43:55
      Secondly, the five states need to sign a memorandum of understanding among themselves
    • 02:44:01
      and then lastly relative to the I-95 Corridor Coalition, that application was put in on behalf of the 13 states that are in the I-95 Corridor and so therefore the Executive Director will be signing the development agreement with USDOT and not the individual states.
    • 02:44:20
      With respect to the five-state agreement, as a participant in the program of Corridors of the Future, North Carolina applied for discretionary funds
    • 02:44:30
      and was awarded $21 million.
    • 02:44:35
      All states will share in that essentially by receiving $4.2 million per state.
    • 02:44:42
      North Carolina will actually be the recipient of the funds and then they will pay a receivable to other states and there are no matching funds required for this.
    • 02:44:51
      The funding will be used for the I-95, 395 Hotlands project.
    • 02:44:58
      All of this would be included in the memorandum of understanding.
    • 02:45:02
      The five states then would formally agree to cooperate with each other through the memorandum of understanding.
    • 02:45:08
      They'll establish a steering committee, identify issues of mutual concern, and to identify each state's projects and schedule of activities.
    • 02:45:18
      They'll advise the individual states of any major activity in their state that would impact the travel in the other states.
    • 02:45:27
      coordinate the hot spot clearance including bottleneck and safety improvements and to plan and implement each state's priority capital projects.
    • 02:45:38
      The I-95 Corridor Coalition has a goal of accelerating the implementation of four coalition initiatives.
    • 02:45:47
      One being real-time traffic information using essentially what's called traffic probe data to bring real-time traffic information to long-distance travelers
    • 02:45:57
      Secondly, bottleneck financing solutions to look at ways to address bottlenecks that exist in one state and with a removal of which would benefit other states.
    • 02:46:10
      Expedited incident clearance, including state-of-the-art practice incident management training, and then also an integrated intercity air, bus, rail, and local transit service program.
    • 02:46:26
      In return,
    • 02:46:27
      USDOT should provide assistance by expediting the environmental process as the Secretary indicated by granting conditional approval for private activity bonds for expediting the receipt of TIFIA and accelerating the review and grant conditional approval for experimental activities.
    • 02:46:51
      Additionally, they should provide assistance by providing a priority for tolling programs
    • 02:46:58
      providing expertise from USDOT and around the country, granting priority on applications of discretionary funds, granting priority on bonus obligation authority, and granting priority on bus capital.
    • 02:47:13
      Being accepted as a Corridor of the Future Program participant allowed North Carolina to receive that $12 million that I mentioned earlier.
    • 02:47:25
      and recently the I-95 Corridor Coalition received funding as a participant in the program for truck parking project along the corridor that Virginia is a participant in.
    • 02:47:38
      You were sent drafts of the development agreement of the memorandum of understanding and as you note everything was draft.
    • 02:47:48
      We are still in the process of negotiating those agreements.
    • 02:47:53
      However, before you or you will be asked in the work session to look at a resolution and the resolution would authorize the Secretary of Transportation to enter into the corridors of the future memorandum of understanding and any amendments thereto and the corridors of future comprehensive development agreement between USDOT and the signatory states and other agreements as would be necessary between the states in furtherance
    • 02:48:20
      of the Corridors of the Future Program.
    • 02:48:23
      And I believe the presentation that Mr. Tucker gave earlier was pretty much a good lead in for this discussion at the end here.
    • 02:48:32
      This is another initiative by the Commonwealth to be involved in multistate
    • 02:48:38
      activities and to continue to pursue coordination with our other states in the hopes that we indeed do provide better transportation service for Virginia as well as for the region. With that, Mr. Chairman, that completes my presentation. Questions?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:56
      Could I just ask a question of Dr. Tischer or maybe the secretary about whether the funding that allocated to Virginia would go toward the 395-395 Hot Lane Project.
    • 02:49:09
      Will this have any impact of salutary or no impact at all on our continuing negotiations with our private partner on developing the Hot Lane Project?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:22
      I would hazard a guess that it's salutary in that other resources that had been committed there could go to hard design and project development.
    • 02:49:34
      That was my question, Mr. Chairman.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:56
      Could you repeat your answer there?
    • 02:49:59
      I was going to ask what happened to the CSX proposal.
    • 02:50:03
      Has that been incorporated somehow or another?
    • Mary Lynn TischerSpecial Assistant to the Commissioner
    • 02:50:06
      Mr. Chairman, if I might, Mr. McCarthy, CSX did not finally submit in the second round and was not, they had been asked to coordinate with us and we had repeatedly tried to engage them in a joint proposal.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:25
      Okay, so I'm sorry now.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:26
      Pardon me, I haven't given any direct information.
    • 02:50:34
      The potential for grants out of this is not significant.
    • 02:50:38
      This is where we are with the administration.
    • 02:50:42
      But we have emphasized bus capital and the rail improvements.
    • 02:50:46
      Are the CSX rail improvements not a part of this?
    • Mary Lynn TischerSpecial Assistant to the Commissioner
    • 02:50:51
      Mr. Chairman, essentially we talk about improvements to the multimodal transportation system.
    • 02:51:01
      We do not explicitly identify rail improvements, but we do suggest that there may be rail improvements in the future.
    • 02:51:09
      And if I could, the five-state proposal was essentially an attempt to add capacity to the I-95.
    • 02:51:21
      Our part of that project or application, excuse me, was the hot lanes in Northern Virginia.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:51:32
      So I've given you bad information in that regard.
    • 02:51:39
      This grant program has fairly stringent limitations on how the funds, if they appear, could be used.
    • 02:51:47
      And so the focus is on congestion pricing projects, which was, again, the unfinished bus capital piece of the 95 hot lanes.
    • 02:51:58
      And then in addition, I guess there's traveler information that would be a multi-state type of exercise.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:09
      So as I read the agreement, Mr. Chairman, it's basically a $4.5 million grant for Virginia, but it doesn't necessarily commit us to anything other than what it says.
    • 02:52:24
      I mean, this is not some brand new model that...
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:52:28
      If I may say, I think there was, and there still may be,
    • 02:52:32
      Some interest at the federal level at making this more into a regional entity and we are prohibited by law from making any commitments beyond the terms of the limited grant application.
    • 02:52:47
      But like the I-81 MOU that we talked about last month, this kind of regional planning exercise might grow into something more robust.
    • 02:52:57
      I think it is an opportunity that we ought to take
    • 02:53:01
      But no one individual, secretary, commissioner, director of rail public transportation, much less a regional coalition, can bind or commit Commonwealth resources without the explicit both authorization and allocation by this body for the General Assembly.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:22
      So one final question.
    • 02:53:23
      So I noticed the agreement also says that
    • 02:53:27
      Virginia or the states would be responsible for any costs above $4 million.
    • 02:53:34
      So that would be our normal approval process.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:39
      We're still in negotiation on this.
    • 02:53:45
      We can't commit beyond what has been, again, allocated by this body or the General Assembly.
    • 02:53:52
      And we don't want to create an entity that clouds accountability.
    • 02:53:56
      Commonwealth Transportation Board is responsible for transportation in Virginia.
    • 02:54:00
      We know whether it's climate change or interstate rail or some of this messaging and technology that works pretty well actually in the northeast corridor.
    • 02:54:11
      We're trying to bring that further south.
    • 02:54:13
      There's value there.
    • 02:54:14
      But we have to be the final arbiter of whether or not something is of value to the Commonwealth.
    • 02:54:21
      And that can't be delegated to a regional entity.
    • Mary Lynn TischerSpecial Assistant to the Commissioner
    • 02:54:26
      And Mr. Chairman, if I might add, there's a distinction here between the Memo of Understanding, which is just between basically the five states, one component of which is how we will handle the receipt of the $4.2 million.
    • 02:54:39
      The Developmental Agreement does not discuss that at all.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:44
      As I've watched the dynamics mature and admittedly as we move forward,
    • 02:54:56
      I see this as a benefit but not supplanting anything that this board has already established.
    • 02:55:08
      I think it enhances our activities significantly.
    • 02:55:15
      I'm not sure where all the
    • 02:55:18
      So this is more like the articles of consideration.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:28
      We're talking about corridors of the future and we're talking about, unless I'm missing something, it sounds like this is only aimed at road building in some fashion.
    • 02:55:48
      Is there any provision for rail in the corridor in this?
    • Mary Lynn TischerSpecial Assistant to the Commissioner
    • 02:55:53
      Mr. Chairman, if I might, Mr. McCarthy, the five-state application was basically about highways and it was about expanding the capacity and our role in that was for the hot lanes, essentially.
    • 02:56:08
      However, it has expanded much beyond that because, partly because of their desire to have
    • 02:56:13
      A development agreement that is similar between the I-95 Quarter Coalition and the Five State and it's expanded quite considerably to essentially be a multimodal approach to the future.
    • 02:56:25
      Specific projects are not identified in either the development agreement or the MOU.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:36
      So that's a not sure.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:38
      Well, I guess, and again, we're in this very ambiguous state trying to negotiate.
    • 02:56:42
      I don't think, given our financial posture, we won't be in a position of turning our backs on for half a million dollars.
    • 02:56:47
      So is this a perfect arrangement?
    • 02:56:50
      By no means no.
    • 02:56:52
      To reject that again is probably a less or a more imperfect action.
    • 02:56:59
      This will be up for debate and discussion on the business agenda.
    • 02:57:02
      I know several people have to leave, so I'm anxious to move along for no other questions.