Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 11/21/2002
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   11/21/2002

Attachments
  • Minutes.pdf
  • TRANSPORTATION BOARD AWARDS CONTRACTS WORTH $35 MILLION.pdf
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:00
      Good morning.
    • 00:00:10
      Thank you everyone for being here.
    • 00:00:12
      I think that we have everyone who is going to be here, although let's see.
    • 00:00:19
      Jim is here.
    • 00:00:33
      We will follow the agenda.
    • 00:00:35
      I'm going to, in a public comment period, I understand we have at least one individual who wishes to address the board with a fine.
    • 00:00:47
      All I'm going to request is, let me say that the CTB adopted a number of years ago a policy on public comment and I have
    • 00:01:02
      Sort of taking it upon myself to suspend that policy while it's under review in hopes of improving it.
    • 00:01:10
      But I do very much want, so that we can stay on schedule, abide by a five-minute limitation.
    • 00:01:18
      And then we will be happy to
    • 00:01:22
      If we can, we'd be happy to provide some direction to any of the individuals speaking as to how we or VDOT or DRPT can follow up with them for any particular individual assistance.
    • Ambrose W. BaileyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:42
      The first I would like is to...
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:49
      I recognize our commissioner, Phillip Shucet, on just a few comments from the story that appeared in the Richmond paper today.
    • 00:01:59
      I don't know if our reporter is here today.
    • 00:02:03
      We will make sure that he is advised of perhaps a more accurate portrayal of the bridge fund.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:17
      I was trying to keep it a secret that we had 200 million dollars.
    • 00:02:21
      No, quite seriously, quite seriously, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 00:02:31
      The point of yesterday's discussion, which I believe you understand, is not
    • 00:02:41
      It is not that we had $200 million that we did not spend.
    • 00:02:48
      It is not that we had $200 million that somehow we had to return to the Federal Highway Administration.
    • 00:02:59
      In fact, we have continually spent and obligated all of our federal funds.
    • 00:03:10
      The issue is could we have paid more attention to bridges than we have in the past?
    • 00:03:23
      The answer to that is yes.
    • 00:03:29
      Back in the mid-90s, apparently,
    • 00:03:34
      Back in the mid-90s, there was an informal policy adopted by VDOT that said that bridge funds could only be used for construction.
    • 00:03:56
      Not for preliminary engineering, not for right of way, not for environmental studies, but only for construction.
    • 00:04:08
      That was at a time in the mid 90's when our federal program was about 35% of our total program.
    • 00:04:22
      The idea, I can only assume at the time, was that we should use state dollars for those upfront activities as opposed to our federal dollars.
    • 00:04:39
      Now, since about 2000, our federal funds comprise about 60% of our program.
    • 00:04:50
      We believe we should change that informal policy that apparently was either never revisited or perhaps was revisited and no one chose to do anything about it.
    • 00:05:04
      We believe that policy needs to be revisited.
    • 00:05:08
      We need to make localities aware that federal bridge funds can be used for PE, for environmental,
    • 00:05:17
      for right-of-way activities as well as for construction of immediate approaches to new bridges.
    • 00:05:24
      And we believe that we should develop and adopt a policy that concentrates more of our emphasis on the bridge program.
    • 00:05:41
      We believe that's a matter of good transportation policy, but we are not sitting on a gold mine.
    • 00:05:49
      We don't have a bag with a penny in it, let alone $200 million, and we have not lost any federal funds whatsoever.
    • 00:06:03
      From a national point of view, we do pretty darn well with our bridges, better than average.
    • 00:06:10
      The average nationwide, there's about 27% of the nation's bridges are either structurally deficient or functionally obsolete.
    • 00:06:22
      We're at about 23% in Virginia.
    • 00:06:26
      North Carolina is at about 34%, West Virginia is about 38%, Maryland is about 29%.
    • 00:06:36
      The fact that we're doing pretty well does not diminish from our belief that as a matter of policy we should be concentrating more than we currently are the use of our federal funds on our bridges.
    • 00:06:55
      I'd be happy to address any questions.
    • 00:06:58
      Mount Curley is here who, before he became chief engineer for program development, was our state bridge and structures engineer.
    • 00:07:09
      This is a matter that has been dear to his heart for a long time.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:16
      Comment more than a question.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:23
      Just looking forward as to how you get ahead of the curve and the decline in bridges.
    • 00:07:30
      I know that it's been brought to our attention in our Hampton Roads area that there's no distinction made between maintenance funds used for bridges and roads and that the bridges are so much more expensive to maintain.
    • 00:07:43
      And I wonder if there's any way to maybe change that policy.
    • 00:07:48
      I assume that would be legislative.
    • 00:07:50
      I don't know, but in Chesapeake, for instance, they say they have to use virtually all their maintenance funds on the bridges, and there's virtually nothing left for roads.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:59
      That's not legislative.
    • 00:08:01
      That's an outfall of this policy from the past.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:06
      So the federal bridge money could be used for maintenance as well as construction?
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:08:14
      It could, but the issue is that in order to address, because federal funds were primarily being used in construction, we have in some cases left folks with no choice but to use maintenance funds
    • 00:08:36
      for bridge repair work that honestly is more, which should be properly classified as construction.
    • 00:08:49
      But now localities have a role to play in this as well.
    • 00:08:54
      Because in our secondary program, people have to make a conscious choice on how they are using their funds.
    • 00:09:03
      And bridges
    • 00:09:06
      sometimes don't float to the top of that list in the fashion that they should.
    • 00:09:12
      You know, work on many bridges is work that's not real glamorous.
    • 00:09:18
      It's not work that you see.
    • 00:09:24
      So I don't believe legislation is required to change that.
    • 00:09:28
      I think that's more of a policy issue and a matter of how we
    • 00:09:34
      work and help make the local governments aware, which I believe Barbara mentioned yesterday, of the fact that they can use this money for preliminary engineering right of way and environmental work.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:48
      Yes, Kenny?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:09:51
      When I chaired the Governor's Commission on Transportation Policy, one of the subjects that came up
    • 00:09:57
      We spent quite a bit of time on was this bridge definition between maintenance and construction.
    • 00:10:05
      And in conversations with the people at VDOT at that time, there was no definitive definition.
    • 00:10:14
      And from a practical matter, I'm not sure that you could have a definitive, this is construction, this is maintenance.
    • 00:10:26
      Gather from what you're saying, Phillip, that you're going to try to make some reality out of this whole thing?
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:35
      Absolutely, Mr. Chairman and Mr. Kline.
    • 00:10:39
      The pencil can certainly be sharpened more than it has in the past.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:46
      Okay, Jim?
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:10:48
      In answer to Helen's question, you talked about the locality getting involved in establishing priorities in secondary systems.
    • 00:10:58
      Is that the only place that they're involved in the allocation of priorities?
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:05
      I was just speaking specifically to the secondary road plan.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:11:08
      But they also are involved in establishing priorities for the primaries, too?
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:13
      Yes, sir.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:11:14
      Thank you.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:16
      Okay, any others?
    • 00:11:17
      All right, Philip, thank you for that explanation.
    • 00:11:24
      Okay, under the public comment section, is Mr. Michael Robinson here, mayor from Kilmonic?
    • 00:11:35
      All right, next on the agenda is, under public comment, is Mary Hyde Berg, resident of Gloucester County.
    • 00:11:44
      Good morning.
    • 00:11:45
      We're glad to have you here and again ask you if you could confine your remarks to five minutes.
    • SPEAKER_13
    • 00:11:52
      I will certainly make an effort to do that.
    • 00:11:54
      How's the sound level?
    • 00:11:57
      Mr. Secretary, members of the Transportation Board, I appreciate your taking your time for me and I thank you for this opportunity to seek your help.
    • 00:12:09
      You have a packet with more detail than you would be able to hear in five minutes, which would be out of character with the things that you've been dealing with here on my personal and local problem, for which I hope to have resolution.
    • 00:12:25
      This problem has been going on for years, and I don't expect it will get solved today.
    • 00:12:29
      But in a larger public policy arena, which is your stated area of concern,
    • 00:12:40
      I see that the current treatment of roads' edges, certainly in Gloucester County and probably other places, with respect to ditching and mowing, needs to be examined.
    • 00:12:55
      Our local folks do a very good job on pavement.
    • 00:13:00
      Gloucester may be one of the few places in the state where you see a hole in the road on your way to work and it's fixed when you come home.
    • 00:13:10
      Roadside edges may not seem important, but we are at a time when we've looked at the money that's brought in wheelbarrows thrown out with a tablespoon.
    • 00:13:19
      And I think that we could do these treatments to reduce costs, to reduce environmental damage, and reduce destruction of roadside beauty.
    • 00:13:30
      and mowing and ditching are the things I'm mainly concerned with.
    • 00:13:34
      I know you've heard enough from Scenic Virginia about cutting of hardwood and sides and I could say something about that too but I don't think I need it on that.
    • 00:13:46
      My two main points are that I feel that complaints about the road edge by one individual should be investigated before the work is done.
    • 00:13:57
      My situation has been that a neighbor that wants to get at me has complained about roadside and cutting or mowing or ditching has been done that had no basis in need.
    • 00:14:09
      It was a clear grudge call.
    • 00:14:12
      And, you know, you can put back this or the other, but you can't put back vegetation.
    • 00:14:18
      And work is being done that is unneeded.
    • 00:14:21
      And we also see that work is being done that is unfocused.
    • 00:14:26
      and I see a lot of places where I know perfectly well people don't complain about something because they know that the VDOT crew will simply come in and make a worse mess without solving the thing that was there.
    • 00:14:39
      I really would like very much to be given the proper ear or committee to share my feelings and pictures and walking to us with on this, if you can make this possible.
    • 00:14:56
      Since this doesn't seem to be your main concern, I won't talk about the criminal trespass that the local Gloucester office carried out against me on the 12th of September.
    • 00:15:08
      and the logs and load of mulch they took from me, which I figure went to landfill, or the almost $900 of accounted costs to the taxpayer for this unneeded operation.
    • 00:15:22
      But you all have given me a lot of good advice already and I look forward to having some guidance in where I need to go with this because I think it needs to be resolved for me, for my property, for the beautiful road that I share with my neighbors,
    • 00:15:38
      and for the waste of costs here.
    • 00:15:44
      Thank you very much.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:46
      Thank you, Ms. Burke.
    • 00:15:47
      Let me suggest that you, and I know that he will be willing to do so, if you would meet with Mr. Frank G. of VDOT, that is clearly a VDOT policy and
    • 00:16:02
      We appreciate you bringing it to our attention.
    • 00:16:04
      I thank you for the letter and the material you sent me.
    • 00:16:08
      And if you would meet with Mr. G., I think that's the proper person, appropriate person for you to express yourself and get clarification on what the VDOT rules are or your suggestions on what they should be.
    • 00:16:26
      And there he is, okay?
    • 00:16:29
      I like the dating game, okay.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:32
      Anybody else?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:41
      Okay, next item.
    • 00:16:42
      Approval of the minutes of October 16.
    • 00:16:45
      So moved.
    • 00:16:46
      Second.
    • 00:16:47
      Been moved and seconded that we approve of the minutes.
    • 00:16:52
      If there's discussion, all in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:16:56
      Aye.
    • 00:16:56
      Any opposed?
    • 00:16:57
      Third item, there are no committee reports.
    • 00:17:00
      We do have our
    • 00:17:02
      Multimodal Long Range Transportation Planning Committee chaired by Judy Connally and that of course involves five others of you.
    • 00:17:16
      Judy, for the benefit of the whole board, why don't we just bring everybody up to speed.
    • 00:17:22
      Just say, I know you and I haven't talked about this, but just on when you're going to meet, may I ask a word about your technical committee?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:17:31
      We had our initial organizing meeting yesterday at 10 o'clock in this room, and we were delighted to have, in addition to the members of the CTB representing, also the director of rail and transit and the commissioner, highway commissioner, but also the representative, John Milliken, who's chairman of the seaports.
    • 00:17:56
      and also a board member of the airport authority and as well as their executive directors and it was I think a very good meeting to start with.
    • 00:18:07
      I think organizational meetings frequently are just a certain amount of busy work that has to be done but we were presented
    • 00:18:18
      At least I tried to present the commission with a mission statement and we are setting up our work plan.
    • 00:18:29
      Our real business will begin in January.
    • 00:18:32
      We hope to meet every two months, or January meaning to
    • 00:18:35
      will entail looking at our detailed work plan for the next two to three years.
    • 00:18:42
      We're trying to accelerate things at the request of our members and also the Secretary to move ahead on this planning effort.
    • 00:18:52
      We are supported by a very excellent group of people called the Technical Committee and that will be chaired by Mary Lynn
    • 00:19:02
      Tischer, and we are very Tischer.
    • 00:19:05
      I always make that mistake.
    • 00:19:07
      And she has had experience in leading an effort similar to this in Arizona and has also deep experience here in Virginia.
    • 00:19:16
      So I think we will be moving ahead.
    • 00:19:19
      What I would like to ask is any member of the CTB who has some
    • 00:19:26
      Interests, visions, ideas, local experts, or anybody that you would like to put us in contact with that might help provide us with important information and ideas about how to proceed in looking
    • 00:19:44
      at what we think the transportation system in Virginia should be like in 2025.
    • 00:19:49
      This is an awesome task, but it is one that I think is doable, and it certainly is an interesting one.
    • 00:19:59
      But we want to keep the whole board informed, and we will be keeping you informed at these meetings, and also if anything particularly interesting comes up in the interim.
    • 00:20:12
      But Mary Lynn is
    • 00:20:14
      open to all kinds of suggestions, not saying she does not have a work plan in mind, but we will be moving as quickly as possible to set up our goals and objectives and for the
    • 00:20:31
      J. Doolittle, John J. Doolittle
    • 00:20:50
      Collaboration, but it was very constructive, I think, to have all those people around the table for the first time.
    • 00:20:58
      And everyone, I think, was quite optimistic that we can change the way business is done, to some extent, and set a more
    • 00:21:08
      All right, thank you, Judy.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:13
      Sorry not to clear that with you ahead of time, but thank you for that update.
    • 00:21:18
      And as you know, that was presented, the multimodal work to date was presented in Lexington, and the CTB will be acting on reports along the way from the various phases of that work.
    • 00:21:39
      The end of December will represent six months of the new fiscal year and we'll try to get a finance committee put together to review some of the data in the first six months.
    • 00:21:51
      But that is, I'm yet to form that.
    • 00:21:56
      I purposely tried to bring everything before the whole board so we can all sort of get up to speed and have a certain comfort level before we
    • 00:22:05
      Delegate more detail to committees and the second committee will be a finance committee.
    • 00:22:14
      Next on the agenda from our local financial assistance division, James Givens.
    • 00:22:20
      Jim.
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:22:23
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:22:25
      The next item on the agenda is the report of additions to the secondary system for the month.
    • 00:22:31
      You'll note that there's been a net addition of 21.26 miles added to the secondary system.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:42
      Move for approval.
    • 00:22:47
      Seconded that we approve those additions and abandonments.
    • 00:22:55
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:22:56
      Aye.
    • 00:22:57
      Any opposed?
    • 00:22:58
      Aye.
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:22:59
      The next item, Mr. Chairman, are two discontinuances of sections of secondary roads, one on Route 783 in Lee County, another on Route 1079 in Henry County,
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:23:22
      Then moved and seconded that we act on the discontinuances.
    • 00:23:28
      Any discussion?
    • 00:23:30
      All in favor please say aye.
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:23:32
      Aye.
    • 00:23:32
      Any opposed?
    • 00:23:35
      And then the next item I have, Mr. Chairman, is four resolutions for additions, street additions, in the town of Bluefield, two-tenths of a mile, town of Grottoes, 28 one-hundredths of a mile, in the city of Hampton,
    • 00:23:57
      1.22 miles of arterials and 1.77 miles of local streets and in the town of Warrenton 59 one-hundredths miles of local streets.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:13
      Okay and again those proposed resolutions that would act on the street mileage
    • 00:24:20
      Additions, payments are set forth under that tab 6.
    • 00:24:26
      Do we have a motion?
    • 00:24:29
      So moved.
    • 00:24:29
      Been moved and seconded.
    • 00:24:30
      Any discussion?
    • 00:24:32
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:24:33
      Aye.
    • 00:24:34
      Any opposed?
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:24:34
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:24:36
      Thank you, Jim.
    • 00:24:38
      Next, Ms. Kastenhoffer, Mobility Management Division.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:24:43
      Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 00:24:45
      Item 7 includes two abandonment requests for the primary system.
    • 00:24:51
      7A is for RAT 33 in King and Queen counties as a result of reconstruction and abandonment of one section of old RAT 33 became necessary.
    • 00:25:03
      7B relates to RAT 522 in Louisa County where 522 has been reconstructed and that resulted the need for abandonment of 19 sections of old RAT 522.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:25:18
      Move for approval.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:23
      Second.
    • 00:25:23
      Moved and seconded.
    • 00:25:25
      Any discussion on the proposed resolution?
    • 00:25:29
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:25:31
      Aye.
    • 00:25:31
      Any opposed?
    • 00:25:32
      Thank you.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:25:34
      Item 8.
    • 00:25:34
      Item 8 relates to RAT 460 in Buchanan County where as a result of reconstruction one section of old RAT 460 needs to be abandoned and one section of old RAT 460 needs to be discontinued.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:54
      Okay.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:56
      Move for approval.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:25:58
      Seconded.
    • 00:25:59
      Seconded.
    • 00:25:59
      We adopt the proposed resolution on the abandonment discontinuance of that project in Buchanan County.
    • 00:26:05
      Any discussion?
    • 00:26:07
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:26:09
      Aye.
    • 00:26:09
      Any opposed?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:26:11
      Item 9 relates to a bridge designation in Scott County.
    • 00:26:16
      The Scott County Board of Supervisors adopted a resolution requesting that the Commonwealth Transportation Board name the new bridge on Route 613 near Route 688 over Big Moccasin Creek in Scott County as the Lindsay Ferguson Memorial Bridge.
    • 00:26:34
      Mr. Ferguson served in the U.S. Army during World War II.
    • 00:26:37
      and the County Board of Supervisors requested to name this bridge on Route 613 to be named in the honor of Lindsay Ferguson who was a very well appreciated member of the community in Scott County.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:26:55
      Move the adoption of that resolution.
    • 00:26:58
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:26:58
      Then moved and seconded.
    • 00:27:00
      Any discussion on the proposed resolution?
    • 00:27:03
      All in favor, we say aye.
    • 00:27:05
      Aye.
    • 00:27:06
      Any opposed?
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:27:07
      Thank you.
    • 00:27:07
      Thank you.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:09
      Right of way in Utilities Division, Arthur Taylor.
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:27:14
      Mr. Chairman, members of the board, good morning.
    • 00:27:16
      We have ten items before you this morning.
    • 00:27:19
      All of them are considered routine actions, either going to the adjacent landowner or the underlying fee owner.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:25
      And in one case, we have one that's capable of independent development and will be offered at public sale.
    • 00:27:30
      We recommend approval as presented.
    • Ambrose W. BaileyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:34
      Move to approve of all ten.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:36
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:27:36
      All right, be moved and seconded.
    • 00:27:40
      Any discussion on those apostles of property to be declared a surplus and the disposition thereof?
    • 00:27:51
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:27:52
      Aye.
    • 00:27:53
      Any opposed?
    • 00:27:54
      Thank you.
    • 00:27:54
      Thank you, Mr. Taylor.
    • 00:27:57
      Construction Division, Mal Kerley.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:28:02
      Good morning.
    • 00:28:03
      I've got 24 projects that I'm requesting your approval.
    • 00:28:10
      We had 21 that were below the engineer's estimate, one that was within the engineer's estimate, and two that are above the seven percent that I'm requesting that you approve.
    • 00:28:21
      On page one, the first one on that page, W01, was one of the ones that was above our seven percent estimate.
    • 00:28:30
      When we analyzed the bids, we found out that there was a mistake made that we didn't transfer over to the final engineer's estimate, the lead containment requirements of painting.
    • 00:28:45
      Therefore, when we did that, the estimate was slightly below the engineer's estimate.
    • 00:28:51
      We had eight bids on this project, and the lowest bidder was about 30% below the second bidder.
    • 00:28:58
      So we felt it would not be beneficial to rebid this.
    • 00:29:01
      I'm requesting that you award that.
    • 00:29:06
      There's really not too much
    • 00:29:11
      Out of the ordinary, I will point out on page two, based on the conversations recently, on item one and item number two, there's two bridges that are being replaced.
    • 00:29:21
      There was a sufficiency rating of 25.6 on A96, and on A97, 32.9.
    • 00:29:28
      Those are in the Stanton District.
    • 00:29:32
      On page
    • 00:29:33
      III, item number five, the first one at the top, that's the second one that was over our seven percent estimate.
    • 00:29:44
      Upon looking at that, we found out that the
    • 00:29:48
      We had called for some generic signal poles and cantilever arms that were a little bit heavier than the standard poles.
    • 00:29:55
      There is also, it's listed in the Hampton Roads District, but there are some work in the Fredericksburg District there.
    • 00:30:02
      So we reanalyzed the bids after, our estimate after the bids came in, it was fairly close to the engineer's estimate.
    • 00:30:11
      The three lowest bidders were within about 6% of each other, so we're recommending that you award that particular item also.
    • 00:30:21
      Going on down, if you notice on page 5, page 5 was one that was within the engineer's estimate, that was about 5% above the engineer's estimate, and we felt after looking at it that it was a good bid and we would award that particular.
    • 00:30:37
      On page six, item number six on that contract is another bridge replacement.
    • 00:30:45
      That sufficiency rating for that particular bridge was 39.1.
    • 00:30:48
      That's located in Bristol.
    • 00:30:53
      If you go to page number nine, number nine, this particular miscellaneous project, earlier we had made a mistake that that would be maintenance funded, which would not require board approval, but it is being funded through construction dollars, which requires your approval, that's why that's added on it.
    • 00:31:16
      On page 10, 11, and 12, those are three enhancement projects.
    • 00:31:22
      There's been discussions recently on the enhancement.
    • 00:31:24
      These are ones that have been approved by earlier boards.
    • 00:31:29
      Pages 13, 14, 15, and 16 are all administrative services division contracts.
    • 00:31:44
      These deal with emergency type operations.
    • 00:31:48
      They're all located in our Stanton District to address sinkholes and emergency type items like there.
    • 00:31:58
      It's something that the District Construction Engineer has requested for several
    • 00:32:02
      For some time, and we finally worked out to have a contract to allow him to bring emergency equipment if we do have a sinkhole in the interstate in those areas.
    • 00:32:11
      If you look at the dollar amounts through there, they seem to vary a little bit in that because there's a high probability of risk associated with the contractor on this particular one.
    • 00:32:23
      The other thing you'll notice in there, we only had one bid for each of those, and that's the same.
    • 00:32:30
      It's a very local issue, and there is high probability for risk in there, so some people don't want to get in that particular business.
    • 00:32:41
      Page 17, 18, 19, and 20 are also enhancement projects that previous boards have approved.
    • 00:32:51
      I'm requesting your approval of all of the projects this month.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:01
      Now, until we got down to the Stanton District sinkholes, I was amazed at the number of bids we're getting on all these contracts.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:33:14
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:33:14
      What we're doing is we're tracking that right now and let's see if I can find it here.
    • 00:33:22
      We are getting very good competitive bids.
    • 00:33:25
      This month, if you looked at our, if you took all the projects we had and added up all the engineer's estimate and all our bids, we're about 15% below dollar amount.
    • 00:33:37
      And I think, I've got it here somewhere, I think that's about $6 million.
    • 00:33:43
      Here it is.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:33:44
      I know that a couple years ago we were maybe getting two or three bids on a project.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:33:51
      We are getting very competitive bids from the industry now, yes sir.
    • 00:33:57
      A lot of the projects we have about, especially on some of those traffic signalization, everybody in the business is bidding.
    • 00:34:06
      It's very competitive.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:09
      Okay, any, do you have a motion?
    • 00:34:14
      I've been seconded.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:16
      I didn't hear either, sorry.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:18
      Been moved and seconded that we accept these recommendations, all of which are awards.
    • 00:34:24
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:34:26
      Any further discussion?
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:34:28
      Mr. Chairman, one question.
    • Ambrose W. BaileyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:34:30
      It may be just slow learning, catching on as you've been teaching us through this period of time, but it requires more approval for the contract to be awarded.
    • SPEAKER_17
    • 00:34:45
      Why does it require board approval if in fact there's additional money spent beyond the contract?
    • 00:34:52
      If there's change, which I can understand if there's a change, but if it goes over the bid amount, does that amount ever come back to you?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:35:00
      That doesn't require, for instance, if you award a contract today and there's a work order on that contract, it does not require us to come back to the board for you to approve that work order.
    • 00:35:12
      Why is that?
    • 00:35:15
      The code requires you to approve the contract.
    • 00:35:20
      I don't think the code says anything about work orders.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:35:25
      Frank, you want to answer that?
    • 00:35:29
      Mr.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 00:35:31
      Keen, Mr. Kerley is correct.
    • 00:35:33
      The 33.1-12 gives certain duties and authority to come with transportation board.
    • 00:35:39
      One of those requirements is the award of all construction contracts and all maintenance contracts over $250,000.
    • 00:35:45
      Any additional cost of that, though, does not require any action for the board legislatively.
    • 00:35:50
      That's why we do not bring anything back to the board.
    • 00:35:53
      We do report to you those overruns and that's why the reporting process is in there.
    • 00:36:00
      It does not require board action.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:03
      But it doesn't preclude it either, does it?
    • 00:36:06
      I'm hoping we're making big improvements here, but we've had work orders as large as the original awards, and those are important in some cases.
    • 00:36:19
      I guess my question is, could we, if we wanted to get into that business, assuming we raised the threshold, because $250,000 is kind of low, is there any interest in pursuing that, I guess?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:36:32
      Well, let's get the motion acted on.
    • 00:36:36
      Any further discussion on the motion?
    • 00:36:38
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:36:40
      Aye.
    • 00:36:40
      Opposed?
    • 00:36:42
      Let me respond to Jerry this way, and I was going to bring it up, but even if you hadn't raised it, it seems to me, and you're welcome to differ, that we don't need to be getting into a lot of these, because I just think that they're, you know,
    • 00:37:06
      More important policy issues for the board.
    • 00:37:11
      We are floating the idea of amending that legislation to up the amounts that Jerry would not require our approval to two million dollars.
    • 00:37:26
      Now, right for both maintenance, which is now $250,000, and that's been the law since 1995, and going from $0 to $2 million on construction.
    • 00:37:39
      Now, that wipes out this entire 19-some pages, because as I looked at it, nothing's over $2 million.
    • 00:37:46
      Now, we picked two million because I don't know if Barbara Connie Sorrell, I believe, prepared it, did an analysis, and that wipes out, as I recall, something like 80% of the projects.
    • 00:38:01
      I personally think that's an authority that I personally be willing for the CTB to accede to the commissioner to sign those contracts.
    • 00:38:15
      But at the same time, Jerry, that doesn't mean that we can't ask and expect from the Commissioner whatever reports that we want, whether it be this, just for information, or cost overruns, work order changes.
    • 00:38:35
      If any of you differ with that, you know, speak up.
    • 00:38:43
      That's the way I feel about it and I think Phillip is of the same mind and it obviously puts a tremendous accountability on whoever the commissioner is.
    • 00:38:52
      And I think that's a step in the right direction.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:38:56
      But I support that.
    • 00:38:59
      I mean, we can't micromanage these things.
    • 00:39:01
      And the commission will know far better.
    • 00:39:04
      This is a sort of a formality we're going through.
    • 00:39:06
      But I guess if we have one specific project that we're really concerned about, we can jump in there.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:11
      Well, I think if that line is pursued and the legislation is changed, the General Assembly gives the commission of that authority, then I think that will then raise the issue of what kind of information do we want?
    • 00:39:26
      What format and what points along the way?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:39:29
      May I make a suggestion?
    • 00:39:30
      Yeah, okay.
    • 00:39:31
      In fact, the commission recommended that we do exactly what you're talking about.
    • 00:39:38
      Very good.
    • 00:39:39
      I think, though, the concern is
    • 00:39:42
      and I for one have it because when I joined this board in 1998, the first meeting
    • 00:39:49
      was a workshop.
    • 00:39:51
      The workshop was about the Springfield Interchange.
    • 00:39:55
      Some of you all may have heard about that project.
    • 00:39:58
      At the time, I was told that the cost of that interchange was $350 million.
    • 00:40:04
      And I suggested that that number was at least fallacious.
    • 00:40:10
      And I think I've been proven to be right, because the cost is now near $700 million.
    • 00:40:17
      That's what we need to watch out for.
    • 00:40:21
      I mean, a million dollar or two million dollar contract is not something we should worry about.
    • 00:40:27
      But if that two million dollar contract gets to be a ten million dollar contract, there has to be a notification system for this board.
    • 00:40:35
      Because we have a fiduciary responsibility.
    • 00:40:38
      And I guess, I don't know that it needs to be codified, but as a matter of policy,
    • 00:40:45
      I think that would be a way to solve the problem.
    • 00:40:48
      When something gets out of hand, you've got to let us know.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:51
      Well, that's the kind of thing we would need to, that's the type of policy we would need to adopt.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:40:58
      Mr. Chairman?
    • 00:41:01
      Yeah.
    • 00:41:02
      I'd like to make a comment on the regard that Mr. Clean just made.
    • 00:41:06
      I believe a policy, a reasonable policy to that effect is proven.
    • 00:41:17
      As I think of sitting here as a member of the board of directors, the issue with a $2 million project that becomes a $10 million project for this board, in my opinion, is more of an issue of
    • 00:41:34
      Why do we have this person as commissioner as opposed to what happened to that project?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:40
      We didn't want to say that.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:41:44
      Well, I firmly believe that.
    • 00:41:49
      And I think a reasonable business reporting requirement with the understanding that there are certainly
    • 00:41:57
      significant issues that might need to be discussed from time to time is a right step in putting the accountability on the department where it belongs without abdicating your all's fiduciary responsibility or accountability as a Transportation Board of Directors.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:42:22
      Okay, Phil?
    • 00:42:23
      I like your suggestion and I hope you look at it even more broadly because the takes and the abandonments that we get are also kind of boilerplate for us and it seems to me that we've been off if we can simply be assured that we have a kind of a dashboard approach to all those things that is that we get reports from those items that we would surrender responsibility for
    • 00:42:48
      When they hit certain marks, we got a toxic dump in the abandonment or take cases and stuff like that.
    • 00:42:57
      Anything we really ought to know, we could identify some criteria.
    • 00:43:00
      Otherwise, they ought to just be done.
    • 00:43:02
      And if we can't get that, maybe do a consent agenda or something that would at least make them easy to dispose of.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:08
      That's a good suggestion.
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 00:43:10
      I think that's a very good suggestion that Phillip made.
    • 00:43:15
      There's so many of these things that, you know, I say this, I haven't been here for six months, but they're basically boiler plates.
    • 00:43:23
      And if there was a consent agenda, it would save a lot of staff time as well.
    • 00:43:28
      With any board member having the ability to pull something off, there was a need to discuss it.
    • 00:43:36
      It would save a lot of time and enable the board to do the kinds of things that Jan and the commission were talking about.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:43
      Which might, for informational purposes, have the list of the contracts being awarded for the month.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:43:56
      You have the same material prepared, just not have to act on it.
    • 00:43:59
      Okay, any other comments?
    • 00:44:04
      Okay.
    • 00:44:05
      Mal, thank you.
    • 00:44:08
      Next is Barbara Reese.
    • 00:44:14
      Good morning.
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 00:44:18
      This is one of your duties that is probably not that important, but a key operational issue for us, and this agenda item number 12 relates to the toll-free passage on state-owned and operated toll facilities.
    • 00:44:32
      We are bringing this resolution to you because in the Code of Virginia is a requirement that the Board adopt rules and regulations around the free passage of toll rules.
    • 00:44:44
      If you look on page two of your resolution, you see the list of personnel who are eligible to use a state-owned toll facility for free, including yourself.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:44:53
      On official business, thank you Mr. Walton.
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 00:45:04
      The issue has become we have over 3,000 of these literally paper little ID cards that we administer and send out to people who are allowed free passage.
    • 00:45:15
      It is an administrative burden on the department and because now all of us have to have identification badges with our photo IDs on it and every one of these state agencies we are recommending to the board that you allow us to use the definition of toll-free
    • 00:45:32
      White, Onzlee Ware
    • 00:45:48
      She uses our toll facilities for free.
    • 00:45:50
      This will give us the rules and regulations in place to get a better handle on these and also eliminate the administrative burden.
    • 00:45:57
      Catherine Tracy had that administrative burden for a while and she can tell you what a nightmare it is and I do hope you will, I recommend you adopt the resolution.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:07
      Move the adoption of it.
    • 00:46:09
      I'll make a comment.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:10
      It's been moved.
    • 00:46:11
      Do you have a second?
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:13
      Second.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:13
      It's been moved and seconded.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:15
      Kenny Klean.
    • 00:46:16
      Not only do you get the little white pass, which I think I've destroyed every one and a half years, but you do get a smart tag, which means you don't have to stop and hand them the thing.
    • 00:46:30
      You just go through the gate.
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 00:46:32
      Correct.
    • 00:46:33
      We do allow people to get non-revenue smart tags.
    • 00:46:36
      They can apply for that.
    • 00:46:37
      If we find out they're a frequent user of a toll facility, they can get that non-revenue smart tag.
    • 00:46:42
      So this just allows two options that eliminates the administrative burden.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:46:47
      Well, I mean, it's the same type of thing.
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 00:46:51
      It's supposed to be for official business only.
    • 00:46:53
      The agency head has to basically sign on the dotted line.
    • 00:46:57
      If, because smart tags have an individual record each time you use your smart tag, they could actually look and see why is this employee using the Dulles Toll Road on Saturday at 2 p.m. when he wasn't working.
    • 00:47:13
      So that's actually a better control.
    • 00:47:15
      But we cannot require them to use those, and plus they do have a cost.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:19
      Mr. Chairman, except for like trucks and sheriffs' vehicles and people who are obviously on official business, I just don't understand why this cannot be done on a reimbursement basis once a month when they file their expenses and not have to go through all this stuff.
    • 00:47:42
      I mean, it's two or three pages of guidelines and all the rest of it, and I just think it's overkill.
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 00:47:49
      Don't disagree with you, but it's in the Code of Virginia and we're required to do it.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:47:53
      Well, we're not required to do it this way.
    • 00:47:55
      I mean, you have a lot of flexibility.
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 00:47:57
      We have to offer free passage and you have to have a toll pass.
    • 00:48:02
      We have to offer that.
    • 00:48:04
      by the Code of Virginia, unfortunately.
    • 00:48:07
      We don't have the ability, I mean, I get, like you said, I get reimbursed for my, when I pay a toll, but we cannot require that of an employee under the Code.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:21
      The cost of the reimbursement would far exceed the cost of giving them the free toll.
    • 00:48:26
      I think let's just vote on it and move on.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:31
      Put it in your reform legislation, will you?
    • 00:48:33
      Yeah.
    • 00:48:34
      No, they might add to the list.
    • 00:48:36
      Any other discussion?
    • 00:48:41
      All in favor of the motion, please say aye.
    • 00:48:43
      Aye.
    • 00:48:43
      Any opposed?
    • 00:48:46
      No.
    • 00:48:46
      That's a record note, aye.
    • 00:48:48
      Thank you.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:48
      Thank you, Bob.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:48:51
      From Rail and Public Transportation, Kevin Page on rail industrial access projects.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 00:48:58
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:48:59
      Good morning, everyone.
    • 00:49:00
      Ms. Rae asked, this is the second and third project we've had with the new board.
    • 00:49:04
      But the first project, I think, was at your first meeting.
    • 00:49:07
      So now that you all have had your feet on the ground for a while, she asked that I just give you a little 10-second sound bite about the program and answer any questions, if there are any, before we go to the action items.
    • 00:49:17
      The Rail Industrial Access Program was created back when DRPT was part of VDOT back in 1986.
    • 00:49:22
      It was codified under 331221.1 of the Code of Virginia.
    • 00:49:28
      Since its inception, we've done 151 projects all over Virginia.
    • 00:49:32
      It's been a very successful economic development tool, not only for attracting and helping businesses grow in Virginia, but also to alleviate or eliminate some truck volumes off of the highway.
    • 00:49:44
      We do have a scoring criteria program as part of our application process, where we look for a return on investment for state dollars, and I'll get into that in just a minute on one of our action items.
    • 00:49:55
      We are coordinated on all of our projects with the Virginia Economic Development Partnership and with VDOT.
    • 00:50:02
      I'd like to thank, at a Barbara Reese's shop, Jim Gibbons and Hugh Adams.
    • 00:50:07
      They manage our program funds for us.
    • 00:50:10
      So, on to our action items if there aren't any questions.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:15
      Any questions?
    • 00:50:18
      All right, now a motion for both of these projects.
    • 00:50:23
      So moved.
    • 00:50:23
      Been moved and seconded.
    • 00:50:26
      Any discussion?
    • 00:50:29
      All right, all in favor of the proposed resolutions to wrap funds for these projects, please say aye.
    • 00:50:36
      Aye.
    • 00:50:36
      Any opposed?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:50:37
      One comment I will make, Kevin and I talked about this yesterday and I used to serve on this committee.
    • 00:50:45
      The Spotsylvania one, if you see the request is for $300,000, we're making the award at $200,000.
    • 00:50:52
      That's a scoring decision.
    • 00:50:55
      A project cannot be granted anything until they score $50,000 or above.
    • 00:51:03
      This was at 50 and that's the reason the award was at 200 instead of 300.
    • Kevin B. PageChief of Rail Transportation
    • 00:51:10
      Mr. Chairman, if I may.
    • 00:51:12
      Thank you, Mr. Kling.
    • 00:51:13
      Roper Brothers Holding is a lumber reload yard, similar to Lowe's, but a smaller entrepreneur.
    • 00:51:20
      What we have to do is look for 50 points for our return on investment, and how we will bring a lower scoring project up as we reduce the amount of funds that staff will recommend to the board for funding.
    • 00:51:31
      That way we can counteract and basically balance out the commonwealth's investment on the return that we feel the need for that investment.
    • 00:51:38
      Thank you, Mr. Kling.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:51:40
      Okay.
    • 00:51:41
      Kevin, thank you.
    • 00:51:42
      Thank you, sir.
    • 00:51:43
      The next item on the agenda picks up from the presentation made in Lexington on the phase one of the multi-modal plan.
    • 00:51:51
      Jeff Southard will make that presentation on our acceptance.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:51:56
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:51:57
      I see that Mr. Fonseca is here from Federal Highway.
    • 00:52:02
      In light of his presentation last night about the tech game, I didn't have a chance to
    • 00:52:06
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:52:14
      I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you all today.
    • 00:52:23
      As we talked about in Lexington when I gave you a presentation on the draft phase one of the statewide transportation plan, VTrans 2025 as it's being called, we spent the last month making revisions to that plan.
    • 00:52:40
      We received a lot of good input from board members, from agency heads, and from others.
    • 00:52:46
      What you had in your packet is the revised version of that.
    • 00:52:51
      Let me very quickly highlight a couple of those things.
    • 00:52:54
      Many of them were sort of organizational, such as adding a preface table of contents, list of figures, acronyms, glossaries, putting appendices at the end, and those types of things.
    • 00:53:04
      But there were some other changes made in terms of adding additional information about the highway needs assessment to clarify what the recommendation was, correcting some of the information that was contained in the public outreach discussion group meeting summaries,
    • 00:53:21
      The policy committee is something that was just recently formed, so we updated the plan to include that information.
    • 00:53:30
      So we've included all of the comments that were submitted by board members also.
    • 00:53:34
      We've included the comments that were submitted by the other agency heads.
    • 00:53:40
      As you know, the state law that was passed last year, 33.1-23.03, places the requirement for the preparation of this plan on the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
    • 00:53:54
      Ms. Connally mentioned that the policy group had met yesterday and voted to
    • 00:53:58
      accept this and we have in your packet a resolution I believe it's at the end of your package that would formally accept this and direct us to transmit it to the legislature consistent with state law.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:54:15
      As Chair of the Multimodal Policy Committee, we did review this.
    • 00:54:25
      We have been reviewing this and we are very appreciative of the ability to get Southard and his staff, Kim Spence, who is delivering, not only delivering the report, but is delivering a son almost as we speak, so she is not here with us, thankfully.
    • 00:54:41
      But we will find this will be a very useful resource to the policy committee and I do recommend as the recommendation from the policy committee that the CTB does accept and forward this report on.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:06
      Then moved and seconded that we accept that report on the phase one.
    • 00:55:10
      Any discussion?
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:55:12
      Philip?
    • 00:55:14
      I raised the concern in Lexington, and I know many of you share it, that it's also hard to do the statewide transportation system for the future without knowing what Virginia's going to look like.
    • 00:55:24
      And this references, in terms of the stakeholders, some of the planning districts.
    • 00:55:30
      But it may not emphasize enough yet our need to find out something about the planning, the regional and state planning that's going on.
    • 00:55:39
      And it may even, we may even find as we work through this process, because I think it's an excellent report, I really like it and I certainly will support it.
    • 00:55:46
      Even their vision statement which talks about building a model for the nation, I assume implicitly means that fits the needs of Virginia, but it doesn't say that.
    • 00:55:56
      Building something that's a model for the world and doesn't fit the needs of Virginia is worth it.
    • 00:56:00
      And so, I just want us to, I think we just have to keep in front of us that there's still this underlying predicate that we're going to know something about what Virginia's going to look like.
    • 00:56:09
      Frankly, I'd just spare a little bit about whether we'll ever know the content and whether the planning is coherent enough at the local and regional level for us to really know, but just make that a caution.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:20
      I support it.
    • 00:56:21
      I think it's worth saying and applying.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:24
      Yeah, and this is one of the areas we covered yesterday is that even in our January meeting we're going to hear what the local MPO plans are and we're going to hear the local, some of the idea of the local, but the relationship between
    • 00:56:39
      Planning and Land Use is going to be a major element in our deliberations.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:56:45
      Thank you.
    • 00:56:47
      Any further discussion on the motion?
    • 00:56:49
      All in favor of the motion please say aye.
    • 00:56:51
      Aye.
    • 00:56:51
      Any opposed?
    • 00:56:53
      Thank you, Jeff.
    • 00:56:54
      Thank you.
    • 00:56:56
      There are two items under new business.
    • 00:57:00
      First, that we did not get to yesterday, that I was going to report on.
    • 00:57:09
      If you will recall, Philip Shucet
    • 00:57:12
      I presented a report on what VDOT has done in reaction to and in implementing recommendations made by the Auditor of Public Accounts.
    • 00:57:25
      It was at Blue Book
    • 00:57:27
      And there were, I believe, 50 recommendations that applied directly to VDOT.
    • 00:57:33
      And Philip reported about the number of those recommendations that either had been implemented since the report that had been issued late in the spring, or where they were in implementing them.
    • 00:57:48
      Well, there were 12 in addition to those 50, and there should be, or there was yesterday, a copy of those 12 that don't affect VDOT.
    • 00:58:01
      Instead, they affect us, there were five, and then the other seven affected the General Assembly, were directed to the General Assembly of the Governor.
    • 00:58:11
      Of the five, we have already, by our actions, implemented two of those five, and that was not bringing before us consultant's contracts, and the other one dealt with approval of location and design contracts, not the design.
    • 00:58:32
      We are required to do location.
    • 00:58:34
      So we've acted on two of those five, but there are three others, and then the seven that speak to the General Assembly and the Governor.
    • 00:58:46
      What I would like to suggest is that I named just a small ad hoc committee to work with Barbara Reese.
    • 00:58:58
      Barbara doesn't have enough to do.
    • 00:59:01
      But Barbara, if you can work with them with your very heavy load and report back to the full board,
    • 00:59:10
      A report on our response, not just to the five that are directed to us, but also weigh in and provide
    • 00:59:22
      The committee of the CTB provided a recommendation to the CTB on what we should do with those other seven.
    • 00:59:29
      It may be that, yeah, we agree with the auditors report.
    • 00:59:32
      We're going to send them on to the General Assembly.
    • 00:59:34
      The General Assembly has already gotten that report.
    • 00:59:36
      But I think it's appropriate for us to take a position on those other seven.
    • 00:59:41
      And so, with that as background, I wanted, and have already cleared this with Phil Stone, but I was going to ask Phil if he would chair that ad hoc committee, and to serve on it with him, I apologize, I haven't mentioned this to you guys, but Helen, if you would work with Phil and Ken White,
    • 01:00:03
      and Ambrose Bailey.
    • 01:00:05
      If you all would do that, I don't think it's a lot of heavy lifting.
    • 01:00:09
      I think Barbara Reese can give you a lot of guidance and I think that's the most appropriate way that we as a full board can then take action on those recommendations.
    • 01:00:23
      And Phil, unless you find otherwise, which would surprise me, I would like to suggest if you could report back in the January meeting.
    • 01:00:33
      Not December, but January.
    • 01:00:35
      You might be able to do it quicker than that if you can just have a caucus and chat with Barbara about it and then make your collective decision.
    • 01:00:44
      So, that's the first item of new business.
    • 01:00:47
      Kenny?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:00:47
      May I make a comment on recommendation 24 and I know we've done sort of getting out of the contract business.
    • 01:00:58
      I hate to keep going back to the commission, but I'm going to.
    • 01:01:00
      The commission was not unanimous on its recommendation, but we were very disturbed at the system in place for the awarding of professional service contracts, engineering, that kind of stuff.
    • 01:01:20
      It was our understanding that the way that is awarded is
    • 01:01:28
      VDOT puts together a list of qualified and ranked order of different companies and individuals.
    • 01:01:37
      And then VDOT negotiates a contract with the highest ranked individual or firm.
    • 01:01:47
      If they find that unsatisfactory, they then negotiate with the second individual or ranked firm.
    • 01:01:56
      and continue down the line.
    • 01:01:58
      The problem is that VDOT cannot go back to number one again.
    • 01:02:08
      So consequently, VDOT is in a way negotiating with itself.
    • 01:02:15
      What the Commission recommended and it was put into legislation and went to the General Assembly and was defeated because the professional service people did not want it.
    • 01:02:27
      They had a very good lobbying operation and I don't begrudge them that.
    • 01:02:32
      But it seems to me and it seemed to a majority of the Commission that it would be better that if you wanted to have qualified
    • 01:02:43
      Bidders, that's fine.
    • 01:02:46
      But then you come in with a best and final or some way of actually having competition.
    • 01:02:53
      The system as it exists today, and it may have changed in the last year, does not provide competition.
    • 01:03:01
      Let me ask you this before I ask Philip.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:21
      If that's the case, Kenny, let me tell you, you can keep bringing up the work of that commission because that's valuable input for all of us, so please don't be shy about that.
    • 01:03:34
      If that legislation was defeated, and if the CTB does not have a statutory role in approving those,
    • 01:03:47
      Then why can't VDOT do what you're suggesting?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:54
      I would hope they would.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:03:59
      Rick, can you help us?
    • Richard L. Walton Jr.Senior Assistant Attorney General
    • 01:04:04
      There's something called the Brooks Act, which is federal law.
    • 01:04:08
      It was passed probably in the late fifties.
    • 01:04:11
      No reason why that couldn't be revisited since it was done in the late 50s, but the Brooks Act essentially requires for a federal aid contract, professional engineering contract, that the process that's used is you don't consider price.
    • 01:04:25
      In short-listing the firms, you're considering their professional ability to do the work, and you're choosing the firm that makes the best presentation, has the best ability staff-wise, the professional engineers,
    • 01:04:38
      to do the work, and you choose that firm.
    • 01:04:42
      Once that firm's chosen, you then negotiate with that firm to try to reach a price that both parties can agree with.
    • 01:04:49
      What Kenny has said is, if you cannot agree upon a price to do the work with the first firm, you must terminate negotiations.
    • 01:04:55
      It's over with.
    • 01:04:56
      And go to number two.
    • 01:04:58
      and try and attempt to negotiate an agreement that's acceptable to both parties with number two, but you're not allowed to go back to the first offeror.
    • 01:05:08
      And that is something that's been in federal law now, like I said, since the late 50s.
    • 01:05:12
      And that was the point that was made by the professional engineering community to the General Assembly was, well, you can do what you want, but federal law is going to prohibit you from doing this on any federal aid contracts that you have.
    • 01:05:27
      So, until the federal law is changed, then Virginia is somewhat captured by what they can do for professional engineering services.
    • 01:05:39
      Now, if it's non-professional services, which VDOT deals a lot with, that allows you to go back and forth and get bad folks.
    • 01:05:48
      from the individual firms and try to negotiate them one against the other to get the best price for non-professional.
    • 01:05:56
      But that's just the lay of the land.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:02
      That's federal aid only.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:06:06
      Mr. Chairman, that's true.
    • 01:06:09
      However, we try to maximize our flexibility in terms of following federal processes for as many projects as we can so that we can make use of federal aid should we choose.
    • 01:06:27
      Rick summed it up very succinctly in terms of the Brooks Bill.
    • 01:06:36
      I can assure this board that we are paying strict attention to our negotiations with the consulting community.
    • 01:06:48
      The few of them that are left doing any work, quite frankly, right now, since we have withdrawn 12 contracts from consultants to bring in house,
    • 01:07:00
      We are currently reviewing that again with the current budget situation and almost assuredly we'll be bringing more work in-house.
    • 01:07:11
      We are also considering the procurement of certain types of services that we have previously been doing as professional services
    • 01:07:25
      as nonprofessional services.
    • 01:07:28
      That's a discussion that we just began this week which may permit us to procure certain types of very focused services under nonprofessional competitive bidding procedures as opposed to negotiated procedures.
    • 01:07:53
      okay Judy showing my ignorance could you define the difference between professional services and non-professional services yeah I was I mean I know but yes I can yes I can and my phone will be very busy by the time I walk from here back no ma'am no ma'am I don't mind at all
    • 01:08:15
      We have, and I don't know for how long, but we have for the past several years procured consultant inspection services.
    • 01:08:29
      We have inspectors who are out on construction jobs.
    • 01:08:34
      We don't have enough
    • 01:08:36
      to cover all of our perspectives.
    • 01:08:40
      And when we don't have enough, we have procured those services as professional services.
    • 01:08:49
      I have asked that we reconsider that, which will disturb many of my former colleagues, that we reconsider that.
    • 01:09:00
      Because basically, when we need inspectors,
    • 01:09:03
      What we ought to be doing is clearly defining the qualifications of the people we need to perform that work.
    • 01:09:14
      I hate to use the word commodity, but it is a bit of a commodity.
    • 01:09:20
      Once we clearly define that, I believe we may be able to get what we need
    • 01:09:28
      through the competitive process, because we're not asking folks to come in with a concept, and we don't need architectural or engineering design services.
    • 01:09:42
      We simply have X number of inspectors, and we need X plus Y.
    • 01:09:49
      That, I believe, particularly in the current environment, may benefit us.
    • 01:09:56
      financially without hurting us from the quality of inspection.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:10:04
      Okay.
    • 01:10:05
      Any other discussion?
    • 01:10:08
      All right.
    • 01:10:08
      Thank you.
    • 01:10:09
      And thank you for those of you who work on that little assignment.
    • 01:10:15
      The only other thing, now have you made copies or Frank made copies?
    • 01:10:19
      There are two items that we can go ahead and I think act on and not have them come back before us.
    • 01:10:26
      Changes in Limited Access Control Points, and... Winchester and Danville.
    • 01:10:35
      Winchester and Danville.
    • 01:10:36
      All right.
    • 01:10:37
      Frank, go ahead, please.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:10:40
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman, commissioners, members of the board.
    • 01:10:43
      These two items are going to come before you at your December meeting.
    • 01:10:46
      I have a request from the City of Winchester and the City of Danville.
    • 01:10:50
      They asked if we could in any way possible bring it earlier so they could get on with that.
    • 01:10:54
      Both of them request to break in limited access and the first one you have come before you is on Apple Blossom Drive in the city of Winchester and I'll wait just a minute until you get that proposed resolution.
    • 01:11:12
      The Commonwealth Transportation Board in February of 1981 imposed limited access lines on our project within the City of Winchester associated with Apple Blossom Drive.
    • 01:11:28
      The city has come back as a result of some property owners and asked if we would indeed allow a break net limited access for property that serves what was known as a C.J.
    • 01:11:41
      Fox Property, Incorporated.
    • 01:11:43
      You have at the back of the resolution a little sketch that shows a 50-foot break in the distance that would be from Valley Avenue on Appleblossom Drive.
    • 01:11:54
      We have had staff look at that request.
    • 01:11:56
      In fact, it was looked at in 1999 and was agreed that we would proceed with the request.
    • 01:12:02
      However, the property owner decided he did not want to proceed and therefore the board at that time did not take any action.
    • 01:12:09
      However, they wish to proceed now.
    • 01:12:11
      We've looked at the opening.
    • 01:12:13
      The opening would not propose any concerns from a safety standpoint.
    • 01:12:17
      It could be developed to provide safe ingress and egress out of that particular property.
    • 01:12:22
      The capacity of apple blossom drives or what's being proposed would not be affected.
    • 01:12:28
      And the property owner would be required to pay the department just compensation for that proposed unlimited access break.
    • 01:12:37
      And the resolution said that would be determined by the department.
    • 01:12:40
      On this particular one we have determined that and that is going to be valued at $98,500 in which the property owner will pay for that and the city is aware of that.
    • 01:12:51
      The property owner is aware that he will need to pay that when he proceeds to.
    • 01:12:57
      We are asking that the board consider this request.
    • 01:13:00
      The City of Winchester has agreed with it and they have asked for it to form a resolution and therefore we would request that the Commonwealth Transportation Board agree with the City of Winchester's request to allow this break and limited access on Apple Boston Drive.
    • 01:13:19
      Mr. Kline.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:21
      Is this a two-lane road?
    • 01:13:24
      Yes, it is.
    • 01:13:25
      Okay, so there's no divide in the middle.
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:13:27
      There's no divide, but where they're located on this particular situation, I believe what they're proposing is a right-in and right-out access so that you would not be making left-hand turns, so that the entrance is going to be designed so it's right-in and right-out without left-hand turns going to Valley Avenue.
    • 01:13:45
      On this particular one.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:13:49
      Any discussion on the motion?
    • 01:13:57
      All in favor of the proposed resolution subject to the condition set forth in that resolution please say aye.
    • 01:14:03
      Aye.
    • 01:14:04
      Any opposed?
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:14:05
      The second request is very similar.
    • 01:14:08
      It's within the city of Danville on Piedmont Drive.
    • 01:14:13
      The city has requested by resolution that we grant this limited access break.
    • 01:14:21
      The limited access feature was established in August of 1979 for a project within the city of Danville.
    • 01:14:29
      Again, from a staff standpoint, we have looked at the opening where it is going to be located.
    • 01:14:35
      It is a 60-foot break.
    • 01:14:39
      We've looked at the safety aspects, the capacity aspects, and there are no problems associated with that.
    • 01:14:44
      Therefore, from an engineering and technical standpoint, there's nothing wrong with granting this particular break.
    • 01:14:50
      One thing that has not been determined as of yet, though, we have not finished the appraisal
    • 01:14:55
      Although the resolution indicates the same as the past resolution on the back page that the developer will pay the department just compensation in accordance with the appraisal that will be completed.
    • 01:15:08
      And what we do in that regard, actually we do an appraisal of the property without the break, an appraisal of the property with the break, and the difference between the two appraisals, which is done independently, is the value of what the department has reimbursed for this particular
    • 01:15:24
      This is done because in buying the limited access rights, we actually paid that type of value in buying those limited access rights when we did in 1979.
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:15:39
      The funds that are obtained from the developer for that break, are they just credited against the cost of acquisition of the project?
    • 01:15:52
      What happens to that?
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:15:53
      They come back to the department.
    • 01:15:56
      I think they go into the overall pot for redistribution.
    • 01:16:07
      This is Art Taylor in my right-of-way division.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:09
      Any other questions?
    • 01:16:14
      Motion?
    • 01:16:15
      Karen?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:16:16
      Could I just, I assume you have standards of how frequently those breaks can occur in a limited access?
    • C. Frank GeeChief of Operations
    • 01:16:23
      Yes, ma'am.
    • 01:16:25
      Generally speaking, we look at, we are very restrictive in when we grant brakes in limited access because the brakes were established, I mean limited access feature was established for a particular reason, and that is to control the roadway from a capacity standpoint.
    • 01:16:38
      At any break that would affect the capacity of safety, we do not bring it before you unless it's an appeal on my decision to not bring it before you.
    • 01:16:45
      Everything that the board gets, we've looked at, and from a capacity standpoint and a safety standpoint, they're fine.
    • 01:16:51
      Generally speaking, unlimited access, it's based, if we had multiple ones, we're looking at not having them integrated.
    • 01:16:57
      If it's 55 mile an hour speed limit, not greater than 550 feet.
    • 01:17:00
      If it's a 60 mile an hour, not greater than 600 feet.
    • 01:17:02
      65, not greater than 650 feet.
    • 01:17:05
      So generally, it's a factor of 10 as a rule of thumb, and it depends upon various things, topography and other things, that may be increased beyond that from a minimum standard standpoint, but from a minimum, 55 miles an hour is 550 feet.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:22
      Okay, you have a motion?
    • 01:17:26
      Motion to approve.
    • 01:17:26
      Do we have a second?
    • 01:17:27
      Second.
    • 01:17:27
      Alright, then moved and seconded.
    • 01:17:29
      Any further discussion?
    • 01:17:30
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 01:17:32
      Aye.
    • 01:17:32
      Any opposed?
    • 01:17:32
      Mr. Chairman, I have one other item.
    • Ambrose W. BaileyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:17:34
      Yes, and opposed?
    • 01:17:36
      Due to the excellent report that was given yesterday by Barbara Reese and her staff concerning bridge funding and those types of items, I'd first like to have some discussion and then after discussion I'd like to put in the form of the motion that I think that maybe at your discretion, you and Mr. Shucet, that maybe a little small committee could be put together to be kept informed of whatever we need to do to move forward the funding process which was
    • 01:18:02
      In which we were briefed on yesterday and to work with it, I think it would be good from this body to have a group that worked with or Barbara could call on and keep us informed to do whatever we need to do to see that we keep moving forward on the bridge issue.
    • 01:18:19
      I think it's a major concern right now across the state.
    • 01:18:23
      And I'm open for discussion on how other members feel about it.
    • 01:18:27
      And after we talk about it, I would like to maybe put in form of a motion.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:18:32
      Okay, that's properly before us.
    • 01:18:38
      What has just been distributed is the notes of Philip Shucet this morning about the newspaper article yesterday.
    • 01:18:48
      That's just
    • 01:18:50
      For you to take home in case you get any questions about it, okay?
    • 01:18:53
      I didn't think I heard Barbara refer to the gold mine.
    • 01:18:56
      I was curious too.
    • 01:19:00
      Well, Ambrose, I mean, I personally, I know it's not as a real simple thing, but I would like to see us move toward establishing a bridge fund.
    • 01:19:13
      I mean, we all know we're looking for every dime we can get.
    • 01:19:17
      But even if we only identified the federal funds intended for bridges, you know, even if that alone constituted the bridge fund.
    • 01:19:27
      So, yeah, I mean, it's appealing to me personally.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:19:31
      I agree with you, Mr. Chairman, and with Ambrose, I think it's kind of surprising to hear yesterday that something identified as bridge funds wound up sort of
    • 01:19:43
      For good reason perhaps, but not being used to fix bridges or build bridges or whatever.
    • 01:19:48
      And some kind of a bridge fund, I think, with the statistics we heard yesterday, I think we're almost obligated to see that some kind of a bridge fund be recognized as such and used as such.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:20:04
      The only note of caution I would make is
    • 01:20:07
      This whole definition between maintenance of bridges and construction of bridges and that is a real question because you might in saying you're maintaining a bridge literally reconstruct the whole bridge and that's one of your problems.
    • 01:20:27
      The other problem you have is this whole local control problem.
    • 01:20:32
      where in the secondary system and to a certain extent the primary system the local jurisdictions are deciding their priorities.
    • 01:20:42
      And I mean, you know, what I try to do of my way is to talk to the local jurisdictions and say, now, you know, you're complaining about this bridge.
    • 01:20:55
      Well, understand that you have more than some control over it, even in the primary system.
    • 01:21:01
      One of the worst bridges rating, the fourth worst bridge rated in the state is in Arlington County.
    • 01:21:08
      And we have been negotiating between VDOT and Arlington County for, well, my whole term on the board.
    • 01:21:16
      And there are some disagreements.
    • 01:21:19
      So Arlington hasn't been willing yet to bite the bullet.
    • 01:21:24
      So that's the other.
    • 01:21:25
      I don't know that we can necessarily say, OK, this is the way it's going to be without the local jurisdictions being considered.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:21:35
      Mr. Chairman.
    • 01:21:36
      I would like to make a comment.
    • 01:21:40
      Both as Vice Chairman of this Board as well as Commissioner VDOT, I support Ambrose's suggestion.
    • 01:21:46
      I want to let you know though that it is very important to me that we get the accountability where it belongs.
    • 01:21:54
      Barbara discharged her accountability in doing this analysis and providing us with the information regarding the fund.
    • 01:22:04
      I have nailed this tack to the forehead of our chief engineer for program development, now Kerley, who in my opinion is the proper person to be accountable for the development
    • 01:22:19
      of a program and is the proper person to address some of the issues that Mr. Klinge pointed out.
    • 01:22:28
      So I certainly support Mr. Bailey's suggestion and certainly would be more than happy to work with a small committee of this board, but the person I would assign to that would be Mr. Kerley.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:49
      Well, yes, Ellen?
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:22:50
      Just one other comment, a thought to follow up on that.
    • 01:22:54
      I think that we deal with a lot of responsibilities here that we think are mundane and rote, but I think when it comes to issues like this of keeping accountability where it belongs and overall board management responsibilities, I think it's incumbent on us to stay out of the business.
    • 01:23:17
      I missed that presentation yesterday.
    • 01:23:24
      Barbara, can I ask you, is this not a work in progress
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:23:47
      Might you have a recommendation that you could work with a subset of the board?
    • 01:23:56
      Would that be reasonable?
    • Barbara W. ReeseChief Financial Officer
    • 01:23:58
      The next steps as we talked about yesterday are that we are getting ready to send letters out to the local governments to say we've discovered that we weren't using them as well as we could have.
    • 01:24:07
      We want you to go back and look as part of your update to your six-year programs, particularly on the secondary system,
    • 01:24:13
      and C, can you reprioritize or would you want to reprioritize?
    • 01:24:17
      Roberto and I were just talking about the meetings we need to have and all the work that needs to happen.
    • 01:24:23
      So I would say in a couple months we'll be in a position to come back to the board and say, okay, this is what we found out, you know, of that $203 million, you know, by cleaning up what we had done in the past and correcting that informal policy, you know, we've spent
    • 01:24:38
      10, whatever the amount of millions it may be that we've done, the boards of supervisors are looking on the secondary system at moving some bridge forward, those kind of things.
    • 01:24:48
      You know, part of it is just a six-year program process activity that obviously this board is going to be very involved in.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:24:58
      Mr. Chairman, I think this discussion has been very helpful in raising, I think, a notch the level of importance that some of us feel about bridge things.
    • 01:25:10
      I don't think we need necessarily to have a committee to follow it, per se.
    • 01:25:14
      I just think it is important.
    • 01:25:17
      It wasn't clear to me yesterday where we left things, except that Barbara was going to work with her staff to get some more information about it, and now Malcolm Curley is going to be in charge of
    • 01:25:27
      J. Smith, Michael A. Smith,
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 01:25:43
      I have some comments.
    • 01:25:51
      I tried to do exactly what you said, define maintenance, and quite frankly the districts want flexibility in that because if I cannot get a project on the six-year plan,
    • 01:26:05
      Our district does a very good job to ensure the bridges are safe.
    • 01:26:09
      So I'm familiar with that particular one.
    • 01:26:16
      I'll work with Barbara on this.
    • 01:26:18
      We're going to come up.
    • 01:26:19
      The bottom line of this is going to come back to the board is, I will come back to the commissioner, that when a county
    • 01:26:27
      presents their plan to us and does not have necessary bridge replacement projects on it.
    • 01:26:35
      By code, the Commonwealth Transportation Commissioner has the authority not to approve that plan and tell them they have to put it on.
    • 01:26:42
      I believe unless you have a separate bridge fund that's dedicated to bridges, you can't go through our normal formula based on the example yesterday.
    • 01:26:53
      You have to have a way to pay for them.
    • 01:26:56
      I don't think the counties are trying not to do it.
    • 01:26:59
      They just don't have the money to do it.
    • 01:27:01
      So it could be sometimes that it comes to the Commonwealth Transportation Commissioner for the secondary system.
    • 01:27:07
      The tough decisions have to be made there.
    • 01:27:10
      The examples on the Barrett Ferry,
    • 01:27:12
      Bridge yesterday in Richmond District.
    • 01:27:15
      It's not that we don't think that's important, but I believe that was about seventh or eighth in the competition for funds that Richmond District had to deal with, and that's why it wasn't fun.
    • 01:27:27
      Tough decisions have to be made if we move forward with this.
    • 01:27:30
      I'll be happy to work with everyone.
    • Ambrose W. BaileyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:27:32
      All right.
    • 01:27:33
      Mr. Chairman, I want to clarify my point.
    • 01:27:36
      And Congressman Helen, I'm the last person in the world that believes in micromanaging anybody in any situation.
    • 01:27:43
      But I do feel that it is an issue worthy of us trying to be informed because we have constituents who look to this board and they don't always know exactly what we are and aren't responsible for.
    • 01:27:58
      And they come straight to us with all the situations.
    • 01:28:02
      So therefore,
    • 01:28:03
      We need to have a mechanism that we can respond back to our, the citizens in the localities and the different bodies in the groups.
    • 01:28:13
      They don't really understand the day-to-day total operations.
    • 01:28:16
      So therefore, I'm in agreement, no way, I think they're doing a wonderful job and maybe we don't need a committee or whatever.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:23
      But you know,
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:24
      Why don't we let Mal, working with Barbara and Phillip continue this
    • 01:28:42
      Project, and with the expectation that we'll get another report in a reasonable amount of time.
    • 01:28:49
      Phillip, is that doable?
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:50
      That would be fine.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:52
      Next two or three meetings, we'll see where you stand on that.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:28:56
      We'll report to you in February.
    • 01:28:58
      Is that satisfactory?
    • 01:29:01
      We'll report to you in February.
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:05
      Hopefully a recommendation.
    • 01:29:08
      Absolutely.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:12
      A forward look.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:29:14
      One other, if that's the end of that, one other thing I wanted to raise, dealing with that limited access control change.
    • 01:29:24
      Now, I don't know if this will be red meat thrown out or not, but you know, one thing that has occurred to me since I got this job full-time for a while, one thing that has occurred to me is that
    • 01:29:42
      Maybe, just maybe, with all this referendum campaign talk, and people not trusting VDOT, or that more money means more sprawl, and Rick Walton had helped me and sent me some background work on it, you know,
    • 01:30:09
      Those two communities that we voted to allow them to change their limited access, I mean, we all know that changing those limited access points are going to increase their local real estate tax base.
    • 01:30:22
      That's why they wanted to do it.
    • 01:30:24
      But is there any foresight by those communities and what it's going to mean ultimately to sprawl?
    • 01:30:32
      I don't know.
    • 01:30:34
      I happen to know something about that latter one.
    • 01:30:36
      That access point is going to lead to a bridge that's about to fall down right now that's already got a long waiting line twice a day.
    • 01:30:47
      And whether there ought to be a way, statutorily, that we can assure a community, particularly a high-growth community, that if a road project is approved in the incipient stages,
    • 01:31:04
      That it truly will be limited access.
    • 01:31:06
      That it's not going to be someday, 20, 30 years from now, chopped up with a lot of intersections.
    • 01:31:13
      Is there some way that the state can work with local government, and I know we don't want to get into land use decisions, but is there some way that we can
    • 01:31:27
      Almost guarantee, if you take a hot area, like Route 15, beautiful country, Kenny knows a lot more about this side, western bypass, whatever you want to talk about, Fredericksburg, Fosseveen, if you could say, if VDOT could say that we will support getting folks from point A to point B, but that's all it's ever going to be.
    • 01:31:52
      I mean, is that good transportation planning?
    • 01:31:56
      I mean, is that the kind of thing that, you know, we ought to do?
    • 01:31:59
      Or is that too much of an encroachment on local government powers?
    • 01:32:06
      Because we end up, the state ends up paying for the roads and all the problems that come with it, air quality and all.
    • 01:32:12
      Kenny.
    • 01:32:13
      Do you want me to leave now, Kenny?
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:32:15
      No, no.
    • 01:32:17
      You're raising a very valid question, my observation after
    • 01:32:21
      Some four years on this board is probably, with the exception of one bridge project, two bridge projects, the most controversial issues that we had to deal with were either establishing or breaking limited access.
    • 01:32:40
      One was down your way.
    • 01:32:42
      An interchange, and I'm trying to think, is it 460 or 316,
    • 01:32:50
      15 or 522 or something, which was established 30 years ago for good, and the area has never really developed.
    • 01:33:02
      And they wanted to put in a fast food restaurant, and they wanted a right in, right out near the interchange.
    • 01:33:09
      And the policy discussion was, well, we gave them this,
    • 01:33:19
      And now they want to take, in effect, break it.
    • 01:33:23
      And what should we charge them for breaking it?
    • 01:33:26
      Because, as you said, it enhances, it gets into the land you said.
    • 01:33:33
      The other one was on Route 17 in Chesapeake, a year before last.
    • 01:33:39
      And they're building a bypass or a through pass to go to North Carolina.
    • 01:33:45
      And we were forced to move the road east because where it was now was up in an area of Whitlands.
    • 01:33:55
      So we were moving it east about, I don't know, a quarter of a mile.
    • 01:33:59
      But the question came up, how many accesses on that 10-mile stretch of road should there be?
    • 01:34:07
      And there were four large farms.
    • 01:34:10
      So we said we'd give them one for each farm.
    • 01:34:14
      Well,
    • 01:34:15
      I mean, you know, between the workshop meeting, one month, and the next meeting, they were on us like cheap suits.
    • 01:34:24
      What they wanted to do is develop the land.
    • 01:34:27
      And they didn't like this limited access idea at all.
    • 01:34:30
      So, I mean, you're right.
    • 01:34:33
      And this whole relationship on land use and transportation, you've got to do something about it.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:34:40
      Well, we're going to have on our program workshop in January John Cogville, who used to be a member of the CTB with McGuire Woods, who's a land use lawyer.
    • 01:34:52
      And I've asked him to speak on land use from a transportation perspective.
    • 01:35:00
      And then also we've got on the agenda the route, Charlottesville Route 29 bypass.
    • 01:35:04
      I mean that's a big issue there.
    • 01:35:08
      And you know, what can we do as a policy board to help prevent some of the problems that we have in our more congested areas now?
    • 01:35:21
      Howard?
    • Helen E. DragasMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:35:22
      Doesn't that become a double-edged sword, though?
    • 01:35:24
      I mean, policies that, I mean, you speak of a mindset that you, deals with congested areas, but then we hear about the southwestern part of the state and the economic difficulties that they're having, and some of those transportation policies could, contrary to what you would do in the congested areas, would benefit those areas, and I don't know, it's a complicated question, and to me, it's hard to sit here in Richmond
    • 01:35:50
      And for me to understand in depth any area except my own.
    • 01:35:57
      There are just so many competing forces at work.
    • 01:36:02
      Everyone wants economic growth.
    • 01:36:03
      I mean, most people understand the need for growth, yet they don't want sprawl, yet they don't want density.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:10
      So there's this inherent tension that... And then you get the tension of local governments, the main thing
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:19
      Well, the Dillon Rule sort of puts us in this because the legislature runs everything but land use.
    • 01:36:34
      And the only thing local governments have that is truly theirs is land use.
    • 01:36:40
      And I mean, you might as well, there's the gulf there that is huge.
    • 01:36:45
      And don't tell me what I can and can't do with my land.
    • 01:36:49
      Oh, by the way, please send money so we can build the roads to those subdivisions we've rezoned, you know, our two-lane dirt roads now, some of which they are.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:36:59
      Well, that's true, but we do have to approve location and design and construction.
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:06
      Are there any findings made when you do a road like the Charlottesville bypass that's done?
    • 01:37:12
      It would remind us permanently of the objectives for limiting access.
    • 01:37:18
      In other words, if the finding is that you need to move traffic around an urban or suburban area, you probably are not going to justify having new access to it.
    • 01:37:30
      If it is simply to provide transportation like this one in Winchester to try to regulate traffic in a busy area, and VDOT comes in and says, well, this is consistent with moving the traffic, the regulating traffic, and it's safe, you may have a different result.
    • 01:37:45
      In the case of controlling traffic, I mean, I was trying to visualize where that Apple Blossom Drive is.
    • 01:37:52
      It's the one off the interstate where you come in at Shenandoah University.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:56
      Is that where it is?
    • Phillip C. StoneMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:37:59
      I think it is the worst exit area I've seen on any interstate system.
    • 01:38:08
      And we just made it worse.
    • 01:38:09
      We just made it worse.
    • 01:38:10
      But when you said it was too late, I really thought maybe that was not the one because I wasn't hearing this too late.
    • 01:38:15
      But that is so hard to get through and around and turn and everything else.
    • 01:38:18
      I don't know.
    • 01:38:19
      I'm depending on your recommendation.
    • J. Kenneth KlingeMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:21
      It's on the west side of 11.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:38:23
      Well, we have, Jerry McCarthy brought up an issue from one of our regional meetings and as a result of that discussion, VDOT is going to work with two counties, Caroline and Botetourt.
    • 01:38:38
      and helping them with these type of issues, land use and transportation.
    • 01:38:48
      Jeff, I don't know if you want to address Phil Stone's question about how aggressive or how helpful and what are the limitations on VDOT when you do work in these early stages?
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:39:04
      Well, I think there's a series of points here.
    • 01:39:06
      Of course, Rick could address some of the legal ones, the extent of which a present board can bind future boards with regards to access breaks or permanently limiting an access break that a future board may decide.
    • 01:39:19
      I think the point that Dr. Stone has raised is the one that in fact Commissioner and I were talking about it as recently as yesterday morning, where I think that VDOT needs to do a better job of early in the process
    • 01:39:43
      Working with local governments to identify the various alternatives that they have and what the consequences of their actions may be.
    • 01:39:53
      The situation that you raised as we go through the NEPA process on a new road, let's take the outer connector in Fredericksburg.
    • 01:40:05
      That project, during the NEPA process, we established a specific purpose and need, which was to connect Route 3 and Route 17 and Route 95 and move traffic that way.
    • 01:40:19
      The design of that road and the access breaks on that road and the purpose and need all were generated based on a specific land use plan as identified by the local governments at that point in time.
    • 01:40:34
      If they subsequently change that, it changes all the assumptions that went into that roadway.
    • 01:40:42
      If that assumptions were that this is going to be and you can look at their land use plan and see where they plant, you know, low density residential, they have golf course, recreational facilities, schools and so forth.
    • 01:40:53
      If all of a sudden that becomes a major industrial site, an office park or a Walmart distribution center or whatever, that changes all of the assumptions that went into determining that this was the right road and the right place to meet the purpose and need that we had.
    • 01:41:12
      So that's part of that disconnect that we have is that we make those assumptions based on the information that the local government has generated through their long-term, long-range land use plan.
    • 01:41:27
      And there is of course always the argument about chicken and egg and that this road induces them to change that.
    • 01:41:33
      H. T.
    • 01:41:55
      The local governments, what they do with that land subsequent to all of us agreeing that yes, CTB will approve to build this road in this location to serve this purpose and need and we understand what the impacts are going to be and then all of a sudden someone changes the assumptions, the facts upon which all the assumptions were made.
    • 01:42:16
      One of the things that, and the secretary referred to, referenced this a few seconds ago, is I had a meeting early this summer with Senator Hauck and a few others that actually proposed that we begin to engage in some pilots.
    • 01:42:33
      The pilots that I'm actually looking for are much more substantial in terms of local governments who are experiencing major growth where there are going to be major roadways where we can go in and actually do some extensive alternatives analysis so that they have a real understanding, and everybody in the community has a real understanding, of the consequences of future acts beyond the roadway.
    • 01:43:01
      The situation that the Secretary referred to is one of the things that VDOT, I believe, should be doing in the process that you've heard the Commissioner speak about of distributing authority where we're moving more positions out.
    • 01:43:13
      If you look at our transportation planning group, when I first got here two and a half years ago, 80% of the people that did transportation planning in VDOT were here in the central office.
    • 01:43:24
      Well, that's not where our customers are.
    • 01:43:26
      And very shortly, I hope, or I shouldn't say too shortly, but we're slowly moving those people out.
    • 01:43:32
      Stanton District, for example, never had a planner.
    • 01:43:34
      They do now.
    • 01:43:35
      Richmond District never had a planner.
    • 01:43:37
      They do now.
    • 01:43:38
      and we will begin to move those people out so that in fact they're out there working with folks because one of the things that we ought to be engaged in is exactly what the Secretary referred to as local governments are required under law every six years to reevaluate and update their comprehensive land use plans.
    • 01:43:58
      We ought to be actively engaged in that process of what are the consequences of these actions?
    • 01:44:04
      What type of infrastructure will it take to support these decisions?
    • 01:44:08
      And what are the long-term problems you create if you change your mind in the future?
    • 01:44:15
      I mean, it's the information is what we can provide them with and frankly, currently, we don't do that.
    • 01:44:20
      And I think as we move some of these very talented planners out into the districts, we will have that ongoing working relationship.
    • 01:44:28
      We've also, with Senator Hauck and the local government folks and some other concerned environmental groups, have looked at some other legislative alternatives in Laker's Mill.
    • 01:44:38
      But I think we can do that both through the NEPA process
    • 01:44:41
      where we're looking at secondary impacts when we're doing something like a outer connector.
    • 01:44:48
      But I think more importantly we can do it as ongoing business as local governments are constantly revising their six-year programs or involved their major rezoning decisions.
    • 01:44:59
      Now, frankly, Richmond is a good example right across the street from where I live out in the far west end of where VDOT did do that.
    • 01:45:06
      And the local government was not very appreciative of what we had to say.
    • 01:45:11
      Because what we said was if you make this decision it's going to result in major gridlock at some intersections and interstates and you don't have the capacity the county said that's not what we want to hear.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:21
      That's why we need to consider having something up front.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 01:45:25
      Right, that's right.
    • 01:45:26
      So we have to be involved earlier in the process as opposed to getting a letter saying would you all please comment on this decision we're about to make.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:38
      Judy?
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:45:38
      I would just say that as part of our scope of work in the long-range policy, multi-modal committee, I think this is recognized as an area in which there's enormous need for more cooperation, coordination, incentives, but there's obviously a real gap between using transportation as a positive tool
    • 01:46:01
      and relating well to the local jurisdictions and for having the local jurisdictions acting very independently and taking not appropriate advantage of the transportation facility.
    • 01:46:16
      So I think we'll certainly be dealing with this at a policy level.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:21
      Great.
    • 01:46:22
      Harry?
    • SPEAKER_06
    • 01:46:23
      I was just going to say the same thing.
    • 01:46:24
      That seems like a very appropriate place for that conversation to take place because it's
    • Julia A. ConnallyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:31
      I also appreciate Mr. Southard moving ahead right now.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 01:46:41
      Okay, anything else to come before the board?
    • 01:46:46
      I will thank you for being here.
    • 01:46:47
      We will, and thank you for your responses to the retreat after the workshop December 18 or 19 with the legislators from the Senate Finance House Appropriations Committee.
    • 01:47:00
      I hope all y'all got word on it.
    • 01:47:02
      Have a safe trip home.
    • 01:47:03
      Thank you very much.