Central Virginia
Commonwealth Transportation Board
Action Meeting 5/17/2002
Auto-scroll
Action Meeting
5/17/2002
Attachments
Actions.pdf
Meeting minutes.pdf
2. Approval of Minutes of April 18, 2002 Board Transportation
3. Committee Reports:
4. Division Report: Net Mileage Growth of the Secondary System of State Programs
6. Action on Discontinuances from the Secondary System of State Neighborhoods Highway: APPROVED Scenic Byways
8. Action on Bridge Designation:
9. Action on Land Conveyances:
ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DIVISION
10. Action on Land Conveyance:
11. Action on Quarterly Street Mileage Payments:
CONSTRUCTION DIVISION
12. Action on Bids Received:
13. Consultant Agreement: DEFERRED (For Information and Review) C.E.I. Services Program
14. Consultant Agreement:
15. Action on Design Projects:
16. Action on Location & Design Projects:
17. Action on Tentative Six-Year Improvement Program and Allocations.
DEPARTMENT OF RAIL AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
18. Action on Rail Industrial Access Project:
19. Action on Industrial Access Railroad Tracks Program:
20. Action on Resolutions of Appreciation:
H. Carter Myers, III
SPEAKER_22
00:00:04
Commonwealth Transportation Board Meeting, May 16, 2002.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:09
Okay, we'll go ahead and get started.
00:00:15
We'll follow the agenda.
00:00:17
The first item on the agenda is a period for public comment.
00:00:21
I don't believe anybody has signed up for public comment.
00:00:25
Next item is to approve the minutes from the last month's meeting of April 18.
00:00:29
Do we have a motion?
SPEAKER_06
00:00:30
Move to approve.
SPEAKER_20
00:00:31
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:00:32
Be moved and seconded that we approve the April 18th board minutes.
00:00:36
Any discussion?
00:00:37
All in favor, please say aye.
00:00:39
Aye.
00:00:39
Any opposed?
00:00:42
Next, committee reports.
00:00:45
We have a report, Sonny, on the Internal Audit Committee.
SPEAKER_07
00:00:51
The Commonwealth Transportation Board's internal audit committee met on April 17, 2002 with members of the internal audit division and reviewed a report on the resolved and unresolved audit companions and accepted as adequate reactions taken are to be taken on the report.
00:01:07
It may be requested that Mr. Sago send a letter to the commissioner expressing their displeasure regarding the number of unresolved public findings and encouraging the new commissioner to take steps to enforce the proper resolution of findings in a timely manner.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:25
Okay, has that been communicated to you folks?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:27
Yes, that's been communicated to me and follow-up reports on each one of those have been returned and communicated back to Mr. Worley and Mr. Sabo.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:01:40
Okay, any other committee reports?
00:01:47
Next, uh, Secondary Road Division, Jim Givens, Jim
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:01:54
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:01:57
The first item is agenda item number four.
00:02:02
This is a report that was compiled by the Secondary Rose Division as a result of a request last month from Mr. Mitchell asking that it's a report on the net mileage growth in the secondary system from 1997 to 2001 for a five-year period.
00:02:24
You'll note that we've accepted 220 miles in 1997.
00:02:35
We accepted 195 miles in 1999.
00:02:42
The average was 207 for that five-year period, or a total of 1,036 miles accepted into the secondary system for maintenance.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:02:56
Any questions?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:02:58
The next item is the monthly report of additions and abandonments on the secondary system and you have that report before you.
00:03:19
The net adjustment was
00:03:22
12.41 miles added to the system.
00:03:26
If there are any questions, I'll be glad to answer those.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:03:30
Move to approve.
00:03:31
Second.
00:03:31
Moved and seconded.
00:03:35
What are we, what are we approving?
00:03:38
Do we need a motion on that?
00:03:39
That's just a report.
SPEAKER_23
00:03:40
In addition, actually in addition, we need approval on that.
00:03:43
No, we need approval.
00:03:44
The report we don't.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:03:46
I've been moved and seconded that we accept
00:03:49
accept the report on the net additions to the secondary road system.
00:03:56
Any discussion?
00:03:58
All in favor please say aye.
00:04:00
Aye.
00:04:00
Opposed?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:04:03
The next item requires your approval.
00:04:06
This is a discontinuance of a section of
00:04:11
Route 880 in Fauquier County and sections of Route 666 and 681 in Nelson County.
00:04:22
Both of these discontinuances result from project improvements which
00:04:33
improved intersections, or what have you, and the sections erode on the map are being discontinued to accommodate those improvements.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:04:42
Move for approval.
00:04:44
Been moved and seconded.
00:04:47
Any discussion?
00:04:50
All in favor of the motion, please say aye.
00:04:52
Aye.
SPEAKER_05
00:04:52
Any opposed?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:04:58
And item number seven, Mr. Chairman,
00:05:02
We have three access projects that we are presenting to the board today for approval.
00:05:11
The first is in Chesterfield County.
00:05:19
In the amount of, bear with me just a second.
00:05:29
I seem to have misplaced it in my book.
00:05:42
In the amount of $450,000 for the Meadowville Technology Park, the second access project is in King William County
00:05:59
for West Point Veneer, and the recommended allocation for that project is $150,000.
00:06:07
And the third access project is a recreational access project in Culpeper County.
00:06:19
And the recommended allocation for that project is $274,500.
00:06:24
All three of these projects have been reviewed by the Access and Ground Transportation Committee, and I think they were recommended.
SPEAKER_24
00:06:34
Mr. Grubb?
00:06:35
Yes, Mr. Secretary, we reviewed these in the Access, Roads, and Ground Transportation Committee this morning.
00:06:43
and we recommend approval of all three of these to the full board and I so move.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:06:49
Seconded.
00:06:50
Seconded.
00:06:51
Seconded that we approve these access projects.
00:06:55
Any discussion?
00:06:56
All in favor please say aye.
SPEAKER_24
00:06:58
Aye.
00:06:58
Mr. Secretary, while Mr. Givens is up if we might please, a member of his staff, Hugh Adams, just returned from Bosnia and I would like Jim to say a few words.
00:07:09
I think we need to
00:07:11
to say a thank you and kind of honor Hugh a little bit this morning.
00:07:16
Jim?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:07:17
Thank you, Mr. Grubb.
00:07:18
Hugh Adams manages this program in the secondary roads division and he's been away from us for a period of about eight months serving in the National Guard.
00:07:30
Hugh is a helicopter pilot and he has been in Bosnia with the National Guard on active duty.
00:07:37
We certainly missed his
00:07:40
smiling face and the work that he produced in the division and we're equally proud and happy that he has returned safely and appreciate the sacrifice that he's made for all of us.
00:07:54
Q, if you'll stand.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:08:17
I think that recognition speaks for itself, and you haven't missed anything here.
SPEAKER_23
00:08:28
I believe, sir, I'm sorry that we seem to have sort of dropped the ball on this net mileage growth report that Mr. Givens made.
00:08:39
I believe someone made a request last month to
00:08:44
get an idea of how many miles, how many roads that we accept, how many mileage we've accepted over the past five years.
00:08:52
And I think this is an excellent report, but it sort of misses the board a little bit because I see and it just occurred to me in one, on the other side of the coin, we show that we abandoned a number of roads over a period of time.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:13
Jim, let me ask something only for my benefit.
00:09:28
Do we block the maintenance of secondary roads?
00:09:31
Does this come out of the monies that we make available to counties?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:09:37
No, sir.
00:09:37
We maintain those roads as a part of our maintenance allocation to the secondary system.
00:09:42
The department does that.
00:09:43
and we maintain the secondary system just like we maintain the primary.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:09:48
Any cost, do you know, have you been able to analyze what it costs to maintain each mile of road that's brought to the system?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:09:59
Mr. Secretary, I have not done an analysis of that but the subdivision street requirements are frequently a point of contention
00:10:11
As far as developers and the counties and citizens are concerned, what is the appropriate width or pavement design or what have you?
00:10:21
And the position the department has taken over the years is we need to build these roads or require that these roads be built to a minimum standard that we think when they're accepted in the system, they will not become a public burden as far as maintenance dollars are concerned in the future.
00:10:41
You're going to have some routine maintenance, pavement repair and that type of thing, but you don't want to have major failures on those roads.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:10:55
Thank you for going to that trouble of getting us that report.
00:10:57
Any other questions, Jim?
SPEAKER_05
00:10:59
I'd like to make a comment about what Jim just said.
00:11:03
I know in the last 90 days in my county, Pennsylvania County, this issue
00:11:11
It's been a real issue with the developers that are buying land, selling lots, and they're cutting private roads into the properties.
00:11:23
And I know even when I was on the Board of Supervisors, I would have citizens that would go in and buy lots and build their homes on these roads.
00:11:32
And then they would
00:11:33
You know, they were told that the big board supervisors can get it in a six-year plan and they'll pay for it, you know.
00:11:39
We know how that goes.
00:11:41
Well, anyway, it has been a real issue about, you know, the state taking these in, and I hope from
00:11:51
My experience on the Board of Supervisors and watching the issue there is that the state will hold true and keep a high standard on these roads that need to come into the system that we take into the system because a lot of folks out there spending a lot of money on homes and being told something about these roads that will happen in the future.
00:12:16
We need to hold a high standard on that.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:12:19
We try to do that, Mr. Byrd.
00:12:20
We do face continual pressure.
00:12:23
And I must say that the more sophisticated counties, the more urbanized counties, tend to have higher standards and requirements than the less urbanized counties.
00:12:35
But it is a continual battle and we'll try to make sure that we get a good product.
SPEAKER_23
00:12:44
Second.
SPEAKER_19
00:12:45
If I may say one thing about that, I have a lot of experience in developing subdivision streets in accordance with state standards.
00:12:53
I think one of the things that we continually have a problem with, I think Jim would probably agree, is that even though the standards are high and set at a good design standard for a minimum,
00:13:12
The problem comes in the residencies with the ability for us to actually inspect the work.
00:13:19
And in the Chesterfield residency, we've been meeting for quite some time as to how we can improve that situation with the inspections, whether the developers can
00:13:33
increase the term of the defect bonds.
00:13:37
There's all types of things that we can do to ensure that we get quality streets into the system and we're working on that as in the Richmond District.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:13:46
I had a similar conversation with Mr. Mitchell yesterday afternoon about site plan review when the developers apply to the counties for review for these subdivisions.
00:13:58
I can tell you that
00:14:01
As a result of some legislation that was presented this year, study legislation, we are trying to undertake a comprehensive review of our subdivision street requirements to see what we can do to make sure that we minimize those requirements.
SPEAKER_19
00:14:20
I really think that the monitoring of what is actually built is probably one of
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:14:37
W. Smith Jr., John H. J. Smith Jr.
00:14:55
But even in the poor areas, they still have to, those private roads that developers are building and telling homeowners, purchasers, that the county will get it paid, they still have to meet, even if a private developer were to pay the road, they still have to meet certain minimum standards before it comes into the system.
SPEAKER_05
00:15:15
I have, several years ago, I had a
00:15:17
An incident where a developer had developed a property on a private road and folks one of them built some very nice homes and of course it was gravel and they wanted it paved and they were told that if you go to the Board of Supervisors they will put it in the Six-Year Plan and well that doesn't happen, you know.
00:15:42
And I know I met with them and for them to bring it up to the states, they couldn't do it.
00:15:48
There's no way that it could be done.
00:15:52
But anyway, the problem is
00:15:55
Sometimes I wonder that the counties, we say we're not involved in land use matters, but in some of these instances, I don't wonder that it shouldn't be some type of a county ordinance that if you're going to develop, I mean, you may have it here in Chesterfield and whatnot, but as Whit said, in some of the rules, we don't have that.
00:16:16
H. C.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:16:35
I frankly don't know the difference on the acceptance process and how it works in the more rural areas.
00:16:43
I know in the urban areas there is a high degree of standards that are brought forward and a lot of it frankly comes from the local jurisdictions.
00:16:52
In many cases, they actually exceed state requirements because of fire and rescue issues or it could be school bus issues.
00:17:00
So there are other things that are part of that process.
00:17:06
But frankly, you can't say it's all just VDOT either.
00:17:08
The localities in the urban areas play as important a role in the acceptance process and the design process as VDOT does.
00:17:17
It goes into the VDOT system and the county can kind of wash its hands of things.
00:17:21
But they are an integral part of the process, how roads are accepted, how they're reviewed.
00:17:27
Frankly, we talked about this yesterday, and I'll probably get shot for saying this, but when VDOT reviews subdivision plans, they don't get a nickel for it.
00:17:37
The money goes to the local jurisdictions.
00:17:41
I suspect somebody may entertain that idea for reviews as long as there is some end result of a better review process.
00:17:50
That's something maybe we can look into in the future, but VDOT doesn't get a dime out of that whole review process, and so the localities get a lot of the benefit.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:00
Nor does VDOT take into account the cost of maintaining the road that's accepted.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:18:05
That's the second part of it, too, is that
00:18:08
You know, these design standards, you might go up to a wider road width because the county would like to have a wider road width more so than VDOT.
00:18:15
Well, that costs VDOT money for maintenance.
00:18:18
So, I think it's a subject that's got to be talked about.
00:18:22
We had, what, 200 miles a year in secondary roads in the private sector.
00:18:27
And at times six years, that's a lot of miles.
SPEAKER_05
00:18:30
So we'll have to think that through a little bit.
00:18:32
VDOT, and Jim, you may want to expand on it a little bit.
00:18:34
I know VDOT has a program also that the counties watch very close to your rural addition program.
00:18:41
And I know in Pennsylvania County, every December, the commissioners for the county, they ride out
00:18:47
And look at requests for rural addition.
00:18:49
There's not a lot of money now, but believe me, those folks in the rural area are looking to see if they can tag into that flow of money to upgrade the roads.
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:19:00
If the county allow those roads to develop substandard, once they've been on the books for 10 years,
00:19:07
That road, according to the code, can be considered for rural addition.
00:19:12
We do have a limit of 5% of the county's secondary allocation that can be spent on that.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:19:21
Okay, all right.
00:19:24
Very good.
00:19:25
Thank you, Jim.
00:19:27
Let's see, Division of Traffic Engineering, Larry Campbell.
SPEAKER_09
00:19:33
Good morning.
00:19:34
Traffic Engineering has one item for your consideration today.
00:19:38
The Grayson County Board of Supervisors has passed a resolution requesting the Commonwealth Transportation Board name the bridge on Route 58 over the New River as the Veterans Memorial Bridge.
00:19:50
The county has agreed to pay the cost of the signs and this item was presented to the Access Roads and Ground Transportation Committee at their meeting this morning.
00:20:01
Move for approval, Mr. Chairman.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:03
I have been moved and seconded.
00:20:04
Any further discussion?
00:20:06
All right.
00:20:07
All in favor of adopting that resolution, please say aye.
00:20:10
Aye.
00:20:10
Any opposed?
00:20:12
Thank you, Larry.
00:20:14
Next, Rosemary Jones, Right-of-Way Utilities Division.
SPEAKER_00
00:20:22
Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
00:20:24
We have three items on the agenda.
00:20:27
All three items are routine conveyances to adjacent property owners.
00:20:33
We recommend their approval.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:36
So moved, Mr. Chairman.
SPEAKER_00
00:20:37
Seconded.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:38
Alright, been moved and seconded.
00:20:40
We adopt the resolution on those three land conveyances.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:20:44
Any discussion?
00:20:46
Yes.
00:20:47
On these conveyances back to the property owners, did we receive any compensation for that?
00:20:55
We're not necessarily giving it back to the same people we purchased it from.
SPEAKER_00
00:21:07
We're giving it back to adjacent owners of the property.
00:21:20
In the case of the Route 622, we are asking for $1,100 in that case.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:28
So we are getting compensated in some form?
SPEAKER_00
00:21:30
Yes, on some of these.
00:21:31
Yes, we are.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:21:33
Thank you.
00:21:33
What's the criteria for deciding on compensation?
SPEAKER_00
00:21:37
Well usually we look at the size of the property if it's a class one.
00:21:42
We always look at the value of the adjacent property and then the value of the property once this area is joined with it and the difference between the two is the price that we ask.
SPEAKER_19
00:21:56
Do we have any idea with the total amount of acreage or parcel numbers that we have as far as access right away that we're holding?
SPEAKER_00
00:22:11
That we have in the system right now?
00:22:14
I do not have that amount.
00:22:16
We probably could find out for you.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:19
Yeah, I agree with that.
00:22:20
In fact, each district, like Ken and I talked about this a long time ago, in the just North Virginia area, there are parcels which VDOT owns.
00:22:29
It just sits there, and maybe it's, you know, they have to buy a whole parcel, but they couldn't use it all, but we still own the residuals.
00:22:36
The question is whether it has any value to the department for that.
00:22:41
I don't know what the total real estate is for non-highway real estate, but it would be interesting to know and see what the disposition of that could be.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:22:53
Well, I know there's a separate law in Virginia that deals with state-owned property that's deemed surplus, but this doesn't fall in that.
00:23:03
This property is not disposed of under that law, I don't believe.
SPEAKER_00
00:23:07
We have residue property and then we have surplus property.
00:23:11
Surplus property is the property we come before you now and ask for you to say that it's surplus to our needs.
00:23:17
And then we have the residue property, which is outside of the right-of-way limits, which we do not need board approval to sell.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:23:24
Okay, let's do it.
SPEAKER_01
00:23:28
Mr. Chairman, I hope that I can shed a little light on this.
00:23:31
We've identified less than 100 parcels that we currently own that can be built on without any zoning, without any problems.
00:23:40
In other words, can be independently developed.
00:23:42
We have well over 2,500 parcels of land that cannot be developed independently without adjacent property use.
00:23:49
some of these pulses are very small some of them have some size to them the exact acreage of course we could we could run down but this goes back over a number of years it may take some time in order to get the actual acreage
00:24:01
The policy is we don't sell these small parcels except to adjacent owners because we don't want to consider, as an agency, we want to do the right thing.
00:24:08
We don't want to sell them to a third party who may cause some problems with adjacent property owners.
00:24:13
So we are limited to some degree on how we can market this information, market these properties.
00:24:18
And generally we react to the fact that the ones that are up for sale are those that can be built on.
00:24:23
We have the sales lines on them.
00:24:25
We try to market them ourselves.
00:24:27
The others we react to on the basis of the adjacent owner requesting
00:24:31
So basically that's the program to go back and find out how many we really owned.
00:24:35
It may take a huge effort.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:24:37
So we're proactive in the ones that can stand on their own.
00:24:42
That's right.
00:24:42
And we're sort of reactive mode if there's an adjacent owner of the others.
SPEAKER_19
00:24:47
Ryan, would there be any potential value as far as dollars go in possibly marketing to the adjacent landowners the smaller parcels for a thousand dollars here and there?
00:25:00
I mean, I know that there has to be some cost associated with us just holding them.
SPEAKER_01
00:25:07
It is, it is.
00:25:08
We have to maintain them.
00:25:09
They're weed cutting.
00:25:09
The residents don't particularly like it.
00:25:11
There are certain things we have to do in maintenance and so forth.
00:25:14
But on the same token, and this is the reality, many of these are very small parcels that you cannot hardly park more than one or two cars on.
00:25:20
People are using them as their yard.
00:25:22
People are using them for gardens.
00:25:24
It's unlikely under our policy of not selling it to a third party that they would be willing to compensate because we've allowed them to use it.
00:25:32
They keep it mowed and so forth.
00:25:34
And there's some are very remote in the mountains in the southwest.
00:25:36
There's some are extremely remote.
00:25:38
Many of them have no access at all, so they must be used with the adjacent property.
00:25:42
So it would be an enormous effort if we really wanted to get in the market.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:25:48
One example I was thinking of, 28, just because we've been working on that one, we're spending $20 million on right-of-way acquisition for the PPTA proposal for acquiring enough right-of-way to buy real estate for the interchange.
00:26:03
The problem is we have to buy a whole parcel.
00:26:06
You can't just buy a piece of a parcel, so you have residual pieces.
00:26:09
It could be two, three acres left over.
00:26:12
In those kind of circumstances where you have adjoining property owners, that's the piece to focus on to sell it back to those.
00:26:19
I think there are pieces that you'll spend more time and effort trying to, first of all, find them, but also trying to sell them, but focus on the things that we know are potentially marketable to those areas, especially
00:26:32
You've got $20 million on that one project in 28.
00:26:35
In Gainesville, there's $48 million on right-of-way on that interchange up there because you have to buy big parcels and businesses.
00:26:44
So I think in those cases, when we go through the program, it's finding ways that while we're trying to acquire the right-of-way, as soon as construction is over with and we know what the residuals are, is then actively market those things to adjoining property owners and try to recoup some of that money.
SPEAKER_01
00:27:01
That's reality.
00:27:02
We are required by statute to offer the original landowner.
00:27:05
If the property can be developed on its own, we are required by statute to offer it back to the original landowner at fair market value at the time.
00:27:12
They have 30 days in order to respond, and then we can negotiate.
00:27:16
But we have certain hopes that we have to jump through to make sure that we follow the statute.
00:27:22
We've looked for many ways, Mr. Chairman, to try to get these things back on the tax rolls, and it is our desire to do that, and that's what we try to do in most instances.
SPEAKER_06
00:27:31
By transferring this small parcel of property to the adjacent property owners, we eliminate the potential danger of a lawsuit in case of someone getting injured there.
00:27:44
We also eliminate the maintenance of those particular parcels by doing so.
00:27:48
Is that correct?
00:27:49
Yes, sir.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:27:53
If I may, I'd like to just add one comment.
00:27:57
I'm relatively familiar with this process in other states as well.
00:28:01
Processes are very similar, requirements are very similar from state to state.
00:28:06
In the short time that I've been here, and I'm not just saying this because Stuart's standing up there, in the short time that I've been here, I think what we're doing and have been doing here in VDOT is one of the best balanced methods
00:28:21
W. Smith,
00:28:28
Then the benefit might be worth.
00:28:32
I've been real pleased with what I've seen in terms of how we're managing our excess property.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:28:37
Yeah, and I agree too.
00:28:39
Maybe it's something, if we have an outsource issue, maybe that's one we ought to outsource.
00:28:46
I'm sure, because those are big headaches for you guys anyway.
SPEAKER_01
00:28:49
Well, we had an experimental project in the Salem area probably ten years ago where we did go through the process and got a broker and
00:28:56
We found it really wasn't much success.
00:28:58
We have as much capabilities and professionalism on staff as we can hire from.
00:29:03
It is something we think about constantly putting this out.
00:29:06
There's a great deal of man hours involved in conveying problems.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:09
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:29:10
Rosemary, Stuart, thank you.
00:29:13
You got others?
James S. Givens
Secondary Roads Division Administrator
00:29:14
No, that's it.
00:29:15
Okay.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:29:16
All right, thank you.
00:29:19
Next we have Randy Campbell, Administrative Services Division.
00:29:22
Excuse me, Mr. Chairman, did we vote on that?
00:29:24
I don't think we voted on it.
00:29:26
I was going to ask.
00:29:26
I thought we had and then we returned to the issue raised by us.
00:29:34
We did not.
00:29:37
We have voted on that and then we return to the discussion.
00:29:40
I made a motion on that one.
00:29:41
I made a motion.
00:29:43
I made a motion on that one.
SPEAKER_02
00:29:44
It's been voted upon as it was.
00:29:48
Okay, Mr. Campbell, Randy?
00:29:50
Yes, sir.
00:29:51
Mr. Chairman, members of the board, this morning we're seeking your approval to dispose of 3.08 acres of land currently known as our Washington area headquarters, which is located in Rappahannock County in the Culpeper District.
00:30:03
We expect to vacate this site probably in January 2003 when we'll move to a new site where we'll have our new area headquarters under construction right now and we're asking you to approve this conveyance.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:17
Do we know who we're selling this to, or is this just authorization to look for a buyer?
SPEAKER_02
00:30:23
This is just authorization at this point.
00:30:26
We'll have to declare it surplus formally and send it through the Department of General Services and get their approval following that.
00:30:32
If no other state agency opts for it through that process, then we'd sell it on the open market at Fairmarket Bath.
00:30:38
And the town of Washington has already indicated an interest in this property.
00:30:43
Move for approval.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:30:45
Second.
00:30:45
Move and second to adopt that resolution.
00:30:48
Any further discussion?
00:30:50
All in favor say aye.
00:30:51
Aye.
00:30:52
Any opposed?
00:30:54
Aye.
00:30:54
Thank you.
00:30:55
Urban Division.
00:30:57
Aye.
00:30:57
Charlie Rasnick.
SPEAKER_09
00:31:02
Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the board.
00:31:04
What you have before you here in this item are the additions to the urban street system in the cities of Bristol, Colonial Heights, and Covington, and in the towns of Chase City, Pulaski, and South Hill.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:17
We reviewed these and we recommend your approval for these additions to the urban system.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:24
Move for approval.
SPEAKER_12
00:31:25
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:31:28
Moved and seconded.
00:31:31
that we adopt the resolution to bring these into the urban system.
00:31:40
Any further discussion?
00:31:42
All in favor please say aye.
00:31:44
Aye.
00:31:44
Any opposed?
00:31:47
Thank you, John.
00:31:49
Construction Division, Don Sallis.
SPEAKER_10
00:31:57
Good morning, Mr. Secretary, Mr. Commissioner, members of the board.
00:32:01
I bring before you today a slight change from what you had yesterday.
00:32:07
Forty-two projects and they're valued at $29.8 million.
00:32:12
Added one that came through the Administrative Services Project process.
00:32:18
I'd like to go through these page by page.
00:32:23
On page one of the ballot we have three interstate projects valued at 2.5 million dollars and I'm asking for your award on those projects.
00:32:37
On pages two and three I have eight primary projects valued at 7.8 million.
00:32:45
Asking for your award on those.
00:32:50
On page four
00:32:52
We have the Route 123.
00:32:54
This is a borrow job.
00:32:57
We thought we could save some money on the overall project by disposing and using this for commercial material.
00:33:06
It's real close to a plant.
00:33:08
It's mostly granite, and we thought this could be crushed and used on a project.
00:33:13
Anyway, it didn't work out the way that we thought, and so we haven't got a price that's low enough.
00:33:19
to follow through on this project, so we'll just add this to the next road project.
00:33:26
So I'm asking that you reject that project.
00:33:30
Okay?
00:33:32
Any questions on that?
00:33:34
Okay, pages five through seven, ten secondary projects valued at $4.8 million.
00:33:40
Asking for your award on that.
00:33:46
Page 8, we have one urban project.
00:33:50
This is a district-wide demolition job.
00:33:53
It came in way over the engineer's estimate.
00:33:55
We're going to look at it again, see if we can define the scope of the work a little better and hopefully get some better prices.
00:34:01
So we'd ask that you reject that one.
00:34:05
Pages 9 and 10, we have eight miscellaneous projects valued at $3.5 million.
00:34:11
I ask you award those.
00:34:17
On page 11, this is the same situation we had before on the district-wide demolition job for the Salem District.
00:34:25
We're going to try to narrow the scope a little bit, let people know, our bidders know a little better what we expect them to do and hopefully result in a better price.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:34:37
Don, how many bidders did we get on these?
SPEAKER_10
00:34:40
Well, we had three on these, which is a little bit lower than we normally get.
00:34:45
One of the problems with our district-wide contracts is we may not spend any money on the job.
00:34:51
We may have no demolitions that go this route.
00:34:54
They may all be added to construction projects, which is what we like to do.
00:34:58
We typically get our better prices when we assign them with projects because people know what they're after.
00:35:04
On this, there's some degree of risk
00:35:06
We give them some knowns but then they're usually renewable contracts and we may ask them to bid on work that they haven't seen before and give us prices by a one-story brick structure and it's a little nebulous and they don't always know what they're bidding on so there's a pretty high degree of risk
00:35:27
So we don't always get the best prices.
00:35:30
There again, that's why we like to put our demolitions with the project so everybody can go in and look at the job.
00:35:42
On pages 12 and 13, we've got two projects that we took in bids in November and the board acted on in December and I'm requesting two actions from the board
00:35:57
The first action is in both cases to rescind the award to the low bidder and then to make award to the second bidder.
00:36:05
And the reason I'm asking this is these were projects you know that we've delayed and contractors have the right to back out of that agreement if we don't authorize those for award in 60 days.
00:36:17
That time's expired.
00:36:19
In the case of the first job, the Tazewell County job,
00:36:24
The contractor could not get bonding and so we offered the second bidder.
00:36:30
The second bidder was well within the engineer's estimate and so we thought the best process was probably to make the award to the second bidder.
00:36:38
It was only $12,000 lower, higher than the first bidder so we think that's a pretty good deal.
00:36:44
It would probably cost us more than that to re-advertise it.
00:36:48
On the second one, the first contractor on the Scott County job, Little Henry's, had too much work underway, and so he's asked not to do that job.
00:36:59
The second bidder there again was $12,000 higher, so I think the same thing is true.
00:37:05
So I'd ask for you to rescind the award to the first bidder and award to the second bidder.
SPEAKER_12
00:37:12
Mr. Secretary, do you have to act on that separately, these two?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:17
Not unless you want to.
SPEAKER_19
00:37:21
Just a quick question on page two.
00:37:24
The Route 5, the bridge, over to Chickahominy, what's a submarine cable replacement?
SPEAKER_10
00:37:34
That's the control cable for the spans to open, the selectable cable is what it is.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:37:41
Hi, Hobie.
00:37:42
I have a general question.
00:37:43
Yes, sir.
00:37:44
The bidding that you're seeing coming in here over the past 90 days, have you found that the prices are, in fact, coming in a little?
00:37:52
I noticed the bids, the number of bidders has increased in some cases, but you find the department's getting some better prices than what we thought we were going to get before?
SPEAKER_10
00:38:00
Yes, sir, and I think Mr. G. talked about some of the prices we got on the Woodrow Wilson Bridge that were just way off the charts as far as good deals, so we have been seeing them.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:09
I noticed that's on this as well for the demolition of that one building.
00:38:15
We've been seeing good prices.
SPEAKER_10
00:38:17
As the work gets stabilized, I expect they'll get more back to our normal prices that we've been expecting.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:38:24
If we find at the end of this year consistently we're getting some better numbers for construction, I guess maybe we'll have to evaluate at the end of the year what is potentially there and then re-evaluate what we have to do some things that maybe we couldn't do before.
00:38:41
Is that sort of the goal and the strategy then?
SPEAKER_10
00:38:45
Well, in the construction industry as a whole, we're seeing some creep in the prices upward, two and a half, three percent overall, but we haven't experienced that yet.
00:39:01
Page 14, this is the Barnsfield Interchange, entrance to the Smithsonian, and I'm asking for your award on that project.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:39:14
This is a monumental day.
00:39:17
It's not part of the PPTA, but eventually we'll be part of it.
00:39:21
But this is the first thing to be started in that whole corridor.
00:39:26
And this is obviously important because of the Air and Space Museum.
00:39:29
This is the interchange for the Air and Space Museum, which is, by the way, well underway.
SPEAKER_10
00:39:34
So this is the final interchange, really, is what it is, just to allow access into the Smithsonian.
00:39:41
On page 15, bids received on December 6th by the City of Norfolk.
00:39:48
This is just to upgrade to purchase software and hardware for the Smart Traffic Center, and they have broken it down into three components.
00:39:59
We had three bidders and each one of them got a little bit, so asking you for a reward on that one.
00:40:07
Bids received February 6th in the Northern Virginia District Office.
00:40:11
This is for the expansion of the Hazard Advisory Radio System.
00:40:18
Three portions to that, the same bidder was low on all three portions of that and I'm asking for your award on that one.
00:40:27
Page 17 is the construction of the hike and bike trail that links the various parks along the Rappahannock River together.
00:40:34
And that was taken in by Fredericksburg and Stafford Park Authority.
00:40:40
Asking for your award on that.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:40:43
We only have one bidder on the hair system.
00:40:51
Is this such an exclusive thing that they're the ones that can bid this thing?
SPEAKER_10
00:40:56
Well, there's probably a couple of bidders out there.
00:40:58
but their ability to produce these things is somewhat limited and we've got a good price as far as our estimate so we're not uncomfortable with only one bidder.
00:41:10
There's two, maybe three if you go all the way to the West Coast manufacturers of these systems.
00:41:26
Page 18 is a project that came in through the Administrative Services Division.
00:41:33
It's received on April 9th.
00:41:35
And this is a hired equipment project for the secondary system.
00:41:41
And this is just general bringing roads up to the 3R standards.
00:41:47
And we're hiring equipment with the operator and then the management of that.
00:41:57
Okay, on page 19, the town of Reedsville took in contracts.
00:42:03
This is for a timber wharf that's about 120 feet long, and they're also going to put a pier on that, about a 60-foot pier, and ask for an award on that.
00:42:15
Any of you built piers, you know that.
00:42:16
Eleven and a half thousand dollars is a pretty good deal to go on that, so we're real happy with that bid.
00:42:24
Page 20, the town of Pennington Gap took in bids to light a trail that they've got along Lehman Field.
00:42:36
And so I'm asking for award on that.
00:42:42
Page 21, this is a project that was sponsored by the County of Frederick.
00:42:51
Bids brought in on April 25th.
00:42:52
This is to build Warrior Road.
00:42:58
Asking for your award on that project.
00:43:03
And on page 22 is the one that I added at the last minute.
00:43:07
This was done in an effort that they need the job done so they can get some work done.
00:43:12
And even though it came in after our normal cutoff periods, I felt it was important to try to get that work started, so I included it.
00:43:20
I hope you all will award that project as well.
SPEAKER_20
00:43:26
I have sort of a generic question, although it does apply to a specific project in Franklin County where there's some experimental placement of materials and so forth from Federal Highways cooperation.
00:43:44
How does the extra cost associated with that handled?
SPEAKER_10
00:43:50
The feds pay for experimental materials.
00:43:52
In this case, this was fiberglass reinforcement, I think it was.
00:44:03
If it would affect installation that cost, they would be willing to pay for that cost as well.
00:44:07
Typically, on those things, it's not much different in this case than normal rebar.
00:44:13
Now, if you're using clad material, sometimes where it can get scraped, there will be some extra installation costs.
SPEAKER_06
00:44:24
Mr. Chairman, I move that we approve the contracts, the awarded contracts as approved.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:29
Second.
00:44:30
Well, let's see.
00:44:31
You move to accept the contracts that they have recommended being awarded, reject the three, and adopt the recommendation to rescind the two.
SPEAKER_02
00:44:41
Do it all in one?
00:44:42
That's correct.
00:44:43
Okay.
00:44:43
Second?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:44:44
Second.
00:44:45
All right.
00:44:46
Been moved and seconded that we adopt these recommendations.
00:44:50
All in favor say aye.
00:44:51
Aye.
00:44:52
Any opposed?
00:44:53
Thank you.
00:44:53
Thank you.
00:44:54
By the way, Don, what's the grand total?
00:44:57
What total cost on the contracts?
SPEAKER_10
00:45:01
It was $29.8 million.
00:45:03
That last contract was about $300,000, so it raised it a little bit.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:45:08
Okay, thank you.
00:45:09
Peyton Carney on a report on the
00:45:13
Consultant agreement is issued.
SPEAKER_18
00:45:16
Good morning.
00:45:17
Item 13 requests approval for a consultant inspection contract with the firm of Parsons Brinklehall Construction Services, providing inspection services for the intelligent transportation system portion of the Penner's Point construction contract.
00:45:34
This is a cost plus net fee contract having a maximum compensation of $1,954,551, providing one senior inspector and two regular inspectors.
00:45:49
Some of the items to be inspected under this contract include closed circuit television systems, variable message sign, lane use signals, control gates, and fiber optic cabling.
00:46:00
Also included in this contract is a review of shop drawings associated with the various intelligent transportation system components.
00:46:10
And this contract provides an expertise in the inspection of these systems that the district inspection staff does not possess.
00:46:19
I'll be glad to answer any questions you may have.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:46:23
Okay, Sonny?
SPEAKER_07
00:46:25
Question as to the construction cost of 10 million.
00:46:30
Is that included in the original approval at the finish point?
SPEAKER_18
00:46:35
I believe a portion of that is.
00:46:38
There's a second contract to be advertised, I understand, for some software and hardware items.
SPEAKER_07
00:46:46
And the total cost of the project was presented to us previously.
00:46:52
Was this amount included as an estimate?
SPEAKER_18
00:46:56
I believe, again, I believe just a portion of that included in this contract is inspection of the software and all the hardware.
SPEAKER_06
00:47:07
Thank you.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:09
Ed, Kevin, I move that the bill be approved.
00:47:14
Been moved and seconded that we approve the consultant agreement.
SPEAKER_23
00:47:17
Correct.
00:47:18
Question.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:47:19
Been moved and seconded.
00:47:21
Discussion.
SPEAKER_23
00:47:21
Yes, sir.
00:47:22
Yes, sir.
00:47:23
I see the fee for this is nine percent.
SPEAKER_18
00:47:27
Yes, sir.
00:47:28
Of what?
00:47:29
Well, it's because the
00:47:31
The fee is fixed based on the consult cost to provide the services to the department.
00:47:42
We have the liberty to negotiate six to ten percent.
00:47:46
This one was negotiated at nine percent.
00:47:49
So the nine percent fee represents nine percent of the total contract value.
00:47:56
The total contract value?
00:47:57
Inspection contract.
00:48:00
What was that, sir?
00:48:01
1,954,000.
SPEAKER_23
00:48:03
Okay, now what is this percentage of construction cost?
SPEAKER_18
00:48:08
That's the percent of the 10 million dollars.
SPEAKER_23
00:48:11
So this is 19% of the construction cost we're paying?
SPEAKER_18
00:48:15
Well, it's not the, it's the construct cost of the items associated with the intelligent transportation system, yes sir.
00:48:25
If you compare it to the entire Prentice Pointe contract, I think it's around 2%.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:48:33
But that's, there's no reason to compare it.
00:48:38
Right, that's true.
00:48:39
So you forget the 2%.
SPEAKER_07
00:48:40
They just got a specific job to do.
SPEAKER_23
00:48:43
So compare it to the overall cost.
00:48:45
Yes.
00:48:48
That's, I think that's the point that Sonny was trying to make.
00:48:54
Why are we comparing this to the overall cost?
SPEAKER_18
00:48:57
Well, we're really not.
00:48:58
Ten million dollars is the accurate figure to compare it against.
SPEAKER_20
00:49:07
Is this kind of multiplier standard in the industry?
00:49:10
Is this a pretty difficult thing to do, that they can command 19.5% fees?
00:49:19
We just always look at that percentage of the construction cost as a kind of a way to look at how these costs to these consultants.
SPEAKER_18
00:49:37
J. Smith, Michael A. Shucet, John L. Smith,
SPEAKER_23
00:49:57
Yes sir, but I thought we had a real big hassle about this over the eight years I've been on this board and every time.
00:50:05
I thought we come to some kind of consensus that we try to keep these things within about a ten percent range.
SPEAKER_18
00:50:10
I think this is the highest percentage contract I've ever brought to you before, but it is an unusual circumstance.
00:50:19
Majority of my contracts range from eight to ten to eleven percent.
SPEAKER_23
00:50:25
That's why I raise the question because this just stands out like a sore thumb.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:50:33
I'd like permission to ask a question here.
00:50:38
I want to be sure I understand it, first of all, before they do.
00:50:44
You just mentioned it includes the development of software?
00:50:48
Yes, sir.
00:50:48
So it's more than just construction and inspection services?
SPEAKER_18
00:50:51
Well, this contract provides inspection to that software, too, to be sure that it functions appropriately and meets the specification.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:04
Inspecting the development of software or doing the development of software?
SPEAKER_18
00:51:08
No, it's an inspection, it's not development.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:51:12
Why don't we pay the guy that did the software in the first place?
SPEAKER_19
00:51:18
I'm going to go back to what point I think Sonny was trying to make.
00:51:24
Was this a cost that we anticipated during the preliminary budgeting?
SPEAKER_17
00:51:30
To answer Mr. Martin's original question, the entire Penners Point cost $135 million or something like that.
00:51:39
That was the construction cost.
00:51:41
Of that, we anticipate that 12% of that cost would be for our construction engineering.
00:51:49
This is a portion of that construction engineering.
00:51:53
Our district folks are going to inspect the normal construction items.
00:51:57
Where we need the help is on this technical incorporation of the software and making sure the intelligent transportation systems work.
00:52:06
So they are reviewing the software development as well as shop drawings.
00:52:11
That's why it, and the commissioner was right, this may be 2% of the entire pennant's point, but to compare apples to apples it's about 19%
00:52:23
Fine.
SPEAKER_19
00:52:33
The real gist of what I'm trying to get to is in the preliminary estimate that we used for programming the whole project.
00:52:43
And are you saying that within the confines of the plan as it exists, as of December's numbers, that this fits within the entire project?
SPEAKER_17
00:52:55
Within the total budget, yes sir, yes sir.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:52:59
I believe four firms committed an expression of interest.
SPEAKER_18
00:53:05
The short list would be three.
00:53:12
Three firms were in the U.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:18
J. Kornblau, Larry C. Caldwell,
00:53:31
and, unfortunately, we can't negotiate price while we're going through the process.
SPEAKER_18
00:53:36
...tell you that the consultant's estimate of hours to provide the service, the service that's prepared is far from varied and we cut out approximately 1.2 million dollars.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:53:51
The Parsons have anything to do with the design aspect of this?
SPEAKER_19
00:53:59
Not that I'm aware of.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:03
Does the design consultant have any responsibility to make sure that the software as they intended it to be to work?
00:54:15
Because what I don't want to see is having another consultant making sure the original consultant designed it right and fixed what the original consultant may not have did right.
SPEAKER_18
00:54:26
I don't understand exactly how this contract was set up, but normally the responsibility falls under the prime contractor, and he may sub that out, and in most cases does.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:54:38
This is such a technical part of it.
00:54:42
We have one company that does the original design, which includes, I guess, software program.
00:54:47
Now this one is inspecting the actual work, but also making sure that the software works as well.
00:54:54
I guess to some extent, if the software didn't work right in the first place, we got a second guy to say the first guy didn't do it right.
00:55:01
There's something wrong with that picture.
SPEAKER_17
00:55:02
I understand what you're saying, Mr. Mitchel.
00:55:04
We have some good experience with that.
00:55:07
That's why
00:55:08
Now understand that the technical aspect that this consultant is going to be doing is for the hardware that's going to be put out there for the traffic management system and coordinating their implementation.
00:55:29
Because a camera has to tilt and pan and signs have to be able to send a message and the signs display the right thing.
00:55:38
But there is a whole separate contract for the integration of the overall work.
00:55:45
It's making everything tie back into our central control room.
00:55:51
And that is not being done by normal construction contract.
00:55:55
We've learned our lesson on that.
00:55:57
There's an RFP on the street to do that entire coordination, which would get into more of your issue of a consultant.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:56:06
Can we defer this, let the Commissioner look at the overall construction management inspection of Penner's Point.
00:56:16
He's got some background in this and I think in view of the questions, maybe we can come out better.
00:56:22
I don't think it will hurt the timing of the project.
SPEAKER_18
00:56:26
I know that some shop drawings are being submitted by the contractor, but I don't see whether another 30 days would create a significant backlog.
SPEAKER_06
00:56:43
This is not just a standard inspection.
00:56:45
This is a very sophisticated system as well as a standard inspection.
00:56:50
So therefore, it's not of the normal type.
00:56:54
I think we're getting oranges mixed up here with bananas or something.
SPEAKER_18
00:56:59
Right, this is not standard roadway construction.
SPEAKER_06
00:57:01
That's what I'm trying to say.
00:57:02
And so I think you're thinking that this is just a standard inspection to most of the members.
00:57:09
And this is not a standard inspection.
00:57:11
We're talking about a sophisticated system being incorporated here as far as the company inspecting that as well.
00:57:18
Is that correct?
SPEAKER_18
00:57:19
Yes, sir.
00:57:20
Okay.
SPEAKER_06
00:57:20
Well, then it's going to run a little higher than normal, I would assume.
SPEAKER_23
00:57:25
But I yield to my understanding.
00:57:29
I support your recommendation, Mr. Chairman.
00:57:31
I accept the fact that this may be a little bit different than the normal one.
00:57:39
I still think that we should try, the commissioner has some concerns about this and I respect the commissioner that he probably ought to take a good look at this and if he comes back and says that's the right thing to do, fine.
00:57:51
And I think we ought to do that.
00:57:52
So I support your idea of let's withdraw this and have the commission take it.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:57:58
Hobie?
00:57:58
Yeah, I agree.
00:57:59
In addition, we're going to get more of these technical kind of operations in the future to get into the Smart Highway Program.
00:58:08
We had a consultant do design work, now we've got a consultant doing the inspection work, and then I hear there's another consultant making sure everything works together besides that.
00:58:17
So it would be good to know the whole picture about how this whole thing comes together.
00:58:22
We've got a lot of consultants doing a lot of work, and consultants checking the other consultants' work.
00:58:29
Somebody's got to be held accountable to make sure it works somewhere.
00:58:32
If somebody didn't design it right in the first place, the second guy says the first guy didn't do it right, then we ought to hold the first guy accountable.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:39
Okay.
00:58:40
Without objection, we'll just leave the motion on the table and return to this issue next month.
00:58:45
Move to defer.
SPEAKER_19
00:58:47
Second.
00:58:47
30 days.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:48
All right.
00:58:48
Move to second it to defer.
00:58:51
Any other discussion?
00:58:52
All in favor say aye.
00:58:54
Aye.
00:58:54
Be opposed.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:56
Thank you.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:58:58
Next, Environmental Division, Jeffrey Rogers, Actional Consultant.
00:59:05
Good morning.
SPEAKER_22
00:59:06
The Environmental Division recommends you request your approval of this consultant agreement with Michael Baker Jr.
00:59:11
Incorporated for air quality conformity services.
00:59:14
The consultant will provide professional services related to the evaluation of conformity of regional transportation plans and programs with air quality plans.
00:59:23
This agreement is necessary for the successful implementation of the department's transportation plans and programs in non-attainment and maintenance areas across the state.
00:59:31
It's necessary to augment the environmental division staff due to the highly specialized nature of the work, the need for timely completion of studies, and because of the complexity of the projects requiring these studies.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
00:59:46
discussion?
00:59:49
Hobie.
00:59:50
This also deals with North Virginia Regional Area Quality Works and working with COG.
00:59:54
Yes.
00:59:55
I'm dealing with that right now.
00:59:59
Yes.
SPEAKER_23
01:00:00
Okay.
01:00:00
Move to approve.
01:00:01
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:00:02
Then moved and seconded.
01:00:06
Any further discussion on this consultant agreement?
01:00:11
All in favor say aye.
01:00:12
Aye.
01:00:13
Any opposed?
01:00:14
Let me point out that our commissioner is not as a non-voting member.
01:00:20
So I don't want there to be any confusion because that happens to be his former employer.
01:00:26
Thank you.
01:00:27
Next item.
01:00:29
Location and Design, Dewey L. Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
SPEAKER_15
01:00:36
We have six projects to present to you today.
01:00:39
One is a design approval and five location and design approvals.
01:00:46
The first one is a design approval of Route 28, Nokesville Road in Prince William County in the City of Manassas.
01:00:56
Route 28, 076, 111.
01:01:01
This project runs from Godwin Drive in the City of Manassas to one mile south of Route 215.
01:01:09
The project is a 2.85 mile length.
01:01:15
Route 28 is a major north-south connecting northern Virginia to rural areas to the south and to the west.
01:01:24
Growth and development in this corridor and current traffic forecast indicate the existing roadway has exceeded its capacity.
01:01:33
Extensive backups are occurring.
01:01:36
Also, this Route 28 corridor qualifies for hazardous elimination safety funding based on its high accident rate, and this first project is being done for safety and capacity needs.
01:01:54
The design public hearing was held on September 24, 2001.
01:02:00
We had 40 citizens attending.
01:02:03
We didn't get any oral comments.
01:02:05
We did get 10 written comments and we also got a petition signed by 22 people supporting the project.
01:02:14
The project right now has preliminary engineering right of way and utility money for it for a total of about 14 million dollars.
01:02:25
The construction is estimated to cost $44 million, but that has not been allocated to the project yet.
01:02:34
The project is expected to go to construction early 2004.
01:02:39
The project will display six families, no businesses, or no nonprofit organizations.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:50
Would this not be part of the PPTA agreement?
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:02:54
No, it's outside of that.
01:02:57
I didn't see it in the construction program.
01:03:00
I guess it's in the feasibility program.
01:03:03
I was trying to see it in the book here.
SPEAKER_15
01:03:05
It's in the feasibility program.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:10
But we said construction by 2004.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:13
Do all these projects, have you matched them up with what is in the tentative six-year plan?
01:03:31
Nothing is falling out?
01:03:33
Make sure the left hand knows what the right hand is doing.
SPEAKER_15
01:03:37
I have not compared them to the six-year program though, sir.
01:03:40
Let me just make a clarification there.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:03:54
Obviously, they should be checked in terms of any reference to schedule.
01:03:59
So that we're saying the right thing.
01:04:02
However, as a matter of issuing design approval, that is sort of the end of the development process after the environmental documents have been approved.
01:04:16
I do suggest that it is prudent to consider the action on design approval
01:04:24
regardless of the activity in the six-year program.
SPEAKER_15
01:04:28
Correct, because we do have right-of-way money to go forward with right-of-way acquisitions.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:35
But we do need to make sure that we have the references correct in terms of schedule.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:04:42
Well, I'm looking at page 478.
01:04:45
And it doesn't have right-of-way.
01:04:46
Tentative plan.
01:04:48
And the only thing in here is the PE at six
01:04:53
Jr., John H. Smith, John L. Smith Jr., John L. Smith Jr., John L. Smith Jr., John L.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:12
I think we do need to have a clear understanding of the relationship between these items that we're asked to act on and how they fit into the six-year plan.
SPEAKER_15
01:05:24
My information indicated that the funds were allocated for preliminary engineering right-of-way and utility relocations.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:31
You're asking for design approval?
01:05:36
Correct.
01:05:36
You're not asking to spend any money?
01:05:38
No.
01:05:38
Do anything else?
01:05:39
No, this has already occurred.
01:05:41
This is at the end that says we've completed all the steps that lead up to design approval.
01:05:48
That's correct.
01:05:48
And we'd like to check that box and say that's done.
SPEAKER_15
01:05:51
And if there's no right-of-way money, the project will just sit until such time.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:05:56
Another issue.
SPEAKER_15
01:05:57
So it doesn't need to be related to what's in the system.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:01
The point of clarification was there is no, in the tentative plan, there is no right-of-way or utility relocation built into that, but this decision is strictly dealing with the PE portion, which is in the tentative plan.
01:06:18
This is just for doing the PE portion of it.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:24
So is it accurate to say that all of these design location recommendations are all in the six-year plan, albeit in the feasibility portion?
SPEAKER_15
01:06:37
They should be if we're at the design stage of the public hearing.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:06:45
We're making what might be something that ought to be easy, hard.
01:06:49
At some point, I don't know the answer if they are all in here or not.
01:06:52
At some point, they have all been funded for preliminary engineering.
01:06:58
We have gone through the process and are at a point where we can say
01:07:03
We have a design for this project that requires your approval.
01:07:09
It's also part of the federal process that that design be approved.
01:07:14
Approving the design is not an authorization to spend more money or a commitment to spend more money.
01:07:27
Okay, Randy.
01:07:30
I move for approval.
SPEAKER_06
01:07:34
Second.
SPEAKER_15
01:07:42
Just to clarify the department's recommendation on this particular project, Prince William County had some comments and we have addressed those in our recommendation.
01:08:04
So the department's recommending approval of these major design features of this project
01:08:09
be approved as presented at the design public hearing with the following modifications that we consider two-way traffic on the southern leg of Chapel Springs Road and that the adjacent land development will continue to be coordinated with Prince William County to ensure that the proposed facility will operate in a safe and efficient manner and also that the auxiliary lane requirements will be further studied at key intersections.
01:08:37
Those were some concerns that Prince William County had.
01:08:42
Okay, the second project again is Route 28 and Wellington Road in the City of Manassas.
01:08:49
This is Route 28, 155, 103.
01:08:52
The project runs from 0.25 miles west of Wellington Road to 0.25 miles east of Wellington Road.
01:09:03
Total of a half a mile project.
01:09:07
The purpose of the project, it will provide a grade separated crossing of 28 Nooksville Road over both Wellington Road and the improved railway B line and a grade separated crossing of Wellington Road over the railroad main line.
01:09:29
The location and design of the public hearing was held on October 30, 2001.
01:09:33
We had 66 citizens, six oral and 13 written comments.
01:09:43
Six citizens supported the project, seven citizens supported it with modification, one citizen did not support it, and then one gave no indication of the preference.
01:09:56
This project, the preliminary engineering and the right-of-way acquisition is estimated to be $8,700,000.
01:10:07
We do have an estimated construction cost of $27.3 million.
01:10:16
But again, this one is just all we're asking for today is location and design approval.
01:10:27
There will be four families and four businesses will be displaced.
01:10:34
No nonprofit organizations.
01:10:39
The department
01:10:42
We do have a city council resolution from the city of Manassas supporting the project.
01:10:49
The department is recommending approval of the location and major design features of this project be approved as presented at the location and design public hearing with the modifications in the final design phase to modify the alignment of curve B to reduce impacts to adjacent properties.
SPEAKER_23
01:11:13
Mr. Chairman, this project is of keen interest to my community, wholeheartedly supported.
01:11:26
We're working with the urban division on this now to try to
01:11:30
Some of the non-actual constraints have been placed on this project from a construction standpoint down the road.
01:11:40
I recognize that we are working within those constraints, but
01:11:45
I'm happy to see that this is in the design, ready to go to design now because I think that this is so important with the traffic congestion in our area and I would hope that the board would support moving forward with this in that regard I would move for approval.
SPEAKER_15
01:12:07
OK, the third project is Route 729, Sherborne-Lead Road in Loudoun County.
01:12:16
This again is a location and design approval.
01:12:20
It's Route 0729, 053, 164.
01:12:26
It replaces an existing bridge over the North Fork of the Goose Creek and widening and approaches.
01:12:35
The project limits runs from nine-tenths of a mile north of Route 728, which is North Fork Road, to .8 miles south of Route 841, Oakland-Green Road.
01:12:50
The purpose of the project is to replace the existing one-lane bridge over the north fork of the Goose Creek with a two-lane structure at the same location and widen and pave the approaches to accommodate farm equipment and emergency vehicles.
01:13:08
The public hearing was held October 10, 2001.
01:13:12
We had fifteen citizens attended.
01:13:15
We had seven verbal and eleven written comments.
01:13:19
Eleven citizens supported the project.
01:13:24
Seven citizens asked for some modifications.
01:13:29
The total cost of the project is about 1.2 million dollars.
01:13:39
There are no businesses and no families or nonprofits displaced by this project.
01:13:48
The existing one-lane bridge was installed as an emergency measure back in 1994 to replace the original truss bridge.
01:13:58
That bridge collapsed during a flood when a tree got hung up in it.
01:14:04
and it only had a life expectancy of about 5 to 10 years.
01:14:09
The new bridge will be approximately 100 feet long, 20 feet wide and have two 10-foot travel lanes
01:14:19
and with the approaches.
01:14:22
We also have a resolution from the Loudoun County Board of Supervisors supporting this project and the department is recommending approval of the location and major design features as it was presented at the combined location and design public hearing.
01:14:42
The fourth project is Route 199 and Route 31.
01:14:47
Mr. Secretary, do you...
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:14:49
Pardon me, pardon me, but going back to Route 729, just a quick moment.
01:14:57
Under the existing typical section, you say it was installed as an emergency measure in 1994, and then this temporary structure has an expected life of five to ten years.
SPEAKER_05
01:15:08
What type of structure did we put in there?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:13
I'm not sure.
SPEAKER_15
01:15:15
You talk about when it was put in in 94?
01:15:17
Yes.
01:15:19
I'm not sure.
01:15:20
I don't have anything on the type of bridge it was that was put in there on the emergency conditions.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:15:29
Okay.
01:15:30
Mal or anyone here, do you know anything about that?
01:15:35
Mr. Commissioner, we can find that out.
01:15:39
For Loudoun County to allow us to build a two-lane bridge where there is now a one-lane bridge is such wonderful news.
SPEAKER_24
01:15:46
I don't think we ought to worry about what's there now.
SPEAKER_15
01:15:57
Okay, the fourth project is Route 199 and Route 31 in the cities of Williamsburg and James City County.
01:16:05
This is 0199, 965, 104, and it's an intersection improvement project for Route 199 and Route 31.
01:16:15
It's four-tenths of a mile long.
01:16:19
This project will improve the intersection of 199 and Route 31, Jamestown Road, by extending existing 12-foot left turn lanes on Route 199.
01:16:32
And in addition, 12-foot right turn lanes will be provided on Route 199, and 11-foot turn lanes will be added to Route 31.
01:16:45
Directional islands in the northeast and southeast quadrants will be constructed to improve pedestrian crossings.
01:16:52
Curb and Gutter and Drainage will be constructed in the disturbed areas and also a 10-foot shared use path will be constructed from Route 31 east to Lake Powell Road.
01:17:09
The public hearing location and design public hearing on this project was held January 23, 2002.
01:17:14
We had 54 citizens attending.
01:17:20
We got 16 verbal and 34 written comments.
01:17:26
This project is estimated to cost around $3.5 million.
01:17:33
There's two businesses that will be displaced, but no families or nonprofit organizations will be replaced.
01:17:41
The department is recommending approval of the location and major design features for this project as they were presented at the location and design of the county.
01:17:53
The fifth project is Route 672 in Rockbridge County.
01:18:00
This is Route 0672, 082, 231.
01:18:03
The project runs from one-tenth of a mile east of Route 655
01:18:11
to Route 996, total length of 1.5 miles.
01:18:18
The purpose of this project is to improve the site distances and also to improve the curvature of one of the existing curves.
01:18:29
The location design public hearing was held December 5, 2000.
01:18:35
We had 22 citizens attending.
01:18:38
We got three verbal and five written comments.
01:18:44
Also, 13 citizens supported the project with some design modifications.
01:18:51
The total cost of the project is estimated to be $2.265 million.
01:18:59
There will be no families, businesses, or nonprofits relocated.
01:19:11
The department is recommending approval of this project as presented at the location and major design features as it was presented at the public hearing.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:19:27
Okay, the final project is...
01:19:30
I think you said Rockbridge County.
01:19:33
I believe that's Rockingham, everybody.
SPEAKER_15
01:19:35
Rockingham, Kentucky
01:19:43
Okay, the last project is an urban project in the city of Galax, Glendale Road.
01:19:52
The project number is U-triple-aught 113-105.
01:19:57
It runs from the intersection of Stearic Drive, which is Route 58, to 0.09 miles east of Cliffview Road, Route 721.
01:20:10
The length of the project is 0.73 miles.
01:20:15
The purpose of the project is to eliminate substandard curves in alignment and improve the poor stopping site distance.
01:20:23
Also to improve roadway capacity with four lanes replacing the present two-lane street.
01:20:31
Public hearing was held November 14, 2001.
01:20:35
We had 26 citizens attending.
01:20:38
We got one verbal and 11 written comments.
01:20:43
Twelve people supported the project.
01:20:47
The project is currently estimated to be $6.6 million.
01:20:53
There will be six families and two businesses will be displaced and no nonprofit organizations.
01:21:03
The department is recommending approval of this project as presented at the location and major design features with modifications in the final design phase to relocate the stormwater management basin to parcel 005.
01:21:24
And also the project designer will incorporate minor modifications in the final design as noted below.
01:21:32
to acquire parcel 005 and relocate the dialysis center to replace the entrance for parcel 006 at the northern property line and shift the drainage structure 4-12 to the south.
01:21:52
Also to include CG9D entrances at appropriate locations to serve the business.
01:22:00
and also to provide an 8-meter commercial entrance for Parcel 042.
01:22:06
Those are the modifications that were recommended with the project.
SPEAKER_20
01:22:13
I have a request.
01:22:17
I waited until there was a project in our district, but it's a generic request and not for immediate, going to have to do this immediately, but if there is ever a way that you guys can find a number
01:22:31
That we use in the project description in these things and the project number that's in here that could somehow coordinate.
01:22:40
It would sure help us be able to look in here and see where these projects are unless we know specifically by description in here how they relate.
SPEAKER_15
01:22:48
Maybe identify them by the page, number, and line item?
SPEAKER_20
01:22:52
Well, I don't know.
01:22:53
I like to track our projects.
01:22:55
Over the years, you become familiar with them when you look at them year after year and you figure out which is which.
SPEAKER_15
01:23:04
What you're asking for is when they show up here, you want to be able to relate it back to the Six-Year Program to a location.
SPEAKER_20
01:23:12
Well, yeah, that would help a little bit.
01:23:14
And see, we have the numbers.
01:23:16
These numbers are the ones that are used in here.
01:23:19
So in looking at what's going on in our district in terms of contract costs, both bids and... We can come up with a way to do that.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:23:32
That's all the projects.
01:23:34
Okay.
01:23:36
I have a motion.
01:23:38
Take it in block.
01:23:40
Do we have a motion?
01:23:43
Seconded that we adopt the proposed resolutions to accept the five locations in design and the one design project.
01:23:52
Any further discussions?
01:23:54
All in favor?
01:23:55
Say aye.
01:23:56
Any opposed?
01:23:57
Thank you.
01:24:00
Next, Bob Casader, tentative six-year plan.
SPEAKER_14
01:24:11
Yes, Mr. Chairman, you have before you for item 17 is the resolution to adopt the tentative six-year program, which does include the construction program, the development program, and also it includes the enhancement program, rail safety, the U.S. Carter 58 program, and the rail and public transportation program.
01:24:30
The program does total $7.2 billion.
01:24:33
As we talked to you yesterday, the total number of projects in construction and development are about 1,134 projects.
01:24:41
857 of those are in the construction phase and another 277 in the development phase.
01:24:47
The tenant program right now is on the website.
01:24:52
If you adopt it today as the official tenant, we will adjust the language in there to say that it has been officially endorsed by the board.
01:25:02
It does go to the Chairman of House Appropriations, Senate Finance, House and Senate Finance, House and Senate Transportation Committees today.
01:25:13
On June the 5th, we have two public hearings scheduled.
01:25:15
One will be in Whitfield in the morning at 9 o'clock and then that afternoon back in Richmond at 2 p.m.
01:25:23
I can only get one airplane
01:25:25
So we will have a plane that will go from Richmond to Wytheville and then will come back to Richmond and any board members that come from Wytheville back to Richmond then we will fly them back to Wytheville also.
01:25:39
We will plan to ask for your final approval at the June 20th board meeting and we will arrange briefings for any of you who desire one we will arrange a briefing between the
01:25:51
T. F. in the final and sometime over the next 30-45 days.
01:25:57
So unless you have any further questions at this point that weren't discussed yesterday, then I staff recommend your approval of the tentative program.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:26:09
Thank you, Bob.
01:26:10
Hobie?
01:26:10
One thing we talked a little bit briefly this morning I think it would be good to have for that June 5th date is the $7.2 billion that's broken up.
01:26:21
I think it would be good for them to have a big picture of how that works.
SPEAKER_20
01:26:50
I spend a little bit of time going between this and this and this is much more user friendly and I really appreciate that but I'm still having a hard time finding some of the things that I know have to be easier somewhere that I think I see in here but I'm not really sure either.
01:27:11
I'm concerned about the France and I really would appreciate you take just a second and go over again.
01:27:16
We are going to have
01:27:19
1.2 billion that we are going to sell.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:27:26
No, we've already sold almost 700.
SPEAKER_20
01:27:29
We've got to sell six more, excuse me.
01:27:32
Can you help me with the second six?
SPEAKER_14
01:27:36
We've already sold $375 million worth of bonds.
01:27:42
We will sell 317 that will go through the allocation formula remaining.
01:27:46
600 will be sold over the next, I think, five years.
SPEAKER_20
01:27:49
375 was what that we've sold?
SPEAKER_14
01:27:54
That's what we sold in the first year.
SPEAKER_20
01:27:59
And they went basically to?
SPEAKER_14
01:28:02
Specific projects listed in the Virginia Transportation Act of 2000.
01:28:06
They were sold in September 2000.
01:28:08
The original was $375 million.
01:28:15
Then there was $317 million that the General Assembly instructed us to sell to replace the half-a-cent sales tax.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:28:28
And that goes through the formula?
SPEAKER_14
01:28:29
That goes through the formula, yes sir.
01:28:37
And then beyond that we are proposing, and I don't have the schedule right here before me, but we are proposing selling additional bonds over the next, I think it's five years, that will cover the other about $600 million that will be sold.
SPEAKER_20
01:28:53
I guess the problem I'm having is I'm so aware of debt service and how it impacts in this book.
01:29:02
Is there a page you can reference for me in this book or this book or several pages that tell me where the debt service is coming out to pay, which bonds, when?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:22
Well this is one year.
SPEAKER_20
01:29:25
Well I understand that.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:29:30
This has got a line item on it for Fran debt service.
SPEAKER_14
01:29:35
It's in the back page of each district.
01:29:38
And there is a summary page in the front.
01:29:41
That does not include all of the debt service, because the debt service on the $317 million, the first two years worth of debt service, the General Assembly provided some money for that.
01:29:52
And that is included in the budget, but it is not included in our program.
SPEAKER_05
01:29:57
That's true.
01:29:59
It could probably be helpful if you could provide with a debt service schedule, which is anticipated to probably help.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:30:13
May I ask a question?
01:30:14
Bob, we need to be sure we understand the question.
SPEAKER_20
01:30:17
Well, and I'm having a hard time trying to form the question because I'm looking at one district.
01:30:27
I haven't had time to go back and study the other districts.
01:30:34
And there's some specific concerns I have within the Salem district, but that's something I'll address not at this moment.
01:30:43
But overall,
01:30:48
There's some funding and the reduction in funding, as I understood it, was going to be basically in the 30% range for each of the districts.
01:31:04
I don't know about the other districts.
01:31:05
I haven't run those numbers.
01:31:09
Salem District is not consistent with that.
01:31:12
So I'm looking for answers as to the funding that is coming out of the construction program that is causing some of those numbers, at least one set of numbers that I have looked at, not complete that.
01:31:43
Don't worry about it.
01:31:44
I'll figure out a different way to ask the question before next month.
SPEAKER_19
01:31:50
I'd just like to make a couple of comments.
01:31:57
This time last week I was probably in a whole lot different frame of mind.
01:32:03
There was some concern on my part about the factoring that we discussed at length yesterday, and I think in the last week we've made some real progress.
01:32:13
Really understanding that and knowing in what direction we are heading as far as the short-termness of the factoring in our plan.
01:32:25
Beyond that,
01:32:26
Let me also say that in my district alone, in the third, fourth, and fifth years of the program, the FRAN debt service equals approximately 50 percent of the district primary funds.
01:32:41
And as you all know, Richmond has been the
01:32:49
has actually been focused in on, has taken a big hit with this program.
01:32:56
But I also want to let everyone know that in my mind and also in some of the General Assembly members' minds, there seems to be some confusion as to the sources of the repayment of the France in the out years.
01:33:16
And with that said, I don't know the answer to it.
01:33:20
I know there's some folks working on that that are going to try to help me understand it more.
01:33:26
But in the next 30 days, I think we'll be looking at that very closely.
01:33:31
As this is a tentative plan, and with the improvements I've seen in it over the last week or two, I'm willing to take this forward as a tentative and support it today.
SPEAKER_12
01:33:47
And I'd like to thank Philip and Bob and your staff for all the hard work.
01:33:56
I think some of you may have even worked on Mother's Day, and I expect that was tough at home.
01:34:01
But anyway, I'd like to thank you all, and you, Mr. Commissioner, and your staff, for the hard work that you all have put in on this and for trying to help us.
SPEAKER_20
01:34:15
I have not realized this new line item was in the district and I hadn't gotten to it.
01:34:32
This debt service for friends.
01:34:35
Does the debt service that's reflected in each district pay for friends sold in that district?
01:34:43
Or does it just pay for debt service beyond those sold in the district?
SPEAKER_14
01:34:48
A portion of statewide friends.
01:34:50
Debt services calculated first is paid for from the priority transportation fund as far as the funds that are paid into the priority transportation fund.
01:35:01
Beyond that, the debt service is prorated according to the balance of the projects that are approved from the Virginia Transportation Act that are approved for debt service.
01:35:14
That service is first paid out of the priority transportation fund because there is money that continues to be paid into the priority transportation fund.
01:35:30
It is not sufficient to cover the entire debt service.
01:35:32
The remaining debt service is prorated among the districts in accordance with the amount of money that was allocated in the Virginia Transportation Act of 2000 to each district.
01:35:44
So each district shares in the debt service according to their share of the transportation.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:35:51
But only to the extent that the projects listed are being funded.
SPEAKER_14
01:35:55
No sir, according to the percentage of what's in the plan.
01:35:59
All the projects are eligible for funding at some point.
SPEAKER_23
01:36:06
I'm sorry, but I didn't quite hear that response, Mr. Cassidy.
01:36:10
Would you say it?
01:36:11
The secretary asked you one question, and you said no, but then you went on to say something else, and I didn't quite hear that.
01:36:19
What were you saying?
SPEAKER_14
01:36:20
I said that the total percentage, because all the projects in the VTA are eligible for funding, and that's the percentage that was used.
SPEAKER_23
01:36:31
So if something in the Salem district, even if they have no France allocation, it's still required
SPEAKER_12
01:36:41
In other words, Bob, you're saying that if I've got a bunch of friends in my district, Brian's or Randy's are going to have to help pay for my interest on my friends, is that right, in my district?
SPEAKER_14
01:37:04
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_12
01:37:06
Even though I don't have any?
SPEAKER_14
01:37:07
If you don't have any, or if, you know.
SPEAKER_12
01:37:11
I mean, if I have a lot, they're gonna, and they don't have any, they're gonna have to help pay for mine, is that correct?
01:37:16
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_04
01:37:17
I don't think so.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:37:25
Kenny?
01:37:26
Bob, you're talking about the VTA 2000 list?
01:37:30
Yes sir.
01:37:31
The one that still exists?
01:37:33
Yes sir.
01:37:33
After the legislature stripped out money in this past budget that was given to us to help fund those?
01:37:41
And now you're telling us that, and by the way, I understand I have a number of EPA projects on that list, but why should Wendy have to pay for the debt service that is coming from Northern Virginia projects?
SPEAKER_20
01:38:02
We do have 58.
01:38:03
I'm going to be up front.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:38:04
No, no, no.
01:38:05
I'm just saying that, you know, if you
01:38:09
What I had hoped I had heard you say, but now since Zirk jumped in, he's right.
01:38:16
You didn't say is that the share of the FRAN debt service is not by what the projects that they are funding by district.
01:38:31
No, sir, because that changes every year.
01:38:34
Well, why can't that change every year?
01:38:38
I mean, you know, this whole Fran discussion has been, the more I've learned about it, the less I like it.
01:38:49
I understand why we're doing it now to make, so the dip isn't deeper than it would be.
01:38:58
But I'm not sure it is fair to fund BTA projects with PRANS and then go charge another district for some of the debt service.
01:39:10
I have a real problem with that and I'm hurting Northern Virginia in saying that, but I think if Northern Virginia has got BTA projects that are FAN PRAN funded that we ought to be paying the debt service on.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:24
Let me ask you something.
01:39:27
Wasn't there something in the Appropriations Act, Bob, that dealt with how to allocate the debt?
SPEAKER_14
01:39:35
I don't remember, no sir.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:39:39
That was just with the 317.
01:39:44
I want to try to use my simple noodle a minute and get these down to where there are yes or no answers.
01:39:53
Yes or no answers.
01:39:55
We looked at the total six-year program.
01:39:59
Forget the districts.
01:40:00
Total six-year program.
01:40:02
There are some projects in there that are financed with frames.
01:40:09
Since they're financed with France, there is some amount of debt service that has to be born in the program.
01:40:18
Yes, sir.
01:40:21
Now, if we break that down into districts, there are some projects in District A that are financed with France.
SPEAKER_14
01:40:34
Yes, sir.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:40:36
Is the debt service charged back to District A specifically tagged to the use of frans in that district?
01:40:48
No, sir.
SPEAKER_12
01:40:51
Did you say no, sir, or yes?
01:40:53
I said no.
SPEAKER_06
01:40:53
No?
01:40:54
No.
SPEAKER_05
01:40:57
I've got one comment.
01:40:58
I haven't looked in detail.
01:41:02
I think through the VTA,
01:41:05
The Lynchburg District was supposed to get like a hundred, hundred and five million dollars for Madison Heights and a couple more things.
01:41:14
A hundred and five million.
01:41:15
I don't know what you're going to sell the brands for, five percent, whatever you're going to bond them in.
01:41:20
Tom, do you want to say something?
SPEAKER_11
01:41:35
Yes, let me see if I can try to put this in.
01:41:39
For the VTA projects,
01:41:41
There is a pot of resources available to fund those projects.
01:41:46
Now it could be priority transportation funds, it could be something from the construction fund, or it could be friends.
01:41:52
It's all available for those projects.
01:41:57
What we use when time comes for those projects is depending upon our cash flow needs and situations at the time.
01:42:03
But they're all resources that are thrown into one pot and then pulled out for the projects.
01:42:08
For allocation purposes, we identify them as FRANs.
01:42:12
And when FRANs really are a cash flow vehicle, they are not like other bond programs where they're sold specifically for Project A or specifically for Project B.
01:42:22
They're sold as a cash flow vehicle.
01:42:25
And as such, it goes into that total cash flow pot.
01:42:29
And therefore, whether you get friends or not, you may have gotten friends and somebody else got the cash.
01:42:35
So it seemed only fair that everybody share.
01:42:38
Otherwise, nobody wants projects with friends.
01:42:42
Does that clarify it any?
SPEAKER_05
01:42:47
Let me explain to you how I look at it.
01:42:50
Yes, sir.
01:42:51
I don't know if I'm going to be able to get this across.
01:42:55
I have a Sal Hogg project in my district called Mouse Nights Bypass.
01:42:59
Let's get him on out of the way to the side.
01:43:02
Then we look at the rest of the district, okay?
01:43:05
And my colleagues here on the board, obviously for the last 60 to 90 days, we communicate with each other.
01:43:13
And as we approve this tentative plan, I'm going to vote for it.
01:43:19
Because in the last week and a half, I've seen movement and changes in it
01:43:24
that benefits the district.
01:43:29
A lot of projects have been dropped.
01:43:32
When I asked Randy what happened, I got killed.
01:43:36
When I asked Sonny, I got killed.
01:43:40
And I asked other people.
01:43:42
I've asked Mr. Kling and I've asked Coby, are you, how do you, we're okay.
01:43:51
And what I cannot understand is,
01:43:55
Bear with me, fellow board members, is when I look at the projects that have been pulled out of what I call rural Virginia, and I have all the respect in the world for my colleagues on this board from northern Virginia and the problems that they have, but when I hear that they're okay,
01:44:17
And then I hear the efforts that we have in the state for sales tax referendums and gas tax, all those type things, and I go look at this thing.
01:44:30
And if I look back, and I don't remember the numbers, I'm probably off some, but if Lynchburg was going to get 100 to 125 million dollars in France,
01:44:39
You know, my simple mind says, well, if you're going to go out there and bond them before five percent, if you want to allocate a debt service to me, yeah, I'll take five, six million dollars, but that's 28 million dollars in here, and I think that's just the general role that's in here.
01:45:00
Again, I'm not totally satisfied with what I see at the Lynchburg District, but it's a great improvement in the last two to three weeks.
01:45:08
and if that's what we have to pick up and start with and go and even in the Lynchburg District when I look out there regardless of having to pay off Madison Heights Bypass I believe we have positioned this district for three or four years down the road that was the proper input of localities and the proper control
01:45:31
of how we put projects in it, Lynchburg can pick itself up and move along and be okay.
SPEAKER_06
01:45:39
I know that this has been a very difficult time for everybody, and I don't believe that any of us can say we're completely happy.
01:45:56
But in my heart I think the staff did a great job and I want to thank them.
01:46:01
A lot of hard work is going into this.
01:46:04
I'm 76 years old and I've learned over the years there's no perfect world here and nothing in this world is perfect.
01:46:13
I think that we have something here that we need to go ahead and move forward.
01:46:19
Like Mr. Byrd said, he's willing to prove his thing.
01:46:22
We can always tweak it down the line.
01:46:25
But I hate to think that we can sit here and pull this thing all apart here today when we need to go ahead and move forward because a tremendous amount of man-hours has gone into this.
01:46:36
And we can sit here all day and debate from one direction to the other.
01:46:40
But that's not going to get us where we need to go.
01:46:42
I think we need to come back on the areas back again, on the areas that we need to tweak.
01:46:48
But in the meantime, let's move forward with the six-year plan.
01:46:52
That's just my suggestion to my knowledge.
01:47:00
And with that, I'd like to make the motion to approve the six-year plan.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:47:05
I second it.
SPEAKER_04
01:47:07
I agree, I think we have to move the plan forward, but I just have a question.
01:47:16
Mr. Boyd indicated that the Frans are really a cash flow vehicle.
01:47:22
No board member got to choose whether they wanted Frans or didn't want Frans.
01:47:28
So it seemed like why wouldn't we take the money to pay back the FRANs off the top before all the money is distributed rather than to try to charge it back to the district based on some artificial number of projects that are getting FRANs versus projects that are not getting FRANs?
SPEAKER_11
01:47:45
Mr. Bevon, it's not an artificial number.
01:47:47
The FRANs are used for VTA projects, except for the 317, which we are taking that off the top.
01:47:53
The FRANs are used for a specific list of projects
01:47:57
A. Givens, Michael A. S.
01:48:11
The percentage is in that list instead of a different percentage.
SPEAKER_04
01:48:14
You're saying because that's what the legislature decided to do?
01:48:17
Correct.
SPEAKER_11
01:48:18
The legislature said we can only use it on this list, and they defined the list and put dollar amounts.
SPEAKER_04
01:48:23
But the first amount of FRANS, which was used for just cash flow purposes, that is being charged off the top.
01:48:30
No, it's not.
01:48:31
It's not?
01:48:32
No.
SPEAKER_11
01:48:32
The only ones off the top are going to be the 317.
01:48:34
That's what I'm saying.
01:48:35
Just a half-cent sale stock.
01:48:37
I thought you meant the 375 we'd already sold.
01:48:40
Okay.
01:48:40
Right, the PTF is taking, remember, as much as possible, the priority transportation fund will pay debt service.
01:48:46
So you're not talking about near as much as you think about being allocated this way.
01:48:51
Because there is money in the priority transportation fund that will take care of a lot of the debt service.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:48:56
So what you're saying is the 375, how did you allocate that debt service?
01:49:01
By district?
01:49:03
by the projects that they funded within the district.
SPEAKER_11
01:49:17
A pot of projects.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:49:21
Did you allocate the debt service on the 375 by the districts that were part of the pot of projects?
SPEAKER_11
01:49:30
That's what we would have done if there was insufficient PTF money to take care of it.
01:49:33
So that wasn't a problem under that service?
01:49:36
Not then, because then we have resources to the PTF.
01:49:39
In the future years, we're not going to have the same resources to the priority transportation fund, so there will be a need to draw from someplace else.
01:49:47
And it's, again, there is a, if you want to look at cash coming in from the construction fund, cash coming from the priority transportation fund, cash coming from friends, it gets all mixed around and there's a cost to building that pot, the whole pot.
01:50:01
And that cost is shared by who gets the benefit of the pot.
SPEAKER_20
01:50:03
I fully intend to vote in favor of this.
01:50:09
I had no intention not to, and I want to do it today.
01:50:13
But I'd also like to be as informed as possible.
01:50:20
We have friends that are going to non-highway and, well, we don't do maintenance with friends, but non-highway programs as well, I recall, as I sit here.
01:50:32
That's correct.
01:50:32
Transit programs as well.
01:50:33
DRPT?
01:50:34
Yes, ma'am.
01:50:35
Where is that debt service?
01:50:37
Is that in here also?
SPEAKER_11
01:50:38
Could be out of the districts.
01:50:40
Out of the transportation.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:50:43
We did not allocate that debt service to those transit projects.
01:50:48
Because we thought it was a disproportionate hit given if you look at the dollar amount.
SPEAKER_04
01:50:54
It wouldn't be a disproportionate wipe out of the transportation trust fund.
01:51:00
The difference is the legislature in that particular case voted highway dollars for a transit project.
01:51:09
They didn't vote to prioritize a transit project.
01:51:12
So, if they voted highway dollars for a transit project, the debt service would come out of the highway portion of the fund also, not out of the transit portion of the trust fund.
01:51:24
The debt service would be larger than what we get out of the trust fund.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:51:28
Let me say this.
01:51:29
This really goes to the issue that the commissioner spoke about yesterday on debt management.
01:51:37
We weren't able to do it, and please correct me someone if I'm wrong, we weren't able to do it this time exactly like it was done last time and exactly like it was originally contemplated because the General Assembly gave us flexibility on France so we could keep some projects that were in the construction stage moving forward.
01:52:04
And so they gave us that flexibility.
01:52:06
I think, Randy, and I do think we've got a short-term issue here and a long-term issue here.
01:52:13
The long-term issue is what Philip spoke about yesterday.
01:52:17
But I think that in the next 30 days we can reexamine this to try to give us all a better comfort level.
01:52:25
But I think the answer is really going to be that it's a combination.
01:52:29
There is some allocation in my district on the projects and then some sharing of pain by all the districts for projects that aren't in your district.
01:52:37
And, of course, in transit is an example.
01:52:40
I suspect Route 288 is an example.
01:52:44
Not sure, but we know, because of the, just the magnitude of that project.
SPEAKER_19
01:52:48
And that's where, excuse me, but that's where there is some disagreement in the determination of what the source of funds is to pay back to friends on particular projects in the long term.
01:53:05
And I'm not so sure that everyone involved agrees
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:53:09
I'm not sure that we're going to be able to fix that without General Assembly action, but I think the staff has done a superlative job in trying to balance these given our directions and given what we've had to deal with.
01:53:29
And I think that the course of action that we should take today, knowing that we've all got some of these debt issues, is to, as Randy said, go ahead and vote on the tentative and we will make this our number one priority to get into this issue quickly.
01:53:50
We might give them a day or two rest.
01:53:52
And then to return to this and try to break down these figures and maybe get it in writing exactly how we're going to treat that so we'll have time to make what of adjustments we need before the final plan.
01:54:05
Yeah, just a minute.
01:54:05
Zirk was first.
SPEAKER_23
01:54:06
Sir, I just, I know we're beating this dead horse to death because it's going to, we're going to have to wake him up and ride him sometimes.
01:54:18
Mr. Byrd made a statement that he had
01:54:25
I had taken a reading from all of his colleagues here on the board.
01:54:31
And he specifically mentioned the Northern Virginia contingency.
01:54:35
And I said, Mr. Byrd, you didn't ask me that question.
01:54:37
I would not have said everything was OK.
01:54:39
I assure you.
01:54:41
I'd like to have some rebuttal.
SPEAKER_11
01:54:44
I would too.
SPEAKER_23
01:54:47
However, that notwithstanding, I
01:54:51
I'll be very candid with my colleagues and with you, sir.
01:54:56
I've had some real consternation about this process all along, and I raised some concerns with Mr. Patel at the last meeting when he briefed us about that 217% of the staff applied to these various projects, and I thought that
01:55:21
That explanation just didn't set well with me.
01:55:28
So that's why I raised that question.
01:55:29
I'm becoming more comfortable with that now, but I'm still sort of out on a limb on it.
01:55:42
And then when the commissioner briefed us yesterday and indicated that
01:55:47
He is concerned about developing more reliable cost estimates.
01:55:54
Made me feel a little bit more comfortable.
01:56:00
But that's not going to come in time for us to make the final decision next month.
01:56:06
So it's going to be in the September, in the fall time frame.
01:56:12
That's why I raised the question about whether or not we are going to have the opportunity to revisit some of these projects because the question that still stands out in my mind and that has not been really addressed is that I see the economy moving in a very positive direction and what if
01:56:38
All these drastic and draconian moves that we've made, turns out that we've got more on hand, money, that is, than we had envisioned that we're going to have.
01:56:51
I haven't heard anyone say, here's how we're going to use it.
01:56:54
And I want to be able to hear someone say that we can put some of these projects back on the table, even if it is, even though we don't have to wait until next year to do that.
01:57:08
For example, I've got a project in my area that's an urban project that you, because of the funding constraints, you moved it out a year, 18 months.
01:57:24
Well, 18 months is a long time when you're having a fight with your constituents and every morning you wake up and you've got a phone call that
01:57:33
I'm sitting out here in traffic, you know, and I've got to deal with that on a day-to-day basis.
01:57:40
So 18 months becomes a long time for us to do that.
01:57:42
So I want to know, and I think that you're making an effort to try to address that, but that question is lingering in my mind.
01:57:54
And the other thing that stands out is the fact that we have
01:58:01
and I know that you're making this effort and you're trying to get control of this cost thing and by virtue of the fact that some of the projects have been
01:58:11
You've reduced them in your cost estimates showing that they're coming back in line.
01:58:16
The cost estimates are lowering.
01:58:18
So I'd like to take that as being some positive elements of trying to come to grips with the situation.
01:58:28
So in that regard, I would hope that this board and the staff will work diligently together
01:58:41
to put these projects back into perspective as best we can considering the constraints.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:58:52
Sir, if it would be helpful, Philip can provide us monthly reports or quarterly reports on changing revenue and in the cost estimating process on the debt service as well as the revenues.
SPEAKER_23
01:59:11
I think that probably would be helpful, sir, and because I think that we all need to know exactly where we're headed and how we're going to get there because I can see these representatives being badgered daily by the citizenry in the various districts.
01:59:32
And they need to be able to say with some degree of accuracy that help is on the way.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
01:59:39
Okay, Bryan and then Libby.
01:59:40
All right, Libby?
SPEAKER_12
01:59:42
Well, I thought the secretary told us yesterday that he, that the transportation board, if money came in, it would not be spent for anything.
01:59:54
without this board's approval.
01:59:56
That is what he told me.
01:59:58
And I think that we've got a commissioner here that is trying to do the right thing and he's only been here a month and I think it takes a little bit of time to get your feet on the ground and get running.
02:00:13
And I think that we as a board should give Philip the opportunity to work on this and then come back to us with this.
02:00:23
But I don't think that we should not approve this plan today.
SPEAKER_23
02:00:26
I didn't say that.
02:00:26
All I said, I laid these rationales out and then my final comment was, or is,
02:00:33
That I will support the plan, but with these...
SPEAKER_12
02:00:36
But you heard the commissioner yesterday, or the secretary, say that he would come to the board if there's extra money.
02:00:43
They have to come to the board with it.
SPEAKER_05
02:00:46
Roy?
02:00:47
I know we've made a motion and whatnot, and like I said, I'm going to support it, and there's a lot of questions and concerns.
02:00:56
The Finance Committee had met yesterday in looking at the budget and we had some review of it yesterday at the workshop.
02:01:03
And several of the Finance Committee members have indicated the possibility of possibly coming back to Richmond in the next couple of weeks ago.
02:01:12
May I suggest that somewhere in the next two weeks, if you folks can coordinate it, not just the Finance Committee, that we have
02:01:22
Starting at 830 one morning, a day-long session, a workshop, and let's go through this budget.
02:01:30
Let's devote, break it up, the VDOT budget.
02:01:33
Let's give Leo an hour, and let's go through this thing and take another day and take a look at the budget.
02:01:41
Now, I think most of us know about our own projects in the plan there, and we'll work on those.
02:01:48
But let's look at these items, the budget.
02:01:51
Let's look at the debt service schedules and let's just get a better feel for it.
02:01:56
I would suggest that we do that.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:01:59
Philip says he will personally oversee that exercise.
02:02:03
I would also, with one caveat, I think it's also worth talking to some localities and getting some feedback from them because in some cases there's some things that they know that we don't know, especially when it deals with right-of-way issues in our urban areas.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:02:19
Hopefully you'll show up at the meeting with that.
02:02:21
Okay Sonny.
02:02:23
One remark I do want to say I appreciate the hard work and dedication of the staff.
SPEAKER_07
02:02:34
It's a tough, tough job and we just did one in December and here we are again.
02:02:41
and they worked weekends and whatever.
02:02:43
It's really, really been tough and the last couple of weeks have been more than interesting to us as board members.
02:02:53
Evidently Joyce gave up on me.
02:02:54
She went to Knoxville to be with her grandchildren, but hopefully she'll be back.
02:02:59
Thanks.
SPEAKER_24
02:03:01
I think we beat this tentative thing to death, so let's move on with the questions.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:03:13
I'm sorry, Hobie.
02:03:14
I've been trying to ask, sorry.
02:03:17
I'm going to support this as well.
02:03:19
I would tell you, we got our plan here to the best of knowledge.
02:03:24
I think the issue now is about how the money is working and how the distributions are working.
02:03:30
Frankly, I hear some things about General Assembly issues that come into play, which also drive this.
02:03:37
That particular piece
02:03:39
I think it's probably the most unclear of this plan.
02:03:42
I absolutely do not understand the total picture of the General Assembly actions and how they deal with this plan.
02:03:50
I think I'd like to understand that when we get together.
02:03:52
And I think it would be helpful for General Assembly members to understand
02:03:56
I think there's a lot of people confused about how all those actions have affected this.
SPEAKER_05
02:04:06
That's the reason I say we need to come back.
02:04:09
If one hour that day is to bring
02:04:11
Senate Finance in or whoever, and have an hour dialogue, then so be it.
02:04:17
Let's take another day and look at this one.
SPEAKER_06
02:04:20
Chairman, we have a motion on the floor.
02:04:22
Can we take a motion?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:04:22
Yeah, been moved and seconded.
02:04:25
All in favor of adopting the Tenant to Six-Year Plan, please say aye.
02:04:29
Aye.
02:04:30
All opposed, like signed.
02:04:32
Very good.
02:04:34
Bob, thank you very much.
02:04:35
Thank you and Billy and Jim and Charlie and everybody else associated with that process.
02:04:42
And I'll ask the commissioner to focus in on the debt service issue, focus in on the directions from the General Assembly so that we can have as much time as we need to within the next couple of weeks to reconvene.
SPEAKER_02
02:05:02
Next item on the agenda
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:11
is Kevin Page.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:05:13
Kevin, good morning.
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:05:15
Yes, thank you Mr. Chairman, members of the board.
02:05:17
Good afternoon.
02:05:18
We have two action items for the board for consideration today.
02:05:22
The first is a rail industrial access project located in Franklin County.
02:05:26
It's Trinity Packaging Corporation.
02:05:28
Trinity is proposing to construct 700 plus or minus feet of track to serve their new facility.
02:05:34
which incorporates 242 new carloads of rail traffic per year, 300 new jobs in an area that right now is 1.4% over the state average, and they plan to participate in a capital investment of $9.1 million.
02:05:51
Trinity scored 64 points, and this project has been very closely coordinated with the Economic Development Partnership.
02:05:58
Some of the board members may remember that Trinity announced that they were going to Clarksville, Virginia, and then another state picked them off, and Franklin County was able to bring them back to the Commonwealth.
02:06:07
So, this project is important for Virginia as well.
02:06:10
I'll turn the floor now over to Mr. White, Chairman of the RTAH.
SPEAKER_23
02:06:13
Mr. Chairman, I move for approval.
02:06:17
Second.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:17
Second moved and seconded.
02:06:19
Any discussion on the motion?
SPEAKER_20
02:06:20
Mr. Secretary, I don't want to belay this either, okay?
02:06:25
It's hours late, but I'm not sure everybody heard Kevin's reference to the unemployment.
SPEAKER_23
02:06:30
Oh, yes.
02:06:31
Oh, well, okay, yes.
SPEAKER_20
02:06:32
And I have a lot of sympathy for your people who are in congestion going to their jobs.
SPEAKER_23
02:06:38
Yes.
SPEAKER_20
02:06:39
But when you don't have jobs, you don't have congestion.
SPEAKER_23
02:06:43
Correct.
02:06:44
That was very succinctly raised in our meeting this morning and that's one of the reasons we had
02:06:53
This was accepted with glee at our committee meeting.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:06:57
Any further discussion?
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:06:58
Paul, please say aye.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:07:01
Aye.
Kevin B. Page
Chief of Rail Transportation
02:07:01
Any opposed?
02:07:02
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
02:07:03
Our second action item today is an action item to update the existing rail industrial access policy to better meet the needs of the tracks program and in a way mirror the road access program that the board deals with as well.
02:07:16
As written as action item 19, we have identified new funding limits
02:07:21
over those that were adopted on November 16th of 95 to include the annual jurisdictional allocation limit, the maximum limit to $450,000 per year and the maximum amount of unmatched funds to be raised to $300,000 per year with a 50-50 match of $150,000 per jurisdiction per year.
02:07:40
Yes, sir.
SPEAKER_23
02:07:41
Does the board recall last month I indicated to you that we were going to come back to you with a request to raise this limit?
02:07:50
The committee passed this this morning and I would like to move that we approve this action
02:08:00
to increase the limits on these funds.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:04
Seconded.
02:08:05
Moved and seconded.
02:08:06
Is there any discussion on the motion?
02:08:10
All in favor of the resolution please say aye.
02:08:14
Aye.
02:08:14
Any opposed?
02:08:15
Thank you, Chairman.
02:08:16
Thank you, Kevin.
02:08:18
Next item is a resolution, a proposed resolution commending Carter Myers for his service.
02:08:26
It is under tab item 20.
02:08:30
Rather than take everyone's time to read it, out loud I believe everybody's had an opportunity to look at it and upon its adoption we will get it suitably prepared and framed
02:08:45
to present to Carter.
John J. "Butch" Davies III
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:08:53
First of all, I think you all ought to know that the day that the announcement was in the newspaper that I had been appointed by the governor to this board, Carter was on the phone.
02:09:04
He drove to Culpepper.
02:09:06
I got three and a half hours VDOT boarding to Carter Mountain.
02:09:13
And I can tell you, it was delightful.
02:09:15
I told him, I said, I had a great time going through the plan, seeing Charlottesville, Albemarle, Albemarle, Albemarle, Charlottesville.
02:09:21
I said, you know, we ought to mix up the alphabet a little better.
02:09:26
But seriously, he did yeoman's work when any jurisdiction in his district, in the Culpeper district, had an issue.
02:09:34
He responded.
02:09:35
He would come and meet with the people.
02:09:37
He adjusted his schedule constantly.
02:09:40
I think he took great pride in having tweaked some people a little bit about the rest stops and the cleanup initiative which I noticed is referred to in the resolution.
02:09:55
Mr. Chairman, I'd like to move adoption of the resolution.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:01
Seconded.
02:10:01
All in favor say aye.
02:10:05
Any new business?
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:06
Kenny, I have a request, Mr. Chairman.
02:10:10
In the January meeting, we were to discuss an agenda item on establishing criteria for the six-year plan.
02:10:21
And it was postponed out of deference to you and Ray Patel being new.
02:10:28
And I'm wondering, now that we're into a discussion of the new six-year plan, if it isn't time to, say, bring it up at the next workshop and then possibly as a board item in June?
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:45
That sounds fine with me, Kenny.
02:10:49
Was this, this came out of your commission, where they laid out something?
02:10:53
Yeah, okay.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:54
And then Tom Boyd worked up the paper.
02:10:58
Right.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:10:58
I think that's appropriate.
02:11:02
If there's no objection, we will get that on the agenda for the workshop.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:06
Well, I don't want to, I mean, I want to give Phil as much time as he thinks he needs, and if it's a month past that, but I think it's time to bring it up.
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:16
I would
02:11:17
I would deeply appreciate more than 30 days.
02:11:21
If we could do that, perhaps discuss it in June, just informally.
02:11:29
Perhaps have a workshop around it, but not for action.
02:11:32
I support your idea.
02:11:35
I would appreciate a bit more time.
SPEAKER_05
02:11:38
Roy?
02:11:38
I have one question I don't have somebody out here.
02:11:41
I haven't looked.
02:11:44
Everybody's been working in their own district and projects
02:11:47
Does anybody know whether the Chincoteague Bridge survived or not?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:53
Anybody know?
02:11:55
Way to go, Mal.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:11:57
Boy, I'd say... By any, uh, any... Hubby?
Philip A. Shucet
Vice Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:01
We never see that one.
Leonard S. "Hobie" Mitchel
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:12:04
Could we?
02:12:06
We, uh...
02:12:07
I'm gonna say this every meeting, uh, you know, we've gone through a lot of bad news here, but we've got some real facts I think we're dealing with.
02:12:17
But come in November, we have a couple of referendums that are coming up that will help alleviate some of the problems around the state.
02:12:24
And I just want to remind the board members who were affected by that.
02:12:27
And frankly, it even affects the more rural areas.
02:12:31
If these are successful, then we've got to start focusing on other things around the state, like I-81, too.
02:12:36
But let's get what we have done now and support it.
02:12:41
And I think it's so important we're adding billions of dollars
02:12:45
Well, why don't, Hobie, why don't we put that on the workshop to bring everybody up to date on, I mean, even though, Sonny, it's, you're far away from it, but it's still, you'll be knowledgeable about
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:13
It more than just in concept, but it'll still be effective too.
02:13:18
That's right.
02:13:18
And some of the arguments in favor of the referendum, that air quality issue, for example, in Northern Virginia is very important.
02:13:29
And then the projects in Hampton Roads as well.
02:13:32
I think that would be very appropriate.
J. Kenneth Klinge
Member, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:35
Mr. Secretary, do we know what happened yesterday at COG on the air quality discussion?
02:13:43
I don't know.
02:13:46
I guess it wasn't too bad.
SPEAKER_12
02:13:49
If we can help the board members in any way, Northern Virginia and Tidewater, you all tell us, Kenny.
Whittington W. Clement
Chair, Commonwealth Transportation Board
02:13:54
We'll be bound to just the people we know.
02:13:57
Okay, anything else before the board?
02:14:00
We stand adjourned.
02:14:03
Thank you.