Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 5/15/2008
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
5/15/2008
Attachments
Meeting agenda.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
Abandonment, discontinuance and transfers in the primary and secondary highway systems.pdf
Naming the Route 602 bridge over the South Fork of the Shenandoah River at the Page_Rockingham County Line, the “William Milnes, Jr. B.pdf
Location approval, r elocated Hockman Pike, Bluefield.pdf
Economic Development Access – Scott County, Project 0980-084-670, N501 eCorridor Regional Park_Southwest.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 220 (old Route 33 and Pittsylvania, Franklin and Botetourt Turnpike), Franklin County.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 613, Nelson County.pdf
Land conveyance, Routes 724 and 742, Pittsylvania County.pdf
Land conveyance, Route 460 (old Route 23), Giles County.pdf
Route 622 (Brick Church Road), York County.pdf
Limited access control changes, Route 17, Hospital Boulevard, Route 635 (Germanna Point Drive) renumbered to Route 628, Frontage Road B.pdf
Surplus and locality land conveyances, Interstate 95_395, Route 1, Clark Street Extension, Old Jefferson Davis Highway, Arlington County.pdf
Cedar Green Road access at Route 28, Loudoun County.pdf
Discretionary maintenance payments to Richmond Metropolitan Authority.pdf
SPEAKER_06
00:00:00
Good morning, everyone.
00:00:01
I'd like to welcome everyone to the May meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:07
We have a very aggressive agenda because we do need to be out of here by 10 o'clock to get over to the Wilson Bridge.
00:00:15
Incredible celebration and ceremony.
00:00:18
As is our custom, we will begin with public comment.
00:00:22
Is there anyone here who would like to address the Commonwealth Transportation Board?
00:00:28
Oh, we have a question.
00:00:30
Thank you very much for this opportunity.
SPEAKER_02
00:00:37
I'm Delegate David Poisson.
00:00:39
I represent the 32nd House District.
00:00:42
And you have on your agenda this morning a proposal to waive the limited access designation for Route 28 to allow for ingress into Belfort Park using Cedar Green Road.
00:00:54
I am here to ask you to approve that lifting, at least temporarily.
00:01:02
The concern on the part of many of the people I represent who work and live in that area and also who shop in that area is that absent that ingress into that area,
00:01:12
Public safety personnel would be limited in terms of their access into the neighborhood.
00:01:17
If you're familiar at all with the area, it's a short piece of road that runs from 28 and used to actually be a lighted intersection that traversed 28.
00:01:24
Now it provides access into an area called Cedar Green Road and Shaw Road.
00:01:30
On that street, there are over 400 people who go to work there every day in Belleport Furniture, Lindsay Volkswagen, and Park Lumber Company, which is one of the oldest commercial businesses in Loudoun County.
00:01:44
So what we're simply asking is that because so much of what needs to be done in that area has yet to be accomplished, and also because all of the people that are around it,
00:01:55
are part of the special tax district.
00:01:57
We simply ask that you allow for this to remain open until the 13 interchanges are completed and the infrastructure that would accommodate all the traffic that comes into that area every day be attended to.
00:02:10
Thank you very much for your consideration of that request.
00:02:13
If you have any questions, I'd be glad to answer them.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:17
Thank you, Doug.
00:02:18
We'll move that up on the agenda real quick in deference to your time and thank you for coming all the way in from Loudon County to address it.
00:02:26
Anybody else want to address the Commonwealth Transportation Board?
00:02:31
If not, is there a motion to approve the minutes?
SPEAKER_08
00:02:33
So moved.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:34
All in favor?
00:02:36
Aye.
00:02:38
Backing into the agenda under the Asset Management Division, Connie Sorrell is here to answer questions on item number one.
00:02:45
There are a whole series of abandonments, discontinuations, etc.
00:02:49
Any questions for Ms. Sorrell?
00:02:54
Is there a motion on action item number one?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:02:57
Move for approval.
SPEAKER_06
00:02:58
I second.
00:02:59
All in favor?
00:03:00
Aye.
00:03:01
Action Item 2 is the renaming of the South Fork Bridge as the William Millen Sr. Bridge.
00:03:06
Is there a motion?
00:03:09
So moved.
00:03:10
Second.
00:03:11
All in favor?
00:03:12
Aye.
00:03:14
Action Item 3 is location approval for the Hochman Pike in the town of Cluesfield.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:03:20
Is there a motion?
00:03:21
Move for approval.
00:03:22
Second.
SPEAKER_06
00:03:23
All in favor?
00:03:24
Aye.
00:03:25
Action Item 4 is an Economic Development Access Agreement for Scott County.
00:03:31
Are there questions of Ms. Buescher?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:03:35
Move the approval.
00:03:35
Second.
SPEAKER_06
00:03:36
All in favor?
00:03:39
Aye.
00:03:39
Action Item 5.
00:03:47
You know what, if I might, with the concurrence of the board, I'd like to move Action Item 8 up at this point right now.
00:03:56
That's the Cedar Green issue and out of recognition of Delegate Poisson's time.
00:04:02
That is the Cedar Green Road access.
00:04:05
Mortis Asalaki is here to answer any questions if there might be any.
00:04:11
I think it's a fairly straightforward issue.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:04:14
Mr. Chairman, Mr.
00:04:16
Le, this seems to be a transition issue between the completion of 28 and the building of the additional support for that area and other areas along the way.
00:04:28
So, is this something that you've had a good chance to look at?
SPEAKER_09
00:04:32
Yes, Mr. Chairman, and members of the board, as the delegate indicated, the request in front of you is to
00:04:40
allow that writing only on a temporary basis and give the improvements identified as a part of 28 widening the construction of 13 grade separated interchange and completion of some of those privately, I'm sorry, interesting secondary roles that already have been designated in the resolution attached in front of me, when all of those are completed.
00:05:01
At that point in time, the request is, at that point in time, we will be able,
00:05:09
Well, I just want to say thank you for your flexibility and I think our resolution acknowledges the temporary solution transition but also reaffirms our intention that this be a limited access.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:05:31
So with that in mind, I would move this approval.
SPEAKER_01
00:05:34
I would second.
SPEAKER_06
00:05:36
All in favor?
00:05:38
Aye.
SPEAKER_06
00:05:38
Thank you, Delegate Poisson, and your persistence on this issue.
00:05:43
This has been about a six-month journey.
00:05:45
I appreciate your hard work and representation here.
00:05:52
Turning back to Action Item 5 under Right-of-Way and Utilities, the Chief Engineer is here to answer any questions.
00:06:02
Let me just go down and take 5A as a block.
00:06:05
Any questions on 5A?
00:06:08
Any questions on 5B?
00:06:10
Any questions on 5C?
00:06:15
Any questions on 5D?
00:06:18
Any questions on 5E?
00:06:21
Move approval of item 5, Mr. Chairman.
00:06:25
Second.
00:06:26
All in favor?
00:06:28
Aye.
00:06:28
Action item 6 is a limited access control change.
00:06:34
Mr. Kerley, could you give a brief overview of this particular issue?
SPEAKER_08
00:06:41
Yes sir, this is tied into a new hospital that is being developed in the Cuddingsburg area.
00:06:47
changed the limited access break on Route 17 and also provide a limited access break which is just a bridge coming across 95 and it will have the new hospital be developed there and tied across 95 coming back into 17.
00:07:07
A little bit below where the existing 17 and the bridge is located.
SPEAKER_06
00:07:12
And would this be consistent with our access management requirements, or does this predate those?
SPEAKER_08
00:07:18
It would predate that.
00:07:19
The access management requirements are not the grandfather's base, but everything has been changed for a long time.
SPEAKER_06
00:07:27
Is there any other questions or comments?
SPEAKER_00
00:07:30
I'm satisfied Mr. Kerley has worked on this and I appreciate that and move for approval.
00:07:36
Second.
SPEAKER_06
00:07:37
All in favor?
00:07:37
Aye.
00:07:39
Action item 7 is a locality land conveyance on Park Street in Arlington.
00:07:45
Are there any questions of Mr. Kerley?
00:07:52
Move it please.
00:07:54
Second.
00:07:54
All in favor?
00:07:55
Aye.
00:07:56
We've already accomplished action item 8.
00:07:59
Action Item 9, which is the action on discretionary maintenance payments to be made to the Richmond Metropolitan Authority.
00:08:06
We had discussed this last month at the work session.
00:08:10
Mr. McClellan.
SPEAKER_08
00:08:13
Well, I think after much upset, the RMA and the district have reached an accommodation that they can live with, so I'll conclude it.
00:08:26
All in favor?
00:08:29
Aye.
00:08:29
All right.
SPEAKER_06
00:08:31
You've done great work this morning.
00:08:37
Mr. Coburn.
00:08:40
Good morning.
00:08:42
Good morning, sir.
00:08:43
Is this a good month?
00:08:44
You're the first one to add money.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:08:45
An average month.
00:08:46
It's been a pretty good month, sir.
00:08:48
Interest remains high on all of our bids, with multiple bidders receiving on both.
00:08:54
On the 23rd of April, we received 33 bids, five of which were over $2 million, which were presented to you today after analysis.
00:09:05
The first one on page one is a thin lift
00:09:10
Plant Mix Overlay on 95.
00:09:14
We don't traditionally receive a lot of bids on that type of work, but we did get two.
00:09:19
They are good bids, and we recommend it's approval.
SPEAKER_06
00:09:25
All in favor?
00:09:26
Excuse me, is there a motion?
SPEAKER_04
00:09:27
Move.
SPEAKER_06
00:09:29
All in favor?
SPEAKER_04
00:09:30
Aye.
00:09:32
Mr. Chairman?
00:09:34
I just have a question of Mr. Coburn.
00:09:36
This is essentially an asphalt contract.
00:09:39
and I'm just looking at the bid amount there and it's substantially lower than the estimate.
00:09:48
I've just been hearing a lot about how with oil prices going up, asphalt prices inevitably growing up and this is I mean very good looks to me like it's very good news if I'm reading this right I'm sort of curious what
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:10:02
The dollars there sort of sell a missed story, if you will, because the scope of the project when it was originally conceived and funded was for a different type of product in the asphalt overlay.
00:10:20
much thicker depth, et cetera.
00:10:23
Pavement analysis showed that the surface course was the problem, not the base course, and so we're attempting to validate thin lift protection of the base.
00:10:36
And so the scope changed significantly here.
00:10:40
But that said, as we went through the analysis with what is sort of a unique product, we believe it still is a very good value.
00:10:53
And this is a significant length of that section of roadway.
SPEAKER_04
00:10:57
Great, thank you.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:10:59
Okay, page two.
00:11:02
Page two, the first project, there is the
00:11:08
In Rockbridge County, we're going through the bridge over the Maury at Glasgow.
00:11:14
As you'll note, we received nine bids on that project.
00:11:20
This project has been in our plan for a long time.
00:11:23
It's a much needed project.
00:11:26
We do have a good estimate.
00:11:28
We do have money to process the project and execute, and we recommend its approval.
SPEAKER_01
00:11:34
How did it improve, Mr. Chairman?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:11:36
The second project there in Henry County is a construction-funded pavement restoration rehabilitation project with safety upgrades.
00:11:52
We received two bids, they are very good bids, and we recommend their approval.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:58
Why would this be a construction fund project versus a maintenance fund project?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:12:04
The amount of reconstruction work and rehabilitation work is sort of the dividing line between what we can do with restorative maintenance or normal repaying or reconstruction and this crosses the line into a reconstruction
SPEAKER_06
00:12:29
The next project is secondary, also in Henry County.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:12:51
Vented the system for a good while.
00:12:54
We did receive nine bids.
00:12:55
You can see we're attracting some out-of-state contractors as well.
00:13:00
Very attractive bid.
00:13:02
We recommend it's approved.
00:13:11
The last of the normal projects there is a pavement marking and message raised pavement marker project.
00:13:20
Maintenance funded in the Northern Virginia area in various routes.
00:13:26
Two bids, they do represent good pricing and we recommend they're approved.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:31
I move it's approved.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:13:33
All in favor?
00:13:36
Aye.
00:13:36
The last item is a pink sheet of a locally administered project in Virginia Beach that we received today.
00:13:46
This is the tying together of the traffic network, traffic signal network, and this is the second phase that they have undertaken.
00:13:55
If you'll note again here, we had six bidders in the Virginia Beach area, primarily electrical contractors, and we agreed with the city that it's a good bid, recommend it's approved.
SPEAKER_08
00:14:10
Second.
SPEAKER_06
00:14:11
All in favor?
00:14:12
Aye.
00:14:14
Thank you, Jack.
00:14:16
Anybody want to bring anything up on your new business?
SPEAKER_07
00:14:19
Mr. Dickens?
00:14:21
I don't want to get into it today, but I'd like to
00:14:25
I have some time on our next agenda to talk about some of the things that we talked about yesterday relative to what the transportation of the future is going to look like, what this board needs to be doing and what the Commonwealth needs to be doing to react to some of the things we heard yesterday from the AASHTO and so forth.
00:14:49
I'd like for us to have some discussions on that if we could, please.
SPEAKER_06
00:14:55
Commissioner, it might not be a bad idea to see if Dr. Tisher maybe could just give a brief outline, maybe four or five issues so we're not all over the playing field, and maybe some either linked or hard copy articles.
00:15:11
to assist people in thinking on that, but some of the things we know that were discussed is, you know, the cost of maintaining the existing system, and what's that look like?
00:15:21
We have very good data on that.
00:15:23
What are the impacts of rising fuel prices?
00:15:27
We know there's diminished demand, but it changes the travel mix.
00:15:34
The interrelationship of transportation in land use, there's been a lot of time talking about that.
00:15:40
I thought probably the most interesting and challenging concept that Mr. Shennerdorf talked about were those sort of regional corridors, regional and national, since not as we talk about them as a state level.
00:15:53
And something that we've talked about professionally for a long time is the fact that high or higher speed rail is really not a substitute for highway travel, it's a substitute for air travel.
00:16:07
And if you look at the future of the aviation industry, there may be some balancing out there.
00:16:15
So we'll see if we can figure out perhaps some way of thinking about those.
00:16:22
We may also want to talk about, for example, in that context, we hosted a meeting of the I-81 corridor states, what about three weeks ago now?
00:16:33
We invited all the secretaries of those states, and the thinking of it as a framework, that may be another way to think about it.
00:16:42
Obviously, the Northeast corridor, where does it start?
00:16:45
Does it start in D.C. or does it start in Richmond?
00:16:47
That's a very powerful and profound question for us.
00:16:51
Are there any other kind of meeting?
00:16:54
We don't want to drown people with information and we do have the adoption of the six-year program at the gym meeting and that needs to be the principal focus of that meeting.
SPEAKER_01
00:17:04
I just wanted to say a word about that I-81 quarter meeting.
00:17:09
I felt like for the first time in all the discussions that I've heard, and I've come to some of this new in the last few years,
00:17:17
that we were hearing the big picture for what happens with 81 and with the whole idea of moving freight throughout that entire corridor and I found it exciting to hear the secretaries of transportation from how many jurisdictions?
00:17:30
Five or six?
00:17:33
All saying the same thing that what we need to do and willingness to cooperate, willingness to even invest in money
00:17:39
I think all the states together perhaps can cause something to happen that we couldn't do by ourselves even as we try to address the individual parts.
00:17:57
So I enjoyed being a part of that.
SPEAKER_06
00:18:01
OK.
00:18:02
Anything else that we think ought to be?
00:18:04
Yes, sir.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:05
Mr. Chairman, I just wanted to take a minute to reflect on some of the things that we heard last night.
00:18:11
At our public hearing, we heard, as you realize, that there's a very large need for transportation investments in Northern Virginia and indeed in the rest of the state.
00:18:22
We heard that there was a great feeling from the local officials who represent the jurisdictions here about how important
00:18:29
Koelemay, John J. D.
00:18:36
Vigorousness of Commerce here.
00:18:40
But you also heard an extraordinary commitment from those local officials that I hope the Commonwealth will be able to match as we go forward.
00:18:49
There really is a driving force here to see something done that puts us on a better course with regard to transportation finance, system performance, and so forth.
00:19:00
And then finally, I think you heard an extraordinary civility from officials that
00:19:05
In many ways, ought to be much more frustrated about the situation they find themselves in.
00:19:11
The state being as uncertain a partner in this area as it has been.
00:19:18
But there's also a spirit of connection and of community and of collaboration that exists there and that really goes deep.
00:19:24
It's something that really is changing the nature of the discussion here in Northern Virginia.
00:19:28
Rather than jurisdictions seeing the pie as a finite something that has to be fought over, there's an understanding that it can be expanded whether it is roads, rail, transit, and so forth.
00:19:40
And I would hope that some of that spirit of connection and collaboration and commitment
00:19:46
can really be reflected at the state level.
00:19:49
I think this body has gone a long way towards showing the state that that can happen, that you can have a civil discussion, you can have differences, and you can bring them together.
00:20:01
But I hope that's some things that you all take from your visit to Northern Virginia, not just the pent-up demand, but really the commitment to find solutions and to make things work.
00:20:12
So I'm pleased that you were here, and I'm pleased that you could
00:20:15
Here's such a good cross-section of what people are thinking.
SPEAKER_06
00:20:20
Any other comments under new business?
SPEAKER_00
00:20:22
And I would like to support what Doug has just said and also bring to everybody's attention the amount of interest that is in our multimodal system and making it a system where transit, both commuter transit and or commuter rail connections and also local transit operations are such key to making the system work up here and I think we have a lot of
00:20:47
opportunities to expand and enhance those programs, particularly with four dollars a gallon gasoline, but we do need to pay attention to their needs, both capital and operating, and I think the local people made a good case for that as well.
SPEAKER_06
00:21:09
Okay, if there's no further action
00:21:11
We're going to adjourn the business meeting, and then Jeff Caldwell is going to tell us about arrangements this morning for the ceremony, which starts at 11.
SPEAKER_08
00:21:23
There's a folder right in front of you there that has parking passes, a map, and a detailed breakdown of the event.
SPEAKER_02
00:21:31
Is that what you're going to do?
SPEAKER_06
00:21:32
Okay, does everybody have that or just me?
SPEAKER_02
00:21:33
You have copies in there for, there's kind of copies in there for those that are driving and those that are on the up.
SPEAKER_06
00:21:40
How many people are going on the bus?
00:21:47
Either Willie or driving separately?
SPEAKER_00
00:21:51
Driving separately should be made for a parking pass.
SPEAKER_06
00:21:55
And if you're not, the last shuttle bus leaves at 1030.
00:22:02
So you cannot be late, and there's a snarling of traffic.
00:22:06
And if you're not familiar, it's just like getting to this hotel.
00:22:09
It was a little bit of a challenge last night.
00:22:11
It will absolutely be the same down there at the bridge location.
00:22:16
Where are the staging areas?
00:22:19
Where should people go for those who are driving separately?
SPEAKER_08
00:22:23
Mr. Secretary, if people were driving, I would suggest, I just talked to Nick Nicholson, he goes back up to Springfield, so I would go down seminary at Route 7, go into Alexandria, and then follow the map there, and then here you go.
SPEAKER_06
00:22:40
I'll show you exactly what he does.
00:22:43
For those who are driving, if you carefully retrace your steps that you got in here last night, go out to Seminary Road and you'll turn left and you'll go to what's known as King Street or Route 7 and about two and a half, three miles.
00:23:02
Turn right on King Street.
00:23:05
That will take you down into Old Town Alexandria.
00:23:08
And then where is the parking area?
SPEAKER_08
00:23:12
On the bridge?
00:23:13
It's on the bridge.
00:23:14
The map shows you.
00:23:15
It shows you downtown Alexandria Square.
SPEAKER_06
00:23:20
You have the drawing.
00:23:21
So do you get on at Route 154?
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:28
So Dr. Davis is going to have lunch for him.
SPEAKER_06
00:23:31
That's right.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:34
So that was supposed to go left instead of right.
SPEAKER_06
00:23:41
That good Italian restaurant would be home.
00:23:50
Oh yeah, I know that path.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:05
I live in Springfield, so as I approach 9 o'clock, I can tell if there's a big accident or not because it's like, wow, window locked, that still is one of the more dramatic things tonight.
SPEAKER_06
00:24:24
I don't know if you can attempt to describe this, but here's the deal.
00:24:35
I suggest that if you have GPS, you press this in your system and leave yourself plenty of extra time.
00:24:44
You will actually be getting up on the bridge and you'll be going up and exit ramp, you're going backwards.
00:24:50
Mr. Kim, I think I know the answer to this already, but do we have any idea how long this program will last?
00:25:17
I believe it's about 45 minutes.
00:25:22
The detail program has us over by 12.17, so an hour and 17 minutes.
SPEAKER_08
00:25:28
Those of us that need to catch a 2 o'clock train, that leaves us time to do so.
SPEAKER_06
00:25:31
And where are you catching that?
00:25:33
Union Station.
00:25:34
Ooh.
00:25:35
That looks simple.
SPEAKER_08
00:25:36
If we're over by 12, yeah, you'll make it.
00:25:38
I was going to take the shuttle back over here and then go down 395.
J. Douglas Koelemay
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:43
What time would the shuttle get back here?
00:25:44
12.30?
00:25:46
Ooh, you're pushing it.
SPEAKER_00
00:25:49
Last time it took us three and a half hours.
SPEAKER_06
00:25:52
Well, I'm going to miss the train on any circuit now.
00:25:54
Which train?
00:25:55
Are you catching the cargo?
SPEAKER_08
00:25:56
No, the Excella.
SPEAKER_06
00:25:58
Oh, you're going north?
SPEAKER_08
00:25:59
Yeah.
00:25:59
Right.
SPEAKER_06
00:26:01
Oh, there's another one in 30 minutes.
00:26:05
Thank you, sir.
00:26:07
North of D.C. you don't have bad trains.
00:26:09
That's right.
00:26:11
And I think for those of you who don't live in Northern Virginia, this is such a good indicator of what it is like.
00:26:18
It is so difficult to predict
00:26:21
How do you get from A to B in a reliable, predictable way?
00:26:26
People live with us, whether it's a big ceremony like Winter Wilson Bridge, they live with us every day on daycare, soccer games, getting to and from work.
00:26:35
Probably a good lesson for all of us in that regard.
00:26:40
So what I'm going to do here is a detailed map
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:26:47
Here's a detailed schedule, and here are parking passes that will get you up and down to the VIP park.
SPEAKER_06
00:26:55
Okay?
00:26:56
Thank you, and hopefully I'll see you all in luck.