Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 12/19/2002
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   12/19/2002

Attachments
  • Minutes.pdf
  • TRANSPORTATION BOARD RECOMMENDS IMPROVEMENTS TO DULLES CORRIDOR.pdf
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning.
    • 00:00:01
      I want to welcome the members of the Transportation Board as well as others here in the room for our monthly meeting of the CTB.
    • 00:00:18
      We will follow the agenda.
    • 00:00:20
      As set forth, I always need to acknowledge and thank Catherine Tracy for her good work in keeping us as well organized as I think we are.
    • 00:00:36
      I want to say that at the end of the agenda where it says adjournment, it will actually be a recess.
    • 00:00:44
      In order to comply with certain notice requirements, we will just have a recess and then reconvene for lunch with members of the Senate Finance and House Appropriations Committee.
    • 00:01:00
      I don't know how many members are going to be with us this afternoon, but the second part of our agenda will be
    • 00:01:12
      The presentation of three different subject matters with the legislators and discussion and that will go no later than four o'clock this afternoon.
    • 00:01:25
      With that said, if there are no other preliminary matters,
    • 00:01:31
      Let me tell everybody on the board, we've got one person listed here under public comment, Mr. Archie B. Ellis, but we have a sign-up sheet.
    • 00:01:45
      of perhaps as many as six others, all of whom I believe wish to speak to an action item on the agenda dealing with Dulles Rail.
    • 00:01:58
      In the interest of time and in view of our agenda, I'm going to ask each speaker to limit his or her
    • 00:02:08
      Remarks to five minutes maximum with the request that as much as you can avoid being repetitive of what may have already been said.
    • 00:02:24
      I think that way you can keep all of our attention
    • 00:02:29
      Perhaps better, and we'll be able to better stay on schedule.
    • 00:02:37
      First, I would like to recognize in our public comment period Mr. Archie B. Ellis.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:02:50
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 00:02:53
      I wanted to pass those copies of the memo that was proven in those around.
    • 00:03:04
      Ladies and gentlemen, my name is Archie Ellis.
    • 00:03:08
      I'm a retired lawyer here in Richmond.
    • 00:03:11
      I've been active with transportation for many years.
    • 00:03:14
      In fact, I go back to the first Secretary of Transportation, Wayne Witham, and before that I had the privilege of speaking to you back in July when many of you had first come on the board.
    • 00:03:27
      And I thought then that your appointment and the circumstances gave you a greater responsibility than other boards have had and an opportunity to take real initiative.
    • 00:03:39
      And that was the basis of my remarks in July, and I want to renew those to you.
    • 00:03:46
      And I've given you the same letter.
    • 00:03:48
      And I would like to very briefly run down it in the hopes of stimulating your curiosity so you'll read it and look at it more critically.
    • 00:04:00
      The fundamental point I'd like to make with you is that the Commonwealth Transportation Board is the most important citizen transportation group in the state.
    • 00:04:10
      I, as an individual citizen, and I represent no group, but I am a little better informed than most of the members of the general public because I've been involved in these things for many years.
    • 00:04:23
      But I would like to see you take initiative.
    • 00:04:26
      My observations from coming to these meetings over many years is that you spend most of your time rubber-stamping what has been done by the department.
    • 00:04:36
      I would like to see things on this agenda that one or the other of you are presenting and urging the others to adopt.
    • 00:04:43
      And I think there are major policy decisions in this state that need your attention.
    • 00:04:48
      You've now all had six months or more of heavy involvement.
    • 00:04:52
      You've seen lots of things in the paper.
    • 00:04:55
      I'm sure you've had lots of reports from staff and others that have caused you to have concern.
    • 00:05:00
      And there are things that I think this board can do, and I think should do.
    • 00:05:05
      And I think you have a statutory obligation to take initiative for the general public.
    • 00:05:10
      That's what I would like to see.
    • 00:05:12
      I know there's political risk in some of that, but I'd like for you to take that risk and bite the bullet and go ahead.
    • 00:05:19
      I've mentioned a couple of things in the letter that I'm giving you that I hope you'll take a look at, one of which is cost-benefit analysis.
    • 00:05:28
      I've been coming to these meetings for many years.
    • 00:05:30
      I've watched many projects, mostly in the Richmond area.
    • 00:05:34
      But I've watched closely the mixing bowl up there in Northern Virginia and the Woodrow Wilson Bridge and Route 288 here in Richmond and some others.
    • 00:05:43
      And I have not seen cost-benefit analysis done.
    • 00:05:48
      And I think if it was done even on a superficial level, some decisions would be much different from what they have been.
    • 00:05:56
      Now I'm sure that somewhere in the U.S. there are transportation officials that have got formulas for doing what you would call a sophisticated cost-benefit analysis, and I'm not capable of telling you how to do that.
    • 00:06:10
      But I would like to see you start that.
    • 00:06:12
      on major projects.
    • 00:06:14
      You might use a $5 million rule or something else.
    • 00:06:17
      But it badly needs to be done.
    • 00:06:19
      And I think if it had been done with several of the major projects that are slurping up all the money in the state, they would not have been done.
    • 00:06:28
      I'd like for you to take a hard look at toll roads and bridges.
    • 00:06:32
      I think that's a critical need.
    • 00:06:34
      People don't like them.
    • 00:06:35
      I don't like them.
    • 00:06:36
      Probably you don't like them.
    • 00:06:37
      They are other reasons.
    • 00:06:39
      But they serve a wonderful function.
    • 00:06:41
      And I think you've got some major projects pending around the state where that would fit.
    • 00:06:47
      We had a fine one here in Richmond, the Richmond-Petersburg Turnpike, which preceded the interstate system.
    • 00:06:54
      It was a cash cow.
    • 00:06:57
      It was contributing money to the Richmond area to pay for roads other than its own maintenance.
    • 00:07:03
      And the tolls were terminated on that road, which I think was a great mistake.
    • 00:07:07
      And you've had $100 million or so renovating the bridge over the James River that it would have paid for itself.
    • 00:07:15
      I think if tolls were put on the Woodrow Wilson Bridge, your problem would be greatly diminished in that expenditure.
    • 00:07:23
      The new proposed crossings and things down in the Tidewater area are the same illustration.
    • 00:07:31
      Put the tolls back on the Hampton Roads bridge tunnel.
    • 00:07:34
      and you cut the traffic problem and you would also get a lot of money to do other things.
    • 00:07:39
      So I would like to suggest that.
    • 00:07:41
      Another item that I think I have observed that I think you might look at and come forward with legislative recommendations about is the allocation formula around the state.
    • 00:07:52
      I know the reasons for a lot of that.
    • 00:07:55
      They're fundamental, they're important and many people think they're critical.
    • 00:07:59
      But I do think I see projects done simply because there's an allocation formula and they need to spend the money in their territory even though they really don't need the road.
    • 00:08:10
      So I think you might take a hard look at that.
    • 00:08:13
      Another one I wish you would take a hard look at
    • 00:08:16
      is Amtrak and rail transportation, and I know you are, but I've been tuned in on that for a long time.
    • 00:08:23
      I was general counsel for a railroad and I was involved in the whole Amtrak process, including the location of the present station here in Richmond.
    • 00:08:32
      The state, the federal government, and I guess I will say the Commonwealth Transportation Board, is now spending some $50 million to renovate Main Street Station.
    • 00:08:45
      And there's a good prospect that there's going to be almost no trains down there.
    • 00:08:48
      In fact, there's very little prospect of many trains for quite a while.
    • 00:08:52
      And you know the federal problems perhaps that are critical on Amtrak.
    • 00:08:57
      But another problem is that the state of Virginia has never put a nickel into Amtrak.
    • 00:09:02
      North Carolina puts a lot into it.
    • 00:09:04
      I think you need to take a hard look at that.
    • 00:09:07
      And I've said a whole lot.
    • 00:09:09
      One item I really want to thank to you is the Huguenot Bridge, which has been a pet project here in the Richmond area.
    • 00:09:16
      And I know there's no funds to renovate that at this time.
    • 00:09:21
      It's roughly a $30 million project.
    • 00:09:23
      But about three years ago, the state spent, I think, a million and a half dollars to hire consulting engineers to make a report on what to do about that bridge.
    • 00:09:33
      I've never seen that report.
    • 00:09:35
      I guess the million and a half has been paid to them, but I don't know what they did.
    • 00:09:39
      And I'd like to see that thing cranked up.
    • 00:09:42
      And the reason it is not being done, it's a 30 million dollar job by their early estimates.
    • 00:09:48
      30,000 vehicles per day is critical in the city.
    • 00:09:53
      And it's not being built because Route 288 is getting all the money.
    • 00:09:57
      And I don't know how many of you are familiar with Route 288, but I see it frequently because I play golf out near it.
    • 00:10:04
      It's out where nobody lives.
    • 00:10:07
      And I don't think it's going to have much traffic for a long time, but it's getting 280 million or so dollars of the Richmond area funding.
    • 00:10:15
      Now on the Huguenot Bridge,
    • 00:10:17
      I want to give you a plus.
    • 00:10:20
      The Chesterfield Residency District, Chris Winstead is a resident engineer, got around to painting the bridge.
    • 00:10:30
      We've been fussing about that from our neighborhood, I live over there, for years.
    • 00:10:34
      It looked awful.
    • 00:10:36
      And they didn't have the funds to paint it.
    • 00:10:38
      It was about a four or five hundred thousand dollar contract job.
    • 00:10:41
      And the staff out there, the bridge gang, as I would term it, created a Rube Goldberg device, and they got out there and they painted that bridge, and it looks beautiful, and I've been the voice for the neighborhood.
    • 00:10:56
      People call me up every day and say, thanks for getting that bridge painted, and I say, call Chris Winstead.
    • 00:11:01
      But you folks that are mostly from out of town probably don't pick up Style magazine, which is the paper in Richmond,
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:11:11
      I want to compliment them.
    • SPEAKER_07
    • 00:11:27
      And I'm told they got very enthusiastic about it and were proud of their work and it wasn't just a chore.
    • 00:11:35
      And I want to suggest to you that they did such a great job.
    • 00:11:37
      You may want to look at that device they created and use it someplace else.
    • 00:11:42
      But anyhow, thank you all for listening.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:46
      Thank you.
    • 00:11:46
      Ms. Dallas, thank you for your comments.
    • 00:11:50
      You keep following the actions of this board as we continue to get up to speed on a number of the issues that you have cited.
    • 00:12:00
      I would invite you to look at our workshop agenda items over the last four or five months.
    • 00:12:07
      And I think that you will see us doing a number of things to the extent that we can because we are limited by the law.
    • 00:12:16
      Thank you for being with us today.
    • 00:12:22
      I'm going to go down this clipboard on the people who have signed up to speak in the public comment period.
    • 00:12:32
      The first name is Bill Vincent, Breakthrough Technology Institute.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 00:12:40
      Good morning.
    • 00:12:41
      Thank you very much for the opportunity to testify today.
    • 00:12:45
      Like a number of other people here, I'm going to testify about the Dulles Corridor Rapid Transit Project.
    • 00:12:51
      As the Secretary noted, I'm with the Breakthrough Technology Institute.
    • 00:12:55
      We're a nonprofit 501c3 based in Washington that promotes advanced energy and environmental technologies, and I'm also an Arlington resident.
    • 00:13:07
      I want to emphasize to you today the importance of the decision that you're about to undertake.
    • 00:13:15
      As you know, there's been significant debate regarding the appropriate transit solution for the Dulles corridor.
    • 00:13:22
      But in the heat of these discussions, it's often easy to lose track of the bigger picture.
    • 00:13:27
      The question here is not metro rail versus bus rapid transit or monorail versus light rail.
    • 00:13:35
      It strikes me that these are false choices.
    • 00:13:38
      They suggest that transportation policy is somehow about systems and vehicles as opposed to being about people, growth, and opportunity.
    • 00:13:48
      The question I think before you today is how do we ensure that transportation contributes to a Northern Virginia where companies choose to do business and people choose to live?
    • 00:14:00
      In other words, how do we provide transportation solutions that serve people without stressing our already faltering economy, without sacrificing important state programs like health care and education, or without saddling future generations with unnecessary debt?
    • 00:14:18
      Regardless of what mode you support, it seems to me that one thing is clear.
    • 00:14:24
      The proposal before you today is the wrong answer to these questions.
    • 00:14:29
      Its astronomical cost, which by the way would exceed by almost 1.5 billion dollars the original cost for Boston's Big Dig, would cripple state and local budgets.
    • 00:14:41
      And just like the Big Dig, the project would be like a black hole, absorbing funding from other important state priorities
    • 00:14:48
      and, frankly, casting a long shadow on the wisdom of the Commonwealth's transportation policies.
    • 00:14:56
      At the same time, the project's expensive, relatively low capacity, outdated, and inflexible design would offer little congestion relief.
    • 00:15:05
      This is particularly true for north-south roads, which VDOT itself, as indicated, would suffer traffic increases because of the proposed project.
    • 00:15:14
      But don't take my word for it.
    • 00:15:16
      As all of you know, the Federal Transit Administration, which you're depending upon to fund at least 50% of the cost, has recently warned that the project just does not meet legal requirements.
    • 00:15:28
      And I'm quoting here from the FTA, when we saw that the locally preferred alternative was rail, we said, oh my, it's never going to pass Congressionally mandated statutory criteria.
    • 00:15:40
      In other words, it's not going to get funded.
    • 00:15:45
      I've been involved in transportation issues for a long time, including five years at the USDOT.
    • 00:15:53
      And I have to be honest with you, I have never seen the federal government step in and so publicly reject a project before it's even been selected by the state.
    • 00:16:02
      This was, in my view, clearly unprecedented and designed to send a strong and decisive message.
    • 00:16:10
      This message, coupled with the defeat of the sales tax referendum and the lack of other local funding sources, leaves you with a pretty clear choice.
    • 00:16:21
      Do you commit the Commonwealth to a project that it cannot afford and that the FTA says it will not fund?
    • 00:16:27
      Or do you find a way to solve our transportation crisis in a reasonable time frame and within a reasonable budget?
    • 00:16:35
      This decision is critical.
    • 00:16:37
      Accepting the locally preferred alternative as proposed to you today is going to lead to tens of millions in engineering funds, expenditures for a project that we know is already financially doomed.
    • 00:16:52
      This is not a desirable or a wise outcome, regardless of what trans option you support.
    • 00:16:57
      Plus, it would violate Governor Warner's recently announced policy that all major transportation projects have to have a detailed financial plan prior to approval showing all sources of funding.
    • 00:17:10
      We know here that federal funding is not going to be available and there isn't a single source of identified state funding that's available either.
    • 00:17:18
      So if you go forward as we believe you will today, I think you run the risk of violating the governor's policy.
    • 00:17:26
      I think also accepting a hybrid solution, as some have talked about, that is rail to Tysons and BRT or some other system from Tysons and Dulles Airport, poses the same problem and the same risk.
    • 00:17:43
      Basic questions in a hybrid solution are also unanswered, such as how many passengers would it carry?
    • 00:17:50
      How much would it cost?
    • 00:17:53
      Are there alternatives that can do the job better, cheaper, and faster?
    • 00:17:56
      The law is clear.
    • 00:17:57
      We need to have answers to these questions before you can move forward.
    • 00:18:01
      Your best bet is to choose a solution that is going to provide relief now without busting the budget, without increasing taxes, and frankly without facing another embarrassing rebuke by the FTA.
    • 00:18:14
      For cities around the globe, including Los Angeles, which has worse traffic congestion than Northern Virginia, that solution is increasingly Bus Rapid Transit, or BRT.
    • 00:18:25
      They're choosing it because its unique blend of cost-effectiveness, high capacity, and flexibility serves people and communities, not vehicles and systems.
    • 00:18:35
      BRT is not a monument to itself.
    • 00:18:38
      It is a practical solution to real problems.
    • 00:18:41
      BRT systems routinely carry far more passengers than the proposed Dulles Rail, yet at a tiny fraction of the cost.
    • 00:18:49
      That's why FTA is supporting it, that's why the Commonwealth has been urged to consider it, that's why Congress supports it, and that's why cities like Los Angeles are implementing it right now.
    • 00:19:01
      I think you really have an historic opportunity here to build a world-class, high-capacity, environmentally-friendly system that serves the entire Northern Virginia community, not just a very narrow east-west corridor from the airport to downtown.
    • 00:19:17
      And this system can be a model for high-quality public transportation without the stigma of embarrassing cost overruns or bloated operating subsidies.
    • 00:19:27
      Some have suggested that choosing BRT today would be a rejection of rail.
    • 00:19:33
      This is not true.
    • 00:19:34
      Selecting BRT simply means that you choose to offer congestion relief now, that you are committed to action instead of more wasteful studies, and that you respect the Commonwealth's dire budget situation and the poor state of the economy.
    • 00:19:49
      Rail can always be built later if circumstances warrant.
    • 00:19:54
      In conclusion, I just want to re-emphasize that as a Northern Virginia resident and someone's been involved in transportation for a long time, we need action now.
    • 00:20:03
      We don't need more waste and delay.
    • 00:20:06
      We certainly don't need a project that's going to dwarf the Springfield mixing bowl in terms of cost.
    • 00:20:12
      It's going to rival Boston's Big Dig and its potential for cost overruns and embarrassment.
    • 00:20:19
      If you don't select PRT today, I hope you will at least defer your decision and study this issue further.
    • 00:20:30
      Committing the Commonwealth to a multi-billion dollar project without the benefit of more discussion and more open hearings seems irresponsible at best, particularly in light of the serious legal doubts expressed by the Federal Transit Administration.
    • 00:20:45
      Thank you, and I'm happy to answer any questions you may have.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:48
      Thank you, Mr. Vinson.
    • 00:20:51
      Alright, next is Patty Mason, and again, we appreciate your keeping your remarks to five minutes.
    • 00:20:58
      Just Mason.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:21:01
      Patty.
    • 00:21:04
      Good morning Chairman Clement and fellow Commissioners.
    • 00:21:10
      My name is Patty Nickerson and I'm President of the Dallas Corridor Rail Association.
    • 00:21:14
      It's a four and a half year old non-profit advocacy group for rail in the Dallas Corridor.
    • 00:21:20
      I wanted to touch on four subjects briefly this morning.
    • 00:21:24
      One is the long continuing and broad support for the Dulles Rail Project.
    • 00:21:30
      The second is what's going on in the Washington region and some regional activity center projections that were released this summer.
    • 00:21:37
      The third is the local jurisdiction's long involvement with land use, trying to shape transit-oriented development around the rail station stops.
    • 00:21:47
      And finally, I wanted to touch briefly on ridership and cost.
    • 00:21:52
      As to the broad support, why you yourselves in 1996 supported the recommendations that grew out of the major investment study for a seamless extension of the metro rail system.
    • 00:22:01
      Our organization consists of business and civic leaders, individuals and elected officials.
    • 00:22:08
      We faxed you down and mailed to you a statement of the members of our board
    • 00:22:13
      We also included a list of a group of 20 organizations that came together.
    • 00:22:18
      We helped facilitate for the public hearing process a group of 20 organizations that came together in support of Dulles Rail Now.
    • 00:22:27
      They include diverse and often not so friendly groups such as the Sierra Club, the Coalition for Smarter Growth, the Greater Washington Board of Trade,
    • 00:22:35
      National Wildlife Federation, American Lung Association, a number of civic groups, and also religious-based groups.
    • 00:22:46
      They testified individually in support of the project, and we testified as a group.
    • 00:22:52
      As a result, as you know, 78% endorsed the rail alternative during the public hearing process.
    • 00:22:58
      Finally, concerning support, former Senator Chuck Robb and former Governor Linwood Houlton have been working with local property owners to develop a petition to submit to the Fairfax County Board, wherein the property owners would pay for the local Fairfax share of the project.
    • 00:23:19
      So that is broad and continuing support for the project.
    • 00:23:22
      As to the projections, Cog released this summer the result of a three-year effort, and it identified about 42 major regional activity centers, and I was reviewing these figures closely a couple of weeks ago before our annual meeting, and I was kind of surprised to see that in Tysons Corner today, there's more employment than is in the entire Roslyn-Vollston corridor, which is served by five metro rail stations.
    • 00:23:48
      They broke it up so that the Dulles Corridor contains five major activity centers, and when you add them up, they currently have more employment that's in the Rosalind-Balsam Corridor today.
    • 00:24:01
      When you look forward 20 years,
    • 00:24:04
      The Dallas corridor employment is projected to go to 280,000 employees, whereas the Balsam-Roslyn corridor is only going to be about 125,000.
    • 00:24:15
      In addition, we have the Route 28 corridor.
    • 00:24:20
      Some of you are familiar with that.
    • 00:24:23
      The four activity centers along that corridor have about 65,000 employees today and in the future are expected to have about 130,000.
    • 00:24:32
      Some of these figures were in the letter that our chairman, who wanted me to send his regrets for not being able to come here, sent to you.
    • 00:24:39
      That means that in 2025 we're projected to have more than 400,000 employees.
    • 00:24:46
      That's really kind of astonishing, and we're the largest employee corridor that's not yet served by Metrorail.
    • 00:24:53
      As to land use, both jurisdictions, Arlington, I mean,
    • 00:24:57
      Loudon, and Fairfax County have been working on the land use issue for nearly a decade.
    • 00:25:03
      I participated in a land use task force that met in 2000 that resulted in the Fairfax County adopting changes to its comp plan to encourage transit-oriented development around the metro rail stations.
    • 00:25:16
      What we've got in that section of the corridor is employment office parks.
    • 00:25:20
      What we want to do is bring in the residential and retail to make them vibrant communities.
    • 00:25:25
      This will happen if there's the public commitment to rail, the fixed rail capital investment.
    • 00:25:31
      It's happened in Arlington, it's happened in Bethesda, and it's happened in the District of Columbia.
    • 00:25:35
      So our local jurisdictions really see this as an important tool of their economic development strategy.
    • 00:25:41
      The increased revenues, property tax, sales tax, income taxes for the state that these high quality developments will generate will benefit both the local and the state governments.
    • 00:25:55
      Just this week, Loudoun County approved a major town center at the last station, Route 772, and it will accommodate eventually 6,000 housing units and 10 million square feet of office and commercial space.
    • 00:26:10
      So Loudoun County is firmly committed to seeing this rail happen and help it transform its county and meet some of its economic obligations.
    • 00:26:18
      As to ridership, rail has the capacity, as you saw on the EIS, to carry nearly 10,000 riders per hour, whereas bus rapid transit is only about 1,800.
    • 00:26:30
      What it didn't note was that the rail system actually could carry up to 50,000 to 60,000 passengers per hour in a single direction.
    • 00:26:38
      So only rail really has the capacity to evolve with our growing corridor.
    • 00:26:43
      Closing?
    • 00:26:46
      Well, I wanted to talk about a vision for the 21st century.
    • 00:26:49
      We have our Dulles International Airport, we have our National Capital City, we see the Dulles Corridor as an increasingly important gateway to the National Capital, and we hope today you will endorse the rail project and help us fulfill our visions.
    • 00:27:03
      Thank you.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:03
      Thank you, Ms. Nicholson.
    • 00:27:08
      Next is Mr. Tom Hurst of the Rapid Transit Action Committee.
    • SPEAKER_03
    • 00:27:18
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary and members of the board.
    • 00:27:22
      Pleasure to be here.
    • 00:27:23
      Thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak.
    • 00:27:26
      Before I start my remarks, first my name is Tom Hurst and I represent the Rapid Transit Action Committee.
    • 00:27:33
      We're a research-oriented group that was formed to promote rapid transit in the Bellas Corridor and elsewhere and to do it now.
    • 00:27:43
      with systems that are available and at a cost we can afford a system we can get in service as soon as possible.
    • 00:27:50
      We have urgent problems when it comes to rapid transit.
    • 00:27:54
      We are confronted with an air quality problem that will result in federal funding ceasing to be available if we don't take immediate steps to correct it.
    • 00:28:05
      One of the problems we have with the rail proposal is there's no way in the world that the rail can get online and providing service
    • 00:28:11
      In time to meet the kind of deadlines that the federal government has mandated and whereas with the BRT system which we support you could have significant improvements within two to three years in the air quality situation as well as in terms of congestion relief.
    • 00:28:32
      Let me take just a couple of minutes to comment on some of the things my friend Patty Nickerson said.
    • 00:28:38
      First, regarding the capacity of BRT during rush hour.
    • 00:28:43
      There are many systems in this country and around the world where they are routinely carrying 27,000 or more passengers per hour on BRT type vehicles.
    • 00:28:55
      per lane during rush hour.
    • 00:28:58
      That's just plain fact, and I can support that if you want detail on that.
    • 00:29:04
      Second, yes it's true, a lot of groups came out in favor of rail, but at the time they came out and said they'd support rail, they did not know what the FTA was going to say.
    • 00:29:14
      They did not know that the director of the Federal Transit Administration was basically going to say, this dog don't hunt.
    • 00:29:22
      And the reason it don't hunt is that it costs 10 times more to do the rail system than the BRT.
    • 00:29:28
      And yes, you get more riders, according to the DEIS, but not nearly enough to make that work from a cost-effective standpoint, which is one of their most important criteria.
    • 00:29:40
      By the way, those of us who received the DEIS did not have in that package of material the list of criteria which the FTA grades projects on.
    • 00:29:51
      I suggest that if those criteria had been included in the package, a lot of the people who commented would have looked at those criteria and said, wait a minute, this doesn't quite work.
    • 00:30:03
      In my day job,
    • 00:30:04
      I own and operate the Masonhurst Company.
    • 00:30:07
      We own and operate commercial office buildings in the Dulles Corridor.
    • 00:30:11
      And you should know that right now in the Dulles Corridor there is 13 million square feet of vacant space.
    • 00:30:17
      Vacant.
    • 00:30:18
      That's like 100 six-story office buildings and the distance between Tysons Corner and Dulles Airport.
    • 00:30:25
      Now, when you come forward with that special tax district, you've been told that's going to pass.
    • 00:30:30
      I can promise you that those of us who own and operate properties in the corridor are going to strenuously resist the special tax district.
    • 00:30:39
      And let's face it, it's an election year.
    • 00:30:42
      I don't think that thing is going to pass.
    • 00:30:45
      You should be aware of that as another source of funding.
    • 00:30:48
      It's not as sure as you might think.
    • 00:30:51
      Furthermore, the notion of raising the polls in the corridor at this time I think also is going to be a political non-starter, particularly in this election year.
    • 00:31:01
      I wouldn't be surprised to see a bill introduced in the legislature to prohibit that happening.
    • 00:31:06
      So, what you have here is a proposal to go forward and spend a lot of money, what is it, 40 million dollars or so, on preliminary engineering on a rail project for which the funding sources clearly have not been identified, clearly are not there.
    • 00:31:24
      You do this against the backdrop of a brilliant, excellent public policy statement by our governor on December 6th in which he announced budgetary and transportation reforms that said any project over $100 million shall not go forward unless the funding sources are clearly identified.
    • 00:31:44
      This project does not meet that basic requirement and so those of us in the business community who have been worried about transportation projects getting out of control have been greatly heartened by the governor's comments.
    • 00:32:00
      We strongly support the direction that he has suggested.
    • 00:32:03
      And we see this three or four billion dollar project as the first case study and whether that policy is going to be applied.
    • 00:32:12
      And today is the time when I guess we're going to find out.
    • 00:32:14
      So I ask you, when you cast your vote, when you have your discussion, please keep these considerations in mind.
    • 00:32:22
      Rail may be wonderful in some situations, but in this case, we can't afford it, it's going to take too long, the funding isn't there, and I ask you not to spend another 30, 40, 50 million dollars on studies when time is precious and money is scarce.
    • 00:32:44
      Thank you very much.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:32:46
      Thank you, Mr. Harris.
    • 00:32:49
      Next, Ho Chang, Fairfax County.
    • 00:32:52
      Mr. Chang.
    • SPEAKER_21
    • 00:32:58
      Good morning, Mr. Secretary and members of the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:33:02
      My name is Young Ho Chang.
    • 00:33:04
      I'm the director of Fairfax County Department of Transportation.
    • 00:33:08
      I'm here to share with you Fairfax County's position on the Dulles Rail project.
    • 00:33:13
      The Fairfax County Board endorsed the Metrorail Build Alternative at its October 28th meeting and forwarded its endorsement to the Secretary Clement on October 29th.
    • 00:33:26
      In its endorsement, the Board stated its support for the Commonwealth's effort to gain final approval and funding for this important project.
    • 00:33:36
      The Fairfax County Board held its own public hearing in addition to the three public hearings held as part of the EIS process, primarily to allow additional opportunity for its citizens to voice any concerns or any comments on the project before the entire Board of Supervisors.
    • 00:33:57
      Fairfax County and the Commonwealth, as some of you already know, have implemented the Dulles Express Bus Service since 1999.
    • 00:34:04
      That service has more than doubled its ridership since 1999 to over 13,000 trips a day.
    • 00:34:11
      We think that serves as a solid foundation for the rail and the corridor of the future.
    • 00:34:19
      The Board of Supervisors endorsed the Metro Rail Build Alternative for the following reasons.
    • 00:34:27
      Oney Metrorail provides the necessary capacity to serve the growth of Tysons Corner and Dulles Corridor.
    • 00:34:34
      Many of you know Tysons Corner has more office space than San Francisco or Miami.
    • 00:34:41
      By year 2020,
    • 00:34:43
      The Dallas Corridor and Tysons Corner will have more employment base, will have the second highest employment base in the entire Washington metropolitan region.
    • 00:34:56
      And as you know, Washington DC has the highest and that is currently served by rail.
    • 00:35:03
      Metrorail serves Tysons Corner and BRT does not.
    • 00:35:08
      Metrorail provides a seamless connection to the region's core and the rest of the Metrorail system.
    • 00:35:15
      Metrorail provides the best opportunity for transit-oriented development.
    • 00:35:21
      The adopted county comprehensive plan sets out a vision for Tysons Corner and the Dulles Corridor.
    • 00:35:28
      concentrating growth of mix of office, retail, and residential uses within walking distance to future rail stations.
    • 00:35:40
      Metrorail improves region's air quality.
    • 00:35:43
      The Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, encouraged the development of the full Metrorail project in their August 20, 2002 letter to the project team due to its greatest impact on reducing congestion and air pollution and gave its highest rating.
    • 00:36:02
      Metrorail reduces harmful emissions, whereas the BRT option actually has a net increase in emissions.
    • 00:36:10
      And finally, based on public comments identifying a preferred alternative, Metrorail is a preferred alternative by a wide margin.
    • 00:36:20
      78% of the people spoke on the alternative support the Metrorail option.
    • 00:36:26
      Thank you for the opportunity to share with you the Fairfax County's position on this project.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:30
      By the way, congratulations on achieving the one million dollar mark, or one million people mark in Fairfax recently.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:42
      Alright, now congratulations.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:45
      Thank you, Mr. Chang.
    • 00:36:46
      Next, Judy, Judy S. Bennett, Hunter Mill Defense League.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:37:00
      Good morning.
    • 00:37:01
      My name is Jody Bennett and I represent the Hunter Mill Defense League.
    • 00:37:07
      The Hunter Mill Defense League is a civic organization and has been in existence for about 15 years and we have been instrumental in looking at land use and transportation issues that affect the Hunter Mill corridor.
    • 00:37:20
      To locate the Hunter Mill Road corridor, it is
    • 00:37:24
      includes Hunter Mill Road, which is a minor arterial road that intersects the Dulles corridor.
    • 00:37:31
      And it is that reason that I come before you today.
    • 00:37:35
      Members of the Board, my testimony will shift away from the important funding issues, the overestimation of ridership, and the underestimation of cost.
    • 00:37:44
      My statement will focus on the impacts on the community.
    • 00:37:49
      This statement is a follow-up on our August 28th letter to Mr. Corey Hill.
    • 00:37:55
      We asked several questions that related to the evaluation of the impacts on the community.
    • 00:38:03
      Despite spending over 20 million dollars, it is our position that the DEIS propose for the dollars graphic transit project did not comprehensively address the effects on the human environment and this is required by the National Environmental Protection Act of NEPA.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:26
      We attended the hearings, we submitted comments, and we reviewed the responses to these comments in the public record.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:38:35
      Again, we feel that the total evaluation of the impact on the community has not been satisfactorily done.
    • 00:38:49
      We believe that a project of this magnitude will have major residential impacts
    • 00:38:57
      We are concerned that the DEIS did not recognize Hunter Mill Road corridor, which crosses the Dulles Toll Road, that it has been declared eligible for listing in the historic district and state and national historic registries in 2002.
    • 00:39:14
      We also were concerned that the DEIS did not recognize Hunter Mill Road via Natives of Virginia Byway.
    • 00:39:20
      We feel very strongly that the DEIS needed to assess the impact that the proposal would have on Ponder Mill Road corridor as a historic corridor.
    • 00:39:33
      We asked how will the intense commercial and residential development in Dresden, precipitated by just the rail funding agreement.
    • 00:39:41
      We asked what effect will that have on volume, traffic volumes, and safety on our minor arterial roads.
    • 00:39:49
      We have some very small roads called Sunset Hills, Hunter Mill, Crowell, Browns Mill, and Eula Roads.
    • 00:39:55
      We also asked if this intense development would generate traffic.
    • 00:39:59
      You heard Patty refer to the intense development.
    • 00:40:03
      We are concerned about that.
    • 00:40:05
      We find VDOT's own statement that the increased density will overwhelm the increased transit capacity.
    • 00:40:14
      Supports our concerns about the community impact.
    • 00:40:18
      We believe that the traffic analysis was too limited.
    • 00:40:22
      If you have read the study like we have read the study, all the volumes, studies,
    • 00:40:28
      Many, many books report over, you recall that they limit the analysis to just one half mile.
    • 00:40:37
      We feel that for those of us who live on a small, rural, winding road, the impact, it was not accurately assessed.
    • 00:40:47
      And this will, because the DEIS talks about mitigation factors or mitigation measures, when you look at who is going to be financially responsible for these mitigation measures, the burden can come back to the state.
    • 00:41:03
      And we know what the funding situation is for this.
    • 00:41:07
      We ask many questions, and we have failed to receive the answers.
    • 00:41:12
      And I think one of the important things that comes to my mind
    • 00:41:16
      In the past few weeks, we have heard our governor talk about trust.
    • 00:41:23
      We have heard our governor talk about financial responsibility.
    • 00:41:27
      We have heard our governor talk about the importance of making good financial decisions.
    • 00:41:34
      You have before you today a very important decision to make.
    • 00:41:41
      The decision that you make can impact the rural community, the communities that we live on, and can impact the mitigation measures that have to be forthcoming.
    • 00:41:55
      It won't be there.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:56
      So we ask you to be very careful in the decision that you make, because your decision reaches down to us.
    • SPEAKER_23
    • 00:42:07
      in Northern Virginia, who lived on these small community roads.
    • SPEAKER_12
    • 00:42:15
      Thank you.
    • 00:42:16
      Thank you, Ms. Pitt.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:18
      Next, Bob Chase, Royal Virginia Transportation Alliance.
    • SPEAKER_22
    • 00:42:29
      Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, members of the board, the Northern Virginia Transportation Alliance is a long-time supporter of mass transit in Northern Virginia and the metropolitan Washington area.
    • 00:42:40
      Improved Dulles corridor mass transit is a top alliance priority.
    • 00:42:45
      Heavy rail works best in dense urban downtown areas such as Washington, D.C., Manhattan, Boston, and Chicago.
    • 00:42:52
      No such intense transit-oriented densities exist in the Dallas corridor today and perhaps never will.
    • 00:43:01
      The CTB may endorse heavy rail as the locally preferred alternative today.
    • 00:43:05
      However, because there is little likelihood that funds exist to build this option anytime soon, what you select as the ultimately desired local option today is not nearly as important as what you and we in Northern Virginia do
    • 00:43:21
      to advance more flexible solutions in the months and years ahead.
    • 00:43:26
      Cost is an issue.
    • 00:43:28
      Northern Virginia could meet most of its unbuilt road and bridge needs for the future for the same cost as rail to Dulles alone.
    • 00:43:38
      That doesn't mean that Dulles Rail may not be worth the investment at some point.
    • 00:43:44
      It does mean that we first need to look at the project
    • 00:43:48
      in conjunction with others and determine where and when it fits into the overall mix.
    • 00:43:54
      This is a question that has never been addressed.
    • 00:43:58
      The Dulles corridor needs improved mass transit service now.
    • 00:44:03
      It may need rail in 15, 20, or 25 years from now, but it most definitely needs improved bus rapid transit wheeled transit now.
    • 00:44:14
      Building rail in two phases, first to Tysons and then ultimately to Dulles and Eastern Loudoun has been suggested.
    • 00:44:21
      The difficulty is that most potential riders live west of Tysons Corner.
    • 00:44:27
      Rail just to Tysons serves relatively few new riders.
    • 00:44:32
      Express bus service followed by rail totally within the Dallas Access Corridor, supplemented by a Tysons Corner mainline feeder service, may be a more practical, affordable alternative.
    • 00:44:47
      Staying within the Access Corridor is significantly cheaper and links more activity centers to the West that have better opportunities to achieve superior transit-oriented land use patterns than points within Tysons.
    • 00:45:01
      Delos Transit has been studied for years.
    • 00:45:05
      Arguably, the best long-term solution still has not been identified, perhaps because the right technology doesn't exist, perhaps because our thinking has not been expansive enough.
    • 00:45:19
      There is still time.
    • 00:45:21
      Travel demand for heavy rail service does not exist today and won't for a number of years.
    • 00:45:27
      The lack of funds may be a blessing, enabling us to continue to search for a more cost-effective, flexible, and technologically advanced transit solution for this key segment of the Commonwealth.
    • 00:45:41
      The CTB's continued involvement in and attention to this subject and in being a strong proponent of a performance-based Northern Virginia regional transportation network is more important than ever.
    • 00:45:58
      The Transportation Alliance applauds what, Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, and members of the board, the Transportation Alliance applauds what you have been doing in recent months over the past year to get transportation in the Commonwealth back on the right track.
    • 00:46:15
      And we wish you a happy holiday, a good new year, and let's hope that a year from now we have a lot better news to talk about, and I believe if you continue in the direction that you are, that we certainly will.
    • 00:46:26
      So thank you very much.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:29
      Thank you, Mr. Chase.
    • 00:46:31
      Anyone else wishing to speak in this public comment period?
    • 00:46:39
      Yes.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:46:51
      Hello, my name is Mike Tobias.
    • 00:46:53
      I'm a resident of Fairfax County.
    • 00:46:56
      I'm asking for your support of the bus rapid transit.
    • 00:47:02
      After going through a lot of meetings and listening to everyone, it seems like one we can't afford a rail at this time.
    • 00:47:10
      And the BRT is affordable, as well as practical, effective, and flexible.
    • 00:47:17
      It can change with our needs.
    • 00:47:19
      It seems fairly simple to me that in order to have mass transit we need to start somewhere and the BRT looks like the best choice at $429 million.
    • 00:47:32
      It's not going to break the bank and unfortunately at 3.3 billion for the rail plus about 700 million for financing of the rail.
    • 00:47:42
      We just can't afford it.
    • 00:47:45
      We do need a mass transit system in Northern Virginia and this offers some options.
    • 00:47:52
      I mean I realize with the rail
    • 00:47:54
      They can add two more cars to make it eight cars per platform, but unfortunately, that causes a traffic jam in Roslyn, where the tunnel is.
    • 00:48:02
      The tunnel can only accommodate six cars without causing a traffic jam in the back.
    • 00:48:09
      At this point, the BRT can hold twice as many people as the rail.
    • 00:48:15
      I see somebody disagreeing.
    • 00:48:19
      It is a viable option, and it's one that we need to really consider, so I'll just keep it short and sweet.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:27
      Thank you.
    • 00:48:28
      Anyone else?
    • 00:48:31
      Okay, that will close out our public comment period, and next on the agenda is the approval of the November meeting minutes, which have been distributed to you.
    • 00:48:45
      Do I have a motion for the approval of those minutes?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:48
      We'll move.
    • 00:48:50
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:51
      Been moved and seconded.
    • 00:48:52
      Any discussion on the minutes?
    • 00:48:54
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:48:56
      Aye.
    • 00:48:56
      Any opposed?
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:56
      Mr. Chairman, I'm going to abstain because I was at the workshop and not at the back.
    • 00:49:04
      That went quicker too, didn't it?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:06
      Yes, it was a lot quicker.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:07
      That was a quick meeting.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:10
      Next, Jim Gibbons, Local Assistance Division.
    • 00:49:14
      Jim?
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:49:16
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:49:17
      You have before you, for item number four, the report of changes to the secondary system for the month.
    • 00:49:25
      We've added about 12 and a half miles.
    • 00:49:29
      If there are any questions, I'll be glad to try to answer those.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:35
      Move for approval.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:49:37
      No questions?
    • 00:49:37
      Been moved and seconded.
    • 00:49:41
      To approve that item, all in favor please say aye.
    • 00:49:45
      Aye.
    • 00:49:45
      Any opposed?
    • 00:49:46
      Okay, Jim.
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:49:49
      Mr. Chairman, the next item are the recreational access projects that have been requested.
    • 00:49:56
      You're being handed, as I talk about the Warren County project, you're being handed a corrected sketch
    • 00:50:04
      The original sketch had an incorrect amount of money shown on it, and that corrected sketch shows that the proposed allocation is $100,000 for the Northern Virginia 4-H Educational Conference Center access road.
    • 00:50:25
      You're also being asked to consider an allocation of $320,000
    • 00:50:31
      for the Stratton Woods Park in Fairfax County and an allocation of $112,000 for an access road for Hossler Creek Wildlife Reserve in the City of Portsmouth.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:51
      Okay, we'll take these up in a block.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:54
      Phil?
    • 00:50:55
      I have a question about the one in Warren County.
    • 00:50:57
      Is there a certainty that the funds will be available to complete the project from the other sources?
    • 00:51:03
      Yes, sir.
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:51:03
      Are they committed funds?
    • 00:51:04
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:51:08
      The road is actually in place for the most part, and it's pretty much to our standards.
    • 00:51:15
      They've asked us to take that into the secondary system, and it does serve a public recreation need.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:24
      OK. Do we have a motion on these three proposed resolutions?
    • 00:51:33
      It's been moved to have a second.
    • 00:51:34
      It's been moved and seconded.
    • 00:51:38
      Motion been duly properly made to adopt the three proposed resolutions on these recreational access programs.
    • 00:51:46
      If there's no discussion, all in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:51:49
      Aye.
    • 00:51:49
      Any opposed?
    • 00:51:51
      Thank you, Jim.
    • 00:51:52
      Next, Mobility Management Division to VDOT, Mr. J.R. Robinson.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:51:57
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, thank you.
    • 00:52:00
      There's a, to item 6A is asking for your approval of a resolution to approve an agreement with Federal Highway Administration.
    • 00:52:10
      for federal ITS funds for the City of Alexandria.
    • 00:52:16
      Alexandria plans to use the funds to provide a fiber optic link and other connections between the City's Traffic Management Center and VDOT's Traffic Management Center.
    • 00:52:31
      Alexandria will provide the match for these funds, and we recommend your approval.
    • 00:52:39
      So moved.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:52:40
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:52:41
      Then moved and seconded.
    • 00:52:42
      Any discussion?
    • 00:52:45
      All in favor of the proposed resolution to enter that cooperative agreement, please say aye.
    • 00:52:51
      Aye.
    • 00:52:51
      Any opposed?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:52:53
      The second agreement is again with Federal Highway for federal ITS funds.
    • 00:52:59
      In both cases, these are funds that were congressionally delegated, designated in the Federal Fiscal Year 2002 Transportation Appropriations Bill.
    • 00:53:12
      This is research that will be done by James Madison University that focuses on
    • 00:53:22
      primarily on two aspects, crash notification systems using wireless telephones for portable devices for automatic crash notification and mobile commerce and information systems.
    • 00:53:39
      Again, in this case, James Madison will provide the match to the federal funds as required and we recommend your approval.
    • 00:53:50
      Helen?
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:53:51
      Does this mean that the state is not expending any money, you're just looking for an agreement, for authorization to execute an agreement, or is there a cost to the state?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:54:01
      VDOT will, there won't be any VDOT money going into these projects.
    • 00:54:07
      Thank you.
    • 00:54:08
      The money will go through VDOT to James Madison.
    • 00:54:11
      James Madison provides a match to meet the federal requirements.
    • 00:54:15
      Thank you.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:18
      Been moved to adopt the resolution.
    • 00:54:22
      Move to second any further discussion.
    • 00:54:25
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:54:27
      Aye.
    • 00:54:27
      Any opposed?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:54:28
      Item 7 is my great pleasure to inform you.
    • 00:54:32
      In September you approved a resolution for a tentative agreement with Federal Highway Administration for a project that VDOT was competing for.
    • 00:54:44
      At the time,
    • 00:54:46
      Well, the short story is VDOT was selected.
    • 00:54:50
      This is a national competition among all the states.
    • 00:54:54
      They tell us it was extremely, there was excellent proposals.
    • 00:55:01
      We were selected by Federal Highway Administration.
    • 00:55:04
      The project started on Monday officially.
    • 00:55:06
      We had the kickoff meeting on Tuesday, and we're really looking forward to this.
    • 00:55:11
      There's a press release in your
    • 00:55:15
      That's just an information item.
    • 00:55:23
      This is a million dollar grant from the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 00:55:30
      Thank you.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:33
      Thank you for that update.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:35
      Mr. Secretary, if I may take just a moment, JR and the entire group in the Mobility Management Division,
    • 00:55:42
      has every right to be very proud of this million-dollar grant.
    • 00:55:46
      They worked hard for it.
    • 00:55:48
      They competed on what was a very competitive basis, and we all bit our fingernails for a few months waiting to find out whether or not we had been selected.
    • 00:55:59
      And I would just like to take the opportunity to thank JR and all the people that worked on his team to make this happen.
    • 00:56:07
      This is a million dollars we didn't have to get, so it's a good story.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:13
      Those of us who are interested in long-range planning, will this data be available relatively soon?
    • 00:56:21
      I mean, this is making data they already have available and in a usable form?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:56:26
      The project is scheduled for 18 months.
    • 00:56:30
      We're going to do what's called three builds, so there will actually be data available.
    • 00:56:35
      This will be on access through a web browser, so it doesn't take any special software.
    • 00:56:42
      First build is six months.
    • 00:56:43
      That will be pretty crude, but after a year, so a year from now,
    • 00:56:50
      That data will be, the data will be available, and we're gonna, there's three bills that go out six months, so after a year, and then after the 18 months, there'll be even more available, and that'll be available to anybody.
    • 00:57:07
      We're talking now probably password protected, so, but that could change if we find that other people have a use for it.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:18
      Great, thank you, Gerald.
    • 00:57:19
      Next, Mr. Taylor, Arthur Taylor, Right-of-Way Utilities Division.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:57:24
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, good morning.
    • 00:57:27
      Item 8 has two conveyances before you for approval this morning.
    • 00:57:32
      There are two adjacent landowners requested by them, and we recommend your approval.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:38
      All right, that's, yes, Jerry.
    • 00:57:40
      It's been moved.
    • 00:57:42
      I have a second on it.
    • 00:57:44
      Second.
    • 00:57:44
      It's been moved and seconded that we adopt the
    • 00:57:47
      proposed resolution on the action on the surplus property.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:57:51
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:57:52
      Aye.
    • 00:57:53
      And you pose.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:57:54
      Thank you.
    • 00:57:58
      Frank G. Limited Access, Frank.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:58:03
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, commissioners, members of the board.
    • 00:58:05
      You have before you, you just passed two conveyances, so this resolution not only does a conveyance, but also a change in limited access that is necessary as a result of the conveyance.
    • 00:58:17
      If you refer to your package in the sketch,
    • 00:58:20
      We had acquired certain properties for our Route 58 project and our Route 777 project, and the adjacent property owner had approached us to buy the property that may not be necessary for future use.
    • 00:58:35
      We determined indeed we could transfer that property but in doing so we had to change the limited access line that was previously established on the 58 project.
    • 00:58:43
      So what you have before you is a resolution to move the limited access line in that is parallel to the center line of the ramp and convey the additional property that would not be needed
    • 00:58:55
      to the adjacent property owner who is Mr. R. T. Arnold.
    • 00:59:02
      In no way is this a break in limited access.
    • 00:59:04
      I would not recommend a break in limited access at this point because we were not allowed because of safety reasons and capacity reasons.
    • 00:59:13
      This is strictly moving the line in so that we can convey the adjacent property that would no longer be needed for highway purposes to the property owner.
    • 00:59:22
      And the resolution before you does that.
    • 00:59:25
      moves the limited access line in and conveys the property to the adjacent owner.
    • 00:59:30
      For what would be the appraised value and the cost of moving the fence and everything, the property owner will bear all the expenses.
    • 00:59:36
      There will be no cost to VDOT for this transaction.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:39
      Okay, move.
    • 00:59:42
      Mr. Paul, do you have a second?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 00:59:44
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:45
      Any discussion?
    • 00:59:48
      All in favor of the proposed resolution, item 9.
    • 00:59:53
      All in favor please say aye.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:59:55
      Aye.
    • 00:59:55
      Any opposed?
    • 00:59:56
      Thank you.
    • 00:59:57
      Thank you Frank.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:59:58
      Next, Ken Lance, Transportation Mobility Planning.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:00:06
      Mr. Chairman and members of the board, we have before you this morning a proposed amendment to our VDOT policy relative to bicycle facilities.
    • 01:00:15
      VDOT's current policy on the department's participation in the development of bicycle facilities was adopted by this board in 1990, about ten years ago, over ten years ago.
    • 01:00:25
      This policy limits the use of highway construction funds to providing bicycle accommodations that can be built as part of a highway project.
    • 01:00:34
      This limitation, however, is not consistent with the change that was made in the Code of Virginia that became effective July 1, 2002.
    • 01:00:41
      Section 331.223.26 now states that our policies should not prohibit or limit us from funding or building bicycle or pedestrian facilities that are not part of highway construction projects.
    • 01:01:00
      Therefore, we are requesting that you adopt the proposed changes to VDOT's policy to align it with the Virginia Code.
    • 01:01:08
      I'd also like to point out that as the state bicycle and pedestrian coordinator, I recognize that there are probably many other changes that we need to consider within our policy, and the overall policy does need to probably be revised.
    • 01:01:24
      The Transportation and Mobility Planning Division has prepared a scope of work for a comprehensive review of VDOT's role in providing pedestrian and bicycle accommodations seeking to balance the needs and constraints faced by users, localities, and VDOT.
    • 01:01:41
      And we expect to undertake this review sometime early next year.
    • 01:01:46
      Susan Simmers of my staff is here today to help answer any questions you may have concerning today's proposed policy amendments.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:01:54
      One of my questions is, I know we're looking at the, there's some planning involved with this, there's obviously construction costs involved, but we're also evaluating the right-of-way acquisitions involved with this because this is going to be independent of highway construction, or in some cases may overlap some of that.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 01:02:13
      This proposed change does not affect the funding participation at this point.
    • 01:02:20
      Yes, sir.
    • 01:02:21
      Okay.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:23
      Okay.
    • 01:02:25
      Move adoption of resolution.
    • 01:02:27
      And move to second it.
    • 01:02:29
      Any
    • 01:02:30
      Further discussion or questions?
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:34
      Couldn't we just authorize the secretary to go ahead and make the adjustments necessary to comply with the statute as they do the review?
    • 01:02:42
      Do we need to have this back again?
    • 01:02:43
      We've got to make them.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:02:44
      Well, I think what Kim was saying, this will get us in line with the statute, but that you're undertaking a general review of the bicycle policy, of the bicycle facility policy.
    • 01:02:58
      Any other questions?
    • 01:03:00
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:03:02
      Aye.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:03:02
      Any opposed?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:07
      Thank you.
    • 01:03:07
      Next, from the Construction Division, Mal Kerley.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:03:14
      Good morning.
    • 01:03:14
      I've got several sheets in here I'll try to go through rather rapidly.
    • 01:03:18
      I did want to point out
    • 01:03:20
      That we average a little bit more than on most of the projects except for the surface treatment ones, a little bit more than nine bids for each of our projects this month, so it's been very competitive.
    • 01:03:32
      We had 56 projects that were below the engineer's estimate, three projects that were within the 7% of the engineer's estimate that we recommend that you award, one above the 7% estimate that we're recommending to reward,
    • 01:03:48
      4 that we're going to recommend that you reject because they're above the 7%, and 3 we deferred until January.
    • 01:03:56
      Going through the sheets, I'd like to point out several things.
    • 01:04:00
      On page number 1 and the first item on page number 2, which talks about the refurbishment of the East River Mountain Tunnel and also the Big Walker Mountain Tunnel,
    • 01:04:13
      This was a project that we re-advertised twice.
    • 01:04:18
      We saved from the original low bid $1.7 million, and I would like to point out as we re-advertise these, we work with the industry
    • 01:04:29
      calling the contractors that bid on those particular projects that were above our estimate to work with them to find out what was wrong with the estimate and it's a matter of the risk factor associated with we were able to redefine what we wanted a little bit better and actually
    • 01:04:47
      We get much better bids than what we would have had originally.
    • 01:04:51
      But we do, in instances where we're above the estimate, we do work with the contract industry, and they are very good working with us to really define what we need.
    • 01:05:02
      And in this particular instance, on these two projects, if I re-advertise them twice, there is an expense for us to do that, but it was a great savings on that, and I wanted to point that out to the board.
    • 01:05:12
      On page two, the second item, that was also one that we re-advertised and the difference now is a delta of about 21,000 by re-advertising that particular one.
    • 01:05:25
      Number six on page two, that was one of the ones that I recommend you reject.
    • 01:05:30
      That's a small one-panel sound wall repair that we feel that we need to re-advertise that.
    • 01:05:38
      On page number three, I point out there's two bridge projects based on our discussions last month.
    • 01:05:48
      Those sufficiency ratings were below 50.
    • 01:05:52
      The third one is 49.2 and the fourth one is 46.2.
    • 01:06:00
      On page four, the top one on page four, I recommend that you reject that.
    • 01:06:07
      We did get six bids on that particular one.
    • 01:06:11
      It was pretty much over, a pretty good amount over our estimate.
    • 01:06:15
      We have talked with the contractors on that.
    • 01:06:20
      Hopefully, talking to them, many of them didn't get an opportunity to get out and visit the site exactly, see what it was, so they'll have an opportunity by rebidding it to actually look at that, and we feel we'll get a better bid on that.
    • 01:06:35
      We are rejecting number six here.
    • 01:06:37
      The second on page four, we made a mistake on that particular one and switched to type of grasses, and I'm not a grass expert, but the more expensive one, we got our numbers backwards on that, so we felt that we'd need to re-advertise that particular one.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:57
      Now, how many acres of wetland mitigation is involved in that particular project?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:07:03
      Let me see if it's in here.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:06
      I'm trying to get a general trend about where our cost per acre wetland mitigation's run is.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:07:11
      Let me see if it's in the right one, sir.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:14
      But you can get it to me later, it's fine.
    • 01:07:16
      I'll project it anyway.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:07:20
      This is off of recollection, but it seems to me it was an 8-acre site.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:07:25
      So it's about 100 grand an acre, a little less than 100 grand an acre.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:07:28
      I just used that on sideways to do a contract in there.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:07:35
      Okay, I'm going page five down.
    • 01:07:42
      Nothing special on there.
    • 01:07:46
      Six, I noticed that we're replacing a bridge, number two on there, the sufficiency rating on there is above 50.
    • 01:07:53
      It's 64.2, where I would imagine that has to do with economic development or capacity concerns on that particular bridge.
    • 01:08:04
      Page 7, nothing special there.
    • 01:08:09
      Page 8, 9, 10.
    • 01:08:17
      On page 11 is another drainage structure there that has an efficiency rating of 39.
    • 01:08:27
      Page 12, nothing there.
    • 01:08:32
      We get into
    • 01:08:35
      Page 13 starts our surface treatments.
    • 01:08:39
      You will notice as we go through these that there are only one or two or three bidders on these projects.
    • 01:08:48
      There's not very many people in the business in this.
    • 01:08:52
      We got as many bids as we normally get for this type of work.
    • 01:08:57
      These were pretty much, all these were under our estimates, and there was one in here I believe we didn't award in that, but we felt the bids were appropriate and that we should award these.
    • 01:09:10
      On page 13, 14, 15,
    • 01:09:16
      16, 17, 18, on the page 19 is one that we recommend that you reject.
    • 01:09:29
      This is a new process that we're trying here, macro surfacing.
    • 01:09:33
      and that we felt that we needed to go, it was above our estimate, we needed to go back out on that.
    • 01:09:40
      This may be a good bid here, of course it's a new process, but we wanted to see if we could get another bidder on this particular work.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:09:49
      Now, that type of substance, have you had much success or you haven't had enough?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:09:55
      No, this is the first project in my understanding.
    • 01:09:58
      Is that right, Don?
    • 01:09:59
      That's the first time.
    • 01:10:00
      Anytime you go out the first time, the bids are a little bit higher.
    • 01:10:04
      I wanted to point out on page 20, when I was going over Don this, hopefully we, if you see what we're going to purchase there, as a part of this enhancement project, that all the toilets that we purchase are sweet smelling.
    • 01:10:20
      I don't know if that's a trade name or not, but if it is, it probably gets people's attention.
    • 01:10:29
      Page 21.
    • 01:10:30
      On page 23, I wanted to point out, you'll notice that was bid by North Carolina.
    • 01:10:37
      That's a rest area that's in Virginia.
    • 01:10:39
      North Carolina maintains it and they're bringing a water line, sewer line into that particular rest area.
    • 01:10:49
      23, 24, 25, 26, 27, and 28.
    • 01:10:54
      I don't have any comments unless somebody from the board does.
    • 01:11:08
      The other thing, our bids this month were in the neighborhood of a little bit over six million dollars below the engineer estimate, if you just add everything up of what we were awarded.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:11:23
      Coming in under the engineer's estimate, does that mean that it's the engineer in the construction district that has evaluated this estimate?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:11:32
      No, what that means is, and we talked about estimates yesterday, I think the commissioner mentioned the last estimate.
    • 01:11:41
      All the documents come into our construction division here in the central office.
    • 01:11:46
      Don Silies Group works on there and we come up with an estimate based on market there that quite frankly nobody but I guess myself, Don Silies, and his people see.
    • 01:11:58
      Not even the Commissioner sees that particular estimate.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:01
      A new model is being utilized in the analysis here.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:12:06
      It's the information that they record from the final estimates and market conditions.
    • 01:12:13
      They will talk to various suppliers that's putting this up.
    • 01:12:17
      We have a team of people who just do that all the time.
    • 01:12:21
      But obviously they would take input from the district offices if need be.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:25
      As a follow-up question to that, the engineer's estimate, is that based upon the criteria change that was made some time ago where we looked at the market, I think it was probably about nine, ten months ago, we bumped up engineer estimates to conform with market conditions?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:12:47
      It's my understanding we're looking at market right now.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:12:51
      Is it conforming to that new condition or to the existing prior to that?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:12:55
      In my mind, it confirms the condition that we have right now, what the market has right now, Frank.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:02
      Well, you remember there's about 187 percent increase in different costs.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:13:07
      Mr. Mitchell, I'm going to carry you back in time.
    • 01:13:09
      In 1980, when we threw a bid-rigging process in Virginia where we had various contractors that was convicted of improprieties.
    • 01:13:20
      At that time, it was determined the department needed to revise its basis of estimating and determining when to award a contract and not to award a contract.
    • 01:13:29
      At that time, we established what is known as a cost-based estimating system.
    • 01:13:34
      The cost-based estimating system is when we have estimators that go out and look at the market estimates.
    • 01:13:38
      As far as materials, labor, equipment, and everything, you come up with what we feel like is a fair value for that work to be done.
    • 01:13:47
      It has nothing to do with the estimating that's going to be going on prior and everything.
    • 01:13:51
      That's basically a statistical type of the estimating system.
    • 01:13:55
      This is a similar process that a contractor would use when he's putting his bid together.
    • 01:13:59
      We use that to determine our estimate for award or rejection of bids.
    • 01:14:05
      No one other than Mr. Kerley, Mr. Sallies, and the estimator ever know that estimate.
    • 01:14:12
      We do not disclose that at all.
    • 01:14:14
      It's protected under Freedom of Information Act.
    • 01:14:17
      So it's a totally different type of estimating process that you discussed yesterday and previously that's done that is basically similar to what a contract would do developed here so we can determine whether or not indeed
    • 01:14:28
      We are getting fair value.
    • 01:14:30
      This was done because anybody has access to the statistical data, because that's public information, and you can put that in your computer and come up with the statistical value of it, but that does not necessarily reflect what the current market conditions are for water rejection with contract.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:14:48
      I'm just trying to see how that ties into the six-year program and the budgeting.
    • 01:14:52
      I understand its proprietary nature.
    • 01:14:55
      I'm just trying to...
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:14:56
      You know, when we go through future estimating cycles under the new program, how this is... We will be using, as Dr. Allen mentioned yesterday, and he mentioned a time period, I think 96 or five years we're doing it.
    • 01:15:09
      What we'll be doing as we update that is dropping off a year and adding the actual cost of projects that we have in there.
    • 01:15:17
      So it will impact that in the long run.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:20
      Mr. Secretary,
    • 01:15:24
      I wish I had a way I could think of to make this an easy illustration.
    • 01:15:32
      The cost estimating system that we discussed yesterday, which we will use at those important milestones along the way, will play a key role in determining the estimated value of projects that go into the Six-Year Program.
    • 01:15:55
      The engineer's estimate that we are talking about is a different process.
    • 01:16:02
      For those of you that are in contracting, we're doing the same things that you would do when we prepare the engineer's estimate.
    • 01:16:13
      We have a complete set of bid documents and you're rolling up your sleeve with the same little green shade on, developing a
    • 01:16:24
      A very near-term final estimate for the execution of that work.
    • 01:16:31
      So it's building, it's based on what's going on in the marketplace right then.
    • 01:16:39
      That is the, when he says the engineer's estimate, that's what we're talking about.
    • 01:16:46
      The cost estimating system is the process that we will use throughout the
    • 01:16:54
      Earlier life of the project up to that final moment of a final estimate.
    • 01:17:01
      It would be impossible to apply that final engineer's estimate to the six-year program because we don't have, obviously, we don't have bid documents ready, so it's
    • 01:17:16
      Maybe we need to think about the names or something.
    • 01:17:20
      I realize it is confusing, but they are two different processes.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:17:27
      That's correct.
    • 01:17:29
      Second, I recommend you approve the recommendations I've made.
    • 01:17:33
      So moved.
    • 01:17:33
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:35
      We moved and seconded that we approve the recommendations.
    • 01:17:40
      Any further discussion?
    • 01:17:46
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 01:17:48
      Aye.
    • 01:17:49
      Thank you, Mel.
    • 01:17:51
      I might remind the board members that I think we've discussed this in the past.
    • 01:17:58
      There will be legislation introduced to raise the limits of projects that would come before us to two million dollars.
    • 01:18:08
      You look over this list, there's only going to be one that will come for our approval.
    • 01:18:14
      Philip and I were discussing a few minutes ago about the appropriateness of our adopting a formal policy that would require the Commissioner to, when he makes a quarterly report to us, as you know we're doing that in our agendas on out into
    • 01:18:35
      May or June, July, 2003, the draft of our agenda is to have a quarterly report from the Commission so that would identify trends and other factors that would allow us to keep up with this process in a general way without having to get into the minutia of each and every bid.
    • 01:18:59
      So, Philip is going to
    • 01:19:02
      We'll work on a draft of a policy for our consideration next year, probably whether or not that legislation passes.
    • 01:19:14
      So we'll go ahead and go on record for how we will address this in a more general way.
    • 01:19:25
      Next item on the agenda is action on Delos Rail, and as you know, of course, we had a presentation last month.
    • 01:19:36
      I'm going to ask Karen Rae, the Director of the Department of Rail and Public Transportation, to give us a quick
    • 01:19:44
      Good morning, Chairman and Board Members.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:54
      What you will have in front of you to start today's discussion is, of course, the Board action, and we did attach a copy of last month's presentation.
    • 01:20:02
      I don't intend to go through that again because we spent a lot of time on that, but for your reference,
    • 01:20:07
      Also, as much of this discussion revolves around process, we have a one-page review of the federal process and a note of what this action, how that fits in today.
    • 01:20:17
      Also, as a reminder, the one-pager that we talked about last month, which is the review
    • 01:20:25
      And copies of all the endorsements from the local entities that have been involved in advancing this project and this is the last step that you will be acting with their commitments clearly in front of you on paper.
    • 01:20:42
      I thought it was important first to understand and honor the process and how many people have brought to bear their very important ideas through this process over a number of years.
    • 01:20:53
      Basically, it's been four decades of discussion and planning and concern about this corridor and the future of this corridor.
    • 01:21:03
      The first significant action actually occurred when the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority
    • 01:21:08
      kept the right-of-way in the corridor open for rapid transit as part of its initial plan with the startup of the airport.
    • 01:21:17
      I think it's very important to note that this has been going on for that length of time, although all of us, including me, are just getting up to speed about what has led us to this point in the decision process.
    • 01:21:28
      Recent studies, how do we get to the point where we are today?
    • 01:21:32
      First and foremost, the major investment studies that were carried out from 1994 to 1997.
    • 01:21:39
      And I didn't make you all copies.
    • 01:21:42
      We'd be glad to.
    • 01:21:43
      We basically have on the table the extensive process, feedback, analysis that has gone into all these different studies available over on the side table.
    • 01:21:53
      Then there was a major investment study supplement in 1999 where the Department of Rail and Public Transportation conducted a follow-up on the 1997 major investment study.
    • 01:22:06
      Then the process moved into the draft environmental impact statement area and that's where we've been focused since about 2000 on going through the federal NEPA process
    • 01:22:18
      By the book, and in fact I might know even beyond what's required under the federal guidelines because WMATA has been our partner in this and they have requirements that far exceed those of the federal requirements.
    • 01:22:32
      During the draft environmental impact statement, I think it's important to note the relationship.
    • 01:22:37
      The Department of Rail and Public Transportation is the project sponsor.
    • 01:22:42
      However, WMATA, who has a long history of successful proven track record of moving EIS process to get a record of decision, was our technical arm, and through an inter-local agreement, they did our technical work for us in concert.
    • 01:22:57
      And today, where we are is that draft environmental
    • 01:23:01
      The statement has gone forward.
    • 01:23:03
      We have published the findings.
    • 01:23:05
      We have sought additional responses.
    • 01:23:07
      The decision to advance the outcome of that process to the next level, final environmental study and record is where we are today.
    • 01:23:17
      The draft EIS was completed and signed off by the Federal Transit Administration in June of this year.
    • 01:23:24
      Public hearings were held in July, and those comments were received, were also published in October of this year.
    • 01:23:33
      From July through November, all the local stakeholders stated their positions on the alternatives, and those are the letters that you have in front of you, stating the preference of all of the partners on this project.
    • 01:23:46
      I'd like to take the liberty of quoting from two or three people who couldn't be here today, but asked me if I would please share with you their thoughts.
    • 01:23:58
      The first one is from Kate Hanley, Chairman of the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors, and she wanted to just make sure everybody realized that among the alternatives considered, Metro Rail would provide the highest ridership, the greatest capacity for moving people through the corridor,
    • 01:24:14
      and the greatest impact on reducing congestion and air pollution.
    • 01:24:18
      And she requests your continued support of her position.
    • 01:24:23
      Also we heard from Chairman York in Loudoun County and his comments were that the extension of Metro Rail conforms with regional air quality plans and is supported by more businesses, citizens and community groups than any other alternative.
    • 01:24:38
      The Environmental Protection Agency has also encouraged the development of this alternative.
    • 01:24:43
      That's from Chairman York.
    • 01:24:47
      And another key stakeholder in the process, Mr. James Wilding, President and CEO of the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority, was quoted as, we have a deep and long interest to see that rail, which has been in the plans for 40 years, make a substantial enhancement to transportation in this corridor.
    • 01:25:12
      Rail will greatly improve access to the Dulles International Airport.
    • 01:25:16
      I would like to thank the CTB for keeping the project moving and listening to the stakeholders.
    • 01:25:23
      And I just share those with you at their request.
    • 01:25:28
      I thought I'd just walk through where we are, what we are acting on today, and what we aren't acting on today, because that seems to have been a recurring question about where we are today.
    • 01:25:41
      Where we are today is that the resolution in front of you is to support the extension of the metro rail line passed all the way through the Dulles International Airport and into Loudoun County.
    • 01:26:01
      It would extend from West Falls Church to Route 722 in eastern Loudoun County.
    • 01:26:07
      The resolution also, however, supports the adding of bus rapid transit elements, enhancing the bus service in that corridor during the time over which we are developing the rail solution.
    • 01:26:20
      That's clearly part of the LPA being moved advanced forward.
    • 01:26:24
      The CTB action is based on strong support by Northern Virginia local governments, which has worked extensively over the last decade to select the best transportation option for this heavily traveled corridor.
    • 01:26:37
      Plans call for the rail to include 24 miles and 11 stations and we've gone through the dynamic of what that project would look like.
    • 01:26:47
      Among the alternatives considered, and we went through the pros and cons of all the different alternatives at the last meeting, the reason that all of the entities are advancing the recommendation to move the metro rail extension forward is that it does provide the highest ridership, the greatest capacity for moving people, and the greatest impact on reducing congestion and air pollution.
    • 01:27:09
      I have to note Jeff Southard's observation yesterday about the challenge we have ahead of us in the issue of air quality.
    • 01:27:18
      The in-depth environmental impact statement process that has been underway since spring of 2000 looked at all the impacts and all the different pros and cons in that corridor, including ridership costs, air quality impact on the surrounding area.
    • 01:27:34
      The next step in the process is to complete a final environmental impact statement that is expected to be completed in April of this year.
    • 01:27:42
      I should note that comes with a
    • 01:27:46
      Before that can be closed out.
    • 01:27:49
      And that would then be submitted to the Federal Transit Administration with a request for record of decision.
    • 01:27:56
      While this process is underway, we plan to request from the federal government a partnership in moving forward to begin preliminary engineering.
    • 01:28:07
      Preliminary engineering is the beginning of the actual project development.
    • 01:28:12
      Our key priorities in that process would be to develop much more detailed cost estimates, a much more thorough financial plan, and I'll note that a lot of things have changed in two years.
    • 01:28:23
      It's time to take a good hard look, but all the partners are still at the table.
    • 01:28:27
      Bottom line on today, the Metro Rail Extension is clearly supported by the local governments and agencies that include Loudoun County, Town of Herndon, Fairfax County, the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority, and the Washington Metropolitan Area Transportation Authority, WMATA.
    • 01:28:45
      Many years of work have gone into this process.
    • 01:28:48
      The groups I've just mentioned have worked for eight years studying various alternatives and after an exhaustive process, over 200 meetings, objective analysis, public hearings, they have determined that the Metrowale extension with bus enhancements until we get there is the best way to meet the needs of the corridor.
    • 01:29:08
      This does not mean that you are making a commitment to fund the construction of the project.
    • 01:29:14
      We will continue to work with the Federal Transit Administration to develop a realistic, detailed cost estimate and financial plan and will be looking closely at a phasing approach to make this project a reality.
    • 01:29:28
      I must note that this requirement that is part of the PE not only meets the Governor's recent initiative but exceeds the requirements of those initiatives.
    • 01:29:37
      The project would not move forward unless all of the pieces have come together in that process.
    • 01:29:43
      It should also be noted that moving the environmental process forward and getting started on PE are critical due to the timing of the upcoming federal reauthorization.
    • 01:29:55
      And in closing, because I did take very seriously when one of our partners asked some questions of us, I spoke yesterday morning with Jenna Dorn, who is the FTA administrator,
    • 01:30:07
      and her comments to me and she gave me total permission and asked me to share them with you were first the FTA supports the completion of the EIS including a locally preferred alternative for the entire corridor to Dulles including the Loudoun County component.
    • 01:30:24
      She also agrees that we are in the process of responding to FTA issues so we can move the project forward into preliminary engineering consistent with the requirements of FTA.
    • 01:30:36
      That's a rough run-through.
    • 01:30:39
      You've had a lot of material sent to you.
    • 01:30:41
      I know you've been overwhelmed with a lot of different comments.
    • 01:30:45
      I stand ready with my staff, which include Corey Hill and Chip Badger.
    • 01:30:50
      We're also joined by several WMATA staff who've been working diligently on this project, John Dittmeyer, Ik Hong, Sheeva Pont, and Rick Stevens.
    • 01:31:01
      So we'd be glad to answer any questions you may have.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:06
      As I understand your response to Gary McCarthy the other day, the thing that we're committing now in addition to selecting an LPA is committing the PE, which would cost about 60 million dollars,
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:24
      Well, you're not, this board is not committing that.
    • 01:31:27
      I will point out we expect to go forward with PE in partnership with the federal government, the local entities, and previous boards have put money in the budgets to advance the environmental and preliminary engineering.
    • 01:31:41
      So you would not be acting, there's already been money put into the budget through previous boards.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:47
      As I understood your earlier information, you expected about 80% of that to be paid by some federal agency, FTA or whoever?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:31:56
      The federal government for PE will pay anywhere from 50 to 80%, and that's part of the discussion we're having with them.
    • 01:32:04
      They traditionally fund engineering at a higher percentage, so we hope to get closer to 80% in our discussion.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:10
      That's not committed at this time?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:12
      Not committed, no.
    • 01:32:13
      We are putting in a formal request, and then there will be a discussion, and they have the final sign-off.
    • 01:32:20
      I don't want to underestimate that, but we think we are now on a path to reaching that sign-off.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:26
      I take it from the quote that you gave from Ms. Dorn that you would disagree with the earlier speakers who said the FTA has rejected Metro Rail as something that would ever be funded by federal funds?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:40
      I would say that what we've done is we've set a process.
    • 01:32:45
      There were some issues raised by FTA.
    • 01:32:47
      I won't deny that.
    • 01:32:48
      Those were realistic issues that our governor has even raised some of them.
    • 01:32:52
      You know, making sure we have the most cost-effective project, but I think we have over the last several weeks set a process in place to resolve those issues, and that's what I think her comments show.
    • 01:33:02
      It's not a guarantee of funding, but it doesn't mean that the door is closed by any means.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:06
      Finally, if I could ask one more question.
    • 01:33:10
      Your reaction to the observations made earlier this morning that this would be a delay in moving forward with something that would try to avoid the air pollution problems.
    • 01:33:25
      Do you agree or disagree that this would be an approach that could cost sanctions to be imposed because of air pollution problems?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:33:37
      Well, I don't, I think the whole point of moving forward today is to minimize the delay in doing anything and the point that I tried to call out and I'm probably to be clear is that we intend to support enhancements in that corridor to keep things going, you know, to the maximum extent possible with bus and technology options.
    • 01:34:00
      So we are doing everything consistent with the comprehensive plans that have been adopted by both Loudoun and Fairfax County to do as much as we can in that corridor.
    • 01:34:09
      What we don't want to do in that corridor is anything that could preclude the future extension to the Dulles Airport in western Loudoun County.
    • 01:34:19
      Eastern Loudoun County, I'm sorry.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:20
      Can I just follow up on that because I thought it was an issue that one of the issues I haven't asked you about and again I'm going to commend staff for their responsiveness to all our many questions but it's a follow-up on Jim's question is the fact that we are looking at a long-term rail situation that EPA does support would that help us in our negotiations in our non-attainment status?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:51
      I'm sure it wouldn't hurt and could help how much it will help.
    • 01:34:58
      I'd like to, after listening to Jeff yesterday, I'd like to say we have a 55-gallon drum of air pollution, and even the best solutions are thimbleful solutions, plus or minus.
    • 01:35:10
      But do I think the EPA went above and beyond anything I've ever seen from the EPA in support of a project?
    • 01:35:16
      I was very, very pleasantly surprised to see their recommendation back to us.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:22
      A process question.
    • 01:35:25
      If we make a record of decision today, that record then goes to FTA for their sign-off after this, or what's the process at?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:34
      Alright, just because I'm sounding like Philip, the terminology I even mix up after three years.
    • 01:35:39
      Today you would be voting on the preferred alternative, which is what we study for the final environmental impact statement, which will be done over the next several months.
    • 01:35:50
      So it's the decision on what is the technology choice that came out of all of the meetings and process we've had to date.
    • 01:35:56
      That clears the way that the final environmental statement will be focused on that alternative.
    • 01:36:02
      Then that is sent to the federal government and we request a record of decision on the corridor from them.
    • 01:36:10
      So they will be the ones who will issue that record of decision.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:13
      And if there's any problems with that record of decisions that would then come back to the group.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:19
      And across the country, many times it does come back for either clarification or additional, or many times it is passed forward.
    • 01:36:27
      And again, I point to WMATA's past track record at moving EIS's very complex ones through to the end of Record of Decision Findings.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:38
      Bill?
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:39
      I want to pursue the point I raised last time after the briefing, which is the cost per passenger.
    • 01:36:48
      The question is, in terms of trying to measure what this will ultimately cost, even though we don't know until we get more information what it will really cost, do you acknowledge that it's likely to cost a multiple of five to ten times the BRT?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:03
      It is the numbers that we talked about last round about the cost per passenger and that right now shows in the twenty-six, Corey, twenty-six dollars.
    • 01:37:18
      A little under twenty-five and we're working hard on two levels.
    • 01:37:21
      Number one, of course, looking at
    • 01:37:23
      starting to take hold of the project and value engineer the project down as far as cost.
    • 01:37:29
      The other thing is there have been some recent developments, some of which you heard about this morning, that will clearly add to the ridership base with some of the new developments, especially Loudoun County is the one that's most obvious.
    • 01:37:40
      Those were not in the original numbers.
    • 01:37:42
      So there will be a raising of that.
    • 01:37:45
      The threshold that Federal Transit looks at, we're not quite there, but it's about $23 is their threshold.
    • 01:37:53
      And what I point to is to carry that capacity, bus rapid transit would never be able to carry that capacity in that corridor.
    • 01:38:02
      And the highway solution in that corridor would be to add five to six lanes of highway to carry the same capacity.
    • 01:38:09
      So there's both the study of the numbers, but there's also the physical capacity to move people in that corridor, and I think that's what the solution is.
    • 01:38:18
      It is a high number, it often is.
    • 01:38:20
      We will be compared against systems that are similar size across the country.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:24
      What are the estimates that you have in mind right now of increased ridership?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:30
      Until my modeling comes back, I just know it would be more than the numbers that we have out there right now.
    • 01:38:39
      I'm sorry I can't answer that.
    • 01:38:40
      I tend to not want to put out numbers that I haven't seen embedded, but I do know that there's some potential for those increasing significantly, and many of our stakeholders have kind of said, have you really captured the true ridership in this area?
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:53
      The numbers given today for the BRT system would not meet the capacity that you are estimating right now?
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:38:59
      No, they would not.
    • 01:39:04
      And to come back to your earlier question in terms of cost per passenger for the rail we're looking at just under 25, for BRT we're looking at 16.
    • 01:39:14
      So in terms of what that delta is between the cost per passenger at 16 versus 25.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:22
      Harry.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:24
      I'm going to pull Corey back up here since he's been here for a lot longer than I am.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:27
      I think everybody knows Corey Hill.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:29
      Corey Hill, who's been our project manager.
    • 01:39:31
      He's the Northern Virginia project manager for all the Northern Virginia projects.
    • 01:39:35
      This is one of his small challenges.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 01:39:38
      All right, Harry.
    • 01:39:39
      I'd like to speak in favor of the resolution and not really ask the question.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:39:43
      Maybe we need to get the proposed resolution before us, and then we'll, if they don't
    • 01:39:49
      Questions to you were, I think, based on your comments that you had made in updating the board.
    • 01:39:58
      But I think if you'll speak to the proposed resolution that's been recommended by that department, why don't we go ahead and just get it before us.
    • 01:40:08
      We'll have a motion.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:40:10
      So moved.
    • 01:40:10
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:40:11
      I have been moved and seconded that the resolution that was distributed this morning by Karen Rae,
    • 01:40:19
      is now properly before, so you want to speak to that?
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 01:40:24
      I think the, as far as I'm concerned, as a relatively new member of this group, the piece I'd like to speak to is the process.
    • 01:40:33
      Anybody that's even vaguely familiar with this federal process, it's, if you're in the midst of it, I'm sure it's painful, but it's long, and it doesn't, you don't get where we are, where we are in this process by accident.
    • 01:40:46
      As Karen said, there have been 200 meetings and a great deal of analysis.
    • 01:40:51
      But when you embark on an MIS like this group did in 1994, long before I was paying much attention to it, I can assure you, to have progressed to this point, we're being asked to take it to the next step today.
    • 01:41:05
      So as I step into the process, I encourage us to move it forward.
    • 01:41:10
      As long as there are alternatives to this plan,
    • 01:41:15
      There will be good people that support different views, but as long as we have the local support that we heard all about today, the people that manage their affairs in that part of the state, I would encourage us to move this project forward.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:41:39
      I, too, am going to support this motion today.
    • 01:41:44
      Over the last four years, or even before that, we have talked, local governments have talked about smart growth initiatives.
    • 01:41:53
      Fairfax County has a comprehensive plan which supports some of the things in this corridor.
    • 01:41:59
      Walton County did, in fact, recently, as of Monday of this week, supported its first transit center, 6,000 dwelling units for high density and 10 million FAR feet of commercial uses.
    • 01:42:14
      Obviously, that will take time.
    • 01:42:15
      That's not going to plop in overnight.
    • 01:42:17
      But the point is that they're adopting land use policies to be in conjunction with transportation initiatives.
    • 01:42:24
      It's one of the few times I've actually seen now we're actually implementing some of these things.
    • 01:42:29
      It will take time.
    • 01:42:31
      I think one of my things that I want to watch is the focus on the financial plan.
    • 01:42:38
      We've heard a lot of comments today about doing this in phases and looking at some alternatives in between.
    • 01:42:44
      This is the right answer, ultimately.
    • 01:42:46
      Airport authority, local government supported it.
    • 01:42:49
      I think as we go through the process, we'll look at pieces of this to find out what's the most cost-effective way of doing this.
    • 01:42:55
      You know, there are pieces of it that are more expensive than others.
    • 01:42:59
      Maybe those are the pieces we look at.
    • 01:43:01
      For a later phase, but do the things where we get the most good.
    • 01:43:04
      We heard comments a lot that the ridership is going to come west of Tyson's Corner.
    • 01:43:10
      Well, maybe that's one of the things we focus on during the preliminary engineering side of this.
    • 01:43:14
      The focus on some of this.
    • 01:43:15
      Sort of help implement some of these smart growth initiatives that we've been hearing about over and over again.
    • 01:43:23
      I also wanted to recognize Kenny and the task force because they've been working on this for years.
    • 01:43:31
      I know I had a little involvement up front.
    • 01:43:32
      It was a lot of work.
    • 01:43:34
      Kenny spent a lot of years working this through the system.
    • 01:43:37
      I think he should be recognized for his effort and the task force effort.
    • 01:43:43
      I'm sure Kenny's going to say something anyway, although he's a little less expert than I am.
    • 01:43:49
      But I am going to support this, and I think it starts to begin to implement the smart growth policies that we've been hearing over and over again.
    • 01:44:00
      It's one of the few times where we're implementing a transit policy to conform to some of the things that we've been hearing about.
    • 01:44:06
      Well, let's do the things that Arlington has done, implementing development around transit centers.
    • 01:44:12
      Well, here we've got the first one and it's at the end of the line.
    • 01:44:16
      And it's going to start coming east.
    • 01:44:18
      I can see that.
    • 01:44:19
      There's already discussions in Fairfax about implementing the comprehensive plan they have in place now.
    • 01:44:25
      I think you'll probably see it over time to help not only increase tax base, but also to increase riderships.
    • 01:44:32
      And those are the things that are not even in the model yet.
    • 01:44:33
      The decision of the other day is not even in this ridership model.
    • 01:44:38
      And it will take some work with FTA to work on that plan
    • 01:44:42
      And frankly, if they do have a problem, I guess we'll hear about it.
    • 01:44:46
      But until then, we need to support this and support the local governments in this initiative.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:44:53
      Jerry?
    • 01:44:54
      Mr. Chairman, I'd like to state at the outset my thanks to Karen and her staff for providing above and beyond the kind of information that I've been looking forward to learn about this project.
    • 01:45:08
      I'd like to say I support this resolution and I just want to get clear though.
    • 01:45:17
      You know I'm not going to let you off this easily.
    • 01:45:20
      I know what you said we're not doing.
    • 01:45:23
      We're not making a commitment to fund this project.
    • 01:45:26
      We are making a commitment to keep it moving down the track so that we gather enough information about what various
    • 01:45:36
      Pictures of it might look like.
    • 01:45:39
      And that will go through the final environmental impact statement process and at some point the preliminary design and engineering.
    • 01:45:48
      At what, this is a process question, at what point does this come back to the Commonwealth Transportation Board for, in other words I'd like to see where we're going with this.
    • 01:45:59
      I understand where we are, thank you very much, but I'd like to see a little bit further down the track where we're going and when will this come back?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:08
      If I can, I'll also look to the Secretary, but first of all, I intended to set up about a quarterly report on where our progress was and all the different work that's going forward, because I think it's essential to not just have it be a meeting a year from now and give you an update.
    • 01:46:24
      I think it's a process that we're in the middle of.
    • 01:46:27
      Any actions that will commit beyond our existing revenues or modify the existing revenues would of course come before this board.
    • 01:46:35
      It will be called out in our six-year and program budget so you'll be voting on that.
    • 01:46:40
      That's probably the most, the next upcoming action is you will vote on the DRPT budget which will include in a little more specificity this particular one.
    • 01:46:50
      Also it will be the first time that we've been
    • 01:46:52
      Woven, more specifically, into the six-year planning process, and that's a huge step forward for all of us.
    • 01:46:59
      We've had our own, but we've never been woven, so you'll have a vote on that six-year plan.
    • 01:47:05
      And any commitment to move forward past PE will include
    • 01:47:10
      I'm sure you okaying that we move to the next level because there will be new financial commitments that go with that.
    • 01:47:17
      The financial planning activity itself I would propose to bring to the board even in the rough format as soon as it becomes available.
    • 01:47:25
      I don't see us waiting this to the end.
    • 01:47:27
      I would like to bring it in for information along the path.
    • 01:47:30
      But the key actions will be the next piece you would see after this action would clearly be the adoption of the DRPT budget which will have this program in it.
    • 01:47:39
      The Six-Year Plan, which will also have references to this program and this project.
    • 01:47:44
      And then the next obvious one would be before we go on to the next level past PE, then you would also see an action from us.
    • 01:47:54
      I support the resolution.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 01:48:01
      I was a little surprised at the figure you gave on the bus cost per passenger.
    • 01:48:06
      I've been led to believe by the advocates maybe that it was less expensive than that.
    • 01:48:13
      What about the Los Angeles thing, the argument that Los Angeles hasn't gone that way with all their traffic?
    • 01:48:19
      Any comments on that at all?
    • 01:48:21
      I think it's interesting to know.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:48:22
      Well, I'd like to point out that the most successful systems are systems.
    • 01:48:27
      And what Los Angeles has done is they have combined a series of options, including heavy rail, light rail,
    • 01:48:34
      Bus Rapid Transit, dedicated HOV lanes, and it's a series of options that a local community designs to put a system together.
    • 01:48:44
      I like to point out, no single component is going to make a system work.
    • 01:48:49
      And I think it's incumbent upon the local jurisdictions and their comprehensive planning and the state as we look at our multi-year.
    • 01:48:56
      We begin to look at this as a system.
    • 01:48:58
      So one is not better than the other.
    • 01:49:01
      It's the combination of all of the systems together which really performs and makes the best system.
    • 01:49:05
      And theirs is truly a combination.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:10
      I have some additional questions regarding the cost, if I might.
    • 01:49:17
      All the supporters of the program, the governmental entities, is their share of the funding coming from the governments themselves?
    • 01:49:26
      Because it's easy to support the Cadillac of systems if you're not paying for it, I think.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:33
      Kenny, maybe you can help.
    • 01:49:35
      Loudoun County last year passed a business professional tax dedicated to this project.
    • 01:49:41
      It's in place and its revenues are escrowed to be put into this project for their share.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:49
      I'm sorry, I couldn't hear what you said.
    • 01:49:50
      Do you mind repeating that?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:49:52
      Loudoun County.
    • 01:49:55
      Louden County last year, their board passed a business professional license tax that is dedicated to this project, and it will achieve the revenues that it needs for its share.
    • 01:50:09
      Fairfax County has some bonding capacity, but Governor Holton and former Governor Holton, former Governor and Senator Robb are putting together a tax district
    • 01:50:25
      for the Fairfax County Share.
    • 01:50:29
      We already have a tax district sort of cutting across the corridor on Route 28, and they plan to have some additional real estate tax collected from the businesses within the corridor.
    • 01:50:46
      That has to go to the Fairfax County Board.
    • 01:50:50
      The airport authority
    • 01:50:52
      will use for its share what is called passenger facility charges.
    • 01:50:58
      Each airport charges per passenger, if you will, a head tax.
    • 01:51:04
      Part of that will be dedicated for their share.
    • 01:51:10
      And the state is looking at the toll road excess revenues on the toll road.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:19
      The state of Virginia.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:20
      The state of Virginia, yes.
    • 01:51:22
      Those are the four non-federal funding partners.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:26
      An additional question, Karen.
    • 01:51:29
      The federal money that would come from the FTA, would that reduce our federal funds available for other projects around the state, or is that a completely separate school of money?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:51:40
      That's a discretionary pot.
    • 01:51:44
      It's competed for nationally.
    • 01:51:46
      It's called the New Starts Program, and it's for new starts of rail projects or building out of rail projects.
    • 01:51:53
      We will be competing with
    • 01:51:55
      This year I think there's 40 or 50 projects in that pot.
    • 01:51:59
      That's part of the urgency you sometimes hear in my voice is concern of that.
    • 01:52:03
      There's two other projects, well there's one other project that I know will also be seeking support and that would be the Hampton Roads Light Rail Project.
    • 01:52:11
      Eventually we'll be looking for some support from that program.
    • 01:52:15
      I think that FTA, because of this technical analysis you've heard about,
    • 01:52:19
      We'll end up making decisions based on how the projects look, so I think our competition is probably more with some of the larger cities.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:28
      So it doesn't affect our standing in the reauthorization or any of the federal highway money?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:34
      Absolutely no, it does not.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:52:37
      If I use your $25 per rider estimate for the rail, and the state cost is a fourth of that, is that a fair?
    • 01:52:50
      Correct, yeah.
    • 01:52:51
      So it's $650, whatever that is, per rider.
    • 01:52:54
      How do you benchmark that number?
    • 01:52:56
      I mean, how do you know that's a reasonable amount to pay, or at what point does it, you say it's just too expensive and we have to find some other lead?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:05
      Actually, I think the important part is, and we kind of talked about this a couple months ago, part of what we're doing in that quarter is clearly congestion relief, and there's a value to that.
    • 01:53:16
      Part of it is the economic development and the smart growth, and that's both a combination of positives and maybe, smart growth would argue, not building more roadways and more utilities, so there's a value added there.
    • 01:53:32
      You can quantify, and I think there was actually a review of the user benefits and a number of things that quantified what we get out of that, and I'll be glad to get that to you.
    • 01:53:40
      It shows that the investment is supported by a number of the different factors that will be outcomes of this rail build, but it's not singular.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:48
      When you say we get, are you talking about the state?
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:53:52
      The state and the localities, the beneficiaries along the line.
    • 01:53:56
      I think that would be really helpful to see in the future.
    • SPEAKER_10
    • 01:54:05
      And to further clarify, Metro has done studies to date as well on the commonwealth's return on its economic investment to date in Metro.
    • 01:54:15
      And that study that they did showed that our investment in Metro to date has had a positive return of 19% on the investments that we've made in Metro to date in terms of economic investment, increased tax dollars, things like that.
    • 01:54:30
      So our history with Metro has been very positive for the state to date.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:54:35
      Is it fair to say that if we don't move forward with a locally preferred alternative that the ability to get to that discretionary federal funding won't happen?
    • 01:54:52
      Let's put it this way, we would be non-competitive in competing for that discretionary funding.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:00
      That is my understanding after knowing the federal process.
    • 01:55:03
      Because it is such a tight pot, there are projects that get quite a bit of the money up front.
    • 01:55:09
      There's a second list of projects that are into the process.
    • 01:55:12
      I'm sure we could always get listed in what I call the C list, which is projects that are under consideration, but there tends not to be any money left by the time those projects move forward.
    • 01:55:21
      So my answer is, from everything I know of this process, the further we are in the process, the better our chances are, with the assumption that we've answered all these questions, the better our chances are of securing the federal dollars that we're looking for to support this project.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:55:39
      I'd just like to support the resolution, and I think it was Mr. Vinson who said he'd been involved in transportation for a number of years, but I think, Kenny, I go back 34 years of dealing with transportation in Northern Virginia.
    • 01:55:54
      I was on the planning commission in Arlington when we established the Roslyn-Barson Carters and started designing the land use and opening the stations.
    • 01:56:03
      I chaired the Roslyn Sector Plan.
    • 01:56:06
      And I can attest to the marvelous achievements that the rail has brought to our community.
    • 01:56:15
      It did take good land use to work in conjunction with it, but we now have a vibrant and a dynamic community that's also very livable.
    • 01:56:25
      I want to tell the Hunter Mill area that if you can work with your local planning jurisdiction that you can protect
    • 01:56:33
      and support very livable neighborhoods around high-density metros, corridors.
    • 01:56:41
      I also am very interested in looking ahead and in terms of long-range planning I'm involved in the Trans 2025 and I definitely hope and
    • 01:56:54
      It's my fervent hope that in 2025 we see a robust rail system that serves the western part of the metropolitan area and structures the growth around it.
    • 01:57:09
      I hope as we proceed with due diligence, which apparently you have embedded into this project, that it will be successful.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:23
      I intend to vote for the resolution to move it to the next step, but I'd like to express a concern that we're not getting ourselves a little bit pregnant.
    • 01:57:37
      I would vote with the caveat that I'm relying on this coming back before us at every step without a commitment now to go all the way.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:51
      And I'd like to echo that sentiment as well and I think the staff will do that, at least hope they do that.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:57:58
      Bill?
    • 01:58:01
      I think everybody's done a good job in this process that Harry described earlier to get us the information we need to make a decision right now.
    • 01:58:09
      I mean, we know what the local governments think.
    • 01:58:12
      We know the comparative advantages of rail that have been identified.
    • 01:58:16
      We know approximation, least of cost.
    • 01:58:18
      And so all that's really been helpful.
    • 01:58:20
      So the process has done what it's supposed to do.
    • 01:58:22
      With a lot of respect for the local government's positions, particularly since they're going to invest in it, they're right there and know what's going on.
    • 01:58:33
      It makes sense for us to go ahead and do the engineering because you're hearing around the table, and I share it too, even though I've been a little more negative than some others, that rail is the preferred alternative, absent the cost problem.
    • 01:58:46
      But almost everything we say about rail on this project applies to a lot of transportation projects, including Shenandoah Valley.
    • Jim D. BowieMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:54
      But it may not be efficient, effective, cost-effective.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:58:59
      So I think it would really be helpful, to me at least, if we could keep working, even while the preliminary engineering is going on, we could keep working on what is the potential value of engineering, what are the realistic estimates of ridership that would make the per capita cost come down,
    • 01:59:17
      And also, what are the additional benefits we get, even though they're hard to translate into dollars, in terms of relief of congestion and that kind of thing, and then a final comparison with the rapid transit system when we get ready to move to the next stage to say whether or not that system would do the same thing at a less cost, even though it's not as attractive to us.
    • 01:59:40
      A lot of times we can't buy what we like.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:42
      Excellent.
    • 01:59:44
      The only one I'd add is the air quality impact, and I think you've got a checklist of the things that we will bring back to you regularly and try to continue this information exchange.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:59:56
      Okay.
    • 01:59:57
      Any unreadiness?
    • 02:00:00
      All in favor of the resolution before us, please say aye.
    • 02:00:05
      Aye.
    • 02:00:06
      All opposed?
    • 02:00:08
      Okay.
    • 02:00:09
      Thank you, Karen.
    • 02:00:10
      Thank you.
    • 02:00:16
      Do we have any other old business to come before the board?
    • 02:00:24
      One of the items that we wanted to
    • 02:00:28
      Bring you up to date on new business is to brief you on where we stand on the PPTA guidelines, the Public Private Transportation Act guidelines.
    • 02:00:43
      Pierce Homer, Deputy Secretary, has done an excellent job in following up, taking the lead on this process.
    • 02:00:55
      And Pierce is with us this morning.
    • 02:00:58
      To bring you up to date and being distributed is an outline of his presentation.
    • Pierce R. HomerDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:01:07
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 02:01:09
      Coming around to you are the slides.
    • 02:01:11
      There are extra copies in the back.
    • 02:01:14
      We are in the process of revising these implementation guidelines for the Public Private Transportation Act that was passed in 1995.
    • 02:01:24
      And these are important because they govern a major aspect of the transportation procurement process.
    • 02:01:33
      It's also important to understand that these are guidelines.
    • 02:01:36
      They are not regulations.
    • 02:01:38
      They are intended purposely to be flexible, to deal with partnership situations.
    • 02:01:45
      If you look on the second page of the handout, there is a history and a status that I think is very important and also very revealing.
    • 02:01:55
      The legislation was initially passed in 1995.
    • 02:01:59
      The first comprehensive agreement, that's the execution of a public-private transportation partnership, was in 1996 with the EMS, Interstate Asset Management, 1998 with Pocahontas Parkway, and then in the year 2000, Rep. 288.
    • 02:02:16
      and at the end of 2001, the Cocoa Expressway.
    • 02:02:20
      So about one comprehensive agreement a year and some of those took more than one year to execute.
    • 02:02:28
      In the last year, 2002, there have been three comprehensive agreements completed.
    • 02:02:34
      Route 28 in Northern Virginia, a complete renegotiation of the Coldfield Expressway, and the Jamestown Route 195 agreement in the Hampton Roads District.
    • 02:02:46
      And that's a significant amount of work.
    • 02:02:49
      When the Secretary arrived last January, there were five additional PBTA proposals that also arrived in January.
    • 02:03:04
      We had a very important set of decisions to make about our ability to manage those.
    • 02:03:12
      If you look historically about one year, we did three in this last year.
    • 02:03:17
      So, earlier this year, five unsolicited PPTA proposals were returned to the original proposals.
    • 02:03:34
      That has left two proposals that were pending and had been approved by the Commonwealth Transportation Board to be addressed under the current rules.
    • 02:03:46
      That's the Dulles corridor transit proposal and that has been recommended by an independent advisory panel to go to the Department of Rail and Public Transportation to negotiate a comprehensive agreement.
    • 02:03:57
      It's important to understand that is based on the previous actions of the previous Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 02:04:04
      The same is true for the Route 58 Public-Private Transportation Act proposal.
    • 02:04:10
      That's the Hillsboro-Stewart section.
    • 02:04:12
      And that is currently pending before the independent advisory committee.
    • 02:04:17
      There are right now also two proposals pending.
    • 02:04:22
      One, the I-40 495, that's the Beltway hot lanes in Northern Virginia, have yet to be formally considered.
    • 02:04:30
      And in mid-January, the closing date for the first solicited PBGA proposal for I-81.
    • 02:04:38
      And those proposals are due in January.
    • 02:04:43
      What are the reasons for revising these guidelines?
    • 02:04:47
      The first is to implement the policy goals of the government, and we address those to the Commonwealth Transportation Board in January of this year.
    • 02:04:59
      The second, which is in my mind the most important aspect of these proposed changes to the guidelines, is to enhance competition.
    • 02:05:08
      Whether it is an unsolicited proposal or solicited, we think that the competition of ideas and the competition of financial resources are going to bring the best value and the best set of transportation improvements to the Commonwealth.
    • 02:05:24
      A third reason for rising guidelines is that the previous General Assembly did pass some legislation that we do need to build into our process.
    • 02:05:33
      A fourth reason, as I mentioned, are resource limitations.
    • 02:05:36
      These post-private proposals require very extensive commitments and very senior staff.
    • 02:05:43
      Traditional mobile procurement allows you to delegate and push those decisions very far down in the organization.
    • 02:05:50
      These require the commitment of senior staff and sources.
    • 02:05:53
      Lastly, in February of this year, the Secretary had created a small internal task force to look at ways to improve the process.
    • 02:06:03
      So those are the combination of reasons why we're recommending changes to the guidelines.
    • 02:06:08
      And at this stage, we have made conceptual goals for the revisions to the guidelines.
    • 02:06:16
      We are not before you today with specific line-by-line changes to the guidelines, but we wanted the CTB aware of what are the guiding principles for that.
    • 02:06:25
      The major goals were laid out in the following two pages of the handout.
    • 02:06:30
      The first item, and this is at the explicit direction of the Governor, is that we should always insist that there be cost and or risk sharing on any public-private transportation proposal.
    • 02:06:42
      If there's not that element to it, there are other ways to procure it.
    • 02:06:47
      Secondly, greater competition, which we have talked about.
    • 02:06:51
      Third is to better define communication and advocacy roles.
    • 02:06:56
      The PPTA process is a very difficult one to manage, and in particular on the revenue side when we're talking about tolls or a special tax district or private sector equity contribution, there are a lot of extraneous forces.
    • 02:07:11
      It's very important that those communications be properly focused and to understand that this is a procurement and that we need to define a process where those types of communications early on when we're talking about policy it should be very open and further down the road where you're actually negotiating a procurement contract there ought to be very clear guidelines about how communications occur with the transportation pages.
    • 02:07:40
      A fourth major goal, and this is one that was raised in the previous General Assembly, was many PPGA proposals, as submitted, had the potential of creating state-supported debt.
    • 02:07:52
      And that was determined to be unacceptable by the General Assembly.
    • 02:07:57
      They asked us to look at this item, and what we have said in response to that is that there is a procedure in place that is approved by the General Assembly on a project-specific basis, that there is an independent funding source, that it is approved by the Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:08:18
      The Treasury Board and the Governor as well.
    • 02:08:21
      So there is a process and it is by design very difficult.
    • 02:08:26
      Another major goal of revision is again the direction of the Governor to encourage multimodal solutions.
    • 02:08:33
      So for example, in the case of the I-81 proposal, one of the elements of that was to insist that there be consideration of rail freight issues.
    • 02:08:42
      The final three goals are contained on the next page of the slides.
    • 02:08:46
      And the first one is to have transparent public sector financial and operational commitments.
    • 02:08:52
      previous guidelines did allow for confidential submissions that dealt with public funds.
    • 02:09:01
      And it was our very strong belief that up front, if sector dollars are involved in a public private transportation proposal, those should be absolutely transparent from the very beginning of the process.
    • 02:09:15
      A related goal is to have very limited confidentiality.
    • 02:09:19
      There may be proprietary elements to a submission, and there may be reasons for the Commonwealth, in terms of its own negotiating posture, that we would want to deem elements to be confidential.
    • 02:09:31
      But for the most part, submissions ought to be open and available to the public.
    • 02:09:37
      Lastly, and I think most importantly, there should be consistency with the transportation goals in the Commonwealth as they're established by the CTB.
    • 02:09:47
      You're working through a process with the 2025 plan, you have numerous other documents, the Six-Year Improvement Program where you articulate priorities, and to the extent that proposals support those goals, then we ought to give preference to those in the process so that we're all moving in the same direction.
    • 02:10:08
      Over on the next page are four very important issues procedurally.
    • 02:10:12
      Some of these will involve the CTB and you may have questions about them.
    • 02:10:17
      We're suggesting four major procedural changes.
    • 02:10:21
      The first we believe will encourage greater private sector investment by combining the initial review committee and the independent advisory panel into an upfront process where the policy and the public financial commitments are addressed.
    • 02:10:39
      That will do two things.
    • 02:10:41
      One, it will remove the barrier of entry and allow, and these proposals are not cheap to prepare, so we think it will encourage the submission of additional proposals.
    • 02:10:54
      Secondly, it will make very clear the difference between the policy considerations up front.
    • 02:10:59
      Should there be a toll on this board?
    • 02:11:01
      Are there appropriate land uses?
    • 02:11:03
      Is a special tax district going to reach these goals and those types of considerations?
    • 02:11:09
      vs. the ministerial or administrative considerations which would be further down the road and the responsibility of the transportation agency to negotiate the very best price for a contract to ensure that the revenue stream meets the defined costs.
    • 02:11:26
      And that's an important distinction in the process.
    • 02:11:30
      The next point on the procedural revisions is to require the formal approval of the Secretary of Transportation and the CTB after that policy review process is done.
    • 02:11:42
      That, in effect, would be a recommendation to this body and to the Secretary to adopt a policy with respect to an individual PPTA proposal.
    • 02:11:52
      At that point, the Secretary has to formally sign off as with the CTB, and they would direct
    • 02:11:59
      Whether it's the Director of Rail and Public Transportation or the Commonwealth Transportation Commissioner to negotiate a contract and to get the best price.
    • 02:12:09
      The third point again is there is an agency that is responsible for negotiating those contracts and we think it's important to draw a line between the policy responsibilities of the CTB, the Secretary of the Governor's Office, and the administrative responsibilities of procuring and executing a contract.
    • 02:12:26
      And those two issues should not be mixed up.
    • 02:12:30
      Lastly, and again very important, that the public-private proposals must be important in each process, that environmental impact statement.
    • 02:12:38
      When we're talking about very large facilities like the Dulles Rail or an I-81, making those two processes meshed is not easy, but it's absolutely essential, and it also provides a way to ensure that there's adequate public participation in the PPTA process.
    • 02:12:57
      And that's one of the guarantees that is built into these.
    • 02:13:01
      If you look to the last page, the question is what are the next steps?
    • 02:13:05
      We held on December 11th a stakeholder meeting.
    • 02:13:07
      It was very, very well attended.
    • 02:13:09
      The industry is very interested in this process, and it has resulted in good investments and good ideas.
    • 02:13:16
      We are intending to release our draft revisions to the guidelines by January 3rd.
    • 02:13:22
      Our emphasis is when caveats to that.
    • 02:13:24
      There are some recent federal highway issues that we may have to resolve.
    • 02:13:29
      If we are unable to resolve it, we may not be able to meet for January 3rd deadline.
    • 02:13:33
      That is our goal today.
    • 02:13:36
      Finally, we would have recommendations to the General Transportation Board at the February meeting for their consideration of what is given us the appropriate time.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 02:13:46
      Mr. Chairman, I'd be happy to answer any questions.
    • 02:13:50
      All right.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:13:50
      Any questions, Mr. Pierce?
    • 02:13:51
      Jared?
    • 02:13:52
      Who is this advisory panel composed of that's telling us all this stuff?
    • 02:13:56
      I've never heard of them before.
    • Pierce R. HomerDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:13:58
      A quiet aspect of government under the current guidelines.
    • 02:14:03
      There is a four-step process for considering the public private proposals.
    • 02:14:10
      It is submitted and it goes to what's known as an initial review committee, which is essentially agency staff who make a determination, does this meet certain minimum thresholds?
    • 02:14:23
      Is it a highway project?
    • 02:14:25
      Is the engineering appropriate?
    • 02:14:27
      Does it look like the financing plan to choose the task?
    • 02:14:30
      The next step in the process is that it goes to the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 02:14:35
      And the Commonwealth Transportation Board would say, yes, we agree this conceptual proposal is a good idea, investigate it further.
    • 02:14:43
      After the CTB action, there is what's known as a detailed proposal that goes to the independent advisory committee.
    • 02:14:50
      That is a group that is appointed by the Secretary of Transportation and historically and under the current guidelines includes a CTB member from the affected district.
    • 02:15:03
      It includes an outside academic or academics, plural, typically would include if there are affected local governments or other transportation entities and then any appropriate technical staff from the agencies.
    • 02:15:19
      And they make a recommendation, not a mandate, but a recommendation to the individual department director as to whether or not to negotiate a comprehensive agreement based on a detailed submission.
    • 02:15:33
      What we are proposing in the revisions is to combine the initial review commission and the advisory group to deal at a conceptual level with the proposal and then make those recommendations again to the CTB and the secretary.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:15:49
      And I gather that the Dulles-Carter transit proposal that we just moved a little further is going to be reviewed according to these new guidelines then?
    • Pierce R. HomerDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:15:58
      No sir, those came to us under, they had been, the Dulles-Carter proposal had been approved I want to say in 1999 by the Commonwealth Transportation Board and so the Dulles proposal
    • 02:16:13
      Route 28 and Route 58 have been approved by previous CTBs and we know we needed to prepare those previous actions and those previous procedures.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:16:28
      I haven't been intimately involved with this process over a number of years.
    • 02:16:36
      I will say it takes an enormous amount of senior staff time to go through this on all levels, not even just within the department, the attorney general's office.
    • 02:16:46
      In fact, I think Philip and I talked, this is almost, the PPTA process is almost for the mega projects.
    • 02:16:53
      I know there was talk about
    • 02:16:55
      doing them for smaller projects, even secondary roads.
    • 02:16:57
      And I think I tend to agree with them as maybe that's the idea of using design-build concepts for those kind of things.
    • 02:17:04
      But I like the PPT.
    • 02:17:08
      I think it's a source for doing, for better or lack of terms, the mega projects.
    • 02:17:13
      It's a good way to help do that.
    • 02:17:14
      What it does is it pools money.
    • 02:17:17
      Nowadays, we've got to look for different pockets of money.
    • 02:17:21
      And you can go to different resources, and you can do it under this proposal.
    • 02:17:25
      One of the questions I have is, we've now gone to a solicited versus non-solicited, which is something we haven't done in the past.
    • 02:17:35
      And do you see any shortcomings on going that particular route versus going with the non-solicited?
    • 02:17:44
      Do you lose any
    • 02:17:46
      Imagine of ideas going that route that when you go solicited, you give a set of criteria that you want to achieve.
    • 02:17:54
      You lose anything in that process by going that route versus a non-solicited.
    • Pierce R. HomerDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:17:59
      Mr. Mitchell, first, we are not doing away with unsolicited proposals.
    • 02:18:04
      So, for example, the Belvay-Hotland proposal is unsolicited.
    • 02:18:09
      What we did in that case, and the emphasis again is competition, what we did in that case was to say, you will be taken up under the new rules.
    • 02:18:17
      Previously, when we received an unsolicited proposal, we basically advertised it for 45 days.
    • 02:18:23
      We did not feel that was an adequate length of time.
    • 02:18:26
      to generate competing ideas, competition that's going to spur lower costs, et cetera.
    • 02:18:33
      So we extended that, Deborah, I think it was about 90 days on the beltway proposal.
    • 02:18:39
      So we do have a process in place, and we absolutely do not want to do away with unsolicited proposals.
    • 02:18:45
      We do, in a very deliberate manner, though, in the major corridors, want to emphasize soliciting proposals to the extent we can.
    • 02:18:56
      Some of those get into NEPA and Federal Highway issues that we may or may not be able to resolve.
    • 02:19:02
      But if our goal is to
    • 02:19:05
      I think the real test of that will be I-81.
    • 02:19:15
      We had one unsolicited proposal.
    • 02:19:18
      We'll know in January do we have several proposals, do we have different concepts, do we have different prices, and if we do arrive in that sort of competitive situation, we then have the ability to
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:19:33
      Some of the task force recommendations is part of that going to come out about organizational structural issues to make sure that when these unsolicited ones or even solicited proposals are moving forward that the resources when the department are there without affecting the other functions of the department
    • Pierce R. HomerDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:20:03
      I think the Commissioner might like to speak to that.
    • 02:20:05
      The answer is yes.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:20:08
      Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
    • 02:20:09
      Hobie, yes, part of our reorganization under the chief engineer is the development of a innovative program delivery section.
    • 02:20:23
      specifically for the reason of not only marshaling resources to deal with PPTA, but speaking for myself and VDOT, to make more use of the solicited approach for one very important reason.
    • 02:20:44
      This body adopts a six-year program.
    • 02:20:49
      A unsolicited proposal regarding a project not included in that six-year program has tremendous impact on the work we do.
    • 02:21:00
      The unsolicited proposal process I think is important and one we certainly want to keep, but this new section that will be under the direction of the chief engineer, Malcolm Kerley,
    • 02:21:14
      Part of their responsibility will be to look at the projects that are early in the six-year program process and think about ones which might be excellent candidates for PPTA.
    • 02:21:32
      You made a point about the things that the PPA process
    • 02:21:36
      I guess the only thing I would say, it can bring all those things to the table if we structure it properly and use it properly.
    • 02:21:46
      It is a wonderful tool that has to be carefully used in my opinion
    • 02:21:54
      Because I think we need to hold in high regard the fact that when we go PPTA, we are foregoing the open marketplace.
    • 02:22:04
      So we want to make sure that all the right combinations are there.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:22:10
      To point to the Board, the Route 28 deal, for instance, there were really two interchanges on the Route 28 corridor that were fully funded or partially funded in the Six-Year Program.
    • 02:22:26
      In fact, it may have been a half of another one, but it didn't do much.
    • 02:22:30
      The PPDA process brought in new money and actually did not only those interchanges, but added twice as many.
    • 02:22:39
      with the potential to actually add four more and widening the road.
    • 02:22:42
      It was new money.
    • 02:22:43
      It was almost $200 million of new money outside of the program that came from another source.
    • 02:22:49
      And then here recently on Monday, there was a potential to even add another $10 million of improvements on a secondary program that was negotiated with the PPCA.
    • 02:22:58
      So there is some
    • 02:23:01
      Outside, we think of what's in the six-year program, but the one thing about this is that it brings the potential in for new money that we don't have.
    • 02:23:10
      Under the right business proposals and the right safeguards for the state and the localities, we can get some things done that are outside of a normal six-year program without environmental constraints.
    • 02:23:22
      That's the other thing we got that's a new twist that we heard about.
    • 02:23:27
      is the air quality compliance.
    • 02:23:29
      Even if we find this money or get these proposals, we may not be able to spend it, just like what happened with 28.
    • 02:23:38
      It's a great system.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 02:23:40
      Jerry?
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:23:45
      I don't know how to ask this except to ask it, but what's the private part
    • 02:23:50
      potentially in the Dulles Rail project.
    • 02:23:55
      I thought that was a government project with these local government funds and all that.
    • 02:24:00
      I understand toll roads and people getting receipts from that.
    • 02:24:05
      What's the private part?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:24:07
      The private part would be in the design and building.
    • 02:24:15
      The firm fixed price plus the possibility of ownership.
    • 02:24:27
      Some entity is going to have to own this project at the end of the day.
    • 02:24:33
      It is a subject that the task force has not chosen to get into until we got far enough along where we had to seriously get into it.
    • 02:24:45
      But WMATA will operate the system as part of their system.
    • 02:24:51
      But the construction and the ownership will probably not be with WMATA.
    • Pierce R. HomerDeputy Secretary of Transportation
    • 02:24:58
      Chairman, if I could add a third component to that.
    • 02:25:02
      The special taxing districts, which is very similar to the VDOT 58 model, that is part of the PTTA proposal.
    • 02:25:11
      Those special tax districts work by petition.
    • 02:25:15
      Jerry, a good example is the Greenway.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:44
      which was financed privately.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:48
      I understand that.
    • 02:25:49
      I was just trying to figure out how this worked in the Dulles project because it's the first time for a PPTA rail project, right?
    • 02:25:59
      That's correct.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:25:59
      This is the first PPTA transit project.
    • 02:26:04
      Okay, thanks.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:05
      Okay, any other questions of Pierce?
    • 02:26:09
      Pierce, thank you.
    • 02:26:10
      Very good.
    • 02:26:11
      I'm sorry.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:13
      One thing it would be good to look into, and I plan on doing this, is the design-build concept, which is really an offshoot of the PPTA.
    • 02:26:24
      I know the General Assembly, I think, authorized, I think, five
    • 02:26:29
      per year or five in total, I can't remember.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:26:31
      Mr. Secretary, we're authorized to do five a year that are under $20 million and five at any one time.
    • 02:26:45
      You know, frankly, that process may be something we consider, which is probably more applicable to secondary concepts, and if we get some of those in there or not... Mr. Secretary, Hobie, the PPTA is really an offshoot of design-build in more ways.
    • 02:27:06
      Design-build, we have money.
    • 02:27:09
      If we have money,
    • 02:27:11
      We don't necessarily need PPPA unless we're looking for new money.
    • 02:27:16
      We have developed, actually we worked on for over a year developing a set of our own criteria for design-build guidelines.
    • 02:27:23
      The Federal Highway Administration has now come out with their final design-build guidelines.
    • 02:27:29
      We've built
    • 02:27:30
      One rest area, building another with differing opinions of its value.
    • 02:27:38
      But no, it's Harry and I. I'm familiar with that.
    • 02:27:42
      I'm new Kent.
    • 02:27:43
      So we'll have two rest areas.
    • 02:27:45
      They're using design-build.
    • 02:27:46
      We're putting a highway advisory radio system in under design-build, and we'll actively be using that process.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:27:55
      Well, I guess as an offshoot of that, as a design bill, some of the things that I had thought about is that using scheduled program money in conjunction with some other business concepts, CDAs.
    • 02:28:12
      or other commitments, maybe local participation in some of these things where they use money in conjunction with state money to fulfill maybe an insufficient funding in a program that the state might not be able to do.
    • 02:28:28
      And I can think of different projects around the state.
    • 02:28:31
      But that's sort of the concept of design build I was thinking of, which is really more PPPA than design build.
    • 02:28:39
      But I think that's sort of the design build concept I was thinking of.
    • 02:28:42
      I don't know if we have the ability to do that or not.
    • 02:28:46
      Maybe that's up for later discussion.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:28:48
      Mr. Chairman, I think the most important change or reform is moving 45 days to 90 days.
    • 02:29:02
      When the PPPA originally was submitted on Dulles
    • 02:29:08
      In those days, you had 45 days and nobody knew it was coming.
    • 02:29:14
      And so to get competition, another company had to really hustle.
    • 02:29:21
      And what ended up happening is the two companies got together and currently in what the PTTA is.
    • 02:29:29
      But the 45 days was, in my mind, sort of
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:29:35
      Okay, we've got two other items on the new business and I think they are before you.
    • 02:29:47
      We've got
    • 02:29:50
      Resolutions that have been offered up on the enhancement money.
    • 02:29:56
      One is from Charlottesville to transfer the enhancement funds that the CTB approved for a rugby road phase two project to transfer those funds to the historic Court Square enhancement project.
    • 02:30:15
      The second one is in Prince Edward County, moving $25,000 that had been approved by the CTB for pedestrian and bike trail over to the Virginia Heartland Regional Visitor Center and Transportation Heritage Museum, which is also in Prince Edward County.
    • 02:30:33
      Butch, you want to say something about your first proposal?
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:30:36
      Sure.
    • 02:30:36
      Yeah, this is part of what came from the request to look at enhancement projects in the localities.
    • 02:30:44
      When I met with the city manager in Charlottesville, I wanted to know why the phase two rugby road project approved in 1995 hadn't been used.
    • 02:30:56
      They were sitting there with $400,000 and he got sort of red in the face and said, well, we didn't take into consideration the relocation of utilities for that project and we're looking at something over $1.2 million to do the project.
    • 02:31:11
      And he said, quite frankly, with that kind of situation, we've got a problem.
    • 02:31:19
      The other one that has been under development for a while is both a joint city-county project.
    • 02:31:25
      Both the city and the county of Albemarle County have put money into it.
    • 02:31:30
      They needed an additional phase to complete it.
    • 02:31:33
      And my reaction was, why, if you have that money already allocated from 95,
    • 02:31:39
      Don't we move it over?
    • 02:31:41
      Go ahead and complete it so hopefully we can get both of these projects off of VDOT's books.
    • 02:31:47
      The City Council passed a resolution making that request.
    • 02:31:51
      It terminates the project that was approved in 1995.
    • 02:31:54
      moves the $400,000 over.
    • 02:31:56
      That is not sufficient money to complete the project, but the county and the city appear to have made significant progress on contributing the balance of the funds, which will complete that project.
    • 02:32:09
      I move its approval.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:10
      Second.
    • 02:32:13
      Okay.
    • 02:32:14
      Hunter, do you want to speak to yours?
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:32:16
      We're doing both.
    • 02:32:17
      Yes, just that I really don't know how this bike trail thing got going to start with, but it's just $25,000, and he's just so unrealistic, and so it really wasn't before my time, either.
    • 02:32:31
      You know, I was involved in county government a little bit at the time, but it... Well, maybe as chairman of the board, if I might.
    • 02:32:40
      Yeah.
    • SPEAKER_15
    • 02:32:41
      I didn't have anything to do with that.
    • 02:32:44
      But anyway, we couldn't do any of the money for the museum and it would be much better used there.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:32:52
      It's nice when you have a second look, isn't it Hunter?
    • 02:32:57
      Second look, yeah.
    • 02:32:59
      All right, Helen?
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:33:03
      Don't take this the wrong way, Butch, because I'm as fond of the city of Charlottesville as anyone here, but it just seems a little premature to me to be transferring that much money to a project when we're talking about looking at, taking a look at the overall process of the TEA and what we do with these projects that are outstanding and unfunded.
    • Karen J. RaeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:33:24
      So maybe if you could just speak to that.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:33:26
      I mean I know the district already has the allocation and maybe that's good enough justification to allow it to be moved.
    • John J. "Butch" Davies IIIMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:33:35
      Yeah, I guess from my perspective I viewed this as an allocation which was within that particular area of the Culver District.
    • 02:33:44
      Those funds were there and it was either have those funds that were to be used for the bike project
    • 02:33:52
      They had an alternative.
    • 02:33:54
      They could have gone in and done what was not a particularly good job of the project and requested approval of amended plans, which was not beneficial.
    • 02:34:05
      My reaction was we're sitting there with a very major project that needs completing, especially with the Lewis and Clark historic effort that's underway that's tied to Monticello and the entire Charlottesville environment.
    • 02:34:17
      The Court Square project is a part of all of that initiative that needs to get completed.
    • 02:34:23
      It seemed like moving this money over, getting that project completed, and they've gotten either two or three phases worth of funding for that project.
    • 02:34:32
      The emphasis was on getting a project completed that had fairly significant importance, not minimizing the bike trail issue and putting that one finally to closure was important.
    • 02:34:46
      The funds were there.
    • 02:34:48
      The people who within the Culpeper District who would have complaints or those others who are sitting there who could allocate
    • 02:34:55
      the $400,000 among other communities within the Culpeper District.
    • 02:35:02
      Quite frankly, in looking at it, the allocation had already been made to Charlottesville Albemarle and it appeared to be a wise investment of the funds given everything else going on in that community related to their historic and tourism initiatives.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:17
      Thank you.
    • 02:35:18
      Okay.
    • 02:35:18
      Yeah, Perry.
    • SPEAKER_16
    • 02:35:19
      I share the thought process, but I think your answer is very reasonable and would support it.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 02:35:25
      Okay, any other discussion?
    • 02:35:28
      Alright, let's see, we have motions?
    • 02:35:32
      Motions on both resolutions.
    • 02:35:34
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 02:35:36
      Aye.
    • 02:35:36
      Any opposed?
    • 02:35:37
      Alright, thank you.
    • 02:35:39
      Any other new business?
    • 02:35:41
      Let me, if there's none, let me just review briefly here the drill.
    • 02:35:47
      Looks like we're in recess until one o'clock.
    • 02:35:51
      Catherine, I think there are box lunches here in this room.
    • 02:35:54
      1.30, as you know, members of the House Appropriations and Senate Finance Committee have been invited to be here.
    • 02:36:02
      I don't know what the head count is.
    • 02:36:07
      I'm hoping that we'll have a number of them have an early morning meeting with the governor tomorrow morning on a budget briefing, so I think we'll have a fairly respectable group here.
    • 02:36:27
      Their staff has asked for us to lead the discussion or presentation on three issues.
    • 02:36:38
      Maintenance, which we're going to hear more about a month or two of one of our workshops.
    • 02:36:46
      Debt management, another very important issue that we're going to need to get up to speed with before we get into the next six-year plan.
    • 02:36:56
      And bridges, which we've already heard about last month.
    • 02:37:00
      I think the
    • 02:37:04
      I suspect that it will be a family free discussion which I think could be useful and productive and we may get off the agenda which again I think is fine but for them to get to know you and vice versa I think there's a real value in that when legislators over the last several years have scrutinized more and more closely
    • 02:37:29
      What VDOT has done, what the CTB has done, there is a bill in, for example, that calls for the appointment of members of the CTB by the General Assembly, by Congressional District.
    • 02:37:42
      And so I think there's just a lot of good that can come from this meeting.
    • 02:37:49
      It may be a big bust, I don't know, but I think it's a good, I think it's something we ought to try.
    • 02:37:54
      If we find that it is productive use of our time, maybe we can refine it and do a better job next time around and build some relationships.
    • 02:38:08
      We will finish up by four.
    • 02:38:10
      The Virginia Road and Transportation Builders Association has been very kind to offer refreshments at 4.30 at the Capitol Club, which is down, Dick, it's in James Center.
    • 02:38:24
      James Center, Dick Daugherty is here, very appreciative of his doing that.
    • 02:38:30
      And for those of you who are going to stay overnight, hopefully there will be an opportunity to have dinner either with each other or with the legislators.
    • 02:38:42
      Any questions or comments?
    • 02:38:46
      Okay.
    • 02:38:46
      Well, I want to thank Rick Walton, our lawyer, and Catherine Tracy again for making these meetings run as smoothly as they do.
    • 02:38:55
      And we will see you back here at one o'clock.