Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Workshop and Action Meeting 3/14/2007
  • Auto-scroll

Workshop and Action Meeting   3/14/2007

Attachments
  • Workshop and meeting agendas.html
  • Board actions.html
  • Meeting minutes.pdf
  • Workshop minutes.pdf
  • Legislative update.pdf
  • DRPT director's report.pdf
  • Transportation Accountability Commission update.pdf
  • Dashboard 3.0.pdf
  • Richmond Highway-Telegraph Road connector.pdf
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      At this point, I would like to call the order of the March business meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:09
      And we will open as is our custom with public comment.
    • 00:00:13
      I know Mr. Schwartz wanted to address the board.
    • 00:00:15
      Is there anybody else who wants to address the board under citizens' time?
    • 00:00:19
      Welcome, Mr. Schwartz.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:00:24
      Mr. Chairman, all members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board, I see what you support us on the executive director of the Commonwealth Development Corporation, Steve Perrin, Jay Kim.
    • 00:00:36
      I'm here to represent the Community Motivation Network and the regionally constipated voters.
    • 00:00:41
      I'm relevant to the board's contribution to the great active discussion on the language and the state bill that has been involved.
    • 00:00:44
      I want to begin by thanking the Secretary, Mr. Carr, for her work on the use of legislation on the subject of trade, taxes, and management, and the general performance standards.
    • 00:01:00
      I think that is a huge accomplishment.
    • 00:01:01
      I'd also like to note that the administration's authority of financial reporting, so that we were interested in, though it weren't sponsored, which would allow us to track year-to-year actual spending, county-wide accounting, and by all means, regional and federal spending categories.
    • 00:01:14
      I think that will help, particularly when our seniors in this state secure program answers in the following part of the public.
    • 00:01:26
      All of what actually is happening from here to here, because we need to manage to put our Six-Year Plan forward so we don't have to get sort of a tracking of how we're doing, taken by various fellows and by various jurisdictions.
    • 00:01:32
      On the performance standards, I want to return to what you said yesterday, and I echo the need for a key conversation with both in the accountability process and the performance standards of development.
    • 00:01:52
      And I don't want to put it more in the very hard work of the CTB members to put it into the policy chapters and the goals of this maintenance project.
    • 00:01:56
      Most of that should inform any refinement of the accountability standards that take place now.
    • 00:01:59
      I'd also add some land we could add, and we're a smart boat community, to be the accountability and mission of the black communities.
    • 00:02:13
      One financial issue that I'll raise with you, I don't know if you've read previously, but several government agencies sending some spending already, I think it's $70 million plus for Virginia and $56 million plus for Maryland.
    • 00:02:19
      I'm hoping that the precision is done like last year that is shared fairly and fairly across each of the program categories and that we don't need to take that as just mitigation air quality or enhancements or RSPP.
    • 00:02:36
      Regarding the budget, the final $9.10 general fund dollars,
    • 00:02:38
      We, you know, very bad about the real hands-on fund and commitment to transit over the ball, but we want to know our concern that in the end our transit share of the fund, you know, that doesn't mean standard 14.7% share, that it gets to be the trust fund, almost, that's about 12%, and other 560% goes to the E.T.T.A.
    • 00:03:02
      right next to the transportation partnership opportunity fund.
    • 00:03:04
      We've been very concerned about the use of the PPCA if we're not getting enough private dollars.
    • 00:03:17
      There's not a total cost.
    • 00:03:19
      That's what you would expect from a review by a Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:03:22
      So it could reasonably be argued that the 500 million could have gone to a centralized fund and it's homeless with the addition of real-time insurance funds and dollars.
    • 00:03:26
      The next comment I have is regarding 3202 that you've been wrestling with.
    • 00:03:37
      And in terms of the regional funding, I think one of the important things to know about Northern Virginia is they now have a prioritization criteria for their priority selection.
    • 00:03:47
      They know they can afford their 2030 plan and they have land use, multi-wall type criteria in selection and they should be amended for that.
    • 00:03:50
      That same criteria I don't think has been developed for Hampton Roads and we remain concerned that the Hampton Roads game exists on external bypass highways up to 460 in the southeastern rather than dealing with extensive criteria congestion for prioritizing that difficult and, yes, challenging politically issue of crossing from Hampton to James.
    • 00:04:09
      Our biggest issue, I think, whether it's bond for gas tax, whether it's spend, is are there project priorities that are being set?
    • 00:04:17
      And this is something CTB can go back and reevaluate.
    • 00:04:20
      Many of them are projects that have, yes, approved, but we have findings about them.
    • 00:04:27
      We started with the new 460.
    • 00:04:28
      It appears to be popular with some officials, but we can't understand every source of the same environment, why we was able to do highway parallel to the one that we had to leave us with surface A in 2030.
    • 00:04:40
      Yes, there are backups in traffic lights, but there are ways to deal with those.
    • 00:04:44
      There are plenty of us who weren't caught in traffic, including roundabouts.
    • 00:04:46
      The traffic for today is 10,000 mables per day, which is maybe $4,000.
    • 00:04:58
      This is the name of the city and county here.
    • 00:05:01
      $60,000, $10,000, $12,000,000 in public money for $1.5 million in private.
    • 00:05:03
      So that is a question of priority for the amount of money we have.
    • 00:05:05
      We quite want that to become a very important part of the Hampton Roads plan.
    • 00:05:08
      I do want to commend you on your resolution there, and we want you to continue oversight because we can't afford to buy the whole thing.
    • 00:05:15
      We want you to be a part of it, and we're part of the solution to get appropriate.
    • 00:05:20
      There are other issues in North Virginia.
    • 00:05:24
      We don't understand why the Tri-County Parkway was approved and it's been made a priority when we still have the rest who would like to sit outside the beltway.
    • 00:05:33
      Who then studies what we've been sitting on the shelf for the past few years as we now move forward?
    • 00:05:38
      Probably one of the most critical congestion corridors in the region.
    • 00:05:40
      One other one on our CT system side of the pathway, with a big perturbation from multiple officials in addition to the citizenry that we very much want them to have to work on solution widening without adequately looking at the range of all furniture.
    • 00:05:56
      And finally, in terms of sports and doing H.O.B.
    • 00:06:02
      in local directions.
    • 00:06:05
      Or increasing the H.O.B.
    • 00:06:06
      from a small H.O.B.
    • 00:06:07
      2 number to H.O.B.
    • 00:06:08
      3, about 95, and testing how that performs before we go to high quality of the lightning.
    • 00:06:14
      And the next step would be to make that your, how to explain your H.O.T.
    • 00:06:18
      test test if you have a casual audience.
    • 00:06:21
      We can see hot lanes and congestion pricing will truly work in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:06:31
      So these are projects we would love to have you re-evaluate.
    • 00:06:34
      We are in a resource-trained environment.
    • 00:06:36
      We do get the new money.
    • 00:06:38
      And we really have to do a better job of linking things to transportation.
    • 00:06:42
      We need to be able to model travel.
    • 00:06:43
      We would like you to serve your planning role in your authority office because, like you did in the pre-trans process.
    • 00:06:52
      Lastly, and I think it is very serious, to have private interview projects, do call us.
    • 00:06:58
      Fundamentally, we look to the party for resetting and making sure we are providing a multi-modal system that is energy efficient that will allow us to remain economically competitive.
    • 00:07:09
      So thank you for your time and for the little support I wanted to give.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:12
      Thank you.
    • 00:07:12
      Thank you, Mr. Schwartz.
    • 00:07:16
      Anybody else want to address the CTB under public comment?
    • 00:07:22
      If not, is there a motion to approve the minutes?
    • 00:07:24
      So moved.
    • 00:07:25
      Second?
    • 00:07:26
      Second.
    • 00:07:27
      All in favor?
    • 00:07:28
      Aye.
    • 00:07:29
      Item number one under the Asset Management Division, Mr. Quentin Elliott is here to answer any questions on the abandonment and discontinuances.
    • 00:07:41
      There's one in Lynchburg and one in Culpeper District.
    • 00:07:44
      Any questions?
    • 00:07:46
      Mr. Elliott, is there a motion for approval?
    • 00:07:50
      Is there a second?
    • 00:07:53
      All in favor?
    • 00:07:55
      Action item two is on a change in the primary system.
    • 00:08:01
      I'd like to take these separately.
    • 00:08:03
      2A is a Henry County for the frontage road.
    • 00:08:07
      Are there any questions of Mr. Elliott?
    • 00:08:11
      I move to approve.
    • 00:08:13
      Second.
    • 00:08:14
      All in favor?
    • 00:08:15
      Aye.
    • 00:08:16
      Action item 2B in York County, which is an abandonment of a frontage road.
    • 00:08:22
      Are there any questions of Mr. Elliott?
    • 00:08:24
      Move approval.
    • 00:08:26
      Second.
    • 00:08:26
      All in favor?
    • 00:08:28
      Aye.
    • 00:08:30
      Action item 3A and again I think given the community action here we'll take these up individually.
    • 00:08:36
      Action item 3A is the naming route 612 bridge in Scott County.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:08:43
      Move approval.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:44
      Second.
    • 00:08:45
      All in favor?
    • 00:08:46
      Aye.
    • 00:08:47
      Action item 3B is the naming of the Occoquan River footbridge, and I would just note, as an editorial comment, I've lived just a couple blocks from that.
    • 00:08:57
      It's a lovely little asset in Northern Virginia, and this is a nice tribute to a good man.
    • 00:09:05
      Is there a motion?
    • 00:09:06
      I'll move it to approval, Mr.
    • 00:09:07
      Chair.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:07
      All in favor?
    • 00:09:11
      Action item 3C is the naming of the US Route 58 bypass bridge in Henry County.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:09:18
      All in favor?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:22
      Action item 3D is the naming of the 58, Route 58 bridge over Indian Creek.
    • 00:09:28
      in Lee County.
    • 00:09:29
      All in favor?
    • 00:09:32
      And lastly, Action Item 3E is the naming of the bridge carrying Bond Street over Route 360 in the town of South Boston.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:09:41
      Mr. Cameron, I want to thank Carol and Quentin and his staff for adding this at a relatively late date.
    • 00:09:48
      This was something that came after the internal deadline within the department and getting materials to us.
    • 00:09:55
      I want to thank them for it.
    • 00:09:56
      All in favor?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:01
      Aye.
    • 00:10:02
      Action item 4, Mr. Waimack is here to answer any questions.
    • 00:10:09
      Let's take these up individually.
    • 00:10:11
      Any questions on action item 4A in the City of Winchester?
    • 00:10:16
      Mr. J. Lou Brutal, Secretary.
    • 00:10:18
      All in favor?
    • 00:10:21
      Aye.
    • 00:10:21
      Action item 4B is on Route 20 in Albemarle County.
    • 00:10:26
      Move approval.
    • 00:10:28
      Second.
    • 00:10:28
      All in favor?
    • 00:10:30
      Aye.
    • 00:10:31
      Action item 4C on Route 460 in Buchanan County.
    • 00:10:35
      Move approval.
    • 00:10:36
      Second.
    • 00:10:37
      All in favor?
    • 00:10:39
      Aye.
    • 00:10:40
      Action item 4D for Route 714 and 29 in Campbell County.
    • 00:10:45
      Move approval.
    • 00:10:46
      Second.
    • 00:10:47
      All in favor?
    • 00:10:48
      Aye.
    • 00:10:49
      And action item 4E, we have a substitute resolution at places.
    • 00:10:56
      Mr. Waynick, if you could make a brief presentation and then if there are any questions.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:11:00
      The substitute is with role of the parent with certain conditions on the band, that is the entrance to a 20-degree field, as you can see, there's some construction.
    • 00:11:08
      Are there any questions, Mr. Wayman?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:31
      All in favor?
    • 00:11:34
      Aye.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:35
      Action item five is a limited access control chain on Route 11 in Frederick County.
    • 00:11:42
      Are there any questions?
    • 00:11:43
      Mr. Waymack?
    • 00:11:44
      Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:11:46
      I second.
    • 00:11:47
      All in favor?
    • 00:11:49
      Aye.
    • 00:11:50
      Thank you, Mr. Waymack.
    • 00:11:52
      Action Item 6.
    • 00:11:55
      Linda Cheatham is here to answer any questions on the Six-Year Improvement Program transfers.
    • 00:12:00
      I just want to make sure there are no questions, these transfers getting increased.
    • 00:12:06
      The later we get in the federal fiscal year, the more complicated these transfers become.
    • 00:12:11
      Are there any questions on Ms. Cheatham?
    • 00:12:15
      Is there a motion?
    • 00:12:16
      Move to approve.
    • 00:12:17
      Second.
    • 00:12:18
      All in favor?
    • 00:12:19
      Aye.
    • 00:12:19
      Thank you, Ms. Cheatham.
    • 00:12:22
      All right.
    • 00:12:23
      Action item seven.
    • 00:12:26
      Welcome once again, Mr. Morrison.
    • 00:12:29
      This action item seven and eight are connected.
    • 00:12:33
      The first is a location decision.
    • 00:12:36
      Action item eight is actually a memorandum of agreement memorializing the understandings that we discussed yesterday in work session and again for the benefit for those who were unable to be with us yesterday.
    • 00:12:50
      It has been now six years that we've been working on this relatively, at least to the average citizen, they would say these are simple, easy issues.
    • 00:13:02
      Working with the Army, Mr. Sterling, is challenging.
    • 00:13:06
      It takes time.
    • 00:13:07
      When you have an adjacent historic property, you have national security issues all combined, and these are very difficult.
    • 00:13:16
      So we'll take up Action Item 7, which is the location approval on the Richmond Highway-Telegraph Road connector.
    • 00:13:26
      All in favor?
    • 00:13:28
      Aye.
    • 00:13:28
      If I might just add, Mr. Secretary, I don't think that many people around here realize the amount of work and negotiations that you and your staff have had to put in on this particular issue.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:13:36
      It has not been easy since they closed the existing road, getting the Army and the Historical Society and everybody on board is certainly not been an easy process and commend you on getting that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:48
      Thank you for your assistance.
    • 00:13:50
      Action item 8 is the approval of the memorandum of agreement and
    • 00:13:55
      As I understand, one of the key factors in that, Mr. Morrison, is if there are additional access points required on these roads.
    • 00:14:02
      And this is an access management type of issue that those would require concurrence of VDOT, correct?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:14:10
      Yes, sir.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:13
      Any questions?
    • 00:14:14
      Is there a motion?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:16
      I'll move this approval.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:18
      Second.
    • 00:14:18
      All in favor?
    • 00:14:19
      Aye.
    • 00:14:20
      Thank you.
    • 00:14:22
      Thank you.
    • 00:14:23
      We now come to scheduling and contracting.
    • 00:14:27
      Mr. Silas will be here for Mr. Coburn.
    • 00:14:29
      Is this a good month?
    • 00:14:31
      Mr. Silas?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:14:34
      Yes, it is a good month.
    • 00:14:41
      Secretary, so as you can see, if you look at the ballot, we didn't discuss any more competition that we had in the ballot design last year anyway.
    • 00:14:48
      So I have seven projects to bring before you today.
    • 00:14:51
      The first project is the concrete pager repairs asphalt overlay on Interstate 295, the original area.
    • 00:15:01
      We have three bidders, which is pretty good for this type of project, so we have to do the competition.
    • 00:15:08
      We got what we think is a real reason for this, so we will recommend the board for that project.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:15:14
      Move it.
    • 00:15:14
      Second.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:15:15
      Donald Taylor.
    • 00:15:16
      Aye.
    • 00:15:16
      John Haynes.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:15:18
      Moving now to the City of Danville project, and you can see the list when we have seven vendors, that's not unusual for that part of the state, we get a lot of competition out there, but that competition drives exceptionally good at this.
    • 00:15:35
      We got that with this project, the extent that, and our engineers estimate that we had
    • 00:15:43
      We have missed a few things that are slightly in hand when it comes to estimating.
    • 00:15:49
      Those things being mostly around the excavation and currently running.
    • 00:15:55
      When you go and buy a yard at the time period, you know how much that costs and you can figure out how much is going to cost in place.
    • 00:16:01
      And I am Mike Firth.
    • 00:16:03
      Who?
    • 00:16:08
      Who?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:32
      All in favor?
    • 00:16:36
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:16:36
      Page 3.
    • 00:16:43
      This project, again, had a lot of competition.
    • 00:16:53
      This project, different than some of us in the Six-Year Plan, we think we got the value of the current project in place, which was borne out by its relationship to the engineer's estimate.
    • 00:17:03
      And with Andrew Keders, as suggested, I was willing to write a list of two kits that were recommended after the award.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:08
      Are we comparing the $3 million one to the $2 million?
    • 00:17:12
      Is that the difference?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:14
      That's correct.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:14
      Is that just simply a cost in materials as you have said earlier?
    • 00:17:19
      That's almost a 50% difference.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:17:22
      That estimate is the six-year plan estimate.
    • 00:17:26
      It's not a defined estimate like you do when you go through and actually factor in the current market value of the cost of materials at present market value.
    • 00:17:36
      That money for that is coming from Cottam Street, an active project, so we've got a little bit of a right wing, there's about $800,000 in right wing money that will be used for construction in the rest of Cottam Street.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:54
      And again, just to remind folks, the construction estimates that are there today in the six-year program were snapshots, really, from last March and April.
    • 00:18:03
      So those estimates are a year old.
    • 00:18:06
      I move this approval, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:18:10
      Second.
    • 00:18:10
      All in favor?
    • 00:18:11
      Aye.
    • 00:18:12
      Okay, page four, there is a replacement page.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:18:16
      These are two of the four planning contracts that came in from Salem District.
    • 00:18:24
      Salem District originally passed two contracts.
    • 00:18:26
      We found that by winning these two, we were excluding some of our smaller players.
    • 00:18:32
      So, this brought to our occasion, we went back and broke those contracts into smaller packages, and as it turned out, one of the smaller competitors ended up being a successful last one this year, but on the other two.
    • 00:18:45
      These are the two that are over two million dollars and we're looking forward to making them for you all.
    • 00:18:48
      And we think we have pretty good deals on these.
    • 00:18:56
      Now, it's given me a pink sheet that is a change from what we had when the staff was putting this together.
    • 00:19:10
      We picked the wrong numbers for the amount of allocation on the number 208, the number 208.
    • 00:19:12
      We had the wrong numbers, but these are the correct numbers.
    • 00:19:14
      So you see that.
    • 00:19:14
      It wasn't allocated in the bid we want, but almost I can.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:16
      I move to approve.
    • 00:19:17
      And that motion is for both orders.
    • 00:19:20
      For both.
    • 00:19:22
      Second.
    • 00:19:22
      All in favor?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:19:25
      Aye.
    • 00:19:26
      And I'm going to move the motion to accept this specific responsibility to give me the list of projects that will be included on the plant next this year.
    • 00:19:41
      Page 5.
    • 00:19:41
      Page 5, we're asking for rejection of this bid.
    • 00:19:45
      Move the approval.
    • 00:20:12
      approval being approved approval the rejection
    • 00:20:29
      And this was my competition on the project with SCOPE.
    • 00:20:36
      And we feel like this is a good value.
    • 00:20:40
      We have particular questions about that.
    • 00:20:45
      We have Mr. Grin from the Commission here to answer the question.
    • 00:20:47
      I go right ahead and move the floor, please.
    • 00:20:50
      Second.
    • 00:20:51
      All in favor?
    • 00:20:52
      Aye.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:53
      Thank you.
    • 00:20:53
      Mr. Chairman, back on the previous one we just rejected.
    • 00:20:58
      In what way were the fitters non-responsive?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:21:04
      These were the highest projects during the course of advertising.
    • 00:21:09
      We defined the errors.
    • 00:21:09
      A lot of them were identified by our fitters.
    • 00:21:11
      And in order to make sure that we have a fit, we have to ensure that all of our fitters received and responded in their bid for those provisions.
    • 00:21:22
      And voted them down did not match.
    • 00:21:24
      and Thomas S. A. knowledge that they have received from their visions.
    • 00:21:31
      We have no way of knowing if it includes their work and is committed to a specification to require us to declare this upon their function.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:37
      Any other questions for Mr. Silas?
    • 00:21:39
      Thank you so much.
    • 00:21:41
      Really good to see the re-emergence of competition in these contracts.
    • 00:21:48
      Okay, now we're coming to new business.
    • 00:21:50
      I know that Ms. Carter has at least one item she'd like to bring up and anything that members would like to bring up under new business as well.
    • 00:21:58
      Ms. Carter.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:21:58
      This is something that I'm very proud of in the Gettysburg District, and I felt like I wanted to share this with the transportation board.
    • 00:22:07
      We speak about on time and on budget, and I believe yesterday I heard performance and quality spoke about, which is very, very important.
    • 00:22:21
      And I would like to say that in the Gettysburg District,
    • 00:22:26
      from the Virginia Chapter of American Concrete Institution Award for 2006, that the Fredericksburg District received this award.
    • 00:22:37
      And it was for the infrastructure for the Lord Delaware Bridge.
    • 00:22:43
      Now, I know we went to see Woodrow Wilson Bridge, and that was beautiful, but believe me, this is beautiful, too.
    • 00:22:50
      I was there, and of course, that area is certainly dear to my heart, even though I don't live there, but it just really is.
    • 00:22:56
      Our guest speaker was Governor Holton, and believe me, he could tell us history from way back.
    • 00:23:04
      about the old bridge.
    • 00:23:06
      And it was just great of what he did say.
    • 00:23:10
      And he hasn't lost anything.
    • 00:23:12
      He's more sharper than ever, I would say.
    • 00:23:15
      And I really appreciate that.
    • 00:23:17
      And also the 30 square district received the award from the Commonwealth.
    • 00:23:22
      And I just think that that's important that the public knows also what a great job that we do in transportation.
    • 00:23:31
      And I invite many of you to go see the bridge.
    • 00:23:33
      It's absolutely beautiful.
    • 00:23:35
      You'll be so proud of it.
    • 00:23:37
      Thank you.
    • 00:23:38
      And I applaud our employees and our great Commonwealth.
    • 00:23:42
      Thank you.
    • 00:23:43
      Thank you, Ms. Carter.
    • 00:23:45
      And Commissioner, do you want to add anything to that?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:48
      She said it so eloquently, there's nothing to ignore.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:23:50
      Do you know where the Delaware Bridge is located?
    • 00:23:54
      No, I thought you would say.
    • 00:23:56
      We've got to go there one sometime with the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:59
      Well, we have the opening of the second bridge on the other side of the town of West Point, April 7th, so perhaps we could make sure that all the members of the CTB get an invitation to that ribbon cutting event.
    • 00:24:15
      We'll be able to see both bridges in action, and they are beautiful bridges, as you said.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:24:20
      They are beautiful, they really are.
    • 00:24:23
      And I'll tell you, you can correct me if I'm wrong on this, but I believe that this is in the town of West Point, but it is in the county of King William.
    • 00:24:38
      I think I'm right on that.
    • 00:24:45
      Okay.
    • 00:24:46
      and then the bridge connects King and William County, am I right?
    • 00:24:51
      I mean King and Queen County.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:55
      Let us get a map, too.
    • 00:24:56
      The boundary lines sometimes, it depends if you're in the middle of the river or on one bank or the other.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:25:04
      Yes.
    • 00:25:04
      But this is where the location is.
    • 00:25:06
      They've got the map, so they're going to tell me, I guess.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:08
      And we encourage everyone, if you just drive east out of Richmond through the town of West Point to go to the northern neck, it's a beautiful drive.
    • 00:25:16
      Beautiful.
    • 00:25:18
      So thank you for bringing that to us.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:25:19
      Yes, yes.
    • 00:25:20
      And thank you.
    • 00:25:21
      Thank you, Mr. Commissioner.
    • 00:25:23
      Mr. Dickens.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:25:24
      Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:25:26
      Two things.
    • 00:25:26
      Congratulations to you and your staff for your success with the general assembly.
    • 00:25:32
      I think some of the bills are great.
    • 00:25:35
      Second item is that I'd like to have an opportunity to sit down with the folks that put these packages together.
    • 00:25:42
      I'm particularly interested in the limited access control
    • 00:25:47
      information that we had.
    • 00:25:49
      There's some suggestions I would like to make that would help me understand more about what the impact these limited access changes and some of these other things would have.
    • 00:26:01
      I don't want to bore everybody else with that, but I'd like to have an opportunity to sit down with whoever I could talk to that I could make some suggestions to.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:13
      I would suggest on both the subdivision streets and the access management, those will be iterative processes.
    • 00:26:19
      This is a little bit, in my mind, and far more challenging than the bicycle pedestrian where we adopted a policy and after
    • 00:26:30
      A lot of internal discussion and then the follow-up accountability that goes along with it.
    • 00:26:37
      So that retrospective look I think is very much a part of it.
    • 00:26:41
      I would envision likely several work sessions on each of those for the full CTB as the concepts and then the actual regulations are developed.
    • 00:26:54
      Trust me, those regulations are going to create a lot of work for each of you, as we've learned in other areas.
    • 00:27:03
      Any other items on new business?
    • 00:27:04
      Ms. Connolly.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:05
      It's not new business into that.
    • 00:27:07
      I just want to congratulate the department for, I think, their wisdom and humanity for introducing their program to hire veterans with disabilities.
    • 00:27:18
      I just think that's great, and I hope it's very successful, and I think it's a very good policy.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:24
      On behalf of the staff and particularly Grindley Johnson and her staff as they have put that program together.
    • 00:27:41
      They were well in advance of some national thinking that is now going on, and very frankly, I've been extremely proud of the enthusiasm and the dedication with which they approached that.
    • 00:27:56
      This is not a business in which you often talk about feelings, but you could feel the support and the commitment of her staff in developing and promoting that program.
    • 00:28:08
      I appreciate the compliments, and on behalf of her and the rest of the department, Garrett Moore in the Stanton District has done just a wonderful job and created a great environment for this to succeed, so we appreciate that.
    • 00:28:24
      Thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:27
      Any other business to come before the board?
    • 00:28:32
      If not, we stand adjourned.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:35
      Good afternoon, everyone.
    • 00:28:37
      I know I must be getting close to being off of probation as commissioner and vice-chair of the CTB simply because the secretary has been on the road with the governor and has been in the Salem District as a member of Dana Martin with him.
    • 00:28:59
      They are arriving at the airport as we speak.
    • 00:29:04
      and I believe Assistant Secretary Carr is with them.
    • 00:29:10
      So we're going to adjust the agenda slightly as we begin the workshop this afternoon.
    • 00:29:16
      We do have several, I think, fairly interesting topics on the agenda which are setting the stage for where we're going in the coming fiscal year.
    • 00:29:28
      Our current agenda calls for
    • 00:29:31
      A report on House Bill 3202 will do that as the second item on the agenda, and I have prevailed upon Director Tucker.
    • 00:29:44
      To start off with his agenda item and we believe that by the closure of that with questions and answers the secretary will be here.
    • 00:29:55
      So welcome everyone.
    • 00:29:57
      Looking forward to a good workshop and a good action item agenda for tomorrow.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:30:04
      Good afternoon, Mr. President.
    • 00:30:09
      The President is not a failed President.
    • 00:30:12
      He also asked me to speak for an hour and a half.
    • 00:30:13
      You can do it.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:30:15
      But you'd better not.
    • 00:30:16
      I hear a motion for that.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:30:19
      This is just a brief outline of what I'm going to speak about today.
    • 00:30:25
      The first item is moving on.
    • 00:30:27
      This is a discussion of our strategic assessment.
    • 00:30:31
      This has been an item that I've tried to report on on a monthly basis.
    • 00:30:36
      We're so to reach that point that we're gathering sufficient information that the consultants can begin putting on the package.
    • 00:30:44
      One of the few things that I want to call to your attention is the fact that we have scheduled four stakeholder workshops.
    • 00:30:51
      What's really important about the stakeholder workshop is really going to get into discussion about DRPT's current mandate as specified in the code and really a good understanding of what those mandates mean and how we carry them out over time.
    • 00:31:06
      For the goal of better defining those mandates in the future, to be specific, which would be the core principles, core goals, core functions of mandates for DRPT's agency.
    • 00:31:17
      We've invited each of you to attend one of these sessions and we've invited a broad range of stakeholders that we have to come to those workshops as well.
    • 00:31:27
      One of the key items that I want to at least put on the radar screen for our upcoming meeting in April is the fact that we will be talking in some level of detail about DRPT's organizational structure.
    • 00:31:40
      I've been on the job nine months, and unlike the Commission, my probation period will be over for a couple of years.
    • 00:31:50
      And I've had some time to review the structure, and looking at the structure from the perspective of organizations that were plucked out of VDOT in 1992 really needs to be realigned based upon what our mandates are.
    • 00:32:06
      So we're going to come back with a pretty significant proposal in terms of changing the structure of the organization to make sure that we are staffed appropriately and that we have the appropriate skillset to really advance the initiative.
    • 00:32:19
      At the same time, we'll begin some dialogue relative to some internal business processes that we need to change, some things that we need to do differently, some things that I think in the individual support of our program by becoming better administrators and better information managers.
    • 00:32:35
      So I look forward to a really detailed presentation for the month of April and May and getting lots of good feedback from the CTB and other stakeholders as we look to bring this process to the closure hopefully sometime in the coming months and months.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:55
      Any questions?
    • 00:32:55
      Matt, I just want to say that I applaud you for having the guts to look
    • 00:33:00
      So deeply at the structure of your organization and really focus on trying to make your organization the best that it can be to carry out its mandate.
    • 00:33:11
      I think that's something that every organization, whether it's a government agency or a private company, needs to do on a regular and ongoing basis.
    • 00:33:22
      And I think it's great that you're going through that process.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:33:25
      Thank you.
    • 00:33:25
      And hopefully we can do another couple.
    • 00:33:29
      OK, no more questions.
    • 00:33:30
      I'll go to the next slide.
    • 00:33:32
      Human service transportation workshops.
    • 00:33:35
      Now, I always laugh at these titles.
    • 00:33:38
      And the bottom line is when we think about human service transportation workshops, think about mobility.
    • 00:33:44
      What we're really starting to take a look at as an agency is the changes that the federal government has made over time to really start taking a look at the various sources of funds that have been spent on transportation.
    • 00:33:57
      And looking at how we better leverage those uses of funds.
    • 00:34:01
      If you saw in your mind that the federal government, particularly towards the transportation transit program, has a job access and reverse commute program.
    • 00:34:11
      We have programs associated with human service and the need for the elderly and disabled.
    • 00:34:16
      And then at the same time, there are tons of other agencies throughout the state, whether they be on nonprofit or public sector side to provide transportation.
    • 00:34:25
      And really what this whole effort is about is how do we leverage those resources, how do we better coordinate those resources.
    • 00:34:32
      In the past, the past role of this program for DRPT would have been a program where we essentially directly allocated funds out without really getting a fundamental estimate, an understanding of the public benefit, a fundamental understanding of how we can best leverage our dollars.
    • 00:34:50
      So what we're doing in this process is we've initiated a Phase 1 dialogue where we will go out to each of the respective regions and talk to them about their purposes and talk to them about some best practices.
    • 00:35:03
      At the same time, we're doing a Phase 2 study to talk about how we best serve as a central coordinator, a central collector, and develop a central set of rules and procedures that sort of will be the guiding light.
    • 00:35:15
      So the practical example that I'll always use for this is during my time here at Richmond, Virginia, I set up probably the most comprehensive welfare work verification program in the United States.
    • 00:35:27
      And it was a welfare work program based upon the use of manual service to move people from point A to point B.
    • 00:35:35
      Now all of you probably know that manual service is infinitely more extensive.
    • 00:35:38
      And it was always my goal that over time that we would look to integrate that service within our existing bus network and within our existing mediation as Americans just building that service for those who are disabled.
    • 00:35:54
      Because if you look at the fact that I may live in this house here and my neighbor right beside me is the person who's in welfare and work, the van comes by and picks up one of us and can't pick up another one.
    • 00:36:04
      And as a taxpayer, I'm the guy who comes for service.
    • 00:36:07
      I don't need the best enough to get the use of those dollars.
    • 00:36:09
      I don't need the best enough in our resources.
    • 00:36:11
      So what we're attempting to do with this program is to begin the process on a statewide basis of really looking at how do we best coordinate this information, how do we best get people to share resources, and how do we, throughout the making process, really get into the details so that grantees understand there is a requirement.
    • 00:36:29
      It's going to be a bigger lift than just the Transportation Secretary.
    • 00:36:33
      We're going to have to reach out throughout the state, to other public agencies, to nonprofits, to really make this work.
    • 00:36:40
      But I think what can happen at the end of the day, we can come up with a model that's not just based on public circuit dollars.
    • 00:36:47
      But also really this community-based effort of matching trips for people who need trips to different parts of the day.
    • 00:36:53
      So we're looking at really some of the most innovative and best practices of finding ways to allow people to complete their transportation and mobility needs.
    • 00:37:03
      And we're looking at pulling this together in November of 2007.
    • 00:37:08
      I will tell you that I'll probably view that more so as the initial phase one task being completed because one of the key focus that we're going to do is create really large magazines that will allow us to get a good understanding of trips that are taking place and really look towards volunteerism to help people complete their trips.
    • 00:37:30
      I'll give you a specific example.
    • 00:37:31
      There's a program in Maine.
    • 00:37:32
      If you live in Bristol, for example, and you have the ability to find some discretionary trips for someone in Bristol, if you need any credit, maybe for a relative who lives in Richmond.
    • 00:37:43
      And if you look at that from a perspective of how do we leverage, how do we not have to infuse lots of public money into different programs, that's one of those best examples because at the end of the day, we know the federal and the state and the local knowledge will never go far and that we're really going to need to have community-based initiatives as a meaningful instance that we have to get part of.
    • 00:38:02
      So that's the goal that we're trying to shoot to.
    • 00:38:05
      And at the same time, we want to make sure that we'll be able to track countries and show you performance in a real way on a monthly basis.
    • 00:38:13
      So I look forward to keeping you informed on this over the next few months.
    • 00:38:17
      If there's any questions, get off.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:38:18
      You lost me when you said that you were in another state and then you could be crazy for...
    • 00:38:24
      Within the state.
    • 00:38:24
      Within the state.
    • 00:38:25
      Okay.
    • 00:38:26
      Within the state.
    • 00:38:27
      Okay.
    • 00:38:30
      Within the state.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:38:31
      Right.
    • 00:38:31
      Good.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:32
      What kind of a budget number are we talking about?
    • 00:38:35
      Have you got a ballpark?
    • 00:38:37
      Are we spending now $20 million on this type of service?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:38:42
      No one really knows how much money is truly being spent.
    • 00:38:49
      Well, we know there are lots of dollars that are coming in from various programs with specific line ideas for transportation, but it's always been the rub is that folks do not want to really leverage in transportation because they did not want to give up those options.
    • 00:39:11
      And in fact, as we go through this process, we're going to attempt to really nail down in a much more systematic way how much money is going through with transportation and to really be able to specifically capture those trips, how they were, how they were utilized.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:19
      And the follow-up, you'll also capture actually how many trips are being made, which if you don't know the money, I'm pretty sure you don't know the trips either.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:39:27
      How many trips?
    • 00:39:28
      And again, we're also going to put this program within our public business model that we're transitioning to all of our programs so that we can be able to quantify every dollar, investment, investment in order to determine that value.
    • 00:39:42
      Great.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:39:43
      I just wanted to say that's great.
    • 00:39:50
      I mean, I have worked in many agencies and whatever, and I can see that you've got this one going in this direction and a van going in this direction.
    • 00:40:00
      I need a van, you know?
    • 00:40:03
      And I just applaud you for that.
    • 00:40:05
      That's wonderful.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:40:06
      Well, I'll tell you, every letter will come when we really need you to work in your respective areas to get everyone to come to the table.
    • 00:40:14
      I've found over time that if everyone loves to talk about coordination, no one really likes to deal with it.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:22
      We'll be there for you.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:40:24
      The next item is the criminal facility site search.
    • 00:40:29
      This is the item that we discussed over the last few months.
    • 00:40:33
      We are on schedule to make a decision sometime in the month of April.
    • 00:40:38
      We've done some additional due diligence and communication with the different localities.
    • 00:40:45
      I keep pointing back to what the goal is.
    • 00:40:48
      The goal is that the General Assembly will provide a lot of new economic development activity within their own region throughout the Commonwealth.
    • 00:40:55
      And that's what we're attempting to do in this process is to maximize that.
    • 00:40:58
      And at the same time, we can easily buy in in terms of what side is ultimately selected.
    • 00:41:04
      And I will tell you, we received tons of very positive feedback.
    • 00:41:08
      And additional information at the end of the day will help us reach a decision that will be very much acceptable to the region.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:41:18
      Any questions?
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:20
      Matt, just a comment on that.
    • 00:41:22
      I know at the end of the day, the decision you make, it's very difficult to make this kind of locational decision and please everybody.
    • 00:41:34
      And you won't be able to please everybody.
    • 00:41:37
      But I would just continue to encourage you that when ultimately you do make a decision,
    • 00:41:43
      to please keep in mind, and I know you will, that these kinds of decisions can have very, very difficult impacts on regular, everyday folks who really don't have the resources to bounce back from some of the potential negative impacts.
    • 00:42:03
      And so if you have to make a decision in the end that has some of those impacts,
    • 00:42:08
      Please take into account and try to do what you can to really minimize those impacts on the affected people.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:42:26
      This is something that I could really spring about the collaborative relationship that we have with VDOT This is probably going to be one of the more comprehensive
    • 00:42:46
      I've seen transportation studies done in my career within a compressed timeframe to pull it together.
    • 00:42:58
      What this is really focusing on is identifying the highest public benefits associated with various options.
    • 00:43:05
      I will tell you within the framework that we're looking at this whole hotline study, we are going to be looking at impact from Richmond all the way up to D.C. and we're going to be looking at both VRE and bus rapid transit all the way up to D.C.
    • 00:43:24
      And I think at the end of the day, what we want to be able to do is look at those different alternatives, look at the points for which they provide utility and relative to the return on investment, and look at what needs to be a matching project we can do over time that will provide high efficiency.
    • 00:43:48
      But this is going to be a study that I think really will help us develop a planning process for future transportation initiatives that will allow us to move away from some of the squishy,
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:53
      Q. Mr. Chairman, I would like to commend Matt Tucker for this particular point and I'll put it in terms of a positive statement regarding a multimodal, intermodal, almost, analysis of the corridor.
    • 00:44:23
      Which is what we adopted as policy three years ago, which the General Assembly has been telling us for seven years to do. I think it's great to see it actually starting to show up in a particular place, a particular corridor, because if we can't figure out some multimodal solution in this corridor, we're in big trouble, because it's a priority for so many people, and I commend you for getting beyond that.
    • 00:44:52
      I'm really looking forward to Christmas this year.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:59
      Mr. Chairman, just a question about your definition of bus rapid transit.
    • 00:45:04
      I have in my mind a very specific technical picture, but I think what do you mean when you say bus rapid transit?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:45:12
      I'd advise bus rapid transit as a set of systems.
    • 00:45:18
      A lot of systems include stations, vehicles, right-of-way,
    • 00:45:23
      But it's not a specific bus and a specific criteria.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:39
      I think in the Dulles discussions we had an idea of a bus rapid transit and it was a very specific form of bus service and I think what you're
    • 00:45:53
      Well, your definition is much broader.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:45:55
      It's much broader and actually the definition I'm giving is really the highest and best use and what you're looking through.
    • 00:46:04
      As you think about it, I think it's a ferocious conversation from our perspective.
    • 00:46:08
      When we look at this quarter and we start thinking about
    • 00:46:11
      I'm with Delta 95 board.
    • 00:46:14
      We're going to have to look at throughout the whole of the ticket to take a step toward bus rapid transit as a supporter.
    • 00:46:22
      How do we allow for that connectivity?
    • 00:46:24
      You can't just leave one bus, rapid transit bus, one north and south.
    • 00:46:26
      We need to make sure there's an activity and figure out how do we do this on a regional basis so that it makes sense to use this throughout the area and how do we build it because bus rapid transit is infinitely less expensive.
    • 00:46:37
      and quicker to bring you all alive than any railroad program.
    • 00:46:50
      Other questions on this topic?
    • 00:46:50
      It's a bumpy road in town.
    • 00:46:51
      Tell us a little bit about the railroad project.
    • 00:46:53
      I have spent no time in this project.
    • 00:47:00
      The big point that I will make is that we will become bringing negotiations to a conclusion in the first week of April.
    • 00:47:09
      And I think that will be a significant milestone for us if we're able to reach a successful agreement, because then there are only two real big milestones left on that part, outside of some of the agreements that we need to execute, and that's getting a final design and approach to an execution of the FMTA.
    • 00:47:25
      And I think it's just so important that folks understand that projects of good magnitude
    • 00:47:30
      Just don't come around every day.
    • 00:47:33
      We're talking about a project that's a multi-billion dollar project that's going to provide critical access from the Nellis Airport through the Tyresus Corner area to downtown D.C. And one of the big emphasis that I've had in the whole discussion about this project
    • 00:47:46
      is to sort of take away the discussion of the tunnel versus area.
    • 00:47:52
      I've been here nine months, and I know we didn't plan this project around whether it was aerial or tunnel.
    • 00:47:58
      We planned it around a new mobility solution.
    • 00:48:00
      And I think we need to keep that in mind, and our goal is to provide mobility for this project.
    • 00:48:05
      And that's what this project will do.
    • 00:48:07
      And I really hope over the next few weeks that we can move this project forward in a meaningful way to get a shovel in the ground.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:15
      Mr. Chairman, I just can't resist this.
    • 00:48:22
      In Virginia, there's an old phrase about FFBA, and I was just wondering what FFGA means in this case.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:48:29
      Full funding grant.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:31
      Full funding grant.
    • 00:48:32
      I thought we were executing people.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:36
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Tucker, I want to commend you personally for the way that you have handled the reviews of the various options there.
    • 00:48:44
      And I think you brought the same professionalism and the thoroughness to that process that you were talking about earlier here.
    • 00:48:51
      There was a lot of squishiness in that project and a lot of squishiness in some of the proposals, and whether that's a precise term or not, I think that's what you're trying to get at.
    • 00:49:02
      And I know you've faced some consequences for the way you did it, and I just wanted to put my voice on the other side and thank you for the thoroughness and professionalism that you showed there.
    • 00:49:12
      I think you've helped that project move along and helped people see that
    • 00:49:16
      The best solution is actually to put shovel in the ground early in 2008.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:49:26
      So thank you.
    • 00:49:29
      Thank you.
    • 00:49:30
      One thing I will share with you is the record by a lot of show levels that were played by Arthur and the U.S. to date for public transportation.
    • 00:49:41
      I think we've reached historic highs since 1957 in terms of public transit usage.
    • 00:49:43
      I've seen people spin it in different ways in terms of, well, you have much more transit.
    • 00:49:50
      I would actually say you have less transit today than you had in 1957 because if you think about automobile availability and the fact how much resources they'd be giving in terms of rail network and passenger
    • 00:49:59
      Thank you, Mr. Tucker.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:19
      Any last questions?
    • 00:50:22
      If not, I'm going to prevail upon, I just got an email from the airplane.
    • 00:50:30
      They're still about 15 minutes away from landing, which gives us about 30 to 40 minutes.
    • 00:50:35
      I don't know where the secretary arrived.
    • 00:50:38
      So what I'd like to do is call on Deputy Secretary Davis.
    • 00:50:45
      And we'll start the first of two coordinated presentations, very frankly.
    • 00:50:52
      As you're all aware, the Governor has appointed a Transportation Accountability Commission, which is geared to bring us to the next level of accountability and really fulfills a part of the agenda that he has established.
    • 00:51:10
      Deputy Secretary Davis has been charged with the initiative of carrying that initiative forward with a very robust panel that has been appointed as we prevail our deputies to give us a presentation this afternoon on where they are and what has been accomplished
    • 00:51:35
      We purposely then scheduled our dashboard, Gary.
    • 00:51:38
      I want to talk about dashboard 3.0 with you as a follow-on to this because we think it works so well together.
    • 00:51:46
      Welcome.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:51:46
      Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 00:51:50
      I'm pleased to take you today.
    • 00:51:52
      We'll cover several stories.
    • 00:51:58
      I want to thank you all for being here today.
    • 00:52:11
      It's a pleasure to be here.
    • 00:52:15
      And what I think are potential opportunities.
    • 00:52:28
      We've never heard of it.
    • 00:52:29
      It's not a global performance system.
    • 00:52:31
      There's always an opportunity for us to do that.
    • 00:52:33
      And over the last several months, I've gotten others that have been looking at the kind of goals that you can say, what are some of the opportunities you're starting at, and some of what I see as some potential opportunities.
    • 00:52:40
      In terms of background, most we know of are satisfied with the acceptable order of a donor.
    • 00:52:46
      And there are essentially four main reasons for this accountability mission.
    • 00:52:54
      And they are, as I said, as a whole, one of the best terms.
    • 00:52:59
      First, to review the existing methods for promoting accountable performance in Virginia.
    • 00:53:04
      We have been using accountability performance at least over the last four or six years, so some of the process and discovery is what you're going to be doing.
    • 00:53:17
      Identify and recommend manual best practices.
    • 00:53:19
      Some of that discovery in this process is when people look at what's happening in terms of performance and accountability, they point back and say,
    • 00:53:27
      That's one of our major presentations that we had.
    • 00:53:35
      The National Expert looking at performance and pointing back to say, well, if you think about performance accountability, we'll look at it again.
    • 00:53:43
      But see if there are some practices that some other states may be using that we can learn from.
    • 00:53:51
      The major task is to recommend quantifiable upcoming measures for the major elements of the State's transportation program, including measures that incorporate the effect of land use and transportation coordination, as well as we know one of the
    • 00:54:08
      How do you make transportation and land use and combat challenges, how do you measure it, must be a major challenge in actually developing the type of bonus measures for land use and transportation?
    • 00:54:28
      Another element was to recommend performance standards for transportation executives and agencies.
    • 00:54:36
      Our current audience gets the exam in terms of their performance standards.
    • 00:54:39
      So we've looked at that and in the process of doing that.
    • 00:54:42
      The thing about this is that the transportation agency is no different than any other agency yet.
    • 00:54:53
      So to the extent that we make recommendations, we can't expect transportation executives as far as they're going to be evaluated differently.
    • 00:54:56
      on policy and agency side.
    • 00:55:03
      We are doing this.
    • 00:55:04
      We are reminding the Commonwealth Commission that we are going to change the event to the extent that they accept that they will apply to all agencies.
    • 00:55:11
      The final aspect is that it says when we look at the top of the measures, we should consider whether there are ways to measure traffic projects that impact, possibly make an impact on communities.
    • 00:55:28
      So that's kind of the target of the commission.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:34
      The commission is made up of twenty-one people.
    • 00:55:47
      That's all the way across from ports to air to roads, rail, transit?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:55:54
      Yes, we talked about transportation not by tactics.
    • 00:56:04
      So, we will be looking at our commitment for each of the quality agencies, including the English.
    • 00:56:08
      We did a long-range plan, maybe with some development of it.
    • 00:56:10
      Let us go around to talking about standards for the fact that it's inclusive of the transportation system as well as the agency.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:15
      Do you know if they intended or said anywhere in this authorization, you know, the role of the CTB and how we do what we do and whether we're doing what we're, is that part of this at all?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:56:29
      It's not included, except for some of the, I think, what we may well recommend, maybe some items, some of them you can see in terms of what I'm,
    • 00:56:41
      I think there was a sort of effort on the part of the Secretary to make sure that this Commission didn't overlap, but this one is possible with CTB, so.
    • 00:57:03
      But I do think there's a lot to do with CTB, but I'll speak to it also.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:08
      A couple of questions, Mr. Davis.
    • 00:57:13
      Does the Accountability Commission intend to meet with or interview any of the members of the CTB in its process?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:57:23
      At this point, we are not planning to do that.
    • 00:57:28
      The meetings are open.
    • 00:57:30
      They're available to the CTB.
    • 00:57:33
      If members want to come to the CTB, that's an expensive position.
    • 00:57:38
      But we have not, at this point, planned to necessarily interview the CTB members or anyone of that nature.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:47
      I would like you to take back a recommendation to the Commission for me speaking personally which is that I think they ought to interview individual CTB members and I think there ought to be substantial overlap
    • 00:58:07
      In terms of their review, I don't really see how you can possibly talk about accountability in transportation in Virginia without looking at the role of the CTB.
    • 00:58:20
      And I think that kind of interaction and dialogue would be very helpful to them.
    • 00:58:25
      I, for one, would be delighted to come and talk to them.
    • 00:58:29
      I can't speak for the other members of the teach CTB, but it seems to me that that would be an important thing for them to do, and I'd appreciate it if you'd take that recommendation.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:58:39
      One of the things, when you mentioned it, it is further my briefing, is that we have established a web presence for the Continental Gold Committee.
    • 00:58:49
      It's under Secretary of Transportation's website.
    • 00:58:51
      and you can go to that website and on that website there's information in terms of meetings, minutes, and when meetings will occur, and after a period of meetings, meetings can come along.
    • 00:59:04
      I will be sure to take that back.
    • 00:59:06
      Thank you.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:12
      Other questions at this point?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:59:19
      As any patient out there, one of the members of the Congress of the Commonwealth Commission is chaired by Jim Sparks, who is a senior VP, Financial Science, and Public Service.
    • 00:59:31
      Vice Chair is John H. Chang.
    • 00:59:34
      Michael A. Davis is the former director of the Fairfax Department of Management and also a former VDOT employee.
    • 00:59:46
      It mixes the private, public, and community leadership.
    • 00:59:49
      This is a fact from myself, from a doctorate student who made a lot of sense and attached to the draft.
    • 00:59:58
      For those of you who may know, we were involved in the Wal-Mart Transportation Center.
    • 01:00:06
      There is a continuity here.
    • 01:00:06
      I can assure you that one of the most involved in the Wal-Mart Transportation Center is just in touch with them.
    • 01:00:12
      There is a subject that the governor may want to continue or can continue to commission a year beyond October of this year.
    • 01:00:33
      Some of what I did is that the mission is to make a series of recommendations and it would be useful if a commission goes around a year or so later to see whether or not those sort of recommendations are actually executed.
    • 01:00:48
      There is a provision for the commission on that stuff, John, in one year.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:54
      Mr. Chairman, interim report, does that mean the board will get a report on this maybe in June?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:01:01
      The report is public record.
    • 01:01:04
      We can make it available to the Board at the time it's published.
    • 01:01:09
      We can make it available.
    • 01:01:10
      It will be available on the Internet website.
    • 01:01:11
      Whatever the purpose of the award is, we'll make it available to the Board.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:19
      We'll make a note and make sure that we get a workshop item for you as an update.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:24
      And also, if we could be informed about the meetings.
    • 01:01:27
      I know, I'm not sure that we are.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:31
      I'll ask Carol to get that agenda and forward it to the members.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:01:43
      I've now focused on the current measures for counterbalance performance.
    • 01:01:50
      As indicated, we've never really experienced the process, and I'm going to sort of fly through some of these.
    • 01:01:58
      And we did not recognize that the process is something called review performance.
    • 01:02:05
      The review performance is at my site.
    • 01:02:06
      I have the main measures on the bottom right.
    • 01:02:09
      I'm a former State Governor in what I call the overarching goals in the following areas.
    • 01:02:17
      This was a sacrifice, not one of the easiest innovations, as carried by the government.
    • 01:02:25
      It's a main initiative that has received a national acclaim.
    • 01:02:27
      It has the overarching goals in the area of the economy.
    • 01:02:33
      In the area of education, health, family, public safety, national resources, government services and transportation.
    • 01:02:40
      It has an example in terms of what these overall goals.
    • 01:02:43
      The goal for the economy, for example, is to be a national leader in the preservation and enhancement of our economy.
    • 01:02:50
      The goal of the government of citizens is to be recognized as the best managed state in the nation.
    • 01:02:58
      The goal of the transportation, I think this is important because this is one of those things where I see a real tide going in what we're doing at the CTB.
    • 01:03:05
      The goal of transportation is to ensure that Virginia has a transportation system that is safe and able to ease the movement of people and goods, enhances the economy, and increases the quality of life.
    • 01:03:17
      This is at the very high end in terms of the state of Virginia, but it's the goal of the transportation.
    • 01:03:27
      The next item here is something called
    • 01:03:32
      The HCP objective is to have performance measures.
    • 01:03:43
      We've been in this performance measures business 18 years.
    • 01:03:45
      And there are a number of measures out there.
    • 01:03:47
      For transportation, there are not eight performance measures.
    • 01:03:50
      There's a five of those on each of these plans.
    • 01:03:51
      Not eight measures.
    • 01:03:52
      One of them is the government.
    • 01:03:56
      And it's the same.
    • 01:03:56
      There's too many of them.
    • 01:03:58
      He brought in a panel of government performance measures experts.
    • 01:04:00
      And to make that essential, we need to cut down those measures.
    • 01:04:04
      Those key measures are the results of what's produced by agencies.
    • 01:04:08
      So that's the second layer here.
    • 01:04:11
      Key measures, they work.
    • 01:04:16
      And here's Mel and I.
    • 01:04:21
      There have been methods developed for each of the transportation agencies and their key measures and they're both a part of the process that we're going to go over in the next several months.
    • 01:04:30
      The next measure is the agency's future plans.
    • 01:04:33
      If you go to any of the transportation agencies' websites, there's a state law which requires state agencies to post their key plan to the website.
    • 01:04:45
      There's a strategic plan for VDOT.
    • 01:04:48
      If you go to the VDOT website for some information, you will find a VDOT strategic plan.
    • 01:04:58
      What's in the strategic plan?
    • 01:05:01
      Each agency has one.
    • 01:05:01
      It's going to contain a division.
    • 01:05:02
      It contains goals.
    • 01:05:03
      It contains our performance measures.
    • 01:05:06
      And as I said, for all the agencies that are not able to perform these measures,
    • 01:05:10
      The next element is something called the Governor's Management Scorecard.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:05:15
      The Governor's Scorecard is a list of the members of the agency operations.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:05:20
      How long does the agency do in terms of the security process?
    • 01:05:26
      What's going on in terms of financial management?
    • 01:05:28
      Does it have a financial plan?
    • 01:05:29
      In HR, does it have a suspension plan?
    • 01:05:30
      How was the time that it takes to actually hire an employee?
    • 01:05:37
      So this is what's called a Douglas-Manton scorecard.
    • 01:05:40
      This particular element is on the mechanical forms.
    • 01:05:44
      It's how the person's going to be commissioned and reviewed.
    • 01:05:47
      It's part of his performance.
    • 01:05:48
      He can be graded to meet and succeed, so he needs improvement.
    • 01:05:55
      This is the main element of the government's performance.
    • 01:05:58
      The next component is the long-range transportation plan, which some of you don't know about.
    • 01:06:03
      The main element of the long-range transportation plan is the status of long-term goals for transportation.
    • 01:06:08
      that I will take to a bit later.
    • 01:06:11
      The problem with this is each agency has its own agency performance record system.
    • 01:06:17
      Now, that is what I think is very cool.
    • 01:06:20
      All of these tie and link together to put together this performance management system that I indicated is in the learning process.
    • 01:06:31
      I will talk to these a little bit
    • 01:06:35
      First of all, I want to mention the general reform and access overarching goals.
    • 01:06:41
      That's overarching goals for seven major areas.
    • 01:06:44
      That's one in four of those definitions.
    • 01:06:48
      And what I'm recommending to the Commission is that this particular goal be the mission of that goal, the mission of that commission as well.
    • 01:06:58
      I'd like to say this thing, peace and will to the people and to others, enhance the economy, and improve the quality of life.
    • 01:07:09
      If you'd love to consider this webpage, you're going to find that this sector of transportation, this is the mission of transportation.
    • 01:07:15
      Within the general performance, there are some outcome measures.
    • 01:07:19
      Those outcome measures are congestion,
    • 01:07:21
      and Ralph Delay from the Texas Transportation Institute, from Long City, Indianapolis, and early... Mr. Chairman.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:31
      Ralph, is that goal the same one that we voted on at the end of the VTrans process?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:07:37
      Well, I've been real close to working on it by VTrans.
    • 01:07:39
      The folks from the 7th of November then worked with the
    • 01:07:43
      My concern is that we do things, we adopt them, we approve them, and then they drop into some place and somebody comes back two years later with yet another either restatement of it
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:12
      and it would please me to know that something we've already adopted is actually referenced and incorporated as we build on it and go forward and I'm just trying to make sure that that's what's happening here because if you reinvented the wheel I would encourage you frankly to use the time more productively.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:08:31
      I'm sharing my answer.
    • 01:08:34
      I'm not reinventing the wheel.
    • 01:08:35
      I'm trying to make sure that the work that we've done is fully put into that process.
    • 01:08:40
      And some of what I'd like, while the CTB did adopt VTrans, it did not specifically adopt gold.
    • 01:08:49
      And what I would like is this gold here will pass the patient to be the gold for CTB.
    • 01:08:55
      When you go to the CTB website, I can see something that says global transportation is through these things.
    • 01:09:12
      If you go to that website right now, you go down to my website.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:14
      And some of what I'm doing is making sure that the work that was done in the past, that we do indeed institutionalize the network, and that's some of what the network is doing.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:09:23
      I would encourage you in that direction.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 01:09:27
      That is a goal.
    • 01:09:28
      How do we measure that goal, that we're meeting with that?
    • 01:09:32
      And that's, I believe, what we're speaking of.
    • 01:09:34
      We would like to have reports on how we are meeting to give this goal.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:09:39
      I will get to that in a few seconds later.
    • 01:09:48
      I think some of what we need is a real challenge when you're voting up on this.
    • 01:09:59
      And what we've heard from that expert is what we've been preaching is you can't vote up on this without wanting to vote.
    • 01:10:03
      Wanting to know what your goal is, please send it to me.
    • 01:10:04
      You can then vote because once you know what your mission is, which is this, you can then vote both.
    • 01:10:07
      But the goal may be to improve safety.
    • 01:10:09
      From that, you can actually govern on one measure.
    • 01:10:14
      How do you measure it?
    • 01:10:16
      You measure it with a fatality?
    • 01:10:17
      It would be one fatality.
    • 01:10:19
      And we actually have a concrete measure that goes to the Commission of Energy and the Commission on subjects, subject to the concerns of the fatality.
    • 01:10:26
      That is, they are challenged to produce a minimum fatality by one measure, by 2010.
    • 01:10:30
      That's a straight goal.
    • 01:10:31
      That's part of the whole point measure of the Commission as well as the daily commission.
    • 01:10:35
      So we start with the Sorrell mission.
    • 01:10:38
      We've developed a series of goals.
    • 01:10:40
      From those goals, we develop objectives and we develop specific targets.
    • 01:10:47
      And that's direction of attention.
    • 01:10:48
      So, you will see, we've done some work along that line.
    • 01:10:52
      I will touch on that as we go further.
    • 01:10:59
      I would encourage you to go to this particular website.
    • 01:11:01
      on the website of what happens to gun information on the economy, on transportation, on all the major assignments of the state's economy.
    • 01:11:12
      And this particular website is the chief of staff.
    • 01:11:18
      Yes.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:19
      Mr. Chairman, Ralph, I think what
    • 01:11:22
      Mary Lee and I are saying, in part anyway, is that it's terrific that we have a goal established that everybody agrees on and sees clearly.
    • 01:11:31
      But a goal is not a plan.
    • 01:11:33
      And the plan, by definition, is how you get from the goal to these different outcomes, or we hope better outcomes, than whatever ones we use as our baseline.
    • 01:11:44
      So you have to establish a baseline of how we're doing now.
    • 01:11:47
      and the goal presumably would be to make improvements in all those outcome measures, but man is the trick.
    • 01:11:54
      That's what separates the pros from the amateurs is understanding the difference.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:12:03
      Let me expand on that in terms of the safety goals.
    • 01:12:06
      The safety goal was developed as a part of how we could change the safety plans.
    • 01:12:15
      We've got to improve this board on coming back now for ourselves.
    • 01:12:18
      And within the power safety plan, there's this overall role of reducing the cost by 105.10.
    • 01:12:26
      But to get to that, there are a series of strategies that one must do to get to that goal.
    • 01:12:32
      And exactly, like being too
    • 01:12:34
      That legislation will forever be done.
    • 01:12:37
      All it may be to improve the sciences, committing to some, probably, I believe, drivers, and put the science in the markings, and in others.
    • 01:12:49
      So there are a number of strategies and trends, and a hundred and eighteen or so strategies that have been put together to try to achieve that target of reducing fatalities by 2010, about 2011-2010.
    • 01:13:01
      I understand what you're saying, and we have put in place an estimate
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:03
      If I may, member McCarthy, I've interpreted over the several months I've been with the board now that critical point you're making about are we linking the things that bring life to goals in our business and hopefully this afternoon we'll be able to demonstrate
    • 01:13:34
      how we're using this to link to our dashboard 3.0 which is what is beyond on time on budget and then the piece that Greg added last year which is internally how are we turning that into an action item through our business planning process and if I'm
    • 01:13:58
      Hearing the conversation from the board, I think those linkages are difficult to forge, but critical to ongoing success of an organization.
    • 01:14:09
      And that's kind of why it takes us a while to get it translated and put into place for policy bodies like this that are giving us good guidance.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:14:21
      As a new member of this board, relatively new member of this board, I have felt somewhat disenfranchised from what he's talking about, which is a goal-oriented process, determining strategies to meet those goals.
    • 01:14:39
      And I just haven't seen this board involved in that type of process.
    • 01:14:46
      And I have seen this board be almost immersed in details that I think are less important for us to be dealing with than the kinds of things we're talking about here.
    • 01:15:02
      So I would strongly encourage
    • 01:15:05
      I think it's important for us to start looking at these types of things.
    • 01:15:09
      I agree with everything my colleagues have said and would encourage this board to look at those things because I think our function, our purpose here is to be a lot more engaged in that type of discussion than some of the more detailed discussions that we get involved with on a regular basis.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:31
      I appreciate the perspective.
    • 01:15:33
      Other comments?
    • 01:15:36
      We'll have more discussion, I have no doubt.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:15:41
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 01:15:42
      Chair.
    • 01:15:43
      Much like I mentioned, Virginia Deforms has these overarching goals.
    • 01:15:46
      I think we need the same type of overarching goals for transformation.
    • 01:15:50
      Some of you who may be re-trans, these things are very familiar to you.
    • 01:15:55
      And some of the process, unfortunately, is we, as a part of establishing outcome measures, we have to look at those.
    • 01:16:03
      And these are the goals that are associated with part of the VTrans effort as well as the key performance initiatives for each of those goals.
    • 01:16:12
      And what you see here are the sacred security.
    • 01:16:13
      That's what transitions matter.
    • 01:16:15
      So you can see that safety and security is a primary goal, and these are the performance measures that are used for those primary goals.
    • 01:16:29
      These performance measures are part of the dark head that was generated as a result of VTrans.
    • 01:16:35
      One of the things that VTrans wanted us to do is to develop an annual performance measure.
    • 01:16:38
      You will be briefed on the annual performance report, I think in the April meeting.
    • 01:16:45
      In that performance report, this is our preview of what's in the performance report.
    • 01:16:50
      It talks about the major goals, talks about the measures, and to the extent that a target is set on whether or not we are headed in the right direction on those specific measures.
    • 01:17:01
      Of course, now what we look at is the number and radius of challenges.
    • 01:17:04
      Unfortunately for that, how long have you been in the right direction?
    • 01:17:14
      At least for 2006, fatalities went up by 10 from 9.6 in 2005 to 9.6 in 2008, so we have seen an increase in fatalities.
    • 01:17:21
      What this report is going to show is what the history has been and what the direction should be in terms of their performance.
    • 01:17:28
      So the major goals that we have, and I'll call you over on the goals, safety, security, preservation, maintenance, that's the primary responsibility of the CTB and transportation is to preserve our current system.
    • 01:17:43
      Other than adults, there is connectivity.
    • 01:17:48
      You can see some of the measures there in terms of how we can get them to do that.
    • 01:17:53
      We have cities that have a big role in terms of overall connectivity to the South Carolina zone.
    • 01:18:00
      We're fondly led and used in calls of light.
    • 01:18:03
      As I said, this information is in the report that's forthcoming to you at any time frame.
    • 01:18:14
      It's called the Indian Transportation Performance Report, which is an inaugural report.
    • 01:18:20
      We have done one of these things, to my knowledge, in Virginia.
    • 01:18:25
      And that's the results of the work that we do at the Long Wind Transportation Clinic.
    • 01:18:34
      I mentioned APC performance, our reporting systems, all of these things apply, all from the new dashboard, which has five to six million measures in it, one time on budget, half the talent in it, those are the talent teams rolled up to, the talent teams that are the statewide measures.
    • 01:18:53
      We have the quarterly report card, so all these systems tie together to make this demonstration an overall performance accountability report.
    • 01:19:04
      Okay.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:09
      Mr. Davis, are you looking at accountability measures that would link cost to some of these other goals or standards, such as congestion?
    • 01:19:27
      In other words, is the Commission going to attempt to not only look at standards and solutions, but a way to measure
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:19:37
      The question here was whether or not there were, or whether it is an answer there on the cost of congestion.
    • 01:20:05
      And there is some data on cost congestion.
    • 01:20:16
      The question becomes, some of that question was related to whether you have cost congestion data and can you use that data to obviously translate into the kind of investment transportation that might be needed to vary the congestion.
    • 01:20:30
      The problem is that the data congested in most cases is very dated.
    • 01:20:37
      You may or may not know that the name of the data congestion is from something called the Texas Translational Institute, and they produced data for the data of 2003.
    • 01:20:47
      That's who just stated that talks about the amount of wait time involved to a delay for the average citizen.
    • 01:20:54
      And they actually translated that into the cost for the individual citizen in terms of the amount of time spent there as well as wait until it's all full.
    • 01:21:05
      So there's a number there.
    • 01:21:06
      That issue has come up, how far we can get to it, but I don't know if that's been mentioned by each one of these Commission members.
    • 01:21:27
      We will not be the dropping solution to that, because the Commission didn't have those dates, you know, six months ago.
    • 01:21:30
      That doesn't mean it can't be something that the Commission recommends to be done.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:33
      I'm talking about something a little different.
    • 01:21:35
      I think in your example, you're talking about looking at the societal costs of congestion versus the potential cost of making the investment.
    • 01:21:49
      I'm talking about something different, and I'll give you an example.
    • 01:21:54
      It may not be a particularly good example, but let's say in a particular case we have a congestion problem.
    • 01:22:02
      One way to address the congestion problem is to build X number of additional lanes of asphalt at a cost of $500 million to pick a number.
    • 01:22:19
      And let's say at the same time there's also the potential to address the same congestion problem by a combination of making a $50 million investment in asphalt and a $50 million investment in demand management incentives, basically paying people to drive at different times or differently or in different places.
    • 01:22:45
      I guess my question is I don't, well to put it this way, I don't think we've been particularly good in Virginia at looking at those kinds of alternatives and yet they're very important alternatives in a resource constrained environment which everybody acknowledges we're in.
    • 01:23:07
      And it would seem to me a great service on the part of the Accountability Commission if they would try to develop some evaluation standards that would allow those kinds of trade-offs to be evaluated.
    • 01:23:24
      And my question is, are they planning to do that?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:23:28
      I think I answered a couple of things.
    • 01:23:31
      One, I think the extent of the Commission would be to recommend something like that.
    • 01:23:37
      The resources available to the Commission about the times constraints would mean that the Commission actually can't do that.
    • 01:23:43
      It doesn't mean that they can't say that instead of spending funds for a vision on new facilities,
    • 01:23:50
      That there are other ways, still, with the congestion.
    • 01:23:54
      It's going down.
    • 01:23:55
      Hopefully, I don't get a face-to-face notice, so it doesn't mess up.
    • 01:23:58
      But to get to some of the congestion, it's not occurring.
    • 01:24:02
      What that would say to me is that perhaps we need to look at some of that non-recurring and do about this.
    • 01:24:10
      We need to look at some of that non-recurring congestion done in a couple of states that put, this is some discovery that happened in the United States, they put quite a lot of money into the non-recurring, congestion, non-recurring of the incidents,
    • 01:24:25
      I think we're going to have more for the commission is really what the state is about.
    • 01:24:52
      and that they in particular separate recurring versus non-recurring congestion and I tend to interfere with that because non-recurring or recurring congestion are really long-term kinds of solutions.
    • 01:25:07
      You have to invest additional funds.
    • 01:25:12
      An honorary term or a religious term kind of means that you can invest in the near term to get some solutions.
    • 01:25:17
      So I think, to answer your question, what we will get from permission is to recognize that there are two levels.
    • 01:25:24
      There are two different levels of
    • 01:25:26
      That's actually an excellent example of the type of thing.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:48
      That I'm talking about is looking at those kinds of alternatives to our traditional thought patterns of how to invest in transportation, which is to build roads, as a means of and really evaluating whether some of these alternatives in a resource constrained environment give us, at least in the short and medium term, more bang for the buck.
    • 01:26:13
      So if that's the kind of thing they're looking at, I'm really encouraged by that.
    • 01:26:17
      There are a lot of other examples, and that's why I think it would behoove the Commission to talk to some of us in the process before they finalize their recommendations.
    • 01:26:26
      Thank you.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:27
      Mr. Chairman, Ralph, will the Commission look at all into the movement toward outsourcing and privatization?
    • 01:26:38
      We've been moving in that direction, much of it, by legislative dictates.
    • 01:26:43
      We proudly proclaim the reduction in the number of employees at VDOT.
    • 01:26:50
      The burning question in my mind is, is it saving us money or is it costing us money to replace VDOT work with VDOT employees with private contractors?
    • 01:27:07
      That's a complex question and a complex issue, but is that something that might be addressed by the Commission?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:27:15
      At this time, we will not be addressed by the Commission.
    • 01:27:18
      The Commission's goals are fairly narrow defined by the Executive Order.
    • 01:27:22
      And that's the charge.
    • 01:27:25
      And I think one of the things we're looking at for the Commission to do, there are issues that I'll assign of what's in the Executive Order.
    • 01:27:33
      There's an element of the Executive Order that's in all the reform measures.
    • 01:27:37
      That's where I would see something like that fit again.
    • 01:27:41
      There are measures outside of developing these broad outcome measures that are outside of the mission or the role of the commission.
    • 01:27:49
      And I think how we deal with that, whether it's coming from the commission members or whether it's coming from the CTB or others,
    • 01:27:57
      What are some of the other types of issues that need to come up that we'll discover as we have hearings and meetings of the Commission itself?
    • 01:28:09
      It's not a critical charge of the Commission, but does that mean that it can be a recommendation to come to the Commission?
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:17
      It seems to me it'd be a germane issue that could be considered by the Commission.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:28:25
      I just want to add my concurrence to what Mr. Bowie said.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:37
      Again, if the Commission is looking at accountability in transportation, the issue of outsourcing and
    • 01:28:49
      As we forge down that path, the risk of not having measures to determine whether in fact it's still the right path to go, if it ever was, seems to me at the core of the whole issue of accountability and transportation.
    • 01:29:08
      I recognize it's not the only issue, but it's another one of those issues that I think it's difficult to say that you're addressing accountability without looking at it.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:29:19
      And I would agree with Mr. Bowie, and if the Commission is not going to look at it, I would suggest that's something this body ought to be looking at.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:28
      As an editorial note, obviously, in managing a transportation business in the 21st century, we've got to have all those tools available to us.
    • 01:29:37
      It is a key element that we're sensitive to in the business plan of the agency as we move forward because it deals with how we do our business
    • 01:29:49
      In context, I tend to look at performance measures and these kinds of an approach as establishing the what so that we have a framework and the freedom to deal with the how.
    • 01:30:03
      And that's really where the tricky part gets to be, I think, in the overall accountability structure that we're headed through.
    • 01:30:10
      Please continue.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:30:13
      This is the progress today.
    • 01:30:16
      We've had a meeting in January.
    • 01:30:18
      We've brought in a sponsor goal to do two supplement measures.
    • 01:30:21
      One to deal with the outcome measures and one to deal with the home standards.
    • 01:30:25
      We have established a web presence.
    • 01:30:32
      I'm a caregiver of that particular website.
    • 01:30:36
      There's information there that should be gave your way to follow the work of the information.
    • 01:30:44
      Through those meetings, what are the recommendations that we, that the video performs, though, as a transition mission, that's one of the things that we've done right then?
    • 01:30:50
      The other is to establish a system without the overarching transportation bills that were part of the defense that was never designated into the commission of the CTB or the law.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:31:09
      Mr. Chairman.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:10
      I've gotten lost between what an outcome measure is in a performance standard, the last, the two subcommittees.
    • 01:31:20
      I think I perfectly understand the outcome measures, but now what's the performance?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:31:25
      Okay, we were given two charges.
    • 01:31:28
      One is to develop a series of outcome measures, whether it's transportation and agency development.
    • 01:31:35
      If I was to replicate a performance standard,
    • 01:31:37
      That's a threatening question.
    • 01:32:06
      Well, I think that's an opportunity.
    • 01:32:15
      And it may touch on some of the questions that Deborah asked, but at least there's lots of questions.
    • 01:32:24
      We have these overarching goals because of things like safety and adulting.
    • 01:32:27
      What we don't have is a goal that deals with the actual delivery of a program.
    • 01:32:32
      And I think the direction that the chemical industry is headed is a fiscal responsibility.
    • 01:32:39
      And when you talk about fiscal responsibility, you talk about issues such as on a time on a budget.
    • 01:32:48
      And perhaps issues such as the excuses of a new program that's not an actual basis have not been determined.
    • 01:32:52
      But one thing that's missing that I think
    • 01:32:55
      I think we need that as a goal.
    • 01:33:00
      The second thing, I think we need to institutionalize so you don't rock the world without them.
    • 01:33:12
      We need to generate an annual kind of goals report.
    • 01:33:17
      One thing that I would like to see established through the website, very comfortable, is that you can walk away with a website that tracks this and makes it available to users and the public generally in terms of what words are said and how we ask you to perform it.
    • 01:33:30
      I would like to see or continue to see the goals that have been documented or integrated into this board, the report board, and the paperwork board.
    • 01:33:48
      You've gotten through the days.
    • 01:33:53
      Congestion is very difficult to measure.
    • 01:33:59
      So what we need to do is advance all the data, figure out how best to measure congestion because it's very poor data at the current time.
    • 01:34:06
      Land use and transportation, how do you measure that?
    • 01:34:07
      You often hear about the job housing ratio.
    • 01:34:10
      III.
    • 01:34:12
      What does that mean?
    • 01:34:13
      And is there a standard?
    • 01:34:15
      Because right now there is no standard to everyone's perception about how generation is created and what it means.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:22
      Mr. Chairman, I'm sorry, I need another clarification, Ralph.
    • 01:34:28
      Those of us who have been involved in this training like this time have heard complaints about congestion for decades.
    • 01:34:36
      I don't understand how we talk about it so much without knowing what it is we're talking about.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:34:43
      I didn't follow that.
    • 01:35:00
      The problem with it is that it's two years old, three years old.
    • 01:35:05
      2003 is the latest data for congestion.
    • 01:35:07
      It's measured only for the three major measures of policy and marriage.
    • 01:35:11
      The problem is, if that's measured and you want to put it in place as a policy to deal with the measures, they do not know the facts.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:20
      Well, they're not getting any better, are they?
    • 01:35:23
      I mean, it's only getting worse.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:35:25
      It's only getting worse.
    • 01:35:26
      It will continue to get worse, and it will be better.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:31
      Well, I guess that's the heart of the matter, isn't it?
    • 01:35:34
      If the congestion is measurable by some factors that TTI has established, and which our transportation research council probably uses, and we know what it is at various points in time, up to the latest data that's available,
    • 01:35:51
      I'm worried that you're going to get lost in the minutiae of this and you miss the forest for the trees.
    • 01:35:59
      My concern is that this is a measurable problem that researchers who are the best in the business know how to measure.
    • 01:36:08
      And I don't want to misunderstand, but I thought I understood you to say that we don't know how to measure congestion.
    • 01:36:16
      And I would be stunned if that were a true statement.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:36:20
      Mr.
    • 01:36:21
      Chair, I submit the property I did not take, and don't know how to say it.
    • 01:36:25
      The issue there is the quality of the data, but we do have to measure it.
    • 01:36:30
      We don't know about the effects of transportation issues.
    • 01:36:33
      But the reason I put it there is if you want to say we want to make an investment in transportation, we build congestion.
    • 01:36:38
      I don't follow that logic.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:53
      I just don't.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:54
      There's something I'm missing.
    • 01:36:56
      As we move forward, I think we'll have a chance to continue this discussion with Dr. Allen's piece of the presentation as we move into the Dashboard 3.0 because it reflects directly into
    • 01:37:07
      where we think we need to hit.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:37:09
      I think the other point I'm making is we have a set of data.
    • 01:37:13
      We need to look at that.
    • 01:37:15
      How do we get a set of data?
    • 01:37:16
      It may be one of the service type data.
    • 01:37:18
      It may be better than what we currently use.
    • 01:37:21
      But the data that's covered in the form, the traditional views of data, data show the form that we have in the form.
    • 01:37:33
      I would like to talk to you about this.
    • 01:37:35
      I'd like to look at the least-nest fashion.
    • 01:37:37
      I think it would be of interest to most of you if it's not just about statewide to entertain some questions from after the meeting.
    • 01:37:51
      Whether it's a county, whether it's any other measure.
    • 01:37:53
      What is that measure for if it's a civil regional county or a local county?
    • 01:37:56
      So I think we're going to expand to regional measures.
    • 01:37:58
      Another means is to pretend to go and explain how well you're doing.
    • 01:38:03
      One way to do that, and this is resistive, buying transportation tickets, or this is to benchmark against other states.
    • 01:38:13
      We have to do that for all.
    • 01:38:16
      I think there's anything in most cases where it's a settlement, so it's probably with mine based on thinking it's other states' peers who don't want to benchmark against us.
    • 01:38:26
      But one way, we have to constantly provide transportation.
    • 01:38:30
      It's big, and the situation is also large.
    • 01:38:32
      How do you compare two other states?
    • 01:38:35
      I think that's one thing that we could use.
    • 01:38:37
      We use it for the sake of the day.
    • 01:38:39
      Virginia is the 12th best managed state in the United States?
    • 01:38:49
      Why?
    • 01:38:49
      Because we're benchmarking against all other states in the United States.
    • 01:38:56
      So I think we can do the same kind of thing for transportation.
    • 01:38:58
      As the vehicle disabled, with the question about VDOT and its performance, how do we compare it to the other states?
    • 01:39:04
      And I think in a lot of cases, particularly in cases such as the dashboard, which is managed
    • 01:39:07
      My problem to note is I don't know if we have done the type of job we need to do to promote and educate the public on what we do in vaccination education.
    • 01:39:30
      And I think we need to do this better.
    • 01:39:34
      This year, we have come before us a number of new performance measures, much later so we'll recommend a new performance measure.
    • 01:39:44
      The citizens have said we're not doing a good job in transportation.
    • 01:39:47
      We need to get ahead of that.
    • 01:39:48
      We need to figure out how we promote what we're doing.
    • 01:39:52
      If that's what it's best to recognize, then you'll put it back to performance-based states in the country if you don't know that.
    • 01:39:58
      Well, some of what we need to do is, I think, to mention his head that the reference to some of that detail is we need to promote and educate the public more on what's going on in Virginia Tech.
    • 01:40:09
      Think about it.
    • 01:40:10
      What do you think is the best way to go about doing that?
    • 01:40:12
      So that, the questions I've asked about performance, and this is something that the legislature is not continually questioning us in terms of what your performance measures are and what you use, and not developing new measures.
    • 01:40:27
      We need to get ahead of that.
    • 01:40:28
      We need to have new measures so that, in general, if someone is there, they're already having measures, and not having any new measures including music and new requirements on that.
    • 01:40:35
      But I think promoting the education and development, we need to figure out how to do that.
    • 01:40:39
      First of all, we don't have to do that right now.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:40
      Mr. Chairman, among the many good points Ralph has made, I think this is an important one that at least I would like to weigh in and encourage us to have a discussion and conversation about.
    • 01:41:04
      There's certainly a political element to it which we don't particularly need to get into,
    • 01:41:10
      There are some real stories to tell about the Virginia Transportation Program that in many cases certainly do lead the nation.
    • 01:41:19
      And we shouldn't hide our light under a bushel basket when we've got something good to promote and talk about.
    • 01:41:26
      And we have several good things to promote and talk about.
    • 01:41:30
      And telling our story to the public
    • 01:41:33
      I would encourage us to figure out soon ways to do that in the months ahead so that the public knows what they're getting, how much bang for the buck they're getting, and even comparative analysis of how much it costs to deliver that bang for whatever buck they want to cough up.
    • 01:41:49
      Because they don't see it as coming out of left pocket, right pocket, back pocket, side pocket.
    • 01:41:55
      It's all coming out of their pocket.
    • 01:41:57
      Mr. Chairman, thank you.
    • 01:42:02
      I wanted to add two cents to that as well.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:24
      Some of the difficulty that we have is we do speak to citizens of the Commonwealth in governmental terms, using governmental measures, when actually there's an opportunity to speak to them as consumers of the transportation services that are provided.
    • 01:42:42
      And that approach is a very different one.
    • 01:42:44
      It's not as a good citizen, you deserve an accounting of your tax dollars.
    • 01:42:49
      It's as a member of the traveling public, you deserve a quality service.
    • 01:42:54
      Here's the value proposition.
    • 01:42:56
      Here's why a hot lane will work for you.
    • 01:42:58
      Here's why transit will work for you.
    • 01:43:01
      And that's very different than just bundling reports.
    • 01:43:04
      R. E. Taylor III, George W. Bush, George W. Bush III, George W. Bush III, George W. Bush III
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:43:24
      Mr.
    • 01:43:25
      Chair, I agree, and I would probably give us the meeting done across the first century.
    • 01:43:39
      What is the best public building you want when we look at our websites?
    • 01:43:43
      Is that for the public, or is that food, or what is activity?
    • 01:43:46
      An example would be, it's probably for flight timing, no travel time.
    • 01:43:49
      If I'm any problem with both of these things, you know, I'm aware of at least one of the things I've asked a couple of times for a particular sector of highway.
    • 01:44:05
      It tells you it's normally a picture of the third ministry on that matter.
    • 01:44:13
      Today, in five-minute intervals,
    • 01:44:14
      It's going to take you four minutes to do that.
    • 01:44:23
      This is something that would appeal to the film public because, I mean, you can't show a little bit because it's like a novel, and so does it, to see that by sight.
    • 01:44:29
      The impact that that really focuses directly on something, and I talk about the way that it's a really immediate thing to show it to me, you know, it was 30 minutes, but it's not minutes.
    • 01:44:38
      Mr. Chairman, I think there's a germ of an idea here.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:02
      If you take this customer-centric focus
    • 01:45:06
      What do people listen to in the morning?
    • 01:45:10
      Every five minutes on the ones or the eights or the tens, they've got their radios tuned to the traffic reports.
    • 01:45:19
      I mean, there's so much invested by people trying to figure out what's going on.
    • 01:45:25
      And if we start thinking about it in those terms, in terms of delivering solutions, I think was the phrase, what's our service delivery goal?
    • 01:45:36
      When we think about it in those terms, we get a little bit different set of questions to be raised and answers to be suggested, perhaps, because people really are interested in this information, and we ought to be able to figure out a way that answers that with performance and improvements to their situation and shows them what it's going to cost, because there is no free lunch.
    • 01:45:58
      We know that, but I'm not sure everybody out there gets that point.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:05
      Interesting observations, ones which will lead to, I have no doubt, some interesting conversations over the next few months.
    • 01:46:13
      We really appreciate that.
    • 01:46:15
      The secretary has joined us.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:46:18
      I yield the chair to the chair.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:33
      Thank you, and my apologies for the delay.
    • 01:46:36
      I'll have an opportunity to talk a little bit about Mr. Martin and I, our travels today, a little bit later on the agenda.
    • 01:46:44
      The next item on the agenda is a presentation and preview of Dashboard 3.0.
    • 01:46:52
      Dr. Gary Allen accompanied by Murali Rao will be making this presentation.
    • 01:46:57
      Welcome, Dr. Allen.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:46:59
      Good afternoon.
    • 01:47:00
      I'm glad to have an opportunity to talk with you again.
    • 01:47:06
      I'm going to talk very briefly about that for 3.08.
    • 01:47:09
      Some of you may recall that we began the process of measuring performance in 2003.
    • 01:47:23
      I think measuring performance
    • 01:47:25
      It's a lot lighter.
    • 01:47:32
      The game's off.
    • 01:47:35
      It really isn't a game of purpose.
    • 01:47:41
      But it's a game of making some steps, like we lose a step, taking that little step and getting it off the rim.
    • 01:47:47
      What I want to do is just very briefly give you an overview of where we're heading in the next steps of the VDOT bags.
    • 01:47:55
      And I think it's quite relevant in much of the discussion that we've had to the point.
    • 01:48:01
      We released the Act for 1.0 in March 2003, and the focus of that badge before was about construction.
    • 01:48:11
      being on time and on budget, and maintenance being on time and on budget.
    • 01:48:18
      And we knew at that time that there might be other kinds of things that we would like to put on the negative.
    • 01:48:28
      However, we also knew that those too will be lost.
    • 01:48:33
      And you can get those out there and begin to make the performance.
    • 01:48:39
      We would at least do two minutes.
    • 01:48:41
      Number one, we can identify where our performance is.
    • 01:48:47
      And number two, we have a chance to set some goals and make that performance better.
    • 01:48:57
      Some of you may also recall that when we started that process in 2003, we had an awful lot of red dots on an annual, a lot of red dots.
    • 01:49:07
      But we weren't concerned about that.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:49:11
      Because it was better than looking at a screen with a blue dot, thinking that you're doing great.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:49:19
      They rolled out the ad for a few points.
    • 01:49:21
      They wrote a figure like, you out, you down, you out.
    • 01:49:26
      And the reason that we did that, how many times did we do that?
    • 01:49:30
      How many times?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:49:32
      We rolled out that second version in 2005 and we added information about operations and information about safety.
    • 01:49:53
      We added a monthly report on the status of finance in this department.
    • 01:49:59
      and we added a section dealing with environmental compliance because we thought those are important things for us to make available for the public.
    • 01:50:13
      Now there's loads and loads of information there.
    • 01:50:16
      If you want to go and explore the details of any project under way, you can do that.
    • 01:50:20
      However, my 81-year-old mother can also go to that dashboard and look at the set of dials and know how we're doing and what Marani and I affectionately call a Level Zero.
    • 01:50:35
      Level Zero is just a dial up there for you.
    • 01:50:36
      It's going to be a red, yellow, and green.
    • 01:50:38
      It's going to tell you something about where you are on the dashboard.
    • 01:50:45
      This is what that dashboard looks like right now.
    • 01:50:48
      Pretty simple to understand.
    • 01:50:51
      Gives you a snapshot of what's going on.
    • 01:50:54
      Might not be perfect, but it does tell you what's going on.
    • 01:50:58
      The area of all operations links you to road conditions, links you to 511 Virginia,
    • 01:51:07
      Let's tell you what the details are.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:51:10
      You can drill down into details about studies, design, product transformation, all sorts of things about finance, act of work support, capital benefits, et cetera, environmental compliance, employment.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:51:24
      I think you know what is contained in that category.
    • 01:51:31
      We're now almost two years out from dashboard 3.0.
    • 01:51:37
      In view of the Accountability Commission work, in view of VTrans 2025 and the performance report, in view of the government's scorecard, and in view of the environment we face, which is an environment that is severely revenue-constrained, but with great challenges across the Commonwealth,
    • 01:52:04
      All the way to Northern Virginia, where our concern is a suggestion affecting economic vitality, to Southwest Virginia, where accessibility is the key to economic development.
    • 01:52:20
      We have to come up with ways to go beyond on-time and on-play.
    • 01:52:26
      And our version 3.0 is designed to take us another step in that direction.
    • 01:52:31
      We want to focus on overall accountability for the department.
    • 01:52:37
      We want to provide public-facing measures in measures that my mother and my father will understand and want to see.
    • 01:52:48
      Incorporate multiple scorecards.
    • 01:52:51
      That's a high-polluted way of saying try to take account of
    • 01:52:56
      The different viewpoints and perspectives that are coming to transportation in terms of performance measures.
    • 01:53:13
      Continue that data-driven approach.
    • 01:53:16
      That's critical.
    • 01:53:17
      Absolutely critical.
    • 01:53:18
      Why is it critical?
    • 01:53:18
      Because we don't want to ever be accused of cooking the numbers.
    • 01:53:23
      If we cook the numbers, there is no accountability.
    • 01:53:26
      And that's the great thing about the dashboard, 1.0 and 2.0.
    • 01:53:31
      We have been contacted by, I guess it's at least 25 or 30 states, not just EOD, but states that vary as well, the local governments and the private sector, and a couple of universities who are very interested in making work out some kind of a deal.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:53:55
      to use the national defense because they are so excited about what VDOT has done.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:54:03
      That data-driven approach is key to that.
    • 01:54:08
      Continued public transparency.
    • 01:54:11
      That's key to trust.
    • 01:54:15
      You have a capability in the public sector of putting little trust dollars over here in the bank.
    • 01:54:24
      There's ways to do that every day, every week, every month.
    • 01:54:32
      You have to be really careful, though, about pulling things out of that bank.
    • 01:54:39
      Because it doesn't take very much to lose that bank account.
    • 01:54:44
      So transparency is the real key to that 43.0.
    • 01:54:48
      We've got to maintain that transparency with those.
    • 01:54:51
      Our vision right now, and we are in the early stages of this, is to focus on the following areas.
    • 01:55:01
      High rate conditions.
    • 01:55:03
      That means the physical assets that are out there.
    • 01:55:05
      What kind of condition are they in?
    • 01:55:08
      That's indicative of whether we are doing our job in maintenance, which is what we're supposed to do.
    • 01:55:15
      Are we taking care of what we do?
    • 01:55:18
      Are the bridges in good shape?
    • 01:55:21
      Are the vapors in good shape?
    • 01:55:24
      How about the guardrail?
    • 01:55:25
      What can we say about those things?
    • 01:55:28
      I weigh performance.
    • 01:55:29
      That goes with the issue of objective mitigation and congestion management, both from the standpoint of recurring congestion and non-recurring congestion.
    • 01:55:40
      Just had a lively discussion about that.
    • 01:55:43
      I weigh safety.
    • 01:55:45
      I weigh safety.
    • 01:55:48
      Very, very important.
    • 01:55:52
      Why is it important?
    • 01:55:54
      Well, if there were a plane crash tomorrow, at the International Airport here, there were six people killed.
    • 01:56:04
      It would make headlines for a long time.
    • 01:56:09
      National Transportation Board would be here.
    • 01:56:11
      It would be examinations, what went wrong, license and learn, et cetera.
    • 01:56:16
      So if we kill 950 people on the highway to Virginia, and we do it one at a time, it doesn't make that difference.
    • 01:56:29
      And yet, it's just important.
    • 01:56:31
      So safety is critical.
    • 01:56:34
      Finance, revenue, and spending.
    • 01:56:35
      We've got that in the dashboard now.
    • 01:56:36
      We need to keep it there.
    • 01:56:38
      It's the public's money.
    • 01:56:40
      VDOT doesn't get one dime that they don't take from you and me for a time.
    • 01:56:47
      Customer Satisfaction, that's an entirely new piece we're proposing in Dash 4.3.0.
    • 01:56:54
      I think those are Mr. Koelemay's points.
    • 01:56:58
      We want to know what the public thinks, and we need to ask them about some real simple stuff.
    • 01:57:07
      Not an absolute word, but just real simple stuff.
    • 01:57:10
      Be on management performance, and you'll see in just a minute what we've got in our math there.
    • 01:57:16
      Central Commission, real quickly, payments, britches, and other things.
    • 01:57:21
      Ladies and gentlemen, we're proposing a good fair court.
    • 01:57:26
      How long can I understand that?
    • 01:57:28
      She likes that kind of look.
    • 01:57:32
      We're going to list all the things that the BRICS project has been drilled down.
    • 01:57:37
      You can get all the information there.
    • 01:57:39
      It's going to focus on state-maintained, state-owned facilities at this point.
    • 01:57:43
      We'd love to be able to add local jurisdictions.
    • 01:57:46
      If we get saved, it's going to be a problem.
    • 01:57:49
      It has to go and move down the road.
    • 01:57:51
      Managing suggestions.
    • 01:57:54
      Managing suggestions.
    • 01:57:57
      Why is this important?
    • 01:57:59
      Well, we know it's important because it has to do with economic vitality, and it has to do with quality of life.
    • 01:58:05
      I've just put up several simple performance areas up here for you to look at.
    • 01:58:15
      HOV performance, major commutative valve performance, and incidences and clearing state line and on major valves.
    • 01:58:22
      The first two items deal with recurring congestion.
    • 01:58:29
      The last one deals more with non-occurring congestion.
    • 01:58:32
      Mr. Davis talked about the percentages.
    • 01:58:36
      Non-recurring is in the realm of around 40%.
    • 01:58:40
      Sometimes it's not as big as 40%.
    • 01:58:43
      So we do something there, we make great strides.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:47
      Excuse me, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:58:51
      I'm not sure I understand what non-recurring means in this context.
    • 01:58:54
      What is non-recurring?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:58:57
      What non-recurring means is a suggestion that is created by an incident that is not associated with normal peak period travel.
    • 01:59:09
      So even a weather event
    • 01:59:13
      It is still non-recurring congestion, but it would throw a red flag for you that, okay, there might be something else going on here in terms of your traffic control, the configuration for roadway, those kinds of things.
    • 01:59:40
      Okay, there was some discussion about can you make a suggestion?
    • 01:59:48
      Well, you know, you can't.
    • 01:59:50
      You can make a suggestion.
    • 01:59:53
      We've got about 700 sensors, loop detectors, and cameras and all kinds of devices, and no one's gonna be here alone.
    • 02:00:00
      We can get information, and we do.
    • 02:00:03
      We have a data archive that sits here in Richmond.
    • 02:00:09
      We get 24-7, 365, continuous feed information that we accumulate in five-minute segments.
    • 02:00:16
      It comes every one minute.
    • 02:00:19
      We can tell a whole lot about what's going on with congestion.
    • 02:00:23
      There's a lot of different ways to measure it.
    • 02:00:25
      We can get into the details of that as we move forward, but what we want to do is we intend to measure performance, so ladies and gentlemen, because once we do that, it's just exactly the same as the step we took with construction on time and already, then we can begin to do something about it.
    • 02:00:49
      We can tell people about it.
    • 02:00:51
      We can help them improve their travel reliability, their travel time reliability.
    • 02:00:53
      A lot of staff that you can take along those lines of communication to do that.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:01:01
      Safety.
    • 02:01:02
      The safety measures I've mentioned here are pretty extensive.
    • 02:01:06
      These safety measures are linked directly to the supposed strategic timing safety plan.
    • 02:01:13
      And they are measures for which DINA is being held accountable in that strategic timing safety plan.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:01:22
      Craggett, the Valley, the Valley Road, the Partridge, Intersection Craggett, various events made with injuries, injuries, and work zones.
    • 02:01:34
      Finance, we'll all look at graduated forecast and actual expenditures, forecast and actual purchasing power trends.
    • 02:01:40
      Why is that important?
    • 02:01:43
      I think you understand why that's important.
    • 02:01:46
      That's not currently on the dashboard, but if we can get that information, we can put it out there.
    • 02:01:50
      Customer Satisfaction is a brand new section of the Proposed Act of 3.0.
    • 02:01:56
      We want to gather information from the public in public information surveys.
    • 02:02:03
      We're going to go out with a fourth wave of that kind of survey.
    • 02:02:08
      We're going to collect information on the overall roadway maintenance, pavement smoothness, and ride quality.
    • 02:02:14
      We know that's important based upon the national statistics that we already have.
    • 02:02:19
      Emergency response, federal removal, design and maintenance, bridges, right there in the middle of the moon, from the south side of the area, etc.
    • 02:02:27
      The last one you'll see is communication with the public.
    • 02:02:30
      We think that's important too for us to ask them, how are we doing that?
    • 02:02:34
      They may tell us we're doing great.
    • 02:02:37
      They might also tell us we're doing it hard.
    • 02:02:41
      In either way, we need to know.
    • 02:02:43
      Management performance.
    • 02:02:45
      This is busy slide, and I'm going to go through all of it.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:02:49
      The top part of the slide is on the development project delivery, related to the construction and maintenance program.
    • 02:02:56
      All that data is available right now or since it's on.
    • 02:02:59
      included under the VDOT management performance.
    • 02:03:02
      The governor's court garden makers are all there as well.
    • 02:03:05
      That's an important thing to at least have available to provide this consistency in terms of the public facing information that's being provided on the dashboard.
    • 02:03:19
      Now let me make one other point with respect to the dashboard.
    • 02:03:22
      The dashboard is not a place that you put absolutely all the information about transportation.
    • 02:03:31
      The dashboard needs to be a place that you have some important level zero information like you do in the dashboard of your vehicle.
    • 02:03:42
      If you see that something's wrong with the oil indicator,
    • 02:03:48
      It doesn't necessarily enable you to diagnose the problem sitting there in your car, but it does pay you better get out of the car and figure out the problem.
    • 02:04:01
      Dashboards can help you do that.
    • 02:04:04
      We are in the very earliest stage of developing this dashboard.
    • 02:04:11
      We're all in aisles.
    • 02:04:12
      We have a lot of work to do between now and July 1st.
    • 02:04:15
      We are at the stage, however, that we would welcome input from the Commonwealth Transportation Board as they get ready to roll with it.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:26
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:04:27
      Thank you, Dr. Allen.
    • 02:04:27
      Questions or comments?
    • 02:04:29
      Ms. Conlon.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:04:29
      This is such an incredibly rich and useful tool.
    • 02:04:33
      Do you have an accountability measure for it?
    • 02:04:37
      In other words, how many people actually go on and use this information?
    • 02:04:42
      How accessible is it?
    • 02:04:44
      I have it my favorite places, so I can get to it very easily.
    • 02:04:49
      But I guess my first question is, do you have an inkling as to how many hits you get, or who your current audience is, and what your goal might be for what percentage of the driving public really
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:05:02
      I know that whenever we roll out, whenever we roll out, we do early.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:05:10
      They're usually associated with that press release, there's plenty of time in the media to go along with that, and early on you will get a number of hits.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:05:19
      A lot of interest, okay?
    • 02:05:21
      You'll get a lot of questions.
    • 02:05:23
      We probably are getting maybe 15 inquiries a month on the current dashboard.
    • 02:05:31
      I don't think we have a tool right now that we're monitoring the kids, but we're always telling them where we are.
    • 02:05:41
      We do have the tools.
    • 02:05:42
      We've got the statistics, and we can provide that to you offline.
    • 02:05:45
      We know whether people are using it or not.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:05:50
      Well, to me, that's a huge goal, would be to increase the number of people who are using it.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:05:59
      Marali, please come up to the podium, please.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:06:18
      It's more that I want to be sure that an effort is being made to make it more accessible and or people know
    • 02:06:47
      We do include a very prominent link from the VDOT external website.
    • 02:06:55
      We could, I'm sure, include a link from the Secretary's website.
    • 02:06:59
      It's like many other kinds of things.
    • 02:07:02
      It's not putty technology.
    • 02:07:05
      In other words, we're not forcing it on folks through some mechanism that you might see when you automatically break up your computer.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:16
      Dr. Allen, we've talked about this a little bit before, you and I, but also in various groups.
    • 02:07:24
      A couple of things here.
    • 02:07:25
      You've been able to document very well that people would like to have more information at every stage of their travel.
    • 02:07:32
      Steve Pittard III, Steve Pittard III, James R. Homer
    • 02:07:52
      What I would suggest even goes further is if we view these people as consumers, we figure out ways that we don't force them through the government structure to get that information or force them into a charged political discussion of whether it's congested or not or whether it's a priority or not.
    • 02:08:15
      Their ability to make decisions, good decisions that enhance the capacity and operations of the system are something they can do without necessarily being directed if they have information.
    • 02:08:28
      Organizing around that information as opposed to around the other functions of the transportation department is a very, very different organizational step.
    • 02:08:42
      And I'll just say this now because we're going to have some more discussions on it, but we've talked about greatly increasing the amount of resources that goes into the operations of our facilities in Northern Virginia because we know in the short term we really can't increase the capacity very much.
    • 02:08:58
      And yet that's like pulling teeth with some people.
    • 02:09:01
      So I think that's going to be a major discussion this board has and that you'll be able to help us with.
    • 02:09:08
      So I appreciate the progress.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:12
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:09:14
      Gary, I want to describe a specific problem, and I'd like you to tell me whether you think the dashboard can address it, or whether it does, or whether it can.
    • 02:09:27
      And this is a true story.
    • 02:09:30
      I was there.
    • 02:09:32
      We had, and it's an example, we had an intersection in Fauquier County where there were a significant number of fatalities over time.
    • 02:09:41
      We needed traffic.
    • 02:09:43
      We sat down at the time with VDOT and had discussion about it.
    • 02:09:50
      VDOT was in agreement that we needed a traffic light.
    • 02:09:54
      VDOT had a design for it, and VDOT told us, well, you ought to get, see if you can get the money, because it really does need to be done.
    • 02:10:04
      It was $12 million.
    • 02:10:07
      And we all looked at the situation in disbelief and we said, why can't we spend a quarter of a million dollars for a traffic light?
    • 02:10:17
      And the answer was, and I was there, but there were a hundred engineering reasons according to, you know, 50 different manuals.
    • 02:10:29
      Why this was the only appropriate solution, the $12 million solution and it involved site distances and it involved taking out hills and flattening roads and redefining the landscape for about a mile in each direction.
    • 02:10:46
      The bottom line is we all decided that by God we were going to get that $250,000 traffic light and we went around
    • 02:10:55
      And we got it.
    • 02:10:56
      And it's there.
    • 02:10:57
      And it's been there now for three years.
    • 02:11:00
      And it's not perfect.
    • 02:11:02
      And there have been a couple fender benders, but nobody's died there.
    • 02:11:06
      My point is that even if you had a gazillion dollars, the $250,000 solution,
    • 02:11:14
      Okay, in that situation was actually the right solution and certainly in a resource constrained environment it was the right solution because it increased safety, it saved lives, and it used a minimal amount of taxpayer money to do.
    • 02:11:32
      That's not to say that that's always the appropriate answer, but there are times when it will be.
    • 02:11:41
      A similar but slightly different example, I had an email yesterday on my computer from someone I know.
    • 02:11:50
      Peter, would you look into the fact VDOT wants to spend two and a half million dollars for this installation in our community that nobody here wants or thinks we need and yet they keep insisting that we do.
    • 02:12:07
      Now, I haven't looked into it, so I don't know the circumstances, but what I'm trying to get at is there are times when on time, on budget isn't enough, as you appropriately pointed out, but particularly so if it's not the right project.
    • 02:12:23
      In my world of commercial real estate development, I can't tell you how many times I had architects come to me with conceptual plans for office buildings that there was no question our organization could build them on time, build them on budget.
    • 02:12:40
      The only problem is that the budget was twice what it needed to be.
    • 02:12:44
      J. J. D.
    • 02:13:08
      Early on, preliminary or conceptual design issues, whether in fact we're looking at the right project to address the problem from a resource efficiency standpoint as well as from an engineering standpoint.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:13:25
      I think from a system, from an individual project-by-project, examine, aid, and stash, what does John Belk design to do, what
    • 02:13:35
      I do think that when we talk about doing a customer satisfaction survey, and we're going to do a couple of those in a year, we're going to be able to parse that information by the directory.
    • 02:13:57
      Certainly we could include tons of questions in that survey that you get at the point you're making.
    • 02:14:03
      and then give VDOT some very good information about its general approach to responding to those kinds of transudated needs.
    • 02:14:19
      And clearly, if the public believes the solutions that VDOT is proposing are either A,
    • 02:14:28
      Hill, or B, a solution that the public doesn't want or doesn't feel like they need.
    • 02:14:39
      And that's important information for VDOT to have.
    • 02:14:43
      I'm sure that there would be instances where that information can feed the VDOT the ways that they need to change the approach to this.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:14:55
      I wonder if I could ask you to do this.
    • 02:14:58
      You say you're at sort of the conceptual stage of Dashboard 3.0.
    • 02:15:02
      If you wouldn't mind, as you work through it, just giving some additional thought to this particular problem and letting us know whether there's a way to adapt the design of the dashboard
    • 02:15:17
      On slide seven,
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:15:42
      with the thought in terms of making Slide 7 supportive of Slide 11, a system condition supportive of customer satisfaction.
    • 02:15:51
      Consider, please consider the rating scale changing that.
    • 02:15:57
      As it stands, you've got the middle ground in there.
    • 02:16:02
      What we have is a situation where some people
    • 02:16:04
      will actually see two categories of good and one category of poor.
    • 02:16:09
      Other people will see two categories of poor, one category of good.
    • 02:16:14
      Whereas if you had a simple satisfactory, unsatisfactory, pass fail, yes, no, that's something that even my four-year-old can know what it means.
    • 02:16:23
      And it will relate back to customer satisfaction
    • 02:16:28
      I think this customer satisfaction is a good thing and just a couple of thoughts about it.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:44
      One, the Governor talked extensively during his campaign and since he's been elected about the difference between on time, on budget being efficiency and
    • 02:16:54
      J. J. J. J.
    • 02:17:07
      Peter Schwartz and I are thinking about here, and how can you factor that in, and does this fit?
    • 02:17:13
      And I know one simple way to do it is to provide a very obvious, easy-to-use feedback.
    • 02:17:21
      Send an email to you or whomever.
    • 02:17:24
      I don't know who to write.
    • 02:17:25
      III, Michael A. Davis, John C. Connally, John C. Connally III, John C. Connally III, John C. Connally III,
    • 02:17:49
      Not welcome, because that's not right.
    • 02:17:51
      I think we welcome them to treat that.
    • 02:17:54
      But I think I want you to, I want somebody to get it and say, ah, look at this, at least the constructive suggestions anyway.
    • 02:18:03
      We all get complaints, but.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:18:06
      I think to make sure I understand your point, I think what you're suggesting is that in the current version of the dashboard there is a pretty easy way for someone to send a note to make sure of something else.
    • 02:18:18
      What you're suggesting is
    • 02:18:19
      I think that, yes you are, Gary, and I think that would be one way of addressing the larger question of effectiveness rather than just efficiency.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:38
      Are we doing the right things, not just are we doing things well?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:18:44
      Any other questions?
    • 02:18:47
      Thank you, Mr. Allen.
    • 02:18:48
      Can we look forward to the actual presentation of Dashboard 3.0, Commissioner?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:18:54
      The next item on the agenda is on the Telegraph Road Connector.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:03
      That's an alternative corridor for Woodlawn Road.
    • 02:19:06
      Dennis Morrison, Northern Virginia District Administrator, and I just would comment, Commissioner, I know all of us are so pleased on these local and regional issues to see the person with the on-the-ground accountability here before the CTB.
    • 02:19:19
      I think that's really a great innovation in this.
    • 02:19:22
      Welcome, Mr. Morrison.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:19:25
      I'm here to talk about the Brisbane Highway Telegraph for the connector.
    • 02:19:37
      My presentation today is trying to obtain approval of two items.
    • 02:19:42
      One is the project location and the second is the project landowner agreement and I'll go through that in a little bit.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:07
      I can see some of us celebrating together this week.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:20:14
      I can see some of us celebrating together this week.
    • 02:20:19
      All right, since we're out here, I'm going to show you the study area.
    • 02:20:25
      If you look to the left, that's kind of small, but that's the project location.
    • 02:20:31
      That's right in front of you.
    • 02:20:31
      You'll see it tonight.
    • 02:20:32
      Adjacent to Route 1, Fairfax County.
    • 02:20:34
      If you look at the map on the right, you will see the view of the street is Woodland Road.
    • 02:20:38
      I'm going to leave that map up and give you a little project history here.
    • 02:20:43
      The access to Fort Belvoir was restricted after 9 or 11.
    • 02:20:48
      That was closure of Woodland Road, and you see that on the right, on the view of the group.
    • 02:20:57
      It was closed to the general public.
    • 02:21:00
      When those two roads were closed, they caused traffic congestion and delay, and traffic shifted to Alton and Brown.
    • 02:21:06
      The roads were closed due to security reasons through this award, and alternate replacement routes were evaluated by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in 2003 by a preliminary feasibility study.
    • 02:21:24
      FHWA, the Eastern Federal Land Highway Division, is the lead agency for this project.
    • 02:21:31
      They are preparing the environmental assessment.
    • 02:21:34
      The project purpose is to restore the Richmond Highway, U.S. Route 1, Helen Press Road, and Route 6-11 public access lanes to the roadway on an alignment that does not correct the security of the failing wall.
    • 02:22:02
      And it's also to reduce traffic congestion and delay of breaches.
    • 02:22:21
      When we started, this had nothing to do with graphics.
    • 02:22:24
      I don't have any questions.
    • 02:22:24
      This is closing time.
    • 02:22:25
      The alternatives that we looked at, in 2003, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers feasibility study, they developed several alternatives.
    • 02:22:29
      We can narrow down to seven and illustrate it on this map.
    • 02:22:32
      The Army identified Alternative C, and that's the old railroad extension, I think it's the third alternative.
    • 02:22:45
      Fairfax County endorsed Alternative A, B, or C for a combination of their alternatives were re-examined in the deep discussion in the environmental assessment.
    • 02:22:57
      Alternative screening, and I'm just going to go over and see whether it's with you.
    • 02:23:14
      The no-build alternatives and other transits do not meet the project purpose of the meeting.
    • 02:23:19
      Such transits and transactions demand management.
    • 02:23:20
      Alternatives A and B in combination, there are, use existing view history to terminate it at health care at-roads, but eliminated by the Army for national security concerns.
    • 02:23:27
      Alternative D, generally collated, co-located with the major transmission line order, was eliminated because of the need of residential properties on the board to limit impacts to wetlands and the Humphrey Engineer Center and the closeness to wildlife habitat.
    • 02:23:50
      Alternatives E, F, and G, which eliminated from early to costly transfers, coordinates of the Hunt-Lehman others far, and that's a 1,425-acre natural resources area in the county.
    • 02:24:04
      authored in C, has remained authored in 4C bar in the EA process, and that's the preferred alternative.
    • 02:24:19
      Generally follows along with times in undeveloped areas with reduced impacts in the third-generation wildlife, adverse impacts in woodland plantations to be dedicated.
    • 02:24:29
      environment, we'll set the timing, record the course of ER, then we'll go to the extension.
    • 02:24:37
      A significant of noticing of significant impact on food is likely because no residents were taken, no direct impact, no impacts in services in the facility, no impacts of threats in endangered species, no significant impact in the state government or the public or the mitigation for adverse effects in the form of resources in the facility.
    • 02:25:05
      Comments from the public?
    • 02:25:06
      On the EA, including the citizens task force, the county department reported the project to the public, including the citizens task force, the county department reported the project. The project cannot wait for RAC decisions.
    • 02:25:22
      I included old road, black lanes, in the typical sections of the road, in terms of the access for days and businesses, and residents of the northern end of the terminal, start cases for mitigation measures, so the second one is the terminal.
    • 02:25:42
      I'm concerned about drainage, stormwater runoff, and ensure protection of the west end of the tunnel.
    • 02:25:45
      The project describes the description of the four alternatives for those project assignments from early fall to widely existing on Mill Road, Richmond Highway, and Fort Worth, and that's where I'll be pointing to.
    • 02:25:59
      The extending of Old Mill Road is a new location due toward Belvoir.
    • 02:26:13
      The whole road is a telegraph road.
    • 02:26:16
      We'll restore public links from the Richmond Highway telegraph road with a runway alignment that does not spread through the security of Belvoir.
    • 02:26:23
      The facility will provide four travel lanes, a race beacon, a curb and gutter, and a 10-foot shear to the path towards the desk.
    • 02:26:30
      For an alternative, we request CTB approval of the location of the program.
    • 02:26:40
      Arthur's project memorandum of agreement.
    • 02:26:45
      The purpose of that is to establish the curriculum's role, responsibilities, funding, procedures published in various projects, and stakeholders who will jointly participate in the environmental planning, design, and construction of alternative work that will be placed to the public within the area.
    • 02:27:02
      Woodlawn Road, and Julia R. F.H.W.A.
    • 02:27:11
      Houston-Thoroughland Highway Division is the lead agency for and providing overall coordination and management of the project.
    • 02:27:20
      VDOT is acting as a cooperating agency and responsible for guiding the decisions associated with its improvements to VDOT-owned and maintained roadways over a VDOT-entered development of law.
    • 02:27:28
      Stakeholders are F.W.S.P.
    • 02:27:31
      in the Federal Land Outlay Division, U.S. Army, O'Hare, Humphreys Engineer's Center, VDOT, Fairfax County, F.H.W.A.
    • 02:27:44
      Commission.
    • 02:27:47
      Additional issues for VDOT
    • 02:27:49
      The CTB has authorized the Center into this agreement, which he wants to do a darn good thing for District 21.
    • 02:28:04
      That's what it's supposed to be, and it should be as amended.
    • 02:28:06
      It is the same agency with the necessary locus on its maintenance, through additional authority for written and highlighted telegraph roads with long-term fuel issues, and will be for the replacement road connected written and highlighted in a telegraph road unless the road is accepted by a transportation contract.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:28:18
      We call each of the federal land our religion, but not half the authority to acquire right-of-way.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:28:26
      Neither of us will acquire right-of-way as necessary when we brought him here.
    • 02:28:28
      All code calls for the design of right of the acquisition form and construction of four lanes will be provided by the People's Access Road, TAR program, or other federal sources.
    • 02:28:48
      No state funds will be issued.
    • 02:28:52
      I've done very little to get to that point.
    • 02:28:54
      We request the CTB authorize the VDOT division to design the project in the next four days.
    • 02:28:56
      That will be delayed.
    • 02:28:57
      Q.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:06
      Questions or comments of Mr. Morris?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:10
      I have a quick observation.
    • 02:29:13
      This is a very unique area of Fairfax County.
    • 02:29:16
      It's close to Mount Vernon down the road.
    • 02:29:20
      It's Woodlawn Plantation itself is a great cultural resource.
    • 02:29:24
      There's a Frank Lloyd Wright House, the folk lady house that's been moved to that site.
    • 02:29:30
      And they do cool stuff at Fort Belvoir.
    • 02:29:32
      They have their battlefield simulation unit there where they
    • 02:29:35
      They actually build the battlefields that soldiers train on virtually before they go to Iraq or someplace like that.
    • 02:29:42
      So there are some very important national security things.
    • 02:29:46
      I have to commend everybody involved.
    • 02:29:49
      This has taken a lot of work from a lot of parties.
    • 02:29:51
      It's very complex, and it's remarkable that it's finally gotten to this stage.
    • 02:29:57
      It's taken a long time, so I salute you for that.
    • 02:30:00
      I have a question in terms of the mitigation
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:30:03
      B. Doolittle, John C. Doolittle
    • 02:30:19
      Well, one is to provide access to the store here.
    • 02:30:29
      Anyone that doesn't provide any different access, you know, you got to put one of the databases back there.
    • 02:30:38
      There's no big swath of land.
    • 02:30:39
      The land we're taking from the store property, a poor build or a swath of land.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:42
      This will significantly improve a congestion and mobility issue that has been increasing since 9-11, correct?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:31:05
      Absolutely.
    • 02:31:07
      And when I see you today, I see you again by the gesture and I can totally add to your support and confidence for the play.
    • 02:31:16
      That area, Route 1 is one of our...
    • 02:31:19
      goes back to that product, Ford, on my data.
    • 02:31:33
      The book is an old highlight.
    • 02:31:34
      It has many, many access things.
    • 02:31:35
      It does control access, management access issues.
    • 02:31:36
      There's just tons of them.
    • 02:31:36
      A lot of that great intersection comes with signal lights, the revenues.
    • 02:31:38
      The peak hours are long, at least three hours, hours of dead, running full, so anything we can do to enhance the system there will definitely improve congestion and accidents.
    • 02:31:59
      We ought to have enough study for that corridor, the safety corridor, and look at ways from pedestrian safety to vehicle safety.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:32:02
      We look for opportunities to have some of the most important interventions today.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:32:19
      High accident locations.
    • 02:32:20
      What you do, you enhance safety at those locations.
    • 02:32:21
      We're looking at that.
    • 02:32:21
      It's just not a normal Virginia corridor.
    • 02:32:22
      It's also a very difficult area.
    • 02:32:23
      You have to do Route 1, you have to do Route 4.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:24
      And I also appreciate the multipurpose bike and pedestrian.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:32
      Thank you.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:32
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • 02:32:33
      Dennis, is this a limited access road for the full length of the connector?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:32:41
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:32:46
      There is no limited access.
    • 02:32:47
      So that's the norm with ours on the bike.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:50
      And that's an important question.
    • 02:32:54
      Has that issue been resolved about the Army's ability to obtain additional access points in the memorandum of understanding?
    • 02:33:07
      It requires the concurrence of VDOT before those can occur.
    • 02:33:14
      Understood.
    • 02:33:16
      The chair would observe that this is the third time this has been on the agenda.
    • 02:33:21
      It's been six years since this road that was constructed by the Commonwealth was closed.
    • 02:33:27
      And I really appreciate your persistence.
    • 02:33:32
      We have some larger issues with Fort Belvoir.
    • 02:33:34
      This is a tiny issue.
    • 02:33:36
      And they're very, very difficult to work out.
    • 02:33:39
      So this is,
    • 02:33:42
      A good note, but again it's taken six years to get to this point, so thank you Mr. Morrison.
    • 02:33:49
      And this will be listed as an action item on tomorrow's agenda.
    • 02:33:54
      Okay, the last item on the work session is a lengthy
    • 02:33:59
      This presentation, what I would like to do is to break this up because there's a lot in here. And while Mr. Carr is getting set, the first thing that I would like to say that since the General Assembly adjourned on the 24th of February, the Governor has been trying to get his arms around this bill. Thank you.
    • 02:34:24
      and he has done that in a variety of ways.
    • 02:34:27
      One of them is here today and so we will be taking notes at the conclusion of this to get a sense of the body or of individuals as to various aspects of this legislation as well as there will be presentation on other pieces of legislation passed.
    • 02:34:47
      But the big one is House Bill 3202.
    • 02:34:51
      You may know that
    • 02:34:53
      The Governor has had a series of meetings around the state and some of you have taken it upon yourselves to show up at those meetings and I know the Governor very much appreciates that.
    • 02:35:09
      In the rush of time, it was not possible to structure something so that we could have every mayor, every CTB member, everyone there at those meetings.
    • 02:35:19
      I oftentimes learn from those at 10 o'clock the night before.
    • 02:35:23
      It's a very, very rushed schedule, and the important thing from the governor's perspective is to have these discussions out in the open and to do them outside of Capitol Square.
    • 02:35:37
      And it's been really a very, very good learning experience for the governor who after 140 legislators have done their thing, there are equal branches of government.
    • 02:35:46
      And so this is part of his deliberative process.
    • 02:35:49
      What I would like to ask in terms of this presentation, because I know some of you have read the bill, most of you read news articles about it, is I'm going to ask Mr. Carr to walk us through the four major components of House Bill 3202.
    • 02:36:09
      And I'd like to stop at the end of each of those components and just go around and see if there are major questions or concerns just so you don't forget.
    • 02:36:20
      And I think that will help us organize our thoughts as we communicate this to the Governor and his personal staff as he, you know, waives and deliberates on this legislation.
    • 02:36:32
      So Mr. Carr, if you could please give us the overview.
    • 02:36:38
      I know folks have been, it's been a long day already.
    • 02:36:41
      This is a terribly important piece of work that is before us.
    • 02:36:47
      And if you could, let's stop at those points of demarcation and stop for questions and comments.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:36:55
      Okay, thank you Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:37:11
      I'm going to cover a number of topics today, as the Secretary mentioned, I'll pause that for each of the four main components in House Bill 1352.
    • 02:37:15
      There's also a lot of good things going on between the government and the state package that I'll cover, and some details on that.
    • 02:37:19
      I should say before I get there that I want to divide this presentation into four different categories.
    • 02:37:32
      The first is the bonding component, which is supervised with that majority of the revenue based new.
    • 02:37:40
      I'm going to talk about new along the way creatives, regional plans, and some other battery healing issues, composition of the body, environmental review process, etc.
    • 02:37:53
      With regard to the bonds, the bill does authorize two and a half billion dollars in additional debt.
    • 02:38:01
      That would be first sold in 2009, a maximum of $300 million per year to be issued, and those for the term are greater than 20 years.
    • 02:38:15
      That money would be 4.3% would go to the Graham Hansen Fund.
    • 02:38:19
      15.7 as a minimum to go to a granted capital remainder to be spent on interstate and primary projects for the 20th and to build a bracket that cannot be spent on secondary or early projects just as in the month.
    • 02:38:37
      There's a formula that is an amalgamation of all the other existing formulas for distributing state hiring dollars that is used in determining the share of the bond revenues each district will receive.
    • 02:38:54
      The requirement is that over the life of the bill of bond issues that each interest get its fair share.
    • 02:39:05
      This is a 10% variance.
    • 02:39:06
      However, in order to accommodate a larger project in one district in one year, you wouldn't necessarily have to sell superlative bond proceeds according to this point in each year.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:21
      And if I could just stop if you want to know what that means to your district just take that percentage of 300 million dollars so for example in the Salem district roughly 10% there would be 30 million dollars a year in bond proceeds
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:53
      How are those percentages determined?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:57
      That is an amalgamation of all the formula distribution of state funds collapsed of primary, secondary and urban.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:40:07
      So it's a hybrid formula?
    • 02:40:09
      Is it fair to say that's what that is?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:12
      It is a hybrid in the sense that it's collapsing various formulas, but if someone is to ask what percentage of state dollars does the Lynchburg District get today in total of state dollars, the percentage here of 7.3% is based on the existing formula.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:34
      Is it appropriate to ask questions now?
    • 02:40:38
      Sure.
    • 02:40:38
      The secondary, the isolation of the funding just for interstate and primary, what's the ration?
    • 02:40:44
      Do you know the thinking behind excluding the secondary and urban?
    • 02:40:50
      Looking at it, lower than Virginia for instance, the secondary carry volumes that are...
    • 02:40:58
      But it was definitely put in for some purpose.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:03
      Mr. Chairman, the percentages going to each of the districts, is that percent of 80% after taking out for the rail enhancement and the transit capital, or would these also be distributed on the same percent?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:23
      No, those are the distribution of the highway funds.
    • 02:41:27
      The Rail Enhancement Fund is allocated on a project basis by this body.
    • 02:41:36
      The transit capital funds, it's a little bit of a gray area and it's unclear what is intended by the legislation.
    • 02:41:44
      That's an area that needs some clarification.
    • 02:41:46
      Would it simply be the normal capital formula or is there some discretion involved?
    • 02:41:52
      We don't know that.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:53
      If you take the 4.3% and 15.7% for rail and hash and transit capital, that's going to be 20% of the 300 million.
    • 02:42:04
      So we're talking about 80% or 240 million that would be going allocated by these distributions?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:42:19
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:42:21
      So Jimmy, issuance can start in 2009.
    • 02:42:24
      It would take eight years in order to issue the entire amount authorized?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:42:30
      That's correct.
    • 02:42:32
      How does that compare?
    • 02:42:34
      H. W. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III, John W. T. Taylor III,
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:01
      If I may take a stab at that and then ask Mr. Carr as well.
    • 02:43:08
      The first thing is this is all subject to appropriation.
    • 02:43:11
      And so one of the key points that Mr. Carr brought up is that they could not begin until 2009.
    • 02:43:18
      The reason for that is there's not an appropriation for the debt service.
    • 02:43:21
      So much of this depends on actions by the 2008 General Assembly.
    • 02:43:27
      But $300 million a year, the construction program has trended slightly above and below a billion dollars, so that $300 million a year is not insignificant.
    • 02:43:42
      But that's just for eight years.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:46
      Excuse me again, just to clarify, it's $240 million for highway and $60 million, I guess, for the rail and the transit.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:43:57
      That's correct.
    • 02:44:03
      As the Chairman noted, the very important point of the House of Commons is that it would not be in the issue until FY9, which is the first year, or fiscal year, of the next budget cycle.
    • 02:44:17
      That's very similar, as you can see, to the way that the Millennium Education Act of 2000 was brought back.
    • 02:44:23
      It was approved in 2000, but the first year of it also opened in 2002.
    • 02:44:27
      The bill calls for two hundred and forty-eight names to be appropriated in the first year.
    • 02:44:38
      That is the figure that the Appropriations Act came up with.
    • 02:44:42
      It deserves the outback grant that as well as the new bonds authorized by this Act.
    • 02:44:47
      The amount of annual debt service will grow to around $200 million dollars per year at any time it gets in 2016 or 2017.
    • 02:44:59
      A very important point that the Secretary made is that these are not dollars that flow from the statute directly in front of the service of debt.
    • 02:45:12
      In the order of the age of additional bonds, the CTB has to have just the age of appropriation of servicemen, and so it can be
    • 02:45:19
      The continued issuance of these bonds will be subject every year to every single legiciple to the appropriation of some sufficient service debt for the continuation of the student.
    • 02:45:34
      In the event that there is no appropriation of the service outstanding debt that has been sold, the bill will require this common recommendation that the transportation truck under the backstop be in the event that another truck is appropriated for debt service.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:45:47
      You began to hint that there are some changes there for the responsibilities of the CTB under this bill in dealing with these funds than the way we would normally work.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:46:10
      Are there others?
    • 02:46:18
      There is no difference between the
    • 02:46:29
      There is a difference, but essentially the structure is identical between the way that the frame that was issued and the way that it is issued.
    • 02:46:37
      That is to be subject to annual appropriation of general fund dollars to service outstanding transportation debt.
    • 02:46:43
      In the event that had already been sold, say a year behind, you were paying a year from before of debt service.
    • 02:46:51
      In the event the General Assembly improved the budget, it did not appropriate general fund dollars
    • 02:46:57
      specifically for the purpose of serving the outstanding debt, then by code, the CTB would have to divert money from the Transportation Fund Fund, which has the first call to service the outstanding debt.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:14
      Mr. White.
    • 02:47:14
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:47:15
      So this introduces some significant uncertainty in attempting to program funds over multi-year projects.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:47:23
      That is correct, and I will show you in a future slide that since the brands were authorized in 2000, when it first started being issued in 2002, there have been five years since, in one of those years, the very first year, the full amount
    • 02:47:41
      The general fund dollar was appropriated to service the debt.
    • 02:47:45
      In two years, a percentage, about 27% of the insurance premiums and revenues were appropriated to service the debt.
    • 02:47:56
      That's the share of the auto insurance premiums.
    • 02:48:01
      The insurance premiums are directly attributed to auto deals as opposed to the full one-third of the insurance premiums and revenues.
    • 02:48:08
      And importantly, the last item with respect to the bond piece, the individual project designations because it is interstate and primary would be made by the CTB.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:38
      and that is a substantial difference from BTA where there was a long laundry list of earmarked projects.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 02:48:45
      This fortunately does not go down that road.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:48:56
      Any other questions on the bond or debt service section?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:25
      Let's go on, we're going to talk.
    • 02:49:26
      The next section is on new revenues.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:49:29
      Okay, in terms of new revenues.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:49:31
      State, statewide revenues.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:49:32
      Statewide revenues.
    • 02:49:34
      There is, there are few sources.
    • 02:49:37
      It's fairly strict.
    • 02:49:38
      We're the first $10 increase statewide in the annual registration fee.
    • 02:49:42
      The annual registration fee for the average will also be held from $29.50 to $39.50.
    • 02:49:47
      There's a similar increase in the annual registration fee for trucks and also some increases in the defibrillator damage and the violation of permit fees for any trucks that generate about $33 million a year.
    • 02:50:04
      There's also a version of the abuse of driver fee that has been around since the second session.
    • 02:50:12
      The way that works, very briefly, there are two kinds of fees.
    • 02:50:16
      So-called offense fees, so for example, if you're committing including violation for various other offenses that are specified in the act, you pay a set fee each year for the next three years.
    • 02:50:31
      This act can be paid over 26 months.
    • 02:50:36
      That covers everything from records Friday, which is a $1,000 a year for each of the next three years, provided with a suspended license, all the way down to
    • 02:50:44
      In addition to the expense fees, there's an ongoing demerit fee.
    • 02:51:05
      The demerit schedule, as you probably know, is put out by DMD.
    • 02:51:10
      The defense's range, I believe, is three to eight demerit points for any individual who is carrying on their driving license on July, I believe, July 15th of each year, a balance of eight or more demerits will be charged a fee of $100 plus $75 for each.
    • 02:51:33
      in accessibility.
    • 02:51:36
      That generates approximately $108 million a year.
    • 02:51:39
      Again, it will take three years to assess the way that the case works out, and it will take three years to fully ramp up the case and another $2 million I'll take here.
    • 02:51:51
      There are also a number of procedural and other issues associated with being able to actually collect these funds and having them be administered.
    • 02:52:00
      In terms of other ongoing revenues,
    • 02:52:01
      There will be a statutory dedication of one-third of the existing insurance premiums.
    • 02:52:10
      I touched on this earlier that that's a current general fund residue that is being transferred from the general fund to the transportation fund funds.
    • 02:52:20
      It's also the revenue stream that is currently intended to service the outstanding grant debt.
    • 02:52:24
      That debt service is $144 million.
    • 02:52:25
      I mentioned earlier that since that veteran was paid in the ETA of 2000, there have been five years, one year of full appropriation, two years of partial appropriation, and two years instead of appropriation.
    • 02:52:39
      There is also the statutory language to dedicate one-half of the non-preferring general fund surplus at the end of the biennium.
    • 02:52:51
      One-half of that, one-half of that would be the trust fund.
    • 02:52:54
      We can't estimate what that would be.
    • 02:52:57
      There was a figure provided by the legislative committee staff for approximately $64 million
    • 02:53:04
      That is derived from looking at a 10-year window rather than counting years.
    • 02:53:11
      Counting years where there was a negative, uncummitted balance as a zero.
    • 02:53:18
      So in summary, in terms of new revenue, there are two and a half billion dollars in debt to be able to do $300 billion a year.
    • 02:53:26
      Again, dependent upon the annual appropriation year in, year out of general funds for the first.
    • 02:53:33
      B. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III
    • 02:53:56
      It's not subject to the legislative and budget process every single year.
    • 02:54:02
      It's money that I bet you automatically close into not one of your education funds, one of its sub-funds, and is, and life in general, essentially, it takes that four-year act to be appropriated for some other purpose.
    • 02:54:18
      It's automatically appropriated for transportation, and the CTB can use it to develop and production its future program.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:24
      But it doesn't take into account changes in behavior, right?
    • 02:54:29
      In other words, people who get charged 750 bucks for not using their windshield wipers might start using their windshield wipers.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:54:39
      I do not disagree with that particular point.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:45
      Okay.
    • 02:54:45
      Was there any type of reliable research organization that came up with the revenue that would be generated by this abusive driver fee?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:54:54
      If there was DMV, VDOT, and the legislative committee staff trying to get together based on some experience and security and agreed on a common set of assumptions that the administration and the legislative branch agreed to, does that mean they're exactly right?
    • 02:55:13
      Probably not, but we all agree that this is the best case.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:17
      Ms. Connally, if I might add, with respect to the abuser fee,
    • 02:55:21
      Insurance companies do the demerit points as a matter of business practice and there is a fairly significant ability to withhold driver licenses that sanction that makes collection of that relatively efficient.
    • 02:55:37
      The fees on top of offenses
    • 02:55:40
      J. Michael A. Stevens III, Michael A. Stevens III, Michael A. Stevens III,
    • 02:55:59
      There are some legal questions as to the ability to reach back and charge fees for demerits or offenses that were committed before July 1 of this year.
    • 02:56:09
      And that probably will have a more substantial impact on revenues than collection rates.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:17
      Well, I just know from just experience that in Northern Virginia, for instance, our
    • 02:56:23
      We have a lot of uncollectable, I'm sure, abusive, but they have- That's been factored into these revenue estimates.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:32
      The point, one last point I would say in terms of this summary, House Bill 3202 revenue summary, you've got the $2.5 billion worth of bonds, you've got $200 million of what arguably are user fees, but then in addition to that, you do have
    • 02:56:48
      About $140 million of dedication of what are today general funds that your insurance proceeds, and then going forward, half of any future surpluses.
    • 02:57:00
      And so, again, if it's $340 to $400 million of statewide resources, depending upon how those surpluses come in.
    • 02:57:14
      Any other questions on the statewide revenues?
    • 02:57:17
      Mr. Dickens.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:57:18
      The most troublesome piece of this to me is the history on the Fran debts and if we are to look back at history to determine what abuse of these are and look back at history to determine what that's going to be and what's going to be coming out of the trust fund in the years to come and that same if there's no appropriations to recovery.
    • 02:57:43
      Very troublesome.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:45
      Yes, and, you know, interestingly, Mr. Dickens, one of the things that we learned in 2002 and 2003, there were promises made about general fund commitments in the 2000 General Assembly session.
    • 02:58:02
      They didn't happen.
    • 02:58:03
      They come right off the top of your construction districts.
    • 02:58:08
      In the 2003 General Assembly, several bills were passed to prevent that from happening.
    • 02:58:16
      So we have to use official revenue estimates.
    • 02:58:19
      There has to actually be money in the bank.
    • 02:58:24
      We could not, for example, in the spring update that we hopefully will be looking at at the April CTB meeting, program these bonds because there is no appropriation.
    • 02:58:37
      So there are some protections built in more, but you're absolutely right that downstream there could be an appropriation for the first biennium and then if the general fund resources are not there, the transportation trust fund would have that liability.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 02:58:55
      Is this an issue for the bonding people, the bonding companies?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:01
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:59:02
      That would be part of an overall mix of concerns I'm sure they would have.
    • 02:59:08
      Mr. Martin.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:59:09
      I'm sorry to go back to that geography thing one more time, but did I understand correctly that we have taken into consideration that when we're doing our revenue stream will not become a deterrence, yet the abusers will be able to continue paying for the privilege to abuse without getting to the point where they are what do you call the habitual offenders and not permitted to drive at all,
    • 02:59:38
      I mean, we've taken all that into consideration that this is a steady stream.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:44
      Yes, sir.
    • 02:59:45
      And this is a, you can't predict how people are going to respond to economic initiatives, but eight demerit points is where you're required to go to mandatory good driving school.
    • 02:59:57
      So there is, that's the rationale for that cutoff.
    • 03:00:02
      I think the additional fees on top of the court fines are probably a little more problematic, and that's why there are such low collection rates assumed in those.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:00:15
      Okay, moving to the authority package.
    • 03:00:22
      Again, assuming that each of the most senior jurisdictions adopt all of these fees,
    • 03:00:26
      I think it allows local governments to impose following taxes on fees.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:00:33
      There's an additional 2% tax on the metaphor.
    • 03:00:39
      It's $16 million a year.
    • 03:00:41
      There's an additional $0.05 on the current real estate tax, which is a major revenue generator at $208 million.
    • 03:00:48
      There's a $100 an hour fee for the first time that you are issued a private license if you are older than 18.
    • 03:00:53
      The provisions of this are that the local governments
    • 03:01:17
      Who would be in need of an R.I.B.
    • 03:01:20
      or transportation authority or are required to impose all of these into a piece.
    • 03:01:28
      They have extended, there are no deadlines on time of which they have to be adopted, but in order to benefit from any of these, they never do a decision to have to be participating in the authority in order to participate in the authority you have to be providing in these.
    • 03:01:42
      They also have a bill that requires that any jurisdiction in this class, including the counties in Northern Virginia, that join this authority are now required to assume responsibility for their secondary program.
    • 03:01:59
      That is changed.
    • 03:02:00
      It also is a greater autonomy for the North Virginia Transportation Authority to operate as an interrelated county transportation authority, VDOT, and it also is MBTA, the Authority's Division of Issues.
    • 03:02:17
      Do you want me to finish with that?
    • 03:02:19
      Emily is divided, 40% of it goes back to the localities, 40% this year will extend in.
    • 03:02:27
      The localities are in turn required to use at least 50% of what they receive for urban and secondary construction projects.
    • 03:02:34
      60% of the overall out of new revenues in Northern Virginia will go back to its authority and first call on that new revenue for a community a year, a community a year will go to La Mana if there is a new federal source of ongoing funding for La Mana through the metro system.
    • 03:02:56
      At $25 million a year, we will go to provide ERP service in Transylvania.
    • 03:03:01
      and $20 million a year will go to the Douglas Metro Rail extension.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:08
      Thank you, Mr. Carr.
    • 03:03:09
      Mr. Schwartz.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:10
      I have two questions, Jimmy.
    • 03:03:12
      The first is, would the organizations like NBTA or whatever regional organization was participating as counties
    • 03:03:25
      Can they use this revenue to pay debt service on bonds that they would flow, this increased tax revenue?
    • 03:03:34
      So they can leverage it by using it to flow new bonds and to pay the debt service.
    • 03:03:44
      My second question is, has anybody looked at and is there data available to show for each of these regions
    • 03:03:52
      The liability that they're taking on for assuming the secondary road construction debt relative to the amount of revenue that they would raise.
    • 03:04:04
      I'm just curious whether the liability is greater than the revenue rates.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:04:07
      A number of the North Virginia localities have provided their own estimates of the additional burden.
    • 03:04:14
      So to be able to manage their own program.
    • 03:04:17
      I don't know, I do not believe that we have one that has to be done as well.
    • 03:04:21
      I think interesting to see.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:28
      Any other questions about the Northern Virginia Peace?
    • 03:04:31
      Any other comments, Mr. Koelemay or Ms. Connally?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:36
      What's the reaction of the Northern Virginia jurisdictions to this?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:40
      I think Mr. Koelemay or Ms. Connally can provide a good summary of that.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:45
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:04:47
      I think the interesting thing that came out of the governor's meeting with representatives of local government in Northern Virginia last week was what they called the workability of the package.
    • 03:04:58
      In fact, the major jurisdictions in Northern Virginia have each indicated
    • 03:05:05
      That there's very little possibility that they would actually enact this set of revenue measures.
    • 03:05:13
      It was assumed even that Fairfax County would take this leap because of its desperate need for funds, but the chairman there has indicated if his neighboring counties don't enact something like commercial property tax.
    • 03:05:28
      III, Michael A. Estes, Steve Pittard,
    • 03:05:44
      The fact of the local governments not being consulted earlier in this process about actually what they might enact, not what might look good on paper, what might pass the assembly, but what would people actually do?
    • 03:05:57
      Because without the regional packages, even for Northern Virginia, there's really not very much in this package.
    • 03:06:04
      There's $60 million a year, which helps us get started on the Gainesville interchange on I-66 a little faster than we might otherwise be able to do it.
    • 03:06:15
      But that's it.
    • 03:06:15
      That's all the money.
    • 03:06:17
      So in some respects, the second point I think that local governments would make in Northern Virginia is that the state hasn't stepped up to its responsibilities here.
    • 03:06:27
      The estimates are that local packages raise about 75% of the funds in this package.
    • 03:06:32
      in what is still, like it or not, a primary state responsibility.
    • 03:06:38
      I think that's going to be a problem.
    • 03:06:42
      I know that the workability question, what will actually work, is really going to be
    • 03:06:47
      J. Robert Jones III, Robert J. Jones III, Robert J. Jones III
    • 03:07:08
      over the next six years, Prince William $3 million a year from the state of Loudon, $2.6 million.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:14
      It's not very much money anymore.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:17
      And that's another reason they're not excited about taking over secondary roads is there's really no funds that are going to follow that responsibility.
    • 03:07:26
      So it sets up some serious questions for us at CTB, for us as a region, and for your regions as well.
    • 03:07:37
      I have a lot more questions than can be answered here today.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:43
      And I would just underline what Doug has said.
    • 03:07:46
      I think our local officials just see very little benefit coming from this as it is now written and see it as really a cost shift from the state to the local government.
    • 03:07:59
      And then the double whammy
    • 03:08:00
      of having the general fund possibly cut, which means then they'll have to ante up more education dollars and more public safety dollars. So, I mean, it's not a plus-plus. It's not lose-lose, but there's no real positive exception. that. Mr. Wynn. Jimmy, the last bullet on your previous slide says that the Northern Virginia Transit Authority could issue additional bonds.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:08:30
      Isn't that entire scheme inherently less efficient, bonds issued on a revenue source like that versus the state issuing bonds with full faith and credit and the rate that you get on that type of bond versus this type of bond?
    • 03:08:47
      Isn't that another inherent inefficiency?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:52
      Mr. Witt, you raise a very important question.
    • 03:08:57
      My understanding in the Hampton Roads area, they've looked at the mix of revenue sources and legislation and they get an A rating, where typically CTB bonds are double A or slightly above that, that has meaning and significance in the world of finance.
    • 03:09:17
      I would say, in a larger sense, to one of the important dynamics.
    • 03:09:24
      As the governor is going around and said quite clearly, I want to fix the bill.
    • 03:09:30
      The local officials who are really being handed this are rolling up their sleeves.
    • 03:09:37
      I know the Hampton Roads Mayors and Chairs met, I believe, yesterday.
    • 03:09:40
      The Northern Virginia Transportation Authority is meeting as we speak.
    • 03:09:45
      on these issues and trying to find a way to fix it.
    • 03:09:48
      One of the points of comparison, I guess a polite way of saying this is there's a lot of moving parts, but if you pull individual components, so for example, the grantor's tax in Northern Virginia generates more than the half-cent sales tax that went to referendum five years ago.
    • 03:10:06
      That's not insignificant.
    • 03:10:08
      There's the ability to do debt.
    • 03:10:10
      It's not quite as stark in Hampton Roads, but the grantor's tax still raises close to what a 1% sales tax in Hampton Roads would have generated.
    • 03:10:20
      So we should not lose sight of those orders of magnitude here, but at the end of the day, the people that have to make it work, and it's not us,
    • 03:10:31
      Hampton Roads,
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:10:45
      Mr. Chairman, Hampton Roads, to give all the localities that are eligible to participate in this regional authority, and we'll generate approximately $200 million in new annual revenue, some several resources, a new 3% regional department tax, see what that generates, a commercial real estate visual tax of $0.10, a 1% initial revenue ratio fee, which is essentially
    • 03:11:14
      100% general tax on all materials.
    • 03:11:20
      That generates, as you can see, 42 to 41 million dollars.
    • 03:11:28
      Forty cents of the random tax, an additional reasonable ten dollar registration fee, an additional ten dollar annual fee, when you have your vehicle expected.
    • 03:11:36
      Applying the sales tax to auto service and repair.
    • 03:11:41
      and the application of a two percent regional gas tax.
    • 03:11:47
      The provisions of the campus roads and the Sacramento News Authority are to consist of one member of the regional governing body and several members of the assembly who represent the state districts.
    • 03:12:01
      In order for the authority to be created, there's a requirement for seven of the nine local governments who also encompass 50% of the total regional population.
    • 03:12:14
      impose all of the new fees and taxes by December 31st of this year.
    • 03:12:26
      There are also provisions such that once all outstanding debt on the Chesapeake Bay Bridge economy has been retired, the disability to assume operational control of that facility
    • 03:12:38
      And on the assumption of that facility by door, you get two counties on history tour, but also have to go into one in four years.
    • 03:12:48
      100% of the revenues collected by this authority would be used for the projects of the family and family of the other law enforcement plan.
    • 03:13:01
      The legislative panel would establish two different tiers of projects and only one project would need to be completed or underway before work on a second tier project should begin to see what the project is there on.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:16
      Okay, any questions or comments on the Hampton Roads package?
    • 03:13:20
      Mr. Witt, Mr. Dickens?
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:24
      The floor is yours.
    • 03:13:28
      What about the local government's concurrence with implementing those taxes out there?
    • 03:13:34
      What's been the attitude local governments take?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:37
      Well, perhaps Mr. Dickens could describe your closest to the situation.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:13:44
      I think the mayors and chairs did meet last Friday.
    • 03:13:47
      There is a concern that if the commercial tax is there, there will be a problem getting 7 of the 12 to support.
    • 03:14:01
      There seemed to be concurrence that without the commercial tax on it,
    • 03:14:06
      VII would be doable and may be significant and more than that.
    • 03:14:15
      The request from the mayors and chairs was that in lieu of the commercial tax, the 10 cent commercial tax, they would request an additional percentage point on the fuel tax, taking that to 3 percent, which is essentially a wash.
    • 03:14:37
      I would say that there is a strong sense that this plan needs to move forward.
    • 03:14:46
      As ugly as some consider it, there's a lot of support on the books.
    • 03:14:56
      If I may make one other comment.
    • 03:14:59
      The authority is made up of elected officials and general assembly officials.
    • 03:15:08
      I think if you look at the authorities in Hampton Roads, and I'm not sure how it just elects other parts of the state, but the most successful
    • 03:15:17
      J. Thomas, Michael A. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III, Michael A. T. Taylor III,
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:39
      Any other questions?
    • 03:15:41
      Mr. Koelemay.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:42
      Mr. Secretary, I had a question.
    • 03:15:45
      Maybe you can help answer it.
    • 03:15:47
      I don't mean it to be political.
    • 03:15:49
      I mean it to be practical.
    • 03:15:50
      How did the two packages for the regions become so different in their revenue sources when in fact, you know, in Northern Virginia we asked why is the local, why are local governments going to raise the driver's license fee, for example, or why in this case is there a
    • 03:16:11
      Why is there a difference in the commercial real estate assessment, or the definition of what commercial real estate is?
    • 03:16:19
      And how did a 1% initial registration fee creep into one package, but it was a sales tax on automobiles that couldn't be in the other package?
    • 03:16:31
      It was a fascinating evolution week to week.
    • 03:16:35
      What happened there?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:38
      I think that's for us to find out.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:41
      Well, the other comment I'd like to make is this.
    • 03:16:43
      This particularly, this list even more than the Northern Virginia package I think brings before us some serious policy questions.
    • 03:16:53
      These are certainly projects in the region of Hampton Roads, but I would venture to say half those projects have a statewide interest in them.
    • 03:17:02
      In fact, we spent much of the last year talking about specifically some of those projects that are critical to the operations of the port, to the operations of the economy, not just in Hampton Roads, but other parts of Virginia.
    • 03:17:16
      We seem to have dodged the policy discussion that should go with that sort of thing happening, and the only discussion that we've had is on the revenue side or on the budget side.
    • 03:17:32
      But there's serious implications for every region of Virginia, not just the two that are raising our money, about what projects are.
    • 03:17:41
      The second thing is, if we were to reclassify our project activity, secondary, primary, and so forth, going forward, a lot of this language that's in this bill doesn't necessarily apply, and it's difficult to see exactly how
    • 03:17:58
      How things will actually work.
    • 03:18:02
      I just wonder if we're not getting a more complex, a much, much more complex situation ahead of us that's going to restrict our ability to really make good decisions for the state.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:15
      If I might just make a few observations, those are very good insights.
    • 03:18:19
      No one really knows where
    • 03:18:21
      This will wind up, but this is a fairly profound alteration in the basic structure of transportation planning and finance.
    • 03:18:31
      I do think when you stand back and look at Northern Virginia, where at least in the legislation as it stands, the emphasis is on transit and secondary roads in very large terms, and Hampton Roads at six projects, all of which will also be told.
    • 03:18:46
      And they do speak to different needs, and so that's probably good if it bubbled up through some kind of planning process.
    • 03:18:54
      But we do know that the relationship between the Commonwealth and the regions, if something like this is to pass and actually be implemented, will be very different.
    • 03:19:07
      And I suspect a great deal more complex than it is today.
    • 03:19:11
      If it feels complicated already today, it will be much more so tomorrow.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:19:16
      A couple of comments or suggestions that may answer some of these questions.
    • 03:19:22
      Delegate Albo led a team in Northern Virginia that worked on the plan up there.
    • 03:19:27
      Delegate Jones and Hampton Roads led a team that worked on the plan for Hampton Roads, which is probably a good indication of why they're very different.
    • 03:19:39
      I think the Northern Virginia area, which was kind of interesting to those others who followed it, was pretty much signed, sealed, and delivered when this thing first got started and the Hampton Roads piece was
    • 03:19:55
      J. J. J. J. J. J. J.
    • 03:20:25
      The other point, and I think you're absolutely on, Mark, that what we are seeing is a moving, if you will, of a responsibility to a locality.
    • 03:20:37
      In Hampton Roads' particular case, most of these roads benefit the port.
    • 03:20:43
      The port is probably the largest economic engine in the Commonwealth, and it has
    • 03:20:51
      impact all across the state.
    • 03:20:52
      So I think you're right on market.
    • 03:20:55
      We're going down some slippery slopes.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:59
      Could I make just one other observation, Mr. Chairman?
    • 03:21:02
      Mr. Allen earlier talked with us about transparency leads to trust.
    • 03:21:07
      And one of the most impressive things for me when I joined this board last year was how hard the board that was sitting here when I joined had worked over the last few years to establish a greater
    • 03:21:19
      transparency, a greater accountability, a greater direct line between what people expected and what was happening.
    • 03:21:29
      As a citizen but also as a member of this board this muddies the transportation water so thoroughly
    • 03:21:39
      I don't know how going forward you ever again establish accountability or citizen trust in what's going to happen.
    • 03:21:46
      You cannot explain this bill to a normal person.
    • 03:21:51
      You cannot explain or put together this way.
    • 03:21:53
      You can't explain to a business executive why you would choose to structure something that's critical to the lifeblood of the economy of the state in this manner.
    • 03:22:02
      There are political reasons for things, and that's fine, but just economically and from a business perspective, it's an absurd package of complexity that we don't need.
    • 03:22:16
      That's my view, and I think it's going to be very difficult to see how we cope with this if it actually goes forward in this matter.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:24
      It's going to be very difficult.
    • 03:22:31
      I've said this before in other cases, but the principle of Occam's Razor, sometimes the simplest solution is the best.
    • 03:22:38
      I know that the governor only has so much time to deal with things in the next two or three weeks.
    • 03:22:43
      I hope that he keeps that in the back of his mind or in the forefront of his mind, because I agree with Doug.
    • 03:22:50
      This is one heck of a New York pretzel that they've concocted here.
    • 03:22:54
      It has got more twists and turns and add-ons and decorations.
    • 03:22:58
      And I know it is meant well, but he was right.
    • 03:23:02
      I would have a hard time explaining this, especially in the Richmond district, which doesn't benefit a whole lot from it.
    • 03:23:11
      and the rest of the
    • 03:23:25
      The General Assembly not really committing a whole lot more in terms of new revenue to finance a well-planned revenue-based transportation plan.
    • 03:23:38
      I mean, I guess it's going sort of in the wrong direction.
    • 03:23:41
      We're trying to do a better job of putting together a transportation system for this century based on predictable, reliable revenue.
    • 03:23:49
      To do things that we all know are necessary, and I'm not sure how this accomplishes that.
    • 03:23:54
      So I go back to, if it isn't simple, it's maybe not the best solution.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:02
      Any other questions or comments, Mr. Chairman?
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:04
      In fact, a couple of things.
    • 03:24:07
      For the past, I guess, 10 days, I've been going there trying to talk to the localities that are in the Culpepper District.
    • 03:24:14
      I think it's been interesting that there is frustration that the needs, especially in the Charlottesville-Albemarle area, are not a part of a package of the solution.
    • 03:24:26
      They don't see any effort to address their concerns.
    • 03:24:31
      And they've been pretty candid with some of the area Republicans, one of whom in particular has been a major defender of this bill.
    • 03:24:39
      One of those Republicans, a different one, actually sent out a report that provided a distribution of funds pro rata indicating that the Culpeper District would get about three times the amount of revenue it actually is going to get under the formula.
    • 03:24:59
      That was prepared by party sources that was later disclaimed, said he relied on it, those people had been
    • 03:25:08
      James was very helpful in providing data in the future in the past to him so he was relying on it.
    • 03:25:15
      What I found was that much of the information that had been circulated was not correct which frustrated some of the local leadership.
    • 03:25:25
      There are three things that I think local leadership has seen.
    • 03:25:29
      First of all, the General Assembly did not assume the responsibility for raising taxes.
    • 03:25:35
      It shifted it to Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads.
    • 03:25:39
      They are major statewide plans.
    • 03:25:41
      The Culpeper Board of Supervisors' comment was, well, it looks like Northern Virginia is going to pay for the road improvements, and our 60 percent of the population that commute to Northern Virginia to work is not going to end up having to pay for it.
    • 03:25:53
      I think
    • 03:26:17
      Doug put his finger right on it.
    • 03:26:19
      I think there's going to be significant fallout, renewed efforts to create special districts, and I think that's going to generate significant problems.
    • 03:26:31
      The last thing I'd like to say, when Judy and I were elected to the legislature, we began service in 1992, and I can tell you that that was a difficult period.
    • 03:26:44
      We were in a recession.
    • 03:26:46
      Governor Wilder literally took funds from every single location he could find.
    • 03:26:53
      A good example that I use is Game and Inland Fisheries.
    • 03:26:58
      Hunting and fishing license revenue dedicated got taken to balance the budget.
    • 03:27:04
      Didn't go to Game and Inland Fisheries.
    • 03:27:08
      When the legislature gets on a pinch,
    • 03:27:11
      It is not going to carry the burden.
    • 03:27:13
      It is going to raid everything it can lay its hands on.
    • 03:27:18
      Remember that when we went through the litany, this is legislatively agreed upon by an act of the legislature.
    • 03:27:29
      They can change their mind tomorrow.
    • 03:27:32
      We may very well, if we have a significant recession, we may very well see that we are in a position of not doing any new construction, but having to pay debt on bonds that we issued.
    • 03:27:45
      And I think that ought to cause us some pause.
    • 03:27:48
      I think that's something that as we look at it, the way it's structured, it ought to give us some concern because those funds are really not dedicated in any secure fashion.
    • 03:28:01
      They are pledge funds that the legislature can take.
    • 03:28:06
      What the legislature ordained, they can take away.
    • 03:28:09
      So I think you need to think about that as well.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:28:13
      Just about everything has been said, so I'm not going to repeat it all over again, but I do want to emphasize one aspect of
    • 03:28:23
      The Bonding Component If the bonding component is to become a source of funds in the final bill, some way has got to be found to prevent what Butch just talked about and what others have referred to earlier.
    • 03:28:43
      This is France all over again.
    • 03:28:46
      Some of us on the board have lived through that, and it's been nothing short of a travesty of what ended up happening a few years after that brand legislation passed.
    • 03:29:01
      And as Justin pointed out, if history is in our guide, it's going to happen again.
    • 03:29:06
      So if two and a half billion in bonds is part of the final bill, I hope some way we'll be found to protect the revenue streams and restrict the source of debt service from sources other than the general funds, if that's possible.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:29:29
      Okay, thank you.
    • 03:29:30
      In the interest of time, Mr. Carr, can you hit the remaining topics quickly?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:29:40
      As far as land use, this report does incorporate wholesale and governor's proposal with regard to substitute for street acceptance.
    • 03:29:51
      I'll touch on that later as it will be stated.
    • 03:29:53
      It also includes a classification of budget language that the governor has been in for a January office with regard to regional performance measures.
    • 03:30:04
      It creates a new impact fee that applies not only to the so-called political counties, but to those counties in the confirmation of learning paths and the reader as of the most recent census.
    • 03:30:18
      The impact fees
    • 03:30:19
      within the Richburg MSA and be used exclusively for promoting streets and bridges in the other jurisdictions since we've been more latitude about what type of public service they need for.
    • 03:30:34
      Six of the seven counties ranked in this type of impact vehicle already have a separate type of impact vehicle written today.
    • 03:30:42
      You should note also that depending on
    • 03:30:45
      There are some counties that, subsequent to the most recent series of census, have passed the 90,000 threshold, but I'm advised by attorneys that the way that has been read is that the population count like that is done after the most recent census.
    • 03:31:02
      It also creates, the bill creates a concept called the Urban Development Area.
    • 03:31:08
      It requires counties to point that out from greater and certain areas of the state to create urban development areas within their comprehensive plan.
    • 03:31:25
      The urban development area would be designated and planned to accommodate 20 years of residential and commercial growth.
    • 03:31:29
      It would have a minimum density of four residential units for growth savers, or at least three times the lowest surrounding density for the area established.
    • 03:31:38
      This requires a locality to provide for narrow street widths, smaller setbacks, and so-called provincial neighborhood design.
    • 03:31:52
      It does not give the local government any new authority with regard to making proposals, either inside or outside of the box.
    • 03:32:02
      That is the status of the Congress's plan.
    • 03:32:06
      And also at the request of some important localities in the state, frankly,
    • 03:32:09
      The legislation also gives the locality the ability to, by resolution certifying that they are all interested in a comprehensive plan that they currently have and already sustainably compliant with the spirit of this act and therefore that they don't have to get any further action.
    • 03:32:26
      It also creates a concept called the early transportation service district.
    • 03:32:30
      This is, again, a family of about 90,000 or more and creates certain areas.
    • 03:32:35
      The boundaries of those areas, which is being determined by VDOT and the locality, and the event VDOT and the locality cannot agree on a boundary of the commission of local government to put aside the boundaries.
    • 03:32:49
      The impact of these districts is that many portions of counties would receive the urban maintenance allocation as opposed to the regular, what VDOT has been, is usually changing roads within the area within this district.
    • 03:33:06
      There have been some discussions about
    • 03:33:10
      How large this district might be.
    • 03:33:13
      Sometimes I know we're looking at creating a very, very large first representation sort of district to take advantage of the additional maintenance money.
    • 03:33:21
      The bill also used Arlington,
    • 03:33:24
      If they brought Enrico put eligible for the existing urban maintenance applications for Enrico, that would be an additional $12 million to get off the top into the maintenance budget, specifically for Enrico this year.
    • 03:33:40
      Arlington would actually suffer a reduction of about $2.5 million a year.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:33:45
      Excuse me, Mr. Chairman, just a quick question.
    • 03:33:48
      How does this service- holistic thing relate to
    • 03:33:51
      existing law which allows service districts to be created since 1970 or something like that if they really wanted to.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:33:58
      You know, the major difference here, Mr. McCarthy, I would say, is that the area, the locality receives an urban maintenance payment for the area, the land area within the urban transportation service district.
    • 03:34:15
      There's a separate service district authority that actually was modified this year's idea for Sunday, as you mentioned, the category language.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:34:20
      Okay, thanks.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:34:23
      There are several other provisions that would be admitted to the Board of Trustees that would be affiliated with IFR and that would be for the statement written down there again for the General Assembly.
    • 03:34:36
      The CTB would also have the authority to set the new documentation for salary.
    • 03:34:46
      I'm buying dinner tonight.
    • 03:34:48
      It falls for the creation of a new, new application on transportation accountability, very similar to the existing plan.
    • 03:34:57
      J. Clark, John C. Taylor III, John C. Taylor III,
    • 03:35:20
      The bill reduces from 120 days to 30 days the period that various departmental agencies have to respond to all permits.
    • 03:35:31
      There's some questions, and I'll mention later, the big tactical issues that are in the bill, and we believe this was intended to apply only to the so-called general permits and VDOT and the direct legislative process.
    • 03:35:47
      We apparently have an excellent working relationship in terms of people around the time and various environmental agencies.
    • 03:35:52
      This provision was intended to apply both to land-specific permits and their conflict with the timelines that are added to the highway title compared to the, I think it's Title 62, which is the other requirements that users are done with, anonymized events, title and code, which are typically longer than the new timeline provision.
    • 03:36:15
      There's also an active clause that requires the CTB to classify and reassign the various
    • 03:36:30
      I had the bullet here that there's a lot of potential on the same consequences of doing and taking that action as an accident.
    • 03:36:37
      Many of us, frankly, have been talking about what we need to start realigning on the way we think about and classify our roads within years.
    • 03:36:45
      One issue that has occurred, however, though, is that if we were to do that today, for example, you might think a whole lot of roads in Northern Virginia that you can use several sources of funding to improve right now, you might classify
    • 03:36:58
      Mr.
    • 03:36:59
      Chair,
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:37:27
      Ms. McCarthy struck a theorem that's dear to my heart when he referred to Osmond's Razor before.
    • 03:37:33
      And given that people who disagree with me will undoubtedly say I'm being self-serving, I'll proceed anyway to say that bullet number one strikes me as counterproductive.
    • 03:37:48
      And I will say during my tenure here, I have 100% of the time, recently at five o'clock this afternoon,
    • 03:37:56
      found that the other board members treat the rural board members with dignity and respect, that the rest of you do what I try to do in looking out for my region equally with looking out for the Commonwealth.
    • 03:38:11
      Knowing human nature, what I see in bullet one would turn us into a virtual two-chamber organization.
    • 03:38:20
      And we all see what two chambers has gotten us into General Assembly.
    • 03:38:25
      So the simplest thing is not my self-interest in, because my tenure or my appointment would remain the same, but my self-interest in doing the best thing for my region and my Commonwealth at the same time.
    • 03:38:43
      I think that would apply equally to everybody else here.
    • 03:38:45
      We might not have a perfect system, but to muddy it up
    • 03:38:49
      with two people with distinctly different criteria for being here, it's probably an unwise way to go.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:38:58
      Okay, Mr. Chairman, there are also a number of technical issues in the bill, with the formatting, etc., consistent dates that some revenues are deposited upon and has been created.
    • 03:39:13
      There's some discrepancies about regular revenues.
    • 03:39:17
      A main issue again that we touched on earlier is that as you know the
    • 03:39:22
      The Davis is the largest provider of additional excavation need on a day-by-day basis in the Commonwealth.
    • 03:39:32
      This year, for example, the Six-Year Program takes $450 million out.
    • 03:39:35
      The Six-Year Program takes $450 million out of what would be in charge of the fund in terms of maintenance.
    • 03:39:45
      This bill, as approved, provides only $200 million toward additional day-by-day maintenance needs.
    • 03:39:48
      There again, the additional 12 million dollars in new maintenance funding by Franklin County is also needed for that.
    • 03:40:03
      And with a bigger incentive for the families to create our transportation services.
    • 03:40:09
      So in general, as you can see, the development of our home labor is limited.
    • 03:40:11
      The sustainable funding outside of the two regions is limited to the development of the different regions, the bad layer of complexity.
    • 03:40:18
      The revenue assumptions of the revenue claims and projections are all based on some assumptions about the annual appropriation of revenue that history has proved to be somewhat tenuous.
    • 03:40:33
      And as an overall idea, total revenues, the new revenue does not begin to address many of the things that we need to do now.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:45
      Okay, we're really running short on time.
    • 03:40:48
      Any additional questions or comments on House Bill 3202?
    • 03:40:51
      Ms. Carter?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 03:40:52
      I have just a couple comments, please.
    • 03:40:54
      I've been very quiet, so give others a chance.
    • 03:40:57
      In the best, one of the best-destroying areas is the Gettysburg District, and I will certainly agree on your vote that you have here.
    • 03:41:08
      that outside of Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads, funding is definitely limited.
    • 03:41:14
      And that hits the Fredericksburg area, which as I stated, is between Richmond and Washington, D.C., and is very highly populated and continues.
    • 03:41:23
      For the economy of the Commonwealth, I think that's very irresponsible.
    • 03:41:30
      And also, the bond rating serving on a board governing body
    • 03:41:38
      Bond ratings have always been a high priority.
    • 03:41:43
      And I believe that that has certainly been overlooked with the members of the General Assembly on the bond rating and what they have presented to the governor to sign of what it could do to the bond rating and also the CTB trust funds.
    • 03:42:00
      I do not think that they have taken the responsibility personally to
    • 03:42:07
      Guarantee that there will be a funding and a mechanism so that localities can improve the transportation needs of the citizens of the Commonwealth.
    • 03:42:17
      And I'm bothered terribly about relying on general funds, serving again as a board member on the locality.
    • 03:42:31
      We had to struggle.
    • 03:42:33
      for education funds, and we had to struggle for safety funds, and we had to struggle for medical funds for those who are certainly in need.
    • 03:42:44
      And I have a great concern of this from the state level of going into general funds that other agencies, especially, that are so important, we have to rely on.
    • 03:42:57
      I'm sorry that we have to do that.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:43:01
      Okay Mr. Chairman, turning now to an update on other legislation that's in support of the C-5 management that I'll talk about very briefly.
    • 03:43:12
      Mr. Carr, if I might, just in the interest of time, we really need to be done by 5.30.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:43:24
      If you take away House Bill 3202, this was a very, very successful legislative session.
    • 03:43:32
      There was half a billion dollars in money towards strategic projects and five very important pieces of legislation.
    • 03:43:45
      I know it's been a long day for folks and there really hasn't been a break.
    • 03:43:49
      Why don't I just ask if there are questions about either the secondary street acceptance, access management,
    • 03:43:56
      The Office of Intermodal Planning, the Bino Maintenance Report of Traffic Impact Analysis.
    • 03:44:01
      These are very significant, very significant pieces of legislation that are going to, in particular, the secondary standards and the access management will come back to this body for development and approval of regulations.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:18
      I have a question, Mr. Chairman, about access management standards.
    • 03:44:21
      Is there an active program underway by VDOT to buy access rights back or, in other words, to begin to limit what may be possible, or would the standards actually accomplish that just by saying, so this is still a major issue for us going forward in Carter?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:44
      Yes.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:47
      Was there something, somebody called me up and said something about tolls on interstates and the CTB.
    • 03:44:55
      Did something happen on that?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:57
      There was legislation approved by the General Assembly.
    • 03:45:01
      Delegate Lingenfelter was the patron, and it simply says that the CTB can toll interstate highways, which arguably we can do today, we do in a number of instances, but subject to federal regulations.
    • 03:45:16
      There was a concern that it could be done under the PPTA and that the CTB didn't have that authority, so it was clarifying in that respect.
    • James L. KeenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:45:31
      The comment would be, has the Research Council or any group evaluated how long it will take us to meet our construction needs with this proposal, given the fact we've identified $103 billion in construction needs.
    • 03:45:44
      So I'm guessing somewhere in the 40 or 50 or 60 years we could address our construction needs with the type of money we could get for construction.
    • 03:45:52
      That's just a comment, but my question would be what if anything has been addressed as far as the revenue sharing aspect of the program that really helps the counties out there in rural Virginia and it brings in additional match money from those localities to do projects in rural Virginia?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:46:12
      Mr. Chairman, Mr.
    • 03:46:13
      Keen, there's an additional $20 million added to the revenue sharing program this year bringing the total program from $15 to $35 million.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:24
      We need to get some written information, Commissioner, if we could back because I believe one of the thoughts was to wait until early next year so they could be combined and it would be sufficient funding.
    • 03:46:35
      Let me suggest this in the interest of time because people need to get back and get settled because dinner is at 6.30.
    • 03:46:42
      If there are no objections, I'd like to start tomorrow morning with this legislative overview.
    • 03:46:46
      Will you be here, Mr. Carr, in the morning?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:46:48
      Yes, sir.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:46:49
      There's a lot of meat here, and there's just not enough time, I think, to do this justice.
    • 03:46:58
      I also want to emphasize, again, House Bill 302 is the most immediate piece of legislation that we have to deal with.
    • 03:47:06
      But if you take that away and the accomplishments, and I want to acknowledge the work of Mr. Carr, who
    • 03:47:12
      has four bills in here that were unanimously passed by the General Assembly in very controversial areas, whether it's access management or subdivision street standards.
    • 03:47:23
      If you look at a budget with half a billion dollars,
    • 03:47:27
      of One Time General Fund money towards strategic goals.
    • 03:47:31
      It was a very successful session in that regard.
    • 03:47:35
      So I think that would be a good way to start our business meeting tomorrow morning and then get into it.
    • 03:47:42
      I don't want these very important issues to get lost in the shop.
    • 03:47:48
      Are there any other questions or comments?
    • 03:47:51
      If not, dinner is at 6.30 at Sam Miller's and we'll start our business agenda tomorrow with this presentation.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:47:59
      Thank you, Mr. Carr.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:48:05
      I would like to resume our work session from yesterday.
    • 03:48:09
      Mr. Carr will present an overview of the 2007 legislative session.
    • 03:48:17
      We spent a long time discussing House Bill 3202.
    • 03:48:21
      That obviously has its challenges.
    • 03:48:23
      I thought that was fairly reflected in the media this morning.
    • 03:48:27
      There is a positive side, though, to this last General Assembly session, which you're going to hear.
    • 03:48:32
      Very significant one-time General Fund support for transportation and several very substantive pieces of legislation all passed unanimously.
    • 03:48:43
      Welcome, Mr. Carr.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:48:45
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 03:48:48
      Chair and members of the board.
    • 03:48:53
      As Secretary, we have a very successful legislative session.
    • 03:48:59
      And those of you who've been to assembly will know that we're currently sincere about the bill passing unanimously to both chambers and figures and town tonight does too much bill.
    • 03:49:06
      And frankly, the majority of bills that pass unanimously are, I would say, five bills that
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:49:10
      The World Governor's Act is through the end of this session.
    • 03:49:16
      Maybe we're highly comfortable with all various stuff.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:49:19
      The first bill, as I pointed out yesterday, was carried by the Republican chairmen of the faculty, the Senate, and the House of Representatives committees.
    • 03:49:37
      We had a very important relationship with both parties, and they were set to do this bill, which will essentially raise the law, allow the Fifth Ward to raise the requirements for a reasonable state to accept a subdivision of the streets into the state system in perpetuity.
    • 03:49:48
      I think there's a lot of discussion on this board.
    • 03:49:54
      I guess over the last year or so, you know, there's been a workshop session in Athens last summer where we discussed this issue and there was a painting from Council that nearly as long as the
    • 03:50:02
      As long as the students meet the needs, and the service structure requirements, the technical requirements, etc.
    • 03:50:13
      What this bill does, and there's been a copy of the bill that took place, it requires the CTB to develop new standards for subdivision creates.
    • 03:50:24
      And it allows the board to establish minimum standards for the connectivity of those priests with the existing and future identification network.
    • 03:50:35
      We believe it's very essential to create a type of grid pattern of priests that will allow people to create a smaller neighborhood road that's welcome to present and reduce spreading of our nature.
    • 03:50:45
      I'm sure it is.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:50:46
      It also includes a state provision of the availability of the existing pedestrian networks, which is important to provide people an alternative to the walk-through blocks again at Campbellville, Minnesota, to get into your car, and turn it all the way around out in Colseck onto Route 29, let's say, and then onto Route 31.
    • 03:51:09
      how the other commandant would be the ability of the CTB in addition to such other methods or the more they be necessary appropriate a challenge would be the activity of brotherhood network a minimization of the service areas will more well
    • 03:51:28
      and also allows for, it's a core funding that we've currently had in some of the individual departments to be ramped up as well as toward the potential organizational health and recovery needs to be established by the board in the course of the review and acceptance of the industry in the system.
    • 03:51:49
      This, the new requirements, the new
    • 03:51:52
      Congratulations will be propagated by the CTB that we can get from the APA so that they can be in place trying to change the curriculum next year.
    • 03:52:10
      As I mentioned, next year, excuse me, as I mentioned yesterday, if the order that will come in 3202 began the legislative process with some other divisions as regard to subdivision degrees and secondary degrees and a defined version of the economy before the second phase happens to be directly in the planning unit that is developed in the U.S.
    • 03:52:23
      I would just say that this project was to get a piece from the ladies, who played it, played it, played it, and we had done it for just the last two years, and we think about the role that the state plays in providing direction and extension
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:52:38
      As in the types of communities that are built, the main way that VDOT is involved is we tell you what the street networks have to be on.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:52:53
      Everybody goes to the street standard because if you do, they're set by the state system.
    • 03:52:55
      This is an extended way to provide an incentive to develop in the types of communities that are built long term to reduce pressure on major commercial businesses.
    • Peter B. SchwartzMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:03
      Jimmy, has the process been set up for writing the regulations to implement this?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:53:09
      Have you all given any thought yet to how you're going to write these or who's going to be involved in doing that?
    • 03:53:23
      Thank you.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:53:40
      This probably shows my ignorance, but major shopping centers, are those streets maintained as part of the shopping center entity, or do any of them come under this major commercial?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:53:57
      I believe someone might like to correct me, but it's just a road that goes through a parking lot and starts flooding the city.
    • 03:54:06
      There's not a consistent answer to that question because there's not been consistent historical practice.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:54:25
      I can show you examples both ways in many parts of the state.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:54:30
      Mr. Secretary, the next bill is Senate Bill 1312, House Bill 2228.
    • 03:54:36
      Again, this was carried by Chairman Moore, with the House Transportation Committee, and Senator Hawkins, and the public meetings on the South Side of Virginia.
    • 03:54:45
      This is the bill to require the VDOT Commissioner to develop an implement of ISPA access management standards.
    • 03:54:54
      There was a question yesterday, I believe, from this team about the extent to which VDOT is more actively acquiring access rights now and raise the credit.
    • 03:55:03
      Will this require additional resources?
    • 03:55:05
      In answer to that, this will require VDOT to have a standard set of rules about the way we govern and provide access on facilities.
    • 03:55:20
      The idea being to minimize and standardize the way that median cusps and stoplights and intersections are provided in space so as to preserve the efficiency of the existing asset and reduce the need to create a definitive facility on their own.
    • 03:55:33
      Also in the legislation, a very, very significant change in the code of Virginia is the ability for VDOT to require two, to require a new property that doesn't access on Tuesday night, to provide for the joint use of its entrance to the adjoining property.
    • 03:55:54
      So say you have two big box stores, the first one comes in, let's say, practically not because it's a safer target.
    • 03:56:03
      We would have the ability to say, OK, big box door number one, we're going to grant you this entrance.
    • 03:56:10
      But rather than put it in the middle of your park, we have to put it on the very edge.
    • 03:56:14
      And you have to
    • 03:56:16
      In addition to the requirements that you allow, if some other big box store comes in next to you, you have to let it be listed as a shared influence.
    • 03:56:26
      So instead of having two or three recordings, one's directed to only one, again, protecting the existing network.
    • 03:56:34
      Finally, another significant issue.
    • 03:56:37
      Currently, the VDOT is avoiding roads.
    • 03:56:41
      If it destroys an existing entrance, the process of widening that, the Commissioner is required to replace the entrance exactly as it was where it was.
    • 03:56:51
      So if you have a property that's on the corner of the secondary and major arterial primary, let's say, and the primary and wide that uses your entrance on the primary, you have to get another one back.
    • 03:57:04
      This bill will allow the commissioner to say, we'll still don't provide you access if it's going to be on the side for the secondary as opposed to that on the primary.
    • 03:57:16
      That's another thing that will change.
    • 03:57:17
      These standards have to be developed and published by the commissioner, by the secretary of the purpose this year, and will take effect after a month.
    • 03:57:24
      Also, if they're appropriate, there's a way to process that.
    • 03:57:27
      The third bill, Mr. Secretary, was the provision of the role of the mobile office that is an existing code.
    • 03:57:42
      This code was carried by Senator Haff and Senator DiCiccio and Brian Moran.
    • 03:57:44
      Among the major changes, it provides that, as directed by the Secretary, majoring in the department was used by the Board of Studies to be inducted under and led by his office, as opposed to becoming one of the individual code agencies.
    • 03:57:57
      That's a way, if necessary, for any greater balance in the more appropriate consideration of all those in the planning process.
    • 03:58:10
      It also provides that this office has a more direct role in providing some importance to the CTB if it is updated by the state recommendation plan.
    • 03:58:15
      And it also gives the audience a hand's roll in coordination, right movement, safety, and high consistency on other issues, working with regional health and safety, local governments, and development agencies.
    • 03:58:37
      Another piece that the governor would like to play in the package, although unanimously approved, is a call for a biennial report to be conducted by VDOT.
    • 03:58:45
      to detail the maintenance budget, the assumptions that were due to development of the maintenance needs.
    • 03:59:02
      That, of course, could be submitted to the governor, the CTB, and J. Barnes, who is the General Assembly's best data guard.
    • 03:59:06
      We believe that with maintenance being such a large and growing portion of our overall expenditures, this is written on appropriate levels of additional oversight and accountability to the maintenance program.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:59:15
      If I might just comment, Ms. Carr, on this biennial.
    • 03:59:19
      This is a lot of work to prepare this report, but the growth of highway maintenance is the single biggest driver in our transportation programs.
    • 03:59:32
      It accounts for one of the reasons why we were in a special session for eight months last year.
    • 03:59:37
      One of our hopes here is obviously to get greater transparency and accountability in our maintenance budgets, and those are going to force some hard choices, Commissioner, but also to educate, and the involvement of J.Lark is to educate members of the General Assembly on how much it costs to plow snow, to replace bridges periodically, to repave, because as everyone on this table knows, those costs
    • 04:00:07
      J. J. J. J.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:00:25
      On to what was carried out in part of the VDOT package was the revision to the climate impact analysis program that we discussed, I believe at the Senate CTB meeting.
    • 04:00:41
      These were a group of changes that the policy advisory committee in a very stable degree would be necessary in order to properly implement.
    • 04:00:45
      This legislation in the past nine years does not include the explicit authority paid in the implementation of the requirements for the best appropriate and necessary for the official construction and workload of the development and construction of the expertise.
    • 04:01:07
      It also eliminates the requirement that VDOT charge the actual cost of each review and keep track of the cost of production of each review but instead promulgate a reschedule.
    • 04:01:13
      So that we can continue to learn the lessons, the information, and as we receive feedback from stakeholders, the A.K.A.
    • 04:01:34
      attention is extended until the long one in 2008.
    • 04:01:36
      The practical effect of that is in order to move a combo of assessments or make some of the past language gradually clarifying that we don't have to go to the recent one, the regulatory process in which we can just publish a change has become effective.
    • 04:01:44
      It also, the bill would clarify that if CTB does not meet any of the timeframes specified in the tax, that there is something to prevent the localities from taking action on the proposal.
    • 04:01:58
      Turning to the Appropriations Act, as you will recall, the assembly of the government got a total of $200 million in one time.
    • 04:02:16
      In fact, due to the General Assembly, Matthew does not oppose.
    • 04:02:18
      As far as he's accessible, it's less than $500 million.
    • 04:02:19
      Opposed by the government, the General Assembly accepted $280 million for the specific presentation, so I think it's adjusted to $20 million.
    • 04:02:26
      The first is a $305 million positive education opportunity fund that was set up a few years ago to incentivize the development of design-built game projects.
    • 04:02:42
      The four projects identified by the governor that were approved were the capital building, lot lanes, hiding around 50th, Fairfax, and Laddo Counties, advancement of the Hillfield Block, Madison, F.B.I.C.E.
    • 04:03:02
      and P42.6.4 interchange.
    • 04:03:04
      It's important that the governor cannot specify in order to simply add specific appropriations to each of those projects.
    • 04:03:08
      The idea was the latest additional pool of investment that could be used.
    • 04:03:10
      But the ability for the department to negotiate on each of those projects was important and would not help become a little scarring position in this particular line of appropriation between the different projects.
    • 04:03:29
      The General simply added two projects that would also be eligible for this funding and that would be the acquisition of the
    • 04:03:33
      E. Wilkerson, and Michael A. Enriquez, and also the development of the EIS server, which is our podcast right now.
    • 04:03:42
      It's getting better and better now.
    • 04:03:45
      As the Governor recommended, it is the funding bill to provide $16.85 million to the Israeli Cancer Fund, and that funding will first be used to speed the five long-going projects that are in our corridor for the U.S. CSX.
    • 04:04:00
      The completion of those projects will allow us to four additional daily DRP payments.
    • 04:04:05
      If I might just make a note on the I-95 VRE allows for four additional trains.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:04:26
      That's more or less a hunting license.
    • 04:04:29
      and there obviously there would have to be track lease payments, there are operational costs, so let's, we need to be real clear about the potential benefits to VRE.
    • 04:04:39
      That is a right to incur additional expenses.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:04:44
      Sir, as transit Mr. Secretary, I would also recommend that the U.S.
    • 04:04:52
      Assembly approve an additional 16 million dollars in the time invested in transit capital.
    • 04:05:02
      At that point, it would be dedicated to a lot of further growth stock and additional 15 million to the R.E.
    • 04:05:06
      and 10 million for an anniversary transit for the same purpose.
    • 04:05:08
      An additional 15 million will be deposited into the state-mass transit capital fund to increase the statewide state participation in transit capital.
    • 04:05:13
      And again, a major milestone here for the first time.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:05:20
      There is major transit rail capital outside of Northern Virginia.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:05:24
      This is a very significant event in state transportation funding.
    • 04:05:42
      And the board will be able to use up to $3,000,000 of that appropriation to complete the rail relocation project, which is to move all of the base 13 and greater sections on the rail route to the Crane Island terminal and to the other terminal.
    • 04:06:01
      Any portion of the 50 million that is not typically available in rail is reported to be more than $10 million to be used by the school district to begin advanced permitting, engineering, and environmental work to keep the crane out of the internal loss zone in 2017.
    • 04:06:22
      Finally, the General Assembly
    • 04:06:25
      Appropriating $20 million in digital medical funds, we made a piece of history in revenue sharing programs, 35 million.
    • 04:06:41
      The only provision of the government recommendations that were not approved was the creation of the two technology grant challenge funds.
    • 04:06:45
      They would hold around five of the students with a previous name for their other students, and participate in the evaluation and selection of the programs and contributions.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:06:52
      on Bill 1312, SB 1312, the one dealing with access and connectivity and so forth.
    • 04:07:08
      How do you coordinate that with local government rules, regulations, plans, comp plans and that sort of thing?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:07:24
      How would we do that in development of the standards?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:07:28
      Well, I guess maybe I can state it better.
    • 04:07:31
      Are you dictating that this would be, these types of things would be incorporated in local government rules and regulations?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:07:40
      No, the legislation specifically mentions that nothing in this act shall preempt the authority of government to determine the entities on the very part.
    • 04:07:54
      So the local government would have to make, the local government would have to be aware of the action standards that the department has as would a property owner if you wanted to do something with that property.
    • 04:08:19
      I don't think it would be accurate to say there would be anything in this bill that would
    • 04:08:22
      On that issue
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:08:38
      There are today in place, for example, spacing and median break standards.
    • 04:08:45
      They, in some cases, are guidance, in some cases followed, others not.
    • 04:08:50
      What this legislation does is to begin to bring a greater degree of uniformity.
    • 04:08:57
      For the urban streets, for example, in Hampton Roads, that would be a matter of regulation and discretion of the CTB in adopting these as to whether or not they would apply to the urban network.
    • 04:09:14
      There is very strong historical practice.
    • 04:09:19
      The local governments and the private engineering firms always do their best to try and incorporate the state standards.
    • 04:09:26
      There will have to be grandfathering provisions.
    • 04:09:30
      This is a major undertaking.
    • 04:09:34
      but what you'll find is for example even secondary street acceptance when those are updated local governments then have to update their design and construction standards manuals and it takes it may take us a year and a half to develop regulations it'll take another year and a half for localities to bring their regulations in conformance with those in some places the localities are going to have precedents and others that would be the state standards that would prevail
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 04:10:03
      My experience with local government has been that local government was often times having difficulty with the VDOT folks working together on this thing.
    • 04:10:18
      I applaud what you're doing.
    • 04:10:19
      I think the connectivity issues are way, way important.
    • 04:10:23
      The access issues are very, very important.
    • 04:10:29
      Jr., Michael A. Smith, John W. Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:10:53
      Q.
    • 04:10:54
      Was there an overriding reason that you could share about why the technology transportation grants were taken out?
    • 04:11:02
      Was it a question of substance or of governance?
    • 04:11:04
      Wasn't there enough time to develop the idea in their minds?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:11:08
      A. Mr. Chairman, I would be speculating if I answered that question.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:11:18
      That's a good answer.
    • 04:11:21
      I have a question about transit.
    • 04:11:23
      A year ago, we were cutting transit operating funds because of budget constraints.
    • 04:11:30
      Does this new investment in transit capital statewide, can we expect that we'll get some relief on the operating side, too?
    • 04:11:38
      I mean, is there a new understanding that this is important and we should invest, or is this
    • 04:11:44
      J. R. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:07
      If not, again, I want to just, Mr. Carr, there were four bills, I believe, what were the votes on those four bills?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 04:12:15
      98 to 0.
    • 04:12:20
      They were all either 98, 99, or 100 to 0 in the House, and 38, 39, and 40 to 0 in the Senate.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:12:25
      I think that's a real achievement and I want to say thank you for a job incredibly well done under difficult circumstances.
    • 04:12:34
      You got great staff support from VDOT and DRPT.
    • 04:12:38
      Again, the attention has been on House Bill 3202, but if you look at the budget and those strategic investments in these bills, it was a very, very good session for transportation.
    • 04:12:51
      Thank you again.
    • 04:12:53
      I have one concluding thing to say.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:13:01
      I think yesterday some of our reactions to HB 3202
    • 04:13:06
      We're really driven by our understanding of the principles, the accountability, the management, the operational responsibilities that we have at Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 04:13:20
      It occurred to me, however, that as important as those principles are, there's also a set of political realities.
    • 04:13:27
      principles, as they say in the Pirates of the Caribbean movie, when the pirate's code was brought up.
    • 04:13:33
      Well, really, maybe sometimes they're more like guidelines.
    • 04:13:38
      Which is, I think, probably what we're called upon to understand here.
    • 04:13:43
      I would just simply suggest that, in general,
    • 04:13:49
      The Governor, I hope, can fix this bill so that there's more certainty, there's more dedicated sources of revenue, things like maintenance are actually addressed more comprehensively, that there's more flexibility in the regional plan so that they can actually work, local governments can actually make it work and make some of this money actually happen.
    • 04:14:12
      That there's some simplification of the governance and other mechanisms, fewer layers of new formulas for distribution so that at least there is a possibility of some strategic planning, some funding consistency and some accountability going forward.
    • 04:14:32
      And those, you had asked for some suggestions yesterday and if I had to give some suggestions I just wanted to make those three.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:14:41
      Thank you.
    • 04:14:42
      Any other comments?
    • 04:14:43
      Those of you who weren't here yesterday missed a very interesting overview and exercise.