Central Virginia
City of Charlottesville
City Council Meeting 11/18/2013
Auto-scroll
City Council Meeting
11/18/2013
ANNOUNCEMENTS
MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
COUNCIL RESPONSE
ANNOUNCEMENTS
SPEAKER_14
00:01:04
Music playing
00:01:34
and more!
00:02:03
you
Kathy Galvin
Member, City Council
00:04:22
Thank you.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:05:36
Okay, let's have seats.
00:05:50
I call to order Srikanth's meeting on November 18th.
00:05:55
We have a pleasure of allegiance.
00:06:21
You start our meeting with awards and recognitions.
00:06:33
We have a treat for us to start our city council meeting today and I would like to introduce
SPEAKER_18
00:06:51
Good evening, thank you for having me.
00:06:53
My name is Sarah Bleech and I'm the Therapeutic Recreation Manager for the City of Charlottesville Parks and Recreation.
00:06:59
And I wanted to introduce a couple of our speakers from VSA Arts, which is a program of therapeutic parks and recreation focusing on promoting creativity in people with disabilities.
00:07:11
One of our projects is a poetry book and we would like to present each of you with a poetry book and I have a couple of poets here and they will present the books and read the poems.
00:07:24
This is Rose Williams and David Smatresk.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:07:27
So Rose, would you like to start with reading first?
SPEAKER_14
00:07:29
Yes, please.
SPEAKER_02
00:07:35
Hello, my name is Rose Williams and I am co-chair of the VFA.
00:07:41
Program that promotes our civic value and people with disabilities.
00:07:48
We are here this evening to present to you our 2013 Poetry Book Project.
00:08:00
In addition to poems, you will also
00:08:10
Poems that have been turned into songs and drama.
00:08:17
And so we thank you for funding our program and we hope that you will continue to do so.
00:08:26
Thank you.
00:08:29
This is Mr. Smithers.
00:08:31
He is going to be reading his poem on page 114.
SPEAKER_06
00:08:38
Please come forward and read the poem Memories of San Francisco by Dave Smathers Stinson Beach, 92 Stinson Beach, 92 The bus stop in Alcatraz
00:09:07
Alred Alcatraz.
00:09:11
It was a rocky boat ride up to the island of San Francisco Bay.
00:09:16
A glorious day, me and mom feeling free till we saw the prison.
00:09:27
Barbed wire, water, no escape.
00:09:34
Inside the cell
00:09:37
Small cells, damp, moist, clammy, barren, tiny cot in the toilet.
00:09:52
Prisoners sweeping, building, laborist things, longs,
00:10:06
Yucky Food.
00:10:12
We clanked the cell door slamming shut.
00:10:18
The recorded voice, prisoners, tell their story.
00:10:26
Thank you.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:10:26
Thank you very much.
00:10:33
I also want to recognize our Councilman-elect, Mr. Fenwick, in the audience, and he'll get used to this place very soon.
00:10:42
Welcome him.
Kristin Szakos
Vice Mayor, City Council
00:10:44
I'd also just like to mention that I had the opportunity, I couldn't stay for the whole thing, but I did come to the poetry reading class in high school, and it was really good, and I really enjoyed it, so thank you for doing that every year.
Dede Smith
Member, City Council
00:10:58
The former director.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:11:02
Thanks for being here.
SPEAKER_11
00:11:11
Yes, I have an announcement for this holiday city market beginning this Saturday, November 23rd.
00:11:17
The holiday market will run every Saturday through December 21st from 8 a.m. until 1 p.m.
00:11:23
The holiday city market is located at the corner of Water and South Street parking lot where our regular city market is located.
00:11:29
Unique gifts and decorations to meet all of your holiday wishes will be offered at the holiday market.
00:11:35
All items are hand-made, home-grown or home-baked by local farmers, artists or bakers.
00:11:40
So we look forward to seeing you there.
Dede Smith
Member, City Council
00:11:46
Yes, I have an announcement.
00:11:48
The Neighborhood Leadership Institute
00:11:50
is accepting applications at this point.
00:11:53
The City of Charlottesville's Neighborhood Leadership Institute provides participants with information on a range of subjects including city boards and commissions, transportation, affordable housing, public safety and volunteer opportunities.
00:12:08
The aim is to equip participants through information and network opportunities to take action and to mobilize others to engage our community in a positive way.
00:12:19
Participants will be challenged to undertake a class project that will be formally presented to city leaders
00:12:25
at the conclusion of the series.
00:12:27
Graduates of the program will also be presented with diplomas at a graduation ceremony.
00:12:33
The class is limited to 30 participants.
00:12:35
It's open to all ages.
00:12:37
It's actually city and county are eligible.
00:12:41
And the deadline to apply is December 15th.
00:12:44
It doesn't give details here, but it begins, I believe, in January.
00:12:48
It's every other Wednesday?
00:12:50
for about three hours in the evening.
00:12:53
Anybody want to affirm me on that?
00:12:55
Several of us did it actually before we were on council.
00:12:58
It is an absolutely amazing opportunity.
00:13:01
It's free and you're even given dinner.
00:13:05
Thank you.
00:13:11
Thank you for reminding me that I didn't give that information.
00:13:15
You can go on to Charlottesville.org, which is our homepage,
00:13:19
and click on I want to or to apply to NLI Neighborhood Leadership Institute.
00:13:27
I would hope it's actually on our homepage and perhaps it can be.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:13:31
And if you go to Neighborhood Services, Neighborhood Services Department, go to them and they can register you also.
Dede Smith
Member, City Council
00:13:39
It's a great opportunity.
00:13:40
It's really, really fun.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:13:42
Ms. Szakos?
Kristin Szakos
Vice Mayor, City Council
00:13:42
All right, I have our Thanksgiving holiday announcements.
00:13:48
Charlottesville city administrative offices will be closed on Thanksgiving, unlike some retail stores in our community.
00:13:55
We'll be closed both Thursday and Friday for Thanksgiving.
00:13:58
Charlottesville area transportation, CAT, will operate on a Sunday schedule on Thanksgiving Day.
00:14:03
Thank you to the drivers who are driving that day.
00:14:05
Full service will resume on Friday, November 29th.
00:14:09
City trash and recycling services,
00:14:11
Curbside, Trash and Recycling will not be collected Thursday.
00:14:14
Thursday collection will be picked up on Friday.
00:14:17
Friday collection will be picked up on Saturday and city offices will reopen on Monday, December 2nd.
00:14:23
And I also just wanted to mention that three of the counselors have been in Seattle for part of the past week at the National League of Cities meeting learning lots of new things and I think as we maybe at the next meeting, we just got back last night so
00:14:38
It's a little too soon to debrief, but I think it would be nice if at some point we can tell a little bit about what we did, maybe at the next meeting.
00:14:45
That'd be great.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:14:48
Ms. Cameron?
Kathy Galvin
Member, City Council
00:14:48
Yes, I have one announcement, and should the acknowledgements be later after that, or right after?
00:14:54
After the announcement.
00:14:56
Okay.
00:14:56
So the announcement, the grand illumination.
00:14:58
Join the City of Charlottesville and the Downtown Business Association as we celebrate the holiday season.
00:15:03
and Light the Tree at Central Place on the downtown mall Friday, November 29 beginning at 5pm.
00:15:11
There will be activities for the whole family including crafts, performers, speakers and music.
00:15:15
The tree will be lit shortly before 6pm.
00:15:18
Come downtown for the holidays.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:15:20
It is really fun.
00:15:21
If you don't believe me, come and try it.
00:15:25
There is a special recognition we want to make
00:15:29
and Ms. Galvin will read and then we have a moment of silence after that.
Kathy Galvin
Member, City Council
00:15:34
Yes, thank you Mayor Huja.
00:15:36
This fall has seen the passing of a couple of individuals that I think represent for all of us here in the city remarkable people who built this city's moral fiber and physical beauty.
00:15:52
The first person I'd like to acknowledge is the Reverend Dr. R.A. Johnson.
00:15:56
He was 92 when he passed away on September 19 at the University of Virginia Medical Center in Charlottesville, Virginia.
00:16:04
He was born on June 26, 1921 in Esmont, Virginia.
00:16:11
The list of awards that Dr. Johnson received during his 77 years in the ministry is extensive and he was the 2003's recipient of our city's coveted Martin Luther King Jr. Community Award.
00:16:24
He could be seen speaking, rallying to integrate the Paramount, Jefferson, University and drive-in theaters, marching, meeting, mobilizing, sitting in at the counters of Woolworth Incorporated, the Waffle Shop, Howard Johnson's and the infamous Buddy's Restaurant.
00:16:41
standing in hotel lobbies and seated across the desk from business owners or policy and decision makers in order to cause change, bettering the lives of the residents of our city and county.
00:16:56
And then last Sunday, November 10th, Gabe Silverman passed away.
00:17:05
He was 73.
00:17:06
He was born in Mexico in 1940.
00:17:10
When Mr. Silverman and his wife moved to a small community outside of Charlottesville, he built a fantastic house, half underground, and as he did everywhere, he then surrounded it with a garden.
00:17:25
And then he began to change the town, this town of Charlottesville.
00:17:29
artist studios, theaters, actually cool restaurants, schools, carnivals, coffee shops, dance halls, everywhere who lives in Charlottesville who has even visited the town is the recipient of his vision.
00:17:42
He loved beauty and was motivated by it throughout his life and I think with that we can all be inspired by those two individuals.
00:17:51
Thank you.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:17:51
Can we have a moment of silence in their memory?
Dede Smith
Member, City Council
00:18:14
Mayor Huja, would you like me to read the appointees to the boards?
Kristin Szakos
Vice Mayor, City Council
00:18:21
Before you do that, I also have one last announcement that I realized didn't get announced and I just wanted to make sure it does.
00:18:27
I was checking my calendar.
00:18:29
This Saturday at 10 a.m. is the Charlottesville Holiday Parade.
00:18:34
Santa, I understand, is coming and I hope that you will all come as well.
SPEAKER_11
00:18:38
And I had one more announcement too.
00:18:40
December 10th, which is a Tuesday at the Jefferson City
00:18:46
Jefferson School City Center at Carver Rec.
00:18:49
We're having a day-long or half-day-long job summit, looking at skilled trades jobs in our community, how do we grow and attract and retain more skilled trades jobs to allow low-income residents of our community to climb the economic ladder.
00:19:02
It is free and open to the public.
00:19:04
You can contact our City Office of Economic Development if you'd like to attend.
00:19:08
It's from 8.30 a.m. until 2 p.m. We've got some great speakers looking at some best practices, etc.
00:19:14
Does anybody happen to know off the top of your head the phone number for this Office of Economic Development?
00:19:20
But anyhow, you can look it up.
Dede Smith
Member, City Council
00:19:22
Get a prize.
SPEAKER_11
00:19:24
So anyhow, just look it up on the city website, City Office of Economic Development.
Dede Smith
Member, City Council
00:19:29
Thank you.
00:19:31
And with that, I'd like to move the following wonderful folks for our boards and commissions.
00:19:37
Nana Garti for the Citizens Police Academy, or Advisory Panel, excuse me.
00:19:43
Raymond Herron for the Jaunt Board, Carla Mullen for the Jefferson Madison Regional Library Board, Larissa Sneethern for MECA Board, Fred Wolf will be on the Place Design Task Force, Missy
00:19:59
Wernstrom for the Region 10 Community Services Board, Gemma Fendley, and Kabirafi Mahuto, I apologize, I probably massacred that, for our youth council, those two young people will be on our youth council.
00:20:14
and Christy Phillips for the Piedmont Workforce Network.
00:20:19
And you too could be on a board and commission.
00:20:22
So watch for openings and the Neighborhood Leadership Institute is a great way to prepare.
00:20:27
So I move that.
00:20:28
That's my motion.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:20:30
Second.
SPEAKER_19
00:20:36
and the phone number for the Office of Economic Development is 970-3110.
00:20:40
Thank you, Mr. Jones.
SPEAKER_11
00:20:41
970-3110 to RSVP for the job summit.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:20:45
Next part of our meeting is matters by the public.
00:20:51
Please sign the list.
00:20:52
As you come, please recognize your name, address, and limit yourself to three minutes.
00:20:58
And first person to sign up is Rose Williams.
SPEAKER_02
00:21:04
Good evening, my name is Rose Williams and I live at 305 Meade Avenue.
MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
SPEAKER_02
00:21:11
I'm here this evening to ask council not to move the downtown performance market.
00:21:21
I feel safe there rather than crossing the street at Meade Avenue.
00:21:33
The crosswalk there is a death trap in my opinion.
00:21:41
You know it's bad when you're in the middle of the crosswalk and the cars still won't stop.
00:21:50
I have worked with the city staff on this ongoing issue and I have made a conscious decision
00:22:01
not to cross the street again.
00:22:06
And I like the downtown market because it's safe, fun, loud, and busy, just like I like it to be.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:22:23
Thank you.
00:22:24
Thank you very much.
00:22:26
Thank you.
SPEAKER_12
00:22:44
I'm actually here to talk about two items.
00:22:47
First of all, Stand for the Silent is an anti-bullying organization in Charlottesville and Albemarle.
00:22:57
And at the recent Pride event, we decided to take a stand for Sage Smith.
00:23:06
And none of us, we have 102 members right now.
00:23:09
We would love to have many more to encourage
00:23:14
standing for the silent and what we did was we set up a booth at the Pride Festival and people came by and we told them about Sage who's been missing.
00:23:28
There will be a vigil this week and we were able to raise $100 in donations, which my daughter is somewhere.
00:23:38
Oh, you have it?
00:23:39
Okay, yeah.
00:23:40
And that is to add to the missing persons for SAGE.
00:23:44
It was disturbing to me how many people came by and they knew about other missing people in this area in Nelson County and we were encouraged by that.
00:23:53
We actually had pictures from other organizations, but a lot of them did not know about SAGE and SAGE was a vibrant individual.
00:24:03
of this community went to Charlottesville High and this community will not be full again until we get Sage back.
00:24:13
My family and the Stand for the Silent, we do not know Sage, but we do know
00:24:18
that Sage is missing and that it disturbed us that people didn't know and we felt led enough to do that for his family.
00:24:27
The one thing that his grandmother wanted was media and I pulled Newsplex over and I was very grateful to them for featuring Sage and letting her have a chance to talk because if you can only imagine if it was your child that was missing
00:24:46
how you would feel and that was encouraging.
00:24:50
We'd like for you to check out Seville Pride which a good friend of mine is the president of and they are having a vigil again I believe in two days.
00:25:01
the last time that Sage was seen.
00:25:03
So we would like to leave this for you all if you could place it.
00:25:07
I don't know where you feel like your heart.
00:25:09
We need to remember that this individual is gone, that this individual is a person and this individual is special, just like anyone else missing.
00:25:20
Secondly, first stand for the silent.
00:25:22
Stand for the Silence of Charlottesville.
00:25:25
As an anti-bullying organization, I believe my son spoke much more eloquently than I did last time we were here, but we are very happy to announce that the organization, like I said, we now have 102 members and that we are presenting the movie Bully, sponsored by Seba Pride.
00:25:50
at Sojourners, United, Church of Christ, Open Affirming Group, movie discussion, refreshments come and we are going to be modeling after a Shenandoah Valley program and actually have a forum of people.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:26:03
What's the date?
SPEAKER_12
00:26:05
Oh, the date.
00:26:05
I thought you were telling me to stop because I see the red band.
00:26:08
The date is November 30, 2013.
00:26:11
It is at 5 o'clock.
00:26:14
and we have individuals from the community and counselors and we are, oh now I need to stop.
00:26:22
Okay, we're having a forum put together and I would like to pass this around.
00:26:27
Thank you very much for listening.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:26:30
John Gooch.
SPEAKER_10
00:26:46
Good evening.
00:26:47
My name is John Gooch and I'm the executive director for a community energy conservation program located at 1819 Broadway Street.
00:26:54
I hope you all got my email that I sent out a little over a month ago.
00:27:00
I just wanted to put my face in front of you so you would know who I am.
00:27:04
I started there September the 1st and just trying to get us out there a little bit more.
00:27:09
We're a nonprofit organization that provides weatherization services.
00:27:14
for low income families in the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Green, Louisa, Nelson, Augusta, Highland and Rockingham, and the cities of Charlottesville, Harrisonburg, Stanton, and Waynesboro.
00:27:27
We provide full house energy audits.
00:27:29
We seal air leaks with insulation, caulking, and weather stripping.
00:27:33
We repair leaky duct systems.
00:27:36
We install carbon monoxide and smoke detectors.
00:27:41
We will repair or replace inefficient or unsafe heating systems.
00:27:45
We install energy efficient light bulbs and we will replace non-efficient refrigerators as well.
00:27:52
We're presently in a program called Crysis which is run by your Department of Social Services from November 1st through March 15th every year where someone can go through the Department of Social Services, get in touch with us as a vendor and we will
00:28:10
visit their home within 48 hours and see what needs to be done for them.
00:28:17
Since September of 2012 in the city of Charlottesville, we weatherized seven homes.
00:28:24
We'd like to do a few more.
00:28:25
We try to do about 10 a month on this side of the mountain and the other side of the mountain combined.
00:28:33
We are in the process of reapplying for our weatherization
00:28:38
to be the weatherization provider for this area through the Department of Housing and Community Development and I will be coming probably to Mr. Jones around the first of the year to get a letter of support from you folks and I hope that you will provide us with that.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:28:54
How can people reach you?
SPEAKER_10
00:28:56
We are, well like I said, through social services.
00:29:01
We also get the fuel assistance list and we actually contact people that way.
00:29:06
Do you have a phone number?
00:29:08
Yes, we have a phone number.
00:29:10
We actually have an 800 number and it's 877-816-0218 or 293-3777.
00:29:21
Thank you.
00:29:22
Thank you.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:29:25
The room neck has to be neater.
SPEAKER_01
00:29:35
Hi, I'm Brenda Castaneda.
00:29:36
I'm an attorney at Legal Aid Justice Center at 1000 Preston Avenue.
00:29:40
We represent the Public Housing Association of Residents and also various individual residents of public housing.
00:29:48
I'm just here tonight to talk a little bit about the RAD redevelopment issues that have come up.
00:29:54
Legal Aid Justice Center is very concerned about preserving the permanent affordability of housing in this community.
00:30:00
and so we were surprised and concerned when the issue of the RAD funding came up.
00:30:07
We have a couple of issues that we were concerned about with that.
00:30:12
One is that the Redevelopment Housing Authority showed a commitment to resident participation and did pass the Resident Bill of Rights a few years ago that to ensure in part meaningful tenant participation in any redevelopment process that went forward.
00:30:29
And with the RAD funding, there's only been one meeting with residents so far regarding that.
00:30:35
There really hasn't been sort of a full discussion of what that would mean.
00:30:39
And there is a couple really important changes that happen with RAD funding.
00:30:43
One is that
00:30:44
The Public Housing Authority would not actually no longer be under the public housing regulations with HUD.
00:30:49
It would not be public housing.
00:30:50
It would be a different kind of subsidized housing.
00:30:53
Another concern that we had is that there is a sunset period.
00:30:56
There's a 15 or 20 year period that the
00:31:01
Subsidy is guaranteed and then it's able to be renewed but we don't know what would happen in 15 or 20 years or if the landscape would change, if HUD would change and so it's turning what's essentially a perpetual subsidy into a subsidy with a sunset.
00:31:18
And with regard to the current RAD funding,
00:31:23
Part of the attractive quality of it was that it would lock in the 2012 subsidy levels and HUD does not fully subsidize public housing.
00:31:33
It looks at the housing and says, well, here's what you need for your operating subsidy and then we're giving you like 82% of that.
00:31:40
And it has gone down over the years.
00:31:42
It goes up and down.
00:31:44
But the RAD program as it's currently proposed by HUD is for the first 60,000 units and it
00:31:52
CRHA is a little bit late in the game and probably wouldn't get in under that and so probably would not benefit from the from the freezing and funding at 2012 levels at this point.
00:32:03
And lastly, once the applications put in there's a mandatory timeline and it's fast.
00:32:09
It's very fast.
00:32:10
Within six months the CRHA would have to have a detailed funding plan and in fact within 30 days of being approved for it would have to have secured funding with a lender who would be able to do that.
00:32:24
So we hope that as redevelopment goes forward we all do hope that it does happen but we hope that it does include sufficient tenant participation and that the city looks to preserve the affordability of public housing long term.
00:32:42
Thank you.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:32:44
John Hayden
SPEAKER_16
00:32:52
John Hayden, Westwood Road.
00:32:55
I've been coming to you complaining about the violent crime and advocating for suspect identifications to be released when crimes occur only to be ridiculed by you and ignored by the media.
00:33:09
In February I told you of 24 reported violent crimes which included shootings, assault and robbery, stabbings, home invasions, larceny,
00:33:21
Gun charges and other violent felonies, and I think it's safe to say that that number has more than doubled.
00:33:28
Four more just in the last month.
00:33:31
So the estimated 50 violent crimes so far this year for this small town, we have maybe heard suspect descriptions of a half a dozen.
00:33:43
What is particularly disturbing is we hear repeatedly of these three suspects who possibly have committed several of these crimes, but we hear no descriptions.
00:33:55
Now comes the city council and using this Kroger stunt, where no one was in danger, wants to erode law-abiding citizens' Second Amendment rights to protect themselves against the violent predators
00:34:10
who you refuse to allow to be identified for politically correct reasons.
00:34:16
Thomas Jefferson once said, the beauty of the Second Amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it.
00:34:24
You could cut down on the crime if you had a thousand pairs of eyes on the lookout for suspects instead of allowing them to remain anonymous.
00:34:36
This policy emboldens criminals if they know no one will know who they are.
00:34:41
We have now seen far too many instances of stores being repeatedly robbed, homes invaded, students robbed at gunpoint to ignore the fact that you have a violent crime problem in this town.
00:34:56
You need to concentrate on public safety not drones.
00:35:01
You need to protect the citizens, not enable the pot smokers.
00:35:06
You need to hire more cops, not mall coordinators.
00:35:11
I know some of you think it's clever to ignore me and not address my questions and concerns as you have in the last year.
00:35:19
It looks like you're more interested in protecting the rights of criminals than you are of law-abiding citizens.
00:35:27
If not, then please answer this question with a simple yes or no first, then a comment.
00:35:34
Are you against broadcasting suspect descriptions by the media when a crime is reported and why?
00:35:42
Or will you once again just ignore me?
00:35:46
Thank you.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:35:48
Lewis Schultz.
SPEAKER_00
00:35:58
My name is Lewis Schultz and I live at 1809 East Market Street.
00:36:02
I'll start with some background for anyone who has not been following along so far.
00:36:06
I've spoken to Council three times since October 3rd to say that I have evidence that City Manager Maurice Jones, Director of Public Works Judith Mueller, and Utilities Director Lauren Hildebrand have violated Charlottesville Code and the Code of Virginia, and in doing so have violated federal civil rights statutes.
00:36:22
I also wrote to Mayor Huja and asked for an investigation to receive sworn testimony from me and others.
00:36:27
Council is empowered to hold such hearings under its charter.
00:36:30
So far I've had very few words in response.
00:36:33
Although the mayor's duties do not include making official statements on behalf of council, he wrote to say that he declined my request and purported to speak for all of council in doing so.
00:36:42
No further explanation was given.
00:36:44
At the last council meeting on November 4th,
00:36:46
Kristin Szakos responded to my comments very briefly to say that the courts were the appropriate venue for the issues I've raised.
00:36:52
It's a shocking thing to hear a counselor say that civil rights violations only matter to counsel when brought forth by citizens who are wealthy enough or otherwise able to hire legal representation.
00:37:01
Sadly, given the city's lengthy history of civil rights abuses, it isn't an entirely unprecedented attitude.
00:37:07
Yes, it may be a matter for the courts, but it is also a matter for counsel to respond to when high ranking city officials are accused of serious crimes.
00:37:14
Dede Smith also spoke up to say that she had looked into the matter and that the city had acted appropriately.
00:37:20
Her comments made it clear that she didn't understand the issues that I've raised.
00:37:23
She certainly hasn't seen my evidence, and given those facts, it's unlikely that she's looked into them.
00:37:29
The documents that I provided on October 3rd explicitly address the actual issue, which is seizure of private property for public use without due process.
00:37:37
That is, anyone who has taken a high school government class ought to know is forbidden by the Virginia Constitution as well as the US Bill of Rights.
00:37:43
It is also forbidden by the city charter.
00:37:45
If what I wrote or have said has been in any way unclear, I've offered contact information and encouraged questions.
00:37:51
None have been asked by any members of council.
00:37:54
If, as suggested by comments made by the mayor as well as Councillors Szakos and Smith, council continues to ignore my allegations and to refuse to hear sworn testimony based on advice from the city attorney,
00:38:03
There's been a serious breach of ethics on Mr. Brown's part, which should have been obvious to counsel.
00:38:08
That itself is a very troubling matter.
00:38:10
The Virginia Bar Association's rules regarding conflict of interest is that a lawyer shall not represent a client if the representation involves a concurrent conflict of interest.
00:38:19
That is, if there's a significant risk that the representation of one or more clients
00:38:23
will be materially limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to another client.
00:38:27
The city attorney is hired and fired by the city manager and cannot fulfill his obligations to that manager and simultaneously advise counsel on its role in hearing testimony against the city manager.
00:38:36
It is the business of the council to hear what I've said and it is its duty to do as I have repeatedly asked.
00:38:41
That is to honor my request for a hearing and to am I allegations of serious wrongdoing, follow with a full report to the public, take appropriate disciplinary action where necessary and train all city employees to respect citizen civil rights and finally abandon all city claims of rights to private properties that cannot be fully supported by the public record.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:39:01
Thank you.
00:39:02
Brandon Collins.
SPEAKER_07
00:39:07
Good evening.
00:39:08
I'm Brandon Collins, 418 Fairway Avenue.
00:39:10
I've lived in Charlottesville my entire life.
00:39:12
I have three children who've lived here their entire lives as well.
00:39:15
And I'm here to speak basically on behalf of FAR, Public Housing Association of Residents, probably one of the boldest and most needed groups in Charlottesville, and perhaps the only group of people sticking up for themselves, and that is the residents of public housing speaking for themselves and on their own behalf.
00:39:38
I'm here to talk about RAD once again, Rental Assistance Demonstration.
00:39:42
It's a HUD program that seeks to convert public housing into project-based housing.
00:39:49
And as Ms. Castaneda mentioned, it ends all public housing regulations and converts to a new system of regulations.
00:39:57
A lot of those changes are alarming.
00:40:02
and we continue to learn more and more about that.
00:40:05
But I did want to thank you all for your initial engagement on this issue.
00:40:10
A number of you, including the city manager, were at a recent panel discussion, two panel discussions with Greg Byrne, the senior project manager for RAD with HUD.
00:40:21
His appearance here in Charlottesville suggests that
00:40:26
HUD is very interested in what Charlottesville has going on and they're paying attention and I think that's due to the credit of FAR and residents of public housing who have gotten out, learned what they can on their own and have expressed their concerns and have expressed a desire to learn a whole lot more.
00:40:45
That panel I think was informative.
00:40:47
We learned about some of our original concerns may not be as awful as we thought but we also learned about a whole new batch of just as equally awful things.
00:40:56
And what all this does is make us realize we need to take a step back and make some decisions.
00:41:03
HUD explained to us how the program works on the national scale, what the potential for use might be in Charlottesville, but now the decisions need to be made
00:41:12
locally and those decisions need to be made by residents of public housing and with the help of the city of Charlottesville who has a great stake in not just redevelopment but the future of affordable housing in this city and I hope you all will continue to stay engaged.
00:41:27
The issue with RAD is that it does create a very short timeline.
00:41:32
and between now and December 31st, a number of major decisions about redevelopment will need to be made.
00:41:40
There's not nearly enough time for those decisions to be made that includes a great deal of resident participation, participation by the city and the housing authority getting its ducks in a row.
00:41:52
Mr. Burns from HUD openly stated that he did not think the housing authority was ready to pursue RAD
00:41:59
He wants housing authorities to apply, but if we apply now, we're really putting the cart before the horse and letting the funding option, one option, guide substantial decisions about redevelopment.
00:42:11
And we think that's a bad way to go, we think that's hasty, that's how terrible mistakes get made, and we hope that you will help us keep this from happening in 2013.
00:42:19
Thank you.
SPEAKER_17
00:42:38
I'm Joe Drago.
00:42:39
I live up in Carsbrook off of Rio Road.
00:42:42
So many issues, so little time, my goodness.
00:42:44
I came here with a few things in mind, but I hear these folks speak, and golly, hardly know where to begin.
00:42:50
You and I, a few minutes ago, were talking about the resentments that can build up if things aren't talked through.
00:42:56
This gentleman who just stood up and spoke here is a perfect example of that.
00:43:01
And the problem we have today is that you folks don't answer our questions.
00:43:05
I know it's set up that way.
00:43:07
County Board of Supervisors, it's even worse.
00:43:09
But citizens come down here and ask you real questions who are practicing advanced citizenship, which is what this is.
00:43:16
We're not sitting on our couches watching American Idol and football.
00:43:19
We're down here talking to you all, and you won't answer our questions.
00:43:23
Why is that?
00:43:24
Why do we have to operate from this political paradigm?
00:43:27
It's injurious to us all, to you folks and to the citizens that came down here.
00:43:31
This guy was well-spoken, and he deserves to be heard.
00:43:34
He deserves to have someone sit down and talk to him.
00:43:37
Maybe what he's saying, and I don't know, I don't know for sure, but maybe what he's saying has merit and that there should be an investigation.
00:43:42
I don't know.
00:43:43
But neither do you folks, I don't think.
00:43:45
So why does it have to be this way?
00:43:48
Why are we stuck in this old paradigm that doesn't work anymore?
00:43:51
And it's even worse at the County Board of Supervisors.
00:43:54
Okay, I read tonight that you folks are going to vote on the possible gun restrictions.
00:44:04
I looked up an article I already read from the FBI, our veritable FBI, and they say that when you take away the gun deaths from gangbangers in Chicago and Baltimore and Richmond,
00:44:17
that this instrument here is the leading instrument of homicide in America, a baseball bat, blunt instruments, in particular a baseball bat.
00:44:25
This is the most lethal instrument for killing someone in America.
00:44:29
This right here in my hand.
00:44:31
Are you planning on also banning baseball bats from Charlottesville?
00:44:35
It starts to get a little absurd after a while.
00:44:38
It also turns out that Harvard just did a study about a year ago, less than a year ago, and they concluded
00:44:45
and there were two of them, Kates and Mauser, a criminologist and a constitutional lawyer.
00:44:52
They concluded that states that allowed firearm open carry saw a huge drop in violent homicides and handgun deaths.
00:45:03
The fact that people are armed dissuades the bad guys from doing bad things.
00:45:07
States that don't allow people to open carry, that restrict firearms, in fact have a much higher homicide
00:45:13
percentage.
00:45:15
Now these are not my opinions.
00:45:17
These are facts from Kates and Mauser, this Harvard study, these FBI statistics.
00:45:23
Clearly, such a divisive issue, clearly guns, I know it sounds cliche, but they're not the problem.
00:45:34
It's the idiots wielding the guns.
00:45:36
Also, Kristin, you correctly mentioned in the newspaper about your concern for violence.
00:45:43
and I stand with you solidly, but there's all kinds of violence being perpetrated in this community that has nothing to do with handguns.
00:45:51
Case in point, tens of millions of our children are being forced.
00:45:55
Is the time up?
00:45:56
Yes.
00:45:56
Okay.
00:45:58
Shucks.
00:45:59
Thank you for coming.
00:46:00
Thank you.
00:46:01
I hope you folks reconsider the format here.
00:46:04
There's a better way to do this.
00:46:06
I'd appreciate it.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:46:07
Thank you.
00:46:07
Todd Niemeyer.
SPEAKER_08
00:46:20
Good evening.
00:46:22
Thanks for the opportunity to speak.
00:46:23
My name is Todd Niemeyer.
00:46:24
I live at 106 Chisholm Place in the city.
00:46:26
I'm here tonight representing the Rivanna Trails Foundation and first of all I want to open with just thank you for supporting
00:46:34
the development of urban trails.
00:46:35
We've had a wonderful partnership with City Parks and Rec Department.
00:46:38
I see that Chris is here.
00:46:39
He's been a super supporter of what we do as Rivanna Trails Foundation in terms of developing an urban trail system around the city and also lately we've been partnering a lot to pass a lot of the easements and ownership of the property to the city, the property that currently the
00:46:58
excuse me, the Rivanna Trail passes over.
00:47:00
So it's been a really wonderful partnership and the trail system and network keeps expanding.
00:47:05
We're especially excited about the Meadow Creek Valley plan that you all are implementing currently.
00:47:09
And to make that park, that linear park, which is going to be an amazing connector, basically from the Meadow Creek Parkway, basically where the railroad tracks cross, all the way to 29, where Bodo's is, it's going to be an amazing corridor for everyone.
00:47:27
because there's a planned multi-use path through there.
00:47:30
But there are several improvements that need to take place along that corridor in order to make it more accessible and more passable.
00:47:37
And one of the ones I want to speak about this evening is the culverts that go underneath 250 and Hydraulic Road.
00:47:44
The Rivanna Trail currently passes through those culverts and goes on top of some concrete lentils, which is
00:47:51
Servable, but it's not the safest and most successful path and so I would like to advocate the potential construction of a raised walkway through both of those culverts.
00:48:02
That's something that the Parks and Rec Department also agrees with us on and I believe that Parks and Rec currently has a CIP request
00:48:11
for the Meadow Creek Valley plan, and hopefully some of that funding could go towards either the design and potentially construction of those walkways.
00:48:21
So, again, thanks for the support.
00:48:23
We're excited about the development of that corridor, and we think it could be a great service to the community, and we hope you'll consider the implementation of those walkways through the culverts.
00:48:32
Thanks.
00:48:34
Thank you.
SPEAKER_09
00:48:39
Brian Weimer, 712 Graves, and actually I want to say first, where's that camera?
00:48:45
You people watching television, thank you, because you could be watching American Idol or My Big Bad Gypsy Wedding or something else, but you decided to watch Charlottesville Civics and all you people here too.
00:48:55
And congratulations on another term for sticking with it.
00:48:59
I know it's sort of a pain sometimes.
00:49:02
And I could talk about all sorts of things tonight.
00:49:04
One of them, I mean there's a big sign up on Avon saying come to the Belmont Bridge thing Thursday.
00:49:11
Thank you so much for letting people know about it.
00:49:13
However, nothing's going to be told at that meeting.
00:49:16
There's nothing new there.
00:49:17
You're going to have a bunch of disappointed people who are expecting great designs.
00:49:20
And all they're going to say is, MMM did nothing for a year.
00:49:24
They were told that the place designed a task force last week some new ideas.
00:49:29
I don't think they're going to sketch something up in a week.
00:49:31
And if they do, pity on you guys for accepting that as a substitute for a year's worth of work.
00:49:39
Somebody told me something the other week that kind of really shattered, and I think I might even owe you all an apology for even getting involved in this process.
00:49:51
Somebody asked me where I live.
00:49:53
I said I live in Belmont.
00:49:55
And they said, oh, you live on that side of the tracks.
00:49:58
I said, I live on what side of the tracks?
00:50:01
On the south side.
00:50:02
That's the poor side.
00:50:05
And I've heard from numerous people.
00:50:07
I keep on sharing this insight.
00:50:08
I think I'm the last person on every joke.
00:50:10
Just like, I finally get the punch line.
00:50:12
that Charlottesville is divided by railroad, south side and north side.
00:50:17
Look at it.
00:50:17
UVA on one side, Fifeville on another.
00:50:19
Look at how schools are funded.
00:50:21
All sorts of different things that all of a sudden this tracks across this city has become an impediment.
00:50:28
And I saw a movie at the film festival last week that you should all watch.
00:50:32
We're going to try to bring it here.
00:50:33
by the people who did the High Line Park in New York, but they also did Lincoln Center.
00:50:39
One of the bigger parts of that was that Lincoln Center, which was built at the same time as our bridge, was built not to connect the city, it was built to protect the arts from the city.
00:50:50
It was built on the same plot of land where West Side Story was shot.
00:50:53
They leveled it and they built walls and they said, screw off city, rich people come, go see your opera.
00:50:59
I think the ridge is the same thing.
00:51:01
This bridge was built to get people out of the city.
00:51:03
It was not built to help the city.
00:51:06
And if you stand on that bridge today and you look down, you look down on a demilitarized zone of emptiness and it has been that way for 50 years.
00:51:13
To perpetuate this bridge is to perpetuate that problem with the city.
00:51:17
You have an opportunity here to address so many things that are not just about concrete and steel or cars, that are about social injustices in this city that perpetuate to this day.
00:51:29
And this is an opportunity to make that gateway somehow connect two halves of a city that have been split apart for too long.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:51:38
Thanks.
Joy Johnson
00:51:55
Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Councilmen and Councilwomen.
00:52:01
My name is Joy Johnson and I reside in 802A Hardy Drive, 8 Creek.
00:52:07
I'm here tonight to speak on behalf of RAD but in a different twist because one of the things that Greg Burns said, which I worked with Greg Burns on the operating cost study,
00:52:22
many, many years ago.
00:52:23
And I had to remind him what residents were saying to him in that whole training, which was that multifamily home and public housing was apples and oranges because you have other things like elevators and all that kind of stuff and growth spurs in locality that could make it
00:52:50
very cumbersome.
00:52:52
So I had to keep reminding him of that and what resident participation is and what we make sure that we do about complying with 964 to make resident participation real.
00:53:06
And in saying that, he pretty much said, but this is not my meeting.
00:53:12
This is a housing authority meeting.
00:53:16
And then the other thing that he pretty much said was, this is a conversation for your board and your council.
00:53:22
This is a local problem.
00:53:24
I'm just here to say that HUD has this carrot, that if you would like to participate, here it is, and here's what I will lock you into.
00:53:34
If you want to come play ball with us, I'll lock you into 93%.
00:53:38
That's what your subsidy is.
00:53:42
But frankly,
00:53:43
This is a conversation that needs to happen locally.
00:53:46
So my conversation to all of the counselors who are here and Bob Fenwick who is sitting back there, when are you going to really start talking about affordable rental unit in the city of Charlottesville?
00:54:00
True.
00:54:00
50, 40, 30, 20, 10, and even the homelessness population situation.
00:54:10
I think we have to talk about that before we can
00:54:13
We'll move on to saying the stock of affordable rental units that is left in the city of Charlottesville, we're going to move it completely away from HUD into multifamily where you have to go to a bank and seek mortgage.
00:54:37
So the conversation has to change.
00:54:40
And so I want to know from the counselor, are you ready to do that?
00:54:46
Are you ready to do that?
00:54:48
Have you assessed what the needs of our affordable rental units are?
00:54:56
I mean, I just learned that there is a third shared housing growing up on the corner on the other side of
00:55:05
West Main Street.
00:55:06
So I'll just wait until the end.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:55:09
Thank you, ma'am.
00:55:11
I'm opening for one more person who would like to speak if you'd like to sign up.
00:55:15
Anybody else would like to speak?
00:55:18
Okay.
00:55:19
So we'll close this part of the meeting.
00:55:22
The comments of the city council members.
00:55:25
While you're waiting, I can make one comment.
00:55:29
Rose Williams talked about farmers' market on the current location.
COUNCIL RESPONSE
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
00:55:33
I just wanted you to know that council is considering request for proposal for development on the current site in the coming months.
Kristin Szakos
Vice Mayor, City Council
00:55:45
I'll jump in.
00:55:47
First of all, I'd just like to thank everybody for coming and speaking.
00:55:52
To Mr. Hayden, I must say that the... Are you still here?
00:55:58
There you are.
00:56:00
Sorry, when I have my glasses on top of my head, I can see my paper, but I can't see all the way out there.
00:56:05
You mentioned that you had been asking for suspect ID to be released, and I was not aware of that particular request, and I'm not sure that counsel is really the ones who can do that for you.
00:56:17
I think that you've asked for various things over time, and we have responded.
00:56:21
That was to me a new one, so I'm sorry that you feel that you haven't been heard, and if you had asked for that before, I'm sorry that I didn't hear it.
00:56:30
I also just, I was surprised to hear that quote from Thomas Jefferson about the Second Amendment, so when you were done, I looked it up, and it's actually not attributed to Thomas Jefferson.
00:56:40
It's something that somebody said he said, but he didn't, so just.
00:56:44
But to Mr. Schultz, I'll just confirm that indeed that the mayor did speak for me in doing this.
00:56:53
We have seen your materials.
00:56:54
You've given it to us repeated times.
00:56:55
I've read every bit of it.
00:56:57
I've talked to the city attorney.
00:56:59
The city attorney doesn't actually work for the city manager.
00:57:01
The city attorney works for the city council.
00:57:03
We hire the, I believe I'm right, we hire the city manager, we hire the clerk, and we hire the city attorney.
00:57:10
Everybody else works for the city manager, so there's not a conflict.
00:57:14
Well, things change over time, so I'm not sure what that is, but at this point, that's what it is.
00:57:20
I'll do rad last because several people spoke about that.
00:57:25
The gun restriction thing, in a way, it's not really even something that we need to talk about now because we're not asking to impose gun restrictions, we're asking for
00:57:37
the right to make local decisions about gun restrictions locally.
00:57:42
So if we pass this this evening, it doesn't say that we have imposed gun restrictions.
00:57:47
It says that we believe that as a locality, we should have the right to decide that for our own community.
00:57:53
And it may be, and I have read the Harvard Report or parts of it, a summary of it, about that gun regulations don't necessarily reduce
00:58:03
Murders, but they incredibly reduce suicides and accidents by gun.
00:58:09
And I think that as we, you know, when people say, well, if you outlaw guns, only criminals will have guns.
00:58:15
Well, that's sometimes not a bad thing because criminals have guns now anyway.
00:58:19
And what often leads to death is people who aren't criminals having guns, children shooting one another with guns in their homes.
00:58:26
people shooting themselves when they get depressed because they have a gun in their home.
00:58:30
So, you know, I don't want to discuss the whole gun control ups and downs here, but I think that that's, there are lots of reasons that some of us feel that that's something we want to discuss locally.
00:58:45
The Belmont Bridge, I was really interested to hear the, you know, I've heard about the tracks and Lincoln Center was interesting.
00:58:53
I will say that in the 50s when that bridge was built,
00:58:56
It wasn't so much north and south side of the tracks because of course Vinegar Hill was north of the tracks.
00:59:02
West Haven is north of the tracks.
00:59:04
The city did a pretty good job of wiping out a lot of that that was north of the tracks.
00:59:07
I'm not defending it, but at the time the bridge was built, we weren't quite so north-south driven.
00:59:13
As far as RAD goes, Joy asked us to say, you know, are you ready?
00:59:19
Personally, I'm not ready.
00:59:21
I think that this looks like a very interesting way to fund
00:59:25
public housing.
00:59:27
And it doesn't take it so much out of HUD, but it does certainly take it out of the idea of public housing and moves it into more of a Section 8.
00:59:34
I did go to one of the workshops.
00:59:36
I was concerned about the speed at which we need to come up with a very, or the housing authority would need to come up with a very detailed funding plan and plan for moving forward on redevelopment.
00:59:48
I don't see us close to that.
00:59:51
I don't, at this point, you know, we are sort of the other partner in this with the Housing Authority.
00:59:58
Things happening on public land in the city would have to have the City Council, whether we are doing the Housing Authority or not, would have to have our participation, so I'm preparing myself for that by reading a lot, but personally I do not feel ready for that.
Satyendra Huja
Mayor, City Council
01:00:14
Other comments for the members of the Council?
SPEAKER_11
01:00:18
First of all, I wanted to ask city staff to follow up with Ms. Williams and her concern about the Meade Avenue sidewalk.
01:00:27
That's very troubling for me to hear.
01:00:29
I'm sure for all of us to hear that you don't feel safe using that crosswalk.
01:00:34
And so if we can follow up.
01:00:35
And I see Amanda Ponce in the back there.
01:00:37
I'm sure she will be tasked with following up on that.
01:00:40
But secondly, speaking of pedestrian issues,
01:00:47
I'm intrigued by Mr. Niemeyer's request for raised sidewalks through the culverts.
01:00:52
I've hiked that trail a number of times.
01:00:54
I wouldn't necessarily put it at the top of our CIP list because I think people are still going to use those sidewalks, but it certainly are those crosswalks, but it certainly is going to make it a better experience and a safer experience.
01:01:06
If it's not a huge cost, I'd like to see us consider that request.
01:01:11
Ms. Robertson, who unfortunately had to leave,
01:01:15
I wanted to thank her for mentioning the vigil for Dashad.
01:01:18
She said what day it was but didn't give the details and I looked it up.
01:01:21
It's this Wednesday, it's the one year anniversary or around the one year anniversary of Dashad's disappearance.
01:01:26
This Wednesday, 5.30 p.m. at Lee Park, there will be a vigil for Dashad.
01:01:33
I fully agree with Ms. Szakos on RAD.
01:01:37
There are intriguing aspects of RAD that I think have merit but I think overall
01:01:44
It's something that's going to be a detriment and certainly is something that would require a lot more citizen input than we've had to date.
01:01:53
But the question for me, which I hope is the question for all of us, is if not RAD, what?
01:01:57
What are the tools that are available to us?
01:02:01
and I suspect this is part of Mr. Jones' evaluation of the housing authorities, looking to the future.
01:02:06
What are the tools out there that are available to us to improve the quality of housing and improve the quality of life in our public housing neighborhoods?
01:02:15
And then I just wanted to comment, Mr. Hayden, you've expressed a number of times your belief that black people are responsible for majority of crimes in this community, in this country.
01:02:30
The statistics simply don't back that up.
01:02:34
and I've read those statistics out loud and we can certainly cite anecdotal circumstances where people of various races have been involved in perpetuating crime.
01:02:47
but the reality is that it's us, it's white people that perpetuate the majority of crime in this country.
01:02:54
That's not what I said.
01:02:55
And you have said that.
01:02:56
No, that's not what I said.
01:03:01
And I do want to also counter you on this implication that the city has a policy of not revealing the race of criminal suspects.
01:03:10
It's simply not true.
01:03:15
We know exactly what you meant Mr. Hayden and so the city does not have a policy of withholding identifying characteristics of suspects including race when it could be valuable in finding perpetrators of crime and I just confirmed that again with Mr. Jones.
01:03:37
Now it may not be that the media chooses to report it in each and every case
01:03:43
but we routinely, routinely provide, publicly provide identifying characteristics including race of people who are suspected of committing crimes in this community and you can stand up here and deny that it's true but it is a fact and so you're entitled to your opinion but you're not entitled to facts.
01:04:05
Thank you.
SPEAKER_19
01:04:07
This is from a press release that was released over the weekend on two early morning robberies that occurred.
01:04:15
It says the student was walking north on 15th Street when confronted by an African-American male demanding the purse.
01:04:22
Later on in the press release it says the suspects were described