Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop Meeting 11/7/2007
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop Meeting   11/7/2007

Attachments
  • Workshop agenda.pdf
  • Board actions.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Meeting minutes.pdf
  • I-81 National Environmental Policy Act process.pdf
  • I-81 safety and operational improvements.pdf
  • I-81 exit 150 case study.pdf
  • 1. Update on Inland Port

    • Virginia Inland Port.pdf
  • 2. Update on VDOT Legislative Studies on Overweight Trucks

    • Legislative studies on overweight trucks operating under permit.pdf
  • 3. Focus on the I-81 Corridor • Focus on the Interstate 81 Corridor

    • Focus on the Interstate 81 corridor.pdf
    • I-81 crescent corridor.pdf
    • Rail initiatives for the I-81 corridor.pdf
  • 4. Secondary Street Acceptance Requirements

    • Secondary street acceptance requirements.pdf
  • 5. Using Technology to Construct, Maintain and Monitor Long-Lasting Structures

    • Using technology to construct, maintain and monitor long-lasting structures.pdf
  • 6. High Occupancy Vehicle Lane Operation at Turkeycock Run

    • HOV lane operation at Turkeycock Run.pdf
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      I'd like to call to order our November workshop.
    • 00:00:04
      And as part of that, first say thank you to our host and Dr. Gary Allen with the 56th Annual Transportation Conference here in Roanoke.
    • 00:00:15
      I'm going to ask Dana Martin to make a few introductory comments on behalf of the Roanoke area and the conference as well.
    • 00:00:23
      But Dr. Allen, could you stand up just so everybody
    • 00:00:25
      I know the CTB knows who you are, but other members, thank you for putting on.
    • 00:00:29
      This will be the largest ever conference in its history.
    • 00:00:34
      And so this is a very important conference about the changing face of transportation.
    • 00:00:41
      We're going to see several real-world examples of that today.
    • 00:00:44
      So thank you, Dr. Allen.
    • 00:00:46
      And all your staff are here.
    • 00:00:47
      I know just how much time you put into this.
    • 00:00:51
      And it is time incredibly well spent.
    • 00:00:54
      Just a couple other housekeeping measures before we get started.
    • 00:00:59
      I do want to acknowledge at the outset Mr. Peter Schwartz and his colleague, Cord Sterling, who has emailed me.
    • 00:01:08
      He's going to be running late.
    • 00:01:10
      Neither one was up terribly late last night, but yesterday was a very important day for them.
    • 00:01:14
      I know we've acknowledged them in the past, but I just want to say congratulations on an electoral victory.
    • 00:01:19
      And what I would suggest that when Cord Sterling comes, that we all kind of stand up and give Cord a standing ovation just to surprise him.
    • 00:01:26
      But congratulations, Peter.
    • 00:01:27
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:01:35
      There's one other introduction that I would like to recognize Mr. John Bell.
    • 00:01:43
      Many of you know that Mr. Bell has decided to retire from the Office of the Attorney General.
    • 00:01:49
      Now, will this be your last meeting with us, John?
    • 00:01:52
      And so I'd like to first, if you would, please stand and acknowledge the great work that you've done for many, many years on behalf of the Commonwealth, the Office of the Attorney General, most importantly, our customers.
    • 00:02:09
      And without John, there would be no VRE.
    • 00:02:12
      We would have an aviation program that is second rate.
    • 00:02:16
      We would have gotten in a lot of trouble at VDOT.
    • 00:02:20
      And John has just dealt with so many issues in so many modes.
    • 00:02:24
      And he's just been a font of wisdom and good cheer.
    • 00:02:27
      And he's also a Notre Dame graduate, which doesn't hurt either.
    • 00:02:34
      And so, again, John, on behalf of the board, thank you for your great, great service.
    • 00:02:44
      But you're not done yet.
    • 00:02:45
      We do want you to introduce your successor, Joanne Maxwell, who is a great friend, has done great work with the Department of Motor Vehicles.
    • 00:02:55
      I've known her for many years, working in the General Assembly.
    • 00:02:58
      But John, could you please introduce Joanne?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:03:01
      This is Maxwell.
    • 00:03:02
      Joanne is returning to the Attorney General's Office.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:03:06
      She has currently or has just left DMV.
    • 00:03:07
      She's been here for three or four years.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:10
      She's a graduate of Old Dominion, born and raised in the Tidewood area.
    • 00:03:13
      Norfolk, and she went to the Winneberry Law School, and I've never heard her before she went to law school.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:03:19
      And so Joanne, we've dealt with Joanne, as you have, with DMV, and also in our office, and we'd love to look forward.
    • 00:03:26
      And unfortunately, in our office, we don't usually have a directory of at least two weeks of overlap.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:03:34
      So Joanne is starting Monday evening, Thursday evening, Thursday evening.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:38
      We're dealing with the Traverse County Parkway, and today we're here.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:03:41
      Welcome, Joanne.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:49
      Okay, with that, I would like to recognize Mr. Martin to offer some welcoming remarks and thank you, Dana, for hosting us here in Roanoke at the Hotel Roanoke.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:03
      It's just a pleasure for me to have you come to my turn.
    • 00:04:09
      And depending on how you came in, it's like an experience I had when I used to live in New York.
    • 00:04:16
      and you got to come back and you'd come down through the mountains or there would be snow covered or autumnally colorful leaves or summery green but it was like you're going through this oasis or wilderness or whatever and finally like Vanadu.
    • 00:04:37
      And you've gotten to a place worth coming back to and we're glad to have you coming back
    • 00:04:45
      and I want to thank you.
    • 00:04:47
      The hotel is going to do a great job as always.
    • 00:04:51
      Dr. Allen has got to be organized wonderfully.
    • 00:04:55
      But you know that part that you don't see, that's where the Reverend has really met the road, the local district staff and the things that they are doing and the quote infrastructure unquote to make you transparently have a great visit.
    • 00:05:09
      So please do so and again welcome.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:16
      Thank you, Dana.
    • 00:05:20
      And there are several items on the agenda today.
    • 00:05:30
      We're going to hear an update on the inland port.
    • 00:05:33
      And that actually links to the major focus of our work session today, which is the I-81 corridor.
    • 00:05:39
      This month is the one-year anniversary of the CTB resolution, charting a new path
    • 00:05:44
      for I-81, both short-term and long-term.
    • 00:05:48
      And that is inextricably linked to the movement of freight, both nationally and internationally.
    • 00:05:55
      So there's a lot of interconnections that may not be immediately apparent on the agenda today.
    • 00:06:01
      So with that in mind, I'd like to call up the first item, which is an update on the Inland Port.
    • 00:06:05
      Mr. Greg Edwards with the Virginia Port Authority is here to give us a quick update.
    • 00:06:11
      Welcome, Mr. Edwards.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:06:13
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary, members of the board, ladies and gentlemen, appreciate the opportunity to be back in Star City today as a flatlander from Hampton Roads.
    • 00:06:21
      I'd echo the gentleman's comments.
    • 00:06:22
      It's always a pleasure to be here in Roanoke, and if you'll bear with me for a moment as I access the proper presentation.
    • 00:06:33
      We're always gratified as Governor Kean has been very, very consistent in his message, as you all know,
    • 00:06:39
      that the Commonwealth possesses two assets for transportation and economic development that are truly the envy of every other state in the nation.
    • 00:06:46
      And of course, those two assets would be the International Air Gateway at Dulles and the International Ocean Gateway at Hampton Roads.
    • 00:06:53
      And on the slide before you, you simply have a reminder of the state-owned marine terminals located in three different localities in the Hampton Roads Harbor, Norfolk International Terminals, of course, in the city of Norfolk, Portsmouth Marine Terminal, and Newport News Marine Terminal.
    • 00:07:08
      You'll also see an artist's rendering of perhaps our most aggressive undertaking, the proposed Craney Island Marine Terminal, which frankly is proposed for land that doesn't exist today.
    • 00:07:19
      It would be approximately six to eight hundred acres of reclaimed river bottom adjacent to the Army Corps of Engineers' dredge disposal site at Craney Island.
    • 00:07:28
      But for today's purposes and today's conversation, you notice a very large star in the Shenandoah Valley, and it's appropriate that we're in the Shenandoah Room today.
    • 00:07:37
      That very large star represents a very unique asset and one that has a story that we love to tell, and I hope I'll tell it adequately in the next few moments, the Virginia Inland Port.
    • 00:07:49
      For those of you interested, we do receive a number of calls each year asking us how we manage to push container ships up the Shenandoah River, which of course we do not, but that'll become evident here in the next few moments.
    • 00:08:01
      Forgive me that this slide is not an exciting slide, but it contains quite a bit of useful information.
    • 00:08:06
      Just a very, very quick review.
    • 00:08:08
      If we turn the clock back 20 years to the late 1980s, we can understand what the Virginia Inland Port is and where it came from.
    • 00:08:15
      And if we do that and go back 20 years in time, I'll point out two very significant factors in our business.
    • 00:08:20
      Number one, the Port of Baltimore.
    • 00:08:23
      was the dominant container port in the mid-Atlantic in the 1980s, and Virginia, frankly, was playing second fiddle to the Port of Baltimore.
    • 00:08:32
      The other significant fact at that time is that Norfolk Southern only reached as far on the U.S. East Coast as the Port of Norfolk.
    • 00:08:41
      Norfolk was the northernmost port for Norfolk Southern at that time, of course, prior to the Conrail merger or acquisition.
    • 00:08:49
      So we both had a vested interest, when I say both, the Virginia Port Authority and Norfolk Southern, in expanding our footprint and expanding our marketplace in basically a four-state region, West Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and of course, Northern Virginia.
    • 00:09:05
      Twenty years later, that is still the bread and butter market for the Virginia Inland Port.
    • 00:09:10
      But at that time, 20 years ago, the Port of Baltimore was dominating cargo coming out of West Virginia, Maryland,
    • 00:09:16
      Pennsylvania and Northern Virginia.
    • 00:09:17
      So the question became, how could we extend the reach of the seaport in Hampton Roads with the hopes of siphoning off some of that truck traffic that was moving directly into Baltimore?
    • 00:09:28
      And at the risk of giving you a gross oversimplification, that was the concept behind establishing an intermodal rail facility between Front Royal and Winchester, in Cedarville, in fact, and trying to capture some of that traffic with a direct rail connection with Norfolk Southern Surface
    • 00:09:45
      to the state-owned marine terminals in Hampton Roads.
    • 00:09:48
      I certainly will not take you through each bullet on the slide, but you can see the original concept and some of the original goals behind the formation of the inland port.
    • 00:09:57
      And I would actually be remiss if you'll allow me to go back for a moment.
    • 00:10:00
      I certainly didn't give proper credit to two gentlemen who really, in fact, deserve the most credit, one being Bobby Bray, our executive director emeritus who had the vision
    • 00:10:10
      to pursue this facility, and of course Governor Beliles and the General Assembly who came alongside and strongly supported the idea and made the vision a reality.
    • 00:10:20
      Now if you forgive me, I'm going to skip this slide for a moment and come back to it.
    • 00:10:24
      I want to give you the micro view of the Inland Port today and then I'll back up and give you the macro view.
    • 00:10:29
      And forgive me, let's see if I can master the laser pointer.
    • 00:10:34
      Well, it's not very effective on that slide anyway, but of course, here in the center
    • 00:10:37
      of the slide, you'll see the Virginia Inland Port, which in fact is an intermodal rail route.
    • 00:10:42
      We receive, strip, and load trains on a daily basis.
    • 00:10:46
      This is a state-owned facility.
    • 00:10:48
      It represents approximately 160 acres, and the Norfolk Southern mainline is right here and services the facility.
    • 00:10:55
      Now, what I want to draw your attention to, and for those of you trying to get your bearings, this is 522 and 340 connecting Front Royal and Winchester.
    • 00:11:03
      You'll notice the surrounding facilities in close proximity to the Inland Port.
    • 00:11:07
      This is the DuPont Automotive Coatings Facility, and they have been a long-time customer of the Inland Port for international cargo.
    • 00:11:15
      They're the ideal customer because not only do they import, they also export.
    • 00:11:19
      So we handle their freight in both directions.
    • 00:11:21
      But as you look at the map, you see some other facilities that are much newer construction.
    • 00:11:25
      This is Cisco, not to be confused with the microchip people.
    • 00:11:28
      These are the restaurant supply folks out of Texas.
    • 00:11:32
      Down the road aways, you see almost a million square feet belonging to Family Dollar out of the Charlotte area, the retailer that we're all familiar with.
    • 00:11:41
      Here, you'll see Toray Plastics, a Japanese company.
    • 00:11:45
      Here, you'll see Ferguson Enterprises, now owned of course by Woolsey out of the UK.
    • 00:11:50
      This facility is actually a formerly bearing truck
    • 00:11:54
      An automotive joint venture, but this is now Interbank.
    • 00:11:57
      The folks out of Richmond that make the ice cream wafers for ice cream sandwiches that we all enjoy so much.
    • 00:12:04
      Almost without exception, these facilities, with the exception of perhaps Interbank, who we're working on by the way, everyone else there in the screen is a customer of the Virginia Inland Port.
    • 00:12:16
      They're utilizing that transportation asset to support their international freight needs.
    • 00:12:21
      and moving that freight of course by rail with Norfolk Southern.
    • 00:12:24
      Now if you'll allow me, I'll go back to the previous slide very quickly.
    • 00:12:27
      This is the story of the Inland Port today 20 years later.
    • 00:12:31
      It is an engine for economic development, but if I told you that 20 years ago that was our vision, I would be very disingenuous with you.
    • 00:12:39
      Our vision 20 years ago was simply to use the Inland Port as a transportation asset to capture freight moving adversely to us over competing ports.
    • 00:12:47
      Frankly, we floundered for the first four or five years of existence up in Front Royal.
    • 00:12:53
      We did not meet our expectations.
    • 00:12:54
      We did not meet our goals in the early 1990s.
    • 00:12:57
      It was only when we locked arms with the local, regional, and statewide economic development community to leverage this asset as an attraction for investment.
    • 00:13:08
      that the Virginia Inland Port really hit its stride and you can see I realize at a distance in the back of the room it may be very difficult to read all the names on the map but I've highlighted some of them in the previous slide.
    • 00:13:20
      Family Dollar was one of the first to come up and make a significant investment that generated a tremendous amount of freight over the Inland Port and now 20 years later
    • 00:13:28
      The Inland Port continues to act as a very strong magnet for investment in and around the Shenandoah Valley.
    • 00:13:34
      And the two most recent examples I would share with you that have been huge for Virginia and huge for the port would be Home Depot, who built 750,000 square feet within about five miles of the Inland Port and is now our single largest customer at the Inland Port.
    • 00:13:49
      And the most recent success is with a company called Osborne Hesti Logistics.
    • 00:13:54
      But they have built their facility to support one particular customer, a customer with some notoriety, Red Bull.
    • 00:14:02
      Red Bull energy drinks, believe it or not, I won't give you the entire history, but the product is all made in Europe, imported to the United States, and they have now become our second largest customer at the Inland Port.
    • 00:14:13
      Now, I cannot tell you that every one of the investments you see on that slide are directly related to the Inland Port.
    • 00:14:19
      But I can tell you that the majority of them, in some way, are related to the present.
    • 00:14:24
      of the Virginia Island Port and the ability to leverage that transportation asset.
    • 00:14:30
      Last year, we handled nearly 31,000 containers in the calendar year.
    • 00:14:34
      You can see the Norfolk Southern locomotive feature there and to the right in the lower right-hand corner.
    • 00:14:39
      That's actually Norfolk International Terminal.
    • 00:14:41
      That's the seaport connection.
    • 00:14:42
      Every Inland Port train originates and terminates at Norfolk International Terminals and then of course moves on its way up through Virginia along the Manassas Line and into Front Royal.
    • 00:14:53
      I'm very pleased to say that with two months to go in 2007, we are projecting that we will grow approximately 10% in container volume at the Inland Port this year.
    • 00:15:04
      We should come close, if not exceed, 33,000 to 34,000 units at the Inland Port for the calendar year and we're very pleased with that.
    • 00:15:12
      And you can see that it's truly next day service for import containers leaving Norfolk International Terminals.
    • 00:15:18
      They would leave at 5 p.m. and move overnight and be available to the customers in the Shenandoah Valley early the next morning.
    • 00:15:25
      So you can truly pick your freight up the next day.
    • 00:15:27
      And of course, the reverse coming down for export cargo being loaded to vessels in the Port of Hampton Roads.
    • 00:15:34
      I certainly won't take you through all these bullets, but these are just some of the services that are available, some of the services that we provide at the Virginia Inland Port.
    • 00:15:42
      It is designated as a U.S. Customs Port of Entry.
    • 00:15:45
      It's also designated as a free trade zone, although we have one customer for TESSA that you may be familiar with that's activated a subzone not on the property, but in the neighborhood, so to speak, and they are actually taking advantage of some free trade zone services.
    • 00:16:00
      And you also get a flavoring there of the major commodities.
    • 00:16:02
      In the early days, we lived with poultry and export logs and lumber.
    • 00:16:06
      And today, we still live with poultry and export logs and lumber.
    • 00:16:10
      But frankly, now the imported retail merchandise that I alluded to for the Home Depots, for the Family Dollars, for the Red Bulls has exceeded our export volume.
    • 00:16:20
      But those are the leading commodities that we're handling through the Inland Port today.
    • 00:16:25
      And again, just the flavoring of some of the companies that you saw in that view from 35,000 square feet.
    • 00:16:30
      Now you can actually see some of the names of the companies that have located in the valley.
    • 00:16:35
      And I would once again reinforce the message that we certainly do not stand before you to take full credit for these investments.
    • 00:16:40
      But we're very pleased to say that in most cases, the Inland Port was a factor, a positive factor in the decisions of these companies to either locate or expand their presence in the valley.
    • 00:16:51
      And the last slide I have for you is really
    • 00:16:53
      Stealing some thunder, perhaps, from Bobby Bray and Jerry Bridges, our new executive director, who I believe you'll hear from as the conference unfolds over the next few days.
    • 00:17:02
      Virginia has truly been discovered over the last decade as an ideal location, not just the Shenandoah Valley, but truly statewide as a mecca for import distribution, internationally related distribution.
    • 00:17:15
      And you see that these success stories are not isolated to any one region of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:17:19
      It's truly widespread all over the Commonwealth.
    • 00:17:21
      It's a great success story.
    • 00:17:23
      for the Port and for the Commonwealth.
    • 00:17:25
      And this has been the driving factor in our growth.
    • 00:17:28
      I wish Dana Dickens were here because it was near and dear to my heart when he was mayor of Suffolk.
    • 00:17:33
      We broke ground on the Target stores import warehouse in the city of Suffolk, which now approaches almost 2 million square feet and employs hundreds of people with the equivalent of high school diplomas or GEDs at a wage that exceeds $12 an hour.
    • 00:17:48
      So it's a very attractive, clean investment.
    • 00:17:51
      And as you can see, it's spread all over Virginia.
    • 00:17:53
      and benefits all of us.
    • 00:17:54
      So with that, Mr. Secretary, if it's appropriate, I'd be happy to entertain any questions.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:00
      Okay.
    • 00:18:00
      Thank you, Mr. Edwards.
    • 00:18:02
      Mr. Tucker, did you want to add just a little anecdote at the end and then we'll take questions?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:10
      I just want to make a couple of comments.
    • 00:18:12
      First, I want to update a little bit about our review of the Roanoke Intermodal Facility.
    • 00:18:17
      But before I do that, I want to comment because when you sit and listen to this presentation,
    • 00:18:22
      It sort of reflects on the thought process that we have when we started looking at detail at the Roanoke-Inamoto facility.
    • 00:18:30
      As Mr. Edwards was talking, we really was talking about in terms of the facility, you have to start thinking about it really when you talk about the economic benefit, direct, indirect, and the biggest one is induced benefits that occur as a result of locating it.
    • 00:18:47
      And it's really a dynamic process as you start looking at how these ports develop over time.
    • 00:18:54
      It is not necessarily the direct or indirect benefit that accrues as a result of having it, but it's the induced.
    • 00:19:00
      The induced is the additional businesses and business activity that is captured as a result.
    • 00:19:06
      That represents an excellent example.
    • 00:19:08
      And as we are looking at the Roanoke Automotive facility, we're sort of seeing some of that preliminary analysis.
    • 00:19:14
      And I think over the upcoming month or so, we'll be talking about it.
    • 00:19:17
      In terms of timeline for the Rono Intermodo facility, we've talked about the fact that we wanted to do some additional due diligence.
    • 00:19:24
      We've done two bits of due diligence.
    • 00:19:27
      One, we've in the process of finalizing an economic impact analysis that will provide for us the types of information that we've heard in the presentation today.
    • 00:19:36
      Second, we've completed some due diligence in terms of reaffirmation of costs, project estimates.
    • 00:19:42
      We are confident that over the next 30 days or so, we're going to be in a position to complete our review.
    • 00:19:47
      and make final determinations about that project.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:52
      I just wanted to again put that a little bit in context because I think the Inland Port and those of you who are around in the mid to late 80s, this concept did not exactly take off and it has taken off in very dramatic ways but in a very different direction than anyone would have guessed.
    • 00:20:11
      And it's hard to imagine today that the Port of Baltimore has a major competitor.
    • 00:20:16
      And that is just such a profound change in the nature of international freight movement.
    • 00:20:22
      Very significant.
    • 00:20:24
      Mr. Edwards is here to answer any questions.
    • 00:20:26
      And Mr. Edwards?
    • 00:20:28
      Ms. McCarthy.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:29
      Thank you, Mr. Edwards.
    • 00:20:31
      Is all the traffic back and forth by rail?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:20:37
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:20:37
      Now, of course, any customer in the Valley, as the gentleman behind me from Norfolk Southern knows, on a daily basis, we're competing with the truck market.
    • 00:20:44
      And of course, in the Port of Hampton Roads, we rely heavily on our trucking partners, so we dance a delicate dance here.
    • 00:20:50
      But for the volume that a company like Home Depot moves, try to secure the necessary truck power to cover those moves is a challenge.
    • 00:20:57
      Being able to move higher volumes by Norfolk Southern Rail is very attractive to them.
    • 00:21:03
      In rare instances, it's not
    • 00:21:06
      Let me back up.
    • 00:21:06
      It's not unusual for our Inland Port customers to occasionally supplement their transportation with trucking moves for freight that may be behind schedule or just in time.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:15
      And how many trains daily go back and forth?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:21:19
      It's actually a dedicated train for the Inland Port now.
    • 00:21:22
      It's not part of a larger train set.
    • 00:21:24
      It is one train in and out per day.
    • 00:21:27
      Obviously, the train arrives and discharges import cargo.
    • 00:21:30
      and loads on export cargo for the return trip to Hampton Roads.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:34
      And would there be plans to expand that going forward?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:21:37
      Actually, our partners at Norfolk Southern have supported us in great fashion because up until about a year and a half ago, the Inland Port road on a larger, the Inland Port freight was placed on a larger train that continued on to Harrisburg and Cleveland and Detroit.
    • 00:21:50
      But because of the growth at the Inland Port, Norfolk Southern agreed that it was sufficient, the volume was sufficient to warrant a dedicated train.
    • 00:21:58
      So I would say if you were very, very pleased
    • 00:22:00
      with the dedicated train that we have today, and there's additional capacity.
    • 00:22:04
      That train is not matched out.
    • 00:22:05
      There's room to grow on that train.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:07
      Great.
    • 00:22:08
      Thank you.
    • 00:22:09
      Sir.
    • 00:22:09
      Mr. Davis.
    • 00:22:10
      Mr. Secretary, which of the routes does that take?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:22:12
      Do they go up the valleys?
    • 00:22:14
      Do they go to Manassas and across?
    • 00:22:15
      Good question, and I'll give you my best answer.
    • 00:22:18
      The train heads west out of Hampton Roads to Lynchburg, and it's in Lynchburg it hangs a right.
    • 00:22:24
      and moves up the NS line from Lynchburg moving all the way north and then through Manassas in the front row.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:31
      So it doesn't use the Shenandoah Valley route, it uses the central Virginia route.
    • 00:22:35
      Correct.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:36
      Does everybody understand that?
    • 00:22:37
      That's a very significant point.
    • 00:22:39
      The train comes all the way to Lynchburg?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:22:41
      Yes, sir.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:41
      Why is that?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:22:43
      I believe, and I certainly wouldn't put anyone from north or southern in the room on the spot, but I believe it's a matter of that's how the track runs.
    • 00:22:50
      That's the most advantageous route for them to utilize
    • 00:22:54
      Believe me, from our perspective, even though that may seem slightly out of route, so to speak, the timeliness of that train is quite sufficient for our customers.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:04
      And if I might just kind of simplify the answer even a little bit more, sometimes you go further on an interstate highway rather than stop and go with a whole lot of intersections on the way.
    • 00:23:13
      I think there's a simple person's way of looking at it, which is the way I like to look at things.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:19
      And the other aspect, Mr. Secretary, is that
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:22
      I noticed we've been talking about a short spur from Culpepper to Front Royal.
    • 00:23:33
      It's very easy looking at the map to see the advantages that would have for the inland port if that could be achieved.
    • 00:23:39
      because that would cut off the leg of the three-sided triangle.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:23:43
      Certainly.
    • 00:23:43
      One of the ironies is in Virginia, of course, everything is driven by economics.
    • 00:23:47
      And the customers that I mentioned every day are considering their trucking costs versus the rail costs of using the Virginia Inland Port.
    • 00:23:54
      And once you move 50 to 60 miles south of Front Royal, coming down into Virginia, you're reaching an area where it's more attractive for the customer to truck the freight simply because there's a cost in savings.
    • 00:24:07
      So there is a fine line of where the Inland Port is competitive and where it is not.
    • 00:24:13
      And certainly any extension of the rail is something that merits consideration.
    • 00:24:17
      Intermodal is somewhat unique.
    • 00:24:18
      It's not like carload freight, but it's certainly something we'd be interested in discussing.
    • 00:24:23
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:24
      Yeah, as the price of a barrel of oil approaches $100 and gasoline and diesel well over $3, how is it still rising?
    • 00:24:34
      I'm just curious how you think that's going
    • 00:24:37
      That's an excellent question.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:24:47
      I would say that in the port today, every major trucker that we're doing business with has a fuel surcharge in place that they charge their customers.
    • 00:24:56
      In the same way, all of the major Class 1 railroads in the United States have an established formula for calculating a fuel surcharge that they also pass on to their customers.
    • 00:25:05
      In the case of the Inland Port, Norfolk Southern sees us, the Virginia Port Authority, as their customer.
    • 00:25:11
      It's a wholesale service.
    • 00:25:12
      If you as a freight owner were to call Norfolk Southern today and say, I'd like a rate for Front Royal, what they will diplomatically tell you is, you need to call the Virginia Port Authority and they'll be happy to give you a rate.
    • 00:25:21
      So we have tariff rates in place.
    • 00:25:23
      That's public information.
    • 00:25:24
      But added to those tariff rates would be the current fuel surcharge that Northern Southern is carrying throughout their network.
    • 00:25:30
      It's not unique to Front Royal.
    • 00:25:32
      It's network-wide.
    • 00:25:33
      And again, as they compete with trucks on a daily basis, those trucking companies also have a fuel surcharge.
    • 00:25:39
      So I understand your question.
    • 00:25:42
      It's certainly a concern.
    • 00:25:44
      And this may be an oversimplification.
    • 00:25:45
      As fuel rises, the surcharge rises for both railroads and trucking companies.
    • 00:25:49
      And so the customer doesn't really gain an inherent advantage
    • 00:25:53
      switching from one mode to another, he's facing that surcharge in either case.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:56
      Isn't the rail... Mr. Schwartz, what I might suggest, because he's representing the ports of Norfolk Southern here, is a rail operator, and I would encourage you to ask those exact same questions to Norfolk Southern.
    • 00:26:08
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:26:09
      Okay, fine.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:11
      Mr. McCarthy.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:12
      Maybe I missed it, and I apologize if I didn't, but just looking at the rail map, is there a good reason why
    • 00:26:20
      The train takes a right turn at Lynchburg instead of going over to the 81 corridor and going up that route?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:26:26
      I certainly don't want to give you the impression that I'm dodging your question.
    • 00:26:28
      I'm not.
    • 00:26:29
      This is one of those, I believe the train has run the Lynchburg route literally since its inception.
    • 00:26:35
      And I'm afraid I don't have a good reason for you why they choose that route versus the I-81 route.
    • 00:26:40
      And I hate to say, well, I'll pass that to Norfolk Southern.
    • 00:26:42
      But in this case, I must.
    • 00:26:43
      You'll have to pose that question to them.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:44
      And that probably is a more, again, a more appropriate question.
    • 00:26:48
      The Port of Virginia is a buyer of these services, not the provider.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:52
      Well, I noticed it goes right through Mr. Davies' hometown, so that's probably a factor.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:58
      Mr. Chairman, I take it that at the beginning, most of your business was going from the port to, I mean, from the inland port to the port.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:27:09
      Correct.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:09
      In terms of maybe cargo value or containers
    • 00:27:14
      You mentioned it was becoming more equal, in other words, more commerce coming back.
    • 00:27:21
      Is that a trend you see continuing?
    • 00:27:23
      Is that a good thing?
    • 00:27:25
      Do you still send back cars empty?
    • 00:27:28
      How does that work?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:27:30
      That's an excellent question, and I'll try to give you a quick answer.
    • 00:27:32
      You're absolutely right.
    • 00:27:33
      In the early days of the Virginia Inland Court, we were almost exclusively export freight.
    • 00:27:38
      The ratio was almost 9 to 1.
    • 00:27:40
      export versus any imports we had arriving and it was driven by poultry and it was driven by forest products.
    • 00:27:46
      In the mid 1990s when we finally began to leverage the Inland Port with our partners in economic development as a great spot for distribution and I'll use Family Dollar as an example.
    • 00:27:55
      Family Dollar built almost a million square feet a half a mile from the Inland Port and they began to move about 1,500 to 2,000 import containers up on the train.
    • 00:28:06
      In a way that changed everything.
    • 00:28:07
      That
    • 00:28:08
      Open the floodgates a little bit, and now with Home Depot moving literally thousands of import containers up on the train, and the new piece of business with Red Bull, which also represents thousands of import containers moving up on the train, the market has flip-flopped.
    • 00:28:21
      We are now much more heavily weighted in terms of import loads.
    • 00:28:25
      Now, as a port representative, I can set my patriotism aside and say, I just want your business, whether it's import, export, it doesn't make any difference to me.
    • 00:28:33
      As a citizen, you can step back and begin to talk about trade imbalances and what's happened to U.S. exports, and that's an important conversation as well.
    • 00:28:40
      But the good news for Virginia companies is as imports grow, and we certainly expect imports to continue to grow at Front Royal, it creates a pool of available equipment, ocean containers, that can then be utilized by Virginia exporters without having to pay the transportation cost of going down to Norfolk to get them.
    • 00:28:57
      So if we can get the steamship lines to partner with us on that, which is no mean feat from time to time, you can, in effect, match freight.
    • 00:29:05
      You have import freight arriving.
    • 00:29:06
      You can turn that equipment for export, which is better from North or Southern's perspective in terms of car utilization.
    • 00:29:12
      Because now, hopefully, you're moving loads in both directions.
    • 00:29:14
      And in fact, the statistics that I have would indicate that our empty movement of containers has actually declined at Front Royal because of that better utilization.
    • 00:29:22
      And we're very pleased by that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:26
      Any other questions?
    • 00:29:28
      I just have one question.
    • 00:29:29
      Does the Inland Port serve the APM facility?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:29:33
      That's an excellent question, and it's a question that I don't have the answer to yet, and I would tell you that you'll hear more, of course, about the APM investment, I'm sure, when Mr. Bridges and Mr. Bray present to the conference.
    • 00:29:45
      APM is the largest, Marist, part of the APM family, as many of you know, is the largest steamship line in the world.
    • 00:29:51
      And so nearly all of the customers that I've referenced in the last few moments
    • 00:29:55
      use Maersk or AP Molar Maersk in some fashion to support their transportation needs.
    • 00:30:00
      But Maersk is not part of the state network as the Secretary knows.
    • 00:30:04
      They have their own dedicated terminal.
    • 00:30:05
      It is accessible by both Norfolk Southern and CSX.
    • 00:30:08
      So there's no operational hurdle to prevent APM from utilizing the Inland Port by rail.
    • 00:30:15
      But there are a number of commercial issues that must be worked out internally between the Virginia Port Authority, Virginia International Terminals and APM
    • 00:30:24
      to make it work because today the economic model at the Inland Port is built on a movement through the state-owned marine terminals.
    • 00:30:31
      If you take that movement outside the state-owned marine terminals to a privately-owned terminal, it creates some pricing issues that we're dealing with right now because many Marist customers would like to use the Inland Port train and we would like them to be able to use the Inland Port train.
    • 00:30:46
      So that's an issue that we're addressing as we go forward.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:49
      Would it be fair to say that this is
    • 00:30:52
      Part and parcel of the competition.
    • 00:30:54
      Now the VPA is in a competitive footing with APM, and this is part of how business is changing.
    • 00:30:59
      Is that fair?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:31:00
      I think that's a very fair statement, sir.
    • 00:31:02
      Okay.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:03
      Thank you.
    • 00:31:03
      Any other questions or comments?
    • 00:31:05
      Thank you for a great presentation.
    • 00:31:07
      Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.
    • 00:31:09
      The next item on the agenda, once again, Dr. Gary Allen, Director of Research Technology and Innovation at the Department of Transportation.
    • 00:31:18
      is going to give us an update on some legislative studies.
    • 00:31:22
      I believe there are a total of three that were mandated by the last General Assembly.
    • 00:31:28
      And while Dr. Allen is talking about those, a little bit of history is in order.
    • 00:31:34
      Every year there are requests to either extend or expand overweight truck restrictions in the Commonwealth.
    • 00:31:44
      Many times those are for very legitimate
    • 00:31:47
      either public or economic development purposes.
    • 00:31:51
      But one of the things also in the session last environment where we made such an issue of and I think successfully educated the General Assembly on the cost of maintaining our highway system and our bridges.
    • 00:32:03
      So the resolution in some cases was to do some enhanced fees or to do studies
    • 00:32:10
      in some cases do both.
    • 00:32:11
      And so Dr. Allen is here to give us a background and overview of three of those studies.
    • 00:32:17
      And I believe there'll be one more coming after this one, which will be the most global and comprehensive yet to come.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:32:23
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:32:25
      I'll try to move through this relatively quickly because I know you have a full agenda this afternoon.
    • 00:32:30
      The slide that I have presently gives you a summary of the three bills
    • 00:32:36
      that Secretary Homer referred to.
    • 00:32:38
      The first bill, House Bill 2917, applies to what are called sand and gravel trucks in the cold, severance counties in southwest Virginia.
    • 00:32:49
      Those are mainly three or four-axle single-unit trucks.
    • 00:32:53
      Their payload, of course, is crushed stone, sand, and gravel.
    • 00:32:57
      And the overweight tolerance is between 5,000 and 11,000 pounds.
    • 00:33:03
      and then there's more tolerance for five-axle vehicles.
    • 00:33:09
      There is no permit fee for those overweight vehicles at all.
    • 00:33:15
      It does apply to the seven counties in Southwest Virginia and that legislation was actually put in place in 1999 to provide a safety net in the event that coal haulers had difficulty with the economy.
    • 00:33:32
      There was a downturn in the economy.
    • 00:33:34
      The argument was they could haul sand and gravel.
    • 00:33:37
      And if their trucks were large enough to haul it, we ought to be able to allow them to do it from an economic standpoint.
    • 00:33:44
      House Bill 1645, pipe cleaning trucks.
    • 00:33:47
      That's pipe cleaning and hydro excavation trucks.
    • 00:33:51
      Those are three axles, single unit trucks.
    • 00:33:53
      The tolerance there was to allow an additional 10,000 pounds.
    • 00:33:57
      There's a very small number of these trucks.
    • 00:33:59
      Probably 20 to 30.
    • 00:34:02
      in Virginia.
    • 00:34:04
      Again, there's no permit that is paid for that.
    • 00:34:08
      Senate Bill 1321, petroleum tank trucks, those are what we consider to be the heating oil trucks, they're delivering oil to homes, that sort of thing.
    • 00:34:20
      They will leave their point of departure and as they move along, they will offload and reduce weight as they move.
    • 00:34:30
      A compromise was struck with this group of the industry to pay a one-time, one-year fee of $800 to be allowed to haul 4,000 pounds efficiently in these tank wagons.
    • 00:34:46
      So that was a fairly substantial fee for that group of trucks.
    • 00:34:55
      The legislative requirements for these three bills are that for
    • 00:34:59
      House Bill 2917 and 1645, the Department is to recommend legislation to the General Assembly by the 1st of December.
    • 00:35:08
      And for Senate Bill 1321 on the tank wagons, it actually says that VDOT is to implement a permanent fee structure by the 1st of July of 2008 in consultation with Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:35:23
      There is no Administrative Process Act requirement for Senate Bill 1321.
    • 00:35:30
      In order to address these three pieces of legislation, the Research Council was charged with conducting some engineering analysis.
    • 00:35:41
      We have undertaken that to estimate the additional maintenance costs of overweight vehicles operating under permits.
    • 00:35:50
      The focus is on the added weight-related pavement damage.
    • 00:35:54
      Higher axle weights actually do increase pavement damage.
    • 00:35:58
      There's ample scientific evidence for that.
    • 00:36:01
      It's what we call a power function.
    • 00:36:03
      A very small increase in axle weights can cause a relatively large increase in how rapidly pavements wear out.
    • 00:36:14
      In terms of the analysis, the modeling approach that we took is conservative in terms of estimating total damage because we did not have
    • 00:36:24
      The time to truly model structures the way we would have liked to.
    • 00:36:29
      Structures, the engineering related to structures design is different because it is primarily related to gross weights and some spacing of the axles.
    • 00:36:40
      Whereas the pavement is primarily related to axle weights.
    • 00:36:46
      In terms of the study approach, the Research Council
    • 00:36:51
      looked at national models, standard engineering design concepts, and developed a pavement damage model that uses the engineering pavement design concept of an 18,000 pound equivalent single axle load, affectionately called an ESAL, or an ESAL.
    • 00:37:14
      Pavements are actually designed to carry a certain number of these single axle loads over the life of the pavement.
    • 00:37:20
      So the more loads you apply, the more rapidly the pavement will wear out.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:27
      That's a simple engineering fact.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:37:31
      We actually calculated the overweight under permit versus the non-overweight e-sales for each truck type.
    • 00:37:39
      We identified the percent of the budgeted FY07 maintenance costs that were attributable to axle loads, things that are called common costs,
    • 00:37:49
      to all vehicles such as snow removal and then costs that are attributable to specific kinds of vehicles such as bus stops or commuter parking lots or things of that nature that we could identify as being the result of a particular type of vehicle.
    • 00:38:10
      We calculated the average, or excuse me, the additional FY07 maintenance costs due to the overweight operating under a permit
    • 00:38:18
      E. Salz for each truck.
    • 00:38:22
      We also are in the process, at the request of Secretary Homer, we're in the process of doing a cost responsibility study that's a bit broader, that is looking at all types of vehicles.
    • 00:38:38
      The focus is on maintenance.
    • 00:38:41
      It is on maintenance.
    • 00:38:42
      It does not include construction, and we're probably going to need to include construction
    • 00:38:48
      in order to get a full-blown picture of what's going on there.
    • 00:38:54
      We do expect to have a draft report very soon, certainly before the end of the year.
    • 00:39:01
      In terms of the findings to this point regarding the three pieces of legislation, as the Secretary pointed out, businesses actually seek overweight exemptions on a case-by-case basis to improve their business efficiency,
    • 00:39:17
      and to take advantage of the full payload capacity of larger trucks.
    • 00:39:21
      I'm sure you have noticed that trucks get larger and larger.
    • 00:39:27
      In a lot of instances, the exceptions are requested because a particular business type will argue that there are already lots of exemptions or exceptions in the code and why should we be treated any differently?
    • 00:39:44
      We need the same advantage.
    • 00:39:46
      and usually those are granted without significant additional cost.
    • 00:39:53
      The calculation of the annual added maintenance cost due to operating overweight under permit is sensitive to the ESAL increase and to the estimates of the mileages that are traveled by these trucks.
    • 00:40:07
      The same approach can be used to estimate the added maintenance cost of a single overweight trip through standard engineering approach.
    • 00:40:16
      What are some of the findings that jumped out at us?
    • 00:40:18
      Well, in the coal severance counties, each of the companies pay a coal severance tax that goes back to the county.
    • 00:40:30
      But the market conditions that were in place in 1999 are not the same market conditions that are in place now.
    • 00:40:40
      And in fact, the sand and gravel overweight exemption
    • 00:40:44
      doesn't appear to provide a safety net for the coal haulers and downturns.
    • 00:40:48
      The reason for that is because the trucks that are being used primarily to haul coal now are no longer those three-axle or two-axle single-unit vehicles.
    • 00:40:59
      They're very different.
    • 00:41:01
      They're very different.
    • 00:41:03
      Instead, what's happening is that this exception benefits the gas well drillers, which is a very strong market, in southwest Virginia.
    • 00:41:13
      Now, certainly you can make the policy decision to exempt them to subsidize that particular industry.
    • 00:41:23
      But we just are pointing out that that's what's going on at this time rather than the original intention of the legislation.
    • 00:41:32
      In terms of the results of the cost analysis, I'll call your attention to this table that I'm showing right now.
    • 00:41:39
      I've listed on the left-hand side
    • 00:41:42
      Just the categories of trucks that are relevant to the three pieces of legislation in question.
    • 00:41:50
      The first two, the three axle single unit tandems and the four axle single unit triaxles really are the trucks that are referenced in the 1999 legislation and in the request to look at sand and gravel haulers as an exemption.
    • 00:42:07
      They actually get to haul the three axles 60,000 pounds rather than a standard three axle single unit tandem in the rest of the state, which can haul 49,000.
    • 00:42:20
      You can see the annual estimate of miles is 40,000, the added E-Sails is 0.7, and the added maintenance cost is $1,023 a year.
    • 00:42:30
      Pretty substantial cost.
    • 00:42:32
      You can notice the four axle vehicles, even though they
    • 00:42:36
      are allowed to haul a higher weight because they're spreading the weight over more axles.
    • 00:42:43
      The e-sals go down, the damage function is less, and the cost is $675.
    • 00:42:49
      That's what we would estimate it to be.
    • 00:42:53
      The next two categories, the three-axle single-unit tandems for pipe cleaning and the tandems for hydro excavation,
    • 00:43:02
      applied to the second piece of legislation, which is House Bill 1645.
    • 00:43:07
      You can see there what the fee structure is for the three-axle.
    • 00:43:12
      It's $229.
    • 00:43:14
      And for the three-axle for hydro excavation, it's only $85.
    • 00:43:19
      That has to do again with the estimated ease-outs.
    • 00:43:23
      The final row is the two-axle single-unit petroleum tank wagons.
    • 00:43:28
      You can see that the legislation allowed them to go from 32,000 pounds to 36,000, annual miles about 26,000.
    • 00:43:38
      The cost estimated is $227.
    • 00:43:40
      I'd also point out to you that this particular group in the marketplace agreed to pay $800 for a one-year fee.
    • 00:43:53
      So that's the fee they struck.
    • 00:43:54
      What we've estimated is a smaller amount.
    • 00:43:59
      You'll recall that we do have to propose some legislation to the General Assembly by the first of December.
    • 00:44:06
      There's a couple options here that we've come up with.
    • 00:44:10
      One is to establish fees only for the three specific types of trucks or haulers using the added maintenance cost approach.
    • 00:44:18
      and then update this, we propose biannually, you might want to do it every four years to reflect VDOT maintenance cost experiences.
    • 00:44:27
      Option B is to recognize that if you take a look at all of the sections of the code that apply to different categories of haulers, you will see numerous exemptions for no-cost overweight permits.
    • 00:44:43
      What we're proposing is you might want to actually
    • 00:44:47
      Let's take a more comprehensive view.
    • 00:44:49
      You might want to establish fees in the same way for all haulers that are currently eligible for no-cost overweight permits.
    • 00:44:58
      We are also proposing that you exempt both options from the Administrative Process Act.
    • 00:45:02
      Mr. Secretary, that completes my briefing.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:06
      Thank you, Dr. Allen.
    • 00:45:07
      Questions or comments?
    • 00:45:09
      Mr. King.
    • 00:45:10
      Is that added cost, added maintenance cost per mile, per year, per lane mile travel?
    • 00:45:15
      What is that?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:45:16
      The added cost that is in the table, that would be an annual fee for the permit to operate at those additional weights.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:27
      Excuse me, clarification.
    • 00:45:28
      Is that per truck?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:45:30
      That is per truck.
    • 00:45:32
      Per truck.
    • 00:45:33
      Per hauler.
    • 00:45:35
      Per truck.
    • 00:45:35
      Yes, sir.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:36
      Gary, would there be a way to estimate of all the haulers, how many are, I get a no see, is it weight exemption?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:45:46
      We can estimate that.
    • 00:45:47
      We can work with DMV to do that.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 00:45:49
      I mean, we don't have a kind of speed of the math.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:45:53
      We do not have it at the present time, but I'm sure we could come up with an estimate.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:56
      Chairman, I believe you found that increasing rather rapidly with the increase in the drillings that's going on for gas.
    • 00:46:03
      Probably a growing number as we talk.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:09
      Gary, you talked about the all-in maintenance cost.
    • 00:46:15
      Does that maintenance cost include sort of the long-term capital cost of replacement of the pavement because of the additional wear?
    • 00:46:30
      Am I correct in understanding?
    • 00:46:31
      In other words, that's factored in, is the cost of...
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:46:35
      The cost data that we were looking at is the actual maintenance
    • 00:46:40
      Let me just make sure, let me just ask it slightly differently.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:59
      Because of the added weight, you've got to do more over a period of time to maintain that roadway because of the deterioration.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:47:07
      You probably would do it quicker.
    • 00:47:10
      Because what you in essence do is you use up service life more quickly than you might have anticipated.
    • 00:47:20
      That's the best way of thinking.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:23
      And again, I think, because your question is a very important one, and there's a distinction between ordinary maintenance and capital replacement.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:31
      Right, that's what I'm trying to figure out.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:33
      And if I'm understanding this right, this talks about ordinary maintenance just for pavements.
    • 00:47:38
      You don't go to structures, right?
    • 00:47:40
      So this does not touch bridges, which is a very important point.
    • 00:47:44
      That's right.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:45
      Well, just to follow up a little bit more, because I don't think I understand it yet, Gary.
    • 00:47:50
      If that means that you're going to complete the service more quickly, does that mean you're going to replace, I'm trying to figure, does that shorten the useful life?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:48:03
      You probably would do overlays sooner.
    • 00:48:07
      You may have to do
    • 00:48:10
      A little bit heavier maintenance sooner because you did not anticipate that the pavement would have a shorter life.
    • 00:48:20
      You've designed it for a certain number of e-sals and when those e-sals are applied to that pavement, it's time to overlay it, refurbish it, do whatever is necessary.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:31
      And does the formula that you use to come up with these numbers reflect that reality?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:48:38
      That's what it attempts to do, yes sir.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:40
      Yes sir.
    • 00:48:42
      If we come with a formula for fees or additional charges for permits to go overweight in these regions, the monies collected from that, do we anticipate requiring monies collected from that go back to the maintenance program in that region or what do we do?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:48:57
      The way that we envision the legislation being drafted is that all that money would be returned to the highway maintenance and operating fund.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:08
      I would add that historically many of those counties have gone to DMV or when VDOT actually managed the permit program it went to support the permit program so the code today is inconsistent on that matter but the genesis of this was the maintenance impact and so I think it would be logical and appropriate and consistent to say it should go to the highway maintenance and operating plan and actually probably
    • 00:49:35
      if there's a geographical concentration of that to keep it in those areas as well.
    • 00:49:42
      But General Assembly may have, we make recommendations, they may choose to go with a different approach to how the monies would be distributed or used if there were indeed to be some kind of fee increase.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:54
      Mr. Secretary, have you got an aggregate number of what this adds up to on an annual basis?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:50:02
      No, we have not done that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:06
      Mr. Chairman, the term overweight seems to be a relative term.
    • 00:50:10
      In other words, we define a weight and then we say you're over that weight.
    • 00:50:13
      So are we in a trap here where we've either under defined or over defined and we're under penalizing or over being or I mean, this is a relative balance as opposed to an absolute.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:50:28
      Yes, it may be a confusing term.
    • 00:50:33
      That's why I tried to use the term
    • 00:50:37
      Overweight operating under permit, overweight simply compared to the standard legislation which talks about the bridge formula which establishes gross and axle weights for both front and rear axles for virtually every configuration of hauler in the commonwealth.
    • 00:50:59
      So it's overweight as compared to that thing.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:03
      So are we caught, Mr. Chairman, in a sort of a time warp here where the technologies of the trucks, the standards we're building our roads to, the way they're used, I mean, these just aren't phased properly?
    • 00:51:15
      Or is this just a, is that just three different systems that aren't responding at the same time to?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:51:23
      Maybe three systems not responding at the same time.
    • 00:51:27
      I think legislation often lags market conditions
    • 00:51:32
      and technology and those usually are the impetus for changing legislation.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:41
      I'm sorry, Mr. Secretary, but what about bridges?
    • 00:51:43
      How does this affect bridges and the fare replacement schedules?
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:51:47
      We did only minimal work looking at how these weights affect structures.
    • 00:51:56
      We simply did not have the time to do that.
    • 00:51:58
      That's why
    • 00:51:59
      That's why I believe that the estimates we have come up with are conservative in their approach because it focuses primarily on pavements, not on structures.
    • 00:52:12
      Now with respect to structures, the thing that we do know is that we can post a structure to ensure that we maintain the safety and the integrity of that structure.
    • 00:52:26
      What you find in the truck legislation
    • 00:52:29
      is that there's been a lot of thought that is in the engineering analysis that has gone into establishing the gross weights for certain axle configurations as they relate to the bridge formula.
    • 00:52:42
      However, since the chief engineer's in the room, I'm going to defer to the chief engineer on those kinds of questions because I think he's the right person.
    • 00:52:52
      He's got two letters behind his name, so I'll defer to him.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:57
      This is a really important question, because if the bridges are having to be posted five years sooner than they might otherwise have had to be, that's a real cost to the Commonwealth.
    • 00:53:15
      And I guess that's what I'm trying to get a grip on is, are we measuring the effect of these overweight vehicles on our bridge replacement strategy, for example?
    • 00:53:26
      I mean, the fact that we don't have an aggregate number of how much this is costing us every year concerns me a lot, and even more so with respect to bridges.
    • 00:53:36
      So, Mr. Curley, I sure hope you can enlighten us on that one.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:53:40
      I'm going to invite Dr. Gomez to come up here.
    • 00:53:42
      The only thing I'll say is that our standard design on bridges until the last few years was HS20-44.
    • 00:53:54
      And 44 means 1944 is when that loading was put in.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:53:59
      It's a very conservative loading.
    • 00:54:02
      The new bridge code changes that loading.
    • 00:54:05
      So I don't know exactly, Jose, I don't know if you have anything that you can add.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:54:12
      I don't know of any studies that have a correlation on that view.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:54:21
      Everyone here probably traveled down the I-81 corridor today to get here.
    • 00:54:24
      And you traveled across many bridges.
    • 00:54:26
      And I stand here before you to say that every bridge on that corridor is unique.
    • 00:54:30
      It's unique in the details of construction.
    • 00:54:33
      And that alone sets every bridge apart.
    • 00:54:37
      So every bridge that sees this overweight vehicle will behave differently.
    • 00:54:42
      And it's those details that force us to make every decision on every bridge unique because every bridge is unique.
    • 00:54:49
      And so that's the crux of the problem.
    • 00:54:52
      Whereas with the ESAL equivalent, pavements in the generic sense are relatively similar.
    • 00:54:59
      And so that concept of service-like loss through the ESAL is a very sound concept for pavements.
    • 00:55:05
      It just doesn't hold for bridges.
    • 00:55:08
      So we are...
    • 00:55:09
      I'm sorry.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:11
      Mal and Jose, maybe I can get at it.
    • 00:55:13
      If I understand the question right this way, Mal, your answer was that until
    • 00:55:19
      The last few years, we've used a standard bridge design.
    • 00:55:23
      The industry is now designing bridges for what we anticipate to be heavier vehicles that will be using them.
    • 00:55:30
      So consequently, we have an age problem.
    • 00:55:33
      As you look at the fleet of bridges, if I get the picture about right, it's not so much the weight of the truck that will cause it to age out.
    • 00:55:43
      It's the design that was used for that structure
    • 00:55:47
      and as we're now modernizing the fleet, we're modernizing for heavier vehicles but if I pick up on Gary's point, the legislation will lag that in terms of what we permit on those bridges.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:03
      Well, I mean, aren't we in a position to have this knowledge so that we don't have to be playing catch-up so that we can anticipate what needs to be done and plan accordingly and program accordingly
    • 00:56:17
      and fund accordingly.
    • 00:56:18
      I mean, isn't that what we're supposed to do?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:21
      I think I can not give a good analytical answer, but we spent a lot of time at the last four consecutive meetings talking about bridges and the annual inspection program and developing really a miniature maintenance program for each of those.
    • 00:56:40
      So while we may not have the ability to calculate a permit cost,
    • 00:56:46
      We do have an appropriate cost for bridge maintenance.
    • 00:56:50
      And so rather than going through the exercise of attributing costs based on the weight of a truck, it may be better to say x percent of traffic is truck or x percent is overweight truck and get at it in that fashion.
    • 00:57:04
      But that would need to be done as part of a more comprehensive, overweight study, which is in the works by the Research Council as we speak.
    • 00:57:15
      All points very well taken.
    • 00:57:19
      And it may make some sense because what's different about bridges is you can't post them.
    • 00:57:23
      You do have the ability to impose operating conditions on a bridge.
    • 00:57:27
      You really don't have a lot of pavement.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:30
      Mr. Koelemay.
    • 00:57:31
      Mr. Chairman, I'm trying to calculate the private sector's interest here.
    • 00:57:37
      The trade-offs would be heavier loads, therefore more economic efficiencies.
    • 00:57:44
      But with restrictions on certain parts of the network, they would have a smaller network.
    • 00:57:48
      There would be a dedicated heavier load network that they would be traveling on.
    • 00:57:55
      Versus more standard loads with greater flexibility, more of the network would be open to them.
    • 00:58:01
      So we do have to be mindful of that.
    • 00:58:02
      Long-haul carriers and regional distributors and localized operations may have different needs in this regard, even though they may be driving the same trucks.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:58:12
      Yes, that's true.
    • 00:58:14
      For example, in the Coles-Severance counties, as I recall, with a six-axle truck, you could actually haul a gross weight of 110,000 pounds, which is, that's a lot of weight.
    • 00:58:27
      That's a lot of weight.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:31
      Any other, Ms. Connelly?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:32
      I'm just kind of mystified by the whole concept of overweight.
    • 00:58:37
      I mean, it's just... Maybe, maybe I should... Is it really to determine which
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:58:43
      Again, I think it's simply a term that has been used as a comparison to what the standard gross weights and axle weights allowed under the major sections of the code.
    • 00:59:09
      and there are certain exemptions that have been applied as a result of special interest coming to the General Assembly and arguing their case and it's being successful.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:25
      So we don't set these limits?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:28
      These are set to some degree, standards are set at the federal level and then there are exemptions established in state code.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:59:37
      That is true.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:42
      Okay, who would have thought that truck rates would be such a fascinating topic, but it is.
    • 00:59:48
      Well, it is money, but I think there's an important, we spend a lot of time talking about freight movements and multimodal, and I think Dr. Allen's point about, look, we modernize our standards to accommodate a changing economy, and we
    • 01:00:04
      have spent so much time talking about, for example, the Heartlands Corridor.
    • 01:00:08
      What is that?
    • 01:00:10
      The Heartlands Corridor is public money to allow double snacking, which is essentially overweight or over height on the rail system.
    • 01:00:17
      So in one case, we're paying for it out of our highway maintenance budget.
    • 01:00:21
      In another case, we're paying for it through a direct appropriation.
    • 01:00:25
      And those economies and those states that keep up with the changing economy
    • 01:00:32
      are those that succeed and are not like the Port of Baltimore.
    • 01:00:36
      The Port of Baltimore failed to keep its providing infrastructure in place.
    • 01:00:42
      And think about that.
    • 01:00:43
      In 20 years, Baltimore has gone from the number two port on the East Coast to not a strong competitor.
    • 01:00:50
      So part of what this is about, and I think what Mr. Koelemay was talking about, talking about freight routes and the freight plan that we had last time, you know, maybe where we evolved to
    • 01:00:59
      Thank you very much Mr. Chairman
    • 01:01:19
      Okay, and both of these points on the Inland Court and Overway Truck have tremendous bearing on the I-81 quarter.
    • 01:01:27
      We now have about six separate presentations on I-81.
    • 01:01:34
      And these are very important discussion points, both in terms of retrospective and division.
    • 01:01:43
      What I'd like to do is see if we can't
    • 01:01:47
      I know, Mr. Martin, are we going to need to break a little bit to address some of your local issues?
    • 01:01:53
      If so, just give us a hand sign and we can suspend.
    • 01:01:56
      Maybe in about an hour and 45 minutes.
    • 01:01:59
      Okay.
    • 01:01:59
      Thank you.
    • 01:02:01
      And then, so I'd like to start off, and again, the interest of multimodalism and intramodalism, we've asked the commissioner and the director to give a joint presentation on the I-81 cord.
    • 01:02:17
      What's the reality?
    • 01:02:18
      What are some opportunities?
    • 01:02:20
      And what's the vision?
    • 01:02:21
      And this is a starting point for several succeeding presentations, one by Norfolk Southern as the major rail freight provider.
    • 01:02:29
      We're going to get an update on the I-81 NEPA process.
    • 01:02:33
      And you've heard previously about the freight planning exercise, which was heavily focused on the trucking industry.
    • 01:02:39
      So there's certainly no exclusion there and a lot of discussion today.
    • 01:02:43
      And we have
    • 01:02:44
      representatives of the trucking industry here to join us today.
    • 01:02:48
      We're going to hear a presentation on the I-81 Rail Initiative, some safety and operational issues, and then close by talking about Exit 150.
    • 01:02:57
      And for those of you who are unable to join us this morning, we really had a great tour of Exit 150 as a new way of solving an old problem.
    • 01:03:07
      And I think that'll be a great presentation as well.
    • 01:03:10
      So Commissioner, Mr. Tucker, welcome.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:13
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:03:15
      The Commissioner and I are going to walk you through this presentation about focusing in on the 81 corridor.
    • 01:03:21
      I think it's important to note that we are working in close coordination with the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, VDOT, and the Secretary's office on the 81 corridor initiative.
    • 01:03:35
      We have a shared vision that reflects the I-81 significance to the global economy, the corridor's assets and its diversity of uses, and we have a vision that recognizes that we're going to have to have strategic partnerships between private, public, and our federal government to really make the types of investments that we need.
    • 01:03:56
      You know, I oftentimes tell people since I'm back in Virginia, it's good to be a Virginian.
    • 01:04:03
      Sometimes I think we lose focus on that, but it's good to be a Virginian.
    • 01:04:08
      If you think about the fact that the last couple of years, Forbes Magazine has ranked Virginia as the top state for doing business.
    • 01:04:15
      Now that has some national significance, but you also have to start thinking about Virginia in terms of its significance in global trade, in the global economy.
    • 01:04:23
      I've often heard the Secretary, as well as our Governor, speak again of the assets that Virginia has.
    • 01:04:28
      If you think about Dulles Airport,
    • 01:04:30
      You think of the Port of Virginia, and you also have to think about the 81 corridor in terms of the advantages that it provides us in terms of connections, not only for national economy, but for global economy.
    • 01:04:41
      Throughout this presentation, what the Commissioner and I are going to try to focus in on are the assets in the corridor, the people in the corridor, and how do we continue to make this corridor something that's vital to protect the quality of lives for our Virginians.
    • 01:04:55
      For Nate, so now the commissioner is going to talk a little bit about the corridor, a little bit about its assets and its conditions today.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:05
      You know, it's interesting as you look at the corridor, we look at it in terms of numbers and data, and it has so many other aspects to it.
    • 01:05:16
      It really made it a unique experience in the Virginia history.
    • 01:05:22
      If you look at the slide as I portrayed it here, I-81, that transportation corridor stretches almost 330 miles, 325 miles from Tennessee to West Virginia.
    • 01:05:37
      It connects now to 21 cities, 13 counties.
    • 01:05:41
      It travels through a largely undeveloped and rural area with only about 25% of the population in its influence served by MPOs.
    • 01:05:54
      And it's got a dominant land use, agriculture, pastures, forests.
    • 01:06:01
      If you think about it in that kind of context, but then you step aside and say, spread out.
    • 01:06:09
      Think about it in its historical context,
    • 01:06:11
      Think about it and what it does and what Matt talked about a little bit earlier in terms of direct impact, indirect impact, and induced impact.
    • 01:06:21
      This portal, as a totality, now serves 20% of Virginia's population.
    • 01:06:27
      And that's a growth since 1970.
    • 01:06:30
      So if you think about that as what it represents has supported that kind of development within our Commonwealth.
    • 01:06:42
      We've gone from two MPOs in this corridor to now five, which talks about the vitality of the economy in those metropolitan areas.
    • 01:06:54
      From 1990 to 2000, the labor force has grown and equaled the Virginia growth rate.
    • 01:07:01
      As the economists look at this, this gets to be a real generator around the economic vitality that we talk about.
    • 01:07:11
      24,000 business establishments in that corridor in the Virginia experience.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:07:19
      So the data that we provide you is substantial in terms of the influence on the economic side.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:30
      Think about the I-81 corridor not just as a freight corridor, but think about it as the main street of this part of the commonwealth and how that has emerged over the last 30 years.
    • 01:07:47
      But like other main streets, it is positive.
    • 01:07:51
      Congestion has increased by pole, commuting traffic.
    • 01:07:56
      That commuting traffic creates congestion.
    • 01:07:59
      It has increased five-fold.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:08:02
      It has a topographic challenge, which is to get large elevation changes through the valley.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:10
      Trucks now take up the space of about four to six vehicles, so it talks about capacity.
    • 01:08:18
      You can see congestion now at peak times, special events, and incidents.
    • 01:08:24
      And I talked to the board before about our experience this year, and that's kind of an example you can see in terms of how devastating a crash this vital kind of part of the network can be in terms of lane closures.
    • 01:08:39
      Nineteen hours is not unusual for us now in a serious incident to have to recover from that incident.
    • 01:08:50
      And you see the kind of backups that are illustrated here.
    • 01:08:54
      We also have a whole variety of assets that now are part of this corridor that are really significant.
    • 01:09:04
      We've worked over the last week to try to
    • 01:09:06
      I want to highlight that in a way for you that brings emphasis to people, the five population centers, the million people in this corridor that are represented and you can see this highlighted in your exhibit and yet it goes beyond that.
    • 01:09:25
      It's a corridor of higher education and higher learning.
    • 01:09:30
      Thirty institutions now operating.
    • 01:09:32
      Now, I didn't memorize all my numbers, so I'm going to come back.
    • 01:09:36
      It's impressive when you look at this in terms of thirty institutions of higher education, the economic benefit that comes from that in the corridor and in the surrounding area.
    • 01:09:50
      Higher Ed prompts thriving research, medical initiatives, employs thousands of knowledge-based workers throughout the corridor, and it results in the economic development partnership efforts like SRI International.
    • 01:10:08
      That's a research institute out of Stanford University that's establishing a new center for advanced drug research in the Rockingham Center for Research and Technology.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:10:18
      We're going to find shorter names
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:20
      Northrop Grumman's got a $22.8 million IT systems center in Russell County.
    • 01:10:38
      So it shows what the diversity of the corridor is starting to develop.
    • 01:10:46
      It opens access to the history of the Commonwealth and the nation, if you look at it from that perspective, which also has an impact on our economy.
    • 01:10:59
      More than 21,000 jobs are direct travel-related employment with a payroll exceeding $330 million in steady growth numbers in jobs and tourism since 2003.
    • 01:11:15
      There's about nearly two billion dollars in direct spending by travelers in 2006.
    • 01:11:25
      That's up for every locality, about eight to nine percent over the last year.
    • 01:11:35
      Impressive numbers when you look at that.
    • 01:11:37
      And it's about people's desire to see history and be a part of history, as Virginia Commonwealth
    • 01:11:46
      Think about the trails and the access that we provide to the scenic corridor.
    • 01:11:54
      It's about access to that mountainous arena, the mountainous area that we have, the valleys that we talked about when we came in, we returned in times of the year.
    • 01:12:06
      Those are the intrinsic kinds of things that I don't think we focus on when we think about the pure economics of weights
    • 01:12:15
      I think the last piece I want to talk and kind of highlight a little bit is the parkways and highways and the movement that I've talked about to this group before around context and the role of transportation.
    • 01:12:41
      We have four main street activities, yet recognizing and creating access to parkways, scenic byways, the National Forest, the National Historic Parks, and a whole variety of experiences
    • 01:12:56
      A quality of life for the Commonwealth, for the people that come here from across the nation and across the world.
    • 01:13:06
      Kind of an exciting, different world as to what this corridor means, not just the frame.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:16
      And from this slide, you clearly see the connections that are provided by ports, airports, to frame, as well as distribution centers.
    • 01:13:25
      When you think about the 81 corridor, you've got to consider it in this context.
    • 01:13:29
      Today, it's about 12,000 trucks in the corridor on a daily basis.
    • 01:13:35
      By 2030, we see that number going up 142%.
    • 01:13:37
      In terms of rail intermodal for Norfolk Southern, it's also 300,000 40-foot truck equivalent units moved across that rail on an annual basis.
    • 01:13:53
      We see rail movement going to double or more than double in the next 20 years.
    • 01:13:58
      And again, when I sort of take a step back and look at this map, I sort of look at it from both the freight and interstate perspective of how pretty much when we're talking about them, how closely we're talking about pretty much their traveling along the same patterns and what the dynamics of that mean.
    • 01:14:17
      With these critical assets that we have, there are challenges as well as opportunities that we need to really address moving forward.
    • 01:14:26
      We have capacity issues in terms of the port as well as connectivity, highway congestion, rail capacity and connectivity.
    • 01:14:34
      But as you can sort of take a look and take a step back at initiatives that this board has looked at over the last couple of years, particularly with the rail enhancement fund in terms of projects that we identified to benefit support over $50 million worth of improvements to Heartland Corridor Initiative.
    • 01:14:52
      If you think about even like the Dulles Rail Project, the benefit that that will provide to the Dulles Airport in terms of, as the Secretary described it, as a two-seat ride to China.
    • 01:15:03
      As you take a step back and look at right now the 81 corridor that we're talking about, we're talking about a solution that looks not only at road improvement but also significant investments in rail to sort of ensure that we maintain this corridor commensurate to its impact on the global economy and importance to Virginians, particularly for maintaining our quality of life.
    • 01:15:28
      But I think at the end of the day, the fact of the matter is when you take a step back and you look at this corridor, the fact of the matter is that the improvements have to be made with strategic partnerships.
    • 01:15:42
      I mean, the investments in the corridor that Virginia is moving ahead with need to be leveraged by investments not only from the federal government, but from states as well as the private sector.
    • 01:15:54
      If we're really going to get the bang for the buck for the dollars that we invest, we need others to step up to the plate as well.
    • 01:16:01
      One of the dynamics that is occurring that the board is actually pushing and the state is pushing
    • 01:16:05
      is the relationship with Norfolk Southern in terms of utilizing the freight rail to take trucks off the road.
    • 01:16:13
      The next presentation that you're going to hear is a presentation from Bill Schafer, who's the Director of Strategic Planning for Norfolk Southern.
    • 01:16:20
      He's going to talk a little bit about that Crescent Corridor Initiative.
    • 01:16:24
      It's sort of a metaphor in terms of the Portland Corridor Initiative in terms of its emphasis looking at multi-state collaboration to really provide the highest base for the buck in terms of taking trucks off the road.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:37
      Before we go to Bill, are there questions for the Commissioner or Mr. Tucker?
    • 01:16:45
      Thank you for a great presentation and I think it's always important to hear our transportation agency heads talking about higher education and historic resources in addition to moving goods and people.
    • 01:16:59
      This is a very, very complex corridor and I seem to recall somewhere
    • 01:17:05
      There's about 60% of the college students in Virginia are in this corridor.
    • 01:17:11
      Now think about that.
    • 01:17:13
      Now our population centers are on one side, but our higher education centers are on the other side of the state.
    • 01:17:20
      That's a very important asset and one that we have to think about because we have a responsibility.
    • 01:17:25
      Heck, I-81 goes right through the middle of James Madison.
    • 01:17:29
      And you deal with the exact same issue, Dr. Davis.
    • 01:17:32
      These are issues that we have to confront as we
    • 01:17:35
      I appreciate this long-term vision for the corridor.
    • 01:17:40
      Very important.
    • 01:17:41
      I'd like to, at this point, welcome Bill Schafer.
    • 01:17:44
      He's the Director of Strategic Planning at Norfolk Southern.
    • 01:17:47
      Welcome, Bill.
    • 01:17:48
      And we look forward to your presentation.
    • 01:17:50
      And you may get stopped along the way for a question.
    • 01:17:54
      And we look forward to hearing from you.
    • 01:17:56
      Thank you for being here.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:17:57
      Thank you very much, Mr. Secretary.
    • 01:17:59
      It's really an honor to be able to discuss with you today our I-81 Crescent Corridor Initiative.
    • 01:18:05
      It's a project where we've had a fortunate confluence of factors.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:18:15
      There's been the wonderful participation and partnership of Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:18:22
      There's also been the increasing congestion on the Commonwealth highways that you're familiar with.
    • 01:18:30
      There's also been a willingness at North Southern to think in terms of public-private partnerships to help alleviate congestion issues.
    • 01:18:41
      And there's also been a strong market presence in all of our considerations here with the I-81 Crescent Corridor, as you'll see as I get into my presentation.
    • 01:18:53
      I'd like to discuss briefly what it is that we're going to talk about
    • 01:18:59
      I will answer the question why we need a present corridor, discuss the investment that we're planning and the implementation of that investment, and then discuss the relationship between the present corridor, the I-81 study, and the public-private partnership we have at the Commonwealth.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:20
      Could he defend the Crested Corridor for us?
    • 01:19:22
      Yes, I'd be happy to.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:19:24
      The Crested Corridor, a little background before I get there.
    • 01:19:30
      It'll all become clear.
    • 01:19:33
      Everyone's seen this map before.
    • 01:19:34
      This is a map of the U.S. in 1998 and the different congestion areas on the different interstate highways.
    • 01:19:41
      Green means it's okay.
    • 01:19:42
      Yellow means it's approaching congestion.
    • 01:19:44
      Yellow means it's beyond congestion.
    • 01:19:46
      In the year 2020, which isn't all that far away,
    • 01:19:49
      There's a significant number of red marks that show up on the map.
    • 01:19:54
      This assumes no additional highway capacity being added.
    • 01:19:58
      The I-81 Crescent Corridor is the blue lines that you see overlaid on a lot of those red lines between the northeast, the southeast, and the southwest.
    • 01:20:11
      What the Crescent Corridor is, it's a network of trains over routes that will link these major markets.
    • 01:20:19
      To put it a little bit in perspective, it's between the Northeast where a lot of people are.
    • 01:20:24
      These brown ovals indicate markets that are heavy truck markets, the burgeoning Southeast, and also the Southwest.
    • 01:20:37
      This shows the interstate highways parallel to it.
    • 01:20:40
      Now, we call this the I-81 Crescent Corridor.
    • 01:20:42
      This, I think, will answer your question.
    • 01:20:45
      I-81 largely because it means a lot to the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 01:20:49
      It is the principal conduit over which the through trucks operate between the market areas that are shown here.
    • 01:20:55
      They don't normally go up with the I-95 corridor.
    • 01:20:58
      They tend to go up the I-81 corridor when they go through Virginia.
    • 01:21:02
      And it's more than I-81 that these rail routes parallel.
    • 01:21:12
      If you start in the northeast,
    • 01:21:14
      We're talking about I-78, which connects with I-81 in the Harrisburg area, which I-81 continues down to I-40 and I-75 in Tennessee.
    • 01:21:23
      But there's a significant amount of I-81 traffic that comes out of the deep south, out of the Atlanta and Alabama areas that come up I-85 and I-77.
    • 01:21:33
      We have rail routes that parallel those routes too.
    • 01:21:38
      The driver for the Crescent Corridor, at least from our standpoint, why do we want to do this?
    • 01:21:44
      That's because there is not very much rail intermodal service along these highway corridors that I just described.
    • 01:21:55
      As a contrast, let me go back to that previous slide as a contrast.
    • 01:21:59
      Here's the red light.
    • 01:22:01
      We also have main lines.
    • 01:22:03
      By the way, these heavy red lines are the routes of the Crescent Corridor.
    • 01:22:08
      The small red lines are the rest of the north southern system.
    • 01:22:14
      We have, thanks to our acquisition of Conrail, is a major rail conduit between the New York area and Chicago.
    • 01:22:22
      We believe that there is a significant opportunity to ... We are already running a lot of intermodal trains across that route today, somewhere between 30 and 40 intermodal trains.
    • 01:22:35
      We figure that is taking roughly four to five thousand trucks a day off the highways between New York and Chicago.
    • 01:22:42
      We believe that a similar amount of traffic exists between the Northeast, the Southeast, and Southwest that a similarly robust market could be developed for rail in the Southeast.
    • 01:23:02
      We are finding significant and growing highway congestion.
    • 01:23:06
      Once the Crescent Corridor, the I-81 Crescent Corridor service is up and running,
    • 01:23:11
      We believe that it will have the potential to divert a million or more truckloads a year from the highway to the trains, and the truckers and the people who ship on trucks have been asking for alternatives to the truck haul up by 81.
    • 01:23:28
      Now what makes the Crescent Corridor service that I'm describing different from what we offer today?
    • 01:23:35
      First of all, as opposed to, say, the Heartland Corridor,
    • 01:23:39
      We're talking strictly domestic freight here.
    • 01:23:42
      This service is not intended to serve ports.
    • 01:23:45
      It's intended to serve freight that originates and terminates in North America.
    • 01:23:51
      We're also proposing to offer a premium intermodal service.
    • 01:23:55
      Now, we offer an occasion to a few of our customers what we call premium intermodal service today.
    • 01:24:03
      It involves a higher average speed and level of reliability.
    • 01:24:07
      then our normal intermodal service and also the premium service requires support from major trucking companies.
    • 01:24:15
      Our major customers have said we would like more premium service out there.
    • 01:24:20
      The network of trains that would operate over these routes right here would be a total of about 28 a day and the whole idea would be to offer a rail service that was competitive with single driver transit times.
    • 01:24:37
      Our intermodal service today, our trains average somewhere between 25 and 30 miles an hour from one terminal to the next.
    • 01:24:46
      That doesn't sound like a lot, but if the train keeps moving, then you can cover a fair amount of mileage in a 24-hour period.
    • 01:24:53
      Where we would improve the intermodal service under the Crescent Corridor is we would go to service that would average somewhere between 30 and 35 miles an hour, roughly an 8 or 10 mile an hour.
    • 01:25:06
      average higher speed, overall speed, and if it's operated with a high level of reliability, then it would have the potential to compete with single driver transit times.
    • 01:25:19
      Now, out there on I-81 today, or I-85 with a speed limit of 65, a truck driver who by law is required to take his rest after 10 hours on the highway can cover somewhere between 550, 650 miles in his shift.
    • 01:25:35
      Then he's required by law to take a rest.
    • 01:25:39
      The purpose of the pressing corridor trains would be to cover the equivalent distance from the time he has finished his rest that the truck would have gone in the 10 hours that he drove it, the train would be going for the next, you know, for the additional hours and would cover the same amount of distance as a single driver of a truck would once you consider his rest time in there.
    • 01:26:04
      The timing on the Crescent Corridor, the cost of it is to be determined, but it's going to be north of $2 billion total.
    • 01:26:15
      We expect to be able to phase this in if funding develops by the year 2013.
    • 01:26:20
      That's only about five or six years from now.
    • 01:26:25
      We are planning, engineering, and constructing track improvements, capacity improvements already.
    • 01:26:32
      on some portions of the routes of the I-81 Crescent Corridor.
    • 01:26:39
      We believe that there's a strong argument to be made for public investment in this proposal that we have.
    • 01:26:47
      First of all, rail is a safe mode of transportation, not only from an employee standpoint, but from a transportation and freight standpoint.
    • 01:26:58
      We as railroads as an industry have a very good record
    • 01:27:02
      As far as reducing the number of accidents that they've had in a given year, a recent report from the Federal Railroad Administration indicates that 2007 is making great progress on an already good record.
    • 01:27:16
      We believe that we also can make a difference in highway congestion, the highway maintenance expense that would be necessary, and the timing and extent of highway expansion.
    • 01:27:30
      As our current ads on TV will indicate, we also believe that there are some environmental benefits to shipping by rail.
    • 01:27:38
      There are fewer emissions, for example, from locomotives pulling truck trailers than trucks pulling truck trailers.
    • 01:27:45
      The footprint of the railroad is much smaller than the footprint of the equivalent capacity of a highway, so the land use is more efficient.
    • 01:27:55
      It's more efficient from a fuel consumption standpoint.
    • 01:27:58
      Of some interest, particularly in the I-81 corridor, rail has a lower impact on historical and cultural assets.
    • 01:28:06
      As you heard earlier in the presentation on the Virginia Inland Port, rail also is very helpful to develop economic conditions in the areas that the rail terminals are in.
    • 01:28:26
      At present, the Commonwealth of Virginia is making a $40 million investment.
    • 01:28:32
      We have a public-private partnership with Commonwealth.
    • 01:28:36
      Most of that money is going where the little oval is, the red lines again being the I-81 Crescent corridor.
    • 01:28:45
      We can't say enough good things about Virginia's support.
    • 01:28:48
      I wanted to give you a little update of where the money is being spent.
    • 01:28:51
      It's between Manassas and Front Royal, which as I am indicating on this map is the choke point for the entire routes of the I-81 Crescent Corridor.
    • 01:29:02
      There are six projects now underway.
    • 01:29:05
      They include longer sidings.
    • 01:29:08
      We're going to extend the two sidings that presently exist between Manassas and Riverton.
    • 01:29:13
      We will build two more sidings, so there will be a total of four of them in the 50 miles between Manassas and Riverton.
    • 01:29:19
      We're going to install five miles of double track, second mainline track in the vicinity of the Virginia Inland Port, north of Front Royal.
    • 01:29:27
      This is in recognition of the fact that the Inland Port is becoming a major generator of business for us.
    • 01:29:36
      It will make it easier, more efficient to serve the Inland Port by having a second mainline track that goes by it.
    • 01:29:43
      We're also going to install a traffic control system, which is
    • 01:29:48
      The rail signal is to control the train movements between the Mississippi Front Royal.
    • 01:29:53
      There are no signals on that route today.
    • 01:29:56
      Traffic control would result in a more reliable train operation and it would also benefit the potential VRE extension to pay market.
    • 01:30:06
      As we'll hear later, we've also committed to haul an additional 40,000 additional container equivalents, truck equivalents a year as a result of these improvements.
    • 01:30:18
      This is just a little schematic map to show where the improvements are going to go.
    • 01:30:22
      The blue rectangles are where the additional passing tracks and double track is going to go, and the yellow line is where we're installing the traffic control.
    • 01:30:37
      As far as the I-81 freight rail study in connection with the Commonwealth of Virginia is concerned, we, Norfolk Southern, are modeling
    • 01:30:45
      The impact that the freight service that we would offer on the Crescent Corridor project, the impact it would have on Virginia highways, particularly I-81, but not restricted to I-81.
    • 01:31:01
      We're coordinating our studies with the Commonwealth and with Cambridge Systematics, validating each other's analyses.
    • 01:31:08
      These are sanity checks.
    • 01:31:09
      We're pooling our findings and results.
    • 01:31:13
      One of the products of this study is expected to be an estimate of the through-truck diversion.
    • 01:31:19
      In other words, the number of through-trucks presently operating over I-81 today that would be diverted through rail as a result of the Crescent Corridor Project.
    • 01:31:30
      The study will be complete in the spring of 2008.
    • 01:31:32
      I want to just mention one other item.
    • 01:31:37
      I heard it mentioned earlier this morning, an additional long-term possibility is what
    • 01:31:41
      We have termed internally as the Culpeper Cut-Off.
    • 01:31:45
      This is sort of a blow-up of the Crescent Corridor map.
    • 01:31:49
      It would be a new route between Culpeper and somewhere on the west end of the Masses Front Royal Line.
    • 01:31:58
      We view this as a long-term concept.
    • 01:32:01
      We don't have any engineering work that's been done on this, but we've done a few little back of the envelope calculations.
    • 01:32:08
      We want to keep this in the back of our minds.
    • 01:32:10
      If such a cutoff were built, it would save between one and two hours in running time of freight trains that otherwise would have to go by way of Manassas.
    • 01:32:22
      This would be 38 miles shorter than the present route and it would free up some capacity on
    • 01:32:29
      The routes out of Manassas in the event that additional passenger trains are needed to be operated in connection with the growing population.
    • 01:32:39
      So in closing, the Crescent Corridor is a new and unique service that we believe will lure trucks off the road.
    • 01:32:47
      The network is a big growth opportunity for us and it's also a big benefit, we believe, to the public.
    • 01:32:54
      The costs are large.
    • 01:32:55
      It will require public participation
    • 01:32:57
      We are not by any means expecting all of our public-private partnership work to be with the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 01:33:04
      We're also working to obtain some federal funding and funding from other states for this project.
    • 01:33:09
      But to the Commonwealth's credit, it already recognizes the need to invest in this project and for which we're very grateful.
    • 01:33:17
      That concludes my presentation, Mr. Secretary, and I'll be happy to answer questions if there are.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:23
      Thank you, Mr. Schaffer.
    • 01:33:24
      I know there were a couple of pre-existing questions that Mr. Schwartz and Mr. McCarthy had.
    • 01:33:30
      Mr. Schwartz, did you want to?
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:32
      Actually, Mr. Chairman, if it's okay with you, I'm thinking that after we get Mr.
    • 01:33:38
      Page's presentation, some of my questions might be questions that I sort of want to put to Mr. Schaffer and Mr.
    • 01:33:47
      Page together.
    • 01:33:48
      It might be more productive.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:49
      Okay, thank you.
    • 01:33:51
      Mr. McCarthy, did you want to
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:53
      Well, I think mine was a simpler question, and that was, is there some reason the existing inland port training takes a right turn at Lynchburg now instead of going on up and using the line that parallels I-81 most directly?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:34:14
      Well, because the traffic originates in Norfolk, or originates and terminates in Norfolk,
    • 01:34:20
      It is a shorter route to go from Norfolk to Lynchburg and then up to Manassas and across to Front Royal.
    • 01:34:26
      That's one reason.
    • 01:34:27
      Another reason is that the train can make that trip with what we call a progressive move.
    • 01:34:34
      In other words, it doesn't need to back up to change directions in any way.
    • 01:34:39
      There is not an existing connection in Roanoke, for example, that would allow a train coming from Lynchburg to make a right turn and go up to the Shenandoah Valley without making a backup or reverse move.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:51
      Mr. Davis.
    • 01:34:51
      Mr. Chairman, I'm curious about a couple things with the $2 billion rough estimate that you have for the Crescent Corridor.
    • 01:34:59
      That includes all the states.
    • 01:35:00
      I was curious if you've broken that out a little bit as to what portion you think might of that estimate might be spent in Virginia.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:35:09
      We have not, to answer your question, not yet.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:11
      Would it be fair to guess that having looked at the distances and everything that it would be as much as a third of it or
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:35:21
      That's possible.
    • 01:35:24
      A lot of the work that needs to be done in connection with the Crescent Corridor is not just in the northeastern part, it's also along the Shenandoah Valley to the southwestern part.
    • 01:35:36
      But yes, that would be a fair pushback estimate.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:41
      That's a big guess.
    • 01:35:44
      The reason I want to ask is because I'm curious about the quality
    • 01:35:51
      of the tracks that you have that go up to Shenandoah Valley in particular in terms of being able to keep any sort of speed level that makes it feasible and what would really be required to bring that up to where you could run 30 to 40 mile an hour freight up to Shenandoah Valley.
    • 01:36:11
      We continue to hear, and I continue to hear a lot about the use of freight rail in the Shenandoah Valley.
    • 01:36:19
      And I'm always very quick to point out to people that actually, if I understand it correctly, the I-81 corridor along I-81 is not a heavy use corridor for freight right now.
    • 01:36:31
      It's more on the other side of the mountain.
    • 01:36:35
      And what I wonder is if you could even give us any idea of what kind of investment might be required to bring those tracks up to speed that come out of Roanoke and go straight up the valley.
    • 01:36:46
      and even if it's feasible to look at that as becoming a major investment on part of the Commonwealth, that would have that quarter be used more extensively.
    • 01:36:55
      Is there been any thought to that to speak of?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:36:58
      Yes, sir, there has been some thought to that and let me try to answer your question by answering it more globally in connection with the context of the whole Preston Carter project.
    • 01:37:11
      We have taken a look at where the traffic is originating and terminating, coming from, and where it needs to go.
    • 01:37:20
      The rail route that is the most efficient one to handle it isn't necessarily the one that's closest to the interstate highway that is handling the equivalent truck traffic today.
    • 01:37:32
      Looking at this map, for example, we find that the preponderance of the freight that we want to handle on the Crescent Corridor project
    • 01:37:40
      is coming from New Orleans, it's coming from Texas, and it's coming from the Birmingham, Atlanta, Charlotte area.
    • 01:37:49
      And at the moment, our best rail lines go by way of Atlanta, Charlotte, and march up east of the Blue Ridge to Manassas and then take a left turn and go up to Harrisburg that way.
    • 01:38:02
      So they go more toward Lynchburg rather than Rowland?
    • 01:38:05
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:38:05
      Now, having said that, another key piece
    • 01:38:09
      of the Crescent Corridor business that we're very anxious to serve is the traffic that originates and terminates in the Memphis area and east of, and somewhere in east Tennessee.
    • 01:38:22
      I don't, you know, don't need to, somewhere around Knoxville, somewhere east Tennessee, somewhere between where I-40 comes in and I-75 springs or I-40 springs off.
    • 01:38:35
      That trait, when it develops,
    • 01:38:38
      would be most efficiently handled up to Shenandoah Valley.
    • 01:38:42
      And my answer to you is that as we phase in the whole implementation of the Cressy Carter, we're going to need all of the heavy red lines to seal this map.
    • 01:38:55
      We're going to start using the ones along the Piedmont side first because
    • 01:39:02
      and Phil them up.
    • 01:39:04
      But the Piedmont, eventually the Shenandoah Line is going to be necessary too.
    • 01:39:08
      Not right away, but at some point.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:10
      Could you comment on the quality of that track bed and sort of what might be required to bring it up to a level to make it more economically competitive?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:39:21
      We've taken a preliminary look at that.
    • 01:39:23
      I don't have dollars and cents, but I can give you a general sense of
    • 01:39:27
      It is a line that never has had the benefit of a major rebuilding in its 150-year existence.
    • 01:39:46
      The line down the east side of the Blue Ridge is a major north-south conduit, much of which is still double-track, I might add.
    • 01:39:57
      So there's a fair amount of capacity on it.
    • 01:39:59
      The one piece of that that doesn't have the capacity, because it never was that kind of line, is masses of Front Royal, which is why we're putting the money where we're putting it today.
    • 01:40:08
      The actual quality of the track structure itself on the Shenandoah line isn't any worse than it is anywhere else.
    • 01:40:15
      The ties are good, the rail is good, but as you may have received, the topography is not ideal.
    • 01:40:20
      And more important from the operation of reliable trains, particularly these I-81 Crescent
    • 01:40:28
      The sightings are too short.
    • 01:40:29
      They're not long enough to accommodate contemporary freight trains.
    • 01:40:34
      Before it can be used for a significant, reliable, intermodal truck competitive service, it will require a fair amount of infrastructure addition to it in the form of lengthened sightings.
    • 01:40:52
      We haven't done all of our studies yet.
    • 01:40:55
      It may need to have some
    • 01:40:57
      tweaks to the curves, take a look at other slow orders that are on the line to, as you point out, improve it to bring the average speed up.
    • 01:41:07
      I hope that answered your question.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:08
      I think I just have two more little questions and then I'll move on.
    • 01:41:12
      I was trying to get at some rough estimate of an investment in that particular track, say from Bristol to Winchester, that would make it a really viable freight corridor.
    • 01:41:24
      Would it be, again, a half a billion, billion dollars, probably, if you were just guessing?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:41:28
      Well, I'm going to dodge that question, which is why.
    • 01:41:32
      We view the Crescent Corridor project as a first step.
    • 01:41:36
      It's not a project that we would expect to complete and then say, well, that was nice.
    • 01:41:40
      We can rest on our laurels.
    • 01:41:42
      We don't have to do anything else.
    • 01:41:45
      It is a bold first step, in our view, that would take a significant public-private partnership to accomplish, but we believe that the effects of it and the success of it will then be catalysts for additional
    • 01:41:58
      Similar upgradings or additions of trains in service to even the Crescent Corridor routes, if not other routes.
    • 01:42:07
      And I think that over time, on an incremental basis, there will be improvements made to all of the red lines in one form or another that are on that map, including the Shenandoah Line, the line down to Bristol, the line through Tennessee.
    • 01:42:22
      But as I pointed out, this is going to take more than what the lines that are our favorite lines of the day will take because the investment has not been there for this many years.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:32
      Mr. Chairman, the reason I was asking the question is trying to lead to a point that we're faced in the Commonwealth, in my opinion, with a major expenditure for correcting the problems in the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:42:45
      And when I say that, I mean both rail and Interstate 81.
    • 01:42:52
      I'm trying to get out of my mind if we're going to be fair to multimodal transportation in the Shenandoah Valley, which is a discussion that we're trying to have as well.
    • 01:43:04
      We need to have an idea, can rail in the Shenandoah Valley be a realistic part of that solution for an amount of money that is reasonable?
    • 01:43:15
      And when I've talked to a lot of constituents, they have no idea
    • 01:43:20
      What it would cost to bring that rail line up to any level of efficiency that would make it economically feasible to be done from a private investment standpoint.
    • 01:43:31
      Now from the state, the Commonwealth, being a partner, however, and saying this is a part of the I-81 corridor solution puts it in a whole different light.
    • 01:43:42
      But I think talking about that corridor is also important along with what you're doing with the Lynchburg
    • 01:43:49
      to Manassas Route, in effect, if we want to get at a real solution to the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:43:57
      I'll leave it at that, but it's part of my thinking that we have to get really serious about a major investment in that rail corridor along with the road itself if we want to address the problem anytime in the next decade of what's going on in the Shenandoah Valley.
    • 01:44:14
      My final question, Mr. Chairman, has to do with a Front Royal to Manassas
    • 01:44:20
      In listening to what you're proposing and being a supporter of that whole concept, you mentioned just briefly that it might be possible if conditions were right to slip a few passenger cars into that transportation mode.
    • 01:44:37
      And I'm very interested in seeing if it's not possible somehow or another to get passenger transportation by rail
    • 01:44:46
      from Winchester Front Royal to the DC area.
    • 01:44:51
      Did I hear you say that might be possible if the improvements and the sidings and the other things are put in place to make that possible?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:45:00
      Let me see if I can clarify that a little bit.
    • 01:45:07
      First of all, VRE is proposed to extend service to Haymarket.
    • 01:45:11
      It's 11 miles west of Manassas.
    • 01:45:13
      That's on the Manassas to Front Royal line.
    • 01:45:15
      Some of the improvements that we're making in connection with the Commonwealth on that line will have a small benefit to the VRE once VRE, if and when VRE decides to extend its service to a market.
    • 01:45:30
      By the same token, improvements that we would make between Manassas and the line going towards Charlottesville and wallpaper, they may, may have a benefit if passenger, at some point, some respect if passenger service is ever offered on that line.
    • 01:45:46
      It is beyond my blue sky thinking that we would have the beginnings of a service that would be competitive for the automobile between Winchester and Washington, D.C. by that round, but you know, enough money ain't gonna be possible.
    • 01:46:07
      The reason I mentioned passenger though is in the context of this Paul Pepper cutoff,
    • 01:46:11
      As long as freight trains are using their track heavily by way of Manassas, then it's going to be much more difficult to get past the trains.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:23
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:46:23
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • 01:46:24
      Mr. Chairman, just one question I do have of Mr. Schaffer now.
    • 01:46:29
      I know you don't have any specific numbers that you pinned down in answer to Dr. Davis's question, but is, in your mind, is the cost of doing at least some
    • 01:46:42
      Basic level of repair on that line that goes up the I-81 along I-81 included in that sort of $2 billion investment for the Capital Crescent.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:46:56
      Yes.
    • 01:46:57
      Oh, yes.
    • 01:46:57
      Let me go back to this map right here.
    • 01:46:59
      Every one of these heavy red lines is considered to be part of the I-81 Crescent corridor.
    • 01:47:07
      There's another point I was going to make, Dr. Davis, in all of this.
    • 01:47:12
      about the Shenandoah Line and the Piedmont Line, there is already a parallel as far as the interstate highways are concerned.
    • 01:47:19
      I-95 is congested in the Washington area, so the trucks use I-81.
    • 01:47:23
      I-81 gets congested, the trucks go to US-29.
    • 01:47:25
      One of the beauties of the highway system, the interstate highway system, is that in most cases, if you know about difficulties, congestion, whatever, there's enough redundancy that you can make an intelligent alternative route and not
    • 01:47:42
      Rail has the same parallel.
    • 01:47:46
      Redundancy is going to be very important going forward.
    • 01:47:49
      If you look at that map, the core of the I-81 Crescent Corridor has redundant routes, and that's by design.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:57
      Any other questions?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:03
      Thank you so much, Mr. Schafer.
    • 01:48:05
      Just a couple of thoughts that
    • 01:48:07
      One is the questions about passenger service in between Front Royal and Manassas Illustrated.
    • 01:48:12
      And one of the challenges that we face in our rail program is like a highway, there's finite capacity and choices have to be made about a mix between passenger and freight.
    • 01:48:23
      So those are going to pose very, very difficult choices for this party.
    • 01:48:27
      Secondly, I think one of the things to me that was most illuminating is when you look at where freight comes from and where it goes to,
    • 01:48:37
      You can't expect to grow your business without making connections in Tennessee and Louisiana and Texas and perhaps even down into Mexico.
    • 01:48:48
      And so we have to understand that this is part of a much larger national phrase investment program that will not work.
    • 01:48:57
      And the limited experience we had with the Heartlands Corridor, where, for example, we were asked by USDOT to manage that,
    • 01:49:06
      became absolutely unworkable.
    • 01:49:09
      Right, Mr. Tucker?
    • 01:49:11
      Because what West Virginia wanted is, well, we'll let Virginia do it if we get Virginia to pay for X.
    • 01:49:17
      And Ohio said, well, sure, you can do that if Virginia pays for Y.
    • 01:49:21
      And that is the nature of a state-to-state cooperative agreement where we are all economic competitors.
    • 01:49:26
      We cannot make a venture like this work without a strong federal leadership role.
    • 01:49:33
      And so one of the things that we will be working on
    • 01:49:36
      as part of the I-81 Corridor Coalition and have now for four years is working towards that grander vision that does bring other states and other interests to the table to think big picture because that's what it's going to take for any of this to be realistically achieved again.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:55
      Mr. Koelemay.
    • 01:49:56
      Mr. Schafer, would you agree with that that leadership is the main constraint here as opposed to market conditions or
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:50:04
      I think it's a blend of conditions, but the Secretary's absolutely right.
    • 01:50:10
      If there's going to be a significant public-private partnership on the order of two to three billion dollars that we're talking about to make the depressant corridor a reality, it's going to take some strong leadership from the public sector, preferably from the federal government, the feds, to help to coordinate all of this.
    • 01:50:27
      Now, the improvements that are being made in Virginia
    • 01:50:30
      will help on a much smaller scale with the amount of truck traffic that Norfolk Southern is able to attract to the rail, even if the I-81 Crescent Corridor can get to be built out fully, but we won't get to that million trucks a year number unless we have all of the states, or these improvements made in all of the states and some sort of leadership from what I'd like to be saying, Mr. Secretary.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:59
      Let's take just one brief question.
    • 01:51:02
      Historically, I hope I remember my history correctly, that there were times when either state government or the federal government owned stock in privately held railroad companies a portion, for instance, if they were to invest a billion dollars in improvements, they would actually buy equity into the company.
    • 01:51:25
      Is that still in existence today that you are aware of?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:51:29
      There are a few places where it does exist.
    • 01:51:33
      Significant pieces of the North and Southern network were owned by the city of Cincinnati and the state of North Carolina.
    • 01:51:40
      And without those routes that are owned by those public entities, we wouldn't have nearly as good a system as we have today.
    • 01:51:49
      They own the whole thing and release it and operate it.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:57
      And as I recall, please correct me if my history is wrong, but the Commonwealth was the dominant shareholder for RF&P in a previous election.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:06
      That's what I remembered, but what I was trying to get at, and maybe I see some head nodding, if there is still an equity arrangement in existence in one of our major private railroads today, where government holds equity.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:20
      Oh, interesting.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:22
      Okay, name two.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:27
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:52:30
      Thank you.
    • 01:52:31
      Very thought-provoking discussion and again, as is the case on so many things, we have to think bigger than just Virginia.
    • 01:52:39
      Freight does not respect state or local boundaries and we have to begin as part of the statewide freight study, we've got to expand that really to start thinking Southeast, North American,
    • 01:52:51
      to really understand the nature of the investment.
    • 01:52:54
      And again, if we understand it, we can capitalize it on it, stay ahead of it, and not go the way of a port to the north that we should not bash anymore publicly.
    • 01:53:05
      Thanks, Mr. Schafer.
    • 01:53:07
      Okay, do we have time, Mr. Martin, for one more presentation?
    • 01:53:11
      We want to do the update on the I-81 NEPA process with Mr. Rick Walton.
    • 01:53:16
      Welcome, Mr. Walton.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:53:28
      I think you can tell me how far I was getting where you're going.
    • 01:53:42
      Down there.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 01:53:42
      Let's back up so we can figure that out.
    • 01:53:52
      We'll go back in time about a year to October of last year when the CTB, as the Secretary mentioned at the beginning of the meeting, passed a resolution regarding Interstate 81.
    • 01:54:04
      It contained four directives.
    • 01:54:07
      The first one was a directive to the Department of Rail and Public Transportation to conduct a freight rail study in the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:54:15
      Secondly, there was direction to VDOT to take immediate action to implement safety and operational improvements in the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:54:23
      Third, there was direction to VDOT to complete the Tier 1 EIS study in accordance with the process streamlining agreement that had been entered into between VDOT and the Federal Highway Administration and to more specifically consider that there be not more than two general purpose lanes in each direction along
    • 01:54:44
      the I-81 corridor taking into consideration 2035 traffic demands.
    • 01:54:50
      Secondly, that the future traffic demands consider rail diversion.
    • 01:54:55
      Third, that a pilot toll project be advanced.
    • 01:54:59
      And fourth, that we use eight independent segments to move into the Tier II studies.
    • 01:55:06
      Finally, CTB directed that we look at a context-sensitive solution approach in the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:55:15
      As far as the Tier 1 EIS is concerned, as directed, VDOT finalized the Tier 1 EIS with the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 01:55:25
      And that Tier 1 FEIS, again, considered a concept with a varying number of general purpose lanes.
    • 01:55:34
      While this slide says one and two in each direction, actually it could end up being no additional lanes in each direction.
    • 01:55:41
      So it's from zero, one, or two.
    • 01:55:44
      again based on 2035 Traffic Command.
    • 01:55:48
      The Tier 1 Record of Decision was received from the Federal Highway Administration in June of this year.
    • 01:55:54
      Again, the Tier 1 Record of Decision discussed the decisions that have been endorsed by the Commonwealth Transportation Board in that document and the ROD did recommend moving these eight independent sections for further detail Tier 2 studies.
    • 01:56:14
      The current Tier II study that VDOT is looking at involves one of the sections, one of the eight independent sections that was the subject of a study, a location study that began in 2001 but was halted in 2003 when it was determined to look at the entire Interstate 81 court.
    • 01:56:38
      This particular section is the overlap of Interstates 81 and 77.
    • 01:56:44
      between exit 72 and 81, and that study is presently funded by the CTB in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 01:56:53
      Regarding this particular tier two study, we are currently negotiating with a consultant to produce that study.
    • 01:57:01
      It's slated to start at the end of the year and scheduled to take approximately 18 months to complete.
    • 01:57:08
      We will use the information from the previous location study
    • 01:57:12
      and the Tier 1 EIS.
    • 01:57:15
      A no-bill will be considered in this study as the no-bill will be considered in all Tier 2 studies of the remaining seven segments.
    • 01:57:26
      And regarding the remaining seven segments, there will be no additional studies to be done until the Interstate 81 freight rail study is completed in the spring of next year.
    • 01:57:39
      As far as safety and operational improvements,
    • 01:57:42
      The Tier 1 ROD did address those in the Tier 1 ROD decision as far as advancing the safety and operational improvements in the I-81 corridor independent of the eight identified sections.
    • 01:57:58
      We are presently looking at two segments of truck climbing lanes, one in Rockbridge County northbound from mile markers 195 through 202 and the other Montgomery County
    • 01:58:10
      Southbound from mile markers 128 through 119.
    • 01:58:15
      The last bullet, while we mentioned the National Historic Preservation Act, any further studies in this corridor, even the studies of these truck climbing lanes, we comply with all of the federal laws that are applicable, Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, National Historic Preservation Act happens to be the one that's mentioned here.
    • 01:58:38
      As far as rail, the Tier 1 rod addressed this as well.
    • 01:58:43
      It indicated that there is public support for improvement to the North and Southern rail lines.
    • 01:58:49
      It also endorsed the concept from the CTB resolution that DRPT work with the Secretary of North and Southern to expedite short-term rail improvements in the corridor and that DRPTs undertake or continue with a multi-state I-81 freight rail study
    • 01:59:08
      to determine potential long-term diversions of truck traffic from Interstate 81 and future rail diversions based on this great study will be factored into those future traffic projections for the future Tier 2 studies.
    • 01:59:27
      Secretary, that's the update I have regarding the I-81 corridor.
    • 01:59:33
      I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:59:34
      Thank you, Mr. Walton.
    • 01:59:35
      Questions?
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:36
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • 01:59:37
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Walton, when we approved this a year ago, it was in the context of, I don't remember the exact number, but something over $100 million, I think, in federal funds being available that the approval of the Tier 1 EIS would free up in a sense to go ahead with some safety improvements.
    • 02:00:00
      And just a couple questions related to that.
    • 02:00:03
      The two truck climbing
    • 02:00:05
      Lane sections that you just referred to.
    • 02:00:08
      What's the overall cost of those and will they soak up that entire hundred plus million dollars or some portion of it?
    • 02:00:22
      If it's only a portion of it, what are you anticipating that the rest of that money would go for?
    • 02:00:30
      And also, what was the basis of the prioritization
    • 02:00:34
      that of the various safety needs along the corridor that these were the highest priority.
    • 02:00:45
      Sure.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:46
      I do would note that the second to last item on this is to talk specifically about the I-81 safety and operational improvements and I believe, Mr. Altizer, aren't those issues covered in that presentation?
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:04
      We can wait if that's correct.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:06
      I think that might be helpful if we get to that point because that's a very legitimate question about what's covered there.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:13
      Mr. Chairman, rail diversion and also even diversion of traffic off of 81 onto other primary roads were two of the greatest concerns that most constituents expressed when we went to these public hearings.
    • 02:01:30
      And I know you say that rail diversions will be factored into these future traffic projections.
    • 02:01:38
      I guess I'm trying to determine the legitimacy of the concern of many of those constituents about this idea of appropriate numbers for rail diversion being used.
    • 02:01:49
      And I think I hear you say that the study that we're doing will give updated numbers that would be considered
    • 02:01:56
      as opposed to what was used in the Tier 1 analysis only?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 02:02:00
      I believe Mr. Tucker probably answered that, but I believe the answer is yes.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:04
      Yes.
    • 02:02:05
      The answer is yes.
    • 02:02:06
      What's happening, you have two data points.
    • 02:02:09
      One data point is Novak Southern's market forecast themselves.
    • 02:02:12
      Right.
    • 02:02:13
      And then the analysis that we're doing that will help us validate the numbers that they show us.
    • 02:02:17
      So we're going to have two data sets from which to benchmark.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:21
      Then the other one had to do with diversion of traffic in the event there were tolls on 81.
    • 02:02:29
      With any of the work we're doing to get ready to make improvements beyond these safety improvements, I gather
    • 02:02:37
      New additional information will be provided about what possible diversion would occur on the primary systems as opposed to using only the tier one information.
    • 02:02:47
      Because that's what I've tried to assure most of the people.
    • 02:02:51
      I just wanted to hear it confirm that those two things would be given the attention that they're demanding.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:03:00
      Any other questions?
    • 02:03:03
      Thank you, Mr. Walton.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:05
      Okay, we've got a little bit more time.
    • 02:03:08
      Let's, if we might, move to the rail initiatives in the I-81 corridor and Mr. Kevin Page presenting.
    • 02:03:16
      Welcome, Mr.
    • 02:03:16
      Page.
    • 02:03:20
      And this, as I understand, will be talking about both the immediate short-term improvements as well as some of the longer-term improvements, correct?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:03:28
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:03:29
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:03:31
      I'm going to be the wrap-up guy, hopefully, that's going to answer.
    • 02:03:34
      I've been making notes here about some of the other comments made, so hopefully we can run through this and I can answer a lot of the questions and comments that came up earlier.
    • 02:03:40
      Mr. Chairman, before we get into the topic of conversation, which is primarily the Norfolk Southern initiatives that we're doing in the 81 corridor,
    • 02:03:50
      I think it's very prudent for us as an agency and you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, to acknowledge that there are six railroad operators in the I-81 corridor.
    • 02:04:01
      CSX and Norfolk Southern are our two primary Class 1 railroads.
    • 02:04:05
      CSX and NS have primary emphasis with coal haulers down in the Kingsport, Bristol area through the Clinchfield Railway and Norfolk Southern as well.
    • 02:04:15
      As well as we run up the corridor with NS, as Mr. Schafer just showed you a few minutes ago,
    • 02:04:20
      and also CSX actually parallels the 81 corridor into Frederick County all the way down to Strasburg, Virginia.
    • 02:04:26
      We have four of our short-line railroads which the CTB has funded through the rail preservation program since 1991 for the exception of Chesapeake Western Railway has not participated.
    • 02:04:36
      But it's very prudent to say that these short-lines are a part of the transportation system in the corridor and also make up for these six railroads that offer that service.
    • 02:04:47
      Amtrak itself offers east-west service, the only passenger rail service that's found in this corridor, and that has a station stop on the Buckingham Branch Railroad in Stanton, Virginia.
    • 02:04:57
      Also, I'd like to mention, Mr. Chairman and members of the board, I would call out that there's $8.58 million in Six-Year Program this year of rail preservation funds for a total project of about $13.2 million.
    • 02:05:11
      And that's through the Buckingham Branch Railroad for the continuation of efficient intercity
    • 02:05:17
      Amtrak passenger operations on that line.
    • 02:05:20
      That project has helped us secure a good, sustainable schedule and efficient operation for Amtrak in the corridor as well.
    • 02:05:31
      Three major initiatives that we've been discussing back and forth today as well has been the Heartland Corridor Initiative, the ID.1 rail infrastructure improvements, which are the short-term improvements, and then the ID.1 freight rail study that leads us on to the more
    • 02:05:45
      Longer-term or legacy projects that set forth the strategy to help improve the transportation and rail network that's in the I-81 corridor.
    • 02:05:54
      To date, there's been over $89 million in public and private funds allocated to projects in this corridor.
    • 02:06:01
      The Heartland Corridor, which is the East-West Initiative, there's $31.9 million total project cost, $57 million
    • 02:06:09
      is the minimum cost that's been identified for those short-term rail infrastructure improvements that's attached to that $40 million of state funding that came as a general fund appropriation.
    • 02:06:19
      And there's $75,000 that has been expended by the Commonwealth on the I-81 freight rail study, which I'll go into a little more detail in just a minute.
    • 02:06:28
      Norfolk Southern and their collaborative and cooperative agreement has paid in full the modeling costs and Woodside efforts to provide to us the 2012 data which Director Tucker commented about just a minute ago.
    • 02:06:42
      The Heartland Corridor Initiative kicked off with the four-tunnel clearance project in Virginia.
    • 02:06:48
      This project is associated with 28 obstructions on the Heartland Corridor.
    • 02:06:53
      This project encompasses about $9.75 million of rail enhancement funds and also includes a $5 million tunnel improvement from the federal government through FHWA Eastern Land Division.
    • 02:07:06
      The four double stack tunnel initiative will be complete after three years in 2009 and we continue as the agency and the Commonwealth in evaluating collaboratively the ten sites for locating a new intermodal facility somewhere in the Roanoke region.
    • 02:07:21
      We hope that that decision, and we anticipate that decision to be coming forth late this fall or early in the winter of this 2007.
    • 02:07:30
      And the entire initiative that began here, which will be complete in 2009 in three years, will be in service, hopefully with the three intermodal facilities constructed and in service and parallel.
    • 02:07:45
      That's a $249 million multi-state initiative
    • 02:07:50
      A hundred and fifty-eight million of that, Mr. Chairman and members of the board, has been allocated or committed by both public and private funds.
    • 02:07:57
      So the phase one improvement will be up and running and we will see service in place in 2009.
    • 02:08:02
      The Virginia-only project is 31.9 million dollars of rail enhancement funds that were funded over a three fiscal year period.
    • 02:08:10
      22.35 of that is $9.75 million in the tunnels and $12.6 million for the intermodal facility.
    • 02:08:17
      $9.6 million is our private-public partnership obligation of north and southern as the 30% match to that project.
    • 02:08:25
      In 2005, when we did the public benefit analysis of this project, I was to set out and remove 150,000 truckloads a year when built out for the Virginia-only projects, and 129 million gallons of fuel was anticipated to savings over the 20-year period.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:43
      If I could just highlight that point, Heartland's Corridor is roughly a $250 million initiative.
    • 02:08:50
      The Virginia share is 11, 12% of that.
    • 02:08:55
      And that's a good example of a multi-state initiative with federal leadership in it.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:09:03
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:09:03
      That's a very good point.
    • 02:09:06
      Now onto some more short-term projects.
    • 02:09:08
      There's the general fund appropriation by the General Assembly in their 2007 session, which set out $65 million of funds to be shared in the I-95 and I-81 corridors.
    • 02:09:21
      As the Commonwealth Transportation Board may recall in the Six-Year Program,
    • 02:09:24
      Forty million dollars of that funding was set out for improvements in the I-81 corridor that were directly associated with the phase one of what was identified in the REBE study of 2004.
    • 02:09:36
      Primarily that's the choke point initiative that Mr. Schafer and others have commented on today and that is primarily from the track section between Manassas and Front Royal, Riverton, Virginia.
    • 02:09:47
      In April, once the General Assembly had appropriated those funds and the Act was signed into law, DRPT contacted Norfolk Southern and asked them to go ahead and work with us to develop a little bit better engineering and cost estimation on these projects.
    • 02:10:02
      A letter of no prejudice was issued in May of this year and Norfolk Southern has worked forward through that letter of no prejudice and developed the engineering and cost estimation and we are working on the four sites for the signings and
    • 02:10:14
      to get the signalization in.
    • 02:10:17
      We're working on developing and negotiating a contract agreement as we speak and we hope to have that agreement up and running and executed by November, the end of November this month.
    • 02:10:27
      And construction will be complete in 2008.
    • 02:10:30
      And Mr. Chairman, this is a bi-directional rail facility from start in May shovel in the ground and in service by 2008.
    • 02:10:38
      We're looking at 18 in no more than 24 months.
    • 02:10:41
      That's an enormous turnaround where we can start seeing benefits
    • 02:10:44
      and construction of what will be a bi-directional railroad, as I'll explain in just a minute.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:49
      And this, again, just if you go back to the map in the Norfolk Southern presentation, this is a segment between Manassas and Front Royal.
    • 02:11:00
      So there will be construction completed on the first, there's actually two phases, so that first phase will be completed by the end of next calendar year, is that correct?
    • 02:11:08
      That is correct, yes, sir.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:09
      Mr. Secretary, do you know, or maybe does Kevin know,
    • 02:11:14
      That cut off that the Norfolk Southern gentleman referred to, is that a real project or is that a hoped for project?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:22
      I would characterize that as a broad concept.
    • 02:11:28
      That's why it is a broad concept.
    • 02:11:30
      That I would note, carefully straddles two construction districts.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:11:36
      Then it would be a gleam in the eye.
    • 02:11:38
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, if I may, I'll continue.
    • 02:11:43
      That's a good question, thank you.
    • 02:11:44
      Onward to the Manassas to Front Royal improvements.
    • 02:11:50
      I want to point out, Mr. Chairman, for $30.9 million, we basically turn a one-way railroad into a two-way railroad.
    • 02:11:57
      The wonderful part of this is with these four same extensions, I'll put this in bridge terms because Matt's got me thinking about one-way roads because he's a road kind of guy too as well, but we're like crossing a one-way bridge.
    • 02:12:09
      If we have another train that wants to oppose the cars that want to cross that bridge, they can't do that today on this railroad.
    • 02:12:15
      So for 51 miles, a long intermodal train today ties up that railroad for that entire 51 miles.
    • 02:12:23
      And what these four signings will do is allow Norfolk Southern to efficiently operate bi-directional train service.
    • 02:12:31
      So four signings at 11,000 feet apiece, 44,000 feet.
    • 02:12:35
      At $30.9 million, we basically turned a 51-mile railroad into a railroad that can run five directions.
    • 02:12:42
      And the placement of those sidings is critical.
    • 02:12:45
      It has been modeled by Norfolk Southern's experts, their modeling experts, to show where the conflicts are on that railroad and where the locations will fall into play so that, as Bill Schafer said,
    • 02:12:55
      While the truckers are parked, they want to run their railroads so that they can be obviously cost effective.
    • 02:13:00
      So we don't want trains to rest in this area.
    • 02:13:02
      We want them to continue to move, and that's why it's considered a choke point today.
    • 02:13:06
      Trains have to wait in order for one train to pass the entire lane before an opposing train can enter into that territory.
    • 02:13:12
      In addition to that, the traffic control system, as Mr. Schafer mentioned earlier, will have direct benefits to the Virginia Railway Express.
    • 02:13:20
      Obviously, when you run passenger trains, you want to run as many passenger trains as possible.
    • 02:13:25
      Having a signalized system in place for the entire length of that road is going to give us an opportunity as well for Virginia Railway Express to operate on that line in a safer fashion than it would have in what they call dark territory today, which means they go into tracks that don't have signals.
    • 02:13:39
      The new mainline will also combine that five-mile siding combination in Front Royal.
    • 02:13:45
      That also has a direct benefit to the Virginia Inland Port because it allows, because Mr. Secretary, this runs actually behind the Virginia Inland Port, it allows an intermodal train to stop and work the Inland Port and still allow trains to travel on that line uninterrupted.
    • 02:14:01
      So that's the benefit of the five-mile trackage there.
    • 02:14:05
      The total improvements have been identified by Norfolk Southern are nearly $61 million.
    • 02:14:11
      I want to be upfront with the board is that this is nearly one half of what is needed for what we call the phase one short-term improvements of about $126 million.
    • 02:14:21
      With that $40 million rail enhancement funds follows with it a $17 million shared public-private cost by Norfolk Southern as a match to this grant.
    • 02:14:33
      and we also, as you recall in the Six-Year Program, we have a $5 million shared contingency between CSX on those I-95 projects and also on the remaining, the phase one, first phase projects in case there is a cost overrun based on what we thought our cost estimation would be.
    • 02:14:50
      So if we anticipate running into that shared contingency, there'll be about a $4 million gap there that we'll have to look at.
    • 02:14:56
      Mr. Chairman, that's about $2.8 million out of that contingency will come as well as $1.2 million in national, north and southern.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:04
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:15:16
      In summary, Mr. Chairman, we have some other related improvements that also have been planned for the future of expanded passenger rail service.
    • 02:15:26
      We have the
    • 02:15:27
      Major rail crossing on Route 28 that was just recently announced by the Governor as being a construction initiative just in the past several weeks.
    • 02:15:36
      Now I want to digress if I may.
    • 02:15:39
      As with VDOT has been working very cooperatively with DRPT and every time we have a bridge project that impacts the railroad that we have potential for future growth.
    • 02:15:50
      VDOT has worked collaboratively with us to make sure that there's enough width
    • 02:15:54
      either over on top of the bridge or under the bridge to allow us an opportunity to expand.
    • 02:15:59
      For example, primarily in the Richmond-Washington corridor, we want to have room for three tracks.
    • 02:16:02
      In this corridor here, we want to have another track in place along that territory for expanded passenger rail operations.
    • 02:16:09
      So this will also come back in a discussion I'll have under item number two under the action agenda.
    • 02:16:14
      Total Phase 1, I-81 Quarter Improvement Project.
    • 02:16:18
      The current cost estimate is approximately $126 million, as I mentioned just a few seconds ago.
    • 02:16:22
      $57 million is funded already as that joint match.
    • 02:16:27
      We have, depending on whether we use a contingency or not, it's strong to say we have a cost to complete or anywhere from $65 to $69 million that's a joint cost to complete.
    • 02:16:36
      That would be both with state and shared risk dollars on behalf of the matching railroad.
    • 02:16:42
      At one point, and it's in bold, members of the board, 40,000 trucks is what is being set out as the performance for this $40 million contract.
    • 02:16:52
      What is very good about this is that the Rail Enhancement Fund contract sets out, and we are, by law, purchasing a public benefit.
    • 02:17:02
      And if the public benefit is not reached or achieved, the railroad, through this contract agreement, has to pay a penalty on lack of performance.
    • 02:17:10
      So we, DRPTs, or the execution of our agreements, guarantee and protect the investment of the Commonwealth.
    • 02:17:17
      And in achieving that, if there is a failure to perform, we get that value back per container, plus the rate of interest that's set out as post-judgment from the General Assembly.
    • 02:17:27
      So we just want to make that point very clear to the Board that we're trying to be very, very good stewards of public funds, especially since they are being invested in a private rail facility.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:17:37
      This is a neutral two-part question.
    • 02:17:43
      It has nothing to do with the railroad's possible penalty.
    • 02:17:46
      By when would that 40,000 trucks be taken off the road approximately what year?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:17:53
      It's a ramp-up, Mr. Martin, very good question.
    • 02:17:55
      It starts about 2,000 trucks the first year and will run out almost to 77,000 trucks by year 15.
    • 02:18:01
      So for discussion purposes, the average for the entire 15-year period
    • 02:18:05
      equates out at 40,000 trucks per year.
    • 02:18:08
      It's a growth curve, sir.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:10
      And the other part of the question was, what does our data tell us about the increasing amount of freight that we can expect that the number of trucks that that's going to add, irrespective of this initiative?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:18:24
      It is anticipated that we will find from working through with Cambridge Systematics that we will be able to actually see the growth curve.
    • 02:18:32
      I don't have the exact numbers today.
    • 02:18:34
      Mr. Martin, but it's a very good question, and one will be coming back to you in spring of 2008 with an answer, too.
    • 02:18:39
      As to what is the projected growth of trucks, I'll talk a little bit about that growth in just a minute.
    • 02:18:44
      I have another slide discussing that based on the truck count at the Tennessee border.
    • 02:18:47
      I'm going to try to get to the point about a net, what that actually would look like, if it would be an improvement at all.
    • 02:18:54
      Right, and I'll have a slide on that just showing what the truck growth will be, so hopefully that will be proportionate as well to the rail.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:00
      Mr. McPherson.
    • 02:19:01
      40,000 trucks each year is how much of the total truck per year traffic?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:19:10
      The total truck per year traffic on Norfolk Southern today as a base is 300,000 trucks on that line per year.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:19
      No, no, no.
    • 02:19:19
      How many trucks on the highway that we're going to remove?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:19:23
      Well, your question to me is how many trucks would you remove with the 40,000 trucks?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:28
      Actually, let me refresh.
    • 02:19:30
      If I understand what you're saying, you're saying you're going to take 40,000 trucks from Virginia's roads?
    • 02:19:36
      Right.
    • 02:19:37
      Is that just I-81?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:19:38
      Primarily, it's I-81, I-77.
    • 02:19:41
      The 40,000 trucks has basically been identified by North and Southern as being coming from the Charlotte Atlanta area.
    • 02:19:47
      Remember how the Crescent Court initiative is operating?
    • 02:19:49
      Okay, but wait a minute.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:50
      Here's where I'm going with this.
    • 02:19:51
      All right.
    • 02:19:51
      That, in one sense, equates to maybe five trucks an hour.
    • 02:19:56
      Okay.
    • 02:19:57
      So, how many trucks are there
    • 02:20:01
      500 trucks an hour, or 300 trucks an hour, or how many trucks per year?
    • 02:20:07
      Is it 40,000 of a million trucks a year, or is it 40,000 of 100,000 trucks a year?
    • 02:20:14
      In other words, what really, how much of a percentage are we reducing truck traffic by this expenditure?
    • 02:20:23
      Not that I'm against the expenditure, but I just wanna know what we're getting for it.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:28
      Mr. McCarthy, Kevin and I engaged in this kind of discussion a couple of nights ago.
    • 02:20:41
      And I think by the end of the night, I ended up saying to Kevin, we just spent an hour on flawed analysis.
    • 02:20:47
      And I'll try to see if I can walk you walking back through it in terms of complexity of it.
    • 02:20:52
      We talked about a little while ago about Norfolk Southern currently through its intermodal business is moving about 300,000 40-foot truck equivalent units a day.
    • 02:21:04
      And we broke that number that night.
    • 02:21:06
      I think it came out to an average of 822 trucks per day.
    • 02:21:11
      And based upon the next slide that Kevin is going to go to, I think that the analysis that we did from through trucks from Tennessee all the way through Virginia, all the way through trucks that traveled the entire quarter,
    • 02:21:21
      I think the number was 5,600.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:21:23
      That's correct.
    • 02:21:23
      I have a slide up on the screen.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:25
      And if you did an additive number of all freight, rail, and truck moving through that corridor, I think the number was right around 13, 14% market share ratio for rail.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:21:35
      Is that correct?
    • 02:21:36
      That's at the 300,000.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:21:37
      Now, to go back to your question, when we talked about the 40,000 number, you have to also put it in the 40,000 number in the context of how we talked about the entire corridor and the entire network of making improvements.
    • 02:21:50
      How the improvements are additive, particularly are the improvements that we make in the state of Virginia.
    • 02:21:54
      Anything we do today, then that we build upon it only adds capacity.
    • 02:21:59
      But then you get the compounding impact of benefit when the multi-state improvements are made and increases the throughput, increased market share.
    • 02:22:06
      And so if you look at the Crescent Corridor discussion, I think the number was ultimately a million trucks taken off the road.
    • 02:22:15
      You sort of, if you gauge in this discussion, you can get to different market share outcomes essentially that you could almost come up with a 30-something percent, but it's a dangerous discussion to take you into because, again, the flows of traffic and business are not necessarily where you're purely taking one truck off the road that doesn't come back or doesn't get in the place.
    • 02:22:36
      And you don't necessarily account for the natural growth that occurs as a matter of hopefully the economy continuing to expand.
    • 02:22:42
      So I think we could work towards a number, but it would not be a number that I would want to stand up and say, this is a number that's a valid go-forward number.
    • 02:22:52
      It's really, you look at it, the 40,000 in the context of what is the capacity on the existing rail lines today?
    • 02:22:58
      What are they able to do?
    • 02:23:00
      And as Kevin illustrated in the previous discussion, they're not able to do that level of movement based upon the conditions of the track today.
    • 02:23:11
      They don't have the sidings to have the capacity.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:13
      Okay, all I'm trying to say is that let's compare apples to apples here.
    • 02:23:16
      You've got trucks per day on this slide and you had trucks per year on the other one.
    • 02:23:22
      And that's a factor of 365 difference.
    • 02:23:26
      And that's significant.
    • 02:23:28
      And what I'm trying to get to is if 40,000 per year, is that a significant number or not?
    • 02:23:34
      And if it is insignificant, what can we do to make it a significant number and what should be
    • 02:23:41
      Well, I guess the short answer is that's what we're doing as part of the study.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:59
      I don't want you to focus on the 40,000 number at the end of the 15-year performance period.
    • 02:24:05
      It's actually 75,000 trucks.
    • 02:24:09
      This is just a small element of the Phase 1 improvements that were identified.
    • 02:24:13
      Kevin alluded to the fact that we're doing a section of Phase 1 improvements that total out to $130 million.
    • 02:24:21
      So we're funding roughly the 40 plus to 30% on top of it.
    • 02:24:25
      So again, this is based upon the money that we just received from the 07 allocation.
    • 02:24:32
      So as we complete the study and get into next year, we'll be able to talk to you about what is the full benefit that we can expect that really give you an answer.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:39
      Well, this is what I'm asking.
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:40
      And thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:42
      What I hope the study would say, among other things, is an affirmative target for diversion
    • 02:24:50
      in order to make the corridor work both multimodal train and freight road and train so that we come up with whatever a reasonable number might be, 20% or some such number to be able to say this is what it would take to do that rather than backing into it by saying they gave us $65 million this year so let's see what we can do with that.
    • 02:25:15
      That's great and I don't mean to dismiss it
    • 02:25:19
      because it's important to step in the right direction.
    • 02:25:21
      But what would it really take?
    • 02:25:23
      Two billion dollars is what Norfolk Southern would do for this Crescent Corridor is one number.
    • 02:25:29
      What would it take to do some of these other things?
    • 02:25:31
      And I think the more honest we are about it, the more likely we'd get the money.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:36
      Well, let me jump in here.
    • 02:25:38
      One, we can get caught into an analytical morass if we're not careful.
    • 02:25:44
      I think there's a great deal of simplicity in saying we want X percentage diverted in the quarter.
    • 02:25:49
      One of the things this study shows is the target audience here is about 20% of the total truck traffic on the interstate system.
    • 02:25:59
      So we need to become more nuanced in how we think about moving freight.
    • 02:26:03
      That's number one.
    • 02:26:05
      And that is our responsibility as part of a planning exercise.
    • 02:26:08
      The important thing is the policy direction that's laid out in the code for the use of these rail fronts.
    • 02:26:14
      There's a public benefit calculus.
    • 02:26:17
      And so, yes, some of it is truck diversions, but other aspects of it are energy savings, air quality, employment growth.
    • 02:26:26
      There's a whole host of things that we all factor into decision making on most of our investment decisions here, a simple extension
    • 02:26:36
      of a road that may cost a lot of money but brings a lot of jobs we gladly support.
    • 02:26:41
      And so one of the things that DRPT is trying to do is systematize that a little bit.
    • 02:26:46
      So I would be cautious about laying down a broad target because, again, think back to the initial presentation, 30 colleges and universities, battlefields, economic growth.
    • 02:27:02
      manufacturing, short haul versus long haul.
    • 02:27:05
      A single blanket diversion rate probably is going to be a misleading number.
    • 02:27:11
      And the important thing is if we have limited resources for investment, are we investing those wisely?
    • 02:27:18
      And that's why the public benefit calculus, that's what it's there for.
    • 02:27:22
      Because what's different about this is we are taking public dollars and investing it in a private rail network.
    • 02:27:28
      And that's why there is that very transparent standard for that.
    • 02:27:32
      So I agree with you that there does need to be consistency of measurement and that's something we talked about previously and that I think can be done in a more transparent and consistent manner.
    • 02:27:46
      But to say that a diversion ratio that makes sense in width, in the width they'll stretch with the overlap of 77 is the same for through the middle of James Madison campus
    • 02:27:58
      I think that's going down the wrong path.
    • 02:28:00
      There are very different calculus in both of those locations.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:03
      And I don't disagree with that, Mr. Secretary.
    • 02:28:06
      What I'm saying is that the aggregate numbers don't get to any of that.
    • 02:28:10
      And all I'm asking is that we do exactly what you're talking about is present it in a realistic fashion that shows us on a consistent measure basis what will happen if we take this path, that path, or the other path.
    • 02:28:24
      That's all.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:24
      Agreed.
    • 02:28:25
      And I would say as
    • 02:28:27
      These partnerships have matured that staff has gotten better at analyzing those.
    • 02:28:35
      And the note I would caution is these investments are not just about diverting trucks.
    • 02:28:43
      There's a lot more there.
    • 02:28:44
      So I think that's a useful measure to get that apples-to-apples comparison.
    • 02:28:48
      But as we know from highway investments, we don't think surely about
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:53
      Mr. Chairman, I was getting at another point earlier that has been brought forward a second time now about the public investment where we invest in a private company for public return.
    • 02:29:15
      Is there factored into the study the concept of buying equity and owning
    • 02:29:22
      in partnership with the private companies, many of these properties, rather than just simply investing public money in the hope that there's gonna be some public benefit.
    • 02:29:33
      Is that a serious part of the discussion as well at this point, or is it more looking to justify why we spend $40 million on a private company for the public benefit?
    • 02:29:47
      What about some ownership, and what about some equity
    • 02:29:51
      that can later be sold back to the public.
    • 02:29:55
      Is that a part of the thinking at all or is that an alien thought at this point in the studies that we're doing?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:01
      You know, Mr. Davis, and this is actually a very important question.
    • 02:30:05
      And in fact, where the Virginia program, which if you've got any of the rail conferences, folks will tell you that Virginia is the cutting edge program.
    • 02:30:13
      We moved away from buying assets in the railroad, which is still a requirement of federal funds because it hamstrung
    • 02:30:21
      of public investment.
    • 02:30:22
      So yeah, you can own a switch or a siding, but the market capitalization for these facilities, I wouldn't even begin to guess that are extraordinary.
    • 02:30:31
      The cost of individual capital facilities are extraordinary.
    • 02:30:37
      And in fact, one of the bridges that was crossed with this 2005 legislation was to say, we're not buying an asset, we're buying a result.
    • 02:30:47
      And it's a little bit like economic development incentives.
    • 02:30:51
      If the jobs materialize, great.
    • 02:30:53
      The incentive was well spent.
    • 02:30:55
      If the jobs don't materialize, we want it back.
    • 02:30:58
      And that's a fairly profound change from the way the program had previously been structured where there was an ownership right in a signal or a switch or some small portion that was a real kind of a chalkboard.
    • 02:31:09
      And we got no return on that investment and no way of gauging the return.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:31:15
      The only reason I raise the question again
    • 02:31:18
      is because I think for small investments what you're saying makes good sense that the public benefits and therefore put the money in it and let it go.
    • 02:31:28
      But when you start talking about investing a billion dollars or half a billion dollars of the Commonwealth's money, I think you need something more tangible in return in order to get the public support for it.
    • 02:31:38
      Even, I mean, it's done in Europe, it's done in other parts of the world where public money is invested in private entities.
    • 02:31:44
      They even own them and then they privatize them in 20 or 30 years.
    • 02:31:47
      I'd just like to make sure that we're studying those options for when we get into the larger investments.
    • 02:31:53
      I really wouldn't quibble if we're spending $20 million or $40 million.
    • 02:31:57
      But if we start talking about spending a billion or half a billion dollars in partnership, then I think the other has to be considered.
    • 02:32:05
      That's the reason I was asking if it is included in the thinking.
    • 02:32:08
      And I think what you're saying to me is that we've gone away from that thinking at this point.
    • 02:32:13
      But I think I'm going to suggest that maybe
    • 02:32:15
      For the larger sums of money, it should come back into our attention.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:20
      Thank you.
    • 02:32:20
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • 02:32:21
      Mr. Chairman, here's what's really interesting to me about Jim's comment about equity.
    • 02:32:29
      I'm listening to the numbers that Bill Schafer put out, and Kevin, you have it.
    • 02:32:34
      And I'm not sure I've got these right.
    • 02:32:35
      And I understand that they're very broad, general, rough numbers.
    • 02:32:41
      at this point.
    • 02:32:43
      But Bill Schafer was talking about a $2 billion investment in the I-81 capital crescent system with the potential diversion of a million through trucks through the system.
    • 02:32:57
      Now, just for the moment, I'm going to make the assumption that if there's a diversion of a million through trucks through the system, that that would equate to those trucks being diverted off of I-81 through Virginia as well as everywhere else.
    • 02:33:11
      And I think the Secretary's point about that diversion is not going to be uniform is a very good point and fair one.
    • 02:33:18
      But let's just put that aside for the moment for working purposes.
    • 02:33:23
      So you've got, and if you're at 5,600 through-truck trips through Virginia a day, just trying to do that in my head, I'm coming up with something like a million six, million seven through-truck trips a year.
    • 02:33:40
      on the I-81 corridor through Virginia.
    • 02:33:44
      So if you could spend $2 billion to divert a million out of a million seven through trucks, that's a huge diversion.
    • 02:33:59
      Now, let's also look, Kevin, if you can go back to the other slide that you had there that showed the growth in the freight traffic on I-81.
    • 02:34:09
      It was the one where you had the 5,600, yeah, going up to 13,300 in 2035.
    • 02:34:17
      So maybe in the roughest of numbers, that 1,006,007 turns into, what, 3.5 million through truck trips a year in 2035.
    • 02:34:31
      And let's assume all of this capital crescent took
    • 02:34:36
      A substantial number of years to kick in in terms of the investment.
    • 02:34:40
      Even relative to $3.5 million through truck trips a year, a diversion of a million is huge, I would think, and would have a huge impact on level of service on the highway.
    • 02:34:55
      Even a diversion of much less than that, I would think, would have a huge impact of level of service.
    • 02:35:02
      And then I just want to put that in the context of, for example,
    • 02:35:05
      The Star Solutions proposal, which was to spend, I don't remember the numbers, $10 billion, $12 billion to do the additional lanes on I-81 to achieve level of service improvements.
    • 02:35:23
      And so I'm thinking to myself, well, you look at a $10 billion investment.
    • 02:35:28
      Put aside where the money comes from and whether it's generated by fees or whatever.
    • 02:35:35
      A $10 billion investment to achieve a certain level of service improvement versus a $2 billion investment to achieve a certain level of service improvement.
    • 02:35:47
      I mean, I don't know.
    • 02:35:48
      The $2 billion sounds better to me than the $10.
    • 02:35:52
      But my point, but I also understand that that $2 billion was a multi-state corridor long investment and you don't have total control over that.
    • 02:36:02
      But this is where Jim's point comes in.
    • 02:36:04
      And I understand I'm sort of stretching the envelope in terms of the thinking here, but how weird would it be to contemplate the idea that Virginia would spend the $2 billion, invest, excuse me, the $2 billion to make those improvements for the partnership on some basis with Norfolk Southern for the entire Capital Crescent Corridor, whether the other states or the federal government stepped to the plate or not.
    • 02:36:32
      Particularly if Virginia got some sort of equity or investment return on that money, as I would think that Norfolk Southern would be looking at providing to anybody who put up that kind of capital, and particularly if it was eight or ten billion dollars less than the money we were going to spend to widen the highway.
    • 02:36:55
      Now, recognizing that that money was going to come from tolls on
    • 02:37:00
      Trucks and so forth, something the trucking industry wasn't particularly happy about.
    • 02:37:05
      But maybe this $2 billion also comes from some toll arrangement on I-81.
    • 02:37:13
      And maybe it applies just to trucks.
    • 02:37:14
      Maybe it applies to cars and trucks.
    • 02:37:16
      I don't know.
    • 02:37:18
      There are a lot of ways to raise $2 billion.
    • 02:37:20
      My only point is that if you could solve a problem for $2 billion rather than $10 billion and you could get some equity return in the process,
    • 02:37:30
      All of a sudden, everything we're looking at here in the big context strikes me as making a lot of sense and potentially very productive.
    • 02:37:40
      Obviously, we have to zero in on what the diversions really are, and as you pointed out, it's probably a whole lot more sophisticated than a sort of a blanket diversion, but it just sounds to me, looking at that big picture, like it sure is well worth the study.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:37:59
      And that's why we're spending millions of dollars on consultants to answer that question.
    • 02:38:04
      And we can all discuss potential ways to spend somewhere between $2 and $8 billion that we don't have.
    • 02:38:13
      But I think your point there is there are smarter and dumber ways to invest dollars.
    • 02:38:23
      And we are acquiring the tools to make those decisions.
    • 02:38:29
      At the end of the day, for the kind of sweeping corridor-wide changes that are being discussed, those cannot be done without improvements in other states.
    • 02:38:40
      And so, where our focus needs to be is on getting some limits on this corridor.
    • 02:38:48
      Does it go up to Canada?
    • 02:38:49
      Does it go down to Louisiana?
    • 02:38:50
      Does it go into Texas?
    • 02:38:52
      And working with our freight partners,
    • 02:38:56
      and we do have to remember there's a competitive situation with railroads and yes, we have a great partnership with Norfolk Southern but I think one of the very first slides is there are six rail providers in this corridor.
    • 02:39:05
      We need to look at that in its totality and again, start layering the different sets of issues and problems on top of it.
    • 02:39:17
      It may very well be that the long haul freight is the low hanging fruit.
    • 02:39:22
      It might be that the urban congestion is, for example.
    • 02:39:26
      We don't know until we have all of those pieces together.
    • 02:39:32
      What if the Culpeper Cutoff were to occur?
    • 02:39:35
      What would that do?
    • 02:39:36
      We don't know the answers to those kinds of what-if questions.
    • 02:39:42
      We do know in the short term, and again, based on available resources, we're talking billions.
    • 02:39:47
      And the reality is we have $65 million to spend on rail improvements here.
    • 02:39:52
      So we kind of come back to that.
    • 02:39:53
      is seeing a different way of doing business and hopefully doing it right and smart and asking the hard questions about the incremental value of this because the numbers between what we have available and the need that everybody around this table has driven, that's a huge, huge gulf there.
    • 02:40:16
      So what I would suggest
    • 02:40:18
      Again, I think when we get the freight diversion study, when is that due?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:40:25
      Spring of 08.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:26
      Spring of 08.
    • 02:40:27
      We'll have a powerful tool for answering those questions and a methodology we'll be able to apply corridor-wide, hopefully.
    • 02:40:35
      And that, in the meantime, we look at what's the good that we can do with these, hopefully, smart investments and
    • 02:40:43
      And our job as sort of a board of directors is to ensure that these investments do actually have a reasonable rate of return and that there is a public benefit to these investments even though they're small in relation to the whole.
    • 02:40:57
      But, you know, all points well taken and I do think Mr. McCarthy's thing about standardizing the measurements is a point well taken because we need to start talking in those more consistent terms.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:41:09
      Mr.
    • 02:41:09
      Page.
    • 02:41:11
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:41:12
      I'll lead on now to this study, which has been a good topic of conversation.
    • 02:41:17
      Three maps very quickly I'll run through.
    • 02:41:20
      Phase 1 improvements is broken into two sub-phases, as the Chairman pointed out earlier.
    • 02:41:25
      The first $40 million is covered in kind of the purple colors, and then the remaining, which is still an evolution of a list of projects,
    • 02:41:35
      are the yellow projects as well.
    • 02:41:38
      This is the phase two of part one of the first initial funding, that $126 million.
    • 02:41:44
      The number one in Hagerstown, which is part of that sub-phase two is not a Virginia improvement, but that is an improvement.
    • 02:41:50
      I think we do need to acknowledge that at Hagerstown there is another choke point.
    • 02:41:54
      So we need to also work with our partners in other states and cooperatively with Norfolk Southern
    • 02:42:00
      that this is an iterative process that doesn't only just involve Virginia.
    • 02:42:04
      It involves a collaborative effort of other states and our operator as well.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:42:11
      Since we have that in here, does that mean we would be willing to, we are considering funding?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:42:16
      No.
    • 02:42:17
      No.
    • 02:42:17
      This is just a list of what Norfolk Southern says is the next group of choke points.
    • 02:42:22
      And in no way, and that's why I called this out, do we feel that that's a Virginia responsibility?
    • 02:42:27
      We just need to put it on the list that
    • 02:42:29
      Phase one included not only improvements for Virginia, but also improvements outside of Virginia.
    • 02:42:34
      So I just wanted to acknowledge that, Mr. Davis.
    • 02:42:38
      Thank you.
    • 02:42:38
      Down in Southwest Virginia, Montgomery Tunnel, which is out on the north to west or east-west line, the Heartland Quarterline, actually, it's a double-bore tunnel, has an east and west route.
    • 02:42:50
      One of those two routes has not been double-stacked yet, so they would bring that into a bi-directional traffic mode, and also Lincoln sidings,
    • 02:42:57
      All the way down to Bristol from Walton, which is just west of Christiansburg, Lexburg area.
    • 02:43:03
      Again, this is just like that 51-mile stretch that I just described earlier as being a one-way railroad.
    • 02:43:08
      This is basically a one-way railroad because it lacks those long sidings.
    • 02:43:12
      Now, on to the topic of discussion that has led us to talk more about the larger, bigger picture of where we're headed with the modeling and the improvements is the ID.1 freight rail study.
    • 02:43:23
      The ID-1 freight rail study is an effort that will determine the maximum feasible truck diversion of truck traffic to rail.
    • 02:43:32
      That is to determine through the cooperative effort of Norfolk Southern
    • 02:43:36
      to look at this corridor not only through Virginia but look outside of Virginia because obviously we need to think about Norfolk Southern on several times as presented and we as well.
    • 02:43:46
      A 500 plus mile haul is what usually attributes to a good intermodal competitive operation and we will look as well in Pennsylvania and New York, Tennessee and others and also take a look at the roll on roll off as a future potential technology.
    • 02:44:01
      This includes coordination with other states in the corridor and we hope to have this complete by spring of 2008.
    • 02:44:06
      The study status, to bring you up quickly and briefly, the truck diversion estimates are in.
    • 02:44:11
      They've just been transferred to Norfolk Southern, and Norfolk Southern has transferred their information to our consultant based on their calculations.
    • 02:44:20
      Based on that, you've seen this slide already talking about the growth, which was discussed earlier.
    • 02:44:24
      Fifty-eight percent of the trucks across the state lines fall out in those categories showing the growth rates as were discussed earlier.
    • 02:44:31
      We will also look further into the financial evaluation.
    • 02:44:35
      Dr. Davis, you brought up some good points as well.
    • 02:44:37
      It's the comparative return on the investment, the future fuel price scenarios, some alternative funding sources like safety lieu, Federal Railroad Administration, bond financing, and the PPTA concept will also be looked at.
    • 02:44:49
      Estimated construction costs and schedule for completion of track upgrades and grade separation are also going to be directly related to the output, which is the
    • 02:44:58
      The next steps of the project is for our consultant through the DRPT multi-modal office cooperative effort is to work to evaluate the diversions including the public benefit calculation based on the RAF public benefit model, develop a priority of projects looking out towards what other incentives need to be put together as a package of improvements for both Tennessee, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and New York.
    • 02:45:23
      and identify funding sources and prioritize those projects for a kick start for construction.
    • 02:45:29
      That concludes my presentation, Mr. Chairman, and I'm available as well as Bill Schafer to answer any questions at this time.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:38
      First question, Kevin, are you going to factor, this is a question I asked earlier and the Secretary suggested that I wait, are you going to factor in current fuel prices in terms of looking at the diversion on the assumption
    • 02:45:53
      That freight on rail is more energy efficient than freight on trucks.
    • 02:45:57
      As fuel prices go higher, rail should have a comparatively greater competitive advantage.
    • 02:46:04
      Are you going to factor that into your thinking on the freight rail study?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:46:09
      The public benefit model, as it's established today, factors in and it has the ability to factor in for the cost of fuel savings between the motor truck and the railroad locomotive.
    • 02:46:18
      In addition to that, it also brings things back to net present value and also extends them out into future cost scenarios.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:24
      Okay, so the answer is yes.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:46:25
      The answer is yes.
    • 02:46:26
      Thank you.
    • 02:46:29
      Thank you.
    • 02:46:29
      Matt will bring that to my question later.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:35
      I could go now or I can wait until somebody else.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:38
      Any other questions?
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:46:41
      You mentioned, Kevin, that
    • 02:46:43
      There was a total investment of about $125 or $130 million of which this first $40 and the $17, which added up to the $65, was sort of the first half of it.
    • 02:46:58
      But you didn't describe what the second half of that is, that other roughly $60 or $65 million.
    • 02:47:05
      What's that being used for?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:47:07
      That's the second part of the phase two, which we're working through with Norfolk Southern
    • 02:47:11
      What I stated to you earlier on the map was basically looking at what had been identified in the Reedy study and other studies that had followed that.
    • 02:47:19
      Norfolk Southern through the Woodside cooperative effort, we're determining through the modeling as to what the next iterative process of the phasing is.
    • 02:47:27
      And so we hope to come back to the board in spring of 2008 and also have a list of projects that will show in a priority order and recommendations go forward with the strategy of completing phase one in subsequent phases in the future.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:39
      Are they likely to be improvements on the section of the rail corridor that runs parallel to I-81?
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 02:47:47
      In theory, we're looking at all of those corridors, including the Culpeper Cut-Off, and the list will be established.
    • 02:47:52
      Obviously, Culpeper Cut-Off will be a legacy project.
    • 02:47:54
      That's a pretty substantial cost project.
    • 02:47:55
      Right.
    • 02:47:56
      But we will be looking at both corridors in this analysis study.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:00
      Okay.
    • 02:48:00
      That's not fun.
    • 02:48:01
      There's no funding yet, as I understand, for the other projects.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:05
      Frankly for him, but the Phase I, which is roughly $120, $130 million, includes all of the improvements between Front Royal and Manassas, as well as the improvements in yellow that we saw down in Bristol.
    • 02:48:20
      That's the $130 million.
    • 02:48:23
      About half of that is funded.
    • 02:48:25
      The only reason that is funded is the one-time general fund surplus.
    • 02:48:29
      So there is no funding for the second half of Phase I.
    • 02:48:33
      Phase II is still yet to be determined.
    • 02:48:37
      Everybody understand that?
    • 02:48:39
      We don't have the funding to complete Phase I, which is a baby step.
    • 02:48:43
      I think we would all agree.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:47
      I think, Mr. Chairman, that's why you're hearing concerns about the investment decision.
    • 02:48:53
      We don't see, you know, if we're a private equity firm, we're going to look a lot further than just what one investor gave us for one year.
    • 02:49:01
      It's hard to have vision when you have those kind of walls in front of you.
    • 02:49:11
      It's all about money.
    • 02:49:13
      And changing the assembly a little.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:17
      Okay, any other questions or comments?
    • 02:49:20
      Ms.
    • 02:49:20
      Page, thank you.
    • 02:49:20
      Thank you, sir.
    • 02:49:21
      Great work.
    • 02:49:24
      We have two more presentations I think we can do quickly to wrap up 81.
    • 02:49:28
      The next presentation is on the I-81 safety and operational improvements and then Mr. Fred Altizer, the I-81 program manager.
    • 02:49:36
      Welcome, Mr. Altizer.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:49:47
      We've all gotten so technologically competent.
    • 02:49:52
      Good afternoon.
    • 02:49:53
      I just don't put any secretary of the members of the board
    • 02:49:57
      It's been almost a year, a couple weeks since we were here last year and the CTB passed a resolution asking us to look at various things.
    • 02:50:07
      We received our rod from the Federal Highway Administration back in June.
    • 02:50:13
      I'm here today to update you on our current status with taking you more on what's been going on.
    • 02:50:20
      I want to begin today with a few trends on safety and I'll try to get through these real quick
    • 02:50:26
      I know somebody's got some questions, and this slide shows just a general increase in the last six years of traffic.
    • 02:50:34
      04 for some reason shows a rather dramatic gain, but it drops off in 05 and 06.
    • 02:50:43
      And that's pretty much the way the entire state average traffic
    • 02:50:52
      Well, traffic deaths, on the other hand, it's interesting to note that traffic, as we have deaths attributed on I-81, has continued to decline, and even in 2004 when traffic already decreased, we did have a low number of deaths that particular year.
    • 02:51:10
      In general, it's back on the epsilon.
    • 02:51:13
      That has to do with, of course, increase in traffic and number of deaths per million miles.
    • 02:51:22
      Here's a couple of interesting facts that 42% of all the deaths on 81 involved a truck.
    • 02:51:28
      In comparison, about a 30% on I-95 that involved a truck.
    • 02:51:34
      So that's kind of a
    • 02:51:36
      An idea of how 81 looks in terms of truck accidents involving capacity.
    • 02:51:49
      Here is a comparison we tried to make with the four interstates and the number of traffic deaths.
    • 02:51:58
      Pretty quickly you can see where 81 is in the lighter colors.
    • 02:52:03
      is close to 95, but in the outlying years, it increases even by 64.
    • 02:52:09
      In a couple of years, it's slower.
    • 02:52:12
      So what's the direction of the board last year in looking at safety improvements in short-term truck lanes?
    • 02:52:21
      I want to give you a real quick update on that now that you look at this.
    • 02:52:25
      We have two traffic management centers now online.
    • 02:52:29
      One in Salem just came online a couple of weeks ago.
    • 02:52:32
      Those will really help get information out to our traveling public and to people who use 81.
    • 02:52:41
      The variable message signs, it's interesting to note here, these signs not only help the drivers when they're on 81, but we've got several of those on the roads that approach
    • 02:52:52
      So when you have a congestion or you got incident management, we try to make the drivers aware that there's a problem on 81 so they can make a decision before they get out there.
    • 02:53:03
      There's 12 roadway weather stations out there now and plans to make a couple more.
    • 02:53:13
      We have Safety Service Patrol on about a third of the entire corridor, and that's one of the things we probably hear more positive comments from our citizens and drivers that use this.
    • 02:53:27
      If you've ever been out there and you've got a flat tire or out of gas or need a problem, that's one vehicle you like to see in your rearview mirror pulled up to go Safety Service Patrol.
    • 02:53:37
      So we've got that.
    • 02:53:39
      We're going to start those, incidentally, in the Whipple area last month or sometime this month.
    • 02:53:47
      Give you a couple ideas about what we've done in the past year.
    • 02:53:51
      You'll see here a ramp extension.
    • 02:53:56
      In that northern right side, you'll see a bridge widening.
    • 02:54:04
      That's at route 50 and 81.
    • 02:54:07
      Dr. Davis gave a very, I thought, eloquent speech at the opening of that in terms of the death of a student who had to get killed on that bridge right where that ramp comes off.
    • 02:54:20
      That's a good example of what I call a small improvement, $10 million a lot of money, but it greatly, greatly improved the
    • 02:54:29
      I can tell you those that use that, all you have to do is go through that interchange and you see the difference today.
    • 02:54:44
      We have four bridges completed in Rockbridge County, about 60 million dollars those include over Buffalo Creek and Maury River.
    • 02:54:55
      You can see there are the
    • 02:54:56
      Truck Climbing Lane is about a little over a mile on the northbound lane.
    • 02:55:00
      Very similar to what we're going to be adding to two other locations on 81.
    • 02:55:05
      I'll talk about those in a minute.
    • 02:55:08
      Those were improvements for the bridge, rehabilitation project bridges that needed to be complete.
    • 02:55:18
      There's about a total of seven
    • 02:55:23
      improvements there in terms of ramp, axial and decal lanes.
    • 02:55:27
      And I can tell you this, the board passed this resolution and last October made decisions.
    • 02:55:33
      Some of these funds did not become available until last or July.
    • 02:55:38
      The districts have worked really, really hard in getting these contracts out.
    • 02:55:42
      And I think out of those, there's about four or five of those today out on the streets that bids come in, especially in your area in Winchester.
    • 02:55:50
      So we'll see some activity.
    • 02:55:51
      probably as early as this winter or early spring next year on these ranks.
    • 02:55:57
      We have some more that are in the Six-Year Plan.
    • 02:56:00
      They're a few more years out, so we'll be doing some additional work on those.
    • 02:56:06
      This is an example here at Winchester of those projects that will be underway.
    • 02:56:10
      Accel again, and Decel Lanes on, I think that's Route 7.
    • 02:56:17
      one of the most, one of the more expensive Accel and Decel projects but heavy development around that interchange and with the amount of traffic on 81 entering the main line gets to be a real critical and safety issue there.
    • 02:56:34
      Give you an idea of the profile of I-81 from Bristol to Winchester and this kind of defines why 81 is a little different
    • 02:56:45
      I-95, but you can see there the up and down of the mountain ranges.
    • 02:56:54
      What defines that is your topography in terms of your major drainage basin, the Tomah and Shenandoah View River going to Blacksburg.
    • 02:57:07
      This location that you're looking at here shows the two truck climbing lanes on the
    • 02:57:15
      Longest and steepest parts of the terrain.
    • 02:57:20
      Those were selected there north of Lexington, northbound and southbound from Montgomery County.
    • 02:57:31
      The profile of those I think speaks for itself.
    • 02:57:36
      We heard a lot about during public hearings on I-81 on Tier 1 of doing something in terms of getting
    • 02:57:43
      The Rockbridge County Truck Climbing Lane is about six miles in length.
    • 02:58:01
      It begins north of Lexington and goes a mile mark of 202 there.
    • 02:58:08
      In fact, we have a public hearing scheduled tomorrow night in Fairfield.
    • 02:58:13
      For that, we anticipate advising the public, of course, the impacts and so forth of that truck finding lane on the community there and across the area.
    • 02:58:25
      If everything goes right, we could, if we get an executed agreement with KBR and things work as they should, sometime late spring or mid-summer, we could see some activity as far as actual construction.
    • 02:58:47
      Montgomery County, that's what's commonly known here as Christiansburg Mountain.
    • 02:58:52
      That's about a little over eight miles in length.
    • 02:58:56
      We are just getting underway in terms of the engineering work on that project.
    • 02:59:03
      The Rock Bridge Truck Climbing Lane is about six to ten months ahead of our Montgomery County project because
    • 02:59:14
      Rockbridge County already had an existing project on that.
    • 02:59:19
      We had engineering work, some engineering work to perform it.
    • 02:59:23
      We could pick up and run with that project much quicker, but we had to start really from the beginning on Montgomery County section.
    • 02:59:31
      The schedule for that is public hearing mid to late summer of next year on that, and that project is about 72 million dollars, and I think, let's back up one here,
    • 02:59:43
      Rockbridge County, one is about $74 million, what's in the six-year plan.
    • 02:59:54
      With that, the last slide shows our unmet needs, and then I'll be glad to take some questions.
    • 02:59:59
      We have about 16 different other areas for ramp extensions that we could do.
    • 03:00:09
      We've done a portion of those about a third.
    • 03:00:12
      We need about 10 more additional truck climbing lanes, and those costs, if we take the two large ones out, we're down to about $200 million for those.
    • 03:00:23
      Our bridge needs on 81.
    • 03:00:26
      Several older bridges, as most interstates go, we're approaching about 40 years.
    • 03:00:32
      Most of 81 is built in the 60s, so the design life of these bridges are close,
    • 03:00:40
      There's 14 bridges identified as having structurally deficient areas that needs to be replaced.
    • 03:00:50
      With that, Richard Caywood, in a couple of minutes, is going to introduce a case study on Route Exit 150.
    • 03:00:57
      But I'll be glad to take some questions and try to answer your questions on it.
    • 03:01:02
      Yes, sir.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:04
      So for the two truck climbing lanes that you're proceeding with,
    • 03:01:08
      I think if you added them together you got to about $140 million dollars.
    • 03:01:12
      Is that the money that was being, the federal funds that were being released as a function of us having approved the Tier 1 EIS last fall?
    • 03:01:27
      Or is that from somewhere else?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:01:29
      The federal funds available for these two truck finding lanes were part of our earmark
    • 03:01:33
      for I-81, four separate earmarks in the last legislative, $100 million for trucks separated, $38 million for freight, managing freight and freight movement, $3.5 million for safety, and about a million plus or minus for ITS and variable mechanism.
    • 03:02:00
      But that, we don't,
    • 03:02:02
      I don't necessarily get all of that money, and Mr. Secretary, if you want to explain it, if Congress gives us a dollar, we only get about 80-some cents, but when you add back our stake net, we're up to about the original allocation on these two projects.
    • 03:02:22
      That's shocking.
    • 03:02:23
      I find that too.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:30
      Mr. Altizer, I'm not sure if we've covered this publicly before, but just to be safe, considering that Montgomery County is starting second with this truck behind me, we have already covered and gone over the analysis and talked to people who are doing the work, and there's no reasonable expectation that there would be any problem with the available funds.
    • 03:02:59
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:03:03
      We try to phase these projects so that if for some reason we find that the cost, these are preliminary estimates, first run estimates, so forth.
    • 03:03:15
      If we find that we do not have enough funds to cover one of these projects, they're phased in such a manner that they can be shortened
    • 03:03:24
      and a couple of different ways and we would just build a smaller project to fit the cost that we had.
    • 03:03:33
      But we did that on both projects because really we, to begin with, these were, again, first grown essence that we had on both of these processes.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:42
      So both of them are secure?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:44
      Correct.
    • 03:03:46
      And in the unlikely event that costs were ever to increase on a capital project,
    • 03:03:53
      Our first priority when we update the Six-Year Program is for those projects that are ready to go to construction, we have to deal with that inflation or increase.
    • 03:04:01
      That's always the first priority.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:04
      Ms. Conlon.
    • 03:04:05
      I'd like to know about the safety service patrols.
    • 03:04:09
      Is there any actual hard data to validate that increasing the area that covers does decrease
    • 03:04:19
      I know it may get into a sort of projecting what you may not have data to project, but it seems intuitively that it's a good idea, but to sell it and to show the public benefit
    • 03:04:35
      I'm wondering if you have some actual...
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:04:40
      I don't have that information, but I think that may be available.
    • 03:04:46
      We feel that in areas where we have an accident, where it could be an idea of change.
    • 03:04:51
      I do know that the state police within these areas are able to respond to other tragic situations much quicker.
    • 03:04:55
      When we're taking care of a fall or an accident, an incident with a track pile or whatever,
    • 03:05:00
      Mr. Chairman, the Research Council has studied the cost-benefit on safety service patrols
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:29
      as it has been done nationally.
    • 03:05:31
      So they look at it as not only, I think it's intangible about the piece of preventing, but it is a key to congestion management and safety response.
    • 03:05:47
      And Mr. Altizer is correct, it does free up emergency response personnel to other tasks.
    • 03:05:54
      So we are looking at expanding the service
    • 03:05:57
      significantly within the Commonwealth.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:03
      Thank you, Mr. Altizer.
    • 03:06:05
      The final presentation is Mr. Richard Caywood, and this is really to go over what many of us saw this morning on an excellent and very short tour.
    • 03:06:15
      I would encourage, while Richard's queuing this up, those of you who are driving north
    • 03:06:22
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 03:06:27
      I just want to welcome everybody to Roanoke.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:06:38
      I do have the privilege of being the host district administrator for the conference.
    • 03:06:46
      But I guess I have the unfortunate privilege of being speaker 3F after lunch, after everybody's been sitting for a long time.
    • 03:06:53
      But I want to start by just sharing something about the area.
    • 03:06:55
      I always like to try to educate folks when they're in town.
    • 03:06:58
      One interesting fact, if you look out that window and look down at Interstate 581, you'd be looking at the highest volume spot on the Interstate system west of Richmond with the volume equivalent to just east of 64th short pump.
    • 03:07:13
      Sometimes there's a thought that we don't have traffic at this part of the state, but we do, and you're actually here in the middle of it.
    • 03:07:19
      I do appreciate all the folks that went on the tour this afternoon.
    • 03:07:22
      I'm going to talk about specifically a interchange in Bonnetite County, but I think something that has application statewide.
    • 03:07:31
      First, just as far as location, exit 150, you see it here highlighted on the map.
    • 03:07:36
      It may look like just another interchange, but it's one of the busiest interchanges on the 81 corridor.
    • 03:07:42
      And the reason for that is you're at a topographical choke point.
    • 03:07:45
      So a lot of freight traffic moving to the north on 81 that wants to go to the Lynchburg area.
    • 03:07:51
      They go through exit 150, hit 460.
    • 03:07:53
      If they want to go north into either West Virginia or the Covington, Clifton, Forge area, they exit to the north there.
    • 03:08:01
      It's also the gateway for a lot of folks to the Smith Mountain Lake area.
    • 03:08:05
      And it's in the middle of three of the fastest growing counties in this area where they come together.
    • 03:08:09
      You have Bedford, Roanoke, and Botetourt.
    • 03:08:12
      So there's been heavy both residential and commercial investment and development right around this interchange over the past few years.
    • 03:08:21
      When you look at it a little bit closer, it's somewhat unique in terms of interchanges.
    • 03:08:26
      And not only do you have an interstate interchange with a major primary, in this case 81 running up and down in 220, which is a major primary route, you also have the parallel route, and this is combined 11 and 460.
    • 03:08:40
      So when you put these all together, you have three of my busiest primaries and one of the busiest sections of 81 that all come together in this extremely small geographical area.
    • 03:08:49
      And just like we saw the earlier slide from Winchester, you can see all the development right in the midst of that, which makes the operation very difficult.
    • 03:08:57
      When we look at it from a top-down view, you'll see we have a further challenge in that all the traffic that goes through comes to this one signal that kind of runs the interchange like a giant clock.
    • 03:09:07
      And what happens, one of the heaviest moves is off of 81 North coming into 220, into this direction.
    • 03:09:17
      The signal controls that ramp, so traffic can very easily back out onto 81.
    • 03:09:23
      You also have a big truck stop here, so you've got a lot of trucks trying to make these moves, which is very inefficient.
    • 03:09:29
      And the other challenge we face is there's no good way to get around this if there's a problem.
    • 03:09:34
      This is one of the largest truck stops in the state.
    • 03:09:37
      Not in terms necessarily of geographic area, but in terms of the number of trucks that go through here.
    • 03:09:43
      We're right in the middle of the corridor.
    • 03:09:45
      As everyone knows, fuel taxes are lower in Virginia, so almost every truck that goes into Virginia is going to stop at fuel in Virginia.
    • 03:09:52
      We're about halfway between the two state borders.
    • 03:09:55
      A lot of them stop here.
    • 03:09:56
      We're also very near a truck weigh station, so a lot of trucks stop here to check their weight before they go over the scale, so an extremely busy spot.
    • 03:10:06
      When I came here, there was a very large project in the Six-Year Plan to rebuild everything.
    • 03:10:11
      It was kind of the up to half a billion dollar pie-in-the-sky rebuild everything project.
    • 03:10:17
      About a year after I was here, this was scaled down to a more limited project where we were going to look at relocating 11460 to pull it away from 81 to get some separation and also rework the ramps.
    • 03:10:31
      That project had a right-of-way cost of over $100 million, just four right-of-way.
    • 03:10:36
      It was still over a $200 million or so project.
    • 03:10:41
      And last year when the board updated the Six-Year Plan, I think there was the thought that that's an awful lot of money to invest right here.
    • 03:10:48
      What can we do, maybe using our money a little more wisely?
    • 03:10:52
      And so the idea of looking at it from an operational and access management approach was derived and put into the plan.
    • 03:11:00
      And again, just looking at a little bit wider aerial view, you can see how all the development around the interchange really creates both challenges and opportunities.
    • 03:11:11
      This is probably one of the best examples of a disconnect between transportation and land use planning played out through time.
    • 03:11:18
      So after the board redefined the project and we started immediately working with the local government to try to make some short-term improvements in addition to this longer effort to look at access management,
    • 03:11:30
      We've reworked the signal.
    • 03:11:32
      We've added some dual lefts.
    • 03:11:33
      We've got a project in the spring to add another set of dual lefts and widen, move out the signal poles to make some more room to help these trucks move through a little more quickly.
    • 03:11:43
      But really, the big project, the $20 million project that's currently in the plan is to look at functionally this whole interchange area and the existing access to model it
    • 03:11:56
      and to look at what improvements we could make that would make the thing run better without rebuilding everything.
    • 03:12:02
      And what we assume will come out of this are a series of both physical improvements and changes to the existing access.
    • 03:12:10
      You have to think, when you look at this aerial photograph that's on the screen now, by current both VDOT and federal regulations, none of these access points to the businesses you see in the picture now will be permitted to be built today in this area.
    • 03:12:23
      We've got a lot to look at.
    • 03:12:25
      We have interviewed the consultants.
    • 03:12:27
      The selection will be made shortly.
    • 03:12:29
      We've also had a longstanding, I think, very good working relationship with the county.
    • 03:12:34
      So an important part of this will be the commitments that they're willing to make to preserve access changes so we don't go and spend a lot of money and then just get back to where we started.
    • 03:12:43
      The final slide, I hope to actually be back before the board about a year from now to do a follow-up to this presentation.
    • 03:12:52
      Step one was just kind of laying the stage, but I think this picture is very interesting.
    • 03:12:56
      If you look, you will see that we have four trucks playing chicken that have managed to block a major artery of the Commonwealth.
    • 03:13:04
      You have this truck going to this truck stop, this truck going to that truck stop.
    • 03:13:08
      I think they've both got maybe a hole they're trying to get into.
    • 03:13:10
      You got a truck coming to come out, and you can see they've gridlocked all the way back to here with these dueling trucks trying to get in and out of these truck stops.
    • 03:13:19
      This was taken fairly early in the evening.
    • 03:13:23
      If you looked at this a little bit later in the day, some of those trucks wouldn't have a place to go and they wouldn't be able to sit there.
    • 03:13:29
      So you can have two trucks that can effectively create a backup onto Interstate 81 and impact thousands of people trying to get in and out of truck stops.
    • 03:13:39
      So definitely a lot of low-hanging fruit here for us to work on.
    • 03:13:42
      And finally, and I think most importantly, this is one of many interchanges in the Commonwealth that have the same problems.
    • 03:13:49
      where they were an old design.
    • 03:13:50
      We had limited access right away.
    • 03:13:53
      The feds didn't regulate the things the way they do today.
    • 03:13:56
      So you had development that encroached on something that was probably not quite built to enough capacity to start with, but then we made it worse by building around it.
    • 03:14:06
      And so what we hope is that the model we developed here is something that you could use up and down the 81 corridor in Northern Virginia, Richmond, Hampton Roads.
    • 03:14:15
      It's something that you look at before you go spend a half a billion dollars.
    • 03:14:19
      Certainly the return on this investment will be equal to a half a billion dollar investment, but what if we can do one-third or one-half of the good for 10% of the money or 5% of the money?
    • 03:14:30
      So we really want to do a proof of concept here, and I'd like to come back and hopefully give you an update in about a year and tell you how we think it's going to work.
    • 03:14:37
      And with that, I'd be happy to take any questions the board would have.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:41
      Is part of the idea here to get rid of the truck stop, at least in that location?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:14:45
      It sounds like a dangerous question, but it also has a lot of legal implications.
    • 03:14:53
      I will tell you that there was a time when this truck stop was probably one of the biggest revenue generators for Botetourt County, and they would have done anything to protect it.
    • 03:15:02
      There's probably nothing that a lot of folks at Botetourt would rather see today than to have it go away.
    • 03:15:07
      because it's a major detriment right now to further development of the county because you've got to get through it to get to the rest of the county.
    • 03:15:14
      There's people that would like to see me come up with a study to find a way to take the truck stop.
    • 03:15:18
      That is not my goal.
    • 03:15:20
      I don't know what the future fate of the truck stop will be relative to its access, but what we're going to do is look at everything.
    • 03:15:28
      There may be solutions that leave the truck stop untouched.
    • 03:15:31
      There may be solutions that require us to close one or both of these in terms of access
    • 03:15:36
      It forces us to buy the property, but it's not the question of just one use.
    • 03:15:41
      It's all the uses together, how they interact with each other.
    • 03:15:44
      So it's not, you can't just say, well, if this wasn't here, everything would be great.
    • 03:15:49
      Things would be better, but it's not the only problem.
    • 03:15:52
      So I think we have to look at it holistically.
    • 03:15:54
      And in particular, when you talk about us exercising imminent domain authority, I think you have to be very careful about the analysis you do that suggests the improvement that you want to make.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:04
      Well, and it's not only about existing uses there.
    • 03:16:07
      Even if you could address existing uses, you'd hate to spend a lot of money for that only to have the county approve a bunch of new uses right across the street.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:16:16
      Yes.
    • 03:16:17
      Now, I will say for new access points, we do have some fairly stringent federal guidelines that we have to follow.
    • 03:16:24
      All these uses have been here for a while.
    • 03:16:26
      So you're in that challenge of zoning and land use decisions made in some cases 30 years ago.
    • 03:16:33
      that are causing major problems today.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:36
      And if you get to that point, how do you make them binding 30 years into the future?
    • 03:16:42
      This is going to be a very challenging legal question, how to get a long-term land use commitment to measure it with the infrastructure.
    • 03:16:52
      We've not explored that.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:53
      I was going to ask whether there was any precedent for long-term binding agreements between
    • 03:16:58
      The Commonwealth and a particular municipality to accomplish that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:03
      I mean probably the closest thing are open space conservation easements but that's a very different animal than what we discussed.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:17:10
      And certainly one of the tools that we have that we use frequently of course is actually the board designating and us purchasing limited access rights but of course that's extremely costly.
    • 03:17:20
      And if you look at the slide you'll see this nice fairly good size.
    • 03:17:23
      I know this is steep and you see it on the ground but
    • 03:17:25
      You see undeveloped things, you know, development kind of cuts off pretty sharply here.
    • 03:17:29
      So what would be very important to us, quite frankly, is what Botatot's going to want to do around it.
    • 03:17:35
      So, you know, if we create a small envelope and make things better, and then the county simply didn't land users just upstream of where we stopped and recreated the same problem a quarter mile up or half a mile up, we haven't done much good.
    • 03:17:47
      So no matter where we
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:49
      I hope not only do we see this a year from now, but I hope every other jurisdiction and every other district is able to get lessons learned from this because I think you have a wonderful microcosm of all the
    • 03:18:16
      problems you can have with and now you're trying to correct and solve them but hopefully in some of these situations we can do some preventive access management and I think that was one of the big things that came out of VTrans and our investigation into ways that we could protect the investment of the Commonwealth and this great infrastructure by protecting it in
    • 03:18:41
      from not being outmoded before it's almost being constructed.
    • 03:18:46
      It brings economic development but to be sure that that is controlled within a reasonable way.
    • 03:18:52
      And I just think your approach is great and I just hope other districts can benefit from this experience.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:19:01
      Thank you.
    • 03:19:02
      I think one key too is just working with localities to try to educate about the long term
    • 03:19:07
      implications of decisions because now Botetize, again, is in this position where their current prospects are limited by their past decisions in a way that they don't like.
    • 03:19:17
      So I think if they had to do it over again, they would do things differently.
    • 03:19:20
      So how do we help cut that off at the past before it's very expensive and difficult to do?
    • 03:19:26
      Very well said.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:27
      We do have a virtually identical situation off of I-95 in Caroline County.
    • 03:19:31
      In fact, there are two projects in the six-year program where this has virtually identical application.
    • 03:19:36
      I'm sure
    • 03:19:37
      There's probably several more around this day.
    • 03:19:39
      Okay, any other questions, Mr. Caywood?
    • 03:19:42
      Thank you.
    • 03:19:42
      That concludes the work session presentations on I-81.
    • 03:19:45
      I know it's been a long day so far.
    • 03:19:47
      Let's take a 15-minute break.
    • 03:19:49
      And now when we come back, we have also, for those of you who are waiting patiently, Morteza and others, we do have a special guest, Mr. Bill Millar from the American Public Transit Association is gonna come talk to us
    • 03:20:03
      He's a special guest who's here for the conference, and I thought we'd take advantage of his presence here.
    • 03:20:08
      But it is now 4.28.
    • 03:20:11
      Why don't we pick up at 4.45?
    • 03:20:14
      And I believe we should be able to move quickly through the remaining work session items.
    • 03:20:19
      And we do have to do the business agenda.
    • 03:20:21
      So chances are we won't be done until about 6 o'clock.
    • 03:20:24
      OK?
    • 03:20:24
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:20:26
      I'm going to go water the wheelies now.
    • 03:20:56
      Hey, hey.
    • 03:21:06
      Well, I'll get your away from me.
    • 03:21:14
      I won't.
    • 03:21:16
      I will.
    • 03:21:18
      I'll never be able to move again.
    • 03:21:18
      No malarkey.
    • 03:21:19
      Oh, yeah, that's great.
    • 03:21:20
      I'm glad I'm back to be here.
    • 03:21:46
      Well, I did.
    • 03:21:55
      In fact, I got here and I had to see some of this stuff.
    • 03:22:06
      I wanted to know why it is that I needed it and that's it.
    • 03:22:11
      But not too bad.
    • 03:22:12
      Why aren't we all passing each other?
    • 03:22:12
      Actually, I came down.
    • 03:22:13
      I appreciate the opportunity to speak here today.
    • 03:22:29
      J. Michael A. Smith III, Michael A. Smith III
    • 03:22:57
      It's just outrageous.
    • 03:23:22
      I wasn't one to say the same thing.
    • 03:23:23
      That's what happens.
    • 03:23:23
      Not like this one where everybody's honest all the time.
    • 03:23:24
      H. J.
    • 03:23:42
      Hello, everybody.
    • 03:24:08
      What I thought I would do, I'm going to do, I'm going to do a lot of honors.
    • 03:24:12
      I did bring some copies of the reports that are fundamentally there.
    • 03:24:35
      If it would be all right, I don't mind if you distributed them ahead of time.
    • 03:24:37
      Even if some guy puts them in and doesn't bother about it.
    • 03:24:38
      E.
    • 03:24:55
      Well, I worked in them.
    • 03:25:24
      Well, he's a fabulous guy.
    • 03:25:52
      I don't know why you've gotten to know him.
    • 03:25:53
      So, I thought I would just introduce what I have for you.
    • 03:26:12
      Greg?
    • 03:26:12
      What's the list?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:26:12
      I can't just tell him on his left.
    • 03:26:16
      Yes, he did leave.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 03:26:18
      He's a see-saw.
    • 03:26:19
      He's the one with the yellow saw.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:26:22
      I'm very good about reading body language, so if you want me out there, I'm out there.
    • 03:26:39
      H. J. D.
    • 03:27:02
      I'm really glad to get a chance to meet you.
    • 03:27:20
      I've been admiring you a lot.
    • 03:27:21
      I'll be here pretty much now.
    • 03:27:21
      That was Orlando!
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:27:36
      Disney World, with the kids, one family had six girls, the youngest girl was three months,
    • 03:27:56
      You want me to hand those out?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:28:10
      I see that.
    • 03:28:15
      Can you just hand them out?
    • 03:28:18
      Is one Mr. Wheeler?
    • 03:28:20
      Mr. Wheeler?
    • 03:28:26
      We had a Mr. Wheeler.
    • 03:28:39
      Okay.
    • 03:29:05
      Oh, you want to wear my arms out?
    • Matthew O. TuckerMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:07
      Well, you do whatever you like.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:29:22
      It sure is better if we can just set it on the ground next to it.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:29:33
      Actually, I think we can get all the wires in.
    • 03:29:51
      Thank you so much.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:12
      H. J. D.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:30:34
      No problem.
    • 03:30:38
      Let us know if you want to.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:50
      I know how that works, sir.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:31:19
      I have a round of applause for our panelists.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:31:40
      Oh, yeah.
    • 03:32:06
      H. J. D.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:40:24
      Folks, if people could take their seats, we can conclude our data.
    • 03:40:42
      Yeah, we did it.
    • 03:41:10
      I'd like to welcome everybody back from our break.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:41:26
      We do have an addition to the agenda while folks are getting settled, and I realize today is a long program, but we're doing two days of work in one.
    • 03:41:36
      We're packing in a lot of the I-81 issues.
    • 03:41:39
      as well as our normal business agenda.
    • 03:41:43
      Our next speaker, if you follow transit, you know the name Bill Millar.
    • 03:41:49
      If you listen to National Public Radio, they're one of the regular sponsors of several programs as part of their outreach.
    • 03:41:56
      Bill Millar is the president of the American Public Transit Association.
    • 03:42:04
      He's worked for a city, a county,
    • 03:42:07
      An independent transportation district, a state DOT, right?
    • 03:42:13
      All before coming to APTA, which is the voice of the transit industry in the United States.
    • 03:42:20
      He has drafted Matt Tucker, most of you probably know by now.
    • 03:42:24
      Matt is now the Vice Chair of the State Affairs Committee of APTA, which going into reauthorization is a very, very important position.
    • 03:42:33
      We look forward to Bill and Matt giving us regular reports and also being up on the Hill doing the good work on behalf of the transit industry.
    • 03:42:41
      So, Bill, thank you for coming down early and being with the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:42:48
      Thank you very much, Mr. Secretary and members of the Board.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:42:51
      It's an honor to be with you.
    • 03:42:54
      I reside in Falls Church, Virginia.
    • 03:42:57
      You may have heard of that community.
    • 03:42:59
      I got here today
    • 03:43:01
      Driving down 81, and I experienced every one of those things you heard about and saw.
    • 03:43:07
      I want to know why you didn't get them done before I got there.
    • 03:43:10
      But anyhow, then I was thinking, gee, wouldn't it be neat?
    • 03:43:13
      Here I am in one of the nation's great historic railroad centers, and wouldn't it have been nice if I'd have had a choice to take the train to come here instead of driving?
    • 03:43:21
      So at any rate, I know you're working on all those problems on behalf of all the citizens of the Commonwealth who sometimes forget to say thanks.
    • 03:43:31
      Let me say thanks to you.
    • 03:43:32
      I appreciate a lot.
    • 03:43:34
      I thought I might start by just telling you a little bit about APTA, though I think the Secretary's done an excellent job of giving you a general introduction.
    • 03:43:43
      We are the national trade organization that represents both the providers of public transportation service, such as the Hampton Roads Transit or the Greater Richmond Transit Agency, or Washington Metro, and also the private companies that work in our business.
    • 03:44:01
      So companies that build buses or rail cars or engineering firms that do work in our business.
    • 03:44:07
      All told, about 1,500 members primarily from the US and Canada, but also from around the world.
    • 03:44:16
      There are many members from Virginia.
    • 03:44:20
      And as you've already heard, you've loaned us some leadership.
    • 03:44:23
      Not only is Matt Tucker a member of my executive committee that watches over me,
    • 03:44:29
      But Matt and I together watched the chair of my executive committee, which is Michael Towns from Hampton Roads Transit.
    • 03:44:36
      So two of the 18 slots on my committee come from Virginia.
    • 03:44:40
      So I just thought you might be interested in knowing that.
    • 03:44:45
      Let me take a minute to just bring up to date a little bit about public transportation in America, where we stand, some of the current trends.
    • 03:44:53
      When I use public transportation, just so we're clear, I'm talking about local public buses,
    • 03:44:58
      local public rail service, paratransit services, rural public transportation, those types of services.
    • 03:45:08
      Now, public transportation in America is on quite an upswing.
    • 03:45:12
      And last year, 2006, we served over 10.1 billion customers.
    • 03:45:21
      That's the highest number of customers that have used public transportation in America in some 49 years.
    • 03:45:29
      And while I'm sure higher gas prices have something to do with it, that's not all.
    • 03:45:34
      This growth in ridership is part of a multi-year trend.
    • 03:45:38
      In fact, since 1995, we've seen the use of the nation's public transit systems grow by more than 30%.
    • 03:45:49
      Our nation's population in that period grew by 12%, and the nation's vehicle miles traveled only grew by 24%.
    • 03:45:58
      In fact, if you adjust those numbers for Virginia, and I left out Northern Virginia because I do hear that occasionally people at this end of the state think of that as an exceptional case.
    • 03:46:08
      So let's talk about the rest of the state for the moment.
    • 03:46:13
      Whereas the national ridership was up some 30%, in the rest of Virginia it was up 36%, just to give you a flavor.
    • 03:46:21
      So transit ridership is growing in Virginia.
    • 03:46:24
      More Virginians are using it every day, and of course that is in part a reflection of the good work that you all do.
    • 03:46:33
      One of the things I'm known for when I make presentations is throw out way too many statistics, and you're in luck.
    • 03:46:39
      I didn't bring a PowerPoint.
    • 03:46:40
      I figured by this point in the afternoon you'd seen enough PowerPoint, but as your chairman has indicated, I did bring along some reports that I thought might be of interest, and particularly if you glance through only one of them, the one with all the pretty pictures,
    • 03:46:54
      is the one that has a lot of the statistics that I'm going to be talking about here today.
    • 03:46:59
      I want to equate you with some of the benefits that we see in public transit.
    • 03:47:04
      Certainly, economically, there's a very strong case to be made for investment in public transportation.
    • 03:47:12
      For businesses, it expands their access to the labor pool.
    • 03:47:16
      From the standpoint of the worker, it expands the opportunity for the number of jobs.
    • 03:47:21
      All told, we figure on average,
    • 03:47:24
      Public transportation projects bring back about six dollars on average for every one dollar that the government invests in those kinds of projects.
    • 03:47:35
      Obviously you can have a bad project that doesn't do that much and you can have a great project that does a lot more, but on average about six to one.
    • 03:47:43
      By the way, some people wonder about rural public transportation, whether that also brings economic benefits.
    • 03:47:50
      We know it brings social benefits, certainly allowing people to get to
    • 03:47:53
      Medical Centers or other things that they need.
    • 03:47:56
      But studies are pretty clear that over $3 of direct economic benefit also comes from investing in rural public transportation.
    • 03:48:06
      So it's not just the return in the cities, to be sure.
    • 03:48:10
      Looking at it another way, every $10 million invested in transit brings about $30 million in local business revenues.
    • 03:48:19
      Just like highway construction, investing in public transportation stays within the state, stays within the community in which the investment is made.
    • 03:48:30
      Our friends at the federal government tell us that about every billion dollars invested in public transit yields about 47,500 jobs.
    • 03:48:38
      So lots of numbers to throw at you, but the picture I'm trying to paint here is public transportation is an important contributor to growing economies.
    • 03:48:49
      But of course, economies are not all we're looking at these days, as important as that is.
    • 03:48:54
      We're beginning to look at the byproducts of a thriving economy.
    • 03:48:58
      And so we all are wondering about things like global warming and traffic congestion, which I know this board in particular focuses a great deal of attention on, and the use of fuel.
    • 03:49:14
      So let me just throw out a couple of statistics.
    • 03:49:17
      And again, here I'm going to be referring
    • 03:49:19
      information that is in the other two reports that I have distributed to you.
    • 03:49:26
      APTA earlier this year engaged a Virginia company, ICF International, to do an analysis of just how much fuel do we save by the public transit we already have, not some theory about what if we all build it and everybody used it, but what is it we save from what we already have
    • 03:49:48
      The numbers were pretty amazing.
    • 03:49:50
      Over 1.4 billion gallons of fuel that is saved every year by Americans using public transit.
    • 03:49:59
      That's over 300,000 fewer fill-ups at the gas pump every day, for example.
    • 03:50:06
      It's about 90% of the fuel that we would import from a country like Kuwait, something on that order.
    • 03:50:12
      The second study that I'm sure you're familiar with
    • 03:50:15
      looks at road congestion.
    • 03:50:17
      And this has been done by the Texas Transportation Institute, the gurus on roadway congestion.
    • 03:50:24
      And they have recently released their report and say on an annual basis that Americans waste over about $78 billion a year stuck in traffic.
    • 03:50:36
      That same report, their analysis shows that Americans would waste an additional $10.2 billion
    • 03:50:43
      stuck in traffic if we didn't have the public transit that we already have.
    • 03:50:49
      So if you occasionally meet those people who might say, why would we invest in public transit?
    • 03:50:55
      I would never use it.
    • 03:50:57
      Well, they're getting a benefit right there simply by the amount of traffic reduction that public transit provides on our roads.
    • 03:51:05
      By the way, I picked out a couple of cities in Richmond, in Virginia.
    • 03:51:10
      And even though these are relatively small systems, they still have pretty good benefits.
    • 03:51:15
      For example, the congestion reduction from the bus system in Richmond is over $3.5 million per year.
    • 03:51:22
      And in Hampton Roads, the transit system there saves something like over $22 million a year in saved congestion.
    • 03:51:34
      Obviously, if I separated out the numbers in Northern Virginia, they would be enormous.
    • 03:51:39
      But I wanted to give you just a couple of other examples.
    • 03:51:42
      The third study that I wanted to bring you up to date with, also produced by a Virginia corporation, SAIC.
    • 03:51:50
      And we asked them to look at, well, we're all concerned about global warming.
    • 03:51:54
      What does transit contribute in the way of reduction of so-called greenhouse gases or other types of air pollutants?
    • 03:52:03
      And it is substantial.
    • 03:52:04
      Again, across the country, the number is pretty amazing, almost 7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide that does not go in the air because people use public transit.
    • 03:52:16
      Well, these are all big numbers, but that isn't how we make our decisions in our daily life.
    • 03:52:21
      We make our decisions by how does it affect my family, my household, that kind of thing.
    • 03:52:27
      So let me take some of these big numbers down to something that maybe is a little bit more understandable
    • 03:52:33
      Let's take that proverbial all-American household that has two adult members in it, both working outside the home.
    • 03:52:43
      Most American households that fit that category, they're both going to drive and unfortunately not drive together, so two autos.
    • 03:52:51
      Now let's suppose that, for example, they say, boy, I want to do my part to reduce greenhouse gases.
    • 03:52:59
      What are we told?
    • 03:53:00
      We're all told to weatherize our homes, replace our windows, all that.
    • 03:53:04
      And that's all good stuff.
    • 03:53:06
      And that'll save you about 2,800 pounds of carbon dioxide in a year.
    • 03:53:11
      We're all told to change out our light bulbs and put these energy-saving light bulbs in.
    • 03:53:17
      And that's a good thing to do, too.
    • 03:53:19
      But if you do that in your old house, you'll save 1,000, maybe 1,500 pounds of carbon dioxide.
    • 03:53:27
      And we're told, get rid of that old refrigerator and go out and what?
    • 03:53:30
      Buy an Energy Star refrigerator.
    • 03:53:32
      Isn't that what we're told?
    • 03:53:33
      That's a good thing to do and we should all do that.
    • 03:53:36
      That'll save about 300 pounds a year.
    • 03:53:40
      So all told, all the things I just told you will save the average household 4,000, 4,200 pounds a year.
    • 03:53:48
      Well, in addition to doing those things, one of those two people, just one, either started carpooling with the other one
    • 03:53:58
      or took public transit or maybe walked to work.
    • 03:54:00
      If they just did that, they would have saved over 4,800 pounds.
    • 03:54:06
      So as good as it is to weatherize your home, change out your light bulbs, change out your old appliances, just having one person in your household take public transit reduces your carbon footprint by some 20 byte, by some 10%.
    • 03:54:26
      which is almost 4,800 pounds of carbon.
    • 03:54:29
      So that's a pretty simple thing to do.
    • 03:54:31
      Now, let's suppose the person does that.
    • 03:54:33
      They start taking transit.
    • 03:54:35
      Hey, this isn't as bad as I thought it was going to be.
    • 03:54:38
      It actually works for me.
    • 03:54:39
      What happens if they get rid of that second car altogether?
    • 03:54:42
      Or in some cases, third car perhaps.
    • 03:54:44
      But what happens if they decide they want to do that and switch that travel over to transit?
    • 03:54:49
      Well, now they save 30% of their carbon footprint.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 03:54:54
      Well, what's 30% of the carbon footprint?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:54:56
      That's as if you could do without any electricity in your house.
    • 03:55:01
      And I doubt that any of you wants to do without electricity in your house.
    • 03:55:04
      So the point here is that you can save a lot by using transit.
    • 03:55:08
      By the way, along the way, when they did all those things, they saved over $6,200 a year in their commute costs.
    • 03:55:18
      So let me review.
    • 03:55:19
      If you take transit, you fight global warming, you reduce air pollution, you reduce congestion to save energy,
    • 03:55:25
      You save money, and by the way, the money you save, that's more than that average household spent on food.
    • 03:55:31
      So by taking transit, you get your food for free.
    • 03:55:35
      Now, you probably haven't thought about it in quite those terms before, but as we get into this debate about what we're gonna do as a nation, we're gonna have to start figuring out those kinds of trade-offs on that.
    • 03:55:49
      But we have a problem, and it's a problem that most Americans can't make those trade-offs
    • 03:55:55
      Even if they wanted to, because in most places in America, in most places in Virginia, public transit is not an option.
    • 03:56:04
      In fact, even using a very, very liberal definition of transit available within about a mile, you find only about half of all Americans could even walk to a bus or a train stop, even if they wanted to in that.
    • 03:56:17
      And so clearly we're going to have to invest more in public transportation.
    • 03:56:22
      We're going to have to make sure it is a viable option for Americans and that we give Americans choice.
    • 03:56:31
      Not only for the reasons that I've described, but things like we all know about the aging of the population.
    • 03:56:37
      We know that the growth in the population, for example, while the U.S. is expected to gain 30% in population in the next 20 or so years,
    • 03:56:46
      The Commonwealth of Virginia at the same time is expected to gain at least 38%.
    • 03:56:50
      So we know if we get the growth we're expecting, we're going to have to have choices.
    • 03:56:56
      That means we're going to have to invest in our road systems to be sure, to keep them up to date.
    • 03:57:00
      It means we're going to have to invest in our airports, sure, to keep them up to date.
    • 03:57:04
      But it also means we're going to have to expand and invest in our public transit
    • 03:57:08
      systems.
    • 03:57:08
      We're going to have to take on new ideas like expanding options through passenger rail service, things of that sort.
    • 03:57:21
      So it's a pleasure to be with you today.
    • 03:57:23
      I hope I didn't take too much of your time.
    • 03:57:25
      I just wanted to introduce the topic to you.
    • 03:57:27
      I knew you didn't have enough papers, so I brought you these reports.
    • 03:57:30
      But I would be very happy, Mr.
    • 03:57:32
      Chair, to answer any questions that you might have for me.
    • 03:57:35
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:57:36
      Thank you, Mr. Miller.
    • 03:57:36
      Are there any questions?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:57:39
      I have a question.
    • 03:57:41
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:57:42
      I represent the district in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:57:44
      We obviously have a big project, the Rail to Dulles project, which the CTB has supported, which is in the final stages of approval by FTA.
    • 03:57:55
      FTA itself serves as policing function that limits the new starts like you've been talking about.
    • 03:58:03
      What needs to happen there?
    • 03:58:05
      Not just for them to have more funds, perhaps, but for them to have a
    • 03:58:10
      More positive attitude about news starts as opposed to limiting those numbers.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:58:14
      Absolutely.
    • 03:58:14
      Thank you.
    • 03:58:15
      And first, let me thank you for the strong, strong, strong support that you've given, particularly the extension to Dulles Airport.
    • 03:58:24
      As a Falls Church person, I certainly look forward to the day when I can begin every air trip that I take with a metro ride instead of only half the trips I take with a metro ride, since I do use
    • 03:58:36
      National Airport as well.
    • 03:58:38
      And likewise, thank you for supporting the light rail project that's down in Norfolk because that too will have enormous benefits in the years that come.
    • 03:58:48
      The New Starts process in the Federal Transit Administration, I have said many times publicly, is a process to stop projects, not move projects forward.
    • 03:59:00
      If the highway folks had to have the same process, the transit folks,
    • 03:59:05
      We'd be on dusty dirt trails instead of a nice interstate system.
    • 03:59:10
      My hope is, under prodding from the Congress, that in fact we will see improvements in that New Start process.
    • 03:59:19
      Just the time delay of that with the inflation rates that we have today means that the projects cost more and more and more, and it's simply a pay me now, pay me later proposition.
    • 03:59:32
      And so I think that has to be revised dramatically.
    • 03:59:39
      I would favor a project development process that is much closer to the one that is used for highways.
    • 03:59:45
      But to be honest about it, I'd rather have that one simplified and the transit one simplified as well.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:53
      Thank you.
    • 03:59:54
      Any other questions for Mr. Millar?
    • 03:59:56
      Thank you again, and we look forward to your presentation tomorrow.
    • 03:59:59
      Thank you, sir.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:00:00
      Okay, picking up the next item on the agenda, we're going to move the secondary street acceptance to last so we can move through so there's some very patient folks who've been with us.
    • 04:00:10
      Item number six is using technology to construct, maintain, and monitor long-lasting structures.
    • 04:00:16
      This is a presentation by Dr. Jose Gomez, you heard from a little bit earlier, and Dr. Thomas Cousins from Virginia Tech.
    • 04:00:23
      Welcome, Dr. Gomez.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:00:41
      Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary.
    • 04:00:43
      Thank you very much for the opportunity to talk about a passion that I share with my co-author, Professor Tommy Cousin from Virginia Tech.
    • 04:00:53
      We'd like to introduce you to the Cooperative Center for Bridge Engineering, give you an idea of the facilities and capabilities we have, and hopefully we will, in this very brief presentation, give you a sense of the goals of the center, which is to make a difference for cost-effective and long-lasting structures.
    • 04:01:20
      This is a joint venture between the Research Council and Virginia Tech.
    • 04:01:24
      Its focus is primarily fundamentally on reducing costs, and those costs can be defined in many ways, from initial costs for improved construction or the use of high-performance materials to reduced costs that's related to congestion in terms of construction projects, basically get in and get out faster.
    • 04:01:46
      We focus on rapid installation and rehabilitation structures.
    • 04:01:51
      We focus on enhancing the maintenance program, perhaps to augment that program and maintain that structure.
    • 04:02:01
      We look and focus on materials to enhance the durability and service life of our bridge structure.
    • 04:02:08
      We are developing and employing health monitoring techniques and evaluation technologies to assist in the bridge inspection
    • 04:02:16
      Program and to better assess our existing infrastructure.
    • 04:02:21
      We have some unique capabilities unlike many continental states.
    • 04:02:25
      We have a full-scale structures testing facility at Virginia Tech.
    • 04:02:30
      We have two state-of-the-art materials testing laboratories, many of you which toured one of them at our facility back when you all met at Research Council.
    • 04:02:38
      We have a facility similar size at Virginia Tech as well.
    • 04:02:44
      Between the two organizations, we bring 15 scientists and faculty with expertise in structures and materials to our center.
    • 04:02:53
      And what makes the center work primarily and foremost is the strong cooperation we have with the chief engineer and our bridge engineer.
    • 04:03:02
      They make things happen, they ask the tough questions that we have to answer in order to implement our ideas and our technologies.
    • 04:03:11
      I like this picture.
    • 04:03:14
      Commissioner Ekern, you might recall this.
    • 04:03:16
      This was taken about, I think, the time you visited the structures lab.
    • 04:03:19
      This is the lab that's about 150 feet long by 50 feet wide, and everything in there at this time is a VDOT project.
    • 04:03:28
      We have completely dominated their structures research program in that regard.
    • 04:03:36
      A lot of our ideas start out in a materials laboratory, and I assure you that I cannot
    • 04:03:41
      The chief engineer or the state structural bridge engineer by taking a specimen of concrete and breaking it and showing them that I can get a better bridge built that way.
    • 04:03:50
      They're not going to believe that.
    • 04:03:51
      This ability to test a full-scale bridge girder in the laboratory gives us that capability to convince those folks that we do know what we're talking about and we can enhance and build a better structure.
    • 04:04:04
      In this case, this is a high-performance concrete bridge girder.
    • 04:04:08
      and I assure you that the load that caused that failure was significantly higher than any truck loading could ever be.
    • 04:04:15
      Of course we don't want that to happen in our bridges and this is one way that we assure that.
    • 04:04:22
      Not just convincing them in the laboratory environment, we also go out in the field and we employ health monitoring technologies that will give us again a better assessment of that new technology and how it performs in the field.
    • 04:04:35
      We implement actual bridge girders leading to construction of the Route 33 bridge in West Point, Virginia as a point of example.
    • 04:04:45
      The results are that we can produce additional cost savings because we can make our girders longer, we can make our girders provide much more durability, thereby saving maintenance costs.
    • 04:05:01
      This is a concept that we first talked about probably 10 years ago.
    • 04:05:06
      This is a fiber reinforced polymer bridge deck system that was in partnership with a firm in Bristol, Virginia.
    • 04:05:14
      We took a piece of their proposed bridge deck and we put it in the I-81 weigh station.
    • 04:05:19
      We subjected it through over a year of just continuous truck traffic as the vehicles went through that weigh station.
    • 04:05:28
      They went across a piece of this proposed bridge deck system.
    • 04:05:33
      We went from that to a full-scale structural test, as you see in this photograph, with the intent of answering the questions of, is it as good as a conventional reinforced concrete bridge deck?
    • 04:05:47
      In fact, it is.
    • 04:05:49
      It's actually in some ways stronger.
    • 04:05:51
      It weighs between a quarter and a third less, or I'm sorry,
    • 04:05:57
      It weighs about a quarter to a third of a traditional reinforced concrete deck.
    • 04:06:02
      Where does that lead?
    • 04:06:05
      We went to a project in Covington, a bridge rehabilitation project.
    • 04:06:11
      We worked not only with the fabricator and the district, we worked with the company that ended up placing this deck in the structure to
    • 04:06:23
      helped them understand how to apply this technology in the field.
    • 04:06:29
      In the final result, we proof tested this concept with a full-scale load test of the structure to ensure that the bridge deck would be able to in fact do what we predicted it would do and carry the load that we anticipate on the structure.
    • 04:06:47
      And the result is
    • 04:06:48
      A structure that is of historical significance in Covington, Virginia that was posted at five times is now posted 20 times.
    • 04:06:55
      And the significance of that, five to 20 times, yeah, that's a number we can certainly tell.
    • 04:07:01
      But I think fundamentally, here's a bridge that the Jackson River runs very near Covington.
    • 04:07:09
      We also look at and try to help augment or enhance our inspection program and our ways to assess existing infrastructure.
    • 04:07:39
      Now the term health monitoring, that's a wonderful academic term because it can mean anything you want it to mean.
    • 04:07:44
      What we like to think it means is we're going to try to answer specific questions on specific bridges for our State Bridge Engineer and his folks.
    • 04:07:53
      And one way to do that is to apply existing technologies that we feel are viable entities that will give us the information that's necessary to answer a specific question.
    • 04:08:05
      Health monitoring in some ways means
    • 04:08:07
      to others, academics might mean lots of gadgets, lots of information being put out there, but at times we get too much information and we're focusing on health monitoring that will give us some very specific answers.
    • 04:08:23
      We also have means to assess and
    • 04:08:27
      We evaluate existing infrastructure.
    • 04:08:29
      In this case, we conducted a load test of the I-81 bridge over the New River, again, supporting our folks in the field and trying to answer specific questions that they have.
    • 04:08:41
      So the benefits of the Center for Bridge Engineering through the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 04:08:46
      We feel like we advance research for safe, long-lasting structures.
    • 04:08:51
      We provide a full-scale testing environment to answer specific structural questions.
    • 04:08:55
      We are looking for cost-effective applications of technology, not just to put technology out there, but save the Commonwealth something, whether it's removing a posting of a structure to providing longer-lasting bridge structures.
    • 04:09:16
      We have the capability to do forensic analysis and advanced structural evaluation to, again, enhance or augment our inspection programs.
    • 04:09:25
      We are capable of rapidly deploying proven technologies.
    • 04:09:30
      If there are questions out there and we know we can get a gadget or a device that will give the specific answer, we have the means to go out there and do that.
    • 04:09:40
      Basically, the bottom line is we provide advanced engineering and scientific expertise.
    • 04:09:47
      And I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:09:50
      Thank you, Dr. Gomez.
    • 04:09:52
      Great presentation.
    • 04:09:53
      Are there questions or comments, Commissioner?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:09:55
      Dr. Gomez, could you give us a quick update?
    • 04:09:59
      I've tantalized the board a little bit under the forensic analysis piece of our participation on the Highway 100 bridge.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:10:08
      Yes, sir.
    • 04:10:09
      The Route 100 bridge is an out-of-service bridge located near the town of Pulaski.
    • 04:10:17
      It's a small-scale version of the I-35 bridge that collapsed in Minnesota.
    • 04:10:23
      We're working with the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 04:10:27
      They are, as you're well aware, they're investigating with the National Transportation Safety Board what happened in that structural collapse.
    • 04:10:36
      They have a computer model that will in fact generate a failure mode.
    • 04:10:42
      We are in the process of testing that structure on the Route 100 bridge to basically determine in fact the failure mode
    • 04:10:52
      and sort of benchmark their computer model.
    • 04:10:57
      What we've done so far, Dr. Cousins has conducted a live load test and has a computer model to simulate that live load test and the spraying, the intent is to test the bridge failure.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:11:15
      The lightweight bridge deck that you showed us a picture of, does that have
    • 04:11:22
      It's a pre-manufactured deck system.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:11:33
      The manufacturer will tell you they can make it to fit any configuration.
    • 04:11:39
      I can tell you that it's a very high initial cost.
    • 04:11:42
      I think the market for that is rapid replacement,
    • 04:11:46
      In high-volume areas, perhaps it's the best niche.
    • 04:11:50
      Another niche is where you see where we're trying to lighten the dead load on an existing bridge structure like that trusses.
    • 04:11:58
      There's another possibility there.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:00
      Order of magnitude, what's the incremental cost for a section of that?
    • 04:12:05
      Is it twice as much or is it four times as much?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:12:09
      Well, between two and three times, and the manufacturer will tell you
    • 04:12:12
      If you build it, they will come.
    • 04:12:14
      If you give us more opportunity, we'll build it cheaper.
    • 04:12:19
      We haven't heard that one before, I'm sure.
    • 04:12:22
      But between about a factor of three right now, I'd say, is a reasonable estimate of the cost of that versus a convention.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:28
      Does it have a service life benefit?
    • 04:12:35
      for a lower maintenance benefit as well as a weight benefit?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:12:40
      All of the above, yes.
    • 04:12:41
      The intent there is that it's more, as durable, more durable, it requires less maintenance, so there's a long-term cost-saving participation there.
    • 04:12:53
      And it, I'm sorry, I lost my train of thought, but yes, there is.
    • 04:12:59
      Great, thank you.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:02
      Mr. Koelemay.
    • 04:13:02
      Mr. Chairman,
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:04
      Thank you.
    • 04:13:05
      I mean, this is one of my prime interests, quite frankly, being from Northern Virginia, knowing how mature many of these technologies actually are, how they're deployed in other places, metal fatigue, the Alaska Pipeline.
    • 04:13:18
      A guy named John Miles at JMU, for example, is one of the creators of the system of the Alaska Pipeline that has that network self-report if there's moisture penetration and corrosion potential and so forth.
    • 04:13:33
      I'm interested in how fast this rapidly deployment of proven technologies is happening, because I do think there could be an element of difference for Virginia.
    • 04:13:43
      We have a high-tech sector that's a leader in this type of thing and that could become a model for the nation.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:13:53
      Correct me if I'm wrong, sir, but you're addressing it in terms of health monitoring and that sort of thing, like the Alaska pipeline.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:59
      Yeah, like the bridge will call you and tell you if it's corroding as opposed to you inspect.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:14:03
      Well, you know, we can always look back and say, oh yeah, that's the failure of the I-35 bridge was because of, it's, Mother Nature doesn't give up her secrets very easily.
    • 04:14:18
      We have
    • 04:14:19
      I can tell you there's a world of development in looking at various transducers, strain gauges, all sorts of technologies are out there.
    • 04:14:29
      But for us, I'm convinced we need to be able to answer a specific question.
    • 04:14:37
      The pipeline, you think, well, there are broad, certainly broad aspects of that, but there are specifics there.
    • 04:14:43
      There's a pressure in that line.
    • 04:14:45
      You can monitor a pressure in a bridge.
    • 04:14:48
      The equivalent would be a certain stress level because of a load.
    • 04:14:52
      But where you put that gauge will tell you what that stress level is or what it's using.
    • 04:14:57
      And so there are very specific details that need to be looked at in every bridge.
    • 04:15:03
      So there are lots of technologies out there.
    • 04:15:06
      The other question I have is the technologies that exist.
    • 04:15:10
      We have a design service life now for 75 years.
    • 04:15:13
      I don't think there's a transducer out there that will last 75 years in any given environment.
    • 04:15:17
      So you've got to be careful with that too.
    • 04:15:20
      The other question is then, if it gives me that piece of information, is that piece of information truly accurate?
    • 04:15:25
      So we are approaching this from answering the specific question and looking at a window where we can give them a detailed answer and have faith in the transducer and that it's giving us a signal and giving us information that's accurate and useful.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:15:42
      What do you consider the greatest constraint on your work?
    • 04:15:45
      Is it just the march of technologies is inconsistent?
    • 04:15:52
      Or it's the breakthroughs in material science that you're waiting for?
    • 04:15:55
      Or is it you're underfunded and could use, you know, you could go twice as fast if you had twice the resources?
    • 04:16:04
      I was on the Virginia Research and Technology Advisory Commission before the CTB, so we did this all the time, and the answer was usually more.
    • 04:16:22
      I could use more because I could go faster.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:16:26
      Tommy will tell you the exact mission, they can all use more.
    • 04:16:30
      You can throw more money at this problem.
    • 04:16:33
      I just want to make sure we throw money the right way.
    • 04:16:38
      We have moved from the state of the art to the state of the practice in terms of high performance concrete.
    • 04:16:44
      Ten years ago, we weren't making bridge girders the same way we are now, and that's because of the research.
    • 04:16:53
      We have to make sure that we don't open up another set of problems
    • 04:16:56
      Dr. Gomez and Dr. Cousins, thank you so much for a great presentation.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:17:20
      I think it gives everybody a great deal of comfort to know that people like you are working at these very, very important tasks.
    • 04:17:26
      The next item on the work session agenda is the HOV lane operation at Turkeycock Run.
    • 04:17:32
      Morteza Salehi, who is the Acting District Administrator for Northern Virginia, will give us a brief introduction.
    • 04:17:39
      Now, is this an action item on the agenda?
    • 04:17:42
      This will be an action item at the December CTB meeting.
    • 04:17:45
      And this does have consequences for commuters in the entire I-95 corridor.
    • 04:17:59
      Welcome, Mr. Salehi.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 04:18:00
      Thank you, sir.
    • 04:18:01
      Good afternoon, Mr. Secretary, Commissioner, members of the board.
    • 04:18:04
      Pleasure to be here and thank you for the opportunity.
    • 04:18:07
      After Dr. Gomez's sophisticated presentation, I feel this is such a simple, simple issue.
    • 04:18:18
      What I would like to do, if I may, I would like to provide you with a very brief overview of the overall proposal that we have for you as far as the HOV lanes operations
    • 04:18:29
      T. Runge, I would like to provide you with a brief overview of that.
    • 04:18:35
      And then following that, if I may, I would like Valerie Pardo, one of my colleagues, to provide more specific information for you.
    • 04:18:43
      Valerie is our district, Northern Virginia District's multimodal liaison.
    • 04:18:48
      She works with transit agencies and then she's
    • 04:18:51
      As a member of the HOV Advisory Committee of Northern Virginia, she has had active involvement over the past several years on a lot of HOV issues, so should be a lot more prepared to provide you with a lot more details about that.
    • 04:19:06
      With that, if I...
    • 04:19:14
      Okay, that's better.
    • 04:19:15
      A word about what the current situation and what has been the situation since 1982.
    • 04:19:23
      Basically, since 1982, after following the approval of the CTB, we in Northern Virginia have allowed non-HOV vehicles to use a short section, three-mile section.
    • 04:19:36
      of the HOV lanes and 395 southbound during the limited hours of restricted hours of 3.30 to 6 o'clock in the afternoon.
    • 04:19:49
      So as a result of that, non-HOV vehicles have been able to bypass congested areas in the scripted interchange since 1982.
    • 04:19:59
      They have been able to bypass the general purpose lanes of the HOV of the scripted interchange
    • 04:20:06
      use the HOV lanes through the sprinted interchange and exit the HOV lanes in that short section using the flyover ramp south of the sprinted interchange.
    • 04:20:18
      This basically took place as a result of congestion that we had in the sprinted interchange area and the goal of reducing the volume of traffic on
    • 04:20:27
      General purpose name, that's a string predicted change, and with the goal of reducing congestion in that area.
    • 04:20:39
      The next slide shows you that that short section of the string predicted change, basically you see the 95, 395, and 495 corridor, and shows that short section, which is
    • 04:20:55
      basically three miles of the entire, not 28 miles total length, 28 miles total HOV, HOV then along 9-5 corridor.
    • 04:21:10
      Again, there's a slip ramp north of the Street Exchange, south of Duke Street, 236.
    • 04:21:21
      That's what non-HOV they can do, they take that ramp,
    • 04:21:25
      They use the HOV lane, and then they, after passing the distributed bypass, they exit from that side of the line.
    • 04:21:37
      Now this has been basically, for the past 25 years, that has been the practice that has reduced relatively, about 2,500 non-HOV vehicles have been using that section of the HOV during the two and a half hour speed.
    • 04:21:55
      So that has been rather a successful, positive proposal in terms of satisfying the goal of the program.
    • 04:22:04
      The challenges have been basically to some extent signing and to some extent enforcement by enforcement agencies.
    • 04:22:13
      The proposal that we have in front of you is basically, now that the frequency change has been constructed, now that we have a lot more general purpose things in the frequency change area, 11 names in the past, the 6 names of the past, and a lot more capacity available in the frequency change, the goal is to discontinue that practice, the proposal in front of you is to discontinue that practice and basically
    • 04:22:42
      make the use of limit, restrict the use of the HOV lane, .22 HOV lane, for example.
    • 04:22:52
      So the proposal basically is a collective proposal by DRPT, Virginia State Police, FHWA, and VDOT, and is also
    • 04:23:07
      A proposal which has been thoroughly discussed with Northern Virginia's HOD Advisory Committee.
    • 04:23:14
      And for all of you to know that our Advisory Committee consists of people from FHWA, from the DMV and AAA and PRTC, and also a citizen group and a representative of Northern Virginia Transportation Authority.
    • 04:23:32
      So it has had the support of all people involved in all of the events.
    • 04:23:37
      The overall impact and the benefits of the proposal, certainly more capacity available for HOV as a result of removal of the 2,500 non-HOV vehicles in that particular section.
    • 04:23:52
      Because of the significant capacity available at general purpose lane, minimum traffic impact would be on general purpose lane as a result of pushing this traffic back again.
    • 04:24:06
      to General Curtis James, certainly eliminates the confusion of segments, findings that we have had through interchange, and simplifies the enforcement, something that members of the State Police welcomed that, and underscores, maybe most importantly, underscores
    • 04:24:28
      I just wanted to bring this slide back and quickly show this to you and then ask Valerie to come and provide a little bit more information about that.
    • 04:24:45
      You can see that slip round commonly referred to as Turkey Card.
    • 04:24:49
      And it's basically north of Edsel Road and south of Duke Street, north of the Dutch Way.
    • 04:24:57
      And you see that non-HOVD can have the ability to take that right up north of Edsel Road.
    • 04:25:05
      I'd be able to take that slip ramp and use the HOV lanes, come all the way down, bypass the entirety of the interchange, and use that flyover ramp south of Old Street, Mead Road, and south of 644, Franconia Road, which is basically south of the speed of these steps.
    • 04:25:27
      With that, sir, may I just have batteries here, and then I'll get batteries up to answer any of the questions that you may have.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:25:34
      Thank you, Morteza.
    • 04:25:36
      Valerie Pardo is the VDOT Northern Virginia District Multimodal Liaison.
    • 04:25:40
      Welcome, Ms. Pardo.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 04:25:43
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 04:25:45
      Chair and members of the committee.
    • 04:25:46
      Hopefully I'll be able to get a pointer to walk you through this configuration and explain a little bit about the history of the GCP resolution set up in the past concerning this exemption.
    • 04:25:58
      It's not showing up over there.
    • 04:26:01
      Okay, as you can see, the orange line is the HOV lane, the blue line is the I-95, 395 main lane, and this gray line over here is the local lane that has been separated out going to the Springfield, to Old Kemal Road and Springfield.
    • 04:26:17
      The gray line is I-495 and Beltway.
    • 04:26:21
      In 1982, when the first time that the CTB allowed non-HOV vehicles to access the ramp at Turkey
    • 04:26:30
      They would come down the ramp and they would continue to the end of the HOV lanes.
    • 04:26:34
      This ended just south of 644 at the time.
    • 04:26:37
      And those vehicles merged back in with the general purpose vehicles along with everybody else.
    • 04:26:43
      By 1990, the HOV lanes were getting a little crowded through the stretch.
    • 04:26:48
      So the CTB again acted and they required that any of the non-HOVs that got on at the slip ramps now had to exit at Old Kingville Road, which is
    • 04:26:59
      and then in 1993, this flyover was constructed back to the regular lane and CTB passed their third resolution allowing the non-HLP vehicles to continue onto that ramp and get back into the regular lane.
    • 04:27:19
      And this is the situation that exists after the crash.
    • 04:27:25
      As you all know, the Springfield Interchange was completed this past summer, and the new configuration can accommodate existing plus additional traffic in the South MPM direction.
    • 04:27:40
      It's difficult we've emerged that existed where the Beltway lanes came in through the 395 lanes has been eliminated.
    • 04:27:47
      Traffic improvements have been separated, and we now have six crew lanes and five local lanes accommodating the traffic through the interchange.
    • 04:27:57
      And these improvements have eliminated the need for the Turkeycock exemption for non-HOVs.
    • 04:28:06
      About 2,500 non-HOVs use a section of the I-395 HOV lane during the two and a half evening peak period.
    • 04:28:14
      VDOT Traffic Engineering did an operational study to determine the impact on the general purpose of making this change and restricting the non-HOV traffic from the HOV lanes.
    • 04:28:27
      They found the impact to be minimal with the traffic being distributed evenly between the local and express lanes through the interchange.
    • 04:28:36
      The level of service on the HOV lanes is expected to improve as the
    • 04:28:42
      The last point I'd like to make here is that the traffic flow may even improve.
    • 04:29:08
      This change will provide more reliable and consistent travel times in the HOV lanes.
    • 04:29:27
      The speeds on the HOV lanes often fluctuate depending on the numbers of non-HOVs that access at the Turkeycock ramp.
    • 04:29:35
      Currently, the HOV speeds
    • 04:29:37
      are slightly faster than what you find in the segment on the general purpose lane.
    • 04:29:42
      Recent travel times show that we're averaging about 55 miles per hour on the HOV through that segment and around 50 miles per hour on the general purpose lane.
    • 04:29:52
      This change will also assist in the implementation of a transportation management plan, the I-95 Fourth Lane Widener Project, which is scheduled to start in early 2008
    • 04:30:05
      We will need all the HOV capacity that we can make available to encourage drivers in the general purpose lanes to shift to carpooling and transit during construction.
    • 04:30:15
      The change was also reviewed by the project team for the I-395 hot lane construction project.
    • 04:30:22
      And they agreed that keeping the SOV access available would not provide benefits to their maintenance and traffic plans or their transportation management plan associated with construction.
    • 04:30:34
      This change will simplify HOV enforcement by allowing the Virginia State Police to enforce HOV throughout the 28-mile corridor.
    • 04:30:44
      It also eliminates the safety problems associated with this exemption, namely that non-HOV drivers often wait on the shoulders of the HOV lanes for the
    • 04:30:55
      And lastly, this modification will underscore VDOT's commitment to the HOV community who have been asking for this change for some time now.
    • 04:31:19
      Before I finish, I would just like to mention that should this change go through,
    • 04:31:24
      We have developed an extensive public outreach campaign to discuss this change with our local and state elected officials, as well as to communicate it to the public.
    • 04:31:34
      The public information campaign includes using variable message boards, radio tags, our 511 system, and press releases.
    • 04:31:42
      And again, if this is approved in December, we hope to implement the change by mid-January.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:49
      Thank you, Ms. Pardo and Mr. Salehi.
    • 04:31:52
      Mr. McCarthy.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:31:53
      Why can't we do all that before we make a decision on this?
    • 04:31:57
      How about those 2,500 non-HOV users, what do they think of all this?
    • 04:32:06
      Have you made any outreach to the public besides your little committee and the officialdom to find out what people who do this think of the idea?
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 04:32:16
      Isn't that sort of backwards?
    • 04:32:22
      Shouldn't we know what people think before we make up our minds?
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 04:32:36
      which would be related to the script before you make a decision on something.
    • 04:33:06
      There's a kind of article that's been here, that we read online, that Dr.
    • 04:33:12
      Gridlock, the Washington Post, a large number of people gathered in the U.S. to do that.
    • 04:33:17
      And that's because of the kind of officials about that.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:33:25
      Okay, other questions to come?
    • 04:33:26
      Mr. Koelemay?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:33:27
      Thank you.
    • 04:33:28
      I'm very familiar with this.
    • 04:33:29
      I live in Springfield, so this has been an adventure, this whole change over the last 20 years.
    • 04:33:35
      But I have a question.
    • 04:33:37
      So the slip ramp won't be closed.
    • 04:33:39
      It'll simply be labeled HOV-3.
    • 04:33:41
      Is that correct?
    • 04:33:42
      So the transition period of informing people that may be used to getting into the lane and now they shouldn't think about getting in the lane is pretty critical.
    • 04:33:53
      The other thing is, which one thing you don't have on your map is that very quickly after Edsel Road, the traffic begins to separate.
    • 04:34:01
      In other words, there's an exit ramp to
    • 04:34:04
      495 North, even before this exit to the local thing.
    • 04:34:09
      So people almost immediately begin to separate out that are actually using that HOV lane to separate out a little bit later.
    • 04:34:18
      So I'm concerned about the safety issue primarily because you're right.
    • 04:34:24
      It backs up.
    • 04:34:24
      People cut across those lanes now to get in the slip ramp.
    • 04:34:29
      The way they get out, the clogging that does occur actually occurs before the differential interchange in the HOV lane.
    • 04:34:37
      The clogging that occurs in the main line actually is further down toward Woodbridge.
    • 04:34:41
      So from my perspective, and I would second the perspective of the groups, it is a good idea.
    • 04:34:47
      It's a great safety improvement.
    • 04:34:49
      And then finally, don't underestimate the HOV commitment because as far as I know, the hot lanes project, the single biggest objection is from the HOV users
    • 04:34:59
      who somehow see that that's gonna degrade their ability to carpool and so forth.
    • 04:35:04
      And we need to deal with that and this is one way to show them there's benefits to the changes, not just difficulties.
    • 04:35:14
      I don't know if we can photograph the license plates of each person who goes in now and send them an individual letter, but that's probably scarab to death.
    • 04:35:23
      But it'd be tough to stop them one at a time.
    • 04:35:26
      However vigorous outreach on public information we need to do as much as we can just to avoid confusion.
    • 04:35:33
      Mr. Sterling, welcome.
    • 04:35:34
      Thank you very much.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:35
      We had a standing ovation planned for you earlier, but we're worn out.
    • 04:35:39
      Take that to Peter.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:40
      He has a bigger margin than I. I like that.
    • 04:35:46
      Actually, like a lot of what Mr. Koelemay has said, as somebody who uses these lanes every day,
    • 04:35:53
      What you see is sort of an anomaly where as cars will pile onto the slip ramp to get into the HOV lanes for a very short period of time, the HOV lanes will clog up while the regular lanes will open up.
    • 04:36:07
      You'll see traffic move quickly.
    • 04:36:08
      And then where these cars are piling back onto the regular lanes a little bit further down, that clogs back up.
    • 04:36:15
      So you have sort of a double anomaly, which not only I think causes problems for those who use the HOV lanes, but use
    • 04:36:22
      The regular lanes as well because of the way the traffic's merging and coming together.
    • 04:36:26
      So, I mean, yes, I think we've got to hear what the public has to say.
    • 04:36:29
      We need to see that, but as one member of that public, a very small group in this particular case, I think this is a good idea.
    • 04:36:36
      I think it's something that needs to happen, and I've often wondered why we have such an anomaly in the system.
    • 04:36:42
      So, I'd encourage you to go forward and bring us before us later.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:36:47
      Any other questions or comments?
    • 04:36:49
      Ms. Paro, Mr. Salehi, thank you for a good presentation.
    • 04:36:53
      This will be an action item on the December agenda, but I think based on the commentary you should plan to move forward with some of your outreach activities as quickly as possible.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 04:37:04
      Mr. Secretary, does that include notifying the public?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:37:07
      You could notify the public that that action ought to be on the agenda, but I would do the outreach in particular to NVTA, PRTC, and NVTC, and FAMPO, just to let them know that's on the agenda, and they'll get the message that this is going to occur.
    • 04:37:25
      Okay, the last work session agenda item, which is a tough one,
    • 04:37:31
      But we don't have a lot of time for this.
    • 04:37:33
      And the original presenter, Nick Donohue, had to attend a funeral today, is unable to be with us.
    • 04:37:39
      So Rick Walton is going to give us an update on the secondary street acceptance requirements.
    • 04:37:45
      This is a very, very important issue.
    • 04:37:47
      And I realize it's been a very long day for folks.
    • 04:37:49
      But we did promise the board a monthly update.
    • 04:37:53
      What I will say, Rick, if you could just kind of
    • 04:37:55
      Race through this and if folks have a question, let's just stop right there and answer it and try to move through this as quickly as possible.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:38:03
      If I can get this to work.
    • 04:38:08
      Every time I click on it, this is all it does.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:38:13
      Not to worry, we have experts.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:38:21
      Technologically challenged.
    • 04:38:24
      Anyway, Senate Bill 1181, which was proposed by Governor Kean and passed unanimously by the General Assembly at the 2007 session, dealt with
    • 04:38:53
      secondary street acceptance requirements and the primary purpose behind it was to ensure that streets accepted into the state system for perpetual public maintenance provided commensurate public benefit.
    • 04:39:06
      Now the legislation specifically mandates that this new regulation shall address at a minimum these four issues.
    • 04:39:14
      The first being a connectivity of road and pedestrian networks with the existing and future transportation networks to minimize storm water runoff,
    • 04:39:23
      and mentalized impervious surface areas to reduce street width and to address performance bonding and cost recovery.
    • 04:39:33
      The Secretary appointed an advisory committee consisting of various stakeholders.
    • 04:39:40
      This committee has met four times and the discussion has centered primarily in the four areas you see on the slide, the connectivity requirements, pedestrian accommodations, area type thresholds and conditional acceptance.
    • 04:39:54
      As far as connectivity requirements, a compact area type for network additions, what we're proposing in the regulation is a link to node ratio of 1.6 or greater.
    • 04:40:08
      And I believe last month, Nick gave you all a presentation where he had the nice, very simple link node, how link node ratio works.
    • 04:40:16
      It would also require one external connection as well as an additional external connection and stub out
    • 04:40:22
      for 50 lengths per fraction thereof.
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:40:26
      Are we going to be tested on how to calculate the link node ratios?
    • 04:40:32
      Yes.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:40:33
      Before we get into the link node ratios and those types of things, back to the stakeholder involvement, I have a little bit of a concern to some degree about involvement in the rural community.
    • 04:40:48
      Inquiring about that, I wanted to know what the rural counties were thinking about the proposal.
    • 04:40:53
      And so, one of the best ways I thought was to go to the individual representing the Virginia Association of Counties, and he proceeds to tell me that's part of the implementation committee, and of course, I'm sure he's doing some communication with the counties by sending emails, various types of communication, but he's not giving anything back.
    • 04:41:14
      And I find that interesting to the degree I think it will impact rural counties very much so.
    • 04:41:22
      But I find that maybe they don't have their ear on the rails to understand what really the impact of this is going to be.
    • 04:41:29
      So I have some concern that maybe we're not reaching all the stakeholders in some of the informational meetings that we need to develop.
    • 04:41:36
      And I don't develop the communications that they need.
    • 04:41:42
      One way we might look at this is maybe we need each district involved to some degree with the representatives to have some input or someone to give the analysis and bring it back and communicate to them.
    • 04:41:52
      So I'm not satisfied with the response I got because I didn't get any response.
    • 04:41:57
      Sure, it impacts them and they have an opinion.
    • 04:41:59
      We don't know what that is from a rural perspective.
    • 04:42:01
      I don't know what Peter's got from that perspective from a rural representative as well, but I don't find a thing.
    • 04:42:09
      I'm finding that hard to believe that the impact I think it could have on rural counties and we don't have a response.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:42:18
      Oh, just further to that, I share your concern on that.
    • 04:42:21
      I had suggested to Nick that in this process he and his committee might want to think about picking some examples, specific sort of like test cases in rural areas to really see how this would work.
    • 04:42:37
      One of the concerns I've had is
    • 04:42:39
      In rural areas, you really have two different things going on.
    • 04:42:43
      You have areas that are truly rural and then you have towns and villages which even though they're in rural areas have a sort of an urban context to them.
    • 04:42:54
      In my particular area, we're working on a whole new plan for the town of Marshall.
    • 04:43:01
      where we're really trying very hard to make sure going forward that the residential areas that are adjacent to Main Street have the appropriate connectivity and so forth and so on.
    • 04:43:11
      And I had offered Marshall as, for example, a test case that could be used just to see whether in fact these regulations really do what everybody intends them to do.
    • 04:43:21
      But to address your concern, maybe that's a way to address this, which is to look at some test cases
    • 04:43:29
      in rural areas and see whether these things work.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:33
      I think those are both great suggestions.
    • 04:43:35
      I do know we have dispatched young Mr. Donohue to meet with the Association of Counties this coming weekend.
    • 04:43:42
      If he comes back alive, we can make one assessment.
    • 04:43:47
      You may need to reconsider these regulations, but I think your point is very well taken.
    • 04:43:52
      This is true of any regulation.
    • 04:43:54
      Until people see a true application in their community, they're not going to make
    • 04:43:58
      This is very abstract stuff as we've learned.
    • 04:44:02
      I think the best thing for us to do is to get our best guess regulation out for public commentary and then it might be appropriate to work in individual districts to use a concrete example or two because topography is going to be the driver.
    • 04:44:18
      If you're in a community that has a lot of water bodies, that drives one set of connectivity issues.
    • 04:44:23
      If you have mountainous terrain, yet another.
    • 04:44:28
      Flatts, Southside, yet another.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:44:31
      And that has been addressed in our discussion.
    • 04:44:35
      In fact, in the discussions we've had, you've always been able to find an exception to the rule.
    • 04:44:41
      I mean, be it a lake, be it railroad tracks, be it a river, be it a cliff that's bordering a piece of property that prohibits access.
    • 04:44:50
      And that's why the draft regulation
    • 04:44:52
      does have a mechanism where both the resident administrator, the district administrator, and the commissioner of it, you know, ultimately, you know, can make exceptions, can waive, you know, certain requirements, you know, based on the, on the topography or, I'm just seeing what's going on.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:45:08
      As I read that, I wouldn't totally set aside with that option for an exception because it lends itself to his opinion.
    • 04:45:16
      I don't know if the model is...
    • 04:45:20
      I trust our commissioner.
    • 04:45:22
      It will obviously be well-contained.
    • 04:45:25
      But will a model be developed for evaluation of whether or not we make an exception or not?
    • 04:45:30
      Those types of things were still unanswered questions as you looked at that.
    • 04:45:33
      And how would you get an exception?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:45:34
      And of course... Well, the local government, I mean, the first would be the local government, and I'm assuming the developer would come to the local government to come to the department to just say, because it's a park-free terrain,
    • 04:45:46
      or for whatever number of reasons, you know, we cannot meet the link node or the connectivity requirement, you know, for, you know, for the particular area.
    • 04:45:56
      And it's on a case-by-case basis, I mean, but, you know, all I can do is say that I believe who's ever viewing it from the department standpoint is going to take a serious hard look at the reasons, you know, why the connectivity requirements cannot be met.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:46:16
      We'll be accused of the sidewalk to nowhere in a lot of our communities if we're not careful here.
    • 04:46:22
      When I read that, that they're requiring one sidewalk in every rural site development, I just can't believe in some of the places that I've been unless I misunderstand what we're talking about here.
    • 04:46:33
      That makes no sense whatsoever.
    • 04:46:34
      And I'd hate to think you'd have an exception to every one of those in many of the rural areas.
    • 04:46:41
      I think we need a little more work on it, and I would like to have a chance to hear
    • 04:46:45
      some more feedback and some of the more rural counties for sure.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:46:49
      And that will be part of the public comment but let's not forget the fact that the General Assembly has instructed us that we have to look at pedestrian connectivity and they've not differentiated between rural, urban, or suburban.
    • 04:47:04
      They have said that another mode of travel is by walking
    • 04:47:09
      and that we need to, and we're looking mostly at subdivisions here.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:47:13
      Mr. Chairman, that doesn't mean a sidewalk though.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:47:15
      And you don't have, there are alternatives to the sidewalk.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:47:19
      Let me suggest that we not get into the specific language of the regulation.
    • 04:47:24
      When we get it graphed out for public commentary, you know, this is going to be a big homework assignment and some of you are very familiar with these issues and I think the important thing to do is read it, provide commentary because ultimately this body has to
    • 04:47:38
      You know, approve, modify, or reject the regulation before it goes to the governor.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:47:44
      Mr. Chairman, I do think after the last meeting I had a parade of visitors on the issue and they brought in examples of subdivisions where it was absolutely impractical.
    • 04:47:57
      Sidewalks were the best example.
    • 04:48:00
      They brought me an example of a large lot subdivision
    • 04:48:03
      where those who would be buying into the subdivision didn't want to see the pedestrian sidewalk or trail.
    • 04:48:11
      That's one of the reasons they wanted the large lots, they wanted the rural ambiance.
    • 04:48:17
      The local government agreed with their assessment, thought it was impractical, thought that actually it was going to take more wetlands than appropriate.
    • 04:48:26
      As they got into the specific example, some of which I think have been shared with others,
    • 04:48:31
      I know you got a lengthy memo from Barbara Fried voicing her concerns.
    • 04:48:38
      What bothers me is I'm not sure whether the committee is addressing those concerns or not.
    • 04:48:43
      I think the committee needs to look at the practical issues that have been raised by those who have to implement the designs.
    • 04:48:51
      And I think they're raising some very valid criticisms before they go forward with a proposed
    • 04:48:59
      requirements, I would certainly hope that they would try to attempt to address those concerns so we don't spend a significant amount of time spending on wheels.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:49:10
      Mr. Secretary, Mr. Davies, there have been a number of issues discussed by the committee, and the development community is represented on the committee and raised a lot of these concerns.
    • 04:49:20
      From the first draft of this regulation to the one we have today, there have been a number of things eliminated from the draft regulations, such as block length.
    • 04:49:28
      which was an issue of discussion.
    • 04:49:31
      The link node ratio has been reduced.
    • 04:49:34
      City of Suffolk has a 1.4 link node ratio in the City of Suffolk that they are on the committee.
    • 04:49:40
      They've told everyone there it works fine throughout the entire City of Suffolk.
    • 04:49:45
      So we're not going down a path that has not been explored by all the jurisdictions in the Commonwealth.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:49:51
      It picks up what James was talking about
    • 04:49:54
      City of Suffolk is not a rural area and it's not a large lot subdivision issue.
    • 04:49:59
      I think there are issues that have not apparently been addressed.
    • 04:50:03
      At least the last draft I saw those concerns have not been met.
    • 04:50:08
      I would hope that you'd make an effort to do that before you bring it to the public.
    • 04:50:13
      Otherwise, we're going to take significant time.
    • 04:50:17
      I would hope we build a consensus before we advance the regulations.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:22
      We are under statutory deadline to issue a final regulation, if I remember correctly, or at least a draft regulation.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:50:30
      The plan was to put this out for public comment in December, to make the presentation today, and then to put it out in December for public comment.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:42
      Undoubtedly, we'll be discussing this at the December meeting as well.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:50:45
      But talking about the rural areas, understand there is no link node.
    • 04:50:48
      The only requirement for the network addition is one external connection as well as an additional external connection to stub out per 50 links in the rural areas.
    • 04:51:00
      Now, in all area types, developments must connect with the adjoining development stub outs to be eligible for acceptance into the state system.
    • 04:51:10
      And a stub out is just a short segment
    • 04:51:13
      Edge of a development intended to provide connectivity with future developments.
    • 04:51:20
      There are exceptions.
    • 04:51:22
      We mentioned some of them incompatible adjoining land use, you know, such as industrial, either existing industrial or industrial shown on the comprehensive plan.
    • 04:51:34
      Although, again, there is a requirement for sub-outs, but the external connectivity requirements of one and then one additional of every 50
    • 04:51:42
      There's an exception that was incompatible joining land.
    • 04:51:46
      Terrain is another one where there's an exception for the external connectivity requirement.
    • 04:51:52
      Existing development, say it's an existing industrial development, again that's an exception for external connectivity.
    • 04:52:00
      And finally, parcel shape.
    • 04:52:02
      Again, where sub-outs may be required, the external connectivity requirement is not required depending on the parcel shape.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 04:52:12
      Chairman, you said it's better not to get into specific language now and save that for later and time is going very short for this session.
    • 04:52:25
      Would it be appropriate, I have a number of questions and complaints and
    • 04:52:31
      I'm concerned about this.
    • 04:52:32
      Would it be appropriate to just send emails to Rick or to somebody?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:52:38
      Yeah, let me suggest that as you read it to, please send an email to Nick, and I think it would be a good idea to copy the Commissioner, Mr. Walton, on behalf to take a copy of those too.
    • 04:52:49
      I mean, I've dealt with a lot of this in local government for 15 years.
    • 04:52:52
      I mean, this is hard stuff.
    • 04:52:54
      But, when we're accepting 200 lane miles a year,
    • 04:52:59
      into our system for perpetual maintenance.
    • 04:53:03
      This, when you talk about long-term financial liability, this is it.
    • 04:53:08
      So, yes, we're going to ruffle some feathers.
    • 04:53:11
      There are going to be some issues.
    • 04:53:13
      But what is driving this in the General Assembly, in very strong consensus, is just like we're making investment choices on the rail side and a public benefit, this is the same thing.
    • 04:53:24
      This should not be open-ended acceptance
    • 04:53:28
      for something that does not serve a public purpose.
    • 04:53:31
      And at the end of the day, that's what these requirements are for, to determine in some fashion, and you get into a little bit more prescription with these kind of regulations, but ultimately it's to determine there is a public benefit for agreeing for 50 or 100 years to maintain this with public dollars.
    • 04:53:49
      And that's the underlying calculus here.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:53:54
      While generally we talk about network acceptance, there are provisions for individual street acceptance as well in the proposed regulation.
    • 04:54:05
      Here are four situations in which an individual street may be considered for acceptance within the system.
    • 04:54:11
      It provides a missing link of connectivity between two existing roads in the system, or it's a collector or above, or a frontage or reverse frontage road.
    • 04:54:20
      or a rural addition.
    • 04:54:22
      In those poor situations, we can look at accepting individual streets as opposed to a network of streets.
    • 04:54:29
      Pedestrian accommodations.
    • 04:54:32
      In a compact area type, sidewalks are required both sides of the road under the regulation.
    • 04:54:39
      In a suburban area type, sidewalks are required for a system of multi-use trails and sidewalks
    • 04:54:47
      and in a rural area type sidewalk on one side of the road or a system of multi-use trails to provide connectivity.
    • 04:54:57
      As I mentioned previously, these requirements in the suburban and rural areas may be modified by the district administrator when the developer proposes alternative pedestrian accommodation that provides the same type of connectivity.
    • 04:55:11
      And in a suburban area where the density is less than two dwelling units per acre, you may use the rural area type accommodations in the regulations.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:55:22
      As far as area type thresholds, Mr. Schwartz?
    • 04:55:25
      I'm sorry, just a quick question.
    • 04:55:27
      In a rural area where you're working in a town where you have a higher density, Rick, of four or six or even eight dwelling units per acre, do you have the option
    • 04:55:40
      of using the more urban model.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:55:45
      You can always go up on the regulation.
    • 04:55:47
      You don't go down.
    • 04:55:48
      You can always go up.
    • 04:55:51
      Again, at the area type thresholds, we have the compact.
    • 04:55:56
      We have the suburban and the rural.
    • 04:55:58
      The commissioner, based upon a resolution from the local governing body, may determine the area type or area type requirements for a specific area
    • 04:56:07
      should be modified and this is only if it's designated for agricultural, forestry, conservation, and or open space uses.
    • 04:56:15
      We've heard from Fairfax County that Fairfax has rural areas and Fairfax has large lot subdivision.
    • 04:56:21
      They believe that they have rural areas of Fairfax County and some of them are dedicated for conservation and large lot development.
    • 04:56:28
      So they want to be able to use a rural standard in certain parts of Fairfax County.
    • 04:56:33
      Now this modification, it seems to apply
    • 04:56:36
      if the zoning or the district classification of the specific area is modified.
    • 04:56:42
      Conditional acceptance is something that's also been discussed in the meetings.
    • 04:56:47
      Developers may choose to meet link node ratio requirements for network conditions through provisions of additional sub-outs.
    • 04:56:56
      Now, the risk here is that where the sub-out provides the connectivity that in the future, the future development does not connect at that sub-out location.
    • 04:57:06
      If that should occur, then that road in the existing subdivision would come out of the system, although it comes out after one year.
    • 04:57:17
      Next steps, there's an internal VDOT review ongoing on design standards with the AASHTO Green Book for context-sensitive design.
    • 04:57:28
      VDOT staff is reviewing National Stormwater Management techniques to determine which are appropriate for use in Virginia.
    • 04:57:34
      As I mentioned previously, the hope is to publish this draft regulation for public comment in December, and VDOT staff is also developing a guidance document that will supplement the regulation.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:57:53
      Thank you, Mr. Walton.
    • 04:57:54
      Any additional questions or comments?
    • 04:57:58
      It's the case that there is sort of an evolving hard draft of the regulation.
    • 04:58:02
      These are not concepts of bullet points.
    • 04:58:05
      These are draft regulations that are evolving.
    • 04:58:08
      Would it be possible for Nick to send the current draft out to the CTB just so there's a snapshot in time and for you all to read those and provide any guidance or feedback?
    • 04:58:20
      And we'll schedule this again for December.
    • 04:58:22
      This will be an iterative process.
    • 04:58:23
      I think we can safely assume there will not be a perfect regulation when it's finally adopted, but there's nothing in there that can't be changed.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:58:30
      Will we vote then to approve it to be published, or is it going to be published?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:58:37
      I'm not sure how the APA process works.
    • 04:58:39
      Is it the agency that has to approve?
    • 04:58:42
      Is it the governor that has to approve?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:58:43
      Well, the plan is, I'm not sure if there's any necessity for approval to receive public comment.
    • 04:58:50
      The plan was to go ahead and publish it
    • 04:58:52
      to receive public comment.
    • 04:58:54
      Based on the public comment, we would come back to the board to get approval of the regulation based on the input from the public comment.
    • 04:59:03
      So this is the board's regulation.
    • 04:59:05
      So the board has the final approval.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:59:07
      Yeah, but I think what the board is saying is they don't want to go forward with public commentary on something that they are not comfortable with.
    • 04:59:16
      That's not to say that every T is going to be crossed or every I dotted.
    • 04:59:20
      So I think the focus needs to be
    • 04:59:22
      on major issues that can be resolved before we take something public.
    • 04:59:28
      That will be our goal at the December meeting, to make sure that we have a regulation, maybe that we don't all agree to, but that it is fair to put out for public commentary.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:59:36
      And Mr. Secretary, are we going to wait to put it out for public comment after the December board meeting?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:59:42
      Yes.
    • 04:59:43
      Let me see if I can clarify, Mr. Secretary, then, so I don't get the question tomorrow.
    • 04:59:49
      Does it require
    • 04:59:50
      Rick, under APA, does it require a board resolution for us to go to public comment?
    • 04:59:57
      Is that the intent of the board?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 04:59:59
      This regulation, this is not, this is a provision of the administrative process that shall not apply to initial regulations promulgated by the board.
    • 05:00:14
      So we're not worried about the APA.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:16
      It's whenever the board... Do we have to adopt a regulation by a date certain?
    • 05:00:21
      No.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 05:00:23
      Just the existing...
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:24
      So we have some flexibility to deal with this, but I think if there are things that the board
    • 05:00:28
      simply says, look, we do not want to take public commentary on this particular aspect because we don't think this is something that ought to be included.
    • 05:00:38
      That ought to be the focus of the three or four big issues that need to come out or be substantially modified.
    • 05:00:45
      Everybody comfortable with that?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:48
      Mr. Chairman, I would just suggest, however, that the comments we've been receiving are actually a part of that process.
    • 05:00:53
      So we're actually in the public comment period.
    • 05:00:55
      In some sense, it's just a very
    • 05:00:57
      It's a very self-selected public that's decided to weigh in.
    • 05:01:01
      I don't want to, you know, buck the will of the board, but moving forward seems to me to be the best way to go.
    • 05:01:11
      Let's get the comments in.
    • 05:01:12
      The fact is, there's no real answers to these things that will satisfy everyone.
    • 05:01:18
      There are legitimate concerns.
    • 05:01:19
      If we can collect them, if we can get a broader set of feedback, then they can keep us
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:01:25
      And your point is well taken, but ultimately if the CTB has to adopt a regulation and
    • 05:01:41
      I've not seen the actual regulations.
    • 05:01:43
      I think we need to see the text of the regulation in black and white as a body before that goes public.
    • 05:01:51
      There is a great deal of commentary that many of you are hearing, sometimes in forums, sometimes in talks.
    • 05:01:55
      Some of it may not be founded.
    • 05:01:57
      And we just need to look at the text page by page and see if there's anything that jumps out before we go forward with seeking formal regulatory comments on it.
    • 05:02:09
      And when would that be?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:11
      I mean, when would we look at a text?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:13
      You'll get an email text this week or next week.
    • 05:02:19
      But then we would have, we would probably have an updated text in time for the December, we do have a December CTB meeting.
    • 05:02:27
      So, and then, so we would have a revised iteration of that text in advance of the CTB meeting.
    • 05:02:36
      to one week before then.
    • 05:02:38
      I mean, we've been discussing this every month, but this is a huge issue and a difficult issue.
    • James A. DavisMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:47
      Because of the scale of it, is it possible that we receive it printed rather than by email?
    • 05:02:53
      How long is it?
    • 05:02:54
      I don't even know.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 05:02:56
      36 pages.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:58
      Okay.
    • 05:02:59
      All right.
    • 05:03:00
      Well, we can certainly do that.
    • 05:03:02
      I appreciate it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:03:04
      Thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:03:05
      All right, if there are no other questions.