Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Workshop and Action Meeting 2/15/2006
Auto-scroll
Workshop and Action Meeting
2/15/2006
Attachments
Workshop and meeting minutes.pdf
Board actions.pdf
Meeting agenda.pdf
Action Meeting
Public Comment
Approval of Minutes January 18, 2006
LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
1. Action on Designation of Virginia Byway:
2. Action on Revenue Sharing:
3. Action on Recreational Access:
LOCATION AND DESIGN DIVISION
4. Action on Location Approval:
RIGHT OF WAY AND UTILITIES DIVISION
5. Action on Land Conveyances:
6. Rail Industrial Access Program:
7. Action on FY06 Supplemental Allocation to the FY2006 Rail Preservation Program of Projects (A) Augusta, Bath, Hanover, and Rockbridge Counties
SCHEDULING & CONTRACT DIVISION
8. Action on Bids Received: the months of December 2005 and January 2006:
NEW BUSINESS
ADJOURNMENT
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:01
Good afternoon and welcome to the February business meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board in view of the General Assembly.
00:00:12
We don't have a work session this week, or this month, excuse me.
00:00:18
And I would like to begin by seeing if there is anyone here in the audience who would like to provide comment from the public.
00:00:27
Any members of the public desire to speak?
00:00:30
Going once, twice, okay.
00:00:34
The next item on the agenda is approval of the January 18th minutes.
00:00:39
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_02
00:00:41
Move approved.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:42
Second?
00:00:43
All in favor?
00:00:46
Aye.
00:00:46
They are approved.
00:00:48
Action item number one, Mr. Estes will be here to talk about action on a designated Virginia Byway in Warren County.
00:00:59
Are there any questions of Mr. Estes?
00:01:03
Is there a motion?
00:01:08
All in favor?
00:01:11
Action item two is on a revenue sharing project
00:01:16
in Fauquier County.
00:01:23
All in favor?
00:01:26
Action item three is action on a recreational access project in Prince Edward County.
00:01:31
Are there any questions of Mr. Estes?
00:01:35
Is there a motion?
00:01:38
Is there a second?
00:01:39
All in favor?
00:01:42
Motion is approved.
00:01:43
Outstanding reports, Mr. Estes.
00:01:45
Thank you.
00:01:47
Action Item 4A is Action on Location Approval in the Town of Wytheville, Mr. Moshowy.
00:01:55
Excuse me, I'm sorry.
00:01:56
Could you please introduce yourself?
SPEAKER_05
00:01:57
My name is Ken Wallace on behalf of Mr. Moshowy.
00:02:00
He's got back problems today.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:01
I'm here to answer.
00:02:02
Sorry.
00:02:03
Are there any questions of Mr. Wallace regarding the Town of Wytheville location approval?
SPEAKER_02
00:02:07
Move for approval.
00:02:08
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:09
All in favor?
SPEAKER_02
00:02:11
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:11
Thank you.
00:02:12
Please come back.
00:02:14
Under right-of-way and utilities, Mr. Waymack is here and this is action on land conveyance in Stafford County.
00:02:23
Ms. Waymack, could you just give us a brief overview of this action?
SPEAKER_10
00:02:26
Yes, sir.
00:02:28
Good morning.
00:02:29
This is a consummation of an agreement made back in 1998 where we agreed to transfer some property in exchange for a new right-of-way with this particular owner subject to the Board's approval.
00:02:41
He is getting the old location of the roadway and the new roadway has already been constructed and this will convey, should you approve it, the old right-of-way back to the original owner.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:53
Any questions of Mr. Waymack?
00:02:55
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_01
00:02:57
So moved Approval Is there a second?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:03:00
Second All in favor?
00:03:04
Aye Thank you Mr. Waymack
00:03:06
Next is Mr. Kevin Page presenting Action Item 6A on the Rail Industrial Access Program in the City of Salem.
00:03:18
Mr.
00:03:19
Page, could you just give us a brief overview?
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
00:03:21
Sure.
00:03:22
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:03:23
Pitzer Transfer and Storage Corporation has been a project that's been ongoing.
00:03:27
We've been working for two years.
00:03:28
Pitcher has finally got to the point where they've constructed, started construction, finishing up their project, need rail access.
00:03:35
It represents a $2.79 million investment for the City of Salem.
00:03:39
Twenty-five jobs have been retained and five new created due to Pitcher relocating.
00:03:45
Four and five annual railcars of building materials and other supplies will be brought in from the Pacific Northwest and other locations.
00:03:51
and will contribute in bringing trucks off of I-81 and serving by rail.
00:03:56
So that's a good thing for the I-81 corridor.
00:03:58
Pitzer has requested $68,520 of rail industrial access funds.
00:04:04
The total track expense is $234,385.
00:04:07
So you can see kind of the coordination there is going to be greater private investment than public investment.
00:04:14
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:04:15
And I assume there will be a media announcement to this grant award.
00:04:22
There will be a press release associated with this.
00:04:24
Mr. Martin, is there a second?
00:04:27
All in favor?
00:04:30
Action Item 7A involves the Rail Preservation Program and projects in Augusta, Bath, Hanover, and Rockbridge Counties.
00:04:40
Mr.
00:04:40
Page, could you give us just a brief overview?
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
00:04:42
Yes, sir.
00:04:42
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:04:44
This, as the decision brief states in front of me, this action item will amend our fiscal year 2006 program projects for DRPT's Rail Preservation and Development Program.
00:04:55
Back in July of 2005 at this board's meeting we brought to the board for approval and was approved some deallocation of funds that were residual left over from grants for the rail preservation program.
00:05:08
We like to be good stewards of state money and turn that money back around again for good things.
00:05:12
and the Buckingham Branch Railroad through the Rail Enhancement Fund application process identified needs in the counties that you see before you to assist in both bringing the freight railroad up to a greater safety class and efficiency both on the Goshen Branch and in adding putting old passing sidings back into service at North Mountain and Crane which will allow us to see better use of transportation operations of the Amtrak and freight trains as they try to operate over the line.
00:05:37
Also, one of the larger projects that probably get good exposure as well in our press media event is the diamond replacement at Doswell, Virginia.
00:05:47
That's where the Buckham Branch Railroad crosses the RFMP line, which is known as the Richmond-Washington Quarter Passenger Rail Initiative that this board has been supporting for several years.
00:05:57
So the diamond replacement, a portion of that cost is being assessed to the Buckingham Branch Railroad and under rail preservation.
00:06:03
That's an eligible expenditure as well.
00:06:05
Ms. Rae has brought these items to the board for approval and I'll be glad to answer any questions that were made at this time.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:12
Any questions of Mr.
00:06:12
Page?
00:06:14
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_02
00:06:16
I'll move it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:17
Second.
00:06:18
All in favor?
SPEAKER_02
00:06:19
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:20
Thank you, Mr.
00:06:21
Page.
SPEAKER_02
00:06:21
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:23
The next Action Item 8 is Mr. Coburn, and you have a replacement on the pink colored paper for contract awards.
00:06:34
Is this a good month or a bad month, Mr. Coburn?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:06:37
This was an unusual month, sir.
00:06:38
All in all, I think it's a very good month.
00:06:44
I apologize for all the pink that's in your package there today.
00:06:49
But before I start, at the district board members' seats, there is a thick, holy envelope that contains the details of plant mix schedules that we are recommending for award in those districts.
00:07:06
So the at-large members would not have that.
00:07:09
In the past, board members have asked for that level of detail, and that's provided for you, for your benefit.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:07:18
Mr. Coburn, could you make sure that at-large board members have that material for the districts that they live in?
00:07:27
Yes, sir.
00:07:29
Oftentimes the general public doesn't distinguish between an at-large or a district member.
00:07:33
It would be important for them to have that information.
00:07:35
Thank you.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:07:37
I said this was an unusual month and that's part of the reason for the pink paper there.
00:07:45
We received bids in January 25th and February 2nd for plant mix and that's the bulk of what you have and we'll get to that at the end.
00:07:55
We needed to analyze those from a statewide perspective before moving forward.
00:08:02
On Monday afternoon, and let's just get into the talk of this,
00:08:06
Monday afternoon we were advised by the SEC, Virginia State Corporation Commission, that there was something unusual in the trail of ownership with one of our construction firms that was low bidder on two of our projects.
00:08:25
and it deals with the state corporation commission in Virginia works with the corporation commission in the parent state of the home office and this firm was recently sold and there's something unusual there and they gave us this information
00:08:43
We've shared that information with the Attorney General's Office and they've advised that we defer taking action on those two projects until next month to allow the firm and the Corporation Commission to resolve that issue.
00:09:02
And those are items number two on page one and number one on page two.
00:09:14
The firm was Bizak Incorporated from Lexington, Kentucky.
00:09:22
And so I would prefer not to discuss that project at any length and we will defer that until the next meeting.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:32
Is it unusual to have a firm from as far away as Lexington, Kentucky?
00:09:40
Not Lexington, Virginia, but Lexington, Kentucky.
00:09:42
Did none of our work?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:09:45
Not really.
00:09:45
Particularly in the southwestern part of the state or some of the boundary areas, we get a number of firms that
00:09:52
bid across the state lines.
00:09:56
I would be purely guessing to give you an indication of how many out-of-state firms out of our 800 are pre-qualified.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:08
Without objection, we will not take action on Action Item 2 on Page 1 or Action Item 1 on Page 2.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:10:19
Getting into the more normal things then, sir.
00:10:22
Item number one is Route 460 in Prince George County.
00:10:30
This is in the vicinity.
00:10:31
It's about seven-tenths of a mile adjacent to 295.
00:10:34
This is the second time we've bid this project.
00:10:38
We saved a significant amount of money with the rebidding.
00:10:42
In analyzing the bids, we believe it's a very good value and recommend its award.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:47
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_02
00:10:48
I'll move it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:50
Second.
00:10:50
All in favor?
SPEAKER_02
00:10:52
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:54
So we're going to skip over page two.
00:10:55
Is that correct?
00:10:56
And go to page, the next one I have on the pink is page seven.
00:10:59
Do we need to turn to the white?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:11:02
If we go to page three, which is the white page.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:07
Give folks some time.
00:11:09
Is action item one on page three?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:11:12
Sure.
00:11:15
We did news, route 143.
00:11:21
We're recommending rejection of that project.
00:11:25
The bids were very far out of our range to be able to justify any reason for those prices and I recommend rejection.
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:39
We reject.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:42
Is there a second?
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:43
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:45
Any commentary?
00:11:48
All in favor of the motion to reject.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:11:53
On page four from December 21 bid letting is the Route 77 Big Walker and East River Mountain Tunnels.
00:12:05
This is a rehabilitation reconstruction of that structure.
00:12:10
We had two bids, a very good projects bid.
00:12:17
After analyzing, we believe it's very appropriate to award that.
00:12:21
It is unusual work, some specialty work, a combination of construction and maintenance funds that make up that required funding, and we recommend its award.
SPEAKER_02
00:12:35
I move the approval.
00:12:36
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:37
All in favor?
00:12:38
Aye.
00:12:40
Turning to page five.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:12:42
Page five is one of our three projects today that are locally administered.
00:12:49
This one was by Henrico County, Knuckles Road.
00:12:55
We reviewed their plans, their bids.
00:12:59
We believe it's a good value and recommend its award.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:05
All in favor?
00:13:09
Page 6.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:13:10
Page 6 is the second of three locally-administered projects.
00:13:15
This is an enhancement project at the entrance to the James Madison home, Route 20, the entrance to Montpelier.
00:13:24
Again, we've looked at that.
00:13:27
It's a good value, and we recommend it's awarded.
00:13:31
We are folks here to speak to any questions you may have.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:35
Move for approval.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:13:38
Second.
00:13:38
All in favor?
00:13:38
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:40
And now we're going back to the pink, correct?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:13:44
Yes sir.
00:13:45
And we'll turn to page seven from the January 25th bid reading.
00:13:53
This is the Battlefield Boulevard project, 64 in the city of Chesapeake.
00:14:00
We had quite a bit of interest on this project.
00:14:03
Five bidders, good value.
00:14:08
We've looked at some concerns that were raised and believe everything is in order and recommend its award.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:15
Are there any questions regarding action item one on page seven?
00:14:23
Ms. Hanley.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:26
It's a good value but it's 12 million dollars above the budget.
00:14:32
Am I reading that right?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:14:33
It was $12 million over what was in the six-year program when it was published.
00:14:39
And in consultation with the programming division, they've adjusted what those funds are, brought those to date.
00:14:52
There are some STIP amendments that have to be made before that contract will be executed, and that's anticipated to work its way through that process.
00:15:01
in the next two to three weeks.
SPEAKER_03
00:15:05
So you're saying the funds are available?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:15:07
Yes, sir.
00:15:08
The funds have been earmarked to be allocated to that project.
SPEAKER_03
00:15:15
Mr. Chairman, I've discovered that this column that we were asking for, the board has particularly asked for as far as what's in the Six-Year Plan, may not be
00:15:27
as you recorded today may not be exactly the monies available for our project and I think that's a little bit of confusion on my part.
00:15:33
I was thinking that we should have that column to represent what would be available if we were to award this project today.
00:15:40
I think Mr. McCarthy is the one that asked for that column to be added to our report and I don't know that
00:15:48
that I was at any concept other than the fact that this is money that would be available to be expended on the project.
00:15:56
In fact, there are more monies available than what's shown in this column.
00:16:00
So my question, could we have, and is it appropriate to have that column represent monies that are available to award the bid?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:16:09
Off the top of my head, I'm sure there are and I'm sure we can work through that process to get that.
00:16:17
This was, as my recollection, the decision at that point in time to report on what was published and would be the construction line item that was available for public disclosure from the Six-Year Program.
00:16:38
I'm sure we can work through that.
00:16:40
I'll be happy to work through it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:41
We'll come back to that comment in just a minute.
00:16:43
Mr. Witt, did you have a comment?
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:44
You said you had some concerns, but resolve those.
00:16:47
What sort of concerns did you have?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:16:49
There were a couple of issues that were raised during the advertisement process, which is part of the reason for the delay in getting this in your bid package.
00:16:58
We had to work through those several concern issues, whether or not they were valid, whether or not they were high risk, low risk.
00:17:08
dealt specifically with the location of a box culvert that was existing and its elevation and how it would possibly interfere with utilities that were to be placed.
00:17:28
Technical issues.
00:17:31
Not procurement issues, but technical issues.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:34
Is there a question?
SPEAKER_08
00:17:35
Mr. Martin?
00:17:36
I'm going to read it to Mr.
00:17:37
Keen, actually.
00:17:38
If we did add a column that shows what was currently available, would you also want to keep the one that's currently here?
00:17:47
I'm thinking in terms of situations where we might wonder why or where a large change came from.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:57
And let's come back to that generic issue of how to array this and let's focus on the matter at hand and when we get through the bids because I think that's a very important question when we get to the conclusion that if that's acceptable to folks.
00:18:10
Are there any other questions about the award of this contract?
00:18:16
Is there a motion?
00:18:17
Oh, I do have a question, excuse me.
00:18:19
These contracts now have completion dates in them, is that correct?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:18:26
Yes, sir, they do.
00:18:26
There's a fixed completion date associated with the project.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:29
And when that completion date, that's part of the final negotiation after the bid award, is that correct?
00:18:36
Or do you know what that completion date is?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:18:38
The completion date is part of the proposal that is advertised, so it is automatically part of the normal proposal.
00:18:46
The only time we would negotiate a different date is if we've had to delay beyond the normal 60-day period in awarding a contract.
00:18:56
And then that can be a negotiated date established through a memorandum of agreement and documented in the contract.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:06
The chair would just note for the record, thinking about Mercury Boulevard, Battlefield Boulevard, very busy, same contractor.
00:19:15
I think it's very important that we make a very clear message to the public and to the contractor that this is a fixed date completion contract.
00:19:26
And I would invite any additional commentary from Mr. Witt, who lives daily with the Mercury Boulevard project.
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:33
I have to share with you all that I have received more than one phone call wondering why in the world of Berkeley Boulevard we'd be going down a similar path awarding with the same contractor, but I am convinced that we go through the process and we've qualified the contractors that are allowed to bid on this.
00:19:57
I absolutely support, Mr. Secretary, what you're saying, and my question is
00:20:02
Completion date is not met.
00:20:03
Does the contract then have penalties for failure to complete?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:20:07
Yes, sir, there are significant penalties if the fixed date is not met.
00:20:13
The fixed completion date for this project is established as November 1 of 2008.
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:21
Construction would commence when?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:20:25
Construction would begin with notice to proceed approximately 30 days from today.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:32
Can I explore this a little bit further because our district was the victim of a fixed date contract once upon a time.
00:20:41
Fixed date doesn't necessarily mean the same thing to everybody.
00:20:46
For example, are there like rain delays or weather related events built into this fixed date moving around a bit or is this absolutely a fixed date and tough if you don't make it?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:20:59
Our current contracts carry with it a fixed date that is not adjusted by weather delays.
00:21:07
If there is work that is added that delays or adds time in that construction process when that work is added that could establish a new fixed date.
00:21:23
That is not the intent of our standard contract language.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:28
As I recall, without getting into it, precisely that addition of other work was used as a
00:21:38
A reason to use weather delays as well.
00:21:43
In other words, it got very murky in a hurry in the case that I'm thinking about.
00:21:47
So I'm just, I'm trying to encourage you to nail this down as tightly as you can, because even those of us who only rarely traverse that area don't know how you all stand it.
00:21:59
And if this is going to get done by a fixed date, I would encourage no loopholes.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:22:06
I hear you loud and clear and we've attempted to eliminate any loopholes that are there in our language as it exists today as opposed to several years ago.
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:19
Okay, is there a motion?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:28
Is there a second?
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:30
I'll give you a break in seconds.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:33
All in favor?
00:22:36
Thank you.
00:22:40
On page eight.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:22:40
Beginning with page eight and going to the last page are the plant mix schedules that we've taken in on January the 25th and February the 7th.
00:22:52
As I indicated, we needed to get all of those in and analyze them as a unit, not only for value but for the impact across the state.
00:23:02
I believe we can take those in a little bit of a package, if you will.
00:23:08
Pages 8 through 15 represent the district-wide schedules making up multiple counties in Bristol, Salem, Lynchburg, Hampton Roads, Fredericksburg,
00:23:33
Culpepper, Stanton.
00:23:40
After analyzing these contracts, some which had good competition, some which only had one bidder.
00:23:50
All of these contracts represented very good values.
00:23:56
Prices that were
00:23:59
in the range of asphalt increases that we very much expected to see in the marketplace today.
00:24:06
There are 22 contracts that we're recommending for award that total $61 million in change.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:19
Are there any questions on any of the plant mix contracts that are recommended for award?
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:30
Is there a motion to approve these in a block?
SPEAKER_02
00:24:37
Mr. Chairman, I intend to make such a motion, but I would say that it sure would help us to be better informed if we could get this ahead of time.
00:24:54
This is a whole lot of money to be
00:24:57
It would be helpful to be able to talk to the district people and get their input at least in our respective districts.
00:25:09
With that being said, I still make the motion to approve in a block.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:14
Is there a second?
00:25:16
All in favor?
SPEAKER_02
00:25:18
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:19
and if you would please note that on the plant mix and this time here is an extremely busy time of the year for the department getting ready for the spring schedule but it is appropriate given the board's oversight responsibilities to have that information in advance.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:25:36
I certainly agree in discussions with the Chief Engineer and the Chief of Operations.
00:25:42
We plan to have a very different schedule in the future.
00:25:47
Thank you.
00:25:48
Page 16 and 17.
00:25:54
represent projects, district-wide projects in Hampton Roads, Fredericksburg, and Stanton, various county locations that did not represent a good value.
00:26:09
In some of these
00:26:11
Tonnage prices were two to three times beyond what could be justified and again you can see in some cases there's very little competition and we're recommending rejection of these these projects.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:29
And so this would be the
00:26:32
Four items on both pages 16 and 17, which would be the Hampton Roads, two in the Hampton Roads District, one in Fredericksburg, and one in Stanton.
00:26:42
Now what, I'm sure the next question is, with that rejection, what is the next step and how do you assure that this routine maintenance is carried out in those districts?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:26:52
These districts have already begun looking at those contracts in specific, what those routes are, are higher priority, are there any contract items, any language in those contracts that skewed the pricing, limited competition, such that these can be restructured and re-advertised at an appropriate period.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:20
And just for the benefit of the board, each district has an established budget for plant mix.
00:27:28
Is that correct?
00:27:29
They've got a fixed dollar amount that they have to work with to?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:27:32
Yes, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:34
Ms. Hanley.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:35
Mr. Chairman, in looking on page 16,
00:27:38
which I believe is the list being proposed for rejection at this current point.
00:27:43
I noticed that several of those, all of those companies for whom we have rejected contracts, we have awarded contracts in the previous action.
00:27:54
Can somebody explain to me how, what is the, what are the vagaries of life such that their tonnage and everything would be okay in one contract but not in the other?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:28:09
I'll try to take a shot at that, yes.
00:28:12
One of the things that we look at contract to contract, are there limitations, hours of operation, are there noise issues, noise ordinances that limit
00:28:25
The time the contractor can be working in an area, the congestion of an area and what he may have to do from traffic control or those types of things that would otherwise negatively influence his pricing schedule.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:42
Well I would suggest to you that looking at this list that can't be it because the ones that are awarded that are proposed for rejection are in areas where they should be having to work all night and have urban problems as opposed to the ones where they were awarded so what else happens?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:29:03
Again, the routes that are there, the supply line that they may have, their production capability, let's say a firm... Let me ask in a different way.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:19
Yes ma'am.
00:29:21
Could the budget available in the different districts make a difference?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:29:31
It could play a strategy with different firms on what contracts they were very aggressively going after.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:40
Well, that wasn't exactly what I meant, and I'm huddling around here in Hampton Roads, but let me ask it this way.
00:29:47
There are two to be rejected in Hampton Roads, which may well be more complicated than by the company that was accepted in some other place.
00:29:58
Would the budget that the Hampton Roads District have allowed for maintenance, even if it's the same contract in two different places, make a difference in the award?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:30:10
That could have an influence.
00:30:15
The particular product that we are requesting on a different contract, the recipe of the asphalt, if you will, whether it's an SMA or surface mixes or those kind of things, they have an influence on how firms bid.
00:30:35
Some products are more difficult to make.
00:30:39
and control the quality of.
00:30:41
So there is a greater risk in some products from a production standpoint that has an influence.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:52
My question is really more a budgetary question.
SPEAKER_05
00:30:56
That would affect the budget.
00:30:57
Let me see to answer your question.
00:30:59
The two projects in Hampton Roads, both have SMA on them, which is a product.
00:31:05
They went for about $98, $115.
00:31:08
Very expensive.
00:31:10
Also, one of them is located, I believe, around the tunnels.
00:31:14
and there was some working in there with the traffic in there that the question was raised after the bids were received on the constructability.
00:31:22
We do look at what we have budgeted for each of these items and we do make some decisions on availability of funds.
00:31:33
We're also looking at do we feel that the price we got was a good price and these two
00:31:40
In Hampton Roads, we're going to take the SMA out of the particular contract, use a different, as Byron said, a different mix, which we think would probably be
00:31:54
In the $70 range, so it's going to bring that down.
00:31:58
We're going to look at that one of the constructability issues that have been raised and look at those.
00:32:03
But we do look at budgetary and what people have in each of their districts.
00:32:07
We try to look at it from a statewide program also.
SPEAKER_01
00:32:11
When you speak of the product and you look at different mix,
00:32:23
And I believe one's probably cheaper than the other, but we look at the quality of it holding up.
00:32:30
How do you decide in what areas of what niche that you're going to use?
00:32:36
The reason I ask that question is how long is it going to hold up?
00:32:42
How much maintenance is going to be required?
00:32:45
And so sometimes the cheapest is not the best.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:32:49
Certainly very, very true.
00:32:52
We look at data we collect from our materials engineers, our pavement engineers, the stresses that we are detecting the pavement, the smoothness of pavement, and look at its life cycle through predictor models to look at what are different applications, different thicknesses, different types of mixes.
00:33:17
What we can expect out of each from a durability standpoint and our engineers give us those recommendations on how we structure that product to begin with.
00:33:30
We're looking in that life cycle of always looking for eight to ten years in that process and that's part of that economic decision that goes into how we structure the contract to begin with.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:48
Any other questions?
00:33:50
Mr. Coburn.
00:33:53
We are on pages 16 and 17 and the recommendation is to reject action items 1, 2, and 3 on page 16 and action item 4 on page 17.
00:34:05
Is there a motion?
00:34:07
Is there a second?
00:34:09
All in favor?
00:34:12
Okay.
00:34:12
Moving on to page 18.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:34:14
Page 18 to 20 represent bids that were taken on February the 7th.
00:34:22
These are district-wide in Richmond District and Northern Virginia District.
00:34:32
All of these nine projects were analyzed.
00:34:40
We validate funding is there as part of that process and are recommended award.
00:34:50
All of them are good values.
00:34:52
Again, you'll note some of them, there was very little competition, but still represent very good values.
SPEAKER_09
00:34:59
Any reason why there's so little competition?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:35:01
Asphalt plants around the state typically have less competition until we start inviting folks across the state line.
00:35:12
We get closer to the boundaries and we get some of that.
00:35:15
We've had some out-of-state contractors looking at our plant mix operations and our surfacing operations.
00:35:25
There's just less competition, less contractors in that part of the business.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:32
OK, there's a recommendation to approve on pages 18, 19, and 20 action items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9 in Northern Virginia and the Richmond District.
00:35:49
Is there a second?
00:35:49
All in favor?
00:35:51
Aye.
00:35:52
OK.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:35:53
On page 21, items 1, 2, and 3, all are in Northern Virginia schedules.
00:36:02
After analyzing those bids, again, some very high prices.
00:36:09
A number of issues we're looking at with the district to restructure those contracts and how they could be restructured.
00:36:18
We're recommending rejection of those three contracts.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:25
I'd like to raise it again because we're seeing it again.
00:36:28
We have two of these rejections are from a company that we just awarded bids in Northern Virginia and the rest of the state, I might add.
00:36:37
Two, when you said there were some of these had not a lot of competition, do you mean within the one bid within the district about one
00:36:50
I expect within the district might have a lot of competition and the next one within the same district might not have much.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:36:56
We see that certainly within the districts.
00:37:02
In this instance, all of these contracts had two different firms bidding on that work.
00:37:11
For an asphalt type of work, I'm always happy to see at least two.
00:37:17
I'd like to see more.
00:37:20
But typically there's not that many firms that are in that market competing.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:26
Now, will we be able to go back out for these rejections very quickly in order to get them done in this season?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:37:33
We're working with the district right now to identify those key routes that they want to restructure, yes ma'am.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:41
Does restructure have anything to do with budget considerations?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:37:45
Certainly it has to take into consideration the budget that the district has available for that work.
00:37:52
It also looks at the highest priorities in perhaps restructuring these three contracts into one or into two.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:01
Let me ask it this way.
00:38:04
Is there enough money, would there have been enough money to have awarded these three contracts?
00:38:12
or are they rejected based on not having enough money left in the pot?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:38:17
These projects have our recommendation for not being a good value.
00:38:23
I'd be hazarding to guess right now to tell you where that falls in the budget.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:30
I have some concern here that again the last person in the pool gets to be the lifeguard here that if we're rejecting these values one thing but I'm having trouble understanding how one of these companies could be a good value on a project that is in the same county as not even district but county as another project I mean even a small part of the district and they must know
00:39:00
I mean, they can't be too different unless, of course, I can't tell what's on these particular lists.
00:39:05
So it might be something that's a very steep hill, I guess, or a 20-lane road.
00:39:10
But I'm having trouble understanding how a company can fluctuate so widely on projects that have to be within a fairly small, very similar, within a very small area, if it isn't money.
00:39:27
And then if it's money, that's a different speech.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:30
Might I suggest at our next meeting that we get a presentation during the work session, and there may as well be action items, but for those contracts that were rejected today, what is the makeup plan to accomplish that work?
00:39:51
Now there may very well be
00:39:54
bid awards or at least some bid awards but there's been a fairly high number of rejections.
00:40:00
Folks didn't have an opportunity to view this in advance and so I think it's a fair question to ask the department to come back at the next meeting and for those items where there has been a rejection to see what's being done to make that up and perhaps have a little more substance.
00:40:14
Is it budget?
00:40:16
I suspect in some of these it may very well be.
00:40:18
If you see it's in the urbanized area, VDOT is in competition with the commercial sector.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:24
So it may very well be a very large project right up the street that's driving prices or... And I would have understood that if they had all, if there hadn't have been so many that had the same company have acceptances and rejections in a very small area.
00:40:37
I would have thought they would have caught on somehow.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:41
Byron, is it possible that one explanation might be that
00:40:46
Simple as some jobs are more desirable to get than others and for the undesirable ones you bid differently and there's less competition?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:40:56
Certainly that's part of the strategy an individual firm will have and some firms will aggressively go after interstate project work as an example.
00:41:09
Some will stay away from interstate project work just for the same reason of how their workforce is structured or their equipment load, how they can best operate their firms.
00:41:24
That's certainly part of the strategy that firms look at.
SPEAKER_09
00:41:27
Would they just take into consideration the amount of work they have?
00:41:30
They've got plenty of work so they'll bid on this and if they get in time, if they don't, it's alright since they have so much.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:41:36
That's certainly part of the bidding strategy different firms exercise.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:42
Is there a motion to reject?
00:41:45
Is there a second?
00:41:47
All in favor of rejecting these bids, please vote aye.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:41:53
And the last item on the agenda today is on page 22.
00:41:59
This is another locally administered project.
00:42:02
This is by the town of Ashland, the Hillcarter Parkway.
00:42:09
Funding is available.
00:42:10
We've reviewed the bids that were taken by the town, and I believe they represent an appropriately good value and recommend their award.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:21
Is there a second?
00:42:22
All in favor of approval?
00:42:26
It is approved.
00:42:27
Mr. Coburn, thank you for an interesting month.
00:42:30
Next month will probably be more interesting.
00:42:32
Can we come back to the question of formatting the question?
SPEAKER_06
00:42:36
I'm sorry, may I ask before Mr. Coburn, may I ask a question?
00:42:39
Going back to the white pages on page three, a bid that we rejected that was $6.2 million
00:42:49
I guess higher than the six-year program funds.
00:42:54
This kind of follows on what Mr.
00:42:55
Keen said and what we're getting ready to do.
00:42:59
I mean, primarily, one of the reasons we're rejecting that is because it exceeds by such a margin the six-year funds available.
00:43:08
But we didn't have the missing piece of information, for example, what other funds might have been available to make up the difference.
00:43:14
And I'm curious about
00:43:16
What happens to that project now that it's been rejected for being so far out of line?
00:43:21
I don't know what the project estimate might have been, the in-house estimate might have been, but obviously this exceeds it by a considerable amount.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:32
I would note, and Byron correct me if I'm wrong, there's a big distinction between the dollar figure that shows in the Six-Year Program, which is an allocation of funding, and as our best guess, remember that number was probably developed a year ago,
00:43:45
versus the engineer's estimate, which is an internal evaluation of the contract.
00:43:53
The scope may have changed fairly substantially since the year before.
00:43:58
Those are two very different items.
00:44:02
I believe one of the reasons that we stuck with what was in the Six-Year Program was to try to enforce that accountability to make us all do better planning and programming and sticking to that number.
00:44:17
It's not perfect.
00:44:19
I would imagine on some of these issues there are fairly significant scope changes from when we thought out the Six-Year Program over a year ago.
00:44:28
But Ms. Coburn, do you want to
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:44:30
You're absolutely right, and that's my best recollection of why we stuck with the published six-year program figure to begin with.
00:44:41
To answer your more specific question,
00:44:45
When we have a project like this, and we have done so on this one, as we analyze it, we're talking with the contractor, and we're trying to identify any things that we have contracted for that are not reasonable, not constructible.
00:45:02
If we see things that are product-specific that are particularly expensive, is there a different way we can do that, and can we restructure that contract?
00:45:13
What would happen here is we'll begin very quickly working, looking at this project and how can we restructure it so that it can be re-advertised and to get that work accomplished and maybe there's a smarter way.
00:45:32
Could be as simple as market saturation at this particular period of time.
00:45:36
It could be a niche market type of project that those firms that would normally compete are very busy.
00:45:46
And so we see all of those types of things.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:53
Coming back to the formatting issue, my own sense is it probably is a good idea to stick with the six-year program number, but what I would ask perhaps for staff to come back
00:46:04
Next month would be some ideas on some other indicators.
00:46:08
Perhaps, for example, is there additional money available in the maintenance budget, if that's necessary.
00:46:17
I don't think we want to be in the business of publishing the engineer's estimate.
00:46:20
That's something that's closely protected in the code of Virginia.
00:46:24
And I think the issue, so many of these awards are not related directly to budget, but it's the unit cost.
00:46:33
Is it the value for the dollars spent?
00:46:36
So it's kind of an independent evaluation rather than available funds, in most cases.
00:46:42
In some cases, it may be a rejection based on that.
00:46:44
Is that a fair assessment?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:46:46
Yes, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:49
Is the board amenable to that?
00:46:50
I'm sorry.
Alan S. Witt
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:51
Mr. Secretary, maybe to repeat what you're saying, but I just think we do have to balance our requirement to have good information on which we make decisions and protecting the taxpayer's money by not putting too much information out there before it is received and accordingly ending up ratcheting up a cost just because we are being free with information that doesn't otherwise have to be public information.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:17
Right, and I do believe one of the ways to solve that, as Mr. Bowie indicated, would simply be to get the information out to board members earlier so there is a time to have informal dialogue and questions both at the district and the central office level.
00:47:33
I think a lot of these questions can be resolved because each
00:47:36
I don't think there's a simple answer that covers every rejection.
00:47:40
My guess is each individual rejection has very different reasons.
00:47:44
It might be maintenance of traffic.
00:47:46
It might be availability of the kind of mix.
00:47:48
It might be competition with the private sector.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:56
I think keeping the construction number in the Six-Year Plan as written is a good idea.
00:48:05
It happens perhaps more often than it used to that the actual bids come in a little higher than that lately.
00:48:12
But at least in the Richmond District, that's something that Tom Hawthorne and I would go over before the meeting.
00:48:19
And I always ask, so where do we get the money for that?
00:48:21
And you'll say, well, it'll come out of next year's six-year plan somewhere.
00:48:25
We'll probably get pushed out in the sixth year.
00:48:28
You'll have less money available for something else.
00:48:33
And that's usually the way it has worked.
00:48:37
But I think keeping that number there is better than the alternative.
00:48:43
We all learned much in the two or three years since we asked for that column to be added.
00:48:49
And I agree with you that it's not usually quite so simple to say that there's a one-size-fits-all solution.
00:48:57
So having at least something that is consistent, that is what is in the current six-year plan, and if it's above that, then that's something I hope to, at least I'll continue to work with my district administrator on how we resolve that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:12
Okay, Ms. Hanley?
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:13
Well I think that is my issue if it's above that and I thought I heard you say on one of these that it was RSTP money or STP money or that was being allocated.
00:49:27
Is that a fair, is that what you said?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:49:29
I think what we were talking about was the Battlefield Boulevard project that you awarded but we cannot execute that contract until the
00:49:38
The SDP fund is amended to account for that allocation and that takes the local action of the several localities that were involved with that.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:52
Is that true statewide?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:49:54
There's a little different process whether it's an MPO area or not, but generally yes.
00:50:03
If projects are outside of the range in the tip and step, then it has to be amended.
00:50:11
That's part of that reconciliation that we go through.
00:50:15
with the programming division.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:17
I guess my question really is, what if that project is in a place that's non-governable by an MPO that makes those RSTP decisions?
00:50:27
I know I was speaking English, but it didn't sound like it.
00:50:31
What happens in that case?
00:50:35
Because I assume there are projects, a law in the state, that are not governed by an MPO.
00:50:42
And so if it were to come in, if that project had been in a non-MPO area, how would that money, how would that STP money have been allocated?
00:50:54
Who would have made that decision?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:57
Where would it have come from?
00:50:58
If it's in a non-MPO area, there would not be regional STP.
00:51:02
There is statewide STP which is allocated by the CTB.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:07
So that would then have to come to us?
00:51:10
Yes ma'am.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:12
Okay, any other questions?
00:51:14
And we'll look forward to a work session presentation on this at our next meeting.
00:51:19
We will get recommendations on any additional data that might supplement the right-hand column, as well as updates on how we'll pick up the projects that were rejected, what actions are being taken to move that along.
00:51:33
I might mention because one of the things that I want to and this is really kind of a segue into some other items in new business but one of the issues as you all know declining competition and as we're discussing transportation funding across the way there is a very significant evolution of the industry that we're relying on to maintain and
00:51:56
build our highways.
00:51:58
Jack Sanford, who some of you know from the Charlottesville area, family owned business for decades, his business ain't testified in front of house finance committee.
00:52:07
It was about 40% VDOT work, about 60% commercial.
00:52:11
At the end of next month, he will have 0% VDOT work.
00:52:16
And he has diversified his business into the commercial areas.
00:52:20
Well, that's one less competitor for these contracts.
00:52:24
And that is a real world consequence of not having, you're seeing the results of that.
00:52:30
Now plant mix is always hard because there are a limited number of suppliers but there are fewer and that lack of competition is a direct result of not having stable, reliable, long-term funding sources that the private sector can make their investment decisions on.
00:52:47
They're not going to erect
00:52:48
a facility to make plant mix if they don't know that there will be contracts there for the next several years to recruit their investment.
00:52:57
That being said, let me turn to the next item which is new business and I did want to call your attention to
00:53:06
A couple of items.
00:53:07
The first is at your place there is an updated listing of the Commonwealth Transportation Board membership and I'd ask Ms. Mathis if you would forward it electronically to board members as well so you can have that.
00:53:23
Secondly is a document and I would ask Ms. Henley if she would just give us a quick overview.
00:53:30
This is the transaction 2030 survey that was conducted
00:53:35
up in Northern Virginia and it is a very good overview of transportation needs as well as necessary transportation funding as well as public attitudes about transportation in the Northern Virginia region.
00:53:53
And I know there's been similar work.
00:53:55
We've had presentations from Hampton Roads MPO.
00:53:58
And I just asked, Kate, if you had any additional comments you wanted to make?
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:03
The fun part is this is the first time I've had a chance to see it.
00:54:06
But having heard several presentations, this is the update of something that Northern Virginia's been doing for
00:54:15
This one was done by the official Northern Virginia Transportation Authority.
00:54:23
Yes, there is one.
00:54:24
It used to be called the TCC before it got to be an authority in 2002.
00:54:30
to talk about what corridors need improving and what needs to happen in order to, as we used to fondly say in the maps in the center, make the red at least turn, the ketchup at least turn to mustard.
00:54:47
When we started doing this, we discovered that we could even talk in traffic not only through F,
00:54:52
but could actually differentiate G, which is the mustard, and H, G, which we called gridlock, and H, of course, the ketchup, which we called hell.
00:55:04
And so these, there were actually some runs done to look at what has to happen.
00:55:11
The I-95, I know it will come as no surprise to Mary Lee that the I-95 quarter is one of the toughest ones.
00:55:18
It needs everything.
00:55:20
in order to keep it from being read at all times.
00:55:24
The Transportation Authority did a survey of the populations in these corridors, and I haven't had a chance to look at this, so I don't know if the survey results are in here.
00:55:36
Are they in here?
00:55:38
If you have a chance, they're on page four.
00:55:44
Yes, they're in here.
00:55:46
And it was fascinating that people pretty much understood what the problems were and were willing to pay for fixing them.
00:55:56
But what we found in Northern Virginia out of a lot of this was people were more than willing to pay for public transportation.
00:56:05
It was an incredible support and for the Dulles Project was just amazing.
00:56:15
Following up on all the other surveys that have been taken since as far back as the famous Deer Departed Transportation Referendum.
00:56:24
So this is sort of an interesting piece of where Northern Virginia needs to go and how much money it will take to get the transportation network there.
00:56:36
And it's on the very back page.
00:56:38
The bottom line is on the back page.
00:56:41
And I know you'll find that it's divided into system expansion and operation and preservation because they're two different things.
00:56:51
The bottom line to build the 2030 plan, of course, is $46.6 billion to build it and operate it and maintain it.
00:57:02
I think that puts in perspective, and I hope it puts in perspective, recognizing that this is just a part of the state.
00:57:08
The need that we have statewide for dedicated transportation funding.
00:57:16
This has been quantified in Northern Virginia.
00:57:18
I'm sure everybody could come up with a number that is equally as daunting, but we've got to begin to chip away at it.
00:57:27
I recommend it for your bedtime reading.
SPEAKER_09
00:57:30
I don't know if this is an appropriate forum here or not, but you know, I'm really sort of offended by the statements I'm hearing out of the General Assembly.
00:57:40
Really sampling all over VDOT.
00:57:42
I've filled with the Board of Supervisors for years.
00:57:45
I've had my battles with VDOT.
00:57:47
And we all know that this department had its problems a few years ago.
00:57:51
But I think we know it has had dramatic improvements.
00:57:55
And I think some of these comments are insults to the men and women who work for VDOT.
00:57:59
You know, if you look at this, you can just say, if VDOT were more efficient, there wouldn't be any problem.
00:58:07
I mean, how nonsensical can you be?
00:58:10
I don't know if it's appropriate that this body do anything.
00:58:12
I guess it looks like we're just trying to defend ourselves or something if we try to tell the General Assembly that they are not going the right way here.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:20
Mr. Watson what I might suggest those that you all write to your local newspapers and put something in writing and sometimes the community newspaper is one of the best ways to communicate that to a local audience and I don't think it needs to be in your face but just to remind people where we were four short years ago eight hundred and sixty seven million dollars of accumulated project deficits
00:58:51
$2.7 billion of fake revenue, less than 30% of projects on time, less than 50% of projects on budget.
00:59:05
And when people say, well, give me some real world examples, I start from north to south.
00:59:10
Woodrow Wilson Bridge, first span opens this spring on time on budget.
00:59:16
Springfield Interchange, the symbol
00:59:19
of management failure throughout state government.
00:59:22
$687 million on time on budget.
00:59:28
Pinners Point Interchange, $92 million on time on budget.
00:59:34
Route 17, I don't recall the, Alan, you may recall the dollar amount on that, but on time on budget.
00:59:39
Those are four of the largest public works projects in the United States of America.
00:59:44
That's a darn good track record.
00:59:47
And so I would encourage you, and thank you for bringing that up, Mr. Watson.
00:59:52
I don't think we need to hit people with a hammer on that, but I think educating the people back home is well worth the time and effort.
00:59:59
And so those of you who do have that relationship with your communities to find an opportunity to just send a letter to the editor, I think would be extremely beneficial.
01:00:10
And on that wonderful segue note, you do have at your places
01:00:17
A handout I do want to share with you.
01:00:19
This is a presentation that I made last week to the Senate Finance Committee, and I want to turn your attention to the last two pages.
01:00:33
Most of the front part of this is explaining the governor's package, and you all are familiar with that.
01:00:38
We've had previous presentations on this, but I want to underscore the cost of doing nothing, and that's on pages 14 and 15 of this.
01:00:48
On page 14, in the year 2010, that six-year program, why did we choose 2010?
01:00:56
That is Governor Cain's last year in office.
01:01:00
This is slide 14.
01:01:01
That six-year program that's released by this board and this governor would stretch out to the year 2015.
01:01:12
And as you know, year six, when you first come on this board, it sounds like a long ways away, but by now, you know it's not that far away.
01:01:20
In that six-year program, we would commit every penny of state dollars to two things, paying for maintenance and matching federal dollars.
01:01:29
At that point, our program improvements would be exclusively driven by Congress.
01:01:36
and the federal mandates that come with it and your maintenance responsibilities you've just spent time on today.
01:01:41
The very next year, and that would be the next governor, the Six-Year Program would be unable to match all of those federal dollars.
01:01:50
So every dollar of state funding that we have left over, we would have to leave $4 on the table.
01:01:58
In fiscal year 2010, the transit capital reimbursement would fall below 20%.
01:02:05
and we would not be regarded as a reliable investment partner.
01:02:08
If you look over on page 15 and I took some liberty with my home county of Prince William to say, well, what's the world look like?
01:02:17
And I think this example and these percentages are true for every county, every city and every town in the Commonwealth.
01:02:25
Our secondary allocation in Prince William County in fiscal year 05, that's just last year, was about $7.4 million that allowed a little over four miles of new four-lane secondary road construction on average.
01:02:37
That's a, you know, obviously those numbers bounce around quite a bit, but on average, that's correct.
01:02:42
If you look fast-forward just a couple years to fiscal year 10, that secondary road allocation for that same county drops to $2.6 million.
01:02:52
and 1.3 miles of new four-lane secondary road construction.
01:02:57
And by fiscal year 15, it drops to $1.9 million or less than a mile of new secondary road construction.
01:03:08
Those percentages will be true for every county, every city.
01:03:13
That's Prince William calling in the state.
01:03:17
So this is one of the messages that you all can help to communicate back home is the cost of doing nothing.
01:03:26
And this is not a pretty picture.
01:03:29
But it is the financial reality that we live with.
01:03:33
And so I hope this example is helpful.
01:03:37
In a matter of days, we will be providing some charts that will show some direct comparisons of the governor's plan, the cost of doing nothing, the House plan, and the Senate plan.
01:03:50
I would give some very
01:03:53
overview comments.
01:03:55
The House plan was released last Friday by the Speaker in the House Republican caucus.
01:04:01
The authorizing legislation has been approved.
01:04:05
We're still waiting on the appropriations, proposed appropriations that would occur this Sunday.
01:04:11
The main feature of the House plan is to dedicate existing general fund resources and to send those to Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia.
01:04:24
and that is defined by construction districts.
01:04:27
So it would be general funds going to those districts and really that is the largest single feature of the program.
01:04:38
What does that mean for areas of the state outside of those areas?
01:04:44
It means, for example, the insurance proceeds that are supposed to pay the FRAN debt will be paid by the existing construction program.
01:04:53
So if you compare, if you go to say the Lynchburg area, whether it's the city or the county, and you ask, well, how would we do under the budget as introduced versus how would we do under that plan, I think you would see parentheses around those numbers.
01:05:12
And we'll have those hard numbers for you in a matter of days.
01:05:16
So that's the broad outline of the House plan.
01:05:21
And I would say, in defense of the House plan, the expenditure program that they have chosen is somewhat similar to the governor's proposal.
01:05:32
So it hits debt service, it hits maintenance needs, it hits transit capital.
01:05:39
It does talk about maintaining corridors.
01:05:42
But the funding levels are such that, and particularly with the regional allocations, that it will have a very different impact from region to region as compared to the governor's plan.
01:05:51
Before I answer a question, let me just, the Senate Finance Committee has voted out a plan yesterday, which is approximately the same size as the governor's, a little bit bigger.
01:06:04
The revenue sources, the House plan predominantly relies on general fund resources and abuser fees.
01:06:11
The Senate plan relies on a grantor's tax, which is somewhat similar to the recordation tax, a sales tax, which is imposed at the RAC.
01:06:23
with a provision for rebates to in-state gas tax payers.
01:06:31
There is a smaller abuser fee and some fairly stiff, overweight truck fines and heavy truck registration fees.
01:06:41
Combined, that's over $900 million a year in transportation revenues.
01:06:46
And in the Senate plan, they take $50 million off the top for rail.
01:06:53
and then the remainder of the money is divided 14.7% for transit and 85% for the balance for highways and that goes through the existing transportation trust fund formula.
01:07:09
As we've tried to talk about and get, because there's a lot of moving parts on the table right now, we've tried to focus on three very basic core needs.
01:07:20
The first is to pay off existing debt, that's the France, and in the governor's budget that's done through a dedication of the insurance proceeds.
01:07:29
The second is to make up the highway maintenance deficit.
01:07:33
And in the current year, we're taking about $350 million out of construction and moving it into maintenance.
01:07:40
That needs to be reversed, and that needs to be a sustainable.
01:07:43
That cannot be a one-time thing.
01:07:46
And then the third, minimally, is to get the transit capital numbers up to 95% in a sustainable fashion.
01:07:55
And so the House and the Senate take different approaches to that and as I say we'll be getting some more quantitative analysis so you can see the strengths and weaknesses of each proposal.
01:08:06
But as you go back and talk to your communities or if you have time to visit across the way with members, it cannot be a long-term reliance on general funds.
01:08:16
Why?
01:08:16
Because general funds can't be appropriated more than two years.
01:08:20
You can't plan a six-year program around that.
01:08:23
Secondly, it has to meet those core needs.
01:08:29
And third, and most important to this governor, and most of you have had careers in local government and civic affairs, ultimately that comes out of education and healthcare and higher ed and public safety and economic development and natural resources.
01:08:44
And one of the things that we're trying to establish is that division between the user fee financed system of transportation versus a general fund for those other services.
01:08:54
So I'll be happy to answer any questions on that.
01:08:57
Yes, ma'am.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:08:58
Mr. Chairman, the House plan then would essentially be a one-time plan.
01:09:04
Is it projected that that would be this biennium and is there projection for the next biennium or it's just the appropriation that would happen in this budget?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:09:16
That is probably a matter of some debate.
01:09:20
The House has said, and I neglected to provide in their proposal, there's $552 million in one-time project designation, so we expect to see, when the budget is released this Sunday, a fair number of one-time project allocations, and that raises concerns.
01:09:37
Is that enough to actually complete a project?
01:09:39
We're familiar with that with the federal bill?
01:09:43
So that is clearly one time.
01:09:46
For the regional allocation of funds they're talking about a dedication of what are currently today general funds and then pledging that to debt.
01:09:56
I will say to you our quick calculation and we may not be fully understanding all the impacts of the bill and won't really know that until the companion budget comes out is that the debt doesn't really terribly much increase the amount of
01:10:10
funds available to Northern Virginia or Hampton Roads, but it is a way of locking in those general fund proceeds in some degree of perpetuity.
01:10:21
The remaining funds, though, however, would be, which is, again, for the areas outside Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia, that would be subject to the annual appropriation cycle because they are general funds.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:35
I guess my question was a little bit different.
01:10:39
Did you say that the money that would be designated for Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia would be in perpetuity?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:46
That's the House proposal and their method of doing that is to tie it to a bonding program, which they believe would
01:11:00
allow for a perpetual commitment of those general funds.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:05
You know, I represent Northern Virginia here and it might seem that I would think that that would be such a terrific idea.
01:11:15
However, what happens when you start funding things out of the general fund that should have their own trust funds and transportation is one of those things?
01:11:28
When you put that into the general fund, you compete directly with education.
01:11:35
And for the Northern Virginia localities, we are the region and the state in education that gets the lowest percentage, because we have large school divisions, but percentage of education dollars.
01:11:49
And we have no interest in seeing the amount of money that's allocated to education decline because that's substantial and quick for local governments to fund education.
01:12:03
So it's always hard for us to see transportation and education
01:12:08
compete for the same dollar.
01:12:11
And so while it sounds counterintuitive, I would think that it's more important to have a trust fund that is sustainable and long-term and allows us not to have to save all our pennies all at once for one particular project, but to be able to fund a six-year program with some assurance
01:12:33
Well said, Ms. McCarthy.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:00
In the spirit of Mr. Watson and somewhat more seriously in the spirit of your educational campaign
01:13:08
I've been conducting my own little harlot game with friends and others who I run into, and I ask them from the perspective of, how much do you think you spend on the gas tax each year?
01:13:22
And it's always fascinating to hear these estimates, because they always say, gee, it's a lot of money.
01:13:27
I say, well, how much?
01:13:28
Yeah, I don't know, $400, $500, $600.
01:13:30
I said, really?
01:13:32
And I said, well, how many miles a year do you drive?
01:13:34
And they say, I don't know, 12,000, 13,000 miles a year.
01:13:37
I said, what kind of car do you drive?
01:13:39
Oh, I got a good one.
01:13:40
I have a Toyota Camry.
01:13:42
I get maybe 25 miles per gallon.
01:13:44
I said, OK. You do the arithmetic with those figures in mind, and your gas tax payment is about $80 a year, not $400 or $500.
01:13:54
And I said, do you really?
01:13:56
And this is just for fun.
01:13:57
But to put it in perspective, I said, you realize you can double the gas tax
01:14:02
And it would still cost you less than a cup of coffee per day.
01:14:05
It would cost you 50 cents a day.
01:14:07
And they're just absolutely stunned.
01:14:10
They have no concept of how much money they pay or how little they pay, really.
01:14:14
And that it all goes for transportation.
01:14:17
It's not normally diverted.
01:14:19
And I'm not arguing that's what we ought to do.
01:14:21
But if you want to educate
01:14:23
I would strongly hope that we could talk in terms of how people are actually spending their money and compare it to things that they don't think twice about spending.
01:14:34
If they go to Starbucks, they'll spend three or four dollars every day.
01:14:37
They go to the local coffee shop, they'll spend at least a buck.
01:14:41
And we could fund a heck of a lot.
01:14:45
Not that I expect anybody to push this idea, but I really do think the educational process has to
01:14:53
Involve the person, the taxpayers point of view into how much you would actually spend to get enormous benefits.
01:15:01
We get 850 million more bucks a year.
01:15:04
And again, not that I think anybody's going to advocate it, but I think it's shameful the arguments that people make in the ignorance that abounds on the subject of how much the average driver actually spends each year and how they spend it.
01:15:27
Well, I mean, for 50 cents a day,
01:15:30
That would double it.
01:15:33
Right now, the average driver is probably paying 25, 30 cents a day.
01:15:38
This is what we're arguing about.
01:15:41
It boggles the mind.
01:15:41
It really does.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:42
A little arithmetic goes a long way.
01:15:44
Are there any other questions or comments on the legislature?
01:15:49
We do have a couple other new business items.
01:15:52
Are these copies?
01:16:01
I did want to talk briefly about our meeting schedule.
01:16:08
I have the sense that people are happy with one-day meetings for the most part, but I don't know that for a fact.
01:16:17
No?
01:16:17
Okay.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:18
For now, I think it's very appropriate this time of year.
01:16:23
Maybe once we get into April or May, it might be different, because we're also missing a lot, too.
01:16:28
We've got plenty of things we'd all like to know more about.
01:16:31
But for these three meetings, I would strongly stick to January, February, and March.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:38
And then we also have a conflict in April with the veto session, and at the rate we're going,
01:16:45
There may be a conflict out into April.
01:16:48
Let me suggest that we do March 16th as a one day workshop and action meeting here in Richmond.
01:16:57
That would be the Thursday one day meeting.
01:17:02
And let me also propose that we do April 20th as a one day meeting.
01:17:11
Yes, please.
01:17:13
And that would be the day after veto session in a normal year.
01:17:17
We may enlist your aide to come down a little early and talk with General Assembly members if that's helpful.
01:17:28
Is noon a good time for the...
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:32
I'm sorry, say again, March 16th and April
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:35
20th at noontime.
01:17:36
We'll get an email out with this, but just if anyone has any major concerns, the 20th would be a Thursday, the 16th is also a Thursday.
01:17:45
And then May the 17th, we're looking at that as potentially on May the 18th as a potential date for the ribbon cutting on the new span of the Wilson Bridge, but obviously there's
01:18:02
A lot of calendars to coordinate on that.
01:18:04
So our suggestion would be, let's reserve May 17th and 18th on your calendars.
01:18:11
And if indeed that event happens, we would probably have the CTB meeting up in Northern Virginia on the 17th and have the 18th for Wilson Bridge.
01:18:23
I imagine there'll be tours and things like that for those of you, it's a fabulous tour if you haven't been on it to see what a great job.
01:18:30
And you want to talk about great engineering and talented people who have spent now ten years on that project.
01:18:39
And then June 14th and 15th, that's likely under a normal set of circumstances would be the adoption of the six-year program.
01:18:52
I know we're going to need every inch of extra time given the General Assembly, so that would be here in Richmond, and let's reserve that as a two-day meeting with a workshop and an action item.
01:19:08
In July, I would like to propose that we go visit the Bristol District.
01:19:16
We visit the Bristol District, and that would be July 19th.
01:19:20
and 20th and perhaps even the Salem District as well.
01:19:27
No meeting in August.
01:19:31
And then we could, oh, and we don't have the, on here, we do wanna try and do something with the Research Council on there.
01:19:45
Let's try for September,
01:19:49
Let's think about this.
01:19:52
Let us get back to you on the fall schedule, but we would be looking at September 20th and 21st as a two-day meeting, possibly in Hampton Roads, October 18th and 19th.
01:20:03
Let's reserve those two days, and that may be an opportunity to go to Charlottesville and get a presentation and spend some time at the Transportation Research Council.
01:20:14
and then November the 15th and 16th would be a traditional meeting and typically we don't have December meetings but I would recommend that we do get a date on people's calendars just a one-day meeting in December in Richmond and it's easier to cancel than to add at that time of year.
01:20:38
Let's just say the 14th, December the 14th.
01:20:41
And we'll get this all out to you via email October was 18th and 19th
01:20:52
Now that may be in Charlottesville, or it may be here in Richmond.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:20:57
But it's not at the same time as a transportation conference, or is it?
01:21:03
I don't remember what the date is.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:04
Oh, that's a good point.
01:21:06
I have VDOT dates, I can come down.
01:21:08
We'll have to do some research on that.
01:21:10
Let's just reserve both dates in October location to be announced.
01:21:19
Any other questions?
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:23
I have some good news.
01:21:27
I've been traveling around the United States on the highway system, and coming back into Virginia this week, last week, on I-85 northbound, just over the line with North Carolina, it's I-85, right?
01:21:43
We stopped at a rest station.
01:21:46
And I tell you folks, I'm about to move in.
01:21:49
It was wonderful.
01:21:51
It was the cleanest place I've ever been in on the road.
01:21:55
It was well maintained.
01:21:56
There were not very many people there.
01:21:58
And so if you find someone has taken up residence, it's probably me.
01:22:03
No, congratulations.
01:22:05
It was an excellent facility.
01:22:06
And I just wanted to be sure that we brought good news about those things when we hear so much difficulty about
01:22:13
on the complications.
01:22:14
It was spectacular.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:17
I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman.
01:22:19
I would invite Ms. Hanley to visit our even newer and grander one on eastbound 64 in the Richmond District.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:26
You can get lost in there, Mr. McCarthy.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:28
I am not about to start taking a tour of the welcome centers and the welcome centers and all that.
01:22:34
Nonetheless, this one was in tip-top shape.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:22:38
Excellent.
01:22:40
At this point under new business, I did want to, and I know I advised you all by email, we all know Karen has accepted a position as Deputy Secretary of Transportation in the state of Pennsylvania, and it looks like the May meeting up in Northern Virginia may be one where we can have the kind of dinner and appropriate kinds of
01:23:02
Thank yous and appreciations but this will be Karen's last official business meeting with us and I just want to ask Karen if she wanted to make a few remarks.
Karen J. Rae
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:12
Well just thank you because it's been, I talked to somebody today and I said it's about what we do but it's about the people we do it with that's really made this three and a half years amazing.
01:23:24
I mean when I look back and think of all the challenges we had and all the times I had to lean on many of you that are here and those that have
01:23:31
to kind of guide me and give me advice and more importantly, help our whole agency look at the programs that we're all about supporting.
01:23:41
It's just been an amazing run.
01:23:44
So I think we've just raised the platform.
01:23:46
I think when I was actually brought in, I was asked to do that.
01:23:50
Some people would say why, but I think we've made such major progress, but it's about doing the right thing, but it's about the people that make that happen.
01:23:58
and it doesn't matter whether it's in Northern Virginia or down in Bristol or in Hampton Roads or even in Farmville, getting stuck in a furniture shop.
01:24:08
It's about the people that are going to make transportation differences in this Commonwealth.
01:24:12
And this board exemplifies the very, very best of people that I've gotten to work with.
01:24:17
So I thank you.
01:24:19
And I also warn you, I very rarely leave people that have been in my life for too long.
01:24:24
Ask Jack Quinn, who now serves on the Rail Advisory Board 20 years after he was my Congressman.
01:24:29
So I hope to keep in very close touch with many of you over the next several years.
01:24:34
And thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:24:36
Thank you.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:24:37
Mr. Chairman, I would be remiss if we let, even though we have time to say things over dinner and libation, I suppose, but at a formal meeting it would not, I believe, be out of line for us in Northern Virginia to express our thanks to Karen too.
01:24:55
You know, sometimes it's hard to realize that the Department of Rail and Public Transportation is small and yet it gets to come and meet with
01:25:05
The Northern Virginia Transportation Commission and every other commission known to person up there on a regular basis and Karen has done that but raising the visibility of rail and public transportation has been important to us that the state recognize that they're not the same and they're both important and that has been something Karen that you've done
01:25:28
Very well for all of us and we thank you very much for the Advocacy for the programs and for the leadership that you have shown in moving Rail and public transportation forward and of course Getting rail a little closer.
01:25:45
We're pushing that train to Dallas and on into Latin.
SPEAKER_09
01:25:50
I just like to say as a member of the rail board I've had a little more opportunity to work with Karen than some of you and I'm gonna really miss her
01:25:57
Karen, on behalf of the Governor, thank you and the meeting is adjourned.