Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 11/16/2006
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
11/16/2006
Attachments
Meeting agenda.pdf
Public Comment
Approval of Minutes October 11, 2006
1. Action on Highway Designations:
LOCATION AND DESIGN DIVISION
2. Action on Location Approval: Presenting:
LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
3. Action on Revenue Sharing: Presenting:
RIGHT OF WAY AND UTILITIES DIVISION
4. Action on Land and Easement Conveyances: Presenting: Stuart Waymack Division Administrator
5. Action on Limited Access:
6. Action on Memorandum of Understanding:
7. Action on FY07-12 Six-Year Improvement Program Transfers for September 27 through October 27, 2006.
8. Location Approval for the Harrisonburg Southeast Connector
SCHEDULING & CONTRACT DIVISION
9. Action on Bids Received: the months of September and October 2006:
NEW BUSINESS
ADJOURNMENT
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:00
Good morning and welcome to the November business meeting of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:07
As is our custom, we're going to begin with public comment.
00:00:10
And I would like to note an important change.
00:00:12
Mr. Archie Ellis is going to address us and he's addressed this body many times on a variety of topics.
00:00:19
It used to be the case under rules and procedure for many years that people had to call in advance and ask permission to come speak to the CTB, which was an inappropriate policy.
00:00:29
And so, Mr. Ellis, what I would like to say to you is you don't have to call in advance.
00:00:34
You just show up.
00:00:35
We have a period for public comment and we actively welcome and solicit comments of the general public.
SPEAKER_09
00:00:43
Alright, thank you sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:57
Is this from the last IBM Selectric still working?
SPEAKER_09
00:01:02
Yeah.
00:01:03
Ladies and gentlemen, my name is Archie Ellis, and I'm a retired lawyer, and I've been messing with transportation issues in the General Assembly and elsewhere for about 40 years.
00:01:14
taking the liberty of coming here to try to tell you folks how to run your business.
00:01:20
And my principal argument for you, which I'll supplement with some details as time permits, is that you are the most important citizen voice on transportation in the state.
00:01:34
And I want you to fix your muscles, even if it may have some political ramifications.
00:01:41
and make some policy decisions to send over to the General Assembly for their session in January.
00:01:50
You all know more than I do about the problems with the General Assembly, but they need advice and they need direction.
00:01:57
And I think you folks should be making some policy decisions, heavyweight policy decisions.
00:02:04
I think you spend most of your time reviewing projects and contracts from the Commonwealth Transportation Board and other state organizations.
00:02:15
And I want you to initiate something.
00:02:19
So I would like to just point out a few details.
00:02:25
I'd like for you to, before this meeting ends, to adopt a resolution calling upon the Secretary and several departments and the staff to arrange a special meeting for the Board sometime between now and your November meeting so that you can review policy issues.
00:02:47
I will give you a number of them, my ideas, but I am sure there are others.
00:02:53
And so that you might make a decision if you're so inclined and vote on it at your next board meeting in November in time for it to be transmitted to the responsible people in the General Assembly.
00:03:07
I'm convinced that they need it.
00:03:09
I think they probably want it.
00:03:12
Now the Secretary has spoken repeatedly about the various problems and there have been memoranda and things that I'm sure you've heard them in your planning session.
00:03:23
I've given you some papers that I've distributed before.
00:03:26
I spoke here last in March 16th, but I think there are five new members here, at least who did not hear my remarks then.
00:03:34
So I've given you papers from the past that document in some detail the ideas that I would like for you to consider, various issues.
00:03:45
And to go through them very quickly, one is the greater use of tolls.
00:03:51
I think we're at the stage with financing in the state and also the special use of roads by certain population densities
00:04:01
where people ought to pay for the deluxe accommodations rather than have the rest of the state bearing the burden.
00:04:10
Right here in Richmond, I can illustrate this point, some years ago we took the tolls off the Richmond-Petersburg Turnpike.
00:04:19
Some of you may not know that was a cash cow.
00:04:24
It was paying its own way, and it was throwing off enough money to pay for other roads in the Richmond area for construction, including Chippenham Parkway, which is a substantial road.
00:04:36
I think it would have generated the $10 million or whatever it costs to renovate the bridge over the James River that was done recently with general transportation funds.
00:04:47
So that's an illustration.
00:04:49
I think another one would be the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel.
00:04:53
And there are others.
00:04:54
There are probably some in each of your districts.
00:04:57
I have felt strongly that the problems with the Woodrow Wilson Bridge and the three billion dollars of whatever has been spent there would have been sharply reduced if a two dollar toll had been put on that bridge and the money would have been there to have paid most of that expenditure to improve it or maintain it.
00:05:14
So I urge you to come forward with a strong policy on the use of tolls, even though they may be detrimental to your area, and I know many people hate them, but I've been using the ones in the Richmond area ever since they were built.
00:05:29
I've got the little device on my car.
00:05:31
and they worked fine.
00:05:33
I don't mind paying for the deluxe facility when I use it.
00:05:38
I think other people should get used to that idea.
00:05:41
You will find in my memorandum, second item, details on certain truck taxes.
00:05:49
The big truck industry in Virginia has not been paying its share for many, many years.
00:05:55
I've only illustrated one aspect and that is the fuel tax.
00:05:59
And to give you a brief illustration, it's graphically as well as a documentary.
00:06:06
In 1956 or thereabouts, when the trucks were at a maximum of about 55,000 pounds, and the motors was paying six cents per gallon tax, the legislature thought the truckers should pay a third more as a surcharge because of their size and weight and damage to the roads then.
00:06:26
So a two-cent surcharge was imposed at that time, about 1956.
00:06:31
I've got it on one of those papers there.
00:06:35
Today the motorist is paying 17 and a half cents.
00:06:38
The trucks are over 80,000 pounds and far more numerous and using diesel fuel so they get more miles in proportion to the taxes paid.
00:06:49
And that surcharge is still only two cents.
00:06:52
To maintain the original level of a third surcharge, it needs to be raised substantially.
00:06:59
To accommodate the size and weight increases in the volume of vehicles needs to be raised even more.
00:07:07
I can't tell you what each cent
00:07:09
The state has mechanisms to collect the funds from out-of-state truckers and the corporation commission used to audit it carefully.
00:07:23
I'm not sure the system is as efficient as it used to be, but there is a system.
00:07:30
On that same subject of the big truck industry, which is a problem for the state on I-81 and I-95 and elsewhere, the use of general funds is a direct subsidy to the big trucks.
00:07:47
It puts more of them on the road.
00:07:49
And you need to make policy as to which way are we going to go with transportation in this state.
00:07:56
And the reason for that is take the one-half cent sales tax, which is the Commonwealth Transportation Trust Fund, $400 million a year.
00:08:06
The big truck industry pays practically no sales tax.
00:08:10
Same with the use of recordation fees.
00:08:13
They pay practically none of those.
00:08:14
So they like the use of general funds for highway purposes.
00:08:19
They do not like the increase in gasoline taxes or the surcharge or some other things.
00:08:27
Maximum weight loss or another aspect that I would direct your attention to because of the acute problems you've got with highway maintenance which is eating up all of your funds.
00:08:38
Excess truck weights are a very big factor in highway damage.
00:08:44
I recently received from one of your members an interesting article on that subject that documents in greater detail than I can.
00:08:52
But many of the roads in Virginia, and if you get an analysis for each of your own districts, there are many roads in your districts that were built many years ago and bridges for 15 and 20,000 pounds maximum weight.
00:09:08
But the law is permitting 80,000 pounds and even more for log trucks and other special interests to run on those roads, which accelerates damage.
00:09:19
Much of the interstate system was not built for 80,000 pounds.
00:09:25
The U.S. highways, I think none of them were built for more than about 60,000 pounds.
00:09:30
So this is an acute problem, and it's compounded by the fact that there are many exceptions in the Virginia law, and every year in the General Assembly, there are proposals to give greater weights for log trucks or one thing or another.
00:09:44
and there's a supporting organization in every case.
00:09:49
But what that does is it permits these vehicles to run promiscuously everywhere.
00:09:55
An illustration of another type is the interstate system which has a maximum weight and the secretary is telling me to shut up and I will do so but if you will look at my memo you will see some other issues that I think you might deal with to
00:10:11
Get off my horse.
00:10:13
Just a couple of modal allocation.
00:10:16
We do not have any funds for Amtrak direct operations in Virginia, even though we get much service.
00:10:23
That needs to be considered.
00:10:25
The distribution formulas to localities, I think, result in some expenditures that would not be done if it was an overall appraisal and a cost-benefit analysis done.
00:10:38
So there are other illustrations and I thank you for listening and for your time.
00:10:44
Thank you, Mr. Ellis.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:46
We also have Mr. Pete Green.
00:10:49
Welcome, Mr. Green.
SPEAKER_14
00:10:54
My given name is Charles, but I'm more commonly known by the nickname of Pete, and most people would not recognize who you were talking about if you used the name Charles.
00:11:03
I'm here today from the Mill Creek Drive area of Isle of Wight County, and I represent about 160 neighbors who for the most part are working families.
00:11:13
There are about 100 homes in our area, and just for a reminder, those of you who were here last October when we asked if you could find some way to avoid
00:11:24
The destruction of our homes, 26 homes in Isle of Wight County by the Route 460 project, and in fact you did resolve at that time to have VDOT work to do that.
00:11:36
In July, it was actually July of last year, we first learned that our homes were going to be impacted by the Route 460 project.
00:11:44
And I realize I'm talking about a situation here that there are no funds for,
00:11:49
But what you may not or may know, we can't sell our homes.
00:11:54
We're in a preferred right of way.
00:11:56
I have two neighbors.
00:11:57
Husbands have transferred out of state, cannot sell their homes.
00:12:00
They have to put it in a real estate contract that they're in a preferred roadway alignment, just can't move them.
00:12:08
So we're looking for some help, and we're not sure.
00:12:11
We're kind of novices of this.
00:12:14
We're in the last part of the stage where we're going to try to do for ourself.
00:12:17
There may be attorneys here, but the people who make money when you use attorneys are the attorneys, not the clients particularly.
00:12:28
When the board ruled last year,
00:12:31
They did rule, in fact, on the CPA-1 alignment.
00:12:35
And at that time, the pink and the green in the arch scale represent an approximation of an alignment that I presented that not a single home will be destroyed in that area.
00:12:49
It will also not have to cross the same wetland twice.
00:12:55
You resolved to go with the CBA-1 alignment and directed VDOT to work with my county to try and find a route that would avoid residential relocation.
00:13:07
In short,
00:13:08
My county refused to work with VDOT.
00:13:11
They held a meeting to try and resolve this, and the first thing they said was, VDOT representatives are here, but they will not participate in these discussions, which stunned us because we felt like we needed VDOT if we needed anyone.
00:13:29
To make a long story short, we were kind of sold out by our county government, and of course we'll deal with that at the next appropriate election time.
00:13:38
But that's not this board's concern.
00:13:41
What we're trying to do is find some way to help our neighbors that want to sell, sell their houses.
00:13:49
In discussing this with some of the lawyers, and as you know, the Metropolitan Planning Board in Tidewater withdrew the Route 460 project.
00:13:58
from their long-range plan, which took it off the table.
00:14:01
So we're here in limbo for a year now.
00:14:06
And as you gentlemen know, it could be three years, four years, five years, and we're still sitting there trying to market their homes.
00:14:13
I'm 72.
00:14:14
I really don't want somebody to come up in the driveway when I'm 78 or 79 and tell me if I'm still alive that now you have to get out.
00:14:22
I have no problem if they want to come and buy my house, but we're stuck right now, so I would ask, probably, I can give you three options, and if you can think of more, you're welcome to them.
00:14:33
One is, if the board can rescind or withdraw its support of the CPA1 alignment at this time, and leave it off the board until such time as VDOT has the funds to proceed with the project,
00:14:48
Then if they want to come back here and present the same thing again or whatever, that's fine.
00:14:54
But if we could rescind that route, get a letter from VDOT, that's no longer the preferred route at this time, the lawyers say we could then market our homes without putting that, disclosing that in the contract.
00:15:06
Second option, I know you have no money, but come up my driveway within the next six months and start condemnation on my property and the other homeowners there so at least we can get on with our lives.
00:15:18
and I'm not sure that that's something can be done.
00:15:26
And the last option is if in fact, and I understand that VDOT did put this on the route in the bid package to the contractors.
00:15:35
I don't know whether the contractors favored the route through our neighborhood or the route south of the wetland.
00:15:43
It's probably not a desirable option, but if they did in fact
00:15:47
The route south of the wetland then can VDOT so state that they support the route south of the wetland and not through our neighborhood, which would also give us an opportunity to market our homes.
00:16:02
We're new at this, as I say.
00:16:04
We know the General Assembly meets in January and we may well show up with a busload of people and signs and march around the building.
00:16:12
That's really not what we want to do.
00:16:14
Most of my neighbors work.
00:16:16
I'm retired, so I'm able to do this.
00:16:20
We're looking for help.
00:16:21
We hope to meet with other state officials in time, but we just don't know what to do from here, and we're stuck.
00:16:30
And I don't know if other localities are that way, but we're stuck.
00:16:33
We just can't move our houses.
00:16:35
And if you gentlemen have any suggestions, we'd certainly be glad to take them.
00:16:40
And if you have any questions, I'd be glad to answer them.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:45
Thank you, Mr. Green.
00:16:46
I appreciate your taking the time to come and be with us this morning.
00:16:49
Property acquisition is by far the most difficult job facing the Commonwealth.
00:16:56
This Route 460 corridor is a priority of the Commonwealth, and so despite the actions of the Metropolitan Planning Organization, we intend to proceed with the development of this facility and to seek
00:17:08
A combination of public and private
00:17:21
looking at alternative alignments to minimize some of those residential impacts and so I would ask perhaps Mr. Walton can apprise you of the current status of that work and I do very much appreciate and understand the uncertainty that this casts over people and their property.
00:17:44
Our goal would be to make a determination regarding the financial feasibility of this project
00:17:52
at some point next year in spring or early summer.
00:17:57
So I don't believe that there will be a quick immediate resolution that you would be seeking here today, but within the limits of the process.
00:18:06
We will try and articulate both a feasibility of a facility will have moved forward and I know that there is work underway to do some relocations to minimize the amount of residential impacts.
SPEAKER_14
00:18:22
We understand that it's a complicated issue and we've never tried to stop the road.
00:18:26
That's never been our goal.
00:18:27
We just wanted to get on with our lives.
00:18:30
And of course, there have been four homes built in that road right away because my county would not post a map on the board giving prospective builders an idea of where the road was going.
00:18:40
And one of the gentlemen is here with me and he certainly, according to law firms, has a suit against the county.
00:18:47
Yes sir, Mr. Dickens.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:04
Mr. Secretary, I wasn't here at the time, but I understand the Commonwealth Transportation Board issued a resolution requesting the VDOT folks and Isle of Wight folks to get together and discuss this.
00:19:18
Was there any resolution to that?
00:19:21
What happened?
00:19:24
Apparently nothing happened from your end.
00:19:27
Does anybody know what happened?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:29
I'll ask the department if you come back and give some hard information on that.
00:19:35
I don't know.
00:19:36
My understanding is that a possible relocation is being examined as part of the environmental documentation to minimize.
00:19:45
There were two locations, I believe, in Isle of Wight County where there were residential impacts.
00:19:50
The CTB resolution did ask that those be looked at for further refinement.
00:19:55
I don't think anyone today can tell us what the status of that is, but the concerns articulated by Mr. Green were listened to and incorporated into the CTB resolution.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:07
Well, I would request that that be looked into and brought back to us at the next meeting, please.
SPEAKER_14
00:20:13
I can tell you very quickly, the county held a meeting
00:20:16
About 200 of us showed up.
00:20:19
The first thing they told us was, even though Dennis U. and other VDOT personnel were in the meeting, they would not be participating in the effort to realign the road.
00:20:28
Then they took 200 of us, put 50 in each corner of the room, gave us a map, and told us to draw.
00:20:34
I preferred alignment on the map.
00:20:37
That's what my county did.
00:20:39
Sometime before the next meeting, two farmers, two members of the county,
00:20:45
2 members of the Windsor Town Council had a private meeting in the barn of one of the farmers drafted their own alignment which so happened to miss all of their farms after the alignment was done and that infuriated the whole county.
00:21:00
The county threw its hands up in the air and walked away from the whole deal.
00:21:05
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:09
The next item on the agenda is the approval of the October minutes.
00:21:13
Is there a motion?
00:21:15
All in favor?
00:21:17
Aye.
00:21:18
Action item number one is a highway designation for the BF Robinette Ridge.
00:21:24
Are there any questions of Mr. Elliott?
SPEAKER_05
00:21:27
Move the approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:29
Is there a second?
00:21:30
Second.
00:21:30
All in favor?
00:21:32
Aye.
00:21:33
The next item, Action Item 2, is a location approval for Stone Spring Road in the City of Harrisonburg.
00:21:41
Are there any questions of Mr. Michelli?
00:21:45
Move to approve.
00:21:46
Second.
00:21:47
All in favor?
00:21:48
Aye.
00:21:50
Action Item Number 3 is 3A is respect a revenue sharing project for Montgomery County.
00:21:59
Are there any questions of Ms. Reese?
00:22:04
I move approval.
00:22:05
Second.
00:22:06
All in favor?
00:22:09
Aye.
00:22:09
The next item, right-of-way and utility division.
00:22:14
Stuart Waymack, let's take these one by one.
00:22:16
Action item 4A on Route 81.
00:22:19
Is there a second?
00:22:23
Second.
00:22:23
All in favor?
00:22:24
Aye.
00:22:25
Action item 4B is for
00:22:28
Route 58 in Patrick County.
00:22:32
All in favor?
00:22:35
Aye.
00:22:35
Action item 4C is a conveyance for Louisa County, Route 635.
00:22:42
Move approval.
00:22:43
Second.
00:22:45
All in favor?
00:22:46
Aye.
00:22:47
Action item 6D in Prince George's County is being removed from the agenda.
00:22:56
Action item
00:22:58
4D is being removed.
00:23:01
Action item 4E on Route 620 in Henry County.
00:23:05
All in favor?
00:23:07
Aye.
00:23:08
Action item 4F, Route 501 in Halifax County.
00:23:14
All in favor?
00:23:16
Aye.
00:23:17
Action item 4G, Route 360 in Essex County.
SPEAKER_02
00:23:24
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:25
All in favor?
00:23:26
Aye.
SPEAKER_01
00:23:26
Can I ask a question on that, please?
00:23:28
Yes, ma'am.
00:23:30
I believe that this is an old road that's abandoned, am I right?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:35
That's Action Item 4G, Route 360.
SPEAKER_01
00:23:39
Okay.
SPEAKER_16
00:23:43
That's correct, yes ma'am.
SPEAKER_01
00:23:45
So that conveyance comes back to VDOT, am I correct?
SPEAKER_16
00:23:48
If we had the underlying fee ownership, it comes back to VDOT.
00:23:51
If it's a secondary road and it's abandoned by the county and we abandon it, it reverts to the adjacent owners.
00:23:57
If it's secondary, in this case, we own the underlying fee.
SPEAKER_01
00:24:00
And I understand that maybe someone wanted to purchase that?
SPEAKER_16
00:24:04
Yes, ma'am, they do.
SPEAKER_01
00:24:06
When VDOT receives the funding, does that go back to the locality, like the district, or does it come back to the general fund?
SPEAKER_16
00:24:16
It comes back to the project, the district construction fund.
SPEAKER_01
00:24:21
Thank you.
00:24:22
Thank you, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:22
Thank you.
00:24:23
Action item 4H, which is Route 1 in Arlington County.
SPEAKER_01
00:24:28
Move approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:29
All in favor?
00:24:32
And I would just like to say, Mr. Waymack, thank you for three years of work.
00:24:35
We've finally achieved this transfer.
00:24:38
Yes, sir.
00:24:38
Thank you.
00:24:39
And just by way of note, this is a transfer of a highway asset for purposes of a bus facility for Arlington County.
00:24:49
It's immediately adjacent to the metro site so they can take advantage of the fueling facilities that are there.
00:24:56
And I believe, if memory serves me well, that
00:24:59
The Arlington Transit part is the fastest growing transit property in the state in terms of ridership.
00:25:08
So they've done very well and this allows them to build on some of the economies at the adjacent facilities.
SPEAKER_13
00:25:15
And could I add that right now we're having to use a bus facility as far as Springfield away for storage and this is definitely a wonderful economy and I appreciate so much the staff being so conscientious in following through on this.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:30
Thank you.
00:25:31
Action item 5A, which is a limited access on Route 895 in Henrico County.
00:25:37
Are there any questions?
00:25:38
Mr. Waymack, is there a motion?
SPEAKER_16
00:25:41
Move to second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:44
All in favor?
00:25:45
Aye.
00:25:46
And again, just an editorial comment.
00:25:48
That is one that has been a representative difficult set of issues.
00:25:55
But the resolution here and the value to the community where the county and the state have worked out a new alignment for the Virginia Capital Trail is just a tremendous amenity for both the county and the Commonwealth.
00:26:08
So thank you, Mr. Waymack.
00:26:11
Thank you.
00:26:11
Thank you.
00:26:11
Action item six, at the request of the chief engineer, that was a proposed memorandum.
00:26:17
between the Commonwealth and Maryland relating a Capital Beltway mobility study at his request as being pulled off the agenda for this week.
00:26:28
Just to note, there is a study underway of looking at mobility options across the Woodrow Wilson Bridge that Virginia is taking the lead on.
00:26:38
This is a recognition of a parallel study across the American Legion Bridge where Maryland is taking the lead.
00:26:47
After last Tuesday, there are some changes in Maryland, and they have indicated there will be continuity on these studies, and it probably makes some sense to have some further communications about how they want to structure and address this study.
00:27:05
Action item seven under the programming division.
00:27:10
Ms. Barbara Reese is here.
00:27:12
These are the programmatic transfers.
00:27:18
Are there any questions of Ms. Reese?
00:27:19
Now, let's take a minute to look at this and just see if there are any questions or concerns.
SPEAKER_13
00:27:27
For the benefit of the new members, you could just give a little background about what the process is.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:27:34
Up until this year, we were not able to keep our internal records up to date on changes in funding to make sure, for example, this month
00:27:43
As Mr. Dickens knows, there was an issue on a project down in the Tidewater area where there was additional funding needed to award it.
00:27:54
We can make recommendations about some funding adjustments to all projects within that district to try to cover the cost and whatnot.
00:28:03
Before that was a staff activity but we could never record it in our official statements or in our official records and in June you allowed us to be able to start doing that so we can always have up-to-date records and this report each month outlines each of those transfers to and from for various projects.
00:28:26
Districts are required to coordinate with you on any that are above 10%.
00:28:31
And that's what this report reflects, and this will be a standing item each month.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:37
Has everybody looked at the actual transfers?
00:28:40
This is very important.
00:28:42
And I would say, as we're in this environment of shrinking revenues and increasing costs, that this action item every month is going to take on increasing importance.
00:28:51
And we talked about hard choices that are going to be in the side.
00:28:54
Is there a motion?
00:28:57
Hello?
00:28:58
Is there a second?
00:29:00
Second.
00:29:00
All in favor?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:03
A question, Mr. Chairman.
00:29:05
Is there a process that you go through when you start pulling money from different projects?
00:29:13
How do you accomplish that?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:29:14
One of the things we look at is it has to be the same type of funding.
00:29:19
For example, if it's federal bridge funds, the first thing we do is look for another source of federal bridge funds.
00:29:25
If it's a primary system project, we look for the primary system within that district.
00:29:30
We do a whole series of different analysis trying to pull dollars from different places.
00:29:36
In the case of this week,
00:29:38
What we were able to do, there was a project in the Hampton Roads region that had priority transportation funds, which are discretionary to the board.
00:29:45
The project has not moved as quickly as had been anticipated.
00:29:52
And in accordance with the goals of the board, where you finance projects to their schedule, we were able to move money from that project, which isn't moving priority transportation funds to another project, the Chincoteague Bridge, to keep it so it could be awarded.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:06
A follow-up question, Mr. Chairman, is how do you compensate those whose ox got gored with money taken?
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:30:14
That happens during the annual update of the program and again it's when everybody, you know, we're in the process now and I was going to tell Mr. Koelemay of updating.
00:30:22
In July you were given a book about the cost to complete all the projects in the six-year program.
00:30:27
The chief engineer earlier this week sent out a memo to all the districts telling them to update all the estimates based on our new inflation factors and we updated costs.
00:30:38
All that data has to be to us by December 1st.
00:30:41
Then we will generate that report again for the December board meeting and you'll see what the cost to complete has changed.
00:30:48
Some may go up, some may go down.
00:30:49
I expect all of them are going to go up.
00:30:51
Hopefully some will come down, and that'll sort of set the basis for what your next update of the Six-Year Program will be.
00:30:58
You know, the project that we took money from for Chinga Tig was the intermodal connector, which is simply not moving as quickly as what it hoped, and the action of the MPO has thrown everything in hilders.
00:31:12
So it doesn't affect schedule of that project, and that's what we look for, projects where the schedules won't be affected.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:18
Okay, so those folks, the projects that money is taken from won't suffer.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:31:25
Ideally they don't suffer.
00:31:26
I can't say they're not going to suffer, but ideally they're the least contentious or least painful of all.
00:31:34
But as the Secretary said, with periods of declining revenue, you know, we just don't have a healthy outlook and it continues to not suffer.
00:31:44
Not improved, to say the least.
00:31:50
Motor vehicle sales and use tax are down significantly for the year, much more than what had been projected.
00:31:57
Not a pretty picture.
SPEAKER_02
00:32:00
Mr. Chairman, Ms. Reese, but there is an additional step between the staff recommendations and the board.
00:32:07
In other words, could you just review that for us?
00:32:11
In other words, how we learn of these things?
00:32:13
Right.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:32:13
What is supposed to happen by the procedures that have been established by your resolution and then also by the internal procedures we established
00:32:21
In all these cases, the district is supposed to contact you and let you know and discuss with you, here's the situation, here's our recommendation.
00:32:30
They make a recommendation to the programming division.
00:32:34
We have to verify funding, expenditures, etc.
00:32:38
But that can't even come to programming until they've talked to you and documented they've talked to you and have your general appeal.
00:32:44
And Mr. Witt, for example, had some concerns that we tried to mitigate.
00:32:50
And we were able to mitigate those concerns.
00:32:53
And then it comes here just for the official action of the entire board.
00:32:59
This used to be somewhat of a hidden part of the process and we're trying to make it more upfront so that as we put the six-year program together in the spring and if your comments and thoughts and your direction, it's not so difficult to get it done.
00:33:14
It helps streamline the process.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:16
If the Hampton Roads issue is not in this center.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:33:21
If it's not in here, it will be taken care of.
00:33:25
It's probably because it's not 10% or more because of the size of that project.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:31
Any other questions of Ms. Reese?
00:33:35
Thank you, Barbara.
00:33:37
The next item, Action Item 8, is location approval for the Harrisonburg Southeast Connector.
00:33:43
There's a long history to this project and there have been a number of presentations to the Commonwealth Transportation Board over the years.
00:33:50
I'd ask Mr. Walton if you could give a brief overview of the issues and the department's recommendation on this project.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
00:33:56
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
00:33:57
The Harrisonburg-Southeast connector is proposed as an east-west transportation link in the southeastern Harrisonburg metropolitan area that will connect major highways and major activity centers within the study area.
00:34:13
The study area boundaries are between U.S. Route 11 I-81 and U.S. Route 33.
00:34:20
The purpose and need of the study was to improve direct east-west mobility across the study area to connect major activity centers and major highways and also to accommodate current and future travel demand across the study area.
00:34:35
A draft environmental impact statement was approved by the Federal Highway Administration in March of this year.
00:34:42
Public hearings were held in May of this year.
00:34:46
There were 143 comments received.
00:34:49
There were five alternatives studied along with the no-build alternative and candidate-build alternative four was the most favored of all the alternatives with 44% of the comments favoring that candidate-build alternative.
00:35:04
One of the major issues identified during the study was the effect that Candidate Bill Alternative 1 would have on the Cross Keys Battlefield, which is a key historic area within the study area.
00:35:16
Now, all potential alternatives that would go through the Battlefield were eliminated from further consideration except for the CBA 1.
00:35:26
And although CBA 1 goes through the Battlefield along existing route 276, we are not recommending this alternative.
00:35:35
CBA 4 and a portion of CBA 1 are identified in the Metropolitan Planning Organization's constrained long-range plan.
00:35:47
The Department recommends that the location of this project be approved on the Candidate Build Alternative 4 alignment as presented at the location public hearing and on a portion of Candidate Build Alternative 1
00:36:02
from Interstate 81 to Route 276 with four specific projects that were identified in your decision brief.
00:36:12
Cannon Build Alternative 4 is supported by both the city and county governments, the citizens participating in the location public hearing process, and agencies commenting on the draft environmental impact statement.
00:36:26
Cannon Build Alternative 4 responds to travel needs in the northern portion of the study corridor,
00:36:32
by enhancing east-west mobility across the northern portion of the study area.
00:36:37
As I mentioned previously, CBA IV is included in the MPO's constrained long-range plan.
00:36:45
The environmental consequences of CBA IV are relatively low in comparison to those of the other alternatives.
00:36:51
Now, CBA 1 was also supported by city and county governments.
00:36:55
And recently, there's been indication by both governments that they are also in favor of the CBA 1 alternative, which staff is recommending that the board approve.
00:37:06
And again, that alternative enhances east-west mobility across the southern portion of the study area, but eliminates an effect on a key battlefield in the area.
00:37:19
A portion of CBA 1 along Route 682 is currently also in the MPO's Constrained Long Range Plan for Secondary Road Improvements.
00:37:29
The cost of CBA 4, again this is a planning cost based on a 500 foot wide planning corridor, is approximately $50 million.
00:37:40
The cost of CBA 1 modified, again with a 500 foot planning corridor, is approximately $68 million.
00:37:49
and again I want to emphasize those are planning corridors and the actual design corridor will be somewhere in the neighborhood of 150 feet which obviously will lessen the impacts on displacements, you know, right-of-way acquisitions and design costs.
00:38:05
Staff would recommend that the Board approve Candidate Build Alternative 4 and Candidate Build Alternative 1 modified as set forth in your decision brief.
00:38:14
I'll be happy to answer any questions you may have.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:17
Are there any questions?
00:38:18
Mr. Walton.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:20
Mr. Chairman, I believe they've done a yeoman's job in working on this and the fact that we have as much consensus as we do is very positive and therefore I would move that we approve it.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:34
Mr. Dickens.
00:38:37
A question.
00:38:38
The link between land use and transportation obviously is a big issue all around the city and the Commonwealth.
00:38:48
And I noticed in the comments from the public that there was some concern about this project inducing some sprawl.
00:38:56
I would like to see in the future when projects of this nature come to us
00:39:03
to have some type of mapping or some reference so that we can have a better understanding of what impact this is going to have on land use decisions and transportation, the connection with transportation, an aerial map or whatever the case may be.
00:39:24
And I will support this one, but as they come to us in the future, I'd like to be able to
00:39:30
to judge for myself as to whether we're exacerbating what is already a bad transportation system by inducing some sprawling type development.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:45
Any other questions?
00:39:46
There's a motion and a second on the floor.
00:39:47
All in favor?
00:39:48
Aye.
00:39:49
Thank you.
Richard L. Walton Jr.
Chief of Policy and Environment
00:39:50
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:51
Action Item 9.
00:39:54
Mr. Don Silas will be here today.
00:39:56
Is this a good month or a bad month?
SPEAKER_06
00:39:58
This is a good month, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:00
Excellent.
SPEAKER_06
00:40:01
Good morning.
00:40:03
We have 10 projects in total to bring to you today.
00:40:06
That's the most we've had in an awful long time.
00:40:08
We've got three different lettings in this group of projects.
00:40:12
We have the October 25th letting, which would be normal.
00:40:16
We also had some left over from
00:40:18
I'd like to present these in accordance to the way they appear in your book.
00:40:47
and the first project is primary project it's I-16 Route 5 bridge and we had excellent competition on this bridge we had four bidders we had one non-traditional bidder when I say that it all of our bidders of course have to be pre-qualified but sometimes we get folks from out of state that don't bid with us very often so we're attracting some people from out of state which is
00:41:15
I would ask that you approve that project.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:32
May I say something about this one, Mr. Chairman?
00:41:37
I really would like to commend the VDOT staff on this Chickahominy River Bridge project.
00:41:44
Four years ago it didn't exist and we had a bridge that was a serious problem and here we are in what I would consider record time actually
00:41:56
I'm going to build this thing and it is one of the most important projects in my district and it's going forward with great haste and with great ability and at less cost than we estimated.
00:42:09
So this is a four-star project as far as I'm concerned.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:14
Probably worth reminding board members that this bridge has been shut down at least three times due to very serious safety concerns and as good as this project is that three years ago was 41 million dollars we didn't think we had to spend.
00:42:27
And so this issue of failing bridges is a live, very real issue.
00:42:32
There are going to be some other bid awards today that are going to raise the same issue, but we have to protect the public safety and that's what this is about.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:40
I would also say that I very much appreciate, and I know our district administrators and staff appreciate the smooth working relationship with the Hampton Roads District because this is a joint project and it just couldn't have been handled better.
00:42:56
Thank you.
00:42:56
There's a motion and a second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:57
All in favor?
00:42:59
Aye.
SPEAKER_06
00:43:02
The next project is 340.
00:43:03
This is the bridge at the, really right at the border of Page and Warren Counties over overall run.
00:43:13
We have three bidders on that in an area where we oftentimes don't get a lot of competition, so we're real happy with that.
00:43:19
We got an excellent deal on that project.
00:43:21
I'd ask for your award to that project as well.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:25
I move approval.
00:43:27
All in favor?
00:43:30
Aye.
SPEAKER_06
00:43:32
Moving now to the secondary routes, Route 651.
00:43:36
And this is a little project in Chesterfield County that's right above Pocahontas Parkway.
00:43:45
As you can see, we had six bidders on that.
00:43:47
Excellent competition.
00:43:48
We got an excellent deal on it.
00:43:49
I'd like to recommend a word of that.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:51
Move approval.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:52
Second.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:54
All in favor?
00:43:59
Aye.
SPEAKER_03
00:43:59
Mr. Chairman, I'd like to abstain from the vote to award this event as a crime.
00:44:13
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:15
That will be noted.
SPEAKER_06
00:44:21
And moving now to Route 608, this is West Docks Road.
00:44:25
This is just north of Fair Oaks Mall.
00:44:28
Much needed improvement in Northern Virginia.
00:44:30
Five competitors on that.
00:44:33
Excellent deal.
00:44:34
I'd like to recommend an award to that.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:37
All in favor?
SPEAKER_06
00:44:44
The next project on the list is a wetland and stream mitigation bank.
00:44:50
Now this is a type of project, it's very specialized, and we typically don't get a lot of competition on this, but in this one we did have three bidders.
00:44:58
We got an excellent deal, and I would like to offer this for award as well.
00:45:10
We have three projects from the September letting.
00:45:14
First one is I-15.
00:45:16
This is one of the safety improvements on Route 15 that goes back probably 10 years on safety improvements and truck turnouts lanes in Loudoun.
00:45:29
This is just a little bit south of Lucketts.
00:45:32
We had six bidders on that, excellent competition.
00:45:36
I'd like to recommend that for award.
SPEAKER_02
00:45:38
Mr. Chairman, could I just bring the board attention?
00:45:42
This Route 15 is an increasingly critical link between Northern Virginia and Maryland.
00:45:50
And it wasn't engineered for the traffic that it's carrying now, and it has been dangerous for a long time, and a larger decision is what we do in that whole corridor going forward.
00:46:00
This is certainly a step in the right direction, and I'm moved we accept this bid.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:06
The next project is Route 40.
SPEAKER_06
00:46:12
This is at the Sussex and Surrey County line.
00:46:17
Seven competitors on this.
00:46:19
Another excellent deal which proves that if you have competition, you usually get good deals and I'd like to recommend that for award.
00:46:34
Next project from September is Route 600.
00:46:38
This is known as Frog Level Road.
00:46:41
We had five competitors in an area that, and there again, traditionally we don't have a lot of competition in.
00:46:47
We got an excellent deal on that.
00:46:48
I'd like to recommend that for award.
SPEAKER_01
00:46:51
I so move for approval.
00:46:53
Second.
00:46:53
All in favor?
00:46:54
Aye.
SPEAKER_06
00:46:56
Now if we could move to the pink sheets that I believe were inserted this morning.
00:47:00
You have not seen these before since we just took these in November the 8th.
00:47:05
But two very important projects.
00:47:08
First project is I-66.
00:47:10
This is the Gainesville Interchange.
00:47:12
This ties into a project that is
00:47:14
It is almost completed in the same area, and those of you that drive through the area know this to be a very congested location, and it's an up-and-coming area of Northern Virginia.
00:47:26
It's much needed improvement, and we had four competitors on this.
00:47:33
Again, excellent bargain, we think, for the job, so we'd like to recommend that for award.
SPEAKER_02
00:47:39
VDOT's reputation went up 100%.
00:47:44
When the other part of 66, the four lanes opened last week, it's a huge, huge relief to this area.
00:47:51
So, with great pleasure, I urge we adopt this bill.
SPEAKER_06
00:48:00
And then the final project for today is 175.
00:48:04
This is the Chincoteague Bridge.
00:48:08
We had a non-traditional, actually we had two non-traditional bidders on this, one of which was successful, American Bridge out of Pittsburgh.
00:48:17
If you don't know them, they're working on the Woodrow Wilson Bridge now, and they work all up and down the East Coast.
00:48:24
And I think that has helped us get a very good price.
00:48:28
The non-traditional bidders use traditional marketplaces trends and they use traditional suppliers and when we get competition from out of the area they're able to avail themselves to other suppliers which usually results in good deals.
00:48:44
So we got an excellent deal on this and like to recommend it forward.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:48
Is there a motion?
00:48:50
Motion for approval?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:52
Second.
00:48:53
All in favor?
00:48:53
Aye.
00:48:54
And suggest a savings go to the King's Highway Bridge.
00:48:57
We would like to make a motion over here that all the savings come our way.
SPEAKER_13
00:49:02
Mr. Chairman, can I just ask that there are two that are significantly below the Lord and the project in Fairfax County and also this one.
00:49:14
There were no design changes.
00:49:15
It's just reflective of
SPEAKER_06
00:49:19
We've noticed the marketplace coming back.
00:49:21
You know, the last year or so, we've not been getting very much competition.
00:49:26
We've not been getting very good prices, price escalation.
00:49:31
We've talked about what's happened with steel and asphalt and concrete.
00:49:34
Those have leveled out.
00:49:36
Competition has come back.
00:49:38
Some of our folks that were doing work for the developer have come back and are working for us again.
00:49:43
And whenever we see this kind of competition, it results in good prices for us.
SPEAKER_03
00:49:48
Mr. Witt.
00:49:49
Just a point of clarification as we look at this pink sheet and think there's a new savings.
00:49:55
The $68 million is the construction cost.
00:49:57
The $90 million is the total project cost.
00:50:00
We still have substantial other costs other than construction that's going to... That's correct.
SPEAKER_06
00:50:05
It's got the CEI in it.
00:50:07
It doesn't have design and right-of-way, but it does have the construction engineering cost as well.
SPEAKER_03
00:50:12
We didn't have a $22 million savings.
00:50:15
I don't know that there's much of any.
00:50:17
I'm sorry.
00:50:22
You all know how much I love this phrase.
SPEAKER_13
00:50:25
Well, maybe it should be clear that we do talk about apples and apples and apples and oranges.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:32
Yeah, I think, Mr. Chairman, I'm glad you pointed that out because I think I, for one, have been using that as a gauge in terms of the bids.
00:50:47
Six-year program number is not reflective.
00:50:50
If it's not an apples-to-apples comparison, you need to do something to make it an apples-to-apples comparison.
00:50:59
Is there, on that project, for instance, as an example, of the $90 million, how much of it was for construction costs?
00:51:07
Do you recall?
SPEAKER_06
00:51:09
Well, now, we do a couple of different estimates.
00:51:12
The early estimates are we don't know any quantities.
00:51:16
Basically, we just use parameters to set the original six-year plan cost, and we update that every year.
00:51:24
But it's never going to, that cost is never going to represent the cost we expect to get in a bid, because there's so many other factors that enter into it.
00:51:33
But we do, right before we take in bids, we do in essence what is VDOT's bid.
00:51:41
We have a group of estimators that call around, get quotes, put together virtual crews, and in essence put together VDOT's bid for the work.
00:51:50
And that is our decision estimate.
00:51:51
That's what we use to see if we're getting a good deal
00:51:54
According to the marketplace at the very time we're advertising it.
00:51:58
Because as we noticed over the past year when prices were spiraling upward, we had difficulty keeping up with the marketplace just like contractors did.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:08
I'm sorry I asked the question inappropriately, but the material we received, for instance, for this project would have
00:52:17
We could do that in future, sir.
SPEAKER_06
00:52:38
Pull the construction engineering part out of it.
SPEAKER_05
00:52:43
I believe we put that in there when we were awarding contracts that were higher than the dollar value we had in our six-year program.
00:52:52
And we were saying, well, where's this money coming from?
00:52:55
And then, of course, we have additional needs probably.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:59
And there's a couple things going on here.
00:53:01
The figure that is shown in the six-year program is based on data that's 12, 15, 18 months old.
00:53:09
The number, the estimate that Mr. Silas references, the engineer's estimate, that's a highly confidential piece of information, and I'm not sure that we want to be in the practice of requesting or discussing that publicly, but that does factor into the recommendation of staff.
00:53:29
There may not be enough money in the six-year program, but there may also be an evaluation that says, look, this is a good
00:53:38
The proposal based on our assessment of market conditions and risk and we don't think the prices are going to get any better if we delay.
00:53:47
We've got three, you know, competition.
00:53:49
The good thing about all these, there have been three or four bids on virtually every one of these projects and that wasn't true nine months ago.
00:53:56
So that's an important evolution.
00:53:58
Having said that, I do think there's some value in the department looking at just having the six-year program construction number
00:54:07
in there, because that's what the public sees, but we also need to understand there's a more up-to-date standard, which is done internally as part of the bid evaluations.
00:54:16
Is that a fair characterization, Mr. Carley?
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:20
Yes, sir.
SPEAKER_08
00:54:20
To answer your question, and I think, Mr. Witt, as this, we did move some money early on for this project.
00:54:28
I think the P.E.
00:54:29
's around $10 million right away is in the $5 million neighborhood, and I think they've got
00:54:36
10, 12 million dollars I think for CE type cost in there.
00:54:39
Just top of my head not looking at it.
00:54:41
So I think we had, if you look at the construction dollars, it was somewhere around, I'm thinking 70 was in there.
00:54:47
I don't know if that's the right number.
00:54:49
I was hoping that we'd get five million dollars less than this, but it was a pretty good bid with the bidders that we had in there.
00:54:58
But that answers your question.
00:54:59
So if it was construction costs, we'd probably be somewhere in the 60s on this.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:06
Thank you, Mr. Dickens.
E. Dana Dickens III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:09
Rookie question here.
00:55:10
The $90 million that was in the Six-Year Program, is that money that was budgeted for this project and is that real money or is that money that we're expecting to get from someplace?
00:55:26
I'm a little confused as to what that number represents.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:30
My understanding is that number is taken from the Six-Year Program.
00:55:35
The Six-Year Program was based on best available revenue and cost estimates over a year ago.
00:55:43
And what it represents under the Code of Virginia Transportation is different than general fund agencies.
00:55:50
We can commit
00:55:51
future revenues beyond the current budget cycle because we have to in capital budgeting.
00:55:59
And so what it represents is that snapshot in time, a best guesstimate base, it's more than a guesstimate, based on the VDOT official revenue estimating process.
00:56:10
That's a transparent, publicly available process.
00:56:13
We spent a lot of time on that at the beginning, front end of the Six-Year Program.
00:56:17
It is also a product of the VDOT cost estimation system
00:56:20
which actually did not exist three or four years ago.
00:56:25
And in fact, we saw the difference between the cost estimate in the six-year program and actual cost estimates was 184%.
00:56:36
was the gap, and that was when we took a snapshot in 2002.
00:56:40
That gap has closed tremendously, and I think you're seeing that with these bits.
00:56:47
They're within, even though it is a painful process, as Mr. Witt will tell you on the Chincoteague Bridge.
00:56:52
There will have to be reallocations from other projects to make up the difference, but we're talking a percentage difference that in the grand scheme of things is manageable.
00:57:07
For example, in January of 2002, we had $250 million worth of contracts that had been opened, recommended for award, and we discovered we did not have the cash for.
00:57:22
And so we got to this stage of meeting and said we can't award those contracts because we are not in a position to enter into those contracts because we cannot assure that we have the funds necessary to do that.
00:57:36
So it is an evolutionary process.
00:57:39
I think the question about the apples-to-apples comparison is an important one.
00:57:43
And I would ask the staff and commissioner if they can look at refining that a little bit.
00:57:52
It's an excellent set of questions.
00:57:55
Where you'll see this is in that previous section that Ms. Reese briefed you on, where you have to
SPEAKER_03
00:58:03
be a part of some very, very difficult decisions.
00:58:06
And we have moved some money around already on this one between projects.
00:58:11
But this bid award, from what I understand, will still have us within budget.
00:58:18
It's just that there's no huge difference between what we have here and what the ultimate budget is.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:27
Thank you, Mr. Silas.
00:58:29
Is there any new business to come before the board?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:32
Mr. Davis.
00:58:33
Just one item.
00:58:34
Mr. Ellis' comments intrigued me a little bit, although I know the complexity of trying to have the CTB issue opinions about public policy issues that the legislature really decide.
00:58:48
But I would be curious if the secretary would comment on the value of us supporting some of your initiatives with the legislature with a resolution.
00:58:59
Is that something that's worthy of the board spending some time doing?
00:59:04
Or is that something that's best left to general discussion?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:08
Mr. Davis, I think the CTB did indeed pass a resolution in November, December, January calling on the General Assembly to make available revenues and articulating the long-term needs.
00:59:22
I don't believe that it was necessarily a blanket.
00:59:25
Endorsement of the Governor's Program, it was simply calling those needs and it was transmitted to the General Assembly is my recollection.
00:59:39
So it's not inappropriate but I would say it's also that task has been undertaken and we gotta keep on that educational process of talking to state legislators about the financial condition of our transportation system.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:55
I've always had the question in the back of my mind, even though I sat on the other chair in the past, how much the general view of legislators would be of value of our opinion on some of the issues of funding sources or whatever, whether it's viewed negatively or positively.
01:00:15
I never had a real opinion on that, to be honest with you.
01:00:18
Since we are appointees,
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:21
I would suggest that, again, we've got, you know, the governor clearly has a position.
01:00:26
We are appointees of the governor.
01:00:28
The CTB has gone on record in support of additional funding for transportation, and my view is the important thing is breaking that message down and taking it back to a community and to individual legislators.
01:00:42
It's one thing to talk about
01:00:44
The very large scale needs of transportation and what could or might be done to improve that situation is another thing to bring it back home and literally to bring it to a kitchen table in a way that individual legislators and communities can understand because there is a gulf between
01:01:06
Thank you very much.
01:01:10
Mr. McCarthy?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:19
Do you anticipate for our December meeting the timing that the Governor might have released whatever financial recommendations he might be making to the General Assembly?
01:01:30
If that turns out to be the case, the timing is right, maybe we could consider some sort of resolution next month in this regard.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:40
The guess is, and I would never prejudge the timing of the governor, but that would be embedded in his budget recommendations, which I think happened just a couple of days after our CTB meeting.
01:01:49
Now, he may choose to pre-announce some aspects of that budget, so we will have a timing issue there, and I'll make sure that the governor's office is aware of that interest to hopefully get in front of that issue a little bit.
01:02:07
Any other new business?
01:02:09
Is there a motion to adjourn?
01:02:13
All in favor?
01:02:14
Thank you and drive safely.
01:02:15
Southside Virginia is experiencing some fairly heavy rain so again please exercise caution on the road tunnel.