Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Retreat 8/22/2017
  • Auto-scroll

Retreat   8/22/2017

Attachments
  • Overview.pdf
  • Minutes.pdf
  • Roles and responsibilities of the board and the commissioner of highways.pdf
  • Survey results.pdf
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:19
      I ask everybody to take their seats.
    • 00:13:23
      We're going to go ahead and get the meeting started.
    • 00:13:29
      Before we all get too comfortable, let's stand and say our Pledge of Allegiance, please.
    • 00:13:33
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • 00:13:49
      Okay, welcome.
    • 00:13:51
      We are live streaming today, but this is while a public meeting, we will not be having any public comment, but anybody in the audience certainly obviously can listen to what these discussions are.
    • 00:14:07
      Now, having said that, I hope that we have a very, very open discussion today.
    • 00:14:12
      I don't think that there's anything that we're talking about that the public doesn't write to hear of these deliberations, and that is the good and bad.
    • 00:14:20
      So I really want to encourage a dialogue.
    • 00:14:24
      Just a few things about
    • 00:14:30
      administration, if you go out the doors to the left and down there are the restrooms.
    • 00:14:37
      But I'd give yourself a five minute walk to planning that because it's a little good ways down there.
    • 00:14:43
      And at 1030 we're going to have some outside consultants come in so if we're in between something we may
    • 00:14:50
      Break in that regard to hear from them and also we'll take a break before 11 so anybody that hasn't checked out of their hotel can do so.
    • 00:15:02
      So before we get started any questions on sort of the format of the day or the
    • 00:15:09
      Administration or anything in that regard, I want this to be free-flowing.
    • 00:15:16
      And while we have an agenda, we're not tied to any specific guidelines in that.
    • 00:15:22
      So if something takes a little bit longer or a little bit less, that's okay.
    • 00:15:26
      Because really, this should be a two-way street.
    • 00:15:29
      Let me also point out, I don't believe that this in any way is going to be the end of it.
    • 00:15:34
      It's sort of the beginning of this process.
    • 00:15:37
      So, you know, hopefully we'll stimulate conversation and we'll have other set of times and other meetings, workshops to continue this over the remainder of the year.
    • 00:15:51
      So, any questions or comments about what we're trying to accomplish today?
    • 00:15:57
      Okay, then I'm going to go up.
    • 00:15:59
      I've got a few opening remarks, but I'd like to go up to the podium.
    • 00:16:04
      So I think that way, as far as addressing everybody, it's a little easier.
    • 00:16:09
      So just bear with me for a second.
    • 00:16:20
      Okay, I think today is pretty historic.
    • 00:16:24
      in that what we're talking about is very important to the Commonwealth of Virginia in transportation, but it's not a particular project we're talking about.
    • 00:16:36
      What we're going to be speaking about is how this board deliberates what it needs to be a functioning and high-level functioning
    • 00:16:48
      Tool for the Commonwealth.
    • 00:16:50
      I've said this many times that the legislature intended for this to be the board that makes those hard decisions on allocating the scarce resources we have for transportation.
    • 00:17:05
      And Nick's going to come up and maybe Jo Anne a little bit and talk about the history of the board and its roles and responsibilities.
    • 00:17:12
      But
    • 00:17:14
      In the nine years or so that I've been associated with transportation, it's only been in the last few that I can actually say that the Commonwealth Transportation Board was really leading this discussion.
    • 00:17:26
      Before that, I would suggest to you it was being led.
    • 00:17:30
      I'm not saying that was bad or good, but I don't think that's the way it was intended when the legislation put up.
    • 00:17:39
      These are hard decisions, very hard decisions, and you should be free to vote your conscience but also to have the information you need.
    • 00:17:51
      and sometimes it's not about the information you have, it's about what you don't have in making decisions and I've found that a couple times.
    • 00:17:59
      I'm in a unique position.
    • 00:18:01
      I'm the first CTB board member to be made Secretary of Transportation or be appointed.
    • 00:18:08
      I guess not many people can make you anything but to be appointed.
    • 00:18:11
      So I had a chance to see how the information was presented
    • 00:18:17
      and then I had it when I got on the other side to say what really was more information that might have been helpful to me in making a decision and so I think that's part of what we're trying to do today is not only to go through these broad scopes but you know at the very end when you really get down to it you're only going to make decisions based on the information you have
    • 00:18:41
      And so that should be part of this, what are you missing?
    • 00:18:44
      And we've got some ideas, but I want to hear from you.
    • 00:18:46
      I mean, the timeliness that certainly we've talked about many times before, actually the meetings themselves.
    • 00:18:54
      These are transportation board meetings, and over the years, and they've done a good job at this, and it's sort of fallen to VDOT, and the meetings have been really geared to what their calendar is.
    • 00:19:04
      And that's not bad, but that's not really what the function of this board is.
    • 00:19:09
      It should be going more the other way in that.
    • 00:19:13
      And of course it's just not VDOT.
    • 00:19:16
      It's DRPT.
    • 00:19:18
      There are certain things we have to do at certain times of the year and you should be prepared for that.
    • 00:19:24
      But what really the board should be deliberating is what it needs
    • 00:19:29
      to make the decisions of moving transportation forward, of allocating these scarce resources back to the policy level.
    • 00:19:38
      Now that doesn't mean you don't get down into some of the details, because I think a big part of this board is working with the locals.
    • 00:19:45
      And I know many of you do.
    • 00:19:46
      The whole thing of SmartScale is to bring this from the ground up, the projects.
    • 00:19:52
      But I think one thing we're also missing is the board needs to have more engagement with our General Assembly members.
    • 00:19:59
      I mean, I've sort of filled that role, or the Secretary's office has filled that role in between, but I think that's something that we need to talk about.
    • 00:20:09
      How do you, we report, how does the General Assembly know what we're doing?
    • 00:20:15
      Are we in sync with where they are or at least reporting to them what we're doing?
    • 00:20:21
      So a lot of things to discuss today and as I said, nothing is off the table.
    • 00:20:28
      I would ever ask people to be civil, but nothing's off, everything's on the table, anywhere you want to go, that's where we should go.
    • 00:20:37
      Now, there's one thing I want to talk about that sort of I believe, feel strongly about that transcends transportation.
    • 00:20:46
      And since we're up here and not too far from Charlottesville, let's make a couple remarks of what happened here a couple of weeks ago almost now.
    • 00:20:57
      You know, I could not be more proud of Governor McAuliffe, you know, standing up for what is right.
    • 00:21:05
      and I look back over my life and quite frankly later years I've really striven for diversity because I found that to be not only the right thing but quite frankly we're talking with some of the earlier it was the right thing to do for my business so right wrong or indifferent I somehow got there but
    • 00:21:30
      This is something our country has been dealing with from its very beginning.
    • 00:21:35
      And I'm a big reader of American history and I like reading about different novels and things.
    • 00:21:45
      But it was no mistake for our founders
    • 00:21:50
      to use that all men are created equal.
    • 00:21:53
      That was not an oversight.
    • 00:21:54
      These were some of the greatest thinkers of their time.
    • 00:21:56
      Remember, this was coming off the Enlightenment, and these were very much influenced by that.
    • 00:22:01
      So anyone that compares some of the actions of these imperfect founding fathers and what their ordeal or their vision for the country, I think misreads what the American experience is all about.
    • 00:22:13
      In fact, 10 years later, after the country was founded,
    • 00:22:16
      The words in order to form a more perfect union started this whole discussion of this path we've been on into how we get to all men are created equal.
    • 00:22:26
      So I'm very much encouraged that very imperfect men or infallible men, whether it's American history or whether it's, if you read the Bible, I like to read a lot about early Christianity.
    • 00:22:38
      That these men can do great things.
    • 00:22:41
      Maybe some of their actions are not so good, but their vision, you know, are called upon to rise up.
    • 00:22:47
      So I just wanted to point out that that's what makes America great.
    • 00:22:54
      It is not our military strength.
    • 00:22:57
      Anybody that's owned or been in business or thinks that your strength comes from you're the best, it actually comes from your moral authority.
    • 00:23:08
      Because whether you think the biggest military history is proven, somebody is always going to have a bigger military.
    • 00:23:13
      So if you only say that that's where our strength comes from, where we come from is this belief that what makes America great, that all people are created equal, unalienable rights,
    • 00:23:26
      and that government is to protect those rights, not favor one over the other.
    • 00:23:31
      I mean that's the very basis, first time in history that a government was formed on that and that's what gives us the moral compass and the moral leadership around the world.
    • 00:23:45
      I put that out, how that comes down to transportation, you guys are somehow have some responsibilities in naming roads and different things in that regard and I think there's going to be a lot talked about over the next few months.
    • 00:24:01
      I think we should put it in the background of our history.
    • 00:24:05
      and I'll get off of this with a closing comment.
    • 00:24:10
      There is no moral equivalency between the side that's standing up for rights and the side that would seek to reduce the rights of the others.
    • 00:24:19
      I'm not talking about the acts of any individual in any one of those groups, but there's just no moral equivalency.
    • 00:24:26
      One was how this country was formed, the other would undermine the very moral fabric
    • 00:24:33
      of what gives us our authority.
    • 00:24:35
      In fact, we go to meetings and particularly in Hampton Roads public hearings, John you'll hear this, I'm always, there's one lady that gets up and quotes Thomas Paine.
    • 00:24:45
      I mean every meeting.
    • 00:24:47
      I read a lot about Thomas Paine and he wrote in 1776 that this vision for America was just not for the Americans but it was the vision
    • 00:25:01
      That's why we've got to continue to be a world leader and denounce this hate.
    • 00:25:07
      and I can quote you go through all during from our Constitution through the Civil War and Reconstruction and Jim Crow and we fought a world war against white supremacy where many people in this country died so it was Payne was very much you know ahead of his time and saying what this meant to the world so
    • 00:25:31
      I point out to you that there's no greater calling I think to any of us as Americans and a little bit in transportation is understanding what it is we're trying to do so I just didn't think I could let that go based on what's happening here some of the things we're hearing out of our leadership and I just again commend Governor McAuliffe for his stance and this has nothing to do about Republican or Democrat
    • 00:25:58
      There are just some things that are right and some things that are wrong.
    • 00:26:02
      And standing up for right is what we've got to do here in that.
    • 00:26:06
      So, alright, enough of that, but I just wanted to let you know that I've taken very seriously not only our responsibilities as a board, but our responsibilities to our citizens.
    • 00:26:20
      and understanding and in all these public hearings we've had.
    • 00:26:24
      I know sometimes that we sort of wish and I've kept to the three minutes but it's I don't know of any other way to do this but listening to all sides and then having people understand where we're coming from in that.
    • 00:26:38
      So all right any questions on where we're going today or anything that in general that there's you want to talk about?
    • 00:26:46
      Now, you can always interrupt as we go forward, but we're going to start with Nick coming up and talking about what are the legislative responsibilities.
    • 00:26:55
      Jo Anne's here and sort of where we've been and where we're going to kick the conversation off.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:27:00
      All right, Nick.
    • 00:27:06
      Good morning.
    • 00:27:09
      So Aubrey asked me to come this morning and I do have Jo Anne here and she has books of the code behind you if you're wondering what this big black brick looking like things are to assist in this discussion what we really wanted to talk about with you all is you know what are the authorities of the Commonwealth Transportation Board you know when you come in as a member we tell you there are certain things that you're going to do but
    • 00:27:29
      I think it's really important as we start this discussion to understand you were the body created by the General Assembly that they have delegated their constitutional authority for picking transportation projects to and to really understand what are your authorities, what are the limits of your authorities, what are the authorities of VDOT and the Commissioner relative to this board.
    • 00:27:50
      I think it's also important to have this discussion because while this board has always been a policy board,
    • 00:27:56
      It has not been treated that way by many administrations.
    • 00:28:00
      So as the Secretary has talked about in the past, there was a member during the previous administration who voted the wrong way and they were gone at the next meeting.
    • 00:28:08
      And there was a new member put in and that is not how this board is supposed to work.
    • 00:28:12
      That's not how it was established by the General Assembly to move forward.
    • 00:28:16
      And again, that's happened in many administrations.
    • 00:28:18
      So I believe it was Governor Warner who replaced
    • 00:28:21
      I think it was seven or eight, nine members of the board in July of his first term after he made them vote to remove all of these funds Governor Gilmore had told the previous board to put into the Six-Year Program.
    • 00:28:33
      And so it was really being driven kind of directly by the administration which in the discussions we've had with the General Assembly was not their intent.
    • 00:28:41
      There, and I think if you look at the reforms that this administration has embraced, we've made it very clear with changes in law that you are a policy board, you are independent, you know, once you're appointed by the governor, you are here for your term.
    • 00:28:55
      And that means, you know, you can vote no, you can vote yes, you can vote whatever your heart is, as the secretary said, on these issues moving forward.
    • 00:29:02
      and so kind of with that you should have a handout that Carol has distributed in front of you.
    • 00:29:07
      There's really three types of boards that exist in the Code of Virginia.
    • 00:29:12
      You're in kind of the middle section so the lowest level of board if you will is the advisory board and the advisory board is exactly what its name says.
    • 00:29:21
      They get to sit around and talk about how they feel about the policies of an agency.
    • 00:29:26
      But they're really providing advice, and the agency can, as it sees fit, take that advice or, as the case may be otherwise, decide not to.
    • 00:29:33
      So an example of that is the Emergency Services Advisory Board.
    • 00:29:37
      That board cannot adopt regulations.
    • 00:29:39
      It cannot put in place new policies.
    • 00:29:41
      What it can do, though, is provide advice to the agencies implementing certain emergency services as to how they would like that to move forward.
    • 00:29:49
      There was a similar board in transportation that has since been disbanded, the Rail Advisory Board.
    • 00:29:54
      That existed since 2005 with the creation of the Rail Enhancement Fund.
    • 00:29:58
      And again, that board existed to provide feedback to the Department of Rail and Public Transportation on their allocation of the Rail Enhancement Funds.
    • 00:30:06
      But if they disagreed with how the department set up the policies, all they could essentially do was write a letter lodging their complaint to the secretary or to the director of DRPT.
    • 00:30:15
      They could do nothing to actually change the policy.
    • 00:30:19
      On the other end of the spectrum are supervisory boards.
    • 00:30:22
      And these are boards that you really see at like a college, you know, so UVA, VCU, these boards are appointed, and then those boards actually hire the chief executive of the, you know, agency that they are overseeing.
    • 00:30:35
      So they, one, appropriate funds, two, set policy, but then three, and this is the difference between you all as a policy board and them as a supervisory board, they manage the day-to-day operations and hire and fire
    • 00:30:48
      the Chief Executive of those agencies.
    • 00:30:51
      Another example of that would be the Virginia VEDP, Virginia Economic Development Partnership, where again they have a board of directors.
    • 00:30:57
      That board goes out, does a search, hires their director, and runs that agency.
    • 00:31:03
      The middle tier, which is the Commonwealth Transportation Board, is a policy board.
    • 00:31:08
      So as a policy board, you have the right to set policies, regulations, and allocate funds that are provided for surface transportation by the General Assembly.
    • 00:31:18
      However,
    • 00:31:19
      VDOT is still responsible for the day-to-day operations on maintenance and safety of the transportation system and the governor hires that chief executive the commissioner in that agency there along with Jennifer Mitchell at DRPT and again those appointments are not subject to any review by this board nor the day-to-day operations of those agencies subject to review kind of by the board and so those are really kind of the three tiers
    • 00:31:47
      You again are in that middle policy tier there and I think we are for the first time really entering the realm where you being asked to independently exercise that policy authority rather than being kind of directed by administrations with regard to how they'd like to see you behave.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:03
      Let me make a couple.
    • 00:32:04
      We have all those boards represented in the secretariat.
    • 00:32:09
      In the supervisory the Port of Virginia is a supervisory board so is the spaceport where they hire
    • 00:32:16
      the Executive Director, there are committees that look over operations and I will tell you I think we've got the right blend now and I like the idea that the director who of an agency is not subject to every four years changing but I can tell you on the supervisory boards I've found sometimes the board gets too far
    • 00:32:37
      and to the operations in that.
    • 00:32:40
      And so we've gotten the right match now is what's the oversight without actually being in there and doing it and that can get you off.
    • 00:32:47
      I can think of the Metro Board being an example where that may be some of the problems that are dealt there, particularly when you don't have commissioners who understand the operations of what the entity they are responsible for, political hires and stuff.
    • 00:33:01
      So on the other side of that, in the Aviation Board, we pretty much have had an advisory board.
    • 00:33:07
      The Aviation Board was out there, but it didn't even have the right to monitor the funds that ran through it that were going to some of the airports.
    • 00:33:19
      So we put rules in this year to move it more in line with what you guys are, having oversight, have the ability to withhold monies.
    • 00:33:27
      from the standpoint if there's something done.
    • 00:33:29
      So these boards are in just in the transportation secretariat we can point to representative types of boards and in fact I think it'll end up being aviation and the CTB will be that middle tier not that I don't mean tier in terms of but that in terms of code but not where the port and the spaceport facilities are.
    • Alison DeTuncqMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:55
      in terms of
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:34:17
      I don't have anything else, but I'd be happy to speak to that.
    • 00:34:20
      So Mr.
    • 00:34:20
      Chair and Ms. Stunk, the board has the ability to create committees that is within your policy determination as a board.
    • 00:34:30
      There are no committees either explicitly required or prohibited.
    • 00:34:35
      by the Code of Virginia which means you as a state creation have the authority to create committees as you see fit and through policy of the board could empower those committees or as it might not be provide them with no power to kind of move forward.
    • 00:34:51
      I do think there have been a range of options that have been considered previously in the past and so I do believe it was under Governor Warner there was a high number of
    • 00:35:00
      committees and I think at that time there was a decision that perhaps they'd gone too far with committees where so much of the work had been pushed down to the kind of committee level that when things came back to the board many there wasn't enough discussion of kind of certain key concepts at the full board but that is something that is within the board's authority and could create if they did deemed appropriate through policy and empower that or not empower that as they saw fit.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:29
      I'll use an example here where we struggled with just recently, and this is not a criticism of the technology, but overseeing what's innovation in technology, you know, and then wanting to know what the work plan was for
    • 00:35:45
      You know, what was going on in that?
    • 00:35:47
      That's probably an overstepping of the authority of this board.
    • 00:35:51
      I'm not saying that they didn't share it.
    • 00:35:52
      I'm just pointing out.
    • 00:35:54
      But that's the balance that we're trying to strive here.
    • 00:35:58
      You know, what you really are, what's the objectives that we want to accomplish?
    • 00:36:03
      How they get there is really up to the agencies, Jennifer and Charlie, you know, although if they don't meet it,
    • 00:36:13
      then we hold them accountable but they didn't get there.
    • 00:36:15
      That doesn't mean they don't.
    • 00:36:16
      Now they've been very good at working and I don't, that's plenty of other examples I'm just saying that because and that's why I've sort of been a little judicious in making different committees because we really haven't talked about where
    • 00:36:29
      You know, other than just getting the things going where the line stops and where, you know, the board has the authority to go, I think if you ask these guys, they'll share with you anything.
    • 00:36:44
      But on the other hand, it's not this board's responsibility to dictate what they think ought to happen and how that's executed.
    • 00:36:55
      They can talk about it, but that is totally within the law within the Commissioner and Jennifer.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:37:04
      Chairman, I was reminded one thing by Jo Anne, which is a very important reminder.
    • 00:37:09
      You can have the committees work to shape certain policies, but it is never a policy of the board until action is taken by the Committee of the Whole, similar to the General Assembly where committees can shape legislation, but unless the full House or the full Senate is willing to vote on that, it has no
    • 00:37:25
      No formal standing.
    • 00:37:27
      So the committees are empowered by the board, could be, excuse me, to work on policy, shape it, deliberate on certain issues, but again, any action to have the force of effective policy would require the full board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:42
      Yes, Ms. Hines.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:44
      I want to ask a question to make sure I understand.
    • 00:37:47
      I understand we shape policy.
    • 00:37:49
      To me, the last step of that is did the policy accomplish
    • 00:37:56
      what it was we hoped when we put the policy in place.
    • 00:38:00
      And so I want to understand from your point of view and from what's in the code, are there limits on how we monitor what happens?
    • 00:38:12
      Are we... Can we compel information to be presented to us about what's going...
    • 00:38:16
      I mean I'm just trying to sort of understand because I don't think we do our job if we're not watching the consequence of the policy that we adopted.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:38:26
      You want to answer that?
    • 00:38:27
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Hines, I think that's actually a direction the General Assembly has started to add new kind of provisions in the code.
    • 00:38:34
      So just this past session they adopted legislation that actually requires this board to set performance targets for the measures that are included in VTrans looking forward and then to report
    • 00:38:47
      basically on the progress towards those targets moving forward.
    • 00:38:51
      Again, I think when the chairman was saying, you know, when you say, here's the product we want to build, you then don't manage the procurement like a supervisory board might.
    • 00:39:01
      The commissioner or Director Mitchell would go out, manage that procurement.
    • 00:39:06
      Ultimately, if it's over 5 million, you'd have to vote on the final bids.
    • 00:39:10
      But it's the implementation that is within the agency's purview.
    • 00:39:15
      Your ability to track the effectiveness of policy, however, is fully within your purview.
    • 00:39:20
      And I would say it is something that the General Assembly has started to ask this board to do, particularly as we've put in place SMART SCALE.
    • 00:39:26
      And we're saying, these are the results we expect to see from these projects.
    • 00:39:30
      I think their expectation is kind of in a few years, we go back and look at these projects we've built and say, did we see the benefits we expected?
    • 00:39:38
      And if so, great.
    • 00:39:39
      If not, why not?
    • 00:39:40
      And trying to understand that in a manner that today I don't think we talk about often.
    • 00:39:44
      We tend to pick a project, build a project, and then we start thinking about what's the next thing we want to build.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:49
      Let me give you a classic example that Charlie and I had to deal with and me more recently.
    • 00:39:56
      It is clearly in the code of Virginia that Charlie is responsible for safety.
    • 00:40:02
      Clearly.
    • 00:40:04
      Let's take and so he comes down to a stoplight and somebody wants to put in an economic thing or we talked about having corridors of you know we want to protect well that's all right except in his he deems that there's a safety it has to be something else that overrides it i mean and so i have been very very clear uh to to if it comes to safety or things that is
    • 00:40:32
      you know totally no matter what any politician or anybody says I want to have that is his decision that is clearly him now that doesn't mean you all know Charlie they're pretty approachable that mean you'll talk about it in a whole bit there's the formal side and then there's the informal side but at the end of the day I get calls all the time gotta have a stoplight here gotta have that
    • 00:40:54
      I don't know.
    • 00:40:56
      You need to talk with the commissioner.
    • 00:40:58
      I'd be happy to put it on, but that is clearly something that I don't think we should override.
    • 00:41:04
      That is not what we're, because you get into that and then you've overridden the law.
    • 00:41:09
      So that's the type of things, but in terms of, you know, performance, did we reduce congestion by putting in these, yeah, that's the type of stuff that, but how we reduced it,
    • 00:41:22
      really is sort of the execution and sort of the projects we pick and stuff.
    • 00:41:27
      So look, I fully get it's a fine line.
    • 00:41:30
      It really is.
    • 00:41:31
      And it really comes down to personalities.
    • 00:41:34
      You know, it does.
    • 00:41:35
      I mean, at the end of the day, we can have all these rules, but it's personalities.
    • 00:41:40
      But I've seen, you know, a board, you know, that I can say at the port board that was, they had blurred the line so much.
    • 00:41:49
      The chairman was in there picking what they were going to work on next week.
    • 00:41:54
      That was, you know, way too far.
    • 00:41:56
      So, yes.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:58
      Can I just follow up with that?
    • 00:41:59
      I do think, though, that some of the policies we've put in place with SMART SCALE
    • 00:42:04
      State of Good Repair, the policies and the way we have organized transportation right now opens the door for us to actually look at are our decisions working?
    • 00:42:15
      Is this working?
    • 00:42:16
      The factor's working.
    • 00:42:17
      Do we need to make changes?
    • 00:42:18
      And I feel as though the Board has been very open about bringing the good and the bad to the table.
    • 00:42:26
      And so I feel that going forward that we're going to have much more, I think, opportunities
    • 00:42:33
      to actually have input to that because it's completely transparent based on data.
    • 00:42:39
      So, well, a lot of this.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:42
      Oh, I think that's right.
    • 00:42:43
      I mean, I thought that's the evolution.
    • 00:42:44
      Up until this, there wasn't a whole lot other than the informal and trying to get Charlie to do something or Jennifer to do something and that.
    • 00:42:54
      And I don't...
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:54
      It's evidence-based.
    • 00:42:55
      We can actually say, wow, we didn't choose the right project there.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:01
      That's right.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:01
      Or we did.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:02
      She would never hear from me, but yeah.
    • 00:43:04
      No, no, we shouldn't.
    • 00:43:05
      We did.
    • 00:43:05
      That's right.
    • 00:43:08
      Yeah.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:10
      May I say one other thing?
    • 00:43:14
      When you were talking about, you know, where we as a board come together, we get the information.
    • 00:43:20
      I do think the committees, and I work with two right now, the two advisory committees here on the board with rail and technology, but I do think there's a lot of work done in these committees that actually make our decisions here at the board, I think,
    • 00:43:38
      And with rail, we hash out so much so that by the time something comes here from the rail committee, there's been a lot of work debate done before it actually gets here because for those who watch our meetings, you know, they'll say, wow, there's a lot of consensus on your board that really isn't a lot of dissent.
    • 00:44:00
      In the committee structures, and I think in how we all work together, we actually go through a lot of that debate offline and then we're able to bring it to the board.
    • 00:44:10
      So I think there's a lot of good work that's actually done.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:44:14
      and I hope I didn't give an impression of favoring or disfavoring committees.
    • 00:44:19
      It's solely within this board's purview, you know, the number or that's a big picture.
    • 00:44:31
      If there's no more questions on the kind of the three tiers of boards I'd like to just move into you know some of the authority that the General Assembly is delegated directly to the board and then really talk about how that compares to the authorities that still remain with the department with the Commissioner and with the Director.
    • 00:44:52
      So I think the board's authorities as we see them really fall into five key categories.
    • 00:44:58
      The first one really deals with, you know, approving the allocation of funds.
    • 00:45:02
      So as I look at, you know, what are the responsibilities of the board, there's a whole host of things that have been in the code for a long, long time going through abandonment of routes and this, that, or the other.
    • 00:45:11
      The most important thing I think this board does is approves a six-year program.
    • 00:45:15
      Every year that's how we allocate billions of dollars and ultimately without this board's action there is no program and without program the commissioner cannot let contracts, Jennifer cannot distribute grants.
    • 00:45:27
      There's a simply, you know, the general assembly appropriates that money but because they have delegated their product selection authority to the board until you act.
    • 00:45:36
      There is no program and those monies cannot be dispersed or spent.
    • 00:45:40
      And so I really view that as kind of the single most important action of the board.
    • 00:45:46
      Also within the realm of financial, the board is responsible for approving the issuance of any bonds.
    • 00:45:52
      So the General Assembly authorizes bonds but in the statute where they've authorized them they require every issuance
    • 00:45:57
      to come to the Commonwealth Transportation Board prior to us going to the bond market and actually selling those bonds.
    • 00:46:03
      You're also required to approve the allocation of any funds from the Virginia Transportation Infrastructure Bank and similarly any funds from the Toll Facilities Revolving Account which is kind of the predecessor to the infrastructure bank which still has funds in it.
    • 00:46:18
      There's several other kind of smaller things but those are really the large kind of items as I see them related to the financial responsibilities of the board.
    • 00:46:27
      The next kind of tranche of area here is dealing with the policy that determines how we're going to allocate some of these funds.
    • 00:46:34
      And again, I think the biggest one there is really SMART SCALE, where you as the board by the General Assembly were delegated the responsibility and duty to develop a statewide prioritization process to use as you determined which capacity-expanding projects you wanted to invest in.
    • 00:46:51
      Similarly, with the State of Good Repair Program,
    • 00:46:55
      There are certain responsibilities given to the commissioner, but ultimately the allocation formula, which is based on a methodology the commissioner develops, you all have to approve that before that formula is effective.
    • 00:47:06
      And so while the department goes out and does the surveys of the roadway, they look at the conditions and then recommend a distribution of those funds based on, you know, their engineering understanding of the
    • 00:47:18
      Ultimately this board has to approve the funding formula that governs the distribution of those funds within the parameters the General Assembly has set out.
    • 00:47:29
      At the same time, you are also responsible for the policy related to several of the transportation programs that the General Assembly has created.
    • 00:47:37
      You know, the High Priority Projects Program, and we've really dealt with that through SMART SCALE, the District Grant Program, and we've also dealt with that through SMART SCALE.
    • 00:47:44
      But, you know, several months ago, we had an extended debate about the revenue sharing program.
    • 00:47:49
      Under the Code of Virginia, that falls squarely, again, within the Board's authority to develop guidelines and policies to really govern how that program works.
    • 00:47:59
      The third tranche of kind of responsibilities we see them is letting contracts.
    • 00:48:04
      So under the code, the commissioner has the authority to let any contracts that are under $5 million or a public-private partnership, but every other contract per the code must come back to this board for it to be executed.
    • 00:48:18
      And so that is a kind of core responsibility of the board moving forward.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:23
      and so you know that is a you know there's several different things listed there but it's all about approving contracts design build and policies and other things of that nature the fourth one is let me just make one comment there if we look back at the comments about the issues that were happened at the downtown midtown tunnel and 460
    • 00:48:46
      People say, how could the Transportation Board have approved those contracts?
    • 00:48:53
      And the issue was, before the reforms under the P3, you didn't have that authority.
    • 00:49:01
      They were totally done by the executive branch.
    • 00:49:04
      in terms and so that's one of the reforms and so now I think I'm correct in this Nick and Jo Anne there is no contract over five million that this board doesn't have authority including P3s and or have to be briefed and allocated before the contracts are signed.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:49:25
      Mr. Chairman, you are correct that the board must be brief.
    • 00:49:28
      However, the P3 contract is made effective by the signature of the commissioner, whereas a $20 million contract for a design build is made effective by a vote of this body.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:44
      But, yeah, yeah, there are some administrative contracts that he can do also.
    • 00:49:50
      But my point I wanted to say is here that with the new reforms, you're fully informed before you allocate money on P3s, even though the signature, that was not the case before.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:02
      Ultimately, we still have the allocation.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:05
      Yes, that's what I'm saying.
    • 00:50:07
      And of course you have representatives on the advisory committee and the whole bit.
    • 00:50:12
      So that is a big change than for way P3s in the past.
    • 00:50:17
      Because clearly, I mean it was totally the executive branch pretty much directing VDOT to execute these contracts.
    • 00:50:23
      That is no longer the case.
    • 00:50:26
      I wanted to point out that was a big change because that whole procurement did not have to come in front of this board.
    • 00:50:41
      Yes, in fact I think Nick will get to the difference between policies you adopt and then those that are actually in code and we in law and we've tried very hard that everything that we have put in to put actually in code.
    • 00:50:58
      So that means if they another administration they would have to have the law changed before they could implement any other or break the law but I mean so we were that's the highest level that we could get in place actual in code statutory code the actions related to these reforms.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:21
      I often found it a little peculiar that
    • 00:51:25
      The secretary could actually have the authority to approve the contracts and you're right.
    • 00:51:32
      You are dedicated to transparency and inclusion that doesn't mandate every secretary to do that.
    • 00:51:41
      And so the only check and balance is the allocation of funds and it seems to me a little bit of a misstep personally.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:56
      Well, you get to, and there is this continual, I won't say conflict, because checks and balances is the best way to put it, between the executive branch, the judiciary, and the legislature.
    • 00:52:10
      Pretty much in the state of Virginia, it's the legislative branch and the executive branch.
    • 00:52:16
      For instance, making you guys independent
    • 00:52:20
      Well, we heard a lot about the giving up executive authority.
    • 00:52:23
      He did.
    • 00:52:24
      I mean, that's why I said the governor chose governance-era politics.
    • 00:52:26
      But I will tell you, policy office was not in favor of that, not because it wasn't the right governance, but because it's giving up executive authority in that.
    • 00:52:36
      And so that's, you know, Dixon, that's part of what was sort of going on.
    • 00:52:41
      You know, governors, the way it was before, they came in and they built the roads they
    • 00:52:47
      I mean, we've talked about this before, right, wrong, but it, you know, if you have all the money to do every road, it's the one thing, but when you have scarce resources, those things change, and that's when it became very political, and we became very political, right?
    • 00:52:59
      I mean, when I got on in 2008 or not, I forgot, and, you know, we had taken $2 billion out of the construction plan or something, and, you know, it was very political about it.
    • 00:53:12
      That's that whole you know how do we get the right checks and balances in and I will tell you sometimes governance takes a backseat to that pull and push between executive and legislative authority like for instance there was a big push they wanted to have the legislature wanted to point people to this board
    • 00:53:34
      you know and I think Nick we pointed out well that'd be great so you're gonna have a legislator on the board it kills a project in another legislators district how's that all going to work I mean so I'm just saying this is continually going on it's getting the right balance and I think we were not there we tried the last three years to get the right balance and now it really comes down to as I said you know how the board operates I think we got it set up legislatively for that to happen but you know how do we interact with that to make sure you know that it does happen
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:54:06
      Chairman, if I may, I think Mr. Cashworth's comments earlier about P3s actually hit some kind of a good point.
    • 00:54:12
      I'd just like to note for our discussions later today because it highlights a kind of a tension or a check and balance, as you would say, that in the past didn't really exist because the board could be dismissed at the pleasure of the governor and was really directed by the administrative branch.
    • 00:54:29
      whether it was the commissioner or the board moving the P3, it was really the administration moving the P3 and the expectation was the commissioner was going to sign that deal and the board was going to provide those funds.
    • 00:54:39
      In as little as six months there could be a P3 moving forward that the administration is pushing but ultimately if they do not bring this board along or get consensus from this board to allocate public funding that might be needed for that project, the commissioner would not be able to sign that contract if it required any public funding because there would be no public funding
    • 00:54:59
      Allocated or authorized for that project.
    • 00:55:01
      And so as you think about like operating in this new paradigm, you are going to be the first kind of vanguard, if you will, of the board that operates with a governor that has not appointed them and cannot remove them, which has never been the case before with the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:55:17
      And so the issue that Mr. Kaspowitz raises is something that I think we should start to think about, not per se on that issue in particular, but just in general, where how do you operate and how do you operate in a world where
    • 00:55:28
      You may or may not be aligned with the direction of the current administration or other things of that nature.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:34
      How many of you have received a call from Governor McAuliffe to tell you to vote one way or the other?
    • 00:55:40
      I don't think any of you have.
    • 00:55:41
      I never have.
    • 00:55:42
      I mean, I cannot say that truth for the other, for another governor I served.
    • 00:55:49
      I'm not saying it's right or wrong.
    • 00:55:50
      I'm just pointing out that that's the way it was done.
    • 00:55:54
      And we witnessed a person who did not vote that way be removed from the board.
    • 00:55:59
      and that.
    • 00:56:01
      The governor was clearly in his authority to do so.
    • 00:56:04
      So I'm not saying what, but I'm just saying that is a much different paradigm than what we are now dealing with, or not dealing with, the world going forward.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:56:18
      Are there other boards that have adopted the similar approach, for example, the port?
    • 00:56:23
      Do they have this, have they had any
    • 00:56:27
      Oh yes, they did.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:29
      Two major.
    • 00:56:31
      One was, this past round, they are now independent.
    • 00:56:34
      Remember the board was, previous governor removed the entire board when he was moving towards privatization and in that regard and Governor McAuliffe came in and didn't take the entire board but took four or five members and put back in with a different vision.
    • 00:56:50
      And also there had two members on the board that couldn't vote.
    • 00:56:54
      They represented the inland ports, but they had no vote.
    • 00:56:58
      Well, that didn't make any sense, so we gave them the power to vote.
    • 00:57:01
      So yes, this is not, you know, as I mentioned, we've now given the Authority Aviation Board the ability.
    • 00:57:08
      They now, just like you do, have to prove the use of funds.
    • 00:57:12
      Here before, it was more entitlement.
    • 00:57:14
      It just went right to the airports.
    • 00:57:15
      They had no authority.
    • 00:57:17
      So yes, this has not just been here.
    • 00:57:20
      It's been across several of the transportation secretariats.
    • 00:57:26
      The recognition, y'all not going to miss this, but I mean, limited resources have consequences.
    • 00:57:32
      I mean, and the better.
    • 00:57:41
      So without governance, you could see how that could really get, you know,
    • 00:57:48
      I'm not saying good or bad, but may not have been the best allocation of resources.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:57:53
      And Mr. Chairman, I consulted with council behind me and they've indicated generally supervisory boards are more likely to have the only remove for cause provision, whereas advisory boards almost always have at the pleasure and policy boards tend to be at the pleasure, though there are a few like this board now that have the provision where members can only be removed for cause.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:15
      I'd just like to emphasize that we've had so many positives in the last four years.
    • 00:58:21
      The amount of benefit that we gained and the oversight of P3s as a board is extraordinary and it's a great check and balance and it's been mixed in with, you know, SMART SCALE improvements in VTrans and so many other very positive steps forward, but it's one of our biggest accomplishments, I believe.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:58:41
      So there's two more tranches of kind of authority of the board that I'd like to go through before we get to kind of the commissioner and the department.
    • 00:58:47
      The fourth one really kind of just deals with you know transportation systems and route locations and so this is kind of the you know old bread and butter authority of the board where abandoning routes, selecting the location of routes, and things of that nature fall within the authority of the board.
    • 00:59:04
      There's also things about the transfer of real estate.
    • 00:59:07
      The board does have the authority to choose to impose tolls.
    • 00:59:11
      You used to have essentially unfettered authority to choose to impose tolls.
    • 00:59:16
      There were limits put in place two years ago where now you can only impose tolls on essentially a non-general purpose lane which either means an HOV lane you're converting or a new lane that you are building.
    • 00:59:28
      And then the final one is really entering into agreements with other entities.
    • 00:59:34
      And so whenever we enter into an agreement with the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, the Hampton Roads Transportation Accountability Commission, the State of Maryland, etc.,
    • 00:59:44
      All of those types of agreements with other principal entities must come to this board to be ratified or enacted unless you give that authority by policy for particular issues to the commissioner as you did do with certain environmental approvals I believe it was late two years ago.
    • 01:00:06
      Alright so moving on to kind of you know that's the board's authority so what is how do we draw kind of the delineation between the board's authorities and kind of the agency's authorities here the Commissioner of Highways is granted broad authority and basically what the code says is except for powers provided by the code to the board and I just walk through those five tranches the Commissioner is empowered to take basically all actions deemed necessary to have a you know
    • 01:00:33
      A. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:00:52
      The General Assembly did adopt legislation this year that set out kind of three core missions of the department.
    • 01:00:58
      The first is to maintain and operate the system of state highways.
    • 01:01:02
      The second is to develop, oversee, and manage highway projects included in the Six-Year Program based on guidance from the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 01:01:09
      And the third is to ensure the safety of the traveling public on the state system of highways.
    • 01:01:14
      And so if you think about really what are the key functions of the commissioner and VDOT, it's really building the projects that the board selects, ensuring safety on the network, and operating and maintaining the network.
    • 01:01:26
      And that does come with policy discretion and other authority from the General Assembly.
    • 01:01:31
      Again, you as the board are delegated certain roles, and then the remaining roles to kind of move forward were provided to the commissioner.
    • 01:01:39
      You know, by the code of Virginia.
    • 01:01:41
      What do we have at the end of this packet?
    • 01:01:43
      And I don't intend to kind of walk through this, but I thought it would be helpful for you all to have.
    • 01:01:48
      There's really four key code sections that deal with the authority of the board.
    • 01:01:52
      So the first deals with the Office of Intermodal Planning and Investment, which now reports to the secretary and his role as chairman.
    • 01:02:00
      of the Commonwealth Transportation Board which is basically charged to work with you all to implement SMART SCALE, develop VTrans, and set performance targets to Ms. Hines' point earlier about tracking performance.
    • 01:02:11
      The second one deals with the Six-Year Program and states very clearly that it is the board's responsibility to develop and approve the Six-Year Program and that's 33.2-214.
    • 01:02:22
      The next one deals with the prioritization process and that's 33.2 to 14.1 and again it makes it very clear that the board shall develop and implement a prioritization process for selecting projects and kind of walks through again that authority.
    • 01:02:38
      And then the final section is a section that deals with the long-range plan.
    • 01:02:42
      and that again states very clearly that the board is responsible for the development of a long-range transportation program which must look at you know the surface transportation needs and you must do that every four years and so again those are just kind of four key code sections I think we talk about these a lot but I also wanted to make sure that each of you had a copy of these sections of code so you could see the the exact language in there.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:03:11
      Questions?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:13
      The evolution of this board, the highway commission was actually established, I think the highway department was established around 1906, 1907, so we've been around 110 years.
    • 01:03:35
      And the first commission was made up of the commissioner, Commissioner St. Julian, Mary Fralin.
    • 01:03:44
      E. Scott Kasprowicz Jr., John Malbon Jr.,
    • 01:04:04
      Commissioner, Highway Commissioners, 1922, where you began to have citizen members of the commission and they were originally broken up by the congressional districts, so they were in alignment with congressional districts then, so the evolution
    • 01:04:24
      The evolution today, you can see there's been a long, long history of citizen members of the highway commission.
    • 01:04:33
      It was in the 80s that the commissioner with the creation of the secretaries, the commissioner was no longer the chair of the board and the secretary who was a cabinet member became the chair and the commissioner then became the vice chair.
    • 01:04:52
      So you can see some of this evolution,
    • 01:04:54
      In large part it's been a fairly intact system for a long time.
    • 01:04:59
      Now last week we hosted the Sashto Conference, the Southern Association of Highway and Transportation Officials.
    • 01:05:06
      As you go, especially through the South, there is incredible differences and you could name any kind of scenario or concoction of commissions and commissioners and secretaries and you can probably find them in those 13 states.
    • 01:05:21
      Some commissions are appointed by the General Assembly, some commissions are appointed by the Governor,
    • 01:05:27
      Some serve short terms and some serve in Arkansas.
    • 01:05:32
      It's a 10-year term.
    • 01:05:33
      So it's a very, just a very diverse situation in various states.
    • 01:05:40
      In some states I would be appointed by you and work for the commission or the board and not for the governor.
    • 01:05:47
      Georgia and South Carolina are two examples of that.
    • 01:05:51
      In Alabama or Mississippi, excuse me, they're elected
    • 01:05:54
      It's a statewide election for the three commissioners.
    • 01:05:59
      So we've got just about any concoction you could imagine.
    • 01:06:03
      If you say, well, how about if you do it this way?
    • 01:06:05
      Well, we can find one that probably does it that way.
    • 01:06:08
      And then throughout the United States, again,
    • 01:06:11
      Many states do have a commission or a board and they operate all different matters from truly advisory only to oversight.
    • 01:06:21
      And in some states the commissioner alone picks the projects.
    • 01:06:27
      Basically the General Assembly or the board says this is how much money you have.
    • 01:06:32
      The commissioner comes back and says this is what the projects you get.
    • 01:06:35
      So again, I think it's interesting that around the country there's incredible
    • 01:06:40
      diversity in terms of how these commissions and boards are organized and their role.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:06:47
      I would just add I think one of the other things where I think Virginia really is kind of unique in some of this is in Tennessee they just have a commissioner.
    • 01:06:54
      They have no commission and the commissioner has discretion with certain pots of money but they just passed a revenue bill and in that revenue bill it doesn't say commissioner go forth and prosper and do well.
    • 01:07:04
      It says here 908 projects we expect you to build with this new money over the next 10 years.
    • 01:07:10
      Similar thing like in Washington State.
    • 01:07:12
      and again they don't have really a full commission there they have a secretary but the General Assembly when they raise revenue they don't say oh you guys are going to do a great job picking these projects they say here's the project we want you to build with this five cent increase in the gas tax and we fully expect you to go you know forth and do this um you know federal funds tend to be outside of those types of things but I think we are pretty unique in the discussions I've had where we have almost full flexibility because everything is line itemed
    • 01:07:40
      Kennedy, to this board, which in a lot of other states, the federal funds tend to be line items, some state funds are, but a lot of general assemblies have been unwilling to essentially relinquish their constitutional authority to pick the capital budget and pick these projects that are kind of moving forward. And even in other states where the department has the discretion, they tend to have to submit a list to the general assembly, which they've developed but the assembly has to approve. move.
    • 01:08:06
      We are I think very, one of the few states where after you guys act there is no other additional approval that is kind of really needed for the department to go out and move forward with these projects and so I think you do have a high degree of authority that's been delegated to this board.
    • 01:08:22
      Smith Jr.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:08:42
      Are there any further questions for Nick?
    • 01:08:44
      Are you going to continue through the years?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:08:47
      That concludes the comments I had at this point.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:08:51
      The next item, I'm happy to have a question.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:53
      Mr. Chairman, I did have a question.
    • 01:08:54
      Nick, there's a lot of lowercase letters under the authority of the CTB.
    • 01:09:00
      Do we have periodic reviews to see if anything is outdated?
    • 01:09:03
      Are they necessary given why we're here today but the future of the CTB?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:09:10
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Connors, I would say that administrations have reviewed those and have proposed legislation from time to time that has been adopted by the Assembly to transfer certain authorities to the Commissioner.
    • 01:09:24
      So for example, I think it was only three or four years ago when the Commissioner received the authority through the Code to execute contracts of less than $5 million.
    • 01:09:33
      I think prior to that time it was
    • 01:09:35
      A million dollars and I think shortly before that it was only half a million and so that tends to be something administrations do to determine whether or not there are things they can do to expedite the kind of function of government or things that maybe don't need to go to the policy board for review and approval there is not a formal process by that which that takes place I'd say it's more an ad hoc basis depending on you know the
    • 01:09:59
      provisions of administrations.
    • 01:10:00
      I think similarly if you guys were to look at this or I think you have had folks who have raised questions as to why is this being voted on by the board.
    • 01:10:09
      I think if we started to hear that time and time again, I think you'd probably see someone put in a piece of legislation say, hey, the board thinks this isn't something that needs to come to it.
    • 01:10:17
      They are comfortable with this being with the commissioner.
    • 01:10:20
      Then we could put in place legislation that would make that change official.
    • 01:10:24
      I'd also say, again, the example of that environmental review
    • 01:10:28
      approval, I forget exactly what it was, but it was about 18 months ago, you all did delegate through a policy for a period of time to the commissioner the ability to execute certain contracts that otherwise would have come back on an individual basis to this board.
    • 01:10:43
      So there are several mechanisms available to kind of look at some of these issues.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:50
      Oh yeah, Charlie.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:52
      Regarding some of these items, they do seem a bit, I'll call it administrative sometimes, but even access break changes where we bring to the board an adjustment to the limited access line.
    • 01:11:05
      The authority to create limited access resides with the Commonwealth Transportation Board, not with me.
    • 01:11:10
      So that is one of the authorities that you have to create limited access right of way.
    • 01:11:15
      So when we bring to you, even though they're sort of administrative and many times it's a project adjustment that is part of the design, it does provide a bit of a balance against the commissioner just granting breaks across the limited access line as he or she sees fit.
    • 01:11:35
      So there is a...
    • 01:11:35
      I do think there's a reasonableness balance there.
    • 01:11:38
      And again, some of these things are very administrative, the approval of agreements with other entities.
    • 01:11:46
      In most cases, they're just sort of, again, administrative and they're not controversial.
    • 01:11:51
      But I just think it does provide a bit of a balance.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:54
      Let me make a comment.
    • 01:11:55
      I'm sorry I take this phone call, but it was exactly about what Charlie was talking about.
    • 01:12:01
      And this is where a policy may come into conflict with political will.
    • 01:12:06
      and it has to deal with this discussion we're having about prohibiting another 29 in Charlottesville and keeping these flee-flowing traffic.
    • 01:12:19
      That is now being conflated, we're the country now conflated, are being confused with people are reading a lot more into that than what it is.
    • 01:12:30
      In fact, you know, one of the, if you know, I used to be in retail and every time I'd open a new store, I'd want my own stoplight.
    • 01:12:39
      Alright, that's the default.
    • 01:12:40
      I mean, that's just what you asked for.
    • 01:12:42
      But what we should be looking at is what is the how to keep the traffic flowing into my store because I'll tell you what will happen is every time you do that, you flow the traffic and then a few years later, I'm moving the store because nobody can get to it.
    • 01:12:56
      So the issue should be about, you know, what is do we need to support the operations of this economic development thing coming in.
    • 01:13:08
      but because of past practices and Charlie being sometimes you know economic development do that not Charlie but the commissioner you know it's been we need to have a stoplight so that's where I see this this you know we've talked about how we're going to change well that type of policy it's got to be explained and people understanding it because at the the answer may not be a stoplight it might be better access ramps whatever
    • 01:13:35
      And that's what we ought to be fixing, the problem, not what somebody says is the answer to the problem.
    • 01:13:43
      because that short-term fix could kill us in the long term for that.
    • 01:13:47
      So I can tell you that's just one example.
    • 01:13:50
      There are going to be others, but that's where the communicating with legislators and not just local, but state legislators, not just local officials.
    • 01:14:02
      That's the type of thing we're talking about.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 01:14:03
      Yes, John.
    • 01:14:06
      The point that I was going to ask, do you see us getting more involved in land use decisions now in terms of our role in providing transportation?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:17
      Part of the land use is smart scale.
    • 01:14:19
      I mean that's a big component and Chad I think and Nick will tell you that developing it in this urban areas that's a part of the score.
    • 01:14:27
      So do I see you specifically know not directing something for a you know a particular area but an overall understanding how land use impacts your ability to move you know to promote economic development and
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:14:44
      Richard L. Whittaker Jr.,
    • 01:15:04
      I would say I briefed the board I think three months ago on the Urban Development Area Grant Program.
    • 01:15:08
      I think it's fully within the rights and purview of this board to say that we want to encourage local governments to put in place growth that has a reduced impact on the transportation network because you have recognized that you do not have the resources to solve all the problems.
    • 01:15:25
      And so having the land use scoring and SMART SCALE is one way to do that.
    • 01:15:28
      providing grants to help local governments plan for those types of areas again on a voluntary type of basis is a mechanism by which you can do those types of things so you as a board have the authority to put in place policies encouraging certain actions or outcomes you you will not be granted in my opinion the authority to approve or reject any local land use authority.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:50
      I'm a much bigger believer in incentivizing someone than penalizing someone about changing behavior.
    • 01:15:55
      And I think that's, you know, policies that incentive that might be helpful.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:00
      Let me just check if I can further say that I don't believe this board should feel compelled to make expenditures that are required based on poor land use decisions on the part of local governments.
    • 01:16:10
      So, you know, the counter to that is that
    • 01:16:14
      That drives a lot of our transportation expenditures, the land use decisions made at a local level, and we shouldn't feel compelled to, you know, address it from a board perspective to make up for poor land use decisions of years past.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:16:28
      I think, yes, oh, go ahead, Gary.
    • 01:16:32
      This is not the land use.
    • 01:16:34
      This may be delving a little bit into the vision of the future role of CTB, but as we talk about being a policy board,
    • 01:16:43
      It's a policy board that has a trigger to it in a certain extent or a governor, not the governor, but a governor on our policies and that's the General Assembly because some of the things that we do are dictated by the General Assembly.
    • 01:17:01
      So my question is two parts.
    • 01:17:03
      It's one is that liaison back to the General Assembly
    • 01:17:10
      through the Board or through the Executive Branch because we've talked about this kind of roundabout over the last several months.
    • 01:17:21
      Is there, should we adopt a formal policy or even an informal one of making suggestions that we deem appropriate to the General Assembly or, and Shannon and Marty have been there,
    • 01:17:39
      Do you find that offensive as a member of the assembly that you're getting advice from a non-elected board?
    • 01:17:45
      Because that's a fine line, but I think in certain circumstances, say how about if we didn't agree with state of good repair being X percent and wanted a different allocation?
    • 01:17:59
      How do we get that back?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:00
      I'm going to let them answer, but I do have a comment how I found that giving them the consequences is a better way than saying, here's what you should do.
    • 01:18:12
      I mean, I have found that, Marty, you might have a different, but when we've gone before them, Nick, we've been very, we've laid out, here's what happens if we do this, and here's what happens if we don't do this.
    • 01:18:24
      Instead of saying, we want you to do this, we've done it that way.
    • 01:18:28
      Now, Marty, you may have a different,
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:30
      We don't do it yet and that's what we've tried to do in fact
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:53
      Yes, that's what we have found in saying instead of putting up a policy we want you to do X to say here's the options before us or before here and here are the consequences that we see of those or the benefits we see in that and then I think
    • 01:19:10
      you know Nick I can't say every time but most of the time that's been our tact and that's they've responded much better to that well now at the end of the day there have been some times where we just had to just say well we disagree and say why and you know I'll point out one other thing too I don't mean this uh and I'll come to you Shannon um to be because I've never been an elected official but I have come to understand
    • 01:19:36
      The impact of politics over reason.
    • 01:19:39
      And I don't mean that to be critical.
    • 01:19:43
      I'm just saying that that is a part of the business we're in.
    • 01:19:47
      And I just have to accept that's, you know, then we just move on from that and that.
    • 01:19:53
      So Shannon.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:54
      The first thing I would say is I agree with Marty and underlying all of this is education, whether it's at the local level or with legislators.
    • 01:20:05
      My experience has been that legislators want to be informed.
    • 01:20:09
      That doesn't mean that politics doesn't win out, but they do want to know the consequences.
    • 01:20:14
      They want to be informed about what constituents are facing and what options are actually on the table.
    • 01:20:22
      I think they also want to know when things aren't working.
    • 01:20:26
      A lot of times things are in the code that not just this board but people assume well it's in the code so it's got to be right but the truth is a lot of times legislators would be shocked if we went back to them and said this isn't working, we can save money, we can do this differently.
    • 01:20:42
      So I think that piece is very important.
    • 01:20:47
      I will say that when I was in the General Assembly actually an idea I had for the legislation that Nick helped write on access management for 29 that I put in in 2009 actually came from CTB members.
    • 01:21:02
      They actually came to me and said, if we want to address the traffic lights on 29,
    • 01:21:11
      This is something we can do, and Nick actually helped me write the legislation for it.
    • 01:21:15
      It did not pass, but it...
    • 01:21:17
      I didn't tell you what the Mark Committee did.
    • 01:21:20
      No, you did not.
    • 01:21:21
      However, you know, it is those kinds of things that help legislators think through what could be done to help manage some of the problems that we're having.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:21:32
      So...
    • 01:21:32
      I guess my question is, should there be a formal outlet to get that to the legislature?
    • 01:21:39
      uh couch it like you're talking about like Marty's talking about but that we do have that debate say hey we want action we want this to happen as an independent board we'd like this to be phrased however we want to couch it but we want to get it to the legislature right now that that comes through this right way we've handled it is through the secretary's office
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:01
      and putting as the chairman of the look many of these legislative things they point blank told me we're doing this as chairman of the transportation board not as your role as secretary of transportation now that may be the way they couch it because they were getting around the you know the executive all that stuff that's how we communicate yeah but on the other hand the informal stuff you're talking about i encourage that all the time yes
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:31
      I do think this board, perhaps having some input into a legislative agenda, legislative recommendations, just like your draft recommendations, whether it's, you know, through the secretariat.
    • 01:22:43
      But I do think thinking through this is, I think could be extremely helpful.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:50
      I mean through, I think we ought to,
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:55
      Well, there could be times they're not allowed to align with the administration, and that's the- I think we ought to tread lightly with having the legislative agenda.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:03
      If I may, I just think- The secretary already, you do, you put together an agenda.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:07
      Heavily influenced, now the governor, this governor's been very good about being independent, and I, of course, you know, but I will tell you other, I don't know this, but I guess other governors, maybe not so, you know, you know,
    • 01:23:22
      independent of you know this governor has been you tell me what you need and well and he's been supportive and he's been in his vision don't get me wrong in that others have come in and said this is what we want to happen.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:36
      I would say tread very lightly.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:23:48
      I would just say to you all if that is I think a core function of this board because I promise you the folks who are upset or not happy with something you're doing they are not being shy about reaching out to their delegates or their senators that's right
    • 01:24:17
      So in turn you need to make sure that both sides of that story are heard so that when they show up and pre-file a bill for the General Assembly they're not putting it in there based on one side of that story and then the bill is pre-filed and then the amount of work that goes into dealing with a piece of legislation that you know could have harmful impacts is a lot.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:35
      And don't make the assumption that the legislative body is a body, it's individual members.
    • 01:24:41
      And so just you might have one guy on board.
    • 01:24:45
      That doesn't mean his counterparts are on board.
    • 01:24:49
      That's right.
    • 01:24:57
      But I do, this brings up a bigger point and we're sort of rolling into this view.
    • 01:25:01
      I'm glad this conversation is going on because it's sort of leading to the future and I want Nick to go through his calendar before we really get into it.
    • 01:25:08
      I think that's where I think in other words
    • 01:25:22
      That's never more input into how we're developing whatever communication it is, the meetings, the legislative, the word is outreach, but communication I think is a better word in that actually the governor.
    • 01:25:39
      I mean the General Assembly if we're independent I mean with the Governor in terms of in that I think inviting the Governor coming to or you know we're going to talk about this other members I've tried to encourage very much open working with members and coming to our meetings and vice versa
    • 01:26:01
      I think that is very clearly and I've tried because I think what I've tried to do is say it's the governor and the executive branch and the legislative all working together for this and yet Governor McAuliffe has been great in leading in that effort.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 01:26:18
      Secretary, I agree with Marty tread lightly on the legislative agenda but I'd like to bring this up and get some advice.
    • 01:26:27
      I'm very passionate about putting a floor in a gas tax.
    • 01:26:31
      for a lot of reasons, and I think it could be presented similar as you said that if you don't do it, here's the results.
    • 01:26:40
      If you do do it, here are the results.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:47
      First of all, you can have your personal opinions that can weigh in on anything.
    • 01:26:59
      When you get to talking about, let's say, legislative agendas, and Nick, you can weigh in much more than this, but there may be competing interests in the legislative agenda in the administration.
    • 01:27:11
      For instance,
    • 01:27:13
      You know, this budget cycle is going to be very, you listened to the Governor's speech yesterday, and it's going to be a very, very difficult budget cycle.
    • 01:27:23
      Very difficult budget cycle.
    • 01:27:25
      Particularly, and I think there's a very good chance that we're going to be under a continuing resolution, which meaning they won't deal with sequestration, and which means that's going to be a significant impact on defense contract spending in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 01:27:42
      So that means revenues that would come from that spending are going down.
    • 01:27:48
      We've got the agencies telling, we're meeting the 21st, telling us we're on a negative outlook.
    • 01:27:54
      You know, so there may be, you're right, you're looking at it, we want, we need more money for transportation.
    • 01:28:01
      Others may assume there's a bigger need for raising taxes in another area.
    • 01:28:08
      I'm not saying, you know, so that's the other side of the agenda is with particularly when you're working with the governor's policy office is that, you know, you can present ideas and that's why I do agree we should tread lightly about actually an agenda but I think we're much more on actions that are up what happens if something, you know, does or doesn't happen.
    • 01:28:28
      I think we're more of an information-giving board than I think an agenda-setting board.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:32
      But I think the question is giving input to the secretary.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:46
      It's fixing something.
    • 01:28:48
      It's fixing.
    • 01:28:49
      We know that the floors weren't put in the regional entities.
    • 01:28:56
      So we as a board recognize there are consequences to the floor not being there in Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia so going to you as part of working through an agenda with the governor and the legislature to say would we want to fix that I'm not saying that
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:21
      Let's go back to the three A's.
    • 01:29:23
      When I came up here, now there's four A's, but there were three A's of transportation funding.
    • 01:29:29
      The General Assembly are the only ones that can appropriate money.
    • 01:29:34
      Our job is to allocate it.
    • 01:29:36
      It's not to appropriate it.
    • 01:29:38
      It's to allocate it.
    • 01:29:40
      Authorization and then when we goes out to either the executive branches or the MPOs or whoever that gets voted to.
    • 01:29:48
      Towards now I think we have a fourth with accountability which comes back to the board and I think that what we need to give is to the General Assembly the consequences of the funds that are being used and how they are.
    • 01:30:00
      I mean let's take SMART SCALE.
    • 01:30:02
      I think we have pretty much laid bare
    • 01:30:06
      what the cost of not having additional monies are.
    • 01:30:11
      I mean I know there's a lot of conversation now ah we got some issues with smart scale it's not smart scale but the issues the issues are the formula allocation and the total pot of money because every district I can tell you there's good projects not getting done every district
    • 01:30:29
      Yeah, where before that was sort of, well, Northern Virginia got it all or Hampton Roads got it all.
    • 01:30:34
      Now, hey, this is all the money.
    • 01:30:36
      Here's what's out there.
    • 01:30:38
      So there's going to be, you know, some, it's easy to say it's smart scale.
    • 01:30:43
      It isn't smart scale.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:44
      It's the amount of monies that we have out there because everybody thinks their project should be done before the other project.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:51
      I mean, you know, everybody, every district thinks that's the case.
    • 01:30:54
      So I would use caution in saying we are, our role is allocation and here are the consequences of that allocation.
    • 01:31:06
      You know, they ask us to look at other resources, that's great, well then we say, but I don't think any board, I mean I think they generally know that this board is in favor of more dollars.
    • 01:31:19
      I think
    • 01:31:21
      I think they generally know that.
    • 01:31:23
      I might be mistaken, John, but I think that's the case.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:26
      So my question is, okay, so is providing that input that we would like to see a floor to you and to negotiate how that would go in, whether it's having discussions or part of the governor's agenda, where does that, how does that happen?
    • 01:31:45
      So I think what Marty's saying is you don't want a formal recommendation from this board.
    • 01:31:50
      But how do we provide input to say this is something that could be fixed?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:54
      Well, I would say what would happen is it would go to ourselves.
    • 01:31:58
      We would present it to the policy and the governor would either say, I am going to put that as part of my package or not.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:04
      Right?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:04
      That's right.
    • 01:32:05
      Or there may be other legislators that say, you know, and we have these conversations, you know, that, yeah.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:32:16
      Mr. Chairman, could I just draw, I think there's two separate things.
    • 01:32:21
      This board should never go before, in my opinion, a legislative committee and say, we as the Commonwealth Transportation Board, Mr. Chairman, speaking to whoever's chairing that committee, we oppose your legislation.
    • 01:32:31
      That would be the single worst decision I believe this board could make because then you would see a whole host of budget amendments or other legislation that would then strip or dictate or further handcuff your authority.
    • 01:32:43
      At the same time, I think you all can very easily, we can create a mechanism where you could provide input to the executive branch to determine whether or not they move forward.
    • 01:32:52
      And if we do that in a public forum, there may be legislators who might choose to take up that torch in the absence of the administration kind of moving forward.
    • 01:33:01
      And I think what we can do is just kind of work into a calendar when something like that might happen.
    • 01:33:06
      But I would, with as much vehemence as I can express in this public forum, strongly say, do not
    • 01:33:12
      This board should not be before legislative committees taking positions or crosswise with the governor in the legislative committee there because
    • 01:33:21
      The governor has, the administration has more juice than this board because they touch every aspect of state government, and if you get into a fight like that in the legislature, you never know what the outcome is.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:32
      Remember, we're a combination of the executive and legislative branch.
    • 01:33:35
      I mean, that's what we are.
    • 01:33:37
      Look, I've ever been in front of committees, and I get these questions asked me all the time, and I say, what secretary doesn't want more money?
    • 01:33:44
      But I don't advocate for it.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:46
      Can I shift something, though, that, well, I know Marty's leaving, but he cares.
    • 01:33:52
      The economic development funds, the rail access funds and the economic development funds, which Marty usually votes against, right?
    • 01:34:01
      But that's in the code.
    • 01:34:03
      So if we wanted to do it differently, so what I'm saying, if you took it out of trying to fix a floor, what we see working through making these decisions, do we approve it or not approve rail enhancements funds?
    • 01:34:17
      or rail access or economic development access funds.
    • 01:34:21
      You know, if we see, wow, we could do this differently or maybe it does need to go through VEDP or we need their recommendation before we get this, that's the, to me as a legislator, I would say I want to know that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:34
      Yeah, and I think it goes through, look, the vehicle, the vehicle, the way we're set up is through the secretary's office.
    • 01:34:40
      And that's what you give me the, give us the input.
    • 01:34:43
      That's the way it's set up.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:45
      But Mr. Secretary, I think the point Nick made is the right point.
    • 01:34:49
      At the moment in the calendar, there's no moment when we even talk about this.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:54
      But that's what we're going to, I preface this by saying I want him to go through his calendar.
    • 01:34:57
      That's right.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:59
      And I, I would say too,
    • 01:35:01
      H. R. Dachshund Jr.,
    • 01:35:18
      Talk to the RMPOs about putting that in their packages.
    • 01:35:21
      That's a great way to do it.
    • 01:35:23
      It doesn't have to be us in this role.
    • 01:35:27
      We all play roles back...
    • 01:35:29
      I mean those of us who represent districts, we have opportunities back in the district to influence how they're talking.
    • 01:35:36
      But right now to me, and I've only been here a year, these are some of the conversations we're not having that we need to regularize so we can figure out if there are things we want to say.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:48
      Ms. Hines, you've been here a year.
    • 01:35:50
      Before that, we were spending all our time figuring out how to use the money, and that's what the whole purpose of this meeting is.
    • 01:35:55
      You're right.
    • 01:35:56
      I mean, as to how do we go forward.
    • 01:35:59
      I think, you know, again, the real conduit we have is, and that's why we're having this, is how do you guys, the input through the link is the secretary's office.
    • 01:36:11
      That is the link, and at the end of the day,
    • 01:36:15
      Your role is, what was delegated, was the allocation, not the appropriation.
    • 01:36:22
      You can say what the consequences are.
    • 01:36:23
      And I think I strongly would, individually, you can do anything you want, but encourage that, uh, that Nick's right.
    • 01:36:32
      If we get up and start saying, every CTB member, we want more money, I can assure you this board will get a lot of changes to it legislatively.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:36:41
      I think that the point that Mary was making in,
    • 01:36:45
      and Shannon as well is not so much trying to dictate anything to the legislature, but is there a time and is there a vehicle on this board that gives us the opportunity that whether it's once a year in October or whenever in the fall where we're thinking solely about
    • 01:37:06
      What message do we want you to deliver on certain topics?
    • 01:37:14
      Not dictate, but deliver concerns.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:17
      That's what we're going to go through.
    • 01:37:18
      Nick, now this is a good time to go through the calendar.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:21
      That is exactly right.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:23
      We thought we would start this conversation as a calendar on a certain time of the year when things should happen or when things are happening.
    • 01:37:30
      So that would, Gary, to get to your specific question, at least to the broader, it's not just legislative, other things.
    • 01:37:36
      This board should expect a cadence of when things should happen.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:40
      I've read this calendar about three times.
    • 01:37:43
      All it is, is formalizing the timeframes for what we already should be doing.
    • 01:37:49
      I didn't see anything in there new.
    • 01:37:52
      We're not going to discuss increasing revenues at any certain time.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:37:57
      Let's let Nick go through it.
    • 01:37:58
      So let me kind of set the framework for what this is and what it is not yet, but should become.
    • 01:38:05
      So the concept behind this is we, the secretary and I were talking and you know,
    • 01:38:11
      We have taken a stance, this administration, of providing you all with as much information as possible as you try and make these decisions and providing it to you in advance of asking you to make those decisions.
    • 01:38:25
      That was an administrative decision that we made.
    • 01:38:28
      Now we've worked with the General Assembly to put some of that in code, but for example, with SmartScale, we decided that scores should be released in January.
    • 01:38:37
      Under the code of Virginia, we could have given them to you in May.
    • 01:38:40
      Now again, we've changed the code to say it must always be in January now, but what we were thinking about is we want to create a calendar that sets the expectation for the next administration.
    • 01:38:51
      And again, I was talking about this yesterday about your, your, the expectations you put on the table for the next administration about the working relationship that you want to have.
    • 01:39:00
      And it's basically saying there are certain things that need to happen and you need to have the expectation of when they're going to happen in advance.
    • 01:39:07
      So there should be no excuse for us to provide materials to you late.
    • 01:39:11
      You should be aware of kind of certain key issues on the calendar in advance of them coming up so you can prepare for those meetings.
    • 01:39:19
      What I've done here is taken a very rough shot at laying out some of the most basic things that need to happen.
    • 01:39:26
      So what's not on here?
    • 01:39:28
      And I think it's something you all will talk about later in your small groups.
    • 01:39:31
      What are some things you should be doing
    • 01:39:34
      that you're not doing today.
    • 01:39:36
      And I think we've just spent 20 minutes talking about one of them which is providing feedback into the legislative agenda shaping, you know, the transportation bills or other things that may be put forward.
    • 01:39:46
      What I would say to you guys is what we want to hear from you today and in the coming months or what are other things that should be on this calendar.
    • 01:39:53
      Let's develop this in a more formal basis.
    • 01:39:55
      I think there's also things related to performance that Ms. Hines kind of raised earlier that aren't on here today.
    • 01:40:00
      because all we've put on here today are things you're currently doing that at a bare minimum these should certainly be happening.
    • 01:40:06
      We'd like to work with you to identify other things that should take place, try and work this into a calendar.
    • 01:40:12
      Have you all adopted as here's our baseline agenda for the next few months?
    • 01:40:16
      There's obviously going to be other things that can be added to that as conditions change but really setting kind of an expectation for the next administration of what are certain actions that need to happen and when do they need to happen.
    • 01:40:29
      I do think this needs to be a kind of back and forth dialogue.
    • 01:40:32
      So for example, input on the legislative agenda would need to come in July because when the executive branch prepares legislation, believe it or not, we start in July and we actually have to have things into the policy office in about a week.
    • 01:40:47
      And so these are not things that can take place in October so those are types of things we can certainly work to add on here but we would want to work with you guys on that to make sure that on the right time frame to work within the existing executive processes that are out there and so if you look at this now
    • 01:41:02
      We've kind of laid out kind of just again key things about you know board action on revised smart scale policy.
    • 01:41:09
      I think generally the commissioner puts out an annual report every November that goes through the conditions of pavements.
    • 01:41:15
      That would be a good time for the board to talk about the conditions of pavements and bridges.
    • 01:41:19
      They've just completed all their surveys in the summer.
    • 01:41:22
      We have all that information.
    • 01:41:23
      It's fresh.
    • 01:41:24
      You're going to be talking about state of good repair dollars and allocating those just a few months after that and so it's giving you the information on where are conditions
    • 01:41:32
      A few months after that, you would start to talk about, are we okay with our current formula for a state of good repair?
    • 01:41:38
      And then a few months after that, you would vote on the project based on the formula that you previously signed off on.
    • 01:41:43
      But it's creating kind of a, I think someone used the word cadence earlier, for the actions of the board where information comes, there's an interim step of action, and then there's a final step of action for the board to really engage on these different topics.
    • 01:41:56
      And I think one of the things that I also really noticed, and I think this is at the Lynchburg, Charlottesville,
    • 01:42:01
      McPherson,
    • 01:42:31
      Are we asked or required to give an annual report?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:02
      We don't give an annual... Well, we got performance measures now under the new legislation.
    • 01:43:08
      The agencies give annual reports a lot to the General Assembly.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 01:43:12
      We don't.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:13
      You do now under performance measures.
    • 01:43:15
      The new legislation we do under SMART SCALE.
    • 01:43:17
      We have an annual report, yes.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:43:19
      Mr. Chairman, the commissioner has his annual report which deals with contracting pavement conditions and bridge conditions as well as several other administrative things that fall within the department and the commissioner's purview.
    • 01:43:32
      I believe DRPT has an annual report on transit ridership and trends and actions that have been taken to increase non-single occupancy, you know, driving or usage of the network.
    • 01:43:43
      You all, too, up until July 1, have not had any required annual reports.
    • 01:43:48
      As the Secretary noted, and I believe I went through the kind of draft surface transportation performance report at, I believe it was the July meeting, and so that is going to be a requirement moving forward annually that you put out that report and update it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:05
      So this calendar here, we should have set it up.
    • 01:44:06
      This is also the basis for you to take, and we're going to have to finish it today,
    • 01:44:12
      and say what are other things like we now know we have the calendar for input into the legislative agenda when that and then we will put on there what would happen when that needs to be discussed just in the timing of things so this is not it's the formal when we have to like for instance I would assume as you know if we discuss we wanted to have something a recommendation to be a resolution that you would give the secretary that you'd have to be considered in the legislative agenda
    • 01:44:42
      And so we've got to set that up in here to go through briefing you or getting your ideas and reporting back to you as to whether or not that would be included based on your input.
    • 01:44:54
      But Gary, to your specific question, this was intent not only to be a calendar, but a thought provoking to say, all right, now what else are we missing and when do we need to slot those in?
    • 01:45:08
      You know, Nick and I, we're influenced by what we do already.
    • 01:45:14
      You know, and we assume, we might be assuming some things, like he mentioned the balance in all these funds.
    • 01:45:22
      Well, we need to just pick a time and just let you all know.
    • 01:45:25
      So those are the type of things, and again, it doesn't have to be finalized today by any stretch, but this was meant to sort of be the beginning, Ms. Hines, of that.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:33
      Can I just ask a question, Mr. Chairman?
    • 01:45:37
      I've been thinking about the access management work that we just did recently, which came about because William raised that as an issue, something he was concerned about, and he talked about it for a while, and then eventually there was a group put together.
    • 01:45:56
      Do we have a formal mechanism or a time of the year when people say, here's something that is
    • 01:46:03
      Bubbling in my district, is anybody else having that issue?
    • 01:46:10
      When do we decide?
    • 01:46:12
      or collectively when something is worthy of further investigation.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:17
      Any workshop and I'll let you go Gary, I mean at the end we can talk about anything so that there's no particular but if there's anything you want to bring up and that's why I saw you know why we've gone to two days some of them don't but we can make you doing one but the intention is we got in that habit so we can set up and we can put that in so
    • 01:46:39
      That's one way to do it.
    • 01:46:40
      Is there any other business in the workshop you might want to bring up for us to present?
    • 01:46:44
      So that's one way to do it.
    • 01:46:45
      Mr. Krasinski?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:46:46
      Well, this could be for maybe small group discussion, but it leads to a question that Alison asked earlier, and that is, I'm a product of a committee structured board with formal standing committees
    • 01:47:02
      who have a chairman of that subcommittee and you rely on that committee to really do the digging on certain topics.
    • 01:47:11
      Now there may be a standing committee on the state of good repair.
    • 01:47:16
      There could be one on strictly finance, one on legislation.
    • 01:47:21
      I could name some, we could all name some, but it is kind of a revamp of how you do things but...
    • 01:47:28
      I'll tell you in the institution that I'm involved with, the committee structure gets rave reviews all the time from the time when we just did the Committee of the Whole and you didn't get a chance to do the digging on specific topics or bring things up because for the sake of a
    • 01:47:50
      The agenda had to be covered.
    • 01:47:51
      So I think as we debate or talk about small group discussions, we should at least give some merit to some formal committees that could be initiated for the future.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:05
      I wouldn't immediately be opposed to that idea, but I do think there's, I do think this board is set up and established in the Constitution very differently than where that may
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:18
      Let me make a couple of quick comments to that in that vein.
    • 01:48:24
      Part of this comes down to how much time you guys want to spend.
    • 01:48:28
      You are not a paid committee.
    • 01:48:29
      You are not a paid member.
    • 01:48:31
      And yeah, I don't mean that to be...
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:48:33
      I just want to be... And that's true.
    • 01:48:35
      In my case, it's different.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:37
      No, no, I point out that I was going to let this conversation go, but I wanted to get to
    • 01:48:42
      You guys can make this a full-time job if you want to.
    • 01:48:45
      I mean, that's, you know, you really can.
    • 01:48:48
      I know you've got to go to NVTA and all the different meetings.
    • 01:48:52
      I know, I mean, I see you in the news.
    • 01:48:54
      I know you're out there.
    • 01:48:55
      You're the eyes and ears.
    • 01:48:56
      So it's not just here.
    • 01:48:58
      So that's the other flip side that the very practical side of.
    • 01:49:02
      is where do you draw that line between using the agencies, using the secretary's office, and, you know, doing something on your own.
    • 01:49:13
      I mean, and I don't mean that, I'm not saying no, I'm just saying.
    • 01:49:16
      But I think to Mr. Williams' comment, that's really a consideration because, I mean, I've noticed we have a couple members, I mean, it's kind of hard for them to do the two days a month.
    • 01:49:25
      And this board, and I will tell you,
    • 01:49:29
      People now, when they find out how much work it is, many of them say, not for me.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:37
      I'm not giving any more.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:44
      This all sounds good in theory, but there's a very real practical matter.
    • 01:49:50
      We understand it's a citizen board.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:52
      Mr. Secretary, I would just say one of the reasons I raised the question I raised is because I think we should be focusing on those things which we think will make the greatest difference for the Commonwealth.
    • 01:50:05
      And if it can all be driven by any individual bringing up something and eventually it gets to be a study as opposed to us having a conversation about how many places might this affect, which I think we have to have with all of us in the room.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:21
      Yeah, Mr. Tonkin, I'll come at you, Nick.
    • Alison DeTuncqMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:23
      The only thing I'd like to add to the committee structure is we have had committees.
    • 01:50:26
      Some of them have been very short-term in nature and some of them I'm not even clear myself whether it's now a standing committee of the board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:33
      There's no standing committees.
    • 01:50:35
      They're all been set up for, now we tend to function more with the rail subcommittee because it's something going on all the time, but there's really none that's a standing committee.
    • 01:50:44
      It's all, I've approached it more ad hoc, except this one more ad hoc than more because she's used it yet.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:50
      Well, and part of the reason we established the real committee as well was because there used to be a real advisory board that was, I guess, I think dissolved in the previous administration.
    • 01:51:01
      But we wanted to have an opportunity to have a group that'll do a deep dive with us on a number of items because so much of it is very specific and does require policy input from the board.
    • 01:51:13
      As Shannon mentioned before, it helps us a lot to have these things vetted by a smaller group so that when they do come to you, you all have the opportunity to tell everybody else on the board, hey, we've already looked at this.
    • 01:51:25
      We've given input on this because some of the items we work on are so specific and different from the regular highway related work that you do.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:45
      I don't think that's how anybody else would look at us.
    • 01:51:58
      If you want to know about transportation, talk to the CTB.
    • 01:52:00
      They're the leaders in this state.
    • 01:52:03
      Because that's when you start taking the leadership on issues.
    • 01:52:06
      I'm not sure that's a role that the legislature ever looked at.
    • 01:52:11
      Individually, yes.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:12
      I think there's a move in the legislature that's moving more towards that.
    • 01:52:17
      Yeah, I mean, I can tell you accountability.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:19
      I see a lot more accountability.
    • 01:52:22
      I don't see them trying to
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:23
      Let me put it this way, Mr. Williams.
    • 01:52:25
      There were plenty of attacks trying to get specifics, and the leadership killed it.
    • 01:52:31
      In other words, I want this project, that would have defeated the whole purpose.
    • 01:52:35
      I agree with you.
    • 01:52:36
      I don't think it's seen as the leaders and the only thing to do, but I do think that they are making sure that we are using their dollars the wisest, and what are the consequences for them to make, you know, in there.
    • 01:52:50
      I could change that.
    • 01:52:52
      Yeah, on that.
    • 01:52:53
      But there is this, to be honest with you, there are some legislators that don't like it because they can't no longer cut a deal.
    • 01:53:02
      And so that is, this is a real, this is a great discussion, but this is a very real, what Gary brought up, Miss Hiney brought up, and Marty same thing, where you rely on the agencies, you know, to provide the information,
    • 01:53:22
      I think we really got to focus on exactly what you said, Ms. Hines.
    • 01:53:34
      What are the two, three, or two or three biggest things that are we moving the needle on?
    • 01:53:40
      And that's really, I mean, I can tell you, back to your comment, Marty, you're exactly right.
    • 01:53:45
      Accountability is not, there's no question the General Assembly is looking at you to make sure that these monies, where they were used and were they used properly.
    • 01:53:57
      That is no question about that.
    • 01:54:00
      So whether it's more concentration on finance or audit and Mr. Kilpatrick and I have been talking a lot about that, you know, because you got these dual relationships as to, you know, the auditors work for Charlie and I mean, but on the other hand, they report, you know, I mean, so they've got to think through that, but those are account of, you know,
    • 01:54:21
      You know, accountability and are we moving the needle?
    • 01:54:25
      I don't think there's any discussion.
    • 01:54:26
      The General Assembly sees that as why they delegated this authority.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:31
      I think a perfect opportunity is if we're doing Swarovski, we've got a policy, but we still have a codified section that we have to follow, but they gave us some leeway to do the policy.
    • 01:54:43
      But if we saw something next year in the codified section,
    • 01:54:49
      that we're like this is you know this is kind of hurting what you guys want I think it's absolutely appropriate then that we as a group Aubrey right you take it to the legislature that's a perfect opportunity that's right but that's just trying to fix the things they've given us now advocating for them to do all new things like raise money that's where I think we could just we should draw the line
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:12
      I think that is a probably between advocacy versus information is I think is right.
    • 01:55:20
      Nick you had something you want to say?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:55:21
      To Ms. Hines' kind of point earlier, I do think something that we haven't really started to do but the Assembly has told you all they now expect you to do is they've told you they want you to set performance targets.
    • 01:55:34
      For each of these measures, and so if you're talking about what are the policies that do the greatest good to the greatest parts of the Commonwealth, you know, I think we should have a real discussion with the board about how do you want to see this information on where things are today and where we think we can go in the future, and how do we report to you on progress, areas of at-risk, and at that point, that to me would be where you all would challenge us
    • 01:55:56
      as staff where you see areas where you might not be seeing the progress you want saying you need to give me three ideas for us to consider, tell us what you think they'll do and then we can try and as a board take action on those.
    • 01:56:07
      But I do think the assembly really is expecting us now that we've started the SMART SCALE over picking projects, let's monitor overall
    • 01:56:15
      Are things getting better?
    • 01:56:17
      And really dig deep into some of those issues.
    • 01:56:19
      And so, you know, there's those five categories.
    • 01:56:21
      There's, you know, congestion, safety, condition, and other areas.
    • 01:56:24
      And I think there's an opportunity for us to provide that information to you all in a manner where you can see trends, see problem areas, see at-risk areas, and where there's good performance.
    • 01:56:34
      And that might also help us provide you all with policy recommendations so it's not a one-off from a member saying, hey, I'm driving on this road and I hate this stoplight.
    • 01:56:42
      I don't think he was wrong, per se.
    • 01:56:44
      And what he was doing there and I appreciate his vigilance in raising the issue but I think you know a more rational way for that perhaps to come up would be hey we don't have congestion on these roads where we have limited access points and there aren't interstates nearby perhaps we need to make sure we have a policy to preserve that high level of performance into the future so they don't become like certain other areas that aren't functioning as well.
    • 01:57:07
      And so I do think there's a real opportunity within this new requirement the General Assembly has given you all, which is to set these targets in these areas of performance and to annually report on whether or not you're making progress.
    • 01:57:19
      There's real opportunities there as we look at trends, you know, good areas, bad areas, and at-risk situations for you to put in place policies that go beyond the investments you make through the Six-Year Program.
    • 01:57:32
      but I think as staff we also need to start coming to you with those things and saying here are problems, here are some potential treatments and at the end of the day you can set those policies if you deem them to be appropriate or not.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:43
      So you know we're going to continue going to 1030 and then take our break at 1030 because I think that's a bet they'll give you more of a chance if you want to go to the rooms closer to the time and then start the presentation by some
    • 01:57:58
      of our, some survey results which I think we'll add to this and that because we've got a few more things to go through so just letting you know where we are.
    • 01:58:05
      Uh, Scott.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:05
      Mr. Secretary, Nick, could you just repeat the last sentence about staff bringing the recommendations to the board?
    • 01:58:10
      I mean, I really think that is the most important part of this from a standpoint
    • 01:58:13
      of us taking new ideas and then acting on them.
    • 01:58:17
      You know, clearly we all have full schedules and work diligently in the pursuit of our responsibilities as board members, but things that you've brought forth during the last three to four years have been really insightful and helped us make good decisions.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:58:30
      And I think to Mrs. Hines' point, though, I don't want us coming to you all with one-off policy type of recommendation.
    • 01:58:37
      So, you know, again, we have performance measures in five category areas.
    • 01:58:42
      You're supposed to be setting targets.
    • 01:58:44
      I think we should...
    • 01:58:45
      There's an opportunity, and again, you all need to provide us with input as to how you want to have these discussions and say it's one on safety.
    • 01:58:51
      We could come in and look at where all the fatalities have been for the last five years on our roadways.
    • 01:58:57
      We could map them, identify certain trends or commonalities between those, determine, you know, are there ones that can be fixed with policy and there may be some that just require investments and we need to go to smart scale and the safety program to address those, but in other areas, you know, we may see that, hey, we have, you know,
    • 01:59:16
      groups of pedestrians dying in certain areas perhaps we need to look at are the multimodal design guns being implemented by the localities in these areas where they're planning dense development we've given them the tools and the flexibility but is it actually playing out when those facilities get built and that could be a policy item where you as a board could say we wish to further enhance or push this concept because we see a problem that can be fixed by policy not money.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:40
      The description you just provided is a perfect example of insights we won't have.
    • 01:59:43
      I mean that granularity of knowledge of fatalities in this case and potential offsets and policies that we could create, we're not going to have that information without input from the staff.
    • 01:59:54
      So it's a very synergistic need between staff and board recommendations.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:59:59
      I also think, and I mean this in a good way, so don't...
    • 02:00:02
      There needs to be some tension where you've set some expectations on this calendar that we're coming to you with certain things, which is going to make us go say, OK, well, we know in four months we have to have the safety performance briefing with the board.
    • 02:00:16
      Let's start looking at this data.
    • 02:00:17
      Are we seeing certain trends?
    • 02:00:19
      What are other states doing?
    • 02:00:20
      What are other regions doing?
    • 02:00:21
      Could we use those here and come to you with packages of, you know, here good, here's bad, here's meh?
    • 02:00:29
      and then here's some things that you know have worked well in other places that may or may not be applicable here but it's up to a policy board to kind of look at and we should give you our feedback we should prompt it
    • 02:00:38
      I think you need to have that prompt.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:40
      I think it's a healthy tension.
    • 02:00:41
      So what we're talking about is going from a transaction-based to a process-based look, because it's everything we've really done, if you look at it, we've been very transaction-based.
    • 02:00:50
      Well, it's a project, we've got to do this, we've got to do that, versus the process or are we feeding information for this board to do the deliberations?
    • 02:00:57
      You had something, Ms. Brown.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:59
      No, no, as you're speaking, I'm wondering at this point in helping make some of the decisions or, you know, how we want the input to be presented to us
    • 02:01:08
      How are we monitoring the performance of these factors?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:01:14
      Talking through all that today might take up the rest of your time.
    • 02:01:16
      I can send you all some information on it, but I think
    • 02:01:20
      what I would say to you all is for the next several months this team is here to work with you all to try and shape processes that work for you into the future to try and work on some of these issues that's why we're trying to start these discussions now in August where we still have four and a half months left to really set the table for moving forward because this is
    • 02:01:41
      This is a new construct.
    • 02:01:43
      Again, it was all driven by the administration in years past.
    • 02:01:47
      And again, this is something that's done with the agencies and their expertise coming back to you all.
    • 02:01:52
      But we also, I think again, attention's not a bad word here.
    • 02:01:55
      There needs to be that kind of healthy tension where you guys are saying, I want to see this information.
    • 02:02:00
      You need to tell me what's happening there.
    • 02:02:01
      And then we need to try and come up with results.
    • 02:02:03
      And again, it may be that this requires a $20 million investment.
    • 02:02:07
      Let's see what happens in SmartScale.
    • 02:02:08
      Or maybe there are some policy treatments we can try and implement that might work here.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:13
      Let me just write your answer to your question.
    • 02:02:15
      There are some things that we can point to.
    • 02:02:18
      Charlie can point to the secondary road improvements and pavement and all that.
    • 02:02:24
      That's something that he can get a good handle on.
    • 02:02:27
      I would dare say if you went to anybody and asked on this board or anybody else, are we improving congestion in Virginia?
    • 02:02:34
      I would dare say we don't know the answer.
    • 02:02:36
      We think we're doing projects, but we really don't know the answer.
    • 02:02:40
      On a project by project bay, we can look at 95 express lanes.
    • 02:02:44
      They appear to be improving it.
    • 02:02:45
      There's free-flowing traffic in that, but that's the first time.
    • 02:02:48
      I mean, this is really what we're talking about is what is it, you know, Charlie can tell us the condition of the roads.
    • 02:02:55
      It's much different to say, are we promoting economic development?
    • 02:02:59
      Have we moved the needle?
    • 02:03:00
      Have we reduced congestion?
    • 02:03:02
      I mentioned on 29, we really won't know for a few years what the real impact of that is.
    • 02:03:07
      Although I will set out, I'm comfortable that Berkmeyer's almost the impact the bypass was going to have because it's almost as long as what was going to be done in the bypass.
    • 02:03:16
      But the point is, is that that's really what we're coming to.
    • 02:03:20
      What is the process and the information that we really start tackling those real issues
    • 02:03:25
      Those things that really matter.
    • 02:03:27
      Are we improving these hard-to-divine issues?
    • 02:03:33
      And I will tell you, I don't think we've done that in the past.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:37
      I see really only three areas where we can routinely measure success.
    • 02:03:47
      Bridge condition and pavement condition and we can pretty clearly show the investment.
    • 02:03:53
      We can show the overall performance and we can show performance district by district in terms of conditions.
    • 02:03:59
      And then in the area of safety,
    • 02:04:01
      through our HSIP, the Highway Safety Improvement Program and the statewide safety plan, we can show various things that we do, the countermeasures we call them.
    • 02:04:13
      It could be guard rail, it could be rumble strips, it could be striping or could be turn lanes and things like that.
    • 02:04:20
      But we can show, we have enough data to sometimes be able to show that we can see a crash reduction by implementing certain things.
    • 02:04:30
      A lot of that work though is done outside of smart scale projects.
    • 02:04:33
      So what we're, you know, we're talking here about smart scale projects and safety being a component.
    • 02:04:39
      We can, but we can talk at a statewide level if we are to install a certain number of miles of edge line rumble strips, we can, we have some predictive measures in terms of crash reductions.
    • 02:04:50
      So we can do some of that.
    • 02:04:51
      But in the smart scale world, the factors in smart scale, you're really, you know, you're approving a project at a time and the question really is, can I start to link these individual improvements together on a corridor or on a system-wide basis and by doing a dozen of these projects along the 29 corridor or the 81 corridor,
    • 02:05:15
      Have I improved accessibility?
    • 02:05:18
      Have I reduced congestion?
    • 02:05:20
      Have I done those things?
    • 02:05:21
      And we just... Too early.
    • 02:05:23
      To date we really have not done that on a system basis or even a...
    • 02:05:27
      even a corridor basis.
    • 02:05:28
      I think the 95 corridor is an opportunity where we can show some results but it really only fits within that corridor.
    • 02:05:37
      You know, once you get off the end of it down below Fredericksburg, we don't, there's no, you know, we haven't done anything.
    • 02:05:43
      So I do think this is a different place to be and frankly around the country.
    • 02:05:51
      There isn't a lot of it that's done.
    • 02:05:53
      You have some long-range planning stuff but really,
    • 02:05:56
      McPherson Jr.
    • 02:06:14
      I frankly think we're doing a really good job of that.
    • 02:06:17
      We might find though, gosh, you know, this particular input is taking us, it's not really giving us the benefit that we expected.
    • 02:06:26
      I kind of doubt that.
    • 02:06:27
      I think this will be more of confirming that the path we're on is a good path with this data-driven process.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:35
      I agree with that wholeheartedly.
    • 02:06:38
      I think one of the challenges we face though is decisions we make this year in SMART SCALE before we can actually get performance metrics maybe a decade from now.
    • 02:06:46
      So things that we'll put in place now, our successors will use as tools hopefully to analyze the success of the decisions we made years or decades before and that's one of the challenges we face.
    • 02:06:57
      It's not going to happen quickly.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:59
      No, that's why it's got to be process, not transaction based in that regard and evaluations.
    • 02:07:05
      And we haven't even, you know, we haven't talked to Ms. Mitchell about, I mean, I could ask her, are we, how's freight movements in the Commonwealth where it was two years ago?
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:15
      The huge factor.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:16
      I mean, those are the type of things, but see, and Charlie made the point, we are one of the very few states, and we are, I'm sure the leader,
    • 02:07:25
      that are having this type of conversation because they've let limited resources stommy them.
    • 02:07:35
      We've not accepted that.
    • 02:07:36
      We're saying, okay, whatever resources we got, we're going to measure what we're doing with them.
    • 02:07:43
      And I would say, and I pointed this out at the last board meeting, I think a big question we're going to see is, is the pot big enough to even move these big things?
    • 02:07:51
      I don't know.
    • 02:07:53
      You know, I don't know.
    • 02:07:54
      I mean, that's another thing that it's going to take time to develop.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:00
      That suggests that our work in the next couple months is adding to SMART SCALE the reporting mechanisms that we need that will continue beyond the tenure of board members that are currently part of this process and is specific and detailed the way it is possible at this point.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:15
      That's why Chad and Margie and that whole, that's going to be a big part.
    • 02:08:18
      It's not just scoring.
    • 02:08:19
      It's now going to become the evaluation.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:24
      Can I follow up on the point you're making, which is so true, we're so early in the process, but you know, you look at 29, the changes there, I mean, are there ways for us to measure progress that doesn't take a decade?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:39
      Technically, tax receipts are up significantly.
    • 02:08:42
      I think some.
    • 02:08:42
      There certainly will be some.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:43
      Timing, are there some things?
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:46
      I think Virginia has examples too.
    • 02:08:48
      I mean, we're going to open those hot lanes on 66 in December.
    • 02:08:52
      What are we going to measure?
    • 02:08:54
      What can we measure on some of these other things?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:56
      Those are pretty easy.
    • 02:08:57
      We set them already up, the measurements we're going to do.
    • 02:08:59
      I mean, quite frankly, inside the beltway and throughput, that's something we're going to get a handle on pretty well, pretty soon.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:09:08
      It is, but I also think the product you've just raised, Ms. Hynes, one, we certainly can track all those things, but there's a policy component embedded in 66, and so I've heard a lot of you talk about SmartScale.
    • 02:09:18
      I would just suggest strongly that
    • 02:09:22
      We know we can't solve this problem with just the resources we have and so I think the real challenge back to staff to the agencies and then in turn ultimately to you all is how do we augment the cash we have with policies tools available to make these things improve long term because I can tell you the hope the the concept of 66 inside is not just that we're you know putting new buses and doing it's the tolling and the demand management will long term
    • 02:09:49
      H. M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown Jr.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:10:13
      Fralin, John M. Brown, John M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown Jr., John M. Brown Jr.,
    • 02:10:43
      over many, many months and with many local and elected officials at the legislature.
    • 02:10:50
      So these are not all perfect, but we got the compromise.
    • 02:10:57
      And same thing on 29.
    • 02:11:00
      Here's another part.
    • 02:11:01
      There's some things that we're, and look, I'm, my background's financial.
    • 02:11:05
      I'm a big believer in Dr. Deming, who are, you know, Deming and if you can't measure it, then why are you doing it?
    • 02:11:11
      But on the other hand, a lot of the reasons are just that people feel better, and I will tell you anecdotally in Charlottesville,
    • 02:11:18
      I mean we're getting just rave reviews about people getting around.
    • 02:11:23
      Tax receipts are up and that's what I used as an example.
    • 02:11:26
      You go look at, of course they were up.
    • 02:11:28
      You couldn't get there.
    • 02:11:29
      Now people can get there.
    • 02:11:31
      And now they want to look at hydraulics.
    • 02:11:34
      And hydraulics.
    • 02:11:34
      So there's another part of this that's not all just numbers.
    • 02:11:38
      But it is about are we moving those things.
    • 02:11:44
      So I'm just pointing out it's not just all black and white.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:48
      But to Shannon's point.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:49
      Yeah.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:50
      I think there's a lot of information we can gain in your term.
    • 02:11:52
      That's right.
    • 02:11:53
      And 29 is a great example of the things we're doing.
    • 02:11:55
      But ultimately, this board looks at system-wide approaches and big picture, as Nick has pointed out, policies that have a macro-level impact.
    • 02:12:03
      Certainly, you know, we can gain insights in the next couple of years on things we're doing today, but are we really moving the needle from a system-wide perspective in the approaches that we're taking, the policies we've put in place?
    • 02:12:13
      So it's a combination of both.
    • 02:12:15
      But we'll get a lot of little prompts along the way from the situations that you've just described.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:20
      Mr. Connors, we're going to take a couple more and then we're going to break and then we're going to small groups.
    • 02:12:26
      I think this would be a good time to continue.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:29
      The committee has been encouraging, not directing, we've been encouraging staff to come up with a data portal and they have and we've soft launched the data portal.
    • 02:12:38
      It's on your point of view.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:12:43
      They've enjoyed every minute of it.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:12:45
      We've got a data portal that may help us have this conversation about the short-term and long-term consequences.
    • 02:12:50
      of our actions.
    • 02:12:51
      And I hope we can have a presentation at some point about how maybe we can use that data portal to make better decisions in real time.
    • 02:13:01
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:05
      We're going to take a quick break, but we're going to go and have some survey results, which I think may add up more.
    • 02:13:11
      Some of the things that you all brought up already are going to be brought up in the next group discussion, or next part of the discussion.
    • 02:13:19
      but I think it's we'll sort of take this break but keep in mind we are doing something here not only the Commonwealth's history but as Charlie pointed out we're being asked all over whether it's AASHTO or I mean people are looking at
    • 02:13:40
      what we're doing uh in here so i mean i i want to keep it clear this is there is no right or wrong there is no i don't have a path you know we have some best practices gary that you you know that we can look at other boards but as we want to start off we may not be exactly like other board and as marty's pointed out you know you know we we're in a political environment
    • 02:14:03
      and I can't stress how much that changes the equation.
    • 02:14:07
      Your private business and committees is a lot different than committees and how we relate so I don't have, I'm going to make it clear, we don't have the actual answer template.
    • 02:14:18
      We have the direction we need to go in and the opportunity and I think what's exciting is we, you know, we're all part of this in that but at the end of the day what we want to get to is are the actions we've taken
    • 02:14:33
      Are we getting results and however you define them more so in macro than on just specific projects because that's never been looked at really in the Commonwealth.
    • 02:14:43
      I've never been measured.
    • 02:14:43
      I shouldn't say that.
    • 02:14:44
      I guess it's been looked at, Nick, but we've never been able to measure it.
    • 02:14:47
      Can we get there in that regard?
    • 02:14:48
      So in that or anywhere.
    • 02:14:50
      So the last thing I'll point out and that is where if you look at the Congress, the administration started with under President Obama and now President Trump.
    • 02:15:00
      I mean, it's all about
    • 02:15:02
      The recognition now, we don't have the political will.
    • 02:15:06
      These are the resources we got.
    • 02:15:08
      It's going to be outcome based.
    • 02:15:11
      There's going to be competition for monies.
    • 02:15:13
      So the more we can get on top of this and prove, I think the better chances we're going to have for what's coming.
    • 02:15:20
      Because at the federal level, it appears it's going to be a lot less granting, a lot less entitlements, and much more competition for grants.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:30
      And that's it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:31
      Okay, it's 1030.
    • 02:15:33
      I think 11 o'clock is checkout, so if you want to take about 15 minutes, we'll get back together and start the presentation from our outside guests.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:33:12
      Yes.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:33
      Guys, why don't we find our seats.
    • 02:35:34
      We're going to go ahead and continue on.
    • 02:35:41
      Part of our analysis was to take a look at where some of you guys think we are and just some different things that we're pleased to have today.
    • 02:35:52
      Jim Burke and Linda Pierce here that are going through some survey results and lead us through some suggestions for improvements around tables.
    • 02:36:00
      So welcome very much to you guys this morning.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:36:03
      Thanks for being here.
    • 02:36:05
      Well, we often run into the CTB when we're at Boar's Head doing something else very often.
    • 02:36:11
      And last time we were there, we were welcomed into the meeting, which was very nice.
    • 02:36:16
      We didn't belong there.
    • 02:36:16
      We were just nearby.
    • 02:36:18
      But we always thought, gosh, what a great group of people.
    • 02:36:19
      Everybody's so friendly and warm.
    • 02:36:21
      So we're glad to be with you this morning.
    • 02:36:23
      We're in from VCU from the Wilder School at the Performance Management Group there.
    • 02:36:27
      And we know you had,
    • 02:36:30
      So some of you had access to the survey.
    • 02:36:32
      It was very late in coming.
    • 02:36:34
      So we're going to go over the responses in terms of what we got, but we'd like to take some time to make sure we hear from everybody.
    • 02:36:40
      So we'll be looking at what was heard.
    • 02:36:42
      but also we'd like to hear from everybody and then we'll move forward into the rest of the afternoon.
    • 02:36:49
      Linda and I are in doing some work at Stanton.
    • 02:36:52
      We've got to run back to our client before the end of the day.
    • 02:36:55
      So we're going to try and compress as much as possible, be efficient without skipping important details because we have to head out of Dodge, Miller and 230 to get back to Stanton.
    • 02:37:07
      So.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:37:07
      Okay.
    • 02:37:08
      Well, hello everybody.
    • 02:37:09
      It's good to be here with you.
    • 02:37:10
      As Jim said, the survey went out pretty late, but we appreciate those folks that did receive it and that did give us some feedback in that.
    • 02:37:19
      So we're just going to go through this today and then give you opportunity for those who did not receive the survey or didn't have time to complete it to kind of weigh in to.
    • 02:37:27
      But just via the response rate, it went out to 20.
    • 02:37:31
      There were 24 invitations to the survey.
    • 02:37:33
      We had 12 responses, so it was a 50 percent response rate.
    • 02:37:37
      It went out to current.
    • 02:37:38
      transportation board members and some past members so we had nine that are currently serving on the board and three past members respond to it.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:37:51
      With the five-point scale going from poor to excellent, CTB rated itself overall at 3.86, which is really good.
    • 02:37:59
      What you don't want to see is, oh, we're doing great.
    • 02:38:02
      We're at a 4.8 out of 5.
    • 02:38:04
      We're so good.
    • 02:38:05
      Then it kind of invites the question, well, why are we coming?
    • 02:38:09
      So 3.86 suggests a fair amount of satisfaction and also room for improvement.
    • 02:38:15
      That's what we like to see.
    • 02:38:16
      We do 360 feedback constantly, and that's right around the zone.
    • 02:38:20
      when we look at individual feedback and when we look at organizational feedback as well where we like to see things.
    • 02:38:26
      Because we can all improve, every organization, every board we work with.
    • 02:38:30
      The boards we worry about most are the boards that say everything is perfect, we do everything great, even though the word compliance just hasn't come up in the last 10 years, so.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:38:42
      Okay, regarding a summary of some of the comments on the effectiveness, overall they were very positive.
    • 02:38:49
      They said that the recent changes to the board have been very beneficial, so some of the work that you've already done to try to organize yourself and to become more effective is starting to reap the benefits of that according to the comments.
    • 02:38:59
      There were some suggestions that one-day meetings could increase the participation of the two or multi-day meetings made it a little bit difficult for some people to come.
    • 02:39:08
      There were also a couple of comments that said that the CTB was beginning to collectively understand and agree to their role in the new changing environment.
    • 02:39:17
      So that speaks I think to some of the discussions that you all have had about what kind of board are you, what should you be doing, how should you be working together, and what's around the corner as we look toward the future of transportation needs.
    • 02:39:30
      There were a couple of comments that said that they'd like to see the board operate on a strategic level to be thinking strategically about the trends in the future, the things that might be coming up in the way, and to spend a little bit more time on those discussions as opposed to perhaps some of the other things.
    • 02:39:46
      And then finally, as always is expected, there's comments on the timeliness of materials.
    • 02:39:52
      There was a general satisfaction with the timeliness of the material, although there was also some statements that
    • 02:39:58
      The more time we have to digest things and read them ahead of time, the better it is.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:40:03
      These are all pretty standard responses from most boards.
    • 02:40:06
      We have worked with many boards that the only ones who want more days are the ones who are getting paid by the day to be on the board.
    • 02:40:14
      But we get feedback all the time that they want the materials earlier.
    • 02:40:18
      but yours is within a pretty good range again compared to some other boards where they get thrown materials at the meeting with five minutes to read complex financial reports and then make a decision and you know none of us does our best work that way so sometimes people are concerned about how do we get material in light of FOIA to people beforehand for the right amount of thought that's needed but that's what we'll be talking about somewhat today when we talk about goals that you all have and clarity about what you want.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:40:49
      We're just going to roll through this, but if you have any questions, we're happy to take them as we continue.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:40:53
      I have a question, I have a comment.
    • 02:40:56
      On the one-day meeting, and this is what you were asking about earlier, Ms. Hines, is that it would be difficult to have a one-day meeting and really explore these thought-provoking measures.
    • 02:41:09
      So I just throw that out there.
    • 02:41:10
      When I first came on the board for the first six months, we had two day meetings.
    • 02:41:15
      I actually think the dinners, and I think your suggestion, Dixon, about having spouses once in a while would be great.
    • 02:41:22
      But I mean, having dinners where you have the chance to interact and get to know each other is good.
    • 02:41:29
      And one day sessions tend to be very much dictated as to
    • 02:41:35
      You've got to get this done and get out.
    • 02:41:39
      So I've seen it both ways and based on where I think we're headed, I just point out I would say it would be difficult to do this in a day and that stuff so.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:41:50
      When doing more strategic work, that downtime like dinner, some unwinding time, get the ideas flowing, capture those ideas in the next morning and then make sure that they're addressed at the next meeting is really critical.
    • 02:42:05
      because very often boards will say we have these great strategic conversations.
    • 02:42:09
      We didn't really capture much of it and then we have these same conversations year after year but we don't see progress on a strategic perspective.
    • 02:42:15
      So we would agree with the secretary that some unwinding time is necessary to bring out the best in strategic thinking if you want the board to be more strategic.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 02:42:25
      I didn't make this point.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:42:29
      What I really enjoy is to have the time, and I know we're never in a position where we're supposed to direct anybody that works at VDOT to do anything, but I've found the most valuable time I have at the dinners and stuff is an opportunity to talk to some of the staff people that are, you know, they're specialists in what the subject was and be able to get, because I get great input from those folks.
    • 02:42:53
      And so I would actually like to see, you know, we see those familiar faces.
    • 02:42:58
      We see them all the time.
    • 02:42:59
      I'd like to see you sprinkle in a few different ones.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:02
      That is a great point.
    • 02:43:03
      That is one thing at the Port Board that happens.
    • 02:43:05
      We have a dinner and every dinner there's a group of different senior management.
    • 02:43:12
      that we spread around.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:15
      I love the faces we see.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:17
      Yeah, no, but I mean, Jennifer and Charlie, maybe that's something.
    • 02:43:21
      So maybe we work that out and, you know, maybe it's not 20, but I think they bring four or five different people each time and they introduce them to the board and say, this person's in charge of Virginia National Gateway Terminal.
    • 02:43:35
      And you just, no presentation.
    • 02:43:36
      You just have a chance to eat with them at dinner.
    • 02:43:38
      So I think that's a great idea.
    • 02:43:40
      Yeah.
    • 02:43:40
      And I think that would help a lot.
    • 02:43:42
      Yeah.
    • 02:43:43
      So why don't we...
    • 02:43:44
      Done.
    • 02:43:44
      You're making some...
    • 02:43:46
      Done.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:47
      Yeah.
    • 02:43:47
      Done.
    • 02:43:47
      Okay.
    • 02:43:47
      Great idea.
    • 02:43:47
      Okay.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:48
      Good.
    • 02:43:49
      Wonderful.
    • 02:43:49
      Yeah.
    • 02:43:49
      That's great.
    • 02:43:51
      That's great.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:51
      One good idea for the day.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:43:55
      That's a great idea.
    • 02:43:56
      Excellent.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:43:56
      Relax, Marty.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:44:00
      Okay.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:44:00
      The next question... We'll hear the 10 other bad ones.
    • 02:44:03
      I'm not bringing those up.
    • 02:44:04
      I'm just kidding.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:44:06
      The next question regarded satisfaction with the project selection process of SMART SCALE and again on a five point scale and you can see the scale on the bottom, five excellent, four great, etc.
    • 02:44:16
      It came in at 4.29 by the 50 percent respondents that we received.
    • 02:44:21
      The majority rated it excellent or great and there were no fair or poor measures.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:44:27
      So basically in terms of what we're looking at, the changes that have been implemented to refine the scoring process seem to be adding.
    • 02:44:34
      This is one of the... some of the comments.
    • 02:44:36
      to it.
    • 02:44:37
      Is there anything else for those who rated it good as opposed to great or excellent?
    • 02:44:41
      Is there anything else you'd want to see in that?
    • 02:44:43
      And we can discuss that more specifically just in terms of the refinement of that.
    • 02:44:47
      But again, a high score in terms of that area.
    • 02:44:50
      In terms of policy changes, you know, this is going to be key to I think our discussion just before lunch and afterwards.
    • 02:44:58
      This item, this comment that came up and we'd like to solicit some more comments probably is not going to take anybody by surprise here.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:45:07
      Moving on, the next question regarded your meetings, kind of your meeting management and what is going well and we heard lots of comments that there was a great exchange in between the board members and staff so that kind of reiterates the comment over here and to the extent that we can exchange the breadth of the staff that would be wonderful.
    • 02:45:28
      Members, you guys gave yourself a pat on the back for being well prepared, very knowledgeable and lots of good conversations that were respectful and civil.
    • 02:45:36
      and Open Dialogue and Transparency.
    • 02:45:38
      So there's a score of an A on that one.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:45:43
      Now the between meetings is always key because again people get together for board meetings as you all know from your experience.
    • 02:45:51
      Good things can happen.
    • 02:45:52
      What happens in between the meetings is sometimes as important as what happens at the meetings because the follow through, the movement of things forward,
    • 02:46:01
      is important.
    • 02:46:02
      So as long as you've got this open communication between agencies and members and we know it's hard operating within the public sector with all that you have to be mindful of as opposed to a different kind of board.
    • 02:46:12
      but that is good.
    • 02:46:14
      The staff is excellent about reaching out and prepping for meetings, something that we do not always hear.
    • 02:46:18
      I can tell you that quite a bit and probably from your board experience, late information, where are we meeting, what's going on, those things are not provided.
    • 02:46:27
      Still, if there's something you would like to see improved in that area to take it to the next level, that would be a good thing to discuss.
    • 02:46:35
      Each person, there's some people who need things way in advance, want lots of contact,
    • 02:46:39
      Other people say, just give me a holler the week before and I'm good with that.
    • 02:46:44
      Information and reports are shared in a timely manner.
    • 02:46:46
      Again, something that we don't hear all the time in terms of central offices being responsive to questions.
    • 02:46:52
      Again, not something we hear all the time.
    • 02:46:55
      Calendar dates are firm.
    • 02:46:56
      We would expect that in terms of basic board structure.
    • 02:46:59
      We do have a few suggestions as we move into the board structure for things you might want to consider to strengthen and deepen the CTB's influence.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:47:12
      OK, what could be improved at or between meetings?
    • 02:47:15
      That was a question that was posed.
    • 02:47:17
      There were some comments on the importance of the board members staying up to date on current information.
    • 02:47:23
      Specifically, it was mentioned that there's some daily briefings, I think agency briefings, that you can subscribe to and that that was very helpful in keeping on track of the current things that are happening.
    • 02:47:35
      Is that correct?
    • 02:47:36
      Daily briefings?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:37
      It's not a briefing.
    • 02:47:37
      It's a summary of news clippings across.
    • 02:47:42
      And do you guys get that?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:44
      You know, I get the VPAT clips, but I don't get the ones targeted to transportation.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:52
      So we'll do that.
    • 02:47:54
      You'll get an email every day.
    • 02:47:55
      I just was reading them.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:57
      Except Marty.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:58
      Marty would prefer not to have it every day.
    • 02:48:05
      We also receive AASHTO at the National Level League
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:29
      They have a daily thing that comes out and can provide you with stuff you may or may not be interested in, but from around the country regarding transportation.
    • 02:48:39
      And that's easy to send.
    • 02:48:40
      That's easy to send.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:48:42
      If you'd like it, you can have it.
    • 02:48:43
      I don't find that one as useful, but then again, we're more than happy to send it on.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:48:51
      And that comment and the board's investment in keeping up to date on the issues really gladdens our heart because, again, we don't always see that with boards.
    • 02:49:00
      It's kind of like they come to their meetings, a few months go by, they read what they need to, and then they convene again.
    • 02:49:06
      But the fact that you're asking for more information and acknowledging the importance of kind of being a subject matter expert, so to speak, on transportation issues is really wonderful.
    • 02:49:17
      There were a couple of comments that, again, there's always
    • 02:49:20
      potential improvements and relevant and timely communication processes even though you scored yourself well it's good to just always kind of check in and say is there anything that we could be doing better some people like email some people like hard copies you know all of that type of stuff so just kind of an annual check-in on that might be good and then there were a few comments about the role of the CTB and not just the CTB it also said the role of VDOT, DRPT it was a broader statement kind of summarized it here but it sounds like you've done some
    • 02:49:50
      We had some good conversations on your role as a policy versus working board versus advocacy board.
    • 02:49:56
      There were some comments that those communications could still be continued a little bit more and a little bit deeper.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:01
      That's the whole purpose of, you know, while we're meeting.
    • 02:50:05
      So that's, I think we sense that and that's what, with all the reforms and the changes that was obviously needed and that so.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:50:14
      We spent a fair amount of time last couple of months circulating around the state.
    • 02:50:18
      Working with local boards and working with the state central board on policy board and the variety of ways they function.
    • 02:50:25
      Needless to say, when you have 24 local boards, they function in all sorts of ways.
    • 02:50:30
      It's hard enough for one board to function right, but you think about lining up all these.
    • 02:50:35
      It's quite complicated, but clarity about what the role is, what the role is not, is absolutely essential for everybody.
    • 02:50:42
      And for also onboarding as we talk about new board members.
    • 02:50:45
      You know, this is what we do.
    • 02:50:46
      This is what we don't do.
    • 02:50:47
      This is how we get involved.
    • 02:50:49
      Basic things, but again, you all are doing very well in your functioning and also doing well in terms of considering the questions to enhance that functioning.
    • 02:50:57
      So that's good.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:51:02
      There was a question, what would you like to receive from the agency directors?
    • 02:51:06
      People indicated that the agency directors are terrific at providing timely information.
    • 02:51:11
      You're available.
    • 02:51:12
      You communicate well.
    • 02:51:13
      There was one comment about the process around the RAB endorsement, so...
    • 02:51:22
      Okay.
    • 02:51:22
      But again, generally people seem to be very happy with the relationship with the agency directors and the amount of communication, their accessibility and their response rate.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:51:33
      One thing we'll look into in terms of the current committee structure and all that, most people indicate they're happy with it.
    • 02:51:39
      You might want to consider some alternatives as well just in terms of what serves your interests and technology, DRPT, local assistance, et cetera were mentioned with warmth and love in the comments.
    • 02:51:51
      So, you know, again, very positive and we've worked with many dysfunctional boards so we spend...
    • 02:51:59
      It's nice to be able to spend time with boards that are doing well and asking the right questions.
    • 02:52:03
      So it makes our jobs a lot easier.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:52:08
      The question of onboarding new board members comes up very, very frequently and this would be about right in line if not better than what we typically hear reported from boards.
    • 02:52:20
      It was on a scale of five.
    • 02:52:21
      It was a three, so it was rated as a good.
    • 02:52:25
      There were no excellent or poor measures, but it's good.
    • 02:52:28
      That means that there's some room for improvement in there.
    • 02:52:30
      and there's a couple of suggestions at the very end that kind of talk to that but to the extent that you know maybe you have a temporary committee or a group that might look at this issue and say how can we improve this it's always typically when a new board member comes on time there's a lot that they have to learn in the beginning and so they they can be a little bit reticent and quiet for the first six months or a year as they try to take in the information to the extent that you can get those new members up and involved and engaged quicker and feeling more comfortable to put forth their voice
    • 02:53:00
      You'd have just better representation throughout the board.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:53:03
      You save usually at least a year in a board member's performance by doing effective onboarding.
    • 02:53:08
      And it's very nice when board members don't want to jump in too quickly.
    • 02:53:12
      We've seen that where some board members, you know, no data in hand, no particular knowledge, but glad to speak my opinion, not very helpful.
    • 02:53:21
      But for other board members who we know are very thoughtful and knowledgeable, getting them involved earlier
    • 02:53:27
      and comfortable is really enhances the quality of the board.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:53:33
      Okay, some comments on the onboarding process.
    • 02:53:36
      Again, there were a few comments on understanding the policy board role and also the fact that they were appointees.
    • 02:53:44
      Comments on how much there is to learn and discussion about ways that you can do that.
    • 02:53:49
      There was a couple of comments that said they had some one-on-ones, I think, with Charlie and Jennifer or some of the folks in your office.
    • 02:53:55
      They really enjoyed that.
    • 02:53:56
      They thought that was very good.
    • 02:53:57
      and to the extent that that could be even expanded would be helpful.
    • 02:54:02
      Annual retreat for new members, I don't personally, I'm not sure why it would just be for new members.
    • 02:54:06
      I think annual retreats for all members is a good thing and maybe the new members could have a special session for something or another but that was a comment.
    • 02:54:14
      And then also just formalizing it, again, just having a critical eye and analytical eye onto the process that you're currently following for onboarding and seeing where there may be some rooms for improvement was a suggestion.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:54:25
      It can be helpful sometimes just to have new board members after they get oriented, get some basic experience.
    • 02:54:31
      They have almost a session to ask the board.
    • 02:54:33
      So the new board members just ask the current board members, what about this?
    • 02:54:37
      How do you handle this?
    • 02:54:38
      What are the key issues you've seen here and there?
    • 02:54:40
      Just a brief session on that.
    • 02:54:42
      And that can be enjoyable and help share your information.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:54:47
      It's all right.
    • 02:54:48
      No problem.
    • 02:54:50
      Yes.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:04
      I think it would be very helpful.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:29
      I've been fortunate enough to be on a lot of different kinds of boards.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:33
      I've often thought it was worthwhile to have a new member assigned a specific mentor
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:00
      of somebody that's been on the board that he or she could call knowing there was an expectation of being called.
    • 02:56:10
      It's hard for somebody coming on that doesn't know anybody to pick up the phone and call somebody and say, what does this mean or what are we doing or what is a transportation alternative, but if there is a given mentor
    • 02:56:28
      that has been on the board for a while, then it's a much easier conversation and learning experience to onboard that person with.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:41
      I agree with that.
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 02:56:42
      I mean, we'll, yes.
    • 02:56:48
      One thing in terms of the onboarding that, you know, you come to your first meeting and you get some information and you talk to folks,
    • 02:56:57
      I think having the district engineer and them playing a role in that onboarding, because I think it's very dependent on who your district engineer is.
    • 02:57:05
      And that's not to say some are bad, some are not.
    • 02:57:09
      Rob Gary was the district engineer in Salem when I came on.
    • 02:57:12
      And we all know Rob and think highly of him.
    • 02:57:15
      And so there was a very clear orientation as to the board and interactions with VDOT and local staff.
    • 02:57:23
      And that was very helpful.
    • 02:57:25
      You know, others just don't communicate in the same way.
    • 02:57:28
      But having the local folks play a role in that onboarding, I think expectations could be very helpful.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:37
      Yeah, I'm having I am.
    • 02:57:41
      I don't know that's the role of the board because it's the execution agency and I know you deal with them.
    • 02:57:48
      I think that's something that Charlie and Jennifer ought to do in that regard.
    • 02:57:53
      I'm really torn between your responsibility as a board member and your responsibility, I mean other than meeting that person and working with them.
    • 02:58:06
      I don't see how that totally fulfills your function as a board member.
    • 02:58:12
      I'm not saying it does, it's not helpful to do, but...
    • 02:58:16
      I'm not sure I understand what you're saying.
    • 02:58:18
      Yeah, I mean, as a board member, a policy member, you know, I don't see where the district administrator gives you a lot of input on your policy.
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 02:58:29
      I'm not talking in a way where it's where the bulldozers and things like that but understanding what was happening in the district, what previous members had done, what their interaction was, to kind of understand what your role should be and actually that it may for me it was helpful in the exact way you're talking about which is
    • 02:58:53
      Where's that line where you're a policy board member versus the day-to-day business?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:05
      We tend to, because VDOT's been the big support agency, but DRPT and getting them involved, I mean, we tend to default one way or the other, and you have responsibility for both agencies in that.
    • 02:59:16
      But I see what you're saying in terms of just, Charlie and Jennifer will let you know who your contacts are for the lay of the land and what you're working on.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:25
      And we've been a little hamstrung because we don't have district staff to see some of you on a regular basis that are out in far-flung districts.
    • 02:59:33
      I know we do have staff in Northern Virginia that sit in on the briefings with the Northern Virginia members, which helps.
    • 02:59:39
      But you know, if there's more that we can do to brief you all, you know, whether it's on a monthly basis or on a more regular basis about the things that we're doing,
    • 02:59:47
      Please let me know.
    • 02:59:48
      And I know many of you do have relationships with some of our staff and have no problem calling them up and asking a question, which I completely support.
    • 02:59:56
      But if there's other things that we can do to keep you all more up to date with what DRPT is doing, please let me know.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:03
      I see where we're getting to now, Cora.
    • 03:00:05
      I think is that we just make that part of the agency onboarding.
    • 03:00:08
      Hall, John
    • 03:00:31
      Yeah, all those different things.
    • 03:00:33
      So I think that's a better way is to say we have something formal for each agency and part of the agency would be to introduce you and have your at that.
    • 03:00:43
      and then the overall responsibilities of the board members and the mentoring.
    • 03:00:47
      Maybe that's a, you know, do it in that regard.
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 03:00:50
      Yeah.
    • 03:00:50
      I definitely understand.
    • 03:00:51
      Yeah.
    • 03:00:52
      I served on a city council, you know, you set the policy and the staff, you know, the staff and administration carried out.
    • 03:00:56
      I just found it to be very helpful.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:58
      No, no, I agree.
    • 03:00:58
      I think that'd be part of what Charlie and Jennifer set up for you and the agency you oversee, the introduction.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:01:04
      Yeah.
    • 03:01:05
      I think that's good.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:01:07
      Okay.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:01:10
      Finally, in terms of other suggestions,
    • 03:01:13
      The timely receipt of information.
    • 03:01:16
      So even though you scored high in terms of a lot of things, I think this seems to be a very nice group of people.
    • 03:01:23
      And so people might be saying, oh, yeah, it's fine.
    • 03:01:25
      We don't want to be a bother.
    • 03:01:26
      But we want the information sooner.
    • 03:01:28
      So we're not exactly sure.
    • 03:01:30
      But it's always something to struggle with.
    • 03:01:34
      It's always worth doing.
    • 03:01:35
      So getting information out in a timely way to afford thoughtful conversation at the meeting is always best.
    • 03:01:41
      Some performance management, including monthly or annual action lists, some metric reviews, strategic communication.
    • 03:01:48
      There's just a lot of room for growth, I think, that you all see within the process of what you're doing, which is a very complicated process.
    • 03:01:56
      It's kind of mind-blowing in many ways.
    • 03:01:58
      And to want to jump deeper into it says a lot about your willingness to be an active, engaged board within the right boundaries of the board.
    • 03:02:06
      A very positive thing.
    • 03:02:08
      In terms of clarification on many levels, we'd like to explore what that really means in terms of clarification of what.
    • 03:02:14
      That can be clarification of role, of course, code, reading code, no offense to those who write it sometimes.
    • 03:02:20
      It's not only complicated, it's also sort of like, but it says this here and it says this here and how do we juggle these kinds of things?
    • 03:02:29
      and sometimes the code is very clear.
    • 03:02:31
      With one group we found the code was crystal clear.
    • 03:02:34
      They just didn't like it so they didn't really know how to read it for some reason.
    • 03:02:37
      It was a tough sentence in the code.
    • 03:02:41
      So I also have a recommendation for mentoring as it came up for new board members which is key and we definitely do support that and again the one-day meetings and that did rise up.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:52
      I'm not asking, was that more than one person that asked for that?
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:02:56
      Yes.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:02:57
      I got to tell you, I think we need, that's one thing that I've seen in here, and I think that's going to be a real issue for this board is determining, again, the amount of work required to really do this versus whether you want to be on the board.
    • 03:03:16
      I don't see where we're headed to any way to make them more than, you know, the half day, day and a half meetings.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:24
      Other than we're just going to be telling you to sign off on stuff.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:28
      and that was what was going on before but you know we'll be happy to take a look I just don't see how we get it done in without a day you know day and a half basically and that I mean what we could do here's the problem we run into if a work and Rick you may have to weigh in on this we have to post the actual meeting for the action items
    • 03:03:55
      In other words, so if we got done early one afternoon, we can't roll right into the action item meeting.
    • 03:04:05
      But you have to post it that way.
    • 03:04:06
      I mean, that's my point is that I guess we could post to say it's either going to be here or there, but then that would run into all kinds of problems with people coming down to talk and then we don't get to it.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:18
      This is not an issue that I'm happy to come for two days, so this is not my issue.
    • 03:04:24
      I was on another statewide advisory board where people were very far flung and we discovered in talking to the FOIA council that you could advertise an action meeting happening in two locations or multiple locations.
    • 03:04:40
      So you could... We were working with the community college.
    • 03:04:42
      You could advertise that...
    • 03:04:44
      The majority of people were going to meet in Richmond and that two people, one in Northern Virginia and one in Southeast were going to go to their community college.
    • 03:04:56
      So people could actually be closer to home at a public meeting where the public could come and observe.
    • 03:05:08
      And so I don't know what the issue is for who it's a trouble for, but perhaps around the action meetings we could consider if people can't come for the whole time that at least that part could take place
    • 03:05:22
      in two or three locations, meaning you'd only really be giving one whole day up to work.
    • 03:05:28
      I just don't, I think we need to figure out what the issue is before, but, because I appreciate it, but I think there might be different solutions that we have to follow.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:37
      The issue, I don't know, but the board person was talking to me about, he just can't, you know, he doesn't want to be away from his job more than one day.
    • 03:05:42
      It's not an issue of he can get through all the information.
    • 03:05:47
      In other words, I haven't had anybody tell me, in fact, most of you have come to say we'd like to have a little bit of downtime.
    • 03:05:53
      You know, in other words, you know, they'd like to have an hour between, you know, we go into that type of stuff.
    • 03:06:00
      Most of what I've said is I just have a work commitment and getting away for two days is difficult.
    • 03:06:05
      And I can see that.
    • 03:06:06
      And it might be a problem, though, about how to serve on the board.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:10
      I mean, that's what I think.
    • 03:06:11
      I think it's a personal decision.
    • 03:06:12
      Do I have the time to get to the board meeting?
    • 03:06:13
      Right.
    • 03:06:14
      That's right.
    • 03:06:15
      I shouldn't be on it.
    • 03:06:16
      Yeah, I mean, that's
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 03:06:17
      To lose some of the camaraderie of those dinners, if there was a one-day meeting, you'd invariably have people just showing up who can that day and leaving.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:30
      I would also say that, you know, I mean, I was a transportation committee chairman.
    • 03:06:34
      I was a little, in looking back, I was a little too structured.
    • 03:06:37
      I didn't allow a lot of, you know, a lot of give and take.
    • 03:06:42
      You do, and I think it's been very useful.
    • 03:06:45
      I mean, it slowed down a little bit without my friend William,
    • 03:06:47
      But I mean, we feel comfortable chiming in.
    • 03:06:51
      And if you try to pack it all in too tight, people are not going to feel, plus you're not going to be able to let them because you got a deadline.
    • 03:07:01
      Yeah.
    • 03:07:02
      I like the way our board meetings go.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:04
      And I'll tell you, that came from a much more general premise.
    • 03:07:07
      And I have just seen that buy-in is tougher than building the projects.
    • 03:07:16
      I often said this, if we get it down to an engineering problem, I'm comfortable with Charlie, we're gonna solve it.
    • 03:07:22
      Yeah, but it's the, that's why I just, I don't, I mean, look, I came from private business and this is a whole lot way of doing than I used to be doing business.
    • 03:07:33
      But on the other hand, what I've experienced is if you don't take the time on the front end, you rarely have success on the back end.
    • 03:07:42
      So it's a matter of
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:07:44
      I'm not suggesting this, but if you're looking maybe for some alternatives, uh, I think we would also think that the action part of our meeting is not much to it.
    • 03:08:02
      It's pretty routine.
    • 03:08:03
      Sometimes I've seen this go through it in a few minutes.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:07
      Cause you've been briefed on it a month before and the whole day.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:09
      The meat of our, uh, of our deliberation has always been the workshop.
    • 03:08:15
      and I have no idea the calendar driving forces but you might want to consider an action meeting every other month of a one day and then a two full days every other month of workshop cutting out the
    • 03:08:42
      The Bus ride around to look at projects and that type of thing.
    • 03:08:49
      I'm not suggesting this.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:50
      No, no, no.
    • 03:08:51
      I think probably the biggest thing that I have heard that we probably have been the least enjoyable is some of the
    • 03:09:03
      There may be certain times where we could have action meeting every other month, that's what I'm saying, and then pack in two full days of workshop.
    • 03:09:30
      Yeah, but the problem is, I was going to say, the only thing with that is the public ability to speak, and they only speak at the action meeting, because that's one place for a meeting.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:39
      You could still have the public in the action meeting on one day.
    • 03:09:42
      You don't need more than a day for that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:45
      Oh, you're saying, in other words, you're saying every other month have two days in one month, okay.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:49
      Two days, one month, one day the next month.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:09:53
      I would just note that there are certain things that you all approve every month that if you go to that so like bids or other things might you know not be able to be approved or if there's a transfer from a closed project to another one that might let it go to procurement I just I think maybe staff could just give you guys some information on you know implications of considering that just it's calendar driven I know a lot of universities do that
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:22
      And so I just don't know whether we have the flexibility of doing that or not.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:10:26
      Let's, particularly with what we want, we talked about the calendar this morning plus the other things that may go on it.
    • 03:10:32
      Let's just take a look at that.
    • 03:10:35
      I think we'll come up with a recommendation.
    • 03:10:39
      For the rest of the year you can plan on two days, so I can, you know, in that, but we'll come up with that.
    • 03:10:44
      If you get your comments from the calendar, we'll put it back and see if there's any ways.
    • 03:10:50
      The problem is, what I do see on here is people like the certainty of the date.
    • 03:10:56
      and so that that that the people can work around so I think that's probably would take precedence over trying to squeeze a day out because if we can just say I know next year at least we can deal with it absolutely yeah and that stuff so
    • 03:11:11
      Mr. Tom.
    • Alison DeTuncqMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:12
      Just to follow up on Mary's comment in terms of being able to participate in the action meeting remotely.
    • 03:11:18
      If you have, you know, the people have very busy schedules and the two days can be difficult.
    • 03:11:24
      So if it's possible to attend the workshop which is very educational and that's where all the discussion, most of the discussion occurs and then have the ability to return back to your hometown and participate in the very some days short action agenda
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:41
      Here's the problem, I agree, but then you have public comment and then you're going to have public comment at your remote location.
    • 03:11:49
      I think we looked at that before and FOIA, you know, I mean, I don't know.
    • 03:11:57
      We got to take a look at that.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:11:58
      I know we had to legislate for one of the state boards to be able to even do a remote meeting.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:03
      Yeah, I'm not sure we even have the ability to do it, but we'll look at it.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:07
      I don't think we can legally do it.
    • 03:12:08
      The Parole Board doesn't.
    • 03:12:10
      I think some boards can.
    • 03:12:11
      I think some, we'll have to see if we can.
    • 03:12:13
      It has to be specific.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:12:19
      Well I think that's right some boards do I think and so we'll take a look at it the only issue I would have with Mr.
    • 03:12:27
      I think that's great except for what required of public comment if you're having a public meeting does that mean you've got to accommodate
    • 03:12:36
      you know if you're at your office for instance do you have to open your we did this a couple times when we were briefing and we had William did it we had to say he had to be open his office had to be opened up for public to come in and look and that may be an issue too yeah so let us look at it but I'm what I'm hearing is I think certainty will be critical and then we'll see how the calendar drives this yeah that now you can always call in you just can't vote yeah
    • 03:13:07
      In other words, you can always, if you can't be there, we can call in and listen.
    • 03:13:11
      I don't think we can vote telephonically.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:14
      Could we not take advantage of the opportunity the legislature created that you could, twice a year, participate remotely as long as the quorum's there?
    • 03:13:24
      Is that not available to us?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:25
      We've got to check to see if our rules allow us to do that.
    • 03:13:28
      We may need a legislative fix.
    • 03:13:29
      I'm not sure.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:13:33
      I served on the transition team for
    • 03:13:36
      transportation.
    • 03:13:37
      I will just say the input that came to that small group, people really wanted that public participation.
    • 03:13:44
      They wanted even more time.
    • 03:13:47
      In fact, there was frustration that they were limited at times in their ability to speak.
    • 03:13:52
      So I think that was an overwhelming concern.
    • 03:13:55
      I do think people appreciate the fact that we move around the state, which does accommodate some of these issues.
    • 03:14:02
      We're not always in remote locations.
    • 03:14:05
      And so people did like the fact that we went to Northern Virginia, Charlottesville, different areas.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:14:13
      Yeah, in fact, there's an important couple areas that they would like us, but if we vote on anything in their area, they want us to vote there.
    • 03:14:22
      That's going to be difficult to accommodate.
    • 03:14:25
      But now that we're live streaming, you can see it all anyway.
    • 03:14:28
      But I do think moving around is a positive.
    • 03:14:34
      I do think that is.
    • 03:14:36
      It also sends a signal to the community that they're important enough that we'd come there.
    • 03:14:43
      I mean, I think that's a two-way street in that.
    • 03:14:48
      All right, let us do some, like Nick said, we'll do some research and come back and calendar and all that and come back in that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:14:57
      We got feedback from most of you.
    • 03:15:00
      We'd like to know if before we move ahead, if as you look through here, if you hadn't taken the survey or you had some thoughts after the survey, what would you add?
    • 03:15:09
      What's missing from what we have just so that we're making this completely inclusive before we move to the next step?
    • 03:15:15
      Is there anything as you look through that slide list that you say, you know what, what's missing here is this?
    • 03:15:20
      Let me take this into consideration.
    • 03:15:39
      You weren't in this morning for the first couple hours of discussion.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:15:55
      And again, this is the whole purpose.
    • 03:15:58
      We don't expect to finish this today.
    • 03:16:00
      It's the purpose of starting it.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:02
      Do they have access to the tape for when they weren't here?
    • 03:16:05
      They will.
    • 03:16:05
      They will, yeah.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:06
      So it might be good for you guys to go back and look and listen to that.
    • 03:16:09
      And I think that'll be helpful in terms of where we go from here.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:14
      Yeah, the live stream's recorded, so you'll be able to pull it up on the CTB website.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:19
      I want to raise an issue which is tangential to this but is bothersome to me and maybe it's something staff could do some work on.
    • 03:16:29
      I'm concerned as we move more and more into being a policy board and not our appointments not being at the whim of the governor that there will come a time when somebody's going to FOIA us.
    • 03:16:43
      for emails which may have passed between us or between us and the district office or whatever.
    • 03:16:53
      The CTB email is not easy or convenient to use in terms of how I suspect most of us live our lives.
    • 03:17:01
      So, and I have been- In other words- I can't get, I can't connect to it on my personal iPad with doing a whole bunch of- Because of AirWatch and all that type of stuff, is that what security-
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:13
      Oh, I understand.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:17:18
      But you don't want to do your personal because... Well, I'm using my personal because that's what I have and because this all happens in the context of my daily life.
    • 03:17:30
      I was on another board where an email box was set up
    • 03:17:36
      that I just blind copied on anything I did on my home and it stored that email.
    • 03:17:44
      So if there was a FOIA that box could be gone to and those emails swept up.
    • 03:17:51
      I'm just concerned that we don't really have a game plan and I think we're all doing different things and as we move forward I think our risk increases
    • 03:18:03
      that somebody in the public is going to decide they want to see whatever any CTB member wrote about anything.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:10
      Yeah.
    • 03:18:12
      You're right.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:13
      You don't... We have... We were able to work around it because we're within...
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:16
      I understand exactly what you're saying.
    • 03:18:18
      It could be...
    • 03:18:21
      You set up a separate email just for that personally, but we'll see.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:27
      I'd love to have the advice about what we can do.
    • 03:18:31
      What we should do.
    • 03:18:32
      That actually works.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:33
      That actually works.
    • 03:18:34
      We have it, but you can't do it on your regular computer.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:18:38
      Well, the issue is, I think you're asking about what's subject to FOIA.
    • 03:18:42
      What can they get to?
    • 03:18:44
      I know that anything I write about related to this... Oh, if you do it on your personal phone, your whole personal phone might be subject to it.
    • 03:18:50
      That's the problem I'm trying to...
    • 03:18:52
      I mean, I was looking at, in other words, that's what we were told not to use our personal phones in that.
    • 03:18:58
      Now, what we do
    • 03:18:59
      is have a separate account set up and say only use this account but let us go back and research and see how the best way I think I understand what you're saying.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:10
      I mean I suppose it applies to texting as well.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:12
      No I think that's right because the more you do and I'm sure you're all I you know using it you talk with your local administrator and something like that and and CTB computer yeah I've seen these emails where people are like
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:29
      You know, I've emailed you twice now and you, you know, you just, are you refusing to communicate with me?
    • 03:19:33
      I'm like, well, I've seen it.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:19:35
      I know what the problem is.
    • 03:19:36
      So we're, we, this computer here has the thing called AirWatch installed on it.
    • 03:19:42
      Our phones, our phones have AirWatch, which allows you to access your VDOT, CTB, all that email.
    • 03:19:51
      And if it's a personal phone, if this happened to be my personal phone, we would load AirWatch onto my personal phone and I would get it.
    • 03:19:59
      you may or may not want air wash loaded on you but unless you want to you know my phone don't work let us work on that because I think
    • 03:20:15
      Some folks here have not lived in the public environment, but any email correspondence is subject to FOIA with some very, very small limitations.
    • 03:20:28
      And I get FOIA requests all the time on my email account and I'm constantly providing that data back through our policy office.
    • 03:20:36
      I have a client that's...
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:20:48
      I do agree, AirWatch brings its own set of problems.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:10
      That doesn't help me in the FOIA.
    • 03:21:14
      That's really what I'm worried about is I sent something to Scott and Gary just FYI hears this and it turns out it's some project somebody wants to know about.
    • 03:21:23
      We all have to find it then and supply it.
    • 03:21:26
      And I don't think any of us has a good mechanism.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:29
      You could check it on this one.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:31
      Yeah, they'll have all that access here, but the convenience, the challenge.
    • 03:21:35
      Yeah, the chance of carrying that around all the time.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:37
      Yeah, I got you.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:38
      Okay.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:21:39
      We can't do anything else.
    • 03:21:41
      Just give them a, do it all.
    • 03:21:46
      Then they're carrying two phones.
    • 03:21:48
      Yeah.
    • 03:21:49
      Okay.
    • 03:21:49
      All right, let us look, we'll work on that.
    • 03:21:51
      Got it.
    • 03:21:53
      Good point.
    • 03:21:54
      And the way we're headed, we're going to have more and more built in the need to do that.
    • 03:22:03
      Okay, anything else or, let's see, we're still well before our break time, so.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:22:09
      You can move forward and get a couple of other things done before lunch.
    • 03:22:11
      Why don't we do that, yes.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:22:13
      Okay, great.
    • 03:22:14
      Okay, great.
    • 03:22:14
      Well, what we thought we might suggest that you do is to digest these results a little bit and also think about other things that might not have been in the survey.
    • 03:22:24
      We thought about just kind of breaking you into three smaller groups and based upon what you heard, based upon additional conversation and additional thoughts that you might have,
    • 03:22:33
      You know, just kind of list maybe the top three to five improvements that you think we should tackle moving forward for the next year.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:22:41
      And if you could be as specific as possible.
    • 03:22:43
      So if we're talking about timeliness and things, what kind of timeliness do you mean?
    • 03:22:47
      Just so that there's clarity about what's wanted.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:22:52
      Oh, from a FOIA perspective, Rick, we got to all stay in here, right?
    • 03:22:56
      We got to stay in this room?
    • 03:23:00
      Yes.
    • 03:23:00
      Well, you can keep them.
    • 03:23:01
      I mean, every room that you break up into
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:04
      Oh, okay.
    • 03:23:04
      So you just got, all right, we're not going to go.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:06
      It doesn't have to be live streamed, impractical to live stream.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:10
      Yeah.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:11
      Or we could just cluster around here.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:14
      Just take three and you know, maybe that's the thing to do right now.
    • 03:23:17
      So, um, you want to Gary, you and Alison and then you three guys and you three and yeah, yeah, yeah.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:23:26
      And that's so, yep.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:28
      How's that?
    • 03:23:29
      That work?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:32
      What's our assignment here?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:23:35
      We'd like to move to lunch say around...
    • 03:23:36
      Pick up.
    • 03:23:37
      I know we're at 12.30.
    • 03:23:38
      We're at 12.15 so between now and 12.15 we can discuss some priorities.
    • 03:23:43
      If we have time we'll debrief them before lunch.
    • 03:23:45
      If not we'll debrief them right after lunch.
    • 03:23:47
      And we'll just...
    • 03:23:49
      Wherever you cluster we'll just move some flip charts over.
    • 03:23:51
      We've got two here and we brought one.
    • 03:23:54
      So...
    • 03:23:54
      Cluster so you can hear each other.
    • 03:23:56
      That's the key thing.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:23:57
      Brainstorm into three about improvements.
    • 03:24:01
      The three.
    • 03:24:03
      I don't want me and Nick dictating anything, but you all should participate.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:23
      Are you doing two or three groups?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:34:29
      Okay guys, we're gonna try to keep on schedule here, so uh...
    • 04:34:33
      Before lunch, you had an opportunity to think about some things to improve on, and now we're going to go through those results.
    • 04:34:39
      So Jim, Linda, you're up.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:34:41
      Great.
    • 04:34:42
      And we've heard from our videographers that it would be best if we bring an easel up here so that a spokesperson from each group, or you could bring your whole group up, whatever you want to.
    • 04:34:51
      But if you could kind of debrief from up here so that we can capture it for the live stream, that would be terrific.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:34:56
      Looks like this group has...
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 04:34:59
      I guess this group's volunteered to go first.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:03
      Yeah.
    • 04:35:06
      Who takes credit for this group?
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 04:35:11
      Hello.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:35:14
      This is uh
    • 04:35:25
      We captured four items that I think overlap with some other suggestions.
    • 04:35:31
      The first one is on meetings and workshops.
    • 04:35:33
      We heard the conversations, and I was one of the ones that was advocating for the one-day meeting, but after hearing the conversation, I'm kind of ambivalent on that.
    • 04:35:43
      I like the two-day meetings.
    • 04:35:45
      and maybe we need to look at a more efficient way of looking, you know, organizing the meetings, review efficacy of tours, but make workshops thematic during the year, kind of taking what Dixon said about the two, one, two, instead of maybe doing that, keep the two-day workshops making the workshops thematic like finance or
    • 04:36:14
      construction, innovation in technology, for instance, and really spend a day on that one topic and all those things that are related to that topic.
    • 04:36:22
      But the meetings will remain transactional.
    • 04:36:25
      And we'll look at the calendar year to see how we can conform thematic workshops with the business at hand that we have to vote on.
    • 04:36:40
      Number two is we like the formal onboarding for new members.
    • 04:36:43
      I think that's a good orientation.
    • 04:36:45
      We need to have a formal orientation for new members.
    • 04:36:48
      And I think the district tours that I had, that gave me a better perspective to see a region that I was very familiar with, but not with a transportation focus.
    • 04:36:59
      So that helped me a lot coming on the board.
    • 04:37:01
      Jr.
    • 04:37:02
      Number three, we like the assigned mentor idea that Dixon was advocating.
    • 04:37:08
      And we also, number four, think we should
    • 04:37:14
      I'd like to review our public engagement.
    • 04:37:16
      I think we've all been to public hearings that were not well attended.
    • 04:37:23
      With today's technology, social media, how do we keep the public engaged?
    • 04:37:29
      I know by law we have to have these public hearings.
    • 04:37:32
      That doesn't preclude us from having continuous ways to engage the public, because we know everybody's got an opinion on transportation, but they don't always come to the public hearings.
    • 04:37:44
      So that's our four suggestions.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:37:46
      Yeah.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:37:50
      Thank you, sir.
    • 04:37:50
      So, chap, we're still communicating in a 20th century way instead of a 21st century technology, so good thing that, yeah, good point.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 04:38:05
      Not a lot of originality from the last group.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:38:32
      We did suggest that the board agenda and material ought to be firm and distributed by one week before the meeting.
    • 04:38:48
      It's gotten to be that the volume of stuff that comes out, especially in the very last
    • 04:38:56
      is hard for some people to get or read or be prepared.
    • 04:39:00
      And sometimes, oftentimes, the first time you see it is when we're sitting here and it's before us.
    • 04:39:07
      And I know that's hard to legislate, but it needs to be a goal down the road.
    • 04:39:16
      We too felt that there should be a more formalized onboarding orientation for new members with a reference book
    • 04:39:25
      where board members, new board members can flip and see what state of good repair is, understand what transportation alternative is, understand what all these various acronyms are, understand what, he can look at the calendar, he, she can look at the calendar, at least have some sort of a
    • 04:39:54
      of a reference book that usually takes a year for one to assimilate from just sitting in here with a mentor, that that mentor is formally assigned for a year.
    • 04:40:10
      And there is an expectation that the mentor will call the new member.
    • 04:40:15
      The member will be free to call the mentor.
    • 04:40:20
      And of course, obviously, the district administrator
    • 04:40:24
      also play a role on this onboarding simply to orient that person to the district with whom they are to represent.
    • 04:40:38
      And I suspect that's done in many districts, but it's a formalized expectation.
    • 04:40:44
      The third thing I'm sure will get Rick jumping out of his skin.
    • 04:40:49
      Consider some sort of a semiannual executive session with the board and the secretary where there is an opportunity to inform, and it is an informative type of session, on any non-public items that may not be able to be discussed in public forum.
    • 04:41:12
      Now realize that to go into executive session,
    • 04:41:16
      That's very limited and has to be determined what it is you're going to talk about.
    • 04:41:23
      Maybe that's doable, maybe it's not and a clarification on what is allowed and maybe there could be some opportunity for that kind of a dialogue which we can't have here.
    • 04:41:35
      And finally to continue the discussion and review of our meeting structure,
    • 04:41:45
      I think we are leaving here today looking at various options and alternatives and rather than saying that this is the way we should go, we would encourage us to continue to find ways to ensure effective deliberation and board involvement with our structure.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:42:11
      A couple of things.
    • 04:42:15
      I have to admit Carol is really good about making sure we try to get to you a week in advance now.
    • 04:42:21
      It's my office that tends to drop that ball and Dick's raising his hand back there.
    • 04:42:31
      So I know it's right so I want to point but we do.
    • 04:42:34
      Some of it is
    • 04:42:36
      Look, I think it's a great goal.
    • 04:42:38
      We need to strive for it.
    • 04:42:39
      Now, what about the length of a presentation?
    • 04:42:43
      I mean, while we're talking about this, that's the other thing we struggle with because of some of the meetings is, you know, you get much over, you know, 15, 20 slides.
    • 04:42:54
      You know, you're probably talking an hour.
    • 04:42:56
      Some of the things you can't, but I mean, that's one thing to consider about is the length, your attention span for not a discussion, but a presentation.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:06
      I think they've generally been reasonable.
    • 04:43:08
      We have very complex issues that we deal with.
    • 04:43:11
      In some cases require 30 slides or so.
    • 04:43:13
      So, I mean, I don't think by and large they've been unreasonable from the standpoint of length.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:18
      I think you've done a good job as chairman, kind of recognizing when some of us are going to nod off here in a minute.
    • 04:43:24
      Yeah, exactly.
    • 04:43:26
      Pulling in those.
    • 04:43:29
      The few times that this happened, which is not often, I think you've reined it in.
    • 04:43:38
      I always feel bad for whoever the presenter is.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:43:42
      I'm not politically correct, but I reined them in nonetheless.
    • 04:43:46
      That's right.
    • 04:43:48
      Okay well we'll be cognizant, I mean that's what the discussion, they should be the, I have no problem letting discussions go on but when it's a presentation and we're just, somebody's asking questions you know that's that's that.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:00
      I think sometimes an executive summary can help where there is a long presentation to start with that and then we can.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:44:11
      I do want to mention C because I've taken great pains to not go into executive session for anything and I understand why and the reason is I'm trying to think of what we would want to talk about that we would not talk about in public.
    • 04:44:27
      We don't have personnel issues because that's not part of our responsibility.
    • 04:44:33
      We typically, the one area it could be is any proprietary information in a contract, but that really hasn't come before us.
    • 04:44:43
      And we've actually, working with Charlie, we've been working to limit what that is.
    • 04:44:49
      I remember P3s used to be all proprietary and now it's
    • 04:44:53
      We publish our term sheet and say, beat it.
    • 04:44:56
      But there are certain things that are, like how they compute traffic and different things in that.
    • 04:45:01
      So that's what I was trying to figure out is what topic.
    • 04:45:07
      Now, if it's just talking about something that is uncomfortable, I'm trying to get a grasp of what might come up that we want to go in executive session over.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 04:45:21
      We say personnel is not in our purview and you're right in that there certainly is no involvement, but there is a knowledge.
    • 04:45:30
      For instance, when there is, there have been some major changes of senior staff that we didn't know about until all of a sudden somebody else is presenting.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:45:43
      And that's an executive role.
    • 04:45:45
      That's letting you know what's going on, but that's your purpose.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 04:45:49
      Would that have to be an executive session?
    • 04:45:51
      I don't know.
    • 04:45:51
      Maybe it's not an uncomfortable thing to discuss in the public.
    • 04:45:55
      The same thing has been when there's been an uncomfortable change on our board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:46:02
      Yeah.
    • 04:46:03
      Okay.
    • 04:46:03
      I mean, I'm just trying to think.
    • 04:46:04
      I'm with you.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:46:05
      Yeah.
    • 04:46:06
      Let me chime in here too, because I was part of this discussion.
    • 04:46:10
      In certain policy debates, one might in an executive session be more apt to take a devil's advocate stand as opposed to in a public session that devil's advocate stand being taken out of context because we're live streaming and all of a sudden there's a quote of Gary Garczynski said
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:46:37
      I'll take it I mean I think you know I get it I mean I think but one of the things I've found is that's where we get into trouble but I understand you know there could be I mean like even though you may not hire somebody you may decide
    • 04:47:05
      Well, look, there could be a time when you're adverse to the chairman and you want to say something in terms of a personnel or something.
    • 04:47:12
      So I get it.
    • 04:47:16
      And so I think we just need to be cognizant.
    • 04:47:18
      And you're right.
    • 04:47:18
      We have to say what we're talking about going in.
    • 04:47:23
      And then we come out and only vote on that particular issue.
    • 04:47:26
      So I'm not saying we shouldn't consider it.
    • 04:47:29
      I do think they should be very judiciously used.
    • 04:47:32
      I think from that in that point and so anyway just a point on that because there's been a couple times a couple conversations I'd love to do it with but I just didn't think it would be you know we're better to just take the criticism or
    • 04:47:47
      and you know I've found usually up front now if it was the Port of Virginia is a lot different we have personnel decisions if we got if there's a lawsuit at VDOT that'd be another one we could go in you know in that or it was some type of you know you know charge against an employee or Charlie or something like that which I think
    • 04:48:10
      I don't know if I just want to talk about it.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 04:48:17
      Anyway, I get it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:48:26
      For instance, or if we were doing something, if we were asked by the governor of the legislature, which we consider working papers, in other words, they want us, it's not, we're not making a decision, he's asked us for something to deliberate on, that type of thing I could see in there.
    • 04:48:45
      So anyway, I get it, I just, I think we just ought to be judiciously about it.
    • Alison DeTuncqMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:48:49
      I'm just going to add to the conversation since I was part of this discussion as well.
    • 04:48:53
      You know, nobody wants to have a hot topic that we need to go.
    • 04:48:56
      You know, we're not looking for issues to go into executive session for.
    • 04:48:59
      In my space, in the financial services industry, it's almost becoming,
    • 04:49:05
      Good governance to allow the board to have an opportunity to go into executive sessions in the event that there is something weighing on somebody's mind where they want to just take a little deeper dive.
    • 04:49:17
      That's a good thought, yeah.
    • 04:49:18
      So that was kind of in the context of where, you know, I was considering.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:49:23
      We could say there's a personal matter that such and such wants to bring up because we have to disclose what we're going in for.
    • 04:49:29
      That's the only thing I'm talking in that regard.
    • 04:49:32
      Remember,
    • 04:49:34
      It's a little bit different.
    • 04:49:37
      We're not a private board that invites the public and decides it wants to discuss.
    • 04:49:48
      I mean, the default here, we are public.
    • 04:49:51
      We've got to have a reason the other way.
    • 04:49:54
      That's what the issue is.
    • 04:49:56
      But I can see where, look,
    • 04:50:00
      I mean the Continental Congress who closed all the windows and barred all that when they were doing about the Declaration of Independence.
    • 04:50:07
      So I know there's some important things but I'm just we just got to make sure we you know have a really good justification.
    • Alison DeTuncqMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:14
      An example would be if our board under before the legislative changes took effect that you know there could have been some angst in the P3 process that nobody felt comfortable bringing forth to the board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:28
      You know, in fact, the only executive session that I can remember being in here is when we were called an executive session that we had to ratify the contract.
    • 04:50:38
      It had already been executed, but if we didn't ratify it, we were still on the hook for paying for it.
    • 04:50:46
      So, I mean, that was, that's a tough, what do you do there?
    • 04:50:49
      Are you going to pay the
    • 04:50:50
      Begin II, whether we billed it or not, or whatever the money is.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:54
      That wasn't him, it wasn't him.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:50:56
      We're not looking at you.
    • 04:50:57
      No, no, no, it was previous administration, yeah, in that regard.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:02
      Mr. Chairman, having that as an option is something we should know, but is it something we should regularly schedule?
    • 04:51:11
      I mean, to me, when you have a need, that that's an option for us.
    • 04:51:16
      For ad hoc when it's needed and stuff.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:19
      Well, and I would point out that you guys should not be shy if you think we need one either.
    • 04:51:23
      In other words, it shouldn't just be us in that.
    • 04:51:29
      So I think we're on the same wavelength there.
    • 04:51:32
      It's not that we want.
    • 04:51:33
      We just need to make daggone sure that the benefits outweigh us doing that and that so.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:41
      OK. Yeah, good.
    • 04:51:42
      Discussion.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:51:45
      Yeah.
    • 04:51:51
      Let me ask one more question.
    • 04:51:52
      Has there any been a topic that we thought we should have been?
    • 04:51:54
      Is there anything come up in the past that you would have thought we should have been in executive session?
    • 04:52:05
      Yeah, I'll tell you offline.
    • 04:52:11
      We go in executive session.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:52:16
      Our group focused first on board orientation.
    • 04:52:29
      I think it's a good one to lead in with because we've become members of this board.
    • 04:52:33
      That should be our first experience.
    • 04:52:35
      So we think it's critical that we formalize that process as all the other groups have so far too.
    • 04:52:42
      I think it's important to define your role and your responsibility, but to me it's just as important.
    • 04:52:47
      It's probably more my emphasis than Jennifer's or my other partner over there.
    • 04:52:53
      What's your name?
    • 04:52:53
      Shannon.
    • 04:52:55
      Shannon.
    • 04:52:55
      Just to determine the limits of what you should be doing also and the limits of your responsibilities.
    • 04:53:01
      Just having served on some public boards, I just, I know most people
    • 04:53:06
      I have an incorrect perception of what they should be doing in terms of how forceful you should be.
    • 04:53:12
      So we thought that was important.
    • 04:53:15
      Emphasis added by me.
    • 04:53:16
      I think Shannon had a good thought.
    • 04:53:19
      If you come up with a new idea and you'd like the board to embrace it or VDOT to embrace a different concept or address a concern, how do you get that out to everybody so everybody's comfortable with it and you're not having to deal too directly
    • 04:53:35
      with VDOT because during all of our discussion we were very conscious of the limits on you communicating with staff.
    • 04:53:43
      When does communication or questioning become a direction?
    • 04:53:46
      Is there pressure on them to react accordingly because you're a member of the Transportation Board?
    • 04:53:55
      So we thought that was important and maybe we have a little more, maybe set a few minutes aside for one of our meetings just to say, hey, what's going on and give it a chance to take root.
    • 04:54:07
      I mean, the IT Committee, I don't have a clue what y'all are doing.
    • 04:54:11
      I don't have a clue.
    • 04:54:12
      So if you've got an idea you want the board to embrace, I've never heard it because we just don't, we don't have a process or even have a habit in place of trying to get new ideas to bubble up through the board like that.
    • 04:54:22
      So we thought that was important.
    • 04:54:25
      The two day meetings, she wrote, uh, that the two day meetings are important.
    • 04:54:31
      I wanted to add, add it that it's the time is not important to me.
    • 04:54:36
      It's how we run the meetings.
    • 04:54:37
      And I think,
    • 04:54:39
      The free flow that we have is really good.
    • 04:54:43
      If it takes two days to do that, then yes, they are important.
    • 04:54:46
      If you could do it in a day, a day would be important.
    • 04:54:48
      Whatever.
    • 04:54:48
      I just think there's so many people on this board that have so much to add to everything.
    • 04:54:54
      One of the best boards I've ever served on.
    • 04:54:56
      And we should continue to have the discussions that we have.
    • 04:55:01
      And the last thing was Shannon brought this up and it's absolutely, I think it's got a lot of merit.
    • 04:55:08
      We deal with issues a lot of times with like rail access, industrial access projects for road projects.
    • 04:55:15
      We don't know anything about the real deal.
    • 04:55:19
      And rather than circulate the report to full report to everybody, because there's probably some sensitive information in it in terms of the financial statements of the company or something like that, is to at least allow access to those who might question it, a place that they could go online, not delivering wads of paper.
    • 04:55:37
      and give them access to at least the full report on the decision how you decided to give or not give the grants.
    • 04:55:46
      Anything else, Shannon, Jennifer?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:55:50
      The one thing that you brought up was on the board orientation, you mentioned we should all go through it.
    • 04:55:56
      Well, we should, we've never had different levels of understanding.
    • 04:55:59
      So we should be like, we should just do that as a full board exercise.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:56:03
      I love the, somebody brought up, I think maybe it was Dixon, brought up the, you know, the flip chart, smart scale.
    • 04:56:09
      What is it?
    • 04:56:10
      You know, all of us could stand to have that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:56:16
      We have mandatory, don't we, uh,
    • 04:56:20
      We have mandatory, Jo Anne, FOIA and conflict every year, so maybe we can, every other year, okay.
    • 04:56:31
      It's now done online now, okay, so yeah.
    • 04:56:35
      But that's probably a good idea, that once we get whatever is standardized, everybody go through it, because you might get some input about what they had to do with it, or that stuff, so.
    • 04:56:42
      And I like this thought about, that's one thing that I really struggle with.
    • 04:56:46
      How do we use technology, not just in the roads, but in our communication?
    • 04:56:51
      We started a website, and then Shannon, not Shannon,
    • 04:56:56
      Oh gosh, Tamara.
    • 04:56:59
      We've done it, but we don't really have anybody designated for the CTB website, and we can put a lot of this information on there in that regard, postings and stuff.
    • 04:57:11
      We do some, but it's not what it could be.
    • 04:57:14
      It could be a lot better.
    • 04:57:18
      I think that's another issue and making these, what you get is public information so making that available to the public too.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 04:57:36
      So we focused first on committees and communication about what committees are doing, partly because two of us are on committees and one person isn't.
    • 04:57:46
      So we think that we should share committee meeting summaries with the full CTB so that everybody knows what's happened in that committee
    • 04:57:55
      and I think Carol already shares the agendas in advance with everybody we couldn't remember for sure but making sure everybody's in that loop so if they so so Marty next time won't be able to stand up and say he has no idea what I was it wasn't a criticism no I know I probably wouldn't have read it had they sent it to me yeah
    • 04:58:11
      And then it was suggested that maybe the full CTB minutes could come the week after the meeting which would allow the people who miss the meeting if they have to miss to kind of stay in the loop and know if there's anything sort of coming that they need to pay attention to in particular rather than waiting for the material distribution that happens we hope a week before the meeting.
    • 04:58:36
      We talked a little bit about the need for there to be strategic communication and education about what's accomplished by the CTB or what's on deck.
    • 04:58:48
      So thinking a little bit more about what comes out after our meetings, about what we've done
    • 04:58:53
      and or how we talk to people about the work that we're doing as the board that get a little attention.
    • 04:59:03
      Several people brought up, you know, how do we put problems or challenges on the table.
    • 04:59:07
      I know in conversations with some staff people they say, you know, there's this thing that's been around for forever and nobody's really looked at it but it's a drag on how we do our work.
    • 04:59:19
      Is that something you'd ever look at?
    • 04:59:20
      It didn't seem like there's a way
    • 04:59:22
      to kind of get those brought to the table or things that we observe.
    • 04:59:27
      We wondered about the CTB adopted policies.
    • 04:59:31
      Are they in a place that one could at least look at what they are?
    • 04:59:36
      Does that need to be integrated into the onboarding process so you at least have a sense?
    • 04:59:42
      I know in a couple instances people were pulling policies out that were adopted 10 years ago, appropriately governing stuff, but there was no way to know that that even existed.
    • 04:59:53
      and then the five responsibility areas that Nick went through in his presentation.
    • 05:00:01
      Could we think about using those to structure our meetings as a way to remind us and to remind the general public what our areas of responsibility are?
    • 05:00:10
      So just having them listed on the agenda and then everything that's financial
    • 05:00:15
      gets discussed in that section and everything that's about letting contracts and then you would also probably have a monitoring section of some sort of whatever thing you're going to focus on.
    • 05:00:24
      So there's another way to potentially organize meetings.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:00:28
      There you go.
    • 05:00:31
      I was thinking, Nick, think about this.
    • 05:00:34
      What if we had at a Governor's Conference, what if we had a session on Meet the CTB?
    • 05:00:43
      I mean, we've never, I've thought about that, I was thinking about it, we focus, you know, VDOT, but we've never, most people don't even know what you guys do.
    • 05:00:51
      Now it's getting more.
    • 05:00:53
      Well, I mean, but I'm just saying what I mean, I'd have to have but I mean, I mean, I think that would be a very informative session.
    • 05:01:01
      You know, now, do we have four year rules with that?
    • 05:01:04
      Rick, if we have them, not not talking about business, but just sort of generally what the CTB is and who the members are.
    • 05:01:15
      And, you know, everyone having a chance to introduce themselves and talk about any topic they want to.
    • 05:01:23
      Yeah, open meeting anyway.
    • 05:01:26
      Actually, would y'all be up for that?
    • 05:01:32
      I mean, I think that would be a very, very, it might be even the formal, I mean, the entire audience session.
    • 05:01:39
      I mean, you guys, this is a very powerful board in terms of money that run through.
    • 05:01:46
      I mean, you know, you're talking about
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 05:01:48
      They would also reinforce with many of the stakeholders that the board is going to be here after this transition and the board is the one who's formally responsible.
    • 05:01:57
      They see all the political appointees faces but we all expire in four months.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:02:02
      You're going to be the institutional knowledge.
    • 05:02:05
      I mean the institution that keeps this.
    • 05:02:07
      Guys, we're going to plan that and I think that would be a very, you know, it'd probably be about an hour where all of you, and we'll work on the format, but where it's, you know, basically we talk about the, you know, what the board's going through and what your response, you know, what it is and just getting you some more exposure.
    • 05:02:27
      I actually think that would be very, very informative and people would like that a lot.
    • 05:02:35
      Okay.
    • 05:02:35
      Well, we're going to do that.
    • 05:02:36
      I mean, we might reach out to you, but my guess is it'll be maybe the Thursday or so of the week.
    • 05:02:45
      So if you guys are good with that, I think that would be a very good session.
    • 05:02:54
      Okay.
    • 05:02:55
      All right.
    • 05:02:55
      Anyway, I was just thinking as we're going through this.
    • 05:03:00
      actually starts the conference starts on Tuesday afternoon but then we go Wednesday morning it could be Wednesday morning but then we then there's an open Wednesday afternoon then all day Thursday Monday yeah let's while we're on these logistics we'll cut into all right so what we're going to do this at the end but so what will happen is on Monday so you guys will probably have to come in Sunday night
    • 05:03:25
      Monday we will have the workshop session and it will go through that Monday and I think Dickson and we were talking earlier will probably have an event that evening for our wives included or spouses included too and then Wednesday morning we'll have the action item or complete workshop and have the action and then at noon the conference starts
    • 05:03:49
      It's like noon to five the first day.
    • 05:03:51
      That's Tuesday.
    • 05:03:52
      Tuesday night will be the opening reception.
    • 05:03:56
      And then Wednesday we have plenary sessions, the entire group.
    • 05:04:01
      And then Wednesday afternoon is open.
    • 05:04:03
      There's hiking, there's golf, there's all the stuff for family if you're bringing that.
    • 05:04:08
      And then Thursday all day, there'll be some full sessions and breakout sessions, different types.
    • 05:04:15
      And then Friday in the morning, it'll last till about 10 o'clock or so, or 11 o'clock, and then wrap up.
    • 05:04:24
      But I think that would be, you know, Nick, we've never done it.
    • 05:04:27
      I think that would be very well perceived.
    • 05:04:31
      And that's so.
    • 05:04:35
      We won't know who the new governor will be, but we're meeting in October, so we won't know who the new governor will be.
    • 05:04:40
      But at least they'll know who you guys are.
    • 05:04:47
      I think it's the only meeting I've missed all year.
    • 05:05:03
      Okay well we sort of got but anyway turn it back over to their facilitators.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:05:09
      There's a couple ways we can go here and see what way you'd want to go or if you have another idea.
    • 05:05:13
      A lot of the issues that came up look around strengthening the board, strengthening CTB.
    • 05:05:19
      and we can distill some of these down where there's agreement and build up the action plan sort of for who's going to do what, who's going to be willing to be on this working group to achieve these goals.
    • 05:05:30
      Again, keeping things, you know, doable and doable in a short space of time so that by the end of this year you'll have things in place.
    • 05:05:39
      So an onboarding process, how would that go and specifics around that.
    • 05:05:44
      If there's no specifics we all know
    • 05:05:45
      The other thing is the strategic focus that came up in the survey and in the discussions.
    • 05:05:54
      How does the CTB focus more time and energy on strategic thinking, strategic time together?
    • 05:06:02
      So those are two things that came up very clearly.
    • 05:06:06
      Is there something else that you'd want to work on in terms of major goals for CTB between now and December?
    • 05:06:14
      It's another broad area.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:06:17
      I would just say on the first part I mean you can delegate a lot of that to the agencies and the staff you know in other words getting this I mean you know not that you wouldn't have input so we can you know if you were I mean strategically is really you and in that regard so just my thought how we get these done
    • 05:06:40
      I mean, Carol's over here going to throw something at me, but we have the support that will help get that done with your direction as to how you want to see it go.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:06:54
      We could basically take these, transcribe them, put in some recommendations, shoot them back to you, and say, here's what you could do.
    • 05:07:02
      And that could go to the agency?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:07:03
      Well, go to the secretariat's office, and then we will take care of getting the staffing necessary to get that in place.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:07:11
      Do you think it's a better discussion to have this strategic discussion?
    • 05:07:15
      How does CTB become a truly more strategic board?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:07:21
      I think that's much more undefined and more timely spent where the others I think we can pull that together for you.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:07:35
      and we'd like to do things typically in the smaller groups it just gives very often we'll have some similarities we saw here once while there's some key differences and those are more likely to get aired effectively in a smaller group I think though for the executive session if you want well or we can just say you know we have a problem Nick so let's go into closed session mr. Whitworth
    • 05:07:58
      So why don't we just divide this into two groups, diversity of opinion, maybe mix it up a bit from what you did earlier, and just voluntarily if you would divide approximately half.
    • 05:08:10
      So Secretary Layne, are you going to be in this?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:08:13
      So I have decided, not that I want to be in it, I just think that they pretty much know a lot.
    • 05:08:19
      Actually, you've exhausted my knowledge.
    • 05:08:22
      No, but I just think, really don't want to, we've got some thoughts, but I don't want to dictate those thoughts.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 05:08:30
      That sounds good.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:08:31
      Two groups of seven then?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 05:08:33
      Yep, that sounds good.
    • 05:08:33
      And as we separate you into the two groups, just a couple of probing thoughts to kind of get started.
    • 05:08:40
      First of all, people say,
    • 05:08:42
      strategic thinking but we all have different ideas of what that is so that might be a good place to start is say what does it mean to be a strategic thinking board so have some discussion about that and then kind of summarize it so we can see where the gaps are and the different perceptions and second of all what should you be strategic about what is on the horizon that you really need to put some of your time and energy and knowledge and thoughts and discussion about so what does it mean to be strategic what should you be strategic about
    • 05:09:11
      And then finally, to get to this point, how are we going to be strategic?
    • 05:09:16
      How are we going to converse with each other?
    • 05:09:17
      How are we going to modify some of the time so that we allow the platform for that?
    • 05:09:23
      So a little bit of the what and a little bit of the how and see what you come up with.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:09:28
      And in terms of procedural things, some things that we find
    • 05:09:30
      is if the board does not prioritize strategy first everybody goes and spends time with the crisis du jour whereas you spend the time with the crisis du jour by the time you resolve that everybody's brain is wiped in terms of strategic thinking so we always suggest strategic thinking early because those crises you'll find quicker ways to deal with those crises with less time strategy doesn't work that way.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 05:09:53
      And the other thing that gets in the way of strategic thinking is spending a lot of time on reporting out, which typically can be done with the timely communication that you all talked about.
    • 05:10:04
      If you get the communication, if it's in the right format that you needed it, if it's the right length, you can read that ahead of time and the reporting time can be shrunken down usually and re-prioritized toward more strategic thinking.
    • 05:10:16
      So those are just some of the things that we've seen in the past, ways that,
    • 05:10:20
      Intended or non-intended, strategic thinking gets a backseat instead of the front seat where it should belong.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:10:26
      Okay, sir, Mr. Gersetzky.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 05:10:27
      One of the problems that we face, though, is strategic thinking, strategic planning for the future.
    • 05:10:36
      We have a static situation because of the revenue equation.
    • 05:10:42
      We could think strategically about all the things that need to be done, but if we can only assume what the monies that we have now,
    • 05:10:50
      That fairly limits how strategic you can get as far as future planning.
    • 05:10:56
      Be aware of that as we go forward.
    • 05:10:59
      We can't make assumptions that we're going to have them up and have an unrestricted strategic plan.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:11:07
      That's what I was saying before, I'm not sure we haven't, but remember we are charged with allocating what we're given so we can be strategic within that.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:11:24
      And isn't it true too that there may be policy tools that could help us solve a problem without the kind of money that we might have used in a more conventional setting?
    • 05:11:37
      And I just feel like we're beginning to see that.
    • 05:11:39
      So I think we should not throw our hands up on the money.
    • 05:11:42
      We need to explore the policy.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:11:44
      That's right.
    • 05:11:44
      Necessity is the mother of invention sometimes and I think that's right.
    • 05:11:48
      I mean it's again back to, I'll use two examples I can think that that shaped our thinking.
    • 05:11:54
      One is hot lanes.
    • 05:11:55
      We had to start thinking about moving more people through, not more vehicles.
    • 05:11:59
      It wasn't a matter of
    • 05:12:01
      you know we didn't have the money we couldn't get the I mean that and the other was you know the this access management I know it really is thinking to be if we're not we don't have the money to go build another road and so we gotta how are we going to use the current asset better
    • 05:12:21
      Hey, you know, one other thing, and this is totally off the subject, but Mr. Garzynski made me think about it.
    • 05:12:26
      I meant to bring it up early.
    • 05:12:28
      We need to be thinking about the roles of what the vice chairman ought to be and the secretary.
    • 05:12:34
      Right now, they're very ceremonial.
    • 05:12:38
      But I just think, yeah, when I say that, they don't do much.
    • 05:12:42
      Sorry.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:44
      No, that's what I mean.
    • 05:12:46
      That hurts.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:49
      No, but I mean.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:50
      Gary, that's not commonly held.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:12:52
      No, but I'm just talking about if I went to bring it up about you know how we plan you know certainly I you know the meetings and different things to counter but I do think that that ought to be something we all think about too how do how do we use those positions and in a different manner because they do have some responsibilities particularly the secretary has to sign some things and they're you know in that
    • 05:13:14
      I just think that's something else.
    • 05:13:19
      As we go through and looking at that, there can be some checks and balances there because all of us are, I think this is true, everybody on this board except for Carol was appointed by the governor.
    • 05:13:36
      So that's the one thing we have in common.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:13:38
      Different governors.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:13:39
      Different governors, but by the governor.
    • 05:13:43
      And that's it.
    • 05:13:43
      Anyway, okay, sorry.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:13:45
      Just nothing else to think about.
    • 05:13:47
      If you could selectively divide into two groups of seven then.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 05:13:51
      And you could mix it up if you want to compete with a different group than you were with before.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:13:56
      Like the other group.
    • 05:13:57
      Damn, I got something choked in.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 05:14:03
      So just go ahead and divide and cluster.
    • 05:14:06
      Again, just some questions to maybe start the discussion.
    • 05:14:10
      What does it mean for the board to be strategic?
    • 05:14:12
      What does that look like?
    • 05:14:15
      What are the things that you should be strategic about?
    • 05:14:17
      And then how can you perhaps reallocate some of your time and your methods in order to provide more opportunity for this strategic thinking and decision making?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:14:29
      We should switch up.
    • 05:14:31
      It's just two groups, right?
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:14:36
      I'll switch over there.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 05:14:42
      I'm tired of you guys.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:14:51
      Sorry.
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 05:14:57
      I wish you could permanently steal the thing from that fella.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:15:11
      First of all, that's a good place to start.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 05:15:18
      What does it mean to be a strategic?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:49:31
      Strategically, one of the first things we thought about was looking at the entire network across Virginia.
    • 05:49:38
      We're moving goods and people and connecting all of this, and so looking at the issue of connectivity.
    • 05:49:44
      And while this board deals with surface transportation of rail and highways, having an understanding of the multimodal connections with air, the port, how do we all work together to strengthen the economy of Virginia?
    • 05:49:59
      How does that work?
    • 05:50:01
      That was, I think, one of the first pieces that we looked at.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:50:06
      Does that lead to how we make policies that drive transportation decisions?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:50:10
      Well, of course, and that's what we were thinking that... Scott, thank you so much for posing that question.
    • 05:50:19
      Yes, but helping us, I think, perhaps look at where we place emphasis,
    • 05:50:26
      You know, it came up that some of our discretionary decisions, it's actually a very small piece of transportation.
    • 05:50:33
      And how can we make better policies or better decisions looking across the whole network of Virginia?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:50:45
      So one thing I might throw out too, that is great.
    • 05:50:51
      One of the things we have tried to do from the secretariat level, and I think, you know, the more I understand you have, the better decisions, but also besides, within the secretariat, outside of the secretariat, this whole new thing of go Virginia and economic development, I think this board is going to have to find a way
    • 05:51:10
      Well Link to work in that now it's all the good news is they're just getting a lot of that set up but that coordination be helpful too because it would be good for you to know uh now there's a lot more proper proprietary over there and this you know maybe Dixon now I think that's maybe one of the things that we do have executive session where we have them come brief about all the projects they're working on
    • 05:51:33
      That might be something, you know, where there are potential projects and so you guys know that there got a potential for a explant in this area or that area and that may be helpful in terms of, now, you know, SMART SCALE will go through it, but at least in terms of your overall thinking, what's going on, so.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:51:54
      And the good news, it is so new.
    • 05:51:57
      Yeah, it is so new.
    • 05:51:58
      And it's going to be more, I think, project focused.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:52:00
      It's tactical knowledge.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:52:01
      But this actually is thinking looking across the whole network.
    • 05:52:08
      So two, I don't know, perhaps you and Greg might want to do the financial on that.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:52:15
      Added to that point, number one is the connectivity of the world, smart cities, smart communities.
    • 05:52:23
      Everything I read, everything I've been to forums, we're going to be living in a connected world.
    • 05:52:27
      So how do we play a role in that?
    • 05:52:29
      What's our role in that new world?
    • 05:52:32
      That's quickly approaching.
    • 05:52:37
      The financial understanding, I'll leave it to the banker and the business guy, but it's become apparent to me that while our number one authority is to decide the funding for transportation projects, with the formula of SMART SCALE and otherwise, we have very little discretion anymore.
    • 05:52:57
      I guess the board used to have 20 years ago whenever it had money to play with, but it's pretty much formula driven.
    • 05:53:04
      So what is our role going to be
    • 05:53:08
      in that other than just discussing and approving.
    • 05:53:12
      How much bandwidth do you need?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:53:14
      Well, the role before it was not formula driven, it was driven by the executive branch.
    • 05:53:19
      I mean, Charlie, how many governor's lists have you had?
    • 05:53:22
      Yeah, every governor's list, so I think it was a fallacy to think the board had any discretion before, I mean, in real discretion.
    • 05:53:33
      Because if you didn't vote for the governor's list, you didn't get to stay around very long.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 05:53:36
      But there was a discretion on spending, not by us.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:53:40
      There was.
    • 05:53:41
      There was.
    • 05:53:42
      By a governor.
    • 05:53:42
      Yeah, by a governor.
    • 05:53:43
      That's right.
    • 05:53:43
      And you're right.
    • 05:53:44
      And so, no, I think it's my personal opinion on that, Hap, is that it really is gone from that to are the parameters, the things Nick were talking about this morning, are the goals you're setting being met
    • 05:54:03
      by that allocation.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:54:05
      I would add to that Aubrey, of course that has to be based on information we have on the success of things that have happened in the past, not only with decisions we've made but the prior boards have made too across the modal ranges.
    • 05:54:17
      We've got to look at that, you know, and scrutinize that information to have the ability to make recommendations and set policies for the future.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:54:26
      I know you have financial understanding but I tell you it's also the other part of this are people generally satisfied with what's happening in other words so I know we've been really focused on I brought this up this morning because that's my back been really focused on some some objective metrics and in that but at the end of the day in addition to the objective metrics it is if people are generally satisfied that in itself is a
    • 05:54:55
      I just wanted to throw that all out because back to your point, we may not have all the money we need, but if they are satisfied that you guys are doing what you can in that, that is also something that you need to just consider.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 05:55:16
      I think the tangent to that came up at our group was
    • 05:55:26
      H. C. in the future because there's no fund for planning for the most part.
    • 05:55:32
      Not at SMART SCALE.
    • 05:55:33
      You can't just have dollars for planning.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:55:37
      But there are planning dollars out there and that's maybe that's one thing that we ought to do is to have the board updated to say okay here's where the planning dollars are in that whole that maybe that's what somebody financial understanding.
    • 05:55:51
      Yeah, there are financial dollars out there.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 05:55:55
      And then the other one that came up was, for instance, the formula that dictated 45 percent stated good repair, 27 and a half, 27 and a half.
    • 05:56:05
      What was the strategic thinking behind that?
    • 05:56:09
      And should that be a discussion that we have for the future that maybe it shouldn't be 45 percent?
    • 05:56:17
      for a state of good repair and 27 for high priority state projects, etc.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:56:27
      Let me give you the background.
    • 05:56:28
      I can answer that question for you.
    • 05:56:30
      Nick, we were dealing with it and the issue had to be exactly that.
    • 05:56:36
      We were not keeping up.
    • 05:56:39
      uh and it was the and I won't call it a guess but it was what Charlie went out and his team and looked and said you know we I think we first had 40 percent and based on feedback we got back they that's what they said about 45 percent is what was needed in the next 10 years to really start bending that curve and then the other part was just 50-50 based on working with the general assembly but no
    • 05:57:04
      That is certainly a metric.
    • 05:57:08
      Now that is a perfect case where giving the information to the General Assembly does make exactly the same.
    • 05:57:13
      Hey guys, we're into year seven now.
    • 05:57:17
      We don't need 45%.
    • 05:57:19
      Or we need, in other words, or something.
    • 05:57:21
      That's the perfect case where you go back and give them feedback and say, you know, we made that.
    • 05:57:25
      So yes, that was really based on working with them and working with the agency to say what's our best estimate as to what we need to do to get this thing turned back around.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:57:40
      That would be great news for them if you told them so we can lower that to 40% that would be the best news they ever heard.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:57:46
      Yeah, so it was never meant to be a, in fact we were just looking while you all were deliberating, all the policies, one of the things we're going to get done before we leave here is going and clean up all the policies that the board has adopted over the years that are no longer applicable.
    • 05:58:03
      1940, it was only $50, you got 50 bucks if you turn somebody in for stealing in 1940.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:58:09
      If I turn, there was a finder's fee of 50 bucks.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:58:11
      Don't get rid of that.
    • 05:58:12
      Well, I don't think.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:58:17
      Well that's what we talked about we talked about so that's what we're gonna do that's another thing let you guys know we're gonna go through back to this setting up the new board first of all saying here's no what we need to present all these or either get rid of everything and reenact the ones we want to keep I don't know how which way we'll go but that'll also get you good in up-to-date as to where what's out there in that in that
    • 05:58:45
      But sort of a little off topic there.
    • 05:58:46
      But that financial, you know, how we get to these things now, the breakdown between 1887 by district on the old formula, that is all the legislature.
    • 05:59:02
      That is all that was based on land mass and population.
    • 05:59:08
      And that's what they said that they wanted these monies to be allocated.
    • 05:59:14
      yeah in that so I think that's I do believe that's going to be a topic of discussion over the next few years particularly with limited resources is that allocation between districts I know we have saw that about on the other card about well the regional money I do think there'll be more push for other regions to raise additional revenues like Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia
    • 05:59:41
      and that so but I think that's going to be really the discussion over the next few years because it's pretty apparent now that we're not going to get a big godsend from money coming from Congress and that's so so I'm sorry you got you guys have some more up there.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 05:59:59
      Number three.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:00:01
      I do that one Dixon.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:00:02
      Dixon.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:00:04
      Communications, public engagement.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:00:09
      Oh yes.
    • 06:00:11
      In looking at the whole, we've spent a tremendous amount of time, and I think beneficial so, in SMART SCALE.
    • 06:00:20
      And I think now we will need to back off into other segments of the whole.
    • 06:00:27
      And we may find ourselves spending equivalent amount of time maybe in maintenance, or state of good repair, or bridges, or public engagement.
    • 06:00:38
      I don't think we've really had, I can't recall, we've had much of a thorough discussion of how do we utilize our public meetings?
    • 06:00:49
      And is there a better way to engage our public?
    • 06:00:53
      Some districts are more active in those public meetings than others.
    • 06:01:01
      Why?
    • 06:01:02
      What's the difference?
    • 06:01:03
      And I think one of the strategic
    • 06:01:08
      issues we should probably look to is do we need to retool our public engagement?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:01:18
      A couple comments on SMART SCALE.
    • 06:01:19
      I could not agree more.
    • 06:01:20
      In fact, I don't think enough attention, not SMART SCALE, State of Good Repair, I don't think enough attention has been given because the districts don't know that almost half their money is coming for that.
    • 06:01:32
      And you never get much credit for it when we don't talk about it.
    • 06:01:35
      But that should write itself coming up this year because that's what the board's going to be concentrating on, State of Good Repair.
    • 06:01:42
      So hopefully after this round, you'll have had two rounds of SMART SCALE and now State of Good Repair and people will see that it's a bigger pot than they were thinking in that.
    • 06:01:54
      And you're right, this came up earlier, that engaging the public, there are some that we get a lot of engagement and some areas we get one speaker.
    • 06:02:05
      or two speakers at and I'm not saying we need to have but you know I'm not sure the mode now part of that is what's prescriptively required because we use federal money and I think the key is though and I think we've been working with if Grindly was here she would harp in on this I think what's required by the federal is just the minimum
    • 06:02:29
      I think there's no way we could go wrong with more public engagement.
    • 06:02:38
      I think that's one thing that we should utilize more.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:02:42
      We just need to make it more accessible.
    • 06:02:45
      I mean, the Richmond district public hearing every year, it probably should be, you know, we probably should talk to the communities.
    • 06:02:52
      Every one of them should carry it on their local government programming network.
    • 06:02:56
      Then you might still only get 100 people there, but you might get 2,000 watching.
    • 06:03:02
      I've been around all these years.
    • 06:03:05
      Unless I was a participant in the meeting, I've never been to one.
    • 06:03:11
      Because, you know, I have other ways to get my two cents and two cents worth them.
    • 06:03:14
      But I mean, I know a lot of people that would probably watch it if they knew it was there.
    • 06:03:18
      just to see what was going on around.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 06:03:20
      I mean everybody's impacted by it, so.
    • 06:03:23
      Maybe we can just communicate the meeting itself better and distribute it better.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:03:29
      It could be a big first habit.
    • 06:03:30
      But we might want to even re-agenda our public meeting, if that's what I'm saying.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:03:37
      I think it's worthy of an hour-and-a-half conversation what would make an engaging public meeting
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:03:46
      Yeah, I can say a lot of it has been the default of the federal money and the requirement to do certain things to be able to use federal money on these jobs.
    • 06:03:57
      And that's really what's been the standard.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:03:59
      Does that require two public meetings?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:04:01
      It requires a public meeting when you're going to vote using their federal dollars.
    • 06:04:06
      So that's one public meeting.
    • 06:04:06
      Well, there's other meetings that are required other than the vote.
    • 06:04:12
      You know, they're...
    • 06:04:14
      Well, we used to have two public hearings.
    • 06:04:19
      Now we have a public hearing when we vote in a town hall when we don't, because I thought that format was better in getting engagement.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:04:30
      Well, that's what I'm saying.
    • 06:04:31
      They're both public meetings.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:04:32
      Yeah, they're public, but one is not a hearing.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:04:34
      And we ought to analyze both of those meetings a little bit.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:04:40
      The hearing is pretty, I think, quite frankly does not engage as well as the public town hall, but a hearing is required when we're voting using federal monies and that stuff.
    • 06:04:54
      So, but good, good comments.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:04:58
      I'll tell you that number four is really connected to number two.
    • 06:05:01
      It was determining, you know, the metrics, performance, the return on our investments, always looking for efficiencies, you know, where it's appropriate.
    • 06:05:10
      That was really Greg's strong point.
    • 06:05:12
      Is there anything you want to add to that?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 06:05:14
      No, I think that happened.
    • 06:05:17
      I both have the same incidents.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:05:20
      That's the most input we get from the public, at least for me anyway.
    • 06:05:24
      I get more input on that subject than anything.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:05:28
      And then finally, there was one on trends, which I think you've done a very good job of helping us, you know,
    • 06:05:35
      at least engage ourselves with regarding demographics, climate, perhaps sequestration, different trends that could affect what's going on at the federal level.
    • 06:05:47
      How does all of that, you're smiling, impact our decisions?
    • 06:05:52
      I did turn to Alison at one point and said, are you laughing at me?
    • 06:05:57
      I'm not.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:05:57
      No, no.
    • 06:05:58
      We're watching a note that's going up while you're speaking.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:06:01
      On that topic, I think the big one is resiliency and sea level rise, particularly in light of the president's new guidelines where he was no longer requiring, the directive order did not require that consideration in infrastructure.
    • 06:06:25
      I don't think that's wise.
    • 06:06:30
      Why would we build something without contemplating that it's going to be impacted?
    • 06:06:36
      We have limited resources have consequences.
    • 06:06:39
      Why would we want to build it more than once?
    • 06:06:42
      I mean, it just doesn't make any sense to me, but I do think that's going to be a big, big topic here.
    • 06:06:48
      We have no money really set aside for those assets that are currently impacted.
    • 06:06:56
      We have, what is it, 40 miles, Charlie, of interstate?
    • 06:06:59
      That might be too, that might be high.
    • 06:07:00
      But it's quite a few miles of, maybe it's primary and interstate and Hampton Roads.
    • 06:07:07
      that you know are susceptible to being washed away and that and so should we I mean I would suspect if they were ever washed away we wouldn't build them back the same way we put them in I mean you know so in there but I do think that's going to be a big big topic of going forward and that
    • 06:07:32
      How about the other group?
    • 06:07:33
      Was that synthesized?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:07:35
      I would say that we're waiting for the House of Commons.
    • 06:07:40
      Nicely done.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:07:42
      I would say the only, at least I took a few notes.
    • 06:07:46
      So the one big idea that I think we had that isn't on your list and it's more of an umbrella kind of
    • 06:07:54
      is to say that VTrans implementation is the strategic avenue under which all of this should happen because VTrans is our document, our tool, our vision.
    • 06:08:08
      And so I think for our group it was like how do we take where we are, what people have come to accept,
    • 06:08:15
      and build out from that, you know, whether it's more planning dollars or more of any of this other kind of stuff, VTrans is the core of what we believe and what we think we're charged to do with the rail plan sort of being, you know, a complementary piece and if there's an IT plan, I mean, so sort of those three areas seem to be where we should be spending our time and how we should be structuring our strategy.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:08:42
      I would just add to that the concept of it being inclusive and modally balanced from a VTrans perspective and starting out with no preconceptions about what an appropriate modal balance is.
    • 06:08:55
      That's a big step forward or a big ask.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:08:58
      And I will tell you, this is one area where Nick's put a lot of time in, but we've also struggled in this.
    • 06:09:05
      And it's back to your comment, Gary.
    • 06:09:09
      Good planning, we may not be able to execute because of resources.
    • 06:09:15
      And so that's really what gave a lot to SmartScale.
    • 06:09:21
      In a lot of ways, it's very, very good, but it's also the recognition that we don't have enough money.
    • 06:09:27
      I've said this before, I think the best way to get more money is to use what you got more wisely, but we do struggle with the plan and planning and what we would really plan and then what you have to do because we're in touch of a big whole
    • 06:09:50
      taking half our money, 45%, having to know we have to use that right off the top to maintain the current infrastructure.
    • 06:09:57
      What's that have left?
    • 06:09:59
      And I would dare say if we had unlimited resources that we would do things in different order.
    • 06:10:05
      Perfect example.
    • 06:10:06
      We're getting all kinds of grief from your area, Hap, because we've done northbound or we've done southbound and they want us to do northbound.
    • 06:10:16
      And why would you put a bridge in without doing the other?
    • 06:10:18
      Well, if we didn't have limited resources, we probably would do that.
    • 06:10:23
      But I can point to all kinds of places around the state where we've had to fix the problem most pressing.
    • 06:10:30
      and move on.
    • 06:10:31
      So I think there is this balance.
    • 06:10:34
      It's not saying that that bridge won't get done.
    • 06:10:37
      What it is saying is compared to other needs in the Commonwealth right now, it is not the top one.
    • 06:10:45
      You know, there's others in front of it.
    • 06:10:47
      But we do understand that, hey, you know, if I was building that, maybe I would, except we don't have that type of resources.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 06:10:58
      We may have to come to the conclusion though that under VTrans it may be the responsibility of this board to come up with a prioritization of major projects that are important to the overall network
    • 06:11:13
      of the Commonwealth.
    • 06:11:15
      We have a few up in Northern Virginia that we know are staring us in the face.
    • 06:11:19
      The Long Bridge, something's going to have to be done about the American Legion Bridge.
    • 06:11:25
      Those are big items, or the Roslinton.
    • 06:11:28
      Everybody's district probably could put some on the table that they think are going to be important to that network.
    • 06:11:34
      But I think as part of strategic planning, we're going to have to prioritize, OK,
    • 06:11:42
      If we have limited resources but we have to hit the top ten and we have to start chipping away at them, what are they?
    • 06:11:49
      What's the most important thing to be done today in the Commonwealth?
    • 06:11:53
      Could we name that?
    • 06:11:54
      See, and I think that's what we've got to get to.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:11:56
      I can tell you, I can name that.
    • 06:11:58
      That's the Long Bridge.
    • 06:12:00
      There you go.
    • 06:12:00
      I can tell you right after.
    • 06:12:01
      That's after, it's after the things we've already got in place.
    • 06:12:05
      Right.
    • 06:12:06
      Yeah.
    • 06:12:06
      I mean, I mean, that we've already got going, but I mean, right now, the future of freight and rail and passenger trains are all tied to Long Bridge.
    • 06:12:20
      I mean, now that doesn't mean all the others aren't very important.
    • 06:12:22
      81, we don't have a plan for 81, really.
    • 06:12:25
      I mean, we're doing a lot of stuff, but that's your, you know.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:12:30
      And with Longbridge's, the issues, because it has such a direct impact on 95 and 66 as well.
    • 06:12:38
      I think is also why it's such, anyway, it's such a critical issue.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:12:41
      If you look at the port, I'm sorry, go ahead Shannon.
    • 06:12:45
      But what that also means is that's why we, we're very open to public-private partnerships and other things because, you know, we're going to have to be innovative to get some of those done.
    • 06:12:57
      And that means, you know, like or dislike, whatever the policy is coming out of Congress, we got to find a way to optimize it.
    • 06:13:08
      In other words, if it's moving more to competition, we shouldn't just say we don't like it.
    • 06:13:12
      We've got to figure out how are we going to compete and that type of stuff.
    • 06:13:16
      So I think that's important in the planning to recognize what do you have to do to attract these other monies.
    • 06:13:25
      It may not be exactly what you want to do, but that's what it can.
    • 06:13:30
      In other words, don't let the perfect get in the way of getting something done.
    • 06:13:36
      If we can get 75% of the benefits for 10% of the cost, we're going to have to do that.
    • 06:13:46
      I'm not saying it's bad or good, I'm just saying that's where we are.
    • 06:13:53
      And so you're right, I think that's where we've really struck on planning.
    • 06:13:58
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:14:04
      I was going to follow up on what Mary was saying and some of what you were saying regarding VTrans.
    • 06:14:15
      VTrans should absolutely be, I think, on a strategic list, but from my perspective, it's very district driven.
    • 06:14:23
      So I'm kind of prioritizing things within the Lynchburg District.
    • 06:14:27
      What I think, looking strategically, how do we do that across the whole network?
    • 06:14:32
      And so that's how I see it different.
    • 06:14:35
      I think VTrans is a little difficult.
    • 06:14:39
      I think it's limited at this point.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:14:42
      I guess when I say VTrans, I don't think about that Tier 1 list so much as I think about those 10 or 11 goal sets in the front that are really, I think, a vision for the future.
    • 06:14:54
      How it plays out, how we decide to use the money, we can mess with that, but that statement of goals is actually, I think, really important and should drive how we move forward.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:15:05
      Sharon, just what you said goes back to something else we talked about.
    • 06:15:10
      Smart scale doesn't take away your brain.
    • 06:15:12
      and this whole thing about, you know, that's why I say numbers are, you know, they're important and the score and the whole bad that it's very transparent.
    • 06:15:23
      But if people just feel better because they got this project built because that's their number one political, you have the ability to do that.
    • 06:15:32
      it's just that it's not the default and I think that's what but we shouldn't I would encourage you not to back away from that is my point is the point I'm trying to make you know in other words if you know that isn't the top of your district but everybody else wants that built well that might be very important because success breeds success and so
    • 06:15:53
      I'm just throwing out there it's only the default because we were so out there just politically doing things that if you looked at him you go nobody would do it that way now we got a default but that doesn't mean we don't override it once in a while you know in that regard so that's this whole thing between
    • 06:16:15
      Unlimited resources and limited resources and visioning and planning and getting something done versus saying, well, it doesn't fit our plan.
    • 06:16:24
      I wish I had an answer, but it's just going to be, I mean, sort of putting one foot, you know, understanding where you're going.
    • 06:16:31
      That's why I say I'm much better at visioning than planning.
    • 06:16:34
      I know I want to get there, and if my plan calls me to get, go this way, but I can't do it, but I know if I do this, it may not be a straight path, but I'm still going that direction.
    • 06:16:42
      That's the way I go.
    • 06:16:43
      And I think that's a little bit about what we're going to have to do here.
    • 06:16:49
      The ultimate goal is here and just keep, you know, hopefully the plan may lead us one way, but if it doesn't lead that way, if you're still going towards the goal, then don't throw it out.
    • 06:17:03
      I know that's not very, you know,
    • 06:17:06
      All you engineers out there, I know that's what I discovered in that, but I don't mean that in and out, but in terms of just where we're, it's just the environment we're in and that stuff.
    • 06:17:19
      So, but I think all the ideas today have been very, very, I mean, you tell me, has this been a, is this where, what you were looking for to at least get the conversation going?
    • 06:17:31
      I think if nothing else, it's a recognition we understand somewhat what we got to deal with, but there is no template.
    • 06:17:41
      We are setting some, you know, other than, you know, there's some good governance things that we can look at best practices, but there's no template for really what we're doing because we, you know, all those things we talked about.
    • 06:17:57
      Any other, this is where I was hoping we'd get to today through this part.
    • 06:18:03
      Is there anything else the board wants to talk about or staff, anything Nick, Charlie, Jennifer, anything that anybody, John, Quentin, anything out there, Garrett, Rob, do you think that just from a first time through that we should talk about?
    • 06:18:24
      We are going to clean up the code, I mean the policies in that, and I don't know why we didn't think about that before, but I guess I will say this, for two and a half years we were just dead on.
    • 06:18:38
      Look, we couldn't have got here today without SmartScale.
    • 06:18:42
      I mean, so we can, you know, it's pretty cool now we're talking about, you know, we can maneuver around, but without that guts of it, we wouldn't be in here.
    • 06:18:50
      We'd still be back
    • 06:18:52
      You know, yelling why some district got the other and we couldn't explain to anybody why we did.
    • 06:18:57
      I still remember in Lynchburg, that guy came up who wanted to sidewalk.
    • 06:19:01
      It was a $200,000, $209,000 sidewalk.
    • 06:19:04
      Charlotte County.
    • 06:19:05
      We got it.
    • 06:19:06
      I would have almost paid for it myself because he'd been here for 20, 20 years.
    • 06:19:12
      I said, I can't believe it.
    • 06:19:13
      20 years, we can't find 200 grand to get this guy a sidewalk.
    • 06:19:17
      I mean, I mean, but I mean, so, you know, and I'm sure we overrode whatever policy we have, but I mean, it's that, but it's just for the environment we're in and that stuff, so.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:19:29
      He got the sidewalk.
    • 06:19:30
      Y'all can rest.
    • 06:19:32
      No, it was more than $200,000.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:19:35
      Looked at my salary and said, whoa, a little different than what it used to be.
    • Henry "Hap" Connors Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:19:40
      HOT sidewalk.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:19:44
      So that point just don't, you know, there's, you know, the districts, I mean, you know, it's given us a guy, but we can, you know, vary from that.
    • 06:19:55
      All we have to make sure is that people understand why we're doing it.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:19:57
      That's it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:19:59
      and that so.
    • 06:20:01
      All right, couple of other things then.
    • 06:20:03
      We talked about the next meeting is in Northern Virginia and so we'll probably come in Monday night.
    • 06:20:12
      You guys will be coming in Monday night.
    • 06:20:14
      It's a Tuesday and then Gary's got us lined up something Tuesday evening.
    • 06:20:21
      Just so you know, we'll be having the public town hall
    • 06:20:27
      Monday night.
    • 06:20:28
      If any of y'all would like to join us, you're more than welcome.
    • 06:20:32
      Four to six.
    • 06:20:33
      It'll be four to six town hall, so any of y'all would like to come in early?
    • 06:20:38
      It'd be great to have you out there.
    • 06:20:43
      I thought I'd invite you.
    • 06:20:47
      And then after that, we'll have the Governor's Conference.
    • 06:20:55
      And at the next two, those two, we'll make sure we set aside some time for this discussion.
    • 06:21:00
      I mean, we'll certainly have follow up from the facilitators.
    • 06:21:05
      So we'll follow up on that.
    • 06:21:07
      Of course, we've got some action items already that we're going to be working on.
    • 06:21:10
      So we'll keep you up to date on those.
    • 06:21:14
      and then we'll be at the conference and I'll get you information about I've already talked to Georgia and Renique and everybody that you know thinks that'd be a home run so we're going to have a session at the conference meet the CTB or we'll call it something like that and I hope you would stay though as much as you can that week and bring your spouses or and if there's someone to bring children I have no issue with that I mean
    • 06:21:42
      You got one room, but no issue with it.
    • 06:21:47
      By the way, we have the entire conference center.
    • 06:21:49
      So it would be a great time, you know, in terms in that.
    • 06:21:52
      So, um, and then, um, we have one more meeting after that, and that will probably be in the Richmond area, uh, in December.
    • 06:22:02
      Uh, and, uh, then the next meeting after that would be with the new administration.
    • 06:22:08
      So.
    • Mary Hughes HynesMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:22:09
      We have the dates.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:22:15
      Yes, we're going to put them out there, but I would tell you everything is subject to them.
    • 06:22:19
      But we're going to put out there the dates, yes, for that.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:22:25
      And that's all.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:22:26
      So, thank you all for coming, and I think this is something that, you know, we ought to, the board ought to consider doing once a year, just in general, not that we don't have time other, but we were, Quentin was talking about there, 32 years, he's in a VDOT and these CTB meetings, he's never seen any meeting like this.
    • 06:22:52
      We never even talked about stuff like this.
    • 06:22:56
      Thank you for your leadership on this Aubrey.
    • E. Scott KasprowiczMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:23:05
      I think it's extraordinary that this board is having a day like this and discussing the things we discussed today.
    • 06:23:09
      So it comes in large part from your leadership and thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 06:23:14
      I think it's been, you know, I do, Marty said it's a great board and it's charged with a heck of a lot of responsibility.
    • 06:23:24
      and that stuff.
    • 06:23:25
      Alright, well everybody, safe drives.
    • 06:23:29
      Thanks a lot.