Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 5/20/2015
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   5/20/2015

Attachments
  • Meeting minutes.pdf
  • Proposed limited access control changes, Route 210, Amherst County.pdf
  • Approval of proposed limited access control changes, Jones Branch Connector, Fairfax County.pdf
  • Maps.pdf
  • Resolution_Agenda_Item_2_Attachment_CE.pdf
  • Authorization for the Commissioner of Highways to enter into a joint funding agreement between Virginia Department of Transportation and the U.S. Ge.pdf
  • Attachment.pdf
  • “1st LT Robert Yowell” Memorial Bridge Commemorative Naming of the bridge over the Robinson River on Route 231 (North Blue Ridge P.pdf
  • Resolution_Agenda_Item_4_Attachment.pdf
  • Request.pdf
  • Addition of projects to the Six-Year Improvement Program for Fiscal Years 2015 - 20.pdf
  • Appendix A.pdf
  • Fiscal Years 2015 - 20 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers, March 21 - April 23, 2015.pdf
  • Monthly Transfer Report.pdf
  • Recreational access to Galbreath-Marshall Park project RECR-204-174, M501, Culpeper County.pdf
  • Resolution.pdf
  • Resolution_Agenda_Item_7_Attachment_Map.pdf
  • Recreational access to Daniel Boone Wilderness Trail Interpretive Center, project SLEN-084-101, C501 (revised), Scott County.pdf
  • Resolution_Agenda_Item_8_Attachment_Map.pdf
  • Nov. 19, 2009, resolution.pdf
  • Adopt TSDAC Tiered Capital Allocation methodology.pdf
  • Presentation.pdf
  • Application list.pdf
  • Policy goals.pdf
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Judge against instead of just out there without having some parameters put around it.
    • 00:00:05
      So I just want to let you know we fully expect to have continuing adjustments as we work through this.
    • 00:00:13
      That's the first thing.
    • 00:00:15
      Second thing, and I'll mention this again in the formal session, I've been working to say exactly, give some parameters not only to the board but to the public and how we're going to move forward under what we discussed yesterday in regard to 66 procurement financing options.
    • 00:00:33
      So, at the formal session, I'll make an announcement as to how that's going to happen and how you can expect to have input into that.
    • 00:00:41
      So, a couple things there and what we will do today is we're going to have to break at
    • 00:00:48
      Close to being done if not, but at 10 we will break to move into public comment.
    • 00:00:54
      So if we're not done this session, I'll suspend it, move into formal session, have public comment, we'll do the action items, and then if we have to we'll come back into this to finalize a couple of things.
    • 00:01:07
      So that's the plan for today, and with that we'll turn it back over to Mr. Donohue and we'll continue on with House Bill 2.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:01:15
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 00:01:17
      Good morning.
    • 00:01:17
      I'm going to pick up where we left off yesterday on the House Bill 2 presentation.
    • 00:01:22
      As you remember, we've walked through a few of the different metrics and exactly how we scored them.
    • 00:01:26
      We have three of those left, and so we have accessibility, economic development, and the land use factors.
    • 00:01:32
      And then the last thing we have is the overall scores, and really walking through, looking at those based on the raw score, relative score with total cost, and the relative score with the House Bill 2 eligible cost.
    • 00:01:43
      So in accessibility, there were three things that were examined in the pilot scoring.
    • 00:01:48
      First was the cumulative increase in access to jobs.
    • 00:01:52
      The second was the cumulative increase in access to jobs for disadvantaged populations.
    • 00:01:56
      And the final was access to travel options.
    • 00:01:59
      With all of these projects, what we have been using is a GIS tool that we developed specifically for the House Bill 2 process that has an input of where the location of all jobs and residents are today within a given region.
    • 00:02:13
      It breaks the region up into zones, and then we map the existing transportation network and look about how far can someone travel and how many jobs can they reach within a 45-minute period.
    • 00:02:25
      We then add the improvement
    • 00:02:26
      into that GIS tool and see how that changes the number of jobs or the distance that can be traveled and look at what is the cumulative benefit or change and increase that takes place for one of those projects.
    • 00:02:40
      We're still working on this tool.
    • 00:02:42
      We're going to need to spend some additional probably resources to make it streamlined to get it to work a little faster and to make it more nimble than where it is today, but it's been a pretty helpful tool and has been eye-opening as we've looked at the results.
    • 00:02:53
      And so again, just to kind of walk you through it, pretend this is a region here and we've cut it up into 15 zones.
    • 00:03:00
      What the tool does is when they're without the project, it looks at zone one and it goes to each and every other zone and figures out how far can you go and how many jobs are in those zones and can you get there in 45 minutes.
    • 00:03:14
      And once it does that for one zone, it then moves to the next zone and does the exact same tool, which gives you kind of the cumulative access to jobs within the region without the project.
    • 00:03:24
      One thing I should note is you kind of see travel from block zone two to zone one.
    • 00:03:30
      That's probably a pretty short trip, and it gives higher credit for those shorter trips than it does for a longer trip, because most people are willing, you know, 100 percent of people will make a five-minute, ten-minute drive.
    • 00:03:40
      Maybe not 100% of people will make a 45-minute, 60-minute drive, so you get less credit the further away a particular job is under this tool.
    • 00:03:49
      Then it goes through all the other blocks and does the same thing and gives you that kind of cumulative access for the region.
    • 00:03:55
      Then what we do is, after you've analyzed that,
    • 00:03:58
      You look at in the blue here is what you could reach without the improvement.
    • 00:04:01
      That red is kind of the extra jobs and zones that can be reached in this region because that improvement has been made to the overall network.
    • 00:04:10
      And again, you go zone by zone and do that and then do it through all the zones.
    • 00:04:14
      And what you get at the end is kind of an overall change in the cumulative access to jobs within a region.
    • 00:04:20
      For the disadvantaged access to jobs, we do something similar.
    • 00:04:24
      However, we focus on disadvantaged populations, which is defined in the pilot tool as low-income, elderly, minority, and then non-English speakers.
    • 00:04:35
      And so you kind of do the same thing that we talked about for the entire population, but really focus it in.
    • 00:04:40
      on this kind of social equity aspect to examine whether or not these disadvantaged populations are also benefiting with regard to access to jobs the same way the overall population as a whole is.
    • 00:04:54
      The last part of the accessibility score is kind of the improved access to travel options and under this one we evaluate projects to see if they enhance non-SOV modal options and they can get a point for each kind of modal option that they enhance and then we scale the project to really understand the impact or the benefit it has by looking at the number of users that would be using that mode and that is how we kind of calculate this last part of the accessibility score which again is 20% of the overall
    • 00:05:23
      accessibility score.
    • 00:05:25
      And so if you take a look here, this is the top ten projects in the pilot scoring.
    • 00:05:30
      using the accessibility score.
    • 00:05:31
      The number one project is the 15 expansion buses.
    • 00:05:35
      Again, we talked about this project yesterday.
    • 00:05:37
      This is a set of buses that are building off of the existing metro network.
    • 00:05:43
      And because they really have that synergy with the metro rail network, they have a really large number of jobs that it increases access to because it serves as kind of a last mile or two connection to some very, very dense activity centers.
    • 00:05:56
      If you move down here you'll see kind of auxiliary lanes and other things that are addressing bottlenecks on major interstate corridors and as one might expect really improving some of those allows people in given regions to really reach a larger number of jobs than they otherwise would be able to.
    • 00:06:13
      And then you see just the multimodal access score, the top one there as this is constructed today is an improvement to an interstate that adds a general purpose lane and an HOV lane.
    • 00:06:25
      And the reason that's the highest is there's expected to be a large number of HOV users on that facility, and that's providing a lot of access to carpooling, vanpooling, and other transit opportunities.
    • 00:06:37
      Here's the bottom ten.
    • 00:06:38
      score and what you see is on accessibility there's a fair number of projects that didn't really register a large amount of benefit either in the access to jobs or in the access to travel options and one of the things we see here is using the 45 minute window in some places most of the jobs today
    • 00:06:57
      can already be reached pretty easily within a 40, even 20 minute types of windows.
    • 00:07:03
      And so while the improvement may have provided a shorter route somewhere or may have reduced the overall travel time for each location, it didn't change the ability of the average worker to get to more jobs within that 45 minute window.
    • 00:07:20
      So a few things, kind of observations and challenges with this is, one, as I said, this tool is new.
    • 00:07:28
      It's been used in other parts of the country, but it's new here to Virginia, and we're creating this on a statewide basis.
    • 00:07:33
      And so it doesn't currently have a transit module.
    • 00:07:36
      That's functioning.
    • 00:07:37
      And so when we evaluate transit projects, we're actually just capturing the benefits of taking users off the roadway network.
    • 00:07:44
      We need to really make sure that we also capture, say, if we're improving VRE, the new number of jobs that people might be able to reach in an hour on that VRE or other transit systems.
    • 00:07:53
      And so we're working on that.
    • 00:07:54
      The other thing is right now the amount of processing time
    • 00:07:58
      That this takes on a staff level is pretty high, and so we're going to really need to work to streamline this, because again, we input all of the land use for the entire state in there, and we have to go by individually and change the assumptions of speed and travel for each individual project to run this tool for all of them.
    • 00:08:17
      It's similar to what you do in a long-range plan for regional models and statewide models.
    • 00:08:21
      We just need to find some ways to make it work a little faster.
    • 00:08:24
      And then the other thing is the results do seem to have a correlation with job density.
    • 00:08:28
      And this plays the same way in both urban and rural areas, so just looking at the activity centers.
    • 00:08:33
      And that would make sense if you're talking about access to jobs.
    • 00:08:36
      Are we making it easier for someone to, say, get into downtown Salem or Roanoke, which is kind of that job density area within that region?
    • 00:08:43
      And the same thing's kind of in Northern Virginia.
    • 00:08:45
      Are we getting access into Tysons?
    • 00:08:46
      Are we creating better access into the Pentagon, things of that nature?
    • 00:08:49
      And there's just a correlation there.
    • 00:08:51
      It was an observation the staff had.
    • 00:08:56
      No questions?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:08:58
      Mr. Fralin is not here yet.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:09:02
      Well, I was a little nervous when Mr. Tucker and Mr. Julian had to go home.
    • 00:09:06
      They have pre-existing commitments.
    • 00:09:08
      They're the ones who scored this, so I got a little nervous yesterday.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:09:11
      Yes, Mr. Connors.
    • 00:09:15
      Nick, as you well know, this came up in our FAMPO meeting that you attended two months, last month.
    • 00:09:21
      Any other
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:09:23
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Connors and members of the board, what Mr. Connors is referring to is when I presented to the Fredericksburg area MPO, there was a lot of concern that many folks in that region actually commute longer than 45 minutes in their car to jobs and I think we did not hear that concern in other regions, but I also want to stress this isn't measuring someone's actual trip.
    • 00:09:49
      What we're looking at is their opportunity to access jobs.
    • 00:09:53
      And so even if we're not putting in improvements that might allow someone to travel, say, from Spotsylvania County all the way to K Street, which I suspect some folks in that area do, that's about an hour and ten minutes even in free flow.
    • 00:10:07
      So it's significantly longer during rush hour but even improvements on 95 will capture other parts and activity centers in the Northern Virginia area which will help increase the cumulative access to jobs and so I think there was a bit of a misunderstanding with some of the board members where they thought this was looking at their actual commutes not the opportunity to access additional jobs because I don't think we can
    • 00:10:29
      I think we need to measure what is happening today because people change jobs and other things happen. What we need to understand is the ability to access those jobs, not what your commute is today because it could be very different tomorrow. And so this is not an issue that was raised in other regions. I just want to make a comment here, a lot of these measures we sometimes
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:52
      I think just in technical terms, you know, in terms of trying to measure something, but if you've been reading the press lately, it's just been another Harvard review done, the actual, what transportation options and access, how that directly correlates not only to mobility in the transportation system, but upward mobility in life.
    • 00:11:14
      In other words, so while we sometimes tend to think that it's just accessibility something where these have real life consequences and more and more studies are showing your accessibility to various options.
    • 00:11:31
      being able to is also directly tied to your ability to improve or better your position whether it's financial or otherwise in life so very important that we keep that in mind sometimes as we you know frame some of these technical issues we're talking about but that's really at the end of the day what we're trying to to accomplish
    • 00:11:55
      And I think accessibility is obviously, when we tend to think of it, how does it connect in, it really has some very social impacts also.
    • 00:12:03
      Mr. Tom.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:09
      A lot of conversations that I've had have centered around using percentage increase as opposed to the absolute numbers of jobs.
    • 00:12:20
      And I wonder if you could speak to that.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:12:23
      Yes, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Tonka, the other, I think, comment we heard on the accessibility, there was the issue raised by FAMPO, there was also the issue of central destinations, which we've removed due to kind of the subjectivity of that definition.
    • 00:12:37
      The other thing that has been raised most permanently in this area is whether we should be measuring the peer number of cumulative increase in jobs or their percentage.
    • 00:12:46
      increase in jobs and at the staff we kind of went back and did some sensitivity testing not using discrete product but just example projects to look at what that could mean.
    • 00:12:55
      We ultimately did not think that was an appropriate recommendation to the board because at the end of the day we're dividing by cost.
    • 00:13:03
      And again, some of those projects that are more costly may have the same percentage increase to jobs as a less costly project, but it could also be four times as many in the raw number.
    • 00:13:14
      And so we wanted to create something that we thought was a fair analysis, and so we're scared the percentages might create a bias towards smaller projects compared to kind of something that looks at the overall increase dividing by cost.
    • 00:13:28
      But that is something, members of the board, we have heard.
    • 00:13:30
      I think we heard it from the Culpeper region, and we also, I believe, heard it from the Petersburg area, if I recall correctly.
    • 00:13:41
      Okay.
    • 00:13:42
      I move on.
    • 00:13:43
      The next factor area is the economic development, and I do want to say this has been one of the toughest areas to crack, and, you know, based on the discussion yesterday on reliability, we're going to, you know, we can look for any additional feedback in the coming weeks, but we're going to
    • 00:13:57
      Unless we hear otherwise, we're probably going to work to try and incorporate that into this with probably a proposed weighting of 60% for the square footage of development, 20% for this intermodal access, and then 20% for reliability.
    • 00:14:09
      So again, I just want to remind the board that was not used in the pilot testing because we were developing that reliability measure when we put in place the pilot testing, but you probably will see that change in the final version of this factor area.
    • 00:14:24
      So the square footage development supported has been the thing where we've gotten the widest range of responses as we tried to do the pilot scoring, and it was the area where we really think we need to have the most work to do in tightening up the definitions.
    • 00:14:38
      As I talked about yesterday, when we got local input,
    • 00:14:41
      From a lot of the folks looking at what is the type of growth that's submitted, we had some people that did very kind of detailed analysis and looked at the sites that were directly accessed and only counted square footage on those sites.
    • 00:14:54
      And then we had other people that drew a five-mile buffer and went in and counted every undeveloped parcel and the maximum allowable zoning and said, we're going to create this much economic development, whether or not the improvement actually was going to create
    • 00:15:06
      And so we've really tried to kind of tighten this up and what we're going to be doing is looking at how far along proposed developments within the project area are moving forward and again this can be a new site an expansion of the existing site or redevelopment of a currently underutilized site and the further along you are the more points you get so you'll get a point if you're consistent and referenced in the local comprehensive and economic development strategy
    • 00:15:34
      There.
    • 00:15:35
      You'll get another point.
    • 00:15:37
      If you're consistent with a regional economic development strategy, most PDCs develop these as do some of the MPOs, and so we'll be looking both at those.
    • 00:15:44
      Is this something that's actually talked about?
    • 00:15:46
      Are you talking about attracting this type of industry in your regional economic development plans or not?
    • 00:15:51
      And if you are, you'll get more points along because it's consistent with the broader planning that's been done in that region.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:01
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_29
    • 00:16:03
      A question on when we talk about square footage that these projects support.
    • 00:16:07
      Are we talking about commercial, retail, residential combined?
    • 00:16:11
      Commercial, industrial?
    • 00:16:12
      How is that broken out?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:16:14
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Kaskowitz, it's essentially everything excluding residential development.
    • 00:16:19
      And I think institutional is probably not considered as well.
    • 00:16:22
      But that is spelled out in detail in the dependencies.
    • 00:16:24
      But it's basically job producing development, not the housing where the people might be.
    • 00:16:32
      Then we'll also give you points as to whether or not these sites where the development might be located, how far along is it?
    • 00:16:39
      So does the comp plan or zoning call for this type of development on that site?
    • 00:16:44
      Is there a site plan pending or approved for that site?
    • 00:16:47
      And are there utilities either programmed or in place on that site?
    • 00:16:50
      And they can get a maximum of up to five points.
    • 00:16:53
      And then for each site, those points are going to be scaled based on a set of factors.
    • 00:16:58
      And these factors really came, the need for these came out in the pilot scoring.
    • 00:17:03
      And so we're going to scale it based on whether or not the project provides direct access to the proposed sites.
    • 00:17:10
      So in some of the pilot scoreings, we had one example was an interstate widening.
    • 00:17:15
      The interstate itself, we were widening between two interchanges and there probably was not a lot of direct economic development that was happening because of just that widening.
    • 00:17:23
      But within a mile, there was a primary roadway that for a long time has been a major commercial corridor with a lot of planned office space and other development that was coming online regardless of whether or not
    • 00:17:35
      That facility was put in place and so we really need to try and distinguish whether or not the improvements are directly enhancing the access or if there just happens to be growth that's proximate to this improvement that might benefit from it.
    • 00:17:47
      And so again, direct access would get 100% of these square footage benefits while indirect access would only receive 50%.
    • 00:17:56
      The other thing that we saw in the pilot scoring is, again, some people looked very narrowly and some people looked out as far as five miles.
    • 00:18:04
      And we really don't think that projects five miles away are receiving the same type of benefit as projects within a mile.
    • 00:18:10
      And so once we've done the scaling based on direct access or indirect access, we'll divide that square footage by the number of miles it is away.
    • 00:18:18
      And so if it's within a mile, you'll get full credit.
    • 00:18:21
      Fralin Jr. Jr.,
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:43
      It seems to me that makes a lot of sense for secondary and maybe primary improvements, but above the interstate.
    • 00:18:53
      And it sounds to me like a new six miles of interstate could have an economic development impact for 30 years.
    • 00:19:09
      You know, I'm thinking about a mega project kind of thing and how they would score on this and it may be that they wouldn't be, I'm thinking about a new road.
    • 00:19:19
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:19:20
      Finish the SMART road for 73 or something like that.
    • 00:19:24
      How would they score on something like that?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:19:27
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, I don't know the specifics of those roads so I can't respond to how they might score.
    • 00:19:31
      What I would say is
    • 00:19:33
      This is the area that has been the toughest for staff since the very beginning.
    • 00:19:37
      It's still the area where the staff are the least comfortable with what we propose.
    • 00:19:41
      I think the really tough thing is on the rest of these, we can draw correlation, we can draw some causality between them, safety, congestion, accessibility.
    • 00:19:50
      We can really kind of quantify some of those and with confidence say, this improvement resulted in this change.
    • 00:19:56
      On economic development, it's very tough.
    • 00:19:58
      There's a whole host of other factors that go into that and I think our concern while I agree with you that say a new interstate or widening of an interstate for six miles in particular is going to probably have economic competitiveness benefits for a region well beyond this five mile buffer that we're allowing things to be considered.
    • 00:20:17
      The real question is where do we draw the line?
    • 00:20:20
      And how do we draw that?
    • 00:20:21
      And I think a lot of the other scoring factors will try and capture that competitiveness aspect.
    • 00:20:27
      We are really trying to focus on where we can draw distinctions that this improvement likely resulted in some of this growth taking place in this area.
    • 00:20:36
      One of the things we heard from our peer workshop, remember last November and September, we brought in folks from across the country who have done these types of exercises.
    • 00:20:45
      They said economic development is the toughest.
    • 00:20:46
      because it's really just hard to make that link and the thing they said is don't give credit to people if they just say widen this road and something great will happen.
    • 00:20:55
      You need to make people demonstrate that they've thought through this process and they know widening this road is going to help me have this development in this site, this development is going to be this type of industry.
    • 00:21:05
      They may not know the company but they have a strategy that they're trying to enhance that they can demonstrate this project plays a role in because that keeps this process a bit more honest.
    • 00:21:15
      That probably will miss some benefits, Mr. Fralin, but I think from a staff's perspective, we needed some way of being able to say there's a relationship between the improvement and the development that took place.
    • 00:21:25
      And I agree with that.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:26
      I understand the fine line that you have to, I mean, it's a little bit of a Potter Stewart kind of situation, you know.
    • 00:21:33
      You know it when you see it.
    • 00:21:35
      It's hard to define it.
    • 00:21:36
      How much discretion is in this score?
    • 00:21:40
      I mean, it doesn't look like there's a lot of
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:21:42
      Mr. Chairman, there's a lot of local input that will go into this measure and so we're going to be looking to the locals to really identify those sites.
    • 00:21:58
      Show us the regional economic development strategy, the local economic development strategy, and kind of demonstrate how it is consistent or referenced within that.
    • 00:22:07
      And so there is probably not a lot of staff discretion, but there's some local and regional discretion that exists within this metric.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:17
      I'm just thinking yesterday, and we formally thanked Scott, Mr. Kaspers, for the flyovers of the Northern Virginia District yesterday and looking at it.
    • 00:22:27
      We had a lot of discussion individually in the helicopter, but when you look at your comment about the economic development of widening a road and compare that to the congestion mitigation of the road, in other words, they're not always compatible.
    • 00:22:49
      And that's what was concerning me a little bit, if we just put all our eggs in one basket on a measure,
    • 00:22:57
      Now, I'm just throwing this as a quick note on a measure.
    • 00:22:59
      You know, we may not capture exactly what you're talking about.
    • 00:23:05
      In other words, that, you know, look, yes, we want to widen this, we want to connect A to B, but if we don't generate economic development or opportunities between A to B,
    • 00:23:16
      you know have we really accomplished what we're doing so I in your comments you're right if you put a you know a mega site in and it you know you improve the interstate for three or four miles you probably draw from 30 40 miles away I mean in terms of that so I just point out that a lot of these tools and I I'm not suggesting there shouldn't be emphasis but
    • 00:23:42
      The score well in one may not help you score well in another in that regard.
    • 00:23:50
      So I think it gets back to what we want to build the roads for.
    • 00:23:55
      And I think most of the time it's just more than one measure.
    • 00:24:01
      Now, I'm not downplaying, please, I'm not, Mr. Garza, I'm not downplaying.
    • 00:24:05
      I think, I mean, I certainly see the congestion issues in Northern Virginia, no doubt.
    • 00:24:10
      But I just caution that when we do one thing to the mutual exclusion of others, it may not be the results that we want.
    • 00:24:21
      And, Ms. Fralin, you mentioned a little bit earlier, what we're going to do after this presentation and work next month, you will actually be adopting the, just to make clear again, that's not the final.
    • 00:24:36
      I think what we'll do is when we get actual
    • 00:24:40
      projects to score, we're going to have a workshop and we can sit down and actually see what these things do instead of having these discussions, not instead, in addition to having these discussions, because I think that's when we can really see how these measures are going to impact and did we get it. So just throw that comment out as to, I think the real value will be when we score these and see how we compare.
    • 00:25:06
      Ms. Valentine, you had something you want to talk about.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:10
      Yes, thank you.
    • 00:25:12
      In our work session in Lynchburg, one of the concerns that came up about square footage was expansion versus new development.
    • 00:25:20
      Because sometimes with expansion, because you have an existing business, they have the cafeteria, the boardroom, they have a lot of the infrastructure in place, but an expansion can actually create a large number of jobs.
    • 00:25:34
      And so they may not be able to compete
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:25:37
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Valentine, that is one of the things we really struggled with on this metric is again we needed something we thought to scale it by since we'll be dividing by the cost to make sure there's no biases between small, large, or medium-sized projects and everywhere we went we kind of we really talked to people should we be using jobs, should we be using square footage, should we be using you know the expected private investment
    • 00:26:06
      and we basically could not, there was no consensus statewide and in many areas they said, well, you tell us.
    • 00:26:14
      We're not sure what it should be.
    • 00:26:15
      We kind of defer to you all and so we, the kind of, we did look at jobs which was going to be a way of doing that, kind of taking into account the fact that in some instances square footage might not be the best proxy for what's taking place and there's that change there, but we just couldn't come up with a way where
    • 00:26:32
      particularly when you have a site that's going to come online and has not yet or is earlier in the development process we can't quantify what the jobs are and we didn't want to end up in a place where we had to put a burden on the local government where they had to actually have a company in hand who would tell them a number of jobs before we would be able to count that as an economic benefit.
    • 00:26:52
      So I think one of the, we did not resolve that issue, but I think one of the things that we can look at doing in the future is maybe we can put an other column in the kind of information that localities provide to us, because as the Secretary said, this is a tool for the Board.
    • 00:27:06
      You're not required to score down there, so maybe we can kind of have, you know, other comments you'd like to provide to the board for consideration.
    • 00:27:13
      They can say, you know, there's a lot of expansion here.
    • 00:27:16
      We expect a high number of jobs even though our square footage is low, or other things of that nature, so we can provide that to you all as we move forward, but we couldn't figure out a way to work that into the overall scoring process just because it proved to be too difficult to quantify jobs.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:32
      And that's a really good point because, again, you make a decision and you get the score, you're not going to say, well, I think that's better.
    • 00:27:41
      I'm going to send it back to score.
    • 00:27:42
      You make a comment, and the law just says, tell us why you chose to do this one.
    • 00:27:47
      So I want to make that point out, too.
    • 00:27:50
      There are some, though, I will point out to infer, and I think the law does infer, that we want to try to use this measure.
    • 00:27:57
      We're going to use this measure.
    • 00:27:59
      But it shouldn't take away your overall judgment as long as we disclose why in our judgment we decided to do it.
    • 00:28:07
      That's really what the intent is.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:09
      Well, I appreciate the clarification, but I just thought it was a very interesting point when we're trying to determine the impact.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:18
      Oh, Ms. Dixon.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:20
      I recall yesterday your receding comments talking about don't try to draw conclusions of how this scoring will or might affect various classes and I understand now why you made those statements because
    • 00:28:43
      I did do a little analysis of the five categories, more specifically looking at the rural areas of C and D categories.
    • 00:28:57
      And to no surprise, I guess, the C and D categories pervasively dominated the bottom ten samples that you used.
    • 00:29:12
      Now, I don't know what the C and D categories did in the lower half versus the upper half, but I do think that we need, as we look at
    • 00:29:28
      making those independent decisions that the Secretary talked about, we do need to understand that as much as we're trying to make this not a biased matrix, it is biased.
    • 00:29:43
      It has to be because of the very nature of the things we're measuring.
    • 00:29:48
      For instance,
    • 00:29:49
      In congestion, there are only two that are C and D that are in the top ten.
    • 00:29:56
      In safety, there are only six.
    • 00:29:59
      In accessibility, there are zero.
    • 00:30:02
      In economic development, there are five.
    • 00:30:04
      In environmental, there are six.
    • 00:30:07
      I mean, there are three.
    • 00:30:09
      But if you look on the bottom ten, those numbers are vastly larger.
    • 00:30:15
      And there are all these are projects that have been done, approved, and I suspect in those areas are very important projects to those specific areas.
    • 00:30:27
      So this is the danger of trying to weigh importance with a mathematical matrix that we're required to do.
    • 00:30:40
      My point is we need to keep this in mind.
    • 00:30:43
      As these new projects come forward, there will be a need for
    • 00:30:53
      For advocates around the table to explain why if this project doesn't score well, it's an important project to those districts that we represent.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:06
      Well, I'll point out, I think that's why 1887 came in.
    • 00:31:11
      Half the monies go directly now to the districts.
    • 00:31:13
      They're only competing within the district.
    • 00:31:16
      And I suspect that this board at the state level are going to really be charged with those major projects.
    • 00:31:22
      You know, that connect regions.
    • 00:31:24
      I'm not saying that's, but I think that's the way things are going to come down.
    • 00:31:28
      And that was the reason why we wanted to make sure monies went right to districts because they're only competing.
    • 00:31:34
      So, so yes, thank you.
    • 00:31:36
      At the end of the day, House Bill 2 on a statewide basis only impacts 27 and a half percent of all the construction monies each year.
    • 00:31:44
      45% go right to for state of good repair to the districts and the other 27 and a half percent goes to the districts.
    • 00:31:52
      So you've got to keep putting that in context.
    • 00:31:56
      I mean, we're talking about less than 30 percent of the money, which probably is going to be, you know, these bigger projects are going to score pretty daggone high, I would guess.
    • 00:32:05
      And we are charged with a statewide connectivity.
    • 00:32:09
      I'm not suggesting that right now, but that's probably the way they're going to fall down.
    • 00:32:13
      We're going to need two, three, quarter million dollars at a pop for some of these larger projects.
    • 00:32:18
      So, and I think that's key, that is still our job.
    • 00:32:22
      Our job is not to fund just every project in every district.
    • 00:32:26
      And I'm not, don't get me wrong, I mean, I think we recognize that because that's why the money goes to 27.5% half of it goes there.
    • 00:32:36
      Our job is to make sure we have a statewide transportation network.
    • 00:32:41
      So, just throw that out.
    • 00:32:43
      And so, you're right.
    • 00:32:45
      If everything, if we hadn't have done 1887, I think exactly, I mean, that's what I was, I think we could have devolved it.
    • 00:32:53
      It's back to, how do we, today, let's get money to the district.
    • 00:32:56
      We're really now, as a district representative, and at large, you now have monies at the district, and you're getting to compete against those projects within your district that are similar scoring the whole bit, and you get to make those decisions.
    • 00:33:09
      So I think 1887 really was, we heard that loud and clear when we went around the Commonwealth, loud and clear.
    • 00:33:19
      But at the end of the day, we really are talking about 27.5% of all our construction monies that will be, if you want to put a project, will be completed statewide.
    • 00:33:30
      And my guess is the larger projects are going to rise to the top simply because of the very nature of
    • SPEAKER_27
    • 00:33:37
      In response to Mr. Dixon, I think we still have the prerogative on this board to advocate and to make decisions that aren't necessarily always strictly tied in to the objective analysis
    • 00:34:07
      Because if you start to go completely objective analysis, why are we sitting here?
    • 00:34:13
      It's really for us to make the case for a particular project and sometimes recognize it.
    • 00:34:22
      It might have scored low, but in the analysis of the whole Commonwealth, it's still important to that district.
    • 00:34:29
      We have to respect and recognize that amongst each other, so I hope that's never taken away.
    • 00:34:34
      I don't think the intent of this law is to just make this totally objective.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:40
      I understand everything you said.
    • 00:34:41
      I was simply laying the bed that my friend from Bristol here is going to have to be a good advocate.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 00:34:50
      Well, I think we could also say that Category C and D make up about 80% of the land mass in the state of Virginia.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:34:59
      And Mr. Chairman, if I could add also, these top ten scores you're seeing in each section are the raw scores.
    • 00:35:05
      So I believe yesterday, Mr. Tucker made reference to there was a project that was in the bottom ten on a particular category.
    • 00:35:12
      When we get to the end here, you're going to see it in the top ten overall.
    • 00:35:15
      And so remember, that's just the aggregate benefit.
    • 00:35:19
      It's not the benefit for the dollar spent.
    • 00:35:21
      And I think when we get to these last few slides here, Mr. Dick,
    • 00:35:25
      Mr. Whitworth.
    • 00:35:29
      You may not see the same dynamic play out as we look at the tops and the bottoms of the overall scores looking at the relative in HB2 cost.
    • 00:35:40
      Okay, continue on, mister.
    • 00:35:43
      The next section of the economic development factor area is the intermodal access and again this is currently weighted at 30% though we're going to move that down to 20% as we move the liability into this metric and what we've done here is we're just kind of three things we're examining and it's really focused on goods movement and intermodal access so
    • 00:36:02
      Are you improving direct access or improving a facility approximate to a distribution facility, an intermodal facility or manufacturing site?
    • 00:36:11
      Are you improving a designated STAA truck route, which is something that's a federal designation that kind of signifies the major truck routes throughout the nation?
    • 00:36:20
      Or are you also improving kind of access around or directly to the Commonwealth's aviation sites, the airports or the ports including inland ports in the Commonwealth?
    • 00:36:31
      And then what we're going to do again is to look at when we make these improvements, scaling it based on the tonnage
    • 00:36:38
      That is anticipated to be, to benefit from that improvement.
    • 00:36:41
      And we get, there's a lot of different national data sources we're relying on right now to provide us that research.
    • 00:36:47
      Mostly being kind of this thing called Trans Search, which is a nationally provided tool that gives you the different types of tonnage by mode on given corridors across the country.
    • 00:36:58
      And so if you take a look here, you can see the top 10 projects, their raw score.
    • 00:37:03
      looking at economic development here and actually the very top one is one of the ones I talked about earlier where there's an interstate that's being widened for about four and a half miles and then what's happening is there's a lot of growth on that kind of parallel primary roadway that was there before and this improvement does help it but a lot of it was already kind of taking place which again led us to go back and look at how we should revise that kind of classification.
    • 00:37:31
      And then you see, you know, kind of the top one there for the intermodal access was one that really addresses some bridges and a freight bottleneck in a more rural part of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:37:43
      It's in a Category D area.
    • 00:37:51
      Moving on to the next.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:37:52
      Are you saying that the score here on the top, this is project number 11,
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:38:00
      Let's go to the next question.
    • 00:38:27
      And if you look over at the next slide, you see a lot of projects.
    • 00:38:31
      And again, some of these scored better in some of the other categories, but they just didn't do very much either for goods movement or nearby economic development.
    • 00:38:40
      As we talked about in the summary slides, there's no project that scored really high.
    • 00:38:45
      in all categories.
    • 00:38:46
      Most projects did really well in one to two, and the ones that scored really high got about three, but no one did well in every category area, and we just had some projects in this 38 that did very little to facilitate new or expanded economic growth or to goods movement.
    • 00:39:04
      So some of the challenges that we have here is, again, just really quantifying this, our lack of ability to draw the causation between the improvement and the economic growth that's coming in.
    • 00:39:15
      There's also going to have to be a very, very strong quality assurance, quality control process in this.
    • 00:39:21
      Right now we had kind of district staff.
    • 00:39:23
      Martin, P.D.
    • 00:39:43
      And so we're just going to keep working with them to make sure that only growth that's benefiting from this development is considered.
    • 00:39:51
      One of the other issues that we've run into is there are some projects that may be proximate to a fair amount of new economic development but have almost no impact on that.
    • 00:40:01
      And the example I would give you is there was a park and ride lot that was considered in the pilot scoring that did relatively well under economic development.
    • 00:40:10
      I went around and asked every member of the HP2 team, did you think this park and ride lot had any role in the economic development happening within these few miles near?
    • 00:40:18
      And the unanimous response was, no, it did not.
    • 00:40:22
      And so we need to go back and kind of make sure that certain types of projects, particularly park and ride lots, those do a lot for congestion.
    • 00:40:30
      They can help with accessibility.
    • 00:40:32
      We as staff do not believe they have an impact on economic development nearby.
    • 00:40:37
      We just think in this one it was just kind of a fluke of how the process was put in place and one of the lessons learned from our pilot scoring process.
    • 00:40:45
      The other thing is we need to do some work in the coming months to make sure we have all the manufacturing, intermodal, and distribution sites identified.
    • 00:40:52
      We have a pretty comprehensive list, but we think there's some gaps in it, so staff are working very hard right now using a multitude of resources to make sure we fill in those gaps before we start to score projects in the fall.
    • 00:41:05
      We have the environmental factor here.
    • 00:41:08
      Again, one of the things I want to talk about before we go through this is we've changed this measure pretty dramatically in the revised construct.
    • 00:41:16
      And so right now there's only one metric that's being shown.
    • 00:41:19
      In the future there will be two.
    • 00:41:21
      There will be that impact to cultural and natural resources.
    • 00:41:24
      And so when you see this, you're going to see some projects that have, you know,
    • 00:41:27
      very few points because they may not have the air quality benefits but when we look at kind of the natural and cultural resources impact every project is going to get some form of points kind of moving forward from that based on the degree to which they avoid or minimize impacts to cultural and natural resources.
    • 00:41:44
      So for the air quality and greenhouse gas perspective, we looked at whether or not the degree which a project helps promote non-SOV travel or reduces freight bottlenecks where there's a large amount of truck traffic.
    • 00:41:58
      And what we defined as a large amount of truck traffic is more than 8% of traffic.
    • 00:42:02
      And a kind of congested bottleneck looking at the volume to capacity types of calculations that Mr. Tucker walked through yesterday.
    • 00:42:08
      And then what, again, we do to scale this so we can divide by cost is for the non-SOV components, we look at the amount of users.
    • 00:42:16
      Again, kind of the benefit or impact we expect the improvement to have.
    • 00:42:20
      And for the truck bottlenecks, we look at the truck volumes as we kind of scale that to divide by the benefit.
    • 00:42:27
      And so again here the top ten using this half of the environmental metric.
    • 00:42:33
      Right now the park and ride lot is the number one scoring project and that's just because there's a high number of non-SOV users as well as it has transit, carpool, as well as kind of ITS and technology improvements and so it does a lot of things to help facilitate that non-SOV travel.
    • 00:43:01
      If you move over to the bottom ten, we have a lot of projects that simply did not address freight bottlenecks or help promote non-SOV travel.
    • 00:43:11
      Again, I want to stress in the future, you're not going to see a bottom ten of all zeros when we add in that other measure because all projects will be getting points under that other measure.
    • 00:43:21
      And so I just want to really highlight that for the board that you're not going to see this type of outcome from the environmental measure score in the future when that other factor is put in there.
    • 00:43:37
      Some of the challenges that we had here is just getting inputs from the applicants and making sure that they can provide that accurate type of information.
    • 00:43:46
      And again, the pilot score did not consider the impact of natural and cultural resources, looking at whether or not it was a categorical exclusion, an environmental assessment, or a full-blown EIS, and then the number of acres of impacted lands.
    • 00:43:58
      That just was not considered in this pilot because we were still developing the measure at that time based on stakeholder feedback.
    • 00:44:07
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, the last factor area is the land use area.
    • 00:44:11
      Before we get into this, I just want to remind members of the board this is only applicable in category, excuse me, waiting frameworks A and B.
    • 00:44:19
      And so again, just as a reminder, that's Northern Virginia, Fredericksburg, Richmond, Hampton Roads, Charlottesville, and the Roanoke-Salem TPO area.
    • 00:44:28
      So those are the only areas where this metric, as currently proposed, is applicable.
    • 00:44:34
      And under this metric, again, we look at really trying to quantify what is the project doing to help promote transportation efficient land use.
    • 00:44:42
      There's been a lot of discussion in the board yesterday and at past meetings about interconnected streets and really promoting types of development that minimize the impact on the transportation network.
    • 00:44:53
      That's really the purpose.
    • 00:44:55
      of this kind of score here.
    • 00:44:56
      And so if you kind of want to think about the different factor areas, congestion is really focused on dealing with the issues we have today and expect to, you know, have from some of the growth that's in the pipeline.
    • 00:45:06
      This is about having some of that future growth minimize its impact on the transportation network.
    • 00:45:12
      So as we're trying to reduce congestion, when that future growth comes in, it doesn't just undo what we did with our congestion-reducing investments.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:45:24
      I'm really interested in this grid network thing that you know.
    • 00:45:28
      If you look at page 33 of the implementation policy guide, it says, is the project assisted with, does the project support traditional neighborhood development design components as defined in section 15.2.22.23.1?
    • 00:45:44
      I haven't looked that up yet.
    • 00:45:46
      I think I will.
    • 00:45:47
      I have no doubt.
    • 00:45:49
      Is that where we're getting at that factor?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:45:54
      Mr. Chairman, there's several ways what we're getting at that factor.
    • 00:45:56
      That is I think the most direct one.
    • 00:45:59
      That code reference refers to a section of code that was added in 2007 under House Bill 3202.
    • 00:46:05
      That is the urban development area section of code that talks about locally designated growth areas that have a mix of uses, interconnected streets is actually explicitly referenced.
    • 00:46:15
      And so that is really where we're drawing that direct connection.
    • 00:46:19
      I would also say looking at kind of the regional VMT projections from those long-range plans the region has put together will also quantify that as well as looking at kind of infill development kind of moving forward.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:35
      Somehow it goes a little bit back to the comments that we had yesterday about whether it's in Northern Virginia, what percentage it ought to be is congested.
    • 00:46:49
      And I just read the letter from Doug Minshew and the Speaker and everybody else, and they want to put it at 60%.
    • 00:46:59
      That may or may not help them score on a state-wide basis.
    • 00:47:04
      We don't know.
    • 00:47:04
      And, you know, they have scored pretty strongly on economic development, for example, up here.
    • 00:47:11
      They scored pretty strongly on this aspect of it.
    • 00:47:16
      And so, you know, I don't know.
    • 00:47:19
      But one thing I am concerned about is we just put all our money in congestion relief.
    • 00:47:24
      It will just push the development further out, and if we don't hold some criteria here for development, we're going to see another set of cul-de-sacs out here west of Dulles.
    • 00:47:38
      You know, all the land flew over, and we're going to be back in the same situation in 40 years.
    • 00:47:45
      That's the concern.
    • 00:47:47
      I understand that they need congestion, but we also have to plan a little bit.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:57
      I was going to bring this letter up at the end, but now since you've mentioned it,
    • 00:48:03
      No, no, it's fine.
    • 00:48:04
      It's okay.
    • 00:48:06
      It does.
    • 00:48:07
      A letter is addressed to me and it's from Speaker Howe and seven or eight others from this area and one from Hampton Road to thank the new
    • 00:48:18
      and the House of Transportation, Ron Villanueva, also signed the letter.
    • 00:48:24
      It employs today, it asks the Commonwealth Transportation Board to strongly encourage two things.
    • 00:48:29
      They want to believe in Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia, and specifically there's mostly from Northern Virginia, as you mentioned, congestion should be 60 percent, and
    • 00:48:40
      I agree with all wholeheartedly a lot of the concerns that you have in that regard.
    • 00:48:47
      Although Mr. Dyke and Mr. Garzynski did express opinions to move it up from the 35%, I think we should give consideration to that in that regard.
    • 00:48:55
      And also the second thing is, back to the comment that Mr. Whitworth was sort of making that I responded to, is that imploring or strongly recommending the Transportation Board really focus on what they consider are major projects.
    • 00:49:10
      It's not supposed to be to take care of local roads planning.
    • 00:49:15
      I'm sure I agree with all that, but I wanted to point out there that the letter, I'll put it in public comment, make sure you all have copies of it in that going forward and respect their comments.
    • 00:49:31
      I think House Bill 1887 again does address some of those because, as we talked about before, this money is going to write to this district and they'll be, even though we ultimately have to approve as a CTB, the district will be making the recommendations on what project they want.
    • 00:49:50
      So I'm glad you brought it up.
    • 00:49:52
      I was going to bring that up.
    • 00:49:53
      I'll make sure it gets in public comment.
    • 00:49:55
      But that is the letter that they sent.
    • 00:50:00
      We were very involved.
    • 00:50:01
      I know Nick and I were very much in these discussions, and I'm not exactly sure I agree with all the tenor, but certainly I value their input, and so I wanted you guys to go ahead.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:12
      Well, let me ask you this question, Secretary.
    • 00:50:16
      If we move the congestion number up, which, you know, it's not, maybe we ought to move the land use number up.
    • 00:50:26
      Right now it's 10 or 15 or something and maybe we need to balance those two things out.
    • 00:50:34
      Mr. President, I think the intent of the letter from the legislatures is to try to coincide with the legislation as it was passed in the General Assembly with the
    • SPEAKER_27
    • 00:50:46
      Martin, Jr. Martin, Jr. Martin, Jr.
    • 00:51:07
      I think the case was made yesterday as we were flying around that accessibility that we've talked about and land use certainly have a place and deserve recognition maybe beyond some of the other factors.
    • 00:51:23
      So that is what I interpreted as the intent.
    • 00:51:29
      Jim could speak to that too or Scott.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 00:51:33
      I agree that we probably need to focus a little bit more on land use.
    • 00:51:39
      Now, what that number is, I think we need to talk about it.
    • 00:51:44
      But I still think, though, we need to send a clear message on the congestion front.
    • 00:51:48
      That's why I made the comments I did yesterday.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:51
      Yeah, and I totally agree with that.
    • 00:51:53
      I mean, I understand where it's coming from in that regard.
    • 00:51:55
      I think that's absolutely right.
    • 00:51:57
      As you know, we basically
    • 00:52:00
      Or let the locals give us input for you to decide in terms of how their categories and how the rankings and the whole bit.
    • 00:52:09
      So I think this is important for them to weigh in in that regard and how they understood the legislation.
    • 00:52:15
      So that's why I wanted to make sure it was known to you and everybody consider that as we go through these.
    • 00:52:21
      Mr. Kasprowicz.
    • SPEAKER_29
    • 00:52:22
      I still have more discussion on this, but I have to.
    • 00:52:24
      I just
    • 00:52:25
      I think this is going to occur with Williams' point.
    • 00:52:28
      If we overweight congestion, we just start the cycle over and over and over and end up with land use policies further out driving our need to make congestion-based decisions in the future.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:52:42
      Mr. Connors.
    • 00:52:44
      I will point out that the Speaker has been a big proponent of land use in transportation.
    • 00:52:48
      I think 3202 came from him.
    • 00:52:50
      So I think he's asking us to strike a balance and not to
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:54
      And I actually believe the balance is what's needed for the not only the policy but in terms of the raw scoring and that's another that's what I was only pointing out that's why we'll have this workshop and Mr. Fralin made the point I mean
    • 00:53:16
      Yes, but then again, if you do that and it doesn't score the project, you really want, I mean, he's got to consider it.
    • 00:53:24
      That's all I'm suggesting.
    • 00:53:25
      But I did want to make this public, and everybody understand the concerns of the General Assembly members that were supportive of House Bill 2, and actually the Speaker, Hal, was the patron of House Bill 2.
    • 00:53:40
      So, Mr. Donahue.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:53:41
      So Mr. Chairman, you can see here on the slide the various factors that were considered using the land use score.
    • 00:53:48
      A lot of them are focused on some of the issues that Mr. Fralin has raised and they talk about really are we kind of creating activity centers where development can take place in the future that will reduce the impact of that new growth on the transportation network.
    • 00:54:03
      We're also looking at kind of regionally
    • 00:54:05
      As these metropolitan areas have developed their long-range transportation plans, have they done it in a way where they've been able to strike a balance between their future growth and the transportation resource they have to try and reduce per capita vehicle miles traveled, again, demonstrating that they've got better jobs to housing balance,
    • 00:54:22
      Kupferberg Jr.,
    • 00:54:38
      2013, we're never going to have enough resources to really build or address all the needs that are out there, and so we need also trying to create encouragement or incentives for some of these regional areas and localities to think about ways they can accommodate their future growth in a less capital-intensive transportation way, kind of moving forward.
    • 00:54:58
      We also have something in here about the access management plans.
    • 00:55:02
      And that's really a regulation that was put in place also as a part of House Bill 3202 which deals with on our major corridors making sure we don't kind of degrade their performance by having, you know, four entrances to an exon at a major intersection where you have those turning movements which causes accidents and congestion with people slowing down and speeding up.
    • 00:55:22
      We left this in to talk about it with the board but as we looked at the pilot scores we're not sure this is necessarily the most appropriate measure for this place as it's kind of you either have the plan or you don't and right now we have a regulation that applies these plans to all the major roadways and so it's kind of ended up being a default point
    • 00:55:41
      Martin, John M. Martin, John M. Martin,
    • 00:55:56
      thing to do this on we just kept it with that for the pilot testing because we didn't have time to go back and examine other options but we think it might actually be more appropriate to look at the amount of both commercial and residential development in an area where this improvement is serving rather than the number of people not driving because even in these activity centers you're going to have driving you're going to have walking you may have transit usage
    • 00:56:20
      I don't think it's appropriate to necessarily focus on who's not in the car but rather on the amount of growth that's happening there because what we needed to do is have more of this growth happen in areas that's less transportation intensive or more efficient in the way that it impacts the transportation network.
    • SPEAKER_29
    • 00:56:38
      Mr. Kaspers, Nick, are there other demand-based metrics that could be included in the land use evaluation?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:56:46
      So Mr. Chairman, Mr. Kashwitz, this is another measure that was tough like economic development but not for the same reasons.
    • 00:56:54
      The really tough part with the land use metric is we have a paradigm in Virginia and for all the local government folks in the room and watching at home, we're not looking to change that.
    • 00:57:04
      But where the state controls the vast majority of transportation investments and the local governments are solely responsible for the land development patterns that the transportation network is supposed to be serving,
    • 00:57:15
      And so we've been trying to come up with ways to kind of create those types of incentives moving forward, and we think the metrics that are there, maybe some of the better ones that we have, I'm sure there may be some other ones we can come up with in the coming months, but we don't have any other ones today that we would recommend to the board.
    • 00:57:32
      We really think focusing on having that kind of
    • 00:57:36
      Walkable, mixed-use, or denser types of development, where appropriate, is the right type of thing to include.
    • 00:57:42
      Again, it's not appropriate in all places.
    • 00:57:44
      It's really in certain nodes that are well-served by transportation access, both transit and highways.
    • 00:57:50
      Thank you.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:52
      I just want to make sure I understand what you said about the access management plans.
    • 00:57:57
      Do most of our major quarters have one, have an access management plan?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 00:58:02
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Valentine, they don't all necessarily have individualized plans that have been developed through a discrete planning process.
    • 00:58:09
      Some of them, like 29, do have more detailed plans, but
    • 00:58:12
      The commissioner actually has what's known as access management regulations that currently apply to all interstates, principal arterials, and I believe minor arterials throughout the Commonwealth.
    • 00:58:23
      And so by virtue of that regulation, they're all subject to a plan restriction.
    • 00:58:28
      It's just some are personalized and some are not.
    • 00:58:30
      They're just default under that regulation.
    • 00:58:32
      So it kind of ended up being points everyone got, whether or not the project was otherwise driving towards the outcome this factor area is supposed to look at.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:44
      Okay, one more before we leave land use.
    • 00:58:49
      I understand that VDOT gets a crack when a locality passes a comprehensive plan, VDOT gets a crack to look at it and comment on it.
    • 00:59:02
      That's correct.
    • 00:59:03
      And with this new formula, I think it's the first time that land use is going to be rewarded or penalized
    • 00:59:13
      I mean, the way we awarded projects before, it was kind of looked at, but it's going to be actually analyzed under this bill, which is a good thing.
    • 00:59:24
      And it seems to me that VDOT would do a locality of service when they look at those plans and not give them a first-year review, but actually say,
    • 00:59:35
      If you pass this plan, it's going to hurt you.
    • 00:59:42
      Give an analysis of those comprehensive plans and how they're going to work with this new process because all of a sudden they really matter.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:51
      They do and they shouldn't be compliant with it.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:53
      If they change their mind later, they're going to score really poorly on this.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:57
      Well, I think this is the first time I think with this that there's actually some teeth into
    • 01:00:04
      The VTrans process about the land use planning and stuff, because you're right.
    • 01:00:09
      And I think that's really some of the inherent positive things about House Bill 2.
    • 01:00:16
      Not only them, but public hearings and heard from our VDOT engineers, well, that's not going to score well under House Bill 2.
    • 01:00:22
      We can do it this way.
    • 01:00:24
      And I think that's exactly what we're looking for long term.
    • 01:00:27
      It will change habits.
    • 01:00:30
      I mean, now, and maybe some, we'll have to take a look at how it does, but I mean, that's the intent, is to really tie together, and we didn't show it here, but if we did it at every of the transportation board meeting hearings, the circle, it now ties together VTrans, allocating the money, and spending the money under 1887.
    • 01:00:51
      In other words, they are interconnected.
    • 01:00:53
      And if you want your project to do well, you need to figure out how that, they are connected.
    • 01:00:59
      I agree 100%.
    • 01:01:00
      Ms. Veltage?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:02
      Are access management plans part of comprehensive plans?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:06
      The comprehensive plans typically, they have a transportation element that will guide the county in terms of where they want various types of development to occur and what types of transportation improvements are needed.
    • 01:01:20
      One of the challenges as I'm hearing this in Virginia is that the typical land use pattern in Virginia is what I call strip zoning, commercial zoning along your primary and your other major arterial corridors.
    • 01:01:34
      You see this phenomenon all over Virginia where it's U.S. Route whatever.
    • 01:01:39
      You'll see these strip zoning 600 feet, 1,000 feet off the center line of the roadway.
    • 01:01:47
      And it provides, it makes it significantly difficult to manage that arterial road as a commercial development occurs.
    • 01:01:55
      Some of the areas are really beginning to try to cluster land use in Northern Virginia, some areas, parts of Richmond, even parts of Hampton Roads and the Roanoke area, but that continues to be the challenge.
    • 01:02:07
      When we talk about access management, if a person owns a piece of land along a primary highway and it's not limited access, ultimately they're going to get a commercial entrance.
    • 01:02:21
      How that gets configured, we have some control, but in the end we can't say you cannot have an entrance onto this roadway if that is your piece of land.
    • 01:02:35
      Ultimately what happens is it goes through an exception process and the like.
    • 01:02:38
      So by going all the way back to the comprehensive plan and really reinforcing the idea of integrating the land use and the transportation system,
    • 01:02:49
      It can really help us and relieve some of the issues that we have today along our primary corridors.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:57
      Because, you know, in many ways it's protecting the assets that we currently have.
    • 01:03:01
      And that's something that regardless if you're an A, B, C, or D, you know, working, trying to perhaps emphasize that or reinforce it in comprehensive plans because, you know, in the long run it keeps us from creating, you know, the cul-de-sacs and just expanding all the development.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:22
      And linear commercial development is the most, again, most challenging for us because of the, it's clobbering the arterial system.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:33
      Yeah, because I agree with Ms. Valentine and I think that I've used cul-de-sac too much because there's nothing inherent that's necessarily, like, we're not going to call it cul-de-sac.
    • 01:03:46
      But what the point is, is there has to be more than one access point for a 100-house development.
    • 01:03:54
      You know, where it's cul-de-sac, cul-de-sac, cul-de-sac, cul-de-sac, dump it onto, you know, 50.
    • 01:03:59
      So what I think is we have, instead of giving them one access, maybe we give them three, you know, so it divides it up.
    • 01:04:09
      Or maybe we give them some on the back and some on the front so there's an outlet, you know, and I assume that's what we're talking about.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:17
      If parallel road networks or interconnectivity between compatible development types, and frankly, the other part is putting compatible development types next to each other, not putting commercial next to residential that then sort of forces, well, we can't make this physical connection because now commercial traffic will drive through the residential neighborhood.
    • 01:04:38
      It's that interaction.
    • 01:04:40
      The parallel street concept and multiple access points and alternative access points can provide a two-lane highway with very few access points can carry considerable volumes of traffic.
    • 01:04:55
      But when you start adding these entrances onto it, it gets worn down pretty quickly.
    • 01:05:01
      So again, land use patterns, I think that this is an area where land use is controlled by local government, but we're responsible for the highway system and there's a difficulty there.
    • 01:05:15
      And again, my entire career has been a difficulty.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:18
      If you look at when we flew over yesterday, the problem is there's not a lot of room for parallel road networks up here.
    • 01:05:28
      You'd have to cut through housing development after housing development to put the parallel road system in place.
    • 01:05:34
      That's one of the challenges that's faced up here.
    • 01:05:37
      And the point that if that's continued, that'll continue to be because you only have a very few major routes.
    • 01:05:44
      and then we go to widen them it causes lots of problems because they're taking homes and different things so it's a difficult problem but it was very evident yesterday flying over putting in parallel roads there's not a lot of opportunity for it up here and without destroying many many homes.
    • 01:06:04
      Mr. Whitworth.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:06
      I certainly agree that the critical issue right here in this
    • 01:06:12
      I think that metropolitan area is congested and we need to address it.
    • 01:06:19
      But I do think that this is the first opportunity that we've had to address an issue that has led to the present crisis and that is inappropriate land use.
    • 01:06:31
      So I would certainly be comfortable and encourage some incremental
    • 01:06:39
      was a very important value on land use because this is the thing that created the problem that we have now to fix.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:06:53
      So Mr. Chairman, members of the board, if you take a look at the scores here, this is based on the current, the way it was done in the pilot scoring.
    • 01:07:01
      Again, staff, we want to recommend changes to you on this.
    • 01:07:04
      So the top scoring project here was a project to add a general purpose, an HOV lane, to an interstate facility at the edge of a metropolitan area.
    • 01:07:14
      It mostly scored the highest because it had an access management plan and a high number of SOV users.
    • 01:07:21
      It did not actually
    • 01:07:22
      Martin, John K. Matney Jr., John M. Martin, John K. Matney Jr.,
    • 01:07:43
      Land use there's going to be driving and so we shouldn't be not considering that so maybe we need to be looking at the residential units and kind of commercial square footage but staff would like to take the next few days and provide some recommendations to the board on that but we did want to show you how we scored it because that's what we've been talking about up until this point but we did see some deficiencies in the scoring through the pilot testing and with the board's kind of interest in this we'd just like to have another few days to give you some additional recommendations.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:11
      John, we have about 20 minutes for public comment, so I'd like to get to the scoring if you could, because we probably need to wrap this up before that and come back in, instead of having you come back up again, so.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:08:22
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:08:23
      So I just, I've jumped through a few slides here, so we're at the scores.
    • 01:08:26
      These are the raw scores.
    • 01:08:28
      So here are the top 10 types of scores, and as Mr. Whitworth talked about, you see a fair amount of As and Bs in the top raw score.
    • 01:08:37
      It's before we divide by cost, and you see a mix of different types of roadway improvements, some of the transit improvements and things of that nature.
    • 01:08:46
      We can move to the bottom ten, and as Mr. Whitworth did note earlier, you see there's a lot more Cs and Ds there.
    • 01:08:54
      Also, as Mr. Matney said, that does represent a much larger part of the land area, the Commonwealth, so there were more C and D projects in this 38 that got evaluated moving forward.
    • 01:09:05
      Again, this is just the raw score here.
    • 01:09:08
      Now what I want to do is really kind of, here's where we're getting into the relative scores.
    • 01:09:13
      This is where we're dividing that raw score by cost, and this is total cost, and I really want to draw the board's attention to the highest scoring project, and that is a very small project in a rural area whose raw score, we gave it a rank of 29 out of 38.
    • 01:09:30
      But once you divide by its cost, which was only $900,000, that far away was the total
    • 01:09:36
      Best bang for the buck out of these 38 projects.
    • 01:09:40
      And so as we kind of talked about earlier, the raw scores, you know, the aggregate benefits, but what the law tells us to examine are what are the benefits per dollar spent.
    • 01:09:49
      And so if you start to look through this, you kind of see a broader mix of area types.
    • 01:09:54
      So all the weighting frameworks are represented in
    • 01:09:58
      It's staff's kind of opinion that there's not more or less of one type versus another so the number one project is an area type G and it's a reconstruction of an intersection.
    • 01:10:09
      The next project is some expansion buses that again rely on the metro system which really bumps up
    • 01:10:14
      There's a score there and that's in a category type A.
    • 01:10:18
      The next one is the commuter lot also in a category type A.
    • 01:10:22
      Then we move to kind of an improvement to a local road to help improve the flow at an interchange and that's in a category type D there.
    • 01:10:31
      And then, you know, we move to C's and there's a few B's moving down there.
    • 01:10:36
      For anyone who's in a category type B, I do want to say we had the least number of projects
    • 01:10:40
      in B, so you're just going to see less B's in that.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 01:10:42
      The B only applies in three areas, and so there are just one ton of projects in this 38 within the weighting framework of B. Mr. Chairman, Mr. Rosen, Mr. Donahue, just noticing that and to go to that, I did notice that on the final results that the B's, I mean there are fewer projects, but the B's also seem to be much lower in terms of their scoring relative to many of the others, yet B's are
    • 01:11:10
      The bottom ten there at the bottom. Are we finding there's something within that category that's going to need to be adjusted to make those entities that are falling in those categories more competitive? Because this doesn't seem to show that V is as competitive with the others.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:11:29
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Rosen, at this time staff don't feel that it's shown that way, but what we can do is to continue to examine projects that might fall in category type B just to see if we keep getting that type of outcome in there.
    • 01:11:43
      Just looking at these 38, I think there were only three or four
    • 01:11:46
      You should not read anything.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:54
      This is a small sample, which is scoring.
    • 01:11:56
      You should not read it into the fact that it's in one area or the other.
    • 01:12:01
      Really, this helps to take a look at if you raw score versus cost.
    • 01:12:07
      I mean, I think this clearly shows the big changes are not between classifications.
    • 01:12:12
      The big changes come between raw score and cost.
    • 01:12:17
      I want to read this letter that we got.
    • 01:12:22
      This is a critical point here.
    • 01:12:24
      The last sentence in the last paragraph is what is considered is Commonwealth is ultimately responsible for statewide transportation network and while local projects should be measured against the CTB recommended plan, the Six-Year Improvement Plan ultimately must be for projects of greatest statewide significance, not a collection of local projects.
    • 01:12:48
      Which clearly is saying that the project that scored the highest probably should not be considered a statewide level.
    • 01:12:55
      Now chances are it would be at the district level, but I want to point out to you that I just want to point out, and I'm not suggesting it's right or wrong, but that's where we're being encouraged.
    • 01:13:07
      So I'm not saying it's right or wrong, guys.
    • 01:13:12
      I am saying there are differences of opinions and
    • 01:13:18
      This is clearly a very different view in terms, I should say different view, that we've espoused here.
    • 01:13:27
      So I just want to make sure that their view is heard, but also what the ramifications are with that.
    • 01:13:34
      Yeah, Mr. Garza.
    • SPEAKER_27
    • 01:13:35
      Yes, I have a question for Nick, but commenting on that, it probably would be appropriate to have further dialogue
    • 01:13:44
      To find out if that's truly going to be a litmus test, because if we don't do that, we're just going to be back before the GA next year with revisions to this, to what we're trying to do. Nick, explain to me this difference of HB2 cost again and total cost with some of the Thank you.
    • 01:14:07
      different numbers you see where the total cost is
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:14:17
      The total cost is just that.
    • 01:14:20
      It's the all-in cost of the project regardless of whether it's the specialized programs that the state and federal funds that are exempt, local money, money from a regional entity or any of that nature.
    • 01:14:33
      That as well as the state funds that'd be subject to House Bill 2.
    • 01:14:37
      That's the total cost.
    • 01:14:38
      When we get to the HB2 costs, we exclude things like the Highway Safety Improvement Program, the CMAQ Program, the Regional Surface Transportation Funds controlled by the MPOs over $200,000, local revenues, and things of that nature.
    • 01:14:53
      So that's the difference between those two columns.
    • 01:14:56
      And then just kind of also to remind people, again, when we move forward and we have these scoreings, we're going to have them in those two categories.
    • 01:15:04
      The High Priority Projects Program by law is supposed to be focused on core statewide significance and the metropolitan networks.
    • 01:15:11
      And that district grant program is really for any type of need identified in the VTrans process from safety to local growth areas to regional networks and core statewide significance.
    • 01:15:21
      So I do think a lot of these things we're hearing now with that change in law, which becomes effective this July 1, you'll start to see these things kind of work their way through.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:31
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to make an observation, make sure I understand this correctly.
    • 01:15:37
      But I understand there's going to be a little bit of a change in the statewide competition for dollars that's going to be based on its quarter statewide significance, like Mike just said.
    • 01:15:52
      But the six-year plan VDOT puts out is interstate, primary, secondary, all across Virginia.
    • 01:15:58
      It's not.
    • 01:15:58
      We're not limited.
    • 01:16:00
      Nor, in my opinion, should we be limited to just using quarters, spending money on quarters statewide significance because it's a state transportation plan and, you know, now the general assembly has the prerogative to change it, but that's not what our role is right now.
    • 01:16:19
      And I think to change that and to give localities, for example, the ability to do that would lead to further balkanization.
    • 01:16:27
      I mean, we already are looking at a little bit of balkanization based on the regional transportation money.
    • 01:16:33
      If we start changing how the six-year plan is put together,
    • 01:16:38
      I'm not in the legislation so they can do what they want to do and the government gets to sign it or not, but I'd be concerned about that.
    • 01:16:48
      I kind of heard that coming in from that letter.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:50
      I just wanted to make sure I put it out there.
    • 01:16:52
      I think Mr. Brzezinski's suggestion is right.
    • 01:16:55
      I will set up meetings to discuss and present what we think, but I did want to make sure that their letter was put out.
    • 01:17:03
      point out some of the ramifications.
    • 01:17:05
      And I'm not saying they're good or bad.
    • 01:17:06
      It's just it will change the result.
    • 01:17:09
      And that's, I think, something that in deference to them, I wanted to make sure that it was heard and that we have a discussion on it.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:19
      So, Mr. Whitworth.
    • 01:17:21
      Nick, explain to me this little project where we're really talking about a $30,000 HB2 cost.
    • 01:17:29
      In the future, would that be part of this conversation here?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:17:34
      Mr. Chairman, I'm not sure we'd end up seeing an example that had so low a cost and that little of HB2 eligible money.
    • 01:17:43
      What I think happened in this particular example is a product was underway, experienced a cost overrun, and the state applied
    • 01:17:50
      I'm sorry, I can't hear you.
    • 01:17:52
      I believe what happened in this project is that it was already underway, experienced cost overruns of around $30,000.
    • 01:17:59
      And what happened is the state added what would now be HB2 money to what was probably a safety project to cover that cost increase and keep the project moving forward.
    • 01:18:10
      And so I don't think you're going to see a project that costs less than a million dollars and then has $30,000 of HB2 money.
    • 01:18:16
      I wouldn't think so.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:16
      And if these numbers are really 90 million versus 30 million, I doubt seriously if they've been at the top of the chart, is that correct?
    • 01:18:26
      If the total cost had been $90 million rather than $900,000, it would not anywhere be close to the top of the chart because it is at the bottom of the chart on the raw score.
    • 01:18:39
      I really don't think this is a good example of how you can move from the bottom to the top.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:44
      Well, I'm not sure I totally agree because cost, you know, is what clearly is driving House Bill 2.
    • 01:18:53
      Now, I'm not saying that, you know the word, we're directed to get the biggest bang for the buck with our judgment.
    • 01:19:01
      And I think part of House Bill 2 is looking at how we can reduce the cost of projects.
    • 01:19:09
      And if you can reduce the cost of the project, it's going to score better.
    • 01:19:13
      So I think that's the real value of it.
    • 01:19:19
      I mean, we just bring out the interchange at 630.
    • 01:19:23
      We've reduced it $50 million.
    • 01:19:26
      And yet, now we have a plan that has the utility that the other one's going to do.
    • 01:19:31
      For $50 million left, I really believe that was the intent of this legislation as to how do we get more efficient with our limited dollars.
    • 01:19:42
      So it may or may not be a good example, but cost is a big determinant in how these projects are going to score.
    • 01:19:51
      Now, we're going to give you the gross cost and the net, and I can see how that can skew
    • 01:19:58
      May be the thinking depending on how you put it in, or you have a different opinion.
    • 01:20:02
      But if we, you know, maybe the benefits aren't really great, but if it doesn't cost a lot, now you need to make the decision.
    • 01:20:09
      There's a screening process that Nick hadn't talked about.
    • 01:20:12
      He gets screened to make sure the project even should be something we score, right?
    • 01:20:16
      I mean, there's a screening.
    • 01:20:17
      It's got to meet a certain, but if it does,
    • 01:20:20
      I mean, cost is going to be a big driver of this.
    • 01:20:24
      Now, we have to keep in mind, our whole objective is to make sure we have a coordinated network and nobody's getting away from that as part of the screening, but to think that the whole idea is to incentivize the least, fitting the purpose in me with a cost-justified solution.
    • 01:20:45
      And it really is encouraging VDOT to come up with designs that meet that that may not be the most expensive.
    • 01:20:57
      So it is.
    • 01:20:58
      I mean, I think that's inherent.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:00
      I hear you.
    • 01:21:01
      I'm just talking about this specific project.
    • 01:21:03
      I'm not sure.
    • 01:21:04
      There are going to be very few projects, I think, that we're going to be looking at that are going to go from the worst score to the top score unless we're going to be talking about $30,000 projects.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:16
      Don't know.
    • 01:21:17
      Could be, could be, but I don't know because it's all relative and I do believe there are some, look, we put in, what is those, the flashing lights out at Chevron and we're going to straighten the S curves up and we've reduced the accidents.
    • 01:21:36
      Martin, John K. B.
    • 01:21:55
      We are encouraged to how we can use traffic management technology.
    • 01:22:02
      That's a big part of House Bill 2.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:22:04
      Mr. Chairman, I think Mr. Whitworth has a point.
    • 01:22:10
      We're probably not going to see many projects like this one with a 30,000 HP2 cost, but if you also look at Project 3, the last one on this slide, that actually was in the bottom 10.
    • 01:22:20
      and now is in the top 10 when you divide by cost.
    • 01:22:24
      And so it was, you know, 33 on raw score, but it's 10
    • 01:22:28
      Once you take that cost into account.
    • 01:22:30
      So I think the broader point is cost plays a large role in what the overall score is going to be there.
    • 01:22:36
      And just to kind of jump forward to some of the HB2 costs so you can take a look at what that does as well as we look at this.
    • 01:22:42
      And on this chart we have the raw score, the relative score by total cost and the relative score by HB2 cost.
    • 01:22:49
      And you can see there are some changes.
    • 01:22:52
      The top four stay the same, the two and three reshuffle.
    • 01:22:57
      The first one that changes that is then that project I was just referencing, which is 33 in its raw score.
    • 01:23:04
      When you divide by total cost, it's tenth.
    • 01:23:07
      But because there was some local funding on this project that paid for about half of its cost, it jumps actually from ten to number five.
    • 01:23:15
      And again, moving forward, staff don't think that either the relative cost by total score or the relative cost by HP2 score.
    • 01:23:23
      We don't think you can see either one of those in a vacuum.
    • 01:23:25
      We think you're going to need to see both of those scores so you can understand its benefit towards its total cost as well as resources we might otherwise be leveraging to help us deliver those projects and bring more local and other non-state resources into some projects we're advancing.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:40
      Okay, Mr. Rondo, we have more questions, but in five minutes we have to start.
    • 01:23:44
      So what I'm going to do, I was hoping we'd finish it, but I don't think we should drop this.
    • 01:23:49
      I think we should let Mr. Donohue come back after public comment to more questions on this.
    • 01:23:58
      So I'm going to
    • 01:23:59
      We're going to suspend this right now so we can take a few minute break because I don't want to be in deference to the many speakers.
    • 01:24:08
      We told them 10 o'clock.
    • 01:24:10
      So we'll take a five-minute break.
    • 01:24:13
      We'll suspend the workshop session now.
    • 01:24:16
      We're only going to go into formal session to hear public comment.
    • 01:24:19
      And then I'm going to suspend that and come back here because there's at least one presentation we have to hear before we can vote.
    • 01:24:26
      So we're going to, Mr. Don, if you'll come back and just go back on the slides.
    • 01:24:29
      We're going to take a five-minute break at 10 o'clock.
    • 01:24:32
      We'll go into form recession and go into public comment and then we'll continue after that.
    • 01:24:38
      So we're in suspension right now.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:24:42
      I think that's one way to do it.
    • 01:24:59
      Martin, Jr.
    • 01:25:15
      O'Brien, John C. O'Brien
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:25:42
      I'm still cheering.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:26:22
      E. L.
    • 01:26:51
      Martin, John F. Kennedy Jr.,
    • 01:27:16
      O'Brien
    • 01:27:35
      Martin, John C. Martin, John C.
    • 01:28:01
      F.
    • 01:28:09
      I think I brought a hand for him.
    • 01:28:39
      Martin, C.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:28:56
      Martin, P.A.
    • 01:29:18
      Martin.
    • 01:29:34
      Martin, C.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:54
      Martin, John M. Martin, John C.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:30:18
      O'Connor Jr., John F. Kennedy Jr.,
    • 01:30:34
      So we're going to hang out for a second.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:31:00
      So that's what I'm saying here.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:31:05
      Martin, John F. Kasprowicz Jr.,
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:26
      Let's get everybody to come to their seats, please.
    • Rob WhitfieldPublic commenter
    • 01:31:37
      CTB members, if I could get you a few seats.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:40
      We're going to start the...
    • 01:31:56
      Okay.
    • 01:31:58
      As Secretary of Transportation, I officially call to order the Commonwealth Transportation Board's May formal session, action session.
    • 01:32:10
      As I said before, we're going to come into this and we're going to go into speaker comments and then go back to our workshop.
    • 01:32:16
      I did want to review the rules for speakers here, the Commonwealth Transportation Board rules.
    • 01:32:23
      Typically when we have hearings around the state, I try not to limit your time, but we have a lot of speakers today.
    • 01:32:29
      Our role here is to do the business.
    • 01:32:32
      We allow you to come talk, but I will hold you strictly to three minutes.
    • 01:32:36
      Please don't take that as a sign that I'm being disrespectful.
    • 01:32:39
      But in honor to everyone and to the board here, the work we have to do, it will be held in three minutes.
    • 01:32:45
      What I'll do is have you come up in the order in which you've been signed up so there's no particular order.
    • 01:32:52
      I'll let the next person know that they're on deck.
    • 01:32:55
      We do actually do.
    • 01:32:57
      Any comment you'd like to make is fine.
    • 01:32:59
      We do actually be civil and meaningful comments as we take them seriously in that regard.
    • 01:33:06
      But we will be held to three minutes.
    • 01:33:09
      And I also want to apologize in advance.
    • 01:33:11
      If I say your name wrong, it's not intended to be disrespectful.
    • 01:33:15
      I may not have read it in the proper manner.
    • 01:33:17
      So with that, we look forward to hearing from you.
    • 01:33:20
      First speaker today, I'll have you come up to the podium here, is Deanna Hare, I've sold that light.
    • 01:33:26
      And then Daniel Zim will be next up.
    • 01:33:29
      So as soon as I call your name, you'll be limited to the three minutes.
    • 01:33:36
      So if you have handouts, I would just put them on the desk right there, and we'll make sure you get them.
    • 01:33:41
      So with that, Ms. Hare, and we'll start the three minutes, please.
    • 01:33:44
      Thank you.
    • 01:33:46
      Morning.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:33:46
      Good morning.
    • 01:33:47
      Thank you so much.
    • 01:33:48
      As you stated, my name is Deanna Heyer, and I'm here representing several neighbors and families who have concern about VDOT's recommendations for the 495-66 interchange specifically in the Outside the Beltway projects.
    • 01:34:01
      And we appreciate that VDOT and Secretary Layne's willingness to discuss alternative solutions, and we'd like to propose an alternative for you all, which would significantly reduce the financial cost and the footprint of this project.
    • 01:34:14
      Specifically, we ask that you consider ending the I-66 toll lanes between Chambers Road and Nutley instead of extending them to 495.
    • 01:34:24
      We also propose that you offer five general purpose lanes instead between 495 and the toll lanes, and my reasons are stated within, and there are attachments in your supplemental materials also.
    • 01:34:36
      VDOT's Tier 2 report notes that a similar option was actually considered by the group, but it has been set aside for now pending further traffic analysis related to the I-66 inside the Beltway project.
    • 01:34:50
      It's not being presented in the public hearings, and we're concerned that this viable option has been passed over due to the rapid speed at which the project is moving, which is understandable, but we don't want to leave any options off the table.
    • 01:35:03
      In the design comparison that you're looking at, you will see that VDOT calls this option the Do Nothing at $4.95 alternative.
    • 01:35:10
      And I'm here to say that we really prefer calling this the Do No Harm alternative.
    • 01:35:15
      And we want to think about both the costs and the benefits of what we're doing.
    • 01:35:19
      VDOT states these benefits as no right-of-way takings at all, no construction inconvenience and minimal construction costs.
    • 01:35:26
      And to be clear, this would mean zero home takings and would negate the need to take land at Stanwood Elementary School and would eliminate the need for several bridge expansions.
    • 01:35:35
      So you can see the dollar signs adding up in what we could save.
    • 01:35:39
      Our proposal would also offer five general purpose lanes at a checkpoint at Nutley.
    • 01:35:46
      Right now, you see on the news last night, there's four lanes if you include the red X lane, which is only offered at rush hour.
    • 01:35:52
      And the VDOT current recommendation has seven lanes pinching down into three free lanes.
    • 01:35:58
      So we don't know yet how many people are going to take those toll lanes to help alleviate this choke point, but we're proposing that we keep five general purpose lanes during this choke point in order to not make this worse.
    • 01:36:11
      The Geno Harm Alternative also offers significant environmental benefits by minimizing the impacts to the watershed because there would be less cement and less impervious surfaces.
    • 01:36:21
      It also decreases noise and pollution by eliminating up to nine new flyover ramps that are proposed in these designs, and they're planned to tower 80 feet over our communities.
    • 01:36:31
      There's simply no sound wall that you can create that will protect our families from these flyovers.
    • 01:36:37
      So we ask that VDOT give time to complete the VDOT inside the Beltway traffic analysis and evaluate what the other improvements in the plan will do for overall cost.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:48
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:36:49
      Okay, thank you.
    • 01:36:51
      Mr. Simm, Daniel Simm.
    • 01:36:54
      Okay, next we have Trish Van Storey.
    • 01:36:59
      Miss Van Storey.
    • 01:36:59
      Oh, good.
    • 01:37:03
      and on deck will be Jennifer Siciliano.
    • 01:37:07
      I would suggest if you'd like if you just leave them up there we will review them because we are limited to three minutes if you'd start the clock please.
    • 01:37:19
      Thank you so much.
    • SPEAKER_35
    • 01:37:22
      My name is Trish Van Story and I'm the president of the PTA at Stenwood Elementary.
    • 01:37:29
      I want to thank you for having me here and I want to thank all of you for your service to our state.
    • 01:37:35
      PTA officers are not traditionally involved in political issues.
    • 01:37:39
      But this is no political issue for our school.
    • 01:37:42
      The plan for I-66 expansion, as it is written now, simply spells the death of our ball fields at Stenwood Elementary.
    • 01:37:51
      No more baseball, no more track, fewer gym classes outside, fewer school assemblies outside.
    • 01:37:59
      Major and incalculable loss of facility by losing this land.
    • 01:38:05
      I attended the community meeting at Kilmer Middle School where VDOT representative Susan Shaw fielded question after question about the VDOT plan to widen I-66.
    • 01:38:18
      When I spoke, I asked the audience to raise their hands if their children attend Stendwood, used to attend Stendwood, or played ball on the fields at Stendwood.
    • 01:38:28
      Probably 80% of the audience of 200 plus people raised their hands.
    • 01:38:34
      Mrs. Shaw's response, quote, I have heard the Stenwood Elementary School impact loud and clear.
    • 01:38:42
      We do have our designer here today.
    • 01:38:45
      He's listening to all these comments, so Mike, I need you guys to come and look at an alternative that would remove the impact from the ball fields at Stenwood.
    • 01:38:55
      Let's see what we can do about that, unquote.
    • 01:38:59
      At that point, the entire audience clapped.
    • 01:39:02
      I believe that was the first and only time Ms. Schall received an ovation during that morning when she announced the good news that they would reexamine the treatment of Stenwood's ball fields.
    • 01:39:12
      But now the new VDOT plan is out and it continues to butcher Stenwood's ball fields in half.
    • 01:39:21
      No change.
    • 01:39:25
      Public speaking courses teach us to be persuasive, not angry.
    • 01:39:29
      But I'm angry.
    • 01:39:30
      No change.
    • 01:39:32
      All to expand I-66 outside of the Beltway where just a mile away the expansion is all happening within the current walls.
    • 01:39:41
      This is land that cannot be replaced, cannot be found somewhere else.
    • 01:39:46
      So I beg you, save our school fields.
    • 01:39:51
      Save our community fields.
    • 01:39:53
      Find a better way to achieve your goal of easier commutes.
    • 01:39:57
      There are so many alternatives and so many very smart people who work with VDOT.
    • 01:40:02
      Make it a priority to find a better way.
    • 01:40:06
      Keep I-66 within its current walls.
    • 01:40:11
      And here are some pictures to show you how we use our ball fields and the students who will be affected by their loss.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:20
      Thank you very much, Mr. Van Storey.
    • 01:40:21
      Thank you all.
    • 01:40:22
      I appreciate your time this morning.
    • 01:40:24
      Jennifer Siciliano, and then that's Vinnie Van Castasun.
    • 01:40:29
      Good morning, ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 01:40:30
      Good morning.
    • 01:40:30
      My name is Jennifer Ciciliano.
    • 01:40:32
      My husband Mark and I live at 8051 Pritchard's Court in Dunloring, and we would be adversely affected by the alternatives proposed.
    • 01:40:39
      While I think the most effective way to provide input to proposed projects is not criticism, rather suggestions of ways the proposals can be improved to meet all needs, I do have to begin by saying that we were quite upset to learn about these proposals on a public website where our names were listed
    • 01:40:54
      It has been said that postcards were mailed to those affected, and while I have yet to receive that postcard, I believe it was an insufficient method to approach such a decision with life-changing implications for those affected.
    • 01:41:13
      I certainly acknowledge the need for change, but I don't endorse change that is not strategically thought through, uprooting established communities whose residents have spent years creating lives
    • 01:41:23
      L. Smith Jr., John M. Smith Jr., John L. Smith Jr.,
    • 01:41:44
      The original proposal showed a significant portion of our property being taken for stormwater management ponds, which are not part of the new designs.
    • 01:41:51
      However, the new designs still show a large, as in 70 to 80 feet at its tallest, flyover ramp that will still eliminate the majority of our acre and a half of woods and current buffer.
    • 01:42:00
      Additionally, these are slated to be general purpose lanes, meaning the sound of tractor trailers and jig breaks will become as common as the birds chirping, all at a monster height taller than any sound wall could ever mitigate.
    • 01:42:13
      As a result, our property will significantly decline in value and investment we consciously made in Dunloring and in Fairfax County almost 20 years ago.
    • 01:42:22
      The flyover ramp needs to go.
    • 01:42:25
      Back to strategy.
    • 01:42:26
      A few years ago, when the hotlines were being proposed, we were also faced with the possibility of a right-of-way impact.
    • 01:42:32
      However, those decisions, with input from the community, were significantly mitigated.
    • 01:42:37
      There were many sleepless nights of unbearable pounding while the sound wall was being built for those eight to ten months, but we endured, and as a result, the result was mutually agreeable.
    • 01:42:48
      I'd like to know how much that wall cost the taxpayers and why after only a few years it will be torn down to accommodate this new plan.
    • 01:42:55
      That's not strategic at all.
    • 01:42:57
      That's simply poor planning.
    • 01:42:59
      And as a taxpayer in the Commonwealth, I'm pretty angry about that.
    • 01:43:03
      I appreciate the opportunity to provide comments today, but I certainly hope that this board considers fully the implications of these proposals.
    • 01:43:10
      There are alternatives to just building more roads, and you need to take a hard look at those before simply destroying communities and the lives of those who live in them.
    • 01:43:19
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:20
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:43:22
      Benny Ben-Kastasad, I sound that correct, and then Mary Tagapayan,
    • SPEAKER_24
    • 01:43:28
      Good morning, sir.
    • 01:43:29
      Good morning.
    • 01:43:29
      It's Benny Venkatasen.
    • 01:43:30
      I live in Dunloring-Maryfield area.
    • 01:43:33
      I applaud you all.
    • 01:43:34
      You've moved the red line.
    • 01:43:35
      You've increased the number of homes being taken.
    • 01:43:40
      You've decided to go away from the P3, which is a good thing.
    • 01:43:42
      We've seen it negatively affect 495 and 95.
    • 01:43:47
      We have a regional problem at our hand.
    • 01:43:50
      that needs a regional solution.
    • 01:43:52
      Susan Shaw has said that from VDOT.
    • 01:43:54
      So that means the whole community needs to come together, all up and down 66.
    • 01:43:57
      Right now, we're seeing just Dunloring, Maryfield, Vienna, and the Fairfax.
    • 01:44:02
      As you get into where it's tight, it's been allowed to be developed, be adversely affected.
    • 01:44:07
      We see the school's land being taken, Stanwood Elementary, Marshall Road on Nutley.
    • 01:44:13
      Nutley's going to take a huge impact.
    • 01:44:16
      I recently did my kitchen this December and they asked me when I went in, would you like to do a rip and repair or rip and remodel?
    • 01:44:24
      And I was, well, I just want to do a rip and repair because that's the cheapest.
    • 01:44:27
      And that seems to be what you all are doing with 66.
    • 01:44:30
      You're not doing a true transform.
    • 01:44:33
      People aren't going to get in buses.
    • 01:44:35
      I'm curious to see what study you have done in the area where people actually got in a bus that took them to access points other than straight to D.C. People don't go straight to D.C.
    • 01:44:45
      They go to Reston.
    • 01:44:46
      They go to McLean.
    • 01:44:46
      They go to Tyson's Corner.
    • 01:44:49
      Some go, they veer off down.
    • 01:44:50
      So why would a person get in a bus just to dump them off at Nutley?
    • 01:44:53
      perhaps.
    • 01:44:55
      What we need is a regional solution.
    • 01:44:57
      It's metro, it's VRE, it's buses, it's everything working together.
    • 01:45:02
      We have mega-buses in the area.
    • 01:45:03
      Why not incorporate them?
    • 01:45:04
      We see Loudoun County doing it, but not Prince William, not Fauquier County for folks to get down there.
    • 01:45:09
      Another thing to think about, we have 267 right here.
    • 01:45:12
      It's a pure toil lane and we have Route 7 right here.
    • 01:45:15
      We see what happens in the morning.
    • 01:45:16
      People either decide to pay the toll or they decide to get in the traffic where they don't want to pay the toll.
    • 01:45:21
      Now I know 66 is a different animal.
    • 01:45:23
      We can't just go and toll it.
    • 01:45:25
      But I urge you to work with the Transportation Committee on the federal side.
    • 01:45:29
      And find that solution.
    • 01:45:31
      If people want to live out in Haymarket and Manassas and have that cheaper home, we've decided in this area that we're going to have a less expensive home, we're going to have a modest home, and we're going to live in a transit-oriented neighborhood.
    • 01:45:43
      And now you're taking those homes.
    • 01:45:44
      You're punishing us.
    • 01:45:45
      You're making us then go be part of the problem rather than the solution.
    • 01:45:48
      We get on Metro.
    • 01:45:50
      We don't cause traffic.
    • 01:45:51
      We ease traffic.
    • 01:45:53
      So I urge you to go back to the Tier 1 study.
    • 01:45:55
      I know the Coalition for Smarter Growth has said that.
    • 01:45:59
      I urge you to do that.
    • 01:46:00
      I've attended several VDOT meetings, probably five or six.
    • 01:46:04
      Not one of those meetings has anybody stood up besides VDOT representatives and said, this is a great idea.
    • 01:46:09
      Let's move forward with this.
    • 01:46:10
      In fact, one member in Vienna, in Oakton, came and he said, I'm from Fauquier County and this is not a good idea.
    • 01:46:16
      What's it going to do?
    • 01:46:17
      It's just going to increase traffic on 66.
    • 01:46:19
      If you build it, they will come.
    • 01:46:21
      People are going to continue to move out.
    • 01:46:24
      During construction and after construction, it's just going to be as bad as it is now.
    • 01:46:27
      Thank you.
    • 01:46:28
      Thank you, sir, very much.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:30
      Ms. Agapayan, if I've said that correctly, I apologize.
    • 01:46:33
      And on behalf of Douglas Stewart, good morning, ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 01:46:35
      Good morning.
    • 01:46:36
      My name is Mary Hagopian, and I would like to speak to you this morning on behalf of my family with regard to the unwise and ill-thought expansion of I-66.
    • 01:46:45
      We are a retired United States Marine Corps family, and we have lived in this area on and off for the last 30 years.
    • 01:46:51
      In August of 2007, we purchased our home at 8056 Pritchard's Court in Dunloring, which abuts the I-495 interchange to I-66 on the northwest quadrant.
    • 01:47:02
      Shortly after we moved in, we became aware of the expansion of I-495 and the development of hot lanes on it.
    • 01:47:08
      With almost no time to react as homeowners with adjacent property, reconstruction of this interchange began in July 2008 and continued for the next four years.
    • 01:47:17
      Throughout that time, we lived without a sound wall for nine months, were awakened many a night from demolition blasts of bridges, and became quite familiar with bulldozers and other heavy construction outside our front window.
    • 01:47:28
      Interestingly, I would march my children out to the Orange Fence, which was one of the only things separating us from one of the largest interchanges on the Eastern Seed Board, and I would tell them, get a good look.
    • 01:47:38
      You're seeing history in the making.
    • 01:47:40
      You won't see this again for 50 years.
    • 01:47:43
      Rarely do I admit this, and don't tell my husband, but I was wrong.
    • 01:47:47
      It took VDOT and Transurban four years to complete the I-495 hot lanes, and now a mere three years later, not fifty, they want to start all over again, tearing down and reconfiguring what they just built at this interchange to add a high-speed fiber ramp 80 feet into the air and take one of the only small forests remaining in the area away from the wildlife, away from the conservation easement of which it is designated, and away from a community that has been established here for 25 years.
    • 01:48:16
      Compared to the vetting that was conducted and completed for the I-495 hot lanes and the decade it took to complete beginning in 1994, the rapid advancement of the I-66 widening, lack of home and property owner notification, and desired project start date less than two years from now could be considered at the very least reckless.
    • 01:48:37
      I'd like to point out that for the eight years my family has lived here in this home, we've experienced VDOT megaprojects for over half of them.
    • 01:48:45
      And now you're asking us to endure another five years of disruption and destruction.
    • 01:48:51
      What has my family done other than being good, law-abiding, Virginia voting, and taxpaying citizens serving this great country to deserve this egregious action that is being ramrodded into place by the Commonwealth of Virginia?
    • 01:49:04
      We would like to see this project stopped altogether.
    • 01:49:07
      However, we are asking you to scale back the design for this interchange and work within the existing right-of-way.
    • 01:49:13
      We are asking you to utilize the current existing ramp that moves traffic from I-495 South onto I-66 West and not add any additional high-speed flyover ramps.
    • 01:49:24
      We are asking you, VDOT, our elected officials, to be mindful of your citizens who live and work in this area and hear our voices.
    • 01:49:32
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:33
      Thank you very much, Pam.
    • 01:49:34
      Mr. Stewart and then Thomas Kramer.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 01:49:44
      Good morning, Secretary Layne, members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 01:49:48
      My name is Douglas Stewart.
    • 01:49:49
      I'm speaking for the I-66 Corridor Coalition.
    • 01:49:53
      We're an alliance of environmental, smart growth, transportation, and bicycle groups working for
    • 01:50:00
      Long-term effective solutions to transportation in the I-66 corridor.
    • 01:50:06
      First, I want to say we very much appreciate the commitment that Secretary Layne has stated for integrating transit, operating and capital into this project.
    • 01:50:18
      Our concern, though, is that the plan will not adequately address near-term transportation needs and will also foreclose long-term solutions that address those needs.
    • 01:50:29
      Our coalition favors a transit-first approach to solving our transportation problems and we believe that the NEPA studies have failed to fully analyze a transit-first alternative that incorporates land use that would maximize trips by transit, walking, and bicycling.
    • 01:50:44
      The discussion this morning about land use and transportation and coordination was very illuminating and it was really great to hear about
    • 01:50:53
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz, Shannon Valentine, L. C. If you look at this corridor, this is a perfect example.
    • 01:51:04
      We have evolving land uses, places like Dunloring, Fair Oaks, just outside the corridor where we're standing today in Tysons, Route 28.
    • 01:51:13
      of mixed use compact walkable development and one thing that we really think this project needs to be asking as we're moving forward is how is it encouraging these kinds of land uses enabling more people to use alternatives to single occupancy vehicle trips.
    • 01:51:29
      On the other hand, is it perpetuating patterns of land use such as all of the development we see in the western part of the corridor where people don't have a viable transportation option besides single occupancy vehicle travel?
    • 01:51:44
      I'm just going to speak to three specific concerns about the project.
    • 01:51:48
      First of all, storm water management.
    • 01:51:50
      We strongly urge that the storm water management, current storm water management standards for protecting the bay be applied to the entire road bed, not just the added impervious surface.
    • 01:52:02
      In our minds, that's not a nice to have, that's a must have.
    • 01:52:05
      Second, as I alluded to, we think that the current transit ridership projections, although it's a robust plan, we think they could be much higher if they were combined with more vigorous land use scenarios that enabled more people to connect to transit by other means besides driving.
    • 01:52:23
      And third, we appreciate the incorporation of bicycle and pedestrian facilities.
    • 01:52:28
      We understand those plans are still in development.
    • 01:52:32
      Those plans really need to be integrated into the final design plans.
    • 01:52:36
      Just one final comment.
    • 01:52:37
      I'm actually speaking for the Virginia Sierra Club on this.
    • 01:52:40
      We fully support keeping congestion mitigation at 35% for Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads.
    • 01:52:45
      Thank you.
    • 01:52:46
      Thank you for your comments.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:47
      Thomas Kramer.
    • 01:52:48
      And then Delegate Jim LaMonion.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:52:57
      Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
    • 01:52:59
      My name is Thomas Cranmer.
    • 01:53:01
      I'm a transportation expert according to the courts here.
    • 01:53:06
      I'm with the Fairfax County Taxpayers Alliance as first Vice President.
    • 01:53:12
      I'd like to comment that it's great that you're willing to consider prioritizing decision making for all of the roads.
    • 01:53:23
      And it's a step forward rather than just using political clout.
    • 01:53:28
      However, the analysis presented in the last day and today has major deficiencies.
    • 01:53:38
      It has not used standardized methods of analysis.
    • 01:53:43
      To be specific, for example, some of the presentations have been, to me, incomprehensible about why inside the Beltway Route 66 is going to increase throughput of cars.
    • 01:54:03
      Arlington County has fought it for years and then also outside the Beltway.
    • 01:54:11
      Yesterday there was a presentation by Fairfax County and they didn't mention what any of the costs were.
    • 01:54:20
      This is absurd.
    • 01:54:21
      I don't have a big presentation about this.
    • 01:54:25
      This was a problem with the Northern Virginia Transportation Commission where they had a meeting just a few days ago and not one word was used for U.S. dollars.
    • 01:54:36
      I mean, this is incredible.
    • 01:54:38
      You know, we've got fairly unlimited pockets.
    • 01:54:42
      Mr. Layne certainly has lots of money to dole out apparently.
    • 01:54:48
      So another problem has been with Route 7 expansion from Ruston Parkway to Tysons.
    • 01:54:57
      The Tysons planners said Tysons would fail if that was not expanded.
    • 01:55:02
      It's not on the 2040 plan for NVTA.
    • 01:55:05
      It's not in the VDOT plans.
    • 01:55:09
      They show a cost in the year 2020.
    • 01:55:13
      For the project for the expansion, but it's not a budget item by any means.
    • 01:55:21
      And I had pointed out that the Fairfax County Department of Transportation had falsified the amount of money to be spent on that.
    • 01:55:33
      They said it was $160 million.
    • 01:55:35
      That's absurd.
    • 01:55:36
      Thank you much for your comments, sir.
    • 01:55:42
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:55:52
      Thank you.
    • 01:55:53
      Delegate Lemonyan?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:56:04
      And then on deck is Rob Whitfield.
    • 01:56:08
      And Duncan, I'm glad to see you here, sir.
    • 01:56:11
      We have been keeping to a three-minute limit with the citizens, and I'd respect that this morning, sir.
    • 01:56:16
      And I normally go long, but since we've got so many, so I appreciate that, sir.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 01:56:20
      I'll do my best.
    • 01:56:21
      Thanks for including me today, and I'm sorry I haven't been able to spend the last day and a half with you as much as I'm interested.
    • 01:56:26
      Some of us have day jobs in the General Assembly.
    • 01:56:30
      was thinking about what I might share with you today, and I got a few points I want to make, but I got a letter actually just coincidentally yesterday from a constituent who's a retired Air Force general.
    • 01:56:41
      He says, Jim, I've lived all over the world, but I've spent most of my time, now 20 years, in Northern Virginia.
    • 01:56:49
      I'm moving out.
    • 01:56:50
      largely because of the traffic situation has become unbearable.
    • 01:56:54
      You, the Virginia House of Delegates, VDOT, and the whole Virginia government richly deserve an F in your work on traffic."
    • 01:57:03
      And then he signed his name, last name happened to be Donohue, I assume there's no relation.
    • 01:57:10
      But that's kind of where we are.
    • 01:57:11
      We've got a lot going on.
    • 01:57:12
      You might say, well, this person's just not informed.
    • 01:57:15
      Well, actually, that was in response to a two-page letter I sent to 17,000 households in my district explaining everything that we've got going on.
    • 01:57:23
      But the public perception's not changing.
    • 01:57:24
      It's going to take time.
    • 01:57:25
      We all know that.
    • 01:57:28
      But we're up against a pretty big
    • 01:57:30
      Pray to Big Task.
    • 01:57:31
      I want to give some credit where it's due, and I'm keeping an eye on the clock.
    • 01:57:35
      And some of you have heard this before, but in implementing House Bill 599, VDOT did an excellent job.
    • 01:57:41
      I had a little bit to do with that bill.
    • 01:57:42
      It's to rate projects rated according to their congestion relief in Northern Virginia, and they certainly exceeded my expectations as the author of that bill.
    • 01:57:51
      But we only rated 37 projects, and only five of those were suggested by the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 01:57:58
      We've got at least another 37 to go, maybe even twice that, and I would encourage you to hurry up.
    • 01:58:04
      One reason is we've got this public meeting on I-66 next week, and unless you're going to pleasantly surprise us, there's no 599 rating on I-66, inside or outside the Beltway.
    • 01:58:15
      How can the public respond to these kinds of offers and opportunities without that information?
    • 01:58:21
      You've heard a lot of people disappointed, but you don't have any data to counter their disappointment.
    • 01:58:26
      By County Parkway would be another one.
    • 01:58:28
      Why hasn't that been rated?
    • 01:58:29
      Okay, if that's a political issue, at least you have the tools and the data if you would use 599 to address those concerns.
    • 01:58:41
      One comment, I see I'm down to 40 seconds or so.
    • 01:58:44
      I want to make, and Mr. Secretary, I want to go into more detail maybe at a later time.
    • 01:58:50
      I'll be happy to meet with tolling and things on I-66 with you.
    • 01:58:54
      But just to say I am concerned that a toll would ever be used for something other than to pay for the construction improvement or the maintenance of a road.
    • 01:59:04
      If it becomes a cash stream for some other thing, then a lot of people say it looks like a tax.
    • 01:59:10
      Separate from the philosophical issue about whether a toll is a tax or not, it has the effect of taking things off budget.
    • 01:59:17
      And you said yesterday in your slides, and I agree completely, fiduciary responsibility, transparent accountability, I'm all for you.
    • 01:59:23
      But when you take that stuff off budget, then there's no need for people to come back and justify every time there's a budget process.
    • 01:59:32
      I think I'm out of time.
    • 01:59:34
      The reason I didn't sign that letter from other legislators saying it will only be weighted 60% is because I still think it ought to be 100%.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:42
      Thank you, sir, for being here.
    • 01:59:45
      And we will be happy to meet with you, sir, to go through that.
    • 01:59:48
      Rob Woodfield and then Jeff Anderson.
    • 01:59:51
      Good morning, sir.
    • Rob WhitfieldPublic commenter
    • 01:59:53
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, members of the CTB.
    • 01:59:56
      I'm Rob Whitfield.
    • 01:59:57
      I've lived in Fairfax County since 1977 and in the last decade I've attended some 3,000 transportation and land use planning meetings on Tysons, on Reston, and among other things the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority and the WMATA.
    • 02:00:16
      And some of the major issues facing us have not so far been addressed in this meeting and it doesn't look as if they're going to be.
    • 02:00:24
      But let me start from the perspective of the I-66.
    • 02:00:27
      I've given you there the sheet from the design guidelines from 2008 and would remind you that heavy rail transit only works where densities exceed 6600 per square mile.
    • 02:00:41
      That is not the case as the densities outside the Beltway, even in the Silver Line corridor, and so please do not consider the heavy rail
    • 02:00:50
      On HB2, there are far too many variables for any reasonable person to understand and evaluate in an objective manner.
    • 02:01:08
      And so the question that troubles me most is, who's going to be doing the rating and the ranking?
    • 02:01:14
      And will that be consistent from one part of Virginia to another?
    • 02:01:20
      We have all these land use plans in Fairfax County, Tysons and Reston, where literally most densities are increased by five to ten times because of bringing rail.
    • 02:01:30
      But the reality is that over 90% of our mobility relies on the highway network.
    • 02:01:36
      and fewer than 15% use the transit system.
    • 02:01:40
      Even buses have to use the highway system.
    • 02:01:43
      The spending provisions for transit vastly exceed the demand and they need to be reduced, respective of demand.
    • 02:01:50
      The I-66, oh, let me switch to MWA.
    • 02:02:00
      MWA, what I gave you in here is from the 2006 proposal.
    • 02:02:06
      You'll see by looking at the next page that they promised 300 million in capital improvements for the Dulles Toll Road.
    • 02:02:12
      That has not been executed.
    • 02:02:14
      It is up to the Commonwealth to enforce the agreement made in 2006.
    • 02:02:18
      And finally, within the WMATA purview, the maintenance facility at Dulles Airport, which is a 260 million capital cost, let's say another 50 million design costs and land,
    • 02:02:35
      The Transit Authority is providing nothing, even though half of the railcars to be maintained there will be used elsewhere in the system.
    • 02:02:43
      Nothing to do with Dulles Rail.
    • 02:02:44
      I've repeatedly asked Chairman York, who heads the DCAC and various other people, WMATA has to have its feet held to the fire.
    • 02:02:53
      If they want the system to operate... Mr. Whitfield, I understand your question.
    • 02:02:59
      Yes, sir.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 02:03:00
      Jeff Anderson, and then Nancy Smith.
    • 02:03:02
      Good morning, sir.
    • 02:03:04
      Morning.
    • 02:03:05
      My name is Jeff Anderson.
    • 02:03:06
      I live in Vienna, Virginia.
    • 02:03:08
      I'm a member of the Fairfax County Trails and Sidewalks Committee, but I'm here speaking mostly as a member of Fairfax Advocates for Better Bicycling.
    • 02:03:15
      I'm also a parent of three children, and I literally just ran over here after riding my kids to school, so that's why I'm dressed in shorts and very casual.
    • 02:03:22
      I'd like to speak in support of the bicycle trail facility that we want parallel to I-66.
    • 02:03:29
      Bicyclists in the area do not believe we are being heard enough.
    • 02:03:34
      The Virginia State Bike Plan that the CTB approved we believe is not being followed.
    • 02:03:39
      We've had 500 county residents send emails via a Washington area WABR alert to let them know that they want this facility added.
    • 02:03:49
      We know that Fairfax County DOT is requesting a parallel bike trail.
    • 02:03:53
      We do applaud the fact that the overpasses are including bike facilities and that's a result of having them included in the hot lanes on 495.
    • 02:04:04
      But we need a parallel bike path in order to allow people access to the rapid bus and future metro facilities if those are ever built.
    • 02:04:13
      At our recent Trails and Sidewalks meeting, one of our members was taking a class in GIS mapping, and he decided to look at the population centers around I-66.
    • 02:04:24
      And using census data from the last census, he determined that 25% of the Fairfax County population lives within one mile of 66.
    • 02:04:33
      And if we look at the other facilities that have been built in the area, the W&OD, the Custis Trail in Arlington, and the Mount Vernon Trail, when those were built, we never imagined that those would be major commuter routes for the bicyclists in the area.
    • 02:04:48
      And Secretary Layne himself mentioned earlier that there's an inability to build parallel roads in our area, and yet we think we're ignoring the chance to build a parallel bicycle facility along 66.
    • 02:04:59
      The other night I was at a VDOT presentation and they used the words multimodal, diverse choices, and connectivity.
    • 02:05:06
      To not include the bicycle facility does a disservice to those words.
    • 02:05:10
      The project date, the data they're using is starting at 2040, end of lifespan, which we'll have to revisit again.
    • 02:05:17
      And based on the growth of bicycling as a viable transportation alternative, if we don't build the facility today, we don't believe it'll ever be built.
    • 02:05:24
      Thank you.
    • 02:05:25
      Thank you, sir.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:05:27
      Nancy Smith and then Joe Balduch.
    • SPEAKER_38
    • 02:05:31
      Good morning Nancy Smith of the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance.
    • 02:05:34
      Well yesterday and today's workshops have certainly covered a lot of important and complex material.
    • 02:05:40
      I'm sure you all will have a headache by the end of the day.
    • 02:05:44
      But certainly information that requires a lot of further debate and examination on your parts in the months ahead.
    • 02:05:50
      But just a couple of observations and concerns from the Alliance over the last couple of days.
    • 02:05:55
      In terms of the complex House Bill 2 process, as currently drafted, the House Bill 2 process seems to lack a critically important big picture statewide perspective, which is essential to achieving a well-connected Commonwealth.
    • 02:06:12
      And towards that end, currently in the draft, it proposes that project submissions would be done by local MPOs and regional planning authorities, but we would suggest that this body should have a more significant role in project submission.
    • 02:06:26
      In terms of congestion mitigation measure, particularly for the category A in Northern Virginia, the Alliance as well as the greater Northern Virginia business community have recommended a weight of at least 60% be assigned a congestion reduction.
    • 02:06:42
      That 35% is totally inadequate.
    • 02:06:44
      Mr. Secretary, you have said that facts, not ideology should drive the process.
    • 02:06:50
      However, waiting assignments will determine the outcomes of these projects.
    • 02:06:54
      An assignment of only 35% for congestion reduction in the most congested regions of the state is more indicative of ideology rather than a factual approach to the needs.
    • 02:07:04
      As to land use, Northern Virginia's land use practices and quality of development exceed those of most other comparable areas of the nation, and so does our transit usage.
    • 02:07:15
      Our congestion is not the result of poor land use or lack of transit, but of a quarter of a century of failure of the state to provide adequate funding for infrastructure for an economy that was generating tens of thousands of new jobs and 40% of the Commonwealth's revenue.
    • 02:07:31
      Again, assigning only 35% of congestion mitigation will most surely ensure that congestion continues to grow and our regional economy continue to slow.
    • 02:07:40
      Moving quickly to I-66 outside the Beltway, the Alliance commends the Commonwealth for taking an initiative to determine the potential costs and benefits of its own design-build approach, and hopefully this will incentivize everyone to sharpen their pencils, but that can really only be achieved with the release of the financials that we referred to yesterday, so we look forward to seeing that.
    • 02:08:00
      The details and assumptions in the study will require careful examination, but we can all agree that the ultimate objective must be the best deal for the taxpayer.
    • 02:08:09
      But care must be taken to strike a careful balance and find a financing model that does not impede the Commonwealth's ability to address our other more immediate needs in Northern Virginia and elsewhere while continuing to move forward on the developments on I-66.
    • 02:08:24
      So I'm almost out of time.
    • 02:08:26
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:26
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:08:27
      Joe, and then we have John L. Thras, if I've said that correctly.
    • SPEAKER_14
    • 02:08:32
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 02:08:35
      My name is Joe Biddleitch, and I'm the Vice President of the Fairfax County Chamber of Commerce.
    • 02:08:39
      Before I go any further, I'd like to thank Ms. Nancy Smith from the Alliance, and we stand with the Alliance on her comments on HB 2.
    • 02:08:46
      On the issue of Interstate 66, we welcome the call from Secretary Layne for an open and vigorous public debate and discourse on the scope and financing of I-66.
    • 02:08:54
      The Chamber's unfettered belief, and for that matter the belief of 15 other business associations, is that the private sector can deliver and has delivered time and time again innovative and entrepreneurial solutions that achieve the congestion relief that Northern Virginia businesses, its residents are demanding and expecting.
    • 02:09:11
      Like the Secretary, we too believe that a multimodal approach on I-66 is the best approach.
    • 02:09:16
      Like the Secretary, we believe that the Commonwealth Transportation Board must act as good fiduciaries in that regard.
    • 02:09:22
      And like the Secretary, we too want I-66 done right.
    • 02:09:26
      The Chamber wants the private sector to compete and compete fairly.
    • 02:09:29
      The Interstate 66 project presents a unique opportunity to attract private investment to the Commonwealth.
    • 02:09:34
      Properly structured P3 will enable the Commonwealth to leverage the limited state and federal transportation dollars in the I-66 corridor and leave some for other important projects.
    • 02:09:44
      The private sector can mitigate a substantial amount of risk to Virginia and minimize the impact of community and, frankly, save many of the homes that might otherwise not be in a VDOT model.
    • 02:09:53
      We agree with Mr. Fralin, Mr. Garzynski, and Mr. Dyke that the process needs to be open and transparent.
    • 02:09:59
      Therefore, we are asking the Secretary to disclose and produce for the vigorous debate and discourse he referenced yesterday, the full analysis and data behind the presentation, including the initial OP3 analysis.
    • 02:10:09
      In fairness, the private sector cannot compete against some of the generalities that we heard yesterday, nor is it fair to leave it up just for three PowerPoint slides.
    • 02:10:18
      Data is important.
    • 02:10:19
      We owe it to Virginia to explore all that in detail.
    • 02:10:22
      With that analysis in front of us, we can then ask the tough questions.
    • 02:10:26
      Will the state really be required to increase its debt capacity?
    • 02:10:29
      How will the state mitigate traffic and revenue risk, a risk barely noted yesterday but identified by rating agencies and other organizations as the riskiest element of the project?
    • 02:10:38
      What source of funding will be used to pay the state's bondholders if traffic doesn't meet projections, as is often the case?
    • 02:10:43
      VDOT has never historically assumed traffic and revenue risk of this scale and complexity before.
    • 02:10:48
      What commitment will be required from NVTA and at the expense of other regional projects?
    • 02:10:55
      Who will be responsible for cost overruns and delays, like we've seen on the projects like Springfield Interchange and Dulles Metrorail?
    • 02:11:00
      And where will that money come from?
    • 02:11:02
      Finally, and most importantly, the media release assumes a maximum upside for the state with no downside at all, an unrealistic scenario and consistent through reality of these toll projects.
    • 02:11:12
      And quite frankly, we don't do that in business.
    • 02:11:14
      We believe in the process and achieving what is best to unlock the new Northern Virginia and the new Virginia economy through meaningful transportation solutions.
    • 02:11:22
      We look forward to opening up the books and examining the data behind yesterday's information so that we can compete and we can find that public, that private partner for the public if one works out for the Commonwealth.
    • 02:11:32
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:11:33
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:11:34
      Mr. Elthrop and then Sheila Blaine.
    • 02:11:38
      Good morning, sir.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 02:11:40
      Good morning and thank you.
    • 02:11:41
      I'm John Elsroth.
    • 02:11:42
      I live at 8100 Revatom Court in Dunloring.
    • 02:11:47
      I have two comments this morning on I-66 and major transportation corridor.
    • 02:11:52
      One is the P-3.
    • 02:11:55
      I'm pleased that the enthusiasm for a P-3 option on I-66 has waned.
    • 02:12:01
      It is difficult for me to see that the existing P-3 deals have been or are a good deal for Virginia, especially the long-term 70 to 80-year deals.
    • 02:12:14
      If you look back, back to 1935, 80 years ago, and consider the transportation conditions at that point and what changed in the meantime, you might say, what are we going to look like 80 years forward?
    • 02:12:29
      When considering that the roads were built under the Defense Highway Act are being sold to a foreign corporation, that to me is perhaps a questionable issue there.
    • 02:12:44
      My second point is that this should be a rail, not a road option.
    • 02:12:50
      Rob Woodward's comments notwithstanding, take a look out the window of this hotel.
    • 02:12:57
      Look at the economic engine.
    • 02:12:58
      The silver line is leading.
    • 02:13:02
      Here at Tysons and at Points West, move to the orange line.
    • 02:13:07
      Maryfield, Ballston,
    • 02:13:10
      looked at the red line over in Maryland.
    • 02:13:13
      Look at the economic development that the rail option is driving on.
    • 02:13:19
      It is the future.
    • 02:13:20
      Rail is the future.
    • 02:13:21
      And in fact, rail is now the future for communities that already have it.
    • 02:13:28
      So those are my two basic comments.
    • 02:13:29
      I have one other note just based on the comments.
    • 02:13:35
      Better signal management.
    • 02:13:38
      If you could get three green lights in a row, wouldn't that help congestion mitigation quite a bit?
    • 02:13:49
      Thank you gentlemen.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:50
      Thank you very much for your comments sir.
    • 02:13:52
      Sheila Blain and then Carol Hook.
    • 02:13:58
      Good morning ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_39
    • 02:13:59
      Good morning.
    • 02:13:59
      Thank you.
    • 02:14:02
      As a self-employed citizen with three kids and a day-to-day life to manage, I'm busy.
    • 02:14:07
      The news over the last few days about how I-66 might best be improved is at best confusing to me.
    • 02:14:13
      At worst, it feels deliberately distracting.
    • 02:14:16
      Secretary Layne, you had an op-ed one day in the post and you're quoted the next day on the Metro section front page.
    • 02:14:21
      And at 10 p.m. last night, I read yet another new piece.
    • 02:14:24
      And the messages to me are a little confusing.
    • 02:14:26
      So when I first sat down to write these comments, I'll admit I was in defensive mode.
    • 02:14:31
      Then I finally found time to delve into that 1,000-page Tier 2 assessment.
    • 02:14:35
      So I do want to thank VDOT.
    • 02:14:37
      It appears that they really did do some research about alternative modes of transportation.
    • 02:14:41
      Overwhelmingly, people support multimodal transportation like extended metro, rapid bus transit, and VRE expansion.
    • 02:14:48
      So my question is this, why are these other modes put off mainly until after I-66 is already widened?
    • 02:14:54
      VDOT has said that buses are part of the project, but will be fully implemented only once the road is widened.
    • 02:15:00
      The same is true of Metro expansion, if the project plan actually has room to do that.
    • 02:15:04
      Why wouldn't you invest our money in buses before spending $3 billion on the road?
    • 02:15:09
      VDOT could use the existing right lane to operate commuter buses all day, more during rush hour.
    • 02:15:14
      Starting in Haymarket, some buses go nonstop all the way to the city, others stop at Tysons, Falls Church, Arlington.
    • 02:15:20
      The VDOT's Tier 2 assessment looked into 47 improvement concept scenarios involving a mix of general purpose lanes, managed lanes, metro extension, light rail, bus rapid transit, and VRE extension.
    • 02:15:30
      All of the top 10 solutions involved extending metro.
    • 02:15:34
      The Tier 1 study was supposed to investigate Orange Line Extension in 2014.
    • 02:15:37
      In January, we were told it's off the table and it's not in any of the long-term plans, according to LaMotta.
    • 02:15:43
      The first phase of the Silver Line cost under $3 billion.
    • 02:15:46
      That's about or less than the cost for the 66 proposed.
    • 02:15:49
      Roslyn's tunnel limited capacity is a concern, I understand, but not all eastbound commuters are heading all the way to the city.
    • 02:15:55
      Some trains could turn around at Tysons or Falls Church.
    • 02:15:57
      That's already happening on the Red Line and Silver Spring.
    • 02:16:01
      I'd like to look back at Ashburn and Leesburg and the toll road.
    • 02:16:04
      I remember when ads encouraged people to move out there because the toll road was underutilized.
    • 02:16:09
      Well, guess what?
    • 02:16:09
      People did move out there, and the road got congested, and you know what the solution was?
    • 02:16:13
      The Silver Line.
    • 02:16:15
      If VDOT isn't widening 66 inside the Beltway, I'd like to see a better effort to preserve communities and retain the toll outside the Beltway as well.
    • 02:16:23
      We live in one of the most affluent areas in the country, just outside the capital of our nation.
    • 02:16:28
      Surely we have some of the brightest minds in urban planning.
    • 02:16:31
      The younger generations want transit-oriented housing and walkable communities like Tysons and Mosaic.
    • 02:16:37
      Is more lanes really the best we can come up with?
    • 02:16:41
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:42
      Thank you, ma'am.
    • 02:16:43
      Carol Hook and then Brian Zelle.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:16:51
      Good morning.
    • 02:16:52
      Good morning.
    • 02:16:52
      I want to thank you all for allowing us to speak with you today.
    • 02:16:56
      My name is Carol Hook and my home is one of the homes that Virginia Department of Transportation has indicated will be taken for the proposed Transform 66 outside the Beltway.
    • 02:17:07
      To some extent, however, that's irrelevant.
    • 02:17:11
      I'm not here today to appeal to your motions.
    • 02:17:13
      I'm here to discuss the concept and my experience with induced demand.
    • 02:17:19
      Induced demand is a phrase used to capture the simple and intuitive notion that expansion of capacity will be met with an attendant increase in demand.
    • 02:17:29
      In other words, they'll come.
    • 02:17:32
      As a native Californian, it surprises me that VDOT refuses to acknowledge
    • 02:17:37
      or seriously engage with concept of induced demand.
    • 02:17:42
      You see, for the first 66 years of my life until I moved here two years ago, I lived in Southern California and have seen the mistakes VDOT is making on a much larger scale.
    • 02:17:54
      For instance, growing up in Southern California, I saw the 91 expand from a two-lane road into a 14-lane freeway.
    • 02:18:04
      In this time, one thing remained constant.
    • 02:18:07
      It was always congested.
    • 02:18:09
      Every expansion promised relief from the congestion, but instead, more people moved further away from their place of employment for larger and cheaper housing, resulting in more commuters, which quickly outstripped the additional capacity of the expanded roads.
    • 02:18:25
      Even now, with two toll lanes in each direction, there is no relief from the congestion.
    • 02:18:31
      No road I have ever seen can be built faster than homes can be built where people move.
    • 02:18:37
      Unfortunately, they are now in a situation where they cannot add the transportation needed, such as the Metro.
    • 02:18:46
      We can even see this with the 495 hot lanes, is brought summerly for those who can afford to use the hot lanes.
    • 02:18:54
      But all of the regular lanes appear as congestion, if not more.
    • 02:18:59
      For every one driver that takes two or more hot lanes, they will be replaced with another driver not using the hot lanes.
    • 02:19:08
      Induced demand is not just fringe theory.
    • 02:19:10
      It is a well-documented phenomenon across many cities in the United States, such as L.A. and Atlanta.
    • 02:19:17
      In contrast, some cities, sorry, as in Paris, have actively reduced the number of traffic lanes.
    • 02:19:25
      At first, there's public outcry.
    • 02:19:27
      The congestion would get significantly worse, but it did not.
    • 02:19:32
      Instead, what happened in Paris, the congestion forced people to use public transportation.
    • 02:19:41
      I understand that policymakers are always asked to solve the problems.
    • 02:19:45
      Some problems cannot be solved.
    • 02:19:48
      This is when we need to find a better solution for it than taking them homes.
    • 02:19:55
      Thank you, ma'am.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:57
      Brian Zelle, and then Jeff Romella,
    • SPEAKER_40
    • 02:20:04
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary and the Board.
    • 02:20:06
      I really appreciated your thoughtful comments on the P3 process yesterday and the desire to take a broader view with the process in the context of I-66.
    • 02:20:16
      That was a very welcome news indeed.
    • 02:20:18
      The current Transform 66 plans do not reflect
    • 02:20:23
      The perspective that regional problems need regional solutions.
    • 02:20:27
      Instead, the plans presented by the Commonwealth will severely impact and destroy the communities just outside the Beltway.
    • 02:20:34
      And the supposed beneficiaries of the plan, the car drivers, will be forced to endure the permanent loss of a free lane that exists today, our beloved Green Hour lane, for pay tolls with unlimited increases for decades to come.
    • 02:20:49
      Rather than provide a consistent approach to Interstate 66, the plans offer our choosing to transform the roadway outside the Beltway remarkably differently than the plans for inside the Beltway.
    • 02:21:02
      With each new detail exposed about this transformation, we learn the project's true impacts, including significant land-taking and homes lost.
    • 02:21:09
      The displaced are your neighbors who live in transit-oriented housing, who choose not to have long automobile commutes, many choosing not to drive at all.
    • 02:21:18
      For them, the project won't just bring increased noise, polluted storm water, and the loss of beloved yards and school recess fields.
    • 02:21:25
      The current plans mean the loss of pedestrian transit access, buffer zones of green space forever gone, and new walls constructed just feet from bedrooms.
    • 02:21:34
      The permanent life of brightly lit flyers towering up to 80 feet over the neighborhoods.
    • 02:21:42
      Under VDOT's plans, the very residents who invested in the transit-oriented housing are the folks who will see their neighborhoods destroyed.
    • 02:21:48
      Jr., James W. Dyke Jr., John Malbon, John K. Matney, James W. Dyke Jr., John Malbon,
    • 02:22:13
      Longer car trips and even more sprawl into the diminishing open spaces of Northern Virginia.
    • 02:22:19
      While the wealthy commuters might well be able to afford a pricey commute twice a day, the working class commuters will face the loss of that free peak lane forever.
    • 02:22:28
      We know that Interstates 95 and 495 already stands to a rush hour today.
    • 02:22:33
      Take a look right over here at Tysons, northbound or southbound on 95 at the end of, I'm sorry, during the evening rush.
    • 02:22:41
      You'll see that with the express lanes open and running right now.
    • 02:22:44
      The congestion has increased at those endpoints.
    • 02:22:47
      This plan is for pavement now with promises of some buses later.
    • 02:22:51
      Is that the best way forward for our region?
    • 02:22:54
      We urge the focus on moving people rather than just cars throughout the corridor.
    • 02:22:58
      Thank you very much.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:59
      Thank you very much, sir.
    • 02:23:02
      Jeff Romella and then Quang Hai.
    • 02:23:06
      Good morning, sir.
    • 02:23:09
      Good morning.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 02:23:10
      Hello, my name is Jeff Romella.
    • 02:23:11
      I'm married.
    • 02:23:12
      I have three daughters, two-year-old twins and a 17-year-old.
    • 02:23:15
      I've been in Dunloring since 1996 and own a small IT company in McLean, Virginia.
    • 02:23:21
      I've seen a lot of change and I understand the need for change.
    • 02:23:24
      However, I'm asking that you transform 66 wisely.
    • 02:23:27
      Dunn-Loring was founded in 1886.
    • 02:23:29
      It's a fragile community and is the earliest platted subdivision in Fairfax County and possibly in Virginia.
    • 02:23:37
      We need to celebrate and protect this history.
    • 02:23:41
      Virginia and Fairfax County are fortunate to have some really smart business-minded
    • 02:23:45
      People serving the government, and we thank you all for your public service.
    • 02:23:49
      However, in the case of the Plan 66 transformation, I believe our public servants at VDOT have failed us if we continue with the current proposed plans or alternatives.
    • 02:24:02
      Tax-paying citizens of Virginia should be placed first in a solution developed that is in the best interest for us.
    • 02:24:07
      As I understand it, based on the video on YouTube, Secretary Layne, legislation was passed last year that mandated the CTB to prioritize and fund projects according to five criteria.
    • 02:24:21
      I'm not going to read through them.
    • 02:24:22
      Sounds like they're in some level of change right now, but I'll go right to it since I only have three minutes and it looks like one minute and 40 seconds left.
    • 02:24:32
      Congestion mitigation.
    • 02:24:33
      VDOT has admitted at several public meetings that I have attended that current designs will not solve the congestion problem.
    • 02:24:38
      In fact, the current design solution will actually cause more congestions.
    • 02:24:42
      If commuters use the hot lanes as intended, they will come in greater numbers to the choke point at 495 and 66.
    • 02:24:48
      If the hot lanes are ended prior to Vienna at the metro and more commuters get on the metro or buses, the congestion at 495 and 66 choke points will be alleviated.
    • 02:24:59
      In fact, the current proposal, which would eliminate the free green lanes that we've all heard about in favor of hot lanes, will make congestion worse instead of better.
    • 02:25:07
      Hot lanes on 495 and 95 have conflicting data, but current data shared to the press most recently by the Washington Post say it's not as successful as planned.
    • 02:25:16
      So if less commuters use the hot lanes than use the free current green lanes, you're guaranteeing more congestion despite billions of dollars spent.
    • 02:25:26
      Why would you want to continue investing in an approach that offers questionable success?
    • 02:25:31
      Economic development,
    • 02:25:33
      I'm going to run out of time, but in the economic development area, you can see that the development in the communities will be hampered as well as if other roads are not built because building them will cut into the profits provided by the hot lanes.
    • 02:25:46
      So there's no economic development incentive there.
    • 02:25:49
      mobility.
    • 02:25:49
      Mobility will be negatively affected, particularly in my community and those further out.
    • 02:25:53
      There will be reticence in the part of either government or private entities running the toll lanes to develop other modes of transportation.
    • 02:26:00
      Environmental, we can go through that.
    • 02:26:02
      The return on investment, the return on investment for this project is much greater if the hot lanes are ended at the Vienna Metro.
    • 02:26:09
      This project would cost significantly less.
    • 02:26:13
      Thank you for your time.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:14
      Thank you very much for coming this morning.
    • 02:26:17
      Yes, and then we have Julie Burka.
    • SPEAKER_34
    • 02:26:24
      Good morning.
    • 02:26:24
      Good morning.
    • 02:26:25
      My name is Kwang Hee from Dunloring.
    • 02:26:27
      I'm here to explain why the Transform 66 project will be bad for residents, commuters, and Northern Virginians.
    • 02:26:34
      VDOT has claimed that all the devastation to Dunloring, Vienna, and Paul Church communities will benefit commuters by easing congestion.
    • 02:26:42
      Yet, the more we learn about the project, the more we learn that the project will
    • 02:26:47
      leave commuters worse off than they are today.
    • 02:26:50
      Specifically, VDOT's proposal involves the elimination of one general purpose lane, the lane that many Virginians refer to as the red X lane, shoulder lane, to create two hot lanes that transform
    • 02:27:04
      66 project will actually result in a decrease in general purpose land during rush hours.
    • 02:27:12
      In other words, commuters are forced into horrible decisions, sit in even worse traffic, or pay a hefty toll twice a day, adding thousands of dollars a year to the cost of their commute.
    • 02:27:25
      Moreover, VDOT has stated that it has no intent to expand I66 inside the Beltway until at least 2040.
    • 02:27:31
      Even if some commuters do not care about paying thousands of dollars a year to use the hot lanes, the project is just funneling even more drivers into the same two-lane bottleneck inside the I-66, inside the railway, or the already congested 495.
    • 02:27:47
      Why expand I66 outside the railway and make Fairfax into a parking lot?
    • 02:27:53
      VDOT has a different treatment for Arlington and Fairfax.
    • 02:27:56
      Arlington has consistently pushed back against VDOT expanding I66 to protect their precious existing communities.
    • 02:28:05
      VDOT continues to tell the public that they have reduced the possible eminent domain into only 12 to 18
    • 02:28:14
      I-66 corridor.
    • 02:28:30
      VDOT can eliminate almost all of the complete and partial home takings by ending the hotlands between Chambers Road and Nalley Street.
    • 02:28:40
      Metro is costly, but it is not an expense.
    • 02:28:42
      It is an investment that creates new economic developments areas like Tysons Corner and Mosaic District.
    • 02:28:50
      Business wants to be close to the metro so that workers can reach their office by metro, and people want to live near metro so they can easily commute to work.
    • 02:28:59
      To begin with, extending the Orange Line Metro to Fair Oaks, where there are thousands of existing parking spaces.
    • 02:29:06
      Truly reduce the car from the road and fix I-66.
    • 02:29:10
      Please correct this before it's too late.
    • 02:29:12
      Please be within the existing right-of-way.
    • 02:29:16
      Do not let VDOT take lanes or homes like they are free, like mine.
    • 02:29:21
      Thank you.
    • 02:29:22
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 02:29:22
      He.
    • 02:29:22
      Thank you very much.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:24
      Julie Herka and then Sean Sui Lee.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 02:29:36
      Good morning, ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_37
    • 02:29:38
      Good morning.
    • 02:29:38
      Thank you, Secretary Layne, for investigating the financing of the I-66 project as reported in the Washington Post yesterday.
    • 02:29:46
      I have been wondering, since you announced the plan to have VDOT toll I-66 inside the Beltway, why you would treat 66 outside the Beltway differently.
    • 02:29:57
      Outside, we've been told it will likely be a P3 with a private company paying $1 billion of the $3 billion and then collecting all tolls as they do on 95 and 495 for the next 75 years.
    • 02:30:12
      I see when in traffic on 495 and 95 that the investor-owned express lanes are not a solution to congestion but feed off it.
    • 02:30:22
      I understand the private investors' expedience in securing more lanes on 95 and the desire to do so on 66 before taxpayers figure out how bad this is for the taxpayers and commuters of Northern Virginia.
    • 02:30:38
      I sit in Fairfax County budget meetings listening to discussions on ways to increase revenue and then read full-page express lane ads selling Northern Virginia's commuters their time.
    • 02:30:52
      Why P3s are a bad idea when it comes to building toll roads.
    • 02:30:57
      The business plan depends on low occupancy vehicles.
    • 02:31:01
      Virginia has to compensate the private investor if too many HOV cars or buses equal too little toll revenue.
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Assistant Division Administrator
    • 02:31:07
      Commuters pay twice, once for the toll and then again if not enough cars are paying tolls.
    • SPEAKER_37
    • 02:31:12
      And in the case of I-66, the third time, as the plan calls for rebuilding bridges and infrastructure that were just completed for the 495 toll lanes and at the Dunloring and Vienna metro stations.
    • 02:31:26
      P3s are a bad idea because of the 75-year contracts, the no-compete clauses, and the 10K or higher tolls annually for commuters, an option most commuters can't afford who live in Centerville or Haymarket.
    • 02:31:43
      In yesterday's Post article, Mr. Gifford from GMU stated that the private sector has a fairly good track record on these types of projects.
    • 02:31:52
      It is in their best interest to do so.
    • 02:31:54
      For I-66, it's also in P-3's best interest to do unnecessary construction, like redoing the 495-66 interchange to connect to their current 495 investment.
    • 02:32:07
      But this is not in the best interest of neighborhoods, the environment, commuters, and taxpayers of Virginia.
    • 02:32:14
      Yes, what an ideal revenue risk project, in Mr. Giffords' words, and in Secretary Layne's
    • 02:32:21
      investigation has discovered.
    • 02:32:23
      Like I-66 inside the Beltway, let's keep the revenue in Northern Virginia.
    • 02:32:28
      In Virginia, a foreign investor is being allowed to squeeze commuters for the next 75 years, the majority of whom work for the federal government.
    • 02:32:37
      Please don't repeat P3 mistake on I-66.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:39
      Thank you, ma'am.
    • 02:32:41
      Any comments?
    • 02:32:42
      Ms. Lee and then Dan Holes.
    • 02:32:48
      Good morning, ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:32:48
      Good morning.
    • 02:32:50
      I'm Sue Lee from Dunloring.
    • 02:32:51
      I'm here to emphasize the devastating impact on Dunloring, Vienna, and fortress residency communities as a result of the I-66 Outside the Bellway project.
    • 02:33:00
      The project will severely impact or destroy our transit-oriented communities.
    • 02:33:05
      These are your neighbors, such as my family, who live in transit-oriented housing.
    • 02:33:09
      We chose to live in a smaller home and pay higher taxes to avoid driving and traffic congestion.
    • 02:33:15
      We are the people who get up in the morning and turn the metro to work.
    • 02:33:18
      We don't drive.
    • 02:33:20
      However, under VDOT's revised plan, hundreds of people, including myself, will still lose our homes and lands completely or partially.
    • 02:33:28
      Our children's school will still be lost partially.
    • 02:33:31
      The tree buffers featuring all homes and ice will be removed.
    • 02:33:36
      The project will bring increased noise and air pollution from years of construction and the new flyover range.
    • 02:33:43
      The new walls will be constructed just feet from your bedrooms.
    • 02:33:46
      and several huge 80-feet noisy fire-over-ramps will travel over neighborhoods.
    • 02:33:51
      The above negative impacts will decrease home values and checks the revenues in John Doering, Vienna, and fortress communities.
    • 02:33:58
      The project will significantly undermine investments from the Fairfax County and developers in creating walkable communities in Fairfax.
    • 02:34:06
      The very residents who invested in transit-oriented housing are the people who will see our neighborhoods destroyed, our homes condemned, and our children moved to other schools.
    • 02:34:19
      Thousands will face criminal aftermath left behind.
    • 02:34:23
      The attached maps that you see
    • 02:34:25
      On your handout, it shows that no change has been made for the five homes and the Stanwood Elementary School in Dunloring, based on the revised plan from last week.
    • 02:34:35
      The five homes remain to be taken completely on one of the five homeowners.
    • 02:34:40
      All our homes are within five minutes of walking distance to the Dunloring metro station and Stanwood School.
    • 02:34:45
      Given the unbeatable transit convenience, it is unrealistic for VDOT to tell us that they will find us a comparable home that meets the same needs that we have today.
    • 02:34:55
      Also attached, you see a picture from a child to Governor Macaulay asking the government not to take these home.
    • 02:35:02
      May I ask Secretary Layne, Commissioner Kilpatrick, Director Mitchell, and all the CTB Board members here, have you ever lived with the fear and stress that VDOT is going to take you home and make you move to another place that you may not like and that may not meet your needs?
    • 02:35:18
      Would you let VDOT take your homes, part of your children's school field and parks, and turn it into Holland with no guarantee of great law relief?
    • 02:35:26
      It is not reasonable to use eminent domain against us, the very transit-oriented residents.
    • 02:35:32
      Even one home taken is too many.
    • 02:35:34
      Please be within the city right away and invest in mass transit options to get cars off the roads.
    • 02:35:40
      Thank you all for listening to our voice.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:44
      Thank you.
    • 02:35:44
      Thank you very much, ma'am.
    • 02:35:46
      Dan Holmes and then Sonja Brie here.
    • SPEAKER_41
    • 02:35:50
      Good afternoon.
    • 02:35:52
      My name is Dan Holmes.
    • 02:35:53
      I'm with the Piedmont Environmental Council and I appreciate this opportunity to address the board.
    • 02:35:57
      I'm here to speak on the HB2 implementation and want to raise several concerns that we have as we move forward.
    • 02:36:04
      One is we believe that there needs to be an increase to the weight on environmental quality and land use factors.
    • 02:36:10
      Environmental quality is the lowest ranked factor in each of the four area types.
    • 02:36:14
      Virginia's natural resources are central to our health and economy.
    • 02:36:17
      Moreover, impacts to environmental and historic resources that are ignored or inadequately considered early can often translate into major delays and increased costs for projects later in development as was seen with Route 460 and the Bayh County Parkway.
    • 02:36:33
      The HB 2 process should put greater weight on these items so that proposed projects with serious environmental problems can be identified before significant resources are invested.
    • 02:36:42
      We urge you to increase the weight allocated to environmental quality to 20% in all four area types.
    • 02:36:50
      In addition, the importance to the link between transportation and land use has been increasingly recognized, including the impact of development patterns and the cost and effectiveness of transportation projects.
    • 02:37:01
      The potential to also spur environmentally and fiscally costly sprawl.
    • 02:37:05
      We can no longer afford to overlook these links.
    • 02:37:08
      The draft policy guide places too much emphasis on congestion reduction and fails to adequately reflect how some of these projects can lead to a diminished return on investment if not all issues are considered.
    • 02:37:21
      Experience has demonstrated that some projects merely shift congestion and increase sprawl and therefore overall congestion for the region.
    • 02:37:32
      To be consistent with the approaches taken for other criteria, we suggest that an approach would focus on at least three types of impacts and add the points for each to the score for impacts of sensitive resources that would equal half of the environmental quality score.
    • 02:37:45
      These three impacts would be wetlands and streams, park, recreation lands, and wildlife refuges, and historic resources.
    • 02:37:54
      Perhaps one of the most important factors that has to be considered here is congestion relief and economic development.
    • 02:38:00
      We just want to make sure that as we proceed that things that are now being viewed as potentially solving our congestion issues may actually increase the problem.
    • 02:38:11
      Specifically, when we're talking about building new roads in areas that would open up new lands to development further away from where these job centers are, it is a recipe for disaster.
    • 02:38:22
      We've seen it before.
    • 02:38:23
      We're going to see it again.
    • 02:38:25
      With regard to economic development, economic development factors should assess both positive and negative economic impacts of a proposed project in order to provide an accurate assessment of the true net impact of the economic development project.
    • 02:38:38
      If economic development factor only considers new businesses created, it will give a highly distorted and accurate assessment of the impact.
    • 02:38:45
      For example, agriculture is the leading industry in the Commonwealth.
    • 02:38:49
      When combined with forestry, we have a total economic impact of $70 billion, providing more than 400,000 jobs.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:39:05
      Good morning, ma'am.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:39:06
      Good morning, everybody.
    • 02:39:07
      Thank you for taking the time to hear our comments.
    • 02:39:11
      My name is Sonya Brehe.
    • 02:39:12
      I live in Falls Church.
    • 02:39:13
      I'm a mother of three in a biking household.
    • 02:39:17
      We commute to work.
    • 02:39:19
      We try to commute the kids with the kids to school and often for running errands around town.
    • 02:39:24
      So I'm here because I wanted to express that to truly transform the I-66 corridor for the future, we need long-term smart solutions that are truly multi-modal, not just for cars, but we need to maximize public transit, biking, and walking.
    • 02:39:41
      We appreciate the incorporation of bicycle and pedestrian facilities at the I-66 crossings.
    • 02:39:47
      That's going to be a huge help with maintaining that connectivity in the neighborhoods.
    • 02:39:51
      However, the proposed Tier 2 environmental impact statement
    • 02:39:55
      does not include the parallel bike trail and lacks details about the connectivity to transit stations along the corridor.
    • 02:40:03
      A shared use trail along I-66 will provide local residents and commuters transportation options enabling them to shift more trips to walking and biking.
    • 02:40:14
      A parallel trail along I-66 will provide direct access for biking and walking from those neighborhoods to schools like Stenwood Elementary School or Oakton High School, to suburban centers like the Mare Field, Fairfax Corners and Fair Oaks,
    • 02:40:29
      and access to metro rail stations at Dunloring and Vienna and future stations as it gets extended out towards Centerville.
    • 02:40:38
      Studies by the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority show that investments in biking and pedestrian accessibility to transit stations can significantly increase transit ridership and at a cost that's much less than building costly parking structures.
    • 02:40:56
      An I-66 trail would also provide regional connectivity to the WOD and the Custis Trail inside the Beltway, providing residents in central Fairfax County connections to work, to bike to work throughout the county and beyond.
    • 02:41:12
      And as we heard earlier, data shows that 25% of our county residents are within that trail benefit area.
    • 02:41:19
      So I urge you to please invest in safe, walkable, bikeable communities by maximizing our investments in biking and walking, especially the parallel trail as part of our solutions to this I-66 corridor.
    • 02:41:32
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:41:33
      Thank you, ma'am.
    • 02:41:34
      Dennis Drinker and then Michael Lambert.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:41:37
      Good morning, sir.
    • 02:41:38
      Good morning, Secretary Layne, board members.
    • 02:41:40
      I'm here, Dennis Drinker, speaking on behalf of the Committee for Dulles.
    • 02:41:44
      Committee for Dulles is a dynamic community of business and business leaders, policymakers, and dedicated individuals.
    • 02:41:50
      We represent businesses that have in excess of 10,000 employees.
    • 02:41:55
      Founded in 1966, the committee plays a pivotal role in making Dulles International Airport the premier air travel service provider for the National Capital Region and an economic feeder for the business community.
    • 02:42:08
      We are the only business-focused organization in the United States that supports an international airport.
    • 02:42:14
      The Committee for Dallas is dedicated to achieving the full potential of the airport and the economic growth of this region.
    • 02:42:19
      The committee considers transportation one of its top priorities and improving our regional transportation network essential for continued prosperity.
    • 02:42:29
      The Committee for Dallas commends the Virginia General Assembly and the Commonwealth Transportation Board for creating a process to
    • 02:42:36
      objectively evaluate road and transit projects.
    • 02:42:39
      We believe this evaluation process will ensure that state transportation resources are invested in an objective performance-based manner to reduce congestion and promote economic development.
    • 02:42:51
      However, the Committee for Dulles is concerned that the implementation of HB2 has become considerably more complex through the inclusion of safety, accessibility, environmental quality, and land use considerations.
    • 02:43:05
      These have resulted in less emphasis being assigned to two measures of greatest importance to state legislatures, citizens, and businesses, which are congestion reduction and economic development.
    • 02:43:17
      The fact that Northern Virginia Transportation Authority has been charged by the General Assembly with producing a regional transportation plan with the primary objective of reducing congestion to the greatest extent practical and to prioritize HB 2313 on projects that are expected to provide the greatest congestion relief relative to the cost of the project clearly indicates the legislator intends the passage of HB 2 was to assign major weight
    • 02:43:47
      Michael Lambert, Stu Whittaker,
    • SPEAKER_30
    • 02:44:18
      Thank you for providing this comment period.
    • 02:44:20
      My name is Marty Sarnambert.
    • 02:44:21
      I'm here to voice my opposition to aspects of the I-66 expansion plan.
    • 02:44:26
      My chief concern is proposed annexation of homes and property along the corridor and the adjacent Gallows Roadway.
    • 02:44:32
      My property is not one of these proposed homes, so my objection here is largely a moral one.
    • 02:44:38
      I believe that a high standard should be used when we do these kind of things and that the use of this kind of power shouldn't be done in the interest of private-public partnerships that are popular here in Virginia.
    • 02:44:48
      My concern with the proposed widening is that it will negatively impact the value of the revitalization that is in my neighborhood Dunmooring and which we have enjoyed over the past decade.
    • 02:44:58
      Fifteen years ago, my neighborhood turned over from gentrified housing development to one filled with young families and new residents building new homes.
    • 02:45:06
      Property values have been on the rise and they continue to go up.
    • 02:45:10
      This is not an area filled with blighted urban homes.
    • 02:45:13
      This makes the proposed seizure of land for the interstate all the more troubling.
    • 02:45:17
      We've seen significant redevelopment in the Maryfield Town Center, to which we have access.
    • 02:45:22
      The community is designed to be pedestrian-friendly.
    • 02:45:24
      Businesses in the Maryfield area depend upon high property values and net incomes of those who inhibit these neighborhoods.
    • 02:45:31
      My neighborhood is an important residential corridor for the Tysons commercial district, and a wider 66 would inhibit pedestrian traffic, delay, and perhaps deprioritize multimodal transportation options in our neighborhood.
    • 02:45:45
      A wider gallows would also serve to encourage vehicular traffic at the expense of pedestrian bus and bike access.
    • 02:45:52
      A beltway is two miles north of Gallows Road.
    • 02:45:55
      It's the proper roadway for high traffic and not gallows.
    • 02:45:59
      VDOT has also had minimal success in reducing noise pollution along interstate routes.
    • 02:46:04
      Hopefully you can appreciate a little of my skepticism that widening 66 will reduce noise pollution in my neighborhood.
    • 02:46:10
      My daughter's local elementary school, Stinwood, is located right next to the I-66 Interstate.
    • 02:46:16
      At this moment, she's taking her annual Standards of Learning test today.
    • 02:46:20
      The school was recently renovated, and I doubt that the noise abatement planning was accounted for in that renovation, especially if the 66 is wider.
    • 02:46:29
      It is certainly not for the proposed flyover lanes, which arise above most sound abatement structures.
    • 02:46:34
      Its fields will also likely be affected by the proposed land annexation, and it's possible the school could lose its green fields, so the gym and blacktop areas are the only areas for resets and PE options available to students.
    • 02:46:47
      So I find it ridiculous that we can require private developers to create green space as part of development efforts, but we cannot do this when we develop roads.
    • 02:46:56
      Southside Park along I-66 is where we enjoy our town, 4th of July fireworks display, and is a part of the affected area.
    • 02:47:05
      I don't believe widening I-66 near Gallows will improve traffic on I-66.
    • 02:47:09
      There's no Metro service beyond Nutley, so as a result, all of that traffic is dumped onto the interstate.
    • 02:47:14
      And I find it ridiculous that it's one of the I-66 proposals that I've heard about would permanently eliminate Metro expansion beyond Vienna.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:47:22
      Sir, that's for your time, sir.
    • 02:47:24
      Thank you very much for coming today.
    • 02:47:26
      Mr. Whitaker.
    • 02:47:27
      Mr. Whitaker.
    • 02:47:28
      Good morning, sir.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 02:47:37
      Good morning.
    • 02:47:39
      My name is Stuart M. Whitaker.
    • 02:47:41
      I'm a financial economist by training, a businessman by experience, and the founder of Transitors.com, which is a transit users group.
    • 02:47:50
      I was delighted with news reports of the analysis of financing alternatives, public versus private, or some combination thereof, announced and presented according to these reports by Secretary Layne here yesterday.
    • 02:48:04
      I agree that it is the responsibility of the Commonwealth to pursue a strategy that is in the best interest of its citizens and
    • 02:48:13
      That the Commonwealth should not automatically choose one financing approach or another.
    • 02:48:19
      I also agree that this is an important matter deserving thorough and transparent review.
    • 02:48:25
      But financing isn't the primary matter at hand.
    • 02:48:27
      It's only a secondary matter.
    • 02:48:30
      The primary matter is how do we pay for what we buy.
    • 02:48:35
      The primary matter is what in fact will we buy.
    • 02:48:40
      We know a lot about transportation.
    • 02:48:42
      Recent research has told us two new things about the role of transportation in our economy.
    • 02:48:48
      First, researchers at the University of Chicago and the University of California at Berkeley have estimated that the quote housing crunch represents more than a one trillion dollar annual drain on our economy and that high quality transit can play an important role in reducing that cost.
    • 02:49:07
      Second, a recent study at Harvard found that commuting time is, quote, the single strongest factor in the odds of escaping poverty.
    • 02:49:16
      The longer an average commute in a given county, the worse the chances of lower income families there moving up the ladder.
    • 02:49:24
      The relationship between transportation and social mobility is stronger than that between social mobility and several other factors like crime, elementary school test scores, and the percentage of two-parent families in a community.
    • 02:49:39
      So while the project financing alternatives, a matter of secondary importance, are being offered for careful examination and scrutiny, the actual project plan, which is of primary importance, has been presented as a fait accompli.
    • 02:49:52
      III, General Lanes, two toll lanes with projected public transit ridership of only 10%.
    • 02:49:59
      The plan is inconsistent with what we have learned from researchers at Chicago, Berkeley, and Harvard, and this approach is in stark contrast to the approach being followed concerning the project financing alternatives.
    • 02:50:13
      I urge the CTB to pursue the same thorough and transparent approach to the I-66 plan as it is pursuing with respect to the I-66 project financing.
    • 02:50:25
      Thank you.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:50:25
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:50:26
      That is all of the speakers that I have signed up.
    • 02:50:31
      Is there anyone else that would like to address the Commonwealth Transportation Board today in the public comment?
    • 02:50:40
      Okay, seeing none, thank you all the speakers who did speak this morning.
    • 02:50:44
      We will make sure that any handout gets to all the CTB members to be read.
    • 02:50:49
      We do very much appreciate your comment.
    • 02:50:52
      So with this, then I'm going to now suspend the formal session and we're going to go back into our workshop session.
    • 02:51:03
      So
    • 02:51:04
      This is the formal suspension of the action workshop and we will now continue calling to session the resumation of the workshop.
    • 02:51:15
      What we're hoping to do is maybe get through this in the next half hour or so.
    • 02:51:21
      We'll see how it goes.
    • 02:51:22
      We do have one session we have to have so we can vote on it in the work session.
    • 02:51:27
      But Mr. Donohue, we'll have you come back up.
    • 02:51:30
      And I think where we left off was the actual scoring of the slides.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:51:34
      Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, just a refresher.
    • 02:51:37
      We had talked about the top 10 projects using the raw score.
    • 02:51:41
      We had talked about the top 10 projects using the relative score, looking at total cost.
    • 02:51:45
      And we are kind of walking through this top ten here where we looked at the HB2 cost, kind of looking at the leveraging.
    • 02:51:52
      And again, just as a reminder, where staff, what we're really recommending to the board is that we not give you just one relative cost, either looking at a relative score, excuse me, looking at just total cost or HB2.
    • 02:52:04
      As we've gone through this pilot exercise, we think both items are of equal importance.
    • 02:52:09
      For the board, because one just kind of tells you overall how cost effective is this project, and the other kind of gives you a sense for whether or not we're able to leverage additional resources when we're considering that project, which is what the HB2 score gives you.
    • 02:52:23
      And one of the things you're kind of highlighting here is this project number three, and I think this is just a really indicative project as the board thinks about the differences between raw score, cost effectiveness, and leverage score.
    • 02:52:34
      This project, on just a raw score basis, is the thirty-third out of thirty-eight.
    • 02:52:40
      So it's in that bottom quartile of projects.
    • 02:52:42
      You look at the relative benefit, it jumps up to ten.
    • 02:52:46
      And so it's kind of in that second, you know, quarter of projects.
    • 02:52:49
      And then when we consider whether or not we're leveraging local dollars, in this instance, local funds are paying for just over half of this project cost.
    • 02:52:56
      And then actually goes up to five.
    • 02:52:58
      And so it's in that top quarter or highest-scoring quarter of projects.
    • 02:53:02
      And so this just really is to demonstrate to you all the importance of looking at the relative cost but also understanding the leveraging of funds that can happen and how that's something we believe is the value for the board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:14
      Mr. Fralin.
    • 02:53:15
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:53:19
      I think we must point out that these scores were relative to the
    • 02:53:28
      were mostly revenue sharing and safety.
    • 02:53:38
      What's the regional money's play into this?
    • 02:53:42
      These scores could drastically change.
    • 02:53:46
      And I understand we've decided to
    • 02:53:50
      Give you both scores, so we punted a little bit on that, but I do think that we need to pay attention to that as we go along because the HB2 score will be subject to a demolition.
    • 02:54:06
      There just will.
    • 02:54:08
      And that's not necessarily a bad thing.
    • 02:54:11
      I mean, that can change a project to whether you build it or not, right?
    • 02:54:14
      Because that's not necessarily a bad thing.
    • 02:54:17
      We need to pay attention to that.
    • 02:54:20
      And so I just wanted to raise that.
    • SPEAKER_27
    • 02:54:26
      Mr. President, just a clarification following up Bill's statement.
    • 02:54:33
      My understanding was the statute does not permit
    • 02:54:37
      The regional taxes from being a part of the analysis.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:54:42
      Is that correct, Nick?
    • 02:54:44
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Garzynski, I think what the statute says is that if the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority or the Hampton Roads Transportation Accountability Commission chooses to fully fund a project using the regional dollars, that project is exempt from being required to be analyzed
    • 02:55:01
      Martin, John M. Martin, John C.
    • 02:55:17
      is equally important and so the first is really understanding what is the total cost benefit of this project because at the end of the day taxpayers in some form are in fact paying that cost all the dollars government has to invest come from taxpayers at different levels of government or through tolls.
    • 02:55:34
      On the other hand here, we also think we want to encourage the co-investment of local dollars, regional dollars, and federal funds under the control of regional entities with the state where we can so that we can leverage more resources into products the state believes is worthwhile to invest in.
    • 02:55:51
      And that's why looking at the House Bill 2 relative cost benefit, we think it's also very important for the state to consider.
    • 02:55:57
      May I follow up on that?
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:55:59
      Just 66, for example.
    • 02:56:01
      How are we going to treat, if we do a PDTA that requires some public subsidy, the total cost and the HB2 cost?
    • 02:56:10
      Because the total cost in that sense is my public subsidy.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:56:14
      Mr. Chairman, so the way we just speaking offhand and you know subject to thinking about this more but just a quick reaction there's there would be two scores one would be the raw score divided by 2.1 billion and the other would be the raw score depending on which procurement option the Commonwealth chooses divided by whatever that remaining public upfront funding is.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:38
      So the PPTA will have to go through House Bill 2 as well?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:56:40
      Uh, the project does, yeah.
    • 02:56:42
      It's got federal, it's got, uh, Governor Martin mentioned it, it needs to be scored.
    • 02:56:47
      Any project that takes statewide, state monies, has to be scored.
    • 02:56:53
      And if it's one dollar on it, it's gotta be scored.
    • SPEAKER_27
    • 02:56:57
      Well, Mr. Chairman, with the emphasis that you've rightfully placed on the process,
    • 02:57:04
      How does HB2 and the analysis of 66 correlate to the process you've created?
    • 02:57:13
      Because it would seem that until we do HB2
    • 02:57:18
      We're assuming that it's going to score well, but until it scores, are your hands tied?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:57:24
      I mean, that's why it was important where I had Director Mitchell and Charlie to give us a project to score.
    • 02:57:31
      I don't mean that to...
    • 02:57:32
      I mean, that was it.
    • 02:57:34
      We could not go down a path until we had a project to score.
    • 02:57:37
      I think we have enough information now to have a project to score in that because we've gone through this process, and I know some of the public got
    • 02:57:47
      The other thing, Mr. Chairman, going back to the slides here is I think you see a greater
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:58:14
      You see all four area types you can recognize when we're looking at the relative benefit either from total cost or HB2 cost both in the top ten as well as in the bottom ten here and so I know again Mr. Whitworth referenced kind of the raw scores and what he said is 100% right about that raw score.
    • 02:58:31
      What we've seen though is a lot of the projects that we evaluate under C and D tended to be a little less costly.
    • 02:58:37
      and some of the projects in the A and B category types, and so that's created a greater mix kind of throughout this 38.
    • 02:58:43
      Again, I can't promise that when we score all the projects this fall and winter, it's going to turn out with, you know, the same kind of mix we happen to have this time, but I do think this shows you that as it's currently structured, staff don't think there's a bias towards any particular area type, but Mr. Rosen, we are going to keep looking at category B there just to make sure that's not true.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:04
      This is more of an observation.
    • 02:59:07
      I'm wondering if it's true that as the revenue sharing
    • 02:59:12
      is going to be phased out or diminished over the next few years.
    • 02:59:17
      Localities, or could localities contribute to a project, and that would, you know, so that allows them to participate.
    • 02:59:25
      So it actually...
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:59:25
      Many localities do.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:27
      So they're able to, you know, so it makes them more competitive than the HP2 process.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:59:31
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Valentine, that was exactly the intent of showing that HP2 cost, because in a way, if they choose to co-invest with the state, they can make at least one of their project scores
    • 02:59:40
      Yes, by virtue of that investment.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:59:42
      It doesn't have to be revenue sharing.
    • 02:59:45
      I mean, if they want to contribute other monies, too.
    • 02:59:47
      So, I think we'll see that mix, but that's exactly right.
    • 02:59:52
      If we can, as Mr. Villasilva, they think we can put 20% of the cost up, and it makes the score better.
    • 03:00:00
      Why wouldn't we want them to do it?
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:00:01
      And, you know, I was just asking for the clarification because there is a concern among some localities that, you know, without revenue sharing, there has not been access to transportation dollars.
    • 03:00:12
      And, in fact, this is another way for them to do it, even as the revenue sharing program goes down.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:00:20
      So, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'm just curious, what does the score have to be for the project to move forward?
    • 03:00:28
      Mr. Malbon, the score has to be whatever the board thinks it needs to be to move forward.
    • 03:00:33
      That's not something as staff I can tell you that the scores are going to be the scores and as the Secretary has pointed out several times, you know, let's go to the lowest scoring project here has a
    • 03:00:45
      Martin, John K. Matney, John M. Martin,
    • 03:01:04
      That's what that score is.
    • 03:01:06
      If you choose to fund the lowest scoring project, and I suspect just as a lot of people commenting today on, you know, products we're considering, I expect if the board funded the lowest scoring project, we'd have a lot of members in other parts of the public, excuse me, show up in other parts of the state and say, I want to know why you did this.
    • 03:01:21
      Your own analysis says this is the lowest scoring project that you could have funded.
    • 03:01:29
      So moving forward, where we are today is we have taken notes of all the kind of remaining issues that the board members have raised.
    • 03:01:37
      You know, some of those key ones are the weighting of congestion and land use in the Category A frameworks.
    • 03:01:42
      We also are going to try and work in reliability into the economic development measure.
    • 03:01:46
      And there are two or three other things that I took notes on yesterday that are on the top of my head now.
    • 03:01:50
      What we would ask of from the members is that
    • 03:01:53
      In the next two, you know, four or five days, please email me with any other remaining issues that you have with this.
    • 03:02:01
      What we're going to do as staff is go back and kind of take those into account and send you a week or so after those five days kind of like the process you'll be asked to vote on in June, take into account these final remaining concerns that we've heard.
    • 03:02:16
      And again,
    • 03:02:17
      As the Chairman stressed, this isn't the end.
    • 03:02:19
      We're going to keep as staff looking at the wording to make sure we can fine tune it.
    • 03:02:23
      We're going to keep testing stuff.
    • 03:02:25
      We're going to figure out ways to try and make sure that you can score these projects faster and do other things.
    • 03:02:30
      It really kind of creates a pivot point for us internally to move from development to implementation.
    • 03:02:36
      which I think is something we need to have so that Commissioner Kilpatrick and Director Mitchell's staff can go out, can work with the local governments, tell them with certainty this is going to be the process, kind of the first round, so that we have projects to analyze and score and local governments really understand what they should be putting in this August and September so that we can score them through the winter.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:00
      And some of the projects that we have defunded, you know, in the plan, those are developed projects that will be scored.
    • 03:03:08
      But that doesn't mean they're the only ones.
    • 03:03:10
      There could be other projects that could be scored, too, so.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:14
      I have one question I've been holding until the end here.
    • 03:03:18
      I think we've reached it.
    • 03:03:20
      Have we changed the policy about the CTB members able to present a project for scoring?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:03:30
      Well, we have not adopted a policy.
    • 03:03:33
      What we recommend is that there would be an opportunity for a CT, you know, whether it's one or two projects a year for the CTB member to make a proposal he'd like to have.
    • 03:03:47
      And if it's five or six, we may take a vote on which one or two we want to put in.
    • 03:03:52
      And there.
    • 03:03:53
      I think we did hear loud and clear, and it gets back to scoring and independence and the whole bit.
    • 03:04:00
      I do think we have to reserve the right if we think there's a project that's just been missed, to reserve the right to put one in.
    • 03:04:08
      I mean, there's a board in that.
    • 03:04:11
      On the other hand, I don't think it should be just, you know, it is us that are putting the projects in.
    • William H. Fralin Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:16
      No, I agree with that.
    • 03:04:17
      I just want to make sure there was no opportunity for that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:22
      Yes, we've put that, we've reserved the right now.
    • 03:04:25
      I don't expect there to be 14 of them put in.
    • 03:04:30
      But I do expect if we think in that way, I think it would be subject to the Board saying, yeah, that's one, we should score.
    • 03:04:36
      I agree.
    • 03:04:37
      Mr. Whitworth.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:04:39
      Will the districts have the capability of
    • 03:04:46
      is stress testing a potential project to the score to know how they might want to format that project.
    • 03:04:59
      In other words, will they have the capacity to know pretty much what a project will score before it's officially presented?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:05:07
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Whitworth, I think what a district will have the ability to do is to understand the aggregate benefits but again the score is relative based on the other projects that get submitted by different localities in that district or other regional entities across the Commonwealth and so they won't be able to say on the congestion score are we going to be closer to a hundred or to zero but they will be able to say
    • 03:05:31
      We think we can reduce this many hours of person delay and increase person throughput by this much.
    • 03:05:36
      The thing that they're not going to know is what are the other potential projects elsewhere in the state that might get submitted.
    • 03:05:42
      So they'll be able to do some analysis, but they won't be able to kind of give it that raw type of score that we see today because they'll need to know every other project in the Commonwealth to be able to do that.
    • F. Dixon Whitworth Jr.Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:05:52
      I was thinking in terms of a decision that has to be made on a local basis.
    • 03:05:59
      We're going to need to put X amount of money into this thing if we want to have a decent score.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:06:04
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Whitworth, I think what they'll be able to do is, you know, the staff will work with them on the crash modification factors and tell them, well, if you actually add this change to your project, that will increase your safety score.
    • 03:06:15
      Or if you, we think right now, the way this is designed, you might be able to more nearly tailor that design, excuse me, you know, this component isn't really necessary, and that can reduce the cost by a million dollars, which will increase your score.
    • 03:06:27
      So I think they can really help them on the projects.
    • 03:06:30
      The thing I want to
    • 03:06:31
      Be clear that I don't think they'll be able to do it with certainty.
    • 03:06:34
      They're not going to be able to tell them exactly what to do with the project or exactly how it's going to score.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:06:38
      But again, as you're talking, as this process goes on and on, the same way VDOT works with the local staff, they'll understand.
    • 03:06:46
      They're already beginning, because we've included a lot of VDOT in this analysis, they're beginning to understand
    • 03:06:53
      How long will it take to score a project?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:07:10
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Malbon, we're going to make it take less time than it took this time when we have more projects the next time.
    • 03:07:17
      It took too long this time, but it was also, you know, we were going through this the first time.
    • 03:07:22
      We found out some of our, you know, questions weren't written narrowly enough, so we got too many wide range of options.
    • 03:07:29
      The pilot testing is really going to help us create a more streamlined scoring process in the future.
    • 03:07:34
      We still have to do some more work on, you know, the GIS tool and some other things.
    • 03:07:39
      It's going to take some time, and it's going to take some staff resources, but we are going to make sure that there's a QAQC process built in.
    • 03:07:48
      We're probably going to try and recommend to you all that we use two to three teams, probably three teams, to score this, which should allow a lot more concurrent work to move forward.
    • 03:07:57
      This time it was literally Chad and four other people who did the bulk of this scoring.
    • 03:08:02
      And I think we need four people or several teams of CHAD and four people doing that scoring for this to be a more efficient process and for us to have the time for QAQC and to allow the locals to see those scores as we move forward.
    • 03:08:16
      So it is a burden, but we're working to make it less of one.
    • 03:08:20
      But at the same time, I think it's very important and it's going to cost some money, but I think it's important that we do this as we look at how to spend the $800 million that's available.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:08:32
      Okay, so we've gotten through what we'll be doing in June is adopting this format that Nick will then move into scoring, and then I'm sure we'll have updates as we've got scoring, but when we haven't, I plan to have a, whether it's an all-day or two-day, whatever, a planning session where we all meet.
    • 03:08:55
      and review the scores that have to give and take back and forth as to how that's working the way it was envisioned.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:09:06
      And Mr. Chairman, real quick before I sit down, I just want to remind you, in addition to Steve Pittard's presentation on the TSDEC recommendations, we do have two individuals who flew in today to talk about the Northern Virginia TDM plan, if we can try and work that.
    • 03:09:17
      I didn't hear that, I can't hear you.
    • 03:09:19
      We have two, I'm sorry, this computer is blocking the microphone.
    • 03:09:22
      In addition to Mr. Pittard's presentation, we do have two individuals who flew in to present to the board today.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:09:27
      Yeah, and I'm sure I was going to get to the, we're going to go through that,
    • 03:09:33
      I want to make sure we were finished up here with House Bill 2.
    • 03:09:38
      So there are two that we have to get through, the tiered capital allocation review, because that's going to be voted on.
    • 03:09:47
      And then we have a group here, as Mr. Donohue pointed out.
    • 03:09:53
      Why don't we entertain, let's have this on the big data.
    • 03:09:57
      Yeah, why don't we do that now?
    • 03:09:58
      And so that way they can go on their way or not hold them up anymore since they flew in directly for this.
    • 03:10:18
      And after that we'll then either take a quick break for lunch or see where Mr. Pittard is, depending on how long this takes.
    • SPEAKER_26
    • 03:10:30
      Morning.
    • 03:10:31
      Secretary Layne and members of the Board, thanks for having us this morning.
    • 03:10:36
      We're delighted to be here, not only because we both have roots in the Commonwealth, Laura was born here and my daughter was born here when I lived here for about 20 years, but because this is a really exciting project.
    • 03:10:49
      I hope you'll be as excited about it once we describe it to you as we are.
    • 03:10:53
      It's really, I think, something that is going to be nationally significant as well as significant to Northern Virginia and the Commonwealth.
    • 03:11:02
      I'm sorry about that.
    • 03:11:24
      First we'll just introduce ourselves and then I'm going to do the beginning part of the presentation.
    • 03:11:28
      Laura will follow up.
    • 03:11:30
      I think we'll get through this in about 15 minutes and have time for questions if that's about right for you.
    • 03:11:36
      So my name is Eric Sundquist.
    • 03:11:38
      I work at the University of...
    • 03:11:39
      Johnson on a project we call the State Smart Transportation Initiative.
    • 03:11:44
      It's about a five-year-old project that engages state DOTs and transportation officials from around the country on a volunteer basis.
    • 03:11:52
      We don't have all 50 states, but we really want the states that are interested in making change, and so we have a self-selected bunch including Virginia.
    • 03:12:00
      This is a little out of date.
    • 03:12:01
      We now have Florida, but we convene folks around best practices and give some technical assistance, and we also have
    • 03:12:09
      Thank you for having us as well.
    • Laura SchewelChief Executive Officer
    • 03:12:17
      I'm Laura Schul.
    • 03:12:18
      I'm the CEO of Streetlight Data.
    • 03:12:19
      We are a big data analytics company that creates data assets to analyze mobility behavior to help policymakers, engineering providers, and all sorts of other actors understand what is happening on a transportation network and implement policy that is better for that deeper understanding.
    • 03:12:36
      So what we do is we pull data from, I think now, 125 million mobile devices across the US.
    • 03:12:43
      As you know, as you're carrying around mobile devices, it's doing a lot of locational things.
    • 03:12:47
      It's pinging GPS to get you directions to where you need to go.
    • 03:12:50
      It's pinging locations so you can look up the nearest restaurant.
    • 03:12:54
      In addition, most new vehicles now have geo-located services within them.
    • 03:12:58
      We are taking that data, we are anonymizing it, we're bringing it together from many different sources, and we're using that to understand
    • 03:13:05
      More deeply than ever was available before what's happening on the ground.
    • 03:13:09
      So the slide you see before you is just a few minutes of data.
    • 03:13:12
      I believe we're in Prince William County.
    • 03:13:14
      Just the raw stuff.
    • 03:13:14
      As you can see, the data from the vehicles is collecting very clearly on the roads.
    • 03:13:19
      You can begin to see the offerings.
    • 03:13:20
      You can begin to see the core patterns of mobility.
    • 03:13:23
      And that's the raw data that we're going to use to create some of the really innovative and powerful metrics that we're going to show you in just a few minutes.
    • SPEAKER_26
    • 03:13:33
      So the project that we're working on now is focused on Northern Virginia.
    • 03:13:38
      I'm going to just give you a brief outline on this and you have sort of a sense of what it is we're talking about and then we'll kind of back up and deal with some of the concepts.
    • 03:13:46
      But we're going to focus on the demand side of the equation.
    • 03:13:52
      We're going to, which for the present purposes is almost anything that isn't a big highway of transit pass-through time.
    • 03:14:00
      So everything else is on the table.
    • 03:14:04
      Following on some of the HB2 conversation, we're going to focus on accessibility.
    • 03:14:09
      So that's trip-making and where people are trying to go, what their origins and destinations are, rather than just speed on a road segment corridor, which is part of accessibility, but only part.
    • 03:14:19
      We're going to focus on personal trip making.
    • 03:14:22
      We could look at commercial vehicles and freight and that sort of thing, but this is really, to focus and have a meaningful project here, we're going to eliminate some of that.
    • 03:14:35
      But one aspect of that is that some transportation planning, my background is in transportation planning, you have these large regional models and you often look at
    • 03:14:46
      Long distance trips and you're trying to facilitate mobility across long distances, but one of the motivating factors here is that every time somebody goes from an origin destination, that's utility for them. That is, you know, they're getting to work or they're getting to the store or whatever. If they go one mile or ten miles or a hundred miles to do that, it's still a trip.
    • 03:15:05
      It's still the same utility.
    • 03:15:07
      And so one of the things that sometimes gets overlooked are those short trips, both the value of them and sometimes the cost of them.
    • 03:15:14
      So I'll explain a little bit more about what I mean in that.
    • 03:15:18
      As Laura alluded to, and her firm is going to be helping us on this, we're going to be using big data-driven analytics that surmount some of the boundaries that we've had in terms of dealing with synthetic models and old-fashioned
    • 03:15:34
      Dyer, collected travel information or no information at all.
    • 03:15:38
      And then we're going to use this data as a really integral part of our outreach.
    • 03:15:43
      So it's going to, there's a lot of people already doing TDM and all kinds of things in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:15:49
      We're going to engage them with this data.
    • 03:15:52
      It's not just going to be a report that plunks out and says, here are the 10 things you should do.
    • 03:15:58
      Now, just the remainder of this, I'm going to take number one here and really talk about TDM and a little bit more about the concepts that we're trying to explore.
    • 03:16:08
      Laura is going to then talk about the data part, and then we'll talk just at the end.
    • 03:16:14
      We don't know exactly what our results are going to be, obviously, but we can sort of generalize about them and then talk a little bit about some of the benefits that are going to come out of this that aren't just about TDM.
    • 03:16:26
      So why the demand side?
    • 03:16:29
      It sounds like from the discussion you guys were having this morning that you were pretty well steeped in this issue, so I'm not going to go on and on about it.
    • 03:16:40
      In our field, we usually deal with supplies.
    • 03:16:43
      You know, more capacity, whether it's whatever mode.
    • 03:16:50
      And now we're moving into managed lanes and so forth that are a form of TDM.
    • 03:16:56
      Basically, supply alone is just a free lunch.
    • 03:16:58
      We don't price it adequately, and the price of these aren't very transparent, and it's like a free buffet.
    • 03:17:04
      You put it all out and it will consume a lot.
    • 03:17:06
      So TDM is a little bit of a way to countervail that.
    • 03:17:12
      So maybe instead of taking, you know, you arrange the buffet so that you don't have to pay for 50 pounds of steak every time somebody shows up.
    • 03:17:22
      Maybe they take some potatoes and some cheese too, as far as, maybe that's a strain analogy, but as far as infrastructure.
    • 03:17:29
      The slide here is from Oregon where they used an analysis coming out of the utility industry where the utility industry in the 90s found that providing negawatts, demand solutions, was cheaper than new power plants and transmission lines in some cases.
    • 03:17:46
      And so it's an attempt to match up the cost of supply.
    • 03:17:51
      You see on the left, you see transit and roadway capacity.
    • 03:17:54
      And on the right, you see bike ped and TDM programs.
    • 03:17:59
      They all score pretty well in terms of meeting people's needs, but in terms of cost-benefit TDM and active transportation, they found we're the low-hanging group.
    • 03:18:10
      So that is one of the reasons that we're focusing on that.
    • 03:18:14
      We can talk more about that, if the question is clear.
    • 03:18:17
      TDM, again, we're using an expansive version of it, not just the sort of traditional TDM programs you might have heard that are based on employees giving out bus passes and things like that, although that is part of it.
    • 03:18:30
      So I'm going to talk briefly about three sort of big bins of TDM.
    • 03:18:34
      Martin, John K. Kasprowicz, John M. Martin, John M. Martin, John M. Martin,
    • 03:18:50
      and discounted bus passes are carpool, parking, bike lockers and that sort of thing.
    • 03:18:56
      Expanding that a little bit, looking at the parking availability pricing, one of the strongest sort of drivers of whether people choose to drive or not is whether parking is free and just how it's allocated.
    • 03:19:09
      The new sharing economy and the availability of a bike or car share or Uber and that sort of thing,
    • 03:19:16
      and land use.
    • 03:19:18
      That opens a huge window, but we don't want to ignore it.
    • 03:19:22
      Land use obviously has a lot to do with how much people need to drive and what loads they take, and so we're going to at least be cognizant of that.
    • 03:19:31
      I don't think it will be a full land use study because we're really focusing on the transportation piece.
    • 03:19:37
      We're not going to ignore it either.
    • 03:19:40
      Connectivity is
    • 03:19:43
      Another issue, and Laura will get at how we're going to look at this, but this is something that I just did off of Google Maps as an example.
    • 03:19:51
      From a house just outside the Beltway to Falls Church High School, which is in this district where, if you were in high school, where you would go, is about a three-mile walk by the network that we have today.
    • 03:20:05
      But it's under a mile if you, as crow flies.
    • 03:20:08
      So we're going to be looking, that has a number of outcomes.
    • 03:20:13
      Obviously, probably you're not going to walk.
    • 03:20:15
      You're going to drive.
    • 03:20:16
      And if you're 14, you're going to have to get somebody to drive.
    • 03:20:19
      And if you're driving at rush hour, because school starts at rush hour, you're going to be on the system at the same time everybody else is trying to get to work.
    • 03:20:27
      And so not only is there a burden on you, but you're burdening the system too.
    • 03:20:30
      And it's not that if we created this pro-flies or something like it that you would necessarily walk, but you might take a bike or you might drive a lot less.
    • 03:20:42
      So, connectivity and the concept of security of trips and where the short trips are going is important in this analysis.
    • 03:20:51
      And finally, first and last mile solutions, it's how easy is it to get to transit or to get to wherever you're going from transit?
    • 03:21:02
      It's a particular case of using sharing that I mentioned before.
    • 03:21:06
      That's often a personalized kind of solution, but that might not be the only thing.
    • 03:21:09
      It might be the available parking, parking ride.
    • 03:21:12
      It might be how's the bike pad network connected to transit and that sort of thing.
    • 03:21:18
      So those aren't the exhaustive list of policies and practices we're going to look at, but they're sort of exemplary in three of the main ones.
    • 03:21:26
      And finally, I'm going to segue to Laura.
    • 03:21:33
      A question about why do this now.
    • 03:21:35
      One I've already alluded to is TDM is tended to not be emphasized in our field as opposed to supply, even though it's cheaper and has a number of benefits.
    • 03:21:46
      The second thing is, which Laura will really go into, is the new methods that we have now and the ability to really think about this in a different way.
    • 03:21:55
      The fan chart or the
    • 03:21:57
      The chart on the left on the slide is repeatedly modeled demand estimates for the nation.
    • 03:22:06
      They're rolled up from states and put together by the federal government.
    • 03:22:10
      You can see year after year we have the same basic slope and estimate.
    • 03:22:14
      The actual demand for highway travel is in the black line.
    • 03:22:19
      So our models are not very accurate.
    • 03:22:22
      And now we have an ability to transcend or augment the models with some empirical data that's very helpful.
    • 03:22:29
      And just looking at this table on the right, that's what North Carolina DOT did.
    • 03:22:33
      They had a bypass project that they were planning.
    • 03:22:36
      And then they went and looked at trip making in the area and found that 50% of the trips were going in and out.
    • 03:22:47
      B. Donta that they were trying to bypass and only 13, 14% were through trips and so the bypass was really not a very good option.
    • 03:22:55
      Very expensive where they chewed up a lot of land and it cost a lot but they backed off.
    • 03:23:00
      So with that I'm going to turn it over to Laura to talk about a little bit more about the data.
    • Laura SchewelChief Executive Officer
    • 03:23:05
      Absolutely.
    • 03:23:06
      So I'm going to talk a bit about the data and then I ran some preliminary analysis to give you three examples within Northern Virginia to help us all get a little more concrete about what it is we're going to be doing.
    • 03:23:16
      So this big data solution is not a robot that tells you what to invest in, and that's very important to get out in front.
    • 03:23:22
      Instead, it is a way to make people who are making decisions, who are communicating with stakeholders, it's a way to make them more effective at what they do.
    • 03:23:30
      It's also not a panopticon or a crystal ball that lets you see perfectly everything that's happening now and in the future.
    • 03:23:36
      It's, again, a very good tool that can drastically increase the speed, the effectiveness, the level of communication by which you
    • 03:23:48
      It's also a very good tool for education and communication, which wasn't the initial reason we started looking at big data solutions for planning, but has been a really great co-benefit.
    • 03:23:59
      Because these visualizations help explain these trends very quickly, very effectively.
    • 03:24:04
      And again, one of the greatest things it can do is speed things up.
    • 03:24:08
      Instead of waiting to find out when problems are happening, we can scan and we will scan all of Northern Virginia to look for particular patterns that lend themselves to cost-effective and community-effective solutions.
    • 03:24:21
      And the last thing, which isn't on the slide, but I know it was discussed earlier today, is we're also doing a special analysis on this, on the income differential in transportation patterns we're going to be measuring.
    • 03:24:31
      So it will allow us to dig into measuring some of the equity implications that, as we've heard, have been historically difficult to get at.
    • 03:24:38
      So a lot of co-benefits on top of the core purpose of this project.
    • 03:24:42
      So, Eric talked about demand solutions, last mile solutions, and connectivity.
    • 03:24:48
      So, I'm going to give you three concrete examples of how we measure each of those.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:24:51
      So, what you're seeing on the map is an analysis on a particular road segment in
    • 03:24:56
      just south of the Beltway, I believe.
    • Laura SchewelChief Executive Officer
    • 03:24:58
      So the little road segment is in yellow on your slide.
    • 03:25:01
      And what I did is I analyzed for traffic in that road segment during congested hours for things that start in that transportation analysis zone up top that says origin, where is it going?
    • 03:25:12
      Simple question, but historically extremely difficult to answer.
    • 03:25:15
      And we see that it's going all over the place, but there's a cluster of trips going to the lower red zone.
    • 03:25:21
      What that tells us is that's a good opportunity for TDM.
    • 03:25:24
      So this pair of transportation analysis zones, it's less than five kilometers or three miles.
    • 03:25:30
      So that means we could look at mitigating congestion in that segment and say, hey, there are a lot of short trips on this.
    • 03:25:36
      That means that a certain set of options might be more feasible than others.
    • 03:25:39
      Maybe this is good for some sort of parallel bike trail.
    • 03:25:42
      Maybe this is great for a circular shuttle that's sort of a quick rotating thing.
    • 03:25:49
      What it may not be good for, you do not want to put a whole new subway system to connect to things that are only five kilometers apart.
    • 03:25:55
      So that's an example of big data helping us be effective in triaging what we can do with our time and our money.
    • 03:26:01
      And it also is good for communicating clearly with the people who would be affected by any policies that we put in.
    • 03:26:07
      So another example, this is the same road segment, but now I looked at trips that started way up in Arlington.
    • 03:26:13
      Where do they go?
    • 03:26:14
      What's interesting is they tend to be going very far away.
    • 03:26:17
      So another segment of congestion on this road segment is not this short distance, it's very long distance.
    • 03:26:23
      No way anybody's going to bite that.
    • 03:26:25
      So instead, if we're looking at mitigating this other chunk of congestion, this says you want to be thinking about buses, you want to be thinking about van pools, you want to be thinking about carpooling incentives, very different set of demand management policies to get at this chunk of the traffic.
    • 03:26:39
      And if you do put in those policies,
    • 03:26:41
      I can give you very good recommendations on where the nodes of those bus or shuttle systems should be.
    • 03:26:46
      If there's a stop up here in this origin zone, the most popular destination will probably be right around here, and that's a great way to make a better bet on the policies or the shuttles or whatever it is that you put in.
    • 03:26:59
      So again, an example of not a robot telling you what to do, but a tool helping you make triaged effective decisions.
    • 03:27:06
      So this is an example of Tysons, where we are right now.
    • 03:27:10
      This map shows for each of the road segments up here, for trips driving on them, are the trips pretty straight?
    • 03:27:18
      Crows flying type trips, or are they very indirect?
    • 03:27:20
      Are they looping around, going out of their way?
    • 03:27:22
      So if the zones are orange, it's a very loopy trip.
    • 03:27:25
      And if it's green or yellow, it's a more straight trip.
    • 03:27:29
      And so what this tells us is it helps us scan for places where we might have some connectivity issues.
    • 03:27:34
      Where not just is it hard to get from place A to place B, but to the people in place A, are they trying to get to that place that's hard to get to?
    • 03:27:42
      So what we see is that people who come into the Tysons Mall take indirect trips, which is not surprising since the mall has a railroad.
    • 03:27:49
      Now this is an example of when you need to apply some local judgment and why this is a tool to enhance local judgment.
    • 03:27:55
      We are not going to build a through road through the mall.
    • 03:27:57
      That is a bad example of a connectivity policy.
    • 03:28:00
      However, if you look at the upper right corner, there's this sort of residential to commercial access road up here that's also orange.
    • 03:28:07
      If we could zoom out of the map, you see that they have a very hard time getting on the highway to get to where they want to go.
    • 03:28:13
      Sometimes they just want to go underneath, but they have to go up and down the highway and through.
    • 03:28:16
      That might be a good opportunity for some extra connectivity dollars or thinking to be put in.
    • 03:28:23
      So my last example is in last mile solutions, as Eric mentioned.
    • 03:28:27
      So I've analyzed the Burke Center Park and Ride in Fairfax, which is a park and ride that we know in Northern Virginia.
    • 03:28:34
      The park and rides are great, but they tend to get full pretty early in the morning.
    • 03:28:37
      So what you may want to do to increase the usage of this transit station is have other ways to get people to the station.
    • 03:28:45
      So then you would want to know, maybe we're going to have a shuttle, maybe we'll have bike lanes, should they be to the north or the south or the east or the west?
    • 03:28:51
      And what this map tells us very clearly is it's an east-west trajectory that you want to focus on, possibly a little more to the east, which is interesting because that means people are sort of moving away from DC to get on transit to go back to DC.
    • 03:29:06
      So you also may want to look at connectivity to the next station in and how the parking affects that.
    • 03:29:12
      So again, this is a tool that helps us target our efforts to enhance usage of this facility and make it more useful for the locals.
    • 03:29:20
      Also, these are reasonably short trips.
    • 03:29:22
      So again, we may be in an opportunity where trails, circular shuttles might be a good option.
    • 03:29:28
      So those are my three examples.
    • 03:29:30
      Eric, do you want to go over briefly the outreach plan?
    • SPEAKER_26
    • 03:29:32
      I think we're running low, so I think the only thing we want to stress here is that there's going to be a lot of it.
    • 03:29:37
      We've already had an initial meeting with some TDM providers and locals, even before we have the notice of receipt, but if you see the slide, we have several check-in points and conversation points built into the project.
    • 03:29:52
      And then this is the last thing.
    • 03:29:54
      We just want to stress that this is not only going to produce the raw material for better TDM in Northern Virginia, but as we've sort of tried to get, is going to help us get better at being thoughtful at looking at trip-making and not just speed on segments.
    • 03:30:14
      It's going to help us look at equity and social questions like that.
    • 03:30:18
      It's going to produce some new visualizations that we can use to
    • 03:30:21
      Get stakeholders that are involved, and I didn't mention this before, but a lot of the material that Laura is getting out of GPS can go back into traditional models, which you still need to figure out what's going to happen when you change a project.
    • 03:30:37
      We still need some projection capacity, but we can improve that and improve performance of those models with some of this empirical data that wasn't available.
    • 03:30:46
      So with that, I think we'll pause and see if there are any questions.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:51
      Thank you for your presentation, Mr. Connors.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 03:30:54
      This is great, Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:30:55
      Thank you.
    • 03:30:56
      Thank you all for the presentation.
    • 03:30:57
      Thank you, Nick.
    • 03:31:00
      When are we going to incorporate this in HB2?
    • 03:31:02
      I'd like to have in my region right now, look at some projects and maybe figure out a way to redesign them.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:31:09
      Well, part of HB2, as it goes, is to look at these types and you get more points.
    • 03:31:18
      It's incentivized to use these types of strategies in the project.
    • 03:31:22
      So I'll let Mr. Donohue expand on that.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 03:31:24
      The numbers we're looking at now, the six-year plan we're looking at now is based on data, old data, that may or may not be valuable, which is driving up the cost of projects and all kinds of things.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:31:38
      So Mr. Chairman, Mr. Connors, I've asked these folks to work with the local representatives as well as some of the VDOT and DRPT staff in this region to have some initial results and analysis available by September, which would still be in the application process if some of the local communities or the regionals want to send in this project.
    • 03:31:59
      I do think we need to do more planning like this, and the reason I really wanted to give Eric and Laura the opportunity to present before you is we couldn't do this just four years ago.
    • 03:32:07
      This type of analysis, when we try to figure out where people are actually going, a long time ago, we had people stand on the side of the road and write down license plates, and then you send them questionnaires and say, at four o'clock on Friday, where were you going?
    • 03:32:19
      And people say, well, I don't know which Friday you were talking about, but I think I was going to the burger joint.
    • 03:32:22
      And, you know, sometimes they were right and sometimes they were wrong.
    • 03:32:25
      Now, when people use Google Maps with all the GPS-enabled things, and this is all anonymous data, just for anyone thinking about the privacy aspects of that, we know exactly when they started traveling, and we know exactly where they went, and we know how long it took them, and we know where it got slowed down.
    • 03:32:40
      And that type of analysis has really only been available, or data, excuse me, has really only been available for the last two or three years, and so this is hopefully the first of several
    • 03:32:49
      efforts we'll be doing in the state level looking at this.
    • 03:32:52
      I do want to stress, as Eric said, again, this isn't going to be a solution for everything.
    • 03:32:55
      We need capacity in a lot of places, but what this is going to help us do is understand where there might be lower cost options to solve some of these problems or to help us augment the capacity that we're putting in place.
    • 03:33:07
      But, Mr. Connors, we will be doing more of this, and this stuff should be available by mid to late September.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:33:17
      All right, thank you very much for your presentation today and hope you have safe travels going through.
    • 03:33:24
      All right, what I'd like to do now is continue with, there's a couple of things that we're just going to make announcements on and then I'm going to get to the tiered capital allocation review.
    • 03:33:34
      Mr., let's see, Mr.,
    • 03:33:40
      Lawson, are you here?
    • 03:33:41
      Yes.
    • 03:33:42
      Yeah.
    • 03:33:43
      Maybe you just come up and you and Mr. Pittard can just direct the board as to where to look for the information in your presentations.
    • 03:33:50
      I think you guys can review it.
    • 03:33:51
      I don't think we need to have an actual presentation, so.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 03:33:55
      Yes, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
    • 03:33:58
      Before you, you have copies, draft copies of the CTF and the VDOT budgets.
    • 03:34:07
      Historically, or I should say over the last four or five years, I have not provided you with a draft budget.
    • 03:34:15
      We've never seen a budget until it was brought to you just before the June meeting.
    • 03:34:21
      What I wanted to do this year was to get you a draft budget
    • 03:34:28
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, for this program that you received in draft form last month to give you an opportunity to see the budget, to see how it's structured, how it's laid out, and what's included.
    • 03:34:38
      And I'll be more than glad to answer any questions you may have as you review it between now and the meeting in June, and you will be provided a formal final copy of the budget at the June meeting for action.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:52
      Right.
    • 03:34:52
      Thank you.
    • 03:34:53
      And so you'll be getting that obviously before then, too, but this gives you a whole month to look at the budget.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:34:58
      And Mr. Fetter, I assume that's the same in DRPT?
    • 03:35:02
      Yeah, the exact same thing.
    • 03:35:03
      Usually y'all are getting this in early June or mid-June, about a week before the board meeting where you're voting on it.
    • 03:35:11
      As John indicated, we thought it'd be a good idea to get it to you sooner so you had more time.
    • 03:35:18
      Since we didn't get to present at the meeting this month, we're both open for questions.
    • 03:35:24
      Either email or give us a phone call.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:27
      Okay, now while you're up there, Mr.
    • 03:35:29
      Chair, why don't you just go on into the tiered capital allocation review because that's going to be voted on in our action session and I want to take us through that.
    • Jennifer MitchellMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:38
      And while Steve's pulling up the presentation, I'd just like to remind everybody what this is about.
    • 03:35:45
      In 2012, there was some legislation that directed DRPT to change the way that we allocate both our operating and our capital funds.
    • 03:35:56
      And so, working with the TSDAC, the Transit Service Delivery and Advisory Committee, of which Mr. Cole is also a member, DRPT came up with a recommended, some new formulas.
    • 03:36:10
      And
    • 03:36:10
      That was then adopted by the CTB in December of 2013, and I know many of you weren't here at the time, but a few of you were.
    • 03:36:17
      There were a lot of concerns raised at the time by various stakeholders who were concerned about disproportionate impacts of that change in the formula, so the CTB directed DRPT to conduct an analysis of
    • 03:36:32
      We've gone through that analysis and that's what Steve is going to be presenting here today.
    • 03:36:44
      So we do need to act on this during the action meeting as well.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:36:48
      And so, Mr. Pittard, I would ask you to go through many of these slides or just what Ms. Mitchell has already said, so I just go through them relatively quickly and get to the heart of the matter for the CTB members to look at, okay?
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:37:02
      Sure, no problem.
    • 03:37:04
      And this first slide,
    • 03:37:06
      Jennifer's really taken care of this.
    • 03:37:08
      It's just the actual wording from the resolution back in December of 2013 where there was some controversy when we made this change to these formulas and so you all asked us to take a look after we implemented it and determined if there was any jurisdictions that suffered a financial loss and if so, should we provide transitional assistance.
    • 03:37:31
      And so that's what we set out to do with the review.
    • 03:37:33
      2015 was the first year of implementing the new process.
    • 03:37:39
      So we wanted to quantify the impact of the change in the funding level and then also the change in that allocation method on each jurisdiction.
    • 03:37:50
      Also, I do think we should make note that we did this work.
    • 03:37:54
      We came up with recommendations.
    • 03:37:56
      It was presented to the TSDAC last month, which is the Transit Service Delivery Advisory Committee, and both Mr. Cole and now Mr. Dyke are on that committee.
    • 03:38:08
      And the committee actually, I'll get to the recommendations at the end, but the committee recommended unanimously our recommendations.
    • 03:38:17
      And I'm going to go through a lot of this pretty quickly at a high level.
    • 03:38:21
      So in doing our review, there were some constant assumptions.
    • 03:38:25
      One of the constant assumptions is we took the 2015 capital program as is.
    • 03:38:30
      We didn't change it.
    • 03:38:31
      We left the federal funding as was allocated in the 2015 Six-Year Program.
    • 03:38:39
      What did change was for WMATA and VRE, we had to allocate their allocations of funding.
    • 03:38:47
      essentially divide that out by the different benefiting jurisdictions.
    • 03:38:54
      And then for the, so we have actually what we did and then we said, okay, what would we have done if we had not made these changes?
    • 03:39:03
      What would have happened?
    • 03:39:04
      And without going into all the detail here, that's essentially what this is.
    • 03:39:08
      It's going back to the prior methodology and saying, without the new money and without changing the methodology, what would have happened?
    • 03:39:19
      And this touches really on what Jennifer had mentioned.
    • 03:39:22
      There was a change.
    • 03:39:24
      We got more funding essentially and part of getting more funding out of HB 2313 back in the 2013 session, part of that was we needed to put some performance around our allocation and some of the tiering over our capital allocation process.
    • 03:39:45
      This, just at a high level, I can go in more detail if you'd like, but this really is the actual formulas.
    • 03:39:55
      The top one here is the old formula, and the bottom is the new methodology that you all adopted back in December of 2013.
    • 03:40:08
      This is the actual summary of the allocations made in 2015 for the Capital Transit Program and it breaks it down by the three different tiers that the board adopted.
    • 03:40:24
      And now finally we get to sort of a breakdown of at a high level the old process if you took the 2015 projects and ran them through that process.
    • 03:40:35
      And at that point there were different tiers and another point was the actual cost of the project that we applied our matching percentage, whether it was the total cost of the project or the non-federal share of the project.
    • 03:40:51
      This slide gives some relative, a range of variation of this
    • 03:40:59
      of the allocation percentages that y'all make towards transit capital projects under both the old methodology and the new methodology.
    • 03:41:08
      And I think the main point I want to make here is on the very bottom line, the main item that has a significant change, it's really the lowest tier of prioritization that y'all set.
    • 03:41:24
      And the other point here is not everybody either puts 80% federal on a project or zero.
    • 03:41:30
      There's a lot of the dollars of the capital program actually have a number somewhere in the middle of federal funding.
    • 03:41:42
      And finally, this slide actually shows the analysis of comparing
    • 03:41:47
      The actual 2015 to the prior methodology using the old level of funding and it shows that everyone did receive more funding.
    • 03:42:00
      All the jurisdictions as well as this is broken down by CTB district.
    • 03:42:07
      This slide just reiterates what I just said and gives a few percentages around that.
    • 03:42:13
      And finally, there are a few other observations that I think are important to note as we move forward.
    • 03:42:20
      First, we just looked at 2015, and within 2015, that's a one-year application period.
    • 03:42:29
      So one grantee may have only applied for vehicles in that year and been
    • 03:42:35
      their capital allocations would have just been in tier one, whereas the year before they may have had no vehicle purchases and all their allocations might have been in tier two and three.
    • 03:42:46
      And the point I'm making there is that would have skewed whether they were perceived to receive a bigger financial gain or a little bit less of a financial gain.
    • 03:43:00
      Also, I think it's important to recognize that this change did have an impact.
    • 03:43:05
      When you change any methodology, it does have some impact, but with the new funding, I think at the end of the day, everyone did receive more money financially.
    • 03:43:21
      Is in any process or methodology change you can always come back later in question and I think that's the final bullet here is really one of the recommendations from the TSDAC was to continue to look at this process and in fact it's in the code that the TSDAC is required every three years to take a look at these allocation procedures.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:43:44
      So the bottom line is you're suggesting keep the same allocation and we'll look at it again in three years.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:43:50
      Second bullet, no transitional assistance is needed and we currently recommend maintaining the current methodology.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 03:43:59
      Okay, questions of Mr. Pittard?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:01
      Mr. Dyke?
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 03:44:02
      Yeah, just one observation.
    • 03:44:03
      I think when the committee met, we also talked about the fact, even though it was referenced here that we're supposed to review this every three years, that we would be continuously monitoring this to see if there were any changes in need for any adjustments which would bring back CTB.
    • Steve PittardChief Financial Officer
    • 03:44:18
      Right.
    • 03:44:18
      And I'll add to that that we put that type of language in the resolution you'll be voting on that there will be a constant review process.
    • Shannon ValentineMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:27
      But no need to bring back its fee unless there's a recommended change.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:44:30
      Yeah, unless they want to recommend a change, you'll bring it to the CTB.
    • 03:44:39
      Okay, everybody, I think Mr. Pittard, thank you very much.
    • 03:44:43
      I think next up we have Ms. Julie Brown, and she's going to talk to us a little bit about primary expansions.
    • 03:44:50
      Yeah, there's Julie.
    • Julie BrownLocal Assistance Assistant Division Administrator
    • 03:45:02
      I do want to provide you an update of our application process this year.
    • 03:45:06
      And I'm just going to really hit the highlights of this, recognizing that we're a little short on time.
    • 03:45:16
      And I'll go to this slide just to explain a proposal we have for you this year.
    • 03:45:20
      This year was a little unusual.
    • 03:45:22
      We had six applications submitted initially with requests for $1.2 million.
    • 03:45:28
      We actually have an allocation of $1.4 million.
    • 03:45:33
      This is in contrast to last year.
    • 03:45:35
      Last year we had $212,000 and we had two applications that were tied.
    • 03:45:40
      So those two counties received $106,000 of their request for $300,000.
    • 03:45:46
      So the first two projects you see listed are the two counties that received a partial allocation last year.
    • 03:45:54
      We are proposing this year, since we do have more money than we have request, that we allow those two counties that were impacted last year to have their request for last year not count against their $300,000 limit for this year.
    • 03:46:09
      That would really only impact one county, and that is Loudoun County.
    • 03:46:14
      Loudoun County, their initial request of $194,000, if we allowed that to count as completing last year's request, they could still make a request for a full $300,000 this year.
    • 03:46:27
      And that would be within our budget, so we are proposing that.
    • 03:46:32
      The other thing I will point out is on our primary extensions.
    • 03:46:36
      This year, we had 101
    • 03:46:39
      We had request of $22.6 million and we had funding of $9.6 million.
    • 03:46:48
      So we are proposing that in addition to using this year's funding that we also use half of the funds available for next year because each of these applications represent payments that are deficient today.
    • 03:47:03
      If we were to use half of next year's allocation, $5.9 million, that would bring the funding available up to $15.5 million and that would ensure that every district does have at least some of their urban deficient pavements paved this year based on the request that we have.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:47:24
      And especially with the passage of 1887 and looking at State of Good Repair, it just made sense to me that we took some of next year's funds and brought them forward because these roads aren't going to get any better over that period of time.
    • 03:47:40
      And the reality is the budget impact, because of the schedule of this work, the budget impact will not be felt until the fiscal year that the money is coming from.
    • 03:47:49
      But again, we thought it was important that they would move forward with these
    • 03:47:53
      Because at the end of the day, our efficient payments are statewide, whether they're on our system or on the local system.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 03:48:03
      General question.
    • 03:48:04
      Understand completely, Mr. Commissioner, what you're saying.
    • 03:48:06
      General question.
    • 03:48:07
      What happens when we get to that fiscal year and you've got half the money for that year available to you then?
    • 03:48:12
      And you've got all these projects that really do need the payments.
    • SPEAKER_29
    • 03:48:16
      These really do need them too.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:48:18
      The reality is you either keep grabbing an additional year forward until we get to the full implementation of the state of good repair funds or just some years will be less than others but again just intuitively to me is the road isn't we have a road