Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Revenue Sharing Committee Meeting 4/11/2023
Auto-scroll
Revenue Sharing Committee Meeting
4/11/2023
SPEAKER_03
00:02:08
do the minutes after that.
00:02:10
Anybody from the public in, it's 14 after, so it should be plenty of time.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:02:16
Devante or John, do we see anybody in the public room that would like to join?
Greg Yates
00:02:25
Okay, and with no public there, I will ask for a motion to approve the minutes of the last meeting.
00:02:33
So moved.
H. Randolph Laird
00:02:34
Second.
Greg Yates
00:02:36
All right, minutes are approved.
00:02:39
Great.
00:02:41
Right in yet or not?
00:02:42
So he should be in for the review I would think.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:02:49
Mr. Yates, anything else from you before we jump in?
Greg Yates
00:02:55
No, I just wonder if we should wait to give Fred a couple more minutes because he wasn't at the meeting before you start the review actually.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:03:04
Do we need to let them know who's online?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:03:06
Sure.
00:03:07
I tell you what, as soon as Mr. Stadt gets on there, I'll let you know who's on our end, Mr. Yates.
00:03:15
We have a few people here in Angel's office, and I've got a few staff online, too.
00:03:22
I see.
00:03:23
Yeah, I can see all the names.
00:03:24
Yeah, I'd like to introduce a few of those folks.
Greg Yates
00:03:27
Well, you want to go ahead and introduce those now?
00:03:29
I don't think... Sure.
00:03:30
I'll introduce myself.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:03:35
I wasn't here at the last meeting.
00:03:36
I had other commitments that I couldn't avoid.
00:03:43
So I'm Ross.
00:03:44
I'm the local assistance division director, and I'll walk us through this PowerPoint this morning.
00:03:50
and we'll talk about the proposals and some of the comments and everything.
00:03:55
In this room I have Angel Deem.
00:03:58
She's our Chief of Policy.
00:04:00
I think everyone knows Angel and Kim Pryor.
00:04:03
I think everyone knows Kim.
00:04:05
You get to see her every month at the CTB.
00:04:08
She's in charge of all the money.
00:04:11
Kim is here with us.
00:04:14
And also from my staff is Terry Short.
00:04:20
And he is our Assistant Division Administrator for Program Management and TA and Revedy Sharing all fall underneath his part of the division.
00:04:30
And I also have Brittany Voll.
00:04:31
She is our Transportation Alternatives Program Manager with us.
00:04:36
and Brittany, I think you also have Michelle Piccolomini with you, is that correct?
SPEAKER_00
00:04:42
Yes.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:04:43
And Michelle is our revenue sharing program manager.
00:04:46
So any details, nitty gritty type questions, they are certainly the people to answer those questions.
00:04:55
So that's what we have here.
Greg Yates
00:04:56
I don't see Brittany.
00:04:58
Put your video ready so I can recognize you, please.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:05:02
You have a video, a camera on your computer, Brittany?
SPEAKER_00
00:05:05
Also in the room here we have Yolanda and Jonathan.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:05:14
Okay, so we also have Yolanda Newton.
00:05:17
She is our state programs manager, so all the state funded programs fall underneath Yolanda and Jonathan List.
00:05:26
Jonathan List is in charge of our access programs and has taken on a few new roles for a while and they're going to help us out.
Greg Yates
00:05:36
Who is John Steele?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:05:38
John Steele is our IT guru and he's the one trying to get us all here.
00:05:45
And then we have Devante Smith, he works with John and they're our communications staff that are keeping us connected.
00:05:54
I see Mr. Stant has joined us.
Greg Yates
00:05:57
Okay, and should we identify the CTB members on here?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:06:03
Sure.
00:06:04
I want to just go through one by one.
Greg Yates
00:06:06
I'm on.
00:06:09
Greg Yates, chair of this committee, and happy to finally get on.
00:06:12
All right.
00:06:12
Just go right down the line.
00:06:14
Who's next?
H. Randolph Laird
00:06:16
I'll take it.
SPEAKER_07
00:06:16
Randy Laird, Mary Hines, Ty Lawson,
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:06:29
Fred, can you make your mic work?
00:06:32
Well, can he make his mic work?
00:06:33
That's important.
00:06:37
Can you talk, Fred?
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:06:40
He's currently muted.
SPEAKER_07
00:06:41
I see he's muted.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:06:44
Can you guys unmute him?
SPEAKER_07
00:06:45
There you go.
00:06:47
All right, can you hear me now?
00:06:49
Yes.
Greg Yates
00:06:51
Glad you could make it, Fred.
SPEAKER_07
00:06:54
I've been trying since nine o'clock.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:07:01
So you're rippering to go.
Greg Yates
00:07:03
All right.
00:07:04
Okay, Ross, we'll let you go.
00:07:06
You or Angel, whoever wants to go next and do the brief review would be great.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:07:14
All right, so I'll get us started here.
00:07:17
And I think we're still waiting on Ms.
00:07:18
Sellers to join us.
00:07:20
I'm trying to turn off this computer, this phone there.
00:07:24
And so what I'd like to start off with is just a review of our
00:07:31
of what we're gonna do today.
00:07:32
So we talked about, we look for public comment, we don't have it.
00:07:35
But what I'd like to do is start off with just a review of the purpose of what we're doing here and just reestablish the purpose.
00:07:43
And then we've already approved the minutes, but we'll go through what we talked about last meeting.
00:07:51
And then we got some questions that were asked of the revenue sharing as we went through revenue sharing, and then we'll move on to transportation alternatives policy initiatives.
00:08:00
So today I want to start off with a review of the purpose of our proposals.
00:08:10
And so I wasn't here, but I think I can wrap it up with basically
00:08:17
three bullets.
00:08:18
And those three bullets are first, we wanna make sure that we have equity in the allocation distribution that we provide to all our localities.
00:08:28
When we revised the revenue sharing policy back in 2018, we had a subcommittee and the subcommittee started off with a statement of purpose, priorities, and recommendations, which guided their policy development.
00:08:41
And in that statement, they stated that the, that's probably gonna sell it right there,
00:08:47
that all our policies should be developed with the understanding that allocations are provided to localities for specific projects and are not allocations to localities for their general use on other transportation projects.
00:09:01
So we're gonna continue with that in mind.
00:09:06
So we wanna make sure that all localities, big and small, have the same access to funds that are no longer needed for the projects that they were originally allocated to.
00:09:16
Today small projects that only have one or two projects in their coffers have to cover any deficits and they don't have opportunity to access surplus funds like a locality with multiple revenue sharing projects have.
00:09:31
We also want to make sure that the redistribution process is fair and puts our excess funds to use as quickly as possible.
00:09:39
Secondly, we want to make sure our processes create efficiencies in the management of our program.
00:09:46
Today, just FYI, we have no more staff to work on our revenue sharing and TAP programs than we did really 17 years ago.
00:09:52
And the revenue sharing program has moved from a $15 million program to a $100 million a year program.
00:09:59
And way back then, it didn't even include cities and towns.
00:10:02
And of course, we all know the TAP program has increased by about 40% with IJA.
00:10:07
And then finally,
00:10:09
Our VDOT funding programs are complicated, and the more we can sync our policies across our funding programs, the easier it will be for our stakeholders to navigate those programs.
00:10:20
So while we have to recognize differences in the purposes of the programs and the size of the programs, we are striving to make our policies as harmonious as possible, and that will make it easier for our stakeholders.
00:10:33
So I want to start off with that just to sort of restate what we're doing here.
00:10:39
and I've lost my feed.
00:10:42
Let me try the CN.
00:10:45
For some reason it just dropped off.
00:10:48
There it goes, it's back up there again.
00:10:52
All right, for some reason I lost the feed there for a second.
00:10:56
So I'm back on there.
00:10:58
And so let's review the last meeting.
00:11:03
Everyone hopefully has had a chance to review the minutes and take a look at those.
00:11:08
We did hold it after a CTB monthly meeting, so we didn't have a lot of time to review the entire packet of information that we sent out.
00:11:16
But everyone was, we were able to get through all the initiatives for revenue sharing.
00:11:20
The discussion focused on the desire to modify the process by which we reallocate
00:11:27
Surplus Funds, and moving it to a more statewide prioritization process rather than leaving the funding within the individual locality.
00:11:34
It's not to say that the individual localities don't get the funding they need, it just needs to go through a statewide prioritization process.
00:11:41
As I noticed in the previous slide, the intent is to make sure that everyone gets the funding they need, but do it in a more systematic, equitable, and efficient manner.
00:11:50
I understand that we had some real good conversation on the revenue sharing policy initiatives, and we had some homework to do and answer some questions, so we'll get to that in the next slide.
00:12:01
So, don't have any questions on the minutes or what we went over last week.
00:12:06
I'll move on to the answers to some of your questions.
00:12:10
and feel free just to interrupt me any time as I move through this.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:12:15
I muted myself.
00:12:16
I do have one question.
00:12:17
Yes, ma'am.
00:12:17
Sorry.
00:12:18
So we did not talk, I don't think, about changing the stack of funding priorities for initially getting revenue sharing.
00:12:35
This prioritization piece that I thought we talked about was if you're short of money, how you would get more money under the proposal that staff put to us.
00:12:49
And we asked that there be more detail in that, but I just want to double check that my understanding was correct.
00:12:56
We're not talking about changing how you get a revenue sharing project in the beginning.
00:13:02
That's right.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:13:03
No, we're not.
00:13:04
That is established in code.
00:13:07
Any change to that process would have to go through the legislative process.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:13:12
That's good.
00:13:13
I just wanted to make sure we were clear that the prioritization we're talking about is to fill a gap and whether that money comes back to the state or
00:13:23
has some utility in a district for some period of time.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:13:27
Okay.
00:13:29
And I guess really this gets to just making sure that everyone has the same access to the funds.
00:13:34
So, we're talking about surplus funds.
00:13:38
We're not really talking about the original funds.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:13:40
Okay, good.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:13:41
Yeah, the original funds go through that four-tier prioritization process.
00:13:45
And I think we went through that last week, but I hit on real quick.
00:13:48
Party one for receiving TAP applications during the application cycle are those projects that already have revenue sharing money.
00:13:58
Two are those that advance a project in the CIP or meet a VTrans need.
00:14:03
Party three are those projects that will meet a maintenance deficiency need.
00:14:10
and priority four or any other projects that would otherwise be eligible for the transportation money from the state.
00:14:19
So those are the four priorities and it's directed to us that we have to provide funding in that order.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:14:25
Russ, the way it works now, if there's an attempt to reallocate, it's being reallocated to other approved or trying to be reallocated to other approved projects, right?
00:14:38
Not just
00:14:39
given to the county, city or town for whatever purposes they may want to use.
00:14:46
They're asking, the way it's doing now is they've got a surplus in a project because they had a cost savings.
00:14:53
And they're saying, can we use the excess on another project that's already been approved by the state?
00:15:01
Because we're sensing that that one may need more funding or for whatever reason.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:15:06
Yes, today, so what will happen is if a locality has a number of projects and they have a surplus on one project, they will ask, they will generally within, we have some caveats, it has to be done within six months of them completing one project and it has to go to another project that's going to advertise within 12 months.
00:15:28
They will generally ask, hey, can I move the surplus from project A to project B?
00:15:35
And then those are all typically revenue sharing projects.
00:15:39
There is a process to moving revenue sharing money to a non-revenue sharing project, but that goes in front of the whole board and that does, it creates a new revenue sharing project without going through the application process.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:15:54
But what you're talking about is altering
00:15:57
And I'm familiar with this.
00:16:00
The way it works now is a locality and they ought to do this.
00:16:06
They're being incentivized to save money if they can.
00:16:09
And if they do, they come in under the cost.
00:16:13
So they've got some excess funds.
00:16:15
And so what they're asking is, can we move it to another approved revenue sharing project?
00:16:22
And you're recommending that we change that?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:16:26
So when we first made this recommendation, that was the intent.
00:16:29
Hey, let's provide incentives to save money.
00:16:34
I can be honest with you and say that's not what's happening.
00:16:38
What's happening is we're creating incentives to increase estimates or increase allocation requests.
00:16:44
So they end up with more money at the end of the day.
00:16:50
So what we're proposing is not to prevent anyone who needs more money from getting the money that they need.
00:16:56
We want that done because that gets the money spent as quickly as possible.
00:17:00
And that's what we want to do.
00:17:03
Our ultimate goal is to spend the money and get the projects done.
00:17:06
But what we have today is an inequitable system, whereas a small locality who doesn't have the ability to transfer money from multiple projects because they don't have multiple projects, have to cover their entire deficit.
00:17:21
So if their estimate goes up,
00:17:26
They have to cover the whole increase, whereas a larger locality that has a wherewithal to have multiple projects can move money around across their own locality to cover deficits that they may have due to inflation or whatever it may be.
00:17:43
So we're not proposing to not let that locality have that money, but what we want to do is go through a prioritization process.
00:17:52
So maybe that smaller locality needs the money now
00:17:56
and we can get that money spent now rather than waiting 12 months and giving that and transferring money from that large locality from one project to another and waiting 12 months for them to get to advertisement.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:18:08
Wouldn't it be helpful Mr. Lawson is to have Russ walk through these numbers so we had quite a bit of conversation around this last time and I think Ms. Hines and perhaps others asked that we bring back
00:18:21
You know, some additional data points to demonstrate what's happening now with those transfers from revenue sharing to revenue sharing projects and then revenue sharing to non-revenue sharing projects.
00:18:34
If we could walk through that and then we can continue the discussion.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:18:39
I'm sorry, I misheard.
00:18:41
I thought Russ said ask questions as we go.
00:18:44
No, I'm fine with listening to the slideshow.
00:18:49
and then raising the points.
00:18:51
And I was pleased that you got the comments from John Bishop circulated, but I'm happy to raise my questions at the end if that's your preference Angel.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:19:05
I wasn't meaning to curtail your questions.
00:19:08
I was just saying that going through what's on the screen right now may provide some additional insights to this conversation.
00:19:15
So it might help to walk through these numbers and then we can continue
00:19:19
along that line of discussion.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:19:23
But I want to assure you that there's
00:19:28
The intent is to use the money as quickly as possible to get as many projects done as possible.
00:19:35
We just want to make sure that it's done in a fair way for both the large localities and the small localities.
00:19:41
If someone needs the money, we want to make sure they get the money so they can get it advertised, but we want to make sure the money is used as quickly as possible.
00:19:50
Today, if we have this transfer, we have these transfers.
00:19:54
The money can sit for a year.
00:19:56
until the next advertisement cycle while another locality may need the money today.
00:20:01
And because they don't have multiple projects, they have to either eat the whole increase or not advertise the project.
00:20:09
So we wanna make sure everyone gets the money they need.
00:20:12
It's just done in a more equitable way so that in a more efficient way is what we're trying to do here.
SPEAKER_07
00:20:19
But who's gonna make that call?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:20:24
So we believe the policies that we've proposed will do that in just that manner.
00:20:31
So we have a set of priorities that we'll go to in a second, because I think one of the questions we had last time was, well, what are the priorities?
00:20:37
What would the priorities be?
00:20:39
So we've got a list of priorities here in a couple of slides.
SPEAKER_07
00:20:43
But who makes the ultimate decision, the CTB or VDOT staff, or who makes it?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:20:50
So I think with the policies in place, the policies will make the decision.
00:20:54
I don't have to make a decision because the policies will say, first tier are these projects, projects that are in deficit, second tier are these projects.
00:21:02
And I have that list here coming up in a couple of slides.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:21:08
Did you say that again, Russ?
00:21:10
You're saying the policy will make the decision and not the CTB?
00:21:14
So we would have so- It's a board policy.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:21:18
So we will have a board policy to say where the priority of the redistributed allocations go, which projects get them first.
00:21:28
And we've got a slide on this.
00:21:29
So for example, the project has been advertised, it gets a bid, and the bid is higher than the allocations.
00:21:37
That project, of course, is the highest priority to get redistributed allocations.
00:21:44
They get their funding.
00:21:46
and then, but we have some caveats as far as how much extra funds any one project should get and also at what levels the board approves it and what levels it can be disapproved administratively and that's in accordance with existing CTB policy.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:22:08
I gotta tell you, it is amazing to me and I've
00:22:13
done several of these revenue sharing projects over the years.
00:22:17
I gotta believe all of them when they go to bid exceed the estimate if for no other reason given the amount of time that it takes to work through the process.
00:22:29
You gotta be a heck of a guesser to come up with a number.
00:22:33
I'm looking at one right now that we got approved back in 15 and it's just now getting ready to be built, just now going out to bid.
00:22:43
There's no way you're gonna come up with the right number.
00:22:47
And if that's the issue here, if we're exceeding, could we maybe not look at some things to get them closer in time so that the estimates at least are consistent with costing today as opposed to in this case, eight years in the future?
00:23:08
I mean, that number is always gonna be off, isn't it?
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:23:11
Well, so can I offer something here to my colleagues?
00:23:17
This program used to operate in years one and two of the Six-Year Plan.
00:23:22
And we had a lot of trouble with people getting these projects launched and under construction in that time period.
00:23:30
During COVID, when we had the big economic downturn, revenue sharing moved out to years five and six.
00:23:37
And with a lot of angst on everybody's part about these projects being so far out because the biggest match can be $10 million.
00:23:47
That's the most state money we'll put on the project.
00:23:50
So it's a $20 million generally project.
00:23:55
The issue of them being so far out, we brought it back in years three and four and the hope is that now they're ready to go to construction in year three so that in fact we're not having this huge lag because I think everybody shares that concern tie.
00:24:16
I gotta believe that 2015 one is an outlier.
00:24:19
I mean, that's a data point that we could ask for is how much
00:24:24
stuff is hanging out that's really old because in fact the program's supposed to be implemented quickly.
00:24:31
And I think
00:24:33
That's another thing we need to kind of like keep our eye on.
00:24:37
Over the years I've been on the board, our goal is to get the money out the door and being put to use for the people of the Commonwealth.
00:24:45
And so we want these programs.
00:24:47
They're supposed to be nimble to move quickly.
00:24:51
So I just offer that as a, you know, maybe something else we want to look at is how many things are out there hanging out and what can we do to move them along?
00:25:02
But
00:25:03
I would just say the one outlier is not the reason to write a policy to address it.
H. Randolph Laird
00:25:14
No, but it seems to me we have set aside funds for these overruns that could be allowed, I thought we were allowing them to tap into those.
00:25:27
It also seems to me that we are disincentivizing
00:25:32
These localities not to save on projects if we take the money away if they've saved money.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:25:40
So I think that's the heart of the change that we're being asked to consider is whether revenue sharing dollars should move to revenue sharing projects that have a gap.
00:25:51
And I think we should let that, let's keep looking at the data.
00:25:56
I mean, some of the things we hoped for in 2018, we actually achieved.
00:26:01
The move from revenue sharing to non-revenue sharing was something we added at the end.
00:26:07
It doesn't look to me like we need to continue that so I think we should be talking about within the revenue sharing projects what's the right thing and we have to remember that the locality has to bring half of the money of any increased bid to the table.
00:26:24
This is a 50-50 program.
00:26:26
It doesn't change once they go to bid so they have to have some money
00:26:31
to bring to the table too on a higher bid.
00:26:34
So anyway, that's just my two cents folks for what it's worth.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:26:39
I think Kim would like to add.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:26:40
Yeah, I just want to add one quick point that part of the recommendation that we're proposing is to create a reserve to help cover overruns on revenue sharing projects.
00:26:52
So there's not currently a reserve that's available for these projects.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:26:58
So for those localities that are achieving cost savings in some manner, that's great.
00:27:05
But the point isn't, you know, any sort of penalty along those lines.
00:27:11
The point instead is to have, as Kim just said, you know, a pot of money that can be used for revenue sharing projects that find themselves in the opposite scenario.
00:27:22
Right.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:27:23
Rather than have them... Would you take away from what we said?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:27:29
So the intent is not to take any money away from any one project.
00:27:32
Remember, these allocations are made by project by project.
00:27:36
So the locality will apply for an allocation for a project.
00:27:40
And we give them their allocation for the project.
00:27:43
If they need a surplus under this process, if they need extra money, then yes, they'll get the extra money as long as there's allocations available on a statewide basis.
00:27:52
So everyone in the whole state has access to the funds, not just a large locality.
00:27:57
It may have four, five, six projects.
00:28:00
They're high in some, low on others.
00:28:02
They get to average it out versus a smaller locality that only has one project.
00:28:07
They come in, their estimate comes in high.
00:28:10
They have nowhere to turn.
00:28:12
They have nowhere to turn except for their own coffers and so the big projects and the localities that have the wherewithal are benefiting from having lots of projects and the small localities have no ability to access surplus funds on a statewide basis.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:28:28
Or that smaller locality project sits and waits until it can apply for more money, which then makes the cost go up even more.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:28:37
So the intent is to make sure everyone that needs the funding can get the funding in the most expeditious manner possible.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:28:44
Russ, did you all get participation from our customers, the stakeholders, like the transportation directors or planning departments of the different
00:29:00
County Cities and Towns so they could have input into this.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:29:05
For this round of policy initiatives, we have not had the opportunity to do that, which is part of what we're doing today.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:29:13
Well, yeah.
00:29:15
but nobody's on the line but us, right?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:29:19
Yeah, that's true.
00:29:20
And I'll be honest with you.
00:29:21
The last time we did this, we did send out surveys to localities and ask them a bunch of questions.
00:29:28
And once we got to the meetings, we had a little input from the large localities, but we didn't get- I got input from small localities.
Greg Yates
00:29:39
I did it on my own.
00:29:40
Okay.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:29:40
No, no, and I did too, Greg.
00:29:44
I just happened to participate in the meeting at the end of our CTB meeting and I called Frederick County, which by the way, I never thought of as a large locality, but they'll be complimented to know that they're thought of that way.
00:30:01
And they had no idea that this was going on.
00:30:04
And so I said, John Bishop, you need to look at this.
00:30:08
And he did.
00:30:08
And he wrote the memo and circulated it.
00:30:14
But I would think those folks definitely ought to be consulted before we make any changes in the policies here.
00:30:23
They do this every day.
00:30:26
And he actually made a comment too.
00:30:28
He said that there are a lot of folks within the Stanton District Office at VDOT that he works with on a regular basis on revenue sharing.
00:30:38
And he asked if they were involved in this process.
00:30:43
Apparently they're not, but I would think before we, I mean, this is good information and we ought to go through it, but I was really surprised when I read his email and his comments to it.
00:31:01
And he, I think politely, but strongly said, he's not in favor of these revisions.
00:31:09
maybe would suggest others if we could get folks like him involved.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:31:15
So Frederick County is one of our larger users of revenue sharing program.
00:31:21
They're pretty active in the program.
00:31:24
In fact, over the past eight years, I think we've had
00:31:28
Terry, correct me if I'm wrong, $20 million of deallocated funds from Frederick County.
00:31:34
So they use a lot of funds, but they also turned in a lot of funds too.
00:31:38
So they've been a part of this, you know, the whole process.
00:31:41
They're very well adept at it.
00:31:42
So they know how it works.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:31:46
So yeah, we could certainly- Yeah, I'll just chime in here and just say, you know, we work at the pleasure of the board.
00:31:55
So if you all want to
00:31:57
incorporate a round of either targeted feedback or general public feedback.
00:32:05
We will incorporate that.
00:32:07
We're certainly inviting the public to participate in these meetings and we'll continue to do that.
00:32:14
But if you all feel there's a gap there, because where we're headed is for this group to
00:32:23
solidify recommendations for policy changes, whatever they may be, and then that will be presented to the full board at such time we're ready to do that.
00:32:35
So we really look to you all to say what you need in any direction for Mr. Yates as the chair, the manner in which we fulfill what you all think you need in order to be comfortable making those policy recommendations to the full board.
Greg Yates
00:32:52
Well, let me say that we were on a fast track maybe to get this to the board in June, but I think we're okay if we push it back another month, which was one of the original options.
00:33:02
Is that correct, Angel?
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:33:03
Yeah, I mean, so for everybody's edification, we probably got started a little later than would have been ideal, but we are where we are.
00:33:12
Our interest isn't to
00:33:16
Kurtale, input or more deliberation amongst you all.
00:33:20
Our interest was to get these policy changes in place to inform the upcoming application round.
00:33:27
So, as the months go on, obviously that opportunity will move away from us because folks will need to adhere to those application deadlines.
00:33:38
And so any changes that we make that aren't in place until let's just say summer,
00:33:46
won't make an impact on the application side until the next round.
Greg Yates
00:33:51
If we did a 30-day delay to have localities who use this program give input, would that still be acceptable timing-wise and help when the new applications come in?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:34:03
Yeah, I think it's more impactful to the TAP program than revenue sharing program as far as the policy changes.
Greg Yates
00:34:11
Do we need to do them concurrently though?
00:34:13
Could we push the TAP program quicker?
00:34:15
We want input on the TAP program too.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:34:17
I think we get input on both, but I think maybe we might have more concurrence on the TAP program.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:34:23
Yeah, we can sort of see where we land today and we'll be in person this week and then we can sort of solidify whether we want to put them on separate tracks.
Greg Yates
00:34:34
Okay, why don't we go ahead and I mean certainly take other questions.
00:34:38
Why don't we go ahead and try to push through a little more data, but I could see us certainly delaying the revenue sharing program by 30 days for public input and we can make a decision on the TAP program at the end of today.
00:34:47
How about that?
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:34:49
Yep, sounds great.
00:34:50
Thank you very much and thanks for the time.
Greg Yates
00:34:52
Really appreciate that.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:34:53
Thanks, Greg.
00:34:54
That's a good move.
00:34:56
Yeah, great questions.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:34:59
So with this table, we were asked the last meeting to provide the number of revenue sharing transfers and to show how that information changed pre the 2018 policy and post the 2018 policy.
00:35:12
And these tables provide that information.
00:35:15
And what you can see is pretty readily is that the number of transfers, the actual number of transfers was cut by about two-thirds for the revenue sharing to revenue sharing projects.
00:35:28
But the value
00:35:30
The average value went up quite a bit.
00:35:33
So where the number of transfers were cut back, the value of the transfers actually kind of went up.
00:35:42
A little bit all over the board of the state, but the average went up a good deal.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:35:48
Does anybody have questions?
00:35:50
Maybe we'll pause there.
00:35:51
The revenue sharing, the revenue sharing, what we're showing there, contrasting 2018 to post-2018,
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:36:00
Do you have a guess on why the overall value increased?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:36:07
I can guess that folks are being more selective about what they were asking for.
00:36:12
Because there were more constraints put on how they could do it.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:36:22
Explain that, Russ.
00:36:23
What do you mean constraints?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:36:24
So prior to the policy change,
00:36:30
I think we had Michelle chime in if I get this wrong.
00:36:35
They had, I think, 12 months after a project was completed to transfer their funds, and they could transfer funds to projects that weren't going to add for 24 months.
00:36:48
I think that was the policy.
00:36:51
And we constrained that to six and 12 months.
00:36:55
Michelle, did I get that close?
00:36:58
Are you there?
SPEAKER_00
00:36:59
Yes.
00:37:01
Can you hear me?
00:37:02
Yes.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:37:04
Okay.
00:37:05
And then prior to 2018, localities could
00:37:11
A lot of localities are using revenue sharing to fund very large projects so we're getting localities that were funding 40, 50, 60 million dollar projects with revenue sharing because they could keep coming back every year because once you're revenue sharing a project you're a priority for more revenue sharing money so these large localities would keep coming back and get more money
00:37:31
for certain projects.
00:37:33
And we constrained that to $10 million.
00:37:36
We said, we're not going to give you any more than $10 million for any one project.
00:37:40
The program's just not big enough to have five or six or seven large localities eat up $10 million each year for large projects.
00:37:49
So how that fits in with the selectiveness,
00:37:55
I really don't know, but it just looks like they're just being more selective, because the number of transfers, a third, but that value, what is that, almost, man, almost double, easily double.
00:38:08
Not so much on the revenue sharing to non-revenue sharing project process.
00:38:13
The number of transfers dropped by about a third again.
00:38:16
The values stayed about the same.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:38:20
So when you say more selective, they're picking their
00:38:23
their best one or best ones, and shedding others.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:38:28
The most money maybe, I'm not really sure how that, where that was, I hear that's coming from, but you see some of the number of transfers dropped dramatically.
00:38:37
You look at Bristol, we went from 227 to 12 over that year, which is pretty dramatic, but the number went up.
00:38:47
You see how great, how much the average went up from 62 to 460,000.
00:38:53
I don't really have a good answer for why.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:38:58
Maybe we'll ask some of these localities to explain.
00:39:02
What are you all doing?
00:39:03
Why did you do this?
00:39:06
To get some intelligence on what's happening here.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:39:13
And what we don't have is, however, what we've never tracked is how many of these other localities that didn't have access to funds
00:39:20
You know, how many times have they had to pay for the the increase, you know, because they didn't have access to surplus funds.
00:39:28
So, you know, that's something that's in the background that we we just don't know.
00:39:33
We just don't know.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:39:35
You realize the bulk of them are they're all being backstopped by private development.
00:39:40
They're not really it's not for the most part, in my experience, coming out of the the city, county or town's money.
00:39:47
It's coming out of
00:39:48
the private sector that's backstopping them.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:39:51
Well that's true for some, Frederick County is one of the ones you're probably most familiar with.
00:39:57
They do use a lot of developer money.
00:39:59
which is why- It's not true for the small rural communities.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:40:02
Yeah, not for the- Nor is it true in Nova.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:40:06
Yeah.
00:40:06
Right.
00:40:07
So I think the experience in some of that northern, with Chester and Frederick, they do things a little bit differently, which is also, by the way, why we see so many deallocations coming from them because we see a lot of, quite often you see developers, it just fall through.
00:40:23
And then, so we end up deallocating a lot of money from those localities too.
00:40:28
What do you mean money's set and didn't get used?
00:40:32
So we bring it back and we deallocate it, bring it back to the application process.
00:40:36
So we can't preclude that, but it does slow down the spending of the money on occasion.
Greg Yates
00:40:47
Any more questions on this slide?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:40:49
So the point is the original intent of the policy changes was to get more money into the deallocation process, share it more equitably across the state, and then make it more efficient.
00:41:03
And we saw that it happened.
00:41:04
That absolutely happened with the policy initiatives.
00:41:09
They were great when it comes to that.
00:41:13
So not only do these changes represent additional allocations, but they also represent just workload on the staff here, both in terms of fiscal transactions and in terms of evaluating the request and tracking the use of the funding afterwards.
00:41:30
And the next slide provides a little information regarding that.
00:41:33
Go to the next slide.
00:41:37
Well, I'll ask you not to get into the weeds of all these examples.
00:41:42
But what I can show you here is that each time we have a request for a transfer, we have to review every request to ensure the justification we're providing meets policy.
00:41:56
And I'll be honest with you guys, I've seen these justifications get really creative over the past few years.
00:42:05
I think last week or last meeting Terry gave an example of an allocation that went up just magically by the same the same exact or the estimate went up the same exact number as a as an allocation that surplus allocation that our project had.
00:42:19
And we see a lot of that.
00:42:22
And some of these are just examples of those.
00:42:24
And I'm sure Michelle, as the program manager, she has to manage one of these, can attest to what I'm saying.
00:42:30
I hate to use the word manipulation, but we see a lot of the manipulation of project completion dates.
00:42:38
Is it really complete?
00:42:39
Is it not complete?
00:42:42
And then advertisement dates and estimates across the whole state.
00:42:45
And we have to evaluate each one of those
00:42:47
Each time we get this request.
00:42:51
So it does create a lot of work on our part and it creates even more issues tracking what happens afterwards.
00:43:01
So one of our poly initiatives, which we'll touch on in the next slide, is to provide those allocations when the locality needs the allocation.
00:43:08
That's what we were talking about before.
00:43:09
Rather than letting it sit for another year until the locality says they might need it.
00:43:18
And we'll get to that in a few minutes.
00:43:21
We feel that our proposals here will simply eliminate all this confusion and all the resources needed to ensure we're following policy.
00:43:29
If you need the additional funding, we plan to give you the additional funding.
00:43:35
when you need it and as simple as that.
00:43:38
So whether you're a large locality or small locality, we want you to get the funding you need to get the projects advertised and get them completed when you need it and use that money as quickly as possible.
00:43:53
So there's no need to waste energy with all these, you know, this game can trip sometimes we see.
00:44:06
So I'll move to the next slide.
00:44:08
So we were asked about a prioritization process, and here's how we proposed that we would actually prioritize the redistribution of the funding.
00:44:16
The next few slides provide an answer for both revenue sharing and TAP, with TAP being a little bit differently.
00:44:21
So first of all, our number one priority for allocation needs to be to any project that has a current bid that is higher than their available allocations, subject to the CTB approval limits, and we have those in the next slide.
00:44:38
What I don't have here, there probably ought to be a second one here or a 1B, is projects that are ready for advertisement, whose estimates are higher than the allocations available, that should really probably be 1B.
00:44:50
So all those two should be kind of wrapped in together.
00:44:53
So if you've got a project that is going to add or has been advertised and it needs money, we need to make sure that the money available goes to those projects so that they can get done.
00:45:04
simple as that so whether you're small locality or large locality you have your own money or not we need to make sure everyone has access to this one as equitably as possible which is the second yeah yeah the second the second one is is we say within 12 maybe say within 12 months here in 12 months i think it's not
00:45:27
12 months is like the next step, but if you need a project now, if you're going to add today and your estimate is too high and you can't go to add without knowing you have some money, we need to make sure you have that money to go to add.
00:45:41
If you have a project going to add in 12 months, we have time.
00:45:45
So that would be the third priority here is if you're going to add the next 12 months, let's make sure we get money to you in time for you to advertise that project.
00:45:55
Third, we mentioned this a few minutes ago, we need to make sure we have some balance for emergency situations or for reallocation for the next application cycle.
00:46:05
So we're proposing having some minimum amount in our balance entry to cover situations where there's an emergency, we need the money, it has to get done.
00:46:15
And because of the size of the programs, we're gonna recommend $5 million for revenue sharing and $2 million for transportation alternatives.
00:46:27
And then fourth, we need to make sure that we cover those localities that have projects under construction.
00:46:35
And for some unforeseen reason, go into deficit during construction.
00:46:39
So if something comes up, they need additional money during construction.
00:46:43
We need to make sure they get the funding they need to complete the project.
00:46:48
and of course per code revenue sharing project, localities with revenue sharing projects can always come back during the next application cycle and ask for more money regardless of the estimate of the project.
00:47:01
Any questions on those priorities?
00:47:02
I think I have Kim, Kim wants to add something here.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:47:05
Just want to clarify that the deallocated money that gets moved to these projects based on these priorities would not be to cover added scope.
00:47:15
only the original scope that was approved.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:47:19
Yes, we have a few caveats here for additional restrictions or limitations on the funding.
00:47:26
The redistribute allocations would not be available for additional scope unless that's absolutely necessary to complete the original purpose and need.
00:47:33
We don't want scope creep.
00:47:34
We don't want additional projects.
00:47:36
We don't want new projects created from old allocations, basically.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:47:41
How does that work?
00:47:42
I'm curious.
00:47:45
I must live in a world of outliers because we just completed a project where the scope was changed on a cost share project much to the frustration of my client because they were the backstop on a $20 million project.
00:48:05
And I believe thankfully the thing was a little under budget
00:48:11
So VDOT did cover it, but actually it was directed.
00:48:14
The scope was something that was directed by VDOT.
00:48:18
They added a turn lane on a road that we connected to and the county didn't want it and the developer didn't want it, but VDOT mandated it.
00:48:30
So the scope of the project changed.
00:48:33
I've forgotten, it was several hundred thousand dollars.
00:48:37
So are you saying that we're gonna have a policy that won't allow that or it will allow it in certain circumstances or what's the proposed policy or rule for that?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:48:51
So this would be consistent with SmartScale and HSIP and any of our other projects.
00:48:56
When you apply for a project, you're applying for a specific purpose and need and a scope of the project.
00:49:04
So we don't want folks coming back and asking for more money because they decided they want some betterment on the project.
00:49:12
They didn't plan on brick pavers.
00:49:15
Now they want brick pavers.
00:49:16
That's a minor amount.
00:49:17
But they didn't plan on undergrounding utilities, but now they want underground utilities.
00:49:23
That's not what you apply for.
00:49:24
That's not what the board gave the money for.
00:49:28
and so now I don't know your specific issue with that project you know sometimes scope can be modified to meet the original purpose and need and that will happen sometime or there may be some requirement that comes along down the line that you didn't know about
00:49:46
Wetlands or environmental or whatever it might be that causes you to technically change the design, but you're not changing the scope for the purpose and need perspective.
00:49:59
Kim wants to add something.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:50:00
I know this sounds like bureaucratic semantics, but we do make a distinction between a scope change and a design refinement.
00:50:07
And a design refinement is something that's required by
00:50:11
you know, design standards or federal regulations or state, you know, it's not added scope.
00:50:16
It's not changing what the purpose and need of the project originally was.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:50:21
Well, again, my circumstances, it was working on a road that was off property and it added a turn lane.
00:50:29
And I mean, these things happen, I suppose.
00:50:34
And I'd be leery if what you're describing is you want flexibility to be able to
00:50:41
address these that you wouldn't want to have a policy that unintentionally cuts these things off.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:50:51
Yeah, I don't think those, again, I don't know the specific situation, but we can look into it.
Thomas Moore Lawson
00:50:59
Well, maybe that's when we have the input from the localities, they can
00:51:04
give you these real-life examples and then we can decide whether we want to have a policy to incentivize that or in this case I would have preferred on behalf of the client that it didn't happen because it cost us more money.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:51:19
And what we want to avoid is folks asking for, and this is probably more applicable for the TAP program, asking for one project, you providing funding for one project, and then that project drastically changes to something else.
00:51:36
That's not what you approved.
00:51:37
That's not what you gave money for.
00:51:39
And we see quite a bit of that, probably more in the TAP program than we do in the revenue sharing program.
00:51:43
So that's what we're trying to avoid.
00:51:47
And so, yeah, we can follow up a little bit more on that and have some more feedback on that.
00:51:53
So continuing with this, the $10 million per project for revenue sharing is the current policy in place.
00:52:02
We are proposing a $2.5 million maximum allocation for TA, and I'll get to that in a few minutes.
00:52:10
and the redistribution allocation increases would be per current board policy.
00:52:15
So this table down here shows the current board policy, anything above these amounts.
00:52:21
get approved by the board.
00:52:23
Anything below these thresholds, you are provided for information purposes, what has happened throughout the month.
00:52:32
Is that correct?
00:52:35
So anything above, so it's a $5 million project, anything above 20% in the state allocations to the project, you would approve it or disapprove it?
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
00:52:46
It's part of the monthly transfer report that I bring to you all each month.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:52:52
So it would be consistent with current SYIP board policy.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:52:57
So Russ, I have a quick question.
00:52:59
So the maximum amount we can give to any revenue sharing project is $10 million.
00:53:06
So if the total cost is between 10 and 20, and they've already asked us for 10, we actually don't cover
00:53:19
Anything, right?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:53:20
We don't cover anything more than 10 million dollars in state allocations for projects.
00:53:26
So 20 million dollars, 10-10 match, they can have a 40 million dollar project, but we still only give up the 10 million dollars of state allocations for revenue sharing.
Mary Hughes Hynes
00:53:36
Yeah, so if we're already at 10, there is no
00:53:41
State Contribution, there is no additional funding.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:53:45
There is no additional.
00:53:46
That's what the second bullet tries to get to.
00:53:49
We can't exceed that threshold.
00:53:57
Any more questions on this?
H. Randolph Laird
00:54:00
I've got one around this retention money that everybody can tap into.
00:54:06
We had indicated that we wanted to align ourselves more with SmartScale on as many features of SmartScale as we could, and we're allocating $5 million as a holdback for cost overruns in SmartScale.
00:54:23
I think it was a 12% number?
SPEAKER_03
00:54:25
Yes, sir, that's right.
H. Randolph Laird
00:54:27
So what's the thinking behind a 5% number for this?
00:54:33
I understand when inflation cools off that the need for this number is not necessary or a higher number is not necessary, but I don't think we're there yet and I think that we're going to have cost overruns
00:54:49
that we would like to I feel like should take care of and we should allocate the money to that to that pool.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:54:58
So you're Mr. Lehrer just so we're clear you're questioning one how did we come up with five and alongside that is are we sure five million is really adequate right now?
SPEAKER_03
00:55:10
Correct.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:55:15
Give me $5 million on the revenue sharing minimum.
00:55:19
So I guess to get to your point about folks needing more money, that would just be the bottom.
00:55:24
That would be what we would shoot for as having a balance.
00:55:28
But as we're moving allocations throughout the year, so if one locality has a surplus, that would immediately go to wherever we need it to go if it's needed at that point in time.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:55:41
So the $5 million is a minimum.
00:55:44
I mean it could be.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:55:45
It's what we would strive to keep in the balance entry.
00:55:47
Now it doesn't mean that we would go below that or you know but it's just to your point Mr. Laird is we would
00:55:56
As the allocations happen throughout the year, those funds would be moving to other projects that need them immediately.
00:56:04
So in essence, we would have more than $5 million at any one time, ideally.
H. Randolph Laird
00:56:11
And that's assuming that everybody agrees we want to do this deallocation process.
00:56:17
And that might not be the best assumption thus far.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:56:20
Right.
00:56:21
And today we have a deallocation process, but as I think Terry went through last week or last meeting, that it's a once a year deallocation process.
00:56:31
Money will sit for nine months or longer, probably longer.
00:56:36
Michelle can clarify that with me.
00:56:39
And before we get to
00:56:55
Project A and put it on Project C that needs it today.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
00:56:59
Right, but I think, Mr. Laird, you're asking even if we set aside the notion that the deallocation process could be used to, you know, maintain if not increase the value of the balance entry account that are, so if we set that aside, are we confident and comfortable that five million is the right number to put into that?
00:57:23
account to handle cost overruns.
00:57:31
I don't know if Russ or any of his team can speak to the adequacy of 5 million based on your knowledge of monies that are been identified for transfers for projects that need additional funding.
00:57:47
If not, we can serve that as a follow-up item.
SPEAKER_05
00:57:54
Yeah, I would just offer just as a potential consideration that our current baseline is zero.
00:58:04
I mean, we don't have an initial start.
00:58:09
So at $5 million, it's an excellent question.
00:58:14
But we also have in circumstances where we'll have a canceled project that literally is $2.6 million.
00:58:22
that could roll in and then become immediately available on top of that.
00:58:27
So I think the root of it, and Michelle can correct me if I'm wrong, we get it wrong, is we want it to be respectful of the allocation process and for the board's consideration and the application process so that we stepped into something.
00:58:46
If we identified that we needed to have additional resources withheld and set aside,
00:58:51
That could be something that we could come back to the board for consideration, but as a starting point, I think that's where the root of 5 million came from.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:59:02
Yeah, if we go back to the average request of $255,000 for revenue sharing and revenue sharing in 305 years, if we use that as a basis, we might want to, you know,
00:59:21
I think you do the math there.
00:59:22
I think that bumps you up to like a $15 million bonus.
00:59:26
If you try to divide 308 by five and then multiply that by 255, just say that's what we need on the average.
00:59:34
That's like $15 million.
00:59:36
But to Terry's point, today we have nothing.
00:59:38
to give anybody anything except those localities that have surplus funding in their coffers themselves and that's again going back to that we're trying to make sure that everyone has access to the extra money not just those that have lots of projects so we can look at the five million dollars to see if it's adequate I certainly think it's a good start
01:00:03
But if we need to bump that up, it's a $100 million project program.
01:00:06
That's 15% of the program in a year.
01:00:13
Certainly reasonable to look at.
SPEAKER_03
01:00:18
Any more discussion on that?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:00:23
So with that I'd like to just recap some of the things we talked about and maybe just give a little more feedback.
01:00:30
We've got some great feedback so far and any more discussion on revenue sharing.
01:00:34
So we'll go through the policy recommendations that we've made and remember these policy recommendations kind of correspond to the chart that we sent out and I re-sent that out last night for everyone.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:00:44
And can we pause at annual one to get a pulse check?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:00:47
Yeah, we will.
01:00:47
We will.
01:00:48
So a policy one, this is just administrative.
01:00:53
Our current policy says it's an annual process.
01:00:55
We're not doing an annual process now.
01:00:57
It's biennial.
01:00:57
So policy one would just be to formalize the biennial process that we've already implemented.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:01:05
And would that be shared with the board on a twice a year basis also?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:01:10
So this would be the current process just formalizing the current process of every other year of an application process rather than an annual process.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:01:22
So we take applications every other year.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:01:26
Which is what we're doing today.
01:01:27
As opposed to annually.
01:01:29
As opposed to annually.
01:01:31
So we're going to stretch it out.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:01:33
Well, that's what we're doing today.
01:01:35
So we're doing a biennial process today.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:01:38
Right.
01:01:38
So we've been, in essence, functioning in a manner different than what the current policy states.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:01:45
And the current policy says do it annually?
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:01:48
Yes, sir.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:01:49
OK.
01:01:50
Feedback.
01:01:51
I recommend we do it annually.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:01:53
To clarify, we have somewhat conflicting board policies.
01:01:58
The revenue sharing policies outlined an annual process
01:02:02
Your Six-Year Program Development Process, which guides development of the entire program, specifies a biennial process.
01:02:11
So that was adopted after the last revenue sharing policy.
01:02:17
So we're just trying to align those now.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:02:20
For what it's worth, and I'm new, but I'd recommend we do annually.
01:02:25
If we're gonna try to be nimble, stretching things out over two years is,
01:02:32
kind of working against that concept.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:02:35
Right, so the thinking behind the biennial process is it gives you more money to allocate so you can make more project selections.
01:02:44
The money goes farther and you can do more with it as opposed to an annual process.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:02:51
No, no, I understand, but I think the devil is in the budgeting of these things.
01:02:58
And we're, again, my experience
01:03:01
is these things just drag on and the numbers are, they're no good, because when the project actually goes to bid, it's way outdated.
01:03:13
So if we could look at these things annually, I would think that would be better than every two years.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:03:21
Right, I believe that a significant reason that the projects take a long time to get to advertisement
01:03:29
is one, in some instances, it takes us a long time to get the project under agreement, which I think Russ is gonna talk about, but also because oftentimes the project isn't fully funded when it's selected, and so it's waiting for subsequent rounds of revenue sharing to request additional money, or it's waiting to apply for smart scale money, and that can introduce two to four years of delay in the project.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:03:57
And I will add that
01:03:58
A big delay with our localities and we're doing our best to get localities to move more quickly because you know and understand that the longer they wait the more expensive their project becomes.
01:04:12
One significant delay we have with the localities with the larger projects, not with the small ones, is their procurement process.
01:04:21
It takes them, you probably reach out to any of them, nine months, easy, easy for them to hire a consultant.
01:04:29
Sometimes that goes into a year.
01:04:31
So when they get the money, and this is part of the problem, when you get the money year one and it takes you nine months or a year to
01:04:37
Pecura Consultant before you even start design, then that money is set there for a year.
01:04:44
If I give you money in years three and four, or even two and three, or whatever it might be, then you know you have money.
01:04:50
You can begin that procurement process.
01:04:52
We haven't actually, you know, deployed the cash.
01:04:59
until they've got their consultant in place.
01:05:02
And it doesn't mean you're not going to get reimbursed expenses that you might incur during that process.
01:05:10
Absolutely.
01:05:11
Once you're in an under agreement, you're good to get reimbursed.
01:05:14
But we don't have that cash outlay until years three and four, which is I think was part of the
01:05:21
purpose for years three and four, and even more, it was five and six earlier, but we brought that back in to three and four.
01:05:27
So none of this is, when the allocations are available, really doesn't slow the projects down.
01:05:34
If someone wants to start earlier, Kim's group is really, we talked about the word nimble, we're nimble about moving allocations around so that folks can get their allocations early if they need it early.
01:05:46
But we don't see projects moving that quickly on local properties.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:05:55
We just don't.
01:05:56
This goes back to the beginning for me, and it's why we ought to involve our, I'll call them our customers, our stakeholders, the localities.
01:06:05
And if they're dragging this thing because it's taken them nine months to get the design underway or even to hire the engineer to do the design, that's something you need
01:06:15
You need to let them know.
01:06:16
And again, I'm involved in projects where we go ahead and pre-engineer it just to jump up that timeline.
01:06:26
So there are ways around that.
01:06:29
But in my mind, nothing gets better by dragging this out.
01:06:33
The numbers just keep going up.
01:06:36
And then we end up in these other problems that you're experiencing.
01:06:40
I'd recommend and I'll vote for keeping it as an annual process.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:06:49
It hasn't been an annual process for probably 2018.
01:06:54
Just one other point that I'll add on that is that it becomes burdensome from the localities perspective when we're taking in applications for all of our funding programs at the same time.
01:07:09
And so right now, SmartScale applications are on a biennial cycle that is the alternate of revenue sharing.
01:07:17
And so localities aren't scrambling to try to get revenue sharing and smart scale applications done at the same time.
01:07:25
In fact, a lot of times we'll see an application for revenue sharing in one cycle followed by a smart scale application in the next cycle.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:07:34
And I would just point out in 2018, when I did an extensive process up here, Ty, with my localities,
01:07:43
They were very comfortable with the alternating years because of the level of work required for all of these applications going into the portal.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:07:53
I guess the thought I would have is it sounds like it would be good to hear from these folks that are actually applying and what would they like to see?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:08:05
We can do that.
01:08:06
I think we'll find it.
01:08:08
This is less taxing on their staff and our staff because we're alternating TAP revenue sharing one year and that's about this not quite the same size as SMART SCALE but it's probably 400 applications statewide between the two and then you go to SMART SCALE so
01:08:28
It benefits both our customers and us that we can spread out our resources across those two years, but we can certainly have more conversation on that.
01:08:40
And so also I think you're talking a lot of project development type issues.
01:08:45
I'd love to have an off conversation with you to bring you up to speed and let you know what we've been doing in the past to help localities
01:08:53
Move things along a little quickly, more quickly, and to encourage them to move projects a little more quickly.
01:09:03
Because we know the quicker we can get these projects out the door, advertised, the better it is for everyone.
01:09:09
Not only localities, but their citizens.
01:09:11
And that's really what we're shooting for.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:09:14
Feel free to call me, Russ.
01:09:16
I'd love to talk with you and see what I can do to help that along.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:09:22
Yeah, absolutely, because we've been working on that for a long time.
01:09:27
So, just a quick point.
Greg Yates
01:09:29
Are we mandated to hard stop at noon because the advertisement or because we've got a lot more information?
01:09:34
What's the status on that?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:09:36
I think we'll have to hard stop at noon.
01:09:38
We have another CTB meeting at the prep meeting.
01:09:42
Okay.
01:09:44
But we'll, I mean,
01:09:46
That's what we're here for.
01:09:47
We're here for all the conversation.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:09:48
We can't get through what we hoped to get through today.
01:09:50
That's, you know, certainly that's fine.
01:09:53
We can pick up next week when we're together in person, you know, from where we leave off today.
Greg Yates
01:09:59
Okay, well, let's stop at about 10 minutes up so we can come up with a strategy for, you know, putting off one thing at 30 days and that kind of stuff.
01:10:07
Look, I'm not leaving.
01:10:07
I've just got to grab a power cord, so don't stop.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:10:09
I'll be right back.
01:10:11
Okay, that's great.
01:10:12
So, policy two was the discussion of... Oh, I'm sorry.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:10:17
Just so we're clear, rather than policy one sort of being a thumbs up from everyone, what I'm hearing is that we want to solicit feedback from localities prior to
01:10:30
to tagging policy one as one that's good to move forward.
01:10:34
Does that make sure we have that?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:10:38
I would certainly say I'm supportive of policy one at this point, but I went through this process five years ago and I don't think it's changed for my stakeholders.
01:10:47
So people wanna do a survey, I'm supportive of a survey.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:10:53
Okay.
01:10:53
Okay.
01:10:53
Okay.
01:10:53
All right.
01:10:54
Just wanna make sure we're all clear.
01:10:55
Sure.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:10:56
All right.
01:10:56
Thank you, Amy.
01:10:57
Two, we talked about creating a balance entry, a minimal balance entry.
01:11:03
We mentioned $5 million, but it sounds like we want to have a little more conversation.
01:11:07
Is $5 million enough to cover what we need statewide?
01:11:14
So we can do that.
01:11:17
We can do some more math and see what we can come up with.
01:11:23
We don't want to take too much away from what's available by sticking it in a balance entry and not being used, but we want to have enough available so when it's needed.
01:11:31
So it's a balancing act.
01:11:34
It's all a balancing act, right?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:11:38
So, Russ, I have a data question for you guys here because you've said several times that small localities are kind of stuck if they have a cost increase.
01:11:50
And so if you look at the five years between 2018 and today, can you tell us by district how many projects were canceled for lack of funding?
01:12:05
because of cost increases, just so we have a sense of what the magnitude of that problem is and how much additional money did they need.
01:12:16
I do think it's important to know whether the locality could have come up with the match themselves because that's another piece of the puzzle.
01:12:25
And so hopefully this isn't more than a dozen over the five years, but if it's more than that,
01:12:35
then I think we need to know that too.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:12:39
Right.
01:12:39
And we'll look into that.
01:12:41
I mentioned this earlier.
01:12:43
I think the bigger question is how many had to cover the incomplete deficit?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:12:47
Well, right.
01:12:48
So it's kind of like three categories.
01:12:50
They canceled it.
01:12:52
They covered the deficit.
01:12:57
They canceled it, but they had their part of the money, but there wasn't any money.
01:13:00
They covered the whole thing, or they canceled it because they didn't have the match.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:13:08
We'll certainly look into that.
01:13:11
I'll be honest with you, that will be a tough lift to try and find that information.
01:13:16
We just don't track it, but we can see if we can't figure it, extrapolate it.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:13:20
If you could tell us how many were canceled by district, that might give us some, which you should be able to have that, right?
01:13:28
Yeah, we should have that.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:13:29
There could be a number of reasons and the ultimate decision after considering those reasons, some of which
01:13:38
Is likely, you know, related to the funding, you know, the locality determines, you know, to cancel the project, but it isn't sort of a clear delineator that it was because of just because of a funding deficit.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:13:50
To Mary's question, though, if you guys or y'all called these localities and said, why did you kick out of this?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:13:59
We have, whenever we deallocate funds, we work through the districts and projects that get canceled.
01:14:05
I'll go back to Frederick.
01:14:06
Frederick County had a few canceled just because the developers pulled out.
01:14:10
And we said, why is money been sitting there since 2018?
01:14:14
Right.
01:14:15
Why did you cancel?
01:14:17
Well, the developer pulled out.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:14:18
So with those conversations, Mr. Lawson, I think what Russ is alluding to is we don't have a data point where we're tracking that so that we could quickly grab that and say of the X number, this number, you know, cancel this for even.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:14:31
No, no, no.
01:14:31
I get it.
01:14:32
We don't have it.
01:14:33
But I would think to Mary's point is a really good one.
01:14:36
Could we find out?
01:14:37
We're trying to create a policy to stop that.
01:14:42
Wouldn't it be wise to try to understand why are the bulk of them if we can put it that way or some of them are kicking out for a specific reason and then we could come up with a policy to attack that issue as opposed to just taking a shot at it and saying let's have a policy and hopefully this will solve that issue because I'm guessing
01:15:08
I mean, for a locality to come up with whatever the number is, half a million, a million, two million bucks, and then go into this program and hope that we get a match and then hope that it goes forward, that is a complicating thing.
01:15:26
And then you add a layer to it of, we've got the private sector that may or may not backstop it.
01:15:34
Let's find out those reasons and then see if we can come up with a policy that'll help them with that.
01:15:41
Okay, we got it.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:15:42
Well, certainly having an amount in the statewide balance entry is a start, right?
01:15:48
Because that's not something we have today.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:15:51
Well, you're saying to cover overruns.
01:15:53
I think Randy had a great point.
01:15:55
Is that enough given the overruns that you're seeing elsewhere?
01:15:59
but I do think it's an awesome, awful shame to get to the very end and everybody agrees to it.
01:16:07
We just got a problem.
01:16:09
The state doesn't have the money to cover its half.
01:16:13
So I think the concept is a great one.
01:16:16
But again, I'd defer to you all as to how many times does this happen and how much money do we need to cover?
SPEAKER_03
01:16:28
Is that it?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:16:30
Number three, and that basically gets to the statewide prioritization process to make sure any surplus allocation for a project is available to all projects statewide that need it.
01:16:44
So rather than, again, as we get back to allocations or major projects, not the localities, how do we prioritize the process so that everyone that needs
01:16:56
Any additional funding for whatever legitimate reason has the ability to get it.
01:17:00
So that's the prioritization process.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:17:03
So I would just point out that there is another change in here that you haven't kind of explicitly called out, which is that because you're saying surplus funds are going to be treated by pulling them into this balance entry account at the state level.
01:17:26
If the board decides not to do that, if they decide to, which is kind of what happened last time, we didn't go all the way that you all recommended.
01:17:35
So right now you can move your revenue sharing money from a surplus from an existing revenue sharing project to another existing revenue sharing project with some rules.
01:17:48
You can also take it to a non-revenue sharing project.
01:17:51
I want to be absolutely clear that I am fine with
01:17:56
Removing the non-revenue sharing projects from this cascade.
01:18:01
I don't see the utility in that.
01:18:05
We saw a big drop.
01:18:07
I think we should keep the revenue sharing money within the revenue sharing program.
01:18:13
That's my personal opinion.
01:18:15
I don't know what others think.
01:18:17
But I think it's time for that piece of the program to go away.
01:18:23
And that's a legacy from when there wasn't any other money except revenue sharing.
01:18:29
And so it was used that way.
01:18:31
And we have lots of other sources of money at this point.
Greg Yates
01:18:34
I totally agree with you, Mary, on that one.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:18:37
I was going to say, Ms. Hinds, I think if I could just state back to you what you may be suggesting is that policy three really could be expressed as a couple of options that are still on the table.
01:18:52
One would be to eliminate
01:18:55
transfers really right and moving that are controlled by jurisdiction I mean that we're basically the jurisdictions moving money right and instead move that surplus money to a statewide balance entry account for further allocation the other the second option would be instead to maintain the ability to do those transfers
01:19:20
from revenue sharing to revenue sharing, the change there being eliminate the ability to transfer from revenue sharing to non-revenue sharing.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:19:28
Right, and if the will of the board was to stay revenue sharing to revenue sharing project, I do think we might wanna think about what the guardrails are.
01:19:40
or the limitations might be in order to address some of the issues that you all have raised, whether it's the length of time before something goes to advertisement or the length of time you can sit on the money.
01:19:56
I mean, I just think if we were gonna do that, we might want some better guardrails than we have right now.
01:20:03
Okay.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:20:03
Sure.
01:20:03
So we can work on that for next time and certainly as we solicit feedback so it's not
01:20:08
All of Nothing, these are sort of options within the state consideration.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:20:14
Okay.
01:20:16
Thank you, Ms. Sargent.
01:20:17
Again, to your point, Ms. Sargent, I think a lot of this is just legacy.
01:20:20
because it goes way back to the formula allocations.
01:20:23
Localities don't have formula allocations anymore like they used to, and they have always seen revenue sharing as their replacement for formula allocations.
01:20:33
How do you say that?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:20:34
I think this is on a journey, Russ.
01:20:37
I really do think it's on a journey, and sometimes you just can't get to the end.
01:20:41
You got to stop along the way here.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:20:45
Which is why we treated this originally, and you know better than I do.
01:20:49
is an incremental approach.
01:20:52
We didn't go all in because we knew all in wasn't going to work.
01:20:56
So that works.
01:20:57
So policy four we had to talk about here, but I think you talked about last week was to get our agreements done more quickly.
01:21:04
Currently, we have a year grace period to get agreements signed.
01:21:08
Most of those agreements get signed within five months.
01:21:12
So there's no reason for a year to be the norm.
01:21:17
So we want to reduce that to six months.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:21:19
Is that pretty standard for our other programs, six months?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:21:25
TAP we have a year, but we get things done generally within six months.
01:21:30
There are some specific localities that we have issues with, but we think we have some strategies to help them out.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:21:38
Yeah, other funding programs don't establish a time frame in which to get the agreement in place because other funding programs don't assume the project is locally administered, which is a little bit different than revenue.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:21:54
Gotcha.
01:21:54
So this is for locally administered projects.
01:21:57
Gotcha.
01:21:58
Okay.
01:21:59
and then finally allow year-round deallocations.
01:22:02
We touched on it a little bit today, rather than an annual deallocation approach and that gets to providing surplus money to projects that need the money today and using the money more efficiently and most quickly.
01:22:17
If we can just do it as the surplus funds become available, provide it to localities that need it rather than waiting until a deallocation
01:22:26
process that happens every January.
01:22:29
That would certainly spend the money more quickly and help localities get projects out the door.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:22:34
So who would reallocate that money, the board or staff?
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:22:40
So it would just be kind of done as projects were completed or cancelled and then any transfer of funding would show up on the monthly transfer report I bring to you all?
01:22:50
either as a transfer for your information or a transfer for your approval, but it always goes back to the deallocation balance.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:23:00
You'd let us know, but you'd let us know that you've done it versus now it actually is an affirmative vote by the board and a decision by the board.
01:23:12
It would still be that.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:23:13
It would still be that.
01:23:15
It would just be part of a larger monthly transaction that gets approved by the board.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:23:20
Yeah, I think the point of this one, Mr. Lawson, is the staff are holding these deallocations to a once a year exercise.
01:23:28
This would allow it to happen in real time as those
01:23:34
as those balances are known and can be deallocated.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:23:38
Okay, so if we had a question, it'd be up to us then to pull that out of your report.
01:23:44
and say what is this and whether we approve that specific item or not.
01:23:49
We don't have to do that.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:23:51
Normally, and I'm making a bit of an assumption here which is dangerous, but normally each district administrator reviews the board packet each month with their board members and there's an opportunity for you to ask questions about anything that's on that transfer report of your district folks who would know about these as well.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:24:13
So if I could chime in as a district person, they do review the transfers.
01:24:20
I do sign off on transfers in between meetings when we're moving money around up here.
01:24:27
And the deallocation process, I am very in the loop about which projects are going to be deallocated.
01:24:35
And so that would be my only request about doing deallocations
01:24:41
year round would be that out of courtesy, the district rep would get the same kind of letter that we're currently seeing where you're sending it to the jurisdiction saying, hey, we're going to deallocate this, that the district rep be in the loop on that so that none of this is a surprise to the district rep.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:25:04
Absolutely.
01:25:06
And coupled with policy three, we'd be able to get the surplus funds to projects that need to get advertised or on the street more quickly.
01:25:16
Right now, there is no process to do it.
01:25:17
It gets deallocated and gets put back into the application process.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:25:23
How do the at-large folks get this?
01:25:27
When you say district folks get briefed by their district engineer or route,
01:25:34
How do the at-large folks get this information?
Greg Yates
01:25:37
I get briefed the same time my district rep gets briefed.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:25:41
Scott joins me for our briefing.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:25:43
Right, right.
01:25:46
But that's for that district, right?
Greg Yates
01:25:48
Yeah, but you can just ask your engineer.
01:25:50
You should be joining that meeting.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:25:52
You can join any district you want as long as you're not the third person.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:25:57
Yeah, I understand.
01:25:57
So it'd be incumbent on me to get it from all the districts.
01:26:02
And Ms. Lawson, currently- All the districts?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:26:04
for our annual process currently, Mr. Lawson, we, the LAD sends the whole entire state's de-allocations to all the at-large members and then the individual district de-allocations to the district members.
01:26:19
So last year, all the at-large members got a list of statewide de-allocations, but this process would have to be done individually each month.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:26:30
Each time, so you just send it,
01:26:33
each month to us then.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:26:34
I think the district engineer would let you know during their briefing that hey we have these projects that are going to get deallocated that had surplus funds we're going to move them we're going to move them all and um they're getting extra funding they're they're getting there because you provide new money on the board action items on the list so they'd give you both which ones got deallocated which ones got more money you know from the prioritization process so it would go both ways
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:27:02
So I'll just point out that Ty and Randy and Mark Merrill, they all live in the same district.
01:27:10
And Ty and Randy are both at large.
01:27:12
So one of you guys might want to affiliate with a different district, because only two of us can be in the briefing at the same time.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:27:19
That's a good point.
01:27:24
And wow.
01:27:27
I understand how you could get it from the district engineer that's closest, but I'm not sure how I would get it from Northern Virginia, for example, or other places.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:27:41
The whole report for the whole state is what is included in the board packet?
01:27:46
So you wouldn't have to seek out anything.
01:27:49
If you had a question about a transfer, you could reach out to Todd and he could get an answer from anywhere in the state, or you could reach out to me and I'd be happy to get you an answer before the board meeting, not during.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:28:02
I'm with you.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:28:03
I have all that detail in my head.
01:28:07
Thank you.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:28:10
So we've got some homework to do, it sounds like, for revenue sharing.
01:28:13
Mr. Yates, I'm sorry.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:28:15
Do we have agreement on any of these?
01:28:18
I'm thinking maybe five we have agreement on.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:28:25
I think there might be agreement on four and five.
01:28:30
And it's more a question of how it's communicated to us than anything else.
Greg Yates
01:28:35
Yeah, yeah, okay.
01:28:38
I'm good with one, but nobody else, we don't have a majority on that?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:28:43
No, I'm good with one too, but we don't have consensus on one.
Greg Yates
01:28:51
Do we need consensus or we just need majority?
H. Randolph Laird
01:28:55
Well, I'm holding back until I hear from the stakeholders.
Greg Yates
01:29:00
Okay, that's fine.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:29:04
Mr. Yates, do you want to talk about next steps?
Greg Yates
01:29:08
Well, I think next step on this would be we want to do the 30-day period for stakeholders.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:29:19
We could also have the TA conversation, Greg, next week because we really haven't had that at all.
01:29:26
That's correct.
01:29:29
Then say by some date in May, we would like stakeholders to weigh in.
01:29:36
Are we talking about a survey?
01:29:38
What are we talking about?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:29:40
Ms. Fye, last time we did this we did, I have the whole book that we did a survey of our locality.
01:29:47
You probably still have the book somewhere.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:29:49
Probably not.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:29:50
We get all the survey questions and we could pattern it similar to what we did in 2017 and basically kind of get to some of the points here that we saw.
01:30:02
and we could get that out relatively quickly.
01:30:06
I hope my staff isn't shooting me in the background but I'm saying we can get it done pretty quickly.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:30:11
So we could work through some proposed survey questions and then run that through you all or through you Mr. Yates to just make sure we've covered the kind of feedback you want to receive.
01:30:25
Thoughts about that?
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:30:27
Can you not just send the information?
01:30:31
All I did was
01:30:33
I asked our local guy if he was aware of it.
01:30:37
I didn't send him anything.
01:30:38
He actually went online, found your materials, Russ, and read through it very well and easily and wrote back.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:30:48
So I would say, Ty, up here, I would like to send it to the heads of the transportation departments in the localities.
01:30:58
So it's very helpful.
01:31:00
for them to get a survey from us that lets Russ and those guys consolidate the information.
01:31:07
The only questions I would have, Russ, is I think using the 17 survey as a base is good,
01:31:15
We have different people and the questions are, you know, the proposals are a little different.
01:31:21
It might be worth it to just send us the survey and let people provide you comment or add a question or whatever.
01:31:29
And that would then let it go out.
01:31:32
You know, we could finalize the survey at the meeting down in Bristol and let you guys get going.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:31:40
And I think it'd be great to see follow up on some of the policy, I mean we should be on the policy initiatives we've already made.
01:31:47
and wrap it in.
01:31:48
So how's it working for you?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:31:51
That's a great first question.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:31:53
Yeah, seem to be pretty happy.
01:31:55
I mean, you know, folks seem to be pretty happy with the changes we've made.
01:31:58
And we certainly got more money out folks.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:32:03
I'm just not sure that I think that imagining the, I think the trouble we had last time was people had a hard time imagining the change.
01:32:11
and I think we'll have that we'll have a little bit of that again that people are like like I'm happy with what I have why would you change it and so the goal of it you know we don't have any data right now that shows if we had had these rules in place over the last five years how it would have changed the flow of the money so people are just guessing and they're always going to guess
01:32:41
Not in the state's favor.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:32:43
And remember, we had a lot of, I'll say pushback, but
01:32:48
We didn't have anybody in favor of our changes last time.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:32:52
I will say again, as I said last month, people were mad at me up here.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:32:57
They were not happy with me.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:32:58
They were not happy with me.
01:33:00
Northern Virginia was getting a huge proportion of this money because they had money and nobody else did.
01:33:08
And so we do have to take our locality hat off and think about the statewide
01:33:16
Program.
01:33:17
If you look at the NOVA numbers, NOVA doesn't have the most projects at all.
01:33:24
So it changed how we use the program change.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:33:31
And I can say all the policy changes worked.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:33:35
They did what we said.
01:33:36
They're fantastic.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:33:37
They're fantastic.
01:33:38
They did exactly what we wanted them to do.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:33:43
Alright so we will have a draft of the survey for your review and feedback next week when we're in person which is probably great because we could sort of hold that get through the TAP discussion because that might change you know a question or two perhaps on the survey get through the review of TAP and then you know be ready
01:34:07
next week to set a course for you know subsequent discussions understanding we'll have that 30-day review period Mr. Yates.
Greg Yates
01:34:15
That sounds good and I wonder if we should we set a virtual meeting maybe prior to the May meeting also just in case we need it we can always cancel it but I'm looking maybe May 17th is a week ahead 10 to 12 if that works or get some feedback and we may not need it but I just think we might want to consider that.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:34:37
Policy limits us to 25% of the meeting being virtual and not consecutive meetings, so we take care of the consecutive.
01:34:50
I just want to be clear, we would need to have additional in-person meetings in order to have another virtual meeting.
Greg Yates
01:35:00
Okay.
01:35:00
Well, we'll have the one in April won't count?
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:35:04
It will.
01:35:05
It will.
01:35:08
I'm just not sure how many more.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:35:10
We would have eight meetings, right, for two of them to be virtual.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:35:18
I'm sorry, Ms. Hines, what was that?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:35:20
We'd have to have eight meetings total in order for two to be virtual.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:35:24
Right.
01:35:25
So the policy you all just adopted limits the
01:35:28
The conduct of the virtual meetings, so they can't be back-to-back, but it also limits the total number of virtual meetings as a percentage of the subcommittee's work, if you will.
SPEAKER_07
01:35:41
Can that be changed to the next meeting?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:35:46
I think that comes from state code, unfortunately.
01:35:49
That 25%, I've encountered that in a number of other bodies I serve on.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:35:56
So then you just need to have this as a, it could be a in and out meeting, but you could call this to order before each monthly meeting if you wanted to, right?
01:36:08
Just to satisfy that rule.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:36:11
Oh, I don't know that I wouldn't do that.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:36:18
I would do it.
01:36:19
We're all gonna be there and we have two or at least two
01:36:24
Committee meetings now, but you could call one and say, does anybody have anything for the good of the order?
01:36:31
And if there isn't, then we officially complied with that regulation.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:36:36
Yeah, but see, we had an in-person meeting in March.
01:36:40
We have April, we have May, we have June, and we would have July would be five in-person meetings.
01:36:51
And
01:36:53
We've had this one, so that's six.
01:36:55
We have to come up with two more in-person, one more in-person in order to do it.
Thomas Moore Lawson
01:37:02
Within the fiscal year?
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:37:04
Well, within this time frame.
01:37:07
Yeah, within the work of the subcommittee.
01:37:08
Within the work plan of the committee, because we're not a standing committee.
01:37:12
If we were a standing committee, then we could do it.
01:37:18
I'm just trying to think of, what did we say about people calling in?
01:37:24
Is there any way to get a critical mass someplace of three of the four appointed members?
01:37:33
Let's leave Ty and Laura out of it just for a minute.
01:37:39
Is there any way to get three of us together in one place?
01:37:45
And the fourth person could call in, because I think that's allowed.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:37:49
Yeah, let me, I don't want to advise incorrectly.
01:37:54
So if we could take that back and then present you all with the options for our, you know, additional meetings when we're together in person next week.
Greg Yates
01:38:06
Yeah, but I think that's logical.
01:38:08
We could, we can meet in a central place.
01:38:13
Okay.
Greg Yates
01:38:15
Randy and Mary could come to Culpeper, which is central, and then Fred could stay where he is.
Kimberly Pryor
Infrastructure Investment Division Director
01:38:19
And Fred could call in.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:38:20
Yeah, and then if Laura and Ty want to come or call in, they can.
01:38:25
But the committee, as appointed, only had four members.
01:38:29
So that gives us some flexibility for not everybody having to travel.
Greg Yates
01:38:37
Right.
01:38:37
Does the 17th work for Randy?
01:38:39
Would that work for you and Mary if we ended up in Culpeper District?
H. Randolph Laird
01:38:42
I don't have my calendar in front of me, but as far as I know.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:38:46
It's a good day for me, Greg.
01:38:48
I could come to call.
Greg Yates
01:38:49
All right, well, let's do tentative 10 to 12 that day, or push it back a little bit later if we need to.
01:38:53
But let's try that.
01:38:55
If we need it, we may not need it.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:38:57
That's May 17th.
Greg Yates
01:38:58
Yep.
SPEAKER_07
01:39:00
Why don't you call it from 10 to 2, just in case we need the time, we can always adjourn.
Greg Yates
01:39:06
Sure, that's fine.
01:39:07
That's fine.
01:39:08
No more than 2.
01:39:11
OK.
01:39:12
All right, let's put that down.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:39:14
And, Greg, you'd have to allow people to attend the meeting in person.
Greg Yates
01:39:19
Sure, gotcha on that.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:39:24
Okay.
01:39:25
Well, this is really good discussion.
01:39:27
I know we didn't get quite as far as we thought we would, but I don't think there's any problem with that.
01:39:33
I mean, we want it to be a well-informed recommendation to the board, so we're happy to take your feedback and go back and
01:39:43
do that additional work and be prepared to present that to you next week and walk through the specifics regarding TAP.
01:39:52
So I think we have, what do we have next week for us?
01:39:55
An hour, hour and a half?
01:39:58
Do you remember?
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:39:59
I don't remember how much time we have.
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:40:01
I think it's no more than an hour and a half.
01:40:03
It may be just an hour.
Greg Yates
01:40:04
Tuesday afternoon, is that where we're doing it?
Angel Deem
Chief of Policy
01:40:07
Yes.
01:40:08
Yes, sir.
Greg Yates
01:40:08
Okay, all right.
01:40:09
All right, well, thank you everybody.
01:40:11
It's a really good meeting.
01:40:13
didn't get as far as I'd hoped, but we really needed to do what we did.
01:40:16
So that's great.
Russell Dudley
Local Assistance Division Administrator
01:40:18
Yeah.
01:40:19
Thank you.
01:40:20
Great discussion.
Mary Hughes Hynes
01:40:21
Thanks, everybody.
01:40:22
See you next week.
Greg Yates
01:40:23
Alrighty.
SPEAKER_03
01:40:25
Good one.
Greg Yates
01:40:26
Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_07
01:40:27
Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_03
01:40:30
What time is the meeting on Tuesday?