Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 9/19/2002
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
9/19/2002
Attachments
Minutes.pdf
BOARD APPROVES $250 MILLION BOND SALE AND AWARDS $34 MILLION IN CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS.pdf
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:00
We need to scoot out promptly today, so I hope we can get through the agenda fairly quickly.
00:00:10
We'll go down, follow along in the agenda.
00:00:14
The first item is the approval of the August 15 meeting minutes.
00:00:21
It's been moved and seconded.
00:00:23
Any discussion on the motion?
00:00:26
All in favor, please say aye.
00:00:28
Aye.
00:00:28
Any opposed?
00:00:29
The next item we're going to, let me say this on committee reports.
00:00:38
We have traditionally met at 10 o'clock on these mornings to allow time for committee meetings earlier in the day.
00:00:48
Until we, right now I'm thinking in terms of three committees at the most.
00:00:54
The committee on multimodal, intermodal planning, committee on finance, audit, and a third committee dealing with
00:01:05
Grants, rail access, industrial access, recreational access, enhancement grants, things of that sort.
00:01:13
But until we do that, let's just ask Catherine, let's just count on meeting at 9 o'clock instead of 10 o'clock since you're here the evening before.
00:01:24
Anyway, I know that will help some of the board members.
00:01:27
The next meeting, by the way, as I think everyone has been informed, is in Lexington at the annual transportation meeting there.
00:01:41
Ion would be my first.
00:01:42
I understand we do workshop and the meeting all the same day on a Wednesday.
00:01:48
So you might note that change, that departure from the usual.
00:01:53
The next item is Jim Givens.
00:01:57
Jim is the Division Administrator of, you'll see there, Local Financial Assistance.
00:02:03
That's a new term.
00:02:05
This is part of the reorganization within VDOT by the Commissioner.
00:02:11
It's formerly Secondary Roads and Urban Roads Division.
00:02:18
So, Jim on Local Financial Assistance.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:02:23
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:02:26
The first item, item number four on your agenda involves the additions and abandonments of roads in the secondary system.
00:02:37
I'll be glad to answer any questions you have about that report.
00:02:41
For the month of August, we added 16.16 miles to the system.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:51
Any questions?
00:02:58
All right, let's see.
00:03:02
We need action.
00:03:04
It's been moved and seconded that we approve the additions and the abandonments in the secondary road system.
00:03:14
Any discussion?
00:03:15
All in favor please say aye.
00:03:17
Any opposed?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:03:21
The next item, item five,
00:03:25
is action on industrial access projects.
00:03:27
We have two projects coming before the board today.
00:03:33
One in the town of Abingdon.
00:03:35
We're recommending an allocation of $450,000 for a bonded project.
00:03:41
The second project is in Henry County.
00:03:48
We're recommending a $265,000 allocation for
00:03:54
I'll be glad to answer any specific questions to give you any more detail you'd like on those two projects.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:04:03
Mr. Chairman?
00:04:04
Yes.
SPEAKER_11
00:04:05
I noticed that one of these has a local match and the other doesn't.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:04:11
Yes, sir.
00:04:12
Could you explain that?
00:04:13
Yes, sir.
00:04:15
If the project is estimated to cost up to $300,000, we can make an allocation of up to $300,000
00:04:24
with no local match.
00:04:26
If it goes over $300,000, then we match it on a 50-50 basis, up to a maximum allocation of $450,000.
00:04:34
Okay.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:04:40
Move to approval of all committees.
00:04:42
Second.
00:04:43
Been moved and seconded.
00:04:44
Any discussion on the motion?
00:04:46
All in favor adopting the proposed resolution, please say aye.
00:04:49
Aye.
00:04:50
Any opposed?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:04:53
All right, number six, Jim.
00:04:56
The next item you have before you, if I could speak just a minute about the next three items collectively.
00:05:04
This is an annual event when each time this year we come before you asking you to approve the maintenance payments
00:05:15
to Arlington and Henrico County and to the cities and certain towns as well as to the Chesapeake Bay Tunnel Commission.
00:05:27
This money has already been included in your CTB budget and at this time of year we ask your approval to make quarterly payments
00:05:39
of this money, and we distribute it to these localities.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:05:51
Do you have a question?
00:05:56
It seems to me that the so-called cost factor or the maintenance cost index seems to vary from like Arlington to Henrico to the city of Richmond to what VDOT's own MCI is.
00:06:13
Can you enlighten us a little bit about how that comes to be?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:06:18
Well in 1986, this process was established in the code.
00:06:23
And we were given certain base rates, lane mileage rates, for the two counties.
00:06:32
And those were different rates at that point in time.
00:06:36
And then at that same time, for the cities, we were given two different mileage rates.
00:06:46
One for, I have to refer to my notes.
00:06:52
Okay.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:06:53
One for the arterials, hang on just a minute, for the principal and minor arterials and one for the collectors and the locals.
00:07:06
Those, we were instructed by the General Assembly in the code at that time to prepare what was called a maintenance cost index.
00:07:16
And that maintenance cost index is adjusted each year in August based on the previous year's
00:07:23
Maintenance Costs for VDOT.
00:07:27
It is a representative sample of some of our maintenance activities.
00:07:35
Part of the reason that has changed has been the fluctuation in the economy.
00:07:41
Also part of the reason that has changed is that over the years
00:07:46
This basket of activities, the way we go about them has changed.
00:07:52
For instance, mowing might have been one that we established in 1996.
00:07:58
We do most of that by contract now.
00:08:00
And it's difficult as the activity changes and our processes are refined, it's difficult to keep those exactly the same from year to year.
00:08:16
There has been discussion about this maintenance cost on the part of the localities and there has been some additional language included in the appropriation act recently that delegated to the board
00:08:39
the authority to make changes in that process or in those base rates.
00:08:49
That was done by the board in December for Henrico County and it was actually enacted following the legislative session when we got some additional enabling language.
00:09:10
That rate was adjusted last year for Henrico County.
00:09:14
The rates that are used to calculate today's payments are a combination of the maintenance cost index from last year plus an additional supplement that tries to recognize the prior to last year we were flatlining our maintenance program.
00:09:38
and we committed to, in the last budget, to raising that level on an annual basis and effectively what you've got here today is a 3.66% increase over last year as a result of that.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:54
For each of these jurisdictions?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:09:55
Yes sir.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:57
I'm sure they'll be glad to hear that.
00:10:01
Mr. Chairman, this is one of those issues that probably warrants some revisiting over the next year or so maybe?
00:10:09
It is being revisited.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:15
As you may recall from Barbara Reese's
00:10:18
In my presentation, I guess at the first workshop when most of you were here for the first time, there was a discussion about the sources of authority and the sources of funding.
00:10:32
And as she related, you've got statutory provisions from the code, and then you've got the Appropriations Act, which of course has a life of two years, but it overrides.
00:10:44
It can't override provisions in the code.
00:10:46
And the Appropriations Act gives this board the authority to apply an alternative way of addressing the maintenance cost.
00:10:59
It was done probably with Henrico County specifically in mind, but we factored in, we realized last spring we needed to do more for maintenance.
00:11:08
We said 4%, arbitrary figure, but better than 0%.
00:11:12
And we are relying upon the Language and Appropriations Act on a temporary basis to allow us to do this.
00:11:20
And the money is in the Six-Year Plan.
00:11:23
It was announced, as I said, in the spring and adopted by the Board in June.
00:11:28
We recognize there is some obsolete language in the code, and that does need to be addressed.
00:11:37
And Barbara, it's on her list, it's on my list of things that we need to look at.
00:11:43
Not sure we'll be ready for anything this coming winter, but it's a pretty, as I understand it, it's a complicated issue.
00:11:52
And we've got to be very careful about the methodology adopted to address
00:11:57
Not only the formula, but also what constitutes maintenance.
00:12:04
Judy?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:12:05
Oh, I was just going to move approval of the action.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:12:08
Any further discussion on that item?
00:12:11
Do we have a motion?
00:12:12
I've been moved and seconded.
00:12:15
Yeah, that's right.
00:12:15
Jerry had the discussion.
00:12:17
Any other discussion on the motion?
00:12:19
All right.
00:12:20
Yeah, we'll take these separately.
00:12:23
This is item six only, is that correct, Jim?
00:12:25
Yes, item... Or do you want to do them in a block?
00:12:29
Well, they're all separate.
00:12:30
Maybe we can do them in a block because we've got Arlington and Henrico in six.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:12:36
I did not explain the purpose of item seven.
00:12:39
Item seven is an adjustment in the mileage of certain specific cities.
00:12:47
One is Purcellville, City of Richmond,
00:12:50
Williamsburg, this is done on a routine basis during the year as the cities advise us that they've had changes in those mileage and that way we avoid bringing all of the changes in at one meeting at the end of the year but the payment is not effective
00:13:19
until the new year rates are approved.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:25
Okay and then item eight was the discussion I think of Jerry McCarthy's.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:13:34
That's correct.
00:13:36
Item six was the Arlington Henrico, the two counties that are not in the system.
00:13:40
Item seven is the change in mileage in four cities and item eight is the allocation for all of the cities.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:13:50
OK, everybody clear on the motions to adopt the proposed resolutions on items 6, 7, and 8?
00:13:57
OK. Any unreadings?
00:14:00
All in favor, please say aye.
00:14:02
Aye.
00:14:02
Any opposed?
00:14:04
Thank you, sir.
00:14:04
Thank you, Jim.
00:14:07
Next is Traffic Engineering Division Administrator, Alona Kastenhoff.
SPEAKER_00
00:14:13
Good morning Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
00:14:16
I have several items before you today.
00:14:20
The first one is item 9 on the agenda and that relates to changes in the primary system due to new construction.
00:14:32
Basically a curve was taken out of Route 11.
00:14:34
and it is in Montgomery County and as a result of the change of straightening this curve basically we need to take care of the old segments of the road
00:14:54
And so it is requested that the old portions would be, a piece of it would be abandoned, another piece discontinued, and another piece transferred to the secondary system.
00:15:09
And in your package you do have the map that shows these three elements of the old section.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:18
Anybody want to take these up separately or do you want to see how we go and take them in a block?
SPEAKER_00
00:15:24
There is just one more discontinuance or dealing with the result of reconstruction that is an action of abandonment that is in Middlesex County on Route 33.
00:15:39
These two items are similar items that there was a
00:15:42
A little bit of reconstruction and then the old road segments need to be either abandoned or transferred or discontinued.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:15:51
Any questions on the Middlesex County?
00:15:54
All right, let's go ahead and take up those two since they're similar.
00:15:58
We have a motion to adopt those two.
00:15:59
Move for approval, Mr. Chairman.
00:16:02
Been moved to have a second.
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:16:04
Second.
00:16:04
Any?
00:16:04
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:04
Any further discussion?
00:16:08
All in favor of adopting the proposed resolutions for item 9 and 10 say aye.
00:16:12
Aye.
00:16:12
Any opposed?
00:16:13
Thank you.
SPEAKER_00
00:16:14
Item 11.
00:16:17
Item 11 has two namings.
00:16:21
I had this type of items before you at the previous meeting.
00:16:25
One is relating to RAT 293 in the City of Danville, where the City Council of Danville requested to name the bridge on RAT 293 as Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Bridge, and the City of Danville has agreed to pay the cost of the signs.
00:16:46
The other naming request is in Wise County.
00:16:52
The Wise County Board of Supervisors requested to name a bridge on Route 158 of Charles Barrowman Sr., who was a highly respected member of the community working in the mining industry.
00:17:07
And the Wise County Board of Supervisors has agreed to pay the cost of the signs.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:13
Okay, do we have a motion on those two proposed resolutions for bridge designations?
00:17:20
Moved and seconded by whom?
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:24
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:25
Okay, any further discussion?
00:17:28
I have a question.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:29
Question.
00:17:30
From time to time we have people with VDOT who are actually killed in the line of work.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:17:37
Dr. Stone, yes, and we are also
00:17:52
Looking into the possibility of a more permanent memorial for employees killed in the line of duty, our work, the work done out on the roads, is the fourth most dangerous job in terms of fatalities in the nation.
00:18:12
It's not something that you think about frequently, and we are looking for a way to do that internally without any cost
00:18:21
to the taxpayers because we feel that strongly about doing it and in a couple months we'll be prepared to brief you.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:30
I hope we take some of these public opportunities to do that too because that's a significant sacrifice we ought to reckon on.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:39
Any other comments?
00:18:41
Motions before us?
00:18:42
All in favor please say aye.
00:18:45
Aye.
00:18:45
Any opposed?
00:18:46
All right.
00:18:48
Item 12.
SPEAKER_00
00:18:50
This item relates to the parking ordinance that York County has.
00:18:54
The original first version of the ordinance was approved by the board in June of this year and this is basically an amended ordinance adding more communities on the parking ordinance.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:12
Any questions?
00:19:13
Hobie?
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:15
Yes.
00:19:17
Hobie?
00:19:18
What do you call a large vehicle?
00:19:22
It talks about large vehicles, prohibiting large vehicles.
00:19:25
That could be a lot of things.
00:19:27
My SUV could be a large vehicle or trucks.
SPEAKER_00
00:19:31
What is a large vehicle designed as?
00:19:37
I am sure that it's in the original ordinance that is defined somewhere.
SPEAKER_02
00:19:44
I move to be approved.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:45
Yeah, presume that that's defined in their local ordinance.
00:19:48
We just ask to adopt approval.
00:19:52
All right, do we have a motion?
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:54
I didn't want to get a ticket, but I parked it on the street.
SPEAKER_02
00:19:58
Good question.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:59
All right, all in favor, please say aye.
00:20:02
Aye.
00:20:02
Any opposed?
00:20:04
All right.
00:20:05
Then item 13.
SPEAKER_00
00:20:07
Yes, this item is about the manual on uniform traffic control devices that is affectionately called as the MUTCD and that is the Bible of the traffic engineering community to do our work.
00:20:20
Adoption of this manual by the states is a federal requirement.
00:20:25
Currently we are using the 1988 edition and the Federal Highway Administration published a new edition which is called the Millennium Edition and the purpose of this resolution to adopt this latest edition of the MUTCD.
00:20:46
This is the book that we are talking about that is the latest version of this.
SPEAKER_07
00:20:52
Move approval of adoption, having studied it carefully.
SPEAKER_11
00:20:58
Second and a question.
00:21:03
This is just a curiosity, not argument.
00:21:08
What is the reason for the temporary control being accepted from that?
SPEAKER_00
00:21:19
Other than approving the federal manual, the states have one option that is if we are having some practice that is exceeding the federal practice.
00:21:34
And our current practice that relates to construction zones, we are exceeding the federal practice.
SPEAKER_11
00:21:45
And we are- So how more complete and better than theirs?
SPEAKER_00
00:21:48
That's correct, and we are planning to continue that practice, that we do exceed the federal requirements when it comes to work zones.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:57
There are obviously, between this version and the last version, there's got to be some obvious changes to the manual in some respects.
00:22:09
Things that are in the review process right now and being processed through the system for installation of the various things that's applicable to, are some of those things grandfathered under the old, in other words, new applications or new processes to put in the things that this deals with?
00:22:25
Any other discussion?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:55
The commissioner I talked about, you know, be nice if we don't have to get the board too involved in items like this because I know you, despite your best intentions, you're probably not going to read that manual.
00:23:11
But we have one member, which is why Judy got on the board.
00:23:17
She had read the manual.
00:23:20
But, Tom, if you'll note some of these whereases, you know, the law requires the board to approve standards like these, and so it's not...
00:23:35
Perhaps as exciting a topic as we would like to see on the agenda, but nevertheless, it's important.
00:23:41
Also, our good counselor, Mr. Walton, has reminded me of the importance that we do go through this process to make it very clear that we have acted in case any issue and litigation were ever to arise about the authority of VDOT to have applied a standard that hadn't been approved by the board.
00:24:04
If there's no other discussion on that item, all in favor of the motion, please say aye.
00:24:11
Any opposed?
00:24:13
Thank you.
00:24:13
Thank you very much.
00:24:15
Next we have Arthur Taylor on the right-of-way in Tilties Division, action on surplus property.
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:24:23
Mr. Chairman, members of the board, good morning.
00:24:25
We have one item on the agenda this morning, Route 199 in James City County, and we would recommend your approval for disposal of this and allow the Commission to execute a deed.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:35
So moved, Mr. Chairman.
00:24:36
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:38
Any other, any, motion been made in second, any discussion?
00:24:43
All in favor of the proposed resolution, please say aye.
00:24:46
Aye.
00:24:46
Any opposed?
00:24:48
Thank you all.
00:24:48
Thank you Mr. Taylor.
00:24:49
The next item you'll see, and this is another example of the Civil War canon, I think we can go forward on this for Mr. Opperman, but we need a slight change in the wording of the resolution, is that correct?
SPEAKER_10
00:25:03
Yes sir, based upon some advice from Mr. Walton.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:06
All right, are you ready to go forward with it today?
00:25:08
Yes.
00:25:09
All right, it says withdrawn in your book, but ignore that.
00:25:12
I want to go ahead and get this out of the way so we won't have to bring up this cannon again.
SPEAKER_07
00:25:17
Okay, Mr. Opperman.
SPEAKER_10
00:25:20
What I'm recommending in terms of an amendment is to strike the last whereas clause, which references essentially the caboose bill, and amend and add to the resolution clause at the end
00:25:35
so that the end of that clause would read, pending appropriate authorization by the Virginia General Assembly.
00:25:46
This reflects the fact that transfer of property in excess of a value of $200 needs to be in the budget bill.
00:25:56
And this will allow us to go ahead and take an action.
00:25:59
This closes the loop from a resolution that the Highway Commission passed in 1980
00:26:05
Loaning the canon to the Museum of the Confederacy.
00:26:09
We're able to close the loop with another resolution pending action by the General Assembly this upcoming season.
00:26:17
Any objections to the donation of the canon?
SPEAKER_07
00:26:20
Is there any restriction placed on the museum as to what they can eventually do with the canon?
SPEAKER_10
00:26:26
No.
00:26:27
In fact, I went back through a surprisingly extensive file that we had on this canon to make sure that we haven't inherited any restrictions from the federal government where we obtained it from in 1932.
SPEAKER_07
00:26:43
So if the museum wanted to sell the cannon, they could do so?
SPEAKER_10
00:26:46
Theoretically, yes ma'am.
00:26:49
They've been taking good care of it for 20 years.
SPEAKER_07
00:26:53
I'm just thinking 50 years down the road, you know, the museum falls into financial straits because they're, you know, I would think maybe we'd want to impose a restriction on this resale or some kind of a transfer back.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:09
Okay, we need a motion.
00:27:12
I move the resolution as amended.
00:27:15
They have been moved and seconded that the resolution as amended be adopted.
00:27:20
Any other questions?
00:27:22
All in favor please say aye.
00:27:24
Aye.
00:27:24
Any opposed?
00:27:25
Thank you.
00:27:28
Next, Mr. Robertson, Division Administrator for the Intelligent Transportation System Division.
SPEAKER_09
00:27:35
Thank you, Mr.
00:27:37
Chair and members of the board.
00:27:38
There are two items.
00:27:40
The first is to request your approval of a contract, a cooperative agreement with the Federal Highway Administration.
00:27:49
This was a competitive solicitation that was issued by the Federal Highway Administration.
00:27:55
VDOT submitted a proposal.
00:27:57
We still don't know if we were selected.
00:28:01
We were shortlisted.
00:28:02
We submitted our best and final offer.
00:28:06
They tell us that it may be September 29th before they get their paperwork done, but they also tell us that we have to sign it by September 30th.
00:28:18
So we're asking for your approval of the resolution to allow the commissioner to sign on your behalf if VDOT is selected for this project.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:27
It has been moved and seconded.
00:28:31
Any questions?
SPEAKER_07
00:28:33
20 seconds on what it is.
SPEAKER_09
00:28:36
Sure.
00:28:37
It's the use of data that's stored to
00:28:49
To analyze the performance of the system, for instance, we collect data from our smart traffic centers and other sensors, volume data.
00:28:59
We're developing performance measures as one example.
00:29:06
There's a half a dozen being considered nationally, but to be able to monitor the performance of the system from a congestion standpoint, so if we make an improvement, we can monitor the improvement, I mean the benefits of that improvement.
00:29:25
And these are new measures that really haven't been in existence before, and they're really trying to measure it from the
00:29:34
Dr, the user standpoint, things that the user can relate to as opposed to average travel times and other, reliability.
00:29:45
People, if you know that a trip's going to take 30 minutes, and you plan for 30 minutes, and you get there in 30 minutes, they're happy.
00:29:57
Even though on a Sunday morning it may only take 15 minutes.
00:30:00
It's when it takes 45 minutes it gets us upset, or an hour.
00:30:05
And so we're trying to measure that, say that differential, and have finer measures of the performance of the system.
00:30:12
so that we can fine tune our improvements that address the problems that are causing those performance problems.
00:30:20
It's something that we've been working on in Virginia already and we're really excited about the opportunity here because it's really extra money that supports what we're already deeply involved with.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:39
Congratulations.
00:30:40
Yeah.
00:30:41
Thank you.
00:30:43
Harry?
SPEAKER_02
00:30:43
I'd just like to note that we often complain about things taking a lot of time.
00:30:47
I think it's noteworthy that we're proving something in advance.
SPEAKER_09
00:30:54
We have our fingers crossed.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:56
Well, you put the cannon in that same category.
00:31:02
Okay, any other questions about this opportunity with the Federalist Feds?
00:31:09
All in favor, please say aye.
SPEAKER_09
00:31:11
Aye.
00:31:12
Any opposed?
00:31:14
Item 17 is what's called a partnership agreement with the Federal Highway Administration.
00:31:19
This actually involves funds that were earmarked by Congress in the 2002 U.S.
00:31:24
DOT appropriations bill for the Washington, D.C. metropolitan area.
00:31:31
The federal procedures require that the funds come through one of the state departments of transportation between among Maryland State Highway Administration, VDOT, and the District of Columbia Department of Transportation.
00:31:50
We've traditionally sort of rotated as these earmarks come up in Virginia.
00:31:56
has agreed to sign the agreement and handle the funds for this particular grant.
00:32:11
We will work with the regional partners and the Council of Governments to execute it.
00:32:15
We don't anticipate that
00:32:17
VDOT will actually manage this project, but the funds by federal procedures, one of the states has to take responsibility for the funding.
00:32:29
And this is again related to data, and trying to take all the data we have in real time in Maryland, D.C., Virginia, the transit systems, and integrate it all together,
00:32:43
to improve so we can look at the region as a whole instead of individual jurisdictions or individual roadways.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:32:52
Okay, been moved.
00:32:54
Do we have a second?
00:32:55
Mr. Davies, any further discussion?
00:32:58
All in favor, please say aye.
00:33:01
Aye.
00:33:01
Any opposed?
00:33:01
Thank you.
00:33:02
Thank you.
00:33:04
Mal Kerley, Chief Engineer, Construction Division, one item, 18.
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:33:12
I'm going to go over the bids that we received that Frank talked about yesterday.
00:33:16
It was in tab two of the booklet that Frank gave to you yesterday.
00:33:22
We had 13 projects that were below the engineer's estimate, one that was above that I'm recommending we award and one that we rejected, plus eight other projects by other, the enhancement projects and the ones from the administrative services.
00:33:38
On page one, you have the interstate projects that we have.
00:33:45
Number two on that list is the one that was
00:33:53
Let's see, one that was above the engineer's estimate and basically when we went over there and reviewed that particular project, our estimate was off because of these bridges, the access to get to the work, we didn't consider that.
00:34:13
It's going to be such that you're going to have to build some scaffolding down there, you're going to have to
00:34:17
Buckett, the concrete down there, and we felt that after we took that into consideration, redid our estimate, it fell in with the bid that we had, so I'm going to recommend that we award that particular one, even though it was over our initial engineer's estimate.
00:34:34
The third one on that particular list is the Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project and passports have asked us to point out any of the Woodrow Wilson Bridge Projects.
00:34:44
This one has to do with ITS type variable message signs, closed circuit television, highway advisory radio and alert signs that are going on that particular project.
00:34:57
On page two, our primary system, the first one, that is the final phase of the loop encircling the city of Stanton, 262, and we'll complete that particular project out there.
00:35:11
On page three, we go into the secondary system.
00:35:19
Number two on the list is the beaver concern that Mr. McCarthy called about.
00:35:24
We had some initial environmental review that there was no impact, and by the time we got out there, there was a beaver that built a little dam that created a wetland impact of 0.12 acres, so we had to go back to the regulatory agency and resolve that.
00:35:41
On page four, really nothing of significance on page four.
00:35:48
On page five, this is the first project that we have under the rural rustic road improvement law that was passed by the General Assembly in the session of 202.
00:36:03
This bill doesn't come into effect until July of 2003.
00:36:06
The local assistance division is working, trying to establish this program.
00:36:15
The law gives local governing bodies working with a department the right to designate a road or segment of a road as a rural rustic road.
00:36:26
And so when they're designated, that improvements can utilize paved surfaces with based on reduced and flexible standards that leave the roadbed undisturbed but without compromising public safety.
00:36:40
So Jim Givens and his group, we've done some in VDOT state forces on a few projects.
00:36:48
This is the first one that we're actually advertising.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:36:51
Let me point out, this was of great interest.
00:36:56
Out in Bristol earlier this week the Rural Rustic Program and so James, Jim, this is one that your boards of supervisors were very interested in pursuing because of the big cost savings if you can deal with the safety issue.
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:37:12
Right, yes sir.
00:37:14
On page six, number two on that list is the one that we're recommending that you reject.
00:37:22
These were for overhead signs on various interstates.
00:37:26
Reviewing the documents, we did have a good number of bidders, about everybody in the game, but the unknowns that the contractors had at the time, we felt that if we could clarify our documents a little bit better and go back out, that it would be the appropriate thing to do.
00:37:40
So I'm recommending that.
00:37:42
One be rejected.
00:37:44
The next seven, eight, nine, ten, and
00:37:56
14 are all enhancement projects that we talked about a little bit yesterday.
00:38:04
Most of these are phase type enhancement projects where they are accomplishing a portion of what they want to do and this is what Barbara was talking about yesterday as to go to get new enhancement projects or try to come back and finish up the ones that have already been
00:38:24
Approved on page 11, excuse me, on page 12 is an administrative services contract to remove pavement markings.
00:38:39
They're using contract help for that because of the hazardous condition of removing the pavement markings.
00:38:45
Disposing of that, VDOT will come back in there and paint the lines back on the pavements, and then the rumble strips on page 13 is an on-call.
00:39:00
There are certain locations that we are going to be able, going to install those, and then that contract would allow us to come back and bring somebody in in other areas that we need it.
00:39:12
And I think that covers all unless there's any questions.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:15
I'm going to move the question, but I have a follow-up after we do the question.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:22
I've been moved and seconded that we adopt the recommendations on these contracts.
00:39:32
Alright, discussion.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:33
Obie?
00:39:34
You know, yesterday we were going through a lot of the projects and Mr. Baldwin had mentioned that many of our contracts are very draconian.
00:39:44
And with all the other things, I know we have a lot of things going on.
00:39:49
If we start looking at some of these contracts with these bids, obviously we'll need contracts with them or is that the process to look at some of those things so we close the loop on things we think are inappropriate or should be added?
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:40:01
As part of the reorganization, the construction division, as it was formerly known, has been split into two different areas.
00:40:10
Scheduling and contract development that's under me and the construction management that's under Frank.
00:40:16
And that's one of the things Frank and I have talked about, that we need to make sure that the contract language that we put out is sufficient to do what we want to do.
00:40:25
And so that's one area we're going to be working on, Mr. Mitchell.
SPEAKER_11
00:40:30
Jim Has there been absolute assurance that the money is there to pay for each and every one of these contracts?
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:40:38
Yes sir, there has.
00:40:41
Barbara Reese won't let us advertise any that there's not money.
00:40:45
What we do now is we check everything through her to make sure there is funding available for the projects we have.
00:40:50
Yes sir.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:52
Thank you for the question.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:54
Mr. Bowie, I will not sign any planned title sheets without Mrs. Reese's previous signature before it comes to me and that includes title sheets that have the signature of the former finance person on it.
00:41:14
That's a control that we have in place.
00:41:16
Mr. Chairman, if I may, just take one or two additional minutes while we're on this topic.
00:41:23
You know, every night before you lay down, sometimes you run the day through your mind again, and I felt that yesterday we somewhat ended the discussion on contracting on a sour note, because we are focused on work orders and overruns.
00:41:39
I want to tell you that I have been very pleased with the partnership we have and the improvements in the partnership that we're trying to make with our contractors.
00:41:53
Contractors deliver our program.
00:41:57
It's not acceptable to not have a good relationship with them.
00:42:02
The leadership of the Virginia Road Builders and the Old Dominion Highway Contractors
00:42:08
have opened their doors and I think they've probably always been open for the staff and me to talk with them to learn how we can each improve our part in that partnership.
00:42:23
So I felt like I should have said that yesterday and did, I mean these are good people trying to do good business just like us and I am really confident that
00:42:36
A lot of these things that have led to some wedges between us and contractors are going to get solved.
00:42:45
I mean, they're going to spend one and a half billion of your dollars this year.
00:42:50
It's just not an option to not have a good relationship.
00:42:56
I know we're headed on a good path there.
SPEAKER_11
00:43:01
Does any of these enhancement projects complete any of the projects that are in the system or are still several phases left?
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:43:12
I believe there's one in there that does.
00:43:15
I was looking over that just before I came down here and some of them, quite frankly, you don't have to do the other phases to get something out of it, but of the, I think there was one extra that we added.
00:43:30
I think there's six of them.
00:43:32
I think one of them, from what I could read, completed it.
00:43:36
The majority of them could be stand-alone if you didn't fund phase two, three, and four.
00:43:43
Or however many phases they had.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:43:46
James, it was my observation from this past spring that very few of the enhancement projects received full funding.
00:43:57
Because there wasn't enough money and people wanted to spread it about.
00:44:01
I think that's more the norm.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:05
Any further discussion?
00:44:07
Jerry?
00:44:09
Well I'll say that when we discuss enhancement projects in the future because I mean we did this for two or three years a while back and I gather there's been quite a few rule changes since the program started out ten years ago and it started out with no promises made for subsequent years and I think personally that was a good way to operate.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:30
Okay, any further discussion on the motion to accept the recommendations on the bid results?
00:44:37
All in favor say aye.
00:44:39
Aye.
00:44:39
Any opposed?
00:44:40
Thank you, ma'am.
00:44:42
Next, Mohammed on the location and design division.
00:44:48
Mohammed Marshari.
SPEAKER_08
00:44:51
Good morning.
00:44:52
Mr. Secretary, this is the first time that I'm appearing before the new board and I'm going to just very briefly let you know what I do.
00:45:01
I'm the state location design engineer and I have oversight responsibilities for designing roadways throughout the state.
00:45:09
I've got two items, items number 19 and 20 in line with the Secretary's comment earlier that I guess we need to be quick.
00:45:18
I can give you as much information as you need or as little as you want and I can give you all the information in front of you.
00:45:27
I can briefly go over it and if you have any questions I'll be more than happy to address your concerns.
00:45:33
Item number 19 is a location, a public hearing that took place on May 9, 2002 to replace Robertson Bridge in the city of Danville.
00:45:45
What we are doing on this, we are replacing a two-lane bridge with a four-lane bridge.
00:45:50
We had four alternatives and a no-build option, and we are recommending alternative number four, which was endorsed by the city.
00:46:00
I'll be more than happy to answer any kind of questions you may have.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:05
Mr. Chairman, I will move this one unless you want to take them both together.
00:46:09
Do you want to take them separately or together?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:15
This is location over, this is location design, let's go ahead and take them separately.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:19
I move item 19.
00:46:22
Second.
00:46:23
Discussion?
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:24
Hobie?
00:46:27
This has only been funded for preliminary engineering only.
SPEAKER_02
00:46:30
Yes.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:31
We have enough on our budget to cover the preliminary engineering only?
SPEAKER_08
00:46:38
Yes, we have actually, so far, $17 million has been allocated in the Six-Year Plan for this project, which is way beyond preliminary engineering.
00:46:47
We don't have enough money for the construction, but...
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:49
Excuse me?
SPEAKER_08
00:46:53
Some of the right-of-way, exactly.
00:46:57
It's fully funded for engineering and some of the right-of-way and maybe a little bit of construction.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:04
As a general question, because I know we're going to have projects where we're not going to be able to.
00:47:08
We have money there beyond preliminary engineering to get it to some level.
00:47:13
I think from the experience from, let's say, that Gainesville and St.
00:47:17
Guy 66, it was going to be substantially a larger project, but we had money there, a substantial amount of money.
00:47:23
So we decided, let's build and do what we can afford to do.
00:47:27
Later on, due projects as they come up.
00:47:29
This may be one where we focus on buying a right-of-way and constructing things as we have enough money for.
00:47:37
So let's do what we can do with the money that's available.
00:47:39
And this, I don't know if this is a project that's applicable for something like that, but... Mr. Mitchell, these are allocated money.
SPEAKER_08
00:47:45
They're not necessarily cash, so we need to be aware of it.
00:47:49
These will come, the next six years we'll have this money.
00:47:52
We are just allocating this.
SPEAKER_02
00:47:56
Any other questions?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:59
Do we need to ever see things like the volume of traffic across these things or I guess we take that for granted that the need is there?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:10
Look, I think you'll see it.
SPEAKER_08
00:48:16
The information is all in the packet that you have.
00:48:18
At least I'm told you have received it.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:23
Any other discussion on the motion?
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:27
Hobie?
00:48:29
The alignment, several alignments.
00:48:32
Yes sir.
00:48:34
One of them goes right, it looks like it goes right into a residential area.
00:48:40
Okay.
00:48:41
And several of them do, some of them don't.
00:48:45
I guess my experience has been when you do that, a lot of public opinion of that, I guess this alternative has been
SPEAKER_08
00:48:57
It's gone through the process.
00:48:59
The city has endorsed it.
00:49:01
Actually, what we're doing, we're aligning it with Park Avenue in order to make it more in line with the flow of traffic.
00:49:07
The other one would have been a T-intersection.
00:49:09
This is a four-lane intersection.
00:49:11
That's really where it should be.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:49:15
Any further discussion?
00:49:17
All in favor of the motion, please say aye.
00:49:19
Aye.
00:49:19
Any opposed?
00:49:20
All right, Muhammad.
SPEAKER_08
00:49:21
All right, the item number 20 is the, we had a location design public hearing for Len Haven Parkway in the City of Virginia Beach.
00:49:30
This roadway at this time is a two-lane roadway with gaps in it.
00:49:36
It's not continuous.
00:49:37
So this project will fill those gaps and provide four 12-foot lanes with raised medians and sidewalks to the citizens.
00:49:51
A location design public hearing was held in May 15, 2000, two years ago.
00:49:55
There has been some concerns over this project and the city and the department has been working very diligently with the citizens to resolve those issues and that's why it has taken us two years to bring this before the board.
00:50:09
I'll be more than happy to answer any kind of questions you may have.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:15
Been moved and seconded.
00:50:18
Discussion on the motion?
00:50:21
If there's no discussion, all in favor of adopting the proposed resolution, please say aye.
00:50:30
Aye.
00:50:31
Any opposed?
00:50:38
Next item is Barbara Reese and John Larson in for Barbara Reese.
00:50:45
These are two very important issues, the first of which I think Barbara Reese reviewed at the workshop last month.
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:50:54
John?
00:50:54
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
00:50:57
I'm John Lawson, the Director of the Financial Planning Division.
00:51:01
We have two items to present to you this morning.
00:51:03
The first one is for the resolution authorizing the issuance and sale of revenue and refunding bonds for Nova Virginia Transportation District and for Route 58 corridor program.
00:51:15
I think Barbara briefed you in July on both of these plans.
00:51:20
What we are looking to do is to sell about $170 million in relation to North Virginia Transportation District.
00:51:27
About $50 million of that is new money for additional projects in the corridor.
00:51:32
For Route 58, it's solely a refunding sale of about $80 million.
00:51:40
With your approval of this item, this will go forward to the Treasury Board for approval next week, and then would go forth for sale the end of October.
00:51:50
Mr. Chairman, since my firm is involved in these items, I want those who are making comments.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:56
I will have the record, so note.
00:51:59
Ms. Shamblin, just a question.
00:52:01
What happens on the refunding portion of this money, the debt service savings, where does that money go?
00:52:09
Does that stay with the department or what happens?
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:52:13
Typically it would stay with the program.
00:52:15
At this point the actual usage of that savings hasn't been identified.
00:52:21
Do you know how much it is?
00:52:23
What would it be estimated?
00:52:24
As the resolution reads, we are requiring at least a 4% savings on the aggregate.
00:52:31
So with the NVTD sale, you're looking at about $5 million in debt service savings and about $3 million on the 58 issue.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:42
But we don't know whether that stays within our monies that are available to us.
00:52:49
What it does is it reduces the need for debt service.
00:52:53
And so the effect of that is what?
00:52:56
Construction.
00:52:58
More construction.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:02
Thank you.
00:53:04
Any other questions on that first item, item 21?
00:53:09
Do we have a motion?
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:11
All right, Phil.
00:53:11
Yesterday we got a booklet giving us some information about our debt and the presentation made to the Standard and Poor's that goes from Moody to Ross.
00:53:21
And it shows the total debt service will reach about $122 million that registered with you.
00:53:27
I mean, we're talking right now.
00:53:29
Does that include all that we're looking at right now?
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:53:33
I can answer that question.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:37
That's everything after we take action.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:43
That was assuming that you would take this action.
00:53:47
Actually that was my question.
00:53:48
Does this also have anything to do with 28 as well?
00:53:52
No.
00:53:53
It does.
SPEAKER_09
00:53:54
Three and a half million of the new money.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:59
R for the Route 28 parallel roads, which are Atlantic and Pacific, so there will be three and a half million for Atlantic and Pacific.
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:54:08
So of the 50 million in the new money for MBTD, that's what you're referring to?
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:11
Right, that's part of that PPTA then.
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:54:12
Yeah, I was thinking you were talking about the 28th sale.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:15
No, no, this is, I was thinking of the other rows.
00:54:17
It's really the secondary part of that.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:19
Move the adoption.
00:54:19
James.
00:54:20
I have been moved.
00:54:22
Second.
00:54:23
Second.
00:54:24
I have been moved and accepted to adopt the proposed resolution.
00:54:27
Any further discussion?
00:54:29
All in favor, please say aye.
00:54:31
Aye.
00:54:31
All opposed, no.
00:54:33
Thank you.
00:54:33
No no's and one extension.
John W. Lawson
Financial Planning Division Director
00:54:37
Thank you.
00:54:37
The second item this morning is Item Number 22.
00:54:42
It is a resolution that is to grant the Commissioner of VDOT the authority to enter into agreements with the Maryland State Highway Administration and the District of Columbia Department of Transportation relating to the Woodrow Wilson Bridge.
00:54:58
The current state code requires that agreements with other states be entered into by the Commonwealth Transportation Board.
00:55:07
With the magnitude of the Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project and the financing plan that's in place and the cooperative nature between Virginia, Maryland and the District of Columbia, we found the need to have
00:55:22
Portions of work administered by one of the agencies on behalf of another agency.
00:55:28
The first, we have two drafts of agreements already in play.
00:55:32
One is with Maryland, relating to the General Engineering Consultant contract, and another one, same type of work with the District of Columbia.
00:55:43
What we're asking is that the board grant the commissioner the authority to enter into those agreements as well as to enter into future agreements that will be needed for work, actual construction work that will be done by one state or agency on behalf of another because it fits in better with work efficiencies and scheduling and so forth.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:08
Move for approval Mr. Chairman.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:10
Thank you.
00:56:12
Then move to the second discussion, Hobie.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:16
I think Maryland has the responsibility of building the bridge within the waters.
00:56:24
And there have sole responsibility if there's any overruns involved with that, that is on, they have to effectively come up with a money difference between what the federal government's given them, what they've already allocated into the project.
00:56:38
Virginia's portion of it, if there's any overruns on that side, we're responsible.
00:56:42
We're proceeding forward with the project on the Virginia side, and I know they're coming out of the water with piers, caissons, but what's the scuttlebutt on what's going on with the Maryland bidding process with the bridge, because I know there's concern there.
Malcolm T. Kerley
Chief Engineer
00:57:00
Marilyn did put out the bridge project.
00:57:10
It was about 75% over their estimate.
00:57:12
As you indicated, they are responsible for the bridge and their two interchanges were responsible for ours.
00:57:18
They had a special group get together.
00:57:22
They did some value engineering things.
00:57:24
Where they are right now is they've advertised the bash gill spans, the movable portions.
00:57:29
They're going to build that.
00:57:31
Then the approaches from Virginia and approaches from Maryland, they're going to advertise the approaches to
00:57:38
from Maryland.
00:57:39
They've offered to let us build the approaches to Virginia, but the Commissioner respectfully turned that down, and they will be advertising that.
00:57:50
Their bids, I believe, come in, I think it's the day after the election in Maryland, but in November the 7th, and then they are going to be advertising their approach spans after that.
00:58:04
So,
00:58:06
We are working with them reviewing things.
00:58:12
They're now going to redesign the superstructure, go from a box to an eye girder as about a $50 million savings is what they think.
00:58:23
And we're involved in that, Nick Nicholson, and I'm on the ad hoc committee that's overviewing that.
00:58:31
They're in a little flux until they find out exactly what the bids that come in from the project they have on right now on the street.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:44
Any other questions on the motion?
00:58:49
If no further discussion, all in favor of the proposed resolution, please say aye.
00:58:57
Aye.
00:58:59
Any opposed?
00:59:01
Thank you, John.
00:59:02
Thank you.
00:59:05
Next item on the agenda is a proposed resolution from the board that would indicate the board's endorsement of the Northern Virginia Hampton Roads transportation referendum.
00:59:22
Now, this action is obviously not required of us, but it is before us to give us an opportunity to show our endorsement as a transportation policy board of these two regional referenda.
00:59:41
If anyone has any questions about the proposed resolution as written, I'd be glad to try to answer them.
00:59:51
Otherwise, the resolution is before us for a motion if you so deem it appropriate.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:59
Mr. Chairman, I'll move it and have some comments after.
01:00:04
I'll second it.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:06
All right, moved and seconded.
01:00:07
The motion is properly before us.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:10
Hobie?
01:00:11
I know we've been communicating, Harry and I have been talking, and I know Helen's had a lot of involvement in this as well as Julia, Kenny, everybody's been involved.
01:00:21
This is such an important part of Virginia's movement towards dealing with the air quality issues in Northern Virginia, transit related stuff, environmental issues,
01:00:32
And it's a road referendum decided by the voters.
01:00:36
It's in North Virginia.
01:00:38
It's already been endorsed by the County of Fairfax, Prince William, Arlington, City of Manassas, Alexandria, Manassas Park, Washington Metropolitan Airports Authority, Town of Leesburg,
01:00:48
All the chambers in Northern Virginia have endorsed it.
01:00:52
U.S.
01:00:52
Congressmen, U.S.
01:00:54
Senators in Northern Virginia.
01:00:58
I think this has got a lot of support for doing this.
01:01:02
I think we've heard arguments on
01:01:05
On the tax side, environmental issues.
01:01:08
But I tell you, this goes a long way of solving a lot of stuff in North Virginia.
01:01:11
I know, Harry, it's a big thing for down in your areas.
01:01:15
And whatever we can do to help each other to push this, I think this is one of the more important decisions we have in the state as it deals with transportation.
01:01:23
Anyway, that's all my comments.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:01:27
All right, thank you.
SPEAKER_02
01:01:30
Harry?
01:01:32
I echo and support all that was just said.
01:01:35
It's very important.
01:01:38
The governor and the legislature have given us this chance to vote to make it happen, and I think this body supporting those efforts is a good public way to say that there isn't any money in it for themselves to pay for these projects, and I wish we didn't have to do it, but there's no good alternative, so I
01:02:03
I heartily support the effort and hope this group will, too.
01:02:09
I'd like to say, as someone who doesn't live in the area, I certainly support it.
01:02:13
And I'm wondering if there are any things that we can do that are meaningful.
01:02:19
Send money.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:19
Send money to support it.
01:02:22
Thank you.
01:02:23
That's right.
01:02:25
If there's something we can ever do meaningful that we should do, so is that.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:32
Okay, any further discussion?
01:02:35
If there is none, then all in favor of the motion, please say aye.
SPEAKER_11
01:02:39
Aye.
01:02:39
Any opposed?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:42
Very good.
01:02:43
Thank you for that.
01:02:44
Under new business, we do have a very important item and we'll call on our commissioner to bring you up to date and this concerns a this
01:03:02
New item represents a great deal of hard work by the Commissioner and a lot of folks at VDOT to give us an opportunity to get out in front of a very important issue, and that is the improvements for the I-81 card under the PPTA process.
01:03:25
So, Philip, the floor is yours.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:28
Thank you, Mr. Secretary, members of the Board.
01:03:31
In early August, as you know, I returned five proposals that were submitted to VDOT under the Public Private Transportation Act that was passed back in 1995.
01:03:43
My decision to return those proposals had nothing to do with the quality or the merit of the proposals, quite frankly.
01:03:53
It had everything to do with a strong belief that VDOT needs to lead this process more often than it is led by the process.
01:04:04
In other words, put an emphasis on solicited proposals as opposed to reacting to numerous unsolicited proposals.
01:04:13
I also believe strongly that it is important that when considering use of processes other than normal competitive bidding processes, the Procurement Act, that at the same time we solicit proposals, we do it in a way that generates the most competition that we possibly can in the private sector.
01:04:39
With I-81 in particular, we are doing everything possible in this solicitation to inspire creativity, innovation, competition, so that we can bring the best and the brightest ideas to the table through this PPTA process.
01:04:59
I said in August that we would have a solicitation for proposals back on the street by October 1st.
01:05:07
I want to tell you, thanks to a lot of good hard work, but there's a quiet young man sitting in the back by the name of George Clendenin.
01:05:15
George, stand up for a minute.
01:05:17
Thanks to George Clendenin's leadership today at two o'clock,
01:05:23
We will be releasing the RFP for the solicitation of public-private proposals for Interstate 81.
01:05:34
The solicitation will be posted on our website at 2 p.m. At the same time, I'll do a press briefing for any questions from the press because we did that when we pulled these five proposals
01:05:47
Back in August, based on many ideas from our own folks as well as from citizens along I-81 during previous studies we've done, we have developed a list of issues that we believe are critical
01:06:08
to the future development of I-81.
01:06:10
The RFP is written in such a way that proposers will be able to respond to all of those issues, some of those issues, or issues that perhaps we hadn't thought about.
01:06:25
I wouldn't encourage anyone to ignore all of them, but we're certainly looking for more creativity there.
01:06:32
We're doing that, as I said, to generate more competition for the effort along I-81.
01:06:37
We want to receive proposals that truly consider mobility, not just moving cars and trucks but moving people and goods.
01:06:46
We're asking folks to take a hard look.
01:06:48
at the ability to move some future freight movements to rail if that's possible.
01:06:56
We are also emphasizing the use of technology in the corridor because that may generate some interesting short, mid, or long-term possibilities.
01:07:07
We will have three pre-proposal meetings along the I-81 corridor, August 1, 2, and 3.
01:07:14
Those will be October, since August did pass.
01:07:18
Thank you, counselor.
01:07:19
October 1, 2, and 3.
01:07:22
And those will be an opportunity for firms that are interested in submitting proposals
01:07:29
To come and ask questions about the RFP, it will also be an opportunity for other stakeholder groups to express items of concern to them for Interstate 81.
01:07:42
Within two weeks of the last meeting, we will post on our website
01:07:48
The transcripts from those three meetings so that proposers will certainly be able to refresh their memory of what occurred at those meetings as well as allowing the public an opportunity to view the comments that were received from those meetings.
01:08:07
Following that, we have what's a very tight schedule.
01:08:10
Proposals will be due, conceptual proposals will be due to VDOT on January 17, 2003.
01:08:18
Now that is a tight schedule.
01:08:21
That's about four months from today to put together a meaningful proposal.
01:08:30
By February 14,
01:08:33
A month later we'll make a decision on whether or not we're going to move one or more proposals on to the next step in the process.
01:08:44
By July the 11th we will select one or more proposals
01:08:50
for negotiations into the comprehensive agreement stay and our target is by September 30th to complete contract negotiations and enter into a comprehensive agreement.
01:09:04
A very aggressive schedule and for those that have been involved in the PPTA process, I think would agree with me on that.
01:09:12
I want to be very clear about one thing.
01:09:15
VDOT, the administration, the governor, the secretary are firmly committed to doing something along I-81.
01:09:24
We don't have several billion dollars to do it at the moment.
01:09:28
We're counting on the creativity of the private sector to come forward with meaningful risks
01:09:35
And meaningful innovation that would allow us to move this project forward using the tool provided by the PPTA Act as amended.
01:09:46
And once again, I'd just really like to compliment not only George, Mal, and several other people who have
01:09:54
Put in some long, hard hours in order to deliver this RFP a couple weeks early.
01:10:02
I'm real proud of it.
01:10:03
Be happy to address any questions anybody may have.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:08
Jim, go ahead Jim.
SPEAKER_11
01:10:12
I'm just going to ask, what is the website address?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:16
Our website address is VirginiaDOT.org.
01:10:21
Virginia spelled out dot org, Virginia D-O-T dot org, and it's under, there's some tabs at the top, and it's under the one tab, business.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:37
Do you have a minimum number of proposals you hope to receive for this?
01:10:45
Like if you don't get board one or two, you say to hell with it, let's redraft and try again?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:10:50
I'd be sorely disappointed to only get one and I anticipate getting three or four.
01:10:56
That would be very healthy.
01:10:58
I would feel good about that.
01:10:59
I'd feel good about that.
SPEAKER_11
01:11:03
In the criteria for evaluation, how much emphasis is going to be put on the private partner assuming risk?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:11:12
A lot.
01:11:13
And by assuming risk, I mean risk that we don't ask the Commonwealth to guarantee.
01:11:18
True risk.
01:11:20
Now, risk doesn't just have to be financial.
01:11:24
There can be other guarantees in terms of schedule, quality of materials, but looking for it to be stated meaningfully and clearly.
SPEAKER_02
01:11:38
I'd just like to compliment
01:11:41
VDOT for doing what you're getting ready to do.
01:11:43
Obviously, I-81 is an important arena to work in, but wherever you have a good place to start, but the little bit I know about the act, it always included timing and secrecy, and I think our taking control of the act and turning it around and getting competitive, making it a competitive process is a terrific idea.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:09
Thank you.
01:12:11
The RFP does state that proposals need to be submitted in black and white in Microsoft Word in a format that's available for posting on our website as well.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:12:28
Now, having been involved in a long lengthy one around 28, I like the idea of doing solicited ones a lot.
01:12:38
Proprietary nature or some of the other ones is difficult to work with, especially when you're working with localities or different funding mechanisms to make these things happen, because it will be something that will be outside the box to make this quarter, because this is an essential quarter for the state.
01:12:54
But I applaud the idea by doing solicited PPTAs.
01:12:58
I think PPTAs is a great mechanism to do what will turn as a mega project.
01:13:05
We talked about even doing one, we had even one for $15 million here down in the down here area actually.
01:13:15
And I think there maybe you look at design builds and some alternatives and do the solicited design build proposals as well later on.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:13:23
Absolutely, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
01:13:27
You know, if we have the money, then the PPK issue is sort of not as much in play.
01:13:34
If we have the money, we now have the legislative authority to do design-build packages.
01:13:40
Of course, in this case, we don't have the money.
01:13:43
I do want to say regarding openness,
01:13:47
We will give proposers the opportunity to request a face-to-face meeting with the chief engineer, Mount Curley, to make a request for confidentiality, but we'll only be receptive to that in cases where it is truly important to protect the proprietary information, certain proprietary information.
01:14:15
We will not likely to look kindly on a request to protect financial information that includes the expenditures of public funds to make the project work.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:34
As you can imagine, I'm pretty happy to hear what you're saying.
01:14:38
I've met with the governing boards of the jurisdictions that cover the one-half, approximately, of the entire length of 81 in Virginia.
01:14:49
We have more in our district than any other.
01:14:52
And part of what I've been able to say is that this governor
01:14:56
And this secretary and this commissioner will do something.
01:15:02
And it is really good to be able to deliver.
01:15:07
And I appreciate that, particularly on such an ambitious time schedule and in the face of such daunting economic circumstances in terms of the resources.
01:15:16
So I do applaud that and look forward to what we'll be doing.
01:15:21
The other thing I want to say though is that when the, what I would call the Marsh Commission worked a couple years ago at the request of the three congressmen whose districts take in 81, Boucher, Wolf, and Goodlatte, former Secretary of the Army Marsh came up with some proposals that
01:15:40
did not involve construction and did not involve lanes and we're not going to lose sight of what VDOT can be doing even as we work at this process because those things having to do with speed management, traffic management and those kinds of things are going to be critical as you can imagine the illusion I made earlier to a VDOT employee killed was in our district on the surface of the road trying to make it safe for others.
01:16:07
and as we see the trucks at the rest stops so heavy in numbers that they can't get entirely off the travel lane sometimes and the alternative is we run them out because of the limitations we do have in the law already about how long they can be there, put them back on the road sleepy and tired and dangerous.
01:16:28
And so some of those things don't have anything to do with construction directly, and we need to be working on those two.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:16:35
I agree wholeheartedly.
01:16:36
We're not going to stop doing what we already have underway on Interstate 81, and we've also, when you see the RFP, you'll see that it is
01:16:45
Very broad in terms of construction as well as non-construction type solution.
01:16:53
It also specifically mentions, if I might add, protection of the scenic nature of Interstate 81 and protection and enhancement of the environment as well.
01:17:05
Not that I was directing that to Mr. McCarthy.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:11
Any other questions or comments?
01:17:13
Well, I want to compliment the Commissioner and also the people he's relied upon to get this done.
01:17:19
I think our getting ahead of the curve,
01:17:23
This proposal that will be announced today, what we're seeking is really going to be, I think, the potential for a unique opportunity to upgrade that corridor years ahead of what it would take if the state were doing it itself.
01:17:43
Very exciting.
Gerald P. McCarthy
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:17:44
On that very point, Mr. Chairman, I would just like to point out to the board members that tomorrow the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Bridge will be dedicated over James River.
01:17:57
I understand our senators will be there as well.
01:18:00
I assume the chairman and the commissioner and a lot of other dignitaries, but that's a public-private
01:18:06
The transportation act project that was completed on time under budget and cost the state about eight or nine percent of the total cost of it.
01:18:17
The rest is financed by private bonds and it looks like it's a really success story for this and I can only imagine how it might have been even better if there were a competitive process but I commend you for taking this initiative but anyone who's still in town tomorrow who would be more than welcome to attend I'm sure.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:18:36
Hobie.
01:18:37
Actually, as a footnote to that, on October the 3rd, in Virginia, we're going to have the Commission will sign, hopefully, a comprehensive agreement on 28th next week, and cut the ribbons on 28th on the 3rd of October.
01:18:52
And that was really bringing money to the table.
01:18:55
There was a tax district that was established.
01:18:59
Property owners were paying for 75% of it.
01:19:01
25% were coming from public funds.
01:19:03
That was a real true way of leveraging money and using the public money to the best good.
01:19:09
And that was a real true innovative way of doing, in that case, almost $200 million worth of infrastructure.
01:19:18
And I appreciate all the commissioners' help and Rick's and Frank's, everybody else involved with us.
01:19:25
That was a, you know, I thought that thing would never happen.
SPEAKER_10
01:19:29
But that's a successful PPTA that works.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:34
All right, thank you, Phil.
01:19:35
Thank you.
01:19:36
We look forward to being in charge.
01:19:38
So it's, thank you.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:39
Any other new business items come before us?
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:43
What is the item that came in our mail packet about the use of memorials on the highway?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:49
That is back on the drawing board.
01:19:51
We'll have a, that'll be on the agenda in the next month or so.
01:19:55
You can throw it away.
Phillip C. Stone
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:57
So is it premature for us to write you with comments?
01:19:59
Yes.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:20:03
If there's nothing else before us then we stand adjourned.
01:20:16
Thank you.