Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 4/20/2016
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   4/20/2016

Attachments
  • Meeting agenda.pdf
  • Meeting minutes.pdf
  • “Sergeant Aaron Xavier Wittman Memorial Bridge” Commemorative Naming of the bridge on State Route 10, Old Hundred Road, over the C.pdf
  • Fiscal Years 2016 - 21 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers, Feb. 19 - March 23, 2016.pdf
  • Addition of projects to the Six-Year Improvement Program, Fiscal Years 2016 - 2021.pdf
  • Approval of proposed limited access control change, Route 134 (Magruder Boulevard) bridge replacement (Brick Kiln Creek), York County and Ha.pdf
  • Rail industrial access, Performance Livestock and Feed Co., Henry County.pdf
  • Economic Development Access Program project bond period moratorium.pdf
  • Economic development access, Graystone Industrial Park, Phase I and Phase II (deallocation) Project 0875-034-781, M501 and Project 0875-034-781,.pdf
  • Adoption of House Bill 2 recommendations for preparation of the Draft Fiscal Years 2017 - 22 Six-Year Improvement Program.pdf
  • Affirmation and Ratification of Commissioner’s Approval of Award and Execution of a Design-Build Contract for the Greater Richmond Transit Compa.pdf
  • Commending Robert O. (Bob) Chase.pdf
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning, Miss Valentine.
    • 00:00:07
      Good morning.
    • 00:00:08
      Are there any in the other room over there?
    • 00:00:21
      Okay, thanks.
    • 00:00:22
      You can go check, just see if we can get them in here, because I know we have a couple of guests.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:00:29
      Are we streaming?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:37
      Okay, so let me call back to order the April
    • 00:00:43
      Workshops Session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:47
      What we really have left this morning is the reports from the executive staff here.
    • 00:00:55
      Before we do that, we have a guest that I promised I would let him address us before we get into this.
    • 00:01:03
      The campaign has been a long-term city manager here in the city of Lynchburg, and I found out, and I guess I've known this before, he's retiring here in a couple of
    • 00:01:12
      Munch, not only the city but the state will surely miss his guiding hand and what you've seen a little bit yesterday of what he's been responsible for and he informed me yesterday.
    • 00:01:23
      He also tutors and teaches and several of his students are now in positions around the Commonwealth so your legacy, Mr. Payne, is well deserved and we appreciate you being in front of us today.
    • 00:01:37
      Please welcome.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:01:38
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary and Mr. Commissioner.
    • 00:01:40
      It's an honor to be here.
    • 00:01:42
      I just want to take a brief moment to welcome you all again to Lynchburg.
    • 00:01:47
      I hope that you had a great day yesterday.
    • 00:01:48
      I know the mayor was here to give some welcoming remarks, but I hope that you enjoyed your tour.
    • 00:01:53
      And I hope you have an appreciation of Lynchburg that maybe you didn't have before you got here.
    • 00:01:57
      For those of you who hadn't been here before, please come back.
    • 00:01:59
      And for those of you who had been here before, I hope you saw some changes, some very positive changes about what has been going on in a very dynamic
    • 00:02:06
      Community of really a quarter of a million people, a metropolitan area of a quarter of a million people of four counties in the city.
    • 00:02:13
      We are very pleased with the support that we've gotten from VDOT and from CTB in a number of areas.
    • 00:02:19
      I know you saw some of our multimodal components yesterday.
    • 00:02:23
      Jennifer, I'm going to hit that right away because I forgot it the other night at my remarks at the public hearing.
    • 00:02:28
      But we are very pleased with the support.
    • 00:02:31
      We have a new transfer station for GLTC.
    • 00:02:34
      We have a new operations and maintenance building under construction that I believe you saw yesterday.
    • 00:02:39
      Did you see it?
    • 00:02:40
      Okay.
    • 00:02:40
      But anyway, so that's been wonderful.
    • 00:02:43
      And then HB2 includes some funding for a circulator downtown, which we really think is the next step in helping downtown to work.
    • 00:02:50
      And we're going to use that as a springboard to apply for a $30 million tiger grant.
    • 00:02:54
      to support the downtown streetscape improvements that are really the next step as we do major utility line replacements across the downtown area.
    • 00:03:02
      So your support has been very critical to that.
    • 00:03:06
      I have to mention the train.
    • 00:03:07
      We had the 611 in here two weeks ago and we had a lot of folks in town, but we have folks from all over the place every day riding the Amtrak, the two trains to the northeast corridor.
    • 00:03:17
      Folks coming as far away as Blacksburg and even points south.
    • 00:03:22
      We are very supportive and very excited about extending the train to Roanoke and then even down to Bristol.
    • 00:03:27
      That's something that we really do appreciate your efforts up there.
    • 00:03:32
      Finally, I just want to briefly touch on the Outfellows Road Project.
    • 00:03:35
      We're very appreciative of the funding that was given to us for that project, that important economic development project that has very strong support from our
    • 00:03:43
      from our major university here, from the businesses in that area and certainly from city council and even from the legislature.
    • 00:03:52
      We are very excited that the first phase is under construction and thrilled to think that the second phase will follow quickly on its heels.
    • 00:04:00
      So the support that's in HB2 for the second phase of that Outfellows Road project is critically important to get the benefits that the first phase has promised.
    • 00:04:10
      So I want to thank you for your support there.
    • 00:04:12
      Again, Mr. Secretary, thank you for the opportunity to welcome you again to Lynchburg.
    • 00:04:16
      We hope that you will all come back and enjoy the rest of your day in beautiful downtown Lynchburg.
    • 00:04:20
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:21
      Thank you, Mr. Payne.
    • 00:04:24
      Let me also start again and thank our host last evening, Mrs. Valentine.
    • 00:04:29
      Her and her husband Mike had us all over at their beautiful home and good dinner, good conversation and so very much appreciate the hospitality and that goes for everybody here in the city of Lynchburg.
    • 00:04:42
      Always a good time to come here and see what's going on and appreciate the hospitality you've shown us.
    • 00:04:49
      All right, so we're going to get into the reports.
    • 00:04:52
      Let me just mention, I know a big one will be the bus rapid transit.
    • 00:04:56
      I'm going to lead that conversation when it gets to my area, my report here, and a couple of others.
    • 00:05:03
      But Ms. Mitchell, why don't you start on a few things, what's going on in DRPT.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:05:09
      Sure, mainly I wanted to give you all an update as a follow-up from our last two meetings in regard to the resolutions passed for the Virginia Beach Light Rail.
    • 00:05:19
      Just as an update, on April 5th, the City Council did meet and they voted to pass a resolution that authorized Hampton Roads Transit to enter into a grant agreement with DRPT for the light rail vehicles.
    • 00:05:34
      During that time, HRT also negotiated a bid for the vehicles through their manufacturer and received a price that is within the budget that they have and they've determined that based on the production schedule is actually shorter than they thought it was going to have to be which means that they don't have to issue a notice to proceed until December of 2016 in order to keep with the construction schedule.
    • 00:06:00
      What that means, we've also, during your meeting, you actually, you also asked that the city execute a memorandum of understanding with the state, which we did last week, and also an agreement, a binding agreement for reimbursement of costs related to the light rail vehicles.
    • 00:06:21
      So we have that agreement in hand and I plan to execute it this week.
    • 00:06:26
      That agreement basically ensures that should the City Council move forward with a notice to proceed for the vehicles in December, should they
    • 00:06:36
      and the state and the city begins to incur costs associated with those vehicles if there's a decision in the future by the city to cancel the project any costs that would be incurred by the state would be reimbursed by the city and the city would also be responsible for any penalties and outstanding payments that would be associated with that so again we expect to have all of those executed by the end of this month as the CTB had asked in your resolution and
    • 00:07:05
      Let me make a point on that if I may.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:09
      You mentioned about the cost of the light rail vehicles and able to order them later, but there is also a provision that that will be more cost than them actually putting them in their normal schedule and in the agreement there is a provision that those costs are borne totally by the city.
    • 00:07:29
      So I'd like to point here that we're going to talk about bus wrap travel later, but we have limited the cost to the state in this project.
    • 00:07:42
      In other words, we have that
    • 00:07:45
      Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:08:06
      I want to make the board know that these documents and it will be the execution of your resolution that we have made all we're going to offer on the light rail in Virginia Beach.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:21
      I would like to mention that the vote was a 9-2 vote with city council in the positive direction.
    • 00:08:30
      But there's still a lot of work to be done between now and when the 30th or something designs end up being done.
    • 00:08:37
      The city is making some commitment to leasing some space.
    • 00:08:41
      I think they understand that there's some gaps they have to do now to be prepared for a
    • 00:08:49
      McPherson Jr., John K. McPherson Jr.,
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:18
      Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John
    • 00:09:36
      One of the things we're going to require is we're not going to enter into a procurement they're not ready for.
    • 00:09:41
      So we may say, you're not ready.
    • 00:09:44
      And so I'll let Ms. Mitchell talk to that.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:47
      So we had a group under the American Public Transportation Association, which is the public transit association, brought in a group of experts in light rail as a peer review.
    • 00:09:59
      Smith, either CEOs or senior executives from the four largest systems in the United States that have light rail, which is Utah, Dallas, Charlotte, and Los Angeles.
    • 00:10:12
      And they came in for a week, met with the city, met with us, met with HRT.
    • 00:10:17
      And essentially they came out and their recommendations are that this is not a project in crisis right now.
    • 00:10:24
      The budget appears to be adequate for the level of design that they have.
    • 00:10:30
      However, they had some concerns about a number of things the city still needs to do to get ready to manage a large design-build contract.
    • 00:10:38
      Those are things like setting up the right project management organization, getting additional expertise on board that has experience building light rail under design-build procurement, setting up the correct policies and procedures that are needed in order to have a nimble project team that can manage a large design-build contract.
    • 00:10:59
      and getting all the agreements and all that sort of the infrastructure in place to be ready to go with the project and all of that is needed long before they even issue an RFP for this and so their concern is that you still have time to catch up but you need to get started now in putting all of those things in place because otherwise you're not going to be ready to manage such a large design-build contract.
    • 00:11:27
      And the cost risks of not being ready are so much greater than the cost that you can incur now to put all these things in place if you do it right.
    • 00:11:36
      So we've sent a letter to the mayor with that report asking them to not delay in getting these things in place and not to wait until after a referendum, for example.
    • 00:11:47
      That report has been very helpful.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:00
      It's a great guide for anyone that's taking on a project this magnitude.
    • 00:12:16
      McPherson Jr., John M. Smith Jr.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:38
      I want to say Mr. Malbon has been a strong voice to them saying obviously the resolution says you don't have too much procurement but we're not going to let state funds be put into a procurement that we don't think is going to be successful.
    • 00:12:56
      I think Mr. Fralin said it's just like developing a project, you're going to have to spend some money to get the project to see it is.
    • 00:13:08
      That political risk, I'll make this statement, I don't know what light rail is going to cost in Virginia Beach, but it's going to cost more than it would have cost a year ago, because of the political angst and where they've been, and we'll talk about that a little bit more with bus rapid transit, but that factor is a real risk that the private parties are going to put into their bids, just no doubt about it.
    • 00:13:31
      We want to make sure they're ready, encourage them, but make sure the board understands the only thing the resolution requires is that they have to be in procurement.
    • 00:13:40
      That does not mean that the state's going to let it go forward if they're not ready.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:45
      That's why it's so important that we hear this peer review because improperly you mitigate that risk when you justify it.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:52
      You can, that's right.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:53
      So that's it for my update, so I'll have to take any other questions.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:01
      24, from Ms. Mitchell.
    • 00:14:05
      Okay, Mr. Kilpatrick.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:06
      I have three items today.
    • 00:14:08
      Yesterday, I believe Carol had pushed out to you John Lawson's quarterly financial report.
    • 00:14:15
      We have moved to pushing that out to you if you had any questions.
    • 00:14:19
      I don't know if you've had a chance to look at it, but sort of in a real simple language, we're not seeing any anomalies in our
    • 00:14:27
      McPherson Jr., John M. Smith Jr.
    • 00:14:42
      activity related to the Norris Bridge.
    • 00:14:45
      The Norris Bridge is State Route 3 at the far end of the northern neck, connects to the northern neck of the Middle Peninsula across the Rappahannock River.
    • 00:14:54
      The bridge is 50 plus years old.
    • 00:14:57
      It is about two miles long and it's a bridge that we've maintained.
    • 00:15:05
      Again, since it was built, it is not a structurally deficient bridge.
    • 00:15:10
      But there are concerns amongst folks that live in that part of the state because of the size of the bridge and the length and the height over the water and some other things.
    • 00:15:18
      There continues to be this concern.
    • 00:15:21
      One of the things that I asked Chief Engineer Garrett Moore to do is put a team together to go down and physically to the bridge site and look at opportunities in terms of
    • 00:15:33
      different ideas getting a very group of our folks from around the department together to look at options and opportunities.
    • 00:15:43
      There are no inexpensive ways to replace or fully rehabilitate that structure and some of that discussion that we had yesterday about state of good repair I wanted to make clear that this group of about two dozen structures in Virginia really fall outside of the bounds of what we believe is practical
    • 00:16:03
      in terms of what can be covered under state of good repair.
    • 00:16:06
      Again, Garrett and his team are going to be down there in the next couple of weeks looking at the bridge, really brainstorming about how would you, what are some opportunities and how would you, how would you rehabilitate and or replace that bridge.
    • 00:16:20
      And that will give us a better idea, frankly, on the cost.
    • 00:16:23
      But I don't, I just don't see within the world of our financial resources within transportation
    • 00:16:31
      to be able to put a large outlay towards a project like that without some special funding.
    • 00:16:38
      And again, special funding, I don't want to be sugar coating it.
    • 00:16:41
      The bridge was originally designed as a toll bridge or built as a toll bridge.
    • 00:16:46
      Tolls were lifted when the original debt was paid off.
    • 00:16:48
      The challenge on a bridge like that is it's a fairly low volume, about 8,000 cars a day, and the math, you could see the math would cause a very, very high toll rate in order to retire the debt.
    • 00:17:02
      You know, other options, we will always look for federal funding options, but those are frankly limited.
    • 00:17:07
      I mean, we talked yesterday about the Fast Lane Program and Tiger Grants, but those will, you know, projects like this will stress even programs like that.
    • 00:17:17
      Again, I just wanted to make it clear, some of you may receive letters from... Let me make a comment on the letters, if I may.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:26
      They've been going around.
    • 00:17:27
      And this gets back to House Bill 2 is great, but it's not a cure-all for everything.
    • 00:17:35
      Because I've gotten a letter from several legislators that say they want us to immediately put this project to be scored under House Bill 2.
    • 00:17:43
      Well, first of all, I'm not sure.
    • 00:17:45
      It's not a capacity improvement that it actually, and I see Mr. Donohue back there shaking his head, that actually would meet the criteria under House Bill 2.
    • 00:17:54
      If it did, Mr. Kilpatrick has mentioned out there's 8,000 cars a day.
    • 00:18:00
      We're talking about a several hundred million dollar project minimum.
    • 00:18:04
      I don't think you're going to see, in terms of competing against statewide funds, that being scored very highly.
    • 00:18:11
      I shouldn't prejudge it, but I'm not even sure in that.
    • 00:18:14
      If you could state a good repair, as Mr. Kilpatrick has pointed out, that would take all the state of good repair in that particular region for the next decade or maybe two, assuming that we could even do that.
    • 00:18:28
      So this is an issue and VDOT has made clear it is safe.
    • 00:18:38
      and not in need of replacement at this time but there is a large public outcry that you have seen around it and of course I think a lot of this comes from people are seeing we're starting a new project about the state there must be monies available so let's get in line to get our share and I have no issue with that but if you look outside of this region where we've attacked this and Northern Virginia projects and Hampton Roads
    • 00:19:06
      They have had an additional funding source.
    • 00:19:09
      So without that, it's going to be difficult, other than us, to maintain the bridge.
    • 00:19:14
      So I just want to point out that this is an issue, and certainly grants.
    • 00:19:21
      But I mean, if you look at the fast lane application, around the country, there are, including in the state of Virginia, a more
    • 00:19:35
      benefit-cost relationship factors in there.
    • 00:19:38
      So I'm not suggesting this is important and the people in that regard, I'm just saying that we still face some challenges.
    • 00:19:45
      And I think VDOT has taken the appropriate approach as to maintaining it, but to replace it would be a significant departure.
    • 00:19:55
      House Bill 2 allows you to make any decision in terms of that but a significant departure from where we are so we'll keep you informed but I just we wanted to make sure you understood we just weren't ignoring it and I'm comfortable that what VDOT is doing is the appropriate it's not safe
    • 00:20:15
      But if you look at it, you'll see that there's some concrete that is cracked and stuff underneath.
    • 00:20:20
      But it's a steel girder in between, but I'm not an engineer, but I trust them.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:25
      The bridge itself is not structurally deficient.
    • 00:20:29
      That doesn't even make one of our top bridges, it's struck with division.
    • 00:20:32
      It does not.
    • 00:20:33
      It is a bridge though that requires constant attention, and we provide that constant attention.
    • 00:20:39
      Most recently, some deck repairs.
    • 00:20:42
      I won't go into the details of the design of the bridge, but basically there's a concrete riding surface that occasionally breaks loose, and we have to cast a, basically it's a pothole patch on the steel deck.
    • 00:20:55
      And that will continue and we have other maintenance activities to ensure that this bridge remains safe and as you heard from Chief Engineer, our bridge inspection program is among the best in the country and we work very diligently to protect these assets as well as protecting the public.
    • 00:21:17
      If at any time we believe that a facility is not safe,
    • 00:21:20
      We will either post that structure and or close it temporarily to traffic.
    • 00:21:26
      There is no indication at all that the Norris Bridge is in any danger of going into that classification.
    • 00:21:36
      The last thing I have is VDOT won a national award yesterday for design build.
    • 00:21:44
      The Design-Build Institute of America, which is the organization that fosters Design-Build, awarded the Virginia Department of Transportation, actually yesterday, Owner of the Year Award.
    • 00:21:58
      I got a congratulatory email from a friend of mine that went to college with him.
    • 00:22:02
      He's an executive at one of the largest vertical construction companies in the country.
    • 00:22:08
      In the vertical world, it's very common to go through design-build on larger projects.
    • 00:22:15
      But in the world of highways, we are truly a leader, and I just wanted to highlight a couple of things.
    • 00:22:22
      Our first design-build project was in 2004.
    • 00:22:25
      In 2016, we had 29 design-build projects under construction valued at $1.17 billion.
    • 00:22:33
      That doesn't account for P3s.
    • 00:22:34
      That's just what I'll call bread and butter design-build contracts.
    • 00:22:39
      We've also completed another 45 design-build contracts since 2004.
    • 00:22:45
      Our program is very solid.
    • 00:22:48
      We are a leader, as I said, in design-build.
    • 00:22:52
      We have found we're working on a federal design-build contract now and finding that we have advanced significantly further than even the federal government in terms of the world's design-build.
    • 00:23:06
      Our contracts typically are coming in on budget and on time.
    • 00:23:10
      O'Brien Jr., John M. Brown, John K. Matney Jr.,
    • 00:23:31
      And it allows us to use innovation and the constructability that comes when you marry the contractor and the designer.
    • 00:23:43
      Again, that office is run by Shalinda Patel, who's also a past recipient of a national award.
    • 00:23:49
      They work for the chief engineer and, again, do a fantastic job in the world of design build.
    • 00:23:55
      So I was real glad to see that we won that owner of the year award.
    • 00:23:59
      That's all I have.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:00
      I've got a question for you, but I want to make a comment on that.
    • 00:24:04
      As you know, legislation, Charlie mentioned P3s, legislation was passed this year.
    • 00:24:09
      Many things became a P3 because there was a part of our design bill, the alternative technical concepts that could not be done under existing state law without being in a P3.
    • 00:24:20
      That was rectified this year.
    • 00:24:21
      That's correct.
    • 00:24:22
      So a lot of P3s in the past would have simply been a design bill with ATC.
    • 00:24:27
      that allows us, and you all understand, in other words, we were able to get the alternative technical concept from a contractor and be able to purchase them and use them even if we don't use that contractor, where before we would only do that after we awarded the bid.
    • 00:24:42
      So that's really the defining, really when we go outside of our normal procurement, it is truly for a risk that we can't, basically a financing risk.
    • 00:24:56
      that we don't have under procurement when we go into a P3.
    • 00:25:00
      So I want to point that out.
    • 00:25:01
      A lot of things that we saw with P3s in the past, they'll be called design-built with ATC.
    • 00:25:07
      And Charlie, would you also mention what's going on at Morgan's Ford?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:12
      Absolutely.
    • 00:25:18
      Page County, Clark County, across the, I don't know which fork of the Shenandoah River, we have a low water bridge that has existed there for a number of years.
    • 00:25:31
      Low water bridge literally means that when the water is low, you can drive across the bridge.
    • 00:25:37
      When the water's not low, you better not drive across the bridge.
    • 00:25:41
      It's a single lane bridge that crosses the Shenandoah River.
    • 00:25:44
      and floods numerous times a year as Shenandoah rises after rain, storms, or snow melt.
    • 00:25:52
      We've been working for a number of years on this project to rebuild this bridge.
    • 00:25:57
      There's controversy related to the bridge as it relates to potential cut-through.
    • 00:26:05
      The bridge has existed, but as the road improves, people may use it more as a way to move around the town of Front Royal.
    • 00:26:14
      There's also been concerns raised about historic impacts and both VDOT, our historic resources folks, who are very, very good at what they do in terms of looking for archaeological sites, historic resources.
    • 00:26:29
      McPherson, John M. McPherson,
    • 00:26:48
      And we are confident that we have addressed the environmental concerns and we've moved forward with the construction.
    • 00:26:56
      We actually, I believe the road is shut down to through traffic as we build this bridge.
    • 00:27:01
      And one of the things we were very careful about with the sensitivity of the environment was not to build, the original concept was a fully modern bridge, fully flood-proofed
    • 00:27:13
      Well above the existing river, larger footprint, larger impact.
    • 00:27:19
      Working with the community, we came back with a design.
    • 00:27:22
      It will be a two-lane bridge, but it will be lower profile to the water with some architectural features.
    • 00:27:29
      And the reality is in significant storms, it may still overtop.
    • 00:27:33
      So the bridge is actually being designed to allow for overtopping in significant events.
    • 00:27:38
      But that number of events will likely drop from several year to maybe once or twice every several years.
    • 00:27:46
      So again, in terms of the frequency of flooding will go down significantly.
    • 00:27:50
      But we move forward with that project.
    • 00:27:52
      Again, there's been some, we've received a number of correspondence from a small group of individuals.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:00
      But a very vocal group of individuals, and a politically influential group of individuals.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:06
      As I said, we're confident that we have been sensitive to the environment, the historic resources in the area, and we've pressed forward with the contract.
    • 00:28:14
      We have a solid contractor out there, and again, expect this bridge to be replaced in a much safer way to travel for folks in that part of the state.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:24
      Secretary Ward came to me shortly after with this project, because it's been going on a long time, and the
    • 00:28:30
      Department of Natural Resources worked hand in hand.
    • 00:28:33
      In fact, we changed the design.
    • 00:28:35
      It's actually more costly what we've done.
    • 00:28:39
      Secretary Ward has been out there many times.
    • 00:28:40
      They have signed off on the project and we have gone back and forth and they're just a group that don't want the bridge fixed.
    • 00:28:48
      and they are using every opportunity, you know, they've gone through, you know, different things and it is clearly aimed at stopping it.
    • 00:28:59
      I've talked with the governor about this, I'll respond to letters, I've talked with their senators.
    • 00:29:04
      If they have a, they can sue and that will be, but otherwise we're moving forward because it is an issue with most of the town clerk there.
    • 00:29:14
      that have come and support this, but there are some that do not, so Mr. Whitworth.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:19
      Mr. Secretary, I've been involved with this project from the first day I was appointed to this board and I've met numerous times with representatives of both sides.
    • 00:29:33
      The bridge itself is even worse than what Commissioner indicated as far as
    • 00:29:40
      The road is closed about 40 days a year.
    • 00:29:49
      These are times when neither rescue squad or fire department can cross it.
    • 00:29:59
      There have been three deaths on this road, on this bridge, where individuals have tried to drive across it and been swept off.
    • 00:30:10
      The town of Front Royal and the county of Warren County have made it.
    • 00:30:16
      It was their first priority when I got on the board.
    • 00:30:21
      And it is something that very much needs to be resolved and built, and it is being built as we speak, contracted and let.
    • 00:30:34
      There is a small group of
    • 00:30:39
      Smith, John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:31:01
      The bridge was built for, I think, a thousand cars a day, something like that, and that usage today is almost 3,000.
    • 00:31:14
      It's in terrible shape, potholes, and the opposition has really tried every angle they can to stop it.
    • 00:31:25
      including environmental and now historical, the claim that an old Indian village called Smoketown was located somewhere close to this.
    • 00:31:37
      VDOT has bent over backwards in so many times to accommodate and to recheck and to change the design.
    • 00:31:47
      and to work with the opposition.
    • 00:31:52
      I can't tell you how patient they've been for a relatively small project to the number of man hours and time and delay that VDOT has extended to make sure that we try to address the concerns that have been expressed.
    • 00:32:17
      I assure you that the vast majority of the citizens on both sides of the river want this to be completed.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:32
      I just wanted the board to be aware.
    • 00:32:34
      You may be getting reached out to.
    • 00:32:35
      There have been different outreaches by this group and I am very comfortable that we have done more than the due diligence
    • 00:32:45
      Regardless, there's African-American interest in that, Indian artifacts, all those we have gone through both VDOT and natural resources.
    • 00:32:57
      Yeah, but I mean we have looked and very comfortable that we are not disturbing that and it truly is a safety issue.
    • 00:33:07
      We're not going to appease this group and we will move forward.
    • 00:33:12
      Till, unless we are ruled by a court to stop.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:20
      We did.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:22
      We had them design the bridge.
    • 00:33:24
      It's much more costly than we would normally put in, but to try to appease this group.
    • 00:33:33
      So I just wanted you to wear, unless I'm aware of any other fact that
    • 00:33:41
      We're continuing forward and instructive Mr. Kilpatrick to continue moving forward on the project.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:50
      That's all that I have.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:51
      Anything else for Charlie?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:33:54
      I just want to say thank you for your help with the Norris Bridge discussions and I'd be glad to attend that meeting if I had that.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:06
      I think it would be appropriate for us to meet with the community down there after we have our experts taking a look at options and opportunities and have a direct dialogue with them.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:22
      Okay, I've got a couple things and I'll start with the one that's probably been in the news the most and that is bus rapid transit.
    • 00:34:31
      I'm going to just take you through what our involvement has been and where we are.
    • 00:34:36
      Let me start up front that any responsibility for this lies with me as the Secretary of Transportation and also the Chairman of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:34:53
      This project was going on
    • 00:34:56
      When we came into office, there was an effort to try to move it forward.
    • 00:35:02
      Whether or not they were going to be able to do that without federal funds, it was probably not going to happen.
    • 00:35:07
      So a federal TIGER grant was put in, Governor McAuliffe supported, and we were awarded that of $25 million TIGER grant to help.
    • 00:35:20
      That was a budget of about $55 million, am I correct?
    • 00:35:24
      D.R.P.
    • 00:35:26
      reviewed it.
    • 00:35:30
      We used the political power and put the capital of the governor to support.
    • 00:35:44
      In fact, that was the only grant that year I think that the governor actually supported to move that project forward.
    • 00:35:51
      It was awarded, the way the grant works is, GRTC was the grant recipient.
    • 00:35:58
      You're familiar with the at-length discussions regarding light rail.
    • 00:36:03
      GRTC was to be the one that would administer the grant, do the construction contract.
    • 00:36:10
      Working with the City of Richmond, we would just have oversight responsibility for the grant through the DRPT, just to make sure it compliant.
    • 00:36:20
      Now the grants come with, particularly with higher grants, come with two things.
    • 00:36:26
      One is a time frame when the project must be delivered and procurement.
    • 00:36:31
      And number two, the scope.
    • 00:36:34
      In other words, once the feds agree that this is the scope, that's the scope.
    • 00:36:39
      If you want to continue the grant, you can't change the scope of the project.
    • 00:36:45
      That was the scope of what had been at that time a city council in Richmond and GRTC were behind in moving the project forward.
    • 00:36:56
      So they started down the path.
    • 00:36:58
      This was, I guess, about June.
    • 00:37:00
      I'm paraphrasing or estimating of 2014.
    • 00:37:03
      We'd been in office a few months when the grant was awarded that fall.
    • 00:37:07
      And about a year later, and Ms. Mitchell was monitoring this.
    • 00:37:14
      Of course, I could read it in the papers too.
    • 00:37:17
      The process to move the grant forward or the project forward was floundering.
    • 00:37:23
      GRTC was unsure whether they were going to get to procurement.
    • 00:37:26
      I think it's fair to say that we were concerned that the procurement wasn't going to go well.
    • 00:37:31
      They were concerned with the procurement.
    • 00:37:33
      There was a lot of discussion on Richmond City Council as to whether or not GRTC had appropriately looked at all the options of the route and the different things with the grant.
    • 00:37:48
      A lot
    • 00:38:09
      talk with the governor's office about that and said yes I mean you know let's see if we can help them and actually we were invited by GRTC and Richmond both the city of Richmond
    • 00:38:22
      Welcome our oversight.
    • 00:38:25
      Typically, as you know, we're not trying to mandate because sometimes when we come in, we're accused of ramming it down people's throats, and we witnessed that in the light rail even though we responded.
    • 00:38:37
      So, you know, we said, look, if you want us to come in, you need to invite us in, which they did.
    • 00:38:43
      I met particularly with Mayor Jones' staff and others and said, you know, we would get involved and think, you know, to be helpful with the project.
    • 00:38:52
      We got in it, it was clear that at that time DRPT did not have some of the rights that VDOT does and basically it's really constructing a road besides buying the capital so asked Charlie and VDOT to get involved in looking at how we could get this project back on track in terms of the procurement in the right of way.
    • 00:39:14
      But we made it clear from the very beginning, the very beginning that this was Richmond's project and GRTC.
    • 00:39:22
      In other words, they were supposed to be the public face.
    • 00:39:25
      We were there administering the contract.
    • 00:39:28
      At that time, as we mentioned that there was this estimate and we did review the estimate and VDOT and DRPT looking at the estimate saying, you know, we believe it's reasonable based on what they've gotten to date.
    • 00:39:44
      And that's what they informed me, reasonable.
    • 00:39:48
      But I'm not suggesting I rely totally on that because I know with the political angst that was going on that no one could verify exactly what the political risk, what that premium was going to be in the biz.
    • 00:40:02
      And there was no way we were going to know until we got to a procurement.
    • 00:40:07
      So I asked Charlie to get VDOT, I think, what's the district administrator there?
    • 00:40:14
      Rob Carey did a great job, got a hold, started working with the city and started the procurement and basically said, you know, this is behind budget, behind about a year.
    • 00:40:25
      And so I asked them, you know, is there a way to incentivize to get the project back on?
    • 00:40:30
      Because we were concerned about the stipulations in the grants.
    • 00:40:35
      Now, during this time, City Council had still not voted to move the project forward, had not, and therefore we had been working, but it was getting down to the wire, either they moved it forward or there's no way we could even get into a procurement to keep the grant.
    • 00:40:53
      So I personally appeared in front of City Council after talking with the Governor's Office and the Mayor's Office and GRTC and appeared before them and said basically,
    • 00:41:05
      That it was made clear that they were putting no more money into the particular project.
    • 00:41:12
      They did not have the political votes to continue to go forward with the project by putting additional money in.
    • 00:41:19
      So I did make the commitment that we would, based on the procurement, we would be responsible for bringing this project to fruition.
    • 00:41:30
      I didn't actually use the word cost, but we would be responsible for bringing it.
    • 00:41:34
      But it was pretty clear that if there, and I have subsequently said we would be responsible for the cost.
    • 00:41:39
      So I want to make sure I'm not passing that buck off to anybody else.
    • 00:41:43
      So they went out and did the procurement going forward.
    • 00:41:48
      The political angst continues today.
    • 00:41:52
      In fact, I think you just got a letter from, I should have gotten a letter, I think I just saw it when I came in from one of the council members.
    • 00:42:00
      And of course, what he said it was forward, but now he wants to re-scope the project.
    • 00:42:04
      And of course, that is not allowed under the grant.
    • 00:42:08
      So the choice we really have is basically do the project or not do the project.
    • 00:42:13
      That's really the choice that we have.
    • 00:42:15
      The procurement went out and it came in.
    • 00:42:18
      It was reported the other day, I think Ms. Mitchell was quoted, that the actual cost of the procurement was $11.5 million more than the estimate.
    • 00:42:28
      I don't want to call it the budget because I'm not even sure there's actually been a budget but the estimate on that.
    • 00:42:33
      We did consider whether or not we had time should we rebid the process.
    • 00:42:41
      It's public knowledge now.
    • 00:42:43
      The winning bid was substantially under the other two by a magnitude of many millions of dollars on that.
    • 00:42:52
      And we probably believe that was the case because they're pretty comfortable they're going to get the incentive, I would guess, that would add another $3.5 million, so this would basically be $15 million over what the estimate is.
    • 00:43:06
      And that's where this number comes from.
    • 00:43:08
      The other thing, so we consider that and based on the spread, we determine that
    • 00:43:16
      The other thing that we considered was the timing of the grant.
    • 00:43:28
      Could we make the procurement, the requirements on the grant to get the procurement
    • 00:43:34
      And it was basically decided that would have put it in jeopardy.
    • 00:43:39
      We might have, but it would have been in jeopardy if we did it.
    • 00:43:42
      And even if we got $10 million reduction, if we lost $25 million, we still hadn't gotten the project to move forward.
    • 00:43:51
      So we found ourselves in the position of either making the decision to move the project forward or kill the project.
    • 00:44:01
      That's what the decision would have been on this.
    • 00:44:05
      So, as I said, I asked Charlie and Jennifer if they could look at how could we fund this project if we move forward.
    • 00:44:14
      Of course, the board had already, you didn't give me carte blanche, but you basically said, you know, based on this, you know, make the decision on whether or not to move this project forward.
    • 00:44:26
      passing it off to you, but it wasn't as if also that we hadn't considered the project.
    • 00:44:32
      So I felt comfortable in asking them to look.
    • 00:44:37
      Charlie, the VDOT went through the process and basically found, and Mr. Brown was involved in this because approximately there was $13 million in the Richmond district only of contracts that were coming in under their budget.
    • 00:44:56
      So there's $13 million that was available, and it's typically what happens in that you work with the district, the customary, the district rep on the board, and they have the ability as long as any particular project is not more than 10%, they have the ability to move it to other projects.
    • 00:45:17
      and so that's where a large bulk of this money would come from going forward is working with Mr. Brown out of the Richmond District so nothing under House Bill 2, no other districts to be moved on this project.
    • 00:45:31
      Typically we go on other projects that potentially were over, this one's over but I do fully admit that this is unusual that would be putting it all in one project so I just want to make sure
    • 00:45:45
      While customary can be, this is something that we don't do very often in that.
    • 00:45:51
      The other couple million dollars should be needed.
    • 00:45:54
      And I also want to point out there could be potential other contingencies.
    • 00:45:58
      This is a fixed price contract, but there's still a lot of political and stuff to be worked out.
    • 00:46:03
      There could be other costs.
    • 00:46:05
      So I want to make that clear up front.
    • 00:46:06
      I know there's a lot of numbers been floating around.
    • 00:46:09
      It's this and that.
    • 00:46:11
      There is a potential, although there's also the potential we could maybe see some savings in some things.
    • 00:46:17
      I would say that's not a high probability, but a possibility.
    • 00:46:21
      So I don't want to sugarcoat it from that perspective either.
    • 00:46:24
      So Ms. Mitchell could find additional monies, but I want to make it clear, and out of her statewide pot, that would be something that could be used in other districts.
    • 00:46:36
      So I just want to make it clear that the several million dollars of this could be used in other districts.
    • 00:46:44
      So based on what those facts and where we were coming from and the parameters under the contract, and I believe there's both policy issues here and the actual issue related to the, that we need to discuss, delivering on this project, I did instruct DRPT and Charlie to move forward with the contract based on that.
    • 00:47:13
      That is what we have before you today.
    • 00:47:16
      I've got some other things to go through and some other projects here.
    • 00:47:24
      I wanted you to understand I'm not going to do things I don't bring to your attention.
    • 00:47:32
      having said that it is in my executive control to make these decisions and quite frankly just a lot of these things used to go on a whole lot that you never knew about and I don't mean that to say you shouldn't have or whatever but that's the normal custom customary part of the way and keeping a thirteen and a half billion dollar construction program going.
    • 00:47:54
      There are decisions made all the time at levels.
    • 00:47:58
      Now, I'm not taking that out and saying that's why I'm bringing this to your attention.
    • 00:48:02
      So that has brought us to where we are today.
    • 00:48:05
      Now, the last comment I'll make and open it up for discussion is this was done prior to House Bill 2, prior to how we are now moving forward on the projects.
    • 00:48:16
      Even the commitment on the grant was made prior to this being implemented.
    • 00:48:22
      So I don't see this as a repetitive because we simply do business differently.
    • 00:48:27
      And in fact, as I mentioned before, this heavily influenced my response to Virginia Beach in their delays.
    • 00:48:37
      Because the point of the fact of the matter is, and while I'm not excusing any estimates that were done or not done or anything, I think people use their best, I mean, I don't see anything nefarious, they use their best estimate.
    • 00:48:51
      But this is a serious factor that political risk does increase these projects.
    • 00:48:59
      There's no doubt there is.
    • 00:49:01
      So what I will be our policy, unless a locality is ready to move forward and takes a unanimous vote, we're going to be hesitant to support any grant applications.
    • 00:49:15
      D.C. because it is
    • 00:49:35
      That's where we are.
    • 00:49:37
      That's how I made the decision.
    • 00:49:39
      I want to be clear, there could be potentially other costs.
    • 00:49:43
      I don't think they're significant.
    • 00:49:45
      There's a lot of people throwing estimates around.
    • 00:49:48
      But that's where we are today to deliver the project.
    • 00:49:52
      And it came down to either delivering the project or not.
    • 00:49:56
      And we did not have the ability to re-scope the project and keep the grant.
    • 00:50:00
      So that's where we are and I'll open it up to questions because I would have questions if I were one of you in that.
    • 00:50:08
      So with that, what we'll be asking you today later in the session under the contracts is to basically confirm and ratify the actions that Mr. Kilpatrick has taken at my direction on that and executing the design-build contract.
    • 00:50:26
      I will mention it is a fixed-price contract on that.
    • 00:50:31
      With that, I'll be happy to entertain any questions or comments that come before us, but you know to the best of my ability the decisions and how we made them.
    • 00:50:47
      Mr. Whitworth.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:49
      I have no problem with
    • 00:50:52
      Williams, John K. Kasprowicz, John K. Matney, John K. Matney,
    • 00:51:09
      That in the future we've all had the benefit of being able to swap funds that may be out there.
    • 00:51:18
      But you made mention of the fact that you found 13 million, you only did 11, so any additional monies would still come from this 13 million, is that correct?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:27
      Yeah, but I would assume, that's why I mentioned, the 11 and a half million is if the contractor does not get the incentive.
    • 00:51:33
      I would assume, particularly since his bid was so much
    • 00:51:37
      Under the other two that he is counting on getting the $3.5 million award.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:43
      But it does take away the safety net that Richmond has for other projects that have not come to fruition at this point.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:51
      That is true.
    • 00:51:52
      Other projects that don't have grants, I will mention, we do have the ability to re-scope some of the project.
    • 00:51:59
      And you heard Mr. Kilpatrick said yesterday, I got X amount of money.
    • 00:52:03
      That's the philosophy.
    • 00:52:05
      The grant really taught our hands here in terms of our ability to re-scope.
    • 00:52:11
      I mean, Ms. Mitchell, am I understanding that at all?
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:14
      No, these TIGER grants are very competitive and it's a national program and they literally get thousands of applications every year.
    • 00:52:22
      When you submit the grant, there's a very detailed benefit cost analysis that's required, much, much more detailed than what we use for HB2 even.
    • 00:52:32
      It's based on all the benefits that the project will deliver based on the scope, you know, so how many stations you have, the miles in the project, the time savings, things like that all end up in a detailed benefit-cost equation.
    • 00:52:45
      And that's one of the factors they use to make these decisions.
    • 00:52:48
      The philosophy behind this program is that you can't go back and then change the scope of the project, very much like H32,
    • 00:52:55
      Williams Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.,
    • 00:53:14
      No guarantee that after you re-scope that we will give you that grant.
    • 00:53:19
      Oh, and by the way, the people that gave you this grant are not going to be here six months from now.
    • 00:53:23
      And, you know, we made the decision that with all of the risk associated with losing that $25 million grant that we were better off still trying to move the project forward with the benefits that we promised to deliver.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:53:37
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:53:39
      Yes, Mr. Williams.
    • 00:53:39
      I just wanted to add, I was part of some of those discussions with Jennifer and
    • 00:53:45
      Rescoping this project was not feasible anyway.
    • 00:53:49
      This is the bare minimum.
    • 00:53:50
      There's a fine line between putting something out there so you can say you have something and putting something out there that can grow a business and grow a ridership.
    • 00:54:00
      We're just over that line just thinking about it.
    • 00:54:03
      Rescoping it gets below the line.
    • 00:54:05
      Again, just walk away before you do that.
    • 00:54:09
      It's a minimal project with a tremendous amount of possibilities.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:14
      Well I didn't get into purposely, I mean certainly the benefits of the project.
    • 00:54:19
      If we didn't think this was a very positive benefit for the region, starting it off connecting different communities and there's been a lot of discussion about that, about the opening up jobs, there's been strong support and connecting the economic development in some of these areas with others.
    • 00:54:42
      Yeah, and so that was, I mean look, if this was a project marginal, I don't know if that's the right word, but we were strongly committed that this project was very beneficial for this region, not just so much for the city of Richmond that's in there, obviously it connects some into Henrico County out there, but many of, quite frankly, the disadvantaged neighborhoods in the area,
    • 00:55:12
      would now be open to other opportunities through this.
    • 00:55:18
      I hope it would go without saying that first of all, I don't think we even put our capital behind a project we didn't think was that type of necessity or something that could be a game changer for many of the peoples in the city of Richmond.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:55:39
      Jones Jr., John W. B. Jones Jr., John W. B. Jones Jr.,
    • 00:55:56
      This approach that's being talked about today would get us closer to that, especially given the fact that if we don't do something, we may lose it.
    • 00:56:04
      I think the prudent thing to do is to move forward and to accept the recommendations coming from our leadership and move forward on this thing.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:17
      Well I fully realize and I think I'll just talk about some lessons learned about this and I think the biggest is the real cost of political uncertainty.
    • 00:56:28
      I know a lot of people want to assign well when did GRTC know this and I started a conversation yesterday
    • 00:56:35
      saying that we understand, whether it's GRTC, I'll mention HRT, I'll throw in there Metro, WMATA, their ability to control these construction, it's a skill set that is not actually inherent, but that's the way the process works.
    • 00:56:54
      So that is one thing we will make sure in terms of any grant that we move forward with that we're support that clearly there is political support for the grant.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 00:57:12
      And at this point, Mr. Secretary, the political will is in support of us moving forward with the current scope.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:20
      Yes, although you cheated on the letter this morning from one of the councilmen saying he would like to re-scope it and that there's a responsibility, I would love to re-scope it too if we had that opportunity.
    • 00:57:31
      Although I do think what Mr. Williams said, there's not much to restore.
    • 00:57:35
      Yeah, to less.
    • 00:57:36
      I mean, you just got to get the benefits.
    • 00:57:37
      So I will say this.
    • 00:57:39
      There's still a lot of political usage.
    • 00:57:43
      There are a lot of people running for mayor.
    • 00:57:45
      So there is still a very lot of politics around this.
    • 00:57:48
      I'm not saying one's right or what's wrong around it.
    • 00:57:51
      I do know that our private parties know there's risk around this.
    • 00:57:56
      I don't think there's any doubt, but yes, they did vote to move the project forward.
    • 00:58:03
      That vote was that they didn't have any more money to put into it, so I don't want to understand whether they would be supportive if we went to them and said you had to put up more money.
    • 00:58:14
      I can't answer that.
    • 00:58:17
      I would say that it would not be the support we have now, but we have made the commitment that we would move this forward.
    • 00:58:25
      Yeah, Mr. Fralin.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:27
      I've got a bunch trying to wait.
    • 00:58:29
      I understand.
    • 00:58:30
      And I first want to say I understand that we took over with limited time to be able to really look at this estimate and make sure it was clear.
    • 00:58:41
      I understand that.
    • 00:58:43
      But I think that's partially GRTC's problem.
    • 00:58:49
      And so to the extent we're paying for their mistake,
    • 00:58:54
      I understand that you made a commitment and I want to support your commitment.
    • 00:59:09
      I understand that you can't call a CTB meeting every time you're standing up in front of somebody and have to make a decision.
    • 00:59:16
      I don't think you should have to do that.
    • 00:59:20
      You've done a great job of being open.
    • 00:59:25
      I think that's been a welcome change.
    • 00:59:29
      These meetings are taking two days, not fifteen or twenty minutes, and that's a great change.
    • 00:59:39
      I also understand that rebid is probably not going to give you a better result.
    • 00:59:43
      It is what it is in that sense.
    • 00:59:48
      The disconnect is between the estimate and the bid, not between the bidders.
    • 00:59:54
      I understand that now.
    • 00:59:57
      Having said that,
    • 00:59:59
      We do have, in the past, limited our exposure on rail and public transit projects, specifically in Virginia Beach.
    • 01:00:12
      And I agree with that.
    • 01:00:13
      And I think we should limit our exposure on these projects.
    • 01:00:19
      That makes a lot of sense to me.
    • 01:00:24
      I recognize that design build is a very important piece of what we do, and it usually delivers very good results.
    • 01:00:35
      In this case, I think we didn't have enough preliminary design work to really understand what was going to be involved with the design here, and I think the contractor's bids reflect that, that they
    • 01:00:51
      Jones, John K. Breslin Jr., John W. Breslin Jr.,
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:12
      Once a contract is awarded, we have a value engineering process.
    • 01:01:19
      It's been available for design bid bill as well as design bill contract for a number of years.
    • 01:01:24
      What that really is is an alternative materials or techniques or physical improvements that provide the same quality project for a lesser price.
    • 01:01:38
      and real simply that they share, we share 50-50 with a contractor in those types of savings.
    • 01:01:44
      So that's what alternative technical concepts really once it goes into an awarded contract we call it value engineering.
    • 01:01:55
      It's a very similar concept and we share in the savings.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:57
      So, but we don't have the ability to enter into that because the law doesn't change until July 1st.
    • 01:02:03
      We have to do it preliminarily.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:06
      Before we act on the bid.
    • 01:02:09
      I can do it today because I have an awarded contract.
    • 01:02:11
      I couldn't do it during the bidding process.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:15
      You don't have an awarded contract yet, do you?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:17
      Yes.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:18
      How did you?
    • 01:02:19
      Because you had given authority to vote for it.
    • 01:02:22
      I understand.
    • 01:02:23
      I'm going to get into that.
    • 01:02:24
      I understand, but under my authority then, Mr. Fralin.
    • 01:02:28
      Okay.
    • 01:02:28
      My authority, yes.
    • 01:02:28
      All right.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:29
      Under my authority.
    • 01:02:31
      Well, let's look at this.
    • 01:02:33
      You know, the resolution that we passed, and we may need, I don't know if we do, Mr. Wilson,
    • 01:02:39
      It said total commitment funding of $49.8 million.
    • 01:02:45
      And it does say that DRPT may require to execute other agreements, but that is not a matter of price.
    • 01:02:53
      That's a matter of getting a contract signed and all that.
    • 01:03:02
      We do talk about being further resolved provided the necessary proposal, evaluation, tasks, and activities related to award of contract are appropriately completed that you can sign and design a building.
    • 01:03:15
      I'm not sure that that is where we are.
    • 01:03:21
      Maybe it is.
    • 01:03:23
      Planning does require our affirmation of the signed bill contract.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:29
      So we are not in a situation where we don't have a choice.
    • 01:03:36
      I get it.
    • 01:03:37
      I get it.
    • 01:03:44
      I get it.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:51
      It also says in the project agreement, it was an attachment to the resolution, VDOT may, but is under no obligation to increase the total capital of funds by procuring its own funding.
    • 01:04:03
      So we did have some protection in, it wasn't a hard collar, as I would term it, but it was the ability to actually limit our exposure, which I think is very prudent.
    • 01:04:17
      However, we say here, in 5.7, capital cost overruns.
    • 01:04:23
      DRPTs shall be responsible for any capital cost overruns exceeding the total capital funds, except those that are explicitly stated in this agreement to be the responsibility of the party.
    • 01:04:37
      So this document is a little inconsistent.
    • 01:04:40
      It says we're responsible and it says it's at our discretion.
    • 01:04:44
      So the way I read it is, we're responsible for it.
    • 01:04:47
      I don't know if that's right or not, but that's sort of the way I look at it.
    • 01:04:57
      How are we notified?
    • 01:04:59
      Is the threshold report normally on road projects how we're notified of variations in bid versus award?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:06
      In terms of the Commonwealth Transportation Board, highway construction and maintenance contracts in excess of $5 million, you award those contracts?
    • 01:05:21
      Right.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:21
      McPherson Jr., John F. McPherson Jr.
    • 01:05:39
      We don't bring that to the board.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:41
      So when we see it and we vote on the project, we do have the estimate versus the cost.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:47
      You do, but you're actually only approving contracts of $5 million right here.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:58
      This original piece is being funded by transit funds, I think, and the overage is being funded by road funds.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:07
      That's correct.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:09
      That, in my opinion, is a little bit of a dangerous precedent.
    • 01:06:17
      And my question, Mr. Brown was unable to be here, but is he supportive of this?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:21
      He is supportive.
    • 01:06:23
      And I would say they're flex funds, but that's correct, it is sort of a precedent.
    • 01:06:28
      They're eligible funds, but you're right, they were originally put on road projects.
    • 01:06:33
      But Mr. Brown is supportive.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:35
      This project agreement was negotiated after the TIGER grant was applied for?
    • 01:06:44
      That's correct.
    • 01:06:45
      Okay.
    • 01:06:45
      I think as a matter of practice going forward, project agreements need to be negotiated before we apply.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:54
      If possible.
    • 01:06:56
      If possible.
    • 01:06:56
      And there's the issue there because we shouldn't even be in this at all, right?
    • 01:07:01
      Because the GRTC should be delivering this project.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:05
      Well, I understand that, but they obviously wanted our money and they want the Department of Railroad money, rather, and so to the extent they're going to apply for a tire grant, I would send the message out that if you're going to apply for these tire grants and you expect the Commonwealth to participate, we better have some sort of agreement ahead of time.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:25
      Well, let me make sure we do, except what would happen is normally we would say, tough, you're out.
    • 01:07:33
      We, because of this project, which is unusual for the state to do this, let me start off by saying it's unusual because of the political capital that was used to move it and we thought the importance of the project.
    • 01:07:44
      We stepped back in.
    • 01:07:46
      We didn't have to step back in.
    • 01:07:47
      We couldn't let the bank flounder, no exposure to us, and the grant would have gone away.
    • 01:07:53
      So we were protected from that, Mr. Fralin, but you're right, you're right.
    • 01:07:56
      So I guess we could put in there, if we ever get involved,
    • 01:08:01
      You know, and overstep our administrative role, we could put something in to say, if you ask us for that, you are acknowledging we're not going to, you know, What I'm saying is, if we're not involved up front, this is going to happen again.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:14
      Somebody's going to apply for something, they're going to get this award, we're going to have a big announcement, everybody thinks this project's going to be delivered, and then we're going to get in a cost overrun, we're going to lose the award if somebody doesn't pay for it.
    • 01:08:26
      and all I'm saying is if we agree up front in the project agreement that we may or may not, that's a subject of negotiation, not a subject of negotiation.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:38
      But that's probably that way anyway.
    • 01:08:40
      We didn't have to step in.
    • 01:08:42
      We didn't have to step in.
    • 01:08:45
      We chose to.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:46
      That's my question.
    • 01:08:48
      So this agreement where we said we would step in was after the Tiger Grand Prix.
    • 01:08:53
      That's correct.
    • 01:08:53
      That's correct.
    • 01:08:55
      That's correct.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:56
      We were not obligated to do this, Mr. Fralin.
    • 01:08:59
      No, I understand.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:59
      And I don't have any, working together, overseeing projects and actual management of the projects, I think that's a good thing.
    • 01:09:06
      There's no problem with that.
    • 01:09:11
      You mentioned that there may be more.
    • 01:09:14
      Can we put a collar on this now and say if there's more, because here's the deal.
    • 01:09:19
      The city of Richmond is not committed to this project enough to share in the cost overruns.
    • 01:09:25
      How good is this for the city of Richmond?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:27
      Do they really want it?
    • 01:09:28
      Let me tell you, we could put a collar and then we set a height.
    • 01:09:32
      You know what I'm saying?
    • 01:09:33
      In other words, part of this has been setting expectations.
    • 01:09:37
      Let's say we would have increased the budget.
    • 01:09:45
      We increased the budget.
    • 01:09:48
      That makes another expectation.
    • 01:09:52
      I agree with you.
    • 01:09:53
      We could.
    • 01:09:54
      In fact, there have been some estimates.
    • 01:09:58
      I would rather you put a percentage or something because if we put on that, that sets an upper limit.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:06
      It is a fixed price contract.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:08
      So we're not talking about a contract.
    • 01:10:10
      I don't know what else is out there.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:12
      I understand we have a fixed price contract and I guarantee there are contingencies in that fixed price that if they encounter some unexpected whatever.
    • 01:10:20
      There are contingencies.
    • 01:10:22
      Probably weather, I mean who knows what all is in there.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:25
      Well why don't you put a limit there.
    • 01:10:26
      You guys know, I don't know.
    • 01:10:31
      I understand what you're trying to do there, and I don't disagree, but every time we put an expectation, I assume we're going to exceed it.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:40
      Well, I mean, I get that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:41
      I mean, I wish because of the way, back to the public.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:45
      We've got a letter from one city council member that wants to re-scope, and obviously that's not something we can do.
    • 01:10:52
      Right.
    • 01:10:54
      What that tells me is the political commitment on city council may not be where it needs to be.
    • 01:11:01
      I don't understand why they're complaining.
    • 01:11:04
      I don't even know where this is coming from because they're capped.
    • 01:11:08
      And I don't know what they would do to the political situation and say, OK, fine, we're going to cover this cost to everyone.
    • 01:11:13
      But anything else, we're sharing 50-50 or so.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:16
      I think I can have that conversation.
    • 01:11:19
      OK. Yeah, I mean, from this point and that.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:23
      I think you should have the conversation, but I personally would object to putting any constraints on you guys right now, because it's a false impression anyway.
    • 01:11:35
      I mean, if we hadn't worked with you guys enough to know that you're all going to fight harder than anybody to keep these costs in line, that's the reason you're there.
    • 01:11:44
      Quite frankly, there's no confidence whatsoever with GRTC investing in this thing.
    • 01:11:48
      The happiest day of this project's life was the day you told me that I was a 10-year-old.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:03
      We are paying for that inefficiencies in New York.
    • 01:12:08
      To get this project done, that's what the state's putting up.
    • 01:12:15
      There's no way to sugarcoat that.
    • 01:12:21
      I am comfortable that VDOT ran a very competitive process. Yes.
    • 01:12:23
      And I'm also comfortable that the surrounding of this increase the cost of the project.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:27
      And this is not a City of Richmond project.
    • 01:12:30
      It's not one of those projects you say this is just for the City of Richmond.
    • 01:12:33
      This BRT is an important move forward in how we do transit.
    • 01:12:41
      It's not light rail, but it's not a typical bus.
    • 01:12:44
      I think a lot of the city council members right now, a lot of political pundits in Richmond right now are thinking, who's going to get on that bus tomorrow?
    • 01:13:07
      But if you look at the demographics of Richmond and who's moving there,
    • 01:13:11
      These folks don't even want a car.
    • 01:13:13
      They don't want to own one.
    • 01:13:15
      And they're pouring into the city.
    • 01:13:17
      And this is the type of system they're looking for.
    • 01:13:21
      It's the type of system they appreciate.
    • 01:13:23
      To be able to get on this thing in a short month, five years from now maybe, six years from now, and ride it into Daniel County, walk three blocks, and go to Wells Fargo headquarters and go to work, it's got amazing potential.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:35
      Well, Mr. Chairman, if I could, I agree with Mr. Williams on the first point.
    • 01:13:40
      I have no problem, as long as we have an understanding that you're going to negotiate this and before we come back with costs overruns that we've got to pay for, we're going to at least try to negotiate that.
    • 01:13:53
      I can get it.
    • 01:13:54
      I disagree with the second piece.
    • 01:13:56
      This is largely a city-rich project.
    • 01:13:58
      It does touch Enrico County, but just a little bit.
    • 01:14:01
      Now, the extensions may or may not come.
    • 01:14:04
      I don't know if we'll get another tiger grant.
    • 01:14:05
      If we don't, extending this to short pump would be very expensive.
    • 01:14:09
      Smith, and would require Henrico County, in my opinion, to really step up.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:14
      Well, one of the things that, not so much the extension, but it does require, is the increased bus service that's needed throughout the community.
    • 01:14:23
      That is something that won't happen without this line.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:26
      I understand Henrico is paying some money, but compared to...
    • 01:14:30
      Very minor.
    • 01:14:32
      Very minor.
    • 01:14:35
      The House Bill 2 comment, you know, we swept a bunch of projects up that weren't fully funded.
    • 01:14:41
      This one clearly wasn't fully funded.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:44
      We didn't even know we were going to do this when we did it, but we swept them.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:48
      I understand.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:48
      Yeah, that's right.
    • 01:14:51
      You're right, we didn't.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:54
      So anyway, having said all that,
    • 01:14:56
      I would like to see, maybe not today, because we've got to do this, but maybe at another meeting, what we're going to do procedurally at the Department of Rail and VDOT to make sure we don't have this problem again.
    • 01:15:12
      Because I'm just throwing out some ideas, and I may be wrong, but there's got to be something.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:16
      I think you're right, and it's particular to grants, and it really gets to political will.
    • 01:15:21
      Let me make one comment, because I came to the board because I don't want to have
    • 01:15:26
      The relationship that I have is power and I don't.
    • 01:15:29
      In other words, that's why I can't.
    • 01:15:31
      But I like that resolution too, and I think you've pointed out, it's ambiguous whether I had the authority or not.
    • 01:15:39
      I could read it that I did, you could sum it up.
    • 01:15:42
      If it had been clear I didn't, I wouldn't have acted.
    • 01:15:45
      I mean, but I made the decision, I had the authority to instruct.
    • 01:15:49
      It could be disagreement, but I don't want to have that type of relationship with the board and that.
    • 01:15:54
      I mean, if I wanted you to know, it clearly was, I can't do this.
    • 01:15:58
      I wouldn't have asked him to execute the contract.
    • 01:16:01
      I just want to make sure.
    • 01:16:02
      And I think that gets back to, and I'll, to the board here, you know, we need to really fully understand what
    • 01:16:09
      Look, I'm acting in good faith.
    • 01:16:11
      I think you believe that and vice versa.
    • 01:16:14
      But it does bring out that you could go either way.
    • 01:16:18
      And I think we ought to be careful in resolutions when you delegate that we make sure we're much more tighter on what you actually delegate.
    • 01:16:26
      And that's not to say you don't trust me or not.
    • 01:16:29
      It's just to say I think that's the way it should be.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:31
      And I agree with that.
    • 01:16:33
      Mr. Chairman, I did want to clarify a remark.
    • 01:16:36
      I didn't mean to express, and I understand why William is great, that this was not a Richmond project.
    • 01:16:44
      This particular piece from end to end is.
    • 01:16:48
      But the concept, the cost, and the experience belongs to everybody.
    • 01:16:53
      And if we can be successful there,
    • 01:16:55
      Thank you.
    • 01:16:56
      That's a road model.
    • 01:16:58
      That's something that works in Lynchburg.
    • 01:17:00
      It's something that works in Roanoke.
    • 01:17:02
      It's something that works in Fredericksburg.
    • 01:17:04
      It's a new concept for us.
    • 01:17:09
      And I think it has a great promise.
    • 01:17:11
      I came up the old days where I'd see those buses pass me when I was on city council before moving back to the 80s with two people and I was just curious how to shut the whole system down.
    • 01:17:22
      And I had to grow for a long time to learn the value of transit and the fact that in our transit professionals we got most of it.
    • 01:17:31
      They're always dealing in tomorrow because it's very hard to ever justify a project today when you're talking about these types of projects.
    • 01:17:42
      It's going to be what people grow into.
    • 01:17:46
      and this is one of those, I just think it has a great potential.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:51
      Mr. Chairman, I understand Mr. Williams is right and anything I'm doing is not a criticism of bus rapid transit.
    • 01:17:57
      It's the process.
    • 01:17:58
      Bus rapid transit in general.
    • 01:18:00
      I think that's probably why we got the Tiger Grant because of what Mr. Williams just said.
    • 01:18:05
      Hey, we're going to show you, Virginia, this is something that's good and I get all that.
    • 01:18:11
      I'm with you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:14
      I mean, that's really similar to light rail.
    • 01:18:19
      I mean, we believe this is transformational for the entire region, and that's really why we wouldn't be talking about if we had a, first of all, we probably wouldn't have a grant if we didn't thank the project, but certainly not going to, you know, I can't think of many issues where I would
    • 01:18:37
      asked the Governor to be where he is without this important type of project.
    • 01:18:42
      Yes, Mr. Dyke.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 01:18:44
      This has certainly been a great discussion.
    • 01:18:47
      I've learned a lot and I think we've moved the ball forward.
    • 01:18:51
      My question is are we now procedurally at a point where basically we have to decide if we're going to ratify what you're coming to us with?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:58
      And speaking of that,
    • 01:19:12
      Mr.
    • 01:19:12
      Chair, I want you to take just a minute and talk about the protections in the contract.
    • 01:19:15
      I think that's important.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:16
      I mentioned just a little while ago about the National Award for the Design-Build Institute of America.
    • 01:19:24
      We are, this is a design-build contract, and design-build contracts fundamentally are different from our design bid-build, which
    • 01:19:32
      A design-bid-build contract is really we pay for commodities, install, pay for feet of pipe, pay for tons of asphalt, tons of stone.
    • 01:19:45
      It's a commodity contract.
    • 01:19:47
      And while there is a fixed price, we pay for actual materials installed, sometimes more and sometimes less.
    • 01:19:56
      We have an overrun.
    • 01:19:57
      We simply, in many cases, overrun the quantity.
    • 01:20:01
      Design build contracts are truly a firm fixed price.
    • 01:20:05
      We don't
    • 01:20:06
      Whether that contractor bid 10 tons of a material or 100 tons, it really goes down to it's the fixed price.
    • 01:20:15
      There's some things that we build into these contracts.
    • 01:20:18
      There's a scope validation period, which is a period of time where the contractor can basically validate their scope and come to us with issues that they have.
    • 01:20:29
      We can either accept or reject those.
    • 01:20:31
      If we reject those, it gives an opportunity for the contractor to say, I'm out.
    • 01:20:35
      I don't recall it ever happening in the world of design build.
    • 01:20:45
      So, we did some protection that really exists in the design-build contracts, more so than they do in our traditional design-bid-build, because again, we're not paying actual quantities. They committed to that fixed price, and that's what we expected to deliver for. And there's a line of argument that that price would be higher if we did it the other way, because we are asking for certainty, but we thought that was, I mean, based on this situation, Thank you. Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:11
      And we've gotten good, as Charlie said, good prices in the past.
    • 01:21:15
      So it's still very competitive.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:18
      The other thing is the incentive actually disincentivizes claims.
    • 01:21:24
      The incentive, the chief engineer has been very, very strong in advocating the use of incentives on many types of contracts because we really believe it drives quality.
    • 01:21:37
      The contractor is focused on early delivery, early completion, and achieving and gaining that bonus.
    • 01:21:45
      And I'm certain that this contractor, Layne Construction, very experienced in design,
    • 01:21:50
      Part of the reason that their bid was so much stronger is they believe that they can deliver this project and get that bonus.
    • 01:21:59
      Again, these are things that we have built into the contract.
    • 01:22:02
      The other piece about what I call scope creep, when we took over administration of the contract, the contract development and now the contract, we were clear to the local partners, the city, the county, and GRTC.
    • 01:22:17
      That adding scope to the project was not okay.
    • 01:22:22
      That you could not add scope.
    • 01:22:24
      There's always something you want to add to make it better.
    • 01:22:28
      Whether it's an architectural feature or a physical feature, there are always those types of things.
    • 01:22:33
      And we were very clear from the beginning that adding those things would not be at the commonwealth's cost.
    • 01:22:40
      Both from DRPT and VDOT's perspective, we were very firm in that from the beginning.
    • 01:22:45
      And so the contract went out.
    • 01:22:47
      Stade within the scope, stayed within the parameters that we had been working on and we frankly, from the beginning, did not allow for scope creep in the project.
    • 01:23:00
      Now that the contract's been awarded, it's clear what the expectations of the contractor are and the other parties and from a physical construction perspective, this contract is not
    • 01:23:13
      Governorpruss, Janet The complexity really goes to the inter-relationship of the... the electronic systems with the buses and the interaction with how the buses will interact with the system, and that's a bit different than some of the things we've done in the past. And then the challenge of utilities within the city, when we have commitment from the city that they're using all their authorities and powers to work to limit them.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:43
      And I've made it clear to the city that those type of issues are not our issues.
    • 01:23:48
      In other words, they've got to.
    • 01:23:50
      In fact, I'll just make this comment.
    • 01:23:52
      We've been somewhat disappointed that the city has not taken more ownership of this project.
    • 01:24:02
      But we are where we are and I want the board to know exactly how we got there and where we stand.
    • 01:24:10
      I think it's been a good discussion and we will present at another time an action item for, well also what Mr. Fralin brought up about how we approach these grants.
    • 01:24:23
      and I think that goes well within the whole House Bill 2 thing.
    • 01:24:27
      You want money, you got to be ready, you're committed to go.
    • 01:24:30
      We just got too much to have this and some of it I know you're not going to get some of the politics but we're just going to be very hesitant to move forward without a city council or whatever that is not totally committed to move this thing forward.
    • 01:24:44
      I know there's no guarantees but this has happened before and we're
    • 01:24:52
      The choice we had was either let the project go or that could be questionable.
    • 01:24:56
      We chose to move it forward.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:58
      I want to say, Mr. Chairman, I think it is a balance.
    • 01:25:01
      We don't want to snuff out innovation.
    • 01:25:02
      We don't want people not applying for tire grants.
    • 01:25:05
      So if we do this on our end, we've got to be real responsive really quick.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:10
      Or we will sort of put a damper on that.
    • 01:25:14
      I understand that too.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:25:16
      I think that's a really good point.
    • 01:25:18
      Before we have the vote, I just wanted to be a little clearer on the money.
    • 01:25:22
      Because I also think the discussion's been really good.
    • 01:25:24
      And certainly I've learned a lot as well.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:26
      W. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:25:47
      The point I was just trying to make is that the Richmond District, it's an opportunity cost in other projects to support this.
    • 01:25:56
      It is.
    • 01:25:56
      So it is within their district.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:58
      And Mr. Brown was in there and
    • 01:26:01
      We'll try to make it
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:22
      Richmond, but I mean, I can't.
    • 01:26:32
      But I think that is an important part of this discussion.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:41
      We're not unfunding anything that would have otherwise moved forward.
    • 01:26:44
      That's right.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:44
      There is no project, nothing in that regard, so anyway.
    • 01:26:50
      I have one more quick topic that's been in the news and I want to make sure you understand behind that and this deals with the Schooner, Virginia in Norfolk.
    • 01:27:00
      That project, as you well know, was an enhancement grant over many years and several million dollars were put in the construction of the project.
    • 01:27:09
      The nonprofit who had the
    • 01:27:14
      The boat went into fault.
    • 01:27:18
      It's owned by a bank and it was going to be sold on the open market.
    • 01:27:23
      It's the Virginia Scooters replica of the first ship in Virginia.
    • 01:27:28
      So, the City of Norfolk works with Nautica's, Nautica and the Maritime Museum, and we were approached at, could we find a million dollars to fund this?
    • 01:27:39
      So, exactly what went to, when I say Department of Transportation, that's where the money flowed through, worked with them, and they identified a revenue sharing project in the City of Norfolk.
    • 01:27:48
      There was no grants available, enhancement funds had been done and all that.
    • 01:27:52
      with the City of Norfolk where it's coming under budget and we simply return Norfolk's revenue share to them and then they use those monies to make the grant, which is again customary in the whole bit.
    • 01:28:06
      What caused some of the news was that it was characterized by people in Norfolk that it was a grant.
    • 01:28:16
      It was not a grant.
    • 01:28:17
      It was simply a return, and we disclosed that and let them know what we were doing.
    • 01:28:21
      And we certainly knew they were going to use it to buy the schooner, but we were returning monies they had.
    • 01:28:26
      I don't know where they got the, you know, how they got the monies or whatever.
    • 01:28:29
      So that's why I just confirmed when asked us, no, we returned their monies.
    • 01:28:33
      It wasn't a grant.
    • 01:28:35
      We weren't mandatory that we had to return those monies.
    • 01:28:37
      It's customary.
    • 01:28:38
      We weren't mandatory, but we had it.
    • 01:28:40
      We found it.
    • 01:28:41
      So I just want to let you know what was coming about there.
    • 01:28:44
      So, okay.
    • 01:28:47
      I think before we close this session and move to public comment, is there anything else for you guys?
    • 01:28:54
      Okay.
    • 01:28:55
      Well, with that, then we will now call to a close the actual workshop session.
    • 01:29:01
      Does anybody need a break, or do you want to take five minutes?
    • 01:29:06
      Let's take about five minutes, and then we will then go right into our action item, have public comment.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:13
      Yea.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:28
      I'd ask everybody to please take their seats.
    • 01:37:55
      and we will officially call the April action item agenda of the Commonwealth Transportation Board to order.
    • 01:38:03
      I think our first, do I have that?
    • 01:38:06
      Yes, I think it's first is public comment.
    • 01:38:09
      Is there anyone who would like to address the board today?
    • 01:38:17
      Okay, hearing none, then we'll move on down to our agenda.
    • 01:38:20
      That would be the approval of the minutes of March 16th.
    • 01:38:23
      Is there a motion?
    • 01:38:25
      Is there a second?
    • 01:38:27
      Any discussion or comments on the minutes?
    • 01:38:30
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 01:38:32
      Any opposed?
    • 01:38:33
      Thank you.
    • 01:38:35
      Next up we have Mr. Moore, our chief engineer.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:38:42
      Good morning Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 01:38:44
      The item here is bridge naming, Sergeant Aaron Xavier Whitman Memorial Bridge.
    • 01:38:49
      The issue is commemorative naming of the bridge on State Route 10.
    • 01:38:53
      Westhundred Road over the CSX Railroad, Chesterfield County.
    • 01:38:56
      The facts, and I'll just read this.
    • 01:38:59
      Sergeant Aaron Xavier Whitman of Chester, Virginia was born on November 6, 1984 and graduated from Lloyd C. Byrd High School in 2003.
    • 01:39:07
      He served in the South Carolina Army National Guard while a student at the Citadel in Charleston, South Carolina, deploying to Afghanistan with the 218th Brigade Combat Team in 2007.
    • 01:39:19
      Sergeant Whitman enlisted in the United States Army in 2010 after completing his education at the Citadel.
    • 01:39:26
      He deployed for a second combat tour in Afghanistan in 2012 with the 3rd Battalion, 69th Armor Regiment, 1st Brigade Combat Team, 3rd Infantry Division.
    • 01:39:36
      On January 10, 2013, Sergeant Aaron Xavier Whitman died from wounds sustained while returning enemy fire to protect and save the lives of his combat team when his unit, which was on Mounted Patrol, came under small arms fire.
    • 01:39:49
      Sergeant Whitman gave his life in defense of a grateful nation.
    • 01:39:52
      On February 24th, 2016, the Chesterfield County Board of Supervisors wishing to memorialize his life and the sacrifices of Sergeant Aaron Xavier Whitman passed a resolution requesting the bridge located on State Route 10, Old Hundred Road over the CSX Railroad, Chesterfield County, be named the Sergeant Aaron Xavier Whitman Memorial Bridge.
    • 01:40:13
      VDOT recommends this request be approved.
    • 01:40:16
      Action required by the board is the vote
    • 01:40:18
      And there is a resolution in front of you.
    • 01:40:21
      If approved, it will go through the normal process we've done with this.
    • 01:40:25
      And that's the recommendation of VDOT.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:28
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to make a motion that we approve the resolution.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:33
      Is there a second?
    • 01:40:34
      Second.
    • 01:40:34
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:40:36
      Aye.
    • 01:40:36
      Any opposed?
    • 01:40:38
      Resolution passes.
    • 01:40:39
      Thank you, sir.
    • 01:40:41
      Mr. Lawson.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:40:45
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
    • 01:40:48
      The first item I have for you is the routine transfers, monthly transfers.
    • 01:40:53
      You'll see most of the items here today are related to either CMAQ or safety funds.
    • 01:41:00
      Unless there's any particular questions, I would ask your approved motion.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:05
      Second.
    • 01:41:06
      Just a point of fact, there's nothing in here related to the topic of we're not making any transfers yet on the bus rapid transit.
    • 01:41:12
      That is correct.
    • 01:41:12
      We'll make sure the board knows we're not doing that.
    • 01:41:15
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 01:41:20
      Any opposed?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:41:24
      The second item you have is for additions to the program.
    • 01:41:27
      We have two projects that are being added.
    • 01:41:29
      Both of these projects are small projects that are 100% funded by the localities.
    • 01:41:34
      We're just adding this to the program to approve our movement or action on these projects.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:42
      Is there a motion?
    • 01:41:44
      Second.
    • 01:41:45
      Any discussion?
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:45
      Mr. Chairman, I just want to ask Mr. Matney, Route 16, Back of the Dragon.
    • 01:41:52
      Yeah, I'd like to ride that road.
    • 01:41:56
      Well, get a motorcycle.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:58
      All right.
    • 01:41:59
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:01
      Any other discussion?
    • 01:42:03
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:42:05
      Aye.
    • 01:42:05
      Any opposed?
    • 01:42:07
      Okay.
    • 01:42:07
      Mr. Lawson passes.
    • 01:42:08
      Thank you.
    • 01:42:10
      Mr. Walton.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:42:13
      As Chairman, good morning.
    • 01:42:14
      Item number four is a request for a limited access change for Route 134 between York County and the City of Hampton.
    • 01:42:23
      It deals with the replacement of existing structures.
    • 01:42:26
      As you'll see from the map, hopefully the map that you can pull up, the shaded area is where the limited access line is being moved in order to accommodate future maintenance and inspection of the bridge structure.
    • 01:42:38
      We would ask for your approval of that limited access change.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:42
      Mr. Malbon, thank you.
    • 01:42:45
      Is there a second?
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:46
      Second.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:47
      Any discussion?
    • 01:42:49
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 01:42:51
      Aye.
    • 01:42:51
      Any opposed?
    • 01:42:53
      Okay, motion passes.
    • 01:42:53
      Thank you, Mr. Walton.
    • 01:42:55
      Mr. Latimer.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 01:43:02
      Morning, Mr. Secretary and members of the board.
    • 01:43:05
      This morning I have a resolution before you for a rail industrial access application of $345,000 for performance livestock and feed company.
    • 01:43:16
      This will be an expansion of a company from North Carolina into Henry County.
    • 01:43:21
      It scored 69 of 100 possible points.
    • 01:43:24
      It will bring 32 jobs and an investment of $4 million.
    • 01:43:28
      Again, the grant is for $345,000 to rehabilitate the rail, and the total cost of the rail rehabilitation will be $900,000.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:35
      And this was presented at a previous meeting?
    • 01:43:39
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:43:42
      Is there a motion?
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 01:43:43
      So moved.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:44
      Is there a second?
    • 01:43:46
      Second.
    • 01:43:46
      Any discussion?
    • 01:43:48
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:43:50
      Aye.
    • 01:43:50
      Any opposed?
    • 01:43:52
      Thank you, Mr. Latimer.
    • 01:43:53
      Motion passes.
    • 01:43:55
      Ms. Brown.
    • 01:43:55
      Good morning.
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:43:56
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, and we have two action items for you this month.
    • 01:44:01
      The first item, agenda item number six, relates to the Economic Development Access Program project bond moratorium.
    • 01:44:09
      This is a follow-up to the workshop item we had last month, and we are presenting a resolution to the CTB to provide a six-month extension to the current bond moratorium.
    • 01:44:21
      Last month, after the workshop presentation, we were asked to reach out to the six impacted localities and gather information about their efforts to date as well as their current investment.
    • 01:44:32
      A summary of their responses should be part of your board package, but just a quick update.
    • 01:44:38
      For three of the projects, the locality should have a majority of their bond investment documented, but
    • 01:44:46
      At least two of those have requested additional time to get the investment in.
    • 01:44:51
      A fourth locality has several businesses that we're currently working with the Virginia Economic Development Partnership on qualifying and we have had some positive indications that we should be able to document with some of that investment.
    • 01:45:05
      So it is our recommendation that the CTB provide a six-month extension on the current bond moratorium and I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:13
      And this is through December 31st of this year?
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:18
      Yes.
    • 01:45:19
      Mr. Chairman, just a discussion.
    • 01:45:21
      I really would like to see the department analyze the situation and really see if we should be in this.
    • 01:45:32
      I don't think we should get people doing this.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:35
      Yeah, I think that's what the actual extension is.
    • 01:45:41
      We're going to do it for six months.
    • 01:45:42
      And they were going to come back to us.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:44
      No, no, no.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:45
      It's the whole program.
    • 01:45:47
      It's the whole program.
    • 01:45:51
      But I think that's what this is.
    • 01:45:52
      This isn't one project.
    • 01:45:53
      It's the whole program.
    • 01:45:54
      We're extending it six months and they're going to come back to us to let us know exactly what your thoughts are.
    • 01:46:01
      You know, what their recommendation should we be in this or not.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:05
      Mr. Fralin.
    • 01:46:06
      Mr. Chairman, just to Mr. Williams' point, I don't agree.
    • 01:46:11
      These are transportation funds, not economic development funds.
    • 01:46:18
      I'd also be interested in you said three projects looked pretty good.
    • 01:46:25
      What were the ones that did not look pretty good?
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:46:29
      So there were six localities.
    • 01:46:31
      that under the current bond moratorium have not met the full investment amount.
    • 01:46:36
      Two of those actually had major announcements in March that should qualify all of their investment and one is working on some.
    • 01:46:44
      I think they'll get at least some of their investment.
    • 01:46:45
      The two localities that to date have not identified any businesses based on their response to us and working with Economic Development Partnership are the town of West Point and Shenandoah County.
    • 01:47:00
      And they both indicate they'll continue working over the next six months, but at this point they do not have any businesses that have committed.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:14
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • Court G. RosenMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:47:37
      O'Rourke Jr., John M. Brown, John M. Brown Jr.
    • 01:47:55
      I have them determine whether it qualifies with road money and there's a disconnect there.
    • 01:48:00
      If there was a way to have the metrics such that you and your team were able to make these determinations, for instance, within Mr. Fralin's district in Rocky Mount, the issue with the road, whether a business is adequately using that road or not, I think it would be easier if Julie and her team were able to determine what that is.
    • 01:48:21
      I also think that, a little bit to your point,
    • 01:48:24
      That the localities, because I think some information you received from at least one project I know of, it was information that you just hadn't had. You didn't even know it was out there and whether businesses were coming or going or whether it was qualified. And I think that we need to in some way make clear to the localities, you can't wait until the deadline to tell us that you have something coming. There needs to be constant communication because there seems to be a rule.
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:48:49
      And we actually since our last meeting we met with the Virginia Economic Development Partnership and one of the things that we agreed is that we need to work closer on these bonded projects long before we get to this point and they actually ask that they be made aware of anyone that's considering because in some cases the bonded project may not be the best decision from the locality meaning you know a couple of these you look at them
    • 01:49:19
      They lack some of your basic utilities, public water, public sewer, and those things do make it difficult to attract larger businesses and so they've agreed that you know we would let them know of anyone that's looking into a bonded project.
    • 01:49:34
      They'd be happy to work much closer with them throughout the entire process.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 01:49:40
      The code of
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:49:48
      specifies certain types of businesses and then it also indicates that businesses that are qualified by the economic development partnership and they basically look at the investment that the company is bringing to the state in addition to what was already there so as an example if it was a business that is primarily doing their business locally
    • 01:50:11
      It may not meet their basic employer definition, but certain types of businesses automatically qualify, like manufacturing.
    • 01:50:21
      But others, it basically depends on their impact to the economics of Virginia, and so they look at to what degree are they bringing in revenue from outside of Virginia.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:50:33
      All that discussion, regardless of what the funds come from, I don't think we're the agency to evaluate these economic development projects.
    • 01:50:47
      We're road builders.
    • 01:50:48
      If the VED people give them the money to build roads, the building minister will do the thing that we always do.
    • 01:50:56
      But it's just, I've never thought it was a good thing.
    • 01:51:01
      Well I think that's that's what we're going to be doing in December well before then coming back to you with the assessment of the program and so you can make a decision
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:23
      We do need a motion for the extension.
    • 01:51:26
      So moved.
    • 01:51:27
      Is there a second?
    • 01:51:28
      Second.
    • 01:51:28
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:51:30
      Aye.
    • 01:51:30
      Any opposed?
    • 01:51:32
      OK, now for the specific jobs.
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 01:51:34
      OK, the second item is for a deallocation of previously approved economic development access funds.
    • 01:51:42
      This is a project in Frederick County.
    • 01:51:45
      Frederick County has two bonded economic development access projects in the same business part.
    • 01:51:50
      As part of their project development,
    • 01:51:52
      The road had to cross a railroad, and the railroad company specifically requested that provisions be made to accommodate their expansion of their railroad lines, which ended up requiring a much larger bridge, and the cost estimate rose.
    • 01:52:08
      As a result, the county made the decision to build this road with revenue sharing funds, because their one-half of the $8 million cost was significantly less
    • 01:52:20
      then it would have been if they had pursued it as an economic development access because under that program they have to fund everything over and above the allocation that has been provided.
    • 01:52:30
      So this roadway actually is still being built.
    • 01:52:32
      It's actually under construction right now but it's being built with revenue sharing therefore they have requested that we deallocate the economic development access allocation and we would ask your concurrence in that request.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:47
      Is there a second?
    • 01:52:49
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:51
      I had a question.
    • 01:52:53
      This is not related necessarily to the city project, but why do highway departments always have to pay when the railroad wants to increase their capacity over a bridge?
    • 01:53:07
      Why does the railroad not have some responsibility in that?
    • 01:53:12
      I'm sure somewhere in the code they got to do this.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:16
      I'm not sure it's a code.
    • 01:53:19
      They own the railroad.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:23
      A lot of people own houses.
    • 01:53:25
      We condemn them too.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:27
      I understand.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:28
      I don't know the specific circumstances about this bridge, but a railroad right-of-way exists, and to a large extent the railroads enjoy significant protections of their right-of-way.
    • 01:53:43
      In many cases, they existed before the roads existed.
    • 01:53:47
      If they have a need, they say at some point we may need to add a second or third track which brings the track physically closer to where we would set a pier for a bridge.
    • 01:53:57
      We may have to extend the, move the piers to get them out of the, with the crash zone frankly.
    • 01:54:04
      What they will do with things, that may be what has happened in this particular case, but the challenge that we do have with the railroads is that we have some pretty limited ability to make any demands on them.
    • 01:54:23
      They are a private land holder, but beyond the fact that they're a private land holder, they do enjoy some protection to go back to the 1800s.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:31
      I'm sure that my question is we've got a perfectly good project that's going to build a bridge over an existing right-of-way and the railroad has no incentive not to say well we kind of maybe one day we might need some you know and so they come in and then the project price goes up and they don't have any share in that and
    • 01:55:00
      That's the thing that concerns me.
    • 01:55:02
      I mean why can't we just say well that's great if you want to expand it then you know in the future you get to pay because right now if they want to expand their right-of-way under an existing bridge you pay for that.
    • 01:55:14
      They do I suspect.
    • 01:55:16
      Why do they get to veto over what we want to do?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:21
      I think it has a lot to do with just the relationship that we have with them and getting access to their tracks.
    • 01:55:28
      I don't know, I think it's a good question and we'll go research it.
    • 01:55:35
      I'm not so much sure it's legal as it is dealing with the Class 1 railroads.
    • 01:55:41
      I mean, look, what we have to pay to get capacity is far beyond a market rate.
    • 01:55:49
      I mean, far beyond.
    • 01:55:51
      But, I mean, when I said they owned it, I wasn't being, I was really proud to say it because
    • 01:55:58
      Simply we need to use, we want access to what we play by their rules.
    • 01:56:04
      I'm not saying that's an answer to what you're saying, but I understand where you're coming from.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:10
      We can report back to you, but I do, working with DRPT as well as our legal folks, we even have some limitations in terms of eminent domain over the rail, so we do have some authorities, but we don't have the same eminent domain, the ability to
    • 01:56:29
      I think the storm water is an issue that came up with this general assembly session.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:39
      I mean, they want to be exempt.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:40
      Now you're going to hear from Mr. Rosen.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:43
      Yeah, I understand.
    • 01:56:43
      I know, but I haven't.
    • 01:56:44
      But my point is, it's in this general, I understand.
    • 01:56:50
      All right.
    • 01:56:51
      Is there any more discussion on this?
    • 01:56:53
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:56:55
      Aye.
    • 01:56:55
      Any opposed?
    • 01:56:57
      The resolution passes.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:57
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:59
      Okay, Mr. Donohue.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:57:05
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 01:57:07
      Before you, you have a resolution that would provide guidance and adopt a kind of draft scenario for staff to use to develop a six-year improvement program to program funds from the high priority project program as well as a district grants program.
    • 01:57:22
      There are several clauses in the resolution.
    • 01:57:25
      Essentially what it does is it adopts the scenario as modified with the exceptions that was presented yesterday and then also directs staff to go back and review the programming policy that you adopted last year with a one-year sunset and provide any recommendations for a future policy to this board by its September meeting.
    • 01:57:44
      Mr. Chairman, I'd be happy to answer any questions the board may have.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:48
      Is there a motion?
    • 01:57:49
      Motion.
    • 01:57:50
      So moved.
    • 01:57:50
      Is there a second?
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:52
      Second.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:53
      Any comments or further discussion on this matter?
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:57
      For reasons that I stated amply yesterday, I will be abstaining from this vote, although I am in favor of what Nick and the staff have done here with these recommendations.
    • 01:58:11
      It's just for me a point in time, though, because we will not have input that will be coming from the Loudoun County Board of Supervisors on one particular item.
    • 01:58:21
      In the whereases that we won't have available until late Thursday evening.
    • 01:58:28
      So that is the cause of my abstention.
    • 01:58:30
      But I hope by the time we get around to the June real vote on the six-year plan, we'll have a favorable outcome to that one item.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:40
      So noted.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 01:58:41
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to associate myself with Gary's comments on that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:46
      Are you going to abstain then?
    • 01:58:47
      Yes.
    • 01:58:47
      Okay.
    • 01:58:48
      So Mr. Dyke will abstain also.
    • 01:58:51
      Okay, anything else?
    • 01:58:54
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 01:58:56
      Aye.
    • 01:58:56
      Any opposed?
    • 01:58:58
      Okay, passes with those two abstentions.
    • 01:59:02
      Okay, now we have Mr. Kilpatrick and on the topic we just spoke about.
    • 01:59:07
      Let me just make two comments before Mr. Kilpatrick gets going on this.
    • 01:59:11
      One is, there was a conversation, these are no cost overruns yet.
    • 01:59:16
      These were, I think that's an improper
    • 01:59:19
      And if we've used them, we shouldn't, the public should understand, they're not cost overruns.
    • 01:59:23
      It certainly is an excess of the budget, but not a cost overrun because now we have actual data in that.
    • 01:59:30
      Second of all, when I was speaking, I think just to clarify,
    • 01:59:33
      The authority I had was as chairman of the board, not as secretary, based on the resolutions.
    • 01:59:38
      I want to make that clear.
    • 01:59:40
      As chairman of the board, I thought, not as secretary, as chairman of the board, and if I said something, that's what I meant, based on the resolution instructing Troy to move forward.
    • 01:59:53
      I know this could be read a different way, but it was from that authority, not the executive authority from being secretary.
    • 02:00:02
      With that, Mr. Kilpatrick, I don't know if you want to...
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:00:08
      This has been well discussed, so just very quickly, you have in the attached brief document, you can see the actual bid amounts, and you can see that Lane Construction Corp. STV was low bid by about $11 million.
    • 02:00:23
      They also received a much higher score, and again, design-build
    • 02:00:28
      Generally speaking, it's 70% price, 30% technical requirements in terms of their technical score.
    • 02:00:36
      Layne Construction is a well-established construction company in Virginia, nationally and internationally.
    • 02:00:43
      They're part of the joint venture on the 29 Project right now, clearly within their capabilities to deliver projects' complexity.
    • 02:00:50
      So what I'm asking you today to do is to affirm and ratify my decision to award the contract, the executed design-build contract for the GRT bus rapid transit project.
    • Marty WilliamsMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:03
      Mr. Chairman, I would move that we approve the resolution.
    • 02:01:07
      I suspect we have a resolution, right?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:09
      Yeah, we do have a resolution.
    • 02:01:11
      Is there a second?
    • 02:01:14
      Second.
    • John MalbonMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:14
      Okay.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:01:18
      Okay.
    • 02:01:18
      All right.
    • 02:01:18
      So there is a motion for approval.
    • 02:01:21
      And the second, is there further discussion on this topic?
    • 02:01:25
      Okay.
    • 02:01:26
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 02:01:28
      Aye.
    • 02:01:28
      Any opposed?
    • 02:01:30
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:01:31
      And we will report the next, coming soon, about how to offer some guidance on this type of situation in the future.
    • 02:01:41
      Now we get into contracts.
    • 02:01:42
      Mr. Moore, additional contracts.
    • 02:01:45
      Sure.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 02:01:45
      I have one contract to bring to you this morning.
    • 02:01:48
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 02:01:51
      It just ties into our State of Good Repair discussion yesterday, because these are two bridges on I-81 in Washington County and Bristol District that are structurally deficient.
    • 02:02:01
      This contract is replacement of the I-81 structures 18-942 and 18-944 over Route 808, Hall Bottom Road, and Sinking Creek.
    • 02:02:12
      In Washington County, it's a design build,
    • 02:02:15
      Orders Construction Company bid $11,283,000.
    • 02:02:18
      We had three bids on it.
    • 02:02:22
      The low bid we've just read, next bid was $13,164, about $1.9 million difference, and the high bid, Wagman, another good company, was about $9.6 million above the low bid.
    • 02:02:35
      So we've got a very good bid price.
    • 02:02:37
      Orders Construction does work for us.
    • 02:02:39
      They're out of West Virginia, have done good work for us in the past.
    • 02:02:42
      We recommend that the
    • 02:02:43
      that the board approve this for award.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:47
      There's a motion for approval.
    • 02:02:49
      Is there a second?
    • 02:02:49
      Second.
    • 02:02:50
      Any discussion, comments?
    • 02:02:52
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 02:02:54
      Aye.
    • Garrett MooreChief Engineer
    • 02:02:55
      Any opposed?
    • 02:02:56
      Thank you, sir.
    • 02:02:56
      Okay, thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:02:58
      We have new business.
    • 02:02:59
      I know we have one item on.
    • 02:03:01
      I'll turn to Mr. Galsinski here for that.
    • F. Gary GarczynskiMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:04
      Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:03:06
      You have in front of you a resolution from our board commending Robert O., Bob Chase,
    • 02:03:13
      who in essence has been Mr. Transportation in Northern Virginia for quite a few decades as the head of the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance.
    • 02:03:24
      Bob has been on top of and has commented on just about any issue that's come before this board in the last 30 years.
    • 02:03:32
      He pushes, he prods, but he always has the best interest of the Commonwealth of Virginia at heart.
    • 02:03:40
      And this has been his life's work, and he is retiring from that position.
    • 02:03:47
      And this resolution commends him for his lifelong effort in that vein.
    • 02:03:55
      So I would put forth that motion, Mr. Secretary.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:03:59
      I think it would be appropriate that we actually read the resolution in honor of Mr. Chase.
    • 02:04:04
      Mr. Husky, I'll do that or would you like, I'll be happy to do that.
    • 02:04:08
      The title is the Commending Robert O.
    • 02:04:11
      Bob Chase Resolution.
    • 02:04:13
      Whereas the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance, NVTA, was created in 1987 to serve as an advocacy group to promote greater citizen awareness of and involvement in regional transportation issues.
    • 02:04:26
      And whereas Robert O.
    • 02:04:27
      Bob Chase,
    • 02:04:29
      has worked with NVTA in varying capacities since its creation including serving as President Emeritus and whereas following his education at Brown University in 1967, Mr. Chase's long-standing interest in politics and public policy issues eventually brought him to the Northern Virginia region where he engaged in a successful business career as a consultant,
    • 02:04:53
      and whereas Mr. Chase's decades living and working in the region as well as his skills in communication and consensus building as well as his reputation for candor and persuasiveness make him an ideal advocate for transportation infrastructure that is safe, convenient and conducive to enhanced economic opportunities and improved quality of life.
    • 02:05:15
      and whereas as a consultant to or official of the NBTA and as a participant in regional planning and advisory organizations, Mr. Chase played a major role in advancing transportation projects and initiatives in the Washington, D.C. area including the Woodrow Wilson Bridge, improvements to Interstate 66 Techway, Virginia Railway Express, Dulles Greenway and the Route 28 Transportation District and whereas Mr. Chase's optimism
    • 02:05:43
      That's a good word.
    • 02:05:44
      For continued progress in developing a coordinated transportation network and enthusiasm for finding reasonable solutions to alleviate problems serves as encouragement that such progress will occur.
    • 02:05:57
      and whereas the Board wishes to express its appreciation to Mr. Chase for his tireless and dedicated service to the Commonwealth, now therefore be it resolved that the members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board extend their highest commendation and appreciation to Mr. Chase for his years of outstanding service on behalf of the citizens of Northern Virginia region and the Commonwealth as a whole and express their best wishes to him.
    • 02:06:22
      So with that, we have a motion from Mr. Garzginski.
    • 02:06:25
      Is there a second?
    • 02:06:26
      Second.
    • 02:06:27
      Any other discussion?
    • 02:06:30
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 02:06:32
      Aye.
    • 02:06:33
      All those opposed.
    • 02:06:35
      So Bob, if you're listening at home, are you seeing this?
    • 02:06:38
      I'm sure he is.
    • 02:06:39
      Very much appreciate all your comments and work over the years and extend to us our very best wishes in your retirement.
    • 02:06:49
      Something tells me we will still run into you quite a bit and that will be to our benefit.
    • 02:06:53
      So congratulations to you, Mr. Chase.
    • 02:06:57
      Now, is there any other new business to come before the board today?
    • 02:07:03
      Okay, hearing none, then Mr. Dyke?
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:07:06
      Our next meeting is going to be in Stanton, is that correct?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:11
      That is correct, and it will be similar to this one.
    • 02:07:14
      We will have the public hearing the night, the Stanton public hearing on Monday, and then we'll be staying Monday and Tuesday night.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 02:07:22
      Where are we staying this time?
    • 02:07:23
      Stonewall Jackson.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:24
      Stonewall Jackson.
    • 02:07:27
      Mr. Whitworth, you've got a high level 200 seat, Ms. Valentine, so no pressure.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:07:34
      Mr. Whitworth, do you own an apron?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:07:36
      I would just ask that we don't lose contact with the bus.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:07:44
      Well, I just wanted to extend on behalf of Lynchburg, thank you all for being here and I'm hoping that some things were a little bit of a surprise.
    • 02:07:58
      They were.
    • 02:07:59
      Anyway, welcome back when you were able to do so.
    • 02:08:03
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:04
      Okay, so I'm sure Carol will get the itinerary out and I appreciate everybody's support and I truly mean that we had some
    • 02:08:14
      We've had some difficult things to work through.
    • 02:08:17
      We'll have some more, but I do appreciate the working relationship that we all have here and look forward to seeing you next month.
    • 02:08:26
      So with that, we will adjourn the meeting.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:29
      You're not taking the iPads today yet.
    • 02:08:31
      We're still working out the issues with getting your email server.
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:08:37
      And we are having the at-large meeting for transportation alternatives immediately following this in this room.