Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 5/14/2014
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   5/14/2014

Attachments
  • Meeting minutes.docx
  • Authorization to update Commonwealth Transportation Board web sites, regulations, guidelines, manuals, policies, and other documents based on Chap.pdf
  • VDOT Infrastructure Protection and Resiliency Enhancements Program (VIPREP) contract award.pdf
  • Delegation of authority to the Commissioner of Highways to enter into a partnership agreement between VDOT and the FHWA for administration of I-81.pdf
  • I-81 Corridor Freight Information System (CFIS) FHWA grant application.pdf
  • Fiscal Years 2014 - 19 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers, March 29 - April 25, 2014.pdf
  • CTB transaction report.pdf
  • Economic Development Access (De-allocation) – Halifax County (Rescinding 11_19_2009 CTB Action) Project 0961-041-722, N501 – Day Par.pdf
  • Letter from Halifax County.pdf
  • 2009 resolution.pdf
  • Confidentiality agreement with Surface Transportation Board for use of Confidential Rail Waybill sample.pdf
  • Designation of secretary to the Commonwealth Transportation Board.pdf
  • CTB direction to Office of Transportation Public Private Partnerships and VDOT.pdf
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning everyone and welcome again to the continuation of the May workshop meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:09
      As we do always and actively stand and say the pledge of allegiance.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:00:17
      I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 00:00:30
      Thank you.
    • 00:00:30
      We'll continue the workshop, as Jason said, we'll go through the main workshop items
    • 00:00:36
      There will be a small break.
    • 00:00:41
      Then we'll open up for public comment right before we start our meeting and the action.
    • 00:00:49
      The first thing, yesterday I know we went through a couple of major projects.
    • 00:00:54
      The intent of this meeting was to bring the CTB board members and other members up to speed as to some of the projects that the CTB has been involved in in the past.
    • 00:01:06
      The next one is a continuation of that, about the precision project.
    • 00:01:10
      As I go through the presentation, this will be the same presentation given that Charlie and I, Mr. Kilpatrick and I, gave to House Appropriations.
    • 00:01:21
      And I thought it would be best for the CTB to have that same level of disclosure.
    • 00:01:30
      And I'll point out by saying that when I became Secretary,
    • 00:01:36
      There were a lot of things I learned that as a CTB member I did not.
    • 00:01:41
      I've made that mission before.
    • 00:01:42
      I'm not suggesting I shouldn't, but I'm consulting that there was a lot level of detail and I believe that as we evolve and the role in this particular part of the CTB to transfer money over, I think that we need a little more involvement.
    • 00:02:02
      So when I finish this, I'm going to give you
    • 00:02:04
      A proposed resolution I'd like us to act on in our workshop session that dives the way for us to be more involved in the P3 or P2 process or those projects that VDOT identifies as hybrids.
    • 00:02:22
      And we'll talk about that a little bit more.
    • 00:02:23
      But I thought I'd go off to the podium.
    • 00:02:24
      It's easier for me to work the slide up here as we go through this.
    • 00:02:28
      Charlie will chime in whenever
    • 00:02:32
      And quite frankly, I really would like, and nothing's off the table.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:41
      Any discussion, anything you want to know, please ask as we go through here.
    • 00:02:45
      So, okay, what do I, how do I, oh, just push this to the right.
    • 00:02:51
      There we go.
    • 00:02:52
      Quickly, just to remind everybody, 460 is a 55-mile road, a proposed new greenfield project between Hampton Roads and the Richmond metropolitan area.
    • 00:03:11
      Primary purpose, actually were three.
    • 00:03:14
      One was economic development of the quarter.
    • 00:03:17
      Two, for helping the trucks and additional traffic out of Hampton Roads in terms of freight going out on trucks.
    • 00:03:29
      And then obviously evacuation of the area would be enhanced with this limited access road.
    • 00:03:37
      That was proposed to be a toll road.
    • 00:03:39
      I think the toll was proposed around seven cents per mile per car and I think it was, what was it Charlie, in about the five dollar range for trucks.
    • 00:03:49
      I think it was in that range per mile for trucks going on the road in that.
    • 00:03:54
      So that was the need and purpose of the road.
    • 00:03:57
      At the time of the contract award, there was a record of decision from Federal Highways, but there was not a permit from the Army Corps of Engineers, which will be key as we discuss where we actually ended up on this particular project.
    • 00:04:16
      Now, before we get started, I thought I'd just let, oh, sorry, yes, Mr. Cole.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:04:24
      Are you sure it's not $5 on the bottom?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:27
      It's not that much, maybe it was, it was, no, it was a little bit more than that, I just can't recall.
    • 00:04:33
      $5 moving, that's $260.
    • 00:04:36
      Oh, no, okay, it must be.
    • 00:04:39
      Something like 7 cents a mile.
    • 00:04:40
      For a car.
    • 00:04:43
      Three times that.
    • 00:04:44
      So about, yeah, that's right.
    • 00:04:45
      I'm sorry.
    • 00:04:45
      That's right.
    • 00:04:46
      It was about five bucks for the, yeah.
    • 00:04:50
      I got confused with the Midtown Tunnel, Mr. Cole.
    • 00:04:54
      You're exactly right.
    • 00:04:55
      That's right.
    • 00:04:56
      So I appreciate that, yes, in that.
    • 00:04:59
      Before we get into the actual details, I'd like to let everybody know
    • 00:05:05
      The parties in this transaction.
    • 00:05:08
      This was a P3, public-private partnership transaction, and the sponsoring entity in this particular case was the Virginia Department of Transportation.
    • 00:05:21
      That, as you know, the way the P3 process works, that it is controlled by the executive branch, pretty much, through the secretary's office, but there has to be a sponsoring entity.
    • 00:05:34
      In this particular case, it was VDOT.
    • 00:05:36
      If it would have been a transit project, it would have probably been DRPT in that regard.
    • 00:05:41
      So, but this was a road, it was VDOT.
    • 00:05:45
      Now, VDOT, obviously, every party has fiduciaries, and then there's, obviously, there were the citizens.
    • 00:05:54
      Now, and I've learned since I have been involved as a secretariat that many of our agencies view their role as being fiduciaries from citizens, it manifests itself in the administration.
    • 00:06:10
      The current administration, they are the elected people in there.
    • 00:06:14
      So many times, and as I said, that's the way these agencies look at them representing the taxpayers is by working with the administration in that regard.
    • 00:06:28
      That's key as we go through this particular project.
    • 00:06:34
      There was some risk with the project, certainly environmental risk, and we'll go through how we got there.
    • 00:06:41
      There were some guarantees made by VDOT, primarily one that this could be a toll facility and that will be, or it was warranted it would be a toll facility.
    • 00:06:51
      And of course it had funding risk, state funding risk in that regard.
    • 00:06:55
      So that's VDOT's role in here.
    • 00:06:59
      And it was the primary negotiator with our private partners, which is the next group, 460 Mobility Partners.
    • 00:07:07
      Now, when I say negotiator, the P3 office was heavily involved under the direction of the administration in going through this particular project in that.
    • 00:07:17
      Our 460 Mobility Partners, of course their fiduciary is pretty clear, it's their owners.
    • 00:07:22
      They're in this to make a profit.
    • 00:07:23
      I'm not suggesting that they don't have, everybody want to be corporate citizens, but that is really where their fiduciary main responsibilities lie.
    • 00:07:35
      And in this particular contract, the only risk they really assumed was construction risk.
    • 00:07:41
      And we'll come back to that because the CTB was briefed at one time about the environmental risk.
    • 00:07:48
      And I don't think they were told something inaccurate, but I don't think it was made clear.
    • 00:07:53
      And I'll come back to that regard.
    • 00:07:55
      So those were the two parties.
    • 00:07:57
      This project took well over a couple of years to negotiate and come to fruition, and most of the time it was those two parties.
    • 00:08:07
      But late in the process, a third party entered into it called the 460-A-Quarter Funding Corporation.
    • 00:08:14
      And this entity was set up to fund bonds of approximately between $250 and $300 million to pay for a portion of the project.
    • 00:08:24
      In fact, I was asked, I think John Lawson, the CFO, asked me to serve on that commission.
    • 00:08:30
      And we, along with myself, along with four other people, I think it was four or five other people, businessmen in the corridor, representatives from bonding agencies, were on that board.
    • 00:08:44
      And our primary responsibility and fiduciary was to the bondholders.
    • 00:08:49
      We disclosed to them what the project was, what the risks were with the project, and then went out and tried to issue the bonds.
    • 00:08:58
      In fact, we were successful in that.
    • 00:09:00
      But it's key here that for the bonds to not be an obligation of the Commonwealth of Virginia, it needed an independent board, and it had to act independently, and it had to have a board looking out for the bondholders.
    • 00:09:15
      So not that nobody was, that we still weren't looking out for citizens, but from a legal and a fiduciary standpoint, if there was a conflict between the citizens and the bondholders, we would favor the bondholders, because that was the risk we were taking.
    • 00:09:33
      That was the role we were in.
    • 00:09:36
      Legal counsel drilled that into our heads.
    • 00:09:38
      If not, then we would have, those would have been obligations of the Commonwealth of Virginia.
    • 00:09:43
      The risks at 460 Funding Corporation were just a couple toll revenues.
    • 00:09:49
      Once the road was completed and the tolling was in place, the risk of paying those tolls back were going to all be on the bondholders.
    • 00:09:58
      And of course they had the risk that the state would not continue to pay its portion of the road.
    • 00:10:05
      So you had appropriation risk in there.
    • 00:10:08
      So that came in very late, I'd say three or four months or maybe a little before that, but late in the process as the administration was looking for additional funds to fund this road.
    • 00:10:21
      And I'll come back to the process of how we got there.
    • 00:10:25
      But key to point out here, 460 Funding Corporation has no employees.
    • 00:10:30
      And it simply, through agency and through contract law, was relying on VDOT for all the negotiations, all the different things.
    • 00:10:43
      It had no role in that regard.
    • 00:10:45
      So that's who the players are.
    • 00:10:47
      Yes, Charlie.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:49
      I just wanted to reinforce one of the things that you said.
    • 00:10:53
      The PPTA is intended to be a procurement vehicle for leveraging private equity, private resources, risk, and then the like to deliver, make the projects in Virginia.
    • 00:11:09
      But throughout its history, in terms of the projects that have been delivered through VDOT, they have been products that have been determined by the administration and the office
    • 00:11:18
      And if you look at sort of the entire history of PPCA, that's how they are.
    • 00:11:33
      I think it's important that what VDOT does happen as the executive, under the chief executive to deliver the project as a PPPA, if you look at the history of PPPA's, they come and hold
    • 00:11:53
      Sizem, Shakes, and Born, and some of them seem very clear and some of them do not seem very clear in terms of how is risk allocated and how is the EPA the best vehicle.
    • 00:12:05
      But again, throughout the history of these projects, that is how they come to VDOT and VDOT is expected to deliver them.
    • 00:12:13
      In this particular case, the project of great importance to Dr. McDonald and made that clear throughout his administration that this was a project that he wanted to ensure that we deliver to improve the force of his support.
    • 00:12:28
      Again, I think it's important to see that context of how these products go through the PPDA process versus a traditional design build or design bid build process.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:42
      No, that's an important part.
    • 00:12:44
      The PP3 laws do not necessarily follow the state procurement laws in other acquisitions.
    • 00:12:55
      And it is determined, the P3, the way it's worked in Virginia, it has been determined through the executive branch that this project would qualify for a P3.
    • 00:13:06
      There has to be a concession, and we'll get into that.
    • 00:13:09
      And there was some question as to whether or not this actually ended up being a P3, which I'll go to.
    • 00:13:15
      But Charlie's exactly right.
    • 00:13:16
      That initial decision is driven by the executive branch.
    • 00:13:20
      And I should point out here, during the time of this, in all fairness,
    • 00:13:24
      There was no idea that there would be additional funding coming.
    • 00:13:29
      Remember, House Bill 2313 was not on the radar.
    • 00:13:34
      The former Governor McDonald had issued a bonding program to move bonds forward, looking for monies, because before 2313, we all knew it had been 27 years before any new funding came in.
    • 00:13:50
      So I think that's also important to realize that monies were scarce, people were trying to get projects done in that, and this was the top priority of Governor McDonald.
    • 00:14:06
      And I'll go through the history of that, but it was made clear that this was his top transportation priority to deliver in that.
    • 00:14:15
      So, yes, Dixie.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:14:17
      Looking at the three entities, all of which have fiduciary responsibilities, was there ever the issue of conflict having been served on two of those three entities?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:34
      Only on one of those entities.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:38
      You are on the CTB board.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:42
      CTB has no role.
    • 00:14:45
      I wasn't put on, you know, no role in this process.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:14:48
      But the first party was VDOT.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:52
      Yeah.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:14:53
      Of which we oversee.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:55
      We don't oversee from the standpoint of the P3 process.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:00
      Mr. Secretary, there's a
    • 00:15:02
      On contracts greater than $5 million, the signing bill is signed by the bill.
    • 00:15:09
      The CTB approves the contract and then I sign.
    • 00:15:13
      Less than $5 million.
    • 00:15:15
      Between $2 and $5 million, I notify you and I approve the signed contract.
    • 00:15:21
      Below $2 million, I sign the contract and you get a report with really no official action.
    • 00:15:28
      fundamentally, on a P3, the role of the Commonwealth Transportation Board is to place funding on, as you do in the six-year planning process, you either apply funds or you transfer funds to projects.
    • 00:15:43
      But you have no approval of the wording on the P3.
    • 00:15:47
      Now, we bring the major business terms to you.
    • 00:15:51
      That's a requirement of the PPTA.
    • 00:15:54
      We bring the major business terms so that you can hear the business terms.
    • 00:15:58
      But an official approval capacity does not exist under the PPTA, let's say.
    • 00:16:05
      That's a fundamental difference between that and the rest of the contracts that we do.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:12
      So that's the point.
    • 00:16:13
      If we would have been approving the contract, it would have had a conflict.
    • 00:16:17
      But we do not, we do not, CTB under the current laws does not approve the contract.
    • 00:16:23
      It's totally the executive branch.
    • 00:16:26
      But, as we'll go through, there are plenty of conflicts that have arisen.
    • 00:16:30
      Because when things don't work, or don't go as planned, then you have conflicts.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:16:36
      Unless you look at the future,
    • 00:16:37
      So, arrangements.
    • 00:16:41
      Does Council still support that there's no problem having a member from this board serving on one or the other?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:47
      Well, we have that all over the state.
    • 00:16:49
      We have members in the NVTA, the Gary Boats, and the whole...
    • 00:16:54
      When I became Secretary of Transportation, I resigned from the 460 funding because I had a clear conflict.
    • 00:17:04
      A clear conflict because my fiduciary switched from the bondholders to the Commonwealth of Virginia in that clear, clear conflict.
    • 00:17:15
      But that's part of the issue we have here is that the CTB has no
    • 00:17:23
      approval role as it currently stands in the P-3 process.
    • 00:17:27
      Neither does the legislature, which we're going to get into because that's what the problem is, but it totally rests outside of the normal procurement rules and it is vested in the executive branch.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:40
      Mr. Secretary, the 6320 Corporation, which was the 460-quarter funding corporation, has been used before, but it's not something you would regularly see as part of the PPCA.
    • 00:17:55
      So that role is not one we would...
    • 00:17:58
      And as we get into the conflicts, there may in fact lie one in terms of the
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:25
      of representation of how the monies flow, but I'll get to that in that.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:18:30
      I think Mr. Garczynski was there.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:35
      I am, yes.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:18:37
      Yes.
    • 00:18:38
      Our level at CTB, we did certainly have the opportunity to review the business side of the deal, but the risk assumption of environmental versus construction is something I don't recall us ever getting into at CTB.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:53
      Yeah, that is correct, and I'll go through that because, in fact, the exact words were the contractor had the responsibility for the permit.
    • 00:19:02
      It had the responsibility for the permit, but it did not have the risk of the permit.
    • 00:19:07
      And in a P3, you would assume that the risk is transferred, so that's one of the issues.
    • 00:19:13
      And I'm saying that was intentionally meant to mislead, but, you know, I think if you'd asked all the board members, we thought the risk of the permit was with the contractor.
    • 00:19:23
      And as it turned out, it was not.
    • 00:19:25
      So, yeah, Mr. Tonk.
    • 00:19:28
      The board, for 2020 corporations, does everything, but...
    • 00:19:32
      It does.
    • 00:19:34
      Yes, they've already named it.
    • 00:19:36
      Where's Mr. Lawson?
    • 00:19:37
      Has their new chair been named?
    • 00:19:40
      John?
    • 00:19:41
      No.
    • 00:19:42
      So, no, but the board remains in place and it corresponds with the bondholders and letting them know what is going on in the project.
    • 00:19:54
      It's made up, and I don't have the names, I forgot to bring, but it's businessmen and executives up and down the quarter, city managers, I think some of the public officials in there, certainly the bond council, I mean it was a financial board setup.
    • 00:20:17
      to raise debt.
    • 00:20:21
      And Charlie said we may not use it in a P3, but I suspect we will use the 6320 again, because to the extent that you can get that debt and a risk passed off on to others when there's a revenue source to be paid for in the risk, I think that's a very viable thing for us to consider in that.
    • 00:20:42
      But, and we'll come to how that came into being as we get there.
    • 00:20:46
      But it does remain in place, and it may at one time be adverse to the Commonwealth of Virginia, depending on what happens with the permitting process that I'll get to.
    • 00:20:59
      It could become adverse, and that was a clear conflict when I became Secretary of Transportation.
    • 00:21:08
      And in fact, you know,
    • 00:21:12
      led a lot to us getting to where we are today because of understanding where we were on the other side.
    • 00:21:20
      Now, 460 Funding Corporation, before I believe it, in terms of the permit, we had no idea if we were going to get a permit.
    • 00:21:30
      So it was disclosed to all the bondholders that we didn't have a permit, we didn't know if we'd get a permit, and no less than four or five times did we disclose to the bondholders
    • 00:21:40
      That there was no guarantee.
    • 00:21:41
      That was a significant risk in this transaction.
    • 00:21:44
      We believe, the VDOT believed we were going to get a permit, but believing and actually having, you know, if you were a bond counsel or, you know, you don't make assumptions, you state the fact.
    • 00:21:56
      The fact is we don't have a permit.
    • 00:21:58
      We don't know if we'll get a permit.
    • 00:22:00
      You proceed at your own risk if, in fact, you decide to fund these bonds.
    • 00:22:05
      And that's the way they were done.
    • 00:22:08
      So those were the parties in the transaction.
    • 00:22:11
      I'll just take you quickly how we got here.
    • 00:22:13
      Early in 2003, the legislature passed legislation requiring VDOT to solicit PPTA proposals at a certain stage in the environmental process on 460.
    • 00:22:25
      It was Delegate McDonald that sponsored this legislation at the time.
    • 00:22:30
      In 2006, a conceptual solicitation was released for the road.
    • 00:22:39
      And in 2008, that procurement was postponed based on input from the offerors that the project was not financially feasible without a large public subsidy.
    • 00:22:49
      So for a couple of years, it was out there, several people were looking at it, and they basically said,
    • 00:22:55
      This cannot be subsidized through tolls.
    • 00:22:58
      It's going to require a significant public contribution.
    • 00:23:03
      In fact, you have to remember these solicitations were being done with the lowest public input.
    • 00:23:10
      So at this time it was zero.
    • 00:23:12
      Public is willing to put up zero.
    • 00:23:14
      Private sector is saying it's not going to happen.
    • 00:23:16
      in that regard.
    • 00:23:17
      So at the end of the Kane administration, the procurement was postponed because of those reasons.
    • 00:23:25
      And then the Governor McDonald's administration come in, and in May of 2010, they actually terminated that original procurement, although it remained a very high priority for the administration.
    • 00:23:43
      And a new procurement was initiated.
    • 00:23:46
      And it changed a little bit because it was structured as a concession project including operation and maintenance again with no public funding program for the project.
    • 00:23:57
      In other words, there was another way given this concession for the private sector to make money through the project for the operations and maintenance.
    • 00:24:07
      And this also allowed the use of the 6320 Corporation as a P3.
    • 00:24:13
      This also allowed that.
    • 00:24:14
      So in May of 2010, the project was re-initiated.
    • 00:24:20
      Now, I was asked as a CT, Mr. Dickson, to get back to your original question.
    • 00:24:28
      The CTB under the P3 Act does have a representative and an independent review council.
    • 00:24:35
      What the independent review panel does is to go out
    • 00:24:38
      Take these, these happened to be solicited offers, they were not unsolicited, they were solicited offers, although I think it was actually under the unsolicited procurement, but they did actually ask for, we actually asked for offers, and the independent review panel was to review the concept
    • 00:24:57
      and did a report back to the CTB and the Secretary, primarily the Secretary, if the project had any, was worthwhile going forward on.
    • 00:25:10
      So I served on an independent review panel.
    • 00:25:13
      I think Mr., the gentleman from Richmond, former CTB member,
    • 00:25:19
      McCarthy.
    • 00:25:20
      Mr. McCarthy served on the review panel along with Metropolitan Representative from Richmond, Hampton Roads, and about, I think it was about 12 people in total.
    • 00:25:31
      And we went through about three months of listing.
    • 00:25:33
      There were three solicitors in this particular project.
    • 00:25:37
      And again, we found that no way this project could be advanced without significant public funding.
    • 00:25:44
      In fact,
    • 00:25:45
      I believe the least amount that was reported was about $800 million is what would be required because they felt like that their bonds could be supported between $250 and $300 million.
    • 00:26:00
      In fact, part of the solicitation was that the private sector would help enhance bringing in some of the financing.
    • 00:26:09
      When it was actually bid, the lowest cost was the net of the financing it brought.
    • 00:26:15
      For instance, if the construction cost was $100, but they could raise $300 in bonds, so the net cost of the Commonwealth was $7, that would have beat out somebody where the construction cost was $9, but they could only raise $1.
    • 00:26:33
      In other words, it wasn't necessarily the lowest construction cost, it was the lowest net public subsidy is the way the procurement went.
    • 00:26:41
      Now fortunately, I think, and Charlie can verify, the construction costs were pretty close.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:46
      And Mr. Secretary, the original pre-teams went out and they brought in their proposals with the IRP.
    • 00:26:56
      To give you sort of a sense on the scale, these were 99 years, a 99-year concession was the original term.
    • 00:27:04
      The public subsidy ranged from, and even at that point it was somewhat speculative, over $800 million to almost a billion and a half dollars.
    • 00:27:17
      And the toll revenues ranging from, or toll rates, excuse me, ranging from 12, 13 cents a mile
    • 00:27:24
      A. Smith Jr., John W. Smith Jr., John K. Matney Jr.,
    • 00:27:40
      Because of the nature of the project and the uncertainty of coal traffic, the brakes were extremely high, public subsidy was growing and growing, and that sort of is the framework of the challenge of pushing significant risks to the product line.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:01
      So based on that, we basically thought the project was dead.
    • 00:28:05
      In other words, could not go forward.
    • 00:28:08
      There was no money, remember, in the Commonwealth, and there was no way the road could be built without a substantial public subsidy.
    • 00:28:18
      Then in 2011, Governor McDonald introduced his bond program, where primarily there were bonds that would have been put in place, and I think it was the Kane administration, or was it before that, Nick?
    • 00:28:31
      The Kane Administration, where it was anticipated that the next several governors would have $3 billion that they could use over a 10-year period, I think, was to move projects forward.
    • 00:28:46
      Governor McDonald got legislative approval to bring up all those bonds, to bring them forward.
    • 00:28:54
      In effect, he gave about three, between Garvey and other bonding, about three billion dollars of bonds could be issued.
    • 00:29:08
      He got legislative approval to do that.
    • 00:29:10
      The thinking was, interest rates were low, competitiveness was great, and we were seeing across the state significant reduction in contracts, so that was a source of funding to bring those forward.
    • 00:29:24
      And of that $3 billion, the Secretary, through the Governor, asked the CTB to put in place, of the $3 billion, $1.4 billion was placed in a holding account to support P-3 projects.
    • 00:29:42
      So about half of what he found, he was going to put on P-3 projects, which made sense.
    • 00:29:47
      These are large projects, needed public subsidy.
    • 00:29:50
      The four projects were 95 hot lanes,
    • 00:29:54
      The Downtown Midtown Tunnel, at that time was Coldfield Expressway, although it was subsequently transferred out and Route 29 was put in its place, and 460 Project.
    • 00:30:08
      Those were the four accounts that was identified that would be supported from this $1.4 billion for P3 projects.
    • 00:30:17
      Again, these did not run through formulas, this was not money coming through the state, totally under the executive control, and put in a holding count.
    • 00:30:29
      Now, when I say, I'm not suggesting it was good or bad, I'm just telling you what happened.
    • 00:30:33
      So I'm not making any value judgments on, you know, there was no monies in the Commonwealth, people were trying to get projects going, it made sense economically to try to move some of these forward.
    • 00:30:46
      Now we got a little bit of money July 2011, the request for detailed proposals is issued.
    • 00:30:52
      They go back to the people who basically said this can't be done and we request the P3 office through the secretariat request detailed proposals.
    • 00:31:03
      And again, the offers indicated additional public funding was needed, and it was at this time that the Virginia Port Authority, and Mr. Fralin I think, I don't know if you were on there at the time or you came after that, was requested to participate in this process and commit up to 250 million dollars in that regard.
    • 00:31:31
      Now, it was during this time also that the idea of the 460 Funding Corporation, because if 250 from the port, 250 from the bonds roughly, it's a billion for a project, okay, now you're down in the $800 or $900 million, which what the subsidy's been saying, and we've got $1.4 billion sitting over there.
    • 00:31:55
      $495 did not take as much money as anticipated.
    • 00:31:59
      The downtown-midtown tunnel, even though we went back and put some on it, did not take as much as anticipated, so coal fills were switched out.
    • 00:32:06
      There was money for the 29 expressway, the 29 bypass at that time was dedicated to it.
    • 00:32:13
      That left this pot of money, so 460 was moved forward.
    • 00:32:18
      I believe at this time it was, and maybe on the next slide, let me come and see if it is,
    • 00:32:25
      No, okay.
    • 00:32:26
      During this time, I'll come back.
    • 00:32:28
      During this time, also, the Army Corps of Engineers expressed a reluctance and thought that this project may have a hard time getting permitted.
    • 00:32:41
      Now, remember it had a record of decision from the Federal Highways, but it did not have a permit from the Army Corps.
    • 00:32:48
      And I will tell you, V, I would say in 95% of the cases that happened,
    • 00:32:53
      that if you have a record of decision, a permit usually follows in that, but in 95% of the cases.
    • 00:33:00
      And that's where we're going to talk about when we should identify high-risk projects, things that are not usual of nature.
    • 00:33:07
      At this time, based on the data that VDOT had, it believed it was between 130 and roughly 200 acres of wetland mitigation, wetlands impacted.
    • 00:33:19
      A large amount, but over 55 miles.
    • 00:33:21
      You look at it, and it may seem reasonable, although it is a large amount.
    • 00:33:26
      And the administration believed that they could either be minimized through construction, it was a design-build road, or mitigated through mitigation.
    • 00:33:37
      And that was what was thought at the time as this project's being developed.
    • 00:33:48
      VDOT was directed to consider all options to advance the project.
    • 00:33:53
      The administration directed VDOT to look at everything.
    • 00:33:56
      How do we move this project forward?
    • 00:33:59
      So in July of 2011, again, another request, we went back out and said, we got a little bit more money, guys.
    • 00:34:08
      How can we, lowest published subsidy, resharpen your pencils?
    • 00:34:13
      And again, the administration of VDOT acknowledged in late of that 2012, there was not a business case that could be made to support this project through the private sector.
    • 00:34:26
      It had to have a major public subsidy.
    • 00:34:32
      And again, I've mentioned this before, that's when the 6320 Corporation comes in,
    • 00:34:37
      The structure was modified under the P-3 guidelines to allow that and so we went out and we were all asked to serve and we went out and raised roughly $250 million in bonding for the project.
    • 00:34:54
      And again, it was disclosed because we had this letter or comments from the Corps, we did not know if we were going to get a permit or not.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:03
      I think it's important this term here, design, build, and finance.
    • 00:35:11
      If you look at the 495 express project, the 95 express, the downtown midtown tunnel, the three total projects, and even public promise, those are design, build, finance, operate, and maintain.
    • 00:35:26
      So they carry a full concession over the term.
    • 00:35:29
      The term lengths are varied, but they carry revenue risks throughout the life of the concession.
    • 00:35:36
      They're responsible for normal O&M as well as what we call maintenance replacement or capital replacement over the term.
    • 00:35:44
      And a 50- or 75-year term is significant ongoing maintenance and maintenance replacement.
    • 00:35:50
      But this project, again, takes that whole operation, maintenance, revenue risk, off.
    • 00:35:58
      And the 6320 Corporation, based on, you'd say, some of that, begins fundamentally different than some of the other major P3 projects that are in place or that are ongoing.
    • 00:36:10
      There's no responsibility to the design, to the contractor, to 460 Mobility.
    • 00:36:17
      That's right.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:36
      So now all the pieces are in place and there was a significant push to execute the contract before the end of 2012.
    • 00:36:45
      I won't get into, there have been lots of different reasons why that was done.
    • 00:36:51
      I will just say that there were extraordinary efforts used to get this contract closed before the end of 2012.
    • 00:37:00
      The Virginia Transportation Infrastructure Bank provided $80 million line of credit that was also used as an enhancement to bondholders if the road was delayed that they would know we would have money to draw on if in fact construction didn't take long.
    • 00:37:18
      We had additional public funds were held for the project.
    • 00:37:21
      Again, the focus was on the lowest possible public subsidy.
    • 00:37:26
      There was a belief that the wetland risk could be addressed, and it was at this time that the CTB was briefed on the major business terms.
    • 00:37:38
      And this is what Mr. Graziencie printed out.
    • 00:37:40
      They were pretty high-level, the terms.
    • 00:37:44
      And I think the one that was most concerning to all of us in that regard, because I will tell you from 460 Fundings Corporation, the only thing we were worried about in the contract, it had no risk.
    • 00:37:58
      I mean, so we were relying on, you know, from our standpoint, we were relying on what was being provided through the administration and VDOT.
    • 00:38:07
      CTB was briefed, and the one thing that I think, looking back, could have been better explained was the comment that the contractor was responsible for the permit.
    • 00:38:19
      Now, all of us assumed that many had contractors.
    • 00:38:23
      Nobody misspoke.
    • 00:38:24
      But in a P3, that's what you do, you transfer risk.
    • 00:38:28
      But that was not the case.
    • 00:38:29
      They were responsible, got paid for it, but if all their best efforts were used and they didn't get the permit, it remained on VDOT.
    • 00:38:40
      And those monies were not reimbursed.
    • 00:38:42
      So there was literally the only risk transferred to the third party once the bonds were issued.
    • 00:38:48
      because was the construction risk in that.
    • 00:38:53
      The Office of Transportation, Public-Private Partnerships, consultants supported and under the direction of the Office of the Secretary, these negotiations came to a head into a contract.
    • 00:39:06
      I keep mentioning this lowest possible public subsidy.
    • 00:39:11
      One way to do that is to front load the contract.
    • 00:39:14
      It's basically allowing the contractor to use monies to finance without coming out of pocket.
    • 00:39:23
      And again, this road was being driven hard, wanted it in place as soon as possible, so that was also a key negotiating strategy was to front-load the contract to get the lowest possible subsidy from the public sector in there.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:42
      Mr. Secretary, this contract, it was designed and focused on the five-year design right-of-way acquisition construction.
    • 00:39:55
      From the time the contract was signed,
    • 00:39:58
      Five years out, traffic had to be moving on this road.
    • 00:40:01
      It's a 55 mile corridor, and there's significant challenges.
    • 00:40:05
      There had been minimal design effort at that point.
    • 00:40:08
      The design was all going to the design team, the winning team.
    • 00:40:14
      So there was a strong focus on, you have to have this road open in five years for significant penalties.
    • 00:40:21
      It would be assessed to the contractor, but they did not deliver the project within that five-year term.
    • 00:40:27
      I will tell you five years seems like a long time.
    • 00:40:30
      So we believe it's a very aggressive schedule to get that amount of work done over that period of time.
    • 00:40:37
      So again, you can see the focus is to what I'll call the finish line, the opening traffic, the contractors developing that manner, again, the strong penalties and incentives to deliver the project in that manner.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:53
      Everything was geared to getting the project done
    • 00:40:57
      as quickly as possible in that.
    • 00:41:01
      Yes, sir?
    • 00:41:02
      Yes, and if I could talk to the contractor would not accept it.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:19
      And again, this was a competitive bid process, head-to-head bidding amongst three bidders.
    • 00:41:26
      The concern of all three of the bidding teams was that there was the chance that a permit would not be issued.
    • 00:41:38
      Now, they were contracted to deliver what we call CBA 1 or CBA 2.
    • 00:41:44
      That was a quarter that they were contracted to deliver.
    • 00:41:48
      If they wandered outside of that corridor, it was at their risk.
    • 00:41:53
      So they had to say this is an order that had been part of the NEPA process and the record decision.
    • 00:41:59
      And they had to carry forward that permit.
    • 00:42:02
      But that was backstop.
    • 00:42:05
      It was essentially 30 months from the time of execution of the contract.
    • 00:42:11
      They think if they're using their best efforts,
    • 00:42:13
      and the firms on the issue, their provisions that allow for either party, it begins at 24 months, then extends out to 30, either party can terminate their contract.
    • 00:42:24
      So again, the ultimate risk was not with the design-build contract.
    • 00:42:31
      They had the responsibility to use their best effort within the select quarter, but if they were unable to receive the permit, that ultimate risk was not, did not resonate with the state.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:42
      And I should add, of course, Mr. Kilpatrick was actually involved.
    • 00:42:47
      I mean, I know from reviewing documents, I mean, just going back through in that regard, but there was communications, and it was made clear during the independent review panel that they were not going to accept that risk.
    • 00:43:01
      You know, quite frankly, that's not really unusual as a developer.
    • 00:43:06
      You can't ever get rid of environmental risk until somebody else goes through the process.
    • 00:43:11
      So, but on the other hand, they were not willing to take that risk in there.
    • 00:43:18
      So now we get to the end of 2012, and the project's in place, contract is negotiated, and you can see it's roughly 900 million from the state, which are GARVEE bonds, 250 from the Port Authority, and 250, 240 million or so in proceeds from the bonds and that.
    • 00:43:35
      So remember this is the design-build road in the summer of the spring of 2013.
    • 00:43:42
      Design work commences.
    • 00:43:44
      Now, that's not unusual for any project.
    • 00:43:47
      You know, about, it's a billion-four.
    • 00:43:50
      We knew
    • 00:43:52
      VDOT knew where most of it was going, but particularly the termini had not been designed.
    • 00:43:58
      For the court to issue a permit, they want to know where it's going, because you know in wetlands, you know, 10 yards one way or the other could make a significant difference.
    • 00:44:05
      So that works begin.
    • 00:44:07
      And a survey and soil borings were taken by the administration, you know, which would have been done to get the specifics of the wetland impact.
    • 00:44:17
      And also the administration orders VDOT to begin opening other work packages.
    • 00:44:22
      Mobilization, all those other things that are necessary to get this road constructed.
    • 00:44:29
      Now again, they were also negotiated because the lowest public subsidy is getting money to contractors.
    • 00:44:34
      So the administration is given the go, VDOT starts opening up these work packages, an office is open, mobilization efforts begin, contractors are being lined up, in addition to the design work being done on the road.
    • 00:44:48
      In September of 2013, and also I should mention, pushing the contractor to get the permit in as soon as possible.
    • 00:44:58
      In other words, the actual work was done in September, but per contract it could have taken longer, but a big push to get the permit in as soon as possible.
    • 00:45:08
      Well, when they do the soil borings and everything in September of 2013, it's now determined that no longer is it 100 acres or so, it's almost 500 acres of wetland impact in that.
    • 00:45:23
      And it's at this time the Army Corps of Engineers says, OK, guys, we're not going to go forward without additional environmental review being done in that regard.
    • 00:45:34
      Clearly, risk is elevating here.
    • 00:45:37
      I don't think there's any way you could put it.
    • 00:45:39
      Clearly, risk is elevating.
    • 00:45:41
      Just so you know, this would have been, at that level, the largest impact in the state of Virginia since the Clean Water Act went in in 1972.
    • 00:45:52
      And remember, King William Reservoir, the city of Newport News wanted to put in, the court actually issued a permit for 400 acres of wetland to be mitigated and a federal judge ruled it illegal.
    • 00:46:05
      So clearly, risk is rising in this.
    • 00:46:08
      But, yes.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:11
      You made the comment earlier about 95% of our projects go through whether it's a design-build, design-bid-build, or other.
    • 00:46:20
      We go through what's called MECLA.
    • 00:46:22
      That's the process that ultimately culminates in a record decision or a fondue of some other document.
    • 00:46:30
      This was not a 95% project.
    • 00:46:33
      This resided in that 5% area.
    • 00:46:36
      As Mr. Secretary commented, this was the largest permit application that we're aware of in Virginia.
    • 00:46:45
      It's clearly the largest highway permit application in Virginia.
    • 00:46:50
      And there's not, frankly, a lot of what's called case history nationally on this size of product.
    • 00:46:57
      Frankly, there aren't that many greenfield products being built in the United States to begin with, especially in coastal areas that have the potential for this great impact.
    • 00:47:08
      And the Corps of Engineers, again, it wasn't that the Corps of Engineers all of a sudden showed up.
    • 00:47:15
      They had worked with us throughout the process
    • 00:47:19
      traditionally when a record decision is issued by the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 00:47:25
      Another federal agency, the Corps of Engineers, accepts that record and decision as part of their permit process.
    • 00:47:32
      I'll call it in the 95%.
    • 00:47:34
      But again, this was not that case.
    • 00:47:37
      The Corps of Engineers is concerned that the level of detail that they needed to issue a permit, a weapon permit, would require an additional, either additional environmental document or a separate environmental document.
    • 00:47:51
      That's something that's important to recognize, where four engineers had said, we're not sure you have enough, given us enough information in your environmental document.
    • 00:48:03
      In 2013, a lot of this work that was going on was providing the Corps additional information about, we went out and resurveyed the existing alignment and did additional environmental work as part of this to provide additional information.
    • 00:48:21
      But in the end, in September, the colonel who is the responsible charge of the Corps of Engineers, the district commander,
    • 00:48:30
      said, we need an official environmental document focused on this that looks at the alternative, which in this case was a supplemental, an SDIS, a supplemental environmental impact stator study.
    • 00:48:47
      Now, whether or not you believe that's federal overreach or you believe it is just the right workings of the Corps,
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:17
      It's still risk.
    • 00:49:19
      It's still risk in the project.
    • 00:49:21
      And yet, at that time, the administration gave VDOT to, they wanted them to start buying right away.
    • 00:49:27
      They told them to go out and buy right away and move dirt as quickly as they possibly could.
    • 00:49:34
      VDOT did not do that.
    • 00:49:36
      VDOT hired consultants, went out and said, let's get consultants to make sure that, you know, this is, you know, something that makes sense.
    • 00:49:43
      So the consultants are hired,
    • 00:49:45
      And one of them happened to be from the Army Corps, former Army Corps of Engineers, who actually wrote the wetlands language, and basically reported back, no, this is not, we don't consider this overreach, this is well within the Corps' limits, as Charlie has mentioned, and that we need to do additional work.
    • 00:50:05
      So, the administration basically said, okay, we'll do that, but prove to them that this road is still the least impacted.
    • 00:50:15
      We want you to limit the scope of the work that says, say, that it's going to prove that this is the least impactful road, to which the Army Corps did not agree to.
    • 00:50:27
      But in December of 2013, VDOT, the Army Corps of Engineers, Federal Highways, and the GOAT, what Charlie mentioned, a supplemental environmental impact statement.
    • 00:50:39
      And that SCIS work began.
    • 00:50:42
      Now, two things happened when that was done.
    • 00:50:45
      Number one, you open up the record of decision.
    • 00:50:48
      And our contract for this road was only on for CBDA 1.
    • 00:50:54
      In other words, the contractor by contract couldn't work on anything but this one particular right-of-way.
    • 00:51:02
      Yet the administration kept telling VDOT, keep paying, push the road forward.
    • 00:51:08
      It also meant that it was going to be a year before you got a record of decision.
    • 00:51:13
      The process was going to take a year.
    • 00:51:15
      before we would know which of the alternatives that are being considered.
    • 00:51:20
      In fact, we're finally just now reaching what those really are and getting down to it.
    • 00:51:25
      I can report that VDOT and the Army Corps are working hand in hand, and we do believe we'll have a permit.
    • 00:51:33
      It may not be on this road, but it'll probably be in September we'll have a better indication of where we're going.
    • 00:51:40
      But we knew that we didn't know where we were going to be for at least a year, yet the decision was kept moving forward.
    • 00:51:50
      And so that's when we came into office, when Governor McCaul came into office, I resigned from the 460 Funding Corporation, got with VDOT, got into the details, found out, and that's when we suspended work
    • 00:52:04
      We first limited the work only on the permit to determine if this could be mitigated.
    • 00:52:11
      Could we really mitigate this?
    • 00:52:13
      And after a couple months, it was determined that could not be done, and that's why the decision was to suspend the work on the project.
    • 00:52:21
      We've got roughly $300 million, $290 million spent on the project, about $240 million to the contractor that has gone out the door.
    • 00:52:31
      Even if we had kept paying, we would not have been in a position to proceed until later because the contract called for escalating payments.
    • 00:52:39
      They continued to go from like $20 million a month.
    • 00:52:42
      And to VDOT's credit, they didn't pay that much.
    • 00:52:45
      They were saying, you know, they checked everything through it, but it called for escalating payments up to $35 million a month based on getting this lowest public subsidy, getting money to them.
    • 00:52:58
      So that's when in March we finally suspended it, came to the board, took that action with the governor.
    • 00:53:05
      We have now negotiated until September 11th of this year a standstill with our 460 corporate mobility partners.
    • 00:53:14
      Let me point out that they have done nothing wrong.
    • 00:53:18
      They have done exactly what the contract says.
    • 00:53:21
      They have done exactly what I would have done if I were them.
    • 00:53:23
      The contract says, pay me, pay me.
    • 00:53:25
      And so nothing they have done is not what we didn't negotiate, but they have agreed to stand still until September.
    • 00:53:36
      They said they'd like to be a part of the solution.
    • 00:53:39
      These are very broad numbers, but of the roughly 300 million we spent, 100 million we would have spent anyway to get to the level of design and permit work that was needed.
    • 00:53:51
      Now I'm rounding off, but if you look at the details,
    • 00:53:53
      We just had to spend $100 million to get there anyway to even know if we had a project.
    • 00:53:59
      The other $200 million where we're mobilizing and all that, that can be, you know, is fair for criticism.
    • 00:54:06
      Although it was part of this negotiation to get the contractor monies up front.
    • 00:54:11
      So, I mean, it's not a separate, but anyway, that push to get the road, that's where we find ourselves with this amount of money out of pocket without a permit.
    • 00:54:21
      And there is no, from a public taxpayer standpoint, there is no good explanation as to why we're here.
    • 00:54:28
      There's no good explanation.
    • 00:54:30
      This was not a road that had, you know, roughly 10,000 cars a day.
    • 00:54:35
      It was not, yes, the purpose and need is great, but it was not a bridge falling down.
    • 00:54:41
      It was not the downtown midtown.
    • 00:54:43
      There really was no business need to drive this so hard.
    • 00:54:48
      I mean, there was no risk.
    • 00:54:49
      Mr. Krasinski?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:54:52
      The big issue on me is that while we're delayed and rightfully so to make sure we're doing the right thing, the courts of Savannah, Charleston, Baltimore are still our competitors in the global market once the Panama Canal
    • 00:55:13
      expands and big boats start coming up the East Coast.
    • 00:55:17
      That's still out there, and the 160 is the health rate situation to get it to 95, and it continues to get delayed beyond this point.
    • 00:55:28
      The Commonwealth falls behind those other areas on the East Coast.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:35
      The Army Corps of Engineers, I've met Percy with the Colonel several times, they agree on the purpose and need.
    • 00:55:41
      They agree that we need to do this.
    • 00:55:44
      What they disagree on is that the alignment that was picked was the least impactful.
    • 00:55:48
      So, I believe we'll get a permit.
    • 00:55:52
      And I believe, looking back, it's easy, you know, a different tack.
    • 00:55:56
      We may have a permit now had we chosen a different tack as to work with the court.
    • 00:56:00
      You know, that's all supposition, but it's easy to say.
    • 00:56:02
      But you're right.
    • 00:56:03
      The colonel has said, I understand the purpose and need.
    • 00:56:07
      He made one telling comment.
    • 00:56:09
      He did say, you know, there's a reason why the road is where it is to begin with, because there's a lot of wetlands in that area.
    • 00:56:15
      Now, I'm not suggesting that what we're doing, but I do believe that we will get a permit.
    • 00:56:22
      Once we know what the permit will be, then we'll set down and VDOT will make a recommendation to the governor as to how to proceed.
    • 00:56:32
      I don't know if it will be a cold one.
    • 00:56:34
      And that's where the conflict, Mr. Whitworth, may come into conflict with 460 Funding Corporation.
    • 00:56:39
      Because even though they took the risk of the bonds, one of the warranties was this was going to be a toll facility.
    • 00:56:47
      So there's a lot of things we'll need to take a look at once we know from the state's perspective what the permit is.
    • 00:56:54
      It may be in our best interest to cancel the contract.
    • 00:56:58
      I mean, it may be.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:57:05
      I think it's important to remember that congested traffic counts is not the only thing that needs to be prioritized.
    • 00:57:17
      I think when we say that we don't miss this case, which I'm not sure that's accurate, I think there is certainly an economic development piece of it.
    • 00:57:26
      I don't think that was entered into lightly.
    • 00:57:29
      I think that the fact that they're contributing
    • 00:57:34
      means that they believe the road is important.
    • 00:57:39
      To your comment, one of the reasons this is important is not purchasing transportation and food.
    • 00:57:44
      One of the reasons that Savannah has done such a good job in growing the report in the last 20 years is they've got a unique distribution system set up with warehouses and lots of inland infrastructure.
    • 00:57:57
      In the top of our area, it's very difficult to replicate because the immediate incentive
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:29
      I believe that all the things that Mr. Zinske and Mr. Fralin have mentioned are still intact, so does the court.
    • 00:59:38
      All I was suggesting is knowing what we know now, we didn't need to take this level of risk
    • 00:59:45
      In terms of pushing it so hard because those things are all there, but we're basically going to be in the same position we'd be anyway.
    • 00:59:52
      So no, listen, in fact, a lot of people can't differentiate my comments between the need for the project and the actual contract by the risk we've taken.
    • 01:00:05
      And plus, I fully admit that we're looking with hindsight.
    • 01:00:09
      But I think also that, look, I was a developer.
    • 01:00:14
      I'm pretty aggressive.
    • 01:00:16
      And I think there's nothing wrong with being aggressive with our Army Corps if we think we're right.
    • 01:00:21
      The problem is when you have $200 million out the door to a contractor that you can't get back, that's a fair criticism.
    • 01:00:28
      It's a fair criticism.
    • 01:00:29
      But please, I agree 100% with that.
    • 01:00:32
      So, yeah.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:00:33
      Mr. Casper.
    • 01:00:35
      How are they shared between various funding sources?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:38
      They are roughly as $100 million from the bondholders.
    • 01:00:42
      And then of that difference, $40 million was internally spent, and I'm rounding off, with VDOT, and the rest was paid Garvey bonds, I think, when it's supported by Garvey bonds, yes, by Garvey bonds.
    • 01:00:58
      No, the Port hasn't participated, and that's a question asked.
    • 01:01:02
      We'll see where we get to once we have a permit, but they have not.
    • 01:01:07
      And there was no need for them to participate, right, as of yet, because the project is not to the point.
    • 01:01:14
      We did it one time, Hope.
    • 01:01:16
      I know that Mr. Kilpatrick had hoped we could get a front end from the Port, but I don't think that's going to materialize in that regard.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:01:28
      Yeah, that's right.
    • 01:01:46
      No, don't start at the 95 because the quicker we can utilize that England, there's lots of land that we opened up for English distribution.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:03
      The section, the easternmost piece, is the area in front of the flood.
    • 01:02:09
      Out for the first 15 to 20 miles, especially in the area of the Blackwater River, an area called Nydore, we've had significant flooding for extended periods.
    • 01:02:20
      The Blackwater River is one of these tidal bunnies.
    • 01:02:23
      The tidal river is just
    • 01:02:26
      From this point in time, what is the involvement or demands on the CTB?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:56
      Well, where we are today, very little.
    • 01:03:02
      And although I'm going to have a resolution that maybe it should be more than that.
    • 01:03:07
      Back to Mr. Fralin's point, I would suggest, since we have a contract on this road that we are obligated on, that the monies that are allocated for this project remain in place until we know what the answer is.
    • 01:03:22
      We have an obligation as of right now.
    • 01:03:25
      And then,
    • 01:03:26
      Well, the CTB will come in if more monies are needed or if there are additional changes, the CTB would have to allocate that.
    • 01:03:35
      So that is where on the current law the next step for the CTB.
    • 01:03:41
      Now, let me finish this real quickly.
    • 01:03:44
      We'll go through the SEIS.
    • 01:03:46
      We hope by the end of the year we have the permit.
    • 01:03:49
      And we think by September that we will know where we're headed, what's going to be the proposed alignment.
    • 01:03:55
      And in fact, I've got a map up there.
    • 01:03:57
      You can't see it, but there's four, four different alignments or some combination thereof could happen, some combination thereof.
    • 01:04:05
      And that's what we're working hard with the Army Corps on.
    • 01:04:09
      And again, I'll reiterate, the colonel has said he believes there's a permittable project there, and he believes in the purpose and need.
    • 01:04:17
      So that.
    • 01:04:18
      Now, there will be outreach to the community.
    • 01:04:21
      We'll just go through this, wrap it up, and come back to where Mr. Zinske is.
    • 01:04:26
      And we hope that by the end of the year, we know where we are.
    • 01:04:29
      I went through the design.
    • 01:04:32
      Mr. Scott asked about the financial status.
    • 01:04:36
      This is where we are on the road today.
    • 01:04:38
      What has been spent for what, and I gave you round numbers of exactly how things have gone, but that's where it is today.
    • 01:04:47
      Look, if in fact we do not get a permit, I think that's highly unlikely, but it's a possibility, a possibility, not a high probability.
    • 01:04:56
      Look, then this money's lost.
    • 01:04:59
      Depending on the alignment and our ability to negotiate with the contractor, hopefully a lot of the money we've spent we can make good.
    • 01:05:06
      And that'll be a question as to whether or not, from this point forward, if it's a different alignment, we'll have to come to grips with, is it a different procurement?
    • 01:05:16
      You know, that's one thing that'll have to be looked at.
    • 01:05:19
      I would argue vehemently that the only way we're going to make our money good is to work with this contract.
    • 01:05:25
      in that regard.
    • 01:05:26
      So I would say right off the bat, he's got a pretty good shot at being the lowest cost since he's already got a bunch of our money in going forward from here.
    • 01:05:34
      But that'll be looked at and can't give you that until we know what's actually permitted and we know what the road will cost.
    • 01:05:42
      So where we are today is back to what, you know, again, significant support of the project.
    • 01:05:48
      The governor supports the purpose and need of the project.
    • 01:05:52
      He has said he gets it.
    • 01:05:53
      So we'll wait to see with what we get and all those things that people have mentioned are a very big part of why this project is needed.
    • 01:06:05
      And let's see here.
    • 01:06:08
      Let me just make sure I've gone through everything.
    • 01:06:10
      We've gone through all that.
    • 01:06:13
      Okay.
    • 01:06:14
      This brings me to where I want to talk with you about today as to what I'd like you to consider in our next action item.
    • 01:06:23
      I think Carol has a resolution that she'd like to pass around.
    • 01:06:27
      And this gets right to Mr. Brzezinski's point of what is our role.
    • 01:06:33
      Done a couple of things in terms of the P3 process.
    • 01:06:37
      And I will say that looking back, and I think, Mr. Kilpatrick, we've had many discussions, this really ended up not being a P3.
    • 01:06:45
      It was a design-build road with a financing portion of it.
    • 01:06:47
      But nonetheless, we are where we are.
    • 01:06:50
      But there has been new leadership in the Office of Transportation and Public-Private Partnerships.
    • 01:06:55
      Doug Coulomay is in charge over there now.
    • 01:06:59
      And they are revising their guidelines with the following in mind, to enhance transparency, increase competition, and to get advice and notice from the CTB and the General Assembly.
    • 01:07:11
      Now, that's what this resolution you have in front of you is, is I would like the CTB to direct the P3 office and working with the P3 office to come up with these guidelines.
    • 01:07:23
      I believe there's a way that we can get the involvement of the CTB and not lose anything in the P3 process in terms of working with our private partners.
    • 01:07:37
      In fact, I've met with many of them, and in fact, they think the more defined the project, in other words, it's a procurement method.
    • 01:07:44
      Somebody started that right up front saying it's a procurement method.
    • 01:07:48
      We should have defined those projects that this adheres to and then go out and get them bid.
    • 01:07:54
      So I think a lot of this will be solved in what we call as a P3.
    • 01:07:58
      But this resolution asks you to direct Doug Coulomay to work with him in coming up with these revised guidelines.
    • 01:08:07
      And in addition to that, it goes on to talk about VDOT and looking at its wetland delineation process, but basically through what we consider high-risk projects.
    • 01:08:18
      You go back and look at this right now and all the signs were there.
    • 01:08:24
      This was a high-risk project.
    • 01:08:26
      Now, I mean, it really is.
    • 01:08:28
      So, I don't care what procurement method we were under, when you really get down to it, the real issue that was discounted here was the environmental risk, getting the permit.
    • 01:08:40
      All the other stuff, you know, gets headlines and the P3 we can talk about, but the real substance of this
    • 01:08:47
      is that there was a discounting, maybe for all the right reasons, but a discounting of the risk associated with this environment.
    • 01:08:54
      So we've got to identify when we have projects, whether it's P3 or design-build or anything else, that's a high-risk project.
    • 01:09:02
      We may decide to continue going forward on it, but it ought to be a decision that is made with the eyes wide open.
    • 01:09:08
      Not putting things out the door.
    • 01:09:10
      So that's what this resolution asks you to consider.
    • 01:09:15
      Mr. Fralin mentioned the prioritization process.
    • 01:09:18
      That ties into this, too.
    • 01:09:20
      Hopefully, we'll identify high-risk projects during the prioritization process.
    • 01:09:24
      But these have got to be tied together.
    • 01:09:27
      And so that's what this resolution I'm asking you to consider this afternoon when we go into the formal session is to consider this and work with the P3 office
    • 01:09:38
      to come up with these guidelines that involve the CTB.
    • 01:09:42
      I believe if we had found a way to involve the CTB, I don't believe we'd be where we are today.
    • 01:09:49
      I just think there's too much knowledge around this table that I had when I was in private practice before I signed the contract, I had a guy in my organization, his only job was to read contracts and tell me why I shouldn't sign.
    • 01:10:03
      Now, if I'd have listened to him, I'd have never signed a contract because he saw a ghost behind every tree.
    • 01:10:09
      But there were three or four times where I am so glad that he did because I hadn't considered something.
    • 01:10:16
      And I think that's what we've got to bring into this process.
    • 01:10:20
      We've got to have a check valve somewhere to say, have you thought about this?
    • 01:10:25
      You know, have you done that?
    • 01:10:26
      And that's what this is, this process is about today.
    • 01:10:30
      I don't, I think there's going to be, there's a lot of different issues related to this.
    • 01:10:35
      There's political, all that.
    • 01:10:38
      Only what I'm concerned about is that we fix it so that we avoid this in the future.
    • 01:10:43
      Mr. Fralin.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:10:45
      I just, I agree with you.
    • 01:10:49
      I've attended this report with the resolution.
    • 01:10:50
      I think
    • 01:10:51
      And I think it's necessary, but I also think that we're one of the few boards in the Commonwealth that actually spends that credit off.
    • 01:11:01
      And even this plan had to be put in six-year plans.
    • 01:11:06
      And we have to go to them.
    • 01:11:07
      We do have control over the outcome, but now it's a true PP3, a PP2A with no public money.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:15
      And we still have some problem with it, but part of that negotiation is that there will not be a competing record.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:11:24
      At some point, we've got to agree to that, because I don't, you know, and so I think there is, while this is necessary, I think, you know, this board is set out to take politics out on transportation decisions to reach them possible.
    • 01:11:42
      Without this board, the General Assembly would make decisions and the General Assembly would let me go to them.
    • 01:11:48
      Now, they're still not going to vote, they're going to be due tomorrow, but it's the responsibility that we have to ask these questions, to look at these projects, and to make sure that they're okay and not just rubber stamp for even the governor or the General Assembly or anybody else.
    • 01:12:03
      And I know that we all take that role really seriously.
    • 01:12:07
      I think what happened in this one was, it evolved, it wasn't, it didn't, the cake didn't look like it ended when it was baked, but it looked like it began.
    • 01:12:23
      So over time, well let's just do this, well then let's just do this, well then maybe we can do this, because the impetus was to get it ready, which is example.
    • 01:12:34
      In the deck, I think you're right, this is no longer looking like a BDTA.
    • 01:12:39
      It looks like a taxpayer dollar supported me.
    • 01:12:44
      The total risk I assume is being borne by the bondholders is not possible.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:48
      No, it will be by the, if the road is built, it will totally be by the bondholders.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:12:54
      Okay, but not the contract.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:56
      Not the contract.
    • 01:12:57
      You're right, the contractor, the only risk he had was to deliver the contract.
    • 01:13:02
      I think you're absolutely right.
    • 01:13:08
      Let me just make one point.
    • 01:13:12
      We had another project where a board member was removed because he didn't vote the way the governor wanted.
    • 01:13:21
      That's a risk of doing this job.
    • 01:13:23
      I think I could not agree more with what William said.
    • 01:13:27
      Now, I'm not saying this governor or any governor, but I'm just saying, you know, that's why I started the conversation, why a lot of agencies, the agencies look at what the will of the taxpayers are in the administration.
    • 01:13:42
      That's just the way it manifests itself.
    • 01:13:45
      But I could not agree with what William said more.
    • 01:13:47
      That is not what the intent of this is, and, you know,
    • 01:13:54
      If that happens, then what you'll get from me is, I think, exactly what we've got here today.
    • 01:14:03
      I want the discussion.
    • 01:14:05
      Now, we may have to go.
    • 01:14:06
      I don't know what the four-year rules are, but if we get into proprietary, we may have to go into closed session.
    • 01:14:11
      I don't know.
    • 01:14:11
      I'm not trying not to be transparent, but if there are proprietary things, because we don't want to lose our private partners, but could not agree more.
    • 01:14:21
      That is really what the role is.
    • 01:14:23
      Four years, five years I served on.
    • 01:14:26
      We didn't have a lot of money.
    • 01:14:27
      There were lots of things that we're trying to get.
    • 01:14:30
      I don't think there was anything nefarious done in this.
    • 01:14:33
      I think it was just a strict pushing forward.
    • 01:14:36
      They can look and criticize, but I think that was just what their focus was.
    • 01:14:41
      I think they can question some of the decisions because I think we're pushing forward, but nothing nefarious.
    • 01:14:48
      But we have money now.
    • 01:14:51
      It is upon us to be good stewards of it.
    • 01:14:54
      And as I said here, I don't think anybody would agree we're in the position we want to be in with this particular thing.
    • 01:15:00
      And so I think just getting right on the table, that's the way I am.
    • 01:15:05
      I don't see the board as a necessary nuisance.
    • 01:15:07
      I see it as part of making sure we get the right answer in the Commonwealth.
    • 01:15:13
      So, yes?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:15:14
      How did we choose 100 million to be our level of involvement?
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:24
      Yeah, Charlie, you can talk about that.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:28
      Mr. Secretary, I think that as a starting point, $100 million also fell inside of some other requirements.
    • 01:15:38
      We have a requirement to do a financial plan for any project valued at more than $100 million.
    • 01:15:45
      This isn't to say that we wouldn't have a $2 million bridge replacement project that would take high risk
    • 01:15:53
      Right.
    • 01:15:53
      ...design-bid-build that our folks need to focus to make sure that we are avoiding or minimizing those potential risks on even the smallest product that we have.
    • 01:16:06
      I think that in terms of the scale of what VDOT delivers to Virginia, we've delivered over 100 design-build contracts over the years and thousands of design-bid-build and probably a dozen to the 15 PPTA projects that we've been presenting.
    • 01:16:23
      The design-bid bill and the design-build project really are bread and butter.
    • 01:16:28
      I'm trying to think of a case where we were not able to obtain a permit.
    • 01:16:34
      And in a design-build arena, the contractor is responsible for the permit.
    • 01:16:38
      In a design-bid bill, we're responsible.
    • 01:16:41
      But in both cases, we have pretty solid safeguards in place.
    • 01:16:46
      But again, to this point, the $100 million threshold is a good place to look.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:53
      We're a policy board.
    • 01:16:55
      I want to make that clear.
    • 01:16:56
      We are a policy board.
    • 01:16:59
      And so we're not responsible for operations.
    • 01:17:02
      I mean, I'm not saying that we don't want to be, but we are a policy board.
    • 01:17:07
      So I think while we want to make the help decision, we do not get into delivering projects.
    • 01:17:15
      So I know there's a fine line there, but I will tell you in today's world, $100 million for what VDOT does
    • 01:17:21
      I mean, that's an interchange.
    • 01:17:24
      I mean, so we can look at it as we go along, but I think that's probably a good starting point because, again, we are not a policy.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:17:32
      Yeah.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:32
      Yeah.
    • 01:17:34
      That's right.
    • 01:17:38
      What I'm looking for, I think we're looking for, is when we get out of normal procurement rules, because if this would have been a design building of normal procurement rules, there would have been additional safeguards before VDOT could have opened under task orders.
    • 01:17:51
      I mean, 29 is a great example.
    • 01:17:54
      29 was not under a P3.
    • 01:17:57
      The notice to proceed was not given to the contractor, where it was directed here to be given in that.
    • 01:18:03
      So I think I thought long and hard about this because, look, Mr. Fralin has been on a board where they were criticized for getting too much into operations.
    • 01:18:12
      So we need to not be in delivering projects, but we need to make sure we're being fiscal stewards.
    • 01:18:19
      Now, if we go along and if we find a hundred million doesn't work, well, maybe we can take a look, but I think that's probably a good place to start.
    • 01:18:30
      Now, Mr. Tunkers, thank you.
    • 01:18:41
      Yeah, I was asked that and, of course, it made front headline news.
    • 01:18:44
      If we had to end up just walking away from this project, it's going to be between four and five hundred million dollars because there will be penalties in the contract.
    • 01:18:54
      Now, I don't think it's going to be anywhere near that much because we also have rights under the contract, too.
    • 01:19:00
      And I, you know, didn't go into it.
    • 01:19:01
      I didn't think the contract would do anything wrong.
    • 01:19:03
      But, you know, it's a two-way street.
    • 01:19:05
      We would assess some things also in that regard.
    • 01:19:08
      And if we can't work it out, it will be litigated.
    • 01:19:11
      That's a total wheels-off case.
    • 01:19:13
      I don't think that's the case.
    • 01:19:15
      I really believe if we walked away, we're probably about where we are now.
    • 01:19:19
      But, you know, there'd probably be a lawsuit, and hopefully we're not going to walk away.
    • 01:19:24
      But I didn't want to get out there and, you know, it's a serious issue, and if everything went against the state, we could be out another hundred to couple hundred million dollars.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:19:35
      Oh, it was, okay.
    • 01:19:37
      Mr. Boggs.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:19:38
      The main purpose of us saying this is my first meeting, so I just told you this is some government postcard, but just looking at this and picking up on John's point, because I see this proposed resolution.
    • 01:19:51
      What we're concerned about here is the risk and what we need to be doing in order to make sure that we minimize the risk.
    • 01:19:58
      And with that in mind, I would think that maybe just dropping this
    • 01:20:03
      I'm fine with that.
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:15
      We were just trying to say, you know, but I'm fine with that because as Troy mentioned, I mean if it's a three million dollar project and it's
    • 01:20:32
      You know, we got risk.
    • 01:20:33
      Well, you know, all I'm saying is what we're trying to do is say, look, this is not our normal delivery.
    • 01:20:40
      We've identified significant additional risk here.
    • 01:20:43
      And you've been involved in projects where that's been the case.
    • 01:20:45
      So we want the board to understand, you know, here's what if we don't go forward, here's if we go forward.
    • 01:20:51
      That's that's really what we're asking.
    • 01:20:53
      Heck, we might have come in here and said, here are the risks.
    • 01:20:56
      And we might have said, let's go forward.
    • 01:20:59
      So, I don't know.
    • 01:21:01
      I mean, but that's what the intent is.
    • 01:21:03
      So, taking out a figure spot, as long as we're identifying high-risk projects.
    • 01:21:10
      Right.
    • 01:21:12
      Yeah, so we don't say, well, it wasn't 100 million, I didn't tell you about that 50 million, the whole speed loss.
    • 01:21:17
      I got it.
    • 01:21:18
      No issue with that.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:21
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:21:22
      You mentioned the context under which this was
    • 01:21:28
      move forward.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:29
      I think it's important because it was a time that we kind of didn't have the money to use P3's and Scott's Cleaning County plan.
    • 01:21:37
      I'm familiar with that because we were trying to find a way to build something, to do something about transportation.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:21:44
      Now that we had, we used P3's for quite a bit, you know, the constant P3's.
    • 01:21:49
      But we were pretty much successful.
    • 01:21:53
      Now that we do have P3's,
    • Aubrey L. Layne Jr.Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:55
      No, no, in fact, but there'll be a less emphasis on what really is a P-3.
    • 01:22:07
      We need to identify this project.
    • 01:22:08
      Let me, a couple things.
    • 01:22:10
      The governor, very much, I'm from the private sector, I very much agree in P-3s, but it's not the only answer.
    • 01:22:17
      I mean, we have, we need to use that as what my procurement.
    • 01:22:20
      The other thing I'll point out is, it's very clear to me,
    • 01:22:23
      Because now I've been on the private side and I was peripherally on this.
    • 01:22:29
      Look, the government doesn't assess risk the way the private sector does.
    • 01:22:33
      When the private sector, when I access risk, I'm looking at how much it's going to cost me and when am I getting paid for it.
    • 01:22:40
      The public sector says, well, you know, I'd have that risk anyway and I want to get this thing done.
    • 01:22:46
      I mean, it's a different assessment in that, how it goes.
    • 01:22:50
      And in the P3 process,
    • 01:22:53
      The public ought to be acting just like a business in the P3 process.
    • 01:22:58
      You know, because that's the way, and that's why I put up here competition to the end.
    • 01:23:05
      I will tell you the P3 office will get up here and tell us that these were competitively been all the way to the end.
    • 01:23:12
      And I will tell you that's when it starts.
    • 01:23:14
      Because they know we're not walking away.
    • 01:23:17
      And that's when things get sweet.
    • 01:23:19
      You know, that's the way it works.
    • 01:23:21
      I did it when I was in the private sector.
    • 01:23:23
      Not in this, but I did it with others.
    • 01:23:24
      I mean, that's just the way it works.
    • 01:23:27
      The governor wants this done.
    • 01:23:28
      Fine.
    • 01:23:30
      If you want it done there, here's what I need.
    • 01:23:32
      I'm not suggesting it was bad or wrong.
    • 01:23:35
      I'm just saying we've got to act more like the private sector.
    • 01:23:39
      And I think that's what you'll expect.
    • 01:23:40
      But no, I do not, we're going to have P3 projects.
    • 01:23:45
      I mean, we could not deliver Interstate 66 without a P3 project.
    • 01:23:49
      No way.
    • 01:23:50
      And where it makes sense, where we really transfer risk, if private sector gets paid for that risk, we get delivered, it's good policy.
    • 01:23:59
      But if you took an objective look to this, and this is hindsight, so I, you know, I think William's right, we got there, it started out being a pie and now it's a cake, but the bottom line is, you know, we didn't transfer any risk at the end of the day in their set.
    • 01:24:18
      Okay, well, this is taking, gosh, an hour and a half.
    • 01:24:21
      I'm sorry, but I thought it was important that you guys knew exactly what the legislators heard in that.
    • 01:24:27
      And I would ask that, we'll take a break, but I would ask that we consider this, before you go to the session, consider this resolution.
    • 01:24:37
      I do think we need to get ahead of this issue, and I'd ask your consideration.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:24:42
      Okay, what's next on the agenda?
    • 01:24:44
      Oh, House Bill 2.
    • 01:24:45
      Another easy talk.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:24:56
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 01:24:58
      My name is Nick Donohue.
    • 01:24:59
      I'm the Deputy Secretary of Transportation, and I cannot figure out...
    • 01:25:03
      There we go.
    • 01:25:03
      I don't work at the PowerPoint.
    • 01:25:05
      I'll be talking this morning about House Bill 2, and my presentation is really going to have two separate components.
    • 01:25:11
      One, for the new members of the board, and just to refresh the existing members, I'm going to give an overview of the requirements of House Bill 2, and then I'm going to begin to discuss the implementation process that we're just starting in earnest, internally, to just get some feedback and direction from the board on that as we move forward.
    • 01:25:29
      And Carol, could you, my presentation number seven?
    • 01:25:33
      Thank you.
    • 01:25:36
      So one of the things I would say about House Bill 2 before we get in this is in 2013, the legislature did a very important thing with regards to raising revenues.
    • 01:25:45
      For the first time in several decades, we updated the funding mechanisms and scheme for funding the transportation program in Virginia.
    • 01:25:53
      However, one of the things that piece of legislation didn't really do on a statewide basis was update the administration.
    • 01:25:59
      of this program.
    • 01:26:01
      So we got a significant infusion of new revenues that breathe new life into our transportation program here in Virginia, but we didn't take essentially kind of the next step, which was taking a really hard look at how are we spending these new monies we have and does the process by which we do it currently get the best results for the Commonwealth.
    • 01:26:20
      And so to that end, one of the major priorities of the McAuliffe administration, working in a bipartisan fashion with the legislature, has been to update this process to ensure that the products that we're selecting are the best ones and get the most bang for the buck for the Commonwealth.
    • 01:26:36
      Because one of the truths we're going to face in this business, no matter how much funding we have, we will always have more needs.
    • 01:26:44
      There's always needs that are out there, and really what this process is about is addressing the opportunity costs.
    • 01:26:51
      That are out there because we can fund a project that will have a need.
    • 01:26:55
      What we don't know today and what we hopefully know at the end of this process is are we funding the project that gives us, that has the highest need and that means some of the projects with lower needs probably will not get funded moving forward but that's what this process is about.
    • 01:27:10
      Prioritizing the needs that we have so we get the best results for the members, for the citizens and taxpayers in the Commonwealth with the money that we have because we can't fund all the needs.
    • 01:27:20
      With that, this legislation was introduced by Delegate Stolle and was a part of the speaker's package in the House.
    • 01:27:27
      It passed unanimously in both the House and the Senate this chamber, this session, excuse me, and what it does is it directs the Commonwealth Transportation Board, this body, to develop a statewide prioritization process that will be used for the allocation of funds starting in fiscal year 2017, which essentially means that
    • 01:27:47
      In early 2016, the Six-Year Improvement Program that this board considers needs to be developed under this rubric.
    • 01:27:57
      And this process does not apply to all funds, but it essentially applies to capacity expansion projects.
    • 01:28:03
      So yesterday, Mr. Garczynski and I had a bit of a dialogue about the current Six-Year Program that this board will be considering next month.
    • 01:28:11
      And we've done things differently in that update.
    • 01:28:13
      I do want to kind of explain this here to the board.
    • 01:28:17
      is what we're doing is moving forward projects that you see in the out years of this plan or program that you'll see in June, that funding is not secure.
    • 01:28:27
      Now that's always been the case where there's give and pull and take on the projects that are in the later years of the program, but in this current program that is more true than ever.
    • 01:28:37
      In fact, any funding you see on a product that's not fully funded and hasn't been through the environmental review process, that is for a product
    • 01:28:45
      that expands the capacity of the highway system, those funds are not safe on that project.
    • 01:28:50
      Those funds will have to be run through this process.
    • 01:28:54
      And so over the next 24 months as we undertake the development of this prioritization process and go through identifying and taking funding off certain projects, it's going to be a very difficult and probably at times unpleasant experience.
    • 01:29:08
      But at the end of the day, the goal is to get to a rational performance-based process where people know you can open up the six-year program, you can see a capacity project, and you'll understand what its benefits are in certain categories and why funding has been placed there.
    • 01:29:25
      And so it's going to be really tough moving forward, but that is the end goal of this process.
    • 01:29:33
      A few things about the prioritization process and the legislation in particular is it does place some parameters around what the board can develop as it moves forward with this process.
    • 01:29:44
      It directs the board to consider at least five factors as it weights and scores projects across the Commonwealth.
    • 01:29:51
      Those are congestion mitigation, economic development, accessibility,
    • 01:29:56
      The legislation also stipulates that in urbanized areas over 200,000, so Northern Virginia, Richmond, Hampton Roads, Roanoke, a few places of that nature, there will be an additional factor that is a composite transportation and land use factor that is something the MPOs are currently tracking.
    • 01:30:16
      And it would look at things like job to housing balance, job and housing access to HOV, HOT, and transit facilities, and things of that nature.
    • 01:30:25
      And so the legislation does kind of say these are the things you at least must consider.
    • 01:30:30
      One of the other important things that the legislation does is it recognizes one size does not fit all.
    • 01:30:36
      And so we're not going to score projects in different parts of the states the exact same.
    • 01:30:41
      In Northern Virginia, I imagine congestion mitigation will probably be the highest-weighted factor, and actually the law says it must be in Hampton Roads in Northern Virginia.
    • 01:30:49
      However, I imagine if we go out to Mr. Fralin's district in Salem, that things like economic development and safety might actually be the higher-weighted factors.
    • 01:30:58
      And so one of the other things that the board will need to work on is developing how do we want to weight these factors in different parts of the state, because again, Virginia's a very diverse state.
    • 01:31:09
      And what's good for one part of the state with regard to evaluating their needs may not be appropriate for other parts of the state.
    • 01:31:16
      And this is a really key part of this process.
    • 01:31:23
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Connors, it's a very good question that you get into and the board does have the discretion
    • 01:31:33
      to also weight factors differently within portions of a district.
    • 01:31:37
      The Fredericksburg district in particular is one where that might be a good candidate because of the extreme diversity within that district and that is something that is at the discretion of the board and there will be work groups that I'll get into later that will be formed to look into these issues and make recommendations to the board.
    • 01:31:56
      One of the other things about this bill is it doesn't apply to all projects.
    • 01:32:00
      We're all funding that exists within the Commonwealth.
    • 01:32:03
      As I said earlier, it's really focused on capacity expansion projects.
    • 01:32:07
      And so what it does is it says, at first, all highway, federal and state highway funding is included, and then it simply excludes certain types of either projects or funding sources that would not be appropriate for this.
    • 01:32:21
      So the first thing it does, it says, repair and reconstruction and maintenance.
    • 01:32:26
      We're not prioritizing those projects.
    • 01:32:28
      The budget of Virginia and the Appropriations Act
    • 01:32:31
      has dictated that be the top priority in the allocation of funds for over ten years and this process does nothing to change that priority.
    • 01:32:40
      Similarly it
    • 01:32:42
      excludes other things like revenue sharing where local governments come in and pay half the cost of the project.
    • 01:32:47
      If a local government is willing to step up and pay 50% of a project's cost, I have a pretty good feeling that's a good high priority for them.
    • 01:32:55
      You know, when someone's doing that, there's a reason for it.
    • 01:32:57
      It also excludes other, you know, revenue sources from the federal government that we get that have strict rules like the CMAQ Highway Safety Improvement Program and the Transportation Alternatives Programs.
    • 01:33:09
      So when we do that, it is a significant amount of money that this process applies to.
    • 01:33:14
      However, it is not a majority of the funds that you will see in the Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 01:33:19
      And I think that's a very important thing for members of the board, as well as the public, to understand is that more than 50 percent of the money that you'll see in this program is not subject to this process.
    • 01:33:29
      However, the money that is subject to it is a lot of the funds that we use today to support economic development, address congestion, other things of that nature.
    • 01:33:39
      One of the other things that's very important to understand is House Bill 2 does not change how we can allocate funds in the programmatic categories in which they're available to the Board.
    • 01:33:49
      Currently today, the Board has chosen to use the $500 million CTB formula, which is on this slide here.
    • 01:33:57
      This bill doesn't change that.
    • 01:33:59
      However, what it does do is say within these categories, and the ones in red are the ones that are subject to House Bill 2, we will have to prioritize projects using the factors laid out in that legislation.
    • 01:34:11
      So again, 5% of the money under the CTB formula still must be spent on smart roadway technology.
    • 01:34:18
      However, as we select those projects, we must prioritize the projects for that pool of funding using the process in House Bill 2.
    • 01:34:29
      The last thing I'll say as background on the legislation is not all projects will be prioritized.
    • 01:34:35
      There is a screening process that's put in place in the law to ensure that only projects that are meeting needs documented in the long-range plan that is approved by the Commonwealth Transportation Board will get scored.
    • 01:34:48
      This is important for two reasons.
    • 01:34:50
      One, it ensures that as we do spend money on a long-range plan and identify future needs,
    • 01:34:58
      that the funding we use are directed addressing solutions to those needs and it also to a certain degree scales back the number of projects that can be considered to something that's more manageable as a process for staff and as well as for the board.
    • 01:35:11
      We are currently in the process of updating that long-range plan.
    • 01:35:16
      It's known as, or we're developing a new long-range plan, excuse me.
    • 01:35:19
      That's currently known as VTrans 2040.
    • 01:35:21
      In the coming months, the board will get additional updates on that process, but it will do a needs assessment that will look at corridors of statewide significance,
    • 01:35:31
      Martin, John M. Martin, John C.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:53
      On the VTrans 240, I'm sure you don't remember that, what are the selection criteria on that?
    • 01:35:59
      The quarters stay less in two terms of what those quarters are, regional networks, who determines that, and improvements.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:36:06
      Because VTrans is sort of a long-range plan, and I'm not sure if we really designed it for a prioritization.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:36:13
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, the corridors of statewide significance are spelled out in the long-range plan, which is approved by the board.
    • 01:36:21
      So at the end of the day, you all as this body have the authority in spelling that out.
    • 01:36:25
      I do want to make it clear, though, that the long-range plan will identify problem areas or needs.
    • 01:36:31
      It will also identify projects.
    • 01:36:33
      However, projects can be scored if they meet a need.
    • 01:36:37
      So if there's a problem on, say, Route 1, and the long-range plan includes Project X,
    • 01:36:43
      If a local government sends in a project that's wide but addresses that need, then we will score it.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:51
      Basically, the way it works now is we have half a billion dollars that we may take and prioritize on the state-wide basis.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:37:01
      The reason we did that and the reason that's in place is because there wasn't enough money to go through the traditional road funding formula to really get to take a bill.
    • 01:37:11
      And so, what this House Bill 2 is saying, we need to come up with a prioritization of the check criteria for that 500 million dollars and within each construction district for any money that would flow through to the bottom line floating in the traditional sense.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:37:28
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, that is correct.
    • 01:37:30
      However, the legislation does exempt the secondary and urban formula funds from this process should the money ever run through that formula again in the future.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:37:39
      So within that half a billion dollars, we've got 25% for high priority projects, 25% for bridges.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:50
      So basically, any new construction is going to have to come from that 25% high priority project.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:37:56
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin,
    • 01:37:58
      Generally, you are correct.
    • 01:37:59
      It would either come from the 25% for high priority projects or the 15% for public-private partnerships.
    • 01:38:04
      There's also some federal funds that don't currently flow through this that are for capacity expansion.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:38:12
      Okay.
    • 01:38:13
      But in terms of the money that we raise, it's fair.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:38:16
      That is accurate.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:38:18
      So in that 25%, we've got to divide that between interstate, urban, and primary.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:38:25
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, you do not have to divide it.
    • 01:38:27
      Those are choices that may or may not be made at the base of the discretion of the board.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:38:32
      What I'm hearing, and I suspect other folks are hearing, is that because no money has been flowing through the informal urban transportation district, which are really cities, have not received money.
    • 01:38:43
      And I want to make time through the formal.
    • 01:38:46
      And I want to make sure that we've got some sort of
    • 01:38:49
      Mr. Fralin, at the beginning of my presentation I said we're starting to take the steps to update the administration of the program.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:39:06
      At the end of my presentation I'll make a case that additional steps are probably necessary to continue to update the administration to really work within this prioritization process.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 01:39:16
      That was wonderful.
    • 01:39:17
      It changed all that, the legislature plan, you know, before you would have been.
    • 01:39:22
      Yeah, but I think there's going to be a coming story.
    • 01:39:25
      Not that you'll get to it, but maybe something else.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:27
      Well, when we do, I just want to, I also want to know, what we pulled out in the out years, because we've had this unique process, or for whatever reason, if they have the money, or whatever reason they got pulled out, that
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:39:42
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Fralin, I believe there were some revenue reductions that did take place in FY15 which was just a simple factor of the gas, the wholesale price of gas was not what I thought it would be and so there were some revenue reductions that took place in the first year.
    • 01:40:09
      So kind of before I start talking about the process moving forward I think it's really important I start to talk about what are the long-term goals for this process and I think Mr. Fralin started to describe some of the issues that we've really faced with regard to our transportation program over the last 10 and maybe even 15 years that hopefully after we get through the next 24 months of developing this process we can start to resolve.
    • 01:40:33
      So a lot of issues that we've seen is there's been a lot of instability
    • 01:40:37
      in the Six-Year Program.
    • 01:40:39
      You had a lot of money come in with the Virginia Transportation Act of 2000, then you had a lot of it come right back out in 2002 and 2003 when certain general fund appropriations were not made.
    • 01:40:50
      You had a similar thing with House Bill 3202 being passed in 2007, portions of it being declared unconstitutional, the inability to sell bonds that were expected to be sold, and then a downturn in the economy.
    • 01:41:02
      And so we've been in a cycle where lots of projects come in and then they quickly go out.
    • 01:41:07
      And that instability has also kind of broken the link between the planning process where we rationally go in and study a problem to come up with solutions in the programming process because we essentially have had no stability year to year to how much money there would be or what funding would be available for new types of projects.
    • 01:41:25
      And so over the next 24 months, as we move forward with kind of pulling certain money off projects and creating a prioritization account,
    • 01:41:36
      I think when we develop this process, we can start to create a project pipeline where people understand where their projects are scoring, what they can do to increase the score of that project, and whether or not they can move forward with funding.
    • 01:41:49
      And you also know where you stand against other projects across the Commonwealth.
    • 01:41:53
      Today, we could call two local governments in here, one who got funding and one who didn't, and they couldn't tell you why they got funding and why the other guy didn't from a transportation benefits perspective.
    • 01:42:03
      And so, you know, just keep in mind as we go through this process of the next 24 months, the end goal here is, you know, using performance to select projects, creating stability for local governments, contractors, and other folks with regard to the projects in the program, and then also creating a project pipeline where we can start to fund PE and develop projects based on things that are scoring high through the prioritization process and address needs that are identified in the long-range plan.
    • 01:42:33
      So with that, though, 24 months sounds like a long time.
    • 01:42:37
      It's not a long time for what we really have to undertake here.
    • 01:42:40
      And so there's going to be a lot of work that's going to go forward with the staff behind the scenes that will then be reporting to the board, and we're going to be doing a lot of things concurrently over the next few months.
    • 01:42:51
      The goal as we move forward is to develop essentially this process within 12 months.
    • 01:42:58
      The reason that is a goal is then we could use the remaining 12 months to actually run projects through this prioritization process and then we actually have to develop a program using the projects that popped out the back end as scoring high and balancing that with the funding that's available in the different categories moving forward.
    • 01:43:16
      So over the next few months, we as staff will be looking to identifying the funding that will be available to run through prioritization, really importantly developing the measures
    • 01:43:26
      For these various factors, so while the legislation tells you the factors the board must use in this process, it doesn't tell you how you must measure that factor, which is going to be a really important thing as we move forward.
    • 01:43:39
      Just as important is what are the priorities in the different parts of the state?
    • 01:43:43
      We're going to have to do a lot of work with stakeholders talking about what is top in this region?
    • 01:43:49
      Is it congestion mitigation?
    • 01:43:51
      Is it economic development?
    • 01:43:52
      Is it accessibility?
    • 01:43:53
      Or is it something else?
    • 01:43:54
      And so that's another thing we'll have to do.
    • 01:43:56
      And then we're also going to need to do outreach to local governments, to transit agencies, to MPOs, to other folks to identify candidate projects that we can then screen and run these successfully screened ones through this prioritization process.
    • 01:44:11
      We are going to be putting in place work groups for these first three tasks that we'll be meeting at first internally and then likely externally after a month or two to work on this process and then we'll come back to the board and provide recommendations as we move forward with this.
    • 01:44:26
      The other thing that I really want to stress in this process is this has to be a transparent process for this to work.
    • 01:44:34
      The VDOT staff and myself along with the DRPT staff could go in a back room and probably create what we think is a great prioritization process all by ourselves, but if we do that I promise you we will have failed because no one else will agree with us.
    • 01:44:46
      So over the next few months we'll be reaching out to MPOs, PDCs, local governments, both municipal and counties,
    • 01:44:53
      As well as other interested stakeholders.
    • 01:44:56
      And we'll be sitting down with them.
    • 01:44:57
      We'll be going to their annual meetings.
    • 01:44:59
      We'll be going to their monthly meetings.
    • 01:45:00
      We're going to talk about this process.
    • 01:45:02
      We're going to ask for their input, really try and get a sense for what they think is important.
    • 01:45:07
      Because if we don't do that and get the buy-in on this process, all of the hard work we're going to do over the next 24 months will be for naught.
    • 01:45:17
      So on the funding work group, I've hinted at this already, but its main goal, and it'll consist a lot of programming staff and other folks internally, is to figure out what funding do we actually have each year to run through this prioritization process.
    • 01:45:31
      And so the key things they'll be having to balance there are identifying the funding and the projects that are not exempt from HB2, and then we're going to have to remove funding.
    • 01:45:41
      from the United States.
    • 01:45:58
      and 17 and 18 and that amount will gradually start to grow as the exempt projects work their way through the pipeline.
    • 01:46:06
      But that's the amount of money that we'll have for this process and that's what this work group is really going to be focusing on.
    • 01:46:14
      They'll also be taking a look at how do we kind of build a project pipeline through the Six-Year Program and the prioritization process where we can start to prioritize P.E.
    • 01:46:24
      and the design of projects based on the score and other things as we move forward to really create that project pipeline.
    • 01:46:33
      Another workgroup that will be established will be one at looking at how do we measure the outcomes.
    • 01:46:50
      Mr.
    • 01:46:50
      Chairmen, Mr. Fralin,
    • 01:46:51
      As I mentioned earlier, that $500 million does exist, and there's also some federal funds that are not currently in that $500 million.
    • 01:46:59
      And so that's how we could potentially get up to $600 million in a given year.
    • 01:47:04
      And potentially bond proceeds and things of that nature, sir.
    • 01:47:09
      So we're going to have another work group that will be looking at kind of how do we measure these different factors.
    • 01:47:13
      And the first thing, and this work is already underway, is other states have done this.
    • 01:47:19
      And in particular, a lot of regional transportation agencies have moved forward with this process.
    • 01:47:24
      And so we have staff calling different states and MPOs to really understand how have you done this, what are the things that have been important for you, how have you measured this, and how has that worked with the public and other stakeholders to really understand what are some of the best practices across the country.
    • 01:47:39
      The other thing that this work group is going to look at is, and this is, you know, may sound silly now, but will be really important, is how are we going to score projects?
    • 01:47:47
      In this factor, I mean there's a whole host of options and we will be making recommendations to the board on this, but it could be something as simple as, are you a high crash location?
    • 01:47:56
      Yes or no.
    • 01:47:57
      Or it could be, to what degree do you reduce congestion or reduce potential future fatalities, where it could be some type of sliding scale.
    • 01:48:05
      Other things that we'll have to look at is, do we just look at what's on the ground today?
    • 01:48:10
      you know congestion on I-66 we all know that's a problem today or do we want to look at things in the future like potentially economic development along the 460 corridor where maybe there's not a need today but there will be something in the future these are all the types of things that we're gonna have to really tackle and understand as we move forward one of the other things and some of the other board members have seen this so please bear with me but for the new members is what are we going to measure
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:48:38
      When we really start to use performance measures and factors like this to prioritize projects, it's important that we have measures that actually capture the things we think are important.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:49:07
      and members of the board, what Ms. Tung is talking about is the last federal reauthorization took the initial steps to kind of transitioning to a performance-based planning process.
    • 01:49:18
      And I kind of talked about this earlier where in the past a lot of state DOTs have dashboards.
    • 01:49:23
      And they're very, very helpful in that they tell you what the current conditions are.
    • 01:49:28
      However, they don't tell you whether or not they thought that's what the condition was going to be.
    • 01:49:32
      So, you know, we have an annual budget in the Commonwealth Transportation Fund of over $5 billion.
    • 01:49:37
      And the dashboard tells you what happened after we spent it.
    • 01:49:41
      But it never told you if that's what we thought was going to happen before we spend it.
    • 01:49:45
      And what the federal rules, and they have not yet come out for the mobility and congestion efforts, will do is actually say we need to project forward what we think is some type of achievable performance and then track our progress as to whether or not we're meeting that performance.
    • 01:50:01
      And so this effort
    • 01:50:04
      will be influenced by that, but they're actually separate.
    • 01:50:06
      The MAT21 provisions will go more into the VTrans process, where we'll be projecting future performance out.
    • 01:50:14
      What we're going to have to do with this process is pick projects that will help us meet those types of goals.
    • 01:50:20
      And over time, if we find out our projected performance that we thought was going to be achieved is not, we may probably should come back and look at how we set up the prioritization process and may need to tweak it.
    • 01:50:30
      If it's not achieving the outcomes, we thought it would over the long term.
    • 01:50:35
      So on this slide, members of the board, I just want to walk through this again because if we use measures to pick projects, let's make sure the measures capture what we think is important.
    • 01:50:44
      And what you see here is a comparison of Denver in 1982 and Denver in 2007.
    • 01:50:49
      Now, before I talk about the transportation metrics, let's talk a little bit about Denver.
    • 01:50:54
      In this time period, it grew by 800,000 people, which is about a 50% growth rate.
    • 01:51:00
      It was listed as one of the top 10 places to do business and locate businesses by Forbes magazine.
    • 01:51:06
      So from all kind of respects, it was an economic success over this 25 years.
    • 01:51:13
      If you look at our transportation metrics, one of the most often cited metrics when we measure performance of the transportation system is the travel time index.
    • 01:51:21
      which is essentially a ratio of how much longer does it take you to drive during rush hour compared to how long it would take you to drive at three in the morning during free flow conditions.
    • 01:51:30
      So your goal there is to have a one.
    • 01:51:32
      It means driving at eight in the morning when everyone on the road is just as fast as driving at three in the morning when everyone's in bed.
    • 01:51:39
      So if you look at Denver in 1982, they had a travel time index of 1.09.
    • 01:51:43
      Not bad.
    • 01:51:45
      Nine percent longer to drive in rush hour than at three in the morning.
    • 01:51:49
      If you fast forward to Denver in 2007, their travel time index has increased to 1.31.
    • 01:51:54
      That's pretty bad.
    • 01:51:56
      You know, in this metric, 31% longer to drive to work during rush hour than in the morning.
    • 01:52:02
      If you also, another often cited metric is delay.
    • 01:52:05
      So it took people four extra minutes to get to work in 1982 because of traffic congestion on average.
    • 01:52:11
      In 2007, it took them almost 12 minutes to get to work, which is an increase of almost 300%.
    • 01:52:17
      The rub here is people in 1982 got to work in 50 minutes and people in 2007 basically got to work in 50 minutes.
    • 01:52:26
      And I talked with the folks who put out the travel time index.
    • 01:52:29
      They agree with all of these numbers.
    • 01:52:31
      Actually all of this data was calculated using their own figures.
    • 01:52:35
      Now what simply happened here is through their strategies with regards to land use, transportation investments, mostly hot lanes and transit networks, they reduced trip distances.
    • 01:52:46
      And so people were in fact driving slower in 2007 than they were in 1982.
    • 01:52:53
      The difference was they just weren't driving as far.
    • 01:52:57
      And these are all choices that the board will need to consider as we look at these two types of issues.
    • 01:53:02
      And really the stress here is the travel time index looks a lot at congestion, whereas kind of the overall average travel time or trip distance is really more of an accessibility function.
    • 01:53:13
      Can you easily get there?
    • 01:53:15
      And so these are the types of things we're going to have to explore and really understand as we create measures to select how we fund our projects.
    • 01:53:22
      Because once you have that measure out there, we really got to understand what it's taking a look at and figure out is that something we actually value.
    • 01:53:32
      The other thing is we'll be creating several work groups that will be working on the weighting of projects in different areas.
    • 01:53:38
      We'll be doing this work very heavily with stakeholders because we're going to need to create sheets like this one you see in this slide where we have percentages for each of these factors weighting their relative importance in the different areas of the Commonwealth.
    • 01:53:52
      One of the other things that we'll have to do, as Mr. Connors mentioned earlier, is the law says we must develop different weighting for each district.
    • 01:53:59
      in each district, excuse me.
    • 01:54:01
      However, there is also the flexibility to have different weighting even within a district for districts that are, you know, diverse like the Fredericksburg District.
    • 01:54:09
      And so those are things that will need to be considered by the board as we move forward.
    • 01:54:13
      And lastly, we'll be having to identify candidate projects.
    • 01:54:17
      So the Office of Developmental Planning and Investment will do a project solicitation
    • 01:54:21
      from different transportation interests across the state to get a set of projects that will then be run through the screening process to determine whether or not they should be prioritized.
    • 01:54:32
      Also, as I mentioned, there are projects currently in the plan that may lose some of their funding as we move forward.
    • 01:54:38
      Those projects will be candidate projects as we move forward and will be run through the prioritization process.
    • 01:54:47
      As I mentioned earlier, we hope to have the actual process in place in 12 months, which then means hopefully in summer or fall of 2015, we will actually start to run the identified projects through the prioritization process and report on the results back to the board so you can see how it's working.
    • 01:55:04
      At that time, we may have to step back and tweak the prioritization process, or folks may agree that it's working out really well, and we'll move forward onto the next step, which will be developing a six-year program
    • 01:55:16
      Mr. Chairman, earlier Mr. Fralin made reference to some needs of urban localities and other things and I do think there's some other considerations that the board needs to take into account as we move forward with this prioritization process.
    • 01:55:34
      One of the things is I listed a whole set of funds that are exempt from the prioritization process at the beginning of this presentation.
    • 01:55:43
      However, the legislation does give the board the authority to develop different prioritization processes for almost every single one of those exempt categories.
    • 01:55:53
      So, for example, the Federal Highway Safety Improvement Program funds are exempt from the writ large prioritization process, and the reason they are is there's pretty specific federal rules.
    • 01:56:04
      It can only go for safety things.
    • 01:56:06
      That does not mean the board could, in its judgment, choose to create a separate prioritization process
    • 01:56:13
      based on just that program's needs.
    • 01:56:16
      The same thing, for example, with transportation alternatives, which the board could argue there already is a prioritization process through the scoring that staff already do.
    • 01:56:25
      But that is something that the board could look at and could consider as we move forward with this process.
    • 01:56:31
      The other things are some stuff that Mr. Fralin started to hint at, and that's does the current formula work well under this prioritization rubric, or does it need tweaks?
    • 01:56:42
      How are the needs of local governments, particularly municipalities, where they maintain their own roads and they're not in the VDOT system considered?
    • 01:56:51
      And so there are ways where we could look at potentially tweaks to the $500 million formula or tweaks to the old 40-30 formula or some merging of those two formulas or we could decide actually it works great
    • 01:57:04
      We don't need any changes, but I do think that's something the board should take a look at as we move forward with this process, because again, House Bill 2 does not change the allocation of money.
    • 01:57:15
      What it does is change how we select projects within those funding categories, kind of moving forward.
    • 01:57:21
      I do want to note to members of the board that any consideration of this nature is not an administrative policy that you could change.
    • 01:57:28
      It would require legislation to be passed by the General Assembly in a future session which would be no small task.
    • 01:57:35
      The funding formula is something that has always been a very, very touchy and controversial subject in the transportation committees and I have no reason to expect it would be any different if the board were to pursue legislation to modify it moving forward.
    • 01:57:50
      So again, just in closing, if we're successful in 24 months,
    • 01:57:54
      And in four years in implementing this, we will put in place a system that helps promote performance, provides stability, and establishes a project pipeline with certainty for local governments and other funding partners.
    • 01:58:06
      And with that, Mr. Chairman, I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:11
      Mr. Chairman, Nick, what about MPOs you already have in your market?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:58:17
      What's the local ones?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:58:19
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Connors,
    • 01:58:20
      That's a very good question and most of the MPOs in Virginia actually do have a prioritization process that they currently use today.
    • 01:58:28
      That process typically is used for the regional surface transportation funds that they receive through the federal program as well as the regional congestion mitigation air quality or CMAC funds that they receive.
    • 01:58:41
      Both of those funding sources are exempt.
    • 01:58:43
      from House Bill 2, and so those long-standing prioritization processes that are in place for those smaller pots of regional money would continue to operate as they do today.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:58:59
      As far as rail and transit, where do they fit into this?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 01:59:05
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Garczynski, it's a very good question.
    • 01:59:08
      So the funds
    • 01:59:09
      that are put through this process are what are traditionally known as highway funds, both from the federal level and from the state level.
    • 01:59:17
      However, for a long period of time, those funds are actually very flexible funds.
    • 01:59:23
      They can be used for passenger rail to a certain degree, transit almost always, depending on the category of funding there.
    • 01:59:32
      And in the past, there have been instances where these highway funds have been used.
    • 01:59:37
      For those types of projects and essentially what this process says is moving forward after 17 new projects that are funded, if it's a transit project that wants to get funding from these traditionally highway monies or flexible surface transportation money, they'll have to compete in this pot.
    • 01:59:54
      Now there are still the state and federal transit funds and those are not pulled into this process and one of the rationales behind that is most of the formula money under the transit program really goes to kind of capital maintenance and repair or the operations of systems so it was exempted from this process just as road and bridge repair and replacement and reconstruction were exempted from this process.
    • 02:00:21
      Chairman, I would also like to add that
    • 02:00:22
      I find a lot of parallel here
    • 02:00:27
      first came out, I think, called Dodd-Frank.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:00:30
      And then what happened as far as the general law being passed, which on the surface was fine, but the depth was in the details.
    • 02:00:40
      And the implications of perhaps the Dodd-Frank fighting in California are deep and varied.
    • 02:00:49
      And we have to watch the same process could be happening here.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:00:54
      We don't get bogged so bogged down,
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:00:57
      out of that, it's hard to move forward.
    • 02:01:00
      It's going to be a real challenge having lived through it in North Virginia for the past 18 months to our prioritization on the region's taxes, being prepared.
    • 02:01:12
      It's going to take a lot of work, and in fairness, it's got to be this award, not just relying on staff to come up with how it's going to work in our districts.
    • 02:01:23
      That's going to be imperative.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:01:28
      So, you know, as we launch this process and we identify the initial candidate projects in that first year, how will we maintain and monitor the criteria throughout the six-year project?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:01:45
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Valentine, that's a very good question and I think one of the other things that this board will need to tackle as we move forward is how often do we run projects through the prioritization process?
    • 02:01:55
      Do we do it on an annual basis?
    • 02:01:57
      Do we do it bi-annually?
    • 02:01:58
      Do we do it in some greater tranche than that?
    • 02:02:02
      Because, you know, when we program funds, projects don't get finished in a year.
    • 02:02:07
      They take multiple years to complete and I think that's one of the things that we'll probably have to examine, look at, explore, and then make some recommendations and you all ultimately decisions on how often we should do that process because it is an open question.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:02:23
      And the intent is not to eviscerate, but to complain.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:02:27
      That's why there was no recognition that he had to work with us.
    • 02:02:31
      And my guess is, it's like anything else, you can only make a decision on the best information you have and make a decision as far as how this project started.
    • 02:02:40
      Well, I don't see a year later, two years later, all of us with a better product to stop this.
    • 02:02:45
      It's sort of like dealing with here in Charlottesville.
    • 02:02:51
      In other words, let's get some projects going that will give us a better decision as we continue our work here.
    • 02:02:57
      I think that's really the whole purpose.
    • 02:02:59
      It's not to slow down work.
    • 02:03:02
      In fact, it's quite the opposite.
    • 02:03:04
      It hopefully will give VDOT a plan that they can implement.
    • 02:03:08
      came into office and there was a governor's list.
    • 02:03:12
      That was different from the previous governor's list, which was different from the previous governor's list.
    • 02:03:17
      And, you know, you see money going to our projects and coming off projects, and they think it's in the out years, and we all know in the out years of those projects that money was priced to look at, but there's no guarantee it was going to be.
    • 02:03:29
      The intent of this is to have VDOT become a delivery agent.
    • 02:03:34
      That we have these projects, and have some certainty what's going to be delivered, and they start rolling them out.
    • 02:03:40
      It's also, just trying to put it out, take some of the politics, it's not naive enough to say it's going to take all of them.
    • 02:03:48
      But, let's take a very controversial road, High County Parkway, for instance.
    • 02:03:52
      If it scores very high, I mean, that's a good criteria for us in the tournament is, you know, you know, what are we looking at?
    • 02:04:01
      My birthday, if it scores very low, you know, that may give us a different way to go.
    • 02:04:05
      So, so we take some of this out because we all know that the Spoozox is getting bored, many times we're standing in front of it.
    • 02:04:13
      So this is an attempt to try, and I believe it can be, we've done it in Northern Virginia, it looks like in Hampton Roads, where it's, look, you get these projects lined up to have agencies that are actually delivering parts with some certainty that that project is not going to get down the road and all of a sudden the next 100 percent, well, that's not my fault.
    • 02:04:38
      I said this when I went to Governor McCulloch.
    • 02:04:42
      I said, Governor, this will really be the last time a Governor will even set the plate because from here on out, the ball is going to be required.
    • 02:04:51
      In other words, we campaigned on some things, and obviously those were considered, but his response was, you know, just line them up.
    • 02:05:01
      I mean, that's the only way, just line them up, pick the right ones, get this prioritization in the process.
    • 02:05:07
      So, we're very closely with the Speaker that Nick and I did.
    • 02:05:11
      I want to point out to Nick primarily, Nick did a lot of this land work, detail working with the staff and the Speaker, so he deserves a lot of credit for this bill.
    • 02:05:21
      But the idea is we got these new monies.
    • 02:05:25
      We talked about the problems of all the things we were trying to do when we didn't have money, trying to put round pegs in square holes.
    • 02:05:32
      And I think, again, it was all well-attentioned.
    • 02:05:35
      Some of these results we got were not so good.
    • 02:05:38
      And so this really is this continuing step that will deliver a program and not a political back and forth.
    • 02:05:46
      But I know politics will always be hard.
    • 02:05:49
      So this is what I mean.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:05:51
      I would suggest there is important criteria that is important to measure the success there.
    • 02:05:59
      And that can be really taken up from Lipsky's comment.
    • 02:06:04
      And that would be an efficient implementation of the usage.
    • 02:06:07
      If you don't have an efficient process, then you don't have a good function.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:06:17
      And Mr. Chairman, I think one of the other things that I alluded to but didn't explicitly state, we also have to make sure everyone understands it and that we can present it in a way where people understand why they've done it.
    • 02:06:31
      If they bought it on the front end but then everything comes on the back end and they have no clue...
    • 02:06:37
      Exactly.
    • 02:06:37
      So I couldn't agree more with your comments, Mr. Whitworth.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:06:41
      Will there be a process for post completion project review to look at how the project performs accurately versus how the metrics align on the front end to adjust the process in the out years?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:06:54
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Kastowitz, that's a very good question.
    • 02:06:56
      We are putting in place the basic elements of establishing a process through that in the long range plan where we will project
    • 02:07:04
      We're going to go back and look.
    • 02:07:11
      And if we said after spending this amount of money after four years and we thought the outcome was going to be Y and it was only half of Y, then we have a problem.
    • 02:07:20
      And we're going to need to go back, hold ourselves accountable to what happened and understand what happened differently than we thought it would and change our processes to be able to account for those factors moving forward.
    • 02:07:31
      The tough part about the business we're in is there are a lot of factors we don't control.
    • 02:07:36
      That doesn't mean we can't influence them.
    • 02:07:38
      You know, transportation really has two kind of components.
    • 02:07:40
      There's supply and there's demand.
    • 02:07:43
      This board has complete control over the supply within the resources available to it.
    • 02:07:47
      However, with the exception of the local officials on this board, we have no control over the demand aspect because that's mostly driven by local land use.
    • 02:07:55
      However, that doesn't mean we can't seek to influence them, in instances, if we deem that's necessary to help achieve the performance we believe the citizens should see demonstrated from their investments in the taxes they pay.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:08:20
      I think this is a unique kind of opportunity for us, because we're the first board that's going to set these priorities.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:28
      And we can change them.
    • 02:08:29
      I mean, the way I read the law, if you go back here, you can change it, but it's not going to be without a party that can do that.
    • 02:08:36
      But I also want to say that the way I read it, we're going to set these priorities, and we're going to follow this.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:08:41
      Now, what's going to happen practically, probably, is projects are going to go really close, like one got a 77 and one got a 75.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:49
      And I don't think that these priorities are necessarily going to bind us to the decision plan.
    • 02:08:55
      In other words, we can still say, well, it's a little bit lower, but I like this, so we're not losing that piece of it.
    • 02:09:01
      That's right.
    • 02:09:01
      That's right.
    • 02:09:02
      Yeah.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:09:02
      In other words, if something comes back like that, if you want to talk about one or two or ten, and one does, you can make that decision, but you have to give the authority to agree.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:09:13
      And on that point, look,
    • 02:09:16
      I saw this at the Hampton Roads, and I think it's sort of like the multiple tests, the local choice tests.
    • 02:09:23
      Usually your first inclination is the test.
    • 02:09:26
      So we'll go through, and I think we ought to give this a time, because when you're at the Hampton Roads, they kind of got all the technical, and they really got it right, and they said,
    • 02:09:34
      Well, I don't like that.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:09:37
      That's not what I was expecting.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:09:39
      I think that we really ought to be right.
    • 02:09:42
      I've said it many times, we probably won't get it 100% right for the first time.
    • 02:09:47
      At least we don't have to have two-thirds of the door.
    • 02:09:53
      That's right.
    • 02:09:55
      But I think we ought to do our best work and run through it and then assess it.
    • 02:10:03
      Instead of, you know, getting it out of the same ballot here that says that Dry Bridge over here is for time in Interstate 66, I would think we would say, well, then we can look at that.
    • 02:10:16
      But my point is, it's not saying, gosh, we're trying to put objective measures in.
    • 02:10:21
      And that's really hard for us to say what's subject, and we don't just don't make any sense of it.
    • 02:10:27
      And so I just needed to be cognizant.
    • 02:10:29
      And that's why we thought we'd get staff worked on first before we were all popping in and saying, you know, in that regard.
    • 02:10:39
      Because we all bring our own devices, and hopefully we've got technical people that cut through some of those to give us the first look.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:10:46
      Yes, we will have, for instance, Fralin, some example in Northern Virginia where the money bill states that they have to be rated, but it doesn't say you have to go by the ratings.
    • 02:10:59
      So if the ratings first come out this year, it will be an interesting dynamic within the VTA.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:11:06
      Mr. Chairman, I just want to clarify one thing for the local government staff representative streaming.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:11:26
      Influencing does not mean control.
    • 02:11:29
      And this board, I don't believe ever wants to control local zoning or other decisions, so I just want to clarify that for anyone who might have taken the comments one way or another that I made earlier.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:11:39
      I've been to those hearings, I don't want to stand in front of them.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:11:51
      That's what it is, huh?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:11:55
      Can I always use your plan here anytime?
    • 02:11:56
      I'm sure it's going to be a pretty loud process.
    • 02:12:00
      I'm sure that they're not getting quite totally the first time, but I think if you get through it, I think our agencies will have a plan to be continuity that we're actually delivering to projects.
    • 02:12:14
      They don't have to worry about a lot of us.
    • 02:12:15
      I started right away, but now the next governor says, I want your money on this one.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:12:22
      Let me ask you one more question.
    • 02:12:25
      Mr.
    • 02:12:26
      Chair and Mr. Fralin, we're going to start that this summer.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:12:36
      I believe we need to get in...
    • 02:12:38
      Excuse me, can you repeat your question?
    • 02:12:41
      Mr. Fralin may have misunderstood you.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:12:44
      Each district has to come up with their own prioritization.
    • 02:12:53
      So we're going to solicit public input as to what those criteria are.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:13:03
      We will be doing that initially as staff and at the appropriate time we will be bringing the board members into those decisions but that is going to start
    • 02:13:10
      probably as soon as later this summer or fall because we're going to get input at the beginning, the middle, somewhere still in the middle and then hopefully before we finalize it because at the end of the day everyone has to be engaged in this process because it's going to have a lot of impact.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:13:24
      I would expect we could have a mid-year change to the Six-Year Plan.
    • 02:13:28
      I mean, as we get closer, that's, we've hit an initial scrub and we fully admit that we didn't get it all, but we wanted to at least say, look, guys, these are the projects, we're trying to identify what it was that happened to the program.
    • 02:13:41
      I'm sure we made a few things that
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 02:13:45
      Mr. Chairman, I just wanted to come down to probably reiterate what Mr. Conner said earlier, but within our districts, we can have a different set of criteria based on whether it's the urban area or the rural area.
    • 02:14:04
      So our districts are going to, a district is not going to have one set of criteria.
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:14:11
      Mr. Chairman, Ms. Valentine, that is the decision that this body has the opportunity to make.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:14:15
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:14:40
      Thank you.
    • 02:14:45
      We understand the task ahead of us.
    • 02:14:48
      Okay, we have the last item, the adjustments for local programs.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:14:55
      Good morning Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
    • 02:14:58
      Thankfully I haven't been sitting here since yesterday.
    • 02:15:05
      Might have just had a little bit of insight on that.
    • 02:15:11
      Good morning Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 02:15:13
      Today I've got a presentation for you on some changes that we're making or recommending for you to make as a result of some legislation in the 2014 General Assembly.
    • 02:15:24
      Deputy Secretary Donohue just gave you a great overview of the CTB formula funds, so I'm not going to belabor this, but there were some changes that were made to that language, specifically two parts of that CTB formula during this General Assembly session.
    • 02:15:41
      The first piece has to do with the 25% set-aside for interstate and primary pavement.
    • 02:15:47
      We've had a lot of dialogue with local government over the last couple of years about pavement conditions in the cities and towns where they maintain their own infrastructure.
    • 02:15:57
      There's a little nuance in the language of the code that those primary roads, and you can think about I came in on the 250 bypass in the city of Charlottesville this morning.
    • 02:16:06
      That carries a primary route number, but technically it's not part of the primary system.
    • 02:16:11
      It's part of the urban system, so it's a primary extension.
    • 02:16:14
      That route number stays for continuity.
    • 02:16:16
      So there's a little nuance in language to make sure that those routes
    • 02:16:20
      would be eligible for that set-aside of 25% to reconstruct pavements on the primary system to add that eligibility.
    • 02:16:28
      And there was also a change to the 5% set-aside for unpaved roads.
    • 02:16:33
      Previously it had been set at 200 vehicles per day, and it was changed to 50 vehicles per day to match the existing unpaved road statute.
    • 02:16:42
      And I'll go into each of those changes in a little bit of detail.
    • 02:16:46
      I already explained what a primary extension was.
    • 02:16:48
      If you look at the lane mileage, it's just under 4300 lane miles statewide of primary extensions that are maintained by localities.
    • 02:16:57
      Nearly half of those are actually in the Hampton Roads District.
    • 02:17:00
      I think that's just an interesting fact to share.
    • 02:17:03
      In terms of lane mileage, those primary extensions represent 14% of the eligible lane mileage that can receive that 25% set aside for paving.
    • 02:17:13
      We also looked at vehicle miles traveled to look and see if it was a difference in traffic.
    • 02:17:19
      Interestingly enough, it came out to 14%.
    • 02:17:20
      So, 14% is a pretty good measure of what those roadways represent in terms of that system.
    • 02:17:28
      The legislative change I would like to mention was brought to us by the Virginia Municipal League and the Virginia for Cities Coalition after a lot of dialogue and we've worked with them on this process as well.
    • 02:17:40
      There's a lot of background with the board.
    • 02:17:43
      When you look at primary extensions and local maintenance, going back really to about 2011, we've done a lot of research, data collection, and looked at the conditions of the roadways that are maintained by local government.
    • 02:17:57
      What you've got is a slide that was presented to the board in June of last year that kind of culminated the work that we had done over a couple of years.
    • 02:18:05
      looking at the condition of their roadways.
    • 02:18:08
      And what we did was we went out with using our pavement data collection contract collected data on the local system to see if we can make an apples to apples comparison on their pavement condition.
    • 02:18:18
      And what we found was kind of interesting.
    • 02:18:20
      If you look at VDOT maintained primary statewide, about 18% are deficient in terms of the critical condition index.
    • 02:18:29
      If you look at the primary extensions that are maintained by local government, it was 42% deficient.
    • 02:18:35
      So they've definitely, our research showed a need on the local side for greater investment with primaries.
    • 02:18:42
      So what I'm sharing with you today is a recommendation on how we can provide some funding from the CTB formula for primary extensions.
    • 02:18:50
      And our recommendation is to set aside 14% of the CTB formula paving allocations, so that's 14% up to 25%, so that we can do an application-based program for local governments.
    • 02:19:02
      We could accept applications
    • 02:19:04
      on an annual basis to support pavement overlay, rehab, and reconstruction projects.
    • 02:19:10
      What we're recommending is a maximum request of a million dollars per locality per year.
    • 02:19:14
      In looking at some of the potential candidate projects out there, we think that's a good number to help get the money spread around.
    • 02:19:22
      By code, the roadway must have a critical condition index rating of 60 or less.
    • 02:19:27
      That shows that there's the deficiency on that segment.
    • 02:19:31
      We're recommending that the projects must be ready to be advertised within six months of allocation, trying to get that money out there working and get those roadway conditions improved as quickly as possible.
    • 02:19:44
      Also recommending that projects that are selected that don't meet that criteria of going to advertisement in six months may be subject to the allocation, again, to keep the money working and get the roadways in better shape.
    • 02:19:56
      Fourth recommendation under that application process is a certification for maintenance of effort.
    • 02:20:02
      One of our goals with this particular recommendation is that this funding is available to supplement, not replace, money that would already be spent on paving in the local system.
    • 02:20:13
      So we're going to look for our local partners to certify to us that they're going to maintain what they're currently doing, and this is over and above what they were already planning to do.
    • 02:20:23
      Sticking with the theme of prioritization, our recommendation would be to prioritize projects for funding based on a technical score that would consider 50% of that score would be comprised of pavement condition, 35% comprised on traffic volume.
    • 02:20:40
      Again, trying to target this pot of money towards projects that serve the greatest amount of traffic and are in the worst condition.
    • 02:20:49
      And then we have a 15% factor in there for prior expenditures.
    • 02:20:53
      For those localities that have invested in their pavement and they still have parts of their system that have great needs, this would basically be a little bit of a bonus to help those projects score well.
    • 02:21:05
      We do have data from 2012 for these roads, these potential candidate projects.
    • 02:21:11
      But if we can continue forward with this, we would need to continue to collect data on the local system so that we can make that comparison and have that clean dataset because there's so many different ways to look at pavement data.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:21:25
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:21:26
      Thank you, Don.
    • 02:21:27
      Let me ask you a question.
    • 02:21:29
      Does this, and I'm looking toward the rest of the presentation, but I think this may be an appropriate place to ask, does this have the potential to punish both companies, including putting more resources and more investment into their roadways than others, and would they end up getting punished by the process because they have had a lot of capital to spend their
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:21:53
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Rosen, that's a fantastic question and we've worked with local governments over the past 10 years on various issues related to maintenance payments and we always hear from those localities that have made significant investments that they don't want to be penalized if something like this were to come along in the future.
    • 02:22:08
      That 15% factor basically helps those folks out so that their projects would continue to qualify and score well and it basically rewards them for making that level of investment in the past.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:22:21
      Where did that number come from?
    • 02:22:24
      Is that where it's 15% a fair number for localities who put significant capital resources into those roads, weighting less than, and understanding safety, accessibility, and all that from a primary extension aspect within a particular institution.
    • 02:22:42
      Is that a fair number to put on that without looking from jurisdiction to jurisdiction as to the resources they value?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:22:51
      Mr. Rosen, to get a little bit more into detail, that's 15% of the technical score.
    • 02:22:55
      We've actually looked at weighting that.
    • 02:22:57
      So, the localities that have spent more than 25% of their maintenance payments on pavement would receive 15%.
    • 02:23:03
      Those that have not expended at that rate would receive no points.
    • 02:23:08
      It would be a reward for those that have invested and it would be basically a negative for those that have not.
    • 02:23:14
      And that 25% is something that we look at compared to what we spend on our maintenance budget, how much we invest in pavement.
    • 02:23:21
      We figure that's a pretty fair rate that you need to be investing in order to maintain your conditions.
    • 02:23:33
      All right, so what does that mean, 14% of 25%?
    • 02:23:37
      The chart on the screen, it's hard to read.
    • 02:23:41
      It's hard to read from here.
    • 02:23:42
      If you look at it, over six years, we're talking about $70 million.
    • 02:23:47
      Fiscal year 15 is just under $5 million.
    • 02:23:51
      It goes up to a high of $14.6 million in fiscal year 19, based on the draft Six-Year Improvement Program.
    • 02:23:57
      So the net result is that it does significantly increase funding that's available for paving projects to local governments with the $70 million over six years.
    • 02:24:07
      But as the pie that we have to work with is only so big, there's an offset to that, which means
    • 02:24:13
      That $70 million had been identified for primary projects that VDOT maintains.
    • 02:24:20
      So because we have a target that we try to reach of 82% pavements in CCI rating of 60 or better, we need to continue to make that investment in order to maintain that performance target.
    • 02:24:32
      So that $70 million that we're going to send to local government
    • 02:24:35
      needs to come back into the primary system and the net result is that that would impact the amount of money that would be available to go to the secondary system paving out of our maintenance budget.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:50
      I think it's the right thing to do to extend this to the cities and towns to maintain their own system.
    • 02:24:59
      But there is an impact to the primary VDOT, the state primary system.
    • 02:25:04
      And we're going to have to make adjustments in our budget because we can't simply say, well, we just won't pay $70 million for it.
    • 02:25:11
      Inman, John W. Whirley Sr., John W. Whirley Jr.,
    • 02:25:27
      It's not actually important for the board to know that there is an impact on the state primary system.
    • 02:25:32
      We will be moving funds within our programs to ensure that very fundamentally that we maintain our pavements in that region.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:25:44
      Shifting gears to unpaved roads.
    • 02:25:48
      As I mentioned earlier, the CTB formula as it was originally adopted established a 200 vehicle per day threshold for high volume unpaved roads.
    • 02:25:57
      The formula threshold has been for quite some time 50 vehicles per day and fiscal year 14 was the first year that funding was distributed using the CTB formula for these high-volume, unpaid roads.
    • 02:26:08
      And it came with some challenges.
    • 02:26:11
      There were 93 counties that had quote unquote eligible unpaved roads.
    • 02:26:17
      Some of those counties had very small mileage of unpaved roads, over 200 vehicles per day.
    • 02:26:23
      And we actually had 12 counties that received funding that they were unable to program based on the 200 vehicle per day threshold.
    • 02:26:30
      Our systems in terms of inventory and traffic data collection are all kind of have historically been triggered around that 50 vehicle per day threshold and getting that inventory and traffic data was a little bit of a challenge for that original change.
    • 02:26:46
      The change to 50 vehicles per day that was made this year is going to ensure that most counties now have the opportunity to receive CTB formula unpaid road money.
    • 02:26:54
      That does provide greater geographic equity.
    • 02:26:57
      It gets money back into some of the more rural parts of the state and ultimately it furthers our goal of eliminating the backlog of unpaid road mileage statewide.
    • 02:27:06
      Our goal, what we've done from a policy perspective within the department, is to really try to focus on providing hard surface roads at the lowest possible cost so that we can really reduce or eliminate that backlog.
    • 02:27:19
      In terms of a recommendation for unpaved roads, we recognize that there are still issues that are specific to high volume unpaved roads that do warrant some special consideration for funding.
    • 02:27:30
      So again, we're going to bring you a recommendation that we set aside 10%
    • 02:27:34
      of the CTB formula unpaid road funds to provide, again, a supplemental funding source for providing a hard surface on high volume unpaid roads.
    • 02:27:44
      Very similar to what we proposed for the primary extensions, we would accept applications for funding on an annual basis for unpaid roadways carrying over 500 vehicles per day, targeting those roadways that have the highest volume
    • 02:27:59
      first with a maximum request of $300,000 per locality per year.
    • 02:28:05
      I can tell you on the screen it says that we have 28 counties with 55 unpaved roadway segments that represent kind of the eligible pool.
    • 02:28:12
      We are still working to refine the inventory and the traffic data and between the time I gave Carol the presentation for today and standing here today, that's now 27 counties with 54 segments and we're going to continue to refine that before we bring
    • 02:28:27
      Something to you for action next month.
    • 02:28:30
      So that number continues to go down, which is what we're after.
    • 02:28:34
      Again, much like primary extensions, our recommendation is to prioritize applications based on the technical scoring criteria, the criteria on the screen.
    • 02:28:45
      Higher volume routes, projects that have engineering complete and right-of-way secured.
    • 02:28:50
      Again, trying to get projects that can get through the development process and on the street quickly.
    • 02:28:56
      Construction beginning within six months, projects that have additional local funds allocated so that there's some other funding sources or skin in the game, so to speak, to get those projects completed.
    • 02:29:08
      Projects that address identified safety issues or provide direct access to schools and public facilities.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:29:19
      Now we're getting our research into where we went back.
    • 02:29:22
      One of the important deficiencies in the decision process we had in the fall was maybe it's so expensive to go in and upgrade it, but it goes to the right-hand part.
    • 02:29:31
      It's in the drinking part, so we didn't need to change that.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:29:34
      So there's a lot of little wars.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:29:37
      There's a lot of character built into it.
    • 02:29:38
      You can go in there and rip all the trees out from both sides and put them in.
    • 02:29:43
      And then it's like
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:29:49
      Commissioner and Mr. Williams, it's a great question.
    • 02:29:54
      We had a code change back in, I think it was 2001, 2002 to establish the Rural Rustic Road Program and that gave us some flexibility to be able to go out and basically maintain the character.
    • 02:30:07
      of roadway and simply go in and put in a hard surface without having to acquire right-of-way and address drainage and make a lot of other changes to the roadway facility.
    • 02:30:18
      It's been very successful statewide and we can now use that approach on roadways up to 1,500 vehicles per day.
    • 02:30:25
      So our intent would be that it would capture many of these projects.
    • 02:30:29
      And that's where that $300,000 number comes from because when we look back on all the years of data and the projects that have been completed on a statewide basis, it costs about $300,000 to do a mile under the Rural Rustic concept.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:44
      I guess I could reinforce that.
    • 02:30:47
      The Rural Rustic program has been very, very successful around the state.
    • 02:30:53
      Prior to that legislation, we were requiring a minimum of a 40-foot fee right-of-way, and in many cases, 50 feet of fee right-of-way, which became very difficult.
    • 02:31:03
      We tried to get that through a donation process.
    • 02:31:07
      In many cases, the whole thing, what we were building, was well more than what the citizens expected.
    • 02:31:13
      They simply wanted to get out of the way.
    • 02:31:15
      So the Rural Rusting Program, that legislation gave significant flexibility to the VDOT and even brought protection and liability in that legislation.
    • 02:31:28
      Sort of unique in that way.
    • 02:31:30
      And I will tell you here, there has continued to be reluctance
    • 02:31:34
      At the, throughout the agency and engineers thinking about needing to deliver a project of these current standards, I can tell you that today the chief engineer, myself, and the chief deputy commissioner have made very clear that in all nine districts that the rural rustic standard will be the standard we use unless there's a compelling reason to do a lot of this.
    • 02:31:59
      So again, we have continued, we've made it very, very clear to our staff because again, the goal of this is to get, frankly, get our folks out of the mud in those areas where they want their roads hard surfaced, to do that in an affordable way within the context and the sensitivity of the surrounding environment.
    • 02:32:20
      and not to build, we're not building a new subdivision road, we're not building a modern highway, we're simply getting folks to get out and run, so that's been reinforced aggressively by both of myself as the chief engineer.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:32:50
      Yes, Mr. DeBruhl, as the risk is sounding parochial, the current program versus the recommendations are going to have quite a significant negative impact on the county of Loudon.
    • 02:33:08
      Have you been in any further discussions with them about that big gelt of announcement of existing, between what they thought they had and now what they'll be receiving of the improvement?
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 02:33:19
      Mr. Chairman, Mr. Garasinski, we've had extensive discussions with Loudoun County and it's actually 26 counties that are receiving less under the legislative change.
    • 02:33:30
      It's not just Loudoun.
    • 02:33:32
      But we have had extensive discussions with Loudoun that are scheduled to go meet with them face-to-face the first week in June to talk about this particular funding
    • 02:33:43
      option and also looking at some of their high priority projects and how they could be done at a lower cost using the rural rustic road concept.
    • 02:33:51
      So it's kind of a two-fold piece.
    • 02:33:56
      We actually have two more slides real quick.
    • 02:34:03
      I know you're ready to move on.
    • 02:34:05
      In terms of funding for the high-volume, unpaid road, this isn't a huge program.
    • 02:34:12
      We're talking about a 10% set-aside off of a 5% set-aside.
    • 02:34:15
      So, in terms of fiscal year 17, we're talking about $700,000.
    • 02:34:20
      Right around 10 million dollars over six years.
    • 02:34:24
      Years 17 through 20 are shaded because there has been some dialogue that may or may not be subject to House Bill 2, so trying to manage expectations of some of our partners, we're just adding that cautionary note.
    • 02:34:36
      In terms of timeline, presenting our recommendation to you today with the intent to come back to you at the June meeting with a resolution to then implement this approach for these two particular set-asides.
    • 02:34:49
      We would immediately be prepared to issue a call for applications with applications being due August 1st which would allow us to come back to you at your October meeting with another briefing with some recommendations for funding and then final allocations to be presented in November.
    • 02:35:06
      That would allow localities to then move forward and be ready to have these projects advertised and ready to go for the next paving season.
    • 02:35:13
      So a little bit of an aggressive schedule, but we're lined up and ready to do that if the board desires.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:35:26
      One of the things we found, there was some very aggressive use of this money by some localities.
    • 02:35:33
      You know, it's really questionable how you're popping down a few trees and it's unpaid and what wasn't there before is now an untrained road.
    • 02:35:40
      I'm just saying we're trying to make sure it's fair to everybody in our case.
    • 02:35:46
      Okay, thank you.
    • 02:35:48
      I think that concludes our workshop agenda.
    • 02:35:52
      A lot of people have been here for a long time, so we're going to move, before we take a break, right into public comment, because many of you have been here, actually, for two days.
    • 02:36:04
      So, I'll officially call to open the
    • 02:36:08
      This is a formal action item, but our first thing will be to call up those people who wish to speak.
    • 02:36:17
      We have, I don't know, eight or ten that asked that our rule is around three minutes, but we'd like to hear everyone here today.
    • 02:36:27
      So, I'll call you up in the order in which you signed up, and the first is Mr. Dennis Workman.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 02:36:40
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, Members of the Board.
    • 02:36:45
      I'm Dennis Rooker.
    • 02:36:46
      I'm a resident of Albemarle County for more than 40 years.
    • 02:36:50
      The Route 29 corridor solutions which Philip Chukette brought to you yesterday are sound recommendations that are supported by years of previous traffic analysis and environmental studies performed by VDOT, the EPA, the Corps of Engineers, and other federal and state agencies with jurisdiction over federally funded transportation projects.
    • 02:37:11
      I've had much background and experience with these issues as I served on the Albemarle County Planning Commission for four years, the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors for 12 years, the Charlottesville Albemarle MPO for 10 years, and the City, County, and UVA Planning and Coordination Council for 12 years.
    • 02:37:30
      I know that I am speaking for thousands of my prior constituents and expressing appreciation for moving forward to a point of final decision.
    • 02:37:40
      Completion of this project list will provide the area with important functional transportation improvements that will serve local and through traffic for many years.
    • 02:37:51
      One of the things I wanted to address was a question that came up yesterday about what the parallel road component of this plan will do for through traffic.
    • 02:38:02
      Eighty-seven percent of the traffic in the corridor today is local, meaning 13 percent is through traffic.
    • 02:38:09
      Of that through traffic, a little over a third is actually through north-south traffic.
    • 02:38:15
      That translates into about 2,000 vehicles a day through north-south traffic on that section of the road today.
    • 02:38:25
      You have below you, when you come out the door of the hotel, the bottom of the hill, I think the only 8 and 10 lane section of Route 29 in the state.
    • 02:38:35
      That widening was done at a cost of about $100 million, and there's a further widening planned, as you know.
    • 02:38:41
      It would be about another $50 million.
    • 02:38:44
      The Pale Ale Roads will take a substantial portion of the local traffic, the 87% of the traffic, off of Route 29, freeing up a huge amount of capacity on this 8- and 10-lane section of Route 29 for the 13% of through traffic to use.
    • 02:39:03
      Combining this additional capacity
    • 02:39:05
      with the installation of a state-of-the-art adaptive signalization system, which is already in the works, and an overpass at Ryer Road will provide for a very significantly improved flow of traffic in this corridor for many years.
    • 02:39:20
      And again, I say that out of long experience.
    • 02:39:22
      I've been involved in every traffic study that has ever been done in this area over the last 16 years.
    • 02:39:28
      I also want to thank VDOT and the CTB for its creation and installation of the Rural Rustic Road Program.
    • 02:39:38
      It has been a terrific success in Avonrall County and has resulted in many of our citizens having better roads than they would have had otherwise.
    • 02:39:47
      Thank you for your consideration.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:39:50
      Next is Trent Pollock.
    • Trip PollardLeader, Land and Community Program
    • 02:39:58
      My name's Trip Pollard with the Southern Environment Law Center.
    • 02:40:01
      You all have covered an awful lot of ground in this workshop meeting.
    • 02:40:05
      I'd like to just touch briefly on two items you've talked about a lot, the 460 and the 29 quarter.
    • 02:40:12
      The Route 460 proposal is a proposal that has quite a history of issues and problems.
    • 02:40:19
      I think it's outrageous that this much money was spent with the risk involved and with what we have to show for it.
    • 02:40:27
      Mr. Secretary, as you said, I think it was far too aggressive in the pursuit of this project and that too much risk was taken on by the state and by taxpayers.
    • 02:40:39
      As Charlie Kilpatrick mentioned, the Corps of Engineers was involved for a long time and has been involved for a long time with this project.
    • 02:40:44
      In fact, they've been warning for over a decade about problems with the possibility of permitting this project.
    • 02:40:51
      So there have been red flags raised with us for quite a while.
    • 02:40:55
      I think this saga highlights a lot of the problems with the PBTA as well as problems with the delineation process and with the failure sometimes to heed the red flags that are put forth.
    • 02:41:09
      So I haven't seen the resolution yet or the language that has been circulated to you all, but the idea certainly of increasing the transparency, increasing competition, and giving greater input and information to you all as well as to the General Assembly
    • 02:41:24
      are all positive and critical steps, and I urge you all to adopt them.
    • 02:41:29
      I also support the call, although, again, haven't seen any details on this, about a revised process for wetland delineation, as well as new rules for high-risk projects.
    • 02:41:38
      So we do have some more short circuits built in the process to address projects that do have these red flags to better protect taxpayers.
    • 02:41:47
      There are also some specific questions that have been raised about the purpose and needs of some of the discussion you had this morning for this project.
    • 02:41:54
      I'm not going to get into it in the limited time here this morning, but there are some comments today that require some further, I think, discussion and examination to make sure that we don't waste further money on trying to build the wrong project for what the needs are, in fact, in this corridor.
    • 02:42:11
      We support improving Route 460, but not a new 55-mile highway about one mile from existing one.
    • 02:42:20
      I'd like to turn now to Route 29.
    • 02:42:21
      I was a member of the advisory panel, and we strongly support the recommendations overall.
    • 02:42:29
      I wanted to address some of the issues that came up yesterday and arose in your discussion.
    • 02:42:35
      But first, I'd like to thank Commissioner, former Commissioner Schuchat for leading the panel, thank VDOT and DRPT staff for their work, and especially thank Secretary Lane for the initiation and framing of this process.
    • 02:42:48
      and the Governor for his support for pursuing alternatives in the quarter.
    • 02:42:53
      Like Mr. Rooker's, but before me, I've been involved in every study just about in the 29th quarter.
    • 02:42:58
      I've been working on this issue for about 20 years.
    • 02:43:02
      And I can honestly say I feel like we are possibly closer today to making some of the most meaningful changes to improve this quarter than we've been in a long, long time.
    • 02:43:12
      One particularly important point that I think you need to keep in mind is one that Mr. Rooker just emphasized, and that's the fact that 85 to 90 percent of the traffic on this section of Route 29 is local traffic.
    • 02:43:23
      The parallel road network was designed and modeled over a 10-year period and refined as ways to get some of that local traffic off of 29, which will have enormous benefits for through traffic as well as local traffic.
    • 02:43:37
      One of the many shortcomings of the bypass proposal was it did next to nothing for the 90% of traffic that's local and would have still been stuck on 29 had that been built.
    • 02:43:47
      So this package, I think, does much more to balance and address both through and local traffic.
    • 02:43:55
      There were also questions raised about the full funding of projects that are already in the Six-Year Plan.
    • 02:43:59
      I think this is critical.
    • 02:44:01
      These are priorities that have been identified again and again by all the players involved,
    • 02:44:06
      over the years, and they are not necessarily going to move forward without that full funding.
    • 02:44:11
      Some of the other members of the committee said, for example, shouldn't the localities pay for some of that?
    • 02:44:16
      Well, if you're going to wait for that, you may be waiting a long, long time for some of those critical pieces of the network to be built.
    • 02:44:22
      And without those parallel roads being built, it's going to be much, much harder to build either of the pre-interchanges at Rio or hydraulic
    • 02:44:32
      because you need a way for traffic to get around during the time of construction of those interchanges.
    • 02:44:38
      So not only is it important to build those parallel roads, but the sequencing is important as well.
    • 02:44:44
      They need to be built first.
    • 02:44:47
      So I urge you to fully fund the Six-Year Plan projects.
    • 02:44:50
      Third, it was said several times that this project is just a start.
    • 02:44:55
      I'd actually take exception to that.
    • 02:44:58
      I think this is an extremely important
    • 02:45:01
      steps that are more than just a start.
    • 02:45:04
      I think it's capable of significantly improving conditions for years to come, maximizing the investment taxpayers have made in this corridor, and making it function much more effectively for possibly decades to come.
    • 02:45:18
      The proposed package is a compromise.
    • 02:45:20
      Although I said we support it overall, we do have things that we don't agree with about it.
    • 02:45:26
      For example, the two worst choke points, every single study,
    • 02:45:31
      has looked at are hydraulic and Rio.
    • 02:45:33
      That's where the congestion is.
    • 02:45:35
      That's where most of the accidents are.
    • 02:45:37
      We support interchanges at both of those intersections.
    • 02:45:41
      Now, the package only calls for funding one.
    • 02:45:43
      I think that's critical.
    • 02:45:44
      I think Rio's very important and absolutely is going to show some of the most benefits out of anything in this package.
    • 02:45:52
      I think, as former Commissioner Schuchat mentioned, you need to be sure to do that right because I think that will help to alleviate some of the concerns about hydraulic.
    • 02:45:59
      And as he also mentioned, hydraulic is more difficult.
    • 02:46:02
      So I think it makes sense to go ahead with RIO, not try to do both, which I think would sink this whole package at the local level.
    • 02:46:10
      It has the preliminary engineering for hydraulic, and I think we could continue to move ahead with that.
    • 02:46:15
      And I think that additional steps need to be considered and move forward, including transit in the corridor, which dropped out after having been in every package we looked at on the panel, and looking at steps to eliminate some of those additional left turn movements.
    • 02:46:28
      I think that's another thing we can do to help both through and local traffic.
    • 02:46:33
      So I think I urge you, bottom line, to adopt this overall package.
    • 02:46:37
      I think we have some real meaningful, doable projects that can be done efficiently and effectively and within the money we have available.
    • 02:46:48
      And I look forward to seeing us move ahead with these improvements.
    • 02:46:52
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:46:53
      Thank you, Mr. Paul.
    • 02:46:54
      Meredith Richards.
    • 02:46:57
      Good morning.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 02:46:57
      Good morning.
    • 02:47:03
      Secretary Layne and members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board, I'm Meredith Richards, speaking on behalf of Seaville Rail in support of the second frequency of the Lynchburg train, which is part of the Route 29 advisory panel recommendations.
    • 02:47:19
      Nine years ago this month, a group of rail advocates in Charlottesville began raising grassroots support for enhanced intercity passenger rail on the Piedmont rail corridor, which parallels Route 29.
    • 02:47:32
      Within two years, we had organized 22 political jurisdictions from Danville to Manassas, as well as many citizens and organizations forming the Piedmont Rail Coalition in support of better inner-city passenger rail for the corridor.
    • 02:47:49
      With the help of our legislators and funded by the Kane Administration, the Lynchburg Northeast Regional Train was launched in October 2009.
    • 02:47:59
      And in every year since then, it has generated the highest ridership per train of all Virginia's regionals and has ranked number one in profit per passenger mile across Amtrak's entire system of over 150 regional trains on 20 corridors in 19 states.
    • 02:48:21
      We continue to work with our partner jurisdictions throughout the corridor to advance intercity rail.
    • 02:48:30
      And while I cannot say that there is consensus among all our partners concerning the advisory panel's package of recommendations, I can say there is consensus in their general support of a second frequency of the Lynchburg train.
    • 02:48:48
      The rail piece in the package of recommendations gives all our partner jurisdictions a $5 billion commitment for a second train to serve their communities.
    • 02:48:59
      Two factors in the remarkable success of the Lynchburg train have been its high on-time reliability and its travel time competitiveness.
    • 02:49:09
      With the travel time to Washington of 3 hours and 42 minutes from Lynchburg and 2 hours and 28 minutes from Charlottesville, the train is already faster than driving.
    • 02:49:23
      And a $9 million capital project in DRPT's draft Six-Year Improvement Plan will reduce that travel time by another 8 minutes.
    • 02:49:33
      The Lynchburg train's extension to Roanoke, coupled with the additional frequency of the train, will help create a balanced network of intercity passenger rail for Virginia, complementing the multiple regionals and planned extensions serving Richmond and Hampton Roads.
    • 02:49:53
      Seaville Rail strongly supports the $5 million down payment on the second frequency of the Lynch Road train as part of a balanced, multifaceted, and multimodal solution for Route 29.
    • 02:50:07
      We believe that ridership on the corridor will grow in proportion to the increased capacity as it does on inner city routes throughout the country and that the additional service will boost the economic interests of all our communities and improve mobility throughout the U.S. 29 corridor.
    • 02:50:28
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:50:30
      Thank you very much.
    • 02:50:32
      Next we have Pete Worsches.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:50:36
      Okay, we have Frank Purkitchen.
    • 02:50:48
      If I pronounced that correctly, I apologize.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 02:50:52
      Here's my writing, I'm sure it's on the singer.
    • 02:50:54
      Frank Burkhead.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 02:50:56
      Good morning.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 02:50:57
      I'm Frank Burkhead, I'm from Charlottesville, Alamo County, and I moved out across the street from here when I was five years old, so I'm
    • 02:51:05
      Quite familiar with the growth of 29.
    • 02:51:07
      I believe we must solve our traffic congestion problems in the Charlottesville region.
    • 02:51:14
      After the 29 bypass idea was killed in February, we've seen the advisory panel move forward.
    • 02:51:19
      However, these ideas have only been floated for about 75 days.
    • 02:51:24
      The panel recommended studying a hydraulic road.
    • 02:51:27
      What would it do to say not study Ryer Road as well?
    • 02:51:31
      Data should drive this process, not an urgency to move forward.
    • 02:51:35
      We have the ability to spend study money first and construct these projects provided they move the traffic and through the region.
    • 02:51:43
      My concern is that moving forward with only one flyover and some interchange concepts will essentially pave the way for concrete canyons.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:51:52
      Plus, during this construction phase, that will... Can you hear better now?
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 02:52:01
      I apologize.
    • 02:52:03
      My concern is that by moving forward with one flyover and some interchange concepts, we'll essentially pave the way for a concrete canyon.
    • 02:52:12
      Plus, during this construction phase that will last many years, there will be nothing but orange cones, jersey walls, and little places for detours.
    • 02:52:21
      This will permanently and significantly alter our community's landscape.
    • 02:52:25
      While I applaud this body's effort to move forward,
    • 02:52:28
      I believe that we should prove study money and not construction money until we know exactly how this will impact our community.
    • 02:52:36
      Additionally, I believe there's a misconception that if all the money is not spent, it will be lost.
    • 02:52:40
      It is my understanding that the money can be placed in a suspense fund for a period of time, thus allowing a careful study before it is so hurriedly spent.
    • 02:52:49
      I'm hoping Secretary Layne could clarify this point.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:52:52
      Thank you.
    • 02:52:56
      And I'm sure I'll not get this next one right here.
    • 02:53:01
      Michael DiGiugno.
    • 02:53:04
      DiGiugno.
    • 02:53:04
      Okay.
    • 02:53:05
      Nice to tell you.
    • 02:53:07
      Good morning.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:53:08
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary.
    • 02:53:09
      Good morning, Board, and thank you for taking the time today to hear us.
    • 02:53:15
      First, I apologize.
    • 02:53:16
      I'm coming into the game very late, so I spent a lot of time on the Internet studying last night what was taking place in Route 29.
    • 02:53:25
      I'm with Federal Realty.
    • 02:53:27
      We own two major projects on the corridor, and the immediate concerns that I see are
    • 02:53:35
      During construction, if you pull back on some of the slides I was looking at last night that I was provided, you'll see that there are many hundreds of businesses in the local area.
    • 02:53:48
      And business may not have a face, but they are relatives, friends, community members that run these businesses.
    • 02:53:57
      As some of the gentlemen pointed out earlier, 90% of the traffic
    • 02:54:01
      is local traffic and they support these businesses.
    • 02:54:04
      So one of the things that comes to mind immediately to me is during construction, they might be choked off, which would be a huge economic impact to the community and to the businesses that are there.
    • 02:54:19
      So I'd like to urge the board to see if we've done or can do an economic impact study
    • 02:54:26
      to see how it will affect during construction.
    • 02:54:29
      I think we all agree obviously 29 needs some improvements and I applaud the board.
    • 02:54:34
      I've only been in the Charlottesville area five years and I've seen it expand and build in traffic so that we definitely need to do something there.
    • 02:54:43
      But in addition to that concern about the economic impact is the speed
    • 02:54:48
      That we are moving forward with.
    • 02:54:51
      So I would urge that we step back, maybe take a look at the broader picture and see how the overall impact will be on the community.
    • 02:55:04
      And that's really all I have.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 02:55:06
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 02:55:10
      Good morning and thank you all for bringing your meeting to Albemarle and I hope you are enjoying your stay.
    • 02:55:27
      I represent the Whitehall District and Albemarle County on the Board of Supervisors only seven years in that role but a 30-year student citizen of land use and transportation issues.
    • 02:55:38
      And from the audience, what I've learned from the task force, I support their recommendations heartily for our Solutions for 29 and thank you, Mr. Secretary, for the public process to expedite this decision-making in the corridor.
    • 02:55:51
      Part of the support is based upon the successful improvement delivery that I've seen in projects in Northern Virginia and hope that we will benefit locally from the experience which VDOT more recently has in working with communities to bring projects successfully finished.
    • 02:56:09
      Walt Kelly had it right 55 years ago with Pogo, the cartoon who said, we have met the enemy and it is us.
    • 02:56:16
      And I have no debate today about origin destination of the 60,000 vehicles on this corridor, but one fact is immutable.
    • 02:56:24
      It is the huge majority of travelers in this corridor have local business, shopping, work, delivery, or shipping happening here.
    • 02:56:32
      In 2007, the VDOT Route 29 corridor study looked from 66 to the Carolina line and contains all the data to support the conclusions.
    • 02:56:43
      Recommended projects from that study to improve mobility are part of our local plans.
    • 02:56:49
      Our local goal has been to get more of us out of the way for the through traveler.
    • 02:56:57
      The parallel road network in our long-range plan adopted in 2005 was developed for that purpose.
    • 02:57:03
      Very significant changes are coming.
    • 02:57:06
      Our NSYNC light control synchronized lights for the whole corridor has been in process and funded locally for almost two years.
    • 02:57:15
      It was supposed to be up and running last summer, but we are expecting it pronto.
    • 02:57:21
      It is number one in our priority list.
    • 02:57:23
      Our experience with this system in the eastern part of Albemarle County has shown substantial reduction in travel times.
    • 02:57:30
      Throughout Virginia and other states, there have been dramatic improvements using this technology, including for side road intersections.
    • 02:57:38
      The area we need to and want to enhance is, as Dennis said, the only eight-lane section of 29 in Virginia.
    • 02:57:46
      The widening was done here at a cost of more than $100 million.
    • 02:57:49
      It is an asset we need to improve and continue.
    • 02:57:53
      It took us 15 years to accrue the secondary road funds for the part of the Meadow Creek Parkway, or the John Warner Parkway, which is now up and running, and a feeder road to the Rio Road intersection.
    • 02:58:05
      Other parallel roads, Hillsdale to the south and Bergmark to the north, are partially constructed with local funds and cross 29 at Rio in a loose S configuration.
    • 02:58:15
      They support both our city and county business main streets.
    • 02:58:21
      Yesterday, the question regarding the number of stoplights removed was raised.
    • 02:58:26
      I want to emphasize that in my view, more traffic improvement will result than just the removal of those four traffic lights for three travelers.
    • 02:58:34
      This is the beginning of refinements in the corridor, such as further left turn changes.
    • 02:58:40
      Safety will improve because our accidents are clustered at these intersections where our improvements will occur.
    • 02:58:47
      When the largest intersections with multiple turn sequences are streamlined through the separation of through and local vehicles, that in itself will speed up the entire corridor with synchronization.
    • 02:59:00
      There will be many more people using parallel road networks because of the improved crossings east and west.
    • 02:59:06
      The Berkmar section today delivers more shoppers to the shopping center to its east than Route 29 does.
    • 02:59:12
      The drivers have already moved.
    • 02:59:16
      More of our stores and the post office will add entrances from these parallel roads, and all these changes will open up capacity on the highest designed, most modern roadway in our area.
    • 02:59:28
      Our long-range plan has fully funded the widening of 29 from the river to the airport, or now Hollymede,
    • 02:59:33
      It's fully funded at three times since 1997.
    • 02:59:37
      Decisions made by others remove the dollars to other projects.
    • 02:59:41
      This history shows our area is committed to making corridor improvements.
    • 02:59:46
      But certainty is what we need.
    • 02:59:48
      Then we can work shoulder to shoulder with our business community and residents to help deliver these improvements.
    • 02:59:55
      If we can provide any information to you as you dig further into these task force recommendations, I invite you to reach out to us.
    • 03:00:02
      John Lynch can provide our contact information to you.
    • 03:00:06
      In closing, just a short story.
    • 03:00:08
      VDOT workers are our neighbors, and the VDOT community lost one of its longtime and most wonderful employees in 2013.
    • 03:00:16
      Ed Bailey, known to all of us as Blue, was a colorful historian of transportation, and he scraped me up off the road when my pony had dumped me in 1959 in the middle of Darth Road, and he was an adult at the time.
    • 03:00:30
      Plue was with VDOT in 1946 when the used bridge from Allegheny County was installed at 50 years of age in Advance Mills.
    • 03:00:40
      He was also present in 2010 and cut the ribbon on the replacement span which never would have happened without the diligence of many citizens and Quentin Elliott.
    • 03:00:49
      So thank you for keeping him on these projects locally.
    • 03:00:54
      We are ready to work with you to complete the task underway in the Charlottesville Outlaw MPO for more than 20 years to create parallel roads to get the locals like me more options to stay off 29 and free up the capacity for through travelers.
    • 03:01:08
      And thank you very much for your consideration.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:01:12
      Thank you.
    • 03:01:13
      That concludes all the people I have signed up, but is there anyone else here that would like to address the board?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:01:21
      Okay, hearing none, of course, would you like to put your questions into the formal session?
    • 03:01:34
      All right, two minutes.
    • 03:01:38
      We'll start in five.
    • 03:01:39
      It'll be 11.40 and we'll come back.
    • 03:01:48
      K. Matney
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:11:44
      Okay, the formal work session is now back in session and our first order of business is approval of the entire meeting's minutes.
    • 03:12:05
      Do I have a motion to approve?
    • 03:12:07
      Is there a second?
    • 03:12:08
      Okay.
    • 03:12:09
      I'll approve.
    • 03:12:13
      Say aye to the discussion or oppose the move on.
    • 03:12:17
      Our next is Mr.
    • 03:12:21
      Walton will talk to us about the website guidelines.
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 03:12:23
      Thank you.
    • 03:12:24
      Mr. Chairman, board members, item number one is a resolution.
    • 03:12:34
      We ask for your approval at the 2014 session, the General Assembly recodified Title 33.1.
    • 03:12:36
      time.
    • 03:12:37
      So as of October of this year, it will be Title 33.2.
    • 03:12:39
      There are a number of board regulations, guidelines, websites that will have to be updated.
    • 03:12:48
      And rather than bring every one of those to you for approval, we're asking for you to delegate that to the Commissioner and to the Director of the Department of Rail and Public Transportation so we can go ahead and make what are essentially just technical changes to all these documents.
    • 03:13:02
      So we would ask for your approval of the resolution.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:13:05
      Is this part of the codification process?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Chief of Policy and Environment
    • 03:13:10
      Well, as you said, Title 33.1 was last codified in the 70s, so it's been a while.
    • 03:13:17
      The code commission has a normal process they go through where I think next year they're going to take on education and recodify all the provisions dealing with education.
    • 03:13:27
      We've been working on this for two years and dealing with their staff, the staff from legislative services.
    • 03:13:34
      and going through and putting things and new orders and new chapters.
    • 03:13:40
      For example, the PPTA, which is in Title 56, will now be in Title 33.2.
    • 03:13:46
      The Transportation District Acts, under which the NVTA operates, which is in Title 15.2 today, that will be moved to Title 33.2.
    • 03:13:56
      So there are a number of code sections that are all going to be brought onto the offices of Title 33.2.
    • 03:14:02
      Well, actually have been, because the legislation is passed and signed by the governor.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:14:09
      Is there a motion on behalf of the board?
    • 03:14:14
      Second.
    • 03:14:14
      Any discussion?
    • 03:14:16
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 03:14:18
      Aye.
    • 03:14:19
      Any opposed?
    • 03:14:20
      Thank you.
    • 03:14:22
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 03:14:23
      Good morning, Dean.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:14:26
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary.
    • 03:14:28
      Good morning members of the committee.
    • 03:14:30
      I have two items, two actions for you.
    • 03:14:32
      One is for your approval of a contract for providing infrastructure resiliency protection services.
    • 03:14:41
      This is a replacement contract, a resiliency contract to Elite.
    • 03:14:45
      It is a five-year contract.
    • 03:14:47
      It is an on-call contract.
    • 03:14:49
      We estimate its value of $20 million over the five years.
    • 03:14:53
      Again, this is a replacement to an existing contract.
    • 03:14:58
      That we have today, which does expire in June.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:15:02
      Is it a different contract?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:15:04
      It's very similar to the previous contract.
    • 03:15:05
      We have updated the language to reflect the movement toward resiliency, much as work is done with Homeland Security and others move toward more resiliency protection.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:15:15
      Are you keeping it the current contract?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:15:17
      No, that contract will expire.
    • 03:15:19
      This is a new contract.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:15:20
      Is there a different person going to be performing the services?
    • 03:15:25
      Yes.
    • 03:15:25
      Okay, so we're changing actually the contract?
    • 03:15:27
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:15:28
      Elite was one of the subs on the previous contract.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:15:30
      They will now be awarded this contract.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:15:47
      I will be glad to clarify that for you, sir.
    • 03:15:51
      This is the Virginia Infrastructure, Physical Security, and Resiliency Protection Program.
    • 03:15:57
      These are cameras for monitoring our critical infrastructure sites such as our tunnels, traffic operation centers, and provide physical security.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:16:06
      Gates System.
    • 03:16:07
      You can't get access gates.
    • 03:16:09
      It's what I should call a physical security gate access point.
    • 03:16:19
      Not just there, but throughout our entire system of 200 plus installations.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:16:26
      And what was the price of the contract?
    • 03:16:28
      This is roughly $5 million a year.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:16:30
      Correct.
    • 03:16:30
      How does that compare to what we were paying previously?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:16:33
      Very similar.
    • 03:16:34
      We've been running about three to four million dollars.
    • 03:16:36
      I should also mention that there are these contracts available for other state agencies, localities that have used this contract in the past.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:16:45
      Okay.
    • 03:16:47
      We have a motion and a second.
    • 03:16:49
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:16:51
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 03:16:54
      Aye.
    • 03:16:54
      Opposed?
    • 03:16:54
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:16:56
      The next item is a resolution for the Interstate 81 multi-state corridor coalition grant.
    • 03:17:06
      The Interstate 81 corridor was a coalition formed in 2011 of the six states from Tennessee up to New York.
    • 03:17:21
      and is a coalition focused on improving safety, efficiency of freight and passenger movement that help save lives.
    • 03:17:29
      Of the six states, the coalition includes 19 local governments, 18 regional governments, 15 non-profit, non-governmental entities and 12 private sector entities including Virginia Tech.
    • 03:17:41
      In 2013, the Federal Highway Administration released a multi-state corridor operations management program grant opportunity to promote regional cooperation and planning, shared project implementation for projects, and improving multimodal transportation.
    • 03:17:59
      They awarded a grant to the ID one-quarter coalition in the amount of $545,000 for the coalition to develop an ID one-quarter freight information system.
    • 03:18:13
      Virginia is the administrative host of the ID one-quarter coalition through Virginia Tech, and so we're required, given there's money expended outside the state,
    • 03:18:23
      We are required by the Code to have the CTB authorize the Commissioner to enter into a contract and execute the partnership agreement with Federal Highway Administration for this project.
    • 03:18:37
      The purpose of the project is to create a freight information system for travelers, trucking community, truckers going up and down 81, travel times, incidents, weather, but really geared toward the trucking community broader than just your regular 511.
    • 03:18:55
      Access to truck parking availability, etc.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:19:04
      It says for the program transfers, it says for a certain amount of money for this particular
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 03:19:08
      This grant, yes, Ms. Williams, the grant is for $545,500.
    • 03:19:17
      That's the amount of the grant from Federal Highway.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:19:19
      This is a one-time grant.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:19:24
      Is there a second?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:19:31
      Second.
    • 03:19:33
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:19:34
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 03:19:38
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 03:19:39
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 03:19:49
      I have for your action today items on the transfers for the 2014-19 Six-Year Improvement Program from March 29th to April 25th.
    • 03:19:58
      The majority of the transfers are moving surplus funds from completed projects to scheduled projects, and I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:20:09
      Okay, is there a second?
    • 03:20:14
      Will these transfers effectively be getting down on the vouchers and the plans will be voting on in June?
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 03:20:23
      Yeah, those would be incorporated into the plan that's in the program that's adopted in June.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:20:28
      Okay.
    • 03:20:29
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:20:31
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 03:20:33
      Aye.
    • 03:20:34
      Opposed?
    • 03:20:34
      Thank you, Ms. Mitchell.
    • 03:20:38
      Ms. DeBruhl.
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:20:41
      Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, I have a resolution before you to deallocate funds under the Economic Development Access Program.
    • 03:20:49
      This deallocation was actually requested by Halifax County.
    • 03:20:53
      They had a project to Day Park that they requested and received $500,000 in Economic Development Access Funds back in 2009.
    • 03:21:02
      The county has decided not to proceed with the project at this time and has requested that the funds be deallocated and returned to the Access Fund Program Account.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:21:14
      Mr. Chairman, if I may, Ms. Valentine, the program that they
    • Jennifer DeBruhlLocal Assistance Division Administrator
    • 03:21:43
      This particular aspect of the Economic Development Access Program, if they don't have a named industry, they have to bond their project.
    • 03:21:50
      And if they don't have a named industry that shows investment in that area within five years, they may have to pay back the money.
    • 03:21:57
      We've extended through bond moratoriums now several times.
    • 03:22:01
      This project was at a point where the county was either going to have to give us another bond for another couple of years or just decide to shelve the project.
    • 03:22:09
      And rather than continue to invest in bonding that
    • 03:22:11
      That money in the event that somebody might come forward who wants the facility, they're turning it back in.
    • 03:22:18
      So it's very responsible.
    • 03:22:19
      They could come back at a later date, ask for funds for the project, and we could certainly entertain that request at that time.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:22:25
      I should have mentioned two things.
    • 03:22:27
      First of all, our new board members.
    • 03:22:29
      It's been the courtesy of the board that when there are specific items in the district, we allow the district member to make a motion or speak in favor of or not.
    • 03:22:40
      And second, by the time we go to the application or something, it's been a long process.
    • 03:22:56
      And so usually it's not one of attention.
    • 03:23:00
      It's one that, yes, we can't do or that doesn't mean they can't get the money back on the issue once they are ready.
    • 03:23:07
      That's the way these programs work.
    • 03:23:09
      So we have a motion.
    • 03:23:12
      Is there a second?
    • 03:23:13
      Second.
    • 03:23:15
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:23:16
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 03:23:18
      Aye.
    • 03:23:18
      Opposed?
    • 03:23:19
      Thank you.
    • 03:23:22
      Here's the point.
    • 03:23:23
      Ms. Gill, how are you today?
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:23:25
      Good.
    • 03:23:25
      How are you doing?
    • 03:23:26
      Mr. Secretary, members of the board, I'm here presenting a resolution for the board's consideration to enter into a new confidentiality agreement to maintain access to the current and future rail data collection by the Surface Transportation Board.
    • 03:23:44
      The Surface Transportation Board has custody of the confidential rail
    • 03:23:53
      The sensitive nature of this data, the Surface Transportation Board requires the execution of the confidentiality agreement with its users.
    • 03:24:00
      The Virginia Department of Transportation and the Department of Real and Public Transportation, along with their consultants, use this information for transportation analysis.
    • 03:24:08
      VDOT recommends that the Board authorize the Commissioner of Highways for his designee to execute the necessary agreement with the Surface Transportation Board for continued access to the confidential railroad data by both agencies.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:24:21
      That's correct.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:26
      Basically, we give real information you have to agree to that can be confidential.
    • 03:24:32
      That's part of what we use for planning purposes, both VDOT as well as part of our public transportation and probably WIC also.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:24:41
      Does that information include what's being carried out straight?
    • 03:24:45
      I don't know the extent to which the information and what the details, but the Brails considered proprietary information must remain.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:24:59
      Again, I don't know.
    • 03:25:00
      I just don't know that detail, whether it includes what it's actually carrying on point.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:25:05
      I mentioned this because the governor has just instituted a rail safety commission, which I have been named co-chair, along with the Secretary of Iran.
    • 03:25:17
      I'm trying to figure out what our goals will be.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:25:21
      I think, to my understanding, it's reconstructed historically, but I think it does include some general categories of the privacy of commodities, but not specifically.
    • SPEAKER_11
    • 03:25:34
      It includes origin and destination information, the type of the commodity, the number of cars, tons, revenue, length of haul,
    • 03:25:47
      My question is, if we sign this confidentiality, are we precluding the safety?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:25:56
      I know that's going to be one of the things from the safety report, is we want to know what's on these trains.
    • 03:26:05
      If nothing else, if it slides into the rivers on fire, we want to know what to use to put the fire out.
    • 03:26:10
      Do you see this any conflict at all?
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:26:14
      Mr. Chairman, I just want to raise an unrelated issue to this.
    • 03:26:17
      So there is an emergency order that has been enacted by the federal government that would require carriers of crude oil to notify the states when they're transporting and where they're transporting those things through various states or the Commonwealth.
    • 03:26:33
      So that type of information, I believe, will be available to that rail task force, the Surface Transportation Board,
    • 03:26:39
      who this current request is before is particular to put it mildly about these types of requests and you must specify exactly what you're going to use that information for and you must do that in advance and so there's been an ongoing dialogue with the Surface Transportation Board that's been going on for some months now and
    • 03:26:59
      The current request before them is to get this data for the purposes of freight planning in the long-range V-Trans process.
    • 03:27:07
      We could submit another request for a different type of information, but if we tacked it onto this request, it would push this one back and probably wouldn't speed up our ability to access that other information.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:27:17
      Okay, so we're not good.
    • 03:27:18
      We can always ask for our...
    • Nick DonohueDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 03:27:20
      Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:27:25
      Is there a motion?
    • 03:27:29
      Second.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:27:30
      Okay, any more discussion?
    • 03:27:33
      All those in favor, please say aye.
    • 03:27:35
      Aye.
    • 03:27:36
      Opposed?
    • 03:27:37
      Thank you.
    • 03:27:40
      And, Mr.
    • 03:27:41
      Page here?
    • 03:27:42
      Oh, we're recording this.
    • 03:27:43
      This is the one that, okay.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 03:27:47
      For the members of the board, we've had some, this is in regards to item number 11.
    • 03:27:53
      So, for this item, you generally receive some new information from the applicant that changes the
    • 03:27:58
      Martin, John K. Matney, John W. Fralin, John C.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:28:14
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 03:28:16
      I've had a discussion with the applicant and with our own department in current reporting this.
    • 03:28:25
      I was looking forward to discussing my friend, Mr. Scheck, on Mr. Mueller's comments in the last month.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:28:35
      Okay.
    • 03:28:37
      All right.
    • 03:28:37
      Well, then we'll defer this to another time.
    • 03:28:40
      Let's see.
    • 03:28:41
      Ms. Cole, we're number 80.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:28:44
      I will move the appointment of Mr. Garzynski as the Secretary of Commonwealth Transportation.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:28:51
      Second, the secretary duties are to sign the minutes and bond documents and otherwise leave them all recirculated.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:29:06
      And I just want to tell Pat, don't get too comfortable in that chair.
    • 03:29:12
      In a moment, you'll be springboarding right here.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:29:15
      It gets harder and harder.
    • 03:29:19
      He too, I guess, double salary.
    • 03:29:21
      You're welcome.
    • 03:29:23
      Zero.
    • 03:29:23
      Any discussion?
    • 03:29:26
      Let's say please say aye.
    • 03:29:28
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:29:28
      Thank you very much for serving.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:29:32
      I look forward to working with you.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:29:42
      Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, members of the board, on April 23rd, we took 15 design-bid-build bids, 15 total.
    • 03:29:53
      Ten of those are below 2 million.
    • 03:29:55
      Three are between 2 and 5 million.
    • 03:29:58
      2 or above $5 million.
    • 03:30:00
      One of those were rejected.
    • 03:30:02
      I'm seeking your approval to let one of those contracts, D-74.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:30:10
      Patrick.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:30:12
      I'm working here.
    • 03:30:14
      But none of those contracts, and I know we haven't put these provisions in, but none of those have an extraordinary issue for you to wear out.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:30:23
      No, sir.
    • 03:30:24
      And to highlight, we have a 606 project built here for the cooperative agreement between our VDOT, Enlaw, and Laval County.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:30:39
      I'm going to address those.
    • 03:30:41
      I'm kind of handling the design bid builds first, then I'll go into the design build.
    • 03:30:50
      It's a $9 million project in Montgomery County, D-74.
    • 03:30:54
      It widens 603 between I-81 and Route 11.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:30:59
      It's a straightaway project.
    • 03:31:09
      The contractor is Faulconer.
    • 03:31:42
      Yes, sir.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:32:15
      All right, I'll get through them quickly.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:32:43
      Let me see what you have on your screen.
    • 03:32:50
      Yeah, I'm seeking approval to let D-74, which is on your first page.
    • 03:33:12
      Yes, correct.
    • 03:33:21
      Well, what I'm doing is they're both under two parts of the code, so I take the design bid build, which is under one part of the code, and then the design build, which is under another.
    • 03:33:31
      The language is a little different, but I break it out into those two pieces.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:33:36
      Yeah, actually we already rejected it.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:33:42
      We're just seeking a motion to approve one.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:33:45
      The first one is on the Interstate 81.
    • 03:33:53
      Is there a motion for exception?
    • 03:33:58
      All those in favor say aye.
    • 03:34:01
      Aye.
    • 03:34:02
      Next is the rejection.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:34:06
      I'm not sure.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:34:20
      This kind of slipped in.
    • 03:34:22
      I don't believe you need to reject it.
    • 03:34:24
      We already rejected it.
    • 03:34:26
      We just need approval of what we're going to award.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:29
      There's not a requirement for you to approve the rejection or issue if you did.
    • 03:34:35
      Correct.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:34:38
      Yeah, it was 30% higher than what we thought it should have been.
    • 03:34:42
      Okay, moving on.
    • 03:34:43
      Then we have two design-build projects, which you see on page three is the first one, $77.4 million.
    • 03:34:52
      I'm seeking approval to award that project.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:34:57
      This project is what I call the Dulles Loop.
    • 03:35:01
      It's on the western side of the Dulles Airport, and it was jointly funded by VDOT, MWOC, and Iowa County.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:35:10
      Mr. Dr. Jensen, is there a motion?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:35:12
      There is a motion.
    • 03:35:14
      I'll ask the commissioner.
    • 03:35:17
      Charlie, we're working with the developer of the community in Brampton because there's a tie in here that needs to be traveled and we'll make sure that stays coordinated with Brampton.
    • 03:35:33
      Can I make a motion to accept the second?
    • 03:35:36
      Second.
    • 03:35:38
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:35:44
      How much of that does the project cost, or does that just stay in the ocean?
    • 03:35:48
      Is there any more money in that?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:35:49
      That should be the construction.
    • 03:35:51
      That's the total value, including, that's not the source of the funding.
    • 03:35:55
      So, in broad terms, it was one-third state, one-third MWAS, and one-third Latin County.
    • 03:36:03
      MWAS and Latin County is slightly less than one-third, but kind of in broader sense, it was a three-way agreement here.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:36:12
      The next project I'm seeking approval to award is the I-66 Route 15 interchange in Prince William County in the amount of $36 million.
    • 03:36:34
      No, if you look down at the bottom, the lower left, the 36 million is inclusive of preliminary engineering, utility relocation, quality assurance and quality control, and the construction of the project.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:36:46
      See, that's what I thought we were going to put on there after tonight, because that's what we were getting before, and I don't know if it adds up to a hundred million after, so I thought we were going through to believe that what we were going to look at on the bed amount is what was in the Six-Year Plan, specifically for that section.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:37:08
      We had Mr. Secretary too, so that the board could see a clear comparison of what we thought was going to cost versus what the actual debt amount was going to be.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:37:16
      Okay, but I mean, of the 36 compared to what we thought was going to be, are we behind or ahead of any law?
    • 03:37:28
      This is the first bit.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:37:31
      Mr. Secretary, on its face, we are some good, or I don't know,
    • 03:37:36
      But again, this is something that we have to be very clear about.
    • 03:37:42
      The parents of the board can say, are the bids coming in high or low or right on the money?
    • 03:37:49
      The challenge we have internally, again, we have a lot of gimmicks.
    • 03:37:54
      We have other things that are in the total cost of the project, but we'll ensure that's done.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:37:59
      Yeah, but I got it.
    • 03:38:02
      Some of those other things add up to what your original statement is.
    • 03:38:05
      All I'm saying is when you give us a contract, compare it to the original statement.
    • 03:38:13
      That's right.
    • 03:38:14
      Yes, that's right.
    • 03:38:15
      Now, if it ends up more, I got it.
    • 03:38:17
      At least up front, we need to make sure.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:38:19
      What Mr. Chairman, I would always say is
    • 03:38:22
      I'm going to just try to figure out where we're going to spend the $20 million.
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:38:31
      Yes, sir, that's correct.
    • 03:38:34
      It's some portion of approximately $20 million
    • 03:38:41
      The bids have come and there is some savings here, but it's not developed in 61A and 36.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:38:49
      So do we have an estimate of what the 36 actually compares to?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:39:04
      Can you look at the ad in the footnotes at the bottom?
    • 03:39:09
      So it includes the engineering, utilities, its QA, and construction.
    • 03:39:13
      What it does not include is right-of-way and other engineering work that we either have done, getting to this point, or will do, by called engineering, oversight work, to carry this out.
    • 03:39:26
      Let me ask you another question.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:39:28
      Is what we have left to do going to be more than $20,000?
    • 03:39:32
      No.
    • 03:39:35
      This was the lowest bid.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:39:49
      Is there a motion?
    • 03:39:52
      As every interchange of I-66, this is extremely important to the western part of Prince William County.
    • 03:40:00
      That service is Prince William and all the way up through to Leakeburg and eventually to Point Ross.
    • 03:40:06
      But this is critical because it's a chilling point, right?
    • 03:40:10
      And it's a dangerous chilling point without this interchange.
    • 03:40:13
      Mr. Chairman?
    • 03:40:15
      Yes.
    • 03:40:15
      Are two names sufficient for recommendation?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:40:19
      I don't recall, but it's more than two.
    • Trip PollardLeader, Land and Community Program
    • 03:40:37
      I don't know the total pool that started.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 03:40:44
      We did have three that were active.
    • 03:40:46
      In the actual short list of those three, one of the things that we did get probably a discount price.
    • 03:40:53
      In using the creativity of the submission design build, there was a flyover involved.
    • 03:40:58
      The winning bidder actually used a diverging diamond, which was a lower profile in there.
    • 03:41:03
      It does not give as much capacity, but it did meet the traffic standards.
    • 03:41:07
      So some of the detail it is, and that is something that the localities wanted a lower profile, and we ran off against them to make sure that we were
    • 03:41:18
      meeting their needs at the same time as we may be aware.
    • 03:41:21
      Does that answer the question?
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 03:41:22
      Yes, sir.
    • 03:41:24
      Yes, Paul.
    • 03:41:25
      If you could help out a layman, non-engineer, according to the footnotes, if a $36 million bid is not including design costs, why would a design bill probably bid not including design costs?
    • Charles A. KilpatrickVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 03:41:42
      It includes, the footnote, it includes the engineering fee, it includes utility relocation, it includes the QAQC portion of inspection, I'll call it, and it includes construction.
    • 03:41:57
      What it does not have, by way of acquisition,
    • 03:42:02
      And it does not have the engineering that we would either have done to get us to this point of delivering the contract and then the balance of what's called construction engineering, which is really inspection services.
    • 03:42:15
      On a design-build contract, our inspection level is considerably less because you have the built-in QAs, quality assurance, quality control.
    • 03:42:24
      So a lot of that is already built into the contract.
    • 03:42:27
      We still have a small amount of field engineering work that we will do.
    • 03:42:31
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:42:36
      We have a motion to get our second on the second.
    • 03:42:40
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:42:41
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 03:42:44
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 03:42:45
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:42:46
      Okay, thank you very much.
    • 03:42:49
      I think we have one item under new business, and that was the resolution that I had recommended for it.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:42:59
      Mr. Fralin?
    • 03:43:00
      Yes, Mr. Chairman, I'm going to move the resolution passing this resolution to the Commonwealth Transportation Board direction of the Office of Transportation and Public Health Partnership.
    • 03:43:14
      Mr. Chairman, I would like to raise and suggest an amendment that I mentioned that you would be able to take out of the language that the courts could see $100,000 in weekly direction from the U3 office.
    • 03:43:32
      Since we're really focused on risk, that's the main thing.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:43:36
      I would accept that as a friendly amendment.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:43:40
      We did a good second, sir.
    • 03:43:43
      We did a good second.
    • 03:43:44
      So, yeah, we did.
    • 03:43:46
      We did a second.
    • 03:43:47
      So, someone has to make a motion to do it.
    • 03:43:50
      Then we'll do a second action.
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:43:51
      I have a motion to bring the amendment to the strike, aligned with the call's decision on remitting employment.
    • 03:43:58
      I second that.
    • 03:44:00
      Okay, I'm second.
    • 03:44:00
      Okay.
    • 03:44:01
      First of all, those on the amended budget, all those in favor, please say aye.
    • 03:44:06
      Aye.
    • 03:44:06
      Aye.
    • 03:44:07
      Aye.
    • 03:44:07
      Aye.
    • 03:44:07
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:44:08
      Is there a second?
    • 03:44:11
      Any more discussion?
    • 03:44:17
      All those in favor please say aye.
    • 03:44:20
      Aye.
    • 03:44:21
      Opposed?
    • SPEAKER_08
    • 03:44:22
      Thank you very much.
    • 03:44:23
      That's all I had on the agenda.
    • 03:44:32
      I think our next meeting is a one-day meeting.
    • 03:44:52
      Thank you everybody.
    • 03:44:53
      And again, welcome to all of you members.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 03:44:59
      Welcome on board, looking forward to working with you.