Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 1/19/2011
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
1/19/2011
Attachments
Meeting agenda.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
Economic development access, Wood Fuel Developers LLC (rescinding June 16, 2010, action and project 0740-040-720, M501), Project 0740-040-723.pdf
Surplus land conveyance, Interstate 95, Greensville County.pdf
Surplus land conveyance, Route 665, Bland County.pdf
Surplus land conveyance, Route 676 (Riley Road), Fauquier County.pdf
Public Comments
Approval of Minutes December 8, 2010
LOCATION AND DESIGN
1. Action on Approval for Pacific Boulevard Extension.
Approval for Pacific Boulevard Extension.pdf
2. Action on Approval for Virginia Capital Trail Specifically the Courthouse East Phase.
Approval for Virginia Capital Trail - Courthouse East phase.pdf
LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
3. Action Economic Development Access:
RIGHT OF WAY DIVISION
4. Action on Surplus Property Land Conveyance Specifically:
ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DIVISION
5. Action on Land Disposition Specifically the Old Church Area Headquarters, Hanover County, Virginia
Land Disposition – Old Church Area Headquarters, Hanover County, Virginia.pdf
PROGRAMMING DIVISION
6. Action on Addition of Various Projects to the Six-Year Improvement Program for Fiscal Years 2011-2016.
Addition of various projects to the Six-Year Improvement Program for Fiscal Years 2011 - 16.pdf
7. Action on FY11-16 Six-Year Improvement Program Transfers For November 9, 2010 through December 20, 2010.
Fiscal Years 2011 - 16 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers, Nov. 9, 2010, - Dec. 20, 2010.pdf
ROUTE 460 INDEPENDENT REVIEW PANEL
Route 460 Corridor Improvement Project_ Independent Review Panel recommendations.pdf
8. Action on Recommendations.
SCHEDULING AND CONTRACT
9. Action on Bids.
NEW BUSINESS
ADJOURNMENT
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:00
be delayed, but all right.
00:00:02
At this point, we'll close out the work session, go right to the main agenda of this Commal Transportation Board.
00:00:10
First thing is public comment.
00:00:11
They wanna have anything they would like, any person in the public like to speak regarding anything?
00:00:25
Mr. Pollard.
Trip Pollard
Leader, Land and Community Program
00:00:27
Good afternoon.
00:00:28
I'm Trip Pollard, Land and Community Program Director for the Southern Environmental Law Center.
00:00:33
I just wanted to touch real quickly on two things that you've covered this morning, one of which you're going to cover again shortly.
00:00:40
First is the General Assembly session.
00:00:42
There are a ton of bills and a lot going on, as the Secretary and others mentioned, and just wanted to say that we support and I wanted to highlight a couple of things that were presented this morning that we think are particularly important, such as creating the Rail Opportunity Fund
00:00:57
Operations Fund, which is critical going forward for Virginia's rail program.
00:01:02
We do hope that the money, though, is soon identified for how that fund will be, how that pot of money will be filled.
00:01:12
It's understanding that it will be proposed just to create the fund but not to actually fund it this year.
00:01:19
Also, I did want to mention one thing
00:01:22
It was not mentioned in your summary today because it's not an administration bill, but I think it's important to this board.
00:01:28
This touches on a lot of policies you all have grappled with over the year, and that is a number of bills that link or address the link between transportation and land use planning.
00:01:37
That's been a consistent priority for this board.
00:01:40
It's in VTrans and elsewhere.
00:01:42
There are a number of bills this session that would actually undo some of the gains we've made in this area in recent years, and I just wanted to bring that to your attention.
00:01:53
The other thing very briefly is 460.
00:01:57
There's been a lot of discussion back and forth and obviously you all are going to have your vote shortly on this resolution but we were one of the groups that did comment and we believe that these three proposals should be rejected because we believe there are cheaper and more effective alternatives to meet some of these very legitimate needs.
00:02:20
But our biggest concern is that fiscal impact and how are we going to pay for this.
00:02:25
So we think there's a huge cost subsidy as the Secretary said, PBTA's are not free and the public contribution is all over the place on these proposals.
00:02:36
Some of them could be as high as over a billion dollars and that's in addition to the toll money.
00:02:41
which is also coming out of the public's pocket.
00:02:45
Because of this, we do agree with the recommendation and the conclusion that none of the proposals as written are financially viable.
00:02:55
For that reason, we believe that these proposals should not be accepted at this point.
00:03:01
However, if you do vote to continue and move to the detailed phase,
00:03:05
I would urge two things.
00:03:07
One is to try to get a better handle on that amount of state contribution because it goes precisely to this prioritization question as a number of you have just mentioned, which is one of the big problems that we've had and keep running into with our PPDA program in Virginia is we have these proposals, we go down a certain number of paths down the road in terms of looking at them, and then we have to try to figure out how to pay for them without always
00:03:33
One of our biggest concerns is both the size of this subsidy and the fact that the money is better spent elsewhere in Hampton Roads on addressing the congestion problems on other parts of the transportation network, and unless those are fixed, whether you support or don't support a new 460 is going to be money that is not well spent.
00:03:56
So for these reasons, we would suggest not proceeding with this particular one at this point.
00:04:03
But again, if you do put those parameters on it in terms of the price and what is the public subsidy that we are willing to put up.
00:04:11
The other thing I just wanted to stress moving forward is the importance, it is one of the recommendations of a robust public involvement process.
00:04:18
You all only get to make a recommendation today from here on in the PPDA process.
00:04:23
The CTB really doesn't have any authority.
00:04:26
And that's, again, I think a larger question for another day of some of the improvements needed in the PPTA process itself.
00:04:33
But it is important to have that robust and meaningful public input.
00:04:37
In the last phase, there was a lot of information.
00:04:41
There were good and bad things about the public input.
00:04:43
There's a lot of information on the web.
00:04:45
But the deadline for public comments was just last Monday.
00:04:48
The IRP committee met and made its decision on Thursday.
00:04:52
And you all are being asked today to make your decision.
00:04:55
And we would submit that's not enough time for meaningful public input to be seriously considered.
00:05:00
So again, we applaud the commitment to the robust public input going forward, but would urge you to build in some more time for that public input to actually be taken into account in the decision-making process.
00:05:13
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:05:14
Thank you, Mr. Pollard.
00:05:15
Is there anyone else?
00:05:17
Okay, at this point, we will close out the public comments.
00:05:20
We have the minutes of December 8, 2010.
00:05:23
Do we have any changes, revisions?
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:05:25
Mr. Chairman, they're not in our package, but they were in what you sent us, what we linked to on the web, and I don't think they're here.
00:05:34
At least they're not in mine.
00:05:36
I couldn't find them all.
00:05:37
The location said we were here.
00:05:40
It said we were in Roanoke, and we were here both.
00:05:43
So we need to fix that.
00:05:45
It also implied on our vote on the enhancement program that we took a recorded vote, meaning a per person vote, because it showed some negatives on it.
00:05:57
I think it was a voice vote.
00:05:59
I did vote no, but I don't know how you record that.
00:06:02
when it's a voice vote, so point of information.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:08
Unenhancement program.
00:06:09
The Chair, Mr. Lyle, would like to know.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:14
I think we did both of them as voice votes, but it's.
00:06:18
We had a decibel meter on you, Chef.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:20
We just have a minute to reflect.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:28
All those in favor say aye.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:30
All opposed, thank you very much.
00:06:35
Go to location and design.
00:06:37
Mr. Thrasher.
SPEAKER_06
00:06:44
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:06:46
Members of the board, good afternoon.
00:06:48
Today you have an informational package placed in front of you dealing with the location approval for Pacific Boulevard, which is located in our North Virginia District Office.
00:06:57
The purpose of this project is to construct the missing link, Pacific Boulevard, between Dresden Street and Relocation Drive.
00:07:04
If completed, it will run the Pacific Boulevard from Nokes Boulevard to Ox Road, North Virginia.
00:07:10
I'd be happy to entertain any questions you may have.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:07:14
All those in favor say aye.
00:07:17
Aye.
00:07:17
Those opposed, thank you very much.
00:07:21
Mr. Hawthorne.
SPEAKER_11
00:07:27
Good afternoon Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
00:07:29
First let me introduce Ian McMilligan who is our project manager for the Virginia Capital Trail.
00:07:35
We are here today to ask for approval of a location for a particularly critical segment of the Capital Trail located in Charles City County.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:07:44
And I'll just point to it here.
00:07:47
It's just the same here in red.
SPEAKER_11
00:07:49
And it's particularly critical because it does establish the point at which we cross Route 5 with the Capitol Trail from the north side to the south side.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:07:59
To give you a little historical perspective,
SPEAKER_11
00:08:07
This segment here, in orange and red, the orange section, is in right away our position today.
00:08:27
And this segment in red is the location of the group today.
00:08:32
This particular segment has been somewhat controversial in that there were two options presented to the public, both of which
00:08:58
met with some opposition and some support and in the end we're recommending the north side of right five as shown here.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:11
In other words, we would follow between paths.
SPEAKER_11
00:09:17
That particular option is supported by the Charles City Board of Supervisors and it has some unique benefits that we see in that
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:47
We believe this is a better place to cross from a traffic safety perspective than this location which is located in the middle of a 55 mile an hour zone and in one of the few passing zones in Charles City County.
SPEAKER_11
00:10:02
So it's our recommendation that the board approve the green alignment as shown on this map today.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:11
I move approval.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:12
Second.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:14
All right, so this is, I'm sorry, before I, I just want to make sure this issue on this crossing the street, all right, it's going to be safe?
00:10:24
You've got a golf cart.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:27
At least to July 1st.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:30
Safe, safe, I mean, I guess that's the biggest thing on this, so we're moving the alignment because of opposition.
SPEAKER_11
00:10:37
No, I'm just talking about the general fact that we have an alignment on the southern side of Route 5 the entire distance you go north then you go south again, right?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:09
So, for the most part, the trail's on the southern that it crosses to the northern part?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:17
No, sir.
SPEAKER_11
00:11:19
The trail is located on the north side of the road from just east of the J. Conroy Bridge.
00:11:28
Right.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:28
All the way up to, as we focus to the north period where it crosses, right by the south side,
SPEAKER_11
00:11:38
So it's safe.
00:11:45
It's going to be safe.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:02
Yes.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:02
Chairman, just to point out
00:12:06
Recently, being on the board, I wasn't aware of this project, and I certainly support the effort that's being made here, but can you tell me what cost?
00:12:14
This is just a bike and trail path, correct?
00:12:17
It's not a highway?
00:12:20
Am I missing something?
SPEAKER_11
00:12:21
No, sir.
00:12:22
You're exactly right.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:23
It's a multi-use path.
00:12:26
Okay.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:27
But for 2.26 miles, we're going to spend $3.6 billion on that?
00:12:33
Am I reading these figures right?
SPEAKER_11
00:12:35
Mr. Chairman,
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:05
I support this project as well, but I share my seatmate's concern.
00:13:12
I would tell you that I started to get involved in a trail in Norfolk that's sort of been under construction for some time, and the folks there would tell you that we apply standards that shouldn't apply to a bike path, because that's what we have.
00:13:30
Those are the standards that we operate under, and that they just shouldn't apply.
00:13:33
And it puts them through incredible hoops and incredible expense.
00:13:37
And I think we ought to take a hard look at that as to what standards we are applying for a bike path.
00:13:43
Obviously, they need to be safe and they need to be adequate to run on and to bike on.
00:13:47
But I think we may be in a situation where our bureaucracy has gotten ahead of us over the years, and we've applied a lot of standards that aren't necessary for the safety and so forth.
00:13:58
So I'm not for this project.
00:14:01
I'm not sure we're going to fix this issue today.
00:14:03
I'll support it, but I've got to tell you, a million and a half dollars for a mile of bike paths.
00:14:10
I've got a couple of boys at home, and they ain't working right now, and we can do some bike paths.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:17
All those in favor?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:18
We'll do it for a half.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:24
Currently, right now, did you say the trail starts on the east side of the bridge?
00:14:29
Is that right?
00:14:31
And the trail actually begins in Jamestown.
00:14:34
Right.
00:14:35
So currently, how does it cross the bridge?
00:14:37
Because I believe that's a single lane bridge with no shoulders.
SPEAKER_11
00:14:40
The bridge, the Chickahominy River Bridge has been recently replaced.
00:14:45
It's now a two-lane bridge, but it has a separate dedicated addition to
00:14:57
House or to connect the trail from one side to the other.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:01
Was the portion of that total $53 million for the entire project part of the bridge replacement, since the trail was incorporated into the bridge?
SPEAKER_11
00:15:11
No, sir.
00:15:12
The $53 million is just for the trail construction on either side of the bridge.
00:15:18
Mr. Estes!
SPEAKER_01
00:15:42
You have me filling in, Julie Brown, Mike had to go to the General Assembly.
00:15:52
But we do have one request for economic development access funds.
00:15:56
This is a project in Greensville County.
00:16:00
This is for access to wood fuel development.
00:16:03
This particular project is a little unique in that the CTB previously allocated funds for access for this project.
00:16:11
Since that time, they have revised their plans for development and access.
00:16:17
And so the request before you today is to both rescind the allocation that CTB made in June of last year and to provide funding based on the new project location and new estimate.
00:16:30
Therefore, we are recommending that you rescind the prior allocation and allocate $285,000 for this access project.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:39
All those in favor say aye.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:43
Aye.
00:16:45
Opposed?
00:16:46
Thank you very much.
00:16:48
Mr. Bennett, what is going on here?
SPEAKER_05
00:16:54
I'm Melissa Quarter, the Program Manager for the Property Management Section.
00:16:57
I've been asked to stand in for Richard Bennett to present these items for surface property conveyance that are on the agenda for today.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:07
Any questions on A?
00:17:09
Again, Mr. Chairman, I discussed this with the district administrator at the firm, but it was, in fact, surplus property, so I moved to approve it, please.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:19
All in favor say aye.
00:17:20
Aye.
00:17:21
Opposed?
00:17:22
Now I have it.
00:17:23
Bristol General.
00:17:24
Can I ask a question before you go on?
00:17:25
Sure.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:26
Don't our rules require us to offer back the person that was taken from originally?
00:17:30
Is that the case in these three situations?
00:17:33
Because it doesn't imply that.
00:17:34
It doesn't say that.
SPEAKER_05
00:17:36
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:17:37
In this case, this is what is considered a Class II property and even though it is being conveyed back to the former owner from whom we acquired, it would not be required in this instance because it has to be a property that's capable of independent development in accordance with the code section.
W. Sheppard Miller III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:56
So if we took some property from somebody but it couldn't be independently developed and we're not required to offer it back to the person we
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:05
If they are still an adjoining landowner, then yes we would and they would be given preference.
00:18:29
All those in favor, say aye.
00:18:35
Aye.
00:18:36
All opposed?
00:18:38
All ready?
SPEAKER_11
00:18:40
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:41
Land disposition.
00:18:42
All right, Randy.
00:18:44
All right.
00:18:45
This one.
00:18:46
What's Campbell?
SPEAKER_04
00:18:47
Yes, sir.
00:18:49
I'm Randy Campbell, administrative services division.
00:18:53
Here today seeking your approval of the resolution before you, which will allow us to dispose of the old church headquarters.
00:18:59
East of Richmond along Route 360, approximately a two-and-a-half acre site.
00:19:05
We estimate it's worth about $240,000.
00:19:10
You had approved this some years ago, but we realized that we didn't have all the property included, and we've since made modifications and added.
00:19:19
The old site was approximately two acres.
00:19:21
We added approximately one-half acre to that, and there's great interest in the property owner next door who's a cemetery.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:29
in this property and others have also come forward and indicated they are interested in this property.
00:19:44
It reminds me of an old joke about how many CTB votes does it take to dispose of property and in this case it's two.
00:19:51
This is very valuable property but it also reminds me of an issue that I've raised in years past and that is I would like to see some feedback to the board, at least to this board member anyway, about what kind of results we get when we dispose of these properties because some of them in this case
00:20:08
Yes sir.
00:20:09
Just one quick point.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:12
I noticed that fuel house and fuel canopy, do we have any environmental issues with this problem?
SPEAKER_04
00:20:33
Not that I know of.
00:20:36
and I'm not, we normally will do what we call a phase one site assessment and go and take a look for anything like that and if it's something that we might proceed on with more in-depth analysis but, and we have some on some other properties, I'm not aware of anything on this property and we have been allowing the vendor who washes the tunnels, Hampton Roads and so forth, to store some equipment on this property, renting it to him with a little lease agreement but we are, we can get rid of that with a 30-day notice.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:05
All those in favor say aye.
00:21:07
Aye.
00:21:07
All opposed?
00:21:08
Thank you very much.
00:21:09
Programming, Ms. Busher.
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
00:21:17
Mr. Chairman, members of the board, the first item that I have is three projects.
00:21:22
I'd like to amend the Six-Year Improvement Program.
00:21:25
One, there is an
00:21:29
Appendix A that shows the three projects.
00:21:33
The first one we've received additional Appalachian Development funds, $20,000 to complete the cost to complete study on the Appalachian Development Highway System in Virginia.
00:21:46
This study has to be completed every five years and they provide us some funding to accomplish the study.
00:21:54
This is basically projects related to corridor Q.
00:21:59
The second project is funding for fog countermeasure pavement markings on I-77 in Carroll County.
00:22:09
The purpose of the new project is to install fog countermeasure pavement markings from mile marker 0 to 10 in both the northbound and southbound directions.
00:22:21
And we're actually taking these funds, surplus funds, off of another project that came in under bid.
00:22:29
And we're adding a project in Lynchburg for various auxiliary turn lanes on various primary routes.
00:22:37
In this case, we're using surplus safety money, HSIP money to accomplish this project.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:43
Do I have a motion?
00:22:44
The next item is to bring to you project transfers in the Six-Year Program greater than
Reta Busher
Chief of Planning and Programming
00:23:11
10%, and they are listed in the attachments, mainly safety dollars being transferred back, unfortunately, to the balance entry account off projects that are inactive or project savings on projects that came in under bid.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:30
Move approval.
00:23:32
Second.
00:23:32
All in favor say aye.
00:23:33
Aye.
00:23:33
All opposed?
00:23:37
Okay, we're on 450.
00:23:40
Where is Mr. Kilpatrick?
00:23:41
Any questions for Mr. Kilpatrick?
SPEAKER_07
00:23:48
Mr. Chairman, Dusty Holcomb with the PFTA Office.
00:23:50
Mr. Kilpatrick must be detained for some reason, so I will try to take his place.
00:23:56
This is a resolution that all three conceptual proposals should advance to the detailed proposal phase of the determinant.
00:24:03
As each proposal satisfies the minimum intent of the PPTA, the guidelines, and the solicitation for proposal.
00:24:12
That the CTB also supports the recommendations of the IRP for consideration by the Commonwealth Transportation Commissioner and Commissioner Whirly.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:21
Before we go on this, I just have to ask one thing.
00:24:24
I mean, are we ever a lot, we're a lot going executive session at some point?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:30
Sure.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:31
Attorney.
00:24:32
It's our attorney?
00:24:33
We have an attorney?
00:24:34
Where's our attorney?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:35
Your attorney?
00:24:37
Okay.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:42
All right, well, I'm not saying today, but I think there's lots of questions about money, but we don't want to have discussions about that.
00:24:48
So after this resolution goes through and we start to develop this project, go along with some of the comments, we'd like to talk about some of the money issues, okay?
00:25:00
And it's just, again, it's just simply we don't want to share some of those comments.
00:25:05
Financial transaction issues, some other issues.
00:25:09
We'll make sure it meets it, okay?
00:25:12
So, one of the things that was raised about the costs and potential financing, but if you even want to make that as an amendment to this, then we'll have that at a future date.
00:25:23
We can do that.
00:25:25
Yes, sir?
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:25
Mr. Chairman, I move approval based on the importance of this project to the state of Virginia.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:33
Thank you.
00:25:33
Mr. Chairman, I ask the question if the administration might be willing to accept a friendly amendment here just to, I won't offer it unless perhaps you feel that it's appropriate, but I would like very much to see if as we determine this maximum amount that we'd like to provide,
00:25:52
If we could also request that some sort of estimate be done of what we think the state could build this project for and have both of those numbers discussed at the same time and if so I think under the further be resolved that first point could be amended a little bit to say we'd like to have both.
00:26:12
We'd like to have our own rough estimate of what we think the state could build it for and we'd like to set a number that we believe we're willing to invest in a PPDA.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:21
Yeah, Dr. Davis, actually we have that number, and that's what I'm, we don't, you know.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:26
That's what you don't want to speak publicly about at this point, okay.
00:26:29
I, I, I, I've, I've, I've preheated.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:31
And that's, so we will, that's why I want to have a, at some point, not today, we're not prepared for it, but to have an executive session, go through our estimates, where we, where the proposers are.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:41
That would be very helpful, I think, when we have the other discussions.
SPEAKER_07
00:26:47
Thanks.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:51
The reason I ask that question is because I felt like in the past when we were discussing these projects that
00:27:02
Oftentimes the CTB was sort of held back from the discussion of what the project might have cost totally to the state and only told what we thought the PPTA would be.
00:27:14
And I think doing our due diligence is very important as well.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:18
And I think particularly given some of the, when you look at some of the things, there is other options.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:25
Thank you.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:28
All those in favor say aye.
00:27:30
Aye.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:32
All those opposed?
00:27:34
That would be me, Mr. Chairman.
00:27:39
I'm just not ready yet.
00:27:41
I understand.
00:27:43
All right, scheduling and contract.
00:27:50
There is one item that's being pulled.
00:27:54
Correct.
00:27:55
Yeah.
00:27:57
It's on page 10.
00:27:59
This is on the courthouse road.
00:28:02
9B-4.
00:28:22
No action.
00:28:25
Do I have to vote on it?
00:28:49
Anybody know?
Trip Pollard
Leader, Land and Community Program
00:28:50
We're not going to vote on that one project.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:53
We just hope they don't vote on it.
00:28:55
Arlington's been called, though.
00:28:56
Been called, right?
00:28:58
That I don't know.
00:28:59
I can find out.
00:28:59
The engineer was working on that.
Trip Pollard
Leader, Land and Community Program
00:29:01
Are there any questions, folks, about any of the contracts?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:08
We have a motion.
00:29:09
Do we have a second?
SPEAKER_04
00:29:09
Second.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:11
All those in favor, say aye.
00:29:13
Aye.
00:29:13
All opposed?
00:29:16
All right, new business.
SPEAKER_11
00:29:25
Anything new?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:30
I think we ought to look into that so we can all kind of exchange best practices maybe that could be on a voluntary basis
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:54
As you go pray, Mr. Rich?
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:00
I remember meeting down in Tidewater and we took a tour through the port.
00:30:13
First time I ever saw that port.
00:30:17
I think if we could spread some of these rules around to different jurisdictions, it would be helpful to think about.
00:30:35
Well, we streamlined this because we can normally get through this in one day.
00:31:00
The second thing is that by having it over two days, then the state has to pick up the cost to redeem and staying overnight in the meals.
SPEAKER_11
00:31:11
Mr. Rich, I'm worried about those taxpayers.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:17
The Wolf Poll Committee, actually, you know, and I recognize this might be an issue for the staff, but it might be helpful if we were to
00:31:28
Every once in a while have meetings in other parts of the state and then see, get folks out where we can actually see some of the projects underway and make some of those.
00:31:38
And then, you know, to go along with what you were saying is maybe have the opportunity to meet with more of the local officials, some of the folks that we're dealing with.
00:31:49
We'll first have to see how much it will cost to do that, but I think it might be useful for us if you'd like to.
00:31:58
One of the reasons up at the Transportation Conference, I thought it'd be great to have Norfolk next year.
00:32:03
All these projects going on, the tide will be open, hopefully the Midtown Tunnel will be somewhere along the way, the port and all that, so you can actually see some of the stuff.
00:32:13
Obviously a lot of things in Northern Virginia, those you haven't experienced being parked in the beltway to see the hot lanes and the Dulles expansion, and even go out to see what they've done out in Dulles, it's very impressive the work on the people movers and all, just to see some of these things.
00:32:33
We'll take a look, but we'll come back to you.
00:32:35
The issue will be about cost.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:39
Anyone else?
00:32:40
Just one thing at the risk of continuing on on these PE3s.
00:32:46
The issue of tolling projects in Hampton Roads obviously has gotten a lot of publicity, and I understand where we are with the fact that that makes these public partnerships and tolls are a part of it.
00:32:57
However, there is an issue of equity, and that is
00:33:01
I don't know of any other place in the state besides Virginia where there is tolling being done.
00:33:08
I would like to raise the topic of tolling in Virginia and the equity and how we might look at that.
00:33:18
If you think about the idea of the fuel tax, and I'm not suggesting for or against, but it is everybody shares in the pain.
00:33:27
Tolls, while they are supported on these projects,
00:33:30
That's not necessarily the case, particularly if there's no public investment in regarding that.
00:33:36
And so I know that's an issue that's going to continue to be raised in Hampton Roads, I'm sure it's in Northern Virginia, just because now we're short of monies, all the projects gotta be told.
00:33:47
I don't know if you saw the publicity where they had the rain of fire, a ring of fire.
00:33:52
Of course that was the worst case that could possibly be.
00:33:56
But I do think it is worth the conversations at this level on the use of tolling and how they should be used not only just for PP3s but also in our overall funding transportation in the state of Virginia.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:09
I just want to make one comment.
00:34:12
I'm old enough to remember when I looked at that map, I said, geez, every one of these facilities I've pointed to used to have tolls.
Aubrey L. Layne Jr.
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:18
I understand.
00:34:19
They sure did.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:20
And we took them off because we said we don't need the money for it.
00:34:24
But I'm sorry, Dr. Davis.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:24
I don't want to extend the meeting, but I was in Norway a couple months ago, and one of the places I actually had to drive to
00:34:33
I drove over 42 miles on a dirt road that was a toll road.
00:34:38
$14 US.
00:34:40
Drive 47 miles on a dirt road.
00:34:42
And I found out it was not the only one.
00:34:44
There are dozens of them in Norway.
00:34:46
So I came back thinking I was going to propose to the governor he might consider a way to help us take care of secondary roads by putting tolls on dirt roads.
Sean T. Connaughton
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:56
This is going to be a great session when we talk about toll in the Virginia.
00:35:00
Thank you all very much.
00:35:01
Appreciate it.
00:35:02
Have a good month.
00:35:03
Thank you.