Central Virginia
Albemarle County
Electoral Board Meeting 12/11/2025
Auto-scroll
Electoral Board Meeting
12/11/2025
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:00:03
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen.
00:00:04
This is the December regularly scheduled meeting of the electoral board.
00:00:09
It's 9.30.
00:00:10
All three members are here.
00:00:12
And I'd like to welcome also our registrar, Andrew Ruge.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:00:17
And elections manager.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:00:19
And the election manager.
00:00:25
I call for a motion to approve the final agenda as it stands.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:00:32
Any objections?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:00:35
All in favor?
00:00:35
Yes.
00:00:38
We have asked the registrar to give a brief announcement.
00:00:42
I know she is terribly busy.
00:00:44
It's the budget season.
00:00:46
And she is up to her eyeballs in creating a budget.
00:00:51
So whatever time you can allow us, we appreciate it.
00:00:54
Okay, I actually want to start with the budget.
00:00:56
Next.
00:00:57
I see down here about the accounting.
00:00:58
I really need to pull it up to the top.
00:01:01
Whatever you need to say, please do, and don't need to go back to your busy schedule.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:01:07
I can't give an accounting just now.
00:01:10
I really don't want to until the budget has been approved.
00:01:13
So the numbers are still moving around.
00:01:15
I just want to say a little bit about that.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:01:17
The accounting, though, is to look at how we are doing this year against our current budget.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:01:23
I understand that that's what that was.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:01:25
Yeah.
00:01:26
Where are we?
00:01:27
What have we spent?
00:01:28
What have we spent since the last time we did this?
00:01:30
Which obviously there wasn't one.
00:01:32
But looking at how are we tracking against our current budget.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:01:36
OK, so I can have that next time.
00:01:37
I did not know that that's what that meant.
00:01:40
OK, gotcha.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:01:41
So then I will tell you that this board has never had accounting from registrar before.
00:01:47
OK, gotcha.
00:01:48
So I'm sure they will be very interested here.
00:01:52
So about this.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:01:54
So a couple of things I do want to say about the ongoing process now is our department, we're working under the assumption that there will be a special election in April.
00:02:09
And so we've geared pretty much everything for that.
00:02:13
So how that affects the budget is we spoke with him
00:02:19
the budget manager that I'm working with.
00:02:21
And so we've added a line item, because I asked how should that be counted in?
00:02:26
And it's going to be a separate line item for just the special election loan.
00:02:31
And so it can be pulled out or added back in as necessary.
00:02:36
So from there, I want to talk about
00:02:41
Yesterday, we had a meeting face-to-face with the space management experts and the county.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:02:51
They were from facilities management?
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:02:53
Yes, absolutely.
00:02:55
And the reason for that is our space is extremely tight.
00:02:59
And when I fill the full-time positions that I have open, we don't have enough workspaces for people to sit.
00:03:06
We actually don't have enough workspaces for people to sit now.
00:03:09
Every day, there's at least two employees that come in and they have to ask, where can I sit today?
00:03:14
Who's not gonna be here?
00:03:16
And so they quickly, they were very responsive to our request, to my request to have them come and meet with me.
00:03:27
And so we walk through and
00:03:30
We're talking now about how to reconfigure our space in some pretty creative ways.
00:03:35
So not only does everybody have a workspace, but also that we're going to change a little bit of security measures with our ballots, move things around a little bit so that we believe things are a bit more, the ballots are isolated from, the ballots and things related to the ballots are
00:03:53
completely isolated from other things.
00:03:55
So we feel pretty good about that.
00:03:57
We even went to the warehouse and looked in there.
00:04:01
They were impressed about everything that was going on in there.
00:04:06
It was really good.
00:04:07
So I've seen it before when it wasn't going to look this way.
00:04:12
So that's in progress.
00:04:13
How soon will some of those things happen?
00:04:16
Maybe as soon as next week.
00:04:18
We all know the holidays are coming.
00:04:19
It's not going to be a complete overhaul next week, but with us in election mode, we are tearing off the piece that's most important that we really need done for the election and planning to get that done before the election, before we hit the hottest part of it.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:04:38
You see Mr. Strather seemed to be very receptive to your priorities and you outlined to him what you needed done as soon as possible and what could wait on the file.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:04:52
Is the outcome going to be expanded space or just reconfigured space?
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:05:01
Reconfigured space because the election calendar is really tight.
00:05:06
I don't want to
00:05:07
do any kind of construction or tearing down or building up until we actually know what's happening with the special election.
00:05:14
And then there are other things that are happening besides election preparation that are happening just besides the space.
00:05:22
So we have a lot of record keeping to change around and update.
00:05:29
We have a lot of moving around of records so that things are in the same place and more accessible to everyone.
00:05:34
So all of that's gonna happen at the same time.
00:05:37
So we don't want to do any construction work.
00:05:39
We're just going to reconfigure the space that we have.
00:05:44
So the last thing, actually, one other thing I want to mention is two more things for you.
00:05:52
The whole of the election official software contract that we have has expired.
00:06:01
So we think, I think that that software was too expensive for what we were paying for.
00:06:10
And so, and actually the way we were using it, I think it was too expensive.
00:06:14
It was too big.
00:06:17
So I'm looking at bids from three different, from three companies, including that one.
00:06:24
We have one called Poll Worker Hub that we're going to look at.
00:06:32
The second one is called Soch, S-O-C-H, it's actually Integra, Soch.
00:06:40
And then the third one is Tenex, that's the outgoing company.
00:06:43
So I've been able to get hold of two of the three and I've asked them if they can do demos for us.
00:06:49
starting the second week of January.
00:06:51
The answer is yes.
00:06:52
We'd like to do them all within the same week and make a very quick decision for what we'd like to do.
00:06:57
We might end up staying with the current company, which is 10X, but we're not sure.
00:07:01
So because it's over, probably going to be over a certain amount of money, we need to have three bids.
00:07:07
So we're going to start with 10X.
00:07:10
And so that's in January.
00:07:13
I looked at, I was noticing registrations.
00:07:18
Last topic for me.
00:07:20
When the registration period ended for the last election, we created a file in a couple different places, actually two files, and it was called, we just labeled it after election.
00:07:30
So we've taken a look at those files now.
00:07:34
And within those files, of course, are quite a number of registrations.
00:07:38
So I said, well, let me just take a look at what the Department of Elections website has for registrations and then add that to the number that we have that are handwritten and just see how many new registrations, just get a ballpark of that.
00:07:53
So between September and September, October, November,
00:08:00
The online registrations increased by 1,066.
00:08:04
This is according to the numbers on the MLX website.
00:08:11
And then the handwritten hard copy registrations that we received since registration period ended is 486.
00:08:20
So that's a ballpark number of new registrations that we have.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:08:26
Who do the SDRs fall into?
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:08:29
They fall in the ones that are on the elect number because they were actually registered.
00:08:35
So I'll be interested to see what that number is in December.
00:08:39
So I'm not sure when they, how they update that portion, but obviously you should see what that number is and I'll report that as well.
00:08:45
And that'll give us a good look for the heart of the election season, how many new registrations that we have.
00:08:51
And I will say that some of them it's, I shouldn't say new, well, there's new and then there's active.
00:08:56
Some of the, the active number went up, but some of them I realized were people that were inactive, becoming active.
00:09:02
So they're not new registrations.
00:09:04
They just moved over into the active category.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:09:08
They turned up and voted.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:09:09
Yeah, they did.
00:09:10
They certainly did.
00:09:11
So as far as our staff goes, that's what we're busy doing.
00:09:14
We are registering and registering.
00:09:18
We have a separate number.
00:09:20
It's about 483 of pre-registrations.
00:09:26
So we're completing that number as well.
00:09:28
Now that's 16 and 17 year old.
00:09:30
Correct.
00:09:32
And the requirement is they need to be 18
00:09:37
by the general election in 2026.
00:09:40
And so we're not sure how many, I'm not sure exactly how many in that hopper are going to be there, but that's the number in the hopper.
00:09:45
It may only end up being 300 because actually some of them are younger than that.
00:09:49
They actually pre-registered, but they're.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:09:53
If they are going to be 18 by November, then they can vote in the primary, but that wouldn't allow them to vote in a special election that is not related to the November election.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:10:04
That's my understanding.
00:10:07
Since you mentioned the primary, I'm sorry, the special election again, if we do have that, I'm going to use that as an opportunity for voter outreach.
00:10:17
because I've found that over the years a lot of people you know the if it's an amendment or resolution whatever that is it's it can be really confusing to people so we're going to find a way to reach out to our entire electorate you know maybe with a postcard or something like that to tell them this is happening to explain it a little bit maybe even include a QR code to point them to to more information about that and just
00:10:46
Last thing I want to mention, it goes into the, I'm sorry, any questions about that so far?
00:10:54
Last thing I want to mention, it dovetails into the upcoming conversation about the reorganization of 202.
00:11:02
So I know that the board is looking at the logistical part and some other things.
00:11:08
I know that Jim had
00:11:09
Responded about some outreach that he did in writing.
00:11:13
And so I talked to a few other people, and this is not my idea.
00:11:17
This is not a new idea, but I think it's a good one.
00:11:21
For the same day registrations and even the provisionals, we found that as we were going through them,
00:11:26
that some of the required information was just skipped it was just missed and because that's that's missing that's material something that's required those registrations those ballots don't count and so we're gonna I think it's a good idea for us to take a look at this template
00:11:45
believe me this is a very rudimentary flood Flintstone would be happy with this but it's not like what it actually looks like but I wanted to just to show you what we'll be showing on a same day registration so with a template that you just overlay so so what here's the scenario so somebody is the same day registrant they fill this out then the election officials have a template and they overlay the template on the filled out application
00:12:11
and you want to make sure that all the places are showing having the right information in them so you won't miss it.
00:12:18
So this might be nice information to have, but we want to make sure that the required information is there.
00:12:24
So it's just going to it's just going to be a simple overlay on the same day registration forms and also the provisional the provisionals so that we help voters and also we help our election officials make sure that help them do their work.
00:12:41
So this comes from a different group.
00:12:42
I'm probably going to get it from Fairfax.
00:12:44
I know that they have it.
00:12:45
I know other groups have it, but I know Fairfax does.
SPEAKER_08
00:12:48
Is there one particular piece of information that was missing?
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:12:51
Mark just more than others?
00:12:54
Yeah.
00:12:55
I think from what I saw, there were two.
00:12:58
There wasn't one particular one.
00:13:00
There were two main ones.
00:13:01
One was the citizen question.
00:13:03
Are you a citizen?
00:13:05
Yes, are you a citizen?
00:13:06
And then the other one was,
00:13:08
put down that they were born in 2025.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:13:10
Yeah, we had a couple of folks indicated they were felons.
00:13:16
But they weren't.
00:13:17
But they weren't.
00:13:20
Read the question wrong, I'm sure.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:13:22
But those questions have to be answered.
00:13:25
They have to be answered if they're answered, actually.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:13:30
The templates that have been used in other places, and I think Fairfax, as you said, was probably the first place that did it because they've got so many.
00:13:38
have worked very well.
00:13:39
I think that's a great idea.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:13:42
And if we get them, that'll guarantee a life changes the form.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:13:45
All right, any other questions from me?
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:13:50
I have one totally off the set that people keep forgetting to ask.
00:13:57
Have you been able to pay our BBA membership fee that's normally handled by the office?
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:14:03
Not yet, but Bucky gave me the information for that.
00:14:06
And now, is there something that you need to fill out before I pay it?
00:14:09
Or just, because that part I need, what do I need from you all?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:14:14
You need to have the names of the three members for next year, because Viva asks that you pay it in advance.
00:14:20
Okay, gotcha.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:14:21
And that's fine.
00:14:22
The nominations have to have gone through, yeah.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:14:24
So you can't send in the money until you know for whom you're paying it.
00:14:29
Okay, gotcha.
00:14:29
All right, so I will ask.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:14:31
anything else questions great to see everybody thank you for your diligent work and in the budget calls and looms and we have to have money one thing I do want to mention I'm sorry last thing
00:14:56
One of our employees, her name was Brooklyn Eubanks.
00:15:00
She, her last day is...
00:15:02
And she's been with us for about four years.
00:15:05
She is awesome.
00:15:07
She's the youngest member on staff.
00:15:10
But I call her a pro.
00:15:11
You just would not know that she was as young as she is to know as much.
00:15:18
So I just wanted to say on record how much I appreciate her.
00:15:22
And I've only been here not even three months yet.
00:15:25
She's made a huge impression.
00:15:27
I just wanted to make sure that people just really, we're going to really miss her and I just wanted to know how much I really appreciate what she did.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:15:35
And she's someone who works late.
00:15:38
Oh yes.
00:15:39
She doesn't leave at five o'clock.
00:15:40
Yes.
00:15:41
So it's really good for the office, particularly in election season.
00:15:44
Absolutely.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:15:45
Stuff is happening.
00:15:46
I see her again.
00:15:47
Yes, absolutely.
00:15:48
And so and she's moving to New York.
00:15:50
And as you said, Brooklyn is going to Brooklyn.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:15:53
She's going to live.
00:15:55
So a budgeting thought, it would seem like the expense profile for the primary
00:16:01
and a theoretical special election would be almost the same.
00:16:05
Similar staffing requirements, all the fixed costs would be more or less the same, which may help the process of allocating those two budgets.
00:16:14
Once you've got one done, you've more or less got the other one done.
Jonell McFadden
Director of Elections and General Registrar
00:16:17
Yes, it was pretty hard to
00:16:19
A question too hard.
00:16:20
It was intricate to break out the things that are not as clear.
00:16:24
The biggest moving cost is the part-time hours and the full-time hours.
00:16:34
Those are the two biggest things that are hard to get.
00:16:39
Well, thank you.
00:16:40
I appreciate it.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:16:41
Thank you, ma'am.
00:16:46
We are now open for public comment.
00:16:49
This board has a long tradition of having open public comment at the beginning of every meeting to identify yourself by your name and if you're an affiliate with any other organization whom you're representing to try to keep your comments to three minutes.
00:17:08
We also, which I want to compliment Albemarle County's electoral board for years,
00:17:15
We enjoy having an interactive reaction and action with public.
00:17:22
There are some boards that are categorically opposed to public speaking or hearing their questions or answering their questions.
00:17:33
We're not that way.
00:17:34
We enjoy knowing what the public and offices of election and people who come have to say in their comments.
00:17:42
So we also engage in public comment during the meeting.
00:17:47
We talk about some topic.
00:17:51
We'll ask if there's a question.
00:17:52
Or if you will please raise your hand and wait until you're recognized so that we don't talk all over each other.
00:17:59
Okay, anyone have a comment or question from the public?
00:18:07
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_08
00:18:09
OK, 202.
00:18:10
I'm Nancy.
00:18:12
Usually Michael's been the chief, and to let you know for, I don't know, 10 years or something, so he couldn't.
00:18:19
So I was asked to.
00:18:25
So from henceforth, we're always going to use the whole room, and I don't think.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:18:29
Nancy, can we ask you to hold your comments so we get to, we have a whole section.
00:18:36
on University.
00:18:37
Any other questions, comments?
00:18:44
Anybody online?
00:18:47
Nobody's got a question online.
00:18:48
Okay.
00:18:50
Well, minutes, Jim.
00:18:53
Do you have approval of minutes to present?
00:19:06
Thank you.
00:19:07
Old business.
00:19:09
Here we go.
00:19:10
New organization of precinct number 202.
00:19:16
and this is the university precinct.
00:19:18
It previously was at university hall until university hall was raised.
00:19:24
And then there was a, just for a little history, there was a group from the university from fire rescue and safety and from the electoral board that got together to look for a different place because clearly when the building's torn down, you can't have a polling place.
00:19:44
and the consensus opinion from all of those gathered, they looked at several different places and eliminated them for an assortment of reasons, came up with Slaughter Recreation Center.
00:20:03
There had been several attempts to explain to the university
00:20:13
All in place needs, such as time for cages to be delivered, time for office selection to come in on Monday if they choose to set up all in place, extraction of cages on the day after, and then it's an all day
00:20:32
It's an all-day process.
00:20:33
The officers of election have to be there early in the morning, five.
00:20:37
Understand that your officers were there at 4.30 this year for reasons we'll explain.
00:20:43
And despite at least two members of this board, and Jim has had conversations.
00:20:54
I've had a face-to-face conversation with the facilities manager for Slaughter-Wreck.
00:21:03
and yet they don't seem to understand and I find this troubling that the university, despite being told the time necessary to have an election, seem to think that they're special and they don't have to comply.
00:21:31
So when this board got an email from the director of facilities manager, with whom I have had a conversation, with whom Jim has had a conversation, with whom the previous chief has had conversations, sends us an email that says, if we let you have Monday afternoon, it will quote, and I'm quoting, will inconvenience 100 students because they won't be able to have their dance class
00:22:02
and you should also, I'm still quoting, you should also remember that it's an inconvenience to the students on election day that they can't use the facility for their dance class.
00:22:18
I was very glad that I was alone in a room.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:22:21
I'll fix that quote a little bit because they didn't refer to election day, they referred to your community event.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:22:30
Yes, yes, thank you, Jim.
00:22:32
Election Day is a community event.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:22:35
And we're, of course, grievously interfering with dance class.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:22:38
Yes.
00:22:40
As someone who took 23 years of ballet lessons, I understand dance classes.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:22:47
Well, you're always pliéing.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:22:49
That's right, standing up.
00:22:52
Exactly.
00:22:53
But I don't think dance classes are more important.
00:22:57
And I don't think they should stand in the way of an election.
00:23:01
The board has agreed.
00:23:02
I have written a letter and have had that letter edited by someone and have honed it down to ask for a personal meeting with the dean of students, the head of facilities management, and anyone else the university wants to send so that we can end a civil, polite,
00:23:30
Bashan tried to educate the University of Virginia that elections are important and that it was at the behest of the university that the electoral board put a polling place on the university grounds so the students could just walk over or take the university transit.
00:23:53
Now, remember, not all people who are in the, quote, university precinct
00:23:59
live on grounds, maybe normal citizens who are not students.
00:24:06
But they wanted an on-grounds facility.
00:24:10
They chose it.
00:24:11
Now we need to be able to use it.
00:24:15
So that's the history.
00:24:16
And I've tried to be as civil as I can be in describing why we need to have a polling place that we can use and that the officers can access.
00:24:29
Unless the board has something else, I'd like to turn it over to Nancy Jump.
00:24:33
Go ahead.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:24:33
Well, we've really got two separate issues here.
00:24:38
One is the university's cooperation with us, and the other is how to actually organize the precinct.
00:24:50
Can I amplify that?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:24:53
Just as the early in-person voting precinct is different from all the other precincts, university is different from all the other precincts.
00:25:03
With the volume of same-day registrations that are done there in a general election being a couple of orders of magnitude greater than many precincts, it's a completely different environment.
00:25:19
And the training and approach that we use in other precincts
00:25:23
clearly isn't the right approach to use at university.
00:25:27
And yet we haven't offered anything different to the university in how to do things.
00:25:32
And in my mind's eye, that's the goal of today is to at least get a start on the, how can we do this better?
00:25:39
Because it's time to recognize that you really are not just bigger, but different.
00:25:45
It's an essential difference that requires an essentially different approach.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:25:49
And so we want to hear from the reason we invited
00:25:53
the officers from the University polling place.
00:25:58
So we can hear what you have to say because you're the ones who are there all day and half the night.
00:26:09
And we want to know what you need before we start offering suggestions, et cetera.
00:26:17
So Chief, we hear from you first.
SPEAKER_08
00:26:23
The 4.30 thing worked out fine.
00:26:27
Everybody was very agreeable.
00:26:28
We got it all up and running by six, so if they are non-negotiable on that, we can live with it.
00:26:35
The other thing is that I met with a couple of EOs at their request, and we definitely will always need the whole space, not just half.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:26:44
We saw that in your notes for the day, that that was a conclusion at the end of the day.
SPEAKER_08
00:26:49
Right.
00:26:50
So I know there was a request in the middle of the day to open it up, but I talked to my EOs and they said, nope, that's just, that's not going to work in the moment.
00:27:01
So we'll fence for it.
00:27:03
If we can always have that, we'd like it.
00:27:05
And there we are.
00:27:08
We've been talking again with a couple of the EOs about how to restructure the room.
00:27:13
And basically what it comes down to is we have to have two kind of separate entities, one today voting and the other with about seven, maybe six people, and then one with like eight or nine people for same days.
00:27:31
And how we organize that, I guess it's kind of still
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:27:37
You basically need two different operations, recognizing that you have two essentially different populations that you're working with.
SPEAKER_08
00:27:43
And again, that was my first time.
00:27:45
I used to Chief Agnihurt did that for 10 years or so.
00:27:48
But then when I accepted this job, I had no idea that we were going to need as many people as we needed.
00:27:55
Clara Belle and Alex kept sending them, and I'm like, I don't think we need that many.
00:28:00
I apologize.
00:28:01
We did.
00:28:01
We could have used a couple more people.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:28:05
and I also will admit I didn't think you were going to need that.
SPEAKER_08
00:28:10
These students just come in, I'm very sympathetic to them, trust me.
00:28:15
They just want to vote, I get it.
00:28:17
They want to do it today and however they can.
00:28:20
I think the other problem that day was the ballot thing and we've got that worked out.
00:28:26
People putting their absentee ballots and they're only there.
00:28:30
That was kind of a sad situation, but I have to say the students,
00:28:35
You know, in the end, they were glad Jim said, well, let him vote provisionally.
00:28:39
And they were OK with that.
00:28:40
They had issues in their, you know, Norfolk and all that they had wanted to vote for.
00:28:46
God bless them.
00:28:47
But they were willing to go with the people's vote.
00:28:50
So I think we worked that main thing out.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:28:53
Another problem that you faced, and if those of you who have never experienced University Precinct during elections
00:29:05
just don't know what you're missing.
00:29:08
I mean, I have been in cage fights.
00:29:11
I've never been in a cage fight.
SPEAKER_04
00:29:14
I have never been in a cage fight.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:29:15
I can only imagine television programs.
00:29:20
But it's not even controlled, marginally controlled chaos.
00:29:28
And I take my hat off to all the officers of election, but they are dealing with
00:29:34
students that just show up.
00:29:46
They don't know anything.
00:29:48
And so you're doing education.
00:30:10
what the ideal population looks like.
00:30:21
People come in and go out the same door.
00:30:29
It's very awkward.
00:30:33
We have trouble keeping track of men
00:30:40
And by having the two rooms, even if you reserve one room for same-day registration, provisional ballot, you can still use an exit door.
00:30:56
It's really an imperative, particularly at university.
00:31:02
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_09
00:31:03
So one of the other things that, I'm sorry, Kim Harris, I was one of the EO's.
00:31:09
I have been blessed to be at the university precinct now for I don't know how many years.
00:31:13
I keep asking if I can move and nobody lets me leave.
00:31:17
The punishment hasn't ended.
00:31:22
It has not, right?
00:31:23
So Paula is another one of our EO's.
00:31:27
Paula and I often work the
00:31:31
Check-in, right?
00:31:33
And so one of the things that is unique to us, I think, maybe more so than others, is that we have a lot, we have to deal a lot with like the mover rules because the students are going, right?
00:31:45
And the students speak another language, right?
00:31:47
Because when they say to you, I moved at the end of last year, they really mean the academic year, they don't mean, right?
00:31:52
So I think, number one, there does need to be a little bit more education for someone who's doing the check-in stuff.
00:31:59
Now, we've been doing it for quite a while.
00:32:01
We don't really have an issue.
00:32:02
We speak UVA, right?
00:32:04
But when we have new people rotate in, it becomes problematic because we're trying to teach them and work with the students at the same time, right?
00:32:12
And with the numbers that we have in November, it's very difficult.
00:32:18
But one of the things that would also be very helpful is we discovered
00:32:22
You guys have provided a QR code that could tell people where they need it to be.
00:32:27
We need more access to more of those, but we also need access to information that says, hey, these dorms are in this precinct, because they're not all in University Precinct, and it's helpful to us if we have some of that information so that we can go, oh, you're in Faulkner?
00:32:46
That's actually, or whatever.
00:32:49
And so,
00:32:51
We need more data like that that helps us move them quickly if they are not in the right place, right?
00:32:58
Or if the mover rules don't apply anymore, because sometimes what they do is, oh, I moved two years ago, because last year they were so allowed to vote in our precinct.
00:33:06
Well, this year, so sorry, your nail's now been too long.
00:33:09
So that's the kind of, I think there's some more education and just data needed that day for the people that are sitting there.
00:33:17
I mean, it's fantastic when we have the list of the mover rules right there, right?
00:33:22
But I mean, we think there's a little more needed for us in terms of all the dorms and where everybody is.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:33:29
And the students, a couple of students with whom I interact said, I'm in such and such a dorm, I live on grounds.
00:33:39
and we did the spreadsheet, did the QR code.
00:33:43
Now, ma'am, you're in the city of Charlotte.
00:33:45
Right, exactly.
00:33:46
No, I live on grounds.
00:33:48
I'm in a dorm.
00:33:49
Yes, ma'am, you're in a dorm.
00:33:51
It's not on grounds.
00:33:52
You have to go to Cherry Avenue.
00:33:55
Right.
00:33:55
So maybe maps that would outside before they get to you,
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:34:06
You all did have a map that showed the line very clearly.
SPEAKER_09
00:34:11
We didn't have it this year, though.
SPEAKER_08
00:34:13
We couldn't find it.
00:34:14
The maps didn't come.
00:34:15
They didn't come this year.
00:34:17
Well, one of the Democratic poll watchers, bless his heart, gave us a thing that we used at the same day of registration of which dorms were in our precinct.
00:34:28
But that came like it happened.
SPEAKER_09
00:34:30
And when we saw it, we saw it later in the afternoon, we were like, oh, we could use that.
00:34:33
But it was in our office.
SPEAKER_08
00:34:36
It came from the city.
00:34:39
Yeah.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:34:40
We had one in
00:34:44
Gina's office, I know, it was up on the wall.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:34:48
You got the list of the dorms by name and whether they were city or town.
00:34:53
From somebody else.
00:34:54
That came to you on election day.
00:34:57
That's what I'm asking.
00:34:58
You didn't get that in your packet.
00:35:00
No.
00:35:01
I understood that it was going, okay, thank you.
SPEAKER_08
00:35:05
This poll watcher did everything it was like.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:35:10
Yeah, I think it was the same sheet that was on the wall in Gina Pace's office.
SPEAKER_09
00:35:18
The other thing is that we cannot always rely on their ability to, and I said the QR code would be great, and sometimes it is, however, it's terrible there to try and get,
00:35:34
They have trouble accessing even their student ID sometimes, even when they're on the Wi-Fi, right?
00:35:39
Because for whatever reason, Slaughter X
00:35:42
Wi-Fi, we have zero connectivity or it's spotty at best.
00:35:47
It's about being in a metal building.
00:35:50
So it is difficult for the students sometimes and it's difficult for us.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:35:55
Let me, I'll get to you.
00:35:58
That's something we've never heard.
00:36:02
We've never heard that that's a problem.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
00:36:05
Thank you.
00:36:06
I just want to add, as someone who goes to a lot of sports events over there,
00:36:10
But even when we log into the University Guest Network, it's inspiring.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:36:29
Thank you.
SPEAKER_09
00:36:30
Jim.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:36:31
I'd like to have a few minutes, if I may.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:36:34
Not more than five.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:36:36
First, real quickly, just a history of why that dang line is so crazy through there.
00:36:43
Until, I think I'm correct, until the mid 1950s, any land that the university acquired automatically became county land, even if they bought it from the city.
00:36:55
And then in the mid 1950s, they changed that rule.
00:36:58
So if UVA bought land, the city land, it stayed city land.
00:37:03
That's why you have some of the doors.
00:37:05
And some of the line goes through the middle of a couple of doors.
00:37:11
I had a very interesting conversation with the chief election officer at Trailblazer, formerly Venable, which has roughly the same number of provisionals that we do, not even less each time, but they really have a lot.
00:37:30
And this woman, she's a hard charger.
00:37:33
and she told me how they do things there and she also sent me some of the stuff that they do.
00:37:42
So one thing is, just so I don't forget to mention it, she really wants students to vote if they can vote regularly somewhere.
00:37:53
She wants them to vote regularly.
00:37:55
She wants to keep down the number of provisions.
00:37:58
so that's nothing new if it's a student that was in the university precinct and moved within the movers rules to trailblazer precinct she wants that student to go back to university do a regular ballot do a change of address
00:38:18
because she thinks that's better for everyone.
00:38:21
So she doesn't like it when we send people to her that could vote here, but that's just her way of looking at things.
00:38:30
It's a voter choice thing.
00:38:37
She makes them go back.
00:38:38
I said, do you not give them the option?
00:38:41
She said, yes, I'd give them the option.
00:38:43
But I think she- We have a lot sent back to us.
SPEAKER_10
00:38:47
with a little slip of paper saying I'm registered for next year there but you know they said I should come vote here.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:38:55
And the students don't seem to mind because they do not.
00:39:02
She makes the whole process and they only have one door.
00:39:08
They have a room that
00:39:10
Talking to her, it sounds like it's probably one and a half of our rooms, not both rooms.
00:39:16
Bigger than the one room, smaller than the two.
00:39:20
She makes the whole process very student-centric.
00:39:24
We make it EO-centric.
00:39:27
We make the EOs do much of the work.
00:39:29
She makes the students do it.
00:39:33
So when they come in, she tries to have an express lane for regular people as opposed to the provisional people and we kind of tried to make that happen but it kind of got jumbled up.
00:39:49
They come in, they get a green envelope, they get a clipboard, and they get a laminated instruction sheet, two-sided instruction, oh you've got it up there, okay.
00:40:01
Ray, I didn't know how to send it.
00:40:04
And these are the kind of things they have on their instruction sheet.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:40:14
The last, the number three on there, many students, and we want to hear from y'all, so we need to stop talking and listen to y'all, but they don't all know their social security.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:40:25
So anyway, the students are responsible for filling out their green sheet.
00:40:30
Plus she has posters up on the wall with these same kind of things.
00:40:35
And then they bring their green envelope back to an EO who barely checks it.
00:40:41
He tells them usually just check to decide.
00:40:45
If they mess up somewhere else, they've got the instructions, it's their fault.
SPEAKER_08
00:40:51
Then it's not going to count.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:40:52
Then it's not going to count.
00:40:55
They are then given a ballot and they are sent off to marking booths and they never come back to an EO.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:41:06
And you don't know whether that ballot gets in the machine or whether it- Ah, yes, you do.
00:41:11
Well- I'll tell you.
00:41:12
You should know.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:41:13
I'll tell you how in a second.
00:41:16
So they mark their ballot, they put it in the green envelope, and they're told after you mark your ballot, put it in the green envelope,
00:41:24
and go over there and put it in the provisional ballot box.
00:41:29
So it never comes back to the EF.
SPEAKER_08
00:41:32
Now the provisional- Because we have to do that log.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:41:35
Oh, wait, that's another part of it.
00:41:37
When the student gets their green envelope, she also has made Avery labels that match what's on the left side of the provisional log and the student fills out those labels.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
00:41:50
Oh my gosh.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:41:50
Well, that's- And so when they come back,
00:41:54
The EO puts the label on the log, puts the four digits of the social security number on the right side, gives the student a ballot, sends them off.
00:42:05
They put it in the envelope, and they carry it over to the provisional ballot box, which is near to the optical scanner.
00:42:14
And we would say, whoa, we can't do that.
00:42:18
I don't know whether they do it for every precinct.
00:42:20
I know they do it for that precinct and maybe for all precincts.
00:42:24
They print provisional ballots that are different from our regular ballot.
00:42:32
I'm guessing they don't have the timing marks in them.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:42:35
You're not supposed to do that.
00:42:38
All the ballots are supposed to be the same, Jim.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:42:40
Well, I don't know about that, but they do that.
00:42:43
because that way the student tries to put it in the optical scanner, the optical scanner will not accept it.
SPEAKER_08
00:42:50
Our technique is folding, which I think is foolproof.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:42:53
Right, I told her.
00:42:54
But they do that, so their provisional ballots are a separate type of ballot, separate ballot style.
00:43:02
So I guess you have two ballot styles for every precinct and one's a provisional ballot style.
00:43:08
And I don't know whether that's
00:43:10
legal or not, ask the voter these six questions.
00:43:15
Yeah, look at these.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:43:16
And there's a comment, Todd Barstow.
SPEAKER_00
00:43:20
Yes.
00:43:22
First of all, I served with Nancy as assistant chief, both pardon me, I'm a little hoarse, but this election and the general in November,
00:43:36
and so have had my those are my only two elections at university so my observations are based on those two but I'd like to echo in terms of my sentiments what Jim has just said
00:43:56
that it seems that we put a lot of the burden on the EOs to make sure the process is right.
00:44:08
Whereas I agree of principle with the idea that the students, before they get in, preferably get into our facility,
00:44:20
are as equipped as they can be to mark their own SDR sheets or envelopes and then present them to us for review.
00:44:32
It gets manic when we're trying to work through educating them.
00:44:37
And you know, for example, in this last election, I had sometimes three and four
00:44:44
at a time who were sitting around me just trying to clear the backlog.
00:44:50
So that's a general observation.
00:44:52
In terms of the first cheat sheet that Jim put up, the idea that the student must know their address
00:45:02
and come with a street address, not just a dorm name and a suite number is absolutely key, I think.
00:45:14
I know that caused all of you who had to process the SDRs a lot of work on the back end.
00:45:21
And my experience with asking students for that address at the desk was that they just didn't know it.
00:45:29
in many cases.
00:45:31
And that's definitely not the place when they're sitting in front of you in our current process.
00:45:38
That's not the place for them to try to figure their address out.
00:45:43
And so just a couple of comments to add to what Jim and the others have stated.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:45:53
Thank you.
00:45:54
Did you want to say something else?
00:45:56
You're muted.
SPEAKER_00
00:45:59
No, that's it.
00:46:00
Unless somebody has any questions about what I have.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:46:04
Because that is a problem.
00:46:05
And I am not convinced that a dorm name satisfies the Constitution or the codes requirement for giving an address.
00:46:19
I'm sorry.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:46:20
Under the bridge satisfies the requirement.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:46:23
Well, under the bridge, under the bridge, you have to specify which bridge.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:46:27
Indeed.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:46:28
But I'm not sure.
00:46:30
But would it help, so my question to the officers, with all the additional information we're trying to provide for you, would it be beneficial if on the wall out there at university where you've got this
00:46:47
massive people trying to get in line would it help if you had a list of all the dorms most city and county divided county dorms university precinct dorms these are the dorms that are university precinct and this is their address yes not just a map a handout
SPEAKER_09
00:47:13
I mean, a handout would be perfect, yeah.
00:47:16
I mean, I'll tell you, the students get confused because there are two addresses usually.
00:47:20
There's the name and then there's the street address and they're like, uh, you know.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:47:24
We don't understand that the name of the dorm is not really an address.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:47:30
Those door names are in our street file.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:47:33
I understand that, but that requires another look up by the officers.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:47:38
And so if you put some- The method used at Trailblazer is hoist that off on the students.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:47:44
Well, that's what I'm saying.
00:47:45
If you had several readable, big maps, I don't mean maps, several bullet points, these are the precincts that are, if you live,
00:47:59
This is going to be the dorms.
00:48:00
If you live in one of these dorms, you vote here.
00:48:03
If you don't, you vote wherever the others are, sometimes city, maybe another county polling place.
00:48:14
But if you had in alphabetical order the names of the dorms and the physical street address, please know this is the street address you will need.
00:48:27
Write it down.
00:48:28
I agree having a handout would be lovely, but you're talking 1,000 handouts.
SPEAKER_07
00:48:34
At the EO.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:48:35
At the EO.
00:48:37
We need those at the EO.
00:48:38
Absolutely.
00:48:39
Both places.
00:48:40
But trying to get the students prepped for when they walk in.
00:48:45
And the guidance from the Department of Elections says that the offices of election are supposed to help.
00:48:58
The voter.
00:49:00
I'm just not saying I agree with it or not agree with it.
00:49:03
I'm just telling you what goes out.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:49:08
Yes, ma'am.
00:49:08
I want to mention one other thing on what the city does.
00:49:13
She's an IT professional, Jessica Hotei, the chief there.
00:49:17
She created her own app using the city's GIS, but the city's GIS, like ours, is too hard to use.
00:49:26
She created an app.
00:49:27
and created a QR code for it.
00:49:30
We used an app from the state and Alex created a QR code for that.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:49:37
Well, there are lots of localities that have students with on, they call them campus, on campus polling places.
00:49:50
And talking to many of the officers who have worked in those
00:49:58
I have yet to come across one that's really less chaotic than university, and some of them are even worse.
00:50:07
I'm not saying be lucky you're not there, but some of these places are absolute bedlam, and you can't have an election like that.
00:50:18
I mean, these are students.
00:50:19
These are people that have shown their intelligence enough to get accepted to a college or university.
00:50:25
They could presumably read and write.
SPEAKER_10
00:50:29
Well, yes, ma'am.
00:50:33
I think, first of all, I want to thank you all for having this meeting and inviting us here for our input on this.
00:50:44
And it's true that in general, university students
00:50:51
are of higher IQ.
00:50:53
That may not be coupled with common sense in all cases.
00:50:58
But one of the things that I think makes the university precinct so unique is not
00:51:23
provide to make them be successful and therefore want to come back and participate in this wonderful democracy that we have.
00:51:34
I think the better and the better we will feel about the work we do.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:51:38
I really like the word you've used, scaffold.
00:51:42
I think that's a good word because they're climbing
00:51:46
Well, it's really good.
SPEAKER_10
00:51:48
I have an education background.
00:51:50
And the bottom line is we need to get everybody to the same point.
00:51:54
Exactly.
00:51:55
Where their vote is counted and they are participating.
00:52:01
People need different degrees of support to get there.
00:52:05
And I think it is incumbent upon us to come up with those systems that streamline that.
00:52:11
I mean, if someone is a curbside voter, we don't go too bad.
00:52:15
exactly get up and walk in so you know somebody shows up and they don't know their address i don't go too bad i agree but i do think that here is another opportunity to partner with the university or to see if we might be able to partner with them to let students know in advance
00:52:33
What do they need?
00:52:35
You're going to need to know your social security number if you're same day registering here.
00:52:40
So I'm just wondering if we might not be able to leverage some of those internal systems that the university has and to get them to partner with us a little bit more.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:52:49
And that was one of the things I'm just going to bring up to the dean of students, not necessarily facilities, but the dean of students, education of the student body.
00:52:58
I mean, you can, as the old folks would say, you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make them drink.
00:53:04
You can try to educate them.
00:53:05
Some of them will and some of them won't.
00:53:10
Everybody does the rah, rah, you got to vote, you got to vote, you got to vote.
00:53:14
OK, we got that.
00:53:15
Voter participation is important.
00:53:19
But they don't.
00:53:20
They're talking about, make sure you vote.
00:53:22
They don't dig into the scaffolding.
00:53:26
This is what you need to do.
00:53:28
And think how much easier it would be if you did it a month before.
00:53:33
filling in a form and mailing.
00:53:35
I mean, you wouldn't have all this hoorah.
SPEAKER_10
00:53:38
Right.
00:53:38
Well, and I was just going to go back to also to the trail days of the incredible precinct.
00:53:44
They're getting second year students.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:53:46
Yeah, exactly.
00:53:47
Right.
SPEAKER_10
00:53:47
You know, I mean, like, we've got all the first year students at the university.
00:53:51
So we, they often are getting somebody who went, has gone through the process, at least in part,
00:53:57
somewhere at the university.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:54:02
And many of you, they're sending back to you, vote back there again.
SPEAKER_10
00:54:07
Yes, they did that quite frequently.
00:54:10
But my point is that I think that we just really do need to remember, we need to assume good intentions on the part of every single player in this.
00:54:20
even the facilities people.
00:54:21
I mean, you know, they're trying to protect the dance class and while we can go, oh, come on for pity sake, if you're a dancer, that's very important.
00:54:32
So, I mean, I just think that we just need to assume good intentions.
00:54:36
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_09
00:54:39
Something that you said struck me about, you know, hey, if you did it a month before and completely agree, I will say we have had a number of cases
00:54:47
where the students have come in and said well I did register and they have the little slip right you know that's something a third party will give you right and they are not in our system and so I don't know what's happening but I know after the last general I think it was I actually called the registrar's office and said it wasn't this one it was the one before and said I'm concerned because I had enough of those
00:55:14
that is I don't know who's registering students to vote but is it getting into our system are they actually turning because these kids think they have registered and they're still having to do same days because they're nowhere to be found so I don't know what's going on but that that the tear-off slip is a result of general assembly law if a third party registers
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:55:42
finds a person on the street and says, you want to register to vote?
00:55:45
Here's the form.
00:55:46
Fill it out.
00:55:47
They have to complete so that the potential voter, the applicant voter, knows who the person, or they have something that is written down that says, John Jones, help me register to vote, with the telephone number.
00:56:06
Because you're absolutely right.
00:56:09
Some of those applications
00:56:13
don't get back to a registrar's office anywhere.
00:56:17
And some of those, once they get to a registrar's office, may or may not get into the system.
00:56:27
And that was what you heard from Jonell McFadden this morning.
00:56:33
She is paying special attention and reorganizing to make sure that all of the
00:56:42
registrations, the actives, the inactive, the mailed out, the absentee, all of that is organized.
00:56:51
Thank you for bringing that up.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
00:56:54
On the topic, I was physically present when, several times, I saw people delivering stacks of applications to the registrar's office prior to the election.
00:57:04
In the hundreds.
00:57:05
People are bringing them in in stacks, and then the folks in the office are feeding them into the system.
00:57:12
but I can't say that all the stacks have ever arrived.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:57:17
Or old stacks that I registered last year.
00:57:20
Nancy has it.
SPEAKER_07
00:57:22
Hi, I'm Nancy Takahashi.
00:57:23
I'm sorry I couldn't see you.
00:57:24
That's okay.
00:57:25
Nancy Takahashi and I said 202.
00:57:28
And well, first of all, I wanna really applaud Nancy and Todd for their leadership in a day of chaos.
00:57:35
It really made things happen and smoothly so their leadership was really great.
00:57:42
I want to comment on this.
00:57:43
I was at the SDR table, the provisional table, and there's one aspect of it that is just crazy, and that is the fact that we have to take each one of the provisional ballots and then log it onto a sheet of paper.
00:57:58
There was one fellow, one of our fellow EOs, Kashmir, he spent the entire day with stacks of these things just rewriting what was there.
00:58:11
and then probably taking bad handwriting and if I was doing it, replicating bad handwriting on a law.
00:58:20
So it's really untenable and we need to find a way I think to make a change there.
00:58:28
I don't know if anyone else will agree how that works.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:58:32
I know your former chief, Mike Merriam, that was a big thing to him.
00:58:37
Why can we not do this electronically?
00:58:40
Why do we have to do this on paper?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:58:43
Because you may not have electronic capability where you are.
00:58:47
And Wi-Fi capability or not in a precinct is prohibited under the code for election stuff.
00:58:56
But you could, I'm sorry, but you could put it into a Google Doc.
00:59:00
Sure, sure.
00:59:02
The code of Virginia requires the provisional ballot logs.
00:59:08
And one of the reasons that it does is because the party or candidate representatives that go to the provisional ballot candidates and the electoral boards must be given those logs so that we can compare them to the provisional ballot envelopes to make sure that the information is correct.
SPEAKER_07
00:59:30
Well, I maybe heard a suggestion that would require the applicant to fill out a little sticky with that information and just put it on the law, which makes sense.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
00:59:42
My only problem with that is a terrible, terrible handwriting.
00:59:49
Exactly.
SPEAKER_07
00:59:50
That was one of the things that we were checking for at the table.
00:59:55
Just saying, you know, what is what's this letter here?
00:59:58
We were checking.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
00:59:59
One of the major responsibilities of the officers is to make sure that on the green form, whether it's the same day or provisional, that it's legible.
01:00:15
And if we drove that home in all of our teaching, it's got to be legible.
01:00:21
And if you have
01:00:23
The student filling out the sticky, you've not corrected whether you can read it or not.
SPEAKER_07
01:00:30
You can check the sticky and see if it is legible, and then if not, make changes.
01:00:35
But that seems like a really easy solution to make.
01:00:39
At seven o'clock, there might have been 200 SDR things sitting there to be logged on.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:00:46
I was wondering how, when you finished the logs, because I was helping with the logs.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:00:52
Exactly right.
01:00:53
Which takes us back to Nancy's point, you need more people.
01:00:59
If you're going, or whoever, I think maybe everybody said it.
01:01:03
If you're going to run this polling place, you need adequate numbers
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:01:10
We're trying to make the point that we need the logs the next day.
01:01:20
We're required to provide them to observers to come to the process.
01:01:23
The logs have another function that they are commonly used for in polling places and I think they would apply to them too at university.
01:01:32
And that is that no matter what I do to review the contents of a provisional envelope, by the time I've done 50 of them, I'm not doing the same job I did on the first one.
01:01:43
But when I have to transcribe some of that information from here to there, I actually have to look at it.
01:01:50
And if you accomplish that before the voter departs, if there is something that is missing or illegible,
01:01:56
You actually detect it at that point.
01:01:58
So there's a valid QC component to filling in the law that doesn't apply if you fill in the law long after the voter is gone.
01:02:05
If you've got a stack of 200 of them, you're not getting any of that benefit.
01:02:09
But there is a potential benefit that can be reaped from doing that.
01:02:13
And not, back to the SDR envelope, not having a properly completed and legible envelope means we don't get that vote.
01:02:23
So all the effort that went into that
01:02:25
on the part of the voter and the part of the EOs were wasted and the voters can get registered.
01:02:31
The registration may not count and their vote may not count.
01:02:34
So it is, in my not at all humble opinion, worth the extra effort to make sure and to use the log recording process as a part of making sure.
01:02:46
Now, it doesn't have to be done by the same EO that's talking to the voter, but it really needs to be done before the voter leaves the polling place.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:02:55
and that's what we've, that's exactly, thank you Bucky, that's exactly what we taught when we were teaching the classes.
01:03:03
Thus my question, you need more people so that you don't have what Todd described as four students that he's trying to, you know, it's like being a blackjack dealer.
SPEAKER_08
01:03:18
It wasn't like that.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:03:19
I know, I saw it.
01:03:20
And you've got this man, these two people, sitting in chairs.
01:03:24
They didn't even have a table.
01:03:26
And they've got stacks on the floor, and they're writing on their lap.
01:03:29
I mean, that's a recipe for disaster.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:03:32
I asked the city chief how many people she had.
01:03:36
She had 18.
SPEAKER_08
01:03:39
Just for SDRs.
01:03:40
No.
01:03:41
For the whole precinct.
01:03:42
You had 16.
01:03:43
Yeah, we had 16.
01:03:44
We had 18 for the general election.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:03:48
And we really had many discussions on trying to get enough people to give you what you needed.
01:04:03
I mean, at one point the suggestion was made that we only needed nine people.
01:04:09
And after I fell out of my chair and got back up, I said, no.
01:04:14
So,
SPEAKER_10
01:04:16
So I was just going to say the staffing, I mean, one of the other challenges is that if the election is held when the university is on spring break, or during this, we are all
01:04:31
I'm just sitting around twiddling our thumbs because we're used to you know here comes the Russian we had what like 60 I mean now 39 the numbers just vary but you're going to see different results in them and that's true for every book but the primary also aligned to a spring break so the students aren't in town
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:04:53
The primary would be the summer break.
01:04:55
The summer is the third Tuesday in June.
01:04:57
OK, summer break.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:04:58
The voter turnout in every polling place is dramatically lower in the summertime.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:05:03
But some people might say, I'm sorry, Jim, I want to finish her thought.
01:05:09
Some people might say you deserve a break.
01:05:13
If you got some time to breathe on that election day, good for us.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:05:18
Good for you.
01:05:20
I'm not sure who AG is.
01:05:23
I feel a lot of information here.
01:05:25
And one is I'm trying to copy it down.
01:05:27
Is that HMS.housing?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:05:30
Yeah, that's the link on, we'd actually looked at this on the university's website where you can sort of do a translation between a dorm name and a physical address.
01:05:41
And it's tricky because you have to fill in all three fields, which are the, which suite number or room number, which bed number,
01:05:53
as well as the name of the dorm.
01:05:55
And if you skip over one of those, it just won't give you any information.
01:05:58
The long address of the building, please.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:06:01
Several years ago at redistricting, 10 years ago, Jim will remember this.
01:06:07
The General Assembly in its infinite wisdom drew the boundary lines and they split a dorm
01:06:15
down the middle, you remember that.
01:06:17
So the people on the, I don't know whether it's north, south, east, or west, but everybody on the west side of the hall was in one polling place, and everybody on the east side was on the, you kidding me?
01:06:28
So the board, this electoral board went to, Ron Bell was our representative at the time, and said, no, no, no, no, no, no, you guys need to fix this, and he got it fixed.
01:06:38
But that was just over the top.
01:06:43
Todd, you got your hand up, please unmute.
SPEAKER_00
01:06:46
Yes.
01:06:47
So does this resolve what I thought was still an open issue regarding addresses and dorm names?
01:06:56
It seemed like you and Jim maybe had a little bit different takes on whether a true street address is required or it isn't or it's a technicality.
01:07:07
And I think there's a fair amount of complexity in terms of what you want to do next in terms of education or preparation that's driven by the need for a street address.
01:07:21
because the students all know their dorm, which is why, you know, which is why the vast majority of the forms you got just had a dorm name and their room number.
01:07:34
Okay.
01:07:34
So I think it's important that that be, if that resolves it, that post, and it's very clear that it's required by NDRA and Virginia code, then that's going to drive one set of actions.
01:07:48
And if it's,
01:07:49
subject to interpretation.
01:07:51
I think you should resolve that before we, you know, you take the next steps on how to improve things.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:07:58
Absolutely.
01:07:59
I couldn't agree with you more, but it's not a question that we can decide in this electoral board.
01:08:06
This is a question that needs to be done statewide because, again, there are lots of polling places on university campuses where
01:08:16
What we all know is you can't use a post office box as your residence.
01:08:22
Nobody lives in a post office box.
01:08:25
How small your dorm room is.
01:08:28
But there are places in Virginia who actually register voters with a post office box or an academic building.
01:08:42
You can't do that.
01:08:42
That's against the law.
01:08:45
Whether you need to have a street address is something that maybe the General Assembly or the AG or somebody else needs to decide.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:08:54
This is an ancillary topic to the university question.
01:08:58
So I would suggest we should get the university question.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:09:01
Well, I was trying to answer Todd's.
01:09:03
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_08
01:09:04
My name is Sherry Steffen.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:09:07
What about homeless people who don't have to address?
01:09:09
They can register, and the way the code is written, it says where you expect to be for the foreseeable future.
01:09:21
And if that homeless person says, I expect to be, as Bucky said, under the bridge, under the Rivanna River Bridge on the Rivanna Trail, there's an encampment along the trail.
01:09:34
Hope it doesn't flood.
01:09:36
That's perfectly legal, absolutely.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:09:40
It may be on private property.
01:09:42
It may not be legal for them to live there.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:09:44
But they can also, and they are invited with great vigor, I hope, to put down a mailing address under the form that says mailing address so that if someone needs to get in touch with them, their polling place changes.
01:10:02
There's something wrong with
01:10:05
They can't get their notification that now you're a registered voter.
01:10:09
They need to have a mailing address.
01:10:12
It doesn't have to be a post office box.
01:10:13
It could be a church.
01:10:16
I go to this church or this church takes mailings for the... You certainly can be registered to vote and not have a permanent address.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:10:27
Do we want to discuss your three options?
01:10:33
Now, or not?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:10:35
They were just some ideas.
01:10:36
I don't believe we can actually solve the whole problem today, because there are a lot of facets to this.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:10:41
Did you get a copy of the three options he had?
SPEAKER_08
01:10:45
Are they in one of these papers?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:10:47
No, no, no.
SPEAKER_08
01:10:48
No?
01:10:49
Uh-uh.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:10:50
No, I didn't really intend it for discussion here.
01:10:52
It's too much material to go over.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:10:54
But maybe we'll send it to Nancy and send it along.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:11:00
Is there anyone else?
01:11:02
Who would like to comment on this?
01:11:06
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_04
01:11:07
The only comment I would make is I would encourage the city electoral board and the county electoral board to get together and try to solve that.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:11:16
As we said, it's not just a Charlottesville city and an Albemarle county.
SPEAKER_04
01:11:22
I understand, but right now, right here, it is between the city and the county.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:11:26
That's a good idea.
01:11:26
That's a fine idea.
01:11:28
I would also submit that
01:11:31
What we need is a planning education meeting that's maybe not an open electoral board meeting, but for the officers of election, and that becomes an education training session.
01:11:51
I'm seeing agreement from the chief.
01:11:54
Does that make sense?
01:11:57
And then we can, you know,
01:11:59
Be prepared for a sit down, get comfortable and sort it out hopefully before April, although once again, it will be a special election and you probably, unfortunately, will not have a great turnout in a special election, but we need to be prepared for it.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:12:16
To Linda's suggestion, I plan to hopefully today contact
01:12:24
People, we have a statewide organization, Virginia Electrical Board Association.
01:12:30
We have our annual meeting in March, I believe it is this year.
01:12:36
I think it's in March.
01:12:38
And I'm going to see if we have breakout sessions of different sized localities and that.
01:12:44
I want to have a breakout session of localities that have big student populations.
01:12:51
So everybody can kind of, with their best practices, answer some of these questions, maybe.
01:12:57
That's a good idea.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:12:58
Collaboration's always good.
01:13:01
Because, again, it's bad.
01:13:03
It's disorganized or it's chaotic.
01:13:07
They're not the most disorganized and chaotic.
01:13:11
It could be worse.
01:13:13
I know that doesn't make anybody feel better, but it needs to be straightened out.
01:13:20
And it needs to be straightened out by clear definitions and clear instructions.
SPEAKER_10
01:13:28
Yeah.
01:13:28
Is Nancy Chief from here?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:13:30
She doesn't know.
01:13:31
We don't know what she's going to do.
01:13:34
We're treating her with kindness.
01:13:39
No, Mike's coming back.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:13:41
Nobody holds any job forever.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:13:45
Okay, if anybody has anything else.
SPEAKER_08
01:13:48
I'll just say, I like the ideas from the city lady.
01:13:52
You may or may not understand.
01:13:54
I'm completely opposite from her.
01:13:56
I hold the students' hands.
01:13:58
They are first years, but I think there is a balance.
01:14:01
So it's a good thing for us to start
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:14:04
That's the template that Jonell was talking about.
01:14:08
A lot of places use the template because then it's easier to see what you've got to have right, and it's got to be there, and it's got to be legible.
01:14:17
The other thing is the comment about the logs.
01:14:25
Logs, unless the General Assembly just does away with them, which, who knows?
01:14:35
You have to have, it's a checks and balances.
SPEAKER_10
01:14:38
We'll work with it.
01:14:40
And that's a staffing issue.
01:14:41
We have more than one person on us.
01:14:43
Exactly.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:14:45
If you have enough officers and they are separated, so they're, I mean, when I walked in and I don't see Todd on the call anymore, but, and I was really glad that it was his wife.
01:15:00
Todd and his wife were sitting practically, she was practically on his lap.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:15:05
No, no, no.
01:15:06
Yes, yes, yes.
01:15:07
They were so close.
01:15:08
There's no impropriety there.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:15:10
That's not what I was implying at all.
SPEAKER_00
01:15:13
I am on and I can't believe that she was not on my lap.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:15:20
Give up.
01:15:21
I'm trying to help you Todd.
01:15:23
You need more space so that when you have, you don't have four students at once.
01:15:30
You've got enough people with enough, you know, enough table space and you don't have an officer sitting in a chair or two officers sitting in a chair working with stacks of paper on the floor.
SPEAKER_00
01:15:43
Yeah, that's how we were set up.
01:15:44
And it worked out much better.
01:15:49
We just couldn't change in the middle of the day with the number of people we had this year.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:15:53
Nancy, I will send you what Bucky worked up as three possible ways to organize the room.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:04
Oh, you'll never find it in email.
01:16:05
I'll send it to her.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:08
No?
01:16:09
All right.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:10
Okay, do we have anything else that we need to... We need to thank these good people for coming in and sharing their time with us and their ideas.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:17
That was exactly what I was getting ready to say.
01:16:19
Thank you very much.
01:16:20
We appreciate it.
01:16:21
If you'd like to stay for the rest of the meeting, you're certainly welcome, but if you'd like to go home and have some hot coffee.
01:16:26
Thank you for your lovely invitation.
01:16:27
Thank you.
01:16:27
Thank you.
01:16:28
Okay, next is election officer accounting reports.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:16:37
to an office account.
01:16:38
That's what Jonell said she doesn't have.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:40
And she's going to do the accounting.
01:16:45
The ADA inspections and certificates have all gone in.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:49
Where are they?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:51
They went in online.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:55
Do we have copies of any of those reports?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:16:59
I can get them.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:17:01
It would seem to make sense to maintain those so that when we've got to go back, if there was an issue or problem or a question, we've got it to refer to.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:17:11
That's why they were sent that way, yes.
01:17:15
Because there are other things that are obviously important also that for which there's no record.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:17:23
Yeah, I've been sending mine to Alex, so he's got all of the ones I did.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:17:32
Electric Board Policy on EO, some assignments.
01:17:36
Bucky, would you like to discuss this?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:17:38
Yes, this is the policy attached to your documents that we took comments on last time.
01:17:44
I tried to incorporate what you put in there.
01:17:47
I hope I did a good job on that.
01:17:52
And we kicked that down to this meeting to take up and sign it.
01:18:00
And the purpose here is to
01:18:03
codify what we actually do so that there's no confusion among ourselves or among the staff of what our expectations are.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:18:13
Would you like to run through this for people who may or may not have this, but who are interested in Congress and elections?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:18:22
I can.
01:18:23
It's been posted online, so everyone who picked up the online minutes has a copy of it.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:18:28
Not everybody looks online.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:18:30
Number one, only the electoral board appoints new officers of elections.
01:18:34
That's not a choice, that's a thing.
01:18:36
Officer's election appointed to one year or three year terms beginning March 1st of the year they are appointed.
01:18:42
Officer of elections, officers of election appointed to one year terms are appointed contingent upon the return of the necessary paperwork and oath documentation.
01:18:52
The elections manager within three weeks of their appointment
01:18:55
or such other period as the electoral board may specify.
01:18:58
This is something that we had discussed earlier this year and voted on as something we wanted to do because a frightening number of EO applications come to us.
01:19:09
We say, yes, you can be an EO and then we never hear from them again.
01:19:12
Under the code, once we have made someone an officer of election, it is relatively hard to unmake them.
01:19:19
So you just wait them out until their appointment ends.
01:19:22
We're making all those appointments contingent upon the actual return of materials so they don't even get on our roster until they send stuff back to us in this one view.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:19:30
And so they need to be told in writing when the letter goes out that says you've been appointed, but you have to do all these other things and we need to have that information back within three weeks or you'll have to start at the beginning again.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:19:51
I'm sorry, I can't.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:19:57
The intent of that is to cover the situation where you're right in front of an election and you'd want to give people a shorter time window to get back to you, get back to us within one week or two weeks or something like that because there's an election coming in five days.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:20:11
But it also covers like someone says, yeah, I'm in Europe and I won't show at home for six months, three months.
01:20:17
Do I have more time?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:20:18
They can also do it online.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:20:22
The oath part might be a little hard.
01:20:24
Also, people can always reapply.
01:20:27
If they let us know what's going on, take another application.
01:20:31
But the idea was that we weren't trying to deal with individual cases.
01:20:34
We were trying to deal with situational, where we're coming up on election.
01:20:38
I don't have three weeks for you to get back to me.
01:20:41
If you're going to be an officer of election, I need you to get back to me within a week or 10 days, because in 12 days, we're having an election.
01:20:52
At the first February meeting, the electoral board, the elections manager will bring to the board two lists, those officers of election whose terms are expiring and who are recommended reappointment, and those officers of election whose terms are expiring who are not recommended for reappointment.
01:21:08
Each of these lists will be subdivided into groups of officers of election who have one-year appointments and groups with three-year appointments.
01:21:14
Only the electoral board can decide to reappoint or not reappoint an officer of election.
01:21:20
The idea here is that if you've had someone who's been an appointed officer for one, two, three years, and they've never worked an election, it might be time not to reappoint them, or even on a one-year basis.
01:21:35
And you may also have feedback from the elections manager based on the evaluation of an officer as to whether they were really good, not really good, borderline,
01:21:47
and things like that might contribute to why someone who had a one-year appointment was appointed for another one-year period of time, because we really haven't gotten a good feel for this person yet.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:22:00
People frequently fall into that latter category.
01:22:05
The chief writes a report, an evaluation, and maybe other officers in that same polling place
01:22:15
will speak to one of the board members or the election manager and say, there's a reason why this person really maybe should be reconsidered for doing something else.
01:22:28
And frequently in the past boards, not just our board, not just the three-year, but previous boards, they said, well, instead of unappointing somebody, we just won't assign them.
01:22:42
You've got plenty of other officers we could use.
01:22:45
You just won't assign them until their term runs out rather than saying, we think you should not be an officer of election, which Bucky say it's hard to unappoint.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:22:57
I prefer disappoint, but the proper use of the word.
01:23:02
Officers of election who have not worked for the past two years or longer will generally not be considered for reappointment.
01:23:08
If you're not in the game anymore, we'll just take you off the rolls until you want to play, and then you can always reapply.
01:23:14
Officers' elections who have not worked for one year or longer may not be considered for reappointment, or if they have been in touch with the elections manager as to why they have been unavailable and previously had satisfactory performance, they may be considered for reappointment.
01:23:30
Former officers of election who were not reappointed may apply again to be an officer of election.
01:23:34
The electoral board has final approval for any appointments as a chief or an assistant chief officer of election.
01:23:40
This is in response to an unfortunate circumstance that we had earlier this year, where the rosters of chiefs and assistant chiefs were sent out to the chiefs and assistant chiefs before the electoral board had actually approved them.
01:23:53
And they were not correct.
01:23:55
That led to some unpleasant discussions.
01:24:00
The electoral board approves the rosters of officers' elections who are assigned precincts for an election.
01:24:05
Such rosters will always be...
01:24:07
Sorry.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:24:09
Can we modify that sentence?
01:24:11
Sure.
01:24:13
The electoral board approves the rosters of officers of elections who are assigned to precincts by the election manager in an election.
01:24:23
We're still approving.
01:24:24
I would say that's one reason we have an election manager.
01:24:28
Had the election manager do that.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:24:31
and it's caused problems in the past.
01:24:38
Well, the initial assignment may be done by either a board or the manager, but it can be open for discussion or it's up to the board to make the final decision.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:24:53
Well, that's what it says.
01:24:55
The electoral board approves the roster of the lawyers.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:24:57
So I don't think you have to add anything else to that sentence.
01:25:00
I think it stands a lot.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:25:02
I move that I'm making a motion.
01:25:04
I agree, Jim.
01:25:07
To say who are assigned to precincts by the election manager.
01:25:10
Your friendly amendment has been accepted.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:25:14
All those in favor say aye.
01:25:16
Aye.
01:25:17
Those opposed say nay.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:25:19
The rosters will always be made considering parity unless the election is a single-party primary, home precinct assignment, the size of the precinct, officer experience, officer evaluations, and previous assignments of the home for election for this or other precincts.
01:25:33
Once the initial roster approval has been received, the Elections Manager may replace individuals who drop out for any reason or make such other assignments as seem necessary and proper to the Elections Manager for the conduct of the election.
01:25:49
Updated rosters will be provided to the Electoral Board on a regular basis as new assignments are made and will additionally be provided to any Electoral Board member on request.
01:25:58
The Electoral Board can overrule any assignment that it sees fit.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:26:03
My comment may or may not be directly related to that, but one of the things that we heard at the Hot Wash, one of the things that we saw in Chief's evaluations or comments that Chief's made were last-minute assignments, meaning literally the week before an election.
01:26:31
We all understand that
01:26:33
that people get sick.
01:26:34
They have whatever circumstances and they call it and say, I can't work.
01:26:39
And you've got to do something.
01:26:41
If you're right at the edge of how many offices you need, you need to put somebody in there or not.
01:26:47
It may be that you don't need another person.
01:26:51
Maybe you're already overstaffed at that point.
01:26:55
But I think we need to be particularly careful about not
01:27:04
putting people in polling places at the last minute.
01:27:09
Unless, again, you're filling an emergency vacancy.
01:27:15
Or you've been trying to get people and you haven't been able to get enough and then suddenly you've got people you can assign.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:27:22
I just have a question for Alex.
01:27:24
Can you give me a ballpark estimate of how many dropouts you had in the last two weeks before the election?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:27:58
they're in crops so what if they can't work the June primary but that doesn't mean they won't be ready to go and we had people last year who were simply because they didn't work the June primary after giving notice of why so so I don't understand what you would change here I don't know I don't know how to change it except
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:28:22
Because it sounds like you're saying, let's use good judgment and getting rosters assigned in advance.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:28:28
Exactly.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:28:29
Try to minimize the number of people.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:28:30
That's exactly what I'm trying to say.
01:28:32
That's why I started by saying I'm not sure it's really germane to number 10.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:28:38
But I agree with the principle.
01:28:44
number 11 upon request and at a reasonable charge not to exceed the actual cost incurred pull that right out of the code the elections manager shall provide a copy of the list of officers of election including their party designation and precinct to which they are assigned to any requesting political party or candidate this list shall include officers of election who have not been assigned to a precinct as well it doesn't say party does that matter
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:29:19
Do you want to leave it open?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:29:20
What's that to the requesting political party?
01:29:23
The code has more specificity about this.
01:29:26
I'm just trying to lay down the concept that you got to give out stuff.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:29:30
Rick, again, it's the code.
01:29:33
And it's code 24.2-115, paragraph A.
01:29:36
Does it go to the chairman?
01:29:42
It can go to the chairman or the chairman's designated
01:29:48
Representative.
01:29:50
And it goes in that same, it says that the list of appointed officers of election can be readily available to anyone.
01:30:02
Their name, that's the list of appointed officers of election as soon as they are appointed by the board.
01:30:13
Then they go on the list and the list is available in the registrar's office.
01:30:19
to anyone.
01:30:21
Then, not less than 10 days before the election, the roster, meaning the precinct assignments and the party designation, shall be available to the chairman or the chairman's representative or a candidate.
SPEAKER_08
01:30:44
Yes, ma'am?
01:30:45
Will they share status?
01:30:46
Will they, is it just our name?
01:30:51
They won't have our personal address or our email or phone number.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:30:55
The name, the party designation, and the precinct to which you are assigned.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:31:00
That's the one that goes to the parties, not the one that's there for anybody from the public.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:31:07
The one that's for the public is the name.
01:31:09
That's it.
01:31:10
Alphabetical order.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:31:13
No, we did do something.
01:31:16
earlier about adding on a thing where the officer can say if their contact information can be made available to party chairs right yes that's what you put if the officer gives written consent right okay
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:31:42
Number 12 is a point of personal interest to me.
01:31:48
The elections manager will make available to the electoral board or any member of the board on request the contents of the complete database of officers of election.
01:31:54
Both officers who are assigned to precincts and those who are not, the board and its individual members will take reasonable and customary care of this information to remit its dissemination down to the board.
01:32:04
which doesn't really sound like a big thing but I spent a couple of months this year when I started trying to get this information out of the then current elections manager and only found out six months after that that I never did actually receive the whole list of information that was available.
01:32:22
which frustrates me no end, as you can hear at this time.
01:32:26
So I'm putting in the policy that the purpose that I wanted this information for, that I was trying to do an analysis of how many of our officers' election are not working in their home precinct.
01:32:38
And the key piece of information I wanted, which was where's their home precinct, was omitted from the data that I was provided.
01:32:45
So it took a lot longer to do the analysis than it should have.
01:32:49
but I did and it worked out that less than half of our EOs are in their home precinct.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:32:56
And to Bucky's point the board looks at the applications so we know what their home address is because it's on their application.
01:33:11
So
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:33:11
Just want to make it clear that anyone from the board can get this information in toto whenever they want to.
01:33:17
And at the same time, we have a responsibility to make sure that people's personal information doesn't become public.
01:33:23
So I can't leave printouts on the table when I leave the meeting room and someone else absconds with the whole list of EOs.
01:33:30
Officers' election can only be removed from the database of available officers of election on approval from the electoral board.
01:33:35
Such approval may come in the form of non-reappointment or may occur due to the removal of a specific officer of election as provided for in the code.
01:33:42
This would seem to be self-evident from what's gone before in this, but I wanted to drive home the point that nobody takes an officer of election out of our database unless one of these two situations has occurred.
01:33:55
We didn't reappoint them for their
01:33:58
They've been removed.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:33:59
And I want to point out for the audience, there is a difference between appointment and assignment.
01:34:07
So there are cases where we have appointed someone, but we don't assign them.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:34:12
You see a ton of those in a primary.
01:34:14
Half the EOs sit home.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:34:16
You don't need them.
01:34:17
The other point that Bucky alludes to, and he's very careful in what he said, there have been people who have been
01:34:28
pointed toward but then sort of lost.
01:34:38
Whether that was intentional or just for record keeping, you don't know.
01:34:42
But there were people who were approved who should have been assigned and they just sort of faded into Neverland.
01:34:52
That shouldn't happen.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:34:57
And then the last point on here is just as the board votes everything in with a simple majority, we can vote to suspend, revise, or delete this policy in whole or in part by a majority vote of members of the board.
01:35:09
Policy doesn't shackle us for all time to do only these things.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:35:12
No policy, yes.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:35:13
No policy.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:35:16
All in favor, say aye.
01:35:17
Aye.
01:35:18
Any further discussion?
01:35:19
We should have had discussion before.
01:35:21
Is there any further discussion?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:35:23
I feel like we did.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:35:24
I think we did, too.
01:35:26
Okay, hot wash recap.
01:35:31
I thought we had a great hot wash. We did it a little bit differently this year.
01:35:38
Bucky supplied a wonderful bola hat and we put the names of all the precincts and we all thinking the same thing.
01:35:44
So we had about, I don't know, four or five little baskets of names of precincts
01:35:50
that we used.
01:35:51
We only used one in the hat.
01:35:53
And then the three board members picked out names and called on the assistant chief so that we didn't go to Woodbrook first or around the table, depending on where you were sitting.
01:36:07
This way it was whatever.
01:36:10
And we asked that people come up with three or four, several
01:36:14
important points they wanted to make, and if anyone else agreed with that, they raised their hand.
01:36:19
So, okay, you don't have to talk about that when it comes to you.
01:36:22
Come up with something else.
01:36:24
I thought we got good feedback.
01:36:27
We had, yes sir?
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:36:29
Yeah, I guess my only comment was it seemed that we spent an awful lot of time patting ourselves on the back about how wonderful we were
01:36:39
I would prefer we spend more time talking about what we can fix, how we can improve, because it wasn't that much.
01:36:47
One minute, pal.
01:36:48
It was about the feeling that you stood up and said something went wrong, you were going to get hammered, because everyone was saying everything was so wonderful.
01:36:56
So that's just a thought and observation.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:36:59
I thought the same thing going around, because the board, the manager,
01:37:06
Other EOs, we've all talked.
01:37:09
The reason you have a hot watch is to make necessary improvements.
01:37:18
Yeah, it's good to say we did this well.
01:37:20
We improved this over the last election and it worked.
01:37:22
We liked it.
01:37:24
But everything was not hunky dory everywhere.
01:37:27
And thank you, Rick.
01:37:29
Thank you.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:37:30
I'd like to ask Alex how you thought you think we got some meaningful ideas for improvement?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:37:39
We did.
01:37:40
So we're looking forward to implementing them for next year.
01:37:44
So good suggestions.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:37:53
And there was plenty of good food and everybody seemed to enjoy it.
01:37:56
You chose not to eat, you chose not to eat, but
01:38:00
Those people seem to be happy.
01:38:05
Any other comments about the hot wash?
01:38:10
This board was careful to have it in December so that it went that far out in the past.
01:38:15
Sometimes the hot wash has been put off till January.
01:38:19
Yeah, you lose your connection.
01:38:20
You lose your connection, you forget, you know, I was really upset about whatever it was.
01:38:25
And then you have to worry about snow.
01:38:26
But we had snow, so, you know,
01:38:30
Anybody have any other thoughts, improvements that we could make?
01:38:37
Okay, and the hot wash only takes place after the November election.
01:38:41
We don't usually have, we've never had hot wash after specials or primaries.
01:38:46
That doesn't mean you can't comment.
01:38:47
That's why the Chief's writing, Chief's notes.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:38:50
You had a great slide on the definition of hot wash, which is in the dictionary.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:38:57
It's an old military term.
01:39:00
It's an after action report.
01:39:03
OK. Jim, you wanted to do something about the contingency planning for the possible April special election.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:39:12
Well, we already talked about the contingency planning as far as the budget goes.
01:39:17
Jonell, you can report on that.
01:39:21
I believe the General Assembly goes into session January 14th.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:39:27
Yes.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:39:27
And I believe that they will probably take up the redistricting issue pretty quickly.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:39:39
Since they called a special session to get the first vote on that, they didn't rush right into it.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:39:46
I assume it's going to pass.
01:39:49
You think?
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:39:52
And I assume if it passes, it will be litigated.
01:39:56
most likely.
01:39:59
So we won't really know for a while whether it's going to happen.
01:40:06
Here we got, do we have 45-day early voting?
01:40:10
Find anything in the code that says that for a referendum you don't have that?
01:40:15
I think you do.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:40:16
You do have that.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:40:17
All elections.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:40:18
unless the court rules which happened in Fairfax and other plain Richmond.
01:40:24
Richmond had four special elections in one year.
01:40:27
They compressed their 45, but they did not in Fairfax.
01:40:32
So they had in-person absentee voting, two elections going on at the same time.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:40:40
So I think that not right now, but sometime in January,
01:40:47
We need to start talking to our other stakeholders and players, i.e.
01:40:55
the school system.
01:40:56
I do not believe the school system will decide that there's no school that day.
01:41:01
Once we actually have a date.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:41:05
Which could already be a teacher workday, you never know.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:41:10
All our other polling places that are non-schools.
01:41:13
They're not going to have any idea.
01:41:16
Well, they may have an idea if they pay attention to the news, but also to our facilities people, I think we need to be getting in touch sooner rather than later with these folks saying, look, this is going to happen.
01:41:34
The last time that we had
01:41:38
Any kind of election that school was in session, I've determined to be June 8th of 2021.
01:41:47
So it's a problem that school's in session.
01:41:49
So many of the rooms that we normally use, you can't use.
01:41:53
So you gotta- And there's no parking.
01:41:55
And they gotta give us another room.
01:41:56
So sometimes it's a classroom because you know it's gonna be a small election, do that.
01:42:03
Getting back to here.
01:42:06
I'm not sure that we want to take room A for 45 days for a referendum where we might be getting 10 voters a day.
01:42:17
We had a primary, I don't know, three, four years ago.
SPEAKER_05
01:42:21
I think that was in 2021.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:42:25
We knew it was going to be small, and we used room B instead of taking room A.
01:42:31
And room B worked out just fine.
01:42:34
But we need to talk to the facilities management people here as to, look this is going to happen, we don't have any choice in it.
01:42:43
So I just wanted to say that I think we need to start looking at these contingencies sometime in January.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:42:52
We have some calendar and code requirement concerns that I dug into on this.
01:43:02
As I could tell, the possible election dates would be April 7th, the 14th, or the 21st.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:43:06
Really?
01:43:08
It has to be a Tuesday.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:43:09
It has to be a Tuesday.
01:43:10
It's got to be 81 days after the order for the special election, and it's got to be 55 days before the next general or primary election.
01:43:19
Right.
01:43:19
And it can't be coincident with a primary election, but it could be coincident with a general.
01:43:24
That's not going to be an issue this time.
01:43:26
So we're down to just three days in April, assuming the General Assembly approves it as soon as possible, which means early voting starts in February for two of those days.
01:43:38
The early voting start for the primary is May 1st of 2026.
01:43:43
Now, when you, after we have the election, whether the special election is on April 7th, April 14th, or April 21st,
01:43:55
After that, there's basically seven days for us to get our results back to the state.
01:44:02
And the state from seven days on until as soon as possible after that time, they're to certify those results for a statewide election.
01:44:11
Which means theoretically, as soon as seven days after the election, they can be done.
01:44:15
10 days after that is the last date that someone could file for a recount.
01:44:21
and the recount is relevant because at the point the recount, that time window expires, then you're free to resection hardware.
01:44:34
The code has two different clauses on this.
01:44:38
One 30 day, not 10 days after, it's after the recount expires and that could be extended by court order.
01:44:46
You could have more time but let's just go with what the planned case is.
01:44:51
The code talks about this in two places in terms of recycling that equipment.
01:44:57
It talks about you have to secure the equipment by locks, if they have locks.
01:45:01
But then it also says, but if your machine has USB keys that you're pulling the information out, you have to secure those.
01:45:08
So it might be
01:45:09
that we don't need to keep our DS300s secure, pristine, not changed, as long as we have a different set of USB keys that we could recycle for those for the next election.
01:45:21
And this is important because if your early voting start for the primary is 5-1 of 2026,
01:45:29
So down here, 17 days after the possible election dates would be 4-24, 5-1, or 5-8.
01:45:38
Two of those mean that we have to start early in person voting before we can free up the equipment for that.
01:45:44
That's going to be a problem for us.
01:45:46
We might have a couple of spare machines we could get going in time for the actual in-person voting and get the rest of the cap and polling place machines done later.
01:45:59
That's assuming we didn't use the spare machines next time, which none of us want to do.
01:46:05
but anyway so there's a logistical timing thing here I think we need to examine the code and make sure that just securing our USB keys will be compliant so that we're not hoist on that petard.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:46:21
I would offer that while Albemarle has planned and has had the financial resources to have extra machines and we were very glad of that in November.
01:46:34
but not all communities have that luxury.
01:46:39
They don't have three or four machines sitting around waiting to be pulled up for emergency duty.
01:46:45
And so I think that before we get too far down the road on planning or I'm not saying you wait till the last minute by any means, I think we have to be proactive but hopefully the Department of Elections
01:47:03
who give guidance and hopefully the court if this goes to court or the General Assembly will understand or we explain to them by somebody that these are considerations they have to give to all localities if they're going to come up with an April election which we don't usually have.
01:47:27
You can't just run out and you can't rent
01:47:32
tabulators, optical scanners, you can rent them, but it's expensive.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:47:36
It's expensive.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:47:41
Thank you for doing all the extra stuff I didn't know you were doing.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:47:45
You put it on the agenda, I figured I'd best do some contingency planning.
01:47:48
Can you send all those?
01:47:50
Sure, I'll send that to you.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:47:58
Anyone have anything else to say about this possible date coming up?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:48:02
It sounds like we definitely need to have it on the January agenda.
SPEAKER_05
01:48:06
Yeah.
01:48:07
Yes, sir.
01:48:08
Doug Earl, can the public know how much a special election would cost them?
01:48:15
Can we know that?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:48:16
Yes.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:48:17
Thank you.
01:48:19
Thank you.
01:48:19
Thank you.
01:48:20
You were taxed dollars at work.
01:48:21
Absolutely.
01:48:22
You have what it's right to know.
01:48:22
Correct.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:48:23
The public needs to know what everything costs, because it's your money.
01:48:29
Yes, sir.
01:48:30
Thank you for asking.
01:48:32
For instance, my soapbox mailed out absentee ballots across the Commonwealth.
01:48:41
People get on a permanent absentee ballot.
01:48:44
It costs roughly $15 a ballot to mail them out.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:48:51
Just to mail.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:48:53
Well, it's not just the postage, it's everything that goes into getting that ballot into the mail and being returned, or not.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:49:01
So it doesn't include the cost of processing it?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:49:04
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:49:06
It includes.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:49:10
Well, it's not.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:49:12
There's no incremental cost for that.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:49:13
It's very expensive.
01:49:14
And the mailing services, Jonell has been extremely active
01:49:21
in looking at where we're getting charged for things that we're all saying, why are we getting charged for that?
01:49:29
So, Doug, thank you very much.
01:49:34
And if you know anybody that's getting an absentee ballot that they're not using routinely, you might wanna not get one anymore.
SPEAKER_10
01:49:42
Yes, sir.
01:49:42
So the, Amber Baker, so the absentee ballots cost across like $15?
01:49:48
I just wonder then, why were we telling voters that it was $30 in order to try to convince them to get off the list?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:49:55
I don't know who said $30.
01:49:56
I did not say $30.
01:49:58
I never heard it.
01:49:59
I never heard it.
01:50:00
If you can tell me the name of somebody that said that, I'd rather not.
01:50:03
Well, I'd like to know.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:50:04
Well, if you get the message out better, $15 is the number.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:50:07
$15 is the number that came out.
01:50:10
Did anybody else hear it?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:50:11
If there's two people in the household that cost $30,
SPEAKER_09
01:50:15
How much does it cost for someone to come in and vote?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:50:23
The first person was very expensive.
01:50:28
The 1500th person doesn't cost any more.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:50:30
This is part of the transparency that we need to have of what does it cost to run
01:50:42
45 days of in-person absentee voting.
01:50:45
And it's accumulative.
01:50:47
It's personnel who work.
01:50:52
It's the extra machines that have to be there.
01:50:55
It's the tabulators that have to be there.
01:50:59
It's the office staff that has to have time blocked out to go help.
01:51:04
I mean, it is not inexpensive.
01:51:09
and 45 days is a long time.
01:51:12
Yes, ma'am.
SPEAKER_10
01:51:13
Speaking of things being posted for public view, the Elections Office accounting reports and budgeting, is that information made public on the website once it's generated?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:51:28
It hasn't ever been generated.
01:51:30
So there is no historical answer to provide.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:51:33
But I can tell you that our current registrar is working really hard
01:51:38
to get that information so that it can go up online and publicly.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:51:43
I mean, she is very- Is this an agenda?
01:51:45
That's going to be a regular item on each agenda is, you know, what's the report for regular meetings?
01:51:50
And it should just be another page on, you know, how it was finished in the budget.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:51:54
The regist- Sorry.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:51:57
I don't know how much detail the county budget, if you were to look at county site rather than our site,
01:52:07
Budget's on there, but I don't know how much they put out.
01:52:13
The election hits on a page.
01:52:15
The line for elections, for sure, but whether that's broken down on what they put out on their website, I don't know.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:52:24
Registrar currently is going through that process, and it's very detailed.
01:52:31
But as Bucky said, as I have said, in the past, it's never been
01:52:37
visible to anybody.
01:52:40
Nobody knew.
01:52:42
Thus, many of the problems that we've had.
01:52:46
Yes, ma'am.
01:52:47
Statewide?
01:52:48
Oh, no.
SPEAKER_05
01:52:49
I'm just talking about Albemarle County.
01:52:52
I mean, Jonell mentioned in her report that she was developing a line item.
01:52:57
It wasn't a line item.
01:52:58
They could either be put in or taken out.
01:53:02
I just wonder if at some point in time, not today, but some point in time, if you know what the line total.
01:53:09
Yes, sir.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:53:11
That's her, that is her goal.
SPEAKER_05
01:53:14
For Albemarle County.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:53:15
For Albemarle County.
01:53:16
She can't tell Fairfax what to do, but yes, the Albemarle County election office budget will be readily available.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:53:28
I've spent what seems to me to be a lot of time looking at electoral board minutes from around the state, looking for what do other people do, and the answer is no.
01:53:37
Nobody ever publishes any budget information on any of those that I can see.
01:53:44
A lot of them don't bother posting their minutes, so.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:53:48
Of course in that, a lot of them don't have minutes.
01:53:51
They don't have meetings, so they have no minutes.
01:53:54
There is one noteworthy
01:53:58
Electoral Board in Virginia that has four meetings a year, if they're lucky.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:54:04
Four to six meetings is not uncommon.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:54:05
It's not uncommon at all.
01:54:08
I think it's deplorable, but it's not uncommon.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:54:14
Okay.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:54:18
Other items?
01:54:20
I have a couple.
01:54:22
Go ahead.
01:54:23
No, go ahead.
01:54:24
I'll catch you.
01:54:25
Go ahead.
01:54:26
Go ahead.
01:54:28
Ladies first.
01:54:29
I'd like to give a report on the BS 300s.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:54:32
Oh, yes, please.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:54:33
I have been in both conversation and some emails.
01:54:41
I find that the vendor is somewhat comfortable with coming into talking to them because they don't just find that they're maybe more forthcoming.
01:54:50
And they are looking at this problem, and I have invited them
01:54:59
They need to come and look at our machines.
01:55:02
They need to send their tech people, not their salespeople, but their tech people, to look at our three.
01:55:10
Then we had a fourth machine that had trouble opening up in the morning.
01:55:13
I think that was a completely different issue.
01:55:15
Completely different problem.
01:55:16
But, you know, while they're here.
01:55:20
We want some resolution, and now that we've got this looming April, nothing like, as one of my former professors used to say, a dream with a deadline.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:55:30
It's looming February.
01:55:31
That's when the early voting started.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:55:33
Well, the election is April, yes.
01:55:36
So we're working on that.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:55:39
No, we knew they were looking at it before.
01:55:41
If they said anything more about what they're looking at.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:55:43
I'm trying to get them to get their little flat feet up here to look at LGs.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:55:48
There's no more specificity about that.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:55:53
No, we're bobbing and weaving and calling back and, hi, remember us in Albemarle?
01:55:58
So I can't tell you when they will be here, only that I'm trying to arrange.
01:56:06
Hello?
01:56:10
Thank you, Phillip.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
01:56:15
This is Rick Garnett.
01:56:22
Do you have contractual obligations on the part of the vendor to provide service in some sort of timely manner?
01:56:32
Because I know
01:56:33
They've been looking at this for a long time, and it doesn't seem like there's any progress that they've made.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:56:38
Well, they've been looking at it since election day, and we've been talking back and forth, and trying to even get a name.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:56:51
They did manage to replicate the problem.
01:56:54
New information.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:56:55
And there are other places that had, if not the same problem, similar problems, but teasing that information out is
01:57:04
somewhat yes.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:57:05
I didn't see where they managed to replicate but that in that email from I was told that by Tyler.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:57:13
Yeah, it's not in writing, Jim.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:57:15
Oh.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:57:16
It's not in writing.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:57:19
Interesting.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:57:21
But I keep asking.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:57:26
You replicate the problem then
01:57:28
They now know what the problem is.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
01:57:32
But you're dealing with regulated software, so if they have to make any change to anything, there's a whole validation process, then it's just tedious and slow.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
01:57:43
And why did it happen to us and not everywhere, and why did it not happen to all of our machines?
01:57:49
That's the question.
01:57:55
Report on the poll pads.
01:57:58
We are trying to get the GIS director for the county to coordinate with knowing and we're trying to get at the same time the GIS county director who did a GIS
01:58:21
site for Albemarle County to work with the office and come and talk to us in the office and Jonell and people who work in the office on getting street files for the office that will facilitate knowing where a voter lives and which precinct and which polling place, et cetera.
01:58:42
But also to get it on the poll pads and for, see the representative from CAP here, we're trying to get them to
01:58:51
both, yeah, to get the socials on the pole pads for CAP so we don't have to go through the arduous, but Margaret did, Margaret for many of you is 90, 90 even, right?
01:59:07
90-year-old lady who is a dynamo.
01:59:13
of Ability to Work.
01:59:17
And she went through and looked at all the people who got mailed out absentee ballots and checked to make sure that the last four of their socials were on their returned material information envelopes and highlighted it so she could then check it.
01:59:36
And she did all of that.
01:59:37
There were some 8,000 of them.
SPEAKER_10
01:59:39
and we would recheck it.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
01:59:41
Yeah, and then the Office of Election rechecked it in the cap, so it was- So what you're saying in cap is you want to get the last four- On the computer.
01:59:53
Socials onto- Bowl pads.
01:59:55
Bowl pads, okay.
SPEAKER_10
01:59:56
So we don't have to use the paper, because we'd use the paper pad as well as the electronic.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:00:01
Yeah, and they do that in other places.
02:00:04
They do it with no ink in other places, and they certainly do it with the Demtech,
02:00:10
We used the laptops that we had from Mike Brown.
02:00:15
They did it.
02:00:18
Okay.
02:00:20
Yeah, you've got the number.
02:00:21
Yes, yes.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:00:24
It has come to the attention of this board that one of our members is experiencing her very last meeting.
02:00:32
And so we got you something to remember off by.
02:00:38
your own bowl of chocolate.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:00:48
Thank you, Jim.
02:00:50
You are so kind.
02:00:52
I'm not offering the chocolates to anybody.
02:00:56
Bucky is a purveyor of good stuff and he brings all kinds of wonderful things.
02:01:02
Oh my gosh, what is this?
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:01:03
And we have something else that we know.
02:01:05
A much more meaningful present.
02:01:07
A meaningful and that you will treasure all your life.
02:01:12
And it's appropriate for opening here.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:01:13
May I?
02:01:14
Okay, good.
02:01:17
Whoever wrapped this did a great job.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:01:20
Good job, Jim.
02:01:21
No, I don't wrap at all.
02:01:22
Well, this...
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:01:28
I'm sorry to tear this up, but...
02:01:32
We should be here all night.
02:01:39
All right.
02:01:41
It's blank.
02:01:42
It's blank.
02:01:42
It has no information on it.
02:01:44
Good job.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:01:45
They didn't check the citizenship.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:01:46
They didn't check the citizenship.
02:01:48
No.
02:01:49
Oh, wait.
02:01:51
This is exactly what it's supposed to be.
02:01:56
No citizenship.
02:01:58
That means it's no.
02:02:03
This is great!
02:02:04
Thank you!
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:02:07
Well, we appreciate all your work.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:02:13
Thank you, Jim.
02:02:15
Jim and I have been on boards for a long time together, rotating on and off, circling each other, whatever, but I'm in the seat that is dependent on the party of the governor.
02:02:28
These two gentlemen are, it doesn't matter who the governor is.
02:02:32
They can be here until- This time around.
02:02:34
Well, yeah.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:02:36
Four years.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:02:37
So you will get a new member in January, and I only hope that she has as much to do with this as I did.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:02:47
Clara Belle and I, I think we first met.
02:02:51
We were a team in the Mariela virtual food- Yes.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:02:58
Roubaix.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:01
Were you on the board then?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:04
No.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:06
Were you on the board then?
02:03:07
So you just as active citizens.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:11
We were on both on the board and a recount later.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:03:14
We had like five teams on that and each team had somebody appointed by the Democrats, somebody appointed
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:26
And here we've got Tom Perriello racing again.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:28
Well, thank you, gentlemen.
02:03:31
You are most, most kind.
02:03:33
Got you.
02:03:38
But I have to say again that Bucky brings bags of chocolates or bags of cookies.
02:03:47
And I always say, oh, Bucky, you shouldn't have done that.
02:03:52
So thank you very, very much.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:03:55
protecting your blood sugar, insulting your pancreas.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:04:01
Thank you.
02:04:03
That is supercalifragilist.
02:04:07
Thank you.
02:04:08
Okay, I would suggest the two of you determine the time for the next January meeting.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:04:15
It's hard to do without a third person.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:04:17
You want to go with your same second Tuesday?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:04:20
My thinking is we should just hold off until we have a meeting.
02:04:24
You've got to have a meeting.
02:04:25
You've got to schedule it.
02:04:25
We have to have a meeting.
02:04:28
But it would be pointless to schedule a meeting without our third person.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:04:33
So you're going to do that.
02:04:34
And just so everybody knows, electoral board agendas and the time of the meeting can be done
02:04:43
outside of a meeting.
02:04:44
So the secretary, the vice chair, whatever, and they will reconfigure who gets to be chair and blah, blah, blah, blah.
02:04:52
You can set that time by simply sending an email to the new member.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:04:57
Legally, that's not.
02:04:59
And call a meeting.
02:05:00
I think as soon as the judge makes the appointment, which may have already happened, except that then we can caucus throughout the period of time.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:05:12
We don't have to wait for January 1st.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:05:16
No, please don't.
02:05:18
And it's perfectly legal for them to do that.
02:05:22
OK, we need to go into an executive session.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
02:05:26
Yes, sir.
02:05:27
Yeah, this is Rick Barnett again.
02:05:28
I just want to make one comment.
02:05:30
I'm so pleased with how the board is working to make everything more transparent.
02:05:37
It's really, really helpful to everybody, I think, to have more transparency.
02:05:42
I appreciate it.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:05:43
Thank you.
02:05:45
Anybody else?
02:05:47
And we, I mean, I think I speak for the board on this.
02:05:50
We are really pleased with the consistency of people who come to the board meetings, either online or who show up.
02:06:01
You're showing your interest in elections and how they take place.
02:06:06
And it's really, it's refreshing and
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:11
There was that one guy one time who crashed the Zoom call.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:15
We're trying to forget about that.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:17
I'm glad that was a one and done.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:22
We don't talk about that.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:06:23
OK. Do we have much executive session?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:28
You want to take a break?
02:06:30
You want to take a five minute break, Jim?
02:06:35
It wouldn't be a meeting if you didn't.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:06:39
All right.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:39
In one of these days, Jim is going to stop smoking.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:06:43
Take a snuff.
02:06:46
A snuff.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:48
Thank you all so much for coming.
02:06:49
It's been very enjoyable.
02:06:51
Who's not standing for the closed session.
02:06:54
If you can drop off, that'd be great.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:06:56
Outside of the meeting.
02:06:58
Wow.
02:07:00
You guys all have a great Christmas.
Rick Garnett
Election Integrity Committee Chair
02:07:06
I'm heading off on Monday to
02:07:08
Amsterdam, for my gratitude.
02:07:10
Thank you.
02:07:10
Thank you.
02:07:12
Have fun.
02:07:12
It's been fun.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:13
See you sometime later.
02:07:15
Happy Christmas.
02:07:16
Next time I see you, I expect you to be doing your fingertip push-ups.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:19
No.
02:07:22
No.
02:07:23
Probably won't happen.
02:07:24
No.
02:07:24
Thank you.
02:07:25
Thank you.
02:07:25
Talk to you guys later.
02:07:27
Anybody else need to...
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:28
I'm going to slip out, but I want to get our...
02:07:36
Karen Schindelbrock.
02:07:45
Karen, are you signing off?
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:48
Yes.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:50
Thank you.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:52
Because you're finished now, right?
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:54
We're just going to executive session and then we'll come back.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:57
Yeah, I'll leave.
Bucky Walsh
Vice Chair, Electoral Board
02:07:59
Thank you.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:08:03
This for a moment.
02:08:12
The electoral board states by vote of the membership that we were in executive session.
02:08:19
Only those three members of the board and our legal counsel were there.
02:08:24
We discussed only those things which we said we were going to do, which were personnel matters and financial matters.
02:08:30
And we are now back into open session by so statement from the board, all those I.
02:08:38
And now the board entertains an adjournment.
02:08:42
Motion from somebody.
Jim Heilman
Secretary, Electoral Board
02:08:43
Newjourn.
Clara Belle Wheeler
Chair, Electoral Board
02:08:44
Amen.
02:08:47
OK. Stop this.