Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 7/16/2009
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
7/16/2009
Attachments
Meeting agenda.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
Cpl. Charles Ellsworth Bowen Memorial Bridge_ Commemorative naming of Route 624 bridge over Cat Point Creek, Richmond County.pdf
Route 729 Virginia Byway designation, Rappahannock County.pdf
Limited access control changes, I-95_495 and Telegraph Road interchange, Alexandria.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 5 and Virginia Capital Trail (Greenspring phase), James City County.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 221, Bedford County.pdf
Land conveyance, I-495 (HOT Lanes - Section 5), Fairfax County.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 633, Roanoke County.pdf
Easement conveyance, Route 671, Albemarle County.pdf
Issuance and sale of Transportation Revenue Bonds, Series 2009A, Northern Virginia Transportation District.pdf
Addition of American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 projects identified by Metropolitan Planning Organizations to the Six-Year Improvement Progra.pdf
Public Comments
Approval of Minutes: June 18, 2009
MAINTENANCE DIVISION
1. Transfer of Frontage Road 100 (Bacova Drive) from the Interstate Highway System to the State’s Primary System and then to the local road system of Henrico County.
Transfer of Interstate Frontage Road 100 (Bacova Drive) from the interstate system to the primary of state highway system and subsequently to.pdf
2. Action on Conditional Order of Abandonment, Original Alignment of State Route 208.
Conditional order of abandonment, original alignment of Route 208, discontinued Aug. 16, 1973.pdf
3. Action on Commemorative Bridge Naming specifically State Route 624 Bridge over Cat
LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
4. Action on Revenue Sharing Reallocation:
Revenue sharing reallocation, New Kent County.pdf
5. Action on Economic Development Access Policy.
Economic Development Access Fund policy revision.pdf
6. Action on Virginia Byway Designation:
RIGHT OF WAY DIVISION
7. Action on Limited Access Control Changes:
Limited access control changes, Route 7 (Leesburg Bypass), Loudoun County.pdf
A. City of Alexandria
B. Town of Leesburg, Loudoun County
8. Action on Land/or Easement Conveyance
A. James City County
B. Bedford County
C. Fairfax County
D. Roanoke County
E. Albemarle County
9. Action on Authorizing the Issue and Sale of Transportation Revenue Bonds.
PLANNING DIVISION
10. Action on FY10-15 Six-Year Improvement Program Transfers For June 1, 2009 through July 2, 2009.
Fiscal Years 2010-15 Six-Year Improvement Program transfers, June 1-July 7, 2009.pdf
11. Action on Rail Industrial Access:
Rail industrial access, SPIG Industry Inc..pdf
12. Action on Downtown Tunnel/Midtown Tunnel/MLK Extension PPTA Project Independent Review Panel Recommendations
Downtown Tunnel_Midtown Tunnel_MLK Extension Project_ Independent review panel recommendations.pdf
SCHEDULING AND CONTRACT
13. Action on Bids
NEW BUSINESS
ADJOURNMENT
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:00
Good morning, everyone.
00:00:02
I'd like to welcome everyone to the July work session and business meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:11
We typically don't start with public comment until the business session, but I know there are some people who have traveled here, so we'll have two opportunities for public comment today, just in a few minutes, and then again at the beginning of the business section of the meeting.
00:00:25
We will take a recess from approximately 12 noon until 1 o'clock for people to... We have a very busy agenda.
00:00:34
You probably want to clear your head a little bit.
00:00:36
We have a very broad-reaching, very ambitious agenda today.
00:00:41
We also have two new faces and appointees of the governor to the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:48
And first I would like to welcome a longtime colleague and friend, Sharon Pandak, Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:54
Sharon, if you want to just spend a minute or two telling us about yourself.
00:00:58
And I know on behalf of the board members, your reputation precedes you, and we welcome you here.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:04
Well, Mr. Secretary, thank you very much.
00:01:06
It's wonderful to be in the same room with you again, working together.
00:01:09
As you know, but I think some other people may not, we worked together when you were in Prince William County as Deputy
00:01:17
County Executive, and I am very pleased that the governor has appointed me to transportation, the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:01:26
I wish, as I've told a few people, I had a degree in alchemy to assist the board in some larger way, but I was county attorney in Prince William County for a number of years.
00:01:38
I now am with a private law firm, and we represent local governments, nonprofits around the state.
00:01:44
I've had a strong interest in transportation and
00:01:47
The Governor had favored me with an appointment to the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, so I am very pleased to be down here at CTB and I look forward to working with you again.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:57
So out of the frying pan and into the fire, you'll feel the heat today.
00:02:02
Next, Aubrey Layne, welcome from the Hampton Roads region and Aubrey, could you tell us a little bit about yourself?
SPEAKER_13
00:02:10
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
00:02:11
I too am pleased to be here.
00:02:13
I would also beg a little bit of the
00:02:16
The board's patience, as we get up to speed, because there's a whole lot of things on the plate.
00:02:21
My background, I'm financial, I'm CPA, and now I'm in property management.
00:02:29
I had the opportunity yesterday to speak with one of the VDOT representatives, Dennis Ure, so I understand a little bit of the problems, and quite frankly, I have properties in every locality in Hampton Roads, so transportation is very important to me, not only as a public servant, but as my business.
00:02:45
I look forward to working with everybody and glad to be here.
00:02:47
I'm glad that the government appointed me, sir.
00:02:49
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:50
And welcome, Ms. Layne.
00:02:52
You in particular will feel the heat today at Hampton Roads, but you have a good colleague next to you to help out.
00:02:59
At this time, what I'd like to do, this is a little bit out of the ordinary, but if there are members of the public who have traveled to be here, who would like to address the board, and we'll have another opportunity for public comment before the business session.
00:03:11
Would anyone like to address the board under public comment time?
00:03:19
Okay.
00:03:21
Going once.
00:03:22
If not, then we're going to move on with the agenda and the first item is the blueprint update.
00:03:29
Commissioner Ekern is going to tell us the next step in this process and as he's getting ready for his preparation,
00:03:37
And really for the benefit of those from the public who are here and new board members, what is driving the very profound changes at VDOT are the dramatic reductions in revenue.
00:03:50
And over the six-year time horizon, we are dealing with a $2.6 billion revenue shortfall.
00:03:59
We have already taken action to reduce the six-year program by about $2 billion to accommodate those reductions.
00:04:07
An additional $600 million is coming out of services and administration.
00:04:15
And so at our last CTB meeting, we had lengthy debate about closing of rest areas, about closing half of our equipment shops, of closing a third of the residencies around the state.
00:04:32
and today the third leg of that transformation and reduction at VDOT is going to be the focus of the Commissioner's presentation.
00:04:41
Welcome Commissioner.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:04:42
Thank you Mr. Secretary.
00:04:43
Good morning everybody.
00:04:45
As the Secretary indicated, this slide does give you that scene set in terms of what we have been dealing with since last October.
00:04:57
Today I'm intending to address, as the Secretary indicated, the third part of the plan or the blueprint has been emerging and we have been briefing you throughout the last few months.
00:05:16
Different than the other parts of the blueprint.
00:05:21
This one, by its
00:05:24
Intricacy is probably the most complex from a functional and department management standpoint as opposed to on the construction program and six-year plan side where the complexity is in finance,
00:05:42
Here the complexity is in function and process.
00:05:47
So this will, as I go through this morning's briefing, I will try to interject a little bit about those processes and some education about our business as we manage it internally to the department because that's the part
00:06:10
This activity, that's the part of this blueprint that is the most complex.
00:06:16
We have spent, in overview, almost eight months getting ready for this part of the blueprint because the concepts, the implementation, and the impact of this part of the blueprint
00:06:37
is at a scale that we have not used before within state government and VDOT.
00:06:49
By reference, if you look back to the era of the 90s, reshaping of the department was accomplished through voluntary incentives as opposed to
00:07:04
involuntary separation and reshaping and restructuring of the department to recognize a long-term future.
00:07:14
That is critical to the processes and critical to what you will be briefed on and get questions about as we move forward.
00:07:28
As the Secretary indicated, the three parts of the plan or the blueprint
00:07:34
have in fact included the revisions to the Six-Year Plan and Six-Year Program, which have been adopted and are in process.
00:07:46
The second part, the programs and services, have been incorporated through the budget adoption for the Fiscal Year 10
00:07:57
and will be continued in fiscal years 11 through 15 or 16.
00:08:03
The next increment will be reflected in the 11-12 budget that we put together.
00:08:09
That brings us to the third part of the blueprint which deals with organization and size of the department.
00:08:17
You can see by the proportions that we've shown on the slide what proportions, about 72% of the $2.6 billion gap has been met through the construction program.
00:08:30
Our services program last month accounts for about 13%, and the administration support and restructuring of the department will achieve about 15%.
00:08:43
I put at the bottom of this slide two driving points out of the philosophies that drive what we have done as we look at the department and reshape its future and what it will look like in July of 2010.
00:09:02
On an agency side, we will be a smaller agency.
00:09:07
The target is 7,500 employees.
00:09:10
We will be providing our services differently, as we have illustrated in the residency consolidation proposals that all of you are hearing about, and a focus at our districts, and we will be proportioned differently.
00:09:29
Proportioned differently in the sense that our core mission is maintenance and operations
00:09:36
which necessarily affects and recognizes the reduction in the construction and project program.
00:09:46
We will also be proportioning differently at the end of the day in our business support activities, those things that we do internal to the department to process bills, to manage our day-to-day activities that are generally unseen by the public.
00:10:07
We also will have a business approach that drives what we're doing that says we will sustain our partnership with the private sectors, different scales perhaps, and different sizes depending on our business.
00:10:30
And we are recognizing that we will not replicate all functions
00:10:35
in 10 different organizational groups across the department so that there is a shared dependency throughout the department.
00:10:47
I highlight that because I want to make sure that everyone understands this is not about a retreat from the long-term direction of the department to decentralize accountability to be closer to the customer.
00:11:03
This is not an issue of centralization versus decentralization.
00:11:08
This is all about good customer service and it is all about making sure that we make the best use of the staff and the services that we provide.
00:11:20
Last year I talked to you about emergency response and what we're doing to remodel our emergency response capacity.
00:11:28
That has turned into a whole variety of activities
00:11:32
focused around predominantly winter maintenance.
00:11:36
That's a hallmark of part of the business model that we will be using as we move into the future.
00:11:45
This gives you in a quick highlight and I repeated a couple of slides that we used in May
00:11:51
So that the new board members would have a ready reference and that you would have all a good reminder of the focuses that are being reflected in our six-year program that has been adopted.
00:12:05
What is going on in the maintenance and operations program where you see that tangible refocusing of our maintenance and operations budgets toward the true centerline emergency response elements of our mission as opposed to the other activities that are further out from the centerline?
00:12:34
And now, lastly, the implementation of the staffing changes and our relationships with the private sector.
00:12:47
As you're all aware, the direction that we are implementing has been, and I kept this slide in place, implemented through our Appropriations Act adopted by the General Assembly.
00:13:03
And I've given you the six key directions that are embodied in that budget amendment language that was adopted this year.
00:13:12
In essence, it reinforces and codifies the direction that we are heading.
00:13:20
That focus toward maintenance and operations, a reduction and a consolidation of facilities, a reduction in layers of supervision throughout the department,
00:13:34
ensuring that decisions are made using good solid methodology and driven by business not by personality and recognizing a goal for the size of the department by June of 2010.
00:13:52
It also required and carried a requirement for the submission of a comprehensive plan
00:13:58
to the Governor, the Chairs of the House Appropriation and Transportation Committees and the Senate Transportation and Finance Committees with an ongoing requirement of quarterly reporting as we move through the transition.
00:14:14
That is in addition to the monthly reports that the CTB has put in place that we will be providing.
00:14:25
What are our current activities?
00:14:27
We need to make sure that as we've been moving toward this stage of implementation that we have a quick alignment or a quick review of the five, six major things that are occurring.
00:14:43
We have in fact submitted the comprehensive plan as required by the appropriation language.
00:14:50
I submitted that as of July 1st.
00:14:54
We have completed and briefed previously on the first stage of personnel transactions as we implemented a reduction of our wage employees across the department.
00:15:07
That was completed June 6 and has resulted in a reduction in some numbers that you'll see in a table here shortly.
00:15:17
Those reviews will continue now
00:15:20
For the residual wage employees that are still on the payroll, each of those groups has an ongoing review period so that we will continue to evaluate the remaining employees that are in the wage positions.
00:15:41
I have announced and realigned for the directorates in stage two.
00:15:47
Stage one was the wage employees.
00:15:49
Stage two will be the first to touch classified employees.
00:15:53
And those two, we have two stages that will affect the department staffing.
00:15:58
They're labeled stages two and three.
00:16:02
Stage 2, in preparation for that activity, we are also realigning a couple of our directorates.
00:16:13
I have announced and moved the learning center function from our organizational development
00:16:19
Directorate to our Virginia Research Council.
00:16:25
This will be an important move for us because I think it will for the first time link together the research that we do with the education and the transformation of a workforce related to those very critical topics about our business
00:16:45
that research brings to the table.
00:16:49
I have moved local assistance from our finance directorate to Rick Walton's environmental local government directorate to recognize a closer tie between project development activities that localities undertake and our relationships with the localities as they process projects.
00:17:13
That will make it a stronger tie between the project development side of our business and the localities that are assuming and do manage those activities in their own jurisdictions.
00:17:28
That is a direct reflection of what I have heard talking to those localities and where their issues seem to lie.
00:17:39
I've also reassigned our multimodal planning office and given it a permanent home within the research council.
00:17:47
That will allow Mary Lynn Tisher, Dr. Tisher, to draw more directly from the skill sets that are available through the research council, the university systems, to support those multimodal planning activities that we engage in.
00:18:06
This week we will complete consolidation of our operation centers.
00:18:12
As you recall, one of the goals was to consolidate from six to five centers.
00:18:19
The center that is located here in the central office is being merged with our Richmond facility, and that will be completed this week.
00:18:29
I also am in the process of authorizing stabilized
00:18:35
Staffing levels for three key functions that are in our operations and maintenance side of the business.
00:18:44
Our maintenance crews, the core 2,500 people that operate equipment and the 181 locations where they are located.
00:18:57
will be one of the first actions I will brief you on this morning as a place for stabilizing that workforce and ensuring our commitment to emergency response.
00:19:13
We are also stabilizing and putting in place our ferry operations staffing and the commitment to bridge tunnel staffing, both in Hampton Roads and in the Bristol districts.
00:19:29
We've also received notice this week that EMWA will assume Dulles Toll Road transfer
00:19:41
If you recall in our comprehensive agreement with them, we are transferring our toll operation to them.
00:19:47
The date was yet to be determined, but it had to be completed by the end of this year.
00:19:53
They have given this notice that they are prepared to undertake that effective October.
00:20:00
When I talked previously about how a plan changes, this is my illustrator today that says, here is a change, 46 people involved in that transfer
00:20:11
which was originally anticipated in stage three which we are now moving up to stage two.
00:20:17
That's a part of the dynamic of how we're managing this part of our plan.
00:20:24
As a quick overview, here is at a snapshot where we were in staffing
00:20:31
As of July 2008 at 8,472 classified employees and you see the splits between our central functions and our classified staff in the field and the wage employees I referenced earlier.
00:20:48
Our benchmark that we have established is to measure against is September
00:20:54
of 2008 and you can see the staffing at 84-64 and what that proportion was and the size of the wage force at that time.
00:21:08
As of July 1st, we are at 8,165 classified employees and we have 113 wage employees and you see the distribution.
00:21:23
This chart I use because I wanted to illustrate the three drivers that affect staffing.
00:21:31
I briefed you previously that we have approximately 1,500 employees who are at retirement age or eligible for retirement.
00:21:41
Many people choose to work here because it is a vibrant place to work.
00:21:45
There are always challenges and opportunities and
00:21:50
Every employee of the department generally likes working with the people they work with every day.
00:21:55
That's why you see long careers in our department.
00:22:01
If we relied only on retirement, natural retirement, and attrition, our projections as best we can do them at the rates we've been experiencing would say that by July of next year,
00:22:15
Our classified employment would be at about 7,841 classified staff.
00:22:22
That is short of the 7,500 goal that you see listed and the breakout that is our target
00:22:30
of approximately a thousand positions in our central functions and 6400 or 6500 at our district operations.
00:22:42
That is why we cannot rely only on attrition and retirement.
00:22:50
What you see here and what I've captured is the brief review of the mechanisms then that we have been utilizing besides
00:23:00
Attrition and Retirement.
00:23:02
The challenge that we have is that attrition and retirement, while it may get us close to a goal, does not get us proportioned the way we need to be to manage the mission that we will have as we move forward.
00:23:20
The critical hire process, which we have had in place since 2007, is a good tool
00:23:29
and will work for us as we move forward to help re-proportion, but it does not re-proportion in the time frame that we need to achieve this new size of the department.
00:23:41
That is why we are now focused at the involuntary layoff process.
00:23:47
A little bit of education.
00:23:49
Now there are all kinds of words that we tend to use in our everyday language to describe
00:23:57
How you separate people from organizations.
00:23:59
Layoffs, involuntary layoffs, you will see language emerging that we are required to use because it is code language and it has particular meaning.
00:24:11
So it will start to sound a little bit bureaucratic, but I can tell you that as this system has been designed for our use in the department, we are trying to step past the bureaucratic language
00:24:26
and make sure that we focus on the principles that we will employ as we deal with people affected by an involuntary separation program.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:42
Let me back up just a little bit.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:44
This proportion piece, and I wanted to mention a little bit earlier, as you think about VDOT,
00:24:53
I want you to think about us not as a singular business, which is popular to do.
00:25:00
You know, what does VDOT do?
00:25:02
Well, it plows roads.
00:25:05
Or it responds to something.
00:25:07
Or it fills a pothole.
00:25:10
And so people tend to develop a singular image about what our business is.
00:25:15
This is the last piece of education I'll do this morning.
00:25:19
In essence, we are for businesses.
00:25:22
We are four businesses.
00:25:24
We are a business that focuses at maintenance and operations of an existing facility.
00:25:31
We are a business that employs professional staff that develops and improves a system.
00:25:40
We label it as engineers, construction, and program project development, and we've got all these neat terms.
00:25:48
We are also a business that focuses on planning and community relations.
00:25:55
That is a key component to help the Commonwealth understand and move toward its future.
00:26:05
And we are a business that focuses at the critical business of business support.
00:26:10
The things that we do to take care of 7,500 people, procure things that those people need to do their jobs,
00:26:17
And so I've labeled that as a business support.
00:26:21
Each one of those businesses has a unique and different business model.
00:26:27
And they have a unique and different way to accomplish their part of the mission.
00:26:32
They overlap, but they are not the same.
00:26:36
That is absolutely critical as you talk about how you restructure and proportion positions throughout the department.
00:26:45
Our focus in Stage 2 touches three of those four businesses.
00:26:52
It balances and downsizes the staffing in construction and project development
00:26:59
to match our future reduced program.
00:27:03
That's the most significant impact in Stage 2.
00:27:07
We have a recognized and a driving force is to regionalize and downsize our right-of-way functions.
00:27:15
If you are not building roads, you are not buying land to build roads.
00:27:21
This is also an illustrator of what we have learned in maintenance and operations about shared dependence.
00:27:29
This right away is a critical resource, but it is not a resource that you can replicate 10 different places within the Commonwealth.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:38
So we are focusing that resource into a regional concept.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:43
As I've indicated previously, we are also stabilizing our core maintenance and operations crew staffing.
00:27:52
The very critical people who are called out
00:27:55
Any kind of a maintenance operation throughout the year.
00:28:00
And we are completing the equipment repair shop consolidation which started in 2006.
00:28:09
As we consolidated area headquarters and implemented the outsourcing of the Interstate Maintenance Program that has necessarily driven the fleet size of the department down and so consequently your investment in equipment shops needs to be consolidated to match.
00:28:31
As the overview and the process over the next 12 months, what I've given you here
00:28:36
are those three stages and the affected functions within the department as they are currently identified.
00:28:44
Stage one was our
00:28:46
staff augmentation, our wage employees, and I've given you an indication of what savings those generate both in fiscal year 2010 and what we anticipate in fiscal years 11 through 14.
00:29:04
Stage 2 notifications for those affected functions that I've got listed there, and I won't read through them all, will begin at the end of this month.
00:29:15
And we anticipate two potential release dates for actual employees leaving.
00:29:24
That would be in September and then in October.
00:29:29
We anticipate that our estimates at the time we started were that we would affect about 450 to 500
00:29:40
Ultimate People depending on attrition.
00:29:45
That's an impressive, that's an important number.
00:29:49
And we, as I've indicated in stage two, are accomplishing this partial consolidation and realignments within central office.
00:29:56
As the overview, stage three, we would begin notification in December with an anticipated release in March of the employees affected by stage three.
00:30:11
You also notice that we had identified the Dallas toll road transfer,
00:30:17
in Stage 3, which is now moved into Stage 2.
00:30:22
You also see those functions and the business support consolidations having their major impact during the Stage 3, the residency consolidation beginning in December, and the completion of the functions that you see listed under the central functions.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:45
As we're getting ready to notify employees of the upcoming options they have, I guess is what you'll be talking about.
00:30:59
There's a category that concerns me.
00:31:01
What about employees that are inactive, yet considered employees that they're inactive maybe because of medical or for some reason that might be included in the reduction?
00:31:13
Have you got a policy to handle that?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:17
Mr. Keene, thank you.
00:31:17
That's an excellent question.
00:31:19
I'll cover it a couple of times, but the quick answer right now is
00:31:22
As we begin notifications at the end of the July, if you are on military leave, long-term disability, or short-term disability, you will not be contacted in those general notifications.
00:31:35
Each of those cases will be handled uniquely and in accordance in the case of someone who is on military leave if they are affected.
00:31:44
They will be notified only after they return.
00:31:48
So those are in essence, I consider those to be suspense cases.
00:31:55
Thank you, I appreciate that.
00:31:57
This is just for your reference again.
00:32:01
This is again a summary of the equipment shops because that's the largest physical plant effect in stage two that are being affected.
00:32:13
The district location, you can see the district name, the location name of the shop, and the Y indicates that those are the shops that will be retained in our set of, excuse me,
00:32:28
In our set of 37 shops that will service the department.
00:32:37
Now when you look at this aggregate table, and I'm only giving you agency-wide summaries for a couple of purposes.
00:32:48
First, on the lower part of the chart, what you see is a recitation then of the affected functions within stage two.
00:33:00
You see in the red those functions in which we are stabilizing and are ensuring that there may be positions available.
00:33:13
That's our area headquarters, crew members and superintendents, bridge inspection, bridge maintenance are all incorporated in that.
00:33:20
And then I also indicated tunnels and the
00:33:30
Time out, senior moment.
00:33:34
What was the other one I hit?
00:33:35
Oh, I hit tunnels and ferries.
00:33:37
I get confused because I'm never sure whether ferries are services or bridges.
00:33:47
As you can see, when you look at that aggregate, that in 2008,
00:33:55
comprised about 5,432 filled positions in the department.
00:34:05
Today that same aggregate represents 5,325 people in the department.
00:34:15
Our work in reshaping the organization for the blueprint where we are headed said for these same types of functions
00:34:24
We would expect about 4,940 staff devoted to these functions throughout the department.
00:34:35
I'm sorry, 4,990 or about 5,000 positions.
00:34:40
So you can tell that there has been a lot of analysis and review because we, in effect, have touched over the last eight months and looked at
00:34:51
over 5,000 positions in the department.
00:34:57
That's over 5,000 positions in the department.
00:35:02
We estimate, we estimate that at the end of July we will issue about 600 notices of intent to involuntary separate.
00:35:19
I'm going to go through that process with you in the next slides, but I wanted to have the volume so that you get a sense of how this process will work.
00:35:32
Mr. Chairman, quick clarification.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:37
A couple of slides back, I think you said 450 to 500 positions affected in Stage 2.
00:35:45
This one is 600 plus notices.
00:35:48
Is that the same?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:50
How does that work?
00:35:51
That's an excellent question.
00:35:53
The relationship is our estimate at 400 to 500 was actual people leaving.
00:36:00
Notification does not mean that people will actually leave.
00:36:05
That is the uniqueness of the process, so we cannot do linear math.
00:36:09
The estimate I give you on the last column at 260 plus
00:36:14
is the number you would reuse to relate to that 400 to 500.
00:36:20
The key conclusion you should reach is that attrition and retirements are working as we re-proportion a department.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:28
Mr. McCarthy, I think to amplify that, this process is governed by the Workforce Transition Act which dates back to the early 1990s and it's a very prescriptive hierarchy and so when notice is given
00:36:43
affected employees have a certain set of rights to, if they're more senior, to move into other vacant positions or perhaps to be retrained.
00:36:53
The commissioner will talk about that in more detail, but the commissioner as an administrator, once this process starts, loses management flexibility as governed by a very stringent statute.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:07
Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
00:37:08
It really sets up this next to the last slide that I have in this briefing and follows up on Mr. McCarthy's question.
00:37:17
As I talk to employees, I draw a contrast between the difference of, quote, involuntary separation in the private sector versus involuntary separation in the public sector.
00:37:28
They are distinctly different models.
00:37:31
The private sector, and I have employees who tell stories who have been laid off in the private sector, generally they show up at work, there's a notice, and they go home, and that's the end of the employment.
00:37:45
I want to make very clear to you that that is not the way we are approaching this process.
00:37:55
In government, as the Secretary has indicated,
00:37:59
The policy is driven by a philosophy that says, and a policy direction, our first goal is to keep people employed.
00:38:13
And a placement opportunity for all affected noticed people based on their qualifications,
00:38:22
minimum or otherwise within established policy and rules.
00:38:28
And what I've done here in the four bullet points for you is to capture how that will work in overview in VDOT.
00:38:37
I want to continue to emphasize, and I'm doing that as we speak, even with all the employees of the department, when you receive a notice that only starts a process, it does not mean you are out of a job.
00:38:53
That process will take anywhere from 8 to 12 weeks to work through.
00:38:58
That is why the ultimate termination date for anyone receiving a notice who ultimately leaves is not until October and late October.
00:39:11
In the intervening period, we will work through these four opportunities
00:39:18
to address anyone's situation.
00:39:22
First, once we have issued the notices of layoff, approximately the first week in August, there will be a notice published to allow employees to identify themselves who wish to substitute for a notified employee.
00:39:43
In essence, if you, and I'm overgeneralizing, so my human resource people and my transition director are about to have a heart attack.
00:39:53
But in essence, what we are doing is saying if you are in the department and you are interested in substituting yourself for an employee who got a notice and you don't know who they are officially,
00:40:10
You can sign up on a specifically designed website that we will have for employees to identify themselves.
00:40:18
My workforce transition team, my people transition team will then match job duties and people.
00:40:26
And if there is a match, we will work through that so that a, quote, more senior employee will say,
00:40:34
I'm willing to substitute.
00:40:36
He doesn't know who he's substituting for.
00:40:38
He doesn't know where it will be or how it will work, but we will work through that match.
00:40:45
They would then ultimately get the layoff notice, and then they would be getting the severance benefits instead of the noticed employee.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:54
Does that substitute person, does that mean that they're more likely to be eligible to retire and
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:03
My suspicion is, and if I were doing, if I were one of those employees, if I were retirement age eligible and this becomes an opportunity for me and I might take advantage of that as a potential retiree
00:41:28
because the incentive is either the severance benefit or extended years of service so that you can cover some expenses, insurances, whatever those might be.
00:41:40
So there's an incentive built into that system for substitutes to identify themselves.
00:41:48
But it is not, I need to go back to, it is not 1995.
00:41:52
This is not an early buyout option.
00:41:55
This is clearly a mechanism that we are using as a part of an involuntary separation.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:03
I guess I just wanted to clarify, would there be any other type of employee other than someone who might be eligible for retirement who would volunteer to do this?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:16
We can brief on that but at the end of the day I couldn't speculate right now and I've chosen not to try to manipulate that.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:25
It sounds like it could be someone other than a retiree eligible person.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:31
If you think about it this way, if my current population is 8,150 employees, there are 8,150 potential substitutes.
00:42:43
So each individual will look at the information.
00:42:46
We've been doing a lot of education since last October throughout the department.
00:42:52
about retirement benefits, pre-planning, all those kinds of things.
00:42:57
And I think people will process that and make some personal decisions about whether they want to substitute or not.
00:43:04
That's the key for this particular mechanism.
SPEAKER_12
00:43:07
Mr. Chairman, what severance package, if any, goes with the layoff?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:15
Now you're getting into a depth that I can't answer, so if we could, because of the amount of material you've got today, I'd like to come back and brief on that, and we can do that as we move forward into the September meeting, perhaps.
00:43:32
The second opportunity for any noticed employee is placement in VDOT.
00:43:39
And those are going to maybe in different parts of the organization.
00:43:44
But as I indicated in the first set of slides, I am opening a series of placement opportunities where we will need people.
00:43:54
And the simple example that I will use is the example of I am upstaffing in our area headquarters, which are equipment operator positions.
00:44:04
There are, in essence, I think we're increasing a little over 100 positions in our field area headquarters.
00:44:12
Those become placement opportunities for people noticed in this stage and in future stages.
00:44:19
We have implemented a policy that we are not hiring from the outside
00:44:26
The secretary has signed off on a policy I proposed which says our order of filling positions will be placement first, internal first, and only after we have exhausted all of those efforts through stages two and three will I start to certify and authorize critical hires from outside the agency.
00:44:50
That is a clear direction
00:44:52
So that we in fact maximize the number of opportunities for people who may be affected.
00:45:00
A third option that will be available is placement in other agencies of the Commonwealth.
00:45:08
There is a specific set of policies and processes and an employee who chooses the option of wanting to be placed will have a form to fill out and will then be matched against opportunities as they come in other agencies.
00:45:27
There's a whole set of rules that work around that and you'll hear from people that you talk to in the districts and central office
00:45:34
All about yellow cards and blue cards.
00:45:37
And believe me, it's fascinating stuff if you really want to get into it.
00:45:41
And I've learned an awful lot about the personnel policies of this Commonwealth in the last four months.
SPEAKER_05
00:45:49
I won't go any further than that.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:53
Beyond that, if you remembered that number of about 260 to 65, even if you are separated from the department,
00:46:04
We technically do not call you laid off.
00:46:08
We technically call you on leave without pay for a period of up to 12 months in which you then have opportunities for placement.
00:46:19
So even if you are laid off in stage two and there is a vacancy that occurs later down in stage three, we have a hierarchy that requires us
00:46:31
to notify that employee and say, do you want this opportunity?
00:46:37
I'm simplifying it, but that's in essence what goes on.
00:46:44
This set of priorities, this direction has been carefully reviewed and crafted for VDOT.
00:46:55
This is not a just general set of rules.
00:46:58
I have had a team that has done nothing but concentrate
00:47:01
on how to make a system work that lives the vision of giving people options in a difficult economic environment.
00:47:12
The decisions that I am reaching have been not only brought forward as a business decision, but I have had them reviewed from three or four different perspectives on every function of the reshaped VDOT.
00:47:26
And so that has caused
00:47:29
Some adjustments, it has caused some good refocus where that was needed and that process will continue over the next 12 months as we continue the implementation.
00:47:45
As I finish up this morning, I also want to make sure that everyone is aware that this activity we are engaged in in the department is very close to every one of us who works in the department because it affects people we have worked with for many, many years.
00:48:07
We do not approach this lightly.
00:48:10
We approach it as carefully as we can.
00:48:13
And we know that some of the decisions will change.
00:48:17
Some of the people who get notices may change as we go through the process because there are circumstances that we cannot fully grasp for that magnitude of 600 people that are getting that first notice.
00:48:32
So the plan will change as we move forward.
00:48:35
We are committed and this schedule will complete implementation
00:48:40
as required by code over the next 12 months.
00:48:45
And as we know, I continue to remind people that like a design-build project, if we discover something, no function or service remains off the table and we'll go back and relook at it.
00:48:59
With that, Mr. Secretary, I'll be glad to take questions and I appreciate you giving me this kind of time to update the board.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:08
Everyone on the board is cognizant of the challenge that this poses, not just to the Department of Transportation, but there has never been an organizational resizing of this scope in the history of the Commonwealth.
00:49:24
Questions of the Commissioner?
00:49:25
Mr. Layne.
SPEAKER_13
00:49:26
You've laid out a very structured plan.
00:49:29
My question relates to the operational efficiency of the organization as we go through this, particularly
00:49:36
If the plan is flexible enough to maintain the institutional knowledge, for instance, whenever you go through something like this, you typically lose people who you haven't targeted.
00:49:48
I just was curious if it's flexible enough for you to adjust based on as things happen in the field.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:56
The answer to that question is twofold, and it's an excellent question, I appreciate it.
00:50:03
As I reviewed the history of the department, the last two events where we had significant loss of staff and brain power occurred in the early 90s and mid-90s and was, from my point of view, this is Dave's perspective, from my point of view was relatively uncontrolled because it was
00:50:25
An incentive program.
00:50:27
And it was very difficult to look at people and say, your incentive, you know, I'm going to deny you your incentive even though I had the right to do it.
00:50:35
The difference with our plan is that it is focused on the new business model we're trying to get.
00:50:42
It lives within the rules that are established in the Commonwealth, which are predominantly seniority driven.
00:50:50
Substitution is the only place where you see seniority broken as the driver.
00:50:57
So if I editorialize, and that's always dangerous,
00:51:03
I will retain, I suspect, a good balance of knowledge, but I will lose good experience based on that substitution provision, and I may lose parts of our future as a result of the seniority provisions because it's the most junior people in any given class that are the ones that are noticed.
00:51:28
So it is a double-edged sword, and the one thing I have confidence in about this is that we know where we want to be, and I know that my workforce, the staff I work with every day are dedicated professionals, and they are doing all the things that we can do to ensure that we don't lose knowledge as we lose people.
00:51:55
Ms. Koelemay.
SPEAKER_13
00:51:56
Mr. Chairman, thank you.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:57
I would agree with you, not in my experience as I have ever seen as comprehensive a review process as you've just outlined.
00:52:05
What I wanted to suggest to you that VDOT probably faces a dynamic and changing future regardless of the current economic or revenue challenges.
00:52:19
Is it your expectation that this process will be permanent
00:52:22
It's been permanent and ongoing to allow you to continue to adjust to what are really going to be year-to-year and certainly six-year-to-six-year fluctuations in VDOT growing as well as VDOT shrinking.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:38
Excellent question and I'm going to editorialize just a little bit.
00:52:43
Of the three parts of the blueprint, it is my personal opinion
00:52:48
that this part needs to be now stabilized and held constant as we move forward.
00:52:55
I have re-proportioned our project delivery and development capacity significantly to reflect a long-term 36% reduction in the program.
00:53:08
The intended strategy is that we will increase, if funding improves and projects come back,
00:53:15
We will move that to the private sector at a greater proportion.
00:53:20
I believe that the staffing that we have is built to sustain a core program for the Commonwealth so that as we deal with projects and there are maintenance projects and construction projects that this staff will develop.
00:53:38
So therefore they are a needed resource on an ongoing basis.
00:53:43
I think we're at the right size.
00:53:45
At this size, we will be in proportion the way we will be.
00:53:49
The jury is out, but I believe we will be measured as probably the most efficient on whatever kind of measures you want to look at department in the country.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:10
The 7500 number has always puzzled me, and I have to commend you and the staff who have done such a critically thoughtful, comprehensive analysis of how to reach 7500 from where we started.
00:54:30
Was there any comparable analysis that created the 7500 number in the first place, or what is the basis for it?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:42
The art of an organization is that convergence of experience and mission.
00:54:56
As you look at that 7500 number, and people have speculated, you know, if you were in Alberta, Canada, they have a province that totally outsources everything.
00:55:13
and so they only have a few people who manage contracts.
00:55:17
Everything is performance driven.
00:55:19
It took them 16 years to achieve that model versus the Commonwealth which has built a model that capitalizes on private sector skills in all four of our businesses.
00:55:35
The art is the art of both proportion and size.
00:55:42
So the
00:55:44
Achieving a level of 7,500 is relatively close.
00:55:50
All the studies that I have done and reviewed in all the work across the history of the department has said, given certain conditions, a department size of somewhere between 7,500 and 8,000 is manageable, is the right size.
00:56:12
That's caveated on the size of the system as it continues to grow.
00:56:18
And that will cause always a constant evaluation of what's the right mix, what's the right proportion.
00:56:27
So best I would speculate is that 7,500 to 8,000 is a reasonable number building up from the bottom or looking at cuts from the top.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:42
And my point, Mr. Chairman, is that it seemed to me the 7,500 came from, you know, the legislature saying you can have no more than 7,500 positions filled.
00:56:54
And I guess I'm trying to get a grip on whether perhaps we shall revisit that someday depending on how all this works out because clearly the department has done a superb job of taking that number and trying to forge a department
00:57:10
that will live within that budget and that limitation, but my question is more fundamental, and that is why 7,500 and where did that come from?
00:57:19
And I don't know whether we can get a, since the person who came up with that number isn't here today, whether we can ever get an answer to that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:29
Actually, Mr. McCarthy, the 7,500 number was suggested by the commissioner and the governor and was then
00:57:38
written into the Appropriations Act, so it was not a number pulled out of thin air.
00:57:43
But it is based on the assumption that there's no secondary construction program, no urban construction program, no primary allocation, all the things.
00:57:52
It's based really on that six-year program and the diminished activities of the department.
00:57:59
Sharon, Mr. King.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:01
Based on your comments and then what's to follow, realizing we're doing this because of inadequate revenues to start with, now that we're going to stop any funds to secondary road maintenance, I'm wondering if we're not going to come back next year or year after next and say, now we've got to right size again.
00:58:22
We really are not doing any road maintenance.
00:58:24
And the 2,500 people out there at 180 locations
00:58:28
Dr. Michael A. Williams III, Dr. Michael A. Williams III
00:58:47
The situation that we're in because of the inadequate revenues to do an appropriate maintenance and construction project.
00:58:55
But back to the question, are we going to have to visit this again because there is no money for secondary road maintenance when we're going to definitely have people out there in 180 locations that eventually we're going to say, look, you know, it would be good to keep you if we had some money to pay you to do certain maintenance issues here on secondary roads.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:18
No one has a crystal ball.
00:59:21
Certainly that's a possibility.
00:59:22
Probably even more immediate is at some point, August, September, October, we're going to get a revised revenue estimate.
00:59:29
And so we may have even more immediate issues to deal with than that long term.
00:59:35
And as we know, secondary maintenance is constrained over time.
00:59:41
We're not adequately funding that in the Six-Year Program.
00:59:43
So that is a plausible scenario.
00:59:46
with the urban system, although that's a shared responsibility with the cities.
00:59:52
Ms. Pandak.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:52
Yes, Mr. Secretary.
00:59:54
Mr. Ekern, let me touch this on the part that there is no money for now and you apparently have re-proportioned and that's the design, engineering, construction of new projects.
01:00:06
Am I to understand that if there were to be money for new projects, the goal would be to outsource and not do the work that might have been done previously within VDOT, in VDOT.
01:00:20
And with, are there adequate staff with your resizing now to do that supervision or would the requirement be that in addition to money to do the actual putting pavement down,
01:00:35
That you would also need the staff to supervise the contracts that are out forced.
Richard Bennett
State Right of Way Director
01:00:40
Wow, multi-part question.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:42
That's really good.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:43
The department is sized to deliver a program that we anticipate in the Six-Year Program.
01:00:52
If there are significant additional revenues added, it would be the intention under this plan to do the project development through consultants, not to up-staff the department.
01:01:05
We are moving as an agency to a project management mentality as opposed to the design mentality.
01:01:12
So we've just held our first institute dealing with strengthening project management.
01:01:19
specifically targeted toward project development.
01:01:26
We are ensuring that all projects are correctly inspected.
01:01:32
Just as we have stabilized around our bridge inspection program to ensure that all bridges are being inspected, we are not dramatically affecting the bridge inspection program.
01:01:44
We are then, as we look at construction inspection,
01:01:47
ensuring that we have experienced staff to match the program.
01:01:54
We will utilize consultants in addition to that if there's this uptick or as we move down.
01:02:02
And the chief engineer is reviewing our inspection standards to ensure that they are reflective of what we need to do to ensure a quality product.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:19
Any additional questions or comments?
01:02:22
And again, Commissioner, if you could go back to that early slide that has the pie chart that shows where these cuts are coming from.
01:02:31
This is so important for board members to explain because one item typically is extracted in a community of interest, but 72% of the reductions are coming out of your highway construction program, 15%
01:02:48
are coming out of the administrative and support.
01:02:52
That's what we've been talking about today.
01:02:55
Thirteen percent are coming out of the maintenance program, essentially the services, the mowing, the rest area, the equipment shops.
01:03:06
But to summarize, you know, that 15 percent that the commissioner has been talking about today, a little bit historical sweep,
01:03:14
When Mr. Davies was first appointed to this board as the senior member, there were about 10,500 VDOT employees.
01:03:24
This time last year, there were 8,500.
01:03:29
This time next year, there will be 7,500.
01:03:31
That is 3,000 full-time employees and about 500 part-time employees in that period of time.
01:03:42
reduction and Commissioner, on behalf of everyone, I want to commend you for the very diligent work that you're doing.
01:03:49
All of us need to be aware that this last 1,000 employees, in a matter of a week, two weeks, about 600 people are going to get notices and they will be asking questions about their economic future, their professional future, their family's future.
01:04:07
They likely will come to you.
01:04:09
It's very important
01:04:11
that you reinforce this is not an easy or a choice that was made easily.
01:04:18
This is economic necessity and business necessity for the department.
01:04:24
It's also important that they remain engaged in the process of working through this.
01:04:29
So there are 600 notices but at the end of that process, only about 260 layoffs.
01:04:35
and the best thing for those employees is to diligently pursue that process with the human resources people in the department.
01:04:45
Thank you, Commissioner.
01:04:47
The next item on the agenda is an update on the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel and the recommendations for an independent review panel.
01:04:57
Presenting is the district administrator, Dennis Huer.
01:05:01
While Mr. Huer is getting queued up, I think all of us
01:05:05
were aware of, some of us painfully so, the events that started on July the 1st.
01:05:11
The Commissioner, again, it's been a very challenging couple of weeks where the Commissioner went down last Friday to brief the region, the media, state and local elected officials and average citizens about what happened, what VDOT is doing today and what VDOT will be doing over the coming weeks and months to address this very serious situation.
01:05:31
Welcome, Mr. Heuer.
SPEAKER_22
01:05:32
Mr. Secretary, ladies and gentlemen of the Board, good morning.
01:05:36
I'm going to jump right into the briefing.
01:05:37
What I'd like to do is direct your attention to the big screen here is to orient everybody on the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:05:45
We have basically our submerged tube is in the soil.
01:05:50
It is not in the water and it has soil cover on top.
01:05:54
The little red diagram or the triangle here is the approximate location where we discovered the fire main that was broken.
01:06:05
I also want to give a little orientation of what the cross section of the tunnel looks like.
01:06:11
We have a concrete encased steel tube with additional concrete on the inside.
01:06:17
I want to start over here on the yellow side of the green that talks about roadway drainage.
01:06:23
When you drive through the tunnel, there are a series of grates.
01:06:27
that collect the runoff of the storm water and the rainwater from the vehicles that go through the tunnel.
01:06:33
And when we wash the tunnel, that water has to go somewhere.
01:06:36
The analogy would be a roof drain on a building.
01:06:40
All the water hits the roof, it goes to the roof drains, it goes through a pipe into the bottom of this lower duct where there is a holding tank.
01:06:50
And in that holding tank is where we do our oil water separating.
01:06:54
maintaining and retaining the grit that runs off of the vehicles and then ultimately that's pumped to another tank with an oil water separator that ultimately goes out into the bay to meet our conditions of the environmental permit.
01:07:11
The next going around is the air flu.
01:07:14
We have the upper duct and the lower duct here and they provide air through this flu to maintain
01:07:23
The appropriate level of carbon dioxide and evacuate that air.
01:07:27
We're providing supply air in this lower duct.
01:07:30
It comes up through this flue, and then it comes out the upper duct, and then it's evacuated into the air.
01:07:37
We've got the roadway surface.
01:07:39
We have this upper duct like I just described.
01:07:43
Coming around at 3 o'clock, we have the emergency access sidewalk and handrail.
01:07:50
Underneath on the other side is another series of grates, like I described the roadway drainage.
01:07:57
Then we have a pump discharge line that evacuates that lower tank and brings it ultimately out into the bay.
01:08:05
We have the lower duct and then we have the fire main.
01:08:09
That was where we discovered the burst.
01:08:11
And that fire main is a pressurized line that I'm going to discuss next.
01:08:17
The fire system plan view has two supplies.
01:08:21
We have a supply line from the city of Hampton.
01:08:23
We have a supply line from the city of Norfolk.
01:08:26
We have fire water pumps that make sure that the line is pressurized, and it is in a circular loop.
01:08:33
So if there is a break at one point, it can be isolated, or if a supply drops off from one of our municipal partners, we can maintain the water for firefighting.
01:08:44
In each of the tubes, there's a series of
01:08:47
We call them standpipes in the tunnel, but essentially they are like residential fire hydrants and they're interspersed.
01:08:54
You can see them as you drive through the tunnel.
01:08:57
We also have chemical fire extinguishers that are in little niches as well in the tunnel.
01:09:05
The situation as we faced on, started on July 1st was the National Weather Service in Wakefield issued a special weather statement at 8.20 p.m.
01:09:16
They followed that with a severe thunderstorm warning at 8.50 p.m. And then they issued a special marine warding at 9 p.m.
01:09:25
The blue pushpins that you see here, this map came directly off the National Weather Service website.
01:09:31
And those were incidents, downed trees or such that they recorded in Wakefield.
01:09:38
The microburst that came through and covered the James River Bridge
01:09:43
hit at about nine o'clock, which was the time that special Marine warning was issued.
01:09:49
There were a lot of simultaneous events occurring on the evening of July 1st, the morning of July 2nd, and they're all numerated on the slide here.
01:10:00
Specifically, we were reporting initially to the all traffic stopped on the James River Bridge, and what that amounted to were Dominion power lines
01:10:12
came across because of that microburst and blocked all four lanes of the James River Bridge shutting down traffic.
01:10:19
We also had a loss of power at both the Monitor Meramec and the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:10:24
And while the Chesapeake Bridge Tunnel is now VDOT's for operations, just to put it in perspective, they were also experiencing results of that weather event.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:35
Mr. Heuer, can you go back to that slide and
01:10:37
You know, we spent a lot of time talking about infrastructure and age and this process.
01:10:44
Has it ever, there ever been an incident when all four water crossings were simultaneously closed due to a weather event?
01:10:54
I know we've had to do that in anticipation of a hurricane, but an unanticipated event like this, it strikes me as pretty, my knowledge goes back
SPEAKER_22
01:11:04
Just approximating five years, but in my five years here, we've never had one where we've shut down all traffic.
01:11:09
And as we go a little further in the timeline, I'd like to hit another couple of events that affected us.
01:11:18
Looking at the timeline here from a regional perspective, this is a macro view.
01:11:24
We had our thunderstorm, then we had the power lines and traffic.
01:11:28
No power at the Monitor Merrimack.
01:11:30
We lost power at the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:11:33
and reconstructing at this point somewhere around 9, 10, 11 we believe is when the fire main actually burst.
01:11:41
It was coincident with the weather event not directly caused by the weather event and I'll highlight the fire main a little bit later.
01:11:50
And we had our both lanes blocked.
01:11:52
And here's where I was talking about, Mr. Secretary, we had a one-car accident after we started rerouting traffic from the westbound Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:12:00
The normal route is heading them around on Interstate 64 to pick up the Monitor Merrimack northbound.
01:12:07
So we had one accident on the high-rise bridge, but as we were shifting traffic to our alternate high-speed route, the Monitor Merrimack, we had a three-car accident.
01:12:17
Until that accident was cleared, essentially northbound traffic, our rerouting was stymied.
01:12:24
We were able to get one lane open at two o'clock,
01:12:28
and then by 7 o'clock we have 730 we had all the traffic restored and that was our initial response action was to restore traffic.
01:12:40
The details of the timeline are still being reconstructed and this is a highlight on here but I'm going to go to this.
01:12:47
This is the piece of the broken iron pipe that caused the
01:12:56
discharge of a whole lot of water into the lower duct.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:03
That piece of pipe, that's what, a water main?
SPEAKER_22
01:13:09
Yes, it's an eight inch piece of cast iron that is embedded in concrete so it is not able to be visually inspected.
01:13:22
The piece that broke out is about 19 inches long
01:13:25
and about four and a half inches wide at its widest part.
01:13:29
So this is a 52-year-old pipe that is embedded in concrete that's in that loop system that I showed you earlier.
01:13:38
Now what we have done is we pressure test that by National Fire Protection System 25.
01:13:46
The protocol is in five-year intervals
01:13:49
You are to pressurize the line to 200 pounds per square inch.
01:13:53
You maintain that for two hours and you look for a pressure drop.
01:13:57
That was performed in 2006.
01:13:58
It held for two hours.
01:14:00
There was no pressure drop.
01:14:02
We also conduct a flow rate test with our pumps and the pipes, obviously looking for obstructions as well.
01:14:10
Can you maintain a certain flow rate that's necessitated by the fire department?
01:14:15
We did that in 2006 as well, and it provided the appropriate flow rate.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:21
But the important thing, and we focus, again, I focus so much on that piece of pipe, but completely unrelated to this, you have every other
01:14:32
Water crossing in the region experiencing power lines down, lights out, tractor trailers turned over.
01:14:38
And there's no relationship that you've been able to find between the electrical storm and the rupturing of the pipe?
SPEAKER_22
01:14:43
What we are investigating is one of the fire pumps, if I, back here, right, at 1145 p.m., our folks in the control room, or prior to 1145 p.m., they had an indicator of light that one of the fire pumps was running.
01:15:02
Now I don't know at this point whether that was a result of the restoration of power and a power surge kicked on one of the pumps, whether it was a mechanical failure or what caused that pump to come on.
01:15:14
Maybe that was the indicator of the fire main break.
01:15:16
We're still investigating that and the Commissioner's going to highlight something at the end of the briefing where we're going to be able to look into that in more detail.
01:15:24
But to try and answer your question, Mr. Secretary, we don't know exactly what caused it.
01:15:28
Was it a, did the fire main pump
01:15:32
which their purposes are to maintain the pressure for firefighting.
01:15:38
I'm speculating at this point now.
01:15:39
Did that over pressurize the line and there was a weak spot?
01:15:43
That's something we're also trying to investigate.
01:15:48
You know, let's look further into the reconstructed timeline.
01:15:52
The major point here is at 626 a.m., all traffic was stopped in the westbound tube because water was observed in the roadway.
01:16:02
Puddles, we all drive through puddles around the Commonwealth depending upon what the rain event is.
01:16:08
Issue has been addressed about emergency evacuation.
01:16:12
Cars do drive through puddles of water, but at a 55 mile an hour tunnel, not knowing what the cause was, we erred on the side of safety, stopped all traffic till we could identify what the issue was.
01:16:24
At 742, the maintenance folks figured out that it was a water supply issue,
01:16:32
and they cut off all the water supply to the tunnel.
01:16:38
Moving further, the next major points here were at 2.13 PM, the right lane was open to traffic and then the next major event was 7.37, both lanes were open and that intervening time was we had
01:16:54
surface pumps, we had the fire department in there using their pumper trucks, hoses were in the roadway, it took us that time to get that out of the roadway to open up both lanes of traffic.
01:17:07
We also had a reconstructed public communication timeline and you can see here it was multifaceted whether it was our person in public affairs communicating with the press, we were interviewing media, we got on Metro traffic, we used 511,
01:17:23
We brought in extra safety service patrols to help direct traffic.
01:17:28
And one of the ones here is we did use a total of 56 changeable message signs.
01:17:33
41 of those were directly communicating incidents, rerouting of traffic related to the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
01:17:42
And 15 of those changeable message signs were directly related and tied into this incident, directing and controlling the Monitor Merrimack Tunnel.
01:17:56
Our action plan started immediately, which was our original initial goal was to restore traffic.
01:18:03
Concurrent with that was conducting emergency response.
01:18:07
Once we had the cause or actually the source identified, we went into emergency recovery.
01:18:13
And that consisted essentially of pumping out the water, going down and investigating what was going on so people could safely get in.
01:18:24
Wednesday evening after we had the pump stations, the lower area pumped out where people could go down, we then found the water main break.
01:18:36
And the way that was done is that hunk of steel was laying in the bottom of the tunnel with lots of concrete from an explosion from a pressurized line that blew that steel pipe, that concrete cover, and it all wound up being down in the bottom of the tunnel.
01:18:57
The next part, we had some pumps that were down there that were evacuating that lower, that would evacuate that lower tank that I described earlier that actually holds the rainwater that comes off of the trucks.
01:19:13
We got those motors became covered in water, electric motor underwater, you got to replace it.
01:19:19
Then while we had the target of opportunity replacing the pumps,
01:19:23
We didn't want to have another failure.
01:19:26
We rebuilt the pumps as well.
01:19:29
What we're doing now in the near term is a process stand down to say, what did we do?
01:19:34
How did we do it?
01:19:36
And what do we need to focus on now?
01:19:40
Going forward, we will issue a contract to repair that fire main at the location where it burst.
01:19:47
But prior to issuing that contract,
01:19:49
We want to do a little forensics in addition to that line to make sure if we do let a contract, we've covered everything.
01:19:56
And then the commissioner now will address looking to the next steps.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:20:02
Mr. Chairman, since the fire protection is so crucial, the line has not been repaired so that you have the high pressure fire protection?
SPEAKER_22
01:20:13
Mr. Davis, one of the things we did in 2005, 2006,
01:20:17
Remember, I went back to those hydrants.
01:20:19
Each one of those hydrants has a valve.
01:20:22
The valve is located in a niche inside the tunnel, a little indented area where they are easily accessible.
01:20:29
Part of our maintenance program, what we did is we replaced all of those valves so when there is either a failure of a valve or in this case a failure of the pipe, we can isolate it
01:20:41
supply water to all of the rest of the hydrants around that loop and only isolate a 150-foot section that the pipe is broken, providing it.
01:20:52
So the rest of the system is energized except for 150 feet.
01:20:57
And one of the first things we did was let the fire rescue folks know on Hampton and Norfolk side that we had a problem and that there was no fire water until we determined what happened and was able to restore
01:21:12
And with the fire departments as their protocols normally, they respond usually with a tanker and a pumper whether the fire system is working or not.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:22
Oh, is there another question?
01:21:24
Mr. Koelemay?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:25
Mr. Chairman, what would you expect would come out of the review panel?
01:21:30
Obviously, you've documented a lot of it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:32
Yeah, Mr. Koelemay, you're getting ahead of the commissioner here a little bit.
01:21:34
Let him talk about that, if you might, please.
01:21:37
Thank you.
SPEAKER_13
01:21:38
Good question.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:21:40
Perfect segue.
01:21:40
With your forbearance, I'm not going to get up and walk over there.
01:21:43
My knees are getting old, so I'm going to stay here to finish up.
01:21:49
Dennis kind of indicated we're actually pursuing three tracks.
01:21:55
There is the first track that he's described to you today, which is the recovery of the facility, making sure things are working there.
01:22:05
Second, we are reviewing the incident specifics to make sure, and that's part of the stand-down process that he's talked about.
01:22:15
III, I've taken another step and I've invited 11 professionals from across the country, various state agencies here in the Commonwealth and the local communities to engage in a review of technology, procedures, protocols utilized in tunnel management and operation.
01:22:41
Over the last
01:22:42
For days I've been in contact with people as are represented.
01:22:48
The one thing I couldn't get edited this morning is Parsons Brinkerhoff is not a part of the invitees to this panel.
01:22:57
And we are finalizing invitations.
01:23:01
I've got acknowledgments from the 11 invited professionals as a part of this process.
01:23:09
I've got acknowledgements and acceptances from ten, so that's why I didn't publish all the names this morning.
01:23:16
We will finalize that last name, yet today they're just getting back to me as they work through their processes.
01:23:25
We anticipate, on the next slide, convening this panel under the support of the Virginia Research Council
01:23:36
to convene in the first week of August and over the course of the next 45 to 60 days to review not hard infrastructure issues, which was done in 2004 and 5, but to look at the use of technologies, our procedures, and our protocols
01:24:02
to give us advice on where we can strengthen those systems as opposed to fixing an incident.
01:24:14
I need to acknowledge up front that as I started down this process of inviting people to assist us with this process, I did get feedback that said Virginia is a leader in the country in a lot of aspects of tunnel management.
01:24:30
Many people, and in fact
01:24:32
Federal Highway Administration scan tours come to Virginia to see how to do it.
01:24:38
And in fact, that's going on, will occur yet this year in another case.
01:24:44
But I think this is a needed extra step that we need to take to address that whole emergency response piece and ensure that our people are supported with the right protocols, the right systems, the right technologies
01:25:01
as we move forward.
01:25:04
I anticipate a final report from that panel by mid-September, which we will then share and ensure that if there's an action plan and implementation that is necessary from that, that it is like all other projects implemented on a schedule.
01:25:26
Now, I started to address your question, and I think I got close, but if you're ready, let's open it up to questions.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:25:34
Yeah, my question, Mr. Chairman, thank you, is will the panel be as ambitious to look at the development of new standards, new designs, new testing techniques?
01:25:46
It's not just the pipe that could be 52 years old.
01:25:50
Some of the procedures actually
01:25:52
Not just related to transportation but the way the facilities are put together in the first place.
01:25:58
You've heard me say before there's now sensing networks that you install that tell you, you know, tell you I'm having a problem, check me.
01:26:08
And, you know, those kind of things have developed pretty quickly in the last few years.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:14
That's an excellent question and a good way to frame the charge.
01:26:18
You're highlighting something that I've learned over the last 14 days or 10 days working on this issue.
01:26:24
And very frankly, it's getting an understanding that a tunnel is exactly as you characterize it.
01:26:30
It's a living system.
01:26:32
It is not like a bridge that has a static kind of component to it.
01:26:37
And so all of those systems that support that living system of a tunnel
01:26:42
really need to be tuned up and I think historically people have had a tendency to only think about it as a static structure that sits underneath some water.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:57
Let me just add, Mr. Chairman, if I could, that I really do see, well we've all lamented the lack of resources to do things that we know are necessary, but I really see a failure
01:27:10
if we're not able to follow up on these opportunities that offer leadership potential.
01:27:16
And I would say we ought to build on the leadership the Commonwealth has in this area.
01:27:21
And I'd like to see us really be ambitious in our review and therefore instructive to the rest of the country as well as anybody else who would pay attention about what needs to be done in this area.
01:27:34
So I would support a very ambitious review process.
SPEAKER_22
01:27:40
Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, could I add one thing on Mr. Koelemay?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:43
One quick point.
01:27:47
We're fortunate in the Commonwealth.
01:27:50
Our chief engineer is not just a chief engineer.
01:27:55
He hates it when I do this.
01:27:58
He is, in fact, an internationally known expert in structures.
01:28:04
And, in fact, this last week he was
01:28:09
He's chair of an AASHTO committee on bridges and structures.
01:28:14
And for the first time under his leadership and his initiative, that committee has issued, and now I'm going to say it wrong, Mal, because I've never been on the technical side, what I call the first uniform set of national structure standards for tunnels.
01:28:32
Because each tunnel has its own set of standards, and that's the way they've been measured and managed in the past.
01:28:39
So in addition to his leadership and expertise, there's a national scan going, is it international or national?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:51
There is an international scan and what they're doing is a domestic scan.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:56
That will be visiting Virginia to capture our knowledge.
01:29:01
So I think that helps support your thoughts on being aggressive in this business.
SPEAKER_22
01:29:08
Mr. Secretary?
01:29:10
Well, we were talking, Mr. Koelemay, talking about some of the ongoing things.
01:29:13
In the period 2003 through 2009, we have expended $8.2 million in maintenance and life safety upgrades and repairs and maintenance in the tunnel for such things as replacing those fire main pumps that we talked about, the valves.
01:29:32
We've
01:29:33
I worked on the ventilation fan sprinkler system replacement.
01:29:36
We've done the upgrade to OSHA standards for those handrails and the sidewalks that I referenced in the drawing.
01:29:43
We have a hydrocarbon detection system in the lower air duct, and we've done work on ventilation fan dampers and controls.
01:29:50
And those ventilation fans are important because that's how, should there be a fire in the tunnel, not only with the fire responders coming in to put it out, we've got to get that smoke out.
01:30:00
So those fans exhaust that smoke from a potential fire through that upper duct.
01:30:05
We also have in the years 2008 and 2009, we have another $46 million program for that work.
01:30:15
And probably the largest number is the electrical switch gear generators and controls to be replaced in a 52-year-old facility.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:24
Mr. Chairman, are any of those
01:30:27
improvements and expenditures jeopardized by the current budget situation in the Commonwealth, or those largely self-supported by, those are our needs assessment that feeds into our operations and maintenance budget.
SPEAKER_22
01:30:43
So that's what we're shooting towards due right now.
SPEAKER_13
01:30:48
A follow-on comment to that.
01:30:49
I brought with me the newspaper article from that day.
01:30:53
Karmageddon, is what it was that referred to, because this was a major tie-up in the Hampton Roads area.
01:31:00
I mean, there were 20-mile backups you could not get from one place or the other.
01:31:05
So obviously, I support a vigorous review, and Mr. Heuer has been nice enough to come by and explain to me all the things that are going on.
01:31:12
The point I would make, Mr. Koelemay, to your comment about funding is, unfortunately,
01:31:19
Either the press or many of our legislatures have picked up on this as a way to impugn the integrity of VDOT, which I only bring up here in that I know that's why we have to do this review, but at the end of the day, it's a 52-year-old pipe.
01:31:36
Our infrastructure is aging, and that the real answer is going to be
01:31:41
having to find additional funding sources.
01:31:43
Now I know that's easy to say and it's probably been said for many years but the fact of the matter is these pipes are going to break again.
01:31:50
Obviously we have to update our policies and procedures for the aging which I'm sure we're doing but I too was at the hearing and I wish I could tell you it was productive.
01:32:02
It was name pointing between Senate and the House of Delegates.
01:32:07
So if nothing else, I'd like to point out this is a critical issue.
01:32:11
Hopefully, this will wake our region up and our legislatures up that we have to quit talking about this and actually do something about it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:19
Thank you.
01:32:21
Any additional questions, Mr. Dickens?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:32:22
One additional comment, and I certainly support his comment.
01:32:28
It was interesting, the follow-up article relative to the General Assembly's requesting an additional study.
01:32:37
was the blog comments that came after that.
01:32:43
And if you think about the article saying, the reference was that what VDOT's doing is not good enough, we need to go further and have a more intensive investigation.
01:32:57
The response from the public was,
01:33:02
It's the General Assembly's issue because the General Assembly is not providing the funding to do the maintenance that we need to do.
01:33:10
I thought it was really interesting and hopefully
01:33:16
Something that we'll see more of in the future is the public is beginning to recognize that we do indeed have a funding issue here and recognize where that buck stops.
01:33:30
I thought it was very telling to follow the public comments about this incident.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:33:40
Mr. Heuer, thank you for making the voyage.
01:33:43
I know that you and your staff have been working very long hours addressing this very challenging situation.
01:33:50
Nothing is more important to what I regard as the most infrastructure dependent portion of the Commonwealth, which is the Hampton Roads region, whether it's the bridges, whether it's the tunnel, whether it's the port, whether it's the Navy base.
01:34:02
Whether it's the airport, even the new light rail, we know that infrastructure is at risk because it is low-lying, there's a lot of water, and things are aging.
01:34:15
So your challenges are acknowledged, and you and your staff are doing a great job.
01:34:19
Thank you so much for your efforts.
01:34:23
Okay, the next item, also in Hampton Roads region, Mr. Dickens is going to brief us on the independent review panel recommendations on the downtown, midtown Martin Luther King extension PPTA project.
01:34:40
While that's being queued up, just to remind folks, the department issued a solicitation for conceptual proposals to add a second tube for the midtown tunnel.
01:34:54
That solicitation was responded to.
01:34:58
The first step in that process is the creation of an independent review panel that Mr. Dickens chaired, and he is going to brief us on the recommendations and the results of that study.
01:35:08
Welcome, Mr. Dickens.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:35:10
Mr. Chairman, thank you very much, and ladies and gentlemen of the Commonwealth Transportation Board, thank you for the opportunity to present the independent review panel's findings on the conceptual
01:35:22
Proposal submitted by the Elizabeth River Crossing in response to the conceptual proposal issued by VDOT on May 30, 2008.
01:35:33
Before I go any further, I want to thank particularly Raymond Partridge and Danielle for all their help in putting this panel together and staffing it.
01:35:45
They and other members of the VDOT staff, Mr. Ekern, have done an exceptional job in making what is a very complex process very doable.
01:35:57
I was honored to be selected, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, to be chairman of this panel.
01:36:04
And what I want to do today is bring to you some of the panel's deliberations, some of the recommendations of the panel,
01:36:13
But first let me give you some background if I may on the process before the panel took its work.
01:36:23
Let me start by saying this project as is evidenced by what you've just seen is absolutely critical to Hampton Roads and I might also add to the Commonwealth of Virginia.
01:36:36
The quality of life,
01:36:39
The economic impact of congestion in Hampton Roads as a result of this tunnel and other crossings and I would say that the water in Hampton Roads is not only a blessing but a curse when it comes to transportation opportunities.
01:36:58
The port is certainly the blessing that is a result of our waterways and while the port
01:37:09
is a small piece of the congestion at the Midtown Tunnel.
01:37:15
Congestion is a large piece of the port's competitiveness as a result of the use of the Midtown Tunnel.
01:37:24
And I say that this project has an impact across the Commonwealth of Virginia because the port, which will be directly impacted by this project, generates about 350,000 jobs around the Commonwealth of Virginia.
01:37:39
A little more than $13.5 billion of payroll.
01:37:43
And gentlemen and ladies, it impacts every district in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
01:37:51
The panel worked using two guiding principles.
01:37:55
One is we must have this project.
01:37:58
And the second is that we must have an affordable toll.
01:38:03
The affordable toll piece was difficult, will be a difficult process.
01:38:09
because the proposal as it was presented, the conceptual proposal as it was presented is in the neighborhood of two billion dollars requiring a total of two to three dollars which most everybody will determine is unaffordable.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:29
Mr. Dickens, can you, there are a number of slides that I think in particular those not from the regional help if you can advance the slides to
01:38:38
I'm not there yet.
01:38:40
I'm getting there, sir.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:49
As a matter of fact, I'm getting there real quick.
01:38:52
But the biggest issue with the panel was the toll, and I think the Secretary has had a lot of discussions about that.
01:39:02
Three parts to the process.
01:39:04
and what I would like to do is take this map and kind of give you some orientation.
01:39:11
This is the Elizabeth River, the Norfolk International Terminals up here, downtown Norfolk here, downtown Portsmouth here, I-64, the new Maersk which is a half a billion dollar economic development opportunity here, I-64,
01:39:32
in this avenue with the new rail line that we have been talking about a number of times.
01:39:39
Portsmouth International Terminal, Norfolk International Terminal, Midtown Tunnel is here, connects with the Martin Luther King Expressway here.
01:39:50
The extension of the Martin Luther King Expressway, which is a part of this project, is here.
01:39:57
and as you can see with the Midtown Tunnel, the Martin Luther King Expressway, the Downtown Tunnel, we have by connecting the, using the Martin Luther King Expressway, connecting these two, we have opportunities for alternative travel if one of the tunnels is congested.
01:40:21
I would point out also to you that there's a new intersection on 264 in this proposal
01:40:26
and there's a piece of property right here in that intersection which belongs to CSX and is an opportunity for an intermodal park which is an important issue that we'll need to discuss as this moves forward.
01:40:47
Obvious objectives of a project like this are to reduce
01:40:54
Congestion and increased capacity, but there are other opportunities here as well.
01:41:01
A facility that might be integrated into the operations of a regional transportation network, improving connectivity, emergency evacuation route, which has been highlighted by Mr. Heuer's remarks of what happened on July 2nd.
01:41:19
Objective also is to reduce and mitigate impacts on the environment
01:41:23
and to coordinate adjacent land uses so that we're maximizing our opportunities.
01:41:32
The process, which is pretty formal, if I may say that, has some interesting processes.
01:41:43
Let me enumerate some of it, if I may.
01:41:46
Components of this project have been identified in the
01:41:50
Hampton Road, or in the Constrained Long Range Plan for a long time, but there have been no funds to build this project.
01:42:01
Under the Public-Private Transportation Act, VDOT solicited proposals in 2008, as I said earlier, to facilitate private investment in this much-needed project.
01:42:16
In response to the solicitation,
01:42:18
A proposal came forward from the Elizabeth River Crossing Group.
01:42:24
The two lead organizations in that group are Skanska Infrastructure Development and also Macquarie Financial Holdings.
01:42:37
There are a number of other organizations in the group, but they are the primary ones.
01:42:44
During the second phase of the procurement, the Secretary of Transportation appointed a 13-member independent review panel.
01:42:53
That panel met five times in Norfolk and Portsmouth.
01:42:58
During those times, we were exposed to presentations by the Elizabeth River Crossing folks, the VDOT staff, and also there was several opportunities for the public to
01:43:14
to make comments in this, regarding the proposal.
01:43:21
The purpose of the panel, we were to accomplish two tasks.
01:43:26
First, to determine the qualifications based on the proposal of Elizabeth River Crossing and their ability to develop and operate the project.
01:43:41
Secondly, we were
01:43:43
asked to develop recommendations to the commissioner that we thought would help make this project more successful.
01:43:55
The qualifications and review recommendations were based on four priorities.
01:44:04
Priority number one, does the ERC have the financial capacity to keep personnel and the relative experience to
01:44:13
to develop this project.
01:44:16
Priority number two, does ERC exhibit a strong work history from projects of similar scope and magnitude and have the experience to complete this project?
01:44:29
Priority number three, does ERC have working relationships, viable financial plan, appropriate insurance, and other
01:44:40
items in place to undertake this project item.
01:44:43
Priority number four, does the RC demonstrate the qualifications through the approach?
01:44:51
Do they have the appropriate risk assessment and adequate organizational structure to make this project come to fruition?
01:45:01
The consensus of the panel was a very strong yes
01:45:08
ERC did meet the qualifications in all four of these priorities.
01:45:14
As a matter of fact, we were very impressed with the proposal.
01:45:19
So as a result, the panel agreed upon recommendations
01:45:23
To advance the ERC's conceptual proposal and even went further and recommended, we proceed directly to an interim agreement.
01:45:36
Normally in this process, you go to a detail proposal.
01:45:39
The panel thought that since there was only one proposer, it would certainly save a lot of time and money if we moved directly to an interim agreement.
01:45:51
In fulfilling our second task, we discussed and developed 15 consensus recommendations which I want to share with you briefly now if I may.
01:46:05
The first recommendation I just mentioned was the interim agreement.
01:46:11
Again, it allows us to move along more quickly with this project and obviously in this case time is money.
01:46:19
And as I mentioned, the toll issue is a very important part of this process.
01:46:25
The second is to continue to work with the FHWA to secure the approval to toll existing structures and to investigate and consider toll collection during the construction phase of the project through value pricing pilot programs.
01:46:42
The next recommendation is to consider the financial and technical feasibility of implementing operational and construction phasing of the project elements in an effort to reduce overall project cost.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:46:56
Mr. Chairman, I heard you make reference to a fair toll, and you used a number, but you passed over very quickly what you thought a fair toll would be.
01:47:06
I was just curious to hear that again if that was possible.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:09
Certainly.
01:47:10
I'd be happy to do that.
01:47:11
The proposal, the conceptual proposal laid out a two to three dollar estimate on the toll.
01:47:22
That most people consider unaffordable and the, what I hear, and nobody has officially stated this, but the objective would be somewhere in the dollar to a dollar fifty range.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:36
Mr. Chairman, if I might just share a perspective
01:47:40
Those of us in Northwestern Virginia pay $4 now to go to Dulles Airport on a 16-mile stretch of the Dulles Greenway.
01:47:49
And in recent travels abroad, $30 and $25 is not an unusual toll at all on bridge structures and complexity of the nature we're talking about.
01:48:01
And I would just hope that our colleagues and friends in Tidewater
01:48:07
I hope that's not a limiting factor in considering what needs to be done here because this definitely needs to be done.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:25
Dr. Davis, you raised a very important issue.
01:48:27
There's an important distinction here.
01:48:29
The Dulles Greenway that you cite for the majority of that toll was a brand new facility where people have options.
01:48:38
They can go on Route 7.
01:48:39
They can go on Route 50.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:41
I don't bother to agree too much with my chairman, but a lot of us don't feel we do have very many options.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:47
This is an existing facility that has been paid for through state and federal revenues.
01:48:57
This is the first instance where we would be retroactively tolling an existing facility for which there is no alternative.
01:49:07
And the toll here is not just on the Midtown Tunnel, but also on the Downtown Tunnel.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:12
I don't wish to impose any hardship on our friends in Tidewater.
01:49:16
I just think we have to be realistic when we start talking about how we're going to pay for a project like this.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:22
Understood.
01:49:23
But this is a very, very important issue.
01:49:26
and for the Hampton Roads region which is looking and their costs of construction exceed any other region of the Commonwealth.
01:49:38
This going back on an existing facility is something we have not undertaken as a Commonwealth in very few places in the US.
01:49:46
So this is a very, very important step that it be done right and that it be done fairly
01:49:53
and that it recognize in particular the social and economic characteristics of this region and I would while acknowledging the toll rates one also needs to look at the relative income levels of a Portsmouth versus Aladdin County and that's a live issue here and one that we do need to talk about.
01:50:13
Mr. McCarthy.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:14
Did I understand you Mr. Chairman to say that this would also add a toll to the downtown tunnel?
01:50:19
Yes sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:21
So if you look at the Elizabeth River, you have four crossings there.
01:50:29
You have the Jordan Bridge, which is currently condemned.
01:50:33
And there is a private sector toll proposal there.
01:50:35
There's the Gilmerton Bridge, which we have slated for reconstruction and hope to see bid awards here sometime this year.
01:50:43
And then you have the Midtown and the Downtown tunnels, which are the major arteries.
01:50:47
And both of those would be told retroactively.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:50
Mr. Chairman, I don't want to belabor the point.
01:50:52
I was trying to make a point that if we're going to use tolls to do projects in lieu of traditional means of financing road construction, I just think we have to be realistic to not give people the wrong impression that a dollar is going to pay for this project and instead face up to the fact that we're going to be using gas tax or whatever other sources of revenue to subsidize that instead of having them believe that they're going to pay for it with a toll.
01:51:20
If we're going to pay for it with a tow, it needs to be realistic.
01:51:23
If we're going to say we're going to do it as a Commonwealth project, which I would support, then we need to say we're going to do that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:30
And I think where Mr. Dickens is taking his recommendations is we need to do both to make this project work.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:36
And I would point out to you that the citizens of Hampton Roads who use that tunnel every day to get back and forth to work would say to you that it is a Commonwealth
01:51:47
And I agree it ought to be shared by the entire Commonwealth.
01:51:54
And in this particular case, with the impact the Port has and the importance of the Port to the entire Commonwealth, you would have some argument of the citizens of Hampton Roads paying full bore on this thing.
01:52:10
There's two sides of the coin, and I agree with you in large part.
SPEAKER_13
01:52:14
One comment while we're on tolls, I guess,
01:52:16
That's vehicular.
01:52:17
Trucks would be told at a higher rate.
01:52:20
That's correct.
01:52:21
Nine dollars I think and plus then we have the whole issue of public transportation and like you mentioned income levels Mr. Secretary and how they would be told so yeah so I think the citizens are realistic but it is something that's never been done before at least that was a big issue decades ago when we took the tolls off so that's why I think the issue on the tolls.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:52:45
I think when you mix PPTAs and public funding, you get a sort of a distorted view of what's going on in terms of priorities in the Commonwealth.
01:53:01
And I just hope that we all realize that, that if we're going to pay half the cost of this from traditional revenues and then half or a third or whatever it's going to be from tolls, we are saying it's not truly a PPTA
01:53:15
where it's all being done that way.
01:53:17
It is being done as a priority of the Commonwealth and somewhat supported by one source of revenues from tolls.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:26
Well, the Chair will reserve a final word on this topic.
01:53:29
There are two P's in public and private.
01:53:32
And the successful public-private, whether it's Route 28, whether it's Pocahontas Parkway here, whether it's the Capitol Beltway hot lanes, whether it's Dulles Rail, have
01:53:45
required these projects are so expensive.
01:53:49
It is a mixture of public and private resources that are necessary to make the projects work.
01:53:55
And again, explicitly in that act contemplates public sector contributions.
01:54:01
We're interrupting the flow of your presentation, Mr. Chairman.
01:54:04
I apologize.
01:54:07
But this is a very, very important issue and the retroactive tolling
01:54:12
of an existing facility has not been done, and so this is a major issue.
01:54:16
Thank you for raising your hand today.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:54:17
And I would make one additional comment to Mr. McCarthy.
01:54:21
I think Bill 3202 allowed for tolling on the Midtown and the Downtown Tunnel as parallel structures, not because they both provide the same access to Norfolk and Portsmouth and they're so close together.
01:54:39
That's why
01:54:40
Tolan is on the downtown tunnel.
01:54:42
Well, it probably wouldn't work if you had one of them free.
01:54:45
Right.
01:54:45
Plus, there's going to be some significant improvements to the downtown tunnel, which makes it work as well.
01:54:56
To continue with the panel's recommendations, one of the recommendations was to form working groups to look at ways to reduce the cost
01:55:07
One of the big issues was dredge materials, tunnel ventilation systems, other critical elements that we could work at with the proposal to reduce the cost of the toll.
01:55:22
Focus on small women, minority-owned businesses, work on a robust public engagement process,
01:55:35
Another recommendation was to coordinate with the Department of Rail and Public Transit, with the Hampton Roads Transit, with the cities of Norfolk and Portsmouth to make sure that we develop an efficient system there so that we take into account all of the opportunities that are presented to us.
01:55:59
Another is to continue to work
01:56:02
to develop an analysis identifying technical, environmental, and financial impacts to light rail transit and bus rapid transit options through the new tunnel.
01:56:15
And I would point out to you there was a significant amount of desire to have another tube in this process to accommodate light rail, which is being developed in Norfolk.
01:56:29
After a lot of discussion and analysis, it was determined that putting another tube there would add a third to the cost and would essentially be a deal killer.
01:56:45
But it was a very prominently discussed issue.
01:56:52
Another recommendation,
01:56:58
Another recommendation was to do a public outreach program to educate the public, particularly in regards to the tolling and how that might work.
01:57:10
Another recommendation was to cooperatively and proactively work with the cities of Portsmouth and Norfolk to lessen impacts on their properties, to provide aesthetics, landscaping, design, and other issues that would blend into the communities.
01:57:30
Another recommendation was to pursue public and private sector funding with the intent of locating additional contributions that could be allocated to the project, particularly related to maintenance money that was currently being expended on the project and other opportunities to find public money to go in this PPT TA.
01:57:58
recommendation was to continue to evaluate the proposal tolling regime, considering congestion pricing during peak periods and tolling escalation throughout the life of the project.
01:58:12
Another recommendation was to work in coordination with the private sector to consider employment to the qualified VDOT personnel, lessening the impact on the project moving to entirely the private sector.
01:58:27
Another was to consider providing for priority access for tolling treatments for transit opportunities.
01:58:36
It's essentially a discount for the transit.
01:58:40
Another recommendation was to work with the localities to identify additional efficiencies with the proposed project and the adjacent traffic network in order to maximize travel efficiencies and throughput.
01:58:57
and I did mention earlier in the discussion the CSX property and I think the Chairman has some additional information there.
01:59:10
Thanks for the opportunity to present this.
01:59:12
The panel worked long and hard.
01:59:14
Alan Witt and Cord Sterling both participated on the panel.
01:59:19
Cord driving long distances to participate and I appreciate that.
01:59:24
I want to thank Elizabeth River
01:59:26
Crossings Group for being very cooperative and very much a willing partner in reducing the cost of this tunnel and the toll that goes with it.
01:59:39
And with that, I'll stand to answer any questions anyone might have.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:43
Questions or comments to Mr. Dickens?
01:59:46
Ms. Pandak.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:46
Mr. Chairman, it may be that I'm new to this, but what's the timeframe and projections on this?
01:59:51
I didn't pick that up.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:54
You may want to respond to that, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:57
The goal here, and the next step in the process would be execution of an interim agreement over the next several months.
02:00:05
Those don't happen overnight.
02:00:09
But as quickly as possible, and that would spell out a more detailed schedule for completion of design and bringing design to a high enough level to execute a design-build contract, to evaluate financial feasibility.
02:00:24
So I think there are some suggestions in the conceptual proposal at the conclusion of that interim agreement, which we'll see once that is concluded.
02:00:38
We'll have a much harder schedule.
02:00:39
There may be folks here who can talk conceptually about the schedule.
02:00:44
Mr. Holcomb, can you talk about that?
02:00:46
But this is a lengthy process of designing and getting
02:00:50
In particular, there's a lot of uncertainty in the capital markets right now, which makes a lot of these projects challenging.
SPEAKER_18
02:00:56
Mr. Holcomb.
02:00:57
Yes, sir.
02:00:57
Thank you.
02:00:59
We anticipate coming to this body in the September time period to give you the major business points about the interim agreement itself and then possibly signing the interim agreement in the September time period.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:12
And in the conceptual proposal, when was construction estimated start recognizing that's a conceptual proposal?
SPEAKER_18
02:01:20
We would anticipate the comprehensive agreement being signed in the late 2010 time period and then construction probably starting in the 2011 time period.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:39
Would you say that in the course of this process you've established this project as the priority, the priority of the region?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:49
Without a doubt.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:51
Because that's always been a problem in your region and in my region, establishing a priority.
02:01:57
We're going to hear a little bit later about market conditions, risk assessments, credit markets, even vehicle miles traveled estimates that have changed the situation for a project in Northern Virginia.
02:02:15
Is the panel at all
02:02:17
Well, I think we're expecting it to move forward.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:02:32
The indications we got from the Elizabeth River crossing people were very positive.
02:02:41
You're right.
02:02:42
It has always been a difficulty in your region as well as in my region to determine priorities.
02:02:49
And I think without a doubt this is a priority in our region.
02:02:55
The Secretary and the Chief Financial Officer are looking for additional public money to put in this project to make it work.
02:03:07
As it stands now, there is none.
02:03:09
It's all private money.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:12
Final question, Mr. Chairman.
02:03:14
Do you have a sort of a working estimate of the size, you know, what the dollar cost for the total package of improvements that you talked about?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:24
Well, the conceptual proposal came in to do all three pieces of this project and in the neighborhood of two buildings.
02:03:35
Conceptual proposals are very broad brush strokes.
02:03:40
And we had a considerable amount of discussion with the panel and the proposer about the cost reductions.
02:03:49
I mentioned dredge disposal
02:03:52
If we can use the cranny island for disposal of the dredge materials, which is right there, significant reduction in cost of having to carry them out to see the disposal.
02:04:05
The proposer mentioned a couple of other changes, ventilation changes, some other things that would reduce the cost significantly.
02:04:15
And one of the things that the panel
02:04:17
Hopes will occur in this interim agreement.
02:04:22
It will be the opportunity for VDOT staff and the proposer to look at these and other opportunities to reduce the cost of this project.
02:04:32
I think many of you will remember that it was proposed, I think it was in our long-range plans, that somewhere around a billion or not too long ago.
02:04:42
So cost escalations and maybe some project creep
02:04:46
Sure.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:04:48
Mr. Chairman, I just want to observe.
02:04:50
I wouldn't presume to speak for my colleagues, but I think it would be a very powerful message to the Board if indeed we could consider this the priority of that region.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:04
Additional questions or comments?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:07
Well, I just hope this would serve as a positive example of why we need money because if we're going to put any public funds into it, right now we don't have them.
02:05:18
And unless somebody appropriates additional funds or raises a gas tax or finds some other way of doing it, this wonderful idea will remain just that.
02:05:30
And, you know, unless the private sector totally is going to cover it, in which case,
02:05:34
The toll rates will be more along the lines of Dr. Davis' anticipation rather than what Mr. Dickens anticipates.
02:05:40
But it's clear it needs to be done.
02:05:43
And if we are going to do the public part of the PPTA, then we're going to have to figure out how that gets paid for because it's certainly not in the six-year plan we just adopted.
02:05:58
And if it's going to get in, we have to figure out where the money is going to come from.
02:06:03
and I'm not giving it back.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:07
Questions or comments?
SPEAKER_13
02:06:09
Mr. Layne.
02:06:10
This may be procedural, the motion to make this the project of the Hampton Roads area.
02:06:16
What is the significance of that?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:20
Did you make that in the motion?
SPEAKER_13
02:06:22
Or the comment?
02:06:25
I'm just trying to understand as I visit the different localities, I think I might have
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:31
We can't speak to the necessarily the priorities of the Hampton Roads Region as they're expressed through the Transportation Planning Organization.
02:06:51
That's their prerogative.
02:06:54
But if you
02:06:56
If we advance this project, we are making a commitment alongside our private partners to make this work.
02:07:03
And we know it will require significant public sector funding to make that work.
02:07:08
And so what that means is to the extent that additional funds can be identified, whether they're operating, whether they're capital, whether they're discretionary, whether they're formula, that they will be committed to this project.
02:07:20
And just by way of example, I'm getting a little bit ahead of some things, but
02:07:26
The Stimulus Act provided for a $1.8 billion program of discretionary grants.
02:07:35
It's nationwide, very competitive.
02:07:37
Sounds like a lot of money, but it's really not when you spread it nationwide.
02:07:41
The one grant that the governor is signing on to is for the Midtown Tunnel to try and make this project work.
02:07:50
He will be working collaboratively with some other states on some multi-state grants, but that's the one.
02:07:56
And that's what we're going to have to do to make this project work.
02:07:59
And if I might, and I've got again some other notes I want to summarize at the end here.
02:08:06
But remember, this is the tunnel that was flooded in 2003.
02:08:11
This tunnel is older than the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
02:08:17
If we are not investing in this,
02:08:20
We are going to be cutting off a very vital and fragile part of the Commonwealth, not only from the economic mainstream, but just the basic necessities of life.
02:08:30
This project is beyond critical.
02:08:32
And so we have to find a way to make this work.
02:08:36
And I'm confident that we will do that.
02:08:41
But to come back to your original question, there's a formal process at the regional level for designating priorities.
02:08:47
At the end of the day, this body has to
02:08:50
make funding priorities and by advancing this we are saying for the Hampton Roads region that CTB will select this out of all the many priorities in the region to try and make it work.
SPEAKER_13
02:09:02
That's what I thought it meant.
02:09:02
I just wanted to make sure in that position.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:09:06
Any additional questions of Mr. Dickens?
02:09:09
If I may, in the business section this afternoon there is a resolution that endorses the recommendations of the independent review panel
02:09:20
I'm going to be, I've suggested Mr. Dickens.
02:09:24
Mr. Dickens will be advancing a resolution to clarify a couple of points in there that I think are very important as we move into a transition of administration to make sure that there is clear policy guidance from this body on a couple of points.
02:09:39
The first is that we, as a matter of policy, think it's a good idea to go.
02:09:46
It is a discretionary choice to go directly to an interim agreement.
02:09:50
That there be no ambiguity about that.
02:09:54
Secondly, that with respect to the development of light rail, that we do it through the ongoing planning process that is underway in that region.
02:10:03
And they're struggling with light rail project.
02:10:06
Do they go to the east, to Virginia Beach, or do they go to the west, to Portsmouth?
02:10:11
On what location?
02:10:12
Is it BRT?
02:10:13
Is it light rail?
02:10:14
Still a host of questions yet unanswered.
02:10:17
But that that process not slow down
02:10:20
The development of this tunnel project.
02:10:24
And if we have learned one thing on these major infrastructure projects, that time truly is money.
02:10:30
On a $2 billion project, the inflation alone is a major factor.
02:10:36
The third is making clear that we will be seeking public funds, both capital and operating, to try and make this project work without specifying a source or an amount.
02:10:49
A fourth thing is, and this I think is a major policy issue, and I hope we'll have some discussion on it during the business meeting, which is to give policy level direction to staff as they develop this project to allow for early tolling.
02:11:07
And what that means is, it would not be a full toll, but there would be tolling installed on existing facilities.
02:11:15
You can use tolls to help manage congestion.
02:11:18
We've learned that on the hot lanes.
02:11:20
And anybody who's dealt in finance, just having a little bit of income stream early on can save you a lot of money in the downstream.
02:11:29
But that is a very, very significant step as a matter of policy at the state and the federal level.
02:11:36
I think it's very important that we not leave VDOT staff out there suggesting that there be clear policy direction from the CTB, that that is something to be pursued.
02:11:48
And then lastly, there was the mention of the economic development properties that the City of Portsmouth has talked about finding ways to maximize economic development opportunities on there.
02:12:00
So those will be contained on an amendment to this resolution to make sure that those things are very clear.
02:12:08
And Mr. Dickens has offered to make those amendments.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:12
That's a friendly question, Mr. Chairman.
02:12:13
If the permission is given to toll existing authorities sooner rather than later, then I assume we would want to start tolling sooner rather than later.
02:12:23
Is that correct?
02:12:25
In other words, before the project even gets under construction?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:30
I don't think that would be appropriate.
02:12:32
I think we would have to have a financial commitment from the private sector
02:12:36
I don't think that the Federal Highway Administration would grant us that authority.
02:12:41
There would have to be in motion a long-term project to both manage congestion in the short term and improve the whole tunnel complex over the long term.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:56
Is there any possibility of it starting before the project is complete?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:02
Oh, yes.
02:13:03
Absolutely.
02:13:04
That would be early tolling.
02:13:05
Perhaps as construction commences, perhaps when final design is done, there would have to be some reasonable trigger.
02:13:11
That would have to be negotiated with the MPO.
02:13:15
with Federal Highway Administration.
02:13:18
This is a major policy issue.
02:13:20
It's likely we have to come back to this body for any sort of actual implementation.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:26
And who would receive the tolls at that early stage or would that be part of the financing of the project?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:31
That would be part of the financing program, yet to be determined.
02:13:34
Probably something
02:13:36
Worth spelling out in the interim agreement just how that process would work and what would be the checks and balances for early tolling.
02:13:45
And again, remember, you've got an interstate highway, a state primary highway, and an urban street with the MLK extension.
02:13:54
This is a very, very complicated question that doesn't allow for a simple, easy blanket answer when it comes to tolling because tolling is different facilities are governed by different laws.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:07
Thank you.
02:14:10
Mr. Chairman, this may be a question that should be asked later, so tell me, but Mr. Dickens referred to the cost of putting light rail through an additional tube tunnel down there, and I think it's exciting the light rail project that's going on down there right now.
02:14:28
Does it
02:14:29
Is there greater potential or does it help get more stimulus money if there's a light rail tunnel as well so that you're in fact linking the mass transit systems?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:14:41
The short answer to that is no because it's not part of the environmental document and so if we were to go down that path and that was something that the independent review panel asked for.
02:14:53
They looked at the time and the cost impacts.
02:14:56
We would have to start the entire environmental review process all over.
02:15:00
We would have to then subsequently restart the entire procurement process.
02:15:04
And having been through the initial phase of the Norfolk Light Rail Project and Dulles Rail, it will be many years before the region identifies a plan.
02:15:15
There is a regional transit planning effort underway
02:15:21
There is in Norfolk a light rail project under construction.
02:15:26
We recently reached agreement with the city of Virginia Beach to acquire railroad rights of way to extend that to the east, but they're just beginning the environmental study of that.
02:15:37
There is no environmental work, no regional planning work done on whether and how there should be a western extension of the light rail system.
02:15:48
And when you enter into that, the question is should it be light rail, should it be bus, should it be HOV, all the typical planning questions that have to be sorted through.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:15:57
So it's not just the incremental cost, there's the whole additional cost.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:02
No, ma'am.
02:16:02
Mr. Chairman, I want to compliment Dana and thank you for the work you've done on that.
02:16:06
I raised the issue about the toll for caution for you in that if you manage the expectation on that
02:16:16
Early on, that it may not be a dollar, it's a whole lot easier to deal with it as time goes on than it is by having people believe that they're going to have a total of a dollar on a tunnel that's going to cost two billion dollars.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:16:31
Good point.
02:16:32
Thank you, and Mr. Dickens, thank you for your time, and this is just the beginning of getting out of that frying pan into a number of fires in Hampton Roads.
02:16:41
I'm sure Mr. Layne will enjoy this exercise with you as well.
02:16:46
OK, before we break for lunch, we'll go to briefing item number four, which is an update on the 95-395 Hot Lanes project.
02:16:56
This is another of the major public-private transportation act projects in the Commonwealth.
02:17:04
Presenting is Young Ho Chang.
02:17:06
Mr. Chang is the project director for this very important project.
02:17:16
has been around, I'm going to say about five years in the development, and Mr. Chang and his team have concluded a round of public comment sessions on the design aspects of this, and he's going to give us an update on the project.
02:17:31
Welcome, Mr. Chang.
SPEAKER_17
02:17:32
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
02:17:35
My name is Young Ho Chang.
02:17:36
I'm the project manager for the 95-395 hot lengths project.
02:17:42
The outline of the presentation is as follows.
02:17:46
I'll describe the project, and we will go over the summary of the location design public hearing held earlier this year, and we'll also update you on the scope review process that is ongoing currently.
02:18:02
Many of you know this already, but the project itself is 56 miles long.
02:18:08
It starts from the north end near the Pentagon at E Street,
02:18:12
and ends at Spotsylvania County near Massaponics exit.
02:18:18
The project is divided into two sections, the northern section and southern section.
02:18:25
The northern section, what we'll do is expand the current two-lane HOV facility to three lanes and it will further extend the HOV system another eight miles to Garrisonville Road which is in Stafford County.
02:18:40
It'll still serve as a reversible HOV hot system.
02:18:45
Southern section continues on to Massaponics, 28 miles in length, and then adds two new lanes.
02:18:54
And again, it'll be a reversible facility.
02:19:01
The 95-395 is an important corridor because it serves current and future military bases.
02:19:08
And it also
02:19:10
In addition to connecting to the 495 hot lanes that is under construction, it's part of an overall HOV hot network in Northern Virginia.
02:19:19
The five military bases are Pentagon, Marks Center at Seminary, that's the BRAC relocation project that is undergoing construction right now, Fort Belvoir, Engineering Proving Grounds, most of which is under construction now, and Quantico.
02:19:38
So all five bases will employ 84,000 people directly in these sites.
02:19:47
As I mentioned, the Capital Beltway hot lanes will provide a seamless connection from the 95-395 project to the hot lanes for the first time.
02:19:57
Also provide connection to Dallas Toll Road HOV and I-66 HOV.
02:20:06
Key features of the 95-395 Hot Lane projects are, first of all, we're offering new travel choices in the corridor.
02:20:14
We're also increasing transit and HOV options and capacity.
02:20:20
And we're also adding new and improved access points throughout the corridor.
02:20:27
We're also reducing bottlenecks that are there currently at E Street near Pentagon entrance.
02:20:35
as well as on the southern end at Dumfries.
02:20:40
I mentioned 56 miles of project and it's interesting to note that we will not take any right of way as part of the project and that's because almost all the work will be done inside the barriers in the current HOV system.
02:20:57
We will need, however, some minor temporary construction easements for some of the flyovers and noise walls we'll be installing.
02:21:06
This project is an actively managed facility through congestion pricing.
02:21:13
We believe it's the most efficient way to get the most out of existing infrastructure, to be able to manage the facility and the flow of traffic with pricing.
02:21:24
With private financing and partnership, we'll also be able to advance the project quicker.
02:21:32
As I mentioned, transit improvements are one of the core goals of this project.
02:21:40
Back in February 2008, Department of Rail and Public Transportation led a study, transit TDM study, in the corridor where it recommended a number of transit and transportation demand management strategies in the corridor.
02:21:56
And this was done with very close coordination in collaboration with local jurisdictions
02:22:03
as well as transit providers.
02:22:05
One of the recommendations from the study is the bus rapid transit operational analysis which we are conducting right now.
02:22:14
This will allow us to define the level of bus rapid transit in the corridor for the first time.
02:22:19
It will also identify potential BRT stations and also will provide a conceptual design so we can all see what it looks like
02:22:29
We'll also conduct some micro simulation work within the station areas to look at the traffic impact, which is very important to the localities.
02:22:37
We'll also identify additional parking right lot needs to serve the BRT operations.
02:22:46
Part of the proposal is the concessionaire for Transurban will provide $195 million to us to be used for transit
02:22:57
and transportation management improvements in the corridor.
02:23:01
Some of the recommendations from the transit TDN study are providing new bus service using the $195 million, bus rapid transit system as I mentioned, additional park and ride lots.
02:23:14
This is in addition to the 3,000 spaces that will be provided as part of the project.
02:23:20
We are recommending another 3,750 park and ride lot spaces in addition to that.
02:23:27
We'll also see improvements to Virginia Rail Express and bus stations in the corridor.
02:23:34
And we also are recommending improvements to existing transit services and enhancing new TDM services.
02:23:45
Location design public hearings were held in February throughout the corridor.
02:23:50
Approximately 300 people attended.
02:23:53
171 people provided 571 separate comments.
02:23:59
Of the 571 comments, about 16.5% voiced their opinion in either support or opposition to the project.
02:24:10
Another 15%, slightly over 15%, commented about noise walls, mostly that they would like to see noise walls in their neighborhood.
02:24:20
About 10% talked about slugging.
02:24:23
and potential detrimental impact on sluggers.
02:24:29
And then you can see the further breakdown in the slide.
02:24:35
We've had and we will continue to have tremendous outreach effort as part of the project.
02:24:42
This is just an illustration of number of meetings we've had, for example, with elected and jurisdictional officials and staff, over 60 so far.
02:24:52
and with homeowners associations about 25 separate meetings and some of the homeowners we met more than once and some we met more than twice.
02:25:01
So we're keeping them aware of the update to the project and as they ask questions and so forth we're going out there to visit the community and explain exactly where we are with the project.
02:25:16
Right now we are conducting scope review of the northern section.
02:25:21
And this is necessary due to more refined construction costs, as you normally see in a project development, more refined revenue forecast, and the current financial market, especially in the private lending side of the financial market.
02:25:39
And I don't really need to go into details about what the market condition is like to try to get private financing.
02:25:45
And also public comments at the public hearing as well as follow-up comments afterwards.
02:25:50
One of which is Churnington Rotary.
02:25:53
We have improvements planned at Churnington, which is right between Arlington and Alexandria, or in Arlington and Alexandria, and the both localities have expressed concerns about the design and the impact from the Churnington Rotary.
02:26:12
So we want to take some time to examine that and see if we can address their concerns.
02:26:17
There's also concerns about Marks Center.
02:26:20
that, as I mentioned, is under construction right now on Seminary Road, which is in Alexandria.
02:26:27
We are looking at possibility of providing direct access to the MARC Center as opposed to what was planned, a bus-only ramp that's planned on Seminary.
02:26:39
We're also reviewing potential phasing options to meet the core project needs as well as future needs in the corridor.
02:26:49
However, we are
02:26:50
We're going to preserve the concession fee for transit as well as the 3,000 new spaces in the corridor as a central core component of the project.
02:27:03
This illustrates or gives you a little bit better idea of where these scope reviews are.
02:27:13
The charlatan rotary, you can sort of associate that, if you will, with the yellow dots on the map.
02:27:20
So, Charlington Rotary, starting from the north is there.
02:27:24
Seminary Bus Only ramp, where BRAC relocation is happening.
02:27:30
And further down at Lorton, we have both Lorton northbound flyover and a bus rapid transit inline station that's proposed.
02:27:38
So, we're looking at that in the possible potential phasing.
02:27:46
Further south, Cardinal Drive flyover,
02:27:49
and south terminus of the project, which is Garrisonville, a fly over there.
02:27:56
We're also looking at additional lane capacity south of Prince William Parkway, right here, to make sure that we can preserve the level of service in the corridor with the introduction of hot lanes and still be able to face the project properly.
02:28:15
So that concludes my presentation.
02:28:17
I'd be happy to entertain any questions you may have.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:28:22
Questions or comments, Mr. Chang?
02:28:25
Yes, sir.
02:28:27
Mr. McCarthy.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:28:30
This is a public-private partnership.
02:28:32
So how much is it the latest estimate of its cost and how much is the public part of that cost?
SPEAKER_17
02:28:39
I'll answer your second question first.
02:28:41
We don't anticipate any public funding for the project still.
02:28:45
That's one of the reasons why we are exploring the scope issues currently.
02:28:51
As far as the estimate is concerned, at this point we have the public sector's number and private sector's number and I imagine in the next few weeks we'll come closer to a number that I can provide to you.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:07
Oh, that's still being, depending on the scope of these changes and so on and so forth.
02:29:14
Right.
02:29:14
Yeah.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:29:16
I'm not even sure how to ask this one, Mr. Chairman, but we talked a lot about the Hampton Roads Project and being sensitive to the toll levels for those people.
02:29:29
What sensitivity analysis are we doing with respect to the toll levels for making this project work in the real world?
SPEAKER_17
02:29:37
Sure.
02:29:39
I think one of the issues associated with congestion pricing is the tolling will change based on level of traffic.
02:29:49
And that's why we're handing this thing out as an actively managed corridor.
02:29:56
So there is sophisticated modeling being done both by our private partners as well as our independent analysis.
02:30:07
So I don't know if that actually answers your question or not.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:11
Well, I guess I'm thinking if I lived somewhere at the southern terminus of this and had to go to the Pentagon every day, how much out of my pocket would you anticipate I would spend?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:30:20
Well, if I might.
02:30:23
This is one where people have a choice, and it's fundamentally different from the midtown, downtown, South Elizabeth Bridge, river crossings.
02:30:35
You have a choice in this corridor.
02:30:37
If I'm a solo driver, today, I can only, in the morning, if I'm heading north, say from Aquia Harbor to go to the Pentagon, I can only go in the general purpose lanes for free.
02:30:51
When this project is completed,
02:30:53
I will have a choice.
02:30:54
I can either go in the general purpose lanes for free or I can pay a toll.
02:31:00
And that toll will rise or fall based on the level of congestion.
02:31:04
On a very busy Friday evening in the summertime, that toll will be very stiff to ration the capacity and to maintain the travel speed.
02:31:15
But I also have an option if I am willing to pick up two other people, I ride for free.
02:31:21
And that is why you see the roughly 6,700 additional commuter parking spaces is to encourage that throughput on HOV that is very essential to the system.
02:31:37
So again, this is actually creating an additional set of commuter choices that don't exist in the situation in the midtown tunnel.
02:31:47
Everybody will be forced to pay a toll in the midtown, downtown tunnels.
02:31:51
Here you have a choice.
02:31:52
I can go in the told lanes or I can go in the free lanes.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:31:59
Also, I heard him say there's no public money involved in this particular change.
02:32:04
That's the proposal.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:32:08
Mr. Koelemay.
02:32:09
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Chang, thanks for bringing us up to date.
02:32:12
There have been a lot of questions about how this project fits and how it will proceed.
02:32:18
Clearly in the public comments, as you suggested, they are
02:32:21
There is an understanding of the importance of access, new links, amenities, sound walls, additional transit, so forth.
02:32:31
And yet there is clearly some opposition to specific designs that you hinted at in specific places.
02:32:40
Is this fundamentally a design set of problems or is it just that we are dealing with
02:32:46
A fairly narrow corridor that really doesn't allow you to have as full a range of options as you might have on other places.
SPEAKER_17
02:32:54
Sure, I think it's really both.
02:32:57
Charnington especially, it's a very built in, built up area.
02:33:01
You have a very different land uses on either side of 95.
02:33:06
So for example, Arlington on the west side is very commercial, retail.
02:33:10
As a matter of fact, they want people to come there.
02:33:13
The other side, mostly Alexandria is
02:33:16
Very residential and it will stay that way and as a matter of fact it's a historic district.
02:33:21
So the goals of Arlington and Alexandria may differ in terms of providing the access and the capacity that we have shown on the project.
02:33:32
So we have this fundamental conflict that we just want to give ourselves more time to work with the two jurisdictions, take this interchange design offline and really go through to see if we can address their concerns.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:33:45
Mr. Chairman, also it appears that most of the comments on what you've dealt with are really focused on specific challenges that you need to have, but also driving this as some of the changes in the overall value proposition for the private sector partners.
02:34:01
Are there certain indicators that they're looking at there that signal do more, do less?
02:34:10
In terms of scope of the project?
02:34:12
If market conditions improve, we could probably do this, but if they don't, we could probably do that.
02:34:18
Is that part of it?
SPEAKER_17
02:34:19
Sure.
02:34:20
That is definitely part of our scope review.
02:34:24
We know the financial market is extremely tough.
02:34:28
There's no need to fight that and still try to continue with a project that is not financeable.
02:34:33
So we are looking at the core elements of the project to make sure that we can keep that intact.
02:34:39
as we slowly phase the other elements.
02:34:42
And certainly a revenue forecast that's different, that's better than what we're experiencing now will allow us to take on the other scope elements later.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:34:54
It's an odd situation, Mr. Chairman.
02:34:58
We end up rooting for more vehicle miles traveled in this case, not less.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:04
Mr. Chairman, thank you.
02:35:06
I appreciate your presentation.
02:35:08
I appreciate the fact that you've been working with Alexandria and Arlington.
02:35:12
I know that through the Northern Virginia Transportation Authority, which I was on, a number of localities have indicated various types of concerns or questions and has had a PRTC.
02:35:25
With respect to the scoping review,
02:35:28
Is that going to be done before you move towards a draft agreement or a final agreement with the private company or are those proceeding in tandem?
SPEAKER_17
02:35:40
I want to make it very clear right now the agreement that we have with the private sector is through the interim agreement.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:35:46
That's what I had understood, yes.
SPEAKER_17
02:35:48
That's correct.
02:35:49
And we need to define the scope obviously for our benefit but also private sector.
02:35:54
They need to know exactly what they're financing.
02:35:57
So we need to work all those things out prior to any kind of commitment on either side.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:02
On the comprehensive agreement.
02:36:04
Sure.
02:36:04
Correct me if I'm wrong in this term.
02:36:07
The comprehensive agreement, the goal had sort of been maybe addressed when in August.
02:36:13
Is that timeframe shifting or do I have it incorrectly?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:18
The goal is to have the major business points and that would include the scope by August.
02:36:25
So would every T.B.
02:36:27
Cross and every I dotted?
02:36:30
No, but we would know if we can make this project work or not.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:34
So these scope reviews would be done in advance of coming up with those final points?
02:36:39
Yes.
02:36:41
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:36:43
Additional questions or comments.
02:36:45
Ms. Chang, if you could go back to the slide that shows the military bases.
02:36:51
I think, you know, as we are dealing in Hampton Roads with trying to keep a carrier in Hampton Roads and we understand the multiplier effect of that,
02:37:04
It is so important for this Commonwealth to be supportive of existing and encouraging of growth that is going to occur at our military installations.
02:37:17
And when you stand back and look at this slide, one could characterize the 95 corridors, the National Defense Corridor, when you look at those bases that are there.
02:37:29
Fort Belvoir is bigger than the Pentagon.
02:37:32
The Marks Center, we've only listed the Department of Defense direct jobs, but the number of contractors that are there and that are planned will make that almost as big as the Pentagon.
02:37:44
Think about what the Pentagon has.
02:37:45
It has a metro stop.
02:37:47
It has shuttle service to VRE.
02:37:49
It's got direct HOV access.
02:37:50
It is surrounded by interstate and free-flowing primary highways.
02:37:56
The Engineer Proving Grounds now is home to the most high-tech agency probably in the world, the National Geospatial Agency and Quantico Marine Corps Base, and these are just the direct Department of Defense jobs, almost 85,000 jobs in this corridor.
02:38:17
One of the things that has made HOV work in this quarter, one of the few places in the whole country has been working with the Department of Defense and their personnel policies and their parking policies.
02:38:29
And we've had a very close dialogue with them to improve the quality of life for their workforce.
02:38:36
So some of the things that we're looking for, if we can get as part of this scope review, and there are studies underway, a direct access into the engineer proving grounds,
02:38:46
would allow someone, Mr. McCarthy, we talked about bus service, that $200 million, $195 million for transit will subsidize bus service in that quarter.
02:38:55
You could get on a bus at Aquia Harbor or somewhere close by a commuter parking lot and go directly into your job at the engineer proving grounds from the hot lanes.
02:39:08
The same with the Pentagon or Mark Center where we're also looking at a direct access.
02:39:13
These are major job centers that have spinoff potential for private contractors, probably three and four times the number of direct DOD jobs.
02:39:25
And this is so important as we try to think about Virginia and this whole urban crescent and the Department of Defense presence, whether it's the carrier in Hampton Roads or growing the engineer proving grounds in a prudent way.
02:39:40
Or I would say at the Mark Center,
02:39:42
Solving a very, very challenging problem.
02:39:45
The BRAC process gave us something that simply does not work with existing infrastructure.
02:39:50
And one of our few opportunities for solving that problem is a direct access ramp into the MARC center.
02:39:56
And so as you look, and we've talked about the Beltway hot lanes and the network and the Dulles Rail project.
02:40:04
This is part of a pretty carefully thought out network that will allow this
02:40:10
Inside Quiet Network that allows for free-flowing transit and HOV throughout the region and is so important.
02:40:19
So thank you, Mr. Chang, for this presentation.
02:40:23
I think the folks in particular in Arlington and Alexandria that I've spoken to, there's a sense of relief that the local issues are being addressed.
02:40:34
And I think to Ms. Pandak's questions, that really has been
02:40:39
The nature of a lot of unrest is what's this going to do to my neighborhood and particularly in that Sherlington area.
02:40:47
And I think what the review has indicated to date, without being conclusive about that, but this project will function just fine without those improvements that were previously proposed.
02:41:02
There's probably a better, smarter solution
02:41:05
But we need to do that in concert with the surrounding communities.
02:41:08
And again, Arlington has commercial on one side, Alexandria has presidential on the other side.
02:41:12
That's a little bit of a challenge.
02:41:17
Thank you.
02:41:23
It's 11.50.
02:41:24
Dr. Allen, you want to try and squeeze in the Ashtow Awards recognition before we break for lunch?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:41:34
As Dr. Allen approaches the podium, I want to take a minute to do a little acknowledgement here because I think this is
02:41:42
One of those bright spots within the Commonwealth that cannot go unacknowledged.
02:41:48
In my three years as Commissioner in this department, I can tell you that my association with the Research Council has been one of the truly, truly bright spots of encouragement.
02:42:05
I can tell you that
02:42:08
Every situation in which I have been faced with the need to have creative, in-depth, methodological thinking carried out.
02:42:23
I knew I could go to one place and get that resource, and that is headed by Dr. Allen as the Virginia Transportation Research Council.
02:42:35
I want to publicly acknowledge
02:42:37
That I am not the first commissioner to have appreciated the depth and the dedication of what that workforce and what that institution represents to the Commonwealth.
02:42:50
Universally, as I talk to those who have had the privilege of having my chair, they come to the same conclusion and the same analysis that I've just given you.
02:43:03
Gary works tirelessly with his staff
02:43:08
It's not unusual to have 20-hour days from him.
02:43:15
Gary, I want to acknowledge you as you acknowledge others here this morning.
SPEAKER_20
02:43:21
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman and Commissioner, for those very kind words.
SPEAKER_22
02:43:27
I certainly appreciate them.
SPEAKER_20
02:43:30
You know, in life, most of the time opportunities are disguised as work.
02:43:38
I have been very fortunate in my life and in my career at VDOT to have a chance to have lots of good opportunities.
02:43:48
In 2003, there was a little tiny glimmer of creating something called a knowledge management program at VDOT.
02:43:58
And I stole some staff that I had in another part of the businesses I run and I put together this little tiny unit
02:44:07
And in five short years, in five short years, that unit has been recognized nationally on a number of occasions.
02:44:19
They were one of ten finalists, ten finalists in the Kennedy School of Government's Innovation in Government's Award Program where there were over, over a thousand applicants.
02:44:33
That's pretty significant.
02:44:35
Today I come to you to just talk very briefly about an award from AASHTO.
02:44:42
The AASHTO Standing Committee on Performance Management has awarded VDOT's Knowledge Management Office and the VDOT Construction Quality Managers Community of Practice one of four national trailblazer awards for the Construction Lessons Learned Program.
02:45:00
In a nutshell,
02:45:02
This was a little pilot project that started in 2007 where the Knowledge Management Office began to work with the District Construction Engineers and all of the construction managers across the Commonwealth to look at the projects that we were doing and take from those projects things that were being learned through either innovation or maybe little mistakes.
02:45:31
Learn those lessons, share them through electronic means and through a website that folks can access, give feedback, and as a result of that, as a result of that, the quality of the construction program has improved and we have in place a very active community of practice of every construction manager in the Commonwealth.
02:45:56
Every week, every week, there are lessons learned
02:46:00
that come out that the commissioner, chief engineer, all the folks in VDOT can see and use.
02:46:07
Almost 100% of the construction field staff use those construction lessons learned.
02:46:13
It's a very, very positive way of improving the construction process in terms of improving quality, learning and sharing knowledge, and revising specifications.
02:46:28
Very quickly, I'm going to name the group that is the lead in this community of practice.
02:46:34
Betty Bailey from Hampton Roads District, Tom Chrisman from Stanton, Eric Groh from the Stanton District, Don Farrow from Nova, Mary Gardner, Gary Tanner, Billy Wright from Lynchburg, Wade Smith from Culpeper, Mark Betterton from Salem,
02:46:58
Matthew Taylor from the Bristol District, Arnold Lloyd, who is the Construction Quality Improvement Engineering Manager, and Marshall Robb, who is also a Construction Quality Improvement Program Engineer, Catherine Clark from the Knowledge Management Program, and Rudy Renfro.
02:47:19
Today we have with us a few of the representatives of that group.
02:47:24
I'm going to ask that they stand as I call their names.
02:47:27
Betty Bailey from Hampton Roads, Tom Chrisman from Stanton, Don Farrow from Nova, who's also a co-chair along with Tom Chrisman of this group, Lloyd Arnold, Rob Marshall, who's a regional CCWIP engineer, Catherine Clark from the Knowledge Management Office, and I don't know if Byron Coburn is here or not.
02:47:51
Yes, Byron is here.
02:47:54
Mr. Chairman, with your indulgence, I'd ask the group to give
02:47:57
These folks, a round of applause.
02:48:07
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:48:10
Thank you, Dr. Allen.
02:48:11
I want to echo what the Commissioner said about you and your team and all the employees here.
02:48:18
Our lot in life is largely a thankless one, and I thank the CTB members
02:48:23
I would agree with that.
02:48:25
When you do a great job, nobody notices.
02:48:28
When something happens, everybody notices.
02:48:31
And you all have just put your shoulders to the wheel and done your job as professionals in a very difficult environment.
02:48:40
We really do thank you for the work you do every day, unrecognized though it may be.
02:48:45
And so we really appreciate the opportunity to learn about the good work that oftentimes we don't see.
02:48:51
OK. With that, we're going to suspend for about an hour for lunch.
02:48:59
There's a food for the board members immediately outside the door and to the right.
02:49:05
And we will reconvene at 1 o'clock.
02:49:23
Thank you.
02:49:24
I'd like to call back into session the July work session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
02:49:31
We will continue with our agenda.
02:49:34
Presentation item number six is the Economic Development Access Policy Overview.
02:49:38
Welcome, Mr. Estes.
02:49:40
I would say I know a couple of board members have to leave and
02:49:44
If we don't complete the work session by two o'clock, we will at that time certainly go into the business session and we will take up any remaining work session items at the conclusion of the business session just so that we can get everything done.
SPEAKER_13
02:50:04
Thank you, Mr. Estes.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:50:07
And for our new board members, my name is Mike Estes.
02:50:10
I handle your local assistance division and
02:50:14
really functioned kind of as lead liaison division for local government special programs dealing with local government.
02:50:20
Today I want to revisit a topic that we discussed briefly last month on the economic development access policy that the board has and really what I want to share today is kind of a little bit more in depth of why I came to the board last month based on some of the questions that were raised and then with the hopeful intent that it would be part of the action item agenda later today.
02:50:42
You can see I'm going to try to go through this, Mr. Chairman, fairly quickly based on the time that we have.
02:50:48
We can stop for questions as we go.
02:50:49
But here's what I'm going to plan to cover today.
02:50:51
And I would want to spend just a few minutes on kind of a brief overview again of the program, how it is to establish the code.
02:50:58
We're going to talk about that importance of that in just a minute, the allocation amount of five and a half million.
02:51:03
That includes not only economic development access roads, but airport access roads and the rail access program that this board is familiar with.
02:51:11
Current policy.
02:51:12
States that the maximum allocation to a locality for these projects is $300,000 unmatched and $150,000 matched, which is what we spent some time on last month, as well as that documentation of capital investment.
02:51:25
The current requirement is 10 to 1, again, in the CTB policy.
02:51:29
As maybe you'll recall, the Board did change the policy back in 2006 based on some work we did, based on some work that came out of the General Assembly, as well as the study group on this program.
02:51:39
But the two items on the allocation amounts and the capital investment have not changed since 1980.
02:51:47
Another important fact that I'm going to revisit just again in just a minute is that really the localities have two avenues to take on this program.
02:51:55
They can have traditional projects which they have a named known entity coming into the locality or bonded where they're trying to take a speculative approach.
02:52:04
Those that are known with the eligible have a known business.
02:52:06
You know, those have the documented capital outlay up front.
02:52:10
Whereas the speculative projects require documentation over a five-year period and what the board put into policy last time was we actually gave them an additional two years that they could come back and get an additional 50% taken off of what they've had to repay.
02:52:26
And we'll talk a little bit more about the repayment again in just a second.
02:52:29
So I'm going to try to skip to really the meat of what we were kind of debating last month a little bit and really the bottom line.
02:52:40
As I believe Mr. Koelemay brought to the attention and kind of highlighted a little better than I did last month the fact that, you know, this money is appropriated kind of a mandate, I guess you'd say, from the General Assembly that it will be spent for this purpose, this purpose alone.
02:52:52
So there was some discussion of can we use it elsewhere.
02:52:54
Basically, without a change in law, this money is for the economic development projects.
02:53:01
We basically have some adequate funding to do more.
02:53:04
We're not getting the ultimate request that we'd like to see.
02:53:07
Mr. McCarthy had questions about rail.
02:53:09
We are fully taking care of any requests that are coming from the rail side of the house.
02:53:13
We don't foresee any problems continuing to meet that with our proposed changes.
02:53:17
And we've had a downturn which received just a second graphically in participation and reimbursement on the road section.
02:53:26
And we've also had a significant amount of payback in return of funds to the program.
02:53:30
So that's really what we're trying to get at today is the fact that we have allocations available
02:53:35
and we'd like to adjust the program to encourage more of its use.
02:53:40
This is a reminder of the allocation history chart over the last 10 years and you can see in the, we'll call it burgundy, the downward trend overall over the last 10 years for the road access.
02:53:50
The blue represents the rail access portion of the program.
02:53:55
As you can see, the last four years have been under the 10-year average, which is again partly why we're here today.
02:54:02
And then one of the key points that I didn't bring to the board last month I think is very crucial is the fact if you look at the mix we talked about the two options localities have whether it's a traditional named industry coming in or a speculative or bonded.
02:54:16
The bonded you can see is in blue and that represents out of the allocations over the last 10 years about 70% of the allocations have gone towards speculative or bonded program projects.
02:54:28
That's an important key aspect as well.
02:54:32
So when it's bonded, it is a risk to the locality.
02:54:35
And if they don't bring in that capital investment requirement that we talked about, that 10 to one, they didn't have to return funds to the department.
02:54:42
And that has been encouraged, or encouraged us having a little bit more of a balance in this fund.
02:54:48
You can see over the last few years the amount of money that's been returned based on those bonded projects.
02:54:54
This graph represents approximately $10 million over the last 10 years that have been returned based on those bonded projects.
02:55:02
In addition to this, the board sees on occasion where a locality, before they've expended any dollars at all, has asked for projects to be canceled based on changed plans within the locality.
02:55:11
That represents another about $9 million over the last 10 years for rail and road access projects that have been deallocated by the board.
02:55:20
So based on that, again, we're getting back to the bottom line is we have at least two years full allocation, that's five and a half million available in this fund that we'd like to encourage, again, more participation on.
02:55:32
Mr. Sterling last month brought up the jobs issue a little bit, and I wanted to just very briefly hit on that.
02:55:38
Again, I had mentioned last month the extensive research we had done on other programs, and the fact that most of those other programs, again, are going to have known entities coming in at the beginning of their project phase, whether it's the Governor's Opportunity Fund or the Rail Access, they're going to have known quantities coming in that can document capital outlay
02:55:58
as well as job creation, and they both have a mix of that for those programs.
02:56:03
So based on that and really the large amount of bonded program that we have, we still do feel like capital outlay is the way to go with this program.
02:56:11
They have five, plus again I mentioned the additional two years, 50%, seven-year timeframe to work through that, and we'd like to suggest that we stick with that approach for this program.
02:56:22
So back to the bottom line of what I presented last month was to
02:56:26
Increase that maximum allocation to local governments.
02:56:30
Again, right now it's $300,000 unmatched with $150,000 matched.
02:56:35
We'd like to increase that or propose that the board increase that under their policy to $500,000 unmatched and $150,000 matched.
02:56:43
And what that does is we've looked at about 20 projects since 2006.
02:56:46
That's at the bottom of this slide.
02:56:49
You can see the percentage of the projects that are over $300,000.
02:56:52
or even 500,000 and that's just a representation of the cost of doing business these days.
02:57:00
The other proposal that we presented last month was to decrease that capital outlay requirement from a 10 to 1 requirement to a 5 to 1 requirement and again that's to introduce additional flexibility and I'll show you one example here in a second but we looked at 45 of those bonded projects we just discussed and 12 of those who produce partial capital outlay credit
02:57:23
would have benefited from this change.
02:57:28
We just pulled two projects, for example, one in Halifax County, one in Mecklenburg County.
02:57:33
I won't go through the math or the details, but if you just look at the third column over, funds returned, those are funds actually returned based on their not being able to meet the full capital outlay investment requirement by those counties to the CTB.
02:57:48
Whereas under the proposal we're presenting to the board again today, you can see that they wouldn't be fully relieved of that requirement, but there would be substantially less impact to those localities.
02:58:01
So again, here's a repeat of what we're proposing today, and I would turn it back to you, Mr. Chairman, and ask for any questions.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:08
Any questions of Mr. Estes?
02:58:10
And this would be for an action item in September?
02:58:14
Today, actually.
02:58:15
It is for today.
02:58:16
Okay, so this is the revised from the previous presentation.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:18
What's adopted, Mr. Chairman?
02:58:20
What's adopted if it were to be adopted today, and when would it take effect?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
02:58:25
Mr. Chairman, Mr. King, we would immediately, I think it's a pretty easy change for our guidance document, and we would get the word out through our local contacts, through VACO and VML, and we could take into effect immediately.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:58:38
And I think it's fair to say what we're trying to do is keep this program meshed up with the Governor's Opportunity Fund so we don't have slightly different eligibility criteria.
02:58:51
One other thing I think is relevant, the Transportation Partnership Opportunity Fund has taken some of this demand off of this program because the improvements vastly exceed
02:59:03
most of these industrial access grants.
02:59:05
So the Canon facility in Newport News was $10 million of TPOF grants.
02:59:11
And that's one of the reasons, again, the rising cost of the highway and the rail improvement.
02:59:17
Any other questions or comments?
02:59:20
Ms. Pandak.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:20
Mr. Chairman, I think it's a good idea to make this process a little bit more flexible and to tie it together.
02:59:27
I think that's really a positive step.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:59:30
Thank you.
02:59:32
And for Ms. Pandak and Mr. Layne, what we try to do with these major items is to have a briefing one month and an action item.
02:59:39
The subsequent, we're not always able to do that in every instance.
02:59:42
In fact, most weeks there's something that comes up that was just not anticipated.
02:59:46
There was a previous briefing on this, some questions and comments, and a little bit of tweaking.
02:59:51
Just come back with the presentation today and action item also today.
02:59:56
All right.
02:59:57
Thank you, Mr. Estes.
02:59:59
And I know you'll be wanting to spend a little bit of time with the two new board members to familiarize them with programs in your shop.
03:00:11
Thank you.
03:00:12
The next item is an update on the
03:00:16
High-Speed Rail pre-application that Mr.
03:00:20
Page and Mr. Badger submitted on behalf of Governor Kean just last week.
03:00:25
Mr. Badger, do you have any introductory comments?
SPEAKER_13
03:00:29
I don't want to steal Kevin's thunder, but we just got an email.
03:00:32
The tally is in.
03:00:33
All the pre-applications were due in on Friday.
SPEAKER_05
03:00:35
Forty states submitted applications for a total of $102 billion worth of projects.
SPEAKER_13
03:00:44
So we have some competition.
03:00:45
There were 278 projects proposed.
03:00:48
We have three, and Kevin will talk about that.
03:00:51
Okay.
03:00:51
Welcome, Mr.
03:00:52
Page.
03:00:52
Sure.
SPEAKER_19
03:00:52
That was quite a lead-in to see what the competition is.
03:00:55
Just as a lead-on to that as well is we're considered to be in the south-southeastern quadrant of those applications.
03:01:01
Of that quadrant, 44 applications were received at a total of $16 billion just in the southeast alone.
03:01:08
The competition is going to be quite stiff, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, but we at DRPT and Commonwealth of Virginia feel that we are very well positioned due to our
03:01:16
Strategic Alignment in the Washington-Richmond corridor area to Petersburg especially since we are linking absolutely the northeast corridor and the southeast corridor here in Virginia.
03:01:28
Of the applications submitted as Director Badger mentioned just a few seconds ago, we submitted a round one track two application for our largest corridor development portion of the three applications and that was for $1.57 billion.
03:01:43
for the development of up to 90 mile an hour service from Richmond to Washington and then inner city improvements for enhancements from Petersburg to Main Street Station in Richmond.
03:01:54
That gives us the opportunity as well to work towards leveling the playing field at Petersburg for potential future service to Norfolk.
03:02:05
As we move forward on the round on the track too, I'll talk about in just a minute, Mr. Secretary.
03:02:10
As well, we also submitted a round one track one project, which was just to reeducate the board on the presentation we had last month.
03:02:18
Track one were the shovel-in-the-ground, ready-to-go projects that had NEPA and all the environmental and preliminary engineering pretty much pretty far along.
03:02:25
As this board may recall, under the Rail Enhancement Fund, we have been participating with Virginia Railway Express in developing the Arcandilla Palace Creek project.
03:02:34
We're at a level with that project that we can move it forward on the fast track and have it built within 24 months of approval of funds.
03:02:40
and awarded those funds by the FRA if they're awarded.
03:02:44
So under round one, track one, we have a $72 million project.
03:02:47
Just as a security blanket, I want to be clear to the board, we also included this project in our round one, track two program.
03:02:52
In case FRA kicked it as a track one project, we were still covered and included those costs in track two just for security purposes.
03:03:00
The round two, track two project that we also submitted, remember under the pre-applications
03:03:05
FRA requested that all of the states and other applying parties submit everything they think they're going to be coming in for under the ARRA program.
03:03:13
So we felt it very prudent and appropriate to also include under round two, track two,
03:03:18
Richmond to Hampton Roads, which was a spread because we haven't made that quarter designation yet as we move forward with that process.
03:03:25
We included the lowest minimum project cost and the highest minimum, maximum project cost we felt would be applied to the maximums, minimums of the five alternatives that have been identified in this corridor.
03:03:36
Having said that, Mr. Chairman, this does not conclude our work.
03:03:39
This is just the end of the beginning.
03:03:41
The hard part is between now and August the 24th,
03:03:44
We need to put together a program management plan, financial management plan, service development plan, and also work with FRA closely as well as our stakeholders CSX and VRE as to how we will move forward and develop these projects in the corridor.
03:03:58
So Mr. Chairman, I'll turn the floor back over to you and Director Badger for any questions or comments that you all may have.
03:04:03
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:05
Questions of Mr.
03:04:05
Page?
03:04:07
I think this is a very significant step.
03:04:11
I think it's important also for folks to understand
03:04:14
that this first priority, which is Petersburg to DC, is CSX rail traffic where we have to balance the needs of freight and existing Amtrak and VRE and now high-speed rail.
03:04:28
That's a difficult balancing act on the one hand.
03:04:31
On the other hand, all of these improvements are within the existing rights-of-way.
03:04:35
And that, I think, is our
03:04:38
Thank you.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:04:42
This has been some discussion about the southern terminus of the northeast in Washington, moving that to Richmond.
03:04:59
How does that impact and does that give us any
03:05:01
leverage here.
SPEAKER_05
03:05:03
If I can answer that, I think that certainly strengthens our application.
SPEAKER_22
03:05:06
Amtrak CEO, Joe Boardman, has said repeatedly, in fact his predecessor also stated that one of their top priorities in expanding the Northeast Corridor is bringing it from Washington down to Richmond.
03:05:18
So very clearly, Richmond has an important role to play in the Northeast Corridor.
SPEAKER_13
03:05:23
It takes pressure off of Union Station, which is a real bottleneck for them.
03:05:27
So I think it just makes our application even stronger.
SPEAKER_19
03:05:32
Mr. Chairman, if I may as a following as well.
03:05:34
The Department of Rail and Public Transportation has been working with Amtrak on the Northeast Quarter Master Plan for the past two years now.
03:05:40
And included as part of that are all of the projects that you see as we've mentioned in our pre-application to Richmond is also included as the next set of projects and the most logical step in the Northeast Quarter to extend it to Richmond.
03:05:53
So we are now going to be included in the Northeast quarter master plan with the same projects that we also have in the Southeast high-speed quarter development plan.
03:06:00
So we're in two places at the same time, which is a very good place to be.
03:06:06
Yes, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:06:07
Okay.
03:06:07
Ms.
03:06:08
Page, thank you very much.
03:06:09
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
03:06:09
Mr. Badger, this is amazing work, and I think, you know, the point you just made, you've been working with the federal agencies for three years on these plans.
03:06:18
So in some respects, again, that's an advantage.
03:06:21
We're within the right of way.
03:06:23
We have a strong working relationship with both the Federal Railroad Administration and Amtrak, so those are real pluses.
03:06:29
Thank you again.
03:06:30
Okay, the next item, presentation number eight, Ralph Davis, Deputy Secretary, will be providing an overview and an answer that repeatedly I think all of us are asked, why can't we do things the way the Europeans do?
03:06:47
So that's the point of today's presentation.
03:06:50
Welcome.
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
03:06:50
Thank you very much, Mr.
03:06:51
Chair.
03:06:52
And to the two new board members, the CTB is required in law to develop a long-range transportation plan for the Commonwealth of Virginia.
03:07:04
The last time a plan was done was in 2004, and we're required to update that plan every five years.
03:07:12
The last plan was called VTrans 2025.
03:07:15
This plan is called BTrans 2035 and for the last year or so we've been undergoing some major efforts for this next long-range transportation plan.
03:07:28
Part of this process is to develop a series of policy papers on transportation in Virginia and we've done those and one of those papers is going to be presented to you today and that's on European lessons.
03:07:43
Also part of the plan is essentially to have extensive public outreach.
03:07:49
And we've done that over the last year or so through a series of stakeholder meetings, meetings with the public.
03:07:57
And most recently of the last couple of months we've had general public meetings.
03:08:01
We've had four of those meetings.
03:08:04
We had one in Northern Virginia, one in Richmond, one in Hampton Roads, and one in Roanoke.
03:08:09
Typically in these meetings you get 20 to 30 or so people.
03:08:15
You think public meetings and you may expect that there are hundreds of people but it's a very small attendance and that's part of the learning process when you go out to the public regardless of how you advertise it.
03:08:28
You get small attendance and those who do attend basically have an agenda specific issue in mind that they want to deal with.
03:08:38
Part of the process, we also had something called a virtual public meeting.
03:08:42
That is, if you couldn't attend the public meeting, you could go to the website and you could respond to essentially what the public saw via the web.
03:08:51
And we basically have 91 or so people who actually went to the website to respond in terms of VTrans 2035.
03:08:59
I attended all the public meetings and the charge was, really, tell us what do you think about transportation 2035?
03:09:06
What should it look like?
03:09:08
One of the things, a lesson I learned is for the public, the future is now.
03:09:14
Generally, the public is interested in the potholes and the sensibility and those kinds of things and very seldom do you see these far outreaching things on what transportation should look like in 20 or 30 years.
03:09:28
I would like to thank the CTB members who did attend those meetings.
03:09:32
I think it
03:09:33
Some cases you have bailed me out of tough questions, and I appreciate that.
03:09:38
And it also may have been a learning experience for you to get direct contact to your constituents out there, so I appreciate that.
03:09:46
I also want to thank the various agencies.
03:09:50
One of the things about my responsibility, and by the way, for those who don't know, we have something called the Office of Intermodal Planning and Investment.
03:09:57
And this office was put in place basically to help the CTB with this long-range plan.
03:10:02
The other thing, it is multi-modal.
03:10:04
It's not just about highways.
03:10:07
So when we go to these meetings, we have highway representatives there, we have rail representatives, we have port, and we have the airport.
03:10:15
And we have a series of maps and so forth for all these agencies and for the public to respond to how these things should mix together in terms of one plan.
03:10:24
So it's beyond just roads.
03:10:25
It's about all the modal agencies.
03:10:29
In these meetings, as I said, the lesson I learned is it's typically the public is interested in their issues as of now, rather than longer-term view.
03:10:40
Another task of E-Trans was to look at a series of policy papers, and we've done six.
03:10:46
In six, these papers are currently online.
03:10:49
There's a paper done on demographic trends, one done on the viability of the fuel tax.
03:10:54
Will the fuel tax be viable over the next 20 years?
03:10:57
A paper was done on congestion, mobility accessibility, natural and human environment.
03:11:03
One of the big issues there is climate change and what impact does it have on transportation.
03:11:06
So we've done a paper there.
03:11:08
And the paper you're going to hear about today is on European lessons.
03:11:13
I've gone through this process before, and what we always hear is why can't we do what the Europeans do, particularly in terms of their passing a rail.
03:11:23
So that's one of the things we wanted to look at.
03:11:25
is to do some analysis and come back to you and I think some of what you will find is there are both pluses and minuses and we did provide that to you in advance.
03:11:34
We have eight more issues that we need to cover and we have a very short time in doing that.
03:11:40
I would like to talk to you some more about the public outreach.
03:11:45
One of your requirements in law is to identify corridors of statewide significance in the Commonwealth.
03:11:50
We have a paper on regional and local decision making.
03:11:53
How does, what's the balance and balance there?
03:11:56
Land use and transportation has been a very key issue for this governor.
03:12:00
We need to bring that back.
03:12:02
Economic development, we have a major work being done on
03:12:06
I'm trying to say what is the economic impact of investment of transportation dollars that work is undergoing.
03:12:13
The whole issue of investment adequacy for the last, in 2025 we identified a gap between a level of investment and our expenditures.
03:12:24
We're not going to do that this time.
03:12:26
What we're going to do this time is identify the 10 to 12 key investment decisions that we need to make over the next 20 years.
03:12:35
and I would like to engage you and get your input, bring to you some ideas we've generated and for you to say we may have 20 of them.
03:12:41
What are the 10 to 12 key issues or key investment initiatives that we need to be looking at over the next 20 years or so?
SPEAKER_05
03:12:49
And finally we have talked about a summit in the October timeframe.
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
03:12:54
I would like to lay out a plan for that and bring to you
03:12:57
Some ideas and get your ideas as well.
03:13:00
What I'm suggesting there is since there is no August meeting that in September if it's in your concurrence that we devote a full day to dealing with VTrans and related policy issues and so forth.
03:13:14
I have had brief discussions with the Secretary in that regard and hope that's something that you will consider as well.
03:13:22
Given those comments,
03:13:24
The next paper, as I indicated, is going to be presented to you by Arlie Reno, and that paper is on European lessons, both pluses and minuses.
03:13:35
Mr.
03:13:35
Chair, if there are no questions of me, I will ask Mr. Reno to come forward.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:13:43
Thank you, Mr. Davis.
03:13:44
Welcome, Mr. Reno.
03:13:46
I'll get you queued up there and
03:13:47
This is an often-heard question, as you know.
03:13:51
Why can't we do it the way those Europeans do, whether it's automotive engineering or passenger rail or land use?
03:13:59
And so we're looking forward to your presentation.
SPEAKER_05
03:14:07
Yes, this is an absolutely fascinating topic and I agree with you.
03:14:12
I'm not sure what we can do with all this information.
03:14:16
I'm Arlie Reno of Cambridge Systematics.
03:14:20
I'm one of the consultant team members helping on VTrans 2035.
03:14:26
Europe is very different in a lot of ways.
03:14:31
There's more differences between Europe and us than there are differences among our states, and those are pretty significant.
03:14:40
The comparisons I'm going to show you are really with the advanced Western European democracies, not with the former Soviet republics who are now entering the
03:14:54
age of trying to become democracies.
03:14:59
The key here is there's a very long and different history for the US and Europe and that makes it hard to take these lessons and begin to apply some of them.
03:15:11
And as Mr. Davis said, there's some positive and negative lessons.
03:15:18
The key is Europe developed a lot earlier than we did with a lot of the city centers in the 1800s being developed or even earlier.
03:15:28
Most of our urban areas have developed in the 20th century really.
03:15:36
and our growth from 100 million in 1900 up to 300 million now today.
03:15:43
Obviously most of our development has taken place since 1900.
03:15:48
Another key difference is that European has followed very different applications of fuel taxes and applications of other fees to transportation.
03:16:01
They raise a lot of money from transportation, use it for transportation and a lot of other purposes.
03:16:08
One of the most interesting things is when we look at mileage per capita and we look at energy use per capita in transportation and then
03:16:18
Europe, as you can see, is a lot less in mileage.
03:16:23
That is, not only do they have a lower rate of vehicle ownership and higher density, but many fewer miles per person, 40 to 67 percent of U.S. vehicle miles per capita.
03:16:38
But because of higher energy efficiency for their vehicle fleet, at least the passenger vehicle fleet, they're even lower than that on per capita energy consumption.
03:16:49
They got there.
03:16:51
European fuel taxes are very, very high.
03:16:55
And obviously, fuel taxes as a percent of the fuel price vary because the fuel price varies a lot faster than the fuel taxes vary.
03:17:06
But they're about 50% in a lot of European places, 40, 50, 60%.
03:17:12
Whereas now, if you look at the US, it's about 15%.
03:17:16
And Europe also raises a lot of money from vehicle fees, that is to register a vehicle originally.
03:17:25
You pay a lot of money in a lot of European countries.
03:17:28
So this number that you see here, Europe raises from transportation users about $1,400 per person per year.
03:17:41
We raise about $400 per person per year.
03:17:44
So you can see
03:17:45
Their fuel taxes and other fees for vehicles are very different than ours on a per-person basis, and these are roughly comparable in terms of per capita income, some a little bit higher per capita income, some a little bit lower.
03:18:03
And here's what the fuel taxes look like in some of the selected Western European countries, the ones that we
03:18:09
In the paper there is a full compilation of all the European Union fuel taxes.
03:18:17
This ranges up to $3.78 per gallon in the United Kingdom and that compares to ours $0.38 per gallon for state and federal fuel taxes on average.
03:18:27
ten times as high a tax burden in the United Kingdom, somewhat less in the other European countries, so obviously they have used that both for energy independence and as a revenue-raising source.
03:18:43
Europe with transit.
03:18:46
Transit and rail, much higher levels of usage than we have here, but that is also a product of history.
03:18:53
They have historical investments in rail, commuter rail, urban transit and so forth.
03:19:00
We know we strongly support transit here, but, you know, transit is right now 1% of all passenger miles of travel in the U.S.
03:19:10
To get it up to 2% would require us to make a capital investment about three times as much as we do now per year.
03:19:19
We're, you know, under maintaining our transit assets as well as our highway assets.
03:19:24
Here's some very interesting information about passenger mile percentages in Europe versus the United States.
03:19:35
And I want to make three important points here.
03:19:38
One is
03:19:38
You know, personal passenger cars are the majority of travel in all these societies.
03:19:46
We're a little bit different because we're 96.2%.
03:19:49
The United Kingdom is next at 86.5%.
03:19:54
Germany is down at 79.5%.
03:19:57
Predominant, you know, all these places at least four-fifths of the passenger miles are by cars.
03:20:05
However, you can see the incredible differences between Europe and ourselves in terms of buses and urban rail and passenger rail.
03:20:14
One of the surprising things is we always think of European countries as having rail systems, but you can see their bus usage is very, very high in comparison to ours.
03:20:28
These are all buses for the United States.
03:20:31
This is school buses, transit buses, intercity buses, and that's the same thing there.
03:20:36
We're at 3.2% by bus.
03:20:39
France is 5.2%, and Italy is up at 12%.
03:20:42
There's a lot of bus use in these European nations.
03:20:47
When we go to Europe, we use their urban rail systems in London, Paris, and so forth.
03:20:54
But those are higher usage than what we have here, urban rail 0.3 in the U.S., up to one and a half in France.
03:21:04
If you look at passenger rail, which includes intercity rail, long distance rail and commuter rail, European cities have a lot of investment in both commuter rail and intercity rail.
03:21:22
When we add together Amtrak and commuter rail in the US it's 0.3% and these countries are up above 5% up to 9% which is a really significant difference and that also is a historical pattern of investment.
03:21:39
There's been a tremendous amount of investment there in order to achieve these things.
03:21:42
If we turn to non-motorized, European countries, some of them, if you go to Denmark and the Netherlands, they use bicycles quite a bit.
03:21:54
And if you look at some of the other European countries, they're similar to us in terms of kilometers per person per year by bicycle.
03:22:04
About the same in Spain and Luxembourg in the U.S.
03:22:08
So there's a lot of differences.
03:22:10
It's cultural difference with regard to bikes.
03:22:14
European cities and land use, they are following the same policies as you are following.
03:22:21
I won't go through all of these, but if you look at your policies, these are the European Union's policies with regard to land use.
03:22:31
They're starting with higher density.
03:22:33
But they are doing the same things as you're doing, applying the same kinds of policies.
03:22:40
The difference is they have a lot different ability to deal with things.
03:22:47
There's a lot more acceptance of public control over all the land uses, public ownership of land uses, and European countries that have lots of non-motorized travel
03:22:59
do things with land use.
03:23:01
They create the pedestrian and bikeways so their amount of control over land use and non-motorized is much greater than the control that we have exercised and that's controlled by local jurisdictions largely.
03:23:17
Safety, this is just painful for me to see actually and should be painful for you.
03:23:24
We have made great advances in highway safety historically.
03:23:32
We reduced the fatality rates per person by 23% from 1990 to 2004.
03:23:40
That is way behind what other nations were doing.
03:23:47
European nations generally did much better improvements starting at lower fatality rates per person because they have lesser vehicle travel.
03:23:57
But they made the roads safer, faster than we made our roads safer.
03:24:01
There's a lot of lessons we can get from there.
03:24:04
The state highway safety plans that are now being done by all the states led by VDOT and fostered by federal legislation, FHWA, I think they're starting to show a difference.
03:24:18
We saw
03:24:18
Somewhat less than a 4% drop in vehicle miles of travel in 2008 in the U.S., but we saw a 10% drop in fatalities.
03:24:28
So I think there's starting to be some lessons learned from other states from what we can do, lessons learned from Europe, so I'm encouraged that they're doing a little bit better.
03:24:40
On economic development, you're talking about that all the time in your deliberations about projects in Hampton Roads.
03:24:51
The United Kingdom has now looked at economic development and environmental protection together with cost-benefit analyses that consider all of that.
03:25:05
And they evaluate their major projects that way.
03:25:10
Sir Rod Eddington, who did what is a world famous study now, said here's the kinds of analysis that we can do looking at an assessment that adds not just the user benefits, the economic development benefits, but looks at the greenhouse gas and societal costs and says now we're evaluating our projects on this basis.
03:25:34
That is a lesson for Virginia and for the rest of the states.
03:25:39
This is interesting.
03:25:41
I don't want to prejudice anybody's favorite project with results from the United Kingdom, but the classifications that he put those things into, urban network projects are like fixing up your freeways.
03:25:59
HOV lanes, rail systems in the urban areas.
03:26:05
They had very, very good benefit cost ratios of over three.
03:26:10
The trade ones, the international gateways, the projects that Eddington evaluated had the higher benefit cost ratios, things that really contributed to the United Kingdom's economic development.
03:26:24
The Interurban Corridor projects, which are more on the long distance highways, long distance rail, so forth.
03:26:32
2.0 benefit cost ratio is a very good benefit cost ratio.
03:26:39
But anyway, these are all very, very promising results.
03:26:44
If you have projects that score more than two to one, that's a project that you ought to be doing, not leaving, lying there and not implemented.
03:26:56
When we get to high-speed passenger rail, as you saw back from the data of 6% to 9% rail usage versus 0.3% in the U.S., we know, obviously, they invest very heavily in passenger rail, high-speed rail.
03:27:14
Their distances are largely shorter than the distances between major U.S. urban areas.
03:27:23
We're continental.
03:27:24
They're really doing things that are mostly on an internal basis for their nations in Spain and France and Germany.
03:27:35
We now, for the first time, have some significant rail resources as the last
03:27:40
presentation talked about, so we have not been spending much on intercity rail or any kind of rail.
03:27:47
And, you know, still Richmond to Boston, that is the number one corridor for passenger rail improvement as you probably are ready to accept that conclusion.
03:28:01
There's other promising corridors too.
03:28:04
There's not all positive lessons.
03:28:07
In freight, Europe does not have a freight rail continental network.
03:28:15
I believe that's because of history, concerns about war.
03:28:22
You don't want to be invaded that effectively using rail systems.
03:28:27
And so Europe does not have a freight rail intercontinental system.
03:28:33
There's only
03:28:33
IV, it's US, Russia, China, and India.
03:28:38
So Europe relies on trucking and this rate of growth of trucking, 38% from 1995 to 2005 is three times our rate of growth of long distance trucking.
03:28:50
And that was, you know, as the European economy integrated clearly, that was a positive for the economy.
03:28:57
The lack of rail, the lack of anything else means that rail grew really rapidly while, I mean, excuse me, trucking grew very rapidly while rail and interland waterways grew much less.
03:29:10
They could have saved a lot of greenhouse gases and everything else if they had had a rail system.
03:29:16
And in fact, transport greenhouse gases grew in Europe from 1990 to 2005 while they were effective in not having growth in greenhouse gases in their other sectors.
03:29:28
Another one, congestion is not better in the earth.
03:29:36
They raise a lot of money but they don't spend it all on solutions.
03:29:40
They use it as a major tax source for everything.
03:29:44
They have a development history.
03:29:47
It's very hard in a European city or in a place like Richmond or Hampton Roads or Northern Virginia to fit more capacity of any sort into the urban fabric.
03:30:01
It's expensive and you need to do a lot of work with the public.
03:30:07
European cities, the Norwegian major cities and London have cordon pricing now.
03:30:15
You pay to enter the central business district.
03:30:19
You're very familiar that your pricing application is hot lanes and that's been studied very extensively already.
03:30:29
The Netherlands is the place in the world which is now in the early stage of looking at a vehicle miles of travel fee system for all vehicles, not just for trucks.
03:30:42
Germany has a truck-based VMT system.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:30:48
How do they measure?
SPEAKER_05
03:30:51
There's two ways, either through onboard diagnostics or through the use of GPS systems.
03:31:00
Onboard diagnostics, you would, when the vehicle goes to refuel or something, you would have a reading of the mileage.
03:31:08
And GPS, you would be tracking where you are.
03:31:13
So those are both expensive to apply.
03:31:19
and the estimates in this country at least are that, you know, 20% of the revenue could go to enforcement and administration of those kinds of things right now until we make some sort of breakthrough in those costs.
03:31:36
A VMT fee system is a little more difficult than a fuel tax system right now, so.
03:31:44
If we look at preservation, the first point I made here is we were kind of shocked a few decades ago when we first went to Europe and looked at what they did with their pavements and bridges.
03:31:57
They lasted longer.
03:31:58
They had performance-based contracting.
03:32:01
I think we're catching up, actually, and through the scams that the commissioner described,
03:32:10
that your chief engineer has done and others have done.
03:32:13
We have identified now what's going on and VDOT wanted me to take out the last point but I left it in.
03:32:23
You've really been one of the leaders in contracting procedures with what you've done in the interstate, what you've done with the public-private side and so forth.
03:32:33
So preservation
03:32:34
We were behind and I think we're doing a lot better now and we're learning back and forth from Europe.
03:32:42
So that concludes those slides and if you have any questions I'll be happy to answer to the best of my ability.
03:32:51
There will be a paper which has a great deal more data for lots and lots of countries that will be available to you on the web or distributed to you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:33:01
Mr. Reno, thank you for a really informative and thought-provoking paper.
03:33:06
Are there questions, Mr. Martin?
SPEAKER_13
03:33:08
One quick question, Mr. Chairman.
03:33:10
Given that the United Kingdom is an island nation, what would be an example of international gateway projects?
03:33:16
Is it seaports and airports?
SPEAKER_05
03:33:18
There are seaports, there are airports, there are intermodal facilities that utilize the channel tunnel.
03:33:26
things like that.
03:33:28
So they have quite a bit of international trade and they obviously rely on imports and exports even to a greater extent than we do.
03:33:39
So it really is their trade related investments, ports and airports and those kinds of facilities.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:33:49
Other questions or comments?
03:33:51
Mr. McCarthy, we're all expecting you to comment on the gas tax rates.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:33:57
It's self-evident.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:34:02
I'd settle for a dime a day.
03:34:10
Mr. Reno, again, this is a very thought-provoking paper.
03:34:16
To me, one of the things that jumps out is bus.
03:34:20
I don't think we pay enough attention to bus ridership.
03:34:25
And even though our articulated policies, as you point out, in many instances are the same as the EU.
03:34:33
We're starting with a different base.
03:34:36
But we have opportunities for the application of bus services, relatively low cost, conservative kind of densities you see in much of Virginia.
03:34:44
It does strike me that's an opportunity to mimic some of that success.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:34:49
Mr. Chairman, rail is also interesting to see that for us to increase from one to two percent
03:34:55
was going to be a huge capital investment where they're already at 10%, 9 to 10%.
03:35:00
That's scary.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:35:02
Mr. Reno, one quick question for you.
03:35:09
European cars get significantly higher gas mileage than American cars made by the same manufacturers and as I understand it are significantly dirtier.
SPEAKER_05
03:35:20
Yes, you're correct on all those counts.
03:35:24
Current European passenger fleets, not truck fleets, truck fleets are pretty much similar because they are constrained by how much stuff they have to haul, but the passenger fleets are currently achieving higher miles per gallon than the new proposed CAFE standard by 2016.
03:35:45
So when that standard goes into effect, we'll still be there.
03:35:49
They're way below what they are already achieving in Europe on greenhouse gases and on fuel consumption.
03:35:58
What you said is also true.
03:36:00
They did not historically regulate the criteria pollutants to the same extent that we did.
03:36:07
Knox, sulfur dioxide, carbon monoxide, so in particular.
03:36:12
So their fleet tends to be dirtier on those standards and of course much better with regard to total fuel consumption and greenhouse gases.
03:36:23
I didn't show you the fuel taxes on diesel.
03:36:26
Those are in the paper.
03:36:28
Most of them, except the UK, have lower taxes on diesel than they do on gasoline, and that encourages more fuel-efficient vehicles because diesels generally get about a third better mileage.
03:36:45
And we have not sold light-duty diesel successfully in this country.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:36:50
In response then to Mr. McCarthy's observation, within the paper do you address the cost of operation of a vehicle?
SPEAKER_05
03:37:02
We haven't addressed the operating cost per vehicle but that is something that is available and I could put some data in there with that regard.
03:37:22
We focus mostly on
03:37:24
What revenues are raised from taxes on vehicles and from taxes on fuels, which are, that's a very substantial difference.
Ralph M. Davis
Deputy Secretary of Transportation
03:37:35
Thank you.
03:37:37
Mr.
03:37:37
Chair, members of the board, I don't know whether this closes the discussion on European lessons, but the whole idea was hopefully all of us would be a bit more informed.
03:37:47
So when we're faced with folks saying, why can't we be like Europe?
03:37:51
We have a bit more information than we had prior to this analysis.
03:37:55
By the way, this study is on the website.
03:37:58
The draft version of it is on the vtrans.org website.
03:38:02
And you can go to that website.
03:38:04
And it's a sort of work in progress.
03:38:06
We will amend it based on information we get and feedback we get from you.
03:38:11
Mr.
03:38:11
Chair, I'd like to make one other point.
03:38:13
I've had an intern work with me this summer, Kevin Farrelly.
03:38:17
Carly, Kevin, would you please stand up?
03:38:19
Kevin is a governor's fellow.
03:38:22
The governor every year brings in the best and brightest from around the state.
03:38:27
And they come into state agencies or into the governor's office and work on various projects.
03:38:33
And Kevin is the graduate of the University of Richmond.
03:38:36
He's been with me for a month and a half or so.
03:38:40
And he's updating the transportation performance report.
03:38:42
You may recall that we released a report several months ago
03:38:47
and Kevin's in the process of updating all that data and hopefully learning some about how state government and our transportation works and we've had a good time over the last month and a half.
03:38:57
Kevin is learning, I'm learning as well and hope it's been a good experience for him.
03:39:01
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:39:03
Welcome, Mr. Farrelly and we hope that you find a calling in public services.
03:39:07
Your two immediate predecessors have done one sitting at the front table right here.
03:39:13
The Governor's Fellow Program is a marvelous way to bring
03:39:17
Great talent into public service and so thank you for doing as much as you do for the little pay that you get.
03:39:26
Okay, what I'm going to suggest right now, we have two other presentations but they also have associated action items and some folks have to get a plane before the airport closes so
03:39:37
What I would like to do is close out the work session and go into the business section.
03:39:44
And we'll just do a presentation before each of those action items.
03:39:47
And I apologize for those who have been waiting patiently in the back room.
03:39:50
But the airport is going to close for security reasons.
03:39:52
We need to get people on the road.
03:39:54
So with that, I'd like to call to order the business session of the July Commonwealth Transportation Board.
03:40:04
Is there anyone who wishes to address the board?
SPEAKER_02
03:40:08
Welcome, Mr. Ellis.
03:40:14
Thank you, Mr. Secretary, members of the board.
03:40:17
My name is Archie Ellis and I'm a retired lawyer and I have spoken to the board many times and I'm here to follow up on a letter that I sent to all of you just July 10th with an attachment suggesting ways to raise funds for transportation.
03:40:35
I didn't expect this meeting to last quite this long, but what I've heard certainly fortifies or supports the remarks and suggestions I'm making, none of which are new, I'm sure.
03:40:47
But I thought putting it on the table might have some significance.
03:40:51
I'm hoping it will motivate you to take action as a board.
03:40:56
In fact, I would like to see you make some sort of motion in your new business section to make this an active item on your agenda.
03:41:05
Raise money for transportation so that you will make recommendations to the governor and the legislature when it's timely to get something done in the upcoming session.
03:41:16
I think you've got to do it within a month or two at the latest if you're going to accomplish anything.
03:41:23
I think it's vital that you do so.
03:41:25
I don't think there's another voice in the state that's capable of doing what you're capable of doing.
03:41:30
I also think you're mandated under the state laws in your position as board members to reflect public policy and to take some initiative even if the governor fires you.
03:41:42
And I would like to see you do just that, put the cards on the table strenuously, vigorously, and flat out.
03:41:50
And nobody's doing that in this state.
03:41:53
Now, my reading of the public voices and my very limited scope of activity
03:41:59
is that nobody is objecting to raising transportation taxes except politicians who are afraid they might not be elected.
03:42:07
So I want you to face this subject and what I hope you will do, I know you can't do it today, is put this thing on your agenda for next month with a staff report and some personal recommendations so that you will come up with a conclusion of some sort.
03:42:27
I have some recommendations.
03:42:29
that you will send to the responsible people and that you will personally agitate in those circles where you have importance to get the ball rolling.
03:42:40
I'd like to make the suggestions that are obvious and a couple that are not.
03:42:45
Increase the motor fuel taxes significantly, not just a little bit.
03:42:51
This is long overdue.
03:42:53
You've heard powerful discussions this morning and I'm sure you've heard others.
03:42:58
I thought there would be people here beating on you about rest stops, but I expect you've been hearing from people back home about that, which is a peanut item, but it reflects to the public the significance of funding.
03:43:12
This is long overdue because the gasoline tax in Virginia has not been changed for quite a while, many years.
03:43:20
Now, what's happened in the ensuing period of time?
03:43:24
Automobiles have gone up in cost three times, I guess.
03:43:27
Gasoline has doubled or tripled.
03:43:31
The cost of highways has gone up.
03:43:34
I'm sure the staff can give you a rule of thumb on that real quick.
03:43:38
But our gasoline taxes stayed the same.
03:43:41
Now we've compounded this even further.
03:43:45
Automobiles get better miles per gallon.
03:43:47
When these gasoline taxes were put into effect, cars were probably getting 15 miles per gallon if they were doing well.
03:43:55
Trucks were probably getting 10 or 12.
03:43:58
Trucks are now bigger, getting more miles per gallon, creating far more costly impacts on the highway system.
03:44:06
And like automobiles, their actual payments for highways has gone down on the basis of miles and tons, etc.
03:44:16
Everything's long overdue for action.
03:44:19
And you read the papers and you know what the politicians are saying.
03:44:23
So again, I come back.
03:44:25
I think you are the voice of the citizens.
03:44:28
And if they knew really and thought about you very much, they would expect you to act.
03:44:34
Now on the second item, I would like to toss out.
03:44:37
Mr. Ellis.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:44:38
Mr. Ellis, we have a very tight time schedule.
03:44:40
Could you please sum up?
SPEAKER_02
03:44:41
Let me be very quick.
03:44:43
As told, you've heard something about that.
03:44:47
I live in Richmond.
03:44:49
I've used the Richmond Metropolitan Authority for years.
03:44:52
I've got the things on my windshield.
03:44:54
I found out to my astonishment I can use that device on the Pennsylvania Turnpike and a lot of other places all the way to Boston.
03:45:02
So, compare the Richmond-Petersburg Turnpike.
03:45:07
I live here.
03:45:08
Tolls were on that.
03:45:09
It was built before the interstate system.
03:45:12
The tolls were taken off on what I thought was a mistaken reason.
03:45:18
The RPT was not only paying all of its own expenses, its maintenance, its own policing, would have paid that many millions of dollars to replace the James River Bridge that you folks just did recently, but it was throwing off money.
03:45:34
It was a cash cow and was building other roads in the Richmond area, built Chippenham Parkway, for example.
03:45:41
It was a big success, and the people in Richmond were only paying about five cents a trip.
03:45:47
It was getting most of the money from the interstate.
03:45:50
So there are other illustrations.
03:45:51
The James River bridges, you've heard discussions down there in Tidewater.
03:45:55
I think the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel needs tolls.
03:45:58
Two things would happen.
03:46:00
It would get money from the tolls.
03:46:02
but it would also reduce the demand because frivolous trips wouldn't be taken and therefore future maintenance and construction would be greatly reduced.
SPEAKER_19
03:46:11
Same thing for the Woodrow Wilson race.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:46:14
Mr. Ellis.
03:46:15
All right, sir?
03:46:16
Yeah, I'm very sorry to catch up.
03:46:18
You vastly exceed your three minutes.
SPEAKER_02
03:46:20
I hope I'm not imposing but I have waited quite a few hours to speak.
03:46:25
Yes, sir, Mr. Ellis.
03:46:26
So I would urge you all to look at my letter.
03:46:30
The other big item that I would throw in there are truck taxes, and I've given you a memo on that, which are long overdue, and then state allocation formulas, which are a very sophisticated aspect, and I can't fully explain it, but I think allocation is done sometimes not on the merits of the project.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:46:50
There are two or three other things that I thank you.
03:46:54
You had an earlier opportunity to speak, and we do have a very tight time frame to get people on an airplane.
03:47:00
Thank you.
03:47:01
Thank you so much.
03:47:03
And your letter will certainly be entered into the record.
03:47:06
What I'd like to do to accommodate folks' travel schedule is to take up action items 8B, 8D, 11, and for Mr. Coburn, we're going to take up bids.
03:47:20
and then we'll come back and complete the remaining items.
03:47:23
So, Action Item 8B which is under the right-of-way division for Mr. Bennett.
03:47:31
Are there any questions of Mr. Bennett regarding Action Item 8B?
03:47:36
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_12
03:47:37
I move approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:47:39
All in favor?
03:47:40
Aye.
03:47:41
Action Item 8D in Roanoke County.
03:47:45
Any questions of Mr. Bennett?
03:47:47
I move approval.
03:47:48
Second.
03:47:49
All in favor?
03:47:50
Aye.
03:47:51
Turning to action item 11, the rail industrial access.
03:47:55
You had a presentation at the work session last month in Washington County.
03:47:59
Are there any questions of Mr.
03:48:00
Page?
SPEAKER_12
03:48:02
Move the approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:48:02
Second.
03:48:03
All in favor?
03:48:04
Aye.
03:48:05
Action item 13 is the bids, and we welcome Mr. Coburn.
03:48:11
Is this a good month or a bad month?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:48:14
Very active month, sir.
03:48:17
A lot of craziness going on, and there's a lot of continued interest in our bids.
03:48:23
We're getting a lot of new contractors wanting to become pre-qualified still, anywhere from 10 to 15 a month, and that's both good news and bad news.
03:48:37
Perhaps we should jump right into the project reviews, beginning with
03:48:46
Page 1, the first project, B95, is two bridge structures, 360 over 460 in the railroad in Nottoway County.
03:49:02
We had seven interested bidders submit on this project, of good value, and we believe that we recommend this project for award to you, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:49:15
All in favor?
03:49:17
All right.
03:49:18
Page 2.
03:49:19
And for those new members, and there's one replacement page or one additional page at the end, correct?
03:49:26
Yes, sir.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:49:28
Page 2 is 265, Danville, the Franklin Turnpike Extension.
03:49:36
You'll notice that there were nine bidders interested in this project.
03:49:40
Again, we believe it's an appropriate bid and recommend this award to you.
03:49:44
Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:49:45
Second.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:49:46
Call in favor.
03:49:50
Page 3 needs a little bit of a description.
03:49:55
This is a design-build project, the 460 connector.
03:49:59
You'll recall that this project was bid previously.
03:50:04
There was a protest.
03:50:07
There was a lawsuit and a court action.
03:50:11
The original bid
03:50:14
The proposal and RFP was terminated.
03:50:18
The project was reexamined and has been rebid.
03:50:26
The board did not take action to rescind the original award after the court case and so at this time we're recommending the board rescind the original award
03:50:42
of the First Procurement.
SPEAKER_12
03:50:44
Mr. Chairman, I would point out that this involves Appalachian Regional Commission funds and these ARC funds cannot be expended anywhere else except in corridor Q, which is right here.
03:50:58
I would move to rescind the original approval and approve this current award.
SPEAKER_13
03:51:05
Second.
SPEAKER_12
03:51:05
Second, Peter.
SPEAKER_13
03:51:08
All in favor?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:51:09
of rescission.
03:51:10
All in favor of rescission say aye.
03:51:12
Aye.
03:51:13
Any opposed?
03:51:15
Okay, page four.
03:51:17
Page four.
03:51:18
Did that include, Mr. Chairman, the new approval?
03:51:21
No, that was just the rescission.
03:51:23
The new approval is on the next page, page four.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:51:27
Page four is the second in current chapter.
03:51:31
This proposal has
03:51:35
It's been resubmitted, analyzed.
03:51:38
Bids were received from two bidders this time.
03:51:44
The result is the same firm has been determined low.
03:51:51
You will notice that there was a significant savings in the price bid from the first procurement, primarily
03:52:05
There was a significant difference in fuel pricing, you'll recall, in this year's period.
03:52:12
Heavy fuel commodity items have certainly made a difference in the way that looks.
03:52:20
And we recommend its award to you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:52:22
So can we say we are snatching victory from the jaws of defeat here?
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:52:27
I wouldn't, but I would second that, sir.
03:52:30
Mr. Chairman, I want to move approval of this project.
03:52:33
Second.
03:52:34
On the heels of this project will be a connector to the 460 link to connect to the Coalfield Expressway termini, and we held a public hearing on that Tuesday night at Breaks Interstate Park.
03:52:47
And it's a very, very impressive piece of road that we're going to get to benefit in the win-win situation of surface mining, whereby that we could utilize post-mining land use to our benefit.
03:53:04
And of course, that comes next, but this is a great project that opens up and begins to take care of some of the traffic out of Kentucky.
03:53:12
As you very well know, Kentucky's completing their
03:53:15
4 Laney of 460 to the state line.
03:53:18
And we're not going to have to expend some of the monies that we ordinarily would have had to do just to take care of their traffic and ramp it down.
03:53:24
We're going to apply that to this project.
03:53:26
This is a very good project and I just wanted to go on record as for that.
03:53:31
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:53:32
There's a motion and a second.
03:53:33
All in favor?
03:53:34
Aye.
03:53:35
Any opposed?
03:53:37
All right, and then we have the one additional page five.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:53:40
The additional page, page five, this is an unusual and different request for the board.
03:53:50
This project is J-69, excuse me, Churchville Avenue in the city of Stanton.
03:53:58
It's a very important project to the city.
03:54:01
This project is bid once and rejected.
03:54:06
The second bids, we had eight bidders.
03:54:10
The project is going through its analysis right now.
03:54:15
There is an issue with the apparent low bidder in fulfilling the commitments of his DBE requirements.
03:54:25
That analysis has to go through a panel hearing which is scheduled for next week.
03:54:32
Since the board does not meet in August,
03:54:37
Whatever the outcome of the results of that panel hearing and the recommendation to the chief engineer would not be heard until September.
03:54:50
There are some time-sensitive items in that contract that's very important to Stanton that we would like to get started this fall if at all possible.
03:55:02
So based on our analysis,
03:55:05
I am asking the board to authorize the commissioner to take the appropriate action as recommended by the chief engineer and through his consideration.
03:55:17
Recognizing this project is over $2 million threshold that would normally come to the board.
03:55:24
Of the several outcomes, if this project is awarded, it would be awarded to one of these two firms.
03:55:33
and you will note there's only a thousand dollars separating the bid of these two firms at about a million six, excuse me, two million six.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:55:42
Mr. Chairman, I would move that we give the commissioner the authority to approve the winner of this bid so that we can move forward according to the instructions that the chief engineer just outlined.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:55:55
I second.
03:55:56
Okay, there's a motion and a second.
03:55:57
Any, the attorney general has
03:56:00
reviewed this issue and is comfortable with this delegation of authority.
03:56:09
Okay.
03:56:09
All right.
03:56:10
There's a motion and a second.
03:56:11
All in favor?
03:56:13
Aye.
03:56:13
Any opposed?
03:56:15
Thank you.
03:56:17
Is that the end of it, Mr. Coburn?
03:56:19
Yes, sir.
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:56:20
I'm sorry.
03:56:22
Mr. Chairman, as we watch Mr. Coburn exit from the podium, I've asked him to brief us quickly on the new technology deployment that we've been experimenting with over the last couple of months with respect to our bid-letting process in which we'll now go into full implementation.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:56:43
Do we have a few slides here?
03:56:46
Let me just brief you.
03:56:49
If you're aware, we have a public reading requirement in the code.
03:56:55
In years past, it was very manual, very labor-intensive process.
03:57:01
We would enter in this room at a pre-established time and open bids very laboriously because it was all very manual.
03:57:12
Over time, we have advanced to embrace the electronic bidding technologies and all the benefits that that's given us.
03:57:22
Interest in attending those meetings by our contractor suppliers, Wayne, but we still needed to have this public opening capability and visibility and transparency.
03:57:38
Over the past six months,
03:57:41
We've explored with IT and brainstormed and stolen ideas from neighboring states and etc.
03:57:50
And Dr. Allen's IT folks have found a method where we can read our bids live, broadcast through the web, and it can be
03:58:09
witnessed, heard, recorded by any number of folks who want to.
03:58:16
In the past six months that technology has grown and other than a few cynical comments like I need a haircut and those things, pretty much everybody has really embraced it and has appreciation.
03:58:34
One of the really significant things is this now real-time
03:58:39
gives our contractors and suppliers the opportunity to see what we're doing and anyone else that's interested in seeing what we're doing.
03:58:48
They hear the results of their bids.
03:58:49
They know how they stacked up as the bid reading occurs.
03:58:54
And it's out there in the open for everyone.
03:58:58
And the spike in the growth of the interest and we've even been able to track where some of the hits come from.
03:59:08
and we even saw some of our contractors that were on vacation in other parts of the country and even in Europe dialing in and watching bid openings on bid day.
03:59:24
We're very pleased with it.
03:59:27
It's a very significant
03:59:29
improvement in our transparency and we think it's a really successful picture on how we present what we're doing and doing our business publicly.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
03:59:43
Any questions, Mr. Coburn?
SPEAKER_13
03:59:44
Just a quick question.
03:59:45
Are the bids submitted online in advance of your request?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
03:59:51
Yes, we have a third-party vendor that all of our bids are submitted and they're released to us at one minute after 10 a.m. on bid day.
SPEAKER_13
04:00:01
So there's no way anybody could access that bid?
04:00:05
Any potential bidder could access it?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
04:00:07
That's correct.
04:00:09
There are keys on different places.
04:00:12
The bidder, as he submits his bid, has to submit his key to place it and lock it.
04:00:19
Then it's downloaded to us.
04:00:22
We have to unlock it.
04:00:23
The third-party vendor can't even read it.
04:00:27
So it's a very proven technology.
04:00:30
It's growing nationwide.
04:00:32
I believe there's something like 16 states that are using this method now.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:00:39
And that's growing of interest.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:00:45
Thank you.
04:00:46
You know, it's these small innovations that VDOT and DRPT have undertaken that are keeping us in the ballgame.
04:00:54
So Byron, Commissioner, thank you so much for this.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:00:58
One quick question.
04:00:59
You mentioned the bids were a lot better because the fuel prices were down.
04:01:03
Do we have any wording in our bids that were let when the fuel prices were high that we benefit when the fuel prices go down?
04:01:14
Is there any opportunity for us to get on the other end?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
04:01:18
Yes, there is.
04:01:20
Our contracts, our unit price contracts,
04:01:26
Some of those individual items have fuel adjustment clauses on them, and it works both ways.
04:01:33
So if prices are down, we're seeing that value return to us.
04:01:41
Other commodities are similar.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:01:47
Mr. Coburn, thank you, as always.
04:01:48
All right, let's go back to the beginning of the agenda, and we will take up the maintenance division items.
04:01:55
Is Ms. Sorrell with us to answer any questions or somebody from the maintenance division?
04:02:00
Mr. Prezioso.
04:02:01
Action item one is the transfer of a frontage road in Henrico County.
04:02:06
Any questions?
SPEAKER_13
04:02:07
Move approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:02:09
Second.
04:02:09
All in favor?
04:02:11
Aye.
04:02:11
Action item two is a conditional order of abandonment on State Route 28.
04:02:15
I think that's in Spotsylvania.
04:02:18
Second.
04:02:18
All in favor?
04:02:20
Aye.
04:02:21
Action item three is the
04:02:23
Kent Point Creek Bridge, which some of us have been to visit, and an important naming for Corporal Charles Ellsworth Memorial Bridge.
04:02:32
Any questions?
04:02:34
Is there a motion?
04:02:35
Move it for approval.
04:02:37
Second.
04:02:37
All in favor?
04:02:38
Aye.
04:02:40
Action item four, revenue sharing reallocation in New Kent County for Route 628.
04:02:45
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_18
04:02:46
Move for approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:02:48
Second.
04:02:48
All in favor?
04:02:49
Aye.
04:02:50
Action Item 5 is the Economic Development Access Policy.
04:02:54
Mr. Estes just presented to you a little while ago.
04:02:57
Any last questions of Mr. Estes?
04:02:59
Move approval.
SPEAKER_13
04:03:00
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:03:00
All in favor?
04:03:02
Aye.
04:03:02
And Action Item 6 is the Virginia Byway designation in Rappahannock County.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:03:06
Move approval.
04:03:07
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:03:08
All in favor?
04:03:09
Aye.
04:03:10
Action Item 7A, and Mr. Bennett
04:03:16
Certainly we're going to want a presentation on 7B.
04:03:18
If you could give a brief description of 7A, there may be some questions.
Richard Bennett
State Right of Way Director
04:03:23
7A is in connection with the Woodrow Wilson Bridge and it is a change of a minor nature as you'll notice in your sketch there to move the limited access line.
04:03:35
We're in combination with the adjacent property owner and the shifting of this line which can be accommodated by the design will lead us to a settlement.
04:03:43
in that combination.
04:03:44
So it's recommended by the department that it be approved.
04:03:50
Is there a motion?
04:03:51
Move for approval, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:03:52
Second.
04:03:52
All in favor?
04:03:54
Aye.
04:03:54
Okay, Action Item 7B, if we can go to the work session presentation in advance of this vote.
Richard Bennett
State Right of Way Director
04:04:06
Carol, I might need that.
04:04:14
This is a, the second limited access request is in connection, is in the Leesburg area and is in connection with a Dominion Virginia Power transmission project.
04:04:25
This is a small transmission project that serves, that's intended to serve the western area or just outside to the west of Leesburg, Perceville and Hamilton and involves the construction of about 12 miles of line from the east side to the west side.
04:04:41
It's been going on for about four years and the State Corporation Commission has approved a corridor that generally follows Route 7 and the Route 7 bypass alignment to accomplish that purpose there.
04:04:54
One thing I want to make clear is that this is not a part of the Allegheny Path transmission project, which is a huge project that is being, you know, currently debated further in the western part of the state.
04:05:05
This involves constructing a 230 kV
04:05:08
Transmission Line, as I mentioned 12 miles along the Route 7 and that is going to build a new substation out into the Hamilton area as well.
04:05:18
The next drawing here is the approximate alignment there as you can see it skirting around the bypass portion of Leesburg there.
04:05:27
The type of construction will be a monopole with a single line
04:05:31
on one side.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:05:33
Chairman, since they appear to have money, I wonder if they'd be willing to widen Route 7 a little bit around Leesburg.
04:05:38
For those of us that travel, that's awesome.
Richard Bennett
State Right of Way Director
04:05:42
As I mentioned, it has gone through, and the State Corporation Commission, you know, evaluated various routes and then selected this modified decorder, which uses the bypass.
04:05:53
And one of the reasons for doing this is that Virginia Dominion
04:05:57
Certainly has a corridor that they could go through downtown Leesburg on the W&OD Trail, but that was a very unfavorable alternative for the citizens of that area.
04:06:07
So a modified D was to use the bypass right-of-way, which is more of a transmission corridor, and some other secondary alignments in order to go around Leesburg.
04:06:20
It does involve placing seven towers within our
04:06:23
Limited access right away, and it does involve allowing them to construct maintenance entrances to those towers within those same areas.
04:06:33
And two of the maintenance entrances are from the Route 7 to the outside because the access to the tower is actually being located outside, but the streams and other things make it very difficult to access those points.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:06:47
Mr. Chairman, that's been done consistent with not
04:06:51
limiting our ability to make the improvements to Route 7 without additional cost, I hope.
Richard Bennett
State Right of Way Director
04:06:56
That's correct, sir.
04:06:58
This is just in your book, you can see that the various sites of this limited access changed are marked in red there that are on all various segments of the bypass from where it begins just on the east side going over to the western side.
04:07:14
As you indicated, we have evaluated the transmission tower locations,
04:07:20
and that they have no impact on the expansion opportunities of Route 7.
04:07:26
Even with the expansion, they still meet all of the clear zone requirements that we would have and have no effect on the, that we can see on the maintenance of the roadway there.
04:07:37
Just a quick listing here, as I said, there are seven access roads and most of them were proposed to avoid streams and other impacts there.
04:07:46
In closing, the towers were
04:07:48
situated in order to accommodate all the roadway planning.
04:07:53
The maintenance use of the roadway is very infrequent unless they have an issue.
04:07:57
It's just for inspection on an yearly or bi-yearly basis.
04:08:01
There are no negative environmental or traffic operations that impact from this.
04:08:07
There will be some trees removed along the corridor, but there has been developed a plan for them to provide landscaping in connection with those areas where trees have to be removed from a
04:08:18
Clearance Standpoint.
04:08:21
And additionally, this would be a case where compensation in accordance with the policy would be expected, you know, from Dominion for the right to be in the limited access.
04:08:31
If anybody has any questions?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:08:36
Thank you, Mr. Bennett.
04:08:38
Questions or comments?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:08:41
I would say, Mr. Chairman,
04:08:43
We all should be impressed with the kind of collaborative effort that goes on like this on a matter-of-fact basis month after month to make our business, Dominion's business, and the people's business really work.
04:08:55
And it's something really that's a good spirit, it's well-developed, and it works to everybody's benefit.
04:09:00
I think as you see this project, it's full of pluses for everyone.
04:09:05
I appreciate that.
04:09:06
Also, I think perhaps Dominion has provided a model for us.
04:09:11
Perhaps we should go to the State Corporation Commission and ask for a rate increase.
04:09:18
I'm just kidding.
04:09:21
But I do think that also points out that there is an understanding in the state that additional funds are necessary and arrangements are necessary to provide the things that people actually do value and are willing to pay for.
04:09:33
It's something that
04:09:35
We're learning that lesson ourselves, how to apply it in our case.
04:09:40
I'd like to move.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:09:42
Is there a second?
04:09:43
Second.
04:09:43
Approval.
04:09:44
All in favor?
04:09:45
Aye.
04:09:46
Any opposed?
04:09:47
Thank you.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:09:49
All right.
04:09:50
I'm sorry.
04:09:51
Quick comment in regards to the Koelemay suggestion that we go to the state corporation for a rate increase.
04:09:58
There have been a number of people who suggest that
04:10:02
Lee III, Michael A. Williams III, Michael A.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:10:20
Too much rationality, sir.
04:10:23
Okay, Action Item 8A is an easement or convenience in James City County for the Capital Trail Route 5.
04:10:32
Any questions of Mr. Bennett?
04:10:36
Is there a motion?
04:10:37
So moved.
04:10:39
Second.
04:10:39
All in favor?
04:10:40
Aye.
04:10:41
And then Action Item 8C, which is for the 495 Hot Lanes Conveyance Flexibility.
04:10:47
Are there any questions of Mr. Bennett?
04:10:50
I move it's approval, Mr. Chairman.
04:10:53
Is there a second?
04:10:55
Second.
04:10:55
All in favor?
04:10:57
Aye.
04:10:57
All right.
04:10:58
And then Action Item 8E in Albemarle County.
04:11:03
Any questions?
04:11:04
Move approval.
04:11:05
Second.
SPEAKER_13
04:11:06
All in favor?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:11:08
Aye.
04:11:08
And then Action Item 9 under Innovative Finance, thank you, Mr. Bennett, is an actual approval.
04:11:16
We're going to have a presentation and
04:11:18
Ms. Brown, I apologize.
04:11:20
This is two days in a row.
04:11:21
We've trespassed on your time more than we should have, but this is an important issue, and I hope you'll give us a brief overview, and then we'll take up the action item.
SPEAKER_01
04:11:40
Good afternoon, everyone.
04:11:42
The next item on the action agenda is
04:11:46
A resolution asking for your authorization to sell up to $75 million in bonds for the Northern Virginia Transportation District Bond Program.
04:11:57
I'm going to take a few minutes to give you a very brief recap of the NBTD Bond Program.
04:12:03
The General Assembly has authorized up to $500.2 million in NBTD Bonds that can be sold to finance various projects
04:12:15
located within the localities comprising that district.
04:12:18
To date we have sold $403.1 million in bonds.
04:12:23
This proposed sale would provide proceeds of $57.4 million to fund a portion of the Fairfax County Parkway,
04:12:32
10 million for the Route 50 Courthouse Road interchange and $5 million for Metrorail parking in the City of Fairfax.
04:12:41
That parking facility has been completed.
04:12:43
This would be a reimbursement for that project.
04:12:46
After this proposed sale, there would be a remaining authorization in the program of $24.7 million.
04:12:53
Among the projects being funded by this sale, two of the projects do have allocations from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.
04:13:03
So proceeds of this sale complete the funding for those projects, enable us to complete the project on time and take advantage of that funding.
04:13:12
Another element of the ARRA is Build America bonds.
04:13:17
and we hope to take advantage of that feature as well.
04:13:20
The resolution that you're being asked to approve includes delegation of authority to the chairman or his designee to include build America bonds in the bond structure.
04:13:31
And what that does for us is allow us to take advantage of an option to receive 35% of the debt service payment from the federal government, which could dramatically reduce our cost of borrowing.
04:13:45
The board's financial advisor, public resources advisory group,
04:13:49
preliminarily estimated that that element could save us up to $5 million over the term of the bonds.
04:13:56
That's about $3.5 million on a present value basis.
04:14:00
So we're very desirous of being able to take advantage of that opportunity.
04:14:05
If you would like, I can step you through the... Ms. Pandak.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:14:11
I probably need Ms. Brown walking me through everything on this, but I do have a question and I am excited as I'm sure that
04:14:19
My fellow residents up in Northern Virginia will be that these projects can move forward.
04:14:25
What happens to the $24.7 million?
04:14:28
Are there additional projects lined up that are being considered and you'll be back to us on that?
SPEAKER_01
04:14:33
Yes, ma'am.
04:14:34
Depending on the development schedule for those projects, we would come back to you for authorization to sell bonds for those projects when it became time effective.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:14:43
Okay, so there's a question of the project being ready to go and the
04:14:48
It looks like maybe you can turn that $24.7 million into a whole lot more money the way you've been creatively bringing in federal funds.
04:15:02
That's pretty exciting.
04:15:05
No, I appreciate that.
04:15:06
Those are all my questions.
04:15:07
I'm ready to move.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:15:08
I think Ms. Brown that the largest single remaining project is the 123 Route 1 interchange, if I remember correctly.
04:15:17
Yes, sir.
04:15:19
Okay, any other questions or comments?
04:15:21
What I would say before Ms. Pandak makes the motion, this is a program that was created by the General Assembly alongside the Route 58 program and the Elk Grove Connector Program in Hampton Roads where localities had the option of either taking recordation tax distributions into their general fund or pooling them for transportation purposes.
04:15:46
And Northern Virginia has pooled theirs
04:15:48
to support this program.
04:15:49
They've added in the right-of-way fees that in other cases go into the secondary road funds in order to support this bond fund.
04:15:57
So again, it's been part of some regional and legislative choices for this.
04:16:04
So with that, by way of background, is there a motion?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
04:16:07
So moved, Mr. Chairman.
04:16:08
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:16:09
All in favor?
04:16:11
Aye.
04:16:11
Any opposed?
04:16:12
You know, Mr. Dickens, that's a great question.
04:16:20
The City of Chesapeake took their funds and used it to help support the Chesapeake Expressway through the Oak Grove Connector, which ties into the Chesapeake Expressway.
04:16:33
They could not arrive at a consensus of projects to pledge those bonds to.
04:16:39
They have that flexibility today to take now.
04:16:42
Most of them are using those in their general funds today, so the time to have done this would have been a decade and a half ago when these funds were first available.
04:16:51
But again, you've got to have agreement on how to use these funds when you have established priorities to make these things work.
04:17:01
Additional questions or comments?
04:17:03
Thank you, Ms. Brown.
04:17:07
I guess the last item is Action Item 10, which is the Six-Year Improvement Program transfer, second to last item.
04:17:17
And Ms. Busher is here to answer any questions about transfers.
04:17:21
Any questions of Ms. Busher?
SPEAKER_13
04:17:24
Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:17:26
All in favor?
04:17:28
Aye.
04:17:29
Action Item 12 is the Mid-Downtown Tunnel, and I know, Mr. Dickens, you wanted to
04:17:35
talk a little bit more, and there is a piece of paper with some additional amendments to that resolution.
04:17:43
Do we have that available?
04:17:47
Ms. Dickens, why don't you...
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:17:48
Opening comments I wanted to make.
04:17:50
When I made my presentation earlier, I rushed through a slide in the early piece of it that described what the plot conversion actually is.
04:18:01
A couple of fellows asked me once again.
04:18:04
What's happening is the Midtown Tunnel, which is currently one, two lanes of heavily traveled two-lane highway in the Commonwealth of Virginia, there will be an additional two lanes built for that Midtown Tunnel.
04:18:21
The Martin Luther King Expressway will have an extension that will connect the Midtown Tunnel 164, 264,
04:18:33
so that there's a connectivity between the Midtown Tunnel and the Downtown Tunnel to give people alternatives for accidents and so forth.
04:18:45
The third piece of this project is the Downtown Tunnel which will have no new capacity but is out of compliance with the current safety regulations that will have
04:19:01
additional fire and ventilation and other lighting improvements to that too.
04:19:08
Do you want to go through the other, the attendance of the resolution?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:16
Sure.
04:19:17
Why don't we do this?
04:19:19
If we could get a motion and a second on the main motion, the resolution.
04:19:24
I would make that motion.
SPEAKER_13
04:19:26
I'll second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:19:27
Okay, there's a motion and a second.
04:19:29
And just as I had described earlier, there are four issues that bear repeating and clarification.
04:19:38
Really more out of my concern, we're going into a period of change of administration and it's important to have some policy guidance established by the CTB as VDOT is attempting to develop an interim agreement and begin negotiations.
04:19:55
And so the first further revolved
04:19:58
just says development of a financeable project that minimizes the total rate to the extent possible which may require some form of public funding to supplement private financing.
04:20:07
I will say on the record to make this project work is going to require a significant amount of public financing.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:20:14
Mr. Chairman, the only problem I have with that statement is using that word minimize.
04:20:20
I understand and support the concept of balanced funding.
04:20:25
But I really don't think this project should start out thinking that minimizing the tolls is going to be the solution.
04:20:32
I think it should read more if we could make it say a combination of public funds and tolls that would support the PVTA portion of the project.
04:20:44
But using the word minimize I don't think is the appropriate language there.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:20:51
Let me get through and explain.
04:20:54
We can come back to that because this is not being made in the form of an amendment yet and we could have that discussion.
04:20:59
The second resolve is the early tolling that we discussed which is a major issue and that's going to be a challenge at every level of government to make that work.
04:21:10
The third resolve is that to the degree that the region is studying multimodal opportunities
04:21:18
that that not hamper the development of this project either in terms of timeline or cost.
04:21:24
And I will say, you know, the city of Norfolk has just done amazing things to get that project going.
04:21:31
Virginia Beach is probably in two or three years will be in a position to start talking about actually constructing that extension.
04:21:42
And after that, the region will probably need to start thinking about where do they go next.
04:21:48
It may be west to Portsmouth.
04:21:49
It may be south to Chesapeake.
04:21:51
Those questions have to be asked in a more open kind of environment.
04:21:56
And the questions have to ask, what's the appropriate mode?
04:22:00
It may not be light rail.
04:22:02
It could be bus or bus rapid transit.
04:22:04
We learned from the European lessons today.
04:22:07
But this project will be hampered.
04:22:10
The environmental document doesn't allow a lot of wiggle room in this area.
04:22:15
The fourth is to continue coordination efforts with CSX Railroad to work.
04:22:22
There is some property ownership there, which the City of Portsmouth is very interested.
04:22:27
in trying to develop, and again, one of the things we're trying to do with our port improvements in the city of Portsmouth, both at the APM and the Portsmouth Marine Terminal is to grow tag space and to help the city of Portsmouth.
04:22:41
They need every ounce of help they can get, and so this is a very important part of that.
04:22:48
So that's the essence there is that, you know, there is this direction and there's not
04:22:53
People second guessing the good work of VDOT as they try to do these very, very difficult negotiations.
04:23:02
Mr. Dickens has offered to make this as a motion.
04:23:05
If you want to have a little bit of discussion, the wording on the first one to make that a little more acceptable, let's have that discussion before the motion gets made.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:23:14
Mr. Koelemay has some language I think that perhaps would make it acceptable to everybody.
04:23:20
If you want to accept it as a friendly amendment or if you want to wait?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:23:23
This hasn't been made as a motion yet, so this is all open for discussion.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:23:27
Well, Mr. Chairman, if I could, let me discuss quickly.
04:23:31
I think what we're into here as a board is we have to understand we're into what is called around the world project finance.
04:23:37
In other words, there's not a set way of doing projects that applies to every project.
04:23:42
Each project is going to have its own customized package of
04:23:46
investors and timelines and instruments and tools and that's what we're really doing here.
04:23:52
We're dealing with a project that's going to require a set of solutions that may or may not be applicable to any other project that we consider.
04:24:01
So we are inventing something new and that means we have to build in flexibility.
04:24:06
I think what the concerns that some of my colleagues have expressed about tools I think is important to recognize.
04:24:13
On the other hand, our purpose is not really
04:24:16
to pretend that tolls can solely finance this.
04:24:20
So I would propose just a simple change that would say in the case of the first further resolve, the development of a financeable project that includes tolls, some form of public funding, and some form of public funding to supplement private financing.
04:24:39
So the tolls are in there but the others is knowledge.
04:24:42
The more important thing I think is the second one that I would propose we might consider language that said the early tolling of the project during construction will lead to the moderation of toll rates in the long term because that's really the objective is to avoid the, we want the toll collections, we just don't want the rate to get astronomical.
04:25:02
So I think that makes it clear that our purpose is to set a reasonable toll
04:25:07
and it is to acknowledge that some form of public financing would be required.
04:25:12
So at the appropriate time, if you'd like me to read it specifically and make a motion to that effect, I'll be glad to do this.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:19
I have a little discussion here.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:21
Mr. Chairman, I just have a question.
04:25:24
As I look at the original resolution under the second bullet,
04:25:32
Is there an overlap between that and the further resolved in this proposed amendment?
04:25:41
I'm just wondering why number one is that the further resolved in the proposed amendment is needed if that's not already picked up under the second bullet.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:50
Which second bullet are you looking at?
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:52
I'm looking at the main...
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:54
Page two of the main...
04:25:55
Page two.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:25:57
Be it further resolved, and then there are two bullets under there, and it talks about reducing, stabilizing reducing toll rates.
04:26:09
I just didn't want to get into, I'm not really arguing the substance, I just didn't want to get into having contradictory statements.
SPEAKER_13
04:26:21
That's in the independent review recommendations, right?
04:26:23
Yeah.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:26:27
seems to capture as is.
04:26:31
Well, let's do this.
04:26:32
How about we just, let's just delete the first one.
04:26:35
And then your recommendation before a motion is made that on the second further resolve clause, the early tolling of the project, Ms. Koelemay, if you could.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:26:44
During construction will lead to the moderation of toll rates in the long term.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:26:53
Do you need for the long term?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:26:55
Say that slowly.
04:26:56
I'm sorry.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:26:59
Early tolling of the project during construction will lead to the moderation of toll rates in the long term.
04:27:23
What you're saying there by the further resolve that the CTB supports the recommendation?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:27:29
I'm sorry, Mr. Crow, we're not eliminating the second bullet.
04:27:31
We're eliminating the first further resolve so that there's no conflict.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:27:40
No good decos unpunished.
04:27:43
First bullet on the addendum.
Sharon E. Pandak
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:27:45
All the bullets stay the same.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:27:48
The base resolution stays the same.
04:27:52
We are eliminating the first further resolve on this piece of paper.
04:27:57
And the second further resolve would say be it further resolved that the early tolling of the project during the construction will lead to the moderation
04:28:09
I'm sorry, you're going to have to repeat that.
04:28:20
Okay, any further discussion about this amendment?
SPEAKER_13
04:28:26
Just one comment.
04:28:28
I think we're in agreement as to your point.
04:28:31
All we're trying to do is make it acceptable.
04:28:33
It's got to be sold at the grassroots level, and wording and stuff is important.
04:28:38
So I don't think we have any general disagreement in what your point is in terms of public and private financing.
04:28:45
But I think it's an important project for the area.
04:28:50
For one thing, we'll get something accomplished to build upon successes.
04:28:56
And so that's really why maybe
04:28:59
I sort of like the word minimize, but I understand where you're coming from.
04:29:02
And if we take that out, I think it covers, Dana.
04:29:05
We've already got it in there.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:29:07
And that is in the base resolution.
04:29:09
Same thing.
04:29:11
So the proof will be in the pudding.
04:29:12
Right.
04:29:13
All right.
04:29:14
Okay.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:29:15
Is that now a motion, Mr. Dickens?
04:29:17
What we've agreed to is to eliminate the first resolve.
04:29:21
We are changing the wording on the second resolve to say the further moderation of toll rates in the long term.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:29:32
Is that correct?
04:29:34
Yeah, not without the further, just will lead to the moderation.
SPEAKER_13
04:29:38
And long term is not a defined term, I don't guess.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:29:51
So the motion is to amend the base resolution.
04:29:56
Is there a second?
04:29:57
Second.
04:29:57
All in favor?
04:29:59
Aye.
04:29:59
So now the total resolution is before us.
04:30:03
Is there a motion?
04:30:05
So moved.
SPEAKER_13
04:30:06
Second.
04:30:06
All in favor?
04:30:07
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:30:08
Any opposed?
04:30:11
Thank you.
04:30:14
Okay, I believe that concludes the action.
04:30:21
Did we miss something?
04:30:26
Oh, yeah, we're getting to new business, sorry.
SPEAKER_13
04:30:31
We have two items that I'm aware of.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:30:36
The first is to approve the minutes from the last meeting.
04:30:38
I neglected doing my haste.
04:30:41
Is there a motion to approve the June meeting minutes?
04:30:44
So moved.
04:30:45
All in favor?
04:30:46
Aye.
04:30:47
Okay.
04:30:47
And then under new business, our chief financial officer at VDOT.
04:30:52
Rita Busher has a resolution that's coming around to you.
04:30:58
and really the issue is stimulus projects that have been selected by the MPOs and the fact that there's not an August CTB meeting.
Reta Busher
Chief Financial Officer
04:31:08
What we would like to do is propose a resolution that would allow the commissioner to add the sub-allocations for the five metropolitan planning organizations of $117 million of ARRA funds to allow the commissioner to
04:31:28
Add the proposed projects from those MPOs, allocating those funds to the Six-Year Improvement Program for 2010 through 15 prior to your formal approval so that we may start the process of vetting those projects, obtaining TIP amendments, STIP amendments, and getting certification
04:31:58
Up to the point of getting certification from the governor for those projects and that would take place in the rest of July and the month of August and then we would bring those back to you in September for formal approval.
04:32:15
But that would allow us to move those projects through the process and get them to the point of becoming obligated.
SPEAKER_20
04:32:26
Any questions?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:32:29
There's a motion.
04:32:30
Is there a second?
04:32:30
Second.
04:32:31
All in favor?
04:32:32
Aye.
04:32:33
Any opposed?
04:32:35
Thank you very much.
04:32:36
Okay.
04:32:37
Anybody else want to bring anything up under new business?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:32:39
Quick question, Mr. Chairman.
04:32:41
I have a question and observation.
04:32:42
One, thanks to DRPT for sending around the update that I asked about last time.
04:32:49
And second, how often is it quarterly, Mr. Commissioner, do we get updates on on-time, on-budget
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:32:56
for projects, if we have any projects left.
04:33:07
We do it as a part of our quarterly status report that we give you.
James L. Keen
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:33:13
The question is, do we have one due in July or do we have one due in July?
David S. Ekern
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:33:23
We have a choice.
04:33:24
We can study tunnels or do updates.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
04:33:30
Okay.
04:33:30
Okay.
04:33:31
Been a very long day.
04:33:32
I appreciate everybody's patience.
04:33:33
There are a lot of very serious issues discussed and decisions made today.
04:33:39
Very important start on the Midtown Tunnel.
04:33:42
I hope that we all recognize this is going to be the first of many actions required by this board and the region to keep that a priority and to keep it moving.
04:33:54
Further business, meeting's adjourned.
04:33:56
Thank you.