Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop and Action Meeting 5/16/2007
Auto-scroll
Workshop and Action Meeting
5/16/2007
Attachments
Workshop and meeting agendas.html
Board actions.html
Meeting minutes.pdf
Abandonment of Frontage Road F-1055, Warrenton.pdf
Highway Designation - Naming Route 609 in Bath County the “Edison Roberts Road”.pdf
Abandonment, discontinuance and transfers in the primary highways system.pdf
Virginia Byway Designation – Route 15 and Business Route 15 Loudoun, Prince William, Fauquier, Culpeper, Madison and Orange Counties.pdf
Economic development (industrial) access (deallocation), Page County.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 602, Amelia County.pdf
Land conveyance, Routes 57 and 674, Henry County.pdf
Limited access control changes, Routes 199, 641, Interstate 64, York County.pdf
FY07-12 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers April 1-30, 2007.pdf
Use of FY 2007 General Fund appropriation.pdf
Workshop minutes.pdf
Department of Rail and Public Transportation (DRPT) director's report.pdf
Virginia Department of Transporation (VDOT) Fiscal Year 2008 draft business plan.pdf
VDOT draft Six-Year Improvement Program and draft Six-Year Financial Plan.pdf
SYIP working draft.pdf
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:02
Good morning, and I'd like to call to order the May business meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:10
As is our custom, I'd like to begin with our public comment.
00:00:15
I know there's a Mr. Max Kendall and a Mr. Chip Pollard here to make comments of approximately three-minute duration.
00:00:24
Mr. Kendall, are you here?
00:00:27
You're welcome to address the board.
SPEAKER_18
00:00:34
Thank you very much for letting me speak to you today.
00:00:39
I'm Max Kendall from Monroe, Henry County, Virginia, and I come before you today to ask you to set up something for us.
00:00:51
I mailed you all a package, a little package that you got.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:54
Yes, sir, I think everyone has a copy of this.
SPEAKER_18
00:00:58
What I'm going to talk about today is your right of
00:01:03
III through Henry County.
00:01:06
Back in 2001, VDOT had a public shooting going in Henry County in Marnville, and they showed various rights of this road to go through Henry County.
00:01:23
At this hearing, the shooting went ahead, we saw that they didn't have a right
00:01:30
and our interchange is at P.A.T.R.I.C.H.
00:01:33
Center and Patrick Henry Cook College in Marnville or Henry County.
00:01:39
P.A.T.R.I.C.H.
00:01:42
is the largest and successful complex in Marnville and Henry County by far.
00:01:48
And so we asked VDOT officials at this public hearing in 2001
00:01:56
to, you know, why they didn't make a right to the paper, sir, and put an interchange in there and run it around into the present bypass.
00:02:08
And they told us if we could show cause, or had a reason, to put a drawing of this for the public to see, that they would do it.
00:02:19
And so the county tennis player was there, and as you can see in your support papers, two letters that he wrote to VDOT in January of 2001.
00:02:31
In February of 2001, we got a rule that the cutter back indicated that our plan would be consistent to cut it.
00:02:40
And so we didn't do anything about it because we were spec'ing, you know, we were spec'ing them to follow this right,
00:02:47
and let that be shown to the people.
00:02:52
And it never was done.
00:02:54
And June the 21st in 2001, VDOT approved the present right which you have on your front paper here.
00:03:03
And this present right also missed the bypass.
00:03:07
And the state's right, on your right side, of being black,
00:03:12
That right does not have very little public water, no public sewer on it whatsoever.
00:03:18
And Henry K. T. Town asked one thing we were blessed with, public water and sewer, and they missed it all.
00:03:24
And I've never seen a place in the United States that grew or expanded without public water and sewer.
00:03:32
You know, I've never seen it.
00:03:34
And so we wanted them to run it, you know, to draw a line to the patient center and run it around and hook it into the bypass.
00:03:44
We got an 18-mile bypass in Henry County built to interstate specification.
00:03:49
Some says it likes a few little things, but that's quite the moment.
00:03:54
And we wanted to hook it into that and run it all the way back to Bassett Falls, because Bassett up there, Henry County,
00:04:01
If any of you have ever been there, I mean, it was full of furniture factories, and now it's a complete ghost town.
00:04:07
It looks worse than the old towns in West Virginia did, back and forth now, because all our factories is gone.
00:04:15
You know, our, you know, our textile is gone, and our furniture badness is hitched about and heated that way fast.
00:04:23
And so what we need is this right change, and if we use five miles of the present bypass, we can save $200 million, because this particular five miles that we want to use
00:04:37
is the most expensive part of it because of all of the, you know, the overpasses built on 620 and you got your bridges over Lowood Creek, you got two bridges built over Smith River, and you also have an interchange right there at the Duchoque Stadium.
00:04:53
It's going to be built in Henry County in the next year or so.
00:04:57
And so what we're asking you to do, if you will, is to ask VDOT to make this drawing as they promised us in 2001.
00:05:05
And I know this board wasn't, you know, there at that time.
00:05:12
We're asking you to make that, you know, to ask VDOT to make both drawings available, the state's right, what they got now,
00:05:21
along with this proposed right that we got and display that on a public showing in Marlborough and Henry County and let the people in Marlborough and Henry County decide which is the best right for our area.
00:05:36
And I'm sorry I don't have a board, the Board of Supervisors.
00:05:40
I have them.
00:05:41
We got it in 2001.
00:05:42
That's the new board now.
00:05:45
And next Monday, I'll be on the board.
00:05:51
The meeting I spoke to, but they had a lot of budget stuff, and my presentation and all on that board.
00:06:04
And so I hope to have that to present to our representative on a submission here, Mr. Dana Martin.
00:06:13
Thank you so much, Mr. Kendall, and thank you for taking the time out of your schedule to come all the way to Richmond and share your thoughts.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:32
The Commissioner has heard them.
00:06:33
He's got a copy of your written comments.
00:06:36
Thank you so much.
00:06:39
The next speaker is Mr. Tripp Pollard.
00:06:41
Mr. Pollard, welcome.
SPEAKER_03
00:06:48
Good morning.
00:06:49
Thank you.
00:06:50
I'm Kurt Pollard, Department of Community Project Director for the Southern Environmental Law Center.
00:06:54
And I'll say you all don't look quite as intimidating as the picture in the time it's attached this morning.
00:07:00
I think you know a little bit what it looks like on this side of the podium.
00:07:04
I just wanted to briefly rave with you all some key issues involving that 81-quarter improvement study.
00:07:11
I sent a letter to you last week outlining some concerns, met with Secretary Homer as well to discuss some of these, and just wanted to share very briefly with you a few of these concerns because it is such a critical issue going forward for the Commonwealth.
00:07:25
The final environmental impact statement was released last month.
00:07:30
It does contain some very useful data.
00:07:31
It contains some important improvements, I think, over the draft study.
00:07:35
And importantly, like the resolution you passed in October, it does reject the one-size-fits-all approach and the concept of separated lanes.
00:07:45
However, unlike the resolution you all passed, it doesn't fully embrace a multi-step approach to 81.
00:07:52
Your resolution left open the door to widening ultimately to six and in some cases eight lanes, but only after a number of other steps were taken and other factors considered.
00:08:01
The final EIS though, proceeds largely to call for widening up to eight lanes for the vast majority of 81.
00:08:10
At a cost, needless to say, of billions of dollars, as well as significant impacts on community and the environment.
00:08:16
And the study does at least mention a lot of the important elements of your resolution, such as recognizing the immediate need to improve safety hot spots and, as you know, the Six-Year Plan, and moving ahead with those which we strongly support.
00:08:28
It also mentions short-term rail improvements to divert additional trucks, and it mentions context-sensitive solutions to be used.
00:08:35
But it only pays lip service to some important elements, I believe, of your resolution.
00:08:39
It does not put the same priority on these steps that you all did.
00:08:43
For example, it eliminates rail projects from the next phase of studies completely, and it dismisses rail options as not being reasonable.
00:08:51
The final EIS does acknowledge the current multi-state study.
00:08:55
saying that, quote, if funded rail improvements emerge, quote, from the study, then the effects of these improvements on future demand projections would be evaluated, quote, as appropriate.
00:09:05
And your resolution said projections of future demand for I-81 travel should be based on then current assumptions, taking into account a multi-state study, among other things.
00:09:15
Finally, I ask to add some important limitations to funded improvements and that they would be considered as appropriate.
00:09:22
This weakens your resolution.
00:09:24
And other provisions, such as the language on context-sensitive solution, are also watered down.
00:09:28
Now, there are other concerns in the final EIS.
00:09:31
For example, it completely ignores improvements to local street networks.
00:09:35
It could provide local traffic a better alternative to 81 and reduce some of the congestion and, therefore, some of the need for both.
00:09:42
It wouldn't completely solve the problem, but it's a package of necessary improvements, which is exactly the type of approach you all called for.
00:09:48
And Secretary Homer actually mentioned, I believe it was at the October meeting, that he thought he saw as an important issue that needed to be looked at.
00:09:57
EIS is completely silent on that, for example.
00:10:01
It also underestimates the environmental damage done and fails to consider adequately the link between transportation and land use, as well as the impact of rising fuel costs.
00:10:09
The bottom line is some key alternatives are slated.
00:10:12
Future needs for expansion are overestimated and some of the impacts are underestimated.
00:10:17
This is not consistent with the policies you have advocated or with the Secretary's or the Governor's calls for better linking transportation land use, protecting open space, and improved environmental protection.
00:10:28
It's also out of step with what the localities in the corridor have said they want to see, and it's out of step with a record public response to the draft study.
00:10:36
Now, we're moving ahead with these shorter-term improvements.
00:10:39
I think everyone's on board with that.
00:10:40
But the fact is, this sets the framework for decades to come.
00:10:44
It's intended to be the blueprint for improvement through 2030.
00:10:47
We need to get this right, especially since the final EIS suggests that much of the analysis of the bill on earnest will be deferred to Tier II.
00:10:55
But then it says, in Tier II, they only plan to use limited review, relying on categorical exclusions and environmental assessments, not environmental impact statements.
00:11:05
These three federal agencies have a projected difference approach.
00:11:09
I hate to say this, but this is exactly the kind of thing that got us into trouble in the 90s.
00:11:13
We need to be sure we are doing complete and thorough environmental studies so that we don't get projects unnecessarily delayed and hung up.
00:11:23
In short, I urge you to insist that the flaws in this study be corrected and that either a revised final environmental impact statement or supplemental statement be issued before any projects proceed further.
00:11:35
At the very least, we urge you to ensure that additional analysis, such as looking at local road improvements and at land use impacts, be undertaken to close the gaps in the study by a specified date so that informed decisions can be made regarding the need for particular projects and to make sure the multi-step process you outline is followed.
00:11:55
Thank you very much for your attention to these critical issues.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:58
Thank you, Mr. Pollard.
00:11:59
Is there anybody else who wants to address the board under citizens' time?
00:12:05
If not, is there a motion to approve the April minutes?
00:12:11
So moved.
00:12:11
Is there a second?
00:12:12
Second.
00:12:12
All in favor?
00:12:15
Aye.
00:12:15
Action item one is on a frontage road abandonment in the town of Warrenton.
00:12:22
Are there any questions of Mr. Elliott?
00:12:26
Is there a motion?
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:29
Mr. Chairman, just before the vote, I just want to announce that I need to recuse myself from this vote.
00:12:35
The sole adjoining or adjacent landowner is Highland School in Warrenton, and I'm on the Board of Trustees.
00:12:43
Can you reflect that in the minutes, please?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:45
We have a motion and a second.
00:12:47
All in favor?
00:12:49
Aye.
00:12:49
Thank you, Mr. Schwartz.
00:12:50
Action item two is a highway designation in Bath County.
00:12:56
Is there a question of Mr. Elliott?
00:12:59
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_13
00:13:02
Move to approve.
00:13:03
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:04
All in favor?
00:13:07
Aye.
00:13:07
Action item 3A is in Culpeper District, a primary route abandonment in Rappahannock County.
00:13:20
Are there any questions?
00:13:23
Move to approve.
00:13:23
All in favor?
SPEAKER_13
00:13:25
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:26
Action, that's it.
00:13:30
There were three separate actions, I'm sorry, under that motion.
00:13:32
Everybody understand the motion encompassed all three?
00:13:36
Thank you.
00:13:37
Under local assistance division, Mr. Estes will be here to answer any questions.
00:13:42
Action item 4A is a byway designation for route 15 in several communities.
00:13:50
Are there any questions of Mr. Estes?
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:53
Mr. Chairman, I move to approve that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:56
Is there a second?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:57
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:58
All in favor?
00:14:00
Aye.
00:14:00
Any opposed?
00:14:02
Thank you.
00:14:04
Action item 5A is industrial access deallocation in Page County.
00:14:10
Any questions of Mr. Estes?
00:14:14
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_00
00:14:15
I move to approve.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:17
Second?
SPEAKER_00
00:14:18
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:19
All in favor?
00:14:20
Aye.
00:14:21
Thank you.
00:14:22
Action Item 6 is under Mr. Waymak.
00:14:27
Are there any questions about either 6A in Amelia County or 6B in Henry County?
00:14:37
Okay, and that motion is for both 6A and 6B.
00:14:41
Is that the motion?
00:14:42
All in favor?
00:14:44
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:44
Action item 7A, a limited access control change in York County.
00:14:51
Are there any questions of Mr. Waymack?
00:14:53
Move approval.
00:14:55
Second.
00:14:55
All in favor?
00:14:57
Aye.
00:14:59
Action item 8, under programming division, these are the monthly transfers.
00:15:03
Are there any questions of Ms. Reese?
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:05
Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:07
Is there a second?
00:15:08
Second.
00:15:09
All in favor?
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:10
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:11
Also, Ms. Reese, under the Financial Planning Division, this is the FY 2007 General Fund appropriation.
00:15:21
Ms. Reese, could you give everybody a brief description?
00:15:23
This is a hard issue to understand, actually a very simple action, but if you could explain this a little bit, it would be helpful.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:15:30
Behind tab nine in your book, if you look at the very last page within that tab is the actual budget language around the one-time general fund appropriations of $500 million to transportation.
00:15:45
The italicized language on that page outlines the uses of those funds as we talked about yesterday.
00:15:51
$305 million of that is for certain TPTA or design-build projects.
00:15:58
The only one I would note, and Dr. Davis is not here, but we certainly have talked about it, is the Route 37 Eastern bypass, the EIS work for that.
00:16:08
That cannot qualify for PPTA or design bill, so we have funded that project, $1.5 million of that work in the regular six-year program, but the rest of these will be negotiated PPTA or design bill projects.
00:16:22
All of which are scheduled to be in negotiations this year.
00:16:26
The $65 million is to certain rail enhancement projects, $45 million to transit capital projects, $50 million to the port, and then $20 million to revenue sharing.
00:16:39
Why we are asking for early approval of this is so that we can negotiate in good faith and get those projects moving in the cash to where they need to go.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:49
Any questions of Missouri's?
00:16:50
Mr. Koelemay?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:52
Ms. Reese, we can't actually tell what the $305 million will be split at the moment because that will be a subject of negotiation.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:17:02
Yes, sir.
00:17:02
But we will keep you informed of that.
Charles M. Badger
Director of Public Transportation
00:17:06
Any other questions?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:09
Is there a second?
00:17:12
Before we take the vote, I would just like to re-emphasize this governor's commitment to transportation.
00:17:17
This is half a billion dollars in general funds.
00:17:21
and the choices, what this could do for higher education, for health care, for mental health and the Governor and the General Assembly made a choice to put this into transportation and we have a very, very serious obligation to oversee and make sure that these funds are absolutely prudent use because the opportunities in these other areas are every bit as important as transportation.
00:17:45
And so we, I think it would be fair to ask Ms. Reese that we come back on a periodic basis to look at the use of these funds.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:55
Mr. Chairman, may I second that, but also commend you and the leadership at the Department of Transportation and the Department of Rail and Public Transportation for suggesting some pretty darn important projects to be included.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:09
Thank you.
00:18:10
All right, there's a motion in second.
00:18:12
All in favor?
00:18:13
All right.
00:18:14
Any opposed?
00:18:16
Thank you.
00:18:18
Action item 10, Mr. Coburn, our favorite part of the meeting.
00:18:22
Is this a good month or a bad month?
00:18:24
Good morning.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:18:26
On April 25th, we received bids on 30 projects, three of which were over $2 million.
00:18:36
Of those, two we are recommending for award as they do represent a good value.
00:18:42
One, we are recommending a rejection.
00:18:48
In detail, page one is 295.
00:18:53
This is a concrete pavement repair in the northbound lane from Chickahominy River Bridge north about two miles.
00:19:02
This is on the east side of Richmond.
00:19:05
It's concrete repair and asphalt overlay.
00:19:09
Two bids were received, very good bids, and we're recommending war to Interstate Construction Corporation.
00:19:18
All in favor?
00:19:26
On page two, this is a regional traffic signal installation and renovation contract.
00:19:36
This is a renewable contract, can be renewed for two years.
00:19:46
This project is based on ten new installations and eight rework locations.
00:19:56
This includes part of the Richmond District, Lynchburg, and Credit Square districts in what we call the central region.
00:20:05
Two bidders that do this work, we're recommending an award to Richard Whalen Electrical.
00:20:15
All in favor?
00:20:20
On page three is project, this is a retrofit sign and removal of catwalks on overhead signs.
00:20:30
We're recommending rejection.
00:20:31
We got three bids.
00:20:32
However, these were not from traditional sign firms who do this type of work.
00:20:39
Analysis revealed it is not a good value.
00:20:43
We did have four.
00:20:45
S. F. F. F. F. F. F.
00:21:09
The firms who submitted their primary business is not signed work.
00:21:14
Some of the individual items were well out of kilter for what we'd expect that work to be bid for.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:25
If we're trying to expand and get more competition, but you, by looking at these companies and their bids, you don't think they could have performed the work?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:21:33
These firms certainly could have performed the work.
00:21:37
However, we would be paying a premium if we would award this type of contract.
00:21:45
We believe there's a little bit of saturation in the market.
00:21:48
It's part of the reason that the other firms didn't bid.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:57
Are there any safety questions that would give this project urgency?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:22:04
No, sir.
00:22:05
We've confirmed with the design, with the structure and bridge folks in that area that these are, while important to pursue, if not urgent.
00:22:17
And we believe restructuring and remarketing is the appropriate tack.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:23
I just have a question about what might lead you to think you would get a lower bid given the price of gasoline going up and other things that happen.
00:22:34
Are you likely to take a risk there?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:22:38
There were several items that were very inconsistent across these several bidders.
00:22:51
Close to unbalancing bid items, extreme ranges on a couple of items were likely to overrun, and so I think that's about all I can say.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:10
Well, thank you.
00:23:11
I mean, we have a lot of respect for your professional judgment.
00:23:13
We just wanted to follow up some of those questions.
Jim D. Bowie
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:17
Yes, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:19
All right, the motion is to reject.
00:23:20
All in favor?
00:23:24
Just a note on that, and I think that's something that's very important to explain to the public that simply because the bid is the lowest does not mean that there's no independent evaluation.
00:23:38
And I know as we move more into design-build, one of the most important things that we can say to people is whether it's a low bid or a design-build,
00:23:49
We have an internal evaluation, both a qualitative and a price evaluation.
00:23:55
And whether it's design-build or PPTA or sealed bid, if it does not meet that standard, we don't approve it.
00:24:03
And that's a very important message, particularly to Koelemay and Northern Virginia, Mr. Sterling, as we get into some of these large design-build projects.
00:24:11
We do this very well.
00:24:12
And Virginia's one of the leaders in this area, but it's the, you know, we sort of see the
00:24:19
the tip of the pyramid in terms of that staff analysis.
00:24:22
I know there's a great deal of work that goes into evaluating those bids as well as the design-build projects.
00:24:27
Thank you, Mr. Coburn.
00:24:30
Okay, any items under new business?
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:34
Mr. Chairman, if I may, I have three items that I'd like to discuss under new business.
00:24:41
The first relates to public-private partnerships and infrastructure projects.
00:24:48
My request would be that the CTB at some point in the near future schedule a work session or portion of a workshop to look again comprehensively at the issue of public-private partnerships for transportation and whether they're in the public interest.
00:25:09
I want to point out to the board
00:25:13
three items which I'll give to Ms. Mathis and ask that she make copies and circulate them.
00:25:19
The cover story of Business Week magazine last week is entitled, Hey Buddy, Wanna Buy a Bridge?
00:25:27
Why Investors Are Clamoring to Take Over America's Roads, Bridges, and Airports, and Why the Public Should Be Nervous.
00:25:34
I don't know if any of you read it.
00:25:36
It's a rather balanced article talking about some of the pros and cons of doing public-private partnerships, but it certainly, in my mind, created an awareness of some questions that I think, as a broad policy matter, the CTB ought
00:25:53
The other two items, the first is a letter which was sent out by the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure to all 50 governors on the 10th of May of this year.
00:26:09
Other transportation officials, you may have been a recipient.
00:26:12
A very cautionary letter about entering into further public-private partnerships for transportation infrastructure starts off, and I'm certainly not going to read it.
00:26:25
We write, to strongly discourage you, meaning the 50 governors, from entering into public-private partnership agreements that are not in the long-term public interest.
00:26:36
and so forth.
00:26:37
And it describes any number of circumstances where these types of partnerships may not be in the public interest.
00:26:46
It's signed by Congressman Overstar and DeFazio, the chair of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure and the chair of the Subcommittee on Highways and Transit.
00:26:57
And they do mention in this letter that they may, in the next safety lieu,
00:27:03
The New York Times.
00:27:19
Committee, and I just want to mention that in April the Texas legislature voted to put a two-year moratorium on public-private partnerships because of concerns they had that the pricing on the transactions was not in the public benefit and some other concerns about
00:27:39
H. J. J. J. J.
00:28:03
So I would ask that we schedule that discussion at some point, and I'm going to give these to Ms. Mathis to hand out.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:13
Ms. Schwartz will consider that.
00:28:16
What I will do is forward to the CTB, the governor's testimony to that very subcommittee just last year, so there's no mistaking where the administration's policy is on this issue.
00:28:29
I would say there are states who have not respected the customers.
00:28:36
And if you read the 2006 concession legislation in Virginia, which we proposed and I believe was unanimously approved by the General Assembly, what it provides is that the benefits of the tolls have to go to the rate payer.
00:28:52
It's a very simple concept, one that has not been observed, for example, in the Chicago transaction.
00:29:00
where the benefits of those concession proceeds were used to underwrite very worthy programs in housing and libraries and other areas.
00:29:12
Could not do that under Virginia's statute or our long-term policy goals.
00:29:16
The Indiana transaction is another one that's been cited, and those were two-thirds of those tolling revenues were exported downstate.
00:29:24
Again, could not conduct a transaction like that.
00:29:29
We'll be happy to consider having, you know, some kind of discussion on this, but I don't want there to be any mistaking what our policy is on this.
00:29:38
We are regarded as a national leader in public-private partnerships.
00:29:44
These have been a source of bipartisan support in the General Assembly because we have a very conservative, very mature program.
00:29:52
And so to the degree that we have discussion, I think it ought to be to differentiate ourselves from some of these states that I think in some respects have perhaps gone too far.
00:30:01
So we welcome that opportunity.
00:30:03
I need to say that many of the criticisms you're seeing in some of those letters are not applicable to the Commonwealth, and I think when you see the Governor's testimony, which I think was provided last year in 2005 when the Governor did, that would probably be a good little refresher on that matter.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:23
So I'd like to bring that up very much, but I would appreciate the opportunity for us to have that discussion.
00:30:30
The second item of new business that I wanted to raise, Mr. Chairman, is that, and this also relates, at least tangentially, to the issue of how we handle the disposition of public assets such as road infrastructures and right-of-way, that there has been a request of the Department of Transportation or VDOT by Dominion Power and perhaps Allegheny Power as well
00:30:59
to utilize the Interstate 66 right-of-way or at least portions of it to erect towers for a new 500-kilovolt power line.
00:31:11
As you know, there's considerable controversy over that power line and whether it's needed, but my concern in raising this this morning as it relates to the Commonwealth Transportation Board is
00:31:24
If we as a board are going to be asked to look at that proposal at some point and the efficacy of entering into that type of contract, I do think that we need to begin to develop some background of knowledge on the issue that would address, first of all, the safety issue in terms of medevac accessibility to the highway where you have these large towers.
00:31:51
So there's a general safety issue.
00:31:53
There is a future use of the right-of-way issue.
00:31:57
There's no question that over the long term there may well be needs, and I think everybody anticipates this, to widen 66 further to the west than it's been widened in the past to potentially run some sort of mass transit on the surface and so forth.
00:32:13
Nobody yet knows what these opportunities would look like.
00:32:16
But there are serious questions about whether the utilization of the right-of-way for a major power line would preclude those options for the Commonwealth in the future.
00:32:27
And the third issue of course is the health issue.
00:32:30
There's a lot of literature relating to health concerns about proximity to power lines.
00:32:36
The particular concern in this case is that we have commuters who sit on the I-66 right-of-way for
00:32:47
So I would request that, first of all, that we get a report from the Department on the status of any conversations in this regard and that we also schedule time to begin to get ourselves up to speed on these particular issues.
00:33:17
My third item of business, and I'll be brief, is I'm particularly concerned about the comments that Mr. Pollard made about the consistency of the final EIS for 81 with the letter and the spirit of the resolution that this Board passed in the fall.
00:33:39
and I don't know quite where we go from here.
00:33:44
I understand that there was some urgency to complete the EIS in order to not hold up necessary spot improvements that I think everybody on this board and probably everybody in this room was in agreement with, but I am concerned
00:34:02
about problems with the final EIS and the potential impact on the future of the corridor and the broader decisions.
00:34:13
And so I don't know, this is really as much of a question as anything else.
00:34:18
It's where do we go from here and how can we be sure that notwithstanding
00:34:24
EIS, the final EIS, that we can make sure that our will is ultimately imposed on what happens with the corridor and what should we do.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:39
Sure.
00:34:40
Two items.
00:34:41
We'll obviously look at I-66.
00:34:44
One cautionary note, I would be hesitant to invest a whole lot of resources in that unless that looks like that's going to become a realistic option just given the limited time and availability of the board.
00:34:55
On I-81, we plan in October to make that a major work session item to get an update on the corridor development, the truck climbing lanes, the safety improvements, the rail program as well as the EIS and what would be the next step in that planning process.
00:35:15
So I think that would be appropriate and we might even be able to
00:35:18
J. Michael A. Davis III, John C. Connally,
00:35:39
That would be the one year anniversary of that.
00:35:41
Hopefully there's been enough work so that there's some actual documentation and investment made that we could sink our teeth into some of those inquiries.
00:35:52
So I think that's an excellent suggestion.
00:35:57
Any other items under new business?
00:36:00
If not, I would like to, if you'll indulge me for just a minute.
00:36:11
I did want to acknowledge two people.
00:36:13
First, former chair of the CTB and Secretary, Whit Clement.
00:36:18
Always great to have you back, Whit, when you're awful quiet back there.
00:36:25
You went through those very difficult periods of making huge cuts in the six-year program that were so painful.
00:36:32
We're going to have a little fun restoring the program here in the next couple of months, but it would not have been possible without the work you did to bring fiscal sanity to that transportation program.
00:36:45
So thank you so much for that.
00:36:52
I'd also like to introduce Mr. Eig, that's spelled E-I-G, with the Attorney General's Office.
00:36:58
John Bell, who is our normal counsel, is unable to be with us today.
00:37:03
And if you could stand up so everybody could see you.
00:37:05
Mr. Eig is one of those persons who works diligently in the Attorney General's Office in our area.
00:37:13
And thank you for joining us today.
00:37:15
If you've got any legal questions, please ask Mr. Eig.
00:37:20
And thanks for being with us.
00:37:21
A third item I would like to note.
00:37:26
Yesterday was a very, very important day, and Mr. Schwartz brought up the public-private partnerships.
00:37:32
And a lot of these questions that are being asked, again, driven, I think, by a nationwide look at public-private partnerships.
00:37:39
But the Transportation Planning Board, which is the regional planning body for the metropolitan DC area, approved a long-range,
00:37:51
We have a 20-year plan that has several very, very critical PPTA projects in there, and that includes Dulles Rail, that includes the Beltway hot lanes, and that includes the I-95 hot lanes.
00:38:05
Collectively, that's about $7 billion worth of construction.
00:38:12
And so we have negotiated, worked very hard, and I think one of the things that people
00:38:20
Don't fully appreciate is the degree of checks and balances in our system.
00:38:25
It's one thing for us to put money in a six-year program, but we have to go out to the individual MPOs, to the Fredericksburg last year.
00:38:33
There were some hard questions on the I-95 project this year.
00:38:36
There were hard questions on the 95 and the Beltway and the Dulles projects.
00:38:41
They've been resolved and answered.
00:38:42
and so that was a very, very significant step forward and if you have a chance to look at the Washington Post article today, I think it's a very good factual recitation of the issues.
00:38:56
The last issue that I did want to raise, the Richmond Times Dispatch this morning has an excellent photograph and if there is no objection, I believe that a caption contest
00:39:10
Among the CTB members would be very appropriate, because it is legitimate to ask, what are they thinking about?
00:39:20
So we will circulate via email, and of course, because it goes out to the CTB, this is public documentation.
00:39:29
It will be available to the public, a PDF file of this excellent photograph.
00:39:35
and we will solicit entries for captions.
00:39:38
They can be collected or selected one by one.
SPEAKER_13
00:39:42
We'll look forward to that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:53
Any other new business to come before the board?
00:40:10
Is there a motion to adjourn?
00:40:13
All in favor?
00:40:16
Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_13
00:40:20
Good afternoon.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:23
My apologies for our chartiness.
00:40:25
There's a lot of business going on, and I would like to call to order the May 16th work session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:40:34
When we conclude the work session, we will be taking a break, if there is time, until 5.30.
00:40:41
And at 5.30, we will begin the public comment session for the Six-Year Improvement Program.
00:40:47
Probably a good idea for those who have questions or concerns on the six-year program.
00:40:53
Let's get into some detail in the questions on that because those questions likely will come up in public comment.
00:41:00
Some of you may need to talk, particularly Mr. McCarthy, to folks in your district on specific questions.
00:41:07
So if there's no other issues at hand, I'd like to call up the agenda.
00:41:13
And the first item is the agency director report for rail and public transportation.
00:41:19
Welcome, Mr. Tucker.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:30
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:41:31
Thank you.
00:41:32
And we'll go to CTB.
00:41:35
This is the quick agenda of items that I wanted to cover in my report.
00:41:41
I want to update you again on our strategic assessment.
00:41:44
I want to talk to you a little bit about our work on our asset management program and update you on the intermodal facility site search and discuss in some details passenger rail in Virginia.
00:41:56
If you recall, this was the item that we identified as requiring additional discussion based upon our discussion about the development of a business plan.
00:42:07
Our strategic assessment update is that we have confirmed our organizational structure.
00:42:13
I just want to provide some feedback in the sense that at our last meeting we were not able to discuss some aspects of our organizational changes which culminated in the personnel decision that was executed on Friday where we eliminated eight positions.
00:42:31
We are moving forward in terms of developing our business plan.
00:42:36
We're still on track to develop the business plan over the next few months.
00:42:40
We're in the process now of really going through and working to document all of our policies and procedures and identify a clear go-forward strategy.
00:42:48
One of the items that we are close to completing and having out on the street is the development of the PMC.
00:42:58
We have a final draft of that document.
00:43:00
I think it's already queued up to go out.
00:43:05
A full implementation is still on target for August 2007.
00:43:17
Again, one of my goals is to be able to update you monthly.
00:43:20
Some of the improvements will take a significant amount of time to occur and they will be implemented gradually, but we do want to keep you up to date.
00:43:28
On the next slide really reflects the commitment and the direction of the CTB from our previous meeting that we will provide monthly update on our progress.
00:43:39
You have a memo that is attached in your agenda that outlines the progress that we've made in terms of the items that you specified for us to provide additional funding towards.
00:43:52
And if there are any questions on that, I would be happy to fill them.
00:43:58
Questions, Ms. Tucker?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:03
Matt, you look like you're applying this to me almost immediately in a couple of instances, but that the majority has actually played out over the next 18 months, is that right?
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:14
Yeah, some of the items in terms of actually just getting the support on board,
00:44:18
We'll take time for some of these documents, and our documents, like our strategic plans that we're required to develop by 2009, are pretty extensive documents that are not updates for this agency.
00:44:30
It will be the actual first time that we've done some of these activities.
00:44:34
But a lot of these initiatives, for example, like the performance reviews, are things that will be coming online fairly soon, within the next couple of months, and you'll see some results in the fall of this year.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:47
And to refresh my memory in terms of the timing, these set you up to actually be able to program substantial amounts of additional funds in the years ahead?
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:58
Yes, sir.
00:44:59
What the funding allowed us to do was actually go out and put these requestable proposals in the interim to contract.
00:45:06
Is that essentially what you're asking?
00:45:07
So that's essentially what we've done.
00:45:10
When you see the fact that we've actually issued a RFP, that means that from a budgeting perspective, we've had to identify and commit a source of funding to cover those costs associated with those initiatives.
00:45:21
And again, some of these we won't know until we actually get confirmed prices back and look exactly what the proposals have given us.
00:45:28
The asset management is a good example in a sense.
00:45:31
That you have two elements of it.
00:45:33
One is actually review and development of policies and then you get into your second phase of it, these action systems.
00:45:39
So a lot of these processes are going to be incremental steps that we're going to need to take.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:45
Mr. Chairman, just a question on the Dashboard.
00:45:50
You may have explained it last month, but I'm familiar with the Dashboard as tracking construction projects on time and on budget and quality.
00:45:59
I know the scope is now under development, but what kind
00:46:03
What sort of thing are we going to track?
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:06
We're going to track our agency goals.
00:46:08
And part of what we're doing is wanting to change some of the discussion on how we've talked about our programs in the past.
00:46:16
And it goes back to a comment that the Secretary sent out in terms of the changes that we're making.
00:46:20
But if you look at the agency 15 years ago, we were primarily an agency that was solely focused in on administering formula grants.
00:46:28
Now we're involved in some pretty significant efforts.
00:46:31
And what we want to be able to do is report out basic results.
00:46:34
For example, like statewide transit ridership.
00:46:37
Today we can't do that.
00:46:39
We have to call up on a transit-by-transit system basis.
00:46:42
And what we want to do is report out the performance.
00:46:46
So that you will know how the dollars that have been invested come back in terms of program results.
00:46:51
Trucks taken off the road or truck diversion rates, which is a better word to use, we want to be able to track those things from our programs.
00:46:59
It's really to illustrate the public benefits associated with our programs.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:08
Mr. Chairman,
00:47:11
On the reorganizational effort, you've accomplished much of what you intended to do thus far, as far as that.
00:47:22
If you recall last presentation, we had two charts.
00:47:24
We had an organizational chart as you existed at that time, and then we had an organizational chart of where we hoped to go to again.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:33
I think what you saw was a functional organizational chart.
00:47:38
It was not a detailed day-to-day working chart and reporting relationship.
00:47:42
But yes, we have confirmed a basic structure.
00:47:46
We've got work to do.
00:47:47
There are some positions that are critical to the agency that we're going to need to fill.
00:47:51
And I will tell you, just like anything in life,
00:47:54
Things have to be or are going to be dynamic.
00:47:56
You may take a look at something and decide to do something different depending on the kind of resources that you attract.
00:48:01
But to the degree that we've made these steps, we've made a determination of where we want to go, we have a path.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:09
Mr. Chairman, I think you know where we're going.
00:48:11
And it's the important question for me that I really need to ask at this point.
00:48:15
And that is, as we make that transition, my concern is, and I guess I'm seeking reassurance, that we haven't
00:48:24
Degraded the rural representation in that new organization that we're looking ahead to implement and that we have the same position at the table representing rural with our interests and our problems and our issues that we would have had before we
00:48:41
went through this reorganizational effort.
00:48:44
And you're not talking that, and there is some, but I just wanted the public reassurance as well on how that structure is going forward and how we will address those issues.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:55
Yes, sir.
00:48:56
And in fact, I knew you were going to ask me that question today.
00:48:58
And I'll tell you, I just, before I came up the hill, I spoke to a rural grantee who had expressed some concerns, and Mike Guy, out of the Bristol region.
00:49:07
And we talked through the issue because I understand when people looked at the function chart and saw rural and then didn't see rural, and we talked through the actual underpinnings of what we were trying to accomplish.
00:49:18
I have to keep reminding people the fact that when you think about DRPT, don't think about us in a context that you would think about VDOT as an example.
00:49:26
VDOT is a large agency.
00:49:28
We're a very small agency, and when someone says an entire function is eliminated, it will lead you to think, if you're thinking about it in the VDOT context, there's hundreds of people, but for us, it could come across as actually being one position.
00:49:42
And the perspective that we have discussed with that particular World Grantee that he was very accepting of is that we're actually beefing up.
00:49:49
The technical assistance that we provide to our rural grantees, it's no step backwards.
00:49:54
It's actually a step forward.
00:49:56
All of our documentation that we provided has been to support and strengthen our rural program.
00:50:01
So, in fact, in a matter of the actions that we're taking will strengthen the provision of rural services, rural technical assistance.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:10
I guess one follow-up.
00:50:12
And with that technical assistance, will we see a change from actually having department representation to having only representation from outsourced groups?
00:50:24
And the reason I ask that question is because I find it hard and more difficult to see that
00:50:28
An outsource group in charge of a particular service might not have the same position at the table that we would have if we had a department representative.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:38
What you will see and what every grantee will see are a combination.
00:50:40
And again, I'll go back to the conversation I had with my guy.
00:50:43
They're having a facility project that's coming online.
00:50:47
And they're in the process of getting bids for that facility project.
00:50:49
To some degree for that specialized project that they may do once in a, what I call once in a lifetime project, you're going to want to make sure that we provide specialized assistance to help them get that project delivered on time and on budget.
00:51:04
There are going to be many other aspects like DRPT specific programs that we are required to administer like 5311-5310 in our day-to-day business.
00:51:12
You may interface with a consultant, and the vast majority of the instances you will interface with a direct DRPT employee.
00:51:19
The other context that I will put it in is that at the end of the day, the grantees are focused in on getting support and good support.
00:51:26
And we should judge it by the fact if they're getting better support than they were getting in the past.
00:51:30
And that's the way I try to package this, is at the end of the day, the integrated approach will give us better support than we've had in the past.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:41
Okay.
00:51:41
Any other questions or comments?
00:51:44
Next item.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:45
This is just an update on the asset management program.
00:51:49
I'll tell you why I keep beating the drums about asset management because it's going to be a fundamental foundation of how we move forward in terms of being able to provide you as CTB members and all of our stakeholders better information about our programs.
00:52:04
That program is well under development.
00:52:07
I met with the consultant myself a few moments earlier this morning, and what we've done is issue a survey to all of our grantees on the transit and human service side to really start getting this critical information about their capital needs and their capital program.
00:52:21
As you look at it today and think about our six-year float program, again, we've been sort of an agency that has taken in information and spat that information out, didn't critically analyze it, didn't have the capability of being able to run different scenarios.
00:52:37
What we want to do, beginning in June, is start to talk a little bit about, as additional funds are coming in, what are the things that we should be thinking about?
00:52:45
It's similar to the discussion that we had with VDOT, that maintenance of our existing services is typically always our first priority.
00:52:53
How do we ensure that, as we move forward with our funding programs, that we're making maintenance of our existing infrastructure as a top priority?
00:53:00
And what are those other goals, through accountability and performance, do we want to accomplish?
00:53:05
So we're going to be coming back to you over the next few months and sort of introducing the discussion.
00:53:10
We want to set the framework up as we come before a dialogue and not with a complete plan and say it's voted up or down.
00:53:16
We really want to engage in discussion with the CTB members as well as all of our grantees about how we structure and how we develop a policy from that.
00:53:25
Very quickly on the Roanoke Region Intermodal Facility Site Search.
00:53:31
Again, all 10 sites are still under consideration, which is important.
00:53:35
But we received a very, very interesting proposal from the City of Cleveland to take a look in more detail about the Colorado site.
00:53:43
Just yesterday, I signed a letter authorizing Norfolk Southern to begin detailed engineering for that site.
00:53:51
And we will be working to confirm a schedule for them completion of that review.
00:53:55
But until such time that we are able to complete that review, confirm costs, determine if it's actually feasible, we will still be looking at the other nine sites.
00:54:06
But it's important that we're very interested by that proposal and we're going to take a good hard look at it.
00:54:13
The next item is really a discussion of, I'll go back, the outstanding issues from our Strategic Assessment of Passenger Rail in Virginia.
00:54:21
This is one of the items that we talked about that we wanted to bring better clarity to our program.
00:54:27
One of the comments and feedback that I've gotten over the course of time that I've been here is that folks have not seen the types of progress in our passenger rail programs that they would have liked to have seen.
00:54:39
You know, one of the things that, you know, I would want to just say up front that Virginia is way ahead of the curve.
00:54:45
If you look at our rail enhancement fund program, it's very innovative.
00:54:49
And one of the things that came about as a result of our consulting review was the fact that we have a very cutting edge program in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
00:54:58
To date, it's been primarily, a lot of the focus has been on the freight side and folks have been left wanting to see some major forward pushes on passenger rail.
00:55:07
But I do want you to feel comfortable in the sense that Virginia is on the cutting edge in terms of identifying reliable funding for improved passenger and freight rail.
00:55:18
Again, this slide discusses a little bit of our actions and approach.
00:55:23
The fact that we need to develop a strategic planning process across all of our programs.
00:55:29
And if you look at the initiatives that have been looked at over time, what I've talked about at our last meeting is the fact that most of the work that we've done has been reactive.
00:55:38
Someone has asked us to do a study.
00:55:40
They've narrowly defined how they wanted us to do the study.
00:55:42
We've done the study.
00:55:43
The study's gone on the shelf.
00:55:45
We've gotten asked to do another study.
00:55:46
It was narrowly defined and we did another study.
00:55:48
We just didn't have a game plan.
00:55:50
But we do know we have some major strategies along some key corridors that rail is going to really help us from the perspective of passenger and freight.
00:55:59
And we just need to be ready and able to move forward with programs and implementation in such a way that rail does not get left behind.
00:56:07
It needs to be considered early in the process and evaluated thoroughly as a solution to some of our transportation needs.
00:56:15
So, achieving a strategic rail vision.
00:56:18
What we said is that as we go through developing a strategic vision, we need to know where will those investments be made, when will those investments be made, and by whom.
00:56:28
What will the outcomes and benefits be?
00:56:30
Again, a prerequisite of all of our program, our rail program, the rail enhancement fund, is the establishment and determination of public benefit.
00:56:37
And I think that's an important thing for us to keep in mind as we look at passenger rail.
00:56:42
And how will these investments be implemented, used, and monitored over time?
00:56:46
And one of the comments that I would like to make is as we go through this presentation, we're going to talk about investment strategies, and I'll talk a little bit more about why that's so important.
00:56:59
DRPT's approach to rail investments is to develop a passenger rail plan and policy documents.
00:57:06
It was pretty surprising for me that we just don't have that document in existence today and develop a strategic rail investment plan.
00:57:13
The strategic rail investment plan is really a document that really helps you in terms of determining how and when and where you make those investments and what your expectations should be in terms of performance.
00:57:26
The passenger rail plan and policy document, again, is a policy document in development.
00:57:31
You know, again, it's asking the basic question, what is the top project in the Commonwealth?
00:57:37
We need to be able to answer that question based upon some objective criteria.
00:57:41
We need to be the lead for the Commonwealth in establishing a framework for the development and advancement.
00:57:45
And we need to be able to have baseline identification and prioritization of passenger rail corners and establish the benchmark standard for evaluation and methodology.
00:57:55
Again, if you look at those bullets and as we've come at least during my short time and had some presentations on these issues, a lot of the questions and a lot of the heartache about what was done at the battle of the study really evolved around those issues.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:09
Mr. Chairman.
00:58:10
Can I ask a question?
00:58:12
Matt, you know I'm probably going to ask you this almost every month, I suppose.
00:58:17
The bottom line of the question is how are we doing on the I-95 corridor for passenger rail?
00:58:22
And I guess what concerns me, and it's a generic concern, because everything you're saying here is very good management.
00:58:33
It needs to be done.
00:58:34
It's long overdue.
00:58:36
On the other hand,
00:58:37
We've managed to accomplish an enormous bit of work in the last few years on Dulles Rail.
00:58:45
And I don't think we went through quite all these steps to get there.
00:58:48
I think the governor or someone, the secretary or the board said Dulles has got to go out to the airport and so on and so forth.
00:58:57
And I guess what I'm trying to say is we need to improve passenger rail in the 95 corridor
00:59:04
How hard an objective can that be to define and sort of organize around and get it done?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:12
If I may interject, Mr. McCarthy.
00:59:18
It's an apt metaphor because as Governor Holton came when he came to talk to us, rail in the Dulles Corridor was planned over 40 years ago.
00:59:29
We've now had 15 years of very expensive and engaged planning in that corridor.
00:59:36
We're on the verge of some important approvals.
00:59:40
It was not an easy process.
00:59:42
And in fact, one of the things that I like to explain to those of us who don't understand, why does it take so long?
00:59:51
The levels of checks and balances and approvals, many of you are involved in one aspect or another, and the Dulles Rail Project is a great example of that, has to be approved by seven public entities, is constantly revisited, is very expensive,
01:00:12
is very political and there we own the right-of-way.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:25
And I would also just say that it's not mutually exclusive that we can't do both at the same time.
01:00:31
We can't continue.
01:00:33
If you look at the funds that were appropriated by the governor,
01:00:36
Yeah, 495.
01:00:38
There's additional investments there.
01:00:40
But again, I mean, one of the points that the Secretary has made to me when I came on board and continues to make as I'm on board as a reminder is that we've been allocated significant funds for 95 improvements, but over time and historically, we have not implemented them very quickly.
01:00:55
So what we need to do on both sides of the equation is we need to have a strategic vision.
01:01:01
But I would agree with you.
01:01:03
I don't have the luxury of sitting on my hands and waiting for a few years of doing this before doing that.
01:01:08
We've already made some commitments on 9581 and other important rail corridors that we've got to live up to.
01:01:14
And we need to move forward and make some advancement on this issue.
01:01:18
Thank you.
01:01:18
The Strategic Real Investment Plan is, again, is the guide for the Commonwealth, and again, we want to have a planning horizon that covers the first five and 20 years out, and we're going to build on a lot of the initiatives and studies that we've done in the past and, again, do some prioritization.
01:01:37
This is a summary of the planning schedule that we're looking to move forward with.
01:01:42
And again, I should emphasize that in no way will we be delaying the advancement of the initiatives.
01:01:49
But I think at the end of the day, we're required by 2009 to have a statewide plan that covers this moment.
01:01:58
Again, I'll talk a little bit about the I-95 corridor strategic approach.
01:02:02
Again, one of our primary goals is to complete the VTA 2000 projects.
01:02:07
And to me, the notion of how long some of these projects have spanned, the scope creep, the uncertainty, the issues that we had in terms of cost means we really need to fundamentally change the way we've done business.
01:02:22
in terms of getting these projects delivered.
01:02:24
And that part is one of the first efforts that we're undertaking right now is to begin a dialogue to look at the MOU agreement and really have some tough discussions about how we improve project delivery.
01:02:36
That's going to be key if we talk about 95.
01:02:39
Nothing is getting cheaper, is it, Mr. Secretary?
01:02:42
We need to find a way to get those projects improvements in place faster, and we need to be able to capture the benefits that were specified in that MOU agreement.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:51
Well, if I might just, if you'll permit me one more editorial comment, and again it goes back to the length of time, I was privileged to cut the ribbon for the Quantico Creek Bridge, which is the major bottleneck in the I-95 Quartering for VRE.
01:03:06
When did that project start?
01:03:07
It began with an earmark by our wonderful Senator John Warner in 1993.
01:03:14
And it took us 14 years to bring that project online.
01:03:19
That was about a $3 million project, the original estimate.
01:03:23
It was $27 million 14 years later.
01:03:27
We have got to find a way.
01:03:29
I mean, we're cutting new ground in terms of these public-private partnerships for these rail projects.
01:03:37
But Mr. Tucker is absolutely correct.
01:03:40
Thank God somebody has a vision 14 years ago to identify a bottleneck and put some funding on it.
01:03:47
But it has been very, very difficult to develop a project in a timely fashion that's not unique to that court.
01:03:56
I mean, that's the nature of these public-private partnerships.
01:03:59
They're very, very hard.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:02
Again, one of the things that we've talked about is the fact as we look at the 95 corridor, we really need to conduct some alternatives analysis.
01:04:10
We need to think out of the box.
01:04:12
I understand we have a sense of urgency in terms of moving.
01:04:15
Everyone expects us to move this long.
01:04:17
But we need to practice some due diligence in terms of making sure that we're making some solid good decisions for us and investing our dollars wisely.
01:04:25
One of the things that I know from what I've seen is some of the incremental approaches that we have taken have led us to make mistakes that we otherwise would not have made if we had taken a longer term look at some of these things and really understand what we're going.
01:04:42
Incrementalism happens because funding comes in incrementally, but it doesn't mean from a strategic point of view that we can't have an ultimate end game.
01:04:50
And we also know from a bottom-down perspective in terms of this I-95 corridor that the improvements to really bring it up to what people expect for passenger and freight rail are going to be very, very expensive.
01:05:02
And it won't be able to be done on the Commonwealth's nickel alone.
01:05:05
We're going to have to identify willing and able, not partnered, but partners if we're going to bring to fruition what everyone has expected out of this corridor.
01:05:17
Along the I-81 corridor, that's been something that has been widely discussed.
01:05:21
I'll just speak to the fact that we are at a point with the study today that we're starting to look at the diversion.
01:05:29
We've gotten some of the information about diversion.
01:05:32
We've asked for the consultant to go back and we'll get metrics thing out.
01:05:36
If you remember the legislation that came from the General Assembly required a 60 percent
01:05:40
We want to be able to look at it and step up in increments to see how we can make various levels of improvements over time and at the same time making sure that we're doing the due diligence and ensuring that we're getting the maximum benefits for the real investments that we're making.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:57
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
01:06:01
Matt, the resolution on I-81 that this board passed a few months back directed that after the completion of the Tier 1 environmental impact statement that the Tier 2 analysis
01:06:18
would take into account the results of this study.
01:06:23
And I'm very concerned about this because my own view is that the analysis in the Tier 1 EIS, which is now being finalized, is badly flawed and will be till the end because this won't be taken into account.
01:06:41
So my question to you is how will the results of this study
01:06:47
get work in what will be the coordination to make sure as we dictate it in our resolution the results of this study will get done on time and will get incorporated into the analysis going forward for the I-81 Carter improvements.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:07:04
I think where we are with that process is first we're getting the market analysis.
01:07:09
And one of the important points that I want to make is that this was something primarily initiated by CSX.
01:07:15
So from the perspective that are we going to get the maximum bang in terms of diversion, here's a private sector entity that directly benefits from getting as much on their rails as possible.
01:07:27
So the study essentially that is occurring to help us determine what is the market diversion rate going to be is driven primarily by the business work that they were already underway.
01:07:37
If the CTB resolution requires that before we make those final decisions that we take into consideration the diversion rates that can be achieved, exactly as what you said,
01:07:49
So the process that we're going to follow is going to be factually that we're going to get the diversion performance metrics and then we're going to set that aside before any final improvements are identified for the Tier II study.
01:08:03
So we are in fact following through that matrix.
01:08:05
In fact, I met with Mary Lynn, Dr. Tischer,
01:08:08
A few weeks ago and we were talking about really what is a process that we're going to go through to really do that evaluation in terms of you get this diversion rate and what does it mean for improvements along 81 from a highway perspective.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:21
And will you be reporting to us as you go through that process so that we'll see the
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:27
I would assume that it would be a very open and transparent process.
01:08:31
In fact, we just had a discussion a few moments ago before the meeting began that it's probably now time that we start communicating out to the public the status of that rail study so that folks can understand exactly where we are in time.
01:08:43
But yes, it will be very open and transparent.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:45
And I don't think anybody's looking for a diversion analysis that unduly favors rail.
01:08:53
I think what we're looking for is a really honest,
01:08:57
Yes, sir, I understand that.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:05
And you have to look at it from the perspective that you get various levels of diversion for Virginia-only improvements versus multi-state improvements.
01:09:16
So, I understand.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:20
Mr. White, Matt, can you flip back to 16 related to Mr. Jollon?
01:09:25
This timeline, it would be helpful to me if you could flesh it out a little bit and tell us how this thing is going to work.
01:09:37
Is the CTB going to be involved, the Rail Advisory Board?
01:09:42
What does public outreach mean?
01:09:44
And Mr. McCarthy asked about the I-95 corridor.
01:09:48
If you could use perhaps TDX as an example of how that previous work would come through this schedule and be examined and by whom?
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:00
Okay.
01:10:03
I guess what I would do is probably recommend that I come back next month and break it out in detail, but the entire intent for us as we went through this process to develop this document is as we get to the appropriate points to do check-ins.
01:10:15
And one of the things that we've talked about is as I talk about the whole flow chart, we're going to have a lot of different pieces of information that feeds into the development of a plan.
01:10:24
and all of those items are one of the items that the CTB is going to look at.
01:10:28
One of them I'll talk about is that whole investment strategy and it really isn't a strategy that looks across all of our programs and identifies what are the performance metrics based on best practices for a transit bus.
01:10:40
At what level should you put a transit bus along a corridor and expect to achieve X level ridership, farebox recovery for inner city rail?
01:10:48
What are those characteristics?
01:10:50
What are those standards?
01:10:51
What needs to be in place before you make those decisions?
01:10:53
So yes, our intention is to come back every step of the way and have the CTB be free and give us direct feedback on adoption of these policies.
01:11:04
Ultimately, at the end of the day, the CTB will have to adopt policies relative to the expansion of public transportation and passenger rail.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:14
So at the next meeting, you were supposed to give us a more comprehensive...
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:18
I'll give you a more comprehensive briefing in terms of the actual steps that we're going to take.
01:11:24
But it is going to be a process over time that's going to have different steps that the CTB is going to have to take a look at and weigh in heavily as we lead toward developing a final program that has prioritized projects.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:42
I think that's it.
01:11:43
Outstanding.
01:11:44
Thank you, Mr. Tucker.
01:11:47
The next item, and this is really a follow-on from a previous meeting on the business plans of both DRPT and VDOT.
01:11:57
This is real important work, and I appreciate everybody.
01:12:01
It's not the most glamorous work, but it's how we deliver our products.
01:12:05
And so I appreciate the very hard work of DRPT and the commissioner.
01:12:11
And in fact, at our last meeting, the commissioner really did not have enough time to give a thorough presentation of his business plan.
01:12:21
The commissioner is required by statute to annually present a business plan which is based on the six-year program.
01:12:29
So while he is messing with technology, I'm going to keep filling air time on his behalf and talking about the importance of what he is about to talk about.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:40
I have to start talking quickly before you help too much, Mr. Secretary.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:44
Thank you, Commissioner.
SPEAKER_13
01:12:45
Welcome.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:47
Good afternoon, everybody, and thank you.
01:12:49
As the Secretary indicated, what I'd like to do this afternoon is to revisit and update a little bit what we've learned since our briefing with you last month around the emerging business plan.
01:13:03
that we'll bring forward for fiscal year 2008.
01:13:08
A couple of headlines up front.
01:13:10
Very frankly, as I've joined VDOT and Virginia, one of the things that impressed me early on was what Greg and the staff had done in pioneering in a business plan effort.
01:13:27
and turning it into real life.
01:13:29
In a lot of agencies you'll look at business plan activities and they become kind of add-ons.
01:13:35
They do not become real tools for managing your business and adjusting your direction.
01:13:43
I think we've demonstrated over the last few months that the Virginia model is a model that focuses on tangible changes on real things that happen.
01:13:55
And I can tell you as I go around and visit
01:13:57
When people ask questions about how does the business plan affect me as an individual either within the organization or those organizations we work with, it is
01:14:14
It's really interesting to be able to show them a direction and implementation and bring it down to real life in terms of how we're continuing that journey of streamlining, modernizing,
01:14:32
and really bringing the Commonwealth an effective transportation system and organization.
01:14:39
My piece and what I want to do for you this afternoon is again just quickly remind you of the emerging definition that we're using around a business plan as we have learned its power.
01:14:55
Again, this is that document and process that we put discipline around
01:15:00
to translate into action statewide initiatives to change our system, transportation system, the business that we run, and to deal with and help the workforce that populates VDOT as we do our business.
01:15:21
I won't spend a lot of time on this slide, but this is kind of the theme that we've had over the last few months that is trying to capture in one place the purpose of a business plan.
01:15:35
Ensuring that we have the right focus, that our business is the right size, and that we're using the right approaches to doing our business.
01:15:47
I used this slide last month as an intro to put the business plan in context.
01:15:56
One of the themes that I've had over the last few weeks now is working with the staff and with the department is using the tools that are around us to shape our business plan.
01:16:11
You've got to connect the dots, and that's what this is about.
01:16:15
So it starts with the very activities that Director Tucker was talking about, that we've had a rich history in, and that this board has shaped for transportation in this Commonwealth.
01:16:29
That is a strategic planning process.
01:16:32
VTrans 2025, key example.
01:16:36
That establishes our goals.
01:16:38
And it does it very articulately.
01:16:42
The Strategic Highway Safety Plan that the Commonwealth has emerged, which is a joint agency venture, again, is a tool or is the piece that we need to turn into action items to actually accomplish reduction in deaths in this Commonwealth.
01:17:02
You look at that center bubble.
01:17:05
Governor's goals as they've been established around accountability, integrating transportation and land use, and obviously in the finance and funding initiatives.
01:17:17
We turn those into action items within a business plan context.
01:17:22
And we try to recognize in a very disciplined way
01:17:27
are recognition of Congressional, USDOT, Federal Highway Administration, General Assembly, and CTB direction to the transportation professionals that do the day-to-day business of transportation.
01:17:44
It's important that we consciously sit down, look at those items, and say, what does that mean for where we're headed in continuing this journey of modernizing VDOT?
01:17:59
That turns into, now I've got to be careful what I do here.
01:18:02
I've got this really sporty set of overheads now that kind of motivate and do stuff.
01:18:08
Those things lead to what I talk about as a business plan.
01:18:13
But the business plan is not the sole and exclusive tool of the department.
01:18:19
We also look to our directorates, divisions and districts to do that, as a part of that process, look at their individual missions.
01:18:31
and talk about what their action plans need to be in conducting those parts of our business that do not rise to the business plan level.
01:18:41
So we'll continue to use this model.
01:18:45
It seems to be getting legs.
01:18:47
And that center set of boxes, what that really represents,
01:18:51
is that disciplined step you need to take between long-range thinking, strategic direction, and carefully putting into place those changes that you need to make in your business.
01:19:05
In VDOT, what we have done is said, we'll take that 12 months at a slice.
01:19:11
And so for the next 12 months, we'll look at a variety of what looks to be 13 new initiatives within our focus areas and make a conscious business decision about their implementation.
01:19:28
Thoughtfully done, which leads to that step of integrating them into then, those that are successful, integrating them into our ongoing business practices.
01:19:40
So what we study in 08, we would expect to implement in 09.
01:19:46
That is very consciously thought out.
01:19:48
If you look backwards into what the staff developed in 07, very conscious thought process around certain business initiatives which are in 08 being implemented.
01:20:02
That's kind of how the cycle works.
01:20:05
Hopefully very quickly.
01:20:06
A 12-month turnaround in a major corporation like VDOT is really moving very rapidly when you put it in that context.
01:20:18
DOTs across the country take several years to make those kinds of changes.
01:20:23
That's what's kind of exciting about the power of our business.
01:20:28
I have this specific and outstanding programming criteria that we use and I won't go into it in depth for you because we talked a little bit about it last month.
01:20:40
But I did want to show you the piece that we're adding and remind you of that as I call up our three focus area leaders to talk a little bit about it.
01:20:49
Our focus areas in the business plan really are standing, I think, the test of time.
01:20:54
We seem to be getting good reactions.
01:20:57
A series of initiatives focused around changes in the transportation system or reshaping the transportation system.
01:21:05
A series of initiatives around our business activities.
01:21:10
How do we do the business?
01:21:12
And a third set that recognizes our workforce.
01:21:16
Key piece because of the changing dynamic in VDOT as we integrate private sector practices, private sector businesses into the business that we have traditionally done solely in-house.
01:21:33
So that opens up a whole set of skill sets, directions that we need to talk about.
01:21:39
And lastly, what we briefed you on last month and will roll out about mid-year, dashboard 3.0.
01:21:48
How do you manage an organization?
01:21:50
You manage it through performance.
01:21:51
You manage it through performance management.
01:21:54
And our dashboard is our way of now taking us beyond on time and on budget without losing our focus on that initiative.
01:22:05
What I'd like to do now is, by the way, in your notebooks, you'll find some sheets like this.
01:22:13
You did a great exercise for us in a flash reaction last month.
01:22:18
We really appreciate that.
01:22:20
Giving us your flash assessment of impact of the initiatives that are either ongoing into 08 or that we'd like to add in 08.
01:22:31
We've done two things since our last meeting.
01:22:35
I had the opportunity to test this same tool on a set of our private sector partners.
01:22:42
You'll find that listed under the sheets that are titled
01:22:47
CEO Forum Assessment, 18 respondents.
01:22:51
We did that in an afternoon.
01:22:54
It's kind of interesting to track your view against that private sector view.
01:23:00
And then we did one other thing the last couple of weeks at the Garver leadership conference.
01:23:06
And you'll find the results of 98 respondents from within the department.
01:23:12
So that's our mechanism to get consensus and get
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:17
Actually, I wanted to ask you about that, and I'm glad you raised it to track that.
01:23:29
Is there much difference between the three sets of responses at this point?
01:23:35
Do you see anything that we should know about?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:38
It's really fascinating for me and I'll give you Dave's reaction to what I see.
01:23:46
On the system side, I see really strong consensus in all three groups about the directions that we're talking about when we talk about reshaping the system.
01:23:55
On the business side, I see some really good consensus.
01:24:01
with the exception of Dave's personal favorite, which is telework.
01:24:09
It is amazing to me how the consensus is they don't like what Dave's proposing about telework.
01:24:18
So to that degree, it illustrates a couple of points.
01:24:26
Leadership sometimes can be a lonely place.
01:24:29
Because those are tools that we need to be successful in a telework environment.
01:24:36
So I've tried to interpret that in my own view as saying, is it a readiness question?
01:24:41
Is it a cultural question that gets it rated differently than I would hope it would be?
01:24:48
On the whole, I'm pretty excited about the fact that we've got
01:24:52
If you look at the highs and the mediums, we've really got good consensus all the way around the table about these are the right things to be focusing on overall.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:03
Mr. Chairman, I just wanted to comment, the private sector went through exactly the same thing, that it was a novelty.
01:25:09
The fact is, whether we like it or not, everything that can be digitized will be digitized.
01:25:14
That means it's available over the Internet.
01:25:16
That means you can work from anywhere.
01:25:18
And to just ignore that that's happening is a mistake.
01:25:22
So, but it took a while for the private sector to get back to it.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:29
Mr. Chairman, Commissioner,
01:25:32
I have a question on the part of the presentation where you talk about the right focus.
01:25:39
And the third item on there, you say delivering projects on time, on budget, and with high quality, all of which are obviously important.
01:25:49
There's a fourth characteristic, though, which is that they have to be the right projects.
01:25:57
If they're not the right projects,
01:25:59
Whether they're on time, on budget, and high quality almost becomes irrelevant.
01:26:05
And so you sometimes hear the word, it's probably overused, right sizing, but the idea is, is
01:26:15
designing first conceptually and then for construction a project that meets the need and doesn't overdo the response to the need which is important in a resource constrained environment obviously.
01:26:33
But it's also important in terms of addressing community impacts of road construction, contact sensitivity, is challenging ourselves always to make sure that we have found the project which is the right size isn't too little but also isn't too much.
01:26:51
And so my question is where in the business plan that you're proposing, where
01:26:59
Do you plug in that sort of self-questioning process where we make sure that we are right-sizing the projects that we're coming out with?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:14
Three different points is where we touch on that indirectly, which will have the result, we hope, of exactly what you're talking about.
01:27:25
First, under the system size, although it's not specifically called for, what you'll see in improving land use and transportation with our partners.
01:27:35
is a conversation that talks about long-range planning from a couple of perspectives.
01:27:42
One, the vision side of the equation and two, the performance side of the equation.
01:27:49
So you will start to see an influence on how we think about projects, corridors,
01:27:56
There's an awful lot of things now that you'll see embedded and proposed within the Six-Year Plan that start to open the door for that dialogue around what should corridors look like and what are the goals for the corridors.
01:28:13
That has a direct influence on what is the right project for a given corridor.
01:28:20
Second place you're going to see this is I've got an initiative that talks about unifying the six-year planning processes with the SCIP.
01:28:32
That will open a whole variety of discussions, I think, not only around process and having documents that are readable and integrated so we do it once, don't do it three different times, and talks about program focus and scope of projects and that's a process that all of you are engaged in as we speak.
01:28:56
The third place I find that impacted is in the workforce piece where we talk about context-sensitive solutions training.
01:29:07
We have an initiative that is underway and starting to take on some greater legs that talks about what are context-sensitive solutions.
01:29:19
My intent in that is to have a discussion that says redefine
01:29:25
What is a successful project?
01:29:29
By defining what is public involvement, how do we do that?
01:29:37
Koelemay, environmental compatibility, engineering consensus, good quality engineering, and on time and on budget.
01:29:45
Developing in four parallel tracks that activity in any given quarter.
01:29:50
That's the real challenge that faces that part of our business today.
01:29:55
So I think you'll see the cumulative effect
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:57
Could that be worked into the dashboard so that when the folks who were working on specific projects are evaluating themselves or being evaluated that
01:30:15
That's one of the gauges on the dashboard, if you will, to see how they're doing in that regard.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:22
That's an interesting point, that's an interesting comment.
01:30:26
I sat in for a little while at the Accountability Commission this morning, listening to some presentations that were being done about how do you measure that very kind of issue.
01:30:36
There's some interesting things going on across the country that are being reported on that do in fact introduce performance measures around project success.
01:30:49
I don't know where the commission will ultimately come out on that, but there is a body of knowledge growing around that.
01:30:56
When we talk about a successful project, that will be one of the challenges I suspect we'll be looking at as the dashboard continues to evolve.
01:31:10
I don't think we're quite there yet, but it's the direction that we're headed, I think.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:31:18
I just have one other comment.
01:31:22
This is hard to change our thinking about actually what we're attempting to do, what our business is and so forth, because it's not going to be the same answers that we've had in the past.
01:31:34
I like that Matthew Tucker talked about it, defining and establishing the public benefit.
01:31:40
I like us to think of responding to travelers and commuters as customers in the system.
01:31:45
E. J. D.
01:32:03
Does it give me the value that I expect?
01:32:06
And I think you're in the right direction here in establishing value.
01:32:10
Ultimately, the project descriptions, sizes, costs, geography and all that need to be behind the interface with the customers.
01:32:22
And you deliver what the customers value, which will be those things, but they really care about the value.
01:32:27
So if we keep our minds there, you're going to end up with the right projects that are the right size.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:32
And very frankly, at the program level, as I've watched the program emerge or been a part of that process, I think the Secretary is very articulate about the impact of 3202 in terms of what it has done to exactly address those kinds of concerns and the investment goals that are being established.
01:32:56
So I think the parts are coming together.
01:32:59
People like to look at this as a simple
01:33:01
One-size-fits-all kind of a tool and it's never quite that direct and I really appreciate the feedback we're getting from the board.
SPEAKER_14
01:33:11
Our staff is listening.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:15
Now, what I'm going to do is give each of, we've assigned senior staff, and you can see them listed on the slide, around reshaping the system, reshaping the business, and reshaping the workforce as the, quote, focus area leaders.
01:33:33
Ultimately what you'll see coming out of this process is a series of about 13 or 15 initiatives
01:33:42
That will be guided by this focus area leaders as we move through the year.
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:47
That's my way of making sure that we keep that in front of the senior management of the department.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:54
I'm going to ask each of them to come up and briefly go through their focus areas, those initiatives, and give you a chance to ask some questions around them as we go forward.
01:34:05
So I'll call on Gary first.
SPEAKER_23
01:34:14
Thank you, Commissioner.
01:34:15
Good afternoon, members of the board.
01:34:17
Good to see you again.
01:34:19
I'll try to move through this fairly rapidly, but not quite as rapidly as last month to give you a little more time to ask some questions, and I'll do my very best to answer them.
01:34:33
There are four major areas
01:34:36
that we are going to be undertaking some actions on in terms of reshaping the transportation system and how we deliver it, how we focus on it.
01:34:50
One has to do with improving preservation and management of the system, the second one improving safety, a third one that deals with mobility, and a fourth that deals with land use and transportation.
01:35:07
We're very early in this process in terms of taking actions, but we have spent a lot of time carefully thinking about the items that we have included under each of these areas.
01:35:22
The first one is to establish a program for the repair and replacement and rehabilitation, primarily repair and rehabilitation, of bridges that are less than 60 feet in length.
01:35:35
If you look across the Commonwealth and you take a map and you color-code it and you look at those counties where we have lots of bridges that are in disrepair, then you will find that many of those bridges fall along the ridgeline just west of the Blue Ridge Mountains along the valley.
01:35:54
Now, you'll also find some of the other counties, for example, in the Richmond District where you have the same difficulty.
01:36:02
The taking care of secondary system bridges is not an exotic or an exciting thing to do.
01:36:12
Nevertheless, it's a very important thing to do.
01:36:15
It's an important thing to do.
01:36:19
There's a little bridge in a county in the Culpeper district now that recently has been closed on the secondary system.
01:36:30
And we had no choice but to close that bridge.
01:36:33
But that is causing our customers, as Mr. Koelemay pointed out, a lot of grief.
01:36:40
They are very, very unhappy.
01:36:44
We believe, based upon some work we've done already in terms of a pilot in the Stanton District and in Culpeper, that we can, with the means we have available to us today and with the processes that are available, if we'll just change a few things, we can take care of these bridges that are most in need of repair.
01:37:10
And we can do that fairly quickly.
01:37:13
We can do it in some instances with our own forces.
01:37:18
We can get traffic back on them.
01:37:20
We can increase the weight limits of those bridges, and that is important for both safety and for economics, economic vitality of the region.
01:37:32
Second point, whole workshops on rapid repair technology for delivering cost-effective maintenance with minimal traffic delay.
01:37:40
Again, that goes to the heart of serving customers.
01:37:44
We know based upon research that we've done that there are a number of technologies that are available to us that can provide very rapid repair techniques.
01:37:56
We can get in in an evening.
01:37:59
We can do some things to repair bridge checks, even on the interstate system.
01:38:04
We can have it back under traffic by 5 a.m.
01:38:09
Well, there's a lot of benefits of doing that from several perspectives.
01:38:14
You certainly reduce the impacts on the public because you can keep them moving.
01:38:19
But you also dramatically reduce the cost of the repairs because you can reduce traffic control costs, which are extensive.
01:38:30
Under traditional kinds of bridge deck repair, you might have a lane down for a month or
01:38:36
If we can get that down to a day or an evening or a couple of days, it makes good sense to do that.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:43
Who attends these workshops or these contractors?
SPEAKER_23
01:38:46
These workshops will be attended by both VDOT personnel and private sector contractors.
01:38:51
And I would point out that the CEOs, when they saw this as a proposal, private sector folks set up, many of them rated this very, very high.
01:39:01
deliver recommendations on the fee structure associated with heavy vehicles.
01:39:06
Those are legislatively mandated studies that relate to allowing vehicles to travel under permit with fairly heavy weights.
01:39:18
And we know that that can cause significant damage to the roadway.
01:39:22
We are working on some assessments from an engineering standpoint of what those impacts are.
01:39:28
And then we're going to be developing a proposed fee structure for the Commissioner and the CTB to review along with legislation which is called for as part of those studies.
01:39:42
The fourth bullet there is to take a look at the, to develop a plan for reassigning components of the highway system to the functional classification system.
01:39:53
That's not due until January 1, 2009.
01:39:55
However, we're already working on that.
01:39:59
It is a very important examination because when you step back from that, it's more than just classifying a road woman into a functional class.
01:40:12
It can have significant policy implications if you step back from that just a bit.
01:40:17
I see the Secretary smiling.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:20
If I might add, it's fortunate that that is a 2009 deliverable, but this body is involved in the approval of that process which may indeed set in motion a fairly significant reshaping, not just to the classification, but the funding that goes with it.
01:40:40
So this is a very important study that we want to have interim reports and updates on as we work towards the fall of 2008 for its conclusion.
01:40:51
That will be a major work product of the CTB.
SPEAKER_23
01:40:56
The biennial report that is referred to on this slide is a biennial report that deals with maintaining the system and the budget and the kind of levels of funding that are required there.
01:41:09
That falls under the responsibility of the Asset Management Division and I'm sure that information will be coming before this board.
01:41:18
Certainly, we're going to continue the implementation of the Total Asset Management Turnkey Maintenance Program, and we are working along those lines.
01:41:31
Improve safety and security.
01:41:34
Implement the 50 actions from the Virginia Strategic Highway Safety Plan.
01:41:42
Many of us, many of us,
01:41:44
have been affected by either a family member or a friend who has been either seriously injured or in some instances killed as a result of a highway crash.
01:41:59
Nothing is more important than safety.
01:42:02
Nothing.
01:42:04
If we were to line up all of the individuals who are killed as a result of highway crashes each year,
01:42:13
Those 900 people in one room at one time, or if they fell out of the sky as the result of crashes of airplanes, we'd sit up and take notice.
01:42:27
But when we kill people one at a time, we seem not to take so much notice.
01:42:35
The actions of the Strategic Highway Safety Improvement Program are critical, and it's part of our business plan.
01:42:44
Implement a program focused on signs and safety.
01:42:48
This has to do with legibility, visibility, retro-reflectivity of signs and pavement markings, both at night and during bad weather.
01:43:00
If we can get our roadways delineated better, if we can have better signing, then we stand a chance of reducing the risk, and let me underscore the word risk.
01:43:13
D. D. D. D. D. D. D.
01:43:34
I'm working on together with Virginia Tech.
01:43:39
Dr. Tom Dingus is a very good friend and colleague of mine who is the head of the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute.
01:43:48
By mid-summer, we hope to have in place a cooperative agreement.
01:43:52
That will create this Virginia Center for Transportation Safety that will be a combined effect of VTTI, the University of Virginia, and the Virginia Transportation Research Council.
01:44:05
We know that research and understanding drivers can help us reduce the risk of fatalities and serious injuries.
01:44:16
Conduct a review of all Virginia's laws regarding pedestrian safety and recommend changes to the code.
01:44:24
Pedestrian safety and bicycle safety may not, again, be the thing that frequently gets in the headlines.
01:44:33
But it is important.
01:44:34
It is very important, especially in urban areas.
01:44:38
And we are examining the existing pedestrian safety laws, the existing bicycle laws, to see if there are ways that we can take steps to reduce the risk of crashes and fatalities along those lines.
01:44:52
Improved mobility.
01:44:56
After all, after all is said and done, mobility is what the end result is that people are interested in.
01:45:06
They want to be mobile.
01:45:07
They want to get somewhere.
01:45:09
They have a purpose for going somewhere.
01:45:15
Congestion takes its toll on economic development.
01:45:23
It dramatically increases the cost of doing business, especially in urban areas such as Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads, and we cannot discount that.
01:45:32
We have to pay attention to it.
01:45:34
The development of a comprehensive statewide congestion management program can help us along those lines.
01:45:41
Expanding the use of safety service patrols and implementing quick clearance techniques we know can dramatically reduce
01:45:51
The congestion that is associated with incidents, and we know that incidents can account for as much as 50% of our congestion difficulties.
01:46:03
Explore the use of advanced technology solutions to improve traffic flow and information in Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia.
01:46:10
We are just beginning to scratch the surface with what technology can in fact do
01:46:15
to provide more information for us.
01:46:18
Communications actually is a substitute for moving people around.
01:46:24
Communication is a substitute for moving people around.
01:46:29
So if you can reduce the cost moving people around through technology, then you can reduce congestion, then you can actually reduce the cost of those things that actually do have to move.
01:46:42
Implement an enhanced Virginia operational information system and 511 Virginia.
01:46:48
We know that a lot of folks are using 511 Virginia to gather information for special kinds of events such as the Williamsburg celebration, the visit of the Queen.
01:47:02
We also know that the current system we have leaves a lot to be desired.
01:47:07
And so we're working on ways to improve those.
01:47:10
It's probably going to be early in 2008 when we get all those things in place, but it will allow us from the standpoint of inside VDOT to respond more rapidly and accurately to incidents and emergency situations, and it will help us provide better information to the public.
01:47:28
develop and implement a comprehensive highway access management set of standards.
01:47:33
We are well down the road on that.
01:47:36
That is in combination with a number of other things, a way that we can help move traffic
01:47:44
H. W. Smith III, Michael A. Stevens III,
01:48:03
You don't have to have direct access.
01:48:06
You can get access better through a good access management program.
01:48:11
Pursue the hot lanes network.
01:48:13
That's something we need to continue to do to work with the private sector with the higher occupancy storylines.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:21
Could I just ask one question?
01:48:24
I find all these just very good, and I'm so glad you're pursuing all these points.
01:48:30
But are there any of these quick clearance techniques that we know of that we aren't implementing right now?
01:48:38
Because certainly in congested areas, it's these incidents that are extraordinary.
SPEAKER_23
01:48:46
Sometimes it simply is a matter of communicating better with other agencies that are involved in the incident itself, police, fire, rescue.
01:48:58
There was legislation that was enacted, as I recall, in this session of the General Assembly that allows us to have VDOT folks move along the
01:49:09
improving land use and transportation with our partners.
01:49:25
As the Commissioner mentioned, this is a key aspect
01:49:38
of changing the transportation system and working with localities regarding land development.
01:49:51
We're not going to forestall development.
01:49:54
No one really wants to.
01:49:55
It's an economic engine that helps all of us.
01:50:00
The issue is making sure that we coordinate land use and transportation.
01:50:05
The implementation of Chapter 527, the traffic impact requirement process that now actually requires local governments when a certain threshold of traffic impact is met to
01:50:21
Do a traffic impact assessment, provide that to VDOT, and then VDOT will comment on that so everyone will understand what the implications of that development are, what those implications are.
01:50:38
When you can communicate that with folks and you can create a forum for dialogue and debate,
01:50:46
Then you get better informed decisions.
01:50:48
VDOT is not going to make the decisions.
01:50:51
They're not allowed to.
01:50:53
But our role is to review these impact statements and provide feedback.
01:50:58
That's a very positive thing.
01:51:00
Local system improvements, aiding localities in determining whether or not to assume control of the secondary system.
01:51:09
There are many, many reasons that one might argue that it makes sense for localities to have control of their own local roads, not the least of which is an incentive to take account of their own decisions and how it affects them locally.
01:51:27
We do have a tool that we have developed to aid localities in making that assessment, looking at what the costs and benefits are, and we're going to be working with any localities that want to pursue.
01:51:38
Mr. Chairman.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:40
Dr. Allen, when you say the biggest obstacle there is the fear of localities on funding.
SPEAKER_23
01:51:45
Excuse me.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:46
When you say the big obstacle there, they would probably love to do their own roads, but the biggest obstacle in stepping forward to assume that responsibility is the fear of the funding factor.
SPEAKER_23
01:51:57
That may be a significant risk that the localities face.
01:52:05
I also think that for some localities, there's a lot of solace in being able to say, well, we would have liked to have done such and such, but you know what?
01:52:17
That dirty old mean VDOT just wouldn't let us do it.
01:52:19
That's my personal opinion, but I think that certainly funding is a significant issue.
01:52:26
I think the other issue I mentioned is important as well.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:31
If I might add on that issue, you know, there's assuming construction responsibilities, which is the first city's initiative, as well as assuming secondary road construction is very different from the maintenance responsibility.
01:52:46
and one of the things that we need to be talking about I think under particularly under the first cities that cities are already in towns already maintaining their own roads and have that capability in-house except for some very large complex projects it just in my judgment makes sense to to vest the construction's responsibility you can move the money back and forth between maintenance and construction when you have when you have both
01:53:13
and I think will actually yield greater economies over time.
01:53:18
It's a different issue with the counties clearly.
SPEAKER_23
01:53:21
And that relates to the second bullet that you see on this slide, which is the local administration of projects with the First Cities Initiative as a baseline.
01:53:29
The third point here relates to subdivision street standards.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:32
Could you go back just a moment?
01:53:34
I want to make sure I understood what you said.
01:53:37
Funding, the fear of funding and consistency of it is one factor, but what was the other one that you first emphasized?
SPEAKER_23
01:53:45
The other point that I made is that I believe that a number of localities take solace in the ability to point the finger at VDOT and say, we would have loved to have done X, but VDOT would not allow us to do that.
01:54:00
If, in fact, they take over their local responsibility, locally, they take over responsibility, then
01:54:07
That capability is no longer there.
01:54:11
So that's my personal opinion from observation over many years.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:21
and as one who comes from local government, I can certainly substantiate.
SPEAKER_23
01:54:27
The subdivision street standards modernization, Senate Bill 1181, that really does some things that provide some very, very strong incentives to local governments, not just to accept anything that then goes into the secondary system and ultimately ends up raising the cost of maintenance for people.
01:54:49
Thank you very much.
01:54:52
Mr. Secretary, you have some questions.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:58
Gary, in terms of reshaping the system, I look at the four system points that you've set up here, numbers one through four, and I think they're great.
01:55:08
I can't take issue with anything that you've suggested in all four of those.
01:55:13
I think they're all necessary, and I think they address the needs very comprehensively.
01:55:20
But I think if you're talking about reshaping the system, you need a system number five.
01:55:25
which I'm going to suggest to you and it goes to the point that I made to the Commissioner earlier and I'm not sure what to call it but it's something like improving analysis for right sizing and I think it deserves the level of recognition of being another one of your systems so that ultimately
01:55:51
It gets institutionalized as a process.
01:55:55
I make the analogy to the medical sector where over the last five or ten years the whole process of second opinion.
01:56:05
When it comes to surgery, for example, and so forth, getting at the fact that within the medical sector there was a recognition that surgeons do surgery and other types of doctors do other things and there was a need to institutionalize a process where there was a step back, an opportunity for the customer to find out
01:56:26
whether in fact with a broader perspective there might be another approach and it was really addressed by the medical sector really by the insurance companies because of the potential for cost saving so it also had other benefits in terms of
01:56:40
impact on the patient and various other things so that's an analogy but I think that having a fifth system here and I don't propose to tell you how to do this but it gets at this issue of making sure we're
01:56:57
institutionally, each time we look at a project, taking that step back and saying, is this really the right project to address this need, nothing less, nothing more, somehow ought to be elevated to the level of a fifth system, if you're really talking about reshaping the system.
01:57:15
That's my suggestion.
SPEAKER_23
01:57:16
Excellent point.
01:57:18
Excellent point.
SPEAKER_20
01:57:19
And I would add another one.
01:57:22
Having been in local government, I would concur with your suggestion that having VDOT as the bad guy is certainly used often.
01:57:33
But what really means a lot to me in this whole land use process and connecting it with transportation is looking at the connection between the comp plans and VDOT's plans.
01:57:51
And maybe this is going to be addressed in 3202 with the urban development areas.
01:57:59
But it seems to me that we need to have a much closer connection between VDOT and the comp plan of each one of our localities.
01:58:12
And to share that even further,
01:58:14
and particularly in Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia and other more developed areas.
01:58:22
We need to look at it more than just as a locality in VDOT.
01:58:27
We need to look at it as a regional land use issue.
01:58:32
We need to think about where our transit lines are going to be, for example, and VDOT
01:58:41
and Matthew's group need to look at where those transit lines are going to be not only today but where they're going to be in the future.
01:58:51
We need to coordinate the land use patterns around those areas so that we can develop the density that we need to make transit work.
01:59:01
In a lot of Hampton Roads, transit doesn't work
01:59:05
Because the density is not there.
01:59:08
And you can't get people to a stop to make it work.
01:59:12
In Arlington, Alexandria, around the metro stops, the way they've developed those transit-oriented development patterns there, it does work.
01:59:22
It seems to me that we're not doing what we need to do to make that coordination and
01:59:29
The Governor's effort to connect land use and transportation, in my view, has to go beyond street standards, which I think are important, and some of these other things that we're talking about.
01:59:42
The bigger issue here is that we have to look at that comprehensive plan
01:59:48
that a locality is doing and connect what VDOT is doing so that we're all on the same team.
01:59:57
We're not developing out in places that are going to exacerbate already a stretched system.
02:00:07
Maybe you get at that with the UDA's, but maybe not.
SPEAKER_23
02:00:11
Another excellent point.
02:00:12
I think that the two points are related.
02:00:15
They are related, and as we move forward here, we're going to work on how we can incorporate that.
02:00:22
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:00:24
Let me just add on that note, if you read the enactment clauses of House Bill 3202, and you talk about hard decisions.
02:00:34
What those two metropolitan areas, Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia, have to do is to develop performance measures for land use and transportation, and those have to be agreed to by this body.
02:00:47
I can assure you that will not be an easy task, especially those of you who represent those areas.
02:00:54
And explicitly mentions, job housing ratio, access to transit, those things are all contemplated.
02:01:01
And that's where you raise the issue correctly about we have to be looking at the system.
02:01:07
That's our job, not necessarily individual pieces of it.
02:01:11
That's the right way to do that and to make that connection.
02:01:15
It's not to be
02:01:16
Boring in on individual rezonings or even an individual segment of a highway, but to make sure that the network works and that there is an agreement between the Commonwealth and those regions.
02:01:26
That is a very important mechanism.
02:01:28
And probably by this time next year, we're going to be faced with the series.
02:01:33
That's what the accountability commission is working on.
02:01:35
I think today there are some canoes who are looking at this exact issue.
02:01:38
How do you develop performance measures for transportation and land use on a regional basis
02:01:43
in a way that is fairly simple, enforceable, and at the end of the day can be agreed to by this body in those regions.
02:01:54
And that's going to be a very interesting and tough dialogue at that level.
SPEAKER_20
02:02:00
And you will get a significant amount of resistance from local governments if you start talking about individual land use decisions.
02:02:09
That's something that's guarded by local governments.
02:02:14
But the regional concept makes so much sense.
02:02:19
I have to think that
02:02:21
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_00
02:02:30
I listened to Mr. Tucker a little while ago and he was speaking about the rail systems and about the quarter and about the transit and where stops would be and et cetera.
02:02:44
Then I listened at this presentation
02:02:48
and is speaking about Hot Lanes Network.
02:02:54
And then performance, and we have got to come and put all of this, this is for Mr. McCarthy, I believe, and his concern a little while ago, that this has all got to come together very quickly.
02:03:11
If not, 95 is going to be a parking lot.
02:03:15
It's going to be a commuter parking lot, and that's what it has become already.
02:03:21
And we speak of the safety issues.
02:03:24
That's what we're all about, this is safety, and that we don't have fatalities.
02:03:30
And I hope that when you visit the area, in the Perthesburg area, and from Stafford on down to the Zonsburg, that some way that we can
02:03:42
get an overview of
02:04:02
doing a great job on strategic planning.
02:04:06
And when I think about comprehensive plans, I believe that in Stafford, in my right court, your comprehensive plan has premier settlement areas, which is the growth areas.
02:04:19
And so that has that all along that quarter.
02:04:23
And that's the comprehensive plan.
02:04:25
That's what it states.
02:04:26
We have them.
02:04:27
and where is the impact?
02:04:29
It's impacting those quarters so drastically and because of the comprehensive plan and I certainly agree with you that VDOT is certainly working, I believe, with localities more than ever because they've had this opportunity and I believe localities are taking this opportunity to work together because something has to be done.
02:04:57
We're just in a critical state, and your strategic plans are great, but we've got to move.
02:05:03
Mr. Cherry.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:08
Question?
02:05:09
I just want to make a quick observation to reinforce what you said.
02:05:13
I gave a talk last night to a group of local legislators and local officials, and when I calmly mentioned the fact that the CTB would be involved in approving the two regional
02:05:25
Well, the land use aspects of it, you know, notes started scribbling and eyebrows started raising.
02:05:31
I'm not sure the word has fully gotten out to everybody about that.
02:05:35
It will be fun.
02:05:38
Well said.
SPEAKER_14
02:05:40
Mr. Whirley, welcome.
02:05:42
Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'm going to review the reshaping the business focus area.
02:05:48
There are six items, improving project delivery, ensuring efficient and effective VDOT management, unify the system investment process, improve SLAM, and I'll explain that acronym a little later, assessing internal control and engaging
02:06:07
I will say before I get into the details that the Commissioner and I are, we go around to each district quarterly and we review the business processes of each district and we focus on a number of different items.
02:06:28
You may not see that listed here, but I want to give you some feel for the structure.
02:06:32
That we're meeting with all the key management going through a number of items from construction projects, to maintenance projects, to administrative items, to human resources issues.
02:06:46
We're doing that on a quarterly basis in more of a
02:06:50
business meeting environment.
02:06:51
So I want to say, even though you don't see that on the schedule, as some of the underpinnings as holding a number of these items together, and the reason I believe we're making good progress on running a good business.
02:07:04
We have a lot of improvements, and I probably could name some more to put on the schedule, but these are the ones that we want to focus on this year or in FYOA.
02:07:16
In terms of improving project development and delivery, implement an enhanced construction engineering and inspection process, and we call that CEI.
02:07:27
If you remember the dashboard, we're looking at construction contracts.
02:07:32
Is it on time?
02:07:33
Is it on budget?
02:07:34
Now we're looking at the additional costs, or other costs, that's associated with bringing the project into completion.
02:07:45
That cost could be project engineers charged with the project, it could be our inspectors, it could be a number of various disciplines within the department that would be charged with the project.
02:07:58
The key here is do we have a budget, what is that budget, and are we managing and monitoring that part of business?
02:08:07
Last year we had on the business plan the development of the CEI process.
02:08:14
Now this year we are implementing that process.
02:08:17
It gets to what the Commissioner talked about earlier.
02:08:20
In FY07 we developed the CEI process, now we're implementing it.
02:08:26
Evaluate and implement appropriate recommendations for the Transportation Accountability Commission.
02:08:33
We felt that was an important part to put on this plan because there may be some new items coming out that, again, will enhance the business.
02:08:41
It could very well be that some of these recommendations may be in other areas of reshaping the system, but we felt this was a good placeholder to put it under the business, under reshaping the business focus.
02:08:53
Commissioner talked a little earlier about the implement contact sensitive solution.
02:09:00
We met with our key managers around the state at our government leadership conference a couple of weeks ago.
02:09:11
There's a lot of discussion, a lot of interest, a lot of good ideas about how to bring this program on and I saw a lot of excitement around it.
02:09:21
In terms of the investigate reducing project development time by 10%.
02:09:28
Again, that was one of the more exciting discussions that we had because there was a lot of debate.
02:09:36
How do you reduce that results in time?
02:09:40
And with the number of engineers in the room, they got into laying out all of the processes step by step and trying to overlay that and said now what brings value to this process, what doesn't bring value and what can be eliminated.
02:09:55
I thought that was a real good discussion and it's going to be a hard one to pull off, but I think it's going to be worthwhile.
02:10:05
Review past outsourcing initiatives to ensure effectiveness.
02:10:09
This is the issue that the board brought to us some time ago.
02:10:14
Let's make certain that these things that we're outsourcing make sense.
02:10:17
Let's just not outsource them and forgive them.
02:10:20
Let's go back and take a look at them and make certain we're getting our money's worth out of outsourcing those particular projects.
02:10:28
So that was the reason we had that item.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:35
Commissioner, or I guess Deputy Commissioner.
02:10:39
On that particular initiative, do we have objective analysis of past outsourcing contracts that are some type of reports that we could have a measure of that we could look at that's been evaluated so we could
SPEAKER_14
02:10:54
We would have a baseline, and from that baseline we could evaluate how we are doing with this outsourcing initiative.
02:11:03
For example, on the CAMS process that we just went through, we do have a baseline for that cost.
02:11:09
So as we go through or complete a year, we can evaluate the effectiveness of that contract, both from a cost standpoint and also from an operational standpoint.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:23
But there are reports on various outsourced contracts that we have that we would have access to that's been analyzed that could be... Cost-benefit analysis, we do have for the items that we've outsourced, yes.
SPEAKER_14
02:11:37
And operations.
02:11:40
And operations.
02:11:41
We know what the performance measurements are.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:44
Did they deliver what we asked for, I guess is the...
SPEAKER_14
02:11:48
I think we haven't conducted the study on was the past outsourcing initiatives effective, but we're going to do that this coming year.
02:11:59
Now, I thought the question was do we have a baseline on which to measure and evaluate those past outsourcing activities, and we do have that, and that will be done in FY08.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:17
Greg, can I go back to the investigate reducing project development by 10%?
02:12:23
Is that an ultimate goal or is that an interim goal?
SPEAKER_14
02:12:28
I think that would be an interim goal.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:30
Okay, because that just in this formation of our Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, we've had meetings with a lot of the local technical people and I would say
02:12:41
That is the major consensus item is the time delay and I think this is what you're talking about between developing a local project and getting it through the necessary approval processes here and that seemed to be the number one concern and that's why I look at 10% and that wouldn't satisfy that audience at least.
SPEAKER_14
02:13:08
Yes, that would be an annual goal.
02:13:14
Strategy two, to ensure efficient and effective VDOT management.
02:13:18
I also have failed to mention that there will be a strategic leader appointed for each one of these items that we have, and there will be timelines and some actions items developed to ensure that these items are done.
02:13:32
Implement area headquarters consolidation.
02:13:35
We did a study last year.
02:13:36
We're in the process of implementing, and we're getting regular reports on how we stand with the implementation.
02:13:43
I developed a list of candidate functions for outsourcing, evaluate, outsource as appropriate.
02:13:49
We still have the legislation that requires us to look 12 months back and look 12 months following.
02:13:56
In other words, what have we outsourced the last 12 months?
02:14:00
And what do we plan to outsource for the next 12 months?
02:14:05
And the commissioners have to report on that in November of each year.
02:14:13
We do have a process and a methodology of trying to identify some candidate functions for outsourcing and we will put those through a cost benefit methodology that we develop in FY07.
02:14:29
Development Fund Research.
02:14:32
You probably saw that on the plan last year.
02:14:36
We think that is something that is important and should be on the plan this year.
02:14:40
You need to invest in research because that's the only way we're going to improve our process.
02:14:46
Strength and Advisory Groups, and I need to explain this a little bit, MPLG, DCE.
02:14:54
MPLG stands for Maintenance Program Leadership Group.
02:14:59
DCE stands for District Construction Engineers.
02:15:03
There are a couple other acronyms that I didn't put up there, but here's the focus of that item.
02:15:10
Our field folks know the processes.
02:15:14
They know the business.
02:15:16
They know how to build a project.
02:15:18
They know maintenance.
02:15:20
What we're trying to do is to formalize that group.
02:15:23
We have our key maintenance leadership folks get together and they debate policy.
02:15:31
They debate processes.
02:15:33
They debate better ways to deliver the product.
02:15:36
What we're doing is creating more of a formal process as opposed to, and I don't like to use this word, but an ad hoc process, a formal process to say here are the recommendations and ideas coming out of that group.
02:15:51
Those ideas would go up to the district administrators as a group, as a council.
02:15:55
They will debate those and determine what types of recommendations need to be implemented.
02:16:02
Clearly that will be presented to the Commissioner and to some of the Chiefs for their input.
02:16:08
I believe that we formalized that process.
02:16:11
It will facilitate process improvement, because who knows better how to deliver the project than the guys who are working out in the field.
02:16:20
At Sam's Mall, it doesn't get the headlines, but I think that's the key to improving the business.
02:16:26
I probably should have had that as the first bullet underneath this section.
02:16:32
And there are several other groups that we have, the engineering group, administrative group, I just listed a couple there.
02:16:39
To unify the systems investment process, the Commissioner talked about this earlier, integrate the SIP and the Maintenance and Operations Program into one process.
02:16:50
We have three separate processes and one of our areas of efficiency and to bring about clarity is to take these three separate documents and if we can roll them into one document.
02:17:02
That will be a challenge.
02:17:05
The SCIP focuses more on the federal side.
02:17:07
The Six-Year Program has federal and state funding in it.
02:17:11
And this will be a challenge, but I think if we can hold off, we'll simplify the process of managing those projects.
02:17:21
Incorporated to the transportation selection process, performance measures related to congestion, reduction, safety, transit, HOV use.
02:17:31
This is an important area.
02:17:33
We do have criteria now for selecting projects to go in the six-year program.
02:17:38
And this is a suggestion that maybe there should be some other measures used into the process.
02:17:45
Again, once this is flushed out, this will come back before the board because this is basically your decision.
02:17:54
But these are some things that we're looking at to determine if it can help in identifying projects.
02:18:03
Approving SWAM.
02:18:05
SWAM stands for Small Women and Minority-Owned Businesses.
02:18:10
The Executive Order 33 of the government's issue said that all state agencies shall reach a goal of a quarter percent of expenditures shall be paid to SWAM vendors.
02:18:25
That's a quarter percent of discretionary expenditures.
02:18:29
In order to look at our budget, we have a $3.8 billion budget.
02:18:35
But from that, you would deduct the salaries that are paid.
02:18:38
You would deduct the utilities that are paid because you can't go out and shop around for utilities.
02:18:45
And you come down to a net number.
02:18:47
That's called discretionary spending.
02:18:50
And that number approximates somewhere around 1.8 billion.
02:18:54
The governor's executive order required us to do 40% of that $1.8 billion in SWAM expenditures.
02:19:02
There's a process that's used to qualify companies as a SWAM vendor.
02:19:09
The department in FY07 selected a goal of 20%.
02:19:13
We felt we could not make it 40%.
02:19:15
and FY06 it was 15%.
02:19:21
I think we came up with like 13 to 14%.
02:19:25
And FY07 we selected a goal of 20%.
02:19:28
This year we're running somewhere between 25 and 28%.
02:19:33
Next year in FY08 the goal will be 30%.
02:19:37
I feel pretty confident that we will make that 30% goal.
02:19:42
enhancing the DBE program through the, Ms. Martin.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:19:49
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Whirley, I've been associated with some other organizations at times that would look at the SWAM goals as inherently good.
02:20:00
And my question is regarding the SWAM goals for us, what measurable and objective impact
02:20:09
What do we have to look at the measurable and objective impact on the transportation system itself that shows that the system is better off with 30% or 40% than it was?
02:20:24
What can we show that, let's say something as simple as a new political administration who didn't see the inherent value in it that we can show to say why SWAM is good and we should continue doing?
SPEAKER_14
02:20:37
I think, Mr. Martin, we are developing some good companies that without this program would not have had an opportunity to get into the transportation or highway business.
02:20:50
This program has allowed some small contractors, women-owned contractors and minority contractors to get into this program and I would say that it has increased competition.
02:21:04
What makes it good for us is that increased competition drives down costs.
02:21:09
I would say that the program is a good program and we will see the benefit.
02:21:15
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:21:17
If I just might add, Mr. Martin, on that topic, one of the things that we've discovered in this industry is increasing concentration in out-of-state providers.
02:21:29
And so if we want to maintain a healthy, dynamic, competitive set of contractors, we have a very keen interest in growing that locally or on a statewide basis.
02:21:43
The contracting industries are no different than home building or branch banking.
02:21:50
And encouraging this, it's difficult to necessarily measure it on a year-to-year basis, but we all know when we went into a dip on the competition for construction contracts,
02:22:04
It was simply a small number of big providers being committed to other projects in other parts of the country.
02:22:11
And so I think one of the ways to think about the SLAM program is growing businesses that create greater competition and greater diversity in our contractor pool.
02:22:23
Very, very important.
02:22:24
But a long-term mission will be kind of tough to measure in the short term, I believe.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:22:29
You know, I agree.
02:22:30
I think we're on a much firmer long-term ground remembering that as opposed to the inherent value of giving businesses the chance that we now are going to get one.
02:22:40
Good point.
02:22:40
Well taken.
02:22:41
Thank you.
SPEAKER_14
02:22:42
The next item is enhance and develop the DBE program through the Business Opportunity Workforce Development Program.
02:22:49
We have a $750,000 grant to help businesses get into the transportation area.
02:22:59
We are about to launch that program, I believe June 1 or mid-June, where we will be working with our DPE suppliers and providers to help them get into this transportation business and secure contracts within the Department of Transportation.
02:23:19
Number five is assess the internal controls.
02:23:24
I mentioned this last month.
02:23:27
I talked about Sarbanes-Oxley and the impact that had on to the business community.
02:23:32
This is the Sarbanes-Oxley-like version for state government.
02:23:38
This mostly focuses on a section in Sarbanes-Oxley known as Section 404, and this is where VDOT and all state agencies
02:23:49
We must assess their internal controls to determine if they are effective.
02:23:54
We need to look at the control environment and all of our controls, assess our risks, and determine if those procedures and processes are working.
02:24:06
This requires our managers and their certifications.
02:24:09
Not that we just have a set of procedures on the shelf, but are those procedures working?
02:24:16
This program, we have to have a first-line assessment of this by September of 07.
02:24:24
We must test the controls by June of 08, and we must
02:24:30
Jr., developing action plan for any deficiencies that were found and have that implemented a little later.
02:24:38
The date is escaping me right now.
02:24:42
This is a huge area for us.
02:24:44
It's going to take a lot of time.
02:24:47
We have already begun the process, and I think our controls are pretty good.
02:24:54
But going through this process and assessing the environment, I've seen some weaknesses and we're in the process of looking at some of those to fix them.
02:25:05
I would say that while assessing internal controls is a major issue this year, I would probably suggest to you that next year when we're doing this business plan, you may see the preparation for implementing a new financial system within VDOT and the Commonwealth of Virginia.
02:25:26
There is a new enterprise application process that's supposed to be ready to go in July of 2009.
02:25:33
So next year when we come up with this reshape the business, you'll probably see a focus area in there on getting ready to implement a new financial system.
02:25:42
That would be a huge challenge for the department.
02:25:47
The last item engaging key partners, continue the forum with the chief executives on improving the business practices.
02:25:55
This is where the commissioner meets, I believe, on a quarterly basis with
02:26:01
A number of the key executives of businesses talk about how can we improve our relationship, our working relationship with each other.
02:26:10
And from that comes a number of ideas and suggestions that we will evaluate and then try to implement if possible.
02:26:19
expand and improve the formal partnering process beyond contractors to include local governments at all levels.
02:26:26
This is new this year, and this is where we're trying to reach out not just to the contractors about business, but also to the localities.
02:26:35
How can they help in this process, and how can we help them looking for process improvement?
02:26:42
I believe that's it, and I'll be happy to entertain questions for sure.
02:26:47
Any questions for Mr. Whorley?
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:26:49
Mr. Chairman.
02:26:51
Greg, maybe the Commissioner may want to answer this and it may be that he's answered it already and I missed it, but my question is the panel of Chief Executives, how is that chosen and how did we go about coming up with those that we're consulting with?
SPEAKER_14
02:27:11
Chief, in the area you want to address that?
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
02:27:17
We meet with two different groups, one from the contracting industry and one from the consulting industry.
02:27:31
We met, there's basically two contracting groups, the Virginia Transportation Construction Alliance and Old Dominion.
02:27:42
We looked at all the contractors that we had.
02:27:45
We tried to pick them from a regional viewpoint and from small and large.
02:27:50
There's about 20 that we meet with.
02:27:54
We did the same thing with the consultant group.
02:27:57
Commissioner Eckert recently met both with the contract group and the consultant group for the first time probably in the last six weeks with both of them.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:28:05
VDOT picks the individual contractors and consultants, and the outside organizations do not participate in that process.
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
02:28:14
Well, they would make recommendations to the Commissioner.
02:28:17
There was a lot of people that wanted to come to these, and he wanted to keep the numbers around 20, so we took the recommendations and then made those selections there.
02:28:27
I worked with Byron and with Celinda, who heads up our consultant, and then checked those with the Commissioner is how we selected them.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:28:35
The next presenter is Meredith Baker.
02:28:44
Welcome, Ms. Baker, to talk about reshaping the workforce.
SPEAKER_17
02:28:48
Thank you, Mr. Secretary and board members.
02:28:54
And since I got to cover most of my presentation the last time, I will offer just to take questions.
02:29:02
A lot of what you see here on the workforce is pretty self-explanatory.
02:29:08
So I'll make that offer to you, Mr. Secretary, just to save some time.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:13
Gladly.
02:29:14
We do have a lengthy presentation yet on the Section Improvement Program.
02:29:17
We have a public comment session we do need to get to.
02:29:21
I appreciate that Ms. Baker.
02:29:22
Are there questions?
02:29:24
And if you look on page 19 of the handout, there's a listing of the five workforce initiatives.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:31
Well, I just want to support the commissioner on workforce item number five, the telework program.
02:29:41
I think this is a vitally important program for the whole state and the nation, and I think if we don't show leadership in it within our own
SPEAKER_17
02:29:53
The World at Work
02:30:12
in this last year that they surveyed have broadened and or either added that type of choice within their workforce.
02:30:22
But from saving work space to giving employees greater flexibility and reducing costs and quite a few companies fight as increasing productivity.
02:30:35
So there are many good reasons to
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:38
Well, I think also it's the leadership that VDOT should go in this.
SPEAKER_17
02:30:42
It makes sense that a transportation agency would want to model this in the state, and that's what we're aiming to do.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:51
Mr. Schwartz.
02:30:52
Just a very quick comment.
02:30:54
In my own business, one of the things that I always thought was very, very important in terms of, and this would relate to your workforce number two goal, get the right people in the right places.
02:31:09
is put a very high premium on creative thinking, fresh blood, broader drawing area.
02:31:20
In my law firm, we would always have this debate about do we want the, in hiring practices, do we want the lawyers who got the best averages in school and so forth and so on.
02:31:34
And one of the things some of us used to say is no, what we were really looking for was the twinkle in the eye.
02:31:39
Everybody got straight A's.
02:31:42
The question was, which are the unique individuals who have the broader creativity, broader experience to keep the institution and the organization and the business fresh?
02:31:54
and responsive to changing conditions and changing times.
02:31:58
And I would encourage you under workforce item two to just give some thought to how, again, how you can institutionalize that goal as you move forward.
SPEAKER_13
02:32:13
It's all about compensation.
Dana M. Martin
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:32:18
Well, Mr. Chairman, Ms. Baxter, similarly,
02:32:24
I would say people will look and see the implicit value.
02:32:29
And in number four, for example, it's easy to see the implicit value.
02:32:32
For number five, it's easy for some of us to see the implicit value.
02:32:37
One, two, and three, please get the measurable and objective link as to what the value is to the transportation system.
02:32:48
As opposed to the people who are involved or the concept itself.
02:32:54
But all of these things pay off.
02:32:58
But if you want them to live beyond the current initiative, then that payoff needs to be right there for anybody to measure and see why it's good and when it's not there anymore.
SPEAKER_17
02:33:09
We did a research study and I actually have a white paper and a lot of the initiatives that my directorate specifically and some of these initiatives came out of that research that we did that was research within the transportation industry as well as specific to VDOT.
02:33:27
So I think a lot of these came out of looking at what the business needs are and I hear your point and let's be sure that we're measuring the effectiveness and translating that for our customers as well as our employees.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:46
Any other questions?
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:50
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
02:33:51
Commissioner, do you have some closing comments for us?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:53
Just very quickly, I really appreciate what the board has done this afternoon in devoting this kind of time to the discussion.
02:34:01
You are in fact shaping what we're doing.
02:34:05
Mr. Martin, the way I look at your comment right now is the business plan and the business is a process by which we bolt into the organization for things that last.
02:34:17
They've got to go beyond who's here and that's a big challenge for us and your advice really helps us.
02:34:24
On the system side, as I listen to the conversation around how do you link system planning to project scope is kind of the theme that I think I heard emerging that needs to be recognized throughout our process.
02:34:43
And that is something that we'll try to get fed into so that we are answering the questions that have been raised.
02:34:52
Throughout the year we'll be, you'll see my comments on my quarterly reports shift from kind of focusing at that activity sheet that you see to more on the progress reports and what we're accomplishing and learning in the business plan.
02:35:11
Mr. Chairman, we really appreciate the opportunity.
02:35:14
Thank you.
02:35:15
In the essence of time, my report stands for itself as a quarterly report.
02:35:20
If you have a question, see me after the meeting.
02:35:23
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:24
Thank you, Commissioner.
02:35:25
The beginning of a very long journey.
02:35:28
Let me suggest this.
02:35:29
Let's take a five-minute break and come back and then ask for the presentation on the Six-Year Improvement Program.
02:35:36
We do have public comment beginning precisely at 5.30, so if there are unanswered questions, we can come back after the public comment session.
02:35:46
There will be hot food set up beginning at 5.30, but I would ask that we not eat while people are doing public commentary.
02:35:53
If you are hungry, you could perhaps slip into the
02:35:56
And when that public comment is done, we can have a light supper over in the network.
02:36:05
So, five-minute break and we'll come back to the Six-Year Improvement Plan presentation.
SPEAKER_13
02:36:20
This is where you notice it's like you're really good at like yoga and meditation.
02:36:29
Let us have time.
02:36:30
I mean, they can put a crayon on top of it.
02:36:33
So we're out.
02:36:34
I'd like to do this.
02:36:35
Well, we must not.
02:36:36
I can't do that.
02:36:37
We're running a big, small, big E. I'll go ahead.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:44
You'll just be interested in saying it because I was fascinated by their reactions to it.
SPEAKER_13
02:36:49
And we have all
02:37:16
Make your, you know, the deacon's point, and all those things along that way. I'll get you a coffee. Appreciate you. Yeah. I think so. Absolutely. They have very nice charts. They're quite successful.
02:37:44
My wife and I have this discussion several times.
02:38:04
I like getting to know each other all the time.
02:38:06
It's a Sunday, it's a Monday, it's a Tuesday.
02:38:07
My children go across this level.
02:38:07
We and Arthur are there.
02:38:08
I'm there all the time.
02:38:09
I'm there all the time.
02:38:09
What's he doing?
02:38:14
Brian got home?
02:38:20
Brian got there?
02:38:22
Oh, he doesn't want to see the sample book.
02:38:32
I was wondering if he was there with Brooke.
02:38:40
I was just wondering how she was feeling.
02:38:46
Alright, I'll call and say thanks.
02:38:59
You know, my daughter was fine when I was a student.
02:39:20
🎵Music🎵 I was looking at the city and probably watching our content today, just that sort of thing. So yeah, I was just going to move on now to the place where I already know that there are a lot of small controllers.
02:39:44
Well, uh, as of this week in a chandelier, we, uh, it depends on what you're talking about.
02:40:08
The children are often well on the spotter than we had those days.
02:40:11
So I said, uh,
02:40:11
Say, okay, I'm just going to get a picture on that.
02:40:25
I'm going to come and invite you out in the morning.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:31
We just had two room cancellation.
02:40:35
You want to?
SPEAKER_13
02:40:36
We're all charged for one night.
02:40:41
That's good.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:40:41
This is, this exercise has really been terrific.
02:40:46
I've been, you know, I couldn't have this level.
SPEAKER_13
02:40:54
Hello?
02:40:55
Hello?
02:40:58
Hello?
02:41:01
Hello?
02:41:05
I think I cut it down just a little bit.
02:41:15
I think I cut this down just a little bit still here.
02:41:23
Yes, but if I don't hold it in my hand,
02:41:26
and Lorraine up on the table right.
02:41:45
You know, now that you say it, smartly in front of me, as I'm coming around this summer, I'm going to ask you to come on with me.
02:42:02
Those levels have been politically involved in the area and region for Germany.
02:42:21
Could be good to accompany you on any level.
02:42:23
He did mention that.
02:42:25
He mentioned the calendar.
02:42:28
I got dates reserved, but I don't know what all the class categories are.
02:42:40
So it's clear.
02:42:41
I'll make sure I have that.
02:42:42
I'm probably bringing mail.
02:42:45
I think she got back. Now, you see, you're going to get, you're going to get pressured out of the, out of the field of reality. On the political side, the police are going to get the aid. Most of them are going to kill their victims. The suggestion they're talked about, they need to be willing to get the meaning of the secret energy.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:43:05
I went to the breaks and did my public stuff.
02:43:10
They showed up exactly what I had been and what I had done.
02:43:16
We're not getting into the rock and roll, but we had something to do.
02:43:18
We're friends.
02:43:19
We can't have a secret.
02:43:19
We're friends.
SPEAKER_13
02:43:20
If you see a country which is easy for money to develop here, you guys can put yourself or anybody else to come in.
02:43:26
Hi Michelle, how are you?
02:43:30
This is Mary.
02:43:31
Hey, is everything okay?
02:43:34
Alright, I have a call from Near Washington Hospital, and I thought that I'd better check with them.
SPEAKER_00
02:43:48
Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_13
02:43:50
We were going to get $46 million in this district to deal with primary arrest.
02:44:04
Now, I see that we're going to get $57 million.
02:44:09
Who gave us $11 million in the contract next month?
02:44:14
H. J. Martin III,
02:44:36
Thomas, Michael A. Doolittle III, John C. Doolittle III,
02:44:53
That's great, but I share your hope.
02:45:10
If nothing comes out of it, boy, is it worth it.
02:45:12
I would like to thank my wife.
02:45:42
Thank you.
02:45:42
We have many different people here today.
02:45:58
We'd like to be guided by several of these players.
02:46:04
And now, I'm going to introduce our next presenter, who will be talking about the future of the United States of America. Please welcome, Mr. John O'Connor. We're so excited to have you here. I'm going to introduce you to the first person in the United States of America, Mr. John O'Connor. Please welcome, Mr. John O'Connor.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:46:28
as you well know
SPEAKER_13
02:46:49
You're some of Arthur's best friends, isn't he?
02:46:59
I'm very happy to have him on this craft land, both for the local and the water type.
02:47:01
Let's get this show on the road.
02:47:23
That's the first.
02:47:23
I'm very pleased to hear that.
02:47:24
It's going well.
02:47:24
Okay, alright.
02:47:44
No, no, no, no.
02:48:05
W. W. W. W.
02:48:24
I guess I'm coming in on detail because this was built and structured, dead and cured years ago.
02:48:49
Mr. Bowie.
02:48:56
Good to see you.
02:49:02
Always good to see you, sir.
02:49:08
So, thank you guys.
02:49:20
I'm here at five.
02:49:21
By the way, somebody else submitted.
02:49:32
Jim, how are you?
02:49:32
Good, how are you?
02:49:33
I'm going to get down to your neck of the woods here, but I'm committed to doing it.
02:49:35
Yeah, well I'm going to do it.
SPEAKER_17
02:49:36
Come along, please.
SPEAKER_13
02:49:37
O'Brien III,
02:50:02
I've been really used to this here.
02:50:17
And I was very concerned with that, as you said.
02:50:46
As it goes through, I don't want to do that anymore.
02:50:47
I think, you know, John, John over there, who takes the question...
02:51:10
They didn't get what they...
02:51:10
They all did.
02:51:11
They all did.
02:51:11
So this was what?
02:51:11
It was right there.
02:51:12
I think it was...
02:51:12
Yes.
02:51:12
Yeah.
SPEAKER_13
02:51:14
We have just one hour for a presentation and I know there will be a lot of questions.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:51:40
Barbara Reese is here.
02:51:42
along with Chip Badger to give us an overview of the Six-Year Improvement Plan as well as Six-Year Financial Plan, two different documents.
02:51:52
Barbara, if you could welcome Ms. Reese, if you could lead us through both.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
02:51:58
Good afternoon.
02:51:59
To begin, in part because there are some new board members, I did want to walk you through what your requirements are as they are set out in state law in terms of the Six-Year Financial Plan as well as the Six-Year Improvement Program.
02:52:13
And you can see those on page two of the presentation.
02:52:16
You administer and allocate the funds in the Transportation Trust Fund.
02:52:20
You do have to set aside the defined portions not only to
02:52:24
Mass transit and construction, but also to the port fund and the airport fund.
02:52:30
You have to allocate money to the highway maintenance function and well as to the interstate primary and secondary and then review and comment on budget items that aren't specifically enumerated.
02:52:44
In terms of your six-year financial plan, we talked a little bit about this, I guess it was last month or the month before when we talked about House Bill 3202.
02:52:53
It is the document that includes the official estimated revenues and allocation assumptions.
02:52:59
For this six-year period, it is $28 billion.
02:53:03
It is based on the official estimate from the Department of Taxation of Transportation Revenues.
02:53:10
That financial plan does determine the funding that is available in the Six-Year Improvement Program for rail, transit, ports, aviation, and highways.
02:53:19
And I would remind everybody that for the highway part, that is the last item that gets funded.
02:53:25
Everything else is a priority before the highway construction program.
02:53:30
And it also sets the actual budgets for the Department of Rail and Public Transportation as well as VDOT.
02:53:37
Unlike other state agencies, the Commonwealth Transportation Board actually has to take an action in addition to allow us to have an annual budget.
02:53:46
Most agencies just operate off the appropriation act of state government.
02:53:53
In terms of revenues, the estimated revenues as I've already mentioned is $28 billion available for allocation.
02:54:02
3.3 billion of that does result from the 2007 General Assembly actions.
02:54:08
Our average state revenue growth is 4% and that does exclude the bond proceeds.
02:54:14
That compares to a number of 2.7% last year.
02:54:17
So House Bill 3202 added 1.3% to our revenue estimate over the six years on an average.
02:54:25
Our average federal revenue growth is also about 2%.
02:54:29
And right now, because our current federal reauthorization ends in 2009 for fiscal years 10 through 13, it's based on just what the estimated fuel consumption growth is in Virginia.
02:54:41
There is, I want to remind everybody, there is a National Surface Transportation Policy and Revenue Study Commission that was set up in St. Louis that is supposed to be looking at how the next reauthorization will meet the surface transportation needs of the 21st century.
02:54:59
Projections still are that the Federal Highway Trust Fund could run out of actual cash in 2009, so we still have all that uncertainty out there, so you do not see us building up assuming any growth in federal revenues at this point.
02:55:15
Just to detail a little bit, the General Assembly actions in 2007.
02:55:19
House Bill 3202 itself includes $2.8 billion for this six-year period.
02:55:26
That's $1.3 billion in new revenue and $1.5 billion in bonds.
02:55:31
And then there is another $500 million in one-time general funds for the specific projects.
02:55:37
The largest item in that is $305 million for negotiated public-private transportation act or design-build projects.
02:55:44
Those are specifically enumerated in the appropriation act, $65 million for rail enhancement, $60 million for transit capital, and $20 million local revenue sharing as well as support funding.
02:55:59
In terms of the overall estimate, page eight just shows you the revenue estimates broken down.
02:56:04
And again, if you look at the total, how we broke down state transportation revenues, you see the first item is the Highway Maintenance Operating Fund.
02:56:14
We have not shown it with the 3202 revenues embedded in that number, Transportation Trust Fund, Priority Transportation Fund, and then House Bill 3202 revenues lined out separately, and then local and other revenues.
02:56:29
The local and other revenues on the state level do include still the Dulles Rail Project and the expected local share.
02:56:37
Until the agreements are all done with EMWA and there is an official transition, we will continue to carry those revenues in our estimate because the Dulles Rail Project is still a Commonwealth of Virginia project at this time.
02:56:51
And then at the very bottom of that slide you can see the other financing sources which are the bonds from House Bill 3202.
02:56:58
Remember that the limit each year is 300 million dollars and then general funds in 08 of 500 million dollars.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:08
Barbara, moving forward and considering the permission that Northern Virginia and Eastern Virginia has in terms of revenue, will that be reflected in reports in their six-year plans moving forward?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
02:57:21
The details of how they would want to show their capital projects that they're funding or whatnot have not been worked out.
02:57:27
I could see situations, though, where there's a project
02:57:30
Barbara, I need to be refreshed.
02:57:35
The priority of transportation fund.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:57:58
Those monies go where?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
02:58:01
The Priority Transportation Fund, most of the money in there is the one-third of the insurance premium that has now been permanently dedicated to that fund and those are used to pay debt service.
02:58:13
And the blue shaded areas, just to give everybody a context, we've shown 2006 and 2007 so you can see the change that is occurring as a result of the legislative session.
02:58:27
In terms of allocations, this is on page 10, you see the summary of allocations.
02:58:34
For those members that are new to the board, I would point out the order of this table is not, may seem
02:58:41
Strange, but this is the priority order of funding based on law.
02:58:45
The first thing that the Commonwealth Transportation Board has to pay for is debt service.
02:58:51
Debt service, as you can see, is going to be about average about $270 million a year.
02:58:57
That does include the debt service for the new bonds that we will be issuing.
02:59:02
There's other agencies and transfers that are made out of your revenues that are available to you.
02:59:08
Those include things like DMV, Department of Tax support for sales tax administration, those types of things.
02:59:16
Highway maintenance, you can see the growth in the highway maintenance program and this is both VDOT maintenance and
02:59:23
City and County Maintenance.
02:59:25
There's more detail in a few minutes.
02:59:26
You can see that is where the most astronomical growth has occurred.
02:59:30
If you look at 2006 level and compared to where we are in 2008, that's over $200 million in additional costs or spending.
02:59:39
Operations, toll roads and administration is the next line item.
02:59:44
Again, this is all laid out in the code about what order you allocate dollars.
02:59:48
Then you have public transportation and rail, ports and aviation, earmarks and special financing is somewhat of a hodgepodge category.
02:59:57
That will change with the final six-year program today.
03:00:01
That includes programs such as the $100 million for revenue sharing, the federal funds with their match that are controlled by the metropolitan planning organizations that they yet have not told us how they're going to distribute those dollars, just an assortment of things.
03:00:17
The other item that's in 2008,
03:00:20
is the $305 million for the PPTA projects.
03:00:25
And then you see highway systems construction is the last item.
03:00:28
Again, that is systems construction, interstate, primary, secondary, urban, through the formulas that are in law.
03:00:35
You can see it is the last bucket that gets filled.
03:00:38
Whatever's left from the top is what gets put there.
03:00:43
This is just a pie chart to show you how the allocations break down.
03:00:48
Debt service of your total revenue is about 6%.
03:00:51
Between earmarks and special financing and then highway systems construction, that's about 32% of the total.
03:00:58
But by and large, highway maintenance and operations are our two largest sources of spending.
03:01:06
The spending priorities that you've had for the last five years really have not changed.
03:01:13
Our way we put the budget together has not changed in the six-year financial plan.
03:01:18
Again, maintenance is 37% of the total budget, and that has grown more than 15% or $200 million since 2006.
03:01:28
For FY 2008, we are assuming 4.25% gross for that program and that's gross for VDOT maintenance as well as the city and county maintenance.
03:01:39
And then our out here assumption is 4%.
03:01:43
and those details are shown on page 13.
03:01:45
You can see the difference between the highway system maintenance that VDOT administered and then the payments to cities and counties.
03:01:52
And just to give you a comparative note, in 2005, FY 2005, VDOT maintenance was $994 million and county payments and city payments were $286 million.
03:02:05
That's the amount of growth you can see there in the last several years.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:02:11
Ms. Reese, maybe it would be a good idea to stop at this one point, the highway maintenance both statewide and to the localities, but if you stand back and look at House Bill 3202, it is worth remembering what we call the maintenance deficit.
03:02:26
In the current year, we're taking $450 million out of construction and into maintenance, and the revenues from House Bill 3202 will add a little over $200 million to those maintenance costs.
03:02:41
And that gap will continue to grow.
03:02:43
So this largest single element in the transportation program and the most rapidly growing is going to continue to be an ongoing
03:02:53
The House Bill 3-2, as we've said, is a great bill for transit and rail and regional funding.
03:03:02
But we still have a fundamental problem simply in paying for the operation and maintenance of our existing network.
03:03:11
And we're essentially borrowing from capacity improvements to do that.
03:03:16
And that's a short term and not a very sustainable form of borrowing at that.
03:03:21
So that issue will remain before us.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:03:23
Just to re-emphasize what the Secretary said, over the six-year period, I believe it's about $1.7 billion or so that is being taken from the construction fund and put back on to maintenance to fund those activities.
03:03:37
So it is a significant amount of money.
03:03:42
In terms of other VDOT spending or allocations that have been assumed in the Six-Year Financial Plan, we have assumed no growth at all in any of the other programs other than the legislatively approved pay increases.
03:03:56
State employees, all state employees did receive a 4% pay increase that will happen in FY2008, and there were some health benefits and retirement benefits that go along with that.
03:04:07
It's important to remember that VDOT's staff strength has been dropping dramatically.
03:04:12
Five years ago, I think we were around 11,000, and we're now down to about 8,700 employees, and that compares to about 9,100 employees July 1st of 2006.
03:04:23
And what you see, one result of that is if you go out on the dashboard and look at internal payroll expenses, that is one of the things under finance,
03:04:32
Our payroll expenses, even though there's been about a 10% pay increase overall for state employees in the last year, we are flat in terms of our payroll expenses.
03:04:44
We're not growing in terms of, even though costs are going up, we're staying flat as we have less employees.
03:04:50
And then the Land Development Program, as the Commissioner mentioned during the business plan, the whole implementation of 527 is still funded in this budget.
03:05:02
In terms of the working draft for the Six-Year Highway Improvement Program, and I guess the first thing I would say to all of you, it is definitely a draft program this year.
03:05:10
It is a working draft program.
03:05:12
As everybody has said, we actually have some money to spend.
03:05:17
Everybody is trying to step back and make sure the right decisions are being made.
03:05:22
There is $7.8 billion available for allocation for highway construction.
03:05:27
I would remind all of you that the law does allow you to decide to put highway funding toward transit.
03:05:34
O'Brien III, Michael A. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III
03:05:56
Packett, there is a listing of all the new projects in the Six-Year Program, as well as those regarding BRAC, which I'll talk about in a minute.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:07
The additional funding that has been- Could I just ask, is there any difference between what is at our desk and what we got in the mail?
03:06:14
No, ma'am, other than we were just making sure everybody had a copy.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:06:17
No, I just wanted to be sure I wasn't- Those spreadsheets, though, I'm going to include, are in the front of the one that was at your place today.
03:06:24
There are two spreadsheets at the very beginning of the book in the pocket on the front, along with another copy of the Secretary's letter.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:34
And if I might, because I know a lot of people say, where are the new projects?
03:06:39
This is for projects that are truly new, so if a project has been accelerated,
03:06:46
for construction.
03:06:48
It does not show up on this list.
03:06:50
So, you know, how you define what's a new project is very important.
03:06:56
And so there are projects that may have been showing either as approval towards construction or not going to construction until 2013 in the previous plan or 2012.
03:07:07
Now we'll be going to construction in the next 24 months, for example.
03:07:11
So be real careful in the characterization of this list.
03:07:16
There's a lot more in this program going on than just these 44 new projects.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:07:22
Right.
03:07:22
New means totally new to the program, not been in there before.
03:07:25
And if you look, if you can identify those when you get to the actual project, it'll have the words new project in bold up in the top right corner.
03:07:35
The additional funding that has been shown on projects in the working draft are basically to accelerate schedules on existing projects that you had already identified in the past as priorities.
03:07:48
The working draft that was sent to you last Friday only shows projects that have new funding allocated to them in FY 2008-13.
03:07:57
That was so to make sure you could focus on those.
03:08:00
The final will show all active projects.
03:08:02
We have a complete book available to you.
03:08:05
Mr.
03:08:05
Keen had asked for one.
03:08:06
He can show you the difference in the sides.
03:08:09
When you look at projects that were already in there that may not have new funding identified because they're winding up or already were fully funded, but he did ask for a full copy and you're welcome to get one.
03:08:21
You can let Diane Mitchell or Jamie Brown-Quarter know and they'll get you one before you leave tomorrow.
03:08:28
In terms of the approach that the Secretary and everyone has talked about, and this goes back to some of the previous discussions as well, what I think the, well I know what the Secretary would like to do by June is really take a multimodal approach to the Six-Year Program, and we have adopted
03:08:48
long-range plans and goals.
03:08:50
If you remember, Mrs. Connally headed up VTrans 2025.
03:08:54
There were a number of goals in there.
03:08:56
There are performance measures that are out there.
03:08:59
In general, you can talk about them as safe use of the network, maintaining and operating the existing network, maximizing efficient, effective use of it.
03:09:09
One of the things that we really were spending a lot of time on is looking at projects across, along the corridor and not necessarily within say for instance the Richmond District versus the Hampton Roads District when you're talking about I-64.
03:09:22
That we really need to think about the entire corridor and the Commissioner and the Chief Engineer are spearheading that and I'll talk a little bit about that in a minute.
03:09:30
And then also just continuing to seek partnerships to leverage other, whether it be private resources or local resources to move projects forward.
03:09:41
In the next couple weeks you should expect to see a straw man of a resolution for the board that has some goals.
03:09:48
It's important to note that there is $550 million in highway construction funding.
03:10:07
Mainly interstate funding and bonds that has not been allocated to specific projects in the working draft.
03:10:14
That is the amount of money, if you want to think about it as an average, a little less, about 80, 90 million dollars a year available that still has to be allocated before the end of June.
03:10:26
In terms of that, the CTB, we are asking you to have your input on the goals and priorities by June 2nd in order for the programming staff here to have time to get a final program put together.
03:10:40
The VDOT district administrators are working with the commissioner and secretary to consider corridor priorities.
03:10:47
Think about I-81, I-64, routes 28, 50, and route 7 in Northern Virginia.
03:10:56
Chief Engineer is leading the effort with the districts.
03:11:00
It is not a financial discussion.
03:11:04
I want to make that clear.
03:11:05
It's very much about what does make sense moving forward.
03:11:08
The finance staff will simply get the output of that and do the programming of individual dollars to them, but this is very much a transportation, engineering,
03:11:17
The criteria that the Commissioner asked the district administrators to think about and to try to shape their list, so to speak, were safety, congestion, and condition.
03:11:32
And that outcome, when those meetings are done, I think some of them are Monday and Tuesday of next week, will be given to you for your consideration and input.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:11:43
Mr. Chairman, one question, Barbara.
03:11:45
Is the $550,008,000
03:11:48
Is that across the entire...
03:11:50
It's across all six years.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:11:53
The other second list you had in the front of your notebook that was left for you was BRAC needs.
03:11:58
BRAC continues to be a hot topic of conversation and concern moving forward.
03:12:03
There's been $544 million worth of projects, costs that have been identified that would need, could potentially need to be funded to deal with BRAC.
03:12:14
And those range from the extension of the Fairfax County Parkway up in,
03:12:18
Fairfax County to signal improvements and transit facilities.
03:12:22
It is a broad range.
03:12:23
You can look at that list and see it.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:12:25
Does that list include those projects which have been certified for the DAR program, which we have before us?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:12:32
I believe so.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:12:34
For those who would, we would not need to cover those.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:12:36
Right.
03:12:36
Tom Farney is leading that effort and he's the one that actually put together this comprehensive list.
03:12:43
There's also a focus that we're trying to put on continuing federal projects.
03:12:48
You've got to remember it's still 50% of the program.
03:12:51
We have put in some line items to try to get some projects on the shelf.
03:12:56
One of our concerns is as we try to deal with federal obligation strategy, making sure we have some work that is ready to move to the next stage.
03:13:03
So you do see some line items for preliminary engineering.
03:13:07
And I wouldn't even call it preliminary engineering.
03:13:09
It's more about planning, NEPA.
03:13:11
All the work that needs to be done in order to develop a project.
03:13:15
There is some reallocation of the Northern Virginia district bond proceeds, again, just to maximize their use.
03:13:21
Some projects have moved up in schedule, some have moved down.
03:13:25
It's an annual process we go through.
03:13:28
In terms of the interstate system, reminder, because the interstate system is a federally financed program, you do not see significant increases there in terms of additional funding being put on the interstate system unless you make decisions to put the bond proceeds on interstate projects.
03:13:47
The good news in Northern Virginia is that Woodrow Wilson Bridge and Springfield are nearing their completion, so they're actually out here money that isn't having to be dedicated to those two mega projects,
03:13:57
It was strange looking at it and seeing you actually had zeros in 13 for those two projects.
03:14:04
There is $59 million proposed for a regional general construction engineering transportation management plan for the six mega projects in Northern Virginia in Fredericksburg.
03:14:14
Those projects are the Beltway in I-95, 395 Hot Lanes Project, Delos Rail, the Fourth Lane Winding on 95, the Fairfax County Parkway in Northern Virginia, and this is an area that we will call the Urban Partner Area.
03:14:30
We have asked for designation as an Urban Partner from the feds and we're waiting to hear whether or not we're one of the ones selected for that.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:14:37
As I looked through the book we received last week, when it came to the HOV hot lanes, I didn't see any funding in there for the PME in the out years.
03:14:49
Is that because it's reflected somewhere else?
03:14:52
Did I miss something?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:14:54
The 95-395, is that what you're talking about?
03:14:57
Yeah, HOV.
03:14:57
That was for the hot lanes project.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:15:00
Yeah, it was not in this particular book.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:15:02
Well, the good news is,
03:15:04
This afternoon, earlier today, the TRB, or TPB, excuse me, in Northern Virginia did vote to include it in the Constraint Long Range Plan.
03:15:15
So now we will...
03:15:16
So now those will gravitate... We will show some PE, but again, that is a privately financed...
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:15:21
Right.
03:15:22
No, I recognize.
03:15:22
So we have some portion of that.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:15:24
Right.
03:15:24
And because we don't have an agreed-to financial plan yet, you may not see a lot, but those projects are moving forward, and we're very excited about that vote today.
03:15:33
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_00
03:15:38
Mr. Reese, would you please explain to me, it says in Northern Virginia, Curtisburg District, Urban Partner Area.
03:15:48
Explain that to me, will you please.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:15:50
Let's see, I guess it was in March, maybe February of this year, the federal government, FHWA and the U.S. Department of Transportation is putting a major emphasis on congestion reduction.
03:16:04
And one of the things they've done is said, we are reaching out
03:16:08
to ask, and it doesn't have to be a state agency, it can be an MPO or someone else, to ask for what's called urban partner designation.
03:16:17
If you are, we applied for that designation, what that means is if there's funding available, we could get priority for that funding.
03:16:26
It doesn't bring funding with it.
03:16:28
So we submitted at the end of April.
03:16:31
We're urban partner designation.
03:16:33
What we included, and we can get you a copy of the application, are the boundaries of the Northern Virginia District, but then it comes down through Fredericksburg and goes down to about the Thornburg area.
03:16:47
Thank you so much, that sounds good.
03:17:10
In terms of the interstate system as well, there is increased funding to ITS activities, signals, guardrails, operations.
03:17:18
The truck climbing lanes in both Montgomery County and Rockbridge County have been funded.
03:17:24
FHWA agreements, one of the things that we continue to work toward is there were a number of agreements that may have been signed as early as the early 1990s that said, if you allow us to build this,
03:17:37
In turn, we'll also do this.
03:17:39
Well, some of these are still outstanding, and three of those that are major that are still outstanding that we're now trying to get off our books are I-581 Interchange and Sailing District.
03:17:49
That has a cost of $69 million.
03:17:51
I-95 at Route 630 in Fredericksburg, that's a $185 million interchange project.
03:17:59
I-64 in Richmond, which is out in western Hennewick County for $23 million.
03:18:05
Those we are funding to the extent that the money was feasible and available.
03:18:12
In terms of the primary system, we believe we have funded most of the CTB or all of the CTB primary system priorities that you had identified or that we had gotten information from the districts that were your priorities.
03:18:27
We do need you to confirm those lists.
03:18:29
The allocations for the primary system that you see on natural projects do address existing projects trying to move up their schedules.
03:18:37
You'll see a lot of cases when you look at the schedules on a project.
03:18:41
You might see construction in 2013, but now the project's fully funded in 2010.
03:18:46
So we need the districts to go back and reset schedules because now funding is available.
03:18:52
Some of the key ones you'll note in there are the Route 360 corridor in Richmond District
03:18:57
Route 29 corridor in Culpeper District, Mr. Davies, we have put the new corridor plan from basically around Route 6 up to Interstate 66 to look at that whole comprehensive corridor, and I know you're working on that.
03:19:12
Route 11 in Bristol District, a number of projects such as that.
03:19:16
Route 750 and 28 because there's so many things going on there.
03:19:21
We really want the district and the CTB members from that area to prioritize which of those projects are priorities because there's quite a few choices.
03:19:33
Page 23 may be the most important page in terms of your urban and secondary systems, the federal share of construction.
03:19:43
If you remember last year, if you look at 2007 on the graph at the top left, if you remember where you see that spike about federal share of construction was over 70%.
03:19:55
Last fiscal year, in terms of what was in the six-year program, if you remember, the graph was it continued to go up a little bit to where it was almost at 80%.
03:20:03
Basically, you had no discretionary state dollars left in the six-year program.
03:20:08
Happy to report that with 3202's passage, we have got that average share down to 48%.
03:20:14
So now you see it coming back together in the middle, which is basically where it really needs to be.
03:20:20
For the secondary and urban systems, where we were looking at 48% last year, their federal share of revenue will be down to an average of about 14%.
03:20:29
Eighty percent of their systems don't qualify for federal funds, so now they'll actually have some money to do some really good things on their system with state dollars.
03:20:42
Your next steps.
03:20:44
There are five public comment meetings beginning tonight through May 31st.
03:20:49
We do need your priorities including corridors and multi-modal goals by June 2nd.
03:20:55
You can send those and we'll put out a note to the Commissioner and Jamie Brown Porter to make sure all that gets incorporated.
03:21:03
Barbara W.
Jim D. Bowie
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:21:31
On the interstate, that's statewide rather than district allocations.
03:21:42
A couple of questions.
03:21:43
One area that bothers me so much is, for example, Exit 17, Interstate 81.
03:21:52
There's $58 million less allocated on that than there was last year.
03:21:58
It's going to be awfully hard to explain to the people who've been anxiously waiting for that.
03:22:04
It was removed from the six-year program when the comprehensive study of I-81 came about.
03:22:12
Finally got put back on.
03:22:15
The people in the Abingdon field that they have, and I think rightly so, feel they have a very serious congestion problem.
03:22:25
They're going to really be unhappy when they realize that not only are they not moving forward, but they're taking a huge step backwards.
03:22:34
Now, I assume that some of the money has been taken out to put on projects which can go forward immediately.
03:22:44
And if that's the case, what assurance are they going to have that it's going to be replaced when they get down the road a little ways?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:22:53
Well, number one, it hasn't been put anywhere.
03:22:56
If you remember the $550 million I mentioned is out there to be allocated remaining.
03:23:02
What we were, again, as I said, as we started putting this all together and we looked at it,
03:23:10
You know, those interchanges, for example, there's one in Salmon District at Route Exit 150, Troutville.
03:23:17
We pulled the construction funding off of that project as well because the Secretary has asked for everybody to step back, look at those corridors and say which are the priorities to make sure that before we put money toward construction of those that everybody agrees that that would be the priority from a corridor perspective.
03:23:35
So in the taste of I-81, there are two major interchange projects.
03:23:39
One is the one in Abington and the other one's in Troutville where it's not saying that by the time you do a final program that those funds won't be back there, but it's just saying rather than making a promise in the working draft that you may come back in the final and say, you know what?
03:23:56
This can't go to construction until FY11.
03:23:59
We don't need to put as much money on it in the next couple of years.
03:24:03
This is not setting any unrealistic expectations.
03:24:06
Same things happen on 64 in Richmond District, in Hampton Roads District, on projects in that corridor, 9 and 5, same thing.
03:24:15
Again, it's stepping back.
03:24:16
Commissioner and the Chief Engineer are working with the district administrators to gather data and information around those three criteria and they'll be working and then talking with you about what should be the priorities, all the board, and then sending it back to us for programming.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:24:33
Mr. Bowie, there's probably not an individual on the board that doesn't have a project they like on the interstate system that may appear in this draft to be a little bit less than where it was last year.
03:24:46
And last year, they were not fully funded.
03:24:48
But we're at a very important historical moment here, which is this is the first time in about eight years, certainly five, I can speak from personal experience, when we have not been cutting.
03:25:02
and we actually have an opportunity to make investment decisions.
03:25:05
It is very important that we make sure we're making the right ones.
03:25:10
The project you cited may very well be the priority of the board.
03:25:15
That's why there's $550 million set aside to do that.
03:25:19
But we owe it to the General Assembly and to the taxpayers to make sure that at this one moment, and this is just the interstate program, there are other issues in primary and secondary and urban and public transportation to make sure
03:25:34
at this moment that these funds are being properly spent and that it is the right party so for example in the 81 corridor you got truck climbing lanes there's the two interchanges there's spot safety improvements there are a lot of things in that quarter we ought to stand back at this point and say and ask the hard question is this the right thing that we're doing we've not had that luxury
03:25:55
I would say even though some of the folks in your district may be a little concerned about that, I would view this as an opportunity to make sure that the folks throughout the entire court are being well served.
03:26:13
This is going to be a hard discussion.
03:26:15
This is a statewide program.
03:26:16
But this is an historical moment and one that we do need to take full advantage of.
03:26:23
Mr. McCarthy.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:26:25
Mr. Chairman, do I understand you to say that, yes, there is $550 million to be allocated for priority needs, but as long as you're doing that to identify priorities, you're also
03:26:37
J. Michael A. Stevens III, Michael A. Stevens III, Michael A. Stevens III
03:26:49
to say, okay, the real priorities in 81 corridor are the real priorities in 64 corridor, 95 corridor.
03:26:57
That's the way you, okay.
03:26:58
I want to make sure I'm clear on that.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:27:00
And if I could just add one note too.
03:27:02
One of the interstate projects I mentioned like the truck climbing lanes or the ones that were the federal agreements, the only projects that are shown for construction
03:27:11
are those that have a federal requirement that truck-climbing lanes are an earmark.
03:27:16
We have no choice.
03:27:17
We are going to build truck-climbing lanes.
03:27:20
Same thing with the interchange in the Fredericksburg District, the one in Salem.
03:27:25
Those are the only ones in there.
03:27:26
I would also point out that we pulled no funding off of any project in the early years of the Six-Year Program.
03:27:32
PE and right-of-way in all cases are still funded.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:27:37
In terms of the project in the Fredericksburg region, it's my understanding from the engineers that part of the reconstruction of that will be driven by, it would be required to be done because of the HOV hot banks coming through.
03:27:49
The current one will not be able to remain when those come through.
03:27:55
Is it possible for any of the costs for the construction of that
03:27:59
We're hoping on that.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:28:05
I actually, I think Mr. Ogle was here.
03:28:08
I asked for that information.
03:28:09
I know he's working with the chief engineer.
03:28:11
So that is some of the considerations.
03:28:13
We have the same situation on the Capital Beltway where we had work in there at 66 at the interchange.
03:28:20
And looking now to see, we already probably enveloped that into the Hot Links project as well.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:28:26
If that happens, I mean, what part would we still be responsible for funding?
03:28:30
Is it the P.E.
03:28:31
right of way?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:28:31
That's all in negotiation.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:28:35
Just a logistical question.
03:28:40
Is there any facility for videotaping or anything, the public hearings that are going to go on over the next few weeks, any possibility that for those of us who can only get to maybe one or two of them, we'll be able to get a DVD or something so that we can actually see the ones that were not
03:29:01
A written record, yes
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:29:16
Yes, we are transcribing.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:29:18
And we will make some kind of recording, whether video or DVD, available?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:29:25
It won't be video, but we are doing transcripts.
03:29:28
We have a court recorder here that will transcribe the entire meeting, so we meet all of our federal and public hearing requirements.
Peter B. Schwartz
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:29:34
Is it possible that there will be, if not a visual and audio, Barbara?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:29:39
I know they asked about that for tonight, and I don't think we set it up for tonight.
03:29:43
We can look about the others, but we are definitely doing written transcripts.
03:29:48
And the other thing is you have to remember there's lots of comments we get in through the email system or in writing that we'll also put together.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:29:57
Mr. Chairman, one last comment.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:30:00
Barbara, we're going to miss your comments as CFO in the future, which we have referred to as Reese's Pieces.
03:30:11
But you posed an interesting set of policy questions ahead on your slide 10, which I think it's remarkable the transportation package.
03:30:19
The second is the earmarks and special financing category is pretty healthy in the out years and does that set up an alternate CTB allocation formula of some kind or eventually
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:30:37
Mr. Koelemay, remember last year 2007 numbers are final.
03:30:44
If you remember what I said, if you look at the 08 through 13, some of the things that are still up in earmarks in special financing such as CMAQ money, STP regional,
03:30:55
There's bonds about $80 to $100 million a year.
03:30:58
The TPOF, the $305 million, all that will end up down in that highway construction line by the final.
03:31:04
But for right now, because it hasn't been allocated to a specific project, the earmarks and special finding is sort of the holding category.
03:31:12
So that number, it may not come back down to $340 million, but it will come much closer to that.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:31:18
Okay.
03:31:18
Well, we'll look forward to your deputy secretary comments too.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
03:31:21
Okay.
03:31:21
Thank you.
03:31:22
Sure.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:31:22
Okay, any other questions before we hear from Mr. Badger?
03:31:25
Welcome, Mr. Badger.
03:31:26
You're going to walk us through the Rail and Public Transportation draft.
Charles M. Badger
Director of Public Transportation
03:31:32
Yes, Mr. Chairman, I am very cognizant of the time.
03:31:34
Yes, I will do this as quickly as I possibly can.
03:31:38
We start with the first data slide here.
03:31:41
This slide is what we call the before and after slide.
03:31:43
This shows you what the revenue forecast for Rail and Public Transportation looked like
03:31:49
Before this session, the General Assembly and the special appropriations that were made has to carry what came out and the essence of this slide is a bold blue banner across the top that says transit and rail revenue forecast increased by 45% as a result of the events in place of the General Assembly session this year.
03:32:09
There is no good news indeed for rail and public transportation.
03:32:13
This slide shows the one-year comparison for rail funding.
03:32:19
This is fiscal year 07 versus fiscal year 08.
03:32:21
The big news, of course, is the special appropriation of $65 million for rail capital projects.
03:32:27
Likewise, we also have the start of rail bond funding for rail capital projects, providing a grand total increase of $77 million in additional funding that will be available for fiscal year 08.
03:32:41
As compared to what we had in fiscal year 07.
03:32:45
The projects that are obtained in the Six-Year Program, there's four categories.
03:32:49
We have the Rail Enhancement Fund.
03:32:52
The only projects that will appear in your draft program at this point in time is a continuation of three projects that have received funding previously.
03:33:00
They'll consume about $12 million and about $17 million if you roll forward into fiscal year 09, and we anticipate coming in with an additional slate of projects with this program.
03:33:10
We do have the $65 million in special appropriation that will support rail corridor improvements in the I-95 and I-81 corridors.
03:33:20
We have seven projects shown for the rail preservation program.
03:33:23
Those are listed in the program.
03:33:26
And for the rail capital bond projects, we have two projects.
03:33:29
One is the rail preservation type project and the other one is rail enhanced.
03:33:35
This is what the funding outlook looks like for rail public transportation.
03:33:39
The big news, obviously, again, is the $65 million special appropriated in fiscal year 2008.
03:33:44
But what's really shifted is if you compare the FY07 number to the FY09, that's the year that the rail bond fund money comes in at full measure, and you're looking at about a $13 million increase.
03:33:57
So it's a very substantial increase in our rail program, and we'll be looking forward to finding projects and programming those funds.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:34:05
And if one went back two years, it would be about three million dollars a year, correct?
03:34:10
Just that little green bar at the bottom, that's where we were two years ago in real funding.
Charles M. Badger
Director of Public Transportation
03:34:16
This is the transit comparison, fiscal year 07 versus 08.
03:34:20
Again, we did have a very significant special appropriation of $70 million of earned debt.
03:34:26
A number of different projects, and we have the first allocation of transit bond funds of $20 million that we're awarding to projects this year.
03:34:35
This represents an increase of $97 million in one year for transit capital.
03:34:40
This is very significant and something we're very excited about.
03:34:46
This slide shows the budgeted transit operating expenses for fiscal year 2008 as compared to what was budgeted for fiscal year 2007.
03:34:58
What you're looking at is about 11% increase in total expenses.
03:35:02
Most of this is being driven by the increase in fuel prices, but it also has to do with health insurance and a number of other cost factors and some service expansions.
03:35:11
The bar is there that you see.
03:35:14
The blue is the operating revenue.
03:35:16
That increases also at about 11 percent.
03:35:19
The state funds, the green, are increasing by about $8 million.
03:35:25
Federal funds go up a little bit.
03:35:27
And, of course, the locals pick up the balance.
03:35:30
The general distribution of shares between revenue, state, federal, and local are about the same in the two fiscal years.
03:35:38
The bar across the top, what that represents is the $113 million that we have in state funds will support about 42% of the eligible operating costs transit systems will incur in fiscal year 08.
03:35:52
That's about the same percent that we did this year.
03:35:56
On the capital side, we have a much larger capital program.
03:36:01
It's about $105 million greater than this year, 2008 than it was in 2007.
03:36:08
Most of that is due to the special allocations, the rolling stock improvements for WMATA, VRE, and Hampton Roads Transit.
03:36:18
We also have the first full funding year for the Hampton Roads Light Rail Project in the mix.
03:36:26
Big news here, of course, is the increase in state funding.
03:36:30
This, again, is about a $94 million increase from one year to the next.
03:36:35
Bottom line for the local governments, you can see that even though we have $105 million more in capital projects, they'll only be asked to come up with a much smaller number, about $49 million less in fiscal year 08 than they were in fiscal year 07.
03:36:54
This is how the money will be spent.
03:36:55
These are the major categories of spending that you'll find in the 2008 program.
03:37:00
Of course, the big consumer funds is the Vermont Assistant, the Metro Matters program.
03:37:06
They also have debt service that they make payments on, and we have the rolling stock.
03:37:10
Allecation.
03:37:12
The others are Hampton Roads.
03:37:14
Again, the light rail program kicks in in earnest in the fiscal year 08.
03:37:18
ERE is in a big position for clearing rolling stock.
03:37:24
We're buying 147 replacement buses and vans next year, 42 buses and vans to expand service, and then we're improving 34 bus facilities.
03:37:34
That's what makes up in a nutshell $447 million in capital expenses.
03:37:41
Here's the outlook for transit operators.
03:37:45
As you can see, beginning in fiscal year 09, we'll begin to receive state recordation tax funds into the operating fund.
03:37:54
That's a very substantial increase, especially from fiscal year 07 up to fiscal year 09.
03:37:59
But we're cautioning our transit systems that they should not assume that they're automatically going to see that much of an increase in their state grant.
03:38:09
We're going to be implementing a maintenance of effort provision, which means that we're going to expect that the transit systems will receive as much local support for operating in fiscal year 09 as they did in fiscal year 07.
03:38:25
This will keep the new money from simply replacing local time distributions.
03:38:31
Now, obviously, they're going to receive larger grants, but it may not be the full increase that you see there.
03:38:37
The intent is to encourage transit service expansions.
03:38:41
The net effect will be to help them out with the costs as they increase for fuel prices and other inflationary factors.
03:38:48
They will receive more state aid to cover those, and they'll receive more state aid to cover any service expansion that they offer.
03:38:55
So in the early years of the program, it may be that some of these funds will actually spill over into the capital program.
03:39:03
On the capital side, again, we have a very large special appropriation in fiscal year 2008.
03:39:09
These are the bond funds.
03:39:13
Excuse me, this is the special appropriation.
03:39:16
In fiscal year 2009, the bond funds kick in at about $60 million a year.
03:39:22
That's an ongoing fund, at least throughout the six-year program we're looking at.
03:39:29
Very significant about this is that the bond funds will go into a separate funding program than our regular mass transit capital support.
03:39:39
And that special program, we can allocate, the board can allocate grants at an 80% state share.
03:39:45
As most of you know, the regular state aid is allocated on a floating scale, and it matches then all over the place.
03:39:52
It's as low as 22 percent this year, and for fiscal year 2018, it is as high as 52 percent.
03:40:00
So it'll be up to us to determine exactly which projects would be assigned funding under which programs.
03:40:09
We have not attempted to program $60 million in fiscal year 2009 and beyond into capital projects.
03:40:17
However, we are receiving $20 million in fiscal year 2008 and we have assigned those funds to capital projects.
03:40:27
The way we did that, we received word on this fairly late in the game, so we really had to select projects from applications that we already had in hand.
03:40:37
And we only had $20 million, so we had to make some decisions on how we were going to divide this money up.
03:40:44
Here's what we did.
03:40:45
First of all, we decided that any transit system that was getting special appropriation would not be eligible for these bond funds.
03:40:52
That was WMATA, VRE, and Hampton Roads.
03:40:56
Then we came up with some criteria for selecting capital projects that would receive the bond funding.
03:41:02
That's what's identified in this slide.
03:41:06
Since the projects were supported with bond funds, there are certain things that we could not support such as debt service on other bonds, leases for facilities and vehicles, and we also determined that whatever we purchased with these funds needed to have a significant useful life.
03:41:24
So other items fell out such as preventative maintenance, office equipment, spare parts, items like that.
03:41:31
And finally we determined that we didn't have enough money to fund all the facility projects that we would like to, so we restricted the funding to only those facility projects that received federal funds.
03:41:43
That got us down to where we could allocate all $20 million and we believe we came up with a pretty equitable distribution.
03:41:50
So the projects that received the $20 million was funded at an 80% state share, and the projects that received the regular state aid, as I mentioned, will receive a 52% state share for fiscal year 2008.
03:42:04
Now very quickly, I want to take you through what you will see in the Six-Year Program.
03:42:10
I'm guessing that some of the newer members may be looking at our section of the Six-Year Program for the first time, and I thought I would just highlight the major sections and explain to you what it is that you'll be looking at.
03:42:21
These are the five sections.
03:42:24
The first section occurs with this first page of our program.
03:42:28
We're in the back of the six-year program, so our first page is page 445 of the working draft that you have in front of us.
03:42:38
This page identifies all of the funding sources that are allocated by this board.
03:42:43
This includes both state funds for public transportation, state funds for rail, federal funds for public transportation, and we break it out by fiscal year.
03:42:54
That's the sum of money that you're actually awarding as grants this year.
03:42:59
We also do identify a six-year projection of all the allocated revenues.
03:43:04
And as you can see, we have almost $3 billion in revenues that will be going towards failing public transportation in the next six years.
03:43:15
The next section of the program is the district section and in here you'll find each public transportation system, commuter assistance agency, human service agency identified by the district that is located and you'll see exactly the funds that are allocated to that system.
03:43:35
This includes the funds that are allocated by you, and it will also show funds that they may be receiving directly.
03:43:41
For example, the Greater Richmond Transit System gets money straight from the Federal Transit Administration, and even though they aren't programmed by this board, they do appear in here, so you can see the total picture for funding for GRTC.
03:43:57
Then we have a section where we have 12 tables that show the programs themselves.
03:44:02
The intent here is to show you how the money is distributed within each program.
03:44:08
This is where you'll find the rail projects list.
03:44:10
They don't actually appear in the district allocations, but they do appear project by project back in the rail tables.
03:44:18
All of the other funds will be contained back in the district allocations.
03:44:22
This just pulls them out by program and shows you how they were distributed.
03:44:28
Then we have the Six-Year Capital Program, or what I should really call Supplemental Five.
03:44:35
The first year of capital projects appears as grants, and then for the next five years we show tentative allocations.
03:44:43
There's an arrow on this slide that's supposed to refer to fiscal year 09 and 10.
03:44:48
I apologize for that, but just notice that as I was reviewing my remarks.
03:44:52
The intent here is to show what projects we're anticipating over the next six years and a preliminary allocation of federal and state funds to support those projects.
03:45:07
For next year, our challenge is going to be to bring in a lot of different components into our grants-making process.
03:45:16
We'll be launching our Trans Capital Asset Management project.
03:45:21
That's certainly going to provide us with a more detailed and complete list of capital projects over the next five years.
03:45:28
We're going to be developing a transit sustainability plan which will help us deal with requests for major new projects.
03:45:36
We need to take a good hard look at it and make sure that the benefits are there to warrant investment.
03:45:41
We'll also be looking at the public benefit analysis that you heard about.
03:45:45
We'll be taking a look at the benefits that our projects are bringing to the state.
03:45:51
And then we do need to develop priorities and procedures for the use of bond funds over the long term.
03:45:59
As I mentioned, we have not programmed the bond funds in fiscal year 2009 and beyond, so we need to come up with policies and procedures to do that.
03:46:08
In closing, I wanted to let you know that as I did last year, I'll be contacting each one of you individually to see if you have any questions on our section of the program.
03:46:18
I'll be happy to come out and meet with you individually and go over the program and explain anything that you might not understand and answer any questions that you might have.
03:46:27
And with that, Mr. Chairman, I'm done.
03:46:30
Under the wire.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:46:32
Thank you, Mr. Badger.
03:46:33
Are there questions, brief questions or
03:46:35
Comments?
03:46:36
Ms. Tucker, do you want to?
Matthew O. Tucker
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:46:37
Yeah, I just do want to make the comment that again, our program is our recommended program.
03:46:42
Under the code, it does prescribe in terms of how the vast majority of DRPT funds are allocated in terms of 75, 73%, 23%, and one and a half percent.
03:46:53
Where we're absolutely seeking the recommendation outside of what we're required to do under the code is, for example, how we chose to distribute the $20 million in bond funds.
03:47:05
So our presentation is our recommendation, and we are open to feedback.
03:47:10
I'm sure we're going to get it.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:47:12
Real briefly, BRE commuter and regular commuter launch, where would they be funded?
03:47:16
Through DRPT or are they separated out?
Charles M. Badger
Director of Public Transportation
03:47:19
BRE will appear in the Northern Virginia District.
Cord A. Sterling
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:47:22
So BRE would be in here.
03:47:23
What about those associated with the interstate system?
03:47:26
Those would be in the other?
03:47:27
Commuter rail lines are not in our curriculum.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:47:31
VDOT said they assumed a 4% increase in maintenance costs as part of their estimates.
03:47:37
Did you have a similar growth number in your budget for operating expenses?
Charles M. Badger
Director of Public Transportation
03:47:44
The operating estimates that we got came directly from the transit system, so we allowed them to provide us with their own estimates.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:47:54
Okay, thank you.
03:47:55
And by way of apology and also introduction, I neglected in my introduction Mr. Badger to announce that Governor Kaine has appointed Mr. Badger as the Chief Deputy of the Department of Rail and Public Transportation just this last month.
03:48:13
I closed it three weeks ago now.
03:48:15
So I want to say, Chip, you've done great work for the department and you've got a whole lot more on your plate and congratulations.
03:48:22
Thank you.
03:48:29
Thank you.
03:48:30
We're going to go into the public comment session in just a minute.
03:48:33
I would like to give for those folks who are here for the public commentary tonight just a couple of thoughts.
03:48:39
The first is that the draft program that you have in front of you is very much a draft.
03:48:45
We've talked about the $550 million that has not been allocated.
03:48:50
That's a significant sum of money and will provoke some interesting conversation and discussion among us.
03:48:57
Secondly, this is a homework.
03:49:05
We are getting homework assignments right now.
03:49:08
Your first and most important assignment is to go back and review the primary system allocations.
03:49:15
And I would strongly encourage the district members to make sure that you consult with your at-large colleagues in that process.
03:49:23
But that's the one thing that I think can be done in a relatively quick time frame to make sure that that work is done because we have some very hard choices and a lot of discussion on the interstate system.
03:49:37
Second point I would make to you as you communicate to the jurisdictions, whether they're counties, cities, or towns, is if you look at where the real expansion in funding is in this transportation program, it is in secondary and urban.
03:49:53
And that decision-making process will unfold.
03:49:56
almost immediately on the urban system, but over the next several months for secondary.
03:50:02
So in terms of managing the expectations of your localities, particularly for counties, they do their public hearings typically November, December, January timeframe.
03:50:12
So they have a little bit of time, which in some cases is good, in other cases bad, depending upon the circumstances.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:50:19
Mr. Secretary, could you just clarify in the primary system allocations, do you mean we can only shift around or we can say certain things need more money on them and we don't have to find it within our own district?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:50:37
No, the primary allocations are set by district.
Julia A. Connally
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:50:40
That's right.
03:50:41
And so it is a shifting around.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:50:43
That's correct.
03:50:43
So it would be for projects within the district and establishing those priorities.
03:50:49
That's the one thing and probably the single most important task for you all to talk to the district administrators, you know, listen to the public hearings and try and nail down the primary allocations as quickly as possible.
03:51:03
Okay?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:51:03
The last thing, and this is really more of an observation, because this is new to all of us.
03:51:08
I've never done an addition six-year program, but this may wind up proving the old adage, it's a whole lot easier to cut a budget than it is to add one.
03:51:19
And we have, I think, by that measure, a great deal more work to do this year than we've become accustomed to in the last several years.
03:51:25
So stay in touch.
03:51:28
Pick up the phone.
03:51:29
If you have questions, feel free to talk to your colleagues.
03:51:32
The one thing, again, because particularly on the interstate, we do not do blast emails to people.
03:51:39
That is not in concert with the opening.
03:51:41
It's okay to have one-on-one conversations with people, but it is not appropriate for there to be email conversations among the board as a whole.
03:51:49
That has to be done in a public meeting in a public setting.