Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 2/19/2014
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
2/19/2014
Attachments
Meeting agenda.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
Monthly transaction report.pdf
Map.pdf
Resolution.pdf
Public Comments
▶︎
0:28
Approval of Minutes January 15, 2014
▶︎
1:06
PROGRAMMING DIVISION
▶︎
1:15
1. Action on FY14-19 Six-Year Improvement through January 27, 2014.
▶︎
1:22
Fiscal Years 2014-19 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers, Dec.18, 2013 - Jan. 27, 2014.pdf
LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
▶︎
5:19
2. Action on Economic Development Access Program Project Bond Period Moratorium.
▶︎
5:22
Economic Development Access Program project bond period moratorium.pdf
3. Action on Virginia Byway Designation on Route 729 in Rappahannock County Located in the Culpeper District.
▶︎
5:42
Virginia Byway designation, Route 729, Rappahannock County.pdf
4. Action on Revenue Sharing Reallocation in Goochland County Located in the Richmond District.
▶︎
6:08
Revenue sharing reallocation, Goochland County.pdf
RAIL AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
▶︎
6:32
5. Action on FY 2014 Allocation to Mass Transit Reserve Fund.
▶︎
6:35
Recommendation for Fiscal Year 2014 allocation to Mass Transit Reserve Fund.pdf
SCHEDULING AND CONTRACT
▶︎
7:06
6. Bids.
▶︎
7:06
NEW BUSINESS
▶︎
15:41
ADJOURNMENT
▶︎
21:36
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:01
Everybody take your seats.
00:00:11
Let's move into the formal work session.
SPEAKER_06
00:00:20
I think our first call of the formal session to order.
00:00:28
Our first topic would be any public comments.
00:00:32
Anyone would like to address the board?
00:00:47
So there are no public comments.
00:01:00
Okay, our next topic will then move.
00:01:04
We have to approve the minutes, right?
00:01:06
So the approval of the minutes.
00:01:09
Any discussion on the minutes?
00:01:11
All those in favor, please say aye.
00:01:13
Aye.
00:01:14
You're approved.
00:01:15
Okay, first topic, programming division.
SPEAKER_01
00:01:18
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
00:01:22
For your action today, I have the transfers for the 2014 through 2016 Six-Year Improvement Program from December through January, moving surpluses off of projects to other projects to be used or to balance entries, especially if they're special funds.
00:01:36
I would like to point out on the less than 10% list, which is on the third page of the handout row C, based on a Hampton Roads Transportation Planning Organization Resolution, they are moving $44 million of the Hampton Roads Transportation funds to the I-64 capacity improvement project on the peninsula.
00:01:56
And that's the first time they've indicated a use of funds.
00:01:59
And I'll be happy to answer any questions.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:02
Do we have to prove that?
00:02:06
Do we have to move them off our books into a regional one?
00:02:10
That's a regional one.
SPEAKER_01
00:02:12
Because all that does flow through our books, per the MOA, we agree that...
00:02:16
It's an interesting question.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:18
I don't know if we can say no.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:21
Wait, wait, wait.
00:02:21
I don't know that we can say no.
00:02:23
Yeah, but we've had this debate before.
00:02:24
If we can't say no, then we can't say yes.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:26
Well, I think it's, yeah, two competing laws.
00:02:29
You have the law that says they control their use of monies, but we physically have it on our books.
00:02:35
She can't move it off our books until we tell them.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:38
This is like C-Mag and R2, you know, Northern Virginia and what they put in.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:42
We're the most required developers.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:43
We ought to get the legislature to fix that problem.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:47
HR, the HPAC does.
00:02:49
Does that fix the problem?
00:02:49
It fixes this problem.
00:02:50
It doesn't go on our books at all.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:52
Because I'll tell you, and I'm going to support it.
00:02:56
But if I had been voting at the TPO, I would have voted no.
SPEAKER_06
00:03:04
Well, you knew as much as I did.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:03:06
And I think there's some others in the room that would have voted no as well.
00:03:13
It was, in my view, it was not, and you heard me, I think you heard me speak to it.
00:03:18
No, you weren't there.
00:03:19
No, I wasn't there.
00:03:20
You weren't there, but I spoke to it, and I thought it was a bad decision.
00:03:26
because I thought that it was premature.
00:03:34
They took 40 or 50 million bucks from the new regional money and put it on a road widening project that we're in the midst of doing with statewide money.
00:03:47
and they did it to accelerate it past one intersection, one exit to the next on 64th.
00:03:56
Well, to accelerate the progress.
00:03:59
It's already planned.
00:04:03
The project's already planned.
00:04:05
It's on the books.
00:04:06
It was just funded to a certain place and they put some more money onto it.
00:04:10
The whole concept of having mega projects
00:04:14
They did exactly the opposite.
00:04:18
They picked a little bit out and they put it on an existing project to move it forward one exit.
00:04:26
And I'm like, stop.
00:04:29
You know, it didn't make sense to me, but it was sort of already done, and a couple of guys, you know, didn't like it either, but they weren't coordinated.
00:04:41
So it happened.
00:04:42
I didn't think it was good use of the money.
00:04:43
I thought it was premature.
SPEAKER_06
00:04:46
Martin, W.
00:05:00
But Diane has to have us say, move them all from VDOT's books into theirs.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:05:05
Okay, is it seconded?
00:05:08
Second.
SPEAKER_06
00:05:08
Okay, all those in favor, please say aye.
00:05:11
Aye.
00:05:11
Any opposed?
00:05:12
I'm excited.
00:05:13
Okay, Mr. Miller stinks.
00:05:15
Alright, so we move the transfers.
00:05:16
Okay, Mr. Bruehl.
SPEAKER_00
00:05:19
Mr. Chairman, I have three items for you today.
00:05:22
The first one is, I presented last month the situation with our Economic Development Access Program.
SPEAKER_06
00:05:28
We have a resolution for your consideration today which recommends a two-year extension of that bond moratorium.
00:05:42
We've got the byway designation.
SPEAKER_00
00:05:45
This is an extension of an existing byway located in Rappahannock County.
00:05:50
It's an additional five miles that would be brought into the Virginia Byway System, which would give us a total just shy of 3,500 miles statewide.
SPEAKER_06
00:05:59
Just to talk?
00:06:01
Is there a second?
00:06:02
Second.
00:06:03
Any discussion?
00:06:04
All those in favor, please say aye.
00:06:07
Aye.
00:06:07
Okay.
SPEAKER_00
00:06:08
Item 4 is a request from Goochland County to reallocate some residual revenue sharing funds from a completed project to fund a new sidewalk project that they would be able to take to construction in June of this year.
SPEAKER_06
00:06:19
First or second?
00:06:23
Discussion?
00:06:24
All those in favor, please say aye.
00:06:26
Aye.
00:06:26
Okay.
00:06:28
Thank you.
00:06:28
Okay, Mr. Pittard's here.
00:06:32
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
00:06:35
We're here today to request your approval
00:06:37
of a $3.7 million allocation to the Mass Transit Reserve account.
00:06:43
As you recall, this account was recommended in our December actions on the capital allocation process for our transit funds.
00:06:54
Is there a motion for approval or transfer?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:57
Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_06
00:06:58
Is there a second?
00:06:59
Second.
00:07:00
Any discussion?
00:07:01
All those in favor, please say aye.
00:07:03
Aye.
00:07:04
Opposed?
00:07:05
Okay.
00:07:06
All right, now we're down to bids.
00:07:10
Now, one thing you'll notice on here, we always had discussion on when you looked at the number to the right and to the left, those are now apples and apples.
00:07:22
That's the part of the contract that you see over to the right is what we thought the contractor was going to provide.
00:07:28
So you now have good, you should have the, when you look at that, if we're over or under, that is a true over or under where we are with that part of the contract.
00:07:38
Times are changing.
00:07:39
Yeah, times are changing.
00:07:40
You're right, they are.
00:07:41
We have a few that are over.
00:07:42
It happens to be, and we'll let Mr. Stiles talk, a place where we have a soul that does most of the work in that part of the state, but nonetheless, I prefer it with Mr. Stiles.
Don Silies
Director of Contracts
00:07:53
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
00:07:54
I bring before you today both bid-build and design-build projects.
00:08:00
In the bid-build project arena on January 22nd, we brought in bids on 117 projects.
00:08:08
This is one of our biggest lettings of the year.
00:08:11
Those projects were valued at $293 million.
00:08:15
Probably about $225 million of those are asphalt plant mix type contracts.
00:08:23
The law requires that the CTB let any projects over $5 million.
00:08:29
So there are 12 of those included in your ballot.
00:08:33
And I'm prepared to answer any questions about those.
00:08:35
They're all paving-type projects.
00:08:38
Yes, sir?
SPEAKER_06
00:08:39
Yes?
00:08:40
In here, I see like within my district, I've got two $7 million contracts, plant-based.
00:08:46
In some cases, so-called overlapping counties, one is four county givers, two.
00:08:52
Why is there two contracts?
00:08:53
Why isn't it different?
00:08:54
Well, it could be for a couple of reasons.
Don Silies
Director of Contracts
00:09:00
It could be their systems, doing secondary systems, which would be funded primarily with state funds.
00:09:07
It could be counties.
00:09:08
It could be just manageability of the contract.
00:09:12
Asphalt is very location-specific.
00:09:16
You can't haul asphalt at a certain distance, so sometimes they're organized so that you get competition amongst people.
00:09:26
Otherwise, there'd be locations in the state where you would have no competition.
SPEAKER_06
00:09:30
It's the same contractor as maintenance funds.
00:09:34
It's all those elements of this.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:40
A couple of comments regarding that.
00:09:44
One is that, again, as Mr. Siley said, we will advertise within a district.
00:09:51
We may advertise multiple contracts.
00:09:54
In some cases, we will advertise the interstate contract
00:09:57
Martin, W. J. Peake, Roger Cole, W.
00:10:23
If we take a particular construction district and lump all the asphalt into one contract, you get, again, you may drive out if it's a single contractor that wins the bid.
00:10:38
This is increased compensation.
SPEAKER_06
00:10:39
Absolutely.
00:10:41
I've got to understand.
00:10:41
If that's the case, I understand it.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:43
There's also a couple of interesting points in terms of there are some bids
00:10:48
That are above what we'd estimated, but there are a number that are below.
00:10:51
The other piece is that we are seeing, especially in paving, we're seeing contractors coming in from adjoining states, both in Southwest Virginia as well as Maryland D.C. coming into Virginia.
00:11:07
And what that is doing is that, again, helping keep the prices down.
00:11:11
In areas where, I'll use Southwest Virginia as an example, where there is limited competition.
00:11:17
I note here that a couple of these contracts is a contractor out of Tennessee that's picked up some of the work down there.
00:11:25
And again, that's good for us because it maintains competitive attention.
SPEAKER_06
00:11:31
In past years we've had only one competitor in that area.
00:11:48
Absolutely.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:56
We will take any time on either a contract that's high or low from, the numbers you're seeing here are what we would call public numbers on our estimates.
00:12:08
We also do what we'll call a confidential estimate internally to make sure that we know where our bids should come in.
00:12:17
So we're doing an inside check on these bids.
SPEAKER_06
00:12:23
Absolutely.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:25
We also check for what we call unbalanced bidding and obvious errors in bids.
00:12:31
And sometimes we'll have to go back to the contractor
00:12:34
and Don and his team will say, are you sure?
00:12:37
Because it appears that there's an error in your bid.
00:12:41
Because we don't want to award a contract when we know there's an obvious misstep or an error in the bid.
SPEAKER_06
00:12:51
Thank you.
00:12:51
Any more comments?
00:12:52
All those in favor, please say aye.
00:12:54
Aye.
00:12:54
Are we closed?
Don Silies
Director of Contracts
00:12:56
We also have three design-build projects valued at about $45 million, and those are also listed in your ballot, and I'm prepared to answer any questions about those, if there are any.
00:13:11
One in Fairfax, one in Loudon, and one in Carroll County.
00:13:16
Is there a motion for approval?
SPEAKER_06
00:13:18
So moved.
00:13:18
Second?
00:13:19
All those in favor, please say aye.
00:13:22
Aye.
00:13:22
discussion?
00:13:23
Hold on, Mr. Louderback.
00:13:24
Just in general on this, I've raised this question before, I think for you Mr. Secretary, are we now considering or looking at, even though we have budget figures and estimates on what these projects are going to be, keeping those in-house as opposed to letting the public know what they are, where the bidders know what we're willing to pay or think we might be willing to pay?
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:47
Well, and that's, Ms. Lauter, you've talked about the, that we put an estimate, or we put a budget, rather, in the Six-Year Plan for right-of-way for engineering and for construction.
00:14:02
And the question is really, does that drive the bidders to say, well, I'm going to bid the number that's in that contract, or in that budget?
00:14:11
We really frankly have not seen that.
00:14:15
We've seen, again, even this lighting, we're still seeing pretty good competitive tension.
00:14:21
There's a bit of a challenge in lumping everything into one number.
00:14:28
Frankly, a lot of our systems are not
00:14:31
Martin, W. J. Peake, Roger Cole, W.
00:14:50
Now this estimate that I speak of, which is really an internal check to make sure that we're comfortable that the bids we receive are appropriate, that we can hold confidential.
00:15:03
But again, because of the nature of the Six-Year Plan and how the money flows in, I just think it would be very difficult to, I'll call it difficult to blend or camouflage.
00:15:11
What we think the construction cost is going to be in our six-year plan.
SPEAKER_06
00:15:15
But the key is we've talked a lot about is a good competitive process.
00:15:22
In other words, making sure we have a good competitive process.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:27
It is as long as you got more than one bidder.
SPEAKER_06
00:15:29
As long as you got more than one bidder.
00:15:30
You're right.
00:15:31
I understand.
00:15:32
You're right.
00:15:34
Any other discussion?
00:15:36
All those in favor please say aye.
00:15:37
Aye.
00:15:38
Opposed?
00:15:40
Okay, I think that's it.
00:15:41
Is there any new business to come before us today?
00:15:44
Mr. Chairman, I'd like to bring one thing up just because I'm relatively new and trying to keep up.
00:15:48
And I know Carol sometimes doesn't get the materials until right before we meet.
00:15:53
But it would be very helpful for me at least to have these materials at least several days in advance so that we can go through them.
00:16:00
It would help the meetings, I think, go faster.
00:16:02
And I just, you know.
00:16:05
That's, well, this past week was my fault.
00:16:08
I'll make sure to get it out.
00:16:11
I'll take that.
00:16:12
But yeah, it's a good comment.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:16
Mr. People.
00:16:17
Mr. Secretary, I don't necessarily do business with the comment.
00:16:20
I appreciate the Secretary's office.
00:16:23
Once we're going along Route 29 and when the governor's office is dealing with it, I know it's a touch of a political situation.
00:16:31
And I know there are a lot of different factions to do it, so I appreciate the efforts to address the situation.
00:16:37
And just for the rest of the board, and I know most of you have heard me talk about it a long time, we stated, Route 29 starts at the North Carolina border.
00:16:46
It's on the ground end with a one-stop light.
00:16:50
Martin, W.
00:17:07
to Charlottesville, there's one stoplight in Livingston.
00:17:11
That's in Nelson County.
00:17:13
That was put in about five years ago.
00:17:15
That is the only stoplight in Nelson County.
00:17:18
So you go 60 miles from Lynchburg to Charlottesville with one stoplight, and you go from the North Carolina border up to the outskirts of
00:17:28
Ledsburg was probably one stoplight in there four or five, which is too many, and we've talked to Campbell County about protecting that corridor.
00:17:36
And then you have three mile stretch in Charlottesville, where you have 22 plus stoplights and traffic comes to a halt and a dead stop.
00:17:48
And so, I apologize for belaboring this point, but it is a significant issue for the Lynchburg District, which goes from the North Carolina line of Danville all the way to the end of Nelson County, where we have probably six stoplights on US 29 on our way to try and get to DC, and then all of a sudden you have 20 or 30 in a three-mile stretch.
00:18:10
So, thank you for your indulgence and your patience.
SPEAKER_06
00:18:14
Any other comments or new business for the board?
00:18:20
Is it possible to appreciate the legislative update?
00:18:27
Is it possible to get anything on a more timely basis as things change on some of the primary or key legislative issues?
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:43
And the other thing that would be helpful is if VDOT has chosen to take a position, what VDOT does not do.
SPEAKER_06
00:18:50
Yeah, that right now, there really are no positions because of the negotiations going on with the...
00:18:58
The only thing we're taking is against.
00:19:02
And that's based on if they're... And I'm just getting to be with the process too.
00:19:07
What happened in crossover, everybody got their bills and this week's budget we're all due this Sunday.
00:19:15
So we got the first look at both the House and the Senate's bills.
00:19:19
We had until Tuesday to identify to the governor's office
00:19:24
What are major areas of concern?
00:19:26
In fact, one thing I didn't bring up today is there's a bill out there and we just let it go.
00:19:32
We're going to repeal the sale of diesel fuel.
00:19:37
You have to turn your receipts in to get your rebate if you use it off-road.
00:19:42
Well, now they're just going to give you $20 off your license renewal.
00:19:48
Well, that cost us about $1.5 million.
00:19:50
I mean, it's not
00:19:52
A lot of money, but on the other hand, I mean, there's quite a few of those going through there, the most significant being the hybrid.
00:19:59
But, what we then do, up until then, we've been negotiating, trying to get things done, killed, whatever, but now it's really in the Governor's hands as to what he's going to raise to a level of concern.
00:20:13
We've given him what our major concerns are, and some of the things y'all have raised today are all our major concerns.
00:20:19
Whether or not they rise to his concern as he goes through what his plan is, that's up to him.
00:20:25
So, I assume that a couple of buyers will make it in, but I don't know that for a fact.
00:20:32
Yes?
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:33
How much was the average going to be?
SPEAKER_06
00:20:35
About $10 million dollars.
00:20:37
$10 million dollars.
00:20:38
$10 million a year.
00:20:40
A year.
00:20:40
$10 million dollars a year.
00:20:42
The other one that we didn't talk about, I'll just quickly go, is that, and we were going to do this, is moving the DMV easy pass, the two DMV easy pass, eliminating the 50 cent or whatever it is per month.
00:20:53
Mr. Lawson's
00:20:54
My favorite topic that I bring up.
00:20:58
But that is now going to be a law that also tells us that we didn't oppose that.
00:21:03
We were going to move that way anyway in that report.
Mark J. Peake
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:06
One final question.
00:21:09
What is the timeline for the increase in sales taxes for internet sales?
SPEAKER_06
00:21:15
That is January 15th, a year from now.
00:21:21
Yeah, that will not be good news for our transit folk because they lose out on that if we revert to the additional motor diesel tax, fuel tax.
00:21:35
Okay, well thank you very much.
Charles A. Kilpatrick
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:36
Meeting is adjourned.