Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 9/15/2005
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
9/15/2005
Attachments
Board actions.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
Board meeting agenda.pdf
Revenue sharing program projects list.pdf
Projects awarded and rejected.pdf
Public Comment
Approval of Minutes July 21, 2005
TRAFFIC ENGINEERING DIVISION
1. Action on Additions, Abandonments and Transferences - changes in the Primary System due to construction and relocation:
A. Route 372 – Washington County
B. Route 23 – Lee County
C. Route 17 – Essex County
OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
2. Salem Smart Traffic Center
A. Salem Smart Traffic Center Project
LOCATION AND DESIGN DIVISION
3. Action on Roadway Improvements:
A. Pocahontas Trail/Warwick Boulevard (Route 60)
4. Memorandum of Understanding and Memorandum of Agreement:
A. Fleet Recreation Park in the City of Norfolk
RIGHT OF WAY AND UTIILITIES
5. Action on Land Conveyances
A. Route 250, Three Chopt Road, Henrico County
B. Route 236, Fairfax County
C. Old Route 17 and Route 238, Yorktown
6. Limited Access
A. Piedmont Drive, City of Danville
LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
7. Action on Industrial Access:
A. Highlands Business Park, Phase II – Washington County
B. 15/64 Zion Crossroads Industrial Park, Phase I – Louisa County
8. Action on Revenue Sharing:
A. FY 2005-2006 Revenue Sharing Program
B. Reallocation of Funds - Hanover County
DEPARTMENT OF RAIL AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
9. Action on Industrial Rail Access:
A. Wythe County
SECRETARY OF TRANSPORTATION
10. Roadside Management Regulation
SCHEDULING AND CONTRACT DIVISION
11. Action on Bids Received: the Month of August, 2005
NEW BUSINESS
ADJOURNMENT
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:00
In view of the time, I'd like to convene the business meeting.
00:00:03
And with that, we will begin with public comment.
00:00:06
Mr. Archie Ellis is here, and I've had a subsequent request for one additional slide of public comment.
SPEAKER_07
00:00:13
Mr. Ellis, welcome.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:26
There you go.
00:00:34
Thank you.
SPEAKER_07
00:00:42
Ladies and gentlemen, my name is Archie Ellis, and I'm a retired lawyer.
00:00:48
I've appeared before the board a number of times in the past, but not recently, though I've been to the six-year planning meetings of various places.
00:00:57
And I'm here to urge several comments upon you based upon observations over a period of time.
00:01:06
And let me say I was very impressed with all the presentations and the
00:01:10
intellectual and other responsibility that you had submitted to you this morning.
00:01:16
I wish the public could hear more of that.
00:01:18
I think they'd be more appreciative and impressed with your work.
00:01:23
But I was, and I've heard a lot of it before.
00:01:26
I sent the secretary and all members of the board a letter of July 30th with six different recommendations to you.
00:01:37
and I've given you another copy of that and I hope you will look at it again because some of the things were pertinent to things you heard this morning but I am here specifically to urge your attention to two issues which on that letter of July 30th are numbers one and two dealing respectively with total roads and truck taxes
00:02:04
And I have another page attached to the material that I've given you which summarizes what I want to say to you today.
00:02:14
The first is that the Commonwealth Transportation Board is the most important public voice in transportation in this state.
00:02:24
And I think it needs to take initiative to make recommendations to the government and the general assembly.
00:02:30
Perhaps you do some of that, but I would like you to do some on specific matters.
00:02:37
Current campaign remarks by the various major candidates have put transportation funding issues on the table.
00:02:45
And the recent expressions by Governor Brown regarding toll roads is squarely at the point
00:02:53
I'm here to urge you to take some action today to take positions and to ask the staff to provide information and other recommendations to you at your October meeting so you can vote up or down.
00:03:08
I'm urging you specifically to recommend greater use of poles on critical highway segments and restoration of poles on some that have happened in the past.
00:03:20
This probably requires some handling of the federal authorities, but it is my understanding that the current law permits this.
00:03:30
It is hoped we will express a position today in the quick staff to advise you better in October.
00:03:37
If legislation is needed, then a request should be submitted with the proper board resolution to the governor and the legislature and the draft to the council.
00:03:49
A good illustration of a proper restoration of coal would be the Richmond-Petersburg Turnpike, I-95.
00:03:57
And there are others.
00:03:58
When I live here in Richmond, I'm quite familiar with the Turnpike, and it functioned very well.
00:04:05
And you may not all of you remember or ever knew that it was a real cash cow.
00:04:12
It was producing funds in the Richmond area that was paying for building all the roads, including Chippenham Harbor, a major road to this area.
00:04:22
It was also paying all of its claims.
00:04:26
And you had, recently, several years ago, a hundred million dollars worth of expenditures to renovate the bridges over the James River on I-95.
00:04:37
The Richmond-Petersburg Turnpike Coals had continued.
00:04:41
They probably would have generated the funds to pay for that out of the total funds, and you'd have had for this board, some of you were here then, probably would have had another hundred million spent elsewhere.
00:04:55
So that's an illustration.
00:04:57
I think there are other places in the state, but I have spoken before on this issue, and an illustration I've offered is that we'll be here.
00:05:08
A huge expenditure that's now going on.
00:05:12
My thought was that if a $2.00 total had been put on that bridge, a large part of the problem would have gone away, and there would have been money for whatever enlargement was necessary, and the people who really used it would have paid for it.
00:05:26
So that's my thought as an illustration.
00:05:28
I could give you some others, but I want to urge you to really face this total failure
00:05:34
and come forward as the major responsible citizen group in the state on transportation with a recommendation to all of those who are necessary to make the ultimate decision.
00:05:49
I'm not sure who that is.
00:05:50
I think your staff will have to tell you.
00:05:53
But it's perhaps the General Assembly.
00:05:56
Perhaps it's the Federal Highway Authority.
00:05:58
Perhaps it's the government.
00:06:00
Give them your position on this and I urge you to seek maximum flexibility so that six months from now if you had another vote you could decide whether or not to put tolls on some segment or store tolls to some that used to happen.
00:06:20
The other issue I would like to present to you, and I've given you two papers attached to explain my comments and supplement them, is the question of truck tax and big truck combination taxes.
00:06:36
In my opinion, and I've given you data that supports my opinion,
00:06:41
They have been grossly underpaid for 30 or 40 years.
00:06:47
They've been repeated studies in Virginia, and you will see them tabulated on that one long page report that I have there that I made in 1989.
00:06:58
I've handed out repeatedly in many public hearings, and it's never been refuted by anyone, so I think it's reasonably accurate.
00:07:09
Since I wrote that memo, what I think is very significant is truck weights have been increased from 70,000 to 80,000 pounds.
00:07:18
There have been a number of exceptions granted, like containers from reports, log trucks, and other things.
00:07:28
And the size has been increased.
00:07:30
You see 53-foot trailers on the road.
00:07:34
And there are exceptions to all of these things.
00:07:37
Now the highways have not changed.
00:07:40
Many of your prime highways in this state were built a maximum weight of 55,000 pounds.
SPEAKER_15
00:07:48
Many of your bridges were built for less.
SPEAKER_07
00:07:52
You're not getting reimbursed for the tremendous additional expense that big trucks have imposed upon the system.
00:08:00
Much of which has been useful, but much of which has been excessive and increased their profits at the taxpayer's expense.
00:08:10
Now you will see from my calculation that the surcharge on big trucks was two cents back in 19, well I think it was 55, yeah 56.
00:08:27
It was two cents surcharge.
00:08:30
When the public was then only paying six cents, that was a thirty-three and one-third percent increase was thought reasonable at that time.
00:08:41
At that time, the maximum weight for trucks was fifty-six thousand eight hundred pounds, and the maximum length was probably much shorter than it is today.
00:08:52
I can't remember what it was.
00:08:54
They were mostly gasoline engines, so they got fewer miles per gallon.
00:09:02
There have been substantial increases since I got those captivated.
00:09:07
And we're now down to where the big truck combinations are paying far less than the 33 and a third percent surcharge.
00:09:16
They're down to about 11 percent or less.
00:09:20
They're much bigger and heavier.
00:09:23
The damage is proportionately greater.
00:09:27
And there have been repeated studies in Virginia.
00:09:30
I've tabulated a number of those.
00:09:32
There have been several in Congress.
00:09:35
And they've all come out with the same conclusions.
00:09:39
But the big truck industry is not paying its share.
00:09:43
So I call upon you to review this subject.
00:09:46
Get your staff to do it.
00:09:48
I'm sure that they have considerable knowledge on this subject.
00:09:53
And I do have a task, a little chart, a one-page chart I'll get you to look at that quickly.
00:10:05
I'm sorry I didn't do it all up for you.
00:10:07
But they compare the fuel surcharge with the weight increases.
00:10:13
And you will see the line on surcharge has gone down steadily.
00:10:18
And you will see that the line on weight has gone up steadily.
00:10:23
Which illustrates the problem fairly concisely, I think.
00:10:28
So I'm calling upon you to take a look at that subject.
00:10:33
In fairness to the general public, other people need to pay their shares.
00:10:39
You have a broad concern about big truck issues on some of the highways in Virginia now, and this could be a factor.
00:10:49
They're presently being subsidized by the division tax payer in their use of the road.
00:10:56
And this is an area that I think you might deal with strongly as a policy issue.
00:11:04
I think I have a
00:11:06
said enough on this subject and I'll answer any questions that you may have.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:14
Okay, any questions?
00:11:16
Mr. Ellis, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_00
00:11:19
I'd just like to say that I personally think Mr. Ellis' comments deserve our attention and I'd like to see us look into this and possibly take some action in October.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:11:30
Mr. Ellis, thank you for your time.
00:11:31
I had a second request after the agenda was printed for Mr. Bob Chase
00:11:36
Who wants to provide some brief comments to us.
Bob Chase
President
00:11:40
Very brief sir.
00:11:41
Thank you very much.
00:11:42
I'm Bob Chase.
00:11:43
I'm with the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance.
00:11:46
We will be communicating with you more about the tri-county parkway but there's a couple of observations I'd like to make based upon today's presentation.
00:11:55
First of all, I think we all appreciate the work that Frank Wilson and his team has done on this.
00:11:59
It's a very tough issue and it's a very tough environment.
00:12:02
The second observation would be that all the options that you're looking at, not just the content but the others, are already on or envisioned on local plans.
00:12:12
These aren't new.
00:12:13
They've already been thought about.
00:12:15
So we're not talking about different options that are all new.
00:12:17
They're all old.
00:12:19
They've evolved from there.
00:12:21
But what you're being asked here to do, which I think is incorrect, is to pick one of these.
00:12:27
And by doing so, you would, in effect, be deleting things from plans as opposed to adding to the plans.
00:12:33
So I think that, you know, we're not looking for one additional north-south route.
00:12:38
We're looking for multiple routes, as Secretary Homer mentioned earlier.
00:12:43
What's missing here and what the study doesn't really focus on is the unique purpose of the Tri-County Parkway continent alignment, which is to reduce traffic on Route 28 south of I-66, which is to take traffic off Route 230 for bypass, which is to take traffic out of northwest Fairfax neighborhoods, and which is to improve access to Bull Run Regional Park.
00:13:10
That's the historical purpose and need for the Tri-County comp plan alignment.
00:13:15
And the comp plan alignment is the only one
00:13:18
That does all those things.
00:13:20
The other options do different things, but none of them does those things.
00:13:25
Traffic volume.
00:13:27
You saw a lot of numbers here today.
00:13:28
What you didn't see is what each of these elements carry.
00:13:32
And specifically, you didn't hear that the comp plan alignment carries more traffic, in particular segment E that goes to the park than all the other options combined.
00:13:44
Segment E carries 105,000 trips per day.
00:13:48
That's more than Dulles Rail carries.
00:13:50
It's a big part of the transportation solution in Northern Virginia, and you can't overlook that fact.
00:13:58
In terms of time savings, computer models are helpful tools, but they don't replace common sense.
00:14:06
And if you look at the maps, what you see is that the comp plan provides the most direct connections
00:14:13
between places that people want to get to.
00:14:17
And common sense tells you that the savings, time savings, are much greater than what are shown in the computer model.
00:14:25
Other than observation was that the impacts you see are measured on the 600-foot right-of-way whereas the actual right-of-way is probably about 25% of that.
00:14:33
So all the impacts and all the forces are far less than what you're seeing.
00:14:39
Mr. Dragas asked a very good question and that was what are the economic benefits here?
00:14:43
You see that you could lose $400,000 in tax revenue.
00:14:47
But I will tell you that I think probably easily the benefits are probably ten times that amount, particularly with the component.
00:14:53
And if you look at the Prince William County and you look at where some of their centers, current and economic centers are, the benefits of those are huge.
00:15:02
Similarly to Route 50 in Loudoun County and in the employment centers in communities west of Dulles Airport.
00:15:09
Huge accessibility improvements by that route.
00:15:13
When you factor that in,
00:15:15
The benefits, economic, dwarf the actual cost.
00:15:21
You're going to hear, and you have heard, people say, this will never be built.
00:15:26
You can't build a compliment.
00:15:28
I'm sorry, it may be a good idea, you can't be built.
00:15:30
Well, some of us, I mean, I'm actually old enough to remember in 1980 when VDOT said, chances of the Fairfax County Parkway being built are somewhere between zero and ten percent.
00:15:42
I'm old enough to remember in the mid 80s when people said the Route 28 Tax District was a terrible idea.
00:15:48
It was putting the state at great risk and we shouldn't do it.
00:15:52
I'm old enough to remember in 1990 when it was said the Dulles Greenway would be a disaster.
00:15:57
couldn't be built, shouldn't be built, private sector shouldn't be built, but today they're selling it for a gazillion dollars to somebody in Australia and it's been a great success.
00:16:06
And there are people here who say you'll never get rail to Dulles Airport and those people are going to be wrong too.
00:16:13
You know, you can't say you can't do things.
00:16:16
The problem in Northern Virginia is not a lack of planning, it's a lack of implementation.
00:16:22
And the list is huge of all the projects that have been deleted from master plans.
00:16:28
We have the third worst congestion, not because VDOT and in reaching people didn't plan, but because we took things off the plan and we said it couldn't be done.
00:16:37
So we need to be protecting things, not taking things off the map.
00:16:43
It's a system we're trying to build, a north-south system, not a menu.
00:16:48
It's not choose one from column A, choose one from column B, choose one from column C. We need all these things and a lot more.
00:16:56
So I would encourage you to look at protecting all of these options.
00:17:01
There's only one Tri-County Parkway.
00:17:03
There's only one of these options that connects all three counties.
00:17:06
The other alignments serve different purposes and they are important purposes and they need to be protected too.
00:17:15
But if you choose just one and you eliminate one, again we are continuing the trend in Northern Virginia of taking things off and we should be adding them.
00:17:26
The final point is, you've got to look at not just today, but you have to look at the future.
00:17:31
Again, we've got the third most congested road network in America.
00:17:36
In the next 25 years, Northern Virginia is going to add a million people, most of them outside the Delta, Loudoun County's population in the Delta.
00:17:46
Since Williams adds more than 200,000 to 600,000, Fairfax adds 300,000 to 1.4 million.
00:17:55
And that doesn't count the people in Culpeper, in Stafford, in Winchester, in West Virginia, Dulles Airport doubling the number of people.
00:18:05
I mean the problem is huge and we need, and the number of vehicles, we're going to add more vehicles in that time period than people.
00:18:14
Again, I will talk to you some more about this in the future, but don't think about it as just that we've got to pick between one versus the other and they're all about the same.
00:18:25
Each of these elements is different, but we need them all and a lot more.
00:18:29
I would urge you and the Commonwealth to help the jurisdictions in Northern Virginia
00:18:35
Thank you, Mr. Chase
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:45
okay moving right along the first item on the agenda is approval of the minutes under motion I have a correction there is a typo towards the end where my name is used and misspelled I'm not taking in any oh it doesn't make any other amendments proposed is there a motion second all in favor
00:19:12
Action item one is under traffic engineering.
00:19:17
If there are no objections, would it be acceptable to take all three up in a block?
00:19:26
Any questions?
00:19:29
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_00
00:19:30
So moved.
00:19:31
Second?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:32
Second.
00:19:33
All in favor?
00:19:34
Aye.
00:19:35
Thank you.
00:19:37
Action Item 2 on the next page under Operations Management, the Salem Smart Traffic Center.
00:19:43
Stephen Brich is here to answer any questions.
00:19:46
Are there any questions of Mr. Brich?
00:19:51
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_10
00:19:52
I move to approve.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:54
Second?
00:19:54
Second.
00:19:56
All in favor?
00:19:58
Aye Motion passes.
00:20:00
Thank you Mr. Brich.
00:20:02
The location and design division, Mr. Machowy is here to answer any questions and we'll take these up separately.
00:20:10
The first is action on roadway improvements, the Pocahontas Trail Boulevard, James City County and the City of Newport Hills.
00:20:18
Are there any questions of Mr. Machowy?
00:20:24
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_06
00:20:25
I move approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:26
Second.
00:20:27
All in favor?
00:20:28
Aye.
00:20:30
Item number four is a memorandum of understanding and a memorandum of agreement on the Lake Recreation Park in the city of Norfolk.
00:20:41
Are there any questions of Mr. Michelli?
SPEAKER_06
00:20:44
I have one question.
00:20:45
Is the allocation of environmental cleanup in these agreements pretty typical?
00:20:52
I mean, it looked like VDOT was assuming a fair amount of responsibility.
SPEAKER_01
00:20:56
We're only assuming any liability that might be caused because a contract is worked.
00:21:03
The baby will take responsibility for what he discovered.
SPEAKER_06
00:21:08
I guess I didn't read it that way.
00:21:12
But I'm glad to hear that.
SPEAKER_01
00:21:15
In our negotiation, we have to be very careful.
00:21:18
And we will be responsible for any damage that may be caused because of our work in the area.
00:21:24
But anything that is preexisting would be their responsibility.
00:21:27
Thank you.
SPEAKER_06
00:21:29
I would move approval then.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:32
Is there a second?
00:21:33
Second.
00:21:34
All in favor?
00:21:35
Aye.
00:21:36
That motion is approved.
00:21:38
The next action item five under right-of-way and utilities and Beverly Fullwater will be here presenting.
00:21:49
We'll take the three land conveyances up separately.
00:21:55
Action item 5A which is route 50 in Henrico.
00:21:58
Are there any questions?
SPEAKER_15
00:22:01
Approve approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:02
Second.
00:22:03
All in favor?
00:22:04
That's fine.
00:22:05
And item 5B is Route 236 in Fairfax County.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:09
Mr. Chairman, it is not in Fairfax County.
00:22:12
It's in Fairfax City.
00:22:15
And although I did ask staff to get me a copy of a letter to see if Fairfax City knew this was going on, they were
00:22:27
The project was cited to Mayor Letterer as being in the County of Fairfax, and I'd like to defer this until it's sorted out where the project is and what the effect is on the affected properties.
00:22:41
It's just improperly noticed.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:44
Without objection.
00:22:46
Item 5C, which is Old Route 17 in Yorktown.
00:22:50
Are there questions of Ms. Fullwater?
SPEAKER_06
00:22:57
I move approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:59
Second?
00:23:00
Second.
00:23:01
All in favor?
00:23:02
Aye.
00:23:04
The next action item is number six under limited access and this relates to Peanut Drive in the city of Danville.
00:23:12
Before we ask Ms. Fulwider if she has if there are any questions for I know Mr. White did want to speak to this item and he does have to leave shortly so Mr. White if you would
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:24
Well, very briefly, this is a somewhat unusual request in that last year I think at this meeting we approved this limited access break for private development purposes.
00:23:42
And since then, that's when the miscommunication started and it has existed since then.
00:23:48
Actually, what this was from the very beginning was a request for a public street from the City of Danville.
00:23:58
And this resolution is designed to correct that error.
00:24:03
And obviously the difference is if it's for a private break, there's compensation involved, and under the policy of the board, if it's for a public purpose, a public street,
00:24:13
There is no compensation and I think it's simply a matter of the city of Danville I'm satisfied that they from the very beginning in the zoning proffers and in the conditions to the zoning of this property required public streets.
00:24:30
And I think they simply got a hold of some bad forms.
00:24:34
They used some forms that had been submitted to us from the Salem District, I think from the City of Radford, maybe the City of Roanoke, that happened to involve a private developer and the blanks got filled in improperly.
00:24:49
But the matter is now, the record is now straight and this resolution is designed to fix things.
SPEAKER_15
00:24:57
Mr. Chairman, I'd also like to note that the City did say they would reimburse VDOT for any costs associated with the appraisal and they will reimburse us $4700 if the Board approves this resolution.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:11
I move adoption, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_06
00:25:15
Does the public street serve other property?
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:21
Yes, it does.
00:25:22
And it's on both sides of Piedmont Drive.
00:25:26
Piedmont Drive is the old location of US Route 29 that went right through the middle of the city of Danville and of course now it was bypassed and the limited access break was approved back a year ago this time and had Danville submitted the proper paperwork it would have been approved as a break for public streets
00:25:51
And it's taken a long time for there to come to light, but it's now apparent.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:00
Any other questions or comments?
00:26:01
There's a motion on the floor.
00:26:02
Is there a second?
00:26:03
Second.
00:26:04
All in favor?
00:26:06
Aye.
00:26:07
Thank you.
00:26:08
Turning over to the next page, Local Assistance Division.
00:26:13
Mike Estes is back.
00:26:15
We'll take the industrial access projects up separately.
00:26:19
Item 7A is the Highlands Business Park.
00:26:22
Are there any questions?
00:26:23
Is there a motion?
00:26:27
Is there a second?
00:26:30
All in favor?
00:26:32
Thank you.
00:26:33
Item 7B is the route 1564 Zion Crossroads Industrial Park.
00:26:38
Excuse me.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:26:39
Mr. Chairman, I'd like to go back to the previous resolution and be sure that it's legally in order.
00:26:45
I guess because of the site.
00:26:51
You're discussing item 6A?
00:26:52
The county of, it says the county of Washington.
00:26:54
It's Washington County.
00:26:56
That's why it says locality, so it's okay to say locality and caps everywhere else and not the actual county.
SPEAKER_10
00:27:03
I think what happens is that the county of Washington becomes a defined term, locality, and then locality.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:20
Our council advises us there's not an issue there.
00:27:24
Item 7B, the 1564 Zion Crossroads Industrial Park Project in Louisa County.
00:27:30
Are there any questions of Mr. Estes?
00:27:32
Move approval.
00:27:34
Is there a second?
00:27:35
Second.
00:27:36
All in favor?
00:27:38
Aye.
00:27:39
Action item eight is action on revenue sharing program 8A.
00:27:47
And this is a very large step that we're taking here.
00:27:51
And I would ask Mr. Estes if he could go through a little bit of a presentation to describe and explain what we're doing.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:27:58
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:28:00
I appreciate the opportunity to do that.
00:28:02
This item is pertaining to the revenue sharing program.
00:28:05
As a reminder to the board, this program is an incentive program that allows the state to match local funds at a 50-50 rate.
00:28:13
This program has its origins in the code and traditionally has been open only to counties.
00:28:17
This year the Appropriations Act, the General Assembly expanded the program to include cities and towns under the urban system, increased the program size from 30 million to 100 million.
00:28:29
That's 15, it was traditionally 15 million in state money, 15 million in local.
00:28:34
This year it's 50 million in local money, 50 million in state money.
00:28:38
That modification and expansion also increased the maximum amount the localities were able to request.
00:28:47
Initially, the counties were able to request up to $500,000.
00:28:50
This year, they're able to request up to a million dollars.
00:28:54
What I'd like to do is, if you could, find, we went ahead and took liberty of putting in a, what I think is a very good summary sheet, nice yellow, and kind of walk you through what the response was.
00:29:11
Second walking from left to right top.
00:29:14
Out of the 176 localities, we had 98 requesting funds.
00:29:21
We're very, very pleased with the response this year.
00:29:23
That's 56%.
00:29:25
They requested of the $50 million available, they requested over $67 million.
00:29:31
So what that does is we take that request and anything that's above 50 million, we have to prorate that request down.
00:29:40
We then take the request and prorate them equally across all localities.
00:29:47
So the proration, for example, was 74, I'll give you the exact right number,
00:29:55
74.5%.
00:29:57
For example, if they requested a million dollars, those localities actually got around $745,000.
00:30:10
And the items at the below just kind of give us examples of what types of projects typically the revenue sharing program funds.
00:30:18
It's a wide array of anything from guard role improvements to bringing roads up to the system to putting them in for engineering for larger projects.
00:30:30
I guess I'll turn it back to you, Mr. Chairman.
00:30:31
Thank you.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:33
Would you say again the change in eligibility?
00:30:35
It used to be only for counties.
00:30:38
And it was 30 million dollars then?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:30:42
Yes, ma'am.
00:30:42
Let me take a shot at that again.
00:30:43
It's a very, very important point, a very big change from the traditional program.
00:30:49
Traditionally, again, it's open only to the counties across the state per code.
00:30:53
The General Assembly last year, with the budget bill, opened it up.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:57
No, but how much money was there when it was only open to counties?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:31:01
Okay.
00:31:01
In the code, it states 10 million, but traditionally, the last few years, that dollar amount's been 15 million of state funds.
00:31:08
That makes a $30 million overall program.
00:31:11
In the budget bill, they took that $15 million that's been there the last few years and they added $35 million of one-time money for this current fiscal year on top of that, bringing up to $50 million in state dollars to be matched by $50 million in local money.
SPEAKER_10
00:31:29
So the counties are getting more this year than they've gotten in the past.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:31:32
Absolutely.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:33
And the cities and towns who have not been eligible to participate in years past are eligible to participate.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:40
If I read these statistics wrong, they've been very, correctly, if I read them right, they've been very involved.
00:31:49
Most of it is going to towns and counties.
SPEAKER_11
00:31:51
Mr. Chairman, if I may, one other thing, they raised it from 500,000 to a million.
00:31:56
which was a significant bump and it made it so that some projects which were being done in phases could now be accelerated.
00:32:05
So that increased the amount as well.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:07
Except nobody got a million dollars, did they?
SPEAKER_11
00:32:10
No, that's what he was talking about with the percentage adjustment.
00:32:12
But they raised that ultimate cap.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:15
But people used to get the max.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:32:17
Well if I could speak to that for example, last year the proration for just the counties that were involved equated about 95% of the 500,000 so they wouldn't have got that either and I think maybe if I could Mr. Chairman take a few minutes to maybe prep you a little bit of some feedback you may receive from your counties and or your cities and towns.
00:32:40
The counties feel like with the expansion of cities and towns now in this program that maybe they would have gotten less this year.
00:32:48
We did run the numbers to look at what if it was just again a county program with a $500,000 max at $15 million and the actual participation from the counties this year has increased again dramatically from last year so that proration would have been about the same dollar amount.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:33:05
There has been some confusion in all this however in the counties as well and one of my jurisdictions was quite upset when they realized the changes without having done their homework perhaps as well as they should have and I'm still concerned as I read the language from the General Assembly even on reallocations
00:33:32
Now prevent them as well from benefiting from that as well because they did not receive the maximum.
00:33:38
They asked for a half million dollars which would have been the previous maximum.
00:33:43
and it just concerns me it's their fault under the language of the code and otherwise but it doesn't represent us well I don't think and it troubled me but there's nothing that I would specifically recommend our doing right now other than giving them our condolences because they need the money very badly to deal with their projects and then they're not going to get it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:06
I would observe that sometimes these very important issues often get missed in budget conferences that deal with very large issues very late in a legislative session and some of those rules were not perhaps as carefully addressed as they might have been.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:24
And if I read this language correctly, unless the code was revised, you will not be able to give any reallocation to cities because it says counties.
00:34:34
So you might want to take a look at that as well.
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:34:36
And we may need help, Mr. Chairman, with the interpretation, but I think our current interpretation would be to apply it to anyone who requested the maximum dollar amount.
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:45
I think, however, you better read the code then, Mr. Chairman.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:48
Okay.
00:34:50
I'm sure that council will be consulted on that one.
SPEAKER_11
00:34:52
Mr. Chairman, I'd just point out that not only did this department give notice to localities, but VACO and VML also gave notice to the localities.
00:35:03
It really is only so much you can do.
00:35:05
I mean, at some point, they have to take ownership of their responsibilities.
00:35:10
I don't place any blame on anybody except the locality.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:35:15
If I might, are there any other questions from the board?
00:35:20
Two questions.
00:35:22
First is what percentage of these projects are going to be administered by the localities?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:35:27
Okay, great question Mr. Chairman.
00:35:30
If you look in the columns to the right of the allocations, it talks about the total number of projects and the total number of locally administered projects.
00:35:40
So you can see a majority, if not all, of the urban systems have been encouraged to be locally administered because traditionally urban localities administer smaller type funding projects.
00:35:52
On the counties, on the other hand, the percentage is about, as you can see, it's
00:35:56
So, am I reading this correctly?
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:02
Out of a total of 265 projects, 151 are locally administered?
00:36:10
And that is, I think, an area we'll likely be making some recommendations both for budgetary and code changes.
00:36:17
We need to get that number up.
00:36:20
My second question has to do with the character of the
00:36:23
The projects and you break it down by type and just
00:36:29
My observation, looking quickly at it, is that there's not a lot of traditional, maybe 11% for widening and 8% for new roads or road extensions.
00:36:42
Many of these are intersection improvements, they're sidewalks, they're things we might consider enhancements to an existing infrastructure.
00:36:50
Drainage, I know it's significant.
00:36:53
Is that a fair characterization?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:36:54
This is a very accurate characterization of this program.
00:36:58
About a quarter of them, I would say in general terms, would be classified as any kind of capacity improvement.
00:37:05
Most of them are affected on what I would deem as well enhancement type projects.
00:37:10
I know when I was working in Northern Virginia with the Fairfax County folks, a lot of that was dealing with traditional, with their concern with the maximum being 500,000.
00:37:19
There's only so much you can do to bring to fruition.
SPEAKER_00
00:37:22
Mr. Chairman, I'd just like to say as someone who's been involved in county government, rural county government, it's a great program.
00:37:29
And it really helped us do a couple things we couldn't have done otherwise.
00:37:32
And it's really putting, letting a, in our case, a rural county put its money where its mouth is.
00:37:39
It shows us it really wants something that's willing to put up a lot of its own money to get to Southern.
SPEAKER_13
00:37:45
Mr. Chairman, move the approval and allocation as designated and exhibited.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:50
I would also note that there will be a press release on this shortly, so you may get contacted by the media and or your localities on the topic.
Katherine K. Hanley
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:05
In order for it to be crystal clear, we may want to go back and put in this chart.
00:38:10
For example, in the Prince William County section of this chart, it's actually very clearly identified what the roads are, but many of the roads in this chart tell you a long gobbledygook number and then from route to route.
00:38:24
If you look at the Prince William section, it has all the names of the roads under there.
00:38:29
It would be useful to put the names of the roads.
00:38:31
You can't find the number of the route, or you might not know what 1244 is.
00:38:36
If you're going to release it, it won't make any sense to the public.
SPEAKER_10
00:38:40
In terms of exhibit A and all of the cities, counties, and towns that have requested funds, was it just a straight pro-rata reduction for all that was sought?
00:38:53
So the $67 million that was sought was reduced pro-rata and awarded, is that right?
Michael A. Estes
Local Assistance Division Administrator
00:38:57
That's correct.
00:38:58
And I will say at the next level down is we actually give localities an option.
00:39:02
For example, say they request money for four projects.
00:39:06
The board's discretion in this, though, is
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:22
Action Item 8B is a reallocation of funds for Hanover County.
00:39:49
Are there any questions of Mr. Estes?
00:39:52
Is there a motion?
James A. Davis
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:53
Move it.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:54
Is there a second?
00:39:55
Second.
00:39:56
All in favor?
00:39:57
Aye.
00:39:58
Thank you.
00:40:00
Action item 9A is action on industrial rail access and Mr. Kevin Page is here to answer any questions.
00:40:08
Are there any questions of Mr.
00:40:09
Page?
00:40:11
Is there a motion?
SPEAKER_13
00:40:12
Move approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:13
Second.
00:40:15
All in favor?
00:40:18
Aye.
SPEAKER_05
00:40:19
Chairman, because the industrial access program was up earlier, have we pretty much for this year, where are we on the scale for spending money that's available between rail and road highway access?
00:40:33
I mean, we've got to be pretty well spending down everything we see obligated.
00:40:37
Can you answer that, Kevin?
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:38
Well, for the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, this is our first allocation here.
00:40:42
It's 450,000 out of the 5.5 million.
00:40:45
Okay, so that's the first one for this year.
00:40:47
That's right.
00:40:47
And as you may recall, we just deallocated TRES just a few months ago as well.
SPEAKER_05
00:40:52
So this is the beginning of the process.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:54
Yes, ma'am.
00:40:57
Item 10 is the action item on the roadside management program.
00:41:00
Mr. Carr has returned.
00:41:01
Are there any questions of Mr. Carr?
00:41:04
Is there a motion?
00:41:07
Is there a second?
00:41:09
All in favor?
00:41:12
Aye.
00:41:12
Action item 11 is action on bids received and Mr. Coburn is here and I believe there is one addition to the bids that you have.
00:41:25
Byron if you could walk us through those one by one please.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:41:29
Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen.
00:41:33
Presenting to you today eight projects that were bid to receive.
00:41:38
Of these eight, in general, competition was good.
00:41:43
It was great.
00:41:45
Starting with page one, interstate system, Route 64, this is the Hampton Ridge Bridge Tunnel.
00:41:51
It's a handrail and sidewalk repair tunnel.
00:41:56
This is a rebid.
00:41:59
This is a maintenance funded project and as such was not an allocation for that project.
00:42:06
However, this bid is an accident.
00:42:12
We would recommend
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:14
Are there any questions?
00:42:16
Is there a motion?
00:42:18
Second?
00:42:20
Hear a second?
00:42:22
All in favor?
00:42:25
Aye.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:42:28
Page 2, this is Route 340, the North Fork Bridge over the, Route 340 Bridge over the North Fork and Shenandoah River at Front Oil in Warren County.
00:42:41
An excellent bid, firm getting back into business, three competitors on that job are recommended to order.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:42:52
Any questions?
00:42:53
Motion is there a second?
00:42:54
All in favor?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:42:59
The second item on that same page is about 206 in King George County over Peppermill Creek.
00:43:09
This is a replacement of a bridge from the 1930 era.
00:43:12
Again, three bidders, an excellent, an excellent head.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:20
That was a big part of our report.
00:43:22
Mr.
SPEAKER_13
00:43:22
Chair, notice on that specific order as well as the next that
00:43:29
A similar thing is happening each time is that a six-year program does not have supposedly adequate money to award this bid.
00:43:39
We're $195,000 short is what's shown in the program on the second one, and then we have seven bids on the other, but that's almost a half a million dollars short.
00:43:49
What projects are getting a reduction of $425,000 to make the award in Wythe County and what project is getting $195,000 reduction in King George County?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:44:03
When we are comparing the bids, we're confirming at two points in the bid process, once prior to advertisement with our programming division, that adequate funds are in those areas for our engineering estimate.
00:44:22
Then as the bids are received, we're doing the comparison at that point in time on the
00:44:31
One hundred project in Wythe County.
00:44:35
Funds were transferred from another project on the route fifty-eight quarter in
00:44:47
The Bridge Over Russell Creek, that project is being redesigned to eliminate a major structure reducing to a smaller type design and funds were transferred from that project to cover this one.
SPEAKER_13
00:45:08
That was primarily the one I was asking about.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:14
Okay.
00:45:15
Robert, any other questions?
00:45:16
I'll move.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:45:17
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:19
All in favor?
00:45:20
Aye.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:45:21
Any opposed?
00:45:26
Page 3, the property system.
00:45:30
Again, we had four bidders on this project.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:34
This is about 50 over 27.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:45:37
This is the replacement of the superstructure, repairs, and approaches to that bridge.
00:45:46
Four bidders, and again, an excellent bid was received.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:53
Any questions?
00:45:55
Move the motion.
00:45:56
Second.
00:45:57
All in favor?
00:45:59
Aye.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:46:03
At 620, this is also called Foursquare Road in Iowa White County.
00:46:10
This is a trench widening reconstruction of a rural route sharing about 1,300 vehicles a day.
00:46:21
That's a collector route.
00:46:24
Two bidders on this job, one new bidder into the environment that we hadn't seen for a bit, and very refreshing.
00:46:36
Again, this was a good bid.
00:46:38
We confirmed with the program division that there had been error in the reported amount in the six-year program, and more than adequate funds were there for that project.
00:46:54
I recommend it's approval.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:56
Is there a motion?
00:46:58
So moved.
00:46:59
Is there a second?
00:47:00
Second.
00:47:01
All in favor?
SPEAKER_15
00:47:02
Aye.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:47:06
Page 5, primary system.
00:47:09
This is Route 460 in George County.
00:47:14
We only have one bidder on this job.
00:47:17
We interviewed the bidder and we took a hard look at those plans.
00:47:26
In discussion with that contractor, we believe there was some risk in that contract in the plans that were not clearly defined, which increased the bid price.
00:47:39
We're recommending a rejection of that.
00:47:43
The department is going to go back and redefine and clarify those planned risk issues, and we believe that we should have a significantly better bid when it is re-advertised.
00:47:57
We recommend a rejection.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:59
Is there a motion to reject?
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:48:00
I move to move.
00:48:02
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:03
All in favor?
00:48:05
Aye.
Warner B. "Byron" Coburn
Scheduling and Contract Division Administrator
00:48:06
The addition is the pink sheet on page six.
00:48:13
This is the 17 crossband on the James River.
00:48:18
This is a repainting, cleaning and repainting the towers and the lift span on the James River Bridge.
00:48:25
We've received three bids on the job.
00:48:29
In looking at and analyzing those, again, talking with the contractors, we realized there were some issues with
00:48:41
The completion of that project, keeping that bridge in operation, and there were, again, some risk issues that needed to be clarified with legal, significantly better bids with that at the recommended protection.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:58
Is there a motion to reject?
00:49:00
So moved.
00:49:02
Second?
00:49:02
Second.
00:49:03
All in favor?
00:49:06
Aye.
00:49:06
Is that it, Byron?
00:49:07
That's it, sir.
00:49:08
Thank you.
00:49:08
It sounds like it was a little bit better competitive environment this last one.
00:49:15
Turning to new business, we do have two items actually in your agenda package at the very back.
00:49:23
The first is a very important item relating to the utilization of available federal funds and obligation authority.
00:49:29
We had a brief discussion about this.
00:49:31
I would like to ask Ms. Reese just to give us a brief overview of what's being done here.
00:49:37
And why it's important.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:49:39
As I mentioned when Mary Lynn was talking to you earlier, one of the things that happened somewhat unexpectedly last week, unlike other re-authorizations we had before, there was almost an immediate
00:49:55
amount of funding available to the states that had to be obligated.
00:49:58
Well, $50 million more, so we worked through the six-year program.
00:50:05
There was plenty of work to be obligated and to use that funding, but because it may not be exactly, we cannot obligate those funds or spend those funds until this court has taken an action.
00:50:19
We don't want to revise the six-year program to $50 million.
00:50:23
In consultation with the Attorney General's Office, it was decided that we could do this resolution empowering the Secretary to take those actions on your behalf, but following your policy goals.
00:50:35
On top of that, we have worked very hard this year to get financial records between the MPOs and the board.
00:50:46
Completely corrected.
00:50:48
We've been able to obligate 100% of our federal funds that were available to us this year.
00:50:52
That was $643 million.
00:50:54
You have to remember the federal fiscal year runs from October 1 to September 30, so we have this 90-day difference between the end of the state fiscal year and the end of the federal.
00:51:07
We were able to successfully obligate all that, and there is a
00:51:11
Press release in the back of your finder that outlines a request that we submitted yesterday morning on behalf of the board to the Federal Highway Administration.
00:51:23
I believe it was on Monday.
00:51:26
We had until yesterday to submit our list of projects.
00:51:30
for spending of any additional federal funds that may become available to the Commonwealth before the end of September.
00:51:37
We had $86 million in projects that were ready to go.
00:51:40
You can see those lists.
00:51:43
There's a variety of things in there.
00:51:46
IDEA 66 plot improvements.
00:51:48
working, Mr. Bowie and Mr.
00:51:51
Keen with the Colfield connector RFI, some right-of-way down in Hampton Roads.
00:51:56
There's a variety of things that are available and we've submitted that list yesterday about noon and we got approval last night and they have forwarded that request.
00:52:05
We've made one to the headquarters in Washington DC and we will probably know
00:52:11
sometime the last week of September we'll immediately have to take the action and you're not here to take that action for us so this just empowers the Secretary to live on your behalf so sort of two things happening at one time that we're trying to take care of in this resolution.
00:52:26
Move approval, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_11
00:52:28
Second.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:29
All in favor?
00:52:31
Aye.
00:52:32
If I might, as a matter of editorial comment,
00:52:35
For months now we have been, I won't say besieged, but periodically we get calls from media outlets around the state suggesting that perhaps Virginia might not be able to obligate all of its federal funds
00:52:48
and implying that perhaps we weren't doing our job.
00:52:52
Now those stories don't arise in and of themselves.
00:52:55
There's a widespread geography and we have invested a lot of time simply talking to members of the media to say, no, we are doing our job.
00:53:07
The commissioner wrote, had to write a letter to one of the newspapers in the Hampton Roads area to say, we're doing our job.
00:53:13
We will fully obligate all our money and indeed we will likely ask for more.
00:53:17
And the action you just took today says you've done your job.
00:53:21
You're going to ask for more.
00:53:22
And so you may get calls.
00:53:25
There's been a lot of education of the media in a lot of different media markets throughout the Commonwealth.
00:53:31
And this is, again, the kind of thing, this is very good work in terms of just the law reconciliation.
00:53:38
The numbers had not been reconciled for years.
00:53:41
And that's a tedious, laborious process, but it's part of having one set of books.
00:53:46
And that's something that the finance staff within VDOT has accomplished.
00:53:51
That's, again, another thing to check off in terms of financial renewal and also having the capability to ask for more federal dollars.
00:54:00
An important step.
00:54:01
So I hope if you get asked that you can carry that message back to your communities.
00:54:07
Thank you.
00:54:08
The last item on here relates to the town of Grundy and a relocation agreement.
00:54:18
I'll ask the chief engineer to give us a brief description of that.
SPEAKER_15
00:54:22
Yes, Mr. Chairman, the purpose of this agreement is basically to allow us to enter into an agreement with the Corps of Engineers, allow the commissioner to sign an agreement that
00:54:32
will allow us to be repaid $1.45 million.
00:54:35
We are building portion of the Grundy project to specifications of the Corps and they have agreed to pay any difference in that.
00:54:43
So it's $1.45 million that this agreement will allow us to be reimbursed by the Corps.
Kenneth Spencer White
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:49
Move the adoption and resolution.
00:54:51
Second.
00:54:52
All in favor.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:53
Is there anything else to come before the board?
SPEAKER_02
00:54:57
Before Ms. Reese, please, and another example of being so well managed in such a good state, the private sector seems very interested in buying our assets now.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:09
I might interject that some seem interested in selling
SPEAKER_02
00:55:12
Well, I will only deal with the fact that we as a policy making board I think need to have some guidance and I know there is the example of the Chicago Skyway that everybody keeps referring to.
00:55:27
and I think that enough time has passed and maybe in the next couple of months the staff might be able to provide us with some of the methodologies that were used in assessing value and also some of the lessons learned whether they because I now notice that the property has been refinanced and there have been some fancy financial footwork and I think we all need to be as smart as we can so I would appreciate it.
Barbara W. Reese
Chief Financial Officer
00:55:54
I'd be happy to do that for you.
Pierce R. Homer
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:55:56
Thank you for that request, and while there is a formal PPTA proposal on the Dulles Tola with respect to that, there is a large, I would say, more than conceptual debate among certain members of legislative leadership about the disposition of our transportation assets and potentially their sale.
00:56:15
So this is a very, very important, very expensive issue.
00:56:22
Thank you for that request.
00:56:22
Any other new business?
00:56:24
Without debate we stand adjourned.