Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 4/17/2008
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   4/17/2008

Attachments
  • Meeting agenda.pdf
  • Meeting minutes.pdf
  • Through truck restriction, Route 193, Georgetown Pike, Fairfax County.pdf
  • Through tractor truck semitrailer combinations restriction, Route 7 Business (Main St.) Berryville and Clarke County.pdf
  • Virginia Byway Designation_ Routes 340, 211, 616, 636, and 650, Page County.pdf
  • Economic development access, Lunenburg County, Project 0780-055-705, N501, Woodland Business Park.pdf
  • Revenue-Sharing Program policy.pdf
  • Location approval, Atkinson Boulevard, Newport News.pdf
  • Location of extension of limited access, I-81 Exit 47 interchange and Rifton Road, Smyth County.pdf
  • Land conveyance, Route 11 and old Route 11 (Valley Turnpike), Shenandoah County.pdf
  • Land conveyance, Route 1110 (Houston Street), Halifax County.pdf
  • Land conveyance, Route 604, Charlotte County.pdf
  • Land conveyance, Route 780 (Canon Way) and Route 781 (Industrial Drive), Gloucester County.pdf
  • Issuance and sale of Transportation Capital Projects Revenue Bonds.pdf
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning, everyone.
    • 00:00:02
      My name is Pierce Homer, and I have the pleasure and honor of serving as Secretary of Transportation and Chair of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:00:13
      This morning, we're going to continue the work section items.
    • 00:00:17
      We have one item left over from guests today.
    • 00:00:21
      It should take about 15 minutes.
    • 00:00:22
      And then we're going to go into our business agenda and we will start that business agenda with public commentary as is our custom.
    • 00:00:31
      Before we do that, however, I do want to recognize two individuals.
    • 00:00:36
      First, the Commissioner and then to be followed by some welcome remarks by the Mayor of the City of Pittsburgh who is able to join us this morning.
    • 00:00:44
      Commissioner?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:45
      Thank you.
    • 00:00:46
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of CTB.
    • 00:00:48
      Ladies and gentlemen, there's a display in the room here this morning that I wanted to call people's attention to.
    • 00:00:54
      Last week, we commemorated work zone safety week nationally, and that is a period throughout the country where we try to highlight
    • 00:01:07
      Not only the contributions that professionals and road workers make both on the private and public sector side but oftentimes in those events or in those activities we lose lives because those are dangerous areas as we all know both for the workers and for people who drive through those work zones.
    • 00:01:31
      So last week throughout the country
    • 00:01:33
      There were a series of these commemorations that went on.
    • 00:01:38
      In the Commonwealth, on Monday the 7th, we commemorated our work zone events at a rest area or at a lookout that we have on I-64.
    • 00:01:52
      As you drive on I-64 toward Charlottesville from I-81, you'll see on the side of the road there's a monument.
    • 00:02:01
      On that monument, which was
    • 00:02:03
      constructed through all donations.
    • 00:02:06
      You'll find the name of all employees that have been killed in the line of duty.
    • 00:02:14
      As a part of that, these cones represent the nine operating districts of the department and our central office and our key partner in this commemoration last week, BTCA, the Virginia Transportation
    • 00:02:34
      Construction Association.
    • 00:02:38
      And it's significant because you'll see that the employees of every district have signed those cones.
    • 00:02:48
      So if you go through each of those 11 cones, you'll find 8315 names on those cones.
    • 00:02:55
      And I wanted the CTB to be able to
    • 00:02:58
      See that commitment that our people make before we return them to the districts.
    • 00:03:03
      This was a labor of love by the employees and very frankly, I'm really proud to be associated with a professional group that does that.
    • 00:03:11
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:03:13
      Thank you, Commissioner.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:03:15
      At this point, I'd like to recognize our
    • 00:03:19
      The sponsoring entity, which is the City of Lynchburg and the wonderful Mayor Joan Foster.
    • 00:03:25
      Mayor, if you would like to come up and say a few words of welcome.
    • 00:03:29
      I know you have large and unmet needs here in the city.
    • 00:03:32
      We heard about them loud and clear on the bus tour yesterday, but we do welcome your comments.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:03:37
      Well, thank you so much.
    • 00:03:39
      I really want to welcome you, Secretary Warner, Commissioner Ekern, Director Tucker, and distinguished members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:03:50
      We're so thrilled that you have selected our fine city to hold your conference.
    • 00:03:56
      It's just a pleasure to have you here.
    • 00:03:57
      I'm sorry I couldn't join the tour yesterday.
    • 00:04:01
      I do have a daytime job, and that called me.
    • 00:04:04
      But I'm happy that you were able to do that.
    • 00:04:07
      I understand some took walking tours as well.
    • 00:04:11
      And being in our downtown, we're very proud of the things that we have done downtown.
    • 00:04:16
      And I know there's a lot more to do.
    • 00:04:19
      That's sort of a pickler to tell you to please come back and visit us, you know, just on your leisure time.
    • 00:04:26
      It's my pleasure, as I said, to welcome you to our city and to the Greater Region 2000 because we definitely are a region and I'm a member of the Executive Council and I'm so proud of our region and we are more and more getting our acts together and working together which can only benefit our entire region when we do that.
    • 00:04:48
      Some of you have had that opportunity to tour our beautiful region.
    • 00:04:52
      So not only did you tour Lynchburg, you toured our region yesterday.
    • 00:04:56
      And I hope that was an enjoyable tour.
    • 00:05:00
      I know that you heard from the area managers on your tour yesterday and during the public hearing last night about the transportation needs of the region.
    • 00:05:13
      I was told I might could go on a bit about that.
    • 00:05:17
      You know, you heard last night and I really do feel that you heard from the best sources and I won't belabor that but please remember that.
    • 00:05:30
      You have a challenging task in time of inadequate revenue
    • 00:05:36
      E. D.
    • 00:05:53
      We are glad we did do that reserve.
    • 00:06:11
      Despite these difficulties, though, I hope that you will be able to engage in some innovative thinking to address the transportation needs
    • 00:06:21
      of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:06:22
      And it's going to probably be very innovative and creative considering the times that we are in.
    • 00:06:28
      I believe, though, that you're going to hear later today about some opportunities for enhanced passenger rail service to this area.
    • 00:06:37
      And I encourage you to support such alternatives to complement the highway system.
    • 00:06:45
      You know, at one time, we did run on the rails.
    • 00:06:49
      A lot of rails came through our area so that is a very huge interest of mine and I hope that you all will seriously consider that.
    • 00:06:58
      Allow me to acknowledge to Secretary Horner and to Commissioner Eklund the good relationship that the local government in this region have with VDOT Lynchburg District.
    • 00:07:12
      We value our partnership with VDOT and only adequate
    • 00:07:18
      funding would make it better.
    • 00:07:21
      Finally, I want to thank our own CTB member, Ken White, for his service to our community and to the Commonwealth for bringing you to Lynchburg for this meeting.
    • 00:07:36
      I thank you.
    • 00:07:40
      Enjoy your stay and I do hope that you come back
    • 00:07:44
      And I hope you have an enjoyable visit, as I said.
    • 00:07:47
      And please check out our downtown and come back for pleasure.
    • 00:07:51
      And I would be available to give a personal tour at any time.
    • 00:07:56
      So thank you so much for your dedication as well to the Commonwealth.
    • 00:08:01
      Because you know, what we do is not easy.
    • 00:08:04
      And it's getting harder.
    • 00:08:07
      So I appreciate everything you do in your volunteer spirit.
    • 00:08:11
      Thank you so much.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:13
      Thank you, Mayor.
    • 00:08:17
      Okay, continuing on from yesterday's work session, the final item was an overview of the six-year maintenance and operations budget, and Connie Sorrell is presenting.
    • 00:08:34
      Welcome, Ms. Sorrell.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:08:59
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary and members of the board.
    • 00:09:10
      I have a fairly short presentation about the budget for maintenance and operations.
    • 00:09:17
      You may remember last year for the first time we included
    • 00:09:20
      An item in the transportation six-year plan that shows the estimate for funding for the next six years for maintenance and operations for each district.
    • 00:09:32
      I'm going to go through just a few of the highlights.
    • 00:09:36
      I just want to start out with
    • 00:09:37
      A few definitions, sometimes it's not always clear what the difference between maintenance and operations and construction may be.
    • 00:09:47
      We usually refer to ordinary maintenance as those things that just keep things running, thinking about changing the oil in your car.
    • 00:09:56
      These are just your basic everyday things.
    • 00:10:00
      Mowing the ditches, mowing grass, cleaning ditches and those kinds of things and some preventative equipment maintenance.
    • 00:10:09
      Maintenance rehabilitation usually is used to refer to repairing an asset or trying to extend its life.
    • 00:10:18
      So pavement milling and overlay, some bridge, superstructure rehabilitation, repairing decks, those kinds of things.
    • 00:10:25
      and some small things, replacement types of activities like pipe replacement.
    • 00:10:31
      Maintenance reconstruction is one of those areas where it begins to get a little fuzzy when things go from being maintenance to being full reconstruction.
    • 00:10:41
      And as you can see in the six-year plan, there are an awful lot of bridge projects that are really the replacement of old bridges that the maintenance program just isn't financially equipped to handle under the maintenance moniker.
    • 00:10:55
      So we think about maintenance reconstruction as when it becomes time to restore an asset to its original condition after its life cycle has followed.
    • 00:11:04
      So bridge replacements, large scale deck replacements, complete reconstruction of major sections of pavements are the types of things we think about when we think about maintenance reconstruction.
    • 00:11:18
      And increasingly these projects are being done by
    • 00:11:21
      The construction side of the house.
    • 00:11:25
      Operations, we think about in terms of just operating the network, trying to make it more efficient, the typical traffic engineering types of work, signal optimization efforts, operating the ferries, the tunnels, rest areas.
    • 00:11:39
      We have 41 rest areas.
    • 00:11:40
      Takes a little money to keep them looking nice.
    • 00:11:43
      and also all of our traveler information programs and safety service patrols and incident management, things we do in that arena.
    • 00:11:54
      So probably the one message I would hope that you take away today is in this,
    • 00:12:02
      in this chart.
    • 00:12:04
      This is the difference between the raw dollars and the blue line where we have been getting increasing funding for maintenance and operations over the last several years.
    • 00:12:16
      Back in 2005, there was actually about a $100 million jump from 2004 to 2005, particularly for
    • 00:12:24
      We did spend that money in pavement work and continue to do that.
    • 00:12:30
      However, if you were to look at the cost of fuel and petroleum products like asphalt, you would see that over the last three or four years, we've lost about 35% of our buying power.
    • 00:12:45
      and so we are working very hard to try and continue to meet our performance standards and targets that we have for pavements and bridges but as you can see our ability to do that is declining so we're trying to make the very best
    • 00:13:03
      The decision, as economically as we can, is becoming increasingly more difficult.
    • 00:13:10
      During this time period of 2004 to 2007-2008, the price of a ton of asphalt has gone from about $62 or $3 to over $90.
    • 00:13:22
      So that's really depicted in the next slide that shows you back in 2004 a mile of a normal overlay for a road was about $35,000 a mile and last year that same mile
    • 00:13:40
      took $54,000.
    • 00:13:42
      So the numbers for 08 aren't in yet.
    • 00:13:47
      I think we still have a couple of bids for Brian maybe reporting those.
    • 00:13:51
      He can tell you a little bit more about where the 08 numbers are going, but they're not going down.
    • 00:13:58
      So I think the price of oil now has reached about $113 a barrel.
    • 00:14:04
      So that's not good news.
    • 00:14:09
      This is just a chart to show you really the overview.
    • 00:14:13
      I think the Secretary used this in a presentation to the General Assembly.
    • 00:14:20
      that just shows where the whole transportation program is going.
    • 00:14:24
      We now have about 1.2 billion dollars in the maintenance program and you can see how it's distributed among the nine districts and for the statewide programs at the very end.
    • 00:14:37
      Local government payments for city street maintenance is now about 325 million.
    • 00:14:44
      Rayland Public Transportation, 358 million, and the construction program for 2008 was about 1.3.
    • 00:14:52
      So you can see that the maintenance program is every bit as large, and now with the reduced revenue, it's going to be overtaking the construction program in terms of the total budget.
    • 00:15:09
      The next slide just breaks down for you by the interstate, primary, secondary operations and our management direction overhead budgets, how much money we're spending in each of these categories.
    • 00:15:26
      So you can see about $276 million of that goes to interstate maintenance, primary and secondary are each getting $373 million and $80 million.
    • 00:15:36
      We're spending a little over $122 million for the transportation operations, which include the traffic management centers, safety service controls, all the tunnels and ferries.
    • 00:15:50
      And then the management direction is broken up between the field, which is about $70 million, and the central office, which is about $15 million, for a total of $1.25.
    • 00:16:05
      It gives you an idea from a system standpoint about what it takes to, what we're spending, how we're spending the money by system to maintain the network and operate it.
    • 00:16:17
      This is the update proposal for
    • 00:16:21
      2009-2014 budget by district and what we've done this year is we've tried to take the money, you may remember last year we set aside 2%.
    • 00:16:33
      We didn't distribute all 4% of the increase in the out years.
    • 00:16:42
      because we knew that as we do our condition assessments and improve the inventory information we have about the condition of the system.
    • 00:16:53
      There are some changes and so we wanted to be able to make sure that we could make adjustments with that small amount of increase without having to reduce any district's budget as we move forward.
    • 00:17:07
      So for 09 and 010 we have distributed all but 1% holding that back as a part of our emergency contingency fund and so in out years 11 through 14 there's still about a 2% reserve and that 4% that
    • 00:17:23
      We'll go to the field, but we're going to wait to distribute it until we get a little better information as we get closer to those years.
    • 00:17:33
      As you can see, the budget is going to be going from about $1.5 billion, which includes the payments to localities, to a little over $2 billion by 2014.
    • 00:17:45
      I'd be happy to answer any questions about the budget.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:52
      A couple of different ones.
    • 00:17:53
      You mentioned the asphalt costs today and you weren't sure where they are, but I'm going to go through the books that we got yesterday and some of the bids we received earlier.
    • 00:18:01
      It looks like a lot of the construction costs are going down.
    • 00:18:04
      That's not coming from the asphalt?
    • 00:18:06
      Do you know which elements it's coming from?
    • 00:18:08
      Is that just labor and other materials?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:18:10
      I don't know.
    • 00:18:11
      Probably Byron Coburn, who will be up shortly, is our state construction engineer, and he's much more knowledgeable.
    • 00:18:18
      You know, a lot of commodities worldwide continue to increase, largely because of demands in China and India.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:25
      And then on your last chart, you showed the maintenance and you see some of them across board.
    • 00:18:30
      And in a couple of cases, let's take Bristol and Salem, FY09, FY10.
    • 00:18:36
      Those do not go up between the two years.
    • 00:18:38
      They're level funded.
    • 00:18:40
      Whereas you look at, say, Lynchburg, it goes from 84 to 93.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:18:44
      We have a fairly rigorous quantitative process for looking at all the interstate primary and secondary pavements.
    • 00:18:59
      E. J. D.
    • 00:19:18
      So where you see a district not going up, they either have, their system is in relatively good condition and when we look at distributing the money based on equity of needs, so for the total number of needs,
    • 00:19:35
      If we had $1.5 billion worth of needs to meet those performance targets, we'd look at what each district's share of those needs are and distribute the money according to their share of the needs.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:19:47
      So these sort of targeted to specific maintenance projects and that's what you're able to say, okay, to do these projects is going to cost this much and it's not sort of a, well, you get 10% and you get 15%.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:19:59
      Statewide level, we don't identify the specific project, but we have the information available for the district to identify that specific allocation.
    • 00:20:08
      In September of 2007, the department
    • 00:20:16
      We did a report which was required by code to the General Assembly and the Board and the Secretary on what every two years we have an official report we do on what the needs are to meet the performance targets and this past year for 08 the needs were right around 1.49 billion dollars so obviously some of those needs are met from the construction program so as you can see many of the bridges that are going to be fixed will add to
    • 00:20:45
      The improvement in the bridge conditions which will help take some of the pressure off of the maintenance program.
    • 00:20:53
      So, I hope that helps.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:59
      Mr. Chairman, I have a question about slide five.
    • 00:21:04
      It gives us an interesting breakdown of the relative importance of the various systems and allocations by district.
    • 00:21:11
      But what I wonder is, do you use
    • 00:21:14
      Is this being benchmarked against sort of a preferred set of allocations or does having this information then drive strategic discussions about potential adjustments like Northern Virginia, for example, is light on maintenance but heavy on rail or vice versa, or is this just for our information?
    • 00:21:37
      This isn't the aggregate to plot the trends and just see vis-a-vis the needs of a district.
    • 00:21:42
      We may be doing too much in one area and not enough in another.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:21:47
      Mr. Secretary, answer that.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:49
      I might just give a little bit of historical context.
    • 00:21:53
      Back in 2002, when maintenance had been flatlined over the six-year program, a legitimate question was asked by this body.
    • 00:22:02
      Well, doesn't it cost you a little bit more to maintain a highway, particularly at the age, and indeed that was true on the face of it.
    • 00:22:12
      What was begun was a very significant analytical effort, first by VDOT, then was put into the codes and requirements that all modes identify their maintenance needs first, whether it's ports, airports, highways, rail, transit, and maintenance.
    • 00:22:28
      It's actually a relatively easy thing for an airport to develop assets that are behind a fence.
    • 00:22:37
      The Department of Railroad Transportation has worked with providers to develop a very significant asset management system.
    • 00:22:44
      Nobody has done more, though, in a very large, nearly 60,000-mile, 20,000-mile network than VDOT to identify assets, what do we own, and then what is the condition.
    • 00:22:58
      It has taken until last year, so almost five years, to really develop a reliable database for interstate, for primary, for secondary.
    • 00:23:11
      We're also working with the localities to develop complicated performance measures for the local states, the urban states.
    • 00:23:21
      That's been a little bit of a struggle because they're in a different place and they typically have a particular city infrastructure.
    • 00:23:27
      The bottom line, though, is that we now have enough of a sampling process and a methodology in place to be able to project out what it will take to keep, and really the key is, what percentage of new pavements are to be deficient.
    • 00:23:45
      I believe that stands about 19%.
    • 00:23:47
      18%.
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:23:48
      18 is the target.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:50
      There's a similar standard for braziness.
    • 00:23:53
      There's a similar standard for drainage.
    • 00:23:56
      There's a similar standard for on-payshell.
    • 00:23:59
      There's a similar standard for guardrail.
    • 00:24:00
      There's a similar standard for striping.
    • 00:24:03
      And what we have done over time is to move away from a system where in 2002 everybody got X percent more than they did the previous year.
    • 00:24:15
      And there was a complete disconnect between the allocation of maintenance dollars and the actual need.
    • 00:24:21
      And the thing we do know about maintenance, it will change over time depending on age, weather events, and traffic values, weight of vehicles in particular.
    • 00:24:33
      and so those mean assessments are updated every year for all of those asset categories.
    • 00:24:41
      I think it's fair to say we have excellent data on bridges, interstate and primary.
    • 00:24:46
      The secondary system is so large though that those numbers do tend to swing because there's a statistical sampling exercise for them.
    • 00:24:55
      That gets built into a need-based formula which I'm guessing by the second or third year we're 100%
    • 00:25:01
      There were a number of districts that were held harmless, so when you see districts that are held flat in the early years of that secure maintenance program, that is the phase-in process to move away from the allocating basis of what we've done over many decades versus a true needs-based allocation.
    • 00:25:21
      Is it year three of this year, of this secure program where it's entirely needs-based?
    • Constance S. SorrellChief of System Operations
    • 00:25:28
      Yes, it is.
    • 00:25:30
      I think I understand it.
    • 00:25:31
      Yes, we're at the point where each district, I think, will have 99% of their share of the needs and of the funding based on their share of the needs.
    • 00:25:42
      So, yes, it's always a little struggle that they kind of shift just a little bit back and forth, but we're closing the gap finally between those who had enough or more than what they needed as opposed to those who were somewhat behind.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:56
      And this is a very, very important milestone if you look at this surface transportation spending snapshot.
    • 00:26:04
      You have VDOT maintenance and mortality maintenance in every district but for one.
    • 00:26:09
      More is being spent on maintenance than construction.
    • 00:26:12
      That one district is Northern Virginia.
    • 00:26:15
      If you took Woodrow Wilson Bridge out of Northern Virginia, Northern Virginia too would be spending more on maintenance than construction.
    • 00:26:21
      And so we are in a situation rapidly
    • 00:26:25
      You've all seen the chart.
    • 00:26:27
      We're spending more on maintenance, less on construction.
    • 00:26:31
      What's that mean?
    • 00:26:32
      That means not only new, not new capacity, but as Ms. Sorrell pointed out initially, that the very significant replacement, so when a bridge, Wilson Bridge near Mr. Koelemay, when it reaches the end of its use for life, that's too expensive for the maintenance program.
    • 00:26:51
      And so those big replacement projects are funded through the Six-Year Program.
    • 00:26:56
      There's less money available for that.
    • 00:26:59
      And that's the dilemma we face.
    • 00:27:01
      So it's not just that we've got this contrast between maintenance and construction, which is a very important dynamic.
    • 00:27:10
      But when you have shrinking construction dollars, you have shrinking replacement dollars.
    • 00:27:17
      So a major tunnel rehabilitation, a major bridge, a concrete highway, say 295 in the Richmond District at former 664 at Hampton Roads where you have pavement, you're 66 outside of the beltway.
    • 00:27:33
      Those are so big and so expensive they cannot be accommodated in the maintenance program.
    • 00:27:39
      And we're now where the ordinary maintenance is outpacing our ability to do that.
    • 00:27:43
      And remember Mr. Wallace's presentation on bridges, the demographic bulge that I think someone says, boy, that's like my retirement age.
    • 00:27:53
      It's very, very true.
    • 00:27:55
      So we face a two-pronged dilemma.
    • 00:27:58
      As our maintenance costs go up, construction goes down, we know we can't do capacity enhancements, the turn lanes, the widening, the interchanges that help mobility.
    • 00:28:08
      We also have less ability to do those replacements of bridges and highways.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:28:17
      Mr. Chairman, I'm pleased to hear that.
    • 00:28:19
      And the reason I brought it up is I think as we build these
    • 00:28:25
      databases and gather the information and begin to have a true picture, our ability to mine that information and understand that, you know, things that are happening in one place differ from another place that whether it's pavement, you know, life or whether it's accident data or whatever that will give us a lot of guidance going forward as opposed to just our intuitive field for how things may be working.
    • 00:28:52
      So I'm encouraged that we're actually on this track and
    • 00:28:56
      I look forward to kind of having that additional tool in our kit.
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:29:03
      If I may, I'd like to just quickly, is there a hint?
    • 00:29:11
      As you think about moving forward, last month I briefed the board on an event that occurred in February.
    • 00:29:19
      If you tie that back to Ms. Sorrell's
    • 00:29:23
      This is the first slide this morning where she showed you four categories of how we think about what we do.
    • 00:29:29
      We take the top category called ordinary maintenance and the bottom category called operations.
    • 00:29:37
      The impact of the events that we've been having in freeway closures, snow and ice control, if you combine those two, it really defines our everyday service components.
    • 00:29:51
      that we have to provide on the existing system.
    • 00:29:56
      Next month I will bring to the board the long range investment plan to enhance our emergency response capacity and capability which will affect the dollars in those two categories.
    • 00:30:12
      So while we tend to want to think about the pavement and what we need to do, there is a price tag for service and that is
    • 00:30:21
      And as I briefed the board last month, we're going to try to rearrange funding within the service component of that maintenance budget that we all think of as maintenance budget to make sure that our emergency response capability is there, that the message signs work, that all the other tools that we need to be able to respond to freeway closures, snow and ice,
    • 00:30:51
      Hurricanes are in place and in top condition.
    • 00:30:57
      So this kind of affects this system as you move forward, and we need to be aware of that, and we'll give you the price tag around that as we move forward.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:31:10
      Okay, any other questions or comments?
    • 00:31:12
      I would say this is a very, very important part of our oversight responsibilities, and I think over the course of the year we're going to continue to look at the data and the down-the-line facts.
    • 00:31:25
      This was done by the seat of the pants six, seven years ago.
    • 00:31:30
      It's a very professionally run organization, but it's important to understand the analysis and the assumptions.
    • 00:31:36
      Thank you.
    • 00:31:38
      Before we begin the business section, I'd just like to call our buddy's attention at your places to the tentative allocation of the enhancement grants for folks to look at.
    • 00:31:58
      If you have a comment, please get that back to Mr. Estes.
    • 00:32:06
      Okay, I'd like to call the order to take a business meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:32:15
      As is our question, we'll begin with public comment.
    • 00:32:18
      We have nine people signed up to speak.
    • 00:32:20
      I'll ask people to limit their commentary to not more than three minutes.
    • 00:32:25
      Mr. Mark Gregor is the first speaker to be followed by Skip Gressel.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 00:32:31
      Good morning.
    • 00:32:33
      Thank you for giving me the opportunity to come speak with you.
    • 00:32:36
      My name is Mark McGregor, and I'm the CEO of Virginia Regional Transportation Association.
    • 00:32:42
      It's a 501c3 serving about 17% of rural Virginia as a transit provider.
    • 00:32:50
      I'm here at the request of the towns of Ashland, towns of Haymarket, and at the direction of my board of directors.
    • 00:32:57
      I'm here to request you to amend the program of progress to include funding for these communities and the intercity bus proposal that was submitted on grant applications to the Virginia Department of Rail and Public Transportation.
    • 00:33:11
      The planning and feasibility have been completed and I've handed out packets to you that have the studies that have been enclosed.
    • 00:33:19
      And we do not understand why other rural communities are entitled to mass transit funding.
    • 00:33:26
      And these towns are asking, why are we not entitled to mass transit funding?
    • 00:33:31
      Why is it not being made available?
    • 00:33:34
      The percentage, and we believe, and at least what I'm here to tell you, is that we believe the percentage authorized by the General Assembly that was taken off the top for administration results in no funding for service.
    • 00:33:46
      to these rural communities, and I'm not familiar with other projects, but whatever projects weren't funded, that money's going to the percentage taken off the top.
    • 00:33:56
      It's the first time in 11 years of submission to DRPT that we have not been allocated for a new start or for a rural transit system.
    • 00:34:06
      These are one and two bus systems in small communities that have requested it.
    • 00:34:10
      Each of these communities agrees to contribute up to 32% of the cost of this service, so they're making a commitment.
    • 00:34:17
      And in your package are the resolutions from the town councils authorizing us to apply for this funding.
    • 00:34:24
      We also believe that the new business plan for DRPT has removed rural transit as a separate priority and the result from our perspective is a loss in funds.
    • 00:34:34
      The accountability, economic benefit, asset management programs that are in place are pricing an undue burden on one or two bus systems in small communities where towns and villages annually commit extensive resources and over five years of double-digit passenger increases have already justified the investment.
    • 00:34:51
      But a one-bus system to have auditors or analysts come out from the state and audit the performance of that particular single-bus system does place an undue burden.
    • 00:35:02
      And I know we have an obligation to report to you and to the community and be transparent in our operations.
    • 00:35:07
      But it does place an undue burden that they're not prepared for, that we don't have the resources or staff to answer the questions and provide the data as requested.
    • 00:35:17
      From us, it looks like an unfunded mandate to do additional work that we haven't done in the past.
    • 00:35:23
      And the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, we believe, provides less support and less as a partner than it did one, two, or five years ago.
    • 00:35:33
      From our perspective, they've become a bureaucracy that focuses on audit function, not passenger service, and they're not a partner with us in our operations.
    • 00:35:43
      In closing, I ask that the CTB amend the program of projects to include the about $750,000 for these worthwhile projects.
    • 00:35:52
      I ask this not as Mark McGregor, but as on behalf of the towns of Ashland, towns of Haymarket, and for the people along the 81, 11, and 66 corridor where we proposed an inner city bus.
    • 00:36:04
      Thank you for your time.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:06
      Appreciate it.
    • 00:36:07
      Thank you, Mr. McGregor.
    • 00:36:07
      Next speaker is Skip Russell, to be followed by Russell Short.
    • SPEAKER_18
    • 00:36:13
      My name is Skip Russell.
    • 00:36:15
      I'm president of the Rondo Corporation in Martinsville, and I'm here in my capacity as a resident of Patrick Henry County.
    • 00:36:23
      I want to thank you for the opportunity to speak briefly about a matter I hope you will find worthy.
    • 00:36:27
      We understand that in this initial stage of the I-73 corridor, it is critical that the state observe the federal environmental laws and that there is a lawsuit pending regarding another section of I-73 near the Roanoke area.
    • 00:36:42
      We do not wish to interfere with the law or the lawsuit since I-73 is so desperately needed for our section of the state.
    • 00:36:50
      This past November, the Henry County Board of Supervisors passed a resolution requesting that you and VDOT reconsider the alignment chosen for the proposed I-73 through our county.
    • 00:37:01
      The reasons for the request are many fold.
    • 00:37:03
      Here are only seven.
    • 00:37:06
      A different alignment would bring easier access to our industrial parks and the Martinsville Speedway, facilities that are critical to our economic rebound.
    • 00:37:15
      Our Board of Supervisors requested the 58-bypass roadway be part of the proposed interstate.
    • 00:37:24
      This change has water, sewer, and water installed in it, meaning new businesses could be attracted more quickly.
    • 00:37:31
      D. using the existing 58 bypass could save 8 to 10 years times raising money on construction.
    • 00:37:39
      Using VDOT's figures, this could save almost $500 million because 6 and 3 quarter miles would not have to be built.
    • 00:37:49
      The Henry County Board of Supervisors has signatures from 185 businesses that are enthusiastically supporting this change.
    • 00:37:57
      The proposed VDOT route did not properly serve these businesses, and that is the reason they are asking you for this change.
    • 00:38:05
      On the Board of Supervisors route, there are multiple intermodal access points, of which there are none on the proposed VDOT route.
    • 00:38:13
      We are aware of this potential as a tremendous asset.
    • 00:38:17
      Lastly, if the proposed VDOT route is not changed, future maps will show two blue lines as close as a mile apart, paralleling each other completely by passing marks.
    • 00:38:33
      Seems like a waste.
    • 00:38:35
      All we ask is that you consider the request of the Henry County Board of Supervisors
    • 00:38:41
      asks VDOT to work with the FHWA without prejudicing or otherwise affecting the litigation, the federal funding, or the advancement of the project, and then direct VDOT to report the results to you all for any further action.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:00
      Thank you for your consideration.
    • 00:39:04
      Thank you.
    • 00:39:04
      The next speaker is Russell Ford to be followed by Barbara Walsh.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:39:10
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary, ladies and gentlemen of the board.
    • 00:39:14
      My name is Russell Ford and I'm a member of the Board of Supervisors of Rockbridge County.
    • 00:39:18
      I'm here to talk to you this morning about the truck climbing lane project on Interstate 81 between Timber Ridge and Fairfield in Rockbridge County and the process of planning and building that project.
    • 00:39:33
      In our county's business, we try to involve as many citizens as we can in every process of planning every action of our county board.
    • 00:39:41
      We respectfully request that your board offers our citizens the same opportunity to participate fully in the planning and review of this project.
    • 00:39:51
      In particular, I'm talking about a request to reinstate the Tier 2 economic and environmental study of this project before it goes forward.
    • 00:40:03
      We have sent to your staff a resolution pretty much to that effect.
    • 00:40:07
      and we welcome comments and questions from many and all members of the board.
    • 00:40:11
      We've had an opportunity to talk to Dr. Davis about this this morning and we intend to come back to the Harrisonburg meeting in two weeks to bring up this and other matters.
    • 00:40:22
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:40:23
      I'd like to say that we enjoy working very much with our local and district VDOT staff.
    • 00:40:29
      They're extremely professional and we've had a good productive relationship even in these very challenging times.
    • 00:40:35
      And we appreciate the work you do to do more with less.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:39
      Thank you.
    • 00:40:41
      Thank you sir.
    • 00:40:42
      And the next speaker is Barbara Walsh to be followed by Patty Wood.
    • 00:40:46
      Welcome Barbara.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 00:40:48
      Thank you.
    • 00:40:49
      Good morning Mr. Secretary and members of the board.
    • 00:40:51
      My name is Barbara Walsh and I'm the Executive Director of the Rockbridge Area Conservation Council, which is a local citizens group that was formed 32 years ago.
    • 00:41:00
      to promote wide stewardship and sustainable use of natural and historic resources in the Rockbridge area.
    • 00:41:06
      As you may know, over the past five years, RAC has been one of the many groups and individuals working diligently and in good faith with VDOT, DRPT, our elected officials on issues related to improving the transportation system in the I-81 corridor.
    • 00:41:24
      Rockbridge area residents have provided countless hours of volunteer time to help keep the public and localities informed, to publicize opportunities for citizen participation, and contribute the knowledge of local experts in science, engineering, land use planning, architecture economics, and a host of other professions that we are extremely fortunate to have represented in our community and among our more than 500 members.
    • 00:41:49
      Although many of the I-81 issues touch upon aspects of transportation planning,
    • 00:41:54
      that go far beyond the scope of the kinds of local issues that RAC typically focuses on.
    • 00:41:59
      RAC realized early on that the decisions that were made for the quarter as a whole would eventually have very significant impacts directly on the residents, the economy, and the historical and natural resources of the Rockbridge area and possibly even the very way of life and rural character that its citizens and visitors cherish so dearly.
    • 00:42:21
      Now, however, we find that Rockbridge is in a completely different role as the location of the first of the targeted highway improvements on I-81 that will set a precedent for the standards and procedures of the projects that will follow throughout the rest of the corridor.
    • 00:42:36
      This is a project to widen, as Rusty mentioned, 6.4 miles on the north-mount side of the highway from Timber Ridge to just south of Rayceen.
    • 00:42:46
      The planning process that has gotten us to this point has already achieved some notable outcomes that we think will serve other projects and communities well, such as the decision to move ahead with the targeted safety pick and to use competitive bidding procedures that will provide opportunities for local and regional firms to compete for these smaller scale projects.
    • 00:43:09
      In addition to these accomplishments, the process has produced an, I think, absolutely unprecedented partnership
    • 00:43:15
      involving private rail business, VDOT, VDRPT, and members of the General Assembly Rail Advisory Board and the CTB to initiate a multi-state highway speed intermodal rail feasibility plan for the I-81 corridor.
    • 00:43:32
      We applaud the members of this board for their vision in recognizing the need to integrate the results of the rail plan into the ultimate design of an integrated transportation system for the corridor.
    • 00:43:43
      It doesn't get much better than that.
    • 00:43:45
      We truly thank the CTB for its role in guiding the process through the not always easy transitions from initial concepts through the ongoing stages of inquiry into the multi-pronged and still evolving design and implementation of solutions.
    • 00:43:59
      Now for the challenges of the first project.
    • 00:44:02
      RAC is here today to express its support for the resolution passed unanimously by the Rockbridge County Board of Supervisors and Lexington City Council.
    • 00:44:10
      to address the unresolved issues of local concern about the Rockbridge Truck Climbing Lane project and to join with our local governments in asking the CTB to take whatever action is needed to help the affected localities secure a seat at the table to work collaboratively with VDOT and to resolve the issues about design and the NEPA categorical exclusion as well as to ask for the CTB's support
    • 00:44:35
      to allow enough time for successful resolution of these concerns before moving on to project phases that will make changes difficult or impossible.
    • 00:44:44
      In addition to working sessions and adequate time for the localities to work together, we would also like to urge the CTB and VDOT to encourage the private sector to collaborate on seeking solutions to the design and impact concerns by specifically identifying those issues in the RFP
    • 00:45:02
      and stating a preference for design-build proposals that are innovative, achieve green highway, context-sensitive and low-impact design performance criteria and use the FHWA ecosystems approach to design.
    • 00:45:17
      A final task will then be to establish ranking criteria to select a proposal that best achieves these goals.
    • 00:45:24
      Before concluding, I want to emphasize two points.
    • 00:45:27
      First, I'd like to make it absolutely clear that RAC does not oppose a well-designed truck climbing lane, which we believe would consist of a single 12-foot lane design that accomplishes the job, namely to improve traffic flow and safety with minimal adverse impact and without unnecessary expenditures for expanded full-depth shoulders.
    • 00:45:49
      It simply doesn't make sense to us as taxpayers to spend lavishly on an oversized roadway in anticipation of a future widening project that has yet
    • 00:45:57
      to be fully defined and that the citizens of Rock Ridge would then have to live with forever regardless of any subsequent reductions in the ultimate highway section following the completion of the rail feasibility plan.
    • 00:46:11
      As the first of the targeted projects for I-81, the Rockbridge Truck Climbing Lane should set the highest standard and serve as the model for innovation, context-sensitive design, and thorough NEPA study and mitigation, and the demonstrated responsiveness to the many citizen comments that were originally judged to be too specific to address at the Tier 1 EIS overview stage of NEPA study as was promised to the Board.
    • 00:46:35
      Again, RAC fully supports and urges you to support the resolution passed by Rockbridge County Board of Supervisors and Lexington City Council.
    • 00:46:43
      The resolution does not propose any specific design changes or studies that identifies concerns arising from the information provided to date with the scale of the design, the categorical exclusion approach that has minimized the investigation and efforts to address both the economic and environmental impacts of the project on local residents and businesses and landowners.
    • 00:47:05
      The resolution simply asks for a meaningful seat at the table for the affected localities and the time to work with VDOT to resolve the issues of significant local importance before the project proceeds further and it becomes too costly or difficult to make adjustments.
    • 00:47:19
      Thank you again very much for the opportunity to address the board.
    • 00:47:23
      I provided Carol Mathis with a copy of some additional specific technical comments and recommendations to distribute to any of the board members who would like to have more details about the particular issues
    • 00:47:34
      and I also have a few extra copies for anyone in the audience who might want to have them.
    • 00:47:40
      Thank you very much.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:45
      Good morning.
    • SPEAKER_19
    • 00:47:52
      I would like to save my time because I know that Barbara went over her time.
    • 00:47:57
      And I would like to say that I echo her remarks and also support the resolution by the Board of Supervisors and the City of Lexington.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:07
      Thank you.
    • 00:48:08
      Thank you, Patty.
    • 00:48:08
      And as we say often, brevity is rewarded.
    • 00:48:11
      The next speaker is Lee Merrill to be followed by Greg Amenetto.
    • SPEAKER_02
    • 00:48:19
      Good morning to the members of the board, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:48:22
      Secretary, I'm a resident of Rockbridge County.
    • 00:48:25
      I'm an architect there.
    • 00:48:26
      And I apologize for our slowness in our community to understand the full scale of what has been proposed.
    • 00:48:35
      I think we were long asleep to think that a truck climbing lane was an additional third lane.
    • 00:48:40
      And while there was not necessarily uniform support for the need at this particular position on I-81 for this improvement,
    • 00:48:49
      It caught a lot of us unaware, and I would like to make that apology for being slow, but while we are amenable to a truck climbing lane, we are unconvinced of the requirement to build all future truck climbing lanes on the I-81 corridor to this section, and it concerns me tremendously that a precedent is being set here that's out of touch with the emerging global realities that we live in.
    • 00:49:15
      and we are frustrated that this not very, not particularly unsafe stretch of the highway is targeted for nearly $100 billion improvement which many of us locally consider to be a considerable overbuilding and probably stalling other valuable and possibly more needed truck climbing lane situations in the Commonwealth and in the I-81 corridor.
    • 00:49:41
      I want to encourage the members of this board to recognize a singular opportunity here today.
    • 00:49:47
      and that is that VDOT's approach to the project is a flexible design build request for proposal process and it could easily accommodate the kinds of changes and kinds of modifications that might come out of a quick and timely review of some of the conclusions that have already been made about this project so that it doesn't have to be unduly delayed to get a good truck climbing lane agreed to by all parties interested.
    • 00:50:16
      I think that this board has the responsibility to oversight to presume that we're doing the wisest and most cost effective design as this project will act as a model for truck climbing lanes and other assumptions about highway design on the I-81 corridor.
    • 00:50:33
      There is an opportunity to benefit from best sustainable practices within the VDOT research groups that we've found out about and in emerging ideas in the federal government about.
    • 00:50:45
      New ideas that are less demanding on our environment in terms of roadway design.
    • 00:50:51
      So I'll finish with just asking that you grant our community this heartfelt request, we plead, to allow us to join with the excellent VDOT people we've been working with or starting to learn from in a meaningful collaboration to resolve these concerns
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:09
      and improve elegantly perhaps our Commonwealth transportation infrastructure.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:51:28
      So thank you for your time.
    • 00:51:33
      Most of you are visitors.
    • 00:51:36
      You probably don't remember Bedford County, which joins Lynchburg 50 years ago.
    • 00:51:42
      I do.
    • 00:51:45
      Rockbridge County is like Bedford County 50 years ago.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 00:51:49
      It's a very, very special place.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:51:52
      I'm a citizen, but I'm also a member of the board of the Rockbridge Area Conservation Council.
    • 00:51:59
      And we, the council, our board of supervisors, the rest of the citizens of the county work very, very hard to continue to make Rockbridge a very special place.
    • 00:52:11
      As a result, we really have to be careful.
    • 00:52:15
      The truck climbing lane is viewed against the economic realities of the county, the fact that it's based on tourism principally.
    • 00:52:27
      We want to be careful about its historical
    • 00:52:30
      I want to talk about values, cultural values, agricultural values, and do everything we can to make sure that we have the best fit with all of these important considerations.
    • 00:52:46
      One thing I've heard here this morning that's come through loud and clear is that you have more work to do with fewer dollars.
    • 00:52:54
      So clearly that would say that you have to give a lot of thought to this investment and I would say that that includes the long-term consideration of the investment and I would say that that includes considering rail alternatives to simply making highways bigger and bigger and having more impact on the areas that they travel to.
    • 00:53:18
      So I echo what my colleagues and fellow citizens have said, and please give us every opportunity to study this carefully before anything is concluded about this project and about this plan.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:53:34
      Thank you very much.
    • 00:53:35
      Thank you, Greg.
    • 00:53:36
      The next speaker is David Foster.
    • 00:53:38
      He'll be followed by Lisa Tracy.
    • 00:53:42
      Welcome, David.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:53:43
      Good morning, gentlemen and ladies of the board.
    • 00:53:47
      I have two brief comments this morning.
    • 00:53:51
      And comment two, I want to allude to a handout.
    • 00:53:56
      So I'm going to go ahead and give this to Ms. Matthews.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:54:01
      I'd like to do comment number one in the interest of time.
    • SPEAKER_04
    • 00:54:08
      Comment number one is a rail-related comment.
    • 00:54:10
      You won't find this surprising coming from the Executive Director of Rail Solution.
    • 00:54:16
      This public hearing that we saw advertised here that was yesterday was to comment on the six-year plan.
    • 00:54:26
      I don't know, maybe it's my own ineptitude, but I haven't found the six-year rail plan.
    • 00:54:31
      So it seems to me that it's a little cart before the horse-ish situation here.
    • 00:54:37
      I looked on the website.
    • 00:54:39
      I didn't see in Chip Barger's presentation yesterday, his PowerPoint, anything about the six-year rail plan.
    • 00:54:46
      So I don't know how we can comment meaningfully on it.
    • 00:54:48
      I think we need to have that before we comment.
    • 00:54:53
      The DRPT is engaged right now in doing the statewide rail plan, which I think is supposed to be out in June.
    • 00:55:03
      And I would urge that we have a practice and an atmosphere of transparency and public involvement in that.
    • 00:55:12
      I think we need the public
    • 00:55:14
      to be able to be involved in the creation of this plan and also to comment on the plan as we go along.
    • 00:55:22
      My second comment relates to the email document that I have handed to you, and this just reinforces some of the comments that the people from Rockbridge County have already made, so I'll be brief.
    • 00:55:36
      In fact, you'll see that this, if you read like most emails, you should start on page two because the oldest email is at the bottom and that's the one from Chris Collins, dated May 4, 2007, where he comments more eloquently than I can about the problems with the design of the rock bridge truck climbing lanes.
    • 00:56:02
      And he's got a very handy one, two, three, four, five there for you.
    • 00:56:07
      And I have highlighted the one that says almost any answer is okay except that we need it for a future improvement.
    • 00:56:17
      In other words, he's trying to describe the independent utility concept that goes with a categorical exclusion.
    • 00:56:23
      Anything related to the truck climbing lane must be necessary for the truck climbing lane.
    • 00:56:29
      He raises the question, could we do this without the extra width?
    • 00:56:34
      And of course, I think the average person would think you could build a truck climbing lane without five or six lanes.
    • 00:56:42
      And as you go through this rest of this email correspondence, you'll see that meeting is held with the FHWA to discuss this.
    • 00:56:54
      And then at the very top of the first page, poor Chris here is frustrated because he says the answer to item one is exactly what the regulations prohibit you from doing.
    • 00:57:05
      And I think there's some of this going on out there.
    • 00:57:08
      We have a categorical exclusion being used for these truck climbing lanes.
    • 00:57:15
      And of course, truck climbing lanes is a normal NEPA exclusion.
    • 00:57:19
      But really what we have here is in Rockbridge County,
    • 00:57:25
      typical road section of I-81 that'll have five 12-foot lanes and in the Montgomery County one an ultimate profile I-81 over eight miles that'll involve six 12-foot lanes and this goes well beyond a truck climbing lane and it's really a six and a half and eight mile
    • 00:57:48
      I just thought you ought to read that and understand that this is not something that is probably being handled the best way, not only in terms of saving taxpayer dollars, but also from an environmental standpoint as well.
    • 00:58:11
      I really share the comments of this other speaker that went right before me but in this time of fiscal
    • 00:58:20
      Crisis, that we should not be building gold-plated truck climbing lanes.
    • 00:58:25
      We should be building typical truck climbing lanes where it gets the job done rather than trying to spend the whole $145 million federal earmarks.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:58:36
      Thank you.
    • 00:58:39
      The next speaker is Lisa Tracy.
    • 00:58:42
      Welcome, Lisa.
    • 00:58:43
      Is there anybody else who wants to address the board asking this question?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:58:49
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary and ladies and gentlemen of the board.
    • 00:58:53
      I am Lisa Tracy and I'm speaking as a resident of Lexington in Rockbridge County and as a taxpayer concerned about how our national and commonwealth dollars are going to be spent in a time of fiscal downturn.
    • 00:59:03
      So it seems I'm echoing much of what you've heard.
    • 00:59:06
      So I'm going to condense my remarks.
    • 00:59:08
      Just to say that the future we were looking at in the late 1990s and the early 2000s, when the plan to widen I-81 in various ways throughout the corridor was first developed, is not.
    • 00:59:18
      The future we're looking at now, as we all know.
    • 00:59:20
      In the past year or so, gas prices have climbed above $3 per gallon, and diesel fuel is now at as much as $4.50, with no sign that the hikes will stop anytime soon.
    • 00:59:31
      and of course at the same time rising fuel costs and an uncertain economy have added greatly to the cost of all sorts of endeavors including construction and the cost of transporting raw materials necessary for construction.
    • 00:59:44
      Earlier this week on radio station WMRA, Senator Cree Deeds and Mr. Homer spoke.
    • 00:59:53
      Mr.
    • 00:59:54
      Deeds mentioned that I believe some 40% of Virginia's bridges and tunnels are currently in substandard condition
    • 00:59:59
      Mr. Homer confirmed, if I heard correctly, that the maintenance is increasingly challenging in an economy where Virginia is currently looking at, I believe, you said $450 million less than the transportation funds we've been counting on.
    • 01:00:14
      This is not the future we were expecting even as recently as four years ago.
    • 01:00:19
      It's time to reconsider and, of course, to be flexible enough to move with the times and to amend earlier plans in order to get the best use of our diminished state and federal transportation funds.
    • 01:00:32
      In Rockbridge County, the stretch we've all been talking about this morning is not unlike other stretches of 81, a stretch where there's particularly a significant safety hazard from congestion, merging lanes, or the uphill grade.
    • 01:00:45
      A single lane in Rockbridge County would certainly be helpful, but there seems little evidence to support the addition of extensive additional grading that could eventually accommodate several extra lanes.
    • 01:00:55
      The time for this thinking is past.
    • 01:00:57
      We need the Commonwealth to spend our money where it will do the most good, and we believe that that is not by spending a very large proportion on additional widening that is much larger than what we think is eventually going to be needed.
    • 01:01:10
      We very much appreciate the time, the thought, and the expertise that went into the original plans, but we believe that events have overtaken those plans in ways that none of us could have foreseen.
    • 01:01:24
      It was very heartening to hear this morning an update on the needed state maintenance and on the development of VDOT's analytical database.
    • 01:01:35
      We're asking you now, please, to bring this I-81 project in Rockbridge County down to a really reasonable size and thereby save needed funds to be spent for more urgently needed repairs and improvements.
    • 01:01:46
      Thank you.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:48
      Thank you.
    • 01:01:49
      Does anybody else wish to address the board?
    • 01:01:53
      If not, we're going to go into our regular business session.
    • 01:01:57
      Is there a motion to approve the minutes?
    • 01:01:59
      We'll move.
    • 01:02:00
      All in favor?
    • 01:02:01
      Aye.
    • 01:02:01
      Aye.
    • 01:02:02
      Action item 1A is with reference to the first act of the county.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:07
      I move its adoption, Mr. Chairman.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:12
      Second.
    • 01:02:13
      Item 1B is a pre-prep restriction in the Town of Barreville.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:02:16
      Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:02:17
      Second.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:18
      All in favor?
    • 01:02:19
      Aye.
    • 01:02:21
      The local assistance division, Mr. Eskewes is here to answer any questions.
    • 01:02:27
      Item 2A is a Virginia Byway designation in Cajun County.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:02:31
      Move approval.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:32
      Second.
    • 01:02:33
      All in favor?
    • 01:02:34
      Aye.
    • 01:02:35
      Action item three is Economic Development Access in Unifor.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:42
      Second.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:44
      All in favor?
    • 01:02:45
      Aye.
    • 01:02:46
      Action item four is Revenue Sharing Program Policy.
    • 01:02:49
      We had a presentation and discussion on this at the last work session.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:53
      Move approval.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:54
      Second.
    • SPEAKER_25
    • 01:02:56
      All in favor?
    • 01:02:58
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 01:02:59
      There's no provision here for this to come back to the board for approval after the commissioner develops the policy.
    • 01:03:07
      Should that not come back to this board?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:03:11
      This would be similar to other guides that we have where this is before we had taken the full guide to the board.
    • 01:03:19
      What we've done is create a policy to represent the high level and represent the details that were laid out in the new code change and then we were going to do a guideline to do our other policies.
    • 01:03:29
      So this is a new policy that we haven't had before.
    • 01:03:31
      My plan was not to bring the full guide with the details of the program implementation, but if you follow me, you can share that with the board or however you guys would see that.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 01:03:43
      Understand the need for it to be developed by the Commissioner.
    • 01:03:49
      Should that not come back to this board to final approval after it's been developed?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:55
      What I might suggest, we don't want to get too much in the week here at the policy board.
    • 01:04:01
      I do think that the staff could bring that back as a presentation if we have questions that way.
    • 01:04:11
      The guidance documents by their definition
    • 01:04:13
      Mr. Chairman, just a point of clarification on the requirements for this.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:33
      Do the projects in which these go to, they must be in the secure or the secondary secure plan, is that correct?
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:04:39
      Mr. Chairman and Mr. Sterling, those projects would have to be in one of our programs or they could be in a local capital improvement program.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:46
      Not necessarily a secondary six-year program.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:04:48
      Not necessarily a secondary six-year program.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:51
      There's a motion and a second.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:53
      All in favor?
    • 01:04:54
      Aye.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:04:57
      Action item 5A is location approval in the city of Newport News.
    • 01:05:01
      My recollection is that this dates back to the 1940s or 50s.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:05:06
      Well, probably not that far.
    • 01:05:11
      Move approval.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:12
      Second.
    • 01:05:13
      All in favor?
    • 01:05:15
      Aye.
    • 01:05:15
      At United 5 please, location approval in Smith County is an interchange of 81 and exit 47.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 01:05:21
      Move approval.
    • 01:05:22
      Second.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:23
      All in favor?
    • 01:05:25
      Aye.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:26
      Bratway, and Utilities Division.
    • 01:05:30
      Coburn is here to answer any questions.
    • 01:05:32
      Action item 6A is Route 11, an old Route 11 valley, current site.
    • 01:05:38
      Are there any questions?
    • 01:05:39
      And this is over.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:05:40
      Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:05:42
      Second.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:43
      All in favor?
    • 01:05:44
      Aye.
    • 01:05:45
      Throughout 11-10 in Halifax, Kent.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:49
      Are there any questions for Mr. Coburn?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:05:52
      Move to approve, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:05:56
      Thanks.
    • 01:05:56
      All in favor?
    • 01:05:57
      Aye.
    • 01:05:57
      That's tonight on 6C with Route 604 in Charlotte County.
    • 01:06:00
      Are there any questions for Mr. Coburn?
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:03
      I move to approve, Mr. Chairman.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:04
      Second.
    • 01:06:05
      All in favor?
    • 01:06:06
      Aye.
    • 01:06:06
      That's tonight on 6C with Route 780 in Gloucester, Kent.
    • 01:06:11
      I move approval Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:06:25
      This book is here to answer any questions along with Mr. Anderson.
    • 01:06:33
      And just by way of historical note, not all of House Bill 3202 was eliminated by the Supreme Court decision.
    • 01:06:43
      One was a $3 billion bond authorization spread out over 10 years, about $300 million a year on average.
    • 01:06:52
      The first draw on this is to match our federal dollars.
    • 01:06:55
      It's very important that nation and world consume state dollars.
    • 01:07:02
      We have less and less ability to match federal dollars.
    • 01:07:07
      These bonds, if we took these bonds away from our program today, we would have a very, very, very challenging situation.
    • 01:07:19
      This is a thin line of defense, I would say.
    • 01:07:22
      Before we go to questions, Ms. Bushi, did you have any introductory comments?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:07:28
      Certainly.
    • 01:07:28
      As the Secretary indicated, staff is developing for sale, potentially in June, the first series of the Commonwealth of Virginia Transportation Capital Project revenue bonds, as authorized by Chapter 896 of the Acts of the General Assembly.
    • 01:07:46
      The Act authorizes the CTB to issue from time to time revenue obligations of the Commonwealth to be designated Commonwealth of Virginia Transportation Capital Project Revenue Bonds at one or more times in an aggregate principal amount not to exceed $3 billion, provided that the aggregate
    • 01:08:07
      The principal amount issued in any one fiscal year does not exceed $300 million, excluding any refunding bonds.
    • 01:08:14
      These bonds would be issued over or be outstanding for a period of 25 years.
    • 01:08:23
      And we would be looking to sell these bonds in a competitive sale.
    • 01:08:28
      And I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:08:33
      Chairman, is it accurate to say that if we don't approve this, this book's much thinner?
    • 01:08:37
      In that case I move.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:08:41
      I just had a quick question of what is the expected response from the capital markets if there's any thought on that with the credit crunch that's out there.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:08:53
      Actually, I believe the response would be a positive one given Virginia's bond rating and the fact that this has been developed within the capacity of the Commonwealth to issue debt.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:08
      Yes, we're on your agenda for next month.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:09:17
      So then we would look.
    • 01:09:18
      The earliest we could sell would be June.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:21
      And that's important to understand about these bonds.
    • 01:09:24
      A brand, which is a CTB note, clearly there's not a lot of involvement of the Treasury Board in oversight.
    • 01:09:32
      W. T. Taylor III, John T. Taylor III, John W. T. Taylor III,
    • 01:09:53
      Mr. Chairman, would it be safe to frame it as borrowing money and paying interest on that to be able to utilize some federal funds that otherwise would be available to us if we had proper financing?
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:10:18
      Absolutely.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:23
      Mr. Chairman, a question.
    • 01:10:26
      Given the status and the impact that the borrowing has on our long-term debt and on our future budget payments and the situation we're presently in with the pending special session, is there any benefit to delaying action while the discussion is pending?
    • 01:10:47
      It would appear that at least at this juncture
    • 01:10:52
      There might be some benefit in the legislative process to re-examine the significant exposure to debt that the legislature has elected to impose.
    • 01:11:08
      Taking this action, it seems to me, as we are concurring with the legislature, I understand the need for the money and to keep things on track.
    • 01:11:16
      I just wonder if it isn't better to perhaps pause
    • 01:11:20
      and let the special session consider the impact of the debt load that they're imposing on the Commonwealth and the future budgets that we're going to have to deal with.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:31
      Excellent question.
    • 01:11:33
      What this resolution does is allow the business of VDOT and the treasury staff to establish a credit relationship with the market.
    • 01:11:45
      The ultimate decision to go ahead with the sale is exclusively to the government.
    • 01:11:52
      And so I think we can accommodate both interests.
    • 01:11:54
      That's an excellent suggestion, though.
    • 01:11:57
      And, you know, it might not be a bad idea, Ms. Buscher, to
    • 01:12:00
      Just to develop what things might look like in the absence of this. Certainly. I think it's fair to say that our program is extremely and perhaps critically reliant on this effort. Excuse me, sorry. To follow up on what Mr. Davies said in your earlier comment, I think there's a misconception among a number of people.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 01:12:30
      That 3202 generated a lot of new sustainable revenue for statewide basis.
    • 01:12:39
      To me, this is debt and is certainly not sustainable revenue.
    • 01:12:47
      Would it be to our advantage to prepare some type of paper, and maybe you've already done that, some type of white paper that
    • 01:12:58
      really illustrates that what 3202 didn't do was provide new sustainable statewide revenue, if I understand correctly.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:09
      Well, and I'll ask Ms. Bush or the Commissioner or Ms. Tucker if they want to chime in as well, but the repayment source for these bonds are the insurance premium taxes, which have been promised since the year 2000 to transportation and never dedicated.
    • 01:13:28
      The way that legislation was written, it was written in such a way to have the left hand and the right hand have the cake and to eat it too.
    • 01:13:39
      And the one thing that did happen was it was made very clear that those insurance premium taxes are now transportation revenue.
    • 01:13:46
      So there is a dedicated revenue source for these bonds, which is a plus for transportation.
    • 01:13:53
      But that comes at the expense of the general fund.
    • 01:13:56
      Those had previously been general fund revenues.
    • 01:13:59
      And so, for example, we have the $505 million of one-time general fund revenues at the end of last year's budget that we put towards those variety of projects.
    • 01:14:12
      The general fund revenue projections went down.
    • 01:14:14
      We've taken $180 million out of that.
    • 01:14:16
      So we are absolutely moving back and forth between the left-hand and the right-hand, between transportation funding and general funds.
    • 01:14:29
      And the larger issue is one that's going to get taken up and when this goes to the Treasury
    • 01:14:38
      There has to be a fairly substantial amount of debt for the college building program and some of the other things, but it's just apparently they've reached an accommodation on that.
    • 01:14:48
      And at the end of the day, what we need in our world with capital planning is stable, reliable, predictable, whether or not we choose to pledge some portion of that to debt.
    • 01:14:59
      And right now we're moving back and forth between general funds and transportation funds, so I think you get
    • 01:15:05
      A very important issue.
    • 01:15:07
      And Butch has obviously mentioned something there.
    • 01:15:09
      And we'll go back, I think, and think about that.
    • 01:15:12
      And maybe a simple way to do it would be to ask the question, what would it be like without the debt, but with this, say, as a pay-as-you-go option?
    • 01:15:21
      Because it's one of the things.
    • 01:15:23
      And in our last six-year program, when we leave here, or when I leave here,
    • 01:15:31
      That last six-year program will extend to 2016.
    • 01:15:36
      By our estimate, we will be, in that year 2016, unable to fully match federal dollars.
    • 01:15:44
      This board will see that six-year program.
    • 01:15:48
      There are two major factors that lead to that situation.
    • 01:15:52
      The first is the growing maintenance costs, which we talked a lot about this morning.
    • 01:15:56
      The second is you get ten years of bonds.
    • 01:15:59
      and then nothing.
    • 01:16:01
      And so that ability can match federal dollars.
    • 01:16:06
      Remember we talked about canary in the coal mine, that rising percentage of federal expenditures were rapidly approaching that point.
    • 01:16:13
      And a lot of people think 10 years is a long ways away, but this board will start to do that.
    • 01:16:20
      And it's 2010, Six-Year Improvement.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:22
      How much of the debt service that we talked about yesterday in the Six-Year Plan is represented by this?
    • 01:16:31
      In other words, how much would you free up if we didn't have increasing debt load as a way of financing, an unsustainable way of financing our program?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:16:46
      I'm sorry, I don't have that number on the top of my head.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:49
      Can you give me a round guess?
    • 01:16:53
      I won't hold you to the exact number.
    • 01:16:57
      Well, maybe you ought to do this.
    • 01:16:58
      Maybe you ought to have that number available as well as long as you're going to look at what's the program look like without $300 million of debt.
    • 01:17:06
      What would it look like without the debt in the first place that we'd be able to apply to our programs and get sustainable revenue from the gas tax or the sales tax or someplace else that goes into the trust fund rather than paying off new debt
    • 01:17:22
      by, in effect, using general fund dollars which are not supposed to be used for transportation.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:30
      Well, it's important to understand, though, the dedication of the insurance premium tax, that is now a transportation revenue that's done.
    • 01:17:37
      That's a good thing from the makings of our program.
    • 01:17:40
      I think the question is, would we be better served taking that what's now $140, $150 million a year with very significant growth potential and using that on a pay-as-you-go basis or using it as part of the debt program?
    • 01:17:56
      That's a fair question.
    • 01:17:58
      I think it would be helpful to ask that question.
    • 01:18:03
      We have a little bit of resources.
    • 01:18:04
      I know Ms. Bush's staff is pretty challenged right now with this particular program.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:09
      That's essentially what I mean.
    • 01:18:10
      You put it perhaps more directly, but if you use that money directly to fund the projects instead of to finance debt,
    • 01:18:18
      What would we be able to do?
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:18:20
      If you're selling about $100 million of bonds, you'd be looking at interest or debt service of about $10 million almost a year.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:33
      Plus the repayment of the debt.
    • Reta BusherChief Financial Officer
    • 01:18:35
      But we would try to level our payments out and we'll be looking at about $10 million on $100 million.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:18:43
      Is that dedicated revenue available for construction and operations or is it limited to debt service?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:51
      No, itís actually a blend.
    • 01:18:52
      So letís just say for sake of argument thereís $140 million worth of insurance premium revenues and we sell say $300 million worth in bonds which is $25 million of debt service.
    • 01:19:08
      The remainder falls into the program and goes
    • 01:19:13
      J. Robert Jones III, Michael A. Smith III, Michael A. Smith III,
    • 01:19:27
      So if you are lucky enough to get an interstate project in your district, like the Whiting 64, it's going to take up a lot of your primary and other allocations that come with matching requirements.
    • 01:19:39
      And so it's important to provide that insulation between the state allocations and the need to match those with the federal dollars.
    • 01:19:49
      That didn't used to be a problem when we had a very healthy, better balance of state and federal revenues, but we don't have a healthy balance today.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:19:58
      And just a clarification, these are called revenue bonds, but there's no real connection to revenue.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:08
      We'll strike that question from the rack.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:20:12
      It's just a bean counter asking me that question.
    • 01:20:17
      The revenue comes from the fact that the General Assembly appropriates the money into a special fund that's the source of the revenue that would be used.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:20:30
      So in the example of the market, it's something like full faith in credit, general obligation bonds.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:34
      It's a 90 bond like the Route 58 program or the Northern Virginia District Bond Program or the Setify Fund.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:20:49
      Okay, any other?
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:50
      One final question for me.
    • 01:20:53
      Mr. Chairman, if we are going to be called upon to consider this type of bond issue on an annual basis, that's the way the program at least has been designed,
    • 01:21:03
      Are there criteria, and I pose this as a question without an answer, are there criteria we should develop on how to actually judge the wisdom of that approval from year to year?
    • 01:21:15
      I mean, it's sort of easy to do because we can do it, but I think you've heard here there's some criteria that at least some people have in mind about the wisdom of selling these types of bonds given certain political circumstances, economic circumstances, other investment type
    • 01:21:33
      I understand the ultimate call will be the governor's and probably maybe I'm answering my own question as I talk that if he has the freedom, he or she has the freedom to make the final decision, I suppose all those factors will come into play at that point.
    • 01:21:53
      Maybe I'll just ask it this way.
    • 01:21:55
      Would you expect that we would, as a matter of course, authorize the selling of these
    • 01:22:03
      each year for the next 10 years.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:05
      We would have to.
    • 01:22:07
      This authorization is not a 10-year blanket authorization.
    • 01:22:13
      I think it's a fair question to look at some alternatives.
    • 01:22:18
      We've got to go through, and there's a presumption built into our program and the legislation.
    • 01:22:23
      I think we're going to deviate from that, of course.
    • 01:22:26
      We want to do some analysis.
    • 01:22:28
      and have a conversation and ask some hard questions here and provide that commentary back ultimately to the Governor.
    • 01:22:39
      We might have conversations with Secretary of Finance, but I think it's a fair and important set of questions.
    • 01:22:47
      And it comes down to the painting now or the painting later.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:50
      So this resolution authorizes the sale and then grants you and the Governor the decision
    • 01:22:57
      to make the sale to separate items.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:01
      Yes, and it also, there's a comparable exercise that will be undertaken at the Treasury Board.
    • 01:23:08
      And they're going to view this, they may take a little bit of time, they may want to look at the details of the college building bond bill that will be discussed during a special session next week.
    • 01:23:20
      Because these bonds affect the state debt limitations, they need to balance on a year-to-year basis to make sure this all fits together.
    • 01:23:30
      And as a AAA state, Virginia will do absolutely nothing that jeopardizes our credit worthiness for our money.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:39
      Mr. Chairman, I move the resolution.
    • 01:23:43
      Second.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:44
      All in favor?
    • 01:23:45
      Aye.
    • 01:23:46
      Any opposed?
    • 01:23:48
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:23:49
      I have one other comment.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:52
      You will note it.
    • 01:23:54
      I'm sorry.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:23:57
      My name is Arthur Anderson.
    • 01:23:58
      I'm with Brevard Woods in Richmond, and we are a bond counsel with Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 01:24:05
      I did want to point out that in the resolution, there is an acknowledgment that the issuance of these bonds has been challenged in a case that was filed in the Richmond Circuit Court, Joseph B. Commonwealth.
    • 01:24:21
      The Office of the Attorney General is handling that litigation.
    • 01:24:25
      I want to mention that because the Treasury Board may wish to see some progress in that case before they will give their approval, even though we are scheduling that.
    • 01:24:37
      And, of course, the Governor may want also to see that that litigation has been dealt with before he would give approval.
    • 01:24:46
      In that way, we would enhance the market that we live on and make sure we get the profits made from rates and that sort of thing.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:24:55
      Is it unfair to ask just maybe a one-minute explanation for what the challenge to it is?
    • 01:24:59
      Yes.
    • 01:25:00
      There are two grounds.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:25:03
      One is what we call the single object rule in the Virginia Constitution that House Bill 3202 just threw in everything with the kitchen sink or included everything with the kitchen sink.
    • 01:25:17
      That particular challenge was dealt with in the NVTA validation case.
    • 01:25:22
      the Supreme Court held that HB 3202 doesn't violate the single object rule.
    • 01:25:29
      The other ground is based on Section or Article 10, Section 9 of the Constitution which is the debt, the state debt provisions
    • 01:25:44
      And the challenge there is that these are bonds backed by tax revenues of the Commonwealth of Virginia, which they have a bootstrapping analysis.
    • 01:25:57
      It's very complicated.
    • 01:25:58
      I don't think there's a need to go into that.
    • 01:26:01
      But basically, they're saying that the general suddenly didn't provide to take these bonds to referendum.
    • 01:26:08
      And they're full faith in credit.
    • 01:26:10
      Now, in our view, on counsel's view,
    • 01:26:14
      The success of that challenge would depend on the Supreme Court overturning a whole line of special fund doctrine cases because, again, the full page is not closed.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:26:35
      Thank you very much.
    • 01:26:37
      We come to our favorite part of the presentation.
    • 01:26:42
      Welcome Mr. Coburn.
    • 01:26:43
      Is this a good month or a bad month?
    • 01:26:47
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:26:48
      What I'm here to present to you this morning are events that we received on March 26th.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:27:14
      Tamm's contract in October of last year.
    • 01:27:17
      Those are the white sheets.
    • 01:27:19
      The pink sheets are additional bids which were received on the 1st of April and a project by the City of Salem received on the 3rd of April.
    • 01:27:32
      Those came in too late to get in your package in normal course of business.
    • 01:27:39
      Let's start right at page one.
    • 01:27:41
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:27:44
      I'll begin with page one.
    • 01:27:47
      This is one of our federal plant mix contracts for Stafford County.
    • 01:27:52
      We received two bids on these, and this does represent a good bid.
    • 01:27:57
      If I may just a second, since last month we've seen, just as you have personally seen, increases
    • 01:28:06
      increases in asphalt prices in the bulk and increases in those commodities that are petroleum based.
    • 01:28:16
      Just as a general rule, even in the last two weeks we've seen an increase in reinforcing steel from about $2.40 a pound to $2.70 a pound with a shortened quote period.
    • 01:28:35
      Quotes right now are being honored for 14 days.
    • 01:28:39
      So the market is tightening and we're looking at all those things as we go.
    • 01:28:44
      I say that so that to give you some sense of the analysis we go through, and I'm telling you from staff analysis that we believe these are good ideas and recommend it's approved.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:28:59
      Mr. Chairman, quick question.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:01
      We heard earlier that asphalt's going up.
    • 01:29:03
      You touched about it, but when I look at the bid amount in comparison to what we had estimated it cost, and I see this in other places with asphalt,
    • 01:29:13
      It's substantially lower.
    • 01:29:16
      What's the result of the bids coming in so much lower if the asphalt's up?
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:29:20
      The asphalt item itself, from what was predicted, is not necessarily lower.
    • 01:29:28
      There are other items in this bid, the milling, the other safety appliances, and those types of things.
    • 01:29:35
      So in total, that estimate represents a good value.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:40
      Those other elements, that large of a component of this overall project, that the price down on them would, I mean, that's almost a million less.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:29:49
      In this project, without getting into the details, I believe those other items represent about 28 to 30 percent of this total contract.
    • Cord A. SterlingMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:00
      But the bid itself is about 20 percent less than what we estimated it cost to be.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:30:06
      The item that was set in the Six-Year Plan for construction, I believe, was
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:30:16
      Well, I think it raises a good general question, too, in contrast to what Connie Sorrell presented this morning about a 50% increase in highway maintenance.
    • 01:30:38
      I think that's right.
    • 01:30:39
      Costs.
    • 01:30:41
      How much?
    • 01:30:44
      Largely due, I think you said, to the price of asphalt.
    • 01:30:47
      In fact, I'm getting a sense that maybe that isn't the determining factor.
    • 01:30:52
      And is there a disconnect between what we're actually seeing in bids today and what we're planning for, I guess is my question?
    • 01:31:02
      Because it looks like we should be seeing increased costs on these bids.
    • 01:31:06
      And instead, for the last six months in a row, they've been going straight down to our advantage.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 01:31:12
      I need to look at the next couple, I think.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:15
      Well, and I guess I would say the commodity, obviously, is the labor.
    • 01:31:22
      Equipment rental, these are very big machines.
    • 01:31:25
      There's five.
    • 01:31:26
      There's a bit of a rental rate.
    • 01:31:28
      And so, yes, you're seeing escalation on the commodity rate.
    • 01:31:32
      You're seeing a more competitive one for labor.
    • 01:31:34
      for some of the equipment that otherwise could be idle, as well as some of the assets that are surfacing during these work and these strikes and things like that.
    • 01:31:48
      Is there a motion?
    • 01:31:49
      I'll move.
    • 01:31:49
      Second.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:50
      All in favor?
    • 01:31:51
      Aye.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:31:52
      Page 2, the first item, A44, is Holloway County.
    • 01:32:02
      This is a bridge replacement of the Blackwater River.
    • 01:32:06
      You'll notice this is typical of some of our roadway and bridge replacement projects.
    • 01:32:10
      We've got a lot of bids on this.
    • 01:32:13
      This does represent a very good value and we recommend it to work.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:17
      And is this where there was a very serious flooding about three years ago?
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:32:23
      I'm not familiar with that one.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:32:31
      But I'm not sure this bridge is the best.
    • 01:32:34
      I don't know.
    • 01:32:36
      I don't know.
    • 01:32:37
      Fair motion.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 01:32:37
      Some of them.
    • 01:32:39
      Second.
    • 01:32:39
      All in favor?
    • 01:32:40
      Aye.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:32:40
      The next project, K-47, again is a federal plant mix project containing other items as well as plant mix.
    • 01:32:54
      Only one bidder.
    • 01:32:55
      We do not believe we'll get a better price on this and we recommend it's approved.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:01
      Is there a motion?
    • 01:33:07
      Second?
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:08
      All in favor?
    • 01:33:11
      I'm sorry.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:13
      I guess it's my standard question.
    • 01:33:17
      It always concerns me when I see one bidder and the price is higher than what we had in the six-year plan.
    • 01:33:23
      I assume, based on what you said, that the bid is within the engineer's estimate.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:33:30
      It's very close to the engineer's estimate.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:34
      It's above the engineer's estimate.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:33:36
      It's very close to engineer testing.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:47
      Well, given your comments a moment ago about the price of steel, the bids are only good for 14 days.
    • 01:33:56
      Without describing the complete process and giving away anything in confidence, what can you tell us that gives us more comfort
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:34:04
      We spend a significant amount of time researching the market and one of the groups in our section that's an internal group is
    • 01:34:27
      calling suppliers, developing quotes, just as they were a contractor.
    • 01:34:33
      And we are looking at those commitment dates.
    • 01:34:38
      We're looking very aggressively at what a project, what an aggressive schedule for building that project would give us.
    • 01:34:50
      We also write our specifications as a shared risk type of contract where certain items, there are escalation clauses, asphalt items are one of those and there are fuel adjustment items in certain
    • 01:35:09
      We have looked internally and developed various techniques that we can contractually share
    • 01:35:39
      and recognize an individual business owner's strategy to bid against us essentially.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:54
      One other brief question, Mr. Jones.
    • 01:35:57
      A few years ago when we were discussing the problem with one bidder project, part of the explanation was that
    • 01:36:05
      The contractors out there, because of the low volume of highway work, they were doing shopping centers and things like that because the economy was doing well.
    • 01:36:15
      They could make more money on those projects.
    • 01:36:18
      Now that the economy is turned down, this project has one bidder and the next one has one bidder as well.
    • 01:36:26
      Is there any change of thinking now in terms of why we're only getting one bid on these projects?
    • 01:36:33
      Do you see light at the end of the tunnel?
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:36:35
      A lot of the asphalt type of work is based on the number of firms that are in that business.
    • 01:36:43
      In this area of the state, there are very few producers.
    • 01:36:49
      In the Hampton Roads area, as an example, most of the aggregate is trucked in or barged in.
    • 01:36:56
      So when you look at all the ingredients that make up asphalt, the sand, the aggregates, the asphalt binder, there's a lot of freight costs that builds into those things coming in.
    • 01:37:10
      There's a limited market of the number of players that are selling that product to us.
    • 01:37:17
      On the other hand, we pay well and we pay on time.
    • 01:37:21
      And so that protection is one of the things that
    • 01:37:26
      The asphalt industry and all of our contractors recognize that we do honor our commitments and we do pay and they recognize that.
    • 01:37:39
      Probably, if we could look into a firm's bid records, we would see a tighter margin on work that they do for us because of that reliability and consistency than some of that that's in the private market.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:37:56
      I think Mr. Coburn sort of answered my question because I was going to suggest that maybe Branscombe has incredible market share in asphalt plants in this particular region and there aren't many other equal-sized competitors out there producing asphalt.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:38:12
      That's correct.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:38:14
      I need to abstain.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 01:38:19
      I can't hear you.
    • J. Douglas KoelemayMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:22
      Branscombe is on my board.
    • 01:38:25
      Could I make one quick comment since we were talking about engineer's estimates?
    • 01:38:30
      In a conversation earlier this week with a gentleman from a major construction company who's very active in Virginia and most other states as well as overseas, there was a casual reference to Florida beginning in certain circumstances to actually release their engineer's estimate with the bid documents.
    • 01:38:53
      In other words,
    • 01:38:55
      to share its own information and to prompt discussions earlier in the process if they were offline and so forth.
    • 01:39:04
      So I don't know what to do with that.
    • 01:39:06
      I don't know what the circumstances there are, but I would be very interested in learning one, if that were true, and two, the circumstances under which that occurs.
    • 01:39:16
      Because we're an information age here, and this is the way we've always done things,
    • 01:39:23
      Sharing of information is the new norm in business, not hiding information.
    • 01:39:29
      And collaboration is the new norm of business, not sort of the false advocacy relationship where somebody wins, somebody loses if money is this or money is that.
    • 01:39:39
      So I would like to see if someone could maybe look into that and
    • 01:39:46
      You know, maybe brief us on those circumstances at some point that there's some alternative ways of doing this.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:55
      All right, there's motion and second on the floor.
    • 01:39:58
      Any other questions?
    • 01:40:00
      All in favor?
    • 01:40:02
      Aye.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:40:03
      This is a normal route.
    • 01:40:11
      Order number 213 is a normal district-wide plant mix schedule.
    • 01:40:17
      Again, as you mentioned, there's only one bidder on this project.
    • 01:40:22
      We do believe this is a good bid and recommend its approval.
    • 01:40:31
      This project is one of the TAMS contracts.
    • 01:40:38
      This one is Stanton North.
    • 01:40:41
      We did receive three bids on this project back in October.
    • 01:40:46
      There was a significant negotiation that occurred through this, which I believe resulted in basically around a $7 million savings.
    • 01:40:55
      The staff has looked at it, and over the length of the contract, we recommend it's approved.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:04
      Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:41:10
      Second.
    • 01:41:12
      All in favor?
    • 01:41:16
      Aye.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:41:18
      In Rockwell County, this is a concrete pavement repair, edge drains, etc.
    • 01:41:26
      We had two bidders interested in this project.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:30
      We believe this is a very good bid and recommend it to you.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:41:41
      This is another type of pavement reclamation and asphalt overlay project, a little different from the previous.
    • 01:41:53
      Again, we had two bidders on this project.
    • 01:41:58
      We believe it's a good bid and recommend it's approved.
    • Kenneth Spencer WhiteMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:04
      Second.
    • 01:42:05
      All in favor?
    • 01:42:06
      Aye.
    • 01:42:07
      Any opposed?
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 01:42:08
      With your note, my extension is like more construction is applied.
    • Warner B. "Byron" CoburnScheduling and Contract Division Administrator
    • 01:42:16
      The last project is a City Asylum project.
    • 01:42:21
      Bids were received on April 3.
    • 01:42:24
      This is a replacement of Colorado Street Bridge over the Roanoke River.
    • 01:42:30
      This project contains a 10-foot greenway for pedestrians and cyclists as part of this.
    • 01:42:41
      Again, you'll see we have five bidders on this project.
    • 01:42:43
      I have a good interest and we recommend this award.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:42:49
      We'll certainly move approval.
    • 01:43:00
      Second.
    • 01:43:01
      All in favor?
    • 01:43:02
      Aye.
    • 01:43:02
      President Coburn?
    • 01:43:03
      Okay.
    • 01:43:03
      Anybody want to bring any items up underneath this?
    • Dana M. MartinMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:43:07
      While you're being passed up, if I had that, I'll talk.
    • 01:43:12
      One of the things that I came across in my business life and came to adopt as a guiding principle is that the one doing the job best knows how that job should be done.
    • 01:43:27
      And earlier today, Mr. Russell talked about Henry County Board of Supervisors.
    • 01:43:34
      Henry County Board of Supervisors passed a resolution asking us to consider the possibility
    • 01:43:42
      of what indeed in the scope of things would be minor changes to the I-70 rerouting.
    • 01:43:50
      However, it would be quite major to this.
    • 01:43:54
      And considering that the Board of Supervisors, the citizens, numerous business and private interests have asked us to consider that, I did look into it and simplifying it
    • 01:44:11
      What we are being asked to consider is using more of existing interstate standard road in the Martin Square area, and that's essentially what it comes down to.
    • 01:44:21
      All the rest of those things are ancillary, and many of them probably would come out to be as projected, but some might not be as good as we would think.
    • 01:44:32
      Overall, though, it came out to be a logical thing to support.
    • 01:44:40
      The resolution that you see in front of you I have had vetted by people who are far more intelligent or at least far, far better paid than I.
    • 01:44:56
      To the purpose of avoiding aggravating existing obstacles to the project or creating new obstacles to the project.
    • 01:45:04
      While personally I endorse this resolution, the only reason I'm not asking us to vote right now is I am
    • 01:45:10
      Deferring to some wisdom from my colleague Jim Boyd that we'd be sure to honor both the spirit and the matter of transparency and to say that we would take time and look at actually voting next month now that I publicly offer this resolution.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:32
      So, this is really an informational item and we'll schedule this as an action item as appropriate.
    • 01:45:47
      I think there are, Mr. Bowie has mentioned about transparency.
    • 01:45:50
      Obviously, it's important that we never undertake resolutions like this without some advance notice to be effective.
    • 01:45:53
      and also without consultation with the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 01:46:07
      And they're the ultimate arbiter on the conditions of their litigation and we need to understand that they are potentially at risk as well.
    • 01:46:16
      But thank you for putting this together.
    • 01:46:17
      We've heard this repeatedly now in several of the public hearings and it's our responsibility for them to address this situation at the federal level.
    • 01:46:20
      Any other items under new business?
    • David S. EkernVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:22
      Mr. Chairman, I do have a brief informational item.
    • 01:46:26
      I'm providing to the members of the board a summary sheet, which beginning May 1st, we will routinely provide to members of the board.
    • 01:46:40
      It's a piece of information that we track in the department, have for many years, and we'll go into a much more in-depth explanation of what's in here, but in concept, what this shows you is at the end of the day, the decisions you make, as you just did, turns into work on the road.
    • 01:47:04
      And so what this gives you in a very quick summary I think is a pretty powerful piece of information in terms of the construction and maintenance contracts that we have underway.
    • 01:47:19
      And so if you look at this status as of April 1st, you will note that we have about 108 construction contracts currently underway that this board or I have approved under the
    • 01:47:33
      processes that we use and about 231 maintenance contracts.
    • 01:47:39
      It shows you their contract value total and the amount that is left to be paid or the incomplete balance based on progress that is going on.
    • 01:47:53
      Like engineer's estimates and everything else, there's nuance and subtlety within this data.
    • 01:47:59
      As I've reviewed it, I've found it to be one of those guideposts that kind of ties things together for me at the beginning of every month.
    • 01:48:11
      What actions have we taken?
    • 01:48:12
      What has it turned into?
    • 01:48:14
      And where is it?
    • 01:48:16
      So we'll bring this back on a routine basis, probably on a monthly basis, as we make awards and
    • 01:48:24
      I have no doubt that this will start to raise some additional questions from the board in explanation as we move forward.
    • 01:48:33
      I thought this was much more interesting than looking at banking information.
    • Pierce R. HomerChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:41
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:48:42
      There's a similar piece to that.
    • 01:48:44
      I know there will be some conversation after this.
    • 01:48:49
      Thank you for this.
    • 01:48:50
      I think it's good to remember that this body seeks to contract over $2 million.
    • 01:48:56
      I think that's the threshold, the majority of the contracts.
    • 01:49:04
      I wasn't certain the contracts are less than $2 million, unless it's been there, a number of contracts might have been associated with that.
    • 01:49:08
      Okay, if there's nothing else, the meeting is adjourned.