Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 10/20/2005
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
10/20/2005
Attachments
Board actions.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
Meeting agenda.pdf
Public Comment: Mr. Pete Green, Mill Creek Farm Subdivision
Approval of Minutes September 15, 2005
INNOVATIVE FINANCE AND REVENUE OPERATIONS
1. Transportation Partnership Opportunity Fund
A. Approval of Guidelines and Criteria for the Transportation
ASSET MANAGEMENT
2. Action on Highway Designations
A. Naming the bridge on Interstate Route 85 over Lake Gaston in
RIGHT OF WAY AND UTIILITIES
3. Action on Land Conveyances
A. Route 6 and Old Route 600, Goochland County
B. Route 24, Campbell County
C. Route 236, Fairfax City
DEPARTMENT OF RAIL AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
4. Action on Rail Enhancement Program:
A. Adoption of Policy Goals and Implementation Guidelines\
INNOVATIVE PROJECT DELIVERY
5. Action on Public-Private Transportation Act (PPTA) Guidelines:
A. Concurrence with the Draft Public-Private Transportation Act (PPTA) Guidelines
SCHEDULING & CONTRACT DIVISION
6. Action on Bids Received: the month of September 2005
NEW BUSINESS
ADJOURNMENT
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:04
Good morning and welcome to the October Business Session of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:00:10
Welcome.
00:00:12
We're going to begin our business meeting with public comment and our first speaker is Mr. Pete Green of the Mill Creek Farm Subdivision.
00:00:21
Mr. Green, welcome.
SPEAKER_08
00:00:24
Thank you.
00:00:24
Good morning.
00:00:26
Thank you to the board.
00:00:28
And we'll make it brief.
00:00:29
I live in the Zuni area of Isle of Wight County in a subdivision called Mill Creek Farms.
00:00:38
On July 19th of this year when we first saw the actual road alignment, our world was sort of turned upside down.
00:00:47
This road, as aligned initially, will bulldoze 30 houses in our neighborhood.
00:00:54
I don't mean this to be facetious, but if
00:00:57
If the designers had put a blindfold on and drawn the road to Isle of Wight, they could not possibly have hit more homes than they did with this environment.
00:01:06
The subdivision was approved by Isle of Wight about 20 years ago when I moved there from Princeton County or Virginia Beach now.
00:01:14
It was approved in an ag and forest district as a
00:01:19
There are about 60 houses in the immediate neighborhood.
00:01:24
Five have been built since this road was aligned.
00:01:28
And we live in the country, we understand what that means.
00:01:33
You know, we accept dust clouds when they're harvesting peanuts, the smell of cotton seed oil when they're getting their cotton up.
00:01:42
We accept the smoke when farmers burn off the fields and we don't mind the slow moving equipment on the road when we want to go somewhere.
00:01:49
But in an effort to save our homes, we met with the Iowa White County Board of Supervisors, explained our concern.
00:01:56
I then contacted VDOT and eventually wound up talking to Mr. Jim Clark.
00:02:01
And we talked about if the CBA 1 is the route chosen, selecting an alternate location in our immediate area to avoid the impact on these houses.
00:02:16
A new road, as you probably may already know, is estimated to be about 62 miles in length.
00:02:22
The current 460 is just over 50 miles from 295 to the 258 bypass in Suffolk.
00:02:31
The board specifically directed correspondence, which I now, the board for some reason got irritated about the correspondence.
00:02:39
with VDOT, and they just withdrew all previous correspondence.
00:02:43
But they did ask VDOT to avoid the homes in this neighborhood, and I have their letter, which I'm sure VDOT has, stating so.
00:02:53
The value of the houses that will be knocked down, it's about $7.8 million.
00:03:00
The value of the farms impacted by this alternate route is about $637,000.
00:03:10
The loss to the county of these houses being torn down is about $54,000 a year in tax revenue, which will go away.
00:03:21
The assessments I got from the Hiloike County Tax Commissioner and
00:03:27
As far as I know they're correct, except I think they're going to reassess them this year.
00:03:32
I will tell you that of the four homes that have sold in our neighborhood over the last three years, every home sold for no less than $50,000 more than the appraised value.
00:03:45
I wouldn't particularly want Alan White to know that.
00:03:48
He may up our appraiser.
00:03:51
We understand the necessity for this road and the necessity is to support the Port to help increasing traffic to the Port.
00:04:02
Everything else is fluff.
00:04:04
460 can't be used as a hurricane evacuation route, but you have to leave home when the sun is shining.
00:04:11
You can't wait until the wind is ripping the gutters off your house in Virginia Beach or Chesapeake to decide you're going to get out of town.
00:04:19
You probably won't even get to the high-level bridge on the Elizabeth River because there will be so many traffic jams.
00:04:26
Yesterday, the speaker mentioned that 48% of the respondents favored the CBA 1.
00:04:35
The reason that is, CBA 1 is the least populated area.
00:04:39
CBA 2 and CBA 3 had probably five times as many representatives at that meeting as we did.
00:04:46
So it's the not in my backyard syndrome.
00:04:49
So I'm sure 48% might even have been low for the people that favored elsewhere.
00:04:55
Just as a comment, and I'm not trying to put it in their backyard, but CBA III, if looped north into the Bowers Hill 664 interchange area, would be a much more rapid movement of those trucks into the port because they have the western branch freeway, which is a direct shot into the port.
00:05:18
258, where they now intend to dump this new road,
00:05:23
There's already one for the bumper every morning.
00:05:26
They can't even handle all the trucks that are riding that road in the morning during the daytime.
00:05:32
Many times I ride by there, they've closed the scales because the trucks were backing up into the traffic lane.
00:05:39
So I appreciate your time.
00:05:42
Thank you very much.
00:05:43
If you have any questions, briefly, each of these white arrows represents a house that will be bulldozed.
00:05:51
I have the pictures of the pumps.
00:05:53
We offer an offer to crowd staff around the wetland.
00:05:57
which is 900 feet long from this point to this point, but this route does not hit one house, does not, it comes within full 500 feet of a house over here, but it does not cause any houses to be bulldozed, and it will protect our neighborhood.
00:06:14
There is another alternate route, and I think VDOT did that, but they did not show that to us.
00:06:20
But thank you very much, and if there's any questions, I'll be glad to respond.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:25
Okay.
00:06:25
Any questions of Mr. Green?
SPEAKER_08
00:06:27
Again, thank you Mr. Green.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:51
Our next speaker is Ms. Pat Jenkins.
00:06:54
Also in relation to the Route 460 location study, welcome Ms. Jenkins.
SPEAKER_03
00:06:59
Thank you Mr. Chairman, I appreciate your time this morning.
00:07:04
I am from Sussex County, and I'm a lifelong resident and landowner in Sussex.
00:07:09
My family and I do own several farms in Sussex and Surrey counties.
00:07:15
We've been hunting, fishing, and providing farmlands, timberlands, and open waters for wildlife for many generations, as I am fourth generation farmers from both sides of the family.
00:07:27
We protect and enhance our farm for the good of wildlife, livestock, and agriculture.
00:07:33
As a family that has enjoyed and literally lived off the land for generations, we wish to continue this environment for the farmers and the wildlife.
00:07:42
Regarding the wildlife, the northern sites listed in the study do contain federal and state protected species, and it's much larger on the north side than on the south side.
00:07:54
The northern area of the study contains increasing sightings of mature and young bald eagles, migratory birds, and nests.
00:08:02
With the James River within 10 to 15 miles of Waverly and the other towns along the study area and the growing population of endangered threatened species, I propose that the state and federal agencies concentrate on maintaining the current environment and noise levels in this area on the northern side of 460 to assist these species in their population growth.
00:08:25
Furthermore, the study area is a longtime farming community.
00:08:29
Farming residents' economic well-being will be greatly impacted by the proposed routes in the North as it slices through the middle of several family farms.
00:08:40
Regarding industrial development in Sussex County, the southern side of 460 is the location of the county's industrial development activities, which include an existing
00:08:51
Particle Board Plant in Waverly, two existing trucking companies in Waverly, all of these are on the south side of Waverly, existing Atlantic Waste Landfill, which receives hundreds of trucks daily, two existing state prisons,
00:09:07
an existing Sussex-Sorris Authority sewage treatment plant for the county and surrounding counties, a proposed recycling plant that has already been approved, and a proposed power plant all in the southern side of the county or in the southern side of Route 460 in and around Waverly.
00:09:25
In reviewing the letters from the local governments in your study, the town of Windsor's industrial development area is also south of the region, or 460.
00:09:34
In fact, Holloway County has made significant investments in public sewer and water in their three development service districts, with the significant Windsor one located to the southeast of the town.
00:09:45
In addition, this county has worked with landowners to designate the balance of the county as rural agricultural conservation areas with the bulk of the county agriculture north of the existing Route 460.
00:09:58
Locating a new limited access highway in rural agricultural areas totally removed from established industrial areas is inconsistent with any county's basic premises of a comprehensive development area.
00:10:12
In the interest of homeland security, nuclear disasters such as the Surrey Nuclear Plant and natural disasters, the most logical alternative would be a route further away from other evacuation routes such as Interstate 64 and further away from the Nuclear Power Plant and the large military presence in the Hampton Roads area.
00:10:32
Based on these facts, I recommend one of the following options regarding Route 460.
00:10:38
And I've also talked to numerous neighbors in my area and you can see that Waverly is very interested in having this road on the south side.
00:10:48
We would prefer to see that you build CBA 1 on the north side of 460.
00:10:54
2.
00:10:54
You enhance or upgrade the existing road with the addition of a fifth lane to serve as a middle turning lane from Petersburg to Suffolk.
00:11:03
As discussed in the VDOT summary of comments, which you did not receive the document yesterday, many governing bodies and citizens requested this option, but I don't feel it was highlighted in yesterday's discussion.
00:11:18
Further discussions need to be held with the local governing bodies of the counties and towns as to why this option is not feasible.
00:11:26
Because right now, the Board of Supervisors of Sussex has only concentrated on adding a turn lane to the existing road.
00:11:35
And then thirdly, bypass the town of Waverly and others south of the railroad.
00:11:39
Again, in Waverly, it's because of our industrial development sites.
00:11:42
My reasons for all these include the large number of existing and proposed industrial developments south of the railroad, increasing wildlife population on the north of 460 due to its location in relation to the James River, large amount of open farmland acreage that supports the local farmer's livelihood, large amount of timberland in the south that could be harvested at market value prior to construction with less funding from the state.
00:12:09
and lastly a greater safety distance from military and nuclear disaster and hurricane evacuation routes in the state that already exist.
00:12:18
Recently I spoke with Congressman Randy Forbes in Colonial Heights.
00:12:22
We discussed a citizen advisory committee for this project and he was in favor of this proposal.
00:12:28
He has referred me to his transportation staff in DC for further discussion.
00:12:32
As suggested by the Chairman yesterday at the Board meeting, I recommend that further time be given to the large amount of options for this critical transportation need of the Commonwealth.
00:12:43
Other options need to be further evaluated in conjunction with the proposed route.
00:12:48
This evaluation needs to include an understanding of the impact of existing and proposed industrial development to the south of the existing roadway.
00:12:57
In addition, further study of alternatives to truck traffic should include increased freight shipments by rail and by way of the James River up to the Richmond Port, which would need improvements to accommodate a larger number of container ships.
00:13:13
But in that way, it would reduce the number of trucks.
00:13:16
In addition to Secretary Homer's recommendation for RFPs to consider more possibilities, I recommend further study including a citizen advisory committee with representatives from the towns, counties, and individual citizens to work with the project team.
00:13:32
These are normally held, as I understand, in Northern Virginia.
00:13:36
These advisory committees usually exist.
00:13:40
That's what Jim Clark told me, the project manager.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:44
Oftentimes, yes.
00:13:46
Can you conclude your remarks, please?
SPEAKER_03
00:13:48
Yes.
00:13:49
I appreciate your time today.
00:13:51
And I've left a copy of more detail in my comments in front of each of you.
00:13:56
And yes, I am on two of the three alternatives.
00:13:58
But at the same time, you know, if it has to come through my way, it has to.
00:14:02
But it also should be the least cost-effective and efficient roadway.
00:14:06
Thank you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:08
Thank you, Ms. Jenkins.
00:14:09
Are there any questions of Ms. Jenkins or any follow-up comments?
00:14:14
Ms. Hanley.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:15
Can we ask the gentleman to come back with this map?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:17
Sure.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:19
Because I do have a question.
00:14:20
Mr. Green, do you mind?
00:14:21
Do you mind?
00:14:22
This is one of the better map presentations I've seen in 20 years of making your point.
00:14:27
Just set it up there so everybody can see it.
00:14:31
We're hearing a lot.
00:14:32
Let me be sure I understand what's happened here.
00:14:36
This has been on, the Isle of Wight supervisors approved this subdivision 20 years ago?
00:14:45
In 1984, 94, 85, whatever 20 years ago.
00:14:53
But five of the houses have been built since this study began?
SPEAKER_08
00:14:58
Oh, that are not indicated there?
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:14
And how long have we thought about having this?
00:15:19
Is there any other preserved right-of-way?
00:15:21
Does anybody know this answer along this corridor, or is this just a study corridor?
00:15:24
Have we preserved right-of-way before, or is this just a study corridor?
00:15:32
Is there anybody in staff here?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:35
Tom, are you aware of any right-of-way reservation?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:38
I'm not aware of any.
00:15:39
I believe it's just a study corridor.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:41
One of the things, the reasons that I asked to do that is I thought your point was about it blindfolded.
00:15:46
If we'd found a way to put it through more houses, we couldn't have hit more.
00:15:50
It was probably fairly accurate.
00:15:52
And it points out, I believe there's a lot of discussion currently about the need to coordinate land use and transportation.
00:15:59
and so this I think is a textbook case of the need to coordinate land use and transportation because even if there were lines on a plan even if we have once this got study got going the situation the localities in now today is they could have not prevented the five houses from going in there
00:16:21
Even if we approved this already, there would be no way for the locality to have prevented the additional five houses from going in.
00:16:31
So in the context for those of us that are listening to the discussion going on about the need to coordinate land use and transportation, this is a textbook case.
00:16:43
And I want to thank you for bringing such a graphic
00:16:46
graphic because it just makes it very clear there are five more not there.
00:16:53
There could be, even while this study is going on, some other people could be pulling permits and building houses while we're talking about it because the locality has no way, even if we'd approve this, the locality has no way to prevent it.
00:17:06
So coordinating land use and transportation is particularly important and I hope that's a message that we all get an opportunity to hear.
SPEAKER_08
00:17:14
Well, and the locality has no way to deny a permit.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:43
No way to deny a permit in that right-of-way.
00:17:45
Thank you very much.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:46
That was very helpful.
00:17:51
Mr. McCarthy?
00:17:52
Could you go back?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:53
Mr. Green, you're up again.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:54
This is fun.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:57
Please feel free to ask Ms. Jenkins questions too.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:59
We'll save a couple for her.
00:18:04
Could you repeat what you said about an alternative we didn't hear about, that instead of going on 258 servicing the port more efficiently with some alternative, could you spell that out or send us all a letter about that?
00:18:18
Because I didn't quite get that.
00:18:20
It sounded like it made good sense in theory, but I didn't quite follow the route you were talking about.
SPEAKER_08
00:18:27
VDOT even could do it much better.
00:18:30
I'm not an engineer, but the current road is to run into 258 in the area of Sutton, which is a bypass.
00:18:37
It is already stand up.
00:18:39
If you try to get on in the morning and go to work, you're going to be bumping and bumping.
00:18:43
If they move, whether they go, no matter which way they go, CBA III would be more conducive to curving north towards the Ballast Hill 664 interchange
00:18:55
And what would happen if you did what you're talking about, putting it up close to the barriers?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:14
Would that cut through all these agricultural districts?
SPEAKER_08
00:19:17
It would cut through South Ag district, it would have to cross the Nesman River, but 258 bypass crosses the Nesman River, so there would have to be a bridge, I'm sure, again, I'm sure, to speed up.
00:19:30
On the subject of coordinating land use and transportation planning, thank you very much.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:53
Maybe Ms. Jenkins could address this one.
00:19:56
The county has designated the area you're talking about that the northern route in Isle of Wight is an ag district, is that correct?
SPEAKER_03
00:20:08
Yes, that was in the study comments and the VDOT provided the draft environmental impact study.
00:20:16
I actually quoted the others in my letter that they said.
00:20:20
And the judges were not quite as settled or formal.
00:20:25
But in recent conversations with the chairman of the board, an official comment is, if you're not going to enlarge the existing route, if that's impossible and not feasible, then, yeah, we'd rather be focused on our industrial sites.
00:20:40
The same designated, for that part of the county, especially the big county, for that part is south of the railroad in 460.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:48
I was just trying to get a handle on here we've got local governments and certain state agencies encouraging the preservation of farmland and providing all kinds of ways to do that.
00:21:01
Then another state agency is theoretically talking about running a road right through that.
00:21:07
That seems to me to be, as Kate said, a textbook example of why we need to get together on those two things before making any decisions about it because that doesn't seem to have happened yet.
00:21:19
In fact, I don't know, I guess I'm not sure this one's ready for prime time yet, but I'd really like to see that explored, and I don't know if the idea of an advisory committee to do that makes sense or not.
00:21:31
I don't know enough about it, but I get the feeling that not everybody has been sitting around the same table talking about this yet, and to the degree that we could encourage that to happen, I think we might all learn something, maybe get a better solution.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:46
Thank you, Mr. McCarthy.
SPEAKER_16
00:21:48
Mr. Watson.
SPEAKER_01
00:21:49
We haven't heard from the Virginia Downer yet.
SPEAKER_08
00:21:53
I appreciate this sentiment, and I hope we will really take into consideration how it affects people's lives as we make this decision.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:01
Yes, sir, please come up and introduce yourself.
SPEAKER_09
00:22:08
My name is James Cobb.
00:22:09
I live in Iowa White County.
00:22:11
just south of the Mill Creek neighborhood.
00:22:14
I was involved in that.
00:22:16
And I didn't realize that you needed to be on the agenda to say anything this morning.
00:22:22
But my biggest concern, in Iowa White County, I was at board a supervisor's meeting.
00:22:29
And I think they walked our input.
00:22:34
Well, the best thing I've been able to get
00:22:37
with this brochure.
00:22:39
And this lady said that that was the best map she had seen.
00:22:43
Well, according to the people in the county, up until this envelope here, when I wrote back last time, it dated September the 19th, is what was sent to me at the end of that.
00:22:55
And after that, I was able to get on a map like this that was out there somewhere.
00:23:06
But it was too late to make any comments.
00:23:10
The only thing I'm saying is if you're going to hold public meetings and you don't look for input from the citizens, then you've got to give information before anybody gives input.
00:23:22
Now, I don't know how long this has been around.
00:23:26
But the only way I got it, I had to take it and go make copies of it, maybe get copies made or whatever.
00:23:32
And I don't really know where it would generate it or how it would generate it.
00:23:35
I think Mr. Green, I don't know that he got it and he come to Richmond or whatever.
00:23:40
But in a way, if...
00:23:43
If I'd have had this to look at six months ago, I could have found it in the bookshelf with VDOT.
00:23:49
But the only thing I'm saying, what you said yesterday, if it's going to be a public-private deal, then, you know, I just think it's in the tool.
00:23:58
Thank you so much for your comments.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:13
Any other comments?
00:24:16
Yes sir.
SPEAKER_09
00:24:19
In this community, we've got a railroad that runs through the community and we've got a high power transmission line that runs through the community.
00:24:27
Neither one of them are that desirable.
00:24:31
Both of them run in fairly straight lines.
00:24:33
On the south side of north and western railroads, other than the town of Iowabaw, Zunai, I know that's about an 11 mile stretch in there.
00:24:43
There'd be no impact on people, businesses of one of them.
00:24:49
And it looked to me like if you could align something with an existing
00:24:54
Thank you, sir.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:09
If you all will permit me just one second, obviously there are some community issues here, but they do clearly tie back to land use and something we have talked about in the VTrans planning document
00:25:22
and the major conference on environmental sustainability that we are one of the sponsors of in September.
00:25:29
The number one issue coming out of that conference was this issue.
00:25:34
How do you make land use and transportation planning fit together and not live in different worlds?
00:25:39
And so I thank the citizens.
00:25:41
I hope you go back and talk to your community about these issues.
00:25:44
This is not easy work, but it's terribly, terribly important.
00:25:47
And thank you so much for taking the time to share your thoughts with us this morning.
00:25:54
Okay, the next item on the agenda is the approval of the minutes.
00:26:00
Are there any comments before we take a motion?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:04
So moved.
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:05
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:06
All in favor?
00:26:08
Aye.
00:26:09
Thank you.
00:26:12
Action item number one is
00:26:16
The approval of the guidelines and criteria for the Transportation Partnership Opportunity Fund.
00:26:24
Ms. Reese, the Chief Financial Officer, is here to answer any questions.
00:26:27
We had a detailed presentation yesterday.
00:26:30
Are there any questions of Ms. Reese?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:32
I just had one little clarification.
00:26:34
As I was reading project eligibility,
00:26:37
I noticed that localities with a population of 50,000 to 100,000, there's a different opportunity for them to apply.
00:26:46
I'm curious how localities is defined in that particular case.
00:26:49
Is that a political jurisdiction or a combination of political jurisdictions?
SPEAKER_04
00:26:53
That's the Governor's Opportunity Fund criteria, and I think it's locality, individual locality, but I'm not...
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:00
Yes.
00:27:00
That would mean a political jurisdiction.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:02
A county, a city, a city or a town.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:05
So it would require a minimum of 50,000 people then?
SPEAKER_04
00:27:08
No, sir.
00:27:09
If you look at Appendix D, behind tab one, if you look, it breaks it down by numbers.
00:27:21
There's different criteria depending on the size of the locality.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:25
One of the things I want to clarify, Mr. Chairman, is the fact that 50,000 population is a minimum requirement, or not?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:33
No, sir.
SPEAKER_04
00:27:34
For 50,000 to 100,000, the minimum private investment is 5 million or at least 50 jobs.
00:27:41
If you're less than 50,000, it's 2.5 or 25 jobs.
00:27:45
See, there's different criteria based on population brackets.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:48
Very good.
00:27:49
Okay.
00:27:49
Any other questions of Ms. Reese?
00:27:52
Is there a motion?
00:27:55
All in favor?
00:27:58
Thank you.
00:27:58
And the Chair would just note, this is a very significant step, and this is going to help some important projects, hopefully in the very near future.
00:28:07
Over on page two under Asset Management,
00:28:13
This is action on a highway designation which is naming the bridge on Interstate 85 over Lake Gaston and Mecklenburg County as the Arthur T. Hart MD Bridge.
00:28:24
Mr. Hofrechter is here from Asset Management.
00:28:26
Are there any questions of Mr. Hofrechter?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:29
All in favor?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:34
Thank you for your presentation, Mr. Hofrechter.
00:28:44
The next item, item three, we have three separate actions on land conveyance and we'll take each one separately.
00:28:52
Mr. Stuart Waymack is here from Right-of-Way and Utilities.
00:28:56
Item 3A is Route 6 and Old Route 600 in Goochland County.
00:29:00
Are there any questions of Mr. Waymack?
00:29:05
All in favor?
00:29:08
Thank you.
00:29:09
Item 3B is Route 24 in Campbell County.
00:29:12
Are there any questions of Mr. Waymack?
00:29:14
all in favor and item 3C is route 236 in Fairfax City
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:25
Mr. Chairman, I'll move approval.
00:29:27
As the board will recall, we deferred this one last time because it was noticed in the wrong jurisdiction.
00:29:32
The applicant for the land use decision in Fairfax City actually sent me a copy of all the documentation, and this has been corrected, so I know that the city knows about it.
00:29:44
So I'll move approval.
SPEAKER_10
00:29:45
I'll second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:47
Thank you.
00:29:47
All in favor?
00:29:49
Aye.
00:29:49
Thank you, Mr. Waymack.
00:29:51
Thank you.
00:29:52
Action item four is action on the rail enhancement program.
00:29:58
Ms. Rae, the director of the department is here.
00:30:00
Are there any questions of Ms. Rae?
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:04
Move for approval.
00:30:05
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:07
All in favor?
00:30:08
Aye.
00:30:10
And again, just an editorial note, this is a very significant step
00:30:14
with a permanent rail fund with guidelines.
00:30:16
And again, we hope to be seeing some important projects and programs moving forward in the very near future.
SPEAKER_05
00:30:23
And just in response to a question raised yesterday, we will give to each of you some maps that kind of identify both the rail connections to the port and where the future growth in the port is in response to Ms. Dragas's question.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:37
And I might, on that note, I think it would be a good idea to invite, if there's no objection, the Port Authority to our November meeting to talk about their expansion plans and to give a little bit of flesh and blood to that.
00:30:55
Action item five is the action on the Public Private Transportation Act guidelines.
00:31:02
Mr. Pelnik is here to answer any questions.
00:31:06
I do want to say at the outset that this is not approval.
00:31:09
This is essentially concurrence because of the differing governing and oversight bodies with respect to this.
00:31:17
The changes will be made with respect to the additional CTB members.
00:31:22
and the advisory character of the CTB action.
00:31:28
Are there any additional questions of Mr. Pelnik?
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:31
Mr. Chairman, it didn't come up yesterday, I don't think, but I remember one of the themes that kept coming up in our discussion of PPTA over the last year or two
00:31:42
and especially the previous commissioner used to bring it up at every opportunity is that he didn't think there was enough private investment involved and I was wondering because it'd take too long to go back and look for it but can anybody tell me whether the guidelines and criteria call for minimum amounts?
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:59
Both the law and the guidelines have been amended to reflect the objectiveness.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:09
Very significant change.
00:32:11
There's a requirement for risk and or cost sharing and hopefully both.
00:32:17
Is there a second?
00:32:21
All in favor?
00:32:24
Thank you so much.
00:32:26
Action item six is Mr. Coburn presenting bids.
00:32:31
Welcome, Mr. Coburn.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:32:33
Good morning, Mr. Chairman.
00:32:34
Ladies and gentlemen, my pleasure this morning to present to you four projects, two that are the normal design bid bill projects administered by VDOT.
00:32:46
In front of you this morning are two pink sheets.
00:32:49
One is, both of those sheets are locally administered projects.
00:32:55
One was included in your package and the other is an addition that came in after your package was distributed.
00:33:05
If we'll begin with the G-93 project on page number one, this is Warwick Boulevard.
00:33:12
This is the first of three projects in a series.
00:33:16
This project was subdivided so that the major project around the J. Clyde Morris Boulevard intersection could be accelerated, constructed, completed before the Jamestown celebration.
00:33:32
We expect a significant amount of traffic in that area.
00:33:39
We got a very good bid on this project recommending its award.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:45
Is there a motion on item G-93?
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:47
All in favor?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:33:51
Page number two, project order G65.
00:33:58
This is Country Club Road in Mecklenburg County.
00:34:06
It is a secondary project.
00:34:10
Bids were received, analyzed.
00:34:12
Bids were significantly higher
00:34:14
This is a motion to reject.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:32
All in favor?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:34:37
The next project listed on page number three is a PPTA project developed under the old guidelines and undertaken by the City of Williamsburg.
00:34:53
Dan Clayton, the Director of Public Works, is here to answer any questions that you may have about that project.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:01
Are there any questions?
SPEAKER_06
00:35:06
Maybe it's because it's a PPTA project, but the fact that the bid amount and the six-year plan amount are exactly the same.
00:35:17
Is that serendipity or is that, you know, how did that happen?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:35:22
A technicality because of the PPTA process, the total funds and that negotiated price gives a set indication.
00:35:35
The earlier printed cost in total for the PPTA, I believe, was about $12 million.
00:35:44
And those costs are negotiated within that range.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:50
It's fair to say these are, the umbrella package is a design-build package and this is an element within that?
00:35:58
Or is this the sole contract?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:01
Mr. Chairman, it's only awarding $2.9 million.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:36:06
The pink sheet is a correction to that.
00:36:08
That was an error communicated through the project manager that we corrected on that sheet.
00:36:16
Perhaps Mr. Clayton can answer those details.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:22
Welcome, Mr. Clayton.
SPEAKER_16
00:36:28
Repeat the question again.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:30
The question is, if this is a PPTA project, is this $5.53 million award the sum total of the PPTA comprehensive agreement, or is this an element in a larger PPTA package?
SPEAKER_16
00:36:50
That is the construction cost only.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:53
Okay, so there is a design and a
00:36:57
Right-of-way acquisition utility relocation that are have been negotiated separately and apart from this construction element so what we're doing is simply awarding the construction piece of that and is this this people this PPTA agreement is between the city right and the contractor okay and so the CTB because it's over two million dollars has to do approval is that correct
00:37:26
That's why we're here.
00:37:30
This is no different than a typical urban contract which exceeds $2 million that you all see.
00:37:37
Again, the method of procurement instead of it being sealed bid is a PPTA design-build agreement that has been executed by the city.
00:37:46
Ms. Hanley.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:47
What's the total cost of the project with everything in it?
SPEAKER_16
00:37:51
We had, I think the estimate was around $12 million, like you said, and the total cost was around $10 million.
00:38:00
So from the estimated cost is about a $2 million savings.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:04
And the other $5 million is being borne by the city, by the private sector?
SPEAKER_16
00:38:13
Yeah, the allocation is falling short on meeting the contract and the city is spending the money on that and it's going to be repaid over a period of time using our urban allocation money.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:25
So I guess for a PPTA, a PPTA to me means there's a public-private part.
00:38:31
This sounds a little bit to me like public-public design build.
00:38:35
My question was, what is the private sector paying?
SPEAKER_16
00:38:41
Well this falls under the old guidelines and I think they were a little different than what they are now.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:46
This is essentially a design build and the risk that's assumed by the private entity is a guaranteed delivery date and a guaranteed prep.
00:38:58
In some cases those have proven to be very good contracts for us.
SPEAKER_06
00:39:02
Would I be correct in maybe Byron in that the Six-Year Plan never had this 5.5 million figure specifically in it?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:39:12
Specifically, there was a total figure?
00:39:15
Yeah.
00:39:15
It may or may not have been broken down by the elements in the program.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:21
Okay.
00:39:21
Is there a motion on item 1005?
00:39:25
So moved, Mr. Chairman.
00:39:27
Is there a second?
00:39:29
Sure.
00:39:29
Thank you.
00:39:30
All in favor?
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:31
Aye.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:32
Motion is approved.
00:39:34
Mr. Coburn?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:39:36
The last project this morning, page number four, is also a first.
00:39:41
I believe this is the first First Cities project.
00:39:47
This is undertaken by the City of Hampton.
00:39:52
It is a standard design, bid, build project, but undertaken totally by the city.
00:40:01
Fred Whitley, the city engineer, is here to answer any questions.
SPEAKER_15
00:40:06
I would ask where the money is coming from for the bid amount, versus what we have in the six-year program on this.
00:40:17
It looks like it's about $1.1 million.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:40:22
Yes, the city has indicated they will pay the additional funds.
SPEAKER_15
00:40:28
and is that considered under PPPA arrangements or is this not a PPPA?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:40:35
No, this is a standard design project.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:45
Ms. Hanley.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:46
When we do this and the obligation is to the locality, the remaining obligation as was just noted for $1.1 million, do we still go through with cities the same way I think we do with counties, or at least some counties, a formal agreement?
00:41:02
that the city will pay 1.1 and VDOT's going to pay 2.3.
00:41:10
Is that what's going on here?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:41:12
Yes, ma'am.
00:41:12
There's a city agreement that concerns the project specifically.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:17
So somewhere else there's a whole bunch of legal documentation that says the city's going to do this and VDOT will do that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:41:25
Sure, but Ms. Hanley, I think the issue here is even bigger than that.
00:41:29
The city of Hampton, Virginia Beach, and Richmond have assumed control of their urban construction program.
00:41:39
We still have in the code a requirement for any contract over two million dollars to be approved by the CTB.
00:41:47
One of the things that we need to think about as a body
00:41:50
is whether or not that's an archaic provision.
00:41:53
These are sophisticated people and this adds another step to the process.
00:41:56
We're asking the cities to manage these, you know, these contracts and we have to do that to get this bid out.
00:42:05
But this is going to be an important issue.
00:42:08
And to move this project forward, it does require approval of the CTB today.
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:14
I move approval.
00:42:16
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:17
All in favor?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:19
Aye.
00:42:19
Mr. Chairman, is further action needed on the issue you just raised at this point?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:24
That would require a change to the Code of Virginia.
00:42:28
And I guess I would say, particularly Ms. Hanley, I know you've expressed concerns on this, but
00:42:33
For example, at Fairfax County, when you were chair of that board, if you were managing a project, you would want to be able to manage the funds and issue the contract and not have to wait until you get time and placement on the CTB agenda.
00:42:49
You want accountability as well as responsibility, and I think we still have one or two steps to go in that direction with the First Cities Initiative to get there completely.
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:58
So we have to go before the General Assembly to
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:01
Yes, there is a code requirement than any construction contract.
00:43:05
Am I speaking on bad information?
00:43:08
Mr. Estes?
SPEAKER_10
00:43:09
Mr. Chairman, members of the board, actually that code change did come through at last session.
00:43:14
It did.
00:43:14
What does require now is I have to make a proposal to the commissioner as to what dollar amounts we want to consider and we'll be taking that.
00:43:22
I believe the plan is bringing it from the board.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:24
Okay, so that is a matter of policy.
00:43:28
Okay, great.
00:43:29
I stand corrected.
00:43:31
Just as a matter of policy, I would say if a city or a town or a county takes the initiative to manage their construction program that that kind of bringing it to the CTB I don't believe adds a lot of value to the process, but that's my own personal belief.
SPEAKER_08
00:43:49
Mr. Chairman, point of clarification as we encourage cities to take on their urban systems.
00:43:56
We were just talking, is this project or projects similar to this moving forward, will they be included in the six-year plan, in our six-year plan, or since it's now in the hands of, in this case, the city of Hampton, is it something we really need to be concerned about?
SPEAKER_10
00:44:16
Very good question, Mr. Chairman.
00:44:18
If I could, we would actually still be requiring anything with federal dollars to be in our six-year program.
00:44:24
There's larger implications about trying to make sure that stuff is included in the tips and the steps and things like that.
00:44:30
But if it's a truly state-funded, portion-only project, it just would be required to be in their capital improvement program.
00:44:38
We would still be requiring federal projects to be in our six-year program.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:43
Since we have a short meeting this morning, this may be a good time to discuss this a little.
00:44:51
But there seems to me to be a statewide interest by all localities of having, to your point, of having somewhere how state money is allocated, even if we are going to cut the localities completely
00:45:05
to whom and how much and for what.
00:45:08
I think we'll find that cities quite appropriately will be able to take advantage of this situation much more rapidly than counties because the urban funding formulas has cities in control of their transport and Henrico and Arlington in control of their transportation now.
00:45:26
But counties don't have that, most counties don't have that availability.
00:45:31
And so I think there's a benefit to the whole program statewide to be able to see who's doing what and how much they're using to do it.
00:45:40
Otherwise we wouldn't have any way to track it.
00:45:42
Now, the capital program is kind of at the same time as the six-year program is, but gee whiz, I think we want to be able to identify what the bottom line is.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:54
It would, Mr. Chairman, appear to me too that there's a secondary consideration once a road is built by the city.
00:46:02
I would assume that still the maintenance and care of it reverts back or stays with the local jurisdiction.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:08
Stays with the city or town or the two counties.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:11
That's the difference between cities and counties.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:14
It would seem very difficult for me for that to be kept separate and as far as funding and if one of those particular projects went down and the locality did not upgrade it and it was required to fit into the state system I could see all sorts of headaches if we're not careful and being consistent.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:36
I think the difference here is that historically VDOT has constructed
00:46:42
The roads that go into the urban system, but once they're built, they are the long-term maintenance and operational responsibility of the city.
00:46:51
One of the things that we try to do of the many fiscal house cleaning measures is to give cities the flexibility to move funds back and forth between maintenance and construction.
00:47:04
For a mature city, that's almost a meaningless distinction between maintenance and construction.
00:47:10
And so I think we need to have that decision-making responsibility, either all on the state side or all on the municipality side, just for pure efficiency and management of those funds.
00:47:25
And as Ms. Hanley points out, it is a different equation for the counties.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:29
Mr. Chairman, just one other question.
00:47:31
The funding still flows primarily from the state to the locality, however, right?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:36
Yes, it is an annual allocation, but mostly a reimbursement on particularly where federal funds are involved.
00:47:47
Any other questions or comments?
00:47:50
Okay, under new business, I know Commissioner Whirley wanted to update us on an issue that got some media attention recently relating to Federal Obligation Authority.
00:48:03
And while some of the questions may be passed,
00:48:07
It certainly did generate a lot of interest in some of the communities and I'm wondering if Mr. Whirley could just take a few minutes and describe how we have performed on that issue.
Gregory A. Whirley Sr.
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:18
We've handed out two schedules.
00:48:20
One is the press release that showed how we use the additional $30 million in which projects and we've also included another sheet that shows the individual projects and how that $30 million will be allocated.
00:48:37
That's just for information purposes, but more detail on how the $30 million was used.
00:48:47
In addition to that,
00:48:49
I think we've handed out an additional document regarding the industrial access projects.
00:48:58
That was a question from the last meeting in terms of the potential return of unused industrial access money.
00:49:08
and you'll see from the fiscal years 1997 through 2000 it shows you going across the top the projects, the number of projects, the net allocation, the expenditures,
00:49:24
The pending return, which means those funds that probably will be, we're still investigating whether or not those funds need to be returned or not, and the funds actual return will be the funds return column, and then the last column is the total potential funds that would be returned.
00:49:45
This was a question that was asked at the last meeting, and this is just an update to that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:54
Thank you, Commissioner.
00:49:55
Are there any other questions or comments on either of these items?
Helen E. Dragas
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:01
Mr. Chairman, the Additional Obligation Authority, I don't really understand this legal class spreadsheet here.
00:50:15
And I'm wondering, I guess, how the decision was made to practice that authority to go to it.
00:50:20
Or is this an acceleration of what we've already programmed in Mr.
00:50:22
Prince?
00:50:23
Yes.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:25
But it's important to note, and if I may provide a little historical context, the questions that were posed to me several times in subcommittee settings was
00:50:38
Are you able to commit all of your federal dollars and aren't you in danger of losing federal dollars?
00:50:46
Which was absolutely untrue.
00:50:50
Said that beginning in July.
00:50:54
We've been categorical about the fact that we would not lose a penny of federal funding and that likely would qualify for additional funding.
00:51:03
You cannot qualify for additional funding unless you are able to fully obligate all of your federal funds.
00:51:10
We did that.
00:51:10
We got one of the larger acceleration bonuses from the federal government.
00:51:17
It does require you to have projects that are already programmed and quote-unquote ready to go.
00:51:23
So that's what this 30 million dollars and it's a real plus.
00:51:27
I want to acknowledge the very hard work because you get about a three-day turnaround from the Federal Highway Administration to do this.
00:51:36
So the folks in programming and financial division were ready.
00:51:40
They had a list of projects and were ready to go.
00:51:42
This is a victory for Virginia.
00:51:45
and just shows the quality of the work and the aggressive nature of trying to capture every available federal dollar.
00:51:57
Ms. Hanley.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:58
But could it be possibly that they were asking currently because maybe in the past, I'm looking here at 97, 98, 99, 2000, that that had not always been the case?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:11
Certainly we have come a long way with our financial management and the ability to ask for additional money.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:19
So we've really improved that whole process.
00:52:23
It is a challenge.
00:52:24
Yes it is.
00:52:27
We have to have the prudent financial management that gives us a cushion of state dollars.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:40
It's almost like a form of contingency to capture those federal dollars.
00:52:44
Typically that happens in August.
00:52:47
This year it was done with three days left to go in the federal fiscal year, so we had, I believe, three days to respond to the Federal Highway Administration request.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:57
But if your six-year plan had gotten, in the past, had gotten to the point where it couldn't move forward in a timely manner, then you would have difficulty doing that as efficiently as we've been able to do that.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:12
Yes, ma'am.
00:53:13
I think that's a very clear and true statement.
SPEAKER_15
00:53:15
Thank you for clearing that up.
00:53:16
Mr. Chairman, I think we could say that that was corrected when we removed 166 projects from the Six-Year Plan in 2000.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:24
Well, the 166 projects and probably most importantly the $867 million in project deficits.
00:53:33
That has been the single largest drag over four years on this program, and that's now down to zero.
00:53:39
And again, thank you for your hard choices and hard work.
00:53:42
Ms. Connally?
SPEAKER_06
00:53:43
I think this is an interesting segue into something that I think you sent us, and maybe not everybody got it because it arrived late in the day, but it was a memo commenting on
00:53:54
Not Virginia's ability to manage our transportation funds, but the worrisome vulnerability of the Federal Transportation Trust Fund.
00:54:05
And I don't know whether you wanted to, maybe it spoke for itself, but I found it alarming looking into the, not the long distance future, but the near future.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:15
Yes, with the passage of a new highway bill, there's very high expectations for
00:54:22
New projects and ability to do a little bit more.
00:54:26
I received, I want to say Monday evening or Tuesday afternoon, a memorandum.
00:54:33
There's an interstate consortium.
00:54:36
It's called the Federal Information Service that does institutional non-partisan analysis for the individual states about major issues.
00:54:45
Medicaid and transportation are probably the two biggest areas.
00:54:49
Their analysis of the Federal Highway Trust Fund, which is funded essentially with gas and diesel taxes, is that it will be unable to meet its obligations beginning in 2008 or perhaps as early as federal fiscal year 2007.
00:55:08
Now, during the discussions at the federal level and the adoption of the new bill, there were concerns about the ability over the life of that six-year bill to live up to those obligations expressed, and Congress did create a committee to look at it.
00:55:24
But the thinking at the time is that that was in the out years of the program and there would be time to address it.
00:55:31
What this analysis states very categorically is that that is not so and that's a function of the sharp increase in gas prices drives down consumption and therefore receipts in the Federal Trust Fund as well as some of the demands for emergency response to Hurricane Katrina and potentially Wilma and others.
00:55:51
So our federal program, which is 65% of the highway construction program,
00:55:57
The lion's share of our transit construction money and the Dulles project are tied up in those issues.
00:56:07
This is an emerging issue and one that obviously is going to take some care and thought to think about.
00:56:15
And I think, again, as Ms. Connally mentioned, a segue into another conversation.
00:56:21
What the Federal Highway Trust Fund needs to do is what Virginia has done.
00:56:27
Thank you for bringing that up.
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:40
Well, Mr. Secretary, I'd just like to say also it's a compliment to your work, Greg's work, also Phillip Chiquette and Whit Clement because I can remember in Karen Rae many trips up and down from Washington, D.C. back here working with the Federal Highway, a lot of meetings that Phil was running late or not able to be here, Karen and yourself, and I just think that the accountability
00:57:04
that we've had here in Virginia since 2000-2001.
00:57:10
It's really paying off and it's showing that we're getting it right here in Virginia and maybe Federal Highway can learn something from the poor little sister state of Virginia.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:20
Well said.
00:57:21
Mr. Bailey, with you having the floor, I understand you have a special guest that you'd like to introduce to us before we adjourn.
Ambrose W. Bailey
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:28
Oh, well, thank you, Mr. Secretary.
00:57:29
I was not able to be with you all at the September meeting, and that was because I got married September the 10th.
00:57:37
Claire and I were married September 10th, and then our regular meeting was just a few days after that.
00:57:42
And a lot of you all got to meet my new wife when you came up last year to Fredericksburg for the all-day, two-day meeting.
00:57:48
She spent the two days with us.
00:57:50
Claire Viewstand, Ray Lane, and
00:58:00
I got a lot of nice cards, phone calls, emails, and notes from you all congratulating me.
00:58:07
Thank you so much.
00:58:08
I just wanted to acknowledge you all's kindness.
00:58:10
We've become a very close board, not only doing business hours, but also in other forms of things going on in our lives.
00:58:18
I appreciate you all's kindness over the past month or two.
00:58:22
Thank you very much.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:23
Okay, Mr. Bailey and thank you and it's just a joy to see you here.
00:58:27
So thank you for taking the time out and Claire, thank you for being with us this morning.
00:58:31
Are there any comments before we have a non-debatable motion to adjourn?
Helen E. Dragas
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:38
A couple quick things if I could back to Route 460.
00:58:42
Thank you, first, Karen and your staff for the maps that you provided.
00:58:46
I think they're all really helpful to me and hopefully you all can take the time to look at them.
00:58:52
There was one other one that I've seen that I was hoping we might be able to get our hands on, which is a map of the existing distribution centers that have developed over the last several years.
00:59:04
Maybe the MPO has it.
SPEAKER_05
00:59:06
We do have that.
00:59:07
We were just kind of culling through what maps would be useful.
00:59:10
We can absolutely get that out to you and I think make it part of the next meeting.
Helen E. Dragas
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:16
And also, I was wondering, Pierce, I was intrigued by your suggestion that maybe the location decision be suspended until which time the proposals are solicited.
00:59:28
But I'm also wondering if the staff was planning on providing us with a recommended alternative.
00:59:36
I don't believe I saw that yesterday.
00:59:38
And I'm very impressed by the time that the citizens took to come up here and share their stories with us.
00:59:46
And just based on my own business experience, there's nothing like local knowledge.
00:59:50
And it's really hard, in my opinion, to make that kind of a decision.
00:59:57
without having the full benefit of what they've gone through in this draft environmental and the public hearings.
01:00:05
So I'd sort of like to hear from them as to what their opinion is of the best route.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:09
Of the staff.
Helen E. Dragas
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:10
Of the staff, yeah.
01:00:11
Yes, ma'am.
01:00:11
I don't know if that was to be expected or not, but I'm sort of threading that out there.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:16
We are trying to move towards strong recommendations in the EIS.
01:00:25
There's a host of issues about when and how to do that.
01:00:29
and whenever this issue comes up, I always look to Mr. Walton because it does have to be a level playing field and all prudent and feasible alternatives, but we'll, we need, your point's well taken and I think we need to, when we bring this issue back in November, to discuss that, discuss that thoroughly, as best how to present that as well as the staff recommendations.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:56
Mr. Chairman, I would certainly favor the idea of a certain timeframe whereby private proposals could be considered before a final selection is made because it makes infinitely good sense to give the private sector an opportunity to propose how they think it could be done.
01:01:15
I think there has to be a time limit perhaps on how long that can run while staff is developing its best recommendation as well.
01:01:24
And then you get the benefit of both.
SPEAKER_08
01:01:28
Realistically, when would this construction probably take place?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:35
If there is funding identified, you would have to get to a record of... Let's assume we had unlimited funding.
01:01:43
You'd have to get to a record of decision which is at least a year away.
01:01:48
You'd have to go through a design process and a 50-mile corridor which is a minimum of
01:01:56
18 to 24 months.
01:01:58
That would be very aggressive.
01:02:02
You would then have to look at utility and right-of-way location, which you're probably looking at several years to do that.
01:02:08
And there are some very difficult utility crossing type issues in that corridor.
01:02:16
And then at the conclusion of that, you could start turning dirt.
01:02:20
These are, yes.
01:02:24
A major corridor like that, and one of the questions, again, depending upon the alternative that's chosen, what's the interrelationship with the railroads?
01:02:37
I think that's a question that deserves some further thought in that corridor.
SPEAKER_01
01:02:43
Mr. Chairman, in the meantime, in that three, four, and longer period of time there before you actually get to the contract proposals,
01:02:52
When do the localities stop issuing building permits, I guess?
01:02:57
They just can't.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:01
And that's Ms. Hanley's point.
01:03:03
Those of you who have been in local government, once there's zoning in place, it's a ministerial decision of the local government.
Helen E. Dragas
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:13
There is a provision in the code for something called the official map.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:32
I don't believe a single jurisdiction in the Commonwealth has adopted that.
01:03:38
But, you know, it's about takings and property rights.
01:03:43
So something may be planned on a map.
01:03:47
There are some who say that by showing that on the map, you're diminishing the value of the property.
01:03:52
We've got some litigation on that right now.
01:03:56
But if, you know, except under very unique mistake, fraud, or change in circumstance, if the zoning is in place, the building permit and or the, you know, the site plan has to follow suit within, there's some prescribed time limits.
01:04:10
I think it's always 90 days for building permit or a year for a site plan.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:17
If, for example, the project is close enough to construction that the locality can put some kind of definitive line on a map for widening so that if it's a rezoning coming in that they can preserve that land and rezoning, that's one thing.
01:04:36
But if it's not a rezoning coming in and somebody comes in for a building permit, there it is.
01:04:42
And so they're kind of two different things.
01:04:45
If somebody decides to go out and build a house in that right-of-way, there's no way Isle of Wight can prevent that, not a single way, because it's already zoned.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:00
Okay.
01:05:01
Is there a non-debatable motion?
01:05:03
I move.
01:05:04
Okay.
01:05:05
We are adjourned.
01:05:05
Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_15
01:05:06
We'll see you next month.