Central Virginia
  • Commonwealth Transportation Board
  • Action Meeting 10/16/2002
  • Auto-scroll

Action Meeting   10/16/2002

Attachments
  • Minutes.pdf
  • TRANSPORTATION BOARD AWARDS 20 CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS WORTH $15.7 MILLION.pdf
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:00:03
      If we could come to order, please.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:00:11
      We all have the agenda for our regular monthly meeting of the board.
    • 00:00:17
      The first item, public comment.
    • 00:00:19
      We've had no request for anyone to address the board.
    • 00:00:24
      Assuming that's still the case,
    • 00:00:29
      Do we have a motion to approve the minutes?
    • 00:00:33
      September 18th.
    • 00:00:34
      Been moved and seconded.
    • 00:00:35
      Any discussion?
    • 00:00:37
      All in favor of approving the minutes as prepared, please say aye.
    • 00:00:41
      Aye.
    • 00:00:41
      Any opposed?
    • 00:00:43
      Next on the agenda is Jim Givens, Director of the Local Assistance Division.
    • 00:00:50
      Jim?
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:00:51
      Yes, sir.
    • 00:00:53
      Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:00:56
      The first item I have is item number four, which is the report of the additions to the secondary system for the month of September.
    • 00:01:08
      And that's 18.63 miles of roads that were added to that system.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:01:20
      So moved.
    • 00:01:21
      Second.
    • 00:01:24
      It's been moved and seconded.
    • 00:01:25
      Any discussion?
    • 00:01:28
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:01:30
      Aye.
    • 00:01:30
      Any opposed?
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:01:33
      Mr. Chairman, item number five is the action requested on recreational access projects.
    • 00:01:42
      We have a project in the town of South Boston and the requested allocation for that project is $144,500.
    • 00:01:51
      We're recommending that.
    • 00:01:57
      The next two items are recreational access projects in Fauquier County.
    • 00:02:06
      Both of these projects have been reviewed and both are eligible for allocation.
    • 00:02:13
      The first includes an allocation of $267,450 for the access road and a $53,000 allocation for
    • 00:02:26
      A bikeway to be constructed with the road.
    • 00:02:31
      The second is a recommended $276,500 allocation for an access road for the Northern Fauquier Sports Complex.
    • 00:02:46
      And in addition, a recommended allocation of $60,500 for a bicycle, a bikeway
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:02:56
      adjacent to that road.
    • 00:03:06
      The next item Mr. Chairman
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:03:23
      is a reallocation or a transfer of some funds that were previously allocated to Henry County and Wise County.
    • 00:03:34
      The reason we bring this action to you is that the code requires that the board approve new projects in the revenue sharing program.
    • 00:03:46
      Those projects are itemized in the second page of your resolution.
    • 00:03:53
      If there are any questions, I would say that the total county contribution is $10,000 in Henry and the state match is $10,000 which is a $20,000 shift on a minor improvement there.
    • 00:04:10
      The ones in Wise County are four projects that are expected to cost $640,000 total.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:23
      Okay.
    • 00:04:24
      Move for approval, sir.
    • 00:04:25
      Moved and seconded.
    • 00:04:26
      Any discussion on the motion to adopt the proposed resolution for the reallocation of the revenue sharing?
    • 00:04:35
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:04:37
      Aye.
    • 00:04:37
      Do you oppose?
    • James S. GivensSecondary Roads Division Administrator
    • 00:04:38
      Aye.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:04:38
      Thank you, Mr.
    • 00:04:39
      Chair.
    • 00:04:39
      Thank you, Jim.
    • 00:04:41
      Next, from the Mobility Management Division, Ms. Kasenhoffa.
    • SPEAKER_00
    • 00:04:46
      Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
    • 00:04:49
      I have a two-track restriction request in front of you today from a residential community in Cluster County.
    • 00:04:59
      They did request that their board of supervisors who in turn did go through the proper process to request two-track restriction.
    • 00:05:09
      Public hearing was had, the study was done, and
    • 00:05:15
      The Board of Supervisors passed a resolution to make this request.
    • 00:05:22
      The Fredericksburg District and Saluda Residences also are supporting this restriction.
    • 00:05:29
      And as our usual processes, we do check with the board member from the area, so Mr. Bailey also reviewed the case and supports it.
    • 00:05:40
      This is only a half of my residential street when the restriction would take place and the travel time penalty is only approximately forty-three seconds and it does meet four of the five criteria to have this restriction so I am requesting approval for this restriction.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:04
      Mr. Chairman, I move for the approval of this action.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:06:08
      All right, moved and seconded.
    • 00:06:11
      Any discussion on the motion to approve this through truck restriction in Gloucester County?
    • 00:06:19
      All in favor please say aye.
    • 00:06:21
      Aye.
    • 00:06:21
      Any opposed?
    • 00:06:23
      Thank you.
    • 00:06:23
      Thank you.
    • 00:06:25
      Stuart Wamack, right-of-way utilities division.
    • SPEAKER_01
    • 00:06:29
      Good afternoon Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen of the board.
    • 00:06:32
      I seek your approval today to class surplus four parcels of land for conveyance to the adjacent landowner.
    • 00:06:38
      The parcel in North Humboldt County, excuse me, on Eastern Shore is an exchange of drainage easements at no cost to the Commonwealth.
    • 00:06:45
      We're simply conveying a drainage easement that we have purchased in exchange for wanting to landowners donating to allow for orderly development of his property.
    • 00:06:54
      The other three parcels are results of realignments of existing roadway.
    • 00:07:00
      The three parcels total compensation of less than $10,000.
    • 00:07:05
      They are conveyance to the adjacent owners and I'll be happy to answer any questions.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:07:12
      All right, it's been moved and seconded that we adopt as a block the resolution calling for the disposition of this surplus property.
    • 00:07:29
      Any discussion on the motion?
    • 00:07:31
      All in favor, please say aye.
    • 00:07:33
      Aye.
    • 00:07:34
      Any opposed?
    • 00:07:35
      Thank you.
    • 00:07:35
      Thank you, Stuart.
    • 00:07:37
      Construction Division, Mal Kerley, item number nine in the tab.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:07:43
      I'm going to go over item two of the handout I gave you a little bit earlier.
    • 00:07:47
      It has to do with the bid items.
    • 00:07:49
      We had 25 projects.
    • 00:07:51
      Four of them were maintenance projects, less than $250,000 that don't have to come before you.
    • 00:07:56
      Six are projects
    • 00:07:57
      that others are doing that we're advertising.
    • 00:08:00
      We had 15 projects.
    • 00:08:05
      The remaining of those 13 were below the engineer's estimate.
    • 00:08:09
      One was in the 7% of the engineer's estimate, which we're recommending approval, and one is above the 7%, and I'm recommending that not be approved.
    • 00:08:20
      If you go through your list, there's 12 pages in there.
    • 00:08:24
      I'll go through these relatively quickly.
    • 00:08:27
      I want to bring your attention to, on the right side, under number of bids.
    • 00:08:33
      You'll notice we are getting very good bids.
    • 00:08:37
      We believe we have good estimates and the competition is pretty good now and we're getting good prices on the projects that we're going.
    • 00:08:46
      I want to bring that to your attention.
    • 00:08:48
      Page 1 is primary projects, four primary projects.
    • 00:08:55
      The last three had to do with safety related issues.
    • 00:08:58
      On page 2 are four secondary projects.
    • 00:09:03
      Nothing out of the ordinary of these.
    • 00:09:09
      Page 3 is urban related projects.
    • 00:09:13
      Nothing on that page.
    • 00:09:18
      Page four is some miscellaneous projects.
    • 00:09:24
      The one, number two, on that page has some construction funds and enhancement type funds allocated to that.
    • 00:09:33
      I wanted to point that out to the board.
    • 00:09:36
      On page five is a maintenance-related project.
    • 00:09:43
      Page 6 is an enhancement project where they're looking to buy some equipment that they will be installing in their center theater.
    • 00:09:59
      Page 7 is a gateway to La Crosse, another enhancement project.
    • 00:10:06
      Page 8 is a Chesterfield County project for intersection improvements.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:10:12
      Chairman, on that particular one, I'd ask to abstain from that.
    • 00:10:15
      I do business with that company.
    • 00:10:17
      Okay, we'll pull that from the block.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:10:20
      All right.
    • 00:10:21
      Page 9 is an urban project, City of Roanoke.
    • 00:10:24
      What I wanted to point out, if you look at the bid price, a little bit over $3.8 million.
    • 00:10:29
      T21 money, enhancement money is $980,000.
    • 00:10:34
      The rest of that money there is coming from the City of Roanoke.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:10:39
      Mr. Chairman, from the report we got last month on the P21 money, my question is, this is 980,000 here, is it a part of the 15 we're going to get this year or next year, is it a part of the 29 million that we owe, or where does this fit into that puzzle?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:11:02
      Alright, these dollars amount here are not what they were talking about for next year.
    • 00:11:08
      These are monies that we already have available here.
    • 00:11:11
      This is not after what Barbara was talking about of continuation money.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:11:16
      These have already been approved.
    • 00:11:19
      The applications have been approved and then they have to come back when they've gotten their bids.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:11:27
      Mr. Chairman, the 29 we were talking about, 120 to 29, when we get to the bottom of that, those are projects that are already approved.
    • 00:11:35
      Is that accurate?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:11:36
      I believe, Mr. Chairman, what he's talking about is there are some of these projects that are in phases where you might have four phases and we might be in phase two.
    • 00:11:46
      And I believe what Barbara's presentation was saying, do you want to add more projects in or do you want to consider the projects you have and fund the remaining phases of those projects?
    • 00:11:59
      This particular one I think is a stand-alone.
    • 00:12:02
      I don't have that data right now, but I believe this is a stand-alone for this particular one.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:08
      This was approved previously, and the money has been allocated previously, and now they're at the building it, bidding it stage, correct?
    • 00:12:19
      That's correct.
    • 00:12:20
      So that doesn't affect necessarily, although it might, depending on how we come out on how we want to do.
    • 00:12:26
      I mean, I guess my simple question is,
    • 00:12:30
      Do we have a standing policy about the enhancement projects being, if you get phase one, we'll promise you do two, three, four?
    • 00:12:39
      No.
    • 00:12:39
      No, we never did.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:40
      That's part of what we're going to try to do when we go back and revisit how we allocate enhancements.
    • 00:12:49
      These are basically projects that we already committed on, the expectations are there, and it's just the contract.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:12:55
      And this is one of those railroad station rehab things, and I'm delighted to see the level of match that the city is putting into this.
    • 00:13:03
      I mean, this is, frankly, what you hope to see for these kind of projects is high leverage.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:13:11
      Mr. Chairman, back on page four where you called your attention to the fact that there was tea money and then there was construction funds, is that an unusual mix?
    • 00:13:22
      What was specific?
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:13:23
      That's unusual for me, Don.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:31
      But in a sense, that's also an average.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:13:34
      We probably had a construction project planned, and they wanted to add more than what we were going to do, so they went to get the money to enhance a project that was already in the system.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:13:50
      In fact, in my opinion, I think we need to do more of that.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:13:54
      Page 10 is some on-call rental equipment.
    • 00:14:00
      Page 11 is for erosion control, on-call also with our wildfire program.
    • 00:14:07
      And Page 12 is the one project that I'm recommending that we reject.
    • 00:14:11
      It's an oyster
    • 00:14:15
      Road project that I thought for Mr. Mitchell about.
    • 00:14:19
      It's under the urban rustic program.
    • 00:14:22
      The bids just came in too high and we felt that we would benefit if we go back out, look at our contract documents and rebid that particular item.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:14:32
      This is one of those projects Delegate May worked hard on, so I think once we look at the scope and then go back out the door.
    • Malcolm T. KerleyChief Engineer
    • 00:14:40
      Yes, we are committed to that program.
    • 00:14:42
      We have about 11 of them done throughout the state.
    • 00:14:47
      It's just on this particular one that looking at the contract documents and the bid, we felt that we needed to rebid this particular project.
    • 00:14:56
      We plan to clean up the documents and then rebid it and do this project.
    • 00:15:00
      Yes, sir?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:02
      OK. Do you have a motion to accept the recommendations of Mao to award these contracts with the exception of the last one and also pulling out from the block the one on page 8?
    • 00:15:20
      So moved, Mr. Chairman.
    • 00:15:22
      Second.
    • 00:15:22
      Second.
    • 00:15:23
      All right.
    • 00:15:24
      Any discussion on these recommendations?
    • 00:15:28
      All right.
    • 00:15:29
      All in favor of the motion, please say aye.
    • 00:15:30
      Aye.
    • 00:15:31
      Any opposed?
    • 00:15:32
      The last one then, if we could treat separately, is on page 8, the bid amount $881,795 in Chesterfield County.
    • 00:15:46
      Do we have a motion?
    • 00:15:48
      I move it.
    • 00:15:49
      It's been moved and seconded.
    • 00:15:50
      Any discussion?
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:15:51
      There was a second, sir.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:15:53
      All in favor of accepting the recommendation, please say aye.
    • 00:15:58
      Aye.
    • 00:15:58
      Any opposed?
    • 00:15:59
      One abstention.
    • 00:16:00
      One abstention.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:03
      I do business with the company.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:10
      All right, any other, those are the action items that have been set forth in the agenda.
    • 00:16:17
      Any other matters to come before the board?
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:16:21
      I'd like to make a brief comment that gets at the issue that my good friend Mr. Bailey brought up earlier.
    • 00:16:30
      We are definitely seeing some advantage in the marketplace.
    • 00:16:38
      Currently, the difference between our final engineer's estimate, which is a very confidential number,
    • 00:16:48
      and bids that we're getting overall in the industry, about a 17% spread below our estimate.
    • 00:16:58
      Now, I understand on behalf of the industry as well as maybe your constituents, you're saying, man, there's some money, we can plow back in and get more projects out.
    • 00:17:09
      You know, just 90 days ago we were in, well, or 180 days ago we were in financial disarray.
    • 00:17:17
      I'd hate to say let's check the box off and say everything's fixed just quite yet, but the signals are very good.
    • 00:17:24
      And historically I can tell you that that number between our final estimate and industry's bids is pretty good.
    • 00:17:34
      Where we have just
    • 00:17:36
      Blown ourselves out of the water with those earlier estimates, but quite frankly they didn't get much attention paid to them.
    • 00:17:44
      Our goal with this cost estimating process, the big goal, is to make that first estimate we ever do
    • 00:17:52
      Not only equal the final estimate, but the final payout on the job.
    • 00:17:56
      Now, that's a lofty goal, but that's where your head needs to be.
    • 00:18:00
      So we're definitely seeing benefit to all of us in the marketplace.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:06
      I thank you, Mr. Commissioner, for this.
    • 00:18:07
      I appreciate the work that you're doing.
    • 00:18:09
      I don't want to get on your bad side.
    • 00:18:12
      No, it's easy.
    • 00:18:13
      He's still on some bridges over there.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:18:17
      I'm with him.
    • 00:18:19
      I'm with him.
    • 00:18:19
      He's still working hard.
    • 00:18:21
      I'm somewhat at a disadvantage now.
    • 00:18:25
      I have to speak up more now.
    • 00:18:29
      One of the things that's come up with me in a lot of different task forces that I've been involved with over a few years was the design criteria of some of the infrastructure we work on.
    • 00:18:39
      I know that mostly it has to do with secondary programs on collector roads or secondary roads within communities.
    • 00:18:48
      Even some of the primary roads.
    • 00:18:51
      I know Route 15 on Leesburg and Route 50 and outside of that we're looking at traffic calming.
    • 00:18:57
      You know, it's kind of interesting.
    • 00:18:59
      We got all this gridlock and we're still studying traffic calming.
    • 00:19:02
      And then different design criteria.
    • 00:19:04
      But I think it has a big role in some of these communities.
    • 00:19:07
      And once we get over all this other stuff, is get into some of the design aspects.
    • 00:19:13
      It really gets into, really not appropriate for the multimodal side, but these collector roads and the secondary roads were in these communities.
    • 00:19:21
      It's gotten to be a bigger discussion in some of the Northern Virginia communities and I suspect it's probably true elsewhere around the state.
    • 00:19:31
      So at one point in time I think some of the lessons learned with some of these studies that are going up north on these things we could utilize that to reduce secondary road standards and that we could proceed with that sometime next year.
    • 00:19:48
      And I know I'm getting a lot of feedback
    • 00:19:51
      From the Loudoun County group, seems like everything happens in Loudoun County lately, but I think it's appropriate for other parts of the urban areas of the state, and even where you've got some of these standards that are appropriate.
    • 00:20:03
      I don't know what everybody else's thoughts on that are.
    • 00:20:07
      Anyway, that's it.
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:10
      Okay.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:20:12
      Any other comments?
    • 00:20:14
      If you found another James Keen, Northern Virginia, you might be glad to come up from
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:20:20
      That's a good point.
    • 00:20:27
      All the board members are really involved with the referendum question that's coming up.
    • 00:20:32
      It's not a slam dunk by any means.
    • 00:20:33
      There's still a lot of work there, but vote early and often I guess is good.
    • 00:20:38
      But the key is to get people to go out and vote.
    • 00:20:42
      And it is a big issue in Northern Virginia and the Tidewater area.
    • 00:20:46
      So much, you can see some of it in the presentation we got today while I was moving commuters around.
    • 00:20:53
      But it really helps a lot of businesses down there too.
    • 00:20:55
      It's so important for both parts of these states.
    • 00:20:59
      And I, well, anyway.
    • SPEAKER_05
    • 00:21:02
      I think you're preaching to the choir.
    • Leonard S. "Hobie" MitchelMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:04
      Oh yeah, but it reinforces you all the time.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:21:08
      Mr. Secretary, I was wondering if you could reaffirm as people are reading this VTrans 2025 that indeed we as a board have just recently gotten it and when we vote on it next time we are more or less accepting it as a first phase and an excellent
    • 00:21:28
      staff job we are not necessarily putting our have had a chance to put our imprint on it and that will occur in the later phases so if people read and they do you know quarrel with with some words that's fine it might be changed now but certainly it is an evolving document
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:21:49
      That's a very important point.
    • 00:21:51
      That is correct.
    • 00:21:52
      I do reaffirm that.
    • 00:21:54
      We will be voting on it next month, and it does need our imprimatur, but I do hope that we will be very engaged in the development of the policy and guiding the steering committee as we go to phase two.
    • Gerald P. McCarthyMember, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:16
      For those of us staying tonight, is there a CTB table, or how does this work?
    • 00:22:23
      I've never been to this table.
    • SPEAKER_09
    • 00:22:25
      No, this is just part of the conference, general conference reception and dinner at Kirkwood.
    • Philip A. ShucetVice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:31
      Right.
    • 00:22:31
      It's a stand-up barbecue, I think, isn't it?
    • Whittington W. ClementChair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
    • 00:22:37
      I want to thank Kathy Tracy, my right hand lady here who is to my left today for helping
    • 00:22:57
      Do the great job she does in organizing and planning these meetings.
    • 00:23:02
      I know it was more arduous this time meeting outside.
    • 00:23:07
      If there's nothing else to come before the board, we stand adjourned.